1999 Speleologist - The Florida Speleological Society
Transcription
1999 Speleologist - The Florida Speleological Society
The Florida Speleologist Vol. 35 No. 1 Winter 1999 The Florida Speleologist Vol. 35 No. 1 Winter 1999 Page 1 The Florida Speleologist Vol. 35 No. 1 Winter 1999 The Florida Speleologist Contents Vol. 35 No. 1 Winter 1999 Editor.....................................Ken Peakman The Florida Speleological Society, Inc. P.O. Box 12581 Gainesville, FL 32604-2581 Incident Report 3 by Brian Williams Emergency Caving Supplies 4 By Bill Oldacre The Florida Speleologist is an educational publication of the Florida Speleological Society,Inc. Material included does not necessarily reflect the views Find it, Buy it, Protect it and Enjoy it! of the Society or the editors. Articles, photographs, by Ken Peakman and advertising are welcomed at all times and should be addressed to the Editor at the address given above. Consult the editor regarding advertis- I Learned About Safety From That ing rates and layout, Original materials will be re(The discovery of Murphy's Law Cave) turned if accompanied by a self addressed stamped by Brian Williams and Quinton Howe envelope. Unless noted, material herein may be freely reproduced provided the author and source are credited. Unsigned material may be attributed to The Caving Experience the editor. 7 11 14 by Marbie Caruso The Florida Speleological Society is a not-forprofit organization dedicated to the safe exploration, Tennessee Alabama Georgia Caving 99’ scientific study, and conservation of Florida caves. Brian Houha Anyone interested in caves or caving is invited to join. Regular membership is $15 per year; family memberships are $5 (family members receive no Election time Again publications). An additional postal charge may apply by Sullivan Beck to international subscribers. Individual copies of The Florida Speleologist, as available, are $2.50 each. Air and water quality problems in Caves The society meets at 7:30 PM on the 2nd and 4th by Sullivan N. Beck Thursday of each month in room CG-73 Of the J. Hillis Miller Health Center on the University of Florida campus in Gainesville, Florida. Contact the Society at the address given for membership applications, subscriptions, orders, or information. 1999 Board of Directors President.........Sullivan Beck Vice-President...Brian Williams Secretary......Caren Beck Treasurer...Jerry Johnson Bill Oldacre, Quinton Howe and Ken Peakman Equipment Chairman...Kevin Green The Speed- Cover: Quinton Howe in Rusty’s Cave Fox way quarry Mountain Georgia (photo by Brian Wilwall near liams) Along with Assorted photos from as- Ocala sorted places by assorted people to numerous to mention :-) Page 2 16 18 20 The Florida Speleologist Vol. 35 No. 1 Winter 1999 Incident Report Date: Place: Time: Event: People: February 14, 1999 Jennings Cave Preserve, Southeastern Cave Conservancy, Marion County,FL 12:30pm Cave Trip with 5 Girl Scouts, 4 adult leaders, 3 FSS members, 1 EMT Brian Williams, Jennifer Langford, Dave Moore, Bill and Phil Walker, Don, Mary Alice, and Rachel Petty. Nancy and Jennifer Guiech, Virginia Francis, Rebbeca DiBella, Kristen Lunsford. (see attached waivers for addresses) Description of incident: On Sunday, February 14th 1999 at approximately 11:30 am a trip to Jennings Cave with 5 girl scouts, 4 scout leaders and 3 FSS cavers began. Brian Williams briefed the group regarding safety procedures to follow around the pit and in the cave. While Brian Williams and Dave Moore began rigging the entry pit, the scout group, and leaders were further briefed by Jennifer Langford on safety and the cave environment. Helmets were issued and adjusted for fit, lights were checked. Each member of the group was to rappel down the 30 ft entrance drop via figure 8 device and bottom belay and ascend via cable ladder and top belay. A single rope was rigged for the descent and a cable ladder was rigged for the ascent. The cable ladder was removed and placed to the side so as not to cause entanglement upon rappel. Dave Moore and Jennifer Langford were sent down first to assist with bottom belay and moving each person to the first room of the cave to wait for the entire group to descend. Don Petty was the first scout leader to make the descent followed by the 5 girl scouts and one more adult leader. Each member of the group was rigged at the top by Brian Williams and instructed on the best method for making the descent. Each member was bottom belayed by Dave Moore. Each group member made the descent without incident with the exception of the last to negotiate the entrance pit. Mary Alice Petty, age 42, Girl Scout leader, was the last member of the group to descend. She was rigged at the top by Brian Williams and bottom belayed by Dave Moore. While backing up to the edge of the entrance pit she slipped at the top and her feet slid forward while her body fell down and back. Her position on the rope remained static, but as she slid down, the right side of her face stuck the limestone ou tcropping on the side of the fissure entrance. The entrance at this point is ~3 ft wide. The impact of the fall caused her jaw to fracture in the rear and split apart in the front resulting in 2 severe breaks but no visible tissue damage on the face. Brian called for Dave to maintain control on belay while Brian e x- Page 3 The Florida Speleologist Vol. 35 No. 1 Winter 1999 amined the victim for head or neck injuries. The victim was conscience and responsive, able to move her head and but still hanging in an awkward position. Brian was safetied to a separate line and managed to carefully extract the victim from the lip of the pit. After removing the victim’s gear and having her sit down, she was examined and determined to have a fractured jaw with some minor bleeding. The victim’s airway was patent and she was calm and responsive. An ice pack was applied to the jaw area. Brian called for an immediate withdrawal from the cave and asked Dave Moore to be the first one out as he was a trained EMT. The group was removed from the cave via cable ladder with rope and harness belay. Dave examined the victim and determined her to be stable. The remaining members of the group were removed in approximately 30 minutes. The victim’s husband then transported her to the Monroe Regional Hospital approximately 15 miles away with Dave Moore in the vehicle monitoring the victim enroute and Brian Williams and Jennifer leading the way in a separate vehicle. After examination at Monroe Regional the victim and her husband chose to drive to Jacksonville, approximately 40 miles north, for further evaluation and treatment. On February 16th the victim, Mary Alice Petty, underwent surgery to repair the fractured jaw. Her full recovery is e xpected in approximately 6 to 8 weeks. The main cause of the incident appears to be foot slippage at the lip of the pit. Although none of the other 11 members of the group experienced any difficulty at the top, there is loose dirt and leaves surrounding the pit entrance that evidently contributed to the fall. Possible preventive measures include a heightened awareness of footing at all times while attempting to enter a cave or pit. Submitted by: Brian M. Williams, Vice-President Florida Speleological Society NSS # 43870 Emergency Caving Supplies By Bill Oldacre Tonight I'm sitting here doing a little research project. Sherlee, my wife, became very ill with colitis, possibly caused by some food she ate. She lost 26 pounds so fast it scared the hell out of me. In an effort to get something into her I began buying a lot of those new energy supplements you see on store shelves. Stuff in cans, stuff in candy wrappers, and more stuff in squirt tubes. Most Page 4 she couldn't eat. So this evening I thought I'd take a few moments to try some of the things I was attempting to feed her. I was thinking all these "power" foods might have some applications to caving. I began with a food bar from the Balance Bar The Florida Speleologist Vol. 35 No. 1 Winter 1999 Company (www.balance. com). It was called the Chocolate Balance Bar, "The Complete Nutritional Food Bar." It tasted like powdery, dry, chocolate fudge made with sawdust. I'd have to be half dead to try another one. No one could eat the thing without a quart of water handy. So rule that out for Sherlee or anyone else. Next, I tried a Chocolate "Performance Energy Bar" from Power Bar (www. powerbar.com). It was soft and pliable and felt kind of good, like toffee, in it's wrapper. This tasted more like something familiar to the shoes of every dog owner. The consistency was about the same too. I had to brush my teeth to get rid of the awful flavor. Then there was that squirt tube, Clif Shot, "The Natural Energy Burst" from Kali's SportNaturals, Inc. No fat, protein, fiber, or vitamins, but a raft of carbo. The Real Berry flavor tasted like stale fruit mixed with honey and molasses. At 194 calories, a caver would have to pack ten of these things to cope with 24 hours of heavy caving under cold conditions (2000+ calories). The caps pop open with just a little pressure on the tube. In desperation, how would the bottom of your cave pack taste? Years ago someone developed one of these high density food items for aerospace applications. I guess some idiot probably did put them into the astronauts emergency gear. They made their way to the store shelves as "Space Food Sticks." Vaguely chocolate in flavor, they were shaped just like a rock hard Tootsie Roll. An FSS member carried some to an old abandoned house we'd camp at when we visited Marianna. Noooobody could eat them. So they were left for the mice and flying squirrels that inhabited the place when we didn't. We returned again and again, only to find that no self respecting rodent would eat them either (not even roach's). Finally, I decided to brave a can of Boost. This is a nutritional drink that is supposed to have most of what one needs to live. Actually, it wasn't completely awful, but it was too big to be considered practical cave food. I also bought Ensure, another power drink. Sherlee tried a little, but refused it. Baby food was out because most of it has too much fiber, the last thing one needs with an inflamed GI tract or deep inside a cave. Besides, how would it look to whip out the old bottle of Gerbers? What finally worked for Sherlee was a milkshake made Page 5 with ice cream and two chocolate Instant Breakfasts. Gatorade took care of the electrolytes and a vitamin pill provided all the extra nutrition she could manage. Antibiotics and anti-inflammatories did the rest. Gatorade might be a good idea in a cave, but the milkshake and vitamin pill offer little value for cavers. A recent cave accident, where a party of three got trapped by rising water for a few days, was interesting. The only food they had was one energy bar of some sort (I wonder if they ate it). Hypothermia was a serious problem and they had to pack tightly against each other, soaking wet, to survive. It seems that we really are taking less food into caves with us than we need. It's a mistake to think that your clothing is what keeps you warm. Wrap your best goose down jacket around a gallon jug of water and put it in the freezer to see what I mean. What keeps you warm is your body's ability to generate heat. And that is strictly dependent on calories. Running out of energy snacks during an extended period underground could actually put one's life at risk. If you no longer have the energy to shiver, you're finished. Most healthy people have enough reserve in their bodies to permit a few days or even The Florida Speleologist Vol. 35 No. 1 Winter 1999 weeks of bad nutrition as long as the calories and basic electrolytes are there. So probably we shouldn't worry too much about good nutrition in the short term. Body fat helps too. With 2% body fat,a person's system is going to have to resorb muscle in short order when the food stops. They'll become hypothermic sooner too. This isn't an argument for being out of shape, but a few extra pounds might be in a caver's favor. So maybe ordinary candy bars offer the best solution. They have lots of calories, don't need much liquid for consumption, they're low residue, and edible even if totally smashed. Hard candy may be a solution, too, if it's individually wrapped. A steady trickle of energy may be preferable to digesting some sticky mass all at once. But for the high cost, bad flavor, and packaging, the Clif Shot tubes came closest to what we really need to sustain us during extended caving trips. Years ago, cavers used to make Goosh by boiling cans of Sweetened Condensed Milk for about twenty minutes. The extremely sweet, caramelized result was very high in energy. Very durable too. However, it was awful to eat, and once the can was opened everyone had to eat as much as they could. Plenty of water was essential. For a starting point, as you explore this subject yourself, consider this. While bulky foods with fiber make us feel satisfied when we eat them, they don't do us any favors in a cave. Better, would be something very high in energy, low in residue, and which can be eaten slowly with as little water as possible (largely for convenience). Simple sugars like honey (monosaccharides) are absorbed immediately. Complex sugars like sucrose (polysaccharides) must be digested first which means they will not be immediately useful in combating serious hypothermia. They also may not give you that energy burst you're looking for halfway out of a 600 foot pit. As for liquids, iodine tablets are important in case you have to obtain drinking water in the cave. You cannot survive more than a few days without liquid and diarrhea won't increase your chances any. Packets of some powdered electrolyte replacer like Gatorade are useful and will help kill the flavor of the iodized water. Garbage bags, or those silvered mylar emergency bags, are good for retaining body heat. Candles are inherently waterproof, provide heat as well as light, and have long burn times. And a well packaged hand warmer could be life saving in an emergency. Cut a hole for your head, Page 6 draw your knees up, and put the garbage bag over you with the heat source underneath. Whatever you select in the way of emergency survival supplies has to be imminently practical. For years we treated children with chronic diarrhea in third world countries using drugs and nutritional drinks. They died, literally, by the millions. Then someone got realistic and gave them the absolute minimum of what they had to have to survive, to hell with anything else. They cut the death rate in half with the simple ingredients, available anywhere, listed below: Table Salt - 3/4 teaspoon Baking Powder - 1 teaspoon Sugar - 4 tablespoons Orange Juice - 1 cup Water - 1 quart/liter (source: World Health Organization) There's a lesson in this for cavers too: Keep it simple, keep it effective, and keep it with you. P.S. Sherlee's doing a lot better. The Florida Speleologist Vol. 35 No. 1 Winter 1999 Find it, Buy it, Protect it and Enjoy it! by Ken Peakman Jennings Cave in Marion County Florida to the best of my knowledge was discovered by The Florida Speleological Society (F.S. S.) in early 1965 and mapped in March of the same year by Dave Corson & Al Krause of the F.S.S. Florida Cave Survey #263. The cave had many visitors prior to F.S.S. proven by the graffiti in the cave. Some of this graffiti was even dated as far back as 1947. The cave was and still is, well known by locals as a party spot and dumpsite. There was a large colony of bats in the cave but the trashed cave and vandals drove them away during the 70’s. In November of 1993 the F.S.S. organized a major cleanup of this cave. There were 25 cavers from all over Florida and several companies that donated services. Waste Management Systems donated a 20 yard dumpster and hauling services, the Marion County Commission waived our landfill charges, Cox Cable Company pro- vided and installed a steel cable/high-wire for our hauling system and they donated food, drinks and ice for the cleanup crew, Chuckies restaurant (owned by Jon Singley who also coordinated the whole cleanup event) donated catered lunches, a dining tent and latrine facilities. It took 2 days of work in and out of the cave to get the job done. It was an elaborate scheme to load and haul this trash and debris out of the cave. The entrance of the cave was some 23’ deep pit and the trash was all through the cave but concentrated mostly in the pit area (later after the trash was removed the pit measured 31’). We rigged pulleys, ropes and a bridal attached to a 55-gallon drum to haul most of the garbage out. This was a sight to see. First the persons in the pit would load trash items into the barrel. Then the command was given “PULL” and with that 6 or more persons would grab onto a rope and pull while walking down the street. The barrel would then lift up and out of the pit and then traverse the high-wire over to the street just above the 20 yard dumpster where slack Page 7 was ordered and the 55 gal drum was emptied. Do this 400 times, yikes! Al Krause Dumping one of many Barrels of trash excavated from Jennings Cave (picture by Bill Birdsall) We removed mattresses, bicycles, lawn mowers, a motor cycle, batteries, oil filters, bottles of all configurations, love notes some of which were still legible and funny, sex toys, carpet, a washing machine and nine No Trespassing Signs! Since the cleanup, the cave still gets trashed which tasks each trip with a cleanup while exiting the cave. We the F.S.S. grew tired of cleaning the cave over and over again. So talk was started about buying the cave and gating it to preserve the cave and to The Florida Speleologist Vol. 35 No. 1 Winter 1999 keep trash out of it. We found that a developer owned the property and he had not paid taxes on the land for the last six years. Ken Peakman took the time to investigate this situation. It seemed that unless someone purchased all the tax certificates on the land before the next years taxes rolled around the land was going to escheat (default) to the county. Ken did all the legwork by determining the actual lot (land) concerned with, getting all the deed information, restrictions, legal descriptions search for liens against the property, filing application for tax deed and finally purchasing the parcel of land containing the entrance of Jennings Cave from Marion County FL via a Tax Deed Sale #278649-2 on April 4th 1998. At that time the Deed was recorded in the Southern Cave Conservancy’s Name as a donation from the Florida Speleological Society (FSS) in the amount of $1112.49. Since the date of acquisition, I, Ken Peakman have been acting as the Cave Manager for Jennings Cave. I have been scheduling trips and cleanups and organizing plans for gating the cave. There are still many Non-Cavers visiting the cave on a frequent basis. These people continue to litter the cave and the surrounding property. This problem may subside greatly, I hope, after the gating of the cave. The weekend of January 22nd 1999, several members from the FSS including myself, did a major cleanup trip on Jennings cave. We effectively removed every piece of trash including foreign debris (logs and other non-natural entering debris) from within the cave. “Lots of trash from the cave” (photo by Ken Peakman) After completing the cleanup of the cave, we discussed possibilities for gating the cave (Bat friendly of course). The best solution we could come up with is to gate the cave below the bottom of the pit approximately 15 feet from the rock zone on the south side of the entrance pit. By doing this, we accomplish several things as well as compromise others. First and foremost we preserve the beauty of the entrance pit. Secondly, we relieve ourselves of the legal implications that may be imposed upon us Page 8 if we admit to (by gating at the surface) the danger of this cave entrance. If the gate was ever breached (which would happen eventually) and someone got hurt, they could come after us with legal action and have a fair chance of winning the case due to the improvements we made to the cave opening. By installing the gate below the surface we relieve ourselves of this responsibility. Furthermore, by gating below the surface and into the cave passage, the breach of the gate would be much more difficult and thus preserve the beauty of the entrance seeing’s how the gate would not be ripped off the surface by a “Redneck and His Truck”. A third benefit is; if the gate were installed in this cave passage, the confines of the passage would make it extremely difficult to “hack-saw” through the gate or lock. The compromise is, the position of the gate will not block all passage of the cave. The passage North of the entrance pit will be left accessible for anyone to explore. This will become the new “Party Grounds” for the local’s. This part of the cave consists of only one room, which is not very big, but will still be littered from time to time. The better side of this means we will not have to contend with The Florida Speleologist Vol. 35 No. 1 Winter 1999 an entire cave cleanup. We will only have to clean this one room on occasion. Also if the locals are not totally locked out of the cave they may not try to breach the gate. Well we are all set for the gating project at Jennings Cave. We will meet at Ken Peakman's house at 9:30AM 02/27/99. That part went fine. Next we all went to the Steel Scrap yard where we spent the next 2.3 hours running around like children looking for construction materials to build a tree fort. We finally decided on assorted pieces of steel that amounted to 470 pounds. That translated into $117.50 of metal. Then we ventured to the Rental Zoo. There we were supposed to pick up the Welder, Cutting Torches, some welding rods and some soapstone. Well we got a little sidetracked with all the Climbing gear hanging on the wall of the showroom. Of course nothing had a price on it, so a few queries were made and the general consensus was; eh we'll buy it from Paul Smith! Anyway we got all the equipment loaded up and left the premises just after noon (they close at noon). When we arrived at Jennings Cave we immediately came up with a game plan and started the execution. Then we realized the rental place never gave us the welding rods we paid for. Oh well, we will have to make do with these crappy 7018 rods that drip like butter melting while welding overhead. We all dropped the pit and examined the gating location. Determined what we needed to cut first and how we were going to hang it. Then we climbed out of the pit. We brought with us a 55-gallon drum full of water for the purpose of wetting down the ground thoroughly before cutting or welding. But, when we started the siphon, we found that if a fire did start, this hose would never be able to extinguish it. It had the pressure of a 90-year-old man with kidney stones trying to urinate! So we regrouped, and decided to do all the Cutting and Welding down inside the entrance pit. Now we had to lower all the steel that we purchased. We also had to position the Page 9 welder as close as possible to the pit so the leads would reach the gate. Luckily, the torch hoses were long enough to reach the gate from the surface. Well we are really making progress now time approximately 3:30PM. Crank it up was the call! The Welder came alive. We have electric! The lights came on inside the cave and I made a test weld to check the heat settings. Its not hot enough I hollered! Turn the welder up Quinton screamed to Robert who was on the surface. Robert hollered back, WHAT? Quinton made the same request. Robert said, I can't hear you, WHAT? Quinton from deep inside his lungs finally communicated our request. This went on for what seemed like 10 iterations. Finally we were ready for business. Brian said ok, lets dig here, chip here, cut a piece 81" long, drill here.....And hey, we were making progress. This was great. Hammering, drilling, cutting, welding, I felt like saying (or maybe I did) "Oh grunt, grunt, grunt, more power" kind of The Florida Speleologist Vol. 35 No. 1 Winter 1999 sounded like "Tim The Tool man Taylor" We got the top piece in place and we could barely see due to the smoke within the tight quarters we were working in, this of course was compounded by the leaves on fire in the bottom of the pit and the constant forgetfulness of having welding glasses on your face. Bang, bang, bang, pop, spit, sizzle, cough, gag, ouch, cramps in our legs and hands, well alright we got the frame in place. What time is it? 8:35PM, Quinton said. WHAT, WHAT, yep that’s right we been working for 5 hours already. Good grief, will we ever get done! Lets take five and get some clean air in our lungs. but in the process the Welder was wreaking havoc on our patients. Every time we struck a bead, the welder would cough, spit and sputter and some times die. When it did die, we only had a mini-mag light to see with inside the cave. This really bites! CRANK IT BACK UP! We hollered. Time and time again this would happen. Then I asked what time it was. Quinton said it's 11:30PM. So we decided we had enough and would just have to come back the gate the vandals would surely sabotage what we did accomplish. So we milked another 30 minutes out of the welder to secure what we have done. next week and finish the job. But heck, if we do not secure up. Finally at 12:05AM we were on the road. Picture below shows “Brian getting ready to secure the swinging gate so vandals could not destroy what we did get accomplished.” (photo by Bill Birdsall) Ok, kill it, booooggggg the welder died. Ok let’s haul up this stuff. Cleanup and pack it The Picture below shows “Sullivan Beck at the Frame of the Gate” (photo by Bill Birdsall) Back to work. Ok, now we are building the actual swinging gate. We got that framed, Interesting though was the amount of visitors we had during the day/night. People with beers wanting to go into the cave, Kids 5-10 years old wanting to go, a concerned neighbor wondering what all the noise was and even late night teenagers, yes 11:00PM wanting to see the cave. These teens left then returned back on foot asking for our Page 10 The Florida Speleologist Vol. 35 No. 1 Winter 1999 help. They were stuck in sugar sand. But we were not in any position to help them. I guess they got out. When we left I followed the foot tracks to the turn with all the sugar sand and saw testosterone surrounding deep rutts that lead out to the road where the footprints disappeared. On March 27th 1999 we got together again and finished the gate. Later in the month of August we discovered that the gate had been breached (dug under). So on August 26th we added 40’ of steel rebar (to make a underground gate) and 18 bags of concrete to seal the underground gate. From here on out it is known as the Alcatraz gate. It is one solid sucker! The total Gate Cost was: $656.13 Tampa Bay Area Grotto donated $200, Central Florida Cavers Grotto also Donated $200, Larry and Nancy Rueff donated an additional $50 toward the repair of the gate and ultimately to the SCCI. Since the gate was installed the cave has had a few bats in it from time to time and we are expecting a colony to reestablish itself in the cave soon. There were more people included in the entire project then were referenced in this ful and sensitive caving partners would comment how they just thought I was kidding because my cry for help sounded kind of “sissy”. When you look at the incident reports compiled by the Bill Birdsall, Lisa Sandlin, NSS it is very easy to take Jerry M. Johnson, Jon and each one and say,"That would Deb Singley, Bill Oldacre, never happen to me", or Ken Peakman, Bill Walker, "Man, they made a really stuCaren and Sullivan Beck, Al- pid mistake". After this little bert and Mardi Krause, Brian adventure I can honestly say, Williams, Quinton Howe, that it can happen to you and John and Bev Harris, Robin yes, you can make a stupid Phillips, Randy and Coleen mistake. Guthrie, Robert Munyer, Let's start at the beginning. Warren and Jennifer Otto, The old "cave dog" Quinton Eric Amsbury, and Irv Ster- Howe had obtained permisling sion from Mr. Van Murphy for us to explore several known sinkholes on his propKen Peakman erty and look for new ones. NSS# 44202 As most people know it is sometimes difficult to obtain I Learned About Safety permission to explore someone's property. Most people From That are hesitant due to the liability (The discovery of Murphy's involved. Mr. Murphy was Law Cave) generous enough to allow us Brian Williams and Quinton access after we signed a liabilHowe ity release form. We always “Help, help, help!!!!! Get a start by telling Mr. Murphy in rope… .I’m not kidding!!!!!” advance we are planning on My throat began to tighten coming out to look around and my voice rose from a and about what time we will moderately alarmed request to be through. The first day we arrived at a high-pitched cry of desperation. What had started out as the farm he wanted us to an uneventful day of ridge- check out a solution pipe that walking had just become a had formed in one of his fields rather tenuous “situation” about 4 years ago. There with a possible unpleasant were ferns beginning to grow outcome. Upon reflection of around the hole and we could the incident later, my wonder- not see the bottom, something article. I would like to list their names here and now. I apologize if I have left anyone out as I am certain I have I just cannot remember their names: Page 11 The Florida Speleologist Vol. 35 No. 1 Winter 1999 to get excited about already. As we all know most solution pipes don't do much more than go straight down and bottom out. This one turned out to be a nice surprise. It was a 40 ft. drop to the bottom with a small opening you could slide through and pop into a good sized room. (30ft long, 12ft. wide and 6 ft. high in some places?). We discovered a few fossilized crabs in the ceiling and at least 3 bats were already calling it home. There was some standing water off to the side in the bottom fissures that looked deep as it undercut the walls. We decided to name this one "Cindy Sink" because Mr. Murphy's daughter-in-law (Cindy) was living in a trailer about 100 yards from the hole. The walls of the pipe were a little unstable as well as the inside of the cave at the bottom. Although there is a possibility of more passage here it seemed wise to avoid alot of digging in this hole. We moved on. The next few sinks we explored were of not much consequence other than a beautiful old sink about 30 ft across and 20 ft. deep. Mr. Murphy told us he had seen a big rattlesnake down in this sink before so Quinton graciously allowed me to drop down and check it out. No rattlesnakes this time but on a subsequent trip I dropped into the sink to find a small diamondback curled up on some branches at the bottom. The sides are very steep and it was obvious that he had fallen in and could not get back out. Of course we intervened in natures plan and rescued the little guy as it was a cold day and getting colder that evening. Quinton did not seemed real thrilled about riding around the rest of the day with a rattlesnake for company, go figure. The next trip to the farm was not until a month later and that story is really what this article is all about. After informing Mr. Murphy of our plans we headed to the woods to look for anything new. Most of the land is planted pines with field roads crisscrossing the property. It makes for some relatively easy cave hunting as we could road cruise most of the land while looking out through the forest for tell-tale signs of sinkholes. The ground underneath the pines was unobstructed by underbrush and it was a simple matter to see a depression or a lone patch of ferns, hop out, check it out and move on. So it wasn't your typical "ridgewalking" but hey, were lazy ok? Many of the sinks we encountered that day were the typical Florida sinkhole, i.e., filled with trash and debris. What's the most prominent piece of trash encountered you might ask? There is the usual scrap wood, tin, appliances,etc, but it seems that Page 12 somewhere underneath all this there is always a bundle of old fence wire that has been rolled up and discarded down at the bottom. Keep this in mind as it plays a key role in the next sequence of events. We spent the better part of the day walking down into these sinks and checking if there still might be any openings underneath the debris that would be worth clearing the hole out to explore. Our method consisted of taking a flashlight and probing under the debris while walking on top of it. Many sinkholes later we had developed somewhat of a complacent attitude towards holes full of trash. This is another key piece of information that contributed to the following fiasco. First, here are a few rules for safe caving while exploring trash filled sinkholes: 1) Never assume that the trash you see is at the actual "bottom" of t he hole. 2) Never stand in the bot tom of a shallow solu tion pipe and yell "Help, help, get a rope",unless you really mean it. 3) Never ever assume someone is just kid ding when they are in a solution pipe yelling,"Help, help,get a rope", even if you can still see the top of their helmet. The Florida Speleologist Vol. 35 No. 1 Winter 1999 One more poignant observation. Yelling (or screeching) "help" three times in a row doesn't necessarily convince your caving partners that you really are in need of assistance. And now for Quintons version of events that day: My recollection of events may differ somewhat from Brian's. For example, he may not be as apt to state, as he so freely did that afternoon, that "We all know solution pipes don't ever open up into anything good." In fact, this is the last statement I remember Brian saying in his natural voice before "it" happened. Let me try to describe the scene. It was approximately 4:30 in the afternoon. We had walked for miles, dropped and climbed several pits, plowed through mountains of discarded wire and assorted trash, wrangled a rattlesnake from one pit for God's sake, and to top it off we hadn't even stopped for lunch. So we arrive at the last two pits of the day. Two solution pipes approximately 10 ft. apart. Trash filled, briar laden (the kind with big thorns), vine overgrown (also big thorns), and surrounded with rusted barbed wire (big rusted thorns). After some pulling, poking and prodding to remove some trash from the area, and Brian from the truck, Sean and I decided it was time for a break. As we sat comfortably atop the trash in one of the pits, (comfort is relative when your sweaty, dirty, hungry and breathing knats ), Sean kicks back to relax while I enjoy a good 'ole "Baker county redneck" chew. Brian is preparing to slide down into the other pipe muttering something about solution pipes never going anywhere, when his voice suddenly changed inflection to sound like a screeching bat colony from hell. Help, Help, Help!!!!.....Get a rope........QUICK!!!!!! Yea, right. Who does he think he's fooling? I can still see the top of his helmet. Then the disturbance grew increasingly annoying and I realized that the rumbling noise was not my stomach but actually the resonating sound of rocks plummeting to the bottom of a very deep hole. I'M NOT KIDDING!!!!!.......GET A *# $@#!&*! ROPE!!!!!! "Hey Sean, I don't think he's kidding." As I scurried over to where the commotion was coming from, I saw my good buddy Brian perched very precariously about five ft. down the pipe with one elbow crammed into a nook in the wall and holding on to a rotten, barbed wire-wrapped crosstie. Surprisingly he was very still and we noticed there was nothing below his dangling feet other than a bundle of old fence wire and the dis- Page 13 tant sound of the birth of a breakdown pile. Well I'll be damn, guess we better get a rope. In less time than it would take to split Brian's gear, we had a hand line rigged Brian pulled back up to safety. In retrospect, we probably could've pulled up a pick-up truck with all the adrenaline pumping through our veins. Hey this is just like one of those accident reports you read about in the NSS bulletin. Not good. When the dust had cleared and Brian was able to breathe again and I remembered to spit, it was then we had a chance to make fun of Brian's somewhat feminine cry for help as well as review the incident in depth. 1) Good: We had a rope already rigged for quick hookup to a nearby tree. 2) Bad: No one was wearing a harness or tied into a rope. 3) Good: It re-affirmed the importance of having caving partners (even if they're not as sensitive and understanding as Quinton and Sean). 4) Bad: Reaction times greatly diminish when cholesterol levels become dangerously low toward then end of a long caving day. 5) Good: No one was injured. 6) Bad: No gear to split up between the survivors. The next order of business The Florida Speleologist Vol. 35 No. 1 Winter 1999 was to assess the hole and make a plan. We determined that the roll of fence wire (that had lured Brian into thinking it was at the bottom), either had to come up or go down before we could investigate further. Since there was probably already plenty of trash in the pit, we decided it should come out. This didn't look too difficult but no one said so for fear of jinxing the pit. Sean rigged a rope for me to safety to and Brian backed the truck close enough to the hole to "mechanically" assist the wire removal. Within minutes we were successful and had the wire out of the hole as Brian rigged for the reconnaissance drop. As Sean and I peered over the edge we could see the helmet light slowly get dimmer and realized that it would have been a nasty little drop if things had have gone poorly. As the rope went slack we scanned the darkness with anticipation and awaited the verdict. Would this be another sand, trash and rocked choked pipe as we had encountered so many times previously that day? As the helmet light disappeared briefly then swung upward, I knew from past experiences we were about to get the answer. "Boys, we got a cave here. You guys coming down or what?" On a subsequent trip to survey the cave with the help of Sullivan and Caren Beck we found the solution pipe shaft to be a mere 31 ft. But as we all know it can be a long 31 ft. if you are "air rappelling". It was exciting to go down a solution pipe and actually find a fairly large cave chamber. No bats yet but lets hope they find a new home now that the debris has been removed to allow for access. Two fossilized teeth were also found in the substrate of the floor but have not been identified yet. On our first exploration of the cave we spent about 3 hours on a dig which connected to a room under the boulder choked second solution pipe. There are a few more possibilities in this cave due to the amount of water that is creating a hole in the floor near the back of the big room. Above this hole is also a fissure crack that appears to go but is quite tight. We also went back on one trip to clean underbrush and install a barbed wire fence around the solution pipes. The last trip involved a tape and compass survey of the cave. (See map). There are other possibilities on the Murphy farm and we have heard stories of one cave that had many rooms and running water but unfortunately the entrance has been filled with Page 14 debris and it will take quite a bit of sweat to clear it away. Sounds like a project for cooler weather to me. See The Maps of Murphy’s Cave on page 21. The Caving Experience by Marbie Caruso After a long hiatus called “mothering” I decided to get a life again and started caving. When I was in high school I fell in with a band of cavers and we did many interesting caves in West Virginia. You can tell how long ago that was because back then we were called spelunkers. Basically my daughter Rachel and I love all the thrills, chills, mud and bruises. The only part of caving I don’t like is the laundry. Doesn’t any body make disposable caving clothes? There are many aspects of caving that I enjoy. One being I always go home with the mementos of an active weekend. Whether it is the bruise I get to watch change colors all week or the great stories I can relate to my eighth grade students. I also enjoy the total concentration that is required for caving. My mind is completely focused on what I am doing, talk about a great escape! I can honestly say I have never found myself bal- The Florida Speleologist Vol. 35 No. 1 Winter 1999 ancing a checkbook or replaying a mother/daughter scenario while negotiating some tight crawlway. I have met wonderful people who have offered their time, equipment, and patience to introduce Rachel and me to Florida caving. These new friends are dynamic and outgoing and contribute qualities that enrich my life. Another fun aspect of caving is the indulgence of acquiring new and shiny gear. Holiday’s gift giving and receiving has changed with each new piece of equipment. I can now “clank” almost as well as my long time caving buds. As each weekend rolls by I look forward to getting out and getting under! One of my favorite excursions has got to be Roosevelt Cave. Water, mud and more mud, almost fulfilled my dream of being reincarnated as a hippo. Another favorite was Dead Man’s Cave. It’s quite exhilarating as you free hang from a hole in the ceiling of a huge (for Florida) room. Briars was the most beautiful and bonus, more mud and lots of water only this I have the rust colored memories to remain on my clothes forever. “Don’t worry, I will bring the maps!” -from the cave journal of Caren Beck Famous last words!! I’m sorry, I know that next time I will not get elected to bring the maps!!! Besides, I didn’t forget totally, they were all in neat stacks, protected in individual zip-lock bags, stashed away in a cozy folder, zipped up in a backpack, and unfortunately, alone in a far- away chalet. Now the chalet was a great idea! It was cozy, kind of like camp!! And so the stories flowed, and I think Brian and Quinton became a little closer friends from the experience of the loft. If not closer friends then definitely shorter, because the head clearance for the loft was about like that of the shower... which isn’t saying much (read very low). On November 7, 1998, eight members of the FSS converged upon Cemetery Pit, Rising Fawn, Georgia. This is a very well known and popular cave and we were forced to wait and watch as a entertaining group of cavers(?) consisting of two novice cavers, two seminovice cavers, and a ring leader, began the descent ahead of us. The novices, who had both repelled one time previously and Page 15 had never been in a cave before, however, they each had brand new Petzl duo lights, sans hard hats, as they ventured down the pit. (Please keep clear of the rock zone:)) What a splendid place to try a second drop!! The aforementioned ring-leader taught an interesting short course entitled ‘how not to live to see tomorrow’ in which he performed a tap dancing trick on the edge of the 154 foot drop. We actually saw him slip (un-safetyed) on the edge as he attempted to attach his rappel device!! This feat was not amusing to those of us who watched and we silently envisioned our recreational trip turning into one of body recovery. The short course on ‘the safe and appropriate usage of descending devices’ just prior to entry into the cave was invaluable! After the daredevil cavers entered, we rigged our own rope and completed the drop without event, although we did think of a safer rigging (using a second bolt to backup) after half of the group was down (better late then never). Once down, Sullivan proceeded to do his famous ferret trick and tunnel into a weasel hole that had been dug out. He successfully maneuvered into the hole, and was embraced by the feeling of mild panic (briefly) as the walls began to close and he felt that his hips were stuck in the descending hole at the end of an ever dwindling s-shaped tunnel. Fortunately, coveralls are expendable and do add bulk, so at their The Florida Speleologist Vol. 35 No. 1 Winter 1999 expense, Sullivan was able to free himself from the cave’s hungry jaws. Coveralls were retrieved . We headed at a steady pace towards the register room. We all challenged and conquered Earl’s ledge, a narrow 1.5 foot wide and 8 feet long traverse that overlooks a 40 foot drop. Warning: It gives the illusion of shrinking to 5 inches wide when you scramble over it. We rigged a simple traverse line with webbing and each of us creatively navigated the pass by way of butt -slithering or stomachsliding. Once we had descended into the register room, we took pictures and convinced ourselves (after looking up at the 40 foot ledge we just passed) that we might actually be as nuts as the first cave group that entered. (Not quite we hope!) The trip proceeded in a round-about manner (see paragraph one for explanation) and we groped our way through mud and stream passage to the waterfall area and back. The real fun started when it was time to climb out of the cave. Of course, by fate, the other caving party had the same idea at the same time, so it was a little crowded at the bottom. This would have been OK, but the other group was constantly shouting up the pit. (You have to do this when you have only three harnesses and 5 people! I don’t know about you, but I don’t go into anything that I can’t get back out of alone.) Then the rope (the one they were using to shuttle down the precious community harness) got tangled up. Not to mention the novice (second time on rope) that as- cended too close to the rig point and jammed up his Petzl ascender. His buddy (ring leader) had to repeat the tap dance jig in order to free enough weight from the loaded device to remove it from the rope... again our stomachs lurched. Both parties successfully managed to climb from Cemetery’s pit with the motivating thought a of nice, greasy (insert your favorite post-cave delicacy here) and a tall cold (insert your favorite post-cave beverage here). Fond lasting memories: Caren: Being ostracized for forgetting the maps. Brian: Photograph time. Lets try to paint it from here. Lets strobe it a little to your right Kevin. A little more. OK, now just a little more...Great! Now stay right there. OK Kevin, Kevin? Jennifer Langford: (while nursing a cold... nothing can stop the determined… If I could just breath. I’m not asking for much really one nostril clear would be sufficient. I sure hope they know how to make hot tea at the Huddle House. The back bedroom: quiet, warm, soft bed, soft pillow, stiff pillow case, all Jennifer’s Position: Bent over a steaming bowl of water with a towel over the head Goal: One nostril Head: Might explode if we change altitudes too quickly Solution: Drugs and Dr. Jim Beam Sullivan: Definitely worth losing your coveralls over!! Brian and Quinton: Telling stories of the past, getting very mellow and a little bit sloppy. Admiring how Dr. JB can cure one of any and all cave pains. Kevin: It’s dark in here. Brian: Ugh, Kevin?? You OK? Kevin: After my broken bones healed, I was informed that 3 good slides were developed out of the entire two rolls of film. Quinton: I thought I was actually going to have a map!! Quinton and Jennifer: We LOVE new gear!! Jennifer Greene: OFF (pause and insert favorite explicative) ROPE!!!!!!! Page 16 Bright and early the next morning, (well it was morning anyway) away we went for another exciting cave trip. Destination: “ Rusty’s”. “Say, did anybody bring a map?” Tennessee Alabama Georgia Caving 1999 Brian Houha "Maybe I should have taken up dancing like Tom Willey has. He meets a lot of girls and doesn’t get into jams like this," I thought after The Florida Speleologist Vol. 35 No. 1 Winter 1999 I had attached my safety jumar to the rope above my rappel rack where the rope was falling apart before my eyes. The sheath had pulled apart and bunched up between my brake bars and wouldn’t feed through. The upper bars had only strands from the core feeding through. Without the sheath, the core looked awfully thin – like strands of kite string. I knew ninety percent of the strength of the rope lies in the core but I had never seen a sheath of a rope separate. Was the core damaged too? Tom Mook, Rod, Pat, and Becky Yost and I were bouncing Rahlston Pit near South Pittsburgh, Tennessee. We had followed a flagged trail up a hillside until we found three strips of flagging tape above a rock ledge. Rod had picked this one but forgot to bring the map of the cave and no one remembered which drop was 79 feet and which was 60 feet. We would have to descend the first drop and figure out how to rig the second. We rigged both ropes to a tree above the pit and lowered each down. Tom decided to try to get by with the shorter rope. Looking down into the depths, the entrance resembled a cross. The pit was in the middle of the intersection of two ancient upper level passageways. The pit had fluted walls cut by water seeping through a fault line in the sandstone cap. The walls were six to eight feet apart. It was quite lovely and I couldn’t wait to descend into it. There was a ledge around 35 feet down and the rope disappeared in the darkness beyond that. I would descend to the ledge, see if the rope was at the bottom, and continue my descent. When I arrived at the ledge, I found the rope bag about twenty feet from the floor. I told Rod and Tom to send down the longer rope. Down it came and I attached to it and had them haul up the short one. I continued my descent until the problem occurred. I sat about forty feet from the floor doing a change over (the time spent practicing in a prusik stand paid off). I climbed out and we pulled up the damaged rope. The sheath had separated not only where my rack had pulled it apart but also at the tail where I had tied a bowline. The stress of the knot was enough to destroy the sheath. We figured Tom’s rope had somehow been exposed to acid. We could pull the sheath fibers apart like cotton. Perhaps it came from his Wheatlamp battery. I have no idea. I told Tom he is so meticulous with things that I could only conclude he had done this on purpose so he wouldn’t have to hear any more of my jokes. I have a shirt that has printed, "Cave Safely. If you die we split your gear." I told everyone I knew how much they wanted my folding lounge chair I had bought at Wall Mart. Rod had gone down the mountain for another rope but forgot to bring the map. We all descended both drops and ended our descent in a tall canyon room. Tom said the cave had 300 feet of horizontal passage that looped so there would be no back tracking. It sounded so easy I didn’t take off my vertical gear. After 50 feet the canyons turned into a crawlway. We pushed a lot of tight crawls but never found a loop so we had to retrace our way in. Next time I will remember to bring the map myself and also bring kneepads. The girls found cave crayfish in a stream and we found a waterfall at Page 17 the end of a canyon. All of us were quite impressed with this beautiful pit. The day before Bill Birdsall and I joined a group to descend Moses Tomb. Seven years ago John Harris lost control rappelling into this 220 ft pit, broke his back and ended up on "Rescue 911". The entrance was a small hole on a rocky mountainside. After the rope touched a tilted slab about 30 feet down, the drop was free into a wide cylindrical shaft. We found frogs and salamanders at the bottom of the pit. As the others climbed up, Bill and I watched large water droplets release from a stalactite at 10 second intervals. Each would sail down from the darkness high above quivering like jello. It was great entertainment. I was last to exit. There is a flowstone wall from ceiling to floor which is decorated with shields, stalactites, and stalagmites. Climbing out of this pit is climbing the equivalent of a 22 story building so there are some rest stops on the way up the rope when one can just hang in the seat harness and admire the sights – beautiful decorations of stone and a light beam from that little entrance hole high overhead. Rains caused me to pack up a day early and start heading for home. I spent time visiting with a lot of old friends and making some new ones so it turned out to be a nice vacation. Patty and Jen at the Speedway quarry w a l l . (photo by Brian Williams) The Florida Speleologist Vol. 35 No. 1 Winter 1999 Election time Again by Sullivan Beck This year we met several times to discuss problems with the current voting procedure (or lack of procedure in some instances). We have tried several different voting procedures over the last few years, none of which have been totally satisfactory. An ideal election (for this club) has to meet several criteria: o o o It has to be fair Everyone should be able to vote for board members, and AT LEAST the President. Voting for other officers (V.P., Secretary, Treasurer) are optional. The election needs to be able to be conducted by mail with only two mailings. The election method we have come up with meets these criteria, and we plan to use it in this and future elections. The plan is fairly simple. At the first meeting in December (Dec. 9), nominations are opened. The purpose of this mailing is to solicit nominations for board member. Any number of nominations can be submitted. Nominations will be closed on the first meeting in January (Jan. 1 3). Ballots will then be prepared with all of the nominees and will be mailed to all club members. Along with this mailing, we will send a reminder to those club members who have not paid their dues. Dues should be sent in with the ballot (or before) in order to be able to vote. Members will mail in their ballots, or may cast their vote at the annual meeting held on the 2nd Thursday in February (Feb 10). Ballots MUST be received before this meeting. Based on the voting, the 7 board members will be chosen, and one will be chosen as President. To vote, each member will select 7 of the nominees to vote for. Then, the member will assign the numbers 1 through 7 to these, 1 being their first choice for President, 2 being their second choice, etc. The board will be chosen based on the 7 nominees who receive the most votes for board member (regardless of their ranking). Then, the 7 board members will have their ranking on all of the ballots added up, and the one with the highest rank (i.e. the lowest total number) will be offered the position of President. A more complete description of the election procedure (including many of the details that have been omitted here) are on the web. They can be seen at the URL: http://www.cise.ufl.edu/~sbeck/fss/ This will be made part of the standard FSS web page. Two other changes have been made this year which affect the club elections. First, the bylaws have been modified slightly to reflect the new election procedure. The deadlines have been changed, and the e lection Page 18 The Florida Speleologist Vol. 35 No. 1 Winter 1999 procedure clarified somewhat to spell out what is required during a club election. The club bylaws (with these changes) and constitution are also available at the above URL. Second, the membership has voted to make club dues (still $15 per year, $5 per year for additional family members) due on Jan 1 of each year. This will greatly simplify keeping track of membership dues. New members will be prorated the year they join (and current members who's dues are paid up until sometime in 2000 will also be prorated). In the second election mailing, we will tell each member their status. Only members who have paid their dues (which can be sent in with the ballot) will be able to vote. One additional change will be made this year. The NSS is now requesting the annual report by the end of January, NOT the end of February. In order to allow us to have the most recent board listed in the NSS members guide, we will move the elections forward one month so nominations will begin in November, ballots will be send in December, and the election will be held in January. Sullivan N. Beck NSS# 43957 President F.S.S. Page 19 The Florida Speleologist Vol. 35 No. 1 Winter 1999 Air and water quality problems in Caves by Sullivan N. Beck Recently, a disturbing change has occurred in the Ocala area caves. In the middle of September, a group of us went to visit Briar cave. We made it back to the melody room fine, but a number of people in the party noticed that they were breathing very hard. Two of the people in the group had cigarette lighters, so we checked the air, and neither of the lighters would light. Carbon dioxide levels appear to have returned to normal at this point, though we continue to monitor the situation. We are also looking into the possibility of having water samples routinely monitored in several of the Ocala caves in order to determine the cause of this. Gainesville caves (Warrens and Bat) were not affected. We also did not check on caves in the Belleview area (Tucks). We exited the cave quickly and without incident, checking the air quality at several points along the way. It was only when we got to the room at the very entrance of the cave that either lighter would light, and even then, the flame was well above the lighter. A week later, a group entered Blue Canyon and immediately noticed problems breathing. Again, this was confirmed using a cigarette lighter. At this point, we decided we needed to visit each of several caves to check the quality of air, and to take water samples for testing. On Oct 2, we visited 5 caves: Blue Canyon, White Cliff, Briar, Catacombs, and Roosevelt. At White Cliff, a lighter would light in the lower level, but the flame was well above the lighter. We did manage to get a water sample from the area near The Loop. In all four of the remaining caves, the lighters would not light even just inside the entrance of the caves. Breathing was very labored in all cases, and clouds of mosquitoes hovered at the entrance of the cave. This is Bill Birdsall with a butane lighter in Briar Cave. As you can see this is an indication that Oxygen levels at at approximately 10% This is a dangerous level and one should exit the cave immediately upon discovery. The water samples were tested for coliform levels, and all were well below dangerous levels. No other tests were performed at that time. Page 20 The Florida Speleologist Vol. 35 No. 1 Winter 1999 Page 21 The Florida Speleologist Vol. 35 No. 1 Winter 1999 Group Photo Taken in Waterfall Cave By our very own photo fanatic Caren Beck. From left to right– Bill Walker, Brian Williams, Eric Amsbury, Sullivan Beck, Jo-Jo Amsbury and the Good Looking guy in the center is your editor Ken Peakman The Florida Speleological Society, Inc. P.O. Box 12581 University Station Gainesville, Florida 32604-2581 Page 22