March 18, 2016 - Cheese Reporter
Transcription
March 18, 2016 - Cheese Reporter
Serving the Since 1876 ry Weekly ust 's Dairy I nd orld W CHEESE REPORTER Vol. 140, No. 39 • Friday, March 18, 2016 • Madison, Wisconsin Senate Defeats Biotech Labeling Bill; Roberts Vows To Keep Trying Walmart To Build New 250,000-Square-Foot Milk Processing Plant In Fort Wayne, IN Both Proponents, Foes Of Voluntary Labeling Want Federal Solution Fort Wayne, IN—Walmart, the largest US grocer, today announced plans to establish a fluid milk processing plant in Fort Wayne, IN. Construction is expected to begin this summer on a more than 250,000-square-foot milk processing plant, which is expected to be one of the largest in the industry. Walmart said the plant will leverage the latest technologies to produce Great Value and Member’s Mark white and chocolate milk for more than 600 Walmart stores and Sam’s Club locations in Indiana, Illinois, Michigan, Ohio and northern Kentucky. Walmart estimates that milk processing at the new facility will begin in the summer of 2017. “By operating our own plant and working directly with the dairy supply chain in the Midwest, we’ll further reduce operating costs and pass those savings on to our customers so that they can save money,” said Tony Airoso, senior vice president of sourcing strategy for Walmart US. “This facility is an example of how we are always finding efficiencies within the supply chain to deliver everyday low prices and high quality groceries,” Airoso added. Walmart’s announcement comes on the heels of Indiana’s 2015 dairy strategy, commissioned by the Indiana State Department of Agriculture (ISDA), to grow the state’s dairy industry by increasing Washington—The US Senate on Wednesday failed to invoke cloture on the Biotechnology Labeling Solutions Bill, which is authored by US Sen. Pat Roberts (R-KS), chairman of the Senate Agriculture Committee. Roberts himself, and supporters of his legislation, including the Coalition for Safe Affordable Food, vowed to continue working for a solution to the biotechnology labeling issue in the near future. In early March, the Senate Ag Committee passed a bill that would have created a voluntary national standard for biotechnology (GMO) labeling claims on foods. Roberts said he heard concerns that a voluntary-only standard would not provide consumers with enough information, so “we worked out a compromise to address these concerns by providing an incentive for the marketplace to provide more information.” In Effort To Support Dairy Farmers, EU Hikes Intervention Ceilings, OKs Voluntary Milk Supply Management Brussels, Belgium—The European Commission on Monday announced an additional package of measures to support European Union (EU) dairy and other farmers while safeguarding the EU internal market. Among other things, the Commission will activate, for a limited period of time, the possibility to enable producer organizations, interbranch organizations and cooperatives in the dairy sector to establish voluntary agreements on their production and supply. This is the so-called Article 222 from the Common Market Organization (CMO), which is specific to • See EU Dairy Measures, p. 6 Under his proposal that failed to win approval from the full Senate, a mandatory labeling program would go into effect only if the voluntary program did not provide significant information after several years. The marketplace would then have had adequate time to adjust and utilize a variety of options to disclose information about ingredients, Roberts explained. “If we do not act, everyone loses. I have acted to provide a responsible, enforceable, scientific and proactive approach to arm consumers with the information they want to make informed choices about what to put on the dinner table,” Roberts commented. “I remain at the ready to work on a solution to a critical problem that will face every American every day.” Despite Wednesday’s vote, “we believe a bipartisan federal policy is within reach, based on discussions with Senate offices in the last few days. We are committed to working to bridge differences and get a compromise agreement through the Senate,” said Jim Mulhern, president and CEO of National Milk Producers Federation (NMPF). “Passage of a coherent food label disclosure law by Congress is the only logical approach in order to avoid the chaotic mess that would arise from leaving this issue up to the whims of 50 different states.” Zippy Duvall, president of the American Farm Bureau Federation, said it was “inexcusable” that the Senate vote on the Roberts legislation fell short. Roger Johnson, president of National Farmers Union, said any compromise agreement reached by Congress “should not limit the freedom of agricultural producers and processors to accurately advertise, label and promote products as nongenetically altered.” “Despite the outcome today, this issue and the need to resolve it will not go away,” said Chuck Conner, president of the National Council of Farmer Cooperatives. “There continues to be ongoing discussions with senators from both sides of the aisle on finding a compromise that can achieve broad-based Senate support. • See Biotech Labeling, p. 4 EU Cheese Production, Exports To Grow In 2016, But Exports Won’t Reach 2013 Levels Washington—Structural change in US milk production, along with changes in dairy product markets, have contributed to increased dairy price volatility in recent years and also have affected the design and impacts of dairy policy, according to a new study. Changing Structure, Financial Risks, and Government Policy for the US Dairy Industry, released earlier this month by USDA’s Economic Research (ERS), focuses on the four interrelated issues of structural change, changes in product markets, price risks, and dairy policy. Structural change encompasses changes in farm size, farm ownership and organization, the location of production, and farming practices. Two decades ago, most milk came from farms with fewer than 150 cows, on which a farm family handled milking, herd management, and crop production for feed, the report noted. Today, most milk comes from farms with more than 900 cows; while most of these farms are owned and operated by a family, most of the labor is provided by hired workers and many farms purchase most or all of their feed. Costs are a driving force behind structural change, the report said. The largest farms earn substantially higher net returns per hundredweight of milk produced, and they have strong incentives to expand. Over time, as farms expand and realize lower costs, they also expand industry production. Increases in production reduce • See Structural Change, p. 10 • See Walmart Milk Plant, p. 7 Average Cheddar Price Retail vs. CME 40-pound Block February: 2007 - 2016 Price per pound Retail CME $5.65 $5.15 $4.65 $4.15 $3.65 $3.15 $2.65 $2.15 $1.65 $1.15 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 Page 2 March 18, 2016 CHEESE REPORTER Past Issues Read this week’s issue or past issues of Cheese Reporter on your mobile phone or tablet by scanning this QR code. Cheese Reporter Publishing Co. Inc. © 2015 2810 Crossroads Drive, Suite 3000 Madison, WI 53718-7972 (608) 246-8430 • Fax (608) 246-8431 http://www.cheesereporter.com DICK GROVES Publisher/Editor e-mail: [email protected] 608-316-3791 MOIRA CROWLEY Specialty Cheese Editor e-mail: [email protected] 608-316-3793 KEVIN THOME Advertising & Marketing Director e-mail: [email protected] 608-316-3792 BETTY MERKES Classifieds/Circulation Manager e-mail: [email protected] 608-316-3790 REGULAR CONTRIBUTORS: Bob Cropp, Neville McNaughton, Dan Strongin, John Umhoefer You can e-mail our contributors at: [email protected] The Cheese Reporter is the official publication of the following associations: California Cheese & Butter Association Lisa Waters, 1011 Pebble Beach Dr, Clayton, CA 94517 Central Wisconsin Cheesemakers’ and Buttermakers’ Association Jim Mildbrand, PO Box 160 Greenwood, WI 54437 Cheese Importers Association of America 204 E St. NE, Washington, DC 20002 Eastern Wisconsin Cheesemakers’ and Buttermakers’ Association Barb Henning, Henning’s Cheese 21812 Ucker Road, Kiel, WI 53042 International Dairy-Deli-Bakery Association P.O. Box 5528, Madison, WI 53705 Missouri Butter & Cheese Institute Terry S. Long, 19107 Factory Creek Road, Jamestown, MO 65046 Nebraska Cheese Association Ed Price, Fremont, NE 68025 New York State Cheese Manufacturer’s Assn Kathyrn Boor, 11 Stocking Hall, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY 14853 North Central Cheese Industries Assn Lloyd Metzger, SDSU, Box 2104, Brookings, SD 57007 North Dakota Cheese Makers’ Assn Chuck Knetter, Medina, ND 58467 Ohio Swiss Cheese Association Darlene Miller, P.O. Box 445, Sugar Creek, OH 44681 South Dakota State Dairy Association Howard Bonnemann, SDSU, Box 2104, Brookings, SD 57007 Southwestern Wisconsin Cheese Makers’ Association Myron Olson, Chalet Cheese Coop, N4858 Cty Hwy N, Monroe, WI 53566 Wisconsin Association for Food Protection Bob Wills PO Box 620705, Middleton WI 53562 Wisconsin Cheese Makers’ Association John Umhoefer, 8030 Excelsior Drive, Suite 305, Madison, WI 53717 Wisconsin Dairy Products Association Brad Legreid, 8383 Greenway Blvd., Middleton, WI 53562 EDITORIAL COMMENT DICK GROVES Publisher / Editor Cheese Reporter e: [email protected] tw: @cheesereporter One other factor potentially limiting the growth of plant based dairy alternatives is taste. Maybe the sum of these products is greater than the parts, but most of them don’t exactly conjure up thoughts of gourmet, specialty or even average. The Potential, And Limits, Of Plant-Based ‘Dairy’ Products Last week (as we reported in a story on page 19 of last week’s issue), 23 food companies announced the launch of the Plant Based Foods Association, which is described as the first trade group to represent the $3.5 billion plant-based foods sector. This development has led us to ponder both the potential, and the potential limits, of plant-based versions of foods such as cheese, milk, yogurt, butter and ice cream. So what’s the potential for these foods? Just for starters, it’s usually a sign of future growth just when a group of companies forms a trade association. The Plant Based Foods Association plans to educate the public about the benefits of moving toward a plant-based diet, and advocate for policies that encourage shifting toward a plant-based diet, both of which should help grow the industry in the future. As far as actual sales are concerned, as noted above, the plantbased foods sector is currently a $3.5 billion “niche,” and growing. The association itself uses the phrase “fast-growing” to describe the plant-based foods sector, and there’s no doubt some truth to that, given that many of the association’s charter members didn’t exist at the turn of the century. It’s also notable that the association says plant-based milks, at $2.1 billion, are driving the category’s growth, having enjoyed 14.4 percent growth in total sales volume over the last two years. Considering what fluid milk sales have been doing in recent decades (declining in bad years, stable in good years), the sales growth for plant-based milks is pretty impressive. The association also describes the plant-based foods sector as an industry that “supports consumer health and the environment,” and we have no doubt that those are two areas that will drive growth of these foods in the future. As far as consumer health is concerned, estimates vary, but in all likelihood there are several million consumers in the US who consider themselves vegans (and 310 million or more who don’t). Why do consumers go vegan? According to The Vegan Society, there are three key reasons: preventing the exploitation of animals, for the health benefits, and for the environment. Looking more closely at each of those reasons, regarding animal welfare, it’s probably safe to say that the number of consumers who consider themselves vegans increases every time there’s a story about alleged animal abuse on a dairy farm. Such stories don’t occur all that often, but they don’t have to, to prompt more consumers to question their consumption of dairy products. The health benefits angle sort of depends on your perspective. The butter industry suffered for decades as everybody from the federal government to health organizations touted the benefits of margarine (the main ingredient of which is partially hydrogenated vegetable oil) over butter. Now the pendulum is swinging back, and indeed it’s difficult if not impossible to find anybody with anything positive to say about stick margarine. And there’s a fair amount of research about the health benefits of milkfat in the diet, as well as the detrimental impacts of eliminating milkfat from the diet. As far as environmental benefits of plant-based foods are concerned, we’re not really convinced that these products are actually better for the environment than animal-based foods. For example, Melt Organic’s spreads contain coconut oil sourced from Sri Lanka and palm fruit oil sourced from Colombia. It’s hard to believe that this product is more sustainably produced than butter is. Speaking of ingredients, the lengthy list of ingredients in some of these plant-based dairy alternatives would appear to be one of factors that will limit their growth in the future. Survey after survey has found that consumers are looking for “simple” foods, that is, foods with short ingredient lists and ingredients that they can actually pronounce. But at least some of these plant based dairy alternatives are pretty much the complete opposite of what these consumers are seeking. For example, Medium Cheddar Style Farmhouse Block from Daiya Foods contains, among its roughly 17 ingredients, such things as tapioca starch, pea protein isolate, xanthan gum, tricalcium phosphate, tricalcium citrate and pea starch. Meanwhile, regular medium Cheddar contains milk, cheese cultures, salt, enzymes and possibly annatto; or maybe just milk, salt and enzymes (depending on the brand). One of dairy’s simplest products, half and half, contains only milk and cream, but Dairy-Free Creamer from Nutpods contains not only coconut cream and almonds but also acacia gum, gellan gum, sunflower lecithin and dipotassium phosphate. Interestingly, many of these plant based dairy alternatives tout what they’re free from: the aforementioned Dairy-Free Creamer from Nutpods, for example, is free from dairy, soy, gluten, carrageenan, high-fructose corn syrup, refined sugars and sugar alcohols. But it still includes nine ingredients, which is seven more than dairy half and half. One other factor potentially limiting the growth of plant based dairy alternatives is taste. Maybe the sum of these products is greater than the parts, but most of them don’t exactly conjure up thoughts of gourmet, specialty or even average. They simply sound unappetizing, although anything is possible given today’s scientific advances. Plant-based foods now have their own trade association, which is usually a sign of future growth. Time will tell what sort of growth these foods have, given both their perceived benefits as well as their very real shortcomings. CHEESE REPORTER (Publication Number: ISSN 0009-2142). Published weekly by Cheese Reporter Publishing Co. Inc., 2810 Crossroads Drive, Suite 3000, Madison, WI 53718-7972; Phone: (608) 246-8430; Fax: (608) 246-8431. Subscriptions: $140.00 per year in USA; Canada and Mexico: $195.00 per year; other foreign subscribers, please write for rates. Advertising and Editorial material are copyrighted material. Any use without publisher’s consent is prohibited. Cheese Reporter does not endorse the products of any advertiser or any editorial material. POSTMASTER: If undeliverable, Form 35579 requested. Periodicals postage paid at Madison, WI. Address all correspondence to: Cheese Reporter, 2810 Crossroads Drive, Suite 3000, Madison, WI 53718-7972 March 18, 2016 CHEESE REPORTER Australia’s Murray Goulburn Signs Pacts With Nutrition Firms, Will Build New Powder Plant Southbank, Victoria, Australia— Murray Goulburn Cooperative (MG) this week announced that it has entered into a framework agreement to establish a strategic supply alliance with leading global pediatric nutrition company Mead Johnson Nutrition (MJN). Separately, and also this week, MG announced that it has secured a long-term nutritionals supply agreement with Indonesian consumer health and infant nutrition company, Kalbe Nutritionals. The two agreements mean that MG is now in a position to proceed with its plans to build a new stateof-the-art nutritional powders plant at Koroit in western Victoria, Australia. The Koroit facility is the largest production facility in MG’s portfolio, with an intake of close to 1 billion liters of milk per annum for the production of skim and whole milk powders, as well as a range of dairy products including cheese, butter, cream and infant formula. The signed framework agreement with MJN sets out key terms of a long-term offtake arrangement under which MJN will commit to acquire certain volumes of nutritional powders from MG on an annual basis. The two parties will now proceed to formalize the detailed terms of the supply agreement. MG said the collaboration will enable the two companies to capitalize on their complementary strengths: MG’s dairy foods and nutritional powders expertise and MJN’s excellence in infant and young child nutrition. Once final terms are formalized, MG will invest $260 to $300 million at Koroit to construct and commission its new nutritional powders facility, while MJN will co-locate a nutritional packaging plant on the site. Once completed, the parties envisage the facilities supplying finished products for sale within the Asia Pacific region, including China. The nutritional powders investment at Koroit is a key enabler of MG’s strategy to shift to more stable and higher value-added dairy products. At $260 to $300 million, MG believes it represents the largest investment in nutritional powder capacity and capability made in Australia for a decade. MG will continue to review the optimal configuration for the nutritional powders investment over the coming months to deliver both MG’s and its customers’ product specifications and demand forecasts. It is now likely that a configuration of two 45,000-tons-per-annum dryers is the optimal solution to provide the required operational flexibility and higher specification dryers while still delivering the same economic return of the originally planned single 63,000-ton-perannum dryer. This approach will see the nutritional powders investment being delivered in two stages, with the initial installation of a 45,000-tons-per-annum dryer that will be increased to up to 90,000 tons per annum as market demand increases. “Mead Johnson is pleased to be working with Murray Goulburn and to be adding additional flexibility and high-quality capacity to our global supply chain,” said Kasper Jakobsen, MJN’s chief executive officer. “We look forward to developing the relationship further in the future for the benefit of consumers across the Asia Pacific region.” “We are delighted to be partnering with Mead Johnson Nutrition, a recognized world leader when it comes to pediatric nutrition to supply the very best Australian-made nutritional powder,” said Gary Helou, MG’s managing director. “MG will now move for- ward with the plans to construct the nutritional powders plant at Koroit to initially provide a further 45,000 tons of capacity. This will be utilized to supply infant formula under our own brand, Devondale Natra Start, as well as our partners’ market-leading brands.” Kalbe Nutritionals manufactures and distributes pharmaceuticals, energy drinks and nutritional products for sale in Indonesia and Asia. It also operates a distribution and logistics division which covers all 33 Indonesian provinces and reaches approximately 1 million outlets throughout the country. The new nutritional supply agreement between Kalbe and MG builds on an existing supply partnership which has seen MG supply dairy powders for use in Kalbe’s range of nutritional products, including infant and child nutrition brands. Under the new long-term supply agreement, Murray Goulburn Cooperative has committed to supply and Kalbe has committed to purchase significant minimum annual volumes over time. Helou called Indonesia an “important Asian growth market for dairy foods,” with “one of Asia’s largest pediatric populations.” y t i l i b a t r e v n Co CrystalBanTM not only prevents calcium lactate crystals from forming in your cheese, but it also allows for more precise moisture levels. No visible crystals More precise management of moisture levels No effect on taste Better Slicing and Shredding characteristics Increased resistance to fracture CrystalBanTM Enhances The Quality & Body Of Your Cheese Nutricepts, Inc. T: 952-707-0207 E: [email protected] www.crystalban.com For more information, circle #1 on the Reader Response Card on p. 14 Page 3 Page 4 March 18, 2016 CHEESE REPORTER Biotech Labeling (Continued from p. 1) “We remain committed to finding a path forward on this issue when Congress returns after Easter recess,” Conner added. The Roberts bill was opposed by, among others, US Sen. Debbie Stabenow (D-MI), the top Democrat on the Senate Ag Committee. “Unfortunately, the Roberts proposal is nothing more than the status quo for consumers who want information about the food they are purchasing. I believe that if the federal government is going to take away states rights, we have the obligation to create a national system of disclosure that provides information to consumers in an easily accessible way,” Stabenow said. “It’s time to provide certainty to our food manufacturers and end this contentious debate by simply creating a national policy for commonsense disclosure of genetically modified ingredients.” Consumers Union, the policy and advocacy division of Consumer Reports, praised senators for voting against the Roberts bill, and urged lawmakers to move towards mandatory, national labeling. One day before the Senate’s vote on the Roberts bill, Consumers Union had urged the Senate to defeat the measure. In a letter to Senate members, Consumers Union spelled out several concerns with the Roberts bill. First, it would preempt state laws “without meaningfully replacing them,” Consumers Union said. Legislators in four states, including Vermont, have voted to require a “modest label” for foods with genetically engineered (GE) ingredients. The Roberts bill “would completely disregard citizens’ wishes by invalidating these laws and prohibiting state legislators from ever requiring labeling for GE food,” Consumers Union said. Second, the bill would create a new, duplicative voluntary disclosure program at the US Department of Agriculture (USDA). Voluntary GE food labeling has already existed for 15 years as the policy of the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA), “where it has only served to foster consumer confusion and has almost never been used by food producers.” Third, the bill only provides for voluntary disclosure of GE food to become mandatory under “extremely unlikely circumstances.” Under the Roberts bill, USDA must require mandatory GE food labeling only if less than 70 percent of labeled foods are not in “substantial participation” with voluntary GE disclosures after three years. “Almost one-third of all covered food products could have no disclosure of GE ingredients whatsoever, and nothing would be done to remedy the situation,” Consumers Union said. “Further, this benchmark could be met not only through product labeling, but also more opaque methods, such as by placing information on a website or making it accessible through a call center, all of which would be difficult for a busy supermarket shopper to access in real time while making decisions about purchases,” Consumers Union said. The chances of the voluntary program providing meaningful disclosure, or ever leading to mandatory labeling, are slim,” Consumers Union stated. Instead of passing the Roberts bill, Consumers Union called on the Senate to pass the Biotechnol- ogy Food Labeling Uniformity Act, which was recently introduced by US Sens. Jeff Merkley (D-OR), Patrick Leahy (D-VT), Jon Tester (D-MT) and Dianne Feinstein (D-CA). That bill would require food and beverage manufacturers to disclose the presence of genetically modified (GM) ingredients on the Nutrition Facts panel of packaged food and beverage products in one of four ways: Use a parenthesis following the relevant ingredient to indicate that this ingredient is “Genetically Engineered.” Identify GM ingredients with an asterisk and provide an explanation at the bottom of the ingredients list. Apply a catch-all statement at the end of the ingredient list stating that the product was “produced with genetic engineering. FDA would have the authority to develop a symbol, in consultation with food manufacturers, that would clearly and conspicuously disclose the presence of GM ingredients on packaging. None of these options would require front-panel disclosures or warning statements intended to disparage GM ingredients. Merkley called Wednesday’s vote “a victory for American consumers,” and said he stands “ready to work with my colleagues to find a path forward that provides a national standard with a consumer-friendly solution.” “This is a significant and hardfought victory for Vermont, but this fight is not yet over,” Leahy said. “I hope that now we can all come together to find a path forward to a strong mandatory disclosure policy that can be applied across the board and across the nation.” Best Practices in Cheese Brine Disinfection Proven effective in large commercial installations. ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ Featuring BioIonix’s exclusive online disinfection efficacy estimate. ...Your indication of effective brine microbial control. ▪ ▪ ▪ Prevents Listeria positives. Continuously destroys other brine microbials. Nonstop protection against bacteria, yeast and molds. No chemicals. Powerful catalytic disinfection. No downtime. Eliminates chlorine shock treatments. Helps prevent biofilms and extends UF membrane life. How we do it: A breakthrough patented catalytic process. ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ No change to cheese color, flavor or texture. Keeps brine clean. Flocculates solids for easy skimming. No brine off-odors Automated operation. No operator required. For more information, please contact us today: Powerful SuperOxidants™ generated from the brine itself. Fully automated system adjusts disinfection strength for changing organic load. For more information, circle #2 on the Reader Response Card on p. 14 ® BioIonix, Inc. 608-838-0300 [email protected] www.bioionix.com from our archives 50 YEARS AGO March 18, 1966: Plain, WI—The Wisconsin Dairies Cooperative of Union Center has purchased the Meister Cheese Factory here this week. The transaction included trucks and cheesemaking equipment, but didn’t include the building owned by Stanley Meister. Marathon City, WI—Oren Lee Staley, president of the National Farmers Organization, this week told members that Wisconsin farmers shouldn’t oppose the sale of colored oleomargarine in the state. If the soybean farmer is getting a good price for his product, oleo isn’t going to be cheap either, Staley said. 25 YEARS AGO March 15, 1991: Madison— The Wisconsin Board of Agriculture, Trade and Consumer Protection this week approved a proposal that will require a mandatory screening test for inhibitory substances to be run on every bulk load of raw milk received by a state dairy plant before that load is co-mingled with any other milk. Washington—The American Butter Institute (ABI) recently formally petitioned FDA to establish, by regulation, a common or usual name for “Light Butter” containing 52 percent milkfat. On the principle display panel of the product would also be a comparative statement expressing the reduction in fat and calories relative to butter. 10 YEARS AGO March 17, 2006: Omaha, NE—ConAgra Foods, Inc. this week announced plans to divest its Swissrose International domestic and imported cheese business as one of several actions designed to improve long-term operating performance. Swissrose is headquartered in Moonachie, NJ, and has a plant in Mayville, WI. Washington—The Association of Dairy Cooperatives in the Northeast recently petitioned USDA to hold a hearing on proposals for a transportation credit fund for the Northeast federal milk marketing order to cover a portion of farm-toplant transportation costs not currently covered under the order for milk for Class I uses. The transportation credit fund would be funded by a “modest surcharge” on Class I milk, the co-ops noted. March 18, 2016 Global Dairy Trade Price Index Falls 2.9%; Only Lactose, Buttermilk Powder Prices Increase At End Of First Quarter, GDT Price Index Was 14% Lower Than At End Of 2015’s Fourth Quarter Auckland, New Zealand—The price index on this week’s semimonthly Global Dairy Trade (GDT) dairy commodity auction declined 2.9 percent from the previous auction, held two weeks ago. In this week’s auction, which featured 134 participating bidders and 118 winning bidders, prices were lower for Cheddar cheese, skim and whole milk powder, butter, anhydrous milkfat and rennet casein and higher for lactose and buttermilk powder. Results from this week’s GDT trading event, with comparisons to the trading event held two weeks ago, were as follows: Cheddar cheese: The average winning price was $2,441 per metric ton ($1.11 per pound), down 5.6 percent. That was for Contract 4 (July). Skim milk powder: The average winning price was $1,731 per ton (78.5 cents per pound), down 2.5 percent. Average winning prices were: Contract 1 (April), $1,690 per ton, up 1.2 percent; Contract 2 (May), $1,732 per ton, down 2 percent; Contract 3 (June), $1,726 per ton, down 3.7 percent; Contract 4, $1,715 per ton, down 2.7 percent; Contract 5 (August), $1,745 per ton, down 2 percent; and Contract 6 (September), $1,765 per ton, down 2.6 percent. Whole milk powder: The average winning price was $1,971 per ton (89.4 cents per pound), down 0.8 percent. Average winning prices were: Contract 2, $1,944 per ton, down 1 percent; Contract 3, $1,940 per ton, down 1.7 percent; Contract 4, $2,024 per ton, up 0.5 percent; Contract 5, $2,116 per ton, up 0.9 percent; and Contract 6, $2,135 per ton, up 3.5 percent. Butter: The average winning price was $2,733 per ton ($1.24 per pound), down 2.8 percent. Average winning prices were: Contract 2, $2,660 per ton, down 5.8 percent; Contract 3, $2,785 per ton, down 1.2 percent; Contract 4, $2,765 per ton, down 1.4 percent; Contract 5, $2,925 per ton, up 3.9 percent; and Contract 6, $2,965 per ton, up 3.5 percent. Anhydrous milkfat: The average winning price was $3,014 per ton ($1.37 per pound), down 6.5 percent. Average winning prices were: Contract 2, $2,920 per ton, down 9.7 percent; Contract 3, $2,991 per ton, down 6.1 percent; Contract 4, $3,154 per ton, down 3.1 percent; Contract 5, $3,256 Page 5 CHEESE REPORTER per ton, up 0.2 percent; and Contract 6, $3,142 per ton, down 6 percent. Rennet casein: The average winning price was $4,083 per ton ($1.85 per pound), down 7 percent. Average winning prices were: Contract 2, $4,042 per ton, down 8.3 percent; and Contract 3, $4,221 per ton, down 2.9 percent. Lactose: The average winning price of lactose at the GDT was $624 per ton (28.3 cents per pound), up 0.8 percent. That was for Contract 2. Buttermilk powder: The average winning price was $1,545 per ton (70.1 cents per pound), up 6.4 percent. Average winning prices were: Contract 2, $1,540 per ton, up 5.8 percent; and Buttermilk Powder Contract 3, $1,555 per ton, up 7.6 percent. The first quarter of this year was characterized by a consistent drop in the GDT price index, with five of the six trading events declining, according to the “GDT Quarterly” report, released this week. At the end of the first quarter, the index was 14 percent lower than it was at the end of 2015’s fourth quarter. This was 29 percent lower than the index 12 months ago and at its lowest level since the first trading event last August, the report noted. The average change in the GDT price index per trading event over the first quarter was minus 2.5 percent, compared with an average change of minus 0.5 percent per trading event over the fourth quarter of 2015. Price indices for all products were lower in the first quarter of 2016 compared to the fourth quarter of 2015, other than lactose, which increased by 16 percent. The deterioration in price indices between the first quarter of 2016 and the first quarter of 2015 at the Global Dairy Trade ranged from minus 47.9 percent for rennet casein to minus 17.3 percent for anhydrous milkfat. Whole milk powder, Global Dairy Trade’s most traded product, was down 28.7 percent on an annual basis. During that same period, the lactose price increased 6 percent. Over the first quarter of 2016, skim milk powder and whole milk powder attracted the highest number of participating bidders, 115 and 128, respectively. At the other end of the participating bidder spectrum, lactose attracted the fewest participating bidders, 22, followed by buttermilk powder, at 27. On average over the first quarter, 88 percent of bidders that placed bids in round 1 won product in the final round. First round demand was 31 percent lower in the first quarter of 2016 than in the fourth quarter of 2015, while supply was down 9 percent in the same timeframe. For a copy of the report, visit www.globaldairytrade.info. Market Administrators In Northeast, Central, Mideast Orders Agree On Pooling Dumped Milk Boston, MA—Pool handlers in the Northeast, Central and Mideast federal milk marketing orders have requested a relaxation of the pooling requirements for dumped milk during the spring flush and summer holiday period due to anticipated surplus supply conditions, according to Erik F. Rasmussen, market administrator of the Northeast order. The market administrators of those three orders have agreed to a temporary policy for the pooling of milk dumped at the farm or other non-plant locations due to present surplus milk conditions. The temporary plant delivery exception will be for the period of April 1 through July 15, 2016, for all three orders. Producers that take advantage of this temporary policy must have been a pool producer for all of their commercially marketed production for the months of March through July of 2016. The milk must be picked up at the farm, measured and sampled for payment. The tanker test will be a weighted average of the producer tests. E-mail: [email protected] THE STANDARD OF EXCELLENCE IN CHEESEMAKING EQUIPMENT INNOVATIVE PROCESS SOLUTIONS, E N G I N E E R E D R I G H T Cheese Vats Cottage Cheese Vats Draining/ Salting Belts Curd Tables Block Formers Horizontal Cheese Vats 10,000 - 80,000 capacity featuring OptiSet Technology USA | The Netherlands | New Zealand | +1 320.231.2210 | www.relco.net T H E R E L C O ® A D V A N T A G E © COPYRIGHT 2015 Relco is a registered trademark and L-TECH is a trademark of RELCO, LLC. For more information, circle #4 on the Reader Response Card on p. 14 Page 6 March 18, 2016 CHEESE REPORTER EU Dairy Measures (Continued from p. 1) the agricultural sector and can be applied in case of severe imbalance in the market. The Commission has concluded that the strict conditions for the application of this article to the dairy sector are fulfilled in the current circumstances. This is an exceptional measure, which must also safeguard the EU internal market and was included by legislators in the 2013 Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) reform but never used before. Also, the Commission will increase the quantity ceilings for skim milk powder and butter put into intervention from 109,000 tons and 60,000 tons, respectively, to 218,000 tons and 100,000 tons. Other measures activated this week include a temporary increase in state aid that will allow member countries to provide up to 15,000 euros per farmer per year; an additional 30 million euros for promotion for the dairy and pigmeat sectors; and examining the feasibility of export credit schemes. “It is now nearly a year since dairy quotas were abolished after a period of 30 years,” commented European Ag Commissioner Phil Hogan. “Their abolition was always likely to be followed by a period of some volatility.” Due to a number of factors, what has been seen since quota abolition is a “significant increase” in production in a number of EU member countries which, when taken with the global changes in supply and demand for milk, “has created a severe market imbalance which is weighing heavily on the market,” Hogan said. The EU is continuing its efforts to try to ensure a rapid resumption of trade with Russia, Hogan said. Dairy UK has consistently highlighted the important role that intervention can play in the current dairy crisis, especially during this spring’s peak production period, noted Dr. David Dobbin, Dairy UK chairman. With intervention currently filling up quickly, Hogan’s proposal to double the intervention ceiling on skim milk powder and butter “is very much welcomed,” Dobbin said. “It is essential that there is an effective floor in the market and an outlet for short-term surpluses. This will help avoid even greater downward pressure on milk prices in the global over-supply situation.” The European Milk Board (EMB) supports voluntary milk production cuts, but said the measures that were approved this week are “only half-baked” and have not been thought through, the EMB said in a press release. “It is clear that measures aiming at increasing intervention volumes and selectively implemented production cuts will not relieve the dramatic situation and thus not put a halt to price slumps,” EMB said. The measure of voluntary production cuts might be well-intentioned but reveals “significant shortcomings,” EMB continued. The problem in this case is that the regulation of volumes is not coordinated on a central EU level, so it cannot relieve the market as a whole. Further, it does not foresee a cap on production volumes for all producers during the period of voluntary production custs, so the positive effect reached through the reduction of volumes will immediately be counteracted by the increase in production of other producers, EMB added. “If producer organizations and cooperatives have the choice whether or not to implement production cuts, their willingness to participate will vary significantly,” according to EMB. “The EU dairy and pigmeat sectors are bleeding. They were hit by the loss of our main export market Russia, worth 5.1 billion euros,” said Martin Merrild, president of Copa. Copa and Cogeca (European agricultural cooperatives) welcomed the fact that there has been some strengthening of the market tools in the aid package, including a doubling of the intervention ceilings for skim milk powder and butter. But they regret that there was no temporary increase in the EU intervention price for SMP and butter to reflect rising production costs and market realities. “I am extremely skeptical as to whether voluntary supply management measures will work in practice, as the European dairy sector has been competing at global levels since the reduction of market support measures nearly a decade ago. Dairy markets are cyclical and it is to be hoped will turn in time as we experienced in 2006, 2009 and 2012,” said Martin Keane, president of the Irish Cooperative Organization Society (ICOS). Nestle To Expand Irish R&D Center In Plant That Produces Powdered Milk-Based Products Askeaton, Ireland—Nestle recently announced that it will invest over 25 million euros ($27.8 million) to expand its R & D center in Askeaton, Ireland. The enhanced facility will be located at Nestle’s existing plant in Askeaton, which produces a range of powdered milk-based products for infants, young children and mothers for export to world markets. The R&D center will focus on global product innovation for Nestle’s Wyeth Nutrition infant and maternal business and is anticipated to open in late 2017. “This center will be a leading laboratory in food and life sciencies to continue to position Nestle at the fore of infant and maternal nutritional product development,” said Stefan Catsicas, chief technology officer, Nestle Research. “It will enable our scientists to explore nutritional opportunities that can improve the health and wellness of children’s lives.” The extended R&D center will incorporate state-of-the-art laboratories as well as a full pilot-scale manufacturing line to facilitate development and testing of new products from initial concept through to finished product development. The project investment is being supported by Enterprise Ireland, the government organization responsible for the development and growth of Irish enterprises in world markets. “This is a strategically important investment for Ireland and is a huge vote of confidence in the future of the Irish dairy industry and the research connectedness in Ireland,” said Michael Cantwell, director of the Food Division, Enterprise Ireland. “Nestle’s decision to extend its R&D center at its manufacturing plant at the Askeaton site is of critical strategic importance and underpins Nestle’s commitment to its Irish-based operations,” Cantwell added. From concept to commissioning RELCO provides innovative process engineering solutions and services: - Safety / sanitary design - Plant tune-up - Automation - Operator training - Retrofit or expanding current systems T H E R E L C O® A D V A N TA G E For more information, circle #5 on the Reader Response Card on p. 14 Email [email protected] or call 320-222-0252 March 18, 2016 Chobani Planning Close To $100 Million Investment To Expand Idaho Yogurt Plant Norwich, NY—Chobani, LLC on Thursday announced a nearly $100 million incremental investment to expand its manufacturing facility in Twin Falls, ID. In addition to expanding its Twin Falls plant, Chobani said it is also exploring plans to expand its original plant in central New York state. Chobani had commissioned its second domestic manufacturing facility in Twin Falls in 2013. The company had previously invested more than $450 million to build the 1-million-square-foot operation. Now, Chobani said it is selffunding major expansion initiatives, including: Purchase and conversion of three production lines for Chobani Flip products, its fastest growing yogurt platform. Purchase of a new production line and a new bulk production line for foodservice opportunities to drive further growth in schools, hotels, airlines and restaurants. Purchase of new equipment for new adjacent categories like Chobani Meze Dips and yogurt drinks. Launch of products to new international markets, including Mexico and Puerto Rico in the second quarter of 2016. “Building the largest yogurt manufacturing plant in the world and expanding it three years later is a really proud moment for us and an example of how right it was to pick Idaho as our second home,” said Hamdi Ulukaya, Chobani’s chairman and CEO. “Our success in Idaho and New Yorki s an example of the power and strength of US manufacturing,” Ulukaya continued. “To food companies like ours, it’s a signal of the momentum of the food movement that we started: better food for more people.” Chobani said its share of the overall yogurt market is 19.3 percent, the highest share in its history. That translates to a 36.1 percent share of overall Greek yogurt, the company said. Chobani said it currently receives up to 4 million pounds of milk at its Idaho and New York plants every day. On the heels of its Chobani Flip product success, Chobani recently announced its expansion and investment beyond the yogurt aisle with two new products: Chobani Meze Dips, which feature real vegetables, herbs and spices blended with Greek yogurt; and Drink Chobani beverage, which the company described as an excellent source of portable protein. Page 7 CHEESE REPORTER Walmart Milk Plant (Continued from p. 1) the volume of dairy processing and creating market opportunities for expanded dairy production. That 2015 report concluded, among other things, that approximately 4 million pounds of milk per day (40 percent of Indiana’s milk) is exported from the state, mainly to fluid milk markets in the East and Southeast; and that there appears to be an opportunity to encourage investment in dairy processing in Indiana for up to 4 million pounds of milk that is currently exported out of the state (for more details, please see “With Milk Production Growing, Indiana Looks At Potential Of Large Cheese Plant In State,” on page 1 of our Mar. 20, 2015 issue). Indiana’s 2015 milk production was a record 4.03 billion pounds, up 3.5 percent from 2014. The state’s milk production has grown by more than 1 billion pounds since 2003. The state’s January milk output totaled 352 million pounds, up 2.9 percent from January of 2015. There were 184,000 milk cows in Indiana in January, up 3,000 head from a year earlier. Fort Wayne, IN, is located approximately 50 miles from the Michigan border. Michigan’s milk production last year totaled 10.3 billion pounds, up 6.7 percent from 2014 and up more than 4 billion pounds since 2002. Michigan’s January milk production, 896 million pounds, was up 5.9 percent from January of 2015. “This is tremendous news for Indiana and not only affirms our dairy strategy is working, but also that our business climate and geographic location is conducive to economic development in the agriculture industry,” said Ted McKinney, director of the ISDA. “I applaud Walmart’s decision and commitment to support Indiana’s dairy farmers and for growing this robust, vital industry in our state.” “I’m proud to welcome this expansion as we work to create quality jobs for Hoosiers and support our Indiana farmers,” commented Indiana Governor Mike Pence. “When preparation meets opportunity, good things happen in the Allen county community,” said Nelson Peters, Allen county commissioner. “We are extremely excited to welcome Walmart here with this unique project.” Are You Really Cutting It? FAM DEVILLE Shredders and Dicers produce a perfect cut quality; are cleaner, smarter and more efficient. Less waste Impeccable hygiene Better cut quality Assured employee safety Increased capacity We cater to cheese processing companies that demand sanitary, durable, practical and efficient food cutting equipment. Our advanced technology is designed to improve your processing and your bottom line. In addition to increased capacity, you get better cut quality, less waste, April 12-14 Milwaukee, WI Come visit us in booth 803 FS40 Hymaks impeccable hygiene and assured employee safety, all while reducing your labor and maintenance costs. Contact us for a consultation or demonstration with one of our product specialists to discuss how we can help you achieve your goals. 1.866.404.4545 www.devilletechnologies.com CMD-3D Flexifam For more information, circle #21 on the Reader Response Card on p. 14 Bowl Ad–Cheese Reporter+Cheese Technology Expo 2016 Reminder.indd 1 CHS-2D 16-01-14 11:03 PM Page 8 March 18, 2016 CHEESE REPORTER Few Young People Plan To Work In Agriculture Industry, Land O’Lakes Survey Finds Minneapolis, MN—A recent survey conducted on behalf of Land O’Lakes, Inc., found that there’s a startling lack of young people planning to work in the agriculture industry. In fact, only 3 percent of college graduates and 9 percent of Millennials surveyed have or would consider a career in agriculture, the survey found. When compared with other industries, survey respondents were least likely to indicate that they have or would consider a career in agriculture (6 percent), with health care and technology at the highest career interest (each at 21 percent); followed by education (20 percent); marketing and sales; finance; and manufacturing and engineering (all at 12 percent). US Department of Agriculture (USDA) studies underscore these findings, Land O’Lakes noted: more than 20,000 agriculture jobs go unfilled each year. Despite this fact, the majority of survey respondents (54 percent) think it is difficult or very difficult for recent college graduates to get a job in agriculture. “We will need to produce more food in the next 40 or 50 years than in the previous 500 years combined,” said Lydia Botham, executive director, Land O’Lakes Foundation. “Our priorities are clear: we must focus on attracting the next generation of ag workers to the highly skilled, well-paid career opportunities. Failing to do so may lead to severe consequences.” Some 76 percent of survey respondents do not think or are not sure if a career in ag pays well. However, 35 percent of Milllennials, significantly more than any other generation, think ag careers do pay well, which may be a promising sign of attracting college students to the ag industry. “People still think you have to wear boots and overalls to work in ag,” Botham said. “But modern agriculture has evolved to become one of the most vital and technologically advanced fields there is today.” To attract new college graduates, Land O’Lakes created the Global Food Challenge — Emerging Leaders for Food Security program to engage future leaders in the challenges and opportunities facing agriculture. The yearlong fellowship program provides selected college students the opportunity to learn about global food security. WCMA Makes Donations To CDR, Second Harvest At World Championship Contest Chris Simon (right in above photo) of Agropur, current president of the Wisconsin Cheese Makers Association (WCMA), presents Mark Johnson, Ph.D., senior scientist at the Wisconsin Center for Dairy Research, with a check for $15,000 to to help CDR graduate students complete their education. Madison—The Wisconsin Cheese Makers Association (WCMA) and its members have raised and donated more than $30,000 to charitable organizations, as a result of last week’s Cheese Champion reception and World Championship Cheese Contest. At the reception, held on March 9, WCMA President Chris Simon presented Wisconsin Center for Dairy Research (CDR) senior scientist Mark Johnson, Ph.D., with a check for $15,000 to help CDR graduate students complete their education. “The CDR is training the next generation of dairy researchers, and in effect, helping to ensure a strong future for Wisconsin’s dairy industry,” said Simon who, in addition to serving as the WCMA’s president, works as vice president of quality assurance and product development at Agropur. “We are proud to partner with CUTTING SYSTEMS T-304 or T-316 Stainless Construction #4 Finish Inside and Out Removable-Locking Cover on Balance Tanks Flat-flanged, Cone or Dished Heads on CIP and Storage Tanks Stainless Steel Adjustable Legs From one-way, two-way, and three-way cutting machines to custom cutting systems designed for unique applications, Johnson Industries has delivered exceptional reduction equipment for over three decades. www.johnsonindint.com For more information, circle #23 on the Reader Response Card on p. 14 Designed and Fabricated to Meet 3A Standards Robust and reliable cutters designed to suit your production FOR MORE INFORMATION, VISIT US ON THE WEB AT CDR in its important work, as we have done for many, many years.” At the conclusion of the World Championship Cheese Contest, cheese makers also donated more than 5,000 pounds of cheese, yogurt and butter to Second Harvest Foodbank of Southern Wisconsin, a gift valued at approximately $15,000. And cheese contest volunteers, often referred to as the B-Team, pitched in another $1,000 to Second Harvest’s Adopt-A-DairyCow program, which ensures that families facing hunger have access to milk, a rarely donated product. “Cheese makers are a generous bunch, and it is no special occasion for them to support their communities,” said John Umhoefer, the WCMA’s executive director. “But special occasions like the Contest do give us a unique opportunity to highlight issues, like hunger, and to make a positive difference.” Ladders optional CIP TANKS, BALANCE TANKS STORAGE TANKS E: [email protected] www.awimfg.com Tel: 888.272.2600 Winsted, MN 55395 March 18, 2016 Dairy CPI Fell 0.5% In February; Retail Whole Milk Price Hits Lowest Level Since May 2010 Washington—The Consumer Price Index (CPI) for dairy and related products in February was 219.732 (1982-84=100), down 0.5 percent from January and 2.6 percent lower than in February of 2015, the US Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) reported Wednesday. That was the lowest level for the dairy CPI since last June, when it was 219.696. The dairy CPI had reached a record high of 229.87 in December of 2014. February’s CPI for all items was 237.111, up 0.1 percent from January and 1 percent higher than in February of 2015. February’s CPI for food at home was 242.062, up slightly from January but 0.3 percent lower than in February of 2015. The CPI for cheese and related products in February was 231.437, down 0.1 percent from January and down 2.5 percent from February of 2015. The cheese CPI has now been above 230 for 23 consecutive months, although it remains well below the record high of 240.046, set in November of 2014. The average retail price for a pound of natural Cheddar cheese in February was $5.369, down more than four cents from January and down more than 11 cents from February of 2015. The average retail price for a pound of American processed cheese in February was $4.436, up more than six cents from January but down more than 16 cents from February of 2015. February’s CPI for whole milk was 204.434, down 2.2 percent from January and 6.2 percent lower than in February of 2015. That was the lowest level for the whole milk CPI since March of 2011, when it was 203.08. February’s CPI for “milk” was 142.243 (December 1997=100), down 1 percent from January and 5 percent lower than in February of 2015. February’s CPI for milk other than whole was 146.201, down 0.3 percent from January and 4.2 percent lower than in February of 2015. The average retail price for a gallon of whole milk in February was $3.23, down more than eight cents from January and down almost 27 cents from February of 2015. That was the lowest average retail whole milk price since May of 2010, when retail whole milk prices averaged $3.178 per gallon. Since then, average retail whole milk prices peaked at almost $3.86 per gallon in November of 2014. The record for average retail whole milk prices remains $3.961 per gallon, set back in July of 2008. Average retail whole milk prices declined two cents in early March, to $3.40 per gallon, according to the monthly survey conducted by Page 9 CHEESE REPORTER federal milk marketing order market administrators. They conduct their survey one day between the 1st and 10th of each month in 29 selected cities or metro areas located in federal order markets. One outlet of the largest and second largest food store chains and the largest convenience store chain are surveyed. In the market administrators’ survey, average retail whole milk prices have declined from $3.49 per gallon in early January to $3.42 per gallon in early February and then $3.40 per gallon in early March. In early March, average retail whole milk prices ranged from a low of $2.39 per gallon in Houston, TX, to a high of $4.22 per gallon in Milwaukee, WI. In addition to Houston, retail whole milk prices in early March averaged under $3.00 per gallon in seven additional cities: Cincinnati, OH, $2.52 per gallon; Dallas, TX, $2.83 per gallon; Denver, CO, $2.83 per gallon; Detroit, MI, $2.76 per gallon; Indianapolis, IN, $2.96 per gallon; Phoenix, AZ, $2.69 per gallon; and Wichita, KS, $2.72 per gallon. In addition to Milwaukee, retail whole milk prices in early March averaged above $4.00 per gallon in two other cities: Baltimore, MD, $4.11 per gallon; and Minneapolis, MN, $4.02 per gallon. Retail prices for reduced fat (2 percent) milk averaged $3.37 per gallon in early March in the market administrators’ survey, down one cent from early February and down six cents from early January. Retail prices for whole organic milk averaged $4.39 per half-gallon in early March, five cents higher than in early February, the market administrators’ survey found. For the organic milk price survey, one outlet of the largest and second largest food store chains are surveyed. In early March, retail prices for whole organic milk ranged from a low of $3.34 per half gallon in Louisville, KY, to a high of $5.49 per half gallon on Pittsburgh, PA. Retail prices for whole reduced fat milk also averaged $4.39 per half gallon in early March, up five cents from early February. February’s CPI for butter was 237.277, down 1.5 percent from January but 1.6 percent higher than in February of 2015. The February CPI for ice cream and related products was 222.532, down 0.6 percent from January and 1.3 percent lower than in February of 2015. February’s CPI for other dairy and related products was 146.846 (December 1997=100), down 0.4 percent from January and also down 0.4 percent from February of 2015. For more information, circle #17 on the Reader Response Card on p. 14 Page 10 Structural Change (Continued from p. 1) real (inflation-adjusted) product prices, and ultimately reduce farm milk prices. In short, shifts in industry structure that reduce average industry costs will place downward pressure on real prices for farm milk. With lower farm milk prices, highercost producers will come under increased financial pressure, and some will close, continuing the process of structural change. With lower real product prices, buyers find more uses for US dairy products, either in domestic or foreign markets, and those new markets become important considerations for producers. Thus, farm costs, prices, and markets are linked. Changes in consumer preferences have led to changes in the mix of dairy products consumed domestically. But the US has also become a substantial commercial dairy product exporter, following improved international competitiveness of the US industry, growing global dairy demand, and changes in trade and dairy policy. Financial Risks Of Dairy Farming Expanded dairy trade brings benefits to US producers and consumers, the report said, but it also creates a new source of price volatility and a new set of financial risks for producers. Dairy farmers face “significant financial risks,” the report pointed out. Many large dairy farms rely heavily on debt to finance operations, and when margins are low, face the risk of not being able to meet loan obligations out of current operating income. The volatility of milk prices, along with the associated financial risks, has increased over the past CHEESE REPORTER 35 years, the report noted. As measured with the coefficient of variation (CV), the ratio of the standard deviation of prices to the mean value, volatility for the monthly NASS all-milk price was 3 percent in 1980-84, 6-7 percent in 1985-89 and 1990-94, 11 percent in 199599, 15 percent in 2000-04, and 20 percent in 2005-09 before falling back to 15 percent in 2010-14. Feed prices, which were relatively stable for many years, began rising after 2005, with notably more volatility. Feed prices reached new highs in July of 2008, August of 2012 and May of 2014. The gap between milk and feed prices “clearly shows a sharp margin decline” in the summer of 2009 and another, to under $4.00, in 2012, the report said. This is a national-benchmark margin: the margins faced by specific farms can vary, sometimes substantially, depending on differences in prices paid for feed and prices received for milk. But movements in the benchmark margin correlate strongly with movements in farm-level measures of financial performance, and the benchmark is therefore a useful indicator of dairy financial performance, the report stated. Margin Protection Program Scale economies in dairy farming provide strong incentives to invest in large operations for those who can assemble the needed managerial talent. Shifts of production to larger dairy farms have contributed to increased efficiency, lower milk prices, and sharp increases in net exports as the US dairy industry’s global competitiveness improved. However, milk and feed price volatility heightens risk for dairy farmers, as illustrated by the 2009 margin crash. That experience provided a major impetus for the redesign of dairy programs in the 2014 farm bill, with an expanded focus on providing margin protection to all kinds of farms through the Dairy Margin Protection Program (MPP-Dairy). MPP-Dairy is a voluntary risk management program that offers protection to dairy producers when the difference between the NASS all-milk price and a nationalbenchmark feed cost falls below a threshold, with escalating premiums, selected by the producer. The program offers a cash payment to producers when national-average margins are narrow or negative. MPP-Dairy is “a large and complex program, and farmers must make some complicated decisions when choosing a level of enrollment,” the report said. The program “appears to offer value to dairy producers,” judging from initial enrollments accounting for 80 percent of US milk production, and model simulations suggest that the protections offered by the program could be more valuable in the future. The potential effects of MPPDairy are subject to two major unknowns, the report noted. The first concerns the impact of the program on milk production and prices, and hence on government subsidies. If the program reduces the degree to which milk production responds to changes in milk prices, then it could lead to extended periods of low prices and increased government support. The second unknown concerns the effect of the program on continued structural adjustment in the dairy sector. MPP-Dairy has not developed complete rules for handling structural change in the industry. Without rules for managing structural change, the program could reduce incentives to increase herd sizes. March 18, 2016 Patent Awarded For Stable Concentrated Dairy Liquids Having Enhanced Fresh Dairy Notes That Stay Stable Washington—The US Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) this week awarded a patent for heat stable concentrated dairy liquids exhibiting enhanced fresh dairy flavor notes. Inventors are Gavin Matthew Schmidt, Jennifer Louise Kimmel, Aaron S. Handrick, Lisa Ann Dierbach, Kenneth Allen Mikeska, Bruce Edward Campbell, and Karen Robinson. The patent was assigned to Intercontinental Great Brands LLC. Disclosed in the patent are stable concentrated dairy liquids exhibiting enhanced fresh dairy notes and methods of making them. In order to achieve the enhanced fresh dairy notes, one aspect of the disclosed methods and products provides a formulation having a reduced dairy protein level and an increased fat content obtained through a specific blend of a creamenriched and concentrated liquid dairy base. By one approach, the stable concentrated dairy liquid has a protein to fat ratio of about 0.4 to about 0.7. In another aspect, the cream enrichment occurs at selected input locations during the concentration and thermal process in order to form a fluid and stable concentrate. The resultant concentrates exhibit a stability for at least about nine months as evidenced by a brew recovery of at least about 90 percent, and the resultant concentrates also have reduced sulfur and/ or nitrogen aroma intensities. While various approaches for concentrating milk have been documented, the relatively severe thermal treatments needed to sufficiently sterilize the concentrated products produced from the prior methods can result in flavor profiles that are different than a fresh dairy product, the patent summary stated. As a result, even if prior concentration and sterilization methods result in a heat and shelf-stable product, the sterilizing process often results in the formation or profiles, in some instances, different than fresh milk beverages. In this case, the formulation and processing methods disclosed in the patent achieve a stable fluid dairy concentrate having enhanced fresh dairy notes through concentration to effective protein and fat levels to reduce and, preferably, eliminate off-notes due to sterilization, and through enhancement via selective cream enrichment to achieve the flavor notes of fresh dairy products within a stable product. March 18, 2016 Puhoi Valley Kawau Blue Tops New Zealand Champions of Cheese Award Auckland, New Zealand—Puhoi Valley Kawau Blue by Puhoi Valley Cheese won the supreme title of Countdown Champion of Champions Cheese Award here at the recent 2016 New Zealand Champions of Cheese Awards. Officially the best cheese made by large producers, Puhoi Kawau Blue was described by judges as an excellent example of a mild-tomedium flavored Blue cheese. “This has great rind development and superb even blue distribution,” said master judge Russell Smith. “The texture is creamy with a great balance of spicy, savory and sweet flavors.” Puhoi Kawau Blue is the result of over 30 years’ experience perfecting Blues by Puhoi head cheese maker Franck Beaurain, he said. While Puhoi Kawau Blue is sold to New Zealand restaurants through food service, the public can buy this exact cheese under its retail name – Puhoi Valley Gorgonzola Style Blue. Mercer Cheese Extra Mature Gouda took the Puhoi Valley Champion Artisan Cheese Award for smaller producers – its third consecutive supreme artisan win. Dutch influence also saw Jeanne van Kuyk from Aroha Organic Goat Cheese win the Milk Test NZ Champion Cheesemaker Award. Jeanne van Kuyk is the first and only female artisan cheese maker to win this award. Aroha Organic Goat also collected the 180 degrees Champion Goat Cheese Award for its Aroha Raw Milk Jubilee. Not only did judges score this cheese a perfect 100, the only three gold medals awarded in this category were given to Aroha Organic Goat Cheese. Winners in the contest follow: Page 11 CHEESE REPORTER Champion Butter: Westgold Unsalted, Westland Milk Products Champion Yogurt: Symbio Probalance Blueberry Whole Grain Yogurt, Fonterra Brands NZ Fresh Unripened Cheese Award: Over the Moon Volcano, Over the Moon Dairy Company Champion Feta Award: Origin Earth Feta, Origin Earth Champion Soft White Rind: Brie, Grinning Gecko Cheese Co. Champion Goat Cheese Award: Raw Milk Jubilee, Aroha Organic Goat Company Champion Sheep Cheese: Mercer Pecorino, Mercer Cheese Champion Washed Rind: Puhoi Valley Cellar Range Washed Rind, Puhoi Valley Cheese Champion Blue Cheese: Puhoi Valley Kawau Blue, Puhoi Valley Champion European Style: Farmhouse Mature, Crescent Dairy Goats Champion Dutch Style: Meyer Tasty Gouda, Meyer Gouda Cheese Champion New Cheese: Matariki, Wangapeka Family Dairy Aspiring Cheesemaker Award: Loran Mathis, Over The Moon Dairy Company Champion Original Cheese Award: Pumahana, Karikaas Natural Dairy Products Champion Flavored Cheese Award: Origin Earth Smoked Sheep Cheese, Origin Eart Champion Cheddar: Kapiti Tuteremoana, Fonterra Brands NZ Champion Export: Puhoi Valley Fresh Goat, Puhoi Valley Favorite Cheese Award: Kapiti Kahurangi, Fonterra Brands NZ Champion Cheese Packaging Award: Dairyworks Grated Cheese Range, Dairyworks Champion Home Crafted Cheese and Cheese Maker: Sentry Hill Quark, Phillippa White. Ireland’s Ornua Opens Cheese Manufacturing Facility In Saudi Arabia; Will Produce Cheese From Reassembled Milk Riyadh, Saudi Arabia—Ornua (formerly the Irish Dairy Board) has opened a new cheese manufacturing facility in Saudi Arabia’s capital city, Riyadh. The 20-million-euro ($22.1 million) facility will manufacture white cheeses for the Saudi Arabian market, which Ornua said is the fifth largest dairy importer in the world, as well as providing a central hub to access the high growth dairy markets in the Middle East North Africa (MENA) region. The new facility will use technology developed by Ornua and Teagasc (the agriculture and food development authority in Ireland) to produce a range of bespoke fresh white cheeses for the increasingly sophisticated bakery sector, retail delis and foodservice customers. White cheeses are hugely popular in the MENA region, Ornua pointed out. The technology allows milk ingredients to be recombined for fresh white cheese production. The facility also includes an “innovation hub” which will be used to codevelop customized “white cheese” solutions with customers. The opening of the new facility “is strategically very important to Ornua as it provides the business with a new route to market for Irish dairy,” commented Kevin Lane, CEO of Ornua. “We now have a manufacturing and trading hub in place to service the high growth dairy market of Saudi Arabia and our growing MENA customer base. “The ability to innovate and adapt to market needs is key to developing opportunities for Irish dairy,” Lane continued. “Our partnership with Teagasc is a great example of how innovative dairy technologies can create new ways of producing dairy products for global markets.” “We are delighted that this inclusive research and development approach by Ornua and Teagasc has proved effective,” commented Mark Fenelon, head of the Teagasc food research program. “The technology underpinning this venture was developed at the Teagasc food research center, Moorepark, and was adapted and managed by Ornua as part of a highly integrated collaborative research program to develop the current suite of local cheeses,” Fenelon added. “It marks a new approach to cheese manufacture involving the production of cheeses from reassembled milk without whey expulsion,” Fenelon continued. YOUR COMPLETE CHEESE PROCESSING SOLUTION Ultra Safe Technology Brooms and Brushes 640 BLOCK/BARREL HANDLING SYSTEMS PROCESS CHEESE COOKING SYSTEMS visit us at: What is Ultra Safe Technology (UST)? UST is a revolutionary new line of brooms and brushes with innovative technology that utilizes enhanced bristle security units directly molded to the brush block, removing any gaps or seams while offering unprecedented bristle retention strength. The hand brushes, deck scrubs, and sweeping brooms each have a unique bristle pattern to optimize function, while spacing between the bristle units makes each tool easier to clean, dry, and inspect. Contact us today for more information. 1-800-826-8302 nelsonjameson.com booth #1241 PH: 855.364.4797 E: [email protected] W: loosmachine.com SHREDDING/DICING SYSTEMS specializing in custom automated food processing equipment For more information, circle #13 on the Reader Response Card on p. 14 COMPANY NEWS Page 12 Cheese CHEESE REPORTER Reporter Ad.pdf 1 1/19/16 4:27 PM March 18, 2016 C M Y SUPPLIER NEWS www.cheesereporter.com/events.htm CM MY CY CMY K Dairy Membrane Filtration, Concentration & Separation Course Is April 5-7 In NY Ithaca, NY—Cornell University is hosting a Dairy Membrane Filtration, Concentration & Separation Technology course here April 5-7 at Stocking Hall on campus. This three-day workshop is designed for those working in any area of dairy processing that involves concentration of milk and milk products by membranes, evaporation, drying and centrifugal separation. The workshop kicks off Tuesday morning with a session on membrane technology, terminology and applications led by Cornell’s Carmen Moraru. Jeff Yeh of Synder Filtration will lead a session on membrane design, construction and developments, followed by R.J. Twiford of Tetra Pak Processing Equipment, Inc. on supporting system design and mass balance used in membrane processing. K. Saagar Vijayaragavan of Complete Filtration Resources GOLF OUTINGS Charity Cheese Makers Golf Outing Scheduled For June 9 In Oneida, WI At Thornberry Oneida, WI—The annual Charity Cheese Makers Golf Outing has been set for Thursday, June 9 at the Thornberry Golf Course. Once again, proceeds from the event will be donated to the Children’s Miracle Network. More information on the outing will be available in the coming weeks. For questions, contact Larry Seyferth: [email protected]. Oregon Dairy Industries Set Golf Outing Date Aurora, OR—The Oregon Dairy Industries association will hold their 66th Annual Benefit Golf Tournament at Langdon Farms Golf Club July 20 in Aurora, OR. Proceeds benefit the Oregon State University Bodyfelt Scholarship Endowment Fund. The price is $185 per person and includes green fees, golf cart, awards, lunch and raffle. For information contact Reitha McCabe at [email protected]. will cover an analytical approach to membrane replacement, and Pall Corporation’s Bob Tyler will discuss cross-flow and direct filter technologies used in dairy processing. The day will conclude with a session led by Symphonic Water Solutions’ Tom Probst on membranes in dairy waste water treatment. Wednesday begins with a session on the membrane care program and audit led by Hydrite Chemical’s Reda Yacoub, followed by Cinder Biological’s Steven Yannone on new enzyme cleaning technology for membranes. After breakfast, Cornell’s Carmen Moraru will cover drying and evaporation principles and technology, and Carrie O’Neal of GEA North America will discuss practical applications of drying and evaporation. Lunch is followed by a session on dry cleaning technologies for dairy led by Leo Bohanon of Hydrite Chemical Co. Kansas State University’s Jayendra Amamcharla will give a presentation on lactose crystallization and its role in concentrated and dried dairy products, followed by GEA North America’s Mark Litchfield on centrifugation technology in clarification, separation and concentration. Wednesday will conclude with a pilot plant demonstration and reception. The final day of the workshop will begin with Cornell’s Alina Stelick on the sensory analysis of dairy ingredients, followed by Cornell’s Nicole Martin on the sources and solutions of bacterial spores in dairy products. The workshop will adjourn at noon. Cost to attend is $700 per person for New York State residents and $840 for non-residents. Registration is now available online at www.bit.ly.CornellMembrane. IDFA Milk & Cultured Dairy Products Conference Is May 24-25 In Indianapolis Indianapolis, IN—The 2016 International Dairy Foods Association (IDFA) will hold its Milk & Cultured Dairy Conference here May 24-25 at the Omni Severin Hotel. The two-day conference is designed for those who work in dairy marketing, product development, plant management, quality assurance, research and development, plant engineering and operations. The conference begins Tuesday morning with a welcome address by IDFA vice president of regulatory affairs and international standards John Allan, followed by an update on the Food Safety Modernization Act (FSMA) implementation. The morning session will dive deep into the latest yogurt category trends. KJ Burrington with the University of Wisconsin’s Center for Dairy Research (CDR) will discuss dairy ingredients in cultured products for clean labeling, and Chr. Hansen’s Mirjana CuricBawden will cover the documented health benefits of probiotics on the human microbiome. The trouble with date marketing and how it can be confusing to consumers and harmful to sustainability will also be addressed. An update on GMO labeling regulations will be given by IDFA’s Emily Lyons, and Donna Berry of Berry on Dairy will cover what’s new on the market. Tuesday will wrap up with the Innovative Product Contest. Conference attendees are invited to send one entry per company for each contest. Awards will be given for the most innovative milk or cultured dairy product, and for the most innovative milk or cultured dairy prototype product or flavor. The second day will kick off with a session on social media and marketing impact on the consumer value equation. Dean Foods’ Roger Hooi will discuss future veterinary drug residue testing requirements for Grade A milk products, and Smitha Stansbury, King & Spalding, will lead a session on FDA food additive approvals and the GRAS system. Cost to attend is $945 for IDFA members, $1,145 for non-members and $375 for government agents and members of academia. To register online, visit www. idfa.org. PLANNING GUIDE April 11-13: International Dairy Federation Dairy Science & Technology Symposium, Dublin, Ireland. For more information, visit www.idfingredientsandcheese2016.com. • April 12 - 13: Oregon Dairy Industries 105th Annual Conference, Salem Conference Center, Salem, OR. For more info, visit www.oregondairy.org/ annual-conference. • April 12-14: International Cheese Technology Expo, Wisconsin Center, Milwaukee, WI. Visit www.cheeseexpo.org. • April 16-19: International Milk Haulers Association. Visit www. milkhauler.org. • April 24-26: ADPI, ABI Joint Annual Conference, Hyatt Regency Chicago, Chicago, IL. Visit www.adpi.org for more information. • June 5-7: IDDBA Seminar & Expo, Houston, TX. For information, visit www.iddba.org. • June 26-28: Summer Fancy Food Show, Javits Center, New York, NY. For details, visit www. specialtyfood.com. • July 11-12: WDPA Dairy Symposium, The Landmark Resort, Door County, WI. For details, visit www.wdpa.net. • July 16-19: IFT 2016, McCormick Place South, Chicago, IL. For info, visit www.am-fe.ift. org. • July 27-30: ACS Annual Convention, Iowa Events Center, Des Moines, IA. For more information, visit www.cheesesociety.org. July 31-Aug. 3: IAFP Annual Meeting, America’s Center, St. Louis, MO. For details, visit www.foodprotection.org. • Aug. 10-11: IMPA Annual Convention, Sun Valley Resort, Sun Valley, ID. For details, visit www.impa.us. d's Dairy In orl d W Since 1876 ee ry W kly ust Serving the March 18, 2016 Page 13 CHEESE REPORTER MARKET PLACE CLASSIFIED ADVERTISING phone: (608) 246-8430 fax: (608) 246-8431 e-mail: [email protected] The “Industry’s” Market Place for Products, Services, Equipment and Supplies, Real Estate and Recruitment Classified ads should be placed by Thursday for the Friday issue. Classified ads charged $.75 per word. Classified ads payable in advance. Display Classifieds charged per column inch. 1. Equipment for Sale 3. Cheesecloth 8. Promotion & Placement FOR SALE: Car load of 300-400-500 late model open top milk tanks. Like new. (262) 473-3530 GO DIRECT! CHEESECLOTH - All constructions, medical grade. Microfiber and dairy wipers too. Contact Lucy Bauccio at Monarch Brands by email [email protected] or call 267-238-1643 PROMOTE YOURSELF - By contacting Tom Sloan & Associates. Job enhancement thru results oriented professionals. We place cheese makers, production, technical, maintenance, engineering and sales management people. Contact Dairy Specialist David Sloan, Tom Sloan or Terri Sherman. Tom Sloan & Associates, Inc. PO Box 50, Watertown, WI 53094. Call: (920) 261-8890 or FAX: (920) 261-6357; or email: [email protected] 2. Equipment Wanted 1. Equipment for Sale FOR SALE: 7,000 Gallon Coldwall Tank. 1,500 Gallon Cream Tank. DeLaval 2,300 Gallon Homogenizer. Damrow 8’ Double Row Press with Air Heads. 20 hp Ampco Pump. Walker 5,500 Gallon Silos (2). Call Don at Eaton Equipment. (608) 375-2256. MSA 200 WESTFALIA SEPARATOR. Just arrived. Perfect Bowl condition NO PITTING. Two for sale. Call Great Lakes Separators at (920) 863-3306 or e-mail [email protected]. SEPARATOR NEEDS - Before you buy a separator, give Great Lakes a call. TOP QUALITY, reconditioned machines at the lowest prices. Call Dave Lambert, Great Lakes Separators at (920) 863-3306; e-mail drlambert@dialez. net. WANTED TO BUY: Westfalia or AlfaLaval separators. Large or small. Old or new. Top dollar paid. Call Great Lakes Separators at (920) 863-3306 or email [email protected] 4. Walls, Flooring ULLMER’S DAIRY EQUIPMENT is looking to buy used daisy hoops, midget hoops, A-frame presses, 20 lb block molds, water/milk silos, homogenizers, and separators. Please contact us at (920) 822-8266 or e-mail us at [email protected]. EXTRUTECH PLASTICS Sanitary POLY 7. Help Wanted BOARD© panels provide bright white, non-porous, easily cleanable surfaces, perfect for non-food contact applications. 10. Cheese & Dairy Products CFIA and USDA accepted and Class A for FOR SALE: Wisconsin 10 month smoke and flame. Call 888-818-0118 or aged StarK Kosher Parmesan and 3 epiplastics.com. month aged Asiago. Shreds, blocks, chunks, loaves. For more information 5. Real Estate email: [email protected] DAIRY PLANTS FOR SALE: http://dairyassets.webs.com/dairy-plants. Call Jim at FOR SALE: Pecorino (from sheep’s milk) for grating, available in 608-835-7705 competitive price. For any interest, FOR SALE: Specialty powder products email Mr. Peppi at dtdairytradeltd@ company. Small but rapidly growing. gmail.com Wisconsin location. Owner’s health is Advertise here. Call 608-246-8430 for more information or email info@ cheesereporter.com FOR SALE: 1500 and 1250 cream tanks. Like New. (800) 558-0112. (262) 473-3530. HIGH CAPACITY SEPARATOR: Alfa-Laval hmrpx 718 HGV hermetic separator. 77,000 pounds per hour separation/110,000 pounds per hour standardization. Call Great Lakes Separator at 920-863-3306 or email drlambert@ dialez.net. www.gmigaskets.com EPOXY OR FIBERGLASS floors, walls, tank-linings, and tile grouting. Installed by M&W Protective Coating Co. LLC. Call (715) 234-2251 forcing this sale. Reply to Box J-1085, c/o KEYS MANUFACTURING: Cheese Reporter, 2810 Crossroads Dr., Dehydrators of scrap cheese for the Madison WI 53718 animal feed idustry. Contact us for your scrap at (217) 465-4001; email 7. Help Wanted [email protected]. FULL-TIME: UPLANDS CHEESE in Dodgeville, Wisconsin is hiring a full-time Ship- 14. Testing Services ping and Office Manager to coordinate all Promote your microbiological, nutritional cheese shipments and customer commuor food sample testing services here. nications. Excellent wages and paid time Call Cheese Reporter at 608-246-8430 off. Contact Andy Hatch at 608-935-5558 or email [email protected] or at [email protected] Sales Representatives We are only as strong as our REPS. Come join our team! Plastopil is a major producer and supplier of flexible packaging for some of the largest bulk cheese producers in North America. We are currently interviewing sales reps for the Pacific Northwest, Midwest, California and Texas territories. CAREERS IN DAIRY FINANCE If you are interested in this excellent opportunity, email: Mr. M. Hazarie [email protected] Herbein is recruiting for some of our top notch dairy clients. For additional information or to submit your resume, please contact us at [email protected]. Controller - Mid Atlantic Region Controller - Southern New Jersey Market Administrator - New York Plant Finance Manager - Texas Internal Auditor (1 yr. exp.) - Kansas City www.herbein.com Page 14 $1.80 March 18, 2016 CHEESE REPORTER CME Block/Barrel Price Tracker - 2015 vs. 2016 $1.70 $1.60 DAIRY PRODUCT SALES $1.80 March 16, 2016—AMS’ National Dairy Products Sales Report. Prices included are provided each week by manufacturers. Prices collected are for the (wholesale) point of sale for natural, unaged Cheddar; boxes of butter meeting USDA standards; Extra Grade edible dry whey; and Extra Grade and USPH Grade A nonfortified NFDM. • Revised $1.70 2015 Style and Region March 12 Weighted Price US Sales Volume US 2016 $1.40 J F M A M J J A S O N D $3.00 $2.80 1.5025 40-Pound Block Avg $1.40 M A M WEEK ENDING March 5 J J A S O N D J Feb. 27 F M Feb. 20 12,150,449 Dollars/Pound 1.5044• Pounds 11,849,492• 1.5040 1.4933 13,020,176 13,014,283• 500-Pound Barrel Cheddar Cheese Prices, Sales & Moisture Contest $2.60 1.5958 1.5833 1.5205 1.5126 8,779,044 9,508,649 34.93 35.10 2.0737 2.1303 Butter Weighted Price US Sales Volume US $2.40 $2.20 2.0004 3,819,313 $2.00 Dollars/Pound 2.0309• Pounds 3,963,381• 4,146,845 5,463,315 Dry Whey Prices Weighted Price US Sales Volume US $1.80 $1.60 0.2563 6,812,009 Dollars/Pounds 0.2530 0.2590 6,142,267 6,649,968 0.2462 8,716,340 Nonfat Dry Milk $1.40 Average Price US Sales Volume US $1.20 J F M A M J J A S NDM Prices O N D 0.7623 16,867,368 Dollars/Pound 0.7627• Pounds 25,731,048• 0.7675 0.7703 14,567,959 16,436,856• DAIRY FUTURES PRICES Since 2010 SETTLING PRICE High Range (Low/Medium Heat): Mostly $2.20 $1.90 $1.50 Weighted Price Dollars/Pound US 1.5694 1.5683• Weighted Price Adjusted to 38% Moisture US 1.4975 1.4962• Sales Volume Pounds US 9,624,946 9,874,812• Weighted Moisture Content Percent US 35.03 35.01• CME Butter Tracker- 2015 vs. 2014 vs 2016 $2.00 $1.60 40-Pound Block Cheddar Cheese Prices and Sales $1.50 $2.10 CME vs AMS Central & East Western $1.80 $1.70 *Cash Settled Date 3-11 3-14 3-15 3-16 3-17 Month March 16 March 16 March 16 March 16 March 16 Class III* Class IV* Dry Whey* 13.79 13.00 25.200 13.79 13.00 25.225 13.79 12.99 25.500 13.80 12.99 25.500 13.83 12.99 25.500 NDM* 77.400 76.875 76.875 77.250 76.600 Butter* 201.000 200.525 199.050 199.050 199.075 Cheese* 1.5180 1.5170 1.5180 1.5180 1.5200 3-11 3-14 3-15 3-16 3-17 April 16 April 16 April 16 April 16 April 16 13.66 13.48 13.40 13.53 13.63 13.38 13.38 13.38 13.38 13.38 24.875 24.875 25.275 25.275 25.625 80.600 79.150 78.000 78.200 77.725 204.250 199.250 196.450 195.250 196.800 1.5040 1.4890 1.4800 1.4880 1.4990 3-11 3-14 3-15 3-16 3-17 May 16 May 16 May 16 May 16 May 16 13.50 13.36 13.29 13.31 13.40 13.56 13.56 13.56 13.56 13.56 25.250 25.250 25.250 25.450 25.450 82.300 81.350 79.675 79.700 78.900 206.000 201.225 198.975 196.475 198.700 1.4930 1.4750 1.4690 1.4670 1.4730 3-11 3-14 3-15 3-16 3-17 June 16 June 16 June 16 June 16 June 16 13.63 13.41 13.69 13.34 13.41 13.77 13.77 13.77 13.76 13.76 25.125 25.025 25.025 25.000 25.025 84.000 82.750 81.250 81.300 80.500 206.725 202.750 201.000 199.525 201.750 1.5000 1.4760 1.4670 1.4750 1.4750 3-11 3-14 3-15 3-16 3-17 July 16 July 16 July 16 July 16 July 16 14.03 13.80 14.11 13.68 13.73 14.05 14.05 14.04 14.04 14.04 25.400 25.275 25.050 25.050 25.275 87.000 85.500 83.925 83.925 83.050 208.500 204.675 203.175 201.825 204.000 1.5370 1.5180 1.5050 1.5100 1.5100 3-11 3-14 3-15 3-16 3-17 August 16 August 16 August 16 August 16 August 16 14.45 14.24 14.43 14.13 14.13 14.47 14.47 13.80 13.80 13.80 25.325 25.325 25.275 25.275 25.275 89.750 87.750 86.200 86.000 85.500 210.500 207.000 205.650 206.750 205.750 1.5800 1.5580 1.5480 1.5500 1.5500 3-11 3-14 3-15 3-16 3-17 September 16 September 16 September 16 September 16 September 16 14.74 14.55 14.56 14.42 14.41 14.70 14.70 14.20 14.20 14.20 26.000 26.000 25.750 25.750 25.750 92.750 85.500 89.000 88.125 87.400 211.750 209.000 207.425 203.750 207.500 1.6090 1.5870 1.5760 1.5790 1.5790 3-11 3-14 3-15 3-16 3-17 October 16 October 16 October 16 October 16 October 16 14.79 14.70 14.54 14.57 14.57 14.66 14.66 14.25 14.25 14.25 27.000 26.500 26.300 26.925 26.925 94.775 87.950 90.300 89.700 89.000 212.000 210.000 209.175 205.325 209.000 1.6110 1.6020 1.5880 1.5860 1.5880 3-11 3-14 3-15 3-16 3-17 November 16 November 16 November 16 November 16 November 16 14.79 14.70 14.56 14.53 14.65 14.86 14.86 14.50 14.50 14.50 27.400 27.250 27.125 27.250 27.250 95.975 92.050 91.500 91.550 90.000 210.725 209.125 208.825 205.500 208.300 1.6100 1.5990 1.5840 1.5850 1.5870 3-11 3-14 3-15 3-16 3-17 December 16 December 16 December 16 December 16 December 16 14.80 14.65 14.56 14.63 14.65 14.78 14.78 14.20 14.30 14.30 27.500 27.925 27.500 27.500 27.500 96.975 96.050 93.000 92.375 91.750 205.475 203.625 203.625 201.000 201.125 1.6080 1.5960 1.5820 1.5820 1.5930 14.79 14.68 14.55 14.57 14.57 32,338 14.44 14.44 14.30 14.30 14.30 2,261 27.500 27.500 27.500 27.500 27.500 5,192 97.825 97.825 97.400 96.650 95.475 6,636 198.000 199.000 195.000 195.000 195.250 6,274 1.5800 1.5800 1.5800 1.5860 1.5820 34,964 $1.60 $1.50 $1.40 $1.30 $1.20 $1.10 $1.00 $0.90 $0.80 $0.70 CHEESE REPORTER READER RESPONSE CARD (Print Your Name and Address Clearly Below) Name _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ For information about the advertisements or new product information, circle the number below which corresponds to the ad or article in which you are interested. Issue Date: 3/18/16 1 Title _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 7 Company _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 14 20 Address _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 26 32 City/St/Zip _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 38 E-Mail _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 44 TYPE OF BUSINESS: ___Cheese Manufacturer ___Cheese Processor ___Cheese Packager ___Cheese Marketer(broker, distributor, retailer ___Other dairy processor (butter, cultured products) ___Whey processor ___Food processing/Foodservice ___Supplier to dairy processor ___Other________________ JOB FUNCTION: ___Company Management ___Plant Management ___Plant Personnel ___Laboratory (QC, R&D, Tech) ___Packaging ___Purchasing ___Warehouse/Distribution ___Sales/Marketing ___Other_______________ PLEASE SEND ME MORE INFORMATION ON: ___Subscribing to Cheese Reporter ___Cheese Reporter’s Reference Books 50 56 62 69 75 81 87 93 99 105 111 117 123 2 8 15 21 27 33 39 45 51 57 63 70 76 82 88 94 100 106 112 118 124 3 10 16 22 28 34 40 46 52 58 64 71 77 83 89 95 101 107 113 119 125 4 11 17 23 29 35 41 47 53 59 65 72 78 84 90 96 102 108 114 120 126 5 12 18 24 30 36 42 48 54 60 67 73 79 85 91 97 103 109 115 121 127 6 13 19 25 31 37 43 49 55 61 68 74 80 86 92 98 104 110 116 122 128 ___Material to advertise in Cheese Reporter ___Other____________________________ 3-11 January 17 3-14 January 17 3-15 January 17 3-16 January 17 3-17 January 17 Interest - March 17 March 18, 2016 Page 15 CHEESE REPORTER DAIRY PRODUCT MARKETS AS REPORTED BY THE US DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE WHOLESALE CHEESE MARKETS NATIONAL - MARCH 11: Cheese production continues to follow rising milk intakes, resulting in cheese output above normal interest and holiday demand. Sales, especially to contracted customers, are generally stable and good. However, a few processors report that sales have slowed, as buyers pause to see what direction cheese market prices will take. Some end users are fielding a lot of offers from cheese makers, but have a desire to work through their own inventories first. Cheese processors hope US consumers will continue to use cheese at a high rate. Yet at some point cheese warehouses will be full unless one or a combination of three things happen: milk flows decline and less cheese is made; domestic cheese consumption increases even further; or export sales increase. Foreign markets are weak and the EU has high volumes of cheese production. NORTHEAST- MARCH 16: Milk volumes are keeping most, if not all, cheese plants operating on heavy seasonal schedules. Overall, cheese sales are fair to good and improving, as holiday needs help boost transactions. Orders from the foodservice industry are steady. Manufacturers note that higher than expected milk protein levels are increasing cheese yields. Wholesale prices, delivered, dollars per/lb: Cheddar 40-lb blocks: $1.9175 - $2.2025 Process 5-lb sliced: $1.6700 - $2.1500 Muenster: $1.9375 - $2.2875 Swiss Cuts 10-14 lbs: $3.0550 - $3.3775 MIDWEST AREA - MARCH 16: Although still a little early for spring flush, Midwest cheese makers are seeing plenty of milk available for their processing needs. Many manufacturers say they are near full capacity. However, they will still buy a few extra loads of milk to complete production schedules, if the milk is priced right. Some spot loads of milk are available at $1.50 to $3.00 under Class. Domestic retail cheese demand continues to be a good draw. Sales into foodservice and Mozzarella for pizza have also been respectable. Barrel cheese and cheese for manufacturing lines are moving slowly with most transactions completed only on standing contracts. Manufacturers feel end users are holding off on purchases and trying to burn through their inventories, before reentering the market. Inventories continue to be long for cheese barrels, but a little lighter for blocks. Wholesale prices delivered, dollars per/lb: Brick/Muens 5# Loaf: $1.8875 - $2.3125 Monterey Jack 10#: $1.8625 - $2.0675 Mozzarella 5-6# (LMPS): $1.6875 - $2.6275 Process 5# Loaf: Cheddar 40# Block: Blue 5# Loaf: Grade A Swiss 6-9#: $1.5625 - $1.9225 $1.6150 - $2.0100 $2.1550 - $3.1425 $2.5725 - $2.6900 WEST - MARCH 16: West cheese production remains steady to higher as milk intakes increase seasonally. Manufacturers say demand is still good from foodservice and retail accounts. However, club stores and other large retailers have slowed their cheese orders somewhat and are taking a wait and see approach to the market. Many want to see what direction the cheese price trend will take before making any large-scale purchase decisions. In addition, end users are facing a lot of offers from cheese makers, especially for cheese barrels, but are hesitant to make buys until they can work through their own inventories. Cheese stocks remain long for barrels. Some end users note a little more tightness with cheese blocks, especially fresh blocks. Wholesale prices delivered, dollars per/lb: Process 5# Loaf: Cheddar 40# Block: $1.6200 - $2.0650 Cheddar 10# Cuts: Monterey Jack 10#: $1.8100 - $1.9700 Grade A Swiss 6-9#: $1.5775 - $1.8350 $1.8000 - $2.0200 $2.6325 - $3.0625 FOREIGN -TYPE CHEESE - MARCH 16: Cheese demand has strengthened in the EU following recent weaker prices. Markets are stable, with production meeting demand and inventories at comfortable levels. Export shipments have increased and stocks in aging programs are deemed sufficient. In New Zealand, the GDT event 160 results on Tuesday did not generate any bids for Cheddar for the next three contract periods. Industry observers believe this reflects heavy inventories and thus, little interest in further acquisitions. Selling prices, delivered, dollars per/lb: Blue: Gorgonzola: Parmesan (Italy): Romano (Cows Milk): Sardo Romano (Argentine): Reggianito (Argentine): Jarlsberg (Brand): Swiss Cuts Switzerland: Swiss Cuts Finnish: Imported $2.6400 - 5.3800 $3.6900 - 5.8900 0 0 $2.8500 - 4.9300 $3.2900 - 4.9300 $2.9500 - 6.4500 0 $2.6700- 2.9300 Domestic $2.0825 - 3.5700 $2.5900 - 3.2875 $3.4725 - 5.5625 $3.2725 - 5.4225 0 0 0 $3.0925- 3.4150 0 WHOLESALE BUTTER MARKETS NATIONAL - MARCH 11: Butter production is active throughout the country as heavy cream volumes continue clearing into butter manufacturing. However, many churners are less interested in pursuing additional cream loads as the spring holiday butter orders are getting filled. In the West, some processors are backing off butter production and shifting cream to other manufactured product lines, like cream cheese and ice cream. Butter inventories are building across the nation. Butter demand from retailers is good in the East and Central regions as the spring holidays approach. NORTHEAST - MARCH 16: The market can reasonably expect regional churning to maintain a high rate, since most butter makers will likely churn rather than sell cream at the current multiples. As the holidays fast approach, some are storing substantial supplies of bulk butter. Demand varies, but retailers in general are placing orders in anticipation of holiday needs. This week, Northeast retail stores posted a noteworthy decline in butter ads compared to last week. The butter market undertone remains weak. CENTRAL - MARCH 16: Bulk and print butter production channels are active throughout the region this week. Spot cream offers are available, and interest is steady to light. Manufacturers indicate sales into print are ongoing, but represent previously arranged sales, for the most part, versus new sales. Consumer feature fulfillment plays heavily into the loads shipping now through the middle of next week. Butter inventories are steady to building. WEST - MARCH 16: As the spring holidays draw near, butter makers are seeing some of the seasonal demand ebb away. Most of the orders are now filled for the early spring holidays and inventories are building. In addition, a few industry contacts say some end users and secondary marketers have filled their warehouses to assure coverage of butter needs for later in the year. Cream supplies are readily available and butter production is still active. But a number of processors are considering what the most economical use of the cream may be. A few butter makers are slowing the churns in favor of producing some other cream products or selling cream where they can. FLUID MILK & CREAM - MARCH 16 NATIONAL: Milk production, in most of the country, is increasing along seasonal patterns. In the Pacific Northwest, industry contacts say the spring flush is underway. In the North Central region, it is early for the arrival of spring flush for many operations. And on both coasts, in California and the Northeast/Mid-Atlantic regions, milk levels are steady to higher. Milk volumes are generally sufficient for all processing needs. In some cases, manufacturers have less capacity available for toll processing. Other processors are gearing up to have a short, hard push on production to move items to retailers ahead of the spring holidays. Bottling demand is mixed with some Midwestern operators scouting for additional milk loads to fill educational institution and retail needs; others see decreases in bottled milk sales. Bottled milk sales are steady in California and in the Pacific Northwest, but lower in Arizona, New Mexico and in the Southeast. In many cases, K-12 milk orders are in flux due to the spring break calendaring. Heavy cream volumes continue to clear into butter churns, and demands from ice cream and cream cheese makers are trending higher. CENTRAL: Throughout the Central region, milk intakes are steadily increasing from week to week. Southern area milk handlers note bigger steps up in production compared to Northern milk handlers. As the flush approaches, though, there is growing concern among marketers and cooperatives regarding maintaining markets for potentially larger volumes of finished products. There has been some discussion about notifications to producers regarding changes in how milk payments will be handled for volumes above year ago marketing. Bottled milk demand is uneven from location to location as school districts cycle through week long shutdown periods. However, the overall demand for bottled milk light to moderate. Most bottlers indicate the overall sales trend is downward. Milk spot loads and condensed skim volumes are readily available throughout the region. Confirmed spot milk sale prices range from $3.50 under to flat Class. However a few milk marketers indicate they received bids of $5-$8 under Class. Milk marketers indicate cheese manufacturers have interest in spot milk loads, as long as prices are at a discount to class. Handlers in the North Central area indicate manufacturing space and time are a premium. Wait times for unloading are growing at some plants as intake volumes increase seasonally. Recent reports indicate that milk discards are happening, but the industry is trying to keep those instances to a minimum. NORTHEAST: Northeast milk production is active throughout the region as increases occur along the seasonal pattern. Some milk handlers indicated milk sales across classes are steady. Manufacturing milk supplies are heavier but manageable. March milk production levels are up in the Mid-Atlantic. Balancing plant managers are comfortable with current milk intakes, while looking ahead to imminent upsurges in milk supplies. Class I milk sales are stable. Surplus milk is moving at substantial discounts in some market channels. Milk production is climbing in the Southeast. March is typically the month milk output in area states gain momentum toward the peak. Participants in the market indicate Southeastern manufacturing plants are operating at capacity levels. Sales to bottling are unchanged. Florida milk production is surging. WEST: Farm milk production continues rising in California. Milk components are stepping lower due to an increase in temperatures. Bottled sales are steady this week. Sales into ice cream and frozen dessert manufacturing are steady as processors are ramping up production for the upcoming spring holidays and summer season. Most educational institutions are closed this week due to the spring break. As a result, orders from bottlers are lower. Some ice cream manufacturers have been pulling moderate condensed skim volumes throughout the week. Sales into Class I are lower as the spring break for most K-12 school calendars will start in the next two weeks. Sales into Class II are higher as the interest for ice cream is growing. Dry product processing is more active this week as some dryers completed repair/maintenancework. Manufacturing milk volumes moving into Class III are steady to lower. Pacific Northwest milk production is increasing. Some processors report the region is heading into spring flush and the processors are working hard to find homes for loads of additional milk. DRY DAIRY PRODUCTS - MARCH 17 NDM - CENTRAL: With recent declining price trends in international markets, buyers are shopping cautiously in the domestic market. With availability of low/medium heat f.o.b. spot loads from numerous producers, as well as offers from resellers, buyers are firmly in control of pricing. Low/medium heat NDM production is steady to higher. Some manufacturers are trying to staunch the flow of condensed skim through the dryers by actively offering spot condensed skim loads. There, too, buyers are interested, if the price is right. Longstanding cooperative efforts between milk purchasers and milk marketers are helping even out the over/ under supply situations in various milksheds. Within those arrangements, additional milk volumes are clearing into Class III production to support steady cheese sales. Inventories are building as on-farm milk production ramps up toward the flush. High heat NDM prices are unchanged. Some interest into specialty end user accounts is picking up seasonally. Stocks on hand are generally sufficient for near term interest. Production is generally limited end of run time slots so that nothing slows the clearing of condensed skim volumes. NDM - EAST: Low/medium NDM prices are unchanged in the range, but steady to lower in the mostly series. Plants continue to report active drying in order to clear increasing condensed skim supplies. Stocks of low/ medium heat NDM, at the producer level, are building as uneven demand builds up total regional supplies. To balance growth, multi-load offerings at lower prices exist from those manufacturers hoping to reduce supply levels. Demand is weak in the spot market as buyers/users postpone purchases for better prices. In some instances, low/ medium NDM interests from export markets are developing around competitive pricing. The domestic market tone is steady to weak. WEST - NDM: The low/medium heat NDM market is weak, with recent offshore auction results underscoring this year’s situation of global chronic oversupply. However, within some Western states, NDM inventories are tighter after significant weekly sales. Domestic prices are unchanged to lower. In conjunction with some higher use of NDM/ condensed skim into cheese manufacturing, regional NDM inventories are mixed. A few manufacturers indicate they have limited quantities available to fulfill block needs. Other producers report that as milk production trends higher seasonally, their NDM output is growing alongside stocks on hand. A few plants completed maintenance projects and are once again receiving milk intakes and channeling those volumes through the dryer. Within various western milksheds, milk marketers are coordinating use of milk among cheese and dryer plants to best handle weekly milk supplies. WEEKLY COLD STORAGE HOLDINGS SELECTED STORAGE CENTERS IN 1,000 POUNDS - INCLUDING GOVERNMENT DATE ...................................... BUTTER 3/14/16 3/01/16 Change ...................................... ...................................... ...................................... 22,007 21,185 822 CHEESE 95,869 93,830 2,039 Page 16 March 18, 2016 CHEESE REPORTER FDA Publishes Final Rule On ‘Mad Cow Disease’ In Food; Confirms That Milk Products Are Not Banned Cattle Materials CME CASH PRICES - MARCH 14 - 18, 2016 Visit www.cheesereporter.com for daily prices CHEDDAR 500-LB. BARRELS CHEDDAR 40-LB. BLOCKS AA BUTTER GRADE A NFDM MONDAY March 14 $1.4425 (-2¾) $1.4875 (-1¼) $1.9400 (-4¾) $0.7450 (-2½) TUESDAY March 15 $1.4300 (-1¼) $1.4875 (NC) $1.9250 (-1½) WEDNESDAY March 16 $1.4300 (NC) $1.4875 (NC) $1.9400 (+1½) $0.7375 (-¾) $0.7375 (NC) THURSDAY March 17 $1.4200 (-1) $1.4875 (NC) $1.9400 (NC) $0.7275 (-1) FRIDAY March 18 $1.5000 (+8) $1.4900 (+¼) $1.9500 (+1) $0.7300 (+¼) Week’s AVG Change $1.4445 (-0.0215) $1.4880 (-0.0240) $1.9390 (-0.0420) $0.7355 (-0.0140) Last Week’s AVG $1.4660 $1.5120 $1.9810 $0.7495 2014 AVG Same Week $1.5410 $1.5600 $1.6800 $0.9840 MARKET OPINION - CHEESE REPORTER Cheese Comment: Monday’s block market activity was limited to an uncovered offer of 1 car at $1.4875, which reduced the price. There was no block market activity on Tuesday. Wednesday’s block market activity was limited to an uncovered offer of 1 car at $1.4975, which left the price unchanged. There was no block market activity again on Thursday. On Friday, 1 car of blocks was sold on an offer at $1.4900, which raised the price. The barrel price fell Monday on an uncovered offer of 1 car at $1.4425, declined Tuesday on an uncovered offer of 1 car at $1.4300, fell Thursday on an offer-based sale of 1 car at $1.4200, then jumped Friday on an unfilled bid for 1 car at $1.5000. Butter Comment: The butter price declined Monday on an unfilled bid for 1 car at $1.9400 (following a sale at $1.9300), fell Tuesday on an offer-based sale of 1 car at $1.9250, rose Wednesday on sales of 3 cars at $1.9400, and increased Friday on an unfilled bid for 1 car at $1.9500. NDM Comment: The nonfat dry milk price declined Monday on an uncovered offer of 1 car at 74.5 cents a pound, fell Tuesday on a bid-based sale of 1 car at 73.75 cents, declined Thursday on a bid-based sale of 1 car at 72.75 cents, and rose Friday on an unfilled bid for 1 car at 73.0 cents. WHEY MARKETS - MARCH 14 - 18, 2016 Washington—The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) this week issued a rule finalizing three previously issued interim final rules designed to further reduce the potential risk of bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE), also known as “mad cow disease,” in human food. BSE is a fatal neurological disorder of cattle that has a long incubation period (two to eight years). It is transmitted when cattle ingest protein meal containing the BSE infectious agent. Cattle affected by BSE are usually apart from the herd and will show progressively deteriorating behaviorial and neurological signs. Studies have linked variant Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (vCJD) in humans to exposure to the BSE agent, most likely through human consumption of beef products contaminated with the BSE agent. The final rule published by FDA this week completes a rulemaking process that began with an interim final rule in 2004 and was followed by interim final rules in 2005 and 2008. The final rule provides definitions for prohibited cattle materials and prohibits their use in human food, dietary supplements, and cosmetics, to address the potential risk of BSE. These materials include: specified risk materials (SRMs), such as the brain, skull, eyes, spinal cord and vertebral column of cattle 30 months of age and older; the small intestine from all cattle unless the distal ileum has been properly removed; material from nonambulatory disabled cattle; and material from cattle not inspected and passed, or mechanically separated. The final rule also confirms that milk and milk products, hides and hide-derived products, tallow that contains no more than 0.15 percent insoluble impurities, and tallow derivatives are not prohibited cattle materials. FDA also finalized the process for designating a country as not subject to BSE-related restrictions applicable to FDA regulated human food and cosmetics. Finally, the rule provides a definition of gelatin and clarifies that gelatin is not considered a prohibited cattle material if it is manufactured using the customary industry processes specified. Gelatin was never considered a prohibited cattle material, but FDA had never specifically defined gelatin in past interim final rules. The US has long had measures in place to prevent the introduction and spread of BSE, FDA said. RELEASE DATE - MARCH 17, 2016 Animal Feed Whey—Central: Milk Replacer: .1250(NC) – .2150 (NC) Buttermilk Powder: Central & East: .7200 (NC) – .8250(NC) Mostly: .7200 (-2) – .8000 (NC) Casein: Rennet: DICE West: .6800 (-4) – .8100 (NC) $2.2200 (NC) – $2.9000 (-15) Acid: $2.3600 (NC) - $3.0500 (-15) Dry Whey Powder—Central (Edible): Nonhygroscopic: .1800 (NC) – .2850(-½) Mostly: .2200 (NC) – .2650(NC) Dry Whey–West (Edible): Nonhygroscopic: .2300 (NC) – .3000 (-½) Mostly: .2300 (NC) – .2700 (NC) Dry Whey—NE: .2200 (NC) — .2875 (-¼) Lactose—Central and West: Edible: .1800 (NC) –.3200(NC) Mostly: .2050 (+1) – .2550 (NC) CRUMBLE SHRED SLICE STRIP CUTTING EDGE Endless Styles of Cuts at Industrial-Level Yields Nonfat Dry Milk —Central & East: Low/Medium Heat: .7100(NC) – .8400(NC) Mostly: .7400(-1) – .8100 (NC) High Heat: .8500 (NC) - 1.1000(NC) Nonfat Dry Milk —Western: Low/Medium Heat: .6850(NC) – .8100 (-1) Mostly: .7200 (NC) –.7650(-½) High Heat: .8400(NC) – 1.1025(NC) California Weighted Average NFDM: March 11 March 4 $0.7885 $0.7590 7,521,889 12,313,745 nules e Gra Coars Whey Protein Concentrate—Central and West: Edible 34% Protein: .5100 (-3) – .7300 (NC) Mostly: .5400 (NC) – .6200(NC) Whole Milk—National: 1.1500 (-2) – 1.4475 (NC) ips le Str Crink Visit www.cheesereporter.com for dairy and historical ices 1/8" D cheese, butter, NFDM and whey prices ‘05 ‘06 ‘07 ‘08 ‘09 ‘10 ‘11 ‘12 ‘13 ‘14 ‘15 ‘16 Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul 14.38 12.56 12.47 16.91 9.02 12.72 12.49 14.23 15.84 20.31 13.75 13.72 13.93 11.14 13.20 17.54 10.11 12.95 16.92 13.42 15.41 21.14 13.78 13.05 13.87 10.49 14.13 16.94 10.45 11.13 16.76 13.67 15.02 22.16 13.97 14.34 10.43 15.20 16.79 10.41 12.30 14.34 13.43 16.92 21.73 14.22 13.39 10.48 18.05 18.66 9.54 12.40 14.74 13.56 17.20 19.34 14.63 13.62 10.65 21.18 19.12 9.52 12.23 18.79 14.65 15.91 19.07 15.55 14.01 10.28 20.54 17.77 9.39 13.37 19.35 15.18 15.65 18.69 14.98 Aug Sep 12.99 10.8 19.41 16.14 11.29 14.39 18.60 16.57 16.32 19.96 15.74 14.23 11.87 19.34 16.63 11.40 15.48 16.63 17.50 16.65 22.39 14.94 Oct Nov 13.72 11.40 17.65 16.63 12.69 15.66 15.78 19.43 16.82 20.94 14.75 12.69 12.32 19.75 15.14 13.76 13.14 17.19 18.48 17.30 18.70 14.32 Dec 13.26 12.37 18.58 13.95 15.04 12.22 15.14 16.30 18.03 14.78 12.90 #1327 ® HISTORICAL MILK PRICES - CLASS 4B Jan s Shred scent e r C & Booth V Cut Contact Urschel for a no-charge test-cut of your product [email protected] | Toll Free: +1.844.URSCHEL (877.2435) www.urschel.com delivering targeted cutting solutions ® Urschel & The Global Leader in Food Cutting Technology are registered trademarks of Urschel Laboratories, Inc. U.S.A. For more information, circle #35 on the Reader Response Card on p.22 02/16/2016 1619CheeseOverviewICTEtag_ChRptr.indd 1 9:30 AM