Fall 2009 - CFD Beratung
Transcription
Fall 2009 - CFD Beratung
Volume 13 Issue 3 Fall 2009 Gridgen Gets Plane in the Air Fast John B. Hinkey, Ph.D. Geminus Technology Development, LLC The test pilot refused to allow the micro air vehicle (MAV) dispenser to drop from his airplane’s wing until someone performed an aerodynamic assessment to determine if it might be possible for the dispenser to return to hit his aircraft, perhaps resulting in a very bad flight test day. A key part of the aerodynamic assessment was a quick computational fluid dynamic (CFD) analysis of the MAV dispenser (a customized Vietnam-era MK-20 canister) with the fins deployed to determine the basic aerodynamic characteristics. So our customer came to us with a two week turn-around goal of setting up a 180 degree symmetry simulation to estimate lift, drag and stability properties versus angle of attack at various deployment flight conditions (speed and altitude). There was not enough time to work extensively with CAD to produce a detailed geometry that had all the necessary geometry construction aids to produce the grid, thus Gridgen’s internal geometry/database generation tools became critical to producing a quality grid in a very short time. An IGES file of the somewhat simplified 3D geometry was all that was supplied and Gridgen did the rest. (Continues on page 2) University Of Siegen Uses Gridgen For Turbo Research Julian Winkler, Institute Of Fluid And Thermodynamics University Of Siegen, Germany Figure 1: University of Siegen researchers use Gridgen’s topological flexibility to create high quality grids on the leading edge serrations. (Close view) Figure 1: Far-field structured 180 degree symmetry block grid topology INSIDE THIS ISSUE Gridgen Gets Plane in the Air Fast 1 University of Siegen Uses Gridgen for Turbo Research 1 Partner Highlight 4 Training Dates 4 Product News 5 Toll Free 800-4PTWISE The Turbomachinery Research Group at the University of Siegen in Germany has been using Gridgen in several areas for several years. They integrated Gridgen into the design cycle for one of their primary areas of work, low-noise fan design. They also use Gridgen for more detailed fluid dynamic research studies, where Gridgen gives them a fine degree of control over grid spacing and distribution needed for accurate simulations. In addition, Gridgen is popular for student projects because it is easy to use. Gridgen is fully integrated into the group’s low-noise fan design cycle. First, an axial or radial fan is designed with an in-house tool, then a multi-block structured grid is generated with Gridgen (Continues on page 3) www.pointwise.com Pointwise® FocalPoint Fall 2009 2 Gridgen Gets Plane in the Air Fast (Continued from page 1) The ease of generating the far- and near-field body grids allowed us to concentrate on the more complicated tail fin grids, which were composed of structured blocks intended to overlap the main body grid by a minimum of two cells. The block structured grids employed matching, non-matching and overlapped block boundaries. The 3D mesh visualization and checking capability was extensively used to ensure proper block connectivity and block boundary overlap. To produce a high quality body cross section, the database creation tools were used to generate a slice along the body axis of the supplied 3D IGES file, which produced a 2D body profile. The main body blocks were then created as domains on the axis of symmetry using this 2D body profile. After generating an optimized 2D, multiple-domain mesh that extended away to approximately 15 body lengths, these were extruded 180 degrees about the body axis. This provided an efficient method to generate and, if necessary, modify and very quickly regenerate the primary axisymmetric 180 degree extent body blocks. Because of numerical robustness and accuracy issues, it was desirable not to have a singular grid on the body axis at the base surface. Figure 2: Near-field structured 180 degree symmetry block grid topology For the non-axisymmetric base meshes, a 2D mesh (domain) was produced via a central rectangular mesh and a surrounding C-mesh. The interfaces between these meshes were optimized by allowing the connectors common between these domains to float during use of the elliptic solver to smooth the mesh. This resulted in a very good mesh quality that became the 2D grid for the base. The 2D base meshes were also used to construct the downstream free stream boundary on the body axis by simply copying and then scaling the base meshes appropriately, thus saving time by not having to produce these meshes from scratch. The blocks needing to extend from the base surface out to the downstream free stream boundary were then constructed. Once the main body blocks were completed, the blocks around one of the fins were conventionally constructed using the fin surfaces defined by the IGES file. The second set of fin blocks was easily Figure 3: Overlapping structured blocks enclosing the base fins created by copying those from the first fin using the mirror tool. Use of the mirror tool instead of simply copying via rotation ensured that any geometry non-symmetries would be mirrored, thus helping to ensure zero lift at zero angle of attack. The ability to make rapid changes to the grid topology, grid density and grid point distributions produced very few grid iterations, which is a must when a fast turnaround is required. Due to the fast simulation turn around requirements, wall functions were planned to be used. Thus, the grids were clustered along the body and fins to produce y+ values of approximately 50 using hyperbolic tangent wall clustering. The outer flow boundaries of the tail fin blocks were constructed by using subsets of the 180 degree axisymmetric body blocks, thus allowing for better block overlapping. The grid diagnostic tools permitted rapid searches for any poor quality grid regions. Gridgen’s native support for the WindUS analysis code (from the NPARC Alliance) enabled direct output files to the native .CGD file format for WindUS, saving valuable time because no conversion utilities or other grid generation/manipulation tools were required. The rapid grid generation process helped to maximize the time available for solving the flow field, resulting in more data being generated at different flight speeds and altitudes. The high quality grid produced a very high quality solution. The flight test went off without a hitch and the ordinance behaved as expected, producing the desired uneventful flight test day. Pointwise has worked closely with us to implement new features in Gridgen/Pointwise and their technical support has been superb, often turning around completely new Glyph scripts or technical solutions within a day. Also, our company has effectively implemented Gridgen with minimal training (the available manuals are very good), saving time and resources to put into other areas of our business. This has allowed us to have rapid response to our customers’ needs and spend more time on the simulation and analysis and less time with grid generation, which is the whole point of having an effective grid generation tool, isn’t it? n Pointwise® FocalPoint Fall 2009 3 University Of Siegen Uses Gridgen For Turbo Research (Continued from page 1) and the flow through the fan is simulated with commercial computational fluid dynamics (CFD) packages. An iterative procedure is applied, based on the CFD results, to decide whether a redesign with subsequent CFD analyses is necessary or, if the simulation results are satisfactory, whether a prototype can be manufactured and tested experimentally. This design process has produced several successful low-noise fan designs. The Turbomachinery Research Group also uses Gridgen in conjunction with more advanced numerical techniques, such as large-eddy simulation, to calculate the flow around airfoils or in whole axial-flow fan assemblies. The main focus here is to gain detailed insight into the flow physics and the calculation of the acoustic source terms from the flow field for broadband noise prediction. One of the group’s recent studies focused on the influence of small tripping devices attached to a single airfoil on boundarylayer development, transition from laminar to turbulent flow and the acoustic implications in terms of trailing-edge noise of the airfoil. For this purpose, the region close to the leading edge of the airfoil, where forward facing serrations have been placed to produce an artificial transition from laminar to turbulent flow in the boundary layer, needed to be highly resolved. Figure 1 shows a close-up view of this region of the grid. Grid refinement around the boundary layer trips can be seen in this figure. Also evident are the grid topology changes needed to match the triangular shape of the trips with the rectangular planform of the airfoil. Gridgen provides the researchers with the degree of control necessary to create grids that resolve all the relevant geometric and flow features, and so get accurate numerical simulations. Figure 3: The grid above was used for a CFD solution to provide boundary conditions for the large-eddy simulation. The grid below is a subset of that grid. The effect of wind tunnel installations on aerodynamic loading and acoustics is another very important factor to take into account in a simulation like this. Wind tunnel interference effects can cause experimental results to differ significantly from freestream conditions. To incorporate these experimental influences into the numerical simulation, a grid was developed that included a simplified wind tunnel setup and the wind tunnel nozzle, as shown above in Figure 3. Flow calculations on this grid were performed to produce the correct inflow boundary conditions for a large-eddy simulation on a truncated domain, which was simply extracted from the full domain by deleting unwanted blocks in the multi-block grid. Gridgen has also been used for several student projects. Students were very pleased with the software because of its simplicity. Many challenges in using the software can be solved by intuition, which makes Gridgen a valuable product for teaching, as well. Gridgen has proven to be an efficient tool for high quality mesh generation and will be used in the continuation of the present projects and in classes taught at the University of Siegen. n Figure 2: Leading edge serrations. (Far view) Pointwise® FocalPoint Fall 2009 Partner Highlight EnSight CFD serves a variety of different sectors, including academic and research, aerospace, automotive, biomedical and chemical, construction, consultants, defense, electronics, energy, manufacturing, marine, petrochemical and sports. Image is courtesy of Drs. Yoram Yadlin and Arvin Shmilovich of The Boeing Company. Computational Engineering International (CEI) develops cutting-edge visualization and animation software. With CEI’s high-end software products, you can expand your simulation process to new extremes. CEI recently created a new interface based on its well-known extreme visualization product, EnSight, specifically tailored to the needs of CFD users. This new interface is simple and focused, designed to allow you to explore your data interactively. EnSight CFD will allow you to be more effective in analyzing, visualizing and communicating simulation results to your team. “EnSight allows us to be very precise for the phenomena we want to visualize,” said Alexis Lapouille of Aero Concept Engineering (ACE). “If you have phenomena at X=1m on a calculation, for example, FLUENT requires you to know where the phenomena is to generate the plane for visualization. With EnSight, you generate an X plane and then simply move it until you find the phenomena. Similarly, the vortex core feature allows you to find the vortex structure in very little time.” CEI has corporate headquarters in Apex, NC, and authorized distributors around the globe. For more information, visit our web site at www.EnSightCFD.com. Darin McKinnis VP Sales and Marketing CEI, Inc. Training Dates Gridgen Advanced and Pointwise Standard Course 10-12 November 2009 Fort Worth, Texas Gridgen Advanced and Pointwise Standard Course 19-21 January 2010 Fort Worth, Texas Gridgen Advanced and Pointwise Standard Course 23-25 February 2010 East Coast Gridgen Standard Course 23-25 March 2010 Fort Worth, Texas Gridgen Advanced and Pointwise Standard Course 11-13 May 2010 Fort Worth, Texas Gridgen Advanced and Pointwise Standard Course 15-17 June 2010 Midwest Gridgen Advanced and Pointwise Standard Course 13-15 July 2010 Fort Worth, Texas Gridgen Standard Course 14-16 September 2010 Fort Worth, Texas Gridgen Advanced and Pointwise Standard Course 12-14 October 2010 West Coast Gridgen Advanced and Pointwise Standard Course 16-18 November 2010 Fort Worth, Texas For more information, contact our Support Team at [email protected]. 4 Pointwise® FocalPoint Fall 2009 Product News Dozens of Time Saving Tools in Upcoming Pointwise Release Gridgen Research Enhances Overset Meshing Pointwise’s upcoming release of Solid Meshing will provide a suite of tools for addressing the issues associated with sloppy CAD geometry and give you access to dozens of other new meshing capabilities. If you’ve ever wished Pointwise could export a file in your favorite format, now’s your chance to turn that wish into reality. Using the new CAE plug-in API, you can write your own exporter for grid and boundary condition data so that your solver appears in the CAE menu. Your ability to customize Pointwise with advanced templates and macros based on the Glyph scripting language has been enhanced through the addition of support for Tk graphic interfaces and the addition of procedural entity selection. Generating turbomachinery grids is easier with the addition of rotational and translational periodicity for curve and surface grids. Two big changes on the hardware side of Pointwise give you more options for using the software. 64-bit support has been extended to the Microsoft Windows operating system. 3D mice, specifically the SpaceNavigator™ and SpaceExplorer™ devices from 3Dconnexion, now can be used for image manipulation, in addition to Pointwise’s traditional techniques. Exporting structured grids to CGNS, addition of toolbar display commands, IGES export, a list of your most recently used files, and many other tools await you in the next release. New features, added during an SBIR Phase I contract with the U.S. Air Force Arnold Engineering Development Center, are set to streamline overset meshing in Gridgen. One bottleneck in the creation of composite grids is the removal of failed interpolation points called orphans. Overset experts have developed eclectic suites of tools to locate, visualize and rectify problems in the composite grid. Although such toolsets have proven effective, they are far from efficient because the user must juggle many separate applications. Tools for importing and visualizing overset assembly interpolation data are being added to Gridgen. Orphan points will be highlighted for easy identification. Furthermore, overset data display will be pervasive throughout all Gridgen’s meshing tools, providing an easy reference when modifying grids to correct overset assembly problems. For complex problems, Gridgen’s Examine feature will be bolstered with additional overset assembly tools, making it possible to display overset hole, fringe and orphan points on block topological and physical cut planes. Furthermore, IBLANK, a key variable in composite grid interpolation, will be visible as a scalar function. Based on the success of this initial implementation in Gridgen, future research would migrate these tools into Pointwise and extend the coupling with overset assembly software such as PEGASUS and SUGGAR. This work is sponsored by Arnold Engineering Development Center, Air Force Materiel Command and the USAF. Automated gridding of complex geometries like this centrifugal pump is made possible through the addition of periodicity, scriptable selection and graphical script interfaces to the latest Pointwise release. Display of overset assembly orphan points in Gridgen. 213 South Jennings Avenue Fort Worth, Texas 76104-1107 Toll-free 800-4PTWISE Tel (817) 377-2807 Fax (817) 377-2799 [email protected] www.pointwise.com FocalPoint is a publication of Pointwise, Inc. It is for Gridgen and Pointwise users and people interested in learning more about numerical grid generation. It includes information about the software, latest releases, future development plans, and tips on how to get the most out of Gridgen and Pointwise while saving time in grid generation. Pointwise and Gridgen are registered trademarks and GridgenGlyph and PointwiseGlyph are trademarks of Pointwise, Inc. All other trademarks are property of their respective owner. Copyright © 2009 Pointwise, Inc. All rights reserved. 5 First Class US Postage PAID FT WORTH, TX Permit 356 213 South Jennings Avenue Fort Worth, Texas 76104-1107 RETURN SERVICE REQUESTED Volume 13 Issue 3 Fall 2009 The Best Tips and Tricks Let our technical support newsletter drive your productivity with the best tips and tricks from our experienced engineers. Sign up for TheConnector at pointwise.com/theconnector and stay ahead of the game with our prerelease notes. Just because there’s a new horse in the barn doesn’t mean we’re sending Old Reliable out to pasture. As one of our customers said, “For real work, you use Gridgen.” That’s why it’s known as the powerful CFD workhorse. While we’re building up Pointwise, our next generation software, fans of Gridgen don’t have to worry. Gridgen is not going away until our customers tell us Pointwise can do everything Gridgen can. In the meantime, our licenses let you run both products, so new users can jump right in with Pointwise’s short learning curve and longtime Gridgen fans can feel comfortable knowing it’s going to be there a long time. You can feel confident about the future. Reliable CFD Meshing is part of our name. Sign up and be the first to know: twitter.com/Pointwise