docSpring 2011 Volume: 35 Issue
download 
Report Transcription
Spring 2011 Volume: 35 Issue
!
!"#$%&''()''''
)1234515!67!)1287(91:;15<!'8=4>?8@4!
+(,$!-!!!
*++$&''('!
!"#$%&'(()*$'!
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
!
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!/!!!
!"#$%&'()*$'(+%',,(
-'."/%0(
12.3'&4(5*60(
(
+%',,(7482$*&(
9$%#//'(7.":'(
(
+%"4#;%(942%*&(
<2="#/(!":#>(
)*;%&2?"%2;=(@&2%#&$(
-'%2A'(7//20';2(
)'&*/2;'(7/8'&'4*(
B'82#&(7A'0'(
<'&0$*/(7C"2&&#(
946'&4(7&#//';*(
D2';.'(D#&&2*>'?'/(
7A';4'()'$'/#=;*(
<2.3'#/(E'&4*;(
5#*;*&(F'0%';(
!*#(F*;>'/#>(
G#$$2.'(F'&.2'(H#&;';4#>(
B"';(5*I#>(
E#/2'(<'&%2;#>()J(
<2="#/(!":#>(
E2';'(K"2;*;#>L+*%*(
9/82&'(12*$(
E&J(1*?#&%*(1*4&2="#>(
+%#I3';0(M#//#>(
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!A!!!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!"#$%&#'%()*+&)#
!
B6C!319D!E834?!@6!C4!E:89F!1G6;E!E:6?4!C:6!1>4!
24??!76>E;91E4!C:49!E:>6C89H!1C1D!247E6=4>!766@I!
+DYHZHHYHUEHHQWROG³(DWHYHU\WKLQJEHFDXVH
E:4!5:82@>49!89!%631281!@6!96E!:1=4!19DE:89H!E6!
HDW"´:KHQZHZRUU\RUFRPSODLQDERXWRXUOLYHV
@6!C4!4=4>!?E6J!19@!E:89F!1G6;E!E:6?4!E:1E!:1=4!8E!
4=49!:1>@4>!E:19!;?I!K8E:!E:8?!89!389@<!:6C!319D!
E834?!@6!C4!C6>>D!6>!4=49!E:89F!1G6;E!4LE>434!
J6=4>EDI!+4>:1J?<!C4!1>4!1!28EE24!E66!G;?D!C8E:!
C6>F<!>4?J69?8G828E84?!6>!6;>!6C9!45696385!
?8E;1E869?!E6!4=49!C69@4>!1G6;E!4LE>434!J6=4>ED!
89!;9@4>@4=426J4@!56;9E>84?M!B6C4=4><!8E!8?!19!
83J6>E19E!H26G12!8??;4!E:1E!12?6!E6;5:4?!6;>!
5633;98E84?M!K4!31D!96E!4=49!G4!1C1>4!67!E:8?!
J>6G243!G451;?4!E:4!34@81!19@!?6584ED!@6!96E!
H8=4!8E!E:4!83J6>E1954!E:1E!8E!?6!944@?M!&6!
3189?E>413!34@81<!5:82@>49!@D89H!G451;?4!67!
?E1>=1E869!8?!1E!E:4!G6EE63!67!E:48>!28?E!67!J>86>8E84?M!
B6C4=4><!69!(J>82!-N<!/0--<!.!:1@!E:4!J241?;>4!67!
1EE49@89H!1!J>4?49E1E869!GD!O6GGD!O1824D<!56P
76;9@4>!67!Q8=4!O426C!E:4!Q894<!19!898E81E8=4!
C:6?4!38??869!8?!E6!895>41?4!E:4!9;3G4>!67!J46J24!
E1F89H!15E869!1H189?E!4LE>434!J6=4>ED!19@!694!67!
E:4!782331F4>?!67!!"#$%$&'(!)*$'+,("<!1!
@65;349E1>D!E:1E!?J41F?!1G6;E!E:4!1G@;5E869!19@!
4928?E349E!67!D6;9H!5:82@>49!89E6!3828E1>D!76>54?!
89!#H19@1M!
!
!
!!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
%DLOH\¶VSUHVHQWDWLRQIRFXVHGRQH[SRVLQJ
4LE>434!J6=4>ED!1?!C422!1?!4LJ218989H!C:D!
J46J24!?:6;2@!51>4<!:6C!E:4D!519!:42J<!19@!C:1E!
E:4D!519!@6!E6!G4!1!J1>E!67!Q8=4!O426C!E:4!Q894M!
B8?!3189!H612!8?!E6!4@;51E4!19@!4928?E!1?!319D!
J46J24!1?!J6??8G24!?6!E:1E!5:19H4!519!655;>M!
&:>6;H:!?E1E8?E85?<!J1??869<!19@!5>8E8512!1912D?8?<!
O1824D!4LJ>4??4@!:6C!?4=4>4!4LE>434!J6=4>ED!8?M!
B4!?E1>E4@!GD!?1D89H!E:1E!:4!28=4@!69!67!R-MS0!1!
@1D!C:49!:4!C1?!89!1!@8?J2154349E!513J!89!
(7>851!G451;?4!:4!C19E4@!E6!4LJ4>84954!E:4!
:1>@?:8J?!67!G489H!4LE>4342D!J66>M!&:4!898E81E8=4!
E:1E!O1824D!?E1>E4@!8?!E6!28=4!G426C!E:4!J6=4>ED!
2894<!341989H!E6!28=4!69!R-MS0!1!@1D!89!6>@4>!E6!
G4EE4>!?D3J1E:8T4!C8E:!91E869?!C:4>4!J46J24!28=4!
1E<!6>!G426C<!E:1E!24=42M!B4!?E>4??4@!:6C!
38?569548=4@!(34>8519!?6584ED!8?!1G6;E!18@!E6!
91E869?!C:6!1>4!;9@4>H689H!1!5>8?8?!G451;?4!67!
?E1>=1E869M!O1824D!349E8694@!:6C!319D!J46J24!
E:89F!E:1E!E:4!#98E4@!%E1E4?!8?!H8=89H!/SU!18@!E6!
E:4?4!56;9E>84?!76>!E:4!;?4!67!49@89H!4LE>434!
J6=4>ED<!D4E!6E:4>?!G4284=4!E:1E!8E!8?!-0UM!
B6C4=4><!E:4!?1@!E>;E:!8?!E:1E!E:4!#98E4@!%E1E4?<!
1?!1!C:624<!8?!692D!H8=89H!-U!67!E:48>!18@!E6!?;5:!
56;9E>84?M!&:4!?E1E8?E85?!1>4!?1@@4989H!G451;?4!
C4!56;2@!G4!@689H!36>4!87!C4!692D!C6;2@!?J>41@!
E:4!C6>@<!87!C4!692D!4@;51E4@!E:4!H494>12!J;G285!
19@!?E6JJ4@!G489H!?6!?427P1G?6>G4@M!(556>@89H!
WR%DLOH\³WKHNH\WRUHIRUPLQXQGHUGHYHORSHG
56;9E>84?!8?!43J6C4>89H!E:4!C6349!67!E:1E!
FRXQWU\´7UHDWLQJZRPHQOLNHHTXDOVZRXOG
49@!4LE>434!J6=4>ED<!895>41?4!:412E:51>4<!
@45>41?4!E>19?38??869!67!?4L;122D!E>19?38EE4@!
89745E869?!?;5:!1?!(.V%<!19@!895>41?4!
897>1?E>;5E;>4M!
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
&:4!>4=421E869!67!4LE>434!J6=4>ED!4LJ>4??4?!
196E:4>!H26G12!8??;4!G;E!:6C!@64?!E:8?!E84!89E6!6;>!
5633;98EDI!.!E:89F!?634E834?!C4!1>4!E66!5>8E8512!
67!6;>!6C9!28=4?!19@!:1=4!E6!>4128T4!E:1E<!
563J1>4@!E6!?634!J1>E?!67!E:4!C6>2@<!C4!1>4!89!1!
J>6?J4>6;?!?E1E4M!K:4E:4>!C4!:1=4!J>6G243?!C8E:!
?5:662<!71382D<!>421E869?:8J?!6>!7>849@?W!C4!:1=4!E6!
>4343G4>!E:1E!6;>!28=89H!569@8E869?!1>4!
E:43?42=4?!1!2;L;>D!19@!?634E:89H!E:1E!.!G4284=4<!
C4!E1F4!76>!H>19E4@M!K4!:1=4!E:4!7>44@63!E6!
C19@4>!E:4!?E>44E?!C8E:6;E!E:4!>8?F!67!G489H!
F8@91JJ4@!19@!76>54@!89E6!3828E1>D!?4>=854M!K:49!
C4!H4E!;J!89!E:4!36>989H<!C4!:1=4!E:4!89@;2H4954!
67!1!:6E!G1E:!19@!1!51>!>8@4!E6!?5:662M!K4!1>4!
2;5FD!19@!1E!E:4!?134!E834!?427P1G?6>G4@!19@!
91X=4!1G6;E!C:1E!8?!H689H!69!89!E:4!>4?E!67!E:4!
C6>2@M!K4!944@!E6!E1F4!15E869!19@!@6!?634E:89H!
E:1E!C822!15E;122D!31F4!1!@8774>4954!89?E41@!67!
765;?89H!6;>!E834!69!E:89H?!E:1E!1>4!96E!H689H!E6!
5:19H4!28=4?M!.!G4284=4!E:1E!C4!519!49@!4LE>434!
J6=4>ED<!G;E!C4!944@!E6!@6!?634E:89H<!96E!Y;?E!E12F!
1G6;E!8E<!G;E!15E;122D!E1F4!15E869M!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
V;>89H!E:4!C44F!67!Z1D<!E:4>4!8?!H689H!E6!G4!1!
Q.[$!O$Q*K!&B$!Q."$!7;9@>18?4>!89!C:85:<!
76>!78=4!@1D?<!J46J24!1>4!G489H!5:12249H4@!E6!28=4!
677!67!R-MS0!1!@1D!19@!G1?85122D!28=4!89!E:4!?:64?!
67!E:6?4!C:6!28=4!89!4LE>434!J6=4>EDM!%6!C:D!8?!8E!
DGD\"$FFRUGLQJWRWKHZHEVLWH³:H
YH
?449!E:4!?E1E8?E85\!-M]!G822869!J46J24!1>4!28=89H!69!
#%R-MS0!6>!24??!J4>!@1DM!O;E!C:4>4!@8@!E:8?!
9;3G4>!5634!7>63I!&:4!K6>2@!O19F!?4E?!E:4!
³H[WUHPHSRYHUW\´VWDQGDUG6LQFHWKLV
28=89H!?E19@1>@!:1?!G449!?4E!1E!#%R-M/S!J4>!@1D!
^1@Y;?E4@!E6!#%R-MS0!E6!1556;9E!76>!89721E869_M!
7KLVVWDQGDUGIRUPVWKH³H[WUHPHSRYHUW\OLQH´
19!89=8?8G24!G6;9@1>D!31>F89H!19!1>41!E:1E!-M]!
G822869!J46J24!655;JDM!&:4!78>?E!?E4J!E6C1>@!
5:19H89H!E:8?!@8>4!?8E;1E869!76>!E:4!G4EE4>!8?!
@4=426J89H!19!;9@4>?E19@89H!67!E:4!8??;4M!&:1E`?!
C:4>4!-$#(./('01.2*(.-$"(!5634?!89\!8E!J>6=8@4?!
D6;!C8E:!19!6JJ6>E;98ED!E6!4LJ4>84954!694!
5:12249H4!67!28=89H!4LE>434!J6=4>ED!±!E:4!
5:12249H4!67!H4EE89H!496;H:!E6!41EM!.E!12?6!
43J6C4>?!D6;!E6!E1F4!1!?E19@!19@!E1F4!15E869!76>!
VRPHWKLQJZRUWKEHOLHYLQJLQ´$UH\RXZLOOLQJWR
E1F4!1!?E19@!19@!Q8=4!O426C!E:4!Q894I!a6>!36>4!
8976>31E869!69!Q8=4!O426C!E:4!Q894<!D6;!519!H6!
E6!Q8=4G426CE:42894M6>HM!
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!]!!!
!
(
!"#$%&'(&)*+%&,%-".*+&%/&0/%1"23&1%/&
92*/2"#:&%11&/":42&
24(&54"2(&673&8&
OD\!)1>62891!(2=1>1@6!
!
B1=4!D6;!4=4>!?E6JJ4@!E6!E:89F!C:6!>4122D!
5424G>1E4?!19@!J>678E?!7>63!)8956!V4!Z1D6I!K4!
F96C!78>?E!67!122!E:1E!)8956!@4!Z1D6!8?!96E!Z4L8519!
.9@4J49@4954!@1DM!Z4L8519!.9@4J49@4954!@1D!8?!
5424G>1E4@!89!Z4L856!69!%4JE43G4>!-bM!!Z4L856!
@4521>4@!8E?!89@4J49@4954!7>63!%J189!89!-c-0M!%6!
C:D!8?!4=4>DG6@D<!G6E:!(9H26?!19@!969!(9H26?!
:1=89H!1!G8H!784?E1!69!Z1D!787E:I!.7!C4!F96C!76>!1!
715E!E:1E!Z4L856!8?!96E!5424G>1E89H!69!Z1D!787E:!1?!
4LE49?8=42D!19@!4LJ49?8=42D<!E:49!C4!F96C!E:1E!E:8?!
8?!1!36>4!(34>85198T4@!:628@1DM!!.E!?443?!E:1E!
4=4>D694!C19E?!E6!:1=4!31>H1>8E1?!19@!41E!915:6?M!
K4!519!12?6!?44!Z4L8519!766@?!H6!69!?124<!
>4?E1;>19E?!4=49!51E4>!E6!)8956!@4!Z1D6!?J45812!
349;?<!19@!67!56;>?4!=4>D!83J6>E19E2D<!Z4L8519!
28d;6>!19@!G44>!1>4!:8H:2D!J>636E4@!15>6??!G1>?<!
>4?E1;>19E?<!19@!?E6>4?M!.>6985122D!6>!31DG4!96E!?6!
8>6985122D<!C4!7154!G>;E12!@>;H!C1>?!6=4>!E:4!G6>@4><!
8338H>1E869!8??;4?!89!(>8T691!E:1E!24H122D!76>54!;?!
E6!51>>D!6;>!@65;349E?!1E!122!E834?<!D4E!:6C!519!E:4!
#98E4@!%E1E4?!)424G>1E4!6>!1JJ>6J>81E4!E:4!
?8H987851954!67!6;>!:628@1D?M!&:4!#98E4?!%E1E4?!?1D?!
C4!519!C1?:!E:48>!@8?:4?<!5;E!E:4!H>1??!69!E:48>!
21C9?<!G;E!C4!519!96E!H189!58E8T49?:8JM!&:4!#M%M!
J>678E?!7>63!;9@65;349E4@!C6>F4>?!19@!5:41J!
569?E>;5E869!C6>F4>?<!318@?<!919984?<!@1D!21G6>4>?!
G;E!E:4D!@6!96E!C19E!E6!569?8@4>!6;>!J46J24!1?!
19DE:89H!36>4!E:19!Y;?E!1!?6;>54!67!5:41J!21G6>M!&6!
569?8@4>!E:4!Z4L8519!6>!8338H>19E?!67!E:8?!56;9E>D!
1?!36>4!E:19!21G6>!C6;2@!3419!E:4D!1>4!
15F96C24@H89H!E:1E!C4!1>4!J46J24M!
!
&:8?!56;9E>D!:696>?!Z1D!787E:!C8E:!
Z1>H1>8E1?!19@!"15:6?<!@>89F?!19@!J1>E84?<!G;E!E:4D!
C822!96E!:696>!6;>!:1>@!C6>F89H!J46J24!C8E:!
FLWL]HQVKLS6RPHWKLQJDERXWWKLVMXVWGRHVQ¶WVHHP
>8H:EM!.9!122!15E;128ED!Z1D!SE:!8?!1!5424G>1E869!67!1!
?3122!G1EE24!E:1E!655;>>4@!89!E:4!Z4L856!?E1E4!67!
+;4G21!89!-cb/M!Z4L8519!76>54?!@4741E4@!a>495:!
76>54?!1E!E:4!O1EE24!67!+;4G21M!!K:1E!>4122D!
:1JJ494@!C8E:!E:8?!:628@1D!C1?!E:1E!?634C:4>4!
1>6;9@!E:4!-Nc0?!E:4!Q1E896eB8?J1985!5633;98ED!
H>4C!?8H9878519E2D!E6!C:4>4!(34>8519!56>J6>1E869?!
G4H19!E6!>4128T4!E:1E!E:4>4!C1?!1!B8?J1985!3896>8ED!
31>F4E!E:1E!56;2@!G4!51?:4@!89!69M!&:8?!
38?56954JE869!67!Z1D!SE:!G489H!Z4L8519!
.9@4J49@4954!@1D!5134!G451;?4!#M%M!78>3?!
38?E1F492D!E:6;H:E!6;>!7>44@63!7>63!%J189!
655;>>4@!69!E:1E!@1DM!!"6C<!C8E:!H>41E!
56334>58128T1E869!67!E:4!)8956!@4!Z1D6!:628@1D!
96>E:!67!E:4!G6>@4><!8E!:1?!G45634!C:1E!8E!8?!E6@1DM!
(?!)8956!@4!Z1D6!1JJ>615:4?!J46J24!C822!
19E858J1E4!H66@!Z4L8519!766@<!784?E1?<!F8@?!G>41F89H!
J8f1E1?!1E!?5:662<!19@!J46J24!41E89H<!@>89F89H<!19@!
J1>ED89H!C:824!?5>41389H!6;E!*24g!Z6>4!Z1>H1>8E1?!
EDE\/HW¶VWU\QRWWRIRUJHWWKHUHDOLW\DQGELJJHU
J85E;>4!1E!:19@!19@!C:1E!8?!>4122D!H689H!69!89!E:8?!
56;9E>D!56954>989H!6;>!J46J24M!!$1E89H!E156?!19@!
?:1>89H!?634!31>H1>8E1?!C822!96E!31F4!E:4!H>41E4>!
LVVXHVMXVWJRDZD\³/D5D]DXQLGDMDPDVVHUD
YHQFLGD´/HW¶VXQLWHVWRSWKHSDUWLHVDQGGULQNV
19@!31F4!>412!?15>87854?!19@!@4319@!>412!5:19H4!76>!
4=4>D694<!96E!Y;?E!56>J6>1E4!J>678E?<!E:4!J4>54JE869!
RI$PHULFD¶VFROOHFWLYHLJQRUDQFHRIRXUKLVWRU\
19@!J628E8512!@8?>4?J45E!76>!6;>!Z4L8519e):85196!
5;2E;>4!19@!E:4!@1D!E6P@1D!28=4?!C4!569E89;4!E6!E>D!
E6!31F4!89!6;>!7138284?!19@!5633;98E84?M!
!
!
OD!\!(319@1!)1?124H96!
(
N;>!7;E;>4!>4284?!69!J46J24!H4EE89H!1!H66@!
4@;51E869M!&:>6;H:!>4?41>5:!C4!F96C!E:1E!E:4!78>?E!S!
\HDUVRIDFKLOG¶VGHYHORSPHQWZLOODIIHFWWKHVXFFHVVWKDW
1!5:82@!:1?!89!?5:662M!):82@>49!944@!1!=1>84ED!67!94C!
4LJ4>84954?!19@!J6?8E8=4!89E4>15E869?!E6!@4=426J!E:48>!
1G828ED!E6!241>9M!.976>31E869!69!:6C!E:4!G>189!@4=426J?!8?!
96C!1=1821G24!J>6=8@89H!d;19E8781G24!4=8@4954!E:1E!
ZLWKRXWWKHSURSHUH[SHULHQFHVDFKLOG¶VEUDLQVXIIHUV
^"1?:<!-NNN_M!!a15E6>?!89!E:8?!@4=426J349E!8952;@4W!
SDUHQWLQJVNLOOVWKHIDPLO\¶VHGXFDWLRQOHYHOSRYHUW\
215F!67!:412E:!?4>=854?<!6=4>!5>6C@4@!28=89H!569@8E869?!
19@!E:4!J6?8E8=4!4LJ4>84954?!E:1E!1>4!J>6=8@4@!E6!1!D6;9H!
5:82@M!(556>@89H!E6!E:4!/000!549?;?<!1236?E!694P:127!67!
5:82@>49!1H4?!0PS!D41>?!1>4!Q1E896?M!!*94!1H495D!89!
+1?1@491<!)12876>981!8?!E>D89H!E6!31F4!1!@8774>4954!76>!
Q1E896!7138284?M!
!
.9!"6=43G4>!-NNc!)12876>981!J1??4@!+>6J6?8E869!
-0<!E:4!)12876>981!):82@>49!19@!a138284?!a8>?E!(5EM!&:8?!
(5E!1226C4@!S0!549E?!7>63!415:!J15F!67!58H1>4EE4?!?62@!E6!
G4!?4E!1?8@4!76>!41>2D!5:82@:66@!@4=426J349E!?4>=854?!76>!
5:82@>49!;9@4>!E:4!1H4!67!78=4M!c0U!67!E:8?!>4=49;4!8?!E6!
G4!;?4@!GD!E:4!56;9E84?!69!J>6H>13?!19@!?4>=854?!
?J458785122D!>421E4@!E6!41>2D!5:82@:66@!@4=426J349EM!*94!
67!E:4!J>6H>13?!8?!E:4!#98=4>?12!+>4?5:662!+>6H>13M!&:8?!
J>6H>13!J>6=8@4?!26C!56?E!6>!7>44!4@;51E869!E6!5:82@>49!
C:6!1>4!67!J>4PF89@4>H1>E49!1H4M!
!
)6;9E84?!89!)12876>981!1>4!1G24!E6!1JJ2D!1556>@89H!
E6!E:48>!944@?<!7;994289H!36?E!67!E:4!3694D!E6!1H49584?!
WKDWKDYH³DWULVNFKLOGUHQ´XVXDOO\LQKLJK/DWLQR
948H:G6>:66@?M!!!.9!+1?1@491<!)(M!1!58ED!89!E:4!%19!
*DEULHO9DOOH\RQHDJHQF\0RWKHUV¶&OXE)DPLO\
Q41>989H!)49E4>!>4548=4@!?634!67!E:8?!7;9@89H!E:>6;H:!
E:4!#98=4>?12!+>4?5:662!+>6H>13M!&:4!J>6H>13!8?!H41>4@!
E6!:8H:!>8?F!7138284?M!&:8?!1H495D!J>6=8@4?!4@;51E869!76>!
G6E:!H494>1E869?M!&:4!1@;2E?!>4548=4!521??4?!E6!241>9!
$9H28?:!76;>!@1D?!1!C44F!19@!C44F2D!+1>49E!$@;51E869!
521??4?!E6!241>9!G4EE4>!J1>49E89H!?F822?M!&:4!5:82@>49!1>4!!
HQJDJHGLQDFXUULFXOXPWKDWHPSKDVLV¶VOHDUQLQJLQDQXUWXULQJHQYLURQPHQW7KHSUHPF!521??>663!
:1?!/-!5:82@>49!76>!E:>44!d;128784@!E415:4>!19@!1!J1>49E!1??8?E19EM!&:8?!J>636E4?!E:4!G;82@89H!67!1!
?E>69H!>421E869?:8J!G4EC449!5:82@!19@!E415:4>?M!.7!1!5:82@!7442?!436E869122D!?174!C8E:!E:48>!E415:4>!
E:49!E:4D!:1=4!1!G4EE4>!1G828ED!E6!49H1H4!89!241>989HM!&:4!?E177!G4284=4?!E:1E!1!5:82@!519!41?82D!241>9!
OHWWHUVDQGQXPEHUVEXWLIWKHUHLVQRWDGHTXDWHVXSSRUWDWKRPHWKHQWKHFKLOG¶VOHDUQLQJLV
KLQGHUHG7KH\EHOLHYHWKDWDFKLOG¶VOHDUQLQJLQYROYHVWKHZKROHIDPLO\3DUHQWVDUHWDXJKWWKH
83J6>E1954!67!>41@89H!E6!E:48>!5:82@M!&:4>4!1>4!15E8=8E84?!19@!521??4?!E:1E!:42J!J1>49E?!241>9!E:4!
83J6>E1954!67!4@;51E869!19@!:6C!E6!?;JJ6>E!E:8?!@4?8>4!89!E:48>!5:82@M!+1>49E?!1>4!4956;>1H4@!E6!
241>9!:6C!E6!G4!241@4>?!89!E:48>!5633;98E84?!?6!E:1E!21E4>!E:4D!519!G4!15E8=4!343G4>?!89!E:4!
424349E1>D!?5:662!?D?E43!19@!1@=651E4!76>!E:48>!5:82@M!&:8?!J>6H>13!715828E1E4?!4=49E?!E:1E!1>4!
89E49E869122D!?4EP;J!E6!:42J!J1>49E?!241>9!:6C!E6!C6>F!89!56338EE44?<!241>9!5697285E!3191H4349E!
?F822?!19@!5633;9851E869!?F822?M!!a1E:4>?!1>4!4956;>1H4@!E6!1??8?E!89!521??>663?!69!E:48>!@1D?!677M!
a138284?!1>4!J>6=8@4@!349E12!:412E:!?4>=854?<!87!944@4@<!19@!7138284?!1>4!1??8?E4@!C8E:!:412E:!
?4>=854!E:>6;H:!56221G6>1E89H!1H49584?M!
!
$JHQFLHVVXFKDV0RWKHUV¶&OXE)DPLO\/HDUQLQJ&HQWHUZLOOQRWJXDUDQWHHWKDW/DWLQR
5:82@>49!C822!?;5544@!89!4@;51E869M!O;E!8E!8?!1!?E1>E!E6!24=4289H!E:4!@8?5>4J195D!E:1E!4L8?E?!89!
4@;51E869M!!%8954!Q1E896!5:82@>49!1>4!?E1E8?E85122D!1E!>8?F!19@!89!?;5:!:8H:!9;3G4>?!8E!8?!83J4>1E8=4!
E:1E!E:4!H6=4>9349E!E1>H4E!E:8?!J6J;21E869M!!&:>6;H:!E:4!:42J!67!E:4!#98=4>?12!+>4?5:662!J>6H>13?!
19@!6E:4>!:8H:!d;128ED!4@;51E86912!J>6H>13?!76>!D6;9H!5:82@>49!E:4!:6J4!8?!E6!?;554??7;22D!J>4J1>4!
122!5:82@>49!E6!49E4>!?5:662!:412E:D!19@!>41@D!E6!241>9M!*92D!E:8?!C822!:42J!895>41?4!E:4!9;3G4>!67!
Q1E896!?E;@49E?!E:1E!49E4>!56224H4?!19@!21E4>!E:4!4@;51E4@!C6>F!76>54M!
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!S!!!
!"#$%&$'()*+#,$
HH!
9(-1;0%/2/*"2&%1&24(&<*=%>?&0*"#2(/&'"(:%&
"#$!%&'()&!*++(#&,(!
!"#$ %&'$ ()$ *))'$ +,)")-)"$ ./0$ &")$ &'1$
+,)")-)"$ ./0$ 2/3$ 4,"/02,$ 5"))+&.$
/-)"6&**)*7$ +&88*$ &")$ %/-)")1$ 9'$ %/8/"508$
2"&559#9$#/$#,)$29&'#$:0"&8*$&'1$*%086#0")*$#,&#$
()&0#95.$&$')92,(/",//1$6&";3$!"#$#"&'*5/":*$
&$ %)"#&9'$ &")&$ /"$ 8/%	/'$ 9'#/$ &$ :&*#)"69)%)$
5988)1$+9#,$%08#0")$&'1$2//1$-9()*3$!*$./0$%&'$
*))7$ &"#$ %&'$ ()$ *))'$ &*$ &$ 2&#)+&.$ 9'#/$
NQRZLQJDERXWVRPHRQH¶VFXOWXUHLQDGGLWLRQ
WR NQRZLQJ RQH¶V RZQ FXOWXUDO KLVWRU\
(&%;2"/0'1$ #,"/02,$ :0"&8*7$ 6&9'#9'2*7$
SKRWRJUDSKV HWF ,W DOVR GHPRQVWUDWHV RQH¶V
%")	-9#.$ 9'$ )<6")**9'2$ /')*)85$ #/$ /#,)"*3$
6/"#"&.*$&$+/:&'$;'))89'2$&'1$59<9'2$((((((((
(
!
V/:)$ &"#$ %&'$ )-)'$ ()$ *))'$ &*$ &$ 5/":$ /5$
6"/6&2&'1&$ /"$ &1-)"#9*):)'#$ 9'$ /"1)"$ #/$ 2)#$
#,)$ &##)'#9/'$ /5$ #,)$ 6)/68)$ &(/0#$ &$ %)"#&9'$
%&0*)$/"$)-)'#3$!'$)<&:68)$/5$#,9*$+/081$()$
X)":&'$ B"/6&2&'1&3$ X)":&'*$ 0*)1$ #,9*$
5/":$/5$&"#$&*$&$:)190:$9'$/"1)"$#/$:&9'#&9'$
6/+)"$ &'1$ #/$ 9:68):)'#$ 6/89%9)*$ #,&#$ +)")$
9:6/"#&'#$#/$#,):3$F)9'2$&$%/::0'9*#7$O9)2/$
P9-)"&$0*)1$,9*$&"#$#/$6/"#"&.$#,)$9:6/"#&'%)$
/5$#,)$+/";9'2$%8&**3$4,"/02,/0#$#9:)7$+)$&")$
&(8)$#/$*))$#,&#$&"#$,&*$())'$%,&'29'23$$
!
0DQ\DVN³+RZKDVLWEHHQFKDQJLQJ"´$
F.$#,)$')+$#)%,'9[0)*$#,&#$&")$()9'2$/55)")1$
"92,#$ '/+7$ *0%,$ &*$ X"&559#9$ &"#$ +,9%,$ %&'$ ()$
6)"%)9-)1$ &*$ -&'1&89*:7$ .)#$ #/$ /#,)"*7$ 9#$ 9*$ &$
5/":$ /5$ )<6")**9/'3$ ='$ &119#9/'7$ #,)")$ ,&-)$
())'$ ')+$ &'1$ 06E&'1E%/:9'2$ &"#9*#*$ #,&#$
,&-)$ ())'$ 9'580)'%)1$ (.$ /81$ &"#9*#*$ *0%,$ &*$
O9)2/$ P9-)"&7$ U"91&$ G&,8/7$ X98()"#$ Q&20$
W0Z&'7$ Z0*#$ #/$ '&:)$ &$ 5)+S$ 9'$ "):&;9'2$ &"#$
69)%)*$9'$#,)9"$/+'$0'9[0)$+&.3$Q/")/-)"7$&"#$
9'$ */%9)#.$ 68&.*$ &$ "/8)$ 9'$ #,)$ R,9%&'/H&L\
W	'/H&L$%/::0'9#.$9'$2)##9'2$#/$;'/+$:/")$$
&(/0#$#,)$,9*#/".$&*$+)88$&*$%08#0")$/5$+,&#$9#$
:)&'*$#/$()$&$R,9%&'/H&L\W	'/H&L3$N)88E
;'/+'$&"#9*#*$*0%,$&*7$O9)2/$P9-)"&$&")$
;'/+'$5/"$()9'2$2")&#$Q)<9%&'$6&9'#)"*$&'1$!
:0"&89*#*3$ Y)$ 9*$ 2").$ ")%/2'9@)1$ 5/"$ ,9*$
:&2'959%)'#$6&9'#9'2*$1)69%#9'2$*%)')*$5"/:$
Q)<9%&'$ ,9*#/".$ &'1$ )-)".1&.$ *#"0228)*$ /5$
#,)$ Q)<9%&'$ +/";9'2$ %8&**$ 9'$ ,9*$ %&'-&*)*$
9'$/"1)"$#/$*,/+$,9*$%08#0"&8$(&%;2"/0'1$&*$
+)88$ &*$ +,)")$ ,)$ %&:)$ 5"/:$ +,9%,$ +&*$
X0&'&Z0&#/7$ Q)<9%/3$ !119#9/'&88.7$ ,)$
9'%801)*$ */:)$ /5$ ,9*$ 6)"*/'&8$ )<6)"9)'%)*$
9'$,9*$6&9'#9'2*$*0%,$&*$&$*)85E6/"#"&9#$/5$,9*$
+95)$U"91&$G&,8/7$+,/$9'$5&%#$9*$&'/#,)"$+)88E
;'/+'$ 5):&8)$ &"#9*#$ 9'$ Q)<9%&'$ &"#$ ,9*#/".3$
4,"/02,$,9*$6&9'#9'2*$,)$1):/'*#"&#)*$,&"1$
+/";$&'1$*#"0228)3$$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$!!
$!
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
!*$&'$9'#)"'	/'&8$&"#9*#7$O9)2/$P9-)"&$+&*$
")%/2'9@)1$5/"$,9*$1955)")'#$&"#$69)%)*3$!$5)+$
/5$,9*$5&:/0*$&"#$69)%)*$#,&#$&")$+)88$;'/+'$
WRGD\ DUH³7KH)ORZHU &DUULHU´DQG³)ORZHU
6HOOHU´ ZKLFK SRUWUD\V DQ XQWUDLQHG DQG
0'*;988)1$ +/";)"$ 9'$ &$ :/1)"'7$ %&69#&89*#9%$
)%/'/:.3$=#$&8*/$*,/+*$#,)$1&98.$*#"0228)$/5$
6)/68)$ +/";9'2$ #/$ *066/"#$ #,)9"$ 5&:989)*3$
4,)$ 58/+)"$ %&'$ ()$ *))'$ &*$ &$ 5/":$ /5$
*.:(/89*:7$ *.:(/89@9'2$ &$ 80<0".$ 9'$ +,9%,$
#,)$ +/";)"7$ +,/$ 9*$ ()'19'2$ 1/+'7$ %&''/#$
*))$ #,)$ ()&0#.$ /5$ #,)$ 58/+)"$ 10)$ #/$ #,)$
,)&-.$ (&*;)#$ #,&#$ ,)$ 9*$ %&"".9'23$ A'$ #,)$
/#,)"$ ,&'17$ #,)$ 58/+)"$ *)88)"$ 6/"#"&.*$ &$
+/:&'$;'))89'2$&'1$59<9'2$58/+)"*$#,&#$*,)$
9*$ 68&''9'2$ #/$ *)883$ 4,)$ 58/+)"$ 9'$ #,)*)$
6&9'#9'2*$ *.:(/89@)*$ &'$ &'%9)'#$ Q)<9%&'$
WUDGLWLRQ E\ ³GHGLFDWLQJ WKH IORZHUV WR WKH
2/1$/5$58/+)"*$9'$&119#9/'$#/$,&-9'2$#,):$9'$
IHVWLYLWLHV´ 'LHJR 5LYHUD $V \RX FDQ VHH
³Y)$ +&*$ &'$ &"#9*#$ +,/$ 0*)1$ ,9*$ +/";$
6/89#9%&88.$ #/$ *6)&;$ 5/"$ #,)$ 0'1)"6"9-98)2)1$
PDVVHVLQKLVKRPHODQGRI0H[LFR´'LHJR
P9-)"&$ B"9'#*L3$ 4,"/02,$ ,9*$ 6&9'#9'2*7$ +)$
&")$ &(8)$ #/$ 19*#9'209*,$ ,9:$ 5"/:$ /#,)"$
&"#9*#*7$ ()%&0*)$ /5$ #,)$ +&.$ ,)$ 6)"%)9-)*$
Q)<9%&'$ #"&19#9/'$&*$ +)88$,9*#/".$ &'1$ (.$ ,9*$
%/::0'9*#$91)/8/29)*$#,&#$,)$()89)-)1$9'3$$
A'$ #,)$ /#,)"$ ,&'17$ &'/#,)"$ &"#9*#$ #,&#$ ,&*$
EHHQ UHFRJQL]HG LQ WRGD\¶V PRGHUQ VRFLHW\
9*$ Q&";$ Q&%,&1/7$ ()##)"$ ;'/+'$ &*$ Q9*#)"$
R&"#//'\$ Q"3$ R&"#//'3$ !8#,/02,7$ ,)$ 0*)*$ &$
1955)")'#$5/":$/5$&"#$#,&'$O9)2/$P9-)"&7$,)$9*$
%/'*91)")1$ &$ +)88$ ;'/+'$ &"#9*#$ 9'$ #,)$ Y96E
Y/6\0"(&'7$ R,9%&'/\&$ %/::0'9#.7$ 10)$ #/$
,9*$8/+E"91)"$&"#7$&9"("0*,9'27$#&##//*7$&*$+)88$
2"&559#9$ &"#7$ #,"/02,$ +,9%,$ ,9*$ &"#9*#9%$ *;988*$
1)-)8/6)13$ $ !*$ &$ Q)<9%&'$ !:)"9%&'$ &"#9*#7$
,)$ ()2&'$ ,9*$ &"#9*#*$ +/";$ &#$ #,)$ &2)$ /5$
#+)8-)$(.$&9"("0*,9'2$*,9"#*$&'1$8/+E"91)"*3!
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
='$ &119#9/'7$ ,)$ 9*$ ;'/+'$ 5/"$ &1/6#9'2$ #,)$
TU9')89')$ V#.8)T$ #&##//$ &"#7$ +,9%,$ +&*$
1)-)8/6)1$ 9'$ #,)$ R&895/"'9&$ 6"9*/'$
V\VWHP´%URZQSULGH(DUQLQJKLVQLFNQDPH
&*$ &'$ &"#9*#$ /'$ #,)$ *#"))#7$ ,9*$ &"#$ 2/#$ ,9:$ /0#$
RI WURXEOH DQG ODQGHG KLP D FDUHHU ³+H KDV
)<68/")1$ :&'.$ 1955)")'#$ #.6)*$ /5$ &"#9*#9%$
6"&%#9%)$ 9'%8019'2$ *92'$ 6&9'#9'27$ 2"&559#97$
&0#/: /#9-)$ : 0"&8*$ &'1$ : &2&@9')$
LOOXVWUDWLRQV´ :LNL $ ZHEVLWH FDOOHG
W	'P&66)"3%/:$ ,&-)$ 9'#)"-9)+)1$ Q9*#)"$
R&"#//'$&'1$,/+$,9*$&"#$,&*$9:6&%#)1$,9*$895)7$
!³:KDWGLVWLQJXLVKHV\RXUZRUNIURPRWKHU
$UWLVWV´"!
!!!!!!!
!³=$#,9';$+,&#$:&;)*$:)$1955)")'#$&'1$/"929'&8$
9*$ #,&#$ =$ 1"&+$ )&%,$ &'1$ )-)".$ %0*#/:)"$ &$
%0*#/:$ /"929'&8$ #&##//7$ =$ 1/'>#$ 1/$ &'.#,9'2$
#+9%)333?-)'$ 95$ ./0$ +&'#$ */:)#,9'2$ &8")&1.$
1/')7$ =>88$ %,&'2)$ 9#$ 063$ =$ *6)%9&89@)$ 9'$ (8&%;$
&'1$2").7$=$1/'>#$0*)$&'.$%/8/"*3$A')$(/##8)$/5$
(8&%;$&'1$*/:)$+&#)"7$#,&#>*$9#3$=$1/'>#$2/$/0#$
/5$ :.$ *#.8)7$ #,&#>*$ :)7$ #,&#>*$ +,&#$ =$ 1/3$ =$
+/081'>#$1/$'/#,9'2$/'$&'./')$#,&#$=$+/081'>#$
+)&"3$B)"*/'&88.$=$")*6)%#$%/8/"$#&##//*7$(0#$=$
+/081'>#$ 60#$ &'.$ /'$ :)3$ 4,&#>*$ ()%&0*)$ /5$
, / + $ = $ 2 " ) + $ 0 6 7 $ # , & # > * $ / 0 "$
VW\OH´/DWLQ5DSSHUFRP$
$
!*$ &$ +)88$ ;'/+'$ &"#9*#$ 9'$ 0"(&'$ /"$ *#"))#$ &"#7$
,)$,&*$9'580)'%)1$:&'.$/#,)"$&"#9*#*7$*/:)$/5$
,9*$ %89)'#$ 89*#$ 9'%801)*$ C0*#9'$ 49:()"8&;)7$ DE
@9(9#7$ ?:9'):7$ F)./'%)$ G'/+8)*7$ 4.*/'$
F)%;5/"17$ 4"&-9*$ F&";)"$ HF89';$ IJKL7$ M&*7$
B,&")88$N9889&:*7$A0#;&*#$&'1$:/")3$$
$
A-)"&887$ &"#$ 9*$ 6/"#"&.)1$ 9'$ */%9)#.$ &*$ &$
:&";)#9'2$#//87$&$+&.$#/$%/'-).$&$:)**&2)7$&$
-/9%)$ #/$ #,)$ 6)/68)7$ )#%3$ !"#9*#*$ 89;)$ O9)2/$
P9-)"&7$Q9*#)"$R&"#//'7$&'1$/#,)"$&"#9*#*$,&-)$
0*)1$&"#$9'$/"1)"$#/$6/"#"&.$&$:)**&2)$&'1$&$
")6")*)'#$#,)$+/";9'2$%8&**7$9'$/"1)"$#/$*,/+$
&$ *91)$ /5$ */%9)#.$ #,&#$ 9*$ /5#)'$ ')28)%#)1$ &'1$
("0*,)1$ /553$ !119#9/'&88.7$ &8#,/02,$ O9)2/$
P9-)"&$6/"#"&.*$#,)$Q)<9%&'$+/";9'2$%8&**$9'$
,9*$ 6&9'#9'2*$ &'1$ :0"&8*S$ ,)$ 1/)*$ */$ +9#,$
)8)2&'%)7$ Q9*#)"$ R&"#//'$ 1)69%#*$ #,)$ *#"))#$
)8):)'#$ /5$ #,&#$ *&:)$ %8&**3$ R&"#//'$ 1)69%#*$
#,)$ 2&'2*#)"$ #/02,$ 20.$ 9:&2)*7$ #,)$
:&%,9*:/$ )8):)'#$ /5$ 2&'2*#)"9*:$ 9'$ #,)$
R,9%&'/$%08#0")3$
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!b!!!
M3#(+%'%#(*,(7&2>*;'(';4(@32%#(+"I&#A'.0(
OD\!)1>62891!(2=1>1@6!
!
);>>49E2D!E:4!%E1E4!67!(>8T691!:1?!G449!;9@4>!1EE15F!76>!E1>H4E89H!Q1E896?M!K4!78>?E!?1C!E:8?!C8E:!E:4!19E8P8338H>19E!21C<!%O-0h0!1226C89H!76>!E:4!
24H128T1E869!67!>15812!J>678289H!GD!>4d;8>89H!J62854!E6!?E6J!19@!d;4?E869!19D694!C:6!E:4D!E:89F!8?!1!J6??8G24!;9@65;349E4@!J4>?69M!!Z6>4!>4549E2D<!&63!B6>94<!
E:4!:41@!67!E:4!(>8T691!4@;51E869!?D?E43!31@4!1!J;G285!?E1E4349E!@4521>89H!E:1E!E:4!Z4L8519!(34>8519!%E;@84?!J>6H>13!89!E:4!&;5?69!?5:662!@8?E>85E<!694!67!
76;>!4E:985!?E;@84?!J>6H>13?!89!E:1E!@8?E>85E<!C1?!89!=8621E869!67!1!94C!?E1E4!21C!E:1E!:1@!Y;?E!H694!89E6!47745EM!B6>9!C:6!8?!12?6!E:4!94C2D!4245E4@!(>8T691!?E1E4!
DWWRUQH\JHQHUDOJDYHWKH7XFVRQVFKRROGLVWULFWGD\VWR³FRPSO\´ZLWKWKHODZ$QGWKHILQGLQJWKUHDWHQHGWKDW³WKHRQO\C1D!89!C:85:!563J281954!519!G4!
HIIHFWLYHZLWKLQWKHQH[WGD\VLVE\HOLPLQDWLRQRIWKH0H[LFDQ$PHULFDQ6WXGLHVSURJUDP´7KH7XFVRQVFKRROGLVWULFWFRXO@!:1=4!-0!J4>549E!67!8E?!G;@H4E!
E1F49!1C1D<!136;9E89H!E6!1G6;E!R-S!3822869<!87!8E!@64?!96E!4283891E4!E:4!J>6H>13M!
!
&:8?!21C!C:85:!C49E!89E6!47745E!i19;1>D!-<!?E1E4?!E:1E!96!?5:662!@8?E>85E!519!8952;@4!89!E:48>!J>6H>13<!19D!56;>?4!E:1E!J>636E4!E:4!6=4>E:>6C!67!E:4!
#98E4@!%E1E4?!H6=4>9349EW!J>636E4?!>4?49E349E!E6C1>@!1!>154!6>!521??!67!J46J24W!8?!@4?8H94@!J>831>82D!76>!J;J82?!67!1!J1>E85;21>!4E:985!H>6;JW!6>!1@=651E4?!
4E:985!?628@1>8ED!89?E41@!67!E:4!E>41E349E!67!J;J82?!1?!89@8=8@;12?M!!(2E:6;H:!E:8?!21C!@64?!96E!31F4!4E:985!?E;@84?!8224H12<!E:6?4!C:6!:1=4!@4?8H94@!E:4!21C!
DSSHDUWREHWDUJHWLQJWKH7XFVRQ6FKRROGLVWULFW¶V0H[LFDQ$PHULFDQ6WXGLHVSURJUDPDQGRWKHUVLPLODUHWKQLFVWXGLHVSURJUDP?!C8E:89!E:4!?E1E4M!!.E!@64?!?443!
E:1E!122!67!E:4?4!94C!21C?!1>4!J1>E!67!E:4!19E8!8338H>19E!J628E8512!1EE15FM!(22!J46J24!67!5626>!89!(>8T691!1>4!G489H!E1>H4E4@<!G;E!8E!266F?!4?J458122D!28F4!E:6?4!E:1E!
1>4!Z4L8519M!!K:D!8?!8E!E:1E!E:4!(7>8519!(34>8519!?E;@84?!6>!E:4!"1E8=4!(34>8519!%E;@84?!J>6H>13?!1>4!96E!;9@4>!1EE15F!G;E!692D!E:4!Z4L8519!(34>8519?I!(>4!
96E!122!67!E:4?4!4E:985!?E;@84?!56;>?4?!76;9@4@!69!E:4!?134!G1?8?!19@!E415:!?83821>!E:434?I!
.E!8?!83J6>E19E!E6!F44J!E:4!4E:985!?E;@84?!J>6H>13!128=4<!96E!692D!89!(>8T691<!G;E!122!6=4>M!a6>!319D!?E;@49E?!E:8?!8?!694!67!E:4!692D!3419?!76>!E:43!E6!
7442!E:1E!E:4D!G4269H!E6!?634E:89HM!K4!241>9!E:>6;H:!6;>!4@;51E869!?D?E43<!:8?E6>D!E:1E!C4!51996E!19@!@6!96E!>421E4!E6M!&:4!Z4L8519!6>!):85196!%E;@84?!
J>6H>13!H8=4?!?E;@49E?!1!?49?4!67!G4269H89H!89!:8?E6>D!GD!E415:89H!C:1E!36?E!67!E:4!#98E4@!%E1E4?!:8?E6>D!G66F?!:1=4!638EE4@M!&415:4>?!89!(>8T691!:1=4!7824@!
21C?;8E?!5218389H!E:8?!E6!G4!;9Y;?EM!&:4D!52183!E:48>!Y6G!8?!E6!>4:;3198T4!E:4!4LJ4>84954!76>!?E;@49E?!E:>6;H:!1!5;2E;>122D!19@!?658122D!>424=19E!5;>>85;2;3M!!.E!
:1?!G449!C8@42D!F96C9!E:1E!Q1E896<!(7>8519!(34>8519<!(?819!(34>8519!19@!"1E8=4!(34>8519!?E;@49E?!:1=4!G449!31>H89128T4@!19@!8H96>4@!89!3189!?E>413!
J;G285!?5:662!?;GY45E?!!19@!E:1E!@>6J6;E!>1E4?!76>!6;>!3896>8ED!5633;98E84?!1>4!3;5:!:8H:4>!C:49!563J1>4@!E6!$;>6J419!(34>8519!?E;@49E?!1?!?E1E4@!GD!!?634!
67!E:4!4@;51E6>?!89!E:4!(>8T691!?5:662!@8?E>85EM!
&:8?!8?!Y;?E!1!3419?!E6!569E>62!E:4!J46J24!G451;?4!C8E:!E:4!31Y6>8ED!67!E:4!(>8T691!J6J;21E869!G489H!Q1E896!E:4!jP-/!?5:662!J6J;21E869!8?!?;>4!E6!G4!
:8H:!1?!C422M!!+4>:1J?!C4!56;2@!12?6!?44!E:8?!1?!1!C1D!E:1E!(>8T691!8?!>41??;>89H!8E?!K:8E4!%;J>43158?E!@63891E869!6=4>!E:4!26C4>!521??4?M!!.E!:1?!?E1>E4@!GD!
;?89H!E:4!?E1E4!67!(>8T691!1?!19!4L13J24<!G;E!8E!?:6;2@!31F4!;?!?E19@!;J!19@!78H:E!E6!?;JJ6>E!E:4?4!51;?4?!76>!6;>!J46J24M!O;@H4E!5;E?!19@!#)!744?!895>41?89H!
@>1?E85122D!56;2@!?669!3419!E:1E!C4!56;2@!12?6!?44!E:4!1G628E869!67!E:4!$E:985!%E;@84?!31Y6>!E:>6;H:6;E!E:4!#)!?D?E43!1?!C422M!
76'&42;=(%3#(52;4'(+.3#/#(76'&4O(M3#(PQRR(<'0'(<##%2;=()*;,#&#;.#(
OD\!):8312561E2!^Z8H;42!";f4T_!
!
(27>4@6!Q6J4T!(;?E89<!1!96E1G24!Z4L851:!19@!J>674??6>!67!21!#98=4>?8@1@!"1586912!(;E69631!@4!Z4L856!
^#"(Z_<!C1?!1C1>@4@!E:4!Q89@1!%5:424!(C1>@!GD!V1=8@!%E;1>E<!@8>45E6>!67!E:4!Z1D1!Z44E89H!)6974>4954M!B4!C1?!
J>4?49E4@!GD!E:8?!C422P>456H98T4@!1C1>@!76>!:8?!56>J;?!67!Z4L851:e"1:;1E2!C>8E89H?M!%634!67!:8?!521??85?!19@!3;?E!>41@!
8952;@4!$2!J1?1@6!89@8H491!^/00-_<!);4>J6!:;3196!4!8@4626H81!^-Nc0_<!D!B63G>4PV86?!^-Nh/_M!B4!:1?!569E>8G;E4@!E6!E:4!
>85:!;9@4>?E19@89H!67!"1:;1E2!5;2E;>4!1269H!C8E:!:8?!H>41E!56224H4!19@!B;4D!&4315:E8198!^,>41E!&415:4>_!Z8H;42!Q469!
+6>E8221M!B8?!2874269H!569E>8G;E869?!56;2@!96E!H6!;996E854@!GD!4=49!Z1D1!?5:621>?!C:6!:1=4!@>1C9!563J1>8?69?!G4EC449!
(91:;15!+46J24?!19@!);2E;>4?!^84!Z1D1<!Z8LE451:<!*23451:<!&46E8:;1d;4:<!Z4L851:e"1:;1E2_M!"1:;1E2!8?!E:4!219H;1H4!
C8E:!E:4!21>H4?E!56>J;?!67!@65;349E?!?;>J1??89H!E:6?4!76>!,>44F?!19@!'6319?!19@!:1?!18@4@!E:4!@458J:4>89H!67!Z1D1!
µJO\SKV¶DQG0D\DZRUOGYLHZGXHWRWKHLUH[WUHPHO\FORVHUHODWLRQVYLDWUDGHFXOWXUDOH[FKDQJHDQGLQWHUUHODWHG
RULJLQV¶KLVWRU\¶!
!
&:4!(C1>@!C1?!?8H9878519E2D!?D3G6285!1?!E:4D!>456H98T4@!E:4!?5:621>2D!:8?E6>85!@8?569945E869!67!"1:;1E2!7>63!
0D\DFXOWXUHVZKLFKKDVVORZHGGRZQ0D\DµVFKRODUVKLS¶7KHJDSZDVV\PEROLFDOO\FORVHGLQWKHKRQRULQJRIWKH
Q89@1!%5:424!(C1>@!E6!Q6J4T!(;?E89!C:6?4!J>831>D!C6>F!765;?!69!E:4!"1:;1E2!19@!"1:;1E2!5;2E;>4!19@!C6>2@=84C<!67!
ZKLFKZDVVKDUHGZLWKWKH0D\D1DKXDWOXQGHUVWDQGLQJDQGGRFXPHQWVKDYHJUHDWO\FRQWULEXWHGWR0D\D³VWXGLHV´
(7E4>C1>@?<!Q6J4T!(;?E89!J>4?49E4@!69!:8?!789@89H?!1G6;E!"1:;1E2!J:826?6J:8512!563J24L8E84?!19@!E:48>!83J2851E869?!E6!
G4EE4>!563J>4:49@!E:4!>85:!E>1@8E869?!67!96E!692D!E:4!Z1D1<!G;E!12?6!67!E:4!"1:;1E21:E6:d;4:!^"1:;1E2P%J41F4>?_M!&:4!
FRQIHUHQFHFRQFOXGHGZLWKRWKHUWDONVE\WRS0D\DµVSHFLDOLVWV¶DQGIRFXVLQJLQRQWKHPLVXQGHUVWDQGLQJVRIDQG
?5849E8785!4=8@4954!67!E:4!E>;4!83J2851E869?!67!/0-/M!
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!h!!!
!"#$%&'&#()%'*'+,-.*/*#
*G4?8ED!89!(34>8519!8?!1!?4>86;?!5:>6985!:412E:!
56954>9M!.9!715E<!E:4!#98E4@!%E1E4?!^#M%M_!)49E4>?!
76>!V8?41?4!)69E>62!19@!+>4=49E869!89!/00]!
>19F4@!6G4?8ED!1?!E:4!9;3G4>!694!:412E:!>8?F!
71589H!(34>851M!&:4!%;>H469!,494>12!'85:1>@!
)1>3691!@4?5>8G4@!E:4!6G4?8ED!4J8@4385!1!
³QDWLRQDOFULVLV´!
!!
&6!521>87D!?634!67!E:4!563369!E4>389626HD!E:1E!
8?!@182D!4L5:19H4@!89!@8?56;>?4<!E:4!E4>3?!
³REHVLW\´DQG³RYHUZHLJKW´GRQRWLOOXVWUDWHWKH
?134!56954JE!@4?J8E4!E:4!?18@!C6>@?!G489H!
569?E19E2D!;?4@!1?!?D969D36;?!E4>3?!GD!E:4!
JHQHUDOSXEOLF7KHWHUP³RYHUZHLJKW´DFFRUGLQJ
E6!E:4!"1E86912!.9?E8E;E4?!67!B412E:<!8?!@47894@!1?!
UHIHUULQJWRDVLWXDWLRQZKHUHDQLQGLYLGXDO¶V
C48H:E!8?!@4?5>8G4@!E6!G4!1E!241?E!E49!J4>549E!6=4>!
E:4!>4563349@4@!C48H:E!76>!E:1E!89@8=8@;12<!
C:85:!=1>86;?!7>63!J4>?69!E6!J4>?69!M!
³2EHVLW\´RQWKHRWKHUKDQGGHVFULEHVD
569@8E869!C:4>4GD!E:4>4!8?!1!G6@D!C48H:E!E:1E!8?!1E!
241?E!E:8>ED!J4>549E!6=4>!E:4!8@412!C48H:E²
C:1E4=4>!E:1E!31D!G4²89!>421E869!E6!E:4!:48H:E!67!
E:4!89@8=8@;12M!"6E4!E:1E!E:4!?E19@1>@?!67!
341?;>4349E!76>!C48H:E!1>4!H494>1E4@!G1?4@!69!
E:4!G6@D!31??!89@4L!^OZ._M!OZ.!8?!1!5125;21E869!
E:1E!1??4??4?!C48H:E!>421E8=4!E6!:48H:EM!!
!
*G4?8ED!56?E?!E:4!#M%M!91E86912!456963D!941>2D!
R-//MN!G822869!199;122D!19@!:1?!521834@!76;>P
:;9@>4@!E:6;?19@!28=4?!1!D41>!M!(?8@4!7>63!E:4!
@41E:!E622!19@!E:4!45696385!1?J45E!67!6G4?8ED<!
6G4?8ED!17745E?!1!J4>?69!89!19!89@8=8@;12!563J24L!
24=42M!*9!19!89@8=8@;12!24=42<!E6!822;?E>1E4<!6G4?8ED!
51;?4?!E:6?4!C:6!?;774>!7>63!E:4!?18@!@8?41?4!
319D!8??;4?!E6!:19@24!19@!6=4>5634M!.E!519!51;?4!
@4J>4??869<!@8?56376>E!89!?65812!?8E;1E869?<!241@!E6!
26C4>!?427P4?E443!19@!?8H9878519E2D!@83898?:!
d;128ED!67!2874!76>!E:4!6G4?4!?427<!76>!4L13J24M!
*G4?8ED!31D!12?6!17745E!436E86912!:412E:!19@!
151@4385!J4>76>31954!1369H!E:4!D6;9H4>!
J6J;21E869M!B412E:!C8?4<!6G4?8ED!895>41?4?!1!
SHUVRQ¶VFKDQFHRIGHYHORSLQJVHULRXVREHVLW\P
>421E4@!:412E:!@8?41?4!569@8E869?!28F4<!E:6;H:!
54>E1892D!96E!2838E4@!E6<!:41>E!@8?41?4<!34E1G6285!
?D9@>634<!J62D5D?E85!6=1>D!?D9@>634<!
:DJ4>E49?869<!1?E:31<!?244J!1J941!19@!@81G4E4?M!
K:824!6G4?8ED!17745E?!J46J24!67!@8774>49E!
G15FH>6;9@?<!6G4?8ED!1369H!E:4!Q1E896!
5633;98ED!8?!3;5:!:8H:4>!C:49!563J1>4@!E6!
6E:4>!>154@!19@!4E:985!H>6;J?!89!)12876>981!12694!
1?!G6E:!Q1E896!3124?!19@!Q1E896!743124?!67!122!
1H4?!:1=4!1369H!E:4!:8H:4?E!>1E4?!67!6G4?8ED!
C:49!563J1>4@!E6!6E:4>!>15812!19@!4E:985!
H>6;J?M!a6>!4L13J24<!941>2D!?4=49!6;E!67!E49!
)12876>981!Q1E896!1@;2E?!1>4!6=4>C48H:E!6>!
6G4?4M!(>H;1G2D!4d;122D!@8?E;>G89H2D<!E:4!#M%M!
6G4?8ED!>1E4?!:1=4!>8?49!1E!?;5:!19!895>41?89H2D!
121>389H!>1E4!1369H!E:4!4*$'+,("!J6J;21E869!67!
122!1H4?!@;>89H!E:4!21?E!76>ED!D41>?<!4?J458122D!
17745E89H!5:82@>49!67!3896>8ED!@4?549E<!
);>>49E2D<!1556>@89H!E6!E:4!91E86912!J>6H>13!
Q41@4>?:8J!76>!B412E:D!)633;98E84?!>4J6>E<!
AcM/!J4>549E!67!B8?J1985!5:82@>49!7>63!1H4?!EC6!
E6!9894E449!1>4!6=4>C48H:E!6>!6G4?4!563J1>4@!E6!
A-Mh!J4>549E!67!3''!5:82@>49!E:6?4!1H4?M!.9!6E:4>!
C6>@?<!E:4!9;3G4>!67!B8?J1985!5:82@>49!1H4?!
EC6!E6!424=49!1>4!36>4!6G4?4!E:19!E:48>!J44>?!67!
6E:4>!4E:985!19@!>15812!51E4H6>DM!Q4E!;?!266F!1E!
?634!36>4!?E1E8?E8512!4=8@4954!J>6=8@4@!7>63!
E:4!?18@!>4J6>EM!-]M/!J4>549E!67!5:82@>49!1H4?!EC6!
E6!78=4!19@!/SM-!J4>549E!67!E:6?4!67!1H4?!?8L!E6!
424=49!1>4!521??8784@!E6!G4!6G4?4<!122!67!C:63!
1>4!67!Q1E896!@4?549EW!89!569E>1?E<!!NM-!J4>549E!67!
)1;51?819!5:82@>49!1H4?!EC6!E6!78=4!19@!-NM0!
J4>549E!67!)1;51?819!1H4?!?8L!E6!424=49!1>4!
6G4?4M!K8E:!E:4!56336994??!19@!G1?85122D<!
3;5:!67!6G4?8ED!G456389H!1!J1>E!67!E:4!Q1E896!
5633;98ED<!8E!:1?!G449!J>4@85E4@!E:1E!E:4!>8?F!
76>!@81G4E4?!C822!G45634!?6!H>41E!E:1E!:127!67!
Q1E896!94CG6>9?!C822!G4!J>6Y45E4@!E6!28F42D!
@4=426J!@81G4E4?!@;>89H!E:48>!2874E834M!
!
!
K8E:!E:4!83J2851E869?!19@!>421E869?:8J!G4EC449!
6G4?8ED!19@!E:4!Q1E896!J6J;21E869!E:1E!5;>>49E2D!
4L8?E?<!319D!:1=4!d;4?E8694@!E:4!>41?69!76>!E:4!
@81G4E4?!563369128ED!E:1E!C8E:89!E:4!Q1E896!
J6J;21E869M!&:4!J4>=1?8=494??!67!6G4?8ED!1369H!
E:4!Q1E896!J6J;21E869!519!G4!4LJ21894@M!*G4?8ED!
89!H494>12!8?!51;?4@!GD!E:4!563G891E869!67!
@4E4>38919E?!67!89?;7785849E<!6>!1G?49E<!J:D?8512!
15E8=8ED!19@!4L54??!569?;3JE869!67!5126>84?M!!
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
&:4!*=4>C48H:E!19@!*G4?8ED!(369H!Q1E896!
k6;E:?!^&**(Qk_!>4J6>E!569@;5E4@!GD!E:4!
Q41@4>?:8J!76>!B412E:D!)633;98E84?!7;>E:4>?!E:8?!
4LJ2191E869!67!E:4!6G4?8ED!4J8@4385!1369H?E!E:4!
Q1E896!5633;98ED!3896>8EDM!&:4!>4J6>E!4LJ2189?!
E:1E!E:4!569@8E869?!67!9694L8?E49E!6>!89?;7785849E!
4L4>58?4!56;J24@!C8E:!;9:412E:D!41E89H!:1G8E?!1>4!
?:1J4@!GD!715E6>?!89!E:4!J:D?8512!19@!?65812!
49=8>69349E?!67!5633;98E84?M!!!!
&:4!>4J6>E!4LJ2189?!E:1E!319D!Q1E896?!28=4!89!
5633;98E84?!C:4>4!E:4>4!8?!1!@8?56;>1H4349E!E6!
J:D?8512!15E8=8ED!19@!19!4956;>1H4349E!E6!31F4!
E:4!@458?869!E6!41E!;9:412E:D!766@!19@!41E!
;9:412E:D!766@!5:6854?M!&6!4LJ2189<!319D!
Q1E896?!28=4!89!?J45812!1>41?!C:4>4!E:4>4!8?!1!
@63891954!67!569=4984954!?E6>4?!C8E:!2838E4@!
7>4?:!J>6@;54!G;E!C8E:!36>4!=1>84ED!67!?C44E?!
19@!?915F!8E43?M!(2?6!C8E:89!E:4?4!28=89H!1>41?!
C:4>4!319D!Q1E896?!>4?8@4!E:4>4!1>4!71?E!766@!
6;E24E?!74C!C422P4d;8JJ4@!19@!?174!1>41?!76>!
5:82@!^19@!6E:4>!1H4!H>6;J?_!J21D!19@!15E8=8EDM!!
!
K:1E!122!E:8?!:8H:!6G4?8ED!J>4=124954!1369H?E!
E:4!Q1E896!J6J;21E869!3419?!8?!E:1E!8E!J2154?!E:8?!
?18@!4E:985!J6J;21E869!1E!1!:8H:4>!>8?F!67!
@4=426J89H!5:>6985!@8?41?4?M!K8E:!Q1E896?!
G489H!E:4!71?E4?E!H>6C89H!J6J;21E869!89!
)12876>981²694!89!E:>44!)12876>9819?!G489H!
Q1E896!19@!569?E8E;E89H!76>EDP?4=49!J4>549E!67!
5:82@>49!1EE49@89H!J;G285!?5:66289H²19@!
@8?J>6J6>E8691E42D!G489H!17745E4@!GD!6G4?8ED!19@!
WKHREHVLW\UHODWHGFRPSOLFDWLRQV³DQ\HIIRUWV
E6!?E43!E:4!>8?89H!>1E4?!67!6G4?8ED!89!)12876>981!
3;?E!1@@>4??!E:4!944@?!67!E:4!Q1E896!
FRPPXQLW\´7KH722$/<UHSRUWLQDGGLWLRQ
1@@?!19@!>4563349@?!E:1E!E:4!H>41E4?E!?62;E869!
19@!6JJ6>E;98ED!E6!?E6J!E:4!6G4?8ED!1369H!
Q1E896?!284?!89!C6>F89H!1$2*!E:4!49E8>4!Q1E896!
SRSXODWLRQ³WRSURPRWHWKHVRFLDODQG
49=8>69349E12!569@8E869?!E:1E!71=6>!:412E:D!
41E89H!19@!J:D?8512!15E8=8ED!19@!E:1E!J>4=49E!
RYHUZHLJKWIURPRFFXUULQJLQWKHILUVWSODFH´!
!
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!c!!!
"#$%&'!()&%%)*!+%,)%&!-.!/01)-&02'#!',3!+4#)4&'#!5,.#4%,2%1!
W&$ B8&%9#&$ A8-)"&$ &8*/$ ;'/+'$ &*$ A8-)"&$
V#"))#$ 9*$ 8/%&#)1$ &%"/**$ #,)$ *#"))#$ 5"/:$ W/*$
$QJHOHV¶V ZHOO NQRZQ WUDLQ VWDWLRQ NQRZQ DV
]'9/'$V#	/'$&'1$9*$8/%&#)1$/')$(8/%;$&+&.$
5"/:$ R,9'&#/+'3$ =#$ %&'$ ()$ *))'$ &*$ /')$ /5$
/$¶V WRXULVW VLWHV WR YLVLW GXH WR LWV
&0#,)'#9%9#.$&'1$#,)$ -&"9/0*$%08#0"&8$&%#9-9#9)*$
#,&#$ /%%0"$ 10"9'2$ #,)$ +));)'1*3$ =#$ %&'$ ()$
%/'*91)")1$ &*$ #,)$ (9"#,68&%)$ /5$ #,)$ R9#.$ /5$
W/*$!'2)8)*3$
³%XLOW LQ E\ VHWWOHUV WKLV KLVWRULF
+&,-)&./!01,'&(,2!01+1.34+!5(++&67!37&'4.(,6!89!
:(2'1.(0!;4(+-(,62!<(':!&!'.&-('(1,&+!2'#+7!=+&>&!
DUHD´2OYHUD?@'.77'AB!!!
³2ULJLQDOO\ FDOOHG 9LQH 6WUHHW LQ LW ZDV
")'&:)1$ &5#)"$ !20*#9'$ A8-)"&7$ #,)$ 59"*#$ Z012)$
RIWKHFRXQW\RI/RV$QJHOHV´&DOOH2OYHUD
='%801)1$ 9'$ W&$ B8&%9#&7$ &")$ *)-)"&8$
:/'0:)'#*$ #,&#$ ,&-)$ :&1)$ 9#$ &$ *92959%&'#$
68&%)$ #/$ -9*9#$ 9'$ &119#9/'$ #/$ 6")*)"-9'2$ #,)$
W	'/\&\R,9%&'/\&$ %08#0")7$ *0%,$ &*$ #,)$ !-98&$
!1/()$ +,9%,$ 9*$ #,)$ /81)*#$ )<9*#9'2$ ")*91)'%)$
9'$ W/*$ !'2)8)*3$ =#$ %&'$ ()$ *))'$ #/1&.$ &*$ &$
:0*)0:7$ +,9%,$ 19*68&.*$ ,/+$ "//:*$ 0*)1$ #/$
8//;$ &'1$ ,/+$ 6)/68)$ 0*)1$ #/$ 89-)$ +,)'$ #,)$
B0)(8/$/5$W/*$!'2)8)*$+&*$)*#&(89*,)13$$
4,9*$ Q)<9%&'$ :&";)#68&%)$ ,&*$ ()%/:)$
;'/+'$ &*$ #,)$ %)'#)"$ /5$ ,9*#/"9%$ &'1$ %08#0"&8$
9'580)'%)*7$ ()%&0*)$ /5$ 9#*$ 2)'09')$ 8//;$ /'$
,/+$ W/*$ !'2)8)*$ ,&*$ 1)-)8/6)1$ 9'$ #,)$ 6&*#$
&'1$#,)$19-)"*9#.$#,&#$#,9*$%9#.$,&*$#/$/55)"3$$
$
=#$ 9*$ &$ 68&%)$ +,)")$ ./0$ 2)#$ #/$ 8)&"'$ :/")$
&(/0#$ ./0"*)85$ 9'$ ;'/+9'2$ &(/0#$ /#,)"$
%08#0")*3$!*$ ./0$ +&8;$#,"/02,$W&$B8&%9#&$ ./0$
&")$ &(8)$ #/$ %&6#0")$ &$ :/:)'#$ 9'$ #9:)7$ #,)$
*:)88$ /5$ %&"')$ &*&1&$ ()9'2$ 2"988)1$ &'1$
#/"#988&*$ ()9'2$ ,&'1E:&1)$ 9'$ 6")6&"	/'$ 5/"$
&'$&0#,)'#9%$Q)<9%&'$%09*9')3$$
$
A'$ %&'$ &8*/$ )<6)"9)'%)$ -9("&'#$ %/8/"*$ /5$
,&'1(&2*$&'1$209#&"*$#,&#$&")$60#$/'$19*68&.$
&#$ #,)$ 89##8)$ *,/6*7$ 5/"$ 6)/68)$ 8//;9'2$ &"/0'1$
"#$!%&'()&!*++(#&,(!
&'1$ *))9'2$ +,&#$ #,).$ &")$ 9'#)")*#)1$ 9'$
(0.9'23$U"/:$&5&"7$ ./0$&")$&(8)$#/$*))$ &'1$
,)&"$Q&"9&%,9$#"0:6)#*$()29'$#/$68&.$&*$#,)$
*9'2)"$ ()29'*$ #/$ *9'27$ *011)'8.$ ./0'2$ 29"8*$
+9#,$ %/8/"5087$ "0558)1$ 1")**)*$ &'1$ ,&9"$ #9)1$
+9#,$"9((/'$%/:)$/0#$&*$#,).$%/::)'%)$#,)$
F&98)$ U8/8;8/"9%&7$ +,9%,$ 9*$ &$ 1&'%)$ #,&#$
):6,&*9@)*$8/%&8$5/8;$%08#0")$#,&#$9*$1)"9-)1$
5"/:$Q)<9%/3$$
R"/+1*$/5$6)/68)$*#&'1$&'1$*9#$/'$#,)$+&88*$
/5$ #,)$ 68&@&$ &*$ #,)$ 1&'%)"*$ *+9"8$ #,)9"$
1")**)*$ #/$ #,)$ ()&#$ /5$ #,)$ #"0:6)#$ &'1$
209#&"3$ V/0'1*$ /5$ 6)/68)$ +,9*#89'2$ &'1$
%8&669'2$ %&'$ ()$ ,)&"1$ &*$ #,)$ */'2$ %/:)*$
#/$ &$ 59'9*,$ &'1$ 6)/68)$ +&9#$ 0'#98$ #,)$ ')<#$
*,/+$*#&"#*3$V011)'8.7$./0$&")$&(8)$#/$,)&"$
#,)$ 8/01$ "9'29'2$ /5$ %,0"%,$ ()88*7$ &$ *92'$ #,&#$
%,0"%,$,&*$%/::)'%)13$$
^)'1/"*$ *#&"#$ #/$ 5988$ #,)$ *#"))#*$ 60889'2$ #,)9"$
89##8)7$ *98-)"$ %&"#*$ 5988)1$ +9#,$ ,/#$ 1/2*$ &'1\/"$
5")*,$ %/"'$ /'$ #,)$ %/(7$ %&889'2$ #/$ 6)/68)$
&(/0#$#,)$5//1$#,&#$#,).$&")$6")6&"9'23$4,9*$
9*$#,)$#.6)$/5$)<6)"9)'%)$#,&#$./0$+/081$2)#$
E\ YLVLWLQJ 2OYHUD 6WUHHW ³3OD]D2OYHUD
*#"))#$ 9*$ '/#$ /'8.$ *))'$ &*$ &'$ 9:6/"#&'#$
,9*#/"9%$&'1$%08#0"&8$*.:(/87$9#$9*$&8*/$&$-9#&8$
&")&$ /5$ ")%")	/'$ &'1$ ")8929/0*$ 895)$ 5/"$ #,)$
W/*$!'2)8)*$Q)<9%&'$%/::0'9#.3$$
$
*;157! &++C! :1<757.C! ':7! D+&>&EF+57.&!
@'.77'!27.572!&2!&!4,(G47!=.(2)!':.146:!
<:(0:!H7I(0&,2!(,!J12!*,67+72!0&,!+11/!
;&0/! 1,! ':7(.! =&2'! &2! <7++! &2! 0:&.'! ,7<!
FRXUVHVIRUWKHIXWXUH´HOSXHEOR$
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
!*$&$")*08#7$/')$/5$#,)$5)*#9-9#9)*$#,&#$/%%0"$9'$
2OYHUD 6WUHHW LV ³&LQFR GH 0D\R´ ZKLFK LV D
6 / 6 0 8 & " $ Q ) < 9 % & ' $ , / 8 9 1 & . $ + , 9 % ,$
%/::):/"&#)*$ #,)$ F&##8)$ /5$ B0)(8&$ /'$ Q&.$
_#,$ IJ`K3$ =#$ 9*$ &$ %)8)("	/'$ /5$ Q)<9%&'$
,)"9#&2)$&'1$6"91)3$!@#)%$1&'%)"*$6)"5/":$&*$
+)88$ :&"9&%,9*$ &'1$ 5/8;8/"9%/$ 1&'%)"*3$
!'/#,)"$ ,/891&.$ #,&#$ 9*$ +91)8.$ %)8)("&#)1$ 9*$
³'LD 'H /RV 0XHUWRV´ RU 'D\ RI WKH 'HDG LQ
")%/2'9@9'2$ 5&:98.$ :):()"*7$ 5"9)'1*7$ &'1$
#,/*)$ +,/$ ,&-)$ 6&**)1$ /'3$ R/8/"508$ &8#&"*$
5988)1$ +9#,$ 1955)")'#$ #.6)*$ /5$ 5//17$ %&'18)*7$
69%#0")*7$*02&"$*;088*7$)#%3$&")$%/'*#"0%#)1$#/$
60#$#,)$()8/-)1$1)&1$9'$"):):("&'%)3$
='$&119#9/'7$9#$9*$&$*6)%9&8$#9:)$9'$+,9%,$5&:98.$
:):()"*$ *,&")$ :):/"&(8)$ :/:)'#*$ &'1$
VWRULHV $QRWKHU VLJQLILFDQW KROLGD\ LV ³/DV
3RVDGDV´ ZKLFK SRUWUD\V WKH QLQH QLJKWV RI
&1-)'#$#,&#$/%%0"*$9'$#,)$:/'#,$/5$O)%):()"3$
4,)$ B/*&1&$ 9*$ &$ *,/"#$ 6982"9:&2)$ #,&#$
"))'&%#*$ #,)$ R,"9*#:&*$ ?-)$ Z/0"').$ /5$ Q&".$
&'1$ C/*)6,$ 9'$ F)#,8),):$ *)&"%,9'2$ 5/"$
*,)8#)"3$ 4,9*$ 5)*#9-&8$ 9'%801)*$ %&'18)E89#$
6"/%)**9/'*$ /5$ Q&".$ &'1$ C/*)6,$ 5/88/+)1$ (.$
%,981")'7$ &108#*7$ &'1$ &'9:&8*$ &*$ +)88$ 6)/68)$
*9'29'2$ ,.:'*$ &'1$ ,/891&.$ */'2*$ 9'$ /"1)"$ #/$
#&;)$6&"#$9'$#,)$%)"):/'.3$$
$
!*$ ./0$ %&'$ *))7$ A8-)"&$ V#"))#$ /55)"*$ 6)/68)$
:&'.$ %08#0"&8$ )-)'#*$ #,&#$ #,).$ %&'$ &##)'1$ 9'$
/"1)"$ #/$ 8)&"'$ :/")$ &(/0#$ #,)$ Q)<9%&'$
%08#0")3$ !#$ #,)$ *&:)$ #9:)7$ 9#$ 9*$ &$ 2")&#$
/66/"#0'9#.$#/$)<6)"9)'%)$*/:)#,9'2$')+$&'1$
#/$ ()%/:)$ %8/*)"$ #/$ #,)$ W/*$ !'2)8)*$
%/::0'9#.3$
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!N!!!
E**A$4'0(S&*I3#.0(
D0(E2';'(K"2;*;#>L+*%*(
&:4!Z1D19!)1249@1>!8?!694!67!E:4!36?E!C8@42D!
F96C9!19@!J4>:1J?!1>H;1G2D<!36?E!8972;49E812!
51249@1>?!67!122!E834!@;4!E6!8E?!563J24L8ED!19@!
>431>F1G24!155;>15DM!"6E!692D!@8@!E:4!Z1D19?!
;?4!E:8?!51249@1>!E:43?42=4?<!G;E!8E!C1?!1@6JE4@!
GD!6E:4>!Z4?6134>8519!91E869?!28F4!E:4!&62E45!
19@!E:4!(TE45?<!C:6!1@Y;?E4@!E:4!345:1985?!67!E:4!
51249@1>!GD!5:19H89H!E:4!9134?!67!E:4!@1D?!67!E:4!
C44F!19@!E:4!369E:?M!!
@-&!*?2"--%7&!4"$4(#&A2B*C&D>$*2*#C&)(E"$%7&
FB2($&!*-(#.*/7.
5*(.672(4.43'("+3,.13%.3".3+38232$0".09.2*(.
:3;3".43'("+3,<.!2.40"%$%2(+.09.3.=>?@+3;.
3A,$4B'2B,3'.43'("+3,C.3%.1(''.3%.3.D>E@+3;.
%34,(+.43'("+3,<.F5*$%.$%.3.+$A$23'.40G80%$2(<.
)0'0,.3++(+.90,.#$%$&$'$2;<H.
&:4!Z1D19!51249@1>!8?!96E!E:4!692D!51249@1>!
?D?E43!C4!;E828T4M!Z6?E!91E869?!89!E:4!C6>2@!;?4!
E:4!,>4H6>819!51249@1>!?D?E43!E6@1DM!&:4!Z1D19!
51249@1>!8?!15E;122D!1!9;3G4>!^1!?D?E43_!67!
51249@1>?!89E4>34?:4@!C8E:!56>>421E4@!@1E1M!&:4!
51249@1>!8?!?E>;5E;>4@!GD!;?89H!E:>44!@8774>49E!
J1>12242!@1E89H!?D?E43?W!89!6E:4>!C6>@?<!E:4!
Z1D19?!31>F4@!E:4!J1??1H4!67!E834!C8E:!E:>44!
5D524?!E:1E!>19!89!J1>12242!^Z1D19!)1249@1>!/00A_M!
&:4!E:>44!?D?E43?!1>4!E:4!76226C89H\!E:4!Q69H!
)6;9E<!E:4!&T62F89!^@8=894!51249@1>_!19@!E:4!B11G!
^E:4!58=82!51249@1><!C:85:!8?!E:4!692D!694!E:1E!:1@!
1!@8>45E!>421E869?:8J!E6!E:4!249HE:!67!E:4!D41>_M!
K:1E!76226C?!8?!19!4L13J24!67!:6C!E6!>41@!19@!
C>8E4!1!@1E4!89!Z1D19!)1249@1>!E4>3?\!
!
!
!
Z1D19!V1E4\!-/M-cM-bM/Mb<!A!)838!]!l6ET!!!
-/M-cM-bM/Mb!8?!E:4!Q69H!)6;9E!@1E4!
A!)838!8?!E:4!&T62F89!@1E4!
]!l6ET!8?!E:4!B11G!@1E4M!
"6E4\!36?E!91E869?!89!E:4!C6>2@!
;?4!E:4!,>4H6>819!51249@1>!?D?E43!
E6@1D!89?E41@M!)69E89;89H<!E:4!
Z1D19!51249@1>!
8?!15E;122D!1!9;3G4>!^1!?D?E43_!!
67!51249@1>?!89E4>34?:4@!C8E:!56>>421E4@!@1E1M!
&:4!51249@1>!8?!?E>;5E;>4@!GD!;?89H!E:>44!
@8774>49E!J1>12242!@1E89H!?D?E43?W!89!6E:4>!C6>@?<!
E:4!Z1D19?!31>F4@!E:4!J1??1H4!67!E834!C8E:!
E:>44!5D524?!E:1E!>19!89!J1>12242!^Z1D19!)1249@1>!
/00A_M!&:4!E:>44!?D?E43?!1>4!E:4!76226C89H\!E:4!
Q69H!)6;9E<!E:4!&T62F89!^@8=894!51249@1>_!19@!
E:4!B11G!^E:4!58=82!51249@1><!C:85:!8?!E:4!692D!
694!E:1E!:1@!1!@8>45E!>421E869?:8J!E6!E:4!249HE:!67!
E:4!D41>_M!K:1E!76226C?!8?!19!4L13J24!67!:6C!E6!
>41@!19@!C>8E4!1!@1E4!89!Z1D19!)1249@1>!E4>3?\!
!
Z1D19!V1E4\!-/M-cM-bM/Mb<!A!)838!]!l6ET!!!
-/M-cM-bM/Mb!8?!E:4!Q69H!)6;9E!@1E4!
A!)838!8?!E:4!&T62F89!@1E4!
]!l6ET!8?!E:4!B11G!@1E4M!
!
a6>!6;>!J;>J6?4?<!C4!C822!765;?!69!&:4!Q69H!
)6;9EM!&:4!Q69H!)6;9E!8?!1!28941>!56;9E!67!@1D?!
C8E:!1!H>41E!5D524!67!E:8>E449!G1FE;9?M!&6!
4LJ2189<!E:4!Q69H!56;9E!8?!>4J>4?49E4@!1?!78=4!
J2154!96E1E869!?D?E43!67!1?549@89H!5D524?²F89?!
^@1D?_<!C8912?!^/0!@1D!369E:?_<!E;9?!^Ab0!@1D?_<!
N¶DWXQVWXQVDQGEDN¶WXQVN¶DWXQV
^O13:1>E_M!%J458785122D<!E:4!Q69H!)6;9E!
)1249@1>!8?!1!969P>4J41E89H<!=8H4?8312!^G1?4!/0_!
51249@1>!E:1E!8@49E8784?!1!@1D!GD!56;9E89H!E:4!
9;3G4>!67!@1D?!J1??4@!?8954!(;H;?E!--<!A--]!
O)!;?89H!1!36@8784@!=8H4?8312!E122D!^89!
,>4H6>819!51249@1>!E4>3?_M!!K:824!E:4!?E1>E!@1D!
69!E:4!Q69H!)6;9E!8?!?E1E4@!E6!G4!69!(;H;?E!--!
A--]!O)$!GD!E:4!Z1D19?<!E:4!1JJ1>49E!49@!@1D!
LVRQ'HFHPEHU&(7KHORQJFRXQW¶V
=4>?869!67!1!D41>²E:4!E;9²8?!692D!Ab0!@1D?!
19@!!96E!E:4!AbS!@1D!?621>!56;9E!E:1E!C4!1>4!122!
7138281>!C8E:M!
!
!!
!!!
a6>!6;>!J;>J6?4?<!C4!C822!765;?!69!&:4!Q69H!
)6;9EM!&:4!Q69H!)6;9E!8?!1!28941>!56;9E!67!@1D?!
C8E:!1!H>41E!5D524!67!E:8>E449!G1FE;9?M!&6!4LJ2189<!
E:4!Q69H!56;9E!8?!>4J>4?49E4@!1?!78=4!J2154!
96E1E869!?D?E43!67!1?549@89H!5D524?²F89?!^@1D?_<!
ZLQDOVGD\PRQWKVWXQVGD\VN¶DWXQV
WXQVDQGEDN¶WXQVN¶DWXQV%DPKDUW!
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
1RWHWKDWWKHODUJHVWRIWKHORQJFRXQW¶VILYH
F\FOHVWKHEDN¶WXQKDVDSHULRGHTXDOLQJIRXUP
:;9@>4@!E;9?M!!
Z19D!G4284=4!E:1E!E:4!563J24E869!67!E:4!7;22!5D524!
67!E:4!Q69H!)6;9E!C822!G4!563J24E4@!C:49!
WKLUWHHQEDN¶WXQVKDYHSDVVHGVLQFHWKHEHJLQQLQJ
67!E:4!>456>@4@!Z1D19!5>41E869!?E6>D!C:85:!8?!
8@49E8784@!1?!E:4!+6J62![;:<!C:85:!8?!E:4!:8H:2D!
19E858J1E4@!V4543G4>!/-<!/0-/M!
!
.9!>4H1>@!E6!E834!8E?427<!E834!8?!569548=4@!89!1!
@8774>49E!31994>!E:19!E:1E!67!E6@1DM!K:4>41?!
569E43J6>1>D!?6584ED!=84C!E834!E6!:1=4!1!
@47898E8=4!G4H89989H<!38@@24!19@!49@<!E:4!Z1D19?!
@8@!96E!1@:4>4!E6!E:8?!56954JE!67!E834M!a6>!E:4!
Z1D19?<!E834!C1?!1!5D528512!655;>>4954!E:1E!C1?!
31>F4@!GD!1!J1EE4>9!67!@8?E895E8=4!5:1>15E4>8?E85?!
67!>4J4E8E8=4!4=62;E8691>D!2874!5D524?!67!E:4!26512!
;98=4>?4!19@!8E?!>421E8=4!47745E!E6!E:4!89:1G8E19E?!67!
E:4!C6>2@M!
!
.E!8?!E:1E!J1>E85;21>!V4543G4>!/-<!/0-/!@1E4²
-AM0M0M0M0!89!E:4!Q69H!56;9E!^Z1D19!+>6J:4584?!
19@!)1249@1>_!²!E:1E!:1?!>4?;2E4@!89!E:4!
J:49634969!67!C:1E!8?!51224@!E:4!Z1D19!
V663?@1D!+>6J:45DM!&:4!Z1D19!V663?@1D!
+>6J:45D!434>H4@!1?!19!4LJ2191E869!19@!
89E4>J>4E1E869!67!C:1E!31D!655;>!17E4>!E:4!
FRPSOHWLRQRIWKHWKLUWHHQEDN¶WXQVRIWKH0D\DQ
51249@1>M!&6!?634<!V4543G4>!/-<!/0-/!8?!E:4!@1D!
67!E:4!J>6J:4?84@!(J6512DJ?4²E:4!@663?@1D?!
49@M!!
B6C4=4><!E:4>4!1>4!E:6?4!C:6!52183!E:1E!E:4!?18@!
19E858J1E4@!@1D!8?!1!31>F4>!67!1!G4H89989H!67!1!
QHZHUDZKHUH³KXPDQLW\ZLOOHYROYHWRDJUHDWHU
XQGHUVWDQGLQJRIRXUSODFHLQWKHXQLYHUVH>«@
.>6985122D<!76>!36?E!67!E:4!28=89H!@4?549@19E?!67!
WKHDQFLHQW0D\DWKHPVHOYHVLW¶VMXVWWKHHQGRI
DQRWKHUFDOHQGDUF\FOHRUVLPSO\DQRWKHUGD\´,Q
4d;12!@8?1H>44349E!C8E:!E:4!/0-/!Z1D19!
)1249@1>!$9@!67!V1D?!%5491>86<!E:4!=1?E!31Y6>8ED!
67!Z1D198?E?!?5:621>?!1>H;4!E:1E!E:4!@1D!36?E!
28F42D!:42@!96!?J45812!341989H!E6!E:4!195849E!
Z1D19?!G4D69@!E:4!715E!E:1E!8E!C1?!19!49@!E6!E:4!
E:8>E449E:!O1FE;9!5D524!19@!E:;?!1!51;?12!4=49E!76>!
5424G>1E869M!.9!715E<!?634!52183!E:1E!8E!C822!G4!E:4!
G4H89989H!67!E:4!a87E:!%;9!17E4>!E:4!@41E:!67!E:4!
a6;>E:!%;9!31>F4@!GD!E:4!V4543G4>!/-<!/0-/!
@1E4M!!!
!!
V4?J8E4!E:4!@8?1H>44349E!E:1E!4L8?E?!69!E:4!
?8H987851954!67!E:4!;J56389H!/0-/!@1D<!E:4>4!8?!96!
@49D89H!E:4!83J15E!E:4!Z1D19?²19@!E:;?!GD!
4LE49?869!Q1E89!(34>851²KDVKDGLQWRGD\¶V
36@4>9!E834M!Z1D19!5;2E;>12!19@!45696385!
83J15E!519!G4!?449!E:>6;H:!7823?<!31H1T894?<!
G66F?!19@!6E:4>!56336@8E84?!:1=4!G449!?62@!C8E:!
E:4!831H4?!67!E:4!Z1D19!51249@1>M!%;5:!G66F?<!
76>!4L13J24<!8952;@4!&:4!Z1D19!+>6J:4584?!76>!
/0-/<!&:4!+;>J6?47;2!#98=4>?4\!B6C!m;19E;3!
&:46>D!19@!E:4!Z1D19!)6?3626HD!$LJ2189!E:4!
*>8H89!19@!$=62;E869!67!Q874!19@!&:4!Z1D19!
)6@4\!&834!(55424>1E869!19@!(C1F4989H!E:4!
K6>2@!Z89@!1369H!319D!6E:4>?M!(!J24E:6>1!67!!
!%#2"#>(.&%#&G*:(&HI7&&
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!-0!!
!
!%#2"#>(.&1/%=&G*:(&J7&
V4?J8E4!E:4!@8?1H>44349E!E:1E!4L8?E?!69!E:4!?8H987851954!67!E:4!;J56389H!/0-/!@1D<!E:4>4!8?!96!@49D89H!E:4!83J15E!E:4!Z1D19?²19@!E:;?!GD!4LE49?869!Q1E89!
(34>851²KDVKDGLQWRGD\¶VPRGHUQWLPH0D\DQFXOWXUDODQGHFRQRPLFLPSDFWFDQEHVHHQWKURXJKILOPVPDJD]LQHVERRNVDQGRWKHU!56336@8E84?!:1=4!
G449!?62@!C8E:!E:4!831H4?!67!E:4!Z1D19!51249@1>M!%;5:!G66F?<!76>!4L13J24<!8952;@4!&:4!Z1D19!+>6J:4584?!76>!/0-/<!&:4!+;>J6?47;2!#98=4>?4\!B6C!m;19E;3!
&:46>D!19@!E:4!Z1D19!)6?3626HD!$LJ2189!E:4!*>8H89!19@!$=62;E869!67!Q874!19@!&:4!Z1D19!)6@4\!&834!(55424>1E869!19@!(C1F4989H!E:4!K6>2@!Z89@!1369H!
319D!6E:4>?M!(!J24E:6>1!67!C4G?8E4?!:1=4!G449!@4@851E4@!E6<!E:6;H:!54>E1892D!96E!2838E4@!E6<!49>85:89H!E:4!J;G285!69!E:4!Z1D19!58=828T1E869!19@!69!J>65218389H!
6>!569@43989H!E:4!/0-/!E:46>D!67!@663?@1DM!!
!!
:KDWDOOWKLV0D\DQ&DOHQGDULQWHUHVWVKRZVLVWKDWWKHFXOWXUDODQGHFRQRPLFLQIOXHQFHWKH0D\DQVKDYHRQWRGD\¶VWLPHLVD5241>!4L13J24!67!E:4!C48H:E!Q1E89!
(34>8519!5;2E;>4?!519!19@!@6!:1=4!69!6E:4>!5;2E;>4?!E:1E!519!!E>19?549@!E834!19@!219H;1H4?M!!
OD\!(319@1!)1?124H96!
(
!"#$%&"'()'*+,-(&.'+/%0*'*1"'#()(&.'2%)*'
%3'"402+*(%&'+&4'*1"'4(33(20,*$'%3'."**(&.'(&*%'
2%,,".")5'61"'*#0*1'()7'(*'()'4(33(20,*'*%'"&*"#'
2%,,"."7'/0*'3%#')%8"'9+*(&%:+)'*1"'21+,,"&.")'
+#"'"!"&'8%#"'4+0&*(&.5';22%#4(&.'*%'*1"'
<+*(%&+,'="&*"#'3%#'>402+*(%&+,'?*+*()*(2)7'(&'
WKHLUVWXG\´6WDWXVDQG7UHQGVLQWKH
(GXFDWLRQRI+LVSDQLFVµWKH/DWLQRPLQRULW\
1+)'1()*%#(2+,,$'0&4"#+21("!"4'(&'"402+*(%&5'
'
61#%0.1%0*'*1"'"402+*(%&+,')$)*"8'
@()A+&(2'21(,4#"&'+#"'4()+4!+&*+."45'B%#'
-(&4"#.+#*"&"#)7'*1"'A#%/+/(,(*$'%3'+2+4"8(2'
)022"))'()'8"+)0#"4'/$'*1"'&08/"#'%3'8+&$'
ULVNIDFWRUVLQDFKLOG·VOLIH5LVNIDFWRUV
2%88%&,$'2%&)(4"#"4'(&2,04"C'DEF'1+!(&.'+'
8%*1"#'G(*1',"))'*1+&'+'1(.1')21%%,'"402+*(%&7'
DHF',%G'3+8(,$'(&2%8"'%#'*1"'A+#"&*D)F'+#"'
#"2"(!(&.'G",3+#"7'DIF'+')(&.,"'A+#"&*'
1%0)"1%,47'+&4'DJF'A+#"&*)'G1%)"'A#(8+#$'
,+&.0+."'()'&%*'>&.,()15''K%)*'-(&4"#.+#*"&"#)'
G(*1'+*',"+)*'%&"'#()-'3+2*%#')2%#"4',%G"#'%&'
*1"(#'#"+4(&.'+&4'K+*1')2%#")'*1+&'21(,4#"&'
G(*1%0*'#()-'3+2*%#)5'61()')*04$'3%0&4'*1+*'
8%)*'@()A+&(2'-(&4"#.+#*"&"#)'1+4'+*',"+)*'
*G%'#()-'3+2*%#)7'G1(21'G+)'3(!"'*(8")'.#"+*"#'
*1+&'3%#'G1(*"'21(,4#"&5'61"')*04$'+,)%'
)1%G"4'*1+*'@()A+&(2'21(,4#"&'+#"',"))',(-",$'
*%'/"'#"+4'*%'+*'1%8"'%#'*%'!()(*',(/#+#(")5''
'
61#%0.1%0*'","8"&*+#$'+&4'1(.1'
)21%%,7'@()A+&(2'21(,4#"&'+**"&4'A0/,(2'
)21%%,)'G1"#"'8(&%#(*(")'2%&)*(*0*"'QWR'%#'
8%#"'%3'*1"')*04"&*'/%4$5';&%*1"#'21+,,"&."'
*%'9+*(&%'+2+4"8(2')022"))'()'1(.1'#+*")'%3'
+/)"&*""()8'2%8A+#"4'*%'G1(*"')*04"&*)'%#'
%*1"#'8(&%#(*(")5''O*'()'0&2,"+#'G1$7'/0*'
@()A+&(2')*04"&*)7'/"*G""&'.#+4")'T'*%'EH7'
G"#"'+/)"&*'8%#"'%3*"&'*1+&'G1(*"'%#'/,+2-'
)*04"&*)5'61()'%0*2%8"'()'4(#"2*,$'2%##",+*"4'
G(*1'*1"'+8%0&*'%3'*"+21+/,"'*(8"'*1"'
)*04"&*'()'"LA%)"4'*%5'';,%&.'G(*1'
+/)"&*""()8'()'*1"'())0"'%3'#+*")'%3'#"*"&*(%&'
(&')21%%,'+&4'*1"'&08/"#'%3')21%%,'
)0)A"&)(%&)5'EIR'%3'@()A+&(2'21(,4#"&'
/"*G""&'-(&4"#.+#*"&'+&4'EH*1'.#+4"'1+4'
#"A"+*"4'+*',")*'%&"'.#+4"5'61()'G+)',"))'
*1+&'*1"'#+*"'3%#'/,+2-)'+&4';8"#(2+&'
O&4(+&)7'/0*'.#"+*"#'*1+&'*1"'#+*"'3%#'G1(*"'
)*04"&*)5'';&4'HWR'%3'@()A+&(2')*04"&*)'1+4'
"LA"#("&2"4'+*',"+)*'%&"')0)A"&)(%&5';&%*1"#'
8+X%#'21+,,"&."'()'*1"'4#%AN%0*'#+*"'3%#'
@()A+&(2')*04"&*)5'@()A+&(2)'4#%A'%0*'%3'
)21%%,'+*'+'#+*"'3%0#'*(8")'.#"+*"#'*1+&'
G1(*"')*04"&*)7'+&4'*G(2"'+)'%3*"&'+)';3#(2+&'
;8"#(2+&)5'Y0*'"!"&'3%#'*1%)"'9+*(&%)'G1%'
8+-"'0A'*1"'SJR'G1%'4%')022"))30,,$'
.#+40+*"'3#%8'1(.1')21%%,7'*1"#"'()'$"*''
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
+&%*1"#'10."'%/)*+2,"'*%'.+(&(&.'+22"))'*%'+'
2%,,"."'%#'0&(!"#)(*$'"402+*(%&5'@()A+&(2'
)*04"&*)')2%#"',%G"#'%&'?;6'%#';=6'"L+8)'*1+&'
"(*1"#'G1(*"'%#'/,+2-')*04"&*)5'
'
M"*7'"!"&'G(*1'+,,'*1")"'21+,,"&.")7'
*1"')0#A#()"'3(&4(&.'G+)'*1+*'*1"#"'1+)'/""&'+&'
(&2#"+)"'(&'*1"'&08/"#'%3'@()A+&(2')*04"&*)'
+**"&4(&.'2%,,"."5'K%#"'@()A+&(2)'+**"&4'*G%N'
$"+#'2%880&(*$'2%,,".")'*1+&'G1(*")'%#'/,+2-)5'
O&'EPPP7'@()A+&(2)'"+#&"4'QR'%3'+,,';))%2(+*"'%3'
$UWVGHJUHHV$QGLQ·VWKHQXPEHURI
+LVSDQLFVUHFHLYLQJEDFKHORU·VGHJUHHVURVHE\
STR5'K%#"'@()A+&(2')*04"&*)'+#"'+,)%')""-(&.'
A%)*.#+40+*"''"402+*(%&'+&4'"!"&'4%2*%#+*"'
4".#"")5'O*'()'(&*"#")*(&.'*1+*'8%)*'%3'*1")"'
4".#"")'+#"'(&'*1"'3(",4)'%3'"402+*(%&'%#'
SV\FKRORJ\DFFRUGLQJWR´6WDWXVDQG7UHQGVLQ
WKH(GXFDWLRQRI+LVSDQLFVµ,VXSSRVHWKDW
+3*"#'%!"#2%8(&.')%'8+&$'21+,,"&.")'+&4'
/"+*(&.'*1"'%44)'G"'G+&*'*%'.(!"'/+2-'*%'
)%2("*$5'61()'(&2,04")'*"+21(&.'+&4')"#!(&.'+)'
8"&*%#)'*%'%*1"#'+*N#()-'%#',%GN(&2%8"'
)*04"&*)'G1%'&""4'A%)(*(!"'#%,"'8%4",)''*%'
"&2%0#+."'*1"8'&%*'*%'U0(*'%#'.(!"'0A'(&'*1"'
2#(*(2+,'VNEH'$"+#)5'?%'#"8"8/"#'G1"&'$%0'+#"'
*(#"4'%3'+))(.&8"&*)7'#"+4(&.)'+&4'*")*)7'
#"8"8/"#''!"#$%&'$()'$*"&(#+%('$"+',$
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!--!!
!
:3,;%0'.6AB$,,(.I.J(%%$43.K3,4$3.L(,"3"+(7..
W$
	'/*$ &")$ #,)$ 8&"2)*#$ 2"/+9'2$
:9'/"9#.$9'$!:)"9%&7$.)#$#,).$&")$
'/#$ ()9'2$ 5088.$ ")6")*)'#)1$ 9'$
,92,)"$ )10%	/'3$ 4,)$ KaIa$
%)'*0*$ 1/%0:)'#*$ #,&#$ !:)"9%&$
,&*$ ()%/:)$ :/")$ 19-)"*)3$ 4,)$
1):/2"&6,9%*$ 9'$ !:)"9%&$ &")$ *,95#9'2$
5"/:$ +,9#)$ #/$ %/8/"7$ +9#,$ #,)$ W	'/$
6/608	/'$ &*$ #,)$ 8&"2)*#$ :9'/"9#.$ 2"/063$
V9'%)$ Kaaa$ #,)$ W	'/$ 6/608	/'$ ,&*$
9'%")&*)1$ 5/"#.$ #,"))$ 6)"%)'#7$ 5"/:$ b_3b$
:9889/'$ #/$ _a3_$ :9889/'3$ W	'/*$ :&;)$ 06$
*9<#))'$ 6)"%)'#$ /5$ #,)$ #/#&8$ 6/608	/'$ 9'$
#,)$ ]'9#)1$ V#&#)*7$ &'1$ &")$ )<6)%#)1$ #/$
#"968)$ (.$ Ka_a3$ W	'/*7$ )*6)%9&88.$
Q)<9%&'/*$ ,&-)$ #,)$ ./0'2)*#$ :)19&'$
&2)$%/:6&")1$#/$/#,)"$"&%9&8$2"/06*3$4,)$
!'28/$ :)19&'$ &2)$ 5/"$ )<&:68)$ 9*$ cI$
.)&"*$ /81$ +,98)$ Q)<9%&'*$ ,&-)$ &$ :)19&'$
&2)$ /5$ K_3$ ^)".$ 6/*9#9-)$ /0#%/:)*$ %&'$
%/:)$5"/:$#,)*)$1):/2"&6,9%*7$(0#$+,&#$
2//1$ 1/)*$ 9#$ :)&'$ #/$ ,&-)$ #,)$ ./0'2)*#$
6/608	/'$ +,)'$ :&'.$ W	'/$ ./0#,$ &")$
%/'#9'0/0*8.$ ()9'2$ 60*,)1$ /0#$ /5$ #,)$
*%,//8$ *.*#):*d$ =5$ /0"$ 50#0")$ 9*$
1)6)'1)'#$ /'$ #,)$ ./0'2$ 6/608	/'7$
)10%	/'$ &:/'2$ W	'/*$ :0*#$ &8*/$
9'%")&*)3$ 4,)$ "&#)*$ /5$ W	'/$ *#01)'#*$
2/9'2$#/$%/88)2)$,&*$9'%")&*)17$(0#$'/#$&#$
#,)$ *&:)$ "&#)$ /5$ #,)$ 5&*#$ 6&%)$ 2"/+#,$ /5$
9#*$6/608	/'3!
?10%	/'$ &'1$ *%,//89'2$
68&.$ &'$ 9:6/"#&'#$ "/8)$ 9'$ #,)$
1)-)8/6:)'#$ /5$ /0"$ */%9)#.3$ N,)'$
*%,//8*$ 5&98$ #/$ 6"/-91)$ (&*9%$
")*/0"%)*$ 5/"$ /0"$ *#01)'#*7$ ,/+$ 1/$
+)$)<6)%#$/0"$*#01)'#*$#/$*0%%))1d$
?10%	/'$9*$#,)$/66/"#0'9#.$#/$:/-)$
5/"+&"13$ ='*#)&1$ /5$ :/-9'2$ 5/"+&"1$
#,/02,7$ *%,//8*$ &")$ #&;9'2$ *#)6*$
(&%;3$ 4,)$ (012)#$ %0#*$ &")$ '/#$ /'8.$
&55)%#9'2$ #,)$ 8&"2)"$ )10%	/'&8$
*.*#):7$ (0#$ &8*/$ 6"/2"&:*$ +,9%,$
*)"-)$ #,/*)$ *#01)'#*$ +,/$ &")$
0'1)"")6")*)'#)1$ *0%,$ &*$ #,)$
W	'/$ *#01)'#*3$ =#$ 9*$ :0%,$ :/")$
%/::/'$5/"$W	'/$*#01)'#*$#/$()29'$
#,)9"$6&#,*$9'#/$,92,)"$)10%	/'$&#$&$
%/::0'9#.$ %/88)2)$ "&#,)"$ #,&'$ &#$
5/0"$.)&"$0'9-)"*9#9)*3$$
4,)$#"&'*9#9/'$5"/:$,92,$*%,//8$#/$
%/88)2)$ 9*$ '/#$ )&*.3$ Q&'.$ /5$ #,)$ W	'/$
*#01)'#*$ +,/$ &")$ )'#)"9'2$ ,92,)"$
)10%	/'$ 9'*#9#0#9/'*$ &")$ 59"*#$ 2)')"	/'$
%/88)2)$ *#01)'#*3$ A5$ #,)*)$ *#01)'#*7$
:&'.$ )'#)"$ +9#,/0#$ [09#)$ 0'1)"*#&'19'2$
,/+$ #,)$ *%,//8$ *.*#):$ +/";*3$ U/"$ #,)$
6&*#$ %/068)$ /5$ 1)%&1)*$ #,)$ B0)'#)$
B"/2"&:$ ,&*$ ())'$ -)".$ *0%%)**508$ 9'$
*)"-9'2$ W	'/$ *#01)'#*$ 6")6&"9'2$ #,):$
5/"$#,)9"$6&#,$/5$,92,)"$)10%	/'3$B0)'#)$
/"929'&88.$ 5/":)1$ 9'$ %/::0'9#.$ %/88)2)*$
&'1$ +&*$ 8&#)"$ &1/6#)1$ 9'$ ,92,$ *%,//8*3$
4,)$ 6"/2"&:$ 9*$ :&1)$ 06$ /5$ #,"))$
50'1&:)'#&8$ %/:6/')'#*$ +,9%,$ 9'%801)e$
?'289*,7$ %/0'*)89'2$ &'1$ :)'#/"9'23$ 4,)$
89#)"�")$ 6")*)'#)1$ 9'$ #,)$ %8&**"//:$ 9*$
(&*)1$ /'$ R,9%&'/\&$ W	'/\&$ 89#)"�")$
+,9%,$ )'2&2)*$ *#01)'#*$ 9'$ #,)$ :&#)"9&8$
#,).$ &")$ &'&8.@9'23$ R/0'*)8/"*$ &'1$
:)'#/"*$ +/";$ %8/*)8.$ '/#$ /'8.$ +9#,$
*#01)'#*$ (0#$ &8*/$#,)9"$5&:989)*$#/$)'*0")$
#,)9"$ *066/"#$ *.*#):$ &'1$ *0%%)**$ #/$
,92,)"$)10%	/'3$4,)$#"&'*9#9/'$5"/:$,92,$
*%,//8$#/$%/88)2)$:&.$()$%,&88)'29'27$(0#$
#,)$ 6"/2"&:$ ,)86*$ *#01)'#*$ 2)#$ *9#0&#)1$
&'1$ 0'1)"*#&'1$ ,/+$ #,)$ *%,//8$ *.*#):$
+/";*3$!
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
4,)$ 6"/2"&:$ 6"/-)*$ #/$ ()$
*0%%)**5083$4,)$6)"%)'#&2)$/5$B0)'#)$
*#01)'#*$$+,/$#"&'*5)"$&'1$%/:68)#)$&$
EDFKHORU¶V GHJUHH LV KLJKHU WKDQ WKDW
/5$ '/'EB0)'#)$ *#01)'#*3$ !$ B0)'#)$
VWXGHQW¶V GHJUHH FRPSOHWLRQ LV WZLFH
&*$ ,92,$ %/:6&")1$ #/$ #,/*)$ *#01)'#*$
+,/$ +)")$ '/#$ 6&"#$ /5$ #,)$ 6"/2"&:3$
!##&9'9'2$ &$ ,92,)"$ )10%	/'$ 9*$
9:6/"#&'#7$ (0#$ 2/9'2$ (&%;$ #/$ *)"-)$
#,)9"$%/::0'9#9)*$9*$&8*/$&*$9:6/"#&'#3$
B0)'#)$ &8*/$ /"9)'#*$ #,)9"$ *#01)'#*$ #/$
2/$ (&%;$ #/$ #,)9"$ %/::0'9#9)*$ &*$
:)'#/"*$ 5/"$ *#01)'#*$ +,/$ &8*/$ 5&%)1$
#,)$ %,&88)'2)*$ #,).$ /'%)$ 1913$ A0"$
50#0")$ 1)6)'1*$ /'$ /0"$ ./0'2)"$
2)')"	/'*3$4,)$(012)#$%0#*$%/'#9'0)$
#/$ ,&":$ #,)$ )10%	/'$ /5$ /0"$ %0"")'#$
&'1$50#0")$*#01)'#*3$=5$#,)$'0:()"*$/5$
W	'/$ *#01)'#*$ 9'$ ,92,)"$ )10%	/'$
&")$ #/$ 9'%")&*)7$ 6"/2"&:*$ *0%,$ &*$
B0)'#)$ *,/081$ ()$ 6")*)"-)1$ &'1$
:08#9689)1$"&#,)"$#,&'$)89:9'&#)13$$
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!-/!!
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
!
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!-A!!
!
!"#$%&#'%()*+&)#
(!Q1E896!89!19!.=D!Q41H;4!?5:662g!&6!?634!67!;?!
E:1E!31D!?6;9@!83J>6G1G24!6>!4=49!83J6??8G24M!
&:4!>4128ED!8?!:6C4=4><!E:8?!8?!89@44@!J6??8G24!19@!
:1?!G449!15563J28?:4@!G476>4M!
!
&:4!94C?!67!?634694!49E4>89H!89E6!E:4!.=D!
Q41H;4!8?!89!8E?427!4L58E89H<!G;E!6954!E:4!94C?!67!1!
Q1E896!6>!B8?J1985!8?!:41>@<!E:4>4!8?!H>41E!Y6D!
G451;?4!8E!8?!96E!?6!41?DM!a6>!1!Q1E896!E6!49E4>!19!
.=D!Q41H;4!?5:662!8?!28F4!5:12249H89H!122!E:4!
?E4>46EDJ4?!E:1E!5634!C8E:!G489H!Q1E896<!96E!H66@!
1E!19DE:89H!G;E!319;12!21G6><!:8H:!?5:662!@>6J!
RXWVZRUNHUVDW0F'RQDOG¶VHWF!
!
!
O;E!E:4>4!1>4!E:6?4!E:1E!>4128T4!E:1E!E:4D!1>4!36>4!
E:19!Y;?E!319;12!21G6><!E:4D!519!>8?4!19@!E1F4!E:4!
5:12249H4M!&:4D!519!J>6=4!E6!E:6?4!1>6;9@!E:43!
E:1E!?E1D89H!56376>E1G24!8?!96E!496;H:<!694!944@?!
E6!?44F!6;E!E:48>!@>413?!19@!6=4>5634!E:4!
5:12249H4?!E:1E!5634!7>63!J;>?;89H!E:48>!@>413?M!!
!
.!E:89F!C4!?:6;2@!122!G4!J>6;@!E6!G4!Q1E896!6>!
B8?J1985!19@!E6!J;>?;4!:8H:4>!4@;51E869M!&:8?<!89!
8E?427<!?4E?!;?!1J1>E!7>63!319D!6E:4>?!67!6;>!
4E:9858ED<!96E!E6!?1D!C4!1>4!19D!G4EE4>!E:19!6E:4>?<!
G;E!E:1E!C4!@47898E42D!?:6;2@!7442!J>6;@!19@!
36E8=1E4@!E6!36=4!76>C1>@M!K:4E:4>!D6;!1EE49@!1!
5633;98ED!56224H4<!1!J;G285!;98=4>?8ED<!6>!1!
J>8=1E4!;98=4>?8EDW!C4!122!;9@4>?E19@!E:4!
LPSRUWDQFHRIDQHGXFDWLRQ%XWOHW¶VWDNHD
36349E!19@!>456H98T4!E:6?4!67!6;>!5626>!C:6!
:1=4!H694!1G6=4!19@!G4D69@W!?E>18H:E!89E6!19!.=D!
Q41H;4!?5:662M!
!
5XEHQ1DYDUUHWWHLVWKHDXWKRURI³$'DUNHU
%:1@4!67!)>83?69\!*@D??4D!67!1!B1>=1>@!
&KLFDQR´$ERRNWKDWUHIOHFWVRQWKLVPDQ¶V
H[SHULHQFHDVDPLQRULW\LQDUJXDEO\WKHQDWLRQ¶V
36?E!J>4?E8H86;?!151@4385!89?E8E;E869M!K:1E!8?!
4=49!36>4!83J>4??8=4!:6C4=4><!8?!E:4!83349?4!
C6>F!:4!:1?!@694!17E4>!:8?!E834!89!E:8?!J>4?E8H86;?!
?5:662M!!
!
B4!:1?!@694!@65E6>12!C6>F!89!4@;51E869<!:1?!
?4>=4@!E:4!)6224H4!O61>@!1?!1!569?;2E19E!76>!
Q1E896!?E;@49E!17718>?<!19@!:1?!C6>F4@!1?!19!
1??8?E19E!E6!1!74@4>12!1JJ4221E4!Y;@H4M!Z>M!
"1=1>>4EE4!:1?!12?6!E1;H:E!89!424349E1>D!19@!
?4569@1>D!?5:662?!19@<!1E!EC49EDPE:>44<!1?!19!
89?E>;5E6>!1E!)12876>981!%E1E4!#98=4>?8ED<!a>4?96M!!
!
B4!:1?!J;G28?:4@!941>2D!694!:;9@>4@!4@8E6>812?!76>!
94C?J1J4>?!19@!31H1T894?!19@!:8?!C6>F!:1?!
1JJ41>4@!36?E!>4H;21>2D!89!E:4!%;9@1D!n*J89869n!
?45E869!67!E:4!Q6?!(9H424?!&834?W!E:6;H:!:4!:1?!
12?6!C>8EE49!76>!E:4!):851H6!&>8G;94<!(2G;d;4>d;4!
i6;>912<!j19?1?!)8ED!%E1><!(>8T691!'4J;G285!19@!
@6T49?!67!6E:4>!94C?J1J4>?M!B8?!C6>F!8?!741E;>4@!
89!?4=4>12!28E4>1>D!19E:626H84?!8952;@89H!M,$2$"A.
6&0B2.N$#(,%$2;!^B1>J4>)62289?_<!N(&32$"A.!
!
699$,G32$#(.642$0"!^V422_<!6.:B'2$4B'2B,3'.
O(3+(,!^j49@122eB;9E_!19@!5*(.O(%0B,4(9B'.
M,$2(,!^B1>56;>E!O>154!i6=196=85:_M!B8?!G66F<!
³$'DUNHU6KDGHRI&ULPVRQ2G\VVH\RID
+DUYDUG&KLFDQR´KDVEHHQUHYLHZHGE\
9;34>6;?!J4>86@8512?!8952;@89H!E:4!"4C!k6>F!
&834?!'4=84C!67!O66F?<!Q6?!(9H424?!&834?<!
K1?:89HE69!+6?E<!19@!+;G28?:4>`?!K44F2DM!!
!
*9!E424=8?869<!Z>M!"1=1>>4EE4!:1?!12?6!?4>=4@!1?!
H;4?E!:6?E!67!J;G285!E424=8?869`?!$33D!1C1>@P
C89989H!nQ874!o!&834?n!19@!:1?!1JJ41>4@!E6!
@8?5;??!=1>86;?!8??;4?!69!)""!19@!)"O)M!.9!
J>89E<!:4!C1?!>4549E2D!J>67824@!GD!1!B8?J1985!
31H1T894!1?!694!67!E:8>ED!15563J28?:4@!D6;9H!
J46J24!;9@4>!E:4!1H4!67!E:8>EDM!(?!1!C>8E4><!
562;398?E<!19@!245E;>4><!:4!96C!28=4?!89!
)12876>981`?!%19!i61d;89![1224D!C:4>4!:4!8?!
C>8E89H!:8?!94LE!G66F<!569E>8G;E89H!>4H;21>2D!E6!
E:4!Q6?!(9H424?!&834?!19@!6E:4>!94C?J1J4>?<!
19@!J>4J1>89H!E6!21;95:!E:4!J628E8512!94C?24EE4><!
O(40"4$'$32$0"<!C:85:!1@@>4??4?!8??;4?!67!
56954>9!E6!Q1E896?!19@!E:4!(34>8519!
5633;98EDM!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
$OPRVWPLUURULQJKLVH[SHULHQFHVLQWKH¶V
1?!694!67!692D!AS!Z4L8519!(34>8519?!89!1!
7>4?:319!B1>=1>@!521??!67!-b00<!8?!%;J>434!
&RXUW-XVWLFH6RQLD6RWRPD\RU¶VWLPHDW<DOHLQ
E:4!-Nh0?M!i;?E!28F4!';G49!"1=1>>4EE4<!
%6E631D6>!:1?!12?6!15563J28?:4@!H>41E!E:89H?!
?8954!:4>!E834!89!19!.=D!Q41H;4!?5:662M!%:4!
49E4>4@!+>8954E69!#98=4>?8ED!69!1!7;22!
?5:621>?:8JW!E:4>4!C4>4!74C!C6349!?E;@49E?!19@!
74C4>!Q1E896?M!.9!E:4!7122!67!-Nhb<!%6E631D6>!
49E4>4@!k124!Q1C!%5:662<!1H189!69!1!
?5:621>?:8JM!&:8?<!E66<!C1?!1!J2154!C8E:!=4>D!74C!
Q1E896?M!%:4!C1?!:8>4@!6;E!67!21C!?5:662!1?!19!
1??8?E19E!@8?E>85E!1EE6>94D!;9@4>!"4C!k6>F!
)6;9ED!V8?E>85E!(EE6>94D!'6G4>E!Z6>H49E:1;!89!
-NhNM!K8E:!E:8?<!%6E631D6>!G45134!E:4!
D6;9H4?E!Y;@H4!89!E:4!?6;E:4>9!@8?E>85E!67!"4C!
k6>F!)8ED!19@!E:4!78>?E!B8?J1985!74@4>12!Y;@H4!89!
"4C!k6>F!%E1E4M!.9!-NNh<!%6E631D6>!C1?!
963891E4@!GD!+>4?8@49E!O822!)289E69!E6!1!?41E!69!
E:4!#M%M!)6;>E!67!(JJ412?!C:85:!C1?!56978>34@!
69!*5E6G4>!/<!-NNcM!.9!/00N<!+>4?8@49E!O1>15F!
*G131!963891E4@!%6E631D6>!76>!1!?41E!69!E:4!
#98E4@!%E1E4?!%;J>434!)6;>EM!*9!(;H;?E!b<!
/00N<!%6E631D6>!C1?!56978>34@!GD!E:4!7;22!
%491E4!GD!1!=6E4!67!bc±A-!19@!C1?!
56338??8694@!GD!+>4?8@49E!*G131!69!E:4!@1D!
67!:4>!56978>31E869M!!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
&:4D!C4>4!1G24!E6!6=4>5634!5:12249H4?<!76>H4E!
1G6;E!@8?5>83891E869!19@!@6!?634E:89H!76>!
E:43?42=4?M!&:4D!C4>4!G6E:!1G24!E6!H6!E6!19!.=D!
Q41H;4!?5:662!C:4>4!E:4D!C4>4!1G24!E6!H4E!1!
:8H:4>!4@;51E869!C:85:!C6;2@!E:49!:42J!E:43!
31F4!1!5:19H4M!%634E834?!C4!31D!7442!
6=4>C:4234@!C8E:!E:4!J>4??;>4?<!>4?J69?8G828E84?!
19@!@87785;2E84?!67!?5:662<!G;E!E:8?!5634?!C8E:!E:4!
E4>>8E6>D!67!G489H!1!?E;@49EM!%634E834?!C4!12?6!
7442!28F4!E:4>4!1>4!96E!319D!67!;?!69!513J;?<!19@!
E:8?!31D!G4!E>;4M!O;E!E:4!9;3G4>?!1>4!5:19H89H!
19@!36>4!Q1E896?!1>4!56389H!E6!;98=4>?8E84?M!
B6C4=4><!:6C!@6!C4!H4E!:8H:!?5:662!?E;@49E?!E6!
G4!89E4>4?E4@!89!:8H:4>!4@;51E869I!&:4!19?C4>!8?!
:1=89H!E:4!;98=4>?8E84?!E1F4!19!15E8=4!>624!89!H689H!
E6!:8H:!?5:662?!19@!E12F89H!E6!E:6?4!89!
@8?1@=19E1H4@!5633;98E84?<!6>!C8E:!:8H:!
J4>549E1H4?!67!Q1E896?!>4?8@89H!E:4>4M!.E!8?!1G6;E!
H4EE89H!E:43!89E4>4?E4@!1E!1!D6;9H!1H4!19@!G489H!
>624!36@42?!76>!E:43M!%:6C89H!E:43!E:1E!E:4>4!8?!
36>4!E:19!319;12!21G6><!E:1E!E:4>4!8?!1!C6>2@!6;E!
E:4>4!E:1E!:1?!D4E!E6!G4!@8?56=4>4@!19@!89!C:85:!
E:4D!519!5>41E4!5:19H4M!Z1F89H!B8?J1985!5:82@>49!
?44!E:1E!E:48>!@>413?!67!C:1E!E:4D!C19E!E6!G4!
C:49!E:4D!H>6C!;J!519!15E;122D!G4!1!>4128ED!1?!
269H!1?!E:4D!@6!?634E:89H!1G6;E!8E!19@!@6!96E!?E1D!
89!1!?E1E4!67!56976>38ED!28F4!319D!67!;?!E49@!E6!
@6M!$@;51E869!8?!19!6JJ6>E;98ED!E:1E!C4!?1@2D!:1=4!
96E!E1F49!7;22!1@=19E1H4!67M!
!
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!-]!!
!
!
!
!!
$
$
$
$
$
F.$V#)6,&'.$4)88)@$$
!
&:8?!36=84!E1F4?!J2154!89!E:4!
Z8??869!V8?E>85E!67!%19!a>1958?56M!&:4!
3189!5:1>15E4>!):4!'8=4>1!8?!J21D4@!GD!
15E6>!O49Y1389!O>1EEM!.9!E:4!36=84!:4!8?!1!
?E>69H!>4?J45E4@!319!67!:8?!G1>>86M!B4!8?!
12?6!1!?89H24!71E:4>!E6!:8?!?69!i4?!'8=4>1<!
J21D4@!GD!i4>43D!'1D![12@4TM!K:49!):4!
@8?56=4>?!:8?!?69!8?!H1D<!:8?!J>8@4!19@!
19H4>!G45634!94C!6G?E1524?!89!:8?!2874!19@!
4=49E;122D!241@!E6!E:4!@4?E>;5E869!89!E:4!
>421E869?:8J!G4EC449!):4!19@!:8?!?69M!
&:>6;H:6;E!E:4!36=84<!i4?!E>84?!@8774>49E!
34E:6@?!E6!H4E!:8?!71E:4>!E6!?44!E:1E!G489H!
H1D!8?!96E!?634E:89H!D6;!5:66?4!E6!G4<!G;E!
LW¶VWKHZD\KHZDVERUQDQGKHZLVKHVIRU
:8?!71E:4>!E6!1554JE!:83M!.9!?E>;HH289H!E6!
789@!1!J2154!89!E:4!38@@24!76>!E:4!71E:4>!19@!
?69!>421E869?:8J!E6!C6>F<!i4?!:6J4?!E6!G>89H!
E:89H?!G15F!E6!96>312M!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
! (2E:6;H:!):4!8?!?E>69H!1E!:41>E!19@!
!
:8?!5:1>15E4>!?:6C?!:83!E6!:1=4!:1@!1!
!
>6;H:!2874<!:4!?:6C?!C41F94??!89!
5633;9851E869!19@!24E?!:8?!19H4>!E1F4!6=4>!
!
@8774>49E!?8E;1E869?M!B8?!>624!1?!1!315:8?E1!
71E:4>!8?!@41@!69M!B6C!):4!5:66?4?!E6!@412!
ZLWKKLVVRQ¶VUHDOLW\LVQ¶WYHU\GLIIHUHQW
7>63!:6C!349!89!3D!71382D!:1=4!6>!C6;2@!
>415E!E6!E:8?!?6>E!67!?8E;1E869M!.E!8?!?6!
83J6>E19E!89!E:4!Q1E896e1!5633;98ED!E:1E!
PHQIDWKHUFKLOGUHQER\VLQ&KH¶VFDVH
C:6!C822!G45634!?E>69H!349!19@!51>>D!69!
E:4!71382D!9134!C8E:!J>8@4!19@!21E4>!:1=4!1!
71382D!67!E:48>!6C9M!&:8?!C1D!67!E:89F89H!
8?!62@!71?:8694@!19@!H64?!G15F!319D!D41>?<!
1269H!C8E:!E:4!E>1@8E869!67!315:8?E1!
J4>?69128EDM!!&6!G4!315:8?E1!3419?!E6!
?:6C!96!C41F94??<!6>!74389894!E>18E?M!&:4!
315:6!8?!;?;122D!?E;GG6>9!19@!91>>6CP
389@4@M!&:8?!1EE8E;@4!E:1E!):4!51>>84?!
E:>6;H:6;E!E:4!C:624!36=84!?4>=4?!1?!E:4!
C122!:4!J;E?!;J!E6!?4J1>1E4!:83?427!
436E869122D!7>63!:8?!>421E869?:8J!E6!:8?!
?69M!&:8?!8?!122!8>6985!G451;?4!:4!
@4369?E>1E4?!:8?!C41F!?8@4!C:49!:4!?44F?!
19!4?51J4!7>63!:8?!744289H?<!>1E:4>!E:19!
5697>69E89H!E:43M!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
7KHFKLOGUHQ¶VILUVWLQVWLQFWLVWRWKLQN!
³0\SDUHQWVZRQ¶WXQGHUVWDQG
3"+.2*(,(.$%.%0.GB4*.2*32."((+%.
EHWDONHGDERXWDQGLVQ¶W
&(43B%(.1(.%2$''.'$#(.$".0'+.
93%*$0"(+.3"+.2,3+$2$0"3'.13;%´!
.!76;9@!E:8?!36=84!E6!G4!
4LE>4342D!4@;51E86912!89!E:1E!8E!G>6;H:E!
1C1>494??!E6!E:4!C1D!7138284?!
5633;9851E4!89!E:4!Q1E896!5633;98EDM!
K4!67E49!G45634!?6!;?4@!E6!E:89H?!
G489H!1!54>E189!C1D!E:1E!8E!G45634?!
96>312!19@!8?!96E!5:12249H4@M!a6>!
4L13J24<!E:4!31994>!89!C:85:!):4!
>415E?!C:49!:8?!?69!1@38E?!E6!G489H!H1DW!
C6;2@!>4?691E4!C8E:!8E!319D!Q1E896?!
C6;2@!96@!19@!1H>44!E:1E!8E!96>312!76>!1!
a1E:4>!7>63!6;>!5;2E;>4!E6!>415E!1?!):4!
@8@M!(2E:6;H:!E:4!>415E869!?443?!E6!G4!
96>312!E:4!15E;12!=8624954!19@!
1HH>4??8=494??!8?!96E!96>312!1E!122M!
Z19D!67!;?!C4>4!E1;H:E!E6!G4!741>7;2!67!
RXUSDUHQWVDQGWKDW¶VKRZWKH\XVHG
E:48>!1;E:6>8EDM!+1>49E12!@8?58J2894!
C6;2@!67E49!89=62=4!H4EE89H!1!G41E89HM!.9!
E:4!51?4!67!i4?<!:4!C1?!G489H!:694?E!89!
1@38EE89H!:4!C1?!H1D!19@!:8?!71E:4>?!
8334@81E4!>415E869!C1?!19H4>!19@!
1HH>4??869M!!
!!
!
!
!
8QIRUWXQDWHO\LW¶VKDUGHQRXJKEHLQJ
JD\LQWRGD\¶VVRFLHW\VLQFHPDQ\SHRSOHKDYHQ¶W
1554JE4@!E:4!8@41!67!?134P?4L!>421E869?:8J?!19@!
1>4!31@4!;956376>E1G24!?:6;2@!E:4!E6J85!4=4>!
FRPHXS-HV¶VFKDUDFWHUDVDWHHQLQGLFDWHVWKH
@8774>49E!J>4??;>4?!:4!:1?!E6!@412!C8E:!6954!:4!
6J494@!;J!1G6;E!:8?!?4L;128EDM!.E!8?!=4>D!@87785;2E<!
4?J458122D!96E!:1=89H!?;JJ6>E!7>63!D6;>!6C9!
71382D<!E6!7442!26=4@!19@!:;319<!>1E:4>!E:19!1?!
19!6GY45E!E6!G4!31@4!7;9!67M!.!13!?;>4!319D!
51?4?!19@!?8E;1E869?!1>4!:1>@!E6!E12F!1G6;E!C8E:!
IDPLO\PHPEHUVEXWLW¶VDERXWNHHSLQJDQRSHQ
2894!67!5633;9851E869!19@!C8E:6;E!J1??89H!
MXGJPHQWZLWKLQRQH¶VIDPLOLD6RFLHW\GRHV
496;H:!:1>3!E6!:;3198ED!69!8E?!6C9M!&:8?!36=84!
8?!49Y6D1G24!G451;?4!:6C!>421E4!1G24!8E!8?!.!13!
?;>4!319D!C822!49Y6D!8E!19@!8E?!319D!34??1H4?M!
%6!319D!J46J24!519!>421E4!E6!E:4!E:434?!
J6>E>1D4@!19@!E:4!:694?ED!C8E:!C:85:!E:4!
5:1>15E4>!4LJ>4??!E:4!563J24L8E84?!67!E:4!71382D<!
H49@4>!>624?<!?4L;12!6>849E1E869<!19@!E:4!
;98=4>?12!@4?8>4!C4!122!:1=4!E6!?44!E:4!7;27822349E!
67!1!36>4!8952;?8=4!:;3198EDP67!96E!89!4=4>D@1D!
>4128ED<!1E!241?E!89!E:4!>4128ED!67!E:4!36=84M!
!
&:8?!8?!C:D!E:1E!2894!67!
5633;9851E869!8?!?6!3898312!89!6;>!
5633;98ED<!G451;?4!319D!5:82@>49!
H>6C!;J!89!741>!67!E:4!>415E869!67!E:48>!
SDUHQWV7KHFKLOGUHQ¶VILUVWLQVWLQFWLVWR
E:89F\!!
!
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!-S!!
64$%,0#%!"..%,3%&!-&!
7,$0&-,8%,)!"..%,3%&19!
!"#$%&'()$*)+,(-&.$/0$
%:6;2@!Y;=49824!67749@4>?!G4!E>41E4@!1?!
1@;2E?!89!)12876>981!5>838912!Y;?E854!?D?E43!89!
RUGHUWRVWRSFULPH",QWRGD\¶VZRUOGWKLVLVD
d;4?E869!E:1E!569E89;4?!G489H!@8?J;E4@!89!?6584ED!
1?!C422!1369H!E:4!Y;?E854!?D?E43M!a>63!-NN/!E6!
-NNh!]]!?E1E4?W!8952;@89H!)12876>981!:1=4!J1??4@!
21C?!E:1E!715828E1E4!E:4!E>19?74>!67!Y;=49824!
67749@4>?!E6!1@;2E!5>838912!?D?E43!^&>41E349E!67!
i;=49824!67749@4>?_M!.9!)12876>981!1!Y;=49824!
67749@4>!8?!569?8@4>!87!:4e?:4!:1?!56338EE4@!1!
5>834!G4EC449!E:4!1H4?!67!-0P-hM!B6C4=4>!;9@4>!
Y;@85812!C18=4><!?E1E;E6>D!4L52;?869!19@!
J>6?45;E6>812!6>!@8>45E!7824<!56;>E?!519!@458@4!
C:4E:4>!E6!?49@!Y;=49824?!E6!E:4!1@;2E!5>838912!
Y;?E854!6>!F44J!E:43!89!E:4!Y;=49824!Y;?E854!
?D?E43M!i;=49824!67749@4>?!?:6;2@!96E!G4!E>41E4@!
1?!1@;2E?!G451;?4!J>8?69?!1>4!96E!1@4d;1E4!J2154?!
76>!Y;=49824?<!G489H!C8E:!1@;2E!5>838912?!C822!692D!
UHLQIRUFHMXYHQLOHRIIHQGHU¶VFULPLQDODFWLYLWLHV
19@!F44J!E:4!3896>8E84?!H>6;J?!89!J6=4>EDM!
&:4>476>4<!E:4!5D524!67!5>834!1369H!Y;=49824?!89!
J66>!5633;98E84?!8?!94=4>!H689H!E6!49@M!
!!
!
B6C!5634!8E!8?!>1>4!E:1E!C4!94=4>!:41>!
89!E:4!94C?!E:1E!89!C412E:D!5633;98E84?!?634!
Y;=49824!C1?!8951>54>1E4@!G451;?4!:4e?:4!
56338EE4@!1!5>834I!.9!E:4!6E:4>!:19@!E:4!34@81!
8?!12C1D?!>4J6>E89H!1G6;E!@4289d;495D!
56338EE4@!89!J66>!5633;98E84?M!i;=49824?!
56338E!5>834?!89!E:48>!5633;98E84?!G451;?4!67!
E:4!215F!67!6JJ6>E;98E84?!6774>4@!E6!E:43M!+1>49E?!
67!Y;=49824?!:1=4!E6!C6>F!E:4!49E8>4!@1D!89!6>@4>!
E6!:1=4!3694D!E6!J1D!76>!G822?!19@!J;E!766@!69!
E:4!E1G24M!&:4?4!F8@?!215F!1EE49E869!7>63!E:48>!
J1>49E?M!B6C4=4><!J1>49E?!?:6;2@!96E!G4!G2134@!
76>!E:4!>4?;2E?!67!E:4!1EE49E869!944@4@!GD!E:48>!
F89@?M!&:4!692D!J4>?69?!E:1E!1>4!E6!G4!G2134!69!
1>4!E:4!J46J24!C:6!5>41E4@!E:4!?D?E43!C4!1>4!89M!
6FKRROVSOD\DELJUROHLQMXYHQLOH¶V
7;E;>4M!%5:662?!7>63!J66>!5633;98E84?!89!C:85:!
Q1E896?!1>4!E:4!3189!694?!C:6!1EE49@!1>4!1369H!
E:4!C6>?4!?5:662?!15>6??!E:4!?E1E4!67!)12876>981M!
&:4>476>4<!D6;E:!8?!H4EE89H!21G42!12>41@D!67!G489H!
1369H!E:4!C6>?4!?E;@49E?!67!E:4!?E1E4M!k6;E:!
78H;>4!6;E!E:1E!E:48>!6JJ6>E;98E84?!67!?;554??!1>4!
389838T4@!1236?E!E6!96E:89HM!(7E4>!122!D6;E:!
G4284=4!E:1E!E:4D!@6!96E!:1=4!196E:4>!6JE869!E:19!
E6!H8=4!;JW!48E:4>!E:4D!H4E!89=62=4@!89!
@4289d;495D!6>!E:4D!?E1>E!C6>F89H!89!E:4!?134!
Y6G?!E:1E!E:48>!J1>49E?!C6>FM!B6C4=4><!E:4!?134!
?E6>D!>4J41E?!6=4>!19@!6=4>!1H189!76>!?6!319D!
D41>?M!
-:8?!?D?E43!C1?!@4?8H94@!E6!F44J!J66>!
J46J24W!C:85:!1>4!31892D!Q1E896?<!6JJ>4??4@M!.E!
8?!J>6=49!E:1E!76>!E:4!?134!74269D!8E!8?!76;>!E834?!
36>4!28F42D!E:19!1!Q1E896!6>!G215F!J4>?69!C822!
H4E!569=85E4@!E:19!1!C:8E4!J4>?69!^Y;=49824!
56>>45E869?_M!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
$
$
%7!E:4!?D?E43!8?!?6!C6>>84@!1G6;E!:8H:!
?E1E8?E85?!67!5>834!89!J66>!948H:G6>:66@?<!C:D!
GRHVQ¶WWKHJRYHUQPHQWVWDUWE\LPSURYLQJ
?5:662!569@8E869?!19@!83J24349E89H!J>6H>13?!
E:1E!C822!:42J!?E;@49E?!G4!655;J84@!19@!96E!:1=4!
E834!E6!H4E!89=62=4@!89!@4289d;495DI!.9?E41@!E:4!
?D?E43!?J49@?!3822869?!67!@6221>?!89!G;82@89H!
J>8?69!G;E!H6=4>9349E!94=4>!:1?!3694D!76>!
?5:662?M!
&:8?!8?!1!5:189!C4>4!8E!8?!4LE>4342D!
:1>@!E6!H4E!6;E!67!G451;?4!67!E:4!>4?6;>54?!
6774>4@!E6!;?M!"6E!692D!E:1E<!G;E!E:4!5>838912!
Y;?E854!?D?E43!8?!31F89H!8E!4=49!36>4!:1>@!GD!
J1??89H!E:4?4!EDJ4!67!21C?!C4>4!Y;=49824?!519!
?J49@!269H!J>8?69!?49E4954?!C8E:!>412!1@;2E!
5>838912?M!B6C4=4><!E:4!?D?E43!@64?!96E!>4128T4!
E:1E!E:4D!1>4!Y;?E!>48976>589H!D6;E:!E6!G45134!
>412!5>838912?!89!E:4!7;E;>4<!6>!E:4D!F96C!C:1E!
E:4!?D?E43!8?!@689H!19@!E:48>!H612!8?!G489H!
15:84=4@I!
$
$
%9!6>@4>!E6!;9@4>?E19@!C:D!Y;=49824?!H4E!
89=62=4@!89!@4289d;495D!C4!944@!E6!;9@4>?E19@!
E:48>!G15FH>6;9@<!28=89H!569@8E869?!19@!
6JJ6>E;98E84?!6774>4@!E6!E:43M!.E!8?!96E!94C!94C?!
E:1E!Y;=49824?!C:6!E49@!E6!G4!31892D!89=62=4@!89!
5>838912!15E8=8E84?!1>4!E:6?4!C:6!5634!7>63!
G>6F49!:634?<!>;>12!1>41?!19@!C:6!215F!
6JJ6>E;98E84?M!K8E:!E:4!83J24349E1E869!67!E:4?4!
EDJ4?!67!21C?!E:4!5633;98E84?!C:6!1>4!G489H!
E1>H4E4@!1>4!J66>!5633;98E84?!C:85:!1>4!31892D!
563J6?4@!67!3896>8E84?W!Q1E896?!19@!(7>8519P
(34>8519M!&:4!5>838912!Y;?E854!8?!E1>H4E89H!
3896>8ED!J66>!D6;E:<!96E!C412E:D!J46J24!C:6!519!
1776>@!1!21CD4>!6>!J18@!E:4!G182!89!6>@4>!E6!H4E!6;E!
67!J>8?69M!&:4!?D?E43!8?!@4?8H94@!E6!24E!E:4!J46J24!
C:6!519!1776>@!E6!J18@<!H4E!1C1D!C8E:!
@4289d;495D!19@!E:4!J46J24!C:6!@6!96E!G4!
8951>54>1E4@M!
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
K6>F!58E4@\!
Q1C>4954<!'85:1>@<!19@!Z1>86!B4??4M!n):1JE4>!
--\i;=49824!)6>>45E869?Mn!PB#("$'(.PB%2$4(Q.2*(.
R%%("2$3'%M!&:6;?19@!*1F?<!)(\!%(,$!
+;G2851E869?<!/0-0M!/0-P/]M!+>89EM!
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!-b!!
(³6RWKHVWHUHRW\SHDERXW
0H[LFDQVEHLQJOD]\LVQ
WUHDO"´(
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!OD\!Q4696>!,1DE19!
!
!!!!!!!K4!122!:1=4!4956;9E4>4@!3;2E8J24!
76>3?!67!6;>!J46J24!G489H!?E4>46EDJ4@!1?!
21TD<!21DG15F<!19@!C8E:!1!15d;84?54!
1EE8E;@4M!.9!76>3?!67!1>E!?;5:!1?!E:4!521??85!
?244J89H!Z4L8519!241989H!69!1!515E;?<!6>!
E:4!19E:>6J636>J:6;?!>1E!6>!36;?4!89!
51>E669?!C:6!8?!@>;9F!19@!@;>89H!E:4!
249HE:!67!8E?!1JJ41>1954!89!E:4!?:6C!@64?!
96E:89H!G;E!E422!Y6F4?!19@!E1F4?!E:89H?!
=4>D!28H:E2DM!K4!:1@!G449!4LJ6?4@!E6!E:8?!
EDJ4!67!51E4H6>8T1E869!19@!89!?83J24!
E4>3?<!:;38281E869!76>!549E;>84?M!!B1?!E:8?!
569@8E86989H!5>41E4@!1!31Y6>!47745E!69!6;>!
J46J24I!B1?!D41>?!19@!D41>?!67!
6JJ>4??869!15E;122D!31@4!;?!21TDI!
!
!
!!!!!!!&:4!19?C4>!8?!96M!*;>!J46J24!96C!
36>4!E:19!4=4>!1>4!E:4!694?!E:1E!C6>F!E:4!
:1>@4?EM!.9!1!>4549E!?E;@D!GD!E:4!
*>H198T1E869!76>!$5696385!)66J4>1E869!
DQG'HYHORSPHQW2(&'³0H[LFDQV
@4=6E4!19!1=4>1H4!67!-0!:6;>?!J4>!@1D!E6!
J18@!19@!;9J18@!C6>F<!?;5:!1?!
KRXVHZRUN´%RRWK7KHSUHYLRXV
136;9E!67!8976>31E869!C1?!E1F49!7>63!1!
>4J6>E!89!C:85:!122!91E869128E84?!C4>4!
563J1>4@M!!&:8?!136;9E!67!:6;>?!56;2@!
692D!G4!15:84=4@!GD!C6>F89H!1!E6E12!67!
E:>44!Y6G?!@;>89H!@1D!19@!H689H!:634!
?E822!:1=89H!E6!E1F4!51>4!67!D6;>!71382DM!.9!
19!1>E8524!GD!E:4!K1?:89HE69!+6?E!E8E24@!
³6LHVWD":KDW6LHVWD"0H[LFDQVZRUN
ORQJHVWKRXUVLQZRUOG´ZKHQRXUIHOORZ
J46J24!C4>4!8976>34@!67!E:8?!>4J6>E!E:4D!
d;4?E8694@!E:4!=128@8ED!67!8EM!%634!E:1E!
C4>4!?F4JE8512!4=49!1?F4@!87!E:4D!C6>F4@!
:1>@4>!E:19!E:4!i1J194?4M!(556>@89H!E6!
E:4!>4J6>E!J>4?49E4@!GD!E:4!!*$)V!
i1J194?4!C4>4!?4569@!C8E:!E6E12!67!!S]0!
:6;>?!Ahb!J18@!19@!-b]!;9J18@<!C:824!
Z4L8519?!C6>F4@!1!E6E12!67!SN]!:6;>?M!!
!
!!!!!!!!%6!C:4>4!@64?!E:8?!241=4!;?I!.9!
>4128ED!C4!1>4!96E!21TD!1E!122<!1?!D6;!519!
?44!6;>!J46J24!1>4!E:4!694?!E:1E!C6>F!E:4!
KDUGHVWLQOLWHUDOWHUPV,W¶VDOUHDG\KDUG
496;H:!89!6;>!91E8=4!56;9E>D!E6!?;>=8=4<!
E:4!9454??8ED!67!C19E89H!1!G4EE4>!2874!89!
H494>12!8?!C:1E!J;?:4?!;?!E6!C6>F!E49!
:6;>?!1!@1DM!O;E!D6;!?44!E:1E!?E822!8?9`E!
496;H:!1E!E834?!76>!C4!C4>4!96E!H8=49!
E:4!?134!E662?!E6!?E1D!1:41@!67!E:4!>154M!
.E!8?!96E!496;H:!E6!G4!89!1!C422!?E19@89H!
J6?8E869!89!6;>!56;9E>D<!4=49!E:6;H:!E:1E!8?!
@87785;2E!89!8E?427!19@!H8=49!E:4!J66>!28=89H!
569@8E869?!C4!1>4!J;?:4@!6;E!67!6;>!91E8=4!
ODQGWRZDUGVDSODFHWKDWLVGHHPHG³EHWWHU´
19@!?634E:89H!67!@>413?M!!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
&:8?!J2154!96!31EE4>!:6C!C69@4>7;2!8E!
31D!G4!J6>E>1D4@!?E822!J;E?!;?!G4:89@!
J628E85122D<!5;2E;>122D<!19@!45696385122DM!
.9!6>@4>!E6!15:84=4!4=49!E:4!?28H:E4?E!
C8?J!67!C422!G489H!C4!3;?E!6954!36>4!
?E1>E!E:4!?134!G15F!G>41F89H!>6;E894!C4!
J>4=86;?2D!4?51J4@!7>63M!%6!C:D!E:49!
1>4!C4!?449!89!1!31994>!E:1E!8?!
@4?5>8G4@!GD!E:4!K1?:89HE69!J6?E!
³0H[LFDQVDUHDOZD\VZLOOLQJFDSDEOH
DQGIOH[LEOH´%RRWK7KH!
>41?69!8?!G451;?4!C4!1>4!C82289H!
!E6!@6!19DE:89H!89!6;>!J6C4>!E6!
!J;?:!E:>6;H:M!K4!1>4!51J1G24!
!67!5>41E89H!563J24L!E:89H?!
!?;5:!1?!E424=8?869?<!>47>8H4>1E6>?<!
!51>?!19@!49@;>4!E:4!E622!8E!
!J:D?85122D!E1F4?!69!;?M!(9@!!
789122D!C4!1>4!724L8G24!496;H:!!
E6!12C1D?!E>D!19@!5>41E4!94C!!
8@41?!E6!:42J!;?!?E>8=4!76>!H>41E4?EM!!!
!!!!!!(?!E:4!E8E24?!?E1E4?<!E:4!?E4>46EDJ4?!1>4!
96E!E>;4M!K4!1>4!96E!21TD<!C4!1>4!96E!
21DG15F<!19@!C4!@6!96E!J6??4??!19!
1EE8E;@4!67!56976>38EDM!O;E!C:1E!C4!@6!
J6??4?!8?!1!H>41E!=12;4!67!?15>87854M!!&:4!
>41?69!C:D!6;>!J46J24!C6>F!E49!:6;>?!1!
@1D!19@!?E822!H6!:634!E6!H8=4!E:48>!71382D!
E:4!1EE49E869!E:4D!@4?4>=4!8?!G451;?4!6;>!
1954?E6>?<!H>19@J1>49E?!19@!J1>49E?!:1=4!
?15>87854@!19@!C822!569E89;4!E6!?15>87854!
19DE:89H!89!E:48>!J6??4??869!E6!:42J!;?<!
E:48>!5:82@>49<!526?4!E:1E!H1J!89!E:4!
@8?1@=19E1H4!E:1E!C1?!5>41E4@!?8954!E:4!
G4H89989H!67!6;>!J46J24M!i;?E!28F4!E:4D!
:1=4!49@;>4@!19@!?15>87854@!E:48>!28=4?!
DQGGUHDPVLW¶VXSWRXVQRZWRGHOLYHUD
?E>69H!>4?62=4W!;?89H!E:8?!H87E!E:1E!8?!H8=49!
E6!;?!@1D!17E4>!@1D!89!E:4!36?E!J:D?85122D!
@>18989H!C1D!E:1E!519!G4!831H894@<!
C6>F89H!7>63!@1C9!E6!@;?FM!OD!15:84=89H!
:8H:4>!H612?!89!4@;51E869!19@!4LJ>4??89H!
6;>!?E>;HH24!89!76>3?!67!28E4>1E;>4!?;5:!1?!
E:8?!C4!519!51>>D!69!6;>!24H15D!19@!
@8?319E24!?E4>46EDJ4?!?;5:!1?!E:8?!694<!C4!
519!>4@;54!E:4!?E>189!C4!:1=4!7154@!19@!
J>4=182M!!
B1>@4?E!K6>F4>?!1>4!%6;E:!!
³0H[LFDQVZRUNWKHPRVWHDFKGD\
S<S.*0B,C.3440,+$"A.20.3.,(80,2.&;.2*(.
0,A3"$732$0".90,.R40"0G$4.
)008(,32$0".3"+.N(#('08G("2<.6.
&,(3T+01".09.2*0%(.*0B,%.%*01%.2*32.
2*(;.3'%0.+0.2*(.G0%2.B"83$+.10,T.3"+.
3,(.83%%(+.0"';.&;.2*(.P383"(%(.3"+.
U0B2*.V0,(3"%.90,.10,T$"A.2*(.G0%2.
SDLGKRXUV´.
....@5*(.M3%*$"A20".W0%2..
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!-h!!
:H6KRXOG&HOHEUDWH0RWKHU·V'D\
./+",01,2$
F.e$O)89&$Q&"#9')@$R3$
.E!C1?!%1E;>@1D<!A\A0!(MZM!C:49!3D!
121>3!5265F!C49E!69M!.E!C1?!E834!76>!34!E6!H4E!;J!
19@!4LJ4>84954!19!4=49E!E:1E!5:19H4@!3D!C1D!67!
YLHZLQJP\PRP¶VKDUGZRUN,KDGWREHUHDG\
GD!]\00!(MZM!G451;?4!.!@458@4@!E6!H6!C8E:!3D!
363!19@!4LJ4>84954!C:1E!?:4!H64?!E:>6;H:!4=4>D!
@1D!1E!:4>!C6>F!89!E:4!(((!J15F1H89H!563J19DM!
.E!C1?!1!=4>D!562@!36>989H<!G;E!E:1E!@8@!96E!31@4!
1!@8774>4954M!
0\PRPDVNHGPH³:K\GLG\RXZDQW
WRFRPHZLWKPH",W¶VYHU\HDUO\$UH\RXVXUH
D6;!C19E!E6!H6I!&:8?!Y6G!8?!E8>89H<!C4!:1=4!E6!
C6>F!71?E!89!6>@4>!E6!7898?:!41>2DM!O4?8@4?<!8E!8?!1!
>4122D!562@!36>989H<!19@!E:4!?J8915:!8?!H689H!E6!G4!
UHDOO\FROGDQGZHW´!
!
,DQVZHUHG³,UHDOO\ZDQWWRKDYHD
744289H!67!C:1E!D6;!H6!E:>6;H:!415:!@1D!19@!
1JJ>4581E4!E:4!4776>E!D6;!@6!89!6>@4>!76>!;?!E6!:1=4!
WKHWKLQJVZHQHHG´!
!
!"#$%$#&'(#)%#*'+,#-.#,/,0"#
$%01213#')#4566#78!8#9#:'1#(,,#)&')#(&,#2(#
)20,;#%<#;%213#)&,#('$,#)&213#,/,0"#;'"8#=&,#
)%>;#$,#)&')#'>>#)&2(#,<<%0)#%<#&,0(#2(#?,:'-(,#
(&,#*'1),;#$,#)%#%?)'21#'#&23&,0#,;-:')2%18#
@,0#;0,'$#2(#<%0#$,#)%#3%#)%#:%>>,3,#'1;#
%?)'21#'#:'0,,08#!"#$%$#;%,(#1%)#*'1)#$,#)%#
*%0+#&%*#(&,#2(#*%0+213A#)&')#2(#*&"#(&,#2(#
(:'02<"213#&,0(,><#21#%0;,0#<%0#$,#3%#)%#3%#
:%>>,3,8##
B,#'002/,;#)%#)&,#30,,1&%-(,(A#)&,#
.>':,#*&,0,#$"#$%$#*%0+(#,/,0"#;'"8#C&2(#
.>':,#*'(#;'0+#'1;#(:'0"8#D02:+,)(#'1;#*'),0#
;0%.(#*,0,#'>>#)&,#(%-1;(#9#*'(#'?>,#)%#&,'08#
=21:,#2)#*'(#;'0+A#2)#>%%+,;#>2+,#'1#,$.)"#
(.':,A#>'),0#%1E#9#*'(#'?>,#)%#(,,#&%*#)&,#
(.21':&#>%%+,;8#9)#*'(#30,,1A#*2)&#(%$,#*'),0#
%1#2)8#!"#$%$#3')&,0,;#)&,#*%0+213#
$'),02'>(E#:%))%1#3>%/,(A#'1;#'#)&213(#:'>>,;#
F0%(';,0'G#*&2:&#'0,#/,0"#(2$2>'0#)%#+12<,(8#
B2)&#)&2(#)".,#%<#+12<,(#*,#*,0,#3%213#)%#:-)#
)&,#(.21':&8#C&,#+12<,(#F0%(';,0'G#<,>)#(&'0.#
'1;#)&,"#>%%+#/,0"#;'13,0%-(#2<#1%)#-(,;#
.0%.,0>"8#!"#$%$#;%,(#1%)#*'1)#'1")&213#
?';#)%#&'..,1#)%#-(A#)&,0,<%0,#(&,#*'01#$,#)%#
?,#:'0,<->#?,:'-(,#9#:%->;#:-)#$"(,><#*2)&#)&,#
,"+-.&,-8#
!
0\PRPVDLG³:HZHDUWKHVHFRWWRQ
JORYHVEXWVRPHSHRSOHGRQ¶WZHDUWKHP
EHFDXVHLW¶VKDUGWRZRUNZLWKWKHPVLQFHWKH\
1>4!=4>D!J;77D!19@!E:85FM!%634E834?!C4!@6!5;E!
6;>!?427<!G;E!C4!1>4!;?4@!E6!8E!12>41@DM!K4!:1=4!
WRFRQWLQXHZRUNLQJOLNHWKDW´!
.9!E:1E!36349E<!.!>4343G4>!?4489H!3D!
PRP¶VKDQGVIXOORIFXWVDQGWKHIHHOLQJRIKHU
>6;H:!:19@?M!ZD!363!:19@?!1>4!67!1!:1>@!
C6>F89H!C6319<!C:6!8?!C82289H!E6!C6>F!
6=4>E834!89!6>@4>!76>!34!19@!3D!EC6!G>6E:4>?!E6!
:1=4!122!E:4!E:89H?!C4!944@M!"6E!692D!E:1E!G;E!
?:4!8?!12C1D?!@4@851E4@!E6!;?!19@!31F89H!?;>4!
E:1E!C4!1>4!69!E:4!>8H:E!E>15F!E6!G45634!H66@!
J46J24M!
ZD!363!C1?!C6>F89H!?6!71?E<!G;E!.!
56;2@!96EM!&:4!?J8915:!C1?!>4122D!562@!19@!
>4122D!C4E<!G;E!8E!?4434@!E:1E!?:4!C1?!;?4@!E6!8E!
12>41@DM!K:49!C4!C4>4!7898?:4@<!C4!:1@!E6!
569E89;4!GD!J;EE89H!E:4!?J8915:!89!?634!C66@49!
G6L4?M!
0\PRPVDLG³1RZZHKDYHWRWDNHWKHER[HV
E6!E:4!6E:4>!49@!19@!J;E!E:43!69!E:4!E>;5FM!&:4!
G6L4?!C48H:E?!1G6;E!S0Pb0!2G?M!K4!12?6!:1=4!E6!
GULYHWKHPWRWKHFRROHUURRP´6KHVDLG³QRZ
D6;!;9@4>?E19@!:6C!:1>@!3D!C6>F!8?<!G;E!E:4!
692D!E:89H!E:1E!F44J?!34!H689H!8?!3D!
36E8=1E869?M!ZD!36E8=1E869?!69!?49@89H!3694D!
E6!D6;>!H>19@J1>49E?<!J1D!E:4!36>EH1H4!19@!J1D!
76>!D6;>!4@;51E869W!D6;>!@>413!67!G456389H!E:4!
21CD4>!D6;!:1=4!12C1D?!@>413!67!G456389HM!.!
ZDQW\RXWRJHWDQHGXFDWLRQ,GRQ¶WZDQW\RX
E6!G4!C6>F89H!28F4!34M!.!C19E!D6;!E6!:1=4!1!
G4EE4>!Y6G!19@!E6!:1=4!1!G4EE4>!2874M!5$("(%.XB(.
("2("+(,.XB(.B"3.G3+,(.*34(.'0.XB(.%(3.80,.%B%.
*$Y0%<.)B3"+0."B(%2,0%.*$Y0%.'0A,3".%B%.G(23%C.
%3#(G0%.XB(.20+0%.'0%.%34,$9$4$0%..#3'$(,0".'3.
8("3.;."0%.%("2$G0%.GB;.0,AB''0%0%.+(.(''0%M!
^k6;!944@!E6!;9@4>?E19@!E:1E!1!36E:4>!@64?!
C:1E4=4>!?:4!:1?!E6!76>!:4>!5:82@>49^?_M!K:49!
6;>!5:82@>49^?_!15:84=4!E:48>!H612?<!C4!F96C!122!
6;>!?15>87854?!C4>4!C6>E:!8E!19@!C4!7442!?6!J>6;@!
RIWKHP´!
B&')#(&,#)%>;#$,#*'(#(&%:+213#
EHFDXVHPRVWSDUHQW¶VLIQRWDOODUHZLOOLQJ
)%#(':02<2:,#)&,$(,>/,(#21#%0;,0#<%0#-(#
F#:&2>;0,1G#)%#&'/,#'#?,)),0#>2<,8#9#0,'>2H,;#
WKDWSDUHQWV¶PDLQPRWLYDWLRQLVWKHLU
:&2>;0,1F(G8#
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
OD!E:8?!E834!.!C1?!?6!E8>4@<!G;E!.!:1@!E6!
F44J!:42J89H!:4>M!K6>F4>?!1?!C422!1?!C4!C4>4!
1>>8=89H!E6!E:8?!G8H!6J49!:6;?4!C:4>4!C4!C6;2@!
:1=4!E6!J15F!E:4!?J8915:M!(E!N\00!(MZ!C4!C49E!E6!
2;95:<!C4!:1@!:127!19!:6;>M!K:49!8E!C1?!E834!E6!H6!
EDFNWRZRUNMXVWE\ORRNLQJDWP\PRP¶VIDFLDO
4LJ>4??869?<!.!56;2@!E422!?:4!@8@!96E!C19E!E6!H6!
G15F!E6!C6>FM!K4!569E89;4@!@689H!E:4!?134!C6>F!
E:>6;H:6;E!E:4!@1DM!(E!1G6;E!9669!8E!H6E!>4122D!:6EM!
&:4!E43J4>1E;>4!C1?!1G6;E!Nh!@4H>44?!a1:>49:48EM!
$=49!E:6;H:!E:4!E43J4>1E;>4!C1?!:8H:<!C4!?E822!
:1@!E6!569E89;4!C6>F89HM!
*;>!@1D!49@4@!1E!A\A0!+MZM!.!>4128T4!C4!
:1@!7898?:!C6>F89H!41>2D!?8954!36?E!67!E:4!E834!
3D!363!1>>8=4?!:634!21E4>!E:19!]\A0!+MZM!(E!E:1E!
E834<!C4!C4>4!?E1>=89H!19@!>4122D!E8>4@M!ZD!363!
E62@!34!E:1E!?:4!C1?!=4>D!E8>4@M!B6C4=4>!?:4!:1@!
E6!@6!E:4!?134!>6;E894!67!4=4>D@1DW!?:4!>4?E4@!76>!
1!G8E<!566F4@!@8994><!J>4J1>4@!766@!76>!E:4!94LE!
@1D<!E66F!1!?:6C4>!19@!C49E!E6!?244JM!&:4!94LE!
@1D!?:4!:1@!E6!>4J41E!E:4!?134!C6>F89H!>6;E894!
7>63!A\/0!89!E:4!36>989H!;9E82!]\00!6>!21E4>!89!E:4!
17E4>9669M!ZD!363!?443?!=4>D!E8>4@!G;E!?:4!
569E89;4?!C6>F89H!:1>@!415:!@1DW!G451;?4!67!34!
19@!3D!G>6E:4>?M!%:4!8?!1!?E>69H!Q1E891!C6319!
C:6!94=4>!H8=4?!;JM!%:4!:1?!G449!3D!>624!36@42!
G451;?4!.!?44!E:1E!?:4!94=4>!H8=4?!;J!96!31EE4>!E:4!
58>5;3?E1954?<!E:4>476>4!.!?:6;2@!94=4>!H8=4!;J!
48E:4>M!
K4!519!?44!E:1E!Q1E896!C6349!?15>87854!
E:43?42=4?!76>!E:48>!F8@?<!89!6>@4>!76>!E:43!E6!
:1=4!1!G4EE4>!2874M!B6C!3D!363!:1?!?15>87854!76>!
34M!%:4!28=4?!76>!34<!E:1E!8?!C:D!Z1D!-0!
PRWKHU¶VGD\LVQRWHQRXJKWRWKDQNDOOWKH
363?!76>!E:4!E:89H?!E:4D!:1=4!@694!76>!;?M!K4!
?:6;2@!1JJ>4581E4!E:43!36>4!19@!E:19F!E:43!
4=4>D!?89H24!@1DM!*;>!36E:4>?!28=4!76>!;?W!E:4D!@6!
4=4>DE:89H!76>!;?<!E:1E!8?!C:D!C4!?:6;2@!G4!
E:19F7;2!E:1E!C4!:1=4!6;>!36E:4>?!C8E:!;?M!
&:19F!D6;!363ggg!
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!-c!!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
"#!$%&'()*#!+&,,&-!!
!
*;>!36?E!J6J;21>!Q8G>1>D!69!
513J;?!8?!E:4!'8=4>1!Q8G>1>D!>49134@!
17E4>!&:631?!'8=4>1!69!a4G>;1>D!-N<!
-NcS!89!:8?!:696>M!&63p?!'8=4>1!C1?!6;>!
78>?E!3896>8ED!5:1954226>!89!E:4!#98=4>?8ED!
67!)12876>981!?D?E43!89!-NhNM!B4!:1@!
319D!15:84=4349E?!1?!1!96=428?E<!J64E!
19@!12?6!19!4@;51E6>M!B8?!?E6>D!8?!
89?J8>89H!E6!319D<!G;E!76>!E:6?4!67!;?!89!
E:4!Q1E896!5633;98ED<!8E!8?!1!E4?E8369D!
E:1E!C4!519!15:84=4!19@!G4!36>4!E:19!Y;?E!
8338H>19E?!6>!J1>E!67!E:4!26C4>!521??M!
B8H:4>!E:1E!C8E:!4776>E!19@!718E:<!694!519!
6=4>5634!?44389H2D!83J6??8G24!6@@?M!B4!
6GE1894@!:8?!56224H4!4@;51E869!89!1!E834!
SHULRGZKHQSHRSOHRIFRORUZHUHQ¶W
H>19E4@!E:4!2;L;>D!67!1!:8H:4>!4@;51E869!
E:1E!C1?!F96C9!1?!1!J>8=824H4M!&6@1D!
4@;51E869!G4D69@!:8H:!?5:662!76>!'1T1!8?!
=84C4@!?634C:4>4!G4EC449!J>8=824H4!19@!
1!>8H:EM!.E!8?!1!24H8E831E4!H612!G;E!56?E?!
F44J!4?5121E89H!19@!E:4!jP-/!?D?E43?!89!
8994>!58E84?!19@!26CP895634!
948H:G6>:66@?!1>4!895>41?89H2D!G489H!
;9@4>7;9@4@!19@!56;9E24??!E415:4>?!1>4!
26?89H!E:48>!Y6G?M!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!(?!1!D6;9H!G6D!&63p?!'8=4>1!
C6>F4@!89!E:4!7842@?!1269HP?8@4!:8?!
J1>49E?!89!&4L1?!C:4>4!:4!C1?!G6>9M!&:8?!
ZDVQ¶WHDV\DQGKHZRXOGDOVRZRUN
@;>89H!?;334>!=151E869?W!C:49!E:4!
:1>=4?E!?41?69!C6;2@!6=4>21J!C8E:!E:4!7122!
?434?E4><!:4!C6;2@!:1=4!E6!38??!?5:662!
19@!?E822!51E5:!;J!69!:8?!38??4@!
?5:662C6>FM!&63p?!F94C!1?!1!5:82@!E:1E!
:4!1?J8>4@!694!@1D!E6!G4!1!C>8E4>!19@!:4!
1554JE4@!:8?!13G8E869!C:49!J46J24!89!E:4!
Z4L8519!5633;98ED!4LJ>4??4@!4LE>434!
@6;GEM!B4!C6>F4@!E:4!7842@?!;J!;9E82!:4!
>415:4@!Y;986>!56224H4<!1E!C:85:!J689E!
@182D!1EE49@1954!C1?!>4d;8>4@!76>!122!
FODVVHV5LYHUD¶VLQVSLUDWLRQLQOLIHIRU
C19E89H!E6!:42J!E:4!343G4>?!67!:8?!
71382D!19@!E6!15:84=4!:8?!J4>?6912!H612?!
C1?!:8?!H>19@71E:4>!C:6!569?E19E2D!
?;JJ6>E4@!19@!4956;>1H4@!:83M!!
B4!6=4>5134!56;9E24??!6G?E1524?!19@!
;2E831E42D!41>94@!:8?!56224H4!@4H>44!
7>63!%6;E:C4?E!&4L1?!%E1E4!#98=4>?8ED<!
C:85:!8?!96C!F96C9!1?!&4L1?!%E1E4!
#98=4>?8EDM!&63p?!'8=4>1!E:49!C49E!
69E6!E:4!;98=4>?8ED!67!*F21:631!C:4>4!
:4!41>94@!:8?!+:MVM!V;>89H!:8?!Y6;>94D!
89!4@;51E869!:4!>456H98T4@!E:4!
83J6>E1954!19@!E:4!944@!76>!Z4L8519P
(34>8519?!E6!G45634!4@;51E4@!1?!C422M!
,WZDVQ¶WXQWLOWKHGD\KHVWRSSHG
C6>F89H!E:4!7842@?!E:1E!&63p?!'8=4>1!
C1?!1G24!E6!43G1>F!69!E:8?!94C!Y6;>94D!
E:1E!C6;2@!>4?;2E!89!96E!692D!J4>?6912!
?;554??<!G;E!6JJ6>E;98E84?!E6!:42J!E:4!
Z4L8519!(34>8519!5633;98E84?!67!
&4L1?!19@!E6!?4>=4!1?!>624!36@42!E6!
J46J24!E:>6;H:6;E!E:4!#98E4@!%E1E4?!19@!
G4D69@M!5LYHUD¶VILUVWFUHDWLYHSLHFHZDV
J4994@!1E!E:4!1H4!67!424=49!C:49!:4!
C>6E4!1G6;E!1!51>!1558@49E!E:1E!:4!C49E!
E:>6;H:M!!
!
5LYHUD¶VILUVWFUHDWLYHSLHFHZDV
J4994@!1E!E:4!1H4!67!424=49!!
C:49!:4!C>6E4!1G6;E!1!
51>!1558@49E!E:1E!:4!
C49E!E:>6;H:M!$=49!1?!
1!5:82@!'8=4>1!:1@!
@458@4@!E6!G4!1!C>8E4><!
G;E!1E!E:4!E834!:4!
1??;34@!:4!C6;2@!
G45634!1!?J6>E?!C>8E4>!
VLQFHWKDW¶VZKDWKH
49Y6D4@!E6!>41@!1E!E:4!
E834M!
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
+LVPRVWIDPRXVQRYHOLV«;."0.%(.'0.
2,3A0.'3.2$(,,3<!E>19?21E4@!89!$9H28?:!1?!
5*$%.:$A,3"2.R3,2*M!B4!;?4@!:8?!78>?E!
:19@!4LJ4>84954!7>63!C6>F89H!89!E:4!
7842@?!1?!E:4!G1?8?!76>!E:4!G66F<!1G6;E!1!
\RXQJER\¶VOLIHDVDPLJUDQWIDUP
ZRUNHU,WZDVQ¶WHDV\JHWWLQJKLVERRN
J;G28?:4@!G451;?4!8E!C1?!C>8EE49!89!
%J198?:!19@!@;4!E6!G21E19E!>158?3!1H189?E!
:83!1?!1!Z4L8519P(34>8519!1;E:6>M!1G6;E!
D\RXQJER\¶VOLIHDVDPLJUDQWIDUP
ZRUNHU,WZDVQ¶WHDV\JHWWLQJKLVERRN
J;G28?:4@!G451;?4!8E!C1?!C>8EE49!89!
%J198?:!19@!@;4!E6!G21E19E!>158?3!1H189?E!
:83!1?!1!Z4L8519P(34>8519!1;E:6>M!B4!
>4122D!C19E4@!E6!789@!1!C1D!76>!Z4L8519P
(34>8519?!E6!4@;51E4!E:43?42=4?!1?!1!
C1D!6;E!67!7842@C6>FM!O476>4!G4H89989H!
:8?!J>674??86912!51>44>!'8=4>1!G4H19!C8E:!
E415:89H!E:4!7842@C6>F4>?!$9H28?:M!B4!
E62@!71>3!C6>F4>?!E6!96E!2838E!E:43?42=4?!
E6!56976>389H!E6!(9H26!4LJ45E1E869?!
E6C1>@?!Z4L8519?M!B4!4956;>1H4@!'1T1!
E6!?44F!6;E!:8H:4>!4@;51E869!6JJ6>E;98E84?!
19@!E6!G4!E>;4!E6!E:43?42=4?!1269H!E:4!
C1DM!&63p?!'8=4>1!;?4@!:8?!4@;51E86912!
?;554??!E6!G45634!1!>4?J45E4@!4@;51E6><!
E415:89H!89!:8H:!?5:662?!E:>6;H:6;E!E:4!
%6;E:C4?E4>9!#98E4@!%E1E4?<!G476>4!
36=89H!69!E6!G45634!1!J>674??6>!1E!E:4!
#98=4>?8ED!24=42!J>86>!E6!G489H!?4245E4@!1?!
5:1954226>!1E!6;>!#98=4>?8ED!67!)12876>981<!
'8=4>?8@4!;9E82!:8?!;9E8342D!@41E:!89!
-Nc]M!&:631?!'8=4>1!C822!G4!12C1D?!
>4?J45E4@!19@!:696>4@!76>!:8?!]c!D41>?!67!
2874!19@!E:4!C6>2@!67!@8774>4954!E:1E!:4!
:1?!31@4!76>!:8?!6C9!5633;98EDM!B4!8?!
?E822!89?J8>89H!E:6?4!C:6!1>4!C82289H!E6!E>D!
E6!>4128T4!E:48>!J4>?6912!@>413?!1H189?E!
4=4>D!76>3!67!>4?8?E1954<!94H1E8=8ED<!
@6;GE<!6G?E1524<!>158?3<!6>!83J6??8G2D!
269H!6@@?M!
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!-N!!
!
-HQQLIHU/RSH]DQGWKH³'LYD´'HEDWHGD!Z85:142!V1>@69!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
*9!Z1D!A<!/0--!17E4>!1!76;>PD41>!:81E;?<!
?89H4>!i499874>!Q6J4T<!17745E8691E42D!985F!9134@!
iMQ6<!>4E;>94@!E6!E:4!3;?85!?5494!C8E:!E:4!>4241?4!
67!:4>!:8H:2D!19E858J1E4@!?4=49E:!?E;@86!12G;3!
³-0#(Z´%HWZHHQPDJD]LQHFRYHUVWRULHV²?:4!8?!
SLFWXUHGRQWKHFRYHURI³3HRSOH´!PDJD]LQH¶V
³:RUOG¶V0RVW%HDXWLIXO´OLVWLVVXH²19@!
FHOHEULW\QHZVSURJUDPVVXFKDV³(´<!=4>D!28EE24!
8?!247E!;9E62@!1G6;E!E:4!]-!D41>!62@!+;4>E6!'8519<!
(34>8519!G41;EDM!%6!4L15E2D!C:1E!C1?!iMQ6!;J!E6!
@;>89H!:4>!G>41F!7>63!E:4!3;?85!89@;?E>DI!K422<!
OHW¶VMXVWVD\VKHFDQDGGPRPP\WRWKHDOUHDG\
269H!28?E!67!Y6G!E8E24?!76;9@!69!:4>!=4>D!83J>4??8=4!
>q?;3qW!E:4!3;2E8PE1249E4@!Q1E891!8?!19!15E>4??<!
?89H4><!@1954><!E424=8?869!J4>?69128ED<!71?:869!
@4?8H94><!J>6@;54>!19@!69!a4G>;1>D!//<!/00c!?:4!
12?6!G45134!1!36E:4>!E6!7>1E4>912!EC89?<!$334!
19@!Z1L8382819!Z;f8TM!K8E:!5:82@>49!19@!
KXVEDQG0DUF$QWKRQ\E\KHUVLGH-/R¶V
?44389H2D!2838E24??!?;554??²EC6!(QZ(!1C1>@?<!
?4=4>12!,>133D!(C1>@!963891E869?<!E:>44!
(34>8519!Z;?85!(C1>@?<!19@!E:4!692D!15E>4??!19@!
?89H4>!89!:8?E6>D!E6!:1=4!1!7823!19@!19!12G;3!1E!
9;3G4>!694!89!E:4!?134!C44F²:1?!41>94@!:4>!E:4!
WLWOHRIWKHµULFKHVWSHUVRQRI/DWLQ$PHULFDQ
GHVFHQWLQ+ROO\ZRRG¶E\³)RUEHV´!31H1T894!19@!
WKHµPRVWLQIOXHQWLDO+LVSDQLFHQWHUWDLQHULQ
$PHULFD¶E\³3HRSOHHQ(VSDxRO´!31H1T894M!!
K8E:!?6!3;5:!J6C4>!19@!8972;4954!89!Q1E896!19@!
969P/DWLQRFRPPXQLWLHVDOLNHPDQ\FDQ¶WKHOS
G;E!C69@4>!87!Q6J4T!8?<!89!715E<!;?89H!:4>!J6?8E869!
E6!31F4!1!J6?8E8=4!@8774>4954!89!E:4!C6>2@!6>!
VLPSO\³IDWWHQLQJKHUSRFNHWV´!
!B1=89H!122!:4>!15563J28?:349E?!?1742D!
?45;>4@!;9@4>!1!?;>42D!G4@[email protected]<!Q6J4T!:1?!
EHHQDFFXVHGRIEHLQJJXLOW\RISRVVHVVLQJ³GLYD.
EHKDYLRU´,QDUHFHQWDUWLFOHIRU³3HRSOH´!
31H1T894<!Q6J4T!C1?!1?F4@!1G6;E!:6C!?:4!7442?!
1G6;E!EHLQJFDOOHGD³GLYD´6KHVD\V³,NLQGRI
OLNHLW:H¶YHNLQGRI6C94@!8E!96CM!O;E!.!
FHUWDLQO\GRQ¶WOLNHDQG,¶YHQHYHUEHHQDSHUVRQ
ZKRKDVZKDWWKH\FDOOµGLYDEHKDYLRU¶ZKLFKLV
?634E:89H!E:4D!E>84@!E6!J89!69!34!76>!1!269H!
WLPH´6WLOOWKRVHRIXVZKRGRQ¶WSHUVRQDOO\
F96C!P("";.9,0G.2*(./'04TC!FDQ¶WUHDOO\EHVXUHRI
WKLVDQGDUHQ¶WZLOOLQJWRMXVWWDNHKHUZRUGIRULW
HLWKHU6RZKDWFDQZHGRWRGHEXQNWKLV³GLYD´
GHEDWHRQFHDQGIRUDOO":HOOLW¶VVLPSOHUHDOO\LI
C4!Y;?E!569?8@4>!E:4!715E?M!!
i499874>!Q6J4T!8?!694!67!E:4!E:>44!
@1;H:E4>?!67!+;4>E6!'8519!J1>49E?!,;1@12;J4!
'6@>rH;4T<!1!F89@4>H1>E49!E415:4><!19@!V1=8@!
/RSH]DFRPSXWHUVSHFLDOLVW$OWKRXJK/RSH]¶V
J1>49E?!94=4>!24E!:4>!6>!:4>!?8?E4>?!H6!C8E:6;E<!E:4D!
C4>4!96E!C412E:D!GD!19D!3419?<!19@!E:4D!12C1D?!
E1;H:E!E:48>!5:82@>49!E:1E!:1>@!C6>F!C1?!9454??1>D!
E6!G4!?;554??7;2!89!2874M!!(!24??69!E:1E!;9@6;GE4@2D!
?E;5F!Q6J4T!?4E!6;E!E6!J1D!76>!:4>!6C9!?89H89H!19@!
@19589H!24??69?!17E4>!H>1@;1E89H!7>63!:8H:!?5:662!
89!E:4!O>69LM!K:824!C6>F89H!89!1!24H12!677854<!!
Q6J4T!7891954@!@1954!521??4?!19@!J4>76>34@!
>6;E894?!89!Z19:1EE19!98H:E!52;G?M!.9!-NN0!17E4>!
?4=4>12!>4Y45E869?!19@!319D!?244J24??!98H:E?<!E:4!
\RXQJGDQFHU¶VKDUGZRUNILQDOO\SDLGRIIZKHQ
?:4!C1?!?4245E4@!89!1!91E869C8@4!563J4E8E869!E6!
1JJ41>!89!19!4J8?6@4!67!J0[.:5\.O38%M!!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
Q6J4T!1?!19!;9F96C9!@1954>!89!19!4J8?6@4!67!J0[.
:5\.O38%M!!
!
Q1E4>!E:1E!D41>!5134!:4>!78>?E!:8H:PJ>67824!Y6GW!
/RSH]ZDVD³IO\JLUO´IRUWKHWHOHYLVLRQFRPHG\
SURJUDP³!".-$#$"A.)0'0,´7KHVHHDUO\\HDUV
E>;2D!@4369?E>1E4!E:4!>4249E24??!@4E4>3891E869!
Q6J4T!J6??4??4?!19@!?49@?!19!89?J8>89H!34??1H4!
E6!D6;9H!J46J24!4=4>DC:4>4!E:1E<!C8E:!:1>@!
C6>F!19@!1!J6?8E8=4!1EE8E;@4<!19DE:89H!8?!
J6??8G24M!!%:4!8?!563349@4@!GD!319D!76>!
5>41E89H!:4>!6C9!6JJ6>E;98E84?!>1E:4>!E:19!G489H!
H8=49!19!41?D!G>41F!28F4!?4=4>12!6E:4>!;J!19@!
56389H!1>E8?E?!67!:4>!E834M!!
!
B4>!51>44>!J>6H>4??4@!69E6!E:4!G8H!
?5>449!C:4>4!?:4!41>94@!1!H>41E!@412!67!
>456H98E869!1?!19!15E>4??!89!1!241@89H!>624!76>!E:4!
G86H>1J:8512!7823!U('("3!F-NNh_M!!B4>!J6>E>1D12!
67!E:4!21E4!&4Y191!3;?85!?E1>!41>94@!:4>!19!
(QZ(!(C1>@!19@!1!,62@49!,26G4!963891E869!
IRU³%HVW$FWUHVVP!Z6E869!+85E;>4!Z;?8512!6>!
&RPHG\´!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
7KHPRYLH¶VSHUIRUPDQFHLQWKHER[RIILFHPDGH
:4>!E:4!78>?E!Q1E89!15E>4??!E6!41>9!R-!3822869!6>!
36>4!76>!1!7823!>624<!1!21>H4!?;3!67!3694D!C422!
@4?4>=4@!76>!E:4!6954!?E>;HH289H!@1954>M!%8954!
E:49!?:4!:1?!?E1>>4@!89!36=84?<!?;5:!1?!]B2.09.!
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
U$A*2.^-NNc_<!5*(.M(++$"A.W'3""(,!^/00-_<!:3$+.
$".:3"*3223"!^/00/_<!U*3''.M(.N3"4(Z!^/00]_<!
19@!:0"%2(,@$"@-31!^/00S_M!a6226C89H!:4>!
?;554??!89!B622DC66@<!Q6J4T!;E828T4@!:4>!?E1>!
J6C4>!E6!4LJ6?4!E:4!G>;E12!3;>@4>?!67!:;9@>4@?!67!
C6349!89!E:4!G6>@4>!58ED!67!i;p>4T<!Z4L856!89!E:4!
7823!/0,+(,201"!^/00b_M!%:4!>4548=4@!E:4!(>E8?E?!
76>!(394?ED!.9E4>91E86912!1C1>@!89!
15F96C24@H349E!67!:4>!C6>F!1?!J>6@;54>!19@!?E1>!
89!E:4!7823M!&:4!7823!12?6!41>94@!:4>!?J45812!
>456H98E869!19@!H>1E8E;@4!7>63!";4?E>1?!B8Y1?!@4!
'4H>4?6!1!)1?1!(M)M!^nZ1D!*;>!V1;H:E4>?!'4E;>9!
B634<!)8=82!(??6581E869n_<!19!6>H198T1E869!
563J>8?4@!67!36E:4>?!19@!7138284?!67!E:4!C6349!
3;>@4>4@!89!i;p>4TM!!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
Q6J4T!C8E:!19!15E>4??!J6>E>1D89H!1!C6319!7>63!i;1>4T<!
Z4L856!89!1!?5494!7>63!E:4!7823!/0,+(,201"<!
!
Q6J4T!12?6!:1?!31@4!:4>!31>F!1?!1!
3;?85819!C8E:!E:4!>4241?4!67!:4>!@4G;E!?E;@86!
DOEXP³2QWKH´^-NNN_!76226C4@!GD!1!?4569@!
DOEXP³-/R´!^/00-_M!O6E:!12G;3?!C4>4!
56334>58122D!?;554??7;2<!C8E:!E:4!21EE4>!?42289H!
48H:E!3822869!56J84?!C6>2@C8@4!19@!@4G;E89H!1E!
9;3G4>!694!69!E:4!/$''&03,+!³P.20.2*3.-@][Q.
7KH5HPL[HV´!^/00/_!G45134!:4>!?4569@!
569?45;E8=4!12G;3!E6!@4G;E!1E!9;3G4>!694!69!E:4!
/$''&03,+!/00M!a8=4!?E;@86!12G;3?!C6;2@!
76226C²!³7KLV,V0H7KHQ´!^/00/_<!
³5HELUWK´!³)0G0.6G3.B"3.
0XMHU´!³%UDYH´^/00h_<!19@!E:4!>4549E!
³/RYH"´!^/0--_M!!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!!
!
!
!
!
&
!%#2"#>(.&%#&G*:(&HJ&
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!/0!!
!%#2"#>(.&1/%=&G*:(&HK&
&
B4>!569E>8G;E869?!E6!3;?85!:1=4!41>94@!:4>!1!H>41E!
@412!67!>456H98E869<!8952;@89H!?4=4>12!,>133D!
(C1>@!963891E869?<!E:>44!(34>8519!Z;?85!
(C1>@?<!19@!/$''&03,+!>19F4@!:4>!1?!E:4!/hE:!
(>E8?E!67!E:4!/000?!@451@4M!
&
&
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
a>63!E:4!247E!'19@D!i15F?69<!i499874>!Q6J4T<!19@!
%E4=49!&D24>!?4>=89H!1?!Y;@H4?!69!?41?69!-0!67!
6G(,$43".!+0'<.
!
!
K8E:!122!67!:4>!4LE49?8=4!4LJ4>84954!1?!1!
?89H4>!19@!@1954><!Q6J4T!F96C?!122!E66!C422!Y;?E!
:6C!@87785;2E!8E!8?!E6!31F4!8E!89!E:4!89@;?E>D!1?!?:4!
@412E!C8E:!:4>!6C9!E>6;G24?!89!H4EE89H!:4>!78>?E!>412!
G>41FM!&:8?!31@4!:4>!1!28F42D!5:6854!76>!
³$PHULFDQ,GRO´J>6@;54>?!21?E!D41>!C:49!E:4D!
C4>4!:;9E89H!76>!1!94C!Y;@H4!76226C89H!E:4!
@4J1>E;>4!67!$2249!V4,494>4?M!B1=89H!?4>=4@!1?!1!
349E6>!69!E:4!?:6C!?41?69?!J>86><!Q6J4T!@458@4@!
E6!Y689!E:4!Y;@H89H!J1942!?6!E:1E!?:4!56;2@!?:1>4!
KHUNQRZOHGJHZLWKRWKHUDVSLULQJDUWLVWV,W¶VQR
?45>4E<!:6C4=4><!E:1E!?634!C69@4>4@!87!?8H989H!;J!
76>!E:4!?:6C!C1?!?634!524=4>!J26D!E6!31F4!:4>!
C1D!G15F!89E6!E:4!2834!28H:EM!!(9@!J>86>!E6!67785812!
56978>31E869<!?634!4=49!?J45;21E4@!E:1E!Q6J4T!
ZRXOGQ¶WHQGXSEHLQJDMXGJHGXHWR³RXWUDJHRXV
GHPDQGV´7KHODWWHUDFFXVDWLRQZDVVRRQSXWWR
UHVWZKHQ³,GRO´!J>6@;54><!"8H42!QDE:H64<!
UHVSRQGHGE\VD\LQJ³>-HQQLIHU@LVLQQRZD\D
GLYD,¶YHZRUNHGZLWKKHURQTXLWHDIHZ
6551?869?!19@!.!:1=4!94=4>!D4E!?449!:4>!G4!1!
GLYD´$VIRUWKHDFFXVDWLRQRIXVLQJWKHVKRZDVD
SODWIRUPWRUHYLYH-/R¶VFDUHHUPDQ\EHOLHYH
WKDW¶VLUUHOHYDQWWRZKDW¶VUHDOO\LPSRUWDQWZKLFK
8?!:42J89H!D6;9H<!?E>;HH289H!1>E8?E?!>4128T4!E:48>!
7;22!J6E49E812!19@!?:4!8?!@689H!Y;?E!E:1EM!K44F!17E4>!
C44F!Q6J4T!6774>?!341989H7;2!1@=854!E6!E:4!
563J4E8E6>?!1?!?:4!>4=412?!122!E:4!E>85F?!?:4!:1?!
3191H4@!E6!H1>94>!;J!:4>!?4d;4954@!?244=4?!6=4>!
E:4!D41>?!1?!19!1>E8?EM!!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
i499874>!Q6J4T!=8?8E?!E:4!&449!Q6;9H4!1E!):82@>49?!
B6?J8E12!Q6?!(9H424?!69!i;94!]<!/0-0M!
!
!
(?8@4!7>63!:4>!51>44>!89!49E4>E189349E<!
Q6J4T!12?6!1@=651E4?!76>!:;319!>8H:E?<!
=155891E869?<!19@!8?!19!1=8@!?;JJ6>E4>!67!
):82@>49`?!B6?J8E12!Q6?!(9H424?M!!.9!569Y;95E869!
C8E:!%6;9@?!67!+4>E;??8?!19@!Z1>5:!67!V834?<!
?:4!?J>41@?!1C1>494??!76>!E:4!C:66J89H!56;H:!
@8?41?4!19@!4956;>1H4?!1@;2E!=155891E869?!E6!
J>4=49E!E:4!?J>41@!67!@8?41?4!E6!89719E?M!.9!
%4JE43G4>!/00]!Q6J4T!C1?!J>4?49E4@!C8E:!E:4!
):82@>49`?!B;3198E1>819!(C1>@!76>!:4>!
569E>8G;E869!E6!E:8?!51;?4!1E!E:4!:6?J8E12`?!
891;H;>12!"65:4!@4!"8f6?!H121M!%8954!E:49!
Q6J4T!:1?!1EE49@4@!E:4!H121!D41>2D!19@!
569E89;4?!E6!31F4!7>4d;49E!=8?8E?!E6!E:4!:6?J8E12M!
.9!/00c!E:4!:;3198E1>819!C1?!89=62=4@!89!E:4!
"1;E851!Z128G;!&>81E:269!G49478E89H!E:4!
:6?J8E12M!&:4!76226C89H!D41>!?:4!4?E1G28?:4@!&:4!
Z1>8G42!a6;9@1E869!89!19!4776>E!E6!J>6=8@4!
7;>E:4>!?;JJ6>E!76>!E:4!:6?J8E12!19@!G4D69@!E:1E!
E6!83J>6=4!:412E:!51>4!89E4>91E869122DM!!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
76>!5:19H4M!(!d;6E4!7>63!1!>4549E!89E4>=84C!C8E:!
³3HRSOHHQ(VSDxRO´!31H1T894!E>;2D!51JE;>4?!
/RSH]¶VLGHRORJ\DQGVHUYHVDVDSHUIHFWFORVLQJ
WRWKLVORQJGUDZQRXW³GLYD´GHEDWH6KHVD\V
³%HLQJDQH[DPSOHWRRWKHUVLVDELJSDUWRIP\
C6>FM!.E!4L58E4?!34!E6!E:89F!E:1E!.!56;2@!G4!51J1G24!
67!5:19H89H!6J89869?<!6>!67!31F89H!J46J24!21;H:!
6>!5>DM!.E`?!1!G41;E87;2!7154E!67!E:4!C6>F!E:1E!s.t!
GR´6RWKHUH\RXJRVWUDLJKWIURP/RSH]KHUVHOI
WKDWZKDW¶VUHDOO\LPSRUWDQWLVPDNLQJDGLIIHUHQFH
89!E:4!C6>2@!GD!?4EE89H!19!4L13J24!E:1E!?J41F?!E6!
SHRSOH¶VHPRWLRQVFKDOOHQJHVWKHLURSLQLRQVDQG
;2E831E42D!G>89H?!1G6;E!J6?8E8=4!5:19H4M!
&:>6;H:6;E!:4>!51>44>!i499874>!Q6J4T!:1?!19@!
569E89;4?!E6!31F4!E:1E!@8774>4954g!
"65:4!@4!"896?!,121<!G49478E89H!):82@>49?!B6?J8E12!
Q6?!(9H424?MO4=4>2D!B82E69!B6E42<!O4=4>2D!B822?<!
)(M*5E6G4>!h<!/00bM!
!
6RZKDW¶VQH[WIRUWKH/DWLQDZRQGHU
C6319!?4489H!1?!8E!?443?!?:4!8?!51J1G24!67!
@689H!1236?E!19DE:89HI!.7!D6;!C4>4!4LJ45E89H!
196E:4>!76;>PD41>!:81E;?<!C422!H;4??!1H189<!
G451;?4!69!(J>82!/h!Q6J4T!C8E:!:;?G19@!Z1>5!
(9E:69D!19@!J>6@;54>!%8369!a;224>!1996;954@!
E:1E!E:4D!1>4!89!E:4!C6>F?!67!5>41E89H!1!94C!
UHDOLW\VKRZWLWOHG³4¶9LYD7KH&KRVHQ´7KH
J>438?4!67!E:4!?:6C!8?!76>!E:4!56;J24!E6!E>1=42!
E:>6;H:6;E!/-!56;9E>84?!89!?41>5:!67!E:4!G4?E!
J4>76>34>?!89!Q1E89!3;?85<!@1954<!19@!6E:4>!1>E?!
89!19!4776>E!E6!?:6C51?4!E:4!=1?E!E1249E!D4E!E6!G4!
@8?56=4>4@!89!E:4?4!J2154?M!%:4!?1D?!E:4!?:6C!
ZLOOJR³WRSODFHVZKHUHDOORIWKLVWDOHQWOLYHV
DQGZRXOGQ
WKDYHRWKHUZLVHEHHQGLVFRYHUHG´
J>6=8@89H!1!J21E76>3!E6!E:6?4!C:6!38H:E!96E!
:1=4!6E:4>C8?4!:1@!E:4!6JJ6>E;98ED!E6!?:1>4!E:48>!
1>E!C8E:!E:4!C6>2@M!Q6J4T!G4284=4?!E:4!?:6C!C822!
G4!>4=62;E8691>D!76>!E:4!H26G12!49E4>E189349E!
LQGXVWU\VHHLQJDV³WKH/DWLQFXOWXUHLVDWDSHVWU\
E:1E!8?!>85:!89!J1??869<!E>1@8E869!19@!
DUWLVWU\´!!Z19D!J>18?4!iMQ6!76>!5>41E89H!1!?:6C!
E:1E!C822!;9@6;GE4@2D!?:4@!1!J6?8E8=4!28H:E!69!
Q1E89!5;2E;>4g!
(22!89!122<!i499874>!Q6J4T!31D!G4!
51J8E128T89H!3694E1>82D!69!:4>!51>44>!89!
B622DC66@<!G;E!122!E:4!C:824!?:4!8?!89?J8>89H!
D6;9H!J46J24!15>6??!E:4!H26G4<!?4>=89H!1?!19!
1=8@!:;3198E1>819<!19@!G>89H89H!122!E:4!G41;ED!67!
Q1E89!5;2E;>4!E6!E:4!76>47>69E!67!H26G12!
HQWHUWDLQPHQW$QGOHW¶VIDFHLWWKHUHDUHVRIHZ
5424G>8E84?!89!:4>!J6?8E869!E:1E!H8=4!G15F!E6!E:4!
5633;98ED!89!E:4!C1D!?:4!@64?!19@!4=49!74C4>!
C:6!@6!?6!C8E:!H49;894!563J1??869!19@!@4?8>4!!
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!/-!!
PQRQ(D'T'()'/2,*&;2'(
9'&%3C"'U#(
OD\!i;19!Q6J4T!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
(J>82!/9@<!/0-0<E:4!?E>69H4?E!
41>E:d;1F4!?8954!-NN/!:8E?!E:4!O1Y1!
)12876>981!J4989?;21M!&:4!41>E:d;1F4!
43191E4@!7>63!8E?!4J8549E4>!1!74C!3824?!
6;E?8@4!67!E:4!E6C9!67!,;1@12;J4![85E6>81<!
O1Y1!)12876>981<!ZqL856M!&:4!hM/!31H98E;@4!
41>E:d;1F4!:8E!E:4!;9?;?J45E89H!1>41!69!
(DVWHUDQGLQWHUUXSWHGSHRSOH¶VFHOHEUDWLRQV
&:8?!E>436>!C1?!?6!?E>69H!E:1E!8E!C1?!742E!1?!
71>!1C1D!1?!"4=1@1M!.9!Z4L85128<!E:4!
G8HH4?E!58ED!526?4?E!E6!E:4!4J8549E4><!1!?E1E4!
67!434>H495D!C1?!@4521>4@!1?!1!>4?;2E!67!E:4!
PDVVLYHTXDNH,QWKHDUWLFOH³0DVVLYH
4XDNHKLWV%DMD&DOLIRUQLD´%LOO+D\HV
VWDWHV³%XLOGLQJVLQ0H[LFDOLVZD\HGEDFN
19@!76>E:!76>!1!389;E4!19@!1!:127!1?!J46J24!
UDFHGWRRSHQJURXQG´7KHUHZHUHUHSRUWV
E:1E!J46J24!C4>4!247E!C8E:6;E!J6C4>!
E:>6;H:6;E!E:4!>4H869!76>!:6;>?!17E4>!E:4!
d;1F4!:8EM!.9!E:4!?31224>!E6C9?!6;E?8@4!E:4!
58ED<!J46J24!>4J6>E4@!:634?!51=89H!89<!89!E:4!
17E4>!31E:!67!E:4!d;1F4W!19@!;976>E;91E42D!
EC6!28=4?!C4>4!26?E!17E4>!?;5:!:634?!
56221J?4@!69!E:43M!!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
.
.
6.+01"(+.80%2.$".3.,(%$+("2$3'.3,(3.4B2%.
('(42,$4$2;.20.2*(."($A*&0,*00+.
!
!
!
&:4!Z4L8519!H6=4>9349E!d;85F2D!
>4?J69@4@!E6!E:4!?E1E4!67!434>H495D!GD!
36G828T89H!E>66J?!E6!@8?E>8G;E4!18@!E6!E:4!
E:6;?19@?!17745E4@!GD!E:4!E>436>M!
!
!
(2E:6;H:!Z4L8519!67785812?!?1D!E:1E!
18@!C1?!G489H!@8?E>8G;E4@<!E:4!715E!8?!E:1E!8E!
ZDVVLPSO\QRWWUXH,Q6DQGUD2QWLYHURV¶
³$LGIRU%DMD&DOLIRUQLD´VKHVWDWHV³0XFK
67!E:4!18@!E:1E!1>>8=4@!89!E:4!17745E4@!>4H869!
C1?!96E!1@4d;1E4!19@!?;7785849E!E6!
DFFRPPRGDWHVRPDQ\SHRSOH´6KHJRHV
69!E6!?1D!E:1E!319D!J46J24!>4J6>E4@!E:4!215F!
67!766@!19@!C1E4>!H8=49!GD!E:4!H6=4>9349E!
E6!E43J6>1>82D!@8?J2154@!58E8T49?!C:6?4!
:634?!C4>4!17745E4@!GD!E:4!d;1F4M!.9@44@!
3;5:!67!E:4!766@!19@!G6EE24@!C1E4>!E:1E!
1>>8=4@!89!E:4!1>41!C1?!96E!7>63!E:4!
Z4L8519!,6=4>9349E!G;E!7>63!a1382D!
343G4>?!28=89H!89!E:4!#M%M!(2E:6;H:!E:8?!8?!
E>;4!67!71382D!343G4>?<!E:4!#M%M!
H6=4>9349E!8E?427!@8@!96E!J>6=8@4!3;5:!18@!
76>!E:4!@8?1?E4>M!.9!E:4!C44F?!E:1E!76226C4@<!
E:4!d;1F4!C49E!36?E2D!;996E854@!GD!#M%M!
67785812?!4=49!E:6;H:!E:4!4=49E!:1JJ494@!89!
526?4!J>6L838ED!E6!E:4!#M%MPZqL856!G6>@4>M!
.9!715E<!E:4!G6>@4>!58ED!67!)124L856!C1?!
H>41E2D!17745E4@!GD!E:8?!E>436>!1?!C422<!G;E!
18@!?E822!@8@!96E!789@!8E?!C1D!?6;E:!67!E:4!
G6>@4>M!!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
6.93G$';.(^3G$"(%.3.*BA(.4,34T.$".3.,03+.
1*$4*.%*01%.2*(.%(#(,$2;.09.2*(.(3,2*XB3T(.
!
!
7KH0H[LFDQJRYHUQPHQW¶VVORZ
J154@!4776>E!E6!?49@!18@!E6!E:4!>4H869!31@4!
E:4!17E4>31E:!67!E:4!4=49E!4=49!C6>?4M!$=49!
96C!6=4>!1!D41>!21E4><!>42847!4776>E?!1>4!?E822!
VORZWREXLOGXSWKHUHJLRQRQFHPRUH³7KH
H6=4>9349E!E62@!;?!E:4D!C6;2@!H8=4!;?!
31E4>812!76>!1!94C!:634!87!C4!:1@!26?E!8E!89!
WKHHDUWKTXDNHEXWWKH\VWLOOKDYHQ¶W
GHOLYHUHGLW´VDLG/HWLFLD5RGULJXH]D
>4?8@49E!67!);51J1:!.9@8H491<!1!?3122!E6C9!
DPLOHIURPWKHHSLFHQWHU³7KHIRRGWKH\
J>6=8@4@!;?!C1?!96E!?;7785849E!76>!;?<!E:19F!
,6@!3D!71382D!7>63!E:4!#M%M!G>6;H:E!?6!
PDQ\VXSSOLHVIRUXVLWVDYHGRXUOLYHV´!
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
'6@>8H;4T!?E1E4@M!Z19D!1556;9E?!28F4!E:8?!
694!:1=4!?;>7154@!E:>6;H:6;E!E:4!>4H869<!
4?J458122D!89!E:4!?3122!E6C9?!6;E?8@4!67!
Z4L85128!C:4>4!E:4!J6J;21E869!8?!67!1!26C4>!
895634!E:19!89!E:4!58EDM!Z19D!:634?!:1=4!
G449!1G19@694@!17E4>!E:4D!C4>4!@4434@!
;9?E1G24!E6!28=4!89M!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
&6!E:8?!@1D<!E:4!?E>;HH24!67!28=89H!89!
E:8?!1>41!17745E4@!?6!3;5:!GD!E:4!41>E:d;1F4!
:1?!E1F49!1!E622!69!E:4!J6J;21E869M!Z19D!:1=4!
?8954!36=4@!C8E:!71382D!343G4>?!1C1D!7>63!
E:4!>4H869!6>!1>4!?E822!C8E:6;E!:634?M!$=49!1!
D41>!21E4><!6;>!C6>2@!E:1E!C4!J>8@4!6;>?42=4?!
76>!G489H!?6!1@=1954@!19@!58=828T4@<!51996E!
:42J!1!>4H869!E:1E!C1?!G1?85122D!>4@;54@!E6!
>;GG24!E:1E!8?!?6!526?4!E6!6;>!6C9!G6>@4>M!
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!//!!
)/'$$(E282$2*;(62%32;()'/2,*&;2'(
ODM!i;19!Q6J4T!
!
!
&:>6;H:6;E!E:4!C6>2@!19@!4?J458122D!89!
E:4!#98E4@!%E1E4?<!C4!?44!@8=8?869!67!521??!C8E:89!
5633;98E84?M!!&:4?4!521??!@8=8?869?!31D!96E!G4!
89E49E86912!G;E!E:4D!1>4!5241>2D!?449M!Z19D!1>H;4!
E:1E!E:8?!655;>?!G451;?4!67!563369!5;2E;>12!
J>15E854?!6>!?83821>8E84?!89!895634M!(!H66@!
4L13J24!67!E:8?!8?!89!3D!:634E6C9!67!)615:4221<!
)12876>981M!.E!8?!2651E4@!89!1!=1224D!1G6;E!19!:6;>!
41?E!67!'8=4>?8@4<!19@!8?!?;>>6;9@4@!GD!6E:4>!58E84?!
C8E:89!E:4!=1224DM!(?!.!H>4C!;J!89!E:8?!5633;98ED<!
.!C8E94??4@!E:4!6G=86;?!@8774>4954?!89!4E:9858ED!
19@!789195812!C6>E:M!&6!?634!?5:621>?<!E:8?!31D!
G4!1!J4>745E!36@42!67!521??!@8=8?869!89!)12876>981M!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
.
.
.
.
.
.
6.4*3,2.2*32.%*01%.+$%2,$&B2$0".09.4'3%%.3440,+$"A.
20.9$"3"4$3'.$"40G(.3"+.(+B432$0".
!
!
!
ZD!J1>49E?!28=4!89!E:4!41?E!49@!67!E:4!
=1224D!89!E:4!58ED!67!)615:4221<!C:85:!1E!1!H21954!
8?!1!@4549E!58ED!C8E:!9854!:6;?4?M!(E!E:4!?134!
WLPHLWLVQ¶WDOX[XULRXVFRPPXQLW\EXWLWLV
1@4d;1E4!76>!1!9854!28=1G24!5633;98EDM!(?!D6;!
J>6H>4??!71>E:4>!41?E!E:6;H:<!D6;!789@!E:4!>;>12!
J1>E!67!E:4!=1224D<!C:85:!8?!31@4!;J!67!E:4!58E84?!
67!&:4>312!19@!Z4551M!.9!E:4?4!5633;98E84?!D6;!
?44!1!36>4!:;3G24!19@!24??!C412E:D!5633;98EDM!
Z19D!67!E:4!J46J24!E:1E!28=4!89!E:8?!>4H869!1>4!67!
C6>F89HP521??!6>8H89!C:6!31F4!E:48>!28=89H!7>63!
C6>F!89!E:4!1H>85;2E;>12!7842@?M!(236?E!122!67!E:4!
J46J24!C:6!28=4!89!E:4?4!5633;98E84?!1>4!Q1E896?!
C:6!12?6!C6>F!89!1H>85;2E;>4<!C:4>4!1!26E!67!E:4!
YDOOH\¶VHFRQRPLFZHDOWKLVSURGXFHG!
!
*9!E:4!6E:4>!:19@<!1?!D6;!J>6H>4??!
71>E:4>!E6!E:4!C4?E!C8E:89!E:4!=1224D!D6;!789@!E:4!
58E84?!?;5:!1?!Q1!m;89E1<!+123!V4?4>E<!+123!
%J>89H?<!19@!'195:6!Z8>1H4<!C:85:!1>4!
J>4@638919E2D!C412E:84>!5633;98E84?M!Z19D!67!
E:4?4!5633;98E84?!1>4!31@4!;J!67!;JJ4>!38@@24!
521??!)1;51?819!89@8=8@;12?!C:6!31F4!E:48>!28=89H!!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
1?!C:8E4P56221>!43J26D44?M!+123!%J>89H?<!89!715E<!
8?!1!31Y6>!:;G!67!E6;>8?3!89!%6;E:4>9!)12876>981!
HVSHFLDOO\LQWKHZLQWHUZKHQ³VQRZELUGV´
J46J24!C:6!:1=4!:634?!89!E:4!=1224D<!5634!@6C9!
IURPQRUWKHUQUHJLRQVWRHVFDSHWKHVQRZ³,KDYH
OLYHGLQWKHYDOOH\IRU\HDUV´VDLG$QWRQLR
*DUFLDDUHVLGHQWRI&RDFKHOOD³,KDYHZRUNHGLQ
1!:6E42!89!+123!%J>89H?!76>!319D!D41>?!19@!.!:1=4!
VHHQWKHFODVVGLYLVLRQVILUVWKDQG´*DUFLDJRHVRQ
E6!?1D!E:1E!1!26E!67!J46J24!7>63!E:4!41?E!49@!67!E:4!
=1224D!C6>F!89!E:4!C412E:84>!58E84?!89!E:4!=1224D!
DQGHVVHQWLDOO\IRU&DXFDVLDQHPSOR\HUV³0DQ\
67!E:4!J46J24!7>63!E:4!41?E!?8@4!67!E:4!=1224D!
5633;E4!E6!+123!%J>89H?!6>!6E:4>!58E84?!19@!C6>F!
76>!C412E:84>!>4?8@49E?!C:6!89!36?E!51?4?!1>4!
&DXFDVLDQ´VWDWHG*DUFLDZKRNQRZVWKLVDOOWRR
C422M!
!
(96E:4>!H>41E!715E6>!E:1E!249@?!24H8E8315D!
E6!E:8?!E:46>D!67!521??!@8=8?869!8?!E:1E!J46J24!C19E!
E6!28=4!89!1!5633;98ED!E:1E!E:4D!519!>421E4!E66M!
Z19D!Q1E896?!C19E!E6!28=4!89!1!5633;98ED!C:4>4!
E:4D!519!7442!56376>E1G24!J>15E8589H!E:48>!5;2E;>4!
19@!E:8?!8?!E>;4!76>!6E:4>!4E:985!H>6;J?!1?!C422M!.9!
>4128ED<!C4!1>4!E:4!>41?69!C:D!C4!G4H89!E6!
?4H>4H1E4!6;>?42=4?!89E6!@8774>49E!5633;98E84?M!
7KHUHLVQRRIILFLDOODZWKDWVWDWHVWKLVEXWLW¶V
1236?E!19!;9C>8EE49!>;24!E:1E!?1D?!E:1E!694!C822!
?4EE24!@6C9!C8E:!J46J24!C:6!E:4D!519!>421E4!E66M!
O;E!1?!E834!J1??4?<!E:8?!96E869!67!521??!@8=8?869!8?!
G489H!J>6=49!C>69H!1?!36>4!19@!36>4!Q1E896?!1>4!
J;>?;89H!:8H:4>!4@;51E869<!C:85:!241@?!E6!G4EE4>!
51>44>?!19@!E:;?!J>6=8@4?!36>4!@8=4>?8ED!C8E:89!
E:4!49E8>4!=1224D!1?!E:4D!G4H89!E6!36=4!89E6!E:4!
C412E:84>!5633;98E84?M!
!
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
M3#(7;'$'>2O(7(H2$%*&0(*,(1#$#'&.3(
OD!i1=84>!(31D1!
!
!!!!&:4!21E4?E!94C?!67!E:4!(91?1T8!J46J24<!36>4!
5633692D!F96C9!1?!E:4!(954?E>12!+;4G26!J46J24<!
?E1>E4@!1JJ41>89H!69!E:4!94C?!GD!E:4!49@!67!/0-0M!
%4=4>12!34@81!6;E24E?!521834@!E:1E<!6954!1H189<!8E!
8?!?;HH4?E4@!GD!>4?41>5:4>?!E:1E!E:4!(91?1T8!
J46J24!C4>4!51998G12?M!&:8?<!@;4!E6!19!
1>5:4626H8512!4L51=1E869!569@;5E4@!89!/00S<!
E:6;?19@?!67!G694!7>1H349E?!C4>4!@8?56=4>4@!
1>6;9@!E:4!1>41!67!V;>19H6<!)626>1@6M!(7E4>!
?E;@D89H!E:4!G694!7>1H349E?!76>3!E:4!4L51=1E869<!
E:4!4=8@4954!8?!@8?5;??4@W!5>;?:4@!24H!G694?<!
3;E821E4@!:;319!>43189?<!E:4!G>41F89H!19@!
5;EE89H!67!724?:!1?!C422!J>6=4!566F89H!19@!
J;2=4>8T89H!C1?!76;9@<!122!J689E89H!E6C1>@?!
51998G128?3M!
!!!!!&:4!(91?1T8!C4>4!19!89@8H496;?!H>6;J!67!
J46J24!C:6!28=4@!1E!C:1E!8?!96C!F96C9!1?!E:4!
76;>!56>94>?<!C:85:!569?8?E?!67!?6;E:4>9!)626>1@6<!
96>E:C4?E!"4C!Z4L856<!?6;E:4>9!#E1:<!19@!
96>E:4>9!(>8T691M!&:4!(954?E>12!+;4G26!J46J24!
1>4!36?E2D!F96C9!76>!E:48>!1>5:8E45E;>4!19@!E:48>!
H>41E!:6;?4?M!,>41E!:6;?4?!C4>4!563J24L4?!E:1E!
C4>4!31@4!6;E!67!?E694<!1@6G4<!19@!3;@W!?634!
:1=89H!;J!E6!h00!>663?M!V4?549@19E?!67!E:4!
(91?1T8!1>4!E:4!36@4>9P@1D!89@8H496;?!J46J24!67!
E:4!B6J8!19@!E:4!l;98M!a6>!36?E!J46J24<!E:4!
(91?1T8!1>4!F96C9!1?!J41547;2!J46J24!C:6!
:;9E4@<!H1E:4>4@<!19@!:1@!131T89H!1>5:8E45E;>12!
1G828E84?M!!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
(
(
(((((V;4!E6!E:4!J628E8512!366@!67!E:4!-Nb0?!19@!h0?<!
E:4!(91?1T8!G45134!F96C!1?!E:4!H>6;J!67!J46J24!
C:6!C4>4!563J24E42D!J41547;2M!Q1E4><!@;>89H!E:4!
¶VDUFKHRORJLFDOILQGLQJVIRXQGWKH$QDVD]L
1?!1!96>312D!=86249E!5;2E;>4M!&:4!3189!=84C!67!E:4!
(91?1T8!5:19H4@!694!@1D!89!E:4!21E4!-NN0?!C:49!
94C!4=8@4954!67!51998G128?3!C1?!76;9@!89!1!
56J>628E4!E:1E!G4269H4@!E6!19!(954?E>12!+;4G26!
J4>?69M!):>8?ED!&;>94>!..!:1@!>4548=4@!1!56J>628E4!
7>63!19!4L51=1E869!?8E4!1E!)6CG6D!K1?:<!#E1:M!
(7E4>!1912DT89H!E:4!56J>628E4!&;>94>!..!76;9@!
E>154?!67!:;319!3D6H26G89P!J>667!E:1E!694!J4>?69!
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!/A!!
!
4=8@4954<!:4!@8@!96E!:4?8E1E4!E6!56952;@4!E:1E!122!
!E:4!(954?E>12!+;4G26!J46J24!C4>4!51998G12?!19@!
!
E:1E!E:4D!1E4!415:!6E:4>!@;4!E6!?4=4>4!52831E4!
!
569@8E869?!19@!@>6;H:EM!&;>94>!..!@8@!96E!E1F4!19D!
!
!
!!
E834!E6!31F4!?;>4!:8?!E:46>D!C1?!J>458?4!19@!
155;>1E4W!:4!@8@!96E!?44F!19D!6E:4>!J>674??86912!
RSLQLRQDQGDOVRFODLPHGWREH³«WKHJX\ZKR
EURXJKWGRZQWKH$QDVD]L´!
!!!!!j1>2!iM!'489:1>@!8?!19!1>5:4626H8?E!7>63!E:4!
#98=4>?8ED!67!"4G>1?F1!E:1E!:1?!G449!?E;@D89H!E:4!
@84E?!67!E:4!(91?1T8!76>!?4=4>12!D41>?!E>6;H:!E:4!
?E;@D!67!56J>628E4?!6>!@>84@!:;319!7454?M!'489:1>@!
:1?!?E;@84@!6=4>!S00!56J>628E4?!7>63!E:4!(954?E>12!
+;4G26!J46J24!19@!:4!1@38E?!E:1E!E:4!694!7>63!
)6CG6D!K1?:!266F?!Y;?E!28F4!19D!6E:4>M!(7E4>!
?E;@D89H!E:4!56J>628E4<!'489:1>@!56952;@4?!E:1E!
E:4!56J>628E4!@64?!96E!G4269H!E6!1!EDJ8512!(91?1T8!
J4>?69M!%669!17E4>!'489:1>@!241=4?!E:4!56;9E>D!
@;4!E6!C6>F!>41?69?!19@!E:4!56J>628E4!8?!
E>19?74>>4@!E6!&;>94>!..!1E!1!21G!89!)626>1@6M!*954!
7XUQHU¶VWKHRU\JRWWRWKHPHGLD5HLQKDUGIRXQG
RXWDERXWLWDQGIHOWVXUSULVHGDERXW7XUQHU¶V
56952;?869?M!V;4!E6!:8?!=1?E!F96C24@H4!1G6;E!E:4!
(954?E>12!+;4G26!J46J24<!'489:1>@!56;2@!96E!
;9@4>?E19@!:6C!694!56J>628E4!519!@458@4!E:4!J1?E!
E>18E?!67!1!5;2E;>4M!(7E4>!?E;@D89H!36>4!E:19!S00!
56J>628E4?<!'489:1>@!F94C!E:1E!E:4!@84E!67!E:4!
(91?1T8!J46J24!C1?!71>!7>63!E:4!694!67!51998G12?<!
RUHYHQFDUQLYRURXV7KH$QFHVWUDO3HRSOH¶VGLHW
C1?!J>831>82D!G1?4@!69!:4>G?<!E:4!(91?1T8!C4>4!
21>H42D!=4H4E1>819M!(556>@89H!E6!'489:1>@<!E:4!
56J>628E4!?:6C89H!51998G128?3!@8@!96E!G4269H!E6!
DQ$QDVD]LWKHFRSUROLWH¶VVKRZQGLHWGLGQRW
31E5:!E6!E:6?4!67!E:4!(954?E>12!+;4G26!J46J24M!
!
!
!
!!!!!&:4!1954?E>12!J;4G26!J46J24<!28F4!19D!6E:4>!
5;2E;>4<!C4>4!:;319P!96E:89H!36>4!96E:89H!24??M!
.E!8?!4??49E812!76>!>4?41>5:4>?!19@!E:4!J;G285!E6!
?44!E:4!(91?1T8!1?!19D!6E:4>!89@8H496;?!E>8G4<!
266F89H!1E!E:43!C8E:6;E!19D!J>4Y;@854!6>!
?E4>46EDJ4M!&:4!(91?1T8!C4>4!H>41E!J46J24<!C:6!
28=4@!89!1!=4>D!?4=4>4!E4>>189M!&:4D<!28F4!19D!
6E:4>!E>8G4<!:1@!1!5;2E;>4!E:1E!:1@!>8E;12<!
5;?E63?<!19@!G42847?M!(>5:4626H8?E?!:1=4!E:4!
@;ED!E6!J>4?49E!E:48>!>4?41>5:!19@!789@89H?!89!E:4!
36?E!155;>1E4!19@!1@4d;1E4!C1DM!.E!8?!4??49E812!
76>!?5:621>?!E6!51>>D!C8E:!E:43!E:4!>4?J69?8G828ED!
67!E:4!J1?E<!19@!@6!4=4>DE:89H!89!E:48>!J6C4>!E6!
>45>41E4!8E!1?!J>458?42D!19@!715E;12!1?!J6??8G24M!.E!
8?!;99454??1>D!19@!94H28H49E!76>!19!1>5:4626H8?E!
E6!5634!E6!56952;?869?!E:1E!38H:E!21G42!1!5;2E;>4!
1?!51998G12?!C8E:6;E!E:4!9454??1>D!F96C24@H4M!
,Q7XUQHU¶VFDVHLWLVFOHDUWKDWIRURQHUHDVRQRU
196E:4><!:4!@458@4@!E6!Y;3J!E6!E:4!56952;?869!67!
E:4!(91?1T8!J46J24!1?!51998G12?!GD!563J24E42D!
LJQRULQJ5HLQKDUG¶VH[SHUWLVHDERXWWKH
56J>628E4M!
!!!!!
!!!!!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!!!!!$=49!E:6;H:!E:4!8@41!67!51998G128?3!1369H!
E:4!(91?1T8!8?!?E822!G489H!?E;@84@<!8E!8?!5241>!E:1E!
E:4!J4>?69!C:6!24@!E:4!4L51=1E869?!1E!'8@H4?!
O1?89<!:1?!E1F49!E:4!E1?F!67!@458J:4>89H!E:4!G694!
7>1H349E?!=4>D!?4>86;?2DM!'8@H4!O1?89!C1?!
IRXQGLQZKLOH3RWWHU¶VUHVXOWVDERXWWKH
4L51=1E869?!C4>4!J;G2858T4@!89!/0-0M!+6EE4>!E66F!
E:4!E834!19@!>4?6;>54?!89!6>@4>!E6!31F4!19!
155;>1E4!>4J6>EM!(556>@89H!E6!+6EE4><!C:1E!
RFFXUUHGDW5LGJH%DVLQZDVD³FXOWXUDO
PHOWGRZQ´LWZDVDQHWKQLFFRQIOLFWWKDWOHGWRD
31??15>4M!+6EE4>!49@4@!;J!>;289H!6;E!?E1>=1E869!
51998G128?3<!:4!>4Y45E4@!52831E4!5:19H4!241@89H!
E6!?51>54!>4?6;>54?!1?!E:4!51;?4!67!E:4!31??15>4M!
&:4!'8@H4!O1?89!4L51=1E869?!@8@!96E!?:6C!E:4!
4LJ45E4@!51998G12?!7>63!E:4!c00!OM)M<!G;E!>1E:4>!
1!H>6;J!67!J46J24!C:6!:1@!4E:985!5697285E?<!E:4!
?134!F89@!67!5697285E?!C4!?E822!?44!E6@1DM!
!
u&:8?!8?!19!4@8E4@!=4>?869!67!1!J1J4>!J>4?49E4@!1E!E:4!
A-?E!(99;12!i134?!)M!k6;9H!)6226d;8;3!69!(J>82!
/A>@!/0--M!
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
@3*('&#(%3#(<"2$.'$V(
OD!i1=84>!(31D1!
!!!!!&:4!Z;8?51?<!12?6!F96C9!1?!E:4!):8G5:1?<!1>4!
1!91E8=4!89@8H496;?!E>8G4!67!J46J24!89!)6263G81<!
%6;E:!(34>851M!$=49!E:6;H:!E:48>!J6J;21E869!:1?!
G449!@45>41?89H!?E41@82D!?8954!$;>6J419!569d;4?E<!
1!74C!Z;8?51!E>8G4?!?E822!28=4!1>6;9@!E:4!
)6263G819!51J8E12<!O6H6EpM!O476>4!%J198?:!
1>>8=12<!E:4!Z;8?51?!J6??4??4@!1!563J24L!?65812<!
J628E8512<!19@!45696385!?D?E43!89!C:85:!E:4D!
@47894@!E:48>!G42847?!1G6;E!>428H869!19@!E:4!
4=4>D@1D!2874M!
!!!!!&:4!Z;8?51?!C4>4!G4284=4@!E6!:1=4!1>>8=4@!E6!
E:4!(2E8J2196!);9@8G6D1549?4!1>6;9@!-<000!O)M!
7KH0XLVFD¶VSROLWLFDOVWUXFWXUHZDVRQHRID
56974@4>1E869M!&:4!56974@4>1E869!C1?!@8=8@4@!89!
EC6!J1>E?W!415:!>;24@!GD!1!3691>5:M!&:4!l8J1!
>;24@!89!E:4!?6;E:!67!E:4!)6974@4>1E869<!C:824!E:4!
l1d;4!>;24@!89!E:4!96>E:M!$15:!J1>E!67!E:4!
56974@4>1E869!C1?!563J6?4@!67!?4=4>12!
1;E69636;?!H>6;J?!67!J46J24!51224@!)15851TH6?<!
C:6?4!241@4>!C1?!51224@!)158d;4M!&:4!l8J1!19@!
=DTXHUHVSHFWHGWKHLU&DFLFD]JRV¶DXWRQRP\EXW
C4>4!569?8@4>4@!E:4!3828E1>D!5:847?!67!E:4!
56974@4>1E869M!&:4!l8J1!C1?!?449!1?!E:4!@8>45E!
@4?549@19E!67!E:4!3669<!C:824!E:4!l1d;4!C1?!
?449!1?!E:4!@8>45E!@4?549@19E!67!E:4!?;9M!%8954!E:4!
56974@4>1E869!C1?!5241>2D!G1?4@!69!?E>;5E;>4!19@!
96G24!?E1E;?<!96G828ED!E66F!69!19!83J6>E19E!>624!89!
E:48>!5;2E;>4M!.9!E:48>!?6584ED<!96G24!?E1E;?!C1?!
692D!J1??4@!@6C9!E:>6;H:!E:4!36E:4>M!a6>!
4L13J24W!87!E:4!l8J1!:1@!1!?69<!E:4!94LE!l8J1!
ZRXOGQRWEHKLVVRQEXWWKH=LSD¶VVLVWHU¶VVRQ
E:8?!G451;?4!E:4!694!C8E:!E:4!96G24!G266@!8?!E:4!
743124<!96E!E:4!3124M!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!!!!!(?!89!19D!?E>;5E;>4@!?E1E4<!E:4!Z;8?51?!
J6??4??4@!19!45696385!?D?E43M!&>;4d;4!C1?!E:4!
3189!4569638512!4L5:19H4!?449!89!E:4!
56974@4>1E869M!&>;4d;4!8?!E:4!4L5:19H4!67!6GY45E?!
6>!?4>=854?!76>!6E:4>!6GY45E?!6>!?4>=854?M!&:4>4!
C1?!96!;?4!67!5;>>495D!89=62=4@!89!E:4!
56974@4>1E869M!&:4!36?E!=12;1G24!6GY45E?!;?4@!76>!
&>;4d;4!C4>4!H62@<!?12E<!434>12@?<!19@!5612M!&:4!
Z;8?51?!C4>4!19!1H>85;2E;>12!?E1E4<!J>831>82D!
?;>=8=89H!GD!E:4!:1>=4?E89H!67!G419?<!56>9<!
J6E1E64?<!19@!D;551M!&4LE824?!12?6!J21D4@!1!31Y6>!
J1>E!89!E:48>!45696385!?D?E43<!E:4!Z;8?51?!C6=4!
E4LE824?!31@4!6;E!67!56EE69!6>!78d;4!^1H1=4_!E:1E!!
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!/]!!
C4>4!76>!J4>?6912!;?4<!6>!76>!E>;4d;4M!,62@?38E:?!
19@!1>E8?19?!12?6!J21D4@!1!31Y6>!>624!89!E:4!
456963D!67!E:4!56974@4>1E869M!
!!!!!):8G5:196!C1?!E:4!219H;1H4!?J6F49!89!E:4!
56974@4>1E869<!1!219H;1H4!7>63!C:85:!E:4!9134!
):8G5:1!5134!E6!G4<!C:49!>474>>89H!E6!E:4!
Z;8?51?M!a6>312!C>8E89H!76>!E:4!Z;8?51?!:1?!96E!
G449!76;9@<!4L54JE!76>!9;34>6;?!@>1C89H?!67!
V\PEROVRQURFNV0XVLFD¶VKRXVHVZHUH
J>831>82D!31@4!;?89H!1!G;82@89H!34E:6@!51224@!
O1:1>4d;4M!.9!E:8?!J>654??<!:6;?4?!C4>4!31@4!GD!
;?89H!5194?!19@!521D!89!6>@4>!E6!5>41E4!?6;9@J>667!
19@!?45;>4!C122?M!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!!!!!'428H869!C1?!1!=4>D!83J6>E19E!1?J45E!67!E:4!
0XLVFDV:LWKWKH=LSDDQG=DTXHDVJRGV¶
@4?549@19E?!89!41>E:<!E:4!Z;8?51?!?1C!E:4!?;9!19@!
E:4!3669!1?!E:48>!J>831>D!H6@?M!&:4!Z;8?51?!
51224@!E:4!?;9!H6@!O65:851!19@!E:4!3669!H6@@4??!
):81M!(556>@89H!E6!E:48>!G42847<!O65:851!C1?!E:4!
:8H:4?E!H6@!19@!:4!C1?!31>>84@!E6!):81M!Q8F4!19D!
6E:4>!5;2E;>4<!E:4!Z;8?51?!:1@!1!5>41E869!?E6>D!
51224@!O15:;4M!(556>@89H!E6!E:4!?E6>D<!1!C6319!
C12F4@!6;E!67!1!21F4!C8E:!1!G1GD!89!:4>!:19@?!19@!
E:1E!8?!:6C!:;319!F89@!G4H19M!&:4!Z;8?51?!:1@!
J>84?E?!C:6!569@;5E4@!54>436984?<!:;319!
?15>87854?!C4>4!J4>76>34@!19@!C4>4!1!=4>D!
83J6>E19E!54>4369812!1?J45EM!*94!5:82@!7>63!415:!
71382D!C6;2@!G4!H8=49!E6!1!J>84?E!E6!>18?4W!1E!1H4!
787E449!E:4!5:82@!C6;2@!G4!?15>87854@!@;>89H!1!
54>4369DM!Z;8?51?!C4>4!G;>84@!89!1!3;33D!?ED24!
;?89H!E:4!(9@419!?ED24W!E:4D!C4>4!G;>84@!C8E:!
$?E62851?!^C66@49!?E85F?_!E6!J>6E45E!E:43!89!E:4!
17E4>2874M!
!!!!!(?!E:4!21?E!l8J1!19@!l1d;4!@84@<!E:4!)158d;4?!
19@!E:4!J46J24!76;H:E!E:4!%J1981>@?!;9E82!1236?E!
E:4!4>1@851E869!67!E:4!Z;8?51?M!);>>49E2D<!E:4>4!
1>4!?3122!Z;8?51?!5633;98E84?!C:6!28=4!;9@4>!
E:4!)6263G819!H6=4>9349E!19@!569?E8E;E869M!
!
:3,;%0'.6AB$,,(.I.J(%%$43.K3,4$3.L(,"3"+(7..
I')21%# C&,'),0# ()'3,(# $'1"# 2((-,(# )&')# '<<,:)# %-0# :%$$-12)"8# C&,# ()'3,# .0%;-:)2%1(# %<),1#
0,<>,:)# )&,# :":>,(# %<# /2%>,1:,# I')21%(# %<),1# <'>># 21)%# '1;# ?,:%$,# /2:)2$(# %<8# C&,'),0# (,0/,(# '(# '1#
2$.%0)'1)#'..0%':&#)%#0'2(,#'*'0,1,((#%<#(-:&# 2((-,(#)&')#'0,#%<),1#231%0,;A#",)#(%# .0,(,1)A# 21#%-0#
;'2>"#>2/,(8C&,'),0#3%,(#'#(),.#<-0)&,0A#?"#&,>.213#)%#-1;,0()'1;#)&,#:%1(,J-,1:,(A#<21;#(2$2>'02)2,(A#
K#(%$,)2$,(#,/,1#32/,#&%.,#%0#'>),01')2/,(#)%#(-:((-,(8#C&,#)&,'),0#'>(%#&,>.(#:0,'),#'#>'13-'3,#
<%0#(-:((-,(8#7#0,%::-00213#)&,$,#21#I')21%#:%$$-12)2,(#2(#)&,#:":>,#%<#/2%>,1:,#%<#$':&2($%#'1;#
)&,#'<<,:)(#%<#2)8#!':&2($%#2(#/,0"#2$.%0)'1)A#",)#;2<<2:->)A#)%#';;0,((8#
:KHQ DGGUHVVLQJ LVVXHV GHDOLQJ ZLWK WKH ³0DFKR´ DQG
!':&2($%A# )&,# *%$'1# 2(# -(-'>>"# .%0)0'",;# '(# )&,# /2:)2$A# ?-)# *&')#
$%()#<%03,)#2(#)&')#)&,#$'1#2(#'>(%#)&,#/2:)2$8#91#/0-."1'"2'-'3-45#'#
.>'"# ?"# D&,002,# !%00'3'A# !'1-,># 2(# .%0)0'",;# '(# '# (),0,%)".2:'>#
!,L2:'1# *&%# (-<<,0(# <0%$# '>:%&%>2($8# C&,# .>'"# 0,/%>/,(# '0%-1;# #-'
2-%6#6-# M%;0N3-,H5# !'1-,>A# @%0),1:2'A# I,)2:2'A# I-.,A# '1;# M%('02%8#
C&,# .>'"# ()'3,(# $'1"# 2((-,(# 0,3'0;213# I')21%# <'$2>2,(A# )&,# $%()#
2$.%0)'1)#2((-,#2(#)&,#%1,#;,'>213#*2)&#$'(:->212)"#'1;#$':&2($%8!
=)-;2,(#(&%*#)&')#I')21%(#'0,#2;,1)2<2,;#'(#'#&23&O02(+#30%-.#<%0#(-?()'1:,#'?-(,A#;,.0,((2%1#
DQGDQ[LHW\$OVRVWXGLHVKDYHIRXQGWKDWD³ORQJ±),0$#0,(2;,1:,#21#)&,#P12),;#=)'),(#(2312<2:'1)>"#
LQFUHDVHG UDWHV RI PHQWDO GLVRUGHUV´ ZKLFK FDXVH D GUDPDWLF LQFUHDVH LQ VXEVWDQFH DEXVH 0DQXHO
(-<<,0(#<0%$#;,.0,((2%1# *&2:&#>,';(# &2$#)%#$'+,#)&,#;,:2(2%1#)%#,1;#*2)&# &2(#>2<,8#!,1#21#(%:2,)"A#
,(.,:2'>>"# I')21%# $,1A# <,,># )&,# 1,,;# )%# .0%/,# )&,20# $'1&%%;8# D%$.'0213# &2$(,><# )%# &2(# :%$.';0,A#
ZKRZDVYHU\VXFFHVVIXO0DQXHOIHOWDVLIKHKDGIDLOHGLQUHDFKLQJWKH³$PHULFDQ'UHDP´7KHUHDUH
PDQ\VFHQHVZKLFKUHIOHFW0DQXHO¶VREVHVVLRQRIKLVFRPSDGUH¶VVXFFHVV,QRQHVFHQHKHGHVFULEHV
&%*#&,#*2(&,;#&,#:%->;#?,#*2)&#&2$8#!'1"#.,%.>,#'-)%$')2:'>>"#'((-$,#?"#)&%(,#>21,(#)&')#!'1-,>#
2(#3'"A#?-)#&,#2(#1%)8#!'1-,>#2(#;,.0,((,;#?,:'-(,#&,#?,>2,/,(#&,#2(#'#<'2>-0,8##
#
Q%0# )&%(,# $,1# *&%# 2;,1)2<"# )&,$(,>/,(# *2)&# !'1-,>A# )&,"# <,,>#
)&,# .0,((-0,# %<# >2/213# 21# '# .')02'0:&'># (%:2,)"8# R-;3$,1)(# '1;# '))':+(#
$';,# '3'21()# )&,20# $'(:->212)"# *&,1# )&,"# ;%# 1%)# <-><2>># )&,#
,L.,:)')2%1(8# # C&,"# 3,)# S-;3,;# '1;# )&,20# $'(:->212)"# 2(# '))':+,;# *&,1#
)&,"#;%#1%)#$,,)#)&,20#0%>,#,L.,:)')2%1(8#T')02'0:&"#2(#'#)%L2:#()0-:)-0,8#9)#
2(#*2)&21#)&,#<'$2>"#)&')#2)#2(#;,/,>%.,;#'1;#:%1:,.)-'>2H,;8# #B2)&21#)&,#
<'$2>"A#%1,#>,'01# &%*#)%#0'1+#)&,#%..0,((2%1#%<#$'>,(#'1;#<,$'>,(8#B,#
'-)%$')2:'>>"#'((-$,#)&')#)&,#$'>,#*2>>#?,#)&,#%..0,((%0#'1;#)&,#<,$'>,#
*2>>#?,#)&,#%..0,((,;8# B,# &'/,#,$?0':,;#)&,# 2;,'#)&')#$,1#'0,#-(-'>>"#
)&,# %1,(# *&%# :'-(,# &'0$# 21# '# <'$2>"A# ",)# '# $'>,# 2(# '>(%# /2:)2$2H,;# '1;#
%..0,((,;8# 7(# /2:)2$(# %<# &,),0%.')02'0:&"A# $,1# (%$,)2$,(# +2>>#
)&,$(,>/,(# %/,0# <,,>213(# %<# *%0)&>,((1,((A# (&'$,A# (2>,1:,A# '1;# ;,(.'208#
0DQXHO¶VLQDELOLW\WRPHHWWKHH[SHFWDWLRQRIVRFLHW\OHGKLPWRKLVGHDWK#
#
9)#2(#2$.%0)'1)#)%#-1;,0()'1;#)&,#;2<<,0,1)#)".,(#%<#/2%>,1:,A#(-:&#'(#)&,#.&"(2:'>A#,$%)2%1'>A#
%0#.(":&%>%32:'>A#21#%0;,0#)%#.0,/,1)#)&,#;,')&#%<#'#$'18##D&,002,#!%0'3'#-1;,0(:%0,(#)&')#)&0%-3&#
%-0#<'$2>2,(#*,#?-2>;#)&,#<%-1;')2%1#%<#*&%#*,#'0,8#C&,#/'>-,(#%<#.'0,1)(#'0,#.'((,;#;%*1#)%#)&,20#
:&2>;0,18#D&2>;0,1#0,.>2:'),#)&%(,#/'>-,(#*&2:&#>'),0#'0,#.'((,;#;%*1#)%#)&,20#:&2>;0,18#9<#2)#2(#
)&0%-3&#<'$2>2,(#)&')#*,#,1:%-1),0#(-:&#>,((%1(A#*&"#;%#*,#:%1)21-,#)%#:%1(-$,#(-:&#)%L2:#*'"(#%<#
>2/213U#91#%0;,0#)%#?0,'+#'*'"#<0%$#)&,#:%1)21-%-(#:":>,(#%<#/2%>,1:,A#2)#$-()#?,321#)&,#&%-(,&%>;8##
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
#
B&,1#'#$,1#;2,(#%<#;,.0,((2%1#)%#,$'(:->')2%1#&,#
2(#1%)#)&,#%1>"#%1,#*&%#2(#/2:)2$2H,;8#C&%(,#*&%#'0,#'>(%#
/2:)2$2H,;#21:>-;,#<'$2>"#$,$?,0(#'1;#0,>')2/,(8#C&,"#)%%#
'0,#0,(.%1(2?>,#<%0#)&,#;,')&#%<#)&,#/2:)2$8#I')21%#)&,'),0#
&,>.(#)&,#'-;2,1:,#/2(-'>2H,#'1;#?,:%$,#:02)2:'>#*2)1,((,(#
)%#2((-,(#21/%>/213#)&,#:%$$-12)"8##
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!/S!!
!
X;%&*4".%2*;(%*(<'0'(H2#&*=/0I3$(
OD\!):8312561E2!^Z8H;42!";f4T_!
!
&:4!+46J24!C:6!:1=4!5634!E6!G4!F96C9!562245E8=42D!1?!E:4!Z1D1!1>4!J1>E!67!694!67!E:4!74C!6>8H8912!58=828T1E869?!
E6!@4=426J!89!E:4!C6>2@M!.E!8?!1!,>41E!B4>8E1H4!E6!G4!+>6;@!67!19@!E6!J>636E4!@;4!E6!8E?!;9?;>J1??4@!15563J28?:349E?!19@!
XQLTXHFUHDWLRQRIUHFRUGNHHSLQJV\VWHPVLHZULWLQJFDOHQGULFVHWF7KH0D\DDUHDQGKDYHEHHQ³&ODVVLFDO´IRU
E:6;?19@?!67!D41>?!G4D69@!E:6?4!D41>?!83J6?4@!GD!$;>6J419!7191E858?3!@;>89H!E:4!?;JJ6?4@!)21??85!+4>86@<!>6;H:2D!(V!
/00!E6!N00<!89!C:1E!8?!E6@1D!51224@!k;51E19<!):81J1?<!&1G1?56<!19@!3;5:!67!&2156P&HDQDKXDF³0LGGOH$PHULFD´
j96C9!76>!E:48>!83J>4??8=4!58E84?!G;82E!E:6;?19@?!67!D41>?!1H6<!C:824!$;>6J419?!28=4@!89!E:48>!C6>?E!;958=828T4@!E834?<!
E:4!Z1D1!C4>4!C>8E89H!J64E>D<!91>>1E8=4?<!51249@>85?<!@4@851E89H!G;82@89H?<!:696>89H!E:48>!(Y1C!^J628E8512!
>4J>4?49E1E8=4?_M!
!
&:4!Z1D1!89@4J49@49E2D!67!122!*E:4>!K6>2@!8972;4954!5>41E4@!19!8996=1E4@!C>8E89H!?D?E43M!.E!C1?!19@!8?!
563J6?4@!26H6H>13?<!8@46H>13?<!?D221G24?M!Q6H6H>13?!1>4!?83J2D!C6>@?<!6>!831H4?<!E:1E!@4J85E!E:4!>41@89H!67!1!
µFKDUDFWHU¶DVVXFKH[DPSOHVGHPRQVWUDWHV!
(DFKµVLJQ¶FDQEHUHDG7KHUHDGLQJLVVLPSO\EDVHGRQZKDWWKHREMHFWLVRUUHSUHVHQWVZKHWKHULWWUDQVFHQGV(XURSHDQ
DHVWKHWLFVRULVFRQVLGHUHG³DEVWUDFW´E\(XURSHDQDQGFRORQL]HGH\HVLVDQRWKHUUHVHDUFKDOOLQLWVHOI)RUH[DPSOH,;
PHDQVµZRPDQ¶DQGLVUHQGHUHGE\WKHKHDGRID0D\D:RPDQGLVWLQJXLVKHGE\DIDFLDOPDUNLQJRIZKDWWRVRPHORRNV
WREHWKH/DWLQUHSUHVHQWDWLRQVRI³,/´$QRWKHULVFRQVLGHUHGDQµLGHRJUDP¶ZKLFKVLPSO\HQWDLOVDQLGHDLVGHSLFWHG
&+2.LVWKH0D\DZRUGIRUµVFDWWHULQJ¶DQGEDVHGRQLQWHUSUHWDWLRQVE\VFKRODUVLQFHQVHLVZKDWLVEHLQJVFDWWHUHG$
PRUHGLIILFXOW0D\DZRUGWRFRQYH\WRVRPHH\HVLVWKHXVHRI72.RUµIOLQWNQLIH¶+RZHYHUZKHQRQHFRPSDUHV
"1:;1E2!1?!C>8EE49!6>8H89122D<!694!?44?!1!5241>!?83821>8ED!^19@!E:;?!E:4!83J6>E1954!67!1!5>6??P5;2E;>12!1JJ>615:!8?!4??49E812!
LQWKHµVWXG\¶RI$QDKXDF3HRSOHV&XOWXUHVDQG/DQJXDJHV7KH0D\DLVQRWOLPLWHGWRVLPSO\ORJRJUDPVDQG
8@46H>13?M!
!
7KH0D\DZHUHDOVRFDSDEOHLQWKHLUODQJXDJHWRXVHSKRQHWLFUHQGLWLRQVWR³VSHOORXW´DZRUGRUWRFRPSOHPHQWD
?J458785!>41@89H!E6!96E!5697;?4!E:4!>41@4>!C8E:!6E:4>!C6>@?M!*=4>!E:4!21?E!549E;>D<!1!Z1D1!?D221G85!5:1>E!:1?!G449!
FUHDWHGDGDSWHGDQGPRGLILHG7KH0D\DV\OODELFFKDUWLVHVVHQWLDOWROHDUQLQJWRµUHDG¶RUZULWHLQ0D\D!
$VGHPRQVWUDWHGDERYHHDFKVLJQLQGHSHQGHQWO\FDUULHVDSKRQHWLFUHDGLQJ7KHWRSOHIWµFRPSRXQG¶IRUH[DPSOHLVD
563G891E869!67!ET;!v!2;W!19@!C:49!563G894@!E:4D!?6;9@!6;E!ET;2;W!:6C4=4><!E:4!Z1D1!C6;2@!96E!J>696;954!E:4!78912!
=6C42!^89!36?E!51?4?<!4?J458122D!87!E:4!?4569@!E6!21?E!=6C42!C1?!E:4!?134!1?!E:4!21?E!694_M!&:4>476>4<!C4!C6;2@!96E!>41@!
WKLVZRUGDVW]XOXEXWDVW]XOPHDQLQJµGRJ¶7KHVHFRQGH[DPSOHLVW]¶LEZULWWHQDVW]¶LELZKLFKLQWXUQFRPELQHWR
PDNHW]¶LELDQGWKHILQDO±LLVQRWSURQRXQFHGUHQGHULQJLWDVW]¶LERUµZULWLQJ¶!
!
:HDOVRKDYHZKDWLVNQRZQDVµSKRQHWLFFRPSOHPHQWV¶8VLQJDSKRQHWLFµVLJQ¶RQHUHLQIRUFHVWKHUHDGLQJRID
)*;%J(I=J(PW(
C6>@M!a6>!4L13J24<!
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!/b!!
!
)*;%J(,&*A(I=J(PY(
WKHULJKWKDQGµZRUG¶LVFRPSRVHGRI6,+PY8PD1M!B4>4!E:4!78912!=6C42!8?!96E!>41@<!241=89H!;?!C8E:!%.BPY8PD<!6>!?8:Y8D<!
PHDQLQJµZDVERUQ¶7KHDERYHH[DPSOHVDUHYHUEVZKLFKDOVRKDYHWKHWHQVHVLQIL[HGLQWRWKHPWKHWHQVHVLQ(QJOLVK
@6!96E!>47245E!122!1?J45E?!67!Z1D1!E49?4?<!G;E!519!41?4!E:4!;9@4>?E19@89H!67!Z1D1!E49?4?_M!*9!E:4!?4569@!4L13J24!E6!E:4!
247E!C4!:1=4!;P&+¶$0PZDKHUHWKHILQDOYRZHOLVQRWORVW7KHPHDQLQJRIWKLVZRUGLVXFK¶DPZDRUµKHVKHLW
JUDEV¶!
!
&:4!219H;1H4!8?!=1?E2D!563J24L!19@!E:4>476>4!>4d;8>4@!D41>?!67!?E;@D89H!19@!241>989H!19@!>4241>989H!^1?!94C!
789@89H?!6774>!@8774>49E!>41@89H?!6>!89E4>J>4E1E869?_M!&:4!Z1D1!Z44E89H!)6974>4954!:42@!199;122D!89!(;?E89<!&4L1?!19@!
6E:4>!?83821>!56974>4954?!1>4!4??49E8122D!=8E12!E6!241>989H!E:4!Z1D1!219H;1H4?!1?!E:4D!C4>4!C>8EE49!6>8H89122DM!O1?85!
>41@89H?!8952;@4!O>41F89H!E:4!Z1D1!)6@4!19@!'41@89H!E:4!Z1D1!,2DJ:!GD!Z85:142!)64!19@!B6C!&6!'41@!Z1D1!
B84>6H2DJ:?!19@!V85E8691>D!67!Z1D1!B84>6H2DJ:?!GD!i6:9!Z69EH634>D<!1369H!6E:4>?M!j96C89H!E:4!219H;1H4!89!
C:85:!E:4!Z1D1!C>6E4!8?!4??49E812!19@!C822!41?4!E:4!51J158ED!19@!51J1G828ED!67!122!E6!G4EE4>!563J>4:49@!19@!>41@!Z1D1!
ZULWLQJDVLWZDVLQWHQGHG:KLOHGHEDWHVFRQWLQXHLWLVJHQHUDOO\EHOLHYHGWKDWWKH0D\DµVFULSW¶ZDVEDVHGRQWKH
0D\DD7¶DDQRU³<XFDWHFD´0D\DRI<XFDWDQ(O3HWHQDQG%HOLFHDQGRUD&KROYDULDQWRUODQJXDJH!
!
!
)RU3HRSOHRI1LFDQ7ODFDKOLWHUDOO\³:H7KH3HRSOH+HUH´RU,QGLJHQRXV3HRSOH'HVFHQWLWLVHVVHQWLDOWR
OHDUQWKHWRROVWREHDEOHWRLQGHSHQGHQWO\UHDGRQH¶VFUHDWLRQQDUUDWLYHVFDOHQGULFDOFDOFXODWLRQVSKLORVRSKLFDO
FRPSOH[LWLHVDQGXOWLPDWHO\RQH¶VRZQ+HULWDJHRIZKLFKQR2WKHU:RUOGSHRSOHKDVULYDOHG!
³2XU:RUG,V2XU:HDSRQ´7KH0D\D0HHWLQJV&RQIHUHQFH(
';4(Z;4#&$%';42;=(<'0'(%*(D&#'U(%3#(<2$";4#&$%';42;=$(*,(PQRP(
OD\!):8312561E2!^Z8H;42!";f4T_!
!
!
&:4!G4?E!C41J69!67!1!J46J24!:1?!?634E834?!G449!F96C24@H4M!.7!C4!J6??4?!F96C24@H4!E:49!C4!1>4!24E:12M!.7!C4!215F!8976>31E869<!E:49!C4!1>4!1E!1!
@8?1@=19E1H4M!K:49!$;>6J419?!78>?E!.9=1@4@!E:4!Z1D1<!96!694!56;2@!J>4@85E!E:4!@4?E>;5E869!E:1E!C6;2@!49?;4M!K8E:!E:4!$;>6J419!H>8J!69!?634!1>41?!67!
C:1E!E:4D!51224@!k;51E19<!$;>6J419?!G4H19!E6!J8221H4!Z1D1!136L51228!^28G>1>84?_<!C:85:!569E1894@!ET69E28!^]00<!6>!56;9E24??_!Y;;9!^G66F?_!1269H!C8E:!1!
>85:!C>8E89H!E>1@8E869M!.9!E:8?!=4>D!?6J:8?E851E4@!>456>@89H!F44J89H!?D?E43<!E:4!Z1D1!C>6E4!1G6;E!4=4>DE:89H!E:4D!56;2@!E:89F!67!89!E:48>!219H;1H4!19@!
1JJ>6J>81E42D!7>63!E:48>!56?36=8?869!19@!C6>2@=84C!C8E:6;E!6;E?8@4!89782E>1E869!6>!76>48H9!8@41?!83J6?4@M!K8E:!E:4!G;>989H!67!36?E!67!E:4!Y;;9<!C4!C4>4!
VWULSSHGRIRQHRI2XU/DQJXDJHVDWOHDVWIRUDFRXSOHRIFHQWXULHV0DD\DD7¶DDQ/DQJXDJHRIWKH0D\DDVLWLVDSSURSULDE42D!51224@<!1269H!C8E:!6E:4>!
>421E4@!219H;1H4?!?;5:!1?!1!):62!=1>819Ee219H;1H4^?_<!@65;349E4@!C:1E!E:4!Z1D1!:1@!E6!?1DM!a6>!E:8?!>41?69!19@!8E?!E:4!83J2851E869?!8E!8?!4??49E812!E6!241>9!
E:4!E:6;?19@!D41>!62@!219H;1H4?!67!E:4!Z1D1!^G6E:!?J6F49!19@!C>8EE49!89!E:48>!6>8H8912!?5>8JE_!E6!G4!1G24!E6!>41@!C:1E!C1?!?18@!1G6;E!/0-/M!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
&:4!(99;12!Z1D1!Z44E89H?!)6974>4954!89!(;?E89<!&4L1?!89!21E4!Z1>5:!8?!1!J4>745E!6JJ6>E;98ED!E6!G45634!15d;189E4@!C8E:!E:4!Z1D1!C>8E89H!?D?E43<!;?89H!
>4549E!?5:621>?:8J!19@!1!J4>745E!219H;1H4!E6!;9@4>?E19@!76>!694?427!E:4!83J6>E1954!67!/0-/M!%83821>!56974>4954?!67!H>41E!83J6>E1954!76>!4LJ6?;>4!19@!
4@;51E869!8?!E:4!199;12!$;>6J419!Z1D1!)6974>4954!^$Z)_!C:85:!E6;>?!@8774>49E!$;>6J419!?E1E4?!E6!E415:!19@!@8?5;??!E:4!Z1D1!C>8EE49!219H;1H4<!:42@!89!
V4543G4>M!&:4!Z1D1!Z44E89H?!67!6E:4>!;98=4>?8E84?!?;5:!1?!&;2194!8?!12?6!=1?E2D!83J6>E19E!76>!E:4!4LJ6?;>4!E6!319D!?5:621>?!67!26H8512!?;G?E1954!C:6!
FRPHWRJHWKHUWRGLVFXVVUHFHQWILQGVRQWKH0D\DODQJXDJHVWRLPSURYHDFFXUDF\RIUHDGLQJVDQGWREXLOGRQSDVW³GHFLSKHUPHQWV´M!K6>F?:6J?!69!E:4!
Z1D1!C>8E89H!?D?E43!@63891E4?!E:4!56974>4954!1?!694!8?!E1;H:E!GD!E6JP?5:621>?!69!E:4!?D?E43!C:63!:1=4!J1>E1F49!89!E:4!;9@4>?E19@89H!1@!89E4>J>4E1E869?!
67!E:4!Z1D1!219H;1H4?M!
!
!
)*;%J(I=J(P[(
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!/h!!
!
S*I"/'%2*;()*;%&*/O(M3#(S*/2%2.$(";4#&(+DRQ[Q(
OD!$2=8>1!'86?!
!
!
!
.E!8?!83J6>E19E!E6!15F96C24@H4!E:1E!E:4>4!8?!19!19E8P
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
.338H>19E!19@!19E8PZ4L8519e):85196!1E36?J:4>4!E:1E!8?!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
21>H42D!?449!89!E:4!?1E4!67!(>8T691!C:4>4!E:4!Q1E896?!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
563J>8?4@!!31Y6>8ED!67!E:4!J6J;21E869M!&:4!?E1E4!67!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
(>8T691!@4J85E?!1!5241>!831H4!67!E:4!J6J;21E869!569E>62!69!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
Q1E896?!GD!C4256389H!21C?!28F4!%O!-0h0M!&:4!5>15F!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
@6C9!67!8224H12!8338H>19E?!8?!:8H:2D!=8?8G24!89!?E1E4?!28F4!
$UL]RQDZKLFKVHUYHVDVDQH[DPSOHWRRWKHUVWDWHV,QIDFWRWKHUVWDWHVVHHPLQJO\MXPSHGRQWKH$UL]RQD³EDQGZDJRQ´9DULR;?!?E1E4?!:1=4!E>84@!E6!J1??!=1>86;?!341?;>4?!C8E:!
@8774>49E!8338H>1E869!J219F?M!&:4!8??;4!8?!C:4E:4>!694!8338H>19E!1H49@1!8?!1JJ>6J>81E4!89!@8=4>?4!?E1E4?!C8E:!@8=4>?4!@436H>1J:85?<!@8774>49E!@8?E1954?!7>63!E:4!Z4L8519P#M%!
G6>@4><!19@!Y6G?!28F4!5>6J!J85F89H!19@!21G6>!>421E4@!Y6G?!1>4!96E!G489H!78224@!GD!(34>8519!58E8T49?!6>!24H12!>4?8@49E?M!(96E:4>!LVVXHLVWKHIHGHUDOJRYHUQPHQW¶VMXULVGLFWLRQRQ
8338H>1E869<!E:4!G6>@4><!91E;>128T1E869<!19@!6E:4>!4976>54349E!8??;4?!H8=49!E:4!569H>4??!;9C82289H94??!E6!@412!C8E:!563J>4:49?8=4!8338H>1E869!>476>3!76>!E:4!91E869M!
&:4!*G131!(@3898?E>1E869!?;4@!(>8T691!6=4>!%O!-0h0<!19@!J>4?;31G2D!C822!@6!E:4!?134!C8E:!#E1:M!B6C4=4><!E:8?!?:6C?!:6C!5>;5812!(>8T691!C1?!E6!E:4!78H:EM!(22!
91E86912!1EE49E869!C1?!E1F49!1C1D!7>63!?E1E4?!28F4!#E1:<!C:85:!d;84E2D!76226C4@!;JM!%E1E4?!?;5:!1?<!a26>8@1<!j19?1?<!*F21:631<!19@!%6;E:!)1>62891!:1=4!?449!E:48>!1EE43JE?!E6!
J49128T4!;9@65;349E4@!8338H>19E?!:4?8E1E89H2D<!#E1:!@8@!96EM!(>8T691P?ED24!G822?!@84@!41>2D!89!)626>1@6<!19@!"4G>1?F1!@458@4@!89!0DUFKWRHQGLWVGHEDWHRQRQH$UL]RQD¶VODZ
UHTXLUHVVWDWHORFDOSROLFHRIILFHUVWRLQTXLUHDERXWWKHLPPLJUDWLRQVWDWXVRIDQ\RQHWKH\VWRSLIWKH\KDYHD³UHDVRQDEOH?;?SLFLRQ´WKHSHUVRQLVDQ!
8224H12!8338H>19EM!K8E:!>4?J45E!E6!E:4!15E869?!E:1E!:1=4!G449!655;>>89H!1369H!E:4?4!?E1E4?<!6E:4>!?E1E4?!C8E:!!'4J;G28519P:41=D!24H8?21E;>4?!38H:E!4=49E;122D!76226C!?;8E!
4=49E;122DM!!
7KHELOO¶VVSRQVRULQ8WDKPXVWFRPSUHKHQGWKDWKLVODZLVQRGLIIHUHQWIURPWKH$UL]RQDODZ7KHJXHVWZRUNHUSURJUDPZKLFK!C6;2@!944@!1!74@4>12!C18=4>!E:1E!
5;>>49E2D!@64?!96E!4L8?E<!8?!54>E1892D!563J24LW!E:4!?J69?6>!67!E:4!21C!4976>54349E!341?;>4!6JJ6?4@!8E!1>E85;21E42DM!(!E:8>@!21C!5>41E4?!1!J15E!C8E:!";4=6!Q4w9!%E1E4!89!Z4L856!E6!
7;9942!Z4L8519?!89E6!E:4!H;4?E!C6>F4>!J>6H>13M!O451;?4!1!?E1E4!519!96E!5>41E4!1!H;4?E!C6>F4>!J>6H>13!69!8E?!6C9<!EC6!G822?!:1=4!G449!@8?38??4@!GD!8338H>19E!>8H:E?!1@=651E4?M!
.338H>19E!1@=651E4?!89!319D!?E1E4?!?1D!E:4!@4G1E4!5241>2D!?:87E4@!89!71=6>!67!E6;H:4>!4976>54349EM!#2E831E42D<!D6;!49@!;J!C8E:!1!21C!E:1E!8?!89!319D!>4?J45E?!1!38>>6>!67!E:4!
(>8T691!21C<!C8E:!?634!67!E:4!569E>6=4>?812!J8454?!?67E494@M!!!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!1HZ0H[LFR¶V*RYHUQRU6XVDQD0DUWLQH]D5HSXEOLFDQDQGD+LVSDQLFSURPLVHGDPRYHLQKHUFDPSDLJQODVW\HDU$ELOOVKHVXSJ6>E4@!C1?!@4741E4@!GD!E:4!
V4365>1E85P569E>6224@!%E1E4!%491E4!89!Z1>5:M!.9?E41@<!"4C!34L856!1JJ>6=4@!1!G822!E:1E!1@@4@!>4d;8>4349E?<!8952;@89H!789H4>J>89E89H<!76>!8338H>19E?!C8E:6;E!1!%65812!%45;>8ED!
QXPEHUZKRDSSO\IRUOLFHQVHV,IWKH%LOOZLQVILQDODSSURYDODQGWKH*RYHUQRU¶VVLJQDWXUHLWZLOOFUHDWHDWZRPE84>4@!?D?E43!C8E:!28549?4?!8??;4@!E6!J46J24!C8E:6;E!J>667!67!24H12!
>4?8@4954!C822!G4!@8?E895E8=42D!31>F4@M!Z?M!Z1>E894T!=6C4@!E6!569E89;4!E6!78H:E!76>!E:4!>4J412<!12E:6;H:!E:8?!8?!E:4!78912!C44F!67!E:4!24H8?21E8=4!?4??869M!%:4!51224@!E:4!5;>>49E!21C!
³GDQJHURXV´DQGDFFXVHG'HPRFUDWVRI³3DUWLVDQSROLWLFDOJDPHVPDQVKLS´IRUEORFNLQJLWVUHSHDO,WPLJKWEHDJRRGVLJQWKDWC4!C822!G4!1G24!E6!3189E189!28549?4?!76>!89@8=8@;12?!
C:6!1>4!28=89H<!C6>F89H<!19@!J1D89H!E1L4?!89!6;>!?E1E4?!>4H1>@24??!67!E:48>!?E1E;?4?<!96E:89H!8?!E1F49!76>!H>19E4@!?6!8E!?443?M!
8WDK¶VDSSURDFKLQYROYHVHQIRUFHPHQWPHDVXUHVSDLUHGZLWKDQRSHQLQJWROHJDOVWDWXVIRULOOHJDOZRUNHUV,Q7H[DVWKHELJJH?E!94C?!7>63!E:4!8338H>1E869!@4G1E4!C1?!
1!G822!GD!%E1E4!'4J>4?49E1E8=4!V4GG84!'8@@24<!1!'4J;G28519M!B4>!24H8?21E869!C6;2@!J49128T4!43J26D4>?!:8>89H!8224H12!8338H>19E?<!C8E:!19!4L54JE869!76>!71382D!:6;?4:62@?!
43J26D89H!G1GD!?8EE4>?!6>!H1>@494>?M!.338H>19E!H>6;J?!19@!V4365>1E?!155;?4@!Z?M!'8@@24!67!:DJ65>8?D<!?1D89H!?:4!C19E4@!E6!@4J6>E!LOOHJDOLPPLJUDQWVH[FHSWIRUKHUIULHQGV¶
919984?M!!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
)*;%J(,&*A(I=J(PW(
!
&:4!)6974>4954!67!E:4!Z1D1!Z44E89H?!67!/0--!89!(;?E89<!&4L1?!C1?!E:434@!1>6;9@!E:4!/0-/!19@!E:4!Z1D1M!.9!8E<!C4!:1@!Z1D1!4J8H>1J:4>?!19@!
F96C24@H41G24?!J>4?49E!69!E:4!83J6>E1954!67!1!@1E4!89!V4543G4>!/0-/!76>!E:4!Z1D1!76>!8E!8?!@65;349E4@!89!E:4!Z1D1!C6>@?!E:43?42=4?W!B6C4=4><!8E!8?!
31@4!5241>!E:1E!E:4!Z1D1!@8@!96E!31F4!J>6J:4E85!J>4@85E869?!G1?4@!69!):>8?E819!3DE:626H8512!8@41?!1G6;E!1!1J6512DJE85!@4?E>;5E869!67!E:4!C6>2@M!!a6>!
E:6?4!E:1E!:1=4!19!89E4>4?E!89!241>989H!1G6;E!1!36>4!1JJ>6J>81E4!;9@4>?E19@89H!67!E:4!/0-/!@1E4<!:8H:2D!>4563349@4@!8?!/0-/\!%584954!(9@!+>6J:45D!67!
E:4!(95849E!Z1D1!GD!Z1>F![19!%E694!19@!E:4!*>@4>!67!V1E4?!GD!V1=8@!%E;1>EM!B6C4=4><!E6!96E!E1F4!6E:4>?!C6>@!76>!8E<!E1F4!E:4!Z1DD¶VZRUGIRULWDQG
OHDUQWKHLUODQJXDJHVDQGWKHLUZULWWHQV\VWHPWRUHDGIRU\RXUVHOI0LFKDHO&RH¶V5HDGLQJWKH0D\D*O\SKDQG%UHDNLQJWKH0DD1!)6@4!1>4!EC6!
FODVVLFVWKDWEUHDNGRZQWKHUHDGLQJRIWKH0D\DZULWWHQVFULSWDQGWKHKLVWRU\RI³GHFLSKHUPHQW´UHVSHFWLYHO\7KHQZKHQWK8?!8?!@694<!H6!G15F!E6!E:4!
?6;>54?!E:1E!@65;349E!E:4!/0-/!@1E4!19@!>41@!C:1E!C1?!?18@!19@!96E!?18@!1G6;E!C:1E!C6;2@!19@!C6;2@!96E!:1JJ49!89!V4543G4>!/0-/M!*94!C822!789@!96!
>474>4954!E6!E:4!49@!67!E:4!C6>2@!1J6512DJE85P?ED24!3DE:?!19@!89?E41@!19!83J6>E19E!@1E4!89@44@!76>!E:4!Z1D1<!76>!87!8E!C1?!96E<!E:49!E:4D!C6;2@!96E!:1@!
@65;349E4@!8E!89!36>4!E:19!694!E834!19@!J2154<!E:6;?19@?!67!D41>?!G476>4!E:4!@1E4M!*E:4>!>4563349@4@!>41@89H?!8952;@4!i6:9!Z69EHRPHU\¶V0D\DP
$9H28?:e$9H28?:PZ1D1!V85E8691>D!19@!+:>1?4G66F<!V85E8691>D!67!Z1D1!B84>6H2DJ:?<!19@!B6C!&6!'41@!Z1D1!B84>6H2DJ:?!1?!C422!1?!'41@89H!Z1D1!(>E!
GD!(9@>41!%E694M!
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!/c!!
!
!
+%"4#;%(S&#$$(1#/#'$#(
OD\!$@C1>@!(>422196!
%E;@49E?!E1F89H!19!$E:985!%E;@84?!):85196!$@;51E869!521??!C4>4!H8=49!E:4!6JJ6>E;98ED!E6!6>H198T4!19@!78H:E!76>!E:48>!
4@;51E869!89!1!J>6E4?E!1H189?E!36>4!#98=4>?8ED!67!)12876>981!G;@H4E!5;E?M!!.9?J8>4@!GD!1!521??!E:1E!?:6C4@!89E4>4?E<!+>674??6>!$9>8d;4!
ZM!Q6J4T!1226C4@!:8?!?E;@49E?!E6!E:89F!67!1!J>6Y45E!E:1E!C6;2@!J6E49E8122D!31F4!1!@8774>4954!89!E:48>!28=4?M!!
*9!a>8@1D<!Z1D<!/h<!/0--<!%E;@49E?!7>63!#)'!6>H198T4@!1!J>4??!>4241?4!1E!E:4!677854?!67!%E1E4!(??43G2D!319<!O>819!
1HVWDQGHLQKRSHVRISRWHQWLDOO\DFTXLULQJKLVYRWHIRU*RYHUQRU%URZQ¶VWD[H[WHQVLRQSDFNDJH7KHJRYHUQRU¶VWD[H[WHQVLRQ
SURSRVHVWRFORVHWKHVWDWH¶VGHILFLWJDSRIRYHUELOOLRQE\FXWWLQJDSSUR[LPDWHO\ELOOLRQLQVWDWHIXQGHGSURJUDPVD9@!
4LE49@89H!E:4!5;>>49E!=4:8524!28549?4!E1L<!J4>?6912!E1L<!19@!?124?!E1L!76>!19!1@@8E86912!S!D41>?!E6!5>41E4!196E:4>!R-/!G822869!89!>4=49;4M!
&:4!E1L!4LE49?869!C6;2@!?45;>4!319D!?174ED!94E!J>6H>13?!E:1E!1>4!=8E12!E6!319D!26C!895634!7138284?M!.9!1@@8E869<!76>!?E;@49E?<!E:4!
4LE49?869!C6;2@!J>4?4>=4!E;8E869!:8F4?!E6!>43189!1E!5;>>49E!24=42?!67!cUM!&:4!cU!895>41?4!67!E;8E869!:8F4?!C1?!12>41@D!1JJ>6=4@!19@!
E:4!#)!1?!C422!1?!E:4!)%#!4LJ4>84954@!RS00!3822869!89!5;E?<!89!415:!513J;?M!)633;98ED!)6224H4?!12?6!E66F!5;E?!4d;1289H!E6!R]00!
3822869M!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
.7!E:4!E1L!4LE49?869!@64?!96E!J1??<!?E;@49E?!19@!?E1E4!7;9@4@!J>6H>13?!C822!E1F4!E:4!G>;9E!67!E:4!569?4d;4954?M!%E;@49E?!89!
J1>E85;21>!C822!7442!E:4!569?4d;4954?!C:49!8E!G45634?!E66!21E4!E6!@6!19DE:89H!1G6;E!8EM!a1589H!;J!E6!A/UP]0U!E;8E869!895>41?4?<!4=4>D!
)12876>981!?E;@49E!C822!G4!17745E4@M!&:4?4!E;8E869!895>41?4?!1>4!>4J>4?49E1E8=4!67!E:4!?E1E4!G>41F89H!1C1D!7>63!8E?!J>638?4!67!J>6=8@89H!
DQDIIRUGDEOHSXEOLFHGXFDWLRQ/DVWDFDGHPLF\HDUZDVWKHILUVWWLPHLQ&DOLIRUQLD¶VKLVWRU\ZKHUHVWXGHQWVLQ³SXEOLF´HGXF1E869!
J18@!36>4!6;E!67!E:48>!6C9!J65F4E?!E:19!C:1E!E:4!?E1E4!569E>8G;E4@!E6!J;G285!4@;51E869M!K:1E!G4H89?!E6!:1JJ49!8?!E:4!J>8=1E8T1E869!67!
:8H:4>!4@;51E869!C:4>4!E:6?4!C:6!519!1776>@!E6!H6!E6!56224H4!C822!H6!19@!E:6?4!C:6!51996E<!C822!96EM!
$PRQJWKHPRVWLPSRUWDQWREMHFWLYHVRIWKHSUHVVFRQIHUHQFHZDVWRDFTXLUH5HSXEOLFDQOHJLVODWXUH%ULDQ1HVWDQGH¶VVXSSRUW
IRUWKHWD[H[WHQVLRQ&RQVLGHULQJWKHSROLWLFDOJULGORFNEHWZHHQ5HSXEOLFDQVDQG'HPRFUDWV1HVWDQGH¶VYRWHEHFRPHVFUXFLDOE6!E:4!
VXFFHVVRIWKHWD[H[WHQVLRQ1HVWDQGH¶VSRVLWLRQRQWKHJRYHUQRU¶VWD[H[WHQVLRQLVQRWJRRG$FFRUGLQJWRWKHVWXGHQWKHOG!J>4??!
56974>4954<!"4?E19@4!E:89F?!E:1E!E:4>4!8?!1!G4EE4>!C1D!E6!1JJ>615:!E:4!?E1E4?!@47858E!19@!4LE49@89H!E1L4?!8?!96E!694!67!E:43M!&:4!
31Y6>8ED!67!)12876>981!'4J;G28519!24H8?21E;>4?!G4284=4!89!1!5;E!122!1JJ>615:<!E:1E!C822!:1=4!?4>86;?!83J2851E869?!69!?E;@49E?!19@!
FRPPXQLWLHV¶GHSHQGHQWRQVWDWHIXQGHGMREVDQGVHUYLFHV!
!5RPLQD6DQFKH]DJUDGXDWLQJVHQLRUDQG%XVLQHVV(FRQPDMRUIHOWWKHLPSRUWDQFHRIWKHSUHVVUHOHDVH³/DXQLGDKDFHOD
7;4>T1<!C:49!89@8=8@;12?!5634!E6H4E:4>!E:4D!1>4!1G24!E6!96E!692D!24E!E:48>!C6>@!G4!F96C9<!G;E!E:4D!1>4!1G24!E6!G;82@!1!?49?4!67!
241@4>?:8J!E:1E!31D!?4>=4!1?!1!>424=19E!4L13J24!76>!6E:4>?<!G;E!36>4!83J6>E19E2D!E:4D!1>4!1G24!E6!5>41E4!1!?49?4!67!G69@89H!GD!
FDUU\LQJRQDSUREDEOHFDXVH´)RUPDQ\WKHSUREDEOHFDXVHUHIOHFWVDYRLGLQJWKHVHULRXVFRQVHTXHQFHVWKHWD[H[WHQVLRQLPSO84?!87!8E!
8?!96E!?;554??7;22D!J1??4@M!!
!
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!/N!!
!
!
!
.E! 8?! 5241>! E:1E! E:4! #98E4@! %E1E4?!
:1?! G449! ;9@4>H689H! @436H>1J:85!
5:19H4?!19@!8E?!J6J;21E869!19@!J46J24!1>4!
96!269H4>!E:4!?134M!(?!+>674??6>!"1=1>>6!
>474>?! E6! 8E<! E:4! #98E4@! %E1E4?! 8?! 89! E:4!
38@?E!
67!
1!
'4PZ4L85198T1E869e!
Q1E8968T1E869M!&:4!G>6C989H!67!E:4!91E869!
:1?! G45634! 36>4! J>4=1249E! E:19! 4=4><!
9694E:424??<! 8E! :1?! 1>8?49! 319D! >158?E!
91E8=8?E! 36=4349E?! E:>6;H:6;E! E:4!
56;9E>D!4?J458122D!89!E:4!?E1E4!67!(>8T691M!!
!
.9! H494>12! Q1E896?! 1>4! 1! D6;9H!
J6J;21E869W!8E?!:8H:!74>E828ED!>1E4?!19@!:8H:!
49E>D! 67! 8338H>19E?! E6! E:4! 56;9E>D! :1=4!
569E>8G;E4@! E6! E:4! E>19?76>31E869! 67! E:4!
#M%M!E6!694!C8E:!@8774>49E!J628E8512!=84C?<!
5;?E63?<! 5;2E;>4?<! 219H;1H4?<! 19@!
E>1@8E869?M! *9! 1! ?83821>! 96E4<! @1E1!
H1E:4>4@! GD! >4?41>5:4>?! @496E4?! E:1E!
Q1E896?! 1>4! 89@44@! E:4! D6;9H4?E! H>6C89H!
J6J;21E869! 89! E:4! #M%M! E:>6;H:! C:85:! 8E!
C1?! 76;9@! E:1E! E:4! 34@819! 1H4! 76>!
Z4L8519?! 8?! /S<! Q1E896?! ^969PZ4L8519_!
/h<! 19@! 89! 563J1>8?69! E6! E:4! C:8E4!
J6J;21E869<! C:85:! 8?! ]-<! E:48>! J6J;21E869!
:1?!G449!>421E8=42D!@45>41?89HM!Z6>46=4><!
E:4!+4C!B8?J1985!)49E4>!>4=4124@!E:1E!E:4!
9;3G4>! 67! Q1E896! 5:82@>49! 89! E:4! #M%M!
6=4>! 1! @451@4²E:4! D41>! /000! E:>6;H:!
/0-0²:1?!H>6C9!ANUM!!
!
!
a;>E:4>36>4<!E:4!)49?;?!12?6!
@4369?E>1E4@!E:1E!E:4!?E1E4!67!)12876>981!
:6;?4?!1JJ>6L831E42D!-]!3822869!Q1E896?W!
67!C:85:!Q1E896?!31F4!;J!AhMbU!67!
&DOLIRUQLD¶VSRSXODWLRQ/LNHZLVH7H[DV
:1?!1!21>H4!Q1E896!J6J;21E869!67!N!3822869<!
28F4!)12876>981<!12?6!569?E8E;E89H!AhMbU!67!
8E?!89:1G8E19E?M!'4?41>5:!:1?!89@851E4@!
E:1E!Q1E896?!569E89;4!E6!28=4!89!E:4!
76226C89H!?E1E4?\!(>8T691<!)12876>981<!
)626>1@6<!a26>8@1<!.228968?<!"4C!Z4L856<!
"4C!i4>?4D<!"4C!k6>F<!19@!&4L1?M!!
!
5'%2;*(E#A*=&'I32.$(2;(%3#(ZJ+J(
OD!O81951!O4>>86T1G12!
!
!
!
!
.9! /0-0! E:4! #M%M! )49?;?! >4=4124@!
E:1E! E:4! Q1E896! J6J;21E869! :1@! H>6C9! E6!
S0MS! 3822869<! C:85:! +>674??6>! "1=1>>6!
?E1E4?!E:1E!E:4!15E;12!9;3G4>!>4J>4?49E?!19!
;9@4>56;9E! 19@! 8?! 1! 569?4>=1E8=4! 78H;>4M!
Z6>46=4>! E:4! /000! )49?;?! >4=4124@! 1!
91E869C8@4! Q1E896! J6J;21E869! 67! ASMA!
3822869<! C:85:! @4369?E>1E4?! E:1E! C8E:89!
E:4!E49!D41>!H1J!G4EC449!E:4!/000!)49?;?!
19@! E:4! /0-0! )49?;?<! E:4>4! C1?! -SM/!
3822869! Q1E896! J6J;21E869! H>6CE:M! &:4!
+4C!B8?J1985!)49E4>!1996;954@!89!Z1>5:!
E:1E! Q1E896?! 31F4! ;J! -bMAU! 67! E:4!
QDWLRQ¶VWRWDOSRSXODWLRQRIZKLFKLWJUHZ
SbU!89!E:4!E834!21J?4!67!E49!D41>?M!!
!
+46J24! 67! 5626>! J>4?49E2D!
FRQVWLWXWH RI WKH QDWLRQ¶V
J6J;21E869W! C:4>41?! C:8E4?! 31F4! ;J!
cMAU!67!E:4!E6E12!J6J;21E869M!B6C4=4>!67!
E:4! S0MS! 3822869! Q1E896?! E:1E! E:4! )49?;?!
56;9E4@!89!/0-0<!E:4!31Y6>8ED!7122?!89!E:4!
Z4L8519! 6>! 67! Z4L8519! @4?549E! 51E4H6>D!
1@@89H! ;J! E6! bbU! 67! E:4! Q1E896!
G>41F@6C9M! &:4! Q1E896! J6J;21E869! :1?!
?;>J1??4@! E:1E! 67! E:4! G215F! J6J;21E869!
31F89H! ;J! AhMh! 3822869<! 1! -/Mc! 3822869!
@8774>4954!G4EC449!E:4!EC6M!!
!
.9! 56952;?869<! E:4>4! 8?! 96! G4EE4>!
J>667! E:19! E:4! )49?;?! 56;9E! 8E?427! E6!
@4369?E>1E4!E:4!@436H>1J:85!5:19H4!E:1E!
E:4!#M%M!8?!;9@4>H689HM!i;?E!28F4!Z4L8519?!
19@!"1E8=4!(34>8519?!C4>4!6;E9;3G4>4@!
89! E:48>! 6C9! 219@! G476>4! E:4! &>41ED! 67!
,;1@12;J4! B8@12H6<! Q1E896?! 1>4! >1J8@2D!
6;E9;3G4>89H! E:43! 89! E:48>! 6C9! 56;9E>D!
1?!C422M!!!&6!J>6=4!E:8?<!Y;?E!E1F4!1!266F!1E!
E:4! -hM-! 3822869! 5:82@>49! G426C! E:4! 1H4?!
67! -h! E:1E! C4>4! 89E>6@;54@! E6! E:4! #M%M!
E:>6;H:6;E! E:4! E49! D41>?! 17E4>! E:4! /000!
&HQVXV«!
!
(2E:6;H:!89!J>4=86;?!D41>?!E:4!
9;3G4>!67!Q1E896?!28=89H!89!E:4?4!?E1E4?!
C1?!:8H:4>!19@!:1?!@83898?:4@!6=4>!E:4!
D41>?!E:48>!J>4?4954!:1?!G449!>456>@4@!89!
6E:4>!1>41?!67!E:4!?6;E:41?E!28F4!(21G131<!
(>F19?1?<!j49E;5FD<!Z8??8??8JJ8<!"6>E:!
)1>62891<!&4994??44<!19@!%6;E:!)1>62891!
1?!E:4!?E1E4?!C8E:!E:4!21>H4?E!J4>549E!
H>6CE:M!!
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!A0!!
!
ZJ+J(X;%#&8#;%2*;(\(<#]2.*(E&"=()'&%#/$(
OD!O81951!O4>>86T1G12!
&:4>4! :1?! G449! 1! 26E! 67! E12F! 1G6;E! 1! J6??8G24! #M%M! 3828E1>D! 89E4>=49E869! 89! E:4! C1>!
1H189?E!@>;H?!89!Z4L856M!Z19D!:1=4!56952;@4@!E:1E!E:4!#M%M!?:6;2@!89E4>=494!?8954!E:4D!E66!1>4!
1E! 71;2EW! J>831>82D! G451;?4! E:4D! 1>4! E:4! 21>H4?E! 569?;34>?! 19@! ?4569@2D! G451;?4! E:4D! 1>4! E:4!
21>H4?E!1>E8224>D!J>6=8@4>M!!(96E:4>!>41?69!E:4D!H8=4!8?!E:1E!Z4L856!8?!94LE!@66>!E6!E:4!#M%M!19@!
E:1E!C4!?:6;2@!:42J!G451;?4!C4!56;2@!E66!G45634!17745E4@<!12?6!G451;?4!67!741>!67!E4>>6>8?3<!19@!
=8624954!?28JJ89H!E:>6;H:!E:4!G6>@4>M!a;>E:4>36>4<!6E:4>?!G4284=4!E:1E!E:4!Z4L8519!H6=4>9349E!
:1?! 96E! G449! 1G24! E6! 569E>62! 6>! 49@! E:4! C1>! 69! @>;H?! C8E:! >8=12! 51>E42?! 4=49! C8E:! E:4! ]S<000v!
E>66J?! @8?J1E5:4@M! ! .9?E41@<! E:4D! 1>H;4! E:1E! a428J4! )12@4>w9! 19@! :8?! 1@3898?E>1E869! :1=4! G449!
XQVXFFHVVIXO DW VROYLQJ DQ\ RI 0H[LFR¶V SUREOHPV ,Q DGGLWLRQ WKH\ EHOLHYH WKDW 0H[LFDQV DUH
8951J1G24!67!?;?E18989H!1!H6=4>9349EM!
!
.9!569E>1?E!E6!E:6?4!C:6!G4284=4!E:1E!+>4?8@49E!)12@4>w9!:1?!G449!;9?;554??7;2!1E!5>41E89H!1!
36>4!?E>1E4H85!J219!1H189?E!E:4!@>;H!51>E42?<!E:4>4!1>4!E:6?4!C:6!1>H;4!E:1E!:4!:1?!15563J28?:4@!36>4!
E:19!J>4=86;?!J>4?8@49E?M!!B8?!1@3898?E>1E869!1269H!C8E:!E:4!1>34@!76>54?!:1=4!G449!?;554??7;2!1E!
FDSWXULQJVHYHUDOPHPEHUVRI0H[LFR¶VRUJDQL]HGFULPHOLNH(GJDU³/D%DUELH´9DOGH]9LFHQWH
=DPEDGD7HRGRUR*DUFLD6LPHQWDO,JQDFLR³1DFKR´&RURQHO$UWXUR%HOWUDQ/H\YDDQG&DUORV
O42E>19!Q4D=1<!1369H!6E:4>?M!!(2?6<!E:4>4!1>4!E:6?4!C:6!?E>69H2D!G4284=4!E:1E!E:4!#M%M!?:6;2@!96E!
89E4>=494!G451;?4!67!45696385!19@!G;@H4E!J;>J6?4?M!!
B6C4=4>! C:1E! E:4?4! 563349E1E6>?! :1=4! 96E! E1F49! 89E6! 569?8@4>1E869! 8?! E:1E! 28F4! E:8?!
56;9E>D<!Z4L856!E66<!:1?!H6=4>9349E12!J628584?!E:1E!51996E!G4!=8621E4@!6>!6=4>>;24@!Y;?E!G451;?4!E:4!
#98E4@!%E1E4?!?1D?!?6M!a6>!89?E1954<!694!67!E:43!J>6:8G8E?!76>48H9!3828E1>D!E>66J?!E6!?E4J!69!Z4L8519!
?682M!.9!3D!6J89869!87!E:4!#98E4@!%E1E4?!C4>4!E6!89E4>=494!89!E:4!C1>!1H189?E!@>;H?!89!Z4L856!96E!692D!
C822! 8E! G4! ;9?;554??7;2<! 8E! C822! G4! @8?1?E>6;?<! 5:16E85<! 19@! 71E12M! a8>?E! 67! 122! E:4! @>;H! 51>E42?! C822!
>4E1281E4!1H189?E!E:4!#M%M!3828E1>D!E>66J?M!%4569@2D<!E:4!51>E42?!C6;2@!?41>5:!76>!6E:4>!341?;>4?!E:1E!
C6;2@!H4E!>8@!67!E:4!#M%M!E>66J?<!76>!4L13J24<!4LE6>E869<!E6>E;>4<!3;>@4><!19@!F8@91J<!1369H!6E:4>?<!67!
WRXULVWVDQGVROGLHUV7KLUGO\0H[LFR¶VFLWL]HQVFRXOGIHHOUHSUHVVHGXQFRPIRUWDEOHDQGXQZLOOLQJWR
566J4>1E4M! &:4! J>4?4954! 67! E:4! #M%M! 3828E1>D! 89! E:48>! 56;9E>D! 56;2@! 3419! 1! 28?E! 67! E:89H?! E6! E:43W!
89?E41@!67!744289H!E:1E!E:4!#M%M!31D!G4!H689H!89!E6!:42J!6;E<!E:4D!31D!H4E!E:4!8@41!E:1E!8E!8?!C8E:!E:4!
?624!J;>J6?4!67!H18989H!7;>E:4>!1554??!19@!4?E1G28?:89H!E:43?42=4?!E:4>4!28F4!E:4D!:1=4!@694!89!6E:4>!
56;9E>84?M!
a;>E:4>36>4<!E:8?!519!12?6!J>6@;54!6E:4>!47745E?!28F4!>4?49E349E!1369H!E:4!Z4L8519!3828E1>D!
19@!J62854!E6C1>@?!E:4!Z4L8519!H6=4>9349E!19@!56;2@!J6??8G2D!51;?4!E:4!3828E1>D!19@!J62854!E6!Y689!
76>54?! C8E:! E:4! 51>E42?M! *9! 1! ?83821>! 96E4<! E6;>8?3! :1?! @452894@! E:>6;H:6;E! E:4! J1?E! D41>?! @;4! E6!
6>H198T4@!5>834!19@!@>;H!C1>?M!&:4!89E4>=49E869!67!E:4!#M%M!3828E1>D!56;2@!3419!E:4!49@!76>!E6;>8?3!
89!Z4L856M!.E!8?!83J6>E19E!E6!7;22D!4LJ26>4!E:4!J6??8G828E84?!19@!J>6G1G828E84?!67!4=49E?!E:1E!56;2@!1>8?4<!
?;5:!1?!E:4!694?!349E8694@<!G476>4!31F89H!19D!@458?869M!(2E:6;H:<!E:4!#M%M!8?!71>!7>63!G489H!89=8E4@!
89E6!Z4L856!C4!:1=4!H6E!E6!83J4@4!E:4!#M%M!7>63!4=4>!49E4>89H!Z4L856!?8954!8E!56;2@!G>89H!;?!36>4!
38?76>E;94!E:19!C:1E!C4!12>41@D!F96CM!!!
)*;42%2*;$(,*&('(PR$%()#;%"&0(+*.2'/(<*8#A#;%(
!
):85196eQ1E896?!7154!1!569@8E869!67!J628E8512!19@!24H8?21E8=4!C1>M!
$UL]RQD¶VVHQDWRU5XVVHOO3HDUFHKDVEHHQWKHLJQLWHUWKLVKRVWLOHSROLWLFDOZLOGILUH
$FURVVWKHQDWLRQVWDWHVDUHGHYHORSLQJODZVWKDWWDUJHW/DWLQR¶VZKRDUH
J4>548=4@!E6!G4!;9@65;349E4@M!(E!E:4!76>47>69E!67!E:8?!J628E8512!36=4349E!8?!
569?4>=1E8=4<!E41!J1>ED!G1?4@!>4J;G28519?!C:6!7442!89?45;>4!1G6;E!E:4!91E869?!
5:19H89H!@436H>1J:85?M!(?!1!>4?;2E<!>4J;G28519?!1>4!J628E85122D!6>H198T4@!19@!
KDYHSHUSHWXDWHG&KLFDQR/DWLQR¶VDVDQDWLRQDOWKUHDW$VWKHWDUJHWDQGYLFWLPV
RIOHJLVODWLYHRQVODXJKWV&KLFDQR/DWLQR¶VQHHGWRHVWDEOLVKDFRXQWHUYDLOLQJ
PRYHPHQWWKDWZLOOVHFXUHWKHFLYLOULJKWVRI/DWLQR¶VIURPFRQVHUYDWLYH
1HH>4??6>?M!#)'!$E:985!%E;@84?!J>674??6><!(>319@6!"1=1>>6!@4?5>8G4?!1!
J1>1@8H3!76>!569?E>;5E89H!1!94C!36=4349E!G1?4@!69!E:4!569@8E869?!>47245E89H!
52831E4!67!5:19H4<!241@4>?:8J<!6>H198T1E869<!8@4626HD<!?E>1E4HDeE15E85?!19@!J6C4>!
FDSDELOLW\&RQVLGHULQJWKHVL[FRQGLWLRQV&KLFDQR/DWLQR¶VDFFRPSOLVKRQO\WKH
FOLPDWHRIFKDQJHDFRQGLWLRQWKDWUHTXLUHVQRWKLQJIRU/DWLQR¶VWRGRDVD
5633;98EDM!!
!
7KHREMHFWLYHIRU&KLFDQR/DWLQR¶VWREXLOGDFRXQWHUYDLOLQJPRYHPHQWLV
WRUHFRJQL]HWKHSROLWLFDOO\KRVWLOHDWPRVSKHUH$VDSHRSOH&KLFDQR/DWLQR¶V
56;2@!96E!G4!36>4!@8=8@4@!19@!;96>H198T4@M!#98ED!19@!6>H198T1E869!:1?!G45634!1!
E:89H!67!E:4!J1?EM!a6>!319D<!J46J24!:1=4!G45634!563J21549E!C8E:!C:1E!28EE24!E:4D!
:1=4<!G289@4@!GD!1!5:1;=898?E85!91E869!E:1E!1@=651E4?!7>44@63W!569?586;?94??!76>!1!
G4EE4>!E636>>6C!:1?!G45634!6G?5;>4@M!Q41@4>?:8J!:1?!319874?E4@!89E6!
6>H198T1E869?!E:1E!569?8@4>!?65812!36=4349E?!E66!>1@8512!76>!3189?E>413!(34>851M!
,QDGGLWLRQ&KLFDQR/DWLQR¶VKDYHEHFRPHIUDJPHQWHGLQWRGLIIHUHQWLGHRORJLHV
E:1E!67E49!@6!96E!569?8@4>!E:4!G4EE4>349E!67!E:48>!J46J24M!.9?E41@<!/- ?E!549E;>D!
):85196eQ1E896!1?!C422!1?!6E:4>!4E:985!H>6;J?!1>E85;21E4!E:48>!8@4626HD!G1?4@!69!
LQWHUHVWRU³9LYD<R´PHQWDOLW\6WUDWHJLFDOO\FRQVWUXFWLQJDVRFLDOPRYHPHQWDQG
DOORZLQJLWWRKDYHLW¶VSRZHUFDSDELOLW\LVQRQP4L8?E49E!89!Q1E896!5633;98E84?M!
!
!:LWKWKHLQFUHDVHRISRSXODWLRQVSHFLILFDOO\0H[LFDQR/DWLQR¶V
569?4>=1E8=4!(34>851!8?!96E!J>4J1>4@!E6!>4241?4!E:48>!@638919E!8972;4954!69!E:4!
91E869M!):85196eQ1E896?!?:6;2@!>456H98T4!E:4!83J6>E1954!67!569?E>;5E89H!1!
36=4349E!E:1E!C822!?26C!E:4!569?4>=1E8=4PULJKWV¶SROLWLFDOOHJLVODWLYHZDUZKLFK
49@19H4>?!6;>!G>6C9!5633;98E84?!15>6??!E:4!91E869M!K822!D6;!G4!>41@D!E6!H4E!
89=62=4@I!
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
OD!$@C1>@!(>422196!
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!A-!!
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
!
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!A/!!
!
i6:9!Z5)189`?!K82@78>4!(55;?1E869?!!
OD\!'6G4>E6!V>M!)89E28!'6@>8H;4T!
O(8,$"2Q.5*(.KB3,+$3"C.PB"(.D_C.DE__!
&:4!(>8T691!?491E6>!155;?4?!Z4L8519!8338H>19E?!67!?E1>E89H!
C82@78>4?<!G;E!:4!8?!719989H!E:4!72134?!:83?427!±!67!J>4Y;@854!
!
i6:9!Z5)189!?18@!E:4>4!C1?!`?;G?E19E812!4=8@4954`!289F89H!C82@78>4?!89!
(>8T691!E6!8224H12!8338H>19E?M!+:6E6H>1J:\!i691E:19!$>9?Ee'4;E4>?!
V64?!8E!?;>J>8?4!19D694!E:1E!(>8T691!%491E6>!i6:9!Z5)189!:1?!
G2134@!;9@65;349E4@!8338H>19E?!76>!E:4!C82@78>4?!89!:8?!?E1E4I!
B1>@!45696385!E834?!@>8=4?!@4?J4>1E4!J46J24!E6!@6!@4?J4>1E4!E:89H?M!
7KURZLQWKHVXEMHFWRILPPLJUDWLRQDQGDOLWWOHELWRI[HQRSKRELD«
19@!?:1TT13g!k6;!:1=4!E:4!>458J4!76>!1!J628E8512!8@4626HD\!G2134!E:4!
Z4L8519?g!%49@!E:1E!>458J4!89E6!(>8T691!19@!D6;!:1=4!E:4!J4>745E!
?E6>3\!
!
8QHGXFDWHGDQGXQDEOHWRILQGD>KLJK!"#$%&'()*+,-)./#01)231)
Z4L8519?M!
6RFLDOVHFXULW\DQG0HGLFDUHJRLQJEURNH"<XSLW
VWKH0H[LFDQV)
7HUURULVPLQWKH0LGGOH(DVWKDV\RXXSDWQLJKW"%ODPHWKH
Z4L8519?!76>!D6;>!89?63981<!?49@!E>66J?!19@!C122!E:4!#%PZ4L856!
G6>@4>M!
&ULPHGUXJXVDJHDQGFRPPXQLFDEOHGLVHDVHVRQWKHULVH"<RX
F96C!E:4!19?C4>M!
O21389H!Z4L8519?<!6>!n8224H12!12849?n<!8?!1!E>1@8E869!:4>4W!19@!89!
*HRUJLDDQG$ODEDPDWRR«WKHZKROHFRXQWU\UHDOO\/DVW\HDU
Z5)189!521834@!E:1E!n8224H12!12849?n!C4>4!89E49E869122D!51;?89H!
1558@49E?!69!7>44C1D?M!
!
!
!
Z5)189`?!5:1>H4?!>41@!28F4!5634@D!G;E!:4>4!89!(>8T691<!8338H>1E869!
8?!?4>86;?!G;?894??!±!19@!?6!8?!?51J4H61E89HM!.E!8?!s%:4>877!i64t!(>J186!
56;9E>D<!C:4>4!>15812!J>678289H!8?!(34>8519!1?!1JJ24!J84M!.E!8?!E:8?!
?E1E4!E:1E!H1=4!;?!%O!-0h0!±!G1?4@!89!21>H4!J1>E!69!E:4!;9J>6=49!
1224H1E869!E:1E!(>8T691!>195:4>!'6G4>E!j>49ET!C1?!F8224@!GD!n8224H12!
12849?nM!(31T89H2D<!196E:4>!C:6JJ4>!C1?!569Y;>4@!;J!694!C44F!17E4>!
%O!-0h0!C1?!?8H94@!±!E:1E!1!+8912!)6;9ED!?:4>877`?!@4J;ED!:1@!G449!
?:6E!GD!Z4L8519!@>;H!?3;HH24>?!^E:4!8958@49E!C1?!?427P897285E4@_M!
(9@!EC6!C44F?!G476>4!%O!-0h0!C1?!?4E!E6!H6!89E6!47745E<!,6=4>96>!
i19!O>4C4>!G4H19!E6!C1>9!J46J24!1G6;E!789@89H!:41@24??!G6@84?!89!E:4!
(>8T691!@4?4>EM!O;E!E:4!719E1?E8512!E124?!@69`E!49@!E:4>4\!89!E:8?!?E1E4<!
8E`?!96E!4=49!E:1E!Z4L8519!38H>19E?!1>4!712?42D!G2134@!76>!>412!
J>6G243?W!E:4D!1>4!12?6!G2134@!76>!89=49E4@!J>6G243?M!V191!Z82G19F!
7>63!E:4!K1?:89HE69!+6?E!C>8E4?!1G6;E!E:8?\!
!
!nO6>@4>!=8624954!69!E:4!>8?4I!+:6498L!G456389H!E:4!C6>2@`?!"6!/!F8@91JJ89H!51J8E12I!.224H12!8338H>19E?!>4?J69?8G24!76>!36?E!J62854!
F82289H?I!&:4!31Y6>8ED!67!E:6?4!5>6??89H!E:4!G6>@4>!1>4!@>;H!3;24?I!(22!C>69HMn!
+4>!E:4!aO.<!C4!F96C!E:1E!E:4!G6>@4>!>4H869!8?!?174>!E:19!8E!C1?!1!@451@4!1H6<!19@!E:1E!319D!67!E:4!?174?E!#%!58E84?!1>4!1269H!E:4!#%PZ4L856!
G6>@4>M!O;E!C:49!8E!5634?!E6!7;4289H!L496J:6G81!89!E:8?!56;9E>D<!715E?!94=4>!H4E!89!E:4!C1DM!
a6>!4L13J24<!&;5?69`?!:8H:2D!?;554??7;2!Z4L8519!(34>8519!%E;@84?!J>6H>1334!8?!69!E:4!=4>H4!67!G489H!4283891E4@!G451;?4!6;>!5;>>49E!
1EE6>94D!H494>12<!&63!B6>94<!:1?!269H!3189E1894@!E:1E!E:4!521??4?!76349E!>4=62;E869!^n[8=1!):4gn_M!(!>4549E!89@4J49@49E!1;@8E!76;9@!122!E:4!
5:1>H4?!1H189?E!E:4!J>6H>1334!E6!G4!712?4M!
!
n.224H12!12849?n!51;?89H!(>8T691!C82@78>4?I!K:824!E:4!#%!a6>4?E!%4>=854!:1?!31@4!96!?;5:!52183<!Z5)189!19@!:8?!8@4626H8512!?;JJ6>E4>?!
C6;2@!:1=4!;?!1554JE!:8?!?J45;21E869!1?!715EM!K:1E`?!94LEI!O21389H!Z4L8519?!76>!895>41?4@!?;9!?J6E!15E8=8EDI !
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!AA!!
!
!
(
(
:RPHQ¶V+DLUFXW(
0HQ¶V+DLUFXW(
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!A]!!
!
7;'%*A0(*,('(M&'=2.*A2.(94".'%2*;'/(@2%.3L3";%(
OD\!'6G4>E6!V>M!)89E28!'6@>8H;4T!
O(8,$"2Q./'0A%802C.PB"(._`C.DE__!
!
$UL]RQD¶VYLFLRXVSROLWLFVLQUHJDUGVWRWKHOHJDOLW\RI
7XFVRQ¶VKLJKO\VXFFHVVIXO0H[LFDQ$PHULFDQ6WXGLHV
^Z(%_!J>6H>13!:1=4!96C!>415:4@!E:4!24=42!67!
E>1H85634@DM!
!
V4?J8E4!19!89@4J49@49E!1;@8E!H8=89H!Z(%!EC6!E:;3G?!;J!
±!789@89H!E:1E!n96!6G?4>=1G24!4=8@4954!C1?!J>4?49E!E6!
?;HH4?E!E:1E!19D!521??>663!C8E:89!&;5?69!#98784@!%5:662!
'LVWULFWLVLQGLUHFWYLRODWLRQRIWKHODZ´±!(>8T691!%E1E4!
%;J4>89E49@49E<!i6:9!B;JJ49E:12<!?E822!3191H4@!E6!H8=4!
G6E:!E:4!J>6H>13!19@!E:4!R--0<000!1;@8E!EC6!38@@24!
789H4>?M!
$ORWRIXVDUHVWDUWLQJWRPLVV+XSSHQWKDO¶VSUHGHFHVVRU
&63!B6>94M!K8E:!:83<!D6;!56;2@!12C1D?!56;9E!69!:83!76>!
1!H66@!21;H:!±!28F4!E:4!E834!^12C1D?_!:4!521834@!E:1E!:4!
C1?!1EE43JE89H!E6!@8?319E24!$E:985!%E;@84?!89!(>8T691!89!
E:4!?J8>8E!67!Z1>E89!Q;E:4>!j89H!i>M<!6>!E:4!E834!:4!521834@!
E:1E!21G6>!241@4><!V626>4?!B;4>E1<!:1@!G449!)4?1>!
&KDYH]¶VJLUOIULHQG!
!
:LWK+XSSHQWKDORQWKHRWKHUKDQG\RXGRQ¶WNQRZ
ZKHWKHULW¶V*URXQG+RJ'D\RU7KHDWHURIWKH$EVXUG
(7E4>!?8EE89H!69!E:4!>4?;2E?!67!E:4!-/0PJ1H4!1;@8E!GD!Z8138
PG1?4@!)13G8;3!Q41>989H!76>!?634!b!C44F?<!:4!:42@!1!
J>4??!56974>4954!69!i;94!-S!E6!@8?5>4@8E!:8?!6C9!
56338??8694@!1;@8EM!K:49!1?F4@!E6!J>6@;54!E:4!1;@8E<!8E!
C1?!569=49849E2D!;91=1821G24M!a6>!H66@!>41?69M!&:4!1;@8E!
15E;122D!J>18?4?!Z(%M!V4?J8E4!E:8?<!:4!;9821E4>122D!
@4521>4@!Z(%!E6!G4!6;E?8@4!67!E:4!21C<!H8=89H!E:4!@8?E>85E!
b0!@1D?!E6!563J2D!6>!42?4!26?4!R-S!3822869M!
!
,IWKLVZHUHDSOD\LWZRXOGEHWLWOHG³-RKQQ\FDQ¶WUHDG´
RU³6D\LWDLQ¶WVR-RKQ´!
!
.E!51996E!G4!76>H6EE49!E:1E!BO!//c-!C1?!@4?8H94@!GD!
B6>94!C8E:!694!?J458785!J;>J6?4!89!389@W!E6!@4521>4!
7XFVRQ¶V0$6SURJUDPLOOHJDO7KXVRQLWVIDFH+%
8?!;9569?E8E;E86912M!
!
&:4!?4569@!E:89H!E6!>4343G4>!8?!E:1E!E:4!J;>J6?4!67!E:4!
DXGLWZDV³WRGHWHUPLQHZKHWKHUWKH0H[LFDQ$PHULFDQ
6WXGLHV'HSDUWPHQW¶VFXUULFXOXPLVLQFRPSOLDQFHZLWK
(M'M%M!-SP$´±!^J1H4!]!67!1;@8E_M!(9@!C:1E!E:4!
1;@8E!76;9@!8?!E:1E!E:4!J>6H>13!8?!89!563J281954!G451;?4!8E!
@64?!96E!=8621E4!19D!67!E:4!76;>!J>6=8?869?!67!BO!//c-!
^J1H4!SA_M!&:4!J>6=8?869?!J>6:8G8E!521??4?!E:1E\!
!
!
x!1@=651E4!E:4!6=4>E:>6C!67!E:4!#98E4@!%E1E4?!
H6=4>9349EM!
x!J>636E4!>4?49E349E!E6C1>@!1!>154!6>!521??!67!
J46J24M!
x!1>4!@4?8H94@!J>831>82D!76>!J;J82?!67!1!
J1>E85;21>!4E:985!>154M!
x!1@=651E4!4E:985!?628@1>8ED!89?E41@!67!E:4!
E>41E349E!67!J;J82?!1?!89@8=8@;12?M!
!
.E!8?!B;JJ49E:12!E:1E!76;9@!Z(%!89!=8621E869!67!
E:4!21?E!E:>44!J>6=8?869?!67!E:4!21CM!
'43898?549E!67!E:4!.9d;8?8E869<!Z(%!:1?!G449!
@4521>4@!E6!G4!8224H12!96E!G451;?4!8E!8?!8224H12<!
G;E!>1E:4><!G451;?4!B;JJ49E:12!:1?!;9821E4>122D!
@4521>4@!8E!?6M!
K:49!,6=4>96>!i19!O>4C4>!?8H94@!BO!//c-!
89E6!21C!69!Z1D!-/<!/0-0<!E:4!=4>D!94LE!@1D<!
&#%V!67785812?!J>6;@2D!J>6521834@!E:1E!E:4!
GLVWULFW¶V0$6SURJUDPZDVLQIXOOFRPSOLDQFH
%8954!E:49<!E:4>4!:1?!G449!96!?E;@D!E6!
FRQWUDYHQHWKLVILQGLQJLQFOXGLQJ+XSSHQWKDO¶V
6C9!1;@8EM!B6C!:4!1>>8=4@!1E!:8?!@4E4>3891E869!
8?!6G=86;?W!:4!36=4@!E:4!H612J6?E?M!K:1E!8?!
38??89H!89!E:8?!J>654??!8?!E>19?J1>495D!^&:4!
()Q#!:1?!?;4@!E6!6GE189!E:4!1;@8E!>456>@?!E6!
@4E4>3894!C:1E!5>8E4>81!:4!;?4@!E6!8H96>4!E:4!
1;@8E_M!B;JJ49E:12!8?!E:4!?134!319!C:6!
FDPSDLJQHGWR³VWRS/D5D]D´,QKLVRZQ
789@89H<!569E>1>D!E6!E:4!1;@8E<!:4!76;9@!E:1E!
0$6PDWHULDOV³UHSHDWHGO\UHIHUWRZKLWH
SHRSOHDVEHLQJµWKHRSSUHVVRUV¶DQG
µRSSUHVVLQJ¶WKH/DWLQRSHRSOH´,IWKHWHUP
³RSSUHVVRUV´ERWKHUVKLPSHUKDSVZHFDQFRPH
;J!C8E:!196E:4>!E4>3M!k4E<!8E!8?!6G=86;?!E:1E!8E!8?!
E:4!:8?E6>85!>421E869?:8J!67!894d;128ED!E:1E!:4!
6GY45E?!E6!G489H!E1;H:EM!
,Q+XSSHQWKDO¶VDQG+RUQH¶V$PHULFDWRSLFV
?;5:!1?!H49658@4<!219@!E:47E<!?21=4>D<!2D95:89H?<!
76>54@!>436=12?!67!J6J;21E869?!19@!31??!
@4J6>E1E869?<!i83!)>6C!?4H>4H1E869!19@!
24H128T4@!@8?5>83891E869!1>4!1JJ1>49E2D!6;E!67!
G6;9@?M!(9@!E:4!:;319!>8H:E?!?E>;HH24?!E6!
6=4>5634!E:4?4!89Y;?E854?!1>4!1JJ1>49E2D!12?6!
6;E!67!G6;9@?M!
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
OD!8H96>89H!:8?!6C9!1;@8E<!B;JJ49E:12!:1?<!89!
47745E<!8??;4@!1!-S00?P4>1!(;E6!@4!a4!±!1!C8E5:P
:;9E!19@!1!5122!E6!549?6>!G66F?<!5;>>85;2;3?!19@!
521??>663?M!&:4!E>1H85634@D!67!E:8?!?8E;1E869!8?!
WKDW786'¶VVFKRROERDUGDQGLWVVXSHULQWHQGHQW
i6:9!+4@85694<!:1=4!G449!?44389H2D!>1589H!E6!
@8?319E24!Z(%!7>63!C8E:89<!^1EE43JE89H!E6!31F4!
Z(%!521??4?!4245E8=4?_<!4=49!>4?6>E89H!E6!E:4!
31??8=4!;?4!67!76>54!^Z1D!A!?5:662!G61>@!
344E89H_!E6!4976>54!E:48>!J>6J6?4@!5:19H4?M!
.958@49E122D<!E:4!1;@8E!>4563349@?!E:1E!E:4!
521??4?!>43189!J1>E!67!E:4!56>4!5;>>85;2;3_M!
!
O4D69@!E:4!:1E4!E:1E!BO!//c-!:1?!;9241?:4@<!?E822!
E6!G4!@4E4>3894@!89!1!56;>E>663!8?!96E!C:4E:4>!
Z(%!8?!89!563J281954!C8E:!BO!//c-<!G;E!>1E:4><!
C:4E:4>!E:4!21C!8?!569?E8E;E86912!^&:4!(56?E1!
21C?;8E_M!&:4!1;@8E!@64?!96E!15E;122D!E15F24!E:1E!
d;4?E869M!)63J281954!1??;34?!E:1E!Z(%!?:6;2@!
DGKHUHWR+RUQH¶V*UHFRP'6319!=12;4?M!&:4!
96E869!E:1E!Z(%!?:6;2@!E>41E!?E;@49E?!1?!
89@8=8@;12?!8?!1!5191>@W!E:4D!1>4!E>41E4@!1?!
89@8=8@;12?<!19@!1E!E:4!?134!E834<!122!89@8=8@;12?!
J6??4??!1!5;2E;>4!19@!122!5;2E;>4!8?!562245E8=4M!(9@!
89!51?4!B;JJ49E:12<!B6>94!19@!+4@85694!:1=4!96E!
12?6!96E854@<!E:4!>8H:E!E6!5;2E;>4<!4@;51E869<!
219H;1H4<!:8?E6>D!19@!8@49E8ED!1>4!J>6E45E4@!GD!1E!
241?E!N!89E4>91E86912!:;319!>8H:E?!E>41E84?!19@!
569=49E869?M!!
!
K:824!E:4!1;@8E!8?!15E;122D!1!>4?6;9@89H!
1778>31E869!67!Z4L8519!(34>8519!%E;@84?P&#%V<!
E:4!>4J6>E!@64?!:1=4!196E:4>!31Y6>!721C!E:1E!
51996E!H6!;919?C4>4@W!8E!1@=651E4?!E:1E!E:4!
ZRUGV³5D]D6WXGLHV´EHUHPRYHGIURPWKH
SURJUDP¶VGRFXPHQWDWLRQWKLVZDVDOUHDG\GRQH
89!/0-0_M!.E!@64?!96E!4LJ2189!C:D!19@!>41@?!28F4!1!
51=4P89!E6!>8H:E!C89H!8@4626HDM!&:4!1@6JE869!6>!
>4Y45E869!67!?;5:!E4>389626HD!±!C:85:!56996E4?!
E:4!38LE;>4!67!122!>154?!19@!E:4!19E8PE:4?8?!67!
J;>8ED!±!?:6;2@!G4!;J!E6!J46J24?!19@!5633;98E84?!
E6!@458@4<!>1E:4>!E:19!1?!@8>45E8=4?!E6!G4!83J6?4@!
GD!1;@8E6>?!;97138281>!C8E:!E:4!@8?58J2894M!!
!
OD!8974>4954<!563J281954!56996E4?!E:1E!
J>636E89H!;98ED!1369H?E!s122t!J46J24?!8?!G1@!19@!
E:1E!5>8E8512!E:89F89H!19@!78H:E89H!76>!?65812!Y;?E854!
1>4!12?6!G1@M!&6!563J2D!C8E:!?;5:!1!21C!?4E?!1!
G1@!J>454@49EM!
!
V4?J8E4!E:8?!19@!@4?J8E4!B;JJ49E:12<!E:4!1;@8E!
?6;9@?!28F4!=85E6>D!76>!Z(%P&#%VM!
'6@>8H;4T<!1!J>674??6>!1E!E:4!#98=4>?8ED!67!
(>8T691<!519!G4!>415:4@!1E\!
y)62;39zH3182M563!!
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!AS!!
!
!
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
%+'.",!/0--!
!
+(,$!Ab!!
"#$%&'(!)*%(!!
!
%+'.",!/0--!
6" Taller GN Riser