New York, NY - Lodging Econometrics
Transcription
New York, NY - Lodging Econometrics
New York, NY Open & Operating Hotels (Census) Market Trend Report Total Open & Operating Hotels US Rank Development Pipeline US Rank Total Construction Pipeline (1) Projects Rooms 135 23,576 59 10,172 27 5,003 49 8,401 • Brand Conversions • Announced Renovations 5 17 • Total Transactions Hotel Size • Greater than 200 Rooms • 200 Rooms or Less m Sa Recent Real Estate Activity 2,096 8,309 Hotels Rooms 19 5,916 503 100,127 147 48,233 133 15,673 223 36,221 Market Metrics pl • Under Construction • Start Next 12 Months • Early Planning Chain Scale • Luxury, Upper Upscale & Upscale • Midscale & Economy • Independents Rooms e Q2 2012 (7) Hotels Leading Brands • Comfort Inn • Hampton Inn 143 64,170 360 35,957 19 11 1,388 1,809 Leading Ownership & Mgmt Groups (Hotels in this Market) • Marriott International Inc 22 8,179 • Hersha Hospitality Management 21 3,132 National Ownership & Mgmt Groups (Resident in Market) • Centerbridge Partners LP 663 73,556 • Whitehall Street Global Real Estate LP 129 21,134 Le’s Real Estate Intelligence Is Your Strategic Advantage 500 Market Street, Suite 13, Portsmouth, NH, 03801 USA p: 603.431.8740, Ext 25 | f: 603.431.4418 | e: [email protected] | www.lodgingeconometrics.com © Lodging Econometrics 2012 New York NY Market Trend Report Q2 2012 pl Section 1: Construction Pipeline Summaries • Pipeline Metrics • Market Tracts by Chain Scale e Construction Pipeline: Sa m Section 2: Individual Construction Pipeline Project Records • Prior Hotel Openings • Under Construction • To Start in the Next 12 Months • Early Planning • Halted Construction • Cancelled • Postponed Section 3: Other Development – Individual Project Records • Projects with Residential, Condo Hotel or Timeshare Units • Brand Conversions • Announced Renovations 500 Market Street, Suite 13 | Portsmouth, NH 03801-3481 USA | p: +1 603.431.8740, ext. 25 | f: + 1 603.431.4418 | e: [email protected] | www.lodgingeconometrics.com New York NY Market Trend Report Q2 2012 Transactions & Property Transfers: e Section 4: Transaction Metrics Sa m pl Section 5: Individual Transaction Records • Transactions with a Reported Selling Price • Other Transactions • Portfolio Sales • Merger Transfers Open & Operating Hotel (Census) Records: Section 6: Hotels Known to be Distressed Section 7: Appendices • Glossary of Terms & Footnote Explanations • Site License Section 8: About Lodging Econometrics (LE) • LEʼs Products & Services • LEʼs Global Coverage 500 Market Street, Suite 13 | Portsmouth, NH 03801-3481 USA | p: +1 603.431.8740, ext. 25 | f: + 1 603.431.4418 | e: [email protected] | www.lodgingeconometrics.com Pipeline Metrics New York, New York Prior Hotel Openings At Q2 2012 2010 Hotels Rooms Current Supply 2011 At Q2 2012 Growth Growth Rate Hotels Rooms Rate Hotels Rooms Construction Pipeline (1) Forecast for New Hotel Openings (2) Under Starts Next Early Total Q1 - Q2 2012 Q3 - Q4 2012 Construction 12 Months Planning Pipeline Actual Forecast Proj Rooms Proj Rooms Proj Rooms Proj Rooms Hotels Rooms Proj 2012 2013 Total Rooms Proj Growth Rooms Rate Proj 2014 Growth Rooms Rate Proj 2015 & Growth Rooms Rate Beyond Proj Rooms Market Tract Lower Manhattan Uptown/Midtown East New York City Area 6 1,779 5.9% 1 669 2.1% 101 32,802 16 3,981 4 1,197 7 1,654 27 6,832 1 105 2 382 3 487 1.5% 8 1,842 5.6% 1 94 0.3% 16 4,514 13 2,940 14.2% 5 761 3.2% 136 25,011 18 3,091 12 2,532 16 2,791 46 8,414 4 533 6 1,013 10 1,546 6.3% 6 718 2.8% 4 439 1.6% 30 6,244 4 562 2.9% 1 116 0.6% 72 19,954 5 754 1 36 6 790 1 9 1 9 0.0% 2 316 1.6% 11 1,066 8.3% 7 684 4.9% 139 14,837 18 2,168 9 1,148 16 2,571 43 5,887 11 1,260 13 1,460 10.0% 7 864 5.4% 3 371 55 7,523 2 178 1 90 10 1,385 13 1,653 1 48 1 0.6% 1 90 1.2% 1 130 503 100,127 59 10,172 27 5,003 49 8,401 21 2,712 28 3,550 3.6% 24 3,830 3.7% 9 1 238 2 238 178 1 Rockland/Westchester Total 34 6,347 7.0% 14 2,230 2.3% Luxury 7 1,854 14.4% 43 14,695 1 210 Upper Upscale 4 1,262 6.9% 2 432 2.2% 47 20,065 2 665 Upscale 6 1,521 13.0% 2 264 2.0% 57 13,473 18 3,863 8 1,841 14 Upper Midscale 8 677 8.3% 2 214 2.4% 75 9,509 17 2,624 4 394 7 Midscale 2 147 4.2% 2 142 3.9% 36 3,767 4 323 2 93 2 Economy 3 175 11.3% 1 669 38.7% 22 2,397 2 91 Independents 4 711 2.1% 5 509 1.4% 223 36,221 15 34 6,347 7.0% 14 2,230 2.3% 503 100,127 Hotel Size <75 Rooms 4 686 2 665 2,617 40 8,321 1,148 28 4,166 244 8 838 12 2,437 24 4,154 59 10,172 27 5,003 49 8,401 1 48 22 3,392 1.7% 10 1,385 1,034 1.0% 81 16,000 3 476 210 1.4% 487 2.4% 540 3.8% 4 543 3.7% 28 6,462 1,430 14.1% 3 273 2.4% 10 1,865 1 94 2.4% 4 337 124 0.3% 36 6,860 1,034 1.0% 81 16,000 776 5.8% 3 1,021 11.2% 10 776 5 598 8 660 3 229 3 229 6.1% 2 91 1 54 1 54 2.3% 1 37 1.5% 51 8,987 4 415 6 877 10 1,292 3.6% 8 1,126 3.0% 1 135 23,576 7 838 21 2,712 28 3,550 3.6% 24 3,830 3.7% 9 423 465 2.2% 1 0.9% 5 3 3 1 178 5 m 2,396 Sa Total 7 200 pl Chain Scale 135 23,576 2 e Times Square Area 5 250 3.9% 6 381 5.7% 138 7,220 8 380 5 242 4 263 17 885 2 142 6 311 8 453 6.4% 3 130 1.7% 1 52 0.7% 7 392 75 - 150 Rooms 13 1,336 8.5% 4 418 2.5% 160 17,831 21 2,366 8 974 22 2,666 51 6,006 3 355 7 729 10 1,084 6.2% 10 1,149 6.2% 8 982 5.0% 26 3,146 151 - 300 Rooms 9 1,953 8.4% 2 446 1.8% 125 26,086 24 5,063 11 2,537 22 5,087 57 12,687 2 341 7 1,305 9 1,646 6.4% 10 2,064 7.5% 40 9,318 301 - 500 Rooms 6 2,201 16.3% 1 316 2.0% 42 16,015 6 2,363 2 650 1 385 1 367 1 367 2.3% 1 487 3.0% 7 2,544 >500 Rooms 1 607 1.9% 1 669 2.1% 38 32,975 1 600 1 600 34 6,347 7.0% 14 2,230 2.3% 503 100,127 27 5,003 81 16,000 Total 59 10,172 49 8,401 9 3,398 1 600 135 23,576 7 838 21 2,712 28 3,550 3.6% 24 3,830 3.7% 9 1,034 1.0% When reading this report, please refer to the appendices for other footnote explanations, Glossary of Terms and our Site License Agreement. © Lodging Econometrics. This research information is intellectual property, is copyrighted and remains the property of Lodging Econometrics with all rights reserved. The nature of our relationship is that of a site licensee with specific rights granted for the subscribing client. Specifically, there are no republication rights granted, nor can the research be duplicated or transmitted electronically outside the organization nor can it be shared with or disclosed to other companies or other parties without the expressed written consent of Lodging Econometrics. 500 Market Street, Suite 13 | Portsmouth, NH 03801-3481 USA | p: +1 603.431.8740, ext. 25 | f: + 1 603.431.4418 | e: [email protected] | www.lodgingeconometrics.com Pipeline Metrics New York, New York Prior Hotel Openings At Q2 2012 2010 Hotels Rooms Current Supply 2011 At Q2 2012 Growth Growth Rate Hotels Rooms Rate Hotels Rooms Construction Pipeline (1) Forecast for New Hotel Openings (2) Under Starts Next Early Total Q1 - Q2 2012 Q3 - Q4 2012 Construction 12 Months Planning Pipeline Actual Forecast Proj Rooms Proj Rooms Proj Rooms Proj Rooms Hotels Rooms Proj Rooms 2012 2013 Total Proj Growth Rooms Rate Proj 2014 Growth Rooms Rate Proj 2015 & Growth Rooms Rate Beyond Proj Rooms Location CBD 23 5,281 7.5% 7 1,546 2.0% 310 77,895 39 7,826 19 3,962 26 4,722 84 16,510 6 710 9 1,404 15 2,114 2.7% 17 2,937 3.7% 5 533 0.6% 53 11,636 Suburban 10 1,033 7.2% 7 684 4.5% 149 16,120 16 1,737 7 706 19 2,855 42 5,298 1 128 8 699 9 827 5.2% 7 893 5.3% 4 501 2.8% 23 3,205 1 33 0.5% 43 6,081 4 609 1 335 4 824 9 1,768 4 609 4 609 10.0% 5 1,159 1 31 503 100,127 59 10,172 27 5,003 49 8,401 21 2,712 28 3,550 3.6% 81 16,000 Marriott Hotel 6 4,630 Hilton Hotel & Resort 8 4,525 Airport Highway Resort Total 34 6,347 7.0% 14 2,230 2.3% 7 838 24 3,830 3.7% 9 1,034 1.0% pl e Leading Brands 135 23,576 2 690 30.9% 6 2,920 Doubletree Hotel 1 399 17.3% 7 2,706 Affinia Hotel 1 114 5.7% 9 2,105 Hilton Worldwide 1 399 3.2% 38 12,778 6 1,224 3 636 3 693 12 2,553 2 145 2 145 1.1% 1 150 1.2% 1 116 0.9% 8 2,142 Marriott International 2 232 2.3% 1 133 1.3% 37 10,551 13 2,605 2 478 10 1,911 25 4,994 3 550 3 550 5.2% 5 864 7.8% 1 105 0.9% 16 3,475 Starwood Hotels & Resorts 6 1,530 25.2% 2 264 3.5% 21 7,867 2 389 1 150 3 395 6 934 2 275 3.5% 4 659 InterContinental Hotels Group 4 1,124 19.4% 29 7,030 8 1,500 4 851 5 770 17 3,121 1 122 2 323 3 445 6.4% 6 867 11.8% 9 1,931 Wyndham Worldwide 2 337 14.0% 31 3,362 1 106 1 144 2 250 2 301 1 106 3 407 13.3% 1 144 1 316 11.5% Sa Major Companies m Sheraton Hotel When reading this report, please refer to the appendices for other footnote explanations, Glossary of Terms and our Site License Agreement. © Lodging Econometrics. This research information is intellectual property, is copyrighted and remains the property of Lodging Econometrics with all rights reserved. The nature of our relationship is that of a site licensee with specific rights granted for the subscribing client. Specifically, there are no republication rights granted, nor can the research be duplicated or transmitted electronically outside the organization nor can it be shared with or disclosed to other companies or other parties without the expressed written consent of Lodging Econometrics. 500 Market Street, Suite 13 | Portsmouth, NH 03801-3481 USA | p: +1 603.431.8740, ext. 25 | f: + 1 603.431.4418 | e: [email protected] | www.lodgingeconometrics.com Market Tract by Chain Scale New York, New York Prior Hotel Openings At Q2 2012 Current Supply 2010 2011 Growth Hotels Rooms Rate Growth Hotels Rooms Rate At Q2 2012 Hotels Rooms Construction Pipeline (1) Forecast for New Hotel Openings (2) Under Starts Next Early Total Q1 - Q2 2012 Q3 - Q4 2012 Construction 12 Months Planning Pipeline Actual Forecast Proj Rooms Proj Rooms Proj Rooms Proj Rooms Hotels Rooms Proj Rooms 2012 Total Growth Proj Rooms Rate Proj 2013 2014 Growth Rooms Rate Growth Rooms Rate Proj 2015 & Beyond Proj Rooms 5 1,614 2 570 1 144 8 2,186 16 4,514 2 388 Times Square Area 1 607 26.2% Upper Upscale Upscale 3 876 26.3% Upper Midscale Midscale Economy 1 2 296 2.5% Total 6 1,779 5.9% Luxury 4 975 40.1% Upper Upscale 3 941 39.3% 1 669 2.1% 1 316 9.5% 2,924 1 210 1 210 1 210 7.2% 9,947 1 487 1 487 1 487 4.9% 13 4,202 7 1,915 1 281 8 2,196 2 397 9.0% 12 2,365 2 268 2 570 4 838 2 268 11.3% 2 271 1 94 1 144 2 238 2 719 49 12,374 4 1,007 4 1,197 3 659 11 2,863 1 105 1 197 2 302 2.5% 2 101 32,802 16 3,981 4 1,197 7 1,654 27 6,832 1 105 2 382 3 487 1.5% 8 12 3,406 12 3,651 1 178 1 178 1 178 4.9% 2,938 4 823 5 1,188 3 685 12 2,696 1 168 1 168 5.7% 2 263 8.5% 9 2,265 2,443 8 1,358 1 52 1 142 10 1,552 2 295 2 186 4 481 22.4% 4 591 22.5% 1 52 1.6% 3 723 11,931 5 732 5 1,054 11 1,814 21 3,600 2 238 2 481 4 719 6.1% 2 127 1.0% 1 124 1.0% 16 2,868 25,011 18 3,091 12 2,532 16 2,791 46 8,414 4 533 6 1,013 10 1,546 6.3% 6 718 2.8% 4 439 1.6% 30 6,244 1 185 1 185 4.4% 1 480 94 34.7% 3.8% 1,842 5.6% 1 94 0.3% Lower Manhattan 2 521 21.6% 15 3 254 13.4% 19 Midscale 4 Economy Independents Total 1 1 249 2.3% 4 445 4.0% 73 13 2,940 14.2% 5 761 3.2% 136 1 238 1 Sa Upscale Upper Midscale m pl Independents 669 1338.0% 8 15 e Luxury 150 2 388 1 178 471 171 When reading this report, please refer to the appendices for other footnote explanations, Glossary of Terms and our Site License Agreement. © Lodging Econometrics. This research information is intellectual property, is copyrighted and remains the property of Lodging Econometrics with all rights reserved. The nature of our relationship is that of a site licensee with specific rights granted for the subscribing client. Specifically, there are no republication rights granted, nor can the research be duplicated or transmitted electronically outside the organization nor can it be shared with or disclosed to other companies or other parties without the expressed written consent of Lodging Econometrics. 500 Market Street, Suite 13 | Portsmouth, NH 03801-3481 USA | p: +1 603.431.8740, ext. 25 | f: + 1 603.431.4418 | e: [email protected] | www.lodgingeconometrics.com Prior Hotel Openings in the Last 12 Months Sorted by Chain Scale, then Market Tract Project Description Owner/Developer Management Group Luxury 10001 Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Tract: Lower Manhattan Nolitan Hotel 30 Kenmare St New York NY 10012 Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Tract: Lower Manhattan Chain Scale: Luxury The NoMad Hotel is a turn of the century Beaux Arts building that has been restored to its original grandeur with interiors by renowned French designer Jacque Garcia. The rooms are residential in feel and decorated with richly textured custom designed furnishings and artwork. The hotel is centrally located to a variety of restaurants, museums and other attractions. Project Stage: Construction Start: Projected Opening: Room Count: Current Brand: Recently Opened Oct-2008 Aug-2011 64 Independent Hotel Chain Scale: Luxury Project Stage: Construction Start: Projected Opening: Room Count: Current Brand: Recently Opened Jul-2009 Aug-2011 55 Independent Hotel Chain Scale: Luxury Sorgente Group of America GFI Hotel Management 50 Broadway New York P: 212 668-1444 R NY 10004 F: 211 668-1655 — R e Flatiron Hotel 1141 Broadway New York NY The Sydell Group Contact: Andrew Zobler 50 Broadway New York NY 10004 P: 212 668-1444 F: 212 668-1655 805 3rd Ave 18th Fl New York P: 39 06 58332919 NY 10022 pl Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Tract: Lower Manhattan Recently Opened Oct-2008 Apr-2012 168 Independent Hotel The Flatiron Hotel is located south of midtown Manhattan in the historic Flat Iron District. The hotel features a rooftop lounge and guest rooms. Amenities include wired and wireless high-speed internet, I-Home entertainment systems, and 37” flat-panel TV's. In addition, each room features a Jacuzzi tub or Swiss and Rainfall shower heads. m 10001 Project Stage: Construction Start: Projected Opening: Room Count: Current Brand: Veracity Development Sa The NoMad Hotel 1170 Broadway New York NY 199 Lafayette St New York P: 212 966-6811 Veracity Development NY 10012 F: 212 996-6882 199 Lafayette St New York P: 212 966-6811 R NY 10012 F: 212 996-6882 The luxury boutique Nolitan Hotel features a restaurant, rooftop lounge, private terraces and decks. Room amenities include 37-inch flatscreen televisions and complimentary WiFi access. Located north of Manhattan's Little Italy, the area is steeped in history and located near a variety of boutiques, restaurants,galleries and cafes. When reading this report, please refer to the appendices for other footnote explanations, Glossary of Terms and our Site License Agreement. © Lodging Econometrics. This research information is intellectual property, is copyrighted and remains the property of Lodging Econometrics with all rights reserved. The nature of our relationship is that of a site licensee with specific rights granted for the subscribing client. Specifically, there are no republication rights granted, nor can the research be duplicated or transmitted electronically outside the organization nor can it be shared with or disclosed to other companies or other parties without the expressed written consent of Lodging Econometrics. 500 Market Street, Suite 13 | Portsmouth, NH 03801-3481 USA | p: +1 603.431.8740, ext. 25 | f: + 1 603.431.4418 | e: [email protected] | www.lodgingeconometrics.com Projects Under Construction Sorted by Chain Scale, then Market Tract Project Description Owner/Developer Management Group Luxury NY Chain Scale: Luxury The Gem Hotel brand is a collection of boutique hotels located in Manhattan. The brand prides itself on having a style that is an authentic reflection of its neighborhood. This GEM hotel is being developed in Union Square. Project Stage: Under Construction Room Count: Current Brand: 32 Independent Hotel Chain Scale: Luxury Project Stage: Construction Start: Projected Opening: Room Count: Current Brand: Under Construction Sep-2010 Sep-2013 210 Park Hyatt Extell Development Company Contact: Gary Barnett 805 3rd Ave 7th Fl New York NY 10024 P: 212 712-6000 F: 212 712-6100 Chain Scale: Luxury This Park Hyatt will be part of a 90-story mixed use tower named ONE57. The tower, rising 1,000 feet and providing breathtaking views of both Central Park and the lower Manhattan skyline, will be the tallest residential property in Manhattan. Located across from Carnegie Hall, the building will have 95 luxury residences beginning on floor 32 above the hotel. 10019 Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Tract: Times Square Area 163 Orchard Holding II LLC Contact: Ben Zion Rasabi 145-11 Jamaica Ave Jamaica NY P: 516 790-1447 Gemini Real Estate Advisors LLC Contact: William Obeid 200 Park Ave S #1305 New York NY 10003 P: 212 871-6283 F: 212 871-7197 — U U 11435 163 Orchard Holding II LLC is building a boutique hotel. Originally started in 2008 with the foundation laid, this project has remained dormant until late 2011. A new architect was brought on board for the most recent incarnation of this project. This hotel will have access on both Orchard and Canal streets. m 10002 Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Tract: Lower Manhattan Park Hyatt 157 W 57th St New York Gemini Real Estate Advisors LLC Contact: William Obeid 200 Park Ave S #1305 New York NY 10003 P: 212 871-6283 F: 212 871-7197 — Sa Unbranded Hotel 163 Orchard St New York NY Under Construction Oct-2010 Jul-2012 114 Independent Hotel e Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Tract: Lower Manhattan Project Stage: Construction Start: Projected Opening: Room Count: Current Brand: pl GEM Hotel Union Square 52 W 13th St New York NY 10011 When reading this report, please refer to the appendices for other footnote explanations, Glossary of Terms and our Site License Agreement. © Lodging Econometrics. This research information is intellectual property, is copyrighted and remains the property of Lodging Econometrics with all rights reserved. The nature of our relationship is that of a site licensee with specific rights granted for the subscribing client. Specifically, there are no republication rights granted, nor can the research be duplicated or transmitted electronically outside the organization nor can it be shared with or disclosed to other companies or other parties without the expressed written consent of Lodging Econometrics. 500 Market Street, Suite 13 | Portsmouth, NH 03801-3481 USA | p: +1 603.431.8740, ext. 25 | f: + 1 603.431.4418 | e: [email protected] | www.lodgingeconometrics.com U Projects to Start in the Next 12 Months Sorted by Chain Scale, then Market Tract Project Description Owner/Developer Management Group Luxury Edition 1 Madison Ave New York NY 10013 Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Tract: Lower Manhattan Project Stage: Construction Start: Projected Opening: Room Count: Current Brand: Start Next 12 Months Dec-2012 Mar-2015 238 Edition Chain Scale: Luxury Marriott International Inc Marriott International Inc 10400 Fernwood Rd Bethesda P: 301 380-3000 10400 Fernwood Rd Bethesda P: 301 380-3000 MD 20817 F: 301 380-6094 S MD 20817 F: 301 380-6094 Plans to convert the former Metropolitan Life Clock Tower into a luxury hotel by designer Tommy Hilfiger and partner JSR Capital Group were withdrawn. Marriott has purchased the property and is likely to brand as an Edition hotel Upper Upscale 10016 Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Tract: Lower Manhattan DLJ Real Estate Capital Partners Contact: Andrew Paul Rifkin 590 Madison Ave 8th Fl New York NY 10022 P: 212 901-4928 Room Count: Current Brand: 130 Independent Hotel Chain Scale: Upper Upscale DLJ Real Estate Capital Partners plans to convert a 12-story 1913 Beaux-Arts building into a hotel including 20 luxury suites. The building was purchased for $36 million in December 2011. Project Stage: Construction Start: Projected Opening: Room Count: Current Brand: Start Next 12 Months Mar-2013 Nov-2014 260 Independent Hotel Simon Development Group Contact: Jonathan Simon 230 Park Ave #539 New York NY P: 213 953-7777 Chain Scale: Upper Upscale This hotel is the first location for Commune Hotel & Resorts new hotel brand. This brand will appeal to a distinct type of traveler; one who is educated, involved and socially conscious with a blending of form, function, beauty and responsibility. The new concept will be innovated, creating evolving destinations that are affordable, efficient and beautiful. — S m pl e Start Next 12 Months 10002 Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Tract: Lower Manhattan Unbranded Hotel 11-13 E 31st St New York NY Project Stage: Sa Unbranded Hotel 50-54 Canal St New York NY 10169 Commune Hotels & Resorts Contact: Stephen Brandman 54 Thompson St New York NY 10012 P: 212 204-5000 F: 212 204-5005 When reading this report, please refer to the appendices for other footnote explanations, Glossary of Terms and our Site License Agreement. © Lodging Econometrics. This research information is intellectual property, is copyrighted and remains the property of Lodging Econometrics with all rights reserved. The nature of our relationship is that of a site licensee with specific rights granted for the subscribing client. Specifically, there are no republication rights granted, nor can the research be duplicated or transmitted electronically outside the organization nor can it be shared with or disclosed to other companies or other parties without the expressed written consent of Lodging Econometrics. 500 Market Street, Suite 13 | Portsmouth, NH 03801-3481 USA | p: +1 603.431.8740, ext. 25 | f: + 1 603.431.4418 | e: [email protected] | www.lodgingeconometrics.com S Projects in Early Planning Sorted by Chain Scale, then Market Tract Project Description Owner/Developer Management Group Luxury Room Count: Current Brand: 150 Four Seasons Silverstein Development Corp Contact: Larry Silverstein 521 5th Ave New York NY 10175 P: 212 551-7339 F: 212 719-9222 Chain Scale: Luxury Work on the foundations began in late 2008 but work stopped a short time later in early 2009. This hotel would occupied 22 stories of an 80-story residential condominium tower being developed by Larry Silverstein on the site of the former Moody’s building in Tribeca. Project Stage: Early Planning Room Count: Current Brand: 155 Independent Hotel Chain Scale: Luxury Project Stage: Early Planning Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Tract: Lower Manhattan 10003 Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Tract: Lower Manhattan Room Count: Current Brand: Chain Scale: West Street Development LLC Contact: Francis Greenburger 55 5th Ave #15 New York NY 10003 P: 212 206-6000 F: 212 727-0563 72 Independent Hotel Luxury — E E e Time Equities Tower 50 West St New York NY 10006 — pl 10007 Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Tract: Lower Manhattan Unbranded Hotel 347 Bowery New York NY Early Planning Work on this project is moving forward again. A building permit application has been filed with the city and with a new architect replacing Helmut Jahn. The $600 million project would have included a luxury hotel with ground floor retail and a restaurant. There will also plans for 290 residential units to occupy several floors. Further planned features included an enclosed roof garden and lounge, onsite spa, fitness center, screening room, and library lounge. m NY Project Stage: Louzon Group Sa Four Seasons 99 Church St New York 666 5th Ave New York — NY 10103 The developers of this property plan to develop a boutique hotel and French restaurant in the former Salvation Army building. When reading this report, please refer to the appendices for other footnote explanations, Glossary of Terms and our Site License Agreement. © Lodging Econometrics. This research information is intellectual property, is copyrighted and remains the property of Lodging Econometrics with all rights reserved. The nature of our relationship is that of a site licensee with specific rights granted for the subscribing client. Specifically, there are no republication rights granted, nor can the research be duplicated or transmitted electronically outside the organization nor can it be shared with or disclosed to other companies or other parties without the expressed written consent of Lodging Econometrics. 500 Market Street, Suite 13 | Portsmouth, NH 03801-3481 USA | p: +1 603.431.8740, ext. 25 | f: + 1 603.431.4418 | e: [email protected] | www.lodgingeconometrics.com E Projects That Halted Construction Sorted by Chain Scale, then Market Tract Project Description Owner/Developer Management Group Upper Midscale Comfort Inn 3070 Webster Ave Bronx NY Project Stage: Cancelled — Room Count: Current Brand: 48 Comfort Inn Chain Scale: Upper Midscale — C 10467 Market: New York, NY Location: Suburban Tract: New York City Area Construction began on this Comfort Inn, but was halted. The property has been sold while under construction. Economy Room Count: Current Brand: 120 Days Inn Chain Scale: Economy 10036 — This project has been cancelled. Sa Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Tract: Times Square Area McSam Hotel LLC Contact: Sam Chang 420 Great Neck Rd Great Neck NY 11021 P: 516 773-9300 F: 516 775-2966 e Cancelled pl NY Project Stage: m Days Inn 548 W 48th St New York When reading this report, please refer to the appendices for other footnote explanations, Glossary of Terms and our Site License Agreement. © Lodging Econometrics. This research information is intellectual property, is copyrighted and remains the property of Lodging Econometrics with all rights reserved. The nature of our relationship is that of a site licensee with specific rights granted for the subscribing client. Specifically, there are no republication rights granted, nor can the research be duplicated or transmitted electronically outside the organization nor can it be shared with or disclosed to other companies or other parties without the expressed written consent of Lodging Econometrics. 500 Market Street, Suite 13 | Portsmouth, NH 03801-3481 USA | p: +1 603.431.8740, ext. 25 | f: + 1 603.431.4418 | e: [email protected] | www.lodgingeconometrics.com C Projects that have been Cancelled Sorted by Chain Scale, then Market Tract Project Description Owner/Developer Management Group Upscale Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Tract: Lower Manhattan Hotel Indigo 237 Duffield St Brooklyn NY Chain Scale: Upscale This vacant property will be developed into a a Courtyard by Marriott. The land was sold by Sam Chang's McSam Hotel Group for $15 million. Project Stage: Cancelled Room Count: Current Brand: 95 Independent Hotel Chain Scale: Upscale Project Stage: Cancelled 10003 Room Count: Current Brand: Chain Scale: CA IBC Chambers LLC Contact: Wililam Coleman 950 3rd Ave #3101 New York NY P: 212 980-4200 C 94109 — C 10022 This hotel project is cancelled. Instead of a hotel, this project is going to be residential housing. 21 Independent Hotel Upscale Project Stage: Cancelled Room Count: Current Brand: 180 Hotel Indigo Chain Scale: Upscale 11201 Market: New York, NY Location: Suburban Tract: New York City Area — m NY 240 Courtyard by Marriott 10007 Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Tract: Lower Manhattan The Charles 1355 First Ave New York Room Count: Current Brand: Today's Hotel Corp Contact: Peter Zen 1500 Van Ness Ave San Fransisco P: 415 441-4000 Bluerock Real Estate Contact: Philip Mendlow 70 E 55th St Heron Tower New York NY 10022 P: 212 843-1601 F: 646 278-4220 — C Sa Unbranded Hotel 87 Chambers St New York NY Cancelled e Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Tract: Lower Manhattan Project Stage: pl Courtyard by Marriott 50 Trinity Pl New York NY 10006 This project has been cancelled. V3 Hotels Contact: Gary Gopalani 26 Court St #2710 Long Island City NY 11101 P: 718 707-0060 F: 718 707-0067 Graves Hotels & Resorts Contact: James J. Graves 404 W Saint Germain St Minneapolis MN 55403 P: 320 252-6034 F: 320 252-3029 This project has been cancelled. When reading this report, please refer to the appendices for other footnote explanations, Glossary of Terms and our Site License Agreement. © Lodging Econometrics. This research information is intellectual property, is copyrighted and remains the property of Lodging Econometrics with all rights reserved. The nature of our relationship is that of a site licensee with specific rights granted for the subscribing client. Specifically, there are no republication rights granted, nor can the research be duplicated or transmitted electronically outside the organization nor can it be shared with or disclosed to other companies or other parties without the expressed written consent of Lodging Econometrics. 500 Market Street, Suite 13 | Portsmouth, NH 03801-3481 USA | p: +1 603.431.8740, ext. 25 | f: + 1 603.431.4418 | e: [email protected] | www.lodgingeconometrics.com C Projects that have been Postponed Sorted by Chain Scale, then Market Tract Project Description Owner/Developer Management Group Upscale Hyatt Place W 125th St & Lenox Ave New York NY 10027 Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Tract: Uptown/Midtown East Project Stage: On Hold Room Count: Current Brand: 177 Hyatt Place Chain Scale: Upscale — Contact: Emmitt Smith — Dallas TX O This project is on hold. Upper Midscale On Hold Room Count: Current Brand: 56 Independent Hotel Chain Scale: Upper Midscale — O pl 10018 Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Tract: Times Square Area McSam Hotel LLC Contact: Sam Chang 420 Great Neck Rd Great Neck NY 11021 P: 516 773-9300 F: 516 775-2966 e Project Stage: McSam Hotel plans to develop a mid-market, full service hotel on West 40th St in New York City. The project is currently on hold, according to Sam Chang. m Unbranded Hotel 308 W 40th St New York NY Howard Johnson 5 Allen St New York NY Project Stage: 10013 Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Tract: Lower Manhattan Room Count: Current Brand: Chain Scale: Sa Midscale On Hold 43 Howard Johnson Midscale East West Bank Contact: Dennis Lee 555 Montogomery St #129 San Francisco CA P: 415 315-2832 — 94111 Richland Holding LLC was constructing a 12-story, 43 key hotel where the Hong Kong Supermarket was once located. Attempts were made to sell the property, but fell short. The mortgage from United Commercial Bank was closed by the FDIC and sold to East West Bank of San Francisco. No construction is taking place on this property. When reading this report, please refer to the appendices for other footnote explanations, Glossary of Terms and our Site License Agreement. © Lodging Econometrics. This research information is intellectual property, is copyrighted and remains the property of Lodging Econometrics with all rights reserved. The nature of our relationship is that of a site licensee with specific rights granted for the subscribing client. Specifically, there are no republication rights granted, nor can the research be duplicated or transmitted electronically outside the organization nor can it be shared with or disclosed to other companies or other parties without the expressed written consent of Lodging Econometrics. 500 Market Street, Suite 13 | Portsmouth, NH 03801-3481 USA | p: +1 603.431.8740, ext. 25 | f: + 1 603.431.4418 | e: [email protected] | www.lodgingeconometrics.com O Size p Projects with Residential Condo Hotel or Timeshare Units Sorted by Chain Scale, Project Stage, then Market Tract Hotel Developer Management Company Project Phase Timelines Start Date Open Date Luxury Park Hyatt 157 W 57th St New York NY 10019 Gary Barnett Extell Development Company 805 3rd Ave 7th Fl New York NY 10024 Phase 1 Under Construction Phase 2 Phase 3 — Sep 13 Units and Room Counts by Stage P: 212 712-6000 F: 212 712-6100 Open Under Start Next Early Remaining Units Construction 12 Months Planning Buildout New York, NY Times Square Area Luxury Park Hyatt Timeshare Units Fractionals Private Residences Condo Hotel Units Hotel Rooms Re 95 210 e Market: Tract: Chain Scale: Current Brand: Sep 10 Larry Silverstein Silverstein Development Corp 521 5th Ave New York NY 10175 — m Four Seasons 99 Church St New York NY 10007 pl This Park Hyatt will be part of a 90-story mixed use tower named ONE57. The tower, rising 1,000 feet and providing breathtaking views of both Central Park and the lower Manhattan skyline, will be the tallest residential property in Manhattan. Located across from Carnegie Hall, the building will have 95 luxury residences beginning on floor 32 above the hotel. Units and Room Counts by Stage New York, NY Lower Manhattan Luxury Four Seasons Sa P: 212 551-7339 F: 212 719-9222 Market: Tract: Chain Scale: Current Brand: Phase 1 Early Planning Phase 2 Phase 3 Open Under Start Next Early Remaining Units Construction 12 Months Planning Buildout Timeshare Units Fractionals Private Residences Condo Hotel Units Hotel Rooms Re 150 150 Work on the foundations began in late 2008 but work stopped a short time later in early 2009. This hotel would occupied 22 stories of an 80-story residential condominium tower being developed by Larry Silverstein on the site of the former Moody’s building in Tribeca. When reading this report, please refer to the appendices for other footnote explanations, Glossary of Terms and our Site License Agreement. © Lodging Econometrics. This research information is intellectual property, is copyrighted and remains the property of Lodging Econometrics with all rights reserved. The nature of our relationship is that of a site licensee with specific rights granted for the subscribing client. Specifically, there are no republication rights granted, nor can the research be duplicated or transmitted electronically outside the organization nor can it be shared with or disclosed to other companies or other parties without the expressed written consent of Lodging Econometrics. 500 Market Street, Suite 13 | Portsmouth, NH 03801-3481 USA | p: +1 603.431.8740, ext. 25 | f: + 1 603.431.4418 | e: [email protected] | www.lodgingeconometrics.com Brand Conversion Projects Sorted by Chain Scale, Project Stage, then Market Tract Project Description Owner/Developer Management Group Upper Upscale Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Tract: Uptown/Midtown East Host Hotels & Resorts Inc Starwood Hotels & Resorts Worldwide Inc 6903 Rockledge Dr #1500 Bethesda MD 20817 P: 240 744-1000 F: 240 744-5494 1 StarPoint Stamford P: 203 964-6000 Project Stage: Start within 6 Months DiamondRock Hospitality Projected Opening: Room Count: Current Brand: New Brand: Chain Scale: New Chain: Mar-2013 705 Radisson Hotel Autograph Collection Upscale Upper Upscale 3 Bethesda Metro Ctr #1500 Bethesda MD 20814 P: 240 744-1150 F: 240 744-1199 CT 06902 The New York Helmsley was sold in March 2011. Starwood Hotels & Resorts has taken over management and will oversee the conversion to a Westin Hotel. The hotel is undergoing a $65 million renovation that will revamp guest rooms, upgrade the building's facade, extend the lobby bar-restaurant, and add five breakout meeting rooms. The hotel will remain open as it renovates two floors at a time. e Radisson Lexington Hotel 511 Lexington Ave New York NY 10017 Underway Dec-2011 Sep-2012 774 Helmsley Hotel Westin Hotel Luxury Upper Upscale pl Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Tract: Uptown/Midtown East Project Stage: Construction Start: Projected Opening: Room Count: Current Brand: New Brand: Chain Scale: New Chain: Highgate Holdings Contact: Yezdi Katrak 870 7th Ave #26 New York NY 10019 P: 212 980-2989 F: 212 223-8893 The owners of the Radisson Lexington Hotel will spend $30 million in renovations to reposition the hotel into the branded boutique Marriott Autograph Collection. m The New York Helmsley 212 E 42nd St New York NY 10017 Upscale Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Tract: Uptown/Midtown East Project Stage: Construction Start: Projected Opening: Room Count: Current Brand: New Brand: Chain Scale: New Chain: Underway Oct-2011 Oct-2012 211 Helmsley Hotel Residence Inn Luxury Upscale Stonebridge Companies Contact: Randy Santulli 9100 E Panorama Dr #300 Englewood CO 80112 P: 303 785-3100 F: 303 785-3199 Sa Helmsley Middletowne Hotel 148 E 48th St New York NY 10017 Stonebridge Companies Contact: Randy Santulli 9100 E Panorama Dr #300 Englewood CO 80112 P: 303 785-3100 F: 303 785-3199 The Helmsley Middletowne Hotel may convert to a Residence Inn. When reading this report, please refer to the appendices for other footnote explanations, Glossary of Terms and our Site License Agreement. © Lodging Econometrics. This research information is intellectual property, is copyrighted and remains the property of Lodging Econometrics with all rights reserved. The nature of our relationship is that of a site licensee with specific rights granted for the subscribing client. Specifically, there are no republication rights granted, nor can the research be duplicated or transmitted electronically outside the organization nor can it be shared with or disclosed to other companies or other parties without the expressed written consent of Lodging Econometrics. 500 Market Street, Suite 13 | Portsmouth, NH 03801-3481 USA | p: +1 603.431.8740, ext. 25 | f: + 1 603.431.4418 | e: [email protected] | www.lodgingeconometrics.com Announced Renovation Projects Sorted by Chain Scale, Project Stage, then Market Tract Project Description Owner/Developer Management Group Luxury Room Count: Current Brand: 934 Independent Hotel Chain Scale: Luxury Project Stage: Construction Start: Projected Opening: Room Count: Current Brand: Underway Feb-2012 Aug-2012 165 Independent Hotel Chain Scale: Luxury Project Stage: Construction Start: Projected Opening: Room Count: Current Brand: Underway Dec-2011 Aug-2012 1,425 The Waldorf=Astoria Collection 10022 Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Tract: Uptown/Midtown East Chain Scale: Luxury 3 Bethesda Metro Ctr #1200 Bethesda MD 20814 P: 301 941-1500 F: 301 941-1553 Highgate Holdings Contact: Yezdi Katrak 870 7th Ave #26 New York NY 10019 P: 212 980-2989 F: 212 223-8893 Located across the street from Carnegie Hall, the Park Central Hotel is within walking distance of midtown businesses, shopping and some of New York City’s greatest tourist attractions. The Park Central Hotel has 14,000 square feet of meeting and function space, including a 8,500 square feet Grand Ballroom. A $35 million renovation is planned to upgrade the guest rooms and public areas. e HNA International Hotels & Resorts 28F, Yintong International Ctr Haikou HAINA 570125 N 86 898 68501002 P: 86 898 68501007 F: pl 10036 Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Tract: Times Square Area Waldorf Astoria 301 Park Ave New York NY LaSalle Hotel Properties Viceroy Hotel Group Contact: Bradford Korzen 421 S Beverly Dr 7th Fl Los Angeles CA 90212 P: 424 249-6900 F: 424 249-6901 The new owners of Cassa Hotel are making minor revisions to the public spaces and constructing a restaurant. The hotel will take on a new name at the completion of the project. m NY Underway Apr-2012 10019 Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Tract: Lower Manhattan Cassa Hotel 70 W 45th St New York Project Stage: Construction Start: The Blackstone Group LP Sa Park Central Hotel 870 7th Ave New York NY 345 Park Ave New York P: 212 583-5000 NY 10154 F: 212 583-5749 Hilton Worldwide 7930 Jones Branch Dr #1100 McLean VA 22102 P: 703 883-1000 F: 703 883-6186 Restoration of the automobile court in front of the hotel is planned. The entry will have a glass and nickel silver clad canopy that would stretch across the three primary openings on the Park Ave facade. When reading this report, please refer to the appendices for other footnote explanations, Glossary of Terms and our Site License Agreement. © Lodging Econometrics. This research information is intellectual property, is copyrighted and remains the property of Lodging Econometrics with all rights reserved. The nature of our relationship is that of a site licensee with specific rights granted for the subscribing client. Specifically, there are no republication rights granted, nor can the research be duplicated or transmitted electronically outside the organization nor can it be shared with or disclosed to other companies or other parties without the expressed written consent of Lodging Econometrics. 500 Market Street, Suite 13 | Portsmouth, NH 03801-3481 USA | p: +1 603.431.8740, ext. 25 | f: + 1 603.431.4418 | e: [email protected] | www.lodgingeconometrics.com Transaction Metrics - Last 4 Quarters New York, New York At Q2 2012 Transactions with a Reported Selling Price Hotels Rooms Other Individual Transactions Hotels Portfolio Sales Rooms Hotels Merger Transfers Rooms Hotels Rooms Total Hotels Sold or Transferred Hotels Rooms Hotels Known to be Distressed Hotels Rooms Market Tract Times Square Area 2 1,077 2 448 4 1,525 5 1,592 Lower Manhattan 6 1,838 2 504 8 2,342 2 390 Uptown/Midtown East 2 391 1 899 4 1,470 2 273 New York City Area 3 579 3 579 1 214 13 3,885 19 5,916 10 2,469 Luxury 1 298 2 478 2 519 Upper Upscale 1 436 1 436 2 1,083 Upscale 2 706 1 224 3 930 Upper Midscale 1 146 2 452 3 598 1 214 8 2,299 2 1,175 10 3,474 5 653 13 3,885 5 1,851 1 180 19 5,916 10 2,469 5 1,851 1 180 9 2,255 1 180 Rockland/Westchester 5 1,851 1 Chain Scale Independents Total Location CBD Sa Economy m Midscale 180 pl 1 180 e Total 10 3,306 16 5,337 Suburban 2 143 2 143 Airport 1 436 1 436 1 214 13 3,885 19 5,916 10 2,469 Highway Resort Total 5 1,851 1 180 When reading this report, please refer to the appendices for other footnote explanations, Glossary of Terms and our Site Licence Agreement. © Lodging Econometrics. This research information is intellectual property, is copyrighted and remains the property of Lodging Econometrics with all rights reserved. The nature of our relationship is that of a site licensee with specific rights granted for the subscribing client. Specifically, there are no republication rights granted, nor can the research be duplicated or transmitted electronically outside the organization nor can it be shared with or disclosed to other companies or other parties without the expressed written consent of Lodging Econometrics. 500 Market Street, Suite 13 | Portsmouth, NH 03801-3481 USA | p: +1 603.431.8740, ext. 25 | f: + 1 603.431.4418 | e: [email protected] | www.lodgingeconometrics.com Transaction Metrics - Last 4 Quarters New York, New York At Q2 2012 Transactions with a Reported Selling Price Hotels Rooms Other Individual Transactions Hotels Portfolio Sales Rooms Hotels Merger Transfers Rooms Hotels Rooms Total Hotels Sold or Transferred Hotels Hotels Known to be Distressed Rooms Hotels Rooms Hotel Size <75 Rooms 1 64 1 64 75 - 150 Rooms 4 460 4 460 151 - 300 Rooms 4 914 9 301 - 500 Rooms 2 916 >500 Rooms 2 952 1,531 1 899 13 3,885 5 1,851 1 436 1 1 Sheraton Hotel 1 224 Major Companies Hilton Worldwide 1 146 Marriott International 3 960 Starwood Hotels & Resorts InterContinental Hotels Group Wyndham Worldwide Sa Affinia Hotel m Hilton Hotel & Resort Doubletree Hotel 180 pl Leading Brands Marriott Hotel 180 e Total 4 1 224 3 191 2,046 5 1,099 2 916 1 316 3 2,430 1 863 19 5,916 10 2,469 1 436 1 224 2 370 3 960 1 863 1 228 1 228 1 214 1 224 1 224 1 220 When reading this report, please refer to the appendices for other footnote explanations, Glossary of Terms and our Site Licence Agreement. © Lodging Econometrics. This research information is intellectual property, is copyrighted and remains the property of Lodging Econometrics with all rights reserved. The nature of our relationship is that of a site licensee with specific rights granted for the subscribing client. Specifically, there are no republication rights granted, nor can the research be duplicated or transmitted electronically outside the organization nor can it be shared with or disclosed to other companies or other parties without the expressed written consent of Lodging Econometrics. 500 Market Street, Suite 13 | Portsmouth, NH 03801-3481 USA | p: +1 603.431.8740, ext. 25 | f: + 1 603.431.4418 | e: [email protected] | www.lodgingeconometrics.com Transactions with a Reported Selling Price Last Four Quarters - Sorted by Chain Scale, then Market Tract Hotel Description & Transaction Details Buyer Seller Luxury Ritz-Carlton 2 West St New York P: 212 344-0800 NY 10004 F: 212 344-3801 Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Lower Manhattan Tract: Date of Sale: Selling Price: Price per Room: Feb-2012 $105,000,000 $352,349 Room Count: Year Built: Chain Scale: 298 2002 Luxury Westbrook Partners LLC Millennium Partners Contact: Avi Banyasz Contact: Pam Malkani 645 Madison Ave 18th Fl 1995 Broadway New York NY 10022 New York NY 10023 United States United States P: 212 849-8800 F: 212 849-8801 P: 212 875-4900 F: 212 595-1831 Westbrook Partners LLC purchased the 298 room Ritz-Carlton, from Millennium Partners, for $105 million. Gen Ma Individual Sales—With A 100% Ownership Interest Acquired Room Count: Year Built: Chain Scale: 934 1929 Luxury Individual Sales—With A 100% Ownership Interest Acquired Date of Sale: Selling Price: Price per Room: Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Lower Manhattan Tract: Room Count: Year Built: Chain Scale: Feb-2012 $48,300,000 $483,000 Highgate Holdings Contact: Mahmood Khimji 3 Bethesda Metro Ctr #1200 545 E John Carpenter Fwy #1400 Bethesda MD 20814 Irving TX 75062 United States United States P: 301 941-1500 F: 301 941-1553 P: 972 444-9700 F: 972 444-9210 LaSalle Hotel Properties purchased the 934 room Park Central Hotel, from Highgate Holdings, for $396.2 million. Highgate will continue to manage the property. The owner plans a $35 million renovation. 100 1998 Luxury Gen 3q11 Hi 16 East 32 Corp Ferrado US LLC Contact: Steven Grapstein Contact: Xavier Ruiz 16 E 32nd St 20411 S W Birch St #360 New York NY 10016 Newport Beach CA 94301 United States United States P: 212 299-7000 F: 212 299-7001 P: 650 322-9000 F: 650 324-3609 16 East 32 Corp purchased the 100 room Vinci Avalon Hotel, from Ferrado US LLC, for $48.3 million. Gen King & Grove Gen Sa The Vincci Avalon Hotel 16 E 32nd St New York NY 10016 P: 212 299-7000 F: 212 299-7001 LaSalle Hotel Properties e Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Lower Manhattan Tract: Jan-2012 $396,200,000 $424,197 pl NY 10019 F: 212 707-5557 Date of Sale: Selling Price: Price per Room: m Park Central Hotel 870 7th Ave New York P: 212 247-8000 Vi Individual Sales—With A 100% Ownership Interest Acquired Hotel Williamsburg & Residences 162 N 12th St Brooklyn NY 11211 P: 718 218-7500 F: 718 218-7555 Date of Sale: Selling Price: Price per Room: Mar-2012 $33,000,000 $515,625 Market: New York, NY Location: Suburban New York City Area Tract: Room Count: Year Built: Chain Scale: 64 2011 Luxury Graves Hotels & Resorts Contact: James J. Graves 404 5th Ave 4th Fl 404 W Saint Germain St New York NY 10018 Minneapolis MN 55403 United States United States P: 646 230-9360 F: 646 230-9371 P: 320 252-6034 F: 320 252-3029 King & Grove, a subsidiary of the Chetrit Group, purchased the 64 room Hotel Williamsburg & Residences, from Graves Hotels & Resorts, for $33 million. The hotel will be known as the King & Grove Williamsburg. Individual Sales—With A 100% Ownership Interest Acquired When reading this report, please refer to the appendices for other footnote explanations, Glossary of Terms and our Site License Agreement. © Lodging Econometrics. This research information is intellectual property, is copyrighted and remains the property of Lodging Econometrics with all rights reserved. The nature of our relationship is that of a site licensee with specific rights granted for the subscribing client. Specifically, there are no republication rights granted, nor can the research be duplicated or transmitted electronically outside the organization nor can it be shared with or disclosed to other companies or other parties without the expressed written consent of Lodging Econometrics. 500 Market Street, Suite 13 | Portsmouth, NH 03801-3481 USA | p: +1 603.431.8740, ext. 25 | f: + 1 603.431.4418 | e: [email protected] | www.lodgingeconometrics.com Ki Other Transactions Last Four Quarters - Sorted by Chain Scale, then Market Tract Hotel Description & Transaction Details Buyer Seller Luxury New York Palace Hotel 455 Madison Ave New York NY 10022 P: 212 888-7000 F: 212 355-0820 Date of Sale: Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Uptown/Midtown East Tract: Room Count: Year Built: Chain Scale: Jul-2011 899 1979 Luxury Northwood Investors Dorchester Collection Contact: John Z. Kukral Contact: Christopher Cowdray 575 5th Ave., 23rd Fl 3 Tilney St New York NY 10017 London ENGLA W1K 1BJ United States United Kingdom P: 212 573-0801 F: 212 202-5301 P: 44 20 76294848 F: 44 20 76290202 Northwood Investors purchased the 899 room New York Palace Hotel leasehold, from Dorchester Collection (Brunei Investment Agency), for $377 million. Gen Meri No Individual Sales—Other Upper Upscale Jun-2012 Room Count: Year Built: Chain Scale: 276 1900 Upper Upscale Individual Sales—Other pl NY 10016 F: 212 689-0023 Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Lower Manhattan Tract: King & Grove Hotels Rockpoint Group LLC Contact: Ed Scheetz Contact: Keith Gelb 512 7th Ave 500 Boylston St #1880 New York NY 10018 Boston MA 02116 United States United States P: 212 675-5100 P: 617 437 8400 F: 415 438-7921 King & Grove Hotels purchased the 276 room Hotel Thirty-Thirty, from Rockpoint Group LLC, for an undisclosed sum. e Date of Sale: Gen Ki m Hotel Thirty-Thirty 29 E 29th St New York P: 212 689-1900 Upscale Date of Sale: Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Times Square Area Tract: Room Count: Year Built: Chain Scale: Apr-2012 RockBridge Capital LLC Magna Hospitality Group LLC Contact: Alan L Assaf Contact: William Burruss 4100 Regent St Ste G 300 Centerville Rd #300E Columbus OH 43219 Warwick RI 02886 United States United States P: 614 246-2437 F: 614 246-2481 P: 401 886-4484 F: 401 886-4485 RockBridge Capital LLC bought out the partner's share of the 224 room Doubletree Hotel Times Square South, from Magna Hospitality Group LLC, for an undisclosed sum. The seller will continue to manage the property. Sa Doubletree Hotel Times Square South 341 W 36th St New York NY 10018 P: 212 542-8990 F: 212 542-8999 224 2008 Upscale Individual Sales—With A Partial Ownership Interest Acquired When reading this report, please refer to the appendices for other footnote explanations, Glossary of Terms and our Site License Agreement. © Lodging Econometrics. This research information is intellectual property, is copyrighted and remains the property of Lodging Econometrics with all rights reserved. The nature of our relationship is that of a site licensee with specific rights granted for the subscribing client. Specifically, there are no republication rights granted, nor can the research be duplicated or transmitted electronically outside the organization nor can it be shared with or disclosed to other companies or other parties without the expressed written consent of Lodging Econometrics. 500 Market Street, Suite 13 | Portsmouth, NH 03801-3481 USA | p: +1 603.431.8740, ext. 25 | f: + 1 603.431.4418 | e: [email protected] | www.lodgingeconometrics.com Gen Ma Portfolio Sales Last Four Quarters - Sorted by Chain Scale, then Market Tract Hotel Description & Transaction Details Buyer Seller Luxury The Carlyle Hotel 35 E 76th St New York P: 212 744-1600 Date of Sale: Aug-2011 Room Count: Year Built: Chain Scale: 180 1922 Luxury NY 10021 F: 212 717-4682 Market: New York, NY Location: CBD Uptown/Midtown East Tract: Sa m pl e Portfolio Sales—With Unallocated Selling Prices New World Development Company Ltd Maritz Wolff & Co Contact: Cheng Yu-Tung Contact: Lewis Wolf New World Tower 30 Fl 11828 La Grange Ave #200 Hong Kong Los Angeles CA 90025 People’s Republic of China United States P: 852 25231056 F: 852 28104673 P: 310 477-3593 F: 310 477-2522 New World Hospitality has completed a US$229.5 million transaction to purchase Rosewood Hotels, including 5 luxury hotels: The Carlyle Hotel in New York City, Rosewood Inn of the Anasazi in Santa Fe, New Mexico, Rosewood Little Dix Bay in the British Virgin Islands, Rosewood Crescent Hotel in Dallas and Rosewood Mansion on Turtle Creek in Dallas. When reading this report, please refer to the appendices for other footnote explanations, Glossary of Terms and our Site LicenZe Agreement. © Lodging Econometrics. This research information is intellectual property, is copyrighted and remains the property of Lodging Econometrics with all rights reserved. The nature of our relationship is that of a site licensee with specific rights granted for the subscribing client. Specifically, there are no republication rights granted, nor can the research be duplicated or transmitted electronically outside the organization nor can it be shared with or disclosed to other companies or other parties without the expressed written consent of Lodging Econometrics. 500 Market Street, Suite 13 | Portsmouth, NH 03801-3481 USA | p: +1 603.431.8740, ext. 25 | f: + 1 603.431.4418 | e: [email protected] | www.lodgingeconometrics.com Gen Ro Merger Transfers Last Four Quarters - Sorted by Chain Scale, then Market Tract Sa m pl e There are no project or hotel records that meet this specification in the current quarter. When reading this report, please refer to the appendices for other footnote explanations, Glossary of Terms and our Site License Agreement. © Lodging Econometrics. This research information is intellectual property, is copyrighted and remains the property of Lodging Econometrics with all rights reserved. The nature of our relationship is that of a site licensee with specific rights granted for the subscribing client. Specifically, there are no republication rights granted, nor can the research be duplicated or transmitted electronically outside the organization nor can it be shared with or disclosed to other companies or other parties without the expressed written consent of Lodging Econometrics. 500 Market Street, Suite 13 | Portsmouth, NH 03801-3481 USA | p: +1 603.431.8740, ext. 25 | f: + 1 603.431.4418 | e: [email protected] | www.lodgingeconometrics.com Hotels Known to be Distressed Sorted by Type of Distress, Chain Scale, then Market Tract Foreclosure Filed Luxury The Alex Hotel 205 E 45th St New York NY 10017 P: 212 867-5100 F: 212 867-7878 Market: New York, NY Tract: Uptown/Midtown East Current Ownership: Izak Senbahar Management: In July 2012: The property remains in foreclosure. In April 2012: The court ruled the lender could proceed with foreclosure. It is anticipated the property will be surrendered to the lender by the end of 2012. In January 2012: The property is still in receivership. The partnership holding the debt is formed by Rockpoint Group, Atlas Capital Group and The Procaccianti Group. In October 2011: The property remains in receivership. In August 2011: The property remains in receivership. In June 2011: The owner continues to operate the property with the receiver. 150 E 58th St #33 New York NY 10155 P: 212 371-8188 1 Post Office Sq #3100 Boston MA 02109 P: 617 412-2800 298 Luxury 1992 Renovation Date: 2011 Alexico Management Group Pyramid Hotel Group LLC Rooms: Chain Scale: Year Built: Brand Affiliation: 203 Luxury 2003 2012 Alexico Management Group Pyramid Hotel Group LLC In July 2012: There has been no change in ownership or management. In April 2012: The court ruled the lender could proceed with foreclosure. It is anticipated the property will be surrendered to the lender by the end of 2012. In January 2012: The property is still in receivership. The partnership holding the debt is formed by Rockpoint Group, Atlas Capital Group and The Procaccianti Group. In October 2011: The property remains in receivership. In August 2011: The property remains in receivership. In June 2011: The owner continues to operate the property with the receiver. 150 E 58th St #33 New York NY 10155 P: 212 371-8188 1 Post Office Sq #3100 Boston MA 02109 P: 617 412-2800 e Current Ownership: Izak Senbahar Management: Rooms: Chain Scale: Year Built: pl 135 W 52nd St New York NY 10019 P: 212 887-9400 F: 212 887-9442 Market: New York, NY Tract: Times Square Area Jack 2 F6 Jack 2 F6 m Flatotel International Hotel 41 206 W 41st St New York NY 10036 P: 212 703-8600 F: 212 703-0895 Market: New York, NY Tract: Times Square Area Current Ownership: Benjamin Soleimani Management: Steven Marx Sa Upper Upscale Rooms: Chain Scale: Year Built: Hotel 41 Boutique Hotel Company 47 Upper Upscale 2002 In July 2012: The property remains in foreclosure. In April 2012 There has been no recent announcement concerning the foreclosure. In January 2012: The auction was not held and the partners are still in negotiation. In November 2011: Crane, AG, a 50% owner of the hotel, filed to foreclose on the developer. An auction has been scheduled for December 5, 2011. 160 E 56th St 350 Fifth Ave #4218 New York New York NY NY 10022 10174 P: 212 750-5588 P: 212 967-9929 When reading this report, please refer to the appendices for other footnote explanations, Glossary of Terms and our Site License Agreement. © Lodging Econometrics. This research information is intellectual property, is copyrighted and remains the property of Lodging Econometrics with all rights reserved. The nature of our relationship is that of a site licensee with specific rights granted for the subscribing client. Specifically, there are no republication rights granted, nor can the research be duplicated or transmitted electronically outside the organization nor can it be shared with or disclosed to other companies or other parties without the expressed written consent of Lodging Econometrics. 500 Market Street, Suite 13 | Portsmouth, NH 03801-3481 USA | p: +1 603.431.8740, ext. 25 | f: + 1 603.431.4418 | e: [email protected] | www.lodgingeconometrics.com Jack 2 1a