the full, print-ready PDF document here
Transcription
the full, print-ready PDF document here
mCe mississippi’s creative economy Realizing the Economic Potential of Creativity in Mississippi Report includes: Executive Summary Study Vignettes mCe mississippi’s creative economy Executive Summary Realizing the Economic Potential of Creativity in Mississippi mCe mississippi’s creative economy Welcome executive summary Mississippi’s rich creative Creative companies alone are responsible for over 40,000 legacy defines who we are as jobs in Mississippi today, but the creative economy is more a people. The state is the than just a significant source of employment. It helps define birthplace of America’s music the high quality of life in many Mississippi communities, and and has produced some of the it is one of the reasons they are excellent places in which to South’s greatest writers. Our visit, to work, or to live. Additionally, our creative economy is creative heritage continues a major amenity that attracts both tourists and talent to the to serve as an inspiration for state, and it kindles innovation and adds significant value to countless artists, entrepreneurs other leading industries in Mississippi, as well. and innovators, and the creative spirit found in Mississippi is just as vibrant and alive today as it was in decades past. By understanding the creative economy as it exists in Mississippi today, we are better positioned to support and further develop The state’s creative tradition has far-reaching implications, this key sector. This portion of our economy has the potential to not only for its contributions to the arts and to American be a major catalyst for job creation and other economic culture, but for its impact on the state’s economy as a whole. opportunities in communities around the state. To better understand this thriving facet of our economy as it exists today, the Mississippi Development Authority (MDA), the state’s lead economic and community development agency, and the Mississippi Arts Commission (MAC) jointly commissioned a study of Mississippi’s creative economy. It examines the scope of our state’s creative economy and the various types of individuals, businesses and organizations that are at its core. In looking ahead, we must focus on our strengths and look at ways we can build upon them. In Mississippi, the creative spirit of our people is one of our greatest assets. By developing our creative economy, we can further strengthen and diversify our state’s economy and better position many of our communities for a bright and prosperous future. Sincerely, This study reveals that more than 60,700 people work in Mississippi’s creative economy, a figure that includes both individuals employed by creative business enterprises and those who work in creative occupations for other companies. Haley Barbour Governor mississippi’s creative economy mCe executive summary The cultural contributions of creativity are readily apparent—as in Mississippi’s literary reputation, musical heritage, and internationally renowned ballet competition; the economic contributions of creativity are not so evident. This report describes the many ways that artistic people, creative enterprises and institutions, and cultural activities can and do attract and retain jobs, increase productivity, stimulate innovation and growth, improve learning, and generate wealth. It then suggests ways to strengthen that reality and promote the image of Mississippi as a heartland of creativity. Powerhouse Community Arts Center, Oxford, MS Introduction Mississippi’s creative people, companies and institutions, past and present, are a vital part of what defines the state. Their achievements and talents contribute to Mississippi’s distinctive ambiance. But these same creative people, companies and institutions collectively also add significant wealth to the state’s economy, in ways that have been undercounted and under-recognized. First, the creative economy is a direct source of economic growth, jobs, and wealth. Second, creativity can improve the competitiveness of manufactured products and services . Third, talented people, businesses that need talent, and tourists are increasingly drawn to places with a creative and cultural milieu, an environment that offers interesting attractions, entertainment and culture. Fourth, a creative environment stimulates innovation in science and technology. Fifth, an educational system that encourages and rewards creativity is the foundation for the 21st century work force, and the arts have demonstrated their success in increasing academic performance. Mississippi’s Creative Economy: Counting, Aggregating and Comparing Mississippi’s creative economy, if defined by the combination of both employees of creative companies and employees of other companies who work in creative occupations, includes roughly 60,704 jobs, shown as the grand total in Figure 2. Mississippi’s creative enterprises are directly responsible for the employment of 40,284 people in 2008 (the sum of the two numbers in the left hand oval in Figure 2) in approximately 3,000 establishments of which almost one in three— 9,580—work in creative occupations. An additional 20,420 Mississippians are employed in creative occupations while employed in sectors of the economy that don’t fit the criteria established for “creative enterprises.” Figure 2: Mississippi’s Creative Economy Figure 1: Convergence of Clusters Architecture Architectural Elements Landscaping Aromas Spiritual Art Healing Art Lifestyle Wellness Spiritualism Construction Creative Enterprises Culinary Arts Weaving Farm Art Agriculture and Food Creative Economy Creative Workforce Other Workers in Creative Enterprises Creative Workers in Creative Enterprises 30,704 9,580 Creative Workers in Other Enterprises 20,420 Consumer Products High Tech Web Design Animation Tourism Cultural Tourism Art Souvenirs Fashions Design Products Advertising 2 mCe mississippi’s creative economy Those industry sectors that are included in the creative economy range from commercial printing and caterers to media related and advertising agencies. Many in these sectors are self-employed as sole owners of businesses, freelancers, and consultants. An estimated 5,250 self-employed individuals, or 17.5 percent of those in creative occupations, fell into this category in 2007 according to the U.S. Census Bureau. While the data presented in this report includes estimates of selfemployed creative workers, it is not able to capture the many individuals with secondary jobs or informal incomes in creative fields, which undoubtedly add to the true scale of the creativite economy. Mississippi has 30,000 people employed in creative occupations, (the sum of the two numbers in the right hand oval in Figure 2.), jobs that require a significant level of originality and imagination. Creative occupations are not just found in the better-known creative sectors like dance theaters, art galleries and advertising agencies. Local governments in Mississippi employ nearly 9 percent of all creative talent, and faith-based organizations employ roughly 5.7 percent, primarily musicians. Trends and Patterns In the past six years, Mississippi has been hit by Katrina, one of the worst natural disasters of recent history, only to then be plunged along with the rest of the nation into a major recession. Over the five-year time span from 2003 to 2008, the creative industries experienced more robust growth during boom times but also were more severely affected by economic contractions. Nevertheless, the creative cluster in Mississippi showed solid growth in employment over the five years. From 2002 to 2008, creative cluster employment grew by four percent in the state compared to six percent growth across all industries but surpassing growth other important value-added clusters such as advanced materials and agribusiness, food processing and technology. Remarkably, overall job growth in Mississippi’s creative sectors exceeded growth in those same creative sectors across the rest of the nation, the exception being 2005 when Hurricane Katrina hit and the Gulf Coast’s employment in creative sectors dropped more than six percent. executive summary Segmenting the Creative Economy To better understand the state’s creative economy, this report separates the creative enterprise cluster into the following six sub clusters: • visual and performing arts • design • film, video, and media • literary and publishing • culinary arts • museums and heritage Visual and Performing Arts The purest segment of the creative economy is made up of those people who earn their living from their artistic talents, the most intentional originators of creativity who turn ideas and visions into art, craft, music, and/or performance. The music that originated in Mississippi’s Delta region, for example, has influenced that art form around the world. Although the scale of this artistic talent is not as great in rural regions as it is in urban art centers, it is just as important in less populated places, and in some, far more important. In 2008, this sub cluster included more than 6,400 people employed in nearly 470 establishments. Based on the occupational data, however, about 1,800 Mississippians classify themselves as pure “artists” producing original work. This sub cluster includes a large number of self-employed people but also many others who work at their art on a part-time basis, supplementing income from other sources. It’s especially difficult to earn a full-time living in music or theater in a sparsely populated region, where many of the artists are employed—for example, as waiters, teachers, or factory workers The average annual earnings for the entire sub cluster is about $19,000. Design Design is an applied art form, applied to products, print and web-based content, buildings and landscapes. The most obvious applications are seen in architecture, gardens, advertising, interior design, and fashion-oriented products. Because the creative content of this sub cluster is not always self-evident, it is often overlooked as part of the creative economy. The creativity embodied in these enterprises is too often taken for granted, attributed to some other factor, and the firm is assigned to some different cluster. This sub cluster has the 3 mississippi’s creative economy second largest employment among the six sub clusters in the state’s creative economy. Design-related businesses in Mississippi employ over 8,000 people in more than 700 establishments in 17 sectors. mCe executive summary Film, Video, and Media This sub cluster comprises 19 sectors that span the distribution and production of motion pictures, music, radio, cable and television programming and multimedia firms. The sub cluster is quite evenly distributed across the state. In 2008, it employed approximately 5,600 people in its 260 plus establishments with an average annual earnings of just over $35,000. Thirty percent of the employment in the sub cluster is directly attributable to cable and other program distribution. Literary and Publishing Literary and publishing have deep roots in Mississippi. About 9,000 people are employed in the sub cluster’s 17 industry sectors, which represents about 28 percent of the state’s creative economy. Mississippi is home to a treasure trove of writers that forms the core of this sub cluster that include some of the nation’s most widely read and beloved fiction writers. William Faulkner, Eudora Welty, Willie Morris, Tennessee Williams, Shelby Foote, Richard Wright, Larry Brown, Richard Ford, Walker Percy, and Ellen Gilchrist are only the beginning of a list that goes on and on. Viking Cooking School, Greenwood, MS Culinary Arts Mississippi is known for certain special foods and a rich foodways tradition. Although it may not have the culinary reputation of New Orleans, it has its own distinctive and authentic tastes. The criterion for being part of the creative economy is that the business, if an eating establishment, employ a trained chef, regularly change the menu, serve local fresh foods, and/ or offer the customer a culinary experience. The Mississippi Hospitality and Restaurant Association estimates that roughly 10 percent of its 2,500 member restaurants have professionally trained chefs, and about 15 of those places also provide venues for art or music. In addition, there are about 30 independent coffee shops with baristas, and some of those roast their own coffees. The final definition includes catering companies, businesses involved in making and selling baked goods, confectionary stores, specialty food items and food processors, and those eating or drinking establishments that had special features associated with creativity. Museums and Heritage Tennessee Williams Park, Clarksdale, MS Mississippi has an exceptionally strong and recognizable cultural heritage that serves to drive and inspire its creative economy. This sub cluster is composed of only three industry sectors, museums, historical sites, and zoos and botanical gardens, and these account for less than 700 jobs and 30 establishments. Although the smallest of the six creative economy sub clusters, it is the most difficult to quantify and is inevitably undercounted because many of the jobs are within government and because there are so many part-time and volunteer employees. While this sub cluster may not be large, it plays a critical role in helping many communities retain their distinctiveness, and it influences much of the state’s music, literature, art, and tourism. 4 mississippi’s creative economy Support Infrastructure Because much of the value of creative economy is based on the manner in which its products are experienced and success of the buzz that it produces, the creative economy depends heavily on support from a variety of physical, intellectual, technical, and social sources to deliver or provide services to the creative economy. The ultimate strength of the creative economy is tied in large part to the quality and quantity of the social and support infrastructure that support it. Organizations Guilds, councils, arts associations, advocacy organizations, and social networks represent the associational infrastructure that enables members of Mississippi’s creative economy to connect to one another, to the state’s broader creative economy, and to external sources of knowledge and creative inspiration. The approximately 200 arts organizations and networks that this study found include formal and informal groups of working artists, educators, and patrons and supporters of the arts. Education and Training Mississippi’s educational institutions assume many roles in the state’s creative economy. They generate its labor force and entrepreneurs; provide access to new ideas, information, and people; and host entertainment and cultural activities in their communities. In each area of activity, Mississippi has significant strengths but also opportunities to do more. The state’s talent is first nurtured in its K-12 schools, and Mississippi’s Whole Schools Initiative is among the best programs in the nation, a model for integrating the arts in the schools. Most of Mississippi’s community colleges are beginning to respond to the state’s transition from a mass production economy to an idea- and experience-based economy and to the growing job market and student demand for applied creative arts in, for example, digital arts, graphic design, landscape architecture, and interior decoration. And many colleges and universities are important sources of and venues for art and culture, especially in the state’s smaller cities. mCe executive summary community at large; and as a way to generate economic impact for the community in which they are held. Festivals also provide the opportunity to tell a community’s story and help create a sense of place. Places and Spaces: Creativity on Display Many creative occupations and processes are individual endeavors, calling to mind the image of the solitary artist in a studio or the writer hunched over a desk. Indeed, creative individuals need such places to create, either alone or with other creative people. But they also need more public places to perform, exhibit and share their work. In Mississippi, hundreds of museums, galleries, theaters, concert halls, restaurants and pubs, historic sites, buildings and neighborhoods, gardens and public spaces serve as venues for the performance, exhibition, and dissemination of creative work. Resources: Investments and Involvement The Mississippi Arts Commission and its network of partners are the most important resources and sources of support for the state’s artists and organizations in the arts, providing direct grants to individual artists and operating grant individual arts councils around the state. Many of these organizations provide funding to support individual artists or community focused events and efforts. Mississippi also has an estimated 46 foundations based in Mississippi that name arts funding one of their areas of emphasis—for activities such as assisting after school programs; providing disadvantaged youth with arts instruction, supporting the many arts-focused festivals around the states; and making grants to support community theaters and symphonies. Other organizations that provide small business assistance include the Mississippi Development Authority, which provides technical assistance for promotion, marketing, and business development. The network of Mississippi Small Business Development Centers can assist businesses in start-up plans as well as around issues such as obtaining financing and expanding market share. Events and Performances One of the most important outlets for artistic expression is the multitude of festivals that are found in almost every county in Mississippi. These festivals serve as an asset for Mississippi’s creative economy in several ways: as an active market for Mississippi artists; as a way to integrate and promote the arts to the Powerhouse Community Arts Center, Oxford, MS 5 mCe mississippi’s creative economy V. Recommended Goals and Strategies The size of the creative economy alone has a large and direct impact on the state’s economy—nearly 3,000 establishments responsible for roughly 40,200 jobs that are engaged primarily in the production, distribution, and marketing of aesthetically or emotionally oriented products or services—is sufficient reason to invest in the cluster. It employs more people than the defense and security, apparel and textiles, and transportation equipment manufacturing clusters, all of which are important sectors of the state’s economy. Add to that the effect of the creative economy on so many other sectors, such as tourism, agriculture, communications and information technologies, furniture and health care and its value as an amenity that attracts tourists and talent, and the potential value far exceeds the conventional view of the lone artist at a festival or performer on the street. The following goals and strategies are based on what has been learned in this study and on the ideas and vision of some of the key stakeholders in Mississippi’s arts, education, and economic development arenas. They are intended to help the state reap the full benefits of its creative people and creative economy. The Creative Economy 1. Is a direct source of growth (Goal II) 2. Adds value to other sectors (Goals IV, V) 3. Attracts talented people, businesses and tourists (Goals I, III) 4. Stimulates innovation (Goals III, IV, V) 5. Is the foundation for the 21st century work force (Goal VI) GOAL I: Facilitate efforts that make communities throughout the state more creative and vibrant. In Richard Florida’s Who’s Your City, he demonstrates the value of place to people and to companies. “Where we live is the central factor that affects all others—work, education, and love—follow. 1” Although the book focuses on large metropolitan areas, small communities can even more easily executive summary distinguish or brand themselves and attract people and firms who may be looking for less expensive, less crowded, and less hectic places. Those communities that are able to offer enough of the urban creative amenities and cultural attractions along with a slower, more family-friendly lifestyle can use that to their advantage to generate and retain wealth. Strategies that allow rural communities to convert their creative talent into economic activities are critical to Mississippi’s future. Strategy A: Use creative talent and enterprises to promote community restoration and revitalization. • Reinstate state funding for Mississippi’s Building Fund for the Arts (BFA) program, a bond bill that could be used to refurbish and maintain buildings as cultural centers. 2 The fund, authorized at $19.2 million and managed by the Mississippi Arts Commission, supported 93 projects between 2001 and 2007. Awards were based on artistic quality, plans, architectural and organizational capacity, and anticipated economic impact. • Offer financial or architectural incentives or technical assistance to make abandoned or unused downtown space available to creative businesses, galleries, and/or studio space in both urban areas and in small communities. Paducah, Kentucky has had one of the nation’s first and most successful artists relocation programs. Recruiting artists nationally with zero interest loans and subsidies for architectural changes, the city attracts some 50 artists, which brought galleries and theaters to a previously distressed area of the city. In Pittsfield, Massachusetts, a group of artists worked with the owners of vacant storefronts in the downtown. The idea was to give artists the opportunity to work in these spaces and exhibit their art, and to bring more foot traffic to the downtown. The effort succeeded in helping both the artists and the property owners, and downtown Pittsfield is now a more arts-active and vibrant place to live and work. 1 Richard Florida, Who’s Your City? New York: Basic Books, 2008, p. 6. 2 http://www.arts.state.ms.us/programs/building-fund.php 6 mCe mississippi’s creative economy • Develop and communicate programs currently available through MAC. • Consider a “Percent for Art” program such as is being implemented on university campuses and many federal projects. Set aside a percentage of funding for public buildings and public spaces to display art such as sculptures, murals and other decorative art in, for example, hotel lobbies, restaurants, banks, hospitals and outdoors. • Consider zoning and private-sector set asides such as those done in the GSA Art in Architecture Program which commissions the nation’s leading artists to create large-scale works of art for new federal buildings. These artworks enhance the civic meaning of federal architecture and showcase the vibrancy of American visual arts. Together, the art and architecture of federal buildings create a lasting cultural legacy for the people of the United States. GSA reserves one-half of the estimated construction cost of each new federal building to commission project artists. The Alluvian Hotel, a cosmopolitan boutique hotel in Greenwood, Mississippi exhibits a collection of award-winning art by Mississippi artists. The Mayor of Sheridan, Wyoming enacted Resolution 24-00 to establish an “Art in Public Places” program in July 2000 and the city of 15,000 now has some 50 sculptures with a western theme downtown. Originally on loan from the artists for $500, about half now have been purchased and are permanent. • Support the designation and formation of “Creative Economic districts,” where creative people and enterprises are encouraged to concentrate, collaborate, live and work. executive summary arts. They created a cultural center in abandoned factories with low rent space for studios and theater companies. Granville Island is now the artistic center of Vancouver and a primary tourist destination served by a steady stream of sea taxies. 4 • MDA and MAC would create a program that helps communities become certified (similar to the state’s Certified Retirement Communities program) and offer technical assistance to communities to inventory their creative assets and develop plans to meet criteria for being designated a “creative community.” Mississippi offers communities the chance to become Certified Retirement Communities, which is obtained after a three-month screening process, and to become recognized under the Mississippi Main Street Association program, supported by the National Trust for Historic Preservation and the Mississippi Development Authority. The Maine Arts Commission established a program in 2001 called “Discovery Research that gave grants and methodologies to communities to map their creative assets, discover their own cultural resources, and provide funds to survey local events, artists, traditions, and tradition-bearers as well as cultural organizations which promote or support the performing, visual, craft or literary arts. The state is now transitioning from that discovery model to a capacity building model. Vermont, based on recommendations of the Vermont Council on Culture and Innovation, encouraged selected communities to look at development through the lens of the creative economy, emphasizing the importance of place, creative partnerships, and creative assets. 5 The state of Louisiana recently passed enabling legislation that allows local communities to create Cultural Districts, and at least 51 districts have been created around the state to date. The Districts provide tax exemptions for the sale of one-of-a-kind art and tax credits to rehabilitate buildings to help create more vibrant downtowns. 3 Granville Island was formed from a sandbar in the heart of Vancouver, British Columbia to hide the city’s heavy industries. In the 1970s a local politician led the move to change its image and rebuild the island’s economy on the 3 http://www.crt.state.la.us/culturaldistricts/documents/act298.pdf. 4 http://granvilleisland.com 5 http://www.vtrural.org/creative-communities.php. 7 mCe mississippi’s creative economy executive summary Strategy B: MAC to continue support and assist Strategy A: cultural fairs and festivals. businesses in the creative industries. Improve • ability of existing technical and business support infrastructure to support the self-employed and microenterprises. MAC and MDA offers technical assistance and support for organizers of fairs, festivals and other celebrations through the Festivals and Events Coordinators Workshops. The program improves the promotion, marketing, fundraising and business planning efforts of festivals. These festivals and other forms of community and regional celebrations can be used effectively to showcase and market a place’s special history, culture, creativity or even weirdness, an increasingly sought attribute. 6 • Help small business development centers, cooperative and manufacturing extension offices, incubators, MDA’s Entrepreneurial Center and employment services to better understand the particular needs and markets of the creative enterprise. Continue to work through existing programs and organizations such as tech parks, incubator space, MDA’s Entrepreneurial Center, etc. The Mississippi Arts Commission (MAC) and the Mississippi Development Authority’s (MDA) Tourism Division have been active supporters of many events through grants and other services. Both agencies recognize the challenges faced by community groups that produce festivals. To address these challenges, MAC and MDA have come together to produce workshops that provide training and networking opportunities for festival coordinators from around the state. The current Mississippi Arts Commission program to help artists with business skills could be turned into a “train the trainer” program that would enable existing services to better understand and support the needs of artists and artisans. www.visualarts.ms.gov. The Mississippi Arts Commission has created the Mississippi Visual Arts Directory Website. The website serves as a resource to all things visual arts in the state and provides artists with the opportunity to increase their visibility. The site is open to all visual artists and craftsmen, museums, cultural centers and galleries and visual arts organizations and all art education facilities. The City of Lowell, Massachusetts has an event called “Destination World” that brings together all of the city’s immigrant and ethnic communities around a single event to highlight the contribution and work of the city’s immigrant population. This also brings new audiences to the downtown. Haywood Community College in western North Carolina hosts an arts business boot camp every summer during which artisans are taught about managing their business, finances, marketing, use of ecommerce, and budgeting. Most years, the camp is oversubscribed, with attendees coming from across the U.S. It’s supported by the Arts Business Institute, co-located with HandMade in America in Asheville. GOAL II: Promote entrepreneurship and small business growth among creative firms. The creative economy, with its emphasis on small scale, over mass production, is exceptionally entrepreneurial. But because the structure of this cluster favors highly flexible small companies with uncertain markets that are dependent more on the strength of reputation and connections than productivity, it is not well understood or served by the public agencies that assist small businesses. Business and capital assistance organizations typically are measured by employment growth, which biases publicly funded services against helping entrepreneurial companies that are considered “lifestyle” or unlikely to grow very large. Develop greater capacity to assist • Expand Mississippi’s existing “Arts Means Business” program to reach a greater number of creative enterprises and creative people, possibly working though membership organizations like the Mississippi Craftsmen’s Guild and by training the staff of existing small business assistance programs and educational institutions to support creative enterprises. 6 Joe Cortright, “‘Keep Portland Weird’ makes sense as a jobs strategy,” Oregonlive.com, February 13, 2010. 8 mississippi’s creative economy The Montana two-year college system developed a program called “artrepreneurship” in its arts and crafts program at Great Falls that emphasizes the business side of the arts. An evaluation of the first class of completers found on average a 152 percent increase in sales, 309 percent increase in out-of-state sales, and four new enterprises started. • Strategy B: The Milwaukee Cultural Council is developing a comprehensive on-line database for all of the people and companies that are part of the creative economy in southeast Wisconsin as part of its creative economy initiative. • Work together across agencies to identify and communicate the state’s creative brand, i.e., “Mississippi’s Creative Spirit.” The Mississippi Development Authority (MDA) Tourism Division contracted with North Star Destination Strategies to determine and define the state’s true, unique and relevant brand position that will help the state stand out in the tourism marketplace. North Star conducted more than a dozen pieces of research to identify what differentiates Mississippi from its competitors. The result? Mississippi is the most southern of all states and the mother of southern culture - yesterday, today and tomorrow. From this, Mississippi’s brand was created, “Find Your True South.” Many places have branded their creative products, such as Kentucky Crafted, Native Handicraft from Alaska and Made in Montana. Fewer have successfully used creativity to brand a place, although Glasgow, Scotland calls itself the “Creative City” and the Berkshires in western Massachusetts use “Berkshire Creative: Creativity Lives Here” as a regional brand. Consider producing a Mississippi Roots Music show that celebrates being the birthplace of America’s music. The Boston Pops has an American Idol style competition called POPSearch. Held in the summer, it plays to a live audience of almost half a million and millions more on television. In 2004, the winner was a van driver for special needs children. 9 Support branding and marketing of the state’s creative places, products and assets. Build the state’s artist’s roster, develop a more comprehensive directory of the larger range of creative enterprises that includes, for instance, lists of writers, designers, architects, interior designers, music companies, animators, and graphic artists. Use the roster to reach broader and more distant markets for the state’s creative products. The Georgia Tourism Foundation supports a web site called Georgia’s Creative Economies that promotes Georgia people, places, and made and grown things. It can be searched by region, category, and subcategory. 8 Assist existing state programs and resources, such as the Small Business Development Centers and WIN Job Centers, to better understand and assist creative enterprises, with a special effort to target the development and growth of creative enterprises by underserved populations. In Kentucky, the state agricultural extension service has an extension agent in the poor, eastern-most and coal dependent part of Appalachia dedicated to working with artisans and artists and the University of Massachusetts-Amherst has an Arts Extension Service that has helped connect communities to the arts and has offered workshops and training for more than 30 years, now including a creative economy training program. 7 • • mCe Strategy C: Help artists find new full-time employment that utilizes their talent. • Support the development of an artist’s employment service, either through the Arts Commission or the Mississippi Department of Employment Security. In Southeast Wisconsin, the Kohler Corporation has an on-going Artists in Residency program that leads to its arts edition products. The company also has an art gallery. In addition, one of the hotels in downtown Milwaukee created a similar Artist-in-Residency program in which a local artist worked on his paintings in the lobby of the hotel. The program has elevated the visibility of the arts and artists and made the lobby of the hotel more attractive. Northern Michigan University hosts an “Art & Design Career & Employment - Art Jobs” designed to provide access to numerous art/design career and employment internet resources. Individuals can search for opportunities across the entire US and even globally. 7 http://www.artsextensionservice.org 8 http://www.gamadegagrownproducts.org/index.php 9 http://www.myspace.com/popsearch 9 mCe mississippi’s creative economy GOAL III Help communities preserve and generate added value from the state’s rich cultural and historic heritage. Strategy A: Encourage investment in and marketing of the state’s cultural heritage in more communities. • The history and architecture of a place influence how people feel about their communities and the decisions people make of where they want to live. This, in turn, influences where companies want to do business. If a place is distinctive enough, values, and invests in that uniqueness, cultural heritage can generate wealth in its own right. Mississippi represents a prime example of this phenomenon. The state’s cultural heritage, particularly as demonstrated by its literature, music, and architecture, is a strong, internationally recognized brand. Literature is epitomized by Oxford, music by Clarksdale, and architecture by Natchez. But all three art forms are present in force in many other places across the state. For example, in 2008 Columbus was named one of twelve national distinctive destinations by the National Trust for Historic Preservation. If the heritage of a place can be preserved in the face of the growth pressures brought on by development, that brand can be used to promote all aspects of Mississippi’s creative economy. Many other communities have some of these same attributes, but they are unrecognized or underappreciated. Taylor, for example, has been recognized as being “quintessential Mississippi [where] tourists come for photos.” 10 Mississippi should focus on those things which are authentically part of our Mississippi culture: • • • • • • • Arts Literarture Music Architecture Food Sacred places Civil War and Civil Rights The state should help communities identify their assets; provide communities a template and best practices. Help each community to inventory and assess the economic value of its cultural and historical assets including its architecture. Although Mississippi has a strong program for preserving and registering historic places, this step would look for a unifying theme that is distinctive and defining and tie it to development efforts. In Mineral Point, Wisconsin, the town used its early mining history to create the historic Shake Rag Alley. The nine buildings attract students in the arts and crafts to classes, and a nearby artists’ community is home to 17 art galleries within a few blocks of Shake Rag Alley. 11 • Make better use of the state’s strong investment in heritage sites and locations by linking them to the creative economy and the arts community. The city of Charleston, South Carolina has worked to establish itself as a center of historic preservation. This includes the location of the American College of Building Arts, which offers degrees in historic preservation, and Clemson University’s Graduate Program in Historic Preservation. Strategy B: Involve the media, new and old, in promoting all of Mississippi’s cultural assets. For example, promote literature and strengthening the market for literary products. • Create a year-round arts colony with an emphasis on writers and composers somewhere in the state. The prestigious Mississippi Art Colony for painters is now more than 60 years old, and a similar “camp” for writers would further enhance Mississippi’s brand as a literary cluster. In Arkansas the Writers Colony at Dairy Hollow in Eureka Springs, renamed the Communications Arts Institute, gives about 50 writers each year a place to work free from distractions and in a community of people with similar interests with whom they share ideas and receive constructive feedback. Typically, writers—now extended to songwriters 10 Christine Schultz, “You could say that some people’s careers find them,” Southwest Airlines Spirit Magazine, May 2010. 11 http://shakeragalley.com 10 mCe mississippi’s creative economy and composers in the new “composers’ cottage”—spend between two weeks and three months, but usually about a month in residency. 12 The Jentel and Ucross year-round art colonies in Sheridan, Wyoming, combine the literary and visual arts. The residents describe their work at regular community meetings and Ucross has a stage that puts on musical and literary events for the community. 13 Strategy C: Further promote the image of Mississippi as a “global literary capital.” • Suggest that Oxford apply to UNESCO for Oxford to be designated a “City of Literature.” This designation will attract international attention to a community that is so rich in literary excellence. The Southern Literary Trail is a collaboration of eighteen towns from Natchez, Mississippi to Savannah, Georgia that celebrate internationally renowned writers and playwrights who were inspired by uniquely southern places. The Trail maps visitors travel to a region that is home to great writers and timeless stories. The Mississippi trail features such writers as Tennessee Williams, Eudora Welty, Shelby Foote, Margaret Walker Alexander, Richard Wright and William Faulkner. The Mississippi Development Authority is currently developing a Mississippi literary trail modeled after similar trails such as the Blues Heritage Trail, tamale trail and agri-tourism trail. Mississippi communities host a number of literary festivals and events around the state such as the Tennessee Williams festival in Clarksdale, the Natchez Literary and Film festival and the Oxford Conference of the Book. and the market, not just R&D, and to make similar investments in helping companies use creativity and design to distinguish and establish new products in the market and new markets. During the course of this report, we learned that while manufacturers in the state recognize the value of consumer-driven design and innovation to their success, they do not yet use it to their fullest advantage. Strategy A: Help manufacturers understand the importance of creativity and value of design as a competitive advantage. • Create a Creative Economy Toolkit, a resource for business focusing on the relationship between creativity and economic growth and how they combine to create value and opportunity. • Recommend that the Mississippi Manufacturers Association establish a council on manufacturing design or a design association within the organization for both education and application of design among manufacturers. The Center for Design Innovation in North Carolina’s Piedmont region brings in top designers to meet with local businesses and is working on forming a design council. It hosts an annual Design, Art, & Technology Symposium and brings in frequent internationally known speakers to give workshops. 14 Winzelear Gear in Chicago, which has been making gears for industry for more than a century, advertises its gears as an art form and the company has a partnership with the School of the Art Institute with fashion designers experimenting with incorporating plastic gears into unique garments and accessories. 15 GOAL IV: Enhance the competitiveness of the state’s business and industry through increased use of art and design. Throughout the 1980’s and 1990’s, Mississippi successfully helped its industries develop or adopt the new technologies they needed to compete, investing in R&D and in technical assistance. Now that those process technologies are readily available and have been adopted in places with much lower operating costs, the competitive advantage has disappeared. The challenge for the 21st century will be to adopt innovations driven by the user 12 http://www.writerscolony.org 13 http://www.ucrossfoundation.org/ 14 http://www.centerfordesigninnovation.org/ 15 http://www.winzelergear.com/ 11 mCe mississippi’s creative economy Oregon Creative Industries was formed in 2008 as a nonprofit association to provide a way for creative people, whether artists, film makers, designers, and architects, to intermingle, exchange ideas, and make deals.16 Strategy B: Help business and industry connect to design resources and expand design capabilities. • Include product design support among the services of the state’s Manufacturing Extension Partnership. The Manufacturing Extension Partnership, which was originally formed to help small and mid-sized manufacturers learn about and adopt newer production technologies, is well positioned to extend its services to helping small and mid-sized firms identify, develop, and use their design competencies and pursue user-driven innovations. • Provide state tax credits for investments in design capabilities similar to the state’s Five Year R&D Skills tax credit. Look at incentives similar to those used in technology businesses. Such credits have existed for many years for science-based research but have not been applied to user-driven, design oriented development. The legislation refers to scientists, engineers, and research professionals. Similar tax credits could be given for positions in design. Strategy C: Facilitate and support networking among creative people and companies • Offer incentives in existing incentive or grant programs for proposals by three or more firms operating as “flexible design networks” to encourage sharing design capacities similar to those given by some 20-30 states in the 1990s for “flexible manufacturing networks” to promote industrial modernization in small and mid-sized manufacturers. USNet was a 15-state program of Regional Technology Strategies, Inc. supported by NIST to train economic development officials and business leaders in collaborative approaches to innovation, marketing, and learning. • GOAL V: Enhance the support and networking infrastructure for creative talent across the state. Creative people tend to be heavy users of digital social networking but not necessarily joiners of associations that bring people together face to face. Yet the evidence is that younger creative people, in particular, seek places where they can meet in person, socialize, share ideas, and build different kinds of relationships than they can on Facebook. Across all age groups, creative people in Mississippi expressed a desire for more opportunities for socializing and networking than is currently available. Strategy A: Promote cross-disciplinary creative networking. • Support local initiatives which encourage more networking opportunities and activities, particularly those that involve young creative people. Berkshire Spark is a networking activity of Berkshire Creative. It occurs monthly at a different locations (e.g. museums, art galleries, banks, etc.). The events bring together several hundred people (artists, cultural organizations and for-profit businesses) to meet and explore new ways of collaborating and partnering. In Milwaukee, Spreenkler Creative is a social networking site for creative people and students that informs them about events, internships and job opportunities, holds events, and provides a blogging site. 17 It also has a “meetup” page for young talent. Encourage and support cross-discipline associations of creative people that mix and blend creative ideas from different perspectives and across different ages and cultures and propagate creativity. 16 http://blog.oregoncreative.org/ 17 http://spreenkler.com/. 12 mCe mississippi’s creative economy Strategy B: Expand knowledge of, and familiarity with, existing arts and culture within the private sector. • Strategy A: Expand and strengthen post secondary degree programs in creative fields of study. • Promote the value of incorporating and displaying art and music in private and public facilities and grounds, such as at hospitals, offices, casinos, and manufacturing plants. Tampere College in Finland formed a network of community colleges, which includes U.S. colleges, to seamlessly combine the business side of a restaurant with interior design, service, menu, image, and pricing principles. During 4-6 week placements abroad students learn these skills and develop new catering products in teams of three that include a caterer, chef and baker. Duke hospital in Durham, North Carolina, has on-going artists in residence —artists, craftsmen, musicians, and writers—all supported by North Carolina Arts Council.18 In Sheridan, Wyoming, establishments ranging from the local Holiday Inn to Arby’s restaurant feature the work of local artists on their walls. • • Continue to assist transactions between artists, designers, and businesses In New York City, a firm called Art Assets serves as a broker between artists and businesses that want to either buy or rent local art work. “Art has the power to transform space. Art Assets harnesses that power to communicate the vision and philosophy of each client to imbue their space with a special sense of value and sophistication” 19 GOAL VI: Build Capacity to grow & retain Creative Talent Living and Working in Mississippi Expand the culinary arts programs at community colleges, include artistic content, and offer international internships. Establish a new two-year associate of applied science degree program in film/video/music production and convert the exiting one-year pre-architecture program to a two-year program with minors in historic restoration and community design. Guilford Technical Community College in Jamestown, North Carolina established the Larry Gatlin Entertainment Technology Center. It offers one and two-year degree programs and continuing education in a range of employment and freelance opportunities in all technical aspects of the industry. • Expand programs in design disciplines at the state’s fouryear colleges and universities and integrate the arts and design into science, engineering, and business. The University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee School of Engineering supports research projects that involve three engineers and one artist to encourage creative solutions. For the fastest growing sectors of the economy, a surplus work force is no longer a sufficient asset to attract investment. Companies depend on talent, generally, but not always, as measured by levels of education, and many firms make their investment decisions based on where that talent already resides or is willing to move. Mississippi should first grow its talent by expanding educational programs for the creative sectors. Second, it should work to retain and recruit creative and talented people by providing environments with the amenities they seek. There is growing evidence that a significant portion of the talent population is looking outside the metropolitan areas for places that have more space, lower costs, and less traffic. 20 18 http://www.ncartsforhealth.org/CulturalServ.htm • • Create a life-long learning experience; Encourage the state to adopt creative strategies in education 19 http://artassets.com 20 “In Praise of Boise: Why space really is the final frontier in the Internet age,” The Economist, May 13, 2010. 13 mississippi’s creative economy Strategy B: Promote the retention of graduates and the return of former graduates of creative degree programs in Mississippi. • • Use social networks to maintain connections among graduates who stay or leave and organize creative alumni groups in major cities. Consider creating a “MS Monster.com-type” employment listing Social networking now makes it easier for graduates who spread out across the country to stay in touch with each other and their roots. By giving some structure to Mississippi-based networks of creatives, and providing ways to stay abreast of opportunities and events back home, some of those who leave may choose to come back. mCe McKinley Technical High School in Washington, DC, which serves a low-income minority population and utilizes creative endeavors such as broadcasting, gaming, and web design to produce the city’s highest level of STEM skills. The school, with federal grants, started an Institute of Urban Game Design. The Mississippi Alliance for Arts Education received a grant from the Dana Foundation to provide training to Mississippi artists interested in working with teachers in school settings so that students may benefit from authentic experiences in specific art forms and to make cross-curricular connections among the arts and other core subjects. The goal of the workshops is to increase the number of artists included in the Mississippi Arts Commission’s Teaching Artist Roster. Schools that engage artists routinely consult this roster for a description of an artist’s skills and a recommendation of the quality of his/her work in the arts and in education. Strategy C: Use creative career programs to increase school retention rates in Mississippi • Establish a “middle college,” that combines grades 11 and 12 with two years of postsecondary education, that focuses on art, design, and multimedia. Such schools, located on community college campuses and heavily supported by the Gates Foundation, have proven to increase attendance and completion rates among underserved populations. A middle college that emphasizes creative career paths can both attract non-traditional learners and develop the state’s talent base. • Offer more curricula choices in creative fields such as music, film, and digital arts in ways that produce basic skill competencies as well as offer career opportunities. The Arkansas Science & Technology Authority established the EAST initiative (Environmental and Spatial Technology) to use digital arts media to facilitate the teaching of math and science. The program includes My Community, where students make documentary films about their communities and culture. • Establish new career and technical education secondary school programs in digital fields including gaming and animation. 14 mCe mississippi’s creative economy mississippi’s creative economy Study Realizing the Economic Potential of Creativity in Mississippi mCe mississippi’s creative economy Table of Contents Acknowledgements 1 I. 2 Introduction A. The Mississippi Context B. The Special Challenges Facing Creative Enterprises in a Weak Economy 3 4 II. Mississippi’s Creative Economy 5 A. Counting, Aggregating, and Comparing 6 B. Creative Enterprises in Mississippi 6 C. Creative Occupations 8 D. Trends and Patterns 9 E. Convergence Among Clusters in Mississippi 10 III. Segmenting the Creative Economy 11 A. Visual and Performing Arts 12 B. Design 15 C. Film, Video, and Media 17 D. Literary and Publishing 19 E. Culinary Arts 21 F. Museums and Heritage 22 IV. Support Infrastructure 24 A. Support Infrastructure: Networking for 24 B. Educational Institutions: Sources of Talent, C. Events and Performances 28 D. Places and Spaces: Creativity on Display 30 E. Resources: Investments and Involvement 31 Compatibility and Competitiveness 26 Learning, and Culture V. Recommended Goals and Strategies 33 VI. A Vision for the Future 42 Appendix A. Regional Distribution of Creative 43 Activity in Mississippi Appendix B: Trends in Creative Economy by Region 44 Appendix C: Defining the Creative Economy 46 Table C.1: Mississippi Creative Enterprises 47 Table C.2: Mississippi Creative Occupations 48 mississippi’s creative economy mCe Acknowledgements This report is a product of a joint effort among the Mississippi Arts Commission (MAC), Mississippi Development Authority (MDA), Regional Technology Strategies (RTS), and Mt. Auburn Associates. We wish to give special thanks to Malcolm White, Director of MAC, for continually sharing information and insights, and MDA Executive Director Gray Swoope and Chief Marketing Officer, Melissa Medley for keeping us connected to and informed of the economic development interests and implications. Allison Winstead, Candice Thomley and Lee Powell and all of the staff at MAC and many staff members at MDA were extremely helpful throughout the project. We also acknowledge the broad base of support for the research and preparation of the report to many people we depended on for information, understanding, insights, and critiques, including the community college presidents at a meeting arranged by State Board for Community and Junior Colleges Executive Director Dr. Eric Clark. We also thank the many artists, crafts people, festival managers, and manufacturers for completing the three surveys, and particularly Julia Daily, executive director of the Craftsmen’s Guild of Mississippi and Jay Moon, CEO of the Mississippi Manufacturers Association, for supporting these efforts through their respective memberships and are grateful to Julia for arranging a site visit and focus group of members. Those who carried out the research and contributed to the reports include RTS Director of Special Projects Dan Broun; RTS Senior Associate Jenna Bryant, who did the quantitative analyses; Mt. Auburn President Beth Siegel and Mt Auburn managing partner Michael Kane, RTS graduate student intern Dana Archer Rosenthal, and Beth Williams, who assisted with copy editing. Stuart Rosenfeld, Regional Technology Strategies 1 mississippi’s creative economy Powerhouse Community Arts Center, Oxford, MS 1. Introduction The culture and creativity that are embodied in the people, places, and institutions of the state of Mississippi provide both intrinsic value, by defining communities and contributing to quality of life, and extrinsic value, by driving and bolstering regional economies. Intrinsically, the achievements and talents of Mississippi’s creative people, companies and institutions imbue the state with a distinctive ambiance and brand. They generate pride in community and sources of non-commodity-based satisfaction. But they convey much more than a sense of place. The cultural contributions of creativity are readily apparent—as in Mississippi’s literary reputation, musical heritage, and internationally renowned ballet competition. These intrinsic contributions have been acknowledged, documented, and valued, but the economic contributions of creativity are not as evident. The extrinsic economic value, however, has been underappreciated and undervalued and these same creative people, companies and institutions collectively add significant wealth to the state’s economy, in ways that have been vastly under recognized. Thus, while acknowledging the intrinsic value of the arts and culture, the extrinsic value in arts and culture and their application in many other sectors of the economy becomes the principal focus of this report. The following pages describe the multitude of ways that artistic people, creative enterprises and institutions, and cultural activities can and do generate new wealth, increase productivity and competitiveness, attract and retain jobs, stimulate innovation and growth, and improve learning. mCe First, the creative economy is a direct source of economic growth, jobs, and wealth. But it is almost always undercounted and underrated because (1) so much of it is embodied in selfemployed artists, designers, freelancers and microenterprises; (2) many creative businesses are classified in sectors not generally thought of as being driven by creativity; and (3) a large amount is generated by secondary forms of employment and self-employment. When appropriately aggregated the size of the creative sectors compare favorably even to the more popular high tech sectors. Second, creativity can improve the competitiveness of manufactured products and services. Talented firms and people create products, artifacts, experiences, and even processes with attributes that imbue them with newly discovered or additional value because they are more aesthetically pleasing, useful, powerful and desirable. Viking Range is a prime example of a company that successfully identified and filled a niche in the market for attractive but industrial strength kitchen appliances. An economy’s capacity to innovate and create new value is the key to sustaining the growth and wealth generating process. Third, talented people, businesses searching for talent, and tourists are increasingly drawn to places with a creative and cultural milieu, an environment that offers interesting attractions, entertainment and culture. Cost is still important to high growth businesses but no longer the deciding factor in choosing a location. Jackson’s Fondren district, by reinventing itself from a slightly rundown neighborhood to a trendy upscale art district defined by its creative businesses, made itself a much more attractive location. Fourth, a creative environment stimulates innovation in science and technology. Creativity, as an action or process, has its own set of profound values apart from economic value. But as an economic actor, it accelerates the innovation impulse. Fifth, creativity is increasingly becoming the foundation for the 21st century work force and the arts a factor in increased academic performance. When Mississippi began industrializing, good work habits and literacy were sufficient. As the state’s industry modernized, industry needed higher order technical and problem solving skills. But today, in an increasingly digitized and entrepreneurial economy, creativity is quickly becoming the 2 mCe mississippi’s creative economy key to competitive advantage in many of the fastest growing sectors of the economy. Further, the arts are proving to be a potent force for improving academic outcomes while also developing an appreciation of culture. For much of the first half of the 20th century, Mississippi sat at the bottom among all states in almost every measure of income or wealth. Its farms had been decimated by the boll weevil and its forests depleted by large timber companies that failed to reseed. A. The Mississippi Context In 1936, Mississippi took a historic step by enacting a plan to “Balance Agriculture with Industry (BAWI).” This allowed the state to provide tax incentives and buildings to labor-intensive manufacturers that were willing to locate or relocate in the state, which altered the playing field of economic development forever. The incentives combined with labor costs and a pro-business climate brought an industrial bonanza, with large numbers of companies relocating or building new facilities in the state. Tennessee Williams Park, Clarksdale, MS Mississippi is fortunate to be an extremely rich source of talented people. Eudora Welty, Tennessee Williams, Craig Claiborne, Morgan Freeman, Leontyne Price, Muddy Waters, James Earl Jones, Walter Anderson, and Willie Morris—and even Brett Favre, in his own way—are but a very few examples of Mississippi’s deep reservoir of well-known creative people. This wellspring of talent developed across the state from a number of sources: from within an educated, privileged agricultural society that was able to appreciate and invest in the arts to the landscape of the coast that inspired many artists and from within the poor and undereducated class of share croppers and tenant farmers that developed its own art forms as an expression of and release from the drudgery of daily life. Mississippi’s history and culture has bred and cultivated imaginative writers; from the writings of William Faulkner, whose family founded a railroad, and whose novels—it was recently discovered—were heavily influenced by slave diaries in his possession1 to Eudora Welty, who was influenced by the depression and social causes. You find this same talent in the blues played at the Mississippi State Penitentiary at Parchman Farm, which produced legendary musicians like Son House and songs like “Parchman Farm Blues” and “Midnight Special.” Mid-century views of Mississippi’s creativity often were overlooked as a result of northern urban standards of success set by professional critics, patrons, and the media, not by consumers, participants, and word of mouth. Urban media paid attention to writers while missing the richness of Mississippi’s blues music, folk art, patterned textiles, visual art, local theater, local foods, dance, and period architecture. Too often the critics that set standards for art and culture missed the art of African Americans, Native Americans, farmhands and shop owners, and they glossed over the art that permeated many rural communities and that exists in carefully preserved historic homes, along the Natchez Trace, and in the distinctive and authentic products of manufacturers. They failed to appreciate Mississippi’s eclectic, and even eccentric, art. “Arts are not isolated, arts are part of a fabric of life here, and add to the soul of the community,” according to Gwen Impson, past president and founder of The Arts, Hancock County. “The local hospital has art on its walls….whether you go to a doctor or the hair salon you see art.” Mississippi is now on the cusp of another transition that may equal the industrialization that resulted from BAWI. Even though the state will continue to attract a solid share of the nation’s manufacturing, the manufacturing employment pie is shrinking. The future may well depend on a new plan – BIWA (Balance Industry With Aesthetics). Can the state’s creative sectors fuel new growth and prosperity by generating work, luring talent-dependent companies, and attracting visitors? 1 Patricia Cohen, “Faulkner Link to Plantation Diary Discovered,” New York Times, February 11, 2010. 3 mississippi’s creative economy Mississippi today is already home to creative talent that exists across ethnicities, ages, classes, races, and spaces. The state is known internationally not only for its outstanding writers, musicians, and stars of stage and screen but also for its historic architecture and sites, and world-famous art exhibits and performances. • • Mississippi hosts the USA International Ballet Competition, one of four international ballet competitions officially sanctioned by UNESCO, recognized as one of the world’s premier ballet competitions. The Mississippi Art Colony has passed its 60th birthday, the oldest artist-run colony in the country. • The Delta has become synonymous with the blues and draws visitors from around the world to experience “Ground Zero” for the typically Mississippian music forms. • The more than 35 year-old Craftsmen’s Guild of Mississippi helps preserve and advance local folk art, crafts, and new art forms. Can Mississippi assemble the pieces of its creative economy in such a way that the whole is far more than the sum of its parts? This report will demonstrate that it is possible to do just that. First, we estimate the scale and describe the scope of Mississippi’s creative economy in terms of conventional economic measures: employment/self-employment, companies, and occupations along the entire value chain. This will enable the state to assess and understand the creative elements of the economy alongside other industries and sectors. The report will also describe—based on interviews, web-based surveys, published materials, and web searches—the support system for the creative economy that cannot be measured purely by economic measures. This support system includes the associational infrastructure, performance venues, events and festivals, education and training programs, forms of technical and business assistance, and financial resources that enable creative enterprises to exist, thrive, and grow. Finally, the report will suggest strategies to further develop and spread the benefits of Mississippi’s creative economy. mCe The Attic Gallery, Vicksburg, MS B. The special challenges facing creative enterprises in a weak economy This study was begun in a very weak national economy, during a recession that has affected levels of charitable giving, government budgets, and consumer spending. Moreover, it was completed in the midst of another disaster affecting the Gulf Coast, the Deepwater Horizon oil spill, the largest oil spill on record. Thus, those elements of the creative economy that depend heavily on private giving and on government support to allow them to keep their programs affordable are in dire straits. At the same time, the much larger numbers of for-profit creative enterprises are facing more intense competition from abroad and tighter pocketbooks among Mississippi-based customers. Purchases of some specialty products, especially those connected to the housing market, are being postponed, affecting architectural and interior design sectors, and others are being outsourced to reduce prices. The market for high-end art has also suffered, although those making functional crafts and mid-range goods appear to be weathering the recession quite well. Still, the recession has caused some interruption to the gradual recovery from Hurricane Katrina, which destroyed so much of southern Mississippi’s important creative assets, and the tourism-dependent economy of the coast is once again threatened. The non-profit sector of the creative economy has been hit even harder. A National Arts Index fell four points in 2008, reflecting losses in charitable giving and declining attendance at larger cultural institutions.2 But the most innovative non-profits are finding answers, and the number of arts organizations are growing. 2 Liz Bartolomeo, First-Ever National Arts Index Measures Health and Vitality of Arts in the United States, Press Release, Americans for the Arts, January 20, 2010 4 mississippi’s creative economy In many ways, the creative economy offers solutions to communities and companies and new ways to compete and reposition the state as the economy regains its strength. The suggestions are not panaceas but steps that can be taken to revive and revitalize places and slowly generate and retain wealth. That is the goal of this report. 11. Mississippi’s Creative Economy Although the term “creative” can be, and is, applied to a wide range of intellectual activities, we use it in a way that directly, rather than indirectly, connects it to economic outcomes. Creativity can be used to describe certain types of companies, people, and places. We include all three: companies for their economic development value and potential; people to describe the workforce attributes and educational needs; and geography to describe clustering tendencies, the importance of milieu, and potential for economies of scale. Creative Enterprises The adjective “creative” is applied first and foremost to companies with products that obtain new or added value from a distinctive appearance, content, sound, or emotional response as well as all the enterprises necessary to take them from raw materials to markets. These include businesses, entrepreneurs, and organizations involved in every stage of production, from conception to initial presentation, and in every link in the value chain, from suppliers and equipment manufacturers to marketplaces. Similar to many other industries, creative enterprises tend to concentrate, or to “cluster,” more heavily in some places than others. This happens because of some special location advantages, historical antecedents, or sometimes purely by chance. The aggregated employment in these enterprises within geographic boundaries equals the scale of the cluster and represents its economic power in the state. mCe employ people who do creative work, such as window designers at retail chains, landscape architects at resorts, advertising writers or web designers for large corporations, or musicians in churches. Creative and design thinking is also becoming more important even in occupations not officially defined as “creative,” whether its planning a manufacturing process, starting a new business or managing a hospital. The need for creativity is especially important in designing and delivering education and workforce development programs. We look briefly at the occupational data while focusing primarily on the companies that represent the economy and recognizing the importance of the arts and culture to learning outcomes. Creative Places Finally, we recognize the importance of place. Creativity depends on the stimulation, inspiration, and exchange of ideas that occur where creative people congregate, socialize, develop relationships, and form networks. The community that supports and encourages creativity embodied in such places, that has cultural assets that attract tourists, and that hosts creative events might be called a creative place. Most such places also find ways to distinguish themselves and provide certain unique experiences that set them apart from other places. Mississippi has many such creative places, some recognized and known, some quirky and exotic but hidden away, waiting to be discovered—or, in some places, dreading discovery that could change them forever. This report does not attempt to quantify creative places as it does creative enterprises and occupations but it does describe the assets that make a place creative and gives examples of some of Mississippi’s truly creative communities. Creative Workers Second, we apply the adjective “creative” to occupations with job requirements that require or benefit from imagination and/ or artistic expression. These occupations exist both within and outside of creative enterprises. For example, enterprises that do not fit the definition of a “creative enterprise” quite often Powerhouse Community Arts Center, Oxford, MS 5 mississippi’s creative economy mCe A. Counting, Aggregating and Comparing B. Creative Enterprises in Mississippi Mississippi’s creative economy, as defined by the combination of both employees of creative companies and employees of other companies who work in creative occupations, includes 60,704 jobs. Mississippi’s creative enterprises are responsible for the employment of 40,284 people in just under 3,000 establishments with almost one in three of these people – 9,580 – working in a creative occupation. An additional 20,420 individuals are employed in creative occupations in sectors of the economy that don’t fit the criteria established for “creative enterprises.” Mississippi’s creative economy of nearly 3,000 establish- The basis for these numbers begins, but does not end, with sectors identified by their North American Industrial Classification codes (NAICS 3) that most closely represent creative businesses (Appendix C). But the baseline definition misses many businesses that produce creative products and are not associated with an industry defined as creative. Examples are specialty foods, fashion apparel, culinary arts, or handcrafted furniture. To identify these firms and supplement the baseline sector data, we relied on the knowledge of experts in industry organizations, web searches, and state industry directories. 4 The industries and occupations used to measure the creative economy are those typically used in creative economy studies. Industry sector occupations that are included range from artists and musicians to commercial printers and caterers to mediarelated and advertising agency employees. The starting point for the definition began with the New England Foundation of the Arts (NEFA) definition, which was based on earlier Mt. Auburn work. It was subsequently adjusted to reflect the particular nature of Mississippi’s creative economy and supplemented with information about creative enterprises in other sectors based on information from business directories, associations, and interviews. The refined definition provides a more accurate, more conservative view than the very broad NEFA definition, and more comprehensive estimate of the number of businesses and people they employ than do the pure industry code-driven numbers. Figure 1. Mississippi’s Creative Economy Creative Enterprises Creative Workforce Other Workers in Creative Enterprises Creative Workers in Creative Enterprises 30,704 9,580 Creative Workers in Other Enterprises 20,420 ments in over 70 different industry sectors (Appendix C) employed roughly 40,200 people, or approximately three percent of the state’s total employment of 1.5 million in 2008. The percentage of workers in the creative economy is more than those employed in Mississippi’s advanced materials cluster, computer and electronic product manufacturing cluster and only slightly less than those employed in the transportation and logistics cluster (3.6 percent). Employment data, however, provide only a partial picture of the Magnolia State’s creative economy. Many other individuals are self-employed as sole owners of businesses, freelancers, and consultants. These self-employed artisans and freelancers make up a much larger proportion of the creative economy than in other clusters, and excluding them would greatly understate the size and importance of the creative economy. An estimated 5,250 self-employed individuals, or 17.5 percent of those in creative organizations, fell into this category in 2007, according 3 The Office of Management and Budget assigns NAICS codes to businesses that use identical or similar processes of production. Chair Caning Campbells Bakery, Jackson, MS Street Musician Port Gibson, MS 4 Determining which businesses produce creative products is by necessity a matter of judgment rather than science, but it provides a more accurate estimate of the true scale of the cluster. 6 mCe mississippi’s creative economy to the non-employer database published by the U.S. Census Bureau. While the data presented in this report includes estimates of self-employed creative workers, it does not capture the many other individuals with secondary jobs in creative establishments. Thus, the numbers presented still somewhat understates the scale of creative economic activity in the state. To better understand the strengths, weaknesses, and needs of Mississippi’s creative economy, the 77 industry sectors have been grouped into the following five subsets, or sub clusters: Design; Film and Media; Literary and Publishing; Heritage; Culinary Arts; Performing and Visual Arts. The distribution of employment among the creative economy sub-clusters in Mississippi is quite similar to that of the nation (Figure 2), although Mississippi has a somewhat larger share of employment in its performing and visual arts sub cluster and slightly lesser share in the design sub cluster. Based on the use of available standardized NAICS-based data alone, the density of Mississippi’s creative economy was Figure 2: Distribution of Employment by Type of Creative Enterprise Mississippi Performing and Visual Arts 20% Design 26% Culinary Arts 8% Film and Media 17% Literary & Publishing 27% United States Performing and Visual Arts 13% Design 31% Heritage - 2% Literary & Publishing 27% Table 1: Comparison of Relative Employment in Creative Economy Sub Clusters Between Selected States and Mississippi Sub Cluster MS AL Literary & publishing 1.0 0.69 1.09 0.84 0.71 1.50 1.24 Design 1.0 0.67 0.57 0.51 0.37 1.48 1.64 Film & media 1.0 0.60 0.67 0.82 0.65 1.26 1.54 Heritage 1.0 0.47 0.60 0.86 0.29 2.02 1.06 Culinary 1.0 0.57 0.65 0.50 0.47 1.55 0.91 Performing & visual arts 1.0 0.64 0.60 0.87 0.53 0.82 0.80 Total 0.76 0.87 0.88 0.65 1.07 1.02 1.0 KY SD WV OH GA Source: EMSI, 2008. Heritage 2% Culinary Arts - 7% compared to that of creative economies in four other predominantly rural states, Alabama, Kentucky, South Dakota, and West Virginia, and to two more urban states, Georgia and Ohio. The numbers represent a comparison of the proportion of workforce employed in each category, normalized to Mississippi as the standard. Thus, for example, 0.67 for design in Alabama (Table 1) means that the relative number of people employed in the design sub cluster in Alabama is only 67 percent of the relative number of people employed in that sub cluster in Mississippi, while 1.48 in Georgia means that the proportion of the total work force employed in Georgia’s design sub cluster is 48 percent higher than Mississippi’s. Film and Media 20% Source: Economic Modeling Specialists, Inc., 2008. Note: Numbers present indices of states’ proportions of relative employment compared to proportions in Mississippi. Indices lower than 1.0 indicate a lower proportion of the state’s total employment compared to Mississippi, and indices greater than 1.0 indicate a higher proportion of the state’s total employment in the sub cluster. In Mississippi the relative concentration of people employed in all creative enterprises was 32 percent higher than Alabama, 15 percent higher than Kentucky, 14 percent higher than South Dakota, and 54 percent higher than in West Virginia (Figure 3). It was slightly lower in Mississippi than in Georgia and Ohio, though Mississippi had a much higher concentration in the performing and visual arts sub cluster. The two more urban states had much greater concentrations of people employed in design and in literary and publishing. 7 mississippi’s creative economy Figure 3: Comparison of Employment in Mississippi’s Creative Economy in Selected States Mississipppi 100 Alabama 76 Kentucky 87 South Dakota 88 65 West Virginia Ohio 107 Georgia 102 0 27.5 55 82.5 110 Source: EMSI 2008. C. Creative Occupations Mississippi has nearly 30,000 people employed in occupations that require or significantly benefit from a high level of originality and imagination (Appendix C). In 2008, those employed in creative occupations had average hourly wages of $14.63. The highest average wages for creative jobs in the state were in the more heavily populated Capital/River and Coastal regions, both of which paid above $15.00 per hour (Figure 4). Figure 4: Regional Distribution of Creative Occupations Hills 19% Pines 13% mCe The largest single category among creative occupations is photographers, with 4,000, followed by public relations specialists, with 2,000. Some regions, however, are stronger than others in certain creative occupations. For instance, the concentration of public relations specialist jobs in the Capital/River area is 40 percent higher than in the rest of the nation, which may be related to the presence of governmental agencies and their need to disseminate information to constituents. The Delta has a higher concentration of librarians, the Pines region a higher than average concentration of radio and television announcers, and the Coastal region a strong concentration of landscape architects. Creative occupations are not just found in the better-known creative sectors like dance theaters, art galleries, and advertising agencies. Local governments in Mississippi employ nearly 9 percent of all creative talent, and religious organizations employ roughly 5.7 percent. Photographers comprise more than 10 percent of the total creative occupations with about 72 percent of them in the “all other professional and technical services” sector, which includes such businesses as meteorological services and specialty surveying companies. The types of firms that employ creative people vary across regions. For example, 17 percent of those in creative occupations work in local governments within the Delta region. Casinos in the Delta are responsible for another 8 percent of this type of employment in creative occupations. Libraries represent another large source of creative employment. Mississippi has twice the librarians per capita than the national average, perhaps reflecting the state’s literary traditions. Over 81 percent of librarians in the Delta can be found in public libraries run by Mississippi regional governments. Delta 8% Coastal 25% NEED CHART Capital River 35% Source: Economic Modeling Specialists, 2008, with regions defined by Mississippi Development Authority’s Tourism Division. Photographer, Ken Murphy, displays his new book 8 mCe mississippi’s creative economy D. Trends and Patterns In the past six years, Mississippi has been hit by Katrina, one of the worst natural disasters of recent history, only to then be plunged along with the rest of the nation into a major recession. While the report focuses on the size and scope of the creative economy, this section takes a cursory look at how creative industries have fared from 2003 to 2008. Over the five-year time span, the creative industries experienced more robust growth during boom times (Figure 5) but also were more severely affected by economic contractions.5 Nevertheless, the creative cluster in Mississippi showed solid growth in employment over the five year period. From 2002 to 2008, creative cluster employment grew by four percent in the state compared to six percent growth across all industries. Employment growth in the creative enterprise cluster, however, has surpassed growth in other important value-added clusters that had been defined by industrial classifications for the Mississippi Development Authority. These include the advanced materials cluster, agribusiness cluster and food processing cluster. Figure 5: Growth of Employment in Creative Industries to All Industries, 2003 to 2008. Figure 6: Employment Growth in Clusters, 2002 - 2008 15% 13% 4% Transportation Education & and Logistics Knowledge Creation -9% Creative Economy -10% Computers & Electronic Product Mfg. -12% Advanced Materials Agribus., Food Processing & Tech Source: EMSI Complete Employment - 2nd Quarter 2009 v2 Overall, job growth in Mississippi’s creative enterprises exceeded job growth in the rest of the nation (Figure 7), except in 2005 when Hurricane Katrina hit. The region of the state most strongly affected by the events of 2005 was, of course, the Gulf Coast, which lost 6.2 percent of its creative cluster employment between 2005 and 2006 (see Appendix B). 4.0% Figure 7: Changes in Employment in Creative Economy, 2003 to 2008 in Mississippi and U.S. 3.0% 2.0%1.0% 0.0% -1.0% 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 -2.0% 2008 4.0% 2.0% -3.0% Creative All Industries Source: EMSI Complete Employment - 2nd Quarter 2009 v2. 0.0% 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 -2.0% -4.0% Mississippi United States Source: EMSI Complete Employment - 2nd Quarter 2009 v2. George Berry, Wood Carver 5 Data in this section is based on the baseline definition of creative industries using the NAICS codes in Appendix C. 9 mCe mississippi’s creative economy E. Convergence of clusters in Mississippi While representing a significant proportion of the state’s economy, Mississippi’s creative economy has far greater impact than what the data alone reveal. The creative economy operates as a “keystone species,” a biologists’ term for something with an impact on its environment that is greatly disproportionate to its scale. The cluster formed by the state’s creative enterprises both overlaps and influences a large number of clusters (Figure 8). • • Figure 8: Convergence of Clusters Architecture Architectural Elements Landscaping Aromas Spiritual Art Healing Art Lifestyle Wellness Spiritualism Construction Culinary Arts Weaving Farm Art Agriculture and Food Creative Economy • living on the state’s many small and non-commercial farms (23,246 firms grossed between $1,000 and $25,000 in 2007). Mississippi’s agriculture also provides a source of inspiration for art. Cable companies, web designers, and graphic artists may also be members of Mississippi’s communications and information technology cluster association, CIT.MS. The tourism cluster is the most obvious area of convergence, with many of the sites that attract visitors to places included as part of the creative economy. The Mississippi Legislature recently enacted HB 1701 recognizing the economic development benefits of tourism and linking it to heritage, history, and culture. Creative goods are a large part of the retail sector, with most of Best Buy’s goods and approximately 10 percent of Wal-Mart’s sales attributed to creative goods—books, music, video and sound systems, even musical instruments. Consumer Products High Tech Web Design Animation Tourism Cultural Tourism Art Souvenirs Fashions Design Products Advertising Some of the overlap is captured by its definition, which includes firms that are also part of other clusters. Certain enterprises operate as creative enterprises within furniture, consumer electronics, information technology and food processing. But some of the overlap is more subtle and affects companies that fall outside of the boundaries established for the creative economy. • • • Music, stained glass, and sculptures are part of the attraction of many religious establishments and creative aromas and salves are a part of other forms of spirituality. Building and landscape architects and interior designers are integral parts of any construction and housing cluster. Many of the eating establishments designated as part of the culinary arts cluster purchase local foods from the food systems cluster and are part of its value chain. The culinary arts may also provide a second source of income for the families Governor’s Awards for Excellence in the Arts Award Winner Bill Dunlap, Artist 10 mississippi’s creative economy III. Segmenting the Creative Economy Although the creative enterprise cluster essentially incorporates the same general industries in all communities, it does differ from one local economy to another based on the specific conditions, economic relationships, and historic culture of different places. To better understand the state’s creative economy, this report separates the creative enterprise clusters into smaller sub clusters composed of companies that have more characteristics and interests in common and thus stronger interdependencies. This helps to clarify the workings of the creative economy and frame recommendations. mCe Design sub cluster is defined in part by companies that apply creative content to the built environment, architecture, landscaping, and interior design. The sub cluster also includes those firms that apply design to consumer products or to influence consumption patterns, such as fashion and furniture design, graphic design, web design, advertising, and design-intensive manufacturers. Eyevox, producing high-end video commercials and corporate films, Aimee’s Linens, Miss Lou Roasters, Sippi Girlz Collection shirts, the Woodworking Collective in Jackson, and Viking Range are companies that manufacture products that engage customers. Film, Video, and Media sub cluster includes the pro- Based on interviews, analyses of economic data, examinations of published materials, and web searches, the creative activities in the state have been grouped into the following six sub clusters, each with its own particular value chain. The sub cluster groupings are not mutually exclusive because some sectors can be part of more than one sub cluster. Potters, for example, design products but are also artists. Bookstores may sell music as well as books, and museum stores often sell local art and crafts at their gift shops. Therefore, the sum of employment in the sub clusters may not add to that of the full creative enterprise cluster. The six sub clusters with examples of their members are as follows. duction and marketing of motion pictures, music, radio, cable, television programming, internet publishing, and multimedia firms. This includes sound and film studios, theaters, distributors, and agents. Visual and Performing Arts sub cluster represents the Culinary Arts sub cluster, which is not defined by industry heart of the creative economy, the most intentional originators of creativity. This sub cluster includes the painters, photographers, sculptors, potters, glassblowers, metal artists, jewelers, and other artisans who use their imagination to produce works of art. The value chain associated with this sub cluster includes the galleries and other venues that support, display, and sell the products such as Crossroads Pottery and the Delta Arts Alliance. The sub cluster also includes theater, music, dance, and spoken word and the performers, promoters, producers, directors, and technicians needed to bring the performing arts to the public, among them the Coast Community Concert Association, Mississippi Opera, TALK Dance Company, and Walter Anderson Players. classification alone, is that subset of the food preparation industry in which aesthetics and creative content are what attracts customers and generates higher prices. The sub cluster includes food establishments that employ trained chefs, gourmet food shops and caterers, and restaurants such as Southfork Fish House in Magee, and State Theater in Starkville. Literary and Publishing is the sub cluster for which Mississippi is perhaps best known. It includes the state’s many fiction and non-fiction authors, poets, and writers of content for the news media or web pages. It also includes book, magazine, and journal publishers, bookstores, distributors, reviewers, and critics. The Clarion-Ledger in Jackson, the Vicksburg Post, Mississippi Public Broadcasting, and University of Mississippi Press are all part of this sub cluster. Viking Cooking School, Greenwood, MS 11 mississippi’s creative economy Museums and Heritage is defined as a sub cluster of museums, libraries, and historical assets, including those that are part of federal, state, and local government agencies or educational institutions. Examples are the Antique Museum, the Delta Blues Museum, William Faulkner’s home, and the Causeyville General Store. The criteria for inclusion among Mississippi’s “creative enterprises,” again, is that the company’s products or services acquire their competitive advantage, or receive substantial value, from a distinctive appearance, form, content, or sound. These diverse businesses are connected by their “creative content,” a somewhat abstract term. The deeper analysis of the more tightly interdependent sub clusters, however, forms the basis for much of the study’s findings and recommendations. What follows is a look at each of the sub clusters and a summary of its properties, value chains, strengths, and weaknesses. mCe INDUSTRIES INCLUDED IN PERFORMING AND VISUAL ARTS 339911 339914 339992 423940 448310 451140 453920 541921 611610 711110 711120 711130 711190 711310 711320 711510 Jewelry, except costume, manufacturing Costume jewelry, novelty manufacturing Musical instrument manufacturing Jewelry merchant wholesalers Jewelry stores Musical instrument and supplies stores Art dealers Photography studios, portrait Fine arts schools Theater companies and dinner theaters Dance companies Musical groups and artists Other performing arts companies Promoters with facilities Promoters without facilities Independent artists, writers, performers* *Distributed throughout. In 2008, this sub cluster included more than 6,400 people emMississippi Musician Plays his Banjo A. Visual and Performing Arts The purest segment of the creative economy is made up of those people who earn their living from their artistic talents and who turn ideas and visions into experiences through art, craft, and/or performance. Although the scale of this artistic talent is not as great in rural regions as it is in urban art centers, it is just as important in less populated places, and in some cases, far more important in such places. Mississippi’s visual and performing arts sub cluster is distributed across the state with higher concentrations in certain communities that attract tourists or that are home to universities. Oktibbeha, Hinds, Leflore, Forrest, and George Counties, for example, had much higher concentrations of artists and performers based on the last census. ployed in nearly 470 establishments. Based on the occupational data, however, about 1,800 Mississippians classify themselves as pure “artists” producing original work. The average annual earnings for the sub cluster is almost $19,000, but with very large income extremes. Individuals employed in theater and dance companies and fine arts schools can expect annual earnings around $7,000, while workers employed at musical instrument manufacturing earn on average about $40,000. This sub cluster also includes a large number of self-employed people and others who work at their art on a part-time basis, supplementing income from other occupations or with transfer payments. It’s especially difficult to earn a full-time living in music or theater in a sparsely populated region, where many of the artists are employed—particularly as teachers and in churches. The average annual earnings for the entire sector is almost $19,000. 12 mCe mississippi’s creative economy The upstream side of the value chain for the visual and performing arts is of less economic significance than the downstream side. Although artists need supplies, equipment, tickets, advertising, costumes, packing materials, capital, and other material and service inputs, their greater need is for performance and to expand their markets. This end of the value chain includes the galleries, shops, art museums, and websites that display and sell art and crafts, the performance venues and technical support necessary to support the performance, agents, and transportation. What is the economic profile of the artists who responded to the survey? The responses suggest that most are not able to earn a full-time living from their art but what they do earn is not captured by any enterprise-based economic analyses. In addition to the transaction-based value chain there is a knowledge-based value chain that transmits ideas, knowledge and inspiration. It includes the formal and informal social infrastructure—the guilds, associations, councils, and web-based groups— and the educational institutions, support services, and grant making organizations. The Craftsmen’s Guild of Mississippi, South Mississippi Art Association, The Arts, Hancock County, and Mississippi Watercolor Society are among the largest membership-based associations. But there also are more than forty theater groups and a large number of smaller formal and informal quilters’ groups. The non-profit sector is vital to this sub cluster, and therefore often studied as an economic engine in its own right. • To learn more about those who earn all or some significant proportion of their living in this sub cluster, we conducted a webbased survey of artists across the state. The following information is based on responses from 200 artists, of whom some 65 percent are over 50 years of age, 62 percent are female, 96 percent have at least some college education, and 54 percent earn over $50,000 per year. Three out of five are originally from Mississippi, and the rest transplants that came most often for employment opportunities—for self or spouse—and/or for quality of life. The survey was distributed with the assistance of the state’s various arts organizations, which may have been why older artists were overrepresented and younger talented people, who may rely more heavily on social and web networks than membership organizations, may not have been captured to the same extent. By far the largest percentage of responses came from those in the visual arts and crafts. With those limitations, the survey was still very useful in understanding how artists earn their livings and what they need to improve their economic situations. • • • • • • 44 percent earn all their income from their art, 46 percent earn some while holding down another job, and the rest pursue art mainly as a hobby. Of those earning other income, 18 percent work for government, one in four teach, 19 percent have retirement income. Only 9 percent operate incorporated businesses, 31 percent operate unincorporated businesses, and 25 percent call themselves freelancers. Only 16 percent have Dun and Bradstreet numbers, which leaves 84 percent of them out of many, if not most, economic analyses. 37 percent devote at least 30 hours a week to their art, while 15 percent spend less than 10 hours a week at it. One in three describes the income earned from his or her art as essential, 41 percent as supplementary, and 20 percent as a hobby. Only 28 work at studios outside their home, and, of those, only one in seven share space. Just how much do the artists earn from their craft? The range is dramatic, from those able to earn their primary income to the larger population of artists who are supplementing other household income. The responses must be tempered by the common knowledge that some income from the arts is unreported, some is bartered, and some is donated. One in five artists admitted to some unreported income while half sometimes bartered art for goods or services and most donated art, despite very minimal tax benefits. But based on reported income, we learned the following: • • • About 45 percent earn less than $5,000 per year, 32 percent between $5,000 and $10,000 and just 8 percent make more than $30,000. For just over half, this is less than 10 percent of their household income, for 20 percent it is up to a quarter, and for 11 percent it’s more than three quarters. The recent recession had a relatively small negative impact, with 37 percent seeing their incomes go down and 26 percent seeing them go up. 13 mCe mississippi’s creative economy How and where do artists sell their work? One successful wood artist estimated that he has booths at about 16 shows a year and most are out of the state. His number of sales has dropped, but that loss has been offset by increased sales of more expensive pieces. Travel to fairs provides much of his income, yet he would prefer to stay nearer to home if there were more shows. • • • Some 36 percent reported no income from festivals, 37 percent estimated up to 20 percent of their income, and only 19 percent earned more than 40 percent of their income that way. 58 percent have a web presence, but only 29 percent of those with web sites earned more than 10 percent of their income on line. Nine percent use Etsy. Artists are using social media; 53 percent use social networking sites such as Facebook or MySpace. What do artists believe they need to be more successful? Skills, markets, and money stand out as their own highest resource needs, but artists also said that more support for art venues, advocacy, and networking would be most helpful. • The very highest needs for resources expressed were for opportunities to be with other artists, funding (grants), and marketing assistance—in that order. Exhibit space and skill improvement were next. • Health insurance surprisingly ranked lowest, perhaps because so many artists have it under another family member or are covered under Medicare. • When asked what is most important to the state’s creative economy, the most common response was having more venues for displaying and selling art. Arts advocacy was next, networking opportunities was third, and access to information about funding sources was ranked fourth. • Finally, when asked about their needs for education or assistance, selling outside the state was number one, accessing funding sources was number two, selling their art was three, and more contact with other artists was listed fourth. The arts community described a deep reservoir of strengths in the state’s art and culture. Various respondents mentioned Mississippi’s richness in diversity, willingness to work together, a historic foundation for art, its inherent talents and eccentricities, sheer energy, societal support and recognition, originality, and resourcefulness. Numerous artists mentioned the Craftsmen’s Guild and Mississippi Arts Commission. The artists surveyed are proud of the creativity of Mississippi. Descriptions of their strengths included the following statements. • “Having traveled, and lived in Florida and California, Mississippi is without a doubt the most supportive and actively seeks to support artists…” • “It provides a creative outlet for rural Mississippians.” • “A wealth of knowledge despite the feelings and misgivings of the rest of the nation.” • “The history of our people in the field of literature and music.” • “[It’s} so deeply rooted—from music to visual to fiction. We have more than any other state.” • “A general appreciation of the arts and great leadership at the state level.” The needs that artists expressed were very consistent, whether it was resources, education, or assistance: marketing, funding, and networking were always on top. The state’s artists would like to be economically self-sufficient. They value networking for learning, inspiration, and support, but they also need capital, either as grants, loans, or investments. Mississippi Crafts Center, Ridgeland, MS 14 mCe mississippi’s creative economy B. Design Design is an applied art form, applied to products, print and web-based communications, buildings, and landscapes. The most obvious applications are seen in architecture, gardens, advertising, interior design, and fashion-oriented products. Because the creative design elements of this sub cluster are not always self-evident, it is often overlooked as part of the creative economy. The aesthetics embodied in these enterprises are too often taken for granted or attributed to some other factor, and the firm considered part of some other cluster, such as construction, agribusiness, communications and information technology, or furniture. The following companies, however, rely heavily on creativity. • • • • Canizaro Cawthon Davis worked with the Ramey Agency on the design of its office in Fondren, which will be featured as one of 45 world class designs of work space in an upcoming book titled ”Where We Work: Creative Office Spaces.” The company’s aim is to “bring our creativity, our ability to listen, and our focus on appropriate results to each project,” partner with clients, and produce designs that achieve shared goals. Viking Range created a product line of kitchen equipment not intended for the average development home but a high-end product with a brand that appeals to discerning foodies. It now is adjusting to new economic realities by introducing lower-priced but still commercial-quality, highdesign appliances, in a line called the Designer Series. Five independent and entrepreneurial furniture makers in Jackson share space, rent, tools, and utilities as a “woodworking collective.” They get their orders through their contacts with architects and decorators and depend solely on word of mouth. They sometimes partner with metal or glass artists for mixed media pieces. The recession has had no perceptible impact on their business and they are busy as ever filling orders. Mad Genius, a 30-employee Mississippi advertising company, is known for its creative genius. Using “creative fusion,” it combines all aspects of a product from conception through post production, and promotion. In mid-2009, Mad Genius merged with a creative film and video production company, Eyevox, crossing over into another sub cluster, which greatly expanded their capabilities. Clients range from Southern Farm Bureau Insurance in eight states to an arts and education initiative, Imagination Education, Inc., which develops educational resources for Mississippi’s public schools. Its CEO, Rick Moore, was named Mississippi’s Small Businessperson of the Year by the U.S. Small Business Administration. • NunoErin in Jackson has turned sitting and touching into an interactive experience by making furniture and wall panels with thermosensitive properties that leave colored imprints of the body and by using designs that imitate nature. Its Swamp Collections, for example, uses shapes found in Mississippi’s Bald Cypress Swamp. It’s founders, Nuno Gonçalves Ferreira and Erin Hayne, are the creative soul of the company. Some of Mississippi’s creative and culturally authentic manufacturers—especially those producing low- to medium-volume fashion apparel and accessories, kitchen or desk supplies, or specialty foods—take advantage of the state-sponsored Mississippi Market wholesale show. Others may think of themselves as traditional manufacturers but, when surveyed, it was clear that they acknowledge and increasingly depend on creative content in their brand and for their sales, and they expect to increasingly do so in the future. This sub cluster has the second largest employment among the six sub clusters in the state’s creative economy. Design-related businesses in Mississippi employ over 8,000 people in more than 700 establishments in 17 sectors. But Mississippi has only a half of the relative concentration of employment in this sub cluster as that of the national concentration, in large part because some of its largest sectors, fashion design, architecture, and advertising, are so heavily concentrated in large metropolitan areas. This does not detract from the subcluster’s importance to the state, where there is particularly under-developed potential for small and mid-sized manufacturers. In Mississippi, workers in design-related industries earn an average annual amount of $44,000, twice as much as the average income of all creative enterprise employees in the state. The largest group within the design sub cluster is architectural services, with 15 percent of total sector employment in 2008. This group has an average income of $62,000. Average earnings are highest among workers in media representation-related businesses, which had average annual earnings above $81,000 last year. 15 mississippi’s creative economy While the manufacturing companies in this sub cluster have conventional value chains with suppliers, subcontractors, and distributors, the value chain associated with the creative aspects is much more complex. It is made up of 17 different industries and is the second largest employer in the state’s creative economy, with over 8,000 working in more than 700 companies. Design companies, for example, are part of the upstream segment of the value chain of a manufacturer, and advertising and branding are part of the downstream end. Architects, landscape architects, and interior designers are part of the homebuilding and real estate sectors. To further test the hypothesis that the aesthetics of design is increasing in importance to the state’s manufacturing companies, an online survey was sent to members of the Mississippi Manufacturers Association. Sixty-one responses, of which 59 percent stated that they sold directly to users or were visible by users, yielded the following information. • • • • 46 percent replied that aesthetic design is of “significant” importance, and 63 percent replied it is “of some or significant importance.” Only one in nine said it was not important. Among manufacturers with products that reach end users, those numbers were 72 percent, with zero saying it had no significance. Two in five stated that they use design to “convey meaning or authenticity,” but more than 63 percent of companies with consumer products stated this. 58 percent responded that design differentiated their products from those of their competitors, and 53 percent said it enhanced recognition and meaning. 59 percent claimed design increased sales, 56 percent said it increased market share, and 36 percent said that it increased profit margin. mCe Figure 7: Ways that Mississippi Manufacturers Use Design Product Design for aesthetics or to convey meaning or authenticity 40% Corporate Communications, Branding Marketing and/or website 30% 21% Packaging Workplace Interior 9% Other (please specify) 32% 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40% 45% Note: Most of the “other” responses are the use of design mostly for functionality or manufacturability Source: Survey data from 62 manufacturers, 2010 The companies were also asked who was responsible for their design. • • • • Design is an add-on to other job functions for 39 percent of respondents. 29 percent of all manufacturers and 39 percent of those with consumer products have dedicated design divisions. 26 percent contract out to design firms and 16 percent to freelance designers. Of those that contract out for design, half go out of state, and only 3 companies work with or hire from Mississippi colleges or universities. Viking Range Corporation, Greenwood, MS 16 mississippi’s creative economy How do companies value creativity in the work force and how much do they invest in design? Design in the past was valued for its effects on manufacturability, cost, and functionality, not emotional impact. The survey suggests priorities have changed. • About 70 percent of respondents said creativity was important or very important (23 percent) in hiring new employees. • Investments in design did not change much in past year, which is probably a positive result given the state of the recent economy. About 26 percent increased investments and 23 percent reduced investments, with the rest staying about the same. • More telling, almost 49 percent expect to spend more on design over the next three years while only 9 percent expect to spend less. Overall, product and environmental design both appear to represent an underutilized capacity for additional growth. The internationally recognized motion furniture cluster in northeast Mississippi, for example, has been able to compete successfully for sixty years on the basis of cost and comfort. About ten years ago, an Appalachian Regional Commission study predicted a declining market without the investment of more in design and innovation. Competitors are not eating into the market for standard goods. Similarly, the large number of historic buildings and neighborhoods in need of renovation create a demand for architecture, landscaping, interior design, and architectural preservation that could be better supported within the state’s borders. The associational elements of this sub cluster are either professional organizations that are generally national, such as the state chapter of the American Institute of Architects in Jackson or American Society of Interior Designers, or associations that include more than just creative enterprises, such as the Mississippi Manufacturers Association. Many of the state’s architects learned their trade in the strong five-year program at Mississippi State, which results in professional accreditation. A small number of colleges offer programs in the field: architecture and landscape architecture at Mississippi State University, and interior design at Mississippi University for Women, University of Southern Mississippi, Delta State University, and Mississippi College. The community colleges offer only a one-year prearchitecture program and a scattering of interior design courses. mCe The Manufacturing powerhouse , PEAVEY ELECTRONICS of Meridian is an example of how design can be used to advance a product. Peavey has more than 180 patents for the design of musical instruments, audio systems and enabling technologies that give these systems such a unique sound. For example, while most Dobros are acoustic, Peavey’s founder, Hartley Peavey, realized that the Dobro, like the guitar, could be an electronic instrument. He started designing an electric Dobro on his own, sketching out design concepts and principles and figuring out how to configure the straps to be worn over his neck the way Dobros are played. The process then was turned over to his designers and engineers who added design and structural improvements. The result was yet another product line in the long list of Peavey musical products. See “Red Hots and Deep Blues: Stories from Mississippi’s Creative Economy.” C. Film, Video and Media This sub cluster comprises 19 sectors that span the distribution and production of motion pictures, music, radio, cable and television programming, and multimedia firms. The sub cluster is quite evenly distributed across the state. In 2008, it employed approximately 5,600 people in its more than 260 establishments with average annual earnings of just over $35,000. Thirty percent of the employment in the sub cluster is directly attributable to cable and other program distribution. Annual earnings in businesses associated with cable programming and subscription programming tend to be the highest, an estimated $59,000. Cable and other subscription programming establishments are primarily responsible for financing and production of original master recordings, with most of their revenues coming from the sale and leasing of master recordings. 17 mCe mississippi’s creative economy The upstream end of the value chain traditionally began with paper products, ink and film, but as it digitalizes it is turning more to software programs, computers, and communications hardware. The upstream segment also includes the creative content for the media, much of which comes from members of other sub clusters—literary arts and visual and performing arts. The capital equipment inputs for media and communications, the technologies necessary to record, film, broadcast and reproduce, are among the largest equipment inputs in the creative economy. One of the state’s premier strengths is integrated record production and distribution, where Mississippi has twice the national proportion of jobs. Downstream, video and music stores, public relations firms, and agents represent the distribu- similar investments in the Piedmont Triad region. Moreover, the competition for location is international and a still-weak dollar is helping to keep production in the U.S., a condition that could change. tional and market end of part of the sub cluster. various types of technical and creative support. For example, the guide lists 5 animation companies, 9 casting companies, 9 costume/wardrobe companies, 10 catering services, and 14 post-production editors, 39 freelance production assistants, and 7 production coordinators. Between 1903 and 2010, 269 feature, documentary, or television films were made in Mississippi, 115 of those since 2000. The industry is growing, with 37 films made in 2008 alone. Mississippi is promoting itself as a film location in an extremely competitive national environment by strengthening its incentive programs and its support infrastructure. Neighboring Louisiana is already one of the most successful filming locations, and Michigan is spending lavishly to attract film and video to compensate for some of its lost automotive jobs. North Carolina invested in studios in Wilmington and now is considering Mississippi’s incentive program includes 20 percent rebates for local expenditures, 25 percent rebates for payroll for resident cast and crew, and 20 percent rebates for payroll for nonresidents whose wages are subject to state withholding. The Mississippi Film Commission has a location and production guide that describes the special assets, availability of transportation and education in each region and lists the companies and freelancers available throughout the state able to provide INDUSTRIES INCLUDED IN FILM, VIDEO & MEDIA 512110 512120 512131 512132 512191 512199 512210 512220 512230 512240 Motion picture and video production Motion picture and video distribution Motion picture theaters, except drive-ins Drive-in motion picture theaters Teleproduction and postproduction services Other motion picture and video industries Record production Integrated record production and distribution Music publishers Sound recording studios 512290 515111 515112 515120 515210 516110 517510 519110 711410 Other sound recording industries Radio networks Radio stations Television broadcasting Cable & other subscription programming Internet publishing and broadcasting Cable and other program distribution News syndicates Agents and managers for public figures 18 mCe mississippi’s creative economy filming and write and produce two short films. McDowell starts his class using 16-millimeter film so that students understand the feel of the camera and the essential skills before moving into high definition and digital methods. About half the students remain in the state and half leave, many for Los Angeles, where there is now a network of Mississippians to help newcomers locate and connect. The industry is organized, in part, through the Crossroads Film Society, a Mississippi organization for independent filmmakers that has regular events and film festivals, and, in part, through the Mississippi Film and Video Alliance in Jackson. A number of other local film festivals are shown in the following chart. MISSISSIPPI FILM FESTIVALS Through the efforts of the University of Southern Mississippi, the state is trying to retain more of its music recording industry. The Entertainment Industry program in the University’s School of Music is the fastest growing major. Three years ago the School formed South City Records as an umbrella company that now hosts five student-run record labels covering a wide range of genres, including hip hop, country, bluegrass, R&B, and of course the blues, all financed by students and faculty. Crossroads Film Festival, Jackson *** Oxford Film Festival *** Tupelo Film Festival *** Magnolia Independent Film Festival, Starkville *** Delta International Film and Video Festival, Cleveland *** See “Red Hots and Deep Blues: Stories from Mississippi’s Creative Economy.” Natchez Literary and Cinema Celebration D. One of the roadblocks to expanding this sub cluster is an insufficient ongoing source of talent in both film production and technical support. The state’s best—and only—institutional source for that talent is the University of Southern Mississippi’s four-year film and video degree program. The program, part of Mass Communications and Journalism, is about 30 years old and has had a steady enrollment of 50 to 60 students. About a quarter of the students are older career changers and about ten percent are African American. Many of the students in the program come through the community colleges, although only Pearl River Community College has a program in film and video, and it is not for credit. The film commission is attempting to establish short-term training programs in the state to develop a larger labor pool for any film companies that want to hire locally to reduce costs. Literary and Publishing Literary and publishing is the largest of the state’s creative sub clusters in terms of employment, with about 9,000 people working in 17 industry sectors, representing about 28 percent of the state’s full creative economy. Average annual earnings are just under $32,000. Mississippi is home to a treasure trove of writers that forms the core of this sub cluster and include some of the nation’s most widely read and beloved fiction writers. A review of one of John Grisham’s latest books by noted author Ron Powers stated that “Aside from the Upper West and Lower East Sides of Manhattan, the Mississippi Delta has probably generated more and better short fiction per acre than any other real estate in America.” 6 William Faulkner, Eudora Welty, Willie Morris, Tennessee Williams, Shelby Foote, Richard Wright, Larry Brown, Richard Ford, Walker Percy, and Ellen Gilchrist are only the beginning of a list that goes on and on. The University of Southern Mississippi program is fortunate to have an experienced and well-connected professor in Scott Dixon McDowell. Students learn about screen writing, editing, and 6 Ron Powers, “Southern Deviations,” New York Times Book Review November 29, 2009. 19 mississippi’s creative economy The vast majority of writers and poets—very likely more than 95 percent—do not have the sales volume to produce a living wage and require other full time jobs. Among the most popular is education but many take jobs in the private sector that allow them enough time for writing. Other writers in the private sector classify themselves as consultants rather than writers and therefore this sub cluster is very likely undercounted. Still other writers earn a full-time living employed by the news media or as writers for corporations who write or edit newsletters, press releases, and technical articles. With the growth of on-line media that use freelance bloggers and student interns, however, these employment opportunities are rapidly dwindling. INDUSTRIES INCLUDED IN LITERARY & PUBLISHING 323110 Commercial lithographic printing 323111 Commercial gravure printing 323112 Commercial flexographic printing 323113 Commercial screen printing 323115 Digital printing mCe A small number of niche book publishers do operate in the state, led by the University Press of Mississippi. But other successful publishers are Quail Ridge Press in Brandon, which specializes in cook books; Genesis Press in Columbus, which publishes romance novels; and Yoknapatawpha Press in Oxford, a small regional press, which publishes southern writers. Mississippi also has 15 specialized magazine or journal publishers, most of them attached to universities. But the state’s best known and most widely read magazine, Oxford American, recently moved to Arkansas. The Southern Foodways Alliance, headquartered at the University of Mississippi, finds and publishes the best of contemporary Southern food writing. A dozen independent bookstores undergird the sub cluster’s creativity. These include nationally recognized Square Books in Oxford and Lemuria in Jackson, which regularly feature readings, book signings, and festivals. Square Books’ role in promoting local authors has been well documented. The bookstore was one of only a few stores to carry the books of John Grisham, a graduate of Oxford’s University of Mississippi, at the start of his literary career; George Saunders and Charles Frazier, author of Cold Mountain, are two other authors who were championed by Square Books before they had achieved a national following. 323117 Books printing 323119 Other commercial printing 323121 Tradebinding & related work 323122 Prepress services 424920 Book & periodical merchant wholesalers 451211 Book stores 451212 News dealers & newsstands Along the supply chain, the state is strongest in its educational programs, festivals, and writers’ workshops. The materials that writers use, the writing materials and, increasingly, software programs, tend to come from national and international sources. Where the sub cluster falls short is in its depth downstream in the value chain, the publishers, printers, and software houses that convert content into commercial products. These are heavily concentrated in New York, London, Boston, and a few other large cities. Square Books, Oxford, MS 20 mCe mississippi’s creative economy The mass distribution networks, however, and most of the book reviewers, are with national media or organizations. With increasing sales through international sources such as Barnes and Noble, Amazon, and Borders, recognition from New York, Los Angeles and London critics and agents are necessary for economic success. The state also has a number of strong newspapers—55 in all— both large and small, daily and weekly. Newspaper publishers are responsible for about two-fifths of the employment in this sub cluster. Some are traditional newspapers but some are specialized business papers or free publications, generally covering entertainment and culture and supported by advertisements. The Delta Democrat in Greenville has been publishing since 1868 and took a stand against segregation during the civil rights movement. The Jackson-based Clarion-Ledger, which dates back to 1837, won a Pulitzer Prize in 1983 for its articles on education in Mississippi. The newspaper, which gave very little coverage to the civil rights movement and opposed desegregation through the 1960s, revised its position in the 1970s and in 2002 hired its first African American executive editor. Almost all of the papers have now moved on line, creating opportunities for bloggers and freelancers who are sometimes paid consultants. The state has unusual strength in its commercial gravure printing industry, which produces stationary, invitations, cards and labels and has four times the proportion of employment the national average. The sector also pays the highest average annual salaries of all the industries in the sub cluster, an estimated $51,600. E. Culinary Arts Mississippi is known for certain special foods, and although it may not have the culinary reputation of New Orleans, it has its own distinctive and authentic tastes. Some are typical Deep South foods, some, like catfish, are more closely associated with the state of Mississippi, and others, like tamales, have found a new home in Mississippi. The 2010 fifth edition of Cornbread Nation describes Sam the Tamale Man, selling tamales from a truck parked on the side of heavily traveled Highway 49. Food has both cultural and creative dimensions that are closely intertwined. • • • • The 2005 edition of 100 Best Art Towns in America highlighted the Bottletree Bakery in Oxford, as a “favorite local buzz shop” and an arts venue. It was featured by Southern Living and Oprah Winfrey as one of the best places for pastries. In February 2010, Hal and Mal’s restaurant and pub, now a community institution in Jackson, celebrated its 25th anniversary with 25 bands. It combines local foods, entertainment, and funky art. Robert St. John is a world famous chef in Hattiesburg who has authored six cookbooks (plus a work of fiction); sells his own branded hot sauces, seasonings, and drink mixes; offers cooking demonstrations; and operates the Crescent City Grill, Mahogany Bar, and Purple Parrot restaurants, which together make up the New South Restaurant Group. In Tunica, since 1937, long before the casinos came, oldfashioned southern cooking from catfish Creole to fried dill pickles at the Blue & White Restaurant on US 61 has attracted famous musicians—including Elvis Presley, once a regular—as well as tourists. This sub cluster is the most difficult to isolate because creative food-related businesses are included in sectors that also include large numbers of non-creative food enterprises—fast food restaurants, chains with fixed menus, and others with standard fares. Our criteria for being part of the creative economy is that the business, if an eating establishment, employ a trained chef, regularly change the menu, serve local fresh foods, and/or offer the customer a culinary experience. INDUSTRIES INCLUDED IN CULINARY ARTS 445291 Baked goods stores 445292 Confectionery and nut stores 445299 All other specialty food stores 722320 Caterers • Selected restaurants • Selected coffee shops 21 mCe mississippi’s creative economy Even after eliminating the obvious corporate chain establishments, the inclusion of a place of business ultimately is a judgment call and the number employed an estimate, for which we relied heavily on reputation and information from the state association. While still an estimate, we have tried to err on the conservative side. The director of the Mississippi Hospitality and Restaurant Association estimates that about 10 percent of his 2,500 members have professionally trained chefs and about 15 of those places are also venues for art or music. In addition, there are about 30 independent coffee shops with baristas, and some of those roast their own coffees, including the Southern Aroma Coffee Roasters, High Point Roasters, Mississippi Coffee Company, Miss Lou Roasters, and Coffee Roaster. The final definition used in this report includes catering companies, businesses involved in making and selling baked goods, confectionary stores, specialty food items and food processors, and those eating or drinking establishments that had special features associated with creativity. The sub cluster also is supported by a topnotch culinary arts school associated with Viking Range and by strong programs at Mississippi University for Women and Hinds Community College. Quail Ridge Press in Brandon publishes a special line of cookbooks, and the state has various food-oriented festivals: the World Catfish Festival in Belzoni, the Mize Watermelon Festival, the Creole Crawfish Festival at Horn Lake, the Sante South Wine Festival in Jackson, and the Sweet Potato Festival in Vardaman, to name just a few. As conservatively defined (including only a small identifiable subset of the state’s restaurants), the sub cluster is responsible for 8 percent of the employment in the state’s creative economy and almost 200 establishments. The average annual earnings in this sector is $23,000 but those who work in specialty food stores make an additional $10,000 per year more. TAMALES may not be a native taste but they have been Mississippified and modified and have become so ingrained in the culture that there now is a Delta Tamale Trail that complements Mississippi’s Blues Trail. The trail includes places such as Solly’s Hot Tamales in Vicksburg, Tony’s Tamales in Jackson, and Hot Tamale Heaven in Greenville—plus many others with unlikely names for gourmet tamales like Shipley’s Donuts in Vicksburg, Airport Grocery in Cleveland, Abe’s Bar BQ in Clarksdale, Onward General Store in Rolling Fork, and Crystal Grill in Greenwood. See “Red Hots and Deep Blues: Stories from Mississippi’s Creative Economy.” Viking Cooking School, Greenwood, MS F. Museums and Heritage Mississippi has an exceptionally strong and recognizable cultural heritage that serves to drive and inspire its creative economy. This sub cluster is composed of only three industry sectors, museums, historical sites, and zoos and botanical gardens, and these account for less than 700 jobs and 30 establishments. Many of the jobs are located in the Capital/River tourism region. Although the smallest of the six creative economy sub clusters, it is the most difficult to quantify and is inevitably undercounted because many of the jobs are within government and because there are so many part-time and volunteer employees. INDUSTRIES INCLUDED IN MUSEUMS AND HERITAGE 712110 Museums 712120 Historical sites 712130 Zoos and botanical gardens 22 mississippi’s creative economy The common use of volunteers and part time helpers very likely also contributes to low average earnings, in the neighborhood of only $21,000, for the sub cluster. This figure is brought down by annual earnings of only about $10,000 for employees at historic sites. Museums, zoos and botanical gardens workers typically average about $23,000. The state’s website lists 222 museums in the state, which offer many unique views of the state’s history, culture, and eccentricities. The museums include, for example, the Aaron Cotton Company Museum in Clarksdale where you can “learn about the history of cotton and the crops relationship to Blues music” and Yesterday’s Children Antique Doll and Toy Museum in Vicksburg with “over 1,000 antique and contemporary dolls from the mid 1800s to the present.” Sixteen Mississippi museums are described in the national travel book Little Museums 7 : • • • • The Prayer Museum in Greenwood is a collection of religious items from around the world—Tibetan, Buddhist, and other religious traditions—displayed in William Honey’s home. He also provides personal seminars on the world’s religions. mCe Natchez is a city-wide cultural site. Its many mansions display rich antebellum architecture that is preserved and renovated by the Historic Natchez Foundation. The historic Natchez Trace extends north from Natchez to Nashville, Tennessee. The scale of Natchez‘s historical and cultural assets is impressive for a city of less than 20,000 people with nearly 80 sites on the National Register of Historic Places. Because some districts include several hundred historic homes, the actual number of historic places is in the range of 1,300 and includes 13 National Historic Landmarks, the highest historic designation given by the federal government. These assets draw thousands of visitors a year, and The Ole Place Café: Home of the Hollywood Star Collection in Ruleville was founded by former Hollywood costume designer Luster Bayless, who bought a hometown department store to display costumes worn by well-known Hollywood stars. the Mississippi Development Authority’s Tour- The Casey Jones Museum in Vaughn displays artifacts and memorabilia based on the story of Casey Jones’ wreck of the Cannon Ball in Vaughn in 1900, later turned into a famous song written by an African American maintenance man. cent of the total employment for that county. Graceland Too is located in Holly Springs, Mississippi, where Paul MacLeod turned his pink, two-story home into a floor-to-ceiling shrine to Elvis Presley. The house, which is full of Elvis paraphernalia, is now repainted white and remains open to the public 24 hours a day. B.B. King Museum, Indianola, MS ism Division found that in Fiscal Year 2008, approximately 2,000 people were employed in tourism-related jobs in Adams County, 15 perSee “Red Hots and Deep Blues: Stories from Mississippi’s Creative Economy.” While this sub cluster may not be large in terms of employment, it plays a critical role in helping many communities retain their distinctiveness, and it influences much of the state’s music, literature, art, and tourism. In the first three months after the BB King Museum and Delta Interpretive Center opened in 2008 tourists arrived from all 50 states and more than 30 countries. Sunflower County, where the museum is located at Indianola, saw a 12.5 percent increase in its estimated travel and tourism expenditures in fiscal year 2009, the year the museum first opened, compared to the previous fiscal year. 7 Lynne Arany and Archie Hobson, Little Museums. New York: Henry Holt and Company, 1998. 23 mississippi’s creative economy Part of the state’s history, of course, is a source of regret and shame—the slavery and lack of civil rights for African Americans and Native Americans. But that history, along with its natural attractions also has shaped and sharpened its creativity, generating the blues, prolific folk art, oral histories, and sites of civil war and civil rights events that have become tourism attractions and have influenced the state’s most treasured literature. Much of the state’s heritage is retained in museums, carefully preserved historic buildings and sites, cemeteries, and parks. The Smithsonian’s Guide to Historic America 8 traces Mississippi’s attractions back to 1540, when de Soto crossed what now is northern Mississippi. Jefferson Davis’s home, The Martha Vick House in Vicksburg, the Delta Blues Museum, Music Hall of Fame, Seafood Industry Museum in Biloxi, Tupelo National Battlefield, Sports Hall of Fame Museum, Mississippi Museum of Art, Elvis Presley’s Birthplace, and Windsor Ruins are only a few of Mississippi’s other noted historical, cultural, and creative locations. IV. Support Infrastructure Because much of the value of creative economy is based on the manner in which its products are experienced and the success of the buzz that it produces, the creative economy depends heavily on support from a variety of physical, intellectual, technical, and social sources to deliver or provide services to the elements of that economy. The value of the support system is far greater than the number of people it employs or the income it produces. For example, formal and informal forums for associating, networking, and sharing ideas are part of how interest in creative enterprises forms and spreads. Public and private schools and personal instruction help develop the next generation of creative people and enterprises as well as consumers of creative products. Planned events—festivals, fairs, exhibits, and shows—operate as marketplaces for creative goods. Some creative and cultural goods are place-based, tied to specific locations. Finally, creative enterprises need resources, whether financial, technical, or business. The ultimate strength of the creative economy is tied in large part to the quality and quantity of the social and support infrastructure that support it. mCe Category Organizations Description Formal support networks and groups such as guilds, councils, associations, and arts centers as well as informal clubs, networks, and organizations. Education & Training Programs and instruction aimed at developing or enhancing creative talent variously offered by public and private arts and craft schools, private teachers, and within educational institutions and supporting industries. Events & Performances Activities such as scheduled theatre, festivals, shows, celebrations, exhibits, gallery openings, and readings, open as well as ticketed, that showcase the creative economy. Places and Spaces Locations such as museums, historic sites, gardens, arts districts, neighborhoods, exhibition halls, film and music studios, incubators, and shared space in which creative assets and enterprises can be created, housed, and displayed. Resources Support such as sources of funding, incentive programs, and information or assistance provided by government agencies, non-profit or for profit organizations, and private foundations. A. Support Infrastructure: Networking for Compatibility and Competitiveness Guilds, council, arts associations, advocacy organizations, and social networks represent the associational infrastructure that enables members of Mississippi’s creative economy to connect to one another, to the state’s broader creative economy, and to external sources of knowledge and creative inspiration. The approximately 200 arts organizations and networks that this study found include formal and informal groups of working artists, educators, and patrons and supporters of the arts. Together the organizations support creative processes and programming for artists and art enthusiasts of all ages and tastes. 8 William Bryant Logan and Muse, The Smithsonian Guide to Historic America: The Deep South. New York: Stewart, Tabori, and Chamng, 1998. 24 mississippi’s creative economy Of the 200 organizations and networks uncovered, the greatest number of them (67) are located in Jackson. As the largest city and state capital, it is also home to a number of statewide organizations. The Pines, Coastal and Hills region were evenly represented with approximately 30 organizations each, and the Delta area lagged behind with only 17. 1. Arts Councils and Community Arts Organizations Local arts councils and community arts organizations play an important role in making creativity visible throughout Mississippi. By sponsoring exhibits of local working or amateur artists, or by supporting arts programming in local schools or senior centers, local arts councils help make the arts viable, visible, and accessible to a broad swath of the state’s population. For example, the Yoknapatawpha Arts Council, the official arts agency for Oxford and Lafayette County since 1972, was founded to create opportunities for the community to experience highquality art. To meet this goal, the organization supports 300 days of programming a year with galleries, festivals, local publications, libraries and the schools. In east Mississippi, the Starkville Area Arts Council makes grants and gives awards to arts educators, artists, organizations and students interested in pursuing education and training in the arts. In Hattiesburg, Partners for the Arts is a vibrant and growing organization that provides financial support to the performing and visual arts departments at the University of Southern Mississippi. In 2009, its 300 members raised $87,000 distributed through a grant program to support the university’s arts programs. Arts organizations were also instrumental in helping the Gulf Coast recover after the devastating hurricanes of 2005. Working with the Hancock County Chamber of Commerce, the Mississippi Arts Commission, and The Arts, Hancock County, an arts recovery program set up shop to help get artists back on their feet and in a sense lead the charge of recovery for the region. The recovery program along with The Arts, Hancock County helped sponsor a traveling exhibition of Gulf Coast artists, helping local artists show their work around the nation and mCe 2. Guilds, Cooperatives and Professional Associations Guilds, cooperatives, and informal craft and hobby groups provide individual artists with entré into a community of individuals involved in similar pursuits. The intangible benefits are significant, if difficult to measure. Those benefits include a shared spirit of creativity, increased social ties and the exchange of ideas and inspiration. These organizations also have concrete and measurable benefits, particularly the more formal ones. Cooperative galleries and guilds may provide places for individual artists to sell their work. Individuals can benefit from having one centralized body responsible for marketing and financial management, as well as by being part of a larger “brand.” The Craftsmen’s Guild of Mississippi and its crafts gallery and store in Ridgeland is probably the most prominent of these organizations, but other cooperative galleries and guilds exist in Meridian, Jackson, Starkville, and Corinth, among other places. Professional associations serve as advocates for the arts, in general, and for artists in specific fields. Associations such as the Mississippi Writers Guild, the Mississippi Museums Association and the Mississippi Gospel Music Association tend to have statewide membership, which allows them to provide a unified voice for artists across the state. 3. Amateur and Professional Companies Amateur theatre, dance and music companies give Mississippi’s aspiring talent places to hone their skills while their professional equivalents provide employment for some of the state’s greatest talent. Approximately 50 community and youth theatres throughout the state offer education, training and performance opportunities to aspiring actors and the chance to enjoy theatre to community members. As with many strands of the arts, community theatres are represented by a statewide membership organization, the Mississippi Theatre Association. begin to recover from the storm’s devastation. See “Red Hots and Deep Blues: Stories from Mississippi’s Creative Economy.” Thacker Mountain Radio Performance, Oxford, MS 25 mCe mississippi’s creative economy The Mississippi Opera, the Mississippi Symphony Orchestra and Ballet Mississippi are statewide professional companies. A number of regional companies, including the Tupelo Ballet, the Gulf Coast Symphony Orchestra, the Hattiesburg Civic Light Orchestra, Meridian Symphony Orchestra and Mississippi Metro Ballet, also provide opportunities for professional artists and audiences. Access to companies like these is a boon to music students at the University of Southern Mississippi who often find weekend employment playing with the state’s several orchestras, thus gaining valuable professional experience. 1. Cultural Contributions In Starkville, Mississippi State University sponsors music and dramatic performances, arts shows, and film festivals, and it supports outdoor art. The University of Mississippi’s museum, Gertrude Castellow Ford Center for Performing Arts, and Faulkner and Yoknapatawpha Conference are open to the entire community. Just a few examples of entertainment and culture colleges and universities offer their community include: • Belhaven College’s 800-seat Center for the Arts B. Educational Institutions: Sources of Talent, Learning and Culture • William Carey University’s Sarah Gillespie Museum of Art Mississippi’s educational institutions assume many roles in the state’s creative economy. They generate its labor force and entrepreneurs that originate and produce creative goods. They provide access to new ideas, information, and people. They also are responsible for developing the creative, right brain thinking that employers increasingly seek. In the survey of manufacturers, 65 percent ranked creativity as an important or very important trait in new employees. Educational institutions host entertainment and cultural activities in their communities. They develop interest in and appreciation for the arts in the population that will become the next generation of artists, designers, and consumers. And they provide a non-traditional means for raising levels of academic achievement. In each area of activity, Mississippi has significant strengths but also opportunities to do even more. How well do the state’s colleges and universities meet labor market and community needs for creativity and culture? Most community colleges have had programs in the fine arts for decades, but mainly as part of their associate of arts transfer tracks designed to send well-rounded individuals into the universities, not into employment or careers. Most of Mississippi’s community colleges today, however, are beginning to respond to the state’s transition from a mass production economy to an idea- and experience-based economy and to the growing job market and student demand for applied creative arts in, for example, digital arts, graphic design, landscape architecture, and interior decoration. And many colleges and universities are important sources of and venues for art and culture, especially in the state’s smaller cities. and Carey Dinner Theater • Millsaps College’s Lewis Art Gallery and Arts and Lecture Series • Alcorn State University’s Jazz Festival. • Art Colony at Tougaloo College • Eudora Welty Writers Symposium at Mississippi University for Women Many of the state’s community colleges also are cultural hubs for their communities. Nearly all sponsor various musical ensembles and theater groups that perform at the college and locally. Some specific examples are: • Hinds Community College’s Marie Hull Gallery and Montage Theater of Dance • Copiah Community College’s co-sponsored Natchez Literary and Cinema Celebration • Jones Junior College’s Eula Bass Lewis Art Gallery • Northeast Mississippi Community College’s Northeast Art Gallery • Pearl River Community College’s museum 2. Creative Abilities The skills and knowledge needed to make a living in creative fields are acquired in many ways but perhaps are most strongly influenced by exposure and support at home and in early school years. Career decisions are influenced by abilities and/or interests that have been shaped by elementary and high school teachers, counselors and by institutions’ learning environments. One community college student found that “it was cool to go to movies” during his previous home schooling, and he turned that interest into a career path. 26 mississippi’s creative economy mCe a. Starting Young Mississippi’s “Whole Schools Initiative” is an innovative approach to not only keeping, but to emphasizing, the arts in schools. It was begun in 1991, when arts curriculums were being cut in schools. The Whole Schools Initiative, funded and supported by the Mississippi Arts Commission, infuses and integrates arts into regular instruction. Its goals are to enrich students’ lives, build sustainable communities and to improve teaching and achievement by putting the arts on equal footing with the three “Rs.” Since 1998 this program has expanded into the middle and high schools. Schools can contract with both participating (teaching) artists and visiting artists to Historically CTE, as vocational education, focused on industrial trades and agriculture, but now it is moving into newer technology, health, and computer-related fields. Mississippi’s CTE includes, among its 48 programs, five that directly support the creative economy: culinary and related foods technology, design technology for fashion and interiors, audio and television broadcasting, computer graphics, and graphics and print communications. Design technology for fashion is the newest track, started as a pilot program with 15 students in 2005 to convert the former occupational clothing track into a more design-oriented program aimed at higher-end and niche markets. supplement and further enrich their programs. Career and Technical Education, once intended as preparation The Mississippi School of the Arts in Brookhaven, created by the legislature in 1999 for artistically talented and gifted Mississippi youth, is a residential school located on a historic campus. An agreement with Brookhaven School District allows students to balance their arts interests with meeting academic requirements at the nearby public high school. The impact generated from the school has been profound: In 2009 students graduating from MSA received $3.2 million in scholarships offers which exceeded the $3 million annual appropriation from the State Legislature. These scholarships include offers from top national and state universities and specialized arts programs such as the American Academy of Dramatic Arts See “Red Hots and Deep Blues: Stories from Mississippi’s Creative Economy.” b. Considering Careers Students begin to think about their future career opportunities in middle school. By high school, many are already on clearly defined pathways in chosen areas of career and technical education (CTE) programs. for immediate employment, now also must offer a path into higher education, most often at a community college. Mississippi’s community college system, the oldest state system in the nation, places a high value on the fine arts in its liberal arts programs. Thirteen of the colleges have programs for visual and fine arts, and all but one have programs in music education. The majority of the students going through the fine arts programs will transfer to four-year schools and go into teaching careers. Beyond the fine arts, however, programs to support creative occupations become scarce. Graphic design and mass communications are offered in five colleges each, and culinary arts in four. Hinds and Mississippi Delta Community Colleges have commercial kitchens and expose students to the art of baking and international cuisines. Coahoma has a fashion merchandising and Apparel Studies program. No Mississippi community college has a two-year architectural program, and none has a program in film/video, animation, or in historic renovation, all areas needed to support the growth of Mississippi’s creative economy. Further, this unmet need receives little attention in the state’s acclaimed workforce programs that have been so successful in supporting business recruitment and retention. Mississippi’s universities also are very strong in the fine arts, with 13 universities offering degree programs in visual/fine arts and 13 with programs in music; and many have mass communications programs. The availability of degree programs is considerably weaker, however, in design, culinary arts, and literary arts. 27 mCe mississippi’s creative economy the Craftsmen Guild in Ridgeland, Mary O’Keefe Cultural Center for Arts Education in Ocean Springs, Meridian Artists’ Coop, Dee Art Place in Columbus, the Caboose Art Gallery in Long Beach, and the Viking Cooking School in Greenwood are only a few examples. The state, for example, has more than 100 dance schools or studios with the industry classification of “fine arts school.” C. Mississippi Arts Commission, WSI Summer Institute The University of Southern Mississippi (Southern Miss) is the state’s flagship school for the creative economy, one of only 24 universities in the nation accredited in dance, music, theater, and visual art. But all of the state’s universities offer something to the aspiring artist or designer, particularly in music. Delta State University has degree programs in both music and music education, Mississippi University for Women offers general music, music education, and music therapy, and Belhaven University, and Alcorn State University have degrees in music. USM and, since March 2009, Delta State University operate recording studios operated by students. A few of the four-year colleges offer some courses and programs in design, with building and landscape architecture and a design program at Mississippi State University, degree programs in interior and graphic design at Southern Miss, plus concentrations in graphic or interior design at a few other colleges. Mississippi University for Women is the state’s only four-year college offering a baccalaureate in the culinary arts. The University of Mississippi is at the forefront of journalism and media, with the Edwin and Becky Meek School of Journalism and New Media, but Southern Miss and Alcorn State have schools or departments of mass communications and most other colleges have programs or concentrations. Many colleges contribute to the state’s reputation as a wellspring for literature. Seven colleges are National Writing Project sites for the development of teaching writing. The University of Mississippi offers a masters’ degree in creative writing, and Belhaven University has a baccalaureate program in the same area. Mississippi residents can also acquire skills and knowledge in a number of non-degree granting private schools. The Natchez Clay Center, Allison’s Wells School of Arts and Crafts in Canton, Events and Performances One of the most important outlets for artistic expression is the multitude of festivals that are found in almost every county in Mississippi. These festivals celebrate everything from the writings of Eudora Welty and Tennessee Williams to the culture of Coastal Mississippi and art from the creations of Walter Anderson to the blues of BB King. Indeed, the Mississippi blues illustrates just how numerous festivals are in the state. These festivals and arts events serve as assets for Mississippi’s creative economy in several ways that generate economic impacts for the community in which they are held. First, they provide an avenue for Mississippi artists to reach larger numbers of audiences and customers. Second, those festivals and arts events that celebrate local culture or history and tell a story about their communities help create a brand and special sense of place. Third, they integrate and promote the arts to the community at large and expose residents to different ideas and people. According to the Blues Highway Association’s annual listing of festivals, there are 56 festivals in the state that prominently feature the blues. From the large annual Mississippi Delta Blues and Heritage Festival in Greenville to the Mississippi Gulf Coast Blues and Heritage Festival in Pascagoula, blues fans and performers can spend almost every weekend of the year hearing and playing the music they love. Jessee Robinson performs at Hal and Mal’s, Jackson, MS 28 mississippi’s creative economy From April to November of 2009, there were only eight weekends that didn’t feature at least one blues festival. Many of these festivals are featured on the state’s Blues Trail, which highlights historical events in the music’s past and helps promote new events by reminding tourists about where live music is currently taking place (See Red Hots and Deep Blues: Stories from Mississippi’s Creative Economy). To underscore the importance to the state’s economy, in April 2010, “Mississippi – The Birthplace of America’s Music” was the theme of the Mississippi Economic Council’s 61st Annual Meeting. 1. Festivals as Market Assets About 66 percent of the Mississippi visual or craft artists who responded to a survey earned income through selling their products at festivals or fairs, and 30 percent reported earning more than a fifth of their income from such events. The Cotton Arts District Festival in Starkville is an example of the type of market asset that festivals represent. Each April, the Starkville Area Arts Council holds an event in the historic Cotton District. The event features a juried arts competition. The 2010 event showcased more than 100 artists and attracted approximately 42,000 attendees. For musicians , festivals are often the best way to get their art out to new and appreciative audiences. More than half of musicians who responded to the survey reported earning income from festivals or annual events. As mentioned, the blues festival circuit is promoted heavily and is usually the prime venue for local acts to perform and promote their music, with many artists selling their CDs and merchandise at the events. While the festivals do attract national level talent, the focus is still on local artists. Respondents to the survey of festivals in Mississippi showed that more than 75 percent of musical performers hailed from within the state. Outdoor concert at the Cedars, Fondren, Jackson, MS Figure 8: mCe Origins of Participants, by percent 50 37.5 25 12.5 0 City Region State Outside State 2. Festivals Promoting the Arts For many individuals, festivals and events represent their primary exposure to the arts. Even if nothing is purchased, listening to new music, looking at art and traditional crafts, and sampling new cuisines can contribute to a community’s overall appreciation of artistic endeavors. Indeed, survey respondents saw this exposure as one of the main purposes of the events. One sponsor of a festival in Vicksburg said, “Our mission is to promote and raise awareness about Mississippi music, heritage and culture. It’s good business for everyone; the venues, and the opportunities created for musicians. Our efforts to provide more music is important for local businesses faced with employee retention issues. By encouraging businesses to participate in providing great Mississippi music, we improve the quality of life for our community.” Festival survey respondents generally agree with that assessment with 80 percent saying that the festival had a medium or major impact in preserving a community’s local culture. 3. Festivals and Economic Impact While the altruistic nature of promoting the arts certainly is present, festivals generate a large economic impact. In terms of sheer attendance, 56 survey respondents reported that more than 460,000 individuals attended the events, which, while impressive, is only a fraction of the total annual attendance for all festivals in the state. Extrapolating the numbers reported by those surveyed to the full 149 festivals held that year suggests more than 1.2 million participants. Although most of the attendees at these festivals were from within the state, 70 percent of respondents reported that more than 10 percent of attendees came from outside Mississippi. 29 mississippi’s creative economy Attendees don’t only spend their time at the festivals; they also spend money, which can have a sizable impact on the economy of the host community. Seventy-five percent of respondents reported that the festival had a medium or major impact on tourist spending in their communities. This amount translates into helping entrepreneurs in the community; 57 percent of respondents reported that the festival had a medium or major impact on small businesses in the region. The Loose Caboose Festival in Newton is just one example of the impact of how a festival can impact a small community. The small festival promotes local crafts and local artists and brings people to downtown Newton who otherwise might not visit it. One small business owner recognizes just how important that event is: “Repeat business to our community is somehow never calculated into economic impact, but as a business owner downtown I personally know the number of customers that come back to my shop from the festival alone and no amount of advertising could reach that many people in one day.” D. Places and Spaces: Creativity on Display Though many creative occupations and processes are individual endeavors, calling to mind the image of the solitary artist in a studio or the writer hunched over a desk, creative individuals need places to create, either alone or with other creative people. But they also need more public places to perform, exhibit and share their work. In Mississippi, hundreds of museums, galleries, theaters, concert halls, restaurants and pubs, historic sites, buildings and neighborhoods, gardens and public spaces serve as venues for the performance, exhibition, and dissemination of creative work. 1. Museums and Heritage Sites More than 300 cultural heritage sites and 130 museums spread throughout the state serve as venues for the celebration, exhibition and, in some cases, sale of art and cultural heritage. These venues celebrate and commemorate a wide range of the state’s artistic and cultural heritage, its most notable achievements and talent and, in some cases, its new and emerging artists. The preserved homes of some of Mississippi’s most famous artists are one subset of this group. Tourists and residents alike mCe can draw inspiration from visiting the homes and workplaces of talent like Eudora Welty, Tennessee Williams, Mississippi John Hurt, and Alice Moseley. Another example is the handful of museums that celebrate the artistic accomplishment and legacy of Mississippi natives, such as the Ohr-O’Keefe Museum, the Walter Anderson Museum of Art or the BB King Museum and Delta Interpretive Center. The Walter Anderson Museum of Art in Ocean Springs holds a permanent collection of approximately 800 pieces of work by Walter Anderson, a muralist, potter and painter, and his brothers Peter and James, all of whom made their homes and artistic careers on the Gulf Coast. Since Hurricane Katrina, the museum’s mission has also included supporting Gulf Coast artists by providing opportunities to exhibit their work. (See Red Hots and Deep Blues: Stories from Mississippi’s Creative Economy.”) 2. Galleries and Studios The study identified more than 100 galleries and working studios that provide venues for new and emerging artists to produce, display and sell their work, the majority of which are located in the Capital and Coastal tourism regions of the state. Undoubtedly, there are many more homes, restaurants, coffee shops, and classrooms that serve these same purposes, though perhaps more informally. A wide range of fine and visual arts, from photography to jewelry to watercolor painting, can be found in the states’ galleries and working studios. Some of these places focus on one type of art or media, such as Jackson’s Pearl River Glass Studio, a renowned stained glass studio that is open to the public for visiting and observation and hosts an annual event to showcase Mississippi artists. Others are owned and operated by cooperatives or membership groups, and serve to display the varied work of their members, as with the Meridian Artists Co-op and the Hattiesburg Arts Council gallery. 3. Performance Venues Local and touring performing artists find a stage and audience for their work in a range of venues located in all corners of the state, from the Tennessee border to the coast. These venues run the gamut from community theatres to municipal auditoriums, blues clubs to casinos. 30 mississippi’s creative economy Ground Zero Blues Club is a music venue in Clarksdale that showcases renowned blues musicians, some of whom got their start in Mississippi. Furthermore, one of the club’s owners is a talented Mississippi native who has returned home: actor Morgan Freeman. Ground Zero is a destination for visitors—many of whom are international—that come to the Mississippi Delta seeking an authentic experience. More numerous and spread throughout the state are countless community theatres, restaurants, bars, coffee shops and music halls that serve as performance venues for aspiring local talent. Corinth Theatre-Arts is a community theatre that nurtures local talent through open auditions for its production season and its youth summer program, while Cups, a local coffee roaster and purveyor, hosts local acoustic and folk musicians at its location in Jackson’s Fondren district. Jackson’s Fondren District is one prominent example of such a district. The neighborhood has been revitalized and is now a desirable residential, commercial and entertainment district. A high concentration of artists, painters and musicians mix comfortably with other area residents, themselves a mix of professionals, long-time residents and newcomers. Galleries, boutiques and restaurants all serve as venues to showcase the work of local artists. The community is now an experience rather than just a place to live or work. See “Red Hots and Deep Blues: Stories from Mississippi’s Creative Economy.” Though it takes place in a bookstore, Oxford’s Thacker Mountain Radio also presents a unique opportunity for local writers and musicians. The weekly radio program, broadcast live each Thursday, showcases authors and musicians. Caroline Herring, one of the show’s founders and original performers went on to become an integral part of the Austin, Texas music scene and has released five albums since 2001. (See Red Hots and Deep Blues: Stories from Mississippi’s Creative Economy.”) mCe The state’s universities and colleges also provide many venues for performers. Mississippi State University’s Meridian campus is home to the recently renovated Riley Center, a fully restored 1889 opera house and a 200-seat theatre. Southern Miss’s music and theatre performance facilities showcase the talent of students and professionals and draw an audience from a onehour radius. Important venues that are easily overlooked are the casinos, especially the concentration around Tunica along the Mississippi River and the Mississippi Gulf Coast. People come for the entertainment as well as the gaming, and the stages attract both big name and local artists. 4. Arts Districts and Buildings Creative industries and individuals benefit from proximity to like minded organizations, companies and individuals. Concentrations of creative economy actors also create positive spillover effects for other individuals and companies that may not be directly involved in the creative economy. For this reason, the existence of arts districts and entire buildings devoted to the arts are a critical part of any place’s creative infrastructure. In several locations throughout the state, artists and creative organizations are all brought under the same roof in historic buildings. The E.E. Bass Cultural Center in Greenville, the Mary C. O’Keefe Cultural Center in Ocean Springs and the Madison Square Center for the Arts in Madison are all former school buildings that now house a range of spaces for creative activity: studios, exhibition spaces, auditoriums, classrooms and offices for local arts organizations. A similar plan is underway in Hattiesburg. E. Resources: Investments and Involvement Success for artists and other creative enterprises depend, at least in part, on access to financial capital and technical support from private and public sources. Resources can come in the form of grants made by charitable foundations and statesupported institutions or in the form of technical assistance provided by organizations geared toward creative businesses and entrepreneurs. But the majority of creative enterprises have the same needs as any other new or growth-oriented businesses for venture capital and working capital. 31 mississippi’s creative economy The Mississippi Arts Commission is the most important resources and sources of support for the state’s artists and organizations in the arts. In terms of support for individual artists, MAC offers grants up to $5,000 to individual professional artists under its Artist Fellowship program. The grant program is seen as “awards of merit.” While applicants are not required to submit information on how they might use the funds, MAC expects the recipients to dedicate the funds towards expanding their ability to create new work. MAC also offers mini-grants of up to $500 to provide artists with funds to assist with professional training, promotional efforts, or purchase of supplies.9 MAC also provides operating grant support for individual arts councils around the state. Many of these organizations provide funding to support individual artists or community focused events and efforts. For instance, the Greater Jackson Arts Council provides grants to organizations that use arts to enhance quality of life in particular neighborhoods of the capital city. mCe network of Mississippi Small Business Development Centers can assist businesses in creating start-up plans and in navigating issues such as obtaining financing and expanding market share. In some states, small business development centers have developed expertise around creative enterprises recognizing that artists may require particular types of services. Mississippi does not as of yet have any comprehensive services but there are some geared towards the success of particular types of creative businesses. For instance, the Franklin Furniture Institute at Mississippi State University offers entrepreneurs and companies in the wood products industry information about new market opportunities such as sustainably-produced products and how to enhance design to meet the aesthetic needs of an increasingly fragmented marketplace. Programs such as these that are tailored to the specific needs of creative industry can have a substantial impact on those businesses that choose to make use of these types of services. Mississippi also has a large number of organizations that award grants to artists and arts organizations. An estimated 46 foundations based in Mississippi name arts funding one of their areas of emphasis—for activities such as assisting after school programs; providing disadvantaged youth with arts instruction; supporting the many arts-focused festivals around the state; and making grants to support community theaters and symphonies. The Gertrude C. Ford Foundation, Inc., for example, is an independent foundation based in Jackson contributed operating grant support to, among other organizations, the Mississippi Museum of Art, the New Stage Theater in Jackson and the Mississippi Opera. The past year has been a difficult time for cultural and arts organizations to attract funds. The weak economy has reduced funds available from foundations and government agencies creating intense competition among non-profit organizations that rely in part on charitable giving or the public sector. Needed resources are not limited to financial concerns. Organizations that provide small business assistance, such as those operated by the Mississippi Development Authority, can provide substantial assistance for promotion, marketing, and business development. For artists or other businesses within the creative economy such assistance can be invaluable. The The furniture industry in Mississippi 9 http://www.arts.state.ms.us/grants/artist-fellowship.php 32 mCe mississippi’s creative economy V. Recommended Goals and Strategies The size of the creative economy alone has a large and direct impact on the state’s economy—nearly 3,000 establishments responsible for roughly 40,200 jobs that are engaged primarily in the production, distribution, and marketing of aesthetically or emotionally oriented products or services—is sufficient reason to invest in the cluster. It employs more people than the defense and security, apparel and textiles, and transportation equipment manufacturing clusters, all of which are important sectors of the state’s economy. Add to that the effect of the creative economy on so many other sectors, such as tourism, agriculture, communications and information technologies, furniture and health care and its value as an amenity that attracts tourists and talent, and the potential value far exceeds the conventional view of the lone artist at a festival or performer on the street. The following goals and strategies are based on what has been learned in this study and on the ideas and vision of some of the key stakeholders in Mississippi’s arts, education, and economic development arenas. They are intended to help the state reap the full benefits of its creative people and creative economy. The Creative Economy 1. Is a direct source of growth (Goal II) 2. Adds value to other sectors (Goals IV, V) 3. Attracts talented people, businesses and tourists (Goals I, III) 4. Stimulates innovation (Goals III, IV, V) 5. Is the foundation for the 21st century work force (Goal VI) GOAL I: Facilitate efforts that make communities throughout the state more creative and vibrant. In Richard Florida’s Who’s Your City, he demonstrates the value of place to people and to companies. “Where we live is the central factor that affects all others—work, education, and love—follow. 10” Although the book focuses on large metropolitan areas, small communities can even more easily distinguish or brand themselves and attract people and firms who may be looking for less expensive, less crowded, and less hectic places. Those communities that are able to offer enough of the urban creative amenities and cultural attractions along with a slower, more family-friendly lifestyle can use that to their advantage to generate and retain wealth. Strategies that allow rural communities to convert their creative talent into economic activities are critical to Mississippi’s future. Strategy A: Use creative talent and enterprises to promote community restoration and revitalization. • Reinstate state funding for Mississippi’s Building Fund for the Arts (BFA) program, a bond bill that could be used to refurbish and maintain buildings as cultural centers. 11 The fund, authorized at $19.2 million and managed by the Mississippi Arts Commission, supported 93 projects between 2001 and 2007. Awards were based on artistic quality, plans, architectural and organizational capacity, and anticipated economic impact. • Offer financial or architectural incentives or technical assistance to make abandoned or unused downtown space available to creative businesses, galleries, and/or studio space in both urban areas and in small communities. Paducah, Kentucky has had one of the nation’s first and most successful artists relocation programs. Recruiting artists nationally with zero interest loans and subsidies for architectural changes, the city attracts some 50 artists, which brought galleries and theaters to a previously distressed area of the city. In Pittsfield, Massachusetts, a group of artists worked with the owners of vacant storefronts in the downtown. The idea was to give artists the opportunity to work in these spaces and exhibit their art, and to bring more foot traffic to the downtown. The effort succeeded in helping both the artists and the property owners, and downtown Pittsfield is now a more arts-active and vibrant place to live and work. 10 Richard Florida, Who’s Your City? New York: Basic Books, 2008, p. 6. 11 http://www.arts.state.ms.us/programs/building-fund.php 33 mCe mississippi’s creative economy • Develop and communicate programs currently available through MAC. • Consider a “Percent for Art” program such as is being implemented on university campuses and many federal projects. Set aside a percentage of funding for public buildings and public spaces to display art such as sculptures, murals and other decorative art in, for example, hotel lobbies, restaurants, banks, hospitals and outdoors. • Consider zoning and private-sector set asides such as those done in the GSA Art in Architecture Program which commissions the nation’s leading artists to create large-scale works of art for new federal buildings. These artworks enhance the civic meaning of federal architecture and showcase the vibrancy of American visual arts. Together, the art and architecture of federal buildings create a lasting cultural legacy for the people of the United States. GSA reserves one-half of the estimated construction cost of each new federal building to commission project artists. The Alluvian Hotel, a cosmopolitan boutique hotel in Greenwood, Mississippi exhibits a collection of award-winning art by Mississippi artists. The Mayor of Sheridan, Wyoming enacted Resolution 24-00 to establish an “Art in Public Places” program in July 2000 and the city of 15,000 now has some 50 sculptures with a western theme downtown. Originally on loan from the artists for $500, about half now have been purchased and are permanent. • Support the designation and formation of “Creative Economic districts,” where creative people and enterprises are encouraged to concentrate, collaborate, live and work. • The state of Louisiana recently passed enabling legislation that allows local communities to create Cultural Districts, and at least 51 districts have been created around the state to date. The Districts provide tax exemptions for the sale of one-of-a-kind art and tax credits to rehabilitate buildings to help create more vibrant downtowns. 12 with low rent space for studios and theater companies. Granville Island is now the artistic center of Vancouver and a primary tourist destination served by a steady stream of sea taxies. 13 • MDA and MAC would create a program that helps communities become certified (similar to the state’s Certified Retirement Communities program) and offer technical assistance to communities to inventory their creative assets and develop plans to meet criteria for being designated a “creative community.” Mississippi offers communities the chance to become Certified Retirement Communities, which is obtained after a three-month screening process, and to become recognized under the Mississippi Main Street Association program, supported by the National Trust for Historic Preservation and the Mississippi Development Authority. The Maine Arts Commission established a program in 2001 called “Discovery Research that gave grants and methodologies to communities to map their creative assets, discover their own cultural resources, and provide funds to survey local events, artists, traditions, and tradition-bearers as well as cultural organizations which promote or support the performing, visual, craft or literary arts. The state is now transitioning from that discovery model to a capacity building model. Vermont, based on recommendations of the Vermont Council on Culture and Innovation, encouraged selected communities to look at development through the lens of the creative economy, emphasizing the importance of place, creative partnerships, and creative assets. 14 Cat Head Delta Blues and Folk Art, Clarksdale, MS Granville Island was formed from a sandbar in the heart of Vancouver, British Columbia to hide the city’s heavy industries. In the 1970s a local politician led the move to change its image and rebuild the island’s economy on the arts. They created a cultural center in abandoned factories 12 http://www.crt.state.la.us/culturaldistricts/documents/act298.pdf. 13 http://granvilleisland.com 14 http://www.vtrural.org/creative-communities.php. 34 mCe mississippi’s creative economy Strategy B: MAC to continue support and assist cultural fairs and festivals. • MAC and MDA offers technical assistance and support for organizers of fairs, festivals and other celebrations through the Festivals and Events Coordinators Workshops. The program improves the promotion, marketing, fundraising and business planning efforts of festivals. These festivals and other forms of community and regional celebrations can be used effectively to showcase and market a place’s special history, culture, creativity or even weirdness, an increasingly sought attribute. 15 Strategy A: Develop greater capacity to assist businesses in the creative industries. Improve ability of existing technical and business support infrastructure to support the self-employed and microenterprises. • Entrepreneurial Center, etc. The Mississippi Arts Commission (MAC) and the Mississippi Development Authority’s (MDA) Tourism Division have been active supporters of many events through grants and other services. Both agencies recognize the challenges faced by community groups that produce festivals. To address these challenges, MAC and MDA have come together to produce workshops that provide training and networking opportunities for festival coordinators from around the state. The current Mississippi Arts Commission program to help artists with business skills could be turned into a “train the trainer” program that would enable existing services to better understand and support the needs of artists and artisans. www.visualarts.ms.gov. The Mississippi Arts Commission has created the Mississippi Visual Arts Directory Website. The website serves as a resource to all things visual arts in the state and provides artists with the opportunity to increase their visibility. The site is open to all visual artists and craftsmen, museums, cultural centers and galleries and visual arts organizations and all art education facilities. The City of Lowell, Massachusetts has an event called “Destination World” that brings together all of the city’s immigrant and ethnic communities around a single event to highlight the contribution and work of the city’s immigrant population. This also brings new audiences to the downtown. Haywood Community College in western North Carolina hosts an arts business boot camp every summer during which artisans are taught about managing their business, finances, marketing, use of ecommerce, and budgeting. Most years, the camp is oversubscribed, with attendees coming from across the U.S. It’s supported by the Arts Business Institute, co-located with HandMade in America in Asheville. GOAL II: Promote entrepreneurship and small business growth among creative firms. The creative economy, with its emphasis on small scale, over mass production, is exceptionally entrepreneurial. But because the structure of this cluster favors highly flexible small companies with uncertain markets that are dependent more on the strength of reputation and connections than productivity, it is not well understood or served by the public agencies that assist small businesses. Business and capital assistance organizations typically are measured by employment growth, which biases publicly funded services against helping entrepreneurial companies that are considered “lifestyle” or unlikely to grow very large. Help small business development centers, cooperative and manufacturing extension offices, incubators, MDA’s Entrepreneurial Center and employment services to better understand the particular needs and markets of the creative enterprise. Continue to work through existing programs and organizations such as tech parks, incubator space, MDA’s • Expand Mississippi’s existing “Arts Means Business” program to reach a greater number of creative enterprises and creative people, possibly working though membership organizations like the Mississippi Craftsmen’s Guild and by training the staff of existing small business assistance programs and educational institutions to support creative enterprises. 15 Joe Cortright, “‘Keep Portland Weird’ makes sense as a jobs strategy,” Oregonlive.com, February 13, 2010. 35 mississippi’s creative economy The Montana two-year college system developed a program called “artrepreneurship” in its arts and crafts program at Great Falls that emphasizes the business side of the arts. An evaluation of the first class of completers found on average a 152 percent increase in sales, 309 percent increase in out-of-state sales, and four new enterprises started. • • Build the state’s artist’s roster, develop a more comprehensive directory of the larger range of creative enterprises that includes, for instance, lists of writers, designers, architects, interior designers, music companies, animators, and graphic artists. Use the roster to reach broader and more distant markets for the state’s creative products. The Georgia Tourism Foundation supports a web site called Georgia’s Creative Economies that promotes Georgia people, places, and made and grown things. It can be searched by region, category, and subcategory. 17 Assist existing state programs and resources, such as the Small Business Development Centers and WIN Job Centers, to better understand and assist creative enterprises, with a special effort to target the development and growth of creative enterprises by underserved populations. In Kentucky, the state agricultural extension service has an extension agent in the poor, eastern-most and coal dependent part of Appalachia dedicated to working with artisans and artists and the University of Massachusetts-Amherst has an Arts Extension Service that has helped connect communities to the arts and has offered workshops and training for more than 30 years, now including a creative economy training program. 16 mCe The Milwaukee Cultural Council is developing a comprehensive on-line database for all of the people and companies that are part of the creative economy in southeast Wisconsin as part of its creative economy initiative. • Consider producing a Mississippi Roots Music show that celebrates being the birthplace of America’s music. The Boston Pops has an American Idol style competition called POPSearch. Held in the summer, it plays to a live audience of almost half a million and millions more on television. In 2004, the winner was a van driver for special needs children. 18 Strategy B: Support branding and marketing of the state’s creative places, products and assets. Strategy C: Help artists find new full-time employment that utilizes their talent. • • Work together across agencies to identify and communicate the state’s creative brand, i.e., “Mississippi’s Creative Spirit.” The Mississippi Development Authority (MDA) Tourism Division contracted with North Star Destination Strategies to determine and define the state’s true, unique and relevant brand position that will help the state stand out in the tourism marketplace. North Star conducted more than a dozen pieces of research to identify what differentiates Mississippi from its competitors. The result? Mississippi is the most southern of all states and the mother of southern culture - yesterday, today and tomorrow. From this, Mississippi’s brand was created, “Find Your True South.” Many places have branded their creative products, such as Kentucky Crafted, Native Handicraft from Alaska and Made in Montana. Fewer have successfully used creativity to brand a place, although Glasgow, Scotland calls itself the “Creative City” and the Berkshires in western Massachusetts use “Berkshire Creative: Creativity Lives Here” as a regional brand. Support the development of an artist’s employment service, either through the Arts Commission or the Mississippi Department of Employment Security. In Southeast Wisconsin, the Kohler Corporation has an on-going Artists in Residency program that leads to its arts edition products. The company also has an art gallery. In addition, one of the hotels in downtown Milwaukee created a similar Artist-in-Residency program in which a local artist worked on his paintings in the lobby of the hotel. The program has elevated the visibility of the arts and artists and made the lobby of the hotel more attractive. Northern Michigan University hosts an “Art & Design Career & Employment - Art Jobs” designed to provide access to numerous art/design career and employment internet resources. Individuals can search for opportunities across the entire US and even globally. 16 http://www.artsextensionservice.org 17 http://www.gamadegagrownproducts.org/index.php 18 http://www.myspace.com/popsearch 36 mCe mississippi’s creative economy GOAL III Help communities preserve and generate added value from the state’s rich cultural and historic heritage. Strategy A: Encourage investment in and marketing of the state’s cultural heritage in more communities. • The history and architecture of a place influence how people feel about their communities and the decisions people make of where they want to live. This, in turn, influences where companies want to do business. If a place is distinctive enough, values, and invests in that uniqueness, cultural heritage can generate wealth in its own right. Mississippi represents a prime example of this phenomenon. The state’s cultural heritage, particularly as demonstrated by its literature, music, and architecture, is a strong, internationally recognized brand. Literature is epitomized by Oxford, music by Clarksdale, and architecture by Natchez. But all three art forms are present in force in many other places across the state. For example, in 2008 Columbus was named one of twelve national distinctive destinations by the National Trust for Historic Preservation. If the heritage of a place can be preserved in the face of the growth pressures brought on by development, that brand can be used to promote all aspects of Mississippi’s creative economy. Many other communities have some of these same attributes, but they are unrecognized or underappreciated. Taylor, for example, has been recognized as being “quintessential Mississippi [where] tourists come for photos.” 19 Mississippi should focus on those things which are authentically part of our Mississippi culture: • • • • • • • Arts Literarture Music Architecture Food Sacred places Civil War and Civil Rights The state should help communities identify their assets; provide communities a template and best practices. Help each community to inventory and assess the economic value of its cultural and historical assets including its architecture. Although Mississippi has a strong program for preserving and registering historic places, this step would look for a unifying theme that is distinctive and defining and tie it to development efforts. In Mineral Point, Wisconsin, the town used its early mining history to create the historic Shake Rag Alley. The nine buildings attract students in the arts and crafts to classes, and a nearby artists’ community is home to 17 art galleries within a few blocks of Shake Rag Alley. 20 • Make better use of the state’s strong investment in heritage sites and locations by linking them to the creative economy and the arts community. The city of Charleston, South Carolina has worked to establish itself as a center of historic preservation. This includes the location of the American College of Building Arts, which offers degrees in historic preservation, and Clemson University’s Graduate Program in Historic Preservation. Strategy B: Involve the media, new and old, in promoting all of Mississippi’s cultural assets. For example, promote literature and strengthening the market for literary products. • Create a year-round arts colony with an emphasis on writers and composers somewhere in the state. The prestigious Mississippi Art Colony for painters is now more than 60 years old, and a similar “camp” for writers would further enhance Mississippi’s brand as a literary cluster. In Arkansas the Writers Colony at Dairy Hollow in Eureka Springs, renamed the Communications Arts Institute, gives about 50 writers each year a place to work free from distractions and in a community of people with similar interests with whom they share ideas and receive constructive 19 Christine Schultz, “You could say that some people’s careers find them,” Southwest Airlines Spirit Magazine, May 2010. 20 http://shakeragalley.com 37 mCe mississippi’s creative economy feedback. Typically, writers—now extended to songwriters and composers in the new “composers’ cottage”—spend between two weeks and three months, but usually about a month in residency. 21 The Jentel and Ucross year-round art colonies in Sheridan, Wyoming, combine the literary and visual arts. The residents describe their work at regular community meetings and Ucross has a stage that puts on musical and literary events for the community. 22 Strategy C: Further promote the image of Mississippi as a “global literary capital.” • Suggest that Oxford apply to UNESCO for Oxford to be designated a “City of Literature.” This designation will attract international attention to a community that is so rich in literary excellence. The Southern Literary Trail is a collaboration of eighteen towns from Natchez, Mississippi to Savannah, Georgia that celebrate internationally renowned writers and playwrights who were inspired by uniquely southern places. The Trail maps visitors travel to a region that is home to great writers and timeless stories. The Mississippi trail features such writers as Tennessee Williams, Eudora Welty, Shelby Foote, Margaret Walker Alexander, Richard Wright and William Faulkner. The Mississippi Development Authority is currently developing a Mississippi literary trail modeled after similar trails such as the Blues Heritage Trail, tamale trail and agri-tourism trail. Mississippi communities host a number of literary festivals and events around the state such as the Tennessee Williams festival in Clarksdale, the Natchez Literary and Film festival and the Oxford Conference of the Book. GOAL IV: Enhance the competitiveness of the state’s business and industry through increased use of art and design. the 21st century will be to adopt innovations driven by the user and the market, not just R&D, and to make similar investments in helping companies use creativity and design to distinguish and establish new products in the market and new markets. During the course of this report, we learned that while manufacturers in the state recognize the value of consumer-driven design and innovation to their success, they do not yet use it to their fullest advantage. Strategy A: Help manufacturers understand the importance of creativity and value of design as a competitive advantage. • Create a Creative Economy Toolkit, a resource for business focusing on the relationship between creativity and economic growth and how they combine to create value and opportunity. • Recommend that the Mississippi Manufacturers Association establish a council on manufacturing design or a design association within the organization for both education and application of design among manufacturers. The Center for Design Innovation in North Carolina’s Piedmont region brings in top designers to meet with local businesses and is working on forming a design council. It hosts an annual Design, Art, & Technology Symposium and brings in frequent internationally known speakers to give workshops. 23 Winzelear Gear in Chicago, which has been making gears for industry for more than a century, advertises its gears as an art form and the company has a partnership with the School of the Art Institute with fashion designers experimenting with incorporating plastic gears into unique garments and accessories. 24 Throughout the 1980’s and 1990’s, Mississippi successfully helped its industries develop or adopt the new technologies they needed to compete, investing in R&D and in technical assistance. Now that those process technologies are readily available and have been adopted in places with much lower operating costs, the competitive advantage has disappeared. The challenge for 21 http://www.writerscolony.org 22 http://www.ucrossfoundation.org/ 23 http://www.centerfordesigninnovation.org/ 24 http://www.winzelergear.com/ 38 mCe mississippi’s creative economy Strategy B: Help business and industry connect to design resources and expand design capabilities. • Include product design support among the services of the state’s Manufacturing Extension Partnership. The Manufacturing Extension Partnership, which was originally formed to help small and mid-sized manufacturers learn about and adopt newer production technologies, is well positioned to extend its services to helping small and mid-sized firms identify, develop, and use their design competencies and pursue user-driven innovations. • Provide state tax credits for investments in design capabilities similar to the state’s Five Year R&D Skills tax credit. Look at incentives similar to those used in technology businesses. Such credits have existed for many years for science-based research but have not been applied to user-driven, design oriented development. The legislation refers to scientists, engineers, and research professionals. Similar tax credits could be given for positions in design. Strategy C: Facilitate and support networking among creative people and companies • Offer incentives in existing incentive or grant programs for proposals by three or more firms operating as “flexible design networks” to encourage sharing design capacities similar to those given by some 20-30 states in the 1990s for “flexible manufacturing networks” to promote industrial modernization in small and mid-sized manufacturers. USNet was a 15-state program of Regional Technology Strategies, Inc. supported by NIST to train economic development officials and business leaders in collaborative approaches to innovation, marketing, and learning. • Oregon Creative Industries was formed in 2008 as a nonprofit association to provide a way for creative people, whether artists, film makers, designers, and architects, to intermingle, exchange ideas, and make deals.25 Encourage and support cross-discipline associations of creative people that mix and blend creative ideas from different perspectives and across different ages and cultures and propagate creativity. GOAL V: Enhance the support and networking infrastructure for creative talent across the state. Creative people tend to be heavy users of digital social networking but not necessarily joiners of associations that bring people together face to face. Yet the evidence is that younger creative people, in particular, seek places where they can meet in person, socialize, share ideas, and build different kinds of relationships than they can on Facebook. Across all age groups, creative people in Mississippi expressed a desire for more opportunities for socializing and networking than is currently available. mCe Strategy A: Promote cross-disciplinary creative networking. • Support local initiatives which encourage more networking opportunities and activities, particularly those that involve young creative people. Berkshire Spark is a networking activity of Berkshire Creative. It occurs monthly at a different locations (e.g. museums, art galleries, banks, etc.). The events bring together several hundred people (artists, cultural organizations and for-profit businesses) to meet and explore new ways of collaborating and partnering. In Milwaukee, Spreenkler Creative is a social networking site for creative people and students that informs them about events, internships and job opportunities, holds events, and provides a blogging site. 26 It also has a “meetup” page for young talent. 25 http://blog.oregoncreative.org/ 26 http://spreenkler.com/. 39 mCe mississippi’s creative economy Strategy B: Expand knowledge of, and familiarity with, existing arts and culture within the private sector. • Promote the value of incorporating and displaying art and music in private and public facilities and grounds, such as at hospitals, offices, casinos, and manufacturing plants. Duke hospital in Durham, North Carolina, has on-going artists in residence —artists, craftsmen, musicians, and writers—all supported by North Carolina Arts Council.27 In Sheridan, Wyoming, establishments ranging from the local Holiday Inn to Arby’s restaurant feature the work of local artists on their walls. • Continue to assist transactions between artists, designers, and businesses In New York City, a firm called Art Assets serves as a broker between artists and businesses that want to either buy or rent local art work. “Art has the power to transform space. Art Assets harnesses that power to communicate the vision and philosophy of each client to imbue their space with a special sense of value and sophistication” 28 GOAL VI: Build Capacity to grow & retain Creative Talent Living and Working in Mississippi For the fastest growing sectors of the economy, a surplus work force is no longer a sufficient asset to attract investment. Companies depend on talent, generally, but not always, as measured by levels of education, and many firms make their investment decisions based on where that talent already resides or is willing to move. Mississippi should first grow its talent by expanding educational programs for the creative sectors. Second, it should work to retain and recruit creative and talented people by providing environments with the amenities they seek. There is growing evidence that a significant portion of the talent population is looking outside the metropolitan areas for places that have more space, lower costs, and less traffic. 29 • • Create a life-long learning experience; Encourage the state to adopt creative strategies in education Strategy A: Expand and strengthen post secondary degree programs in creative fields of study. • Expand the culinary arts programs at community colleges, include artistic content, and offer international internships. Tampere College in Finland formed a network of community colleges, which includes U.S. colleges, to seamlessly combine the business side of a restaurant with interior design, service, menu, image, and pricing principles. During 4-6 week placements abroad students learn these skills and develop new catering products in teams of three that include a caterer, chef and baker. 27 http://www.ncartsforhealth.org/CulturalServ.htm 28 http://artassets.com 29 “In Praise of Boise: Why space really is the final frontier in the Internet age,” The Economist, May 13, 2010. 40 mCe mississippi’s creative economy • Establish a new two-year associate of applied science degree program in film/video/music production and convert the exiting one-year pre-architecture program to a two-year program with minors in historic restoration and community design. A middle college that emphasizes creative career paths can both attract non-traditional learners and develop the state’s talent base. • Guilford Technical Community College in Jamestown, North Carolina established the Larry Gatlin Entertainment Technology Center. It offers one and two-year degree programs and continuing education in a range of employment and freelance opportunities in all technical aspects of the industry. • Expand programs in design disciplines at the state’s fouryear colleges and universities and integrate the arts and design into science, engineering, and business. The University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee School of Engineering supports research projects that involve three engineers and one artist to encourage creative solutions. Strategy B: Promote the retention of graduates and the return of former graduates of creative degree programs in Mississippi. • Use social networks to maintain connections among graduates who stay or leave and organize creative alumni groups in major cities. • Consider creating a “MS Monster.com-type” employment listing Social networking now makes it easier for graduates who spread out across the country to stay in touch with each other and their roots. By giving some structure to Mississippi-based networks of creatives, and providing ways to stay abreast of opportunities and events back home, some of those who leave may choose to come back. Offer more curricula choices in creative fields such as music, film, and digital arts in ways that produce basic skill competencies as well as offer career opportunities. The Arkansas Science & Technology Authority established the EAST initiative (Environmental and Spatial Technology) to use digital arts media to facilitate the teaching of math and science. The program includes My Community, where students make documentary films about their communities and culture. • Establish new career and technical education secondary school programs in digital fields including gaming and animation. McKinley Technical High School in Washington, DC, which serves a low-income minority population and utilizes creative endeavors such as broadcasting, gaming, and web design to produce the city’s highest level of STEM skills. The school, with federal grants, started an Institute of Urban Game Design. The Mississippi Alliance for Arts Education received a grant from the Dana Foundation to provide training to Mississippi artists interested in working with teachers in school settings so that students may benefit from authentic experiences in specific art forms and to make cross-curricular connections among the arts and other core subjects. The goal of the workshops is to increase the number of artists included in the Mississippi Arts Commission’s Teaching Artist Roster. Schools that engage artists routinely consult this roster for a description of an artist’s skills and a recommendation of the quality of his/her work in the arts and in education. Strategy C: Use creative career programs to increase school retention rates in Mississippi • Establish a “middle college,” that combines grades 11 and 12 with two years of postsecondary education, that focuses on art, design, and multimedia. Such schools, located on community college campuses and heavily supported by the Gates Foundation, have proven to increase attendance and completion rates among underserved populations. 41 mississippi’s creative economy VI. A Vision for the Future Mississippi already has much of what it needs to be more widely recognized for the creative people and places it already possesses, to extend its economic impacts to more people and more places, and to broaden the impact of creativity on other sectors of the economy. The state has a literary and music tradition and a broadbased architectural heritage that can hold its own against any state in the nation. Mississippi is a mecca for anyone interested in the history of the blues, southern fiction, or antebellum architecture. It’s also known for being a wellspring of performing and visual artists. Mississippi has a plethora of both formal and informal associations, guilds, coops, and social networks that serve as both sources of inspiration and innovation and various forms of business support in all forms of creative endeavor. Mississippi also has regions that are rich in creative talent, though not necessarily in assets or incomes; regions that have been historically poor that have been helped economically only marginally by industrialization. Creativity, unbounded by age, class, race, or ethnicity—and sometimes even benefitting from it— which may offer a new approach to economic growth. It builds on its existing place- and people-based strengths, not on outsiders, on distinctiveness, not on imitation, on customization, not mass production. Mississippi’s Rural Place Building initiative was the Southern Growth Policies Board’s 2010 Innovator Award winner, which recognized its ability to identify and build on community assets, promote entrepreneurship and new business development, and collaborate on regional issues. Creativity can affect and infect large numbers of people and businesses. In the past, many employers valued conventional work habits over ideas, and the unconventional worker was penalized. Today, the new fastest growth sectors need and want creative people, and they are restructuring the workplace to accommodate them. mCe Creativity also appeals to young people, both as it is expressed and exposed in the amenities available in the community and in the social environment. Those that are mobile often choose locations based on such amenities and they need to be made aware of what Mississippi has to offer. Finally, the effects of the creative economy extend across many other sectors of the economy, from agriculture and furniture to automobiles and telecommunications. The most obvious intersect is with tourism, but the application of artisans to farmers, auto or furniture designers to each other, landscaping to construction, creativity to research, and music to religion put art and design at the heart of those sectors. Their success depends heavily on their access to and use of creative talent. The state is fortunate to have an arts commission that works closely with and supports artists across the state, an economic development agency that recognizes the importance of creativity to its goals, and an extensive arts program in the elementary schools. The areas that are still most in need of strengthening are higher education in applied arts and design, the application of design in manufacturing, more accessible and relevant business support for microenterprises, and fuller integration of the arts with technology. Mississippi Arts Commission, WSI Summer Institute 42 mCe mississippi’s creative economy Appendix A. Regional Distribution of Creative Activity in Mississippi The Capital/River region, the most populous region of the state, has the largest number of quantifiable jobs in creative enterprises, more than 11,000 workers, which represents about three percent of its workforce. The two largest sectors in this tourism region are design, and literary and publishing, which together account for just more than half of the employment in creative enterprises within the region. Figure 1: Employment in Creative Enterprises by Tourism Region 15.1% 16 13.4% 14 10.9% 2008 jobs per 1,000 people 12 10 8.6% 8 6.2% 6 4 2 0 Capital/River Coastal Hills Pines Delta Literary firms and businesses related to publishing dominate employment in most of the regions in Mississippi, but they appear to be most important to the Hills. The Hills’ creative economy has 38 percent of the jobs in the literary and publishing sector, primarily in the industries involved in commercial printing. While employment numbers are important in grasping the size of the creative economy, the total number of jobs do not identify areas of specialization. Table 2 details areas of the creative economy in which each region has a concentration of employment compared to the nation. The numbers are based only on the aggregation of sectors by industry classifications that are designated as “creative.” They do not include the creative enterprises discovered through in-depth, company by company reviews and added to the totals since comparable data are not available at the national level. Most of the regions do not display a uniqueness of creativity; however, concentrations of employment in the visual and performing arts, including crafts, are equal to or above the national average in the Capital/River, Coastal and Hills regions. Table 2: Regional employment concentrations compared to national average concentrations (location quotients) by sub cluster, 2008. Mississippi Capital/River Coastal Hills Design 0.59 0.76 0.55 0.62 0.47 0.28 Source: NAICS 2008 only, excludes employment in creative Film & Media 0.57 0.71 0.53 0.53 0.52 0.41 enterprises in other sectors. Literary & Publishing 0.70 0.72 0.56 1.09 0.50 0.43 The Coastal tourism region has a similar distribution of employment within the creative enterprises. Nearly 50 percent of the employment in creative enterprises is related to design and literary and publishing. Coastal Mississippi does, however, have a slightly higher percentage of jobs in literary and publishing enterprises. Heritage 0.57 1.53 0.45 0.00 0.11 0.34 Culinary Arts 0.73 0.83 0.59 0.55 0.90 0.88 Performing & 1.02 Visual Arts 1.20 1.07 1.07 0.86 0.45 Total 0.82 0.62 0.71 0.57 0.43 0.84 Pines Delta Source: EMSI, 2008 and RTS 43 mCe mississippi’s creative economy While this report has been focused on sub clusters within the creative economy that tend to stand out in terms of scope and scale of employment, there are some sectors within these sub clusters that, though less numerous, are important to note in discovering the true creative character of region. In the Delta tourism region, the culinary arts and film and media sectors did not exhibit high employment or significant employment concentration. However, within those sub clusters, employment concentrations for confectionery and nut stores, radio stations, and baked goods stores are well above the national average. The Capital/River region tends to mimic the specializations of the state as a whole. Integrated record production and distribution, media representatives, commercial gravure printing, cable and other program distribution, historical sites and direct mail advertising all have high concentrations of employment when compared to the nation as a whole. Dance companies have twice the employment concentration in the Capital/River region as in the United States. Design industries help to characterize the Coastal region’s specialization. Jobs in display advertising and drafting service establishments are most intense in this region. The Coastal region also has a great concentration in tradebinding and related work. The Hills tourism region has the highest concentration of employment in commercial gravure printing of any other region of the state, a concentration 17 times the national average. Integrated record production and distribution industry employment is five times the national average concentration in the Capital/River region, twice the national average in the Hills region, and also well above average in the Pines region. Appendix B. Trends in Creative Economy by Region The dip in 2005 creative cluster employment was not felt in every region of the state. The Delta, reeling from negative creative employment growth in 2004, outperformed the other regions in terms of growth in the cluster in 2005. In more recent times, the creative employment in northern Mississippi has suffered losses. The Delta lost more than five percent of the jobs in creative enterprises from 2006 to 2007 and continued to experience decline in jobs in 2008. Creative job losses of a lesser degree were also felt in the Hills region. Between 2006 and 2008, the Hills creative sector lost over 4 percent of its employment. All of the regions, however, were affected by the most recent recession and experienced slow job losses in the creative economy. To date it appears that the Coastal and Capital/River regions have weathered the financial storm better than the rest of the state, but the true effects of the Great Recession remain to be seen. Comparisons of each region against the State of Mississippi are presented in the following graphs. Employment Growth in Creative Industries Mississippi and Capital/River Region 6.0% 4.0% 2.0% 0.0% -2.0% 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 -4.0% Mississippi Capital/River Source: EMSI Complete Employment - 2nd Quarter 2009 v2 44 mCe mississippi’s creative economy Employment Growth in Creative Industries Mississippi and Pines Region Employment Growth in Creative Industries Mississippi and Coastal Region 8.0% 6.0 % 4.0% 2.0% 0.0% -2.0% -4.0% -6.0% -8.0% 6.0% 4.0 % 2.0% 0.0% 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 -2.0% 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 -4.0% -6.0% Mississippi Coastal Region Mississippi Pines Region Source: EMSI Complete Employment - 2nd Quarter 2009 v2 Source: EMSI Complete Employment - 2nd Quarter 2009 v2 Employment Growth in Creative Industries Mississippi and Delta Region 4.0% 2.0% 0.0% -2.0% 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 -4.0% -6.0% Mississippi Delta Region Source: EMSI Complete Employment - 2nd Quarter 2009 v2 Employment Growth in Creative Industries Mississippi and Hills Region 6.0% 4.0 % 2.0% 0.0% -2.0% -4.0% -6.0% -8.0% 2003 2004 2005 Mississippi 2006 2007 2008 Hills Region Source: EMSI Complete Employment - 2nd Quarter 2009 v2 45 mississippi’s creative economy Appendix C: Defining the Creative Economy The definition in this report includes 77 industries, as classified by the North American Industry Classification System (NAICS 30), that are involved in the production, distribution, and marketing of artistic goods and services. The definition includes only industries whose businesses are primarily engaged in the artistic community in the state of Mississippi. For example, electronic stores retailing mass-produced televisions, DVD, and game consoles are not included in this definition. Still included, however, are the companies who created the movies on the DVDs sold in electronic stores. Measuring the creative economy involves two major steps. Our team starts from the belief that the demand for goods and services drives the need for jobs in any economy. The team starts with a look at creative industries by using established industrial codes (NAICS ) to develop the baseline definition. The data are collected at the establishment level. Included in this baseline definition are also the self-employed who report their earnings to the IRS. A conservative approach is applied to the selection of the appropriate NAICS codes. All or most of the businesses in a selected NAICS definition must fit the creative economy criteria. It is this baseline definition that is used in comparisons across time and geographies. Defining the creative economy along with industry codes can be quite misleading as some businesses may not fall into industries typically thought of as creative in nature. Thus, the definition presented in the table below should be thought of as a starting point. When data were available, EMSI data were augmented to present a more complete picture of the economy. An example of this approach would be in the culinary arts sector of the economy. Using business directory data from Selectory.com and the Southern Aroma Coffee Roasters, the definition was expanded to include food processors, specialty restaurants and coffee roasters that fit into the creative economy. The Viking Culinary School was also added to the culinary arts definition based on employment reported to Selectory.com. Another example is the large number of public libraries that are typically classified mCe under local government. In this case, employment data was obtained from the Mississippi Library Commission. The design industry was augmented to include those manufacturing firms whose products are design-focused such as Viking Range and Peavey Electronics. Employment counts for both companies were obtained from Selectory.com. Selectory. com was also used to add in textile and apparel companies whose design and manufacturing processes fit the creative definition. This enhanced definition is used to quantify the true State of Mississippi creative economy. In addition to collecting data on industries in the creative economy, our work also involves a direct look at creative workers. The team captures the creative workers who work in creative industries on the industrial side of the equation, however, most creative occupations are found in other industries like government, accounting firms, and hospitals. To get a more complete illustration of the creative workforce the team reviews the staffing patterns of the all industries in the economy and the total number of creative workers regardless of whether they are employed in a creative industry. Creative occupations are determined by the skills inherent in the job function. Data used in this report came primarily from Economic Modeling Specialists, Inc. (EMSI). EMSI estimates suppressed data for regional economies in an effort to gain a more comprehensive picture of employment. Additionally, EMSI estimates jobs and earnings for all workers in the economy and not just those who are attached to an establishment. Because the number of non-covered workers (workers who are not covered under the unemployment insurance law) in a given area can be large, job figures in EMSI Complete will often be much larger than those in state LMI data. 30 The Office of Management and Budget assigns NAICS codes to businesses that use identical or similar processes of production. 46 mississippi’s creative economy Table C.1: Mississippi Creative Enterprises Culinary 445291 445292 445299 722320 Arts Baked goods stores Confectionery and nut stores All other specialty food stores Caterers Design 332323 337212 Ornamental and architectural metal work manufacturing Custom architectural woodwork and 541310 541320 541340 541410 541420 541430 541490 541810 541820 541830 541840 541850 541860 541890 541922 millwork Architectural services Landscape architectural services Drafting services Interior design services Industrial design services Graphic design services Other specialized design services Advertising agencies Public relations agencies Media buying agencies Media representatives Display advertising Direct mail advertising Other services related to advertising Commercial photography Film & Media 512110 Motion picture and video production 512120 Motion picture and video distribution 512131 Motion picture theaters, except drive-ins 512132 Drive-in motion picture theaters 512191 512199 512210 512220 512230 512240 512290 515111 Teleproduction and postproduction services Other motion picture and video industries Record production Integrated record production and distribution Music publishers Sound recording studios Other sound recording industries Radio networks 515112 515120 515210 516110 517510 519110 711410 mCe Radio stations Television broadcasting Cable and other subscription programming Internet publishing and broadcasting Cable and other program distribution News syndicates Agents and managers for public figures Cultural Heritage 712110 Museums 712120 Historical sites 712130 Zoos and botanical gardens Literary Arts & Publishing 323110 Commercial lithographic printing 323111 Commercial gravure printing 323112 Commercial flexographic printing 323113 Commercial screen printing 323115 Digital printing 323117 Books printing 323119 Other commercial printing 323121 Tradebinding and related work 323122 Prepress services 424920 Book and periodical merchant wholesalers 451211 Book stores 451212 News dealers and newsstands 511110 Newspaper publishers 511120 Periodical publishers 511130 Book publishers 511199 All other publishers 519120 Libraries and archives Performing and Visual Arts 339911 Jewelry, except costume, manufacturing 339914 Costume jewelry and novelty manufacturing 339992 Musical instrument manufacturing 423940 Jewelry merchant wholesalers 448310 Jewelry stores 451140 Musical instrument and supplies stores 453920 Art dealers 541921 Photography studios, portrait 611610 Fine arts schools 47 mCe mississippi’s creative economy 711110 711120 711130 711190 711310 711320 711510 Theater companies and dinner theaters Dance companies Musical groups and artists Other performing arts companies Promoters with facilities Promoters without facilities Independent artists, writers, and performers* *Distributed throughout. Designers 17-1011 17-1012 17-3011 27-1021 27-1022 27-1023 27-1024 27-1025 27-1027 27-1029 Table C.2: Mississippi Creative Occupations Artists 27-1011 27-1012 27-1013 27-1014 27-1019 27-2011 27-2012 27-2031 27-2032 27-2041 27-2042 27-2099 27-3043 51-9071 Art directors Craft artists Fine artists, including painters, sculptors and illustrators Multi-media artists and animators Artists and related workers, all other Actors Producers and directors Dancers Choreographers Music directors and composers Musicians and singers Entertainers and performers, sports and related workers, all others Writers and authors Jewelers and precious stone and metal workers Culinary Artists 35-1011 Chefs and head cooks 51-3011 Bakers Cultural 25-4011 25-4012 Archivists Curators 25-4013 25-4021 25-4031 25-9011 Museum technicians and conservators Librarians Library technicians Audio-visual collections specialists Media 11-2011 11-2021 11-2031 13-1011 27-3011 27-3021 27-3022 27-3031 27-3041 27-3042 27-3099 other 27-4011 27-4012 27-4013 27-4014 27-4021 27-4031 27-4032 27-4099 Architects, except landscape and naval Landscape architects Architectural and civil drafters Commercial and industrial designers Fashion designers Floral designers Graphic designers Interior designers Set and exhibit designers Designers, all other Advertising and promotions managers Marketing managers Public relations managers Agents and business managers of artists, performers, and athletes Radio and television announcers Broadcast news analysts Reporters and correspondents Public relations specialists Editors Technical writers Media and communication workers, all Audio and video equipment technicians Broadcast technicians Radio operators Sound engineering technicians Photographers Camera operators, television, video, and motion picture Film and video editors Media and communication equipment workers, all other 48 mCe mississippi’s creative economy Vignettes RED HOTS AND DEEP BLUES Stories of Mississippi’s Creative Economy mCe mississippi’s creative economy Table of Contents Acknowledgements 2 Introduction 3 The Thrill is Most Certainly Not Gone The Delta Blues Live On 5 From Brookhaven to Hollywood The Mississippi School of the Arts Creates Future Stars 9 After the Deluge The Visual Arts Help Bring Ocean Springs and Bay St. Louis Back to Life 13 University of Southern Mississippi the Arts University of Mississippi 19 Preserving the Past, Preparing for the Future Natchez Looks Forward 23 Fashionably Fondren! A Jackson Neighborhood Takes Off 27 Luxury and Revitalization in the Delta Viking Range Leads the Charge in Greenwood 31 The Word from Oxford How the Literary Arts Continue to Shape a Community 35 The Hot Tamale Trail Taste Treat of the Delta 41 Peavey Electronics Taking Rock N’ Roll Global 45 Pearl River Community College Helping Mississippians Reach Their Creative Potential 49 Red Hots & Deep Blues mississippi’s creative economy mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues Acknowledgements This report is a product of a joint effort among the Mississippi Arts Commission (MAC), Mississippi Development Authority (MDA), Regional Technology Strategies (RTS) and Mt. Auburn Associates. We wish to especially thank Malcolm White, Director of MAC, and his staff for continually sharing information and insights, and MDA Executive Director, Gray Swoope, Chief Marking Officer, Melissa Medley and the MDA staff for suggesting sites for the vignettes. We also thank the many people we interviewed at each of the sites for the time they spent with us and their candor. The vignettes were written by Dan Broun, Jim Lott, Jenna Bryant, Dana Archer-Rosenthal, Michael Kane, and Stuart Rosenfeld. Beth Williams was the final proof reader. Dan Broun, Editor Stuart Rosenfeld, Project Manager Regional Technology Strategies We wish to express our gratitude to the individuals and groups across the state that generously provided the photography used throughout this study. 2 mississippi’s creative economy 1. Introduction What would the American creative scene be without Mississippi? Imagine today’s rock n’ roll without the blues licks that still make up its core. Imagine southern literature without Faulkner embracing regional literary identity. And can we imagine a world that never had Elvis? But Mississippi’s contributions to creativity are not only in the past. In 2010, throughout the state there are individuals, organizations and communities that are showing how arts and design strengthen the economy of the Magnolia State. This report tells these stories in a way that portrays the full gamut of Mississippi’s creativity. Each story is based on interviews with many people, background research, and, in many cases, site visits. We appreciate the full cooperation and candor of many people across the state of Mississippi in helping us compile these vignettes. These profiles hopefully begin to offer a more complete picture of Mississippi and how creativity continues to flourish and have a real impact as we enter a new decade. In effect, the people, programs and institutions described in the vignettes represent important assets in the state’s creative economy. In some instances, these assets are well-developed and functioning effectively, both creatively and economically. In others, the assets could be more strongly supported and turned into even richer components of the state’s creative economy. We highly recommend that the vignettes be viewed as a starting point for further development. Powerhouse Community Arts Center, Oxford, MS. Tamales, Mississippi Delta Taste Sensation mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues In this report you will read about how: The Gulf Coast’s visual arts community worked to recover from the devastating hurricanes of 2005 Hartley Peavey took his guitar playing dreams and created a world-renowned company Pearl River Community College looks to expand its creative offerings Historic preservation contributes to the economy of Natchez Greenwood and fortunes were turned around by a creative entrepreneur A tourist trail brings hot tamales to famished customers The story of the Delta Blues brings new dollars into the state The literary arts thrive in Faulkner’s hometown of Oxford The creative economy contributed to the revitalization of the Fondren section of Jackson The University of Southern Mississippi and the Mississippi School of the Arts train the state and young people for careers in the arts. Chair Caner at work Street Musician Port Gibson, MS Campbells Bakery Jackson, MS MS Arts Commission WSI Summer Institute 3 The Thrill is Most Certainly Not Gone The Delta Blues Live On 5 mississippi’s creative economy The iconic image of the Delta blues is Robert Johnson standing at the crossroads making a deal with the devil to play the guitar like no one had before. So it would be cliché to say Mississippi is at a crossroads when it comes to taking advantage of promoting the blues to tourists from around the globe. It also would be wrong. With places like Ground Zero Blues Club in Clarksdale, the sparkling new BB King Museum and Delta Interpretative Center in Indianola and the Blues Heritage Trail linking sites around the state, blues in the Delta and beyond have moved beyond the crossroads to take a place on the main street of economic development. It wasn’t always this way, and indeed the thought of basing a tourism industry on the blues once might have been seen as impossible and possibly even sacrilegious. After all, the traditional blues were born out of poverty. Musicians sang about growing up in tough circumstances and often used their music not as a way to celebrate their hometown, but as a pathway to escape it. How do you attract visitors to that environment? In fact some people would prefer that you not even try. “Some people don’t want to promote the blues,” says Luther Brown, Director of the Delta Center for Culture and Learning at Delta State University in Cleveland, Mississippi. “These ‘blues Nazis’ say you can’t have blues unless we are living in poverty.” Signs, Signs, Everywhere a Sign In years past, people were making their way to the Delta on their own, and little was done to promote the area as a tourist destination. While there is a long history of blues festivals in such towns as Greenville or Clarksdale, most tourists had to rely on word of mouth to find local juke joints where blues music still is played or grave markers where legends were put to rest. mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues “First we needed better maps and guides,” he said. “If you come without a guide, then all you see is poverty. Second, we worked to publish a dedicated issue of Living Blues magazine focusing on the Mississippi Delta. And third, we put up a marker at Club Ebony in Indianola that got everyone excited about the potential for blues markers.” It was the latter effort that has borne the most obvious fruit. In 2003, the Mississippi Blues Commission was reestablished by the State Legislature, and one of its major activities was the creation of a Blues Heritage Trail. The Trail features more than 100 markers that highlight critical events or individuals in the history of this most American of music forms. The trail also features six markers outside of the state and Brown has a vision of markers going up around the world. “Eventually, we need to see markers outside the country,” Brown noted. “For example, there is a big blues festival in Notodden, Norway. Having a marker there would be a relatively inexpensive and targeted way to promote the Mississippi Delta.” Another exciting development is turning the markers into more than just signs on the side of the road. The goal is to have the markers become multi-media so that tourists can hear the music the signs commemorate. Brown and others have noticed a change in attitude about the blues that can be in part attributed to the success of the trail, although understandably it can be hard to measure dollars generated by signs on the side of the road. Then, to help promote the blues, a group of organizations and individuals formed the Blues Highways Association to formalize efforts to increase blues tourism in the state. According to Brown, one of its founders, the Association had three main goals. Riley B. King (B.B. King) Blues Trail Marker, Indianola, MS 6 mississippi’s creative economy “At first, local businesses expressed doubts about the blues trail,” Brown said. “They said things like ‘Why would anyone care about the blues. I don’t like the blues.’ Now people say things like ‘I don’t really like the blues but when I was traveling in Germany everyone was excited to hear I was from the Delta because of the blues.” The Whole Delta is a Stage As exciting as the trail is, the key to getting visitors to spend more time and spend more money in the state is ensuring they have something to do while they are in the state. Clarksdale, in particular, has worked to promote the blues. mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues The B.B. King Museum and Delta Interpretive Center in Indianola sits on the site, and actually includes part of the original building, an old cotton gin where King himself once worked. The museum, which opened its doors in 2008, has an ambitious aim. “The museum is the story of music, the story of civil rights, and the story of Mississippi told through the life experience of B.B. King and through the people of this community,” said former museum director, Connie Gibbons. “It is really a powerful, compelling story.” Exhibits are fully multi-media, and visitors are able to not only Oscar winner Morgan Freeman along with partner Bill Luckett opened the Ground Zero Blues Club in Clarksdale. The club showcases blues artists from around the country, and on selected nights you can see internationally renowned musicians return to the Delta to play. But, the festival circuit continues to be the heart and soul of the blues industry in the Mississippi Delta, across the state, and even across the Mississippi River. Festivals range from the oldest, the Mississippi Delta Blues and Heritage Festival in Greenville, to smaller events such as Bentonia Blues Festival. Large events in Helena, Arkansas, and Memphis also have spillover benefits in Mississippi, with tourists staying at hotels and stopping to visit museums and historical sites on the Mississippi side of the state lines. The sheer number of blues related festivals is impressive in 2009, from April to the middle of November, there were only eight weekends without a scheduled festival in the state. The festivals mean thousands of visitors who spend money on food and lodging during their stay. see artifacts from King’s musical journey but also to learn about the history of the Delta, in the 20th century, from the great flood of 1927 to segregation to the civil rights movement and the creative spirit that grew out of those struggles. Visitors are exposed to the beauty and intricacy of the blues through such activities as mashing up their own blues songs or combining a classic from King himself with a hip-hop track from Outkast or other artists. All of these activities are aimed at making sure that the blues remain a living part of American musical life. Although the museum is young, the economic impact has already been tremendous. Sunflower County, where Indianola is located, saw a 12.5 percent increase in its estimated travel and tourism expenditures in fiscal year 2009, the year the museum first opened, compared to the previous fiscal year. The museum is funded in part by a local tourism tax and attracts visitors from around the nation and the world. Within the first three months of opening, the museum hosted visitors from all 50 states and more than 30 foreign countries. The Original Guitar Hero At one of those festivals, you just might be fortunate to catch a glimpse of perhaps Mississippi’s most famous blues export, B.B. King, who was born in the little delta town of Itta Benna. But no worries if you don’t catch him rocking the stage at the local festival, a new and impressive museum is telling his story in a way that not only preserves blues heritage but also is serving as an economic engine for the region. B.B. King Museum, Indianola, MS 7 mississippi’s creative economy One of the keys to the museum’s early success has been the goal of its planners to make sure that it is a world class facility. Nationally recognized exhibit and architectural firms were brought in to make sure that the museum was a historical place that operated with a 21st century sensibility. It was not necessarily a cheap endeavor, but a key to its success was the extent to which the local community bought into the vision. Supporters of the museum raised $1.7 million from Indianola residents alone—an impressive figure for a town of only 12,000 people. Involving the community is one of the major goals of the museum. The museum is sponsoring children’s programs to make sure that the music reaches young children who otherwise might not have exposure. The museum sponsors after-school programs for elementary school-aged children that extend beyond the blues. “Blues are the foundation for all American music,” Gibbons said. “For instance, so much of rock and roll is based on the blues, so we don’t have to limit ourselves in our school programs to blues. This is what allow us to keep music relevant to young kids.” Shelly Ritter, who directs an older museum, the Delta Blues Museum in Clarksdale, which also operates a blues program for young people, agrees that the blues are a gateway to help young people understand the power of music. “I see us as preserving music heritage; it just evolves into new music,” she said. “I encourage it by keeping the roots music alive and keeping it viable. Like the kids that come into our program, they start new music and it is usually a rock band, but it is based on the blues licks they learn in the class.” mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues Indeed, Ground Zero took the deeper pockets of its investors to be able to stick through the inevitable growing pains that any music venue faces as it builds its customer base. The Museum is working to recreate Club Ebony, an old music haunt in Indianola, establishing it as a place where people can spend the day at the museum and return at night to see blues masters in action. Another challenge is making sure that the benefits of blues tourism flow throughout the community. Making sure, for instance, that local tour guides are given the opportunity to lead tourists around the community and to encourage visitors to eat at locally owned shops. Brown, for instance, who organizes large tour groups through his program at Delta State, always makes sure to take his groups to lunch at the Senator’s Place, a locally owned restaurant serving home-cooked meals in Cleveland. Brown and others would like to see more local businesses take advantage of the opportunities that heritage tourism offers. For instance, there are few galleries or places in the Delta where you can buy hand-crafted art or souvenirs, a missed opportunity to market to the thousands of visitors who are looking to bring back a piece of the Delta along with the memories of the music they hear. Despite the challenges, most people are optimistic about what the future holds for blues and blues related tourism in the state. “Lots of people are looking for authenticity and real stuff,” Gibbons said. “Mississippi can offer that in ways others can not. We’re in paradise and we don’t even know it.” Increasing the Impact All those involved in blues tourism recognize there are real challenges to making sure that blues and blues related tourism succeeds. One big problem is making sure there are enough places for people who visit to see music being played. “There are great musicians in the Delta and they don’t always have a place to play,” Gibbons says. “The biggest challenge is having live music where it is consistent. That is one thing that Clarksdale is doing. But it is expensive to establish consistency.” 8 From Brookhaven to Hollywood The Mississippi School of the Arts Creates Future Creative Talent Mississippi School of the Arts, Brookhaven, MS 9 mississippi’s creative economy During hard economic times when school budgets are tight, coupled with pressures to devote every minute of every school day to test preparation, the arts are often the first to go. Students are told to put aside their artistic talents for another day, even with the knowledge that that day may be put off indefinitely. After all, how many of us take time after a long day of work to act in a community theater production or write a short story? But what if your job were as a full-time actor or a full-time writer? The Mississippi School of the Arts (MSA), a residential school for high school students in the state, is giving young people a chance to not only experience the arts but to prepare for careers that contribute to the creative economy. Located in Brookhaven, the residential school serves about 250 students from across the state. Students enroll for their final two years of high school. They can choose to concentrate in a particular artistic discipline, such as dance, literary arts, theatre, visual arts, or vocal music. mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues studio. All this means that MSA is not for everyone. It is for those young people who truly are passionate about becoming artists or who want a career in the arts. “It is a hard long day and they have to want it,” Principal Jana Perry said. “This is not for someone who kind of wants to take an arts class. It’s for someone who wants to pursue arts as a profession.” “You Don’t Have to Be a Starving Artist.” Pursuing arts as a profession is on the minds of staff and teachers at MSA, and part of their mission is helping students understand the paths they can take once they leave MSA and eventually enter the world of work. Lights, Camera: Class Suzanne Hirsch, the superintendent of MSA who grew up in southern Mississippi, says that teaching students about the possibility of working in the arts is not their only goal. They need to teach the parents about possible careers in the creative economy as well. Of course, students do not simply show up at the campus and begin to take classes. Rather, MSA employs a rigorous admission process that requires students to not only pass substantial academic requirements but to have an “on site audition” where they show that they have talent in their chosen course of study. Looking at the audition process for the theatre course of study offers some indication of what is expected of students who want to attend MSA. The on-site audition for theater includes: “When I was in high school I didn’t even know the arts were a possibility as a career, because no one in my area knew it was career. We are trying to educate families that you don’t have to be a starving artist, the arts don’t have to have something you can ‘fall back on-’ this can be it.” One of the interesting elements of the MSA curriculum is that the school recognizes that teaching students about the arts is more than just creative expression. • • • • Performance of a cold read, and Performance of a memorized dramatic or comedic monologue (words spoken by one person in a play) from a published play (two minutes maximum). Performance of an adjustment (a change in a character’s behavior) to the original monologue. Performance of a movement based improvisation. If a student passes that gauntlet and makes it to Brookhaven, what can he or she expect? An even more rigorous schedule— classes from 8:00 am to 4:30 pm and then back to rehearsal or Mississippi School of the Arts, Lampton Auditorium, Brookhaven, MS 10 mississippi’s creative economy “We are fostering artists, period, and that is our mindset,” Perry said. “But then we start talking to them about what connects them to arts. A person may be in the vocal arts but he is being called to work in a medical profession as a doctor who specializes in larynx development. That particular discipline works with vocalists. So if you don’t want to perform for a living there is a whole business side of things. We help them make those discoveries.” Connecting with the Community MSA’s counselors work with students to help them explore careers and how best to meet their goals. One of the unique things about MSA is that students get such strong exposure to academics and life outside the walls of the Brookhaven campus. Students take academic classes at Brookhaven High School in science and mathematics, which are treated seriously. MSA test scores rank among the highest in the state. Attendance at Brookhaven High is just one of the ways in which the school contributes to the local community. The campus, located on the site of the former Whitworth College in downtown Brookhaven, is actually owned by a local group called the Brookhaven Trust. A local advisory board consists of representatives from the local arts council, local government and local citizens. The interaction between the school and the community is critical especially in a residential program, where students are away from their families for nine months of the year. But the residential component of the program is absolutely critical to the school’s success and its ability to serve students from across the state. mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues Excelling Beyond the School Walls One of MSA’s challenges is helping families and prospective students in these smaller communities understand how the arts can be a career and what a rich tradition the state of Mississippi possesses. “It is absolutely amazing, but very few people realize what a long list of artists Mississippi has produced, and we make sure students know that list,” Perry said. “We talk about what it is about Mississippi that produces the arts. And we want them to go back to their community and talk about their experience at the school.” “Our biggest challenge is getting our name out and not missing children who could benefit from the MSA. Maybe we get a student a year late, a senior says ‘can I come?’ and we say you have to be a sophomore. We’ve been given this opportunity by the State Legislature and I don’t want to miss any opportunity for any child. “ An additional challenge is the real budget constraints at the state level that threaten all public schools, especially one that is able to be so generous to its students by offering free tuition and boarding at the school. The school feels the pressure to justify its economic impact not only on Brookhaven but on the state. Given that the school only opened its doors in the fall of 2003, students who graduated from MSA and then went on to a four-year college are just now entering in the workforce. “People may not have an outlet in a smaller community where budget constraints are so tight they may not be able to afford to offer a ceramics class or vocal class,” Hirsch said. “That means students are not exposed to that rich culture in Mississippi that is already there. At MSA, we are just tapping into it and helping it thrive.” Mississippi School of the Arts, Brookhaven, MS Where young musicians excell. 11 mississippi’s creative economy Despite the young age of the school, there is evidence that the school is making a difference. For instance, in 2009, students graduating from MSA received $3.2 million in scholarships offers, which exceeded the $3 million annual appropriation from the State Legislature. These scholarships include offers from top national and state universities and specialized arts programs such as the American Academy of Dramatic Arts. The relative youth of the school means that demonstrating long-term impact is difficult. But the success of more established programs such as the North Carolina School of the Arts in Winston-Salem suggest that the future is bright for the MSA. The MSA is hoping to expand its arts curriculum. It began offering dance in the fall of 2009, and in the future it hopes to add media arts and instrumental music as concentrations. mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues Certainly there has been some exposure for the school through the omnipresence of that singular artistic medium known as “American Idol” in which MSA student Jasmine Murray was a finalist in 2009. While not every performer makes it to Hollywood out of Brookhaven they might just go on to become a world class ballerina performing at the USA International Ballet Competition in Jackson, produce a Tony-award winning Broadway hit or maybe join the long list of Mississippi literary giants studied in classrooms across the country. 12 After the Deluge The Visual Arts Help Bring Ocean Springs & Bay St. Louis Back to Life Chandeleur Outfitters, Ocean Springs, MS Bay St. Louis Little Theater, Bay St. Louis, MS 13 mississippi’s creative economy Hurricane Katrina was the worst natural disaster in the history of the United States but in the midst of this disaster, residents of Mississippi’s Gulf Coast turned to art—for comfort and as a way to make sense of the hurricane. “I often felt I was living in the middle of a Salvador Dali painting,” says artist Ruth Thompson. “Every morning I walked out and looked at the water and it was beautiful and it was as it was supposed to be and then you turned around and nothing was as it was supposed to be.” Slowly, things are beginning to return to normal on the Gulf Coast, and the visual arts are playing a key role. If they are not making things exactly as they were before, perhaps they are making them even better. In particular, two communities at either end of the Mississippi coast, Ocean Springs and Bay St. Louis, are emerging from the storm with a greater sense of how a community’s economic future can be built on the arts. Bay St. Louis Like many Bay St. Louis residents, Thompson grew up coming to the community from “across the lake” in New Orleans. Indeed, Bay St. Louis was home not only to many families with vacation homes but also to individuals who commuted to work in the Big Easy from Mississippi. The New Orleans influence did not stop with commuting patterns; the town became noted for its general whimsical nature, its funkiness and its love of the arts. mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues Thompson embraced the arts, both culinary and visual, through her own business. Her family opened a bakery downtown that provided homemade items to local residents while doubling as a large gallery to display local artists’ work. The gallery was one of 52 places in the city that sold art prior to Katrina and, like most of the rest of the 52, her place of business was completely wiped out by the storm. But, like most of Bay St. Louis’ community of artists, she didn’t give up hope for some day helping her community rebuild. The Arts, Hancock County was a relatively new organization when Katrina hit. Started in 2000 through the hard work of Gwen Impson, a transplant from the Washington, D.C. area, the organization started as an attempt to help the artists of the county network. After the storm, it became an organization steeped in recovery. Working with the Hancock County Chamber of Commerce, the Mississippi Arts Commission, and The Arts, Hancock County, an arts recovery program run by Thompson set up shop to help get artists get back on their feet and, in a sense, lead the charge of recovery for the region. The U.S. Department of Labor stepped up with a business recovery grant that made available to artists up to $5,000 in supplies to make or market their art. While the grants could not be used to rebuild houses and studios destroyed in the storm, the money was critical in helping artists return to their craft. Hitting the Road The next step was to find a place to sell the art. The Arts Recovery Group, along with The Arts, Hancock County, worked to create a traveling exhibition featuring local artists that would travel across the nation. The impetus for the show was practical, according to Thompson. “Mostly, my job after the storm was looking for artists to give them opportunity to sell their work outside the community,” she said. “Not only did local consumers not have money to buy art, we didn’t have walls to put art on.” Mockingbird Cafe, Bay St. Louis, MS Thompson worked with others to secure 12 shows around the country that let people know that Hancock County was still there and still producing quality art. The impact was substantial, with many local artists getting national representation and just as importantly a chance to hope again. 14 mississippi’s creative economy “One artist fell into a black depression after the storm,” Thompson remembered. “The shows gave him a reason to get up every morning and work.” The shows ran from November 2005, just two months after the storm, until July of 2007. But by then, the rest of the country had begun to turn elsewhere. “By 2008, the Katrina card had been played,” Thompson said. “People didn’t understand that we were still in recovery mode. They said “c’mon, it has been two years, get over it.’” “Arts are really at the center of the recovery” Of course, people with this mentality were not seeing a town with many of its buildings still in ruins and its once vibrant downtown still in full recovery mode. Luckily, the local chamber and The Arts, Hancock County didn’t stop working to help make the arts a real part of the continuing recovery effort. “As an economic development professional, I saw arts as a visitor attraction component for Hancock County,” Tish Williams, the director of the Hancock County Chamber of Commerce said. “You need something besides the beach to keep people coming back. Hurricane Katrina’s impact on the arts allowed me to get the word out that Bay St. Louis was coming back.” mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues “Arts are not isolated, arts are part of the fabric of our life here. It adds to the soul of the community,” says Impson. “Everywhere you go there are arts. The local hospital has art on its walls. During the storm, they evacuated the patients, then the equipment and then the art. So whether you go to the doctor or the hair salon you see art.” While the town may take years before it is at the point it was prior to the storm, when it was named one of the 100 best small towns for art in the U.S., it is clearly on the path to recovery. Downtown now features several galleries that highlight local artists, and an estimated 17 businesses sell art in Hancock County. Almost as important, the rebuilt homes in the community hopefully will bring an influx of new residents who represent a market for the arts. The famed Second Saturday Art Walk is back and running, which, as one local resident put it, represents a “return to normalcy” for a community that had to deal with anything but normal circumstances. The Chamber provided office space for the arts recovery effort and, just as importantly, opened an arts gallery in its office, becoming the first arts space to open after the storm. The organization also became a fierce advocate for the arts as a focal point for the recovery effort, an effort that shone through in dramatic fashion with the reconstruction of a bridge spanning the Bay. The new glimmering bridge now features art-created by local craftspeople-across its structure, serving as a reminder of the importance of the arts to the region. The bridge was recently awarded an American Transportation Award for its innovative design. “Arts are really at the center of recovery,” Williams says. “This is not just starting at the Chamber, this is an entire community embracing art.” That community includes businesses beyond the galleries that are beginning to reopen downtown. Ellis Anderson reading at Bay Books, Bay St. Louis, MS 15 mississippi’s creative economy Ocean Springs When you are picking up pieces in the street from destroyed buildings, it might seem awkward to describe yourself as fortunate. But the arts community of Ocean Springs often uses the word “lucky” to describe the relative lack of damage they faced during those bleak days of 2005. The major art institutions, particularly the Walter Anderson Museum of Art, suffered limited damage, and the vibrant downtown was able to suffer limited interruption in business as a result of the storm. But while the high ground of Ocean Springs may have prevented catastrophe, it has been the drive of certain individuals who recognize the importance of the arts to the community and it is helping the town’s creative economy thrive. When you think of Mississippi’s creative legacy, you might think of William Faulkner or Eudora Welty in the literary arts or Elvis Presley or B.B. King in music. But for the visual arts tradition on the coast, it is the Anderson family of Ocean Springs, along with George Ohr, Richmond Barthe, and Dusti Bongé that came to mind. Shearwater Pottery, founded by Peter Anderson, has been in operation since the 1920s producing beautiful work and attracting visitors from around the globe. Walter Inglis Anderson is considered one of the premier visual artists of the 20th century and is the namesake of one of only two accredited arts museums in the state. An “unusual” and powerful asset The Walter Anderson Museum of Art is at the center of much of the visual artistic life on the coast. The museum not only puts on displays of Walter Anderson’s and other artists, it sponsors exhibits that travel to museums around the country getting the word out about the Mississippi Gulf Coast and its arts heritage. “Having an accredited museum in a community the size of Ocean Springs is an unusual asset,” said Gayle Petty-Johnson, a former director of the museum. “You wouldn’t anticipate finding a museum on the Mississippi Gulf Coast that sends out traveling exhibits around the globe.” The prominence of the museum in the local life of the community was one reason that Ocean Springs was able to begin the recovery process. The museum reopened quickly after mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues the storm, and staff helped the town put on an annual arts event, the Peter Anderson Festival. But more than anything, the simple act of the museum opening its doors after the storm was an important symbol to members of the community. “We started opening every Sunday and made it free for Mississippi residents,” Petty-Johnson said. “What we would see were people just sitting in galleries. We gave them a place where they could get some of their soul back. “ The museum staff also opened up their gallery space to begin to feature Mississippi Gulf Coast artists. “We also started showing living coastal artists,” Petty-Johnson said. “That had not been in our vision. Katrina gave us a new mission. There were no galleries in Ocean Springs and these artists needed an outlet to earn money. We began to show really the finest of our Gulf Coast artists.” The museum reached out to promote local artists during its traveling shows. Whether it was Sausalito, California, or Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Petty-Johnson would seek out local galleries to display gulf artists as a companion to the Walter Anderson traveling exhibit. This helped spread the word about the quality artistic expression still going on in Ocean Springs and throughout the Gulf region. “All of this has come to us because of the arts” The presence and outreach of the museum, and indeed of the Anderson family, is one that is felt by not only the residents but by the business community. “We’ve reaped the benefits of a community that was created as a result of the catalyst that is the Anderson family,” said Margaret Miller, director of the Ocean Springs Chamber of Commerce. “We’ve gone from a few businesses in downtown to more than 100 restaurants in the community. All of this has come to us because of the arts. I don’t even qualify that statement.” With a community so dependent on the tourist trade, Miller and others see the visual arts as way to draw visitors to the community and a way to keep them there. 16 mississippi’s creative economy “Arts are part of what makes a community attractive to doctors and retirees,” Miller said. “My husband doesn’t even know he likes art, but that is really what keeps him here and keeps his interest. Just the idea that it’s out there.” If Ocean Springs has artistic challenges, it is in the continued perception that it plays the genteel relative of staid Mobile as compared to the perception of Bay St. Louis as a funky refuge for the wondrous debauchery of New Orleans. Staff at the Walter Anderson Museum, for instance, expressed some wry amusement when recounting that when they try to break out and show more eclectic works, visitors complain that they straying away from the traditional watercolors and coastal scenes of the Anderson family. It is true that most artists find that the money they make selling art tends to be on typical coastal scenery pieces rather than on avant-garde fare. “If you really want to sell, your best bet is coastal sorts of things because that is what people want to buy,” local artist Susie Arnnager said. “People want to come back and take with them something that reminds them of the coast.” That being said, there are artists dabbling in non-traditional ware, who use their coast location as a way to draw inspiration even if they don’t necessarily feel the need to show a sunset in every drawing. “It’s the light that draws artists here,” Petty-Johnson speculated. “There is an amazing unusual light. When you are in Taos there is a different light or in Provence there is a different light. The same is true in Ocean Springs.” mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues City of Ocean Springs, MS “Artists don’t always understand the business side of the equation. Five of our young artists with a great following opened galleries but they didn’t last long. They didn’t like the business part of it.” There are community efforts to help artists become more connected to one another and perhaps use the increased networking as a way to improve their ability to sell their products. The new Mary C. O’Keefe Cultural Center of Arts and Education in downtown Ocean Springs features a wide array of studio space, rooms for artists, classes, and gallery space that give local artists a place to convene with their colleagues, create new pieces and show their work to the wider community. The 26,000 square foot converted school will serve as a centerpiece as the town continues to promote itself as not only an artistic destination for tourists but as a center of creative activity for permanent residents. Need to highlight the success of Arts Means Business and its origins in the Gulf Coast. Together They Stand Another challenge facing Ocean Springs is making sure that all business leaders understand the importance of the arts to the future of the community. Miller says that although she has great cooperation from elected officials, “there is the process of educating people about the importance of the arts. I am not sure those involved in economic development are aware of the connection between the arts and the economy. I want them to understand.” But it’s not enough for economic development professionals to understand the connection between art and business. Artists themselves need assistance with the business aspects of creativity. “It is a tough road for artists financially,” Miller pointed out. One common thread between the towns on either end of the coast is that bringing artists together is at the core of their redevelopment. Both Ocean Springs and Bay St. Louis have relied, and will continue to depend, on the community-focused arts economy to rebuild after the devastation wrought by Hurricane Katrina. “Everybody understands that for the Bay to recover completely we have to work together,” said Ruth Thompson. “No one organization can do it alone. It has to come from artists themselves. An arts organization doesn’t make this community, artists do.” 17 University of Southern Mississippi the Arts University of Mississippi Univeristy of Southern Mississippi 19 mississippi’s creative economy On the football field, Brett Favre calls the plays. But did he ever play a part in a play in a theatre production during his time at the University of Southern Mississippi? He holds numerous National Football League records, but has he ever recorded an album? Favre might be the most notable alumni of the school in recent decades, but he is not the only talent to pass through its gates. At Southern Miss, high-quality arts programs are cultivating the next generation of the state’s artistic talent. Southern Miss is one of only 24 schools in the country to be accredited in all four areas of higher education in the arts: dance, music, theatre, and visual arts. Accreditation speaks to the rigorous quality of arts education at the university but also hints at the comprehensiveness of the arts education that the school offers. The list of degrees and specializations available to students is exhaustive. Through the departments of arts and design, music, and theatre and dance, Southern Miss offers more than a dozen bachelor degrees and two dozen master degrees, as well as doctoral degrees in music. This diverse offering includes nationally distinguished programs and courses of study available at very few universities in the state and country. Examples, include the undergraduate curricula in sculpture and design, the master of fine arts degrees in theatre, bachelor of science degrees in the entertainment industry, and the doctoral degrees in music education and music performance. Southern Miss dance program A Jaw Dropping Experience Perhaps the most important element of preparation for a career in the arts is performance. For students in the theatre department at Southern Miss, the personalized classroom training they receive is enhanced by the performance opportunities afforded by the eclectic season of productions that the Department of Theatre and Dance puts on every year. For 2009-2010, mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues the playbill spanned from Shakespeare to contemporary regional humor and edgy contemporary drama, with stops along the way for musical theater. Added to this variety in productions is the chance for students to work as paid actors for the university’s Southern Arena Theatre, a summer repertory program that puts on three performances each summer and just completed its 33rd season. The icing on the cake? A state-of-the-art facility dedicated in 2000 that includes three performance spaces ranging from 70275 seats, rehearsal spaces, design studios (including a computer-assisted design lab), and faculty offices. Lou Rackoff, Director of the Theatre and Dance Department, spent most of his career as a professional actor and director and still remembers his first encounter with the department’s facility when he arrived as a visiting guest artist. “When I walked in, my jaw dropped to the floor,” he said. “It’s an unpretentious but well-designed building…a facility that most regional theatres would be jealous of.” The advantage to this facility, said Rackoff, is that “students have the chance to work at a very high level”—and this pays off for them when they graduate. Most students leave the state to pursue graduate studies or internships and employment as working actors in cities across the country, from Atlanta to Los Angeles. Like theatre students, the university’s music students, who number more than 500, are able to hone their professional skills before they graduate. The School of Music puts on approximately 400 concerts and ensemble performances a year and all students in the program are required to perform. Outside the university’s gates, many students find paid performance opportunities --at churches and events throughout the Hattiesburg community, as well as in the Mississippi, Tupelo and Pensacola orchestras, all of which are within a reasonable drive from Hattiesburg. The School of Music’s symphony orchestra, comprised of between 70 and 90 students and now in its 89th season, performs between six and eight concerts a year to audiences of around 1,000 people. Over the years, symphony members have had the chance to interact with the impressive list of world-class talent that has visited the school--from classical stars like Placido Domingo and Yo-Yo Ma, to Ray Charles and Patti LaBelle. For this reason, the School of Music has adopted the motto “Bringing the World to Mississippi,” which was originally coined by one of the school’s many international students. 20 mississippi’s creative economy Making Records Operating out of another corner of the School of Music is the Entertainment Industry program, the university’s fastest-growing major. The program started approximately five years ago as an emphasis option within the music major. Today, the program has more than 150 majors in its two tracks, entertainment management or production, and the curriculum includes courses in everything from accounting to live music production. Darko Velichkovski, the former director of the Mississippi Orchestra, was brought to Southern Miss to create the entertainment industry curriculum. To him, one of the most significant elements of the program is that it attracts students who might not have otherwise gone to college, and provides them with a college education that goes beyond the vocational skills they could receive at the private technical institutes that offer specialized training in elements of music production. Another draw of the program is what Velichkovski describes as the chance to “put your hands on something for real:” South City Records. About three years ago a group of students and two professors came together to create this company as a means of providing students with hands-on experience in all facets of the music production process: pre-production, production, mixing, and advertising. Today, South City Records is registered with the state as a tax-paying corporation and serves as an umbrella company for five different student-run record labels. The initial financing came from the small group of students and professors who launched the label three years ago. The company now has become self-sustaining: proceeds from the sales of initial production runs are put back into the company to pay for production of new albums and more additional production runs. The labels, which cover the hip hop/R&B, country/bluegrass, rock, singer/songwriter and blues genres, each have their own talent, business and marketing functions and are continually identifying and signing local and regional talent. So far, South City Records has released several eclectic compilation albums that showcase musical talent from throughout Mississippi, and several more are in the works. The label is creating opportunities for new and established local and international artists: from former Nashville artist Jacky Jack White, who mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues The Entertainment Industry Program, Univeristy of Southern Mississippi signed with the label upon retiring to a town outside of Meridian, to Omar, a recent gradate of Southern Miss who sings traditional Latin American bohemian ballads and is the first artist signed to the new Latin music label that the company is developing. The diverse talent that South City Records showcases is not a happy coincidence. Rather, it is the logical embodiment of Mississippi’s rich musical heritage and the continuing influence of this tradition. As Velichkovski says, even the alternative rock music scene in Mississippi is “all mixed up with the sticky, humid, blues thing” and this diversity is also the key to the record label’s future success. “We do feel that we are uniquely positioned. We are in the cradle of American musical heritage... We are here at the source, surrounded by talent. I want the students to understand how important it is for them to position themselves uniquely [in the marketplace].” Many of the Entertainment Industry program’s graduates go out of state to find employment in New York , Los Angeles and Nashville, the country’s major recording centers, but the ones who do stay in Mississippi find a place for the skills they learn in the program--not only in regional music venues and casinos, but also in the broadcasting, public relations and advertising industries. However, Velichkovski has a vision of South City Records growing beyond being a student entity to being the first professional step for graduates of the program—a place where they can “earn and learn” for a year or two. Looking Beyond and Ahead Student talent alone, of course, does not sustain the vibrant performing arts scene at Southern Miss. The audience is a crucial ingredient, and by all accounts the Hattiesburg community is exceptionally supportive of the arts. In fact, Bill Baggett, pro21 mississippi’s creative economy fessor and chair of the Department of Art and Design, describes Hattiesburg as a “hospitable and inviting place to be an artist,” a factor that has played no small part in anchoring him to Southern Miss, where he has taught since 1983. “The interaction between the community and university has kept me here,” he says. In turn, his influence on both the community and the university is visible in the form of two large scale murals he has designed and executed—one at the university’s student union building and the other at the Hattiesburg Public Library, which is recognized as the world’s largest stainless steel mural. This spirit of support is embodied in the Partners for the Arts, a civic membership organization whose sole mission is to support the arts departments at Southern Miss. Founded in 1997 by a group of friends interested in promoting arts programming at the university, the group now has more than 300 members who raised $87,000 in the most recent year. This money is all awarded to the arts departments at the university through a grantmaking process. Barbara Carter, the current president of Partners for the Arts, describes the “enormous energy” generated by the university’s arts activities and attributes it to interactions between friends—in their homes, at their churches, at social events and soccer games. Now, the organization is trying to expand its membership to include people from the greater Hattiesburg region. Future of the Arts in Hattiesburg So what does the future hold for Hattiesburg in terms of the arts? Some see increased collaboration between the town and the university, others see Hattiesburg’s emergence as a regional hub for the arts, and still others see efforts in Hattiesburg as a means of drawing attention to the work of Mississippi artists at the national level. Susan Fitzsimmons thinks these goals are not mutually exclusive. In fact, she is contributing to several of them. A professor of art and a member of the board of directors of the Hattiesburg Arts Council, Fitzsimmons has spearheaded efforts to display mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues tion.” On the other side of the coin, Fitzsimmons is working with Bill Baggett and a New York artist to put together a traveling show of the work of Mississippi artists. This is an effort toward reversing the trend that she sees of importing art from other parts of the country rather than exporting it. Also in the works is the rehabilitation of the Old High School in Hattiesburg, a building designated as a Mississippi Landmark and listed on the National Register of Historic Places. The plan is to restore the building’s structural and historical integrity so that it can be put to good use. The renovated building is to include gallery space, and Southern Miss’s College of Arts and Letters plans to be a tenant, using the building for classroom and performance space. Though it suffered a setback in the form of a fire and faces significant financial hurdles, this project could come to embody the vision of greater collaboration between the university and the town in the arts arena. Lou Rackoff, of the theater and dance department, thinks that the population growth that Hattiesburg experienced after Hurricane Katrina in 2005 and other regional amenities—such as two hospitals and the nearby Camp Shelby military base—provide a great opportunity for the university’s arts programs. “We are trying to be a part of that [growth]….We think that our department, in combination with the School of Music and the Department of Art and Design, could comprise an arts magnet [for the region].” But in the meantime, the University of Southern Mississippi will continue to produce graduates with the skills and experience to compete in the statewide and national arts industries. In many cases, Southern Miss graduates will be at an advantage for the professional opportunities they have already experienced by the time graduation comes, and the enthusiasm with which students embrace these opportunities is telling. Velichkovski says this best: “[Our students] wake up eager. We are not here for academic exercise. You are building your life here.” student artwork at galleries and arts spaces around town. This is, in part, an effort to give students professional experience as exhibitors and artistic entrepreneurs because, as she says, “[there is] beginning to be more awareness on the part of the students that arts education needs to be entrepreneurial educa22 Preserving the Past, Preparing for the Future Natchez Looks Forward Dunleith Mansion, Natchez, MS 23 mississippi’s creative economy mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues In 2008, the National Geographic Society’s Center for Sustainable Communities ranked the top 109 Historic Places around the world that met the criteria of “populated communities possessing a historic character, district or dominant place.” In this formidable competition, which included Aix-en-Provence and Dijon in France, Edinburgh in Scotland, York in England, San Gimignano in Tuscany, and Munich in Germany—Natchez, Mississippi ranked number 40. The Society chose Natchez because it “has fantastic architectural heritage and the stories, of all cultures, to back it up”- quite a tribute to Natchez’s historical and architectural assets. The opulence of the cotton planters’ lifestyles can still be seen in Natchez today, and the area has one of the best preserved concentrations of architecturally distinctive antebellum estates in the United States. Many of these palatial estates are preserved, thanks to the support of civic groups and private foundations, and serve as important representations of Greekrevival architecture in the Southern style. Many people and organizations have gone to great lengths to districts include several hundred historic homes, the real number is closer to 1,300. These include 13 National Historic Landmarks, the highest historic designation given by the federal government. preserve these treasures, both for cultural and for economic reasons. But, before the assets and economic impact are outlined, a look at the history is an important first step. The History Human habitation of the Natchez area dates back to early Native American tribes, although it was the later Natchez tribe that lived in the region of southwest Mississippi for 800 years prior to the first European contact. Originally a territory of France, Natchez was traded among European powers as New World land became a precious commodity. In 1798, Natchez, and the entire state of Mississippi, were taken by the United States in an effort to expand the country’s western borders. Natchez became the first capital of the new territory and in 1817 was established as the first capital of the new State of Mississippi. Although the capital was moved to Jackson a few years later, Natchez remained a center of economic activity for Mississippi throughout the 19th century and was a major agricultural and shipping hub for a young nation. Historical Assets The scale of Natchez‘s historical and cultural assets, for a city of less than 20,000 people, is impressive. Nearly 80 sites are on the National Register of Historic Places, but because some The Natchez National Historic Park has 102,000 objects in its collection, with approximately 81,000 archeological artifacts and documents found in the Melrose Estate, William Johnson House, and Fort Rosalie. Melrose Estate, one of the grandest of the Greek Revival mansions from Natchez’s plantation past, is complete with historic furnishings and original outbuildings throughout the nearly 80-acre site. Since construction in 1845, the mansion has been owned by only three families prior to National Park Service (NPS) acquisition, which helped preserve the property over the past 150 years. William Johnson House, a small Greek Revival townhouse in urban Natchez, was home to a slave freed by a white planter thought to be his father. Johnson’s 2,000- page personal and business diary provides important glimpses of antebellum southern life and relations between whites and freed blacks. His home is presently maintained by the NPS as an important center for interpreting Natchez’s African-American history to modern-day visitors. The naturally fertile soil around Natchez gave birth to a booming cotton production industry. With its strategically important location on bluffs high above the Mississippi River, Natchez also became an important port for shipping the cotton crop to mills in the north, and its plantation owners accumulated great wealth. Prior to the Civil War, Natchez had more millionaires per capita than any other city in the United States. Monmouth, Natchez, MS 24 mississippi’s creative economy mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues The Natchez Museum of African American Culture, located in the city’s old post office, is another important historical and cultural asset. It contains photographs and artifacts that chronicle and interpret the history of slaves and African-Americans in the region, with a current exhibit of art from West Africa from where large numbers of slaves came. Prior to the Museum’s founding in 1990, some of the mainstream historical record projected the image of contented slaves and overlooked the cruelty of the slave trade and the museum helped set the record straight. The first Africans were brought to Natchez by early French settlers as labor for the growing settlement. That would eventually become the state of Mississippi. Just east of the downtown Natchez area is the site of Forks of the Road, the development of the Natchez Historic Collection, and its tireless work to identify and catalogue current and endangered properties, the Foundation has been at the forefront. In many ways, the Foundation is the conscience of historic preservation in the area, as well as one of its saviors. second largest slave market in the U.S. in the nineteenth century. The site became a refugee for freed slaves once the Union Army took the city in 1863. The Mississippi Department of Archives and History (MDAH) has been critically important to the preservation of Natchez’s historic and architectural assets, with projects such as the restoration of Jefferson College and the Grand Village of the Natchez Indians and its contributions to Natchez’s efforts to get all of the historic properties and sites on the National Register of Historic Places. MDAH also provided grants to building owners for façade improvements, and it helped Natchez obtain Certified Local Government status, an important designation for historic preservation funds. Staff from MDAH also worked extensively with the Historic Natchez Foundation in its early efforts to reclaim some of the neglected historic buildings in the late 1960s and 1970s. As one interviewee noted, “MDAH has been a lifeline to our preservation efforts. They’ve been there every time we’ve needed them.” Key Players In spite of an early commitment to preserve and protect the historical and architectural assets of Natchez, the city lost its way in the 1960s and 1970s when the economy declined and industry began to move out. The downtown suffered from serious neglect, and many of the stunning architectural and historical gems deteriorated. If it hadn’t been for the work of several key players, the city could have declined even further. Local policymakers in Natchez have long understood the importance of historic preservation. In 1954, the city adopted the first preservation ordinance to maintain its historic/architectural assets. Thanks to this ordinance, the town now has five historic districts, most in the downtown area. Former city planners, the Historical Commission, and elected officials continue to generate and enforce historic preservation regulations. Among the organizations and institutions committed to preserving Natchez’s past, a few stand out as key players in preservation efforts. The Historic Natchez Foundation was founded in 1974 to preserve and enhance the buildings and neighborhoods, an important part of Natchez’s history. As a time when the city was perhaps not as focused on protecting it historical assets, the Foundation mustered the will, leadership and resources to stop the decline. Through its efforts around National Historic Register designation, its support to home owners and building owners who need tax credits and incentives, its Since its founding in 1988, the Natchez National Historical Park has helped to preserve Natchez’s historic significance. The Park has a multi-million dollar visitor’s and interpretative center, as well as several architecturally and historically significant collections, houses and sites. The opening of the center marked one of the first attempts by preservationists to tell the full and accurate story about slavery in Natchez. The Garden Clubs of the 1930s were another of the early advocates for historic preservation and the first to bring in outside visitors to Natchez. Some of the revenue generated by the tours over the years has gone directly to homeowners, and the income helped their efforts to renovate and maintain the structural and architectural integrity of their homes. The Office of Tourism and Natchez Convention and Visitors Bureau (CVB) have been instrumental in making Natchez a national destination for visitors, conventions, and meetings. The CVB works with all the historic, cultural and events organizations to coordinate promotion and to enhance the quality of the visitor experience, and the revenue generated adds to the historic preservation income stream. 25 mississippi’s creative economy City and county leaders also have recently initiated a plan for restructuring and streamlining economic development in the region. This effort could enhance, among other things, the relationship between historic preservation and economic development. Economic Impact of Historic Preservation Natchez has arts, music, garden tours, conventions and great views that attract a lot of tourists, but as a local business owner said, “It’s the history, the culture and the architecture that is the core. Everything else would still go on, but without the historical assets, it wouldn’t be the same.” The Natchez Mayor’s Office estimates that roughly 700,000 people visit the city each year, many coming for the Spring and Fall Pilgrimages, Garden Tours, Natchez Festival of Music, Balloon Fair, conventions and meetings—but also for the sheer pleasure of walking the streets of Natchez and taking in the view from the bluff overlooking the Mississippi River. Again, the historical and cultural assets are what make this attraction of tourists possible. The impact of that many visitors is substantial for Natchez and for Adams County. In 2008, about 2000 people were employed in tourism-related jobs in Adams County, 15 percent of total employment for the county, and tourism-related tax revenues from rooms and restaurants in Natchez alone was over $1 million. The Natchez Historical Park makes a significant contribution to the local Natchez economy. In 2008, the park saw 232,470 visitors who spent $11,863,000, which contributed to creating 222 jobs and generating $4,416,000 in wages and adding $6,835,000 of value to the Natchez economy. The renovation and repair of historic properties and homes also has an economic impact with 1,170 people in Adams County employed in construction and specialty traderelated work by 62 firms. A former city planner for Natchez estimates 200-300 applications a year for permits to renovate and/or repair historically significant homes, much of this done by a group of highly-skilled mill working firms and professionals. They, in turn, sub-contract to complete work on homes and historic buildings including to a small mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues but highly-skilled group of African-Americans. Several talented craftsmen from these families have passed those skills on to their children. The economic benefit of the Historic Natchez Collection is also notable. The wealthy barons of the cotton industry furnished their homes with a distinct style of furniture and decorative arts that were quite elegant. The Historic Natchez Foundation secured the license for what became known as the Historic Natchez Collection. The Foundation sold the design rights to major furniture manufacturers in North Carolina and other companies throughout the country, which pay the Historic Natchez Foundation a royalty for using the design. Mimi Miller said that “at its peak, the licensing brought in $400,000 a year to the Foundation, which helped support our preservation work.” In recent years, revenue from the Collection has declined but it still brings in roughly $30,000 a year. The Future In addition to the work of all of the key organizations noted above, there are also several projects in the planning stages that will continue to strengthen the historical and cultural assets of Natchez. The Community Alliance, the city and others have been working on the Natchez Trails Project, a $3 million project funded by the Federal Highway Administration, the Mississippi Department of Transportation, and private contributors. Once completed, the trails will become a virtual “Museum of the Streets.” The National Park Service will also oversee a new project. NPS purchased seven acres of land near the Fort Rosalie site and plans to tear down deteriorated buildings, constructions, parking and walking areas, and develop a new set of interpretative exhibits on Natchez’s colonial history. Furthermore, several structures on Canal Street will be renovated and used for extended visitor information and contact sites. 26 Fashionably Fondren! A Jackson Neighborhood Takes Off Fondren Place, Fondren, Jackson, MS Photo courtesy of Frank Ezelle 27 mississippi’s creative economy mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues He feels the district has a “richness that is not seen in other parts of Jackson. What makes the community really unique is the concentration of artists. The artists provide an energy foundation that is not felt in any other community in the city.” A Break from the Past Fondren Art Gallery, Fondren, Jackson, MS Photo courtesy of Frank Ezelle “Fondren is a brand,” says Alison Hopton Davis,“Fashionably Fondren!” When Davis took over as executive director of the Fondren Renaissance Foundation, the community had become something completely different from the town she lived in years before. The neighborhoods of Fondren now exhibit art deco architecture, specialty boutiques and a medley of restaurants. The community is now an experience rather than just a place to live and work. Even real estate in the Fondren area has become easier to sell. Davis, also a real estate agent and architectural historian, remembers when you couldn’t put the word Fondren in a house listing. “The neighborhood used to have a stigma,” says Davis. “Now I can put Fondren on any listing and it is snapped up!” What makes the Fondren district stand out from other areas of Jackson is not only the architecture and unique shops, but the people. Fondren has become home to a large number of artists, painters, musicians and a host of other creative individuals. Local artists’ works are exhibited at the art galleries and many of the restaurants double as venues that showcase area musicians. Some residents believe the demographic and economic diversity in Fondren is a reason for the community’s vibrancy. Ron Mills, better known to those in the Fondren District as Captain Ron of the Fondren Express Trolley, feels the community is very diverse even in terms of the types of occupations people hold in the area. “You have artists, lawyers, glass blowers, and doctors all living in the same neighborhoods in Fondren,” says Mills. One of the oldest communities in Jackson, Fondren started as a large plantation owned by the Garland Family. Sometime during Reconstruction the land transferred ownership, and in the mid-1800s the 5,000 acres of land became home to a state hospital. By the end of the century the area was a fully functioning, self-sufficient community with a general store—namesake David Fondren’s General Merchandise and Fancy Grocery and a post office. Over the years, the community developed into a regional medical mecca. The community is anchored by large economic drivers the University of Mississippi Medical Center, a VA hospital and St. Dominic Hospital and is home to a host of medical practices and rehabilitation centers. Unfortunately, the community began to suffer as newer homes were built in neighboring communities. Over time, Fondren was left with a much older population and deteriorated housing stock. Crime became more of a problem and much of the commercial space was left vacant and abandoned. According to Barry Plunkett, president of the Fondren Renaissance Foundation, “the area was hemorrhaging businesses and suffering from decreasing property taxes.” There was also the belief that the local businesses were suffering from the ills of the local community because of the lack of foot traffic and deteriorated infrastructure. People were no longer coming to the community for their entertainment and shopping needs. “Fondren was not a place where people walked on the street after 5 or 6 pm, ” says Davis. Mike Peters of Peters Real Estate feels that the Fondren of yesteryear was not serving the needs of the medical community, a dominant force in the Fondren District. Healthcare workers and patients had to find other places to eat. The loss of businesses began to affect the surrounding infrastructure. 28 mississippi’s creative economy According to Mike Peters, the leadership at St. Dominic Hospital was a driving force behind Fondren’s revitalization when the hospital decided to invest in the community. About eight years ago St. Dominic made a $1 million dollar commitment to the Fondren area by funding one of the predecessors of the Fondren Renaissance Foundation, a community organization charged with preserving and revitalizing the Fondren community. Then the community started with baby steps. Residents of Fondren began starting neighborhood clean-ups. Businesses started to reopen. Traffic calming was installed and attention was paid to neighborhood lighting. Abandoned buildings were purchased and converted into mixed-use property. mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues Fondren Corner was one of the first mixed-use properties in the area, combining retail, office and residential housing. When the abandoned Fish Commission State Office building fell into foreclosure several years ago, Peters and his partner decided to bid on the property. Once their bid was accepted, the partners scoured the southeastern region of the United States to look for inspiration for how to renovate the historic building in ways that could ultimately help to reshape the entire community. Fondren Corner now houses retail shops, offices, studio space and 16 apartments leased to an eclectic group of individuals. Peters comments, “There’s no typical tenant. One of my ten- Lifestyle Development As a way to draw in new residents and money to the district, the former executive director of the Fondren Renaissance Foundation focused on the inherent strengths of the Fondren community such as the architecture and the prominence of long-time business residents, like Brown’s Fine Art Gallery. He believed a strong emphasis on creative arts and design in Fondren could help to bring the community back from hardship and improve the quality of life of the existing residents. “Lifestyle development,” or economic development that also strongly focuses on the social and recreational aspects of a community, is about attracting a younger and more diverse population to a community by offering a quality of life that fosters a more social and creative feel to a locale. This focus on lifestyle development helped to create the diverse culture that Fondren is known for today. Lifestyle development projects often involve mixed-use properties that encourage individuals to live, work, and play in the same area. ants is 80 years old and lives next door to a couple of artists. We also have tenants who work at the hospital.” Public/Private Partnerships Part of the success of Fondren’s revitalization has been the active participation of both public and private groups in the area. Collaboration between private entities and the public sector has proven to be fruitful for Fondren while providing the financial resources necessary to help preserve the history and culture of the community. In keeping with the community’s focus on the arts, most of these partnerships have revolved around rehabilitating historic places into creative arts venues that attract a diverse audience and provide a steady stream of property tax revenue to the district. When an old, deteriorated antebellum home on Old Canton Road known as The Cedars was in danger of being demolished, the Fondren community, through the leadership of the Fondren Renaissance Foundation and the Mississippi Arts Commission (MAC), came to the rescue. The Cedars, now a events venue and art gallery, was acquired through a grant from MAC and privately raised funds of $300,000 raised in less than 10 days. More recently, the Duling School, an old, abandoned elemen- Outdoor concert at the Cedars, Fondren, Jackson, MS tary school in Fondren, was converted to commercial space that includes shops and a restaurant in the old auditorium. Built in 1927, the Duling School was a large expense to the school board due to high maintenance costs and did not benefit the city by being on the tax rolls. The Jackson School Board donated the property to the developer, thus elimi29 mississippi’s creative economy nating the high maintenance costs, and became a 20 percent partner in the project, which entitles the school board to a percentage of future profits. The Duling School now houses several shops including a hair salon, an antique shop, and The Auditorium, a restaurant that also serves as a live music and film venue. mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues The Future of Fondren Fondren is also not without its growing pains. Part of the revitalization and preservation of the community involves the need to maintain the Fondren brand while continuing to provide affordable housing, especially to the artists. Peters says, “the community needs to be very diligent that [Fondren] doesn’t choke the creative class out and become more vanilla”. Peters’ main concern is the increase in property values and rents could potentially force some of the people who helped shape the community culture out of Fondren in the next 10 years. Parking has also become scarce with the increase in traffic coming into the community for entertainment and shopping. Alison Hopton Davis, of the Fondren Renaissance Foundation worries about running out of the financial resources that have allowed the foundation to continue to provide support for the community, as well as the free events. Many of the same resources have been tapped over and over again and could potentially dry up. More importantly, while community participation has been instrumental in reshaping Fondren, maintaining that momentum is one of the biggest challenges the community faces going forward. Fondren Corner Building, Fondren, Jackson MS Photo courtesy of Frank Ezelle 30 Luxury and Revitalization in the Delta Viking Range Leads the Charge in Greenwood Viking Range Corporation, Greenwood, MS 31 mississippi’s creative economy The scene. A large estate in East Hampton, New York. A couple sits in the living room just after Christmas. Trevor: So darling, where should we vacation this year? Celeste: Paris again? Trevor: No, no, the crowds at the Pompidou were dreadful. Rome? Celeste: Ugh, not Rome, the food at Alberto Ciarla is so overrated. Let’s stay stateside this year—some place where we can stay in luxury, eat a world-class meal, and definitely get those spa treatments you are so fond of. Trevor: Well, you know I do love my Pine Sea Scrub. Hmm, let’s see, great food, great hotel, well there also need to be lots of culture—you know a place to browse those book stores you love, take a cooking class at a culinary academy, maybe even the chance to go to a museum or two nearby. mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues The Art of Cooking—Viking Range Style Exactly what is Viking? If you ever marveled at the ability of a restaurant to get your meal cooked just right along with the orders of 40 other patrons dining at the same time, it often depends on a commercial quality oven range. Fred Carl, a former building contractor, believed that there was market for such commercial quality ranges in homes. And indeed there was. After opening its first plant in 1990 in a 35,000-square-foot facility, Viking’s Greenwood production facility is now more than 240,000 square feet. It not only manufactures ranges but other appliances both large and small, bringing a sense of commercial restaurant quality to people’s homes. A reason for Viking’s success has been its ability to move beyond mass production and focus on more intricately crafted items. Whereas many companies in Mississippi and other southern states tried to enter the market solely on price, Viking competes on quality and design. Viking ranges routinely sell for upwards of $8,000. Celeste: Trevor, are you thinking what I’m thinking? Trevor: Celeste, my darling, there can be only one choice. Both together: Greenwood, here we come! So maybe Celeste and Trevor are figments of an overactive imagination. But certainly the attractions of Greenwood, Mississippi are real and are drawing visitors from around the globe. While other tourist attractions are based on proximity to some historical attraction or some grand geologic formation, Greenwood’s draw comes from its commitment to the creative economy and, more precisely, because its largest employer, Viking Range, is one the most creative companies in the state of Mississippi. The dream of Viking’s founder and CEO Fred Carl, to build a dynamic, creative product in his Delta hometown has come to fruition and has served as a catalyst to create a dynamic place to visit and to live. In doing so, Greenwood shows just how critical creative enterprises and people can be to building the economic future of a community. The most serious economic times since the Great Depression, however, have taken a toll on Viking’s competitiveness model. Since the spring of 2009, Viking has been forced to lay off nearly 300 of its 1,500 workers. Downturns in the housing market have meant fewer people installing Viking Ranges as part of their new dream houses. But, like most successful companies, Viking is adjusting to new economic realities by introducing a lower-priced but still commercial-quality, highdesign appliance line called the Designer Series. Viking Range Corporation, Greenwood, MS 32 mississippi’s creative economy This more affordable line still depends on high-end craftsmanship but is priced with people in mind who may have experienced a change in discretionary income but still have designer tastes. It is a strategy that leads industry experts excited about the prospects for companies like Viking. The Washington Post recently reported: “While boomers and seniors are winding down their appliance purchases, millennials are just getting started, and their tastes are higher-end. As a generation that grew up watching the Food Network, today’s newly minted adults don’t see features such as stainless-steel finishes as frivolous.” mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues or the temptingly titled “Pies and Tarts Workshop.” For the more adventurous, the cooking school offers culinary weekends that are packages combining classes and the nights at the Alluvian. Doing Business in the Delta Viking’s success and prospects for continued success have been critical to the growth of Greenwood, not just for the amenities that Carl and his company have attracted, but for showing that the Mississippi Delta is a great place to do business. “When we are recruiting businesses, we use Viking as a recruitment tool,” Angela Curry, executive director of the GreenwoodLeflore Industrial Board, said. “Companies say, ‘If Viking can manufacture those appliances in Greenwood, then we can make our product there too.’” Curry refers to the negative attitude that many still have of the Delta, and the fact that Viking Range and its ancillary businesses’ presence in the Delta goes a long away to alleviating those concerns. “One of our challenges is changing the perception others have of the Mississippi Delta and showing that we are progressive and that we have progressed,” Curry said. Eating, Sleeping, Cooking and Shopping in Style Walking in downtown Greenwood, it would be hard to find anything but a progressive image. Viking opened the Alluvian Hotel, in part as a place to put up customers who traveled to check out their product in person. Now people come back on vacation to stay in the luxurious rooms, eat at the world-class Viking Range Cooking School, Greenwood, MS So sits Viking’s Empire in Greenwood. But while the offerings of Viking are impressive, something else is happening in Greenwood that is equally important. Other creative businesses are coming to town and opening up shop. Turnrow’s Books is one such example. Jamie Kornegay was working at the venerated Square Books in Oxford and dreaming of owning a similarly outstanding independent bookstore when he visited Greenwood. He hooked up with Carl, who helped him nurturing his business, and Kornegay opened a new bookstore in a refurbished building just steps away from the Alluvian. While the bookstore is comprehensive, it features Southern and Mississippi literature and an outstanding food section that attracts the foodies that are drawn to the cooking school and the Viking experience. It also benefits from relative proximity to Square Books and Lemuria Books, another independent bookstore based in Jackson. This triangle of strong bookstores restaurant Giardina’s, or perhaps try their hand on an actual Viking Range at the Viking Cooking School. means that national authors can travel to multiple locations in the state while on a book tour. Carl himself likes having a place like Turnrow in his hometown. The Cooking School, in fact, has become one of the area’s biggest attractions. It allows students to take short courses that feature “French Country Classics” a “Mardi Gras” themed meal “We used to go to Oxford for a good bookstore and now we stay home,” he said. 33 mississippi’s creative economy The bookstore isn’t the only addition to the cultural life in Greenwood in recent years. Several new gourmet restaurants such as the Delta Bistro have opened that not only celebrate the culinary arts but make it a point to utilize local farms, as mouth-watering menu staples such as “house-made mustard and honey-rubbed grilled pork tenderloin, served with a loaded baked potato cake and charred onion compote” would attest. It is all part of what Carl envisioned when he made it a point to base his business in Greenwood. mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues “We are selling the Greenwood Experience,” Carl said. “We are an epicenter for Delta Culture.” The expansion of downtown has another purpose beyond attracting visitors to Greenwood- the increase in amenities means it is easier for Carl to attract workers, especially at the executive level, to Viking. “It is a recruiting tool for many of our employees,” Carl said. So many highly-skilled people who may have bought into a preconceived notion about the Delta may have a different notion after spending a few days roaming Greenwood. People like Curry who are charged with promoting Greenwood to new businesses have fully embraced Carl’s vision. “When we bring businesses, we can take a tour downtown, and they can see a boutique hotel, a fabulous bookstore, and walk out and say, “Wow, I am in Greenwood, Mississippi!” 34 The Word from Oxford How the Literary Arts Continue to Shape a Community The Literary Arts Tradition, Oxford, MS 35 mississippi’s creative economy Though revered author William Faulkner has long since passed away, the literary arts are alive and well in Oxford, Mississippi, the town he made famous. While Faulkner looms large in the consciousness of residents and visitors alike, there is no shortage of literary talent in town today. Rather, the combination of literary heritage, a first-rate creative writing program at the University of Mississippi, and a number of unique institutions, has continued to draw established and aspiring writers to the town. mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues The result is a place where the literary arts are alive and well. In fact, Ann Abadie, associate director of the University of Mississippi’s Center for the Study of Southern Culture, puts Oxford in the same category as Paris and New York, saying “There are few places in the world that are so rich for new and aspiring writers and book lovers.” The Bookstore at the Center of Town In 1979, Oxford native Richard Howorth and his wife Lisa returned to Oxford with the intention of opening a bookstore after having both worked at a well-known independent bookstore in Washington, D.C. This seemed like a risky plan to some, including a loan officer who told the couple that the town’s residents didn’t enjoy reading, and representatives from the American Booksellers Association, who thought the market was too small to support an independent retailer. Nevertheless, with an initial investment of approximately $20,000 or less, they opened Square Books on the second floor of a building that Richard’s family owned on the town square. Thirty years later, the Howorths own three stores: the original Square Books, now in a different location than when it first opened; Off Square Books, specializing in used and rare editions; and Square Books Jr., which sells children’s books. Square Books is recognized as one of the nation’s preeminent independent booksellers, and Richard Howorth has served as a leader of the American Booksellers Association. Square Books, Oxford, MS While the Square Books family of stores seems the epitome of the local independent bookstore, with its location on the town square and its rotating staff recommendations section, the stores’ loyal customers are international. For about ten years, the store has sold books through its website. But even before the advent of ecommerce, Square Books did a significant amount of its business through mail order. “I have customers all over the world,” says General Manager Lyn Roberts. “Some of them are long-term relationships. They order books, and we chat, and I recommend books based on what they’ve read in the past. A lot of this conversation takes place virtually now, but in the old days it used to be through letters.” In this way, Square Books is not really competing with the giant, Internet-based booksellers like Amazon, but offering a very different and much more personal service. No Longer a One Author Town Perhaps more important, though, is the transformative role that Square Books has played in the life of the town and its literati. “It made all the difference,” says Ann Abadie. “Faulkner used to be the one writer in town. There were a few others…but really we were William Faulkner’s town.” Furthermore, the town had few resources to offer writers: a small library, and a less-thanimpressive campus bookstore that, according to Abadie, sold “textbooks, a lot of bibles, a little Faulkner.” Square Books, Oxford, MS 36 mississippi’s creative economy But times have changed according to Abadie. For one thing, its many individual arts institutions and their collaborative efforts ensure that there is no shortage of literary programming for people of all ages. For example, the Center for the Study of Southern Culture has been working with the Junior Auxiliary of Oxford to bring young adult authors to local and county schools and raise enough money to give a book to each fifth and ninth grader. Square Books hosts approximately 150 authors a year, and sometimes as many as three writers a week. Framed photos of hundreds of visiting authors line the walls of the store, and the ever-growing roster of one-time and repeat visitors includes notables like Toni Morrison, Allen Ginsberg and William Styron. These days, with Square Books’ reputation firmly established in the consciousness of publishers, many of the visitors are established authors on tour to publicize new work. But the full roster of visiting writers runs the gamut, including local writers and authors who are visiting the University of Mississippi for one reason or another. Also on the roster are many repeat visitors because, since the store’s earliest days, according to Roberts, Richard Howorth has cultivated friendships with authors. Many of these visitors stay with the Howorths rather than check into a hotel. In this vein, Roberts acknowledges the role that Square Books has played in recognizing and championing emerging literary talent, though she makes it clear that she would never attribute any author’s success to Square Books. Nevertheless, she does note that Square Books was one of only a few stores to carry the books of John Grisham, a graduate of University of Mississippi, at the start of his literary career; George Saunders and Charles Frazier, author of Cold Mountain, are two other authors who Square Books championed in the days before they had achieved a national following. The store can do this because “we actually read the books [we sell],” noted Roberts, laughing. In fact, the love of books and reading is the common thread amongst the stores employees throughout the years. “That’s the number one attraction of working here,” she says, though also notes that the store has employed its “fair share of English or M.F.A. students, people writing on the side and with various other literary aspirations, [including] people who’ve gone on to work in publishing.” mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues Town and Gown, Growing Up Together Around the same time that Square Books opened, the University of Mississippi launched its creative writing program, offering bachelor and master’s degrees. Since then, the M.F.A. program in creative writing has grown to be one of the nation’s finest, and a place for both established writers and students to cultivate their skills. The program was started under the guidance of Willie Morris, previously the editor of Harper’s Magazine. With his extensive contacts in the literary world, Morris was able to attract fine authors to come visit Oxford and Square Books— and, undoubtedly, Square Books has been one factor that has helped anchor writers in Oxford in the decades since. Since that time, Oxford has become a hub for what Wayne Andrews describes as “new South writers.” Barry Hannah, a prominent member of this group, was the director of the creative writing program and was its writer-in-residence from 1983 until his recent death. Other members of this group who made their homes in Oxford or studied under Hannah include Larry Brown, John T. Edge, Jack Pendarvis and Donna Tartt. Once a month, two writers from the University of Mississippi’s M.F.A. in creative writing program give an evening reading at Square Books. In addition to providing an opportunity to have an audience, writers also find entrée into a supportive community of other writers. The University of Mississippi’s English and creative writing departments also have hosted any number of visiting writers. John Grisham and his wife Renée bought and donated to the university a house across the street from William Faulkner’s home Rowan Oaks. The house now serves as a residence for the Renée and John Grisham Writer-in-Residence, a year-long opportunity for emerging authors to live, write and teach in Oxford. Some of these writers have even stayed after their tenure, putting down more permanent roots in the town—no doubt in part because of the supportive environment they find there. “Oxford is a town that recognizes the value of the written word. People understand what writers do—the workflow, holing up to write…This town celebrates writers. Writers matter as much as musicians…they are like rock stars, “ says John T. Edge. Edge 37 mississippi’s creative economy is a James Beard Award-winning food writer, and the executive director of the Southern Foodways Alliance, an Oxford-based organization dedicated to documenting, studying and celebrating the culinary cultures of the American South. mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues promote their work…and their work is being supported through several avenues, including businesses like Square Books, Thacker Mountain Radio, and some of the town’s restaurants.” Literature as a Tourist Attraction Broadcasting Live from Oxford Fortunately for literary enthusiasts across the state and country, you don’t have to live in Oxford to enjoy the roster of talent that Square Books attracts. In 1997 Richard Howorth and two partners launched Thacker Mountain Radio, a live and unrehearsed radio show broadcast each Thursday evening throughout the fall and spring. Thirteen years later, the show is an independent nonprofit organization with three staff, and a house band, though it is still hosted at the Off Square Books location. Each episode features a handful of authors and musicians, as well as some crossover talent: musicians who have written books, or writers who moonlight as musicians. Guests read from their work, perform their music, talk about their work, or tell stories in front of a standing-room-only audience of about 200 people. In nice weather, audience members spill out onto the sidewalk, forming a crowd three or four people deep. The live broadcast on the University of Mississippi’s Rebel Radio station is recorded and edited for rebroadcast on Mississippi Public Broadcasting in a primetime spot. In keeping with the times, the program can be streamed over the Internet, making it accessible to a broader national audience. As with the visiting authors at Square Books, Thacker Mountain Radio guests have included well-known talent, touring musicians, and local authors. For a guest who is well prepared and knows what to expect, the experience is great because, according to Roberts, it is totally different from the radio interview format that authors are used to. Perhaps the best part for them, she suggests, is the audience: “It’s a great audience—they are attentive, forgiving, they send out good vibrations.” While less frequent than readings at Square Books and Thacker Mountain Radio performances, the town of Oxford hosts two annual events focused on the literary arts. These events draw visitors from throughout the country and the world, making literature a tourist attraction in Oxford. The Faulkner and Yoknatapawpha Conference is an academic conference held every July since 1974 and sponsored by the Center for the Study of Southern Culture, an interdisciplinary center at the University of Mississippi. The event draws scholars from around the world to take part in plenary sessions and panel discussions on a subject related to Faulkner; for example, the theme for the 2010 conference is “Faulkner and Film.” The Oxford Conference on the Book is another literary festival, borne out of collaboration between the Center for the Study of Southern Culture and Square Books. Richard Howorth initially approached Ann Abadie with the idea of creating something less academic and less focused on the South than the Faulkner conference, but that would offer people the experience of hearing about literature in the town Faulkner made famous. Now in its 17th year, the Oxford Conference on the Book offers three days full of speakers, panel discussions, writing workshops, book signings and readings, and a literary tour of the Wayne Andrews of the Yoknapatawpha Arts Council suggests that Thacker Mountain Radio is one of the things that makes Oxford’s entire arts scene unique—including its literary arts universe. “[The arts scene here] is multilayered…it’s not in the traditional silos. People are using technology to cultivate and Thacker Mountain Radio Performance, Oxford, MS 38 mCe mississippi’s creative economy Delta. Attendees include people from every imaginable part of the broadly defined literary world: fiction and non-fiction writers, poets, editors, agents and publicists, illustrators, songwriters, playwrights, and of course, readers. This year a small grant raised by the Center for the Study of Southern Culture will bring a group of school children and teachers from the Delta to the conference to hear five authors of young adult and children’s literature read. mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues Abadie believes that the conference has been a “great success from the beginning.” While some might see this as a biased view given her close involvement in its genesis, one testament to the event’s success is its ability to attract enough grant funding each year (with the exception of one) to make the event free and open to the public. And when the public leaves they have a better sense of how the literary arts are not just limited to the page; they can have a real impact on the quality of life of a community. Rowanoke, Home of William Faulkner, Oxford, MS 39 e C The Hot Tamale Trail Taste Treat of the Delta Hot Tamales served up from the Mississippi Delta 41 mississippi’s creative economy mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues If you want to know why all the fuss about hot tamales, here’s what you do. Take a trip to the Mississippi Delta – Leland, Cleveland, Clarksdale, Greenville, Greenwood, or all the way down to Vicksburg- and mosey in to Solly’s Hot Tamales, or Doe’s Eat Place, or Joe’s Hot Tamale Place (The White Front Café), sit down and order the Hot Tamales. They are served in bundles of three, but most of the Tamale business is take-out by the dozen, packaged in a tin can. When the Tamales arrive, you have a little work to do. Don’t eat the Corn Husks in which they are served, but carefully untie the bottom of the husks, spread them out, and you face some spicy beef or pork topped with delicious corn dough. Dig in! Aren’t they wonderful? You will be eating spicy shredded meat ed. “I know why daddy and them basically did it; it was just another way for them to make money, and pretty cheaply. And then hot tamales just evolved around here. I mean, you know, its just weird; it’s like barbecue in Memphis. I think people like hot tamales in the Delta – it seems like anyhow.” Doe’s Eat Place sells 250 dozen tamales a week. John Williams, Jr., owns John’s Homestyle Hot Tamales in Cleveland, Mississippi. He ships his tamales to other restaurants in the Delta and reports that he makes “thirty-five to forty dozen an hour.” These thriving restaurants represent an opportunity for entrepreneurs to earn a living, even in areas where jobs are scarce. flavored with chili powder, paprika, ground cayenne pepper, onion, garlic, and cumin—plus several secret spices. Chase it down with a cold beer and you will experience the taste sensation of the Delta – hot tamales. The “Art” of Making Tamales How Did Hot Tamales Find Their Way To Mississippi? Tamales came to be a Delta favorite sometime in the early years of the twentieth century when Hispanic laborers came from to the area to work the fields. The Mississippi laborers discovered that the cornhusks kept the meat warm until lunchtime, and soon everyone was eating “hot tamales.” After the harvest, the laborers went back home, and African Americans started making and then selling tamales because of the inexpensive ingredients—some shredded meat, cornhusks, corn dough, and a few spices. Next came the Chicago connection. After WWII, many African Americans from Mississippi migrated to Chicago in search of jobs. The food culture of Chicago included pushcarts and street vendors, and some of the transplants began selling tamales on the street, out of shacks, and out of storefronts. Every chef is more or less an artist- in working with his or her hands and adding a little of this, that, and the other, in what is a very creative process. This is certainly true for hot tamales. Amy Streeter Evans’ 2005 oral histories describe the creative processes of Signa of Doe’s, owner in Greenville, Barbara Pope, who runs Joe’s Hot Tamale Place in Rosedale, and Williams, of John’s Homestyle Hot Tamales in Cleveland. Signa’s grandfather emigrated from Italy in 1903 and opened an Italian Corner Grocery in Greenville. Signa’s father acquired a recipe for hot tamales from a co-worker at the Greenville Air Base in 1941 and began selling hot tamales to the neighborhood. Today, Signa carries on the tradition his father started many decades ago, ensuring Doe’s Eat Place is Robert Stewart, owner of Stewart’s Quick Mart in Cleveland, Mississippi, told Amy Evans, oral historian for the Southern Foodways Alliance, “We were in Chicago about twelve years. I sold tamales all over Chicago. I couldn’t keep them.” The Popularizing of Tamales in the Delta Dominick Signa, Jr., (Doe) owner of Doe’s Eat Place in Greenville, Mississippi, continues the tamale tradition that his father start- Doe’s Eat Place, Greenville, MS Photo courtesy of Hello Delta Photography 42 mississippi’s creative economy a cultural and culinary icon of the Mississippi Delta. When asked where the recipe came from, Signa responded: “somebody gave it to them… And they kind of modified it and took away and added a little bit and this, that and the other and that’s how they kind of got it like that.” When asked about the recipe, Signa first explained that he switched to parchment paper from the cornhusks because “it holds the tamales a lot firmer, and “they won’t boil out.” When Evans asked Signa if he would share the recipe, he responded “No. But I will tell you a funny story. When I went to daddy and told him I wanted to get married, he said ‘Now look, it’s fine you’re getting married and everything, mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues dozen shuck-wrapped tamales an hour. He credits his volume to his production process experience in manufacturing. He hopes to eventually standardize his recipe to manufacture and sell John’s Hot Tamales across the country. John is proud of the flavor in his tamales. “There’s flavor throughout. It starts with the shuck. I spice up my meat and then when I get ready to cook it, it’s already spiced up. You have to cook the dough after you wrap it. Williams stresses a “well-balanced flavor where you don’t have one ingredient overriding another one. Your taste buds tell you if it’s just right. And it needs to have a kick to it, because you’re calling it a hot tamale.” These three chef-artists are typical of the dozens of hot tamale but don’t tell your wife the hot tamale recipe because if she gets mad she may marry somebody else and they may go make hot tamales.’” places in the Delta. The idiosyncratic character of each of these family-run restaurants contributes to the mystique and fun of eating hot tamales in Mississippi. Joe Pope, the eldest of ten children, began selling hot tamales in Rosedale in the 1970s after a friend shared a recipe with him. When he retired, he opened Joe’s Hot Tamale Place, also known as The White Front Café. His youngest sister, Barbara Pope, who worked at his side for seven years filling and rolling tamales by hand, took over the business after Joe died in 2004. Barbara, her sisters, and their 97-yearold mother can still be found at The White Front, cooking and selling the same hot tamales that Joe made famous. It was just a week before Joe died that he shared the recipe with Barbara and her sister. In the winter, they make 160 dozen per week, but in the summer they make as many as 400 dozen. Barbara explained “most of the time I cook on Tuesdays and Thursdays—the meat and in between those day we roll the tamales. We cook, we buy the meat, we cut it ourselves, we ground our own meat.” Barbara is proud that they have stayed with the shucks, not parchment paper, because, with the paper, “there’s too much grease inside.” The recipe remains a sentimentally and economically valued family secret, remaining tightly held in families. Barbara has turned down several offers to sell the recipe. Promoting the Culinary Arts and Foodway Traditions John Williams, Jr., cousin to the late Joe Pope of Rosedale, grew up eating hot tamales at Joe’s Hot Tamale Place. He opened John’s Homestyle Hot Tamales in Cleveland, Mississippi, in 1999 after losing his manufacturing job. With his son and daughter at his side, Williams fills and rolls about forty This unique characteristic of Mississippi lends itself to be promoted as something for tourists to experience. In 1990 Frank Carlton organized the first World Championship Hot Tamale Contest, now held each July in Greenville as part of the Washington County Convention Center’s Food Festival. Each entrant’s hot tamales are judged on flavor, appearance, texture, and overall impression. The winners receive trophies, cash prizes, and the right to brag. In 2006, The Southern Foodways Alliance, part of the Center for the Study of Southern Culture at the University of Mississippi, in partnership with Viking Range Corporation, established The Hot Tamale Trail. It features more than 15 Tamale Eateries on its website and offers a guided tour of The Hot Tamale Trail for $75. Amy Evans Streeter, the Oral Historian for the Southern Foodways Alliance, produced 15 awardwinning Oral Histories by interviewing the proprietors of the tamale restaurants. The Southern Foodways Alliance, founded in 1999, promotes the culinary arts and, in addition to the Mississippi Delta Hot Tamale Trail, also developed the Southern BBQ Trail, the Southern Boudin Trail, and the Southern Gumbo Trail. Streeter explains that the Southern Foodways Alliance aims to “to document, celebrate, and teach about the foodways of 43 mississippi’s creative economy the south.” They publish southern recipes and a newsletter, host a website, and have published four cookbooks. Streeter says “We highlight culinary events to celebrate, and in some cases, help to develop new events.” Streeter believes that culinary tourism is a very important part of the tourism industry. “We help people plan a driving trip through Mississippi, which is so valuable to our economy.” mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues Gastro-tourism As the Baby Boomers reach retirement age, it is now these retirees who have the leisure time and the financial resources to travel and become tourists. And these tourists don’t want to go to Disneyland or another amusement park; they want to experience something unique. They are looking for an “experience,” not a breathless adventure. So culinary tourism becomes more attractive and more important. Those over 60 who go to New Orleans may never set foot on Bourbon Street, but they will chase down some of the dozens of amazing restaurants. If a tourist comes to Mississippi to listen to the blues and visit antebellum homes, they want to eat well and sample regional fare like the hot tamale celebrated by Mississippi bluesman, Robert Johnson. Hot tamales and they’re red hot, yes she got’em for sale Hot tamales and they’re red hot, yes she got’em for sale She got two for a nickel, got four for a dime Would sell you more, but they ain’t none of mine Hot tamales and they’re red hot, yes she got’em for sale, I mean Yes, she got’em for sale, yes, yeah 44 Peavey Electronics Taking Rock N’ Roll Global Peavey Electronics, Meridian, MS 45 mississippi’s creative economy Few people have influenced the music industry like Hartley Peavey. His company, Peavey Electronics, is a leading manufacturer of electronic instruments and amplifications systems. The Peavey guitar client list reads like a major record label, with top artists like Shania Twain and Duran Duran. Peavey systems can be heard at the Sydney Opera House, the Grand Ole Opry, and many other international cultural institutions. You might expect a music industry giant like Peavey to come from a big music city like Los Angeles, Nashville, or New York. But for this global leader, home is Meridian, Mississippi, the city that actually gave birth to Peavey’s rock and roll dreams. It was a 1957 concert that altered his life. Only 15 years old at the time, Hartley Peavey drove to the nearby town of Laurel to hear the great Bo Diddley. Then and there something changed in young Peavey, and he believed he was destined for rock and roll greatness. The sound of Bo Diddley’s legendary guitar awoke this new passion, and Peavey felt his calling was to play the electric guitar as well as the man who inspired him. As it turns out, the aspiring musician was partly right. At the time Peavey’s father owned a small music store in Meridian and was wary of his son’s rock and roll dreams. It wasn’t so much that the elder Peavey disliked rock and roll music as it was that he had seen too many electric guitars returned to his store by parents whose children had quickly abandoned their rock and roll dreams. The elder Peavey Hartley Peavey, Founder of Peavey Electronics mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues tried to make a deal with his son. He could get an electric guitar as soon as he actually learned how to play the guitar. Hartley gave it his best, but his talents fell far short of his father’s hopes. Since his father would not be of assistance, Peavey knew the only option was to make his own electric guitar, and he set about crafting one with steel strings, a spare acoustic guitar, and some electrical wiring. Once the guitar was assembled, Peavey had to find a way to amplify the sound and get the same volume and quality that Bo Diddley was able to get. Using the same ingenuity that he used to make the guitar, Peavey went about the task of designing and making an amplifier. After weeks of experimentation, Peavey’s homemade amplifier became a reality. Although he did not realize it at the time, this was the beginning of Peavey Electronics’ success in the music industry. In spite of giving up his dream of performing, Peavey would help revolutionize the guitar industry and the sound of amplified and electric music. Peavey Electronics began in 1965 as one man’s attempt to create the highest quality product at an affordable price. In the basement of his family home, Peavey focused most intensively on the amplifiers. He “would build one amplifier a week, go out and sell it, come back and start on another one.” Peavey Electronics has continued to grow since its early days through an ongoing commitment to innovation, to creating new, cost effective systems that serve the needs of an evolving recording industry. In addition to the music industry, Peavey identified new industries where technology would be relevant. He realized that despite strong competition for music amplifiers, there were only a few high-priced products for public address systems that were growing in popularity. Peavey decided that his music amplifiers could be altered into a more affordable public address system. This decision marked a major development in Peavey Electronics, and it built upon its core competencies in making music amplifiers to meet the growing need for audio services in entertainment and other industries. 46 mississippi’s creative economy Peavey’s Impact Today Peavey Electronics is an indisputable giant in the industry. The company continues to produce some of the most popular electric guitars, amplifiers, speakers, electronic keyboards, and other electronic audio-enhancement equipment. The company’s product lines include several series of bass guitars, a number of different electric guitars, as well as microphones, mixers, public address systems, and amplifiers. It also produces accessories, such as cables, bags, straps, tubers, and speaker stands. The company’s impact and influence on the music and sound system industry is extraordinary. Peavey Electronics was the first to produce guitars using a Computer Numerically Controlled (CNC) machine. Other people thought he was crazy, that he couldn’t “machine” a guitar and get the right precision and tolerances. At that time the main competitors, Gibson and Fender, were making guitars strictly by hand. Nonetheless, using CNC equipment cut down on the costs of making the guitars while maintaining the precision needed to make a good quality product. Now, electric guitars are essentially made this way. Peavey set the industry standard. The company’s MediaMatrix system was the first computeraided designed and controlled audio system, and it has set the world standard for audio sound. The system is in use in more than 5,000 transportation facilities, theme parks, sports stadiums, and casinos. Peavey sound systems have been incorporated into the new Shanghai airport and were the primary system used in the Beijing Olympics. Peavey also has a new product line of software and others are in the pipeline. One program allows the consumer to imitate a range of different sounds that creates a virtual band. More than 2000 Peavey products now are distributed in 136 countries. And, in order to more effectively compete in the global market, Peavey Electronics has established an international production and distribution system in 33 facilities across the United States, Canada, England, and Netherlands. Throughout this period of explosive international growth, Peavey Electronics continues to maintain its international headquarters in Meridian. Peavey Electronics is the tenth largest manufacturer in Mississippi, with more than a million square feet of warehouse and manufacturing space. mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues Peavey’s Creative Approach Peavey has more than 180 patents for the design of musical instruments, audio systems and enabling technologies that give these systems such a unique sound. This level of innovation is a result of the process he uses to conceive of and design his products and the way the company approaches the market. As Peavey said, “We listen to our customers and what they want and need, and then we find creative ways to meet those needs in a timely fashion and at a price that they can afford. In order to survive in this industry, this is what you have to do. You have to build a solid foundation that gives you flexibility and an ability to be creative. If you don’t have that, nothing else matters.” Hartley surrounds himself with the best people he can find. He provides the spark and serves as the inspiration. He then brings in industrial engineers, product designers, software people, programmers, as well as mechanical and electrical engineers into the discussion. “They all argue about the designs, the electronics, the systems for building a product, and at some point, it all becomes clear. Basically, we come up with the products by talking it through, pushing the envelope and by trying to be as creative as we can.” An example of how this creative process comes together involves the dobro. Most dobros are acoustic, but Hartley thought that, like the guitar, the dobro could be an electronic instrument. He initially started on the idea of designing an electric dobro on his own, sketching out his design concepts Hartley Peavey showcases his products 47 mississippi’s creative economy and principles and trying to figure out how the straps could be configured so that the player could wear it over his neck (the way dobros are played). At a certain juncture, the process was turned over to his designers and engineers. They took the initial work and transformed it by adding a few key designs and structural improvements. The result was yet another product line in the long list of Peavey musical products. Another important business strategy for Peavey is vertical integration. The company designs and makes all it needs to manufacture and sell products in-house. Hartley said that he could have outsourced the production of some of the component parts of his amplifiers, but chose to develop the skills within the company. As a result, “we had to learn how mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues Given the origins of Peavey Electronics, Hartley Peavey knows the power that an early love of art and music can have in shaping a child’s future. And he believes in Mississippi. “People ask me why Mississippi and I say, where do you think rock and roll was born?” to design and make our own chassis, our own circuit boards, and eventually everything else in-house. And, while we thought it was a tremendous disadvantage… we discovered that it was the best that could have happened.” The Future In recent years Peavey has talked of challenges he faces running a design and technology-driven business in the heart of Mississippi. While Peavey would like to keep the company headquarters and manufacturing in Meridian, he is often forced to look outside of Mississippi to find qualified and motivated engineers, product designers, and computer programmers. Just as he demonstrated industriousness in the face of previous business challenges, Peavey has applied his own creative solutions to help build relevant skills among Meridian’s residents. In order to have enough skilled employees, Peavey helped establish a job training program at Meridian Community College. Despite his unwavering commitment to improving economic conditions in Mississippi and Meridian, Peavey feels that others in this industry will have to help the state create more of a culture of educational investment. He points in particular to state policy makers whom Peavey suggests must aggressively invest in high-level job training programs and skill development. 48 Pearl River Community College Helping Mississippians Reach Their Creative Potential Pearl River Community College Campus, Poplarville, MS 49 mississippi’s creative economy mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues The number of people calling themselves artists of performers more than doubled between the 1990 and 2000 census. Pearl River Community College is beginning to position itself for such a transition. The Fine Arts program at Pearl River Community College The school has developed a statewide reputation in athletics, especially football, where a number of graduates have gone on to play professionally. Yet within the state, with its emphasis and success in both athletic prowess and industrial development, the college has also developed an artistic side—through its fine arts, applied arts in design, and nascent film program. Investing in Fine Arts Pearl River Community College Pearl River Community College (PRCC), which can trace its roots back to 1909 when it was a county agricultural school, is itself part of the state’s cultural heritage and history. The college maintains a museum in the 62-year-old Hancock Hall that houses, among other things, Native American artifacts, a timeline of the college’s history, a dorm room as it was in the 1940s, and a room dedicated to the college’s music tradition. Even Hurricane Katrina, which decimated the campus, damaging most of its buildings, could not take away its heritage. In 1921, the college became Mississippi’s first publicly funded two-year college, and, a shortly after; it became part of the nation’s first system of “junior” colleges. The college’s main campus is in Poplarville, which has a population of about 2,600 and is only 18 miles from the Louisiana state line. Over the years PRCC, along with Mississippi’s other community colleges, has been a major force in the state’s transition from an agricultural state to one that is today home to numerous advanced manufacturing businesses. By the 1980s, the college was supporting the technology and skill needs for the state’s modernizing manufacturing base. But with accelerating automation and global competition, the region’s dependence on traditional manufacturing has diminished some, and many of the replacement jobs and entrepreneurial opportunities depend on creativity, either as a marketable product or an amenity to attract talented people. The college’s Fine Arts program, chaired by Archie Rawls, offers an Associate of Arts degree intended primarily for students intending to go on to a baccalaureate degree. About 100 students are enrolled in the degree program, which includes visual arts, musical ensembles, and theater. The college expects to break ground on the new Ethel Holden-Brownstone Center for the Arts in the first half of 2011. This new center, supported mainly by the will of former graduate Ethel Holden-Brownstone but also by the Mississippi Arts Commission should open sometime in 2012. The visual arts curriculum includes courses in drawing, painting and water colors, two dimension design in color and composition, and a special studios program that includes stone cutting, jewelry, and metal work. Once the new center is built, the college will add ceramics and graphic arts courses. Enrollments are way up in the arts. Instructor Charleen Null has seen enrollments leap from 67 students, when she arrived about 15 years ago, to almost 200 today. Poplarville has a large number of artists and galleries for a city of its size, but its proximity to the Gulf Coast (a half hour away) and New Orleans (little more than an hour away) provides students exposure to a large base of working artists and art markets. Null’s students range from high school dual enrollments to students in their 50s and 60s. Some have not completed high school and up to 10 percent already have a baccalaure50 mississippi’s creative economy mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues Television and Film Production An Opportunity Waiting in the Wings Students perform at Pearl River Community College ate degree. Most transfer into four-year fine arts programs at Delta State University, Mississippi State University, and the University of Mississippi, and some leave the state. Those that don’t transfer to fine arts move into computer graphics, photography, or the ever-popular teaching career. The musical ensemble programs are also quite popular. But with an open enrollment policy, attrition in music is high over the course of the program and only about half complete their baccalaureate—generally because their expectations were unrealistic. Applicants may have sung in a church choir or school chorus and been told to enroll because they had a nice voice but can’t read music and didn’t realize the level of academic requirements and hours of practice they’d face. Students have many opportunities to perform in the region, though students take part in three vocal ensembles, three concert ensembles (concert, march, and jazz), a theater group, and various other vocal, brass, woodwind, and percussion groups. These groups perform regularly at the school and in the community. The college lost its auditorium—located in Moody Hall, the oldest building on any two-year college campus in the state—during Katrina’s 135 mile per hour winds. Since then, performers have been forced to find alternative venues wherever they could, including chapels and cafes. The vast majority of those in music or theater who do complete their education go into teaching in Mississippi in their field, not into performance careers, although some continue to perform and supplement their incomes. The fine arts are also an elective in most other programs, and about 1,000 students from other programs—many in technical and commercial fields—do enroll in the fine arts, as appreciation courses to fulfill their humanities requirement. This broader exposure can help build demand for the arts. Pearl River is the state’s first and only community college to teach film and TV production despite the new incentives to attract film companies to the state. The catalyst for this program, in fact, was not market demand but a program called “Healthy People Now.” The college’s nursing program and Ron Hague in the college’s public relations office partnered to develop videos for K-12 students on wellness. With a grant from a foundation, the college was able to upgrade its video equipment to produce 12 videos a year. Based on the enthusiasm and competence of the students working on the videos and the success of Louisiana’s film industry, Hague saw an opportunity to expand the program. If successful, Mississippi might be better positioned to work from across the Louisiana border and further develop its own film industry. Hague was quick to point out that this is not a program or even a course, both of which require state approval, and Mississippi does not have a two-year program on film, even as the secondary system is starting approved programs. This, in fact, is only the second year of this one-hour, nontransferable credit course. The ages of the twelve students in the program range from 18 to 29, including one student who previously had studied at the New York Film Academy. Most students interested in continuing their studies in film, however, will look out of state, to, for example, the University of New Orleans (UNO) or to other states. This year, two or three students will most likely transfer to UNO. The University of Southern Mississippi is the only four-year school in the state with film programs, but the community college course credits won’t transfer there. Some of the students are also likely to take positions in the state’s television industry. The program has working relationships with two nearby TV stations and is seeking support to cover living expenses that would allow students to intern at Mississippi Public Broadcasting, headquartered in Jackson. 51 mississippi’s creative economy Students will have only four credits when they complete the two-year program, but they’ll have about 24 professional shoots, a 10-30 minute thesis film, and summer work—generally in Louisiana—to put together a starter portfolio that can give them a foothold in the industry. PRCC also organizes a film festival in Hattiesburg, which takes place in April. Creating opportunities for students to build their resumes and meet others in the industry is critically important. According to Hague, success depends on connections and on “what’s in your resume.” Julian Benson is a typical student in the program. A native of Hattiesburg, he was drawn to the program after a home schooled education despite its lack of transferability because, as he said, “I’m a film major through and through” and “I want to make movies.” PRCC is helping him fulfill his dream by giving him needed skills and helping him develop his portfolio. The first year, he said, is learning what it takes to work on a crew, the need for teamwork and the realization that you can’t do everything by yourself. In year two they get into production, including a filmed thesis. Benson, at age 19, has a realistic sense of what it will take to make film a career, and right now he doubts that this can happen in Mississippi. He plans to transfer to the University of New Orleans and then go where the work takes him, hopefully in the South. He also has high hopes that the state will begin to draw more production companies because he would like to come back. Mississippi is beginning to realize that to get the most from its efforts to attract film production, the state needs a workforce with the skills, knowledge, and experiences to fill the many positions needed to make a movie—the grips, gaffers, best boys, stylists, and other crew members. The Mississippi Film Commission is currently working with the state’s workforce development program to develop programs that it hopes to pilot at community colleges in the fall. These short programs of a week or two would help prepare Mississippians for as many of the “trade” positions associated with the film industry as possible, such as the production assistants and grips that can be trained in anywhere from two days to two weeks. The effort is still in the early stages, as they look mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues for consultants and develop the curriculum. These jobs, of course, are short term and often free lance, so individuals who work in these areas would require a stream of movies made in state or they would need to be willing to travel to surrounding states to make a livable wage. A structured program that provided more technical skills, such as editing, and greater depth in how the industry works might provide steadier employment, but such programs are not yet available in the state’s colleges or universities. University of Southern Mississippi has the strongest film program, but it’s aimed more at filmmaking than the related technologies. PRCC’s President Dr. William Lewis believes “there’s potential to turn this into a full-blown” program….once the budget crisis is over.” Graduates can easily reach the burgeoning film industry across the Louisiana border as well as build Mississippi’s own capacity in the industry, but current budget constraints make it difficult to develop new programs. Expanding the programs to, for example, match those offered at Piedmont Community College in North Carolina, Howard Community College in Maryland, or Valencia Community College in Florida would give the state a leg up in building the film and media sectors of its creative economy. Hague is hoping for resources from private sources to be able to improve their equipment, possibly adding a better editing bay, which could take the program to the next level. Students perform at Pearl River Community College 52 mississippi’s creative economy Embedding Arts and Design in the Curricula Although the college has no occupational programs aimed at preparing students for creative occupations, many programs have courses that give students a chance to explore their creativity. The Business, Marketing, and Management degree program, for example, includes a four-hour course on “visual merchandising.” Students learn both one- and threedimensional design and, through the program’s two display windows, they create themed designs for various products. By the end, students have a portfolio of their designs that can be shown to potential employers or customers. Unfortunately, the program’s occupational courses are not accepted for credit mCe Red Hots & Deep Blues in the Interior Design program at the nearby University of Southern Mississippi, a result of a state policy that prohibits transfer of occupational courses to any specialized four-year degree program. Students in the Drafting and Design degree program courses also have a chance to be “creative” in their architecture course when asked to design a physical structure and in a “special projects” course. But for the most part, design is aimed at working in industry on prescribed designs. Finally, the college also offers the more traditional programs in fine art and communications and newer programs in web design and graphic design. Overall, the administration recognizes and values the contribution of art and culture to its communities and supports it with education—mainly as a pathway into something that requires more education. 53