Mv Pargi f - Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Transcription

PUB.LIC TIEARING .PROCEEDINGS
It is herebyinformedthat as per the Ministry of Environmentand Forests,Government
of Indi4 New Delhi vide its notification no. S. O. 1533 dated t4/0912006,& their
AmendmentPnblic Hearingwas fixd for the following project coveredunder CategoryB,
lrlls. vrai integrtted textile park ltd hasproposedfor expansionof power plant projec!
as mentionedin their requestapplication.
A copy of the draft Rapid Environment Impact AssessmentReport and the
ExecutiveSummarywere sentto the following authoritiesor offices to makeavailablethe
draft EIA Report for the inspectionto the public during normal office hours,till the Public
Hearingis over:
1.
2.
3,
4.
The Disfict CollectorOffice, Nadiad.
Jilla PanchayatOffice, Nadiad.
District IndustriesCentre,Nadiad.
The Chief Conservatorof Forests,Ministry of Environment& Forests,Govt. Of Indl4
RegionalOffice (West Zone),Kendrip ParyavaranBhavarUE - 5, fuea Colony, Link
Road- 3, RavishankarColony, BHOPAL - 465 016
5 Taluka PanchayatOffice,at Kheda ,Tal & Dist - Kheda
6 RqgionalOffice, Cujar* Pollution Control Board, Sardarpatel bhavanBlock B,Nadiad
Other ooncernedpersons having plausible stake in the environmentalaspectswere
requastedto sendtheir responsein writing to the concernedregulatoryauthorities.They
were requestedto sendtheir commentsto the regulatoryauthoritiesas under:
Central Governmentin Ministry of Environment and Forests,Crovt. Of India CGO
Complex, Lodi Roa4 New Delhi - ll0 003 as the matter falls under Category B of
Scheduleof the aforesaidnotifi cation.
The Public Hearing vrns scheduledon date on #h l{ovember 2011 at ll:fil
intogratedtextilepark ltd compound,village- Bidaj, Taluka& Dlst : lfteda
A.M. Vraj
An advertisementin English was publishedin 'Times of India' drted Olll}tzlll
in Gujarati "Divya bbaskar' on Slt0lZ0lll
and
Shri M.V. Pargi . Collector & District Magistrate, Nedied supervised and presided
over the entirepublic hearingprocess.
A statementshowingparticipantspresentduring the Public Hearingis enclosedherewithas
Ann'exureA.
A statemontshowing salient points highlighting issuesraised by the participantsand
respondedby the representativeof the applicat during the Public Hearing in English and
Gujarati Languagesis enclosedherewithas Annexure B end 81.
The eopiesof responsesreceivedin uriting from otherpersonsbavingplausiblestakein
environmentalaspectsandthe repliesby the applicantsto the sarneare enclosedherewithas
Annexure Cl to C4.
4
Place:* Bidaj,
D*e:4llll20ll
Encl.:
1.
J.Illriyadarshi
RegionalOfficer, GPCB,Nadiad
As a Representative
of the
Member Secretary,GPCB.
Gandhinqgar
AnnexureAbB, Bl andCl to C4 asabove.
M.v. Pargi
Collector & District
Magistrate,Nadiad
f
nuNexuge.a
AspertheMinistryofEnvironment,afdForests,Govemmentof|ndia,NewDe|hividesitsnot
no.S.O.1533dated14/09/2006
an{theiramendment,
Public
Flearing
plant
isfixedforexpansion
ofpower
- BidajTal & Dist- kheda
project
of M/s,Vrajinbgrate6
1.x1;le:park
ltd.located
atvillage
Thestatement
presentduringPublicHearingheld on 4thNovember
showingParticipants
parkltdcompound,
2011,11:00
A.M.at Vraiinteqrated
textile
Vill- Bidaj, Taluka
& Dist:kheda.
Sr.no
Name and Designation
Organization/Village
1
ShriM.V.Pargi.
Districtmagistrate& collector
2
Shri J.D.Privadashi.
Regional officer ,
GPCB
Sign
"**h'ut,,l,
Nadiad
?llrr,
-!s\tlev'
a
J
4
,
\3 <rx€ 51.
\>ss.ll
It
&q..t?
1.
'rJ
[0 trlovr
\(rtw,tcri-
f*
-
5
9n /, c.hrr. J,-r,/_
6
,
7
Vtsha vrt 6ltav qrnz4
8
-<.'5--+*,
$z
/
R. n ,.r -q \ c.^.-
( ,
(?.r\qo,
Suz-rt1
DrPzsll
>l
*,tuv*-,2-z\^J,---j
9
4/^**^
l0
t1
t2
Bo/,7)
(, u nrrl, k !,,,-a.iinu^4
Uil'U
9
<
6t,o-/w
6lrlth
'
Il H(
/
W
tc( 3 ':ir1
kl*?uA
Ii-,\in
15
14
"l?lh
1..2'..r, 1
\r
'r'r.0s-r
s" A"h".,x"A' o"11'
Kgnwbl'*''
nJ--<-:s
ftt.rJ
n
A
--
YJ
,l-ol2 \---/
'
//
ilos!
I
' l:AY,..tc.
L*o v>1
B )l l!["- [r
,
't
atrUt
-.\I
13
t4
trl-
I
tl o-.-.-
\rv-r'^-\/
kj*s'o
\
C
Jlau-r,-t'
I
/''
g{l*
b,
)* 7*1
L-.
#'
I^
*F
6\u".Flr-
'lo Vr"i I^l- \ea,[e]*r.r+J'$.J[r=r+
ffil----
Sr.no
t7
\G'-LR-M,
A,^,..-)
'
l
R,.l*\\/
1r
nM*'t4AIE-^/DrL'*
\1
SvapN ut1 paisL(nlr'rrfir ') sH 4^t'TT Sn t n r &r
Ph'fu\-
I Y,l\c@\Lol2
Sign
affi*
v
'sH fr)-tTL -eaLp4 A4
t-(.;sn"\
'
2-fi &Rcu" Dv&! r . P+&co+a s-o'.-Aal*^";Ja
q l
rLZ
2\
Hl^^vlL.,-,*n^
-e Ot I
r 1
l?,,J.* P N, g^4)^
A-.t-
fi-o. 2.fii
(uhln
A"r"<-49)
4 ^,r^ *ka'n-ot
2-14
/r
Lb
L)
)r
L\
]o
4tc<r
o, n(^, t r,0o[)\
Q,c^r4
{ \ tr rya/yV q(,t)4/,
>c-innlcr,l,
ft . f-L^rLt
AIJ îldA rv,
?2_ t/, K
oh,,**,t
.f- t< . /1,n.""*,-|
1t/
\+
tYtfr-wl
/
,
wt'[1 L
-sal 1
eoZ.l*
N- Ji.,J
J,&r-^lty
y'th'*-t
/Q4â/t*^\
n /our'r! ,
3q O**t
gL
p o l a\ cz).ay
) l-tt?& 4z {_rrt \ a, \,rtr-l
(-;\^
ct .\
.\,
\
\ C/a L[Y|.LL,r{,E\l!v\\-/
3 l &"*t-Al, /. NnJ,
0\-'l e
fu/
co).<r? A-f 7-
A*^
r \\rr
Q.,\ r^^-1.--,'
(d1yr,^rrano . {6P
-lL,n(Xtl
S rn PGJ .o,^^,r*k
, l
,*-
2+ 4yn ,-.)
W<{uFz Jr" z
5, nrl^-+L'.r--r
/@
il.-"l--
W-".
@x-"-*
'/vtt/
(gW
.aa
A.
Yg-"-^-;t
&r*
:9r
Sr.no
fl 2"Irl- 1we1"-
3r
3i
Lo uabtzzZ%'-J'
/Qazzz
h1
_i#"^d,\r^-,pÂl
hr^
ItJu n*,
h\
hr
o,'/-l2.qu'
3 0<ach "r"-",
A""*(
AA -rf c-$
o
.C, Qr{1.1l-
\rr
%L,:1.,qbnov1. p
(,j'rt lq'"ci l.9t
q
^.tXtq/ !rc^q\
h
Ib ,4=rl "- ^?u&rr=q S"-%ra-t#--q-st*--'\L.
\3
rl,
*]\*T\
'Ahunl
0a4..{c..
(*"ors.u^
/
rt
KvWt/(cz'rflrtt4
pt
c),{?.v\
I
^
.
f-^1
.*-/
"L/- nt1
\?A
sa' J"{ry"....J0^
e;Ao{
*
M
-@qd
ukyk
v^dw
v
l
.
r
I l4-)
11^^4tDy Skr dLEh
\g
,/?/nbo4
n
r /
r\o
\^ ['
AM
Vla
"viasYL
Qy
Sign
v
n
' \
lV-:
"''
,
l-/
6.6.-_c,t ,
f l 1 k * , 1.
W)
6t$*k'
Pl P. \r'c+-r-{
P1b,*
@1.<
-a__
.
\
O't tA W
61,ta-?/
a&s=^
'\
t
^. ,
lf,^.-.-1{
UA
o{Yr"
v{\\qr
[3qrlt€\et
K*^
fir-qn
v t
, A
I
04d,(
9*
!Ju
S:
hDotr,
tl ' iQ
. *LtL--/
L-
^94 l"(
*tl*vl
G.il"or
,'ffi
W
Sign
Name hnd Designation
Sr.no
,ta
q9
6r
(.t
(t
{3
rn r[/ (i 7tl la tcre)ye
*9ft1
OJ
nAqq
l'-vv
t-t1 Y
atagl
7r Le<I
lLt/ulq Y
J{-4
l^\l
9't t C
qtry1/
Ivr6? TnK
d llva
ft i *t 2.t '{\,
'tb-&rhra,
o lVJl
\J-1\ '*tt atv
t1'\\)
\
\'
i\
u-
t)tnciif
6y) f(t ptL/
\
L4 l) ".)
+i
/\
ff
EL
(q-
Y
".a..^\)*tzt\
vnlrr'l (
?Su4
(L-r,1 - *-
an l{(,!
d r f?*4'4L. *,,P-ob*
{1 /&-JlaQr;
Gl
,
/
c-tr $ov-,-
ri'>%
)>,qfl, r,r r,.lrr4.
l
Q>t
^ a.{---
r-rnf\Sf
l
Kn*l"-t
AW-
l.---
/w ,bo /,t
.r\\-No^
b
r "i-qJ\t $'A,f'
?1
Eu+ 04').2<V/ , 1 ( ) q 4
IL
l)..g-ott*J.,1
/
l
r/
>? f.,tpte:t"" (Jlr{^^
Dl Tvyloru WtÎ )
vf
YL
i l a
l \
litl lh
{3^'t"'r,
t'
Vork-il'Qct.**
(. n^|)uk 6"\ia
Tla,ga'-r:fo'
n
t?h.rre,lnlno)
t
l
-/t/Z
1
dTaI
e..Q-<r..,r--a
)..4-
\R>,1
P*#W
&
-tJ ^
7-4,y ,
i l , ^" \
G?
N4Z-
I
A
,
MLat
nrr*^\
il;b
I
S1-z(1^^"/v f,t [*,Ux.tfV<l-,,
vk
T)
.17*Ail'"t
r71<t\
/
t
L l/
-So)-frn .9cCfi
lu\r
ne"X-
Sr.no
&
f/^<.^
6)
M
(z
r3
zt;>
t / cttSq,l
--lt
r tnntf t^^-r,CA
f
,, \,
V\lrLuviob
H,, Y"11-6e-1r,,
*-,^)r
n *,-lE"
F.,fi]3
grD
d-z1t
l_/
-2+2
rx?orn
t>\--.-.r_,91
'1rt L4n)rary
9z
ffi-
q\
utZ
l-(J<-v
(ffi4<x
ffi\-
.Rz/t4Z/fL1
8id"6
st'J\>)n---2J
krb/{
\
V.O Qtt&t{;
m , L ,e e { " t '
6lr^t9
N-
Cr Aa<o-{'rArry,]
l-a-r
)
-2-rrr
crJ-s rl
0{l}<
.v\b,,
C1)+T
9r
4 rritz 4,061/'ttd zi z^
G{Ll"r"
6l ot
Vlt
Qrnnit
-*)rr,.-
9Y
bi ,)-^\ fl^
1r
fi
cr\a"""\ ' tz*fl,
)"t t\ - 2{ r?,- C{ S,JTI--
-z*^ t) ft',aI
k-a-I_t-q-
@a
Cr<\\'x-
.,r\,
$"..,r
\r- n ,n
Lt r .1.-.,r
qr
t c-n>{\,
,
f L-La<z\
.-\
\z-<-r-
-J--
^rilt*t
fu/--("-
Q.,tr{l cttQ1 aD161O1ii
W6'v
o).v.tf i.{ t N
$- p-". S .ftxltc'fl|{l.) u qovl L-{\"{1
q- {*n/b lazfrtv{
J ?LC
z-)hat.y%^/h
+Ac\
' - ^ ^ {. . n . . J
" r - .t'
l
^^'.-,,
jcr^*[)
,QPIT
Ar,.tl..(
=r-*}a{al-Lt_
rr //^/oU-' n/Jil
v) t!\v4)) 17""u^t
9r
^ât'4
sl ct\f \\k\
-1. r
<r'tl<t
,z'l--;
rs hdolT l<
T 1U i r - r9 -
7V r,l.srzt al,<brr8r
Sign
'#,tg
N,o"
4n"tq [4t U
erv-'
4-
-&
(w
6q"{
ttl
Sr.no
.
.
:
Sign
,
I
: /
.< nr
i \-v.4
kr* L[v. {po.,aa
l<sryu
fr/
\
Qi."Ll
.rl ,ryU*^J
li û4 "n. SalY.^h-
A,'&q
,,
\
flr'U. J"Atr'z;t<'
t.
ll2-
)u3
luh
(us
)r(
k r l
D lde:^
1c')
\/,l.u.lotnn.i. P . 0ntt.,0r.r,rl
I
-A qVF
dqt"
c/+
a
tst lc t r\
s\t.i
\
QI, r:^,
oYntK
6zr-fl *-bq
g/tll/
c.1q,/ 6-zttg/
s dot6/
tDg DiP\"
Yc{Yt
Eao 6n"v
Wf\
(
€eo ch.qrDa
tq7 Heu"\qkr4v.laf€(
tto
d^g},
Vq \Aê\^J
r+o Ap.b, *jI-*t'-lA/q^
t,
t+l Sqnkel Pq{.|
l t L \lo^tsoh o sl\r^lda
ll
\,/
r l 9 ,(auir el^sks;
(r-1 . P4 "
\\\
C-P(4
\rc-\ l \
1l c4
\,/. 4 W."qzL4-t-
./
z
w
bt/\il(
try J*5/"r
(-
t l
A^n@"
' Sutla-t'
F^r*l t 4"o,,
.U ',9o)ô J
+@-'
(w4
X,-{G4r
VU^<
U*,
a@-
+7(
\-....-J
ANN.EXURE -B &NGLISE}
pg Miryg"y of Environment and Forests(I\,!OEF),
Crovernmentof India" New Delhi
$.
vide its notification no- s o 1533 dst{ r+* ieei--cfio
aoa zuusequentamendments o
195(E)datd l9\anuary z}w,PublicHearing has
ben fixed on 4hNovemb er21tL for
lws Vrqi Intqrated Tsrtile Park Ltd for the exfansion
of IntegratedTextile park Ltd along
ytr trq 25}fw (Twenty Five)
Power
Plant
at
viltage v'e*r'
Bidaj, Ta
rs E
& 'Disr: Kheda.
-captive
Theproject hasbe€ncoveredunder
bategoryB.
Mr. J.D-hiyadarshi , Regionalofficer, GpcB- NadiadAs a represq,ntative
of
the Member Secretary,GPCB welcomed
all presentto the publicHearing.FIe
the project
detailsand addedthat it was asperthe advertisementin..The Times
9{li19
of
India" dated0l/lo/2011 in Englishand in "Divya dh*ku/' on o3/$/Z0l
I in Gujarai. He
also mentionedthat the doqrmentsrelatedto
@iect was disptayedd the va4iousplaces
mentionedin the advertisoment.He then openedth" puuti. H€aring
after due perrrission
from the District lu4gistrate.He invited tne bro;wt noponent to glv€
their introductionand
He also declaredtn"t oocethe presentationwould be over, the
then begln the presentatiron.
forum would be opeirto the 'oncerns of the locally affectingpeopre.
The Vraj Integrated Textile Park Ltd's representativeMr Yogesh Thakar (pirector
of
wrPL), opeaedtle presentationand gavean iffrodustion aboutthe upcoming
projea aod
its necessity.Tlrc Presentxion was further'continued by the representativepf
Ramans
Enviro Serviceh/t Ltd !Irs. Pralffuti Shah, explainedthe various aspectsof tho project
in
detail alongwith the information relatedto studyon environmentalimpact asseo$meot.
Afterthepresentatioq
Mr. J.D.Priyadarshi, Regional officer, GpcB-Nadiaqsrded
that atl locally affecting persotut could make their representationsor grve their
zugge$ionvcomments
beforethe fonrm.Iur M.V.pargi , District lvlagisfiate &
Collector then openedthe forum to the representationVsuggestions
frorn the locally
atrectedpeople.
The following points were raisedby the participantsandrespondedby the representativeof
the applicantduriagPublic Hearing
Sr
No
l.
Name and Address
Poirts Represented
Rcplies from Applicgnt
Mr.Ishwar
Bhai He welcomed the project and The
proponent has well
Naranbhai Desai infornredthat dueto tlis projecqthe appreciated the point and is
(residenf of village region would see increase in thankful forthe same.
Bareja)
and will be an
exemplary for future development
in this area.
Sr
No
lI 2
Name and Addness Points Reprcsented
Replies fnom Applisanl
Mr. Rajnikant
tre rarsed the concernedabout the Ihe representative
of the projectRPatel (a resident disposal ofFly ash to be generated
Proponent replid
that the
ofvillage Bidaj)
w_hitethe operation of thi power conveyanceof fly
ash will use
plant.
Pneumatic system and it will be
co[ected in two silos having
adequatecapacfy. It will be then
sold to Brick Manpfacturersand
we have already tied up with
therr, documentsofthe sameshall
be part of EIA. For sellineof flv
ashto CementffnanufacnrLs, the t
possibilitiesarebeing explored. I
In addition, bottom ash shall be I
disposedto low lying areas.
I
on completion of the presentationby Project Proponent,Shri J.D.priyadarshi,
Regional
!fficer, GPCB, Nadiad and as a represontativeof Member secretary, GpcB has raised
following questions,
l) wh&t will be thg
fatus of the upgradationof the existing sewage/Efflupnrtreahent
plant becauseofthe
proposedorpansion?
2) The technical details / design capacrtyof the Electrostdic precipita,tor
as an air
pollution contnrl measure.
3) Statusof the permissionfrom CGWA for withdrawal of the additional
Sarrnd water
and what is the planning of re-usg recycle, storageof rain harvestedinat.,
during
Monsoon?
4) What is the presentstdus of 5 (five) MW power plant?
The porntwise reply given by the repr€sentativeof the proponentis asbelow:
1) The existing sewage/effluenttreatmentplant of 100 KLD will be further upgraded
matchingthe anticipatedquantityof 925KLD.
2) Therewill be ESP of four fields. Out of these,three fields will be operationaland
the fourth one will act as a standby.So that any given time desiredemissionnorrns
will be achieved. ESP hasbeendesignedso asto achieveemissionstandardsof 50
mg/nm3.
3) CGWA permission for the existing park has ben already obtained and for
additionalwithdrawal ofground water CGWA applicationhasbeenmade.
a) The 5 MtV pow€f,plant which was eadier to be set up in Phase-I,constructionhas
not beenyet started.The 25 MW Power Plant will now be set up in Phase-tr.No
power plant will be in Phase-I
The Distria Irrtagistrate& Collector, Shri M.V.Pargi also enquiredabout
the disposal
industrialeffluent and Storm water from Park. tt *", informed by the representativeof the
of the
proponentthere are separateStorrr water drain and it will
be sent to rechargepit for
harvesting. The treatedindustrial effluent witl be fully re,used/recycle
for toilet flushing,
gardeningplantation,road washing,dust zuppression
systemetc.
Mr' J'D'Priyadarshi
Summarizedall the points raisedduring the public hearing
and
infonned the forum that four written representation
have been received from Mr.
Pravin P- sheth (senior citize4 anHeshwar),.?aryavaran
Mtra,,_ Ahmedaba4 Ivfr
K'C'Parmar,Barejaand Mr. PrabhatChauhanad;g wiitr ttre
other Famersfronnthe village
Bidaj' The copies of written representatioo*J the reply received
from the project
proponentshallbecomepaxtofproceedingasAnnexurecl
to c4.
ThePublic Hearingendedwith thanksto the Chair.
J.D.Priyadarshi.
RegionalOfficer, GPCB-Nadiad
As a representativeof the
MemberSecretary,GPCB
4
M.V.Pargi.
Z
Collector& District l\{agistrate.
Nadiad
al'laadt-r (lzer,[t)
q{[.ttgtI'ti .t-t ,iatett,-t.[0d[ t qnJf-tt*tL
g.tlg: dU.Ul.tqee, ctt{,,,t
cltt?ct
?t11.?-tt
qn&1'1t*tt.[l
tY-e-tooq,U..l{ el3 ?,t[dtqtt{q.r.rr-[l]t$.{t.tt o1.o[Qq,
Utrgh.tl ])or{ "t'[lbti
qd e{l,.,o[[r : [\sr, orgsloceil- Qsr,druerz
r,tt.r{.d.rr.IeqMr-u *u) q"t tJ[Q.]ia)erardar
*u)-[ ,r{q1z-uqr) x-i.r-rorr
6[?o]ia)aatle tt$ et].-u h+qc{lsur(rq {.n qla-ilqLqlr<{[-?)
-tLd'd ti..oo ge* qr 6[?,o)ia)aade qLJc0.qr,l uQe.stl*.{t. r{I.+eell,
urLrllsuhsr{.,11rrucr
q3}rerhriaeLqls -rL}rtAt\R{ els gtrcellti.
]t3lteth4acrqlJ, -tR.tLt,
i*rs uc*t+r{l.rr[, Ur-{rcr
(Borr{r+srdr.s-1.o6,t[Adu)i ,,tr.tsr.t[
u-l zsLrqi] r,tLdcl-[ qfl&uciqrhs il[\g qa :]%?t.il.
I'ti+6[i.1 dt.i.-to-?ott) 'ri urrlqr{ ut{e d u.I u r,iol-[*1dlc[l
loti.).Iqt do)o (aL6*tt
i.ut.t.u-u
$ruilm&ua{ serReear.,lutfl dtu$sa{@a-tl {qhp{l,r.r[q$Leilsgtr+elli.ugsErr
*tL)ul*sauqlt-ai %Ru.%.
,l'rslzctr{e} ul*sail*-)t-r qreqn}e.r.r[qre.iu gcerl3s+r'r[
urqe].
.I. qr 6[Qo)ia)aauJet
,rd e[., 3tr-ft-usr,+lsarr[ ql.Ierc.ud
arEliq-{I-rlqRqqqr,{l
lidsa{L hri qrgtdtuut[. cr.?6rLg
iq-[-tr qqfqt$ E+r€rz-z
?rqarr,].-.rrqe]
u[d[u qr. G[...r.n
ut].ue do]-[ qrglil rE s{.
atl*rtiluglaltr} ul*sa-[ horal',Lqzqqlqeeiuud-u ?4eru+r,l'tz
ll&q.$h.iasLqlJ, -rR,ut,,l'rtdldlsa
i*-)tt-u dA s[ *.dt dl.terffqrLrflsulhsr{,1n-uct
*[ ri'r.dl..urolldsr?r?
{o*}a ui sdgaR.
e]eL+qLhs?,t?r?clk
elsl-i ,ltr-fttEur.r]se.il%Bl[€.
ge'qr{+qLhsr,r?r?clk
eilsg-Lr+sll
e}sl arusa.{rrlurd.er
tgur.il ,lqz }il*sa u,rlt-a at.ugttr*ri
Utt{etUc3ct?.tlai
3rt't d.
't.
.t!r{ }tl +qq
??(urdl
t
r[ltJ+ttc.ltS
{teetc*ttdhttd
,luld gha u)*sai
!il*garl,r.I.r-adru
i'r,{I rgurai
(t&. qrlqn)
ur.rEtdg.r).r,tl rcu{
<'tlradlectl.u.l .l .u),I*r-il
sd 3 utuuldsail sreel
o+sasqTe.il.
l,trc.tr?
lreid?
d'forr{.[ .r3l.rrle].,lr1Z
Uu!il*sa ut fq+cu*riitrnef
ftttt.t d.
rftat.f}sicrq)e
,lt,tl gru \re? tetr-z{e{l
Gerlcur*uqhhlq gru
(t&.tors'r)
6qc.t+?r.tt{ ter.{ r,lttt
qtgtt.r.{ttiur.{ u5!}, {ctr.r*t
*1) qrl}il
h3re.ft c4cr?plt
1 ctg-r*tt) g.U{aU[h.a+[+a*r
rtlot.rtefutt.{Igc[.
-tI Gqqlotsue].u.l cl-tl{org
t"itrqsre.fl4 urdetlttls?rrl.
r'l.tt?ol?d,
eisl.fi lEur.il qte r[ *.J1.dl.ra[, rililetlsufQsr{,i1nrud
u3lrer[i.ia$ qlJ,
'tRue,ui uo,,tua{lqr0, g?t-{lct
}tgqethriaerq}s r utilht\ut ul*sa q,ii-ai..[l{tr rr-rl qrq,l
sEcru3du sler.
Ucu.+r)
eqtaqdqi ut{q *{r/ugt\a qtcll-ugksrurk{r-z-{lghcrti+c1ttE?Br
qraqRf&hU srl.
scl.t
u1;\tet
[\{ast +utnct{,}garccrtir,uietlds{*Ps it{t\)a*{I.rs-{Idtctgu
R1rdt.il
hcr.r1
urql.
3..
gt\cthiqttstetqr) q{. ure[],{rgR+r.rg{ urs+r'u) }dL.rgcfc.rrur+th[il-uurild.qa
rlqt {urdser/ {301,qaur{lqrs[l-u
rioreq]s-uhel zeuql.
Y..
rig{rri rsr{e qi.l (q) .IorL
qla.[s,ucrqRf*rtthrt.udtdluuql.
eqtaqd.n qqf.rtet
6q{saaqlel'nddsauq]aa'tr
atie rcr'il'{r{
urdhh 6r?[u]rrcurri
1..
o+tctt{litprgRtd qtellil $ksur kir-Z-{lft}rcuroo Sta}G[arqhR-r d. * t\+.rtfu?Br
r,u€,
r,u.r0.
ctq J[elc{lardil€{ saqrq,l
r4r-Ztix elaua+si6eisal*|2sitilD)ae 3rcrrLluu.rel.x daqie{le srdu u.l dg
QtQ?
}1"1tro.{le[orrq.
d-3 o|Heel*.tLe{l{sldqeL
qlAtr-r*{Iate{l.rrrel.r&.
+trt{.{g!rs1h,iacr.{l
qL{'tt f0+'1[ilsesL
srld qd.il qrqtl.il%aRqtd11) ]-dtrr $c[at rur ahfaj a'i[d'{a dq{et t}'
n1),4ctl.[ ulR+rcrtLr) ]dtr gofc.twr thtti ]t?@$tctt]ti.r4t{e t}'
Y..
*tt)
qLjnr.tuei aqg$qi{ut.{.{rrt[ut{et q.r[qut-[.ig{ x.c {ou qla-rL\[ct?K.tt'z e.[t.*j
'<tL'ei Utqlry-tgl'lt*tl
oritrgrt St tLltl UL{e te[I. .rdtt oflm Oq:Sr{ttrr {tU q}a'tt Ut+a
r<tl'aqlqqtti I'tL'ttl'tdt'
urie t). *-tr StrCIqLS{rq}ei aqg6*liS16ttt'{r
ulaltbrsu5[\cttttsllaqry
aruqr$qi.{I-fisutctt
u"I gdsar:tl r,Iq..{I.,{re"[I
Jtdtsa.i@?aa
ul.I ur-rerql.iq-[I-uutihtt aturcucq!] qr+[.{lt{tgll'tt'[ste
qrcft-u.[IgLe
qr+rLfl
u)-[ c4cr*rr
qRlqder{er
qr) uecrqR.rg-r.[c4cr?nr
t]. *{r am ti {au"Jrltarri*ilge.{r{ ut.rel.ui r'il'ilt"=rs
u) utqqr*f ut'rq1i*rr qrotrtrtc*rt),s+a+iet{ u) aerL
r*ctli Udlgaqr
s{ u\€rlt}rsds*ili cLtt{?cLt
qt) qLqrqtqiut'rtI.
ds qlefiot
*ilt\s lgut.tl ,ltt dFra.tiqtie lgural (
er.Ic{I
erlsg-u+ell*ri.
s[ *.{t. rftquffl,l.r.r[.rlcr
qletBt
.trtR, c'tthnui X' Ucttct
t. rlt UhCrt[. rla,dSAan,l. q.r[qtqt,ha u*tA'Uge. all ].t{1.
{iar
+t*tL{qt
deuu-q eg.r hal torss)fqrl udl.{l uu.[t.dt\.r*ri uL{etttgutal il'Ls ,l'tr 6td'il
{l-t t[l.+ll-xqi sl.tt*tlur{e d.
q+fqecralsg'tL+efi?4tat[?
hta art tirra qn}l.s{"
#
'-t'-/
*1dt.dl.rartl
qril\s u[\st{,
qld,
:I%?tdu!$$ h't lst
ucnt+th.r-trqhhh.
ulq..tt..rnc[
dw}a .tutsd.sat,
dt+{tsa
.td[4u4.
-
"'"5ilTl*:ll"ffiJiflffin"n**i*nNsxuRg
:,t
t/
Vraj Integreted Textile Park LJd., T,aKheda , D\t
-
Kheda, GITJ,AtrIAT
DaE:26110111
page 0l/05
Frcm:
PravinbhaiSheth, Senior citizen, Environmetalist.
A{, lGlindi Apparbnen0 Chikuwadi, Ankteshwar-393001.Gujarat
Cell No. :09377958840
MemberSecretary
GPGB,Gandhinagar,
fax:079-23222794
t4opy
R.O.GPCB,
mdi-4-
Ex T:f58 2ss14zl
Collector shri,
Distrtict Kheda
fax 0268 256534S
copy
MemberSecretary
SEIAA€ujarat
fax 07923222784
sub. : Environmentpublic hearingof vrai fnteoratedTextilepark Ltd..on 04111t11
at Ta.Kheda,Dist.Kheda,Gujarat.
RespectedMr. Hardik Shah Saheb
I studiedenglishverciondraft REIAreportof proiectproponentunderreference.
( u.vm-try-to
remain prcsentmy-setf
at schedutedate,incaseif I cannot repoft,pleasereadmy commengand
minutethe sainewith acceptabteneltponsetrom ProjectProponentand 'rrlfud; the
samein itnutes)
Thoughboththe environmentconsultantsarc a NABETaccreditedconsultantfor
the secto6 as specified,
nd on reviewingit, it has unnecessarilyattracted
fewqueriestoseekfurtherclar@an<|abouttheiecommendedmitigationmeasurej
for.environmentprotectionand so does tg-overgoryanegativeadvensetmpacts.sLEIA/GpcB
compliances
and technicaldetailsneed more attention,it would have&en better if report would have
beenrevieived oy
project proponentproperly and e:rtendedtheir expert'svaluablein puts'oeiorc
-uoritting it to GpcB for
gnvironment
oubtichearinqdateand alsofor oublic viewinq.
Needlessto mention.tftatnow, therc is a needto.hannonizeinfra structure and industrialgrourh
with the
!ffi
:9..9.":lp^Tl1:i15
:p1?.i:_l,T9"r-9^9ryi.9eratio;;;E'ie.sustsliioii.+tine
effective wav.
Revi?Yis,farriedout in=aggsilivem,anner=iust
to srlpogrt=pfgiect
nrooonentwith a requestto qivedue
tgiq!,FtE4ble in
Ereide.Etiot!
,.
pr.esentation
to GPCB/ MoEF.
.
\-r' Hopemy reviewfindingsshalt hetpprojectproponentto up datedraft REIAreportfurther.
CleanGuiarat-- GreenGuiarat
Pleasep.giqtermy viewsand includein minuteswith thEprojectproponenfsacceptablercsponse.
Likelvqueriesattracted on reviewstudv and,needsaiueciariicationsand iustincations.
Review findiXgg
(A I
Pointsworth notinq
A. Goodinfrastructurcto boost the developmentof textileunits at Khedaand so doesthat
of Gujaratand a good supportto gatherscatteredtextileunits of Ahmedavadat one zone.
B. Prom_oters
backgroundis well defined,so projectsustainabilitymay
be a probtem.
c. Baseline studie.sarc rccenqi.e. Febll to Aprii 11,which proielts truenot
pollutidnload. i
contd page02-
DraftREIAReportt:u,,f*:d.by pravinbhaiSheth,
Ankteshwar.
Carefor nextgeneration
SaveEnvironmeint:
Environment Public hearing of
Ta Kheda. Dist.
Textile Park
-Z
GUJARAT
Page 02/05
D. Installing a manual fire alarm system will be an added support
grade the socio
E. Employrient opportunity for $99 persons will be a great support to up
economic level of Kheda.
F. No trees cufting will be there.
undertaking'
G. No dyeing house activities will be encouraged for proposed proiect under a notarized
r€felred
to be alsweredlcoll€c6onl?
reouiredrquestions
Glarifications
!o:bem?ce,as
,
Queslions
02
03
04
Refpage9.5,sr no. 32,in all you w!!.g9Y9t9qt9F.l-89{!gflgryen belt arca,it is appreclatedm2
eui lTis udT tN Accbioence vvlf+rsuian uREcilvEoF DEwLoPlNG,ftll{lMUil e5800
lS NOTlN ORDERT
et""n U"ft atualtt,it s-eemstfrat SLEIAACOTPLIENCE
'
5
no.
Al,sr
RefSLEIAAlefrerdt 25105109
sa, pl irovide detailson tie ups with localagenciesfor tree plantationin
RefersLElAA,A.7,
reportt
is not includedin compliance
phasemannei.This"ino.
hat; y;t submittedTORcomptiancesundera notarizedundertakingto authority?,
lf so, pl providethe coPYof same.
iniOe,sr no. 5, in caseif treatedeffluentdoes not complywlth rcfensd
ReferGpCBconsent-di'O
you will
specin""Uon",th"n trowyou wili managerequiredqty of waterfor grcenbelt andwhat
such
time
any
has
units
For
exlsting
effluent?
,
Ob* f,or Voriwifl Oitboie such reJectdd
Instancesiverereported?,if so pl providedetails'
pl
ReferGpCBcon""ni OtOinAOA,ir. no. 24,hastree plantationcarriedout as per norms'
confirmthe samewith the details.
ThoughToR has not specified,but it-isatwaysa general.conditionthat glllb4gqPltould
f,'etpsall vieweb toituOy it Properlyand eachquestions/
Oesiriatty numUereO,ivtrrcn
pagehumberc'
confuslons/clarlficationsrequiredcan havea backuprefere-nce
?
numbered
serially
pages
not
are
all the
in view of thls, why
-NAbEi
or hiddenl
a... et1 partt,
iade sn to 7lf missingtlt confuseswhethernot required
b... EtA'parttil, Annexurepagesnot seriallynumberedt
pagosnoiserially numbercd,AnnexutoF, up to pages23
EfEpattry, ennexursC,-O,g
"...
iresertaltyhumbered,thenagalnserialnumberchangesl.
.
. _ _-_\..
pl ensurethat flnaiRElA report,atl pageswill bo sedallynumbercd,In caseif you navoany
reservation,pl clarify it for not adhedngto this'
basetlnestudiei datarepo4 it is ratherdraft S3p$ llA-rcqgn
Sinceit is one
07
BUTthat
""""6n
NABETAccREDtrAiiou CemmcATE for RamanisEnviroservicespvt ltd ls-iustified to
08
responsofor EGOCHEMsafei-ind.servicets notjustified,as copy of acceptancelettErin specifying
NABETtetterdt l8 Aprit 2oir not attactredand morcov6r similaitype of certiffcate
the dateof issueand validity periodin not attachedtPl providethe same'
?
APPROACLT
Ref.oaqe1.4.nowttre cost ittt"*tite mfg,is reducedbyway oJHOLISTIC
09
of
inclusive
Ref.pageZ.l, capmip-j"* costfor ffinsion is propctei 9l?2.!6^crorcs
10
STP
of
that
except
2.2
fable
Rs i0 crorestowarls-dnl'"ist"r, but this is not reileiting in
EMsystemcost of Rs 6'{7 croresand
@ R".4.,83croresf, pf pt*'iOe Aetaitsfor balance
of expansionl
cost
projecte4
capital
your
Frhaps'this may c'frlnge
11
12
i3
14
is 29.8ha.or27.4146ha?
Ref.page2.5,areafor proposed-expansion
TRADERS
Ref.page2.7,T z.S,whyyou preterto frocgry -lyg9 gty-of importedcoal frgqr LOCALdircctly
importing
not
for
consralnt
whlt
ii
ttre
insteadot import-rig;iird"ttyFm Indonesia?
your payback
anduirhece"""ri,ii'i*"uring from tocattraAersat higher,costwill this not disturb
period?
projectedlanded
As mentioned,naturatgas availabilityis a constraint,it is o[<,but when you
use,but haveyou
to
and
economical
is
cheaper
coal
cost of naturalg""-"r" io"l and appriised
carcof
takenin accountof additionatcost incuning on storageof coauash,ftrc risk, taking
environment
ttiglrtyhealthn-a"arOouspoltutant like mertury in coal,and additional
of c ral
management <- ritigation measurcison iollution control bacauseof usage
pa$e
2.8
.(
Ref.
"ost
in
totality
)
factor
as tue'i? pt submit reviseJcost
Ref.page2.11,T2.6B.,
lS {0500?
a,.. Why only i0 parametersmonitoredfor RW,how aboutother parameteFas
( it is alreadyconsideredin Table5'l I )
b.... liow aboutother likely suspectedpollutants?
contd Page03
09377958840
Reportreviewedby PravinbhaiSheth,Ankleshwar.Cell
SaveEnvironment:Garcfor nextgeneration
Environment public hearing of
Textile Park
Ta Kheda. Dist
GUJARAT
page03/05
15
17
18
v
c.... lle there-any industriesin 3 km radiatarea?tf so, pl providedetailsandtypes.ofindustries.
d... When this land was pnocurcd,was it a planeone 6r was thereany indusfrialaciivity
earlier.
Re!:P-age
2.11,2.4.5,how far is Sabarmatiriverflow is from projectsite ? in case,if it is within 3 km
radialdistance,then will thers be any chanceto pollutethis rivbr becauseof the projector by any
memberindustries?, if so, what additionalmitigationmeasunes
you will incorporate:?
Ref.plge 2.16,T 2.8,only 9 parametesmdntionedfor importedcoal analysis,
a... Howaboutother parameterslike volatilematter,hardgroveindex,-inherent
moisture?
b... Hea-vy
metatsrcferredas NlL,but hasalttheparameteE
likeZn, cu, pb, Hg,As, Ni,cr
etc.considered?.
pro^vide_cop_yof
the analygisreportsubmittedby overceasorigin.
qle-ase
Ref.q39e_2.18,,1n
whrt pspect BFBCboilermay be moreefficientas iomparedto AFBCboiter?
a... ls BFBCboilereconomicalin costwise
b... or moreeffieientin generatingmoresteam
j..: or generatingleaststakeemissionsquantum?
Ref.page2.30,2.4.13,providing
employmentopportunitysupporGthe sustalnabilltyof the
proiectandproviding banks/ATMcourierservices,shopssup'portsthe businessaciivities,BUT
as regardsGSR,pl providesomebetternieasureswhichwill-lielpin progress,
devetopment
9f gtudyalea and upliftmentof affectedperconsresidingIn stud:yaria.
Ref.page3.7,T 3.2, study areafor AAe monitoringconiideredonly up to 5 km,
a... Howaboutfor extendedareaup to 10km ?
loadof 'CO'potlutantloadas it ls alsoa
Q... Howaboutpresentload and incremental
part of NAAQstandards?
c... Pl provideisopleth'sfor'CO'aswell.
fef plge 3.13,GW, you havemonitored37 parameterswhilst Ref.page3.17,that for SOIL,
Only8 parametersmonitored,
a... lt is-necessaryto monitorequalno. of parametercto assessthe percotationetatus
of pollutantsfrom SOILto GW.
b... H9v9you carrie.d-o_ut
imagingsensitivitytest to confirmthe GWpoilutantsstatus/quantum
of the Bowof.@tl ?
c... Whatwas'lC lovel in GWand that In SOILsamples?
\
Ref.-page
3.71,drinkingwatel supplyserviceand supplyposltionts mentioned,as regards
qualitypart,how manysamplesanalyzedas 1510500
to justify the sameare fit as driifing water?
( as an NABET/QCI
accreditedenvironmentconsultant,this should havebeenjustiftedas a
proactiveactionand if the concemedsamplenot foundfit, then rcspectiveSa anchshouldbe
advisedfor a propertreatmentor projectproponentcan offer ROplint or othei treatmentunder
GSRactivitiesto the extent
Refpage3.73,healthcare infta structurein study area,anathereany TB, Cancer,Dialysis,Aids,
Asthmacentets,as on post operationemploying22OOO
employeesithesemay be a common
Occupationalhealthdisorder, and if such centercarc not iheie, project propbnentjoinfly
with memberunits can developsuch hoalthcareunits underCSn activitibsio that manhrc loss
timecanbe a minimal.
It is_prcsumed
that you or your memberunits can not providehousingand bansportfacilities
to all the employees,
a... Are thercenoughhousingfacilityin study area?
b... Howfar is the nearcstpublicha4sporttike bus stand/autostandfnomproiectsite ?
Ref.page5.1, T 5.1
a;.,:,tiief;sr"no3, add 'GO'also,slnceyou will usecoal as a fuel,
b... ref.sr no 4, which lS no.you arerefening.
page
!ef.)
9.f, f ( ? ), you will maintainmaxinventoryof vital RMcoal ONLY@ 5500MT
at any time!,i.e. hardlyONLYFOR2.6daysstock as againstmonthlyusage@145OO
lUfm,
a... ls thereany limitationsin regardsto statutoryprovision/tunOivaitrabitity/safety
nonns,
if so, pl explain.
b... With this very limitedinventory,will yourprofectbe sustainabte?
You mayhaveto recalculatethe levelof minimuminventoryand perhapsyour EMpnormsmay
haveto changeto up dateyour draft REIAreportaccordingly.
contd page04
DraftREIAReportreviewedby PravinbhaiSheth,Ankleshwar.Cetl
09372958840
\\z
SaveEnvironment:Garefor nextgeneration
Environment public hearing of
Vraj Integreted Textile Park Ltd., Ta Kheda , Dist Kheda, GUJARAT
page0405
27
28
t
m
29
30
31
Ref.page6.4,6.2.3,
,
a... WhereChtorinewill be used?
I PlprovideMSDS.
2 Howmanyammoniatorchesyou will haveas a minlmalstock.
3 Pl provideisopleth.
4 Whatwilt be monthlyquantityusage?
5 Why is not reflectedin RMusagelist ?
b...
1 Fromwhercstaficelecticity likelyto generate?
2 Fow do you assurezerostaticchargebeforeunloadlngsuch material
alreadyhavingdeveloped
staticcharge.
. for PPE,first P standaf91PERSONHE!
BgJ*paEe6"!2. '6.2.613
and iro-tpe_gqorpl,
pags8.9is otc
ygu-rade
agn*ment-/lloU
with
near
by
OHC/IIOGTORS,
chemistshop?orL tn trmemedical
.HaY-e
tneatnentto your constructionand postoperationemployeeswithout cashpaymentIn caseof any
medicalemergencies
?
Doyou havea written agreementfor mufualaid to seekextemalasslstance?
Ref.page9.3, sr no. 13,for presentactivities,you have22 membets,and only 5 units have
s_lrtedproduction,s9 for remainingunits,do you haveany scopetoinstruct them NOTTO
GOFORDYEINGOPERATION
as you haveassurpdunderirotarizedundertakingthat for
proposedproject,you will not encouragedyeinghouseactivities,lt is well appbclated.
Ref.page9.3 sr no. 14,fol3rddltional
you will incurcapitatcost@ Rs.122.46
9 members,
crores
as againstexistingcost of [email protected]
croros(tor 22 units)t Whyiuch hlghlroject capitatcost?
HasGPGB/safety
dept earlierlssueda showcause/closurcnoticeto you or any of yourexisting
unitsfor violationof their statutorynormstowardsenvironmentproteition/unsife cbndition?
lf so, pl providedetails.
32 Ref.page9.6,sr no. 42,whyyou are rechargingall rain waterinsteadof harvestingpartof rainwater
stockingit and reusingto reducefreshwaterup takein view of nafuralresourceJionservation
conceptl Any way roof waterand surfacerainwaterto be harvestedand only run.offwater
aftertreatmentto be recharged.Pl provideschematicdiagramfor reusingrainwaterwith
proximateasE$mpdc$on.hsrer
rmrch% fresh,water( GWIup tako,wilt-bereduced.
Pl proride a plan layout specifyingfreemovementof fire tehderwhichmoveeasltyin the
peripheryaroundthe projectslte andaroundthe memberunits with easvreversaidrive.r
inc|udingpositionandqtyofwindsocksforexistingactivitiesa@ion.
34 Whatwas the survival ratesof the treesalreadyptanled?
35
a... Howlong consbuctionperiodwill continue?
b... Howyou will takecareof anyliketyhabitatdisturbances
.
c... Howyou will managefor theirdrinkingwatErandsanitationfacilities?
36
Vl
37
38
39
40
41
a... Whatwill be Yourtrafficdensityduringpeakhrs ?
b... Howtherewill not be any incremental
loadof air pollution?
you
going
Are
your
to
have
own
PUC
centre
to controlvehicutarpollution?
9...
d... Willyou or your membeprefuseto unloadthe vehiclesnot complyingPUCitandards?
a... Whatwill be the minimumfire waterthat can be kept readyat any point of time ?
b... Will this fire waterbe requlredto giveany pretreatmentfoi ifs si:iaUility or you
can use rawwater straight away?
ls NAAQstandardsas refenodarc Bvised one ?
ls ita privateownedlandor govemmentteasedland?
Whatwill be per daynuaterrequirement'forgreenbeltpla:riatiorrs
?
Willthere be any water loggingdue to construction,activities
or on post commissioningof project
Will therc be any chanceto disturb or diversifyingnaturalnalaor storm waterdrainagesystem?
Howmany% peoplewiit Ueemployedfromlocalarea?
contd page05
DraftREIAReportreviewedby PravinbhaiSheth,Ankleshwar.Cell
0g3Z7gO8B4O
a
l
SaveEnvironment: Ca?efor nextgeneration
Environment
publichearingof
;!
,:i
/
:/
page05/05
Haveyou followedthe guide lines/ins*trctionsfor proiectproponent
and that for
environmentconsultantwhile preparingand submifring
draft REIAreportfor public
consultation?
43
ai
4
Hasany part of draft REIAreportwas enbustedto other
agency/agencies
( exceptEco cHEIbt])
tre
:fSJ#X" [:L,,i:?*"ratio
oesirco-iniormalon's
ii onf; R-;'A;;ort arons
withoreir
45
As rcgards data on base line srrtdies, can you fonra$
attested copies of analysis data of
GW SW, Soil, Noise as appticabt" i"i"""'lf-"*#"Ji
46
would you mind if after rcceivin-9the EG if-plausibte-stai<e-trotder
,
tlko mysotf , would lke to
assessthg coqnP$anccofeG conoitionsand'extE"icumii"i'Jr$,JTonimitmenfs
madaby you
tfiattlg ailti{itiment Fotecton measunesandC$Raetivites
?
47
who authorizeopersohrtot
lri,Ir,ris absence,rcpresentauvewho is tu1time
employeeand well convercant'd'in
"fp.q""1t!iql
aran
r"pori"nd mitigau6nmeasurestowardsenvironment
protection) will give the presentationandneia
pto"fr t ttt er the public quostionnairesprocess
I
?
In otder to avoid-repe"t"i r"r"" nt"
il;iil;
of sensorc you shal instal in rire ararm?
49
Whatadditionalmeisures you can.inc9n9r.t"
"1"fr,
ii, iriUfy grleenbuitdingconceptspectailyfor the
buildingblocksrequiringair conditioniniyrprrig#Iln
ano-towtemperaturesto'ge areasas in
summerwhentemperatureat proJectsit6^qlelfto eiceeo
40/4s;{iliJntigraoe.
50 ln caseif you or memberinouitri6s, use Cru
t6.on""rr" energy,
how you wit takecare of mercurypotution on it,s oiscarding.
l.
il
lll
lv
:
vi
llencounagetimberfree construction.
Prusesorarsystemfor gardenrantems,pumpingwater
to overfieadtanks.
Pl cetebrateworld envir6nmentoay eac'tryeilffi;;;tr
awanEness
on environmentprotection.
Pl inviteparticlpantswtro extenoedvaruiSte.in put"
to- n:" public hearingwhenyou
commissionedthe projectto witnessyorr iu"'ce"s.
li,H$"fmm#t
cirzerc,
orpham,
wirrows,
mig:'cietv:;6akor;ili'p"oon"rikesenror
Pl budgetsomeitonaiionfor cM, Gu;arafsbeti bachao
abhiyanand kanyakelvanlabhiyan. \
Pl fonrardyour reply_through.hard
c-opythrough a suitablemeansto my contactaddrcss
as mentonedso
that I cansquara0p my queltions ateireviewing ute-rspri
tolusutv minutesas an agreedons.
Pl drawmy attentionif I am wrong somewherein my
feedback.
we knowthat you are a developer,but pl noterlrat-queries
areattractedbasedon information,sfumishedin
your rcportcinly,refercncepagesano SglAA/.Gpca'pages
arc
onlv a indicativeon"io, your easyrcferenceto
answerthe questions,ho*dr"i
inout" b"for"
"ubtnittino"ouru
Wewelcomethe projecthavingdue mitigationmeasures
to controtenvironmentpollution
basedon baseline studies of Jtuoy areawith due considerations
on incrementatloadof
pollutantson accountof post proj6ctcommissio"ing.
Thanksand regards
t
(.nu(r-vrr"r:.
$urrL/
Pravinbhaisheth
file: eph vraj kheda
pl excuse for any typingftypeseting/spellingfuocabulary
mistakes.
Jai Jai Garvi Gujarat -Jai Bharat
GleanGujarat--- GreenGujarat
With festival greetings
HAPPYDIWALTAND PROSPEROUS
NEWYEAR
DraftREIAReportreviewedby Pravinbhaisheth, Ankleshwar.Gefl
END
,t2
\'(-
t
N
t
1
?
Dare Zltll}Atl
To,
P.Sheth,
Pravinbhai
list,
Environmenta
SeniorCitizen,
393001,
Ankleshwar
Appt.,Chikuwadi,
A-8,Kalindi
Gujarat
4lLlLL, at Ta. & Dist' : Kheda,
SUB: Env.publicHearingof Vraj IntegratedTextileParkPvt. Ltd. on
Gujarat
REF: Yourletter no. NIL dated 26lLOl2Otl
DearSir,
your
we appreciate
to abovementionedsubjectandthe letterunderreference.
Thisis with reference
aregivenasbelow:
replyto the questions
underthe pointsworth noting.Thepointwise
observations
Sr.
No.
1
Reply
Questions
RefPage9.5,srno.32,inall you will developtotal Ref,Page2.5,'f 23 A & B' Outof the total
BUTlT 50.45hectaresof land, @ 30 ha areas
80000m2 greenbelt area,it is appreciated
to memberunits.
WITH SLEIAADIRECTIVEhavebeenallocated
IS NOT IN ACCORDANCE
MINIMUM95800m2 Greenbelt
OFDEVELOPING
Out of total land allocatedto member
lS NOT
area!!!,itseemsthat SLEIMCOMPLIENCE
units,30%of the landwill be utilizedin
tN oRDER!Ref SLEIM letter dt 25/05109AL,sr
the Green belt/area & landscaPing
no.5
development.Hence,the area to be
developedas green zone will be @
sq. m. within the premisesof
9O,OO0
memberunits.
Moreover, there will be roadside
plantationas well as green belt / area
development
@ t0Yoin the parkpremises
by the developer.
as
Hence,the total areato be developed
greenbelt/zonewill be @1,40,000
sq.m.
2
ReferSLEIM,A.7,srno.58,plprovidedetailson tie The ECCfor the first phase has been
for tree plantation
in phase accordedin May, 2009.The park is still
upswith localagencies
phase.Hence,tie up
Thisis not includedin compliance
report! underdevelopment
manner.
with local agencieswill be done at the
.^4
fully operativestageof the project.
Have you submitted TOR compliancesundeii TORcomplianceis a part of the EIAreport
notarizedundertakingto authority?if so, please and same is attached herewith
as
providethe copyof same.
Annexure-A.
ReferGPCBconsentdt05|12/06,sr no.Sjncaseif
treated effluent does not comply with referred
specifications,
then how you will managerequired
qty of water for green belt and what you will
instances
were reported?,if so pl providedetaits.
As mentioned in the section 2.4.2,
Memberprofileat TableNo 2.4A& 2.48,
no dyeingand processing
unitsarepartof
the park.Theparkhousesunitsthat have
low pollutionpotentialsuchas Spinning,
Weaving,POY,Sizing,Wrapping packing
etc. Hencethe quality of the effluentis
deemedto be in lieu with the quality
parameters.So far, there has not been
any instance reported and any such
instance
seemsunlikely.
ReferGPCBconsentdt OS/tzlOS,
sr noZ+, tr-asThe tree plantationis in the developing
tree plantationcarried out as per norms, pl phaseand is beingcarried
out in stepconfirmthe samewith the details.
wise manner. lt is beingvery difficultto
grow and maintain1000trees per acre;
tie up with localagencies
will be donefor
developmentof balanceno.of trees.
ThoughToRhasnot specified,
butlt i;i6s
a All the Chaptersof the Reportare seriaily
generalconditionthat all the pagesshouldbe numbered
and easilyglanced
upon.The
seriallynumbered,whichhelpsall viewersto study Annexures
however,
neednot necessarily
beserially
numbered.
questions/confusions/clarifications
required can
havea backupreferencepagenumbers.In viewof
this,whyallthe pagesarenot seriallynumbered? NABETpage
3/7 to I 17are not required.
a....EtApart t, NABETpagbl/ltotl7 missing!it
confuses
whethernot requiredor hidden!
b... EIA part lll, Annexurepages not serially Annexure
F have been numbered
numbered!
properly,howeverthe file got corrupted
c....EIApart lV, AnnexureC,D,Epagesnot serially and
hence,
numbering
hasbeenchanged.
numbered,
AnnexureF,up to pages23
The samewill be correctedin the final
are seriallynumbered,then againserial.number
report.
changes!
Pl ensurethat final REIAreport, ail pageswill be
serially numbered, in case if you have any
reservation,
pl clariryit for not adheringto this.
Sinceit is one seasonbaseline
it is ratherdraft RapidEIAreport.
We agreeto your interrogation.lt is Draft
Rapid EIA report. The same will be
reflectedin the final reportsubmission
to
authorityfor appraisal.
NABETACCREDIATATTON
CERTIFTCATE
for Raman,s Eco Chem sales and Servicehas been
Enviroservicespvt ltd isjustifiedBUTthat for ECO issued conditional certificate and
CHEMsalesand serviceis not justified,as copyof acceptanceof the same is conveyedto
acceptanceletter in responseto NABETletter NABET.The final certificateas statedin
dt8l}4/z}tL not ittached and more over similar the letter is awaited.
type of certificatespecifoing
the dateof issueand
validity period in not attached! pl proiaides
the
same.
Ref. page 1.4, how the cost of textile mfg, is The Textile Park housesunits that are
reducedby way of HOL|STIC
APPROACH?
having end products of fonrvardand
backward integration. Hence, the
presenceof commontransportation
and
infrastructural facility would save
individualcost bournedby the individual
unit members.Hence,the cost of tertile
manufacturing
will be reducedthrough
thisapproach.
Ref.page
2.4, capitalprojectcost for expinsionis
projectedt22.46 croresinclusiveof Rs 10 crores
towardsEM system,but this is not refiectingin
table 2.2 extept that of STp@ s. 4.g3 crores!pl
provide details for balanceEM Systemcost of
Rs.6.17crores
and perhapsthis may changeyour
projectedcapitalcostexpansion!
Ref.Page2.S,
area for proposede[anEn-T
29.8ha.o127
.4146ha?
We would like to state the cost
mentionedin the fourth columnof Table
2.2istorthe ultimatephaseof the park.
The costto be allocatedfor EMSis given
at Annexure8.
The areafor proposedexpansion
is @
Ref Page2.1, T 2.5, why you prefer.to procure The concernis first
highlyappreciatehuge qty of imported coal from LOCALTRADERS
Howeverin referenceto page2.7,T 2.5;
instead of importing directly from Indonesia? it is apparent
that the requirementof
What is the constraintfor not importingdirectly coalis not very high.
Thus,after a careful
from lndonesia?What is the constraintfor not ponders,we have
decidedto procureit
importingdirectly and unnecessarily
procuring fromthe localtraders.
from local traders at higher cost, will this not
disturbyour paybackperiod?
As mentioned, natural gas availability is a The point is appreciatedand is very well
constraint,it is ok, but when you projectedlanded taken for the implementation.Required
in the Final
shallbe incorporated
cost of naturalgasv/s coal and appraisedcoal is changes
cheaperand economicalto use, but have you Report.
taken in accountof additionalcost incurringon
storageof coaUash,fire risk,takingcard.ofhighly
healthhazardouspollutant like mercuryin coal,
coston
and additionalenvironmentmanagement
mitigationmeasureson pollutioncontrolbecause
of usageof coal as fuel ? pl submit revisedcost
factorin totality .( Ref.page2.8)
fn referenceto pagez.LL,T 2.68& page
a... Why only 10 parametersmonitoredfor RW, 3.11,T 3.4;the sourceof rawwaterbeing
groundwater, the sampleof the ground
howaboutother parametersas lS10500?
( it is alreadyconsidered
water is analyzed by lS 10500
in Table5.1!)
parameters.lt is only out of parameters
Ref.page2.11,T2.68.,
of concernthat we havementionedsome
of them in T 2.68. The comprehensive
detailsof the sameare givenat T 3.4.The
analysisshows variation due to the
specificityof eachlocation.Theadditional
pollutants? parametersshall be incorporatedin the
b....Howaboutother likelysuspected
Final Report. The analysisresult shall
reflect any other likely suspected
pollutant.
c... Arethere any industriesin 3 km radialarea?lf There are no other Industriesin the
radiusof 3 Km.
so,pl providedetailsandtypesof industries.
d... Whenthis landwas procured,
wasit a plane The land was barren at the time of
procurement.
oneor wasthereany industrialactivityearlier.
Riverflowsapproximately
Ref.pagez.tI, 2.4.5, how far is Sabarmatiriver TheSabarmati
flow is from projectsite?in case,if it is within 3 at 7,7 kmsfrom the projectsitewhichis
km radialdistance,
then will there be anychance outside
of the3-kmradius.
pollute
to
this river becauseof the projector by
any memberindustries?, if so, what additional
you will incorporate?
mitigationmeasures
Ref. page 2.16, T Z.g, only
The report of Coal analysisis given at
mentionedfor importedcoalanalysis,
TableNo. 2.8, the hardgrovegrindability
a... How about other parameterslike volatile indexis 5G55 whereas
inherentmoisture
matter,hardgroveindex,inherentmoisttire?
i s @ 1 2- L 3 T o . .
b... Heavymetalsreferredas Nl! but hasall the Detailed heavy
metal analysishas not
parameterslike Zn, Cu, pb, Hg, As, Ni, Cr etc.
been carried out, which will be carried
considered?pleaseprovide copy of the analysis out duringcommencement
of the project
reportsubmittedby overseas
origin.
and will be submitted to concerned
Ref.page2.18,1n
what respectBFBCGCTmaybe
moreefficientas comparedto AFBCboilei?
a... ls BFBC
boilereconomicat
in costwise
b...or moreefficientin generatingmoresteam
c...or generatingleaststakeemissions
quantum?
authority.
As per view of technicalconsultantfoi
power plantAFBC(Atmospheric
Fluidized
Bed Combustion)and BFBC(Bubbling
Fluidized
Bed Combustion)
are the same
terminology and is being used
interchangeably.
Ref. page 2.3O, 2.4.tt, ptoviding emplffiEnt The TextilePark has
a dedicatedCentre
opportunity supports the sustainabilityof the for the Vocational
Trainings.This shall
projectand providingbanks/ATMcourierservices, enable
the locals to acquire the
shops supportsthe businessactivities,BUT as knowledge
of the lndustryandcouldlead
regardsCSR,pl provide some better measures to theirall-round
development.
whichwill help in progress,developmentof study As a part of
CSR,as mentionedin page
areaand upliftmentof affectedpersonsresidingin no.7.t, Section
7.2,there will be health
studyarea.
related facilities provisionslike medical
camps/checkups.
Ref. page 3.7, T 3.2, stuay-area-toffi
monitoringconsideredonly up to 5 km,
a... Howaboutfor extendedareaup to 10 km?
b-.. Howaboutpresentloadand incrementalload
of 'CO'pollutantload as it is alsoa part of NAAe
standards?
c... Plprovideisoplethsfor ?CO,aswell,
ln Reference
to the page3.7,T 3.2,AAe
havebeenconsidered
for the 7 Kmarea.
However, maximum GLC has been
obtainedin l-Km radius.
The farthest monitoring station was
establishedat @ 6.7 Km for AAQ.
However,the Landuse pattern,Ecology
survey as well as the Socio-economic
surveywere carriedout for the studyare
of 10 Km.
Ref page 3.13,GW, youffi
TOR proposed by Applicant and ttre
parameterswhilst Ref. page 3.17,that for
SOIL, AdditionalTORfrom SEACdon,t mention
Only8 parametersmonitored,
any additional soil parametersto be
a... lt is necessaryto monitor equal no. of
monitored.
parametersto assessthe percotationitatus
of
pollutantsfrom SO|Lto GW.
b.,, Haveyou carriedout imagingsensitivitytest
|
to confirmthe GW pollutantssta
the flow of GW?
c... What was 'K level in GW and that in SOIL
samples
?
Ref.page3.71,drinkingffi
water samptesnaveoein ani@i
supplyposition is mentioned,as regardsquality per
lS 10500)as a part of representative
part, how manysamplesanalyzedas 1510500
to samplingas per guidelineof MoEF.The
justify the sameare fit as drinking
water?(asan samehasbeendescribed
at TableNo.3.4
NABfl-/QClaccreditedenvironmentconsultant,
(Ground
& 3.5
water and Surfacewater)
this should have been justified as a proactive
of Chapter3.
actionand if the concernedsamplenot foundfit,
then respectiveSarpanchshouldbe advisedfor a
propertreatmentor project proponent
can offer
ROplant or other treatment underCsi.activities
to the extent.
Refpage3.73,healthcare@
TheTextilepark is about to GJnCoweO
area, are there any TB, Cancer,Dialysis,Aids,
with Multi-functionalityHealth Centre
Asthmacenters,as on post operationemploying
takingcareof all the employees
on site.
22000 employees,these may be a common
Occupational
healthdisorders,and if suehcenters
are not there, project proponent jointly with
memberunitscan developsuchhealthcareunits
underCSRactivitiesso that man hrs losstime
can
bea minimal.
It is presumea
tnatffi
Mostof the employees
in ttre pa*
stntt
cannotprovidehousingand transportfacilities
to be from the nearbyvillageareawithin a
alltheemployees,
commutabledistance.Henceadditional
a... ls thereenoughhousingfacilityin study
area? housingfacilitieshavenot beenprovided.
b... Howfar is the nearestpublictransport
likebus The Textile park has the major public
stand/autostandfrom projectsite?
transportation facility right at ifs
entranceofthe gate.
Ref.page5.1, T5.1
We take a note of ii anA-COTitt Oe
a... ref. sr no 3, add ,CO,also,sinceyoir
will use consideredas one of the parameter
of
coalasa fuel.
the MQ monitoringprogramme.
b... ref.sr no 4, whichlSno.you are referring.
R e f .p) a g e 6 . 4 , (Tf f i
At page6.4, T, the inventoryo-f
6I'iT
inventoryof vital RM coalONLY 55OO
MT at any shown as 55@ MT, which is
@
11
days
@
time!, i.e. hardly ONLYFOR2.6 days
stock as considering the
total
monthly
againstmonthlyusage@ 14500MTM,
J
(
a... ls there any limitations in regardsto stitutory
requirementof 14500MT.
provision/fundavailability/safety
norm!, if so, pl
explain.
b... With this very limited inventory,will your
projectbe sustainable?
Youmayhaveto recalculate
the levelof minimum
inventoryand perhapsyour EMPnormsmay have
to change to update your draft REIA report
accordingly.
error. Chlorineis not
It is a typographical
Ref.page6.4,6.2.3,
to be used.
a...WhereChlorinewill be used?
2 PlprovideMSDS.
2 Howmanyammoniatorchesyouwill haveasa
minimalstock.
3 PlprovideEsopleths.
4 Whatwill be monthlyquantityusage?
5 Whyis not reflectedin RM usagelist.?
1 Fromwherestaticelectricitylikelyto
b...
generate?
2 How do you assurezero staticchargebefore
unloading
suchmaterialalreadyhavingdeveloped
staticcharge.
the correctionand will
Ref.page6.12, 6.2.6.3, for PPE,first P standsfor We acknowledge
page8.9is ok.
incorporatein final EIAreport.
PERSONNEL
andnot personal,
Haveyou made agreement/MoU with nearby
chemist shop for a in time
OHC/DOCTORS/
medicaltreatmentto your constructionand post
operationemployeeswithout cash payment in
caseof anymedicalemergencies?
The Park is deemed to have Multicentrewithinthe sitehence
functionality
shallhaveaccess
to the
all the employees
as pertheirtimings.
specialists
you
Ref.page9.3, sr no. 13,for presentactivities,
have22 members,and only 5 units havestarted
production,so for remainingunits, do you have
any scope to instruct them NOT TOGO FOR
DYEING
OPERATION
as you have assuredunder
notarizedundertakingthat for proposedproject,
youwillnot encourage
dyeinghouseactivities,
it is
TheTextileParkhasa written agreement
between its member units in order to
NOTTO GO FORDYEINGOperation.All
the membersof the Parkare very well
aware of this Clause hence Dyeing
Operationshallnot be carriedout in any
case.
There will be preparationof off-site
with the
Doyou havea writtenagr-eement
for'mutualaid emergencyplan in consultation
localauthorities.
to seekexternal
assistance?
.
wellappreciated
K
31
Ref.page9.3 sr no. 14,for additionll9YBrnbers,
you will incurcapitalcost @ Rs.122.46croresas
agafnst existingcostof [email protected]( for 22
units)! Whysuchhighprojectcapitalcost?
32
Ref.page9.6,sr no.42,why you are recharging
all The point is taken into consideration.
rainwater insteadof harvestingpart of rainwater Individual member units will be
stockingit and reusingto reducefresh.water up encouragedand directedto opt for roof
take in view of natural resourcescoiservation top harvesting. The same will be
concept! Any way roof water and surfacerain harvestedwithin their own premises.
waterto be harvestedand only run-offwaterafter
treatmentto be recharged.pl provideschematic
diagramfor reusing rain water with proximate
assumption
on how much% freshwater( GW)up
takewill be reduced.
33
Pl providea planlayoutspecifying
free movement The approachroadshave beendesigned
of fire tenderwhich move easilyin the periphery in suchway to haveeasyaccessto each
aroundthe projectsite and aroundthe member memberunits.
units with easy reversaldrive includingposition The units being non-chemicalin the
and qty of wind socksfor existingactivities and nature,the peripheralroad within the
for proposedexpansion.
premises will be as per FactoryAct
34
35
In referenceto page 9.3 Sr No 14, the
capital cost of Rs t22.46 crores is
inclusiveof both the phases. tt is very
apparentthat the project cost for the
existingpark is Rs 111.41Croresand for
Has GPCB/safetydept earlier issued a show
additional9 units it shall be Rs 11.05
cause/closure
noticeto you or anyof your existing
crores.
units for violation of their statutory norms
towards
environment
protection/unsafeNo closure/showcausenoticehavebeen
condition?
lf so,pl providedetails.
issuedto the parksofar.
requirement.
What was the survivalrates of the trees alread Thesurvivalrate of plantedtrees 30%.
@
planted?
However,we are in processof plantation
development
in phase1.
a... Howlongconstruction
periodwill continue?
b... How you will take care of any likelyhabitat
disturbances.
c... Howyou will managefor their drinkingwater
andsanitation
facilities?
The developer is responsible for
establishing infrastructure related to
watersupply,drainageand powersupply
only.Thisdevelopment
will be completed
withinperiodof 3 years.
a...What will be your traffic
hrs?
b... Howtherewill not be anyincremental
loadof
air pollution?
The park is locatedon NationalXighway
8, havingsufficientRightof wayto absorb
the additional traffic due to proposed
park.
c... Areyou goingto haveyour own pUCcentreto
controlvehicularpollution?
d... Will you or your membersrefuseto unload
pUCstandards?
thevehicles
not complying
a... Whatwill be the minimumfire watErthat can Thefirewater
reserveto be t<eptreaOyat
be keptreadyat anypointof time?
any point of time will be @ 3000KL. No
b... Will this fire water be requiredto giveany pre-treatment
will be required.
pretreatmentfor it's suitabilityor you canuseraw
water straightaway?
ls NMQ standardsas referredare revisedone?
Yes,revisedNAAQstandardshavebeen
ls it a privateowned land or Soternm;t leased Theland private
is
land.
Whatwill be per daywater reqGremenifor
ffeen The total requirementfor green belt /
area development(freshand recycled)
will be 660 KL.
Will there be any water l"gg,,rg d* t"
construction
activitiesor on postcommissioning
of
project?
Willtherebe anychanceto disturbor diversifying
naturalnaalaor stormwaterdrainagesystem?
Howmany% peoplewill be emptoyeA
frornfocaf Theemploymentof the peoplewiil Uein
area?
accordance with
the
prevailing
Governments'
rulesandregulation.
Haveyoufollowedtheguideffi
project proponent and that for environment?
Consultant
while preparingand submittingdraft
REIAreportfor publicconsultation?
Hasanypartof
orartneffi
The secondarydata relatedto land use
other agency/agencies
( exceptECOCHEM)if so,
pattern has been procured from Vraj
have you incorporatedthe desiredinformation,s
The samehasbeenverified
in draft REIAreport alongwith their accreditation (proponent).
by the Landuseexpert.
K
YTsr
details?
As regardsdata on base line studies,can you
forward attestedcopiesof analysisdata of GW,
SW,Soil,Noiseas applicablein caseif needed?
45
As regardsdata on baseline studies,can you The data on baselinestudieswill be
foruardattestedcopiesof analysis
dataof GW, producedin caseof necessity.
SW,Soil,Noise
asapplicable
in caseif needed?
46
Would you mind if after receivingthe EC,if The ECcompliance
is beinguploadedon
plausible
stakeholderlikeme wouldliketo assess the websiteas per
ECCcondition.The
the complianceof EC conditionsand extent of
samecan be madeavailable.
In caseof
fulfilling of the commitment,smade by you
towards environmentprotection measuresand any further clarification,we requestyou
to approachin writingfor the same.
CSRactivities?
47
Whoauthorizedpersonfrom applicantside(or in Mr. YogeshThakar(Director)and Mr.
his absence,representativewho is full time Naushad Alchi (Project
manager) is
employeeand well conversantwith draft REIA
authorized and responsiblefor the
report and mitigation measures towards
environment protection) will give the project.The presentationwill be givenby
presentationand proceed further the public the proponentfor projectdetailsand by
questionna
the consultant for Environmental
iresprocess?
impacts.
rA
ln order to avoid repeatedfalsefire alarm,whii
typesof sensors
you shallinstallin firealarm?
49
Whatadditionalmeasures
you caniniorporateto Theconcept
of thegreenbuilding
shallbe
justifogreen buildingconceptspeciallyfor the
developed
byeachof theindividual
unit.
building blocks requiring air conditioning/
refrigerationand low temperaturestorageareas
as in summerwhen temperatureat project site
likelyto exceed4O/+Sdegreecentigrade
50
In caseif you or memberindustrieiuseTft to The developeris obtainingECCfor
the
conserveenergy,how you will take care of infrastructure
developmentof the park.
mercury
pollution
on itsdiscarding.
The individualmemberunitswill haveto
The required fire protective measures
and alarmswill be installedas per the
prescribed
regulations
/guidelines.
obtainthe requiredstatutorypermissions
and comply the directives of the
concernedauthority.
ForVralntegrated Textilepark [td.
E n c l . : A n ne xu re A & B
BYSEAC
TORAWARDED
TO ADDITIONAL
A : COMPLIANCE
ANNEUXRE
!X
Polnl Descrlplion
No.
I
Duly notorized undertoking
textile
no
that
$sfktg
processing, dying, gormenfing
ond woshing unit sholl be
ollowedin ihe TextilePork.
2.
the
for
Need
Proposed
justified
in
exponsionshould be
Chopter
No.
Section
No.
Poge
No.
Flgure No. I
Toble No. I
Annexure No.
AnnexureC
2.4.2
2.7
1.4
1.3
2
2.2
2.3
TobleNo.2.1C
3
3.7
3.r8
Toble3.8
no.3.3
Figure
2
2.4.5
2.11
2
2.2
2.2&
2.3
2
detoil.
3.
Project site specific detoils such
os distonce of ihe Textile Pork
boundory from the neorest (l)
Villoge (2) Woter Body : Creek /
Nolloh/ Loke / Pond / Reservoir
/ Conol (3) Notionql HighwoY
(4) Stote Highwoy (5) RoilwoY
line (6) Heritogesite (7) Notionol
Pork / Wild Life Sonctuory /
ReserveForestsholl be included
in the ropid EIA report io be
prepored covering one seoson
(otherthon monsoon)doto.
4.
5.
6.
Presenflond use pottern of the
studyoreo os well os the project
oreo sholl be given bosed on
imogery.
sotellite
Existing noturol droinoge
pottern of the project site ond
likely impocts on it due to
project.
Detoilsof lond ocquisitionfor
the proposedexponsion.
AnnexureC
{Copyof sole
deed)
ANNEUXR€A : COMPLIANSETO ADDITIONALTORAWARDEDBYSEAC
1
7.
8.
Toble2.1B
Figureno.2.2
(Pogeno.2.321
2.6
2.4.2
2
Loyout plon of the TextilePork
showing green belt, common
utilitiesond proposed industriql
with
olong
units etc.
proposed
demorcotion of
exponsionby different colour.
Provisionof seporole entry, exit
ond continuous unobstrucfed
open pofh within fhe project
qreo for unobstructed eosy
movement of the emergency
vehicle / tire tenders without
reveningbock. Mork the some
in the loyout.
Number ond types of trees Thelondof the porkbeingbonenwifhonly
julifloro,thereisno tree existingon the
existingof site, trees to be cut prosposis
for the proposeddevelopment site,hence,no tree hosto be cut for the
proposol for
tree proposeddevelopment
ond
2.fi
2.4.11
tronsplontotionis ony to b.e
2
done.
9.
Deloilsof type of industries
ond
itsnumbenwhich likelyio come
up in the TextilePork.Listof the
member units (existing ong
proposed),
produch
monufoctured /
to
be
monufoctured olong with
individuqlproductioncopocity,
effluent generotion quontity,
effiuent chorocferisticsetc.
2
2.4.2
2.6&
2.7
Tobleno.2.4A
&2.48
10.
Detoiled study on geohydrology of the oreo ond
3
3.4
3.14
AnnexureF
A : COMPLIANCETOADDIIIONALTORAWAREEDBYSEAC
ANNEUXRE
XI
ll
12.
13.
14.
impoct of proposed ground
woter extroctionon the some,
which should olso include
proposed for ground woter
rechorge. Permissionobtoined
from fhe CentrolGroundWqter
Authority for extroction of
groundwoter.
Wqter bolonce
including
quontity of effluent to be
generoted, recycled, reused
ond dischorged.
Detoils of the Combined
Effluent Treotment Plont
including its copocity, size of
eoch unit, retention time ond
otherfechnicolporometen.
Chorqcteristics of untreoted
ond treoted wostewoter. A
detoiled effluent treof obility
study vis-d-visthe odequocy
ond etficocy of the treotment
focilities proposed for the
wostewoter to be generoted
olong with odequocy ond
efficocy
report..
The
chorocferistic on
which
treotobilityis bosedshollolsobe
stoted.
Applicofion wise breok-up of
treoted effluent quontity to be
recycled / reused in ufilities,
green belt development etc.
Detoils oboui ovoilobility of
sutficientopen lond for utililng
2
2.4.4
2.to Tobleno.2.6A,
2 . 1 3 Tobleno.2.6C
2.38 Figureno.2.9
2
2.4.6
2.15
Tobfeno.2.7B
2
2.4.6
2.14
Tobleno.2]A
2
2.4.4
2.4.6
2.10
2.13
Tobleno2.6A
Tobleno 2.6C
BYSEAC
IOR AWARDED
TOADDITIONAL
A : COMPLIANCE
ANNEUXRE
xtl
treoted etfluent for plontotion /
gordening. How it will be
ensured thot treoted effluent
won't flow outsidethe premises
linked with storm woter during
highroinydqys.
2
1 5 . Detoiled loyout of effluent
conveyctncepipelinewithinthe
TextilePorkolong with distonces
ond oll lechnicol specificotions,
linediogromond totol copocity
of the pipeline to convey
effluent. Detoils of pumping
stotions,pumping copocity in
eoch pumpingstotionetc if ony
shollolsobe furnished.
1 6 . Detoilsregordinginlet normsof 2
the CEIP ond moniioring
scheme for ensuring thot
effluent received of the CffP
conform to the inlet sfondords.
Whether ony pretreotmentfor
specific porometerswould be
requiredby ony memberunii in
order to ochieve the CEIPinlet
norms.
I
1 7 . Detoilsof the monitoringplon of
the member units to ensure
complioncewith the inletnorms
of the CEIPos well os to ovoid
shockloodingon the CEIP.
8
1 8 . CEIPemergencymonogement
systemin cose of mqlfunctionof
mojor components; include
most likely molfunction I
2.4.6
2.4.6
2.13
2.14
8.5.1
8.4 &
8.5
8.5.1
8.4 &
8.5
no.2.5
Figure
{pogeno.
2.35)
Tobleno.2.7A
A: COMPTIANCEIO ADDITIONATTORAWARDEDBYSEAC
ANNEUXRE
xill
19.
disruption/ worst cose scenorio
for ossessingthe impoct &
mitigotionmeosures
Provisionof flow meter/ flow
totqlizer of the outlet of the
CETPto ensurethot dischorge
quontity ond quolity will never
exceedthe prescribedlimits.
2
n.
Explore fhe feosibilitiesfor reuse
of treoted effluent in the
proposed CPP, insteod of
ufililng if for plonlotion /
gordening.
21.
Technicol detoils of the
proposed power plont olong
with detoils of strotegy for
implementotionreuse/ recycle
ond olher cleoner production
optionsfor reductionof wostes.
Generotionof woste gosesond
utilizotionof woste heot hove to
be setout.
One
seoson site-specific
meteorologicoldoto including
temperoture,relofive humidity,
hourly wind speed ond
direction ond roinfoll sholl be
provided.
22.
23.
2.4.6
2.14
At present,il is not feosible to utilizethe treoted
effluent in CPP. However, os suggestedby the
SEAC,the possibilitieswill be explored on bosis
of the techno-economicql viobility in
consultotionwith the experts.
2
2.4.7
2.152.27
3
3.2
3.2
Tobleno.3.l
One complete seoson AAQ
3
doto (except monsoon)to be
given olong wiih the dqtes of
monitoring. The porometen to
be coveredshollincludePMl0,
PM2.5, SO2 ond NOx. The
locotion of the mor..ritoring
3.3
3.9
Tobleno.3.3
A : COMPLIANCEIO ADDITIONALTORAWARDEDBYSEAC
ANNEUXRE
xtv
24.
25.
26.
stotionsshould be so decided
so crsto toke inlo considerotion
the predominont downwind
direction,populotionzone ond
sensitive recepton including
reservedforests. Thereshould
be of leosi one monitoring
stotionin the upwind direction.
Thereshould be of leost one
moniforing stotion in the pre
dominont downwind direction
of o locotion where moximum
ground level concentrotion is
likelyfo occur.
lmpoct of the project on fhe
AAQ of the oreo. Detoilsof lhe
model used ond the input the
porometersused for modeling
should be provided. The oir
quolityconloursmoy be plotted
on o locotionmop showingthe
locotion of project site,
hobilotion,sensitivereceptors,if
ony. Thewind rosesshouldolso
be shownon thismop.
Explore the pos5ibility of
switchingover to cleoner fuel
likePNGinsteodof cool/lignite.
Type ond quontity of tud
required, its source ond
tronsportotion.Detoils of cool
hondling, storoge, etc. Fuel
onolysis
to be provided(sulphur,
osh content ond heovy metols
includingPb, Cr, As ond Hg).A
4
4.5.2
4.54.16
Figure
no.4.l4.4
2
2.4.3
2.8
2
2.4.3
2.7
TobleNo.2.5
2
2.4.7
2.16
TobleNo.2.8
2
2.4.7.1
2.16
&2.17
A : COMPLIANCETO ADDITIONALTORAWARDEDBYSEAC
ANNEUXRE
XV
27.
28.
29.
30.
confirmed fuel linkoge should
be provided.
Specificdetoilsof (i) Detoilsof
the utilitiesrequired(ii) Fluegos
emissionrote from eqch utility
{iii) Air' Pollution Control
Meqsuresproposed to eoch of
the utility olong with its
odequocy.
Technicoldetoils of ESPolong
with its odequocy, detoilsof ils
operotionolcontrolswith DCS,
systemfor online moniloringof
the pollufontsfrom the stock
etc. Detoilsof provisionsto be
kept in ESPto ensurefhot in ony
cose the oir emissiondoes not
crossthe GPCBnormsincluding
provisionof stondbyfield in the
ESP,preventive mointenonce,
foilure/ trippingcontrol system,
guoronfee from the ESp
supplier,
olternotive
onongements in cose of the
foilure/ trippingof the ESpetc..
Detoilsof Lime stone injectioh
technology to be odopted to
conirol SO2to ensurethot SO2
level in the ombient oir do not
exceed
prescribed
the
stondords.
Listof oll the sourcesof fugitive
emision. Detoiled plon for
prevenfion ond control of
fugitive emission/ dusting ot
2
2.4.7.2
2.17
2.20
2
2.4.7.5
2.232.24
2
2.4.7.5
2.24&
2.25
2
2.4.7.5
2.23
2
2.4.7.5
2,25
TORAWARDEDBYSEAC
ANNEUXRE
A : COMPLIANCE
TO ADDITIONAL
31.
32.
33.
eoch ond every stoge of fuel
hondlingincluding unlooding/
looding
stocking 'l
/
conveyonce / tronsfer etc.
Defoiled specificotions ond
schemotic diogrom of woter
sprinkling sysfem including
number of sprinklen to be
instolled, pipe diometer ond
nozzlediometerof the sprinklers,
quontity of wofer to be
consumedby sprinklers
etc.
lmpoct of the projecf on locol
infrqstructureof fhe qreo such
os on rood network due lo
tronsportotionof fuel, osh, row
moteriolsond finishedgoods of
unifs within the pork etc.
Whether ony
odditionol
infrostrucfure
would need to be
constructed ond the ogency
responsiblefor the some with
timefrome.
Defoilsof floro ond founo duly
outhenticoted should be
provided. In cose of ony
scheduledfouno, conservotion
plonshouldbe provided.
Detoilsof monogement of the
hozordous wostes to be
generoted from the project
stotingdetoil of storogeoreo for
eoch type of woste, its
hondling, its utilizofion ond
disposoletc. How the monubl
4
4.5.6
4.18
3
3.8
3.223.59
Tobleno.3.lI
&3.12
2
2.4.8
2.28
Tobleno.2.l4
BYSEAC
IOR AWARDED
TOADDITIONAL
A : COMPLIANCE
ANNEUXRE
XVII
hondling of the hozordous
wosteswill be minimized.
34.
plon
osh
of
Detoiled
hondling ond
evocuqtion,
utilizotion should be Provided.
Undertoking stoting thot qsh
2
2.4.7.5
(c)
2.26&
2.27
C
Annexure
(Undertoking)
pond sholl not be constructed
ond it shqll be stored in closed
be
should
only
silos
incorporofed.
35.
36.
37.
Copy of membershipcertificote Themembershipceriificoteof neorbyTSDF
of Common Environmentslfocilitywillbe obtoinedon commencementof
woste.
the porkfor disposolof hozordous
lnfrostructurelike TSDF,if ony
AnnexureE
2.27
2.4.7.5
2
token, shouldbe incorporqted.
{Copyof MoU
Copies of MOU / ogreements
with brick
done with octuol consumers
monufocturers)
regording utilizotionof fly osh,
bottom osh etc. shouldolsobe
incorporoted.
8.6&
8.5.3
8
Detoilsof meosuresproposed
8.7
noise pollution
the
for
obotementond itsmonitoring.
8.5& 8.6 8.4- 8.9
Environment 8
Detoiled
Monogemenf Plon of the
project with respect to woler,
noise
ond
other
oir,
environmentol otiributes. A
detoiled EMP including the
protection ond
mitigotion
meosuresfor impoct on humon
heolthond environmentos well
os detoiledmonitoringplon ond
environmentol monogement
proposed
for
cell
implementqtionond monitoring
BYSEAC
TOADDIIIONALIOR AWARDED
A : COMPLIANCE
ANNEUXRE
wlll
of EMP. The EMP should olso
include the concePt of wosteminimisqtion,recycle / reuse /
recover techniques, energy
noturol
conseryqtion, ond
resource conservotion. Totol
copitol cost ond recuning
cost/onnum eormorked for
environment Pollution control
meosures.
Occupotionol heolth imPocts
on the workersond mitigotion
meosuresproPosed to ovoid
the humon heolih hozords
olong with the Personol
protective equiPment to b'e
provided to the workers.
Provisionof industriolhygienist
the
monitoring of
ond
occupotionol injury to worken
os well os imPoct'on the
workers. Plon for Periodic
medicol check uP of the
worken exposed. Detoils of
work zone ombient oir quolitY
monitoringplon os Per Gujorot
FoctoriesRules.
Risk ossessmeni including
prediction of the wont-cose
moximum
ond
scenorio
credible occident scenorio
reloted to fire ond exPlosion
due to storogeond useof
issues
fuel shouldbe conied out. The
worst-cosescenorioshouldtoke
6.2.6.2
6 . 1 2&
6.13
6.7- 5.9
Figure6.1
A : COMPTIANCEIO ADDITIONALTORAWARDEDBYSEAC
ANNEUXRE
XIX
into occount the moximum
inventory of storoge of site ot
ony point in time. The risk
contours should be plotied on
the plont loyout mop cleorly
showing which of the qctivities
would be offected in cose of
on occident toking ploce.
Bosed on the some, proposed
sofeguord meosures including
On-Site / Otf-Site emergency
plon shouldbe provided.
40.
DisosterMonogement Plon of
the project.
6
41.
Meqsuresto guord ogoinstfire
hozords including detoils of
outomotic fire detection ond
confrol system & detoiled fire
control plon showing hydront
pipeline network, provisionof
DG Sets, fire pumps, jockey
pump, etc. should olso be
provided.
5
42.
43.
44.
6.3
6.r56.23
6.2.6.1 6.9 &
6.r0
Provisionto ensure sufficient Therewillbe provisionof 3@0Cubicmeter
woter storoge oll the time for copocityunderground
storogetonkwithinthe
useduringemergencysituotion. porkoswellos CPPoreowhichwillserveosfire
woter reserve.
Submitchecklistin the form of
8
8.5.7
8.8Do's & Don'ts of preventive
8.10
mointenonce,strengthening
of
HSE,monufocturingutility stoff
for sofetyreloied meosures.
Detoiled five yeor greenbelt
2
2.4.11
2.30
development
progrom
includingonnuolbudget
A : COMPLIANCETO ADDITIONALTORAWARDEDBYSEAC
ANNEUXRE
45.
46.
Proposol for socio'economic
octivities
developmeni
including community welfore
progrom most useful in the
project oreo for the overoll
the
of
improvement
environment.Submilo detqiled
plon for sociol corporote
responsibilities
Detoilsof schemefor surfoceoS
I
well os roof top roin woter
I
horvestingond ground woter
I
reveoling thoi I
rechorge
quontity of ground woter
I
would
b" I
extroction
compensotedby equivolentor
more quontity of roin woter
proper
with
rechorged,
colculotions
scientific
considering roinfoll in the
region,cotchment oreo, lond /
soil chorocteristics, ground
lwoter rechorge rote, durotion
lof roin woter horvestingetc.
I oetoits of provisions of preII treolment of the rginwoter in
run off is to
I the cose of surfoce
lOe horvested. Locotion of
I
I rechorge percolotion wells on
2
2.4.13
2.30
2
2.4.10
2.29
I
I theloyoutplon.
47.
Plon for complionce of the
CREP guidelines for the
proposedpower plont
48.
Plonfor complionce of the CEIP
guidelines issued by CPCB for
2
2.4.12
2.30
Willbe followed.
BYSEAC
TORAWARDED
A : COMPTIANCE
TOADDITIONAI.
ANNEUXRE
xxl
49.
50.
51.
the
Combined
Effluent
TreolmentPlont.
Point wise complionce of the
ReferAnnexureA
conditions stipuloted in the
Consbnt to Estqblishond E.C.
orderissuedto the textilepork.
Whetherony litigotionpending
No litigotionogoinsfthe compony.
ond / or ony direction / order
possed by ony Court of Low
ogoinst the compony, if so,
detoilsthereof.
A tobulor chort for the issues Willbe port of reportofterconductingpublic
roised qnd oddressed during
heoring
publicheoring/consultotion
ond
commitment of the project
proponenton the some should
be provided.An oction plon to
oddressthe issuesroisedduring
public heoring ond th."
necessqryollocolion of funds
for the some should be
provided.
ANNEXURE
B
COSTOF ENVIRONMENTAT
MANAGEMENTSYSTEM
Sr. Items
No.
Amount (Rs.ln Crores)
Cosl of Pork
Cost
Development iowords
EMS
I
Lqno cosl
2
Commoninfrostructure
A
Sitedevelopmentond Roocls
B
Wotersupply& distribution
2.44
1.1*
c
urqtnqge ltne
1.88
1.88
D
)ewoge treotmenlplont (STp)
4.83
4.83
E
Lopltve power plont
40.00
2.50**
F
Powertronsmission
ond distribution
4.61
G
Lqnascoptng
0.48
3
CommonFocilities
8.52
4
Foctorybuilding
5
Technicolfees
4.84
6
rr e-operoTtveexpenses
7.68
TOTAl
Na*a
:::.-._:
*For
", r\nsyr;teqsewage nng networK
ESPInstallationas ApC measures
13.13
12.59
21.46
122.46
\
10.31
rage t or z
\
ArvNgLvRF.CZ
\
fief.PM/MP/&a4n011
\vz
Date: 3rdNovember20il
To
ShriHardikShah
MemberSecretary
GujaratPollutionControlBoard
Gandhinagal
sub. : Environmental
PublicHearingof Vraj lntegrated
Textilepark Ltdto be heldat
Bidaj,Khedaon 04.11.2011
S
i
r
,
.
.
'l
We have reviewed draft EIA report of above mentioned project. Following
are
comments/suggestions/observations
regardingprojectand draftEIAreport.
our
1'
As per the Environmental
Clearanceissuedto this project36 projectswere supposectto be
established
in the park'Why only4 to 5 unitsare operationaitill
dateaftercommencement
of parkfor
morethan2 years?
2. Pleasejustifythe expansionof parkwhenthereare atready30 unitsstillneedto establish.
3. Whenwas landacquiredfor the expansicin
of the park?
4. Whatwasthe processof landacquisition?
Wasanygovernment
landwas acquiredfor expansion?
5' Pleasegive list of original36 unitswhichweresuppbsedto be established
plusotherunitswho are
goingto establishafterexpansion.
6. By whichdateall unitsare expectedto be fullyfunctional?
7' Thereare no detailson individual
unitsandtheirproduction
capacities
withinpark.
8. Whetheralreadyexisting4-5 unitshavesubmittedtheirEnvironmentalAudit
reportsto GpCB?lf yes
thenwhatwerethe majorcommentsof Auditor?
9' As mentionedin existingCGWA Clearance;proponenthas carriedout detailedhydrogeological
investigation
of the area?lf yes pleaseattacha copy.
10. Whetherfresh
application
to CGWAhasbeenmadefor amendedwaterrequirement
of park?
1! Whycoalbasedpowerplantshouldbe installedwhencleanerfuelare availablein the markct?
12. As mentioned
in waterbalancediagramof powerplant,RO rejectand CT & Boilerblowdownwateris
nearly500cu m per day.Pleasejustify500 cu m perday of witer usagein dustsuppression
andcoal
handlingsystemwitharea.
13. February
to April2011 doesnotrepresent
oneseasonas perguideline
of ElA,so baseline
monitoring
t. Tff [[:ilniT"T?:ff'il53'?"*""n
brick/cement
manufacturers
forconsumption
offtyash
generated
frompowerplant?lf yes givecopyof it.
15. How manypeoplewill be employedat park?Amongthem how manywouldbe localskilledand
people?
unskilled
16' In caseof failureof implementation
of Environment
Management
Plan,whowillbe heldresponsible?
17' Whatwill be responsibilities
of individual
companies
to aihievesustainable
development
and reduce
pollution?
Yourstruly
MaheshPandya
Cc.
1. Shri.M.V.Pargi,(lAS)DistrictColtector,
DlstrictKheda,
2.Mr.J.D.priyadarsni,
ResionatOfiicer,
nr:KOr*"d
,^./
,x/ \3- /t
I$\5Hf;+ffi.93
tJs....-..!"
9-9J
t
0
rage z or z
' l
"
:
ParyavaranMitra
road
502,RajAvenue,Bhaikakanagar
Thaltei,Ahmedabad- 380059
Telefax- 079-26851321
email- [email protected]
in
website- www.paryavaranmitra.org.
u
Page
1ot,
tO GSWAN
UL
CurrentFolder:INBOX
ComposeAcldressesFolders Options Search Help Fetch
N{essage
List I UnreadI Pelete
PreviouslNext
SignOut
CSWAN
ForwardIFbm'ardasAuachment
I Rcplf l Replr,All
Subject: Commentson EPH of Vraj,IntegratedTextile Park Ltd to be held at Bidaj,
Khedaon 04.11.2011
From: "paryavaranmitra" <[email protected]>
Date: Thu, Noventber3. 2OL712:43pm
To: "MS GPCB" <[email protected]>
(q$g)
Priority: Normal
VersionI boivnload
Options: YiewF\rllHeatler
rhisa.sLlilg lAcltlrg;\cklrcss
tso,r.\
I ViewPrintable
Ref.PM/MP/844/20ti.
3rd November 2011
To
Shri Hardik Shah
Member Secretary
Gujarat Pollution
Gandhinagar
Sub.
Control
Date
Board
public
: Environmental
Hearing of Vraj
Bidaj, Kheda on 04.11.2011
Integrated
TextiLe
Park Ltd
to
be he
Sir,
We have reviewed draft
EIA report
comments/suggestions/observations
of above mentioned project.
regarding
project
and draft
Following
are our
EIA report.
\
this project
3G projects
w
5 units
are operational
Li
1.
As per the EnvironrnentaL Clearance issued to
supposed to be established
in the park. Why only 4 to
date after conmencement of park for more Lhan 2 vears?
2.
PJease justify
the expansion of park when there are al-ready 30 units st
need to establish
3.
When was land acquired
for the expansion of the park?
4.
What was the process of land acquisition?
was any government land was
acquired for expansion?
5.
Please give list
of originat
36 units which were supposed to be establi
plus other units who are going to establish
after
expansion.
6,
By which date alr units are expected to be fully
functional?
7.
There are no details
on individual
units and their
production
capacitie
within Park.
8.
whether already existing
4-5 unj-ts have submitted
their
Environmental
A
reports
to GPCB? rf yes then what we::e the major corunents of Auditor?
9.
As mentioned in existing
C G I . I AC l e a r a n c e ,
proponent has carried
out deta
hydrogeorogical
investigation
of the area? rf yes please attach a copy.
10.
whether fresh application
t o C G W Ah a s b e e n m a d e f o r a m e n d e d w a t e r r e s u i r e m
of Park?
11.
why coal based power plant should be installed
when cleaner fuel are avail
in the market?
12.
As mentioned in water balance diagram of power plant,
RO reject
and CT e
Boiler
blow down water is nearly 500 cu m per day. please justify
500 cu m per d
of water usage in dust suppression
and coal handling
system with area.
13.
I'ebruary to April
2011 does not represent
one season as per guideline
of E
so baseline monitoring
does not represent
one season data.
14.
Any agreemen! has been made between bricklcement
rnanufacturers
for c o n s u m p
of fly ash generated from power plant? trf yes give copy of it.
15.
Hor., many people wi-lI be employed at park? Arnong them how many rvould be l-oc
ro uswAAl
PageZof2
skilled
and unskilled
people?
16.
rn case of failure
of implementation
of Environment Management plan, who w
be held responsible?
77.
What will
be responsibilities
of individual
companies to achieve sustainab
developrnent and reduce pollution?
Yours truly
Mahesh Pandya
Cc.
1. Shri .M.V. Pargi,
(IAS) District
2. Mr. J. D, priyadarshi,
Regional
^ j.
Colfector,
Dist,rict
Kheda, collector
Officer,
cpCB- Nadiad
Paryavaran Mitra
502, Raj Avenue, Bhaikakanagar road
Thaltej,
Ahmedabad - 380059
Telefax - 079-26851321
email - parvavaranmitra€yahoo,com
website - vrrlrw.paryavaranmitra.org.
i4
Attachments:
untitled-[2.|
.%
17*,
I texVhtml]
Porynls.+d
I View
Delete& PrevI Unread& PrevI Unread& Next I Delete& Nexr
Moveto: INBOX
office.
\z
\
rT
VRA]
Date:311112011
To,
MaheshPandya,
Paryavarn
Mitra,
502,RajAvenue,
Bhaikakanagar,
Thaltei,Ahmedabad380059
SUB: Environmental
Publichearingof VrajIntegratedTextileParkLtd at Village:
Bidaj,Kheda,Gujarat
REF: Your office letter no. PM/MP18412011
dated311112011
DearSir,
reply
subject.Pleasefindbelowthepointwise
Thisis withreference
to abovementioned
forthequestions
raisedin the letterundeireference.
issuedto this project36 projectswere
Glearance
1. As perthe Environmental
supposedto be establishedin the park. Why only 4 to 5 units are
of parkfor morethan2 years?
operationaltill dateaftercommencement
for ECCfor first phase,it was plannedto have36
At the time of approaching
plotsand accordingly
36 memberunitswere envisagedfor eachof the plot.
demandfor largerplotsthe multiplenumbers
However
becauseof the purchase,
As a
of plotsadjacentto eachotherhas beenprocuredby manypromoters.
result,numberof unitshavebeenreducedto21. Out of these21, allthe plots
phase.
andsevenare in construction
havebeensotdout andfiueareoperating
trainingcentreand
for administrative
building,
Whereas
threeplotsarededicated
textile
six are soldto non polluting
combined
treatmentplant.While'remainlng
unit whichwillnothaveanydyeingor processhouse.
relatedto
All the plotshavebeensold out to the membersand infrastructure
etc.
pipelinefor re-useof thetreatedwater,rainwaterharvesting
roads,draining,
havebeencompleted
sincethegrantof EC.
Lr'|
'(-\.
.'yn'
p60"
u
(
VRA]
2. Pleasejustify the expansion of park when there are already 30 units still
needto establish.
Because of the availability of good infraqtructureand forward-backward
integratedunit, there is a demandfor new plots.As a result,the park is being
expandedwith enhancedpowergenerationcapacity.
3. Whenwas land acquired for the expansionof the park?
The landfor expansionhas begunpasteighteenmonthsconsideringthe success
of phase-|.
4. What was the process of land acquisition?Was any government land was
acquiredfor expansion?
No Governmentland has beenacquiredfor the proposedpark.
5. Pleasegive list of original 36 units which were supposed to be established
plus other units who are going to establishafter expansion.
The profileof existingmemberunitsas per earlierEIA reportis as shownbelqrv:
TABLE{: MEMBERUNITPROFILEOF THEPARK(PHASE1) AS PEREARLIEREIA REPORT
Sr.
No.
Typeof activity
1
Spinning
Weavino
Processinq
2
3
4
Garmentino
5
Sizinq
6
Yarndveing
TOTAL
Therevisedprofileforthe phase2is shownbelow:
No.of units
1
14
1
18
1
1
36
N
VRA]
TABLE2 : MEMBERUNITPROFILEOFTHEPARK(PHASE1) AS PERREIA REPORTFOR
HXPANSION
Sr.
No.
Type of activity
1
Soinnino
Weavino
Finishing
Knittino
TechnicalTextile
2
3
4
5
6
7
1s
CommonInfrastructure
Traininqcenter
No. of units
1
8
3
4
1
3
1
20
6. By whichdateall units areexpectedto be fully functional?
by
all plotsalongwiththe infrastructure
Theparkwill be readyfor possession-of
theendot 2012.
7. Thereare no detailson individualunits and their productioncapacities
withinPark.
of eachunitwillbedecided
in Point(5).TheCapacity
Thedetailsarementioned
by the memberunit. However,it. has beendecidednot to allot any plot to
purchase
submitted.
house,dyeingunitas pertheUndertaking
8. Whetheralready existing 4{ units have submittedtheir Environmental
Audit reports to GPGB?lf yes then what were the maior commentsof
Auditor?
AuditSchemeforthefiveunits,asthey
of Environmental
Thereis noapplicability
do nothaveanyprocesswastewater.
9. As mentionedin existing CGWAClearance,proponenthas carried out
investigationof the area?lf yes pleaseattacha
detailedhydro-geological
copy.
N
VRA]
The Park is in the developmentphasefor the Phase-|,henceno detailedhydrogeologicalinvestigation
has beencarriedout.
10. Whether fresh application to GGWA has been made for amendedwater
requirementof Park?
Yes, fresh applicationto CGWA has been submittedmade for the amended
waterquantityalongwith the report.
11.Why coal based power plant shoutObe instaltedwhen cteanerfuel are
availablein the market?
The detailexplanationhas beencoveredat page2.8 of DraftEIA PublicHearing
report.
12.As mentionedin water balancediagramof power plant, RO reject and CT &
Boiler blow down water is nearl/ 500 cu m per day. Pleasejustify 500 cu m
per day of water usage in dust suppressionand coal handling system with
area.
The re-useof the treatedwastewaterfor the dustsuppressionwill not be 500 mg
It is anticipatedto be 650 KL maximum@ 30 L per tonne of coal.The restis to
be re-usedfor toilet flushing,gardeningafter blendingwith fresh water as be
seenfromT 2.6C,page2.13of the.DraftEIAreport.
13.Februaryto Aprit 2011does not representone season as per guidelineof
ElA,so baselinemonitoring does not representone season data.
The baselinedata has been carriedout from 14h Feb 2011 to 7h May 2011
representing
the summerseason.
for
{4. Any agreementhas been madebetweenbricUcementmanufacturerc
consumptionof fly ash generatedfrom powerplant?lf yes givecopyof it.
L
N
manufacturersis part of Drafi EIA
The copy of the agreementwith the Brick
reportasmentionedinAnnexureE.Weareinprocessoftie.upwiththecement
units.
manufacturing
{5.Howmanypeop|ewi||beemp|oyedatpark?Amongthemhowmany
people?
woutd be locat skilled and unskilled
about 2o'0oo-22'000people'
There will be direcuindirectemploymentof
accordancewith the prevailing
Employmentof the local people will be in
centre has beenplanned
VocationalTraining
Governmentrulesand regulations.
for localpeoplefor the skilledemployment'
of EnvironmentManagementPlan'
16. In case of failure of implementation
who will be held resPonsible?
for the
park Limitedwiil be responsible
The deveroperi.e. Vraj Integratedrextire
effectiveimp|ementationofEnvironmenta|ManagementP|an.
individual companies to achieve
17. what will be responsibilities of
pollution?
sustainabledevelopmentand reduce
\
of the parkis to havesustainable
one of the basicaimsof the development
and backward
interaliaswith unitshavingend productsforward
development
units to have Environmental
integration.Park will also facilitatemember
measurethroughthe requiredtraining
Protection
for Environmental
Awareness
from
requiredpermission
program. Individualcorlpanieswill haveto obtain
authorities'
concerned
Thanking
You.
Youts fafinftilly'
Textile
ccro,
l. R.O.,GPCB,Nadiad
.
*{gq carro H{"tr*-
srfH\a\\u
c.( sx
c\,
\\st\\"\ott_
+\et\bq.
\,1n.
{t;.
"irq.$
;_
-.'r\arn
.{ntrtt
. d\, Lt\SLr-
tf t6. qqlSa(f\.t
1
AxNgxuR6;
c3
sb:*+ .nGol,$,
Uet{ ''}sr,
CquEiA 4>1.fr1 ql\
qrsror{r\ <,rrts{e,
b\\o\"(z.t *rrtorqJ,
atzt o9q *rr0 qrcrc\al '( (,\' "r'rl$ g Gdlqlq
1\{\ i{\d
rrof\oru'r acr\ r:\ g*.r rqi arrr\ . D\ \al
"$
>1\er,o0 q11ee\rtel
Ffat eqlantr1 g.{c11 Ar^\*A ql
\ra\
\\
e,"r\+tl
Sf\"rrt 3tat. %."^G crd t=4oi
5ar'\a{
g-r.rr"tr anr\
tc,rrgr Fgbq
,
.pr,\ g-l'qi
I Gl .*tl
cz-rQ >^\ \"i.rl]
?\at {ute1r1 -6a,qrati -r.-"rr
ar*il 6\R\€ d{ .tq tets
A$ tor 4.1 t*^n
8"tc-ttu\ .rsrr\..,
adl,
.<do E{\.{
Ct I xr{
gl\ctter\
"fgi
c\c\q{
err1\\@\d) ctu\rqt,
{
2".,Qt
C* I \"\r.?i\
li\trqr
cQrrre\
S \S
ca I D\\{\ Gl.r \r3r
"aRth
ru
b,4
"G
s2flr(j!\\a
4".{
Vt{Vtg0 -ro,^.,^l.
gafi -dt.
g3gu1 q\
-}"
abo.J&,
cnr.,'f, -enr\ .t.,'it"-fli
@r\f
a
tt,1
clg
e{znrrcl
da-q., i
€g
-lrr\ql
anLrcr.ê\r_
c^r"( $qrr/
6"\\\ "'.'..\ enrt.-l *r.t
"l
-t{O,
\
otttr.{qi
OrSrtl
>,{L\lhl<
SteNS.
FIl
VRA]
dt. r otiaoR eott
}Ja,
$. rtr. q?arr?,
1''I ' ott\tt, ct . et96
J?r@latatelqte
f4qqsgt 6Ga+>s)sua6q rus fdft)s
rr{qr$)q o\sgarcst 6rr6rd
"il
au't"ttqiltEst,
Utrtlougr?r alue dfQa ?gltrd eteil wttcrcusi $, otr cuord t4t t
{qte4i ect0t &. uru{r r}uraai
-oua %4tactuE ""ioti tsude "tO. ut
ottGrd
at \s'[s Gqqcq't4t.
ectrE,tt srrrului e*tr\t uu-uaru
se)Qu
ai {qs ilrqqr f{,tttt, o\ ertrerqil*q\"rr€rc,g*tt u"r,r.
urqa) f4rcug,
gt 6Ga+>s)suauSqqrS fdfDs cr0r
Q1-"
3?.*^^ )
<-___J
OrS
d 5 a d , c r r a t t y: , i t n l ! f g ' r ' ] , ' J " ( Q r ' 1 ) t 1 t ' r t lf\o t a t t t ' r
,{q1EtL
--_________=_
- 1
a't/% crttf g/sq :u 'l a,,rk1
Za41 ort ,:?5._A7
&4r%
€11, v/ zq I coz?-
-
A x N g X u RE ; C {
Yrdq'l ,
gc$Vee<r,?*t*'l
n
\
Ueau z-'tsr
*lDr{ -zncz-t.t\
J
;;a?
/uau:_
ar raro{14 ur r! o+ -fl ,
of24
r
Tzt"
41f?-1"14
't"'J
(n!"1
a4at)3
1
;;; -cl4 c'flsr"t"ia/'*n?tjfl
X;':,
8'_K'
o?rc,t"':u
*fl",i d
- )
d'urc"r &, te G' f';.*;:rl
i
vt<Ja rA
ui
"7
J
\ ^
\
cJllf t E I ott
3i72r1751' qJlq
or,tf i
>l 6U
#)
€44t ;\r
ei\'
92t1i
.
A
ttsrr< aqi a
a-'tr\ a<,?qi
't"'n
4l
t
'
\
e 4'-ril$r
-,.
\
crttYll
'
'\ u
dq
*tn'"t
4'?{t6l
n -'qa?atc4
't^ *'rzte;s-bet :*--?*.u*',,1t
(<''t'-'
i?bn+
3 ' -' '
a r 7 1?1: u 1 ' t t '
o-ir'n
r)vltel
n
cltrt4
&'{Ll'
friel
,,':Ht-:* ;,;';':f":&'ry
o-4tt ?Adc-fl
o.,''V=''el
cruto< e->tttclta+| 't'r'r$
"i
'
-e-zrbC-f 2'd
"']1.1
(-t) 6ij
.:;sn.,l .,-r^.ororr zr}y.'a"'il
-Ltl?6t t-4'
oz-D|.fir,tl ",zntt'i' ;
r,|t|
't
^ \ !
r-.!.. '{{""ir-rdt
,- ^n --,'
''b
qt
' e'tta44gr^}ti
'
*>1alctr
'arr><lal
a-r1
clql
o O Ce r Eh
'r,nti
a4hrr?s')
f
auql ;
g
hl
G^-4
. lLro(al"
,',
:>-+'\4
on,)a
-rotver
-r,rrc-1il A -". b-gr 4{1. .
t -IPt c';itt'l
6u'*r1 .i*n 1"i4 a*r1.
41 '<-r'.-l 6n+a757c'l<?.'t{ d.
";
or-nr{
4^t-t*J
-I-l,l,et "€tt
+..?-*,q.rJ"\ &\"n
oant
-+$4 c{.id.
oe,ft(>rte
Gnrql
=il"ra
cd+}er:r<rr b 4
"}s$f}
-eaui, h-4 r"r.,l.rr\
e €lli
d4€
411t16'11 n-f9-ftqi
Cel, ).\rn .e elleer
Car t\tn11s.-fl"fikg,.
Cal {i *tn sqJ q, c-,'Cnt}:li?et R
(rs) ri\t c,at tttl b^L\
(.rr qai)-\c'..-.J
\.Âo-J
c$)
rrJ*\.,,
e.'1...1.
olt(c'rJ
(sr \r4,\ah(\
(r:
"S\r e,..f,t+
\$rl_
(e'l Q,ttttlvrCvrt
rn"rit",rnr rf
GeJ
On)
BF ,q
lltv
{-:rt.
pf ?rfl
r1\-F a4Tluei
rll
VRAJ
d[. u otiaett ?ol,t
}Ja,
dtetet cu dts'r rl,laror[u\gc\,
9@rtd@tt6
U.rt\. 4'tst, ctt. e96
RG<itot4erqle
f4qqegt 6lla+)s )sila6e
q,r$fAf{X 4} rrr{qr$rt e\sgarct'r} qrord
at"tdlq ilLEaL
e'ttqott€t?t ade QJttcr tgedtd qrei, tsrtcctgi s', ott cttotd t4"r
+iqte4 qrrt t4'tc eqrcr ghr otru\cr {rJt'us eiUqil a ecu0t r}, *ai
tdl"t'tt ctuldlta"r 4eustsRottd.s qtruett ue'rti r\qputc\ ilat\{t Qtt?t
b. ottq"il tgutaal t4)a.tr n{ 'ton wude c4\. utt ouordar \sJs
eqeoq d4t. erutaecl lgtt srctuuui e*tA"r ttr\ e'rartt st)t ai {q$
tttqctt A"i{'t, c\ o1 eteri.-rt\c{ €{d$st e1strt
ourqa\fdrcrrg
gt 6Jla+)s)silau6eqr$ fd.f4)sqCt
G;gl,'^rt
-
\9 !tu\)
rr r)tlr :r/bstaJ.:5"c?
q$zltt- ,
, . (
lf\q7Q\crlt
*Th,e
l-'hrtFu/At:'-f"x
d+d r/ro/r-olt
1
\
l > r vl A
'Eii-,ii,,-i_
Dt
t
frr
f4
s,o g
.;*:l***-r*o*',t+:::":etigei**;i
t**
-,
- ?'t
j i Dl t r I t

Mv Pargi f - Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Transcription

Similar documents

2 DAY Eponoquest

Quad Answers Take Home

Inżynier Utrzymania Ruchu – Elektryk

ChemAlloy Article

k`mY ZeQ./u( Tenta:

WRITING SKITTS CHECKTIST PLANNING WRITINC

INFORMATION - Types of Energy part 1

FOTECMASK rg

CFM Board Chairman Resignation and New Appointment