Section 4: Hazard Analysis
Transcription
Section 4: Hazard Analysis
SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS INTRODUCTION This section of the Plan describes the natural hazards that can occur in the Southside Hampton Roads region and provides information such as general background information, local data (such as the location 1 and spatial extent) and historical occurences for each hazard. This section also presents best available 2 data regarding notable historical damages within the region. The hazards discussed in this section are as follows: FLOOD HURRICANES AND TROPICAL STORMS SEVERE THUNDERSTORMS LIGHTNING TORNADOES WINTER STORMS AND NOR‟EASTERS EROSION (COASTAL AND RIVERINE) EARTHQUAKES LANDSLIDES SINKHOLES DROUGHT WILDFIRE DAM/LEVEE FAILURE TSUNAMIS EXTREME TEMPERATURES 44 CFR Requirement Part 201.6(c)(2)(i): The risk assessment shall include a description of the type, location and extent of all natural hazards that can affect the jurisdiction. The plan shall include information on previous occurrences of hazard events and on the probability of future hazard events. Some of these hazards are interrelated (for example, hurricane events can cause flooding and tornado activity and nor-easters can cause flooding, coastal erosion and winter storm conditions), and thus discussion of these hazards may overlap where necessary throughout the risk assessment. To a large extent, historical records are used to identify the level of risk within the planning area—with the methodological assumption that the data sources cited are reliable and accurate. This section also provides a series of maps that illustrate the location and spatial extent for those hazards within the region that have a recognizable geographic boundary (i.e., hazards that are known to occur in particular areas of 1 Significant historical events are based on information made available through the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) unless otherwise cited. In most cases, NOAA information is obtained directly from NOAA‟s National Climatic Data Center (NCDC), the world‟s largest archive of weather data. 2 Historical damage information is based on best available data and should only be considered approximate figures for general analysis and planning purposes. More information on the calculation of estimated property damages is provided in Section 6: Vulnerability Assessment. HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:2 the region such as the 100-year floodplain). For those hazards with potential risk not confined to a particular geographic area (such as winter storms, thunderstorms and tornadoes), historical event locations and/or general information on the applicable intensity of these events across the entire planning area is provided. It is important to note that for most hazards analyzed in this section, some level of property damage was possible during any or all of the hazard events cataloged. However, for events that occurred deeper in the region‟s past, historical records in some instances may show no report of property damage. Therefore, totals of past property damages derived from historical records are considered to be estimates and should not be used as a stand-alone indicator of hazard risk. The next section included in this Plan, the Vulnerability Assessment, further expands upon the foundation established in this section and provides information on the vulnerability of the jurisdiction in the region to the hazards presented here. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 4:3 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS SUMMARY OF PRESIDENTIAL DISASTER DECLARATIONS A presidential disaster declaration is issued when a disaster event has been determined to be beyond the capabilities of state and local governments to respond. Since 1953— the first year presidential disaster declarations were issued in the United States—the region has been named in seven such declarations (Table 4.1). Under a presidential disaster declaration, the state and affected local governments are eligible to apply for federal funding to pay 75 percent of the approved costs for debris removal, emergency services related to the storm, and the repair or replacement of damaged public facilities. The types of natural hazards that led to these disaster declarations in the Southside Hampton Roads region are ice storms, winter storms and hurricanes. The most recent disaster to impact the region was Hurricane Isabel which made landfall on September 18, 2003. Hurricane Isabel set records for number of disaster victims, breadth of power outages, dollars spent for citizen and local government response and recovery, and the largest grant for mitigation projects for the State. Altogether 100 Commonwealth jurisdictions were declared disaster areas; 93,139 individuals in the declared jurisdictions applied for federal and state assistance; more than $257 million in state and federal assistance has been provided to individuals and business owners for recovering from the storm; $105 million was distributed to local governments for debris removal, emergency protective services and permanent work; and $25,937,544 was provided to support emergency needs such as water, ice, and generators at critical public facilities. The second most recent disaster to impact the region occurred during the night of the 24th and lasted through the 25th of January 2000, when a winter storm produced record breaking snowfall in many areas of the state. A freezing rain storm on Super Bowl Sunday swept through Virginia and coated much of the State in heavy ice. As a result, power lines were down and 285,000 Dominion Virginia Power customers in central Virginia lost power for over three days. The President declared 103 Virginia jurisdictions eligible for federal disaster assistance on February 28th. TABLE 4.1: PRESIDENTIAL DISASTER DECLARATIONS ISSUED FOR THE SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS REGION YEAR DATE DISASTER NUMBER DISASTER TYPE 1972 September 8 339 Tropical Storm Agnes 1996 February 16 1086 Blizzard of 1996 1996 October 23 1135 Hurricane Fran 1998 October 9 1242 Hurricane Bonnie 1999 September 24 1293 Hurricane Floyd 2000 February 28 1318 Severe Winter Storm 2003 September 18 1491 Hurricane Isabel CITY/COUNTY Isle of Wight County, Norfolk, Portsmouth, Suffolk, and Virginia Beach Isle of Wight County, Norfolk, Portsmouth, Suffolk and Virginia Beach Isle of Wight County and Suffolk Norfolk, Portsmouth, Suffolk and Virginia Beach Isle of Wight County, Norfolk, Portsmouth, Suffolk, and Virginia Beach Isle of Wight County and Suffolk Isle of Wight County, Norfolk, Portsmouth, Suffolk and Virginia Beach Source: FEMA SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:4 NATIONAL CLIMATIC DATA CENTER STORM EVENT DATABASE Much of the data on the remaining tables in this section was taken from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration‟s (NOAA), National Climatic Data Center (NCDC) database. NCDC receives storm data from the National Weather Service who, in turn, receives their information from a variety of sources, including, but not limited to: county, state and federal emergency management officials, local law enforcement officials, skywarn spotters, National Weather Service damage surveys, newspaper clipping services, the insurance industry and the general public. Information on hazard events not recorded in this database is discussed in narrative format in each of the following hazard subsections. Because NCDC data is most accurate beginning from the early to mid 1990‟s it is only marginally useful. In most cases, local or anecdotal data was used to help supplement the NCDC data to provide a more accurate depiction of previous hazard occurrences in the region. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:5 FLOOD BACKGROUND Flooding is the most frequent and costly of all natural hazards in the United States, and has caused more than 10,000 deaths since 1900. Approximately 90 percent of presidentially declared disasters result from flood-related natural hazard events. Taken as a whole, more frequent, localized flooding problems that do not meet federal disaster declaration thresholds ultimately cause the majority of damages across the United States. Floods are generally the result of excessive precipitation, and can be characterized as follows: general floods, in which precipitation occurs over a given river basin for a long period of time; and flash Flooding from Hurricane Floyd in Suffolk washes floods, which are the product of heavy localized out a road and bridge. Photo courtesy of the City of precipitation falling in a short time period over a Suffolk. given location. The severity of a flood event is determined by the following factors: a combination of stream and river basin topography and physiography, hydrology, precipitation and weather patterns, recent soil moisture conditions, and the degree of vegetative clearing in and around flood-prone areas. General floods may last for several days or even weeks. The primary types of general flooding include riverine, coastal and urban flooding. Riverine flooding is a function of excessive precipitation levels and water runoff volumes within a stream or river. Coastal flooding is typically a result of storm surge, winddriven waves, and heavy rainfall produced by hurricanes, tropical storms, nor‟easters and other large coastal storms. Urban flooding occurs where man-made development has obstructed the natural flow of water and decreased the ability of natural groundcover to absorb and retain surface water runoff. Most flash flooding is caused by slow-moving thunderstorms in a localized area or by heavy rains associated with hurricanes and tropical storms. Flash flooding can also occur due to accelerated snow melt, a dam or levee failure, or from a sudden release of water held by an ice jam. Although flash flooding occurs often along mountain streams, it is also common in urbanized areas where much of the ground is covered by impervious surfaces. Flash flood waters can move at very high speeds and “walls” of water have been known to reach heights of 10 to 20 feet. Flash flood waters and the accompanying debris can uproot trees, roll boulders, destroy buildings, and obliterate bridges and roads. The periodic flooding of lands including and adjacent to rivers, streams, and shorelines, referred to as the floodplain, is a natural and inevitable occurrence that can be expected to take place based upon established recurrence intervals. The recurrence interval of a flood is defined as the average time interval, in years, expected between a flood event of a particular magnitude and an equal or larger flood. As the magnitude of a hypothetical flood scenario increases the recurrence interval increases. That is, the greater the magnitude of a given event, the less likely it will occur over time. Floodplains are delineated by the frequency of the flood that is large enough to cover them. For example, the 10-year floodplain will be covered by a 10-year flood (should it occur) and the 100-year floodplain by the 100-year flood. Flood frequencies such as the 100-year flood are determined by plotting a graph of the size of all known floods for an area and determining how often floods of a particular size occur. Another way of expressing the flood frequency is the chance of occurrence (expressed as a percent) in a SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 4:6 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS given year of a flood event of a given magnitude. For example, the 100-year flood has a 1 percent chance of occurring in any given year. Table 4.2 shows flood damage values by fiscal year from a national perspective. TABLE 4.2: NATIONAL FLOOD DAMAGE BY FISCAL YEAR (OCTOBER–SEPTEMBER) FISCAL YEAR DAMAGE 1960 $111,168,000 1961 $147,680,000 1962 $86,574,000 1963 $179,496,000 1964 $194,512,000 1965 $1,221,903,000 1966 $116,645,000 1967 $291,823,000 1968 $443,251,000 1969 $889,135,000 1970 $173,803,000 1971 $323,427,000 1972 $4,442,992,000 1973 $1,805,284,000 1974 $692,832,000 1975 $1,348,834,000 1976 $1,054,790,000 1977 $988,350,000 1978 $1,028,970,000 1979 $3,626,030,000 1980 No data 1981 No data 1982 No data 1983 $3,693,572,000 1984 $3,540,770,000 1985 $379,303,000 1986 $5,939,994,000 1987 $1,442,349,000 1988 $214,297,000 1989 $1,080,814,000 1990 $1,636,366,000 1991 $1,698,765,000 1992 $672,635,000 1993 $16,364,710,000 1994 $1,120,149,000 1995 $5,110,714,000 1996 $6,121,753,000 1997 $8,934,923,000 1998 $2,465,048,000 1999 $5,450,375,000 2000 $1,336,744,000 2001 $7,158,700,000 Source: National Weather Service IMPLICIT PRICE DEFLATOR DAMAGE IN 1995 DOLLARS 0.22620 0.22875 0.23180 0.23445 0.23792 0.24241 0.24934 0.25698 0.26809 0.28124 0.29623 0.31111 0.32436 0.34251 0.37329 0.40805 0.43119 0.45892 0.49164 0.53262 0.58145 0.63578 0.67533 0.70214 0.72824 0.75117 0.76769 0.79083 0.81764 0.84883 0.88186 0.91397 0.93619 0.95872 0.97870 1.00000 1.01937 1.03925 1.05199 1.06718 1.08960 1.11539 SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN $491,000,000 $646,000,000 $373,000,000 $766,000,000 $818,000,000 $5,041,000,000 $468,000,000 $1,136,000,000 $1,653,000,000 $3,161,000,000 $587,000,000 $1,040,000,000 $13,698,000,000 $5,271,000,000 $1,856,000,000 $3,306,000,000 $2,446,000,000 $2,154,000,000 $2,093,000,000 $6,808,000,000 No data No data No data $5,260,000,000 $4,862,000,000 $505,000,000 $7,737,000,000 $1,824,000,000 $262,000,000 $1,273,000,000 $1,856,000,000 $1,859,000,000 $718,000,000 $17,069,000,000 $1,145,000,000 $5,111,000,000 $6,005,000,000 $8,597,000,000 $2,343,000,000 $5107,000,000 $1227,000,000 $6418,000,000 U.S. POPULATION (MILLIONS) 180.671 183.691 186.538 189.242 191.889 194.303 196.560 198.712 200.706 202.677 205.052 207.661 209.896 211.909 213.854 215.973 218.035 220.239 222.585 225.055 227.225 229.466 231.664 233.792 235.825 237.924 240.133 242.289 244.499 246.819 249.464 252.153 255.030 257.783 260.327 262.803 265.229 267.784 270.248 272.691 282.125 284.797 DAMAGE PER CAPITA (1995 DOLLARS) 2.72 3.51 2.00 4.05 4.26 25.94 2.38 5.71 8.24 15.60 2.86 5.01 65.26 24.87 8.68 15.31 11.22 9.78 9.40 30.25 0.00 0.00 0.00 22.50 20.62 2.12 32.22 7.53 1.07 5.16 7.44 7.37 2.82 66.22 4.40 19.45 22.64 32.11 8.67 18.73 4.35 22.54 MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:7 LOCATION AND SPATIAL EXTENT Hydrological features are plentiful in the Southside Hampton Roads region. From the Chesapeake Bay, to the Elizabeth River and branches, the Blackwater River in Isle of Wight County and the Atlantic Ocean along the shores of Virginia Beach, water is a major part of the way of life in the region. When heavy or prolonged rainfall events and/or hurricanes, tropical storms and other coastal storms (including nor‟easters) occur, these rivers, streams and bodies of water are susceptible to some degree of riverine and coastal flooding. There have been a number of past riverine and coastal flooding events, ranging widely in terms of location, magnitude and impact. Other flood events that occur in the region are localized in nature, resulting from heavy rains occurring in a short period of time over urbanized areas that are not able to adequately handle stormwater runoff. These events typically do not threaten lives or 3 property and do not result in emergency or disaster declarations. The coastal flooding hazards associated with hurricanes and tropical storms are included separately under the “flood” hazard. In so doing, the storm surge hazard has been identified as a unique flood and will be addressed separately from the “100-year” coastal and riverine flood hazard in the Hazard Identification and Analysis and Vulnerability Assessment sections. Figures 4.1 through 4.7 show the existing potential flood hazard areas throughout the region based on the best available GIS data for FEMA‟s identified 100-year floodplains (areas inundated by a flood with a recurrence interval of once every hundred years, also referred to as the flood with an annual chance of one percent). The official flood maps for each jurisdiction in the region vary in age. Where available, more detailed flood hazard data for each participating jurisdiction within the region is provided in Section 5: Vulnerability Assessment. Figures 4.8 through 4.12 show the storm surge hazard areas that can be expected as the result of Category 2, 3 and 4 hurricanes, based on the Sea, Lake and Overland Surge from Hurricanes (SLOSH) model. SLOSH is a computerized model run by the National Weather Service to estimate storm surge heights resulting from hypothetical hurricanes by taking into account the maximum of maximums of various category hurricanes as it relates to pressure, size, forward speed and sustained winds. The regional analysis represents the composite maximum water inundation levels for a series of parallel tracks making landfall at various points along the coast. The SLOSH model, therefore, is best used for defining the “worst case scenario” of potential maximum surge for particular locations as opposed to the regional impact of one singular storm surge event. 3 The vast majority of flood events in the United States do not meet the per capita damage thresholds required to trigger a presidential disaster declaration and the release of large sums of federal aid. This fact demonstrates the need for local governments to establish a comprehensive mitigation strategy that includes achievable actions that do not rely entirely on assistance from the state and federal government. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 4:8 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS SIGNIFICANT HISTORICAL EVENTS4 Many of the historical flood events that have occurred in the region have been the result of coastal storms, tropical storms or hurricanes. Other localized flooding occurs when heavy rains fall during high tide causing waters that would normally drain quickly to back up because of the tides. Based on historical and anecdotal evidence, it is clear that there is a relatively high frequency of flooding in the region. Some of the notable flood events to impact the region are discussed below. The Storm of 1749 is one of the most notable storms to occur in this region. It was responsible for the formation of Willoughby Spit, a formation of land approximately two miles long and a quarter mile wide. This storm created a fifteen (15) foot storm surge that flooded much of the region. Photo credit: City of Portsmouth. An unnamed hurricane struck the region on August 23, 1933 and created a high tide in Norfolk of 9.69 feet above Mean Lower Low Water (MLLW), a record for the area. Eighteen people were killed by this storm that also flooded downtown Norfolk and destroyed homes at Ocean View. Winds were recorded at 70 mph in Norfolk, 82 mph at Cape Henry, and 88 mph at the Naval Air Station in Norfolk. The Ash Wednesday storm of 1962 produced very high flooding throughout the Southside Hampton Roads region partly because it occurred during "Spring Tide" (sun and moon phase to produce a higher than normal tide). The storm moved north off the coast past Virginia Beach and then reversed its course moving again to the south and bringing with it higher tides and higher waves which battered the coast for several days. The storm's center was 500 miles off the Virginia Capes when water reached 9 feet at Norfolk and 7 feet on the coast. Huge waves toppled houses into the ocean and broke through Virginia Beach's concrete boardwalk and sea wall. Houses on the bay side also saw extensive tidal flooding and wave damage. The beaches and shorefront had severe erosion. Locals indicated that the damage from this storm was worse in Virginia Beach than that caused by the 1933 Hurricane. The islands of Chincoteague and Assateague were completely submerged. Receding water exposed hundreds of thousands of dead chickens drowned by the flooding. The Virginia Department of Health indicated that it was an extreme health hazard and asked all women, children and elderly to evacuate. A million dollars in damage was done to NASA's Wallops Island launch facility and an estimated $4 million in wind and flood damages occurred to the City of Hampton. Winds were recorded at speeds up to 70 mph causing 40-foot waves at sea. This storm also produced Virginia's greatest 24-hour snowfall with 33 inches and the greatest single storm snowfall with 42 inches (these were recorded to the West in the Shenandoah Mountains). 4 Many of the flood events that have occurred in the Southside Hampton Roads Region have been caused by hurricanes, tropical storms or nor‟easters that have impacted the region. Therefore, there will be some duplication of discussions about the significant historical events across the different hazards. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 4:9 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS In September of 1999, Hurricane Floyd was responsible for wind and flood damage in the Southside Hampton Roads region. Several trees were uprooted as wind speeds were recorded between 50 and 80 mph across the region. Flood waters washed out parts of Route 10 between Isle of Wight County and Suffolk. Highway 32, a major evacuation route, was flooded in Suffolk. Suffolk reported 78 homes and 25 businesses damaged by floodwaters and many other homes and businesses were flooded across the region. In September of 2003, Hurricane Isabel caused flooding in the region that in some areas was as bad as the flooding caused by the 1933 hurricane and the Ash Wednesday Storm of 1962. Table 4.3 provides information on 21 significant flood events that are known to have occurred between 1994 Rainfall totals from Hurricane Floyd. and 2004 in the Southside Hampton Roads region. Source: NOAA Climate Prediction Center The flood events documented by the National Climatic Data Center resulted in a total within the region of no known deaths or injuries, and only approximately 5 $670,000 in total reported property damages. TABLE 4.3: SIGNIFICANT FLOOD EVENTS (1993-2004) LOCATION Norfolk, Virginia Beach, Hampton Roads, and Isle of Wight County DATE OF OCCURRENCE TYPE OF EVENT DEATHS/ INJURIES PROPERTY DAMAGE 11/17/1994 Coastal Flooding 0/ 0 $605,000 DETAILS Strong easterly flow between Hurricane Gordon, a category 1 storm meandering 150 miles south of Cape Hatteras, and a strong anticyclone over New England, caused significant coastal flooding and damage in the Sandbridge section of Virginia Beach, beginning around noon on November 17th. The worst flooding occurred on the 18th when tides were running up to 4 feet above normal. The heaviest damage occurred along 14th street, where 100 feet of the fishing pier washed away. Several homes suffered minor damage, with two requiring extra work to remain in place. A 1000-foot stretch of road and several protective steel bulkheads were damaged. The abovenormal tides caused other minor flooding in Tidewater. The Nansemond River overflowed its banks in Suffolk and caused minor flooding. High tides on the James and Pagan Rivers caused several roads to be under water in eastern Isle of Wight County. 5 Obviously, there has been more monetary flood damage in the region other than that recorded by the National Climatic Data Center. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 4:10 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS TABLE 4.3: SIGNIFICANT FLOOD EVENTS (1993-2004) DATE OF OCCURRENCE TYPE OF EVENT DEATHS/ INJURIES PROPERTY DAMAGE Norfolk, Virginia Beach, Suffolk, and Isle of Wight County 12/23/1994 Coastal Flooding 0/ 0 $65,000 Norfolk 7/18/1996 Flash Flood 0/ 0 $0 Virginia Beach 7/18/1996 Flash Flood 0/ 0 0 Portsmouth 7/24/1999 Flash Flood 0/ 0 $0 Suffolk Norfolk 7/24/1999 7/24/1999 Flash Flood Flash Flood 0/ 0 0/ 0 $0 $0 Virginia Beach Portsmouth Norfolk 7/24/1999 Flash Flood 0/ 0 0 8/14/1999 8/14/1999 Flash Flood Flash Flood 0/ 0 0/ 0 $0 $0 Virginia Beach Portsmouth Suffolk 8/14/1999 Flash Flood 0/ 0 0 9/7/1999 9/7/1999 Flash Flood Flash Flood 0/ 0 0/ 0 $0 $0 Norfolk Virginia Beach 9/7/1999 9/7/1999 Flash Flood Flash Flood 0/ 0 0/ 0 $0 0 LOCATION SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN DETAILS A double-structured storm system produced minor coastal flooding in the Tidewater region. The effects were much less than expected as the main storm moved well east of the mid-Atlantic before curling northwest into Long Island. In the Sandbridge section of Virginia Beach, a beachfront home collapsed into the sea. The combination of pounding surf and wind from Hurricane Gordon in late November and this event finished off the home. In addition, a few more bulkheads were flattened. Several roads in the Tidewater area suffered minor flooding, including Rescue Road in the Town of Smithfield. One to two inches of rain within six hours produced flooding along the 300-400 block of East Little Creek Road. Also, people were trapped in cars with water waist high along Campostella Road. Two to four inches of rain within six hours produced flooding in the Kempsville area along Indian River Road and Princess Anne Road. Also, high water was reported in the Oceanfront area along Atlantic Avenue. Parts of Interstate 264 were covered with more than 3 feet of water. Some other roads were impassable. Spotter reported just over 7 inches of rain in 4 hours. Many roads were flooded and impassable. Many roads including Hampton Boulevard were flooded and impassable. Many roads were flooded and impassable. Numerous underpasses flooded. Numerous primary roads flooded. Many underpasses flooded. Numerous primary roads and underpasses flooded. No details available 1500 block of Camp Pond Road flooded out. No details available A slow-moving line of thunderstorms with very heavy rains caused numerous flooded roads throughout the area, with some secondary roads impassable. MAY 2006 4:11 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS TABLE 4.3: SIGNIFICANT FLOOD EVENTS (1993-2004) DATE OF OCCURRENCE TYPE OF EVENT DEATHS/ INJURIES PROPERTY DAMAGE Virginia Beach, Hampton Roads, Portsmouth and Isle of Wight County 9/15/1999 Flood 0/ 0 $0 Suffolk 9/15/1999 Flood 0/ 0 $0 LOCATION SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN DETAILS Very heavy rain from Hurricane Floyd produced widespread flooding and flash flooding across much of central and eastern Virginia, and northeast North Carolina. Rainfall amounts generally ranged from 12 to 18 inches in much of the region. Numerous roads were washed out due to flooding. Many areas normally prone only to flooding of poor drainage and low lying areas experienced significant flash flooding. Also, there were enormous agricultural/crop losses due to the flooding. Very heavy rain from Hurricane Floyd produced widespread flooding and flash flooding across much of central and eastern Virginia, and northeast North Carolina. Rainfall amounts generally ranged from 12 to 18 inches in much of the Virginia Tidewater. Numerous roads were washed out due to flooding. Many areas normally prone only to flooding of poor drainage and low lying areas experienced significant flash flooding. River flooding was extensive and prolonged in the Chowan River Basin. The Blackwater, Meherrin and Nottoway Rivers exceeded flood stage. Also, there were enormous agricultural/crop losses due to the flooding. MAY 2006 4:12 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS TABLE 4.3: SIGNIFICANT FLOOD EVENTS (1993-2004) DATE OF OCCURRENCE TYPE OF EVENT DEATHS/ INJURIES PROPERTY DAMAGE Norfolk 9/15/1999 Flood 0/ 0 $0 Isle of Wight Countywide 10/17/1999 Flash Flood 0/ 0 $0 Portsmouth 10/17/1999 Flash Flood 0/ 0 $0 Suffolk 10/17/1999 Flash Flood 0/ 0 $0 Norfolk 10/17/1999 Flash Flood 0/ 0 $0 Virginia Beach 10/17/1999 Flash Flood 0/ 0 0 Norfolk 7/26/2000 Flash Flood 0/ 0 $0 Suffolk 7/30/2000 Flash Flood 0/ 0 $0 LOCATION SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN DETAILS Very heavy rain from Hurricane Floyd produced widespread flooding and flash flooding across much of central and eastern Virginia, and northeast North Carolina. Rainfall amounts generally ranged from near 7 inches from eastern Caroline County to Richmond City to Brunswick, Lunenburg and Mecklenburg counties, to 12 to 18 inches in much of the region. Numerous roads were washed out due to flooding. Many areas normally prone only to flooding of poor drainage and low lying areas experienced significant flash flooding. Primary routes out of service included US 460 near Wakefield, US 58 near Emporia and Franklin, and Interstate 95 south of Petersburg to Emporia. River flooding was extensive and prolonged in the Chowan River Basin. The Blackwater, Meherrin and Nottoway Rivers exceeded flood stage. Water levels in the city of Franklin were estimated to be several feet above the flood of record which occurred in August 1940. The flooding was considered to be a 500 year flood of record. Also, there were enormous agricultural/crop losses due to the flooding. Very heavy rainfall, locally up to 5 to 9 inches, associated with Hurricane Irene, resulted in numerous flooded roads and roads closed due to high water. Very heavy rainfall, locally up to 7 to 12 inches, associated with Hurricane Irene, resulted in numerous flooded roads and roads closed due to high water. Very heavy rainfall, locally up to 5 to 9 inches, associated with Hurricane Irene resulted in numerous flooded roads and roads closed due to high water. Very heavy rainfall, locally up to 7 to 12 inches, associated with Hurricane Irene, resulted in numerous flooded roads and roads closed due to high water. Very heavy rainfall, locally up to 7 to 12 inches, associated with Hurricane Irene, resulted in numerous flooded roads and roads closed due to high water. Heavy rain flooded roadways and caused closure of underpasses on Tidewater Drive in downtown Norfolk. Flooding also occurred at Chesapeake Boulevard and Chesapeake Street in the East Ocean View section of Norfolk. Heavy rain caused flooding of Kings Fork Road in the western part of the city. MAY 2006 4:13 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS TABLE 4.3: SIGNIFICANT FLOOD EVENTS (1993-2004) LOCATION DATE OF OCCURRENCE TYPE OF EVENT DEATHS/ INJURIES PROPERTY DAMAGE Portsmouth 8/11/2000 Flash Flood 0/ 0 $0 Norfolk 8/11/2000 Flash Flood 0/ 0 $0 Virginia Beach 8/14/2000 Flash Flood 0/ 0 0 Norfolk 9/5/2000 Flash Flood 0/ 0 $0 Windsor 6/16/2001 Flash Flood 0/ 0 $0 Suffolk 6/16/2001 Flash Flood 0/ 0 $0 Norfolk 7/23/2001 Flash Flood 0/ 0 $0 Norfolk 8/28/2002 Flash Flood 0/ 0 $0 Virginia Beach 8/28/2002 Flash Flood 0/ 0 0 Norfolk 10/11/2002 Flash Flood 0/ 0 $0 SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN DETAILS Very heavy rain caused flooding and the closure of Interstate 264 at Frederick Boulevard. Extremely heavy rain caused widespread flooding of roads in downtown Norfolk. The intersections of Granby Street and Brambleton Avenue, Princess Anne Road and Monticello Avenue, and City Hall Avenue and Granby Street were all closed due to high standing water. Also, underpasses on Campostella Avenue, Tidewater Drive and Colley Avenue in Norfolk were closed due to accumulated water. In Portsmouth, Interstate 264 at Frederick Boulevard was closed due to standing water. Very heavy rain caused widespread flooding and closure of roads in the vicinity of Princess Anne Plaza. Also, sections of Rosemont Road were closed due to flooding. Heavy rain from slow-moving thunderstorms caused the side of an underpass wall to slide into the road at Granby Street and Interstate 64 resulting in road closure. Knoxville Road, Rose Drive, and numerous other secondary roads impassable around Windsor. Flooding reported near Whaleyville. One street closed. Car submerged at the underpass on Colley Avenue and 21st Street. Also, numerous roads covered by 1 to 2 feet of water. Rainfall amounts of 2 to 3 inches within 2 hours caused roads to be closed or blocked due to high water. Union Street and areas near City Hall and Granby were flooded. Cars were reported stalled out in deep water, also. Rainfall amounts of 2 to 3 inches within 2 hours caused some roads to be closed or blocked due to high water. Rosemont at the Virginia Beach Boulevard and around the Kings Grant area were closed or blocked. Cars were reported stalled out in deep water, also. Rainfall amounts between 3 and 3.5 inches caused flooding of some streets and low lying intersections, including the intersection of Tidewater Drive and Virginia Beach Boulevard. MAY 2006 4:14 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS TABLE 4.3: SIGNIFICANT FLOOD EVENTS (1993-2004) DATE OF OCCURRENCE TYPE OF EVENT DEATHS/ INJURIES PROPERTY DAMAGE 10/11/2002 Flash Flood 0/ 0 0 Portsmouth Suffolk Airport 9/3/2003 9/3/2003 Flash Flood Flash Flood 0/ 0 0/ 0 $0 $0 Norfolk 9/3/2003 Flash Flood 0/ 0 $0 Portsmouth 6/10/2004 Flash Flood 0/ 0 $0 Isle of Wight 7/25/2004 Flash Flood 0/ 0 $0 Norfolk 7/25/2004 Flash Flood 0/ 0 $0 Portsmouth 8/2/2004 Flash Flood 0/ 0 $0 Norfolk 8/2/2004 Flash Flood 0/ 0 $0 0/0 $670,000 LOCATION Virginia Beach TOTAL DETAILS Rainfall amounts between 3 and 3.5 inches caused flooding and closure of Atlantic Avenue between 42nd and 65th streets. Waist high water reported on some roads. Flooding of streets in northern Suffolk. Water as high as mailboxes in a cul-desac. Many roads closed due to high water, including 8000 block of Hampton Boulevard. Six inches of water across road at Airline Boulevard and I264. One foot of water across road at intersection of Oregon and Dakota Roads. Lawnes Creek Bridge on Route 10 near Rushmere reported closed due to flooding. Also, several other roads were closed due to flooding in the northern part of the county. Many streets flooded in downtown Norfolk including Waterside Drive. Duke and Randolph Streets reported closed due to high water. Flooding on I264 and Portsmouth Boulevard. Flooding reported at the intersection of Park Avenue and Virginia Beach Boulevard, and at the intersection of Robinhood Road and I-64 underpass. Source: National Climatic Data Center (1993 to 2004 data) PROBABILITY OF FUTURE OCCURRENCES Flooding remains a highly likely occurrence throughout the identified flood hazard areas of the region. Smaller floods caused by heavy rains and inadequate drainage capacity will be more frequent, but not as costly as the large-scale floods which may occur at less frequent intervals, including extended torrential rainfall and storm surge events associated with hurricanes, tropical storms and nor‟easters. While the potential for flood is always present, many of the jurisdictions within the region do have policies in place 6 that should help lessen potential property damage due to future floods. 6 The Capability Assessment section of this Plan provides an overview of the programs and policies that each jurisdiction has in place that are designed to reduce the impacts of the flood hazard. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:15 HURRICANES AND TROPICAL STORMS BACKGROUND Hurricanes and tropical storms, along with nor‟easters and typhoons, are classified as cyclones and are any closed circulation developing around a low-pressure center in which the winds rotate counter-clockwise in the Northern Hemisphere (or clockwise in the Southern Hemisphere) and whose diameter averages 10 to 30 miles across. A tropical cyclone refers to any such circulation that develops over tropical waters. Tropical cyclones act as a “safety-valve,” limiting the continued build-up of heat and energy in tropical regions by maintaining the atmospheric heat and moisture balance between the tropics and the pole-ward latitudes. The primary damaging forces associated with these storms are high-level sustained winds, heavy precipitation, and tornadoes. Coastal areas are particularly vulnerable to storm surge, wind-driven waves, and tidal flooding which can 7 prove more destructive than cyclone wind . The key energy source for a tropical cyclone is the release of latent heat from the condensation of warm water. Their Hurricane Isabel approaches North formation requires a low-pressure disturbance, warm sea Carolina and Virginia in September of surface temperature, rotational force from the spinning of the 2003. (Photo courtesy of NASA) earth, and the absence of wind shear in the lowest 50,000 feet of the atmosphere. The majority of hurricanes and tropical storms form in the Atlantic Ocean, Caribbean Sea, and Gulf of Mexico during the official Atlantic hurricane season, which encompasses the months of June through November. The peak of the Atlantic hurricane season is in early to mid-September. Based on a long-term average, approximately six storms reach hurricane intensity per year. Figure 4.13 shows, for any particular location, the chance of a hurricane or tropical storm affecting the area sometime during the Atlantic hurricane season. The figure was created by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration‟s (NOAA) Hurricane Research Division, using data from 1944 to 1999. The figure shows the number of times a storm or hurricane was located within approximately 100 miles (165 kilometers) of a given spot in the Atlantic basin. 7 For purposes of this risk assessment, coastal flood hazards associated with hurricanes and tropical storm events are included separately under the “flood” hazard. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 4:16 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS FIGURE 4.13: EMPIRICAL PROBABILITY OF A NAMED HURRICANE OR TROPICAL STORM Source: National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, Hurricane Research Division As an incipient hurricane develops, barometric pressure (measured in millibars or inches) at its center falls and winds increase. If the atmospheric and oceanic conditions are favorable, it can intensify into a tropical depression. When maximum sustained winds reach or exceed 39 miles per hour, the system is designated a tropical storm, given a name, and is monitored by the National Hurricane Center in Miami, Florida. When sustained winds reach or exceed 74 miles per hour the storm is deemed a hurricane. Hurricane intensity is further classified by the Saffir-Simpson Scale which rates hurricane intensity on a scale of 1 to 5, with 5 being the most intense. The Saffir-Simpson Scale is shown in Table 4.4. TABLE 4.4: SAFFIR-SIMPSON SCALE CATEGORY MAXIMUM SUSTAINED WIND SPEED (MPH) 1 2 3 4 5 74–95 96–110 111–130 131–155 155 + MINIMUM SURFACE STORM SURGE PRESSURE (MILLIBARS) (FEET) Greater than 980 979–965 964–945 944–920 Less than 920 3–5 6–8 9–12 13–18 19+ Source: Federal National Hurricane Center SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 4:17 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS The Saffir-Simpson Scale categorizes hurricane intensity linearly based upon maximum sustained winds, barometric pressure, and storm surge potential, which are combined to estimate potential damage. Categories 3, 4, and 5 are classified as “major” hurricanes, and while hurricanes within this range comprise only 20 percent of total tropical cyclones making landfall, they account for over 70 percent of the damage in the United States. Table 4.5 describes the damage that could be expected for each hurricane category. TABLE 4.5: HURRICANE DAMAGE CLASSIFICATIONS STORM DAMAGE LEVEL CATEGORY DESCRIPTION OF DAMAGES No real damage to building structures. Damage primarily to unanchored mobile homes, shrubbery, and trees. Also, some coastal flooding and minor pier damage. 1 MINIMAL 2 MODERATE Some roofing material, door, and window damage. Considerable damage to vegetation, mobile homes, etc. Flooding damages piers and small craft in unprotected moorings may break their moorings. 3 EXTENSIVE Some structural damage to small residences and utility buildings, with a minor amount of curtainwall failures. Mobile homes are destroyed. Flooding near the coast destroys smaller structures, with larger structures damaged by floating debris. Terrain may be flooded well inland. 4 EXTREME More extensive curtainwall failures with some complete roof structure failure on small residences. Major erosion of beach areas. Terrain may be flooded well inland. 5 PHOTO EXAMPLE Complete roof failure on many residences and industrial buildings. Some complete building failures with small utility CATASTROPHIC buildings blown over or away. Flooding causes major damage to lower floors of all structures near the shoreline. Massive evacuation of residential areas may be required. Sources: National Hurricane Center and the Federal Emergency Management Agency A storm surge is a large dome of water often 50 to 100 miles wide and rising anywhere from four to five feet in a Category 1 hurricane up to 20 feet in a Category 5 storm. The storm surge arrives ahead of the storm‟s actual landfall and the more intense the hurricane is, the sooner the surge arrives. Water rise can be very rapid, posing a serious threat to those who have not yet evacuated flood-prone areas. A storm surge is a wave that has outrun its generating source and become a long period swell. The surge is always highest in the right-front quadrant of the direction in which the hurricane is moving. As the storm approaches shore, the greatest storm surge will be to the north of the hurricane eye. Such a surge of high water topped by waves driven by hurricane force winds can be devastating to coastal regions, causing severe beach erosion and property damage along the immediate coast. Storm surge heights and associated waves are dependent upon the shape of the continental shelf (narrow or wide) and the depth of the ocean bottom (bathymetry). A narrow shelf, or one that drops SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:18 steeply from the shoreline and subsequently produces deep water close to the shoreline, tends to produce a lower surge but higher and more powerful storm waves. Damage during hurricanes may also result from spawned tornadoes and inland flooding associated with heavy rainfall that usually accompanies these storms. Hurricane Floyd, for example, was at one time a Category 4 hurricane racing towards the North Carolina coast. As far inland as Raleigh, the state capital located more than 100 miles from the coast, communities were preparing for winds exceeding 100 miles per hour. While Floyd made landfall as a Category 2 hurricane it caused the worst inland flooding disaster in North Carolina‟s history. Rainfall amounts exceeded 20 inches in certain locales and 67 counties sustained damages. Similar to hurricanes, nor‟easters are ocean storms capable of causing substantial damage to coastal areas in the Eastern United States due to their strong winds and heavy surf. Nor'easters are named for the winds that blow in from the northeast and drive the storm up the East Coast along the Gulf Stream, a band of warm water that lies off the Atlantic coast. They are caused by the interaction of the jet stream with horizontal temperature gradients and generally occur during the fall and winter months when moisture and cold air are plentiful. Nor‟easters are known for dumping heavy amounts of rain and snow, producing hurricane-force winds, and creating high surf that causes severe beach erosion and coastal flooding. There are two main components to a nor'easter: (1) a Gulf Stream low-pressure system (counter-clockwise winds) generated off the southeastern U.S. coast, gathering warm air and moisture from the Atlantic, and pulled up the East Coast by strong northeasterly winds at the leading edge of the storm; and (2) an Arctic high-pressure system (clockwise winds) which meets the low-pressure system with cold, arctic air blowing down from Canada. When the two systems collide, the moisture and cold air produce a mix of precipitation and have the potential for creating dangerously high winds and heavy seas. As the low-pressure system deepens, the intensity of the winds and waves increase and can cause serious damage to coastal areas as the 8 storm moves northeast. 8 Depending on the location of jurisdictions participating in the Southside Hampton Roads Hazard Mitigation Plan, nor‟easters are viewed as winter storm or coastal events, as the coastal storm characteristics and coastal impacts of nor‟easters are limited to coastal communities. The Dolan-Davis Nor‟easter Intensity Scale, which shows levels of coastal degradation based on beach and dune erosion, overwash and coastal property damage is particularly relevant to jurisdictions such as Virginia Beach, and to a lesser extent Norfolk, Portsmouth and parts of Isle of Wight County. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:19 LOCATION AND SPATIAL EXTENT Since the mid-1800s, numerous tropical cyclones have affected Virginia on a statewide basis, causing the deaths of an estimated 228 people and costing the Commonwealth more than a billion dollars in damages. The eyes of over 70 storms have tracked directly across Virginia with 11 having made landfall on or within 60 miles of the Virginia Coast. The region is geographically located in an area that can expect to experience hurricane damage in any given year. In fact, 106 such storms have passed within 75 miles of the Southside Hampton Roads region since 1851 (Figure 4.14), 29 of which crossed directly through the region. 2 Category 3 hurricanes passed within 75 miles of the region (both unnamed storms in 1879 and 1899), 14 were Category 2 hurricanes, 31 were Category 1 hurricanes and 117 were tropical storms. Of the storms that passed through the region, Hurricane Ivan was the most recent in 2004. Remains of a restaurant in Isle of Wight County after Hurricane Isabel. Photo credit: Isle of Wight County Hurricane winds impact each jurisdiction uniformly. All building stock, infrastructure and critical facilities are equally vulnerable to these hazards. Vulnerability maps showing infrastructure and critical facilities that are at risk to these hazards are found in Appendix B. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 4:20 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS SIGNIFICANT HISTORICAL EVENTS9 The National Weather Service began keeping weather records on January 1, 1871. Prior to that, information on past hurricanes and tropical storms to impact the Southside Hampton Roads region were taken from ships logs, accounts from local citizens, newspapers and other source. There are several 10 historical references to major storms that affected coastal Virginia in the 1600's and 1700's . Some of these storms were strong enough to alter land masses, including the widening of the Lynnhaven River (September 6, 1667) and formation of Willoughby Spit (October 19, 1749). These reports also indicate severe flooding caused by these storms (12-15 feet of flooding in some cases). Better records have been kept since 1871. One for the first of the storms to be well documented was a hurricane that occurred in October 1878 that resulted in Cobb and Smith Islands on the Eastern Shore being completely submerged. One of the worst storms to impact the region occurred in August 1933 when a hurricane known as the Chesapeake-Potomac Hurricane of 1933 passed just west of the Hampton Roads area. The storm made landfall in northeastern North Carolina and moved northwest. This hurricane produced the record high tide for the area which exists today, at a level of 9.69 feet above Mean Lower Low Water. The highest sustained wind was clocked was 88 mph at the Naval Air Station (NAS). Less than a month later, another hurricane struck the area with winds again clocked at 88 mph at NAS, but tides only rose to 8.3 feet above Mean Lower Low Water. Another unnamed storm occurred in September of 1944 creating the fastest 1 minute wind speed to ever be recorded in the area (134 mph at Cape Henry). Gusts were estimated to 150 mph. The local National Weather Service office recorded 72 mph winds with gusts to 90 mph. Although the center of circulation for Hurricane Hazel did not pass within 75 miles of the region, wind speeds of 78 mph were recorded at Norfolk Airport with gusts up to 100 mph and an unofficial reading of 130 mph was also reported in Hampton. In 1960 Hurricane Donna passed through the region with a fastest 1 minute wind speed of 73 mph at Norfolk Airport, 80 mph at Cape Henry and estimated 138 mph at Chesapeake Light Ship. Lowest pressure of 28.65 inches holds the area record for a tropical storm. 3 deaths were documented in association with this hurricane. On August 27, 1998, Hurricane Bonnie tracked over the region after passing over the northern Outer Banks. Winds speeds were sustained at 46 mph with gust to 64 mph at Norfolk Airport. Four to seven inches of rain combined with near hurricane force winds knocked out power to 320,000 customers across Virginia. Highest tide was recorded at 6.0 feet above Mean Lower Low Water. This was the most significant storm to impact the region since 1960 (Hurricane Donna) On September 6, 1999, Hurricane Floyd passed directly over Virginia Beach on a track similar to Hurricane Donna in 1960. Wind speeds were recorded at 31 mph with gust to 46 mph. Rainfall amounts of 12-18" were recorded in portions of eastern Virginia causing extensive flooding in portions of the Southside Hampton Roads region. Just as the rest of the country has experienced, Southeastern Virginia has felt the impacts of very active hurricane seasons for the past ten years. In 1996, Hurricanes Bertha and Fran impacted the region, followed by Hurricane Danny in 1997, Hurricane Bonnie in 1998, and Hurricanes Dennis, Floyd, and Irene 9 As previously mentioned, many of the significant hurricane, coastal storm and tropical storm events were also significant flooding events. As such, many of the significant historical events for hurricanes may also be discussed in the description of the flood hazard. 10 The first historical reference to a major hurricane that could have affected the Virginia coast was in August 24, 1635. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 4:21 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS in 1999. Although each of these storms were downgraded by the time they reached the Southside Hampton Roads region, they each created problems for the region when they passed through, two of which resulted in Federal Disaster declarations (Bonnie and Floyd) for the region. Tropical storms Helene in 2000 and Kyle occurred in 2002, and most recently, Hurricane Isabel caused major damage in the region in 2003 (winds speeds of 54 mph with gusts to 75 mph in Norfolk and significant beach erosion was reported). Table 4.5 shows the historical storm tracks within 75 miles of Southside Hampton Roads region since 1851 that are the basis for Figure 4.14. TABLE 4.5: HISTORICAL STORM TRACKS WITHIN 75 MILES OF THE REGION (SINCE 1851) DATE OF OCCURRENCE STORM NAME WIND SPEED (MPH) STORM CATEGORY 8/25/1851 9/10/1854 8/20/1856 9/17/1859 9/27/1861 11/2/1861 9/18/1863 10/26/1872 9/29/1874 9/17/1876 10/23/1878 8/18/1879 9/9/1880 9/10/1881 9/11/1882 9/23/1882 9/12/1883 8/26/1885 7/2/1886 9/11/1888 10/12/1888 9/25/1889 6/17/1893 10/23/1893 9/29/1894 10/10/1894 9/23/1897 10/26/1897 8/18/1899 10/31/1899 7/11/1901 6/16/1902 9/15/1904 9/1/1908 8/25/1918 12/3/1925 9/19/1928 8/23/1933 9/16/1933 9/6/1935 9/18/1936 8/2/1944 9/14/1944 10/20/1944 6/26/1945 7/7/1946 8/14/1953 8/31/1954 UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED UNNAMED BARBARA CAROL 45 45 60 60 70 80 70 45 70 90 105 115 80 70 45 45 45 80 40 40 60 45 65 50 85 75 70 60 120 65 80 40 65 50 40 45 45 80 90 75 100 50 105 40 50 65 105 100 TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM CATEGORY 1 HURRICANE TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM CATEGORY 1 HURRICANE CATEGORY 2 HURRICANE CATEGORY 3 HURRICANE CATEGORY 1 HURRICANE TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM CATEGORY 1 HURRICANE TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM CATEGORY 1 HURRICANE CATEGORY 1 HURRICANE TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM CATEGORY 3 HURRICANE TROPICAL STORM CATEGORY 1 HURRICANE TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM CATEGORY 1 HURRICANE CATEGORY 1 HURRICANE CATEGORY 1 HURRICANE CATEGORY 2 HURRICANE TROPICAL STORM CATEGORY 2 HURRICANE TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM CATEGORY 2 HURRICANE CATEGORY 2 HURRICANE SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 4:22 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS TABLE 4.5: HISTORICAL STORM TRACKS WITHIN 75 MILES OF THE REGION (SINCE 1851) DATE OF OCCURRENCE STORM NAME WIND SPEED (MPH) STORM CATEGORY 8/12/1955 9/20/1955 7/10/1959 7/30/1960 9/12/1960 9/14/1961 9/1/1964 9/17/1967 8/28/1971 6/22/1972 7/1/1981 9/30/1983 9/14/1984 9/27/1985 8/18/1986 9/25/1992 7/13/1996 7/24/1997 8/28/1998 9/16/1999 9/24/2000 10/12/2002 9/18/2003 8/14/2004 CONNIE IONE CINDY BRENDA DONNA UNNAMED CLEO DORIA DORIA AGNES BRET DEAN DIANA GLORIA CHARLEY DANIELLE BERTHA DANNY BONNIE FLOYD HELENE KYLE ISABEL CHARLEY 80 70 40 50 105 40 45 40 65 50 60 65 60 105 80 65 75 45 85 80 45 45 100 40 CATEGORY 1 HURRICANE TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM CATEGORY 2 HURRICANE TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM CATEGORY 2 HURRICANE CATEGORY 1 HURRICANE TROPICAL STORM CATEGORY 1 HURRICANE TROPICAL STORM CATEGORY 1 HURRICANE CATEGORY 1 HURRICANE TROPICAL STORM TROPICAL STORM CATEGORY 2 HURRICANE TROPICAL STORM Source: National Hurricane Center PROBABILITY OF FUTURE OCCURRENCES It is likely that the region will be impacted by hurricanes and tropical storms in the future. The region is less likely to experience the effects of a major (Category 3 or stronger) hurricane, however it remains a possibility. The effects of smaller hurricanes (Categories 1 and 2 with wind speeds from 74-110 miles per hour) and tropical storms (sustained wind speeds of at least 39 miles per hour and torrential rains) will be more frequent, as storms making landfall along the North Carolina and Virginia coastlines could impact the region in any given year. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:23 SEVERE THUNDERSTORMS BACKGROUND According to the National Weather Service, more than 100,000 thunderstorms occur each year, though only about 10 percent of these storms are classified as “severe.” Although thunderstorms generally affect a small area when they occur, they are very dangerous because of their ability to generate tornadoes, hailstorms, strong winds, flash flooding, and damaging lightning. While thunderstorms can occur in all regions of the United States, they are most common in the central and southern states because atmospheric conditions in those regions are most ideal for generating these powerful storms. Thunderstorms are caused when air masses of varying temperatures meet. Rapidly rising warm moist air serves as the “engine” for thunderstorms. These storms can occur singularly, in lines, or in clusters. They can move through an area very quickly or linger for several hours. The National Weather Service collected data for thunder days, number and duration of thunder events, and lightening strike density for the 30-year period from 1948 to 1977. A series of maps was generated showing the annual average thunder event duration, the annual average number of thunder events, and the mean annual density of lightning strikes. Figure 4.15 illustrates thunderstorm hazard severity based on the annual average number of thunder events from 1948 to 1977. FIGURE 4.15: ANNUAL AVERAGE NUMBER OF THUNDER EVENTS Source: Federal Emergency Management Agency SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:24 Straight-line winds, which in extreme cases have the potential to cause wind gusts that exceed 100 miles per hour, are responsible for most thunderstorm wind damage. One type of straight-line wind, the downburst, can cause damage equivalent to a strong tornado and can be extremely dangerous to aviation. Figure 4.16 shows how the frequency and strength of extreme windstorms vary across the United States. The map was produced by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) and is based on 40 years of tornado history and over 100 years of hurricane history. Zone IV, the darkest area on the map, has experienced both the greatest number of tornadoes and the strongest tornadoes. As shown by the map key, wind speeds in Zone IV can be as high as 250 MPH. FIGURE 4.16: WIND ZONES IN THE UNITED STATES Source: Federal Emergency Management Agency SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 4:25 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS Hailstorms are another potential damaging outgrowth of severe thunderstorms. Early in the developmental stages of a hailstorm, ice crystals form within a low-pressure front due to the rapid rising of warm air into the upper atmosphere and the subsequent cooling of the air mass. Frozen droplets gradually accumulate on the ice crystals until, having developed sufficient weight, they fall as precipitation—as balls or irregularly shaped masses of ice greater than 0.75 in. (1.91 cm) in diameter. The size of hailstones is a direct function of the size and severity of the storm. High velocity updraft winds are required to keep hail in suspension in thunderclouds. The strength of the updraft is a function of the intensity of heating at the Earth‟s surface. Higher temperature gradients relative to elevation above the surface result in increased suspension time and hailstone size. Figure 4.17 shows the annual frequency of hailstorms in the United States. Large hail collects on streets and grass during a severe thunderstorm. Larger stones appear to be nearly two to three inches in diameter. (NOAA Photo Library, NOAA Central Library; OAR/ERL/National Severe Storms Laboratory) FIGURE 4.17: ANNUAL FREQUENCY OF HAILSTORMS IN THE UNITED STATES Source: Federal Emergency Management Agency SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 4:26 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS LOCATION AND SPATIAL EXTENT Thunderstorms are common throughout the state of Virginia, and have been known to occur during all months of the year. In addition to the high winds associated with these events, thunderstorms can also bring dangerous lightning that can cause fires, property damage and may cause death or serious injury. Thunderstorms can also produce hail, which can cause varying degrees of property and crop damage. According to the National Climatic Data Center, the region has experienced a recorded 112 severe thunderstorm events since 1950 resulting in 1 reported death, 15 injuries and approximately $595,000 in property damage. Severe thunderstorms impact each jurisdiction uniformly. All building stock, infrastructure and critical facilities are equally vulnerable to these hazards. Vulnerability maps showing infrastructure and critical facilities that are at risk to these hazards are found in Appendix B. SIGNIFICANT HISTORICAL EVENTS Table 4.6 provides details of historical severe thunderstorm activity in the region as recorded by the 11 National Climatic Data Center. TABLE 4.6: SIGNIFICANT SEVERE THUNDERSTORM EVENTS (1950-2004) LOCATION Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Norfolk Norfolk Suffolk Norfolk Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Suffolk Norfolk Norfolk DATE OF MAGNITUDE DEATHS/ OCCURRENCE (KNOTS) INJURIES PROPERTY DAMAGE 7/9/1956 62 knots. 0/0 $0 8/10/1956 0 knots. 0/0 $0 4/8/1957 55 knots. 0/0 $0 3/13/1958 0 knots. 0/0 $0 2/18/1960 5/17/1960 5/21/1962 2/13/1966 N/A N/A N/A N/A 0/0 0/0 0/0 0/0 $0 $0 $0 $0 2/13/1966 55 knots. 0/0 $0 1/27/1967 0 knots. 0/0 $0 4/30/1968 60 knots. 0/0 $0 7/17/1968 0 knots. 0/0 $0 7/1/1969 0 knots. 0/0 $0 7/3/1969 6/21/1970 7/16/1972 N/A N/A N/A 0/0 0/0 0/0 $0 $0 $0 DETAILS No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available 11 While the Severe Thunderstorm hazard is understood to include lightning and hail as hazardous elements, tables are provided with lightning and hail activity presented separately with the understanding that some duplication of deaths, injuries and property damage may occur when comparing all three tables. The Southside Hampton Roads Mitigation Planning Committee determined that the lightning hazard should be discussed and analyzed as a separate hazard, independent from the thunderstorm discussion and analysis. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 4:27 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS TABLE 4.6: SIGNIFICANT SEVERE THUNDERSTORM EVENTS (1950-2004) LOCATION Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Norfolk Virginia Beach Norfolk Isle of Wight Isle of Wight Isle of Wight Norfolk Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Norfolk Isle of Wight Norfolk Virginia Beach Norfolk Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Portsmouth Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Suffolk Isle of Wight Norfolk Norfolk Virginia Beach Norfolk Norfolk Portsmouth Suffolk Norfolk Norfolk Norfolk Isle of Wight DATE OF MAGNITUDE DEATHS/ OCCURRENCE (KNOTS) INJURIES PROPERTY DAMAGE 7/10/1973 56 knots. 0/0 $0 8/12/1973 0 knots. 0/0 $0 4/4/1974 N/A 0/0 $0 4/5/1974 0 knots. 0/0 $0 6/20/1974 60 knots 0/0 $0 6/23/1974 N/A 0/0 $0 6/23/1974 N/A 0/0 $0 8/29/1974 N/A 0/0 $0 2/24/1975 N/A 0/0 $0 3/19/1975 0 knots. 0/0 $0 3/19/1975 0 knots. 0/0 $0 3/24/1975 50 knots 0/0 $0 4/25/1975 N/A 0/0 $0 4/25/1975 55 knots 0/0 $0 4/25/1975 65 knots. 0/0 $0 7/29/1976 65 knots 0/0 $0 10/9/1976 0 knots. 0/0 $0 10/9/1976 0 knots. 0/0 $0 6/6/1977 N/A 0/0 $0 6/6/1977 0 knots. 0/0 $0 6/6/1977 53 knots. 0/0 $0 7/1/1977 0 knots. 0/0 $0 6/3/1978 0 knots. 0/0 $0 5/23/1979 N/A 0/0 $0 2/23/1980 52 knots 0/0 $0 4/4/1980 4/4/1980 52 knots 85 knots 0/0 0/0 $0 $0 4/4/1980 85 knots. 0/0 $0 7/5/1980 8/15/1980 6/16/1982 6/16/1982 6/16/1982 6/16/1982 8/11/1982 61 knots 57 knots N/A N/A 60 knots 60 knots N/A 0/0 0/0 0/0 0/0 0/0 0/0 0/0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 5/8/1984 N/A 0/0 $0 SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN DETAILS No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available MAY 2006 4:28 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS TABLE 4.6: SIGNIFICANT SEVERE THUNDERSTORM EVENTS (1950-2004) LOCATION Portsmouth Norfolk Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Isle of Wight Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Norfolk Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Suffolk Isle of Wight Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Suffolk Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Norfolk Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Virginia Beach DATE OF MAGNITUDE DEATHS/ OCCURRENCE (KNOTS) INJURIES PROPERTY DAMAGE 5/8/1984 5/8/1984 N/A 57 knots 0/0 0/0 $0 $0 5/8/1984 53 knots. 0/0 $0 6/5/1985 60 knots. 0/0 $0 6/5/1985 52 knots. 0/0 $0 10/15/1985 N/A 0/0 $0 7/9/1986 69 knots. 0/0 $0 7/9/1986 69 knots. 0/0 $0 7/9/1986 55 knots. 0/0 $0 6/2/1987 60 knots 0/0 $0 7/31/1987 0 knots. 0/0 $0 6/26/1988 50 knots. 0/0 $0 3/15/1989 60 knots. 0/0 $0 3/15/1989 50 knots. 0/0 $0 3/30/1989 N/A 0/0 $0 3/31/1989 52 knots 0/0 $0 3/31/1989 65 knots. 0/0 $0 3/31/1989 54 knots. 0/0 $0 5/6/1989 0 knots. 0/1 $0 5/6/1989 0 knots. 0/0 $0 6/2/1989 N/A 0/0 $0 6/2/1989 70 knots. 0/6 $0 6/15/1989 70 knots. 0/0 $0 9/23/1989 52 knots. 0/0 $0 2/9/1990 N/A 0/0 $0 5/10/1990 0 knots. 0/0 $0 5/10/1990 0 knots. 0/0 $0 6/8/1990 0 knots. 0/0 $0 6/8/1990 0 knots. 0/5 $0 6/22/1990 60 knots. 0/0 $0 SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN DETAILS No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available MAY 2006 4:29 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS TABLE 4.6: SIGNIFICANT SEVERE THUNDERSTORM EVENTS (1950-2004) LOCATION Virginia Beach Isle of Wight Suffolk Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Isle of Wight Isle of Wight Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Isle of Wight Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Isle of Wight Virginia Beach Suffolk Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Suffolk Virginia Beach Suffolk Isle of Wight Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Isle of Wight Suffolk Portsmouth Portsmouth Portsmouth Norfolk DATE OF MAGNITUDE DEATHS/ OCCURRENCE (KNOTS) INJURIES PROPERTY DAMAGE 6/22/1990 0 knots. 0/0 $0 7/1/1990 N/A 0/0 $0 7/1/1990 N/A 0/0 $0 7/1/1990 55 knots. 0/0 $0 7/1/1990 60 knots. 0/0 $0 7/11/1990 N/A 0/0 $0 7/12/1990 N/A 0/0 $0 7/12/1990 55 knots. 0/0 $0 7/12/1990 0 knots. 0/0 $0 9/7/1990 N/A 0/0 $0 9/7/1990 0 knots. 0/0 $0 10/18/1990 60 knots. 0/0 $0 3/29/1991 52 knots. 0/0 $0 3/29/1991 0 knots. 0/0 $0 5/1/1991 N/A 0/0 $0 5/1/1991 0 knots. 0/0 $0 8/4/1991 N/A 0/0 $0 8/19/1991 60 knots. 0/0 $0 8/19/1991 52 knots. 0/0 $0 9/19/1991 N/A 0/0 $0 9/19/1991 0 knots. 0/0 $0 2/15/1992 N/A 0/0 $0 7/18/1992 N/A 0/0 $0 7/18/1992 0 knots. 0/0 $0 7/18/1992 50 knots. 0/0 $0 7/27/1992 55 knots. 0/0 $0 7/31/1992 N/A 0/0 $0 7/31/1992 8/9/1992 8/28/1992 8/28/1992 8/28/1992 N/A N/A 52 knots N/A 55 knots 0/0 0/0 0/0 0/0 0/0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN DETAILS No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available MAY 2006 4:30 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS TABLE 4.6: SIGNIFICANT SEVERE THUNDERSTORM EVENTS (1950-2004) LOCATION Isle of Wight Isle of Wight Isle of Wight Isle of Wight Isle of Wight Isle Of Wight Portsmouth Norfolk Airport Isle of Wight DATE OF MAGNITUDE DEATHS/ OCCURRENCE (KNOTS) INJURIES PROPERTY DAMAGE 9/4/1993 N/A 0/0 $1,000 9/22/1994 N/A 0/0 $50,000 9/22/1994 N/A 0/0 $5,000 5/19/1995 N/A 0/0 $0 11/11/1995 N/A 0/0 $75,000 1/19/1996 N/A 0/0 $0 1/19/1996 56 knots 0/0 $0 1/19/1996 54 knots 0/0 $0 3/15/1996 N/A 0/0 $0 Suffolk 3/15/1996 N/A 0/0 $0 Isle of Wight 5/11/1996 N/A 0/0 $5,000 Windsor 6/12/1996 N/A 0/0 $2,000 Smithfield 6/15/1996 N/A 0/0 $3,000 Smithfield 6/15/1996 N/A 0/0 $3,000 Smithfield 6/24/1996 N/A 0/0 $7,000 Norfolk 6/24/1996 N/A 0/0 $10,000 Smithfield 7/18/1996 N/A 0/0 $5,000 Suffolk 7/18/1996 N/A 0/0 $3,000 Virginia Beach 7/18/1996 0 knots. 0/0 $2,000 Portsmouth 7/31/1996 N/A 0/0 $3,000 Suffolk 7/31/1996 N/A 0/0 $4,000 7/31/1996 0 knots. 0/0 $2,000 5/1/1997 N/A 0/0 $5,000 Virginia Beach Isle of Wight SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN DETAILS No description available No description available No description available One tree and several large branches were down near Walters on Route 258. Numerous trees and power lines down throughout the county. Several barns are damaged, and small grain silo and tractorsemi trailer overturned in the Orbit/Lake Butler area. Trees down on power lines on Rte. 10 and 258. No description available No description available Numerous large trees were downed. Three to six inch diameter tree limbs were blown off of 12 trees along Route 58 between South Hampton County line and Suffolk. Numerous trees and power lines downed throughout the county. The worst damage was occurred near Rushmore and Windsor. Several trees uprooted onto wires near the Blackwater River. Numerous trees downed. Two telephone poles downed on Route 258. Several trees and storage shed blown down near Route 13 and Route 616. Roof partially blown off a house on Minnesota Avenue. Several trees blown down along Route 10 in Smithfield. Tree was blown down onto a car at Benns Church Golf Course. Numerous trees and power lines blown down. Several trees blown down on Atlantic Avenue. Several trees and power lines blown down. Several trees and power lines blown down. Also, sheet metal torn off storage building. Large tree blown down on Back Cove Road. A tree fell down on house. MAY 2006 4:31 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS TABLE 4.6: SIGNIFICANT SEVERE THUNDERSTORM EVENTS (1950-2004) LOCATION Whaleyville , Suffolk DATE OF MAGNITUDE DEATHS/ OCCURRENCE (KNOTS) INJURIES PROPERTY DAMAGE 7/6/1997 N/A 0/0 $10,000 7/16/1997 N/A 0/0 $2,000 7/16/1997 N/A 0/0 $5,000 Suffolk 7/19/1997 N/A 0/0 $5,000 Portsmouth 4/9/1998 N/A 0/0 $2,000 Suffolk Airport 4/9/1998 N/A 0/0 $100,000 Suffolk 4/9/1998 N/A 0/0 $2,000 Virginia Beach 4/9/1998 52 knots. 0/0 $10,000 Virginia Beach 5/21/1998 82 knots. 0/0 $0 Suffolk 6/3/1998 N/A 0/0 $3,000 Windsor 6/16/1998 N/A 0/0 $3,000 Isle of Wight 6/16/1998 N/A 0/0 $2,000 Portsmouth 6/16/1998 N/A 0/0 $2,000 Portsmouth 6/16/1998 N/A 0/0 $2,000 Portsmouth 6/16/1998 N/A 0/0 $2,000 Suffolk 6/16/1998 N/A 0/0 $3,000 Norfolk 6/16/1998 N/A 0/0 $5,000 Norfolk 6/16/1998 58 knots 0/0 $0 Virginia Beach 6/16/1998 0 knots. 0/0 $2,000 Portsmouth 2/28/1999 N/A 0/0 $5,000 Suffolk 2/28/1999 N/A 0/0 $1,000 Norfolk 2/28/1999 70 knots 0/0 $0 Portsmouth 3/3/1999 53 knots 0/0 $0 4/23/1999 76 knots. 0/0 $0 4/23/1999 0 knots. 0/0 $5,000 5/24/1999 N/A 0/0 $2,000 Holland, Suffolk Norfolk Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Suffolk Airport SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN DETAILS Several trees blown onto power lines. Also, an old two story farm building was collapsed. Several trees fell down. Numerous trees blown down. Metal furniture blown off porch into river and shingles blown off of houses. Trees down on power lines. Damage occurred to three tied down airplanes. One of the planes was lifted up and crashed into the other two. Also, a panel was blown off a hangar and temporary tents were destroyed. Several trees fell down. Sixty MPH straight-line wind caused damages to the part of a metal roof of a fire station and a storage building. Concrete wall of the storage building was caved in when supports gave away. No description available Several trees were down and a few trees limbs fell down on houses. A car was blown a couple hundred feet. Several trees twisted down causing power outages. Several trees were down. Numerous tree limbs and debris blown onto Route 164 in Twin Pines area. Dugout roof at baseball field blown off at Churchland high school. Four pine trees blown down at Churchland high school. Numerous trees were down. Several trees down and damaged a few homes. Wind gust of 58 knots (67 mph) was recorded at Norfolk International Airport. A few trees were down. Trees and wires were down on two houses. Large tree down blocking Route 460. Wind gust of 81 mph reported by Norfolk International Airport Tower. Wind gust to 61 mph reported at WAVY TV 10. Cape Henry Tower reported wind gust of 76 knots (87 mph). A motel on Shore Drive suffered window damages. Several trees were down near Suffolk Airport. MAY 2006 4:32 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS TABLE 4.6: SIGNIFICANT SEVERE THUNDERSTORM EVENTS (1950-2004) LOCATION DATE OF MAGNITUDE DEATHS/ OCCURRENCE (KNOTS) INJURIES PROPERTY DAMAGE Norfolk Virginia Beach Suffolk Isle of Wight 5/24/1999 N/A 0/0 $2,000 5/24/1999 0 knots. 0/0 $1,000 7/7/1999 N/A 0/0 $1,000 7/24/1999 N/A 0/0 $2,000 Portsmouth 7/24/1999 N/A 0/0 $1,000 Windsor 7/28/1999 N/A 0/0 $1,000 Norfolk 7/28/1999 N/A 0/0 $1,000 Virginia Beach 7/28/1999 0 knots. 0/0 $1,000 Windsor 8/11/1999 N/A 0/0 $1,000 Suffolk 8/14/1999 N/A 0/0 $2,000 Norfolk 8/20/1999 N/A 0/0 $15,000 Suffolk 8/26/1999 N/A 0/0 $1,000 Norfolk 8/26/1999 N/A 0/0 $2,000 Isle of Wight 5/29/2000 40 knots 1/ 3 $0 Portsmouth 6/18/2000 50 knots 0/0 $2,000 Norfolk 6/18/2000 67 knots 0/0 $100,000 Portsmouth Virginia Beach 6/19/2000 50 knots 0/0 $2,000 6/19/2000 50 knots. 0/0 $4,000 Norfolk 7/19/2000 50 knots 0/0 $2,000 SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN DETAILS Trees were down Large tree limbs down near Salem Woods. Large trees were down. A few trees were down. A large tree fell down and many tree limbs were down. A large tree fell on power lines. A large tree blocked road and fell on power lines. Large tree was down off Kings Road near London Bridge area. Two large tree limbs were down on Route 460. A few trees were down. Roofs were blown off of a motel and an apartment building in the East Ocean View section of the city. Also, some structural damage occurred to the apartment building. Another hotel in East Ocean View suffered minor roof damage. Numerous power lines were down by large tree branches. Wind blew house off jacks and power lines were down in Ocean View. A powerful storm system off the North Carolina and Virginia coast produced high winds and waves over the James River. One man was killed and three others were treated for hypothermia from the still-cold water when their 16 foot fishing boat capsized in the James River. Effects from the high winds did not extend very far inland. Trees blown down on Linear Crescent. A severe thunderstorm hit downtown Norfolk and Portsmouth as the OpSail 2000 Festival was ending, sending vendors scurrying to fold tents and spectators running for cover. Several tall ships broke free of their moorings and several sailors were knocked into the Elizabeth River. Part of a brick wall was knocked down at Bute and Botetourt Streets, and another wall partially collapsed at a building on Front Street in Norfolk. A large tree fell into the Painted Lady Restaurant at 17th and Monticello Avenue in Norfolk. High winds blew down several trees. High winds blew down several trees onto power lines at Colony Trailer Park. Trees were blown down on power lines and caused power outages in the Colonial Place section of the city. MAY 2006 4:33 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS TABLE 4.6: SIGNIFICANT SEVERE THUNDERSTORM EVENTS (1950-2004) LOCATION DATE OF MAGNITUDE DEATHS/ OCCURRENCE (KNOTS) INJURIES PROPERTY DAMAGE Norfolk 8/1/2000 50 knots 0/0 $0 Suffolk 8/16/2000 N/A 0/0 $2,000 Suffolk 8/16/2000 50 knots. 0/0 $2,000 Isle of Wight 12/24/2001 N/A 0/0 $15,000 4/19/2002 61 knots. 0/0 $5,000 5/2/2002 N/A 0/0 $2,000 5/13/2002 N/A 0/0 $2,000 5/13/2002 5/13/2002 5/13/2002 N/A N/A N/A 0/0 0/0 0/0 $2,000 $2,000 $2,000 5/13/2002 0 knots. 0/0 $2,000 Virginia Beach 5/18/2002 0 knots. 0/0 $1,000 Portsmouth 2/22/2003 50 knots 0/0 $2,000 Norfolk 2/22/2003 50 knots 0/0 $5,000 2/22/2003 50 knots. 0/0 $2,000 2/22/2003 50 knots. 0/0 $2,000 5/8/2003 62 knots. 0/0 $0 6/7/2003 50 knots. 0/0 $5,000 Suffolk 6/13/2003 50 knots. 0/0 $2,000 Norfolk Virginia Beach Isle of Wight 7/9/2003 59 knots 0/0 $0 7/9/2003 50 knots. 0/0 $2,000 8/17/2003 50 knots 0/0 $2,000 Suffolk 8/17/2003 50 knots. 0/0 $2,000 Suffolk 8/17/2003 50 knots. 0/0 $5,000 Windsor 3/7/2004 50 knots 0/0 $2,000 Suffolk 3/7/2004 50 knots. 0/0 $4,000 Suffolk 5/23/2004 50 knots. 0/0 $2,000 Holland 5/26/2004 50 knots. 0/0 $2,000 Virginia Beach Suffolk Isle of Wight Portsmouth Suffolk Norfolk Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Suffolk SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN DETAILS No description available High winds blew down trees on North Lloyd Street near downtown Suffolk. Also, dime-sized hail fell in the Route 460/Route 13-32/North Main Street corridor near downtown Suffolk. High winds blew down trees at the 300 block of Drum Hill Road. High winds with the passage of a cold front turned camper upside down and ripped siding off of house in the Smithfield area. Roof and siding peeled off of a building at Back Bay Wildlife Refuge. One foot diameter trees were down. Trees were down. Trees were down. Trees were down. Trees and power lines down. Trees were down. Numerous tree limbs were down in Thoroughgood area. Spotter estimated a wind gust of 55 mph. Trees were down. Numerous trees and power lines were down. Also, some minor damage occurred to houses. Trees and power lines down. Trees and power lines down. No description available Parts of a building blown into the road. One tree down on a house in Holland section of Suffolk. No description available Trees fell on power lines on Northampton Boulevard. Several trees were down on road. Trees down on Everets Road. Trees down on Edwards Road. A tree fell down on a house. Trees were down on Mill Swamp Road causing power outages. Trees were down at 2700 Block of Arches Mill Road and along the Kings Highway Bridge Road. Numerous trees were down throughout city. Trees and power lines were down. MAY 2006 4:34 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS TABLE 4.6: SIGNIFICANT SEVERE THUNDERSTORM EVENTS (1950-2004) LOCATION DATE OF MAGNITUDE DEATHS/ OCCURRENCE (KNOTS) INJURIES PROPERTY DAMAGE Smithfield 6/10/2004 50 knots 0/0 $2,000 Suffolk 6/10/2004 50 knots. 0/0 $2,000 6/25/2004 50 knots. 0/0 $2,000 6/30/2004 7/7/2004 50 knots. 50 knots. 0/0 0/0 $2,000 $2,000 7/7/2004 50 knots. 0/0 $2,000 7/7/2004 50 knots. 0/0 $2,000 7/14/2004 50 knots 0/0 $2,000 7/14/2004 50 knots. 0/0 $2,000 3/8/2005 50 knots 0/0 $2,000 1/15 $595,000 Virginia Beach Suffolk Suffolk Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Smithfield Virginia Beach Windsor TOTAL DETAILS Three trees were down along Smithfield Boulevard near Hunter Way. Two trees were down in the vicinity of Trumpet Drive and Okelly Drive. Trees and power lines were down. Trees down on Kings Highway. Trees down. Numerous trees down west of oceanfront. Trees down along 3600 block of Virginia Beach Boulevard. Trees down on Route 10 and Burrells Bay Road. Trees down at North Landing and Princess Anne Road. Trees down along Central Hill Road. Source: National Climatic Data Center Table 4.7 shows a summary of reported hail events for the Southside Hampton Roads region between 1950 and 2004. A total of 48 hail events are known to have impacted the region since 1957, resulting in a total of approximately $15,040,000 in property damage. The size of the recorded hailstones ranged from 0.5 inches to 2.5 inches. TABLE 4.7: REGIONAL HAIL ACTIVITY (1950-2004) LOCATION Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Isle of Wight Virginia Beach Norfolk Suffolk Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Suffolk Suffolk Suffolk Virginia Beach Isle of Wight Suffolk Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Isle of Wight DATE OF OCCURRENCE MAGNITUDE PROPERTY DAMAGE 1/10/1957 4/8/1957 6/14/1963 5/7/1967 7/3/1968 10/14/1971 6/23/1974 6/23/1974 6/6/1977 8/5/1983 6/27/1985 6/2/1989 6/8/1990 7/1/1990 7/1/1990 7/1/1990 5/1/1991 5/1/1991 5/1/1991 5/1/1991 7/18/1992 7/18/1992 9/4/1993 0.67 in. 1.00 in. 0.75 in. 1.75 in. 2.00 in. 1.50 in. 1.75 in. 1.00 in. 1.75 in. 1.00 in. 0.75 in. 0.75 in. 1.75 in. 1.00 in. 2.50 in. 2.50 in. 1.75 in. 2.00 in. 1.00 in. 1.00 in. 1.00 in. 1.00 in. 1.75 in. $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $1,000 SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN DETAILS No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. MAY 2006 4:35 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS TABLE 4.7: REGIONAL HAIL ACTIVITY (1950-2004) DATE OF OCCURRENCE MAGNITUDE PROPERTY DAMAGE Portsmouth 3/15/1996 0.50 in. $0 Norfolk Virginia Beach Isle of Wight Portsmouth Norfolk 3/15/1996 3/15/1996 6/24/1996 6/24/1996 6/24/1996 6/24/1996 0.88 in. 1.25 in. 1.00 in. 1.75 in. 1.75 in. 0.75 in. $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 7/3/1996 7/3/1996 7/3/1996 7/18/1996 7/31/1996 3/29/1997 3/29/1997 3/29/1997 3/29/1997 5/1/1997 1.75 in. 0.88 in. 1.00 in. 1.00 in. 0.75 in. 1.00 in. 1.75 in. 1.25 in. 0.75 in. 1.75 in. $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $25,000 5/1/1997 5/1/1997 1.50 in. 1.75 in. $0 $10,000,000 5/1/1997 1.75 in. $5,000,000 7/16/1997 9/8/1997 3/21/1998 5/8/1998 5/8/1998 5/8/1998 5/8/1998 6/15/1998 2/28/1999 7/24/1999 9/7/1999 3/11/2000 3/11/2000 3/11/2000 4/17/2000 0.88 in. 1.00 in. 0.75 in. 1.00 in. 1.00 in. 0.88 in. 0.88 in. 0.75 in. 0.75 in. 0.75 in. 0.75 in. 0.75 in. 0.75 in. 1.00 in. 0.75 in. $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 LOCATION Virginia Beach Portsmouth Portsmouth Virginia Beach Portsmouth Portsmouth Portsmouth Suffolk Norfolk Virginia Beach Portsmouth Suffolk Norfolk Virginia Beach Norfolk Virginia Beach Norfolk Isle of Wight Suffolk Norfolk Virginia Beach Suffolk Suffolk Portsmouth Suffolk Portsmouth Norfolk Norfolk Smithfield SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN DETAILS Marble size hail reported in Churchland section of Portsmouth. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. Dime size hail occurred at Bayside Hospital. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. Many homes were damaged by hail. No details available. Hail caused widespread damage to homes, businesses and vehicles. Hail caused widespread damage to homes, businesses, and vehicles. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. 0.75 inch diameter hail reported by a spotter on Carver Road in Smithfield. MAY 2006 4:36 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS TABLE 4.7: REGIONAL HAIL ACTIVITY (1950-2004) LOCATION DATE OF OCCURRENCE MAGNITUDE PROPERTY DAMAGE DETAILS 4/17/2000 0.75 in. $0 4/21/2000 0.88 in. $0 5/10/2000 1.75 in. $10,000 5/27/2000 6/18/2000 6/22/2000 1.75 in. 1.00 in. 0.75 in. $2,000 $0 $0 8/16/2000 8/16/2000 0.75 in. 0 kts. $0 $2,000 4/15/2002 4/15/2002 4/19/2002 6/1/2002 6/1/2002 0.75 in. 1.00 in. 1.75 in. 0.75 in. 1.75 in. $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 5/3/2003 5/29/2003 8/17/2003 8/17/2003 7/7/2004 4/23/2005 4/23/2005 1.00 in. 1.00 in. 0.75 in. 1.25 in. 0.75 in. 1.00 in. 1.00 in. $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0.75 inch diameter hail reported just west of Holland in southwestern Suffolk. 0.88 inch diameter hail reported in Kempsville section of Virginia Beach. Hail up to 1.75 inches reported from Ocean Lakes towards the oceanfront. No details available. No details available. Dime sized hail fell along Sweatt Road. No details available. Dime-sized hail fell in the Route 460/Route 13-32/North Main Street corridor near downtown Suffolk. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. Dime to golf ball size hail between Little Creek and Thoroughgood sections, and west end of Virginia Beach oceanfront. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. No details available. Suffolk Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Suffolk Virginia Beach Suffolk Windsor Suffolk Isle of Wight Isle of Wight Virginia Beach Norfolk Virginia Beach Suffolk Portsmouth Isle of Wight Virginia Beach Norfolk Norfolk Virginia Beach TOTAL 78 Events Source: National Climatic Data Center $15,040,000 PROBABILITY OF FUTURE OCCURRENCES Severe thunderstorms will remain a highly likely occurrence for region. Hail will also be experienced in the region in the future due to such storms. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:37 LIGHTNING BACKGROUND Lightning is a discharge of electrical energy resulting from the buildup of positive and negative charges within a thunderstorm, creating a “bolt” when the buildup of charges becomes strong enough. This flash of light usually occurs within the clouds or between the clouds and the ground. A bolt of lightning can reach temperatures approaching 50,000 degrees Fahrenheit. Lightning rapidly heats the sky as it flashes but the surrounding air cools following the bolt. This rapid heating and cooling of the surrounding air causes thunder. On average, 89 people are killed each year by lightning strikes in the United States. LOCATION AND SPATIAL EXTENT Multiple cloud-to-ground and cloud-to-cloud lightning strokes observed during a nighttime thunderstorm. (Photo courtesy of NOAA Photo Library, NOAA Central Library; OAR/ERL/ National Severe Storms Laboratory) According to the National Lightning Safety Institute, Virginia had nineteen (19) lightning-related deaths from th 1990 to 2003 ranking the state fourteenth (14 ) in the United States in such deaths. This breaks down to th be 0.19 deaths per million people ranking Virginia as the twenty-seventh (27 ) most at risk state in regards to lightning-caused death per population density. According to the Virginia Department of Emergency Management, lightning has killed 62 people in Virginia and injured at least 252 people between 1959 and 2003. It is believed that many additional injuries go unreported. Nationally, from 1959 through 1994, lightning injured 13,057 people and killed 3,239, mostly men between the ages of 20 and 40. Nationally, most strikes occurred between 1 p.m. and 5 p.m. during weekends. The National Lightning Detection System identified an average of seven million cloud-to-ground lightning strikes per year, resulting in one lightning casualty once every 86,000 strikes. Figure 4.18 shows average lightning flash density per square mile, per year as reported by Global Atmospherics, Inc. This graphic shows that the Virginia Beach area is a relative „hot spot” for lightning strike activity. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:38 FIGURE 4.18: AVERAGE LIGHTNING FLASH DENSITY – 1990-1996 Source: Virginia Power, displayed on the NOAA website According to the National Lightning Safety Institute, damage estimates reported by government agencies (such as NCDC) do not accurately represent actual losses due to underestimation or underreporting of actual damages. Nationwide, realistic lightning costs and losses may reach $4 to $5 billion per year including losses associated with forest fires, insurance claims and damages to warehouses, aircraft, electrical infrastructure and nuclear power plants. SIGNIFICANT HISTORICAL EVENTS According to the National Climatic Data Center database of storm events, 12 lightning events not directly associated with a thunderstorm event are known to have impacted the region since 1950, resulting in 3 known deaths, 7 known injuries and over $106,000 in reported property damage, as shown in Table 4.8. PROBABILITY OF FUTURE OCCURENCES The Southside Hampton Roads region will continue to be at risk to the lighting hazard. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 4:39 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS TABLE 4.8: LIGHTNING ACTIVITY IN THE SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS REGION (1950-2004) DATE OF OCCURRENCE DEATHS/ INJURIES PROPERTY DAMAGE Smithfield 6/20/1996 0/0 $0 Portsmouth 5/6/1996 0/0 $5,000 Suffolk 4/1/1998 0/0 $4,000 Suffolk 8/1/1999 0/2 $10,000 Norfolk 6/14/1994 0/2 $0 Norfolk 6/16/1996 0/0 $2,000 Norfolk 8/26/1996 0/2 $0 Norfolk 7/30/2000 0/0 $45,000 Norfolk 8/11/2001 1/0 $0 Virginia Beach 3/15/1996 0/0 Virginia Beach 5/6/1996 0/0 Virginia Beach 7/30/2000 1/1 Virginia Beach 7/1/2004 1/0 LOCATION $0 $40,000 $0 TOTAL 3/7 Source: National Climatic Data Center $0 DETAILS Lightning strike caused power outages to 5,600 customers in the Smithfield area. Lightning strike caused power surge that created problems with city's central computer system. Also it damaged city's radio system. Lightning strike caused damage to a one-story house. Several rooms had plaster blown off the walls due to the strike's force. The roof and boxing were also damaged. Several homes at Blue Teal Court were struck by lightning and several people were hospitalized. A bolt of lightning struck and critically injured a 50year-old woman and a 38-year-old man playing in a golf tournament at Greenbrier Country Club. Both suffered severe burns. Lightning strike knocked down a large oak tree that fell onto a road. Lightning strike seriously injured two boys who were sitting on the bench of a picnic table beneath a tree. Lightning struck six homes in the Ghent and Ocean View sections of Norfolk. One bolt hit a tree on Old Ocean View Road and started a fire. The burning tree then fell into a nearby home. Occupants of the house escaped without injury. A woman struck by lightning while on boat. Lightning started a small fire near Kempsville Road and Centerville Turnpike. About 2000-2500 Virginia Power customers lost power. Lightning strike caused fires that damaged the roofs of two houses. Lightning struck and killed a man doing yard work near a tree in the Great Neck Point section of Virginia Beach. A roofer, working at Providence Road Elementary School, was struck by lightning and later died. $106,000 SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:40 TORNADOES BACKGROUND A tornado is a violent windstorm characterized by a twisting, funnel-shaped cloud extending to the ground. Tornadoes are most often generated by thunderstorm activity (but sometimes result from hurricanes and tropical storms) when cool, dry air intersects and overrides a layer of warm, moist air forcing the warm air to rise rapidly. The damage caused by a tornado is a result of the high wind velocity and wind-blown debris, also accompanied by lightning or large hail. According to the National Weather Service, tornado wind speeds normally range from 40 to more than 300 miles per hour. The most violent tornadoes have rotating winds of 250 miles per hour or more and are capable of causing extreme destruction and turning normally harmless objects into deadly missiles. Each year, an average of over 800 tornadoes is reported nationwide, resulting in an average of 80 deaths and 1,500 injuries (NOAA, 2002). They are more likely to occur during the spring and early summer months of March through June and can occur at any time of day, but are likely to form in the late afternoon and early evening. Most tornadoes are a few dozen yards wide and touch down briefly, but even small short-lived tornadoes can inflict tremendous damage. Highly destructive tornadoes may carve out a path over a mile wide and several miles long. Waterspouts are weak tornadoes that form over warm water and are most common along the Gulf Coast and southeastern states. Waterspouts occasionally move inland, becoming tornadoes that cause damage and injury. However, most waterspouts dissipate over the open water causing threats only to marine and boating interests. Typically a waterspout is weak and short-lived, and because they are so common, most go unreported unless they cause damage. The most comprehensively observed tornado in history, this tornado south of Dimmitt, Texas developed June 2, 1995 curving northward across Texas Highway 86 where it entirely removed 300 feet of asphalt from the road tossing it more than 600 feet into an adjacent field. It also caused F4 damage at an isolated rural residence just north of the road. (NOAA Photo Library, NOAA Central Library; OAR/ERL/National Severe Storms Laboratory) The destruction caused by tornadoes ranges from light to inconceivable depending on the intensity, size, and duration of the storm. Typically, tornadoes cause the greatest damages to structures of light construction such as residential homes (particularly mobile homes), and tend to remain localized in impact. The Fujita-Pearson Scale for Tornadoes was developed to measure tornado strength and associated damages, and is shown in Table 4.9. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 4:41 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS TABLE 4.9: FUJITA-PEARSON SCALE FOR TORNADOES F-SCALE NUMBER INTENSITY PHRASE WIND SPEED F0 Gale tornado 40-72 MPH F1 Moderate tornado 73-112 MPH F2 Significant tornado 113-157 MPH F3 Severe tornado 158-206 MPH F4 Devastating tornado 207-260 MPH F5 Incredible tornado 261-318 MPH F6 Inconceivable tornado 319-379 MPH TYPE OF DAMAGE POSSIBLE Some damage to chimneys; breaks branches off trees; pushes over shallow-rooted trees; damages to sign boards. The lower limit is the beginning of hurricane wind speed; peels surface off roofs; mobile homes pushed off foundations or overturned; moving autos pushed off the roads; attached garages may be destroyed. Considerable damage. Roofs torn off frame houses; mobile homes demolished; boxcars pushed over; large trees snapped or uprooted; light object missiles generated. Roof and some walls torn off well-constructed houses; trains overturned; most trees in forest uprooted. Well-constructed houses leveled; structures with weak foundations blown off some distance; cars thrown and large missiles generated. Strong frame houses lifted off foundations and carried considerable distances to disintegrate; automobile sized missiles fly through the air in excess of 100 meters; trees debarked; steel re-enforced concrete structures badly damaged. These winds are very unlikely. The small area of damage they might produce would probably not be recognizable along with the mess produced by F4 and F5 wind that would surround the F6 winds. Missiles, such as cars and refrigerators would do serious secondary damage that could not be directly identified as F6 damage. If this level is ever achieved, evidence for it might only be found in some manner of ground swirl pattern, for it may never be identifiable through engineering studies. Source: The Tornado Project, 2002 According to the NOAA Storm Prediction Center (SPC), the highest concentration of tornadoes in the United States has been in Oklahoma, Texas, Kansas and Florida respectively. Although the Great Plains region of the Central United States does favor the development of the largest and most dangerous tornadoes (earning the designation of “tornado alley”), Florida experiences the greatest number of tornadoes per square mile of all U.S. states (SPC, 2002). Figure 4.19 shows tornado activity in the United States based on the number of recorded tornadoes per 1,000 square miles. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:42 FIGURE 4.19: TORNADO ACTIVITY IN THE UNITED STATES Source: American Society of Civil Engineers The tornadoes associated with tropical cyclones are most frequent in September and October when the incidence of tropical storm systems is greatest. This type of tornado usually occurs around the perimeter of the storm, and most often to the right and ahead of the storm path or the storm center as it comes ashore. These tornadoes commonly occur as part of large outbreaks and generally move in an easterly direction. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:43 LOCATION AND SPATIAL EXTENT When compared with other states, Virginia ranks 29th in number of tornado events, 25th in tornado deaths, 26th in tornado injuries and 28th in damages. These rankings are based upon data collected for all states and territories for tornado events between 1950 and 2003 (Storm Prediction Center, 2003). Figure 4.20 illustrates the approximate location where confirmed tornadoes have touched down in the region. The Fujita Scale classification of each tornado is indicated next to each occurrence. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 4:44 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS SIGNIFICANT HISTORICAL EVENTS According to National Climatic Data Center records, the region has experienced 50 tornado events from 1950 through December of 2004, causing 1 death, 10 injuries and approximately $5,126,000 million in property damage (Table 4.10). Details for each event, where available, have also been recorded in this table. TABLE 4.10: TORNADO EVENTS IN SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS REGION (1950-2004) LOCATION Norfolk Norfolk Portsmouth Suffolk Isle of Wight Norfolk Norfolk Virginia Beach Norfolk Norfolk Portsmouth Virginia Beach Suffolk Suffolk Suffolk Norfolk Virginia Beach Norfolk Suffolk Virginia Beach Virginia Beach Isle of Wight Suffolk Virginia Beach DATE OF DEATHS/ MAGNITUDE OCCURRENCE INJURIES PROPERTY DAMAGE 4/8/1957 5/27/1957 7/10/1959 10/9/1959 F1 F F1 F2 0/2 0/0 0/0 0/0 $250,000 $3,000 $3,000 $25,000 2/18/1960 F1 0/0 $25,000 4/8/1962 4/11/1962 F1 F0 1/0 0/1 $250,000 $3,000 10/25/1967 F1 0/0 $25,000 4/30/1968 8/10/1968 11/3/1971 F1 F1 F1 0/0 0/0 0/4 $250,000 $0 $2,500,000 7/27/1972 F1 0/2 $25,000 5/20/1973 5/28/1973 3/19/1975 6/6/1977 F0 F1 F1 F 0/0 0/0 0/0 0/0 $0 $3,000 $25,000 $25,000 10/2/1977 F 0/0 $25,000 4/4/1980 3/30/1981 F1 F2 0/1 0/0 $250,000 $250,000 7/4/1981 F1 0/0 $25,000 8/3/1988 F2 0/0 $250,000 11/28/1988 F2 0/0 $250,000 3/29/1991 F0 0/0 $25,000 8/15/1992 F0 0/0 $0 Isle of Wight 8/6/1993 F0 0/0 $0 Isle of Wight 10/5/1995 F0 0/0 $10,000 Isle of Wight 10/5/1995 F0 0/0 $10,000 Smithfield 7/12/1996 F1 0/0 $25,000 SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN DETAILS No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available No description available A tornado was sighted at the Franklin Airport. This is open area and no damage was noted. Brief tornado touched down uprooted a large oak tree and several cedar/pine trees. It tore roof off of garage. Tornado touched down briefly in a wooded farm area. Outbuildings were damaged; tree tops blown out; and several trees down just north of Burnt Mills Lake. Small tornado damaged 10-15 homes and several trees in the Moorfield subdivision of Smithfield. MAY 2006 4:45 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS TABLE 4.10: TORNADO EVENTS IN SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS REGION (1950-2004) LOCATION DATE OF DEATHS/ MAGNITUDE OCCURRENCE INJURIES PROPERTY DAMAGE Norfolk 7/24/1997 F1 0/0 $400,000 Norfolk 7/24/1997 F0 0/0 $100,000 Smithfield 7/30/1997 N/A 0/0 $0 Portsmouth 7/30/1997 N/A 0/0 $0 Suffolk 7/30/1997 N/A 0/0 $0 Norfolk 7/30/1997 N/A 0/0 $0 Virginia Beach 7/30/1997 N/A 0/0 $0 Virginia Beach 4/9/1998 F0 0/0 $0 Norfolk 4/8/2000 N/A 0/0 $0 Norfolk 6/19/2000 N/A 0/0 $0 Virginia Beach 7/24/2000 F0 0/0 $20,000 SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN DETAILS Tornado path started just south of Poindexter Street on Guerriere Street in Norfolk. The tornado then continued north-northeast into the Berkley Avenue Industrial Park before crossing into the southern portion of Norfolk and lifting after causing damage on Roseclair and Joyce Streets. One business, a car wash was destroyed, and six buildings sustained major roof damages in the Roseclair and Joyce Street areas of Norfolk. Tornado first touched down west of Route 460 between Liberty Street and Indian River Road. The tornado tracked northnortheast across Indian River Road and across the eastern branch of the Elizabeth River before lifting east of Harbor Park and south of I-264. It caused minor damages to several residential structures. Several waterspouts were reported over the James River. Several waterspouts were reported just north of Portsmouth at the intersection of the southern Chesapeake Bay and the James River. Several waterspouts were reported over the James River. Several waterspouts were reported just north of Norfolk over the southern Chesapeake Bay. Several waterspouts were reported just north of Virginia Beach over the southern Chesapeake Bay A fairly long tracking tornado touched down in portions of Chesapeake and Virginia Beach. The tornado was first detected in the Riverwalk section of the city of Chesapeake around 4:30 PM. The tornado tracked east-northeastward through the Greenbrier section of Chesapeake and moved through the city of Virginia Beach along a KempsvilleRosemont-Lynnhaven axis. The tornado damage was generally of F0 intensity (weak) along the entire track in both Chesapeake and Virginia Beach. Norfolk emergency manager reported a waterspout north of Ocean View. No description available A waterspout that formed over Back Bay came ashore at Campbell Landing Road and destroyed a 20 by 30 foot outbuilding before dissipating. Many trees were blown down and camper shells and lawn furniture were tossed across the neighborhood. MAY 2006 4:46 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS TABLE 4.10: TORNADO EVENTS IN SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS REGION (1950-2004) LOCATION DATE OF DEATHS/ MAGNITUDE OCCURRENCE INJURIES PROPERTY DAMAGE Norfolk 8/20/2000 N/A 0/0 $0 Norfolk 10/9/2000 N/A 0/0 $0 Virginia Beach 10/9/2000 N/A 0/0 $0 Suffolk 5/21/2001 F0 0/0 $25,000 Suffolk 6/1/2001 F1 0/0 $15,000 Suffolk 2/22/2003 F0 0/0 $25,000 Virginia Beach 8/8/2003 F0 0/0 $5,000 Norfolk 9/18/2003 F0 0/0 $0 Suffolk 6/25/2004 F1 0/0 $2,000 Suffolk 6/25/2004 F0 0/0 $2,000 Virginia Beach 7/12/2004 N/A 0/0 $0 Virginia Beach 8/14/2004 N/A 0/0 $0 1/10 $5,126,000 TOTAL 50 Events DETAILS A waterspout formed in Hampton Roads harbor between Norfolk and Newport News. A waterspout formed off Ocean View Beach, and then quickly dissipated. A waterspout was observed by the Coast Guard near Lynnhaven Inlet. Tornado (F0) occurred in the 5000 block of Manning Road. Several small outbuildings were destroyed. A tornado touched down near Jackson Road about 8:10 PM. The damage path for this tornado was approximately 100 feet wide. The tornado skipped up and down for about a mile along a path to the northeast of Turlington Road. It uprooted a number of trees and took shingles off roofs. The tornado became a funnel cloud which touched down again around 8:15 PM just south of Sleepy Hole Road and passed through a part of Sleepy Hole Golf Club. The tornado continued north northeast through Chatham Woods after causing extensive damage along Burning Tree Lane. The total path length in the northern part of the county was about 1 mile long and 100 yards wide. Numerous trees were down and a number of houses lost siding and some roofing material. Several 50-60 foot trees pushed over into houses. Tornado (F0) briefly touched down with minor damage reported at Salem Crossing Shopping Center. It caused minor damage to a movie theater and adjacent post office knocking down antennae and some mailboxes. Fire department observed narrow funnel and swirling debris at the surface. Brief F0 tornado occurred in association with Hurricane Isabel. No damage was reported. F1 tornado downed numerous trees near intersection of Route 660 and Route 668. F0 tornado downed several trees on Cypress Chapel Road in Whaleyville. Funnel cloud reported between Sandbridge Beach and Back Bay. No damage reported. Originally reported as a tornado, but never touched down. Source: National Climatic Data Center SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:47 PROBABILITY OF FUTURE OCCURRENCES It is likely that the region will continue to experience weak to moderately intense tornadoes. It is unlikely that very strong tornadoes (F3, F4 or F5) will strike the area, though it does remain possible. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:48 WINTER STORMS AND NOR’EASTERS BACKGROUND A winter storm can range from a moderate snow over a period of a few hours to blizzard conditions with blinding wind-driven snow that lasts for several days. Some winter storms may be large enough to affect several states, while others may affect only a single community. Many winter storms are accompanied by low temperatures and heavy and/or blowing snow, which can severely impair visibility. Winter storms may include snow, sleet, freezing rain, or a mix of these wintry forms of precipitation. Sleet—raindrops that freeze into ice pellets before reaching the ground—usually bounce when hitting a surface and do not stick to objects; however, sleet can accumulate like snow and cause a hazard to motorists. Freezing rain is rain that falls onto a surface with a temperature below freezing, forming a glaze of ice. Even small accumulations of ice can cause a significant hazard, especially on power lines and trees. An ice storm occurs when freezing rain falls and freezes immediately upon impact. Communications and power can be disrupted for days, and even small accumulations of ice may cause extreme hazards to motorists and pedestrians. A freeze is weather marked by low temperatures, especially when below the freezing point (zero degrees Celsius or thirty-two degrees Fahrenheit). Agricultural production is seriously affected when temperatures remain below the freezing point. A heavy layer of ice was more weight than this tree in Kansas City, Missouri could withstand during a January 2002 ice storm that swept through the region bringing down trees, power lines and telephone lines. (Photo by Heather Oliver/FEMA News Photo) Nor’easters are extra-tropical events that produce strong winds and precipitation in the form of heavy rain, ice or snow. They can cause increases in tidal elevations (storm surge), wind speed, and erosion. These cyclonic storms, called nor‟easters because of the direction of the storm winds, can last for several days and can impact very large areas. The presence of the Gulf Stream off the eastern seaboard in the winter season acts to dramatically enhance the surface horizontal temperature gradients within the coastal zone. This is particularly true off the Virginia coastline where, on average, the Gulf Stream is closest to land north of 32 degrees latitude. During winter offshore cold periods, these horizontal temperature gradients can result in rapid and intense destabilization of the atmosphere directly above and shoreward of the Gulf Stream. This air mass modification or conditioning period often precedes wintertime coastal extra-tropical cyclone development. It is the temperature structure of the continental air mass and the position of the temperature gradient along the Gulf Stream that drives this cyclone development. As a low pressure deepens, winds and waves can uninhibitedly increase and cause serious damage to coastal areas as the storm generally moves to the northeast. The coastal counties of Virginia are most vulnerable to the impacts of nor‟easters. Since the storms often occur at night, and typically make landfall with less warning than hurricanes (due to their rapid formation along the coast), residents may be caught at home unprepared. On the other hand, nor‟easters typically SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 4:49 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS occur during the tourist off-season when fewer non-residents are visiting the coast. As with hurricanes, structural vulnerability to nor‟easters is proportional to the strength of the structure, with mobile homes being particularly vulnerable. TABLE 4.11: DOLAN-DAVIS NOR’EASTER INTENSITY SCALE STORM CLASS BEACH EROSION DUNE EROSION PROPERTY DAMAGE OVERWASH 1 (Weak) Minor changes None No No 2 (Moderate) Modest; mostly to lower beach Minor No Modest 3 (Significant) Erosion extends across beach Can be significant No 4 (Severe) Severe beach erosion and recession Extreme beach erosion Severe dune erosion or destruction Dunes destroyed over extensive areas On low beaches Loss of many structures at local level Loss of structures at community- scale 5 (Extreme) SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN Massive in sheets and channels Extensive at regional-scale; millions of dollars MAY 2006 4:50 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS LOCATION AND SPATIAL EXTENT Historical evidence indicates that the Southside Hampton Roads region has been impacted by varying degrees of snow storms and ice storms over the last century. In terms of receiving measurable snowfall, the National Climatic Data Center estimates that there is statistically an 85.8 percent probability that the region will receive measurable snowfall in any given year; a 78.9 percent probability in winter; and a 24.4 percent probability in spring (Table 4.12). Figure 4.21 shows the number of days (annually) with snowfall greater than one inch. Figure 4.22 shows region‟s winter storm hazard risk as determined in the Virginia State Hazard Mitigation Plan. Winter storms impact each jurisdiction uniformly. All building stock, infrastructure and critical facilities are equally vulnerable to these hazards. Vulnerability maps showing infrastructure and critical facilities that are at risk to these hazards are found in Appendix B. TABLE 4.12: PROBABILITY OF RECEIVING A MEASURABLE SNOWFALL JURISDICTION Isle of Wight Norfolk Portsmouth Suffolk Virginia Beach TOTALS: ANNUAL PROBABILITY WINTER PROBABILITY SPRING PROBABILITY FALL PROBABILITY No data 89.8% No data 92.5% 75% 85.8% No data 88.7% No data 87.2% 60.7% 78.9% No data 35.8% No data 26.9% 10.5% 24.4% No data 5.6% No data 6.9% 2.1% 4.9% Source: NOAA, National Climatic Data Center, Snow Climatology Page SIGNIFICANT HISTORICAL EVENTS According to the National Climatic Data Center, the Southside Hampton Roads region has experienced 24 significant winter storm events including snow and ice storms, extreme cold, and freezing rain since 1993 (Table 4.13). These events account for $20,120,000 in property damages for the affected areas, which includes multiple counties. The region received presidential disaster declarations from major winter storms in 1996 (the Blizzard of ‟96) and 2000. Some of the more significant winter storms to impact the region in the twentieth century are discussed below. On March 1-3, 1927 a nor'easter hit the region with high winds gusting to 62 mph at Cape Henry and 52 mph at Norfolk. Heavy snow fell across North Carolina into Virginia and travel was delayed for two to three days. In Virginia Beach, high tide and heavy surf on March 2 inflicted considerable damage. The beaches in some places were washed back 50 feet and denuded of the overlying sand, exposing the clay beneath. On April 11, 1956, a severe Nor'easter gave gale winds (greater than 40 mph) and unusually high tides to the Tidewater Virginia area. At Norfolk, the strongest gust was 70 mph. The strong northeast winds blew for almost 30 hours and pushed up the tide, which reached 4.6 feet above normal in Hampton Roads. Thousands of homes were flooded by the wind-driven high water and damages were large. Two ships were driven aground. Waterfront fires were fanned by the high winds. The flooded streets made access to firefighters very difficult, which added to the losses. On January 30-31, 1966, a blizzard struck Virginia and the Northeast U.S. It was the second snowstorm to hit Virginia in a week. The first storm dumped 9 inches in Norfolk. With fresh snow on the ground, arctic air settled in and temperatures dropped into the teens. The second storm dumped one to two feet of snow SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:51 over a large part of the state. Intense winds and drifting snow continued and kept roads closed for several days after the storm. Temperatures dropped into the single digits with some falling below zero. Wind chill temperatures were dangerously low. The winter of 1976-1977 was the coldest winter on the East Coast of the past century. Storms across the state dropped a few more inches every few days to keep a fresh coating on the streets that were just clearing from the previous storms. The average temperature for the month of January in Norfolk was 29.2°F which was 12° below normal. The prolonged cold wave caused oil and natural gas shortages and President Carter asked people to turn thermostats down to conserve energy. The major elements of this winter were the cold temperatures. There was little snowfall associated with this winter in the Southside Hampton Roads region. The “Presidents Day Storm” of February 1979 dropped 7 inches on snow on Norfolk on February 18-19 and 13 inches of snow were recorded for the entire month. The following winter, 20 inches fell in Virginia Beach and a foot of snow fell in Norfolk in a storm that hit the region in February. On March 1, another foot of snow fell in Norfolk and the total snowfall amount of 41.9 inches for Norfolk was the snowiest winter ever recorded in eastern Virginia. The “Superstorm of March ’93,” was also known as “The Storm of the Century” for the eastern United States, due to its large area of impact, all the way from Florida and Alabama through New England. Impacts in the Southside Hampton Roads region were not as severe, but this storm still caused major disruption across a large portion of the country. The “1996 Blizzard” from January 6 to January 13, 1996 affected much of the eastern seaboard. In Virginia, the winter storm left up to 36 inches of snow in portions of the state. In the Southside Hampton Roads region, most of the communities saw at least a foot of snow between January 6 and January 12. Many other descriptions of historical occurrences of winter storms and nor‟easters can be found online at http://www.vaemergency.com/newsroom/history/winter.cfm SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 4:52 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS TABLE 4.13: WINTER STORM ACTIVITY IN THE SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS REGION (19982004) LOCATION DATE OF OCCURRENCE TYPE OF EVENT Isle of Wight County 9 jurisdictions, including Isle of Wight 17 jurisdictions, including Isle of Wight 20 jurisdictions, including Isle of Wight 33 jurisdictions, including Isle of Wight 40 jurisdictions, including Isle of Wight 12/28/1993 Winter Weather 1/6/1996 Winter Storm 25 jurisdictions, including Isle of Wight 1/19/2000 Winter Storm 7 jurisdictions, including Isle of Wight 1/25/2000 Winter Storm 4 jurisdictions, including Isle of Wight 2/2/1996 Winter Storm 2/16/1996 Winter Storm 3/7/1996 Winter Storm 12/23/1998 Ice Storm 12/3/2000 Winter Storm PROPERTY DAMAGE DETAILS $0 No description available. $50,000 No description available. $0 A winterstorm tracked northeast from the gulf coast states to off the Virginia coast. It spread a mixture of snow, sleet and some freezing rain from the lower Chesapeake Bay southwest into south central Virginia. $0 A storm tracked northeast from western South Carolina Thursday night to off the North Carolina coast Friday morning. Then it moved off north and spread heavy snow across Virginia. $0 A low pressure area developed over the Carolinas and then tracked off Virginia coast. It spread light snow across central and eastern Virginia. $20,000,000 A major ice storm affected central and eastern Virginia from Wednesday into Friday. A prolonged period of freezing rain and some sleet resulted in ice accumulations of one half inch to one inch in many locations. The heavy ice accumulations on trees and power lines caused widespread power outages across the region. Approximately 400,000 customers were without power during the maximum outage period. Some customers were without power for about ten days. Many accidents occurred due to slippery road conditions, especially bridges and overpasses. Many secondary roads were impassable due to fallen tree limbs or whole trees. $0 Two to three inches of snow fell overnight as an area of low pressure passed south of the region. The highest amounts were measured along a line from Caroline county in the north, through the city of Richmond, then along the southern shore of the James River. $20,000 A significant winter storm dropped 8 to 12 inches of snow across portions of eastern Virginia. There was blowing and drifting of snow from winds which gusted over 40 mph at times. The snow mixed with sleet and freezing rain occasionally during the late morning hours. In Isle of Wight County, strong winds pushed the Pagan River onto South Church Street. Isle of Wight County snowfall totaled 7 to 8 inches. $50,000 A winter storm struck parts of extreme southern and southeastern Virginia. The storm affected a relatively small area, but the areas that had snow received some hefty totals. Windsor reported 4 inches of snowfall. Local law enforcement agencies reported scores of accidents, several of which involved injuries. Schools were closed the following day. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 4:53 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS TABLE 4.13: WINTER STORM ACTIVITY IN THE SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS REGION (19982004) LOCATION DATE OF OCCURRENCE TYPE OF EVENT PROPERTY DAMAGE 27 jurisdictions, including Isle of Wight 2/22/2001 Winter Storm $0 18 jurisdictions, including Isle of Wight 1/2/2002 Winter Storm $0 19 jurisdictions, including Isle of Wight 12/4/2002 Winter Storm $0 43 jurisdictions, including Isle of Wight 1/6/2003 Winter Weather/ mix $0 27 jurisdictions, including Isle of Wight 1/16/2003 Winter Storm 0 12 jurisdictions, including Isle of Wight 1/23/2003 Winter Weather/ mix $0 17 jurisdictions, including Isle of Wight 2/15/2003 Winter Storm $0 24 jurisdictions, including Isle of Wight 1/9/2004 Winter Storm $0 14 jurisdictions, including Isle of Wight 1/25/2004 Winter Storm $0 SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN DETAILS A winter storm produced 1 to 4 inches of snow across south central and eastern Virginia. Local law enforcement agencies reported numerous accidents, some of which involved injuries. Many schools were dismissed early on the day of the storm, and several schools in the area were either closed or had a delayed opening the following day due to slippery road conditions. A winter storm produced 8 to as much as 12 inches of snow across south central and southeast Virginia. Local law enforcement agencies reported numerous accidents. Most schools in the area were closed Thursday and Friday due to very slippery road conditions. A winter storm produced 1 to 4 inches of snow along with 1/4 to 1/2 inch of ice from south central Virginia northeast through the middle peninsula and Virginia northern neck. Numerous trees and power lines were reported down due to ice accumulations, resulting in scattered power outages. Local law enforcement agencies also reported numerous accidents. Most schools in the area were closed Thursday and Friday due to power outages and very slippery road conditions. A weak winter storm produced only a dusting to 1 inch of snow across portions of central and eastern Virginia. Accumulations from this storm were mostly on cars and grassy areas, with roadways remaining generally wet although some slush was reported. A winter storm produced 4 to 8 inches of snow across portions of central and eastern Virginia. Local law enforcement agencies reported numerous accidents. Most schools in the area were closed Friday due to very slippery road conditions. A winter storm produced around one inch of snow across portions of south central and southeast Virginia. Local law enforcement agencies reported several accidents. A winter storm produced 1 to 3 inches of snow, along with sleet and 1/4 to 1/2 inch of ice accumulation, across central and eastern Virginia. Local law enforcement agencies reported numerous accidents. Most schools in the area were closed Monday due to very slippery road conditions. Two to as much as five inches of snow fell across portions of central, south central, and southeast Virginia. The snow produced very slippery roadways, which resulted in several accidents. Two to as much as four inches of snow and sleet fell across portions of eastern and southeast Virginia. The snow and sleet produced very slippery roadways, which resulted in numerous accidents and school closings for a few days. MAY 2006 4:54 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS TABLE 4.13: WINTER STORM ACTIVITY IN THE SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS REGION (19982004) DATE OF OCCURRENCE TYPE OF EVENT PROPERTY DAMAGE 2/15/2004 Winter Storm $0 12/19/2004 Winter Weather/ mix $0 12/26/2004 Winter Storm $0 1/19/2005 Winter Weather/ mix $0 1/20/2005 Winter Weather/ mix $0 36 jurisdictions, including Isle of Wight 2/3/2005 Winter Weather/ mix $0 TOTAL 24 Events LOCATION 22 jurisdictions, including Isle of Wight 43 jurisdictions, including Isle of Wight 10 jurisdictions, including Isle of Wight 43 jurisdictions, including Isle of Wight 41 jurisdictions, including Isle of Wight DETAILS One to three inches of snow fell across portions of south central and southeast Virginia. The snow produced very slippery roadways, which resulted in several accidents and school closings for a few days. One half inch to as much as three inches of snow fell across central and eastern Virginia. The snow produced slippery roadways, which resulted in several accidents. A winter storm produced a narrow band of six to as much as fourteen inches of snow across the Virginia Eastern Shore, Hampton Roads, and interior southeast Virginia. The snow caused very hazardous driving conditions, which resulted in numerous accidents. Smithfield in Isle of Wight county reported 12 inches and Isle of Wight reported 11 inches. One half inch to as much as two inches of snow fell across central and eastern Virginia. The snow produced slippery roadways, which resulted in several accidents. One half inch to as much as three inches of snow fell across much of central and eastern Virginia. The snow produced slippery roadways, which resulted in several accidents. . One half inch to two inches of snow fell across much of central and eastern Virginia. A few isolated areas reported close to four inches. The snow produced slippery roadways, which resulted in several accidents. Smithfield in Isle of Wight county reported 2.3 inches of snow. $20,120,000 12 Source: National Climatic Data Center PROBABILITY OF FUTURE OCCURRENCES Winter storms will remain a likely occurrence for the region. While storms will be more likely to produce small amounts of snow, sleet or freezing rain, larger storms, though less frequent in occurrence, could also impact the region. 12 Damages are based on the methodological assumption that damages were equally distributed among impacted counties. While this may not produce an exact estimate of property damage within the region, it is deemed sufficient for planning purposes within this context. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:55 EROSION (COASTAL AND RIVERINE) BACKGROUND Erosion is the gradual breakdown and movement of land due to both physical and chemical processes of water, wind, and general meteorological conditions. Natural, or geologic, erosion has occurred since the Earth‟s formation and continues at a very slow and uniform rate each year. Major storms such as hurricanes and tropical storms may cause more sudden, rapid erosion by combining heavy rainfall, high winds, heavy surf and storm surge to significantly impact river banks and the shoreline. As it relates to natural hazards that threaten property damage, there are two types of erosion to be concerned: riverine erosion and coastal erosion. The primary concern of both riverine and coastal erosion is the gradual removal of rock, vegetation and other sediment materials from river banks, stream beds and shorelines that result in soil instability and possible damages to property and infrastructure. Riverine erosion is a long term geologic process that reshapes river beds and stream banks as sediment is excavated and transported downstream. Typically, it occurs faster during periods of high velocity flows brought on by heavy rainfall, stormwater runoff and/or dam releases. Riverine erosion is most often mitigated through local sediment and erosion control projects, such as the construction of armored revetments and bulkheads or the replacement of vegetation that serves to stabilize eroding soils. The riverine erosion hazard is also greatly minimized through the designation of riparian buffers and the enforcement of regulatory setbacks from eroding river banks. Erosion threatens to damage a waterfront home. (Photo courtesy of FEMA) Coastal erosion is a significant, long term hazard that threatens to undermine waterfront homes, businesses, and public facilities along our all of our nation‟s shorelines, eventually rendering them uninhabitable or unusable. Coastal erosion is driven by number of natural influences such as rising sea level, large storms such as tropical storms, nor‟easters and hurricanes, storm surge, flooding and powerful ocean waves. Manmade influences such as coastal development, offshore dredging or shoreline stabilization projects can also exacerbate coastal erosion, even when initially intended to minimize immediate or erosion effects. According to FEMA, coastal erosion has been a factor in more than 25 federal disaster designations during the past twenty years. The average annual erosion rate on the Atlantic coast is roughly 2 to 3 feet per year. States bordering the Gulf of Mexico have the nation‟s highest average annual erosion rates (6 feet per year). That being said, erosion rates vary greatly from location to location and year to year. Both the Atlantic and Gulf coasts are bordered by a chain of roughly 300 barrier islands, which are composed primarily of loose sand and are the most dynamic land masses along the open-ocean coast. Barrier island coastlines have been retreating landward for thousands of years in response to slowly rising sea levels. A recent study by The Heinz Center (2000), Evaluation of Erosion Hazards, states that over the next 60 years, erosion may claim one out of four houses within 500 feet of the U.S. shoreline. It also states that nationwide, erosion may be responsible for approximately $500 million in property loss to coastal property owners per year, including both damage to structures and loss of land. To the homeowners living within areas subject to coastal erosion, the risk posed by erosion is comparable to the risk from flooding and SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:56 other natural hazard events. While not as sudden, coastal erosion clearly influences the stability and condition of coastal property and beaches when such other events occur. LOCATION AND SPATIAL EXTENT Although some riverine erosion occurs in various locations along the rivers that flow through the Southside Hampton Roads region, there are no riverine erosion hazard data or maps available at this time to conduct a region-wide analysis. Riverine erosion concerns are localized in nature and are best suited for site-specific analyses. Coastal erosion is a significant concern in the Southside Hampton Roads region. According to the Virginia Institute of Marine Sciences (VIMS), the Atlantic and Chesapeake Bay coasts surrounding the area are very dynamic in terms of shoreline change and sediment transport processes. VIMS and other agencies occasionally perform studies to determine long term shoreline change patterns for various locations across the region. However, these studies are largely intended to track shoreline and dune evolution through natural and manmade alterations, and not designed to determine erosion rates or areas of coastal erosion. While the Federal Emergency Management Agency does not map erosion hazard 13 areas, it does map the highest risk areas for coastal flooding with wave action (“V zones”) . For purposes of this analysis it can generally be assumed that areas identified as coastal high hazard zones are also at risk to the effects of coastal erosion. While coastal flooding is typically a short term event, coastal erosion may best be described as a relatively slow natural process occurring over the long term, with occasional major impacts wrought by coastal storm and flooding hazards. Another complicating factor in accurately determining specific coastal erosion hazard areas is the continuous implementation of shoreline reinforcement or nourishment projects completed by federal, state and local government agencies. Typically, areas of high concern with regard to long term erosion are addressed through shoreline hardening or stabilization projects, such as seawalls, breakwaters and beach sand replenishment. For example, in 2002, the Virginia Beach Erosion Control and Hurricane Protection Project was completed, protecting more than six miles from the imminent hazards of coastal erosion through sand renourishment. Many other projects have been completed in the region and still others 14 are pending approval and/or funding . The ability to continue successfully mitigating the effects of coastal erosion hazards throughout the region will depend on regular shoreline monitoring and the design and implementation of site-specific solutions, as has been done in the past. This photo, taken while the Virginia Beach Erosion Control and Hurricane Protection Project was underway, shows the significant difference between the unimproved area and the area of the widened beach berm already completed. (Source: City of Virginia Beach) HISTORICAL OCCURENCES No significant riverine erosion events have been recorded in the region. Coastal erosion events often occur in conjunction with hurricanes, tropical storms and nor‟easters. 13 14 For more information on FEMA V-zones, refer to the Flood hazard. In countering the effects of coastal erosion, Virginia Beach‟s shoreline has been renourished annually since 1951. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:57 PROBABILITY OF FUTURE OCCURENCES Over time, riverine and coastal erosion will continue to occur in the Southside Hampton Roads region. Coastal erosion will be more immediate and severe during hurricanes, tropical storms and nor‟easters. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:58 EARTHQUAKES BACKGROUND An earthquake is the motion or trembling of the ground produced by sudden displacement of rock in the Earth's crust. Earthquakes result from crustal strain, volcanism, landslides or the collapse of caverns. Earthquakes can affect hundreds of thousands of square miles; cause damage to property measured in the tens of billions of dollars; result in loss of life and injury to hundreds of thousands of persons; and disrupt the social and economic functioning of the affected area. Most property damage and earthquake-related deaths are caused by the failure and collapse of structures due to ground shaking. The level of damage depends upon the amplitude and duration of the shaking, which are directly related to the earthquake size, distance from the fault, site and regional geology. Other damaging earthquake effects include landslides, the down-slope movement of soil and rock (mountain regions and along hillsides), and liquefaction, in which ground soil loses the ability to resist shear and flows much like quick sand. In the case of liquefaction, anything relying on the substrata for support can shift, tilt, rupture or collapse. Many roads, including bridges and elevated highways, were damaged by the 6.7 magnitude earthquake that impacted the Northridge, California area January 17, 1994. Approximately 114,000 structures were damaged and 72 deaths were attributed to the event. Damage costs were estimated at $25 billion. (FEMA News Photo) Most earthquakes are caused by the release of stresses accumulated as a result of the rupture of rocks along opposing fault planes in the Earth‟s outer crust. These fault planes are typically found along borders of the Earth's 10 tectonic plates. These plate borders generally follow the outlines of the continents, with the North American plate following the continental border with the Pacific Ocean in the west, but following the mid-Atlantic trench in the east. As earthquakes occurring in the mid-Atlantic trench usually pose little danger to humans, the greatest earthquake threat in North America is along the Pacific Coast. The areas of greatest tectonic instability occur at the perimeters of the slowly moving plates, as these locations are subjected to the greatest strains from plates traveling in opposite directions and at different speeds. Deformation along plate boundaries causes strain in the rock and the consequent buildup of stored energy. When the built-up stress exceeds the rocks' strength, a rupture occurs. The rock on both sides of the fracture is snapped, releasing the stored energy and producing seismic waves, generating an earthquake. Earthquakes are measured in terms of their magnitude and intensity. Magnitude is measured using the Richter Scale, an open-ended logarithmic scale that describes the energy release of an earthquake through a measure of shock wave amplitude (see Table 4.14). Each unit increase in magnitude on the Richter Scale corresponds to a 10-fold increase in wave amplitude, or a 32-fold increase in energy. Intensity is most commonly measured using the Modified Mercalli Intensity (MMI) Scale based on direct and indirect measurements of seismic effects. The scale levels are typically described using roman numerals, with a I corresponding to imperceptible (instrumental) events, IV corresponding to moderate (felt by people awake), to XII for catastrophic (total destruction). A detailed description of the Modified Mercalli Intensity Scale of earthquake intensity and its correspondence to the Richter Scale is given in Table 4.15. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 4:59 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS TABLE 4.14: RICHTER SCALE RICHTER MAGNITUDES Less than 3.5 3.5-5.4 EARTHQUAKE EFFECTS Generally not felt, but recorded. Often felt, but rarely causes damage. Under 6.0 At most slight damage to well-designed buildings. Can cause major damage to poorly constructed buildings over small regions. 6.1-6.9 Can be destructive in areas up to about 100 kilometers across where people live. 7.0-7.9 Major earthquake. Can cause serious damage over larger areas. Great earthquake. Can cause serious damage in areas several hundred kilometers across. Source: United States Geological Survey 8 or greater TABLE 4.15: MODIFIED MERCALLI INTENSITY SCALE FOR EARTHQUAKES SCALE INTENSITY DESCRIPTION OF EFFECTS I Instrumental II Feeble Some people feel it III Slight Felt by people resting; like a truck rumbling by IV Moderate V Slightly Strong VI Strong VII CORRESPONDING RICHTER SCALE MAGNITUDE Detected only on seismographs <4.2 Felt by people walking Sleepers awake; church bells ring <4.8 Trees sway; suspended objects swing, objects fall off shelves <5.4 Very Strong Mild Alarm; walls crack; plaster falls <6.1 VIII Destructive Moving cars uncontrollable; masonry fractures, poorly constructed buildings damaged IX Ruinous X Disastrous XI Very Disastrous XII Catastrophic Some houses collapse; ground cracks; pipes break open Ground cracks profusely; many buildings destroyed; liquefaction and landslides widespread Most buildings and bridges collapse; roads, railways, pipes and cables destroyed; general triggering of other hazards Total destruction; trees fall; ground rises and falls in waves <6.9 <7.3 <8.1 >8.1 Source: United States Geological Survey Figure 4.23 shows the probability that ground motion will reach a certain level during an earthquake. The data show peak horizontal ground acceleration (the fastest measured change in speed, for a particle at ground level that is moving horizontally due to an earthquake) with a 10 percent probability of exceedance in 50 years. The map was compiled by the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) Geologic Hazards Team, which conducts global investigations of earthquake, geomagnetic, and landslide hazards. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:60 FIGURE 4.23: PEAK ACCELERATION WITH 10 PERCENT PROBABILITY OF EXCEEDANCE IN 50 YEARS Source: United States Geological Survey SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:61 LOCATION AND SPATIAL EXTENT Virginia is affected by both the New Madrid Fault in Missouri and the Charleston Fault in South Carolina. During the last 200 years, both of these faults have generated earthquakes measuring greater than 8 on the Richter Scale. There is also an area of frequent, yet very weak, earthquake activity located to the southwest of Charlottesville, Virginia. Figure 4.24 shows the earthquake intensity level associated with the Southside Hampton Roads region, based on the national U.S. Geological Survey map of peak acceleration with 10 percent probability of exceedance in 50 years. According to this data, the entire region can be considered to be in a low earthquake risk zone, with a peak ground acceleration value (%g) of 1 and 2. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 4:62 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS SIGNIFICANT HISTORICAL EVENTS Table 4.16 lists the 7 significant earthquake events that have impacted the Southside Hampton Roads region as compiled from National Geophysical Data Center records for the period 1638 to 1985. TABLE 4.16: SIGNIFICANT SEISMIC EVENTS IN THE SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS REGION LOCATION Norfolk Norfolk Norfolk Norfolk Norfolk Norfolk Norfolk Suffolk Suffolk DATE OF OCCURRENCE 12/16/1811 8/28/1833 9/1/1886 2/21/1916 4/21/1918 3/1/1925 9/5/1944 9/1/1886 4/21/1918 15 MMI 5 3 5 3 2 2 3 5 2 DISTANCE FROM EPICENTER (MILES) 1188 N/A 560 581 N/A 1339 881 527 N/A Source: National Geophysical Data Center PROBABILITY OF FUTURE OCCURRENCES Earthquakes of significant magnitude are unlikely occurrences for the Southside Hampton Roads region, though the proximity of the region to the Charleston Fault could increase the possibility of feeling some impact of a large earthquake if it were to occur along that fault line. 15 Modified Mercalli Intensity (MMI) scale for earthquakes. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:63 LANDSLIDES BACKGROUND A landslide is the downward and outward movement of slope-forming soil, rock, and vegetation, which is driven by gravity. Landslides may be triggered by both natural and human-caused changes in the environment, including heavy rain, rapid snow melt, steepening of slopes due to construction or erosion, earthquakes, volcanic eruptions, and changes in groundwater levels. There are several types of landslides: rock falls, rock topple, slides, and flows. Rock falls are rapid movements of bedrock, which result in bouncing or rolling. A topple is a section or block of rock that rotates or tilts before falling to the slope below. Slides are movements of soil or rock along a distinct surface of rupture, which separates the slide material from the more stable underlying material. Mudflows, sometimes referred to as mudslides, mudflows, lahars or debris avalanches, are fast-moving rivers of rock, earth, and other debris saturated with water. They develop when water rapidly accumulates in the ground, such as heavy rainfall or rapid snowmelt, changing the soil into a flowing river of mud or "slurry." Slurry can flow Landslides can damage or destroy roads, railroads, pipelines, electrical and telephone lines, mines, oil rapidly down slopes or through channels, and can wells, buildings, canals, sewers, bridges, dams, strike with little or no warning at avalanche speeds. seaports, airports, forests, parks, and farms. (Photo Slurry can travel several miles from its source, growing by Lynn Forman) in size as it picks up trees, cars, and other materials along the way. As the flows reach flatter ground, the mudflow spreads over a broad area where it can accumulate in thick deposits. Landslides are typically associated with periods of heavy rainfall or rapid snow melt and tend to worsen the effects of flooding that often accompanies these events. In areas burned by forest and brush fires, a lower threshold of precipitation may initiate landslides. Some landslides move slowly and cause damage gradually, whereas others move so rapidly that they can destroy property and take lives suddenly and unexpectedly. Among the most destructive types of debris flows are those that accompany volcanic eruptions. A spectacular example in the United States was a massive debris flow resulting from the 1980 eruptions of Mount St. Helens, Washington. Areas near the bases of many volcanoes in the Cascade Mountain Range of California, Oregon and Washington are at risk from the same types of flows during future volcanic eruptions. Areas that are generally prone to landslide hazards include previous landslide areas; the bases of steep slopes; the bases of drainage channels; and developed hillsides where leach-field septic systems are used. Areas that are typically considered safe from landslides include areas that have not moved in the past; relatively flat-lying areas away from sudden changes in slope; and areas at the top or along ridges, set back from the tops of slopes. In the United States, it is estimated that landslides cause up to $2 billion in damages and from 25 to 50 deaths annually. Globally, landslides cause billions of dollars in damage and thousands of deaths and injuries each year. Figure 4.25 delineates areas where large numbers of landslides have occurred and areas which are susceptible to landsliding in the conterminous United States. This map layer is provided in the U.S. Geological Survey Professional Paper 1183, Landslide Overview Map of the Conterminous United States, available online at: SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:64 http://landslides.usgs.gov/html_files/landslides/nationalmap/national.html. FIGURE 4.25: LANDSLIDE OVERVIEW MAP OF THE CONTERMINOUS UNITED STATES Source: United States Geological Survey SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:65 LOCATION AND SPATIAL EXTENT Figure 4.26 shows general indication of areas that may be susceptible to landslides according to the United States Geological Survey. Minor landslide events are possible in localized, steep-sloped areas during extremely wet conditions. Portions of eastern Isle of Wight County and Suffolk are moderately at risk to landslides. This is an area where bluffs are present along the James River. SIGNIFICANT HISTORICAL EVENTS There is no history of significant landslide events in the region. PROBABILITY OF FUTURE OCCURRENCES Landslides remain a possible occurrence in localized areas of the Southside Hampton Roads region, but impacts from such events would likely cause minimal localized damage. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 4:66 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS SINKHOLES BACKGROUND Sinkholes are a natural and common geologic feature in areas with underlying limestone and other rock types that are soluble in natural water. Most limestone is porous, allowing the acidic water of rain to percolate through their strata, dissolving some limestone and carrying it away in solution. Over time, this persistent erosive process can create extensive underground voids and drainage systems in much of the carbonate rocks. Collapse of overlying sediments into the underground cavities produces sinkholes. The three general types of sinkholes are: subsidence, solution, and collapse. Collapse sinkholes are most common in areas where the overburden (the sediments and water contained in the unsaturated zone, surficial aquifer system, and the confining layer above an aquifer) is thick, but the confining layer is breached or absent. Collapse sinkholes can form with little warning and leave behind a deep, steep sided hole. Subsidence sinkholes form gradually where the overburden is thin and only a veneer of sediments is overlying the limestone. Solution sinkholes form where no overburden is present and the limestone is exposed at land surface. Collapses, such as the sudden formation of sinkholes, may destroy buildings, roads, and utilities. (Photo: Bettmann) Sinkholes occur in many shapes, from steep-walled holes to bowl or cone shaped depressions. Sinkholes are dramatic because the land generally stays intact for a while until the underground spaces get too big. If there is not enough support for the land above the spaces, then a sudden collapse of the land surface can occur. Under natural conditions, sinkholes form slowly and expand gradually. However, human activities such as dredging, constructing reservoirs, diverting surface water, and pumping groundwater can accelerate the rate of sinkhole expansions, resulting in the abrupt formation of collapse sinkholes. Although a sinkhole can form without warning, specific signs can signal potential development: Slumping or falling fence posts, trees, or foundations Sudden formation of small ponds Wilting vegetation Discolored well water Structural cracks in walls, floors Sinkhole formation is aggravated and accelerated by urbanization. Development increases water usage, alters drainage pathways, overloads the ground surface, and redistributes soil. According to FEMA, the number of human-induced sinkholes has doubled since 1930, insurance claims for damages as a result of sinkholes has increased 1,200 percent from 1987 to 1991, costing nearly $100 million. LOCATION AND SPATIAL EXTENT Existing soil types in the Southside Hampton Roads region are not conducive to the formation of natural sinkholes. There is a higher potential for soil piping and/or erosion caused by leakage from drainage pipes, culverts, etc. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:67 SIGNIFICANT HISTORICAL EVENTS There have been no reported sinkhole occurrences in the region. Most sinkholes in this region are caused by pipes underneath the ground that form cracks due to age and over time leaks erode the dirt and soil around it. PROBABILITY OF FUTURE OCCURRENCES Sinkholes remain a possible occurrence in localized areas of the region, but impacts from such events would likely cause minimal localized damage. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:68 DROUGHT BACKGROUND Drought is a natural climatic condition caused by an extended period of limited rainfall beyond that which occurs naturally in a broad geographic area. High temperatures, high winds and low humidity can worsen drought conditions, and can make areas more susceptible to wildfire. Human demands and actions can also hasten drought-related impacts. Droughts are frequently classified as one of four types: meteorological, agricultural, hydrological or socio-economic. Meteorological droughts are typically defined by the level of “dryness” when compared to an average or normal amount of precipitation over a given period of time. Agricultural A USGS streamflow gaging station at the Ogeechee droughts relate common characteristics of drought to River near Eden, Georgia in July 2000 illustrates their specific agricultural-related impacts. Emphasis the drought conditions that can severely affect tends to be placed on factors such as soil water water supplies, agriculture, stream water quality, deficits, water needs based on differing stages of recreation, navigation and forest resources. (Photo crop development, and water reservoir levels. courtesy of the United States Geological Survey) Hydrological drought is directly related to the effect of precipitation shortfalls on surface and groundwater supplies. Human factors, particularly changes in land use, can alter the hydrologic characteristics of a basin. Socio-economic drought is the result of water shortages that limit the ability to supply water-dependent products in the marketplace. Figure 4.27 shows the Palmer Drought Severity Index (PDSI) summary map for the United States from 1895 to 1995. PDSI drought classifications are based on observed drought conditions and range from -0.5 (incipient dry spell) to -4.0 (extreme drought). As can be seen, the Eastern United States has historically not seen as many significant long-term droughts as the Central and Western regions of the country. FIGURE 4.27: PALMER DROUGHT SEVERITY INDEX, 1895-1995 PERCENT OF TIME IN SEVERE AND EXTREME DROUGHT Source: National Drought Mitigation Center SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 4:69 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS LOCATION AND SPATIAL EXTENT Drought typically impacts a large area that cannot be confined to geographic boundaries; however, some regions of the United States are more susceptible to drought conditions than others. According to the Palmer Drought Severity Index (PDSI) Summary Map for the United States, the Commonwealth of Virginia as a whole is in a zone of 5 percent to 9.99 percent PDSI less than or equal to -3 (-3 indicating severe drought conditions) meaning that drought conditions are a relatively low to moderate risk for the Southside Hampton Roads region. Furthermore, it is assumed that the region would be uniformly exposed to this hazard and that the spatial extent of that impact would potentially be large. It is important to note however, that drought conditions typically do not cause significant damage to the built environment. SIGNIFICANT HISTORICAL EVENTS The drought of record for Virginia occurred in 1931 when the statewide average rainfall amount was 7.64 inches compared to an average mean rainfall amount of 17.89. This was during this period that also saw the Great Dust Bowl that helped lead to the Great Depression. Since 1993, the National Climatic Data Center has recorded only 2 instances of drought to impact the 16 Southside Hampton Roads region (Table 4.17). Though instances are recorded on a monthly basis by the National Climatic Data Center, events are usually part of ongoing drought conditions that last several months or years. In addition to this official drought record, periods of drought-like conditions are also known to have impacted the region in 200, 2002, 2003 and 2005. Water restrictions have been put into place as far back as three years and shallow wells are known to have lost water in and around the region. According to State of Virginia records, a declaration of a State of Emergency Due to Extreme Drought Conditions was executed by the Governor of Virginia on August 30, 2005. The Executive Order was to be effective from August 30, 2002 through June 30, 2003. Isle of Wight County is currently (2005) seeking federal disaster drought aid because of drought conditions effecting crop production. TABLE 4.17: OCCURRENCES OF DROUGHT IN THE SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS REGION (1993-2004) LOCATION 17 jurisdictions, including Isle of Wight 20 jurisdictions, including Isle of Wight DATE OF OCCURRENCE 10/31/1993 DETAILS Unusually dry weather during the summer and early fall led to many communities in southeastern Virginia to place water conservation measures into effect in October 1993. 9/1/1997 A very dry period from May through September resulted in drought-like conditions across much of central and eastern Virginia. Monthly rainfall departures from normal for Norfolk included: -2.21 inches in May, -2.73 inches in June, -3.05 inches in August, and -1.93 inches in September. This caused significant crop damage throughout much of the area which was estimated to be around $63.8 million. Source: National Climatic Data Center 16 Drought occurrences recorded by the National Climatic Data Center are not necessarily unique events, as many instances of drought persist through multiple reporting periods. This is reflected in the details provided for some longenduring occurrences in Table 4.17. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:70 PROBABILITY OF FUTURE OCCURRENCES Based on current and seasonal outlook drought maps available through the National Weather Service‟s 17 Climate Prediction Center and the National Drought Mitigation Center , there is no concern for imminent or forecasted drought occurrences. However, based on past events, it certainly remains possible over the long-term that the Southside Hampton Roads region will experience recurring drought conditions when precipitation falls below normal for extended periods of time. Based on climate data, the region will likely continue to experience occasional periods of extreme heat, but not nearly as severe as other regions of the country. 17 Current and seasonal drought outlook maps are made available by the National Drought Mitigation Center at www.drought.unl.edu/dm/index.html. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:71 WILDFIRE BACKGROUND A wildfire is any fire occurring in a wildland area (i.e., grassland, forest, brush land) except for fire under 18 prescription. Wildfires are part of the natural management of the Earth‟s ecosystems, but may also be caused by natural or human factors. Over 80 percent of forest fires are started by negligent human behavior such as smoking in wooded areas or improperly extinguishing campfires. The second most common cause for wildfire is lightning. There are three classes of wildland fires: surface fire, ground fire, and crown fire. A surface fire is the most common of these three classes and burns along the floor of a forest, moving slowly and killing or damaging trees. A ground fire (muck fire) is usually started by lightning or human carelessness and burns on or below the forest floor. Crown fires spread rapidly by wind and move quickly by jumping along the tops of trees. Wildland fires are usually signaled by dense smoke that fills the area for miles around. On Sunday, August 6, 2000, several forest fires State and local governments can impose fire safety converged near Sula, Montana, forming a firestorm regulations on home sites and developments to help that overran 100,000 acres and destroyed 10 curb wildfire. Land treatment measures such as fire homes. Temperatures in the flame front were access roads, water storage, helipads, safety zones, estimated at more than 800 degrees. (Photo by buffers, firebreaks, fuel breaks, and fuel John McColgan/U.S. Forest Service Firefighter) management can be designed as part of an overall fire defense system to aid in fire control. Fuel management, prescribed burning, and cooperative land management planning can also be encouraged to reduce fire hazards. Fire probability depends on local weather conditions, outdoor activities such as camping, debris burning, and construction, and the degree of public cooperation with fire prevention measures. Drought conditions and other natural disasters (hurricanes, tornadoes, etc.) increase the probability of wildfires by producing fuel in both urban and rural settings. Forest damage from hurricanes and tornadoes may block interior access roads and fire breaks, pull down overhead power lines, or damage pavement and underground utilities. Many individual homes and cabins, subdivisions, resorts, recreational areas, organizational camps, businesses, and industries are located within high fire hazard areas. The increasing demand for outdoor recreation places more people in wildlands during holidays, weekends, and vacation periods. Unfortunately, wildland residents and visitors are rarely educated or prepared for the inferno that can sweep through the brush and timber and destroy property in minutes. LOCATION AND SPATIAL EXTENT In July 2003, the Virginia Department of Forestry released a GIS-based wildfire risk assessment for the Commonwealth of Virginia. While this assessment is not recommended for site-specific determinations of 18 Prescription burning, or “controlled burn,” undertaken by land management agencies is the process of igniting fires under selected conditions, in accordance with strict parameters.) SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 4:72 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS wildfire vulnerability, the data was utilized in this Plan as an indicator of potential areas of wildland/urban interface concern within the Southside Hampton Roads region, as shown in Figure 4.28. Essentially, potential wildfire risk areas are presented in three categories indicating the relative level of threat to the community: High, Moderate and Low. There are 679 areas that are classified High wildfire threat areas. When compared with aerial imagery it appears that these areas are lightly developed wooded areas, including some marshland and other forms of undeveloped land. There are 563 relatively large areas that are classified as Moderate wildfire threat areas. These areas include both undeveloped and developed land. Most of the land area of Isle of Wight County and the western two-thirds of Suffolk have been classified as Moderate or High wildfire threat areas. Much of the remainder of the region, including most of Portsmouth, Norfolk and Virginia Beach, are classified as Low wildfire threat areas. This includes heavily developed commercials areas and several residential areas. These more heavily developed areas represent a slightly greater threat with regard to the spread of urban fires. SIGNIFICANT HISTORICAL EVENTS According to Virginia Department of Forestry records, the region experiences an average of 12 wildfire events per year, the majority of which are caused by open burning, arson and smokers. The majority of recorded events have taken place in Isle of Wight County and no events have been recorded in Portsmouth and Norfolk. Only minor property damages—generally amounting to less than $15,000 per year—have been recorded as resulting from wildfire events. Table 4.18 shows the damages of wildfire events in the region between 1995 and 2002. TABLE 4.18: OCCURRENCES OF WILDFIRE IN THE SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS REGION JURISDICTION Virginia Beach YEAR FREQUENCY BURNED ACRES DAMAGE 1995 1996 1 1 10 0.5 $0 $0 1997 2001 2 4 8 28 225 263.5 $0 $0 $0 1995 10 17.5 $0 1996 1997 3 8 1.25 8.5 $0 $500 1998 1999 4 3 9 1.5 $600 $0 2000 2001 5 17 50 6.5 61.65 105.9 $3,000 $0 $4,100 1995 14 154.7 $33,750 1996 1997 2 5 121 132 $8,000 $20,960 1999 2000 3 2 10.5 30 $5,400 $0 2001 1 27 38 486.2 $3,000 $71,110 85 855.6 $75,210 Virginia Beach Total Isle of Wight County Isle of Wight County Total Suffolk Suffolk Total TOTAL Source: Virginia Department of Forestry SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:73 PROBABILITY OF FUTURE OCCURRENCES Wildfires remain a highly likely occurrence for the region, though most will likely continue to occur in less urban areas and be small in size before being contained and suppressed. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:74 DAM / LEVEE FAILURE BACKGROUND Worldwide interest in dam and levee safety has risen significantly in recent years. Aging infrastructure, new hydrologic information, and population growth in floodplain areas downstream from dams and near levees have resulted in an increased emphasis on safety, operation and maintenance. There are approximately 80,000 dams in the United States today, the majority of which are privately owned. Other owners include state and local authorities, public utilities and federal agencies. The benefits of dams are numerous: they provide water for drinking, navigation and agricultural irrigation. Dams also provide hydroelectric power, create lakes for fishing and recreation, and save lives by preventing or reducing floods. Though dams have many benefits, they also can pose a risk to communities if not designed, operated and maintained properly. In the event of a dam failure, the energy of the water stored behind even a small dam is capable of causing loss of life and great property damage if development exists downstream of the dam. If a levee breaks, scores of properties are quickly submerged in floodwaters and residents may become trapped by this rapidly rising water. The failure of dams and levees has the potential to place large numbers of people and great amounts of property in harm‟s way. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN Lake Burnt Mills in Suffolk. (Photo courtesy of City of Suffolk) MAY 2006 4:75 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS LOCATION AND SPATIAL EXTENT 19 According to the National Inventory of Dams maintained by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers , there are 37 major dams located in the Southside Hampton Roads region (Table 4.19). Major dams are defined as dams being 50 feet or more in height, or with a normal storage capacity of 5,000 acre-feet or more, or with a maximum storage capacity of 25,000 acre-feet or more. Of the major dams located in the region, three are classified as “high” hazards where failure or mis-operation of the dam could cause loss of human life. It is important to note that these hazard classifications are not related to the physical condition or structural integrity of the dam (nor the probability of its failure) but strictly to the potential for adverse downstream effects if the dam were to fail. The state regulatory agency for dams is the Virginia Department of Conservation and Recreation through the Dam Safety and Floodplain Management Program. TABLE 4.19: MAJOR DAMS IN THE SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS REGION NAME OF DAM HAZARD CLASSIFICATION YEAR BUILT NORMAL STORAGE (ACRE FEET) High High High Significant Low Significant 1942 1963 1959 1962 1921 1912 7,449 14,620 6,372 1,000 10,600 6,025 Lake Burnt Mills Dam Western Branch Dam Lake Mead Dam C-Pond Dam Lake Prince Dam Lake Cohoon Dam Source: National Inventory of Dams Figure 4.29 shows the location of all major and state-regulated dams in the region, and notes which of those are classified as high, intermediate and low hazard. SIGNIFICANT HISTORICAL EVENTS In Suffolk, during Hurricane Floyd in 1999, Speight‟s Run spillway was compromised rendering Turlington Road impassable. Other dams in Suffolk were overtopped by what was reported as 8 feet of water. There is no other record of any damages, deaths or injuries associated with dam failure in the Southside Hampton Roads region. PROBABILITY OF FUTURE OCCURRENCES Dam failure remains an unlikely occurrence for all major and non-regulated dams in the Southside Hampton Roads region. The Virginia Department of Conservation and Recreation is tasked with monitoring the routine inspection and maintenance of those dams that present the greatest risk or are in need of structural repair. 19 The National Inventory of Dams was developed by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers in cooperation with FEMA's National Dam Safety Program. The full inventory contains over 75,000 dams, of which 7,700 are classified as major, and is used to track information on the country's water control infrastructure. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 4:76 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS TSUNAMI BACKGROUND The word tsunami is Japanese and means “harbor wave.” A tsunami is one or a series of great waves that are created by an earthquake, landslide, volcanic eruption, submarine earthquake or other undersea disturbances. From the area of disturbance, tsunami waves will travel outward in all directions. Tsunamis can originate hundreds or even thousands of miles away from coastal areas. A tsunami is not the same as a tidal wave. The time between wave crests may be five to 90 minutes and the open ocean wave speed may average 450 miles per hour. As tsunami waves approach shallow coastal waters, they appear to be of normal size. Although the waves slow down as they reach shallow water, the energy remains constant. When tsunami waves crash into the shoreline, they may be as high as 100 feet. Areas at greatest risk are less than 50 feet above sea level and within one mile of the shoreline. Rapid changes in the ocean water level may indicate that a tsunami is approaching. Most deaths during a tsunami are the result of drowning. Associated risks include flooding, polluted water supplies, and damaged gas lines. Tsunami Hazard Zone signs are posted at coastal access points or other low-lying areas that would clearly be vulnerable to a large, locally generated tsunami. Signs are placed at locations agreed upon by local and state governmental authorities. Tsunami Evacuation Route markers are used to designate the evacuation routes established by local jurisdictions in cooperation with emergency management officials. (Photos courtesy of Washington State Department of Transportation) In the United States, tsunamis have historically affected the West Coast (Figure 4.30), but the threat of tsunami inundation is also possible on the Atlantic Coast. Pacific Ocean tsunamis are classified as local, regional, or Pacific-wide. Regional tsunamis are most common. Pacific-wide tsunamis are much less common, with the last one being recorded in 1964, but are larger waves that have high potential to cause destruction. The Pacific Tsunami Warning Center was established in 1949 at Ewa Beach, Hawaii to monitor conditions in the Pacific Ocean and to provide warnings in case of tsunamis. According to the Pacific Tsunami Warning Center Laboratory in Novosiirsk, 796 tsunamis were observed or recorded in the Pacific Ocean between 1900 and 2001. Approximately 117 caused casualties and damage and at least nine caused widespread destruction throughout the Pacific. The greatest number of tsunamis during any oneyear was 19 in 1938, but all were minor and caused no damage. There was no single year of the period that was free of tsunamis. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:77 FIGURE 4.30: PRIMARY TSUNAMI HAZARD AREAS LOCATION AND SPATIAL EXTENT There is no historical evidence of tsunami events directly affecting the Southside Hampton Roads region. However—although tsunamis are more frequently associated with Pacific Rim states—historical evidence does indicate that tsunamis have affected the Eastern United States. In fact, 40 tsunamis and tsunami20 like waves have been documented in the Eastern United States since 1600 . Tsunami events along the East Coast are not the result of traditional sources of tsunami waves (i.e., subduction zones such as the Cascadia Subduction Zone), but rather are typically the result of slumping or landsliding associated with local earthquakes or with wave action associated with strong storms such as hurricanes. Other possible causes of tsunami-like activity along the East Coast could include explosive decompression of underwater methane deposits, the impact of a heavenly body (i.e., an asteroid, comet or oceanic meteor splashdown) or a large underwater explosion. One significant contributing factor to tsunami-related damage is the massive amount of moving debris possible during a tsunami event—including manmade debris such as boats and also on-shore debris as the tsunami strikes land. 20 This was documented in an article written by representatives from the National Geophysical Data Center in Volume 20, Number 3 of The International Journal of The Tsunami Society. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:78 SIGNIFICANT HISTORICAL EVENTS To cite one commonly referenced example in terms of Atlantic tsunamis, a severe earthquake registering 7.2 on the Richter Scale on November 18, 1929 in the Grand Banks of Newfoundland generated a tsunami that caused considerable damage and loss of life at Placentia Bay, Newfoundland and is also known to have impacted upon the New England shoreline and was recorded as far south as Charleston, South Carolina. Tsunamis were also generated by the Charleston Earthquake of 1886 and the New Madrid earthquakes of 1811 and 1812. Additionally, a magnitude 8 earthquake in November 1755 may have caused 10-foot waves along the East Coast. Two off-shore areas are currently under investigation according to a 2002 National Geophysical Data Center report. One area of interest consists of large cracks northeast of Cape Hatteras that could foretell of the early stages of an underwater landslide that could result in a tsunami. The other area of interest consists of submarine canyons approximately 150 kilometers from Atlantic City, New Jersey. Significant factors for consideration with regard to these areas are recent discoveries along the East Coast that demonstrate the existence of pressurized hydrates and pressurized water layers in the continental shelf. This has produced speculation among the scientific community on possible triggers that could cause sudden and perhaps violent releases of compressed material that could factor into landslide events and the resulting tsunami waves. PROBABILITY OF FUTURE OCCURRENCES There is still much uncertainty as to the severity of the tsunami threat to the East Coast. With only 40 events recorded since 1600, the probability of future occurrences, while possible, is unlikely. However, this does not mean that jurisdictions in the region should not plan for a tsunami occurrence. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS 4:79 EXTREME TEMPERATURES BACKGROUND Extreme heat is defined as temperatures that hover ten degrees or more above the average high temperature for the region and last for several weeks. Humid conditions may also add to the discomfort of high temperatures. Health risks from extreme heat include heat cramps, heat fainting, heat exhaustion and heat stroke. According to the National Weather Service, heat is the leading weather-related killer in the United States and has killed more people than lightning, tornadoes, floods and hurricanes combined in the last 10 years. However, most deaths are attributed to prolonged heat waves in large cities that rarely experience hot weather. The elderly and the ill are most at-risk, along with those who exercise outdoors in hot, humid weather. Photo courtesy of Environmental Protection Agency Extreme cold is generally associated with extreme winter storms. Extreme cold is a deceptive killer as it indirectly causes injury and death resulting from exhaustion and overexertion, hypothermia and frostbite from wind chill and asphyxiation. LOCATION AND SPATIAL EXTENT According to the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner for the Commonwealth of Virginia, there were 30 deaths recorded in Virginia that were the result of extreme heat or cold. Summertime temperatures in the Southside Hampton Roads region can easily climb into the high 90 to low 100 degree range with high humidity rates. The region is also vulnerable to extreme winter weather occurrences that can bring extreme cold temperatures and wind-chill. SIGNIFICANT HISTORICAL EVENTS While temperature extremes occur fairly frequently in the region, the National Climatic Data Center (NCDC) has only recorded two extreme temperature events recorded that have impacted the region. The first was in August of 1995 and the second was in May of 1996. There are no reported instances of extreme cold weather recorded by NCDC. PROBABILITY OF FUTURE EVENTS It is possible that the Southside Hampton Roads region will experience periods of extreme temperatures in the future. SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006 4:80 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS DATA SOURCES The following primary data sources were among those used to collect the information presented in this section. American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE), “Facts About Windstorms” (www.windhazards.org/facts.cfm) Bureau of Reclamation, U.S. Department of the Interior (www.usbr.gov/) Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) (www.fema.gov) Lin Cao, Wei-Ning Xiang, and Joseph C. Wilson, Department of Geography and Earth Sciences University of North Carolina at Charlotte (www.lightningsafety.com/nlsi_lhm/GIS_study.html) National Climatic Data Center (NCDC), U.S. Department of Commerce, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (http://lwf.ncdc.noaa.gov/oa/ncdc.html) National Drought Mitigation Center, University of Nebraska-Lincoln (www.drought.unl.edu/index.htm) National Geophysical Data Center (www.ngdc.noaa.gov) National Hurricane Center, National Oceanic & Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) (www.nhc.noaa.gov) National Lightning Safety Institute (www.lightningsafety.com) National Severe Storms Laboratory (NSSL), U.S. Department of Commerce, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (www.nssl.noaa.gov) National Weather Service (NWS), U.S. Department of Commerce, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (www.nws.noaa.gov) North Carolina Geological Survey (www.geology.enr.state.nc.us) Storm Prediction Center (SPC), U.S. Department of Commerce, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, National Weather Service (www.spc.noaa.gov) The Tornado Project, St. Johnsbury, Vermont (www.tornadoproject.com) United States Geological Survey (USGS), U.S. Department of the Interior (www.usgs.gov) SOUTHSIDE HAMPTON ROADS HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN MAY 2006