luxury - Internet Retailer
Transcription
luxury - Internet Retailer
portal to e-commerce intelligence LUXURY on theWEB Exclusive Rankings, Data and Analysis of the World’s Largest Luxury E-Retailers Special Report: Luxury on the Web SECTION SECTION 2 SECTION 3 4 SECTION 1 SECTION Table of Contents 5 Luxury merchandise: A new path to e-commerce growth . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Sales of luxury products on the web are experiencing a major growth spurt. And while the bulk of the largest luxury e-retailers are American, Latin American and Chinese merchants are growing much faster. Who are the luxury leaders online? . . . . . . . . . . 12 The largest online luxury players dominate, as they operate well-established, recognized brand names that wealthy consumers admire. Smaller and younger e-retailers, however, are putting up an aggressive fight. Which luxury products sell best online? . . . . . . 20 Luxury e-retailing is dominated first and foremost by designer apparel merchants, though high-end jewelry and accessories are also frequently purchased on the web. Who buys luxury merchandise online? . . . . . . . 25 The online luxury market is extremely attractive to wealthy women, but many young professionals are showing they have enough disposable income to purchase high-end products on the web. Marketing luxury online: It’s all about social media . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28 The world’s top luxury e-retailers are slightly ahead of the e-commerce industry in e-mail marketing and search strategies, but they are light years ahead with social. Copyright 2015, Vertical Web Media LLC. All rights reserved. All Content of the Top 500 Guide, whether in print or digital formats, and all content of the Top500Guide.com database version of this publication (collectively, the “Content”), is owned by Vertical Web Media and protected by U.S. Copyright and by applicable intellectual property laws worldwide. The Content is intended solely for the personal use of Purchasers or Authorized Recipients of said Content, which use is limited to viewing, analyzing and creating reports for internal non-commercial use only. Purchasers and Authorized Recipients of the Content may share such usage with others within his/ her company, but may not copy, download, reproduce, republish, sell, make available, distribute, display, transmit, share, or otherwise distribute any part of the Content to any other persons or entities without the written permission of Vertical Web Media. Purchasers and Authorized Recipients of the Content, in any and all of its formats, may not modify, create derivative works of, reverse com- Publisher: Jack Love [email protected] CEO/President: Molly Love Rogers [email protected] Vice President, Sales & Product Development: Tom Duggan, [email protected] 312-572-6250 Executive Editor: Kurt T. Peters [email protected] Editor in Chief: Don Davis [email protected] Vice President, Research: Mark Brohan [email protected] Research Director: Stefany Zaroban [email protected] Managing Editor, Production and Special Projects, Research: Bill Briggs [email protected] Associate Editor, Research: Jonathan Love [email protected] Research Analyst: Sylvia De Oliveira, [email protected] Senior Research Analyst: Kat Fay, [email protected] Editor: Allison Enright [email protected] Editor, Online Marketing: Zak Stambor [email protected] Editor, Mobile: Katie Evans [email protected] Managing Editor, Digital Content: Tracy Maple [email protected] Managing Editor, B2B E-Commerce: Paul Demery [email protected] Senior Editors: Frank Tong (China), [email protected] Sandra Guy, [email protected] Associate Editor: Matt Lindner, [email protected] Associate Editor, B2B Commerce: Nona Tepper, [email protected] Associate Editor, Mobile: April Berthene [email protected] Editorial Director, Conferences: Mary Wagner [email protected] Production Director: Thomas Chambers [email protected] 312-362-9531 Director of Marketing: Erin Dowd [email protected] Web Production Editor: Farnia Ghavami [email protected] ADVERTISING MANAGERS Southwest, Florida, Ohio, Pennsylvania & International: Cindy Wilkins, [email protected] 312-572-6247 Northeast: Nancy Bernardini, [email protected] 312-572-6276 Southeast (excluding Florida): Judy Dellert, [email protected] 312-572-6279 West: Dave Cappelli, [email protected] 312-362-0063 Midwest, Northwest, Canada & B2B: Oliver Love, [email protected] 312-572-6251 Research & Classifieds: Elizabeth Riley-Green, [email protected] 312-572-6263 pile, disassemble or reverse engineer, republish, sell, license, lease, sublicense, assign, incorporate into published material or any information retrieval system, or otherwise transfer any of the Content without written permission of Vertical Web Media. The trademarks and service marks “Vertical Web Media”, “Internet Retailer®”, and “Top 500 Guide®”, and any logos, designs, slogans or other source-identifying devices, including combinations thereof (excluding any third party owned trademarks or service marks) (“VWM Trademarks”) displayed on Top 500 Guide print, digital and Top500Guide.com database research products are owned by Vertical Web Media. All Top 500 Guide print, digital and database research products are designed to provide accurate and authoritative information in regard to the subject matter covered. These research products are sold with the understanding that the publisher is not engaged in rendering financial, legal, accounting, tax or other professional service. Vertical Web Media makes no warranty as to the reliability, accuracy, timeliness, usefulness, adequacy, completeness or suitability of the Top 500 Guide Content. 2 ©Copyright 2015, 2016 Internet Retailer® & Vertical Web Media LLC. All rights reserved. We make connections that bond people to brands. Epsilon is much more than a marketing agency. We’re an allencompassing marketing partner for your brand. We find, acquire and retain customers for brands around the world. First, we find out who you need to talk to, understand who they are, how they think and how to talk to them. Then, we create targeted messages and experiences that hit the right media, mindset and moment to convert them into customers. After we’ve helped you win their business, we help you win their hearts. We engage customers with your brand and turn them into your most loyal fans so great results become sustainable. Learn more about breaking down the myths and stereotypes of your luxury shoppers in our New Face of Luxury research. epsilon.com Special Report: Luxury on the Web Introduction from the Publisher How global e-commerce is moving upscale A lot has been researched and written about the growing income disparity between affluent and working class families in the United States and elsewhere around the globe. And all of the research leads to an inescapable conclusion—real wages and disposable incomes of middle- and working-class families have stagnated for more than a decade, while the rich have gotten a whole lot richer. In short, all e-retailers have something to learn by studying these high-growth luxury web sites. As such, this first-ever, data-rich research report on luxury e-retailers fulfills the mission that Internet Retailer has long maintained for all of our media products— to provide unrivaled business intelligence in all areas of e-commerce so that our subscribers can take their e-retailing game to a higher level. Like everyone else, the wealthy took a big hit when the housing bubble burst in 2007 and the Great Recession followed. But unlike the rest of society, the finances of the rich recovered with remarkable speed, dramatically expanding the income gap separating those in the upper-income strata from the hoi polloi. This year, according to the Spectrem Group, a market research firm, the number of millionaires in the U.S. exceeded 10 million for the first time—roughly double the number that existed in 1997. This research report contains a detailed analysis of the annual web sales, growth rates, market shares, average orders, conversion rates and marketing metrics of the 74 e-retailers around the globe who dominate the online luxury market. The regional segmentation of this market, the types of merchants that control it and the nature of merchandise included in online luxury are also analyzed and compared. All 74 leading luxury e-retailers were selected from our Top500guide.com database that contains a wealth of current financial, operating and marketing metrics of the world’s 3,000 largest e-retail web businesses. While hundreds of these top retail web sites sell some luxury products, our research team picked the 74 e-retailers who primarily sell luxury items (see the description of the selection criteria on page 5). Such income disparity is concerning to retailers targeting the mass market, but it is joyous news to retailers and makers of luxury items. And it’s the online luxury merchants that may be celebrating the most. In North America and Europe, which have the highest concentrations of wealthy consumers, luxury e-retailing businesses are growing considerably faster as a group than the other leading retail web sites in those regions. In the process, these luxury e-retailers are creating new pathways to e-commerce growth by booking average orders three times higher than other online merchants, perfecting the digital merchandising of their respected brands, and connecting with their well-heeled shoppers by practicing excellent social networking techniques. Did we miss some competitors that should have been included? Possibly. When it comes to publishing annual rankings—and we expect this to be an annual research publication—the first effort always leaves room for improvement. Nonetheless, this inaugural ranking of luxury web sites reveals the leaders and the trends of a big-ticket online market that is often overlooked, and the data on these high-end web merchants reveal a consistent story. It is this: Luxury products sell well online, very well, and this market is headed up, way up. Jack Love Publisher, Internet Retailer 4 ©Copyright 2015, 2016 Internet Retailer® & Vertical Web Media LLC. All rights reserved. Life’s too short for e-commerce. "Using New Relic, we reduced downtime hours by 80% over a five-week period. It's absolutely critical to our day-to-day operations." — Roger Hoffmann, VP of Technology Operations Nordstromrack.com | Hautelook Performance analytics for online retail. SECTION Special Report: Luxury on the Web 1 Luxury merchandise: A new path to e-commerce growth Sales of luxury products on the web are experiencing a major growth spurt. And while the bulk of the largest luxury e-retailers are American, Latin American and Chinese merchants are growing much faster. By Jack Love A s visionary as he is, when Jeff Bezos pioneered e-retailing 20 years, initially selling only books on his new Amazon.com website, it’s a good bet he never envisioned websites that sell Rolex watches, Hermes handbags, Tiffany jewelry or Diane Von Furstenberg gowns. The web, it was thought, was for the sale of everyday items to the everyday shopper. Even now, the most common image of luxury merchandising involves a boutique in a fashionable section of town with snobbish sales associates like those in the film “Pretty Woman.” While the Rodeo Drives of the world still exist, this image of luxury retailing no longer reflects reality. In fact, the newest and fastest-growing segment of luxury merchandising is now found on the web. The “carriage trade,” as the luxury market was once quaintly described, has carved out a profitable and rapidly growing niche on the Internet. Luxury Websites Help Drive Global E-Commerce Growth Top 74 Global Luxury Web Sites 14.6% Top 1000 Retail Web Sites in US Top 500 Retail Web Sites in Europe Top 500 Asia E-Retail Sites 11.6% 9.5% % 2014 Median Web Sales Growth 13.5% Source: Top500Guide.com Measuring the precise size of the global online luxury market is extremely difficult, since hundreds, perhaps thousands, of retail websites around the world sell a number of items that everyone would consider luxury merchandise. But none of these web merchants break out their sales by the types of goods they include, and most do 6 ©Copyright 2015, 2016 Internet Retailer® & Vertical Web Media LLC. All rights reserved. Special Report: Luxury on the Web Average E-Retail Growth Rates not primarily sell luxury products. To identify the world leaders in luxury and analyze the sales growth and other trends in the online luxury Top 1000 Retail Web 15.7% Sites in US market, Internet Retailer’s research team analyzed every e-retailer Top 500 Retail Web 15.6% Sites in Europe ranked in our Top500Guide.com database, which contains detailed Top 3000 Global 28.5% rankings and scores of other E-Retail Sites financial and operating metrics Source: Top500Guide.com on the 1,000 largest e-retailers in North America and the 500 largest web merchants in each of the four other major regions of the globe where we rank and detail the retail leaders on the web—Europe, China, Asia, and Latin America—in all the 3,000 top e-retailers around the globe. Top 74 Global Luxury Web Sites 18.9% How we selected the luxury web merchants In doing so, they identified 74 leading web retailers with high average order values whose businesses consist of selling primarily luxury brand products online—mostly highpriced designer apparel, luxury-branded handbags and other accessories, premium watches, and jewelry. In addition to those retailers mentioned above, the lists includes such other iconic luxury brands as Louis Vuitton, Burberry, Neiman Marcus, Helzberg Diamonds and Chanel, to name a few. (See “How we selected the luxury web merchants” for a full explanation of the selection process used.) To identify the web sites that make up the 74 leaders of the global online luxury market, our researchers accessed six core e-commerce databases of the Top500Guide.com—the Top 500 and Second 500 in North America, and the Top 500 e-retailers in each of the Europe, China, Asia and Latin America. In each of these databases, they set the average order filter at $300 and above, to identify those web merchants with average orders that are at least two to three times the median average order of $125 recorded by the Top 500 web merchants in America, the most matured of all e-commerce markets. They further trimmed the resulting list by eliminating web sites that exceeded the $300 bar, not by selling luxury items to the rich, but by focusing on goods that carry high prices but are clearly not targeted solely to affluent consumers. These include retailers of computers and other electronic gear, home appliances and furniture. Finally, the research team scoured the list of all 3,000 e-retailers in the core database to find sites that sell mostly branded luxury items but which failed to make the $300 cut-off used in the initial screen. G Luxury sales surpass average e-retailing growth rates In comparing these 74 luxury websites to all leading e-retailers around the globe, it’s clear that sales of luxury products on the web is experiencing a major growth spurt. In 2014, the combined sales of the 74 luxury sites grew 18.9% to $11.5 billion. That exceeds by more than 3 percentage points the average growth rates in the U.S. and 8 ©Copyright 2015, 2016 Internet Retailer® & Vertical Web Media LLC. All rights reserved. Special Report: Luxury on the Web The Global Picture: The Luxury E-Commerce Market NORTH AMERICA EUROPE CHINA # of Companies: 51 # of Companies: 6 # of Companies: 6 2014 Web Sales: $7,595,560,873 2014 Web Sales: $1,912,782,206 2014 Web Sales: $1,280,094,493 Share of Global Online Luxury Market: 66.2% Share of Global Online Luxury Market: 16.7% Share of Global Online Luxury Market: 11.2% LATIN AMERICA # of Companies: 6 2014 Web Sales: $96,793,239 TOTAL ONLINE LUXURY MARKET Share of Global Online Luxury Market: 0.8% # of Companies: 74 2014 Web Sales: $11,477,130,981 Source: Top500Guide.com Share of Global Online Luxury Market: 100.0% ASIA # of Companies: 5 2014 Web Sales: $591,900,169 Share of Global Online Luxury Market: 5.2% Europe, where most luxury e-retailers are based. While it does not exceed the average growth rate of 28.5% achieved by all 3,000 e-retailers in the Top500Guide.com database, that global average is hugely inflated by a handful of large e-retailers in China and elsewhere in Asia, which sell lowerpriced items and which last year achieved growth rates in the triple or high double digits. A much more meaningful measure of how luxury web merchants are growing compared to the rest of the e-commerce field is found in an analysis of median growth rates. Last year, the 74 luxury websites studied achieved a remarkable median growth rate of 14.6%, with half of those sites exceeding that number and half falling short of it. That exceeds the median growth rates of the 3,000 largest web merchants on the planet, not 9 ©Copyright 2015, 2016 Internet Retailer® & Vertical Web Media LLC. All rights reserved. Special Report: Luxury on the Web China & Latin America Grow Luxury E-Commerce Faster 32.7% 17.5% 19.4% 2014 Cumulative Web Sales Growth 19.4% 18.9% to mention the 1000 largest e-retailers in the U.S. and 500 largest in Europe, which recorded median growth rates in 2014 of 11.6% and 9.5% respectively. Regions where luxury e-retailing thrives This astonishing growth in 8.8% the sales of luxury products online is anything but even around the globe. To Europe North China Asia Latin Total paraphrase Willie Sutton, # of Cos. 6 America # of Cos. 6 (excl. China) America Online # of Cos. 51 # of Cos. 5 # of Cos. 6 Luxury the infamous bank robber of Market # of Cos. 74 Source: Top500Guide.com the 1930’s, luxury websites sell the lion’s share of their products to consumers in North America, because that’s where the big money is. Fully 51 of the 74 luxury sites identified by Internet Retailer are American-based, and they account for about two-thirds of global online sales of luxury merchandise. Europe and China follow, but by quite a distance, accounting for 16.7% and 11.2% respectively of the worldwide sales of the luxury e-retailers studied. Now, however, the hegemony that American web merchants have in the luxury market is being challenged. Luxury web merchants in Europe, China and even Latin America grew faster in 2014 than their counterparts in America. Of all of America’s rivals for the hearts, minds and clicks of well-heeled consumers, Chinese e-retailers present the most formidable challenge. Last year, the six Chinese online luxury merchants in the study grew at a combined 32.7%, nearly double the growth rate of the Americans. And given the fact that China is the world’s largest and fastest growing e-commerce market, China’s share of the online luxury market is certain to rise dramatically above the current 11%. This is particularly true because of the Chinese government’s plan to shift more of the country’s GDP to consumer spending and because Chinese consumers are infatuated with Western luxury products and brands. G 10 ©Copyright 2015, 2016 Internet Retailer® & Vertical Web Media LLC. All rights reserved. “I knew we needed to put ourselves in a position where data and analytics would drive our decision-making.” Adam Karp CMO, 1stdibs Online luxury marketplace 1stdibs is pushing the limits of digital by using online data to inform business decisions, and to understand and accommodate a growing clientele. As a result, 1stdibs has created a bridge between a sophisticated old-world industry and a cutting-edge ecommerce-based marketplace. READ THE CASE STUDY © 2015 Cardinal Path, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Proprietary and Confidential. | cardinalpath.com SECTION Special Report: Luxury on the Web 2 Who are the luxury leaders online? The largest online luxury players dominate the market, as they operate well-established, recognized brand names that wealthy consumers admire. Smaller and younger e-retailers, however, are putting up an aggressive fight. T o quickly grasp the competitive dynamic of the global online luxury retailing market, you need look no further than the ranking of the 10 largest competitors in the field and compare that list to the 10 fastest growing competitors in online luxury. The most striking thing about that comparison is that not a single competitor—not one—appears on both lists. And the leader is…Neiman Marcus Does that suggest that the largest luxury e-retailers are more established, have well recognized brand names and got a relatively early start in online retailing to leverage those brands? The answer is yes. In fact, the world’s leading online luxury e-retailer is Neiman Marcus, the Dallas-based department store chain that was one of the first luxury retailers to go online, launching its site in 1999. Last year, the Neiman Marcus web business, which also includes its wholly-owned e-commerce site BergdorfGoodman. The World’s Top 10 Luxury Web Sites Retailer URL Home Market Neiman Marcus Richemont SA Ralph Lauren Media Gilt Groupe Estee Lauder Coach Inc. LVMH (LouisVuitton) RueLaLa.com Blue Nile Inc. Kela.cn NeimanMarcus.com Net-a-Porter.com RalphLauren.com Gilt.com EsteeLauder.com Coach.com LouisVuitton.fr RueLaLa.com BlueNile.com Kela.cn North America Europe North America North America North America North America Europe North America North America China Rank at Home Merchant Type 43 31 59 68 73 82 56 84 85 35 Retail Chain Web Only Brand Manufacturer Web Only Brand Manufacturer Brand Manufacturer Brand Manufacturer Web Only Web Only Retail Chain Category Apparel/Accessories Apparel/Accessories Apparel/Accessories Apparel/Accessories Health & Beauty Apparel/Accessories Apparel/Accessories Apparel/Accessories Jewelry Jewelry 1. Internet Retailer estimate. 2014 web sales Growth $1,148,500,000 1 $844,404,600 1 $780,000,000 1 $670,000,000 1 $603,750,000 1 $500,000,000 $481,557,000 1 $480,000,000 1 $473,516,000 $350,000,000 1 11.5% 25.7% 26.2% 11.7% 15.0% 24.5% 15.0% 9.1% 5.2% 5.9% Source: Top500Guide.com 12 ©Copyright 2015, 2016 Internet Retailer® & Vertical Web Media LLC. All rights reserved. THE WORLD’S LARGEST ECOMMERCE MARKET IS YOUR NEXT GROWTH OPPORTUNITY. IT ALL STARTS WITH PAYMENTS. 5 BILLION DEBIT & CREDIT CARDS IN CIRCULATION 350 MILLION ACTIVE ACCOUNTS 400 MILLION CARD CONNECTED ACCOUNTS ONE INTEGRATION FOR CHINA’S PREFERRED PAYMENT METHODS Chinese shoppers will spend $670Bn online in 2015, making up 40% of Global eCommerce Only 1% of total transactions are done with an international card (Visa, MC, Amex, Discover) Plug in NihaoPay and allow China’s millions of eCommerce shoppers to pay you with ease. FOR MERCHANTS 1 (650) 446-8888 FOR RESELLERS [email protected] WWW.NIHAOPAY.COM [email protected] Special Report: Luxury on the Web 10 Fastest Growing Luxury Web Sites Retailer URL Home Market Gallerist Ritani LLC Real Real Inc. Secoo.com Signet Jewelers Rent the Runway Fifth Avenue Bob’s Watches Shangpin.com Yoogi’s Closet Gallerist.com.br Ritani.com TheRealReal.com Secoo.com Kay.com RentTheRunway.com 5Lux.com BobsWatches.com Shangpin.com YoogisCloset.com Latin America North America North America China North America North America China North America China North America Rank at Home Merchant Type 239 367 239 155 125 282 70 611 43 645 Web Only Brand Manufacturer Web Only Retail Chain Retail Chain Web Only Web Only Web Only Web Only Web Only Category Apparel/Accessories Jewelry Apparel/Accessories Apparel/Accessories Jewelry Apparel/Accessories Apparel/Accessories Jewelry Apparel/Accessories Apparel/Accessories 1. Internet Retailer estimate. 2014 web sales Growth $7,022,075 1 $50,000,000 $105,100,000 1 $75,000,000 1 $275,000,000 1 $80,100,000 1 $228,626,002 1 $17,000,000 $298,780,991 1 $15,661,675 197.6% 117.4% 91.1% 87.3% 67.6% 66.9% 59.3% 53.1% 50.0% 49.7% Source: Top500Guide.com com, generated $1.15 billion in sales, 36% more than the next largest competitor on the list, Net-a-Porter.com, a European-based web-only merchant of luxury fashions. Accounting for a remarkable 10% of the combined worldwide sales of the 74 luxury web sites in the study, Neiman Marcus might well be considered the Amazon of luxury e-retailing. Before the web, it was perhaps better known for its iconic catalog than for its stores, and at the dawn of the e-retailing era, Neiman embarked on a brilliant strategy of leveraging its brand and catalog online. Today, its web site boasts a 5-year CAGR of 13.9%, a conversion rate of 3.14% (well above average for the luxury market) and an average ticket of $410. Further, it is America’s 43rd largest e-retailer. While it lacks Neiman’s brand recognition, the web-only Net-a-Porter.com is also a well-established luxury merchant with a retail web business that dates back to 2000. And it has global ambitions. Earlier this year, Richemont SA, Net-a-Porter’s majority owner, purchased another high fashion pure play, American-based Yoox.com, which ranks 24th on the e-luxury list and 211th in the Top 500 Guide ranking of leading American e-retailers. The merger of the two will help Net-a-Porter close much of the sales gap with NeimanMarcus.com. The other e-retailers on the top 10 luxury list share many of the same attributes of Neiman and Net-a-Porter—seasoned web operations that own or market well-established brands, such as Ralph Lauren, Coach, Louis Vuitton and Estee Lauder. Each one ranks among the top 100 e-retail sites in their home markets. As a group, they fairly represent the three types of organizations that control the e-retailing business—web-only retailers, retail chains and consumer brand manufacturers. All but three (Gilt.com, RueLaLa. 14 ©Copyright 2015, 2016 Internet Retailer® & Vertical Web Media LLC. All rights reserved. Special Report: Luxury on the Web com and Kela.cn) have been online for at least 15 years. But their most distinguishing characteristic is their impressive share of the online luxury market. Together, these top 10 luxury e-retailers account for a commanding 55% of total sales of the world’s 74 leading luxury web sites. Aggressive e-retailers challenge a top-heavy market While the top 10 luxury web merchants control more than half of the market now, that may not be the case in the next few years. That’s because as a group they are growing at only 15.4%, well below the average 18.9% growth of all luxury e-retailers surveyed. By comparison, the 10 fastestgrowing e-retailers on our luxury list grew last year by an average of 65%, increasing their combined share of the global e-luxury business from 7% to 10% in just one year. Growth is not the only thing that differentiates the top growers from the top sellers. The fastest growing web sites in the luxury market are relative upstarts in e-retailing. Brazilian luxury fashion merchant Gallerist.com, the world’s fastest growing luxury e-retailer, was launched only in 2011. Top 3 Luxury Web Sites by Region Retailer URL Rank at Home Merchant Type Category 2014 web sales1 Growth North America Neiman Marcus NeimanMarcus.com 43 Retail Chain Apparel/Accessories $1,148,500,000 11.5% Ralph Lauren Media RalphLauren.com 59 Brand Manufacturer Apparel/Accessories $780,000,000 26.2% Gilt Groupe Gilt.com 68 Web Only Apparel/Accessories $670,000,000 11.7% Europe Richemont SA Net-a-Porter.com 31 Web Only Apparel/Accessories $844,404,600 25.7% LVMH (LouisVuitton) LouisVuitton.fr 56 Brand Manufacturer Apparel/Accessories $481,557,000 15.0% Farfetch Farfetch.com 93 Web Only Apparel/Accessories $290,367,672 12.7% Kela.cn Kela.cn 35 Retail Chain Jewelry $350,000,000 5.9% Zbird.com Zbird.com 37 Web Only Jewelry $323,000,000 30.0% Shangpin.com Shangpin.com 43 Web Only Apparel/Accessories $298,780,991 50.0% China Asia Enigmo Co. Ltd. Buyma.com 75 Web Only Apparel/Accessories $235,346,546 16.9% L Brands LaSenza.com 115 Retail Chain Apparel/Accessories $130,521,417 0.7% Beams Co. Ltd. Beams.co.jp 154 Retail Chain Apparel/Accessories $90,000,000 1.0% 64 Retail Chain Apparel/Accessories $39,294,607 10.8% Latin America Daslu Loja.daslu.com.br 21Diamonds 21Diamonds.com.br 106 Web Only Jewelry $21,750,000 17.6% Medalhão Persa MedalhaoPersa.com.br 140 Web Only Jewelry $14,837,383 17.8% 1. All web sales figures are Internet Retailer estimates. Source: Top500Guide.com 15 ©Copyright 2015, 2016 Internet Retailer® & Vertical Web Media LLC. All rights reserved. Special Report: Luxury on the Web Web-Only Merchants Have Lion's Share of Online Luxury Similarly, Seattle-based Ritani.com, a pure play web merchant specializing in jewelry, was also launched in 2011 and last year became the secondBRAND fastest growing luxury web site by MANUFACTURER increasing its sales 117%. In fact, all 30.5% WEB ONLY but two of the fastest growing luxury 44.0% e-retailers were launched within the last eight years. One of the exceptions is Signet Jewelers, which owns the Zales, Jared, and Kay jewelry web RETAIL CHAIN sites and stores, and which launched 24.4% its first web site in 1998. The outlier CATALOG / is BobsWatches.com, which has been CALL CENTER Source: Top500Guide.com 1.1% selling pre-owned Rolex and other luxury watches online since And They're Growing Faster Than The Rest 1999. Web Only 20.4% Two other distinguishing features of the fastest 15.5% Retail Chain growing luxury e-retailers are their size and their 20.0% Brand Manufacturer origins. While all of the top 10 luxury sites are large 7.4% enough to rank among the Catalog/Call Center Percentages are 2014 top 100 web merchants in Web Sales Growth Source: Top500Guide.com their home markets, only two of the fastest growers can make that claim, and both are based in China, an explosive e-commerce market that produces many anomalies. As for origins, six of the 10 largest luxury e-retailers trace their lineage to the major retail chains or brand manufacturers. The reverse is true for the fastest growers. Seven of the fastest growing luxury web sites come from the ranks of web-only retailing, whose members often grow faster online than retail chains and brand manufacturers simply because web retailing is their sole focus. With the exception of Signet Jewelers, none of the fastest growing competitors in online luxury owns a well-known luxury brand. Yet, given their incredible growth their message to the big brands sitting atop the online luxury market might be this: Don’t rest on your solid gold names because we’re coming after you. 16 ©Copyright 2015, 2016 Internet Retailer® & Vertical Web Media LLC. All rights reserved. Special Report: Luxury on the Web The balance of power in luxury e-retailing is changing The differences between the top online luxury e-retailers and their smaller but faster growing competitors highlight a significant change in the overall e-luxury market. There are no market share studies that go back a decade ago, but given the launch dates of the 74 leading luxury e-retailers, it’s fairly likely that the old line luxury chain retailers and branded manufacturers dominated the online market back then even more than they do today. When exactly this balance of power in online luxury began to change is hard to determine, but it clearly has changed. Today, 44% of all web sales of the 74 global leaders in luxury e-retailing is generated by web-only merchants; that compares to 31% and 24% respectively for luxury brand manufacturers and chain retailers. It’s also likely that the pure-play share of this market will increase in future years, given the fact that the 37 pure play websites included the list of 74 leading online luxury merchants continue to grow faster than their competitors. G 17 ©Copyright 2015, 2016 Internet Retailer® & Vertical Web Media LLC. All rights reserved. Special Report: Luxury on the Web The world’s largest luxury e-commerce players Luxury Rank E-Retailer Home Market Home Rank Merchant Type Category 2014 web sales Growth Average Order 1 NeimanMarcus.com North America 43 Retail Chain Apparel $1,148,500,000 1 11.5% $410 1 2 Net-a-Porter.com Europe 31 Web Only Apparel $844,404,600 25.7% $202 1 3 RalphLauren.com North America 59 Brand Manufacturer Apparel $780,000,000 1 26.2% $195 1 4 Gilt.com North America 68 Web Only Apparel $670,000,000 1 11.7% $360 1 5 EsteeLauder.com North America 73 Brand Manufacturer Beauty Products $603,750,000 1 15.0% $138 1 6 Coach.com North America 82 Brand Manufacturer Accessories $500,000,000 24.5% $230 1 7 LouisVuitton.fr Europe 56 Brand Manufacturer Accessories $481,557,000 1 15.0% $650 1 8 RueLaLa.com North America 84 Web Only Apparel $480,000,000 1 9.1% $150 1 9 BlueNile.com North America 85 Web Only Jewelry $473,516,000 5.2% $1,669 1 10 Kela.cn China 35 Retail Chain Jewelry $350,000,000 1 5.9% $500 1 11 Zbird.com China 37 Web Only Jewelry $323,000,000 1 30.0% $540 12 Shangpin.com China 43 Web Only Apparel $298,780,991 1 50.0% $330 1 13 FarFetch.com Europe 93 Web Only Apparel $290,367,672 1 12.7% $400 1 14 Signet Jewelers2 North America 125 Retail Chain Jewelry $275,000,000 1 67.6% $200 1 15 Tiffany.com North America 131 Brand Manufacturer Jewelry $256,000,000 1 5.8% $350 1 16 Buyma.com Asia Apparel $235,346,546 1 16.9% $360 1 17 ToryBurch.com North America Apparel $230,000,000 18 5Lux.com China 19 BrooksBrothers.com North America 20 KateSpade.com 21 75 Web Only 139 Brand Manufacturer 34.5% $246 Apparel $228,626,002 1 59.3% $490 1 170 Retail Chain Apparel $187,084,800 1 16.0% $155 1 North America 178 Brand Manufacturer Apparel $172,501,150 1 15.0% $400 1 Barneys.com North America 183 Retail Chain Apparel $165,910,680 1 20.0% $450 1 22 Gucci.com Europe 145 Retail Chain Accessories $161,489,580 1 13.2% $400 1 23 Jomashop.com North America 203 Web Only Jewelry $140,664,000 34.3% $475 24 Yoox.com North America 211 Web Only Apparel $130,909,663 25 LaSenza.com Asia 115 Retail Chain 26 Ross-Simons.com North America 27 Bluefly.com 28 70 Web Only 12.1% $240 Apparel $130,521,417 1 0.7% $436 1 228 Retail Chain Jewelry $112,933,137 1 6.0% $250 1 North America 229 Web Only Apparel $111,145,361 1 10.0% $300 1 TheRealReal.com North America 239 Web Only Apparel $105,100,000 1 91.1% $130 1 29 JamesAllen.com North America 252 Web Only Jewelry $96,825,600 1 8.0% $4,300 1 30 Burberry.com Europe 210 Brand Manufacturer Apparel $92,706,728 1 25.9% $448 1 31 Beams.co.jp Asia 154 Retail Chain Apparel $90,000,000 1 1.0% $300 1 32 Ashford.com North America 263 Web Only Jewelry $89,442,906 25.3% $326 33 GoldwinWebStore.jp Asia 161 Web Only Apparel $84,552,205 1 10.9% $404 1 34 RentTheRunway.com North America 282 Web Only Apparel $80,100,000 1 66.9% $140 1 35 Secoo.com China 155 Retail Chain Apparel $75,000,000 1 87.3% $200 1 36 Store-US.HugoBoss.com North America 304 Brand Manufacturer Apparel $72,225,000 1 7.0% $100 1 37 LorealParisUSA.com North America 310 Brand Manufacturer Beauty Products $69,900,000 1 12.1% $70 1 1. Internet Retailer estimate. 2. Signet owns multiple jewelry web sites, including Kay.com, Jared.com and Zales.com. 3. DVF.com is the URL for fashion designer Diane Von Furstenberg. 4. Helzberg.com is the web site of Herzberg Diamonds. Source: Top500Guide.com 18 ©Copyright 2015, 2016 Internet Retailer® & Vertical Web Media LLC. All rights reserved. (continued on next page) Special Report: Luxury on the Web The world’s largest luxury e-commerce players (cont’d) Luxury Rank E-Retailer Home Market Home Rank Merchant Type Category 2014 web sales Growth Average Order 38 KimonoIchiba.com Asia 233 Catalog/Call Center Apparel $51,480,000 1 8.2% $300 1 39 ArmaniExchange.com North America 357 Brand Manufacturer Apparel $51,477,000 1 6.2% $220 1 40 Ritani.com North America 367 Brand Manufacturer Jewelry $50,000,000 41 Ice.com North America 374 Web Only Jewelry $48,100,000 42 Lafayette148NY.com North America 378 Catalog/Call Center Apparel $47,924,000 43 SecretSales.com Europe 316 Web Only Apparel 44 Tumi.com North America 402 Brand Manufacturer 45 DiamondNexus.com North America 46 EileenFisher.com North America 47 Loja.daslu.com.br Latin America 48 Dexclusive.com North America 49 BlissWorld.com 50 117.4% $5,500 6.9% $300 1 8.2% $630 $42,256,627 1 14.3% $252 1 Accessories $41,600,000 1 27.6% $290 414 Web Only Jewelry $39,600,000 1 2.0% $565 1 415 Brand Manufacturer Apparel $39,500,000 11.0% $354 Apparel $39,294,607 10.8% $300 1 444 Web Only Jewelry $34,472,282 North America 450 Retail Chain PeruvianConnection.com North America 51 DVF.com3 52 64 Retail Chain 1 1 23.2% $274 Beauty Products $33,117,900 1 10.0% $275 1 453 Catalog/Call Center Apparel $32,443,229 1 5.0% $312 1 North America 486 Brand Manufacturer Apparel $28,350,000 1 32.6% $250 1 Gemvara.com North America 487 Web Only Jewelry $28,245,725 1 20.0% $1,000 1 53 21Diamonds.com.br Latin America 106 Web Only Jewelry $21,750,000 1 17.6% $1,450 1 54 BobsWatches.com North America 611 Web Only Jewelry $17,000,000 1 53.1% $5,650 1 55 Adiamor.com North America 636 Web Only Jewelry $16,000,000 2.7% $1,250 1 56 YoogisCloset.com North America 645 Web Only Accessories $15,661,675 57 Whiteflash.com North America 664 Web Only 58 MedalhaoPersa.com.br Latin America 59 Ziamond.com 60 1 49.7% $900 Jewelry $14,900,000 1 4.6% $5,000 1 140 Web Only Jewelry $14,837,383 1 17.8% $250 1 North America 674 Web Only Jewelry $14,264,000 1 7.9% $750 1 usa.Hermes.com North America 707 Brand Manufacturer Accessories $12,800,000 1 19.6% $220 1 61 Helzberg.com North America 745 Retail Chain Jewelry $11,350,000 16.8% $250 1 62 BrianGavinDiamonds.com North America 757 Web Only Jewelry $10,784,000 0.6% $3,000 1 63 CasadasAlianças.com.br Latin America 184 Retail Chain Jewelry $10,697,129 1 12.6% $350 1 64 WorldJewels.com North America 766 Web Only Jewelry $10,450,000 1 3.3% $1,800 1 65 Fashionphile.com North America 770 Web Only Accessories $10,200,000 1 17.4% $600 1 66 UGallery.com North America 832 Web Only Artwork $8,411,508 1 30.0% 67 Angara.com North America 855 Web Only Jewelry $7,726,169 1 5.0% $700 1 68 Gallerist.com.br Latin America 239 Web Only Apparel $7,022,075 1 197.6% $250 1 69 ItsHot.com North America 932 Brand Manufacturer Jewelry $5,441,099 1 6.0% $225 1 70 Allurez.com North America 948 Web Only Jewelry $5,000,000 11.1% 71 Bluemercury.com North America 957 Retail Chain Beauty Products $4,787,211 1 10.0% $75 1 72 Chanel.com Europe 455 Brand Manufacturer Beauty Products $4,687,500 1 25.0% $400 1 73 PoshMommyJewelry.com North America 967 Brand Manufacturer Jewelry $4,446,779 1 5.0% $250 1 74 E-Closet.com.br Latin America 341 Web Only Apparel $3,192,045 1 20.5% $300 1 4 1 $1,050 $1,800 1. Internet Retailer estimate. 2. Signet owns multiple jewelry web sites, including Kay.com, Jared.com and Zales.com. 3. DVF.com is the URL for fashion designer Diane Von Furstenberg. 4. Helzberg.com is the web site of Herzberg Diamonds. Source: Top500Guide.com 19 ©Copyright 2015, 2016 Internet Retailer® & Vertical Web Media LLC. All rights reserved. SECTION Special Report: Luxury on the Web 3 Which luxury products sell best online? Luxury e-retailing is dominated first and foremost by designer apparel merchants, though high-end jewelry and accessories are also frequently purchased on the web. T o get an idea of how far e-commerce has progressed in just the last several years, consider this: The best-selling and fastest-growing segment of the web-based luxury market is designer apparel. Not long ago, it was thought that apparel was not a good market for e-commerce, because, some argued, customers wanted to touch the fabric, see its colors first-hand, and try on the garment before buying it. That notion was dismissed several years ago. Last year, 12.2% of total web sales for the 1,000 largest e-retailers in North American was generated by websites specializing in apparel, while dozens of other sites without that focus sold some apparel online as well. And when it comes to selling luxury products online, apparel takes center stage. Designer apparel dominates the e-luxury market Designer Apparel Tops Luxury Sales Online Growth Rate Designer Apparel 19.7% Luxury Accessories 19.3% Jewelry 17.6% Cosmetics 14.5% 10.8% 21.6 61.4% 6.2% Source: Top500Guide.com For this chart only, Artwork is included in Accessories. It account for 0.1% of total luxury web sales. Share of Total A breakdown of the sales of the world’s leading 74 luxury sites by type of merchandise sold shows that high-priced designer apparel commands a market share that is five times apparel’s share of the total e-commerce market. That’s not a typo; it’s a fact. Fully 61% of all sales on 20 ©Copyright 2015, 2016 Internet Retailer® & Vertical Web Media LLC. All rights reserved. Special Report: Luxury on the Web the world’s 74 leading luxury websites is generated by the 33 luxury web merchants that sell designer apparel as their primary merchandise offering. With an average order of $303—or 43% higher than the average ticket of all apparel e-retailers—the apparel websites on the list of 74 leading luxury e-commerce businesses defy the conventional wisdom about the merchandise best suited for e-retailing. Not only do they succeed on the web; they dominate the online luxury business, both in terms of market share and in terms of growth. The apparel businesses on the list of leading luxury websites grew 19.7% last year, more than any other principal luxury merchandise category. And despite their much higher average ticket, the 33 luxury apparel websites achieve an impressive conversion rate of 2.54%, nearly as high as the 2.85% average conversion rate of the 137 apparel merchants ranked among America’s Top 500 e-retailers. In Luxury Sites Achieve Huge Average Tickets short, luxury apparel is one of the best product segments that $732 Average Ticket e-retailing offers. $350 Median Ticket This list of luxury apparel sites includes some well-known $212 designer brands, including Ralph Lauren, Tory Burch, Hugo $125 Boss, Armani, Eileen Fisher and Diane Von Furstenberg. And 74 Luxury Web Sites Top 500 American Web Sites it includes such well-known Source: Top500Guide.com apparel retail chains as Barneys, Burberry, Brooks Brothers and Neiman Marcus. Neiman Marcus, the world’s leading luxury merchant on the web, also leads the apparel segment of online luxury, controlling a remarkable 16% share of this prized segment of luxury e-retailing. Jewelry—The most competitive segment of e-luxury Jewelry, the second largest merchandise segment of the online luxury market, accounts for 21.6% of all web sales of the world’s top 74 e-luxury websites. It has almost as many competitors (28) as the luxury apparel segment, but they pursue a market with one-third as much revenue as luxury apparel. Not surprisingly, this segment of the online luxury market produces the highest average ticket ($1,392) and the lowest conversion rate (1.3%) of all major merchandise segments. After declining in 2013, all online sales of jewelry came back strong last year. The 28 larger and biggerticket jewelry websites included in the list of leading global luxury e-retailers 21 ©Copyright 2015, 2016 Internet Retailer® & Vertical Web Media LLC. All rights reserved. Special Report: Luxury on the Web had a comeback as well, growing their combined sales by 17.6%. The leader in the online jewelry category is Blue Nile, one of the oldest pureplay web merchants in the category and the perennial leader of the webbased jewelry market. With $474 million in online sales last year, Blue Nile towers over the next two largest competitors in web-based jewelry sales, both of which are based in China. They include second-ranked Kela.cn, a retail chain with $330 million in online jewelry sales; and third-ranked Zbird. com, a web-only jeweler with $323 million in sales. Signet Jewelers, which operates the largest jewelry chains in North America and the United Kingdom, Average Conversion was the fastest growing e-retailer 3.32% Median Conversion in the jewelry business in 2014, growing its web sales by 68% 1.97% 2.48% last year alone. But most of that growth came from Signet’s 2014 1.80% acquisition of Zales, a chain that generated $109 million online Top 500 American Web Sites 74 Luxury Web Sites in 2013, enough to become the Source: Top500Guide.com 210th largest e-retailer in the U.S. The other major chain in jewelry e-retailing is Tiffany, which ranked fourth among jewelers on the top luxury e-retailing list with web sales of $256 million last year. Luxury Sites Have Much Lower Conversion Rates Despite the fact that three of the top five jewelry websites on the global luxury list are owned by retail chains, web-only merchants last year accounted for nearly 59% of the sales generated by the 28 jewelers on the luxury list. Furthermore, while the eight retail chains and brand manufacturers ranked among the world’s largest online jewelers boast more recognizable brand names, they have an average ticket of just $297, less than one-quarter of the average ticket for all 28 jewelers on the list. By comparison, the 20 web-only jewelers on the luxury e-retailer list achieved a stunning average ticket of $1,830, belying the notion that name brands automatically yield higher average orders. One of those pure-play luxury jewelers holds the most unassuming URL of all global leaders in luxury, BobsWatches.com. That e-retailer boasts the highest average ticket of all luxury merchants—$5,650. It achieves that top perch by selling pre-owned Rolex and other high-end watch brands on a website that’s been in operation since 1999. While BobsWatches.com ranks 22 ©Copyright 2015, 2016 Internet Retailer® & Vertical Web Media LLC. All rights reserved. Special Report: Luxury on the Web Top Luxury E-Retailers by Type of Merchandise Product Segment Segment Leader 2014 Web Sales 2014 Growth 2014 Share of Segment Apparel Neiman Marcus $1,148,500,000 1 11.5% 16.3% Luxury Accessories Coach Inc. $500,000,000 24.5% 40.9% Beauty & Health Estee Lauder $603,750,000 1 15.0% 84.3% Jewelry Blue Nile Inc. $473,516,000 Artwork UGallery $8,411,508 1 15.0% 19.1% 30.0% 100.0% 1. Internet Retailer estimate Source: Top500Guide.com only 16th among the world’s top jewelry websites, it is clearly on a path to improve that position. As recently as 2010, Bob’s Watches was a tiny e-retailing business with annual sales of just $375,000. Then it launched its unique “Rolex Exchange,” which is modeled after the New York Stock Exchange and allows sellers and buyers to offer and bid for pre-owned Rolex time pieces. Since that launch, Bob’s Watches has grown dramatically. Last year alone, the site increased sales by 53% to $17 million. Accessories—The luxury brands they carry Of all the luxury brands owned by the world’s largest luxury e-retailers, the accessories segment of the market has the highest concentration of brands most luxury shoppers know. Only seven of the 74 top-ranked luxury e-retailers are categorized as merchants of accessory items, but five of those own brands that are among the best known names in luxury retailing— Louis Vuitton, Gucci, Hermes, Coach and Tumi. All told, accessories account for nearly 11% of total sales of the top 74 online luxury retailers included in this study, and the seven competitors in the segment grew at the healthy clip of 19.3% last year. However, the two leading luxury brands of handbags—Coach and Louis Vuitton—dominate this segment of the online luxury market, accounting for 80% of its total sales. Last year, these two changed positions as Coach took the top spot from Louis Vuitton by out-growing it 24.5% to 15%. Still, less than $20 million in online revenue separate the two, and none of the other five competitors in the group seem ready to challenge these leaders anytime soon. Gucci.com, which ranks third in the accessories segment, generated revenue of $161 million online, or $320 million less than second-ranked Louis Vuitton. Estee Lauder owns the web market for luxury beauty products The smallest segment of the global online luxury market consists of highend fragrances and other beauty products. Together, the five beauty product websites included among the global leaders in luxury accounted for just 6% of total sales generated last year by the world’s top 74 luxury 23 ©Copyright 2015, 2016 Internet Retailer® & Vertical Web Media LLC. All rights reserved. Special Report: Luxury on the Web e-retailers. They grew last year at just 14%, the slowest growth rate for any merchandise category in the luxury market. Their average ticket of $192 is also the lowest of any other luxury product category, since fragrances and make-up products typically are lower in price than the other types of merchandise included in luxury. Nonetheless, these e-retailers are included in this online luxury report largely on the strength of their well-known luxury brands, such as Chanel, L’Oreal and Estee Lauder, and because their average tickets are nearly double the average order of all 52 e-retailers included in the beauty merchandise category of the America’s 1,000 largest web merchants. The only competitor that operates a major website in this segment of the global luxury e-retailing list is Estee Lauder, the $11 billion producer of highend cosmetics and other beauty products. Estee Lauder launched its first e-commerce website 18 years ago, and it now operates 14 websites around the world, including those for its other major brands, such as Clinique, Bobby Brown, and Aveda. While these websites last year generated $604 million of online sales—5.5% of the company’s total sales—the web is Estee Lauder’s fastest growing sales channel. Last year, sales from that channel grew by 15%, double the growth rate for the company as a whole. That fact is not lost of the company’s management team, which is expanding its web business with a bigger investment in mobile commerce and global e-retailing. Given Estee Lauder’s long-term success in the online cosmetics business, it’s a wonder the other four online competitors in this segment haven’t tried to emulate it. The fact that they haven’t come close to doing so is evidenced by Estee Launder’s astonishing 84% share of total sales of all five competitors in this segment of the luxury market. G 24 ©Copyright 2015, 2016 Internet Retailer® & Vertical Web Media LLC. All rights reserved. SECTION Special Report: Luxury on the Web 4 Who buys luxury merchandise online? The online luxury market is extremely attractive to wealthy women, but many young professionals are showing they have enough disposable income to purchase high-end products on the web. S ince designer apparel, jewelry and luxury accessories account for well over 90% of the sales of leading luxury e-retailers, it would follow that the customers who shop these sites most often are women. And, in fact, women account for 55% of shoppers on luxury websites, which is higher than the female share of sales for America’s 500 largest web sites, where buyers are evenly divided between women and men. Women shoppers account for only 55% of luxury e-retail shopping What is surprising is that women make up “only” 55% of the sales of the world’s top luxury web sites, considering the mostly female-oriented product lines of these web businesses and the preponderance of female models that adorn most luxury websites. Even Online Luxury: Where Women Rule a cursory examination Online Shopper of the products sold Demographics and the merchandising methods used by luxury websites might lead most Women Men Men Women observers to conclude 55.06% 44.94% 49.65% 50.17% that women easily account for two-thirds or more of the traffic and transactions of online Top 500 U.S. Web Sites Luxury Web Site Shoppers luxury retailers. Source: Top500Guide.com Yet, women make up 25 ©Copyright 2015, 2016 Internet Retailer® & Vertical Web Media LLC. All rights reserved. Special Report: Luxury on the Web 56% of the shoppers at leading designer apparel sites, 55% of accessory sites, 60% of beauty product web sites and 53% of jewelry sites. Why aren’t these percentages even higher given the fact that the products on luxury web sites are overwhelmingly aimed at women? One likely answer is that a fair percentage of luxury sales online is purchased as gifts by men for women, while the reverse happens relatively infrequently. It is quite likely that many men prefer to shop online for those luxury gifts rather than buying them in high-fashion shops that seem foreign to them and are populated mostly by female shoppers. In addition, a growing number of products designed for men Online Luxury Market Is Surprisingly Youthful now appear on the product pages of luxury Online Shopper Demographics sites. Many e-retailers categorized as jewelers, for example, are selling high-priced watches for 44 or Younger 45 & Older 44 or Younger 45 & Older men, not just diamond 52.20% 47.80% 51.69% 48.38% rings for women. Luxury web sites specializing in designer handbags also carry high-priced Top 500 U.S. Web Sites Luxury Web Site Shoppers briefcases, suitcases and wallets that are aimed at Source: Top500Guide.com male shoppers. The same is true for luxury apparel, which was once the exclusive province of female shoppers. Today, most web sites specializing in designer apparel display a growing component of men’s fashions as well. Because the male audience for luxury web sites is surprisingly high, it behooves managers of luxury e-retail businesses to insure that their web marketing, merchandising and content is not so tightly focused on women that they fail to capitalize on the significant opportunities they have in pursuing male shoppers. Online luxury is surprisingly youthful If the relatively high male make-up of the online luxury shopping market is mildly surprising, the age demographic of shoppers on the world’s largest luxury websites is wildly surprising. Given the very high average tickets that luxury merchants command online, one might expect that their shopper 26 ©Copyright 2015, 2016 Internet Retailer® & Vertical Web Media LLC. All rights reserved. Special Report: Luxury on the Web Online Luxury Market Is Surprisingly Youthful Online Shopper Demographics 44 or Younger 45 & Older 52.20% 47.80% demographic would be skewed to an older clientele that has the type of disposable income required to shop luxury brands. 44 or Younger 45 & Older 51.69% 48.38% That expectation, however, is not the reality. Slightly more than 52% of shoppers on the world’s 74 leading luxury Top 500 U.S. Web Sites Luxury Web Site Shoppers web sites are 44 years of Source: Top500Guide.com age and younger. That youthful orientation contrasts sharply with the age breakdown of shoppers at America’s 500 largest e-retailers, which get 48.4% of their business from shoppers who are 44 and under. Furthermore, the age breakdown of shoppers on luxury websites is consistent across most types of merchandise. The percentage of shoppers in the 44 and under age group is 53% at luxury web sites specializing in designer apparel, 54% at websites selling luxury accessories, and 53% at jewelry websites. The one exception to the youthful luxury shopper rule are the five luxury e-retailers that specialize in beauty products. For those sites, the 44 and under age group contributes just 47.2% of online sales. No surprise—The wealthy buy luxury online There’s only one demographic of luxury web shoppers that fits the stereotype—wealth. Fully 53% of shoppers at the world’s 74 largest luxury web sites have household incomes exceeding $60,000, and 24% boast a family income above $100,000. Compare that to the family incomes of shoppers on America’s 500 largest web sites. There the percentage of web shoppers with family incomes exceeding $60,000 is $48.8%, while the percentage of shoppers with family incomes of more than $100,000 is 21.2%. The message that these demographics convey is that the luxury market is extremely appealing to the aspirations of young professionals. They’re wealthy enough to purchase status symbols such as designer clothes and Louis Vuitton handbags, but they’re a decade away from buying a Mercedes. G 27 ©Copyright 2015, 2016 Internet Retailer® & Vertical Web Media LLC. All rights reserved. SECTION Special Report: Luxury on the Web 5 Marketing luxury online: It’s all about social The world’s top luxury e-retailers are slightly ahead of the e-commerce industry in e-mail marketing and search strategies, but they are light years ahead with social. W hen it comes to marketing, the world’s 74 leading luxury e-retailers are extremely aggressive, easily outperforming the average marketing practices of America’s Top 500 web merchants, who as a group are the world’s biggest and best practitioners of digital retail marketing. That probably should not come as a surprise. These 74 web merchants possess some of the most valuable brand names on the planet, and since they sell products with Leading Luxury Sites in extremely high margins, it’s relatively Paid Search Spending easy for them to justify major marketing 2015 monthly paid investments. They do not fail to leverage Internet Retailer search spending these advantages by relying heavily on Neiman Marcus $672,000 all forms of digital marketing to connect Blue Nile Inc. $592,000 with their base of wealthy and extremely Signet Jewelers (Kay.com) $462,000 loyal buyers and also to recruit new L’Oréal Group $390,000 buyers among youthful shoppers who Tiffany & Co. $374,000 aspire to own luxury branded products. Top 5 Share of Total Luxury SEM Spend 40.3% Luxury Search Spend per Web Sales 0.054% Top 500 Search Spend per Web Sales 0.047% Paid search spending figures provided by ROI Revolution Inc. Source: Top500Guide.com. Luxury brands are well-suited for digital marketing Prior to the advent of e-retailing and digital marketing, companies with high-priced luxury brands invested their marketing dollars by publishing their promotional catalogs, advertising in specialty magazines directed at wealthier consumers and sponsoring events that attract a high percentage of upscale enthusiasts. It was difficult for them to justifying advertising on the primary electronic medium of the day—network television—because they would doubtless be paying for 28 ©Copyright 2015, 2016 Internet Retailer® & Vertical Web Media LLC. All rights reserved. Special Report: Luxury on the Web access to millions of consumers who were never going to be their potential customers. Digital marketing is different, because it can be highly targeted to those consumers who are potential luxury shoppers. And from the beginning Luxury Sites Use Facebook of the digital age, merchants of More Aggressively… luxury products jumped on the digital Top 5 Luxury Sites on Facebook # of FB Likes marketing bandwagon, beginning with L’Oréal Group 19,459,093 its two initial forms—e-mail marketing Burberry Ltd. 18,035,514 and paid search. And while nearly all LVMH (LouisVuitton) 17,677,024 major e-retailers followed suit, luxury Ralph Lauren Media 8,324,375 web merchants as a group take a back Hugo Boss 7,610,118 seat to nobody when it comes to e-mail Top 5 Share of Total FB Likes 60.0% marketing and SEM. Luxury Likes per Total Luxury Web Sales 1.03% Top 500 Likes per Total Web Sales 0.27% ...Connect More Often With Shoppers Via Twitter… Top 5 Luxury Sites Using Twitter # of Followers Burberry Ltd. 3,576,381 Tiffany & Co. 1,186,395 Ralph Lauren Media 1,058,010 DVF.com (Diane Von Furstenberg) 811,001 Kate Spade 779,952 Top 5 Share of Total Luxury Twitter Followers 59.1% Luxury Followers per All Luxury Web Sales 0.11% Top 500 Followers per Total Web Sales 0.03% ...And Get Wider Viewership of YouTube Videos Top 5 Luxury Sites On YouTube # of Views L Brands 201,150,258 Burberry Ltd. 54,999,158 L’Oréal Group 23,419,101 Ralph Lauren Media 13,855,497 Hugo Boss 11,692,645 Top 5 Share of Total YouTube Views 85.8% Luxury YouTube Views per Web Sales 3.10% Top 500 YouTube Views per Web Sales 2.06% Source: Top500Guide.com The 34 leading luxury web merchants included in the Top 500 Guide, Internet Retailer’s annual ranking of America’s largest e-retailers, are top-tier e-mail marketers. In 2013, the most recent year for which comprehensive data is available on retail e-mail marketing, these 34 luxury e-retailers performed a median average of 15 promotional e-mail blasts per month. By comparison, the median average number of monthly e-mail efforts for all 500 top American e-retailers that year was just 10. While no e-mail data is available for American e-retailers ranked below 500 or for any foreign web merchants, this limited comparison is nonetheless significant because America’s 500 largest web merchants are among the most prolific retail e-mailers in the world. When all 74 luxury web merchants included in our ranking of luxury sites are compared to America’s 500 largest merchants on search marketing spending, the luxury merchants have a 29 ©Copyright 2015, 2016 Internet Retailer® & Vertical Web Media LLC. All rights reserved. Special Report: Luxury on the Web slight edge here as well. The world’s top luxury e-retailers last year spent .054% of annual web sales on paid search, compared to .047% for all Top 500 American e-retailers. While the SEM difference between the two groups is small, the 74 luxury merchants come from around the globe, while the Top 500 are all based in North America, which leads the world on paid search marketing. Luxury e-retailers are social media marketing stars If the world’s top luxury e-retailers are slightly ahead of the e-commerce industry in the two oldest forms of digital marketing, they are light years ahead in the newer forms of digital marketing, all of which are based on social networks. As in the case of e-mail and SEM, this study compared the social media marketing efforts of the world’s 74 largest luxury web merchants with that of America’s 500 largest e-retailers, which as a group outspend all other retailers around the globe in social media promotions. Because they have a well-established relationship with a small and fairly homogeneous segment of retail shoppers—those in the top 10% and those aspiring to get there—luxury merchants like to think of their buyers as part of their branded family. That mindset sets their social media marketing priorities, and particularly their heavy reliance on Facebook. The 74 luxury e-retailers in this study have on average 1.03 Facebook likes per every $100 of online sales, nearly four times FB likes-to-sales ratio of America’s Top 500 e-retailers. What’s the message that these luxury merchants seem to be telling other online retailers: One reason for the above average growth of online luxury may be attributable to their mastery of Facebook as a marketing and branding tool. The same might also be said of the luxury group’s use of Twitter. The total number of Twitter followers for all 74 luxury web merchants in our study is equal to 0.11% of their combined annual sales. By comparison, the Twitter follower-to-sales ratio for America’s 500 largest web merchants was 0.03%, or less than one-third the relative Twitter following of the online luxury retailers. The top luxury merchants also have a higher average viewership of their You Tube videos than do the American merchants ranked in the Top 500 Guide. This is perhaps the most surprising outcome of the social marketing analysis of the leading luxury web sites, if only because America’s 500 largest e-retailers are leading the worldwide trend of posting marketing videos on You Tube. Despite that, the 74 leading luxury e-retailers boast a YouTube 30 ©Copyright 2015, 2016 Internet Retailer® & Vertical Web Media LLC. All rights reserved. Special Report: Luxury on the Web viewer-to-sales ratio of 3.1%, fully 50% higher than the ratio maintained by the Top 500 American e-retailers. Does superior social media marketing equal faster growth? Documenting the luxury e-retailers’ superiority in the use of social networks for marketing purposes is a lot easier than explaining it. An argument can be made that this outcome is the result of the affinity luxury buyers have to luxury brands, which translates into a greater connection with those brands via social networks. Others might argue that luxury merchants are by definition niche marketers who naturally rely more on social media marketing because mass media marketing is a less efficient use of their marketing budgets. Still, the fact remains that many e-retailers outside the luxury segment possess powerful brands as well and could better connect with the followers of those brands if they applied the same level of social media marketing that the luxury brands employ. Similarly, most e-retailers ranked in the American Top 500 are every bit as oriented to niche markets as their counterparts in luxury retailing, and therefore are every bit as likely to benefit from the social network exposure that the luxury brands achieve. There is but one caveat with a blanket conclusion that social media is the primary driving force behind the above-average sales growth of the luxury web sites. It is that only two of nine luxury web merchants that are ranked among the top five luxury users of Facebook, Twitter and You Tube are growing at rates exceeding the average growth of all e-retailers. Those two are Ralph Lauren Media, which ranks among the top five in all three social media categories and grew last year by 26%; and DVF.com (Diane Von Furstenberg), which ranks among the top five luxury brands on Twitter and which grew last year by 33%. While this does not diminish the overall positive impact that social media marketing has on all luxury e-retailers, it does suggest that there is a limit to the benefit websites get from social media exposure. G 31 ©Copyright 2015, 2016 Internet Retailer® & Vertical Web Media LLC. All rights reserved. Top500Guide.com SORT. CUSTOMIZE. RANK. AND ANALYZE. ALL INTERNET RETAILER RESEARCH DATA IN AN ONLINE DATABASE FORMAT 7,500 4,000 Online Databases Available: Top 500 Second 500 Europe 500 Asia 500 China 500 Latam 500 Mobile 500 Social 500 Top500Guide.com e-commerce executives indexed e-retailers profiled 600,000 financial, operating performance and marketing facts 8 Databases 900+ vendors profiled