\\3aseAop~M l<yHracaV1"

TOO \\ UeHTP no oueHI<e ~ HenAaTe>l<aM
\\ 3aseAop~M l<yHracaV1"
OT4ET N2178/2
06 OUEHKE TPAHCnOPTHOrO CPE.QCTBA
HaHMeHoBaHHe 06beKTa ou,eHKH:
3aKa3~HK/Co6CTBeHHHK:
litcnonHHTenb:
'-lneHCTBO B nanaTe OU,eHW.HKOB:
Tponnerli6yc nacca>KiilpCKiilrli «Ka3axcraH » 3TC-398,
111AeHTiii4>111KaU,IiiOHHblrA HOMep NQ 00044
f"Y «0TAe11 4>111HaHCOB ropOAa nerponaB/lOBCKa»
PK, CKO, r. nerponaB/lOBCK, yn. KOHCTIIITYU,Iillil
Ka3axcraHa, 23
PHH 480100223532, Eilt!H 050240005234
Eilt!K KKMFKZ2A
ltllt!K KZ210 70103 KSN4814000, KOA 4523255
rY «AenapraMeHT Ka3Ha~erlicrea no CKO KoMI!ITera
Ka3HaYerlicrea MIIIHIIICTepcrea 4>1!1HaHcoe PK»
TOO «U.eHrp no ou,eHKe 111 Hennare>KaM «3ABenopi!IM
KyHracarli»
PHH 600700192417, ltllt!K KZ439261802153378000;
Eilt!K KZKOKZKX B AO «Ka3KOMMepu,6aHK»
AerliCTBI!ITellbHblrA ~neH no «AnMaTIIIHCKaR nanaTa
Ou,eHW,IIIKOB», CBIIIAeTellbCTBO NQ26-2011-0910/101l or
29.05.2012 r.
t.tenb ou,eHKH:
OnpeAe/leHI!Ie pbiHO~HOrA CTOIIIMOCTIII liiMyW,eCTBa
BHAOU,eHKH:
06R3aTe/lbHaR
Ha3Ha~eHHe
ou,eHKH:
AflR npi!IBaTI!I3aU,Iillil
BHA onpeAellReMOH CTOHMOCTH:
PbiHOYHaR CTOI!IMOCTb cornacHo
ou,eHOYHOrli AeRrenbHOCTIII»
OcHoBaHHe AJ1R ou,eHKH:
Aoroeop NQ36-178 or 10.05.2012 r.
AaTa cocrasneHHR o~eTa o6 ou,eHKe:
13.06.2012 r.
AaTa nposeAeHHR ou,eHKH:
07.06.2012 r.
Kypc $ no H.6 Ha AaTY ou,eHKH:
148,89
PbiHO~HaR
CTOHMOCTb 06beKTa:
3aKOHY PK «0 6
'
1 275 000 £o8uH MunnuoH aaecmu ceM&8ecRm nRm&
m&ICR'Il meHze unu
8 600 £aoceM& m&ICR'I wecm&coml aonnafl.OB CWA
r. AnMATbl 2012 r.
- AI\MaTbl, VA l(a3biOeK DV1 50,
c 85, TeA: +7(727) 317-05-53, +7(727) 251-20-50,
--707) 155-47-79, e-mail: l<ungasa.@ ail.ru, [email protected]<z, web: www.advalorem.l<z
Ol'leT NQ 178/2 o6 ou,eHKe Tponnei:16yca nacca>t<HpcKoro «Ka3axcraH • 3TC-398, HAeHTHcf>HKaU,HOHHbli:l HOMep NQ00044
ConpoBOAHTenbHOe nHCbMO K o~eTY o6 04eHKe
NQ 178/2 OT 13 J.110HR 2012 rOAa
YsaJKaeMaR 3aype Ta.nanKeposHa!
B coomeemcmeuu c oozoeopoM N!!36-178 om 10 MaR 2012 z. Ha oKa3aHue yc.nyz no OL{eHKe
oeuJKuMozo u HeoeuJKuMozo .uMyUjecmea, 30KI110t.teHHbiM MeJKoy BaMu u TOO «l.l,eHmp no OL{eHKe u
HenllameJKOM «3oeei10pUM KyHZOCOU» B 11UL{e oupeKmopa Caet.teHKO o.n.
npoeeoeHO OL{eHKQ
uMyU{ecmea c L{ellbiO onpeoe11eHUR pbiHOt.tHoi:i cmouMocmu o6beKma. npueeoeHHble ucCIIeooeaHuR u
aHOI1U3 no3BOI1RIOm coe11amb Bb/eoo o moM, t.tmo eepoRmHaR pbiHOt.tHOR cmouMocmb Tpo.n.nei16yca
naCCQJKUpCKOZO ccKQ3QXCmQH>> 3TC-398, uiJeHmUt/JUKOf.4UOHHbiU HOMep N!! 00044 no cocmORHUIO HO 07
UIOHR 2012 zoiJa cocmaBI1Rem:
1 275 000 (oiJuH MUI111UOH iJsecmu ceM&iJecRm nRmb m&ICRt.t} meHze u11u 8 600 (soceM& m&ICR'I
wecm&comJ iJ01111apos CWA no Kypcy H6 PK (1$ -148,89} Ha iJamy nposeiJeHuR oueHKu.
06pOUjOIO BHUMQHUe, t.tmo 3mO nUCbMO He RB/1RemCR Omt.temOM 06 OL{eHKe, 0 mO/lbKO
npeoeapRem omt.tem npueeoeHHbiU oa11ee.
no11HOR xapaKmepucmuKa u onucaHue o6beKma OL{eHKU, Heo6xoouMaR uHrjJopMOL{UR u pact.tembl
npeOCmOB/leHbl B Omt.teme, OmOe/lbHble t.tacmu KOmopOZO He MOZym mpaKmOBOmbCR pa30e/1bHO, 0
mollbKO e CBR3U c noi1HbtM ezo meKcmoM, c yt.temoM ecex npuHRmbtx oonyU{eHuu u ozpaHut.teHui:i.
,l{aHHbiU omt.tem o6 OL{eHKe uMyu.jecmea cocmae11eH e oeyx 3K3eMni1Rpax, uMeiOUjUX oouHaKoeyiO
IOpUOUt.teCKYIO CUlly, no OOHOMY 0/lfl KOJKOOU U3 cmopoH.
EC/Iu y Bac B03HUKHym KaKue- 11u6o eonpocbt, noJKa11yi:icma, o6pau.jaumecb HenocpeocmeeHHO K
HOM.
611azooapuM Bac 30 npeoocmae11eHHYIO B03MOJKHocmb oKa3amb BaM yCIIyzu, u HaoeeMCR Ha
00/lbHei:iwee B30UMOBbiZOOHOe compyOHUt.tecmeo.
C yeaJKeHueM,
Caet.teHKO o.n.
,l{upeKmop TOO ccU,eHmp no OL{eHKe u Hen11ameJKa
«30Bei10pUMKyHZOCOU»
© 2011 TOO «L.IeHTP no ou,eHKe 11 Hennare>KaM «3ABenop11M KyHracaH» , reHepailbHa~ rOCYA8PCTBeHHa~ nl1u,eH311~
per111crpau,111oHHbiH NQ IOn-0092-(27332-191 0-TOO OT 15.02.2002r.
Crp. 2 113 13
Ol'leT NQ 178/2 06 Ol..leHKe Tp011J1eH6yca nacca>t<HpCKOro «Ka3aXCTa H» 3TC-398, HAeHTH$11Ka1..1110HHbiH HOMep N200044
Cm1COK I-1Cnollb30BaHHO~ lli-1Teparypbll-1 I-1CT04 HH KH HH <f>opMaU,HI-1
4
0CHOBHble CBeAeHHA 06 lllcnOilHHTeJle H 3aKa34 HKe
5
5
06W,I-1e CBeAeHHA 06 OT4eTe
rnaaa 1. 06w.aA 'taCTb
1.1.
0CHOBHble nOHATI-1A, 1!1CnOilb3yeMble B HaCTORW,eM 0T4eTe
6
1.2.
OrpaHI!141!1TellbHbre ycnoBI!1A 111 CAellaHHbre AOnyw,eHI!1A
6
1.3.
060CHOBaHI!1e 1!1 Bbi60p MeTOAOB OU,eHKI!1
1.3.1.
3aTpaTHbl~ nOAXOA
1.3.2.
AoXOAHbl~ noAXOA
1.3.3.
CpaBHHTellbHbl~ noAX-O A
7
7
8
8
rnaoa 2. OnHcaHHe H aHallH3 06beKTa 04eHKH
2.1.
06beKT 04eHKI-1
2 .2.
Onl!1caHI-1e o6beKTa ou,eHKI-1
2.3 .
Cl>OTO 1!1 MeCTOnOilO>KeHI!1e Ha KapTe
2 .4.
AHa/11-13 Hai!111Y4Wero 111 Ha1116onee 3<f><f>eKTI!1BHoro I-1Cnollb30BaHI!1A o6beKTa 04eHKI-1
9
9
9
9
r nasa 3. Pac'teT CTOHMOCTH 06beKTa 04eHKH
3 .1 .
OnpeAeneHI!1e CTOI!1MOCTI!1 o6beKTa ou,eHKI!1 B paMKax 3aTpaTHOro nOAXOAa
10
12
13
© 2011 TOO «l...leHrp no o~eHKe 11 Hennare>KaM «3Aeenopi1M KyHracaVI», reHepanbHaA rocyAapcreeHHaA Jll1~eH311A
per~~tcrpa~IIIOHHbiVI N2 IOJl-0092-(27332-191 0-TOO or 15.02.2002r.
O"NeT NQ 178/2 o6 OL\eHKe Tp01111ei16yca nacca>t<HpCKoro «Ka3axcraH • 3 C-398, H,D,eHTH¢>HKal\HOHHbli1 HOMep N200044
CnucoK ucnon&30BOHHoi1 numepamyp&l u ucmo&~HUKU UHc/JopMOf.CUU:
1. 3aKoH PK «06 ou,eHOYHOH AeRTellbHOCTIII B Pecny611111Ke Ka3axcraH», AcraHa, 30 HOR6pR 2000 roAa
N2109-ll
2. (TaHAapT OU,eHKIII «OU,eHKa CTOIIIMOCTIII ABIII>t<IIIMOfO IIIMyW,eCTBa», YTBep>t<AeHHbiH np111Ka30M 1-1.0.
MIIIHIIICTpa IOCTIIIU,IIIIII Pecny611111KIII Ka3axcraH OT «09 » AeKa6pR 2010 fOAa NQ 325.
3. 3eMe/lbHbiH KOAeKC OT 20 IIIIOHR 2003 fOAa NQ 442-11
4. nocraHOB/leHIIIe npaBIIITe/lbCTBa OT 02.11.2001 N 1389 «BonpOCbl lliiiU,eH3111pOBaHIIIR AeRTellbHOCTIII
no ou,eHKe IIIMyw,ecrsa» (c 1113MeHeHIIIRMIII, BHeceHHbiMIII nocraHosneHI!IeM npaBIIITellbCTBa PK OT
24.06.02 r. N 689).
5. (OBMeCTHbiH np111Ka3 MIIIHIIICTpa IOCTIIIU,IIIIII Pecny611111KIII Ka3aXCTaH OT 21 HOR6pR 2002 fOAa N 171 Ill
MIIIHIIICTpa <j>IIIHaHCOB Pecny611111KIII Ka3axcraH OT 2 AeKa6pR 2002 rDAa N 597 «06 YTBep>t<AeHIIIIII npaBIII/1
no npiiiMeHeHIIIto cy6beKTaMIII ou,eHOYHOH AeRTellbHOCTIII Tpe6osaHIIIH K MeToAaM ou,eHKIII npeAnPIIIRTIIIR,
KaK IIIMyUJ,eCTBeHHOfO KOMnlleKCa».
6. (OBMeCTHbiH np111Ka3 MIIIHIIICTpa IOCTIIIU,IIIIII Pecny611111KIII Ka3aXCTaH OT 21 HOR6pR 2002 fOAa N 172 Ill
MIIIHIIICTpa <j>IIIHaHCOB Pecny611111KIII Ka3axcraH OT 2 AeKa6pR 2002 rOAa N 598 (( 06 YTBep>t<AeHIIIIII npaBIII/1
no npiiiMeHeHIIIIO cy6beKTaMIII OU,eHOYHOH AeRTe/lbHOCTIII Tpe6oBaHIIIH K COAep>t<aHIIIIO Ill <j>opMe OTYeTa
o6 ou,eHKe »
7. (OBMeCTHbiH np111Ka3 MIIIHIIICTpa IOCTIIIU,IIIIII Pecny611111KIII Ka3aXCTaH OT 21 HOR6pR 2002 fOAa N 173,
MIIIHIIICTpa <j>IIIHaHCOB Pecny611111K111 Ka3aXCTaH OT 2 AeKa6pR 2002 fOAa N 600, MIIIHIIICTpa IIIHAYCTPIIIIII Ill
TOprOB/1111 Pecny611111KIII Ka3aXCTaH OT 26 HOR6pR 2002 fOAa N 96 Ill npeACeAaTe/lR AreHTCTBa Pecny611111KIII
Ka3axcraH no ynpasneHIIIto 3eMellbHbiMIII pecypcaMIII oT 23 HOR6pR 2002 roAa N 90 «06 YTBep>t<AeHIIIIII
npaBIII/1 no np~t~MeHeHIIIto cy6beKTaMIII ou,eHOYHo11 AeRTellbHOCTIII Tpe6osaHIIII1 K MeTOAaM ou,eHKIII
HeABIII>t<IIIMOfO IIIMyW,eCTBa (3a IIICK/ltoYeHI!IeM npeAnpiiiRTIIIH KaK IIIMyUJ,eCTBeHHbiX KOMn/leKCOB)»
8. np111Ka3 KOMIIITeTa no CTaHAapT1113aU,IIIIII, MeTp0110fllllll Ill cepTIII<j>IIIKaU,IIIIII MIIIHIIICTepcrsa IIIHAYCTPIIIIII Ill
TOprOB/1111 Pecny611111KIII Ka3aXCTaH OT 29 AeKa6pR 2002 r. NQ 510 «06 YTBep>t<AeHIIIIII Ill BBeAeHIIIe B
AeHCTBIIIe rocvAapcrseHHbiX CTaHAapTOB Pecny611111KIII Ka3aXCTaH» (CIIICTeMa ou,eHKIII IIIMyw,ecrsa PK.
TepMIIIHbr 111 onpeAelleHIIIR. npiiiHU,IIInbr ou,eHKIII. CT PK 1127-2002, CT PK 1126-2002)
9. C111creMa craHAapTOB ou,eHKIII IIIMyw,ecrsa C!>C PK 14640 KA0:2004
10. niiiCbMO MIIIHCTPOR Pecny611111KIII Ka3aXCTaH NQAK-05-B-1548 OT 11.09.96r.
11.niiiCbMO MIIIHCTpOR Pecny611111KIII Ka3axcraH NQAK-05-6-2061 OT 12.12.1996r.
12.PacYeT YHIII<j>IIIU,IIIpOBaHHOrO Ha6opa pecypCHbiX Ill CTOIIIMOCTHbiX nOKa3aTe/leH B 6a3111CHOM ypOBHe
U,eH Ha CTpOIIITe/lbHO-MOHTa>t<Hble pa60Tbl MOAYilbHbiX 3AaHIIIH. MIIIHCTpOH PK., AllMaTbl, 1996.
13.Cn 81-01-94. (BOA npaBIII/1 no onpeAe/leHIIIIO CTOIIIMOCTIII CTpOIIITe/lbCTBa B COCTaBe npeAnpoeKTH OH Ill
npoeKTHO-cMeTHOH AOKyMeHTaU,IIIIII. MIIIHCTpol1 Pocc111111 . M ., 1995.
14.CTp0111TellbHbre HOpMbl PK. AcraHa: 2003.
15.B. H. KYTYKOB. PeKOHCTpyKU,IIIR 3AaHIIIH. «BbrcwaR WKOila». M., 1991.
16.C6opHIIIK yKpynHeHHbiX noKa3aTe/leH BOCCTaHOBIIITe/lbHOH CTOIIIMOCTIII 3Aa HIIIH Ill COOp
17.C6opHIIIK OU,eHOYHbiX HOpM. AllMa-ATa, 1982r.
18.0u,eHKa IIIMyw,ecrsa. AJ.1. 3111MIIIH . - M.: «IOplllcnpyAeHU,IIIR», 2007.
19.0u,eHKa HeABIII>KIIIMOCTIII. r. C. Xapp111coH Aeno, 1994r.
20.0u,eHKa CTOIIIMOCTIII HeABIII>KIIIMOCTIII. E.H. l-1saHoBa.- M.: KHOPYC, 2007.
21.3KOHOMIIIKa HeABIII>KIIIMOCTIII. B. 1-1. PeciiiHa. Aeno, 1999r.
22 .3KOHOMIIIKa HeABIII>KIIIMOCTIII, B. A. ropeMbiKIIIH, MOCKBa, 1999r.
23 .npaKTIIIYeCKOe pyKOBOACTBO no OU,eHKe OCHOBHbiX <j>OHAOB, MpCKBa, 1993r.
24.AaHHbre AreHTCTBa Pecny6niiiKIII Ka3axcraH no craTIIICTIIIKe.
25.0u,eHKa pbrHOYHOH CTOIIIMOCTIII HeABIII>KIIIMOCTIII. B. PYTral13ep,- M.: Aeno, 1998. -384 c.
26.0u,eHKa HeABIII>KIIIMOCTIII. noA peAaKU,IIIeH 3aCily>KeHHOro AeRTe/lR HayKIII PC!>, AO KTOpa
3KoHOMIIIYeCKIIIX HayK, npo<j>eccopa A.r. fpR3Hosol1, AOKTopa 3KOHOMIIIYeCKIIIX HayK, npo<j>eccopa A.M.
C!>eAOTosol1, MocKsa «C!>IIIHaHCbllll craTIIICTIIIKa», 2007 r.
27.AaHHbre AreHTCTBa Pecny611111KIII Ka3axcraH no craTIIICTIIIKe.
28.AaHHble IIIHTepHeT CaHTOB.
© 2011 TOO «L...IeHTP no OL-IeHKe 111 HennaTe>r<aM «3Aeenopi!IM KyHracal1» , leHepanbHaR rocYAapcTeeHHaR Jllll~eH3111R
perHCTpa~IIIOHHbiH N2 IOJl-0092-(27332-1910-TOO oT 15.02.2002r.
CWO#
Ol'leT N!! 178/2 o6 ou,eHKe Tponnei16yca nacca>K~o~pcKoro «Ka3axcra H» 3 C-398, HAeHrH$HKau,~o~oHHbli1 HOMep N!!00044
OcHOBHble cseiJeHUR o6 HcnonHumene u 3aK03'1UKe
HcnonHumenb:
AiJpec:
Tenet/JoH:
e-mail:
PHH
Pac'lemHbiU C'lem
CmpaxosaHue
zpaJKiJOHCKO-np08080U
omsemcmseHHocmu:
PeKBU3umbl nuqeH3uu:
'lneHcmso e naname
OqeHIJ4UKOB:
OqeHIJ4UK:
OqeHIJ4UK:
TOO «l.J,eHTp no OL\eHKe 11 HenllaTe>t<aM «3ABenop1-1M KyHracaH»
IOpi-1A1-1YecKI-1H aApec: 050000 r. AllMaTbl, AI1Malli-1HCKI-1H paHoH, yn.
Ka3bl6eK 61-1 50, oct>1-1c 75
+7 (727) 317-05-63
E-mail: [email protected]
PHH 600700192417
P/C
KZ439261802153378000
AO
B
AI1MaTI-1HCKOM
cf>!-1/11-ia/le
«Ka3KOMMepl\6aHK»
rpa>f<AaHCKO-npaBOBafl OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb lf1cn0/1HI-1Tellfl 3acrpaxosaHa B AO
«Ka3KOMMepl\-nOili-1C» (Aorosop crpaxosaHI-1fl cep1-1R 13-12-312NQ045-11
OT 04.11.2011 r.).
fll-11..\eH3Hfl Ha ocyw.ecrsneHHe OL\eHOYHOH AeRTellbHOCTH NQ IOJl-0092(27332-1910-TOO) NQQQ00079 OT 15 <J>espallfl 2002r., BbiAaHHafl
MHHHcrepcrsoM IOCTHL\HH Pecny611HKH Ka3axcraH.
AeHCTBHTe/lbHbiH 4/leH no «AilMaTHHCKafl nanaTa 01..\eHW.HKOB»,
CB1-1AeTellbCTBO NQ158 or 08.06.2011 r.
CaBYeHKO 0/lbra naB/lOBHa
rocyAapcrseHHaR llHL\eH31-1fl ct>Jl-01583 NQ0131825 or 01.07.2009 r.
Mbii1Tbll~6aH H¥pllaH ~OpfaH6eK¥1lbl
rocyAapcrseHHaR llHL\eH31-1fl ct>Jl-00623 NQ0000577 or 14.05.2004 r.
AccucmeHm oqeH(J4UKa:
AcKap On>t<ac JlecxaHyllbl
AHnnoM «Ka3axcKoro Hal\HOHallbHOro yHHBepc!-1TeTa» NQ0040330 or
11.06.2010 r.
30KQ314UK/Co6cmBeHHUK:
rY «0TAell cf>HHaHCOB ropOAa nerponaBJlOBCKa»
PK, CKO, r. nerponaB/lOBCK, yn. KOHCTHTYI..\1-11-1 Ka3axcraHa, 23
PHH 480100223532, 61.-1H 050240005234
61.-1K KKMFKZ2A
lf11.-1K KZ210 70103 KSN48 14000, KOA 4523255
rY «AenapraMeHT Ka3HaYeHCTBa no CKO KoMHTeTa Ka3HaYeHCTBa
MHHHcrepcrsa ct>HHaHcos PK»
CnucoK iJoKyMeHmos, Ha ocHoBaHuu KomopbiX 6bma npou3seiJeHa oqeHKa
01..\eHKa 6bl/1a np01i13BeAeHa Ha OCHOBaHI-H1 ClleAYIOW.I-1X npasoycraHaB/11-lBaiOUJ.H)(,
I-1HbiX AOKyMeHTOB (KcepoKoni-1H):
1. TexHI-1YeCKI-1 nacnopr
2. AKT npl-ieMa-nepeAaYI-1 or 25.03.2011 r.
TexHn., ·~~
© 2011 TOO «l.J,eHrp no Ol.leHKe 111 Hennare>KaM «3ABenopiiiM KyHracai1», reHepanbHaR rocyAapcrseHHaR Il111l.leH3111R
perncrpal.IIIIOHHbli1 N!! IOJl-0092-(27332-1910-TOO OT 15.02.2002r.
S~
l3fl. Q
~- ~
OT'!eT N!! 178/2 o6 ou,eHKe Tponne~6yca nacca)l{~t~pcKoro «Ka3axcra H• 3TC-398, HAeHTHcf>~t~KaU,ItiOHHbl~ HOMep NoQQ044
rnasa 1. 06~a~~ 'faCTb
1.1. OcHOBHble noHRmuR, ucnonb3yeMble s HacmoRuceM Om"'eme
3aKa3'fMK- !f>M3M4ecKoe MllM IOPMAM4eCKoe llMU,O, norpe6MTellb ycllyr ou,eHW,MKa.
0U.eHKa- onpeAelleHMe B03MO>KHO~ pbiH04HO~ MllM MHO~ CTOMMOCTM 06beKTa OU,eHKM.
Ou.eHO'fHafl
AeflrenbHOCTb
npeAnpMHMMaTellbCKaR
AeRTellbHOCTb,
ocyw,ecrBilReMaR
OU.eHUJ,MKaMM, HanpaBileHHaR Ha ycraHOBileHMe B OTHOWeHMM 06beKTOB OU,eHKM pb1H04HO~ MllM MHO~
CTOMMOCTM Ha onpeAelleHHYIO AayY, eCilM MHOe He npeAYCMOTpeHO 3aKOHaMM .
Ou.eH~MK -
!f>M3M4ecKoe MllM IOPMAM4eCKoe llMU,O, MMe10w,ee llMU,eH3MIO Ha ocyw,ecrBileHMe
ou,eH04HO~ AeRTellbHOCTM.
MeTOA
ou.eHKM
-
cosoKynHOCTb
Ae~CTBM~
OpraHM3aU,MOHHO-TeXHM4eCKOro XapaKTepa,
IOPMAM4ecKoro,
MCnOilb3yeMbiX
AJ1R
!f>MHaHCOB0-3KOHOMM4eCKoro
ycraHOBileHMR
pb1H04HO~
M
M MHOH
CTOMMOCTM 06beKTa OU,eHKM.
noAXOA K OU.eHKe - cnoco6 onpeAelleHMR
B03MO>KHO~ pb1H04HOH MllM MHOH CTOMMOCTM 06beKTa
OU,eHKM C McnOilb30BaHMeM OAHOrO MllM HeCKOilbKMX MeTOAOB OU,eHKM.
CTaHAapTbl
OU.eHKM
-
HOpMaTMBHbiH
AOKyMeHT,
pa3pa6aTbiBaeMbiH
B
COOTBeTCTBMM
C
3aKOHOAaTellbCTBOM Pecny61lMKM Ka3axcraH M yYBep>KAaeMbl~ ynollHOM04eHHbiM rocyAapcrBeHHbiM
OpraHOM
no
CTaHAapTM3aU,MM,
MeTpOilOrMM
M CepTM!f>MKaU,MM,
B KOTOpOM
yCTaHaBilMBaiOTCR
AJ1R
BCeo6w,ero M MHOrOKpaTHOro MCnOilb30BaHMR npaBMila, npMHU,Mnbl M xapaKTepMCTMKM B 061laCTM
ou,eH04Hoi1 AeRTellbHOCTM.
OT'fer o6 ou.eHKe- nepeAaBaeMoe 3aKa34MKY nMCbMeHHoe coo6w,eHMe ou,eHW,MKa o pe3yllbTarax
pa60Tbl no OU,eHKe no lf>opMe, ycraHOBileHHOH ynOilHOM04eHHbiM opraHOM, M COOTBeTCTBYIOW,ee
Tpe6oBaHMRM HaCTORUJ,ero 3aKOHa.
PbiHO'fHaJI CTOMMOCTb -
HaM60ilee BepORTHafl U,eHa, no KOTOpOi1 AaHHbiH 06beKT MO>KeT 6b1Tb
OT4Y>KAeH Ha OCHOBaHMM CAellKM
B YCilOBMfiX KOHKypeHU,MM,
KOrAa CTOpOHbl CAellKM Ae~CTBYIOT,
pacnollaraR see~ AOCyYnHo~ MH!f>opMau,Mei1 o6 o6beKTe ou,eHKM, a Ha u,eHe CAellKM He orpa>KaiOTCR
KaKMe-llM60 4pe3Bbl4aHHble 06CTOfiTellbCTBa, KOrAa:
• OAHa 1-13 cropoH CAellKM He o6R3aHa OT4Y>KAaTb o6beKT ou,eHKM, a APvraR cropoHa He o6R3aHa
npMo6peraTb;
• CTOpOHbl CAellKM XOpOWO OCBeAOMileHbl 0 npeAMeTe CAellKM M Aei1CTBYIOT B CBOMX MHTepecax;
• u,eHa CAellKM npeACTaBilfleT co6oi1 3KBMBalleHT AeHe>KHoro B03Harpa>KAeHMfl 3a o6beKT ou,eHKM,
M npMHY>KAeHMR K COBepweHMIO CAellKM B OTHOWeHMM CTOpOH CAellKM C 4be~-llM60 CTOpOHbl He
6blll0 •
.Q,aTa OU.eHKM - AeHb MllM nepMOA BpeMeHM, Ha KOTOpbiH , onpeAellReTCfl B03MO>KHaR pb1H 0 4HaR
MiliA lAHaR CTOMMOCTb 06beKTa OU,eHKM.
1.2. OzpaHu"'umenbHble ycnosuR u cdenaHHble donyuceHuR
npM BblnOilHeHMM HaCTORW,ei1 pa60Tbl Ou,eHW,MK MCXOAMil lt13 ClleAYIOW,I-1X orpaH~KTeJI
YCilOBM~ 1t1 AOnyw,eHMi1:
1. B
npou,ecce noAroroBKM HacroRw,ero oT4era, Ou,eHW,MK MCXOAMil M3 AOCTosep HOCTM H eJUu'4'1.1"U\
AOKyMeHTOB, nolly4eHHbiX or 3aKa34MKa.
2.
Ou,eHW,MK
He
Hecer
orsercrBeHHOCTM
3a
IOPMAM4ecKoe
onMcaHMe
npasa
co6CTBeHHOC1l1
OU,eHMBaeMOe MMyW,eCTBO, AOCTOBepHOCTb KOTOporo pe310MMpyeTCR CO CllOB 3aKa34MKa. Ou,eHHBae
e
npaBa C06CTBeHHOCTit1 paCCMaTpMBaiOTCfl CB060AHbiMit1 OT KaKMX-Illt160 npereH3M~ MllM orpa HM4eHHH, He
HaXOAMTCfl nOA apeCTOM, B 3allore, He 061lO>KeHO cepBMTyYaMM, KpOMe, OrOBOpeHHbiX B OT4eTe .
3.
Ou,eHW,MK He npoM3BOAI-11l o6Mep noMew,eHMi1, nollaraRCb Ha sepHOCTb MCXOAHOi1 MH!f>opMaU,M H,
npeAOCTaBileHHOH 3aKa341t1KOM.
4.
Or ou,eHW,MKOB He rpe6yercR noRBilRTbCR B cyAe MiliA CBMAeTellbCTBoBaTb MHbiM o6pa3oM no noBOAY
COCTaBileHHOrO OT4eTa MiliA OU,eHeHHOrD MMyW,eCTBa, KpOMe KaK B Clly4ae O!f>I-1LJ,It1allbHOrO Bbi30Ba CyAa.
5.
npM npoBeAeHMM OU,eHKM npeAnOilarallOCb OTCyYCTBMe KaKM~-IlM60 CKpbiTbiX lf>aKTOpOB, Blllt1RIOW,MX
Ha croi-1MOCTb ou,eHMBaeMoro MMyw,ecrsa. Ha Ou,eHW,MKe He lle>KMT orsercrseHHOCTb no o6Hapy>KeHMIO
(MiliA B Clly4ae 06Hapy>KeHMR) nOA06HbiX lf>aKTOpOB.
© 2011 TOO «L...IeHTP no 01.-leHKe H HennaTe>KaM «3ABenopHM KyHracalir», reHepailbHaR rOCYA8PCTBeHHaR nHI..IeH3HR
perHCTpai..IHOHHbllir N2 ton-0092-(27332-191 0-TOO oT 15.02.2002r.
<>p.6~
O"NeT NQ 178/2 o6 OL\eHKe Tponnei:16yca nacca>t<HpcKoro «Ka3axcra H• 3 C-398, 11AeHTI1<PI1Kal\110HHbiH HOMep NQ00044
~CXOAHbre AaHHbre, I-1CnOilb30BaHHble Ou,eHW,I-1KOM npH noArOTOBKe oTYeTa, 6bllll-1 nollylleHbl 1-13
6.
HaAe>KHbJX
I-1CTOliHI-1KOB
1-1
Clii-1TaiOTCR
AOCTosepHbJMH.
TeM
He
MeHee,
Ou,eHW,I-1K
He
Mo>KeT
rapaHTI-ipOBaTb 1-iX a6COJ110THYIO TOliHOCTb, n03TOMy TaM, r Ae 3TO B03MO>KHO, AellaiOTCR CCblllKI-1 Ha
I-1CTOliHI-1K 1-iH<f>OpMaU,I-11-1.
7.
H11 3aKa3li11K, Hl1 Ou,eHW,I-1K He MOryT l-1cnOJlb30BaTb OT4eT ( 111111 11106y10 ero llaCTb) I-1Halle, lleM 3TO
npeAYCMOTpeHO B Ha3HalleHI111 OU,eHKI-1, yKa3aHHO~ B OT4eTe.
8.
MHeHI1e Ou,eHW,I-1Ka OTHOCI-1TellbHO pbrHOliHO~ CTOI1MOCTI1 Ae~CTBI-1TellbHO TOilbKO Ha AaTY ou,eHKI1 .
Ou,eHW,11K
He
ce6R
npi1HI1MaeT Ha
npl1pOAHbiX VC/10811~ ,
IOP11A11lleCKI1X 11
3KOHOMI1lleCKI1X,
OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a
noC11eAYIOW,11e
KOTOpble
113MeHeHI1R
cou,l1allbHbJX,
MOryT nOB/111RTb Ha
CT011MOCTb
ou,eHI1BaeMoro 11Myw,ecrsa.
9.
0T4eT 06 OU,eHKe COAep>K1-1T npo<fleCCI-iOHallbHOe MHeHI1e 0U,eHW,11Ka OTHOCI1TellbHO CT011MOCTI1
OU,eHI1BaeMOro 1-iMyW,eCTBa, npeAHa3HalleHO AJIR npi1HRTI1R peweHI1R B 11MyW,eCTBeHHOM cnope B
COOTBeTCTBI111 C U,ellRMI1, yKa3aHHbiMI1 B ,lJ,OrOBOpe 1-1 B 0T4eTe.
10.
0T4eT 06 OU,eHKe COAeP>K!'IT npo<fleCCI10HallbHOe MHeHI1e '0u,eHW,Io1Ka OTHOCI1TellbHO CT011MOCTI1
ou,eHI1BaeMoro 11Myw,ecrsa, pbiHOliHaR u,eHa Komporo, OTpamaeT ero npo<f>eccl1oHallbHOe MHeHI1e 11
noclleAHI1~ He rapaHTI1pyeT Toro, liTO no 3TO~ u,eHe 6YAYT cosepwaTbCR peallbHbre CAellKI1.
11.
ny61111KaU,11R OTYeTa o6 ou,eHKe u,elli1KOM, llaCTRMI1 111111 OTAellbHbiX CCblllOK Ha OTYeT, AaHHbiX,
COAep>KaW,I1XCR B OTYeTe, 11MeHI1 11 npo<fleCCI10HallbHO~ np11HaAJ1e>KHOCTI1 OU,eHW,11Ka 3anpew,aeTCR 6e3
ero ni1CbMeHHoro cor11ac11R.
12. 3ARBJ1EH~E
O~EHUJ,~KA. Mbl, H11>KenOAn11CaBWI1eCR, AaHHbiM YAOCTOBepReM, liTO B COOTBeTCTBI111 C
11MeiOW,I1MI1CR y
HaC AaHHbiM11 :0 113JlO>KeHHble B AaHHOM OT4eTe <flaKTbl BepHbl 1-1 COOTBeTCTBYIOT
Ae~CTBI1TellbHOCT11;
Ae~CTBI-1TellbHbl
CAellaHHbl~
11CKI110lii1TellbHO
B
aHa/1113,
BbJCKa3aHHbJe
npeAe11ax
orosopeHHbJX
MHeHI1R
B
11
AaHHOM
nollylleHHbre
oTYeTe
BbJBOAbl
AOnyw,eHI1~
11
orpaHI1lii1BaiOW,11X VC/10811~ 11 RBJlRIOTCR HaWI1MI1 nepCOHallbHbiM11; • Mbl He 11MeeM Hl1 B HaCTORW,eM, H11
B 6yAyW,eM KaKOr0-111-160 1-iHTepeca B 06beKTe C06CTBeHHOCTI-1, RBJlRIOW,eMCR npeAMeTOM AaHHOro
OT4era:
Mbl
TaK>Ke
He
I-1MeeM
1111liHO~
3ai1HTepeCOBaHHOCTI-1
1-1
npeAy6e>f<AeHI1R
B
OTHOWeHI111
BOBJlelleHHblX CTOpOH; • HaWe B03Harpa>f<AeHI1e Hl-1 B KOe~ CTeneHI1 He CBR3aHO C 06bRBileHI1eM 3apaHee
onpeAelleHHO~ CTOI-1MOCTI1, 1-1111-1 TeHAeHU,I1e~ B onpeAelleHI111 CTOI1MOCTI-1 B nOilb3Y K/111eHTa; • 3aAaHI1e
Ha OU,eHKY He OCHOBbJBallOCb Ha Tpe6oBaHI111 onpeAelleHI1R MI1HI1MallbHO~ 1-11111 orosopeHHO~ U,eHbl; •
Hl-1 OAHO 1111U,O, KpoMe noAn11casw1-1x AaHHbl~ OT4eT, He OKa3bJBalll-1 npo<f>eccl1oHallbHOro coAe~CTBI-1R
OU,eHW,11KaM, nOAn1-1CaBWI1M AaHHbl~ OT4eT; • HaW aHa/1113, MHeHI1R 11 BbiBOAbl 6bllll1 nollylleHbl, a 3TOT
OT4eT cocraBJleH B nOilHOM COOTBeTCTBI-11-1 c EA11HbiM11 CraHAapraMI1 npo<f>eCC110HallbHO~ npaKTI1KI1
Ou,eHK11; • paclleTHaR CTOI1MOCTb np113HaercR Ae~CTBI-1TellbHO~ Ha AaTY ou,eHK11; · ou,eHW,I-1KI1 1111liHO
npo1-13Belll1 Hapy>KHbl~ 1-1 BHYTPeHHI-1~ ocMorp ou,eHI-1BaeMoro 11Myw,ecrsa.
1.3. 060CHOBQHUe U Bbi60p MemodOB oqeHKU
1.3.1. 3ampamH&Iii nodxoa
3aTpaTHbl~ MeTOA B OU,eHKe MaWI-1H 11 o60PYAOBaHI-1R OnloipaeTCR B TeopeTHlleCKO
nJia e
TPYAOBYIO reop1110 CTOI1MOCTI1, a 1-13 ou,eHOliHbJX np11HU,I-1nos ocHOBbrsaercR Ha n p11Hu,11ne 3aMe
a
e
KOTOpbl~ rllaCHT, liTO OCBeAOMJleHHbl~ HHBeCTOp He 3anJlaTio1T 3a 06beKT 60ilbWVIO cy
cpaaHeHI-110 c
3arparaMio1
Ha
npolo13BOACTBO
(np1o1o6pereH11e)
aHallOrl-1liHOro o6beKTa
OAHHa o
noJle3HOCTio1 C COnOCTaBHMbiMI-1 TeXHio1K0-3KCnllyaTaU,Io10HHbiMio1 noKa3aTe/1RMio1.
3aTpaTHbl~
o6opyAOBaHI-1R
nOAXOA
nYTeM
-
paclleTa
nOAXOA
K
OU,eHKe,
BOCCTaHOBI-1TellbHO~
KOTOpbl~
CTOHMOCTI-1
OnpeAellReT
TeKyW,y iO
C nOCileAYIOW,HM
CTOH
Y4eTOM
B
OCTb
HeH
o6ecu,eHeHI-1R, Bbi3BaHHOro BbiRBJleHHbiMI1 3JleMeHTaMI1 HaKOnlleHHOrO 113HOCa .
CTOio1MOCTb BOCnp01o13BOACTBa npeACTaBJlReT C060~ TeKyW,He 3aTpaTbl Ha np01-13BOACTBO 1-1111-1
np1o106pereH1o1e HOBOrO o6opyAOBaHio1R, nOilHOCTbiO 11AeHTio1liHOrO OU,eHI1BaeMOMY no <flyHKU,110HallbHbi M,
KOHCTPYKTHBHbiM 11 3KCnllyaTaU,110HHbiM xapaKrep1-1CTio1KaM .
CTOI-1MOCTb 3aMeW,eHI-1R -
3TO M11Hio1MallbHble TeKyW,I1e 3aTpaTbl no np1-106peTeHI110 Ha pbiHKe
aHallOrl-iliHOrO o6opyAOBaHI1R, MaKCI1MallbHO 6Jli13KOro no CBOI1M <flyHKU,I10Ha/lbHbiM, KOHCTpyKT11BHbiM
1o1 3KCnllyaTaU,Io10HHbiM xapaKTep11CTio1KaM K OU,eHio1BaeMOMy.
Op. ?W
© 2011 TOO «L.leHTP no Ol..leHKe 11 HennaTe>KaM «3ABenop11M KyHracaiil», reHepanbHaR rOCYASPCTBeHHSR IlHI..leH311R
perHcrpal..lHOHHbtH NQ IOil-0092-(27332-1910-TOO OT 15.02.2002r.
~
7
113 3 1/J X
ONer NQ 178/2 o6 ou,eHKe TponneH6yca nacca>t<HpcKoro «Ka3axcraH • 3TC-398, HAeHTH<j>HKaU,HOHHbiH HOMep NQQ0044
np11 nOilHOM AOCTI1>KeHI111 <j>yHKL\110Ha/lbHOro, KOHCTpYKn1 SHOrO 11 napaMeTp114eeKOrO eXOACTSa
np11HRTO rosOp11Tb 06 11AeHT114HOCTI1 06beKTOS, a n p 11 npl16m1311Te/lbHOM 11 4aCTI14HOM eXOACTSe -
06
aHanori14HOCTI1. OeHosy pae4eTa CT011MOCTI-1 socnpoi-13SOACTBa 1-1111-1 CTOI-1MOCTIII 3aMew,eHIIIR cocrasnReT
pae4eT 113Aep>KeK
np0113SOACTSa TOro
11/111
11HOrO
MaWI1HOTeXHI14eCKO~
S11Aa
npOAYKI...\1111,
T.
e.
ce6eCTOI1MOCTI1.
3aTeM, 113 paee411TaHHO~ TaKI1M o6pa30M 6a3bl, Bbi411Ta10TCR norep11 CTOI1MOCTI1 06opyAOBaHI1R B
pe3yllbTaTe 113HOea.
1.3.2. Aoxot3Hb/U noaxoa
01...\eHKa Mawi1H 11 o6opyAOSaHI1R AOXOAHbiM nOAXOAOM npoi13SOA11TCR nyreM nporH031-1posaH11R
COSOKynHOCTI1 6YAYW,11X AOXOAOS, KOTOpble noTeHL\11a/lbHO MOryr 6b1Tb reHep11pOSaHbl S pe3yllbTaTe
11enOilb30SaHI1R 06beKTOS MaWI1H
TeKyW,e~
CTOIIIMOCTI1
no
CTaSKe
11 o6opyAOSaH11R,
A11eKOHTa
e nOelleAYIOW,11M np11SeAeH11eM AOXOAOS
Tpe6yeMO~
(T.e.
11HSeCTOpaMI1
CTaSKI1
AOXOAa
K
Ha
11HSeCTI11...\1111), Sb16paHHO~ e y4eTOM pl1eKa 11Hsecr11posaHI1R (MeTOA A11CKOHTI1posaHHoro AeHe>KHoro
noToKa) 111160 e noeneAy10w,e~ npRMO~ KOHsepTal..\11e~ cra6111111311posaHHoro AOXOAa (3a OTAellbHO
S3RTbl~ rOA) S TeKyW,yiO CT011MOCTb, T.e. AelleH11eM Se/111411Hbl 3TOrO AOXOAa Ha eOOTSeTCTSYIOW,11~
06W,11~ K03<j><j>l11...\11eHT Kani1Ta/1113al..\1111 (MeTOA npRMO~ Kani1Ta/1113al..\1111).
noeKO/lbKY AOXOA e03AaeTCR
seeM np0113SOACTSeHHbiM KOMn/leKeOM, TO SHa4alle 01...\eHKa
MaWI1H 11 060PYAOSaHI1R AOXOAHbiM nOAXOAOM paee411TbiSaeT AOXOA OT <j>yHKL\110HI1pOsaHI1R see~
npOI13SOACTSeHHO~ ei1CTeMbl.
3aTeM MeTOAOM ocraTKa Sbl41leHReTeR 4aCTb AOXOAa, KompyiO MO>KHO OTHeCTI1 K MaWI1HHOMY
napKy 3TO~ CI1CTeMbl.
Aanee
e
noMOW,biO
MeTOAa
A11eKOHT11posaHHbiX
AeHe>KHbiX
noToKos,
111111
MeTOAa
Kani1Ta/1113al..\1111, onpeAellsteTeR CTOI1MOCTb scero MaWI1HHOro napKa .
Ee1111 HY>KHO onpeAelli1Tb CTOI1MOCTb KaKo~ - 111160 eA11H11U,bl MaWI1Hbl 111111 o6opyAosaHI1R, TO ee
OL\eHKa
MaWI1H
11
o6opyAOSaH11R
AOXOAHbiM
noAXOAOM
paee411TblsaeT
e
noMOW,biO
AO/lesoro
K03<j><j>l1 L\11eHTa.
1.3.3. CpaeHumenbHb/U noaxoa
CpasHI1TellbHbl~
nOAXOA
K
OL\eHKe
MaWI1H
11
o6opyAosaHI1R
o6beA11HReT
HeeKOilbKO
npaKTI14eeKI1X MeTOAOS OL\eHKI1. He3aSI1ei1MO OT 11enOJlb3yeMOrO MeTOAa o6o6w,eHHaR exeMa OL\eHK11
SK/1104aeT e/leAYIOW,I1e 3Tanbl:
•
aHa/1113 pbiHKa 11 ero eerMeHTa, K KOTOpOMY OTHOei1TeR 06beKT OL\eHKI1
e
e6op 11 peri1CTpal..\11R TeKyW,e~ pb1H04HO~ 11H<j>OpMal..\1111 06 06beKTaX, KOTOpble MOryr
6b1Tb npi13HaHbl aHa/loraMI1 no OTHOWeHI110 K OL\eHI1SaeMOMY 06beKTY
•
nposepKy AOCTOSepHOCTI1 eo6paHHO~ 11H<j>OpMal..\1111 11 OTees He HaAe>KHbiX eseAeHI1 H
•
Sbi60p MeTOAa OL\eHK11 11 pae4eT CTOI1MOCTI1 OL\eHI1SaeMoro 06beKTa
AHa/1113 pbiHKa - o6R3aTellbHbl~ 11 sa>t<Hbl~ 3Tan np11 np11MeHeHI111 epasHI1Te ll bH oro AOXOAa .
CpasHI1TellbHbl~
OL\eH04Hbl e
noAXOA
npOL\eAYPbl,
K
OL\eHKe
Hanp11Mep
Tpe6yeT
SHeeeHI1e
SblnOilHeHI1R
1...\eHOSbiX
11
HeKoTopble
seno
napaM eTp 114 e eKI1X
orarenb
e
KOppe
onpeAelleHI1e el11lbl Slli1RHI1R OTAellbHbiX napaMeTpos Ha CTOI1MOCTb o6be KTos AaHHOH op,Hopo
rpynnbJ, nocrpoeHI1e KoppellRL\110HHO-perpeeel1oHHO~
MOAe/111
11 T. n ., TO
Hellb3R orpaH
e6opOM 11H<j>OpMal..\1111 TOilbKO 06 OAHOM, XOTR 11 AOCTaT04HO 6Jli13KOM aHa/l ore. Bo SCex
Heo6XOA11MO
crpeMI1TbeR
e<j>opM11posaTb
SbJ6opKy
OAHOPOAHbJX
o6be KTos,
AaHHbJe
o
n03S0/1RT Sbln0/1HI1Tb He06XOA11MbJe onepal...\1111 CTaTI1CTI14eeKOrO aHa/1113a .
3aTeM eo6paHHYIO 11H<j>OpMal..\1110 nposepRIOT Ha AOCTOSepHOCTb 11 OTeei1Sa iOT HeHaAe
e
eSeAeHI1R. Hanp11Mep, nposepRIOT eXOA11MOCTb 1...\eH Ha OAH11 11 Te >Ke MOAe/111 Ma WI-1H Y pa3H
npOAaSL\OS 11 np11
He06XOA11MOCTI1 11X
11
0411W,aiOT
11
OT e/ly4a~HbiX 11eKa>KeHI1~
11
HeCOOTB eTCTBI1H
HOpMa/lbHbiM yC/lOSI1RM npOAa>KI1 111160 11eK/1104aiOT 113 paeeMOTpeHI1R 1...\eHbl, KOTOpble He/10ri-14H bl np11
eonocras/leHI11-1 e napaMeTpaMI1 eOOTSeTCTSYIOW,I1X MaW11H. noene nposeAeHHO~ nOArOTOSKI1 1...\eHOSy iO
11H<j>OpMal..\1110 TeM 11/111 11HbiM MeTOAOM o6pa6aTbJSaiOT 11, S KOHe4HOM e4eTe, nolly4aiOT 1-ieKOMYIO
CTOI1MOCTb 06beKTa .
flpOOHORU3Up0808 Bb/RBneHHb/e mpe60BOHUR1 oqeHU4UKU npuwnu K 8b/80t3y, 'lmO 8 t30HHOM
CRY'40e cnet3yem UCnORb3080mb Memot3 30mpamHOZO not3xot3a.
© 2011
Op.Bc;p0
TOO «l...leHTP no Ol..leHKe Ill HennaTe>KaM «3Asenopi!IM KyHracali1» , reHepailbHaR rocyAapCTseHHaR nlill..leH31-1R
peri-1CTpai..IIIIOHHblli1 N210n-0092-(27332-1910-T00 OT 15.02.2002r.
H~l3 ~.
Ol'leT NQ 178/2 o6 ou,eHKe Tpo1111e~6yca nacca>KHpcKoro «Ka3aXCTaH » 3TC-398, 11AeHTl1cpl1Kau,HOHHbl~ HOMep N200044
2.
rnasa
OmtcaHMe M aHanM3
2.1. 06beKm oqeHKU
06beKTOM ou,eHKI-1
RBnReTcR
Tponne~6yc nacca>+<1<1pcKI-1~ «Ka3axcraH» .
2.2. OnucaHue o6beKma oqeHKU
npeACTaBnReT co6o~
06beKT ou,eHKI-1
Tponne~6yc
nacca>+<1<1pcKI-1~
«Ka3axcraH»,
MapKI-1
3TC-398,
1<1AeHTI-1<j>!-1KaU,I-10HHbl~ HOMep N!!00044.
Ha MOMeHT OCMOTpa
pacnonarancR Ha TeppHTOpHH
OU,eH!-1BaeMbl~ Tp011Jle~6yc HaXOAI-1/lCR B HeHCnpaBHOM COCTORHI-11<1 H
TOO
yn . raUJeKa ,
"neTponasnoscKI!'I~ Tponne~6ycHbl~ napK" no a.Qpecy:
24.
OnHcaHI!'Ie 1-1 HHbl e xapaKTepHCTHKH o6beKTa ou,eHKH npHBeAeHbl s Ta6nHu,e
1.
Ta6nMu,a
N!!
HaMMeHoBaHMe
n/n
1.
XapaKTepMCTMKM
1
MapKa
2
AaTa BbmycKa
HIOHb 2003 r.
3
3aBOACKO~ HOMep
405878
4
I,IIAeHTH<j>HKaLJ,HOHHbl~ HOMep
00044
5
TeXHHYeCKOe COCTORHHe
HeT nepeAHero 6aMnepa, H3Hoc nacca>+<lllpCKHX Kpecen 1-1
3TC- 398
Ca/lOHa, MHOrDYHCJleHHble nospe>+<AeHHR JlaKOKpaCOYHOro
noKpbiTHR, CHilbHbl~ H3Hoc BOAHTellbCKoro aneKTponaKeTa,
CO CllOB C06CTBeHHHKa TpaHCnOpTHOe cpeACTBO He
HCnpaBHO
2.3. 4>omo oqeHuaaeMozo o6beKma.
¢>OTOrpa<j>HH 06beKTa OU,eHKH npHBeAeHbl B npHilO>KeHHI-11<1
1.
2.4. AHanu3 Haun}"'wezo u Hau6onee 3cpcpeKmuaHozo ucnon&30BOHUR o6beKma oqeHKU
Ha1-16011ee a<j><j>eKTII'IBHOe HCnOJlb30BaHHe HMyW,eCTBa - 3TO HCnOJlb30BaHHe HMyW,eCTBa, KOTOpOe
RBJlReTCR
<j>H3HYeCKH
B03MO>KHbiM,
10p111AHYeCKH
pa3peweHHbiM,
3KOHOMHYeCKH
COCTORTe/lbHbiM,
ocyw,eCTBHMbiM C <j>HHaHCOBO~ TOYKH 3peHHR 1<1 npHBOARW,II'IM K MaKCHMa/lbHO~ CTOII'IMOCTH 3TOrO
HMyw,ecrsa.
¢>H3HYeCKI-1
B03MO>KHbiMH
RBJlRIOTCR
Te
Bapl!'laHTbl
1<1CnOI1b30BaHHR
06beKTa,
KOTOpble
OCyW,eCTBII'IMbl C TOYKH 3peHHR era <j>I-13HYeCKHX xapaKTepHCTII'IK H AOCTynHOCTH KOMMYHHKa U,H~ .
Bee <j>H3HYeCKH B03MO>+<Hble 1-1 IOP1<1AHYeCKI-1 pa3peweHHbJe sap!-1aHTbl ll'lcnOI1b30Ba HHR o6beKTa
ou,eHKII'I conocrasnRIOTCR no KPHTepi-1RM 3KOHOMHYecKo~ a<j><j>eKTHBHOCTH . Ha1-16on e e a<l>4>eKTMB
Bap1<1aHT 1<1 RBJlReTCR Hai-111YYW1<1M AJ1R paCCMaTp1<1BaeMOro 06beKTa.
YYI-1TbiBaR,
OC06eHHOCTI-1
OLJ,eHHBaeMOrO
06beKTa,
CYI-1TaeM,
YTO
llyYWHM
H
HaHOO ee
3<j><j>eKT1<1BHbiM 1<1CnOI1b30BaHI-1eM 06beKTa RBJlReTCR era TeKyw,ee Ha3HaYeH!-1e .
© 2011 TOO «L.IeHTP no ou,eHKe 11 HennaTe>KaM «3,Qeenopl1M KyHracalim, reHepanbHaR rocy.QapcTeeHHaR Jll11..1eH3l1R
perltlcTpai..IIIIOHHbllil N2 IOJl-0092-(27332-1910-TOO OT 15.02.2002r.
.~l3
f (J
~- UP
9
OT'leT N!! 178/2 o6 OL\eHKe Tponnei:i6yca nacca>Kio1pcKoro «Ka3axcra H» 3TC-398, 11AeHrH<j>HKal\110HHbiH HOMep N!!00044
rnaBa
3.
Pac'feT CTOHMOCTH 06beKTa OU,eHKH
3.1. OnpeiJeneHue cmouMocmu o6beKma oqeHKU s paMKax 3ampamHozo noiJxoiJa
AflR paCYeTa CTOIAMOCTIA 060PYAOB3Hit1R OU,eHW,IAKOM npiAHRTa nepBOH3"131lbH3R CTOIAMOCTb
rponnei16yca cornacHo npeAOCTasneHHOMY 3aKa3Yit1KOM AKTY nplt1eMa-nepeAaYit1 or 25.03 .2011 r. 3a
BbiYeTOM lt13HOCa.
<f>lt131t1YeCKOe COCTORHIAe 06beKT3 OU,eHI-183/lOCb nOC/le ero OCMOTpa 1t1 Ha OCHOB3Hit11t1 CBeAeHI-1i1,
nollyYeHHbiX OT BllaAellbU,a . 0npeAefleHit1e <f>1t131-1YeCKOrO lt13HOCa IAMyW,eCTBa npOBOAIAilOCb 3KCnepTHbiM
nyreM.
AflR
o6ecneYeHit1R
cneU,It13/llt1CT3Mit1
lt1
eAIAHOrO
CHIA}f{eHIAR
nOAXOAa
BlliARHIAR
K
OU,eHKe
TeXHIAYeCKOro
cy6beKTI-1BHOCTit1
AJlfl
COCTORHIAR
OLJ,eHKIA
pa31llt1"1Hb1Ml-1
COCTORHIAR
(1t13HOCa )
OCMaTpiABaeMbiX 06beKTOB lt1CnO/lb30B3/13Cb Ta6Jllt1U,a, o6pa3eU, KOTOpoi1 npeACT3B/1eH Hlo1}f{e .
WKana onpeiJeneHUR cf1u3ullecKozo U3Hoca
Ta61llt1U,a 2 .
CocroRHHe
o6opyAOB3HHfl
XapaKTepHCTHKa ~H3H'feCKOrO COCTORHHfl
Ko3~ .
KOATex.
COCTOfiHHfl
H3HOCa,
%
Hosoe, ycraHosneHHoe 1t1 ew,e He
Hosoe
3KCnllyaTI-1pOBaBweeCR 060PYAOB3Hit1e B OT/liA"'HOM
A
5
B
17
c
33
D
50
E
67
F
83
COCTORHIAIA
6biBWee B 3KCnnyaTaU,It11t1 060PYAOB3Hit1e, nOilHOCTbiO
OTpeMOHT1t1pOB3HHOe 1-1/11!1 peKOHCTpylt1pOB3HHOe, B
OYeHb xopowee
OTJliA"'HOM COCTORHIAIA.
6biBWee B 3KCnnyaraU,It11t1 o6opyAOB3Hit1e, nO/lHOCTbiO
OTpeMOHT1-1pOB3HHOe lt1/llt1 peKOHCTpylt1pOB3HHOe, B
Xopowee
XOpOWeM COCTORHI-11!1
6b1Bwee B 3KcnnyaraU,l-11t1 o6opyAOBaHit1e, rpe6y10w,ee
YAosnersopiATellbHOe
HeKoroporo peMOHTa HillA 3aMeHbl OTAellbHbiX MellKIAX
yacrei1 raKIAX, KaK nOAWIAnHIAKIA, BKI13Ab1Wit1 1t1 AP·
6biBWee B 3KCnnyaTaU,l-11t1 060PYAOB3Hit1e B COCTORHIAIA,
npiArDAHOM
YcnoBHO npiArOAHOe
AJlR A31lbHei1wei1
3KCnnyaraU,It11t1, HO
rpe6yiOW,ee 3H3"11t1Te/1bHOrD peMOHTa IA/11!1 33MeHbl
rnaBHbiX Yacrei1, raKIAX, KaK ABIArarenb,
i-1
APYriAX
orsercrseHHbiX y311os
6b1Bwee s 3Kcnnyarau,l-11A o6opyAoBaHit1e, rpe6y10w,ee
HeyAosnersopHTellbHOe
K3nlt1T3/lbHOrD peMOHTa, T3KOrO, K3K 33MeHa pa60 YI-1X
opraHOB OCHOBHbiX arperaTOB
060PYAOB3Hit1e, B OTHOWeHIAIA KOTOpOrO HeT pa3yM HbiX
HenpiArDAHOe K
nepcneKTIAB Ha npOA3}f{y, KpOMe K3K no CTOIAMOCTI-1
nplt1MeHeHit110 lt1/11t1/10M
OCHOBHbiX MaTep1t13/lOB, KOTOpble MO}f{HO 1!13 Hero
G
lt13BileYb
PacYeT
<f>yHKU,IAOHallbHOro
lt13Hoca
npoBOAIAilCR
MeTOAOM
3Kcnepr1t13bl
<I>YHKU,l-10Ha/lb
COCTORHIAR, npOBeAeHHOi1 TeXHIAYeCKIAMIA cneU,l-13/ll-1CT3Mit1 KOMn3Hit11t1 no WKalle, npeACTa B/leHHO -
B
ra6n1t1u,e Hlt1}f{e .
WKana onpeiJeneHuR cfJYHKquoHaJJ&Hozo U3Hoca iJsuHCuMozo uMytt4ecmsa
no MemoiJy 3Kcnepmu3bt cocmoRHUR
Ta6111AU,a
CocroRHHe
XapaKTepHCTHKa ~H3H'fecKoro cocroRHHR
o6opyAOB3HHfl
3.
KOA~YHK.
Ko3~.
H3HOCa
H3HOCa,%
A
0
Coorsercrsyer nyYWIAM MIApOBbiM o6pa3u,aM,
Ha yposHe nyYWIAX
MIApOBbiX CT3HA3PTOB
BnO/lHe Bnl-1CbiBaeTCR B COBpeMeHHbli1
rexHonorlt1YeCKIAi1 npou,ecc
© 2011 TOO «L..IeHTP no OL.\eHKe 111 HennaTe>KaM «3ABellOpi!IM KyHracal:l», reHepa11bH8R rocyAapcreeHHaR nl!ll.leH31!1R
periiiCTP841110HHbll:l N2 IOn-0092-(27332-1910-TOO OT 15.02.2002r.
OTYeT No- 178/2 o6 01..\eHKe Tponne~6yca nacca>t<11pcKoro «Ka3axcraH» 3TC-398, 11AeHTI14>11KaU,110HHbl~ HOMep NoQQ044
COCTORHHe
XapaKTepHCTHKa ~H3H'4eCKOrO COCTORHHR
o6opyAOB3HHR
KOA~YHK.
Koa~.
H3HOCa
H3HOCa,%
B
5
c
15
D
40
E
75
BnonHe KOHKypeHTHO cnoco6Ho, OAHaKo HMetOTCR
o6pa3'-'bl, llYliWHe no BTopocreneHHbiM napaMeTpaM.
BnonHe
KOHKypeHTOCnOC06HO
lt1CnO/lb3YIOTCR B COCTaBe Ae~CTBYIOW,e~
TeXHO/lOrHlleCKO~ '-'enOliKIA, XOTR He3Halllt1Te/lbHO
ycrapeswe~
KoHKypeHTocnoco6Ho, OAHaKo HMetOTCR o6pa3'-'bl,
KoHKypeHTocnoco6Ho
He3HaliHTellbHO llYliWIAe no OCHOBHbiM napaMeTpaM.
lt1cnOI1b3YIOTCR B COCTaBe Ae~CTBYIOW,e~
TeXHO/lOrHlleCKO~ '-'enOl!Ke, XOTR ycrapeswe~
HeKOHKypeHTocnoco6Ho, 3HaliHTellbHO ycrynaeT
11YliWI-1M o6pa3'-'aM no OCHOBHbiM napaMeTpaM
He
KOHKypeHTOCnOC06HO
(noliTI-1 s
2
pa3a). lt1cnonb3YIOTCR s cocrase
Ae~CTBYIOW,e~ TeXHOI10rl-1lleCKO~ '-'enOliKe, XOTR
ycrapeswe~
Eie3HaAe>+<HO HeKOHKypeHTOCnOC06HO, CHRTO C
np01-13BOACTBa. Bo BCeX OTHOWeHIARX npOIArpbiBaeT
Eie3HaAe>+<HO ycrapeno
aHanoraM. He Bni-1CbiBaeTCR B Ae~CTBYIOW,I-1~
TeXHO/lOrlo1lleCKI-1~ npo'-'eCC (HO RBJlReTCR
He06XOAIAMbiM B paMKaX HcnO/lb3YeMO~
TeXHO/lOrl-11-1)
Pac1.1eT CTOI-1MOCTI-1 o'-'eH!-1BaeMoro o6beKTa npeACTasneH s Ta6111-1'-'e
HaHMeHoBaHHe
o6beKTa
TponneH6yc
3TC-398
4.
N!!
roA
BblnVCKa
nepBOHall3/lbH3R
CTOHMOCTb
CpoK
3KCJ1/1, 1
neT
<I»H3.
H3HOC1
%
Cl»yHK.
H3HOC1
%
HaKonn.
H3HOC1
%
00044
2003
15 000 500
8,83
90%
15%
92%
VIAeHT.
PbiHOliH3R
CTOHMOCTb,
TeHre
PblHOliHaR
CTOHMOCTb1
AOIIII. CWA
1275 043
8 564
TaKHM o6pa30M, CTOHMOCTb 06beKTa 04eHKH, onpeAeneHH3R B paMK3X 33TpaTHOrO nOAXOAa,
COCTaBnReT
1 275 043
TeHre H/lH
8 564
AO/lllapa CWA.
© 2011 TOO «L...IeHTP no 04eHKe 11 Hennare>KaM «3,Qeenopi1M KyHraca~». reHepanbHaR rocy,QapCTBeHHaR nH4eH311R
perHCTpa4110HHbl~ N2 !On-0092-(27332-191 0-TOO OT 15.02.2002r.
O"NeT N!l 178/2 o6 ou,eHKe Tp01111ei16yca nacca>t<HpcKoro «Ka3axcraH >> 3TC-398, H AeHTH4l~o~Kau,~o~oHHbli1 HOMep N!l00044
3AKJ110liEHHE 06 0'-'EHKE
BepORTHaR pb1H04HaR CTOI-1MOCTb 06beKTa 04eHKI-1, no COCTORHI-110 Ha
«07»
lo110HR
2012
rDAa, C
yYeTOM OKpyrneHio1ii, COCTaBilReT:
1 275 000 (o;JuH MunnuoH aaecmu ceM&aecRm nRm& m&ICR'I} meHze unu 8 600 (aoceM& m&ICR'I
wecm&comJ aonnapoa CWA no Kypcv H6 PK (1$- 148,89} Ha aamy npoae;JeHuR oueHKU.
HToroBaR Belllo141-1Ha CTOI-1MOCTI-1 06beKTa 04eHKI-1, yKa3aHHaR B OT4eTe 06 04eHKe, MO>KeT 6b1Tb
np1-13HaHa peKOMeHAYeMOii AflR 4e11eii COBepweHio1R CAellKI-1 C 06beKTaMI-1 04eHKI-1, eC/11-1 OT AaTbl
cocrasneHI-1R
oTYeTa
o6 04eHKe AO AaTbl
cosepweHI-1R
npeAcrasneHI-1R ny6ni-14HOii o<j>epTbl npowno He
AHpeKTop/01..\eHW.HK:
(rocyA3PCTBeHH3R nHL\eH3HR
Cl>n-01583 N20131825 OT 01.07.2009
c
o6beKTOM 04eHKI-1
cas4eHKo
1-1111-1 AaTbl
o.n.
r.)
01..\eHW.HK:
(rocyA3PCTBeHH3R nHL\eH3HR
ca>n-00623 N!!0000577 oT 14.05.2004 r.)
AccHCTeHT OL\eHW.HKa:
CAellKI-1
6onee
MblnTbll(6aii H.~-
AcKap O.n.
© 2011 TOO «WeHTP no o~eHKe 11 Hennare>KaM «3Aeenopi1M KyHraca~». reHepanbHaR rocyAapcreeHHaR Jllll~eH3111R
perliiCTpa~liiOHHbl~ N2 IOJl-0092-(27332-191 0-TOO OT 15.02.2002r.
Crp. 121113 13
OTYeT NQ 178/2 o6 ou,eHKe Tponnei.16yca nacca>tH1pCKoro «Ka3a xcraH» 3 C-398, HAeHTH<j>HKaU,HOHHbli.1 HOMep NQ00044
© 2011 TOO «L(eHTp no Ol..leHKe 1-1 HennaTe>KaM «3ABenopV1M KyHracalil»,
perV1CTpal..lV10HHbllil N2 IOn-0092-(27332-191 0-TOO OT 15.02.2002r.
reHepanbHa~ rocyAapCTBeHHa~ nV11..leH3V1~
~-
.., ., " "' .'·:.'·"'· -"'·.
r;;;:·"··r
l{;(e~l!.tl,e
t.OQt011t-~'11<l,
,~e4!>eK'I'O>n/ nqe"'l,\l"""eH~~
. .
.. ......
II ne-t ·~J:!a'l!~iti;;e~;tt~~
~~p~:~t;--p;;owilu nv~.artrzt! ,;eflr.>tJ{.)t!-;1;;,~~:(~~~
:11-----------.·-~
- tJ¢.11;1~My< miG-CiJ:t.;fi!Pi:~~l'i :;.· · ,:,:,.~!'1-li
HM i'l'l"ii!
! P<l1fJ~t(J!;''ti}Jl.t\l:} W,'l lj;.l'Q~jO~ ,o,i(j<!f,t.~. H~T ~l,l~r1NO ~•f\I'N'H'•pa, t>l,.CC
!
,
r'O iliCXJ'Ioiti'IJI., t>Vll\l;<tt>~fl >Hl'lOt
I
~t. CJ:I eJi(:t;.IC~f.!>ttl!t<!i!•~~t;J~·• fJ'MI'!Ctlt;;tm•O<~
! C~~'.,\l;~l'Xl~ >IC.~(i J<~'f
--~· ~er t•i!PiAH~t·.'-(j.,.._.!::',}
r¥~.-~.--~~l-J..;,o, l)~itca);.;-;IJ~; ,lx i>l~Qc;{;;·c't<n·;~._.f~ i~~t"JC
a~,i'IXC\'~!'1 », Z003 toAll Bt.tnycKii;,
.J.eHt~¢w;ka u,4l~'H~>r~l\1 flC:u.nu~ C\:104'!.
l f'J<tC1>iJ:41!tp¢KI1J i~eC~!1, J;!l'ifih,1'1t,t(t MZI!<tCN: <:anOH!l , 1/ HOrt\Yk!Lnl!'Ht!b'l €!
p:;).~·;;~'f5Y'n~CC;:iilkMPC~m
a"",\i'"'·"-flt!.
aJ.a~CTlllH>, 2003 i't!All Ot<li'P{'\'V.<l ,
tlt!>HTf.,$:HK~Ul1Q.~I'l
Te.PI
~~;'\~p
i (4JJ:>tmi1f, ~"'[l;flt'()"'>~I;/I~I I J>It>iit ii(ffl4'Jitu<i!\i'lh !1i1 ll<li'~Oit.p~1v.J •tn:Cfli0 nO~ti).bi TMil,
\.n/1b:tit>:il~ tl~ft\it;.~(.tt~,rtr~llii-C~t.r;w;> :Vl'!Ktpcnahera1co c.!l-DE< ro·ti . 1lF.H~I1"!il
;. 'lfolilH'::tiOipT'rliO,. tci>Mtt!:!tlt~ l"l.lil
-'<'~-"""'-'·'"'"'"·"""'_...,_.:,..J._,., ,,._.,, •>""'"-"""~"""•~"',.;i>·''i;,;:~:~~·j.<>"'·;,.i>~"<~·'--iMc"·:.:· ,;,,, ,.
~
·
1 ?.·u-o~m>tP~i l:>¢1i9filil,.;"rli!"''lil, H€'T liiOA•~T>;'l1it·P:*O.f'V ~pe.;;:.o;t, ,.M~H·~ ~
!
MltOMOO 00044
; i*;l~"lJ¢. !1~~fl¢~l;>\>~\?.tq,JJ,llt/lk<:fi}(lfhl!<:t/lT9, C: fi!~ !>H illfi i·~:H<O£ fi<JC, i'l<!i~f)<PJ1 ~
Kf}~tt'l,~·, :>Ciii.>'lti h\>l:i:i ~tHiOt:C~J!Oi;i;ll, MHQtO\.I#c!C/i~)fHt.l' riotJ~!i)O\.ll;t~!fiJiil
r lH!¥,PKiJ;Il~'QH~t!), llQK!)~IT~ill,
. c,l~;f;;r;;;·~-~~~a ·
,. {f)lt~.f!H'J . Hill
::-;-;;-;:rc:~a-·--·1~
' "'i!.!t
2!l 3 r~.oa iii-WI'i'(C1'1a,
~0!11!1).!1\tll t l'la!4,W13HH 1'1 '"OM.:ep 00\."416
C'' J UJQe (;{l~~:te~~n11<1H,Ii fpjl.li ,f!OI)t;tO<;
!'!ill il¢f~'l'
nep;,Q,Httt~ii~~~!}t¢ f.',.,.,;:;;;~ ~-;'f;e~.::;:;;~~~;;,,·:e; n~~Ar.t:>rc·
. ·I
6&,111'1t~pil, Ji!,fl'·OAMOH ,4!Jit'fHl, '~ t1J\ b!l~!l1 ;1\.}ly:).; n~:qf>Ci'; ~<t~K-1:>1 L!lMi f!t>l, rltrt'
i':a)~~ll;TitH -11,
i HwANilltti fi,ll,Ml'll~•'l, H ~llil!ll*~ $-llP,. "t1!1bHt.i\l. ll'iii"'OC »ii!Ct2:0·mp>:l1Ji,<
1 .•q:.<t:c,efl, Cf4'/lt:Mb.11il ~1$,H(l.; ca.•t:;r""a· ~~1Ho:ro"l. J1cnf!HHhlfi TiiO:OPlll-llilft!>'~lttt
j ll~I!:OI'if:;'ii'.O.>!Htlit~ fl{IJ~(:ltolt~fl, Jt1fl hll!bl~ 11~1')<1;1~ l.)l1f.4,!d'l t;tl · . h()ll;)
I M<tll!.~j.)Of'JI;;b'flil, tti).1' elOJl\f'l'IC:Jtt>•~Ftii o ''P~~,, f;p . ~ noa cc.6nuf'rHi~ott<.il.
""'' ~lf.P.:
J'l"~~ .. ..
·aw~
.; P'.".+.•.:~t.· Fi ~rre<iD8
...:;,-,.. n"~~... ~~~
· · ~ ·· "" ··
l'ta<!i\i!:«:T~H ~+.
K!itl~H
200!tt<>:At1 lfll!'I'IYt'<i!.U,.
,QEtt'tiHj:ll1 !t<ll.j)'!;O~ H l:ll~ ~C~Mil:tf)
i. tp,r;H<Cnopt>1~'tt£~!l(,!l,~~~ ~-Q13'~;~, " , . ,
.~,--.. -.
i H"t~ M~P.If.it"(~{~ ~~. ~t(tr .it 'll\7/.I;H~fl;:f ~JMl't~·Plii, jj4~0Htn t p•> QOlo!OO•biX
~€If
"\0
MOM~Oiit
01)04 l
l ~flJ'-"fi'J,tit~ih;tit!I~;~)<Qttl)littt, ><1i'ffl~i?~e~ .~Gep4i ,
; naC.{il;>m p CII+iX ~~~J\1 ~t
i
1'109 pe~·Hv.•r'.
IJ~Itt.t~l >t3~0<;
,ria . OKfJll\:~~(H~:.' fl tiKPt.H >1 :1!, .;;~/ll:otllrl ;'I » ~H0t
' !.H1Lii1letlb0!1;;Jf-'! -1!fl~l!'t!Jcy,rh;1>'i0t <l " t~' ~:,.1Q S
,_...,.......,..,....~--.,._----+j,l' . ,;.~.:; fi.:.'~:; ;¥$'; ;.¢.;,;!fi,;.;. ':~J ,;.'t2f:l"f "--,. ~·
p:;M:Si6~naiei~tl'{~l7! 31"C/S£#B
i!33J>t:'ta<HI, 20C!iHO,tJ,i'f Gbtrw~:!i,a,
·
· ·--···.- "".,.,,...• ··
---
ttil.Q-.Yt:iit
-__ :-~.'m.c.;;,;:,.>w·:.>·n,_,,"?".1".'·"-·A'"""..,...~ .
......,.,,,.,...""".~~:·:......-~~~-.·,
-r;wtnetf6'f(: ~att!l')l(!f~C~tl'll1- ~·H::-::1~
Sl;jYX(:T~li:t,~, ~QO$ ~A~' 8~1"-vtK.,~.
;.'l.:i:"flt~~i'lKi:tUt1tli!'lril#'~ !10Me~ 0004~
..
_
-·--·--~""'"'~~""··~·~'·""'"Y"~
H r ·n~p$A;H' X-~!1 , ptl!iwrt~ Cf!l'.IIJJ~' !O!;l) .it~;s·v• e'ti ,t~tJerM , pa )ttnl r,; J,:'!ll."""'
hl~t f.li .· ~~i .~1)~! .. ~· Jt~H;tlr,; 1'1<li;:~Mt.fil..PC:~¥lll. KP'tlte:n;•. CWlW!;.li~l II ~Hqt
C~i!O~if. :r.:;,·if:~l'QN_,t~J1,.e;~~~~~~i htrtlpE*Ae'H'I'H! t'iai<c;;tp~ro~HOfJ::l tiCtlf!}l>i rww .
1).!11
! c-.;nm~~>H1>t~rttli: O.O,>f! 'lllttkdfo Ji.'l~t;;JClfl;.lf~lttiJ, O::IJ '!l.Oiif <:.;;!Jt..f~·?M ;;t>'' "~
J.J£~!$,11(1 'TW~ ~· ~~~~0 ttfj_Hil !S~~---'~·-~·~. ·~~····
~~~).(>.%~C';~:"!<c""''.-t.
-·fl'Oil.l'i !2>i!J•rt 11iiCPi>a.i!IIPCk~i~ :3H::- 3-~fl
>:!r ne""~,;!\H'fl'ro· a'Mi'l~li, it!H MptiJ.tt'\N 0 ~l'}ili!iJfQ J('$)11,~h'W, >~fl'l
'
' 'W,t),li~ttl 0d;\tf'l!ipu,1 fi ., lHUJ,.Vi l ~fl't,\;1.\~f it!JI}((l.ft, CU"~I;<H~i¥ 11:;tMOt
K<~Jiii>~t'l' aH r,, ~tv03 ~a.a'~>t:r.'{tt-:.a,
lil,~'H 11~1!1ii'i1U;Ii0!1t*l.lH ft{!JIWJ;
'.Qi5-t:r'SE'·..,r.n'!l.3 TP,,O,..C'lO,:<Tl1t;;•e
to C!\Qll c.:l!fictue~H~\"a rp~tH~flof'Tt tOu <:P.t;Ul.f 1~0 ~•e 11.:1 ~o;t,, 4:1'rcv•nFN)(.lT
,II
'tl~¥1h't~li,~~Jii.10:11"fl!li1 !i.OM~P C<lP~Bi
Clffli!ll'll>liii i1 3HOt
CMO:H<i, .¥.HGf¢'>Ji1{cJI'l'Hr•u;N
t'JC¥J.t1~tfei{OfQ'Meliir~njk~T <), f.:H!Jt;.H!)h\'1 Jll:iiHOC nact/ii'!-l:tlf.l'~KM~ .;;pe ¢-tY1,
00$0
£;1111.1;.Hbt~ f13~Ci<; C:a, O:fji'!, f,,,.(l;{;,o,.HOte'I.HIJ,l() f1f;l,l,tfJ~ l llt:'l"'li"'Jit
' ,•tlJ itl:il<~!:tl"'i~Clf'? f!QRP~It¥11'1, \,{I 4:J•0111 \.IJ~CT!f}11:"H l1 Htfi> rpr,Hcnor:n:,.oat
___
;;q;;;;i~Sv~~~~
':'~~~"l;~ ~'i~.'iss
.
'
.
1\,a,~lil!.'tY\i!H "··, iOOl fOA.~ ~it111'(C!!.il,
:
, ,4l!!,..n1$Jt Kill.I)'Hi.l!;!.ti~lY. ~l)Mii'P o~> 1
po:111~6yc na:'Cc;;;~p'(;~·r~tt-Sg,s
~ ,a3a>:~!i!i»,, .4003 {¢44i tlulrty<.:~~;l!!,
HA>frHtil!;¢%tt~lJU.~OJIHblYt HG•Me~ 00~2
i
q;e~Jl,¢1fkt:t111Ht.a ,.¢~
1 Ht.'l f!~S)~'Iii(O .ti~Mrtil'p~, ·~H:~;.;b;~~;~H$\, .l;;,IJ.>;•H> ..U~H,
~sr ;;a;QHero
{i(;IMM\l'p~;.'~ii1~~l1hl~'ht31<0t!; n;rr;-ca.ik~ttpc~<lil:>: f!ipe~Jl 1jt'f1J'it.-H!ili'l i'i:l!i'IO<'
; {;<ll,'!Qtl~ . M!!!Ct!Q!i.!:\(~;!ifliilll\' flOUp!i!ifiAi:l'H~HI liiH!;{li>;j:l.i!Lt~~H CHI.) tlUKP~H M',
.
! (11/'i~Hld~ 1.1'ltlO( ~;!);fft-tMb~'JI/,;1! U i!I IJ!l'i~'t!J{lnfii!·C f~, ~ Q !J.)'ft l>v!}nJ?en!i•'1K"'
P~Ef1E.F:ct~~~.£Jt{'A~'f~o l41t IM ·~~.~~w,
. . . . _--~· -· . -~-- .
,..tI .
I
l?lli:E!PE!'AH!!!t/!:ll'~&olil.i ~tlpt.tl, l'ii?Jl' il .l,i'l"'l!rO g,;j<l,f1t'P~ . ( ~<llln ti'~ \>i HOC.
P4Ml!itt·t.t:·~$)rO .ll/!.M'fPG'f!tlNer'(<.,. J;t.tll~lnt.Ji-11i13~ottlc n:atce.~~tupCtt'»lo. pecen..
! (Wt:>1t>,kj.i'(1l1.~H0t; C~/1¢~;~,, MHOf"tl'.ili';C:Iili?HHtil(,t .J'lC!l~"l~t}C••>M
I Jta~>~Ci'~S-P3C!Q4if'? ro rtW!pbiftlfll,, .::.~ MO:U oo6en)/J?i1~1''~"1 l fh l•iet\O?THilf'
_'"""'__, __,,.~.·- ~ ~··· .. ". . ·~-- ~---..~ ..___j_tpL\tt_nv.t) ",e -'t!~ ~t:>AY·
W.t itMI!.»'~O.Ifam1~ a5'1:!C:I<ttt
· ··:~.<¥1'r~~·7'«'""'-""-'IW'~-""' · --''41-~~"-"'"'~~·- ""-y""~-r-e•
Tportlitt:i&;c~i'iuec~~~f'J·~~~~<~i1 arc 3>98
H.,l;1iJ;\'('' t\ !1 lt 1 1003 fQ,P~ l!i>>fl 'fCII.'i,
tl,!li!'!~tl1~11~~ff OI'I'Hbl~ . t<C.M;t:'f}. (10!\.3
j
! 11
<iO<C.~{!A,\'111e<Jf~~>I$'Ptl :;tlfetlTPOn;;!l'!>e'fa, CO' CI)OB t.:~tlC:T!3~ H!H1V.cl
-~~~~--~-~~._,_~~~~·- -J.l' art~~ttt£1:~.£e~p~~~~.~?~~ .
Tpolw~crl{t n1l~t.:ilJtti'lp{:l\~l1 ~T( · 398
j'
•1,Ctt!;~<~ T>i$>rH.i!UY,Oil!HhiV l'!O.rhep
! l1G•q)l:!ffi1:~,.
K.~il~lM:To;~>l"", ~OOl tM.•) ~~n~·( 114,
·1
,.A···_.,._,...
-.--
H~n n<-v~A<t~~~.tli~~p,a" w;r nl!l~t:~fl,t:i!f~X ¢lap. pa;>ti¥lTbt sa""H)!JE! ¢lap ,
~ >_ ;,:; :'_· .. ::;;'/ : ~--- : ., : .
.
.. .
.
.~
Cl<lJ1!:>H~l ~il:l,!;l!!;'i~~~ait\l<l,pit.!!M,<; f'l~€!~11, Cl'l!t!:d1to1'r, ~u .. ct ~<1/lt.'lli<l ,.
,\tt<O!Oc~l;&ii.!!Jiltli;!ii f106~l+lAIJ~t1•1 ·1Jl!{<liif.P~!~O·•I·!1C'f~ ~>•.;f;•t~clht~l. '"';1tt~i;iW
. . ~----·~
.
Hi:.·~. .· .'1e,Z,.t!AJ1i'll ¢tap, i;J'l;lhti.<:>lii.·· !'1.'.~. ·\iO>C nat; .a~t'P!"" · !ip.ec~.n >:~>1.~ht'!t;Ji/!
tt~\iO>C ~~:~.~QHJL .v. ~;oro~•1c.1>:tlt-<I.>Hi!..:;em pt~!i¥1;!?H ri'R .~~<.c;;po,;c.-....H~r::•
CHI!bHI.tf.i 111:jtl()t OO.lli~ll!lt!.1{:J<(I <O' $ft(,''IJ(l )Q{l\)" t,l, !<<It!
IJ\)SA
~<JIDHIJ/lel.;it!Qttl .~J:.t(lr;:n~, J}ITJt}n r¢ 1;3,~ 11'*' , .1t;>t<JIQ, HPr 3a~~ r>ro &at.~nE>pa ,
.~.....,....,.,.,.-::-=-:-:--::-::----_,.-+c;;;;,.o::..·.;;;':.;.;
f!'t:;rt~=-.:;:o:.:~o.::~';:;;.n..::,t
c
·e:;;.;d1q;.·.t~,..,~~;,:.-lliito:l
· -;d·s:.·~~~~~.e.~a~~!l~~,~!. J(OA"~ . ,
TpQ'jf~';i~~tt.a.;:e,a}Kftptl!':W:fi 3TC ·39:5
!'htf t!t1tJ~t:l.~,~fO:~<lt\V~C~l, p;llfhlii<l f:i~€'Att1Hl: llP.,fl.ii51 .~p;;, p.a D1fril<
W:;.naxtt:!J!'l.w, 2003 tOthl Bt•trJVt»·'.
t'lepr:.nf1et> !l?6'<'tJ~~t ·liT$111'UO, ~e.;!) rc :)3ID'lt?e c eH1 c MEr ~2,l!H.er<'
1 A!.ltt'ft.t'ijHti~;UU,M~i'fuiVi Fittr~>~:p. 0•;·:~5
UiJ \•<H? f.hl. !Ji'(l~\Htl ~;;\'!itt!" '*i'O~t•L tUll1hf'tli1 tHHtl< nd ttilJt'. ~lPt'i:«~.
!lf)!ft{.e!1, \·M!ihnt>l;i·l't~""~.;.jill('H'\<1, •\' HGr>::r•~;N:ttl!'iiHI;>Hi! nC·Ji pe,;;.Al!'H'<'P
nal';q~paco••Koro
OO'i'!*'WmM, tl!1.,t;HwJ1 •1Jl!l!.!:lt I,Jo,:i,l'lt'l:l.t.'t;Cl'lor<O
JJ~l.'ltf0 (J i1'ii •O:Ii't4, .'.:QC!lQEi' C000(l,ehHI~Kii Tp;71h C!'H:lf;'l'lHQf' i::jlf>;iilt:T'SO Hi'~;;
~0,..,1,\1 ;
Tp.;;;.rt~tlff.(t~,.~,a-c~c.:a-·,-.--»--7"""'--:---~----+-!i:"'"·~:;:; :•r:...t""H.-,f.t•. .. 'A-.t""1c_#_o-""··tj':'"~-M-A-!e""p-~~; ~;·;-;;p~p,;;; :i;-p;;;6tnQ ;;~ ·~A~"e
Ka3.;,;~ct9'!1>~, 200:1 t¢A<l (lt.lfl'¥i:t(<J,
~•4t!Hl~¢l'i1Kfli.41Ci<!l(bi fil li ~Mol!~ 0Ci55
- .... - -..-· . . -.- __ _
__ _ __ _
___
, _ -¥""":':'.........,._..:.,.__
PQ:ttJilii~O'(C Fl~l!:~i,iilil1 p~tmif ~i\ ·3S/S
" f\~:ta.~cr:Pil•, :!004
crtrn.t.rv, M.t'l A-1\l'tPi'!-.J ~1J0~lt<• 'ltlW"e ~·~~·, ;.reT ?~H;;-rq .'$a.MnilJ;~B,
(.~IJ{!~ . ~ tl i>!i91;:; r15f\::i;oilii!I~PCI>\Hl! I<P~t!ll , ¢1t.1~H~.>~il! ~HWot.C>J.rtO · ~,
f•IHOfl;lil:.t~,Tht¥H~hl~ •t'ltillpe-WA,.~H"'~ JHtRi::l'l\$}l.4t¢'1~0FO tloltpt;!h•IO, 11~t
OO,Ll,i;.ft!!lt'b~~titri:V~p~ri~, ·~~,Qbl~t!lH JtiHtU~ lj(;,.\frH~Ilt>(H,)fQ
i
I ,Mit!ltp{lf!r,.rt(l fif. to ~~.il '<;>fu;1$a~H·~1l':a "l'pa:tu::m:l'pt¥-oe· C¥>€.U.C'~''!ltl .,.,e 11<1
,L~...- - ·-.,. .......,."'L~~t1;tl~--'>'->o.i~~~~~~~'!>M<.~,..,,....__
. r'a'i&i-iY~ !lili\P (W,HI.* '~Ji/IC,
.
~a,a,;;.<eto fi<'!hftH!f.lil., C~1l1bl'l·llliii MHoc. !l<~>rc.,tlf•.l'ltlCrtm
, v,.)>!tl' t;;.i;!/lt}.Ho;,
~
-~
!1~1ll~fi1,q,~Hbl~O '*H
f tQ>;;f}t>•'I'Hlil, !'fel !5Q,!l,t1Teflt>t;;H.Of0 !<j:lf!(IJ,ii, CO C-110.!! co6tTI}OI"nl'1•'iil
.
-
~:r·c.~~~i·""'·-1 ~---··r-""""""~
.
'
-'
-
· ··
...,..,...,.._~ ~·~
! 1-ilt,~t: tlf>~rr~~<>j:l'OIUU~1>Ht
1f;'""'~~ei~~~;~. ~¥.11~· _, 1I~l98
E!T
BLHl '~!hi,
hpecen, C!<l.ryt.l'ltttli
NI"'0%1J'~>1C$l'f:l .. H .~If! l'lOElPI?J.;\,QO!Hl!A .~ flKO Kp~ tC'~"!OfO
~ J'$ HCn~ T'riQ t~~tll'iS HI} t<\1)~'1,
,
'~~ ~~.J:Ji.l:~:ctatHl, 7:00'4 tOilla·l!i.liti11'Ci!la,
~~e~ri<i$Mta• H.il!'f 1'\bil\ .oM~P ot'i l.S
~ti;.;J.;li:li"CT~lHJf, 2Q04· t0,Q
i'h?p~A;i!i!til 6i!Mf11,t~la, Hil't ~· t.';.JC'J.I;t1~t.
¢>.~p. ptt~~Pf1Tl:>l ertr.~tlti Kit !<~AI'l"f"'. ,;~.u.ej2\!lx, ~.;HCH a,; . hl.tJ.•·JMI! ~l>l01J• <<O J,
ri>Aa "'"'l'li 'f~·(a.
~~..u.~~•l'lll$l'l~i'I!J.t,Qt~.Hbl~ HnM;rp l.lt\11
~o.~~~a;;·en~"~~~~pel¢w~
_.,:, ,-,.~.....,...""':"""'"-~-""--·-~,.,.,o-~__'-:·--·
H¥1'
·' ~~ ····~·· ·-~·-- ·~---
QQ ,c,qQ$
-~:p;5,cTe~H~H~Ka wpai>i'l;ITP!'-rHoe
·I er.trAI:f6'P He:'t~ihi:Q.4\f.
. ' Ht' r nt.i d~AH>f. ¢!.3:ji, t#il~'Hu~~ l<lj~~t;;;;;;;,~~~"
,;:pe-e;; c~~1tt~r~t.·ll1
•w~Jeu .
t"' ~i~J,.,f'l') f)(i?
H MPP<l
-rO';;;w~"'ieti!;II(,M~c ,
ll~ii\3$XCT3 H », 200~
P.Af3 l£~1'11/CK~:,
U.O,~Hn!.tjl~ l!a~~(l, H1.1f H "MIZt:l.o'OS(j
P'l:IJ1fte~~~;,~;pr,t~~a~f3;·r:.s~ts
v~a~a~cr-3~i),
zoo~
ro,Ajl at.Jnyt·JJ:a,
UA{!'HTW~lki.ii,J,!'!C>H!litifl1 1'101;'@~ OOSl
h:p~"e!.l'(, <;;VIJ'- 1;/H'li!Jii t1i!HJ;i\': ~,1$!-l.a, 'WtH\?f>OI:.!i<tt::li!J~,rJW.tfiOWp<'~'~'N "''
f!;ltc~O. pat.i:J'lHCt'O li\l>it!)t.tt\<llt, t:o.t/!tiKb\~ ~Q~(I(' 00,\'tfi'NMt•<'H(If CI
!H!NT~OfHl~t':!fJt H~tniJ,OI'dil'O GaMm~pa:, pa3f1HThJ ~MWI? ¢'aptot, pa,3611to
l1~>• •e ere"!/.!{l,
-4-·---·
·
i
lpoa,"~I;J~uy~ r;t~cel!!~~tnc"f'~
:nc-J:~s
CO CflOtli CQ~\:T'!l?H!'iM'.W.<! T~it H >::n<;~p HOI? C'(Jl!',QC'TgCJ H(fr. 11<il
! ~. c•,o: ..
~n
~·-~··~1'~'<'-·--~<,~<''~'<·~W
,.,;;: . ,
;~'. ~":··
: ·.
.rre ,~AHl-lx .p.~p, 2141l.~:;H~t\~ tm·16t-
•
•
·
~--.,·-~-·-
' pe~61i1
l rt llteit.•~<;vi~CM:< trJ:Jt!<i.e!t, •(Htlbihli·~ l~:fHQC '?II OHa, M""O!C"' 1t.~e~ HW.i
I ~o ~;)I.'»<A1:••H 'I ll,;ti<Qt~:piiCQ4HOrc no~;~1n1::L >:HJlbHflt'i\ .r\1 or
·
-"4
, J~·w ttiliiliJ.
1d(ill<(>~<;T1Ht'u, ~:(l(J,q rQ.!l;a !li>I11'(C"i<l,
4W:jt0.1,
H_f''f l~At l~
'
lliH. p~,.n~~r
•fU!;t:H1H4'1t!!il~10Htt!>H11'!\0M.&p D082
,
t>l ~t!A.H!1e
·~,
0 6 Mfl~p.;l , 'C~I ti~H ttl
fj
110t
i !lOAH-re,t.C-\!.)('.71 3.~2<1\tpO<Tli\KI!fil, CO< tii:tll:l 'C<Q:l:f'BI.!~« H1 ..;i!lihtMC
I
.,;···-"~_ _Lg;I,~~!!J.g~ :~:0/tY·
.
.
O!i''!'HO
,~
.,
$
---"'t-· - ---,..--·~
r'DC,
~~'e.'"'p---;..--
1/ !:p•••;;;;; ..., ot~ ''".·~TP0,'11&k.l.?tc,Lt"wo;~o5~tb•2..h>~·;;a rp.a... cnt~p~•~Oti'
~
kl-oVfn~r.::a1K\1Pe:;;,, :l1C·3'98
,att~. 200.4 ro .ii l9*r~yc,..,t,
11q!tt H>ll~~~ Ol>Hi!t!1tli H<OIIt!rp tl~:tt
··el'io~ tailcC;;1P!:ll:,~ 3TC 3'08
ll llH~. i(}IJ4 ro;!l.tllit.my~"a,
I'! ,
11ii!a~~~tli-HtL.ti! ;Chlt'-f;,p GCiM
ll
~·it
:>.QA'f•
~
N
,_ _ _ _ .......,.
~....-.-..,!'.:.~
'1r..'1 l'lt'(ffi',4,HI<l!;t · ~\!), l!:t'rT i1fi1Hi.',4~1 fo
41!1<: pt~• ., ,~p · ,el!/l, ;z:
. bH'III; '' rlOC
MIH·fl~ , n1Til>fi td:i •iflnOC
ca.rto.,.a. M or n ·~cD~H H~~~ •
noil!pJit~~~~~' :::~tB'()~~iiCo~HOfo no..;p I ·f:\)i; r.:•1f~ll>f19tii1: •t !JHO{
! ~ .. .cr. Hl!Jlt~~x6r · Jl£H , na..; 'foi, -ta c;;c toY.\<:rije,•t-n•~.cl Jl<) "ll"!
HOM>.!,:.;.., 1
- -- ~-1·~'~~~-~~\SJ~; '
-· ·~ ~-----· ~~-
F Hv
---- .
; :>s;ow :;Ji~~tf .e n~Mo, P•l ov ra 'acA~I:ii"l np .. 5.111 apa, Ht·• Ju;;. r:l
' 5aMt1titM, p a~01fTO ~11 ' t ~l.lt: np.:'l!!IC !J&M08C~ Cl"et<JJC. f:l<U0~1 .;> c-;: .• a IIJ
)
tii.J))M:; ... er nu¢-wil>i~:( !ffap, 01ftl>ll
~~ l'IJHOc. nac:nrur1f.C~<tu ~.pe(·
M.tit::HO"i~1tif~H tore noupt~••·JWH>l<~
llili\0 K;PaCO...HOrt1 ft0"'1i""TI1}{, l<j1 t,H l)i~ H.iH.:tt UOtl,•1T!J 1'. C!"iOfO
I '"'''t>•1
,
~-. ~ JKot ·~n
, Jiit!I;;TP'DO.ill'(!:! f.:i"
;1,
HJI,
-9 (:JiiO ·
ollt t& IJh H,to:a "'pu
-.----~L~Elt!it·
.. -~·- .· ""'... ~
i'O!~lSii il fl~#l' A,H-ae·ett>itiiO, ii>€'·T fi.I'IPf.l!l.lt"-111
t~ O~IttO~ CO!:.l rl\10 ,.f' r<;.
--·· . - -··
,lp, O<Homuf
OahOfl.ol?
t'fl!l(;1 , !Pil30VI !:rl ~~~~it ~il ,ll)!it=:.pR~. ~11flbt';;!-Ail U~HO
flii, (;rlllh~biil
•Hi!OC l'lni;l\:i;l~~(l Rn): ilj:fe~~ , C' }l tH-ibt:i M:fHti·C <,:,,IJ~ n ,i,
~'1~;c na~e~~p>e~~,» :H-e · ·98
'l XtftlH H<k 7/J~ t<JpfJ ll<L>'I n' (Kil,
tir~&t K~Ok!4urtl •i·~·,..,er~ OOSG
A.frt: lf'pa~ra-no:pc:~atrn
2 ·
«.~--,.....
·~
. •... ». o..· ~....;....._-20I l ron:
~
B aoor.s~imr
AcT~r.r:or 19 .'itHBap.a:
20i 1 WJlij·.. .'.1<2· . 31f~al,n. . {tO n~pe~l'tfe ~})O)IJle~6y®).l. ~ KOMM)IHfUthHOM
co6'e'f'Baaa:ocnru. mpo.]:(-a · A~bt B (CqM'. ·1fWfi)HytQ co6Cl'neHno.ctb Ceaepo-
KaaaxcTa~C!toii:
c noCT.alfo:an:esi!el·r
o6~>t
atx~MaJt
2/' ~mtapn 20ll . tp;at~ ~-. Jl .«0
eoo\rt'B~EUIOC"r'll ··aEI~,ata. rop·n,n;a
~uan~:a-m Ceeepo·K~~c.-ra;H:e:~o~·o~
·
.W IMa·r a ropo$l
·
' CTaHCKoli
.ii·~~ee\rl.la
o5tla~r or
H3 KGMMyll(t'\lllHOti
KOMM)'.iUUll'>HYlO coficrrneHHOCTll
': :· HwR:ena~uca.nuuteoJl a coc'Eftl3ie:
F~! «l'*t(ZQ:!m€HU£? (/ittJ.lancQ(J: . · i~{JP,Q (l · :JlClft~!f,a;Jl B . JlMUe :m~.~ecmren1t
nar.IaJl.~HTU\a .· Cyxo,~~a . ·J\~B:·~ ,· Bal!~fft~ ·OTJ!teJia paee1pa ¥t MORlfroptulrn
ri{W;.ell..~a t<oMJ.\~fi~'mh~Oa coti~~lttl~~~tll ~n:,p;uc5eKoua A.l{.~ r,nautforo
cnett«aJntcT~ p~~ct'pa H' ~{QIU~l#~J~:. ~6~,¢Jto~ .K.P~~fYl1W1"&Hcfif co6cweuHoc11r
.s. ;q.
' . . '": .... ,.
:'·-:;::' tie . izm:xf.a0(£.'U:: i!Jfft()'g,
m a.u. 'J(}; ' ma u
atttt< ·MOfftlftl:tP. ·hlt' -·~.(f.
s · Jnm;e Htt'UUffim~ orp,t:.n:a
opmmn~-(;}.tfHC}f;Q . .· ' .
:r{).·, n'pt!S~QK . TaM~tlaeaa..A.X.,. l1lr'ImHHlta
rt1rlBO.i0"'~~0HOMtNecKQi"O .~1"J{ena !(}ftlJl«l.B .E .f, ttpe,n:~a~. npae-n:effRst .AO
«i~C~~!(}} Bt:tPaEtEitma,W.J<., c .,f).atroD excrpo.qpt: H
r{Owc~, tjuwm~o'(l zoiZoi:kJ
TORTJ.;J6aeHa
·i7$' .
TJ.ef1Jt2f?t1(;~/JGBCI<:G.>~ .. B· lflUt~ HamtJll)J!n1t:, · ~W'OMO\SOlf< r.K.,,. .fY ..«0mo~
:(I;WiUU£itQ/:~O,\~'.:t)!Jtli,"t~,I'JQ~~ ¥,(}3{l-t'iCttr,:tpn . . ft~#(Ja~"?iitpO:H:QB_i) . . 11}{J<1FHJJ1fit2T!J(.l
__
-a11.ma o.fiU.Ji&JJ~ •·
:fl: f!NJ . 'tJ oda5. .
.·... . .
ac-~aJ~ B mlu;e :aattu:&a•ma
Xitfm~tea s~m.
~P,yfuif - ~pof~t QicymeeT:J~tma npHeM.. rt~peJJ:aTfy
·c·
:<rpo1l!n:e[ioycon.
'
.
J1i~
· .:.:.._.:~~~~~~
··· .:::.:ll:.!.:itt:=.df~
·~'Ca~
· ~e~._:M!;!!.
· ·~:. ~o~(1.!4a
rY
AcmaJfbUi
OemP¥:?1'tC!(f)tfJ8C1}a.»
<<0maen
@tmtlucoe
20po_t)a
Il . .
KriB3,tt B!CSO.l p
OKII 452231
I
-
....
nnuft
J.Cl·to-rneHHOcT~f<>
v.3.neJ...-:rpOTJl3nt..:- epBuc:"'
TorBcapu•u.ttcrno c
'
..-
qJ.tt:Ul'i
..
ipo1pnr rc-Cepro~c>>
Tnemo~;t; fi.K
'
~$'aJI.JIILHEYC IIACCA1Kl£P'C1GW
I
I
<d<A3~UCTAH>>
!
'J
I!\taHd 2'()0}
.
\
..
- ~ ~
.. ~
.
,,
J. 06m;:ne cs
Tp<)Jmei-i6yt 3'rC -398
~ 1nrn
'
o6 JO)lleJ'ln.:u:
.
{<Ka3
-
: :. :~ 5
CJaH». ttpeA'E{a:3Jia.l:J;·e a 1tru1
:swyrpHropo,;a;emx uepeno30K rraccaapoa: aa 1Jla.r.trle:H'6'ycmtx .roffl'!IDlX~ l ):·:
Tporore~6yc lJ .t<m:s:.Manrqe ;cot :ncn~einut pacie'(Jlrtaa ua-~I<cn:nya~FQ9 .
. upri Tl~~u-aepaTy-pax·m·p .. ~ammero l}Q3Jzyx1f0T }.IH:Hjc -.ttO~C ):{0 iTn:roc 'i10°C H ..
oTI!t}ca'temno:ii ero Im~qocm ~to SOo/o.npn ~woe.
Tpa.tute».6yc MmKc 3KCrt.rtya-rupomnic-'l H~ ~rpomre}:ifiycHl-!Jx .rn!l.ntJtx \c
ncmifinmoij
IJPOAOJIMH~ro )'K)!Q;8'a .rt6 1~{)~~~12,~),
'
'
Tp omre.f~6yc nac<CID!aipom-m src~ 398 ttl(~axckH''
l
'!
fhn r:a-c;rw,tn:eJTh
TOO ''3sLelcipowauo;.;CepatiH::''{
re</(/ .
l'
li!terrm<jmr.-an;nomu.rli HOMep '1Jl'!J)lt.!i!6yca '
3aBOJICKml. !IOMep TJtronoro 3lleKl'J)O.!O!l!T:;rrerur ,
;:;
z.
Cf1953.¥g ,
O<::fl;OB.Rblt 'fCXRlN'!!CKne .1!(3fJHbU.~ :u • rpak"TepuC'THJ\:11
l
24
11 ..
~~c~=];~~~·qr JL~ c~er.:
2.3 h-1acca c.l:ilapiDltet'IJIOro Tprimreii6yca, Kr.
1'~5~
1
ll
,
r
II
..
: I
il
I
¥-
l
3'rw9!~~voo
001' 't
.
f
nc
~·-.-:-/1_,..,-.- l ·f~ilo<.,..-,....._;-,....-..~
J
I!
;" I
1
.1 j
1
__l_!:--
Tl:;<) ":f_rwtn-prtf1W~!.~'Il.l';;. •
l
I ~·• ; ' • . . ;.-:·~ .•· -;
•
2.4 ra&pliTiD.JC. Pa:l~f·¢:pt>t TpOJmen- ca,. M~C
..,.
~m:a:
~e~· In:;pe:mn:u'\l om.nrcp · M: :n ~tcmnw;eii ·
Me~ 5a.Mllepo_Mff t'OJICHU«Ifi TOl'WIJ!Jlt.eMmma
.. n:mpaa
· '·
~1""
.. 13(hl0t)'I'a. ' '
+·t
it-
.~ i
'
•
11855
12250
2500
·
,
. ''
..
• :•
"
"200
•
2.s .Ivfzax-c}lMMbt,laH.:cll.~pd~~~~ijf.1J~ TpoMe~oyca,. KMJq:
..
-
npe,aeJ11JtJaJI ae ,M<.'i.uee
f
4J~'(tCCJ<al!
•
2.G DpC:.I\vt pa3r:oHa TpOnne:H6yca ca ca~pue~mo.H Maccci! c
· Cl\Oj>QC'rn
.
60
1
c aJ
j' ·
50 a<M/t;t;
- MaKCl'J1.tllJJJiHOC,. l'ip¢)IeJI:hUOC
• rpAA'Uft~:OCl\"'e
2
C,
•.
•
26
2. 7 Conpcthmllea;Me.Iisawuam a!!e~ipJ.rtJec~ .' eueif 1pO~mefr6yc4 co
IJ.CeMH riO,D;KJllO'tteiD.1biMJ1 M31LU1F1:3M$! H mttlaptYraMH QpU i~OMHH ·1 ·liMX
l\.!1lt.\IaTHl:!eCi01X
<jJaA-ropax notOCT 15150"69.
i
I
:
l
- - -r·-·
I
··~··
tvfccro 3~epa conponu;tJl0WU 1~'lon~mt:m
:
I'
l- . j ..
w·
~<0-·¥----~ ·
B c.tni"Hfrm OOltpO! ltJmc mm
I ct)-mJ;e,;;.
l001l;;11 l HH,
nop~m ··
~ .....
L~~-M---~-..._-~-----. . . . .~~---1. f·,fe.fKAY f<Y;;i(Jfit!r.t :Jl .3J.rteiO]J~:t"'¢CKOH UClihiO C
J-!£l,!~.~alllJ KhlM ~ij¥J?S!:.R:C~l:$:t\.t1r,!. 5 5013.
2. v1eR<;zy' :1.tt~m:rpl1.'lCC~fiU.t:CW!MH C
5
MbM
!
~~~.:'!lffiaJihHPI!1,;IUurpwtK;tlniCM 5:50E·J_i_24_B_···......( .....1;.2_ B_.· +-+--5-~. ~
6'
.r.....
'
3, !Y1ewJ'.'l,y h')tloBOM·li ::JJ.n:::KTP~t~·o,e~pr. nerutMn c
lii?~!!~;t'!bl+\t R!!!J2~~K~leM .
-~~~I~_
.
.
_...._
·
fl _
.
I
~ 2.8 ToJi;; )"'ec:nGf nptl HO:PM~llblX KIDtMa·nrqec~rx ycn~llW..ID\ no
fOCT 151 50-69 M:A. .
.
I
~ npeJJ;emln.tii, h'fiD\Ci:IMa.>"'lbHlllH
'
l
0~2
- 4>a~-ru:qecKH!!
I
C~ /
2_9 Pocypc lpOJtneii6yca ~o n:cpuoro :KJ:rruxntnJ,J;oro peMorrr~ rrpu
yt:;l c.miDI 3KCI1Jlya-raa;~· .a tfO(Jtn~C:Tl\Wt C !'pe:ooa
pe~WH'fHO~:;KCU?l)'nl:~OHHO'ti Jl.O~~Clff?Jlilli l:te f>.te
2 10 Co.\lep~aH'He ;n;patcn.t"Htfut~
MeTI1Jtnoa:
.
..
.
- 30:1.01.\')
- ~cpe6pc
.
.
U'l ,ttMCTB)'10Ul.¢M
400 Th!CU<M.
I
)
j
0,0011 r.
.5,3208 r.
0~4224 r .
• ···· . .:.,:--·.;,..,·>·
...
~<~~.,.
1
~,:
't
.ilcnapTaM.eU J(H!'fitarm (Se:Bell-ot>-K'aaSX01'3itfCI\:Oii oo.nacnt
CB, JJ' Jl~1'EJI~CTB
0
0 rocY)lAI
IOPH)llNFiCKOrO JD{UA
1Cl:BEJ$0HPErHCl'PAI(Hlff
N!.884~12(8-[Y. .
~fi!f~rJX{)Hlfr.a:R l!(!Mep
05.0240005234
· << 4 » <~enp.ang 200S
HauMer;:osaH.ue:r'o.c..yJl.ap~·lutumoe yttpe--Ameuu~ · 1' ~0'F?lM
4J1 ruau too r~p Oila
lUt"Tf}UflaB,rnn1rr<:a H . . . .
·
p\ifecro !LXQ»t)l,t!ll UL 150008, ~u.epo~Ka<la:::<aa.a:t!CilH oO-JIUCTh,
ffCT)JOOan: H)HCKI y;:m:u,aJ":'olJCTHT)'tuUt J: :.Ua:craHft~ 23
. ""\
"
r.
t' OfJOJl
j
.. b ):('lf.Jt:fEjliJHOCTb
tl
·8 PAMift'\X
""'"~ ..... ""'" .· · An
E. Ccia:Hi\!6:t!l\OB
~
~ ~puJt
B
,-,..,...
.-....... .. ~
OCr.
~~lP,lffC.'lb
·l·J&:in'k \1:01;) oprru:lil .
-
<l>JI-01583
Ha samr;rne p;e.srre.rthliOVJ'J>IO no on:e11xe U:M:J'UJ;ec:raa
H ):t<WT :tlpaJJO :aa OCytD:0C'l'BJICHHe n;esrT<MhlilOCTH
no CJICflvtO~ cneu,;uanHsa~
1. _.!_?~~~~I<:a IICf(BH/Kl:l~tOr! ·HMYU~eCl'~lJ.(;a f!c kJim•.remteM
.mmeH3mo
np<!.t\.r tpWITHii KUK
HMy!llecTlleHifhl~
lwMn:reKcon)
;\.'ll\1 A Tbi.TI .1-,J 1\ 6
A.JIIVI!\ TJ4HCI{A51 nAJIArf A
A ~, Ill bl J1 A P
()I IE I Ill~ I·II{() B
~
"
. \
I
;1
II anaTachi»
I I\ I I I I' h 1,1 1II II
5IBJUieTCH LIJieHOM «AJIM3TVIHCKOH ]] (lJ I (l'l' I.J
I ,I\ 11.1 J l :.I J ~hl.
1ay illhiJia p
ll o J'I,tJ l
! l ~ I. I ! l
0 IJ,eH IJJ,VI KOB».
.
lI I
1
OcHoBaHHe:
OIJ,eHW,l1KOB»
. .
O_n~~rt~tf~~:JJ:\'t,aTitllCKOii
MaJtbraJJvtapona P.A.
f l H l olllh\11
!Yf.O.
~>.;,·"·,.~·.::·..
fi1!/M.n.
~:~-~~~- -·· .. ~. ·,.
'
t-~
'
~
II;
t'
'
I
\
\
..
09.10.2Qllr.
'i...:'•' ,/...
i
·/
.___.I .
· !V
'
.· -
l
v
/
I
U . .A
•
l
'i
t;
.'. ~ ·'"' 11 .
r'·~·~1'•''·'"''
..., \w· '1\
o. .t;.~ri<l.i.•~
\
. ('
0. \ L
.
t
/
~, .·; ·'
/
//1
Pemi'.~au~f.f.hli·• uoMcp «26-20 11-091 O/IOJh>
)].ant pentcTpaitmt «29» Man 2012 1.
'·-
Tiph·l·y uo '\u·pi ul (, l U II 0•1 I HI CI
Tiph'l '. JI l ' ll 1'\ IIi 1<1 1) ., 1\1111\ lt .ql l OI J.
,. ~ r
- · ar•l"'··.o
~~
·~,
'-..._.. ..._,,.,. , · ,t~t•
$.
rf(~~;:"bl ouet;-IJU~'~on
<
·'
I
OT
' II OG III .U I 111( 1111M1.
, \ : 1,\ HIII •I ·'II •h \ · tl l ll
lla~' lll
PeweHHe CoseTa «AJIMaTMHCKOH II <U tcl'l'ht
Ill .
MaJit.J a'*'mtpoua P.A.
AJlMA TbiJibll\ liAF AJIAY W biJIAP
AJlATACbl
AJlMATHHCK.I\}1 llAJIATA
OUEHW,~1KOB
AnMaTbiJihii\ 6araJiaylllhiiiap IlaJiaTaChi
MyllleCIHlli
KY8JIIfl
CBH~ETEJihCTBO
AJIMaThl R:aJiaChl
ropOJl. AJIMaThl
qJieHa AnMaTHHCKOH OaJiaThi o~eHII.I,MKOB