docOrchard Valley Final Report - Engineer
download 
Report Transcription
Orchard Valley Final Report - Engineer
Orchard Valley Subdivision Introduction Following the November 5th hearing regarding the Orchard Valley Subdivision Petition for the repair and maintenance of the storm sewer drainage system and the decision by the Board of County Commissioners to move forward to a final hearing, our office surveyed the damaged storm area, prepared construction plans, and requested construction bids from several area contractors in order to better define the actual cost of the necessary repairs. Contractor Estimated Costs to Repair As mentioned in previous reports, our initial estimated cost for the repair of the damaged 36” plastic storm pipe was $43,500. After completing construction plans we contacted five area contractors known to excel at projects of this size and scope. Construction plans were sent to four of the five who expressed interest in bidding. Of those four, only one returned a cost estimate. Smith Construction bid the project at $39,205.00. The cost of making these repairs using Clermont County Engineer staff has also been evaluated. While our crews certainly have the skill to perform the work, we do not possess all of the equipment necessary to replace such a deep storm pipe and would therefore need to rent additional equipment to accomplish the task. Accounting for the cost of rental equipment, our fee to complete this project would be $51,613.42. Assessment The report presented on November 5, 2014 referenced only the 64 lots that contribute directly into the damaged 36” storm water drainage pipe near the end of Scarlet Maple Court. Based upon previous direction from the Board, the repair and maintenance costs were divided among those 64 lots based upon the actual drainage area that each lot contributes. Under that scenario, based upon the $39,205.00 bid price, the cost recover this expense over 10 years would range from $22.25 to $97.54 per lot per year. Likewise, the yearly maintenance cost would range from $3.97 to $17.41 per lot per year. This method of proportional fees seems logical for the current necessary repair; those who contribute more runoff have a proportional financial stake. If this were a standalone project that approach may be the best fit, but we must remember that we are establishing a small district in which all privately owned storm drainage pipes will now be the responsibility of the county to maintain. Therefore, upon further consideration, it has come to light that this may not be the optimal method for maintaining this storm water district into the future. This current repair is a significant distance downstream from the beginning of the watershed and there are 64 lots that contribute runoff in some way to this point. There are also privately owned storm sewer drainage pipes near the beginning of the watershed that would become the responsibility of the county (example circled in white on the map below). The potential need to repair these upstream pipes in the future raises concern for the proposed proportional fee schedule. If the cost to repair these upstream pipes is shared across all 64 lots per the previously proposed fee schedule, there would be a significant number of lots paying varying fees when they contribute little to no runoff directly to the upstream location. If fees are recalculated so that only those lots that contribute to the upstream pipe are charged for their repair, we could be faced with a situation where that cost is split among only 2 or 3 lots, creating a situation not dissimilar to what the original petitioners are facing. If the Board votes to establish this storm water maintenance district, it is recommended that all lots within the district contribute an equal share to the maintenance and repair of all privately owned storm water drainage pipes within. As discussed previously, the bid price to repair the damaged 36” plastic storm pipe is $39,205.00. In addition to this immediate repair, Clermont County would also perform maintenance of these storm pipes including video inspection on a 5 year cycle and cleaning of the storm pipes on a 10 year cycle or as needed. There is approximately 1,325 feet of storm pipe located outside the right of way in the proposed district. Video inspection costs are estimated at $2,000 which equates to $400 per year and cleaning costs are estimated at approximately $3,000 which equates to $300 per year. Divided among the 64 lots evenly, the cost to cover the $39,205.00 improvement cost over 10 years would be $61.23 per lot per year. The yearly maintenance costs when broken down using the same procedure would add $10 to each lot per year, bringing the total cost per lot to $71.23 per year until such time that the initial improvement costs are recovered when the cost per lot will then be reduced to cover maintenance only. Exhibit A Drainage Area Map Exhibit B Estimated Cost per Lot Sorted by Owner SCARLET MAPLE DRAINAGE AREA ESTIMATED COSTS BY ACREAGE SORTED BY NAME PIN OWNER 182406C266. 182406C238. 182406C222. 182406C262. 182406C260. 182406C227. 182406C239. 182406C248. 182406C220. 182406C252. 182406C246. 182406C207. 182406C254. 182406C261. 182406C208. 182406C243. 182406C218. 182406C270. 182406C269. 182406C234. 182406C225. 182406C257. 182406C250. 182406C206. 182406C242. 182406C247. 182406C216. 182406C235. 182406C236. 182406C213. 182406C241. 182406C223. 182406C237. ADAMS REBECCA A & CHRISTIAN G BARGER NICOLE L & ARTHUR BARRINGER DAVID C & SHERRI G BISCHOF RICHARD BLICKENSDERFER CHRISTOPHER D & LEAH BLOOMER KENNETH L & SHERYL A BRAUN JEFFREY S & MELISSA BROWN JAMES C & THERESA H BURGDORF RONALD S & KAREN M BURKHART JAMES S & MICHELLE R COLEGATE RAYMOND S & KARLA M COOK GARRY L & VIVIAN D CUNNINGHAM TRACY KEAN & TRACEY KAY DAVIS CHRISTEN M & KLM DINGUS HANK A II & HEATHER L DIXON MATTHEW & KELLY DOW KELLY A ENGEL DONALD R JR & BEVERLY A ENGLE DONALD R JR TRUSTEE EWING MICHAEL D & TONI S FACCIOLO MICHAEL J & TAMMY J FATUTE FRED A & REBECCA L GAMBLE GARY C & SMITH KAREN A GILMAN RANDY E & JODY L GODWIN TODD N GOLDEN DENNIS L JR & JENNIFER L HATTON DIANE J HAWES JUSTIN N & LAUREN M HINNERS DREW A & DEBORAH M HITTNER MARK F & SALLY E HODGE BRENDA HOLTZMAN BRENDA K JANZEN ROBERT M & HOLLY L MAILING ADDRESS 5581 HOFFMAN RD 5432 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 5531 SCARLET MAPLE DR 4901 VINE ST 5569 HOFFMAN RD 5541 SCARLET MAPLE CT 5430 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 5429 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 5527 SCARLET MAPLE CT 5437 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 5425 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 5540 SCARLET MAPLE CT 5441 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 5571 HOFFMAN RD 5538 SCARLET MAPLE CT 5422 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 5523 SCARLET MAPLE CT 5589 HOFFMAN RD 5587 HOFFMAN RD 5440 CHERRY BLOSSOM 5537 SCARLET MAPLE CT 1557 WILD CHERRY DR 5433 CHERRY BLOSSOM COURT 1541 WILD CHERRY DR 5424 CHERRY BLOSSOM COURT 5427 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 5522 SCARLETT MAPLE CT 5438 CHERRY BLOSSOM COURT 5436 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 5528 SCARLET MAPLE CT 5426 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 5533 SCARLET MAPLE CT 5434 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 CINCINNATI OH 45217 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 IMPROVEMENT COST PER YEAR $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 MAINTENANCE COST PER YEAR $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 TOTAL COST PER YEAR $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 SCARLET MAPLE DRAINAGE AREA ESTIMATED COSTS BY ACREAGE SORTED BY NAME PIN OWNER 182406C224. 182406C265. 182406C231. 182406C264. 182406C258. 182406C233. 182406C230. 182406C249. 182406C209. 182406C253. 182406C221. 182406C214. 182406C211. 182406C244. 182406C229. 182406C263. 182406C240. 182406C259. 182406C219. 182406C226. 182406C228. 182406C210. 182406C245. 182406C205. 182406C251. 182406C267. 182406C212. 182406C268. 182406C215. 182406C217. 182406C232. JOHNSON CRAIG A & AMY M KENNEBECK RICHARD & EMMA KERN JENNIFER A & LINDA M LAMMRISH DAVID H & ELIZABETH A LAWRENCE ANDREW E & SHEA D LAWSON WILLARD C JR & DEBRA A LEGETTE TODD & DONNA C LOUGHRAN BILL E & KRISTINE E MAZAN BERNIE J & SHERRI K MCDONOUGH WAYNE E & CARLA L NAGEL JASON E & JENNIFER L PIELSTICKER JOHN D & VICKY J PIERCE TROY & PATRICIA L REDROW JAMES A & MARIA K RHEA TIMOTHY V & BRENDA ROBINSON JONATHAN D & TARA L ROCKWELL ADAM & MARIAN SAUNDERS TY KEVIN & DEBRA C SCHULTE RICHARD S & CATHLEEN M SEDGWICK JEFFREY P & BAUR SARA J SMITH BRANDON S & HEATHER L SMITH MICHAEL L & SANDRA D SMITH RAYMOND E & TONI D SPENCE MICHAEL DAVID & STEPHANIE LYNN THOMAYER KURT A & TAMI L UNKLE C RICHARD & JAMIE L VEARIL LORI L WELSH DWANE C & BONNIE A WETICK ROBERT E & DONNA M ZOROMSKI SCOTT C & PAULA J ZUNIC CHRISTOPHER & PARKER CYNTHIA MAILING ADDRESS 5535 SCARLET MAPLE CT 5579 HOFFMAN RD 1545 WILD CHERRY DR 5577 HOFFMAN RD 1555 WILD CHERRY DR 5442 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 1547 WILD CHERRY DR 5431 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 5536 SCARLET MAPLE CT 5439 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 5529 SCARLET MAPLE DR 5526 SCARLET MAPLE CT 5532 SCARLET MAPLE CT 5421 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT P O BOX 183 6055 DELICIOUS ASHA CT 5428 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 1553 WILD CHERRY DRIVE 5525 SCARLET MAPLE CT 5539 SCARLET MAPLE COURT 1551 WILD CHERRY DR 5534 SCARLET MAPLE COURT 5423 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 1540 WILD CHERRY DR 5435 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 5583 HOFFMAN RD 5530 SCARLET MAPLE CT 5585 HOFFMAN RD 5524 SCARLET MAPLE CT 5521 SCARLET MAPLE CT 1543 WILD CHERRY DR MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 LOVELAND OH 45140 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 IMPROVEMENT COST PER YEAR $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $3,918.72 MAINTENANCE COST PER YEAR $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $640.00 TOTAL COST PER YEAR $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $4,558.72 Exhibit C Estimated Cost per Lot Sorted by PIN SCARLET MAPLE DRAINAGE AREA ESTIMATED COSTS BY ACREAGE SORTED BY PIN PIN OWNER 182406C205. 182406C206. 182406C207. 182406C208. 182406C209. 182406C210. 182406C211. 182406C212. 182406C213. 182406C214. 182406C215. 182406C216. 182406C217. 182406C218. 182406C219. 182406C220. 182406C221. 182406C222. 182406C223. 182406C224. 182406C225. 182406C226. 182406C227. 182406C228. 182406C229. 182406C230. 182406C231. 182406C232. 182406C233. 182406C234. 182406C235. 182406C236. 182406C237. SPENCE MICHAEL DAVID & STEPHANIE LYNN GILMAN RANDY E & JODY L COOK GARRY L & VIVIAN D DINGUS HANK A II & HEATHER L MAZAN BERNIE J & SHERRI K SMITH MICHAEL L & SANDRA D PIERCE TROY & PATRICIA L VEARIL LORI L HITTNER MARK F & SALLY E PIELSTICKER JOHN D & VICKY J WETICK ROBERT E & DONNA M HATTON DIANE J ZOROMSKI SCOTT C & PAULA J DOW KELLY A SCHULTE RICHARD S & CATHLEEN M BURGDORF RONALD S & KAREN M NAGEL JASON E & JENNIFER L BARRINGER DAVID C & SHERRI G HOLTZMAN BRENDA K JOHNSON CRAIG A & AMY M FACCIOLO MICHAEL J & TAMMY J SEDGWICK JEFFREY P & BAUR SARA J BLOOMER KENNETH L & SHERYL A SMITH BRANDON S & HEATHER L RHEA TIMOTHY V & BRENDA LEGETTE TODD & DONNA C KERN JENNIFER A & LINDA M ZUNIC CHRISTOPHER & PARKER CYNTHIA LAWSON WILLARD C JR & DEBRA A EWING MICHAEL D & TONI S HAWES JUSTIN N & LAUREN M HINNERS DREW A & DEBORAH M JANZEN ROBERT M & HOLLY L MAILING ADDRESS 1540 WILD CHERRY DR 1541 WILD CHERRY DR 5540 SCARLET MAPLE CT 5538 SCARLET MAPLE CT 5536 SCARLET MAPLE CT 5534 SCARLET MAPLE COURT 5532 SCARLET MAPLE CT 5530 SCARLET MAPLE CT 5528 SCARLET MAPLE CT 5526 SCARLET MAPLE CT 5524 SCARLET MAPLE CT 5522 SCARLETT MAPLE CT 5521 SCARLET MAPLE CT 5523 SCARLET MAPLE CT 5525 SCARLET MAPLE CT 5527 SCARLET MAPLE CT 5529 SCARLET MAPLE DR 5531 SCARLET MAPLE DR 5533 SCARLET MAPLE CT 5535 SCARLET MAPLE CT 5537 SCARLET MAPLE CT 5539 SCARLET MAPLE COURT 5541 SCARLET MAPLE CT 1551 WILD CHERRY DR P O BOX 183 1547 WILD CHERRY DR 1545 WILD CHERRY DR 1543 WILD CHERRY DR 5442 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 5440 CHERRY BLOSSOM 5438 CHERRY BLOSSOM COURT 5436 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 5434 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 IMPROVEMENT COST PER YEAR $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 MAINTENANCE COST PER YEAR $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 TOTAL COST PER YEAR $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 SCARLET MAPLE DRAINAGE AREA ESTIMATED COSTS BY ACREAGE SORTED BY PIN PIN OWNER 182406C238. 182406C239. 182406C240. 182406C241. 182406C242. 182406C243. 182406C244. 182406C245. 182406C246. 182406C247. 182406C248. 182406C249. 182406C250. 182406C251. 182406C252. 182406C253. 182406C254. 182406C257. 182406C258. 182406C259. 182406C260. 182406C261. 182406C262. 182406C263. 182406C264. 182406C265. 182406C266. 182406C267. 182406C268. 182406C269. 182406C270. BARGER NICOLE L & ARTHUR BRAUN JEFFREY S & MELISSA ROCKWELL ADAM & MARIAN HODGE BRENDA GODWIN TODD N DIXON MATTHEW & KELLY REDROW JAMES A & MARIA K SMITH RAYMOND E & TONI D COLEGATE RAYMOND S & KARLA M GOLDEN DENNIS L JR & JENNIFER L BROWN JAMES C & THERESA H LOUGHRAN BILL E & KRISTINE E GAMBLE GARY C & SMITH KAREN A THOMAYER KURT A & TAMI L BURKHART JAMES S & MICHELLE R MCDONOUGH WAYNE E & CARLA L CUNNINGHAM TRACY KEAN & TRACEY KAY FATUTE FRED A & REBECCA L LAWRENCE ANDREW E & SHEA D SAUNDERS TY KEVIN & DEBRA C BLICKENSDERFER CHRISTOPHER D & LEAH DAVIS CHRISTEN M & KLM BISCHOF RICHARD ROBINSON JONATHAN D & TARA L LAMMRISH DAVID H & ELIZABETH A KENNEBECK RICHARD & EMMA ADAMS REBECCA A & CHRISTIAN G UNKLE C RICHARD & JAMIE L WELSH DWANE C & BONNIE A ENGLE DONALD R JR TRUSTEE ENGEL DONALD R JR & BEVERLY A MAILING ADDRESS 5432 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 5430 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 5428 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 5426 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 5424 CHERRY BLOSSOM COURT 5422 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 5421 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 5423 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 5425 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 5427 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 5429 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 5431 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 5433 CHERRY BLOSSOM COURT 5435 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 5437 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 5439 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 5441 CHERRY BLOSSOM CT 1557 WILD CHERRY DR 1555 WILD CHERRY DR 1553 WILD CHERRY DRIVE 5569 HOFFMAN RD 5571 HOFFMAN RD 4901 VINE ST 6055 DELICIOUS ASHA CT 5577 HOFFMAN RD 5579 HOFFMAN RD 5581 HOFFMAN RD 5583 HOFFMAN RD 5585 HOFFMAN RD 5587 HOFFMAN RD 5589 HOFFMAN RD MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 CINCINNATI OH 45217 LOVELAND OH 45140 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 MILFORD OH 45150 IMPROVEMENT COST PER YEAR $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $61.23 $3,918.72 MAINTENANCE COST PER YEAR $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $10.00 $640.00 TOTAL COST PER YEAR $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $71.23 $4,558.72 Exhibit D Construction Plans Exhibit E Low Contractor Bid