Asian Development Bank (ADB)

Adapting to
Climate Change
STRENGTHENING THE CLIMATE RESILIENCE
OF THE WATER SECTOR INFRASTRUCTURE
IN KHULNA, BANGLADESH
!"#$%&#&##&$&%
!
"
'(#))
*
& &
+!
,-
,./
0
*/+
/
* 1
2 (-3
,
,-
,
45
,6
, ,
7
,
,
,
/
8
9
/
:
,
,
3 ,
- -
,;,
//
-
,
-
3/-
,
"
+
/8<9,
;!
=/0
*
>>0
0/
(?=2=2))))
@3?=2=2=)))
---
@
/
+
,A3'
@3?=2=2==)%
B
Contents
;
!
<
,*
,
6
C-
,.
,
6
**
:
!
!
D0
!
A3!
C >
=
$
$
#
#
2
=
/
1
'!
C
6
'
:
)
)
=
$
#
=
/
>
-
*;!
;! ,**
!
C
:
)
=
2
;
E
*
2
2
2
Tables and Figures
!
(
(
(2
()
(>
(=
($
(%
(#
(
(
(
<
@
@
@2
@)
@>
@=
@$
@%
@#
@
@
@
@2
!@
,*
:
,
.
.,
!
@
,(00
!
;,
!
:#>F@
-!E
A
,
C
1
.-**
1
*/-**
1
*/-**
*
,! ,
,,!
*
,
1
.-;, '!
,!
-
!*
'
.
@
-
,!
0
@-
*
,!C0
1
E.
*
,$G#0!!
EE
*
,$G#0!!E0
E
,'!1
#>F@
-',!
*0
!
*
**
1
0,
&&&H'
@
>
1
0,
&&&H'
@
>
- 1
0,
&&&H'
@
>
- =
%
#
$
#
)
=
%
#
2
2
)
>
%
>
=
%
2
>
$
Acknowledgments
(
-
,
,
,
4(5
I'
,,
!'
,1!
.
**(
--"
!
/
/;
1
/!
/
45/-
(*
I
,
(-
,3,
/"/ ,10
4 105/(
./J@
E-JD(0JA
KJ
K-,
!,;LL*
/J.
J.AD7J00D7J00
,.J0.J0!
0J.
"L'J0L'J!00'J"!,J
,0M,
10-
, ,
3 / / ,
E
6
, 0 , E
6
/ ' *
J.1!!-
J.**
K
/ / / L
,-
(
'
,
N *
/-
(,
*'
:/
,
( ( ( , ,
E/ /
@/ , ,
0 ( .
/ / ;
1 / !
/ 0 (/ /;
1
/!
//
Abbreviations
CA
6!
**
10
N *
.**
.1!
(
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
,A
**
,10
N *
.**
.1!!-
Weights and Measurements
E
2
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
* G 4(5
(
O <)%=
<
O ($
Introduction
Background
,,,
,/
-& 6GG0 / - /
/ 7 ,/ - , / ,
/
,
/P-
//
P
,,
,
,,!
,
,
( , - I / - !- ,7 , 0 C
/ - -
, / , -
/
,
-&/,
--
, , - ( ,
,, , - - -/ ,
L
/
,
,,
,
,,
-/
-
,
**!
1
/
-6
,/
45
,
,
/-/
,
./&-
,
/2-,
,-
:+
:,
/
,
,-
6
,#%DQJODGHVK&OLPDWH&KDQJH6WUDWHJ\DQG$FWLRQ3ODQ
%7HFKQLFDO$VVLVWDQFHWR3HRSOH·V5HSXEOLFRI%DQJODGHVKIRU6WUHQJWKHQLQJWKH5HVLOLHQFHRIWKH:DWHU6HFWRU
LQ.KXOQDWR&OLPDWH&KDQJH0
2
( , , $$/ 3 , ,
.**
4.**5/
-
)
$
2
% ,
(
:
,
45
,,&,
:/--
,-
.
J45I
,&
,
&,,
,
(,
-
-
,/-,
. * *
4.**5/ - )> 7
45/
,2-
Overview of Khulna
.
-4@5/-
7
,
3 / ,
(-
>
/-3-)>>)(I
&,,
-
,'
&,
,.0/
%F
,.**###,8&/9->F,
/,
-
>F,
3/%F,
).I
-
,
&
(,.)G#-/#)45/
#F
,,
-0C
(3
,22°*
00/
-
,
>°*
N
,
/.
3
(
#%%//
$,.(
!/-I
-
"
$/
2/)
,/$)
,
/
>(
-<$
!
,
-
-
//
,
,74,
5
!.-/,
,A
4CA5@'
-3
! ,
,
.,,-
J ,
- ,
/ / 0
/
,
,@
#$>/=-,,
-
,6
'/
,6'
:
,,-
.
'/,-
,
.
/
0'
,
,
,--(
4-53,
,-
)
>
=
.
6WUXFWXUH3ODQ0DVWHU3ODQDQG'HWDLOHG$UHD3ODQIRU.KXOQD&LW\²
.
6
, % &\FORQH 6LGU LQ %DQJODGHVK 'DPDJH /RVV DQG 1HHGV $VVHVVPHQW IRU 'LVDVWHU
5HFRYHU\DQG5HFRQVWUXFWLRQ
@45
6'/
,1(-
6'-
D
'
9 ,
Figure 2
Salinity Concentration in Rivers in and around Khulna
6
?%&&(@%&&5A
-B=
/
/
?C;A
%/
=/
)/
/
N
@
0
0
N
N
!
C
"
N
@
0
0
N
N
!
C
"
N
@
0
0
N
N
!
C
"
N
@
0
0
N
N
!
C
"
N
@
0
0
N
N
!
C
"
N
@
>
=
$
%
#
6CD
"
6'
6'
*6'
'6''
0
0'
!/QE
CAO
,A
/QEO
!
+ N * @ ! ,
. 1 ! : I ' ,
(
,,
.'/
,
'
-
0'
/-0'
6
:
(-,
.,
-
-,
- - (
- ,, / .1!!-
4.1!5
-
,-/-,
N *
4N *5$
.,,,
-
,
4/-
5/-
3 , (
* '
:/ - .I :/-
"
%
$
.1!
:
,
-
5HSRUW DQG 5HFRPPHQGDWLRQ RI WKH 3UHVLGHQW WR WKH %RDUG RI 'LUHFWRUV 3URSRVHG /RDQ DQG 7HFKQLFDO
$VVLVWDQFH*UDQWVWRWKH3HRSOH·V5HSXEOLFRI%DQJODGHVKIRUWKH&LW\5HJLRQ'HYHORSPHQW3URMHFW0
%
Study Approach and Methodology
(
,
./ 45 :
,
.,
2>J45
,
. ,
2 >J 45 J
45
,
2>/
:J
45 ,
J 45 , L
,
-
-
-
,
-@2
Figure 3
Flow Diagram of the Study
!
'-
,
,
:
,
2>
*
R(
R
R!&
R;
R
R1
RE
R6
-
,
*
4
5
',
!/
,/
R1
R'
>
R1
R@
R,,
R
RE&
4-5
R*
G,45
E
6
',
-
1
>
-
6
1
//
6
'
6O
!
+,
(
7 ,
Climate Change Projection
Climate
(-
/ / ,
! '
A
!
* * 4 **5 - - , #&&
/
/&-
/
-
-/
-
/
-
/
-/ / -
- -,
/-
-
Table 1 Summary Features of Climate Projections for Khulna
,%
2
(
(
>,
?>°*
C
?$°*N
@
(
>,
?>°*N/
N/
?>°*@
',
(,
>F>4/%=5
,
,
(,
#2F>4/$2#5
,
,
!
,
NG!)=F
G@
=2F
NG!>F
G@
)=F
',
>
,=
,
)
>#>
>
,=
,
)
)>>
*O*/O
(
-/$=#/,,
:
/,,,
4/#),
)
#5(
:(
-#%>#/%%$
(
-/>#/,,
:
/
-,
,
,,
,
- 3 , /
,,,(,
/,,
-
,
-
!
+,
#
(
!'
A
!
,
,4////
5 3
-/ - , / / ,
-
,
-J
& J -, , -/ ,, -
-
-/L
/
/
**$7KH)RXUWK$VVHVVPHQW5HSRUW---QS
,
6
8
!
--,
6
*0
4A*D0>Q0 &C05
,
4>°3>°5/
,,
(
-&
,
,(,
(
(/
-/
,6
*0
C
/
,
Sea-Level Rise
,
/-
,,4/
-5-
,, / , ( &
- /
452>/
**
(
&
/>2)>/,
,
(-,
,-
/-
, - **
:4,
#5
River Discharge
,
,6
.,
6
/-
,
6
,/
,6
*0
4A*D0>Q0 &C05
,,
,6
-;
/
,
6
. 2 > , / 3 C
4/
,
5-
Socioeconomic Scenario Development
@
/
-.I
2>!
/
/-/
-3-
,
.
-(
Hydraulic Models Development
( - Q
, ,
(
,
P!
-'
D
0
/
!0
/;0
P
-@)/,
,
(2
(
-
03 ,
0
/6
(;0
7,-
,2
/-
-
, / ,
(,
/ ,
-,
45
,,
2
%
,2
/45
,
6
*0
-
,=
&
,
/
,
-
/-
,,
,
,
6WUHQJWKHQLQJWKH5HVLOLHQFHRIWKH:DWHU6HFWRULQ.KXOQDWR&OLPDWH&KDQJH*
I
04($#$&"5/>/3*
3 ,
Table 2 Key Parameters for Socioeconomic Development
/
,
*
.**
F
-+45#$=/
J45/)>/2J
45/>>/>
2--
1
,
2
>>
F
,
.**
-
-
6
-
=F
(
,
-
-#-=F
;
,
@
/
4-5+45$$F/ -
-
:
45#F2/452%$F
>
6O
/.**O.**
!
+,
Figure 4 Model Framework
C
*
:
6
!/
,/
,
-
6
.
E
6
',
1
>
E
0
0
0
!
+,
1
/
/
',
-
!
1
4/5
,
6
5
Table 3
6
:
Features of the Three Mathematical Models
<
6
>
*
!
-'
D
0
-/
/
,
-
C
10
(
!0
, 0 .A
-
,
!
-'
D
0
C
10
(
;0
-/
/
,
.**
0 .A
0 .A;
"-
( !
-'
D
0
/-
,
3
,
-
10O ,10
/.**O.**
/(O
0
,-
,
--/-7/
0
&
0;
,
&-
,-
!
+,
,
/
,
,@>
-
,!
-'
D
0
/@=$
- , ! 0
! #@$
CA-
.1!
Scenarios Examined under the Study
,
-
,
.I-,4()58'9-/
,0
,,
-
,
'2>/
7
& ' , I 4,
5
Damage Assessment
D
/ 4/ / / ,5/ ,/.
,,-
(
,
,&/
,
/
/
@/
-3/-
,
,
,
,
/
,,,/
(;0
-
-
,
2& ,
Figure 5
Comparison of Simulated and Observed Moving Average Water Levels in Khulna
)
?/-A
%
=
)
%
=
)
!I= I= 0I$ NI$ !I$ I$ 0I% NI% I% "
I% @I# 0I# I# "
I#
!
B
%&&8@%&&5
?A
%&&8@%&&5
?A
1O1
1O?)=
!
+
Figure 6 Comparison of 2007–2009 Measured and Simulated Salinity Levels at Labanchara
%
=
4QE5
)
%
=
)
N$
N$
!
N%
CA
N%
N#
N#
!
4QE
5
CAO
,A
/QEO
"
+0,
#CA-
/
-
>
,
!
+
,
6
22
Figure 7
Comparison of 2007–2009 Measured and Simulated Salinity Levels at Mollarhat
%
=
4QE5
)
%
=
)
N$
N$
N%
N%
N#
^ŝŵƵůĂƚĞĚ͕ĚĂŝůLJĂǀĞƌĂŐĞ
KŵĞĂƐƵƌĞŵĞŶƚ
^ĂůŝŶŝƚLJĐƌŝƚĞƌŝŽŶ;ϭŐͬ>ĐŚůŽƌŝĚĞĐŽŶĐĞŶƚƌĂƟŽŶͿ
<t^ŵĞĂƐƵƌĞŵĞŶƚ
N#
CAO
,A
/QEO/.1!O.1!!-
"
+0,
#CA-
/
-
>
,
!
+
Table 4
/
2
)
>
=
$
%
#
%&'&
T
T
T
T
O
!
+,
%&(&
T
T
T
T
Scenarios Used for the Study
T
,%
T
T
T
T
2
T
T
T
T
";
T
/
/
;
E
>
)
>
)
2% ,
&,
,
;,
/
3
,
&
,
/
-
,
,,
/
,-
,
--
,
(
,
-
-
,
,,
'
7
/,
/
,
-
,-
/,
--
+
4 5 / ,
,
,
-
( ; 0
- ,
-
- ,
/ - ,
-
,
; 0
/
/,,
45/,
-
2(
,,-,
.
- -
- / ,-
,,
,.I
-
7,
,
4/,5,
,
,(
/,
-,,-
,
/,,/
/
C
, : - ,
, , -,,
,-
)
/,
,
4/ / ,/ / / 5-
:-
,,,-
D
-/
,
-
,
@/ - -
/
!
/,
,
-,
,
,
/
- G,/-
,
4(5
(
,
-
/-
,
!
-,
/
,
,,
/-
0
/ ,
- A
- /,3
,
-
2
)
O,4
,-
/
,-
5
HOU/-H
,4
,
5U
,-
-
,45
,,
/,/
J45
,
J45,
,
6
2'
/-
(,
/,
J/
-
Other Issues
E
,
-
./
-&
,,
(
;AC
/
-E
&
AC
/*
;/ "- H
/ 3 46!5 2/
.;(6!
-
&
,I
7
L(
,6!&
-
/.
6!
.
/,
-.
,#>>!-
,/
-
,D
-/,P-7
,P
/,-
.
,
-
Estimating Impacts on the
Proposed Surface Water
Supply System
(
,
.I--
,
45 ,
- 4/ - 5 ,
N N - -
,
- / 45 3 , =4QE5/QE>(-D/
0
/
,///E4@%5
Impacts on Water Availability
/,
-
-
,
-4,
65
,
-,
- @#
(>/#>F,
-,
N
N
,
-
,
-
,/'2>=@
/-
,
-'24/25'>4/>5
'4/5(
-#F
,#>F
,
-'
( ,
- ,
- - N *
4N *5
$
42Q5#22Q
2$ />-
)$2Q
,
-
-#>F,
-
0
/
/7)F
2=F>
,#>F,
-
- - -- , 3
-
(,
/#>F,
-,
2>
"/-
2>-
,,,-
,
,-
>
=
$
29
"
-7A
*
'4##$57
3
,=4QE54=
VW5/-3
-
/QE45
/.
#>F,
-
,,
-3
,
#>F
,
N *)HDVLELOLW\6WXG\IRUWKH.KXOQD:DWHU6XSSO\,PSURYHPHQW3URMHFWLQWKH3HRSOH·V5HSXEOLFRI%DQJODGHVK
(
27 ,
Figure 9
95% Dependable Flow in Base and Reference Scenarios
350
300
Flow (m3/s)
250
200
150
100
50
0
Haridaspur
Mollarhat
Upstream
of Phultala
Run 1
Phultala
Run 3a
Daulatpur
Labanchara
Run 5a
2QO
!
+
Impacts on River Salinity
(
,
33
,
-(>/2>
/33/QE
,
%
@
,
,30
,
,
(&3
,3
3/QE(3&3
,
,
,
&
@
'/
,
3&3
22F4/
,2
-
5(22F0
-
3QE,
,
,
,
'/>F4/
5
,0
->>
'24/2
-&5/
,/-
3
>/
$>/->F3
%
(!0
/
/
,
(-
-
>>F
,
,
-/,
,
-
=
/
28
Table 5
Projected 95% Dependable Flow and Salinity Levels
*
/
E 6
>
/
/ - ;
0
#>F '2
,
-42Q5
'>
22
%)
=
)%
%2
2
2
%
>
))
$$
%2
2
$$
=
)>
%
%%
'$
2
%
>
))
$$
%2
'#
2
$%
=
))
%
%=
03
'2
4QE
5 '>
'$
'#
#
%
>#
$%
=
$
%$
=
$
>
2
$
%$
=
$
2
$
%2
2
=
=
2
$
%$
=
$
"
,
=QE
>#
=
)>
=
$>
'2
=
=
%
)>
=
$=
'>
=
%#
%
)#
=2
$=
'$
$
=>
2
>
=
$>
'#
>
%=
)
>>
=2
$>
"
,
/QE
)
)
2)
>2
=%
'2
)
>
2>
>2
$
'>
=>
%
2$
>)
$
'$
)2
$
2#
>)
=#
'#
)
$
=
)
>>
$
2
QO
/QEO
"
+2O2/
/&J>O>/
/&J$O2/
/
&J#O>/
/&
,
>F3
4/
>F
35
-
-
,
$
!
+
Adaptation Options
,/
,
-,
--(/
L
,
#
,-
(-
,
&,, - - -/ -
3
,
-,
(-
/-
/
-
-3
#
(
8
98&
9
*
,
:
/-&
,
-,@/
,
---
--
23 ,
:
2&&&C;
Figure 10
Change in Mollarhat Salinity Duration Curves due to Climate Change
#
%
$
=
>
)
2
>
2
)>
=
$>
#
=$
/
4F5
?
"$A
'
'2
'$
'#
'>
QEO
!
+
+45--
/
,
-/
,
J45
-
,3
L(
/-
-
!
-
,,
,
,
N */ , / , / / D/
E/0
//--
L4,
$5
/ / 7 ,
/
.P/E/
P-
, , 7 , - : 3 ,
.I (,
/ - ,
0'/-
0
-
.
-
;
-&4
'>5/L
,
2>C
/
),
0
-
,,
,
( -
- ,
/ / -
/ ( = &
-
(,
-,
-+ '
!LO @
-'7 u
,D!
u F : @
,
A
E
- ,
) 4=> >
) 5 - QE > -
,>JF
,
-J
,/>>/J--4>F5J4%F5/,
-7
,)>=/2-A
-,
/
-
L
=
/
25
Table 6
,
B
C
'
)
,
0
>
Evaluation of Adaptation Options
=
P
<%2#
Cy0
P<)/
P
C
1
0
/ <#)
Cy0
P<%/
L
2>
=
=
,,/
*
4
/
5
0
,,/
*
4
/
5
2O/Cy0O
!
+,
/
:4/,5
,
-P
F
,
.**-7
,-,
- 7 D
-/ - / ),
0
/-
/ &
- 3 ( &
,
,,
'--
-,,,&
,
:
Gorai River Dredging
(6
'/
,,-
-/
-,
6 ' @
/ ,
- 4/ G5 / 6
' ,
6
'
7
,
6
'
' ,- ,
- 6
' :
, /
. 3/6
,
6
''
:/-
,
<$
(
,
:
,
,
-%
,
:
,
/
-
,
-
,=2Q-
6
'
/-
,
(
,
-
3/QE0
-
L
'2-
4,
>>-
5/
)'>
,
/7
7P
P
,--
,
,
/-
-,
7
7
,.**/,,
7,
,
(,
,
=2Q-
,
-6
'
:###
%& ,
-
4,
$>-
52(-
&,
:
-/,-,
//
J
,J
L,/
-/,,
,
:,
/ : 6
'###/,,
,,,
(
,-
.
,,
-
,
6
''
:-,,
,,,
Proposed Investment Project
,
,
,4,
5-
/
,-
:@/,-
),
0
-
/
&,,
;,
/ , -
,, 73
/-&
,/,-N *
L7L
,
4,
$5
( N * / , CAI
/ ,
)>
,-4>)
25-
7-
,=>
-/-
,<=>
)(
L
--
,)2'2
(/
L7,
/
,
-
;/-7
/-
3--
,-7
,/QE
@
3/
,-/#QE
,
-
>QE/--
3+
,
3-/QE4/#$>QE5
, , / : - + 7 = , / - -3
>D
-/
- , $$ 2 - , ( -
,>(L
,
3
7
,-,
2,-3
3
(
-3-
,
2
,3
/-
4,
))
=5-
(7
,>F3
)
CA
N *I-7
/
0
3
,/Q,
,,
>
>
N *7
,
=
/
%2
' - / - 3 / - 3 ,
4/
6
' ,
- ,
6 '5 , /
-
0
%/=-
,
C
/,
/ , , /
-L
-
/ - -
,
/-
7
3L
,
=
.1!/
3/QE,
,#
Estimating Impacts on the
Current and Proposed Urban
Drainage System
1
3
-
,
,- /&&>&&&&,
-
$
Impacts on the Current Urban Drainage System
@/
.I
-,
4($5(-
-
-4/2VW5,
#F
2)F,
24'25
>)F,
>4'>5,
&&&,
@
-
:-
,
&&&,
>
/
&&&,
,
&&>&2/
&&&,
,
2
&&>&>(-
, ,
4/ @ 5 ,
) Table 7
Waterlogged Area in Khulna with Climate Change (%)
<'
4#
5
-
-
4@?@?@25
2
#
$
%
>
2)
$
%
#
>&&&
,
)
2
2
%
2
>)
>&&>&
,
>%
%
)
2
<<
4G5
<&
4G25
<2
42G=5
&&&
,
=)
$
=
&&>&
,
%
$
2&&&
,
=
2&&>&
,
<%
4=G#5
O
"
+(
&
!
+
$
%%
"
/,,7
,
D
-/,
,7-,
/.I
,,,
-
,-
7,
,-
/
3
%9 ,
)#2=2>&&&,
(
3
,
,
)F
)F2>%F>
Proposed Improvements to the Urban Drainage System and Impacts
of Climate Change on the Improved System
.I 3 ,, -
,
(,
/-
-
-
%
,
/-
%F
,
-,,
,
4/,
,2
5*
,
/
-
,//&3
,
-/-
<$
,
&&>&
<$
,
&&&
(
(%
-
--
2>'2>
-&&>&&&&,
-
,
Table 8
-
=
&&>
,
&&
,
2&&>
,
2&&
,
>&&>&
,
>&&
,
6
"
1
"
1
"
1
"
1
"
1
"
1
Waterlogged City Area, with Climate Change (%)
<<
4G5
%
#
=)
%$
$
%2
=
$#
>%
=%
)
=)
<&
<2
4G25 42G=5
$
=
$
>
%
%
$
$
2
%
=
%
#
%
%
2
%
2
<%
4=G#5
<'
4#
5
2
>
)
%
$
2
-
-
4@?@?@25
#
%
%
22
)
2
>)
#
O
"
+(
&
!
+,
%
(8
,/9-
,
/
,
(
,
/-
,
/
,
-
,
1
7KH(FRQRPLFVRI$GDSWDWLRQWR&OLPDWH&KDQJH$6\QWKHVLV5HSRUW)LQDOFRQVXOWDWLRQ
GUDIW1
/*
%7 ,
/-
,
22F
)F2/,
>)F
#F
>&&&,
/,
,
,
,
=2
)$/
,,,
,,
>%F
2F>,
&
,
@
-3
,,
>&&&
-
D
-/ 2 >/ , %F , - ,
&,
(,
/
4/
57
.,
-
Adaptation Options
-,
'2>
,-/-
,
-
(
/
/&3
,-/
/
-
,/
.I-
2>
%F
,-,,
,
(#
-
--
-
/
-
-
@2(
-
)/
3
,
,
2F>-&&&,
(,22=F,
/,
&
&
,
-
,
,
/
,
&/-
Table 9
-
=
6
2/
&&>
,
"
2/
"
&&
,
>/
"
&&>&
,
>/
"
&& ,
Waterlogged City Area, with Climate Change (%)
<<
4G5
<&
4G25
<2
42G=5
$
%2
%=
%
%
$
#
%
$
%
$
=
$#
%
$
$
$
%
2
>
22
)
>%
=%
%
%
)
2
)
=)
%
2
%
=
2
%
$
2
2
>)
#
)
O
"
+(
&
!
+,
-
<%
<'
-
4=G#5 4#
5 4@?@?@25
%3 ,
/
-/-
,
(
-
3
,,
**
4,
#5
45
4/ ,
, 5J 45 4/ -5J45
3
4/&5
'
,
-
-,
7,
-,,
,
' = % 4/ - - & 5 (/ -
,
- ,
- ( # ,
, ( G, - /,4/
5
,
-,,
,,
(
;)&,
-4,
>5F
/#,
%#,
>&
)#$,
&
(
,2)F,
>&
F,
&
2
( ,/ -/ / , ,/
Table 10
Cost of Drainage System Improvements for Different Scenarios
("D
/
-
=
2&"D
/
BH6
D
BH6
D
4(
5 4<
5 4(
5 4<
5 4(
5 4<
5 4(
5 4<
5
)#2
$
2
=)
#
))
>
/2
%$
>
$>
$
2
2#
=
>
)
/=$
=$
%#)
2
Cy0O
"
+
,
,
%F
,-,,
,
!/
Cy0
,
-
!
+
#
2
,F,
:
,*
(
G,
7,
,
,,
-
/
,
-
@
/,
7,
2>
-
2/
=2
)$
)
)#
)
2#
4%5
45
4$5
-
>-
>-
>-/
/
2-
2-
2-/
/
,45
,
,45
,
,
2
,45
,
,
>
>
)
2
=
$
>
)%
>
E
/%$
%%
$
)2>
=2
/2
/>$
)/#=)
2/$)>
=
22
!
+,
"
+(
&(
,
O
)
22
2""2&
D
/
<
=
=/=2
#)
))#
=)2
/2$)
)/%2
/$>
2/==>
2
)
6
/=
/%$
)>>
/>=
2/>#2
2/==
#/2)>
/>$
>#/>)%
#
>=)
B
Damage Costs and Adaptation Benefits (Tk million)
,
-
45
Table 11
)
2
2
2
$
2
,
#>
2$
%
)>
/)#)
$2
/=%
)/=>
=>
>2>
/
/>#>
%$
2/=$$
>/$
#/)=
$/>#
2#/>#
%/=$#
%>
/>>
!
=
/
>
-
%5
'& ,
Proposed Investment Project
(-
-
,
7
,
.2
-
L/
,
-
-
(
4,
8,
95-
3
<>=
/
,
/
,
/
,
/&3
/
,
/
,
,,
(
,
-(
,,
/-
-
-(
7
,,
2>
/,
,
*
-
<)
,
2<
,
>
(*'
:/-.I
:/3
,
,
,
,.
Table 12
-
=
Waterlogged Area in Khulna with Unified Improvement (%)
6
<'
-
<<
<&
<2
<%
4#
<
4G5 4G25 42G=5 4=G#5 5 4@?@?@25
G ;,
%#
>
=
=
2
G ;,
#
)
=
=
;,
?
#
>
>
>
G ;,
$=
$
=
$
;,
?
%
=
>
O
"
+(
&
!
+,
2
7HFKQLFDO $VVLVWDQFH WR WKH 3HRSOHIV 5HSXEOLF RI %DQJODGHVK IRU 3UHSDULQJ WKH &LW\ 5HJLRQ 'HYHORSPHQW
3URMHFW *
I 0J # &LWLHV 'HYHORSPHQW ,QLWLDWLYH IRU $VLD 6XSSRUW WR .KXOQD &LW\
&RUSRUDWLRQ*
I
0
Limitations and Conclusions
Limitations
(
/
/N */1
,
2
-
/
-
,
/,
-(/
,
-,
(
,
-
E
, / ,
/ "
, . 2 > - 6
,/
L
,
/@/
6
*0
-
,
-
,
-
/ /
/--3
,/
,
E//
,,
--7
,/
,/
-/
/-
4,
%5 (/ ,
1
,
,
-/
,
/,
,
-
/,&
,
/
-
,
/
;
-
),
/
-
, , - ,,
,
-
,7,(,
/
-
,
/
7
@/ - , , 3 (-
./,
,/
-
&,,
,
-
/,
&
-&
/-,,
,,
,&
,
!
/,-
,
(/,
(
,
-4
:/5,
/
,
-
2
1
/ / N * &OLPDWH 5LVNV DQG $GDSWDWLRQ LQ $VLDQ &RDVWDO 0HJDFLWLHV $ 6\QWKHVLV 5HSRUW
1
/*
'2
'% ,
,0
/
4,
5D
-/-
7,
-
/7
&
/
,-
7
,
:/
,,
-
C / , - , /
- - -
*
-
,/7
,-
(,
/,
,
-
/,
,
Conclusions
(
-
3
.I-(
&
-
,
L
,
@
,
1-
/-
7
,
/
--
3,
* - .I -
/
/
,,
(
,
,
,
,
0
/ 7 3
/ , -
7
/
%F
,-,
,
&&& / - < G<$ / , 73
(
G,//
:,
(
,,
-&
3 , , 7/ ,
,,
(,7
:,
-
/
-/
,
, , , / -/&/
-(
6
' 3 - - ,, ,
@
J
,&
,-
,
( - I ,
, - .(,
/,
,
:-
-
:-
,/
-,/
(/ , - , ,/
/
,
:C
&
,/
,,/
,
-
,,,,,-
:
-
$GDSWLQJWR&OLPDWH&KDQJH
!
"
#
$
!
$
%&'&
%&(&
)
*
)
$
!
*
"
+
$ERXWWKH$VLDQ'HYHORSPHQW%DQN
,-.
,
/
0
-
.
"
.
1
2 3
4%
5&'
42 %(
,-
6
,-
78
93
0
,
-
*
7
,-
,
6
2((&
6
6
/
:
583"5%"5&5%"%"
/
*
: /!22%599
/
/
/