battle of new orleans - Louisiana State Museum
Transcription
battle of new orleans - Louisiana State Museum
Commemorating the Bicentennial of the Battle of New Orleans 1815-2015 Desk Reference for Educators ©2014 Developed for the Battle of New Orleans Bicentennial Commission by the Office of the Lieutenant Governor and The Historic New Orleans Collection Author of Narrative Jason Wiese Associate Director Williams Research Center of The Historic New Orleans Collection Lesson Design and Project Director Ann Lilly Trappey Education Consultant For information, please contact Richard Hartley Director of Special Projects Office of the Lieutenant Governor [email protected] or Julie Vezinot Director of Boards and Commissions Office of the Lieutenant Governor [email protected] A BATTLE REMEMBERED Battle of New Orleans 1815 Battle of New Orleans Commission The following are members of the commission: Honorable W. Henson Moore III (Chairman), Baton Rouge; Mike Bayham, Chalmette; Edward O. Cailleteau Baton Rouge; William Highland, Chalmette; Gary D. Joiner, Ph.D., Shreveport; Representative Nick Lorusso, New Orleans; Elizabeth McDougall, Arabi; Mark Romig, New Orleans; Willam A. Schultz, New Orleans; Katie Tommaseo, Arabi; Roger Villere Jr., Metairie; Mark Zelden, New Orleans. A Message From LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR JAY DARDENNE The 200th anniversary of the Battle of New Orleans (1815–2015) provides Louisianans with another exciting education opportunity. Once commemorated as a national holiday every January 8, the Battle of New Orleans was remembered as one of the most significant military victories in our nation’s early history. General Andrew Jackson’s triumph helped to foster our national identity when the United States was an infant republic. Yet few Americans today know much about the Battle of New Orleans, or the broader War of 1812 of which it was a part. The 200th anniversary provides educators a unique opportunity to focus on the importance of the Battle of New Orleans and the War of 1812. The Battle of New Orleans Commission, chaired by former Congressman Henson Moore, the Office of the Lieutenant Governor, The Historic New Orleans Collection, and the Department of Culture, Recreation and Tourism have developed this standards-based desk reference. Designed for ease of implementation and aligned to state standards and GLEs, the lesson plans and projects will assist teachers in actively engaging all students in learning about Louisiana, especially the importance of the Battle of New Orleans. As we join together to commemorate the 200th anniversary of the Battle of New Orleans, I urge you to make full use of the educational materials which are being provided. Please visit the Battle of New Orleans website, www.battleofneworleans2015.com or the Department of Culture, Recreation and Tourism site, www.crt.state.la.us/education, for more information about our educational resources and opportunities. It is my desire that Louisiana students will experience a renaissance in the learning of Louisiana history and culture. Field trips to The Historic New Orleans Collection, the Chalmette Battlefield, operated by the National Park Service, and other historical sites and museums such as the Cabildo in New Orleans or the Capitol Park Museum in Baton Rouge are strongly encouraged. It is my pleasure to provide this curriculum and my hope that it will assist in achieving academic growth at your school. Thanks for all you do for the students of the great state of Louisiana! JAY DARDENNE TABLE OF CONTENTS I. BATTLE OF NEW ORLEANS: AN OVERVIEW............................1 II. ACTIVITIES 1. Battles for New Orleans Timeline.............................................35 2. Plotting the Course .................................................................36 3. Why Was New Orleans So Important?.....................................37 4. John Bull Before New Orleans ................................................38 5. The Life of Andrew Jackson......................................................40 6. Problems, Obstacles, & Opposing Forces.................................42 7. Assorted Defenders...................................................................45 8. Jackson’s Louisiana Forces.........................................................48 9. Battle of Lake Borgne, the First Battle for New Orleans...........49 10.The British Arrive.....................................................................51 11.Preparing Line Jackson.............................................................53 12.The Night Battle of December 23, 1814..................................54 13.Military Music.........................................................................56 14.The Engagement of December 28, 1814..................................58 15.Unwelcome Guests...................................................................60 16.The Artillery Duel of January 1, 1815......................................61 17.What if the Baratarians Had Sided with the British?.................62 18.Women of New Orleans...........................................................64 19.January 8, 1815, Battle of New Orleans...................................66 20.Treaty of Ghent........................................................................69 21.Songs About the Battle of New Orleans...................................71 III. APPENDIX Extended Response Rubric.............................................................75 Grade Level Expectations Literacy and Writing Standards..............76 Selected Sources.............................................................................80 BATTLE OF NEW ORLEANS: AN OVERVIEW INTRODUCTION The anniversary of the Battle of New Orleans was once celebrated as a national holiday every January 8th. Americans remembered it as the most significant military victory in our nation’s early history, with the possible exception of Yorktown, during the Revolutionary War. General Andrew Jackson’s triumph helped to foster our national identity when the United States was still an infant republic. Yet few Americans today know much about the Battle of New Orleans, or the broader War of 1812 of which it was a part. “The United States in 1812” map. Archiving Early America. March 15, 2014. WHY WAS NEW ORLEANS SO IMPORTANT? In the early 1800s, American growth beyond the Appalachians relied on the port of New Orleans, which served the Mississippi River and by extension the entire interior of the continent. Hundreds of new farms and settlements in the Ohio River valley, Kentucky, and Tennessee produced crops and commodities that were too heavy to carry overland to the markets on the East Coast. In the days before steam propulsion, bulky cargoes had to be floated downriver on rafts or flatboats. Most of the streams and rivers in the western American territories led to the Mississippi and to the old French and Spanish city of New Orleans. This is why the United States purchased New Orleans and the vast colonial province of Louisiana in 1803. By the start of the War of 1812, despite its being part of the United States for nearly a decade, New Orleans was still geographically and culturally isolated from the rest of the country. There were no roads and hundreds of miles of a mostly unbroken wilderness separating Louisiana from the other states. Getting there could be difficult, as the threats of hostile Indians by land and pirates by sea were ever present. Even so, New Orleans was a growing, cosmopolitan city of approximately 20,000 people by 1814, almost evenly divided between white and black people. Unlike their Englishspeaking Protestant countrymen, New Orleanians were Latin and Catholic in their history and culture. They tended to speak French or Spanish instead of English, a habit reinforced by the recent arrival of thousands of French-speaking refugees from the Haitian Revolution. The city’s foodways and architecture marked it as radically different from the rest of the United States, a unique blend of European, African, and Caribbean traditions. Yet the former territorial capital became a new state capital when Louisiana entered the Union as the eighteenth American state in April of 1812. Two months later, President Madison declared war on Great Britain, and Louisiana became a possible target for invasion. Because of their isolation from the rest of the country, the people of Louisiana were not as caught up in the war against Great Britain, either for it or against it. Local merchants suffered some losses due to the British Royal Navy stopping American ships and seizing cargoes and seamen, but authorities in New 1 Orleans were far more concerned about the rumors of British spies inciting Indian attacks and slave uprisings in the sparsely populated southern territories. Governor William C. C. Claiborne understood that New Orleans was poorly defended and somewhat politically unstable because of its diverse population. American flags flew in the Place d’Armes (now Jackson Square), but many New Orleanians considered themselves to be French or Spanish at heart, even if they saw opportunities in the new, young republic of the United States. The early nineteenth century was a politically complicated time: revolution had spread from the Americas in the 1780s to France in the 1790s, and was still spreading through the Caribbean and back to the Gulf of Mexico. The future seemed very uncertain, and no one knew if the United States would succeed and grow. Our strong national identity had not yet emerged. was no way the United States could defend itself from the huge and powerful fleet of the Royal Navy. There were some early victories in single-ship actions that were celebrated in America and that angered the British public, but soon enough the tide swung around in Britain’s favor, and the Royal Navy imposed a tight blockade of American ports, choking off trade and bottling up our few warships in port. Great Britain actually hadn’t wanted to go to war with the United States at all, because it was already embroiled in a life-or-death struggle with Napoleon Bonaparte’s France. As an island nation, Britain faced the constant threat of being invaded by sea, or of having its seaborne trade cut off. To counter these threats, Britain developed its large and powerful Royal Navy, which had to patrol and control the seas worldwide to protect extensive trade routes, colonies, and allies. Trade restrictions were another type of warfare: Napoleon imposed a “Continental system” to block British trade with Europe. Britain responded with its own “Orders in Council,” which cut off trade between Napoleonic France and the rest of the world. The young United States was simply caught in the middle of a European war. Even though it was a neutral nation, its merchant fleet, which had long carried trade between Europe and the Americas, became a target for the warring British and French. American ships and cargoes bound for France were seized by the Royal Navy as prizes of war, and British-born seamen were “impressed,” or forced into service in the Royal Navy. Why was this? A single frigate required a crew of more than two hundred men. Hundreds of warships patrolling the seas in all weather conditions required tens of thousands of sailors, and new men were always desperately needed. The British government, aware that MR. MADISON’S WAR If New Orleans was vulnerable to attack, so too was the rest of the United States. When President Madison declared war against Great Britain in June of 1812, he was challenging one of the most powerful militaries in the world. Britain’s Royal Navy had triumphed against the combined fleets of France and Spain and controlled the world’s oceans. The British army had been at war almost continually since the 1790s, and its veteran regiments had seen every kind of fighting through Europe, the Mediterranean, and beyond. By contrast, at the beginning of the War of 1812, the United States had no large standing army or navy. President Madison’s predecessor, Thomas Jefferson, had relied upon citizen militias and a small fleet of gunboats to patrol harbors and inland waterways. The construction of large navy frigates begun by Jefferson’s predecessor, John Adams, had been suspended years before. Even if it hadn’t, there 2 Causes of the War of 1812 British impressment of American sailors Seizures of American ships and cargoes by the Royal Navy Indian attacks against American frontier settlements thought to be encouraged by British agents Desire by some Americans to “annex” Canada as part of United States “Mr. Madison’s War” (1812). The Historic New Orleans Collection, 2001– 68– L.3 The William C. Cook War of 1812 in the South Collection. their policies were infuriating the Americans, eventually withdrew some of the restrictions that were affecting American sea trade, but the news travelled too slowly to avoid the American declaration of war. From its beginning, the War of 1812 was unpopular in some parts of the United States, especially New England, whose maritime economy was being strangled by the Royal Navy blockade of its ports. But it wasn’t popular in Britain, either. After years of war against France on the Continent, the cost of yet another war seemed too much to bear. The first two years of war were inconclusive, and consisted largely of skirmishes along the Canadian border. In 1814, after Napoleon’s armies had finally been defeated in Spain and at the Battle of Toulouse, in France, the Royal Navy in North America was joined by veteran British army regiments. In an effort to put a quick end to “the American War” in the summer of 1814, the redcoats marched into Washington, DC, and burned most of the government buildings there, including the White House. Even though the British offensive eventually stalled and withdrew from the Chesapeake, it was clear that “Mr. Madison’s War” was not going well. 3 LOUISIANA’S SITUATION IN 1814 That was the news in New Orleans in the late summer and fall of 1814, and it was mixed with disturbing rumors about a planned British invasion of Louisiana. It turns out that the rumors were absolutely true. In fact, the idea had been suggested two years earlier, in August of 1812, as a way to reduce American pressure on British Canada. In March 1813, Royal Navy captain James Stirling contributed a detailed report on Louisiana’s terrain and defenses. Stirling and others believed that the cultural differences between TIMELINE: Summer of 1814 July 5 Royal Navy squadron ordered to blockade Mississippi River August 10 British government officially authorizes invasion of Louisiana and seizure of New Orleans August 24 Washington, DC, burned by British troops August 30 Lt. Lockyer ordered to contact, recruit Baratarian pirates 4 Louisianans and Anglo-Americans could be exploited to aid the British cause. Royal Marines had been landed in Spanish West Florida to arm Creek and Seminole warriors, and one of them, Colonel Edward Nicolls, issued a proclamation to the “Natives of Louisiana” encouraging them to rise up against the illegal and “imbecilic” US government. Some British diplomats and government ministers even claimed that the 1803 Louisiana Purchase had been illegal, pointing out that Napoleon Bonaparte lacked the legal authority to sell Louisiana to the United States or anyone else. An existing treaty had dictated that Louisiana must be returned to Spain if France ever decided not to keep it. Yet Napoleon was powerful enough in 1803 to ignore inconvenient political agreements, and it was in the interests of the United States to play along. In any event, on August 10, 1814, the British government issued official orders to proceed with the invasion. The Pirate Laffite One of the more colorful characters associated with the Battle of New Orleans is the famous (or infamous) pirate Jean Laffite (also spelled Lafitte). He has been the subject of many books and at least two movies (both called “The Buccaneer”). Many popular versions of the story hold that Laffite acted as one of General Jackson’s guides and advisors during the battle, and that he saved the American cause with large quantities of gunpowder and the assistance of his crew of Baratarian pirates. The historical Jean Laffite was probably born in Bordeaux, France, sometime around 1780. Eventually he and his older brother Pierre Laffite (1770–1821) ended up on the northern Gulf Coast, where they established an armed encampment on Grand Terre, in Barataria Bay. Their business was piracy and the smuggling of contraband goods into American Louisiana, including enslaved persons from the West Indies. Business was good for the Laffites: many prominent citizens bought their stolen merchandise, as many of these goods were difficult to buy legally in Louisiana at the time. Legends continue to swirl around the brothers, some more easily verified than others. The Laffites did offer their services to the American side after they were approached by the British in September of 1814, and General Jackson eventually overcame his reluctance to be aided by “hellish banditti” and accepted their aid. The Laffites contributed a large quantity of gunflints for American muskets and rifles, and a crew of Baratarians manned one of the American gun batteries on Jackson’s front line. Pierre Laffite appears to have acted as an advisor to General Jackson, but Jean Laffite was almost certainly not present on the battlefield during the crisis, and was instead guarding one of the southern approaches to the city, in an area near the present-day Jean Lafitte National Park and Preserve. For their assistance against the British invaders, the Laffites and their men earned pardons from the United States government and many of them subsequently left Louisiana. Jean Laffite is believed to have died off the Mexican Yucatan coast in 1826. Stories about buried treasure left behind by Laffite and his Baratarian pirates can still be heard in Louisiana to this day. PREPARING THE INVASION In early September of 1814, before a large invasion fleet began to assemble in Jamaica, British officers attempted to enlist Jean Laffite’s Baratarians. The Royal Navy was well aware of the pirates, who had seized English merchant vessels in the Gulf of Mexico. British officers were confident that Laffite knew every nook and cranny of the coast—all the secret routes through the swamps and into the city. Jean Laffite put them off, however, stalling for time until he could cut a better deal with the Americans. Copies of the British proposals to Laffite soon found their way into Governor Claiborne’s hands, and from there, sped their way to the new commandant of the 7th US Military District, a recently commissioned major general formerly of the Tennessee Militia. His name was Andrew Jackson. “OLD HICKORY” The 47-year-old Jackson was an unknown factor to both Louisianans and the British. A tall, rugged man of Scotch-Irish ancestry, Jackson had a quick temper and a fierce loyalty to his friends and family. He wasn’t formally trained like military officers of today, and prior to entering the militia, he’d had a career as a lawyer, judge, and politician in the frontier settlements of Tennessee. His hawk-like eyes suggested a personality that was pitiless and inflexible. The Creek Indians—on whom he had honed his skills as a soldier—had a name for him: “Sharp Knife.” His men called him “Old Hickory” because he was as tough and reliable as that wood. Jackson essentially learned how to be a soldier on the job and in the saddle during the Creek War of 1813 and 1814, much as he had learned to be a circuit judge riding from settlement to settlement alone, in the wilderness, as a young man. What he may have lacked in formal training, Jackson made up for in determination and unusually sound instincts. His strategy of carrying the war to the enemy and beating him on his own ground brought the Creek War to an end the previous March, and earned him a promotion into the regular US army. In his new job, Jackson became responsible for the security of what was then the southwestern corner of the United States, including New Orleans. In the end, the Creek War provided Jackson with valuable training for the impending British invasion of Louisiana. Jackson’s dislike of redcoats went back to his boyhood in the Carolinas. A popular story relates an incident during the Revolutionary War: a young Andrew Jackson refused to polish a British officer’s boots, and for his disobedience he received sword cuts to his face. The deaths of his brothers and mother during the war left him an orphan, and he nursed a deep hatred of the British years later, as a man. When news from Louisiana’s governor arrived concerning the British invasion of Louisiana, Jackson had just seized Pensacola in Spanish West Florida to deny the British a safe harbor. He knew the Royal Navy had already tried and failed to take Mobile Bay, but he didn’t know when or where they would strike next. The evidence from New Orleans was strong, and Jackson departed Mobile for Louisiana on November 11, traveling overland to scout all the landing sites and possible 5 approaches to the threatened city. He and his men arrived on a cold and rainy December morning at Fort St. Jean, just outside of New Orleans. By now, rumors of the British invasion were rampant, and a sense of doom pervaded the city. At first glance, the general looked gaunt and worn, his clothes shabby from the long journey. However, the locals also noticed how he sat ramrod straight in the saddle. Jackson went immediately to meet with the governor and mayor, and that afternoon, he addressed a crowd that had gathered outside. He was brief, but full of fire: the British were coming, he told them. He was there to fight and defend the city. Would they join him? Out in the crowd, the Creoles and people of all different backgrounds saw and heard him, and sensed that there was something different about this man, and that he meant exactly what he said. Gloom gave way to hope and even excitement. Men who the day before would have called themselves Spaniards or Frenchmen made up their minds to stand with Jackson and fight as Americans. 6 “Major General Andrew Jackson” (1819). The Historic New Orleans Collection, 1979.112 JACKSON’S SOLDIERS For his part, Jackson was dismayed in the days that followed to find a poorly defended city paralyzed by social and political disagreements. He immediately went to work, personally surveying the terrain and ordering improvements to defensive works. Locals were ordered to obstruct all the bayous and creeks that might aid the British approach. General Jackson also reviewed both his regular US troops and the Louisiana militia. He did have some professional soldiers, but not many— only about 1,100 men and some sailors. Fortunately, Jackson’s professional soldiers would be aided by militia and volunteers from Louisiana, Mississippi, Tennessee, and eventually Kentucky. As state militias and volunteers poured into the city that December, Jackson approved the raising and equipping of additional units, including Choctaw Indians, Baratarian pirates, and two armed battalions of free colored men. Free colored men had served in the local militia since the Spanish colonial period. Some had served with distinction in the West Florida campaigns of Bernardo de Gálvez in the 1780s. Under the Spanish system, there was a policy called fuero militar, which was a special legal status given to men serving in either the regular army or the militia. This legal privilege Jackson’s Regular Troops • US Light Artillery • 7th Regiment US Infantry • 44th Regiment US Infantry • US Marines • US Light Dragoons • US Navy Approximately 1,100 men “Laffite The Pirate” (1945). The Historic New Orleans Collection, 1983.123.9. A Free Colored Battalion Soldier - National Park Service A member of Captain Thomas Beale’s New Orleans Rifles - National Park Service 7 included exemptions from certain taxes. For free men of color, it was a means of obtaining a legal status that was equal—or nearly equal— to their white neighbors. There was also the social prestige that came from wearing a uniform. Andrew Jackson had made clear in a proclamation to the free colored inhabitants of Louisiana that they would be treated equally to white soldiers, and they accepted his promise. The men of the Free Colored Battalion of New Orleans stepped forward for service and were soon joined by a second battalion of free colored volunteers, recent immigrants to Louisiana from Haiti. Together, the two battalions brought over 450 men under Jackson’s command. Some white locals rebelled, but when an assistant paymaster questioned Jackson’s authority to employ black soldiers, the general responded sharply, “Be pleased to keep to yourself your opinions upon the policy of making payments to the troops with the necessary muster rolls without enquiring whether the troops are white, black, or tea.” Jackson had no time for nonsense. Time was running out: strange sails had been sighted in the Gulf. Other Louisiana Militia Troops and Where They Came From • Jedediah Smith’s “Feliciana Troop of Horse” (St. Francisville area) • Dubuclet’s Volunteer Troop of Hussars (Bayou Teche, Attakapas District) • Hubbard’s “Mounted Company of the 2nd Brigade” (Attakapas) • Griffith’s “Volunteer Company of Mounted Riflemen” (Bayou Sara, Feliciana Parish) • Gordon’s “Company of Volunteer Infantry from Rapides” • Trudeau’s “St. Charles Troop of Horse” (St. Charles and St. James Parishes) • Chauveau’s “Company of Orleans Cavalry” (New Orleans) • Ogden’s “Orleans Troop of Dragoons” (New Orleans) • LeDoux’s “Company of Volunteers of Pointe Coupee” • Alpuente’s “Company of Louisiana Bayou Militia” (New Orleans) • Thomas’ Company of Louisiana Militia (Baton Rouge) • Thibodeaux’s Detachment of Lafourche Volunteers Source: Powell Casey, Louisiana in the War of 1812 (Baton Rouge, 1963) Kentucky Militia - National Park Service 8 THE INVADERS ARRIVE - National Park Service The advance ships from the British fleet had arrived off the mouth of the Mississippi at the same time Jackson reached New Orleans on December 1, 1814. Their flagship, HMS Tonnant, anchored a week later near Ship Island, some eighty-five miles from the city. Due to the sandbar at the mouth of the Mississippi River, and the shallowness of the inland waterways, large British warships could get no closer to the city. Even so, British morale was high, despite the uninviting terrain and difficulties ahead. Little new information had come in about New Orleans’ defenses except that they consisted mostly of militia and volunteers. British naval and army commanders began planning their approach to the city, which required the capture or destruction of the American gunboats sighted in Lake Borgne. Lieutenant Nicholas Lockyer assembled 45 launches and barges from the fleet, and 1,000 seamen and volunteers to man them. This fleet of pulling boats, armed with muskets and small naval cannons, entered Lake Borgne on December 12; their objective was the fleet of five American gunboats, which they caught 48 hours later. Anne S.K. Brown Military Collection, Brown University Library 9 THE FIRST BATTLE The naval Battle of Lake Borgne on December 14 ended with the capture of all five gunboats and one dispatch vessel, the Alligator. The first battle of New Orleans had been won by the British. It was a costly victory, and even Lt. Lockyer was badly wounded, but the way was now open for British troop transports, and small parties began to explore the western shore of Lake Borgne for the best route to the city. When news of the battle reached New Orleans the following day, December 15, panic gripped the city, and Jackson realized that without the gunboats he would be blind to the movements of the British force. “Battle of Lake Borgne” (Between 1815 and 1844). The Historic New Orleans Collection, 1950.54. The Sacrifice The plantation house of Maj. Gen. Jacques Villeré was used by the British as headquarters from December 23, 1814, to January 19, 1815. This drawing shows the old house as it was about 1860 -- National Park Service 10 Governor Jacques Philippe Villeré (LSM 01145), oil on canvas, by Andres Molinary, c. 1910. Courtesy of the Collections of the Louisiana State Museum. Alexander Walker, writing about the Battle of New Orleans in the 1850s, relates a tale connected with the British landing on December 23, 1814. Major Gabriel Villeré of the Louisiana Militia had been tasked with guarding the downriver approach to the city, but he and his men were surprised by British advance troops and captured at his father’s plantation. The young Villeré was determined to escape and raise the alarm in the city. This he did, seizing a moment while his captors were distracted to dive through a window and run into the trees as darkness fell. As British troops pursued him, spreading out to cut off any chance of escape, Major Villeré found himself at the foot of a large live oak tree on the edge of the cypress swamp. He was cut off and certain to be recaptured. His plan was to climb the tree and evade detection until the searchers had passed. But as he started to climb, he heard a whimper at his feet. “He looked down and beheld his favorite setter crouched piteously on the ground,” Walker wrote, “by her mournful look and action, expressing … her sympathy for the perils of her master, and her desire to share his fate.” The major’s heart sank at the sight of her, for her presence under the tree would reveal his hiding place, and everything—his family’s honor and the fate of his city—depended on his successful escape. He had no choice but to sacrifice his loyal friend. “With a deep sigh and eyes full of tears,” Walker tells us,” the young creole seized a large stick and striking the poor, fawning, faithful dog as she cowered at his feet, soon dispatched her.” The major hid her body and climbed the tree, thereby eluding the searching British soldiers. At length he managed to find his way to General Jackson’s headquarters in the city, and was the first to alert him that the British army had landed in Louisiana. Whether the story of Major Villeré’s dog is true or an artful embellishment we do not know. Historians continue to sort fact from fiction in the many stories of the Battle of New Orleans. PUBLIC REACTION AND MARTIAL LAW TIMELINE: Early December 1814 December 1 Andrew Jackson arrives in New Orleans, rallies locals to defend city December 8 –11 Large British fleet anchors near Ship Island, off Louisiana coast Jackson spread out his available force to cover all the approaches to New Orleans, ensuring good communication so that they could be quickly brought together to any point of attack. He appears to have kept his numerical strength a secret, even from his own junior officers. Jackson was beginning to have his doubts about the loyalty of New Orleans, and those doubts, along with the panic in the city after Lake Borgne, led him to declare martial law, though he had no legal authority to do so. A strict curfew was implemented, and hunting guns and other weapons were taken from households for military use. HELP ARRIVES FROM FELLOW STATES December 9 –16 Volunteers pour into New Orleans, including some Choctaws and free colored men from Haiti December 14 Battle of Lake Borgne December 16 Jackson declares martial law in New Orleans Carroll’s Tennessee Militia - National Park Service On December 20, two large groups of Tennessee militia arrived from upriver along with Thomas Hinds’ Mississippi Dragoons. The Tennesseans were led by Jackson’s friends John Coffee and Billy Carroll. Kentucky militia troops were known to be en route. What brought young men from the frontier settlements down to New Orleans? Some of the Tennesseans had served with Jackson in the Creek War, seeing it as a duty to protect their homes from hostile Indian attacks. New Orleans was also important to the future prosperity of their farms and towns, as everything they grew and manufactured would have to float down the river to the port, and from there to markets elsewhere in America and abroad. There was also militia pay and the promise of land 11 bounties from the government. Most were young men, accustomed to hard work and deprivation, and handy with a musket or rifle. One problem was arming them, as muskets and rifles were in very short supply. Another problem was linguistic: many of the local soldiers and volunteers in New Orleans spoke only French, which complicated relations between locals and out-of-state units. Yet Jackson’s personality was indomitable, and he required every soldier to do his duty, no matter what language he spoke. Jackson’s headquarters was a hive of activity, and on the afternoon of December 23, news arrived that hit like a thunderbolt: the British had landed in force downriver. Jackson’s response was immediate. He said, “By the eternal, they shall not sleep on our soil.” He would attack them that very night. Militia and Volunteers December 1814 – January 1815 • Plauche’s Uniformed Battalion of Orleans Volunteers • Louisiana Militia Companies • Captain Thomas Beale’s Company of New Orleans Rifles • LaCoste’s 1st Battalion of Free Men of Color • Daquin’s 2nd Battalion of St. Domingue Free Men of Color • Captain Pierre Jugeant’s Choctaws • Coffee’s Brigade of Mounted Tennessee Gunmen • William Carroll’s Mounted Tennessee Volunteers • John Adair’s Kentucky rifles • Hinds’ Mississippi Dragoons • Jean Laffite’s Baratarians Approximately 4,100 men Hinds’ Mississippi Mounted Rifles - National Park Service 12 THE BRITISH LANDING they shall “ Bynotthesleepeternal, on our soil ! ” -Andrew Jackson “Map Showing the Landing of the British Army”(1816). The Historic New Orleans Collection, 1979.238.7. At this point, a British advance force of approximately 1,600 men, plus rocket artillery, had successfully landed in secret, having reached a point about eight miles below the city. Their route had been scouted six days earlier by two British officers dressed as local fishermen, who had studied the plantations and levee road without being detected. Though the advance comprised only about a third of the troops available, the cream of the force was here, including elements of veteran British regiments such as the 95th Rifles Regiment, who wore distinctive green jackets instead of the usual red coats. This advance was led by Major General John Keane, temporarily commanding the ground forces until the expected arrival of Sir Edward Michael Pakenham. Though some of his men wanted to push on, Keane ordered the main body to make camp on the grounds of Villeré’s plantation, near the river, after establishing guards, forward observers, and scouting parties. In this defensive position they could rest and refresh themselves until reinforcements could reach them, hopefully that evening. Due to the shortage of small boats, the British could only land, at most, two thousand men at a time, and that only after hours of strenuous rowing back and forth across Lake Borgne. General Keane knew that he was at least ten hours away from being reinforced and resupplied. His initial landing had been unopposed, but he was still outnumbered and outgunned by the Americans. Therefore, he would be careful, wait for the rest of his army to come up, and move on the city in force. On the afternoon of December 23, the outposts alerted the British camp that a body of American horsemen was approaching down the river road. About two hundred brightly dressed cavalry advanced in loose formation, but they quickly retreated after the British formed a line of defense and fired a volley at them. The British veterans were not at all impressed by this first look at the Americans, and the incident only reinforced their general impression that they would meet no determined resistance. Yet at about seven that night, after dark, they discovered that they were quite mistaken. 13 THE “NIGHT BATTLE” OF DECEMBER 23, 1814 14 Confused fighting and marching in the dark, illuminated momentarily by flashes of gunfire— such was the battle of December 23. Photocopy by Dan Leyrer from Frost’s Pictorial Life of Andrew Jackson. - National Park Service Major-General Sir Edward Pakenham - National Park Service As most of their comrades gathered around campfires, or slept, the guards near the river watched what they supposed to be an American merchant schooner glide down the river and anchor opposite the Villeré plantation. They called out to the sailors aboard, but got no response, until the schooner suddenly opened fire on them. This was the USS Carolina, and her cannons were the prearranged signal for an all-out attack. While the deadly cannonade pounded the British camp, the forward guard posts heard the tell-tale rumble of horses and marching feet approaching through the darkness from upriver. The Americans came on in two columns. The ensuing fight was long, bloody, and often quite Christmas Day, word quickly spread that General Pakenham had finally arrived to take charge of the army. Sir Edward was a young man—only 36—but he was a distinguished veteran of Wellington’s Peninsular army who had faced the soldiers of Napoleonic France. It’s hard to know what he thought or felt upon reaching his army at last, but he immediately set about solving the problems that he found on his arrival. His first order of business was to end the constant harassment from the Carolina, and if possible, to destroy her consort farther up the river, the USS Louisiana. The first part was duly accomplished at daylight on December 27 when British gunners firing heated shot succeeded in starting a fire aboard the Carolina. She blew up after confusing due to the darkness, the fog rolling in from the river, and the common language shared by many of the combatants. For almost two and a half hours, the fight raged, with men fighting hand-to-hand, and the Americans briefly penetrating British defenses. The tide was turned as British reinforcements finally began to arrive, and at length the Americans were driven off. Both sides suffered losses. Jackson’s bold strategy, while costly, had slowed the British advance and given the Americans valuable time to fall back and fortify a line of defense upriver. Mounted dragoons covered the retreat and effectively screened the Americans from close surveillance in the days that followed. Meanwhile, redcoats continued to arrive, and on her crew had evacuated to the opposite shore. The other American schooner escaped upstream, and would remain a threat in the days to come. Jackson’s bold strategy, while costly, had slowed the British advance and given the Americans valuable time to fall back and fortify a line of defense upriver. Map recreated - National Park Service 15 PREPARING “LINE JACKSON” Jackson’s men had withdrawn behind the Rodriguez Canal, a couple of miles upriver from the British camp. There he employed the soldiers and many citizens and slaves from the city in the hasty construction of an earthen barrier along the far bank of the canal. Enslaved men from nearby plantations were set to work digging and piling muddy earth, and fence slats and wooden siding was stripped from properties for miles around and used to reinforce the rampart and prevent it from collapsing. Soon the canal was dug out and deepened and a wall of earth extended a thousand yards, from the river to the cypress swamp. Cotton bales provided platforms for eight gun batteries along the wall. Across the river, more heavy artillery guns were being prepared. Jackson knew that his inexperienced troops would stand no chance against veteran British infantry out in the open field, so he wisely kept them in a strong defensive position behind the rampart. Work on the American defenses continued both day and night. “Defeat of the British Army, 12,000 strong, under the command of Sir Edward Packenham” (1818). The Historic New Orleans Collection,1989.79.135; bequest of Boyd Cruise and Harold Schilke. 16 AMERICAN TACTICS Jugeant’s Company of Choctaw Volunteers - National Park Service Meanwhile, the British general Edward Pakenham had to resume his army’s push toward New Orleans while minimizing his vulnerability to American attacks. George Gleig of the British 85th Regiment later described their situation this way: “Regularly as night closed in… began that system of irritation in which General Jackson appeared to take so much delight; and which … served to harass and annoy our troops severely.” Gleig was referring to the nighttime raids on British outposts. In Europe, it was not usual to attack an opposing army’s camp after nightfall unless one was attacking that army in force. The American general did not play by those civilized rules. Every night, in addition to ordering his cannons to target any hint of a campfire in the British outposts, Jackson sent out small groups of Choctaw warriors and buckskin-clad frontiersmen armed with tomahawks and Kentucky long rifles—a practice denounced as barbaric by Pakenham and his officers. Jackson had the support of about sixty Choctaw warriors who were especially talented as scouts and skirmishers, able to silently approach the enemy through the swampy woods, attack suddenly, and then just as silently withdraw. There’s a story about one of the Choctaws, known only as Poindexter, who made quite a business for himself selling souvenir rifles he had taken off of the British guards he’d killed. These attacks would raise the alarm in the main encampment several times each night, and served to keep the British invaders on edge through the campaign. Obviously, the early intelligence on New Orleans’ defenses had been wildly wrong. Far from being welcomed by Louisiana Creoles opposed to American rule, the British expedition had been met with a united and determined hostility. The neighboring plantations were mostly emptied of stores, and most of the cattle and horses had been driven off. Few horses had been captured to mount officers, and the heavy British artillery guns had to be moved by hand. On top of this, the unusually cold and wet conditions made life very unpleasant indeed. Rain soaked their wool uniforms, and a number of men from the West India Regiments had already died of exposure. The troops were quickly using up their rations, and food became increasingly scarce. As if the damp chill and their empty bellies weren’t bad enough, the inhospitable swamps of south Louisiana also seemed ominous to the invaders. A Royal Navy midshipman named Robert Aitchison had been charged with keeping a campfire burning at the mouth of Bayou Bienvenue, to mark the landing place for incoming troops. He later wrote that he and his colleagues were wary of the local wildlife: “I took very good care to keep a glorious blaze of light, not only for the sake of our boats, coming up with soldiers, but because we were not a little afraid that some stray alligator, or some other brute inhabiting these swamps, might make a meal of us before we were aware of it.” 17 THE ENGAGEMENT OF DECEMBER 28, 1814 “Map Showing the Landing of the British Army” (1816). The Historic New Orleans Collection, 1979.238.7 The time had come for General Pakenham to move forward to his objective, which he did on the morning of December 28 through a reconnaissance in force. His whole army moved upriver in two columns—one following the levee road on their left and the other the edge of the swamp to their right. Their objective was to scout the American defenses, and if possible, attack and overrun them. Driving the mounted American troops back as they advanced, the riverside column rounded the bend by Bienvenue’s plantation, passing a burning house as they did so, and the American army was right there in front of them. As Colonel Alexander Dickson, the commander of the British artillery, later recorded, “at this point we suddenly found ourselves within 700 or 800 Yards of the Enemy, drawn up behind an entrenchment, touching the river and from thence extending … across to the wood … and the Enemy commenced a brisk fire of Cannon, with considerable effect on our Column, which had been pushed nearer than it otherwise would, from our so Unexpectedly getting close to their line of entrenchment.” 18 The way to New Orleans was barred by a thousand-yard long, fortified wall of earth, with cannon strategically placed at points along it. Pakenham and his officers put the infantry regiments under whatever cover they could find, before riding back and forth to examine the barrier as best they could. One of the engineers climbed a tree with a spyglass, and discovered the additional obstacle of a waterfilled canal in front of the wall. To make matters worse, the surviving gun-schooner was anchored in the river in a position to rake any army that dared to approach the American position. After long consideration, Sir Edward ordered his army to return to its downriver encampment. Rather than throwing away his best infantry regiments in a frontal attack on such a strong position, Pakenham chose to bring up cannons to hammer the American line first with artillery to open a breach for his troops to pour through. Due to poor communication, Pakenham was unaware that a junior officer had probed forward through the woods and found that the American defenses at their extreme right were weak and susceptible to being overrun. If exploited, they possibly could have forced Jackson’s entire army from its strong position. But the general’s decision had been made and the orders given. Battlefield communication was always a challenge in the days before radios, and messages often had to be carried by mounted messengers. In any event, the Americans had withstood the first major push against them. Fortunately, Jackson also noticed the weakness in his defensive line and took steps to extend it further into the swamp, where it would be harder for enemy troops to get around it. This is from an old photograph of the now destroyed plantation home of Augustin Francois Macarty, used by Andrew Jackson as his field headquarters. From the collection of Stanley Clisby Arthur. -National Park Service THE ARTILLERY DUEL OF JANUARY 1, 1815 Royal Artillery Mounted Rocket Corps Colnaghi and Co., 1815 Anne S.K. Brown Military Collection, Brown University Library Having settled on what he felt was the most sensible plan of attack, on December 29 Pakenham ordered his engineers and artillerymen to construct forward gun batteries about 700 to 800 yards from Jackson’s line, on the grounds of the Bienvenue plantation. Since the army’s own cannon had not yet arrived, the Royal Navy loaned Dickson a number of naval 18 and 24 pounder cannons. That’s how much their shot weighed; the guns themselves would have weighed well over a ton each, and there was no way to get them from the fleet to the front line except through sheer manpower. Hundreds of sailors accomplished this seemingly impossible task by the night of December 31, as engineers and working parties built the batteries to shelter them. There was no cover out in the bare cane fields, so they used sugar casks filled with dirt as makeshift protective barriers. As the gun crews crept up into position before dawn on New Year’s Day, the infantry regiments took up a position behind them, in readiness for the opportunity to storm any opening in the rampart. A heavy fog obscured the Americans until it burned off at 9 o’clock; then they promptly opened fire. Colonel Dickson of the Royal Artillery observed that the first salvos “put the Enemy into a visible confusion, but they very soon put their people under cover of the parapets, and opened from all their Guns in reply.” American shot soon plowed through the makeshift British batteries, killing gunners, but still Dickson’s men kept up a brisk fire. For over two and a half hours, this 19 artillery duel raged, while thousands of redcoated infantry eagerly waited for the cannons to open the way to New Orleans and glory. At length, however, the British guns fell silent, having run out of ammunition, while the American cannons continued to hammer away. Pakenham’s own army— again forced to retire from the battlefield and return to camp—was tremendously demoralized by these setbacks, and had reached a crisis point. They were essentially stuck there between the river and swampy woods, and facing superior artillery. Pakenham knew he could not honorably or safely retreat to seek battle on better terms elsewhere; the only way out was forward, to New Orleans. With the support of his veteran officers, he opted to make an all-out attack when expected reinforcements from General John Lambert’s brigade arrived in a few days. He began planning a multipronged assault on both banks of the Mississippi. “The Battle of New Orleans” (ca. 1850). The Historic New Orleans Collection, 1959.60.2 “Cannon ball from the Battle of New Orleans” (between 1800 and 1815). The Historic New Orleans Collection, 1944.40; Gift of Sylvia Norman Duncan Harry Macdonald. 20 THE PLAN Pakenham’s main attack, under General Gibbs, would hit near the center of the American line, at a point believed to be defended by untrained militiamen; this column would be led by the 44th Regiment carrying ladders and woven fascines—bundles of sticks—that could be used to bridge the canal and climb the rampart. A second brigade, led by General Keane, would attack Jackson’s river-side flank to draw attention and fire away from the main attack. Groups of free-firing riflemen would precede both attack columns to harass and distract the dangerous American cannon crews. The third brigade, commanded by General Lambert, would be held in reserve to support either attack column as necessary. Finally, a fourth brigade would cross the river before daylight, capture the American batteries there, and turn those guns against Jackson’s line. It was an ambitious plan that also involved the construction of a canal to enable boats to ferry the troops across the river. The timing and execution of each brigade’s operation would be crucial. TIMELINE: December–January 1814 December 28 Pakenham advances army in a reconnaissance in force, studies American defenses, and retires to previous position December 28–31 British sailors haul heavy artillery eighty miles from the fleet to the front lines December 31 Royal artillery commander establishes forward batteries after nightfall January 1 Artillery duel between British and American batteries ends when British gunners run out of ammunition; planned infantry attack is cancelled, and British army again retreats January 2–3 Pakenham plans grand assault as reinforcements begin to arrive from fleet Rifleman, 95th Regiment, 1815 Anne S.K. Brown Military Collection, Brown University Library 21 JACKSON PREPARES FOR ASSAULT Meanwhile, Jackson did what he could to prepare his men for the coming assault. On January 3, he was reinforced by over 2,300 Kentucky militiamen, but they were ill-equipped. Later that day Jackson wrote: “not more than one third of them are armed, & those very indifferently. I have none here to put into their hands. I can, therefore, make no very useful disposition of them.” Already he’d had to deal with a rumored plan to surrender the city by threatening to burn New Orleans to the ground rather than let the redcoats have it. Worse, he was tired, having slept and eaten very little. Though history would later overlook it, Jackson was quite ill at the time; not only had he picked up a case of dysentery on the march from Mobile, but he was also suffering chronic pain from two pistol balls lodged in his body from duels—one near his heart and the other in his arm. In a dispatch dated January 3, Jackson requested that the Secretary of War replace him with “some proper officer to take command of the army here, when my want of health, which I find to be greatly impaired, shall oblige me to retire from it.” But there was no one else on the scene, and Jackson retained the sole command of the American side throughout the crisis. Meanwhile, life in the threatened city went on. A young woman named Laura Florian described the scene in a letter to a friend. “The town is as quiet & tranquil as if inhabited by shades & spectres instead of man,” she wrote. “We have [been] busy since the commencement of the war here making lint [bandages] for the wounded, shirts, pantaloons & blanket coats for the Kentuckians & Tennesseans who may almost literally be called Sans Culottes” (poor working class men). She added: “Blankets, mattresses, pillows have been sent from almost every house for their use, & I assure you if the bravery of our Men is to be commended, the humanity of the ladies deserves no less praise.” PAKENHAM’S PLAN UNRAVELS On the British side, preparations for the grand assault went forward on all fronts, but morale was not at all what it had been. Of this period, Lt. Gleig wrote: “I do not recollect to have experienced at any period of my life, a degree of fatigue at all to be compared with that which now oppressed me. During three whole nights and days I never closed an eye; my food, during that entire space, consisted of a small quantity of salt beef, a sea-biscuit or two, and a little rum. ... it was no uncommon thing for both officers and men to appease the cravings of hunger by eating … sugar; not, indeed, as it was found in the casks, but after they had moulded it into 22 cakes.” Finally, the time for the final grand assault drew near, and in the wee hours of January 8 the weary but determined regiments quietly moved forward to their assigned positions, as British gunners reoccupied and restocked the forward batteries they had abandoned on New Year’s Day. All around in the darkness, in the freezing early morning air, a good many men wondered how much longer they had to live. Not many of them knew it, but an epic tragedy had begun to unfold. The canal designed to float the 4th Brigade to its position across the river had collapsed, and those men hadn’t even left the East Bank yet. Pakenham’s artillery commander later wrote, “It is much to be regretted that no person called Sir Edward up during the night to acquaint him with the delay and difficulty in getting the boats into the river, as in all probability he would have begun with fewer boats, … [and] a force with Artillery etc. would have been across long before daylight to execute their orders agreeable to the original plans.” Worse, the colonel leading the 44th Regiment at the head of General Gibbs’ main attacking column had neglected to learn where the fascines and ladders were stored, and now sent two hundred men scurrying to the rear to find them. Pakenham had not been told of these difficulties in time to do anything about them. The British were running out of supplies and time, and the Americans would only get stronger. The sky was showing signs of the coming dawn, and the attack had to be made now. At Sir Edward’s signal, the blue rocket soared above the battlefield, and the regiments all rose as one to advance. 85th, The Bucks Volunteers Light Infantry, 1808 Anne S.K. Brown Military Collection, Brown University Library Pakenham’s Plan Unravels • Man-made canal engineered to float small transports from swamp to river suddenly collapses, delaying 4th Brigade’s departure. • Pakenham is unaccountably not informed. • 44th Regiment neglects ladders and fascines needed to storm American defenses, and must return to the rear to get them. • Low morale and dwindling supplies make further delays dangerous. • Rapid approach of daylight dictates that the attack proceed immediately. 23 24 “Plan Of The Attack And Defence Of The American Lines below New Orleans, on the 8th January, 1815” (1816). The Historic New Orleans Collection, 1979.238.4. THE BATTLE OF JANUARY 8, 1815 “Battle of New Orleans” (1856). The Historic New Orleans Collection, 1960.22. Everyone saw them, the American Line included. Jackson and his officers watched one rocket soar up near the woods to their left, and then another answering flare from near the river at their right. Jackson turned to one of his aides and said, “I believe that is their signal to advance.” Soon enough, through the fog and gloom, the approaching ranks of red-coated infantry could be seen advancing in columns. The Americans opened up on them almost immediately. Some British soldiers stumbled over the small irrigation ditches as the crackle of American muskets and rifles was joined by the tremendous booming flashes of cannon fire. Numbers of men began to fall, jerked backwards by hails of iron and lead, sometimes crying out. Through the smoke and horrendous noise, they took a terrible beating, but still the regiments continued to advance, right into the teeth of the American batteries. Pakenham’s artillery commander, Alexander Dickson, could see that they had got off too late, instead of exploiting the darkness. He wrote: “When the fireing first Commenced there was rather too much light, that is to say if the attack had been a little earlier it would have been better, as the Enemy could not have directed their fire with such certainty, for although as I moved forward, in the first instance I only saw the Enemies fire by the Flashes, Still the troops in motion were perfectly visible.” The intense fire of American 25 artillery and small arms quickly halted the main British attack. Cannon shot and musket balls tore through the advancing ranks, killing General Gibbs and badly wounding General Keane. Their loss left the attacking brigades leaderless, and some men fled while others waited in vain for orders. The 93rd Sutherland Highlanders bravely marched across the battlefield to aid Gibbs’ column, drums beating and bagpipes wailing, very distinctive in their red coats and tartan trousers. General Pakenham cheered them on as he rode toward the front to personally assume command. He saw clearly what was happening and he did what was expected of him. But as he tried to rally his men, a burst of American grapeshot knocked him off his horse, badly mangling his leg. His staff quickly found him another mount and helped him into the saddle, but he was soon hit again, and that time his wounds proved to be fatal. The battered remnants of the British expedition were now commanded by Maj. General John Lambert, who quickly decided— despite a successful assault on the West Bank of the river—that his force was now too weak to capture New Orleans. After discussions with his surviving officers, Lambert gave the order to retreat, and sent a flag of truce to the American lines to request a cease-fire, so that the wounded and dead could be collected. British casualties numbered over two thousand men. “Battle of New Orleans and Death of Major General Packenham [sic] on the 8th of January 1815” (1816). The Historic New Orleans Collection, 1949.2 i,ii. 26 The Battle of New Orleans was over, and incredibly, the British army, the best trained and most powerful in the world, had lost. The victors were a ragtag force of local and state militias, regular US troops, free men of color, Choctaw Indians, and Baratarian pirates. It was then, and remains to this day, one of the greatest upsets in military history. Jackson’s victory made him into an American icon, and eventually got him elected as our seventh president. But beyond that, Jackson’s successful defense of New Orleans, at the far edge of a young but growing United States, put the world on notice that this critical port, and the control of the Mississippi River, would remain in American hands. The pride in this victory led to celebrations in city streets all over the country. Bells rang and people cheered and newspapers could not be printed fast enough. Soon a booming market in commemorative prints took off, draping Jackson in the laurels of victory, and placing New Orleans in the center of a new American patriotism. Battle of January 8, 1815 British Force approximately 9,600 men American Force approximately 5,200 men “Sketch of the Position of the British and American Forces, during the Operations against New Orleans from 23d. Decr. 1814 to 18th. Jany. 1815” (June 30, 1915). The Historic New Orleans Collection,1971.98; bequest of Richard Koch 27 DIVINE INTERVENTION Photo courtesy of The Archdiocese of New Orleans During the night of January 7, 1815, Andrew Jackson and his relatively small, little-prepared and ill-equipped band of soldiers organized their defenses against the large, very well equipped British army that would attack the city before dawn. At the same time, many citizens not directly involved in the army joined the Ursuline Sisters in an all-night vigil in their chapel on Chartres Street, imploring Our Lady of Prompt Succor to give the victory to Jackson for the United States, saving the city of New Orleans from British control. During the night, the Superior, Mother Ste. Marie Olivier de Vezin, promised Our Lady that if Jackson and his men won, a mass of thanksgiving would be sung every year in memory of her saving help to the city on that day. As dawn was breaking, Fr. DuBourg began a mass for the same intention. At the very moment of the Communion a courier rushed into the chapel announcing that Andrew Jackson and his men had won the victory, and the mass ended with the joyous singing of the Te Deum. “Dominique You” (ca. 1945). The Historic New Orleans Collection, 1983.123.8. Free Men of Color and Choctaw Indian Volunteers at New Orleans Courtesy of the Army Art Collection 28 THE BATTLE OF JANUARY 8, 1815 “Battle of New Orleans” (1890). The Historic New Orleans Collection, 1959.20. The Rifle Brigade When the 95th foot, c. 1808 Anne S.K. Brown Military Collection, Brown University Library 1814. 5th The West India Regt. Anne S.K. Brown Military Collection, Brown University Library 29 WHEN DID THE WAR OFFICIALLY END? It has often been claimed that the Battle of New Orleans was fought after the War of 1812 had ended. While it is true that the Treaty of Ghent—the diplomatic agreement to end the war between Great Britain and the United States— had been signed in Europe on Christmas Eve of 1814, no treaty goes into effect immediately with its signing. First, official copies of the document must be sent to the governments of the signing nations “While many historians and students of the Battle of New Orleans have a long held belief that the battle was fought uselessly, after the signing of the Treaty of Ghent, documents such as this letter written by British War Secretary Henry Bathurst to General Pakenham have given pause for reconsideration by some experts. It is evident that Pakenham had orders to take New Orleans even though a treaty was expected. British foreign policy may have taken a drastic turn with a victory.” GARY JOINER, Ph.D. Professor of History, Chair Department of History and Social Sciences Louisiana State University, Shreveport for review, possible debate, and ratification, or official approval. In the age of sailing ships, this took some time. The British commissioners who negotiated the Treaty of Ghent with their American counterparts had insisted that hostilities could not end until both governments had ratified the treaty. Even upon ratification, a treaty does not become binding until the ratified copies are formally exchanged by representatives of each government. War Department 24th October 1814 M. Genl The Hon.le Sir E. Pakenham Secret Sir: It has occurred to me that one case may arise affecting your Situation upon the Coasts of America for which the Instructions addressed to the late Major General Ross have not provided. You may possibly hear whilst engaged in active operations that the Preliminaries of Peace between His Majesty and the United States have been signed in Europe and that they have been sent to America in order to receive the Ratification of The President. As the Treaty would not be binding until it shall have received such Ratification in which we may be disappointed by the refusal of the Government of the United States, it is advisable that Hostilities should not be suspended until you shall have official Information that The President has actually ratified the Treaty and a Person will be duly authorized to apprise you of this Event. As during this Interval, judging from the Experience we have had, the termination of the war must be considered as doubtful, you will regulate your Proceedings accordingly, neither omitting an opportunity of obtaining signal success, nor exposing the Troops to Hazard or serious Loss for an inconsiderable Advantage. And you will take especial care not so to act under the Expectation of hearing that the Treaty of Peace has been ratified, as to endanger the safety of His Majesty’s Forces, should that expectation be unhappily disappointed. I have etc. Bathurst 30 In the case of the War of 1812, the Treaty of Ghent was ratified by the US government on February 16, 1815, and the ratified copies of the treaty were exchanged by US and British diplomats the next day in Washington, DC. The War of 1812 was finally officially over, more than a month after the Battle of New Orleans had been fought. WHAT IF THE BRITISH ARMY HAD WON THE BATTLE? There’s an old joke along the lines of “If the British army had beat Andrew Jackson in 1815, people would speak English in New Orleans today.” Some historians and tour guides have supposed that Louisiana might have become a British colony had Pakenham’s troops won the Battle of New Orleans in 1815, and that the westward expansion of the US would have stopped then and there. Other historians point out that there’s no solid documentary evidence to suggest that Great Britain ever intended to hold New Orleans or Louisiana long-term had it succeeded on the battlefield, and that Britain’s primary interest in the War of 1812 was to end it as quickly as possible, and to do what they could to protect their valuable Canadian territories. In the end, we can’t be certain what would have happened to New Orleans if the battle had gone the other way. It’s a question about which historians continue to disagree. New research may help to settle the question, but in the meantime it is fascinating to imagine how the history of the lower Mississippi Valley might have unfolded differently. Among other things, Andrew Jackson might never have been elected president, and Native American tribes of the Southeast might have remained in their ancestral lands, instead of being forced to migrate west. Such questions help us to see that history is an intricate chain of causes and effects. Our interpretations of the past are constantly changing, as new information becomes available. 31 WHO WON THE BATTLE OF NEW ORLEANS? Former president Thomas Jefferson was overjoyed with the news from New Orleans, seeing it as confirmation that the people of Louisiana, despite their cultural differences with other Americans, could be “sincerely attached to the Union.” But others were not convinced, and in some versions of the history of the famous battle, Louisianans were depicted as being mostly Frenchmen and foreigners, who refused to defend their city and stood by while real Americans from the frontier settlements of Tennessee and Kentucky fought the battle with their long rifles. A popular song that appeared soon after the War of 1812, called “Hunters of Kentucky,” helped to popularize this notion. In the song, Louisiana soldiers aren’t even mentioned, but it’s implied that they weren’t brave enough to face the threat to their homes and loved ones. The song ends with these lyrics: “And now if danger e’er annoys, remember what our trade is / Just send for us Kentucky boys, and we’ll protect you, ladies.” A century later, Jimmy Driftwood wrote his variation on the same story, the version made famous by Johnny Horton in 1959. In reality, General Jackson’s triumph at New Orleans came from the joint efforts of French-speaking Louisianans and English-speaking militiamen from Tennessee and elsewhere, and in any case the issue was largely decided by Jackson’s strong defensive position and 32 “ the American advantage in big cannons. Even so, throughout the nineteenth century, many printed views of the famous Battle of New Orleans prominently feature the frontier militia of Tennessee and Kentucky as being the most active combatants. Some writers and artists simply liked the striking contrast between the spit-andpolish regular soldiers of the British army and the rough-edged, buckskin-clad frontiersmen from Kentucky and Tennessee, seeing a heroic and uniquely American character in the latter. More recent histories have helped recover and explore the contributions of Louisiana’s militia and volunteers at the Battle of New Orleans, and have shown a reality that is far more interesting than the accepted popular fiction. Buckskin-clad frontiersmen fought alongside Frenchmen who so recently had joined the Union, and many others—black men, Choctaws, even pirates. Together they prevailed over the army that had beat Napoleon and burned the public buildings in Washington. Their shared victory demonstrates to this day that diverse languages, races, and cultural traditions are not barriers to a sincere, collective devotion to our country. But the gratitude, the admiration of their country, offers a fairer reward than that which any praises of the general can bestow, and the best is that of which they can never be deprived, the consciousness of having done their duty, and of meriting the applause they will receive. ” Directed by major-general Jackson to be read at the head of each of the corps composing the line below New Orleans, Jan. 21, 1815 Arsène Lacarrière Latour, Historical Memoir of the War in West Florida and Louisiana. Expanded ed. (The Historic New Orleans Collection; University Press of Florida, 1999) Smith, John R. Peace. ca 1814. Library of Congress. Web. 13 Apr. 2014. 33 ACTIVITIES 34 GLES: LITERACY AND WRITING STANDARDS Grade 3: 46 Grade 4: 50 Grade 5: 20, 21 Grade 7: 43, 44 Grade 8: 62, 63 Grade 11: US.1.5 RH.6-8.7 RH.11-12.7, Activity 1: Battles for New Orleans Timeline WHST.6-8.9, WHST.11-12.9 OVERVIEW: Using a variety of primary and secondary resources, students will find and record information about important dates and events in history and create a timeline in which they integrate visual information concerning these important dates and events. DIRECTIONS: Have students construct a timeline that may be displayed on butcher paper or newsprint around the classroom. The dates of major events leading up to and including the battles for New Orleans, as well as events following the battles, should be included on the timeline. The timeline should be used throughout the school year to reinforce the concept of time and chronology of historical events. For each date on the timeline, have students write a brief description of the event under the date. Students may include drawings or other visuals to depict the event. Encourage students to use colors to represent different events. RESOURCES: markers colored pencils newsprint or butcher paper Internet access for research (optional: for enrichment exercise) Electronic references for timelines include the following websites: The Historic New Orleans Collection www.hnoc.org/BNO/bno_timeline.html National Park Service www.nps.gov/jela/historyculture/places-chalmette-battlefield.htm Public Broadcasting Service (PBS) www.pbs.org/wgbh/amex/neworleans/timeline/ America’s Story from America’s Library (Library of Congress) www.americaslibrary.gov/jb/nation/jb_nation_jackson_1.html Time Line Maker www.teach-nology.com/web_tools/materials/timelines/ 35 Activity 2: Plotting the Course GLES: Grade 3: 4, 5, 6 Grade 4: 5 Grade 5: 3, 4 Grade 7: 1 Grade 8: 2 Grade 11: US.1.5 LITERACY AND WRITING STANDARDS RH.6-8.1 RH.6-8.2 RH.6-8.7 RH.11-12.1 RH.11-12.2 RH.11-12.7 WHST.6-8.2b OVERVIEW: DIRECTIONS: Students will use historical and contemporary maps as well as The Historic New Orleans Collection and the National Park Service timelines to identify and label locations and dates for important events that occurred between the British and Americans leading up to and during the battles for New Orleans in 1814. Ask students to complete the outline map of the Gulf of Mexico and the area surrounding the battles for New Orleans using the timelines, historical and contemporary maps, and the list of locations below. Students will label the locations on the map and write important dates and events that occurred in these locations. Students should also include a title for their maps, map key, compass rose, and a map scale. 1. Gulf of Mexico 2. Pensacola 3. Mobile 4. Cat and Ship Islands 5. Lake Borgne 6. Lake Pontchartrain 7. Barataria Bay 8. New Orleans 9. Mississippi River 10. English Turn 11. Chalmette 12. Bayou Bienvenu 13. Villeré plantation 14. Macarty plantation 15. Rodriguez Canal The Historic New Orleans Collection and the National Park Service timelines may be found on the following links: http://www.hnoc.org/BNO/bno_timeline.html http://www.nps.gov/jela/historyculture/places-chalmette-battlefield.htm RESOURCES: The Historic New Orleans Collection and the National Park Service timelines & outline maps Historical and contemporary maps may be found on the following links: http://hnoc.minisisinc.com/thnoc/scripts/mwimain.dll/144/M3/WEB_DETAIL_M3/SISN%2018200?SESSIONSEARCH http://hnoc.minisisinc.com/thnoc/scripts/mwimain.dll/144/M3/WEB_DETAIL_M3/SISN%2019219?SESSIONSEARCH http://hnoc.minisisinc.com/thnoc/scripts/mwimain.dll/144/M3/WEB_DETAIL_M3/SISN%201837?SESSIONSEARCH http://www.nps.gov/history/history/online_books/jela/hrsi1.htm Have students discuss and explain their completed maps. Display the maps on a thematic board. Refer to the maps as needed when discussing events relating to the battles for New Orleans. 36 GLES: Grade 3: 5, 6 Grade 4: 5 Grade 5: 3, 4 Grade 7: 1, 3 Grade 8: 2, 4, 6, 70, 78 Grade 11: 1.5 LITERACY AND WRITING STANDARDS RH.6-8.1 Activity 3: Why Was New Orleans So Important? RH.6-8.7 RH.11-12.1 RH.11-12.7 OVERVIEW: DIRECTIONS: Students will use visuals to learn why the Mississippi River and New Orleans were of utmost importance to Great Britain and the United States. Provide students with a map outline of the Mississippi River valley. Have students color the route that the Mississippi River takes as it travels from Lake Itasca in Minnesota to the Gulf of Mexico. Students will also color and label the major tributaries that feed into the Mississippi River. Locate and label the major cities that are situated along the river. Display the finished maps in the classroom for further reference. http://www.earlyamerica.com/earlyamerica/maps/US_1812/ “The United States in 1812” map. Archiving Early America. March 15, 2014. Brainstorm with the class the reasons why control of New Orleans and the Mississippi River were so important to both the United States and Great Britain. Have students read and discuss “Why Was New Orleans So Important?” on pages 1 and 2 in this document. Students will work in groups of two to complete the Reasons Why New Orleans and the Mississippi River Were So Important graphic organizer (below). RESOURCES: markers colored pencils crayons maps of the Mississippi River and river valley Reasons Why New Orleans and the Mississippi River Were So Important Conduct a show-and-tell session in which students explain the reasons why New Orleans and the Mississippi River were so important. Students should be able to draw conclusions as to why the British hoped to conquer New Orleans and why the United States so desperately needed to maintain control of this important port city. Display the completed graphic organizers in the classroom. 37 Activity 4: John Bull before New Orleans GLES: Grade 3: 48 Grade 4: 52 Grade 5: 24 Grade 7: 46 Grade 8: 67, 68 Grade 11: US.1.5 LITERACY AND WRITING STANDARDS RH.6-8.1 RH.6-8.2 RH.6-8.4 RH.6-8.6 RH.6-8.8 RH.11-12.1 RH.11-12.2 RH.11-12.4 RH.11-12.6 OVERVIEW: DIRECTIONS: Students will closely examine Have students read “Mr. Madison’s War” on pages 2 and 3 of this document. Discuss with the students why the war was not going well for the Americans. Emphasis should be placed on the burning of Washington, DC, and the effects of Napoleon’s surrender in Europe. the “John Bull before New Orleans” political cartoon and discover inferences made therein about the situation depicted. Give students a copy of the “John Bull before New Orleans” political cartoon and the Library of Congress Political Cartoon Student Analysis worksheets (on the right). Students will work in groups to interpret the political cartoon. Students will identify and discuss the information that is presented in the cartoon. Students will offer informed speculations concerning the creator’s point of view as depicted in the cartoon and explain how the illustrator presents his message. Have students identify any propaganda techniques that are found in the cartoon. Ask volunteers to share with the class their findings using the Political Cartoon Student Analysis worksheets. Engage the class in a discussion of the glimpse offered by the “John Bull before New Orleans” political cartoon into a key moment of United States history. Information about political cartoons may be found on the following websites: RESOURCES: markers colored pencils crayons “John Bull before New Orleans” political cartoon The Library of Congress Political Cartoon Student Analysis worksheets Internet access for research (optional: for enrichment exercise) 38 John Bull before New Orleans political cartoon: http://louisdl.louislibraries.org/cdm/singleitem/collection/lapur/id/6024/rec/1 Library of Congress Political Cartoon Analysis Worksheets: Cartoon Analysis Worksheet: http://www.archives.gov/education/lessons/worksheets/cartoon.html Teacher’s Guides and Analysis Tool: http://www.loc.gov/teachers/usingprimarysources/guides.html Student’s Analysis Tool: http://www.loc.gov/teachers/primary-source-analysis-tool/ Have students create political cartoons that analyze the issues surrounding the battles for New Orleans. Encourage the use of markers, colored pencils, crayons, computer graphics, etc. Conduct a show-and-tell session in which students explain their cartoons. Students should be able to describe the propaganda techniques used in their cartoons. Display the cartoons in the classroom. Charles, William. John Bull Before New Orleans. 1815. New Orleans Public Library, Louisiana Division/City Archives and Special Collections, New Orleans. Web. 10 Apr. 2014. OBSERVE REFLECT QUESTION Have students identify and note details. Sample Questions: Encourage students to generate and test hypotheses about the source. Have students ask questions to lead to more observations and reflections. Describe what you see. What’s happening in the cartoon? What do you notice first? What was happening when this cartoon was made? What do you wonder about... who? what? when? where? why? how? What people and objects are shown? What, if any, words do you see? What do you see that looks different than it would in a photograph? What do you see that might refer to another work of art or literature? What do you see that might be a symbol? What other details can you see? Who do you think was the a audience for this cartoon? What issue do you think this cartoon is about? What do you think the cartoonist’s opinion on this issue is? What methods does the cartoonist use to persuade the audience? 39 Activity 5: The Life of Andrew Jackson Grade 3: 6, 47, 53 Grade 4: 5, 50, 53, 57 Grade 5: 20, 21, 24, 26 Grade 7: 43, 44, 47 Grade 8: 62, 66 Grade 11: US.1.1 US.1.5 LITERACY AND WRITING STANDARDS RH.6-8.3 RH.6-8.5 RH.11-12.1 RH.11-12.2 WHST.6-8.2 WHST.6-8.2b WHST.6-8.2f WHST.11-12.2 WHST.11-12.2b WHST.11-12.2e OVERVIEW: DIRECTIONS: The students will identify and describe major events that occurred during the life of Andrew Jackson and explain how these events influenced his life. Have students read “Old Hickory” on pages 5 and 6 of this document. Discuss with the students how events in General Jackson’s life influenced his attitudes and beliefs and created the man who was not afraid to stand up against the strongest army in the world. Have students explain why his troops affectionately called Jackson “Old Hickory.” RESOURCES: posters markers colored pencils Life of Andrew Jackson graphic organizer Internet access for research (optional: for enrichment exercise) 40 GLES: Organize the class into nine groups. Assign each group a different topic concerning Andrew Jackson’s life: • birth information and childhood experiences during the American Revolution • education • marriage and adopted children • duels • legal and political careers • military career • participation in the Creek Indian wars • the War of 1812 • the Battle of New Orleans Have students use primary and/or secondary source documents (textbooks, encyclopedias, and reliable Internet resources) to find information concerning the major events of Andrew Jackson’s life. The following websites contain information on Jackson’s life: The Hermitage timeline: http://www.thehermitage.com/jackson-family/timeline http://teachingamericanhistory.org/library/jackson/ Have students use The Life of Andrew Jackson graphic organizer to record information as they examine their assigned topic (see the sample on right). THE LIFE OF ANDREW JACKSON TOPIC AND DATE OF EVENT: SUPPORTING DETAILS: Birth information and childhood experiences during the American Revolution Education Marriage and adopted children Duels Legal and political careers Military career Participation in the Creek Indian wars War of 1812 Battle of New Orleans As students research their assigned topics, have them prepare maps detailing Jackson’s locations and movements as they relate to their assigned topic. Post these maps around the room for future reference and discussion. Students will use their completed Life of Andrew Jackson graphic organizer to present their findings to the class using PowerPoint presentations, posters, or various other visual presentations. As student groups present their reports, have the other students record important facts and supporting details on their copies of the Life of Andrew Jackson graphic organizer as each topic is presented. Students will use RAFT writing (view literacy strategy descriptions) to write a newspaper article in which they describe one of the major events in the life of Andrew Jackson (see the sample below). ROLE AUDIENCE FORMAT TOPIC Newspaper reporter US newspaper subscribers Newspaper article Major event in the life of Andrew Jackson and the effects of this event on Jackson’s life Students should orally present their newspaper articles to the class and then display the RAFT letters on a thematic bulletin board. Gather the class back together. Solicit observations from each group and discuss their findings with the class. Compare student findings. Some teacher guidance may be needed. Have students add the dates and other pertinent information concerning the life of Andrew Jackson to the timeline. The timeline should be used to reinforce the concept of time and chronology of historical events. 41 Activity 6: Problems, Obstacles, & Opposing Forces GLES: Grade 3: 3 Grade 4: 53 Grade 5: 26 Grade 7: 47 Grade 8: 72 Grade 11: US.1.5 LITERACY AND WRITING STANDARDS RH.6-8.1 RH.6-8.2 RH.11-12.1 RH.11-12.2, WHST.6-8.2f WHST.11-12.2e OVERVIEW: DIRECTIONS: Students will learn about General Jackson’s response to the problems and obstacles that he found when he arrived in New Orleans early in December of 1814. Students will also learn about the forces that made up the opposing armies. Discuss with students the problems and obstacles that General Andrew Jackson faced when he first arrived in New Orleans. The discussion should probe student background knowledge of the defense of and conditions in the city, lack of weapons and equipment, and volunteer as well as professional troops that reported to the city. Have students use DL-TA (directed learning-thinking activity; (view literacy strategy descriptions) to examine the major obstacles that Jackson faced as he prepared for the arrival of the British invasion forces. The class discussion should activate students’ interest and build on background knowledge concerning the battles for New Orleans. RESOURCES: posters newsprint markers Internet access for research (optional: for enrichment exercise) Invite students to make predictions about the content they will be reading. Have students write the predictions in their notebooks in order to keep a record of them while they learn the new content. Guide students through a reading selection from “Jackson’s Soldiers”, found on pages 7 and 8 of this document, stopping at predetermined places to ask students to check and revise their predictions. At each stopping point, ask students to reread their predictions and change them if necessary. New predictions and relevant information should be recorded. Ask questions involving the content. Students’ attention should be directed to the obstacles and problems that Jackson encountered when he arrived in New Orleans on December 1, 1814. Explain Jackson’s actions to immediately address the seemingly insurmountable obstacles. Attention should also be placed on the varied assortment of troops that poured into the area to protect New Orleans. Once students have been exposed to the content, their predictions may be used as discussion tools. Ask students to compare what they predicted would be learned to what they actually learned concerning the immediate problems facing Jackson; the solutions that he used to solve these problems; and the massive troop buildup that was a response to his call for assistance. Hold a class discussion in which students describe their experience with DL-TA. Have students orally explain and summarize what they learned about Jackson’s response to the situation that he found upon arriving in New Orleans. 42 Review with the class the varied assortment of troops that were under the command of Major-General Pakenham and General Jackson. Place students in groups of two and give each group an Opposing Forces Table. Using posters or newsprint and markers, have students complete a web diagram using the information in the Opposing Forces Table on right. OPPOSING FORCES TABLE BRITISH INVADERS AMERICAN DEFENDERS Major-General Sir Edward Pakenham General Andrew Jackson Infantry Regiments 7th and 44th Regular United States Infantry 4th (King’s Own) US Light Artillery 7th (Royal Fusiliers) Detachment of United States Marines 21st (Royal North British Fusiliers) 43rd (Monmouth Light Infantry) 44th (East Essex) Louisiana Militia, including Orleans Rifle Company (Beale’s Rifles) Orleans Battalion of Uniform Companies Carabiniers 85th (Bucks Light Infantry Volunteers) Dragons à Pied 93rd (Sutherland Highlanders) Francs 95th (Rifle Corps; 6 companies) Chasseurs 1st & 5th West India (colored) 14th Dragoons (dismounted) Royal Artillery including rocket troops Drivers Royal Navy Royal Marines Louisiana Blues Baratarians Two battalions of Free Men of Color Other Louisiana Militia in Reserve Tennessee Militia Coffee’s Tennessee Mounted Infantry Kentucky Militia Company of Choctaw Indians Cavalry: Hinds’ Mississippi Dragoons Attakapas Dragoons Chauveau’s Horse Volunteers Feliciana Troop of Horse 43 Activity 6 (continued) Students will write the names of the opposing generals in the center of each of the web diagrams. In the outer ovals of the web diagrams, students will list the different fighting forces that were led by each general. AMERICAN DEFENDERS BRITISH INVADERS In a culminating activity, hold a class discussion in which students orally explain and summarize what they learned about the different troops that fought at the battles for New Orleans. Have students write a paragraph in which they provide a concluding statement that supports the information presented in the “Jackson’s Soldiers” reading and the Opposing Forces chart. Ask for student volunteers to share their writings with the class. 44 GLES: Grade 3: 53 Grade 5: 24 Grade 8: 70 Grade 11: US.1.1 LITERACY AND WRITING STANDARDS Activity 7: Assorted Defenders RH.6-8. RH.6-8.2 RH.6-8.7 RH.11-12.1 RH.11-12.2 RH.11-12.7 WHST.6-8.2a WHST.6-8.2b WHST.6-8.6 WHST.11-12.2a WHST.11-12.2b WHST.11-12.6 OVERVIEW: DIRECTIONS: Students will develop multimedia presentations about one of the groups that came to defend New Orleans against the British invasion. Divide the students into groups. Assign one of the assorted defenders groups to each student group. RESOURCES: markers colored pencils Internet access for research (optional: for enrichment exercise) GRADING CRITERIA CONTENT Historically Relevant Facts • Choctaw Indians • Kentucky forces • Mississippi forces (including: Hinds’ Mississippi Dragoons) • 7th and 44th Regular United States Infantry • Tennessee forces (including Coffee’s Tennessee Mounted Infantry) • United States Marines Have students use “Jackson’s Soldiers” and “Help Arrives from Fellow States” found on pages 7–8 and 11–12 of this document to learn more about the assorted group of defenders that joined Jackson’s army and fought in the battles for New Orleans. Students will use primary and/or secondary source documents (books, encyclopedias, and reliable Internet resources) to read about the volunteer and regular United States army troops that came to defend New Orleans against the British invasion. Students will prepare a five-minute multimedia presentation to share with the class concerning their group of defenders. See multimedia project rubric below. POINTS MULTIMEDIA RUBRIC 5 4 Contains at least 2 accurate pieces of information for each required heading (5 pts) Facts are accurate Significance of Information and significant for all entries (5pts) Accurate facts; most info is significant 3 2 1 Contains 3, accurate Contains 2, accurate Contains 1, accurate Most facts are accurate, some info is significant Some facts are accurate; some info is significant Much important information is lacking Pictures or Graphics Contains at least 4 accurate/ relevant (5pts) Contains 2, accurate and/or lack relevance (3/2pts) Contains 1, accurate Spelling No errors (5pts) 1 error 2 errors 3 or more errors Grammar/Style No errors (5pts) 1 error 2 errors 3 or more errors Organization Well organized and easy to follow (5pts) Average organization Title Page or Visual Contains title, group members’ names, date (5pts) Visual Appeal Colors and graphic design complements information, does not detract from audience engagement with information. (5pts) Colors/graphs visually appealing but detract from audience engagement with information (3pts) Little attention given to graphic design Group Participation All members participated in organization/construction of visual. Covers all indicated issues related to the topic. Some assignments incomplete, some members not on task (3/2pts) Failed to cooperate, incomplete or poor quality product Lacks organization Information incomplete (2pts) No information given 45 Activity 7 (continued) As students read informational texts, have them use a graphic organizer to summarize and record information concerning important facts and contributions made by their assigned group of defenders (see New Orleans Defenders sample below). NEW ORLEANS DEFENDERS DEFENDERS IMPORTANT CONTRIBUTIONS AN ASSORTMENT OF DEFENDERS DEFENDERS Company of Choctaw Indians Kentucky Militia Hinds’ Mississippi Dragoons 7th and 44th Regular United States Infantry Tennessee Militia and Coffee’s Tennessee Mounted Infantry United States Marines 46 IMPORTANT CONTRIBUTIONS Readings on the different groups that came to defend New Orleans against the British invasion may be found on the following websites: Choctaw Indians: http://www.nchgs.org/html/road_to_new_orleans.html http://www.history.army.mil/html/topics/afam/aa-art-2.html Kentucky Forces: http://kynghistory.ky.gov/history/1qtr/warof1812.htm http://www.nps.gov/history/history/online_books/hh/29/hh29m.htm http://lanclib.org/history/resources/exhibits/no/no.htm http://www.2ndkentucky1812.com/2012/03/29/kentucky-regiments-the-battle-of-new-orleans http://www.americaslibrary.gov/aa/jackson/aa_jackson_icon_2_e.html Mississippi Forces (including Hinds’ Mississippi Dragoons): http://battleofneworleans.org/Britishland.htm http://jeffersoncountyms.org/jefftroop.htm http://npshistory.com/handbooks/historical/29/hh29m.htm http://files.usgwarchives.net/la/state/military/war1812/battle-no.txt 7th and 44th Regular United States Infantry: http://battleofneworleans.org/ http://www.crt.state.la.us/museum/online_exhibits/Cabildo/6.aspx http://www.nps.gov/history/history/online_books/hh/29/hh29m.htm http://www.frenchcreoles.com/CreoleCulture/battalion%20creoles/battalion%20creoles.htm Tennessee Forces: http://www.battleofneworleans2015.com/page.php?name=battle-story http://www.tennessee.gov/tsla/exhibits/veterans/1812.htm http://www.tennesseehistory.com/class/NewOrleans.htm http://www.gutenberg.org/files/25699/25699-h/25699-h.htm http://www.tngenweb.org/campbell/hist-bogan/NewOrleans.html United States Marines: http://battleofneworleans.org/ http://www.nps.gov/history/history/online_books/hh/29/hh29m.htm http://www.frenchcreoles.com/CreoleCulture/battalion%20creoles/battalion%20creoles.htm http://files.usgwarchives.net/la/state/military/war1812/battle-no.txt As student groups present their findings to the class, have students use split-page notetaking (view literacy strategy descriptions) to record information from their peer multimedia presentations (see sample left of page). Hold a class discussion in which students reflect on the important contributions made by these assorted defenders. Some teacher guidance may be needed. Have students imagine that the diary of an American soldier, who participated in the battles, was found in an old chest in an attic in Nashville, Tennessee. Have students write an entry in which they describe the assorted group of defenders that were present for the battles for New Orleans. Ask for student volunteers to share their diary entries. 47 Activity 8: Jackson’s Louisiana Forces GLES: Grade 3: 53 Grade 4: 52 Grade 5: 26 Grade 7: 50 Grade 8: 66, 67, 70, 75 Grade 11: US.1.1, US.1.5 LITERACY AND WRITING STANDARDS RH.6-8.1 RH.6-8.2 RH.11-12.1 RH.11-12.2 WHST.6-8.2 WHST.6-8.9 WHST.11-12.2 WHST.11-12.9 OVERVIEW: DIRECTIONS: Students will learn that the Louisiana forces that joined Andrew Jackson’s army in defending Louisiana and defeating the British during the battles for New Orleans were a very diverse group. By analyzing visuals associated with the different ethnic groups, students will see that these forces represented a true cross section of Louisiana’s population at that time. Students will learn how to look for potential bias and consider the point of view of the artist. Organize the class into groups of two. Provide copies of the paintings that depict the different Louisiana ethnic groups that joined Jackson’s forces and the How to Analyze Visuals worksheet (see sample below). Students will analyze and interpret the paintings while completing the worksheet. RESOURCES: Images of the different Louisiana ethnic groups that joined Jackson’s forces to defend New Orleans HOW TO ANALYZE VISUALS What is the title of the image? What is the image about? Evaluate the details. (What do the details suggest?) Think critically about the information that you see in the image. How is the artist’s personal perspective reflected in the image? Is the purpose of the visual to entertain, inform, or to persuade the audience? Visuals of the different ethnic groups that fought in the battles for New Orleans: The Battle of New Orleans, John Andrews, 1856, detail showing Free Men of Color battalions http://www.crt.state.la.us/louisiana-state-museum/online-exhibits/the-cabildo/the-battle-of-new-orleans/ The Creole Soldier http://www.frenchcreoles.com/DCP03387.jpg Captain Daquin’s Battalion of San Domingo Free Men of Color http://www.history.army.mil/html/topics/afam/print/1814-p.html Major Lacoste’s 1st Battalion of Free Men of Color http://www.battleofneworleans2015.com/page.php?name=whos-who Ask student groups to report their findings concerning the images, bias depicted in the visuals, and the point of view of the artists. Open the discussion to the entire class in order to allow students to think and communicate graphically. Have students imagine that they are a war correspondent working for a newspaper that is located on the East Coast. Students will write a descriptive passage, in the form of a newspaper article, in which they describe the people and the events that are represented in their favorite visual. ROLE AUDIENCE FORMAT TOPIC Regional newspaper reporter from the East Coast Subscribers Newspaper Jackson’s feature article Louisiana forces (descriptive passage) Ask student volunteers to read what they have written to the class and then display the newspaper articles on a thematic bulletin board. 48 GLES: Grade 3: 46, 48, 53 Grade 4: 50, 54 Grade 7: 43, 46, 48 Grade 8: 62, 65, 70 Grade 11: US.1.1, US.1.5 Activity 9: Battle of Lake Borgne, the First Battle for New Orleans LITERACY AND WRITING STANDARDS RH.6-8.1 RH.6-8.2 RH.6-8.7 RH.6-8.9 RH.11-12.1 RH.11-12.2 RH.11-12.7 RH.11-12.9, WHST.6-8.2, WHST.11-12.2 OVERVIEW: DIRECTIONS: Students will cite specific textual evidence to support the use of primary and secondary sources in the process of analyzing and interpreting historical data while learning about the first battle for New Orleans, fought on Lake Borgne. Have students learn about the Battle of Lake Borgne by reading “The Invaders Arrive” and “The First Battle” on pages 9 and 10 of this document. Students will use split-page notetaking to organize their notes and to record supporting details and information as they read the passages about the Battle of Lake Borgne (see the graphic organizer below). THE BATTLE OF LAKE BORGNE NOTES Date: December 14, 1814 Topic: The Battle of Lake Borgne Describe the difficult terrain and obstacles that forced the large British warships to anchor 85 miles from New Orleans near Ship Island. Five American gunboats had been sighted in Lake Borgne. Describe what British Lieutenant Nicholas Lockyer did to prepare for the conflict with the American gunboats. Even though the British won the first battle for New Orleans in Lake Borgne, explain why the victory was costly. Explain why the Battle of Lake Borgne was so important. Describe what happened when news of the American loss reached New Orleans. As the students gain new knowledge, stop periodically as content is covered and ask students to cite specific evidence supporting their responses as they fill in their Battle of Lake Borgne Notes graphic organizer. RESOURCES: Gather the class back together. Solicit observations from students and discuss and compare their findings. Some teacher guidance may be needed. markers colored pencils Internet access for research Organize the class into groups. Have each group look at different primary sources that relate to the Battle of Lake Borgne. (optional: for enrichment exercise) Below is a list of selected primary sources on the battle: The Historic New Orleans Collection: http://hnoc.minisisinc.com/thnoc/scripts/mwimain.dll/144/M3/WEB_DETAIL_M3/SISN%202149?SESSIONSEARCH http://hnoc.minisisinc.com/thnoc/scripts/mwimain.dll/144/M3/WEB_DETAIL_M3/SISN%207366?SESSIONSEARCH http://hnoc.minisisinc.com/thnoc/scripts/mwimain.dll/144/M3/WEB_DETAIL_M3/SISN%201842?SESSIONSEARCH National Park Service: http://cr.nps.gov/history/online_books/hh/29/hh29f.htm http://cr.nps.gov/history/online_books/hh/29/hh29g.htm 49 Activity 9 (continued) As the students look at and analyze these primary sources, have them complete the National Archives and Records Administration Document Analysis Worksheets. (Adobe Reader will be needed to open the worksheets which are in PDF format.) Adobe Reader is a free download at http://get.adobe.com/reader/. Map Analysis Worksheet: http://www.archives.gov/education/lessons/worksheets/map.html Photo or Painting Analysis Worksheet: http://www.archives.gov/education/lessons/worksheets/photo.html Written Document Analysis Worksheet: http://www.archives.gov/education/lessons/worksheets/document.html As primary source documents on the Battle of Lake Borgne are analyzed, have students use the Battle of Lake Borgne primary source chart to analyze the primary sources (below). Ask students to tell how they would explain the documents to someone who was completely unfamiliar with the Battle of Lake Borgne. BATTLE OF LAKE BORGNE PRIMARY SOURCE CHART DECEMBER 14, 1814 TOPIC: BATTLE OF LAKE BORGNE PRIMARY SOURCES What is the title of the primary source? What type of primary source is it? Why was the primary source written, recorded, or painted? Which words or terms would be considered uncommon today or would mean something different? How would you explain the primary source to someone who was completely unfamiliar with it? When would it be more useful to use primary sources rather than secondary sources in analyzing historical events? Gather the class back together. Solicit observations from each group and compare and discuss their findings. Some teacher guidance may be needed. Discuss with students why primary sources are important. Ask students: • When is the use of primary sources the most appropriate means of researching a historical topic? • When would a secondary source be more appropriate? • Upon completion of the presentation of information, engage students in a discussion involving the questions in their Battle of Lake Borgne Notes graphic organizer and Battle of Lake Borgne primary source chart in order to clarify any misconceptions about the issues, information, or concepts. • Have students work individually, using the questions and answers, to write a short summary of the “story” of the Battle of Lake Borgne. Students should also include an explanation of the process of analyzing and interpreting historical data. Have students add the dates and other pertinent information concerning the Battle of Lake Borgne to the timeline. The timeline should be used to reinforce the concept of time and chronology of historical events. 50 GLES: Grade 3: 46 Grade 4: 50 Grade 5: 20, 23, 24 Grade 7: 43, 46 Grade 8: 62, 65 Grade 11: US.1.1 LITERACY AND WRITING STANDARDS Activity 10: The British Arrive RH.6-8.1 RH.6.8.2 RH.6-8.5 RH.11-12.1 RH.11-12.2 WHST.6-8.2f WHST.11-12.2e OVERVIEW: DIRECTIONS: Students will cite specific textual evidence to support analysis of secondary sources, connecting insights gained from specific details about the British secret landing only a few miles from New Orleans. Have students read “The Bristish Landing” passage on page 13 of this document. By using “The British Arrive” process guide below, students will gain additional insight of the British invasion on Louisiana soil. THE BRITISH ARRIVE List three facts concerning the first British invasion force: Describe the way in which the British scouted the area to find the way to the levee road along the Mississippi River: State the reason why the 85th Light Infantry and the 95th Rifles Regiment were known as the cream of the force: List an interesting fact about the uniforms of the 95th Rifles Regiment: Name the temporary commander of the British ground forces prior to the arrival of Sir Edward Michael Pakenham: State the reason why Major General John Keane did not want to push on to New Orleans immediately: State the reason why the British believed that the Americans would not offer a determined resistance against them: RESOURCES: Internet access for research (optional: for enrichment exercise) Information on the December 23, 1814, night battle may be found on the following site: https://archive.org/stream/historicalmemoi00latogoog#page/n108/mode/2up 51 Activity 10 (continued) Ask students to work with a partner to fill in the guide. Then ask students to share their findings. Engage the class in a discussion of the events surrounding the British arrival on December 23, 1814. Place students in groups of four and use text chains (view literacy strategy descriptions) to create a short story about the British landing near New Orleans. On a sheet of paper, ask the first student to write the opening sentence of a text chain in which the students explain the topic of the first British invasion force’s secret landing in Louisiana. The student then passes the paper to the student sitting to the right, and that student writes the next sentence in the story. The paper is passed again to the right to the next student, who writes a third sentence of the story. The paper is passed to the fourth student, who must complete the story. See the sample text chain that follows: Student 1: The British had to row their men and supplies across Lake Borgne because the lake is shallow and their large ships would get stuck. Student 2: Two British officers dressed up like fishermen and were able to find a route to the Mississippi River without being noticed. Student 3: Major General John Keane was the British general in charge of soldiers that were very experienced. Student 4: Two hundred American soldiers on horses spotted the British troops and ran away when the British fired on them. As a culminating activity, ask students to share their text chains with the class. Hold a class discussion and ask students to compare methods of reconnaissance used in 1814 to those used today. Reread the last sentence in the reading passage: “Yet at about seven that night, after dark, they discovered that they were quite mistaken.” Ask students to predict what they think happened next. Have students add the date and other pertinent information concerning the landing of the British invasion force to the timeline. The timeline should be used to reinforce the concept of time and chronology of historical events. 52 GLES: Grade 3: 6, 47, 53 Grade 4: 53, 57 Grade 5: 25, 26 Grade 7: 47 Grade 8: 66, 75, 78 Grade 11: US.1.1, US.1.5 LITERACY AND WRITING STANDARDS Activity 11: Preparing Line Jackson RH.6-8.1 RH.6-8.2 RH.6-8.3 RH.6-8.7 RH.11-12.1 RH.11-12.2 RH.11-12.3 RH.11-12.7 OVERVIEW: DIRECTIONS: Students will create visual representations of Line Jackson and be able to describe the ways in which General Jackson prepared for the approaching British army. Discuss with the students some of the unorthodox tactics that General Jackson used to protect his inexperienced troops and to harass and annoy the British. Have students fill in the K-W-L-H chart as they read and research information about the American general who did not play by civilized rules. The chart asks students to tell what they already know, what they want to find out, what they learned, and how they can learn more about the topic (see below). K-W-L-H CHART What I Know What I Want to Find Out What I Learned How Can I Learn More Have students read “Preparing ‘Line Jackson,’ ” found on page 16 of this document. As the students read the passage, have them complete the Line Jackson graphic organizer. Ask students to work with a partner to respond to each question in the Line Jackson graphic organizer as they read about the ways in which General Jackson prepared for the invading British army. LINE JACKSON Where was Line Jackson? Who built Line Jackson? RESOURCES: What materials were used to build Line Jackson? markers colored pencils crayons What did Jackson have the workers to do with the Rodriguez Canal? K-W-L-H chart Line Jackson graphic organizer Internet access for research (optional: for enrichment exercise) What use were cotton bales to the line of defense? Why did Jackson need to build this strong line of defense? When was work done on the line of defense and on the canal? Ask students to share their findings. Engage the class in a discussion of the preparations that were made to form a line of protection between the advancing British army and the city of New Orleans. Ask students to use their completed Line Jackson graphic organizer and their K-W-L-H chart while participating in the class discussion. In a concluding activity, have students create visual representations of Line Jackson and the Rodriguez Canal. Ask for student volunteers to display and explain their visual representations to the class. Display the visual representations of Line Jackson on a thematic bulletin board. 53 Activity 12: The Night Battle of December 23, 1814 GLES: Grade 3: 46, 47, 48, 54 Grade 4: 50, 58 Grade 5: 20, 21, 24, 26 Grade 7: 43, 47 Grade 8: 62, 65, 66 Grade 11: US.1.1, US.1.5 LITERACY AND WRITING STANDARDS RH.6-8.1 RH.6-8.2 RH.11-12.1 RH.11-12.2 OVERVIEW: DIRECTIONS: Students will identify key steps in a text’s description of the night battle that occurred on December 23, 1814, and integrate visual information with other information in print. Students will use SQPL (student questions for purposeful learning; view literacy strategy descriptions) to learn more about the second battle for New Orleans that began on the night of December 23, 1814. Generate a statement pertaining to the night battle. This statement should be thought-provoking and designed to encourage students to wonder about and challenge the proposed topic of information that will be presented in the lesson. For example, an SQPL statement about the night battle of December 23rd might be: Chaos erupted with muskets, bayonets, tomahawks, long knives, and even fists being used during the intense night battle of December 23, 1814. Present the statement to students. Have students pair up to generate two or three questions they would like answered about the SQPL statement. Next, the class will share questions, which are then recorded on the board. Repeated questions from the groups are highlighted to emphasize their importance. Add questions to be sure all gaps in information are filled. Students are now ready to discover the answers to their questions. As content is covered, stop periodically to allow students to determine if their questions have been answered. RESOURCES: The “Night Battle” of December 23, 1814 chart Internet access for research (optional: for enrichment exercise) Using the “Night Battle” of December 23, 1814 reading, found on pages 14 and 15 of this document, and information from primary and/or secondary source readings, Internet resources, and lectures, have students work in pairs to research and analyze the night battle of December 23rd. Student attention should focus on the following: events preceding the battle, Jackson’s reasons for taking the battle to the British, the battle, and the aftermath of the battle. More information concerning the night battle of December 23, 1814, may be found on the following websites: http://cr.nps.gov/history/online_books/hh/29/hh29h.htm https://archive.org/stream/historicalmemoi00latogoog#page/n108/mode/2up 54 As students research their assigned topic, have them use split-page notetaking (view literacy strategy descriptions) to organize pertinent information concerning the night battle of December 23rd (see the chart below): THE “NIGHT BATTLE” OF DECEMBER 23, 1814 Date: December 23, 1814 Topic: The Night Battle of December 23, 1814 Describe the scene in the British camp at the Villeré Plantation. List three facts concerning the USS Carolina. While the USS Carolina was pounding the British camp, describe what happened next. Describe the fight that ensued between the British and American troops. Explain why a common language shared between the opposing armies presented a problem. Explain what happened to turn the tide of the battle in favor of the British. Explain why Jackson’s bold strategy to take the battle to the British was so important. Explain why there was much joy in the British camp on Christmas Day. List three facts concerning British General Sir Edward Pakenham. Explain what General Pakenham succeeded in doing to stop the constant bombardment from the USS Carolina. Hold a class discussion and ask students to share their findings on the night battle of December 23rd. Check student responses for accuracy and clarify any misconceptions about the content. Have students add the date and other pertinent information concerning the night battle of December 23rd to the timeline. The timeline should be used to reinforce the concept of time and chronology of historical events. In a culminating activity, have students create a graffiti wall in which they create their own drawings of the events that transpired leading up to, during, and after the night battle of December 23rd. Ask students to explain their graffiti. Display the Night Battle of December 23rd graffiti wall in the classroom. 55 GLES: Activity 13: Military Music Grade 5: 26 Grade 8: 70 Grade 11: US.1.5 LITERACY AND WRITING STANDARDS RH. 6-8.1 RH.6-8.7 RH.11-12.1 RH.11-12.7 WHST.6-8.9 WHST.11-12.1 OVERVIEW: DIRECTIONS: Students will use primary and secondary source materials to learn about the functions of the different musical instruments that were used during the battles for New Orleans. Using information from primary and/or secondary source readings, Internet resources, and lectures, have students read information about the different types of musical instruments that were used during the battles for New Orleans. As students read, have them use split-page notetaking to organize pertinent information concerning the different musical instruments used during the battles and their various purposes (see the Military Musical Instruments sample below): MILITARY MUSICAL INSTRUMENTS Musical Instrument Purpose of the Musical Instrument On and Off the Battlefield bagpipes bugles drums fifes trumpets Information concerning the musical instruments used during the battles for New Orleans may be found on the following websites: http://www.metmuseum.org/toah/hd/ammu/hd_ammu.htm http://www.drums1812.org/HTML/Instruments.html http://www.nefa.net/archive/songmusicdance/pipes/war.htm RESOURCES: markers colored pencils crayons Internet access for research (optional: for enrichment exercise) Hold a class discussion and ask students to share their findings recorded in their split-page notes. Check for student understandings and allow students to make corrections if necessary. Have students listen to military music played by bagpipes and fife, and, drum corps. The following websites contain recordings of musical instruments used by the military: http://www.militaryheritage.com/sound.htm http://podcast.history.org/2013/05/13/fifes-and-drums-the-instruments/ http://history.org/history/fifeAnddrum/media.cfm?sort=video http://www.loc.gov/search/?q=recordings+of+bagpipes Hold a class discussion involving the different recordings. Ask students to describe the effectiveness of each instrument involved during military conflict. 56 Have students create collages in which they depict scenes in which musical instruments were used during the battles for New Orleans. Encourage the use of markers, colored pencils, colors, computer graphics, etc. Conduct a show-and-tell session in which the students explain their collages. Students should be able to describe and analyze the depictions in their collages. Display the collages in the classroom. Place students in groups of three to five and use the round robin discussion technique (view literacy strategy descriptions) to answer the following questions: • What types of musical instruments were used during the battles for New Orleans? • Explain why musical instruments were used during battles. • In what ways were musical instruments used off of the battlefield? • In what ways were musical instruments used on the battlefield? • What was an advantage of a bagpipe over a fife? • Describe the importance of drummer boys to their army. Round robin is a great technique to ensure all students participate in a discussion. Have each student in the circle quickly share his or her idea or solution to a question. Students may be given one opportunity to “pass” on a response, but eventually every student must respond. This technique is most effective when, after the initial clockwise sharing, students are asked to write down their responses. This allows all students’ opinions and ideas to be brought to the teacher’s and classmates’ attention. It also provides a record of the group’s thinking, which may be used for grading purposes and to prepare for future assessments. Gather the class back together. Solicit observations and compare and discuss student findings. Some teacher guidance may be needed. Using their split-page notes, have students write a well-organized short essay in which they analyze and describe the ways in which musical instruments were used on and off the battlefield during the battles for New Orleans. Ask for student volunteers to share their completed short essays with the class. Snare Drum (LSM 00476.1), wood and hide, manufactured by Klemm & Brother’s, Philadelphia, c. 1860. Courtesy of the Collections of the Louisiana State Museum, loan by Gaspar Cusachs. “The British Bugler Boy Sounding The Charge” (January 23, 1858). The Historic New Orleans Collection, 1974.26.5.8. 57 Activity 14: The Engagement of December 28, 1814 GLES: Grade 3: 46, 54 Grade 4: 50, 53, 58 Grade 5: 20, 21, 23, 24 26 Grade 7: 43, 47 Grade 8: 62, 65, 66, Grade 11: US.1.1, US.1.5 LITERACY AND WRITING STANDARDS RH.6-8.1 RH.6-8.2, RH.11-12.1 RH.11-12.2 WHST 6-8.2 WHST.11-12.2 OVERVIEW: DIRECTIONS: Students will use primary and secondary sources to learn about the events that transpired as the British scouted Jackson’s line of defense on December 28, 1814. Have students read “The Engagement of December 28, 1814” on page 18 of this document as well as other primary and/or secondary source documents (books, encyclopedias, and reliable Internet resources) to learn about the events that occurred between the American and British troops on December 28, 1814. As students read informational texts, they will complete a graphic organizer in which they summarize information about important events that occurred during the engagement between the armies on December 28th (see graphic organizer below). THE RECONNAISSANCE Events of December 28, 1814 Supporting Details Additional Information RESOURCES: The Reconnaissance graphic organizer Internet access for research (optional: for enrichment exercise) Information concerning important events occurring between the American and British troops on December 28, 1814, may be found on the following websites: https://archive.org/stream/historicalmemoi00latogoog#page/n142/mode/2up http://www.hnoc.org/BNO/william_cook.html http://www.hnoc.org/BNO/bno_timeline.html http://www.crt.state.la.us/museum/online_exhibits/Cabildo/6.aspx http://cr.nps.gov/history/online_books/hh/29/hh29j.htm http://www.nps.gov/history/history/online_books/jela/hrst.htm 58 Students will present their findings to the class. Hold a class discussion in which students reflect on the important events that occurred on December 28, 1814. Use the Fishbowl discussion technique (view literacy strategy descriptions) to answer the following questions: • What was General Pakenham’s objective on December 28th? • How did the British approach the American line of defense? • What prevented the British from marching into New Orleans? • How did Pakenham and his engineers scout the American defensive line? • What other obstacles stood in the way of the British? • What did Pakenham decide to do after seeing the American line and all of the obstacles? • What had a junior officer and his troops been able to do? • How might history have changed if methods of communication were better? • What plan did Pakenham decide to use after seeing the American line? • What did General Jackson do next? Divide students into two groups sitting in concentric circles. A small group of students in the inner circle (the fishbowl) is asked to discuss the above questions while the other group (the outer circle) looks on. The outside group must listen but not contribute to the deliberations of the students who are “in the fishbowl.” At some point during the discussion, give those students in the outer circle an opportunity to discuss among themselves their reactions to the conversations that they have observed and to ask questions of the students in the fishbowl. Have students work individually, using the information from their The Reconnaissance graphic organizer and their participation in the Fishbowl discussion, to write an informative summary in which they explain important events that occurred on December 28, 1814. Ask student volunteers to read their summaries to the class as the other students listen for accurate information. Facilitate any discussion that follows. Have students add the date and other pertinent information concerning the events of December 28, 1814, to the timeline. The timeline should be used to reinforce the concept of time and chronology of historical events. 59 GLES: Activity 15: Unwelcome Guests Grade 3: 47 Grade 4: 53 Grade 5: 23, 24 Grade 7: 47 Grade 8: 6, 66, 72, 75, 78 Grade 11: US.1.1, US.1.5 LITERACY AND WRITING STANDARDS RH.6-8.1 RH.6-8.2, RH.11-12.1 RH.11-12.2 WHST.6-8.2 WHST.6-8.2b WHST.11-12.2 WHST.11-12.2b OVERVIEW: DIRECTIONS: Students will learn about the inhospitable conditions that the British invading army was forced to endure during its stay in Louisiana. Have students read “American Tactics” found on page 17 of this document as well as other primary and/or secondary source documents (textbooks, encyclopedias, and reliable Internet resources) to examine the inhospitable conditions that the British troops experienced on Louisiana soil. Attention should be focused on General Jackson and his army, the people of Louisiana, and the environment and wildlife. Use the Unwelcome Guests graphic organizer below to help students assimilate, think critically about, and apply new knowledge concerning the hostile conditions that the British army was forced to endure during the months of December 1814 and January 1815. G eneral J ackson and H is T roops L ouisiana C reoles T he B ritish A rmy L ouisiana E nvironment RESOURCES: Unwelcome Guest graphic organizer Internet access for research (optional: for enrichment exercise) L ouisiana W ildlife Ask students to work with a partner to respond to each dilemma as they read about the problems and terrifying situations that the British troops experienced on Louisiana soil. Then ask students to share their findings. Engage the class in a discussion of the inhospitable conditions. Ask students to use their completed Unwelcome Guests graphic organizers while participating in the class discussion. Have students assume the role of a British soldier stationed in Louisiana during the battles to capture New Orleans. Students will write a letter home to their families in which they explain the tactics that General Jackson and his army used to harass and terrorize the British troops, the unwelcoming treatment of the Louisiana Creoles, the hostile environment, and the terrifying wildlife. ROLE AUDIENCE FORMAT British soldier in the invading British army Family at home in Letter (informative essay) Great Britain TOPIC Louisiana, it is not what we thought it would be! Students should orally present their letters to the class. Ask students to select exemplary letters. Display selected letters on a thematic bulletin board. 60 GLES: Grade 3: 46 Grade 4: 50 Grade 5: 20, 21 Grade 7: 43 Grade 8: 62, 70, 77, 78 Grade 11: US.1.1, US.1.5 LITERACY AND WRITING STANDARDS RH.6-8.1 RH.6-8.2 RH.6-8.7 RH.11-12.1 RH.11-12.2 RH.11-12.7 WHST.6-8.2b WHST.6-8.2f WHST.11-12.2b WHST.11-12-2e Activity 16: The Artillery Duel of January 1, 1815 OVERVIEW: DIRECTIONS: Students will read and analyze primary and secondary sources concerning the 1815 artillery duel of New Year’s Day and write a narrative account from the perspective of an individual who might have been present at the battle. Have students use “The Artillery Duel of January 1, 1815” reading on pages 19 and 20 of this document and other primary and/or secondary source documents to learn about the New Year’s Day artillery battle. Students should examine the events leading up to and during this important battle. Ask students to work with a partner to fill in the Concept Wheel graphic organizer. As the students read and examine the primary and secondary source documents concerning the 1815 artillery duel of New Year’s Day, they will write supporting details concerning this important battle in the spokes of the wheel. Information concerning the duel may be found on the following websites: https://archive.org/stream/historicalmemoi00latogoog#page/n156/mode/2up http://www.nps.gov/history/history/online_books/jela/hrst.htm http://www.crt.state.la.us/museum/online_exhibits/Cabildo/6.aspx http://hnoc.minisisinc.com/thnoc/scripts/mwimain.dll/144/M2A/WEB_DETAIL_M2A/SISN%209399?SESSIONSEARCH http://www.hnoc.org/BNO/bno_timeline.html http://cr.nps.gov/history/online_books/hh/29/hh29k.htm A rtillery D uel of N ew Y ear ’ s D ay RESOURCES: markers colored pencils Internet access for research (optional: for enrichment exercise) Have students share their Concept Wheels with the class. Ask students to describe the immediate and long-term consequences and problems that the British faced in having their supply base hours and miles away from their fighting forces. Post the completed Concept Wheels on a thematic bulletin board. In a concluding activity have students assume the role of a British newspaper reporter present at the artillery duel on January 1, 1815. Students will use the information in their Concept Wheels to write a narrative account in the form of a newspaper article in which they explain and describe the events that occurred during the great artillery battle (see sample below). ROLE AUDIENCE FORMAT TOPIC British newspaper reporter covering the 1815 New Year’s Day Artillery Battle Subscribers in Great Britain Newspaper article 1815 New Year’s Day Artillery Battle Students should orally present their newspaper articles to the class and then display the articles on a thematic bulletin board. The newspaper articles should be checked for logic and accuracy of cited information. Have students add the date, January 1, 1815, and other pertinent information concerning the events of the artillery duel to the Battles for New Orleans timeline. The timeline should be used to reinforce the concept of time and chronology of historical events. 61 GLES: Activity 17: What if the Baratarians had sided with the British? Grade 3: 53 Grade 4: 52 Grade 5: 23, 24, 26 Grade 7: 47, 48, 49 Grade 8: 66, 69 Grade 11: US.1.1 LITERACY AND WRITING STANDARDS RH.6-8.1 RH.6-8.2 RH.6-8.4 RH.11-12.1 RH.11-12.2 RH.11-12.4 WHST. 6-8.2 WHST. 6-8.2d WHST. 6-8.2f WHST.11-12.2 WHST.11-12.2d WHST.11-12.2e OVERVIEW: DIRECTIONS: Students will use a questioning and answering process to construct meaning from primary and secondary source texts and use critical thinking skills to summarize content as they read about the important roles that the Baratarians played in the battles for New Orleans. Have students use primary source documents as well as “The Pirate Laffite” and “Preparing the Invasion” reading passages found on pages 4 and 5 of this document to research correspondence that occurred among the British, Jean Laffite, Jean Blanque, Governor W. C. C. Claiborne, and Andrew Jackson. This activity requires students to work in pairs. Give each group a different copy of one of the primary source documents and a Question and Answer chart (see below). QUESTION AND ANSWER CHART Question Answer (include supporting details) WHO? WHAT? WHEN? WHERE? WHY? HOW? Links to the correspondence may be found on the following websites: RESOURCES: Letter from the Hon. W.H. Percy, captain of HMS, Hermes, and senior officer in the Gulf of Mexico, to Nicholas Lockyer, Esq. commander of HMS Sophia (Appendix pp. x-xi): Internet access for research Letter from the Hon. W.H. Percy, captain of HMS, Hermes, and senior officer in the Gulf of Mexico, to Nicholas Lockyer, Esq. commander of HMS Sophia (Appendix pp. x-xi): https://archive.org/stream/historicalmemoi00latogoog#page/n298/mode/2u (optional: for enrichment exercise) Letter from Mr. Laffite to Captain Lockyer, Barataria, 4th September, 1814 (Appendix pp. xi-xii): https://archive.org/stream/historicalmemoi00latogoog#page/n298/mode/2up Letter from Mr. Laffite to Mr. Blanque, Barataria, 4th September, 1814 (Appendix pp. xii-xiii) https://archive.org/stream/historicalmemoi00latogoog#page/n300/mode/2up Letter from Mr. Laffite to Mr. Blanque, Grande Terre, 7th September, 1814 (Appendix p. xiii) https://archive.org/stream/historicalmemoi00latogoog#page/n300/mode/2up Letter from Mr. Laffite to his excellency W.C.C. Claiborne (Appendix pp. xiii-xiv) https://archive.org/stream/historicalmemoi00latogoog#page/n300/mode/2up Letter from Mr. Laffite, he elder, to Mr. Blanque, Grande Terre, 10th September, 1814 (Appendix pp. xiv-xv) https://archive.org/stream/historicalmemoi00latogoog#page/n302/mode/2up Proclamation, Head-quarters, seventh military district, Mobile, September 21st, 1814 (Appendix pp. xxix-xxx) https://archive.org/stream/historicalmemoi00latogoog#page/n316/mode/2up 62 Battle of New Orleans.org http://battleofneworleans.org/laffite.htm Guide students through a reading selection from one of the letters. Stop to ask and answer the questions on the Question and Answer chart. Ask students to work with a partner to fill in the guide as they read informational text concerning the correspondence between the British, Jean Laffite, Jean Blanque, Louisiana Governor William C. C. Claiborne, and Andrew Jackson. Next ask students to share their findings with the class. Engage the class in a discussion of the critical nature of the correspondence and the impact of Laffite’s decision to support Jackson. Using their Question and Answer charts, have students write a well-organized paragraph or short essay concerning their designated primary source document. Ask for student volunteers to share their writings with the class. After completion of the study of all of the battles for New Orleans, extend this activity by focusing on the important role played by Jean Laffite and the Baratarians. Have the students reflect on the different outcome that may have occurred if the Baratarians had sided with the British. Ask students to work in groups of five to create a story chain that summarizes how different the history of Louisiana and the United States might have been if the Baratarians had not joined Jackson and the Americans at this critical time. The first student will write the opening statement, which argues that the outcome of the battles for New Orleans may have been different if not for the Baratarians. Students two, three, and four will write sentences that contain supporting details to defend the opening statement. Student five will write the concluding statement that supports the argument presented. Conclude the activity by having students read their story chain to the class. STORY CHAIN 1 3 4 2 5 63 Activity 18: Women of New Orleans GLES: Grade 3: 53 Grade 4: 52 Grade 5: 23, 24, 26 Grade 7: 47, 48, 49 Grade 8: 66, 69 Grade 11: US.1.1 LITERACY AND WRITING STANDARDS WHST.6-8.2 RH.6-8.1 WHST.6-8.2d RH.6-8.2 WHST.6-8.4 RH.6-8.4 WHST.6-8.9 RH.6-8.7 RH.6-8.10 WHST.11-12.2 RH.11-12.1 RH.11-12.2 RH.11-12.4 RH.11-12.7 RH.11-12.10 OVERVIEW: DIRECTIONS: Students will integrate visual information with other primary source texts to discover ways in which the citizens of Louisiana aided American soldiers in need. Have students read an excerpt of Laura Florian’s letter, found on page 22 of this document, as well as other primary and/or secondary source documents (textbooks, encyclopedias, and reliable Internet resources) to learn about the important role that the women of New Orleans played in supporting the American troops that came to fight in the battles for New Orleans. Use a process guide (view literacy strategy descriptions) to help students assimilate, think critically about, and apply new knowledge concerning the ways in which funds were raised to purchase supplies and the ways in which the women of New Orleans worked to support the American troops (see the Women of New Orleans to the Rescue process guide below). WOMEN OF NEW ORLEANS TO THE RESCUE: Explain why the Louisiana legislature, the city of New Orleans, and the German Coast and Attakapas regions raised funds for the militiamen. Describe the amounts of money that each group raised for this project and give the total amount raised. Describe what was purchased with these donated funds. - Louisiana State Museum Explain what the women of New Orleans did with these purchased goods. Identify who received these finished goods. RESOURCES: Women of New Orleans to the Rescue process guide One Week’s Work graphic organizer Internet access for research (optional: for enrichment exercise) 64 Ask students to work with a partner to respond to each statement in the guide as they read about the ways in which the women of New Orleans helped to supply the needs of the American army. Next ask students to share their findings. Engage the class in a discussion of the desperate situation that some of Jackson’s troops faced, the financial action taken by the people and government of Louisiana, and the response of the New Orleans women to supply the troops with provisions. Ask students to use their completed process guides while participating in the class discussion. Information concerning the actions of the Louisiana legislature and the citizens of Louisiana to assist the troops that came to defend New Orleans against the British invasion may be found on the following websites: Historical Memoir of The War in West Florida and Louisiana in 1814-1815 by Major Arsène Lacarrière Latour, Chief Engineer in the Late 7th Military District, United States Army (last paragraphs on pages 141 and 142) https://archive.org/stream/historicalmemoi00latogoog#page/n164/mode/2up Letter from Laura Eugenie Florian to Lydia Latrobe Roosevelt concerning the Battle of New Orleans http://hnoc.minisisinc.com/THNOC/SCRIPTS/mwimain.dll/144/THNOC_MANUSCRIPTS/WEB_DETAIL_M2A_INHOUSE/REFD+’mss%20 645’?SESSIONSEARCH General Jackson’s letter to Nicholas Girod Esq., Mayor of the City of New Orleans, Head-quarters, 7th Military District, January 27, 1815 https://archive.org/stream/historicalmemoi00latogoog#page/n360/mode/2up Using information from Historical Memoir of the War in West Florida in 1814 –1815 by Major Arsène Lacarrière Latour, have students complete the One Week’s Work graphic organizer (see below). ONE WEEK’S WORK Article Produced Number Produced Visual of Items blanket cloaks waistcoats pantaloons shirts shoes mattresses Ask for student volunteers to share their One Week’s Work graphic organizer with the class. Discuss with the class the different styles and types of clothing worn by the American troops. Focus on the vast quantity of items that were hand produced by the women of New Orleans in only one week. In a culminating activity, have students imagine that they are one of the soldiers in great need of warmer clothing during the battles for New Orleans. Have the students write a thank you letter to a woman in New Orleans who provided the much appreciated clothing item. Students should include the ways in which the clothing item helped to influence the outcome of the battles. Ask student volunteers to share their thank you letters with the class and facilitate any discussion that may follow ROLE AUDIENCE FORMAT TOPIC American soldier in need of warmer clothing and supplies at the battles for New Orleans New Orleans woman Thank you note Response to receipt of gift of a new item of clothing or equipment 65 Activity 19: January 8, 1815, Battle of New Orleans GLES: Grade 3: 46, 47, 48 Grade 4: 50, 54, 58 Grade 7: 43, 46, 47 Grade 8: 62, 65, 66, 72 77 Grade 11: US.1.1, UW.1.5 LITERACY AND WRITING STANDARDS RH.6-8.1 RH.6-8.2 RH.6-8.3 RH.11-12.1 RH.11-12.2 RH.11-12.3 WHST.6-8.2 WHST.6-8.2f WHST.11-12.2 WHST.11-12.2e OVERVIEW: DIRECTIONS: Students will use primary and secondary sources to learn about and chronologically plot the events of the Battle of New Orleans of January 8, 1815. Provide students with an anticipation guide that contains statements about the January 8, 1815, Battle of New Orleans (see the January 8, 1815, Battle of New Orleans sample on page 67). Have students use “The Battle of January 8, 1815” reading on pages 25–27 of this document, textbooks, encyclopedias, and reliable Internet resources to read about the events that occurred during the battle and to complete their anticipation guides. The “Before” column of the anticipation guide will be completed before any research or discussion takes place; the “After” column will be completed after students read or discuss the informational source. Before reading about the January 8, 1815, Battle of New Orleans, read each statement and mark if you agree or disagree with the statement. After reading, go back to each statement and decide whether the “before” reading responses need to be changed. For all statements, provide evidence from the primary and secondary sources for the “after” reading responses. RESOURCES: markers colored pencils Internet access for research (optional: for enrichment exercise) 66 Ask students to work in pairs to discuss their responses before reading and learning the content. Open the discussion to the entire class in order to provide multiple hunches about the accuracy of the statements. Do not give any answers at this point. Stop periodically as content is covered and ask students to reconsider their pre-lesson responses. Students should revise their original responses as they gain new knowledge about the statements. JANUARY 8, 1815, BATTLE OF NEW ORLEANS ANTICIPATION GUIDE 1. The British used rockets to signal the beginning of the attack on January 8th. before agree disagree after agree disagree evidence 2. The American forces met the approaching British army on the battlefield. before agree disagree after agree disagree evidence 3. The deadly fire of the American guns and cannons forced the British troops to retreat shortly after the battle began. before agree disagree after agree disagree evidence 4. A large number of British officers were killed early in the battle. before agree disagree after agree disagree evidence 5. The fighting on January 8th took place on the east and west sides of the Mississippi River. before agree disagree after agree disagree evidence 6. Three out of four American generals died during the battle. before agree disagree after agree disagree evidence 7. The British were successful in the battle on the West Bank of the Mississippi River. before agree disagree after agree disagree evidence 8. The British regrouped and were able to scale the American line on their second attempt. before agree disagree after agree disagree evidence 9. The Americans won the January 8th Battle of New Orleans. before agree disagree after agree disagree evidence 10. Jackson’s victory at the Battles of New Orleans helped him to become the 7th president of the United States. before agree disagree after agree disagree evidence 67 Activity 19 (continued) Information concerning the January 8th Battle of New Orleans may be found on the following websites: https://archive.org/stream/historicalmemoi00latogoog#page/n176/mode/2up http://www.crt.state.la.us/museum/online_exhibits/Cabildo/6.aspx http://www.hnoc.org/BNO/bno_timeline.html http://www.hnoc.org/BNO/william_cook.html http://cr.nps.gov/history/online_books/hh/29/hh29m.htm http://cr.nps.gov/history/online_books/hh/29/hh29p.htm http://cr.nps.gov/history/online_books/hh/29/hh29q.htm http://www.nps.gov/history/history/online_books/jela/hrst.htm Upon completion of the presentation of information, engage students in a discussion involving the anticipation guide statements in order to clarify any misconceptions about the issues, information, or concepts. Anticipation guides are especially helpful to struggling and reluctant readers and learners as they increase motivation and focus students’ attention on important aspects of the content. Provide students with a Chain of Events graphic organizer. Chain of Events graphic organizers are used to describe the stages or steps of an event. Students will use the information in their anticipation guides and readings to complete the graphic organizer concerning the stages of the January 8th Battle of New Orleans. Key questions that may be asked when organizing information are: What was the first event that initiated the battle? What are the next events? How are the events connected? What is the final outcome? Have students present their Chain of Events graphic organizers to the class and hold a class discussion in which students explain and analyze the stages of the January 8th Battle of New Orleans. Display the Chain of Events graphic organizers in the classroom. Have students work individually, using the information from their Chain of Events graphic organizer, to write an explanatory essay in which they narrate the sequence of historical events that occurred during the January 8th Battle of New Orleans. Students should also include the effects of the victory in New Orleans on the nation, New Orleans, and General Andrew Jackson. Ask students to share their completed essays with the class. Have students add the date and other pertinent information concerning the events of the January 8, 1815, battle to the timeline. The timeline should be used to reinforce the concept of time and chronology of historical events. 68 B eginning F irst E vent S econd E vent T hird E vent F ourth E vent F inal E vent GLES: Grade 3: 46, 47, 54 Grade 4: 50, 53, 58 Grade 7: 43, 44, 46 Grade 8: 62, 65, 70, 77 Grade 11: US.1.1, US.1 LITERACY AND WRITING STANDARDS RH.6-8.1 RH.6-8.2 RH.6-8.3 RH.6-8.4 RH.6-8.5 RH.11-12.1 RH.11-12.2 RH.11-12.3 RH.11-12.4 RH.11-12.5 Activity 20: Treaty of Ghent WHST.6-8.2 WHST.6-8.2b WHST.6-8.2f WHST.11-12.2 WHST.11-12.2b WHST.11-12.2e OVERVIEW: DIRECTIONS: The students will research events pertaining to the end of the War of 1812 and the Treaty of Ghent to determine if the battles for New Orleans made a difference in the outcome of the war and the history of the United States. Generate a prompt related to the Treaty of Ghent that will cause students to wonder, challenge, and question whether the battles for New Orleans, which were fought after the signing of the peace treaty, really made a difference in the outcome of the war and the history of the United States. The prompt does not have to be factual, but it should provoke interest and curiosity. The following is a sample prompt: The War of 1812 ended on December 24, 1815, when Great Britain and the United States signed the Treaty of Ghent. The battles that were fought for New Orleans really did not matter because the war was over. Present the prompt to the students. Students should pair up and generate two to three questions about the prompt they would like answered. Examples of student questions might resemble these: Why were the battles fought after the war was over? Who won the War of 1812? Did the British get to keep the land that they captured during the war? Did the British promise to stop impressing Americans? RESOURCES: Treaty of Ghent split-page notetaking chart The Causes and Effects of the Events of the War of 1812 Internet access for research (optional: for enrichment exercise) When all student pairs have generated at least two questions, ask someone from each team to share their questions with the entire class. Write the questions on the board. When similar questions are asked, star or highlight these questions. After all student questions have been shared, add questions addressing important information that the students may have omitted. Have students read “When Did the War Officially End?” “What if the British Had Won the Battle?” and “Who Won the Battle of New Orleans?” on pages 30–32 of this document. Students should also read the “Smoking Gun” letter found on page 30. Discuss with the students the importance of the Battle of New Orleans and how it is remembered and celebrated as one of the most significant military victories in the history of the United States. Also talk about how this victory catapulted Andrew Jackson into the nation’s spotlight. As students read informational text or listen to information presented orally on the topic of the Treaty of Ghent, they should pay attention to information that helps answer the questions written on the board. Special attention should be focused on the questions that are starred or highlighted. As the content is covered, stop periodically and have students discuss with their partners which questions have now been answered. Ask for volunteers to share their findings. 69 Activity 20 (continued) Use split-page notetaking (see sample chart below) to have students record the questions from the board and the answers provided by the readings and class discussion. Students will use the questions and answers for later study. TREATY OF GHENT Date: December 24, 1814 Why were the battles fought after the war was over? Treaty of Ghent The means of communication were very slow. It took weeks for the news to travel across the Atlantic to Washington, DC, and then more time was needed for the news to reach New Orleans. The forces in New Orleans were not aware that the treaty had been signed on Christmas Eve. History of the Treaty of Ghent may be found on these websites: http://www.ourdocuments.gov/doc.php?flash=true&doc=20 http://www.archives.gov/historical-docs/todays-doc/?dod-date=1224 http://avalon.law.yale.edu/19th_century/ghent.asp http://www.loc.gov/rr/program/bib/ourdocs/Ghent.html http://www.pbs.org/wned/war-of-1812/essays/treaty-ghent/ http://www.history.com/topics/treaty-of-ghent Treaty of Ghent video: http://www.pbs.org/wned/war-of-1812/classroom/commencement/dissecting-treaty-ghent/ Gather the class back together. Solicit observations from each group and discuss their findings with the class. Compare student findings and have students check the work in their split-page notes for accuracy. Some teacher guidance may be needed. Have students work individually, using the information in their Treaty of Ghent split-page notes to write an informative essay in which they establish a claim as to which country won the War of 1812 and whether the battles for New Orleans did make a difference in the history of the United States. Ask student volunteers to read their summaries, checking for accuracy and facilitating any resulting discussions. In a culminating activity, have students complete the flow chart in which they analyze the causes and effects of the events of the War of 1812. Ask students to share their completed flow charts with the class. Reasons America Declared War on Great Britain Provisions of the Treaty of Ghent War of 1812 Treaty of Ghent December 24, 1814 Have students add the date and other pertinent information concerning the Treaty of Ghent and events pertaining to the end of the War of 1812 to the timeline. The timeline should be used to reinforce the concept of time and chronology of historical events. 70 GLES: Grade 3: 48, 53, 54 Grade 4: 54, 57 Grade 5: 24, 26 Grade 7: 46, 47, 50 Grade 8: 65, 66, 67 Grade 11: US.1.1, US.1.5 LITERACY AND WRITING STANDARDS RH.6-8.1 WHST 6-8.2 RH.6-8.2 WHST.6-8.2d RH.6-8.4 WHST.6-8.2f RH.6-8.6 WHST.11-12.2 RH.6-8.8 WHST.11-12.e RH.11-12.1 RH.11-12.2 RH.11-12.4 RH.11-12.6 RH.11-12.9 Activity 21: Songs about the Battle of New Orleans OVERVIEW: DIRECTIONS: Students will analyze songs as historical artifacts to learn about the January 8, 1815, Battle of New Orleans; identify key events, people, and beliefs associated with the battle; and compare and contrast two songs that were written about the battle. Have students read “Who Won the Battle of New Orleans?” on page 32 of this document. Discuss with the students the contributions made by the many different ethnic groups that fought on the American side. Provide students with copies of the “Battle of New Orleans” song by Johnny Horton, the “Hunters of Kentucky or Half Horse and Half Alligator” song, and the Library of Congress Songs and Poems Analysis worksheet. Songs and worksheet may be found on the following websites: “Battle of New Orleans” song lyrics by Jimmy Driftwood: http://kids.niehs.nih.gov/games/songs/patriotic/battleofmid.htm The story of the “Battle of New Orleans” song and author: http://www.tsimon.com/battle.htm “Battle of New Orleans” song lyrics sung by Johnny Horton: http://www.louisiana101.com/battle.html “Battle of New Orleans” by Johnny Horton: http://www.teachertube.com/viewVideo.php?video_id=19272 RESOURCES: “Battle of New Orleans” song lyrics by Jimmy Driftwood “Hunters of Kentucky, or Half Horse Half Alligator” song lyrics The Library of Congress Songs and Poems Analysis worksheet “Hunters of Kentucky or Half Horse and Half Alligator” song and the Library of Congress Songs and Poems Analysis worksheet: http://www.loc.gov/teachers/lyrical/songs/hunter_kentucky.html http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7rFB2Pq19yU Place students in small groups. Allow time for students to read the songs. Play the “Battle of New Orleans” song by Johnny Horton. Ask for student volunteers to read the “Hunters of Kentucky or Half Horse and Half Alligator” song. Listen to the song that is recorded on the youtube link. Hold a class discussion concerning students’ opinions of the two songs. 71 Activity 21 (continued) Students will work in their small groups to discuss and analyze the two songs as historical artifacts as they complete the Library of Congress Songs and Poems Analysis worksheet. Hold a class discussion in which a spokesperson from each group shares their group’s findings. Focus questions may include the following: 1.What is the message a listener/reader can get from the song lyrics? 2.What might the intended purpose of the song be? 3.What does the song say about an event in history? 4.What fighting groups are mentioned? Why do you think that so little is mentioned about the Louisiana forces? 5.What exaggerations are made in the songs? 6.How is General Jackson portrayed in the two songs? How does the Battle of New Orleans affect Jackson’s political future? 7.What questions does this song raise? How can the students find the answers to their questions? Have students compare and contrast the two songs using the Venn diagram below. Using the completed information from the Venn diagram as well as the Library of Congress worksheets, have students paraphrase the information by writing an informative paragraph in which they include narration of the historical event or draw an illustration that narrates the historical events described in the songs. Post student work on a thematic bulletin board. “Hunters of Kentucky or Half Horse and Half Alligator” song 72 “The Battle of New Orleans” song “The Battle of New Orleans” song Music and lyrics by Jimmy Driftwood Well, in eighteen and fourteen we took a little trip along with Colonel Jackson down the mighty Mississip. We took a little bacon and we took a little beans, And we caught the bloody British near the town of New Orleans. We fired our guns and the British kept a’comin. There wasn’t nigh as many as there was a while ago. We fired once more and they began to runnin’ down the Mississippi to the Gulf of Mexico. Well, I see’d Mars Jackson walkin down the street talkin’ to a pirate by the name of Jean Lafitte He gave Jean a drink that he brung from Tennessee and the pirate said he’d help us drive the British in the sea. The French said Andrew, you’d better run, for Packingham’s a comin’ with a bullet in his gun. Old Hickory said he didn’t give a dang, he’s gonna whip the britches off of Colonel Packingham. We fired our guns and the British kept a’comin. There wasn’t nigh as many as there was a while ago. We fired once more and they began to runnin’ down the Mississippi to the Gulf of Mexico. Well, we looked down the river and we see’d the British come, and there must have been a hundred of ‘em beatin’ on the drum. They stepped so high and they made their bugles ring while we stood by our cotton bales and didn’t say a thing. Old Hickory said we could take ‘em by surprise if we didn’t fire a musket til we looked ‘em in the eyes. We held our fire til we see’d their faces well, then we opened up with squirrel guns and really gave a yell. We fired our guns and the British kept a’comin. There wasn’t nigh as many as there was a while ago. We fired once more and they began to runnin’ down the Mississippi to the Gulf of Mexico. Well, we fired our cannon til the barrel melted down, so we grabbed an alligator and we fought another round. We filled his head with cannon balls and powdered his behind, and when they tetched the powder off, the gator lost his mind. We’ll march back home but we’ll never be content till we make Old Hickory the people’s President. And every time we think about the bacon and the beans, we’ll think about the fun we had way down in New Orleans. “Hunters of Kentucky or Half Horse and Half Alligator” song http://www.loc.gov/teachers/lyrical/songs/hunter_kentucky.html We fired our guns and the British kept a’comin, But there wasn’t nigh as many as there was a while ago. We fired once more and they began to runnin’ down the Mississippi to the Gulf of Mexico. Well, they ran through the briars and they ran through the brambles And they ran through the bushes where a rabbit couldn’t go. They ran so fast the hounds couldn’t catch ‘em down the Mississippi to the Gulf of Mexico. We fired our guns and the British kept a’comin. But there wasn’t nigh as many as there was a while ago. We fired once more and they began to runnin’ down the Mississippi to the Gulf of Mexico. “Battle of New Orleans” song lyrics by Jimmy Driftwood: http://kids.niehs.nih.gov/games/songs/patriotic/battleofmid.htm 73 Appendix 74 Extended-Response Rubric EXTENDED-RESPONSE RUBRIC SCORE DESCRIPTION 4 The student’s response • constructs a sophisticated argument; • supports the argument with ample, well-chosen evidence; • addresses and demonstrates understanding of four of the documents; • integrates a substantial amount of relevant information beyond what is provided in the documents; • contains valid historical understandings and interpretations with no errors significant enough to detract from the argument. 3 The student’s response • constructs an acceptable argument; • supports the argument with sufficient and appropriate evidence; • addresses and demonstrates understanding of three of the documents; • integrates adequate relevant information beyond what is provided in the documents; • contains mostly valid historical understandings and interpretations, although less important ideas or details may be overlooked or misunderstood. 2 The student’s response • constructs a weak and/or flawed argument; • supports the argument with limited and/or uneven evidence; • addresses and demonstrates understanding of two of the documents; • integrates some relevant information beyond what is provided in the documents; • contains some valid historical understandings and interpretations, but a few significant errors may be present. 1 The student’s response • must include at least one valid historical understanding or interpretation that addresses the prompt and is stated in the student’s own words; • must demonstrate a minimal understanding of the topic; • may contain several significant errors. 0 The student’s response is incorrect, irrelevant, too brief to evaluate, or blank. 75 Grade-Level Expectations Literacy and Writing Standards 3rd Grade Geography 3 Interpret a graph, chart, and diagram (G-1A-E2) 4 Use a compass rose and cardinal directions to locate and interpret a map of the community and Louisiana (G-1A-E2) 5 Locate major geographic features of Louisiana on a map (G-1A-E2) 6 Construct a chart, line graph, or diagram to display geographical information (G-1A- E3) 3rd Grade Historical Thinking Skills 46 Complete a timeline based on given information (H-1A-E1) 47 Use information in a map, table, or graph to describe the past (H-1A-E3) 48 Identify primary and secondary sources (H-1A-E3) 4th Grade Geography 5 Draw, complete, and add features to a map (including such map elements as a title, compass rose, legend, and scale), based on given information (G-1A-E3) 4th Grade Historical Thinking Skills 50 Interpret data presented in a timeline or construct a historical timeline (e.g., events in history, historical figure’s life and accomplishments) (H-1A-E1) 53 Interpret historical information in a map, table, or graph (H-1A-E3) 54 Compare and contrast primary and secondary sources (H-1A-E3) 5th Grade Geography 3 Interpret a map, using a map key/legend and symbols, distance scale, compass rose, cardinal or intermediate directions, and latitude and longitude (G-1A-M2) 4 Locate major landforms and geographic features, places, and bodies of water/waterways on a map of the United States (G-1A-M2) 5th Grade Historical Thinking Skills 20 Interpret data presented in a timeline or construct a historical timeline (e.g., events in history, historical figure’s life and accomplishments) (H-1A-E1) Construct a timeline of key events in American history (beginnings to 1763) (H-1A- M1) 21 Demonstrate an understanding of relative and absolute chronology by interpreting data presented in a timeline (H-1A-M1) 22 Identify different points of view about key events in early American history (H-1A-M2) 23 Identify the causes, effects, or impact of a given event in early American history (H-1A-M3) 24 Use both a primary and secondary source to describe key events or issues in early American history (H-1A-M4) 25 Identify historical issues or problems in early America and explain how they were addressed (H-1A-M5) 26 Conduct historical research using a variety of resources to answer historical questions related to early American history (H-1A-M6) 7th Grade Geography 76 1 Analyze various types of maps, charts, graphs, and diagrams related to U.S. history (G-1A-M2) 3 Identify and describe significant physical features that have influenced U.S. historical events (e.g., Ohio River Valley in the American Revolution) (G-1A-M2) 7th Grade Historical Thinking Skills 43 Construct a timeline of key events and key figures in U.S. history from 1763 to 1877 (H-1A-M1) 44 Interpret a timeline to identify cause-and-effect relationships among events in U.S. history (H-1A-M1) 45 Explain the point of view of key historical figures and groups in U.S. history (H-1A-M2) 46 Explain the causes, effects, or impact of a given historical even in U.S. history (H-1A-M3) 47 Explain how a given historical figure influenced or changed the course of U.S. history (H-1A-M3) 48 Compare and contrast two primary sources related to the same event in U.S. history (H-1A-M4) 49 Propose and defend an alternative course of action to a given issue or problem in U.S. history (H-1A-M5) 50 Conduct historical research using a variety of resources, and evaluate those resources for reliability and bias, to answer historical questions related to U.S. history (H-1A-M6) 8th Grade Geography 2 Locate major landforms and geographic features, places, and bodies of water/waterways on a map of Louisiana (G-1A-M2) 4 Construct a chart or diagram to display geographical information in an organized way (G-1A-M2) 6 Describe ways in which location and physical features have influenced historical events in Louisiana and the development of the state (e.g., Mississippi River/swamp in the Battle of New Orleans) (H-1A-M2) 8th Grade Historical Thinking Skills 62 Construct a timeline of key events in Louisiana history (H-1A-M1) 63 Interpret data presented in a timeline correlating Louisiana, U.S., and world history (H-1A-M1) 65 Analyze the causes, effect, or impact of a given historical event in Louisiana (H-1A-M3) 66 Analyze how a given historical figure influenced or changed the course of Louisiana’s history (H-1A-M3) 67 Identify given source material to identify opinion, propaganda, or bias (H-1A-M4) 68 Interpret a political cartoon (H-1A-M6) 69 Propose and defend potential solutions to past and current issues in Louisiana (H-1A-M5) 70 Conduct historical research using a variety of resources, and evaluate those resources, to answer historical questions related to Louisiana history (H-1A-M6) 72 Describe leaders who were influential in Louisiana’s development (H-1D-M1) 75 Describe the contributions of ethnic groups significant in Louisiana history (H-1D-M1) 77 Describe major conflicts in context of Louisiana history (H-1D-M3) 78 Describe and analyze the impact of Louisiana’s geographic features on historic events, settlement patterns, and economic development, etc. (H-1D-M4) 11th Grade Historical Thinking US.1.1 Produce clear and coherent writing for a range of tasks, purposes, and audiences by: • conducting short and sustained research • evaluating conclusions from evidence (broad variety, primary and secondary sources) • evaluating varied explanations for actions/events • determining the meaning of words and phrases from historical texts • analyzing historians’ points of view US.1.5 Analyze historical periods using timelines, political cartoons, maps, graphs, debates, and other historical sources 77 Grade-Level Expectations Literacy and Writing Standards Literacy and Writing Standards for Literacy in History/Social Studies 6–12 Reading Standards for Literacy in History/Social Studies 6–12 78 RH.6-8.1 Cite specific textual evidence to support analysis of primary and secondary sources. RH.6-8.2 Determine the central ideas or information of a primary or secondary source; provide an accurate summary of the source distinct from prior knowledge or opinions. RH.6-8.3 Identify key steps in a text’s description of a process related to history/social studies (e.g., how a bill becomes law, how interest rates are raised or lowered). RH.6-8.4 Determine the meaning of words and phrases as they are used in a text, including vocabulary specific to domains related to history/social studies. RH.6-8.5 Describe how a text presents information (e.g., sequentially, comparatively, and causally). RH.6-8.6 Identify aspects of a text that reveal an author’s point of view or purpose (e.g., loaded language, inclusion or avoidance of particular facts). RH.6-8.7 Integrate visual information (e.g., in charts, graphs, photographs, videos, or maps) with other information in print and digital texts. RH.6-8.8 Distinguish among fact, opinion, and reasoned judgment in a text. RH.6-8.10 By the end of grade 8 read and comprehend history/social studies texts in the grades 6–8 text complexity band independently and proficiently. RH.11-12.1 Cite specific textual evidence to support analysis of primary and secondary sources, connecting insights gained from specific details to an understanding of the text as a whole. RH.11-12.2 Determine the central ideas or information of a primary or secondary source; provide an accurate summary that makes clear the relationships among the key details and ideas. RH.11-12.3 Evaluate various explanations for actions or events and determine which explanation best accords with textual evidence, acknowledging where the text leaves matters uncertain. RH.11-12.4 Determine the meaning of words and phrases as they are used in a text, including analyzing how an author uses and refines the meaning of a key term over the course of a text (e.g., how Madison defines faction in Federalist No. 10). RH.11-12.5 Analyze in detail how a complex primary source is structured, including how key sentences, paragraphs, and larger portions of the text contribute to the whole. RH.11-12.6 Evaluate authors’ differing points of view on the same historical event or issue by assessing the authors’ claims, reasoning, and evidence. RH.11-12.7 Integrate and evaluate multiple sources of information presented in diverse formats and media (e.g., visually, quantitatively, as well as in words) in order to address a question or solve a problem. RH.11-12.9 Integrate information from diverse sources, both primary and secondary, into a coherent understanding of an idea or event, noting discrepancies among sources. RH.11-12.10 By the end of grade 12, read and comprehend history/social studies texts in the grades 11–CCR text complexity band independently and proficiently. Writing Standards for Literacy in History/Social Studies, Science, Technical Subjects 6–12 WHST.6-8.1 Write arguments focused on discipline-specific content. WHST.6-8.2 Write informative/explanatory texts, including the narration of historical events, scientific procedures/ experiments, or technical processes. WHST.6-8.2a Introduce a topic clearly, previewing what is to follow; organize ideas, concepts, and information into broader categories as appropriate to achieving purpose; include formatting (e.g., headings), graphics (e.g., charts, tables), and multimedia when useful to aiding comprehension. WHST.6-8.2b Develop the topic with relevant, well-chosen facts, definitions, concrete details, quotations, or other information and examples. WHST.6-8.2d Use precise language and domain-specific vocabulary to inform about or explain the topic. WHST.6-8.2f Provide a concluding statement or section that follows from and supports the information or explanation presented. WHST.6-8.4 Produce clear and coherent writing in which the development, organization, and style are appropriate to task, purpose, and audience. WHST.6-8.6 Use technology, including the Internet, to produce and publish writing and present the relationships between information and ideas clearly and efficiently WHST.6-8.9 Draw evidence from informational texts to support analysis, reflection, and research. WHST.11-12.2 Write informative/explanatory texts, including the narration of historical events, scientific procedures/ experiments, or technical processes. WHST.11-12.2a Introduce a topic and organize complex ideas, concepts, and information so that each new element builds on that which precedes it to create a unified whole; include formatting (e.g., headings), graphics (e.g., figures, tables), and multimedia when useful to aiding comprehension. WHST.11-12.2b Develop the topic thoroughly by selecting the most significant and relevant facts, extended definitions, concrete details, quotations, or other information and examples appropriate to the audience’s knowledge of the topic. WHST.11-12.2d Use precise language, domain-specific vocabulary and techniques such as metaphor, simile, and analogy to manage the complexity of the topic; convey a knowledgeable stance in a style that responds to the discipline and context as well as to the expertise of likely readers. WHST.11-12.2e Provide a concluding statement or section that follows from and supports the information or explanation provided (e.g., articulating implications or the significance of the topic). WHST.11-12.9 Draw evidence from informational texts to support analysis, reflection, and research. 79 Selected Sources SELECTED BOOKS ABOUT THE BATTLE OF NEW ORLEANS Robert Aitchison, A British Eyewitness at the Battle of New Orleans: The Memoir of Royal Navy Admiral Robert Aitchison, 1808–1827, Gene A. Smith, ed. (The Historic New Orleans Collection 2004) Harry Albright, New Orleans: Battle of the Bayous (Hippocrene Books 1990) Wilburt S. Brown, The Amphibious Campaign for West Florida and Louisiana, 1814-–1815: A Critical Review of Strategy and Tactics at New Orleans (University of Alabama Press 1969) Ron Chapman, The Battle of New Orleans: But For a Piece of Wood (Ron Chapman 2013) John Henry Cooke, A Narrative of Events in the South of France, and of the Attack on New Orleans, in 1814 and 1815 (T. and W. Boone 1835) Jane Lucas De Grummond, The Baratarians and the Battle of New Orleans (Louisiana State University Press 1961) Remy R. Dixon, The Battle on the West Bank (The Battle of New Orleans 150th Anniversary Committee of Louisiana 1965) E. M. Eller, W. J. Morgan, and R. M. Basoco, Sea Power and the Battle of New Orleans (The Battle of New Orleans 150th Anniversary Committee of Louisiana 1965) George R. Gleig, A Narrative of the Campaigns of the British Army at Washington and New Orleans, under Generals Ross, Pakenham, and Lambert, in the years 1814 and 1815....(John Murray 1821) Winston Groom, Patriotic Fire: Andrew Jackson and Jean Laffite at the Battle of New Orleans (Alfred A. Knopf 2006) Leonard V. Huber, New Orleans as it was in 1814–1815 (The Battle of New Orleans 150th Anniversary Committee of Louisiana 1965) Stuart O. Landry, Side Lights on the Battle of New Orleans (Pelican Press 1965) Arsène Lacarrière Latour, Historical Memoir of the War in West Florida and Louisiana in 1814–15, Expanded ed. (The Historic New Orleans Collection; University Press of Florida 1999) William A. Meuse, The Weapons of the Battle of New Orleans (The Battle of New Orleans 150th Anniversary Committee of Louisiana 1965) Frank L. Owsley, Struggle for the Gulf Borderlands: The Creek War and the Battle of New Orleans, 1812–1815 (University Presses of Florida 1981) Benton Rain Patterson, The Generals: Andrew Jackson, Sir Edward Pakenham, and the Road to the Battle of New Orleans (New York University Press 2005) 80 Tim Pickles, New Orleans 1815: Andrew Jackson Crushes the British (Osprey 1994) Robin Reilly, The British at the Gates: The New Orleans Campaign in the War of 1812, rev. ed. (Robin Brass Studio 2002) Robert V. Remini, The Battle of New Orleans: Andrew Jackson and America’s First Military Victory (Viking 1999) Valerie McNair Scott, Major-General Sir Edward M. Pakenham (The Battle of New Orleans 150th Anniversary Committee of Louisiana 1965) Alexander Walker, Jackson and New Orleans: an Authentic Narrative of the Memorable Achievements of the American Army, Under Andrew Jackson, Before New Orleans, in the Winter of 1814, ’15 (J.C. Derby; H.W. Derby 1856) Samuel L. Wilson Jr., Plantation Houses on the Battlefield of New Orleans (The Battle of New Orleans 150th Anniversary Committee of Louisiana 1965) SELECTED BOOKS CONCERNING MILITIA AND VOLUNTEER SOLDIERS Powell A. Casey, Louisiana at the Battle of New Orleans (The Battle of New Orleans 150th Anniversary Committee of Louisiana 1965) Powell A. Casey, Louisiana in the War of 1812 (Privately published 1963) Marcus Bruce Christian, Negro Soldiers in the Battle of New Orleans (The Battle of New Orleans 150th Anniversary Committee of Louisiana 1965) William C. Davis, The Pirates Laffite: the Treacherous World of the Corsairs of the Gulf (Harcourt 2005) Ed Gilbert, Frontier Militiaman in the War of 1812: Southwestern Frontier, Adam Hook, illustrator (Osprey 2008) Tom Kanon, Tennesseans at War, 1812–1815 (University of Alabama Press 2014) Rosemarie Fay Loomis, Negro Soldiers, Free Men of Color in the Battle of New Orleans, War of 1812 (Aux Quartres Vents 1991) Roland C. McConnell, Negro Troops of Antebellum Louisiana: A History of the Battalion of Free Men of Color (Louisiana State University Press 1968) Marion John Bennett Pierson, compiler, Louisiana Soldiers in the War of 1812 (1963; reprinted for Clearfield Co. by Genealogical Pub. Co. 2003) Elbert L. Watson, Tennessee at the Battle of New Orleans (The Battle of New Orleans 150th Anniversary Committee of Louisiana 1965) 81 SELECTED BOOKS ABOUT THE WAR OF 1812 AND CREEK WAR Kathryn Braund, ed. Tohopeka: Rethinking the Creek War and the War of 1812 (Pebble Hill Books 2012) René Chartrand, A Most Warlike Appearance: Uniforms, Flags and Equipment of the United States Forces in the War of 1812 (Service Publications 2010) Ronald J. Drez, The War of 1812 Conflict and Deception: The British Attempt to Seize New Orleans and Nullify the Louisiana Purchase (Louisiana State University Press 2014) Donald Hickey, Don’t Give Up The Ship!: Myths of the War of 1812 (University of Illinois Press 2006) Andrew Lambert, The Challenge: Britain against America in the Naval War of 1812 (Faber & Faber 2012) Benson L. Lossing, The Pictorial Field-Book of the War of 1812…. (Harper & Brothers 1869) Nathaniel Millett, The Maroons of Prospect Bluff and Their Quest for Freedom in the Atlantic World (University Press of Florida 2013) Robert V. Remini, Andrew Jackson and His Indian Wars (Viking Press 2001) Mrs. Dunbar Rowland, Andrew Jackson’s Campaign Against the British, or the Mississippi Territory in the War of 1812. Concerning the Military Operations of the Americans, Creek Indians, British, and Spanish, 1813–1815 (Macmillan 1929) Gene A. Smith, The Slaves’ Gamble: Choosing Sides in the War of 1812 (Palgrave McMillan 2013) J. C. A. Stagg, The War of 1812: Conflict for a Continent (Cambridge University Press 2012) Alan Taylor, The Civil War of 1812: American Citizens, British Subjects, Irish Rebels, and Indian Allies (Vintage 2011) Alan Taylor, The Internal Enemy: Slavery and War in Virginia, 1772–1832 (W. W. Norton & Company 2013) 82 SELECTED JOURNAL ARTICLES “A Contemporary Account of the Battle of New Orleans by a Soldier in the Ranks,” Louisiana Historical Quarterly IX (January 1926) Alexander Dickson, “Journal of Operations in Louisiana,” Louisiana Historical Quarterly XLIV, nos. 3 and 4 (January–April 1961) Major Forrest, “Journal of the Operations Against New Orleans in 1814 and 1815,” Louisiana Historical Quarterly XLIV (January–April 1961) John A. Fort to “Dear Brother,” January 28, 1815, in “Historical Documents,” Louisiana Historical Quarterly XXXII (January 1949) John K. Mahon, “British Command Decisions Relative to the Battle of New Orleans,” Louisiana History 6.1 (Winter 1965) Carson I. A. Ritchie, “The Louisiana Campaign,” Louisiana Historical Quarterly XLIV, nos. 1 and 2 (January–April 1961) John Snyder, “Jean Lafitte and the British Offer of 1814,” Louisiana History 20 (Spring 1979) Howell Tatum, “Major Howell Tatum’s Journal While Acting Topographical Engineer (1814) to General Jackson Commanding the Seventh Military District,” ed. John Spencer Bassett, Smith College Studies in History VII (October 1921– April 1922) Robert C. Vogel, “Jean Laffite, the Baratarians, and the Battle of New Orleans: A Reappraisal,” Louisiana History 41.3 (Summer 2000) Robert C. Vogel, “The Patterson and Ross Raid on Barataria, September 1814,” Louisiana History 33.2 (Spring 1992) Matthew Warshauer, “The Battle of New Orleans Reconsidered: Andrew Jackson and Martial Law,” Louisiana History 39.3 (Summer 1998) 83 84 85