WingBeats Volume 3 Number 2 - Florida Mosquito Control Association
Transcription
WingBeats Volume 3 Number 2 - Florida Mosquito Control Association
of the American Mosquito Control Association , Vol. 3, No.2 by the Florida Mosquito Control Association Summer 1992 r-~--------------------------------------~------------------------------------~~~~~~~~~~~~ of the American Mosquito Control Association , Vol. 3, No.2 by the Florida Mosquito Control Association Summer 1992 DIBROM®Concentrate provides fast, consistent knockdown of adult mosquitoes. DIBROM Concentrate will effectively control your large-area mosquito problems, whether it's residential areas and munici palities, tidal marshes, swamps and wood lands or livestoCk pastures and feedlots. DIBROM is a fast-acting, short resid ual organophosphate insecticide that is proven effective against the most tolerant and resistant strains of mosquitoes. ·' By using DIBROM as labeled, you won't affect fish, wildlife or livestock, so it's environmentally compatible. It can easily be applied by ground or air, and its low application rate gives significantly more coverage per tankload. If you're looking for a solution to large area mosquito control, look to DIBROM Concentrate. Ma ke sure they never get off the ground again. DIBROM®CONCENTRATE Avoid accidents. For safety. (ead the entire label incrudlng precauliona'Y slate· . menls. Use all chem1carsonly as direc ted. DI BR OM isa registered [(ademarkofChevron Chem icalCo.lornaled insecticide Copyright .:: 1991 Val"!nl U SA Corporat ion. All rights reserved. VALENT® -~ ~ Editor: Dr. Charlie Morris Florida Medical Entomology Laboratory IFAS-University of Florida 200 9th Street, SE Vera Beach, FL 32962 4071778-7200 FAX 4071778-7205 Assistant Editors: John Gamble, Daytona Beach , Florida James Mc Nelly, Cape May Court House, Ne w Jersey Photo Editor: Alan Curtis, Ve t o Beach. Florida Graphics Editor: Bonnie K. PaHok, Vera Beach. FL EDITORIAL BOARD: Kellie Etherson. Gainesville, FL Tho mas Flool'e. Panama Cit y. FL Dr. Carlisle Rathbuw , Panama Cit y, FL Jim Robinson. Odessa , FL Neil Wilkinson. Fort Myers. FL Pete Pederson. Altoona. FL Dr. Da vid Dame. Gainesville. FL Dr. Lewis Nielsen, Salt Lake City. UT Dr. Charles Apperson, Raleigh, NC Sally Wagner, Saginaw, MI Dr. Edward Wa lker, East Lans ing, MI William Jany, Lanas ka, PA Kern Walcher. Valdos ta, GA Dr. Bruce Eldridge, Davis C A William Zawicki, Freehold. NJ Dr. Lai S. Mian, Highland , CA Dr. James Cilek, Garden City, KS FLORIDA MOSQUITO CONTROL ASSOCIATION P. O. Box 11867 Jacksonville, FL 32211 9041743-4482 FAX: 9041743-6879 1990-91 Board of Directors: PRESIDENT: George Wichterman. Ft. Mye", FL PRESIDENT-ELECT: Dr. Richard Baker, Vero Beach, FL VICE PRESIDENT: Robert Ward, Punta Gorda, FL SECRETARY-TREASURER: Elisabeth Beck, Jacksonville, FL IMMEDIATE PAST-PRESIDENT: Oscar T. Fuilz, Savannah, GA N.W. REGIONAL DIRECTOR: James Clauson, Santa Rosa Beach. FL N.E. REGIONAL DIRECTOR: Richard Smith, Jacksonville, FL S.W. REGIONAL DIRECTOR: Dr. Frank Van Essen, Naples, FL S.E. REGIONAL DIRECTOR: Lester Scherer, Stuart, FL AMERICAN MOSQUITO CONTROL ASSOCIATION 707 East Prien Lake Road P. O. Box 5416 Lake Charles, LA 70606-5416 3181474-2723 FAX: 3181478-9434 1990-91 Board of Directors: PRESIDENT: Cyrus R. Le"er, Salibury, MD PRESIDENT ELECT: Dr. John A. Mulrennan, Jr., Jacksonville, FL VICE PRESIDENT: Dr. Chester G. Moore, fort Collins, CO PRESIDENT 1991: Matthew M. Yates, Baton Rouge, LA PRESIDENT 1990: Dr. Robert D. Sjogren, SI. Paul, MN TREASURER: John S. Billodeaux, Jennings, LA EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR: Mark Vinsand, Lake Charles, LA REGIONAL DIRECTORS: Canada: Ke ith Evans, Edmonton, AL North Atlantic: Thomas Ca ndelelti, Bar negat. NJ Mid-Atlant ic: Dr . Bruc e Harrison, Washington, DC South Atlantic : Martin G. Hyatt , Cha rleston Hgls., SC North Central: Sally Wagn er, Saginaw. MI South Central : Dr. Dan Sprenger. Houston, TX West Cent ral: Sammie Lee Dickson, Salt Lake City. UT North Pacific: Peter DeChant , Portland, OR South Pacific: B. Fred Beams, Sana Ana, CA Latin Am erica-Caribbean: Dr. Marco F. Suarez. San Juan, PR Indus try Director: William Zawicki, freehold , NJ r. of the American Mosquito Control Association P by the Florida Mosquito Control Association Volume 3, Number 2 Summer 1992 CONTENTS Source Reduction: "Mosquito Control for Stormwater Managers" . , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , .... , 5 by John C. Gamble It seems to many of us that civil engineers are on the mosquito's side when it comes to building storm water management facilities , They build ideal water-retaining ponds with shallow slopes that flood and dry up with the regularity that ideally matches flood water mosquito biology requirements. The best way to get engineers to help rather than hinder is to give them something mathematical. Don't try to explain the biology of mosquitoes, just tell them what should and should not be done to prevent mosquito breeding. Here is one set of recommendations used to assist in this engineering train ing process. Fly Wheels: "The Minnesota 'Twin' " ... ,.".,.,.,. , .,.,",.,., .. , ...... , ..... . . , ... 8 by Jim Robinson and Joe Ruff They're back! After missing for a couple of issues, Jim and Joe are back with another machine review. This time it's Conner Engineering's BISON ULV generator, and that ain't no bU._.never mind , Lines of Flight: "Helicopter: Lease or Purchase?" . , ., ... ,., .. , ., ..................... 13 by Richard D. Huggins The first article in this new column is by its editor, a pilot and mosquito inspector. This often asked question is here answered in different ways by three different New Jersey mosquito control programs. Perhaps their experiences will help you decide. Biosynopsis: "The Eastern Treehole Mosquito, Aedes triseriatus" .. , .... , . , , . , . , . , .. , . 17 by Dr. Ned Walker With the recent invasion and spread of Aedes albopictus and its replacement of Aedes aegypti in some parts, container-breeding mosquitoes are a hot topic these days. Let's not forget our native container mosquitoes that can cause problems. In the easter U.S., that means Aedes triseriatus. Feature: "Mythical Mosquito Control" , , , , , , , , ... , . , . , ... , . , , . , . , . , .... , . , .. . . , . , . , . ,18 by Lee Mitchell Anyone in mosquito work, be they researcher, teacher, insp.ector, director, secretary or custodian are asked their opinions and recommendations about the myriad of non chemical miracle solutions to mosquito control. Here is an article you may want to give such folks to help persuade them of the uselessness of some approaches. Program Profiles: "FAMU's Mulrennan Lab" ,.,., .................... ,., .... ,."".,21 by Thomas G. Floore "Chip Chat" editor, Tom Floore, steps out of this computer jockey saddle to tell us about the history and recent changes at the John A. MulreIU1an, Sr. Researc Laboratory, his home base. The Florida Mosquito Control Association has not tested any of the products advertised or referred to in this publication, nor has it verified any of the statements made in any of the advertisements or articles, The Association does not warrant, expressly or implied, the fitness of any product, advertised or the suitability of any advice or statements contained herein. 1992 Florida Mosquito Control Association: All rights reserved . Reproduction in whole or part for educatio'nal purposes is permitted, without permission, with proper citation. WING BEATS: Published quarterly as the official publication of the Florida Mosquito Control Associa tion and the American Mosquito Control Association. This publication is intended to keep all interested parties informed on matters as they relate to mosquito control, particularly in the United States. EDITORIAL: Address all correspondence regarding technical editorial matters to Dr. Charlie Mor ris, Editor, "Wing Beats" magazine, Florida Medical Entomology Laboratory, IFAS-University of Florida, 200 9th St. SE, Vero Beach, FL 32962; telephone: 407/778-7200; FAX: 407/778-7205, ADVERTISEMENTS: Address all correspondence regarding ad vertisements to Mrs. Debra Tarver, Outdoor Tech" Inc" 1499 Morning Dove Road, Tallahassee, FL, 904/668-2352. ABOUT THE COVER: East Volusia County Mosquito Control District's (Daytona Beach, Florida) McDon nell Douglass SOOE helicopter larviciding over salt grass (Distichilis spica to). Photo by John Gamble with pilot assistance by Richard Mann (056) and Harold Cobb (lOB). re. There is a group oflarvicides that combine all the qualities you're looking for today. It's the ALTOSID@full line of mosquito control products. Biorational ALTOSID larvicides give you consistent performance without harming non-target organisms. And because our larvicides exploit the mosquito's own biology, resistance has never been encountered. With a range of formulations, our larvicides go where you need them, while giving impressive residual activity and controlling a vast number of mosquito species. And considering that ALTOSID larvicides save you time, labor and equip ment costs, this is one form of control that fits easily into your budget. All of which means that now you can fight mosquitoes with the full force of nature. For more informo tion, coIl1-800-2A8-7763 ©1992 leecon. Vector Management Division is a divi~ion of Zoecon Corporation, a Sandoz Company, 12200 Denton Drive, Dallas, Texas 7523A. AlTOSID is a trademark of Sondoz Ud. 41 zoeeon. Always read the label before using the product. John C. Gamble Mosquito Control for Stormwater Managers , Very often the primary breeding sites·of mosquitoes are the result ' of man's activities .intentional and unintentionaLPre:venlionof , . mosquitilbreeding sites, where possible,.is still the best and most desirable abatement practice. Often, la~d developers. and 'oilier . public agencies, 'particuhu:y 'those iltvolvediil ·land moditicati~n . such as highway departments, create mosquito breeding sites when ·they' '(:onstruct mads .or stormwaler handling -sysieins. "This happens because'the engineerS a~e Concerned with remov~ ing .waterfrom the road orparking lot and dOil't :thinkabout ·creating mosquito breeding si~s. No one trained them to consider . suclt<-things.1tbecomes the responsibility of mosqUito -con.trol .to . educate the~ enghieeISabout thebiologicalaspects of theirdesigns aitd\how_it affects the .potential'Ior inosq'l!ito breed.ng~.·. , .: ' , . E.st VoIusiaMosquito Control District, DaYtona Beach,Florida, . has,developed a system .t hataUows them input into the planning and designphCises of manydevelopmenfprojeets. Part of'that. -system-is the following document used to inform and assist these engineers hl designing, reviewing and constructing projects that ·will not add to the mosquito problem. (Editor) ' . A poorly des ign ed roadside ditch for mosquito prevention. The ditch ha s a sod block put there intentiona1Jy by the water managem ent district. This site breed Culex, Photo by Bob Purce1J Best Management Practices For Mosquito Control In Stormwater Management Facilities The surface storage of stormwater required by state and local regulations, has created mosquito larval habitats. Our goal is to eliminate larval mos quito production from stormwater management facilities. This requires a basic understanding of mosquitoes' life cycles and habitats. The immature stages of mosquitoes (eggs, four instars of larvae, and pupae) utilize per manently or intermittently wet habitats. The most pestiferous mos quitoes lay eggs on damp ground that periodically floods. These eggs may survive for years between floodings. The primary disease vectoring mos quitoes lay eggs on the water's surface. Some mosquitoes can develop from Continued on page 6 A correctly mointoined wet retention pond, The water spray prevents mosquito breeding and the thin border of vegetotion on 0 steep sided pond is not enough to harbor mosquitoes that fish cannot reach, Photo by George O'Meora WING BEATS, SUMMER 1992 5 Continued from page 5 eggs to adults in as few as six (6) days. Top minnows are the most effective predator of immature mosquitoes in permanent or semipermanent water bodies free of vegetation. The use of the above information can result in proper design, construction, and maintenance of stormwater manage ment facilities that are mosquito free. Three elements are important to assure that a stormwater management facili ty does not produce mosquitoes: 1) Design of the proper facility for the site based on soils and other site constraints 2) Proper construction and certifica tion by the designer 3) Maintenance of the system has to be guaranteed should be graded to avoid isolated pockets of standing water. A maintenance easement of at least fif teen (15) feet should surround the facility above the design high water line. Although wetland plantings are typically required, they may create a mosquito problem. The following plants are recommended (Eric Cotsen moyer, Lake County Florida Mosquito Control), for the conditions listed: Occasionally Wet • Sagittaria latifolia - Common Ar rowhead, Duck Potato • Juncus effusus - Soft Rush • Pontederia lancifolia • Juncus roemerianus - Needle Rush • Juncus dichotomus These three elements, when done together, can achieve the goal of no mosquito production from these facilities. DESIGN The three basic types of design are wet, dry, and intermittent system. The designs should be based on site characteristics and sound engineering principles. The Soil Technician at the Volusia County Agriculture Center is available for free consultation on soils and water tables. The Soil Survey of Volusia County provides good, but less detailed information that should be field validated. The design selection· should be based on soils, seasonal high water table, and predevelopme;nt drainage characteristics. Slopes should allow ease of maintenance and small children to extricate themselves. Maintenance plans should be careful ly reviewed to prevent additional problems. Wet system retention or detention facilities are usually used in a high water table situation. The permanent water table can maintain top minnows, provided there is eighteen (18) inches of water at the driest time. The bottom 6 SUMMER 1992, WING BEATS Predominately Wet • Sagittaria lancifolia • Pontederia cordata • Stirpus californicus - Giant Bulrush • Scirpus robustus - Salt-Marsh Bulrush low water table soils. The pipe should be placed at least one (1) foot above the seasonal high water table. The inlet sumps may produce a few mosquitoes, but the maintenance value outweighs this easily treated problem. These systems can be maintained regularly and easily by jetting the pipe with a Vac-type truck unit. The least desirable system is an in termittently wet/dry system. It is used at a site where overriding design criteria exist such as tree preservation in a high water table soil. These undesirable systems can be significant ly improved by utilizing minnow reser voirs, constructed of FDOT type "C" catch basin (a minimum depth of two (2) feet), with a solid bottom and grated top. The top of the catch basin is in stalled at ground level. The catch basin becomes a protected refuge for min nows when the retention facility is dry. Each individual depression within the retention area should require one reservoir. Maintenance of these reser voirs can be done by hand or a jet/pump mechanical system. A small permanent water pond in one part of the facility could perform a similar function. Retrofitting existing facilities that function as intermittent wet/dry systems, contn;lry to the original design, would benefit from this revis ed design. CONSTRUCTION • Juncus effusus - Soft Rush Dry systems (retention areas or swales) are suited for low water table, permeable soils. These areas should be designed to be dry within three (3) days based on a twenty-five (25) year storm event (24 hour duration). A good rule of thumb is to place the bottom one (1) foot above the seasonal high water table. Where this minimum freeboard can not be achieved by raising the retention area, a wet system should be used. We do not recommend the use of underdrains to control water eleva tions because of their expense, suscep tibility to failure, and frequency of maintenance. As an alternative to sur face storage, we have regularly approv ed underground exfiltration systems in Inlets and outlets should be con structed with erosion protection devices. Construction should be per formed with hydraulic excavators or similar equipment to avoid depres sions. A professional engineer should certify that the facilities have been con structed according to the proposed plans. MAINTENANCE An agreement in the stormwater management permit should specifical ly identify the responsible party for maintenance. A maintenance sched ule, and a procedure to insure that maintenance is carried out are also imContinued on page 7 Continued from page 6 portant. Mandated maintenance is an important element in local stormwater regulations. Side slopes should be kept free of weeds. Grass should be proper ly managed to prevent erosion. Weed management, chemical and/or physical removal, should be used in permanent water facilities. Requests to stock top minnows in wet facilities can be made to the Mosquito Control District. Tire tracks in roadside swales and other ac tivities that cause ruts and depressions in dry facilities should be avoided. This is a guide to allow professionals involved in stormwater management to prevent a problem with some simple solutions. It is possible to solve existing problems using the same information. It is our hope that this document will convince people to become a part of the solution, not part of the problem. Proper surface storage of stormwater to eliminate mosquito production is one of the most inexpensive, and en vironmentally sensitive approaches to mosquito control available today. John Gamble is the Assistant Director of the East Volusia . Mosquito Control District. , THe main office of the District is in Daytona Beach. John is located at 600 South Street, New Smyrna Beach, FL 32168-5864; 904/428-2871; FAX: 9041423-3857. Arosu rf'" MSF, a biodegradable spray, is the wise environ mental choice to control mosquitoes. It slightly changes the suriace characteristics of water. Just enough to keep mosquito larvae and pupae from firmly attaching. The water wets their breathing structures-and they drown. Arosuri MSF is the only registered, non-petroleum based product for killing mosquito larvae and pupae-effectively controlling these stages in more than 25 species. It's invisible on the water (No oil sheen, or Odor.) And it has little or no effect on other animal life or plants. You can even spray it on potable-water sources l With recommended dosages, Arosuri MSF costs less to use than petroleum oils. It's also cost-competitive with bacterial-control agents and growth regulators. To learn how it can work for you, write or call: MSSI (Midwest Spraying & Supply) 505 Brimhall Ave, PO Box 519, Long Lake, MN 55356 Telephone (612) 472-6499 Fax (612) 473-5302 Hotline (800) 448-8525 MSS/ is the e.<clusive u.s. dlS/fibulor lor Arosuri MSF. produced by Sherex Chemical Company. Inc ~~ MOSQUITO'" CONTROL CHEMICALS EQUIPMENT SERVICE Mosquito Golf Morris & Pattok SUPPLIES TRAINING NORTHEAST VECTOR MANAGEMENT, INC. P.O. BOX 754 FREEHOLD. NJ 07728 1-800-331-7240 FAX 908-431-3451 WING BEATS, SUMMER 1992 7 Fly Wheels The Minnesota "Twin" Robinson & Ruff A couple of Fly Wheels columns back we noted the symbiotic relation ship of Minnesotans and mosquito control, well here is one more case of it. The subject of this issue's evaluation is Conner Engineering's BISON from Rogers, Minnesota. Larry Conner might be a new name to many of you but his association with mosquito adulticiding equipment has well developed roots. Conner was in troduced to our industry while racing pint sized screamers with our admired and respected friend Bill Tenney, of London Fog fame. It's easily apparent that modifying engines is in this man's blood, while making them perform seems to be his lifelong passion. If the character of the man at the helm is any indication of the direction of this company, we eagerly await to see what new products they will unleash at our doorstep. In a time when so many machines are becoming more look-alike every day, the BISON is a refreshing stab at breaking with tradition. Just when we thought we had seen everything, here comes a two-lunger, one-banger. Say, how's that again? Well, the critter has two cylinders all right, but there is only one spark plug pok ing it's nose from under the shroud. It seems Mr. Conner has taken Briggs & Stratton's 18 horse twin cylinder engine and entrusted half of it with performing compressor duty. The stock cylinder head has been replaced with a nifty casting which segregates the original valves without modifying their operation. The intake manifold is plugged at this port, but is otherwise unmodified. The new head is fitted with a combination of reed in take and disc exhaust valves to direct the air pumping chores. An aftercooler is neatly tucked into the engine's cool8 SUMMER 1992, WING BEATS ing shroud to remove some of the heat of compression. With the opposing cylinder com pressing air, the engine does not ex hibit vibration levels that you might associate with single cylinder engines. The reciprocating mass has not been altered, so there should be no imbal High pressure air nozzle. Photo by Jim Robinson ance imposed on the crankshaft. This is well proven technology that has serv ed yeoman duty for years in the con struction industry. This is our first opportunity to evaluate a high pressure air atomizer for the Fly Wheels column. High pressure systems have been around in pesticide application equipment for many years, with the most common ex ample being the London Aire XKPD. The nozzle functions similar to an industrial coating system where the li quid is injected (or siphoned) into the center of a high pressure air blast. The Bison's nozzle assembly is centered in a cast aluminum cone. The assembly resembles a jet eductor, that apparent ly is designed to increase the mass of air entrained with the spray plume. There is a pop off valve located above the cylinder head that is set at 125 PSI in case any dirt might get into the noz zle's air passages. There is also an 80 PSI pressure safety switch in this plumbing that completes 'the metering pump/spray solenoid circuit. This switch prevents pesticide being pumped into a nozzle without enough air pressure to assure proper atomization. A 3-way electric solenoid valve is located directly at the rear of the fluid connection to the nozzle. When the spray switch is turned on, the valve opens the passage permitting the pesticide to flow straight through to the nozzle. When the switch is 'off' air is vented into the fluid portion of the noz zle and any material remaining is aspirated through the nozzle. This ef fectively prevents "afterspray" that many view as a problem area. This would not be functional with the speed correlated system when the vehicle merely stops but the spray is not turn ed off. The nozzle assembly is equipped with the necessary locking swivels to permit the Spray to be directed every way imaginable, including down into the back of the truck. There are safety retainers to prevent the nozzle blowing off if any of this articulation is attemp ted under pressure. The BISON is quite compact con sidering the nice sized tanks supplied. The placement of the various com ponents, engine/compressor, metering equipment and tanks, is rather conven tional except the metering equipment sits straddling the plastic gasoline tank. A similar piece of equipment, distributed west of the Mississippi as the HP910, places the metering pump down on the frame. The polyethylene insecticide tank is equipped with a lockable cap, minus the lock. Because it's just a push fit to Continued on page 10 . FLY ~WHEEI.s SPEC SHE.E T _ CONNER ENGINEERING - BISON COLD AEROSOL GENERATOR ULV ~. ¥ANUFACTU~E~ j Conner Engineering, Inc. 22401 Industrial Blvd. Bldg. C Rogers, MN 55374 I ENGINE 1 Manufacturer... Briggs & Stratton Model... 422437 (modified 18 Twin) Type... Alum block, iron sleeve, single cyl., electric start Valvetrain... L-head, 2-valve/cyl Displacement... 21.17 cu. in.l347 cc Bore x stroke... 3.44 in.l2.28 in. Horsepower... 18 bhp @ 3600 rpm Torque... N.A. ft @ 2600 rpm Lubrication... pressure w/filter I .C H1SSISI Layout... drive on same crankshaft Frame... steel "2" rails Mounts... engine/compressor mounted solid to frame 1 -DIME~SIONSI Length... 40.25" Width... 30.75" Height (nozzle @ 45deg) ... 31" Weight (dry) ... 275 lbs.(mfr)* [PRICE 1 Base Price ... $2,995 Price as Tested ... $3,895 w/LPG-18 Flow Control r _BLOWERiCOMPRESSOR Manufacturer... Briggs & Stratton/ Conner Engineering Type... The opposing cylinder of B&S 18 H.P. twin, fitted with alum head, reed/disc valves & aftercooler Displacement... 21.17 cu. in.lrev. Output (@ 3000 RPM) ... 17 CFM (mfr)* Max Speed... 3600 RPM Max Pressure... 100 PSI Filter... SMI (pleated permanent element) 1 Fuel capacity... 5.8 gal/22 liter Engine oil... 3 pints/l.42 liter Insecticide tank... 15 gal/56.8 liter 1 Flow controls ... ELF (speed coor dinated), LPQ-18 pump fixed flow, venturi/ orifice fixed flaw, spray hour meter Remote Controls - start, choke, flush, power RPM 2400 2600 2800 3000 Truck Cab 69 dBA 69 dBA 71 dBA ' 72 dBA Sidewalk 77 dBA 79 dBA 80 dBA 83 dBA FLUID CAPACITIES 1 REMOTE CONTROL 1 Switches... Spray off/on Indicator light... Spray on Flush, Output (spraying), Fault 1 _OPTIONS ·1 INSTRUMENTATION 1 Pressure... gauge @ engine Flow Rate ... scale on pump base Safety cut-off... air pressure switch (80 PSI) DROPLET SPECTRUM 1 (Cythion @760-780F by Teflon slide wave @ 15 feet) Flow Rate (oz/ml) MMD (avg/3) Largest Droplet Pressure (Standard Gauge) 90.0 3.0/88.7 13.79 33 mu 99.5 (max) 3.0/88.7 13.42 33 mu 90.0 4.3/127.1 16.37 47 mu 99.5 4.3/127.1 14.40 42 mu 53 mu 90.0 6.45/190.7 19.03 99.5 6.45/190.7 18.88 64 mu (Orchex 796 @ 800F by Teflon slide wave @ 15 feet) 13.42 26 mu 99.5 4.3/127.1 14.18 31 mu 99.5 8.6/254.3 10.0/295.7 16.32 38 mu 99.5 1-- ~UE{CO~StJMPtION 2400 2600 2800 3000 RPM ... RPM ... RPM ... RPM ... 0.63 0.74 0.82 0.89 GPH GPH GPH GPH I· FLOW CONTROL ACCURACY (through nozzle @ 90 PSI) Setting Range (scale) (mllmin) 5% 21-21 10% 40-41 25% 118-119 50% 212-216 90 95 97 99 Gauge PSI PSI PSI PSI (max) Standard· 89.5 PSI 95.0 PSI 97.4 PSI 99.5 PSI Average (ml/min) 21 41 119 215 Speed 2399 2605 2808 3005 SUMMER 1992, WING BEATS 9 Continued from page 8 close, it should at least be pinned to keep it closed. Most of the normally serviced com ponents are easily accessible. The oil filter is probably the most difficult item to reach, but we have seen much worse. N one of the controls are confusing ex cept our example had no labeling on the engine kill switch. The unique engine conversion may also permit easier local servicing for major pro blems. Anyone familiar with the B&S twin can easily work on the com pressor portion of the combination as well. Our "bovine" was equipped with the PDQ 18 Flow Control which translates into a constant flow system using the Fluid Metering Inc. rotary piston pump driven by an electric motor. The motor is energized through a voltage regulator set at 8 volts. This keeps the motor in the 1600 - 1700 RPM range. Better regulation of pesticide flow over a wider range can be realized with a slower pump speed. Our experience substantiates this, but also indicates the necessity of matching the pump size to anticipated flows. FMI pumps have a critical linear piston speed at which point they will induce cavitation and thus create non-linear flows. The regulator on the engine's alter nator did an excellent job during the tests. In fact, once the unit was beyond start-up, the voltage varied less than 0.1 of a volt. If the unit were connected to the vehicle battery, it would be sub jected to variations caused by lights, radios, etc. The pump head supplied was a 1-CSY (stainless steel case with a ceramic piston turning in a carbon liner). This unit has a 1/4' diameter piston that should cover most of the normal flow requirements. A pulse dampener, in the form of an inverted filter, was fitted to the discharge side of the pump. The suction side was equipped with a large, fine mesh filter that was easily serviced. Fuel consumption at 2600 RPM and an indicated 95 PSI was a modest 0.74 gal.lhour. This pressure should safely atomize labeled rate applications of 10 SUMMER 1992, WING BEATS Cylinder head for the compressor side of the Bison. Photo by Jim Robinson malathion at 10 MPH. With 5.8 gallons of usable fuel supply, you would even have a little change left from a hard 8 hour shift. This is a very quiet sprayer. At 2600 RPM and in the truck cab (with the windows up), the operator is only ex posed to 69 dBA of noise. A pedestrian on the sidewalk would sense a passing 79 dBA. Please recall that decibels are measured on a logarithmic scale so this is a big jump. Even though the unit is bolted solid to the frame there was little resonance transmitted into our pickup's cab. Compared to the drone of the rotary lobed equipment, piston compressors are in a different league. The standard in-cab remote control is very basic. An on/off button and a green light to tell you that the pump should be running. There is a more ad vanced remote that's available as an option that includes switches for start/stop, choke and power on/off. The newest subject had us scratching our exposed heads (all right, Joe still has most of his hair left to launder) over terminology to describe it's in tended market. In the past, we noted that units being evaluated were heavy duty, implying that this somehow denoted size as well as beefy construction. In this case, the BISON is the smallest vehicle mounted sprayer in Conner's lineup, but we would be remiss if we did not note it's construc tion as heavy duty. That is also true for this range of the machines produced by the other ULV equipment manufac turers. This size, or capacity, range is probably the fa~test growing segment of sprayers .to be utilized in this country. For comparison purposes, horse power is crudely related to the atom ization capabilities of pneumatic machines currently on the market. The BISON is really a 9 horse power machine masquerading in an 18 horse's clothing. This is not inten tional, as the Conner lineup includes two machines larger than this one. But the 18 HP decals are still there. The machine proved capable of meeting the Cythion label criteria by atomizing the high flow 10 MPH rate of 4.3 fl. oz.lmin. It is also capable of atomizing much higher flow rates of common light mineral oil diluents commonly used with pyrethroids. In those cases where a larger particle is advantageous, the engine may be throt tled down. Higher flows of malathion should be Continued on page 11 Continued from page 10 off limits to this unit, however there should be a safety margin for inadver tent trips over 10 MPH if the sprayer is equipped with speed correlated metering. Lower dosages or materials diluted in light mineral oil may extend the machine's speed envelope much higher. This distinction clearly points out the need for programs to analyze their needs before choosing a particular spraying system. The Droplet Spec trum table on the specifications page reveals a great deal about a sprayer's capabilities. It's a fact of life, higher speeds and viscous materials require plenty of horse power to keep the MMD down. Conner Engineering has experienc ed a few growing pains with their new line of application equipment, but that's to be expected. They are taking a fresh look at some established techni ques and seem to be paying attention to details. The BISON (or HP910) is a competent, quiet, able performer that should fare well in the newly popular mid-powered range of mosquito ULV adulticiders. Much to the chagrin of our local fans, the Minnesota Twins are the cur rent reigning world champs. While the BISON may show some ancestral resemblance, it is certainly no one's "twin: ' Jim Robinson is Director of the Pasco County Mosquito Control District, Odessa, Florida, and a Co-director of the WHO Collaborating Center for Testing and Evaluation of Pesticide Ap plication Equipment. . loe Ruff is a Biological Scientist with' Florida A&M University's John A. Mulren nan Sr. Research Lab, Panama City. He has worked on mosquito control equip ment development and calibration with mosquito control districts for over 20 years. DYNA·FOG® World Leader In Aerosol Generators For Over 30 Years OVER 20 MODELS-with simplicity of design , ease of oper ation and innovative technology to meet every application need-regardless of size. A DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM THAT COVERS THE GLOBE where research , engineering , development and distribution combine to meet the changing needs of the industry economically and efficiently. YOU GET MORE THAN SUPERIOR PERFORMANCE CHEMICAL APPLICATORS-you get DYNA-FOG . The name you identify with quality, service, reliability and support. TYPHOON ULV 11-HP MINI-PRO ULV 5-HP . MAXI-PRO ULV 18-HP For the location of your nearest DYNA-FOG Distributor call (317) 896-2561 today. 17335 U.S. Hwy. 31 North Westfield, IN 46074 U.S.A. Phone: (317) 896-2561 FAX: 317-896-3788 Telex: 810 260 3990 WING BEATS, SUMMER 1992 11 Richard D. Huggins I Helicopter: Lease or Purchase? Fixed wing aircraft have been an in tegral part of New Jersey mosquito control since World War II. The stan dard operating procedure is to lease or contract with a company to do aerial applications as needed. When only fix ed wing aircraft were available, owner ship was not economically practical for most mosquito control agencies. Fixed wings must be operated from an airport, an expensive operation to in itiate and maintain. Besides high cost, fixed wing aircraft have limited use for mosquito control. The high cost of operation coupled with limited use, make purchase of fixed wing aircraft unfeasible for many programs. In the early 1960s, the helicopter became an alternative to fixed wing aircraft for larval and adult control of mosquitoes in New Jersey. As the helicopter began to be used on a regular basis, agencies recognized the broader spectrum of uses that this uni que piece of equipment could provide. Not only can it be used for pesticide applications, it can be used to deliver workers and equipment to areas previously inaccessible for surveillance or water management projects. Another advantage rotorcraft has over fixed wing aircraft is that a helicopter need not be operated from an airport. Since a runway is not required for operations, the helicopter can be bas ed wherever it is deemed appropriate. The increased usability of rotorcraft raised the question: When does pur chase become more economical than leasing? This article will examine how three New Jersey county mosquito con trol programs, Cape May, Atlantic, and Ocean, addressed this question. CAPE MAY COUNTY Cape May County covers 277 square miles of which nearly 36 percent are coastal marsh; 50,000 acres of salt marsh and 10,000 acres of fresh water marsh. The black salt marsh mosquito, Aedes sollicitans, is the primary target mosquito species. Cape May County Mosquito Extermination Commission began their helicopter program in 1974 with a leased Bell Model 47 G4A. The Commission recognized the speed and efficiency that a helicopter would pro vide in their program for surveillance and application. Cape May was ex tremely satisfied with the helicopter's performance during the eight years they leased but became dissatisfied with the cost of leasing. Between 1974 and 1980, the average cost per hour of the lease increased on an average of 7.2 percent a year. Bet ween 1980 and 1982, the cost situation worsened - the increase averaged 75 percent per hour of operation. The in , Continued on page 14 1 .I Ocean County Mosquito Extermination Commission personnel doing laral inspection with a Jet Ranger in a New Jersey salt marsh. WING BEATS, SUMMER 1992 13 Continued from page 13 creased cost of leasing meant the Com mission had to reduce the helicopter's role in surveillance and application drastically. Cape May could no longer afford to pay for the hours needed for what it now deemed essential. In 1982 the Commission looked into the feasibility of aircraft ownership as an alternative. The next year, after an ex tensive investigation, they purchased two Hiller UH 12E piston engine helicopters. The next five years showed a remarkable increase in the efficiency and economy that could be directly associated with ownership. With no time constraints that a lease usually imposes, the amount of time available for surveillance rose by 25 percent, resulting in additional breeding areas being located, according to Commis sion Entomologist James McNelly. Cape May could now also include adulticiding in their aerial program. All previous aerial adult applications were done by the New Jersey State Airspray program on a request basis. Additional time also became available for aerial photography and surveillance of water management areas. The helicopter could now also be used for the transportation of men and equipment for repair of marsh equipment. Another benefit was hav ing a full time pilot that would be familiar with Cape May County and the mosquito control program. The cost per hour for the first five years of ownership was 21 percent higher than the final five years of leas ing. This 4.2 percent average increas ed cost per hour for each year of ownership is far smaller than the predicted rise of leasing costs over the same period and the actual average in crease for the last five years of leasing. Judy Hansen, Superintendent of Cape May County Mosquito Exter mination Commission, feels that any organization that uses a helicopter more than 250 hours per year and needs the availability of a ship for surveillance and application to large inaccessible breeding areas, should look into ownership. "A mosquito com 14 SUMMER 1992, WING BEATS mission becomes more responsive to public needs and is 100% more effec tive.", she says. ATLANTIC COUNTY Atlantic County has approximately 33,000 acres of salt marsh that breeds mosquitoes. Prior to 1982, aerial surveillance was not part of the Atlan tic County Mosquito Unit's operation. Salt marsh inspection data was col lected by field personnel by land or boat. Occasionally, a neighboring county would provide limited aerial surveillance information if they found time in their own inspection schedule. In 1982 the Unit began leasing a helicopter for 50 hours per season. The helicopter was used exclusively for lar val mosquito surveillance. If aeriallar viciding was necessary, it was provid ed by the state airspray program's fix ed wing. Last year, Atlantic County began to use a leased helicopter for larviciding in smaller areas that the state's fixed wing aircraft could not cover. The con- tract called for 50 hours of surveillance at $380.00 per hour, and 85 hours of application at $800.00 per hour. The helicopter is used to treat 5,000 acres annually, with the state aircraft lar viciding the remaining acres. As helicopter use increased, Atlan tic County became aware of some limitations to leasing. One problem is that since the helicopter is not based in Atlantic County, the contract necessitates that a 24-hour prior notice be given to the leasing company when it is needed for mosquito control. Another problem is that there is a possibility that the weather at the helicopter's base of operation may pre vent them from flying even when the weather is fine in Atlantic County. This can limit the effectiveness of con trol efforts since timing of application is often a critical element. Another disadvantage of leasing for Atlantic County is the potential for a new vendor each year, or possibly hav ing no vendor interested in bidding on the limited number of hours stated in Continued on page 15 London Aire Mode118-20 ULV Aerosol Generator A totally reengineered, state of the art generator, the Model 18-20 makes mosquito control more efficient and conVenient than ever before. It has an 18 Hp engine des igned for maximum o utput, even at vehicle speeds of 20 miles per hour. f""" • Q uieter Operation • Durable Engine • Remote Cab Control • Increased Nozzle Height LONCON FOG~ INCORPORATEO\!!JI MANUFACTURERS OF IN SECT CONTROL EQU IPMENT 505 Bllmhall Ave • PO Bo,~ <106 • Long Lake. MlnneSOla 55356 PHONE (GI2) 473·5366 FAX (G 121 47) 5302 ORDER HOTLINE (BOO) 448-8525 Continued from page 14 OCEAN COUNTY the bid solicitation. Whenever there is a new vendor, time is lost familiariz ing the pilots with Atlantic County and the mosquito control program. Atlan tic County has had five vendors in the last eight years. Even with these disadvantages, Atlantic County feels that leasing a helicopter is still cost effective for their program. The Unit is a department of the county parks system and its budget is relatively small. According to the unit's director, Bill Reinert, the pur chase and operation of a helicopter is not economically feasible at this time since most of the acreage can still be treated by the state aircraft. Because of reduced funding of the state airspray program, counties using their services for larviciding must pay for the pesticide used. In the future, counties may have to pay the full cost of state services. As Atlantic County bears more and more of the costs of aerial applications, aircraft purchase may become a viable option. Prior to 1969, Ocean County Mos quito Extermination Commission's aerial applications were provided by the state program's fixed wing aircraft. The Commission felt that although the state program did an excellent job, there were drawbacks. The main one was that trying to schedule an airspray was often difficult since the aircraft were also needed by other counties at the same time. In 1969 the Commis sion determined that a helicopter was needed for surveillance and larval con trol on their 27,000 acres of salt marsh. So in 1970, they leased a Bell 47 G3B1 helicopter from March through November for these purposes. The helicopter proved to be so valuable that in subsequent years the Commission opted to lease two Bell 47 G4A helicopters per season, and increased the hours leased from 300 to 600. The helicopters were kept at the Commis sion yard and fuel was provided by the Commission. All other operating and maintenance costs were borne by the contractor. The first years of leasing went by with few problems. The cost per hour of operation increased each year by an average of 5 percent which at that time wasn't considered enough of a rise to warrant investigating the purchase of aircraft. Shortcomings of the lease program eventually became apparent. The 600 hours of helicopter time budgeted each year was an estimate of the hours needed in an average year. The pro blem was that if Ocean County had a bad mosquito season they needed more than 600 hours and if they had a dry season the commission would have to pay for helicopter time it real ly did not need. It also became ap parent over the years that as the price per hour increased, the quality of the aircraft deteriorated. The helicopters were being used year-round for agricultural work and, since the Bell 47 was no longer in production, new equipment could not be supplied. Until 1981 the relatively low cost per hour still outweighed the disadvan tages, so Ocean County continued to ·lease. Between 1981 and 1983, the cost Continued on page 16 VECTEC INTRODUCES THE MOST ADVANCED MOSQUITO CONTROL TECHNOLOGIES ON THE MARKET: The ELF CONTROLLER An economical, independent linear flow control device developed for use with Fluid Metering Inc:s 12 volt positive displacement pumping systems. INEXPENSIVE, EFFICIENT and EASILY INSTALLED, the ELF CONTROLLER connects to both electronic and mechanical speedometers, It can use either the vehicle's or the ULV sprayer's 12 volt DC power, The technologically-advanced ELF CONTROLLER is made from state-of-the-art, solid-state components. It offers THREE OPERATIONAL MODES: Variable -linear chemical rates at speeds from 2 to 22 mph . Constant set chemical rate based on 10 mph output rate . Flush - maximum output rate for quick line cleaning, There's an OVER-SPEED AUDIBLE ALARM in variable mode . AUXILIARY OUTPUTS : (1) Speed pulse output from sending unit. (2) Over-speed indicator output (22 mph). (3) Fog mode indicator output. (4) Output to control3-way electric solenoid valve in flush mode. The ELF CONTROLLER makes the use of variable flow available to all mosquito control programs 'at an affordable price! The ELF SYSTEM: The ELF CONTROLLER is also available in a complete system . (1) Control module (2) Power module (3) Terminal block (4) FM QP pump (5) 3-way solenoid valve (6) 2 quart flush tank (7) Air pressure gauge. Veelec HC FIRST IN FLYING INSECT CONTROL CHEMICALS • TECHNOLOGY • EQUIPMENT 6984 VENTURE CIRCLE· ORLANDO, FLORIDA 32807· (407) 677-0350· (800) 367-1299 WING BEATS, SUMMER 1992 15 Continued from page 15 per hour skyrocketed by 139 percent. This, coupled with the deterioration of the aircraft provided, persuaded Ocean County to consider an aircraft purchase. After considerable research, they purchased two reconditioned Bell 206B JetRanger helicopters in 1984. This model was chosen for several reasons. The JetRanger was in produc tion and the safety and reliability of the turbine engine and the airframe was well documented. The JetRanger was also being used for liquid and granular applications elsewhere. Ownership gave the Commission total control over the maintenance and operation of the helicopters. The most important factor for selec ting the IetRanger was the relatively low operating costs compared to other helicopters in the same class. The in itial cost per hour rose by 15 percent with a subsequent annual increase of 8 percent. Ocean County is satisfied that the initial cost increase is justifiable because of the predicted stability of future cost per hour increases. With the purchase of the helicopters, the acreages treated each year rose from 32,000 to 62,000 acres, a dramatic 94 percent increase. Ocean County Mosquito Control Commission Superintendent, Tom Candeletti, feels that the increase in quality of the helicopters coupled with the extraor dinary increase in productivity justifies the decision to purchase. SUMMARY These three examples reveal an evolutionary process involved in deter mining whether to lease or purchase. After the decision is made that an aerial capability could enhance the mosquito control program, the agency wiIllease equipment first. It would be hard to justify the high initial expense of purchase when there is no data sup porting the request. The aerial capability then has to be proven an in valuable part of the program. Once this is recognized, the agency begins to see some of the limitations involved with leasing. Then comes the time when the cost of leasing limits the use of the air craft. Eventually, the high initial cost of aircraft purchase can be justified by increased efficiency and future cost stability. Cape May and Ocean counties reached the point where program ef fectiveness and economics dictated the need to purchase. Atlantic County can still depend on the state airspray pro gram. If the state program continues to transfer the fiscal responsibility to the counties, in the near future Atlan tic County and other programs may see purchase as a viable option. Richard D. Huggins · i~ .. a 1S-year veteran Seniot Iri spector and heIicoptef'lHiot for the Ocean County Mos, quito Exterminatiori Com mission, 784 West. B~Y , Avenue, Baregat, N~w Jersey 08005; 609/698-8271; 609/698-2351. Fax: ' ASPECIAL ANNOUNCEMENT FOR ALL MOSQUITO PROFESSIONALS ... VecTec is proud to announce it has received EPA registration for its new permethrin mosquito adulticide, PUNT 57 OS, as a ground ULV and barrier spray. PUNT 57 OS has the Qualities Professionals want: It is: A. A concentrated ULV oil soluble formulation . B. Less costly per acre than other permethrin ULV formulations; 30 to 50 percent. C. Effective against organophosphate resistant strains. D. Much less toxic to mammals than either Malathion or Dursban. E. Highly toxic to troublesome mosquitoes such as Ae. albopictus and Ae. taeniorhynchus. F. Non-irritant, non-corrosive and virtually odorless in use. G. A quick knockdown product; "no biting frenzy." For more details call VecTec's NATIONAL SERVICE NUMBER 1-800-367-1299. Veelee 'NC FIRST IN FLYING INSECT CONTROL EQUIPMENT· CHEMICALS • TECHNOLOGY 6984 VENTURE CIRCLE· ORLANDO, FLORIDA 32807· (407) 677-0350 16 WING BEATS, SUMMER 1992 Dr. Ned Walker's Biosynopsis of .. The Eastern Treehole Mosquito Aedes triseriatus . Importance Aedes triseriatus is not the mosquito that you slap in the evening, or the one that has Joe Public on the phone all summer long with complaint calls. It just isn't all that abundant in most places in its range. Aedes triseriatus never drew much attention until it was found to be the vector of La Crosse encephalitis virus. La Crosse encephalitis is primarily a problem of children in the upper Midwest and east. Symptoms can range from a mild flu-like illness to seizures and coma. Ohio leads the nation in number of cases, followed by Wisconsin, Min nesota, Illinois and Indiana. Outside this "LaCrosse encephalitis crescent," cases occur in Texas, North Carolina, Michigan , Missouri, Iowa , West Virginia and New York. . Geographic Distribution Aedes triseriatus occurs from Florida, north to Ontario and Quebec, and west to the Dakotas and Texas. From north to south, the species ex periences quite a range of temperatures and conditions, and it has successfully adapted to local requirements. Adult Description The tarsi and proboscis are uniform ly dark. Silvery scales cover the sides of the thorax and are the most diagnostic characteristic. The ab dominal segments are dark and unbanded. Larval Habitat Even though the accepted common name for "Tris" is the eastern treehole mosquito, it also breeds in tires, main ly in shaded locations. It can be found in a single water-filled tire behind the garage or in a tire dump with thousands of tires. In scrap tire yards, adults reach incredibly high numbers, as many as 60,000 females per acre in mid-summer. Aedes triseriatus has become an important urban mosquito because of its association with scrap tires. pile where they are produced. Associated Species In addition to the Asian tiger and yellow fever mosquitoes, Tris larvae oc cur with a variety of Culex and Anopheles mosquitoes. One mosquito, Toxorhynchites, which preys upon Tris larvae can be a major factor regulating the population dynamics of Tris in treeholes and tires. Oviposition One of the most interesting aspects of Tris' biology is its diapause and hibernation during the winter. Eggs are laid singly on the side of natural and man-made containers. In the north, Tris overwinters as eggs. Begin . ning in mid-August, eggs "sense" that daylight is getting shorter. The eggs then switch into diapause and will not hatch even if flooded. Diapause prevents eggs from hatching when lar vae will not have enough warm weather to complete their develop ment. The eggs hatch in the spring when temperatures rise and rains draw up water levels. In the south, both eggs and larvae overwinter. Larval Behavior The amount of food available in con tainers greatly influences the produc tion of This larvae. If plentiful, larvae survive crowded conditions and withs tand competition for food from other mosquitoes. In treeholes, food is deposited and mosquito waste pro ducts are flushed out with rainfall that flows over the trunk of the tree. In tires, the major food source is decomposing leaves. Flight and Migration The flight range of adults is rather short and often ranges only a few hun dred yards from the treehole or tire Aedes triseriotus feeding on 0 mou se, Mus musculus. Photo by: Leonord Mun stermonn Bloodfeeding Few mosquito species feed on rodents. These mammals are usually too jittery and quick to sit still for that. But Aedes triseriatus, even though it bites a wide variety of mammals, in cluding humans and sometimes birds, particularly likes chipmunks and squirrels. These woodland rodents are active during the day when Aedes triseriatus is seeking hosts in the woods. Chipmunks and squirrels can become infected with LaCrosse virus and can infect other mosquitoes that feed on them. This females can also pass the virus on through the eggs to the next generation thus providing an overwintering mechanism for the virus. Male Tris infected by the tran sovarial route can, in turn, infect females with the virus during mating, a kind of "mosquito venereal disease." , Dr. ' Walker is. an Assistant . , Professor ·ofEntomology at ', ' Michigan' State University, East Lansing·. ' " ,, WING BEATS, SUMMER 1992 17 Feature Lee Mitchell Mythical Mosquito Control Economics and science play impor tant roles in every mosquito control program. By virtue of common sense and public overview we utilize person nel, equipment and insecticides in an efficient manner to guide our pro grams. We wisely encourage citizen in put and participation in our communi ty activities. How then do we respond to requests and comments regarding mosquito control methods that have lit tle scientific support? Naturalists often claim that bats, pur ple martins and other insect-eating birds can adequately control mosquito populations. Homeowners purchase electrocuting insect traps and elec tronic insect repellers by the thousands. Industries advertise the in sect repelling qualities of all-purpose lotions such as Skin-So-Soft® and the hybrid Citrosa plant. Your response to such inquiries may cost you either public support or precious operating funds as you sink money into a losing proposition. mosquitoes biting people in the yards. Biologists are concerned about the high number of non-pest insects such as beetles and moths that are attracted and killed by bug zappers. Some of these insects are beneficial as natural biological controls on other insect pests and others are important in the food chain. Some people will operate ELECTROCUTORS The ultraviolet or black light elec trocutor traps, also known as Zappers®, Bug Blasters® and Big Wackers® are probably the most popular choice by homeowners for mosquito control. One industry official estimates that up to 1.75 million bug zappers are sold annually in this coun try at upwards of $100 each:These traps do attract and kill thousands of insects, but often, as Gord Surgeoner and Blair Helson showed in Canada 15 years ago and Roger Nasci confirmed in Indiana nearly a decade ago, mos quitoes comprise less than 5 percent of the catch. Of even greater impor tance was the finding that these devices did not reduce the number of 18 WING BEATS, SUMMER 1992 ' ; ' ~ :~-'" . - Bot tower on Sugarloaf Ky in South Florida . Photo by Doug Wassmer Nature, Man gang up to bring down bat tower by J. P. Faber, Staff Writer Precariously balanced on the muddy edge of the Hillsborough River just east of Tampa lie the ruins of a bizarre ex periment. Here, 57 years ago, Dr. Charles Campbell's 36-fool bat lower failed to beat back the forces of nature. a zapper 14 hrs a day, in good weather and bad, from the time of the first mos quito hatch in the spring until the end of November. Even though we attempt to mosquito adulticiding with insecticides as specific as possible in terms of flow rates, droplet size and time of applicaContinued on page 19 Nature was a powerful opponent in those days, and not least among her dangers were the hordes of insects that plagued area residents. Campbell's bat tower was intended to combat mosquito swarms for the early developers of Temple Terrace, who were attempting to transform the groves of Temple (of course) oranges into a posh surburban community. The Tower was designed to house more than 1,000 bats, imported from Texas, who were each supposed to dev9ur some 3,000 mos quitoes per night. Despite a cavelike interior, nurseries for baby bats, and ribbed hanging racks, the bats never took to Campbell 's tower. Instead they flew south, or wherever bats go, after being terrorized by local teen-agers--Ieaving the developers of Temple Terrace with a $10,000 failure (in 1924 dollars, mind you). Abandoned, the tower stood in a state of disrepair until historic interest was revived in 1976, and plans were made by the city to purchase the tower's land and refurbish the strange landmark. Fifteen thousand dollars was granted that year by the federal Department of Housing and Urban Development to restore the tower, but confusion over who owned the land delayed the pro ject until a 1979 arsonist's fire that gut ted the structure put an end to the idea. (This article appeared in the JuLy 11, 1981 . issue of the Tampa Times. Reprinted here by permission of th e Tampa Tribune.) Continued from page 18 tion, many people still prefer the non discriminatory electrocutor traps and then blame the decline of favored backyard songbirds on the use of pesticides. Dr. George Craig, Jr., of the University of Notre Dame goes so far as to call bug zappers a "fraud on the public." REPELLING DEVICES .. t The word fraud can also be used to describe a variety of mosquito repell ing devices. At least ten studies in the past 15 years have unanimously de nounced these devices as having no value whatsoever. Early versions of mosquito repelling devices use elec tromagnetic energy while more recent designs produce high frequency sound. Some of these devices are capable of being "fine tuned" by the purchaser, with instructions indicating that the device can be adjusted until the correct frequency is found to repel mosquito pests. None of these devices have proven effective in repelling mos quitoes when evaluated scientifically. There are many instances in which devices have been marketed that have little or no testing to support their ef ficacy claims. It may also be noted that in some of the product advertising, homeowners are urged to use these devices to rid their home of pests without the need to inhale "even one breath of poisonous spray." Such statements play on public fears that in secticides are harmful to humans and should be avoided. ty to release the fresh aromatic citronella oil. The Citrosa plant does not bloom or reproduce naturally but may be started with leaf cuttings. Although there are numerous anec dotes about the effectiveness of Citrosa there are no scientific studies that sup port the idea that the Citrosa plant are effective repellents. The plant leaves must be touched or disturbed to release the citronella aroma. As a house plant the lemony fragrance is quite pleasing, although the plant will spread and grow to a height of several feet if it is not pruned. Plants sell for about $12 and is tender below 45F. The proprietary bath oil Skin-So-Soft will repel mosquitoes in the lab but, like citronella, it mayor may not be ef fective on individual humans. The same applies to Culicoides biting midges. In laboratory trial, Rutledge and coworkers estimated that Aedes aegypti was about 30 times more sen sitive to the most commonly used in sect repellent DEET (N, N-diethyl-m toluamide) than to Skin-So-Soft. Jerry Butler, however, has found that there are also some attractants in the com mercially available product and that the primary repellent component in Skin-so-soft is better than DEET. The mechanisms of how repellents work are not know. Most of us are well aware that the public expects and in some cases even demands that insecticides should be very specific in their action. It is humorous to note that Skin-So-Soft can also be used for 31 purposes, including removing chewing gum from hair, skin, and most-non-porous surfaces; cleaning ink from skin and most-non porous surfaces; cleaning ink from skin and most vinyl and painted sur faces; cleaning paint brushes; remov ing tar from car finishes without damaging paint and as a suntan oil. PURPLE MARTINS An appraisal of the benefits of utiliz ing purple martins and bats for mos quito control offers fewer oppor tunities for humor and may lead to Continued on page 20 CITROSA MOSQUITO FIGHTER® AND SKIN-SO-SOFT® The Citro sa "Mosquito Fighter" plant and Avon's Skin-So-Soft bath oil are also marketed for their mosquito repelling qualities. Citrosa was genetically created by crossing tissue cultures of an African geranium with the Grass of China. The grass contains citronella oil, which has been used for many years as the active ingredient in mosquito repellent coils and candles. The geranium gives the plant the abili Brass -Warid .8. Nozzle· .Also availableiri35, ·50 and 100 gallon .models TOY4llY POflYABlE! ORDER TODAY! '. WING BEATS, SUMMER 1992 19 Continued from page 19 quite heated debates. It has been known for many years that purple mar tins consume large numbers of flying insects. Proponents of the value of pur ple martins have often used the state ment by Wade that "a purple martin will eat 2,000 mosquitoes in a day." He also stated that 10,000 to 14,000 mos quitoes could be consumed per day when mosquitoes are plentiful. All of Wade's values were non-scientific estimates based on his belief that mar tins had an extremely rapid digestive process and metabolism. He reasoned that an adult purple martin would have to consume its body weight each day in flying insects in order to survive. Thus, if an average adult martin weighted 4 oz., this would be the equivalent of 14,000 mosquitoes.Ac tually, Wade's math was faulty because he greatly overestimated the weights of an individual mosquito and martin and many more would have to be con sumed to provide the necessary nutrition. Wade did not analyze the stomach contents of martins but did recognize that their diet included flies, dragonflies, beetles, moths, locusts and other bugs in addition to mosquitoes. Unfortunately, many naturalists have failed to differentiate between Wade's theories and scientific fact. Exhaustive studies of the diet of pur ple martins by several ornithologist in dicate that while mosquitoes are a part of the diet they eat many more wasps, ants, house flies, crane flies, stinkbugs, tree hoppers, beetles, butterflies, moths and dragonflies. Mosquitoes make up less than three percent of their diet. After all it takes a lot of mosquitoes to add up to one dragonfly. Ornithologist James Hill is founder and director of the Purple Martin Con servation Association. He is especial ly anxious to dispel the longstanding notion that a single martin eats thousands of mosquitoes in one day. According to Hill, "The number of mosquitoes that martins eat is extreme ly insignificant, and they certainly don't control them." Rather than erect martin houses and other cavity-"type 20 WING BEATS, SUMMER 1992 houses for insectivorous birds specifically for the purpose of mos quito control, we should build them simply to attract these interesting birds for their esthetic and educational value. It is a mistake to promote the welfare of those wildlife species that only seem beneficial to man in some obvious way. to be safe and effective. Although ultraviolet electrocutor traps will at tract and kill mosquitoes, they are often misused and kill large numbers of in nocuous insects. Vertebrate predators such as purple martins and bats will BATS More recently some naturalists have become interested in the welfare of bats and have noted the value of insec tivorous species in controlling mos quito populations. They have subse quently recommended the construc tion of bat houses for the protection and propagation of those species that have been evicted from caves or human residences. That such an idea is a new one may be quickly refuted by referr ing to the literature. During the 1920's several large bat towers were con structed near San Antonio, Texas and Key West and Tampa, Florida with the intent of controlling malarial mos quitoes with high numbers of insect eating bats. Mosquito populations were not reduced but the large ac cumulations of guano was sold at a profit. The bats of temperate regions re main almost exclusively insectivorous. As with martins, bat food consists mainly of beetles, wasps, ants, flies, stoneflies, mayflies, moths and grasshoppers. Mosquitoes make up less than 1 percent of their diet although the percentage may be higher when mosquitoes are abundant. The evidence from stomach analysis and feces examination show that insec tivorous bats do help regulate some in sect populations, both beneficial and pest species - but not mosquitoes. However, bats are worthy of our pro tection regardless of their capacity or proclivity to consume pest or vector populations of mosquitoes. SUMMARY It is our responsibility to educate the public about mosquito control and to utilize those methods that are known Purple Martin with preferred prey. consume mosquitoes and should be considered as part of an integrated pest management program. A public education program should accompany the use of artificial cavity-type houses for the promotion of insectivorous bats and purple martins. Predators can not totally replace source reduction and chemical control. Electronic mosquito repellers have a dismal performance record and should be vigorously discouraged. The Citrosa Mosquito Fighter plant has no proven merit and research is needed to demonstrate any mosquito repelling qualities that it may possess. Personal protection from mos quitoes is best gained by the proper use of DEET and other topical repellents, including Skin-So-Soft. Lee Mitchell is ~ Biologist . with the Thledo Area Sani~ tary District; .s015 Stickney Avenue, Toledo, Ohio 43612; 419/726-7891; FAx~ 419/ 726-7721. . Program Profiles FAMU's Mulrennan Lab Thomas G. Floore While the state of Florida's natural resources and climate have made it a leading tourist state in America, this economic windfall did not "just hap pen." Many of the same natural features that are attractive to residents and tourists also provide favorable habitats for hordes of bloodsucking pests, some of which vector deadly diseases of man and animals. Before Florida became a popular tourist state, insect problems had to be reduced to tolerable levels for out-of-state visitors unaccustomed to such pests. This was achieved, largely during the past 30 years, by the efforts of many in dividuals working primarily in mos quito control and research. Mosquitoes remain a problem in all areas of Florida but especially on the peninsular coasts. In addition to mos quitoes, the Florida Panhandle is periodically plagued by a pest known locally as the dog fly, elsewhere as the stable fly and scientifically as Stomoxys calcitrans. When present, it is as significant a nuisance as saltmarsh mosquitoes in southern Florida. THE BEGINNING Following the establishment of what is now the Florida Medical Entomology Laboratory (u. of Florida) in Vero Beach in 1956, great strides were made in abating the pest mosquito problems throughout the state. Dr. John A. Mulrennan, Sr., the first professional entomologist employed by the Florida State Board of Health, lobbied for the formation of a second research laboratory to concen trate on solving the dog fly problem. In 1961, the Florida Legislature authorized and funded such a lab as part of the health department. The lab was established in Panama City when Dr. A. Jack Rogers, Dr. Carlisle B. Rathburn, Jr. and Burie W. (B. W.) Clements, Jr. of the Vero Beach lab were transferred to Panama City in 1964. The early mission of what was then the West Florida Arthropod Research Laboratory (WFARL) was spelled out in Chapter 388, F.S, 388.42: "To test insecticide resistance in dog flies, yellow flies and other arthropods, and to carry out other experimental work with chemicals, insecticides, and other substances and procedures, for testing effective methods for the control of such flies and other arthropods." During the next two years, these scientists conducted mosquito and dog fly biology and control research from temporary facilities located at the (Navy) Mine Defense Laboratory (Coastal Systems Station). Permanent research buildings and facilities were completed in 1966 on the present 10-acre site donated by the Bay County Panama City Airport Authority. Jack Rogers was the first director of the laboratory, serving until 1976 when he was promoted to Chief of En tomology Services in Jacksonville. Under his directorship, WFARL grew from 3 to 15 employees investigating the biology and control of mosquitoes, dog flies, sand flies and eye gnats. He initiated studies to determine the ef fects of insecticides applied for dog fly control on non-target estuarine organisms. Initially, basic biological studies at the laboratory concentrated on dog fly production in the accumulated bay grasses along the Gulf shores and in the nearby farm country. Later studies indicated that the majority of the flies originated north of the beaches in the farm country and migrated up to 70 miles to the Gulf beaches on norther ly winds primarily in the Fall. During that time, dog flies literally drove vaca tioners indoors or away from the Panhandle beaches and greatly im pacted the tourist economy of the area. The Dog Fly Control Program was established by Legislature in 1972 to control dqg flies along the Florida Panhandle Gulf Coast beaches from Pensacola to Apalachicola Bay. Aerial control procedures established by WFARL during the early 1970s are still employed today for dog fly control. A cooperative study on dog fly con trol and migration was initiated in 1980 with the USDA, Medical and Continued on page 22 Aerial view of the John A. Malrennan. Sr. Research Laboratory WING BEATS. SUMMER 1992 21 Continued from page 21 Veterinary Entomology Research Laboratory, in Gainesville, Florida. This cooperative study enabled the laboratory to expand dog fly research into the agricultural areas to confirm results of previous studies. The realiza tion that dog fly populations were pro duced in northern Florida, Alabama and Georgia eventually resulted in a reduced emphasis on dog fly control and biology research at JAMSRL. Dog fly control is now a separate operation under the Department of Agriculture. Sand flies, also known as biting midges, no-see-ums and punkies, re main as much a problem in some areas of the state as mosquitoes. Sand fly lar vae mature in environmentally sen sitive intertidal and marsh habitats where larvicides most often are detrimen tal to other non target organisms. The laboratory has in vestigated chemical, as well as other methods for controlling sand flies since 1964. Effective, environmentally safe control of sand fly larvae with chemicals is impractical at this time. Aerosol insecticides, such as Scourge®, have been tested at the laboratory and show promise in con trolling adult sand fly populations. Eye gnats are annoying pests of humans and livestock and have been suspected of transmitting pink eye in humans and conjunctivitis in livestock and small mammals. Laboratory and field research studies were conducted at JAMSRL for over 10 years. An at tractant trap which proved effective in monitoring eye gnat populations was developed by staff member, Joe Ruff, while at the University of Florida. DIVERSIFICATION B. W. Clements, Jr. was appointed Director of the laboratory in 1976. Dur ing Mr. Clements' 14-year tenure as director, the scope of the lab's efforts expanded significantly. He added study sections on environmental im pact and biological control and a per son to serve as liaison with mosquito control programs and the public. In November 1986, the laboratory's name 22 SUMMER 1992, WING BEATS was officially changed to the John A. Mulrennan, Sr. Research Laboratory (JAMSRL) in honor of the late Dr. John A. Mulrennan, Sr. and his contribu tions that established Florida · as a world leader in mosquito control. Mr. Clements retired in December 1990 after more than 30 years of state service. The laboratory's Microbial and Chemical Pesticide Evaluation Section, headed by Dr. James C. Dukes, con tinues the lab's traditional role of assessing the effectiveness of insec ticides against Florida's pestiferous mosquitoes and other biting flies. Evaluations and recommendations made by the section are pivotal in the decision making process of many mos quito control agencies in Florida and worldwide. Studies include insec ticidal droplet analysis, evaluation of new insecticides, application equip ment and efficacy studies of ex perimental and labeled adulticides and larvicides for the control of medically important insects. The dog fly research staff changed their emphasis to environmental ef fects of pesticides used to control mos quitoes. This gave rise to the Pesticide Environmental Impact Section in 1986 which is headed by Dr. Noor Tietze. This section's basic laboratory and field biological and toxicological studies on a variety of environmental ly sensitive organisms, including grass shrimp, blue crab and several fish species, have already proven beneficial in the assessment and recommenda tions of insecticides used in Florida. A Biological Control Section was also established in 1986 to study alter natives to traditional chemical mos quito control methods. Dr. Eric T. Schreiber, head of the section, is em phasizing the colonization and release of natural enemies, particularly several species of Toxorhynchites, nonbiting, cannibalistic mosquitoes that prey on other mosquito larvae. Schreiber's sec tion also monitors urban mosquito populations to determine the effects of biocontrol measures on pest mos quitoes. The challenges for this section will be to develop biological control agents that are effective in a variety of mosquito habitats and to develop economical techniques for their pro duction and use. In 1987 the mission of the lab was legally changed to reflect the shift in focus at the laboratory: "To perform basic and applied research to develop and test formula tions, application techniques, and pro cedures for the control of arthropods. Special attention shall be given to the needs of the mosquito control districts, counties and municipalities by pro viding information, assistance and recommendations for the safe and effec tive control of health and nuisance ar thropods." A NEW BEGINNING The current director, Dr. John P. Smith, was appointed in 1991. His goal is to expand the laboratory's role as a support facility for information and special research needs of the public and local mosquito control agencies in Florida. In 1992, under Smith's leader ship, the JAMSRL was transferred by legislative action from the health department to the Florida Agricultural & Mechanical University (FAMU), Tallahassee, while maintaining its physical location in Panama City. The John ·A . Mulrennan, Sr. Research Laboratory is situated on a beautiful piece of land on North Bay, an inlet from the Gulf of Mexico, in Panama City, midway between and about 100 miles from Tallahassee and Pensacola. A list of the JAMSRL staff literature contributions for the past 30 years is available free. Contact the author at JAMSRL, 4000 Frankford Avenue, Panama City, FL 32405; 904/872-4184; FAX: 904/872-4733. Tom Floore is a Biological ScientM with the Chemical & .. Mictobial Pesticide Evalua tion Section at the 19hn A. Mtdrennan Sr~, Research Laboratory. He thanks Jack RogerS, Jim ' Dukes, John Smith,. Eric Schreiber and Phil Hester for their help in preparing this article. [ / Quality IS Economy U.S. DISTRIBUTORS ADAPCO, INC. INTERNATIONAL DISTRIBUTORS . ENVIROTECH INTERNATIONAL P. O. Box 8489' . Delhi 110052: INDIA Phone 407-644·6292 RELIABLE LABS 8060 Telford Way Sandy, UT 84092 Phone 801 ·942· 1685 B & G CHEMICAL & EQUIPMENT CO.. INC. P. O. Box 540428 Dallas. TX 75354 Phone 214-357·5741 NORTHEAST VECTOR MANAG~MEIiIT, INC P. O. Box 754 Free~old, NJ 07728 Phone 201·431·9563 CLARKE MOSQUITO CONTROL PRODUCTS P. O. Box 72288 Roselle, IL 60172 Phone 708·894·2000 ZANUS CORPORATION 1555 Howell Branch Rd., Sle . 81 Winter Park, Fl 32789 North Melbourne 3051 . AUSTRALIA 1259 EI Camino Real Suite 134 Menlo Park, CA 94025 Phone 415·591·7783 CORNBELT CHEMICAL COMPANY P.O. Box 410 McCook, NE 69001 Phone 308-345·5057 C. RUDDUCK PTY LTD . 93 Howard Street KEM·SAN, INC. P. O. Box 727" Oakville. Ontario LSJ 5C1 CANADA LABORATORI EMILIANI INDUSTRIA CHIMICA AFFINI Via Appennino 457 47100 Forti· ITALY WELLCOME SINGAPORE PTE LTD 33 Qualily Road Singapore 2261 WELLCOME ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH TRADEQUEST, INC. Ravens lane 5 Kronprindsens Gada Berkhamsted, Herts SI. Thomas, USVI 00802 HP42DY UNITED KINGDOM .-. LOWNDES ENGINEERING CO., INC. 125 BLANCHARD ST. I P.O . BOX 488 VALDOSTA, GEORGIA 31801 PHONE (912) 242-3361 TWX 81()-786·5861 CABLE - LECO VALD FAX (912) 242·8763 Pi CYTHION® and ABATE® Mosquito control that keeps peace with people and the environment. Today Mosquito Control Professionals must be public relations specialists and ecologists along with their other skills. Science and Industry are providing more tools and concepts while the public and government are asking more questions. You have to be sharp to be a career mosquito professional. We salute and support your dedication. Responsible mosquito control requires environmentally sensitive applicators and selective insecticides. The mosquito control industry traditionally provides careful needed application. American Cyanamid, in turn, proudly supplies and supports your efforts. You can continue to rely on CYTHION® ULV and ABATE®for your mosquito control IPM programs. They are tough on mosquitoes, but gentle to the environ ment. Continue to use them wisely. THE WORLD NEEDS &'''' Registered Trademarks of American Cyanamid Company 7190 MOSQUITlO CONTROLTM I _ _ CYANAIWID " ~ AMERICAN MOSQUITO CONTROL c/o Outdoor Tech., Inc. 1499 Morning Dove Rd . Tallahassee, FL 32312 Dr. Richard F. Darsie, Jr. University of South Carolina PO Box 699 ' iVfcCle_~anvi 11 _~~C_29458 - -- DI"I~ AgrIcultural wayne. NJ07470 vPc Ventures ©1990 Non-Profit Org. - U.S. Postage PAID rallahassee, FL Permit No. 407