A journey to the centre of our world page 10
Transcription
A journey to the centre of our world page 10
special issue / June 2011 / France Telecom-Orange Corporate Social Responsibility initiatives and commitments commitment changes with Orange social contract. Sent to our 102,000 employees in France, this document lays out the foundation for a new social model and reaffirms our commitments as a responsible employer. Based on dialogue with employees, it reconciles economic performance and social quality. page 06 Stéphane Richard, solar power. The deployment of mobile solar power stations in Africa, and in Madagascar in particular, shows how innovation and care for the environment can be combined to drive economic growth and social progress. page 09 safety. Digital safety can be taught in the same way as road safety. It’s up to operators to shoulder that responsibility, as Orange Slovakia is doing with students, teachers and parents. page 14 Chairman and Chief Executive Officer “Through its universal dimension, CSR brings us closer to society and its stakeholders.” interview page 04 Madagascar, Moldavia, United States, Poland, Slovakia, France, Spain… A journey to the centre of our world corporate social responsability complete report France Telecom Orange 2010 Read all about it! See our complete report: key figures, track records, action plans, road maps and more… This first issue of Initiatives magazine brings you an overview and an illustration of the initiatives implemented by the Group in the sphere of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR). To get the big picture as regards issues, track records and future objectives, you should consult the complete 2010 Corporate Social Responsibility Report. This contains a wealth of general information about the Group’s CSR organisation, governance, and policy, along with details about its action plans and road maps in the environmental, economic, and social fields. In short: a global report on www.orange.com! page 10 years of commitments. For the past 15 years, France Telecom-Orange has worked hard to include sustainable development and Corporate Social Responsibility principles in its corporate strategy. In the digital society, the Group is shouldering its responsibilities to nurture social ties and ensure the greatest possible number of people benefit from new technologies. Because CSR is important when it comes to creating value both for stakeholders and the Group, Orange has built the question into the heart of its Conquests 2015 strategic plan. The central role confirms the Group’s ambition to become a benchmark CSR player in the telecoms sector. page 06 june 2011 / initiatives 02 4 pillars for responsible commitment > For Orange, being a responsible company first and foremost means recognising and supporting its people. As a responsible employer, Orange has committed to being a Group that people like to work for, thanks to a new approach to human resources, a new management style, and a renewed commitment to common values such as equal opportunity. It’s a social model that puts the Group’s people squarely at the centre of its concerns. > Because fast-changing technology is giving rise not only to new types of usage but also to new types of risk, Orange is committed to ensuring transparency, quality and security for all its customers. This commitment means we have a duty to set the example in areas as varied as respect for quality of service, privacy, data confidentiality, answers to concerns about radio waves, or helping children and their parents throughout their digital experience. > Share the benefits of the digital world with the greatest possible number of people. This is one of the prime tasks of the Group and a major responsibility. Combating every manifestation of the digital divide (product accessibility for dependent people, the deployment of access infrastructure, support for local economic growth by building bridges to the culture, healthcare and education spheres) is an area in which Orange’s commitment is very clear. > Last, the Group is finding innovative solutions for a greener world. In this respect, its efforts are being directed towards minimising its energy footprint, managing the waste it generates, and reducing the impact of its products by promoting their eco-design. Developing technological solutions enabling each and every one of us to live and act as an eco-citizen is also a strong line of development for the Group. credits initiatives is published by France Telecom, 6, place d’Alleray, 75505 Paris Cedex 15, France – a Public Limited Company (SA) capitalised at 10,595,434,424 euros – Paris Trade Register No. 380 129 866. Publisher: Marc Fossier. Editor in Chief: Christine Hermann. Design & Layout: – Managing Editors: Bertrand Fauquet – Isabelle Derveaux. Texts: La Machine à Écrire – Dominika Uhrikova. Photo credits: Abaca Press, Nicolas Baker, Jurg Christandl, Stéphane Foulon, Isabela Herrero, Eduar Sirbu, France Telecom Image Library, Orange Librairie, Orange Brand Site. Acknowledgements – External contributions: Agnès Fuseau, Zakaria El Hessni (Les Ateliers du Bocage) – Jean-Marc Jancovici (Carbone 4) – Denis Cheissoux – Fondation Akbaraly – Rado Jancula (Narnia school) – Mirella Panek-Owsia´nska (Responsible Business Forum) – Ines Rivera – Perry Romere, Guillaume Ramey, David Martinotti (SBM Offshore) – Steven Art (Umicor) – Cristina Bueti (ITU) – Internal contributions: Francia Andriamampionona, Mathilde Arnavon, Bérengère Arnold, Benja Arson, Séverine Blanchard-Jazdzewski, Jean-Luc Bohé, Dominique Borie, Lucie Boyn, Ludmila Buzulan, Yann Decoux, Pierre de La Bourdonnaye, Mélissa Fofana, Jacques François, Gilles Gaillard, Erwan Gelebart, Wanda Gromulsova, Jesus Guijarro Valladolid, Philippe Horville, Marianne Lahaye, Carole Le Cunff, Frédérique Limido-Milesi, Laurent Martin-Blanc, Marc Martinucci, Jean-Luc Pistoresi, Jean-Luc Rabenitany, Holy Ranaivozanany, Danielle Rigaudière, Remisko Bartlomiej Roch, Maria Pilar Serrano Rivera, Gérard Taxis, and Beata Woyczynska, to name but a few. FTEL_1104278_MAGAZINE_RSE-GB.indd 02 100% post-consumer fibres, process chlorine free. 18/05/11 19:25 Exploring the initiatives and commitments of France Telecom-Orange 03 in the front line in 2010 page 13 Poland Kraków meet a front-line CSR activist page 15 France Mirella Panek-Owsiańska, Chairman of the Responsible Business Forum, talks about the role of her association in promoting best practice and about the advancement of CSR research in Poland, and appraises the initiatives of TP Group in this area. Villabé the experience of one lucky apprentice Apprenticeships are a royal road to the world of work and business. The example of Mélissa, who floated a long-shot job application past Orange when she was at an Apprentice Training Centre, speaks volumes. Gilles, her mentor, who has been with the Group for the past 30 years and more, infected her with his love of the job and trained her in the ins-and-outs of the customer service engineer’s job. Melissa is now forging ahead under her own steam. page 16 France – Belgium the epic journey of an end-of-life mobile, from collection to recycling A photo report of the final journey of a mobile phone, from its landing at an Orange collection point to the recovery of the rare metals it contains or its reconditioning for resale in a sheltered sector workshop. And you can help too, by handing in your old mobile phones. Out of 3 billion unused mobile phones worldwide, only 5% get collected! page 12 Moldavia Chisinau recognition for women managers Orange Moldavia CEO Liudmila Climoc was voted “Manager of the Year” in 2010 by VIP Magazin. The accolade is recognition for the hard work and commitment of a woman who is attentive to the needs of Moldavian society, and is also a sign of the country’s progress towards gender equality. page 10 Madagascar Antananarivo dawn of a new start page 13 page 17 United States Spain Houston Madrid telepresence an everyday reality How do the staff of a multinational corporation manage to work together when they’re thousands of miles apart? At SBM Offshore, ever since Orange Business Services installed their telepresence network, that’s no longer an issue. Plus it also means less travelling and hence fewer CO2 emissions and more quality time with their families for staff! FTEL_1104278_MAGAZINE_RSE-GB.indd 03 Disrupted by a political crisis in 2009, Madagascar is today one of the world’s poorest countries. What role does Orange play in the island republic’s economic development and its social environment via its products and its commitment to education and healthcare programmes? Answers inside. only connect… for seniors Because making access to the benefits of the digital universe for the greatest number is one of the Group’s key priorities, it’s offering specific help packages for older or disabled people. We talked to Ines Rivera, 69, who, thanks to Orange, is a satisfied connected customer! page 14 Slovakia Bratislava teachers, parents, and kids act to minimise the risks of new technologies We go behind the scenes at the “Kids and Mobile Communications” programme, which distributes interactive awareness-raising packs to 7-16 year-olds in Slovakia’s school system – a smart, fun way to educate youngsters about the potential risks involved in using the new technologies. 18/05/11 19:25 june 2011 / initiatives 04 interview interview Stéphane Richard The Chairman and Chief Executive Officer sets out his vision of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) and explains how it permeates every strand of Group thinking and strategy. What role do you assign to Corporate Social Responsibility, with Our next step has been to unite our staff around a common set of respect to economic reality, technological change, and manage- aims and objectives in France and in our entities around the rial vision? world, in both the technical and commercial domains. CSR must Stéphane Richard: It has pride of place, and sits naturally with not be allowed to become the exclusive prerogative of special- all of these three aspects. Not only because CSR topics reflect ists, but must, on the contrary, engage the greatest possible economic realities but also because a telecommunications group number of people across the Group. like ours has an important role to play in the way it channels technological change, and because CSR is an integral part of our In July 2010, you launched a new, four-pronged strategic plan managerial vision and corporate project. called “Conquests 2015”. How far did Corporate Social CSR is a strong requirement as well as an ambition. It helps to Responsibility enter into the equation when you were setting strengthen our employees’ sense of belonging to the company. your objectives? As such, it forms the bedrock of our social cohesion and of the S. R.: Corporate Social Responsibility largely permeated and engagement of our workforce. inspired our discussions while we were developing this strategic plan, and will accordingly be found in each of our four major How are these issues addressed throughout the Group? “conquests”, starting with the first: the place of our employees in S. R.: We began by putting our commitment on a formal footing the organization. We are determined to learn the lessons from the by appointing a member of the top management team to be in social crisis we experienced in recent years, and we want to charge of these questions, namely Jean-Philippe Vanot, Deputy make France Telecom-Orange a benchmark for quality of life in Chief Executive Officer. The subject is also addressed at Board the workplace. I trust this will attract younger people to our level, where there is now a specialized governance and corporate company. social responsibility committee. Gender equality, diversity and equal job opportunities are also issues of the highest importance for the Group. To give you another example: in our core business of network management we constantly strive to minimise energy consumption when running our equipment and infrastructure, and we encourage all programmes that contribute to this goal. France Telecom-Orange is also helping to make the benefits of the digital world accessible to the greatest number, and democratising the use of new technologies in order to combat the digital divide. This is CSR forms the bedrock of our social cohesion and of the engagement of our workforce.” a commitment that we make to society, and that sits at the heart of our core business as an operator. In practice, this translates for example into the deployment of new networks for the benefit of many countries in Africa via submarine cables, and into innovative solutions to improve the distribution of healthcare and education in emerging countries. FTEL_1104278_MAGAZINE_RSE-GB.indd 04 23/05/11 14:20 Exploring the initiatives and commitments of France Telecom-Orange 05 Do you have the sense that you are giving a new impetus to Corporate Social Responsibility within the France TelecomOrange Group? S. R.: I hope so! I want to raise the profile of CSR both in our thinking and in our strategy. The involvement of the senior management team, and the impetus we are continually renewing on these topics, are essential if we are to ensure that all our employ- Being aware of what is happening around us is essential.” ees rally to the call of CSR. I also want to involve myself personally in this approach and I spell out its benefits as often as possible, both inside and outside of the Group. How important are consultation and dialogue for you? S. R.: Dialogue and consultation are key for a service company like ours, with over 200 million customers worldwide. Being aware of what is happening around us is essential, and through its universal dimension, CSR brings us closer to society and its stakeholders. Adopting a receptive, humble attitude to these issues is essential. Openness vis-à-vis other spheres such as the cultural or voluntary areas, for instance, helps to expand our vision and change the image people have of our Group. This necessity also calls for a stronger presence on the ground. At the end of the day, my personal vision of management is closely akin to these concepts of humility, attentiveness, openness, and transparency, without which there could be no trusting relationship with our workforce and our customers. FTEL_1104278_MAGAZINE_RSE-GB.indd 05 18/05/11 19:25 june 2011 / initiatives 06 2010 express the Social Contract: the foundation of a new social model In recent months, France Telecom Orange has embarked on an overhaul of its social policy aimed at putting the human side at the heart of the company – a priority enshrined in the Conquests 2015 strategic plan. In France, this responsibility takes the shape of a “New Social Contract”, the outcome of an unprecedented joint construction exercise and extensive consultations. In this document, sent to all 102,000 staff in France by Stéphane Richard in September 2010, the Group laid the basis for a new social model and restated its commitments as a responsible employer. Based on consultations with employees, and on collective agreements and discussions in early 2010, it simultaneously reflects the desire to impart a new momentum to the Group’s social ambitions and to respond to > employees 3,800 ongoing human challenges. As an integral part of development strategy, the new “Social Contract” sets out each component of the framework for the new relationship between the Group and its staff. This is because the scope of the “Social Contract” extends from employment policy to employee compensation, and from the role of managers to quality of life in the workplace. To drive implementation and transpose the Contract in practical terms into the everyday reality of staff, France Telecom-Orange injected large-scale resources, with 900 million euros earmarked for investment between 2010 and 2012 in external recruitment and in improving the work environment, information systems, and so on. The number of staff recruited this year in France out of a total 10,000 hires planned between 2010 and 2012. management WORKING TO IMPROVE QUALITY OF LIFE IN THE WORKPLACE The Group is deeply committed to issues of wellbeing and improving the work environment. Among the many initiatives implemented, a newlycreated employee satisfaction survey in France aims to strengthen the follow up on the company’s social performance. The survey findings are also factored into the performance-related pay component of senior management in France. 400 The number of local employee representative bodies in Europe and a number of countries in Africa. TRAINING The average number of training hours per person at Group level in 2010. Developing skills is a central priority in Orange’s HR policy. The Group is pursuing an ambitious programme in this area, underpinned by specially-dedicated resources, including 17 occupational schools and 9,000 online training modules. 29 DIVERSITY a founder member of the Arborus fund New consultation body for all countries An agreement on the creation of a Global Works Council was signed with all the social partners in June 2010. The structure is designed as a discussion forum with employee representatives on all continents, focusing on the great economic and social issues of the day, and aimed at reflecting the multicultural dimension of a Group where 40% of the workforce is employed outside France. FTEL_1104278_MAGAZINE_RSE-GB.indd 06 Alongside other large groups recognized for their commitment to gender equality, France TelecomOrange participated as a founder member in the establishment of Arborus: Europe’s first subsidies fund for equal opportunity in the workplace, launched in April 2010 under the patronage of the European Economic and Social Council. Arborus’s first concrete achievement was the launch of the European Gender European Standard. By becoming a partner in this European initiative, France Télécom-Orange is looking to encourage the promotion of a common European culture in the matter of equal opportunity in the workplace and benefit from innovative ideas to establish this ambition in all its European subsidiaries. 23/05/11 14:20 Exploring the initiatives and commitments of France Telecom-Orange key milestones 07 > customers The Orange position in the ranking of best mobile networks in continental France according to industry regulator ARCEP. austrian minutes help good causes Since it was launched by Orange Austria, the Orange Hilft (“Orange Helps”) initiative has already garnered over 30,000 fans on Facebook and collected 83,000 euros. The principle is simple: customers can convert their unused minutes of talktime into cash donations. The money is then transferred to selected partner charities working with vulnerable people: Caritas, Licht ins Dunkel, and the Make-AWish Foundation®. crisis management Orange mobilised to guarantee service continuity To deal with emergency situations, a crisis management process guarantees a rapid, effective response. The system proved its worth when Atlantic storm Xynthia cut a swathe of destruction through western France in late February 2010. Widespread damage in the Centre, Poitou-Charentes and Pays de la Loire regions deprived 170,000 homes of access to telephony services and cut 100,000 subscriber lines. Over 2,000 customer service engineers and network specialists went into action to restore communications as soon as possible, and the network was again in working order in less than ten days. 94% Mobile network coverage in Armenia Orange initiated a major push in 2010 to boost network mobile coverage by over 10%. In parallel, capacity was also increased to keep pace with the explosion in data traffic. FTEL_1104278_MAGAZINE_RSE-GB.indd 07 Egypt: an extensive information programme In Egypt, Mobinil has, for some years now, been running an extensive programme designed to inform the public about radio waves: 35 information and external communication meetings and 12 internal sessions were organised in 2010, raising awareness among some 6,400 participants. Information is available on the Mobinil website and in three brochures concerning responsible mobile phone use, how the networks work and their impact on health and the environment. In 2010, Mobinil also helped the GSMA - the mobile industry’s worldwide association - to produce its first information brochure in Arabic concerning mobile networks and radio waves. Testing the customer experience The Simplicity+ network reached full maturity in 2010. It now has over 150 staff working in 15 test centres around the globe. As a result, the Group has carried out over 300 customer tests on how well our offers are understood and on the customer experience. Launched in 2004, Simplicity+ increases the quality and simplicity of Group products and services by making customer perceptions central to the launch process and the entire product lifespan. A network of customer test centres in each country is tasked with improving the customer experience by gauging user perceptions in terms of simplicity at each stage in their use of our products. 18/05/11 19:25 june 2011 / initiatives 08 2010 express democratising access to the digital world Like being able to read and write, learning to use digital aids has now become essential for a fulfilled social and working life. As a logical follow-on from Orange Foundation campaigns to combat illiteracy, the Orange “Digital Solidarity” campaign launched in late 2010 helps community associations to immerse their members in the digital world to help them master it. The Group is providing fully-equipped, web-enabled learning centres throughout France. Facilities are already up and running in ten cities and there are plans > society to open up close to 200 centres in 2011. Staff volunteers with a range of skills are teaching and helping beneficiaries recruited by partner charities including Secours Populaire, Force Femmes, the Agir Contre l’Exclusion Foundation, and Solidarité & Avenir. The Orange Foundation is also helping community associations to acquire IT hardware and software. It donates some of the Group’s recycled computers to help the most disadvantaged users. short calls HEALTHCARE Orange Healthcare has joined the mHealth Alliance to deliver healthcare services via mobile phone in West Africa. The partnership will help take advantage of rapid advances in mobile telephony technology and of the ground-breaking initiatives already taken by Orange to help improve healthcare and public health in emerging countries. In Egypt, Mobinil is contributing to a tele-dermatology project in conjunction with Click Diagnostics. It is seeking to improve Egyptians’ access to dermatological care using a smartphone app. DEVELOPMENT In Senegal, Orange backed the set-up of a Business incubator in the new technologies sector. Inaugurated in Dakar in April 2011, it aims to contribute to the development of ICT by backing some 30 small and mid-sized companies over a 3-year period. 1,3 million customers had benefited from Orange Money by end-2010 Orange Money delivers a whole raft of services for people without access to traditional banking services thanks to a mobile number. Orange Money is also a way for companies and small businesses to simplify the payment of merchant services, and even wages. Already available in Republic of Côte d’Ivoire, in Senegal, in Mali, in Niger and in Madagascar, this highly secure service will be deployed in all countries in the Africa-Middle East region during 2011. suppliers: CSR audits around the world The steady offshoring of production processes by some telecoms industries has led to the launch of component and electronic product assembly plants in East Asia. In China, for example, this has resulted in the creation of huge business parks in some cities, with dormitory blocks for employees who flock to find work from all over the country. What’s more, their working conditions may fall well below European standards. In view of this, the Joint Audit Cooperation (JAC) initiative, launched in early 2010 by France Telecom Orange, Telecom Italia, and Deutsche Telecom, is hugely important. Placed on a formal foot- FTEL_1104278_MAGAZINE_RSE-GB.indd 08 ing in a memorandum of understanding, the system helps to jointly audit the corporate social and environmental responsibility practice of members’ Asian suppliers. Audits are carried out by international agencies specialising in CSR, and the first took place in July 2010. To date, 19 audits have been carried out. Out of a total 1,500 questions asked, 67 non-conformities were recorded, 21 of which were critical. The most common involve working hours, health & safety, and wages. The findings led to remedial action plans and will be followed up by a subsequent review. SENIORS Simplified mobile handsets for seniors. In 2010, after France and Slovakia, three Orange subsidiaries, in Romania, Switzerland and Spain, launched a range of mobile handsets specifically-designed to meet the needs of seniors. INVESTMENT France Telecom Orange is involved in four projects to lay high-speed broadband optical fibre submarine cables designed to improve the quality of web connectivity in Africa, the Middle East and the Indian sub-continent. Through these major investments, the Group is implementing two planks of its strategy: democratising Internet access, and contributing to developing the quality of its global network. 18/05/11 19:25 Exploring the initiatives and commitments of France Telecom-Orange key milestones 09 Orange undertakes to collect used mobile phones In France, Orange, Emmaüs and the Ateliers du Bocage jointly developed a project to recycle mobile phones. Since 2010, the partnership has been exported to Africa, where there is, as yet, no structured sector. A pilot centre to process mobile phones run by the movement Emmaüs International opened in March in Burkina Faso, creating five new jobs. Orange has committed to backing the Africa project over five years. A second workshop opened in Benin in 2010 and several other countries in Africa should shortly follow suit. In another example, in 2010, Orange Spain launched an offer to collect used mobile phones in exchange for discount vouchers worth up to 140 euros. The telephones recovered are then handed over to MobilePoint, which reconditions the phones and sells them at affordable prices in emerging countries. Orange Romania and WWF launch eco-label After France and Spain, it was in Romania that in December 2010 Orange and WWF launched an eco-labelling system for mobile handsets. The programme allows customers to select their model based on five environmentally-responsible criteria to define an overall “environmental performance” indicator. The number of new countries which in 2010 deployed the energy action plan in their organisations. Some 21 countries are now contributing to the Group’s efforts to set up more environmentally-friendly networks. > environment 2 awards for Orange solar-powered base station programme CERTIFICATION The programme won an accolade at the Global Telecoms Business Awards 2010, as well as the prize for best mobile technology for emerging markets in February 2011 at the Global Mobile Awards 2011, held in Barcelona. More than 920 stations had already been installed by end 2010. 4 activities and processes in the environmental management system of Orange France and the Orange Business Services Cesson Sévigné site won ISO 14 001 certification in early 2011. The Group has decided to further extend the certification to a more nationwide footprint by 2015. Time for a carbon audit! In 2010, Orange embarked on a carbon audit using the Bilan Carbone® method developed by ADEME, the French Environment and Energy Management Agency. The method, which is compatible with the international ISO 14064-1 standard and with the GHG Protocol, factors in the direct and indirect greenhouse gas emissions generated over the entire life-cycle of a product or service. It can be used to lay the groundwork for cutting energy consumption. The programme launched by France Telecom-Orange has four components. The first involves identifying the main areas of greenhouse gas emissions in the FTEL_1104278_MAGAZINE_RSE-GB.indd 09 business in the widest sense of the word (ie, by Group operations and also upstream by its suppliers and downstream by its customers). An initial assessment was carried out in France based on 2009 data and will be used as a baseline for measuring the impact of future operations. Another audit of greenhouse gas emissions was carried out at Mobistar, the Group subsidiary in Belgium. These two initiatives helped to analyse the carbon dependency of our activities, segment by segment, and to gear up to reduce it. In a related development, the use of a Bilan Carbone ® carbon audit on a single process, namely paperless billing, will help to gauge its carbon footprint and identify means of operational action. A carbon and business analysis carried out in connection with a long-term investment in the mobile network should also help foster the factoring in of CO2 emissions restrictions in investment decisions. Last, a special study has been launched to determine how to help customers to lead less carbon-intensive lives via teleworking solutions. This programme is set to continue throughout 2011 in order to cover more countries and analyse other investments and processes. 18/05/11 19:25 june 2011 / initiatives 10 Abidjan, Amman, Antananarivo, Bamako, Bangui, Bern, Bissau, Bratis lav In a remote part of Antananarivo, women walking to the neighbouring village. At the end of the road is an Orange solar-powered base station. Healthcare changes with the advent of the LION submarine cable and broadband services, enabling distant health centres to carry out remote diagnosis. FTEL_1104278_MAGAZINE_RSE-GB.indd 10 An Orange engineer with the 100% solar powered base station. The goal of narrowing the digital divide with a smaller environmental footprint is underway. Orange Money is already a resounding success on the island, with over 150,000 active customers. 18/05/11 19:25 Exploring the initiatives and commitments of France Telecom-Orange tis lava, Brussels, Bucharest, Cairo, Chisinau, Conakry, Dakar, Gaborone, 11 ANTANANARIVO MADAGASCAR In Madagascar, telecoms are helping to drive the local economy Dogged by political instability, economic and cyclical problems, not to mention severe poverty, Madagascar is experiencing recession against the backdrop of the global economic crisis. But as a Madagascan proverb says, “Prosperity will come: you have to start with very little”. Orange Madagascar has taken this approach in its various activities and commitments in the service of the local social and economic fabric. 76%(1) of the Madagascan population lives on less than a dollar a day per person + 65% of the country now has Orange mobile phone coverage 25% of Madagascans own a mobile phone Over 800 Orange Money points of sale throughout the country (1) According to the Madagascar National Statistics Institute. With its annual per capita GDP(2) of 1,004 dollars, Madagascar is one of the world’s poorest countries, despite its wealth of natural and mineral resources. The economic situation has deteriorated there since 2009 and the start of the ongoing political crisis, which continues to adversely affect the country’s economic growth. Another line of development for telecommunications is mobile solar powered base stations deployed in remote rural areas. These “green” base stations are helping to extend Madagascan coverage even further and expanding access to telephony and the internet for the greatest possible number. TELECOMS AS GROWTH FACTORS In this difficult environment, the telecommunications sector, which saw steady growth between 2005 and 2008, has been in a downturn for the past two years. Yet it remains a vital growth factor for the island state. Madagascan citizens have powerful expectations in this respect, and welcome new services with open arms. Orange Madagascar made a splash when it began offering web services, for example, cornering a 30% market share in the space of a year. By cutting the cost of broadband services fivefold relative to a conventional satellite connection, the deployment of the LION undersea fibre-optic cable in late 2009 was a first response to the challenge of boosting trade in the island and democratising web usage. Marketed also in several other African countries, the Orange Money offering was launched in Madagascar in 2010 and is helping in its own way to stimulate the local economy (see box). INNOVATING FOR IMPROVED PUBLIC HEALTH In a country where 70% of the population has no access to drinking water and where public health issues revolve as much around access to healthcare as its quality, technology can also play an important role in improving the situation. Questions of patient screening, care and treatment take on vital importance in such situations. Gynaecological cancers, for example, which are being combated by the Akbaraly Foundation, account for over 50% of cancers in women. In 2010, with the help of Orange, three hospitals in Antananarivo, Majunga and Fianarantsoa were equipped with broadband to help them carry out remote diagnostics digital imaging transmission and also by online training for medical personnel. Thanks to this system, doctors can make a reliable diagnosis with the help of specialised centres such as the Gustave Roussy Institute in Paris. Patient benefits include timely diagnosis and safe treatment protocols developed with the help of experts, at a time when the female cancer mortality rate is running at 60%. A similar partnership exists with AMADIA, an association specialising in combating diabetes. EDUCATION THE KEY TO THE FUTURE The economic situation is also having repercussions on the educational system, notably in respect of access to and financing for studies. Some 19.9% of Madagascans are illiterate, and only 14% attend secondary school. The advent of broadband also means that new training and job opportunities are opening up. Set up in conjunction with local institutions and agencies, the Orange School rapidly became the Premier operational school in Madagascar for careers in sales and call centres. It enables young Madagascans motivated by the new technologies, as well as personnel from local businesses, institutions and bodies, to access hands-on, operations-oriented training for future sales staff, telephone sales and advisory staff, and sales managers. The School brings the hope of quickly finding employment in a fast-growing sector and opens up a range of bright new career prospects. (2) GDP per capita based on purchasing power parity. ORANGE MONEY STIMULATES TRADE Launched in Madagascar in May 2010, the Orange Money electronic wallet facilitates access to secure banking services from any mobile phone in a country where only 5% of the population have a bank account. Midway between banking and microfinance, Orange Money can be used for transferring funds from one account to another and for making purchases or paying bills. The service is more reliable and cheaper than a transfer by bush taxi and is built on a network of several hundred points of sale and distributors. It’s making a substantial contribution to stimulating and streamlining cash transactions throughout the country. FTEL_1104278_MAGAZINE_RSE-GB.indd 11 18/05/11 19:25 june 2011 / initiatives 12 Lisbon, London, Luxembourg, Madrid, Malabo, Manama, Nairobi, Niam ey CHISINAU MOLDAVIA “We still live in a man’s world, but mindsets are changing and gender equality is gaining ground in Moldava” says Liudmila Climoc, here sitting among her executive committee. moldovan Liudmila Climoc voted “Manager of the Year” Crowned “Manager of the Year 2010” by the local Moldovan magazine VIP Magazin, Liudmila Climoc, 35, and CEO of Orange Moldova since 2008, has her feet firmly on the ground, accepting the accolade as recognition for the hard work put in by an entire team. She runs a tight ship with a firm hand, well aware of her responsibilities. Don’t even think of suggesting to Liudmila that there’s something unusual about being a woman and a top manager. As she says, “Sure, we still live in a man’s world, but mindsets are changing and gender equality is gaining ground in Moldova. At Orange alone, there are three women on the 9-member Executive Committee. That’s recognition of our analytical abilities and our grasp of change management and successfully moving on aided by our motherly instincts”. Qualities such as these are crucial in Liudmila’s position, at the helm of a market leader with 2 million Mobile, Internet & Fix customers out of a total population of around 3 million. She is well aware of the attendant responsibilities: “The telecoms sector is a catalyst for the Moldovan economy, where it accounts for around 10% of GDP. We are playing a central role as a supplier of services that drive economic growth and as a creator of jobs.” What is she most proud of? “Being the first country in the world to launch High-Definition mobile voice calling. This innovation was awarded as a technology break-through in last year World Mobile Congress in Barcelona. It shows what Moldovans can do, and it certainly helps to keep top talent at home.” FTEL_1104278_MAGAZINE_RSE-GB.indd 12 Her sense of responsibility also reaches well outside the Business box. “I make sure that we take an active part in Moldova’s social and cultural life. As the representative of an international group, we are a key interface when it comes to inviting some of the world’s top artists here, such as Cesaria Evora, Goran Bregovic or Above & Beyond last year, and to making sure the rest of the world knows all about our home-grown Moldovan talent. Eurovision is also one of our major sponsorship in Moldova with the final being held in Germany May 14th.” Liudmila is also very much aware of her stakeholders, and the expectations of her compatriots when it comes to innovation, support for young professionals, and efforts to combat exclusion. “Orange is helping to drive the ongoing transformation of Moldovan society, its economic growth, the strengthening of its democracy, and its cultural regeneration. We won’t succeed in everything we attempt right off, but we’re aiming to make practical advances with a typically Moldovan attitude, which is to do everything with all our heart and soul!” 18/05/11 19:25 Exploring the initiatives and commitments of France Telecom-Orange am ey, Paris, Port Louis, Port Vila, Rabat, Santo Domingo, Tunis, Vaduz, 13 telepresence, loud and clear… HOUSTON USA SBM Offshore is a leading group for the design, manufacture, installation and operation of oil rigs. It employs a workforce of 5,150 in 15 countries, eight of which are connected by telepresence thanks to Orange Business Services. Perry Romere, Operations Project Support Director at SBM Houston, has the details. “We have offices all over the world and personnel from 55 different nationalities, so when we wanted to step up cooperation 12,000 hours of travel saved annually 1,000 metric tons of CO 2 between our people in Houston, Monaco, Kuala Lumpur, and Schiedam, joining the telepresence community was a no-brainer,” says Perry Romere. “With our network, which allows us to hold meetings in near real-life conditions thanks to ultra-high-definition images, spatialised audio, and stable, broadband communications, we can cooperate 100%, even from 10,000km away, and avoid a huge amount of travel into the bargain! What’s more, we understand each other emissions avoided better than when using conventional video or audio resources. We all speak English, but accents are sometimes very different, so it helps that we can actually see each other. In short, it’s not only a technologically impressive solution, it’s definitely the way forward! It means fewer CO2 emissions, more quality time with our families, and greater safety for personnel. The benefits of telepresence are simultaneously environmental, social, and economic.” 6.6 million km not travelled 14 months investment payback period KRAKÓW POLAND year-on-year, CSR is steadily gaining ground in Polish mindsets An interview with Mirella Panek-Owsiańska, Chairman of the Responsible Business Forum, Poland’s leading NGO promoting CSR. Are there any specifically Polish issues concerning CSR? Mirella Panek-Owsiańska: It must be said that awareness levels among Polish firms and consumers still lag behind what you see in Western Europe, for example. But things are changing. Although economic growth rather than the debate on its impact on society is still the overriding priority, our annual survey of over 500 key decision-makers shows a growing interest in CSR with each year that passes. Today, in fact, expectations are higher as regards social rather than environmental issues, but that’s partly the outcome of having a largely coal-dependent economy. How does your organisation work to promote CSR? M. P.-O.: Our Forum was set up eleven years ago and since then it has forged 39 strategic partnerships with businesses – mainly international groups. We are a platform for cross-sectoral debate with a remit to provide CSR expertise, to inform people, and to encourage sharing of best practice and developing knowledge, notably by publishing our own survey findings or supporting academic research programmes. What is your assessment of TP Group’s work in this area? M. P.-O.: TP Group is clearly a leader in the CSR arena in Poland, and one of the first companies to build a CSR framework into its strategy. We’ve worked with TP for the past five years, and it’s an important partnership for us. Because of its size and nationwide presence, TP’s initiatives concern large swathes of Polish citizens. We have also saluted its efforts to cut its network and information system energy consumption. Other important partners in the Forum, such as Coca-Cola, Ikea and L’Oréal, have already shown an interest in aspects of this “Green IT” programme. What upcoming challenges are you likely to face? M. P.-O.: We intend to continue and step up our efforts. Now that the big groups have made considerable progress on these issues, our main focus will now be on broadening the target of our action by relaying our messages more energetically among SMEs and forging ties with consumer bodies. TP GROUP IN TOP THREE FOR CSR AWARD TP took the third place in the 2011 ranking of Responsible Companies in Poland (based on their activity in 2010), and the first place in the “telecommunications, technology, media and entertainment” category. This ranking is established every year by the daily newspaper Gazeta Prawna, the Koźminski University and the Responsible Business Forum. Its results are audited by the advisory company PricewatehouseCoopers. FTEL_1104278_MAGAZINE_RSE-GB.indd 13 18/05/11 19:25 june 2011 / initiatives 14 Warsaw, Yerevan, Yaoundé, Abidjan, Amman, Antananarivo, Bamako, Ba ng PETRZALKA SLOVAKIA Noemi, 12 years old “I’ve learned quite a lot of interesting things; from now on, I think I’ll stop giving out my number to so many people.” Rado Jancula, head teacher “Guiding the young toward a responsible use of technology is a long-distance run and cannot be achieved without the participation of parents. This project has enabled us to involve entire families in the learning process, which is extremely important.” Zuzana Markusova, parent “I appreciate the initiative very much. We parents demand that teachers watch over our children to make sure that they don’t visit inappropriate websites, yet we often forget we are responsible in the first place. My thanks and compliments to all organisers for opening our eyes!” FTEL_1104278_MAGAZINE_RSE-GB.indd 14 teaching responsibility in a digital world Thanks to advances in computer and telecommunication technology, our kids are provided with extraordinary opportunities; however, they are often unaware of the risks constantly lurking online. In recent years, Orange Slovakia has been joining in the international efforts towards child protection against harmful content, and is doing so in a rather unusual way. Except for its inspiring name, Narnia seems to be a school like any other. Situated in Bratislava’s notorious “concrete jungle”, Petrzalka, it welcomes the visitor with an inconspicuous facade, behind which pupils are swarming in and out of classrooms. A boy not older than 9 or 10 is tapping the keys of his mobile just under a sign reading “free Wi-Fi zone”. “In Slovakia, some 90 percent of children use the Internet and mobile phones every day, but school curricula still do not include courses raising awareness on risks associated with modern technology,” says psychologist Maria Tothova-Simcakova, who is responsible for the “Children and Mobile Telecommunications” project funded entirely by Orange Slovakia. Launched in 2006, the nationwide initiative is aimed at filling this gap and helping today’s e-generation recognise and avoid dangerous, inappropriate or unlawful behaviour such as phone and on line harassment, abusive emergency calls, or privacy violation. A team of ten psychologists annually visit around 300 schools throughout Slovakia, and conduct a series of 45-minute courses meant for children aged between 7 and 16, thus reaching over 10,000 pupils a year. As a framework for these courses, the experts have designed various experiential, gamebased resources, learning activities and training tools to engage curiosity and encourage discussion – from colouring books for the youngest to awareness key-chains for their older peers. In addition, they have created an educational website (www.oskole.sk) as well as a comprehensive guide for educators and parents. “In fact, while we were working on the project, we found out that most parents have no clue how much time their children spend online and what kind of websites they visit; yet it is imperative that adults be informed on the importance of Internet safety, otherwise they cannot help their children navigate through the digital world in a responsible way,” explains Tothova-Simcakova, adding that this inspired the team to expand the project and start giving extra lectures for adults. The courses are available to all elementary schools upon a simple request. At Narnia, almost all pupils and parents have already attended at least one lecture. And it is no wonder the initiative attracts so many participants: the lessons are lively, interactive and fun. The discussion at Narnia is revealing: a 12-yearold boy says it has been the seventh time that his mobile was confiscated by a teacher after it rang in the middle of a class; several children admit to have downloaded a paper or an essay from the Internet; and it turns out that not a single pupil is without a Facebook account. “This is supposed to be an open forum for children to express their experience,” remarks Tothova-Simcakova, “and, even more importantly, for us to get to listen to them and hear their needs. With each lecture, we gain a clearer idea of how to best equip these little cybercitizens for future challenges.” 18/05/11 19:25 Exploring the initiatives and commitments of France Telecom-Orange Ba ngui, Bern, Bissau, Bratislava, Brussels, Bucharest, Cairo, Chisinau, 15 VILLABÉ FRANCE Gilles to Mélissa: handing on the flame Today an account manager in Massy, near Paris, Melissa Fofana travelled the apprenticeship route to learn the ropes as a customer service engineer, working with Gilles Gaillard, her enthusiastic mentor. Although Melissa have now taken wing at Orange, she is more than happy to turn back the clocks alongside her one-time mentor Gilles Gaillard for this article. When you see how the two of them just click together, it’s easy to understand that they very quickly found themselves on the same wavelength. “We hit it off right from day one,” says Melissa, straight off. “He took me under his wing and taught me all the ins-and-outs of the engineer’s job.” A twinkle in his eye, Gilles notes that “Melissa was very determined and a good listener. But the mutual understanding and two-way communication we established also gave me a lot of satisfaction. It’s a real treat to see someone growing because of the knowledge you have passed on to them.” THE QUEST FOR EXPERIENCE Melissa’s first steps as an apprentice date back to 2005. At that time, she was in a science track in a French Lycée, but was actually hankering after learning a job. “I wasn’t in any particular difficulty at school, but I’d got bored with the lessons,” she says. “Also, I had realised early on that businesses were looking for people with qualifications and experience. After enrolling in an apprenticeship centre, she also – as a long shot – applied to Orange, and was hired by the Villabé customer service unit. a customer service engineer. “Because I’m a fairly outgoing person, I love this job,” explains Gilles, “because it brings me into face-to-face contact with customers.” That attitude makes him something of a go-getter, so that he’s often entrusted with young apprentices. Gilles says that passing on knowledge is essential to preserve the character of the job he loves. “Of course,” he says, “you have to be good at the technical side to solve your customers’ problems, but that’s not enough. There’s a knack to dealing with customers, which is hard to pin down, but which can only be learned by doing. That’s what I tried to pass on to Melissa, too.” LEARNING A JOB “At Orange, I felt that people wanted me to learn a job and to create the conditions for getting a qualification,” adds Mélissa. “From a personal viewpoint, that experience allowed me to forge real friendships with people who are very professional and very human at one and the same time. Even if I work 20km away today, I regularly come back and lunch with Gilles and the gang.” So it’s win-win all round: as an excellent way of entering the workforce for young people like Melissa, apprenticeships also mean that a company like Orange can perpetuate the knowhow of experienced workers like Gilles. LEARNING BY DOING Gilles was there to welcome her. After joining France Telecom in 1978, he held several positions before settling down as FTEL_1104278_MAGAZINE_RSE-GB.indd 15 18/05/11 19:25 june 2011 / initiatives 16 Conakry, Dakar, Gaborone, Kampala, Lisbon, London, Luxembourg, Ma dr FRANCE – BELGIUM a second life for mobile phones! Eight billion mobile phones have been manufactured worldwide, but only 5 billion of them are currently in use. What happened to the other 3 billion? Usually they get thrown away or lie forgotten in a drawer somewhere. Only 5% of them are actually collected – an unsustainable situation that Orange France has decided to tackle head-on. From the management of natural resources via the recovery of rare and precious metals in a full-fledged “urban mine”, to the creation of community projects (involving, eg, the organization of collection channels and reconditioning workshops), the collection of used mobile phones generates real sustainable and societal benefits, as we show below. 1. A COLLECTION BOX IN AN ORANGE SHOP It all begins with collection. In France, some 2,000 collection points have been installed in Orange network points of sale. These brought in 400,000 mobile phones in 2010, and a target of 600,000 has been set for 2011. Taking your end-of-life mobile phone to a collection point is straightforward and is gradually starting to become a reflex… 2. WELCOME TO THE ATELIERS DU BOCAGE, IN DEUX-SÈVRES, WESTERN FRANCE. Used handsets are now taken to this company, a social reintegration company which is part of the Emmaüs International network and the Group’s partner in collecting and recycling used mobile phones. The workshop has a staff of 69, which includes people on government work schemes, social integration contracts, and long-term employment contracts. Within the next twelve months, it has plans to increase the workforce to 100. Emmaüs International partnering with Orange has also set up similar organisations in three African countries: Burkina Faso, Benin and Madagascar. 3. INITIAL SORTING 4. TESTING THE HANDSETS 5. BACK ON SALE During the first sort of incoming mobiles, they undergo a visual check and the condition of the keypad and connectors, etc. is also checked. Mobiles in working order and not yet obsolete are set aside for reconditioning. This concerns about 20% of the mobiles collected. Mobiles suitable for a second life are tested and retested: personal data are deleted and all the functions are carefully checked, as are the batteries. The result is a pre-owned mobile that’s as good as new. These will go back on sale in France and in emerging countries, allowing new users to own a phone at a lower price. The proceeds from this operation are donated in full to voluntary-sector associations working with the Ateliers du Bocage. Hand in 100,000 mobile phones in France, and you can set up a workshop employing five people in Africa. And 12,000 phones handed in can help get someone in France back into work. FTEL_1104278_MAGAZINE_RSE-GB.indd 16 18/05/11 19:25 Exploring the initiatives and commitments of France Telecom-Orange Ma drid, Malabo, Manama, Nairobi, Niamey, Paris, Port Louis, Port Vila, Rabat, 17 MADRID SPAIN mobile essentials While the younger generation tends to adapt naturally to new technology, older people sometimes find it hard to keep up. Unless, that is, like Ines Rivera, they benefit from a specially-designed offer. At 69, this Madrid retiree opted for the Orange Esencial offer dedicated to seniors. Her feedback is very positive. Why did you choose the Esencial plan? I’m not very comfortable with all this new technology. I’ve had a mobile phone for years, but these new ones seem too complicated for me. I suppose they come with a lot of bells and whistles, but all I really need it for is to make and receive calls. So my daughter told me about Esencial, telling me it was a very simple phone and that it also had an emergency call button that could be very useful for me. As she knows more about this than I do, I trusted her.... What are your first impressions? When I first saw the handset, I was a bit worried. You have to admit that its design isn’t as spectacular as that of other phones. Yet when I took hold of it, I immediately noticed the large keyboard, the sound of the ringtone, the call light, and especially the emergency call button! To cut a long story short, it’s child’s play, actually. The plan also suits me down to the ground. Perhaps I don’t use the texting function enough, but I’m not very comfortable with it and I prefer voice calls, anyway. 6. DECOMMISSIONED HANDSETS Mobiles that don’t work and can’t be reconditioned are sent to Antwerp, Belgium, to the “urban mine” operated by Umicore. The recycling and recovery facility handles 350,000 metric tons of waste electrical and electronic equipment (WEEE: motherboards, mobiles, computer chips) sent there from all over the world. 7. SORTING AND PROCESSING The WEEE is crushed, riddled, sorted and processed on a site covering several hectares, in complete compliance with environmental requirements. All fumes emitted are scrubbed, for example. Have you changed the way you generally use the telephone? No, not really. But now, when it rings, I can hear it, and for personal safety reasons, I’m never without it. So I’m very reassured, and so are my family and friends. 8. RECOVERING THE RARE METALS To isolate and recover the rare and precious metals they contain (gold, copper, palladium, silver, rhodium, etc.), the WEEE undergoes a long and complex process lasting around 3 months and involving various furnaces and electrolysis baths. A mobile contains small amounts of up to 17 such metals, the supply of which is not inexhaustible. We know, for example, that at current rates of extraction, we will have used up all the nickel on earth within half a century. CONVICTION Involving the recycling of precious metals and the management of rare resources, helping to get people back into work, creating solidarity networks, and making affordable handsets available to disadvantaged people, the collection, sorting, reconditioning and breakdown of used mobile phones creates a virtuous circle that is an integral part of sustainable development. FTEL_1104278_MAGAZINE_RSE-GB.indd 17 18/05/11 19:25 june 2011 / initiatives 18 cross-currents Combating global warming calls for a global approach towards our customers and towards society at large.” Marc Fossier On 8 April 2011, at the Paris headquarters of the France Telecom Orange Group, Executive Vice President, CSR, Marc Fossier, invited two experts to discuss energy and the impact of telecommunications on climate change. These were Jean-Marc Jancovici, an engineer and a co-founder of the Carbone 4 consultancy who has authored pioneering research on global warming; and Cristina Bueti, climate change and ICT programme coordinator at the International Telecommunications Union. Below are Excerpts from a lively discussion on the challenges facing us, moderated by journalist Denis Cheissoux, an expert in the natural world and environmental issues, and among other things anchor of the France Inter radio programme, CO2 mon amour. View the e video of th on discussion orange.com Denis Cheissoux: The expressions “global warming” and “greenhouse effect” entered our vocabulary about a decade ago, even if the problem itself goes back further. What would become of our lives and our planet if we didn’t do anything about these today? Jean-Marc Jancovici: We would first be confronted with an energy abundance problem, notably in the economic regions which import the lion’s share of their energy (as is the case in Europe) followed by a major climate-change problem. At the outset, the problems would be the same as those we have been experiencing since 2007, in other words, a series of increasingly severe economic crises and, when the atmosphere had absorbed a sufficient amount of CO2, a bigger climate change than what we are seeing today, far exceeding the means that we will have to cope with it. To ensure that the climate change problem is largely cushioned, we reckon that we will need to divide global CO2 emissions by three by 2050. If we want to achieve a fair global distribution of the effort, among, say, the populations of India, Vietnam, Bangladesh, Brazil or Mongolia, we will need to cut our emissions in France by a factor of four or five. FTEL_1104278_MAGAZINE_RSE-GB.indd 18 Denis Cheissoux: You might say, Marc Fossier, that historically speaking, climate change isn’t really your business. In this respect, we think first of cement works and energy generation, and not necessarily of telecoms. So why are you taking an interest in this topic? Marc Fossier: You’re right. For decades, information and communication technologies were considered to be a “clean” sector. The playing field of a group like France Telecom Orange is information, a field that at first sight seems light-years from energy issues. Let me give you a few figures to set the scene. In 2010, the Group’s total energy consumption amounted to just over 4,000 GWh an average power of a few hundred megawatts a day, the equivalent of a small electricity-generating plant. When we look at our greenhouse gas emissions, we find a total of 1.5 million metric tons of CO2 generated by the Group as a whole (which, I would point out, operates in 35 countries worldwide). But if we divide that figure by the number of our customers – just over 200 million – it comes to just 7.7kg of CO2 generated per customer per year, or the equivalent of the amount generated during a 60km ride in a car emitting 130g of CO2 per km. 18/05/11 19:25 Exploring the initiatives and commitments of France Telecom-Orange 19 Denis Cheissoux: That doesn’t seem a lot, but with the huge surge in data traffic, surely that figure is bound to increase ineluctably? To ensure that the climate change problem is largely cushioned, we reckon that we will need to divide global CO2 emissions by three by 2050.” Jean-Marc Jancovici Marc Fossier: You’re quite right, and it’s the outcome of an automatic process: our energy consumption is growing simply because telecoms are playing an increasingly important role in society. In practice, data traffic in our networks is almost doubling every year. With such a huge increase in the volumes of data carried, our electricity consumption is going through the roof.… The vast majority of our energy needs is covered by electricity, rather than by fossil fuels. So we have a duty and a responsibility to cut our electricity consumption, and it’s not that easy. Denis Cheissoux: Jean-Marc Jancovici, I don’t know if you’ve ever visited a data centre, but to simplify things, they generate heat and they have to be cooled down. Presumably, that consumes a lot of energy… Jean-Marc Jancovici: When you look at the energy question in a data centre, you have to take several contributing factors into account. The first, and not necessarily the most obvious, is the energy used to manufacture the equipment. Building the servers themselves burns a lot of energy. And they also gobble it up when they are working. And because such hardware contains a great deal of electronics, the electricity used to operate the components generates heat through the Joule effect. Unless that heat is evacuated the server will heat up and stop working properly. That calls for more electricity to ensure that the system stays at an acceptable temperature. Denis Cheissoux: Can we hope for any improvements in this respect? Marc Fossier: Orange has made a lot of progress in this area both as regards its own consumption and that of its customers. I’m talking about a process known as server “virtualisation”, where the computer programs are dissociated from the machines operating them. It allows us to get the most out of our computers. With the increasing volumes of data carried, electricity consumption is rocketing. Our role, our responsibility, is to minimize it.” Marc Fossier Denis Cheissoux: Cristina Bueti, you are right at the heart of standardisation. What role does your institute play? Cristina Bueti: The ITU is helping to work towards a “climate neutral” ICT industry in three ways: by cutting the sector’s energy needs, by encouraging the use of ICT to minimise travel and so cut CO2 emissions, and by fostering the use of ICT to cut emissions in other sectors. FTEL_1104278_MAGAZINE_RSE-GB.indd 19 18/05/11 19:25 june 2011 / initiatives 20 cross-currents We provide a forum where our 192 Member States and 700 privatesector representatives can talk and develop specific technical standards for telecoms equipment. We are also developing methods to evaluate the energy consumption of telecoms equipment and how it is being reduced.… The switch to Next Generation Networks (NGN), launched by the ITU, will contribute to cutting the energy needs of ICTs by 40%, as telcos will need fewer switching centres. Denis Cheissoux: That means investment, I suppose… Cristina Bueti: It’s vital, of course, that both industry and governments invest and put legislation in place that is bound to improve the present situation. It’s important for businesses, but it’s also important for end-consumers…. We’re also developing evaluation methods to create reliable key performance indicators so that we can compare different companies. Denis Cheissoux: Is that where the main weakness lies today? Cristina Bueti: It’s true that it’s really difficult to compare consumption from one business to another.… For the time being, we have estimates of ICT consumption, but they are only estimates. We’re not yet in a position to calculate accurately what an industry or company actually consumes. Denis Cheissoux: Marc Fossier, in these first decades of the 21st century, how do you manage to reconcile the need to cut energy consumption and the exponential rise in data traffic? Isn’t it like trying to square the circle? Marc Fossier: It’s a requirement our engineers and strategists have to deal with on a daily basis. It’s quite true that our data traffic is increasing exponentially, but fortunately, technology is making great strides in the other direction. We continually have to resolve economic and strategic equations, and we do that through our daily efforts to optimise what we do – something that is essential in a complex Group like ours. We have a workforce of 170,000, remember, and tens of thousands of technical facilities. By optimising the air conditioning temperature in a datacenter, we can save a few precious KWh… The deployment of innovative technologies also plays a driving role. Last, we can also decide on the optimum time to replace the most energy-greedy equipment with equipment that is more state-of-the-art. People are individually responsible for their own emissions, wherever they are on Earth, and regardless of the cause of the emissions.” Jean-Marc Jancovici Denis Cheissoux: So, what do you do to factor energy issues into the running of a Group like France Telecom-Orange? Marc Fossier: When I look at what I do, day-to-day, I would say that my role is to get people to change the way they see these issues, and encourage senior management to see them from a corporate social and environmental responsibility angle. We carried out a carbon audit in 2010, for example, and we took a close look at some complex investment processes in this respect – thinking about the issues and risks involved and the decisions to be taken over the long term in a business that’s changing very rapidly. This calls for a highly complex strategic planning exercise and requires us to model our energy consumption in an uncertain environment out to 2015, and even out to 2020. Obviously, a telecommunications company has to take the long view. It’s our business to plan and deploy the infrastructure of the future, and so to know how our networks are going to be deployed and used. It’s a thought process that interacts at a very deep level with our investment and technology processes – in other words, we are asking “what investment for which type of equipment, and when,” in an environment where it’s not just the cost of energy that’s a very fast moving target, but also customer demand. Denis Cheissoux: Jean-Marc Jancovici, what advice would you give an International Group like France Telecom Orange…? What do you need to do to have a good road map? Jean-Marc Jancovici: It’s simultaneously very simple and very complicated. You could say the basic rule is that an activity generates less carbon if it is forced to do so by a more restrictive environment, in relative terms, at least. It’s much easier to say than to do, because then you have to try to develop reliable forecasting methods and forecasts that allow you to predict the various scenarios. When I say “in relative terms at least,” what I mean is that it’s going to be hard to avoid multiple recessions, given the dithering you see before the energy/climate issue is tackled head-on. I think that we have to expect a number of recessions over the next 10-20 years that will obviously impact the economic climate and which will act as a big stick for some activities, which will resist better than others. Denis Cheissoux: Marc Fossier, you also help your customers to make savings, with videoconferencing, for example, which reduces the need for travel and for expensive trips. That’s part of your job, too, isn’t it? Marc Fossier: This is the third main component on our combat against climate change. The first involves curbing our own consumption, and it isn’t easy. The second is controlling the electricity consumption of the equipment we supply to our customers – those broadband “boxes”. We are also trying to see how we can contribute to combating global warming and greenhouse gas emissions vis-à-vis both our customers and society in general. I could cite a number of broad-based areas where we can have an impact, such as workflow and teleworking using techniques like telepresence, videoconferencing or remote access to corporate information systems, and so on. Denis Cheissoux: What gives you grounds for optimism, Cristina Bueti, and what are the current and future drivers in this sector that you can see developing from an international perspective? Cristina Bueti: I believe that it is certain that companies and governments in both the industrialised and emerging countries have embarked on a virtuous trend. We are still hopeful that it will grow and grow. At global level, we also place great store by negotiations, designed to help governments understand the importance of environmental issues in their policies. But we also hope that companies like France Telecom Orange and others will continue their efforts and their commitment to standardisation efforts, and to efforts to raise awareness and change attitudes. It’s important to pave the way for changing behaviour and creating a new paradigm that can completely change things. FTEL_1104278_MAGAZINE_RSE-GB.indd 20 18/05/11 19:25 Exploring the initiatives and commitments of France Telecom-Orange 21 Denis Cheissoux: Jean-Marc Jancovici, why is global warming THE major issue facing all of humanity in the 21st century? Jean-Marc Jancovici: In fact, climate change is not the only big issue facing humankind. More generally, we are getting closer and closer to the “edge of the dish”. When you put a colony of bacteria in a Petri dish, at first, the dish is very, very big and the colony is very small, so it can grow and grow. But when the colony starts to get closer to the sides of the dish, it starts thinking about its future, and the possibilities open to it. When it comes to humankind, the situation is identical: the changes that we are inflicting on our environment have become so major that we can no longer see them as negligible, like we did before. We now run the risk of sabotaging the very basis on which have built our social and economic activities and our prosperity. ICTs can pave the way for a completely new generation of products using very little energy and for the development of pioneering strategies that will lead to energy savings” Cristina Bueti Denis Cheissoux: Which leads us to the question: what climate do we want for tomorrow? Does this mean that we have become joint managers of the climate? Jean-Marc Jancovici: Yes, it does. We can only think about the climate or energy from angles that are highly transverse and hence applicable to all areas. The impact on the global climate of one ton of greenhouse gas emissions is totally independent of where the emissions are generated. So their transverse nature lies in the consequences. People are individually responsible for their own emissions, wherever they are on Earth, and regardless of the cause of the emissions. In the energy sphere, the transverse nature stems from the fact that all economic activity involves transformation. Telecommunications activity exists because minerals can be transformed into hardware, coal into electricity, or the sound of a voice into electrical pulses. All economic activity therefore requires energy to subsist: energy is the transverse mark of change that can be applied in any area and in any economic activity. If we place limitations on energy, we create a duty of responsibility and action on all economic activity of whatever type. In the 21st century, the crux of the problem will shift. In addition to the pressure created by the depletion of natural resources, we will also need to manage critical environmental situations. Once again, the energy-climate tandem is the most emblematic of the great challenges awaiting us and which have, unfortunately, already begun to affect us. There are plenty of others, but this one stands out simultaneously for its scale and its all-embracing character. FTEL_1104278_MAGAZINE_RSE-GB.indd 21 View the e video of th on discussion orange.com 18/05/11 19:25 june 2011 / initiatives 22 Orange and CSR Covering its principles, main components and key figures, below is an overview of the France TelecomOrange CSR commitments, which are set out in greater detail in our annual CSR report. our ambition In 2009, Orange ratcheted up its long-standing commitment by setting itself the ambitious target of becoming the “CSR Leader” in the telecoms sector. That ambition corresponds to our profound conviction that Corporate Social Responsibility helps drive valuecreation both for the Group and all its stakeholders. The new Conquests 2015 strategic plan, unveiled in July 2010, confirms the central role of the CSR programme, which sits at the heart of the Group’s new strategy. Main thrusts The France Telecom Orange CSR programme is built around four fundamental commitments. The first of these consists in recognising and supporting our people. The second concerns the Group’s customers, towards whom we have to meet transparency, quality, and security requirements. Fostering access to the benefits of the digital world for the greatest number of people, and finding innovative solutions for a greener world, round out the list of Group commitments. We have identified our strategic CSR priorities on the basis of two com- plementary factors: an analysis of stakeholder expectations, and the identification of the risks and opportunities of sustainability. The prioritisation is updated at least once a year to take the changing context into account. Each priority is broken down into specific targets, with its own key performance indicators. Our commitment to respect for persons France Telecom Orange was one of the first corporations to sign up to the United Nations Global Compact in 2000, highlighting our commitment to respecting and promoting fundamental human rights in our activities and sphere of influence. Respect for the basic principles set out in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and by the International Labour Organization (ILO) is explicitly enshrined in our Code of Ethics. In 2006, France Telecom gave its commitment a whole new dimension in signing a global agreement on fundamental labour rights within t h e G ro u p w i t h U n i o n N e t w o r k International (UNI). Through this agreement, France Telecom strongly asserted its resolve to respect funda- mental human rights both within the Group and in its relations with its suppliers and sub-contractors. Implementing these commitments is a complex process, progressively implemented in our countries around the world according to the local context and in compliance with national sovereignty requirements. To ensure further progress, France Telecom Orange is relying on its commitment to two-way dialogue with stakeholders to identify the priority issues in each country and implement appropriate initiatives. corporate governance The Group’s Corporate Social R e s p o n s i b i l i t y p ro g r a m m e i s steered by the CSR Division, which reports to the Executive Committee. Its director is a member of the top management team. Dedicated structures To ensure effective steering of the action in each entity, a group of CSR Sponsors reporting to senior management have been appointed in each Group function and entity operating on all the markets addressed by the Group. They meet six times a year in the CSR Sponsors Committee to ascertain that the strategic choices agreed by the Executive Committee are being implemented. A network of CSR managers contributes to the programme’s operational deployment. In 2010, to step up the pace of integration of CSR issues in subsidiary decision-making processes, CSR Committees were organised in Senegal, Poland, Spain, and Romania. An ethical foundation As long ago as 2003, France Telecom’s Board of Directors adopted a Group code of ethics. Circulated to all staff worldwide, the code can be accessed at www.orange.com. It details the Group’s core values and sets out the principles guiding its relationship with customers, shareholders, employees, suppliers and competitors, as well as its attitude towards the environment and the countries where it operates. It also mentions a number of behavioural guidelines with which each staff member, director and senior executive are required to comply. CSR organization within France Telecom Orange Executive Committee CSR Group Division Entities Country CSR Committee CSR Sponsor Committee (6/yr) CSR Sponsor CEO or direct report CSR Sponsor Executive director or direct report Operational CSR Committee (6/yr) CSR Manager CSR Manager Project managers for each area Clear principles France Telecom Orange complies with corporate governance principles, and notably those set out in France’s Financial Security Act and the US Sarbanes-Oxley Act. The Group Group Functions work as a network Project managers for each area is especially vigilant as regards the responsibility and integrity of its senior management and Board members, the independence of Board members, the transparency and disclosure of infor- mation, respect for shareholder rights, and the Group’s code of ethics. The Group’s corporate governance is structured by the Board of Directors and its specialised committees: Audit Committee, Corporate and Corporate Social Responsibility Committee, and Strategic Committee. Dialogue at several levels A toolkit for the countries As a corporation with numerous locations, we maintain discussions with our stakeholders at Group and business-line level as well as at country level, where contact with local issues and players is more immediate. While the three biggest countries – France, Spain and Poland – have set up their own mechanisms for interfacing with stakeholders, we now have a methodological aid to help countries that do not yet have a structured process for their contacts with stakeholders. Dubbed “CSR Dialog Toolkit”, it showcases the CSR initiatives already launched by the subsidiaries and enhances their impact by including the perceptions and expectations of the main stakeholders at local level, contributing to the deployment of our CSR strategy by providing a common framework guaranteeing that our action is consistent from country to country. relations with stakeholders Being attentive to stakeholder expectations and building them into our everyday practice are central planks of our CSR policy. Several aims are pursued in our regular discussions with the agents concerned by the workings of the Group (staff, customers, shareholders, the public authorities, civil society, etc.). The discussions are designed to ensure that Group CSR projects are consistent with stakeholder priorities, and map FTEL_1104278_MAGAZINE_RSE-GB.indd 22 the risks and opportunities relative to societal issues and the needs of the countries where we operate. They are also a means of identifying innovation opportunities leading to new growth prospects, at the same time as they help drive the economic and social development of those countries. For stakeholders, these discussions are an opportunity to put forward their expectations as part of an ongoing, long-term process. 23/05/11 14:21 Exploring the initiatives and commitments of France Telecom-Orange 23 our activities our turnover France Telecom-Orange is one of the world’s leading telecommunication operator. Under the Orange brand-name it markets and distributes fixed line telephony, internet, television and mobile services. The Group is also a global leader in telecommunications services for multinational companies, trading as Orange Business Services. In 2010, the France Telecom-Orange Group generated 45.503 billion euros in turnover from its activities. our customers France Telecom Orange had close to 210 million customers worldwide as at 31 December 2010. Some 150 million of these are customers for mobile products and services, while 13.7 million are broadband customers. our global footprint Business services in 220 countries and territories. Consumer and small business activities in 35 countries : Armenia, Austria, Bahrein, Belgium, Botswana, Cameroon, Central African Republic, Dominican Republic, Egypt, Equatorial Guinea, France, Jordan, Kenya, Liechtenstein, Luxembourg, Madagascar, Mali, Marocco, Mauritius, Moldova, Niger, Poland, Portugal, Republic of Côte d’Ivoire, Spain, Romania, Senegal, Slovakia, Switzerland, Tunisia, Uganda, United Kingdom, Vanuatu. breakdown of number of customers in millions 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 fixed line internet mobile 10 our people France Telecom-Orange employs a workforce of almost 170,000 worldwide. rest of the world 23.3% France 60.1% Spain 1.9% rest of the world Madagascar Rép. Côte d'Ivoire by country 60.1% 16.4% 9,6 % by region Egypt our CO2 emissions by source workforce distribution Jordania Senegal Dominican Republic Slovakia Switzerland Romania Spain Belgium 170,000 Poland France 0 the proportion of France TelecomOrange global emissions generated by network infrastructure and datacenters. of CO2 emissions are generated by Group buildings using domestic heating oil, gas or coal-fired energy sources. The figure for premises powered by electricity is 10.3%. of CO2 emissions are generated by the Group’s fleet of vehicles. Travel on business by air or rail accounts for 3.6% of atmospheric CO2 emissions. 30% of CO2 emissions are generated by Group activity in Poland, a country heavily depended on coal in its energy mix. 20% of emissions are generated in France. Spain generates 8% of France TelecomOrange’s global CO2 emissions. The rest of the world accounts for 42% of the total figure. Poland 14.7% % of female in the Group The Group has set gender equality as a priority amid its wider policy in favor of equal opportunities for all. Its ambitious goal is to employ at least 35% of women among the Group’s governing bodies by 2015, in line with the average percentage of women among the Group’s workforce. France our CSR priorities commitments recognize and support employees Poland Spain OBS International (Equant) Belgium ensure transparency, quality, security and safety for our customers Romania Switzerland Slovakia Dominican Rep. Senegal Make the benefits of the digital world accessible to as many as possible Ivory Coast Kenya Madagascar priorities • Place people at the heart of the company through a new social contract to support employees in their development and meet corporate and societal challenges, particularly in respect of equal opportunity objectives & kpis • % of women on management committees • Social barometer • Lead the way in service quality with our European activities • Promote and ensure safe and responsible use of products and services, particularly with regard to protecting children, respecting privacy and data security • Promote the economic and social development of countries in which the Group operates, through its services • Strengthen and extend the Group’s leadership in accessibility offerings and their specialized distribution • average percentage of recommendations reported by the Customer Experience Tracker • Payment times for local suppliers in the AMEA zone (under construction) Egypt Jordania Rest of the World Total Group 0 10 % of women among the global workforce FTEL_1104278_MAGAZINE_RSE-GB.indd 23 20 30 40 50 % of women among managers and top managers 60 find innovative solutions for a new and greener world • Bring eco-designed products and services to market, and help to reduce customers’ environmental footprint through the Group’s offerings • Play a significant role in the collection and recycling of mobile handsets • Manage the Group’s energy consumption to decrease its CO2 emissions by 20% by 2020 • Turnover of offers contributing to a reduction in the environmental impact of our customers. • Rate of mobiles collected in comparison to the number sold by Orange. • Total energy consumption of the Group. 20/05/11 14:53 FTEL_1104278_MAGAZINE_RSE-GB.indd 24 18/05/11 19:25