country music - caveinspiredmusic.com
Transcription
country music - caveinspiredmusic.com
caveinspiredmusic.com COUNTRY MUSIC Introduction This is a rich category of down to earth music inspired by caves, ranging from simple cave ballads to death and murder ballads, nearly all connoting that real country feeling so familiar to American cavers who drive to those countryside caves while listening to country music on their car radios. The numerous versions of Clement's "Milller's Cave" illustrate the growing trends in country music throughout the 1960s where producers were willing to try anything that would give the music a broader and more commercial appeal. These entries take up 23 pages, so “Miller’s Cave” has been listed separately and split into two sections: 1960 to 1970 and 1970 to 2004. The Violent Femmes bit hit, “Country Death Song” has also been listed separately here. The original studio version in 1984 was followed by at least four live recorded versions by them right up to 2002. Four country songs listed below were inspired by real caves: Hiawatha Caverns in Minnesota, Blanchard Springs Caverns in Arkansas, Mammoth Cave in Kentucky, and Nickajack Cave in Tennessee. “Dead Man’s Cave” may well have been influenced by a real cave legend but this was not possible to ascertain. Two songs had more than one version recorded: “The Cave” written by Larry Kingston and “Cave Man” by Chris Smither. _____________________________________ CY1 United Kingdom 1965 AN AMERICAN SAILOR AT THE CAVERN CY – Rock – Vocal & Instrumental Comp: Tim McCOY & Tom MURRY Perf: THE RANCHERS Phil Brady (vocal) Frank Peters (steel guitar) Rec. Co: Cavern Sound Ltd.; Liverpool Time: 2:18 Label: C.S.T.(Cavern Sound Ltd.) IMSTL 2A Flip Sd: Sidetracked Spec: 7" 45rpm Notes: A native of Liverpool, Phil “Brady learned about country music from the seamen returning from the USA. Encouraged by Hank Walters’ Black Cat club, he formed his own band, the Ranchers, in 1962, including Frank Peters on steel guitar, and they built a reputation in the north-west despite the fierce competition from beat music.” in the Liverpool area. (Rovi 2013) The Cavern Sound Recording Studio was installed in Feb. 1964 to provide demo recording facilities for local groups. The Ranchers only played once at the Cavern in 1965 on March 12, so this was not doubt the date of this recording or maybe it was recorded in the studio. (Thompson 1994) “Because the Cavern went into liquidation, most copies [of this 45] went to the official receiver, and it is the UK’s most collectable British country single.” (Rovi 2013) As for the songwriters, we are told that former seaman Tim McCoy “wrote the number with the aid of an old shipmate called Tom Murray, a guitar and a tape recorder. Tim didn't know what to do with his number till he was passing a youth club in Park Place. He heard a group playing [a Toxteth group called the Jackals], looked in and offered them the title he’s written and now they feature it in their act. And the title: 'The Sailor At the Cavern', and it is about a seaman who jumps his ship in Liverpool, goes to the 'Cave' and meets all the people who are just not around anymore.” (Harry 2013) When The Ranchers recorded it the title was modified. This is definately a country & western song with a distinct Hawaiian influence. The second and third stanzas talk about the Cavern Club, which had originally been a jazz cellar club, then a skiffle club, and finally a rock club – 2. I went to a place called "The Cavern" last night, The best place I've ever been; Cilla Black was singing there, she's Liverpool's singing queen; I met John, George, Ringo, an' Paul, fine young fellows one an' all, An' they asked me if I was free, then why not settle by the River Mersey. A thousand miles of travel an' many ports I've roamed CHORUS: I found a place for me by the river Mersey, land of the Liverpool sound. 3. If you're ever in Liverpool an' you're passin' Mathew Street, Just drop into the Cavern an' hear that Mersey beat; Once you've heard the rhythm, you'll never want to leave. See also under Recorded in Caves – Artificial Caves – United Kingdom – The Cavern Club; & under Cave & Bat-Inspired Record Labels – Cavern-Other – Cavern Sound Ltd. Ref: Harry, Bill 2013, Behind the Scenes 1, Mersey Beat, triumphpc Phil Brady & The Ranchers, An American Sailor at The Cavern (2:18), YouTube (◄COMPLETE AUDIO SAMPLE) The Ranchers, An American Sailor at The Cavern, 45cat Rovi 2013, Phil Brady & The Ranchers, Biography, Alllmusic Thompson, Phil 1994, The Best of Cellars: The Story of the World Famous Cavern Club, Bluecoat Press, Liverpool, p. 81, 160 _____________________________________ CY2 United States 1995 BACK TO THE CAVE Country – Comedy – Vocal & Instrumental Comp: Skip EWING & Tim JOHNSON (LY-CY1) Rts: Sony Music Entertainment Inc. Perf: Joe DIFFIE (vocal & guitar) Paul Franklin (steel guitar) Stuart Dunkin (fiddle) Glenn Worf (bass) Lonnie Wilson (drums) Prod: Joe Diffie & Johnny Slate Prod. Co: Johnny Slate Productions Time: 3:59 1. Single 45: Epic 34 78333 Flip Sd: Whole Lotta Gone 7” 45rpm 2. CD: LIFE’S SO FUNNY Epic 67405 (Tk 7) 3. Reissue CD: LIFE’S SO FUNNY (2003) Sony Special Products 61178 (Tk 7) Notes: A light-hearted comic country song about doing things like they did in the days of prehistoric caveman. (See LY-CY1) The chorus spells it out – Back to the cave make a little fire A man and a woman and a primal desire That's the way it is that's the way it was Before he made the wheel, man was making love. The end of the third stanza gives things a new twist – In the time machine at the end of the hall We can be a couple of Neanderthals, Do you want to go back to the cave? This CD album reached position 28 on the U.S. Billboard Top Country Albums charts. Ref: Joe Diffie, Back to the Cave (3:57), YouTube (◄COMPLETE AUDIO SAMPLE) Joe Diffie, Back to the Cave, Lyrics, sweetslyrics Joe Diffie, Biography, Wilipedia Joe Diffie, Life’s So Funny CD, Back to the Cave, Chorus, Allmusic (◄AUDIO SAMPLE) Joe Diffie, Life’s So Funny CD, Back to the Cave, Chorus, CDUniverse (◄AUDIO SAMPLE) ________________________________ CY3 United States ca.1964 THE BALLAD OF HIAWATHA CAVERNS * CY – Ballad – Vocal & Instrumental Comp: LEE & FRITZ (LY-CY2) Mus: (Unaccredited) Andrew JENKINS Perf: LEE & FRITZ (vocal) (with accordion) Prod. Co: (?) Time: 2:12 Label: Hiawatha Caverns KB 4519 Flip Sd: Ease My Aching Heart Spec: 7” 45rpm Notes: A nice country ballad that uses almost note for note the music of Andrew Jenkins, “The Death of Floyd Collins.” The three stanzas here have the same 8-verse structure and the same rhyming scheme (see LY-CY2). Hiawatha Caverns only operated as a show cave from 1964 to 1966. Apparently there were two Hiawatha Caverns in different counties in Minnesota. This small one, in Winona County, was mapped in 1991 to a total length of 44 feet (13m) and the map shows a pool, formations, and a natural bridge. (Gerboth 1991) The photo of the entrance door dates to 2007, more than 40 years after the commercial operation was abandoned. Greg Brick, a Minnesota cave historian, provided this photo and a copy of Gerboth’s article. It is not known if other 45 records were released on this unusual label. Ref: Brick, Greg 2010, eMails dated Aug. 5 & 27, 2010 Gerboth, Dave 1991, Minnesota’s Two Hiawatha Caves, Minnesota Speleology Monthly, v. 23, n. 11, Nov. 1991, p. 101-111; Reprinted in 1991 Speleo Digest, p. 129 ________________________________ CY4 United States 1978 BLANCHARD CAVE * CY – Folk – Vocal & Instrumental – Cave Pic Cover Comp: Jimmy DRIFTWOOD (?) (LY-CY3) Perf: Jimmy DRIFTWOOD [aka. James Corbett Morris] (vocal & guitar) Ed Nickolson (guitar) Johnny Minick (bass) Timothy Green (Indian drums) Prod: Clyde Snider Prod. Co: Rackensack Records; Timbo, AR Liner Notes: (LP) Jimmy Driftwood Time: 2:34 1. LP: I HEAR YOUR PEOPLE SINGING (PC-RE-US# ) Rackensack 78836 12” 33rpm (Sd 1 – Bd 1) 2. Reissue on Anthology CD: 26 CLASSIC OZARK MOUNTAIN SONGS (2007) (Jimmy Driftwood Legacy Project) (Tk 14) Notes: A tribute to this show cave in Arkansas, called Blanchard Springs Caverns, which first opened to the public in July 1977, shortly before the release of this song on LP. Jimmy Driftwood was born in Mountain View, Arkansas, which is where this show cave is located. His parents and grandparents had a “great wealth of folk songs” and, starting in his youth, Jimmy collected many folk ballads from people in the area. (Anon. 1969) He “became involved in environmental issues when the United States Army Corps of Engineers planned to dam the Buffalo River. Driftwood worked to defeat the plan, which ultimately led to the establishment of the Buffalo National River. Driftwood played a major role in preserving Blanchard Springs Caverns, which later came under management of the United States Forest Service.” (Anon. 2005) Jimmy writes in the liner notes – “ ’The most beautiful cavern in the world is Blanchard Cave.’ That is what a man who was a world traveler said to me, and I believed him. Someday you ought to go to the natural entrance and look down in a hole that might have been made by a Greek god with an Olympian auger. Two Indian uncles took me there when I was a child. They were born in the Ozarks and moved in early life to the Indian Nation – now Oklahoma. Two long cedar trees had been dropped into the hole. One went to the bottom and the other rested on a ledge part way down. My uncles went down in the hole and stayed a long time. My dad and I stayed above ground. I seem to recall that my uncles’ trip into the underworld had something to do with religion. There is a creek in the cavern that pours out of a hillside, making Blanchard Spring. Many times I have gone as far back as one could go, to where the water came straight up like a huge spring – I could never dive down through the spring. The old timers said that when the spring issued muddy water and there had been no rain here it was a sign that the Buffalo River was muddy. They believed there were big sinks in the Buffalo which came through the Ozarks to Blanchard Spring. I have heard of people going in a cave, getting lost, and after several days coming out across the White River. Let me tell you how I came to write the song Blanchard Cave. I wrote “The Battle of New Orleans” and used it in teaching school for twenty-one years before RCA heard about it and had me record an album, Early American Folk Songs [1957]. Others recorded the song and it became a multi-million seller [Johnny Horton – 1959]. The National Forest in which Blanchard Springs is located was having a groundbreaking, June 20, 1970, for the Visitor’s Information Center, and I was asked to sing “The Battle of New Orleans.” That morning when my wife, Cleda, and I arrived at the site, a severe thunderstorm struck. As we sat in the car, surrounded by the terrible thunder and lightning, the thought came to me that, if the cavern could have been made in the twinkling of an eye, it would have been on such a day. So, I picked up my guitar and began to compose and sing. Cleda made notes of the lyrics. When the time came for me to sing on the program, I sang the new song, Blanchard Cave. Later, the National Forest people came to my house and taped the song, in my living room. It is used in the film shown to visitors before they go into the cave. Many people have asked for the recording, so we decided to make this album and to use other songs of the area along with The Ballad of Blanchard Cave.” Jimmy sings five stanzas in country style telling how Father Time got together with Mother Nature and built a castle with pillars underground. Later men found this “castle” and called it Blanchard Cave. (See full lyrics LY-CY3) The show cave is northwest of Mountain View, Arkansas off Route 14 and the Jimmy Driftwood Barn is located on Highway 5 north of town. In this photo on the right there is a small sign promoting the show cave. The Jimmy Driftwood Legacy Project re-mastered and reissued this out-of-print LP album as a special CD along with another LP, “Beautiful Buffalo River.” This CD was released in 2007, which is well beyond the cut-off date for this discography, but it is mentioned here because the LP is extremely hard to find and there are those who may want to have the song. Ref: Anon. 1969, Jimmy Driftwood: Doctor of American Folklore, Opry, v. 1, n. 10, April [1969], p. 6 Anon. 1977, Welcome to Blanchard Springs Caverns, Forest Service, U.S. Department of Agriculture Anon. 2005, Jimmy Driftwood, Nation Master Encyclopedia, nationmaster Allen 2012, Jimmy Driftwood, Allen’s Archive of Early & Old Country Music, blogspot Blanchard Springs Caverns, Home site, blanchardsprings Eder, Bruce 2013, Jimmy Driftwood, Biography, Allmusic Jimmy Driftwood – Americana, 50 Classic Ozark Mountain Songs, jimmydriftwoodlegacyproject Gurnee, Russell & Jeanne 1980, Gurnee Guide to American Caves, Zephyrus Press Inc., Teaneck, NJ, p. 44-45 Jimmy Driftwood, Biography, Wikipedia Jimmy Driftwood, Discography, rocky-52 Streeter, Richard Kent (Editor) 2005, The Down in Arkansas Songbook, The Jimmy Driftwood Legacy Project, Calhoun, GA, p. 9 _____________________________________________________ VARIOUS VERSIONS OF THE CAVE In chronological order of Release CY5 United States 1967 THE CAVE Country – Vocal & Instrumental Comp: Larry KINGSTON (LY-CY4) Rts: Mayhew-Window Music (BMI) Perf: Johnny PAYCHECK [aka. Donald Lytle] (vocal) Lloyd Green (steel guitar) (with guitar & bass) Prod: Aubrey Mayhew Prod. Co: Little Darlin' Corp.; Nashville, TN Rel. Date: August 1967 Time: 3:32 1. Single 45: Little Darlin' LD-0032 Flip Sd: Then Love Dies 7" 45rpm 2. Reissue on CD: THE REAL MR. HEARTACHE – THE LITTLE DARLIN’ YEARS (1997) The Country Music Foundation 008 (Tk 20) Notes: An important 6-stanza country ballad that starts out talking about exploring a cave and ends up pointing out the dangers of nuclear warfare. The lyrics tell of a man dreaming of finding a cave as a teenager, crawling around in it, getting lost and falling asleep, then waking up to an earth-shaking noise, and exiting the cave only to find parched ground and total devastation caused by the bomb. Larry Kingston, the song writer, was originally from Lafayette, Indiana. South-central Indiana is an area rich in caves and Larry could well have explored some of them in his youth since his lyrics suggest a certain familiarity with caving – II. And like most any young boy would, I crawled into the cave And through the damp, dark darkness there I slowly made my way; Tunnel after tunnel going this way and that, 'Til suddenly I knew, I didn't know where I was at. With his producer, Aubrey Mayhew, Johnny Paycheck co-owned his record company, Little Darlin' Records. In the late 1060s, “Paycheck and Mayhew, along with steel guitarist Lloyd Green, would record a slew of highly influential records and set the mold for exactly who and what Johnny Paycheck was supposed to be -- dark, brooding, moody, violent -- with such milestone recordings as "Pardon Me (I've Got Someone to Kill)," "You'll Recover in Time" (about being straightjacketed in a mental ward) and "The Cave" (a song about nuclear destruction), all of which sent influential waves of change throughout the country music community. The seeds were sown during these years of 1964-69 for what would then be known as Outlaw Country, and no one could fit that bill better than Johnny Paycheck, a man who lived the life he sang about.” (Dickerson 2011) This single reached position 32 on the US Country Charts. The only known case of a modern country singer who has performed more than one cave song; Paycheck also recorded a version of "Miller's Cave." For more information on Johnny Paycheck see under Country Music – Miller’s Cave 1960-1970. Ref: Anon. n.d., Johnny’s Biography, Johnny Paycheck Official Website, johnnypaycheckmusic Bear, Eddie 2006, Larry Kingston, Artist Tributes, eddiebear Dickerson, Deke 2011, Musings of a Muleskinner, blogspot Johnny Paycheck, Biography, Wikipedia Johnny Paycheck, The Cave, (3:22) 45cat (◄COMPLETE AUDIO SAMPLE) Johnny Paycheck, The Cave (3:32), YouTube (◄COMPLETE AUDIO SAMPLE) Johnny Paycheck, The Real Mr. Heartache – The Little Darlin’ Years CD, Allmusic (◄AUDIO SAMPLE) Johnny Paycheck, The Real Mr. Heartache – The Little Darlin’ Years CD, Amazon _____________________________________ CY6 United States 1967 THE CAVE Country – Vocal & Instrumental Comp: Larry KINGSTON (LY-CY4) Perf: Gene STEWART (vocal) (with guitar, bass, & drums) Prod. Co: Stop Records Inc.; Nashville, TN Rel. Date: ca. Oct. 1967 Time: 2:56 Label: Stop ST 127 Flip Sd: This Just Can’t Be Happening Spec: 7" 45rpm Notes: This is the Larry Kingston song alright, probably recorded in Nashville, TN. A perfectly valid version by a relatively unknown country artist. There is only one very minor wording change – Stz. 1, vs. 2 – I dreamed I was a boy again, just barely in my teens For the last verse, as with the Johnny Paycheck version, Stewart pauses and slows the pace to sing – Where people used to live, before the bomb came down. And the last five words resonate with all the force of their meaning. Nothing further could be learned about this singer other than that he did at least nine singles for different labels including Decca and King (see the Praguefrank discography). He should not be confused with Gene Stewart & The Country Rebels of Rayville, Louisiana. Ref: Gene Stewart, The Cave 45, (2:56), musicme & YouTube (◄COMPLETE AUDIO SAMPLE) Praguefrank 2010, Gene Stewart, Discography, Praguefrank’s Country Music Discographies, countrydiscography.blogsport.fr _____________________________________ CY7 United States 1982 THE CAVE Country – Instrumental Comp: Larry KINGSTON Rts: Mayhew-Window Music (BMI) Perf: Lloyd GREEN (steel guitar) (with guitar & bass) Prod: Aubrey Mayhew Prod. Co: Little Darlin' Corp.; Nashville, TN Rec. Date: ca.1968 or 1969 Time: 2:12 A. American Releases: 1. LP: GREEN VELVET President 12" 33rpm 2. Reissue on CD: MASTER OF THE STEEL STRINGS – THE LITTLE DARLIN’ SOUND OF LLOYD GREEN (2004) Koch 9801 (Tk 14) B. British LP: GREEN VELVET (1982) President PRCV 112 12" 33rpm (Sd 2 – Bd 4) Notes: Lloyd Green is most noted for his session work and he worked a lot with Johnny Paycheck at Little Darlin' Records in the late 1960s. It is he who played steel guitar on Paycheck’s original vocal version of this song in 1967 (see above). On that Little Darlin' recording he only gets in occasional spooky licks to dramatically underline certain verses. But here he does a full instrumental interpretation of the music. This piece is a slow tempo instrumental with a guitar intro followed by Lloyd’s high-pitched steel guitar doing variants on the theme. The guitar returns, backed by the bass and occasional chords on the steel. It closes with a short silence followed by a one forceful final guitar chord. Lloyd Green also plays backup on two versions of “Miller’s Cave” (see under Country Music – Miller’s Cave – Early – Johnny Paycheck CY-MC-EY13 and Late – Don Williams CY-MC-LT3). Ref: Lloyd Green, Biography, Wikipedia Lloyd Green, The Cave (2:08), YouTube (◄COMPLETE AUDIO SAMPLE) Lloyd Green, Discography, rocky-52 Lloyd Green, Master of the Steel Strings CD, steelguitarmusic Lloyd Green, Master of the Steel Strings CD, CDUniverse (◄AUDIO SAMPLE) Kienzle, Rich 2004, Master of the Steel Strings CD, Review, Not Fade Away, Issue 54, Nov.-Dec. 2004, nodepression _____________________________________ CY8 United States ca.1985 THE CAVE Country – Vocal & Instrumental Comp: Larry KINGSTON (LY-CY4) Rts: Dream City Music/Window Music Publ. Co. (BMI) Perf: Ken SCOTT (vocal) THE CAROL LEE SINGERS (backing vocals) Prod: Charlie Fields Prod. Co: Charta Records; Nashville, TN Time: 3:24 Label: Charta CH 184 Flip Sd: Cuttin’ Close to the Heart Spec: 7" 45rpm Notes: I had found this single listed in the highly useful Phonolog Catalog and in 1986 when I was in Nashville, I went to the Charta Records office to buy this single. Ken Scott was there that day and I was introduced to him, but I failed to ask how he got this song. The Carol Lee Singers made frequent appearances on the Grand Ole Opry in Nashville. Charta Records came out with their first singles in 1977 and Charta 196 was released in 1985, so we might assume that this one was released in 1984-85. Ref: Anon. 2008, 45 Discography for Charta Records, globaldogproductions _____________________________________ CY9 United States 2004 THE CAVE Country – Contemporary Bluegrass – Vocal & Instrumental Comp: Larry KINGSTON (LY-CY4) Rts: Mayhew-Window Music (BMI) Perf: Josh WILLIAMS (vocal, guitar, & mandolin) Ron Stewart (fiddle) Kristin Scott Benson & J. D. Crowe (banjos) Randy Kohrs (guitar) Missy Raines (bass) Photo by Michael Wilson Prod: Don Rigsby Prod. Co: Pinecastle Records; Orlando, FL Time: 3:30 CD: LONESOME HIGHWAY Pinecastle PRC 1136 (Tk 11) Notes: A nice version of this older country disaster song, first recorded by Johnny Paycheck in 1968. This is a newgrass rendition and should be listed under bluegrass music, but it was considered better to group it here with the other three versions of the song. Regarding this album one critic commented – “Josh primarily sticks to guitar and mandolin, but he also serves up some tasty mandolin licks on ‘The Cave’.” (Ross 2004) Ref: Josh Williams, Lonesome Highway CD, The Cave, Stanzas 2 & 3, Allmusic (◄AUDIO SAMPLE) Josh Williams, Lonesome Highway CD, CDUniverse Jurek, Thom 2013, Josh Williams, Biography, Allmusic Ross, Joe 2004, Josh Williams, Lonesome Highway CD, bluegrassworks _____________________________________________________ CY10 United States 1956 CAVEMAN Country – Rock ‘n’ Roll – Vocal & Instrumental Comp: Hal BYNUM & Larry COKER (LY-CY5) Rts: Lode Publishing Co. (BMI) Perf: Terry FELL (vocal & guitar) Buck Owens (guitar) Prod: Terry Fell Prod. Co: RCA Victor Rec. Co: Lewis Talley Studio; Bakersfield, CA Rec. Date: Sept. 15, 1956 Liner Notes: (CD) Colin Escott, 1993 Time: 1:56 A. American Releases: 1. Single 45: RCA Victor 47-6707 Flip Sd: Play the Music Louder 2. Promo EP:(with 2 Homer & Jethro songs) RCA Victor DJ-20 & 47-6706 7" 45rpm (EP) (Sd 2 – Bd 1) B. West German Releases: 1. Reissue on Compilation LP: TERRY FELL/ BIG BILL LISTER (1977?) Country Classics Library 1102 12" 33rpm (Sd 1 – Bd 3) 2. Reissue on CD: TRUCK DRIVING MAN (1993) Bear Family BCD 15762 (Tk 2) Notes: A smash-bang, Tarzan-Neanderthal-type love story. Lots of hoopa-la-ugh stuff done to the beat of a tom-tom, Native American style, with a decidedly country-sounding guitar accompaniment. A weird mixture. The only amusing break in the heavy-handed lyrics comes in Stanza 4, where he takes his girl to his cave in Gaga to "show her caveman etchings that were scratched upon the wall." This refers to the trite old playboy seduction line, "come on up to my place and I'll show you my etchings." The musical tradition here is country & western, but the style is close to rock ‘n’ roll. “Terry Fell a very popular hillbilly singer of the 40’/50’s who had arrived from his home state of Alabama out to California during the late Thirties. Terry was to make over 30 records for a dozen or so labels over a two decade period in time without ever losing the real security of a full time job outside music.” (Bentley & Tricker 1985) He’s best known for his bit hit “Truck Drivin” Man in 1954, which became a classic, especially in the trucker country music scene. In the early 50s, Terry Fell recorded alone or with his group called, "The Fellers," or “His Seven Southerners” mostly for RCA Victor and its subsidiary label, X, but also for the Memo, Courtney, and 4-Star labels (the latter two were Los Angeles labels). Ref: Bentley, C. & Tricker, P. 1985, Roll Street Journal, v. 3, n. 3, Issue 11, Spring 1985, p. 30 Simmons, Screamin' Brian 1977, Terry Fell, The Camel-Walk-er Magazine (Fanzine), n. 5, Sept. 1977, Farnborough, England, p. 20 Terry Fell/ Big Bill Lister LP, Dismarc Terry Fell, Biography, Wikipedia Terry Fell, Caveman (1:56), YouTube (◄COMPLETE AUDIO SAMPLE) Terry Fell, Truck Driving Man CD, Allmusic Terry Fell, Truck Driving Man CD, CDUniverse _____________________________________________________ CY11 United States 1997 CAVE MAN Country – Vocal & Instrumental Comp: Chris SMITHER Rts: Homunculus Music (ASCAP) Perf: Chris SMITHER (vocal & guitar) Chris Maresh (bass) Brannen Temple (percussion) Prod: Stephen Bruton Prod. Co: Hightone Records; Oakland, CA Time: 4:36 CD: SMALL REVELATIONS Hightone/ Shout! Factory HCD 8077 (Tk 4) Notes: This mellow song starts out – When I was a cave man Paintin’ on the wall, I never had a dollar, Man, I had it all, And I was very high In the order of things. Just one step and I’d spread my wings and fly Oh, I would fly From there on Smither sings four more stanzas that talk of the vicissitudes of life and have nothing to do with cave man or caves – “And I never knew the truth might set me free;” ”Each one is truly mine, they never last;” “And I could save your soul I do believe;” “And I’ll be on my way before it’s gone;” he then repeats the second stanza. And he wraps the song up with – When I was a cave man When I was a cave man I had it all (2X) The lyrics are somewhat difficult to hear in places without the lyric sheet. For full lyrics see elyrics. Ref: Chris Smither, Biography, Wikipedia Chris Smither, Cave Man, Live (6:16), YouTube Chris Smither, Cave Man, Lyrics, elyrics Chris Smither, Small Revelations CD, Allmusic (◄AUDIO SAMPLE) Chris Smither, Small Revelations CD, CDUniverse _____________________________________ CY12 United States 2000 CAVE MAN (Live) Country – Vocal & Instrumental Comp: Chris SMITHER Perf: Chris SMITHER (vocal & guitar) Prod: Darleen Wilson Prod. Co: Hightone Records; Oakland, CA Time: 5:21 CD: LIVE AS I’LL EVER BE Hightone HCD 8120 (Tk 7) Notes: Concerning this live recording of Chris Smither’s song one reviewer remarked – “Songs like ‘Cave Man,’ from 1997’s Small Revelations, find an easy soulfulness in their unadorned settings.” (Cooke n.d.) Another reviewer said – “ “Cave Man’ boasts a gorgeous melody about the supreme loneliness.” (Armstrong 2003) And a third reviewer remarked – “Few recordings can delve as deeply into the psyche as Smither’s ‘Cave man’.” (Smith 2004) Ref: Chris Smither, Cave Man, Live (6:16), YouTube (◄COMPLETE AUDIO SAMPLE) Chris Smither, Live As I’ll Ever Be CD, Allmusic (◄AUDIO SAMPLE) Chris Smither, Live As I’ll Ever Be CD, Wikipedia Cooke, Matthew n.d & Armstrong, Lee 2003 & Smith, Graham 2004, 3 Customer’s Reviews, Live As I’ll Ever Be CD, Amazon _____________________________________________________ CY13 United States 1968 THE CAVERN Country – Vocal & Instrumental Comp: Perf: Eddie DEAN (vocal & guitar) Leon COPAS Prod. Co: Crown Records; Culver City, CA Time: 2:10 LP: LITTLE GREEN APPLES Crown CST 578 12” 33rpm (Sd 2 – Bd 2) Notes: An urban cowboy song sung in a lazy baritone voice with chunky rhythm & cymbals. Only a few verses were heard in the sample – [….] that the one so dark within Deep in the heart of a cavern Beyond [these] depths far below |….] a ball like a crystal [….] Ref: Brennan, Sandra 2015, Eddie Dean, Artist Biography, Allmusic Eddie Dean (singer), Bio, Wikipedia Eddie Dean, Little Green Apples LP, Amazon.fr (◄AUDIO SAMPLE) Eddie Dean, Little Green Apples LP, apple Eddie Dean, Little Green Apples LP, Discogs Callahan, Mike; et al. 2010, Eddie Dean Sings Little Green Apples LP, Crown Album Discography – Part 6, bsnpubs _____________________________________ CY14 United States 1966 DEAD MAN'S CAVE Country – Vocal Comp: Eddie MILLER (LY-CY7) Rts: Vidor Publications (BMI) Perf: Bobby GRIGGS Prod. Co: Bettye Jean Productions Matrix: 45-60528 Label: Tower 234 Flip Sd: Woman At Home Spec: 7" 45rpm Rel. Date: Feb. 1966 Time: 2:30 Notes: An obscure song by an obscure Country singer. The songwriter may be the same Eddie Miller who wrote several of Patsy Cline's songs and was elected to the Nashville Songwriter’s Hall of Fame. Vidor Publ., owned by Tex Ritter and Johnny Bond, was named after their wives – Violet (Bond's wife) & Dorothy (Ritter's wife). (Anon. 1985) The lyrics are very intriguing from the standpoint of cave folklore. Are they referring to an existing legend connected with a known cave in the United States? There are several caves named Dead Man's Cave (or Dead Man Cave) west of the Mississippi: one in Missouri (Pulaski County), two in Texas (Burnet & Kendall Counties), and two in Wyoming (Albany & Big Horn Co.), one in Utah (Salt Lake Co.). And in the east there is one in Garrett County, Maryland, one in North Carolina (Smoky Mtns.) and Deadman's Pit in Georgia (Dade Co.) – just to name a few. Legends, as told in this song, involving 39 men who entered a cave and never returned; caves where slaves were bound in chains; caves leading to the infernal fires of Hell. All this sort of thing can be found in cave folklore, but I don't know of any specific American cave legend that combines all these elements. There's some resemblance here to the Indian legend connected with the Cave of the Catacombs (Calaveras County, CA) (also known as Miller’s Cave) owned by Jerry Miller in 1950-62. (Halliday 1955) Ref: Anon. 1985, Goldmine, v. 11, Issue 5, n. 120, Mar. 1, 1985, p. 28 Bobby Griggs, Dead Man’s Cave, 45cat Halliday, William R., Hidden Skeletons of the Mother Lode, in Mohr, Charles & Sloane, Howard 1955, Celebrated American Caves, Rutgers Univ. Press, New Brunswick, NJ. p. 195, 197-198 _____________________________________ CY15 United States ca.Early 1960s MAMMOTH CAVE SECRET * Country – Vocal Comp: Charlie STEWART (LY-CY8) Rts: Grandwealth Music Co. (BMI) Perf: Charlie STEWART (vocal) (with piano, steel guitar, bass, & drums) Prod: Bennie Hess Prod. Co: Show Land Records; Nashville, TN Time: 3:07 Label: Show Land SL-151971-B Flip Sd: Hitchhiking Talking Duck Spec: 7" 45rpm Notes: Charlie Stewart was a Hoosier country singer who generally did comedy songs. Between 1959 and 1964 he recorded ten other singles mostly on Nashville or Indianapolis labels: two others for Show Land Records, three for Nabor, and one single each for four other labels. (Abrahamian et al. n.d.) A very intriguing title here for what turns out to be a country murder ballad with 8 stanzas. The lyrics (see LY-CY8) tell of picking up a girl in Glasgow, Kentucky and riding off with her – And that was the start of the Mammoth Cave secret A secret that’s haunted my conscience for years. At night they “parked on a hillside at Mammoth Cave Park” to drink beer, he made advances, and she resisted and jumped out of the car. To stop her from screaming he choked her to death. Thinking about a lifetime of prison, he decided – But if I could get into the cave undetected The darkness would hide us, the rocks wouldn’t tell. I dragged her down to an underground river An’ I [wooed] her into her watery grave Just me an’ the blind fish that pick at her bones Would know the dark secrets of old Mammoth Cave. In the final stanza, as he is dying, he must say – But the Mammoth Cave secret is a secret no longer Oh, Lord, I just had to tell. Then in stanza 7 he tells about in the cave – This song comes from a long tradition of country death and murder ballads, some of which directly involve caves, such as all the Floyd Collins ballads and Jack Clement’s “Miller’s Cave.” I first located this 45 single in a rather curious way. I had learned on the Library of Congress Recorded Sound Reference Center Website about an old 45 country single with the intriguing title, “Mammoth Cave Secret.” I went right to eBay and looked under the artist’s name. There was a 45 by this artist but the seller only gave the song title on the flip side. Well, I knew that title from the LOC site so I went ahead and ordered it straight off. Ref: Abrahamian, B.; Ball, C. et al. n.d., 45rpm Recordings by Indiana Bands; (No longer online), indiana45s Charlie Stewart, Mammoth Cave Secret, Discogs Charlie Stewart, Mammoth Cave Secret (3:15), YouTube (◄COMPLETE AUDIO SAMPLE) Charlie Stewart, Mammoth Cave Secret, Sonic, Recorded Sound Reference Center, Library of Congress, loc.gov Mammoth Cave National Park, Park Service Official site, nps.gov Mammoth Cave National Park, Wikipedia _____________________________________ CY16 United States 2005 NICKAJACK CAVE (JOHNNY CASH’S REDEMPTION) * Country – Rock – Vocal Comp: Jamie O’HARA (LY-CY14) Rts: Sony/ATV Songs/Magic Knee Music (BMI) Perf: Gary ALLAN (vocal) John Wesley Ryles & Perry Coleman (background vocals) Brent Rowan (electric guitar) Steve Nathan (organ) Robby Turner (steel) Michael Rhodes (bass) Eric Darken (percussion) Chad Cromwell (drums) Prod: Mark Wright & Gary Allan Prod. Co: MCA Nashville; Nashville, TN Gary ALLAN Rec. Co: Sound Kitchen; Nashville, TN Time: 4:14 CD: TOUGH ALL OVER MCA Nashville B0003711-02 (Tk 6) Notes: Song is entirely inspired by a decisive incident in the life of the famous country music star, Johnny Cash. In October 1967. Driven to despair by his addition to pills and alcohol, Cash decided to end his life by dying in Nickajack Cave. He wrote in his autobiography that he had resolve to – “Go into Nickajack Cave and let God take me from this earth and put me wherever He puts people like me.” Earlier in his life he had visited the cave with friends in search if Civil War relics. Another country music star, Hank Williams, Jr., had been to the cave with Johnny and later remarked about his recklessness and his disregard for safety in the caves. (Miller 2003) After several hours the batteries of his flashlight died. His energy sapped he laid down to rest in the dark. Miller writes – “Suddenly, he felt a new energy and though he couldn’t see where he was going, he started to crawl through open passages, eventually feeling fresh air on his back which told him he was near the entrance.” (Note – the “fresh air” or cooler autumn air would have been felt on his face if he was headed toward the entrance, and that is the way the lyrics have it also) This event must have taken place soon after the Tennessee Valley Authority started impounding the Nickajack Reservoir on Sept. 14, 1967. (Ball 2006) Once the reservoir was filled the lower half of the huge cave entrance was flooded and the cave floor was completely underwater. One of the largest cave entrances east of the Mississippi River, its flat-roofed opening spans 140 feet (43m) and is 50 feet (15m) high. The total length of the main cave is about 3,500 feet (1,067m), but there is a network of small passages 900 feet (274m) from the entrance and about 1,500 feet (457m) of passage were known in this section. (Barr 1961) (See detail of network section on left, which, if pivoted a quarter turn clockwise, fits on the main map of the cave just southeast of the entrance.) Allan introduces the song – “Every man has to come to a crossroads somewhere along the way. Johnny Cash came to his crossroads in a place called, Nickajack Cave.” Be forewarned, this is not traditional country music; with its heavy, prominent drums, the song might rightly be classed as country rock. Lots of instrumental amplification and reverb with a driving beat. Allan gravelly voice fits well with the gravity of the lyrics. The text tells the story, including the dialogue that Cash claimed to have had with God while he was in the cave (see LY-CY13). There is a definite religious flavor to the song but this is not gospel music, it’s Nashville new country music. The video clip on YouTube, directed by William Cody Pittman, uses some cave shots, entrance and a huge cave interior, etc., but none of them taken at Nickajack Cave itself. The CDUniverse critic said – “The standout song, however, is ‘Nickajack Cave (Johnny Cash's Redemption),’ an intriguing narrative about the Man in Black's darkest days that hints at Cash's signature sound without attempting to duplicate it.” (Anon. 2013b) However another critic considers the song only in the context of a concept album – “ ‘Nickajack Cave (Johnny Cash’s Redemption)’ is one of the most praised songs on the album. Every time the album is brought up in a discussion you can bet somebody will mention this song. I don’t think all the praise is warranted, unlike the rest of the songs this one externalizes the pain. Every other song [on the CD] is about dealing with loss, this one ruins the flow of the album in my opinion.” (Stacey 2010) “Tough All Over sold over 99,000 copies in its first week, debuting at No. 3 on the Billboard 200 and No. 1 on the magazine's Top Country Albums chart.” (Anon. 2013a) This CD album was ranked album number 7 on the "Country’s Best Albums of the Decade" list by both Rhapsody (Online music service) and the 9513 country music blog. Ref: Anon. 2012, Nickajack Cave, Wikipedia Anon. 2013a,Gary Allan, Biography, Wikipedia Anon. 2013b, Gary Allan, Tough All Over CD, CDUniverse (◄AUDIO SAMPLE) Ball, Donald B. 2006, Historical Accounts of Nickajack Cave, The Journal of Spelean History, v. 40, n. 1, Issue 129, Jan.-June 2006, p. 20-21 Barr, Thomas C. 1961, Caves of Tennessee, State of Tennessee, Division of Geology, Bull. 64, Nashville, TN, p. 305-306 Cash, Johnny & Carr, Patrick 1997, Cash: The Autobiography, Harper, San Francisco Gary Allan, Nickajack Cave, Lyrics, songlyrics Gary Allan, Nickajack Cave, The Redemption of Johnny Cash (4;17), YouTube (◄COMPLETE AUDIO SAMPLE) Gary Allan, Tough All Over CD, Stanza 1, Amazon (◄AUDIO SAMPLE) Gary Allan, Tough All Over CD, Wikipedia Halliday, William R. 1966, Depths of the Earth, Harper & Row, New York, p. 288-297 Miller, Stephen 2003 (2005), Johnny Cash: The Life of an American Icon, Omnibus Press, New York, p. 161-162 Nickajack Cave, Wikipedia Stacey, Jordan 2010, Album Review, My Kind of Country, wordpress Stratton, Christopher 2005, Johnny Cash Walked the Line, quoted in Matthews, Larry E. 2007, Caves of Chattanooga, The National Speleological Society, Huntsville, AL, p. 100-101, Online at explorefaith Tennessee Valley Authority, Nickajack Reservoir, Nickajack Cave (Map - Detail), The Limestone Ledger, v. 11, n. 4, p. 40 (Reprinted in Speleo Digest 1963, p. 1-43 & also Speleo Digest 1961, p. 1-99) caveinspiredmusic.com