View File
Transcription
View File
Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended) Planning Statement PROPOSAL: Planning application for the demolition of 2 houses and the creation of new car sales area at Toyota Dealership, Manchester Road, Altrincham. SITE: Toyota Dealership, Altrincham APPLICANT: RRG Group Ltd Manchester Our ref: RRG1/3/PS Date: August 2012 Road, CONTENTS Page 1.00 Introduction 3 2.00 Site and Surroundings 5 3.00 Planning History 7 4.00 The Proposal 8 5.00 Relevant Planning Policy 10 6.00 Key Issues 15 7.00 Conclusion 21 Doc ref: RRG1-3.001 Doc date: August 2012 Page 2 of 21 1.00 INTRODUCTION 1.01 This planning statement is submitted in support of a planning application for the demolition of 2 houses and the creation of new car sales area at the existing Toyota Dealership, Manchester Road, Altrincham. The application seeks the demolition of 2 houses in order to extend the car sales area. 1.02 The applicant, RRG Group Limited, has operated at this site for in excess of 13 years. Overtime Toyota has brought in new requirements which all franchises must adhere to; in addition to this, in order to remain competitive it is important that this dealership is allowed to grow and prosper to meet the company’s aspirations and also the expectations of its customers. 1.03 The applicant currently operates successfully from this site and it is a vital local business offering local employment opportunities. Despite the current national economic downturn, RRG wish to make further investments in the Manchester Road site to ensure its future viability and vitality. The Manchester Road dealership is in fact one of the smallest Toyota dealerships in the UK and does not currently adhere to Toyota Standards. 1.04 At present there is an application pending consideration at this site for the demolition of the 2no. dwellings, expansion of the sales pitch area, an extension to the showroom and the creation of an egress only route onto Woodcote Road, however the outcome of that application is uncertain. For the applicant there is a need to demolish the 2no. dwellings for qualified, pragmatic and economic reasons. The applicant is now the owner of the 2no. dwellings following the Council’s confirmation that future road widening will take place on Manchester Road which will lead to some of RRG’s current site being compulsory purchased. In light of this RRG purchased the two dwellings to enable them to extend their site. The 2no. dwellings are no longer occupied and are currently a local eyesore (particularly no.289) and the longer the dwellings stand empty the more the properties will deteriorate and become neglected. As such, this proposal seeks to demolish the two dwellings in the short term and enable the expansion of the Doc ref: RRG1-3.001 Doc date: August 2012 Page 3 of 21 sales display area to revitalise this corner of Manchester and Woodcote Road whilst enabling RRG to take the opportunity to invest in their current site and strengthen its offer to customers. This proposal also includes the provision of an emergency exit route only onto Woodcote Road; this could have both internal and external gates and be conditioned as such. It should be noted that the LPA has hitherto raised no objection to the principle of the proposed extension to the car display area subject to satisfactory landscaping and lighting schemes. 1.05 It is considered that - in light of all material considerations - the proposed development accords with the provisions of the development plan and the National Planning Policy Framework. It is therefore respectfully requested that planning permission be granted. Doc ref: RRG1-3.001 Doc date: August 2012 Page 4 of 21 2.00 SITE AND SURROUNDINGS 2.01 The site is located on the A56 Manchester Road in Altrincham adjacent to the Trafford college site and in close proximity to the newly developed Stamford Book mixed use site. To the immediate north (adjacent to the road frontage of the Toyota site) exists a pair of semi-detached properties which sit on the corner of Manchester Road and Woodcote Road. Woodcote Road is further characterised by residential properties, where the rear gardens of five of these properties back on to the subject site. Opposite the site there are a mixture of uses including a church, residential properties and some commercial uses. 2.02 The site can be described as being located on one of the principal thoroughfares in Altrincham; the duel lane road is constantly busy and heavily trafficked. The A56 extends from the A556 to the south and continues all the way through Sale, Stretford and Old Trafford towards Manchester. The surrounding area comprises a mixture of uses, with predominantly commercial uses fronting the main road, with residential properties PHOTOGRAPH 1: The Toyota garage can be seen in the background (with Trafford College behind it), with 289 & 291 Manchester Road in the foreground. Photo taken from the corner of Park Road / Manchester Road looking in a southerly direction being located on the smaller roads off the A56. 2.03 As previously mentioned, the site is located adjacent to Trafford College which sits on the junction of Stamford Brook Road which leads to the recently developed housing, office and retail development known as Stamford Brook. This Doc ref: RRG1-3.001 Doc date: August 2012 Page 5 of 21 section of the A56 is busy and heavily commercialised; Altrincham Retail Park can be found less than 1km from the subject site. 2.04 The site is located within close proximity of the junction of Manchester Road, Park Road and Woodcote Road. This junction is notoriously busy and is renowned for traffic to be backed up in all directions on Manchester Road and Park Road at peak times. Junction of Manchester Road & Park Road RRG Toyota dealership, Manchester Road, Altrincham Source: Extract from Trafford Revised UDP (2006) Proposals Map to illustrate subject site location in Altrincham Doc ref: RRG1-3.001 Doc date: August 2012 Page 6 of 21 3.00 PLANNING HISTORY 3.01 There have been numerous planning applications relating to the site in the past, below is a table showing the most recent planning history (last 10 years). Application Number Description H45828 Display Date and Decision of internally Approved with conditions illuminated fascia sign and 12.08.1998 internally illuminated Appeal freestanding gantry sign H/ADV/60375 Erection of Dismissed 15.04.1999 internally Refused 26.10.2004 non- Appeal illuminated and illuminated signage Decision Upheld and 14.03.2005 entrance statement. H/59236 New entrance way with Approved with condition external entrance feature, 28.09.2004 hero sign, alterations to site layout and block paving. H/59495 Single storey extension to Approved with conditions existing car repair 09.07.2004 workshop to form additional workbay. H/ADV/50208 Display of illuminated 1 and internally Split decision 12.02.2001 3 non- illuminated signs. H/ADV/59233 Erection of signage: 5 flag Approved with conditions signs, 1 entrance sign and 28.09.2004 1 hero sign. H/ADV/62657 Display of 5 banner signs, 3 Refused 31.08.2005 hero signs and 3 auto assured signs. H/ADV/64386 Doc ref: RRG1-3.001 Doc date: August 2012 Display of 7 illuminated Split Decision 05.06.2006 Page 7 of 21 advertisements. H/ADV/70283 Erection of 2 internally Split decision 25.11.2008 illuminated hero signs, 4 non illuminated signs, one directional sign and 4 flag poles and signs 78514/FULL/2012 Demolition of 2 houses and Pending Consideration creation of new car sales area. Extension to existing car showroom. vehicular Manchester Woodcote accesses Road Road New off and and closure of existing access off Manchester Road. 4.00 THE PROPOSAL 4.01 It is proposed to extend the dealership site so that it would include the land at 289 and 291 Manchester Road (this would involve the demolition of the existing properties). In place of the dwellinghouses, RRG would reconfigure the outside display space and customer parking from the extant situation to enable a larger car display area to the north of the site (area of the former dwellinghouses). The current customer parking area would then be relocated to the south of the site accessed via the existing access off Manchester Road. The reconfiguration of the site in this way would not only allow the vehicle display area to increase in size and be a more visually attractive site but it would also allow a significant increase in customer parking to 19.no spaces including 2no. allocated for people with disabilities. The site reconfiguration would also enable the area to the rear of the showroom (west) to be more efficiently used, providing 1no. customer service bays, 4no. MOT parking bays and 12no. allocated staff parking spaces and a Doc ref: RRG1-3.001 Doc date: August 2012 Page 8 of 21 further 15 spaces for demonstrator (sales staff) cars. Provision for 5 cycle spaces and 5 motorcycle spaces (3 of which would be for staff) would also be provided. 4.02 This proposal is accompanied by a planting plan and schedule which details the proposed boundary treatments; this includes a line of pleached trees along the site’s boundary with no. 1 Woodcote Road, this will provide a solid screen above the existing fence. Additional landscaping is proposed along the boundary of the site with Woodcote Road and at the corner of Woodcote and Manchester Road, for further details please see drawing number L001. In addition, this proposal seeks to provide an emergency exit only route onto Woodcote Road, this could be gated both internally and externally and conditioned as such. It is considered that the use of this gate for emergency purposes only could be appropriately conditioned as follows: “The exit route onto Woodcote Road shall be used for emergency purposes only and at all other times shall be closed to all vehicles. Its use will be prevented by the erection of internal and external gates, details of which shall be submitted to and approved by the LPA in writing prior to the commencement of development. An emergency is defined only by the temporary closure of the principal access onto Manchester Road in the event of a road traffic accident or other incident at that point”. 4.03 For details of the proposal please see the submitted application drawing, number M11-35-09. Doc ref: RRG1-3.001 Doc date: August 2012 Page 9 of 21 5.00 THE DEVELOPMENT PLAN UNITARY DEVELOPMENT PLAN 5.01 The site is located within Trafford MBC local authority boundary and is therefore subject to the planning policies contained within the Trafford Revised Unitary Development Plan (adopted 2006). According to the UDP Proposals Map, the site is not designated as being subject to any specific planning policy, but it is noted that the site is located on a road which is denoted as being part of the Sustainable Integrated Transport Network (Policy T1) and is considered part of the Quality Bus Corridor (Policy T11) which seeks to improve the quality and safety of facilities for public transport users on (amongst others) the A56. 5.02 Of most relevance to the subject site is the Policy T8 (indicated by a blue triangle on the Proposals Map as seen above) - Improvements to the Highway Network. Part II of the UDP confirms that the council will support the maintenance and improvement of the highway route within the borough and that, amongst others in the Trunk and Primary Route Network, the A56 Manchester Road / Park Road junction improvement. Policy T8 confirms that: ‘The Council will not grant planning permission for any development that will prejudice the construction of any of these listed improvement schemes’. ‘These improvement schemes are proposed to bring about the range of benefits that are set out in Policy T4’. 5.03 Policy T4 goes on to state that the council will support and encourage improvements that will (amongst others) modernise and improve the network to relieve congestion and improve safety on existing roads, and reduce the impact of motorised traffic on local roads: Doc ref: RRG1-3.001 Doc date: August 2012 Page 10 of 21 ‘When considering proposals for new development that individually or cumulatively will have a material impact on the functioning of the Highway Network, the Council will seek to ensure that the safety and free flow of traffic is not prejudiced or compromised by that development in a significant adverse way’. CORE STRATEGY (adopted January 2012) 5.04 POLICY L7: DESIGN – this policy confirms that in relation to matters of design, development must: • Be appropriate in its context; • Make best use of opportunities to improve the character and quality of an area; • Enhance the street scene or character of the area by appropriately addressing scale, density, height, massing, layout, elevation treatment, materials, hard and soft landscaping works, boundary treatment and; • Make appropriate provision for open space, where appropriate, in accordance with Policy R5 of this Plan. 5.05 In relation to matters of functionality, development must: • Incorporate vehicular access and egress which is satisfactorily located and laid out having regard to the need for highway safety; • provide sufficient off-street car and cycle parking, manoeuvring and operational space; • provide sufficient manoeuvring and operational space for service vehicles, as appropriate; • Be satisfactorily served in terms of key utilities such as water, electricity, gas and telecommunications; • Be satisfactorily served in terms of the foul sewer system and; • Provide appropriate provision of (and access to) waste recycling facilities, preferably on site. Doc ref: RRG1-3.001 Doc date: August 2012 Page 11 of 21 5.06 In relation to matters of amenity protection, development must: • Be compatible with the surrounding area and; • Not prejudice the amenity of the future occupiers of the development and/or occupants of adjacent properties by reason of overbearing, overshadowing, overlooking, visual intrusion, noise and/or disturbance, odour or in any other way. 5.07 In relation to matters of security, development must: • Demonstrate that it is designed in a way that reduces opportunities for crime and; • 5.08 Not have an adverse impact on public safety. In relation to matters of accessibility, development must: • Be fully accessible and useable by all sections of the community. • Provide good connections within the site and to adjoining areas; • Where relevant ensure that streets and public spaces are designed to provide safe and attractive environments for walkers and cyclists; • 5.09 Provide safe, convenient links to public transport and community facilities. POLICY W1: ECONOMY – this policy notes that Broadheath will be retained and supported as a principal employment location in the south of the Borough. The Council recognises the significant contribution that existing successful manufacturing industries make to the economy of the Borough and will continue to support these industries where appropriate within the context of the Development Plan for Trafford. MATERIAL CONSIDERATIONS NATIONAL PLANNING POLICY FRAMEWORK (THE FRAMEWORK) 5.10 At the heart of the National Planning Policy Framework is a presumption in favour of sustainable development. For decision-taking this means: • approving development proposals that accord with the development plan without delay; and Doc ref: RRG1-3.001 Doc date: August 2012 Page 12 of 21 • where the development plan is absent, silent or relevant policies are outof-date, granting permission unless: • any adverse impacts of doing so would significantly and demonstrably outweigh the benefits, when assessed against the policies in this Framework taken as a whole; or • specific policies in this Framework indicate development should be restricted. 5.11 Building a strong, competitive economy: The Government is committed to securing economic growth in order to create jobs and prosperity, building on the country’s inherent strengths, and to meeting the twin challenges of global competition and of a low carbon future. 5.12 The Government is committed to ensuring that the planning system does everything it can to support sustainable economic growth. Planning should operate to encourage and not act as an impediment to sustainable growth. Therefore significant weight should be placed on the need to support economic growth through the planning system. 5.13 To help achieve economic growth, local planning authorities should plan proactively to meet the development needs of business and support an economy fit for the 21st century. 5.14 LPA should support existing business sectors, taking account of whether they are expanding or contracting and, where possible, identify and plan for new or emerging sectors likely to locate in their area. Policies should be flexible enough to accommodate needs not anticipated in the plan and to allow a rapid response to changes in economic circumstances. 5.15 Requiring good design - The Government attaches great importance to the design of the built environment. Good design is a key aspect of sustainable development, is indivisible from good planning, and should contribute positively Doc ref: RRG1-3.001 Doc date: August 2012 Page 13 of 21 to making places better for people. 5.16 Although visual appearance and the architecture of individual buildings are very important factors, securing high quality and inclusive design goes beyond aesthetic considerations. Therefore, planning policies and decisions should address the connections between people and places and the integration of new development into the natural, built and historic environment. 5.17 Planning policies and decisions should aim to ensure that developments: • will function well and add to the overall quality of the area, not just for the short term but over the lifetime of the development; • establish a strong sense of place, using streetscapes and buildings to create attractive and comfortable places to live, work and visit; • optimise the potential of the site to accommodate development, create and sustain an appropriate mix of uses (including incorporation of green and other public space as part of developments) and support local facilities and transport networks; • respond to local character and history, and reflect the identity of local surroundings and materials, while not preventing or discouraging appropriate innovation; • create safe and accessible environments where crime and disorder, and the fear of crime, do not undermine quality of life or community cohesion; and • are visually attractive as a result of good architecture and appropriate landscaping. Doc ref: RRG1-3.001 Doc date: August 2012 Page 14 of 21 6.00 KEY ISSUES 6.01 Considering the proposed development and the relevant planning policy outlined above it is considered that the key issues in this application are whether or not the proposed development is acceptable in principle, and whether it would have an acceptable impact upon residential amenity, particularly by way of visual impact. Acceptability in Principle 6.02 This proposal arises from the current opportunity for RRG to expand the Altrincham dealership following the purchase of two vacant properties on Manchester Road, one of which is severely deteriorating due to years of neglect. The two properties were purchased by RRG following confirmation from the Council that a future road widening scheme will in fact be implemented and as a result, in the future part of the RRG site will be compulsory purchased. As such, in order to secure their future at this site RRG took the opportunity to purchase the vacant properties and now it is important for qualified, pragmatic and economic reasons that the two dwellings are demolished and the acceptable extension of the car display area is secured, as in the meantime the properties are further deteriorating, to the detriment of the visual appearance of the local area and there is an economical cost to RRG. This opportunity is also in line with the desire of RRG to expand the existing Altrincham dealership in order to strengthen its offer and its role in the competitive market of car sales. The existing site is in fact one of the smallest Toyota dealerships in the UK and does not currently adhere to Toyota Standards and as such, RRG wish to make further investments in this site and bring it up to the company’s standards and aspirations and also to enhance the customer’s experience in line with their expectations. 6.03 Given that the dealership is extant at this site and has operated a successful business without complaint for in excess of a decade, it is considered that this location is suitable and acceptable for this type of use. At present, dwelling Doc ref: RRG1-3.001 Doc date: August 2012 Page 15 of 21 houses directly abut and back on to the site and this has been the situation throughout RRG’s use of the site, as such it is not considered that the demolition of 2 dwelling houses (one of which is vacant and has become an eyesore to the local area) to enable the expansion of the car display area would have any detrimental impact upon surrounding dwellings more than the current situation. 6.04 The site is located on a road which is identified by the local planning authority as part of the Trunk and Primary Route Network and as such comprises a prime location for commercial use particularly of this type where a key aspect of the sales comprises passing trade. 6.05 Core Strategy Policy L7 provides various criteria against which to assess new development, this policy notes that design must: - Be appropriate in its context – as mentioned the dealership is extant at this location and has existed free from complaints for in excess of a decade; - Make best use of opportunities to improve the character and quality of an area –The proposals take the opportunity to demolish two existing neglected and deteriorating dwellings and redevelop a prominent corner along a major transport route. The proposals would significantly improve this prominent corner by removing the dilapidated dwelling at no.289 and the adjacent property no.291 and reconfiguring this corner to open up the Toyota site and enable a visually attractive display area. This area would also feature landscaping and planting of low shrubs and hedges and the replacement of any existing trees where possible. - Enhance the street scene or character of the area by appropriately addressing scale, density, height, massing, layout, elevation treatment, materials, hard and soft landscaping works, boundary treatment and – as mentioned above landscaping and appropriate boundary treatment would be provided (as shown on drawings M11-35-09 and L001), particularly along the site frontage to Doc ref: RRG1-3.001 Doc date: August 2012 Page 16 of 21 Woodcote Road and the boundary between the site and no. 1 Woodcote Road. 6.06 This policy goes on to note that in terms of functionality new development must: - Incorporate vehicular access and egress which is satisfactorily located and laid out having regard to the need for highway safety – it is proposed to retain the extant access on Manchester Road, it is considered that given this access is extant it is satisfactory and appropriate. - Provide sufficient off-street car and cycle parking, manoeuvring and operational space – drawing M11-35-09, shows the proposed parking layout, this provides 19no. customer parking bays, 11no. service bays, 4no. MOT bays, 12no. allocated staff parking bays plus 15no. bays for demonstrator vehicles, 5no. cycle parking spaces and 5no. motorbike parking spaces. It should be noted that at present 18 parking spaces are provided for customers, and 35 spaces are marked out for staff and servicing combined. The remainder of the site is largely unmarked. The proposal comprises the provision of an additional 8 car parking spaces and 5 cycle parking spaces and 5 motorbike parking spaces (this figure has been reached through the use of the LPA’s standard of 1 space per 50sqm, as set out in SPD3), it is considered that this comprises significant and appropriate levels of parking in accordance with the LPA’s standard. - provide sufficient manoeuvring and operational space for service vehicles, as appropriate – it should be noted that large transporter vehicles do not access this site, new cars are delivered on transporters to the Salford HQ site and then transferred individually to the Altrincham dealership. It is proposed that this service arrangement remains in place and could be secured by condition. Doc ref: RRG1-3.001 Doc date: August 2012 Page 17 of 21 6.07 POLICY W1 notes that Broadheath will be retained and supported as a principal employment location in the south of the Borough. This policy acknowledges that the Council recognises the significant contribution that existing successful industries make to the economy of the Borough and will continue to support these industries where appropriate within the context of the Development Plan for Trafford. 6.08 Clearly this application seeks the expansion and strengthening of an extant local business. 6.09 Finally, the Framework asserts that the Government is committed to securing economic growth in order to create jobs and prosperity and goes on to state that the Government is committed to ensuring that the planning system does everything it can to support sustainable economic growth. Planning should operate to encourage and not act as an impediment to sustainable growth. Therefore significant weight should be placed on the need to support economic growth through the planning system. The Framework continues: “To help achieve economic growth, local planning authorities should plan proactively to meet the development needs of business and support an economy fit for the 21st century”…”LPAs should support existing business sectors, taking account of whether they are expanding or contracting and, where possible, identify and plan for new or emerging sectors likely to locate in their area. Policies should be flexible enough to accommodate needs not anticipated in the plan and to allow a rapid response to changes in economic circumstances.” Conclusion on the Principle of Development 6.10 It is considered that in light of the above assessment the proposed development is in accordance with the development plan and as such comprises sustainable development, and therefore in the context of the Framework should be “approved without delay”. The proposals would result in a successful business remaining in the local area providing a valuable source of employment. The dealership has Doc ref: RRG1-3.001 Doc date: August 2012 Page 18 of 21 operated from this site in excess of a decade and as such it is considered that the minimal extension to the display area would not materially impact upon residential amenity or the surrounding area. Impact on Residential Amenity 6.11 As the site is bounded to the north and west by residential dwellings it is important to assess the potential impact of the proposed development on residential amenity. 6.12 Firstly, it should be noted that the dealership is extant and has operated at this site in excess of a decade. The site would continue to be accessed via Manchester Road and as such no additional cars would access the site via Woodcote Road as a result of the development. 6.13 Core Strategy Policy L7 notes that in terms of amenity protection new development must: - Be compatible with the surrounding area – As the site is an existing car dealership and this has been the case for in excess of a decade it is considered to be a compatible use. - Not prejudice the amenity of the future occupiers of the development and/or occupants of adjacent properties by reason of overbearing, overshadowing, overlooking, visual intrusion, noise and/or disturbance, odour or in any other way – Again as the site is extant and has operated as a car dealership adjoining residential properties for over a decade the proposed extensions to the sales display area would not detrimentally impact upon residential amenity. The extended display area is proposed to be screened by carefully selected landscaping, including low shrub and hedge planting and the replacement, where possible, of any existing trees. This would retain and enhance residential amenity. Doc ref: RRG1-3.001 Doc date: August 2012 Page 19 of 21 6.14 The proposed extended display area would extend to the frontage to Woodcote Road and the boundary of no. 1 Woodcote Road. As can be seen on drawing numbers M11-35-09 and L001 boundary treatments are proposed to soften the visual appearance of the car display area onto Woodcote Road and specifically no.1 Woodcote Road, this boundary would be screened by proposed planting of shrubs, hedges and trees. The car display area would be arranged to capitalise on the Manchester Road frontage, it is not the intention to draw potential customers onto Woodcote Road, the entrance to the site would remain on Manchester Road and signs would clearly display this. At present and historically no. 289 Manchester Road has directly abutted the car display area with the approval of the LPA and further properties along Woodcote Road have backed onto the site without issue. In light of this it is considered that there would be no detrimental impact on residential amenity. Doc ref: RRG1-3.001 Doc date: August 2012 Page 20 of 21 7.00 CONCLUSION 7.01 The site is located on a busy and important arterial route through Trafford Borough and has been occupied by RRG for in excess of a decade. This application seeks the expansion of the display area to include land currently comprising nos. 289 and 291 Manchester Road. 7.02 The site already shares boundaries with residential properties, so it is not considered that the additional land would have any greater impact on nearby residential properties as the existing use would prevail. The additional land would allow for the display of vehicles and additional customer parking to be provided; uses which would not cause nuisance or disruption to the residential neighbours. In any event, suitable and sensitive boundary treatment would alleviate concerns of the neighbours (in particular those at no. 1 Woodcote Road). 7.03 It is asserted that the expansion of the car display area to include land at 289 and 291 Manchester Road, Altrincham would not be contrary to the development plan, or national planning policy. The site is located in a mixed use area which is dominated by commercial uses along the main road, so it is not considered that the extension of the car dealership onto the additional land would have an unacceptable impact on the character of the site and surroundings. 7.04 For the reasons as set out above, it is concluded that the development would be in accordance with the relevant local and national planning policy. Therefore in accordance with Section 38(6) of the Planning and Compulsory Purchase Act 2004, it is respectfully asserted that planning permission should be granted. Doc ref: RRG1-3.001 Doc date: August 2012 Page 21 of 21