FALL 2013 - Fenestration West Magazine
Transcription
FALL 2013 - Fenestration West Magazine
FALL 2013 • Fen-BC Conference 2013 Expert speakers, industry awards among highlights • Education in glazing Creating the University of the Fraser Valley • Bi-fold doors Innovations in a wide-open market BC’S LARGEST ALUMINUM EXTRUDER NEW 8” FRONT LOADING PRESS extruding premium quality profiles with two week lead times FULLY AUTOMATED ANODIZING LINE with 30 foot tanks to meet all design specifications AUTOMATED WAREHOUSING SYSTEM provides 1600 bundle capacity warehouse to maintain a stocking program for customers SCHEDULE A TOUR TODAY or request a quote. Visit www.apexextrusions.ca or call 604-882-3542 PROUDLY CANADIAN OWNED AND OPERATED IN LANGLEY, BC VOLUME 1 NUMBER 3 FALL 2013 in this issue... Features On the cover Glass skylights, curtain walls key to creation of University of the Fraser Valley. See page 14 Fenestration West is published quarterly on behalf of the Fenestration Association of BC (Fen-BC) by Market Assist Communications Inc. Publisher . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . J. Michael Siddall 604.740.8369 . . . . . . . . . . [email protected] Editor. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Frank O’Brien 778.996.2411 . . . . . . . . . . . . [email protected] Art Director . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Paddy Tennant 604.507.2162. . . . . . . . . . . [email protected] Assistant to the Publisher . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Peg Neilon 604.989.3452 . . . . . . . . . . . . [email protected] Fen-BC Executive Director. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Zana Gordon 604.855.0245. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . [email protected] Editorial Consultants Terry Adamson . . . . . . . . . . . . Westeck Windows Mfg Inc. 604.792.6700. . . . . . . . . . . [email protected] Debra Dotschkat . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . GC Glass Canada Inc. 250.454.9923 . . . . . . . . . [email protected] Al Jaugelis . . . . . . . . . . . . . RDH Building Engineering Ltd. 604.873.1181 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . [email protected] Leonard Pianalto . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . RJC 604.738.0048 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . [email protected] Katie Wilkinson . . . . . . . Stella Custom Glass Hardware Inc 604.231.5892 . . . . . . . . . . . . . [email protected] Contributing Writers Stéphane Hoffman • Robert Smithson PUBLICATIONS MAIL AGREEMENT NO. 42594527 RETURN UNDELIVERABLE CANADIAN ADDRESSES TO: Fenestration Association of BC PO Box 595, Abbotsford, BC V2T 6Z8 Fenestration West is printed on Pacesetter Dull 70lb text; 10% post consumer waste; Elemental Chlorine Free (ECF); Acid Free; FSC Certified While information contained in this publication has been compiled from sources deemed to be reliable, neither the publisher nor the Fenestration Association of BC (Fen-BC) will be held liable for errors or omissions. The opinions expressed in the editorial and advertisements are not necessarily those of the publisher or Fen-BC. Fenestration West Conference 2013 Speakers, sessions and Fen-BC awards. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Bi-fold doors Architects and new hardware open up market niche . . . . . . 8 Recycling window glass Costs challenge innovative two-year program . . . . . . . . . . 10 Project profile Cover story: University of the Fraser Valley . . . . . . . . . . . . 14 Member profile Westeck a leader in the fenestration industry . . . . . . . . . . . 20 On the cutting edge New developments in windows, doors and glass: stackable sliding doors; backpainted glass walls; one-sided bullet-proof glass; wood-trimmed hybrid curtain walls; door lock controlled by smart phone . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26 Acoustic performance of windows e need for proper seals, wider spacers, heavier glass . . . 29 Association News Messages from the Board . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Fen-BC task group addresses NAFS labeling. . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Technical bulletin: energy performance requirements . . . 13 Fen-BC educational seminars coming up . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 Fen-BC hosts pre-hangers meeting. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 Industry Items Vancouver Building Bylaw released . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Outlook: Major projects in North hit record high; Metro Vancouver spending down . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 Commercial daylighting: more than opening blinds . . . . . 12 WorkSafeBC: trangressions costly . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 National Building Code under review . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 Win-Door conference coming to Toronto . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19 Alberta plans for construction surge . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19 Korea sees ‘invisible’ tower rising . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24 Triple-paned BC 4-plex nets national green award . . . . . . 25 Columns Legal View Robert Smithson: Probationary periods: be certain the employee fits the job. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28 Technical Talk Tougher codes will drive demand for higher performance glazing and frames . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 30 FENESTRATION WEST / Fall 2013 3 We did it! Fenestration Association of BC has completed its first year and it was a busy one. Come out and help us celebrate this milestone at our AGM on Debra Dotschkat, Chair, October 22, 2013. Fenestration Association of BC e following day, October 23, will see our annual conference which is always very informative and well attended. We have a great line-up of speakers and we will see our panel discussions again this year. If you would like to help shape your industry there is still time to put your name forward to be on our board of directors. e past year has seen many new members as a result of all our work on code regulations and working with Government. Most of our training seminars and information packages can only be received by members to show the value of membership! So if you haven’t already, now is the time to join! “ This Code change will have more impact on the fenestration industry than any other in our history. www.fen-bc.org Our website has been launched and tweaked (not twerking) over the year and is the go-to place for all the association, school and magazine information. anks to all the directors on the board as well as the many volunteers that helped the association have a great year. We look forward to working with you all again in the future! – Debra Dotschkat, GC Glass Canada; Chair, Fenestration Association of BC n Change for the good As I write this, I see it is exactly 80 days to December 19. Are you ready? December 19 is transition day for windows and doors and the 2012 BC Building Code. In my almost 30 years in this business I have never heard so much talk about a new code implementation. Justifiably so. is Code change will have more impact on the fenestration industry than any other in our history. And yet there are so many in the industry that are sitting on the sidelines, watching to see what happens. I’ve said it before and, yes, I will say it again: Code improvements and changes are good for the industry. It is not the Code that is the problem; it is how poorly it is enforced. So, kudos to all you guys working hard to be ready; I know you’re out there, compliant products are in the works, with many ready. As the Code rolls out think about your time and investment. To the guys that are just waiting, you should also think about the time and investments made by those that are preparing for inevitable change. ” Terry Adamson Vice-Chair, Residential – Terry Adamson, Westeck Windows & Doors; Vice-Chair, Residential, Fenestration Association of BC n Much ado about NAFS labeling Vancouver bylaw comes in March 1, 2014 LANGLEY – Fen-BC has a task group working with Fenestration Canada to prepare a label reference document for window manufacturers who are preparing products for the NAFS Canadian Supplement (NAFS-08), with more details available at the Fen-BC conference this October. But, as noted by Al Jaugelis, technical director of Fen-BC and a fenestration specialist with RDH Building Engineering, window consumers should be alert to the potential of mislabeling of window products “deliberately or not.” Only windows that have been tested to the NAFS-08 standard are eligible for labels and allowed to be installed in BC as of December 20 of this year. Manufacturers print their own labels under the ‘honour system’, Jaugelis notes, which could open opportunities for abuse. Here are some things to watch for: • If the window deflects under finger pressure, the label is suspect. • If the window has a size or configuration that no one is likely to have tested, the window is suspect. • If there are multiple NAFS labels on a product, the labels are suspect. Consumers are urged to ask for test or engineering reports if they doubt the label. n e new City of Vancouver Building Bylaw will come fully into effect on March 1, 2014, if city staff recommendations are accepted. For Part 3 (commercial) buildings, the bylaw will become effective with the enforcement of the BC Building Code on December 20, 2013. e City released its 2014 Building Bylaw in September, noting that the revised Code is a “first of three incremental steps” to bring one- and two-family homes towards carbon neutral new construction, with future updates planned in 2017 and 2020. For Part 3 buildings, the Bylaw references the 2010 version of ASHRAE (American Society of Heating, Refrigeration and Air-conditioning Engineers) 90.1, which is also adopted by the new BC Building Code. However, the bylaw allows the option of meeting energy efficiency goals under the standards of the National Energy Code for Buildings 2011 (NECB 2011), “subject to minor revisions to ensure consistency between the two standards.” e bylaw will require windows in residential (Part 9) buildings to have lower U-values than is currently mandated under the BC Energy Efficiency Act. e bylaw requires that all entry doors have a “clear opening” of at least 865 mm (34 inches) and that all interior doors have an opening of 800 mm (31.4 inches). For the complete Vancouver Building Bylaw report, see http://former.vancouver.ca/ctyclerk/cclerk/20130924/documents/ rr1.pdf, or visit the Fenestration Association of BC web site at www.fen-bc.org. n 4 FENESTRATION WEST / Fall 2013 NEW TOOLS! NEW RESOU RESOURCES! RCES! CANADA’S PREMIER GLASS FABRICATOR HAS A NEW WEBSITE Visit vitrum.ca to explore, compare and view all of the architectural glass offerings Vitrum has to offer - like you’ve never seen before. >> View Vitrum’s extensive collection of architectural glass products. >> Design It, Create It, Build It! Our interactive design tool. >> Browse our Project Galler y and get inspired to design with glass. >> Request samples or obtain further product inf ormation. Learn more about designing and building with glass from Canada’s Premier Glass Fabricator at vitrum.ca vitrum.ca.. Fenestration West Conference 2013 Specifying the Energy Performance of Glazing Products in BC Fen-BC is proud to present Fenestration West 2013. Conference sessions cover safety, efficiency and sustainability: the new 2012 BC Building Code; the current best practices for replacing windows and doors; NAFS-08 and its impact on the fenestration industry, and much more. Meet, mix, network, learn and enjoy the facilities of the fabulous Delta Hotel Burnaby. Speakers & Sessions The Architectural Institute of BC’s Continuing Education System recognizes these sessions as Core Learning Units. Dynamic Electrochromatic Programmable Glass n Presenter: John Carpenter – president, Clearstream Architectural Products Ltd Dynamic Electrochromatics are programmable insulated glazing units that self adjust or can be overridden on demand. View Dynamic Glass eliminates the need for external shading devices and internal blinds, eliminates glare and solar heat gain as required but can be programmed to allow solar heat gain during cold weather months, and is bird friendly. 0.75 AIBC Core Learning Units 6 n Panel Leader: Leonard Pianalto – RJC Since the introduction of the British Columbia Energy Efficiency Act (“the Act”) in 2009 by the provincial government, the glazing industry, in combination with the engineering and architectural communities, is facing shared challenges with meeting the requirements of the Act. In particular, the following questions arise with respect to fenestration: 1. What projects fall under the jurisdiction of the Energy Efficiency Act, and when is ASHRAE 90.1 applicable? 2. Who is responsible for ensuring compliance with the Act? 3. How is enforcement managed? 4. What are the thermal performance requirements for different projects? 5. How can thermal modeling and testing of performance be incorporated pre-tender? 6. What are the labeling and documentation requirements? Our panel will summarize the collaborative efforts of a task force comprised of representatives from Fen-BC, the Ministry of Energy and Mines, APEG-BC and AIBC to implement changes to the complex window industry supply process, from specifications all the way through to construction. 0.75 AIBC Core Learning Units Panelists: Leonard Pianalto, RJC; Alex McGowan, Levelton; more panelists to be added FENESTRATION WEST / Fall 2013 Acoustic performance of windows n Presenter: Briét (“Brizi”) Coetzer, BSc (Eng), MMus – BKL Consultants Urban planners in most Metro Vancouver municipalities have requirements in place to ensure that new residential projects proposed for high noise environments will be designed to achieve acceptable interior noise levels. Although exterior walls, roofs, doors and ventilation will sometimes require upgrading, it is usually the windows that are the controlling factor with respect to interior levels. Even where there are no specific requirements imposed by municipalities, designers may need to pay careful attention to the acoustic performance of windows where noise sensitive buildings such as residences, hotels, churches, schools and hospitals are involved. In order to effectively select and specify windows in such cases, it is important to understand the many parameters that affect sound attenuation as well as the standards used to specify acoustic performance. is presentation will provide a brief discussion of basic acoustics, an explanation of single number ratings such as STC and OITC, examples of municipal government requirements, discussion of the various parameters affecting the sound transmission through windows and the inter-relationships between the acoustic performance of windows and other exterior building components. 0.75 AIBC Core Learning Units e key to predicting the effects and Building the water-tight side practical considerations of thermal hinged door – hardware bridging for building assemblies performance – lessons learned (panel) n Presenter: Catherine Lemieux – Morrison Hershfield e majority of thermal performance calculations used in today’s North American codes and standards take into consideration thermal bridging from framing in the field of the wall, yet they do not consider heat loss at thermal bridges such as shelf angles and exposed slabs. is can result in the use of inflated thermal performance values in design calculations, and may lead to inappropriate mechanical systems design, potential moisture problems and compromised occupant comfort. e presentation will focus on how to accurately account for thermal bridging in design of assemblies, evaluate relative impact on whole building energy performance and consider design implications associated with energy improved / efficient details. n Panel Leader: Terry Adamson – Technical Director, Westeck Windows and Doors is panel discussion will lead the audience to consider that although the new door standards are very challenging, success is possible. Without giving away all of our hard work secrets the panelists will provide some direction to the audience on what has been successful and where the bigger challenges and pitfalls are that they fought through. For example, it has been their experience that once you have figured out water, the structural challenges are far bigger mountains to climb. 0.75 AIBC Core Learning Units Panelists: Terry Adamson, Westeck Windows and Doors; Brian Hepburn, Slegg Lumber; Darryl McIntosh, Lynden Door; Kevin Saito, QAI; Jack Sharpe, Oakmont Industries; Anton Van Dyk, Centra Windows 2013 Fen-BC Awards Fen-BC recognizes and honours those individuals and companies that have gone above and beyond in advancing the progress of our industry, or in service to the association. Below are the award categories: • Fen-BC Member of the Year (Company); • Residential Project Excellence Award (Company); • Commercial Project Excellence Award (Company); • Outstanding Individual Award (Individual); • Community Contribution Award (Company or Individual); • Fen-BC Volunteer of the Year (Individual). n 0.75 AIBC Core Learning Units Art Gallery of Alberta image courtesy of Randall Stout Architects, Inc., Copyright 2010 ADVANCED FENESTRATION SOLUTIONS FOR ENHANCED PERFORMANCE BRITISH COLUMBIA For more than a century, Kawneer has been the leading manufacturer of architectural aluminum products and systems for commercial construction. And, for the past 30 years, we have proudly served western Canada with quality products from our Lethbridge, Alberta facility. A dynamic product portfolio including curtain wall, windows, entrances, storefront framing systems and sun control, delivers enhanced performance and superior results. From thermal efficiency and water ingress resistance, to sustainability and blast/impact resistance, Kawneer is committed to providing western Canada with products and systems that not only meet, but exceed, the stringent design and performance requirements of this region. Chris Lambert, 604.552.4202, [email protected] Dave McCannell, 604.469.6342, [email protected] ALBERTA Paul Gulkiewich, 403.485.6505, [email protected] MANITOBA / SASKATCHEWAN Mike Washnuk, 204.257.0177, [email protected] kawneer.com Architectural Aluminum Systems Entrances + Framing Curtain Walls Windows © 2013 Kawneer Company, Inc. FENESTRATION WEST / Fall 2013 7 Eclipse hardware, from the DS Group, is used by the majority of bi-fold door manufacturers serving the BC market. The elite system is capable of supporting weights up to 220 pounds per panel. Photo: The DS Group ARCHITECTS, NEW HARDWARE PUSH OPEN A MARKET NICHE By Dermot Mack A stunning million-dollar-plus house in the Cape development on Bowen Island, designed by West Vancouver architect Allan Peters, had one feature that defined its location: a set of massive NanaWall System bi-fold doors that opened the entire living room to the deck and its view over Howe Sound. For its 67-unit GlassLos condo development on the New Westminster waterfront, designed by Ramsay Worden Architects, Aragon Properties is installing floor-to-ceiling glass doors that slide like an accordion to each side, opening the living and dining room to spectacular Fraser River views. And, in cities and towns across BC, big folding glass doors are opening up restaurant and bar patios for easy access and extra seating. “When we started offering Eclipse bi-fold doors in 2001, people told me they would never sell, yet now they are hugely popular,” said Chris Kamensek, president of the DS Group of Burnaby. Some industry insiders estimate that up to 90 percent of the bi-fold doors sold in BC now sport Eclipse hardware, and leading window and door manufacturers, such as Anderson, Loewen and Marvin, specify them. e latest evolution is the Eclipse E3, a premier bi-fold system for larger folding doors. It has been designed for strength – it can support 220 pound panels – and medium to large residential and commercial applications. Stainless steel bearings in the pivots and carriers allow even the largest doors to be moved with “fingertip ease” between the open and closed positions, according to the company. “Most window and door sales are flat this year,” Kamensek noted, “but demand for bi-folds is tracking straight up.” Rated as “special product” Yet, despite their rapidly growing popularity, folding exterior doors are not addressed under the new NAFS-08 standard in the BC Building Code, Vancouver TV personality Natalie Langston tugs open the NanaWall System folding glass doors on a high-end Bowen Island house. Photo: Paul Duchart 8 FENESTRATION WEST / Fall 2013 Folding glass doors open an entire wall to Fraser River views at the GlassLofts condominium project in New Westminster, by Aragon Properties. Photo: Aragon Properties which addresses Part 9 (small residential) buildings. For Code compliance, folding doors must be tested and rated as ‘Special Products’, explained Murray Frank, president of Constructive Home Solutions Inc. “NAFS-8 specifically excludes a number of products normally considered commercial glazing products,” Frank told a seminar on the new Code, “such as curtain wall, storefront and commercial entrance systems.” Meanwhile, hardware makers are rolling out new bi-fold systems that promise to make the doors even more popular in new homes and renovations. An example is U.S.-based Truth Hardware, which introduced its new Sentry Bi-Fold Hardware System into Canada this year. e multi-lock system includes a patented hinge design, according to Truth. e company also claims that the preset carrier and guide hinges allow faster installation. Long-time bi-fold door manufacturer Westeck Windows and Doors of Chilliwack, however, has opted for a New Zealand hardware package, the Centor Systems. “We have sold thousands of bi-fold doors, some as high as eight feet,” said Westeck general manager Neal Turner. Turner said Westeck has looked at other bi-fold hardware but believes Centor is the best in the business. Centor’s latest folding door innovation is the F3 bottom-rolling system that can be installed in any opening that formerly held a sliding door. e F3 transfers the door weight to the bottom, so there is no need for a strong overhead structural beam. is means folding doors can be installed without structural adjustments, according to Centor. n Truth Hardware has introduced its new Sentry Bi-Fold Hardware System into Canada this year. Photo: Truth Hardware FENESTRATION WEST / Fall 2013 9 New windows for older MURBs Bin of waste glass: recycler can take all types of windows at lower cost than landfills. Photos: Action Glass Costs challenge innovative two-year old program By Frank O’Brien e first BC recycling business capable of turning waste window glass into an industrial sandblasting material is threatened by rising costs at its Abbotsford facility. Enviro-Corp Recycling [a Division of United Concrete & Gravel Ltd.], which recycles huge volumes of glass containers, is taking in waste windows of all types, trucking it to its crushing plant in Quesnel and turning the glass into Enviro-Grit, which is widely used as an inert sandblasting material in the pipeline industry. Fen-BC member Brad Johnston of Action Glass Inc. of Burnaby, which specializes in glass and window replacement, sees the Enviro-Corp system as badly needed in the industry – and Metro Vancouver agrees. Action Glass generates about 6.5 tonnes of waste window glass per week, all of which was previously dumped at Metro Vancouver landfills at a fee of $107 per tonne. Enviro-Corp is charging $55 per 10 tonne, according to Enviro-Corp manager Wayne Elias, who noted the site can accept any type of commercial or residential window glass, even in PVC or aluminum frames. Rare in BC, Enviro-Corp has access to the heavy-duty crushing and grinding equipment needed to recycle dense window glass into a marketable material. Costs mounting However, Elias said Enviro-Corp’s window glass recycling might not be able to continue unless the cost structure changes. When Enviro-Corp started the process two years ago it was less expensive because, at the time, it was running trucks empty to its Quesnel crushing plant and hauling backhaul material south to Abbotsford. e window glass helped supplement shipping. Today, however, the backhaul business has waned and so the cost for hauling the heavy glass has increased. Elias said Enviro-Corp would need commitments of large volumes of window glass and would likely have to increase dumping fees to make recycling feasible. Aside from that, his five-acre Abbotsford FENESTRATION WEST / Fall 2013 site is already heavily committed to recycled bottle glass. “We would have to find more space if the window glass volume increased,” he said. Enviro-Corp likes to have at least a five-year supply of recyclable glass on hand. Volumes increasing A Metro Vancouver spokesman noted that there are very limited options for window or plate glass recycling. “Its high density makes it uneconomical to ship long distances so recycling options are reliant on proximity of specialized recyclers,” said Bill Morrell. “Enviro Grit sounds like [it] could fill a need.” at need is apparently increasing. In the City of Vancouver, for example, house demolition permits increased 84.7 percent from 2009 to 2012. In the Dunbar area alone, an average of 75 houses are coming down every year. Add that to the waste from window manufacturing and commercial demolition and renovation projects, and the mountain of landfilled window and door glass continues to grow. As Action Glass’s Brad Johnston summed up, “What a waste.” n I N D U S T R Y O U T L O O K Major BC projects set record as North leads VANCOUVER – Total capital cost of major projects in BC hit a record high in the second quarter of 2013 on a surge in proposed LNG projects in the north, according to the Association of Consulting Engineering Companies – British Columbia (ACEC-BC)’s BC MPI Review. But in the key commercial and residential sector so important to fenestration, growth was moderate with a 2.4 percent increase from a year earlier. e BC MPI Review is a quarterly report that provides analysis on the Province of British Columbia’s Major Projects Inventory. Total capital cost of major projects in BC reached $299.4 billion in the second quarter of 2013, representing an 8.8 percent jump over the previous quarter and 26.5 percent higher than one year earlier. Total capital cost represents the combined value of projects identified as proposed, construction started, completed and on hold. Keith Sashaw, ACEC-BC president and CEO, notes that spinoffs from the resource projects could have a “profound effect” in northern construction of commercial and residential projects. e North Coast region reported a large 45.7 percent jump in proposed projects to $99.3 billion in the second quarter from the previous quarter and propelled the year-to-year gain to 137.5 percent. e key drivers of this gain were the Pacific Northwest LNG and the Prince Rupert LNG projects. Combined with the manufacturing sectors’ proposed Kitimat oil refinery and related project investments, resource-related projects account for more than $50 billion. e North Coast region continued to have the highest proposed and total capital cost dollar amount of any region in the province. e overall manufacturing sector saw a 45.4 percent increase to $28.8 billion in the second quarter almost exclusively on the proposed Kitimat oil refinery and related project investments. Total project costs for residential and commercial projects reached $58.8 billion, a growth of only 2.4 percent over the previous quarter, with proposed projects down slightly, the report found. n Construction pace – and prices – slow VANCOUVER – Non-residential construction spending in Metro Vancouver was down from the first quarter in the second quarter of this year, due in large part to a drop in industrial spending, according to the Vancouver Regional Construction Association. Prices for construction materials were also lower. Metro Vancouver saw a 1.8 percent drop in total non-residential building construction in the second quarter of 2013 to $890.4 million seasonally adjusted, from $906.7 million in the first quarter of 2013. Commercial building construction edged down 1 percent to $591.6 million, institutional-government rose 1.3 percent to $247.5 million, while industrial building construction investment fell 20.7 percent to $51.3 million from the first quarter of 2013. “e current economic slowdown will likely continue through 2013 before growth picks up in 2014 and beyond, which bodes well for higher private sector investment in 2015,” the Association cautions. Building construction prices declined for the first time since early 2010, with the second quarter 2013 index edging down to 98.3 compared to 99.4 in the first quarter in Metro Vancouver, resulting in a 0.6 percent year-over-year price decline. n FENESTRATION WEST / Fall 2013 11 Effective daylighting at the offices of the Centre for Digital Media, Vancouver. Photo: Light House How commercial daylighting is figured Modern office buildings and other commercial spaces oen rely on daylighting – that is natural light through windows and doors – to create more efficient and pleasant business spaces. But it is more than just opening the blinds, according to Light House, the Vancouver centre for sustainable construction consulting. e following, provided by Curtis Dorosh, manager Green Building Services at Light House, are the guidelines for “sidelighting,” also known as windows: When designing for commercial daylighting, the model should be “that 75 percent or more of all regularly occupied spaces achieve daylight illuminance levels of a minimum of 250 Lux (25 footcandles) and a maximum of 5,000 Lux (500 footcandles) in a clear sky condition on March 21 or September 21 at 9:00 am and 3:00 pm; areas with illuminance levels below or above the range do not comply. However, designs that incorporate view-preserving automated shades for glare control may demonstrate compliance for only the minimum 250 Lux (25 footcandles) illuminance level.” Under the prescriptive method for windows, the calculations are even more complex: “Achieve a value, calculated as the product of the visible light transmittance (VLT) and window-to-floor area ratio (WFR) of daylight zone between 0.150 and 0.180. e window area included in the calculation must be at least 0.76 metres (30 inches) above the floor. (0.150 < VLT X WFR < 0.180).” e daylight must also provide sunlight redirection and/or glare control devices to ensure daylight effectiveness. n Safety transgressions can be costly National Building Code under review WorkSafeBC carries a big stick when it comes to maximum penalties for employers who flaunt safety regulations. Under the Workers Compensation Act, all employers, workers and others connected with work must comply with the Act and the Occupational Health and Safety Regulation. WorkSafeBC can levy an administrative penalty against an employer for: failing to take sufficient precautions against workplace accidents, injuries or illness; not complying with the health and safety requirements of the Act and Regulation, or with any order; or for having an unsafe workplace or working conditions. If the employer acted with reasonable care, an administrative penalty cannot be issued. WorkSafeBC cannot impose an administrative penalty on anyone other than an employer. If an employer is convicted of an offence, the maximum fine for a first offence is a fine of up to $589,010, plus up to $29,450.52 per day that the offence continued beyond the first. For subsequent convictions, he or she can face a fine of up to $1,178,019.98, plus up to $58,901 per day that the offence continued beyond the first. Imprisonment can be for up to six months for the first offence, and one year for any subsequent ones. Furthermore, if the offender gained financial benefits as a result of the offence, the court can order that the offender pay an additional fine equal to the amount of that financial benefit. n Public review on proposed changes to the 2010 National Model Construction Codes starts October 15, 2013 12 e Canadian Commission on Building and Fire Codes (CCBFC) invites interested parties to take part in the Fall 2013 public review of proposed changes to the 2010 National Model Construction Codes. e National Model Construction Codes, comprising the National Building, Fire, Plumbing and Energy Codes, are model codes developed by the CCBFC that the provinces and territories can adopt as is, or with modifications, as part of their building, fire and plumbing regulations. e public review is one of the principal steps in the process for updating national code documents, providing a nation-wide forum where anyone can review and comment on the changes proposed. Following the review, CCBFC Standing Committees will consider all comments and make final recommendations on each proposed change. Subject to approval by the CCBFC, the final changes will be published by the National Research Council in the 2015 editions of the National Model Construction Codes. e public review will run from October 15 until December 13, 2013 on the National Codes web site, www.nationalcodes.nrc.gc.ca. For further information, contact Anne Gribbon, Secretary to the CCBFC, at [email protected]. n FENESTRATION WEST / Fall 2013 A S S O C I A T I O N N E W S Bulletin issued on energy and BC Building Code VICTORIA – e Building and Safety Standards Branch has issued an information bulletin providing more information about changes to the 2012 BC Building Code that add energy performance requirements to both Part 3 and Part 9 buildings. e Part 3 requirements apply for permits taken on or aer December 20, 2013. e Part 9 requirements apply for permits taken on or aer December 19, 2014. It is published as Technical Bulletin B13-05 on the website of the Ministry of Energy, Mines and Natural Gas – Office of Housing and Construction Standards (www.housing.gov.bc.ca). Association members interested in engaging with these issues may be interested in joining Fen-BC’s Commercial Energy Issues Task Group and/or the Residential Energy Issues Task Group. For more information, contact Fen-BC. n Fen-BC educational seminars coming up e Fenestration Association of BC is offering a series of full-day educational sessions and members are urged to register. All sessions will be presented at the Fen-BC training facility at Unit #101, 20351 Duncan Way in Langley. • How to be a Better Foreman December 10, 8:00am - 4:00pm • Negotiating Skills December 17, 8:00am - 4:00pm • Hazard Recognition and Control December 19, 8:00am - 4:00pm n Any entry door must confirm to NAFS-8 standards. Photo: Dano Screen Meeting called on side-hinged doors LANGLEY – On September 10, Fen-BC hosted a successful meeting of prehangers with 82 industry participants, regarding preparation for the rollout of the new NAFS Canadian Supplement, which now covers side-hinged doors. Under Part 9 of the new BC Building Code, side-hinged doors are defined as any exterior door on a house, separating conditioned from unconditioned spaces. A follow-up meeting is now set for November 7. As noted by Zana Gordon, executive director of Fen-BC, “this is a prime opportunity to reach prospective customers before the December 20, 2013 NAFS enforcement deadline.” e dra agenda for this meeting includes a buffet luncheon from 11:30 a.m., followed by an update on side-hinged door developments across the country. A feature presentation, “How to get your doors NAFS tested without going out of business” looks at the business case for NAFS-tested side-hinged doors and shows how to tailor the investment to the business opportunity. is presentation, by Jean-François Kogovsek of Maxam Marketing in Quebec, should help decision-makers decide when to test their own products and when to buy tested systems from others. ere will also be a supplier showcase, with each supplier presenting a brief overview of his or her products. For complete information, contact Fen-BC. n FENESTRATION WEST / Fall 2013 SERVICE AND QUALITY BEYOND EXPECTATION TEMPERED • INSULATED LAMINATED • FABRICATED The preferred supplier of fabricated glass products PFG Glass Industries 604 607 4500 www.pfgglass.com MEMBER 13 PROJECT PROFILE Installation of a 200-foot-long skylight above the central atrium The original buildings were stripped to the metal studs, and the old building envelope stripped off and replaced. Innovative glazing transforms military complex into light-filled university By Frank O’Brien Photos: Stantec A dark and defunct old military compound in Chilliwack has been transformed into the light-filled University of the Fraser Valley in a massive renovation that recruits innovative glazing and a 260-foot-long skylighted atrium that pulls it all together. e five-building complex was built in 1998 by the Department of National Defence but had 14 FENESTRATION WEST / Fall 2013 been intermittently occupied, explains architect Ray Wolfe, a senior associate at Vancouver-based Stantec, which acted as architects and engineers on the $31 million makeover that went on to capture international recognition. ough never used, the military buildings were “in very bad shape” and required extensive upgrading, he added, with the project aimed at LEED gold standards. Each of the structures was a stand-alone building, connected by underground tunnels. “ere were virtually no windows in most of the walls,” Wolfe said. idea “weThehadbest was to stitch the buildings together with a giant atrium that used glass for daylighting. ” 83-metre (260-foot) skylight covers the “atrium spine” that pulls the renovation project together. The atrium is covered by a skylight and sheathed in glass and slim wood sections for sunshading. The atrium is also lit by an 11-metre (36-foot) curtain wall, with steel supports in the mullions. One building had to be demolished and all of the buildings were gutted to the metal studs and then re-clad in metal panels and connected together with the giant glass-and-wood sheathed atrium. Glastech Glazing A number of glazing options – supplied by Fenestration Association of BC member Glastech Glazing Ltd. of Port Coquitlam – were installed during the 20-month rebuild. And, says Wolfe, the project’s aesthetic and functionality hinged on the daylighting. Windows are Kawneer1600 double-pane glazing with low-e coating and argon gas with thermally-broken aluminum frames. e windows are set into custom-extruded caps, corners and frames mounted by Stantec into the metal-clad walls supplied by Lam Metal Contracting Ltd. of Burnaby. “e best idea we had was to stitch the buildings together FENESTRATION WEST / Fall 2013 15 The completed University of the Fraser Valley was recognized by 2013 international World Architectural News for Best in Class University Buildings for Vancouver-based Stantec. with a giant atrium that used glass for daylighting. It is that atrium spine that creates the views and the space for students and staff to collaborate and connect. e atrium is what really transformed the old buildings into a first-class university,” Wolfe explains. Innovation When complete, the former 100,000-square-feet complex had been expanded to a 165,000-square-foot university, highlighted with the 260-foot by 20-foot atrium that has breakout areas for study space. e two-storey atrium is capped with a skylight that runs its entire length. e skylight is designed to minimize roof snowloads. It also has operable windows on the sides to allow for fresh air ventilation. e atrium is finished with a 36-foot tall curtainwall that is supported by steel inside its mullions. e atrium glazing is covered by fixed-in-place, slim wood sections for sunshading. One of the other glazing innovations was the installation of fire-rated safety glass separation from offices and an adjoining classroom. Wolfe credited consultant Bill May from Protection Engineering Ltd. for coming up with the idea and the material. e solution was SCG 16 FENESTRATION WEST / Fall 2013 Project: University of the Fraser Valley Cost: $31 million Architect/Engineering: Stantec Structural Engineering: Equilibrium Engineering, Stantec General Contractor: Stuart Olson Dominion Construction Roofing Contractor: Flynn Canada, Surrey Metal Wall Cladding: Lam Metal Contracting Ltd. Glazing: Glastech Glazing Ltd. FENESTRATION WEST / Fall 2013 17 fire-rated safety glass] has “the[Theequivalent fire rating of a five-inch concrete wall. ” Stantec designed custom-made aluminum fins and caps to mount the aluminum-framed Kawneer 1600 glazing. Installation of all windows was by Glastech Glazing Ltd. of Port Coquitlam. Contraflam 60 glazing from France-based Saint-Gobain International AG. “It has the equivalent fire rating of a five-inch concrete wall,” said Stantec architect Ivan Velikov. is five-layer glazing cost $400 per square foot. 18 Also, lead equivalent glass was installed in a dental classroom lab. e ¼-inch thick glazing provided x-ray protection equal to a lead-lined wall. As well, structural glass panels were used as guardrails on three suspended bridges that link the classroom buildings together. e entire project took 20 months to complete and came on in budget at $207 per square foot, which included a geothermal field and a “chilled beam” HVAC system. It is forecast to be 60 percent more efficient than the former University of the Fraser Valley campus it replaced. e new school was ready for the first students in September 2012. It went on to gain international recognition as the WAN 2013 Best in Class University Buildings from World Architecture News. “It’s a tremendous honour for our Stantec team to be recognized on the international stage,” commented Mark Travis, Stantec’s lead design architect for the UFV project. “is was a unique undertaking with intricate challenges, and to be recognized along with well-known architects from around the world really speaks to the quality of design that our team achieved, in addition to the strong relationship we were able to establish with UFV.” Based in London, the annual WAN Education Awards are a major international competition judged by a panel of renowned architects and designers from around the globe. n FENESTRATION WEST / Fall 2013 Win-Door will be held November 12-14 at the Metro Toronto Convention Centre. Photo: Win-Door Win-Door conference set for Toronto TORONTO – Win-Door 2013 is regarded as one of the best fenestration shows in the industry and it will boast more than 100,000 square feet of exhibit space, 150 exhibitors and 3,500 delegates when it opens this November 12 in Toronto for a three-day run. e annual show at the Metro Toronto Convention Centre features machinery, doors, hardware, the latest computer soware, testing services and much more for the window and door industries. For exhibitors and attendees, it’s the yearly face-to-face place to do business. ere is also an extensive series of seminars, demonstrations and expert speakers, according to organizers. e event also includes Fenestration Canada’s annual general meeting, with information on code updates, technical committees and Energy Star updates. For information and registration for Win-Door 2013, visit http://windoorshow.com or phone 416-445-5225. n Big window contract looms in Alberta EDMONTON – e Alberta government will call for bids this year for the construction of 19 new schools in nine different high-growth communities. e Request for Proposals has been issued and will be awarded in the summer of 2014. It should be of interest to BC window suppliers and contractors, because, according to the government, all of the schools will feature “large windows that provide natural lighting.” It is all part of a $503 million Alberta plans to spend on school construction over the next three years. n FENESTRATION WEST / Fall 2013 19 MEMBER PROFILE Westeck Windows and Doors Westeck manufacturers a variety of bi-fold doors. Shown is a version as 1L3R, meaning 1 left 3 right. Photo: Westeck Homegrown innovation keeps Chilliwack firm a leader in the fenestration industry By Frank O’Brien Westeck Windows and Doors of Chilliwack is well known for its industry breakthroughs in product, design and colours but it is from-the-floor manufacturing innovations that perhaps best explain how Westeck has remained a BC industry leader for 14 years. Westeck, formed in 1999 by Casey Kerkhoff, began as a “vinyl window maker just like everyone else,” said general manager Neal Turner. Two key inventions, however, soon put Westeck onto a different and faster track. “We developed a PVC casement window with a solid fir interior. It is called our Combo window and it took the market by storm,” said Terry Adamson, Westeck’s technical director. Westeck then became the first BC vinyl window manufacturer to paint vinyl frames 20 in any colour the Eighty percent of Westeck windows client requested. are sold into the new home market. “ose two things propelled us into the custom window market.” Westeck soon became the go-to manufacturer for custom home builders, quality home renovations and high-end multiple-unit residential developers seeking the right combination of window performance and colours such as black, bronze and silver, aesthetics. Eighty percent of Westeck remains one of Westeck’s top sellers. As windows are sold into the new home Turner explains, the design allows market. customization in that feature rooms can e combo window, now known as the sport all fir interiors while the entire project PVC 4000 Combo Casement in designer will have identical profiles on the exterior. FENESTRATION WEST / Fall 2013 Specials Department Supervisor Josh McGinnis displays oval vinyl window frame. General Manager Neal Turner and Terry Adamson, Technical Director ...there is more interest in the “ window and door industry now in BC than at any time in history. ” Natural-gas fueled PVC profile prep machine, designed by Westeck founder Casey Kerkhoff, can prepare 18 lineal feet of vinyl for paint in under 15 seconds. Innovation Westeck encourages its 120 frontline manufacturing staff to be innovative, and the encouragement has paid off with at least two breakthroughs that reduced cost and created better products. One example is a PVC paint preparation machine, designed by Casey Kerkoff and built in Westeck’s Chilliwack plant. e natural gas-fueled machine can prepare an 18-foot length of vinyl for painting in less than 15 seconds. Another is a hot air bending tube machine that replaced the use of expensive and messy glycerin oil commonly used to produce rounded vinyl products, such as oval windows. e bender machine, now used daily, was developed by a long-time Westeck employee. Complete manufacturer Westeck is a complete manufacturer, not just a fabricator. e company produces its own sealed units, and specialty glazing. “We cut and assemble our own sealed units using Edgetech’s warm edge foam SuperSpacer. Having that additional control gives a great deal of flexibility to meet rush unit orders or quickly create a replacement FENESTRATION WEST / Fall 2013 if something goes wrong on the loading dock or in the field,” Turner explained. Because of Westeck’s ability to provide a variety of products (vinyl, aluminum, wood and Combo windows, as well as an extensive line of standard and custom wood, aluminum, steel, fiberglass and metal clad doors, including bi-folding exterior doors), Westeck has become a “one stop” manufacturer for builders and homeowners. While primarily a supplier to the BC market, Westeck’s windows are also shipped across Canada and to the United States where they are popular in heritage renovations and higher-end single family homes, condominium and townhouse developments. Westeck also offers a robust vinyl window, based on European tilt-and-turn technology, as a challenger to aluminum-framed windows in the commercial market. “We believe it will see wider acceptance as the new Energy Codes become enforced,” Turner said. Meeting the Code Like all window and door manufacturers, Westeck is prepared for the enforcement this December of the new North American Fenestration Standard known as NAFS-08 and the Canadian Supplement, as part of the 2012 BC Building Code. 21 In-house designed and built PVC profile heating oven reduces the cost and mess of bending vinyl frames into virtually any shape Westeck custom windows are often requested for contemporary high-end custom homes. Photo: Westeck Windows and Doors 22 FENESTRATION WEST / Fall 2013 “[NAFS-08] is an industry challenge, but it is necessary,” Turner said. “I think that it will flush out the very poor products that are sold in the market.” He sees the new building codes simply as another hurdle that premier manufacturers must meet. “e simple fact is if we didn’t have building codes we would all have single-pane windows in our homes and doors with leaking sills.” Turner praised the Fenestration Association of BC for its work in co-operating with code officials, inspectors and the industry on getting the word out on the need for higher performing products. Due to the large variety of window and door products that it offers, Westeck had a Westeck manufactures a line up of bi-fold doors, popular in high-end homes. “ 1 61 0 -6 -5 3 04 6 om g.c Tested products include two new Westeck products rolling out this year; a PVC li-and-slide door and a solid fir frame window with aluminum clad exterior. Westeck has studied the concept of triple-pane windows that many believe will become necessary in Vancouver to meet new energy standards coming in Engineeringforcommercialand residen-alglazing LicensedinbothCanadaandUSA NFRCcer-fiedthermalmodeling Innova-vesolu-onsfor glazingapplica-ons l-n New products 2014. Adamson, noting that the extra weight and cost of triple-pane glazing may prove restrictive, suggests that adding a fourth surface coating to the typical dual pane, single low-e unit may allow manufacturers to meet the new City of Vancouver window standard without necessarily going with a triple-pane configuration. Turner welcomes such debate. For him it proves that “there is more interest in the window and door industry now in BC than at any time in history. is is an exciting time to be in the industry and it is definitely growing,” he said. If history and innovation is any guide, Westeck Windows and Doors will continue to grow with it. n FENESTRATIONINNOVATIONEXPERTS nsu huge challenge in testing everything to meet NAFS-08. “We have done a lot of work and we still have a lot of work to do,” Adamson said. ” tonc o 1999 company founded in Chilliwack, BC 5 offices: Chilliwack, Kelowna, Vancouver, Victoria, Nanaimo 60,000 square feet of manufacturing space, Chilliwack 120 employees www.lay Westeck by numbers ... if we didn’t have building codes we would all have single-pane windows in our homes and doors with leaking sills. FENESTRATION WEST / Fall 2013 GLAZING,CLADDING ANDSPECIALTY STRUCTURALENGINEERING 23 SIDE ELEVATION showing camera capture zone FRONT ELEVATION LED facade system not activated FRONT ELEVATION LED facade system: 30% power FRONT ELEVATION LED facade system: 100% power Panel shows how an elaborate system of cameras and projection screens will make tower appear to “vanish”. Photos: GDS Architects First ‘invisible tower’ rising in Seoul GDS Architects have designed the world’s first “invisible” building, a 450-metre (1,476-foot) tower now under construction in South Korea, next to Seoul’s Incheon International Airport. With a touch of a button, the glass-sheathed Tower Infinity will appear to vanish, according to GDS director Michael Collins, from the architect’s California office. e building achieves its “invisible” effect through an elaborate system of cameras and projection screens designed to camouflage the skyscraper. Strategically placed cameras outside of the tower will be used to capture real-time images of the building’s surroundings – the sky, mostly – and those images are projected off of the tower’s glass LED facade. Kim Hee-jae, who is in charge of the tower’s architectural planning at Korea Land and Housing Corporation (the state-owned backer of the project), told reporters that the invisible illusion will only be used during certain hours of the day and from certain angles to prevent risks to air traffic. Even when the effect is turned on, Mr. Kim said, the building’s red aircra warning lights will have to remain on to keep pilots safely away. n Glass-sheathed Tower Infinity will soar 1,476 feet above Seoul, South Korea. 24 FENESTRATION WEST / Fall 2013 Other BC winners: UniverCity Childcare Centre The consultant on the Belmont was RDH Building Engineering Ltd. It features low-e coating and argon-filled fibreglass-framed triple-glazed windows by Cascadia Windows and Doors Ltd. VANCOUVER – A Vancouver four-plex that includes triple-paned windows has captured one of three BC awards in the 2013 Canadian Green Building Awards. e Georgia Green Eco 4-Plex, by Shape Architecture, replaced a single-family house with four compact residential units. e airtight building envelope includes triple-glazed windows and skylights, rainwater capture in underground cisterns, extensive daylighting and cross ventilation. It was designed and built to achieve LEED Platinum certification. Above: award-winning Vancouver four-plex by Shape Architecture captured a national Green Building Award. Photo: Eric Scott Triple-paned 4-plex captures Green Award “is project was notable for the quality of its planning and for the impressive energy performance numbers. e refined aesthetics, the clever circulation system and the beautifully laid out and light-filled interiors make this a welcome addition to a rather bland and banal residential neighbourhood,” said the jury. “e superior building envelope, including high-performance windows, is indicative of the considered approach to passive design, focusing more on the reduction of energy loads than on FENESTRATION WEST / Fall 2013 state-of-the-art energy technology.” Other BC winners in the national award were the Belmont Building, a 13-storey West Vancouver condo tower; and the UniverCity Childcare Centre at Simon Fraser University in Burnaby. e 2013 Canadian Green Building Awards, which named eight winners across Canada this year, is an annual national program presented by Sustainable Architecture & Building (SAB) Magazine and the Canada Green Building Council (www.cagbc.org). n 25 A look at what’s new – and sometimes wacky – in the window and door industry Stackable sliding patio doors fold neatly into the frame Tacoma, Washington-based Milgard Windows & Doors has introduced its Moving Glass Wall System that uses stackable sliders to open up entire walls of a house. Milgard claims it is affordable for the average homeowner. ere are several standard sizes available with three- or four-panel configurations that include a fully weather-stripped structural interlock system and two low-e glass options. n You can fire at intruders safely through new two-way bullet-proof glass Return fire through bullet-proof glass Backpaint glass allows office staff to write right on the walls. Photo: Sniqi Backpainted glass office walls Vancouver’s Brooks & Corning, a 100-year old furniture company, says backpainted glass walls are becoming a big hit in contemporary offices. “Conventional whiteboards wear out over time, but glass doesn’t and it cleans up easily,” said company general manager Bob Ross. Brooks & Corning purchases its custom glass through Garibaldi Glass of Burnaby. n 26 Armour Group. Inc. of Florida offers the perfect solution to troublesome home invaders: a window glass that “provides ballistic protection from one side and the ability to counterattack from the other. e Oneway Return Fire Glass maintains structural integrity and protection levels while allowing defenders to return fire” right through the glazing. n FENESTRATION WEST / Fall 2013 Woodtrimmed Hybrid Curtain Wall Unison Windows & Doors Inc. of North Vancouver believes it is the first BC company to offer a Hybrid Curtain Wall System featuring a wood interior and a wood or aluminum exterior. Unison is importing the aluminum and rubber components for the system from Germany-based Raico and manufacturing the units using local wood and glass. “It is extremely high performing in both thermal [certified to Passive House in Europe, down to .8 U-Value] and air, water and structural,” said Kris Smith of Unison. Smith said Unison is aiming the product at the commercial glazing sector. “We can pre-cut, pre-process, and pre-assemble the gaskets, wood, and aluminum components. We can also offer pre-finishing, as we have an in-house spray booth,” he explained. n App controls door lock Ontario-based Weiser has developed the first intelligent deadbolt – a door lock that communicates with a smart phone. e Bluetooth-enabled lock and a Kevo mobile app allows someone to control door locks without even taking their smart phone out of their pocket or purse, from anywhere. e Weiser Kevo retails for $249 and rolled out this October. n Lock and unlock with a smart phone Have a new “cutting edge” fenestration product? Send the information in to Fenestration West magazine at [email protected] FENESTRATION WEST / Fall 2013 27 using the words found in the BC process than he actually was. Employment Standards Act, being the first Sable’s hiring letter for Geller stated, “three consecutive months of employment”. “Your first three months of employment is It is critical to ensure that the contractual considered probationary. Permanent terms, including the probation period, are employment will be determined based on Employers must be certain compliant with the applicable employment mutual satisfaction and job performance.” employer fits the job standards legislation. A situation soon arose in which Sable by Robert Smithson Fourth, documentation needed Geller to work in unsupervised I sometimes refer to the should be kept, during the circumstances. is would have been probation period as the Rodney probation period, of the contrary to industry requirements that an Dangerfield of employment law employee’s progress in relation apprentice receive training and practical (for those of you not old to the agreed-upon criteria. A experience under the direction of a enough to know, that means it good rule of thumb is that there qualified, certified tradesperson. gets no respect). But few legal should be at least one interim Geller informed Sable that he was mechanisms can be more review of the employee’s willing to continue to work in a situation in effective in getting employers performance which there was a out of employment Robert Smithson and conduct qualified heavy-duty relationships that seemingly have no future. before the final decision on ...there should be at mechanic available to give A probation period can be viewed as one suitability is made. him the “agreed apprentice least one interim long audition for a job, revealing an Finally, the employer training and practical review of the employee’s experience.” Sable individual’s true skills, attitude, and ability should conduct a final performance and conduct terminated Geller’s to fit in. review, making a before the final decision probationary employment But an employer must take certain steps reasonable decision about on suitability... to ensure it has gained the full benefit of a suitability, prior to the and, in turn, Geller sued probation period. e employer and expiry of the probation for wrongful dismissal. employee should agree, in writing, prior to period. Court decisions indicate employers e BC Supreme Court stated that “a the commencement of the employment, on should, to whatever degree is possible, probationary employee must be given an the terms of a binding probationary period. apply objective criteria in performing a opportunity to demonstrate his ability to ere are numerous preferred components good faith assessment of the probationary meet the standard the employer set out” at of an enforceable probation clause. employee. the time of hiring. It found that Sable and Three steps Court ruling Geller did not have a common First, the parties should define A recent BC Supreme understanding of their respective “roles the standard of review – oen Court decision relative to the apprenticeship or the degree the standard adopted will be demonstrates that a of supervision available or required.” “suitability” for ongoing probation period e Court went on to state that it was employment. at’s a bit of a doesn’t give the incumbent upon Sable to “make its fancied-up way of saying the employer a expectations clearer to [Geller] employee must be a good fit carte than it did”. Geller, it found, did not for the job. “have a reasonable opportunity to Second, demonstrate his suitability for because the job”. His claim of wrongful suitability is a dismissal was upheld and somewhat hazy standard, the damages were awarded. parties should then go a step e point the further and set out the primary Geller and criteria by which the employee Sable will be measured. ese might Resources include, for instance, attitude, blanche entitlement to Ltd. case compatibility with co-workers and clients, ditch the employee at the drives ability to follow directions, demonstrated first opportunity. home is that the employer can’t make progress in acquiring the necessary skills of Geller was hired on an arbitrary decision to terminate a the job, good attendance, overall efficiency probationary status by Sable probationary employment relationship. and output, adherence to company policies, Resources Ltd. in 2010 aer It must apply rational thought to the etc. completing a decision and make a reasonable ird, the length of the probation period pre-apprenticeship program decision, in all the circumstances, about should be clearly stated. e period is in heavy mechanics. While the employee’s future. n sometimes defined in terms of time worked Sable was aware that Geller Robert Smithson is a labour and employment lawyer, rather than just the passage of calendar did not yet have his and operates Smithson Employment Law in Kelowna. time (because time on the job is what’s heavy-duty mechanic’s For more information visit www.smithsonlaw.ca. is subject matter is required to assess the individual’s suitability journeyman ticket, it provided for general informational for continued employment). seemed to think he was purposes only and is not intended as legal I prefer to define the probation period farther along in that advice. L E G A L V I E W Probationary periods “ ” 28 FENESTRATION WEST / Fall 2013 Acoustic performance of windows Proper seals, wider spacers and heavier glass help keep it quiet By Dermot Mack of a ‘standard household noise’ Myth busters spectrum to be subjectively quiet.” • ere is scant evidence that triple-pane glazing offers higher e higher the STC rating, acoustic performance than a double-pane window with the the better the acoustic same total glass weight and the same overall section depth, performance. studies have shown. For instance, an older single • While gas-filled glazing units perform acoustically better at glazed window with a sealed some frequencies and worse at others when compared to frame may have an STC 27 air-filled units, on average there is no improvement for traffic rating, while a double-pane noise isolation with gas-filled window units. sealed unit with a 13 mm air • Tempered glass does not provide the acoustic performance of space could rate at STC 30 or laminated glass. better. A typical 6” solid concrete wall would be rated As the EuroLine experience thicker than 6 mm while still around STC 55. shows, reducing noise levels providing an airspace of at least e push to improve window through windows is not really 12 mm. acoustic performance is about the number of panes of Adding lamination can also predominantly driven by glass: it has more to do with the increase the STC rating, but at a municipal zoning thickness of the cost. and development glazing, the air ere are also aesthetic If the window bylaws, notes Briét space and how well trade-offs. Studies consistently isn’t sealed airtight, the insulated unit Coetzer, an show that using smaller all of the efforts acoustic specialist is sealed. windows reduces sound with BKL on the frame and As the City of transmission, but consumer Consultants Ltd. of glazing can be Vancouver noise demand today is for larger North Vancouver. control manual windows. wasted. “Most of these notes, “provided As for window frames, by-laws in the Lower Mainland the units are well sealed, Coetzer said a heavier frame subscribe to the CMHC double-glazed windows are not would generally provide better published criteria for maximum significantly better at blocking acoustic isolation. “Test data acceptable indoor levels of road traffic noise than a single-glazed shows that aluminum frames and rail traffic noise. Houses window with the same total are slightly inferior with façade noise levels above thickness of glass.” However, [acoustically] to vinyl, wood 55 dBA would generally require since double pane windows are and vinyl-clad wooden frames a window and/or wall upgrade roughly twice as thick as a especially in the upper to reduce indoor noise levels to single pane of glass, they tend to frequencies,” she noted. meet the CMHC criteria,” provide about 3 dBA more But aside from the glazing explained Coetzer, who presents sound reduction than a single and framing materials, acoustic a seminar on the acoustic pane. performance may ultimately be performance of windows at the Thicker glass decided on how well the Fenestration Association of BC’s According to Coetzer, the window is made and how well it annual conference. e CMHC single step that a window is installed. residential indoor noise criteria manufacturer could take to “If the window isn’t sealed is a level of 35 dBA in improve acoustic performance airtight, all of the efforts on the bedrooms, and from 40-45 dBA is to go with a larger frame size frame and glazing can be in other rooms, but municipal that would accommodate glass wasted,” Coetzer said. n criteria may differ. “ ” Briét Coetzer, BKL Consultants Ltd. of North Vancouver. Photo: BKL Consultants Ltd. I nside the glass cabinet at EuroLine Windows’ Delta showroom a rock-and-roll radio station is blaring at 90 decibels (dBA) – loud enough to damage hearing within eight hours – but when the cabinet door is closed, the room goes quiet. e sealed cabinet, explains EuroLine’s Roque Datuin, is made of double panes of glass, each 16 mm thick and with a 15.8 mm air space between the panes. “It has a Sound Transmission Class (STC) rating of 34”, Datuin explains aer a vivid demonstration of how important windows are to acoustic control. Acoustics, in fact, are a hot fenestration topic these days as urban municipalities attempt to deaden ever-increasing sound levels. Years ago, the National Research Council (NRC) and Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) developed the STC ratings, which are “based on the amount of attenuation required to reduce each octave‐band level OITC ratings Coetzer said that the STC single number ratings have largely been replaced by OITC (Outdoor-Indoor Transmission Class) ratings in applications involving traffic noise mitigation. OITC is considered more robust than STC, in that OTIC has the additional capability to preserve rank orderings for certain lower frequency sounds constituent in rail, aircra and road traffic noise. FENESTRATION WEST / Fall 2013 29 T E C H N I C A L TA L K Tougher codes codes are adopted,” Hoffman cautioned. Although the 2010 version of ASHRAE 90.1 “will drive a demand for higher elected to retain the prescriptive 40 percent glazing performance glazing and frames” ratio, the 2012 version of the IECC has decreased the maximum fenestration area to 30 percent of the Fenestration Association of BC members who work gross wall area, he explained. with commercial clients in the United States know As states adopt the 2012 IECC, getting beyond that some states have adopted 30 percent will be even more challenging than ANSI/ASHRAE/IESNA Standard 90.1-2007, Energy getting past 40 percent with the current code, Standard for Buildings except Low-Rise Residential according to Hoffman. “It will be even harder to Buildings (ASHRAE 90.1-2007). ASHRAE 90.1 meet code if one wants to also exceed maximum requires U-Value and SHGC to be determined fenestration areas using according to NFRC 100/200 (which is commonly available systems that also recognized by the BC Energy Act). are on the market today. However, most states – including ese stricter requirements in Washington and Oregon – have the energy code will also have a adopted the International Energy significant impact on glass Conservation Code (2009 IECC in buildings pursuing LEED Oregon and 2012 IECC in accreditation. Currently, Washington). A few states, like Leadership in Energy and California, have their own Environmental Design (LEED) “home-grown” energy codes. Every uses ASHRAE 90.1 2007 as the three years energy codes are revised to baseline. continuously improve the energy “With a maximum efficiency of new and renovated fenestration area of 40 buildings. percent in the baseline “Consequently, stricter energy Stéphane Hoffman, Morrison Hershfield design, the total energy conservation measures are adopted budget that the [LEED] design team has to with each code cycle,” said Stéphane Hoffman, a work with becomes even less. Whether it is senior building science specialist and vice-president to meet code or to earn additional points of the Façade Engineering Group at Morrison under Energy and Atmosphere, exceeding Hershfield, one of the largest building envelope 40 percent fenestration area will require engineering companies in North America. Hoffman, even higher performing envelope systems with engineer Medgar Marceau, recently presented a or greater energy savings in other areas to paper at a U.S. building envelope symposium trade-off ”, Hoffman states. “While LEED discussing how new energy codes will affect the Silver may still be within reach without the North American fenestration industry. additional Energy and Atmosphere, LEED “With most states having implemented the 2009 Gold or Platinum will be increasingly rare.” IECC during the 2007-2012 global financial crisis, “e focus on continuously improving relatively few buildings were permitted under this the energy efficiency of new building new code, and hence few designers have had to deal through energy codes will drive a demand with the challenges of complying with the new for higher performance glazing and better thermal performance requirements of the building thermal performing frames,” Hoffman said, envelope. One of these new requirements is the 40 percent limit on fenestration area. For those buildings adding it could provide an incentive for emerging technologies such as vacuum that have been permitted under the new code, this insulated glazing, vacuum insulated panels, new limit has had a significant impact on the design electro-chromic glass, and other innovations of so-called ‘glass’ buildings,” Hoffman said. that can help improve the thermal Commercial office and multi-residential performance of glazing systems. developments are two segments most impacted by As Hoffman explains, the 2012 IECC will these changes. have an exception to the glazing ratio for Under the prescriptive building envelope buildings where 50 percent or more of the floor requirements of ASHRAE 90.1-2007, Section 5.5.4.2 plate benefits from day lighting. is, he notes, Fenestration Area states, “the total vertical will drive a need to address the benefits and fenestration areas shall be less than 40 percent of the impacts of increased glazing early in the gross wall area” and “the total skylight area shall be conceptual design phase of the projects. less than 5 percent of the gross roof area”. Similar “Early collaboration between the design requirements exist in the 2009 IECC. architects, mechanical engineers, and building Even tougher rules coming envelope consultants will be even more crucial on “As challenging as the maximum fenestration area is, it will be even more challenging once the new 2012 these projects.” n 30 FENESTRATION WEST / Fall 2013