14YE 3 Panel r2.indd - Energy Spectrum Advisors Inc.
Transcription
14YE 3 Panel r2.indd - Energy Spectrum Advisors Inc.
Majority Gas: Net Production Rate Multiple ($ / MCFEPD) vs. Proved R/P All Property Sales ($10MM - $2,000MM) Announced in the Last 12 Months Red Indicates Last Quarter. Point Size is Proportionate to Total Price. 20,000 $3.25 15,000 10,000 5,000 y = 216 x + 3,932 $18.00 Majority Oil $2.75 $19.50 Majority Gas $3.00 $15.00 $2.25 $12.00 $1.75 $9.00 $1.25 ec 5 10 15 20 25 Total Proved Reserves / Current Net Daily Production Annualized (Years) 30 $21.00 $16.50 $2.50 $13.50 $2.00 $10.50 $1.50 $7.50 $1.00 D 0 0 -1 M ar 1 35 -1 2 S Jun ep-1 2 - D ec 12 -1 M ar 2 -1 Jun -1 3 3 Se p- D ec 13 -1 M ar 3 -1 4 Jun -1 4 Se p- D ec 14 Median $ / BOE $ per Net MCFEPD Median $ / MCFE -1 4 Trailing Twelve Months Through Majority Oil: Net Production Rate Multiple ($ / BOEPD) vs. Proved R/P All Property Sales ($10MM - $2,000MM) Announced in the Last 12 Months Red Indicates Last Quarter. Point Size is Proportionate to Total Price. 300,000 250,000 $ / Net BOEPD 200,000 150,000 100,000 50,000 y = 2,122x + 60,591 $100,000 $13,000 $ 110,000 $14,500 $120,000 $16,000 $70,000 $8,500 $80,000 $10,000 $90,000 $11,500 $40,000 $4,000 $50,000 Majority Oil $5,500 $60,000 Majority Gas $7,000 D ec 0 0 5 10 15 20 25 Total Proved Reserves / Current Net Daily Production Annualized (Years) 30 M - ar 11 35 - 12 Jun -1 2 Se D ec p- 12 M -1 ar 2 Jun -1 -1 3 3 Se D p- ec 13 M -1 ar 3 -1 4 Jun -1 4 Se D p- ec 14 Median $ / BOEPD Median $ / MCFEPD -1 4 Trailing Twelve Months Through Proved R/P as Estimate of Asset Sale Price Why does one property sell for $40,000 per net BOEPD and another for $140,000 per net BOEPD? Using statistical analysis, E-Spectrum Advisors has identified a positive correlation between Proved R/P and dollar paid per daily unit of net production. R is defined as Total Net Proved Reserves. P is defined as Current Net Daily Production Annualized. As indicated in the data table, most reserve information is taken from buyers’ press releases. For example, using the oil chart and formula above, one can see that a majority-oil transaction with an R/P of 15 years could sell on average $92,421 per net BOEPD. Securities offered through E-Spectrum Advisors LLC, a member of FINRA and SIPC. Sale of Operated Cleveland Properties Sale of OFS Company Sale of Multi-Basin Royalty and Overriding Royalty Interests Sale of Permian Basin and North Texas Oil Properties July 2014 July 2014 May 2014 January 2014 www.energyspectrumadvisors.com 5956 Sherry Lane, Suite 900 Dallas, TX 75225 Phone (214) 987-6100 7500 San Felipe, Suite 600 Houston, TX 77063 Phone (713) 706-6382 Patrick George (214) 987-6129 Coy Gallatin (713) 870-0426 Central Oklahoma Reclamation Stephanie Sullivan (214) 987-6143 Damian Wells, P.E. (214) 987-6127 Will Hundley (214) 987-6153 Sale of Barnett Shale Mineral and Royalty Interests (Tarrant and Johnson Counties, TX) Sale of North Texas Oil Properties Sale of Mid-Continent Gas Properties and Processing Plant Sale of Eagle Ford Royalty Interests September 2014 July 2014 July 2014 July 2014 Extensive technical and financial expertise, complimented by unmatchable industry relationships and personalized service, allows us to repeatedly help our clients realize their transaction goals. Focused on asset and corporate divestitures in the upstream energy sector. Sale of Appalachia Properties and Midstream Assets Sale of Non-Op Bakken Shale / Three Forks Properties Sale of Multi-Basin Royalty, Overriding Royalty and Non-Operated Working Interests Sale of Anadarko Basin Properties (Blaine and Kingfisher Counties, OK) Pending December 2014 October 2014 October 2014 Sullivan Osage, LLC Pizzitola Resources, Inc. Las Colinas Energy Partners, LLC Beasley Oil Select Current and Recent Transactions YEAR END 2014 Trailing Twelve Months through December 2014 MAJORITY GAS An no D un ate ce d 12/22/14 12/19/14 12/2/14 11/17/14 11/4/14 10/31/14 10/6/14 10/3/14 9/24/14 9/22/14 9/18/14 9/15/14 8/26/14 8/18/14 8/14/14 8/11/14 7/30/14 7/29/14 7/29/14 7/18/14 7/7/14 7/7/14 7/7/14 7/7/14 6/30/14 6/27/14 6/9/14 5/30/14 5/7/14 5/5/14 5/5/14 5/2/14 5/2/14 4/30/14 4/29/14 4/1/14 3/31/14 3/7/14 3/4/14 2/26/14 2/14/14 2/13/14 1/31/14 1/30/14 Bu ye r Se lle r To tal ($ Pric MM e* ) Southwestern Energy Co. Questar Corp. Southwestern Energy Co. Camterra Resources Samson Resources Undisclosed Harbinger Group Inc. EnerVest; FourPoint Energy LLC Bravo Natural Resources LLC W&T Offshore EOS Petro Inc. Vanguard Natural Resources LLC G2X Energy Inc.1 E&B Natural Resources Vine Oil & Gas LP; Blackstone Group Rex Energy Corp. Vanguard Natural Resources LLC Templar Energy LLC Mountaineer Keystone Energy LLC Linn Energy LLC Pantera Acquisition Group Rice Energy Inc.1 Undisclosed Warren Resources, Inc. Undisclosed Talos Energy LLC American Energy Partners LP KKR Antero Resources Corp.1 Sabine Oil & Gas LLC Saka Energi Indonesia Cimarex, Devon, EVEP, FourPoint Legacy Reserves L.P. Indigo Minerals LLC Hawkwood Energy; Covey Park Energy Undisclosed1 Jonah Energy LLC Rooster Energy LLC Memorial Production Partners LP Gulfport Energy Corp.1 Atlas Resource Partners LP Merit Energy New Source Energy Partners LP FourPoint Energy LLC Statoil Undisclosed WPX Energy Inc. Forest Oil Corp. Goodrich Petroleum Corp. QEP Resources, Inc. Exco Resources, Inc. Linn Energy LLC Canaan Natural Gas PE Funds Undisclosed Dune Energy Inc. Bill Barrett Corp. WPX Energy Inc. WPX Energy Inc. Shell Oil Co. Shell Oil Co. Hunt Oil Newfield Exploration PDC Energy; Lime Rock Partners Pioneer Natural Resources Co. BP America Production Co. Chesapeake Energy Corp.; Statoil Petsec Energy Citrus Energy; TLK Energy; Troy Energy Invest. Cimarex Energy Co. Stone Energy Corp. East Resources Inc.; Undisclosed Penn Virginia Corp. Muskingum Watershed Conservancy District Forest Oil Corp. Swift Energy Co. QEP Resources, Inc. WPX Energy Inc. EP Energy LLC EnCana Oil & Gas (USA) Inc. Red Fork Energy Ltd. EnCana Oil & Gas (USA) Inc. Cochon Properties LLC Memorial Resource Development LLC Rhino Resource Partners LP Geomet Inc. Occidental Petroleum Corp. CEU Paradigm LLC EnerVest Management Partners Ltd. Per MCFE Median Simple Average MA JORITY OIL An no D un at ce e d 12/5/14 11/20/14 11/18/14 10/29/14 10/28/14 10/24/14 10/20/14 10/17/14 10/9/14 10/7/14 10/6/14 10/3/14 9/24/14 9/24/14 9/16/14 9/15/14 8/29/14 8/29/14 8/19/14 8/18/14 8/13/14 8/12/14 8/12/14 8/8/14 8/4/14 8/4/14 8/1/14 8/1/14 7/29/14 7/29/14 7/24/14 7/22/14 7/18/14 7/17/14 6/25/14 6/24/14 6/24/14 6/16/14 5/27/14 5/23/14 5/23/14 5/21/14 5/21/14 5/20/14 5/15/14 5/15/14 5/6/14 5/6/14 5/5/14 5/1/14 4/30/14 4/29/14 4/18/14 4/10/14 4/10/14 4/8/14 4/7/14 3/26/14 3/25/14 2/28/14 2/25/14 2/24/14 2/14/14 1/31/14 1/30/14 1/24/14 1/21/14 1/7/14 1/2/14 ALL U.S. FROM $10 MILLION TO $2 BILLION Bu ye r 394 53 300 185 61 108 205 1,950 250 18 128 561 210 155 1,200 120 278 588 500 340 390 336 17 353 138 200 1,750 73 95 1,131 175 772 355 150 530 11 1,800 30 35 185 107 1,400 19 268 Re se ($ Pric rve MM e ) 394 53 300 185 61 108 205 1,950 170 18 128 561 40 155 1,200 18 135 588 303 340 390 117 17 353 138 200 1,170 73 95 925 158 772 355 150 431 11 1,800 30 35 185 107 1,054 19 268 Re Pro (B serv ved CF es E) ($ Va /M lu CF e* E) NA NA NA 159 NA NA 125 755 286 27 80 389 73 222 NA 21 150 228 485 340 302 NA NA 208 50 77 NA 85 NA 595 189 463 276 84 200 NA 1,493 14 15 NA 70 408 NA NA NA NA NA 1.16 NA NA 1.63 2.58 0.60 0.67 1.59 1.44 0.55 0.70 NA 0.83 0.90 2.58 0.62 1.00 1.29 NA NA 1.69 2.76 2.59 NA 0.85 NA 1.55 0.84 1.67 1.29 1.79 2.16 NA 1.21 2.20 2.27 NA 1.53 2.58 NA NA ($ /M V CF alu EP e* D) 29.0 11.8 50.0 22.0 11.0 8.3 24.9 195.0 33.0 13.9 11.8 67.0 NA 154.0 258.0 3.0 17.5 65.0 51.9 40.0 27.6 20.0 7.6 82.0 15.0 57.0 175.0 11.9 NA 105.1 8.5 109.0 63.0 21.0 107.2 NA 351.2 5.6 4.3 6.0 22.0 110.0 2.9 35.0 13,587 4,457 6,000 8,413 5,546 13,015 8,215 10,000 5,157 1,311 10,810 8,373 NA 1,006 4,651 5,833 7,741 9,046 5,833 8,500 14,130 5,834 2,242 4,299 9,200 3,509 6,686 6,113 NA 8,796 18,690 7,087 5,635 7,143 4,021 NA 5,125 5,348 8,136 30,833 4,863 9,583 6,395 7,658 $1.49 $1.51 ALL U.S. FROM $10 MILLION TO $2 BILLION Se lle r (M Pro MC du N FE ctio et PD n ) To tal ($ Pric MM e* ) ReOil Eagle I LLC Undisclosed Gulf Pine Energy Partners LP Synergy Resources Corp. American Energy Partners LP1 Carrizo Oil & Gas Inc. Dome Energy AB Oak Valley Energy; Earthstone Energy Inc. SM Energy Co. Mid-Con Energy Partners LP Natural Resource Partners LP Fleur de Lis Energy LLC Atlas Resource Partners LP Cabot Oil & Gas Corp. Various Eagle Energy Exploration LLC Callon Petroleum Co. LRR Energy Parsley Energy LP Oxy Undisclosed Athlon Energy Inc. Undisclosed Undisclosed Fuse Energy LLC Mid-Con Energy Partners LP Vitesse Energy LLC Emerald Oil Inc. SM Energy Co. Undisclosed Mid-Con Energy Partners LP RSP Permian Inc1 Diamondback Energy1 Lime Rock Resources PetroQuest Energy, Inc.1 Dome Energy AB Dome Energy AB Energy & Exploration Partners Inc. U.S. Energy Corp.1 Undisclosed Sundance Energy1 Sanchez Energy Corp. Bonanza Creek Energy Inc.1 W&T Offshore Inc. Panhandle Oil & Gas Inc. Earthstone Energy Inc. Atlas Resource Partners LP Triangle Petroleum Memorial Production Partners LP Parsley Energy LP EP Energy Corp. SM Energy Co.1 Vitesse Oil LLC Parsley Energy LP1 Undisclosed Athlon Energy Inc. SK Innovation Legacy Reserves LP Memorial Production Partners LP Mid-Con Energy Partners LP New Gulf Resources Lonestar Resources Inc. Diamondback Energy Lime Rock Resources Liberty Resources II LLC Athlon Energy LP Pacific Energy Development Corp. Fieldwood Energy LLC EPL Oil & Gas Inc. Alta Mesa Holdings LP Apache Corp. Dixie Energy Trust Undisclosed Tall City Exploration LLC; Undisclosed Eagle Ford Minerals LLC GAS Ventures LLC Flatonia Energy LLC Magnum Hunter Resources Corp. LCS Production Co; AG Hill Oil and Gas LP Kaiser-Francis Oil Company Linn Energy LLC Undisclosed EF Energy LLC Bill Barrett Corp. Fairway Resources Partners II LLC Undisclosed Juno Energy II LLC Cimarex Energy Co.; Undisclosed Venoco, Inc. Eagle Energy Trust Undisclosed Texas American Resources Co. Enhanced Oil Resources Inc Pioneer Natural Resources Co. Undisclosed EnerVest Management Partners Ltd. Liberty Resources II LLC Baytex Energy Corp. Sundance Energy Mid-Con Energy III LLC Various Various MDU Resources Midstates Petroleum Company VistaTex Energy LLC Range Ventures LLC Treadstone Energy Partners LLC Undisclosed Sundance Energy Undisclosed Shell Oil Co. DJ Resources LLC Woodside Energy (USA) Undislosed Oak Valley Energy Resources LLC Merit Energy Co. Marathon; QEP Resources, Inc. Merit Energy Co. Pacer Energy Ltd. BHP Billiton TS Dudley; Chesapeake; Baseline Minerals Inc. Undisclosed OGX Resources LLC Neon Energy Ltd. Hibernia Resources; Piedra Energy II; Undisclosed Plymouth Exploration LLC; Kayne Anderson Celero Energy; SM Energy Co. Alta Mesa Holdings LP Mid-Con Energy III LLC Halcón Resources Corp. Clayton Williams Energy, Inc. Henry Resources LLC; Various Oasis Petroleum Inc. Sequel Energy Mid-Energy Partners Continental Resources Inc. SandRidge Energy, Inc. CNOOC Per BOE Median Simple Average 210 1,400 48 125 726 250 24 66 85 120 340 350 225 210 112 195 213 38 252 200 140 382 135 10 155 19 187 109 330 15 57 259 538 200 24 35 27 715 12 116 43 639 226 51 80 71 420 120 935 165 153 100 64 133 27 873 367 112 173 41 450 71 288 333 455 88 30 750 70 Re se ($ Pric rve MM e ) 210 1,400 NA 125 66 250 24 66 85 120 340 350 225 152 112 195 117 38 150 200 72 236 135 10 155 19 146 37 330 15 57 92 167 200 24 35 27 715 12 80 16 445 69 40 75 71 420 110 935 129 93 100 64 133 27 409 367 112 173 41 398 63 200 333 393 60 21 750 70 (M Res Prov M erv ed BO e E) s ($ Val /B ue O * E) 7 NA 3 NA 49 17 NA NA NA 6 8 19 12 NA 4 19 4 3 3 7 NA 11 13 1 NA 1 19 2 30 1 3 22 5 NA NA NA NA 33 <1 5 NA 60 NA 2 9 11 47 4 83 8 NA NA NA NA 2 31 NA 9 7 2 16 7 7 9 31 3 NA 57 3 $17.04 $18.62 % APP (Marcellus) RM APP (Marcellus) Ark-La-Tex MC (CVS) MC (Woodford) Multiple MC (Panhandle) MC (Woodford) GOM GC Onshore RM RM CBM Haynesville APP (Marcellus) Haynesville MC (Panhandle) APP (Marcellus) MC (Kansas) MC (Panhandle) APP (Marcellus) GC Onshore / GOM APP (Marcellus) MC (Kansas) GOM Multiple GC Onshore Utica GC Onshore STX (Eagle Ford) Multiple RM GC Onshore GC Onshore MC (Woodford) RM GOM GC Onshore APP (Utica) CBM MC (Kansas) MC MC (Anadarko) Pr ov ed Ga R/ s P 55% 100% 100% 100% 75% >50% 86% 50% 100% 74% 58% 77% 100% 100% 96% 100% 71% 60% 99% 60% 57% 100% 96% 100% 72% 58% 93% 100% >50% 78% 100% 63% 83% 85% 97% >50% 92% 72% 54% >50% 100% 70% NA NA ($ 3.6 47.1 0.1 1.2 1.4 2.7 0.2 1.1 0.7 1.2 3.1 4.6 1.9 1.6 1.5 4.0 1.5 0.3 1.8 1.5 1.0 3.0 2.1 0.2 11.1 0.2 1.6 0.4 3.2 0.1 0.4 1.1 2.2 2.0 NA 0.8 0.2 8.4 0.1 0.6 0.2 20.0 0.7 1.7 0.7 2.1 2.9 1.2 5.9 0.9 1.0 NA 0.6 NA 0.3 4.8 3.3 0.9 1.7 0.3 3.8 0.7 2.2 2.7 4.0 0.8 0.4 25.0 0.9 /B V O alu EP e* D) 59,138 29,724 NA 100,806 47,143 93,633 120,000 61,270 117,736 100,251 109,677 76,087 118,421 94,800 75,659 48,750 80,000 138,182 83,500 137,174 75,213 78,550 64,286 47,619 13,956 125,974 92,852 93,500 103,275 116,935 137,805 83,101 76,811 100,000 NA 46,667 135,000 84,813 234,615 128,215 79,500 22,250 98,757 24,099 101,905 33,161 144,828 93,617 158,475 149,245 93,150 NA 108,383 NA 103,654 85,250 113,046 125,843 104,848 117,479 104,726 95,301 92,733 123,746 98,325 80,000 52,500 30,000 78,222 Re gio n STX (Eagle Ford) Multiple GC Onshore Niobrara PER STX (Eagle Ford) RM STX (Eagle Ford) Bakken PER Bakken PER STX (Eagle Ford) STX (Eagle Ford) RM MC (Mississippian) PER MC PER West Coast PER PER STX (Eagle Ford) PER Barnett GC Onshore Bakken Bakken Bakken Bakken MC PER PER Bakken GC Onshore Multiple RM Multiple Bakken RM STX (Eagle Ford) STX (Eagle Ford) RM GOM STX (Eagle Ford) STX (Eagle Ford) RM Bakken RM PER PER RM Bakken PER West Coast PER MC (Mississippian) Multiple STX (Eagle Ford) MC ETX (Woodbine) STX (Eagle Ford) PER Bakken Bakken PER Niobrara GOM GOM % O il Pr ov ed R/ P 92% >50% 55% >50% >50% 82% >50% >50% >50% 89% 90% 86% 86% >50% 73% 53% 67% 95% 90% 100% >50% 67% 83% >50% >50% 100% 87% 90% 82% >50% 90% 74% 65% >50% NA NA 100% 82% 100% 54% NA 57% 85% 87% 89% 65% 100% 100% 100% 74% 75% NA 89% NA 100% 67% NA 95% 92% 100% 93% 93% 69% 89% 88% 60% >50% 51% 91% $94,800 $92,978 *Total Price may include and Value may exclude consideration for non-E&P assets, such as gathering & processing assets and working capital. **12-month NYMEX Strip as of the transaction announcement date. Considered to be an acreage transaction and / or is not included in the R/P correlation. (1) NA NA NA 19.8 NA NA 13.8 10.6 23.7 5.4 18.6 15.9 NA 3.9 NA 19.2 23.4 9.6 25.6 23.3 30.0 NA NA 7.0 9.1 3.7 NA 19.6 NA 15.5 61.1 11.6 12.0 11.0 5.1 NA 11.6 6.7 9.8 NA 8.7 10.2 NA NA O il* * 57.61 58.71 67.90 75.96 77.48 80.26 87.39 86.60 90.72 89.99 90.85 90.89 92.79 92.60 92.90 95.46 96.43 97.01 97.01 98.21 99.90 99.90 99.90 99.90 101.10 101.32 99.25 97.83 95.95 95.01 95.01 95.38 95.38 95.47 96.79 95.19 96.72 97.64 97.94 97.30 96.57 96.42 92.74 93.69 Ga s* * 3.20 3.41 3.69 3.99 3.95 3.78 3.86 3.95 3.94 3.90 3.94 3.96 3.99 3.88 3.96 4.00 3.84 3.86 3.86 3.98 4.19 4.19 4.19 4.19 4.35 4.32 4.54 4.44 4.74 4.67 4.67 4.66 4.66 4.77 4.78 4.37 4.46 4.65 4.66 4.58 4.67 4.72 4.52 4.44 $6,395 $6,868 P (M rod BO uc Ne EP tion t D) 28.77 NA NA NA 1.35 14.97 NA NA NA 19.67 41.46 18.42 18.75 NA 26.64 10.42 29.30 15.20 50.10 27.39 NA 21.42 10.68 11.74 NA 29.48 7.77 18.70 11.17 11.15 21.55 4.18 32.09 NA NA NA NA 21.80 32.88 17.04 NA 7.42 NA 21.05 7.93 6.19 8.94 24.72 11.24 15.86 NA NA NA NA 13.68 13.20 NA 12.44 23.38 25.63 24.41 8.60 28.81 38.72 12.81 20.69 NA 13.11 27.08 Re gio n 5.6 NA 89.9 NA NA 17.1 NA NA NA 14.0 7.2 11.3 17.3 NA 7.8 12.8 7.5 24.9 4.6 13.7 NA 10.0 16.5 11.1 NA 11.7 32.7 13.7 25.3 28.7 17.5 54.5 6.6 NA NA NA NA 10.7 19.5 20.6 NA 8.2 NA 3.1 35.2 14.7 44.4 10.4 38.6 25.8 NA NA NA NA 20.7 17.7 NA 27.7 12.3 12.6 11.7 30.4 8.8 8.7 21.0 10.6 NA 6.3 7.9 O il* * 66.79 75.79 75.06 81.47 80.73 80.47 80.42 80.80 84.21 86.48 87.39 86.60 90.72 90.72 92.34 90.89 93.71 93.71 92.02 92.60 95.28 94.86 94.86 95.16 94.86 94.86 94.86 94.86 97.01 97.01 97.83 98.87 98.21 98.54 101.74 101.32 101.32 101.51 98.67 98.91 98.91 98.61 98.61 98.15 97.31 97.31 94.84 94.84 95.01 95.17 95.47 96.79 98.87 98.04 98.04 97.76 96.07 95.51 94.71 97.51 96.86 97.73 96.57 92.74 93.69 92.69 92.32 91.60 93.34 Ga s* * 3.65 4.05 3.94 3.72 3.67 3.64 3.71 3.79 3.83 3.91 3.86 3.95 3.94 3.94 4.02 3.96 4.03 4.03 3.95 3.88 3.91 4.01 4.01 4.00 3.86 3.86 3.86 3.86 3.86 3.86 3.88 3.84 3.98 3.98 4.48 4.47 4.47 4.62 4.45 4.37 4.37 4.43 4.43 4.50 4.45 4.45 4.75 4.75 4.67 4.69 4.77 4.78 4.77 4.96 4.96 4.59 4.55 4.50 4.51 4.62 4.70 4.68 4.67 4.52 4.44 4.51 4.27 4.23 4.27
Similar documents
2nd Quarter - Energy Spectrum Advisors Inc.
Majority Gas: Net Production Rate Multiple ($ / MCFEPD) vs. Proved R/P All Property Sales ($10MM - $2,000MM) Announced in the Last 12 Months
More information