Swimming and Spa Pool Water Treatment Edition: 2011

Swimming and Spa Pool
Water Treatment
Edition: 2011
Swimming and Spa Pool
Water Treatment
References
Water quality – determination of free chlorine and total chlorine
Part 2: Colorimetric method using N,N-diethyl-1,4-phenylenediamine
for routine control purposes (EN ISO 7393-2 : 2000)
Swimming Pool Water
Treatment and Quality Standards
2009 Pool Water Treatment Advisory Group (PWTAG), UK
Management of Spa Pools
Controlling the Risks of Infection, March 2006
Health Protection Agency, London, United Kingdom
Guidelines for safe recreational water environments
Volume 2: Swimming Pools and Similar Environments
World Health Organization, 2006
Standard Methods for the Examination of Water and Wastewater; 18th ed.,
American Public Health Association, American Water Works Association,
and Water Environment Federation, 1992, USA
Colorimetric Chemical Analytical Methods (CCAM)
I.C. Thomas, B.Sc., F.R.I.C., G.J. Chamberlin,
9th Edition, The Tintometer Ltd., Salisbury, England
Extract, E.M. and Shute ,G., “Why, How and When to Test Pool/Spa Water”,
June 12, 1986, The Tintometer Company, Salisbury, England
Pool Chlorination Facts
A technical and practical reference for aquatic professionals for using
chlorine in swimming pools, Robert W. Lowry, 2003, New York, USA
Swimming Pools
Part 2: Safety requirements for operation;
EN 15288-2 : 2008
Swimming and Spa Pool
Water Treatment
Editor
Tintometer GmbH
Schleefstraße 8 -12
44287 Dortmund
Phone (+49) (0)2 31 / 9 45 10 - 0
Fax (+49) (0)2 31 / 9 45 10 - 20
[email protected]
www.lovibond.com
Germany
Text
Dr. rer. nat. R. Münzberg
Illustration
E. G. Hesse
Typsetting and Layout
M. Ostermann
All rights reserved
Copyright© 2009 by
Tintometer GmbH, Germany
No.: 93 81 01
Foreword
Welcome to this edition of the Lovibond® Handbook of Swimming Pool and Spa Pool Water Treatment.
The handbook is intended mainly as a practical guide for owners/operators to
assist in the efficient operation of their pools and spas.
Our aim is to illustrate the basic principles of modern water treatment procedures
and to explain in some detail the significance and affect of the chemicals currently used for disinfection, flocculation, pH adjustment and the maintenance of
water balance.
The ever increasing demands made on pools and spas make the monitoring of
the water quality an essential part of the treatment programme. These requirements are met by the Lovibond® range of water testing equipment. This is simple
to use, is reliable and accurate and yet is cost effective. The second part of this
handbook explains the Lovibond® test procedures in detail and provides useful
advice on how to apply them.
This edition has been prepared by Dr. Robert Münzberg. He has based it on
his dealings with our customers´ problems and his consulting with other pool
experts. Acknowledgement is made for the kind advice in this handbook by Mr.
Geoff Shute, the retired Chief Chemist of the Tintometer Ltd., Amesbury, England
and by Mr. Howard Gosling, Swimming and Spa Pool Water Treatment Advisor,
Nether Compton, Dorset, England.
We have tried to provide the fullest information on aspects of water treatment and
testing but realise that we cannot cover everything so we apologise if we have
not included your particular application.
Tintometer GmbH
Lovibond® Water Testing
Germany
www.lovibond.com
Table of contents
Page
Basic requirements of Swimming Pool Water Treatment . . . . . . . . . . . 6
1. Water Circulation - simple diagram of pool layout . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6
2. Flow Rate - explanation of turnover time and the importance of
filtration and circulation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6
3. Dilution - addition of fresh water . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
Main Treatment Processes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
1. Filtration and filter Backwashing - how it works, what it does
and why . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
2. Flocculation - how it works and why it is necessary. Types of
flocculation currently available . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10
3. Water Disinfection - its purpose . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11
Water Treatment Chemicals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13
List of current popular products and processes with explanation of
how they work, advantages and disadvantages including:
Chlorine Gas . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13
Sodium Hypochlorite . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13
Calcium Hypochlorite . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16
Chlorinated Isocyanurates (stabilized chlorine) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16
Bromine (BCDMH, DCDMH, and Sodium Bromide) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18
Ozonation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19
Active Oxygen . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20
Biguanide (PHMB) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21
Copper / Silver . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21
Ultraviolet (UV) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22
Algicides . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23
pH control (acids (Including CO2) / alkalis (bases)) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24
Alkalinity (levels and adjustment) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26
Calcium Hardness (levels and control) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26
Spa Pools . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 27
Design and Capacity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28
Filtration . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28
Chemical Treatment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29
Operational Criteria . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 30
Water Testing Equipment and Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31
Colorimetric analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31
Photometric analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 32
Electrochemical methods (Redox and Amperometric) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 33
Chlorine . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 34
Bromine . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37
pH . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 38
Alkalinity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 39
Ozone . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 40
Calcium Hardness . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 40
Chloride . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 41
Sulphate . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42
TDS (Total Dissolved Solids) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 43
Langelier Balanced Water Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 44
Operational Problems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 47
Cloudy Water . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 47
Green Water . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 47
Complaints of smarting eyes etc. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 48
NOTE: mg/l = mg per litre which is numerically the same as
ppm (parts per million).
Swimming pool water treatment - the basics
The primary objective of pool water treatment is to maintain the water in a safe
and pleasant condition for swimming. More specifically this objective can be
summarised as needing to :
• keep the water free of pathogenic (harmful ) bacteria
• keep the water free from growths of algae
• ensure the water is neither toxic nor irritating to swimmers
• prevent the formation of undesirable smells or taste in the water
• prevent corrosion of the pool surround, its fittings and equipment
• prevent scale formation in the pool, filter or pipework.
A simple diagram can illustrate the operation of a swimming pool even allowing
for todays wide variety of treatment processes:
Flow rates and turnover
Pools become polluted at different rates. Generally the shallower the water the
more bathers per cubic metre, and an open air pool has greater surface pollution
than an indoor one.
6
Tur nover is the number of hours it takes the filter to pass one
complete volume of pool water. The calculation for this is : Turnover in hours =
Pool capacity m3
————————
Filter rating m3/hr
The filter rating is the flow of water through it designed to achieve a specified
degree of clarification, say down to 10 micron, or 0.01 mm, within a certain period.
So each type of pool requires its own matched filter to develop a satisfactory
turnover period.
As a general guide these are as follows :
30 min – 1 hour
Paddling and waterslide splash pools, also Hydrotherapy pools
30 min – 1.5 hours
Teaching pools
10 min – 45 min
Leisure waters up to 0.5 m deep
30 min – 1.25 hours Leisure waters 0.5 to 1 m deep
1 hour – 2 hours
Leisure waters 1 m to 1.5 m deep
2 hours – 2.5 hours
Leisure waters over 1.5 m deep
2.5 hours – 3 hours
Conventional public pools up to 25 m long with a 1 m shallow end.
3 hours – 4 hours
Competition pools 50 m long
4 hours – 8 hours
Diving pools.
Hotel and Health Club pools may be able to have a longer turnover period than
an equivalent public or leisure pool if there are strict limits on bather loads and the
time the pools are used. The Design Bather Load should be known and enforced
by operators at the entrance. Similarly, school pools may have been designed to
have 'rest' periods between classes.
7
Dilution
Disinfection of the water and the filtration process will not destroy or remove all
of the pollutants present.
A programme of dilution of the pool water with fresh water is desirable to reduce
the build-up of pollutants from bathers and the by-products of the disinfection
process.
To some extent dilution is carried out by the sheer nature of back washing the
filter where the water flushed to drain must be replaced. Unfortunately this is not
frequent enough to maintain the concentration of undesirable pollutants at an
acceptable level.
Some pollutants can only be reduced by dilution – organic chloramines like chlorcreatinine for example, cannot be broken down by chemical means.
A useful guide as to volume required is 30 litres per bather per day in a public
pool, which should give benefits of lower levels of pollutants and hence reduce
the use of the treatment chemicals themselves.
Filtration
The main purpose of the filter is to remove particulate matter and debris from
the water. It strains out suspended solids down to sub-micron- size particles in
order to maintain water clarity. It does not remove dissolved salts nor does it deal
with micro-organisms.
The long established material for filters is sand and this is still preferred by many
designers of large pools since it’s use has been so well proven over 100 years.
Other types are : Cartridge filters
Zeolite mineral
Diatomaceous earth
Dolomitic filter material
8
The cartridge filter is a self-contained unit constructed of a synthetic fabric such
as spunbonded polyester in a pleated format which is attached to a centre core
within a cylindrical drum. This provides a large surface area for filtering in a very
small confined space.
This type of filter is generally only used for small pools.
In both sand and zeolite filters, water is passed through the material under pressure. While passing through the sharp edged media, small particles of debris are
trapped in the gaps, starting in the top layers.
Zeolite material is now growing in popularity over sand as is absorbs ammonia,
gives good water clarity and can bring savings on chemical costs.
A gravitiy, vacuum or a pressure process occurs in a diatomaceous earth filter.
Mesh bags are placed in a vessel usually under pressure and the diatomaceous
earth is introduced into the system and settles on the mesh. Water passes through
the now impregnated mesh and debris is collected as before.
Dolomitic filter material produces an alkaline reaction with the pool water and is
used to stabilise the pH, particularly when chlorine gas is the disinfectant. Due to
it’s composition there is a build up of calcium and magnesium bicarbonates in the
water which increases its hardness and this contributes to the pH stabilisation. This
process slowly uses up the dolomitic material and so at the appropriate time it’s
level in the filter has to be topped up. The depth should usually be approximately
40 cm ( 15 ins ) on top of the sand. Where Dolomitic Media is in a filter do not
use Hypochlorite in the pool.
An advantage of this type of filter medium is it’s additional ability to filter out Iron
and Manganese from the water.
Flo
w
thr
ou
gh
the
po
ol
Acid or alkali
for pH control
Chlorine etc.
for disinfection
Flo
w
to
po
ol
Flo
Active granular carbon
Test methods :
free and combined
chlorine; pH value;
ozone etc.
w
fro
m
ol
Po
po
ol
r
te
wa
Fresh water supply
Test of m-value
(Total alkalinity)
Filtration
Volumetric flow (pump)
Active carbon additive
Flocculation agent
Ozone mixer
Back washing
Ozone
9
Flocculation
Colloidal or finely suspended materials may not be trapped on the filter bed but
continue to be circulated in the pool giving the water a cloudy appearance and
reducing visibility for bathers.
This problem is more likely to occur in an outdoor pool due to the effect of the
elements – wind and rain. The pool water is prone to collect windblown debris
like dust, algae, spores, insects and footborne materials like soil and grit.
In order to remove this finely dispersed material the use of a flocculant is necessary. This is a chemical which is added to the pool water and which causes
the particles to group together to form larger particles (flocs) which become big
enough to be caught by the filter media and removed from the water. Following
is a list of some of the more popular flocculants :
ALUM (aluminium sulphate)
PAC (polyaluminium chloride or aluminium hydroxychloride)
PASS (polyaluminium sulpho silicate)
SODIUM ALUMINATE
IRONIII CHLORIDE HEXAHYDRATE
IRONIII SULPHATE
Chemically they all behave in similar ways by forming a gelatinous precipitate by
hydrolysis.
Aluminium-based compounds operate best at pH levels between 6.5 and 7.2
and iron salts between 6.5 and 7.5
Iron salts however may leave an iron residual in the water which may cause staining, and so these are not now used on a large scale.
The most commonly used flocculants are the polyelectrolytes like PAC and PASS.
As non-filterable water turbidity is usually caused by negatively charged particles
these polyelectrolytes are cationic and attract the particles causing an increase
in the floc size.
Cationic polyelectrolytes offer additional advantages as
• At the recommended dosage rates they are capable of flocculating living
organisms such as algae and bacteria which would otherwise pass through
the filter – the infectious cysts of Cryptosporidium and Giardia are small and
resistant to disinfection.
• They produce a tough floc that is resistant to disintegration from the action of
the pump impellor.
It should be stressed that flocculants must be used correctly at the recommended
dosage rates and this is best achieved by dosing continuously by means of a
dosing pump. Suppliers instructions must be followed.
10
Backwashing of Filters
With all types of filter there comes a time when it becomes loaded with debris
and it is necessary to clean or backwash the filter bed.
The indication that this course of action is appropriate is when the pressure gauge
on the filter shows that there is a pressure differential between the top of the filter
bed and the bottom
Backwashing is the process of reversing the flow of water through the filter. This
agitates the material and loosens the bed. The sharp grains collide with each other
causing the collected debris to be flushed out to drain (waste).
This is the mechanism in sand, zeolite and dolomitic filters but in the case of diatomaceous earth filters the reverse flow not only removes the debris but the filter
media itself. This then has to be replaced before filtration can again proceed.
Since cartridge filters cannot be backwashed they must be physically removed to
be cleaned. They are flushed out, possibly with a garden hose to force debris off
the surfaces, then cleaned with a strong solution of chlorine (about 100 mg/l) before
being refitted for re-use. There are also proprietory chemical filter cleaners.
Water Disinfection
Disinfection, relative to swimming pool water, means essentially to
• keep the water free from potentially harmful bacteria.
• keep the water free from algae growths.
• ensure that the water is not irritating or toxic to the bathers.
• prevent the formation of undesirable smells or taste.
In other words it is safe and pleasant for bathers to swim in.
Disinfection is concerned with the destruction of micro-organisms – viruses,
bacteria, algae, moulds and fungi. These exist in large numbers in our natural
environment. The two important types as far as swimming pool water is concerned
are bacteria and algae.
Millions of bacteria are present on the human body. Many are quite harmless but
others cause illness and swimming pool water is an ideal medium for the passing
of bacteria from one person to another.
By adding a disinfectant to the water, the pool operator is initiating a process which
will hopefully destroy these bacteria as quickly as possible and hence minimise
the risk of cross-infection.
Algae are natural forms of plant life and are present in all natural water courses
– rivers, ponds, lakes etc. There are thousands of species in a diverse range
of colours. The presence of algae in swimming pools is highly undesirable as
algae growths turn the water cloudy and make the pool surfaces slippery and
dangerous.
11
The disinfection process should be effective in controlling algae but supplementary
chemicals called algicides are available for use in cases where they are difficult
to remove.
In well managed and adequately disinfected pools, the spread of viral infections
should not occur. Nasal and respiratory infections can be contracted by bathers in
crowded areas; however, these are more likely to be caused by infected airborne
droplets rather than contact with the pool water itself.
Two organisms which are particularly resistant to disinfection are the infective
cysts of CRYPTOSPORIDIUM and GIARDIA. These are microscopic protozoa
found widely in the natural environment, often in animals. They are responsible
for diarrhoea and sickness and can be a problem in busy pools. Although resistant to disinfection they are larger than bacteria and therefore more susceptible
to coagulation and hence removal by filtration.
Other pollutants are introduced into the pool water and these originate from the
bathers as well. By far the most important are nitrogen compounds from body
sweat and urine which, in the form of ammonia, react with some disinfectants to
form potentially irritating by-products. Measures must be taken to remove these
either by chemical means or dilution – this will be dealt with in more detail later.
12
Treatment Chemicals
Please note that all disinfectant chemicals used for Pools and Spas are specifically for that purpose and that normal household (e.g. toilet) cleaners are NOT
suitable.
Chlorine Gas
Liquified chlorine gas is the purest form of chlorine disinfection, it contains 100%
of available chlorine.
When chlorine gas reacts with pool water it produces free available chlorine and
hydrochloric acid. This process causes the pH of the water to fall to below pH2
– highly acidic-requiring the continuous and automated addition of alkali in the
form of sodium carbonate (soda ash) or sodium hydroxide (caustic soda) to raise
the pH again.
Chlorine gas is best suited for use in hard water areas where the natural hardness
of the water helps to neutralise the acidity produced.
Chlorine gas must NEVER be used in residential pools.
Sodium Hypochlorite
Sodium hypochlorite is by far the most popular of the disinfectants used in swimming pool water.
It is a pale yellowish liquid with the characteristic smell of household bleach. The
commercial product contains between 10 and 15% of available chlorine which is
considerably more than the domestic product.
Sodium hypochlorite is prepared by passing chlorine gas through a solution of
sodium hydroxide under very controlled conditions. An excess of sodium hydroxide
is left after the reaction to improve stability and this means that the solution has
a very high pH – about pH 12.
13
Even under satisfactory storage conditions – in the dark and at cool temperatures
– sodium hypochlorite decomposes slowly, liberating oxygen and losing its available chlorine content. Its pH however always remains high.
Some blended solutions are available which contain stabilising agents to retard
decomposition. These are usually nearer the 10% available chlorine strength and
although they are more stable they still gradually deteriorate due to heat, light etc.
It is generally recommended that during summer months storage is limited to a
period of one month in dark containers at temperatures as cool as possible.
Important note
Never add acid directly to sodium hypochlorite solution as this will cause the
production of chlorine gas.
CAUTION: ALWAYS add chemicals to water. NEVER add water to a chemical as
a violent action may occur.
Although acid is necessary for pH correction it should be added to the pool
gradually. In the case of hydrochloric acid (muriatic acid) it should be first diluted
by adding to a plastic bucket or watering can with pool water then sprinkled
over the surface.
With sodium hydrogen sulphate (dry acid) it should be dissolved in a plastic bucket
or watering can of pool water then poured into the pool in different places.
Alternatively sodium hypochlorite may be generated in situ by maintaining a high
level of sodium chloride (common salt) in the pool water – usually 3.000 to 4.000
mg/l and passing some or all of it through an electrolyser. Natural sea water can
also be used instead.
The system is not suitable for large pools but can be satisfactory for small pools
with light bather loads as long as the electrolytic generation system can cope with
fluctuations in conditions and maintain the recommended free chlorine residual.
The mechanism of sodium hypochlorite in pool water is as follows:
SODIUM +
WATER
HYPOCHLORITE
NaOCl
+
H2O
(Hypochlorous +
Acid
(Free chlorine)
Sodium
Hydroxide
(HOCl
NaOH
+
The proportion of hypochlorous acid produced depends on the pH of the pool
water as it is subject to a reversible reaction thus:
HOCl
Increasing pH
Decreasing pH
Hypochlorous
Acid
H+ +
Hydrogen
Ion
OClHypochlorite
Ion
As the pH increases the reaction products are formed while the active HOCl
predominates at lower pH values:
14
pH % HOCl
% OCl–
5.0
100
0
6.0
96
4
7.0
75
25
7.2
66
34
7.5
49
51
7.8
33
67
8.0
23
77
As HOCl is the active form of the disinfectant and the OCl-ion has virtually no
disinfecting power it would be ideal to run a pool at pH 5.0. Unfortunately this is
not possible as this is an acidic condition and is unsatisfactory for both the pool
plant and bathers alike.
The most satisfactory conditions exist between pH 7.2 and 7.5 when around
50% of the disinfectant is present as HOCl. It is comfortable for bathers and
non-corrosive for the pool surround, its fixtures and fittings.
Although HOCl is considered as being ‘free chlorine’, all colorimetric methods
of analysis for this measure, the sum of the hypochlorous acid HOCl and hypochlorite ion OCl-.
15
Calcium Hypochlorite
Calcium hypochlorite (cal hypo) is a stable alternative to sodium hypochlorite.
Available commercially in granular form or as tablets it usually contains 65% of
available chlorine, which is considerably more than sodium hypochlorite.
Cal hypo is not normally dosed by hand but rather it is dissolved in water and
pumped into the pool circulation system automatically.
The tablets are placed in a feeder system through which the pool water flows,
or alternatively placed in the skimmer baskets as in the case of domestic pools.
Regular use of cal hypo will increase calcium levels in the water which is beneficial in soft water areas. Concrete pools in these areas often suffer grout loss
from between the tiles and sometimes the screed from behind the tiles due to
the water having a ‘calcium demand’ and seeking out sources of calcium to help
satisfy this.
Cal hypo is doubly beneficial in these cases as it both disinfects and helps to
satisfy the calcium demand of the water.
In a hard water area with continued use of cal hypo, grout attack is unlikely but
rather the risk of scale deposits on the sides of the pool and calcification of the
filter is possible. Balanced water is very important here –see page 42.
Cal hypo is alkaline with a pH between 11 and 12 so acid is needed for pH
correction in the pool.
The Total Dissolved Solids content of the water will also rise but not to the same
extent as when using sodium hypochlorite.
Chlorinated Isocyanurates (stabilised chlorine)
These are compounds of chlorine and cyanuric acid which are in world-wide use
due to the fact that the cyanuric acid acts as a stabiliser in outdoor pools, reducing
the chlorine loss due to the action of ultra violet rays from the sun.
Two compounds are available – sodium dichloroisocyanurate ‘Di-Chlor’ and
trichloroisocyanuric acid ‘Tri-Chlor’.
Di-Chlor
This is a granular material containing about 60% of available chlorine. It is a
highly soluble compound which makes it ideal for direct application to the pool.
Furthermore it has an almost neutral pH which means it will not have an effect
on the pH of the pool water.
When dissolved in water Di-Chlor produces hypochlorous acid (free chlorine) and
cyanuric acid and it is important to monitor the latter as well as the free chlorine
as it’s concentration tends to build up in the pool water until a situation arises
when chlorine – lock occurs –see page 41.
16
Tri-Chlor
This contains about 90% of available chlorine and is normally supplied in the form
of large tablets. It is not particularly soluble which makes it ideal for flow-through
erosion feeders, floaters or in skimmer basket applications.
It has a low pH – about 3 which may require pH adjustment with pH-increasing
chemicals like sodium carbonate (soda ash)
It produces hypochlorous acid and cyanuric acid in solution in a similar manner
to dichlor and the same potential problem applies over the build-up of cyanuric
acid.
As a general rule free chlorine residuals must be kept higher than with regular
hypochlorites because with Di-Chlor and Tri-Chlor a reduction in the rate of kill of
bacteria occurs with increasing concentrations of cyanuric acid. The level recommended depends on the cyanuric acid content as indicated in the table:
Cyanuric acid mg/l
Minimum free chlorine mg/l
25
1.5
50
2.0
100
2.5
200
3.0
17
Bromine
Bromine has always been considered a disinfectant with similar properties to
chlorine but in the context of swimming pool water treatment it is superior.
In chlorine treated water, by-products are often formed which cause eye irritation
and sometimes offensive odours. These are, of course, the combined chlorines,
the chloramines.
In bromine treated pools, although combined bromines are formed, the bromamines, eye irritation is virtually totally absent as these, unlike the chloramines,
are good disinfectants with their activity almost being equal to free chlorine or
free bromine.
The use of elemental bromine however is very uncommon as it is a heavy red
liquid which is very corrosive and gives off pungent fumes. It’s handling therefore
requires very special precautions and consequently it is generally unsuitable for
use in pool water treatment.
A safe alternative which is very popular world-wide is an organic compound
which contains both bromine and chlorine molecules. This is 1-bromo-3-chloro5,5- dimethylhydantoin (BCDMH ).It is usually supplied in the form of tablets and
contains 61% of available bromine and 27% of available chlorine.
BCDMH dissolves in the water to release both free bromine (hypobromous acid)
and free chlorine (hypochlorous acid) and although the latter is also a disinfectant, the primary disinfectant in a pool treated with BCDMH is hypobromous acid)
it kills bacteria and oxidises organic matter and in doing so ‘spent bromine’ is
left in the water in the form of the bromide ion. The hypochlorous acid present
regenerates this ‘spent bromine’ back to hypobromous acid and so the process
continues. As a result the active disinfectant in a BCDMH treated pool is always
hypobromous acid.
BCDMH does not require any special storage conditions other than ‘cool and dry’
and if this recommendation is followed it is a very stable compound .
A potential negative aspect on the use of BCDMH is that a small proportion of
bathers develop an itch followed by a visible rash within 12 hours of exposure
to water treated with this chemical. The problem is unusual in children and more
common in bathers of say 50 years or more.
18
Ozone
Ozone is the most rapid disinfectant and most powerful oxidising agent available for water treatment. It is a highly active gas which reacts immediately on
contact with bacteria or other contaminants and impurities found in swimming
pool water.
Ozone is not a stable gas and it reverts quickly back to oxygen. This is why it has
to be generated on-site and immediately introduced into the circulating pool water.
The most efficient commercial production method is to pass dried air through a
corona discharge ionising field.
Ozone is also a toxic gas and so any which is unreacted must be removed from
the water, prior to it’s return to the pool, by means of a deozonising filter. This is
normally activated carbon.
Commonly found bacteria like E Coli are killed up to hundreds of times quicker
than with chlorine and even the highly infectious organism Cryptosporidium,
which is resistant to high levels of chlorine, is destroyed by 3 mg/l of ozone in
just one minute.
Ozone’s powerful oxidising properties prevent the build up of undesirable and
odour producing by-products of the chlorination of human-based organic pollution – monochloramine, dichloramine and nitrogen trichloride. It does this by
breaking down the components of urine and sweat thereby removing the precursors of the chloramines etc.
Ozone also acts as a powerful flocculant and renders the use of additional, more
conventional flocculants unnecessary. A noticeable beneficial effect of ozone
treatment is consequently the exceptional clarity of the water.
In commercial pools, as all of the ozone has to be removed from the return water, chlorine has to be added post filter to maintain a residual in the pool itself to
combat pollution. The level of chlorine is much less than would be required in a
chlorine-only pool.
In residential pools ozone is sometimes the only source of purification and as
the dose is much lower than that required by much larger pools, the water is not
deozonated. Normally a long-life copper-based algicide is used to provide a back
up and occasionally a little chlorine may be added after an extra contamination
load, say after a pool party. "Safe practice" decrees that a disinfectant residual
(chlorine or bromine) should be used at all times.
19
Active Oxygen
This is the popular name for an alternative method of pool water treatment to
the established compounds based on chlorine or bromine. Although compatible
with both of these, even being used in conjunction with them, active oxygen is
based on the strong oxidiser potassium monopersulphate. It is also referred to as
potassium peroxymonosulphate or simply monopersulphate compound.
Potassium monopersulphate is a chemical which oxidises organic pollution without
producing any of the irritating combined chlorine products. It is a white, granular
free-flowing powder which is very soluble in water but it is acidic so pH correction
of the pool water may be necessary.
It is sometimes used as the only oxidiser in private pools but here it has an accompanying special algicide which assists with the disinfection process.
In public pools it is mainly used as an alternative to chlorine when shock dosing is required. Using chlorine for this can often bring problems from increased
levels of combined chlorine rather than a reduction in them. This is due to some
organic chloramines not being destroyed by chlorine whereas the use of potassium monopersulphate will break them down by oxidation.
In addition to its use as a non-chlorine shock it is used as an oxidiser when a
pool is being run on bromine as the primary disinfectant. Here it can be used
with BCDMH to assist with the regeneration of the ‘spent bromine’ back to hypobromous acid.
Alternatively, as part of a two product disinfection system it is widely used with
sodium bromide as the bromine donor. The potassium monopersulphate oxidises or ‘activates’ the bromide ion to bromine which rapidly forms the powerful
disinfectant hypobromous acid. This, on reaction with pool water pollution is
reduced to ‘spent bromine’ when the action of the monopersulphate oxidises it
back to bromine. This process can be repeated continuously as long as there is
sufficient oxidiser present.
Adequate and efficient filtration is essential when using potassium monopersulphate as pollutants and oxidised material must be removed from the water as
soon as possible. Regular backwashing is necessary to prevent a build-up of
organic pollutants within the filter bed. The use of a suitable flocculant may be
beneficial.
An alternative oxidiser to potassium monopersulphate is liquid hydrogen peroxide
. This works in a similar manner but being liquid is more difficult to handle and
is less stable.
It is normally used in private pools only and is coupled to an automatic dosing and
control system which ensures that the correct quantity of chemical is dosed.
The advantage of hydrogen peroxide is that the products of decomposition are
oxygen and water thus not adding to the TDS level in the pool.
20
Biguande
Polyhexamethylene biguanide (PHMB) is a non-chlorine bactericide developed
for use in private swimming pools. It is not recommended for use in pools fitted
with an ozone device. Special versions exist for spa/hot tub use.
Although it does have some algistatic properties it must be used in conjunction
with specifide algicide to minimise the risk of the growth of the more robust strains
of algae. Monthly oxidising with Hydrogen Peroxide is also required.
Many pool owners welcome an alternative to the established halogen treatments,
although it must be emphasised that PHMB and chlorine are not compatible and
should not be mixed in pool water. In fact, it is vital that all traces of chlorine in a
previously chlorine treated pool must be removed before any PHMB is added;
this is caried out using Sodium Thiosulphate.
PHMB is cationic and so acts as a flocculant in the pool. Backwashing of the filter
more frequently is thus recommended.
Copper / Silver (Ionisation)
This is associated with electronic devices (ionisers) which generate copper and
silver ions to provide disinfection in lightly-used private pools.
Silver is a well-known bactericide and copper an algicide and their use in pool
water treatment is based on the ability to control their ions in solution.
An ioniser electrochemically generates silver and copper ions from a solid electrode
composed of the two metallic elements. This is housed in a flow cell, through
which the pool water passes.
The silver and copper ions are thus introduced into the pool and the capacity of
the system is selected such that the desired level of the two metallic ions is built
up in the water in a few days. The power output is then set to maintain the level,
allowing for backwashing and bather load.
The charged silver and copper ions are potentially effective against bacteria and
algae respectively, and working together are effective against a wide range of
organisms.
The charged ions also have a flocculating effect, grouping dead micro-organisms
and bacteria, which are then removed by the filter.
This process does not provide any mechanism of oxidation in the water and so
it is advisable that a low level of a primary disinfectant be maintained. Recently,
Ionisers based on other minerals such as Zinc have been introduced, just using
erosion rather than electrical action.
21
Ultra-Violet (UV)
Until fairly recently ultra-violet light (UV) water treatment was considered a relative
newcomer to the business of disinfecting swimming pool water.
UV has been known to be effective in destroying bacteria and other micro organisms for nearly a century and has been used for the treatment of industrial and
drinking water for nearly half that time.
Ultra-violet light is generated by electric arcs, usually using a mercury vapour
lamp. It exists in the part of the spectrum which is beyond the shortest wavelength
visible to the human eye. It is most effective in the region between 240 nm and
280 nm, the so-called germicidal wavelength.
In swimming pools, UV breaks down chloramines and other organic compounds,
like urea, by photo oxidation. Water temperature does not affect the process
which means that the disinfection and chloramine reduction is equally efficient in
unheated outdoor pools as well as warm leisure or hot hydrotherapy pools.
UV disinfection treats the full flow from the pool filters and provides protection
against the problem of pseudonomas contamination of the filter bed.
A low concentration of a primary disinfectant is required to be added to the water
to act as a residual disinfectant. This is usually chlorine and it should be used at
the minimum possible level which may be as low as 0.5 mg/l free chlorine for a
private pool, but adjusted so that algal growth is prevented from adhering to the
pool surfaces. UV equipment will help control waterborne algae but is unlikely to
have any effect on growing spores on the pool structure.
It should be noted that the disinfectant should be added after the UV treatment
chamber to minimise the affect of UV light on the chemical.
22
Algicides
The appearance of algal growths in outdoor pools is an all too common nuisance.
As well as being unsightly, they can prove to be dangerous if they make surfaces
slippery. The pool water may turn cloudy and ultimately, if allowed to multiply
unchecked, they can block filters or reduce their efficiency.
The most common cause of algal growths appearing is the failure to maintain an
adequate free chlorine residual in the water at all times.
To prevent algal growth and to kill any existing algae there are two types of product
in popular use, QAC’s and Polymeric Copper compounds.
QAC or Quaternary Ammonium Compounds are effective at low concentrations
(1 to 4 mg/l).They are also surface active agents and so at high concentrations
they can cause foaming in the water.
Some QAC’s create a demand on chlorine and bromine disinfectants and so the
level of these in the pool should be raised several mg/l above normal before addition of the QAC to counteract this. It is thus important that some care is taken
in their dosing into a pool..
Polymeric Copper or Chelated Copper is where copper is bound to an organic
molecule for dosing which reduces considerably it’s toxicity to bathers but still
enables it to be effective against algae. These types of product are often used as
”winterisers” in private pools to prevent deterioration of the water while the pool
is unused over the winter season.
Copper sulphate is no longer used as an algicide because as well as its toxicity
it can cause problems with hair discolouration, and staining of pool surfaces,
especially at pH values over 7.4.
23
pH Control
The pH is a logarithmic scale, which ranges from 0 to 14.
A pH of 7.0 is neutral and if the value is above this, the water is alkaline i.e. it
contains more alkaline components than acid components.
Conversely, if the pH value is below 7.0 it contains more acid components than
alkaline components and is therefore acidic.
The optimum pH for swimming pool water is slightly alkaline, that is between pH
7.2 and 7.8, preferably 7.3 to 7.5 for chlorine based disinfectants. This narrow
target range is necessary for the disinfection process to be running efficiently, for
the comfort of the bathers and for the general condition of the pool structure, its
fixtures and fittings.
If the pH is too high (>8.0) the effectiveness of the disinfection process is reduced,
the water may become cloudy and scale formation can be promoted.
If the pH is too low (<7.0) eye and skin irritation can occur and the pool fittings
can be damaged by corrosion.
To avoid wild swings in the pH level caused by the addition of treatment chemicals it is necessary to maintain an acceptable level of ALKALINITY in the water.
This is usually about 100 mg/l –see Balanced Water page 42 and is made up
of dissolved carbonates, bicarbonates and hydroxides. These have the effect of
acting as a buffer to prevent large changes in pH upon the addition of acids or
alkalis to the water.
The following chemicals are used for pH adjustment :
To raise the pH level:
• Sodium Carbonate (Na2CO3) or Soda Ash, also called pH Plus. This has a pH
of around 10 and will also raise the alkalinity of the water.
• Sodium Hydroxide (NaOH) or Caustic Soda.
This is very alkaline with a pH of 14 and must be handled with care. This will
also raise the alkalinity of the water.
• Dolomitic Filter Material has the effect of raising the pH but it is not dosed separately as a chemical. It is included in the filter on top of the sand, and topping
up is required at regular intervals, see Filtration section pages 8 and 9.
To lower the pH level:
• Sodium Hydrogen Sulphate (NaHSO4), Sodium Bisulphate or Dry Acid. Also
called pH Minus.
This is a free flowing crystalline powder or granules which in solution has a
pH of 1. It is normally dissolved in some water in a plastic container and then
sprinkled around the pool. It also adds sulphate to the water.
24
• Hydrochloric acid (HCl) also known as Muriatic Acid. This is an economical
pH reducer but handling can be a problem, the concentrated acid (32%) is
highly corrosive. Commercial grades should not be used as their iron content
may be high and this could cause discolouration and cloudiness in the water.
It is advisable to dilute the concentrated acid by adding to water in a plastic
container before sprinkling it around the pool.
NOTE Always add acid to water, not the other way around.
• Carbon Dioxide (CO2) this is a gas and therefore requires special injection equipment. When combining with the pool water, carbon dioxide forms carbonic acid
which reduces the pH and also adds alkalinity to the water. This has distinct
advantages in soft water areas where the natural alkalinity of the supply water
is low, but in hard water areas it is not suitable as it will raise the alkalinity to
unacceptably high levels. CO2 works best at reducing pH value where the total
Alkalinity of mains water is less than 150 mg/l as CaCO3 and Hardness is less
than 300 mg/l as CaCO3.
In commercial pools pH adjustment is carried out as a continuous part of the
treatment process through a metering pump. Dosing by hand as described above
is only carried out in private pools where there is no alternative.
Causes and effects of pH values:
25
Alkalinity
The alkalinity of a water is a measure of the alkaline salts dissolved in it – carbonates, bicarbonates and hydroxides. It should not be confused with pH which is a
logarithmic scale indicating whether a solution is acidic, neutral or alkaline.
The higher the alkalinity the more resistant the water becomes to a change in
pH value – it buffers the water (see section on pH control). An optimum level of
alkalinity is required for a pool – usually around 100 mg/l measured as calcium
carbonate CaCO3.
If however the alkalinity rises to over 200 mg/l it can make any pH adjustment
difficult, and cause cloudiness in the water.
To raise alkalinity levels SODIUM BICARBONATE (NaHCO3) is used. This has
negligable effect on the pH of the water but it will add alkalinity.
Sodium carbonate (Na2CO3) on the other hand will raise the alkalinity but will also
raise the pH.
Small regular adjustments of the alkalinity level are preferred to large doses at
infrequent intervals.
To reduce the alkalinity, acid must be used. This is normally added to the deep
end of the pool with the pump switched off so that the alkalinity is burned off
rather than causing just a reduction in pH.
Calcium Hardness
Water supplies are often termed ”soft ” or ”hard” and this relates to their content of calcium and magnesium salts. A soft water will usually have less than
50 mg/l of these salts expressed as CaCO3. Hard water will contain over 300 mg/l
as CaCO3.
Soft water will cause problems in swimming pools as it will have a ”calcium
demand” and seek out calcium from the pool structure. This is usually the tile
grouting and even the painted concrete surface itself may not escape attack. This
leaves gaps between the tiles and ultimately the tiles themselves may become
dislodged due to erosion of the cement.
It advisable therefore that the calcium hardness of the pool water is established
at the earliest opportunity and if necessary the concentration is raised to at least
200 mg/l as CaCO3 by the addition of Calcium Chloride flake. This is a very soluble
material and it should be noted that it will also add chloride ions to the water and
will contribute to the Total Dissolved Solids content – see pages 25 and 42. High
levels of calcium hardness (up to 1000 mg/l) have been known and as long as
the water is Balanced –see page 42. It is not detrimental. Some suggestions are
that it adds a sparkle and a deep blue colour to the water.
If it is required to reduce the level of calcium hardness the only way is to dump
some of the water and top up with fresh, containing lower natural hardness.
The use of Dolomitic filter material –see page 9 will also add calcium ions to the
water which will be a benefit in soft water areas.
26
Total Dissolved Solids (TDS)
Total Dissolved Solids is the sum of the dissolved compounds – hardness salts,
treatment chemicals etc. in the water. It’s importance has been recognised over
recent years as giving an indication as to whether the pool is becoming saturated
with chemicals in one form or another, and hence the length of time the water
has been in the pool.
TDS is measured electronically as the conductivity of the water to which a factor
is applied (usually about 0.7) to convert it to TDS in mg/l.
A popular recommendation for the maximum TDS in a pool is 1000 mg/l above
the feed (mains) water. So if the feed water has a TDS of 400 mg/l, the maximum
for the pool should be 1400 mg/l.
TDS can only be reduced by dilution and this must be carried out as a matter of
priority if the water reaches the absolute maximum of 3000 mg/l, as at this level
the water can be :
• salty to taste
• conductive – to produce corrosive conditions
• dull in appearance
Spa Pools (Hot Tubs)
A spa pool consists of a relatively small volume of warm water (35°C – 39°C) in
which bathers sit as opposed to swim. It is often circular in design and constructed
of acrylic or glass reinforced plastic (GRP) or of concrete.
The water is circulated inwards through nozzles set at frequent intervals around
the perimeter and out through, main drains or skimmers. Alternatively the design
may be of the overflow type in which the water flows into channels constructed
around the outside of the shell. Even with this design, there will usually be a low
suction point.
It is essential that the recirculating water is cleaned by an adequate filtration system
and disinfected by an appropriate chemical treatment.
Most spas have some form of air injection system to create turbulence in the
water, and this, with the increased temperature, can affect the efficiency of some
of these treatments.
IMPORTANT: If there is water in a Spa, it must be treated and tested, even if noone is using it, and records of this must be kept.
NOTE. A spa pool is distinguished from a Whirlpool Bath by the fact that the
latter is drained and cleaned after each use. It has no filtration system and is not
chemically treated.
27
Capacity and Bathing Load of Spa Pools
Each type of spa pool will have been designed to contain a maximum number of
bathers at any one time. The recommendations are that a minimum surface area
of 0.37 m2 (4 sq ft) and a minimum of 0.25 m3 (55 gallons) of water be provided
for each bather.
It is also important to ensure that the maximum bathing load (number of bathers
using the spa per hour) is not exceeded.
Filtration
The most efficient type of filter for a spa is the high rate sand filter. This can handle
between 2 and 20 gallons of water per minute per square foot of filter area.
A particle size for the sand of 0.40 to 0.55 mm and effective distribution is critical
for proper operation of this type of filter.
Alternatively a Diatomaceous Earth (DE) filter system may be used –see Filtration
page 9.
In both cases above, body oils and cosmetics removed from the bathers by the warm
water accompanied by aeration, collect on the filter media. With sand filters, backwashing does not remove all of the oil coating and gradually all of the sand particles
28
become coated, until oil passes straight through and a slight milkiness is imparted in
the water. Regular, annual sand changes will prevent this from happening.
In domestic spas, cartridge filters are popular – see Filtration page 9. In these
cases the fabric filaments become coated with oil until they are saturated, at which
point the oils pass through, again imparting a slight milkiness in the water.
The filter element is removed and cleaned with a proprietory cleaner after which
it is suitable for re use.
Chemical Treatment
In a spa the increased temperature and turbulence causes chemical loses from the
surface. Chlorine is more volatile, has a higher vapour pressure than say bromine
and so is lost more rapidly. However it works faster than bromine and the response
time after dosing is quicker. Bromine is often favoured despite this as it is more
stable in hot water and is easier to handle – see Bromine page 17.
It is favoured particularly in light usage spas, whereas in heavily used facilities
chlorine is more popular.
Spa water can gain combined chlorines very rapidly and the use of ozone is
proving popular in keeping these under control. In addition ozone also acts as a
flocculant so the overall effect is a very much improved water quality. Ozone is
also used with bromine to give very efficient usage of the disinfectant – the ozone
oxidises the spent bromine back to useful bromine.
UV treatment is also useful in spas. The continuous UV disinfection helps to ensure
safe spa water by destroying bacteria and other organic pollutants, but a small
residual of chlorine or bromine must be maintained in the water at all times.
Dosing Levels
As a general guide where chlorine-based disinfectants are used (without ozone),
a free chlorine level of 3 to 5 mg/l should be maintained in the spa water.
In the case of bromine related disinfectants, a level of 4 to 6 mg/l of total or active
bromine should be maintained.
Where ozone is used in addition to chlorination, free chlorine levels still need to be
maintained above 1 mg/l and ideally between 2 and 3 mg/l to ensure adequate
disinfection.
Water Balance (see also page 42)
If bather safety and comfort is to be guaranteed, water balance, as well as the
correct level of disinfectant, must be maintained in spa water at all times.
The total alkalinity level is probably the most important parameter to control after
the disinfectant.
When the air-blower is running, the spa water loses carbon dioxide causing the
pH to rise, which in turn causes the alkalinity to fall. In medium to heavily used
spas it is useful to have a programmable dosing pump to add regular amounts
of sodium bicarbonate solution. This should maintain the alkalinity and in turn
help stabilise the pH level.
29
Operational Criteria
Turnover rate for spas is expressed in minutes and is calculated from the following equation :
Turnover rate (minutes)
=
Gallons of water in spa
——————————
Flow rate in GPM
A proper turnover time is essential to ensure good water quality. A suggested ideal
turnover time is less than 15 minutes for Residential and 6 minutes for Commercial
Spas, even with light to moderate bather loads.
An industry standard in the UK requires that spa water is changed whenever
the number of bathers equals half the spa capacity in gallons e.g. for a 500 gall
(2.3 m2) spa, the water should be changed after every 250 users. For an average
bathing load of 12 people per hour for 10 hours a day, this would mean dumping
every 2 days. The filter backwashing usually coincides with water dumping since
it takes most of the water to properly backwash the filter anyway. For Domectic
Spas, we advise that there is full Water Replacement every 3 months no matter
how little usage.
A system for continuous dilution of the water by means of a controlled valve to
waste is useful and prevents water from becoming stale and over used – giving
high TDS.
Although European Standards recommend 30 litres per bather this may not be
practical and an easier system to work to would be a complete change of water
every working day unless there is a very light bathing load.
30
Water Testing Equipment and methods
Notes on Sampling
It is very important that a representative sample of the pool or spa water is taken
for analysis so
• always take the sample from the same place. This is generally best at the furthest
point from the return to the pool of the freshly disinfected, filtered water.
• take the sample from approximately 300 mm below the surface and slightly
away from the side of the pool.
• always rinse the sample container several times with the water before taking
the sample for testing.
Colorimetric Analysis
This method of water analysis is by far the oldest and simplest way of determining
the concentrations of anions and cations in water.
In it’s applications to swimming pool and spa water analysis it was established well
over half a century ago that by adding a selective reagent to a sample of water a
colour was produced, the intensity of which was proportional to the concentration of chlorine in the water.
Calibrated colour standards were produced, some in transparent plastic material,
others in glass, against which the coloured test solution was matched to give the
result of the analysis.
These two systems are still in use today with the plastic colour standards usually
in the cheaper, less robust, test kits, while the glass colour standards tend to be
in the better designed, professional kits developed for public pools and leisure
complexes.
It is with this latter type, the chemically produced glass standards, which we at
Lovibond® are primarily concerned and we have been producing these for the pool
market for over 60 years at the Tintometer factory in Salisbury. Coupled with the
well known Lovibond® Comparator the glass filter discs have been developed to
suit changes in reagent types and formulations to give the greatest visual sensitivity
in colourimetric water analysis.
The Lovibond® Comparator system has been continually updated and improved
so that now it brings to the operator probably the best all-round features for accurate visual analysis :
• accurately calibrated glass colour standards, guaranteed non- fading even
under extreme conditions.
• a Comparator unit which accepts discs, cassette-style, ensuring very perfect
location every time and which has an in-built optical prism unit to bring the
two fields of view – test solution and glass colour standard – adjacent to
each other for accurate colour matching.
• a complete reagent system based on tablets. These have been shown to be
the most reliable and consistent in reagent preparations – see more under DPD
page 32.
31
An important point worth mentioning and often overlooked by operators is that
for accurate results to be obtained when using this type of equipment, the correct
lighting conditions should be used.
It is recommended that in the Northern Hemisphere, North daylight is used and
in the Southern Hemisphere, South daylight. If these are not possible, or testing
is being carried out during the hours of darkness, a Lovibond® Lighting Cabinet
should be used – either portable or mains operated. These give a simulated
daylight illumination and are preferred over ordinary tungsten or fluorescent lights
which can cause errors.
Photometric Analysis
Modern technology has brought the field of electronics to pool water testing and
the use of portable photometers is becoming widespread.
These are instruments which pass a beam of light through the coloured test solution onto a photodetector. The intensity of the light collected is then converted,
by the microelectronics, into a value of concentration which appears in a digital
display.
Hence, in this method of analysis, there is no colour matching for the operator to
do, and providing the test procedure is followed exactly and some very important
factors are noted, photometers can give very accurate test results.
These factors are :
• the correct type of reagent is used – special photometer grades of tablets are
often specified.
• the reagent must be completely dissolved with no particles floating in the test
cell.
• there must be no bubbles adhering to the inside walls of the test cell.
• the test cell must be dry on the outside with no finger marks on the glass.
• the cell compartment itself must be kept clean and dry.
32
Electrochemical Methods
Redox Potential (ORP)
Redox is a term for an electronic measurement to assess the state of balance
between the oxidised and reduced states of a substance. In a pool, this is usually
chlorine and the measurement is in millivolts (mV). The mV reading is known as
the redox potential. It is not a measure of the concentration of the oxidised or
reduced forms of the chlorine but indicates the state of the reaction.
An increase in the mV reading indicates an increase in the concentration of the
oxidising substance (free chlorine) but the reading is not related directly to the
free chlorine concentration.
Redox controllers are used only to give a qualitative estimate of free chlorine – a
reading of around 700 mV would indicate approximately 1 mg/l – and so give a
useful indication of how water quality is affected by bather load.
Redox response is not linear however and the response levels off rapidly above
about 1.5 mg/l of free chlorine
Redox response is very sensitive to pH changes and unless the pH is finely
controlled redox is very imprecise in control applications. The response of redox
electrodes is relatively slow after start-up – often in the region of 20 minutes, so
time must be allowed for the reading to stabilise.
When redox units are in operation, it is important that the electrodes are maintained and cleaned on a regular basis. To do this the electrode is taken out and
impurities removed mechanically. The electrode must then be recalibrated using
a special redox calibration solution, rinsed then replaced.
Manual testing of the pool water for free chlorine remains important.
Amperometric
This is form of electrochemical measurement and is concerned with the determination of the concentration of free chlorine as hypochlorous acid – as mentioned
before this is the ”active” form of free chlorine. Other methods measure both
hypochlorous acid HOCl and hypochlorite ion OCl-.
Amperometric analysers form the basis of automatic controllers in large pools as
they can accurately control the level of hypochlorous acid in the water. Further
more the response time of the sensors is rapid ensuring a minimum of delay in
adjusting the level of disinfectant.
Amperometric controllers are much more sensitive and prone to external interference than redox controllers. They actually measure a small current flow which
is proportional to the number of chlorine atoms discharged at the operating
electrode in the cell. Any changes in the conductivity of the water will affect this
and in a spa pool particularly unless the important parameters of alkalinity and
pH are controlled along with some form of continuous dilution, an amperometric
system can become very unbalanced and inaccurate.
33
Chlorine
OTO
Ortho Tolidine (OTO) has been used as a colorimetric reagent for chlorine for over
70 years. It is simple to use and produces an instant yellow colour with chlorine.
However, as knowledge was gained on the mechanism of the chlorine disinfection process and the fact that there is more than one kind of chlorine residual, the
chemistry of OTO was examined and important factors were found which could
adversely affect the test. These included:
• the acidity of the reagent solution
• the method of adding the reagent
• the effect of time on colour development
• the need for a re-evaluation of the test for chlorine levels greater than 1 mg/l
Research suggested that when testing water samples at normal pool temperatures
the result indicated by OTO was that for total residual chlorine i.e. free available
chlorine plus combined chlorine (chlorine which has combined with ammonia to
form chloramines). To obtain the free available chlorine separately the sample
should first be chilled to 1°C.
Recently however, by far the most damming feature of OTO is its toxicity. In
Europe in the 1970’s its use became restricted when it was categorised within a
group of aromatic amines which are suspected of being carcenogenic (causing
cancer). Workers handling them since then have been subject to regular medical
inspections and the use of OTO in the swimming pool industry has been actively
discouraged – its use in many countries is prohibited. Despite this, OTO test kits
are still widely available across the world, mainly due to their low price.
DPD
Thankfully a satisfactory, safe alternative to OTO was introduced in the late 1950’s
by Dr.A.T.Palin in England who found that the reagent NN Diethyl-p-Phenylene
Diamine Sulphate could be used to selectively produce a colour with free available
chlorine. We all know this reagent today as DPD and it has become accepted in
many National and International Standards for drinking water analysis. It follows
then that it is eminently suitable for monitoring swimming pool water.
The reagent itself is commonly available in two different forms: as a liquid and
as a tablet.
With DPD in solution, care must be taken in storage as it deteriorates on exposure to light. In addition, it is only stable in acid solution, so a separate reagent
consisting of an alkaline buffer solution must be used with it to ensure that the
correct pH is produced in the test solution (about 6.3) for the full intensity of colour
(red) to be developed.
The most popular form of the reagent with pool operators is when it is supplied in
the form of tablets. These are packed in aluminium foil giving them a long shelf life,
34
and this, together with production techniques ensuring accuracy in formulation,
makes the product a most reliable and consistent test reagent.
Advantages of Tablet Reagents over liquids are:
• ease of handling
• ease of dosing – one per test
• long shelf life
• no storage problems
Mechanism of the DPD test
There are two DPD tablets which are regularly used in swimming pool and spa
water analysis:
DPD No.1
–
measures free available chlorine,
DPD No.3
–
used in conjunction with the No. 1 tablet and measures the total
Residual Chlorine from which the combined chlorine is calculated.
Free Available Chlorine
The DPD No. 1 tablet, which contains the NN Diethyl p Phenylene Diamine Sulphate, gives a colour which is specific for free chlorine, and this colour is measured
either colorimetrically or photometrically:
A clean test cell is rinsed with the water to be tested and is left empty.
A DPD No. 1 tablet is added and crushed with a clean stirring rod. The water
sample is then added and the cell is filled to the 10 ml mark.
The solution is mixed well with the stirring rod until the tablet has completely dissolved. The lid is put on the cell.
The colour must then be measured immediately to determine the free chlorine
content of the water in mg/l (ppm).
35
Combined Chlorine (Chloramines)
This is the general name given to the derivatives of chlorine which are produced
when free chlorine reacts with nitrogen compounds like ammonia and urea from
bathers.
HOCl +
Hypochlorous
Acid
HOCl
+
NH3
Ammonia
NH2Cl
+
Monochloramine
H2O
Water
NH2Cl
NHCl2 Dichloramine
+
H2O
NCl3
Trichloramine
+
H2O
HOCl
+
NHCl2
These are the products of the chlorine reactions which are responsible for most
of the complaints form bathers of skin and eye irritation.
Trichloramine, more commonly called nitrogen trichloride, produced in the last
reaction, is an unstable compound and being volatile comes off the surface of
a pool as a gas with a nauseous odour. In addition, it is an extremely severe eye
irritant. The chemical reaction does not proceed to completion at pH values above
5 so usually only very small amounts, if any are produced.
The two chloramines we are most concerned with are monochloramine and
dichloramine. In the DPD test they are usually determined together using the
DPD No.3 tablet :
The cell containing the dissolved DPD No.1 tablet – from the free chlorine test – is
removed from the instrument and a DPD No. 3 tablet is added to it and mixed to
dissolve with the stirring rod. The cell is allowed to stand for 2 minutes for complete
reaction of the combined chlorine (monochloramine and dichloramine).
The cell is then replaced in the instrument and the colour is measured again. The
result is total chlorine in mg/l.
To obtain the result for combined chlorine apply the following equation :
Combined Chlorine = Total Chlorine - Free Chlorine
Important Note : The DPD No.3 tablet contains potassium iodide which even in
minute traces will cause a reaction from the combined chlorine present in the
sample. It is essential that test cells and lids are thoroughly rinsed after using this
tablet before another free chlorine test is carried out otherwise a false reading for
free chlorine will be obtained.
36
To eliminate this problem some operators prefer to use separate cells for the
free chlorine test and the total chlorine test, transferring the liquid from the free
chlorine cell into another clean cell to which the DPD No.3 tablet is added, thus
avoiding any Iodide contamination of the first cell.
Interpretation of Results
The reading for free chlorine (HOCl and OCl -) is the most important of all the pool
tests. The general recommendation is for at least 1 mg/l of free chlorine to be
present at all times in the water (more, if Cyanuric Acid is used: see page 17).
In addition it is also important that the ratio of the concentration of free chlorine to
combined chlorine is at least 2:1. For example if the free chlorine concentration is
1.5 mg/l the combined chlorine concentration should be 0.75 mg/l or less.
In spa pools, with elevated temperatures, high turbulence and possible high
organic loading from heavy usage, a free chlorine residual of 3 – 5 mg/l should
be maintained.
In all cases it is desirable that the combined chlorine concentration should be
below 1 mg/l if practically possible.
Bromine
The test for bromine is very similar to that for chlorine in that it uses the DPD
No. 1 tablet.
Where it differs is that in the bromine test, the tablet not only responds to free
bromine but also to any combined bromine – bromamines – which may be present.
As discussed before, these compounds are good disinfectants in their own right,
unlike the chloramines which have very little disinfecting power.
We therefore say that the DPD No.1 test is measuring total bromine or active
bromine.
Levels of bromine as measured by the DPD No.1 tablet should be between 4 and
6 mg/l. This applies in pools as well as spas. The test procedure is as follows:
A clean test cell is rinsed with the water to be tested and is left empty.
A DPD No.1 tablet is added and crushed with a clean stirring rod. The water
sample is then added and the cell is filled to the 10 ml mark.
The solution is mixed well with the stirring rod until the tablet has completely dissolved and the lid is then put on the cell.
The colour produced is then measured to determine the concentration of total
bromine in mg/l.
Although it is not strictly necessary to monitor the build-up of combined bromine
on a day to day basis, it is a good idea to occasionally separate the total bromine
into free and combined as, like with chlorine. It is desirable to have a ratio of free to
combined of at least 2:1. This is carried out with the use of a DPD Nitrite tablet:
37
Prepare a clean cell and crush a DPD No.1 tablet in the bottom of it – leave it
empty of water.
Rinse out another cell, then fill to the 10 ml mark with water sample, and add a
DPD Nitrite tablet.
Crush and mix to dissolve with a clean stirring rod.
Add the contents of the cell to the empty cell containing the crushed DPD No.1
tablet. Mix well to dissolve the tablet particles.
Measure the colour produced which gives the concentration of combined bromine in mg/l.
To obtain the concentration of free bromine subtract the result for combined
bromine from that for total bromine.
pH
As we have seen pH measurement and control is essential in any pool or spa to
maintain the value within the desired range. For heavily used pools, the pH value
should be measured continuously and adjusted automatically, for other pools it
is sufficient to measure the pH value regularly and adjust it if necessary .
pH measurements in these cases are by colorimetric indicator and the one which
is used world-wide is Phenolred.
This has a good colour change from yellow to red over the pH range 6.8 – 8.4
which makes it ideal for the monitoring of pool and spa water, which should be
around the middle of this range.
Testing can be carried out with phenol red tablets or liquid, but in the case of
the latter it is necessary to use a separate dechlorinating/debrominating liquid
to prevent the disinfectant reacting with the indicator and changing it’s colour.
The tabletted reagent has this dechlorinator/debrominator as an ingredient in the
formulation. Phenol red in tablet form is also much more stable than the liquid
and is easier to use:
A freshly rinsed cell is filled to the 10 ml mark and a phenol red tablet is added.
This is crushed and mixed thoroughly to dissolve, using clean stirring rod.
The colour produced is matched either visually or in a photometer to give the pH
value of the sample.
Note. If the colour produced is purple when testing a brominated water sample
this is usually an indication that the bromine concentration is above 10 mg/l
pH-Value
For disinfectants based on chlorine to work properly and efficiently the pH value
of the pool or spa water is critical. The normal recommendation is that the pH
value should be maintained at between 7.2 and 7.6 with the target being 7.3 to
7.5, as disinfection will be more effective.
38
For pools and spas using bromine-based disinfectants a wider pH range is acceptable – 7.2 to 7.8. This is due to the fact that the efficiency of the disinfection
is maintained over this range.
Total Alkalinity
Alkalinity at levels below 50 mg/l may cause ”pH bounce” which means large
changes in pH value in response to changes in dosing levels of disinfectant and/or
pH correction chemicals.
To prevent this, the level of alkalinity in a pool or spa should be based on the type
of disinfectant in use :
Chlorine gas disinfection 180 – 200 mg/l
Sodium hypochlorite disinfection 120 – 150 mg/l
Calcium hypochlorite disinfection 80 – 120 mg/l
To raise total alkalinity the addition of sodium bicarbonate is required – 1.5 kg per
50 m3 (11.000 gall) will raise TA by 15 mg/l..
If too high – over 200 mg/l - use sodium bisulphate – 2.4 kg per 50 m3 (11.000
gall) reduces TA by 20 mg/l.
ALTERNATIVELY
10 litres of 15% hydrochloric acid (muriatic acid ) reduces TA by 20 mg/l.
The test for TA is quite straightforward using either liquid reagents in a drop test
method or with tablet reagents in a tablet-count method.
In the liquid method a few drops of a colorimetric indicator is added to a measured
volume of sample. Titrant is now added dropwise, until the indicator changes
colour. The number of drops of titrant used are counted and a simple calculation
gives the total alkalinity in mg/l as CaCO3.
A much simpler method is to use Lovibond® Total Alkalinity tablets. These are
added one at a time to a 50 ml volume of the pool or spa water. The colour produced initially is yellow which changes to bright red at the end-point. The number
of tablets used is counted and the following formula is applied :
( No of tablets x 40 ) – 20 = Total Alkalinity in mg/l CaCO3
If more precision is needed the volume of sample can be doubled to 100 ml when
the formula becomes :
( No of tablets x 20 ) – 10 = Total Alkalinity in mg/l CaCO3
39
Calcium Hardness
If the Calcium Hardness in a pool is below say 70 mg/l as CaCO3 the water is
likely to be corrosive to the pool structure and have a ”calcium demand”. Ideally
the level should be raised to at least 200 mg/l by the addition of calcium chloride
flake – 1.5 kg added to each 50 m3 (11.000 gall ) of pool water will raise the
calcium hardness by 20mg/l.
The test for the level of calcium hardness can be photometric but is more usually
carried out by the tablet-count method :
Lovibond® Calcium Hardness tablets are added one at a time to a 50 ml volume
of the pool or spa water. The colour produced initially is pink which changes to
purple at the end-point. The number of tablets used is counted and the following
formula is applied:
(No of tablets x 40) – 20 = Calcium Hardness in mg/l CaCO3
Ozone
Ozone is a toxic gas and consequently in larger installations in particular, it must
be removed form the water before it is returned to the pool after treatment.
However in spa pools, small amounts are generated to combat the oxidisable
products which are produced – combined chlorines etc. which means that ozone
rarely gets back into the spa itself. In any case the concentration of ozone in the
atmosphere above spa pool water should not exceed 0.1 ppm.
The test for ozone in water can be carried out using the DPD method, but recently a new reagent based on Indigo Trisulphonate has been developed which
is more selective, as the DPD method suffers from interference from any chlorine
or bromine which may also be present.
DPD Method for Ozone
• Ozone in the absence of residual chlorine or bromine:
Rinse a cell with sample and leave empty.
Add either [one DPD No.1 tablet and one DPD No.3 tablet], or (one DPD No.
4 tablet) and crush with a clean stirring rod.
Add the water sample to the 10 ml mark and mix gently with the stirring rod to
dissolve the tablet(s).
Match the colour produced either colorimetrically or photometrically and record
the reading as residual ozone in mg/l – call this reading A.
• Ozone in the presence of residual chlorine or bromine.
The above procedure is followed and the reading now corresponds to ozone
plus total residual chlorine or bromine.
40
The second procedure is as follows;
Rinse the test cell thoroughly then fill to the 10 ml mark.
Add one DPD Glycine tablet, crush and mix to dissolve with the clean stirring
rod.
Rinse a second cell with sample and then leave empty.
Add either [one DPD No.1 tablet and one DPD No.3 tablet], or (one DPD No.
4 tablet) and crush with the stirring rod.
Add to this cell the solution in the first cell and mix thoroughly to dissolve the
tablet(s).
Match the colour produced either colorimetrically or photometrically and record
the reading as total chlorine or bromine in terms of ozone in mg/l – call this
reading B.
To obtain the ozone concentration subtract reading B from reading A.
Ozone using Indigo Trisulphonate
In acidic solution, ozone rapidly decolourises indigo. The reduction in colour of a
standard indigo solution is related to the amount of ozone present in the water.
The advantage of the Lovibond® method based on indigo is that chlorine and
bromine are prevented from interfering by incorporating supplementary ingredients
into the tablet reagent.
Indigo Method
Rinse out a suitable cell with the water sample then add one Ozone test tablet.
Crush with a clean stirring rod then add the water sample carefully up to the fill
line, avoiding air bubbles.
Mix gently to complete solution of the tablet, avoiding vigorous stirring.
When solution is complete, measure the colour produced colorimetrically or
photometrically and record the reading as ozone in mg/l.
Chloride
In pools running continuously on sodium hypochlorite disinfection, the build up
of chloride can become a problem. In addition pH correction using hydrochloric
acid (muriatic acid) will add chloride to the water.
High chloride levels can impart a salty taste to the water as well as giving poor
colour and clarity. Levels are acceptable up to about 1000 mg/l and can be reduced by regular backwashing of the filters and/or adding fresh water.
Obviously the level of chloride will be a lot higher than 1000 mg/l for a pool running on salt for the electrolytic generation of chlorine. In this case the chloride
concentration is about 2500 mg/l as Cl or 4000 mg/l as NaCl.
41
Testing for chloride is a simple procedure using Lovibond® Chloride tablets in a
tablet-count method.
For a range of 0 – 1000 mg/l as Cl measure a 10 ml sample of water into a clean
container and add about 40 ml of chloride-free water (deionised).
Add one Chloride test tablet and shake to dissolve. The solution will go yellow.
Continue adding tablets one at a time until the colour finally goes brown. Count
the total number of tablets used and apply the formula:
(No. of tablets x 100) – 100 = chloride in mg/l Cl
For a range of 0 – 5000 mg/l as Cl measure a 2 ml sample into a clean container
and add about 40 ml of chloride-free water (deionised).
Add one Chloride test tablet and proceed as above. Finally apply the formula:
(No. of tablets x 500) – 500 = chloride in mg/l Cl
To convert the result to mg/l sodium chloride NaCl multiply by 1.6.
Sulphate
It is becoming increasingly apparent that high sulphate levels can cause severe
damage in concrete pools by attacking cement-based materials. In tiled pools
sulphate attacks the tile grouting causing crumbling and expansion of the
cement. This ultimately may result in tiles falling off the pool wall and floor.
Sulphate is introduced into the water from the use of sodium bisulphate (dry acid)
for pH correction and from the use of aluminium sulphate as a flocculant. The
problem is most likely to be found in heavily used pools using alkaline chlorine
donors like calcium or sodium hypochlorite.
A maximum recommended level for sulphate in pool water is 360 mg/l. It can only
be reduced by dumping some of the water and refilling with fresh.
A simple turbidimetric method is available for monitoring sulphate levels where a
tablet reagent is added to the water sample in a special double-tube assembly.
42
Any sulphate present will produce a cloudy solution which is measured by moving
the inner tube until a black spot printed on its base just disappears from view. The
result is then read off from a scale on the side of the outer tube.
This tube assembly is also used for the turbidimetric Cyanuric Acid test.
Cyanuric Acid
The presence of cyanuric acid in pool water results from the use of chlorinated
isocyanurates as disinfectants –see page 16.
In the process of disinfection, the chlorine becomes used up but the cyanuric
acid molecule remains, and over time can build up to such a concentration as to
cause what is popularly known as Chlorine-lock in the pool.
Chlorine-lock usually occurs when the concentration of cyanuric acid in the pool
water reaches levels of 150 mg/l and above. The water itself looks dull and lifeless
and perhaps has a greenish tint and yet the DPD No.1 test for free chlorine still
shows a good result – the water has become "over-stabilised" and the chlorine
is locked in.
Hot weather and extended periods of drought with perhaps water rationing
promote elevated levels of cyanuric acid in pools treated with chlorinated isocyanurates.
A level of 30 – 50 mg/l is satisfactory for stabilisation and should the level rise to
above 100 mg/l it is advisable to reduce it by dumping some of the water and
topping up with fresh.
It may be necessary to shock-dose the pool with free chlorine to kill any algae
growth which may have appeared. In this case it is important to use either
Sodium or Calcium Hypochlorite not more of the stabilised chlorine (Di-Chlor
orTri-Chlor).
A simple turbidimetric method is available for monitoring cyanuric acid levels;
alternatively a low cost photometer is available which carries the test along with
chlorine and pH.
The turbidimetric test is as follows;
The tablet reagent is added to the water sample in a special double-tube assembly.
Any cyanuric acid present will produce a cloudy solution which is measured by
moving the inner tube until a black spot printed on its base just disappears from
view. The result is then read off from a scale on the side of the outer tube.
Total Dissolved Solids (TDS)
The Total Dissolved Solids content of pool and spa water is a measure of the total
quantity of solid material dissolved in it.
In mains water this comprises of hardness and other natural salts and the level
will depend on the source of supply, but is within the region of 50 – 500 mg/l
43
The TDS level will gradually increase in a pool due to evaporation and concentration
of hardness salts, impurities introduced by the natural elements, wind and rain,
and the chemicals added to the water as part of the treatment process – chlorides
and sulphates for example.
The real value of TDS measurement is that it can indicate whether too many
chemicals have been added as a result of heavy bather load or lack of dilution
and the water is becoming ”stale”.
It should be monitored by comparison between the pool and the mains feed water
to the pool. TDS should ideally not be allowed to rise more than 1000 mg/l above
the feed water, up to a maximum of 3000 mg/l
Should it become necessary to reduce the TDS level, this is carried out by replacing some of the water in the pool with fresh water. In some pools a satisfactory
TDS level can be maintained by regular backwashing of the filters.
Measurement is by electronic meter which is really taking a conductivity reading
of the water and applying an internal factor to display the TDS in mg/l.
Balanced Water (Langelier Index)
When a water is in balance, it is said to be neither corrosive nor scale-forming.
In other words, it will not deposit a layer of calcium scale neither will it dissolve
an existing layer of scale.
For most well run pools, the water will be in balance if the pH value is kept within
the recommended range, but other factors should be taken into account which
can affect the condition of the water. These are the total alkalinity, the calcium hardness, the TDS content and lastly, the temperature of the water. The concentration
of chlorine or bromine do not appear in the Balanced Water Calculation.
The formula for determining whether he water is balanced was developed by
Langelier in the 1930’s, hence the result after applying this is often called the
Langelier Index or the Langelier Saturation Index or simply the Balanced Water
Calculation.
Why is the balance so important? Because if it is not correct, corrosion and erosion are possible.
There are 3 main causes of corrosion and erosion;
• Galvanic attack
• Aggressive water
• Low calcium hardness.
Galvanic attack occurs when two or more dissimilar metals are in close proximity
in a water environment (pool or spa ) which contains high levels of chemical salts
or TDS. The presence of chlorides encourages the water to be more conductive.
To prevent this the TDS can be reduced or the level of calcium hardness raised so
that a thin layer of scale is laid down to inhibit the metal’s efficiency as an electrode.
Lower levels of chlorides will prevent the water from acting as an electrolyte.
44
Low calcium hardness will often result in the loss of grout around the tiles, as the
water tries to satisfy its need for calcium.
It is necessary therefore to maintain the TDS at sensible levels (ideally no more
than 1000 mg/l above the feed water ) and yet maintain an adequate level of
calcium hardness in the water (around 200 mg/l minimum ).
The formula for calculating the Langelier Index is as follows :
pH + Temperature factor + Alkalinity factor + Calcium Hardness factor - TDS factor
And is applied using the table below to obtain the factors from the actual test
results for Total Alkalinity, Calcium Hardness and TDS.
Temperature T.F.
Calcium
C.F.
Hardness mg/l
Total
A.F.
Alkalinity mg/l
Total
Dissolved
C 0
as CaCO3
as CaCO3
Solids mg/l
F0
Factor
0 320.0
5 0.3
50.7
0
12.0
3 370.1
25 1.0
251.4
-
-
8 460.2
50 1.3
501.7
12 530.3
75 1.5
751.9
-
-
16 600.4
100 1.6
1002.0
2000
12.2
19 660.5
150 1.8
1252.1
-
-
24 760.6
200 1.9
1502.2
29 840.7
250 2.0
2002.3
-
-
34 940.8
300 2.1
3002.5
4000
12.3
41
1050.9
400 2.2
4002.6
-
-
531281.0
6002.35
8002.9
- - -
800 2.5
10003.0
-
-
- - -
1000 2.6
- -
6000
12.4
45
1000
12.1
3000 12.25
5000 12.35
In practical terms an Index Value in the region of zero to + 0.3 is considered
satisfactory i.e. a low positive result, which indicates that the water can lay down
a thin layer of protective scale.
Example:
Langelier calculation:
pH = 7.5
Temperature = 840 F (29 C0)
f 0.7
7.5
Total alkalinity = 100
f 2.0
Calcium hardness = 300
TDS = 1100
f 2.1
subtract: f 12.1
Total = + 0.2
IMPORTANT NOTE:
A high Total Alkalinity is no compensation for a low Calcium Hardness. Each
parameter should bi within its recommended range.
Additional Water Balance Considerations
• In soft water areas where the constant addition of calcium is necessary to
maintain a calcium level above the minimum, it could be advantageous to use
calcium hypochlorite as the chlorine donor in order to obtain the calcium in
addition to the chlorine from this product.
Also where the natural total alkalinity is low, the use of carbon dioxide gas for
pH correction with calcium hypochlorite would be advantageous to produce
an increase in the total alkalinity.
• In hard water areas where it may be difficult to reduce total alkalinity and pH to
the recommended range, the use of hydrochloric acid (muriatic acid )may be
necessary and it may be appropriate to operate with a total alkalinity of around
140 – 150 mg/l.
46
Operational Problems
Problem
Possible
Cause Treatment
Pool water
No stabilizer in pool – sunlight Check disinfectant level going green
dissipating disinfectant
and add stabilizer if
necessary
OR
High Cyanuric acid level
(Chlorine lock)
Dilute with fresh water
to reduce cyanuric acid
to recommended level
Algal growth
Inadequate disinfectant level
in pool
Ensure disinfectant level
is adequate throughout
pool – use algicide
Water dull -
lifeless
Check and reduce TDS by
dilution if necessary
TDS too high
(High chloride level)
High Cyanuric Acid level Check and reduce
(Chlorine lock)
cyanuric acid if necessary
Salty taste in
TDS too high Check and adjust by
water
dilution
High Chloride level
Check and adjust by dilution
Cloudy water
Heavy bather load over-
loading the filtration system
Reduce bather load
check filters
High pH
Check and adjust pH
High Alkalinity
Check and adjust Alkalinity
Signs of erosion Calcium Hardness too low
of grout between
Check and adjust
tiles
Check and adjust
pH too low
47
Problem
Possible
CauseTreatment
High Sulphate level
Check and reduce to
360 mg/l if necessary
pH erratic
Low Alkalinity
Check and adjust
pH difficult to High Alkalinity
Check and reduce if
adjust
necessary
Complaints of
pH outside recommended Check and adjust pH
Smarting eyes
range
and skin
irritation
Free chlorine low
Check and adjust
Combined Chlorine too Check and adjust by
high
dilution
Allergy to disinfectant
If individual try another
Pool with different
disinfectant
pH difficult to Check and reduce if
High Alkalinity
adjust
necessary
48
49
Associations-Memberships
The Swimming Pool and Allied Trades
Association
1a Junction Road, Andover, Hampshire,
England SP10 3QT
England
www.spata.co.uk
APSP
The Association of
Pool & Spa Professionals
2111 Eisenhower Ave.
Alexandria, VA 22314
USA
www.apsp.org
Bundesverband
Schwimmbad & Wellness e.V.
An Lyskirchen 14
50676 Köln
Deutschland
www.bsw-web.de
Bundesverband Deutscher
Schwimmmeister e. V.
Römerstr. 151
50389 Wesseling
Deutschland
www.bds-ev.de
Bundesverband
der Hygieneinspektoren e. V.
Hohenstaufenstr. 62
10781 Berlin
Germany
www.bundesverbandhygieneinspektoren.de
TÜV Rheinland Akademie GmbH
TÜV Rheinland Group
Rhinstr. 46
12681 Berlin
Deutschland
www.tuev-schwimmbadbauer.de
Verein zur Förderung des IWW
Rheinisch-Westfälisches Institut für
Wasserforschung e. V.
Moritzstraße 26
45476 Mülheim an der Ruhr
Deutschland
www.iww-online.de
Schweizerische Vereinigung
von Firmen für Wasser- und
Schwimmbadtechnik
Schlösslistraße 9 A
3001 Bern
Schweiz
www.aquasuisse.ch
Lovibond® Catalogue
Pool & Spa Water Analysis
Your free copy, order code: 93 80 40
Tintometer®-Group
Tintometer GmbH
Lovibond® Water Testing
Schleefstraße 8-12
44287 Dortmund
Tel.: +49 (0)231/94510-0
Fax: +49 (0)231/94510-20
[email protected]
www.lovibond.com
Germany
The Tintometer Limited
Lovibond House / Solar Way
Solstice Park / Amesbury, SP4 7SZ
Tel.: +44 (0)1980 664800
Fax: +44 (0)1980 625412
[email protected]
www.lovibond.com
Tintometer AG
Hauptstraße 2
5212 Hausen AG
Tel.: +41 (0)56/4422829
Fax: +41 (0)56/4424121
[email protected]
www.tintometer.ch
Tintometer South East Asia
Unit C-11-3A, 3 Two Square,
No. 2, Jalan 19/1, Petaling Jaya,
46300, Selangor D.E
Tel.: +60 (0) 3 7955 4013
Fax: +60 (0) 3 7955 4014
[email protected]
www.lovibond.com
Malaysia
Switzerland
UK
Technical changes without notice
Printed in Germany 11/10
No.: 93 81 01
Lovibond® and Tintometer®
are Trademarks of the
Tintometer Group of Companies