O Scale Trains Magazine
Transcription
O Scale Trains Magazine
M AG A ZI NE O Scale Trains Jan/Feb 2010 u Issue #48 US $6.95 • Can $8.95 Display until January 31, 2010 Celebrating the art of 1:48 modeling ! D A O R IL A R R U O Y N O G N I K WOR E’S NOW’S THE TIME TO BE… ER H D N A CE R U O S THE RE KE IT TO MA N H A PP E BRIDGES & SIGNALS 3-RAIL & 2-RAIL TRACK The o n l y O Scale SOLID RAIL Track N , HO, and O Scale Track, Layouts & Accessories STRUCTURES SWITCHES & CROSSINGS www.atlasrr.com www.atlaso.com “The Model Railroader’s Guide to the World’s Greatest Track” CATALOG COUPON Send this coupon, with payment, to the address below (“Attn: Track Catalog”) to receive your Atlas All-Scales Track Catalog for just $2.00! (offer applies to US residents only) Name ROADBED TRACK LAYOUT PACKAGES Address Email Our prototypical T-shaped rail easily connects to other brands of “O” scale track! Phone # Scale[s] Modeled O HO N includes all track, switches, electrical components needed To find an Atlas dealer, go to http://locator.atlasrr.com Get a copy of the latest Atlas Catalog at your LHS or visit www.atlaso.com Atlas O, LLC • 378 Florence Avenue • Hillside, NJ 07205 • www.atlaso.com Celebrating the art of 1:48 modeling Issue #48 Jan/Feb 2010 Vol. 9 - No. 1 Editor-in-Chief/Publisher Joe Giannovario [email protected] Art Director Jaini Giannovario [email protected] Managing Editor Mike Cougill [email protected] Advertising Manager Jeb Kriigel [email protected] Customer Service Spike Beagle O Scale Trains Features 4 Cover: Yes, that is a copy of John Allen’s famous engine house at Gorre on his Gorre & Daphetid RR (pronounced gory and defeated). The model is made of cardstock. The engine house resides on Jim Gore’s On30 Jemez & Rio Grande RR. Jim describes how he built the model starting on page 4. Centerspread: A painting by Larry Fisher inspired this scene on Ray Grosser’s O Scale railroad. Ray scratchbuilt the bridge even to the extent of cutting his own scale lumber. Ray’s article starts on page 34. Starting Over, Part 1 — Joe Giannovario 17 The Engine House At Gorre — Jim Gore The old OST layout is gone and a new one takes its place. Joe will detail the design and development process. Yes, John Allen’s Gorre! Jim gives us insights and details on building this well-known structure out of cardstock. Flag Pole Uncoupling Tool — Ted Horvath 34 A Humpback Bridge — Ray Grosser 38 Newark & Marion Freight House — Harold Russell 43 Bashing A U30C Into A BQ23-7 — Ed Reutling 52 2010 O Scale National Convention Contributors: O Scale Trains welcomes your feature articles, photos, and drawings. Such material should be sent to the above address for possible publication. If we accept, you will be notified immediately. For more information concerning article preparation guidelines, please send an SASE to the above address and request our “Guide For Authors” or visit our website at: www. oscalemag.com. 12 29 Contributors Ted Byrne Gene Clements Carey Hinch Martin Brechbiel O Scale Trains Magazine, ISSN 1536-9528, USPS 24457, is published bi-monthly in January, March, May, July, September and November by OST Magazine, PO Box 289, Exton PA 19341-0289. Subscription rates: US Periodical Mail, $35 per year, US First Class Mail, $45 per year; Canada or Mexico, $55 per year; Overseas, $80 per year. Postage paid at West Chester, Pa., and additional mailing offices. POSTMASTER send address changes to O Scale Trains Magazine, PO Box 289, Exton PA 19341-0289. Follow along with Capt. Mix as he scratchbuilds an interesting CB&Q early diesel locomotive. This is going to take a while! NMRA 75th Anniversary — Ken Jaglinsky Visa, MC, AMEX & Discover accepted. Call 610-363-7117 during Eastern time business hours. Dealers contact Kalmbach Publishing, 800-558-1544 ext 818 or email [email protected] Advertisers call for info. www.oscalemag.com • ©2010 All Rights Reserved Printed in the U.S.A. Building A Center Cab Diesel, Part 1 — Capt. Tom Mix, USMC, Ret. 27 Complaints L’il Bear Subscription Rates: 6 issues US - Periodical Class Delivery US$35 US - First Class Delivery (1 year only)US$45 Canada/MexicoUS$55 OverseasUS$80 MAGAZINE Ted’s designed a clever and simple way to hide the uncoupling tool. Inspired by a painting, Ray added this unique feature to his layout. A small freight house for any layout drawn by Harold. He’s at it again. Ed shows how he did this unique conversion. It’s not as difficult as you might think. If you go to the 2010 Convention check out Jerry Guth’s SP layout. Departments 7 9 11 15 23 46 49 56 56 57 58 The Art of Prototype Modeling — Mike Cougill Neville’s Workshop — The Modern Image — Gene Clements Reader Feedback Traction Action — Martin Brechbiel Product News & Reviews Modelers’ Showcase Buy-Sell-Trade Ads Events Listing Advertiser Index Observations — Joe Giannovario Jan/Feb ’10 - O Scale Trains • 3 Building a Center Cab Diesel - Part One Capt. Tom Mix, USMC Ret. Here’s an overview of the locomotive Tom will be describing in coming issues. Tom’s model was built to P48 standards but it is easily adapted to O standard. Ever since I got into building railroad models I have always concentrated on steam engines and freight cars from the 1920s and ‘30s. I never considered having a diesel on my steam road. Diesels are ugly; they sound wrong, and have no visible moving parts. Even with today’s sound decoders that can bring a model engine to life, a diesel is still a rather boring, moving steel box that rumbles along with an occasional air horn blat. But a steam engine has the fascinating movement of side rods and crossheads and that wonderful sound of a steam whistle along with the chuffing and assorted sounds of air pumps, generator whine; the sound of the fireman’s shovel on a steel deck, clank of the water hatch and much more. However, I am afflicted with that common sickness among scratchbuilders, that of seeing a drawing of an engine, either steam or diesel, and studying it with a “How would I build that?” frame of mind. I follow the CB&Q railroad and have been a member of the Burlington Route Historical Society for many years. I have a good collection of books, photos and drawings of that road’s equipment. I have seen photos of a Burlington center cab diesel and then I ran across an excellent drawing and article in the July 1984 Railroad Model Craftsman. The drawing was by Marty Feldner and F. Hol Wagner, Jr. wrote the article. That drawing, in O Scale by the way, really perked the question of “How would I build that?” There are no commercial trucks (that I know of) for engines like this and with those narrow hoods, would there be a motor small enough to fit and still be powerful enough to pull our heavy O Scale cars? More studying and research found that there are suitable motors, and the trucks would have to be scratchbuilt, but gearboxes are available and wheelsets are out there for both O Gauge and Proto 48. Etched material is available for the deck and there are commercial brass shapes of all kinds. My growing interest in building this particular center cab cascaded into setting aside my current steam projects and concentrating on the construction of one of those boring steel boxes with the wrong sound and no visible moving parts. See, I told you there really is a sickness with scratchbuilders! 4 • O Scale Trains - Jan/Feb ’10 This series will be of how I built this engine but I’m sure that there are builders out there who may have ideas that are easier and simpler than my methods. For those following this series, especially first time builders, I want to talk about working with brass based on my experiences of soldering, milling, turning, filing, and yes, occasional swearing, while learning about this wonderful material. Moreover, who knows, you too may become afflicted with that common sickness among scratchbuilders. Understanding Brass The main understanding of brass is its hardness. There are several degrees of hardness from easy machining to a softness that is easy to form. C360, Free Machining Brass, is the one that you will use the most because of its easy workability. It comes in many sizes of flat bars, rectangular, square, and rods. It works very well for drilling, especially when drilling and tapping small holes such as down to 0.037” or a #63 bit for 00-90 screws. C360 is easily machined in a lathe or mill and has no problems with soldering. C260, Cartridge Brass, is softer, usually comes in sheets, and is easy forming. You can also get this in stamped flat bars rather than extruded flat bars like C360. C260 is also used in tubing both rounds, square or rectangular. One trick in using C260 sheets when you will be bending for a locomotive boiler, or in the case of this diesel, the cab and hoods, is to hold the sheet and flex it. You will note that it will bend more easily in one direction than the other. Then you will know which way to bend or roll. C260 does not mill very well as sometimes the mill leaves a ragged cut. Drilling and tapping small holes in soft brass, like C260 will almost guarantee to break either the bit or tap even while using a fluid. These small bits and taps are cleverly designed to break right at the surface making it impossible to remove. Usually the part cannot be saved so a lot of work up to that point is lost. C770, Nickel Silver, comes in thin sheets up to a thickness of ¼” and possibly thicker. I lived in Denmark for many years and found that in Europe nickel silver is popular and used more often than brass by modelers. I learned to use this mate- rial while living there and like it very much. It solders more easily than brass, is easier to form, and holds paint better than brass. Rivets show very well such as in tender sides. It can be a bit tough to machine but I use a lot of it especially when constructing components that will represent steel in a model such as steam engine crosshead guides. I used it on the trucks as wear points for vertical movement of the axle journals. After painting, the wear of that movement will make it appear that the journals are moving against “steel” rather than brass. If you are building this engine, you might consider using nickel silver for the cab and hoods. Sources OnLineMetals.com: This company takes small orders, is prompt and their prices are reasonable. Their site also gives information on materials, their structure and composition and how it is used. They sell many materials: aluminum, steel, brass, nickel silver, plastics and shapes like pipes, rods, tubes, bars. SmallParts.com: They carry much of the same for materials, but they also carry fascinating things like gears, universals, fasteners of all kinds, sealers, bearings, pulleys and belts. The list goes on. If you click on their site, you will be there for an hour or so checking out what they have. Specialshapes.com: This company has many brass shapes such as channels, H shapes, angles, flat bars, sheets, rods, etc. They also carry brass screws and washers in 00-90, 0-80, 1-72, 2-56, at a much more reasonable price than what you see in the small packets at hobby shops. Be careful of their larger flat bars such as 3/32 and 1/8” thick sizes, as they most likely will be stamped and soft. Not good for drilling and machining. Motor Man [www.micro-loco-motion.com]: I have been experimenting with precision and coreless motors for power rather than the common brush and magnet motors we have used for years. These small motors are quite powerful and what is nice is that often they use less than 1 amp under load which means one decoder having both sound and power can be used rather than two decoders for the same purpose. Motor Man has many sizes of coreless motors and many are gear head motors. Goldmine-elec.com: Truly is a gold mine for electronics. For the motor that I used, check this site. When you open, on the left is a column, click on motors, then DC motors, scroll down to Item # G16026 (if in stock). This is a German Faulhaber. It is used, but to me they look brand new. Cost is $7.95. I bought mine while on sale for $4.95. Note there is a plastic shroud covering the motor that has to come off. You will invent some new swear words getting that shroud removed. I found the easiest way was to make several saw cuts through the plastic at the gear end and carefully pry with a small screwdriver. This motor is powerful for its size and best of all it will fit in the narrow hood. I bought three of these motors and on the one in the diesel, I ground off that gear. If you want sound in your model, check the speakers also sold in the “Gold Mine.” I bought a flat speaker, not quite 1½” dia., 8 ohm, for a package of two for a $1.00. P&D Hobby Shop [www.pdhobbyshop.com] sells gearboxes for the trucks. You can buy these with the 36” wheels (O gauge) and tower as a complete set. I bought the gearboxes and transmission shafts with worm gears and the plastic universals. However, the geared axles with 36” P48 wheels This close-up view of the side shows the fuel tank detail. This view of one hood shows Tom’s attention to the tiniest details. Even the cab has additional details. Jan/Feb ’10 - O Scale Trains • 5 came from Protocraft. These are a drop-in for the P&D gearboxes. I made my own tower of brass with Delrin chain and chain gears from Grandt Line that I had on hand. This chain and gears are identical to the ones sold by P&D. The Irish Tracklayer [www.irishtracklayer.com] has a good variety of brass parts for diesels and steam. The hood’s door hinges and latches and the etched brass numbers came from this site. Precision Scale Co. [httt://psc1.virtualfocus.com/] has an enormous amount of brass castings for whatever you might want to build. A few of the parts on this model came from PSC. Protocraft: If you are considering moving to Proto 48 check the Protocraft catalog. Not only do they carry P48 wheelsets, both geared and plain of several sizes, but they also have castings for trucks, track, and the tools for working in P48. Their e-mail is [[email protected]]. Now, with all of this out of the way let’s talk about this Burlington diesel. In addition to the drawings, information and photos in the RMC issue, The Burlington Route Historical Society sells a CD with four of their back issue Burlington Bulletins. Cost is $25, and includes shipping. One of these Bulletins, #6, deals with all the center cabs used by that road. They were from Mack Trucks, Porter, Whitcomb, Midwest, Cummins and GE. making for six models total. The 1928 Mack was a 30 ton (and quite ugly). The 1930 Porter was a 45 ton, the single 1931 Whitcomb, #9120, was a 60 tonner, and the three 1933 and ‘34 Midwest locos, numbers 9121, 6 • O Scale Trains - Jan/Feb ’10 9122 and 9123, were 65 tons. All of these in Bulletin #6 have drawings and photos so you can build another model rather than the 65-ton Midwest that I built. This diesel can be either O Gauge or Proto 48. I build in P48 which means this will scale out using the prototype drawings for all measurements. However, O standard gauge (1.25”) will require compensating for the extra width in the trucks and wheels. Right here you should note that when I discuss the measurements in building this engine I will use a material’s thickness such as 0.012” sheet or 1/8” x 2” bar stock. But, when it comes to that material being cut or shaped into a component on the engine, I will use the prototype measurements. It will be four feet, not one inch. I never understood when reading construction articles, why the author used a regular rule for the measurements of a window or loco cab instead of a scale measurement. It is easier to visualize the prototype when laying out a part when you measure 10 feet rather than 2 ½ inches. An O Scale rule is so much easier to use than converting all those measurements. To build a model such as this diesel you will need a lathe and a mill with the mill also used as a drill press. You will have to solder both thick and thin brass. William Kendall wrote an excellent article in OST #40, An Introduction to Soldering. I use a resistance-soldering unit that I have had for more than 30 years and I couldn’t build without it. For heavy components, I also use a torch like the one in William’s article. In the next issue, Part Two of this series covers building the Commonwealth trucks. u The Art of Prototype Modeling Michael Cougill The Curve I’ll get to the new name shortly. Right now I want to talk about “The Curve.” I’ve referred to the one curve on the layout several times in different articles and columns. As you’re all nauseatingly aware by now, it is a 36” radius curve going to the staging cassette on one end of the layout. I usually photograph this stellar piece of railroad engineering in a way that minimizes just how sharp and kinked it actually is. Well, time to come clean and show the beast for what it is. Photo 1, taken from the end of the layout, illustrates the lovely kink near the end of “The Curve” as it enters the staging cassette. The excuses (reasons) of how this sorry state of affairs came to be are many, but mostly come down to plain laziness on my part. When I laid it out, I grabbed the wrong template. I made up two of them to test how wide a radius I could use in this space, one 36” and the other 48”. Guess which one I grabbed? I didn’t realize the mistake until track work was well underway, and given that I had already spiked each and every tie, I didn’t want to do it over. As if that weren’t enough of a sin, I also got the alignment and flow of the curve off when I individually hand laid all those wonderfully spiked ties to begin with. The track started to drift quite close to the wall and I just laid the ties in whatever radius was required to avoid going outside. Oh yes, rest easy folks, your editor is on top of things. So what’s a guy to do? I’ve thought of yanking it all out and doing it properly several times, but all that lovely scenery and rock-hard ballast just seem to banish all thoughts of that kind. Furthermore, “The Curve” as I’ve taken to calling it now, is a great way to test new rolling stock. If a car can negotiate this fine example of trackwork, then everywhere else on the railroad is a cakewalk. It also reminds me of a similar industrial spur that the Pennsy had in Richmond. It came off of the westbound freight main and snaked its way between two buildings to reach a scrap yard some distance away. I remember seeing an SW7 and two or three 52’6” gondola cars squealing their way around it at a snail’s pace and just clearing the adjoining structures. If the prototype can do it why can’t I? So, “The Curve” will remain as is for now. It’s used as an industrial lead, not as a through track, therefore slow orders and equipment restrictions are the rule of the day, until the Head of Maintenance gets bored and has to come up with something for us to do. The new column name I decided it was time to shake things up a bit with the column, so now it’s the Art of Prototype Modeling. The term “finescale” is a bit imprecise as it could also refer to simply modeling to more refined standards in traditional NMRA gauge. The column’s emphasis is still on P48, but with a tighter focus on prototype modeling, since that’s really what the “P” in P48 stands for. Now that the layout is essentially done, I’ve been doing a lot more freight car modeling and discovered the joys of prototype research. So that’s where I’ll be headed from now on. However, it won’t be freight cars only. Prototype modeling embraces structures and yes, I’m going to say it, scenery too. This aspect of the hobby has opened up new areas of enjoyment and the learning curve has been a smooth, constant radius so far, unlike certain other curves previously mentioned. Best regards, Mike u Jan/Feb ’10 - O Scale Trains • 7 SPECIAL EDITION SERIES SUPER DETAILING-THE LIKES YOU HAVE NEVER SEEN FROM SUNSET CHALLENGER - SE UP - D&RGW - CLINCHFIELD THE SPECIAL EDITION CHALLENGERS: 2 Rail Models - Special Super Detailing Available with DCC / SOUND / PUFFING SMOKE ($200 more) or DC. Less than 30 of Each Available to Reserve. Very limited quantities. Reserve Price under $2000 ERIE S-3 / S-4 Berks Made in post-war modernized. Two versions of the Erie Berks. We are detailing this to the hilt, but it will be made to run as well. Look for these Berks in late 2010. Offered with DCC/Sound and Smoke $200, or DC. Reserve Price Under $1500 GREAT NORTHERN 0-8 Great Northern Fans Rejoice: Sunset is making the famous O-8 Mikados with opened or closed cab. We are super detailing these, so that you can proudly display and run your O-8 anywhere. Built by our premier Korean builder. Offered with DCC/Sound and Smoke $200 or DC. Reserve Price Under $1500 NP W-3 / W-5 MIKE The W class mikados were the Northern Pacific's heaviest 2-8-2's and were originally assigned to the Yellowstone Division, where the ruling grade is about 1 per cent in both directions, until the big Z5 articulateds replaced them. DCC/Sound and Smoke $200. Reserve Price Under $1500 SUNSET MODELS INC. 22 Beta Court · San Ramon, CA 94583 · 925-820-7701 · fax to 925-820-7709 · www.3rdrail.com Tote Tray for Scenery Materials While working on the layout I needed a tray to carry the scenery material to the job. I made a tote tray out of scrap wood in the workshop. 1 Photo 1: The basic tray is made with flakeboard for the bottom (18” x 23”) and 1x2s for a frame. The center piece is a 1x4 with a slot cut out for a handle. 3 2 Photo 2: I added some additional wood scraps to make compartments. One block was drilled to hold brushes and other round tools. Photo 3: Here's the tray loaded and ready to work on the layout. Jan/Feb ’10 - O Scale Trains • 9 When does my MT. ALBERT SCALE MODELS PRESENTS subscription expire? Your subscription expiration is now printed on your mailing label! T H E F I R E S T AT I O N No. 4 in a Series of Limited Edition Craftsman Kits O Scale 1:48 Original Design by Roger Malinowski Laser Cut Plywood and Basswood Diecast Fire Engine Included Detail Parts from Aspen Scale Models CD-ROM with Full Instructions and Construction Photos 11 Years in business specializing in DCC & Sound! Battery & Track Powered O • On30 • On3 • Fn3 • G • #1 6997 CR 5, Ridgway CO 81432 • 970-626-3733 www.rgsrrhobbies.com WATCH OUR WEBSITE FOR NEWS LIMITED RUN - $170.00 plus shipping EMAIL OR PHONE YOUR RESERVATION TODAY MT. ALBERT SCALE MODELS PO Box 1218, Mt. Albert, ON L0G 1M0 CANADA 905-473-3161 905-473-3891 fax [email protected] www.mtalbert.com s BF&M Baldwin Forge & Machine Box 5, Baldwin MD 21013 How can we help you? Custom machine work, 3-R to 2-R conversions for steam, diesel or electric. Driver castings machined. General repairs to O Scale locomotives. Call Joe, evenings 7 to 9 PM. 410-592-5275 or [email protected] Stevenson Preservation Lines O Gauge Kits and Parts from past Master Modelers Catalog 2005 Price: $3.00 Baldwin Model Locomotive Works Lobaugh Adams & Sons Lenoir Kansas City Kit Hines Lines Alexander Pearce Tool Co. Bob Stevenson, 2326 230th St. Ames, IA 50014 10 • O Scale Trains - Jan/Feb ’10 http://RailsUnlimited.ribbonrail.com/ email: [email protected] “We take time to give you full service” Unique O Scale models • Urethane cars; 40’ & 50’ boxcars, reefers, stock cars, milk cars, pickle car & circus cars. Full Service O Scale Dealer • Kits, DCC & Sound Supplies Books: new & out of print • Darkroom Services • Railroad Photos Model Railroad Sales & Service NEW! Wagontop Boxcar & Gons for PRR and SAL Ted Schnepf 126 Will Scarlet Elgin Il 60120-9524 847-697-5353 or 847-697-5366 Prototype Pre-fabricated Track It makes you wonder if the prototype railroads may have taken an application from model railroading and applied the process to their track maintenance procedures. I’m referring to pre-fabricated turnouts and track sections much like the sectional, flextrack and ready to install turnouts commonly used in the hobby today. Take a look at Photos 1 and 2. This turnout was transported to the location after being built at the factory. Being too long to be transported as a single assembly, it was cut into multiple sections and loaded into a gondola car equipped with a special bracket that allows the sections to be secured for movement. After being unloaded at the site where it will be installed, the sections are pot welded back together to form a complete turnout. You will also notice a section of pre-fabricated track which was built onsite. While not shown in the photographs, a maintenance flatcar loaded with 39 foot long track panel sections and some ballast cars were stored on a yard track and will be moved to the site once the rebuild project begins. This project takes place at the north end of the yard ladder at Amory, Mississippi. Its purpose is to correct an engineering problem. Originally designed and built sometime around the turn of the 20th Century, the yard tracks have seen numerous modifications and repairs. The No. 10 turnouts that are in place are now substandard due to increased car lengths and weights. Number 2 track was the first track off the north ladder and created an “S” curve that was acceptable for cars up to 50 feet long, but not for the cars in use today. Numerous derailments have occurred at this location and a “Terminal Order” was issued, restricting speeds to 5 MPH under the control and visual observation of a crew member. An upgrade to modern engineering standards was necessary to correct this problem. The plan consisted of removing the turnout from the lead and replacing it with straight sections of panel track on the north ladder lead. The new turnout, a number 16, would be cut in just south of the turnout for the North lead on track one. The Number 2 track would then be shortened and tied into the new turnout, creating a much greater radius that meets the requirements of modern locomotives and freight cars due to their coupler systems. 1 While this project involves yard tracks, it is no different than the mainline being blocked. Time is critical for train operations and the North end of the yard would have to be closed down to rail traffic to complete the project. Mainline movements would require protection since Track 1 parallels the main line. A schedule was made to give the maintenance crews the maximum time needed for the rebuild that would least affect yard engine as well as mainline operations. Starting at 7:00 am, a “Stop Order” was issued to all mainline traffic covering the milepost location of the construction. Although the mainline was not affected, traffic could only proceed on the verbal authority of the foreman in charge of the project. Cranes on either side removed the old track and turnout as the rails were cut. Afterwards, the old ballast was removed and the roadbed prepared for the new track and ballast. Once the new track sections were installed and everything tied back together, the ballast cars were unloaded over the repaired sections so the ballast tampers and regulators could go to work bringing the new track up to grade and into alignment. The final touches were to dress up the area, remove all debris and install the new hand throw on the turnout. The project was winding down at 5:00 pm when we came through on a loaded coal train. (Sorry I didn’t have the chance to take any photographs.) As far as I know, this project corrected the derailment problem. John Armstrong covered the “S” Curve scenario in his book Track Planning for Realistic Operation in Section 5 Operating Reliability through Standards. Derived from prototypical engineering data, John covers the “S” curve and locations where it can be found lurking on even the best planned layouts. Just as on the prototype, if we make the transition from an earlier era’s equipment to the longer cars of today, we may also find that we now have a problem “S” curve that will not handle the longer cars. The solution may be a re-design of the effected track area. I would recommend that all railroad modelers have a copy of Track Planning for Realistic Operation in their libraries. Not only is it a valuable tool, but it will also explain why prototype scenarios are built the way they are. Keep ‘em on the rails until the next time. u 2 Jan/Feb ’10 - O Scale Trains • 11 Starting Over: Pt 1 OST Builds A New layout It’s been a bit over 5 years since I started building the Coal Creek Railway and it was just not working for us. I’d made several design choices which I now regard as mistakes. • I built the layout too high (54”) for short people like Jaini and me. The height made it very difficult and uncomfortable to work on the layout. • I built tracks too close to the wall which made it nearly impossible to scenic. • I designed the layout without a firm idea of what the scenery would look like or where structures would be placed. As a result it sort of “just growed” and looked it. • There was too much mainline track crammed into too little space and too little track in the yard. • I built the benchwork too deep to reach across without having to stand on a step stool or step ladder. With all of these flaws in mind I began to design a new layout from the ground up and I am going to share that process with you over the next year. It will entail more than just designing a new layout as I will describe some of the research I’ve done and how I found sources of information. I started the process with a list of “Givens & Druthers” as recommended by John Armstrong. First the Givens: 1. The new layout will be based on a real prototype, the Abingdon Branch of the N&W. I will model from Bristol, VA to White Top, VA. 2. The minimum radius will be 44”. This will work just fine for small steam and the Geeps. 3. No track will be closer to the walls than 6” from the centerline. This will help make sure there is room for scenery and my hand if I need to get to a derailed car. 4. No benchwork will be deeper than 30” unless there is access to it from 3 sides. No more step stools. 5. The benchwork will be between 36" and 48” high, give or take a couple inches. 7. The maximum train length will be 96”. This is about perfect for the Abingdon Branch which ran very short trains with doubleheaded locomotives. 8. Room space is 14’ wide by 22’ long with access at the right end of the room. 9. My modeling workbench has to fit under the new layout. Now the Druthers: 10. The new layout will be double-deck to get a longer run. Max grade will be 4% (which is almost what the real grade was). 11. I will model two time periods: 1948 and 1968. This will allow me to run small steam and GP-9s. 12. I will use Atlas O track and switches for speed of construction, plus I had a design tool based on Atlas products. Armed with this list, I began to doodle benchwork configurations trying to find an arrangement that would utilize my space efficiently. Periodically I get an email newsletter from Model Railroader (it’s free to subscribers) and one of them mentioned that the MR website has an online database of trackplans. I logged in and started looking. MR sorts its plans by square footage. My room is a bit under 308 sq. ft. Nearly all the track plans in the MR database that are less than 300 sq. ft. are all designed for narrow gauge O Scale. I picked the next sort which was 300-600 sq. ft. and the first plan that popped up looked intriguing. In January of 1999 MR published a plan for the Pennsylvania Reading Seashore Lines by Max Schwanda. It’s a walk-in design with a long central 12 • O Scale Trains - Jan/Feb ’10 peninsula that then wraps around the walls. Mr. Schwanda’s room was 12’ by 30’ so he had length where I had width but I felt sure this was the place to start. Using Mr. Schwanda’s plan as a template I flipped it over to fit my room, shortened it by 8 feet and expanded the width by 2 feet. Compare this new design (Figure 1) with the old design (Figure 2). You can see that the new design provides much easier access for track laying, scenery and maintenance. Figure 1. Benchwork arrangement for the new layout Figure 2. Old layout benchwork Research Now that I had an idea of how the benchwork would fit the room I had to come up with a trackplan and, for once, I wanted a trackplan that reflected a real prototype. I knew quite a bit about the Abingdon Branch as it has been the subject of several articles in both model and prototype magazines. I planned to start the design at Bristol since this is where the engines on the branch were serviced. I then picked several locations along the branch that would be developed into vignettes along the wall. These included Abingdon, Alvarado, Damascus, and Creek Junction, all located in Virginia. I decided to “terminate” the railroad at White Top, VA which was the highest point on the branch. White Top had the distinction of being the highest point (3500’) east of the Rockies with regularly scheduled passenger service. In reality, the line continued from White Top another 35 miles or so ending in West Jefferson, NC. The N&W, unlike other railroads, names its branchlines based on where they start rather than where they end, hence the Abingdon Branch. I dug out what reference materials I had on hand and started searching the Internet for more data. For modeling purposes, the best article was written in 1975 by Tony Koester with photos by Jim Boyd published in the September 1975 Railroad Model Craftsman. Little did they know the whole line would be scrapped just two years later. Back in 1957 O. Winston Link published a photo essay titled ”Mixed Train” in the July issue of Trains. The Abingdon Branch was again the subject of a Trains article in June of 1984 written by Lloyd D. Lewis which included a general history of the line from 1900 to its demise in 1977. I discovered that the nickname for the branch, the “Virginia Creeper”, predated the N&W operation. The line was originally built as the Virginia-Carolina Railway and that led me to a publication titled The Virginia Creeper by Doug McGuinn. I also scoured other N&W books for photos and clues about the line. These included August Thieme’s The Norfolk & Western... As I Knew It, Mallory Ferrell’s Norfolk & Western Steam’s Last Stand and O. Winston Link’s The Last Steam Railroad in America which devotes and entire chapter to the Abingdon Branch. As for modeling plans, thank goodness Bob Hundman, publisher of Mainline Modeler, had grandparents who lived in Abingdon. His fond memories of the town led him to publish many plans over the years including the Abingdon passenger station, the freight house, pedestrain foot bridge, the Bristol depot and the depot at Green Cove. I also did extensive research on the Internet. I started with a Google search on “Virginia Creeper” and discovered the line from Damascus to White Top has been turned into a bike trail managed by the U.S. Forest Service. Virtually every bridge and trestle between those two points still exists and there are photos of many of them on a website dedicated to the biketrail [www.vacreepertrail.us]. I found a website for the town of Damascus and one for White Top. The depot at Damascus is gone. The depot at Green Cove, just before White Top, is the original while the depot at White Top itself was rebuilt by the Forest Service in 2000. I found topographical maps at the MapTech website [www. historical.maptech.com/index.cfm], and I found a trove of N&W photographs online at Virginia Tech [imagebase.lib.vt.edu/browse. php?folio_ID=/trans] with over 12,000 photos. I found 3 photos of the same end of the Damascus depot and one photo showing an end and the rear of the White Top depot. ed the walls a very pale blue-white. Once that was done we addressed the floor covering. Previously, I simply painted the concrete floor. After standing on that floor for many hours I decided we needed something easier on the feet. I opted for commercial grade carpeting installed over a foam pad. The second major issue with the room was lighting. Originally I had 9 incandescent flood light fixtures. As you can see in Photo 1, this resulted in hot spots of light and lots of shadows between the fixtures. I decided to install Compact Fluorescent Lights (CFLs), but not just any CFL. For about two years now I’ve been using an Ott-Lite lamp at my workbench and I really liked the clean white light it put out. I called Ott-Lite and found they made CFLs with an Edison base. Since I already had pots in the ceiling I opted to add 29 more, basically one pot every 2 feet around the periphery of the room and down the center over the peninsula. CFLs use much less energy than incandescent bulbs, about 75% less. The 38 CFLs I’m using now consume 15 Watts less energy than the 9 flood lights I had before. They don’t heat up the room either. The downsides are cost and warm-up time. Ott-Lites cost about double what a run-of-the-mill CFL would cost in a big-box home improvement store but the quality of light is spectacular. As for warm-up time, it takes about a minute before the lamps come up to full brightness. I can deal with that. Next time... a plan evolves. u Photo 1: The old lighting system during construction of the original layout. Notice the hotspots on the wall from the flood lights. Figure 2: A portion of a topo map from green Cove to White Top. Check out the horseshoe curve! Last but not least, I joined a mailing list at the N&W Historical Society and posted a few questions about the line. Several people replied with answers and leads to answers. This would prove to be one of my best decisions. Prepping The Room Jaini and I tore out the old layout right to the walls. We repaint- Photo 2: The new lighting system during construction of the new layout. The Ott-Lites provide even, bright, non-glaring illumination. Jan/Feb ’10 - O Scale Trains • 13 P&D Hobby Shop 31280 Groesbeck, Fraser, MI 48026 Voice: 586-296-6116 • Fax: 586-296-5642 Open Mon-Fri 10-8 • Sat 10-6, Sun 12-5 www.pdhobbyshop.com For All Your O Scale Needs Power/Repower Kits for Red Caboose GPs from $160. P&D F Units Powered A Units - $289 Call Now! O Scale Trains Subscription Rates: 6 issues US - Periodical Class Delivery US$35 US - First Class Delivery (1 year only) US$45 Canada/MexicoUS$55 OverseasUS$80 Grade Crossing Signal Set Grade Crossing Signal Set CS-2 Grade Crossing Signal Set includes: CS-2A Signal withCrossing flat cap Signal and basic mast support CS-2 Grade Set includes: CS-2B Signal with bell cap and junction support CS-2A Signal with flat cap and basic mastbox support AWS-1 Advanced Warning Signs (X2) CS-2B Signal with bell cap and junction box support WPS-1 Whistle Post Signs (X2) AWS-1 Advanced Warning Signs (X2) GCF-1 Flasher/Detector WPS-1 Whistle Post Signs (X2) GCF-1 Flasher/Detector $69.95 plus $6.95 S/H in the continental U.S. Custom Signals $69.95 plus $6.95 S/H inwww.customsignals.com the continental U.S. 27 Gellatly Drive (877) 523-3236 www.customsignals.com Custom Signals Wappingers Falls, NY 12590 phone/fax 27 Gellatly Drive Wappingers Falls, NY 12590 (877) 523-3236 phone/fax PO Box 289, Exton PA 19341-0289. voice: 610-363-7117 • fax 610-363-7357 • Office hours are Mon. - Thurs. 10:00 am to 5:00 pm. Leave a message and someone will call you back. Closed Fri. thru Sun. • Back issues available are: 32, 38, 40, 41, 44 & 45 @$6.95 ea. Include $5.00 postage for every 4 copies. • Subscriptions which start with the current issue already on the street will be charged $2 extra for postage. Subscriptions and back issues can be ordered at our website. Check our website for free downloadable PDFs of early issues. • OST is published in January, March, May, July, September & November. Issues usually arrive by the second week of the issue month. If your issue is not delivered by the end of the month, call and we will replace it. • Your subscription expiration date is now printed on the mailing label. 14 • O Scale Trains - Jan/Feb ’10 Hard Coal Scarcity Let me take this time to say how much I enjoy O Scale Trains and how much I enjoyed talking N&W steam with Mr. Giannovario at the Baltimore O Scale National. I’d like to comment on Ed Bommer’s B&O coal trestle article. It’s a fine article and I enjoyed reading about this really nice model. However, I take issue with the suggestion that folks along the Virginian, N&W and other bituminous coal roads heated their homes with anthracite coal. A family friend, who for many years ran a fuel business here in Lynchburg, refutes that notion also saying: “You couldn’t get anthracite coal, everyone burned bituminous!” I can attest that after years of pouring over photos taken along the Virginian, N&W and C&O, it’s extremely rare to see a hopper from one of the anthracite roads in a train, let alone seeing one on a local coal trestle. It may seem logical that people might have preferred the clean burning anthracite, but the soft coal was much more readily available and probably cheaper since it didn’t have to be shipped as far. I most respectfully suggest that Mr. Bommer is mistaken on this point. Thanks for listening and keep up the great work on the magazine. Ed Burnett, Lynchburg VA, via email Drillbits & Drill Bits I am glad to see that somebody else out there knows the correct terminology for the drills we use. I was pleasantly surprised when I saw [Joe’s] reference to the use of a twist drill on page 51 of issue #44. I maintain there is no such thing as a drillbit. Bernard Brock, Santa Fe NM Joe replies: Bernard is correct. There is no such thing as a drillbit. There is, however, such a thing as a drill bit. The “bit” is the cutting device that fits in a drill. The typical metal cutting bits most hobbyists use are called twist drills. There are other types of metal cutting drills. Bits designed for drilling wood have names like auger bit or Forstner bit. Crossing Gate Electronics Regarding Ted Byrne’s PoweringUp article on grade crossing detection and how to actuate the crossing signal realistically. That is a very interesting solution that he describes. I faced a similar dilemma when I had to give up the DC-only crossing detectors I had used and find something that would determine the directionality for either DC or DCC operations. The infrared detection system offered by John Parsons of MRMatix ([www.mrmatix.com], P.O. Box 6763, Longmont, CO 80501) proved to be just the answer for me. His system can operate lighted and motorized type crossing signals, and John was very helpful in working out a wiring modifi- cation for the particular crossing signal I wanted to use. Charlie Morrill, via email Danielson’s Trees #47 was a great issue. I was mpressed with the trees on the feature layout --but no mention was made of them. Their source and construction methods, etc. would have been wonderful Donald P Wilkinson, via email Duane Danielson replies: Ninetynine percent of the trees are from Scenic Express modified by me and repainted to more proper colors. I think they are the EX200 series with about 15 in a pkg for $29. I have over 3000 trees so far. Sweeper Correction I am quite pleased with how my Double Truck Double Brush Trolley Sweeper article came out in issue 47. Thank you. The following corrections should be noted: • Figure 1 on page 12: There should be a box around the left ‘33’, as there is around the right most ‘33’. • Second paragraph, second sentence on page 13 should read: With DC this would give pole reverse but with DCC, the forward direction is determined by the connection of the orange and gray leads to the motor. Thank you, again. Bill Brandt, via e-mail Jan/Feb ’10 - O Scale Trains • 15 Extra! Extra! Read All About It! 5 $19.9 h p& plus Two new O Scale publications. Learn all you need to know about O Scale in the 21st century. We cover: Operations, Track & Trackplanning, Locomotives, Rolling Stock, Scenery & Structures and we cover the specialty topics of Narrow Gauge, Traction, P48/Finescale and the latest in Command Control Systems. Plus we give you our exclusive Source lists to help you find everything you need to enjoy modern O Scale. The 2nd Edition Guide is completely rewritten and revised with all new color photos and upto-date Source lists. No O Scaler should be without a copy of this invaluable guide. To order A Guide To Modern O Scale, 2nd Ed. in the U.S., send check or money order for $19.95 plus $5 p&h to O Scale Trains Magazine, PO Box 289, Exton PA 19341. Pennsylvania residents must add 6% Sales Tax. Outside the U.S. or if you wish to pay by credit card, please go to www.oscalemag.com and purchase through the website shopping cart. 16 • O Scale Trains - Jan/Feb ’10 For too long O Scale modelers have had to contend with layout books and trackplanning articles geared to HO or other scales. Pieces of The Puzzle changes that by giving design tips and techniques directed to the unique needs of O Scale. This 48 page book also includes a PDF format photo CD featuring the book’s photos in full color along with a bonus chapter of extra material and photos not included in the printed copy. Pieces of The Puzzle will get you off to a good start if you are new to O Scale, P48 or just thinking of finally starting that new layout. $14.9 plus 5 p&h To order Pieces of the Puzzle in the U.S., send check or money order for $14.95 plus $3 p&h to Cougill Studios, PO Box 1402, Richmond IN 47375. Indiana residents must add 7% Sales Tax. Outside the U.S. or if you wish to pay by credit card, please go to www.oscalemag.com and purchase through the website shopping cart. The Engine House at Gorre Jim Gore The engine house at Gorre. It’s all cardstock! For those of us of a certain age (and even some who are younger), John Allen has been an icon for longer than most of us are willing admit. His Gorre & Daphetid (G&D) has been the exemplar for model railroad realism and operation. I had the chance to visit John’s layout once. Unfortunately, I shipped out to Vietnam a week before the scheduled visit. When I returned, John had died and the G&D had burned to the ground. In the September 1948 issue of The Model Craftsman, John introduced us to his engine house at Gorre. It was build of the common scratchbuilding materials of the day: Strathmore bristol board, stripwood (if you could get it), and celluloid from old film (for the windows) – total cost 98 cents. I am still amazed at the results, although I get a chuckle over John’s suggestion of using an ice pick to create scribed siding on the bristol board. Over the next few years John won regional and national honors for that structure while introducing another concept – ageing or weathering of structures. John’s structure was meant for shortline or secondary service, but it was a beauty! After examining the drawings John provided for the magazine, this is a building with a lot of character and (as my wife puts it when she sees a new house) lots of potential. However, it is pretty small but ideal for narrow gauge. Although there have been several kits released over the past 60 years to honor or reproduce that engine house (most notably the Fine Scale Miniatures version), the most recent offering is unique. Made entirely of cardstock, by Clever Models, it harkens back to John’s original and certainly challenges the builder to step into the “shoes of the master” as it were. Indeed, the Clever Models kit doesn’t rely upon stripwood at all, it’s all cardstock! With all of the wonders of CAD design and the artistic ability to create textures, colors and weathered patterns, this model is contemporary in its production but reprises some old construction techniques and disciplines. I had the pleasure of working with Thom Miecznikowski of Clever Models in testing his version of the G&D Engine House and suggested a few design changes and additions. Thom discovered that, unlike their other models, the number of parts and details for the engine house would require over 50 printed pages and be pretty costly. So, Clever Models has opted to offer the model on DVD, bundled with some options and a model of John’s water tower at Gorre. I’ve been receiving the various pages via email, printing them out on my own printer, and doing test construction. I thought I would relate my adventures to the readers of OST. Getting Into Cardstock Modeling Paper and cardstock models are not new. The art has been practiced in Europe for several centuries. Probably one of the most famous paper and card modelers was Joseph Merrick in the late 19th Century. If you are an aficionado of European model railway magazines, you already know the wealth of cardstock models available. Examine some of the well-known layouts in the United Kingdom and Europe and you will see many incredible card and paper models, rivaling the best of the craftsman kits. Of course European modelers also have other media that we American modelers are less familiar with. (Anybody tried an etched-brass structure kit recently?) For some reason, in the 1970s, we gave up on cardstock models (it was thin cardboard, after all) and turned to wood, plastic, plaster, and various resins. With the advent of new CAD software, the days of single color artwork on cardstock are gone. The new purveyors of cardstock models can truly call them craftsman kits as they contain a multitude of detail and color variations (weathering) already printed. All you have to do is add those detail parts make it more threedimensional. Cardstock First, you must print out the pages on appropriate paper. Clever Models use 80 lb cardstock for their kits but I decided to go with what was available at the local office supply store. After some experimentation, I decided to use 65-lb ultrawhite cardstock for all of the sides and ends, as well as those parts which will require bending. For the large (and flat) struc- Jan/Feb ’10 - O Scale Trains • 17 The kit arrives as a DVD but you must print out about 60 pages by the time you’re done. This page shows the exterior side of the end wall. The window openings are cut out and windows and frames from other pages are added in layers to give a 3-D look and feel. Here’s that same end after the various pieces have been layered on to give dimension. An interior wall is also laminated. This layering gives the wall considerable strength and integrity. tural parts like the fascia, windows, window and door frames, etc. I used 110-lb cardstock (ultra-white if you can find it, but I have found that the standard white works well enough). You can use just about any home printer. I have both inkjet and laser printers, and both seem to work just fine. Set the printer settings as if you were going to print a photograph so that any “grain” is minimized. Also tell your printer that you are using cardstock so that it eases up on the feed-roller tension a little. Although I have never experienced it, I am told that some printers might make the print a little green or yellow. You may have to adjust your printer’s color settings. Obviously, since it is printed from a PDF file, these are not laser cut parts, so you will need lots of #11 blades. I used over 20 blades to complete the model. At the first sign of dullness, replace the blade. This is especially important when cutting out the openings for all of those windows (and there are a lot of them). The other valuable tools include a good metal straight-edge (or two). A square is quite nice to have for some parts and a self-healing cutting pad. Planning Despite the fact that it’s cardstock, you have invested in a craftsman kit; treat it accordingly. If this kit were not provided on DVD, it would cost well over $100 for the 60+ pages of printed parts and options. Most model kits tell you to take the time to read the instructions before commencing. Since I was experimenting with this kit, there were no instructions, but it did teach me something very important about card- 18 • O Scale Trains - Jan/Feb ’10 This is a page with a set of interior beams. They must be folded and the tabs appropriately glued in order to create the set of seven interior supports. stock craftsman kits. Take the time to study all of the pages of parts and visualize not only how the parts are to be folded and cemented together but how you want it to look when completed. Ask yourself: “What is my order of construction? Which of these parts need to be sandwiched in multiples for the best effect?” I spent a week jotting down notes before I lifted the first #11 blade. Six weeks later (about 1.5 hours per day), I completed the project. Adhesives Although it may not sound correct, I used CA glue (medium viscosity) for cementing the parts together even for the large building sides. If you draw a bead of CA along the wall edges just 2 or 3mm inboard, as well as along the edge of each window or door opening, and place a few dabs in between, and then quickly put weight on the piece, the CA will spread sufficiently. Don’t use white glue (or any other water-based glue), it will warp the parts and cause the ink to run or discolor. After trial and error (a whole lot of error), I would not recommend spray adhesives either. The solvent in the cement soaks through the cardstock and discolors everything. That’s the nice part about the kit; if you make a mistake, just print out another piece and start over (I did that a few times too). The opposite side with the interior laminations. The structural beams are all individual pieces. I used a piece of Kappler’s O Scale 12x12 as a gluing surface when creating the beams. They are just slightly larger and the “jig” can be removed when the tab has been glued and the sides aligned. The gussets are double pieces with their edges painted using a black magic marker with the backs painted with a Floquil Rail Brown marker. Making the Model Dimensional There are four methods to creating a realistic cardstock model: layering, edge-painting for contrast, weathering, and detailing. The trick to any of these kits is creating three-dimensions out of two. Think, for example, of a window. The realism of a model window is the fact that the mullions, frame, glass, and the sill are all on different planes. With a printed cardstock model, the same thing applies. Clever Models provides those layers in the form of extra windows, frames, mullions, etc. When all cut out, they can be layered to create the window on the wall. A typical window, then, would have a sandwich of an inside set of mullions, a layer of clear plastic, the exterior mullions, and then the exterior frame with perhaps another frame placed on top of that, all completed with a layer for the lower sill. So, for this model, the walls are layered with fascia strips (to your chosen thickness) with doors and windows often made of four or five layers, to give them true three dimensions. Of course, the edges of the layered parts must be painted to remove the white color of the cardstock. Besides, covering the white of the paper, the edge color can be used to create a little contrast to make the layer even more noticeable. In addition to the old standbys from Floquil (I use their acrylics) I have accumulated quite an array of acrylic paints from the local arts and crafts stores. Some of my favorite colors are driftwood, blue-gray, and a variety of browns (Railroad Tie Brown is a particularly useful soft contrast color), in addition to whites, and yellows. I choose a color that is slightly darker than the printed color. This gives a little shadow to the part and adds to the dimensionality. I use a black permanent marker with a fine point for the edges of things like tarpaper and some hinges to really increase the contrast. Whenever possible, the colors should be painted from the reverse (white) side of the part. Use the side of the brush to apply the paint. With the bevel of the cut coming towards you, misapplications of the paint (“slop”; it’s a technical phrase) tend to be on the white side, where they won’t be seen. The exposed edge of a folded part must also be painted. In that case, I use the tip of the brush but dilute the paint by dipping the brush in “wet water” (a drop of dish detergent in a small bowl) before dipping into the smallest amount of paint. When dragged lightly along the folded edge, the paint tends to run quickly into the fold. You might think that the water would warp the parts but most acrylic paints are so thick and set so fast that this doesn’t create a problem. Weathering Once completed, cardstock kits can be weathered just like any other kit. Before adding the clear plastic windows (or even before cutting out any parts), a light coating of Dullcote (or similar) will give the surface some tooth for weathering powders and will protect the colors from fading. Obviously, you can’t use washes (especially alcohol washes) to any great effect. However, some controlled streaking can be done with very dry washes (several times) of acrylic paints and weathering chalks can be used with great results. With brick buildings, I even outline a few bricks with my fine-point black marker to indicate grime and mold. Details Of course, we all want to add those details that personal- The sides of the engine house are created by placing two appropriate sides together and joining them with overlays of material to represent the outside braces and inside beams (you can make out the joint, here, on the inside view). Is the building too short for K-27s or K-36s? Just print out another side and make the building three courses long! As I began to create the box of the structure and add the supporting beams, I added Kappler scribed material for the floor (you could also use Clever Models’ wood underlayment laminated to sheet plastic) and laid some On30 track. Jan/Feb ’10 - O Scale Trains • 19 Before the final wall went up, I created some interior details. With all of those windows and skylights, somebody is going to peek in and see if there is any action going on inside. I used all kinds of details and figures from my various junk boxes. John Allen’s original structure had brick stacks and metal vents extending into the enginehouse. I liked circular ones instead, so Thom designed new ones for me. Cardstock does a remarkable job of resembling sheet metal. This vent is composed of seven pieces which are cut and folded. Although John Allen’s structure was designed for the warmer climates of southern California, my layout is set in the high mountains of New Mexico. I wanted some doors and Thom Meicznikowski was kind enough to design some for me. John Allen’s cupola had windows, so that’s what I added. Clever Models also provides a cupola with slatted vents, instead. I still have no idea why John added that piece of stripwood along the base of the cupola, but I did too. ize the structure and give it that used appearance. In the case of a structure that might appear overly two-dimensional, I think the external details are particularly important. For example, even though you could add an additional layer to represent a door-knob, I added something a little more dimensional. Those pins that seem to be everywhere on the latest shirt that you bought work just great for an O Scale doorknob (I think I have enough to populate every door on every O Scale layout on the planet). I always keep a good supply of Grandt Line (or other suppliers) lamp shades The roof is Clever Models’ roof underlayment laminated to around. One really good way to give the 3-D look is somethe roof sheets, with the skylights cut out. I liked some of the thing sticking out from the flat surface. So, a lamp or two Rusty Stump’s skylights better, so it’s easy to add them in the over loading doors and entryways gives a good appearance. appropriate place (at each end, in this view). Eventually it will be Another nice touch is a gutter and downspout along the edge covered with cardstock shingles, except for a few holes to reveal of the roof. I have used soda straws carefully cut in half for that very nice underlayment. gutters with plastic rod for the downspout. Clever Models 20 • O Scale Trains - Jan/Feb ’10 The holes in the shingles have to be repaired. The underlayment is nicely exposed and an unlucky employee gets to climb the ladder and make the fix. Now it’s an engine house and ready to go! It will soon be installed on my On30 Jemez & Rio Grande. It is indeed remarkable that John Allen produced this realistic and dramatic model for less than a dollar. The Clever Models’ version is as realistic and it does challenge the skills that craftsmen must possess. Many current day craftsman-kit aficionados ask me why anyone would bother to regress back to old techniques and materials when so many new (and easier) kits are available? Once you have completed a few of these cardstock beauties, it becomes much easier and less daunting to challenge that box of sticks or to scratchbuild that structure you’ve always wanted. I view these cardstock models as the best of modern computer aided design with incredible artwork combined with some tried and true techniques that may have been lost or pushed aside. So, why do I want to bother with cardstock structures? Quite frankly, my most common response is like that of most mountain climbers, “Because I can and because it’s there!” u All of those nifty detail parts make the scene come to life and tends to convince people that maybe cardstock isn’t so bad after all even sells a cardstock set of gutters, but you still have to do a little painting and weathering and create the downspouts. A few stacks of various stuff (standpipes, smoke stacks, etc.), is also a good touch. Some scrap stripwood to create a frame around an inset door or a wooden ramp outside a loading door also help to create the illusion of form and function. Finally, add a little clutter along the base of the structure to give more dimensions and make the entire scene come alive. No matter how well I do (and I suspect there may be others like me), there will be a gap somewhere that just won’t go away. Even though paper/card is a very forgiving medium, sometimes (usually due to my own ineptitude) things just don’t quite line up (or the CA dries too darn fast before alignment). That’s the time to get a little creative. In Howard Zane’s scenery world, it’s HIWAB (hide it with a bush). My HIWAB is “hide it with a board” (or two or three). Jan/Feb ’10 - O Scale Trains • 21 22 • O Scale Trains - Jan/Feb ’10 Traction Freight There are passengers and then there is freight…and more opportunity! When last appearing here, I made a less than oblique comment about discussing traction freight trailer kits and moving freight under the wire. The vast majority of modelers hear the words traction and trolleys and immediately jump to the conclusion of running a passenger operation, picking up and transporting commuters or residents out and about town. And while perhaps many modelers do run a passenger trolley about their layout in some configuration, so much more could be done to interchange with one’s other modeling interests, be it steam or diesel driven. This of course does not refer to those heavy mainline boxcabs and electrics common to the PRR and other lines. Consider in your mind’s eye the remarkably tight radii that accompany driving down the street and making turns and now image a trolley following the same route. Ok, that’s simple and easy to visualize and accept, particularly for those that have ridden such. But now consider taking 36-40’ freight cars around the same curves! To facilitate getting around that corner you could maybe relieve the corners of the freight car to have a rounded end and if that wasn’t enough, you could permit the coupler to pivot or use a radial coupler that would swivel through the arc as defined by the end curvature of the car. Now you can run freight cars through your cityscapes, wrap right around the blocks and navigate directly up to the doorways of warehouses and businesses to make deliveries with none of those nasty expulsions from steam or diesel powered locomotives. Traction freight cars were built and used by such luminaries like the Northern Ohio Traction & Light Company, Union Traction, the Cincinnati & Lake Erie, and the Western Ohio Railway. Of course, just about any configuration of regular freight car translated across to traction freight cars, e. g. , flat cars, gondolas, boxcars, reefer cars (even billboard reefers), and the list goes on. There were even standard designs generated by the Central Electric Railway Association (CERA) to address increasing freight business and to decrease maintenance and repair costs. Thus was borne the Standard Freight Trailer, or CERA box trailer, as described in the Electric Railway Journal in 1926. For a good introduction into the use of traction freight and freight cars, I can recommend that you sit down with a copy of Not only Passengers: How the Electric Railways Carried Freight, Express and Baggage. This happens to be Bulletin 129 of the other CERA, the Central Electric Railfans’ Association, and copies can be located with minimal effort. And of course back issues of both Traction and Models combined with Trolley Talk are both invaluable resources; the former published plans of an array of box trailers, and even a paper model that could be cut out and assembled. So, what are the options for traction modelers? Unsurprisingly and unfortunately, very few options indeed exist for today’s O Scale traction modeler. A few short decades ago you could order as many as 6 different types of box trailers from All-Nation; those kits still surface periodically but with decreasing frequency. One of the 36’ box trailers that I’ve managed to acquire is shown in Photo 1. All-Nation also 1 had offered a stake side flat car trailer with and without a load, and a gondola. Midwestern Train Hobbies produces (produced?) two traction trailer kits; a flat car and a stock trailer. While the flat car provides an outstanding entry point for scratchbuilding a vast array of possibilities, the stock trailer can provide a reasonable representation of an actual prototype car, albeit one that will have to have all of the appropriate details added to it as these kits come with very little, if any, detail parts. The stock trailer is patterned after the #651-79 series of cars that ran on the Interstate Public Service Company in Indiana that were built in 1924. After that lengthy list of possibilities, there seems to be precious few other options except to scratchbuild such cars for your layout or to score a vintage car off eBay (Photo 2). But before 2 embarking on that exercise, note that LaBelle (who continues to make some outstanding wooden O Scale trolley kits) also makes three different box trailers in HO, including the CERA box trailer, a standard design one can build in as many as 16 different configurations. One could probably scale up such kits with reasonable assurances of success. I think it’s entirely possible that we’ll head off in that direction in some future installment! u Jan/Feb ’10 - O Scale Trains • 23 More Laser-Cut Kits from B.T.S. ! McCabe Lumber Co. MoW Speeder Company House This company house was inspired by one from Pickshin, WV. The kit includes the piling to build it for a level surface or for a sloped location. Interior partitions are included as are positionable doors and windows. This kit consists of laser-cut basswood, plywood, and detail castings. #17237 $ 54.95 Approx. Size - 31' x 35'. An old boxcar body, a truck chassis, and some great planning on the part of the crew provided the main ingredients for a unique and handy speeder. The body kit consists of laser-cut basswood, plywood, cardstock, and brass, urethane, & white metal detail castings. And the driver, load, and decals are included. The fully-assembled mechanism is American Made by David Hoffman. It features a sheet brass frame, lost-wax brass end steps, NWSL gears and wheelsets. Scale 27’ long over footboards. On3/On30 versions also #18280 $ 239.95 available. Green Springs Depot Handcar Shed West of Bellevue, Ohio stands Green Springs Junction on the NKP. Over the years, the original depot was modified with large doors in the baggage room. This kit consists of laser-cut basswood, plywood, and cardstock, self-adhesive shingles, and detail castings. The doors are positionable, and floor and interior partitions are included. Approx. Size - 24’ x 52’ #17162 Track gangs needed a place to store their handcars when not in use as well as all their tools and supplies. Sheds with tracks quickly answered the need. This kit consists of laser-cut basswood, plywood, and cardstock, and detail castings. The footprint is approximately 18’ x 20’. $ 109.95 #17503 $ 49.95 McCabe Water Tank Willet’s Supply Co. Willet’s Supply Company represents a small trackside firm dealing in just about anything! This kit consists of laser-cut basswood, plywood, and cardstock, and detail castings. Approx. Size 45' x 24' #17435 $95.95 At the McCabe Lumber Company, the water tanks were unsophisticated, open-top 20,000-gallon tank based upon several different prototype tanks. The standard gauge version of the tank is shown in the photos. The bents of the On3/30 version are a scale 30" shorter in height; details and the tank are the same as the standard gauge version. The base of the tank has a scale 18' square footprint. See-thru 'water' is included. Laser-cut wood with plastic & metal detail castings. #17490 O $ 99.95 #17489 On3/30 $ 99.95 Junior’s Shiner A perfect little mobile home fit for the 1930’s to the present time. The kit includes venetian blinds and color awning. Laser cut wood and styrene with metal detail castings. Approx. Size - 34' x 22' #17405 $ 49.95 www.btsrr.com Shipping - $5.00/order in the US 304-823-3729 All Scale Catalog - $5.00 Celebrating 30 Years of Service since 1979 OST 01-10:Layout 1 11/3/09 4:46 PM Page 1 Resistance Soldering – the Easy, Professional Way to Solder Starting at 199 95 $ #82111 Get our BIG catalog of model trains, tools and more FREE with any order! Order Toll-Free 1-800-225-1066 Shop On-Line at www.micromark.com Please mention code 3694 when ordering Etched brass numbers SP-style, MSRP: $15. Deichman’s Depot O Scale 3518-1 Conrail (Svngs Bond) SD-40 DC/DCC $407.95 2004100-2 D&H U23b DC 212.45 20-2779-2 NS U30C w/P2 AC/DC 404.95 7345-1 Beacon Feeds PS4427 Hopper 57.75 7374-2 WM 40' Airslide Hopper 50.95 7768-2 Reading Fishbelly Hopper 44.60 7766-1 WM 55T Fishbelly Hopper(Pt. of Balti.) 44.60 7780-4 PC (MOW) H21a Hopper 55.20 9383-2 Kimberly-Clark 70T Cov. Hopper 55.20 9052-1 ASD 36' Wood Reefer 55.20 9053-2 Libby's 36' Wood Reefer 55.20 9062-2 Dubuque 36' Wood Reefer 57.50 9088-2 Great Falls Beer 40' Wood Reefer 67.95 9091-1 Flaharty Dairy 40' Wood Reefer 82.95 9122-1 Harding Butter 40' Reefer 65.95 9196-1 Borden's 40' Wood Reefer 57.75 9403-6 NH 50' PS-1 DD Box 55.20 9855-2 Schmidt's 50' PS-1 PD Box 59.45 9280-5 Trusweet 17,600K Tank 66.25 9286-3 ADM (Leaf) 17,600 Tank 66.25 9287-2 ADM (Molecule) 17,600 Tank 66.25 9693-3 PRR (Delivery Scheme) USRA SS Box 50.95 3002009-1 WP 53'6" Wood Express Reefer 67.95 Deichman’s Depot 110 Ivyside Dr, York PA 17402 Ph: 717-755-1108 • Fax: 717-840-9650 [email protected] www.deichmansdepot.com finally a TOUGH sUper GlUe. © 2009 Gorilla Glue Company Another Special Tool from fOr THe TOUGHesT jObs On planeT earTH® 1-800-966-3458 Made in U.S.A. East Gary Car Co. Dept OST 3828 St. Joseph Ct Lake Station IN 46405 They’re Back! Former Indianapolis Car Company sides are now available from new tooling. Parts #100 & #200 $3.00 each More brass numbers coming soon! Field parts for your interlocking tower: pipe carriers, crank stands and cranks. Visit our web site for details. Orders under $50 please add $4.50 for postage and handling. SASE for updated list. The Irish Tracklayer 2682 W. Palo Alto Ave Fresno CA 93771 www.irishtracklayer.com Jan/Feb ’10 - O Scale Trains • 25 VALLEY MODEL TRAINS Dimensions: 9-3/4 x 4-3/4 x 4-1/2" Dock Adds 2" to Length 135 NW Greeley Avenue, Bend OR 97701 479 - 2 per pack 4 x 3 x 2-3/4" 489 Loft Barn Kit O.............................................42.98 36.55 479 Long-Bell Lumber skid shacks 2/ O42.98 36.55 Crow River Products Resin and Metal Kits..... 308 www.sumptervalley.com [email protected] Tel: 541/382-3413 Fax:541/389-7237 Footprint with loading dock 3" X 10" Use in the yard, on a dock or industry. 308 Fixed Boom Crane O.....................65.00 58.50 Includes utility tank shown on right - For use with Derricks, ClamShell Derricks or as Logging Donkeys Hours: Mon. thru Fri 8:30 AM - 5PM and sometimes on Saturdays O111 323 323 3-Drum Steam Hoisting Engine O .....80.00 73.60 O111 Utility Tank O....1 ¼”L X 2 ½”H ........net 8.00 Main Street Heritage Resin Kits..... 505 503 5 x 9-1/2" w/ boardwalk 5-1/2 x 8" w/ sidwalks 505 The Weekly Record O ...................66.95 61.60 503 Bill's Place O..................................62.95 57.90 Evergreen Hill Design O Laser Cut kits Footprint: 9" deep (including both decks) 11" wide (including stairs) 8" high (including fire barrels) 2007 Dollar Bros Motor Express Kit O 2007 Dollar Bros Motor Express Kit O 169.95 144.50 lots of detail parts 2005 Includes pool table, cues, balls, stove, radio 2011 2005 30's Gas Station O (4 x 6.25”) ......59.95 50.99 2011 Pool Hall with table O (5.25 x 6”)..69.95 59.50 Add $8.00 S&H in 48 States • Others pay actual postage cost • N.Y. residents add 8.25% sales tax. (prices are subject to change w/o notice) www.valleymodeltrains.com 26 • O Scale Trains - Jan/Feb ’10 Visit our website to see hundreds of HO and O Scale Craftsman Kits 489 valleymodeltrains.com 484 484 Elevated Warehouse Kit O.......................79.95 67.98 6 x 4-1/4 x 6" Check our website for latest O Scale Listings Custom Run Items valleymodeltrains.com Specializing in O Scale 2-rail model trains since 1985 ● We buy or consign brass model collections ● Model reservations gladly accepted ● Prompt, courteous service ● The Public Delivery Track Now order online! PO BOX 1251, Wappingers Falls, N.Y. 12590 Credit Card Orders Welcome Order/Info(845)297-3866 Fax(845)298-7746 American Model Builders O Scale Laser Kits Now order online! Sumpter Valley Depot Atlas..SP 2 bay hopper car, large lettering...$63 SP and SINCLAIR 8K tank cars..$63 ea SP double sheathed box cars...reserve WP 40' "Rides Like a Feather" box car...reserve WP 52' mill gondola, feather logo..reserve MILW and RI "MDT" steel reefers...$55 ea Golden Gate...Sleepers..Erie, DLW, SF, MILW..$119 Coaches..PRSL, RG, Erie, DLW, MILW, RDG..$109 Head end cars..Erie, DLW, MILW, NYC...$119 Weaver...50' flat w/trailer..UP, Erie, SP, SF..reserve RPO & Baggage..Erie, CNJ, SF, PRSL..$75-$90 Locomotives Atlas..U-23, GP-15, RSD's, Dash-8, RS-3..$159-$299 RS-1's, GP 7/9, F-3's..$399-$449. SW's..$199-$359 GP-35's, SD-35's, SD-40's, D8-40b's..$329-$449 Alco Century's..PRR, EL, CN, ACL, L&N, BRC..$329-$449 3 rail scale diesels..fixed pilots, k-d couplers..inquire 3rd rail, Sunset..Greenbrier..$999. O-1..$899 SP Mogul..$749-$849. AM-2 $1499. MT-4..$1095 Wvr/Wms brass..PRR K4, A5, B6, others..call Weaver..SD-40, C628/630, E-8, Sharks..$199-$399 MTH..Premier and Railking Scale diesels..$199-$429 K-line..GP-38..CNJ. RS3..Rdg, NYC, WM, SP, PE E's..NYC, SP, CN; F's..PRR, NYC, Amtk....$249-$429 Passenger & Head End Golden Gate..Sleepers..Pullman, PRR, N&W..$109 Coaches..$100-$109. Baggage, RPO, Combine..$119 Aluminum streamliners..NYC, SP, SF, PRR..call Atlas..Industrial Rail..SF, GN, PRR, PRSL..$49 60' coach, Comb, Bag, RPO..$69. Horizon cars..$89 CALIF ZEPHYR 80' domes and sleepers..$129 MTH sets..AMTK, UP, SP, Septa, NYC..$249-$329 Weaver..60' baggage or RPO..PRSL, Erie, CNJ SF, PRR, NYC, NH, UP, CN, N&W, B&M..$60-$90 Box Cars Pecos River..SOU, KCS, NYC, SF, SP, T&P..$35-$45 Atlas..40' Woodside..30+ roads!!!...$47-$55 40' Steel..Rebuilts, or AAR..20+ roads..$47-$55 40' & 50' Trainman, 1970's (refurbished)..$30-$35 X-29's..$50-$62. HyCubes..60'..$69. 40'..$35 50'..Siide or plug door..$50-$60 60' auto parts..$52 Weaver..40' PS-1, 50' modern, Steelside, Outside braced 40+ roads..Old ones our speciality..$25-$40 Refrigerator Cars Weaver/Crown..30+ roadnames in stock..$25-$40 57' Mechanical..15+ roads..no sound..$35, sound..$50 Atlas..53' xprs..$65. 40' steel..$45-$55 36' & 40' woodside..oldies, newies, custom..$50-$125 40' plug door..Trainman, 1970's refurbished..$30-$35 K-line..Woodside..same detail as Atlas..$40-$60 Covered Hoppers Weaver PS-2 & AC-2..old & new..30+ roads..$25-$40 Centerflow or Grain..old and new..25 roads..$25-$40 Atlas..3 bay PS-2..$35. ACF 2 bay..$55-$65 New Trinity 5161..$66-$70 Cylindrical 40'..$45-$55 Airslides and PS4427's... .20+ roads......$45-$55 Hopper Cars Atlas..3 bay..WM, SOU, BN, NH, Rdg, RG..$35 Ore cars..CN, UP, DMIR..$25. H21a 4 bay..$50-$58 2 bay. usra or Panel side..10+ roads...$50-$60 Weaver..2, 3, 4-bay..30+ different roads....$25-$40 Tank Cars Weaver...40' & 50', new & old, 20+ roads...$27-$35 Atlas..33K..Propane, Delta, CNTX, Union Tex..$52 17K..Trusweet, ADM, GATX, SHPX, Stauffer, more..$65 8K..Navy Gas, Woburn, Staley, Taylor, more..$52-$59 11K..Beacon, SHPX, UTLX, Anchor, Dow..$55-$65 Flat Cars, Stock Cars Atlas..Double stacks..$129-$289. Pulp flats..$49 Front runner..$45. 89' flats..$60-$65. Trailers..$29-$35 Trainman 50' flat w/pipe load and stock cars..$30-$35 Wvr..40' & 50' flat cars, Stock cars..20+ roads..$25-$40 Gondolas Atlas..52'..15+ roads..$30-$35. 40' composite..$52-$59 Wvr..LV, RI, SF, UP, NW, Rdg, B&M, MEC, PRR..$28 Atlas Track..2 rail, 3 rail, 3 rail steel Industrial Rail..Locos.cars.trolleys.sets.track Dealers..request our wholesale list www.PublicDeliveryTrack.com e-mail us: [email protected] Drexel Hill, PA • Paso Robles, CA 610-259-4945 • 805-226-0320 Never Been? Now’s the time to come!! If you’ve never been to a National Convention of the NMRA or to Milwaukee Wisconsin, now is the time to come and visit us in July 2010. We are planning a, rip roaring Midwestern, good time for all, both model railroader and general interest attendee alike. Our goal as a committee is to have the best attended convention in NMRA history! On Sunday we are going to kick off the week with a Beer and Brat Fest (a Milwaukee favorite) at Ziegler Park, just a stone’s throw away from the convention site and hotel. I can hear the Um-pah-pahs now! Some of you may have not felt comfortable attending a national convention because you don’t know anyone else. Never fear, at Brat Fest we will match you up with three other attendees who model in the same scale, or maybe even the same prototype, or are fellow freelancers. You may get to know some interesting people, get new ideas about the hobby, and have a great time. I challenge the other regions in the Midwest to consider chartering a bus or taking AMTRAK to Milwaukee as a group in order to lower an individual’s transportation costs and to increase the fun factor. So will there be a bus originating in Indianapolis? Bring your spouse, significant other, your family or a friend along. They don’t have to be NMRA members and you don’t have to railroad every minute. There are lots of fun things to do in Milwaukee. We will have garden, shopping and sightseeing tours as well as general interest clinics for non-rails. There will be a special event every evening consisting of a dinner cruise aboard the Edelweiss, a dinner social at the Milwaukee Public Museum, the Ladies Luncheon at the Wisconsin Club, a Sunset Zoofari at the world renowned Milwaukee County Zoo, a dinner train trip on the East Troy Electric Railroad and a Milwaukee Fish Fry at the Historic Turner Hall. You can also find adventure at the Harley Davidson Museum, the Milwaukee Art Museum, the Eisner Museum of Advertising and Design, the Mitchell Park Domes, Discovery World and Pier Wisconsin, the Betty Brinn Children’s Museum, and on the Schooner Dennis Sullivan. There will be free musical entertainment at River Splash and Jazz in the Park, or you might take in one of our ethnic festivals or Bastille Days. We also have the Milwaukee Brewers baseball team at Miller Park with its retractable roof. If you feel lucky, take a trip to the Potawatomi Casino. All of these attractions are in walking distance or a short bus ride from downtown. Not enough to do in Milwaukee? Downtown Chicago is a short ride via AMTRAK. Besides all the great ideas and information that you can gain at the clinics and demonstrations, there will be several layout and industrial tours for you to choose from including tours of Kalmbach Publishing and William K. Walthers. Come and see what it’s all about. We’re looking forward to meeting you! Sincerely, Ken Jaglinski – Vice Chair u Jan/Feb ’10 - O Scale Trains • 27 CHICAGO “O” SCALE MEET March 12-14th, 2010 NEW LOCATION!!! Westin Lombard Yorktown Center Show registration – write or email 70 Yorktown Center MARCH MEET – 2636 Hallquist Ave. Lombard, Illinois 60148 Red Wing, MN 55066 (630) 745-7600 1-800-937-8461 Ask for the Chicago O Scale Rate WWW.MARCHMEET.NET BUY, SELL, TRADE, CLINICS, LAYOUT TOURS & MORE! Considered the best O Scale show of the year------Limited tables available--------Register early for your preprinted badge 28 • O Scale Trains - Jan/Feb ’10 Flagpole Uncoupling Tool Ted Horvath It is fair to say that Kadees® are the couplers of choice for O Scale operators, and that many of these folks prefer manual uncoupling to the buried magnet & trip pin approach. I also favor manual uncoupling because it simulates the prototype’s reality, and does not limit uncoupling to specific locations. However, layout design, with respect to benchwork height and depth, must take into account the Giant Hand reaching down with an appropriate tool. The subject of uncoupling tools comes up regularly on Internet forums, and in those discussions people advocate a variety of things, including coffee stirrers, screwdrivers, tongue depressors, and purpose-made tools such as offered by Micro-Mark. Clearly, no one particular tool suits everyone. The flagpole uncoupling tool described here works well for me and I hope some readers will find it useful. Start with a 12”-13” length of 3/16” diameter metal rod. I used zinc-plated steel rod (from TSC) but brass or aluminum would work equally well. Grind the tip to a sharp angle, say 10º, all the way through to the other side of the rod (Photo 1). This will produce a nice rounded point for easy insertion between the couplers’ knuckles. The rounded outside face of the tapered portion seems to help the tool to rotate and spread the knuckles. When not in use, the uncoupling tool doubles as a flagpole, which can be located wherever convenient and handy for operations. The base is a 0.75” square of 0.031” brass with a 3/32” hole drilled in the center. Solder a 1.5” length of brass tube, with an inside diameter just large enough for the metal rod, centered over the hole (refer back to Photo 1). Mount the base to the layout with a small screw inserted down through the Photo 1 Photo 2 brass tube. Photo 2 shows the flagpole next to a cardboard mock-up for a proposed industry on my layout. Obviously, several flagpole uncoupling tools could be positioned on the layout so that one is always within reach. A 3/16” diameter rod scales out to 9” and is most likely too thick for a prototypical flagpole, but I have found that a 1/8” diameter rod does not open the couplers’ knuckles as well. Also, a 3/16” rod is easier for me to aim and rotate with my fingertips. Even oversized, this “flagpole” adds a realistic touch to the layout. Good luck and happy modeling! u Jan/Feb ’10 - O Scale Trains • 29 1:50 scale die cast construction and transportation replica models from SpecCast. We offer the highest level of quality and detailed features. “You can see the difference” and so will your customers. CON 008 1:50 Schield Bantam C-35 with Dragline Crane CON 012 1:50 Northwest Model 25 Shovel CON 011 1:50 Military LeTourneau Super C Tournapull with LP Carryall Scraper 38021 1:50 Red and Silver White WC22 Dump Truck 38019 1:50 John Deere White WC22 with Vintage Van Trailer 38013 1:50 Chicago Nortwestern Railroad White WC22 Stakebed Truck 39501 1:50 Union Pacific Railroad International KB-8 with Vintage Van Trailer Dealer inquiries welcomed. To learn more about these products or to become a SpecCast Dealer please call: (800) 844-8067 ext.245, e-mail: [email protected], write to: SpecCast • PO Box 368 • Dyersville, IA 52040 32 • O Scale Trains - Jan/Feb ’10 OST2 SMR TRAINS Virginia & Truckee In stock now! Photo by Get Real Productions Your source for: Motive power, rolling stock and structure plans (since 1975) Quik-Signs sign sets Scale industry directory Model Building Services Models built by Stu Gralnik 264 Marret Rd • Lexington MA 02421 Ph: 781-860-0554 [email protected] Scratch-built Steel Mill Paper Creek Models Send $2.00 for catalog Underground Railway Press Assembled buildings from any manufacturer’s kit. Kitbashed, painted and detailed...“Just Like Real!” P.O. Box 814OS Brevard, NC 28712-0814 www.modelbuildingservices.com Jan/Feb ’10 - O Scale Trains • 33 A Humpback Bridge Ray Grosser A painting by Larry Fisher* of a Soo Line FA-1 going under one of the humpback bridges north of Detroit Lakes, Minnesota, was the inspiration for this bridge on our new O Scale Nostalgia Trip railroad. The bridge pictured was one of many around the country and there are still a few around here and there. They seemed to last forever but toward the end of their life span, they required more maintenance and in snow country, they were prone to drifting snow around and in the cuts they spanned. We had to add some scenery to the outside edge of our curved track in order to get enough real estate to make the 1 34 • O Scale Trains - Jan/Feb ’10 bridge look reasonable. I prefer to have a whole bridge with scenery on both sides of the cut rather than a half bridge at the edge. Doing this on our layout is easy as we have the edge trim secured to the stringers with drywall screws. I just removed the old trim, added some 1x3 pieces to the ends of the stringers and put some Styrofoam over the top to make the topography. It was then covered with Sculpta-mold to make the surface a bit tougher (Photo 1). Running the train through the area really fired up the desire to get the bridge under construction (Photo 2). 2 To get started I decided to cut all my own lumber. I used basswood to make all the structural components. I do not have a modeling saw, so I used my 10-inch table saw with a carbide tipped blade that I found at Lowe’s (Photo 3). This blade is thinner and smaller than a regular blade so I had to make a new blade guard. For that I used some pine, thinned down in a planer to get the correct thickness, and then I 5 3 6 traced the existing blade guard to the wood, cut it out and sanded it carefully to fit the opening in the saw’s table. After mounting the blade in the saw, it is a simple matter to turn on the saw and raise the blade up through the new blade guard (Photo 4). (Editor’s note: Use common sense and caution when doing this. If the new blade guard is loose or unsecured, it can come off from the force of the blade’s rotation and cause an injury.) 4 end result appears as an old timber that had been treated with creosote. Normally the upper parts of the bridge might have been built with untreated oak, but that turns black in a short while when left out in the elements, so I used the same stain on the rest of the timbers but I had it thinned out 3-1 to get just a thin grey finish. Once I had the measurements for the bents completed, I was able to take them off the layout and finish them on the workbench. However, these were the only parts I was able to make this way (Photo 7). The bridge would not only be humped in the middle, it is also skewed over the track on a 7 I decided to build the bridge on site rather than on the workbench. This takes on a life of its own once you get started (Photo 5). I had to run that train through at least 24 times. (Yeh I know, it could have been done in one pass, but there is something about an O Scale train with all metal wheels running over track with a slight gap every 39 scale feet.) After measuring the height needed to clear everything, I started with the two bents in the center. All the other bents would have to be installed in line with these two. The round pilings were roughed up with a razor saw blade, cut to length and then stained with Ebony colored stain I got at Lowe’s (Photo 6). If you apply the stain and wipe off most of it, the Jan/Feb ’10 - O Scale Trains • 35 curve. This presented way too many variables for my worn out brain to calculate so as previously mentioned, I built things on site once the bents were completed (Photo 8). I did not have any small nails, so I used railroad spikes. They don’t look too bad from a galloping horse or a rocking railroad caboose. 10 8 Once all the bents were constructed, I put them in place and began the work of setting up the deck girders. The whole project turned out to be a cut-to-fit job (Photo 9). Several times I cut pieces twice and they were still too short. The skewed bridge is easier to look at than it is to build. I found several photos showing skewed structures like this and they appeared to be going in several directions at once. It makes for an interesting scene because nothing is square with anything else. 9 I did make an error when fitting up the handrail pockets. In an attempt to try to get them to look like ones in the Fisher painting, I actually measured wrong (Photo 10). The model’s are close to eight feet apart while the painting’s appears closer, but I decided to leave them. Realizing that installing scenery under a decked bridge would result in problems, I managed to catch myself before I put the deck on the bridge. It was really starting to come together and with the approaches cut out of two inch blue Styrofoam we were able to just glue them on to the scenery base and start the roadways. This shaping of blue Styrofoam is always done in the barn or on the driveway with the wind blowing. The fastest way I have found to remove blue Styrofoam and shape it onto scenery is to chuck up a wire brush in a right angle grinder and chew away. Photo 11 shows the completed bridge with #74 passing while the local farmer replaces several rotten deck boards and a few broken off hand rail stanchions. The next project is to build some fences to keep the horses off the tracks. u * Larry Fisher’s painting reproduced with permission of the artist. 11 36 • O Scale Trains - Jan/Feb ’10 Jim Hackworth Buy⁄Sell⁄Trade MODEL TRAINS (and Subsidiary JH Consulting) 2631 Edgevale Road, Columbus OH 43221-1113 Phone: 614-4514517 Fax: 6144514557 Email: [email protected] • Web: www.jhmtrains.com AOCC* Gem PRR B6 0-6-0, C/P or N/P, OB . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $575.00 WSM PRR J1a, 2-10-4, C/P, OB . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $1,550.00 WSM PRR M1, 4-8-2, C/P, Nice, OB . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $1,150.00 USH NYC J3a De-Streamlined 4-6-4 w/Centipede tender, C/P Ex, OB . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $1,275.00 USH C&O 2-8-4, C/P, Runs good, OB . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $1,275.00 USH PRR M1a, 4-8-2, C/P, OB . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $1,175.00 MG NYC J3a, C/P, NOB From Tony Ambrose . . . . . . . . . . . . . $1,395.00 USH NYC S1b, 4-8-4, C/P, OB . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $1,250.00 MG PRR J, 2-10-4, C/P, Icken Gears, NOB . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $1,895.00 USH NYC H10, 2-8-2, Mint, N/P, NOB . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $1,275.00 USH PRR L1, 2-8-2, N/P, LN, NOB . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $1,175.00 Gem PRR A5 0-4-0, C/P, NOB . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $475.00 Atlas EMD GP9, F/P UP, OB . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $250.00 OM N&W C630 High Hood, FM Trucks, New, OB . . . . . . . . . $1,195.00 OM NKP GP35 N/P, LN, OB . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $950.00 Consignments AOCC* USH B&O C16a, 0-4-0, C/P, OB.......................................................$675.00 PRB PC&F 62’ Boxcar, F/P UP, OB.................................................$250.00 OM PRR PAPB Set, Late Run, F/P, New......................................$2,875.00 OM #0445 C39-8, C/P, OB..............................................................$1,195.00 OM NKP War Caboose, C/P, Wtd, OB............................................$295.00 CB J&L Tank car, C/P, OB...............................................................$295.00 Scale Mod Ind Roundhouse Kit.........................................................$159.00 PRB 60’ Greenville Boxcar, F/P GT, New.......................................$ 295.00 Atlas EMD F2/3, AB Set, Both Pwd, F/P SRR, OB.........................$650.00 RY Models (Yoder) Brass C&O Woodside Caboose LN, OB........$375.00 USH PRR N5 Caboose, New w/Trucks, N/P, OB.............................$250.00 OM PS2-CD Covered Hopper, C/P ATSF, OB, LN........................$319.00 PRB SP Gunderson D.Stack Set, LN, OB......................................$1,395.00 Sunnyside PRR N5c Caboose, N/P, OB ...........................................$309.00 MG PRR N8 Caboose, N/P, NOB......................................................$250.00 Alco PRR N6a, C/P or N/P........................................................each $225.00 *All Offers Cordially Considered Layaway Available LSASE for Complete List Shipping Cost Based On Location Ohio Residents Add 6.75% Sales Tax Estates⁄Liquidations Collection Reductions Jan/Feb ’10 - O Scale Trains • 37 The Newark & Marion Railway (Pennsylvania Railroad) Freight House Drawings, Text and Photos by Harold Russell This freight house was located in Marion, NY on the southeast corner of Walworth-Marion Road (Buffalo St.) and the intersection of the Newark and Marion Railroad. Farmers and small manufacturers of the region wanted to get their products to market. To do this, they would take their products to the freight house where the agent would log in the shipment and collect the shipping fee. The Marion Canning Company, Comstock Cannery, and a Birds Eye frozen food plant shipped processed produce in addition to fresh produce grown in the area. The town had large cold-storage facilities, an ice house and a large fertilizer plant. Some History The Beebe syndicate built the eight mile Newark & Marion Railway in 1905. The Beebes were noted as the builders of electric railroads in Upstate New York and in the tradition of the electric railroads; the N&M’s construction featured light rail and flimsy bridges. The railroad was essential to Marion’s produce traffic but encountered financial difficulty in 1917. After this, the branch was operated by a group of local businessmen until May 1930 when the Pennsylvania Railroad purchased it. The railroad was distinctive because for a time it ran down the center of north Main St. in Newark. It stopped for a red traffic light and even stopped for crossing cattle. The light construction of the line limited it to 2-8-0 locomotives and freight car weights of 210,000 pounds. The diesels arrived in 1954. The railroad featured one round trip train per day - sometimes less when traffic was light. Newark had many canneries. In spite of this, twelve to fifteen cars of raw produce such as apples, beets, 38 • O Scale Trains - Jan/Feb ’10 The southwest corner of the freight house. The platform ramp was sloped to allow easy access by hand trucks. The end door allowed trucks to unload if the door on the east side was being used. The roadside view of the freight house. The office occupied this end of the building. At this point the railroad had a passing siding which served cars being loaded or unloaded as well as a runaround for the locomotive. The platform at this end could be accessed by a set of stairs. Note that the roof overhang on the platform’s side is much greater than the opposite side in order to protect goods on the platform. The window above the end door provided marginal light for the freight end of the house and at the same time a measure of security. Curiously, both are off center. potatoes and spinach were shipped southward to large cities served by the Pennsy. The railroad ceased operations in 1984. Some of the roadbed remains today. We owe the website of Newark, New York [www.cgazette.com/towns/Newark/history/] and Bill Caloroso’s book Pennsylvania Railroad’s Elmira Branch for information on the Newark & Marion Railway. Modeling the Freight House The Marion freight house was small and is suitable for easy modeling. The building can be modeled easily using commercial board and batten siding and roofing. Stripwood will most accurately represent the platform, stairs and door bumpers. Grandt Line, among others, sells windows and doors that may be suitable. The east side of the building as well as the south end had a large freight door to serve trucks with bumpers located at the bottom of the doors. The railroad side, with one freight door, had a platform from which freight could be easily transferred to waiting cars. There is evidence of boarded up doors and windows and these could be a subtle modeling feature. The floor of the depot’s freight section was at platform level with a small elevated office located at the north end of the building. A short set of stairs enabled the freight agent to access the different levels. The intermediate vertical trim board on the building’s sides indicates that at one time the office was enlarged. The freight house siding shows evidence of last being painted Pennsy red. Under this there is evidence of it once being gray. The building had composition roofing and a red brick chimney. There are ample opportunities to add neat details to your model. One could expect the platform of a busy freight depot to have boxes of freight, one or two hand trucks and a scale. A bench could be located outside the office doors. The grass would be neatly trimmed with perhaps a flower patch. The truck side could have a gravel driveway with dirt peeking through at the tire tracks. Some shiny black spots could indicate leaking oil from the trucks. u Jan/Feb ’10 - O Scale Trains • 39 9" 3" ROADSIDE 60'-7" TRACKSIDE 19-'0" 40 • O Scale Trains - Jan/Feb ’10 20'-2" Jan/Feb ’10 - O Scale Trains • 41 9" 3" SOUTH SIDE 60'-7" NORTH SIDE 5'-7" Custom Building, Repair & Painting Services Available Buy-Sell-Trade, Consignments-Appraisals, eBay Sales Website: www.alleghenyscale.com • Email: [email protected] 470 Schooley’s Mountain Road, Suite 8-117, Hackettstown, New Jersey 07840 • Voice - (908) 684-2070 • Fax - (908) 684-8911 Steam Sunset 3rd AT&SF "1950" 2-8-0 FP L/N, 2-Rail, Oil Tender, Lights, Road # 1950 .............$695 Pecos River AT&SF 4-6-4 CP EX, Original 1930 Version, Pro Paint, Lights, # 3450 .........$825 Weaver AT&SF Hudson "Blue Goose" FP New, 2-Rail, Road # 3460................................. $1,095 Max Gray AT&SF 4-6-2 CP EX, Pro Paint, Pittman Can Motor, Road # 3437 .....................$825 Overland C&O F-19 4-6-2 CP EX, Pro Paint, Road # 494, "George Washington" ........ $1,595 C&LS C&O H6 2-6-6-2 FP New, 12 VB Tender, Road # 1477................................................. $3,795 Kohs & Co. C&O H8 Allegheny 2-6-6-6 FP New, Weathered, Road # 1628 ...................$5,895 USH C&O K4 2-8-4 Kanawha UP L/N, Can Motor, KTM Japan, Great Runner ...............$1,195 Westside C&O T1 2-10-4 UP L/N, Can Motor, KTM Japan .....................................................$1,795 PSC #17161-1, CB&Q S4a 4-6-4 FP Mint, Road # 4002, Upgraded ....................................$2,595 PSC #17171-1, D&RGW L-76 2-6-6-2 FP Mint, Black Boiler, Road # 3351 .........................$2,495 Key D&RGW L-105 4-6-6-4 FP New, Postwar Mod, Black Boiler, # 3700 ........................$3,695 PSC #16857-1 D&RGW L-131 2-8-8-2 FP L/N, Black Boiler, # 3600.....................................$3,895 PSC #16857-2 D&RGW L-131 2-8-8-2 FP L/N, Green Boiler, # 3607 ................................... $3,795 PSC #17247-4 D&RGW M-68 4-8-4 FP New, Green Boiler, Road # 1804.........................$2,895 Max Gray Erie K5 4-6-2 UP New, Unassembled, Spoked Drivers, 1 of 10 ....................$2,695 Custom Brass Little River 2-4-4-2 UP L/N, Can Motor, Test Run ........................................$1,795 US Hobbies L&N M1 "Big Emma" 2-8-4 CP L/N, Pro Paint, Road # 1970 .........................$1,195 OMI NYC J1e Hudson 4-6-4 CP L/N, Pro Paint, Cockerham Drive, Road #5336 ..........$2,295 Kohs & Co. NYC J3a Hudson 4-6-4 FP New, Scullin Disk Drivers, Road # 5425 ........... $3,795 WSM NYC J3a Hudson 4-6-4 CP L/N, Pro Paint, Original Version, Road # 5405 ......... $1,095 WSM NYC J3a Hudson 4-6-4 CP L/N, Pro Paint, Original Version, Road # 5414 ......... $1,095 WSM NYC J3a Hudson 4-6-4 CP L/N, Pro Paint, Fully Streamlined, Road # 5447 ......$2,295 WSM NYC J3a Hudson 4-6-4 CP L/N, Pro Paint, Mod Strmlng, PT-4, # 5451 ...............$2,295 USH NYC J3a Destreamlined Hudson 4-6-4 CP EX, PT-4 Tender, Road # 5447 .......... $1,095 Key NYC K3q 4-6-2 FP New, Single Window Cab, Road # 4675.........................................$2,250 PSC NYC S1b Crown Niagara 4-8-4 CP New, Pro Paint, Road # 6021, Exquisite..........$4,095 Sunset N&W Class J 4-8-4 CP L/N, Pro Paint, Coal, Lights, Road # 600 ..........................$1,195 PSC #15699, N&W Class S1a 0-8-0 UP L/N, Road # 200-244................................................ $1,595 Overland NP Z8 2-6-6-4 CP EX, Coal Version, Weathered, Road # 5130 .......................$2,295 Gem-Heike PRR A5s 0-4-0 CP L/N, Complete Rbld, 1 of a Kind Model, #94................$2,895 SS/3rd-Heike PRR E6s 4-4-2 CP L/N, Complete Rbld, 1 of a Kind Model, #1092.........$2,695 Sunset-Heike PRR H9s 2-8-0 CP Complete Rbld, 1 of a Kind Model, #1145 .................$2,595 Key PRR H10 2-8-0 FP L/N, Pro Details, Weathering, Road # 8014 ...................................$2,495 Overland PRR HH1 2-8-8-2 CP New, OMI # 139, 1 of 10 Produced ...................................$2,595 US Hobbies PRR I1sa 2-10-0 UP New, Late Run, New Correct Steel Driver Tires ........ $1,295 Key PRR J1a 2-10-4 FP L/N,210F84 Tender w/Antenna, Road # 6498.............................. $2,795 Westside PRR J1a 2-10-4 UP New, 210F84 Tender w/Custom Antenna, ....................... $1,695 Kohs & Co. PRR K4 4-6-2 Prewar Version FP New, 130P75 Tender, Road # 3863 .........$4,195 PSC-Heike PRR K4s 4-6-2 Postwar CP L/N, Complete Rbld, 1 of a Kind, #1329 ........... $2,795 Westside PRR M1 4-8-2 UP New, Last Run, Full Backhead .................................................. $1,495 Max Gray PRR M1a 4-8-2 UP Mint, Late Run, 210P75 Tender .................................................$995 Overland PRR M1b 4-8-2 FP Mint, 210p75 Tender w/Antenna, # 6753...........................$2,295 Max Gray PRR N1s 2-10-2 CP New, McCafferty Paint and Weathering........................... $1,695 Westside PRR Q2 4-4-6-4 UP New, KTM Japan ....................................................................... $1,995 SS/3rd PRR S1 Duplex 6-4-4-6 FP L/N, Deskirted, Lightly Weathered, # 6100 ............$1,195 Overland P&LE A2 2-8-4 FP New, W/Decals, OMI 0159 ........................................................ $1,995 Overland RDG T1 4-8-4 UP Mint, W/Decals, OMI 0150......................................................... $1,595 Weaver-Heike RDG G2sa 4-6-2 CP L/N, Complete Rbld, Exceptional, #112 .................$2,495 PSC SP AC-9 2-8-8-4 FP New, Coal Version, Road # 3800 ....................................................$3,295 PSC SP F-4 2-10-2 FP L/N, PSC # 16915-1, Postwar, Road # 3679 ........................................$1,795 PSC #17347-1, SP GS-4 4-8-4 Postwar Version FP New, Black, Road # 4436................$2,695 PSC #15839-1, SP MT-4 Crown 4-8-2 FP New, Gray Boiler, No Skyline, Ser. 4 of 9 ......$2,495 SS/3rd SP MT-4 4-8-2 FP New, 2-Rail, Daylight Scheme, Skyline, Road # 4352........... $1,495 PSC #16467-1 SRR PS-4 4-6-2 FP New, Green/Black, Road # 1401 ................................... $1,695 42 • O Scale Trains - Jan/Feb ’10 USH SRR USRA 0-8-0 CP L/N, Pro Paint, Green & Gold, Road # 6531 ..................................$795 Sunset SRR USRA Lt 2-8-2 CP EX, Pro Paint, Black Boiler, Can Motor, Road #6296........$995 OMI #0167 SP&S Z-8 4-6-6-4 UP New, Oil Version, Road # 910-911 ................................$2,695 Sunset UP Early Challenger 4-6-6-4 CP EX, Cockerham Drive, Pro Paint, #3939.......$2,395 Sunset UP "9000" Class 4-12-2 UP New, Postwar Version ....................................................$1,195 US Hobbies UP C Class 2-8-0 CP EX, Can Motor, Oil Tender, Road # 329 ..........................$795 PFM UP C-57 Class 2-8-0 FP L/N, Lights, Road # 739, Samhongsa ................................... $1,595 Key UP FEF-2 Oil Version FP L/N, TT Gray, Silver Stripes, Road # 825, Rare ..................$2,495 USH UP FEF-3 4-8-4 CP EX, Pro Paint, 2 Tone Gray, Oil Version, Can Motor.....................$995 SS/3rd UP MK Class 2-8-2 FP Mint, Never Unwrapped, Short Vandy, #2260 ...................$795 USH UP TTT Class 2-10-2 CP EX, J. White Drive, Lt Weathering, Road #5078............... $1,895 USH UP TTT Class 2-10-2 - Custom Rebuild CP EX, BL FWH, Sweeney Stack, Larger Tender, # 5305 .................................................................................................................$2,195 C&LS WM M-2 4-6-6-4 FP L/N, Hinged Smokebox Front, Road # 1208 ..........................$3,195 Westside WM 3 Truck Heavy Shay UP L/N, Late Run, Can Motor, Full Backhead ......$2,095 Diesel OMI #0356/0356/0358 ALCO FA-1/FB-1 Units UP New, Per Unit ...........................................$595 Car Works B&M ALCO S-1 Switcher CP EX, w/DCC and Sound, Road # 1161 ...................$650 PSC B&M EMD SW-1 Phase 1 CP EX, Low Stack, Black w/Red Nose Stripes, # 1112.......$625 OMI #0304/0305 EMD E8 A/B Units UP L/N, Per Unit ...............................................................$595 OMI #0292/0293 EMD F3 A/B Units UP New, Per Unit ..............................................................$625 Oriental EMD GP-9 Phase III UP New, Samhongsa Korea........................................................$825 OMI #0393-0397, PRR ALCO FA-2/FB-2 - A-B Units CP New, w/Ant., Tower Drive ...... $1,595 OMI # 0201A PRR ALCO DL600B High Hood UP New, w/Antennas, 2 Available ............$695 OMI # 0425, 0426, 0425 PRR BLW RF-16 Shark Nose A-B-A Units UP Mint, .................$2,995 SS/rd PRSL Budd RDC-1 - Two Units FP New, 2-Rail, Powered & Dummy Units, # M402/M405 .....................................................................................................................................$795 Atlas O P&LE EMD GP7 Units FP L/N, 2 Rail DCC/Sound, Pwr & Dummy Units ..............$575 Atlas O SRR F3 Phase 1 A/B/A Units FP L/N, 2 Rail DCC/Sound, Freight Scheme ..........$895 OMI #0322 UP ALCO PA-1 UP New, 2 Available ...........................................................................$750 Hallmark UP EMD FT A-B Units CP EX, Yellow/Gray, Lights, Crew, Road # 516/516B....$795 OMI # 0354 UP Standard Turbine UP Mint, , Round Tender ...............................................$2,695 Atlas O WM F3 Phase 1 A/B, CP L/N, 2 Rail DCC/Sound, Fireball Scheme, # 51A/B.......$695 Kohs PRR GG1 Brunswick 5 Stripe, FP New, Clarendon, Fixed Cplr, #4840, Rare .......$4,995 Kohs PRR GG1 Tuscan 5 Stripe FP New, Clarendon, Drop Cplr, #4911............................$5,195 Rolling Stock PSC GN HWT Empire Builder 9 Car Set FP New, PSC # 16981 .............................................$7,595 PSC Harriman 72' 72-D-3 Diner UP New, PSC # 15477 ..............................................................$425 Custom Brass PRR B60 Baggage Car CP EX, CNJB # 702-O .....................................................$295 SS/rd PRR BM54, P54 Commuter Cars FP New, 2 Rail, Baggage, Combine, Coaches Price Each ...........................................................................................................................................$250 Sunset 3rd PRR B60, P70, Baggage, Coaches FP New, 2 Rail, Price Each ...........................$275 P. Co. PRR X-42 Mail Storage CP New, Pro Paint, Shadow Keystone, Road # 2541 ........$350 PSC REA Steel 50' Express Reefer CP L/N, Late Version, PSC # 15519, Lg. REA Herald .$295 Overland GPEX 47' Pfaudler Steel Milk Car UP New, OMI # 0700.........................................$295 Div. Point N&W CF & CH Class Cabooses FP New, Several Versions Available ................$395 W&R NP 24' Wood Caboose FP L/N, 2nd Run, Version 3, Interior, Road # 1644 .............$435 Overland Palace Poultry Car UP L/N, OMI # 0055, W/Trucks .................................................$575 Kohs PRR N5c Cabin Car FP New, Version 2, "Buy War Bonds", # 477009, 1 of 10 ..........$675 RY Models PRR GLca Fishbelly Twin Hopper UP New, AB Brakes ........................................$275 Overland UP CA-1 Wood Caboose UP New, OMI # 0797 .........................................................$225 Kohs & Co. VGN Class C10-1 Caboose FP New, Road # 309.....................................................$595 C&LS WM "NE" Steel Caboose FP L/N, Round Heralds, 2 Versions Available ..................$435 International Harriman 65,000 Gal. Water Tank UP New, Model # IH-03, W/Spout .....$395 Various Craftsman Structure Kits UP T. Yorke, Stoney Creek, Others...................................Call Various Freight Cars - Brass, RTR, Kits FP Pacific Ltd, PSC, USH, Atlas, etc..........................Call Bashing a U30C into a BQ23-7 Ed Reutling I like the unusual. As a rule, the routine mass marketer doesn’t make the unusual, especially in 2-Rail. If I want an unusual model, I’ll have to somehow make one from something which is available or, in a worse case scenario, I’ll have to scratchbuild what I want. In this case, there is a diesel body which is close enough: the MTH GE U30C. For the real modeler, there are obvious discrepancies, but, until a B23-7 is introduced by the mass market producers, we’ll just have to accept close enough, or sell the kids to fund an accurate custom built model. I was aiming to at least have the winged radiator and the fresh air openings on the rear of the hood as close enough. My friend Greg Elems, searched through his magazine library and found the plans from an older magazine, and was kind enough to send me a copy that I had rescaled to 1/4” = 1’ so that I’d have some good information to go by. I laid a cutout of the cab on the dummy U33 shell I purchased and began imagining where I’d need to cut to approximate the B23-7 (Photo 1). Upon removing the cab and some of the hood, it was time to cut the frame to the correct length. I simply cut the cab out one of the photocopies, and used the paper pattern as a guide 1 (Photo 2). Remember now, some of the hood cuts were done at the existing seams of the U33, which might not line up exactly with what is needed to replicate a B23-7 hood. These are some of the close enough scenarios I mentioned before. 2 After cutting the frame, the next chore is to deal with the 3-Rail pilot. I determined that by removing the amount of frame material shown in Photo 3, the rise on all the pilot steps would be the same with the correct number of steps and with the pilot close to the correct height. Photo 4 shows the fitted, but not finished pilot. Photo 5 shows how it all fit together, along with the filled in 3-Rail coupler hole. At this point in time, I forced myself to get the Ambroid Proweld out and glue up the frame and pilot. The Cab The cab, in this case is pretty much just a box with tapered sides and a beveled and tapered front. The rear walls are simply flat. Jan/Feb ’10 - O Scale Trains • 43 3 6 4 7 5 8 I cut 0.060” styrene for the bottoms of the sides, the rear sheet, and the two pieces of the wedged lower front. I checked the fit and sizes of all five pieces, and glued them up and then the two tapered portions of each side. Note that I haven’t made any window cutouts yet (Photo 6). Cut the two windshield sections of the front, then put them in place first and then cut out the windshield openings and side/rear window openings (Photo 7). It is time to fill the voids and also smooth off the ridges (Photo 8). Note, the red scratch filler is a Spot Glaze used in auto body work. I personally prefer it over green or white 44 • O Scale Trains - Jan/Feb ’10 putty. The cellophane tape, blue putty, and styrene add-ons are a part of the molding process. I usually finish with 600 grit wet/dry paper which makes everything ready for a nice finish. At this point, the article will probably depart from how you will work, because I finished my kitbash with a cast urethane body. You will see the change of color and also that true to form, my castings quite often have pin holes which need filling. You are now here (Photo 9). 9 The Drive I didn’t use the drive from the Weaver C425, but I’m sure it could be used. I just set them together, for comparison (Photo 10). Finishing One part of the finishing process is an attempt to do some window glazing on thick cast walls, but not have them look three scale inches thick (Photo 13). Notice that I attempted to model the rubber seal which holds the glazing in the frame. Well, it didn’t work with my limited casting procedures. I do think, for a single model, that if I would have added #20 wire or similar to the castings, or just to the styrene cab, it would work. Photo 14 shows the glazing cut to fit the window opening, and Photo 15 shows the added-on frame in place. As for the rest of the finishing process, it is straight forward: strip the original paint, add grabs to the cab and rear of the hood, then repaint and decal. For once in a lifetime, I actually painted a loco and decaled it as it was in real life. Even the road number is correct. As usual, I bought the specially made decals from Eric Ethridge [[email protected]]. If anyone is interested in a replacement cab similar to mine, I can make duplicate castings. u 13 10 14 Now back to the serious part of powering the loco. I started with a stock size 0.060” thick K&S brass sheet for the deck, and to fasten the truck bolsters, the motor cradle and the center chain tower. No matter which Weaver chain drive I chose, there would be that dreaded drive shaft through the fuel tank which never bothered me (Photo 11). Two #43 holes were drilled to line up with the original mounting lugs under the long hood, and two others for mounting the front pilot. Photo 12 shows the large amount of room for additional electronics if one chooses to include them. Maybe one day I will modernize and add Dallee sound and a speaker. We’ll see. 11 15 12 Jan/Feb ’10 - O Scale Trains • 45 NEWS: Brewer’s Coaling Platform FOS Limited Model Railroad Structures, PO Box 1321 Pawcatuck CT 06379 • www.foslimited.com Brewer’s Coaling Platform can be used to serve your shortlines, branchlines or logging sites. The kit features laser cut walls, door and windows as well as metal and plastic detail parts. The 2” x 10” platform is made from scale lumber and easily assembles with templates and laser cut jigs. It retails for $39.95. Pre-order today and receive 5% off, by using coupon code COAL. Please type this into the promo code box upon checkout. Kit began shipping October 15th. For more info and photos please go to: [www.foslimited. com] NEWS: Micro-Mark #84519 Digital Level; MSRP: $34.95 Micro-Mark, 800-225-1066 • www.micromark.com Carpenter levels are just too large and inaccurate for machine set-up, and too clumsy for measuring model railroad track grades and superelevation. So, MicroMark encased a high precision digital level in a compact housing that’s only 2 inches square by 1 inch deep. At the press of a button, the large LCD reads the relative angle between machine surfaces or the percent of grade from level. Embedded magnets attach it securely to cast-iron/ steel surfaces for hands-free measurement. The measurement range is 0 to 45 degrees/100%. The accuracy is 0.05 degrees/0.01%. The Hold button remembers the last reading. The housing is made of durable CNC-machined, satinfinish alloy. The level includes a battery and auto shut-off battery saver. NEWS: Industrial Steam Crane/Shovel; MSRP: $129.99/$89.99 Model Tech Studios, PO Box 1497, N Hampton NH 03862 603-964-5995 • www.modeltechstudios.com NEWS: Camp 12 On3/On30 Engine House; MSRP: $49.95 Sidetrack Laser, www.sidetracklaser.com • 503-449-5361 Sidetrack Laser has designed a Backwoods Engine House for your O Scale Narrow Gauge Locomotives. Perfect for any backwoods scene, this single stall shed has roll-up fabric walls, a detailed workbench and takes locomotives up to 9” long. The kit features laser cut structural components and details, as well as corrugated metal roofing, fabric walls and cast detail parts. NEWS: Catalog of Scale Plans; MSRP: $2.00 Underground Railway Press, PO Box 814OS, Brevard NC 28712 The 35th edition of the URP Catalog of Scale Plans includes plans for motive power, rolling stock and structures for mainline, logging, shortline, narrow gauge and traction railways. 46 • O Scale Trains - Jan/Feb ’10 The O Scale Industrial Steam Crane/Shovel kits have 12 main superdetailed sections making for fast overall construction. The primary construction is plastic with metal and lasercut detailing. The cab is able to rotate on the tracks and the crane boom or steam shovel may be adjusted as desired. Each kit includes a fully illustrated manual with many images. The kits are also available built and weathered at [www.finishedmodels.com]. NEWS: 34” and 28” Turntables Millhouse River Studio, 541 River Road, Niagara Falls, NY 14304, 716-830-5267 • www.studiozphoto.com/Millhouse. html Millhouse River Studio has announced the availability of a beautiful O Scale turntable available in two sizes: 34” and 28”. The turntable is constructed with cabinet grade Baltic Birch plywood and can be used for 2- or 3-Rail operation. Atlas nickel silver track is also installed and wired on the bridge and in the pit. The 3/16” aluminum welded bridge is controlled by an industrial timing belt gear drivetrain which is powered by a 24VDC gear motor that produces 200+ lbs. of torque for smooth operation with even the heaviest locomotives. The bridge comes complete with girder detail applied to the aluminum bridge sides and laser cut/etched wood decking is installed and stained with a wash to give it a nice weathered look. Bridge bogies come with sealed roller bearings for lifetime trouble free operation. Pewter details are included, such as control cab, lattice girder electrical arch, bridge bogies and railing stanchions. The depth of the turntable is 6.5” and the corners can be cut off the top for tight installations. The 34” model is $1,100 plus shipping, the 28” model is $950 + shipping. Either table may be ordered weathered for extra cost. NEWS: O Scale Scenic Accents® & Woodland Classics Woodland Scenics, PO Box 98 Linn Creek MS 65052 573-346-5555 • www.woodlandscenics.com Woodland Classics are ready-made trees with classic appeal, an economical price and designed to mix and blend throughout your layout for superior realism. The colors of their original patented foliage compliment each other and their other tree lines, turfs and foliages. Foliage textures and colors vary according to tree variety. The painted tree trunks are finely detailed, flexible and represent a multitude of realistic shapes and branching forms. Woodland Classics vary in structure, textures, shapes and densities. These variations mirror nature’s contrasts and highlights and reinforce Woodland Scenics trademark mixing and blending of the Landscape System. The actual trees will vary in size and shape and no two trees are alike within one package. For the sizes suitable to O Scale prices range from $10.99 to $19.99 per package with 2 trees per package and 10 varieties. Woodland Scenics is introducing two new O Scale Scenic Accents. These scale figures, accessories and animals have been sculpted and hand-painted in fine detail. Scenic Accents scaled figures add color, detail, personality and life to any layout, project or diorama. Best of all, they are economically priced! The new O scale Scenic Accents are: A2757-Depot Workers & Accessories-The conductor reviews the passenger manifest at the check-in podium while two workers maneuver dollies loaded with luggage and shipping crates. Additional standing train schedule, luggage and crate included. SRP $22.99 A2758-Park Benches-Set of six benches ready for your layout residents to sit and enjoy the park, wait for the bus or place anywhere else you would find seated pedestrians. SRP $14.99 NOTHING * * Is what happens when you don’t advertise. To advertise in OST contact [email protected]. Jan/Feb ’10 - O Scale Trains • 47 Review: Trains to Victory America’s Railroads in World War II Donald J. Heimburger & John Kelly, Heimburger House Publishing Co. 7236 West Madison Street, Forest Park, Illinois 60130 • www.heimburgerhouse.com Reviewed by Bill Davis Like many modelers when it comes to railroads, I have an interest in the late 1930s and early 1940s. This is in part because it was the beginning of the period of change we call the transition period. However, it was also the time when trains were the way most Americans traveled and how their goods were shipped. This was never more obvious then during the war years from 1941 through 1945 when the movement of men and machines were at their highest. So with this in mind, I knew I had to have a copy of Trains to Victory, the new book on the war years from Heimburger House Publishing. This book tells how the railroad industry was used to haul the men and the supplies needed for the war effort. To tell the story, Don Heimburger and John Kelly have gathered 542 B&W photos and an additional 285 B&W illustrations. They also have included a 32-page color section with advertisements from the period and some photos. I would have liked more color photos, especially those by Jack Delano, but what is here is a good representation of the times. Finally, there is the beautiful 4-color dust jacket. All this information is contained in a beautifully done 380-page hardcover book. I found the quality of the reproduction of the pictures and illustrations to be exceptional. From a historical standpoint, the book tells in words, numbers and pictures just how monumental a task it was for both men and machines. This is a very complete study of the period. There are 13 chapters that cover the various operations the people involved for the railroads had to handle for the task of getting men and equipment to their destinations. Unlike WWI when the government took over the railroads, this time the railroads prepared in advance for the coming war, by creating their own organizations. So even when the government required certain conditions, they were prepared. One of the amazing things about this time is that with less equipment, the railroads moved more tonnage and personnal than ever, especially when compared to the WWI era. Because of this, they pressed every piece of equipment they had into service to meet the need. This was especially true when moving oil which was a huge operation. One thing I really enjoyed about this book is all the personal stories of the people who rode the trains as well as the 48 • O Scale Trains - Jan/Feb ’10 railroad workers, their families and how the war affected them. These stories gave the book a wonderful touch. Another section of interest is how women were brought in to work in jobs they wouldn’t have been allowed to do before the war, and how they were so willing to sacrifice their own needs for the war. In spite of all the shortages caused by the war the railroads managed to add a lot of new equipment. The chapter titled Built with Pride for the War Effort tells the story of the new locomotives, steam and diesel, as well as the freight equipment. This chapter has an extensive photo section and plans for a couple war emergency boxcars. The last part of the chapter tells about the troop trains and the special equipment built for troop movement. There are plans and interior layouts for these special cars as well as information on interior and exterior colors. All the information needed by modelers. One thing I didn’t know is that the troop cars weren’t built until the men were returning. That explains why so many survived into the late ‘50s & ‘60s. Many of the military camps had their own railroads and equipment for both training troops for railroad work and moving equipment. There are many great pictures of these operations. The huge railroad operations at Fort Eustis are especially well covered. Now I must admit that I have very little interest in foreign railroads however, I found this section of the book very interesting. We built and sent a tremendous amount of equipment to keep the railroads of the world running. Also, to operate these railroads there were many units of railroad men who volunteered for the service so they could use their skills to run these railroads. There are many pictures and stories of these operations in this section. Seeing American equipment with foreign design lines and couplers was unique to say the least. Once the war was over there was the monumental task of getting our equipment and men home. After all, once they were back in America, how do you get them all to their homes throughout the country? How do we move the many wounded troops to hospitals and recovery centers and then home? How do you get all the equipment back? All this is extensively covered. Lastly there’s the future! The world had changed and the railroads wanted to let people know they were changing too. They rebuilt their equipment, purchased new and modernized in hopes of a continued bright future. However, the days of railroads being the main mode of transportation were nearly over. The last chapter gives the statistics of what our railroads had done and as that chapter is titled They Succeeded Magnificently, after reading this book I have to say they did! As a modeler, I found this book to be a great asset. It helped me understand what happened and how those years changed the railroads and the world forever. The wealth of pictures will help me to more accurately model the equipment and operations of that time. If you are interested in this period I highly recommend this book. It is an enjoyable read with a wealth of photos and information not often found in one book source. I know I’ll be referring to this book for many years to come. Long-time readers of OST will remember Mike Culham’s series on building a small O Scale railroad. Mike was apartment dwelling at the time he wrote that series. Since then he has moved into a single family home and has rebuilt the Great Central Railway once again. Here is his plan and some photos. Jan/Feb ’10 - O Scale Trains • 49 Engine 43, a leased RGS C-19, pulls a mixed freight across Main Street in the small town of Pajarito, New Mexico, on Jim Gore’s On30 Jemez & Rio Grande. Sure hope the lineman is a railfan! 50 • O Scale Trains - Jan/Feb ’10 A Sunset SP Mogul pulls a string of reefers across a trestle in Yosemite National Park. The layout, Mount Marlborough Scenic Railroad, was built by Dan and Armando Vargas, Images of the Past. We covered their recreation of Grand Central Terminal in OST #37. Photo by Scott Mann. 2010 O Scale National Convention Why Attend? Up to 300 trading tables, clinics, tour of the California State Railroad Museum, videos, convention car, contests, six O modular layouts on site, about 40 home and club layouts open for visiting ,fly into/out of a major western city and drive a Grand Tour between there to and/or from the convention and visit dozens model and real railroads, national parks, and other attractions. Convention sponsored and managed by O Scale West. Where: Santa Clara, California (San Francisco Bay Area) When: June 30 - July 3, 2010 Location: Hyatt Regency Santa Clara. Room rate: $109 plus tax for 1 - 4 occupancy Registration: $35, $40 after May 31, registration includes spouse and children under 18 Table Rental: 30" x 72" tables are$45, $50 after May 31. Electrical hook-ups are free Banquet: Fri. July 2, $50 per plate including gratuity and tax, sign up by June 20 Tour: Wed. June 30, California State Railroad Museum, Sacto., $60 per person, incl train to/from Sacto. and admission, sign up by June 1 Web Site: www.2010oscalenational.com E-mail: [email protected] Telephone: 650-329-0424, please call between 9AM and 8PM Pacific time A free newsletter with registration information will be available on the website for download after February 1, 2010. To receive a hardcopy, send an LSSAE with 2oz. of postage to: 2010 O Scale National, 876 Boyce Avenue, Palo Alto, CA 94301-3003. Jan/Feb ’10 - O Scale Trains • 51 2010 O Scale severalNational freight cars. Random mixing ensures at least one such car isConvention in each train. As a result the layout runs smoothly and reliably. The mountains seen behind the engine terminal were on site, about 40 home and club layouts open for visiting ,fly into/out of a major western city and drive a Grand Tour between there to and/or from the made by dipping bed sheets in plaster, then draping them convention and visit dozens model and real railroads, national parks, and other attractions. Convention sponsored and managed by O Scale West. over plaster screen. Jerry preferred a specific kind of plaster Where: Santa Clara, California (San Francisco Bay Area) RodJuneMiller When: 30 - July 3, 2010 for this work, and unfortunately he was unable to locate it Location: Hyatt Regency Santa Clara. Room rate: $109 plus tax for 1 - 4 occupancy Photographs by Anne Bothwell when he recently completed the last section of scenery. Registration: $35, $40 after May 31, registration includes spouse and children under 18 The30" Grand Tour is a$50 setafter ofMay do-it-yourself driving There are many model scenes that are typical of Jerry's Table Rental: x 72" tables are$45, 31. Electrical hook-ups are free routes Banquet: Fri. July 2, $50 per plate including gratuitycities and tax,and sign upSanta by June 20 between several major Western Clara, sense of humor. There is the diesel salesman being eaten by a Tour: Wed. June 30, California State Railroad Museum, Sacto., $60 per person, incl train to/from Sacto. and admission, sign up by June 1 CA where the convention will be held. The routes include vulture, and the kangaroos all the way from Australia looking Web Site: www.2010oscalenational.com layouts,[email protected] operating preserved railroads, railroad museums, for my house. E-mail: Telephone: 650-329-0424, please call between 9AM and 8PM time national parks and other attractions. ToPacific participate in the The layout is located approximately 17 miles south of tour, fly into one of the selected cities, rent a car, and drive Gardnerville, NV and approximately 30 miles south of CarA free newsletter with registration information will be available on the website for download after February 1, 2010. To receive a hardcopy, send an tour toto:the OfBoyce course itPalo is possible to son City, home of the NV State Railroad Museum and the LSSAEawith 2oz.route of postage 2010convention. O Scale National, 876 Avenue, Alto, CA 94301-3003. reverse that and take a tour route after the convention, or, rebuilt (and running!) Virginia and Truckee Railroad. Specdrive one tour route before and another after the conventacular Lake Tahoe and Yosemite National Park are less than tion. More information is on the convention’s web site at 100 miles away. There is a motel about 3 miles away and the [www.2010oscalenational.com] convention web site has contact information for it. Jerry Guth’s completely finished 24’ by 64’ SP layout is All the layouts on the Grand Tour will have contact inforone of the layouts on the 2010 O Scale National Convenmation for the owners available on the convention web site tion’s Grand Tour. Some of these layouts have never before [www.2010oscalenational.com], early next Spring. been open for visiting. Jerry’s layout is in a purpose-built layout building. He lived in this building while he built his house, and after moving into the house, he began construction of the layout, which took about nine years. Jerry joked to me that he built the layout in order to have a place to put the buildings he loves to build. Jerry is a long-time model railroader who lived in Southern California where he was very active in a round-robin group that operated on way freight (or peddler) oriented HO layouts. When he moved to Western Nevada, his original plan was to build in On3, but he changed his mind and built in O. He told me that if he had known he would end up in O when he built the building, it would have been 30 feet wide instead of 24. Jerry is a superb modeler. The scenes in the photos that accompany this article are typical of the quality and realism of his modeling. The track plan is a large convoluted loop. There is one The bridge is a model of the SP bridge over the San Lorenzo reversing loop. There are two towns, Wrights and Coyote, River at Santa Cruz, California that was destroyed in the 1906 where way freight switching is done, and a division point, earthquake. The bridge is all basswood and built just like the Carcass Flats, where there is an industrial area, an engine terprototype with pillow blocks etc. minal, and a yard. There are 92 buildings on the layout, 32 at Wrights which includes18 industrial spots including the mine; 27 buildings at Coyote with 12 spots, and 33 buildings at Carcass Flats with 14 industry spots. All the industries are named for Jerry's friends. There is about 950 feet of track and 66 turnouts all handlaid. The minimum radius is 72 inches, and most curves are 84 inches minimum radius or larger. The minimum turnout size is number 6. The maximum mainline grade in one section is 1.9%; the other mainline grades are 1%. The short branchline grade to the mine is 4%. Train control utilizes a Lenz DCC system using Lenz throttles along with CVP wireless throttles. All engines on the layout have been converted to DCC. Turnouts are air-operated except for one town, built The engine facility. All of the structures are built from before the decision to use air, that has solenoid-operated SP plans and all are scratchbuilt except for the roundhouse and turnouts. The mainline is signaled. yard office. A reefer block is departing eastbound. Jerry installed Masonite® track cleaning pads underneath Why Attend? Up to 300 trading tables, clinics, tour of the California State Railroad Museum, videos, convention car, contests, six O modular layouts Jerry Guth’s SP Layout 52 • O Scale Trains - Jan/Feb ’10 Jus Trains Golden Gate Depot Info (302) 453-0465 Orders (888) 453-9742 IN-STOCK K-Line Circus ’09 18” Heavyweight Car *Mon-Fri 9-6 * Fax Orders (302) 368-6447 NYC 21” 6-pk 575 2-Pk 259 215 Newark Shopping Center Newark, DE 19711 Store open 7 days a week DISCOVER P70 20” Coach 4-Pk 399 LIRR, PRSL, PRR 12# Sunset/Third Rail No Deposit on Reservations Heavyweight 20” 4-Pk 399 MC 2-Pk 199 1520W F-3 Texas Special Set 285 1464W UP 50th Anniversary Set 320 18” Aluminum Coach or Shop Car 119 15” Aluminum Advertising Car 85 Gold Unit Replica Tractor Set 38 PRR 20” Head-End Set 359 NYC. PLE H-10 2-8-2 1245 Wab, IC, B&O, MR, Sou, NH, RG, CP GG-1 Girls Freight Set 335 Steam Girls Freight Set 379 GG-1 Girl’s Passenger Set 335 VISA CNW H-1 4-8-4 1245 2009 Lionel Product Vision Line Golden Memories F-3 AA $239 ABA $335 #70 CT, Advert x2, Obs x 2 WP, SF Red/Sil, SF Blk/Red, TS, NYC PRR 0-8-8-0 CC2s Steam 21688 18” Heavywt Coach 2Pk 177 15” Aluminum 4-Pk 229 2-Pk 119 18” Alum Animal Car 102 Most Orders over $200 Free Ship 89 Williams Trains 2-car add-on $80 Full Set $395 PRR GG-1 Congressional Set 410 2-car add-on $115 Full Set $515 N&W 4-8-4 J Class Steam 259 GG-1 NW-2 179 PRR x 4 C&O, SF, Seabd 155 SF 2-10-10-2 Steam 1399 1799 Buy both PRR & SF get $300 GE ES44AC Evol Hybrid 699 Die-Cast Shell Combo Flat w/Boxcar & wagon 45 Wood Gondola w/Cicus Equipment 48 22250 Dining Dept Billboard Reefer 65 FA-1 AA 225 B 80 ABA 299 UP 3GS21B Genset Switch 539 Combo Flat/Stock Car w/Wagon 38 Die-Cast, 3 smoke units Scale Dining Woodside Reefer 59 B&O, LV, L&N, NYC, PRR, RI, Buy both diesels get $50 SF, WM, LNE, GN K-Line 2009 Product Pullman 12-1 Sleeper 109 PRR & Pullman Broadway Lmt 18” 4-Pk Broadway Lmt 18” 2-Pk PA-1 AA 225 B 80 ABA 299 Op. Wind Turbine 3-Pk F-7 AA 205 B 70 425 222 185 SF, PRR, RG, UP, D&H, NYC, CP ABA 269 Ethanol Tank 3-Pk, Sound 216 Am, ACL, B&O, Burl, C&O, GN, Ethanol Tank 3-Pk 152 Lack, NH, PRR, UP PRR Op. Stock Car Sound 120 Shark AA 219 B 75 ABA 289 Can National Coal Train 639 B&O, D&H, PRR x 2, NYC, Demo Santa Fe 2900 Class 4-8-4 1345 Virginian 2-10-10-2, EOB 1899 UP FEF 3 Versions 1199 In-Stock 2 or 3 Rail NYC J3a Super Hudson Southern FM Trainmaster 359 Coaling Tower $195 Reserve Southern 18” Alum 4-Pk 21” SP Daylt Alum 5-Pk 575 Southern 18” Alum 2-Pk SP Articulated Diner Set 575 Scale Smoking Caboose 20” Diner/Observation 2-Pk 249 MR, Southern Scale MR 4-6-4 J6a Baltic, 2# 999 CP 4-4-4 Jubilee TMCC 999 SP 4-6-0 M-6, M-9 Mogul DEAL! 2-10-4 “Colorado” 2 Heaters Call Troop Sleeper 6# 1938 Dreyfuss Hudson EOB 1175 SP AM-2 Cab Forward, EOB 1675 E-7 AA 245 B 105 ABA 345 Stourbridge Lion Set ACL, B&O, Burl, C&O, NYC, UP, Prr Tuscan, Sou, MR, Tex Spec Dash 9 Power 149 BNSF, CSX, Anthracite Coal 2-Car NS, SF, UP, CNW, Amtrak, Con, SP GP38 139 Dmy 80 BNSF, Chessie, Wabash FM, Legacy Weaver Models 2009 NH, NS, SF, GT, AK, GM&O, DTI, PC BL-2 Powered 139 BAR, B&M, 21” Alum 2-Pk 259 Coach 132 C&O, C&EI, GM Demo, FEC, Monon, Milw Rd, Grt Northern RI Red/Black, WM-Fire, MP FM Trainmaster 155 CP, JC, N&W GP7, Legacy REA or B&O Express Troop MR, NYC, Rdg, SP, Wabash, N&W NH EF-4 Rectifier TMCC 2 or 3 R $70 3/$200 3# NW-2 155 B&O, Con, LV, NYC, PRR, UP, MR, GN, Monon, JC 18” Aluminum Business Car 119 1245 DMIR, B&LE, CB&Q DEAL! 425 222 59 85 Troop Kitchen 4# 85 Troop Hospital 4# 85 Any 6 for 489 Delivered MOW Troop Cars 50 2/$95 Monon, N&W, CB&Q, C&O, GTW, Erie, WM, L&N, Lack Wartime Gondola $25 or 4/$90 4# N&W, MEC, Sou, LN, B&M TMCC/EOB 999 95 415 419 315 NYC, SF Black Mesa SF SD-40, TMCC 323 21667 Red River Co. Boxcab 78 Rotary Dump w/Conveyor 499 21639 Pan Am Railways Boxcar 37 50,000 Gallon Water Tank 113 U33C Power 149 CSX, D&H, MR 21640 UP Modern Steel Reefer 35 Sunoco Industrial Tank 52 21643 PRR Die Cast Gondola 48 SF, SP, UP, NH, PRR, Reading, WP Standard O PRR 16 Wheel Flat w/Transform 62 UP Bathtub Gondola 3-Pk 139 21645 SP 43’ Alum Mod Hopper 59 Husky 2-Pk Maersk, UP 159 22414 Linde Box w/Alum Tank 47 CA-4 Heritage Caboose 70 22447 Wabash DC 2-Bay Hopper 42 DRG, SP, CNW Rutland Milk Car w/Platform 111 Mtn View Creamery Milk Depot 87 SD90 Power 149 BNSF, CSX, Northeast Cab N&W, Wab 67 Demo, NS, BN, Con, Amtrak, SF SF Wedge Plow Flatcar 67 Gargraves UP, MP, CNW, MKT, RG, SP, WP SF Idler Flatcar w/Load 56 Genesis Power & Dmy 219 O Gauge ATSF Water Tank Tank 52 37” Flex Tin $5.55 Cs 50 259 SF Tool Car 60 37” Flex Stainless Phantom Case 305 WP Heritage 60’ Box 63 42, 72, 100” Tin Switch Man 34 Rem 53 Freight $60 SF Tool , N&W 3-Bay Above w/DZ-2500 TMCC $59 DRGW DS Box, DT&I Reefer, RC Uncplr #107 $23 Op. #108 $28 DRGW 40’ Flat, B&M Coke Flat 369 Gantry Crane Track $20 Stainless $22 Die Cast Scale Hudson Katy or MP Heritage Hopper 60 NYC, B&O, GN, SF, JC, CP 90 Degree Crossing $19 DVD 9 Wabash PS-4 Piggyback Flat 73 Now with Wood Ties Circle 032/ $39 063/ $62 089/ $90 New Haven I-5 385 In-Stock 042/ $45 054/ $59 072/ $67 080/ $85 096/ $92 106/$99 Call on DZ Products Transformers Lionel ZW 425 180W Brick 75 MTH Z-4000 385 Z-1000 Brick 59 80’ Alum 5-Car $549 DCS System 255 Legacy #990 299 PRR, NYC, NP, GN, L&N, TMCC Cab-1 68 Command Base 68 AK. CNJ, CN, GTW, N&W TMCC Command Set 125 TPC 300 124 PRR O-1 2-Unit Electric, TMCC 899 UP Gray, SLSW, KCS, LV 4-Pk 299 TPC 400 165 Mikado WP, UP, SF, MR 699 TMCC, Railsounds, Odys GG-1 Scale Electric 255 PRR x 5, PC, CR EF-4 Rectifier 165 NH, CR, N&W, VGN x 2, PRR Blk 2-8-0 Rdg, NYC, B&O, WM 389 TMCC, Railsounds, Fat Boy, Cruise 72’ (18”) Streamline 4-Pk 195 72’ Madison 4-Pk 239 2-Pk 120 UP FEF w/Legacy Grey only 989 60’ Amfleet 3-Pk 155 Amtrak x 2 NYC F-12e 4-6-0 Ten Wheeler 575 MTH 2009 Vol II 2 or 3 Rail Steam NYC 4-4-0 Empire State 639 Pass Set $222 MTH 2009 Vol II Diesels Power 359 Dmy 169 R-11 Subway 4-Car 449 2-Pk 175 KCS 5pk 335 2pk 137 Vista 75 GP38-2 B&M, BN, CP, D&H 2111 Reading GP-35, DC 3# 250 Alco PA ABA 639 ABBA 755 Orient Express 2-3-1 Pac. 999 Southern, DRG, UP B 139 Black, Green, Brown re-run FT ABA NYC Mohawk 2 or 3 Rail 999 L-3a, 3b, 3c L-4a, 4b 639 N&W J Passenger Set 1079 2-Car 137 RPO 77 Vista 77 N&W J Express Mail Set 1079 NH East Wind EP-3 Pass Set 819 Princess Coronation Steam 1079 London, Midland, & Scot, British LMS 4-Car 365 Bag/Pass 95 GP-7 359 Dmy 169 BAR, Erie 2-10-0 Russian Decapod 899 GP-9 359 Dmy 169 C&O, UP Erie, Pitt Shaw& N, W. Md 4-6-4 Royal Hudson 899 BC, Southern, CP-Royal Tour NJ Transit ALP46 399 Dmy 189 Santa Fe 2-10-0 Decapod Railking ABBA 755 Erie, NYOW, Seaboard, MoPac Zephyr 4-Unit Sets 2 types FEC SD70M-2 Twin-Stack UP SD70ACe Twin Stack Set Maersk GP-60M Twin-stack 649 649 649 649 L-4a Mohawk Freight Set 1079 DMIR 2-8-8-4 Yellowstone 1299 Yellowstone Freight Set 1399 F40PH 3-R Power 389 Dmy 169 Alaska, Amtrak, CAR, VIA 4-6-0 Camelback Steam 819 Premier Passenger Cars 5-Pk 335 Amtrak Superliners 335/172 JC, NYO&W, Reading 2-Pk 137 Full Vista 77 RPO 77 0-6-0 USRA Steam Atlas 2-Rail 2008 DAP MTH UP M10000 Diesel Passenger 649 M1000 Coach $85 2# 899 2113 Savannah & Atlanta 250 Scale Diesels Pwr 259 Dmy 129 2114 WM GP-35, DC FM VGN, Chessie, JC, SP 2115 NKP GP-35, DC 250 GP-35 also in PRR, CNW, GA Sharknose AB $488 A 145 RS-11 LV, Conrail, NH, SP VO1000 Autotrain, PRR, NKP, CNW NYC, PRR, B&O MP15DC Am, NS, G&W, BNSF F-3 ABA 425 B&O, MR, Wab, WP PRR Modified P5a PRR FF-1 2235 MR Hiawatha Power B 250 $489 SW-1 259 JC, RI, C&O, GN Brill Trolley w/PS2.0 199 NYT, Pitt, Phila Sub Trans, MTA SW-1 Switcher 259 CNW, MR, Scale Diesels Pwr 259 Dmy 129 $599 7890 Ann Arbor RS-1, DC Other RS-1: 299 NH, RI, C&O 519 Erie, VGN 2-8-8-8-2 Triplex 1299 N&W 4-8-4 J-Class 999 2 #’s Diesels 2 or 3 Rail 7805 Jersey Central SD-35 NJ Transit ALP44 389 Dmy 169 3GS21B Genset 389 Scale 399 CSX, BNSF, NS, Army, UP, NRE AEM-7 Electric 389 Dmy 169 Diesels 389 Dmy 169 Scale 399 Amtrak x 3, MARC, Septa Amfleet 4-Passenger 277 2-Pk 142 Septa, MARC, Amtrak x 2 ES44DC KCS, CSX, CN, NS B&O GE I/R Box Cab 399 GP-7 GN, L&N 7822 CSX SD-35, DC 4-6-4 Royal Hudson 899 BC, Southern, CP-Royal Tour GP-9 Buff & Pitt, CN ES44AC 399 Dash 8 Conrail, CSX x 2, UP 60’ Flat w/Trash Containers 57 739 NH x 3 European RS-3 Erie, LV, NH, SP&S Dash 8, DC Und, UP, BC, SP 299 FP45 Maersk, MRL, SF, MR 385 Demo, CP, UP 169 Dummy for above 195 Specialty Set AA16 NOHAB 3-R 399 2-R 449 GN, Denmark, GM Demo, Norway, VO1000 Power 259 NP, UP, 7840 BNSF Patch Job -8, DC 299 Belgium, Luxembourg, Hungary Burl, Patapsco & Black Rivers 7841 BNSF Patch Job Dmy 195 2008 Vol II RailKing Am. Freedom PA Passenger 599 Scale Size Diesel 255 Dmy 129 GE Evolution Hybrid Set 449/479 GN 2-8-8-2 R-2 Freight Set 1399 7848 GE Demo Dash 8, DC NYC J1e Hudson Passenger 999 TRAXX F140 AC2 399 2R 449 CNW E-4 Streamlined Pass 999 Demo, SBB Cargo, Veolia, Europe C628 D&H, LV, N&W, SF SP Cab Forward Freight Set 1389 Erie Triplex Freight Set SD45 MR, GN x 2, SF, UP 299 RailKing – Scale Size U30C Chessie, MR, PRR, SP GP-35 PRR, NYC, GN, AK, GMO 275 7823 Penn Central SD-35, DC 275 SD70Mac AK, BNSF, CSX Dash-8W CN, CSX, SF, UP 275 East Carbon x2, Gen. Am., Joe Trans EP-3 Electric 1389 C&O M-1 Stm Turbine Pass Set 899 PRR P5a Beer Train Set 819 th 64’ 19 Century Coach 76 LIRR, B&O 3-Pk 225 2009 Dealer Appreciation 0-8-0 Steam Switcher 359 GP60M SF, DC IC, Sou, NYC, NKP, NP, PLE GP-9 USCG, FEC, PRR, SP 255 All Atlas Rolling Stock $25-$40 299 Limited Quantities UP DDA40X Diesel Loco MP-15AC CP, CSX, MR, UP 255 649 RS-11 DW&P, NYC, NP, PRR 255 20-3279-2N&W Class A 2-6-6-4 1150 R142A MTA Sub 5-pk 369 2-pk 125 ScaleTrax -INSTOCK 10” 3.00 SD70ACe BHP Billiton, KCS, UP BMT 2500 Subway 3-Car 399/269 SD70M-2 NS, CN 250 O31 or O54 Curve 3.00 O80 4.45 1 ¾” 4-Pk 7.75 30” Rigid or Flex 8.65 ITAD $23 90, 45 or 22.5 Xing 16 Op. Track 16 Remote Switch O31, O54 or O72 $38 999 Switch #4 $44 #6 $51 Bumper 13 UP Pass 5pk 335 2pk 137 Vista 40 O72 3.75 R40 Subway 4-Car 445 2-Car 175 Engineering Version Orient K-Line 2-R Shay $499 Lackawanna, PLC www.justrains.com Just TrainsTM Free Shipping over $200 on all Korber 302 One Stall Diesel Shed w/Shop Orders (888) 453-9742 Made in USA www.justrains.com 69 901 Action Machinery 6 x 8 917 Gen Lt & Power Sub Station 25 32 959 Midland Supply 8 x 6 35 960 John’s Cutlery 25 304 3-Stall Roundhouse, 30”D 189 304A Xtra Stall or 304B Extender 45 902 Jaybar Company 6 x 8 27 921 JLC Manufacturing 305 Sandhouse, 16 x 6 65 45 966 Lehigh Engineering 6 x 8 903 Skyline Steel 6 x 8 25 25 950 American Flag Co. 14 x 9 306 2-Stall Diesel Shed 25 x 11 306A Extender 12.5 x 11 6x8 69 69 27 967 Shoe Co. 7 skylts 20 x 9 x 11 69 905 Blackshear Refrig. Transport 307 3-Stall Trolley Barn 23 x 11 308 Quincy Mining Co. 310 Mitchell Textile Co. 59 95 47 39 908 Shanahan Freight 20 x 8 x 9H 911 Perfect Tool Co. 8 x 16 953 Joe’s Pickle Factory 14 x 9 69 954 Buck Island Canning 8 x 12 59 135 912 Roller Bearing Co. 9 x 28 969 Gen Lt & Pwr Office 6x13x12 65 55 55 P56 Cut Stone 957 Lewis & Sons Machine Shop 315 Grain Silo, 7 x 19 x 22 H P81 Random Stone 10 89 P83 Concrete 10 915 Quaker Foods 9 x 12 49 75 955 RJK Tool & Die 9 x 14 3115 Grain Silo, 7 x 34 x 22 H 968 Freight Terminal 8 x 15 13 25 D929 Roof Top Water Tank D30 12 49 85 P57 Double 956 James Company 13 x 8 x 9H 55 New Modular System Kit 74.95 Unlimited configurations 24 walls 320 3-Stall Roundhouse 26” Deep 159 916 General Light & Power 48”L 175 958 Mill Works 11 x 7 w/Tower 49 Just Trains (888) 453-9742 Buy–Sell–Trade Buy-Sell-Trade ads are $5 for 30 words plus your address information. Additional words are $0.25 each. Subscribers are permitted one free ad per subscription cycle . All B-S-T ads are prepaid. You may send ads by postal service with a check or money order. Ads sent by email or called in must use a credit card. See our contact info on page 2. FREE O SCALE LIST: List of O Scale shows for 2009. Send LSSAE to Bob Retallack, Dept OST09, 2224 Adner Ct, Columbus, OH 43220. WANTED: Small N&W custom-built or scratchbuilt steam. Especially looking for N&W 4-8-0 by Bill Lenoir. Also 2-8-0, 4-6-0. Also looking for N&W brass parts, e.g., pilot, cylinders, domes, tenders, etc. Contact Joe Giannovario, [email protected] or call 610-363-7117. WANTED: Ambroid special run 50’ Milw. boxcars, Hallmark comp gons, Sunset WWII emergency boxcars, PRB WWII comp gons, Lobaugh 50’ reefers, WWII era boxcars what have you? Mail only. Jim Seacrest, PO Box 6397, Lincoln, NE 68506-0397 FOR SALE: Brass and die-cast parts for All Nation/ Babbitt steam locomotives, frames, drivers, rods, valve gear, boilers, cabs, tenders, and details. Also restoration and repairs available. Some complete kits available on a limited basis. Some older kits and built up kits also available on a limited basis. Write and include $1 for a catalog. Babbitt Railway Supply Co., 715 Barger St, Mayfield KY 42066. Call 270-247-0303 between 8 am and 8 pm CST, or email [[email protected]]. WANTED: The O-Scale 2 Rail Club is a modular train club looking for members or those to follow this standard and start a club. We are using a portable 2’ x 4’ foot table format. Follow the modular standards for placement of the two track mainline, wiring, and table height. Visit the web site at: www.oscale-2rail-club.com Request a free PDF of the O-scale 2 rail club standards guide from: [email protected] FOR SALE: New Sunset 2-Rail engines: 2-Rail UP Big Boy, $1500; 2-Rail UP Challenger $1500, 2-rail UP 4-12-2 $1500, 2-Rail B&O EM1 2-8-8-4, $1500. Email: [email protected], or call 505-898-6956. WANTED: Steam/Diesel era, DM&IR, Soo Line, DSS&A. Frt., pass., MoW, cabooses, NO ORE CARS. Joe Fischer pass. & head end cars. What have you? Mail contact only. Jim Seacrest, PO Box 6397, Lincoln, NE 68506-0397 WANTED: LTD AMT Steam/Diesel era GN, NP, C&NW, CM&O engines, passenger cars, freight cars, MoW, cabooses, What have you? Mail only please. Jim Seacrest, PO Box 6397, Lincoln NE 68506. FOR SALE: Ft. D.D.M.& S. decal sets. Will do 2 locos and several cars. $18.50 per set. Call Mike at 515-353-4292 or email bluffcreektrains@wccta. net. FOR SALE: Sunset, mint condition B&M 4-8-2, NP 4-8-4, PRR K4 and P70 coaches. Also many books: PRR, NYC, Reading, WM, B&M, CB&Q, NP, C&NW and others. Contact Ed Jarolin, PO Box 782, Sundance, WY 82729, 307-283-1029 or email: [email protected] WANTED: Car Works Alco HH660. call Frank 503-452-2336, or mail to: Frank Hillman, 10007 SW Balmer Cir., Portland, OR 97219-6374 WANTED: GN brass PFM E-6, 4-6-0, Oriental 25’ caboose, Oriental 60’ combine, GHB Brill 250. Call Frank 503-452-5336 or mail to: Frank Hillman, 10007 SW Balmer Cir., Portland, OR 97219-6374 FOR SALE: Exceptional brass Midland Reproductions full-length Budd dome kit. Contact: [email protected], or 302-379-1302. TRADE: Have Precision Scale Southern Pacific SD-7 Black Widow, Road# 5324 w/can signal lights. Would like to trade for PSC SP SD-9 Black Widow w/small Emergency signal lights. My SD-7 is new in original box. I can provide photos. Bill Gruner, 541-464-8579, or email [shipguy@ cmspan.net]. FOR SALE: All engines F/P, MINT & TRO. SP AC-12 #4294 PSC $4950; SP 2-8-0 Glacier Park Models #2811 $2200;SP MT-5 #4370 PSC (latest run) $2750; SP P-10 PSC (Skyline Casing/ Deskirted) w 120 C-8 Tender Soufie Drive, $2500; P-8 PSC w 120 C-8 Tender Cockerham Drive $2500; ATSF Pecos River Brass - Heavyweight Chair A/C (#3050-3069) and R.P.O w/o Skylight (#57-59/70-79) U/P $400 each. Reasonable offers considered. Bruce Antell 650-347-4402 Office, [email protected], 50 S. San Mateo Drive, Ste 105, San Mateo, CA 94401 Events To ensure your event listing makes it into the proper issue, please note the following deadlines for publication: Jan/ Feb issue: November 1 of the prior year. March/April issue: Jan. 1. May/June issue: March 1. July/August issue: May 1. Sept. /Oct. issue: July 1. Nov. /Dec. issue: Sept. 1 January 2010 1-3: Baltimore MD Baltimore Society of Model Engineers Open House Two model railroad empires occupying 2500 sq. ft., operating trains and trolleys in HO & O scale, static model displays; railroad heralds; and railroad artifacts. And for our youngest visitors, Thomas the tank Engine models. Located at 225 W. Saratoga St, 3rd floor walkup. Questions about this event info or our organization should be directed to Jim Berg at: 410-859-4376 (day), 410-519-9837 (eve). Contact jtmcberg@ gmail.com March 2010 12-14: Lombard IL Midwest March Meet 2010. New location! Westin Lombard Yorktown Center, 70 Yorktown Center, Lombard IL 60148. Call 800-937-8461 and ask for the Chicago O Scale room rate. Show registration write to March Meet, 2636 Hallquist Ave, Red Wing MN 55066 or call 630-745-7600. By email contact [email protected]. 56 • O Scale Trains - Jan/Feb ’10 June 2010 30th to July 3rd: Santa Clara CA The 2010 O Scale National is being held in lieu of the 2010 O Scale West. The hotel room rate is $109/night plus 10% room tax, for up to 4 people in the room. Registration is $35, $40 After April 30, 2010. Vendor tables (72”) are $45, $50 after April 30, 2010. A banquet will be held at 7:30 PM Friday outside the hotel. For more details, contact the O Scale National Convention, c/o 876 Boyce Ave., Palo Alto, CA 943013003 or call Rod Miller at 650-3290424 between 9:00 AM Pacific Time and 9:00 PM Pacific Time. Email: rod@ rodmiller.com. July 2010 11-18: Milwaukee WI NMRA National Convention & 75th Anniv. The National Model Railroad Association (NMRA) will be celebrating its 75th birthday in 2010. As part of the festivities the National Convention will be held in Milwaukee Wisconsin, the birthplace of the NMRA. We are planning a, rip roaring Midwestern, good time for all, both model railroader and general interest attendee alike. Dates for the convention are Sunday July 11th to Sunday July 18th. On Sunday the 11th, we are going to kick off the week with a Beer and Brat Fest (a Milwaukee Favorite) at Zeidler Union Square Park, just a stone’s throw away from the convention site and hotel. Contact Ken Jaglinski, Vice-Chair. Contact [email protected] 51 Irish Tracklayer 25 Public Delivery Track 26 AAA Turntables 16 JD’s Trains 21 Rails Unlimited 10 Allegheny Scale Models42 Just Trains 53, 54, 55 RGSRR Hobbies 10 Atlas O JV Models 10 Scale University 34 15 IFC Bachmann22 Keil-Line10 Scenic Express Baldwin Forge & Machine 10 Key Model Imports 14 SceniKing9 Brummy’s Ballast 33 LaBelle Woodworking Co. 26 SMARTT6 BTS24 Micro-Mark25 SMR Trains Bullfrog Snot 10 Millhouse River Studios 9 SpecCast32 Chicago O Scale Meet 28 Model Building Services 33 Stevenson Preservation Lines 10 Model Rail Scenes 25 Sumpter Valley Depot 10 Sunset⁄3rd Rail Clever Models 9 Custom Signals 14 Mt. Albert Scale Models Deichman’s Depot 25 MTH Electric Trains East Gary Car Co. 25 Get Real Productions 33 26 8 IBC Underground Railway Press 33 Mullett River 27 UpBids.net33 57 NCE Corp 37 Valley Model Trains 26 Golden Gate Depot BC O Scale Realty 25 Wasatch Model Co. 28 Gorilla Glue 25 O Scale Trains 14 Weaver32 Guide to Modern O Scale 16 P&D Hobby Shop 14 Woodland Scenics Hackworth Model Trains 37 Pieces of the Puzzle 16 Howard Zane 10 Protocraft16 Advertisers Index 2010 O Scale National 28 Jan/Feb ’10 - O Scale Trains • 57 Joe Giannovario OST Reader Poll Last issue I posed a poll about what is important to you, the O Scale Modeler. The response to the poll has been great with nearly 500 respondents at this point in time (late November). So here are the results (with comments) which I will share with all the major importers and manufacturers. 1. Model is dimensionally accurate - Models should be built to the correct overall length, width and height of the prototype modeled: 97% said this is important in any model they consider buying. 2. Accurate castings and details - Models should have the correct details for the prototype modeled and these details should be of fine quality: 91% said this was important. 3. All wheels sets gauged the current NMRA standards Manufacturers should use either the older 0.172” tire design or the newer 0.145” tire design, but keep the 0.177” Check Gauge for maximum track compatibility: 82% responded this was important. The message here is don’t invent something new that isn’t universally compatible. 4. Drive wheels sprung - Axles or journal boxes sprung on either steam or diesel: 61% said this was important. In most people’s experience springing is inadequate. 5. Drive wheels equalized - Axle to axle or axle to frame equalization on either steam or diesels: 64% said this was important. Many people felt that equalization doesn’t work well and drives up model cost. 6. Drive wheels sprung and equalized - Applies to both steam and diesel: Only 47% thought this was important. 7. Ease of maintenance/disassembly - Screws and fasteners should be easy to reach with typical modeler’s tools: 96% replied this was important. 8. Factory painted and lettered - Prototypically correct lettering and numbering: 60% replied this was important. The prevalence of factory painted models makes customizing or correcting errors difficult. 9. Constant intensity lighting: 57% said this was important and frankly I am baffled by this. 10. Directional lighting - Headlight dims or turns off when in reverse: 56% said this was important (see question 9). 11. LED lamps - Use low power LEDs rather than incandescent bulbs: 63% said this was important. LEDs would almost never have to be replaced. 12. Lighted class lamps on steam engines: only 49% said this was important. Many modelers would like a switch to turn them off. 13. Factory installed Command Control System - either DCC, or DCS or TMCC: 45% said this was important indicating that the many O Scalers still run straight DC control. 14. If Command Control equipped, do you want sound: 56% said this was important. So, if we’re going to get a command system factory installed make it with sound. 15. If not Command Control factory installed should there be sound trigger cams on the drivers: 47% said this was important. 16. Should locomotives be Command Control ready - fac- 58 • O Scale Trains - Jan/Feb ’10 tory installed wiring and sound cams: 71% replied this was important. Questions 13 through 16 taken together indicate that O Scalers would like to choose their own control systems. 17. Smoke units in either steam or diesel locomotives: 23% said this was important which makes it pretty clear that smoke units are wasted on O Scalers. 18. Low current, high torque motors - Motors that draw 1 amp or less are available for use in O Scale models, they just cost a bit more: 85% said this was important. Other than cost, there is no reason we can’t have high performance motors. 19. Slow speed operation for switching - Slow smooth operation at 1 smph or less: 95% responded this was important. In other words, skip the high speed gearing and build for operations. 20. Dual motors in articulateds - Does each engine need its own motor: 40% said this was important, the rest said it was a waste of money. 21. Dual motors in diesels - Do you prefer the so-called China Drive or a single horizontal motor driving both trucks: 79% voted for the single horizontal motor configuration. Recently there has been a great discussion online about this question and the consensus was that the typical China drive (low-cost vertically mounted motors driving spur gears on the wheels) did not allow for smooth slow speed performance and was not able to be modified by the modeler. 22. Written Warranty - Know what your rights are as an owner. Put the warranty in the box, not on a website: 79% said this was important. 23. Minimum radius stated on the box - Put this information where it can be seen before purchase: 81% said this was important. 24. Minimum radius no greater than 60” - Most O Scale locomotives should run on track with a radius no greater than 60”: 60% said this was important. 25. Limited quantity - Are you interested in “collector” models of 100 pieces or less, or subtle variations in units: Only 7% said this was important. My take on these responses are that O Scalers (i.e., the 2-Rail modeler) do not care for the concessions made by manufacturers to the 3-Rail market. They’d rather have really good slow speed operation than electronic gimmicks. Ditch the smoke unit and lighted class lights. Spend the money on better motors and gearing. Command Control is growing in O Scale but mostly as a user-installed option. However, O Scalers gripe that they pay the same price for models without any electronics as the 3-Railers with all the goodies. That will change soon. Happy New Year! We start our ninth year of publication with this issue. This past year was rough on the hobby in general but we’ve weathered the worst I believe. I am especially pleased to have Tom Mix’s scratchbuilding series begin this issue. I think it’s a high water mark for the hobby akin to the Mel Thornburgh articles in the 40s and 50s. Keep Highballin’u O Scale Trains mth 02-2010.qxp 11/9/2009 1:44 PM Page 1 SWISS KROKODIL Available In 2 and 3-Rail Versions Tuscan Swiss Crocodile Electric 20-5637-1 Hi-Rail Wheels $899.95 20-5637-2 Scale Wheels $899.95 For American modelers, the Crocodile (spelled krokodil in German) is perhaps the single most recognizable European locomotive, having been imported as a Märklin model in several scales since the 1930s. Like the Lionel Santa Fe F3, the Märklin HO Crocodile was a top of the line model that many boys of the 1950s and '60s dreamed of, but few actually owned. If you were one of those boys (or even if you weren't), this new Premier model offers the chance to own the most detailed, smoothest running O gauge model of this iconic mountain goat ever made. This full 1/45 O scale die-cast model arrives in 2010 as a die-cast model equipped with M.T.H.'s ProtoScale 3-2 technology, capable of running on 2-rail or 3-rail track. Premier Line engines, like the Crocodile, are as prototypically accurate as we can reasonably make them, and feature a large number of added-on details. It comes equipped with elaborate lighting features including cab interior illumination and our full Proto-Sound 2.0 digital sound system. FEATURES INCLUDE: •1:48 Scale Modern Diesels •Equipped With Proto-Sound 2.0 Digital Sound •Superbly Detailed Die-Cast Metal Construction •Locomotive Speed Control In Scale MPH Increments •Full Digital Sound Including Operating Horn & Bell •Operates On AC or DC Power •Available With Hi-Rail or Scale Wheels •Operate On 3-Rail or 2-Rail Track SEE IT IN ACTION ACTION ON THE WEB www.mthtrains.com/europe ©2010 M.T.H.Electric Trains 7020 Columbia Gateway Drive, Columbia, MD 21046