ANNEX C11

ANNEX C11
STANDARD TWINNING PROJECT FICHE
1.
Basic Information
1.1
Publication Notice reference: EuropeAid/ 136-571/DAH/ACT/XK
1.2
Programme: Annual Action Programme for Kosovo1for 2014
1.3
Twinning Number: KS 14 IB AG 01
1.4
Title: Support to Kosovo Food and Veterinary Laboratory
1.5
Sector: Food Safety
1.6
Beneficiary country: Kosovo
2.
2.1
Objectives
Overall Objective:
The overall objective of the action is to increase the protection of public health by introducing food
safety control measures and educational programs for national control bodies and food business
operators as well as to create preconditions for export of the products by enabling the introduction of
food safety standards and full implementation of the legislation.
2.2
Project purpose:
Support Kosovo Food and Veterinary Laboratory in increasing the range, quality and reliability of
services provided including development and validation of existing services and introduction of
new test method, with particular focus on drugs and residue testing program.
2.3
Contribution to National Development Plan/Cooperation agreement/Association Agreement/Action
Plan:
The Government’s main strategic objectives of economic development of the Agriculture sector
focus on improving the productivity and quality of agriculture products as well as increasing
production with the aim of food stability and import substitution whilst promoting environmental
protection. An increase in the level of competitiveness and alignment to EU relevant standards in
particular concerning food safety, an increase in the incomes for the rural population and quality of
life as well as creating equal opportunities for all marginalized groups are the general objectives of
the RD Policy. The budget for Agriculture sector has continuously increased since 2009 and with
that also the production and processing capacities in the Agriculture Sector. Legislation covering
the area of food safety is mostly harmonized with the Union acquis and one of the key
achievements is adoption of new hygiene package in 2013. This pace of development in the food
production could not be followed by the government technical departments, more specifically food
1
This designation is without prejudice to positions on status, and is in line with UNSCR 1244 and the ICJ Opinion on the Kosovo
declaration of independence.
1
testing laboratories, namely not being able to food testing services which would not only assure
public health and increase consumer confidence but facilitate export of food and food products
from Kosovo to regional and EU market. Development and accreditation of national food testing
laboratory would massively contribute to increasing consumer confidence in domestic products,
facilitate export of food products and reduce cost for testing which is borne by either food business
operators or in case of government cost of national drug and residue monitoring plan.
3.
Description
3.1 Background and justification:
Kosovo institutions have developed mechanisms and a comprehensive legal basis to allow
implementation of legislation and policies on food safety, livestock breeding, animals and plant health.
As noted in a number of reports on Kosovo Food and Veterinary Agency (KVFA) the legislation is
generally aligned with EU acquis and the mechanisms established are following EU best practices.
However the mechanisms established are not sufficiently prepared in terms of capacities and knowledge
as well insufficiently funded to properly implement the above policies and legislation.
For the food safety sector, Kosovo Food and Veterinary Agency is an executive agency under the Prime
Ministers' office responsible for implementation of integrated Food Control system better known in the
EU as "from farm to fork".
Furthermore, Food Law places the main responsibility for food safety on food business operators whereas
the KVFA should confirm that safety and quality provisions of the law are properly implemented and
respected. This change has entirely shifted traditional role of the Inspector from the classical role of
inspection to more of the Auditor who ensures that Food Businesses are complying with the requirements.
Major reorganization also took place in terms of institutional set-up whereby as per food law
veterinary/sanitary and phytosanitary inspectors placed in the municipalities should be transferred to the
Food and Veterinary Agency and they should perform their tasks and duties from the 6 KVFA regional
offices. Another important aspect of reorganization is adoption risk based systems of checks and controls
as well as application of the system 1 establishment -1 inspector.
As part of preconditions for access to EU markets, KVFA with the support of the EU funded projects has
implemented Animal Identification and Registration System and also implements annual drug and residue
monitoring programme.
Significant investments are done both by the donors and Kosovo budget in building and equipping the
Food and Veterinary Laboratory. Currently the infrastructure is in place and most of the equipment
installed and operational. ISO system 17025 is implemented and national accreditation is obtained.
However, the range and the quality of services provided by the food laboratory are very limited and most
of the tests and methods performed are not validated. Testing of samples collected for the purpose of the
implementation of national programme on drug and residue control is carried out abroad and the cost of
this service ranges between 100,000 to 200,000 euros. Considering that most of the equipment is in place
and relatively new, these tests can be performed in the Kosovo Food and Veterinary Laboratory. Massive
range of microbiological, chemical and other food tests and analysis are carried out in the regional
laboratories, causing increased expense and time consumption. Typical services food analysis services
such as analysis of Vitamins & Minerals, Nutritional Analysis, Food Allergens, Natural Toxins, Shelf
Life Studies etc. are not performed at all. Reason for this is that, although there is equipment in place
there are not sufficiently trained personnel to carry out these tasks.
2
3.2 Linked activities (other international and national initiatives):
Since 2002 KVFA has received continuous support from the EU and other donors such as WB and
USAID in its development from the classical veterinary services to the executive food safety agency as it
is now. The main objective of the Agency is to ensure that food produced or imported in Kosovo is safe
for consumption and of the appropriate quality. As stated in the Food Law, KVFA is responsible to
perform checks and controls of food/feed, animal health and plant health at all stages of production,
import-export, processing, transport, storage and retail. Significant investments are done both by the
government in building the necessary infrastructure for laboratory and also by the donors in equipping the
laboratory and introduction of quality management system. While the government invested more than 1
million euro in building the laboratory, donors (namely EU) invested over 0.5 M€ in equipment and also
provided technical support through twinning projects in building laboratory management capacities and
quality control.
3.3
Results:
1-GAP analysis for Food Safety Laboratory Completed, including recommendation for further development;
2-Identified list of food tests and food analysis to be implemented by the Kosovo Food Laboratory by the end of the
project is prepared and implemented;
3-technical specifications and price quotations for the missing equipment in the food safety laboratory is delivered;
4-Training programme implemented;
5-Proficiency testing programme implemented;
6-File for preparation for accreditation is prepared.
3.4 Activities
The proposal made by the MS should include the activities they propose to achieve the results
listed in the fiche. The following list of activities is indicative:
1-Review available equipment in place, human resources and educational background;
2-Develop list of food tests and food analysis that can be carried out with the equipment
already available in the Kosovo Food Laboratory (particular focus on tests and analysis
related to veterinary drugs and residues as per EU legislation);
3-Present list of missing equipment and cost estimate for purchase of the equipment;
4-Prepare training program and training schedule for the staff working in Food
Laboratory;
5-Implement training program for food safety laboratory, including organization of
proficiency testing as needed;
6-Neccesary preparation for accreditation is completed.
3.5 Means/ Input from the MS Partner Administration:
3.5.1 Profile and tasks of the Project Leader
3
As stipulated in the twinning manual, Project leader is expected to be high-ranking official
in MS, responsible for institutional management of services that include food safety
laboratory. The MS Project Leader is expected to direct the implementation of the project.
Project leader among other is responsible to ensure close co-operation and the overall
steering and co-ordination of the project.

University level education or equivalent professional experience of minimum 10
years in the field of Food Safety, Veterinary or relevant fields

Minimum 3 years of professional experience in laboratory management

Proven contractual relation to public administration or mandated body, as defined
under Twinning manual 5.4.5

Experience in project management

Working level of English language

Computer literacy
Assets:

Experience in coordination activities among different institutional stakeholders

Experience in institutional capacity building
Tasks of the Project Leader

Overall responsibility, coordination and direction of the MS TW partner inputs

Ensuring backstopping and financial management of the project in the MS

Supervising and coordinating implementation of the project

Mobilization of the short-term experts

Project reporting

Close cooperation with beneficiary institutions

Participation in Steering Committee meetings.
3.5.2 Profile and tasks of the RTA
RTA is expected to have the necessary educational background related to the areas
covered by this fiche, namely Veterinary, Food technology, Microbiology, Chemistry or
related fields and the necessary years of working experience ( as per twinning manual) in
managing/working in the Food Testing Laboratories in EU Member States.
4




RTA Profile:
A University Degree in Food Safety, Veterinary Medicine, Microbiology or other relevant area to
the sector or 10 years of equivalent professional experience
At least 5 years of work experience in the Laboratories. Managerial position will be considered as
an advantage
A minimum of 3 years professional experience in the development and/or strengthening of Food
Testing Laboratories
Fluency in both written and spoken English
Tasks of the Resident Twining Adviser:







Support and coordination of all activities in the BC
Day to day management of the project
Advising on EU policies and best practices, related legislation and regulations
Coordination of the short-term experts activities for both components
Monitoring project implementation and proposing corrective management actions, if
required
Organization of visibility events (kick-off, final event and thematic events)
Networking with stakeholders of the project in Kosovo and in MS.
The duration of the RTA secondment is 24 months.
3.5.3 Profile and tasks of the short-term experts:
Short-term experts with experience and competence matching the project components should have
relevant university degree, or professional experience in the relevant field, experience with on-the-jobtraining and knowledge transfer, fluency in English, computer skills and ability to work in team.
Considering very technical nature of the assignments, there is no specific requirement
with regards to educational background of the deployed short term experts, however,
among other, proposed experts should have the following technical experience;
3 years of practical experience in working in the food testing laboratory-microbiology;
3 years of practical experience in working in the food testing laboratory- Chemistry;
3 years of practical experience in working in the food testing laboratory-drug and residue
testing;
3 years of practical experience in working in the food testing laboratory-contaminant
identification;
3 years of practical experience in working in the food testing laboratory-food allergens;
3 years of practical experience in working in the food testing laboratory-natural toxins;
3 years of practical experience in working in the food testing laboratory-quality control;
3 years of practical experience in working in the food testing laboratory-document and
5
processes management;
4.
Institutional Framework
Institution responsible for this twinning project is Kosovo Food and Veterinary Agency-Food
Laboratory Section.
Results of the project will not lead to a change of the institutional framework however it will
significantly strengthen the role of Kosovo Food and Veterinary Agency in the area of Food Control
and Food Testing.
5.
Budget
Title: Support to Kosovo Food and Veterinary Laboratory
IPA Contribution
Twinning Contract
100%
700,000.00 €
6.
Implementation Arrangements
6.1
Implementing Agency responsible for tendering, contracting and accounting
The European Union Office in Kosovo will manage the procurement, implementation, quality control,
reporting and coordination with other donors. A Project Steering Committee will be responsible for the
overall direction of the project and comprise of representatives from the beneficiary institutions and the
EU Office. Monitoring will be performed centrally by the European Commission. The project may be
evaluated at the interim or ex-post stages under the supervision of the Commission's Evaluation Unit. The
project may be audited by the Court of Auditors in line with the standard European Commission
procedures.
6.2 Main counterpart in the BC :
BC Project Leader
Mr. Valdet Gjinovci, PhD
Chief Executive Officer
Food and Veterinary Agency
Government of Kosovo
RTA counterpart:
Mr. Xhemajl Dervishi
Chief Food and Veterinary Laboratory
6.3 Contracts
One twinning contract with the overall value of 0.7 million euro.
Please note that the awarding of the twinning contract is subject to the conclusion of a financing
agreement between the European Commission and the Government of Kosovo for the Annual Action
Program for 2014, which does not modify the elements of the twinning procedure. If the precedent
condition is not met, the contracting authority will cancel the call for proposal without the candidates
6
being entitled to claim any compensation.
7.
Implementation Schedule (indicative)
7.1
Launching of the call for proposals
December 2014
7.2
Start of project activities
September 2015
7.3
Project completion
September 2017
7.4
Duration of the execution period
24 months
8. Sustainability
Proposed measures to be implemented through this project have two fold importance, 1-ensure protection
of public health through provision of safe food and of the appropriate quality and 2-set up preconditions
for the access of Kosovo's agri-food producers and processors to the markets in the region and EU which
directly influences income generation and employment.
The achievements of a Twinning project (mandatory results) should be maintained as a permanent asset to
the Beneficiary administration even after the end of the Twinning project implementation. This
presupposes inter alia that effective mechanisms are put in place by the Beneficiary administration to
disseminate and consolidate the results of the project.
9. Crosscutting issues
The project is of a very technical nature and as such does not have a major impact on environment.
However, there a few issues which will be addressed by the project and which have indirect impact on the
environment. Those are mostly related to handling of animal by-products from the Agri- food processing
industry; implementation of Good Agriculture Practice which among other include controlled use of
pesticides and other chemicals; advice in managing of organic fertilizers, use of environmentally sound
farming techniques etc.
7
Environment and climate change (and if relevant disaster resilience)
Environmental considerations will be duly reflected in all IPA-financed activities and disaster resilience and risk prevention and management
should be integrated in the planning, preparation and implementation of projects.
Engagement with civil society (and if relevant other non-state stakeholders)
Kosovo Chamber of Veterinarians, Agri Food producer associations, Livestock Breeding associations will have important role on
implementation of the action. Their participation in the project working groups is indispensable. It is foreseen as much as possible to have them
not only as trainees but also use them as trainers during the project implementation. Representatives from those associations will be part of
steering committee.
Equal opportunities and gender mainstreaming
Equal opportunities and non-discrimination against women, minority and vulnerable groups (including children, disabled and elderly people) will
be taken into consideration in all aspects of EU-funded activities, particularly in relation to public services, legislative matters and socioeconomic support programmes.
Proposed project will also provide an opportunity for the qualified woman to get involved in the activities which are traditionally done by man e.g.
Inspection services, auditing of food processing plants etc.
In this regards woman will be particularly encouraged to attend training programmes and they will also have an advantage under training of
trainer's scheme and leadership role in the functioning of regional office of the Kosovo Food and Veterinary Agency.
MINORITIES AND VULNERABLE GROUPS
Project will be implemented in the entire Kosovo and specific implementation arrangements shall be put in place for the minority's areas.
ANNEXES TO PROJECT FICHE
1. Logical framework matrix in standard format (compulsory)
8
Annex 1: Logical framework
OVERALL OBJECTIVE
OBJECTIVELY VERIFIABLE
INDICATORS (OVI)
SOURCES OF
VERIFICATION
Increase Laboratory capacities in implementation of
national food safety control programme and National
drug and residue control plan
Increased consumption of domestic
products;
Decrease in the number of food borne
illnesses;
Access to regional and EU market for
specified products;
FVO assessment report on
drug and residue monitoring;
Number of reported food
borne illnesses before and
after the action including
number of consumer
complaints;
Number of new validated
tests and analysis performed
by the food and veterinary
laboratory;
Reliable and validated methods for food
testing and drug and residue testing.
Testing for drug and residue
monitoring plan is performed
entirely by FVL and not
outsourced.
National Annual Control
Plan
Annual report of Food
Safety Laboratory
SPECIFIC OBJECTIVE
OBJECTIVELY VERIFIABLE
INDICATORS (OVI)
SOURCES OF
VERIFICATION
ASSUMPTIONS
9
Ensure uniform implementation of legal framework on Food
Safety in accordance with EU rules and regulations as well as
EU best practices;
Support Kosovo Food and Veterinary Laboratory in increasing
the range of services provided, including development and
validation of existing and new tests as well as preparation for
international accreditation.
Drug and residue monitoring programme
approved by relevant DG of the EU
commission and implemented according to
FVO recommendations.
Food and Veterinary Laboratory, among
other are performing tests required for the
implementation of drug and residue
monitoring programme.
Validated methods are in place and
preparatory work for the international
accreditation is being carried out.
FVO mission report.
BC and RTA
Counterpart are fully
involved in the
implementation of the
Applications for international project.
Number of new tests
introduced and methods
validated.
accreditation for specified
tests and methods.
RESULTS
OBJECTIVELY VERIFIABLE
INDICATORS (OVI)
SOURCES OF
VERIFICATION
1-GAP analysis for Food Safety Laboratory Completed,
including recommendation for further development;
Application for accreditation;
KVFA annual report on
work of the Laboratories;
List of validated tests and methods;
2-Identified list of food tests and food analysis to be
implemented by the Kosovo Food Laboratory by the end
of the project is prepared and implemented;
3-technical specifications and price quotations for the
missing equipment in the food safety laboratory is
delivered ;
Increased staff competences
Twinning project reports;
FVO assessment report on
Drug and Residue
Monitoring plan
Technical staff working
in the laboratory is
committed and not
subject to turnover in
case of political
changes.
ASSUMPTIONS
KVFA provides
necessary human
resources and
requested kits,
reagents and
samples to perform
the necessary tests.
4-Training programme implemented;
5-Proficiency testing programme implemented;
6-File for preparation for accreditation is prepared
10
ACTIVITIES

Assessment of the current capacities of the FVL
including human resources and equipment;

Prepare list of tests carried out at present and those
missing for the food safety part;

Define training needs for the missing tests;

Preform training FVL staff in the execution of those
tests with the validated methods;

Present criteria for the international accreditation of
the FVL and define work plan for achieving it;

Prepare application for international accreditation.
MEANS
OVERALL COST
Twinning contract
0.7 M Euro
ASSUMPTIONS
FVL staff provides
requested information
on available
equipment and list of
missing tests.
Sufficient budget is
allocated to enable
preparation for
accreditation.
11