Session 5 - aciclaw.org

UNITRANCHE FINANCING AND
SECOND LIEN LOANS
Carolyn Alford, King & Spalding
Sarah Borders, King & Spalding
Alfredo Cantoral, AllState
Randall Klein, Goldberg Kohn
April 30, 2015
ACIC Spring Investment Forum
Unitranche v. Other Financings
• 1st Lien/2nd Lien Debt
• Subordinated Debt
• Mezzanine with a Lien
• Unitranche Debt
2
1st Lien/2nd Lien Financing
• Two separate groups of lenders
• Two separate agents
• Two sets of loan documents
• Two liens
• One common collateral pool
• Lien subordination
3
Subordinated Debt Financing
• Two separate groups of lenders
• Two agents
• One Lien in one collateral pool in favor of
senior lender
• Sub Debt lenders are generally unsecured
• “Mezz with a lien”
• Payment subordination
4
Unitranche Financing
• Single debt agreement with borrower, with single
set of covenants
• Single set of collateral documents
• Single collateral pool
• Single agent
• Multiple forms of unitranche
5
Evolution of the Unitranche Product
• History
• Size of Market
• Players
• Trends
6
Advantages of Unitranche
• Speed of Transaction
• Certainty of Closing
• Reduced Closing Costs
• Post-Closing Administration Simplicity
7
Disadvantages of Unitranche
• Less established market and no model forms
• More “Last Out” friendly
• Less precedent for assessing enforceability
• Syndication complications
• Bankruptcy complications
8
Agreement Among Lenders (AAL)
• Separate agreement that creates separate “first
out” and “last out” tranches of the unitranche
• Reallocation of interest between lenders
• Payment waterfall
• Voting rights of lenders
• Purchase option
• Remedy standstill
9
Evaluating Unitranche Risk
• Borrower are often not a party to AAL.
• Agent’s hold in each tranche is important.
• Enforceability of AAL, in and out of bankruptcy,
is less certain.
• Risk of “secret agreement”.
10
Waterfall
• Prior to trigger event, payments are allocated
per the debt agreement (subject to interest/fee
skim).
• After trigger event, AAL reallocates all
collateral proceeds and all payments received
post trigger to affect first out/last out priority.
Agent fees and expenses paid first, followed by
all first out amounts, and finally all last out
amounts.
11
Waterfall
Trigger events are highly negotiated, and often
include:
• Payment default
• Bankruptcy
• Financial covenant default (sometimes an earlier
trigger than default)
• Commencement of exercise of remedies
• Failure to timely deliver a borrowing base
certificate (ABL deals).
12
Voting Rights
• Amendments generally are Required Lenders
vote (subject to sacred rights).
• Required lenders may require more than 50% of
the entire facility (in which case the larger
tranche controls).
• AAL may override required lender votes to
require a majority of first out lenders and a
majority of last out lenders.
13
Voting Rights
• AAL may also include a list of items requiring
approval of all lenders.
• Upon a trigger event, majority of first out
lenders may control amendments on certain
aspects of the debt documents.
• Trigger events may include payment default,
bankruptcy default, or exercise of remedies, with
delivery of notice to the relevant tranche.
• Affiliate lender and defaulting lenders
complicate voting further.
14
Exercise of Remedies
• Debt agreement may provide that a majority of
lenders control remedies (which would mean the
larger tranche controls) or that a majority of
either class or both classes is required to institute
remedies.
• Control over remedies may change based on
trigger events.
• Standstill Periods:
• First Out Lenders
• Last Out Lenders
15
Bankruptcy Risks
• Less precedent on enforceability
• Post-petition interest, fees & expenses
• Classification of claims and voting on a
bankruptcy plan
• Credit bidding
• Sale of assets
• DIP financing/use of cash collateral
16
Purchase Option
• Provides last out lenders with right to purchase the
first out obligations upon the occurrence of certain
trigger events.
• First out lenders may have a limited right to
purchase the last out obligations.
• Principal way to resolve disagreement on how to
proceed in a restructuring/workout.
17
Assignability
• Consent rights
• Agent
• Borrower
• Right of first offer/Right of first refusal
• Cross over lender issues
18