this screener comparison chart

Commonly Used Parent-Report Developmental Screening Tools
Instrument
For use with
Questionnaire
items
Single stage
screener?
Developmental
areas screened
Ages & Stages
Questionnaires®,Third
Edition (ASQ-3): A
Parent-Completed,
Child-Monitoring
System
Children from 1-66
months
Denver
Prescreening
Developmental
Questionnaire
(PDQ II)
Infant Development
Inventory (IDI) and the
Child Development
Review Parent
Questionnaires (CDRPQ)
Children from birth to
18 months (IDI); and
children from 18
months to
kindergarten (CDR-PQ)
The IDI includes about
85 developmental
milestones divided by
month and across 5
domains; the CDR-PQ
includes about 100
items divided by month
or year and across 5
domains; also includes
open-ended questions
Parents’ Evaluation of
Development Status
(PEDS) and PEDS:
Developmental
Milestones (PEDS:DM)
ASQ-3 includes 21
age-specific
questionnaires, which
allow you to
accurately screen
anytime between 1
and 66 months—
whether at the AAP
recommended 9-, 18, and 24- or 30month well-child
visits, or whenever
the child enters your
program
Yes. Empirically
derived cutoff scores
produce results that
clearly suggest
whether to (a)
evaluate further, (b)
closely monitor,
and/or (c) share
information with
parents about a
child’s strengths and
recommend activities
for healthy
development
Communication,
gross motor, fine
motor, problem
solving, and personalsocial, plus selfregulation,
compliance,
language, adaptive
behaviors, autonomy,
The PDQ is a
105-item
questionnaire
regarding a
child’s current
level of
development. At
each visit the
parent is asked
to answer 7-10
age-appropriate
questions
No. Results of
the PDQ showing
two or more
delays produce a
referral for
further screening
with the
professionally
administered
DENVER II.
Yes. The results are
compared to age
norms, and classified as
“typical” for age in all
areas, or as
“borderline” or
“delayed” in one or
more areas of
development
Yes, when used in
combination. PEDS
alone “provides
decision-making paths
to aid in interpreting
parents’ responses to
questions.”
Personal and
social, fine
motor, gross
motor, and
language
Social, self-help, gross
motor, fine motor,
language
Expressive language,
receptive language,
fine motor, gross
motor, socialemotional, self-help,
academics in both
reading and math
(older children)
Children from
birth to 6 years
Children from birth to
8 years
PEDS is a single
questionnaire
containing the same
10 open-ended
questions for all ages
to elicit and address
parents’ concerns.
PEDS:DM provides 6-8
milestones-type items
per well visit
Sample item
Time to
complete and
score
Standardization
affect, and
interaction with
people with ASQ:SE
The parents answers
Yes, Sometimes, or
Not Yet: Does your
child stack a small
block or toy on top of
another one? (18month questionnaire,
fine motor area)
2-3 minutes to score.
Once parents
complete the
questionnaire (10-15
minutes), the
professional consults
a scoring grid with
clearly designated
results
Standardized in an
unparalleled national
sample of 15,138
children
(sample not
available)
The parent checks (or
doesn’t check)Runs
well, seldom falls (2-0
years, gross motor
area)
10 and 20
minutes to
administer and
interpret the
test.
IDI: 5-10 minutes CDR:
10-20 minutes
Drawn from the
DENVER II, which
was normed on
2036 children in
Colorado;
diversified in
terms of age,
place of
residence/
ethnicity/cultural
background, and
maternal
education
IDI: Studied in 86 highrisk 8-month olds seen
in a perinatal follow-up
program and compared
with the Bayley scales;
CDR: Standardized with
220 children aged 3-4
from primarily white,
working class families
in south St. Paul, MN
IDI: 85%
CDR: 68%
IDI: 77%
CDR: 88%
7th-8th grade level
Sensitivity
86%
DENVER II: 68%
Specificity
85%
DENVER II: 88%
Reading Level
4th-6th grade level
unknown
The parent circles No,
Yes, or A Little and
adds comments: Do
you have any
concerns about how
your child talks and
makes speech
sounds?(expressive
language and
articulation area)
PEDS: Takes about
two minutes to
administer and score
if conducted as an
interview.
DM: 5 minutes to
administer, one
minute to score.
PEDS: Standardized
on 47,000 families
from various
backgrounds,
including levels of
socioeconomic status,
language
backgrounds, and
varying ethnicities.
DM: Standardized on
more than 1600
children across the US
74%-80%
70%-80%
th
st
Initial cost
One-time investment
for each program: No
reordering
required!ASQ-3
Starter Kit: $275.00
Includes: ASQ-3
User’s Guide, ASQ-3
The Denver II
Complete
Package: $160. It
includes the test
kit as well as a
Training Manual
and pad of 100
Health Care Starter
Pack (HC-S)
$150.00
Includes 75 IDI, 75
CDR-PQ, 75 CDC - With
all necessary manuals
and instructions.
th
PEDS: 4 -5 grade
reading level
nd
DM: 1 -2 grade
reading level
PEDS:DM plus PEDS:
$315.00. Includes the
PEDS:DM starter kit
plus 100 PEDS
Response Forms and
the PEDS Brief Guide.
The PEDS:DM
Reordering
required?
Ongoing costs
Languages
Quick-Start Guide,
and a photocopiable
print master set of 21
questionnaires and
scoring sheets, as
well as a CD-ROM
with printable PDF
questionnaires
No.
Test forms.
Yes.
Yes.
None. All forms may
be photocopied or
reprinted from the
disk by the
purchasing
organization for no
extra charge
English, Spanish, and
French
DVD training: ASQ-3
Scoring and Referral,
Ages & Stages
Questionnaires on a
Home Visit; on site
customized seminars
offered through
Brookes On Location
professional
development
program; annual
“train-the-trainer”
workshops available;
Trainers Toolkit and
online training
options in
development
$40 per pad of
100. $2.25 per
use on Denver
Online.
Photocopying is
not allowed.
$45.00 per pad of 75
(instructions
included).Photocopying
is not allowed
Recording Form (100
supplied with each
order) includes the
PEDS
Scoring/Interpretation
Form that identifies
when the PEDS:DM is
needed.
No, all forms are
'scannable' and can
be easily added to
electronic records.
PEDS Response Forms
(pad of 50): $18.00.
English and
English, Spanish, and
English, Spanish, and
Spanish
Vietnamese
Vietnamese
Training
Instructions for
Instructions are
Using PEDS: DM
options
scoring and
included in the
instructional video,
interpreting the
required Child
PowerPoint slide
PDQ II are
Development Review
shows, and additional
distributed with
Manual
downloadable
the
training material
questionnaires;
available on web site.
DENVER II
Training DVD or
videotape
available for
rental or
purchase;
DENVER II
master
instructor
training sessions
held in Denver
Publisher
Brookes Publishing
Denver
Behavior Science
PEDSTest.com, LLC
Developmental
Systems
Materials
Every effort has been made to ensure that the information in this chart is accurate, according to the latest information
available from the publishers of each of the tools. Please contact the publishers directly with any questions.
Sources
[1] Child Development Review. Retrieved November 26, 2008.
[2] Denver Developmental Materials, Inc. Retrieved February 9, 2015.
[3] PEDS: Parents’ Evaluation of Developmental Status. Retrieved February 6, 2015.
[4] “Identifying Infants and Young Children with Developmental Disorders in the Medical Home: An Algorithm for
Developmental Surveillance and Screening.” Retrieved November 26, 2008.
[5] “Selecting Developmental Surveillance and Screening Tools.” Retrieved November 26, 2008.