DNR Regulatory Efficiency Reviews
Transcription
DNR Regulatory Efficiency Reviews
Executive Director’s Office 1313 Sherman Street, Room 718 Denver, CO 80203 Memorandum From: Date: Re: Mike King March 31, 2015 Review of Rules Pursuant to SB 14-063 Senate Bill 14-063 requires each Principal Department to conduct a review of its rules to assess the continuing need for, and the appropriateness and cost effectiveness of, its rules to determine if they should be continued in their current form, modified, or repealed. See 24-4-103.3, C.R. S. The bill sets forth a list of considerations in conducting the review, including: 1. Whether the rule is necessary; 2. Whether the rule overlaps or duplicates other rules of the agency or with other federal, state, or local government rules; 3. Whether the rule is written in plain language and is easy to understand; 4. Whether the rule has achieved the desired intent and whether more or less regulation is necessary; 5. Whether the rule can be amended to give more flexibility, reduce regulatory burdens, or reduce unnecessary paperwork or steps while maintaining its benefits; 6. Whether the rule is implemented in an efficient and effective manner, including the requirements for the issuance of permits and licenses; 7. Whether a cost-benefit analysis was performed by the applicable rule making agency or official in the principal department pursuant to Section 24-4-103 (2.5); and 8. Whether the rule is adequate for the protection of the safety, health, and welfare of the state or its residents. The attached table summarizes the Department of Natural Resources’ schedule to review its rules pursuant to SB 14-063 over the three-year period from January 1, 2015 through December 31, 2017. Each of the rulemaking proceedings described below will include a public-participation process. If you have quesitons about this review schedule or would like to provide input on the Department’s reviews of its rules, please contact DNR Deputy Director Bob Randall, at 303-866-3311 or [email protected]. Board of Land Commissioners |Division of Reclamation, Mining & Safety | Oil & Gas Conservation Commission Water Conservation Board | Division of Forestry | Division of Water Resources | Division of Parks and Wildlife CDNR Review of Rules Pursuant to SB 14-063 Page 2 DIVISION OF WATER RESOURCES Period for Review Rules & Subject Matter Notes Review in 2016, with 2 CCR 402-1 (Dam Safety and Construction) Authoritative Body: State Engineer Stakeholder comment 2 CCR 402-2 (Water Well Construction, Authoritative Body: Board of Examiners of Water period underway, with Pump Installation, Cistern Installation and Well & Pump Installation Contractors rulemaking occurring on or Monitoring and Observation Hole/Well after Oct. 6, 2015. Construction) Review in 2016, with 2 CCR 402-3 (Adjudicatory Hearings before Authoritative Body: Colorado Groundwater potential amendments the Colorado Ground Water Commission) Commission Review in 2015, with 2 CCR 402-4 (Small Capacity Well Permits in Authoritative Body: State Engineer potential amendments Des. Basins) potential amendments adopted in 2017. adopted in 2017. adopted in 2016 Currently seeking input 2 CCR 402-5 (Procedural Rules for Hearings) Authoritative Body: State Engineer Review in 2017. 2 CCR 402-6 (Denver Basin Rules) Authoritative Body: State Engineer Review in 2017. 2 CCR 402-7 (Statewide Nontributary Rules) Authoritative Body: State Engineer Review in 2016. 2 CCR 402-8 (Senate Bill 89-181 Rules) Authoritative Body: State Engineer Draft amended rules 2 CCR 402-9 (Fees for Water Data Bank Cash Authoritative Body: State Engineer distributed, now awaiting Fund, Publication Cash Fund, and Satellite input from stakeholders. Monitoring System Cash Fund) from stakeholders, with rulemaking occuring in Sept. 2015. Potential amendments to be adopted in Nov.-Dec. 2015. Review in 2017. 2 CCR 402-10 (Geothermal Rules) Authoritative Body: State Engineer Review in 2016. 2 CCR 402-11 (Denver Basin Artificial Authoritative Body: State Engineer Recharge Extraction Rules) Review in 2017. 2 CCR 402-12 (Ark. River Water Bank Pilot Authoritative Body: State Engineer Program) Repealed in 2004. 2 CCR 402-13 (Water Administration Fee Authoritative Body: State Engineer Program) Review in 2015, with 2 CCR 402-14 (Administration of Licensing, Authoritative Body: Board of Examiners of Water potential amendments Financial Responsibility, Continuing Well & Pump Installation Contractors adopted in 2016. Education and Remedial Action) Review in 2016. 2 CCR 402-15 (Submittal and Evaluation of Authoritative Body: State Engineer Interruptible Water Supply Agreements Submitted Pursuant to 37‐92‐309 CRS) Rules hearing scheduled for 2 CCR 402-16 (Measurement of Ground September, 2015. Water Diversions in Republican River Basin) Rules recently promulgated, 2 CCR 402-17 (Determination of the to be reviewed in 2017. Nontributary Nature of Ground Water Authoritative Body: State Engineer Authoritative Body: State Engineer Produced through Wells in Conjunction with the Mining of Minerals) Review in 2016, with 2 CCR 410-1 (Management and Control of Authoritative Body: Colorado Groundwater potential amendments Designated Ground Water) Commission Water Court Rules (Diversion and Use of Authoritative Body: State Engineer adopted in 2017. Review in 2017. CDNR Review of Rules Pursuant to SB 14-063 Page 3 Tributary Ground Water in the Arkansas River Basin) Review in 2015, with Water Court Rules (Measurement of potential amendments Tributary Ground Water Diversions Located adopted in 2016. in the Arkansas River Basin) None. Rules stipulated by Stipulated Rules (Use, Control and court decree. Protection of Surface and Ground Water Authoritative Body: State and Division Engineer Authoritative Body: State Engineer Rights of the South Platte) Review in 2017. Water Court Rules (Ground Water Authoritative Body: State Engineer Withdrawals In Water Division 3 Affecting the Rate or Direction of Movement of Water in Confined Aquifer System) Review in 2017. Compact Rules (Improvements to Surface Authoritative Body: State Engineer Water Irrigation Systems in the Arkansas River Basin in Colorado) These rules were approved Water Court Rules (Measurement of by the Water Court in March Tributary Ground Water Diversions Located 2013. No immediate in the South Platte River Basin within Water amendments planned. Staff Division No. 1) Authoritative Body: State Engineer will review and make recommendations following first full year of reporting in Spring 2015. To be filed in Water Court Proposed Water Court Rules (Withdrawal of in early 2015. Ground Water in Water Division 3) Initial stakeholder meetings Proposed Water Court Rules (Post-1985 held. Decision whether to Depletions from the Arkansas River) Authoritative Body: State Engineer Authoritative Body: State Engineer proceed will be made in April 2015. If proceeding, rulemaking will occur in Dec. 2015. COLORADO OIL AND GAS CONSERVATION COMMISSION Period for Review Rules & Subject Matter Notes 2014 100 Series Rules (Definitions) Regulatory efficiency review conducted in 300 Series Rules (Drilling, Development, association with adoption of substantive changes Production, and Abandonment) to these rules. 600 Series Rules (Safety Regulations) 900 Series Rules (E&P Waste Management) 2015 300 Series Rules (Drilling, Development, Production, and Abandonment) This review will be conducted in conjunction with rulemaking associated with implementing 600 Series Rules (Safety Regulations) recommendations of the Governor’s Oil and Gas 800 Series Rules (Aesthetic and Noise) Task Force and with COGCC’s 2015 proposed 900 Series Rules (E&P Waste Management) regulatory agenda involving “Flood Plain Best Practices,” “Noise,” “Horizontal Offset Well Analysis for the Denver-Julesburg Basin,” and “900 Series Update.” 2016 1000 Series Rules (Reclamation) Regulatory efficiency review 1100 Series Rules (Pipelines) 1200 Series Rules (Wildlife Resources) 2017 400 Series Rules (Unit Operations, Enhanced Recovery Projects, and Regulatory efficiency review CDNR Review of Rules Pursuant to SB 14-063 Page 4 Storage of Liquid Hydrocarbons) 500 Series Rules (Practice/Procedure) 2 CCR 404-3 (Well Category Determination Procedures) COLORADO PARKS AND WILDLIFE Period for Review Rules & Subject Matter Notes March 2015 2 CCR 405-1 (P-1 - PARKS AND OUTDOOR Open annually for all issues, to include review RECREATION LANDS) pursuant to factors in SB 14-063 March 2015 2 CCR 405-2 (P-2 – BOATING) Administrative clean-ups made to entire chapter Sept. 2017 2 CCR 405-3 (P-3 - RIVER OUTFITTERS) Nov. 2017 2 CCR 405-4 (P-4 - SNOWMOBILE Administrative clean-ups made to entire chapter REGULATIONS) in November 2014 2 CCR 405-5 (P-5 - OFF-HIGHWAY VEHICLE Administrative clean-ups made to entire chapter REGULATIONS) in November 2014 2 CCR 405-6 (P-6 - PROCEDURAL RULES) Administrative clean-ups made to entire chapter in March 2015 Administrative clean-ups made to entire chapter in September 2014 Nov. 2017 Nov. 2017 in November 2014 March 2015 May or July 2015 2 CCR 405-7 (P-7 - PASSES, PERMITS AND Open annually for all issues, to include review REGISTRATIONS) pursuant to factors in SB 14-063 2 CCR 405-8 (P-8 - AQUATIC NUISANCE Will be reviewed pursuant to factors in SB 14-063. SPECIES (ANS)) Jan. and March 2015 2 CCR 406-0 (W-0 - GENERAL PROVISIONS) Open annually for all issues, to include review pursuant to factors in SB 14-063 Nov. 2015 2 CCR 406-1 (W-1 – FISHING) January, March, May, Sept. 2 CCR 406-2 (W-2 - BIG GAME) Open annually for all issues, to include review pursuant to factors in SB 14-063 and Nov. 2015 Open several times each year to make annual changes to quotas or seasons, administrative clean-ups, and CPI adjustments; future reviews will include factors in SB 14-063 July and Nov. 2015 2 CCR 406-3 (W-3 - FURBEARERS AND SMALL Open several times each year to make annual GAME EXCEPT MIGRATORY BIRDS) changes to quotas or seasons, and will include review pursuant to factors in SB 14-063 July and Aug. 2015 2 CCR 406-5 (W-5 - MIGRATORY BIRDS) July 2017 2 CCR 406-6 (W-6 – FALCONRY) Open annually for all issues, to include review pursuant to factors in SB 14-063 Added #607H, and made administrative clean-ups to entire chapter in July 2014. --- RESERVED --- Nov. 2017 2 CCR 406-8 (W-8 - FIELD TRIALS AND Administrative clean-ups made to entire chapter TRAINING OF DOGS) in November 2014 March 2015 2 CCR 406-9 (W-9 - WILDLIFE PROPERTIES) Open annually for all issues, to include review July 2017 2 CCR 406-10 (W-10 - NONGAME WILDLIFE) pursuant to factors in SB 14-063 Removed greater sandhill crane from #1004A(5) and made administrative clean-ups to entire chapter in July 2012 March 2015 2 CCR 406-11 (W-11 - WILDLIFE PARKS AND Amended #1103 exemptions and made UNREGULATED WILDLIFE) administrative clean-ups to entire chapter in March 2015 May or July 2015 2 CCR 406-12 (W-12 - LAKE LICENSES) Will be reviewed pursuant to factors in SB 14-063 Sept. 2016 2 CCR 406-13 (W-13 - POSSESSION OF Added #1317B and made administrative clean-ups CDNR Review of Rules Pursuant to SB 14-063 Page 5 WILDLIFE, SCIENTIFIC COLLECTING, AND to entire chapter in September 2013 SPECIAL LICENSES) Nov. 2016 2 CCR 406-14 (W-14 - WILDLIFE Amended #1401A(2)a(14) and #1401A(2)b(13) on REHABILITATION) provisional inspections and made administrative clean-ups to entire chapter in November 2013 Nov. 2015 2 CCR 406-15 (W-15 - LICENSE AGENTS) Open annually for CPI adjustments to the sale of licenses by license agents, and will include review pursuant to factors in SB 14-063 Jan. 2017 2 CCR 406-16 (W-16 - PROCEDURAL RULES) Added #1670D for disaster relief authority and made administrative clean-ups to entire chapter in January 2014 Nov. 2016 2 CCR 406-17 (W-17 - DAMAGE CAUSED BY Added commercial market garden regulations BIG GAME) (#1700F) and #1719A to determine eligibility requirements for temporary game damage materials and made administrative clean-ups to entire chapter in November 2012 DIVISION OF RECLAMATION, MINING, & SAFETY Period for Review Rules & Subject Matter Notes Jan. 2015 to Dec. 2015 2 CCR 407-2 (Regulations for Coal Mining) Rule amendments will be proposed to clarify existing rules and correct typographical errors. The rule amendments will conform to the federal counterpart regulations, 30 CFR Part 700, and also to requirements set forth by the Director of the Interior Department’s Office of Surface Mining that arose out of deficiencies identified by OSM in its ongoing review of the MLRB’s coal mining rules Jan. 2015 to Dec. 2015 2 CCR 407-1 Rule amendments will be proposed for Regulations for Hard Rock/Metal Mining clarification, including Designated Mining Operation liability release requirements, as well as deletion of obsolete provisions. The rule amendments will also include definition clarifications, all of which will provide more consistency and understandability Jan. 2016 to Dec. 2016 2 CCR 407-4 (Regulations for Construction To provide more conistency and understandability, Material) rule amendments will be proposed for clarification, including requirements for annual reports, as well as deletion of obsolete provisions. Jan. 2017 to Dec. 2017 2 CCR 407-5 (Regulations for Coal Mine Rule amendments will be proposed to align the Health & Safety) certification requirements for coal mine officials with federal rules. Jan. 2017 to Dec. 2017 2 CCR 407-6 (Regulations for Mine Safety & Rule amendments will be proposed to reflect new Training Program for Tourist Mines) policies pertaining to operations that conduct tours and mining/prospecting activities. COLORADO WATER CONSERVATION BOARD Period for Review Rules & Subject Matter Notes June 2016 2 CCR 408-1 (Regulatory Floodplains in Last reviewed and updated November 2010 to add Colorado) technical measures, such as freeboard, for increased public safety and property protection. March 2015 2 CCR 408-2 (Colorado Instream Flow and Last reviewed and updated January 2009 to Natural Lake Level Program) implement HB 08-1280 to amend water acquisition CDNR Review of Rules Pursuant to SB 14-063 Page 6 procedures (Rule #6). Sept. 2016 Sept. 2017 2 CCR 408-3 (Recreational In-channel Last reviewed and updated November 2006 in Diversions) accordance with CRS 37-92-102. 2 CCR 401-1 (Colorado Weather Last updated May 2012. DORA performed sunset Modificaiton) review and made recommendations to CWCB and the General Assembly, and CWCB updated rules accordingly in accordance with CRS 36-20-107. STATE LAND BOARD Period for Review Rules & Subject Matter Notes Sept. 2016 2 CCR 409-1 (Sale and Disposition of Forest Staff reviewed these rules in 2014 pursuant to Products from State Forest Lands) criteria in SB 14-063. Review completed in 2014. 2 CCR 409-2 (Procedures for Nomination, SLB Commissioners will consider rescinding these Rule rescision will begin in Evaluation, and Selection of Stewardship rules because they are inconsistent with statute June 2015 and be Trust Lands) and their objectives can be handled more completed in Dec. 2015. effectively by Board Policy (400-1) than by formal rule.