here - Association of Energy Engineers (AEE)

A Better Package:
Why Save Energy?
The Key to Significant Energy Savings
•
Simple Economics: Energy savings is a direct
benefit to a building owner.
Jack Hopkins, P.E.
Principal, Applied Engineering
•
Energy Independence: Reducing energy use will
help promote independence for a given country.
Presented to: Association of Energy Engineers
May 13, 2014
•
Global Warming: Reducing fossil fuel use will
reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
US Energy Use
HVAC Equipment
•
Buildings: 40% of total energy use
•
Applied Equipment: 20 to 30% of total
•
Buildings: 70% of total electric use
•
Unitary or Packaged: 70 to 80% of total
•
HVAC: 40% of electric use
•
Which is the low-hanging fruit?
•
HVAC: 45% of peak electric demand
•
Which is being pursued?
A Better Package.key - May 14, 2015
Supply Air Temperature vs.
Supply Air Flow
Statement
•
•
Improvement must come from the most basic
quality level for packaged equipment, as these
units will be selected for the majority of commercial
projects.
Owner vs. Tenant
•
What if we start from scratch?
•
Packaged units are generally sized on sensible
heat.
Qs = 1.08 x CFM x (TLA - TEA)
Air Handler Design
•
What is optimal supply temperature?
•
What is optimal airflow?
•
Which should govern?
Psychrometric Chart
A Better Package.key - May 14, 2015
Balance of Space Condition
and Coil Performance
•
•
•
A lower supply air temperature will result in a dryer
space condition for a given space setpoint.
A dryer space condition will also allow comfort to
be maintained at a higher space temperature.
A dryer space condition will usually result in better
indoor air quality.
Physical Factors
•
•
What is required to vary coil discharge temperature
(assume constant flow)?
Supply Air Temperature
Optimization
•
Start with 55 degree discharge air
•
Unit kW = Fan kW + Comp kW + Cond kW
•
Drop to 52 degree discharge air: Unit kW = ?
•
Rise to 58 degree discharge air: Unit kW = ?
•
What is optimal?
Optimal Supply Air Temp
•
Why 55 Degrees?, David Knebel, P.E., circa 1998
•
Actual optimal temperature is between 45 and 50
degrees.
•
13-15% savings using lower temperature supply air
than 55.
•
Even greater savings over equipment with 58
degree discharge
What is required to vary airflow?
A Better Package.key - May 14, 2015
Why Have We Drifted in the
Wrong Direction?
Confirm with Mfr. Software
•
Experiment with number of coil rows/fan cfm
•
EER up with lower supply air temperature
•
Part load efficiencies even greater because:
•
Fan savings for lower airflow is continuous
•
Compressor penalty is intermittent
•
Economics and Competition
•
Less expensive to make a bigger fan
•
More expensive to make a thicker coil
•
Is cost justified?
•
Some manufacturers are doing well with this
•
Others would follow if market demanded it
Future Issues for Packaged
Equipment
•
Building sensible loads are being driven downward
•
Better envelopes
•
Lower lighting densities
•
% of latent to total goes up
•
Some packaged equipment can not handle
increased latent loads
Fresh Air Damper Design
A Better Package.key - May 14, 2015
What is This?
Censored!
Slide Plate
•
Backward Progress
•
Frequently fail in a wide-open position
•
Wallpaper falls off!
•
Building damage frequently results during the delay
between failure and diagnosis
Poor Rotating Dampers
Poor Rotating Dampers
•
2012 IECC: Fresh air dampers within the building
envelope must have AMCA Class I leakage rates
•
2012 IECC: No requirements for HVAC unit
dampers
•
2010 ASHRAE 90.1: Two values, based on climate
zone. •
All Others: No requirements for HVAC unit dampers
A Better Package.key - May 14, 2015
Proper Rotating Dampers
Proper Rotating Dampers
Proper Fresh Air Dampers
Consequences
•
Should be properly sized
•
Accurately controlled
•
•
Blade Seals
•
Leakage path during unoccupied periods (wastes
energy)
•
Can't properly balance fresh air flow
•
Economizers: Magnify problems
Edge Seals
A Better Package.key - May 14, 2015
Leakage Standards
Cabinet Leakage
•
ASHRAE: None
•
IECC: No reference
•
ASHRAE 90.1: No reference
•
IECC Building Leakage Test: Usually fails through
HVAC unit
Cabinet Improvements
•
Prefer double-wall sandwich panels (foam injected)
•
Over single-wall metal with foil-faced fiber, taped.
•
We need a standard!
•
Custom AHU Manufacturers: Less than 1% of rated
airflow. Typically test to less than 1/2%
External Factors
A Better Package.key - May 14, 2015
External Factors
Standards vs. Regulation
•
Duct design
•
Industry groups: www.advancedrtu.org
•
Duct insulation
•
Owner groups
•
Air distribution
•
Still - developers will always be price-driven!
•
47? 50? 52? 55?
•
Standards (90.1, LEED) only apply to the 1% of
projects!
•
DOE vs. ASHRAE
Conclusions
•
Energy-based improvements will not only result in
less energy use for new projects, but it will extend
to equipment replacement and building renovation,
arguably a larger market than new construction.
•
We must push for a greater commitment if
significant equipment innovation is to occur for the
next generation.
Questions?
A Better Package.key - May 14, 2015