Angola - Banco BPI
Transcription
Angola - Banco BPI
Economic and Financial Research Contacts: +351 21 310 11 86 | Fax: 21 353 56 94 | E-mail: [email protected] Angola June 2016 Angola – Adjusting swiftly to a new normal For the second time in the span of a decade, the Angolan economy faces the challenge of a drastic drop in oil prices in the international markets. Despite adopting a proactive attitude in implementing economic policies better suited to this new scenario, the Angolan authorities have not been fully capable of shielding the economy, which has intensified social pressures and renewed calls for urgent economic diversification. According to estimates by the International Monetary Fund, average nominal GDP, per capita and measured in USD, is expected to record a 36% drop from 2014 figures. The same source places its 2016 GDP forecast for Angola at USD 81 billion, down from USD 127 billion only two years prior. Given the sizable weight of imports in all components of aggregate expenditure, this variable, more than any other, reflects the true state of the Angolan economy, particularly from a development perspective. Despite this significant challenge, the adjustment process remains on track and is probably approaching a plateau of stability, towards a new normal, a scenario that will probably be smoothed by additional funding by the IMF, through an Extended Fund Facility (EFF) supported program currently under discussion and whose details and conditions are likely to be published in the near future. The country’s extensive dependence on oil-sector revenues, the subdued degree of diversification still observable in the economy, as well as the adverse effects caused by external economic constraints, all affected the Angolan economy negatively in 2015. Although preliminary data findings are yet to be published by the country’s statistics office, the Angolan Executive estimates a 2.8% GDP growth rate for 2015, primarily spurred by the oil sector. This estimated growth rate is starkly below not only the estimate placed on the Amended State Budget for 2015 (6.6%), but also the State Budget 2016 estimate (4%), as well as the growth rate recorded in 2014 (4.8%). 2015 featured an increase in oil production, which helped offset some of the deceleration observed in the remaining sectors. In 2016, we expect a continuation of these trends. Beyond the behaviour of oil prices and production (the Executive expects production to reach 1.89 mbpd), the economic performance will be primarily dependent on the State’s ability to secure additional external funding (both bilateral and multilateral), as well as its ability to implement additional restrictive economic policies, such as tightening the budgetary policy, depreciating the currency and increasing interest rates – which will inevitably impact internal demand. The inflation rate for the city of Luanda stood at 29.2% in May, this following a return to double-digits figures in July 2015. The currency devaluation of about 54% in real, average terms, since 2014 (according to our calculations), an increased tax on consumption and selected imports, as well as the slashing of fuel subsidies, together with constraints on the supply side, all contributed towards this development. We expect to see the current trajectory staying throughout the year, blurred during the second quarter by the one-off nature of some of the factors mentioned, while the average inflation rate is expected to near 30% by the year’s end. The economic policy is expected to maintain a restrictive stance and remain aimed at stimulating the adjustment process of internal demand to the new context of significantly lower oil prices, this while efforts towards the diversification of the economic activity continue. The execution of the 2016 State Budget during the early months of the year suggests the possibility that revenue may fall short of the Executive’s goals. The Government aims to reach a deficit of 5.5% of GDP, a goal that, given the estimates for capital expenditure, depends extensively on the future trajectory of the oil production and prices, as well as the country’s ability to secure additional external funding. Meanwhile, according to IMF projections, government debt levels for Angola are near the sustainability threshold, with the Fund estimating that the ratio in relation to GDP for the current year will exceed 70% of GDP (including the Sonangol debt). According to recently-published Census results, the Angolan population increased nearly five-fold between 1970 and 2014, standing near 25.8 million inhabitants by the end of 2014. Of all provinces, Luanda remains the most populous, with nearly a fourth of the total population (nearly 7 million), while Bengo is the least populous province in the country. It is also worth noting that, according to the released figures, a large percentage of the population is 18 years old or under (55% in 2014). Paula Gonçalves Carvalho [email protected] José Miguel Cerdeira [email protected] Vânia Patrícia Duarte vania.patrí[email protected] Sílvio Bernardo Magalhães* [email protected] Note: * this report was made in collaboration with Sílvio Bernardo Magalhães, a BFA analyst, currently a trainee at BPI. Research Department Paula Gonçalves Carvalho Teresa Gil Pinheiro José Miguel Cerdeira Vânia Patrícia Duarte Chief Economist Technical Analysis Agostinho Leal Alves Tel.: 351 21 310 11 86 Fax: 351 21 353 56 94 Email: [email protected] www.bancobpi.pt www.bpiinvestimentos.pt/Research Index Angola Economic Activity Global and Regional Economic Context Economic Activity in Angola Other economic activity indicators and perspectives for 2016 Developments in the oil and natural gas markets Oil Natural Gas 05 05 06 07 08 08 09 Public Finances Budget implementation in 2015 State Budget for 2016 Government Debt 10 10 11 12 Angola assessment by the Rating Agencies 14 Finantial and Monetary Sector Exchange Policy and Inflation Possible effects on inflation of a prolonged devaluation of the kwanza Monetary Policy 16 16 17 18 Banking situation in Angola Balance 2015 Financial sector in a regional context 20 20 21 External Sector Goods and Services Account vas Oil Prices Diversification of the economy and import replacement International Competitiveness 23 23 25 26 Social Context Caracteristics of the angolan population – 2014 Census (final data) 27 27 Main Indicators Main economic indicators Gross domestic product Oil sector Growth forecasts for Angola (real GDP, % change) 29 Consumer price index External sector Public accounts Key financial variables 30 E.E.F. Angola June 2016 4 E.E.F. Angola June 2016 Economic Activity Global and Regional Economic Context The recent IMF’s forecasts suggest a fragile economic Growth among importers is likely to surpass exporters growth for the world economy in 2016. Economic growth is in Subsaharan Africa expected to remain moderate among the developed economies, (real GDP growth rate, %) reflecting unfavorable demographic trends, timid production 9.0 growth and lingering effects from the 2008/09 financial 8.0 crisis. Although the expansionist monetary policies (in the 7.0 Eurozone and Japan) and the low oil prices both spur internal 6.0 demand, weak external demand, the currency valuation in 5.0 some cases and some restrictions in financial conditions, all 4.0 may weight down the pace of the economic recovery. Among 3.0 2.0 the emerging and developing economies, growth rates should 1.0 remain substantial, although disappointing given the historical 0.0 background, a path that is particularly linked to low commodity 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 prices and the deceleration of the Chinese economy. Oil-exporting countries Oil-importing countries Source: IMF The economic activity in Sub-Saharan Africa decelerated in 2015, in line with the drop in commodity prices, the adjustment of the economic growth model in China and the increased cost of funding. Additionally, several countries faced adverse domestic events, which exacerbated the direct impact of the lower commodity prices, including, among others, adverse climate events and the Ebola outbreak. The drop in commodity prices represented a significant shock to the region, given its extensive weight on total exports. This performance resulted in the deterioration of the trade balances, which in turns impacted the local currencies and increased inflation rates. In order to contain this situation, the Central Banks throughout the region adopted restrictive monetary policy measures, while governments slashed expenditures. In some cases, the decision to increase tax rates further hindered private consumption. Oil exporting countries were among the hardest-hit, given the particularly steep drop in oil prices and the larger levels of dependence in comparison to other commodity-exporting countries. Among importing countries, growth remained robust, if subdued in comparison to the preceding year. Although the lower oil prices have benefitted these countries, such benefits have been partially mitigated by the currency depreciation and the lower prices recorded in other commodities. This adverse economic context hindered the challenge of combating poverty levels, which remains high throughout the region. Although commodity prices have now recovered from the low figures recorded at the start of the year, the expectations are the maintenance of relatively low and volatile prices through the year, which is likely to hinder the economic activity in the region to recover to previously recorded levels. Further constraints may lie in factors such as depreciation of the local currencies, increased inflation rates and the subsequent reduction of purchasing power, high unemployment figures, restrictive monetary policies and a constraining external financial situation. Much of Southern and Eastern Africa face severe droughts, which are likely to impact the price and the availability of food. Such factors will affect the countries in different ways, according to their specific features. Real GDP growth rate % 2015 2016 2017 3.4 3.0 4.0 Oil-importing countries 4.0 3.6 4.4 Oil-exporting countries Sub-Saharan Africa 2.6 2.2 3.4 Angola 3.0 2.5 2.7 Cameroon 5.9 4.9 4.6 Rep. Congo 2.5 4.4 4.3 Nigeria 2.7 2.3 3.5 Source: IMF (Regional Economic Outlook April 2016) We identify both external and internal risks to the economic activity in Sub-Saharan Africa. Concerning external risks, we highlight a potentially steeper economic deceleration in China than expected, a more fragile economic recovery in Europe, increased volatility in the global financial markets (Brexit possibility) and restrictive global financial conditions (for example, in the USA). On the domestic front, delays in adjusting to external shocks may create political uncertainty and impact confidence levels among investors and local agents, which would impact the economic recovery; adverse climate conditions (increasing the inflationary pressures), as well as terrorist threats and/or political unrest, all could negatively impact the economic activity. 5 E.E.F. Angola June 2016 Economic Activity Economic Activity in Angola 2016F 2015E 2014Pr. 2013 2012 2011 2010 The reliance on oil sector revenues, the insufficient Growth in the oil sector (by volume) should surpass degree of diversification of the economic activity and non-oil growth in 2016 the negative effects caused by the external economic (growth rate, %) context, all hindered the Angolan economy in 2015. 12 Although the preliminary data from the Angolan Statistics 10 8 Office has not been published, the Executive estimates that 6 the economy expanded 2.8%1 during the preceding year, a 4 result primarily driven by oil sector. This result stands not only 2 as a sharp drop from the figure placed on the Amending State 0 Budget for 2015 (ASB 2015), when the Executive expected -2 -4 a 6.6% growth rate, but also to the growth rate recorded in -6 2014 (4.8%). Growth in the oil sector, estimated at 6.3%, was driven Oil Sector Non-oil Sector GDP by expanded oil production, whose daily average rose Source: Government 7.6% from 2014 figures and helped offset a 49% drop in oil prices during the same period. This sector’s performance IMF is more pessimistic on the economic activity was a clear departure from the decreasing trajectory recorded growth than the Government in the previous years, when production was hindered by (real GDP growth rate, %) several technical and operational problems in some oil fields, 8 as well as by the delays in initiating some projects. Despite 7 the recorded growth figures, this result is still well below the 6 Executive expectations, as recorded in the ASB 2015 (9.8%), 5 a discrepancy explained by weaker-than-forecasted production 3.3 4 (the Executive predicted an average daily production of 1.83 2.8 3 million barrels, but according to the Ministry of Finance, this 2 figure stood at 1.76 mbd). Production restrictions, technical 1 problems, delays in the start of new projects and instability 0 in new wells at Bloc 17 may have also contributed to these 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015E 2016F results. IMF Government Source: IMF; Government The moderate growth recorded by the Angolan economic activity is linked with the poor performance of the non-oil sector, which decelerated significantly IMF revised downward its forecasts for the Angolan from its 2014 result. Indeed, according to the most recent economic growth government estimates, the “new economy” is expected to (real GDP growth rate, %) have expanded 1.3%, reflecting the deceleration in agriculture, 6.0 fishing, construction and services. More so, it is expected that 5.0 the manufacturing industry contributed negatively to GDP growth. Non-oil industries were hindered by the fall in private 4.0 consumption and public investment, as well as a currency 3.0 shortage. Concerning this point, it is important to highlight the import-focused nature of the Angolan economy, which makes 2.0 the shortage of foreign currency have a stronger impact on 1.0 the country’s ability to obtain consumption goods, industrial 0.0 raw materials, intermediate goods, services and capital goods, 2015E 2016F 2017F 2018F 2019F 2020F which places restrictions on the non-oil sector’s capacity to WEO Oct.2015 WEO Apr.2016 function properly. Source: IMF Taking into account the latest forecasts by the Angolan Executive, the non-oil sector is likely to have accounted for nearly 75% of the domestic output in 2015, with the remainder representing the oil sector. The non-oil sector has, over the past few years, had an increasingly larger contribution to GDP, but this process of diversification has not yet translated into the establishment of activities with exporting potential, capable of generating foreign reserves and reduce the country’s exposure to fluctuations in its oil-related revenues. While some degree of replacement of imports has been recorded, namely in food items, both private consumption and services sector growth generated larger import requirements, without a manufacturing sector capable of offsetting this lack. 1 Linhas Mestras para a Definição de uma Estratégia para a Saída da Crise Derivada da Queda do Preço do Petróleo No Mercado Internacional”, Angolan Republic (January 2016). 6 E.E.F. Angola June 2016 Economic Activity Other economic activity indicators and perspectives for 2016 Q116 Q315 Q115 Q314 Q114 Q313 Q113 Q312 Q112 Q311 Q111 Q310 Q110 Along with the adverse economic environment and The economic climate, as measured by the OECI, subsequent limitations related to the deceleration of deteriorated significantly in 2015 the economy, confidence indicators have registered (points) an unfavorable trajectory through 2015. By the 30 end of the year, the general economic climate indicator 20 dropped significantly below its historical average, a result shared by the sub-indexes related with the manufacturing 10 industry, construction, trade, transports, tourism, mining 0 industry and communication. We highlight three sectors: -10 manufacturing, construction and trade, by the negative -20 results recorded in the last three months of 2015. In -30 manufacturing industry, the businessman revealed a deterioration in financial conditions and shortage of raw materials. In construction, the main restrictive factors were Overall Economic Climate Indicator difficulties in securing credit and lack of demand. In trade, Historical Average Source: INE the business owners cited the excessive bureaucracy and state regulations, as well as financial difficulties and the shortage of stocks. The Angolan economic environment is likely to remain challenging in 2016, given the unlikely possibility that oil prices can return to previous high levels, this while the world economic environment is likely to remain unfavorable. Still, the Executive expects an acceleration of the economic activity for the current year, calling for a GDP expansion of 3.3%, a result primarily driven by increasing dynamism in the non-oil sector. According to the State Budget for 2016 (SB 2016), the Government expects to see the oil sector decelerating to 4.8% in the current year, anticipating an 7.0% increase in oil production to 1.89 mbd, but, in contrast, anticipate a 13% drop in average oil prices in comparison to 2015 (USD 52), to USD 45. Despite this, data published by the Ministry of Finance for the first five months of 2016 note that the average price dropped to USD 34.6, lower than the Executive’s expectations, while oil production, although expanding (1.76 mbd between January and May), is still far from the Executive’s goal. Maintaining this trend, the Government’s forecast for the oil-sector may be overvalued and the overall economic growth may be below the expectation. On the other hand, the Executive expects the non-oil sector to accelerate to 2.7%, boosted by energy and agriculture. Nevertheless, if confirmed this performance, the growth rate should represent a decrease from past growth rates for the sector (between 2008 and 2014, average growth stood above 9%). In agriculture, the sector is likely to benefit from the aids granted and by the beginning of an extensive reform process, which may boost the agricultural production, as well as the reassessment of the production expected in irrigation perimeters in Caxito Rega, Bom Jesus, Calenga e Mucosso. Despite this, agricultural production may still be hard-hit by the droughts currently plaguing several parts of Africa. The latest IMF forecasts are substantially below Government expectation. Indeed, the fund expects GDP growth to decelerate to 2.5% in the current year, from 3.0% in 2015, below the forecasted average growth for the Sub-Saharan Africa region and slightly above the forecasted average growth for the oil exporting countries of the region (2.2%). Real Growth Rates - Angola 2015 2016 2017 IMF 3.0% 2.5% 2.7% Government 2.8% 3.3% - BPI 2.8% 1.2% 2.1% EIU 2.7% 1.1% 3.0% The BPI forecasts for the Angolan economy are more Moody's 3.0% 3.5% 4.0% conservative than the Government and the main S&P 3.5% 3.3% 4.0% international institutions. The drop in oil prices, which has featured prominently since mid-2014, is likely to continue to hinder the Angolan economy, which is adjusting to a “new normal”. Our Brent forecast for 2016 is USD 44 per barrel (on average), close but down from the USD 45 expected by the Executive. More so, oil production, while up during the first four months of the year in comparison to the same period of 2015, remains short of governmental expectations, which may imply that the sector will also fail to meet its production goals for the year. Foreign currency shortages, together with the country’s large import needs, may hinder investment and further delay the diversification process for exports. Even with the IMF support, already requested by the Angolan Government, it’s unlikely that any significant effects from this program will already be noticeable this year, given the sizable challenges the country 7 E.E.F. Angola June 2016 Economic Activity faces, together with the adverse economic climate. Lower oil revenues may also limit the Government’s ability to prop up the economic activity, including the promotion of public investment in infrastructures, restraining the potential of non-oil sector. Lastly, the ongoing adjustment of the Chinese economic growth model is likely to impact Angolan exports for that country, as well as the anemic global economic growth. Main risk factors for economic growth in Angola Internal - External - Maintaining or further decrease of oil prices in the international markets - Steeper economic deceleration in China - Uncertain and volatile global economic and financial background Technical issues related to oil production and LNG Slow implementation of structural reforms Maintaining the downward trend of international reserves Disordely implementation of public expenditure cuts Difficulties in replacing imports Disturbances caused by rapid increase in prices of essential goods Developments in the oil and natural gas markets Oil Production costs per barrel of oil Oil prices have plummeted since mid-2014, dropping to 2003 minimums in the beginning of this year. This development has placed problems for oil-exporting countries, especially those that are most heavily reliant on fiscal and export revenues from the oil sector. These financial woes become even more prominent in countries where the costs of production per barrel of oil are higher. As such, Middle Eastern countries benefit from lower operational and capital expenses, helping to compensate the current downturn in prices. 9.9 8.5 12.3 10.7 17.3 12.6 23.5 20.4 27.8 23.8 29.9 29 35.3 31.5 36.1 35.4 41.1 36.3 52.5 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 48.8 (USD per barrel) Oil prices have been recovering gradually in recent months Angola - Exports and oil prices (USD per barrel) (billion USD; USD) 120 110 100 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 Jun-14 WTI Oct-15 Feb-16 KUW ASAU IRA EAU IRA RUS 120.0 6.0 100.0 80.0 60.0 3.0 Jun-15 ARG 140.0 7.0 4.0 Feb-15 VENEZ 8.0 5.0 Oct-14 LIB CASAQ CHI MEX NIG COL ANG NOR EUA CAN RU BRA Nevertheless, since mid-February this year, Brent prices have recorded a gradual recovery, supported in part by expectations of a deal between the main exporting countries to control production and thus reduce supply and raise prices. Source: Rystad Energy Still, the lack of such a deal in the latest Doha meeting casts a shadow over this strategy. In fact, Russia has constantly surprised the market with successive production increases, coming from the minimum of 6 mbd in the turn of the millennium for almost 11 mbd in 2015. Recently, the country revealed that production would reach 12/13 mbd. It is known that Saudi Arabia has capacity to increase the current production level of 10 mbd to 12 mbd, a level never checked. Additionally, Iran has reaffirmed its intention to expand the oil production and recover the market share lost following the lifting of the sanctions applied by the West. Meanwhile, such concerns have apparently not given pause to investors, with current prices hovering around USD 48/50. 2.0 40.0 1.0 20.0 0.0 0.0 May-12 Jan-13 Sep-13 May-14 Jan-15 Sep-15 May-16 Jun-16 Export Revenues Average price per barrel (RHS) Brent Angola (15-45 Day Forward Strip Price) Source: Bloomberg 8 Source: Ministry of Finance E.E.F. Angola June 2016 Economic Activity According to the International Energy Agency (IEA), global demand growth for oil is expected to recede to 1.3 mbd during 2016, down from the 1.8 mbd figure recorded in 2015. Data released by the agency notes that demand for this commodity during the first quarter of the year stood at 1.6 mbd, while global supply in May decreased by 0.8 mbd, in comparison to the preceding month, reflecting outages in OPEC and non-OPEC countries. OPEC crude output fell by 110,000 barrels per day, explained by big losses in Nigeria. Additionally, output stood 590,000 barrels per day below a year earlier, the first substantial drop since 2013, according to the IEA. Regard to the non-OPEC countries, the IEA expects that oil supply stood at 56.8 mbd in 2016, 0.9 mbd less than the average recorded in 2015. Plummeting oil prices hindered investment in the sector. According to IEA, investment in the sector dropped 40% during the last two years, with the most expressive reductions occurring in the USA, Canada, Latin America and Russia. According to the International Energy Agency, the oil market is expected to rebalance during the next year, assuming that no new market shocks occur. Production cuts are likely to allow for a gradual recovery of oil prices over the next few years, aided by subdued fears related to deceleration in the Chinese economy and stronger investor confidence. Data released by the Angolan Ministry of Finance notes that oil production for the first five months of the year rose 2% to 1.76 mbd, in comparison to the same period of 2015. On the other hand, the average price for Angolan oil during the same period dropped to roughly USD 34.6, down 35% from the figure for the same period of the previous year. Natural Gas A report by the World Bank notes that natural gas prices dropped 15% during the first quarter of the year, primarily due to weaker demand and the high amount of stocks. The institution expects this trend to continue throughout the remainder of 2016, boosted by the significant expected drop in prices in Europe (-38%) and Japan (-23%), maintaining the context of a lower demand for the great amount of available supply. It also expects that growth in the energy sector, export growth and the deceleration of supply growth may support the prices throughout the year. Natural gas prices have followed a downward trend (USD per MMBTU) 14.0 12.0 10.0 8.0 6.0 4.0 2.0 0.0 May-16 Nov-15 May-15 Nov-14 May-14 Nov-13 May-13 Nov-12 May-12 In Angola, Sonangol and other associated companies developed a liquefied natural gas (LNG) project, which aims to harvest the natural gas resulting from oil production and Russian Natural Gas border price in Germany reduce emissions and the greenhouse effect. The factory Source: IMF installed in the Soyo region for this effect begun operations in 2013, stopping in April 2014 following technical issues. Recently, the firm resumed the export of liquefied natural gas shipments. Moreover, an agreement was struck with French energy company EDF to sell and deliver natural gas on destination, starting this year and lasting until 2018. This project has the participation of Sonangol (22.8%), Chevron (36.4%), Eni (13.6%), Total (13.6%) and BP (13.6%). According to statements by the oil Ministry, regular gas prospecting is scheduled to start in July this year, with the latest estimates pointing towards a production capacity of 5.2 million tons per year. According to the World Bank, the estimated economic impact for this project is substantial, possibly adding 2 percentage points on GDP during its debut year, if the project reach the maximum production capacity. Vânia Patrícia Duarte 9 E.E.F. Angola June 2016 Public Finances Budget implementation in 2015 Considering the Angolan State Budget, the oil sector retains a sizeable weight on the revenue side. As such, given the low oil prices in the international markets throughout 2015, total tax revenue recorded a 26% drop in comparison to 2014, in line with a 46% drop in oil revenues, according to the figures inscribed in the State Budget for 2016 (SB 2016). Considering the historical trend, oil tax revenues has accounted for roughly 70% of all collected revenue during the past six years. On the other hand, non-oil tax revenue improved in comparison to 2014, a result driven by the Government’s efforts to consolidate the non-oil tax base, with measures which include the expansion of tax base, the increase in tax inspections, improvement in housing taxation and the creation of the General Tax Administration. Nevertheless, implementation failed to meet the Executive’s goals, highlighting the difficulty to diversify the Government’s revenue sources. The two main reasons include the weaker tax collection on sales of goods & services (53% implementation) and on international trade (57% implementation), according to the figures in SB 2016. The level of reliance on oil tax revenue limited the Executive’s spending capacity, which explains a spending cut of about 27%. On current expenditure, a substantial drop in spending on goods & services and current transfers are likely to offset increases in spending for salaries and interest payments, according to the figures inscribed in the SB 2016. Regarding current transfers, this decrease is mainly explained by a reduction in subsidies, due to the gradual phasing out of the fuel subsidies, ongoing since September 2014, with this item dropping from 13% of total expenditure in 2014 to only 6% in 2015. Increasing interest payments, on the other hand, is mainly related to growing government debt, together with the devaluation of the domestic currency. The noticeable disparity between budgeted and implemented capital expenditure (the degree of implementation reached 170%) is evidence not only of the exchange rate adjustments that followed the Amending Budget publication in 2015 , but also the additional budgetary slack granted by funding agreements for infrastructural projects secured throughout the year. The Budget implementation for 2015 reveals an undervaluation of public revenue, as has been the case in previous years. Considering the already conservative average oil price assumed by the Executive, one could likely expect that implemented revenue for 2015 would surpass those forecasted in the Amending State Budget. Indeed, the average oil barrel price was 30% above the USD 40 assumed for the ASB for 2015, which translates into an oil revenue 56% above budget estimates. This result also reflects an excessively cautious approach to the marginal tax collection rate per unit of oil. Expenditure surpassed budgeted expectations, namely due to interest payments and current expenditure. On the same note, capital expenditure rose well above expectations, likely due to additional spending following the Government securing additional loans with multiple international institutions during 10 Lower oil prices represent a challenge to Angolan public finances (fiscal balance, % GDP) 12.0% 10.0% 8.0% 6.0% 4.0% 2.0% 0.0% -2.0% -4.0% -6.0% -8.0% 8.1% 10.3% 6.7% 0.3% -4.5% -6.6% 2010 Budgeted 2011 2012 2013 Executed 2014 Pr 2015 ASB Source: Ministry of Finance Breakdown of total revenues (% total revenues) 7% 2014 2015 13% 50% 26% 37% 67% Oil Non-oil Other Source: Ministry of Finance Phasing out fuel subsidies has lead to a reduction of the weight of subsidies in fiscal expenditure (% total expenditure; % GDP) 16% 7% 14% 6% 12% 5% 10% 4% 8% 3% 6% 4% 2% 2% 1% 0% 2012 2013 2014 Weight on total expenditure Weight on GDP (RHS) 2015 0% Source: Ministry of Finance; BPI cal. E.E.F. Angola June 2016 Public Finances the second half of the year. Given this results, the fiscal deficit Revenue path signals weak diversification of the tax ratio in percentage of GDP is expected to stand at 4.5%, base; expenditure adjusts to the context down from the 7.0% forecasted by the ASB for 2015. This (% GDP) represents a 2.1 percentage points (p.p.) improvement 60% from the 2014 result, when the declining trend for oil prices first started, with the global balance receding by 50% 30%, reflecting a more restrictive fiscal policy than in the 40% preceding year, in line with the global goals of economic policies in this phase, aiming to adjust demand to a more 30% adverse global background. 20% State Budget for 2016 10% 0% The State Budget for 2016 assumes an average oil price 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 of USD 45 per barrel, down from the USD 52 recorded Revenue Expenditure Source: Ministry of Finance; BPI cal. in 2015. The Executive expect oil production to expand to 1.89 mbd during the year, while oil tax revenue is expected to grow 5% in comparison to 2015, this while non-oil revenue is expected to expand 28%. Despite this, analysis of the data Macroeconomic assumptions regarding oil revenue during the first five months of 2015, and 2013 2014 2015 2015 2016 assuming this pace of production for the remainder of the year, Exec. Prel. SB ASB SB 107.7 96.9 81.0 40.0 45.0 makes it likely that the degree of revenue implementation will Oil price per barrel (USD) 107.5 100.7 51.7 33.3 fall significantly short of the Executive’s goals (according to Average price recorded Average daily oil production (mbd) 1.72 1.67 1.83 1.83 1.89 our calculations, the implementation rate should be around Real GDP growth rate (%) 6.8% 4.8% 9.7% 6.6% 3.3% 70%). Still, it is worth noting that the first two months of the Oil Sector -0.9% -2.6% 10.7% 9.8% 4.8% year saw what are likely to be the lowest oil prices for 2016 Non-Oil Sector 10.9% 8.2% 9.2% 5.3% 2.7% 7.7% 7.5% 7.0% 9.0% 11-13% and, as such, oil revenue is likely to surpass our estimates. Inflation – end of period (%) Ministry of Finance. Concerning non-oil tax revenue, the figure forecasted by the Source: Notes: Reference price for State Budget deliberation; Average price for a barrel of Angolan oil; Executive is possibly too optimistic, given a likely cool down Average price for the first quarter of 2016 of the economic activity in 2016. This significant improvement expected by the Executive may be related to an overvaluation of taxes collected on goods & services and international trade, as was the case in 2015. 1) 2) 1) 3) 2) 3) Heavy reliance on the oil sector impacts the performance of public finances On the expenditure side, the Executive expects to see an increase from the previous year’s implementation. (% GDP; USD per barrel) Nevertheless, as was the case in previous years, the degree 12% 120 of expenditure implementation could be limited, which would 10% 100 8% drive expenditure below budgeted. This is a likely scenario as 6% 80 some of the implementation at least partially depend on the 4% Government’s ability to secure external funding, particularly in 60 2% the case of capital expenditure. The Executive expects interest 0% 40 payments to continue to expand due to the devaluation of the -2% 20 Kwanza and increasing government debt. As such, the fiscal -4% deficit is expected to reach Kz 781 billion, or -5.5% of -6% 0 GDP, which would represent a deterioration of the budget Fiscal Balance Oil price (RHS) Source: Ministry of Finance balance in comparison to the preceding year. The non-oil fiscal deficit is expected to be even more significant, with the current forecast placing it at -23% of non-oil GDP, which calls for further diversification of the revenue sources and the need for tighter expenditure policies and monitoring. The deterioration of the public finances is also forecasted by the IMF. Indeed, this institution wrote in its most recent Regional Economic Outlook (April 2016) that it expects a deterioration of the fiscal balance to -7.1% of GDP in 2016, from -4.1% of GDP in 2015, while the following year should see a 1 p.p. reduction. Oil prices are expected to remain subdued throughout the year, thus continuing to pressure the Angolan public finances. This environment will force the Executive to prioritize public investment and highlight the need for tighter monitoring of the investment projects. More so, we note the Government’s intention to follow through with phasing out all fuel subsidies and use the low oil prices currently in practice to soften the impact of these measure on the lower classes. In this case, it is central the need to improve the social assistance for the most disadvantaged, the more affected by the increase in fuels prices. 11 E.E.F. Angola June 2016 Public Finances The significant drop in oil prices has driven a sizeable reduction of collected tax revenue Budget Balance – Sub-Saharan Africa (million USD) (% GDP, including grants) 3,500 2015 2016 2017 3,000 Sub-Saharan Africa -4.1 -4.6 -4.1 2,500 Oil-importing countries -4.1 -3.9 -3.5 2,000 Oil-exporting countries -4.1 -5.5 -4.7 Angola -4.1 -7.1 -6.1 Cameroon -5.7 -7.9 -6.5 -11.8 -12.6 -5.7 Equatorial Guinea -3.0 -8.1 -10.3 Nigeria -4.0 -4.7 -4.3 1,500 1,000 500 Rep. Congo 0 May-14 IRP IPP Nov-14 ITP May-15 Nov-15 May-16 Revenues from concessionary Source: IMF (Regional Economic Outlook April 2016). Source: Ministry of Finance Risk factors for the performance of public finances in 2016 Internal - Economic activity slowdown - Exchange rate behaviour - Domestic oil market developments External - International oil market developments - Volatility and uncertainty in the international financial markets - Easiness to get external funding Government Debt The lower amount of taxes collected will increase the Government’s reliance on debt to finance its expenditure plans. According with the SB 2016, the deficit will be entirely covered by external sources, a measure justified by the need to safeguard the international reserves. As stated in the SB for 2016, we are seeing a reduction of funding secured through the use of credit lines, which contrasts with increased disbursement associated with projects. As such, it is likely that the Government expects to secure funding from the international organizations, in order to fulfil priority projects, namely those aimed at diversifying the economic activity. Public Debt Public Debt (million USD) % GDP External (million USD) % GDP Internal (million USD) % GDP 2013 Exec 2014 Prel 2015 Est. 2016 SB 30.6 39.3 41.0 49.2 24.5 31.0 40.5 49.7 15.7 20.2 23.4 30.8 12.6 15.9 23.2 31.1 14.9 19.1 17.6 18.4 12.0 15.1 17.4 18.6 Source: State Budget 2016. 12 2021F 2020F 2019F 2018F 2017F 2016F 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 The Executive expects government debt to reach USD 49 billion in 2016, nearing 50% of GDP (this excluding debt owned by Sonangol, which, according to the IMF in IMF expects that public debt ratio should reach the last November, amounted to 15% of GDP). This increase is sustainability threshold this year caused, primarily, by increasing external debt, which is expected (gross public debt, % GDP) to expand to 31.1% this year, from 23.2% of GDP in 2015, 80 according to the SB 2016 (domestic debt is also expected to Public debt sustainability limit: 70% 70 expand to 18.6% in 2016, from 17.4% in 2015). Additionally, 60 the Executive is considering a return to the international markets 50 this year, aiming to diversify its sources of funding. At the time 40 of the SB 2016 draft, there was still no information regarding the 30 financial assistance programme requested by the Government 20 to the IMF and, as such, government debt is likely to expand 10 further due to the inclusion of any financial assistance granted 0 by the programme. Also worth noting is Angola’s debut on the international securities markets last November, when it issued sovereign debt under the form of Eurobonds, amounting to USD Source: IMF 1.5 billion. Bonds issued have a 10-year maturity and a yield of 9.5%, with demand exceeding supply five times. Issuing the E.E.F. Angola June 2016 Public Finances debt in dollars served as a natural protection against the risk Trajectory of public debt ratio in percentage of GDP of exchange rate fluctuations, as oil revenues are denominated using the North-American currency. (% GDP) IMF, on the other hand, performed a significant review of its forecasts for the trend of government debt. In November 2015, during its article IV review, the IMF expected government debt to reach 57.4% of GDP in 2015, followed by a reduction to 53% of GDP the following year. The more recent Regional Economic Outlook for April this year tough, places government debt at 62.3% of GDP in 2015, and expects this figure to expand to 70.1% during 2016. Note that these figures include both government debt and debt owed by state-owned organizations and the country’s airline carrier (Sonangol and TAAG, respectively). Note also that this reading far exceeds forecasted debt levels for the rest of the region and, should they come to pass, would place Angola at the sustainability threshold for government debt in 2016, placed at 70%. 80 60 40 20 0 2013 2014 Sub-Sah. Africa. Angola 2015 2016 2017 Sub-Sah.Africa Exporters Source: IMF The expansion of government debt recorded over the past few years is owed not only to the need to fund public deficits, but also to the devaluation of the domestic currency, which impacts debt issued in foreign currency. Such debt is expected to amount to 63% of all government debt, representing a 5 p.p. increase from 2015 preliminary findings (according to the State Budget for 2016). Concerning domestic debt, the Executive expects the opposite, forecasting a 6 p.p. reduction to roughly 17% of GDP. Government debt level remains susceptible to shocks, particularly those related to economic growth, exchange rates and international oil prices. This calls for an urgent consolidation of the public finances, with measures aimed at the non-oil sector, as well as the better rationing of Government expenditure, including the maintenance of the phase-out process for fuel subsidies, improvements to capital investment and cost-cutting measures aimed at public service salaries. More so, it is important to note that Angola owns a more comfortable financial buffer than during the 2009 oil shock, which includes the Angolan Sovereign Fund (USD 5 billion). Moody’s notes that the full buffer should amount to USD 14/15 billion or 12% of the estimated GDP for 2015. Sources: Relatório de Fundamentação do Orçamento Geral do Estado para 2016; Mnistry of Finance; Regional Economic Outlook – FMI (April 2016); Artigo IV – FMI (November 2015). Vânia Patrícia Duarte 13 E.E.F. Angola June 2016 Angola assessment by the Rating Agencies As expected, the constraints affecting the Angolan economy have weighted into the reviews performed by the major rating agencies, particularly the low oil price environment and its consequences. Standard & Poor’s, whose rating for Angola was reviewed down in February, has the most negative perspective of the big-three, placing the rating at B, 5 degrees below the waterline between investment and speculative grades. The agency considers that forecasts pointing to a longer period of low oil prices will further destabilize the country, on both the budget front and the external balance and believes that public funding needs, together with the devaluation of the kwanza, will increase the Angolan debt burden. Despite this, the outlook was determined “stable”, considering that the current account deficit is expected to gradually decrease over the medium term, reducing risks associated with external funding, while expected Government action could prevent further deterioration of the budget deficit and debt burden. Fitch places its rating at B+, one grade above S&P’s, maintaining this rating at its March 25th review, although the outlook was updated to “negative”. The agency also sees the large decrease in oil prices, together with the still-high dependency of the Angolan economy on oil revenues, as catalysts for further deterioration to the country’s macroeconomic, budgetary and external situation, increasing downward risks for the Angolan economy. Fitch also notes, positively, the adequate and expedient response to the oil shock, which allowed to soften the decrease in international reserves, however it expects that with oil prices remaining historically low, further erosion might be unavoidable, which would lead to a rating downgrade. Lastly, Moody’s proceeded to downgrade its debt rating this past April, going from Ba2 to B1, placing it on level with Fitch. Rating agencies' forecasts for 2016 Explaining this decision, Moody’s also noted the deterioration variable Fitch 2.5 of the country’s financial and external situation due to the GDP Growth (%) 4.6 low oil prices. More so, Moody’s stressed the low forecasts for Fiscal Deficit (% do GDP) 57.0 economic growth in Angola, given that large growth rates had Public Debt (% GDP) 35.0 been one of the main supports for the country’s credit quality Oil price (USD) Current account deficit (% GDP) 8.4* in the recent past. Like Fitch, Moody’s also placed the outlook Rating B+ at “negative”, noting the devaluation pressures affecting the Outlook kwanza, which may create further difficulties to the country’s Date for the next review 23/09/2016 balance of payments. Nevertheless, Moody’s views the start Sources: Fitch, Moody's, S&P's of negotiations with IMF as a positive step, given that these Note: *(incl. FDI) may lead to a financial package that would not only support the country’s foreign reserves, but also assist in the Government’s efforts towards adjusting the economy to the new context and Hydrocarbon Exports solve structural problems affecting the Angolan economy. In comparison to other African oil-producing countries, and according to an evaluation conducted by Moody’s1, the issues affecting Angola’s external equilibria and real economy are the most worrisome, rather than the Angolan public finances. Moody's S&P's 3.5 3.3 1.8 5.5 53.3 50.0 33.0 40.0 6.8 10.0 B1 B - = 05/08/2016 12/08/2016 (percentage of export of goods) On one hand, Angola’s growth rate is expected to record a steeper decline than other countries in similar situations, given that natural gas and oil together represent 97% of all exports and 45% of the GDP. More so, the goal of reaching a production rate of 2 mbpd is likely out of reach until 2020 at the earliest. Contrary to this, Nigeria is in a much more resilient position, with 90% of its economy relating to the non-oil sector, while the Rep. of Congo, facing similar constraints as Angola due to low diversification, is succeeding (for the time being) in increasing its oil production. 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 2015 Angola 2016 Nigeria Rep.Congo 2017 Gabon Source: IMF, BPI cal. With that said, Angola’s most pressing matter in comparison with similar countries relates to its external position: although its export revenues denominated in USD, along with the currency buffer, provide a good guarantee of solvency, the devaluation pressures impacting the kwanza make it so that the weight of the country’s debt denominated in USD (which should reach 59% of GDP in 2016) may increase significantly. More so, external imbalances also impact the current account balance, which decreased from a 6.8% of GDP surplus in 2013 to a 5.7% deficit last year. Nigeria faces somewhat similar problems, with devaluation pressures on the Naira straining the country’s foreign reserves and its economy posting the Key drivers of rating actions on four African sovereigns, concluding reviews for downgrade, Moody’s Investor Service 1 14 E.E.F. Angola June 2016 Angola assessment by the Rating Agencies first current account deficit in 10 years in 2015 (3% of the GDP). Meanwhile, regarding the Rep. of Congo, despite also being affected in its current account balance by the low oil prices, the consequences for this country are lessened, mainly because it benefits from the protection from devaluation pressures granted by being a member of the Central African Economic and Monetary Community and sharing the Franc CFA with several countries. International Reserves Current Account Balance (months of imports) (% GDP) 10 0 8 -5 6 -10 4 -15 2 -20 0 2015 2016 Angola Nigeria -25 2015 2017 Rep.Congo 2016 Angola Gabon Nigeria 2017 Rep.Congo Source: IMF Gabon Fonte: FMI On the other hand, when comparing the situation in public finances, Angola compares favourably with these two economies. While it is true that 2015 recorded a budget deficit, it is important to note that this follows a string of surpluses lasting until 2013. As such, Moody’s notes that despise subdued non-oil revenue (non-oil tax revenue on the non-oil GDP amounted only to 13%, according to latest budget execution data), the rapid adjustment of the Angolan Executive in terms of spending cuts should allow for only small deficits to be recorded during the next few years. Inversely, the Rep. of Congo is likely to have its debt increase significantly (from 20.9% of GDP in 2013 to 54.5% in 2016), primarily due to the lower oil revenues which will drive budget deficits upwards (16% in 2016, 11% in 2017). Concerning the scenario for the Nigerian economy, despite an expansionist budget for the current year, which will see the deficit reach 3.7% of GDP, the low levels of debt (16% of GDP) will continue to justify rating stability, with Nigeria being the only of these 3 economies to retain a “stable” outlook by Moody’s. Regarding the implicit spread on debt issued with a Spread on 10-year debt* 10-year maturity, we note that the risk premium for Angola rose until February this year, before adopting a (basis points) downward trajectory. This trajectory is particularly related to the oil price’s fluctuations towards a base level that brought 1,200 1,100 risk premiums closer to those reported for Nigeria, although 1,000 Angola retains the largest risk premium for countries with similar 900 characteristics (around 800 basis points). 800 700 600 500 400 Nov-15 Dec-15 Angola Jan-16 Nigeria Feb-16 Mar-16 Apr-16 May-16 Gabon * Implicit spread on 10-year debt denominated in USD traded in the Source: Bloomberg, BPI cal. José Miguel Cerdeira 15 E.E.F. Angola June 2016 Finantial and Monetary Sector Exchange Policy and Inflation Inflation For this year, and keeping with the trend observed since the second half of 2015, the year-on-year inflation rate kept at double-digit figures, with monthly changes of the annual inflation rate (as measured by the Luanda CPI) averaging 300 basis points (b.p.). Indeed, inflation has expanded from 12.4% last October to 29.2% in May. Note that the inflation rate for Angola had not surpassed the 20% mark since September 2005, back when the normalization process was still underway, following the end of the civil war in 2002. One of the main reasons behind these inflationary pressures relates to the gradual devaluation of the Angolan currency against the US Dollar, which started discreetly between September and October last year, picking up the pace last January (see box). Also contributing to this effect was a new round of fuel subsidy cuts at the end of the year, which impacted not only fuel prices, but several other goods, due to higher transportation costs. Domestic gas prices were also raised during this period, as well as fees for water and electricity in Luanda and Benguela. Another reason lies in the increase of the consumption tax in September, which affected several domestic goods, including water (to 65%, from 20%), beer (to 60%, from 20%) and cigarettes (to 65% from 30%), along with the introduction of a 5% levy on gasoline and diesel. Additionally, it was recorded a slight increase to the import tax, which increased, in the cases of water, beer and cigarettes, to 40%, 60% and 80%, from 10%, 20% and 30%, respectively. We note a certain degree of protectionist bias applied to these taxation changes, which clearly favours goods produced domestically, something in line with the general strategy of economic diversification. As such, prices for food & non-alcoholic beverages (which have a high import percentage) have contributed substantially to inflation growth: over the past 12 months, this category has been responsible for an average of 45.1% of inflation in the country, with fuel, housing and utilities accounting for 11.4% of price growth. It is also worth noting that the Executive’s strategy of restricting import activity as a way to halt the loss of foreign reserves has led to scarcity for select products with little to no domestic production, which in turn drove prices upwards. (yoy%; mom%) 35.0% 4.0% 30.0% 3.2% 25.0% 20.0% 2.4% 15.0% 1.6% 10.0% 0.8% 5.0% 0.0% May-14 Nov-14 Monthly (RHS) May-15 Nov-15 0.0% May-16 Annual Source: INE Changes in consumption tax rates Assets Domestic production Imports Before After Before After Water 10% 40% 10% 30% Juice 10% 40% 10% 20% Beer 20% 60% 20% 60% Whisky 30% 70% 30% 45% Champagne 30% 55% 30% 45% Cigarettes 30% 80% 30% 65% Perfumes 30% 40% - - Petrol - - - 5% Diesel - - - 5% Source: KPMG Angola. Inflation by class of goods (May) Class Average Weight in inflation in last 12 months Annual Inflation 45.1% 26.6% Alcoholic Beverages & Tobacco 3.6% 37.9% Clothing & Footwear 6.1% 19.3% 11.4% 31.6% Furnit. & Household equip. 6.9% 26.4% Health 5.4% 56.6% Transports 5.8% 28.6% Communication 0.1% 1.0% Leisure & Culture 1.6% 21.6% Education 1.4% 33.6% Restaurants & Hotels 3.3% 26.2% Other goods & services 9.1% 38.3% Food & non-alcoholic beverages Hous., Water, Elect., Fuel Source: INE, BPI calc. During 2016, we expect inflation growth to remain high, with the possibility of a downward trajectory starting during the second half of the year. It is somewhat possible that the average price growth for the whole year may be around 30%. The one-off nature of some taxes, as well as the end of the phase-out process for the subsidies, lends credence to the notion that some of the strongest inflationary pressures may diminish in the next months. Nevertheless, the role of fuel as a raw material means that its impact on inflation growth will be prolonged by secondary effects. More so, the trend adopted by the inflation rate in the long term will depend on multiple factors, namely the value of the Kwanza, as a large devaluation will increase inflation due to pricier imports. Even so, recent policies adopted by the BNA allows us to predict that, on one hand, currency fluctuations will be more gradual and, on the other hand, these pressures will be offset by probable new increases in the BNA interest rate (the last increase took place in April, to 14%, from 12%), in an attempt to discourage consumption and foster savings. Also, several measures undertaken by the Executive may also 16 E.E.F. Angola June 2016 Finantial and Monetary Sector have positive results, namely its program aimed at combating price speculation. The main aim of such policies is to avoid the sale at higher prices in the informal market. One of the requirements for traders is that prices are available and public before sale, something which still does not occur. Possible effects on inflation of a prolonged devaluation of the kwanza Inflation in Angola has adopted an upward trend in Inflation recent months, with one of the main reasons being the devaluation of the kwanza against other currencies: (yoy%; average annual inflation rate, forecast after May) given the sizeable component of imports in multiple kinds of 70% 35.0% goods, any currency devaluation will lead to pricier imports, 60% 30.0% which will impact the inflation rate both directly and through 50% secondary effects, mainly when the imported goods are raw 25.0% 40% 30% materials or equipment, which entry in the production costs 20.0% 20% of firms. The so-called exchange rate “pass-through” is a 15.0% 10% ratio that determines how a currency’s valuation/depreciation 0% 10.0% impacts the domestic price’s variation, as a percentage of BPI Forecast -10% 5.0% -20% the currency fluctuation. Pass-through estimates for African 0.0% -30% countries tend to hover around 40%1 , which means that Mar-13 Dec-13 Sep-14 Jun-15 Mar-16 Dec-16 a 10% devaluation will reflect in a 4% change in domestic Effective Exchange rate devaluation prices. In Angola, the devaluation of the kwanza translated 12-month average of inflation into a 10% devaluation of the effective exchange rate in 2015, Source: INE, Bloomberg, BPI cal. and, according to preliminary BPI calculations (which assume a distribution of international trade by partners similar to the end of 2015), this figure has now expanded to 26% during this year and until May. Beyond the influence of the effective exchange rate, Angolan prices are most likely being impacted by spillovers from the parallel exchange market, which must also be taken into account. Note that this exchange rate has also evidenced the devaluation of the kwanza, which may have lost 15% of its value during the first quarter. kwanzas per USD The ongoing shortage of foreign currency, due to lower Kwanza Exchange Rate oil export revenues, has driven much of the pressure for the devaluation of the kwanza, with the BNA performing (USD/AOA; EUR/AOA) several discrete devaluations of the Angolan currency (32% devaluation in 2015, 23% since the beginning of 180 this year and until June). By January 4th, the BNA fixed 170 the exchange rate against the US Dollar at 156.36 USD/AOA, 160 150 a 15% devaluation which followed other, less pronounced, 140 devaluations. The current exchange rate against the US 130 Dollar is now at its lowest reading ever recorded: USD/ 120 AOA 166.71. 110 Considering that the Angolan economy is still significantly reliant on the use of USD (and, more recently, the euro), together with the ongoing difficulties in securing foreign reserves and the need to further adjust internal demand to the scenario of lower oil revenues, it is likely that the trend of currency devaluation will continue: pointing to this scenario, the spread between the official and parallel exchange rates for the USD (in percentage of the official rate), has fluctuated between 73.0% and 171.7% between November 100 90 Jun-14 USD/AOA Dec-14 Jun-15 EUR/AOA (RHS) Dec-15 200 190 180 170 160 150 140 130 120 110 100 Jun-16 kwanzas per EUR Our calculations, assuming a possible devaluation of the Angolan currency, indicate that average price fluctuation for 2016 may be close to 30%, with the possibility of some deceleration towards the end of the year. Source: Bloomberg, BNA Razafimahefa (2012) indica este valor como a média para várias economias da África subsariana, mas outros estudos indicam valores relativamente próximos. De acordo com o nosso estudo econométrico, o pass-through do câmbio efectivo (excluindo o câmbio paralelo) será de 38%. 1 17 E.E.F. Angola June 2016 Finantial and Monetary Sector 2015 and last March, this while the spread stood at a mere 25% in 2014. Also pointing to this scenario is the fact that for multiple weeks in 2016, the BNA has refrained from conducting any foreign currency auctions for commercial banks. Still, it is likely that these devaluations will proceed in a gradual manner and in combination with reference rate increases, as a way to diminish the impact on the inflation rate. This was one of recommendations made by the IMF in its Article IV review, last November. Also, we can expect the moderate use of foreign reserves to soften the devaluation of the kwanza, as such reserves have been gradually reduced, with the latest readings recording a stabilization around USD 24 billion (in May, the net international reserves stood at USD 24.4 bn). In an economic strategy planning document dated on February 20162, the Executive noted that it expects the difference between foreign currency bought by the BNA and foreign currency sold to the banks will reach USD 4.6 billion, a difference that will be compensated through the use of reserves in equal amount. Also, in order to soften the social impact of foreign currency shortages, Angola has adopted several priority criteria in obtaining foreign currency, giving preference to food, medicine, agricultural and industrial imports, along with the oil sector. Also, the Government has placed restrictions on the amount of currency allowed to move out of the country. We note that despite the Government’s intentions of guaranteeing crucial imports, such measures may also hinder the economy’s ability to function properly. Gap between official and informal exchange rates Net International Reserves (USD/AOA; % of official exchange rate) (million USD) 40,000 200% 180 180% 170 160% 160 140% 150 120% 140 100% 130 80% 120 60% 110 40% 100 20% 0% 90 Apr-14 Oct-14 Apr-15 Oct-15 Apr-16 Spread in percentage of exchange rate (RHS) kwanzas per USD 35,000 USD/AOA 30,000 25,000 20,000 15,000 10,000 5,000 0 May-13 Feb-14 Nov-14 Aug-15 May-16 Source: BNA Source: Bloomberg, BNA Monetary Policy The BNA has adopted a restrictive monetary policy since Monetary policy reference rates the second half of 2015, in order to moderate inflation growth, which surpassed significantly the 7%-9% range (percentage) defined by the Central Bank. Aiming for a holistic monetary and exchange policy that combats the issue of foreign currency 18.0% scarcity, while at the same time preventing unrestrained 16.0% 14.0% inflation, the BNA has performed 5 increases to the BNA rate 12.0% (the reference rate for Angola) in 2015, from 9% to 11%. 10.0% 8.0% This followed two subsequent increases in February and March 6.0% 2016, to 12% and 14%, respectively. The marginal lending 4.0% rate has also been raised, being placed at a fixed 200 basis 2.0% points from the BNA rate and following the latter’s trajectory 0.0% May-14 Nov-14 May-15 Nov-15 since September. On the other hand, the mandatory reserves Benchmark rate (BNA rate) coefficient has remained stable at 25% since June 2015. For Standing liquidity absorption facility rate the remainder of the year, we expect the monetary Standing lending facility rate LUIBOR Overnight policy to remain restrictive, given the adverse scenario caused by the low oil prices still in effect, as well as the need to contain aggregate demand and halt the climb of the inflation rate. Following the agreement for the IMF May-16 Source: BNA “Linhas Mestras para a Definição de uma Estratégia para a Saída da Crise Derivada da Queda do Preço do Petróleo No Mercado Internacional”, República de Angola (Janeiro de 2016). 2 18 E.E.F. Angola June 2016 Finantial and Monetary Sector intervention, we expect the Executive to follow these guidelines, along with the fund’s recommendations to raise transparency standards for the country’s monetary policy: the international institution stressed the need for anchors that guide monetary policy. Angola has also implemented additional measures, such as the prioritization of key sectors and needs, which will be granted priority in currency auctions. According to the Executive, its intention is to rationalize the distribution of foreign currency in order to maximize several factors: employment (primarily in the oil sector), inflation control (to guarantee the viability of food imports), healthcare, education and key public expenses. This strategy has, nevertheless, resulted in deeper scarcity of foreign currency for commercial bank operations, with some of the latest auctions seeing the vast majority of the auctioned currency being secured by state-owned companies, including the Angolan airline company TAAG and the public TV station TPA. In the future, according to the Executive’s planning, we are likely to see the introduction of incentives aimed at fostering credit granted to the manufacturing sector by the commercial banks, although details of such measures are still unknown. In the interbank market, LUIBOR rates have remained high, with the overnight rate recording an increase of 300 basis points since last April, which drove subsequent increases in all other rates. The multiple rates have climbed upwards since 2015, particularly following a large and abrupt increase of the overnight rate in June 2015. Last May, the overnight rate stood at 14%, with the remaining rates all recording larger readings and adopting growth trajectories. In April 2016, the M1, M2 and M3 monetary aggregates recorded year-on-year increases between 25% and 26%, a result in line with the annual inflation for the month (26.3%). Credit granted to the economy (in kwanzas) rose 25.5% yoy in the same month, while deposits rose 26.4% yoy. Circulation in USD remains an important part of the Angolan economy, as evidenced by the fact that even following significant reductions until 2014, in the last months, the percentage of deposits and credit granted to the economy in foreign currencies has kept between 33-36% and 27-29%, respectively. Deposits and Credit (million AOA) 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Jan-2016 Monetary Base 1,275,119 1,323,583 1,392,045 1,580,641 1,675,454 1,807,230 M1 2,155,799 2,271,912 2,584,637 3,096,862 3,419,821 3,616,645 M2-M1 1,365,085 1,477,106 1,810,107 2,006,621 2,283,924 2,327,026 M3-M2 152,227 134,019 1,936 6,633 8,155 9,829 2.88 2.93 3.16 3.23 3.41 3.29 2,136,279 2,647,774 2,926,430 2,946,702 3,469,354 3,573,845 - 23.9% 10.5% 0.7% 17.7% 20.1% Money Multiplier (M3/BM) Credit to the economy Change rate % GDP Deposits Change rate % GDP 20.5 22.1 21.2 19.3 28.2 25.9 3,312,486 3,504,768 4,119,193 4,763,815 5,323,043 5,604,962 - 5.8% 17.5% 15.6% 11.7% 18.7% 31.8 29.3 29.9 31.2 43.2 40.7 Source: BNA Note: Nominal GDP - INE until 2013 and IMF's forecasts for 2014-2016. José Miguel Cerdeira 19 E.E.F. Angola June 2016 Banking situation in Angola Balance 2015 The structure of assets in the banking sector underlines a trajectory of credit replacement for the last three years (whose weight on total assets has dropped 12 p.p. to 45.7%), contrarily to government bonds, whose weight rose 8 p.p. to 26% of all assets. This situation reflects not only the high risks associated with private sector credit, the lack of transparency and judicial protection, but also the high degree of attractiveness generated by the Treasury Bonds, whose yields to maturities of 91, 181 and 364 days have all recorded increases in 2015, of 7.46 p.p., 7.84 p.p. and 5.12 p.p., respectively. This development, together with the existence of some default risk in the interbank money market (IMM), have also caused sizeable drops in the volume of interbank transactions, with the indicator for Liquidity Swap Operations dropping roughly 57% in 2015. The tendency towards a large concentration of the banking sector has decreased moderately. Until late 2014, the 5 major banks accounted for over 70% of total assets and credit granted. In 2015 though, despite some efforts towards reducing concentration, this figure is still above 60%. The degree of deposit concentration also receded, dropping 3.8 p.p. to 67.6%, while the drop in credit granted was less pronounced (1.5 p.p. to 68.7%). The same course was observed in the bonds market (own and client portfolio), with the 5 major banks concentrating 74% of the market in 2015 (80% in 2014). Deposits, credit and loan-to-deposit ratio (mil milhões de Kwanzas; %) 6,000 80% 5,000 60% 4,000 3,000 40% 2,000 20% 1,000 0% 0 Dec-13 Apr-14 Aug-14 Dec-14 Apr-15 Aug-15 Dec-15 Deposits Credit to non-financial sector Loan-to-deposit ratio Source: BNA Banking Structure - Assets (billion AOA) 10,000 On an annual basis, deposits and credit recorded growth rates of 14% and 2% in 2015, respectively. Deposits in the domestic currency expanded 16.2% during the year, against a 9.1% increase in deposits denominated in foreign currency. The rate of change in credit recorded a curious decrease of 5.2% in its domestic currency section, against an 18.7% rise in credit granted in foreign currency. This behaviour is primarily explained by the currency exchange effect, particularly the devaluation of the domestic currency observed in the preceding year. The credit/deposits ratio, whose reading recorded a high of 65.5% in late 2012, has adopted a downward trajectory, ending 2015 at 59% (-6.5p.p.). Despite this low reading, the ratio for credit in default remains above 15%, which, according to Moody’s methodology, is considered “weak”. The high degree of sectorial concentration in the credit market and the subsequent effects on the reduction of public expenditure for 2015 may partially explain this degree of exposure. Merely 4 sectors (Trade, Private, Housing and Construction) concentrate over 64% of all credit granted to the economy in 2015, 0.5 p.p. above the figure for 2014 (and 7.3 p.p. above the level recorded in 2011). The main indicators for the financial system published by the BNA (see table) sugest some caution. The solvency ratio, while above the legal minimum of 10%, dropped to 19.8% in last December, this following a 22% high recorded in February. Despite this, the excessive exposure of the economy to the oil 20 8,000 6,000 4,000 2,000 0 Dec-14 Apr-15 Aug-15 Loans Bonds Deposits Other assets Dep.Non-resid. Currency Equity & other part. Dec-15 Source: BNA Banking Structure - Liabilities (billion AOA) 6,500 5,500 4,500 3,500 2,500 1,500 500 -500 Dec-14 Mar-15 Jun-15 Sep-15 Transf.Dep. Oth. Dep Bonds Repurc.Agreem. Reserves & Capital Other Dec-15 Source: BNA E.E.F. Angola June 2016 Banking situation in Angola sector (who is primarily responsible for slowing the growth rate for long term deposits and increasing the probability of default by the bank’s debtors) may have effects on the decreasing capital base, due to the deterioration of the quality of assets. The asset liquidity ratio dropped to 39.7% in December, this after reaching 42.4% in July 2015 (a 5-year high). This scenario may lead to a reduced capacity by the banks to honour their commitments in the short term, given that the ratio for liquid assets over short term demands dropped 5.6p.p. during the final quarter of 2015. On the other hand, the profitability of assets and equity recorded significant improvements in 2015, increasing 1.1 p.p. and 8.0 p.p. to 1.7% and 12.9%, respectively. This result is clearly linked to efficiency gains recorded in the sector, with the cost-to-income ratio dropping 11.4p.p. to 47.4%. The trend of increasing currency positions by the banks, mainly through the purchase of securities indexed to the US dollar, reached a peak at September 2015, when the bank’s net open currency position reached 41% of equity. This scenario mainly relates to the situation faced by the oil sector and is a consequence of the major reductions in available foreign currency, along with the fragility of the financial system, as evidenced by cases of money laundering, which impacted the relationship between the domestic banks and their correspondents. Considering only direct effects, it is estimated that the banking system has a low degree of exposure to the oil sector (less than 5% of all credit). Nevertheless, oil price volatility, due to the undiversified nature of the Angolan exports (which constrain the availability of foreign currency), remains an important mechanism for the transmission of imbalances in the banking system. Among the main consequences resulting from the current low oil prices, we highlight the devaluation pressures on the kwanza and the negative impact it has on capital compliance (along with its loss in case of default), the lower investment in public projects, payment delays and higher chances of defaulting (particularly relevant for the construction sector), lower deposits from both the oil sector and the Government and increased profitability for Government bonds due to funding needs, which may lead to capital losses by the banks. Some of the imbalances recorded are deeply related to the Angolan banks’ ability to maintain their foreign currency accounts and perform external payments. This is related to Angola’s position on the grey list of Financial Action Task Force on Money Laundering until 2016, which signals lack of compliance on all regulations for money laundering and terrorism funding, thus straining the relation with banking correspondents (North American). While Angola has since been removed from the list due to tighter supervision standards by the BNA, the banking sector is still hindered by lower levels of trust in international circles. The pace at which the BNA injects foreign currency towards the commercial banks has been insufficient to compensate the extra commitments assumed by the banks. Negative impacts from this scenario are as large as the commitments assumed by the bank (on behalf of their clients), primarily in operations of trade finance, letters of credit, stand-by letters of credit, etc.. In a report by Moody’s titled “Banking – Africa 2016”, Angola is described as owning the most vulnerable banking system in Africa. The report notes that the main reasons for the surge in the risk on the quality of assets are weak economic growth, currency devaluation and exit of capitals. Also relevant are the scenario for risk management, loss coverage and the stilldeveloping supervision capacity. This is certainly a challenging scenario for the country’s monetary authority, which must seek to mitigate the sizable effects of the lower oil prices and simultaneously correct the major imbalances present in the banking system. A clear path to this effect is to adopt internationally recognized accounting and management standards, consolidate the sector, restructure the business fabric and adopt efficient standards for risk management. Such actions will contribute towards sectorial stability, reduced risks of default and a more efficient allocation of bank resources. We highlight that the desired robustness, efficiency and competitiveness of the financial system primarily depends on improved macroeconomic fundamentals for the country, namely higher oil prices and success on the country’s economic diversification efforts. Financial sector in a regional context For most of Sub-Saharan Africa, despite recent improvements, the banking sector continues to perform below the standards set by developed countries. In order to measure the financial system’s performance in Sub-Saharan Countries (SSA), the IMF used the Financial Development Index in its most recent Regional Economic Outlook. This index measures the depth, access and efficiency of the markets and financial institutions. According to this indicator, the performance of the SSA region has accelerated moderately over the past 15 years. Among oilproducing countries, Angola recorded the best performance, also scoring above-average for SSA countries. Angola developed particularly fast in banking deposits, which grew from 21% to 49% of GDP, while banking loans expanded from 5% to 24% of GDP between 2005 and 2013, thus becoming the reference levels for the region. 21 E.E.F. Angola June 2016 Banking situation in Angola The main findings for the SSA region note that the financial system has recorded solid improvements, even if it remains below developed-country standards. Financial inclusion has also shown progress, benefiting from innovations in the field of financial services, namely in payments by phone. Nevertheless, there is still ample room for improvement. Angolan Financial Sector Indicators dec-14 mar-15 jun-15 sep-15 dec-15 Solvency = FPR/APR+ (ECRC/0.10)) 19.8 21.2 19.7 18.8 19.8 Basic capital (Level 1)/(Risk-weighted assets) 13.9 15.2 14.3 13.7 13.8 Credit Foreign Currency/Total Credit 27.4 27.7 31.0 32.8 30.8 NPL/Total Credit 11.7 13.0 13.8 13.2 11.6 (NPL -provisions for NPL)/FPR 32.8 34.3 26.8 24.0 19.6 Credit to Public Sector/ Total Credit 10.6 10.7 7.5 7.2 7.3 Credit to Private Sector/ Total Credit 89.4 89.3 92.5 92.8 92.7 Return on Assets (ROA) 0.6 0.6 1.1 1.6 1.7 Return on Equity (ROE) 4.9 4.1 8.8 12.6 12.9 Total costs/Total gains 99.9 99.9 99.7 99.8 99.8 Cost-to-income=Administrative & Commercialization Cost/ Operating Income 58.8 48.9 42.9 43.8 47.4 Net Assets/ Total Assets 33.9 39.3 42.3 40.4 39.7 Net Assets/ Short-Term Liabilities 43.2 50.4 54.1 52.5 50.6 Total Credit/Total Deposits 59.9 58.8 56.0 58.4 59.0 Liabilities Foreign Currency/Total Liabilities 33.1 32.2 33.0 34.7 33.5 23.7 21.9 32.2 40.8 34.4 23 24 25 28 28 Capital Adequacy Quality of Assets Distribution of credit by activity sector Profitability & Returns Liquidity Sensitivity & Market Change Net Open Exchange Exposure /Capital Number of banks reporting for the period Source: BNA/DSI Another important conclusion relates to the fact that the banking system continues to dominate the financial environment in multiple countries. In the case of Angola, the financial system is almost fully controlled by the banking sector, whose weight amounts to 95% (domestic banks having the largest weight). The remaining 5% is split between pension funds and National Development Banks. Concerning the recent financial developments for the region, the macroeconomic fundamentals provide the main drivers for development. Still, negative current developments, due to the recent crisis faced by the commodity market (mainly in oilexporting countries, like Angola and Nigeria), provide weak perspectives for growth in these countries. In order to fully reap the benefits of financial development and secure macroeconomic stability, the IMF stresses the importance of creating and implementing proper policies aimed at the financial sector. Such policies are expected to further the goals of creating stronger institutions, promote sturdier regulations and increase the financial inclusion. Sílvio Bernardo Magalhães 22 E.E.F. Angola June 2016 External Sector Goods and Services Account vs oil prices Goods and Services Balance 60,000 50% 40,000 40% 30% 20,000 20% 0 10% 2014 2013 2015 F Services (Net) Goods Goods & services (% GDP) - RHS 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 -10% 2005 0% -40,000 2004 -20,000 2003 Since the Angolan economy is characterized by its high concentration of exports on the oil sector, any variations in its price or production will have a direct impact on the balance of goods and services. Indeed, oil sector exports represent 95% of all Angolan exports. On the other hand, we note that import activity behaves on a time delay to these commodity price cycles, which drives a temporary worsening of the foreign trade balance during oil price drops, as is currently the case. (million USD; % GDP) 2002 Since 2004, the Balance of Goods and Services recorded an average surplus of 23% of GDP. The years 2009 and 2015 though, stood as clear exceptions, with falling oil prices triggering a worsening of the balance to deficits of 0.5% and 2.1% (estimate) of GDP, respectively. Source: BNA, IMF, BPI Note: F - forecast On one hand, imports of capital goods – machinery – and some Exports and imports of goods & services services both reveal a high elasticity degree to the performance of the oil sector, as measured by production or sectorial revenue; (million USD) on the other hand, imports of goods and services reflect internal 80,000.0 demand behaviour, which are indirectly affected by oil sector 70,000.0 revenues (through multiple transmission channels, including 60,000.0 the private and public sectors, via Government’s investment 50,000.0 and expenditure), along with the stance of economic policies. 40,000.0 30,000.0 20,000.0 10,000.0 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2008 2009 Imports of Goods (fob) 2015 F Imports of Services 2007 2006 0.0 2005 Thus, in a context where oil sector revenues have dropped 50% since 2013, and given the need to halt (or, at least, control) the decrease of foreign reserves, the application of restrictive monetary and fiscal policies stimulates the adjustment of internal demand with a lagged effect on imports. Observing the goods and services external account and its main Source: BNA, IMF, BPI Total Exports (fob) Note: F - forecast components, we note that exports dropped over 50% since 2013; this while imports rose 9% in 2014, followed by a 30% drop in 2015 (see table). This trajectory is expected to continue Exports and imports of goods & services throughout 2016, even if in a less pronounced manner, as was (index - base 100=2013) the case during the 2008-2009 crisis. In 2015, assuming a ceteris paribus scenario (meaning equal oil production and non-oil GDP growth) an oil price of 57 USD/barrel would be enough to eliminate the goods and services deficit (average oil price stood at 53 USD). For 2016, this breakeven price will probably be lower, as we expect to see further adjustments of internal demand, meaning that import activity is likely to maintain a trajectory of soft decline. The G&S oil-price equilibrium probably in the 45 to 50 USD range. Nevertheless, this price will still be insufficient to drive the Current Account to surplus, given the significant imbalance in the so-called Primary Incomes (net), which include external flows related to Salaries, Interest and Dividends, which are expected to record a deficit of 5% of GDP. 120 110 100 90 80 70 60 50 40 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Imports of Services Imports of Goods (fob) Total Exports (fob) Source: BNA, IMF, BPI Goods and Services Balance 2014E 2015E Exports change -13% -43% Imports change 9% -30% 2016F -13% Note: 2014 and 2015, assuming provisional figures of BNA; 2016: forecast assuming BPI scenario. E - estimate F - forecast Paula Gonçalves Carvalho 23 E.E.F. Angola June 2016 External Sector In 2015, according to data released by the Government, Quarterly International Trade the Angolan trade balance of goods recorded a Kz 2.574 billion surplus, which represents a 12% yoy drop, with (yoy%; million USD) both exports and imports receding, 20.6 and 29.5%, 100% respectively. 80% Recently-published data for external trade during the final quarter of 2015 also recorded a similar trajectory, with exports and imports decreasing 21.5% yoy and 34.5% yoy, respectively. This trend is also observable in the export activity on a quarteron-quarter basis, where a 12% drop was recorded, while import activity posted a residual growth of 0.3%. Overall, the trade balance recorded a surplus of Kz 425 billion, a 1.5% improvement from the 2014 result. 60% 40% 20% 0% -20% -40% -60% -80% 14000 12000 10000 8000 6000 4000 2000 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 2013 2014 0 2015 The current structure for Angolan international trade Trade Balance (RHS) Imports reflects a narrowing of its degree of openness, which resulted in foreign trade losing some relevance to the national economy. The degree of economic openness, as measured by the trade balance, stood at 20.2% in 2015 (-3.3 p.p. from 2014). This behaviour is deeply linked to the high level of dependency on the oil sector (both in exports and the structure of GDP), and the resulting vulnerability to the oil Destination of exports, by country price shock. Exports Source: BNA (% total) The structural coefficients of Angolan external trade underline the low level of diversification, both in terms of product categories and trade partners. Concerning the composition of trade, this degree of concentration is evidenced by the weight of oil exports, which accounted for 96.6% of all exports in 2015 (97.9% in 2014). For imports, a group of 4 categories (Machinery and Equipment; Agriculture items; Common Metals; Food) account for 56.9% of total imports in the preceding year (56.8% in 2014). Concerning the direction of trade1, this indicator shows that the top 5 destinations for Angolan exports account for 66.2% of the total (66.8% in 2014), while the top 5 sources of imported goods account for 49.3% of total imports (47.2% in 2014). 100% China USA 80% India 60% Spain Taiwan 40% Canada Netherlands 20% France South Africa 0% 1998 2002 2006 2010 2014 Portugal Other Source: BNA Angola has gradually lost the ability to sustain its import activity with export revenues. Over the last 3 years, the global coverage rate recorded a 48.4 p.p. drop, standing at 197% in 2015. While this reading appears to be a broadly positive sign of commercial competitiveness, this rate does not hold much significance for the Angolan economy, given the unsatisfactory levels of foreign trade and the low Imports source (2014) levels of sectorial competitiveness (due to low technical progress implementation and weak industrial dynamism and (% total) productivity). The downward performance of the coverage rate2 of imports by exports over the last few years has been explained by successive drops in exports and imports levels, which amounted to 43.6% and 41.5% in 2015, respectively. On one hand, excessive supply of oil in the international markets and the subsequent drop in its price have driven lower export activity. On the other hand, the deterioration of the terms of trade, due to an exchange policy aimed at maintaining foreign currency reserves at comfortable levels, together with the restrictive stance adopted by the remaining economic policies (monetary and fiscal) have been pointed as the main factors behind the lower import activity. Portugal 15% 25% Singapure China USA 14% Belgium UAE 3% Brazil 4% UK 4% 12% 4% 6% 6% 7% South Africa France Others Source: BNA The main trading partner in the Q4 2015 was China, being the destination for 45% of the Angolan exports and the source of 16.8% of imports. In the last quarter of 2015, the Angolan coverage rate improved in comparison with the same period of 2014, now being 187.1% (156.2% in the Q4 2014). Nevertheless, a year-on-year comparison showed a 16.2 p.p. drop in the coverage rate. 1 2 24 E.E.F. Angola June 2016 External Sector Structure of Exports Structure of Imports (million USD) (million USD) 80000 80,000 70000 60,000 60000 50000 40,000 40000 30000 20,000 20000 10000 0 Oil 0 2000 Non-oil 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2005 2007 2009 Capital Goods Intermediate Consumption Goods Current Consumption Goods Merchandise 2014 Source: BNA 2011 2013 Source: BNA An analysis of the Revealed Comparative Advantages , which Terms of Trade aims at an attempt to normalize the coverage rate, (which is important, given the weight of hydrocarbon exports on the (Index, 2000 = 100) behaviour of hydrocarbon imports), shows a stabilization in the degree of competitiveness for the hydrocarbon 200 sector, in comparison to the remaining sectors of the 150 economy, some of which have recorded drops. Such decreases result from both structural and conjuncture problems of the 100 economy as a whole. 40 30 20 10 0 -10 -20 -30 -40 -50 50 0 Terms of Trade 2016F 2015E 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 -50 Terms of Trade - % change Source: IMF - Regional Economic Outlook Diversification of the economy and import replacement As a direct consequence of the weight of the oil sector on the national economy, the trade balance and net foreign reserves (NFR) have been affected by lower oil prices in the international markets and the subsequent lower oil export revenues. The budget deficit for the current account (USD 8.748,1 million) and the subsequent 10.7% drop in NFR to USD 24.550,2 million in 2015 (according to the BNA) have hindered the performance of the economy as a whole. The real sector of the economy recorded an estimated 2.8% growth rate for 2015, with the oil sector expanding roughly 6.3%, this while non-oil grew 1.3%. In 2014, foreign reserves sold to commercial banks covered 107% of all imports of goods and services. For 2015 tough, this indicator recorded a 39 p.p. drop, standing at 68%. Forecasts for 2016, according to the Executive, point to a 5 p.p. decrease to 63%. Such tight management of the exchange market has led the exchange rate to devaluate 32% in 2015, allowing for a reduction of 29.9% in imports of goods, which raised the coverage ratio of imports with international reserves to 7.72 months. Such results, while still modest, are in line with the strategy of import substitution evidenced by the new customs tariffs, which raised taxes on imported goods that can, according to the Government, be produced domestically. One previously quoted Governmental strategy document explicitly states the goal of propping up the non-oil sector by increasing internal production (primarily in basic products), promoting exports of products that attract foreign reserves towards the country. Still, this strategy may have negative consequences for the economy. If on one hand, larger protectionism may lead the Executive to work towards raising production levels and competitiveness, on the other hand, such measures also tend to hinder the access to cheaper productions goods and raw materials, given the economy’s low levels of competitiveness. Currently, with an economic environment adverse to investment and maintenance of past production levels 3 RCA links the sectorial coverage rate (of different sectors of the economy) with the global coverage rate. 25 E.E.F. Angola June 2016 External Sector (lack of production equipment and intermediate goods, infrastructural issues related to the energy sector and communications, water shortages, etc), we note that the industrial activity appears to be weakening, as is evident in several indicators: the industrial production index decreased 2.7% during the 3Q2015; the Overall Economic Climate Indicator notes unfavourable growth for the final quarter of last year (decreasing from 9 points to -27), with all sub-indexes standing below the historical average. Thus, on one hand, the current external macroeconomic balance for the Angolan economy demands (and taking into account the perception of the international investors, rating agencies…) a policy of currency devaluation, which enhances the impact on the terms of trade, given that the two behave inversely. Despite this, the prioritization granted to macroeconomic balance (foreign reserve stabilization) may difficult or even delay the process of diversification and import replacement, should this measures impede the flow imports beyond what is strictly necessary. In other words, protecting the reserves will itself lead to greater currency devaluation. Subsequently, further devaluation may, in a context of excessively fast adjustment, lead to significant price increases for imported goods and services, which will hinder the Angolan economy’s ability to secure much needed equipment and raw materials. International competitiveness Doing Business 2016 (Points) Total Ranking Protect. minority inv. Paying taxes Starting business Getting electricity Trad. across borders Getting Credit Const. permits 2015 Regist.property 2016 Enforcing contracts 200 180 160 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 Resolving insolvency Concerning Angola’s competitiveness, several international organizations continue to identify extensive room for improvement. In the recent Doing Business 2016 report, which measures and tracks changes to regulations applicable to small and medium businesses in 189 countries, Angola was ranked 181st (39.64/100 points), 2 places above its result for the previous year. This improvement, according to the World Bank, particularly refers to a more streamlined process to open a business, improvements to the electricity coverage and tax payments. As in the previous report, Angola remains at the very bottom of the ranking for governance in cases of insolvency and near the bottom for the compliance of contracts. The poor results obtained in this last category relate to property records and construction licenses, for whose rankings Angola dropped 3 places this year (to 169th and 108th, respectively). Source: World Bank Serious hurdles remain for businesses in obtaining credit and facilities in internal trade (108th place). On the other hand, despite the loss of 2 places, investor protection remains Angola’s best category. With a score of 39.6 points, Angola is 60.4 points short of the “frontier”. The latest report saw a 2.18% increase in the distance-to-frontier indicator, a result driven by a 19.6% improvement in the ease to start a business and a 1.9% for the payment of taxes. Note that such constraints are fairly common among African Nations. On its meeting in Kigali, Rwanda, the World Economic Forum addressed the latest economic developments in the African continent, taking into account the adverse global economic conjuncture, especially the drop in commodity prices, the lower growth in Europe and the strength of USD. The WEF considers that several factors which have been relevant for growth in Africa over the past few years, such as strong external demand, reasonable access to funding and macroeconomic reforms, have been negatively affected by low competitiveness across the region in the last years, particularly in terms of productivity. According to the Global Competitiveness Index 2015-2016, Africa has performed poorly in comparison to other regions, particularly in matters of infrastructure, human resources, technological readiness, business sophistication and innovation. Such lower competitiveness raises a bigger challenge in terms of economic diversification for the region. As such, and aiming at raising competitiveness in Africa, WEC, the World Bank and the OECD jointly introduced a recommendation package with two main focuses: public-private cooperation and regional integration. According to the recommendations, the private sector must lead the way in striving for higher competitiveness standards, supporting better policies and its consequent implementation, while regional integration constitutes an important element in raising competitiveness through trade and diversification. As such, the main recommendations relate to the need to improve labour market efficiency and the development of skills, support small and medium businesses, increase productivity and profitability for the agricultural sector and reinforcing governance institutions and structures. The establishment of a joint infrastructural strategy was also recommended, as well as improvements towards a more streamlined circulation of goods, services and people, the promotion of regional trade through regional and global value chains and an easier access to credit, as well as the integration in financial markets. Sílvio Bernardo Magalhães 26 E.E.F. Angola June 2016 Social Context Characteristics of the angolan population – 2014 Census (final data) The Angolan population increased nearly fivefold between 1970 and 2014, according to the Censos in the corresponding years, currently standing around 25.8 million inhabitants, of which 48% are male. The population of Angola is expected to continue increasing over the following years, as noted in forecasts by the Population Reference Bureau, an organization which develop studies about population, health and environment, who considers that, by mid-2030, the Angolan population will reach, approximately, 39.4 million inhabitants (65.5 million by 2050). Of all provinces, Luanda is the most populous, with nearly a quarter of the total population (nearly 7 million), while Bengo is the least populous province. Luanda also has the country’s largest population density (368 inhabitants/km2), clearly above that recorded for the country (20.7 inhabitants/km2). Also note that the percentage of the population at or under 18 is 55%, according to the 2014 Census. For Luanda, 63% of the population is at or under 24 years of age (65% nationwide). Performing regular census allows for a deeper understanding of the Angolan population and its needs. Deeper understanding of the social and housing conditions of the population allows the Government to better pursue the desired standards for the infrastructural network, healthcare, education, among others. This data is also crucial to facilitate public expenditure management and resource allocation, in order to develop policies in a more rigorous and adaptive manner for the socioeconomic background. Characterization of the angolan population in graphics Angolan population, by province Urban and Rural Population Split (% of total population) (% of total population) Bengo Cuanza Norte Namibe Cuando Cubango Lunda Sul Zaire Cabinda Moxico Lunda Norte Malanje Cunene Bié Uíge Cuanza Sul Huambo Benguela Huíla Luanda 37.36% 62.64% 0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25 0.3 Urban Source: INE Rural Source: INE Angolan Age Pyramid Population with over 5 years, by level of education (million) (% of total population) 90-94Y 11.9% Mulheres Homens 1.2% 0.8% 80-84Y 70-74Y 60-64Y 18.8% 50-54Y 40-44Y 30-34Y 67.2% 20-24Y No education level Primary Education Secondary Education, 1st cycle Secondary Education, 2nd cycle Higher Education 10-14Y 0-4Y -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 Source: INE 27 Source: INE E.E.F. Angola June 2016 Social Context Literacy rate of the Angolan population, by province Employed Population, by main economic activity (percentage) (% of total employed population) 24% Literacy Rate Angola: 65.6% 44% Agric.&Fish. 2% Industry 6% Constr. Trade;auto repair 4% Transp.,stor.&com. 3% 6% Adm.activ. Public Adm.&defense; social sec. Education Other act.&serv. Not expressed Source: INE Employed Population, by sex Unemployment Rate, by province (% of total employed population) (percentage) Female Source: INE Bengo Lunda Sul Huíla Cunene Namibe Bié Huambo Benguela Malanje Lunda Norte Cuanza Sul Uíge Cuanza Norte Male Luanda 55.23% Zaire 44.77% Unemployment Rate Angola: 24.2% Cabinda 45.0 40.0 35.0 30.0 25.0 20.0 15.0 10.0 5.0 0.0 Cuando Cubango Source: INE 4% 2% Moxico Bié Moxico Malanje Huíla Lunda Norte Cunene Lunda Sul Cuanza Sul Uíge Cuando… Huambo Benguela Cuanza Norte Bengo Namibe Zaire Cabinda 5% Luanda 100.0 90.0 80.0 70.0 60.0 50.0 40.0 30.0 20.0 10.0 0.0 Source: INE Vânia Patrícia Duarte 28 E.E.F. Angola June 2016 Main Indicators Main economic indicators 2010 Population (million) GDP per capita (USD PPP) 2011 2012 2013 2014P 2015F 2016F 21.7 22.3 23.0 23.7 24.4* 25.1 25.9 6,230 6,416 6,671 7,030 7,271 7,344 7,381 Source: IMF WEO Apr 2016 Notes: P - Preliminary; F - Forecast * The figures of the last Censos revealed that population was 25.8 million; the later publication of this indicator is not reflected in the IMF's forecasts" Gross domestic product 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014P 2015F 2016F Nominal GDP (billion AOA) 7,579.5 9,780.1 10,876.0 12,056.3 12,462.3 12,475.6 14,218.1 Nominal GDP (billion USD) 82.5 104.1 115.3 124.9 126.8 103.0 81.5 Real GDP (% change) Oil Non-oil 3.4 3.9 5.2 6.8 4.8 2.8 3.3 -3.0 -5.6 4.3 -0.9 -2.6 6.3 4.8 7.8 9.7 5.6 10.9 8.2 1.3 2.7 Composition of GDP (by sector) Agriculture 6.0 9.2 -22.5 42.3 11.9 0.8 4.6 Fishing 1.3 17.2 9.7 2.4 19.1 5.8 0.2 Diamonds and Other -10.3 -0.7 0.3 3.3 1.0 2.2 1.0 Manufacturing 10.7 13.0 14.0 8.6 8.1 -4.0 3.1 Electricity 16.1 12.0 11.7 8.1 8.0 3.5 3.1 Construction 10.9 3.5 10.4 34.4 17.3 2.5 20.0 Trade 8.7 9.5 13.4 7.0 8.0 2.2 2.4 Other 4.7 9.6 8.3 0.7 6.0 - 0.0 Source: Ministério Planeamento Note: P - Preliminary; F - Forecast Oil sector 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016F Oil production (millions of barrels per day) 1.76 1.63 1.72 1.73 1.63 1.76 1.89 Angolan oil price (average, USD per barrel) 77.8 108.7 111.0 107.5 100.7 51.7 45.0 Source: Ministry of Finance, State Budget 2016. Note: F - Forecast Growth forecasts for Angola (real GDP, % change) 2014 2015 2016 BPI (May 16) 4.8 2.8 1.2 Amend.SB 2016/Linhas Mestras 4.8 2.8 3.3 IMF (Apr 16) 4.8 3.0 2.5 AfDB/OECD/UNDP (May 2016) 4.8 3.8 3.3 EIU (Apr 16) 3.9 2.7 1.1 29 E.E.F. Angola June 2016 Main Indicators Consumer price index 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016F 15.3 11.4 9.0 7.7 7.5 14.3 19.2 Consumer prices (end of period, %) Source: INE; IMF WEO Apr 2016. Note: F - Forecast External sector 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014P 2015F 2016F 61.3 64.6 61.6 55.0 45.8 36.3 39.0 of which: oil 59.8 63.0 60.4 53.9 44.6 34.7 37.2 Imports (% GDP) 20.2 19.4 20.6 21.2 22.1 20.6 21.4 9.1 12.6 12.0 6.7 -1.5 -7.6 -5.6 19.7 27.5 32.2 32.2 27.8 22.3 18.6 5.4 7.2 7.8 7.5 8.6 7.1 5.7 Exports (% GDP) Current account balance (% GDP) Gross foreign reserves (USD billion) month of imports Source: IMF Article IV (Nov. 2015). Note: P - Preliminary; F - Forecast Public accounts Total Revenue (% GDP) of which: oil Total Expenditure (% GDP) 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014P 2015P 2016F 43.5 48.8 45.9 40.4 34.6 27.4 27.6 33.0 39.0 37.3 30.3 23.4 14.6 15.6 40.0 40.2 41.3 40.8 41.1 30.9 29.0 Fiscal Balance (% GDP) Non-oil primary balance (% GDP) Gross Public Debt (% GDP) of which: external 3.4 8.7 4.6 -0.3 -6.4 -3.5 -1.4 -26.2 -26.9 -29.2 -38.4 -27.5 -15.8 -14.3 44.3 33.8 29.5 32.9 40.7 62.3 70.1 20.6 19.5 18.8 23.6 27.4 33.1 46.8 Source: IMF Article IV (Nov. 2015) Note: P - Preliminary; F - Forecast Key financial variables 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016* USD/AOA (end of period) 92.6 95.5 96.0 97.8 102.1 136.0 - USD/AOA (average) 91.9 94.0 95.6 96.9 98.5 121.0 160.7 180 days 19.0% 18.1% 15.3% 15.1% 17.4% 15.4% 15.7% 181 days - 1 year 18.2% 16.0% 14.4% 13.9% 13.9% 15.2% 15.2% > 1 year 23.7% 17.7% 15.1% 13.1% 13.7% 14.8% 14.3% 2.4% 5.8% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% Exchange Rate Nominal Interest Rates (AOA, end of period) Active interest rates (to non-financial institutions) 1) Passive interest rates Demand deposits 90 days 8.2% 4.3% 3.1% 3.3% 4.0% 5.0% 5.5% 10.0% 6.7% 4.7% 3.9% 4.3% 5.2% 5.1% 181 days - 1 year 6.8% 5.6% 4.9% 5.1% 5.6% 3.9% 3.9% > 1 year 1.6% 8.6% 7.0% 5.6% 4.9% 4.6% 4.6% 91 - 180 days Source: BNA, Bloomberg Note: * Based on data available as of June 17; 1) interest rates verified in April 2016 (last figures available). 30 "Esta publicação destina-se exclusivamente a circulação privada. A informação nela contida foi obtida de fontes consideradas fiáveis, mas a sua precisão não pode ser totalmente garantida. As recomendações destinam-se exclusivamente a uso interno, podendo ser alteradas sem aviso prévio. As opiniões expressas são da inteira responsabilidade dos seus autores, reflectindo apenas os seus pontos de vista e podendo não coincidir com a posição do BPI nos mercados referidos. O BPI, ou qualquer afiliada, na pessoa dos seus colaboradores, não se responsabiliza por qualquer perda, directa ou potencial, resultante da utilização desta publicação ou seus conteúdos. O BPI e seus colaboradores poderão deter posições em qualquer activo mencionado nesta publicação. A reprodução de parte ou totalidade desta publicação é permitida, sujeita a indicação da fonte. Por opção própria, os autores não escrevem segundo o novo Acordo Ortográfico. Os números são apresentados na versão anglo-saxónica, ou seja, utilizando a vírgula como separador de milhares e o ponto como separador decimal e utilizando a designação de "milhar de milhão" para 10^9." BANCO BPI, S.A. Rua Tenente Valadim, 284 Telef.: (351) 22 207 50 00 4100 - 476 PORTO Telefax: (351) 22 207 58 88 Largo Jean Monnet, 1 - 9º Telef.:(351) 21 724 17 00 1269-067 LISBOA Telefax: (351) 21 353 56 94