Extended Primary Care Services in Southwark: progress report

Extended Primary Care Services in Southwark: progress report
Overview and Scrutiny Committee
1. Background
NHS Southwark Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG) undertook a review of urgent care
services across Southwark during 2013 including our local Walk-in Centre. Local
analysis and engagement with residents showed the current model for accessing primary
care was neither consistent nor optimal with:
• variation in service provision and quality
• system is complicated and difficult for patients to navigate leading to use of A&E
and other urgent care services as default
• different ways in which these services are funded and commissioned leads to
fragmentation, duplication and inefficient use of resources.
Following the review of the Walk-in Centre, Southwark CCG agreed to commission an
alternative service across Southwark delivering extended primary care access. The CCG
made an investment of £2.1 million to fund recurrent service costs and was successful in
securing Challenge Fund resources (£975K) to support infrastructure, GP engagement
and set up.
The key elements of the new service model are:
• Access point in two locations across Southwark, 8am – 8pm, 7 days a week –
accessible via booked appointments in primary care (local general practice and
GPOOH) and referral from King’s A&E/ other agreed urgent care access points.
• Access to patient primary care record
• Rapid telephone management by senior clinician to support robust demand
management and balance the needs for same day demands with the needs of
patients who require continuity of care for planned care needs.
• Alignment and consistent application of access policies across general practice
The new service, providing additional levels of access to Southwark patients, will operate
seven days a week, 8am to 8pm. The CCG has commissioned this new model of care
from the two neighbourhood GP federations - Improving Health Ltd (IHL) and Quay
Health Solutions (QHS). The CCG has kept the Oversight and Scrutiny Committee
(OSC) appraised of progress since the review of urgent care services first began in late
2013 and this paper provides an update on progress.
2. Progress to date
This service will be delivered from two sites across the borough – Lister Health Centre in the
south and Bermondsey Spa in the north. The first site went live at the Lister Health Centre
on 11 November 2014 and an overview of progress to date is provided below. The second
site in the north is due to go live on 1 April 2015.
a) South service: Lister Health Centre
i) Service activity
•
Overall activity: Over the first 14 weeks over 4500 patients have been seen in the
Extended Primary Care Service (EPCS), over half of which were booked via general
Chair: Dr Jonty Heaversedge
1
Chief Officer: Andrew Bland
The best possible health outcomes for Southwark people
practice. All practices have now used the service, although utilisation varies. After a steady
increase, activity dipped during the holiday period which was mainly driven by a reduction in
practice referrals to the service.
Source of referral
Walk-in patient: Not registered/Out of Area
Walk-in patient: Registered Southwark
SELDOC (GP Out of Hours Service)
Accident and Emergency
Health Visitor
Incorrectly coded referrals
Practice booked appointments
TOTAL
Chair: Dr Jonty Heaversedge
2
Activity
707
649
516
89
50
54
2440
4505
Chief Officer: Andrew Bland
The best possible health outcomes for Southwark people
•
Walk-in presentations: As the Committee will be aware, the EPCS replaces the Walk-in
Centre previously based at the Lister Health Centre, which was decommissioned in
November. Whilst there was work undertaken during October and November to
communicate the service changes to the public through a number of mechanisms it was
recognised that some patients may continue to present at the centre. Therefore the CCG
has agreed a transitional arrangement will be in place to manage this cohort of patients
and ensure they receive appropriate clinical treatment. This arrangement will be
reviewed after six months and take into account patient activity and activity. In addition,
there are PALS officers on site to provide information and support registration.
The graph below shows that whilst walk-in presentations to the new service reduced over
the first three weeks, an increase was seen leading into the holiday period as may be
expected. However the number of walk-in presentations has continued to decrease over
January and February. There is ongoing work to understand the types of patients presenting
and this information will be shared with practices as part of regular reporting.
Chair: Dr Jonty Heaversedge
3
Chief Officer: Andrew Bland
The best possible health outcomes for Southwark people
It should be noted that the number of patients self-presenting to the EPCS remains low
relative to activity levels at the previous Walk-in Centre. During December, there were 418
walk in presentations to the Extended Primary Care Service which compares with a monthly
average of approximately 2200 patients attending the Walk-in Centre during 2013/14. It
should also be noted that the activity at the Lister Walk-in Centre had decreased year on
year as shown below.
Further information on activity at surrounding Walk-in Centre’s has been requested; however
anecdotally, no increases in Southwark presentations have been reported. Work to improve
coding will provide clarity on the distribution of out of area patients as opposed to
unregistered local patient.
•
Distribution of activity
Age: Young children accounted for the majority of attendances over the first three
months, with just over a third of patients aged 0 to 10 years, whilst younger working age
adults (18-45) made up 39% of presentations. The planned communication and
engagement campaign aims to target these particular groups.
Day and time: This service aims to improve access to primary care services and to date over
a third of appointments have been delivered outside of core GP hours. The distribution over
Chair: Dr Jonty Heaversedge
4
Chief Officer: Andrew Bland
The best possible health outcomes for Southwark people
the week is relatively even although the busiest days are Monday and Saturday. Areas for
development include
• Practice referrals for Sunday appointments and early morning slots: this would be
considered as part of the borough wide work to review and align practice access policies.
• SELDOC: The local GP out of hours provider has continued to refer to the service and
whilst activity has increased since go-live, absolute numbers remain relatively low.
Whilst the majority of referrals would be expected take place over the weekend,
SELDOC are able to book morning appointments during the week and this is an area
that will be explored.
Out of Hours: 37%
In hours: 63%
•
Impact upon A&E
The Lister Health Centre is located near King’s Emergency Department and there
is a re-direction pathway in place. A comparison of activity at the King’s Urgent
Care Service, which is staffed by GPs and manages minors, in the periods before
and after the service went live in 2013 and 2014 was undertaken to consider any
changes in minor attendances at King’s ED. This showed no significant changes
following the launch of the service.
At this point in time it is not possible to assess the impact of the service on urgent
and emergency care services in a meaningful way. This is due to a number of
factors including the short period of time the service has been running for, the
holiday period not being representative of usual service utilisation and the wider
Chair: Dr Jonty Heaversedge
5
Chief Officer: Andrew Bland
The best possible health outcomes for Southwark people
issues impacting upon A&E performance. The CCG is working with relevant
parties to more clearly understand the impact upon patient flows and the wider
system.
The service provider met with King’s Emergency Department leads in February to
review the re-direction protocol and identify opportunities for improvement which
includes providing access to the electronic shared appointment system.
•
Health Visitor Service: a new service, funded through NHS England winter monies,
operating at weekends and accepting referrals from the Extended Primary Care Service
began in December and there are discussions in progress to increase activity
•
Coding: Please note there is ongoing work to improve coding and reporting and some
caveats on the data provided here.
ii) Practice and patient feedback including complaints
• Since go-live in the south site, all twenty member practices have used the service,
although utilisation has varied. The Improving Health Ltd (IHL) team has completed
a programme of ‘check-in’ calls and practice visits which has informed ongoing
service improvements. Feedback to date has been positive.
• Patient feedback has been positive, with 97% of survey respondents indicating they
were ‘Extremely likely’ or ‘Likely’ to recommend the service to friends and family.
The service is in the process of collating this information and summary reports will be
considered as part of contractual discussions. Patient experience and views of the
changes to the overall primary care pathway including consistent telephone
management, will be considered as part of the local evaluation. This is being
overseen by the Challenge Fund Steering Group.
• Complaints and incidents
The CCG funded two Patient & Liaison Services (PALS) officers to support patient
navigation and signposting during the transition period. The PALS log of issues and
complaints has highlighted themes and issues. This is reviewed at weekly provider
management team meetings and reported to Commissioners. In some instances,
this has highlighted a lack of clarity regarding the scope of the service. For example,
there have been some inappropriate referrals to the service from practices which has
reinforced the need for timely senior clinical review. The provider clinical lead has
reviewed cases and followed up with the practices in question. The service provides
both GP and Nurse Practitioner appointments and feedback has highlighted the need
to clearly communicate this to patients at the point of referral. Subsequently this has
been reiterated in practice communications.
Any incidents will be raised at provider senior management team level and reported
as part of standard contractual monitoring process.
b) North service: Bermondsey Spa
• Scope of service: The north service will be delivered from Bermondsey Spa and provide
appointments for same day and urgent care needs, in line with the model operating in the
south of the borough. However it will also offer some routine appointments, namely some
routine tests, dressings and contraception delivered by a practice nurse.
•
Service start date: The service is now due to go live on 1 April 2015. Whilst it was
originally due to mobilise on 24 February 2015, following internal review and discussion
Chair: Dr Jonty Heaversedge
6
Chief Officer: Andrew Bland
The best possible health outcomes for Southwark people
with the service provider a new mobilisation start date was agreed. This has been
agreed with NHS England, as co-Commissioners.
•
Premises: The CCG commissioned a utilisation review in September to identify a well
located space in the north of the borough, following confirmation that no single GP
practice could accommodate the Extended Primary Care Service. The preferred
option was Bermondsey Spa Medical Centre, however the freeing up of appropriate
space required the consolidation of some GSTT services from Bermondsey Spa to
Artesian. The CCG has worked closely with GSTT to
- appraise the Overview & Scrutiny Committee of the changes and plans in place
to manage this
- support communication to patients affected by the changes through development
of appropriate materials an
- review progress and ensure the service moves were completed within the
required timescales. The service moves were completed on 6 February 2015.
Harprit Lally
Challenge Fund Programme Manager
Southwark CCG
February 2015
Chair: Dr Jonty Heaversedge
7
Chief Officer: Andrew Bland
The best possible health outcomes for Southwark people