04-08-2014 - Regional Office, Chandigarh
Transcription
04-08-2014 - Regional Office, Chandigarh
~'!f vr o Telephone No. : +91-172-2638061 F<lx No. : +91-172-2638135 ~ ~ ChI'll'I<>I'll ~q"'lIi\ mt(; q :ill CI{ 0 I, craf veT mq;rr ~ ;:fo 24 - 25. ~ - 31 lJ, \71 ('HI Flj q f{ CI ~ 01 ~ ~ ~, ~ - 160030 GOVERNMENT OF INDIA Northern Regional Orrice, 8<lYs No. 24 - 25, Sector 31-A, Dakshin Milrg, chandigarh - 160030 MINISTRY OF ENVIRONMENT, FORESTS & CLIMATE CHANGE No. No.7-52/2003-RO(NZ) ( {lJ] I Dated: 07.11.2014 001I, The Executive Director NHPC Ltd. NHPC Office Complex Secto~33,Faridabad Haryana-121003 Sub: Nimoo Bazgo Hydroelectric Project (45 MW) at village-Alchi, Leh( J & K) by NHPC Ltd.- Site inspection regarding. MoEF's letter No.J-12011/3/2005-IA-1 dated 30 th May, 2005. Ref: 1'll51G4, ,:N':!ffi ~ 1I \3<'clR.Cld qR4hHI Cf>I ~&IUI 2014 em 'PcPm 11m I ~ ~&IUI -$ ~ ~ ~&Iull a qqf -$ ~ 4th & 5th August, om qR'4131F!1 3I'fuCflIR41 ~ 3lull5tdllfRt &ill ~ ;fl;r-CflAclI'4{1 '4'5f ~ ~ 11m ~ 'BRPt 3IJlICJ5! ~ ~3IT 3IJlRt '="Cfllr-'r.:1~qr-r::rl~ ~ lR Cfll~cn~ ~ ~ tm -$ fffir Cl%I 11m ~ I ~ '4'5f -$ 3rfrr mm Jffi1d cpR qft ~ 3f1dR CIRI ~ ~3IT lR Cfll~ql~ ~ / (~WJIR) Ae!i!ICfl (~) Tel. No.(0172)-2638994 Email:[email protected] dWF!Cfl: Copy to: 1. The Director(S), Monitoring Cell, Ministry of Environment, Forests and Climate Change, Indira Paryavaran Bhawan, Jor Bagh, Aliganj, New Delhi--110003 for information and necessary action please. 2, The Chief Engineer, Nimoo Bazgo Power Station, National Hydroelectric Power Corporation, NHPC Office Complex, village-Alchi, Leh (Ladakh)-1941 01 for information and further necessary action. (/ u~ f!..d).,.. ~~,~ I(;;fF) Ae!i!ICf)(~) ~ffi\If ;To Telephone No. : +91-'172-2638061 Fax No. : +91-172-2638135 3n"t ~~. <til .r{f (>Ill ~wm :Ifm1 m<flIT q<lj"C1'{UI, cra:r vcr \5'l(>lClI<lj .::l q~C1~lTj J""!?!!(>lll GOVERNMENT OF INDIA MINISTRY OF ENVIRONMENT, FORESTS & CLIMATE CHANGE No. NO.7-52/2003-RO(NZ) ohr ;To 24 - 25, ~T - 31 '(,1", ~ ~'. ~ - 160030 Northern Regional Office, Bays No. 24 - 25, Sector 31-A, Daksl1in Marg, Chandigarll - 160030 Dated: 07.11.2014 To The Executive Director NHPC Ltd. NHPC Office Complex Secto~33, Faridabad Haryana-121 003 Sub: Nimoo Bazgo Hydroelectric Project (45 MW) at village-Alchi, Leh( J & K) by NHPC Ltd.- Site inspection regarding. Ref: MoEF's letter No.J-12011/3/2005-IA-1 dated 30th May, 2005. Sir, On the basis of site inspection of above cited project by the undersigned on 4th & th 5 August, 2014, point wise discussions with project executing authorities and subsequent information submitted so far, a comprehensive monitoring report is being submitted to Ministry for further necessary action and following comments and observations are forwarded to you for necessary action at your end. Accordingly, information and 'action taken report' on the following points may be submitted to this office urgently: 1. 2. S.N. 3. 4. 5. While the Power Station has been commissioned for 45 MW capacity, it is being run on 6-10 MW capacity as there is no provision to transmit the power from power house to National Grid. It is really a national loss of resources as well as the manpower. Please take up the matter with National Power Grid Corporation to create the facilities to transmit the power from Nimoo Bazgo HEP to National Power Grid. The progress in this regard may be informed. The matter may be pursued with the local forest deptt. to get the CA T Plan implementation completed and physical and financial progress of CAT works may be submitted re!=jularly to this office in the following proforma: Funds released by Funds spent by the Details covered of Area the Project forest deptt. till Engineering by plantation Works done ti II and no. authorities till date. date. of date. plants planted. You are requested to take necessary action on the following points also and submit an 'Action taken report' to this office: a) CAT Plan implementation should be completed as early as possible so that the benefits of CAT works could reach to the project during Qeneration of power. A sub-committee may be constituted with the officers from NHPC b) and State Forest Deptt. to monitor the CAT works and submit details of works done so far with videographic support. The muck dump sites should be restored and engineering as well as plantation work may be completed on all the dump sites. Physical and financial progress about CSR and eco-development activities beinQ run by the Proiect near projec should be updated from time to time. --2 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. Uploading of six monthly progress report and monitoring reports on the web site of the Company is to be ensured. Latest monitoring reports in respect of Ambient Air Quality, Noise Level, silt rate of the river, Bio-chemical Oxygen Demand (BOD) and Coliform count of surface water etc. on reqular basis. Uptodate details about the quantum of crate works! wire crate works/breast walls etc. at different dumpinq sites alonq with expenditure fiqures till date. Uptodate figures for allocation of funds for different environment management plans along with utilization of funds. The information about restoration aspects in following proforma from the date of startinq the pro'ect till date: Name, Material excavated Material re-utilized Material dumped at location and till date in cubic till date in cubic different dumping sites meters capacity of all meters till date in cubic meters approved dumpin~ sites Uptodate physical and financial proqress about Fisheries development. All the contractors should be instructed to collect the Pollution under check Certificates (PUC's) in respect of their vehicles including dumpers & Loaders and submit to this office for record. Periodical reports in Form-3, 4 & 13 to J & K SPCB as per Hazardous Waste (M, H & T) Rules, 2008. Action taken or proposed to be taken in this regard may be submitted to this office. A special cell was constituted for conservation of bio-diversity. The meetings held, the minutes of the meeting and the progress so far may be submitted. An R & R Committee has been constituted by Deputy Commissioner to monitor the progress about the R & R works. The physical and financial progress of the same may be submitted. Physical and financial progress about implementation of R & R scheme may be updated with next six monthly proqress report. Regular submission of six monthly progress report in soft and hard copy may be ensured in 1st week of June & December as the same will be displayed on the Web site of the Ministry of Environment & Forests. Next six monthly progress report is due in 1st week of December, 2014. An early reply and 'Action taken Report' is requested. Yours faithfully, ~\\~ (Surendra Kumar) Director(S) Tel. No.(0172)-2638994 Email:[email protected] Copy to : 1. The Director(S), Monitoring Cell, Ministry of Environment, Forests and Climate Change, Indira Paryavaran Bhawan, Jor Bagh, Aliganj, New Delhi--110003 for information and necessary action please. 2. The Chief Engineer, Nimoo Bazgo Power Station, National Hydroelectric Power Corporation, NHPC Office Complex, village-Alchi, Leh (Ladakh)-194101 for information and further necessary action. ~an1Sf ufo Telephone No. : +91-172-2638061 Fax No. : +91-172-2638135 lIi'<dttl vnm "3tf{ ~ffi(1 ~ Q4'1(f{OI, crar vcr "1t'lClFlj qf{ClA"" ~ Cfll "1ll <>l <ll ~ ;;fa 24 - 25, ~ - 31 TI, ~ GOVERNMENT OF INDIA ~ ~. ~ - 160030 Northern Regional Office, Bays No. 24 - 25, Sector 31-A, Dakshin Marg. Chandigarh - 160030 MINISTRY OF ENVIRONMENT, FORESTS & CLIMATE CHANGE Dated: 07,11.2014 No. NO.7-52/2003-RO(NZ) The Director(S), Monitoring Cell Ministry of Environment, Forests & Climate Change, Indira Paryavaran Bhawan, Jor Bagh, Aliganj, New Delhi-110003 ~ ~ if d<>'clR.<Id qRillJI<i1 em ~lffUI fu;:ricD 4th & 5th August, 2014 coI ~ 'lJm I ~ ~lffUI cb ~ "Rlft ~lffUIl am qRillJI<i1 3IfuCliIRill 'R ~ cb ~ 3lal~«IllfRt &ill ~ qft ~ 3IR.iXII am ~ ~ l:[;f ftDl! 'JIRi t I 3lJlffi ~ t fu> 3lICH!'4Cli Clil~ql~ ~ ~ Clil41<>14 coI '4t 4~1<>I4 &ill qft ~ Clil~ql~ 'R 3WRI ~ qft cR I mr.r wm ~~\~~ (~ CJ>lffi) Ae~ICli (va-) Tel. No.(0172)-2638994 Email:[email protected] ~3-JT!f Ufo Telephone No. : +91·172-2638061 Fax No. : +91-172·2638135 lr.'ll1\ll;;nr;\ 3ffi(1 ffiCI)R qlj'ICl{UI, q;;:r lJcf \jj(>lClI~ q~Cl~Oi 1f:>lI(>llj GOVERNMENT OF INDIA MINISTRY OF ENVIRONMENT, FORESTS & CLIMATE CHANGE No. NO.7-52/2003-RO(NZ) 3"ff{ lffift~ Cfll'z:{l(,! 0l0l ~ ;.To 24 - 25, :HcR.~' ~ m~. ~~ - - 31 ([, 160030 Northern Regional Office, says No. 24 - 25, Seclor 31·A, D<'Ikshin Marg, Ch<'lndigarh - 160030 Dated: 07.11.2014 To The Director(S), Monitoring Cell Ministry of Environment, Forests & Climate Change, Indira Paryavaran Bhawan, Jor Bagh, Aliganj, New Delhi-110003 Sub: Nimoo Bazgo Hydroelectric Project (45 MW) at village-Alchi, Leh( J & K) by NHPC Ltd.- Site inspection regarding. Ref: MoEF's letter No.J-12011/3/2005-IA-1 dated 30th May, 2005. Sir, Please find enclosed herewith site inspection report of above cited Project which was monitored by the undersigned on 4th & 5th August, 2014. The salient features of non compliance of few environmental safeguards in brief are given below: 1. Latest monitoring reports in respect of ambient air quality, noise levels, water quality at project working sites and silt rate in the river Indus are yet to be submitted. 2. Benefit cost ratio of the project with internal rate of return for the year 2013-2014 & 2014-2015 is yet to be submitted. 3. CAT Plan implementation and implementation Biodiversity Plan are slow. 4. Uploading of six monthly progress report and monitoring reports on the web site of the Company is yet to be ensured. Recommendations for action keepmg m view the nature and extent of violation m reference t 0 M mrs "t rvs ' DOltt ae . e er No. J11014/267/2007IAlldtd25062007 S.No. Nature and extent of violation Further course of action recommended ---1. No violation detected Minor violations (not serious in As regards implementation 2. of environmental safeguards laid down in nature) detected. MoEF's clearance letter, the progress of implementation of a few conditions is very slow. Hence, a non-compliance/suggestive letter is being written to rectify/improve them and submit 'An action taken report' 3. SiQnificant violations detected. NA NA 4. Serious violations detected. rhls IS for your Information and necessary action please. Yours faithfully, ~~\~~ (Surendr~Kumar) Director(S) Tel. No. (0172)-2638994 EMail:[email protected] Encl. as above: Ministry of Environment, Forests & Climate Change Northern Regional Office Chandigarh DATA SHEET 1. 2. 3. Project Type: Name of the Project: Clearance letter (s)1 O.M No. & dates: 4. Location: a) District (s) b) State (s) c) Latitudes/longitudes 5. Address for correspondence: a) Address of Concerned Project Chief Engineer (with Pin Code/ Tel No.lTelex/Fax No.1 E. Mail address) Nimoo Bazgo HE Project (45 MW) Hydro-electric project a) J-12011 /3/2005-IA-1 dated 30.05.2005. No Forest Land required. A no objection in this regard has been obtained from Forest Dept., Govt. of J&K vide letter No. CC/FC/423/348- 50 dated 24.6.2004. a) Chief Engineer, NHPC Ltd., Silk Route Inn, Lower Skara, LEHO, Near BSNL Complex, Leh (Ladakh), J&K - 194 101 Phone: 01982-250089, Fax: 01982 255411, E-mail: [email protected] b) The Executive Director, Corporate Planning Division, NHPC Office Complex, Sector-33, Faridabad-121 003. Telefax: 0129- 2271425 6. Salient features: a) of the project It is a run of the river Scheme having 60 MW power generation capacity. b) of the environmental management plans S. No 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. . EMP Biodiversity Conservation CAT Plan Fisheries Development Health Care Energy Alternatives Muck Disposal Restoration of borrow areas ,quarry & construction sites Reservoir Rim stability, treatment and green belt creation. Solid Waste Mqt. Disaster Manaqement Plan Environmental Monitoring Programme Resettlement and Rehabilitation Total Tot al (Rs. in lakhs) 69.00 265.83 118.70 55.00 25.00 40.60 75.00 31.00 27.50 110.00 20.00 53.60 891.23 --2- 7. Break up of the project area a) Submergence area: Forest land Private Land a) Submergence Area: 287.67 ha Forest area: Nil I. Others: II. - Pvt. Land: 15.50 ha - Govt. land: 265.20 ha - Army land: 6.97 ha b) Others: 77.91 ha - Pvt. Land: 2.57 ha - Govt. land: 75.34 ha Total: 365.58 ha. 8. Break up of project affected population with enumeration of those losing houses /dwelling units only, agricultural land only both dwelling units and agricultural land and landless labourers/artisans. a) SC/ST/Adivasis 9. b) Others Financial details: a) Project cost as originally planned and subsequent revised estimates and the year of price reference. b) Allocations made for environmental management plans with item wise and year wise break up. c) Benefit cost ratio/Internal Rate of Return and the year of assessment. d) Whether (c) includes the cost of environmental management as shown in b) above. e) Actual expenditure incurred on the project so far. f) Actual expenditure incurred on the environmental management plans so far: No. of families getting affected- 19 Population - 104 persons from 4 villages. Losing house only- Nil. Losing private land- 19 families Loosing both house and Private land- Nil a) 19 b) Nil a) Approved cost: Rs. 611.01 crores (at Dec. 2005 PL). b) RS.1006.00+Rs.1144Iacs= 2150.00 lacs Yet to be informed Yes Rs. 917.38 crores upto March, 2014 Rs. 1127.78 lacs till March, 2014 --3- 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. Forest land requirement: a) the status of approval for diversion of forest land for nonforestry use. b) the status of clear felling. Not applicable Not applicable Not applicable c) the status of compensatory afforestation, if any. d) Comments on the viability & sustainability of compensatory afforestation programme in the light of actual field experience so far. The status of clear felling in nonforest areas (such as submergence area of reservoir, approach road) if .any, with quantitative information. Status of construction: a) Date of commencement (actual and/or planned) Not applicable Not applicable November, 2006 (Actual) b) Date of completion (actual and/or planned) March, 2013 Reasons for the delay if the project is yet to start: Dates of site visits a) Date of previous site visit Not applicable. b) Date of present site visit: Nil 4-5.08.2014 (A) From NHPC Ltd. and others: 1. Dr. Abid Nazir, Env. Officer 2. Sri. P.K. Saxena, Mgr (Civil/Env), (8) From MOEF, NRO, Chandigarh Shri Surendra Kumar, Director, MoEF, [\IRO, Chandigarh PART-II STATUS OF COMPLIANCE & PART-III DETAILED MONITORING REPORT l\Jimoo-Bazgo Hydro Electric project (45 IVlW) is a run of the river scheme on the Indus River about one km. upstream at village-Alchi in Leh district of Jammu & Kashmir. A concrete gravity dam with 57 meter height from deepest foundation level will be constructed.Total land requirement is 515.20 hectare. Out of that 12 hectare is private th land and rest 503.20 hectare is government land.The 11 Century Alchi Monastery is located 1.4 km down stream of the project site. Due to this project a total of 19 families from four villages will be affected on account of acquisition of their land. Public hearing was held on 15.12.2004 at village-Saspol, district Leh. The capital cost of the project is --4- 637.97 crores at January, 2004 price level. The project construction was started 2006 and the project has been completed in March, 2013. Partially complied For catchment Area Treatment, land for nursery has been developed near Saspol by Forest Department, Leh under Biodiversity Conservation Plan. The work on engineering measures as proposed under the CAT plan has been started in specific sub watersheds, on deposit basis, by Forest Department and Soil Conservation Department, Leh based on their detailed proposal submitted to the project. Engineering works as well as biological works have been done in CAT Plan implementation. Out of total budget allocation of RS.265.83 lacs, funds to the tune of RS.227.84 lacs have been spent by March, 2014. The PA has been asked to submit physical and financial progress about the CAT Plan implementation. Condition No.(ii) NOC from Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) for Alchi Monastery should be obtained before starting any construction activity. Complied NOC has been obtained from ASI vide letter No. F.No. 24/07/2005-M dated 08.3.2006. Condition No.(iii) Resettlement & Rehabilitation package for 19 families a proposed in EMP should be implemented in toto. The economic rehabilitation of the affected population should be covered through training e.g. computer vocational education, food processing, electronic/mechanical jobs etc. Being complied Land acquisition was carried by J&K State Department. The final list of project affected Persons (PAFs) has been received from State Govt. R&R is being implemented as per R&R plan. Against the budget provision of RS.53.60 lacs, funds to the tune of RS.163.21 lacs have been spent so far. The PA has been asked to submit physical and financial progress about the R & R Scheme implementation. Condition No.(iv) The solatium for the project affected families should be given 30 percent of land price in line with the government of India guidelines. Complied Solatium for PAFs was paid as per the existing rates. Condition No.(v) The proposed Fisheries Development Plan should Under be implemented in consultation with the State compliance Fisheries Department. For development of fish hatchery land near Chhuchot Shamma (4 Kanal 8 Malra) has been acquired near Leh. Two instalments of Rs.29.675 lacs & Rs. 45.00 Lacs have --5- been released for Fisheries Management Plan in favour of Commissioner Secretary, Forest & Fisheries, J&K for the above works. Total budget allocation is RS.118.70 lacs. Condition No.(vi) The Biodiversity conservation Plan proposed for protection of Flora & Fauna of the project area as well as catchment area on page 18 of EMP, should be followed in toto. Under compliance Biodiversity Conservation Plan is being implemented along with Catchment Area Treatment Plan. Funds to the tune of RS.69.00 lacs have been kept in the budget out of which funds to the tune of RS.1 0.62 lacs have been spent till date. Part B: General Conditions: Condition No.(i) Adequate free fuel arrangement should be made for the labour force engaged in the construction work at project cost so that indiscriminate felling of trees is prevented. Fuel depot may be opened at the site of provide the fuel (Kerosene/Wood/LPG). Complied The project is commissioned and is under operation. Free fuel (LPG cylinders) had been supplied in the mess of labourers and workers. Condition No.(ii) Medical facilities as well as recreational facilities should also be provided for the labourers. Complied NHPC Project dispensary is having one doctor, 3 nurses and 1 dresser to cater to the medical needs of PAFs, locals and labors, free of cost. Condition No.(iii) All the labourers to be engaged for construction works should be thoroughly examined by health personnel and adequately treated before issuing them work permit. Complied The project is commissioned and is under operation. All labourers have been examined by the doctors of the contractor. No labourer had been reported to b~ suffering from noticeable contagious illness is working at project. Condition No.(iv) A Monitoring Committee for R&R should be Being complied constituted which must include representatives of project affected persons from 5T category and a woman beneficiary. A Monitoring Committee for R&R has been constituted after consultation with Deputy Commissioner/Chief Executive Office, Ladakh Autonomous Hill Development Council (LAHDC), Leh and includes representative from PAF's, ST category and a woman beneficiary. Third meeting was held under the Chairmanship of DC/CEO, LAHDC on 11.12.2008. --6- Condition No.(v) area including Restoration of construction dumping site of excavated materials should be ensured by levelling, filling up of burrow pits, landscaping etc. The area should be properly treated with suitable plantation. Under compliance Measures are being taken for restoration of construction area including dumping sites as per EI\/IP. Condition No.(vi) Financial provision should be made in the total budget of the project for implementation of the above suggested safeguard measures. Being complied Financial provision for the implementation of environmental safeguards suggested in the environmental clearance letter of the projects has been kept in the EI\/IP report and OPR of the project. The budget provision and the expenditure till date are given below:Sl. Cost (Rs. Lacs) EMP No. EX~. Incurred ( s. Lacs) 1 2 3 4 Biodiversity Conservation Plan CAT Plan Fisheries Development Health & Hygiene 5 Energy Alternative 25.00 6 Muck Disposal Plan 40.60 7 Restoration ot Borrow fJltS & uuarry sites 75.00 8 31.00 17.00 9 Keservolr Kim I reatment, &Landscapinq Solid waste management 27.50 10 Disaster Management Plan 110.00 Proper sewerage and septic tanks have been provided in the colony Hydro Metereological Institute has been installed 11 12 Environment Monitoring Programme Resettlement and Rehabilitation 20.00 53.60 Condition No.(vii) A 69.00 265.83 118.70 55.00 Greenbelt 10.62 227.84 74.67 Project hospital developed Solar panels have been installed lVIuck disposal area has been protected suitable by engineering measures Restoration work . done Multidisciplinary Committee should be constituted with representatives from various disciplines of forestry, ecology wildlife, soil conservation, NGO etc. to oversee the effective implementation of the suggested safeguard measures. 163.21 Complied --7 Multidisciplinary Monitoring Committee, to oversee the effective implementation of Environmental Safeguards has been constituted on 27.8.2007. Condition No.(viii) Being complied Six monthly monitoring reports should be submitted to the Ministry and its Regional Office for review. The project has been monitored first time on 4-5.08.2014 and regular submission of six monthly progress report is yet to be ensured. The PA has been asked to submit six monthly progress report in 1 st week of December and 1 st week of June every year in soft and hard copies both as the report will be displayed on Web site of the Ministry of Environment & Forests in pursuance of the provisions of new EIA Notification No. 1533(E) dated 14 th September, 2006. Condition No.(4) Being complied Officials from the Regional Office, MoEF, Chandigarh who would be monitoring the implementation of environmental safeguards should be given full cooperation, facilities and documents/data by the project proponents during their inspection. This condition is being complied by the project proponent satisfactorily. Condition No.(S) responsibility of implementation of Being complied The environmental safeguards rests fully with the NHPC & Government of Jammu & Kashmir. . This condition is being complied by the project proponent and Govt. of Jammu & Kashmir satisfactorily. Condition No.(6) In case of change in the scope of the project, project would require a fresh appraisal. to Assured comply The project authorities have assured to seek fresh environment clearance in case of change of scope of the project. Condition No.(?) The Ministry has the right to add any additional condition subsequently, if found necessary and to take action including revoking of the clearance under the provisions of the EPA, 1986, to ensure effective im plementation of the suggested safeguard measures in a time bound and satisfactory manner. It is MoEFCC decide upto to It is upto the MoEFCC to decide the addition of additional condition on the basis of monitoring report. However, there is no recommendation from this office to add any condition at the moment. Condition No.(8) This clearance letter is valid for a period of five years from the date of issue of this letter for commencement of construction work. Not applicable --8 The construction work at the project site was started within 5 years of the issue of EC. Hence, the validity clause is no more applicable in this project. Condition No.(9) A copy of clearance letter will be marked to Complied concerned Panchayat, if any, from whom any suggestion/representation has been received while processing the proposal. I This condition has been complied by the project proponent satisfactorily. Condition No.(10) State Pollution Control Board/Committee should display a copy of the clearance letter at the Regional Office, District Industries Center and Collector's Office/Tehsildar's Office for 30 days. Complied This condition has been complied by the project proponent and other concerned authorities satisfactorily. Condition No.(11 ) The Project proponent should inform the public Complied that the project has been accorded Environment Clearance by the MOEF and copies of the clearance letter are available with the State Pollution Control Board & MOEF. This should be advertised within 7 days from the date of issue of the clearance letter at least in two local newspapers that are widely circulated in the region and the copy of the same should be forwarded to RO, Chandigarh. This condition has been complied by the project proponent satisfactorily. ~~" (Surendra Kumar) Director(S) Encl. as above: