Alfresco Security Best Practices

Alfresco Security Best Practices
Toni de la Fuente !
Alfresco Senior Solutions Engineer!
Blog: blyx.com Twitter: @ToniBlyx!
!
[email protected]!
Who I am?
•  Alfresco Senior Solutions Engineer!
•  Working with Alfresco for 5 years!
•  More than 2 years as part of the team!
•  Always involved with:!
•  Operating Systems!
•  Networks!
•  Security!
•  Open Source!
•  Consultant & Auditor: ethical hacking,
penetration tests.!
•  And writing about that at blyx.com since 2002 !
Agenda
•  Intro!
•  Project life cycle and security!
•  Planning!
•  Installation!
•  Post-install configuration and hardening!
•  Maintenance!
•  Monitoring and auditoring!
•  Other security-related tasks!
•  Demo: information leaks and metadata!
•  Conclusions!
•  Next steps!
The
Alfresco
Platform
The Alfresco
Platform
A robust, modern ECM platform
focused on scalability & usability !
Consumer like UI
Document
Management
drag-and-drop with MS Office intergration!
Business Process"
Rules and workflow that users can use!
Electronic
Records
Management
Team
Collaboration
Social features
content activity feeds & social feedback!
Metadata and Security
building rich context around content!
Ecosystem of Integrations"
CIFS, WebDAV, SharePoint, Exchange,
GoogleDocs, CMIS, SAP, Salesforce,
Kofax, and thousands more.
!
Image
Management
Alfresco
Process
Management
Rich Media
Support
Web Content
Services
Introduction
Introduction
• 
In Alfresco we must take security seriously.!
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
Because we care about contents!
If Alfresco stops working and that poses a problem for
your business, security is important.!
Security is a process not a product.!
Think of protection, integrity and privacy.!
Reduce as much as posible the MTBF, to guarantee
minimum MTTR posible.!
Taking into account the Security Plan of the
organization, Contingency Plan and Disaster Recovery
Plan.!
Project Life Cycle and Security
Planning and previous review!
• 
What should I secure? It depends on…
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
Project needs
Interfaces
Users, applications or both
Customization
Architecture, high availability and scalability
Document
Management
Interfaces?
Collaboration
Web Content
Management
Number of…?
Records
Management
Email
Archive
Customization?
It depends on the network architecture
B
A
Share
Alfresco
DataBase
Index
Content
Store
App Srv
Installation
Best practices and tips 1/2
• 
Run Alfresco as a non-root user!
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
Avoid default password (admin, db, jmx).!
Change default certificates and keys in SOLR.!
• 
• 
• 
Configure all ports beyond 1024!
Authbind on Debian-like OS!
IPTables port redirect!
Use keytool or your own certificates.!
installRoot/alf_data/solr/CreateSSLKeystores.txt!
Set permissions for configuration files, content store,
indexes and logs. Only the user running Alfresco must be
able to access this folders.!
• 
• 
chown –R alfresco:alfresco installRoot/!
chmod –R 600 installRoot/!
Best practices and tips 2/2
• 
• 
Before installing run Alfresco Environment Validation Tool in order
to avoid conflictive services and ports.!
Keep SSL active when possible:!
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
Use Apache (or other web server) to protect your application server
and services.!
SELinux (review alfresco.sh)!
When possible, run bundle installer to keep third party binary files
controlled and avoid rootkits !
• 
• 
• 
• 
Do not use self-signed certificates in live environments.!
Take care with SSL Strip: force using SSL and teach your users!!
Check your certificate strength on:!
• 
https://www.ssllabs.com/ssldb/analyze.html!
If third party applications are installed by OS rpm repository use rpm command!
rpm –Vf /path/to/binary!
rpm –V <rpm-name>!
Check third party vulnerabilities often.!
Post Installation Configuration
Which ports should I open? IN
Protocol'
HTTP$
FTP$
SMTP$
CIFS$
CIFS$
IMAP$
Share$
Point$$Protocol$
Tomcat$Admin$
Tomcat$AJP$
SOLR$admin$
Port'
8080$
21$
25$
137,138$
139,445$
143$
7070$
TCP/UDP'
TCP$
TCP$
TCP$
UDP$
TCP$
TCP$
TCP$
IN/OUT'
IN$
IN$
IN$
IN$
IN$
IN$
IN$
Activated'
Yes$
Yes$
No$
Yes$
Yes$
No$
Yes$
Comments'
Including$WebDav$
Passive$mode$
$
$
$
$
$
8005$
8009$
8443$
TCP$
TCP$
TCP$
IN$
IN$
IN$
Yes$
Yes$
Yes$
NFS$
Lotus$Quickr$
RMI$
111,2049$
TCP/UDP$
6060$
TCP$
50500T50507$ TCP$
IN$
IN$
IN$
No$
No$
Yes$
JGroups$
JGroups$
7800$
7801T7802$
TCP$
TCP$
IN$
IN$
No$
No$
OpenOffice$
8100$
TCP$
IN$
Yes$
$
$
Cert$installation$on$the$
browser$needed$
$
$
Used$by$EHCache$for$
cluster$and$JMX$
management$
Cluster$discovery$$
Ehcache$RMI$
communication$between$
node$cluster$
Localhost$only,$not$
needed$to$open.$
$
Which ports should I open and keep in
mind? OUT
Protocol'
Port'
SMTP%
25%
DB%–%PostgreSQL%
5432%
DB%–%MySQL%
3306%
DB%–%MS%SQL%Server%1433%
DB%–%Oracle%
1521%
DB%–%DB2%
50000%
LDAP%
396%
LDAPS%
636%
docs.google.com%
443%
OpenOffice%
8100%
TCP/UDP'IN/OUT' Activated'
TCP%
OUT%
No%
TCP%
OUT%
Yes*%
TCP%
OUT%
Yes*%
TCP%
OUT%
Yes*%
TCP%
OUT%
Yes*%
TCP%
OUT%
Yes*%
TCP%
OUT%
No%
TCP%
OUT%
No%
TCP%
OUT%
No%
TCP%
OUT%
No%
JGroups%
NFS%
7800T7802% TCP%
OUT%
111,2049% TCP/UDP% OUT%
No%
No%
Kerberos%
DNS%
NTP%
%
88%
53%
123%
No%
Yes%
Yes%
TCP/UDP% OUT%
UDP%
OUT%
UDP%
OUT%
Comments'
To%your%MTA.%
Depending%on%DB%
Depending%on%DB%
Depending%on%DB%
Depending%on%DB%
Depending%on%DB%
For%authetication/sync%
For%authetication/sync%
%
Only%for%remote%OpenOffice%or%
Alfresco%Transformation%Server%
Between%cluster%nodes%
Only%if%using%remote%NFS%for%
contentstore%
If%Kerberos%SSO%is%configured%
Basic%DNS%service%
Network%Time%
* Also allow outbound traffic to Facebook, Twitter,
LinkedIn, Slideshare, Youtube, Flickr, Blogs if you are able to use Publishing Framework,
Target Servers for Replication or Cloud Sync.
Control and review!
• 
Controls processes and ports used by the system
(Linux):
# netstat -­‐tulpn|grep -­‐i java tcp 0 0 0.0.0.0:50500 0.0.0.0:* LISTEN 8591/java tcp 0 0 127.0.0.1:8005 0.0.0.0:* LISTEN 8591/java tcp 0 0 0.0.0.0:8009 0.0.0.0:* LISTEN 8591/java tcp 0 0 0.0.0.0:139 0.0.0.0:* LISTEN 8591/java tcp 0 0 0.0.0.0:8080 0.0.0.0:* LISTEN 8591/java tcp 0 0 0.0.0.0:21 0.0.0.0:* LISTEN 8591/java tcp 0 0 0.0.0.0:8443 0.0.0.0:* LISTEN 8591/java tcp 0 0 0.0.0.0:445 0.0.0.0:* LISTEN 8591/java tcp 0 0 0.0.0.0:7070 0.0.0.0:* LISTEN 8591/java udp 0 0 0.0.0.0:137 0.0.0.0:* 8591/java • 
!
On Windows OS: !
• 
netstat –an | findstr <port #>!
Activate SSL for all services required
HTTP à HTTPS!
• 
• 
• 
• 
Appliance supporting SSL offloading!
Activate HTTPS on a frontal web server (Apache, IIS, etc)!
Activate HTTPS on the application server!
FTP à FTPS !
• 
• 
Check official documentation!
SharePoint (jetty) à SSL!
• 
• 
• 
You will avoid MS users related workarounds!
Check official documentation!
SMTP à SMTPS: IN and OUT!
• 
• 
Check official documentation!
IMAP à IMAP-SSL !
• 
• 
• 
Greenmail (based) or Perdition or Stunnel!
JGroups!
• 
Stunnel or Proxy!
Post installation configuration - 1/5
• 
Redirect ports below 1024:!
• 
E.g. for FTP and IPTables: !
•  iptables -t nat -A PREROUTING -p tcp --dport 21-j
REDIRECT --to-ports 2121!
•  http://wiki.alfresco.com/wiki/File_Server_Configuration!
• 
Change JMX credentials and roles!
• 
• 
http://blyx.com/2011/12/20/persistencia-en-las-credencialesjmx-de-alfresco/!
Make sure you have control of your logs!
• 
http://blyx.com/2011/06/02/consejos-sobre-los-logs-en-alfresco/!
Post installation configuration - 2/5
• 
Are you going to use external authentication?!
• 
• 
Replication Service between on-premises?!
• 
• 
Encrypt communication between Alfresco and the LDAP/AD or
SSO system (port 636 TCP for LDAPS)!
HTTPS!!!
Disable unneeded services:!
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
ftp.enabled=false!
cifs.enabled=false !
imap.server.enabled=false !
nfs.enabled=false !
transferservice.receiver.enabled=false!
audit.enabled=false/true!
webdav: disable on tomcat/webapps/alfresco/WEB-INF/web.xml!
SharePoint: do not install VTI module if unneeded.!
Post installation configuration - 3/5
•  Backup configuration and sequence!
•  Backup Lucene 2 AM!
• installRoot/alf_data/backup-lucene-indexes!
•  Backup SOLR 2 AM Alfresco core and 4 AM Archive core.!
• installRoot/workspace-SpacesStore !
• installRoot/archive-SpacesStore!
•  Backup SQL.!
•  Backup contentStore, audit, etc.!
•  Consider using LVM snapshots for the contenstore and snapshot-like
backup for db!
•  For small amounts of content you may use:!
•  http://code.google.com/p/share-import-export/!
•  Try recovery often as a preventive measure !
•  Add a checked Alfresco recovery procedure to your Contingence Plan!
•  Consider using Replication Service for disaster recovery plan:!
•  replication.enabled=true and replication.transfer.readonly=false!
Post installation configuration - 4/5
•  Disable guest user:!
•  For NTLM-Default:!
• alfresco.authentication.allowGuestLogin=false (default is true)!
•  For pass-through:!
• passthru.authentication.guestAccess=false (default is false)!
•  For LDAP/AD:!
• ldap.authentication.allowGuestLogin=false (default is true)!
•  Limit number of users and state of the repository:!
•  server.maxusers=-1 (-1 no limit)!
•  server.allowedusers=admin,toni,bill (empty for all)!
•  server.transaction.allow-writes=true (false to turn the whole system
into read only mode)!
Post installation configuration - 5/5
•  Do you want to have control of deletion?!
•  http://camelcase.blogspot.com/2011/03/purge-alfresco-archivednodes.html!
•  Disable trashcan:!
•  Create a file like *-context.xml with the following content:!
<bean id="storeArchiveMap" class="org.alfresco.repo.node.StoreArchiveMap"> <property name="archiveMap"> <map> </map> </property> <property name="tenantService"> <ref bean="tenantService" /> </property> </bean> Maintenance
Maintenance
• 
• 
• 
Daily review of logs and audit records (if enabled).!
Daily review of backup, and monthly restoring!!
Delete orphan files, log rotation/compression and
temporary files cleaning.!
• 
Use a crontab script, for further information:!
•  http://www.fegor.com/2011/08/mantenimiento-diario-dealfresco.html!
Monitoring and Auditory
Monitoring and Auditory
• 
JMX!
• 
• 
• 
Hyperic!
• 
• 
http://blyx.com/2009/11/19/monitoring-alfresco-nagiosicingahyperic-auditsurf-jmx-rocks/!
Javamelody!
• 
!
http://blyx.com/2009/11/19/monitoring-alfresco-nagiosicingahyperic-auditsurf-jmx-rocks/!
Nagios/Icinga!
• 
• 
Jconsole!
VisualVM!
http://blyx.com/2010/09/13/monitoring-alfresco-con-javamelody/!
Nagios/Icinga plugin
• 
• 
Always monitoring! !
Nagios4Alfresco Plugin!
Monitoring and Auditory
•  Failed logins auditory:!
audit.enabled=true audit.tagging.enabled=true audit.alfresco-­‐access.enabled=true audit.alfresco-­‐access.sub-­‐events.enabled=true audit.cmischangelog.enabled=true •  To know what is being audited:!
$ curl -­‐u admin:admin http://localhost:8080/alfresco/service/api/audit/control!
•  Rename: tomcat/shared/classes/alfresco/extension/audit/
alfresco-audit-example-login.xml.sample !
$ curl -­‐u admin:admin "http://localhost:8080/alfresco/service/api/audit/query/
AuditExampleLogin1/auditexamplelogin1/login/error/user?verbose=true" { "count":5, "entries": [ { "id":7, "application":"AuditExampleLogin1", "user":null, "time":"2012-­‐03-­‐05T19:20:48.994+01:00", "values": { "\/auditexamplelogin1\/login\/error\/user":"toni" } } Other security-related tasks
Other security-related tasks - 1/2
• 
Avoid information leaks through metadata (demo)!
• 
content + metadata in Alfresco DB !
!vs.!
•  (content + metadata) + metadata in Alfresco!
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
Consider using the new type “d:encrypted”!
Add checksum to the content (third party development)!
User blocking after a certain number of failed
authentications (LDAP or third party)!
Change webdav visibility root!
Session timeout for Explorer and Webdav!
Session timeout for Share!
Session timeout for CIFS!
Set CIFS and FTP on read only mode if required!
Other security-related tasks - 2/2
• 
• 
• 
Consider using a network scanner in order to avoid storing of viruses
and trojans or an internal action like ALFVIRAL (Google Code). !
mod_security to limit file size or intercept content (audit purposes).!
To filter which applications can access to services or remote API!
!
<Location /alfresco/service/*> order allow,deny allow from localhost.localdomain # Add additional allowed hosts as needed # allow from .example.com </Location> <Location /share/service/*> order allow,deny allow from localhost.localdomain allow from 79.148.213.73 # allow from .example.com </Location> Demo: Alfresco for avoid leaks information
Demo Script
• 
Starting an attack: gathering information!
• 
• 
• 
• 
Google Hacking!
FOCA!
Exiftool & wget!
Publishing/Replication/Sync contents with Alfresco (web
sites, blog, social networks or just contents.)!
Backdoors and metadata: yes, we can…!
Cleaning contents with Alfresco!
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
cmd-line-action-clean-metadata-1.0.1.amp!
Configuration (script + alfresco-global.properties)!
Add rule!
Test!
Tools, References and Links
• 
Gathering info tools:!
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
FOCA http://www.informatica64.com/
foca.aspx!
Exiftool http://owl.phy.queensu.ca/~phil/
exiftool/ !
Metagoofil http://www.edge-security.com/
metagoofil.php!
Libextractor http://www.gnu.org/software/
libextractor/!
Shodan http://www.shodanhq.com/!
Alfresco Security Toolkit CMD
LINE !
• 
cmd-line-action-cleanmetadata-1.0.1.amp!
• 
Cleaners:!
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
Exiftool!
OOMetaExtractor http://www.codeplex.org/
oometaextractor!
MS Office 2003 & XP
http://www.microsoft.com/
downloads/details.aspx?
displaylang=en&FamilyID=144e5
4edd43e-42cabc7b-5446d34e5360!
BatchPurifier - $19
(BatchPurifierCon.exe)!
Explanation:!
• 
• 
http://blyx.com – theory!
http://blyx.com – practice / POC !
Conclusions
Conclusions
• 
Working on Security could be sometimes a nightmare but…!
!
Picture from: http://www.defcon.org/images/defcon-17/dc-17-presentations/defcon-17-alonso-palazon-tactical_fingerprinting.pdf
Conclusions
• 
• 
Trust no one, including users!!
Nobody cleans documents.!
• 
• 
• 
• 
Almost everything can reveal information!
Currently we have tools and information available to secure
Alfresco, but unfortunately they are not on a single place
and we have to improve some of them.!
Remember: security measures have to be taken constantly!!
Other topics to be covered in future related to security:!
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
Security in development!
In-depth auditory !
Users, roles and permissions.!
Authentication subsystems creation (webinar already carried out in Spanish)!
SSO with CAS, Siteminder, OpenSSO, JoSSO, ForgeRock, Oracle Identity
Manager, etc. !
PKI integration or best practices for digital signatures, content encryption, etc.!
Next steps
• 
Lets use “Alfresco Security Toolkit” as main project for
collection of security related docs and tools. !
• 
• 
• 
• 
http://code.google.com/p/alfresco-security-toolkit/!
“Hardening Alfresco Guide”.!
“Bastille Alfresco” – useful?!
Any idea? !
Any questions?
# while you=applause; do
echo THANKS!;
done
Toni de la Fuente!
Alfresco Senior Solutions Engineer!
Blog: blyx.com Twitter: @ToniBlyx!
!
[email protected]!