Journal of Psychology

Transcription

$%''
& ,$%
#,
!
/ 0 *1) . )* +# ,& - (&
@# 03
* EEG
I
& 89:;< = > & ) ? 0
G
& A
RS T24 * B C 4C 0 ; / AP
& :;
T
E
X % B C 4C - ;A1
1)< # T
3 B ;<
T ^
# *
1 ; 0
N
@3 & 234 5 *67
E $D )A B C 4C
F* H F
@F & 3 *67
0 1B &
13 4 ,& J &
0 1M*N 4< & * O : ;K E 24
0
U0 @
4P & 0 ;A1 *V ;C W @* S *67
&
MK*
3M
#34 5 W P +& 6 0 K S
;. 0 2
**I
1)<
& 6[ E7K YW Z
@ 4<) ^
]
&\
^ ) * & B5 =S ( ^
0
(*O T ;* +# Y 4
*I;
G `
;
*N 4 < T .4
;
*N
.4 bS &
E , =*& :;< 0
K
&
;< 8 A
&
^ 0 *1 2 *
4<
+& 6 - K S
& :C * , 4<
#$''
$%''
& ,$%
#,
% &#$
!"
!
:
#
" :
!
! $ %& '
)*
-! .
( /
0 1
3 +
" :
+
" :
" :
(
!
,
!
&! : ! 1 2 & "
6777 :4 5 )&
! 67777 :
? '1
: ! >;*<
' B :C *<
F! G
,
C
H &
0
& 1)2*2 3 '%///,- ( )
.5
6
7 8
=!
1@
A B
: ? 5
. DE
?
:H
*+
#1
)& 8 9) :
&
+
4
& ) 3
F ; ,
;*& 4 @`
,
:
De$$ %%cdDDXhC De$$ %%e$$%%gA c$ddd$effd: ;K @C
2
#$''
% &#$
!"
B
J @ )*&
B
]#
4
3 *#
@ #
B
B
M , )*&
M , )*&
B
B
M , )*&
M , )*&
) @
J @ )*&
=
E K 4
0
&
M , )*&
3
4.
Y* .
J
4
3 &
R 3
@ O
4
Y* <
3
@]
g
^*
S *
@*F
4 O
n #4 *
o4
^*
0 j ;> i$
l: 35 ;> ik
g @E *< 4 & & ;> i%
0
4 +& ;> ie
*& ;C ic
Z# *& ;> id
RK *KW ;> if
F < ;> i'
m*< ;> iX
g# ;> i$D
SE B ( ;> i1$
0 @ ;, # ;> i$k
5 # ;> i$%
U5 O; ;> i$e
4 @> ;> i$c
= *> ;> i$d
#
1 ;> i$f
4 * 4 O ;> i$'
0@ O
;> i$X
;> ikD
&58
#
-
;C ik$
;C ikk
! "
#$''
% &#$
;*<
4
&0
2 S 4 @*,
$
l:
35
F < R 3 ;C
*& 4
;C
# o 4 ;C
$$f
=
$e$
4
$X$
3 ...
= > & ) ? 0 @3 $D )A B C 4C
@# 03
A
,& J
F* H F
& I
4P
3 M
1 )<
+& J
;C
3 G +*E3
g @E *< 4 & & Y* . ;C
E K YW Z
0
^ * ;C
E ;C
# o 4 ;C
; C0
4
;C
@F & 3 *67
* EEG
G
&
0 1B &
13 4
& 0 ;A1 *V ;C W @* S *67
&
MK* & :; E X % B C 4C - ;A1
P P ^ G 4 O @* ;C
M# ;C
W 4. ;C
:
3 B * @F U5
;>
*
& 234 5 *67
& 89:;<
E
0 1M* N 4 < & * O : ;K E 24
0 @ R S T24 * B C 4C 0 ; / AP
0
U
,* @*F @* ;C
0
gKW ;C
0@ W q ;C
= *> ^ *
Ir 4
$d$
/ 0 *1) . )* +# ,& - (&
;C
KW A,. ;C
P P 3 4 Mp C@m* ;C
0
gKW ;C
f%
$D%
;C
;C
0@ W 4 3 E
E:. gKO
g @E *< 4 & & Y* . ;C
0 *,# ^ @ O ;C
$c
%f
!"
T
#34 5 W P
+& 6 0 K S
1 )< # T 1 ; 0 N
;. 0 2
**I
(*O T ;* +# Y 4
&
3 B ;<
& 6[
&\
0 *I;
0 *1 2 * T ^
& B5 =S ( ^
T
&
K
;< 8 A
&
@ 4<) ^
]
G `
^
^ ) *
.4 ;
*N 4 < + & 6 - K S
:C * , 4< # *
;
*N 4<
.4 bS &
E , =*& :;< 0
4
#$''
% &#$
!"
% &
<2&
0 B &3 &
T0 * & 0 =
u ; > 4#
.@# &
) : 6;
#
: 4
3 *; &
8 4r &
- F
t! 9S F g
. 1
; K*
v ;+ 0 34W
* O 0 , 4 T0 & >
: > E4r i$
. < 8 > B & > & 3 @# ) Y > 4P &
B &3 2 g* 5 i$i$
. 4# 0 4< T@
B &3
w*G 0
, >
J 5 & * ( x> +K
Yr +K Z ) +K !
E 89 S i$ik
. 4# ;
F
Z \S E S RE ( i$i%
3 * # W ; ; k/c yAW & A4 - OAr
. 1 * 0
8 4r & ; ; $/c 4( - r
OAr - # o & Tz P
.
8:F
0 &B
4P & E - E S i$ie
& > E S )]K i$ic
& @# & @# * (Word 2003 – Xp 2001)
. 1
;> - +K
.@# & (Original Article) Y*r 89 S Y # @# ; / 89 S {4 i$id
.(
@. H K;W &) @ ] 3 F @# | OAr kD 3 89 S i$if
4}K - @ K 4 *;< B
8 4r & F 3 +K % T E S t ! 3 h i$i'
.) 1 @ 4< G
:89 S M*N - 4O ik
K*
& ;K & (Title Page B 4 - OAr)
- OAr iki$
@ K 4 w*G J 5 #34 5 1 T
- . T 1 4 <
T E S B 4 :Y #
T=
F YO T 4}K - @ K 4 ]* ;]E )K J 5
gA TB 1@ K 4
.@# & E S
~
(\& ) E S 4}K
5
$
#$''
.@# & 0@* > 8 >
; T 2
K*
4 Tz@
4
0
& &0
5- , .T 2
& B5 z@
; Y > l # :(u ; )
;
8 ,E ( 3 Yr W 0 ; & B5 - K S T ; M 8 ] l # Y # :•O&
0 *1 F*; T
;
E ;W & > B *& Tz:;< 4 € ;
4 *KA *.4
.w*SO 0 ; 3 Yr W 0
* -
3 ES 0 ;
3
E7K B *& :��
4 Tw*SO l P w*G l # :w*SO 2
. @# ; 1 > & 0 5 Y* O 0
.w*SO 0
T
!"
r:< Y # @ &
! 4 - OAr ikik
& B5 g;
@# ; *& > kcD 3 E S - r:<
.@# & @# # 0 *1 F*;
:@# & 3 4 Y # ;K & E S Yr iki%
. ;#/1 0
-2
% &#$
T@ ;# )E < w*SO
F
M*S;K *V 4P & K> 1 : ]
.@ 5 Y &
@G B 5
.@# & APA 2 & •& M*N - 4O >U :•& ikie
.@# &
# B 4 0 ‚4&
@.
4 T h] ikic
35 (vE[ @* 7 &) E S l:r
4G@
4G
F O 87* i%
.)
/, B5 8 SO
ES B h
.@# & B 1@ K 4 @ K 4 - @ & @# o RE ( )Or )*E4}K ie
.) 35 /< Y > >U & F 8 . @ 3 A; ic
6
#$''
% &#$
!"
$ #' (
$ )
J( @ ;J< K LF! G ,
@; #? @ ;! ! * CI '
CM N @
9) ;"
5 0O ? 4 )' @ P
Q R! ( S
@' !)'
;&
$
. " @ F, U
0 + L
F? ; + ) @T
!"
) * ,' #$
/0 12
. & ,-#!+ ,
3 % &
,
& ,4/5 12 ,
3%# 6
7 %
71 5
89
%#:90 %;2 " 5
#!" <%
=%
1
#>
. 4#
7
% &
#
@ %
; B
g F 0 `
!"
?% *
&
,
,
,
,
,
"5 ,
g
#$''
=>??
-. /
0
B
B
& =>
,
#
% &#$
!"
!
* ')+ &
$
1
1
B KW
;
;
&0
2 S 4 @*,
;C
;C
@*`!
'D Tƒ 5 - N J & )* +#
/ 0 *1) . g*& \&
& 4N &
.@ @# H +;
8 4r & T@ 4&
A eD B3 B 5 A eD C
4 35
0 *1) . & 3 4N & g* !M .@ ~ ƒ 5 )* +# &
4 35
0 *1) . @,„& ! J *S g .@# . TB KW
&
/ 0 *1) . J *S T /
.@ C
& 3
4F C 03 @ 3 =*& T /
; B 3 T /
T
13 4 0 J *S
3 B
B 3 g *& C
B =
g u ;
T 4<= B g*& g* !M .
4. 8 A T /
; B 3
4 <= B
=
g u ; g* !M .@ 5 ) &
4`, \&
/ 0 *1) .
13 4
G 4<= B
13 4 0 *I; C
;< #)*, . 0 *I; C B
4<= B
C
B B4* 1 Y* O .@ ;K*
/ 0 *1) . *&=* &
;< #)*, . 0 *I;
;# A - (&
/ 0 *1) . &
13 4
.@ @ B * g
; B 3 , 13 4 T 4<= B T / 0 *1) . ,)* +# :0@* C B 1j
. / 03 @ 3 =*& , /
8
#$''
% &#$
!"
& 0 @,; 8 S*SO \ 4 B4 C $B 4&
/
;* +# 0 1 g*& \&
/ )* +# 0
1
,& …4 < 0@ &• . T) @*
F
- (& 3 @ 5 ) & 0 ;
? 0 & .)
& @ 3 * B !M TB 4&
e
%
/ ($X'c T ƒ 5 ƒ 5) ƒ 5 - N & ; k 4<= B g*&
B 4&
0 @,; @ 4# g; MV * T($Xdf dJ c8 4xE5) 8 4xE5 - N &
f
;E ) ) B K
b+
B q T *I;
g g*& A - (& &
.($XXX T ;E T$XXd 'h*†4E
.@ C ƒ*À @` 3 B 4&
/ 3
; {4 ($Xdf) J 8 4xE5
X
+# R / ƒ & C @# &
0 *1) . 0 @ 4 R / B 5 N 3
RKC T)p AW g* 7 T@ @G 1 ƒ
) 4‡ & @ 4
1
#
R / 8 4r g
. 4# v*r4
* ` B4 &
;. )*,G4
$$
$D
ˆ$X'$ T @*
4 C ˆ$Xdf TJ
8 4xE5) )
& 0 *1) . 0
Tƒ 5 ƒ 5) ƒ 5 *KA
C E W .($XXX T ;E ˆ$XX$ T$% # $k * .
3 ; *& TB 4&
/ &0
, 8 4r & 4<= B @,& ‰9 ;W T($X'c
$c
& C @# F 0 =
RV T
‚
13 4 ,& $e 1B &
T) @# F ($XdfTJ
8 4xE5)
/ 0 *1) . J *S 3
A;
@,& g 3 ƒ
* 4`
g* 8 g*&
, - (& 0 & 0@ 4#
$f
$d
.($XXDT B4K *& ˆ$X'X T B
B4K .) @ ` 2 1
/ 0 *1) .
1- religiosity
3- Eysenck
5- Allport
7- Maltby
9- personal
11- Meadow
13- Shaw
15- neuroticism
17- Robinson
9
2- psychotisim
4- Eysenck
6- Ross
8- Lewis
10- Kahoe
12- Genia
14- extroversion
16- Janson
#$''
% &#$
!"
4<= B g*& A - (& 4. =
3 < & C)
EW g
& .($XXc TB
;E ) @ C 2 1 R / )
&
0 *1) .
*&
/ 0 *1) . g*& 0
, - (& * =
g
;W W g
.) @ @
T 4<= B
& ;
g g**
($XXX T ;E
$XXc) B
;E
& C 0 @# F 8 ,E ( R V C ) @S;,
;E .) ;< {4^4 g**
& T@
/ 0 * 1) .
4<= B g*& 0
,
A - (&
T
B 4F
($XXc) ;E N & .@ @# . 4F
0 4
yAW ; C
/ @ S T@ 4#
wO
& C0
& K S
$
@# & 3 { Y& G T($XdD) T 4 0 ; & ; & {4^4 g .@ C
& C
3 @ u ; T@
B
C
4. 0@ 4# * 3 g
.)
; & T@ ;<
/ *V • 4.
*& i
/ 0 *1) .
&
R* g @& .($XXX T ;E ˆ$XXd Th*†4E
;E ˆ$XXe TB
;E ) )
@ T 4 g B*
/ 0 *1) . 3 3 ;
Š^ 0 3 @
. 4#
@4
0 *1 3 @ 0 (< C @
N & @ 4# g J &
@ Š*^4
/ 0 *1) . )* +# g*& - (& 3 @ 5 ) & u ;
g YW & B 4 T *1 G 2 / 4 Yr g C 4r .($XXX T ;E )
.)<
ƒ 5 )* +# ,&
/ 0 *1) . g*& - (&
& & Y`
& 0 .) @# R*V 8 A; 0 & 3 A; & 0 `
g* ! & ;E
%
k
**I ($X'% T Y&
‹ 41) Age- universal (I-E) J *S 3 0 & &
0 *1) . 3 J *S g .) ; < Y* O & B5 3 A; &
5@@
1- Ford
3- Venable
2- Gorsuch
10
#$''
% &#$
!"
0 *1) . 3 0 @#l:r u ;
@# J ;G ($Xdf) J
8 4xE5
/
& @ 4 ($XXd) ;E N 3 C @
G *;<
*&
/
A; T)
/ *V
/
@. C
4 B * 0 6[ 8 4r
@C
*r4
;E R* g @ & .($XXX T ;E T$XXd ;E ) 4 #
,&
/ 0 *1) . g*& - (&
& 0 & B4 35 g T ;+* 5 0 4
.($XXX T ;E ) 4# A; T)* +#
$
TB
B 1) B
B1 .
4. * 0
*KA T
04 3
ƒ 5 .@ ;<
/ 0 *1) . )* +# g*& - (&
g =S & (kDDe
= Cg =
&
13 4
4<= B
C @ @S;, ($X'c) ƒ 5
4 35
*
0 *1) . & R / C @
N & g* q .@&
e
%
k
Th
ƒK T ;KE ) )
B 4. 0
4 35 3 =*& T@ 0 9 & g C
=
4<= B = C 4}K @ 4
g R*
g @& .(kDD%
B
B
N & .(kDDe TB
B 1 ) @# &
/ 0 * 1) .
* B 1 0 ; .@ ; 1 @
g =S T * 3 g
8 S*SO R V (kDDe)
g *N `* 14 0 *I;
& 0 .) g *N 0 *I; 4‡W @* 7
0 *1) . &
1B &
4<= B T 13 4 g*& - (& T)*K .
! 1 .) @# 2 1 0
, - (& @ ‰ ;
C
&
/
T) @ 5 ) & 4<= B
R / g*& A - (& * w*SO g
4‡W & (kDDe) B
B 1 Y*E g*
&.
g*& 3 (& g g
;C &
. @*C7 )* +# R / g*& - (& - ,E (
ƒ* 14 0 *I;
. C •O& ‰ @F * 0 *1 3 @
& - & B4
@
N & Wg &
.)
C @*E4
A; u ; @# l:r J *S & ˆ($XXd) ;E =
1- Egan
3- Resick
11
2- Falysetti
4- Davis
#$''
% &#$
!"
0 3 3
/ 0 *1) .
& & C0
& 3 A; & B 4
5
g Œ C
‰ @F B 4&
/ )* +# ,& g*& (& T 3
8 A;
: , . ƒ )* +# ,& R / (&
& 2 @ z@ =
.) 8 A; 0 & &
2
- 5- 4
, .
SD=f/$e) E
'k cD
B9 K1 & 3 A 'D T ^ W w*SO
* (n=eD) B
4 3 * .@ ;# )C #
B K 3 (M=c'/f'
- & MG
/
# 3 N 4 4 .(n=eD) @
Y*` B 3
.@# H +;
8 4r
- *1 3 @ 4
/ 0 *1) . & 3 0 & :($%'% TB KW
&)K
/ 0 0 *1) . TJ *S g
g .) z4(, ;K 0 @ @
&)K
&)
&
/ 0 *1) . J *S
J & .) 1 G A;
0 B K & ) K T 4<
:) J *S 3 e 0 J *S
M*S;K *V
M*S;K 8 4r & > )
8
3 Y` ; )K+ Y
0 ; U+ T
0 34 5 J &
& (& T @< & G w* - (&
C Y g .@
B
8 <5 & .4
1) G T
@# *r4
$
.)
k' 0 T
/ 0 *1) .
1R /
> ) @# Y*]
.) P <
$X 3
;
B 3
;
8 *W 1@ 3 3 0 4 < T E T@
S; T Y
B5 4
1
1- religiosity oriented
12
#$''
% &#$
)? & 3 &T
Y g
.3
@ *1
G
$
P8/E 4F
/ 8 4;
!"
4#
@*
/ 03 @ 3 C J *S g Y g* 4
/ 03 @ 3
/ Z
0@. 0 @*G
& 4
/ 0 ;
R / 3 / z (, 0 & 3
> B 4 )O
' &
! Y .)
X &Y ;
3
+# *KA TR / & 4
S;
@ TB5 Š *.
.3
b+
4.8/E
g* 7 & : ) @# 3 V5 $%'$ 3 B5 & F YW
C J *S g
& 0 J *S & B5
1
B *
& w P 3 J *S
T3
T; >
/ 8:
&
1
/ 0
1 g*&
F
4 *
v ;+ 0 2 & J *S
; )* & G g* !M .) ; 1 G
& 4
k
B *
& 53 ` C) ; 1 G
& 4
.)
Y 0 & TD/'d m Y 0 & TD/X% ˆ)K+ Y 0 & Ž > 0 AE5 R ^
3 *V & u ; g .) @ 5 ) & D/cf T ! Y 0 & ‰ ;
D/fX T 4
.) H4 ( 9 & Y
T 4#
& 3 \ 4; >
! Y 0 AE5
.) (r=D/'' P<D/DDD) , 03
* 2 3 @ 5 ) & u ; g* !M
B5 & :
C
O
ƒ B4 Y
0 & J *S g
& ; 0 4*# TJ *S g 0 /1
0 &. 5) & C
ƒ B4
8 8 A & .4 & C ) @# W P @ ; 8
& < 8 Y@
O J *S YC
* Y
h. g J
&
4 35
. 4#
A; (EPQ) ƒ 5 )* +#
1B & T( F* /8 6 &)
1- hedonistic oriented
13
4C
13 4
3 ;* +# ,&
& 4N &
;* +# @,& J *S g .) @ #
2- internal consistency
#$''
% &#$
!"
J *S g g* q
.@F
4<= B
(
1B / 1B &)
0
& B4 35 g
; )* & G
@ 4# .) • J *S @ *1 &
J *S g & 3 & ($%ff) @S 0@ O
. 3 .) @# 2 1 @,;
@#
O Ž
> 0 AE5 R ^ w P 3 J *S 3 Z
; .) ;<
& 3 4 €:
0@ & S P
T04;O
2
& 5
) 4‡
*&=*
8 @G
&0 &)
@S 0@ O .) ; 1 G
J *S ; .)
C A; * Y* O 3 E.P.Q
- * &
1
.@#
O ’/“• (L) J *S ’/“‘ (P) J *S T’/f' (N) J *S T’/•‘ (E)
.@ @# @* 7 04;O
N 3 J *S
;
,& 0 5 0 1 @;& .) @# @
Th . *I; )*
& .4 & 2 1
/
,& g*& \&
=+& .) @#
&
=S
& &B
@# Y* O
&
3 ƒ
*&=*
/ 0 *1) .
.)
=+&
=
g u ;
0 *1) . ,& *
;* +#
B
B3
,& g 8 A
/ 0 *1) . ,& )* +#
,&
;< #)*, . 0 *I;
@# ;<
;* +# 0 *I;
4 0
@# † ƒ
@ 1
O
1
# @. ƒ*À & B
B 3 @ ; z O g* *
/ 0 *1) . ,& )* +# ,& 0 & t @S g* !M .)
.)
14
#$''
% &#$
h.
t
k/e'
k/eX
D/cX'
iD/eX'
iD/cf
k/$%
D/ke
D/$e
!"
0 &t
S
@; z O
( n=eD) B 3
@ ; z O g* *
k/d$
%/dD
%/kd
%/dD
$$/cX
$c/e$
d/'k
e/%%
c/Xc
$%/d$
$%/ke
$$/X'
$%D/kf
c%/fd
%e/DD
kD/d'
g* * ($)
#
@.
( n=eD) B
@ ; z O g* *
k/df
e/c%
e/$X
%/fc
X/kX
$%/D'
c/ec
e/cX
e/eX
$$/%%
$k/fe
$k/%'
$%$/dk
ed/Xk
%%/df
kD/ce
4<= B
13 4
4 V
1B &
/ 0 *1) .
; B 3
/ 03 @ 3
4F C
* p<D/Dc
** p<D/D$
13 4 T 4<= B
B3
g* * T @ 5 ) & u
g B*
.) B
3 ; C
1B &
B
3 =*&
4O &
13 4
4 <= B @ ,&
B
B3h.
g*&
8 A
/ 0 *1) . , &
.) 8 A;
B 3 TB 3 3 =*& B
/ 0 * 1) . g* * . 4#
h . g*&
, 8 A
Wg & .) TB
3 =*& B
. 4#
@
/
;
)* +# R / g*&
@,&
15
! @. g
.)
.@ @# ;# /1 (&
@# †
@` &
# @. B4 *
/ 0 *1) . 3 @,&
; J &
4 V
T 8 A
0 ,
@
3 ;
B 3
;K
;K u ;
! & ;* +#
#$''
,E (
'
$
f
4 0 *I; 0 & B4 *
d
c
$
$
iD/%$
iD/$X D/$d
* p< D/Dc
$
iD/eD
D/dd
iD/kk
e
;K
%
$
iD/$%
iD/$%
D/Dk
D/$'
$
iD/Df
D/$X
iD/Dd
D/kd
iD/De
% &#$
R ^ (k)
k
!"
#
@.
$
$/D
$/D
D/D'
D/$c
D/D$
iD/D%
iD/kk
iD/kX iD/ed
D/dk
D/%e
iD/kd
iD/k$
D/Dk
D/$d
4<= B
13 4
4 V
1B &
/ 0 *1) .
; B 3
/ 03 @ 3
4F C
** p< D/D$
-3 4
4<= B & 0
, 4O &
/ 0 *1) . @ ,& u ; J &
•4
.)K*
, @W
”@ \&
.)
A 0 (& 0
1
- , 0 (& 0 ƒ 5 )* +# ,& 3 @,&
&T /
; B 3 @,&
13 4 & ) ?
;K
@S g 9 &
/
; B 3 .)
/
; B 3 g*& - (& .@
B
4<= B & B5 3 h
Y& G 4O &
13 4 & *
/ 03 @ 3 @,& .)K*
,
1B &
* 4 V
& 03 @ 3 C )
EW g .
(& A 8 4r & .4
/ 03 @ 3 C )
E W g .)
, ) ? (& g .
(&
3 ƒ –* & T 4F C @,& .@
B 0
, ‚
T 4<= B & *
.@
B
, 0 (& )* +# ,&
/ 0 *1) . 0 @ C *&=*
& B4* 1 - E ,
ƒ* 14
T@ @#
”: *I; B 4 &
0 *I;
;* +# 0 *I; C
/ 0 *1) . g*&=* 0 *I; B 4
16
$
k
%
e
c
d
f
'
#$''
% &#$
!"
. (F(5,74)) P<D/DDD @
B
0
, 04 E ANOVA Y* O
&0
, 4O & 8:* O h . Tg 0 *I; 3 ƒ –* TB4* 1 R ^
Y& G 4O & ;* +# *I;
•4
.@ 3
/ 0 *1) . *&=*
13 4
4<= B @,& .@
4‡W g*& =* 0 *I; B 4 & .4
4<= B @,& .@ 3
/ 0 * 1) . *&=* & A 0 (& &
P<D/DD% B=iD/%$ &
13 4 @,& *I; g*;K+ P<D/DDD B=iD/e' &
, B @& g TB @S
A ) : & .4 .@
*&=* B3 g 9 &
.@&
=
/ 0 *1) . @S T 4<= B = C & C )
0 *1 F*; •O&
- , 04 E
/ 0 *1) . )* +# ,& (& T=
g u ; J &
; B 3
A - (& g 9 &
/ 0 *1) . .@
)
&0
.@
B
4<= B &
, )?
;K g 9 &
/
EW )
/
; B 3 B5 3 ;K
@S g 9 & T 13 4 @,&
- (&
13 4 & A 8 4r &
/ 03 @ 3
/ 0 *1) . C
/ 03 @ 3 T 4& *&=* Y& G C B !M * 41• @, & .@
-) . ,& 3 ƒ –* & *
1B & g*& (& . B
, ) ? (&
.@
B 0 (& T / 0 *1
B
B3
/ 0 *1) . C @
B
%
k
$
ˆ$XXd T B * 4E ˆ$Xfc T E9 )*& T Y*. 5 0
;E 0 ;
n
T)
1- Argyle
3- Paloutzian
17
& n
CŠ
=
g u ;
&
; & ; g ) B K`
@ C # B 4&
/
B 4&
/
h .
2- Beit-Hallahmi
h. 8 A & C
8 A @ C ($XXc)
#$''
% &#$
!"
…4 <
(kDDe) B
B1 0 ; =
g u ; g* !M .)
& )* +# R / & ‚4& 8 ,E (
ƒ* 14 0 *I; & .4 8 ^
0 *1) . ,& 3 < & h . 8 A & ‰ r
C @*
C 8 4r
T(kDDe) B
B1 =
z:< & g* !M . @*C7 )* +# ,&
/
g*& - (& u ;
0 **I –* B4* 1 E ,
ƒ* 14 0 *I;
. 5 @ @ R / )* +#
- (& &
($XXX) ;E 0 ; & =
g u ; —4 8 ` & :
& ) n
/ 0 *1) .
4<= B g*& A
g*& - (& @ &
($XXD) B4K *& ˆ($X'X) B
B4K . 0 ;
A - (& =
g .) n
/ 0 *1) .
4<= B
.@ C @*
4<= B
R / g*&
v ;+ 0 =
C 4r &
C Y @,
(kDDe) B
u ;
=
8 4r
C ) g ;` g M
. C *KA B 4
4 ! 34W g
: C r:< Y U 4
B4
)* +# R / g*& - (& C F * 0 *I; 4‡W $
B 1 @ 4# . 1 8 A; u ; @*E4 & F
5 g; 1 @
.) .4 Y& G * 3 g
o +;
, .3
4 C
& 0 *1 3 @ 0 &
k
4 0 3@
39 h
- O & G A;
4 0 & C 1
g & p
4F
0 4 …4 < ($XXX) ;E - NW: .)K* N
.) ;`
18
#$''
% &#$
!"
3 0 •* 0 v*P
B 0 ;<
1@*q*
.
G .4 4
/
0 ƒ
34 5 TM*E ,
0 8 A
T)
C;
& .4 B @& ,E ( F .
.@ C g**
& 4N & R
0 B4 35 3 A; 8 ^ %
*
/ 0 ; {4 & .4 & .B 4&
/ ,&
0 *1 3 @ 3
A; 0 J *S B 4 TR /
.) )* @.
& TR /
g*& ,&
8 ` @. C B5 g ^ g* 5 8
v ;+
/1
=
& 4< 3 v ;+ B
* 0 *K&
4.4 0
3
+& @ 4
NW: g
@& .) @# . B K 0 4 &
: 0 , . =
g
B5 & : .)K — ( Y& G • 4. & B4
B5 u ; C )
.)# .4 g 3 0 •* & 50 =
@ &g
&
v ;+ 0 B4 35 3 0 *1 & C )# @*C @ &
; g & 8 ` g MV *
u ; @4
/ 8 ,E ( & ‚4& 0 3 @
E ;W 0 (< = C
. 5 @ @ 0 {4 ;
'd/Df/%D
'f/DX/k$
''/Dk/%D
19
: E S - *E - +K )
~
: ES
- +K )
~
: ES 2 / ~
#$''
% &#$
!"
References
•&
/ 0 *1) . g*& \&
T ;*&
,& .($%'%) ;* 5 Tƒ# 0 TB KW
/ 0 *1) . J *S & 3 ˆ
):
.e$id% OAr k
#T !
F .
4
- *1) . J *S ˜&
F
;
˜
˜
.B
-
;
.B Ar
&
H4
&
@#
& .($%'e) -
˜
&
TB KW ˜
l P .˜ /
&
.($%ff)
T @S 0@ O @
# C E .(EPQ) ƒ 5 ;* +#
F
Allport, G.W., & Ross, J.M. (1967). Personal Religious Orientation and
Pprejudice. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 5, 432-433.
Argyle, M., & Beit-Hallahmi, B. (1975). The Social Psychology of Religion.
London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
Bahrami Ehsan, H. & Tashk, A. (2004). Aspects of Relation between
Religious Orientation and Mental Health: Assessment of Religious
Orientation Scale. Journal of Psychology and Education, 34, 2, 41-63.
Egan, E.; Kroll, J.; Carey, K.; Johnson, M. & Erickson, P. (2004). Eysenck
Personality Scales and Religiosity in a US Outpatient Sample.
Personality and Individual Differences, 37, 1023-1031.
Eysenck, H.J., & Eysenck, M.W. (1985). Personality and Individual
Differences: A Natural Science Approach. New York: Plenum.
Falsetti, S.A., Resick, P.A., & Davis, J.L. (2003). Changes in Religious
Beliefs Following Trauma. Journal of Traumatic Stress, 16, 391-398.
Ford, T.R. (1960). Status, Residence and Fundamentalist Religious Beliefs in
Southern Appalachians. Social Force, 39, 41-49.
Genia, V., & Shaw, D.G. (1991). Religion, Intrinsic-extrinsic Orientation and
Depression. Review of Religious Research, 32, 274-283.
20
#$''
% &#$
!"
Gorsuch, R.L., & Venable, G.D. (1983). Development of an “Age-Universal”
I-E scale. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion, 22, 181-187.
Johnson, R.C., Danko, G.P., Darvill, T.J., Bochner, S., Bowers, J.K., Huang,
Y.-H., Park, J.Y., Pecjak, V., Rahim, A. R.A., & Pennington, D. (1989).
Cross Cultural Assessment of Altruism and its Correlates. Personality
and Individual Differences, 10,855-868.
Kahoe, R.D., & Meadow, M.J. (1981). A Developmental Perspective on
Religious Orientation Dimensions. Journal of Religion and Health, 20,
8-17.
Maltby, J. (1995). Personality, Prayer and Church Attendance among U.S.
Female Adults. The Journal of Social Psychology, 135, 529-531.
Maltby, J., & Lewis, C.A. (1996). Measuring Intrinsic and Extrinsic
Orientation Toward Religion: Amendments for use Among Religious
and Non-religious Samples. Personality and Individual Differences, 21,
937-946.
Maltby, J., McCollam, P., & Millar, D. (1994). Religiosity and Obsessionality: A
Refinement. Journal of Psychology, 128, 609-611.
Maltby, J., Talley, M., Cooper, C., & Leslie, J.C. (1995). Personality Effects
in Personal and Public Orientation Ttoward Religion. Personality and
Individual Differences, 19, 157-163.
Maltby, J., (1999). Religious Orientation and Eysenck's Personality
Dimensions: The Use of the Amended Religious Orientation Scale to
examine the Relationship Between Religiosity, Psychoticism and
Extraversion. Personality and Individual Differences, 26, 79-84.
Paloutzian, R.F., (1996). Invitation to the Psychology of Religion (2nd Ed.)
Massachusetts: Allyn and Bacon.
Robinson, T.N., (1990). Eysenck Personality Measures and Religious
Orientation. Personality and Individual Differences, 11, 915-921.
21
#$''
=>??
' 2 !-
678
4
4
*
*
& =>
9 :
#
.;
% &#$
!"
!
$ < 2 "
123 4
5
! ?@
=
>)3> $)
J@
4
@# J # C E:. gKO
J @ ” 4C *E &
@# J # C 0@ W 4 3 E
1
; i g @E *< 4 & & Y* . ;C
@ #
1
; 0 *,# ^ @ O ;C
@*`!
= C & (3P) ) ? 0 @ 3 0
& J & g @E ) @ 234 5 *67
&) . ^W=
,E ( g .) @# F T@
B ; # 0 E $D f K B 34 5= 0 @# 03
& 89:;<
B5 0 ,E ( 4 0 , . )
;C
1 & B4 35h B4 35=* l P &
35 # {4 3
2 & 0 *1 4 .@ # & @
B ; # 0 K 0 B ;K& 0 E $D f K B 34 5=
)
5 0 @# 03
& 8:` 0
C C 4C 3 A k' B
@# F 0 #4<
(n=$e) = 35 1
& @# H +; T 4& (T=de) 2 & 0 (S 3 9 & (CBCL) ” 4C 0 ;
$kD #34 5 0 K . '
k 8@ & ) ? 0 @ 3 0
& hx .@ @# M*KS (n=$e) ; C
B
\ 4 ” 4C 0 ; )
‰ @F hx .@# . = 35 1 0
4 35 0 & 0 S*G
G Y* O
F 4
; g U 2 3 A; & @ 5 ) & 0
)
.@# Y* `
1
234 5 8 K . B 3 h T ; C 1 & K S
35 1 C
B
Y* O .@ ; 1
#<
; 0 J *S 3 8
0 , = C T) ? 0 @ 3 0
&
T(P<D/Dc)
.)
C @* (P<D/D$) @# 03
& 8:`
C0
* (P<D/D$) `#B4 G 0 ;
@# 03
& 89:;< = C R ) ? 0 @ 3 0
& 234 5 C ) 1 F*; B 4 g & &
. 4# :; B C 4C
.TRF TCBCL T” 4C T @# 03
& 89:;< T) ? 0 @ 3 0
& :0@* C B 1j
22
#$''
% &#$
!"
B C 4C
;.
AP
4O
& .4
G: T ;#/ 1 0
@! P
B C 4C 8:`
C @ 4& & g & B
3 < & T ; * .) ; 2 ;K1
.@# @ 4< ;# /1
) TB 3 )#/1 & C )
4O 0
3 #
@ @4
B5
• 8 **I
4O @
! 1 C ) g )*,G
C 4C g*;K+ 0
C C 4C 3 0 *K& C )# .4 @ & T@ &
` & T@ C
4 B5 3 1
&
@ ;K 0 ;
AP 8:` @.
k
$
T@E
Yx *1) @&
@ * E K1 & ;W •4 & B
g ) g`
4P & R V 0 ;
AP 8:`
C )*,G g 2 / & ; .( kDDk
8:` g B
0* * & 0 @
.4 T) @ 4+ = C ,* P
%
.( kDDc T B4
) 8 C) ) @# z4(,
e
0 4 ) ) @# 5 & @r kc d g*& C 4C B 89:;< {4*# B *
0 SP
& 89:;< g .(kDDk T f C & d2 3 YS & TkDDD TcB !4&
:`
1 .@ 4# M*KS X @# 03
& ' @# 03
89:;<
$D
0 *1 C T 1 K TH (^ @ @
4. b+# « 4<»
C @ ;K
*&
1 C EW
T K. ) B @&
K. 8 `#
;.
03 ‡ T
CB / ;+* & @ ) 5 0 N; B
& • ,
@,; 0 =
u ; .(kDD$ T 94`
Ž #5) ”4 8:`
0 C A
@ 4#
{ . ƒ* * C & ; *& T @# 03
& 89:;< C @
B
$%
$k
$$
ˆkDDe TB `
g*; 4C 3 YS & T$XXX TB `
B T$XXX T g 3 C)
1- Gimpel
3- Cartright-Hattont
5- Buchanan
7- Barkley
9- externalizing
11- Kazdin
13- Costin
23
2- Halland
4- Flouri
6- Mash
8- Internalizing
10- Self
12- Tynan
#$''
% &#$
!"
k
& @ # { . 0 )*, . .($XXX TB `
4 & 3 YS & T$XX% T$34*
,* =+& /E T @# 2 1 @r cD 09 & 89:;< g {4*# B * T ƒ* * C
g*; 4C 3 YS & T$XXD TB `
g 3 C) @ 4# Y #
*E & 4 3
.(kDDe TB `
#<
`#B4 G 0 ;
1 0 @ *1 & @# 03
& 89:;<
%
0 F
; :;< T
C B / .4
:;<
RE G
C)
d
c
*67 89:;< g .@ @ 5 DSM-IV-TR
P3
03 ‡ :;<
0 ; .( kDDk T C & 2 ) @
, . B , T 4 < T” 4C & & +
g* q . 4#
F B9 K
1 3 5 B@# P & B C 4C g 0
#<
M;< v*,^ * O u ; & 5 0 *1 0 :;<
:C 8:` R*C
›‡
g @E & 1 4 < B 0 • , &
4 g* ! ;G . 4#
89:;< g
15=* .@&
= C 8@# & 5
4< ) W T 4#
0
8:`
(< • ,
@ 50
:; B C 4C
4& H4 ( *
f
@ ) MK* È
4 z
T & (^ =*& T S < T0 *1 89:;< B4q
'
B: C ˆ$XXX TB `
ˆkDDe T & & ˆ$%'% T)K 4C 4 & ˆ$%'k T”
$D
&4E)
;. @^ )* +# :;< T(kDD$ TB `
g* * ˆkDDd TXg*; 4
4 & ˆ$%'k T”
B: C ˆkDDk T$k B `
q ˆkDDD T$$B `
0 0 13
(kDD$ TB `
g* * 3 YS & T$XXd T$%n 9 ˆ$%'% T)K 4C
.@ ;K (kDDc T$eB4K 4 ) I#
4# 3 1@ 3 & ‚4&
e
1- Hughes
3- Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder
5- Oppositional Defiant Disorder
7- Angold
9- Marmorstin
11- Loeber & et al
13- Long
2- Breslow
4- Conduct Disorder
6- Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of
Mental Disorders (DSM)
8- Barbara
10- Milne & et al
12- Richard & et al
14- Davison
24
#$''
% &#$
!"
5 g M 3 C ) @# l ( 0 3 Y 4 89:; < g
#) H &
C # ” 4Ci@E A Y , ” 4C ; ) @
g @E
4 & B4
e
%
k
$
8 &)
T g*;
E 3 Y S & TkDD$ T 8
ˆkDDk T E & ˆ kDD%T B `
c
3 Y S & T$XXk) B4 ; .($%'% T)K 4C 4 & ˆ$%'k T”
B: C ˆkDDe
)K `# 0 F*; @# 03 B & 89:;< C ) @S;, (kDDk T E &
MC 8 N T8 6 & g* 4G :)
1
0 ‰94 , C @ ;K
@E g* 4G
)
& B C 4C T0 @ 3 ƒ {4 g . E7K YW v*,^ 0 8
T@ E Y x *1 3 Y S & TkDD$) B *C ”: qC ; g*
.@
—4
3 & (< T@ @ # *
g @ E 0 / )*E4}K v,^ T C @ C B *& (kDDk
@ C B * & * ($%'%) )K 4C 4 & .@
=
@# 03
& 89:;<
TB # P ‡ 0
4< & ‰ E V 0 ; 8:`
& :; B C 4C g @E C
\&
@ @ # R .4
# 4 u ; .@ ;K B 4 n
Tg < @E
0 Y , C ! T *1 G ” 4C
#R* 5 .4 C
” 4Ci@E Y& S;
@ C F B 4.4 B C 4C
0 ;
AP 89:;< @ 4 R
.(kDDk Td *&)
0 =
03
N 0
@# 03
& 89:;< v ;+ ,&
B * P ” 4C 1@ 3
C0 @
8:` Y*E & ) ; 1 G 0 3
89:; < g 0
0 2 & B
3 0 *K& .4 T@ C
F
@ # 03
& 89:;< & ‚4& 8:< @ B 4
C 4P & .)
CR.
X
'
f
, E g !4E ˆkDDD TB `
g ) 4O ” 4C 0 0
G
1- Burt.& et al
3- Smart
5- Patterson
7- Ervin
9- Wells
25
2- Bradly
4- Holenstein
6- Beena
8- Lochman
#$''
% &#$
!"
%
@ C ˆ$XX$ T)K 4C 4 & T$XX% Tk 3 & ˆkDDc T$B4* 4 3 YS & T$XXd
4O
@ 0 0
T( kDDD TB `
g 3 YS & T$XX% T 3 &
d
c
e
T n*C
n * C T$X'f TB `
g *& T$XXf TB `
@E4 5)
'
f
A* T$XX'
0 0
(kDDD T B `
0 3 YS & T$XX' T C &
X
.
G (kDD% TB `
3 @ TkDD% T 3 @ ) 4O 4 <
89:;<
C)
0* *
ˆkDDk TB
.)
& :; B C 4C 4
•* 4P & C :< @ g ;K. & 3 `
C )& 6 8 S*SO .@ # &
4O 4 < 8:< @ @
C &0 ;
B
;. 0 *1
4r 0
& $D0 ;
1 4 < 8:< @
`
3 @ ˆ kDD% T3 @ ) F* 0 ; 8:` 3 ,* v*P
6[ (kDDD T3 @ 3 YS & T$XXX T$kB4 ; i ;K& T$X'' T$$@ 4
TY? 1 4 < 3 (< Y 4 C @
B
8 S*SO `
& .4 &
$c
$e
$%
0 @ C *&=*
4# 3 @.
1 4 < 8 ^ , Tv*,^ 0 @ 3
@ ;K B 4.4 B C 4C
@# 03
& 8:` yAW @# 0 & 0@ *
kD
$X
$'
$d
T$XX$ T h
* & T$XXD T J4 0 T$XXe T$fh
* C)
k$
B & Y* ˆkDD% 3 @ 3 YS & T$XXD T3 @
3 YS & T$XXdT B `
kk
g @E 0 @ 3 0 4*# C *E 0 < @ 2 /E T(kDD% TB `
B
1- Davison
3- Kandall
5- Bierman
7- Pfiffnar
9- Sanders
11- Behavior Family Intervention
13- parenting
15- Marital breakdown
17- Davies
19- Robins
21- Silburn
2- Braswell
4- Arnold
6- Cunningham
8- Terri & et al
10- Forehand
12- Webster-Stratton
14- Conflict
16- Cummings
18- Dryfoos
20- Price
22- Dean
26
#$''
% &#$
!"
0 ; g 89:;< 3 0 * * 64 0 2
. 3 T@
G z@ 4
4N g @& .(kDD% TB `
B 3 YS & T$XXf TB4 ;
;K& ) @# &
0 @3 0
& T0 @ 3
1 4 < 8:< @ J & B `
3@
(kDD% T B `
B 3 YS & T$XXX T3 @ ) @ 5 4. & (triple-p) ) ?
G
;. 0 *1
4r J & 0 ;
1 4 <0 0
G
C
TB `
3@ ))
O( @ ! 0 < @ ƒ
& g .(kDD% T3 @ )
& C 03 (< Y 4 @ +&
V B C 4C ;N O Y 4 C (kDD%
.(kDD% T3 @ ) @
= C) ‚
B C 4C F* 0 ; 8:`
g @E 0@ 5 C 4<
AC 4< =
& T2 g
l4(
z@
4O S 4N & g @E 0 234 5 w P 3 C )
; B C 4C ;
;C
TB `
)*&
3 @ ) 4#
K*
:@ C
g @E 0 ` 24< 0@
0 & ; C• , B * &
w P 3 B C 4C
;.
E ; C 4<
3 z@
C 4< ThA &
\*O
AP
F
T
2
;. )*W:r hW T” 4C
4C/ 234 5 0
& .(kDDD
; 8
T= =
•
.B C 4C
1
2 ;K1 •
.B C 4C
&3 T #4 T0 ; 0@ 5 C =
•
.(kDD% T3 @ ) ) ? g @E 0 8
; 1 G @* 7 4 v ;+ 8 ,E (
) ? 0 @3 0
&
+& 6
3 @ ) 0 ; 89:;< B
&4< & F 0 4; 3
& g .)
;K& $X'' T@ 4 ˆkDDc T3 @ ˆkDDeTB `
3 @ ˆkDD$ TB `
ˆkDDc T3 @ 3 YS & TkDD$ Tƒ & 3 ˆkDDD T3 @ 3 YS & T$XXf TB4 ;
27
#$''
% &#$
!"
k
TB `
& 3 YS & TkDDD T 3 ˆkDDc T3 @ 3 YS & T$3
C ,kDD$
e
%
0 @ 3 0 4*# T(kDD% TB `
gC ˆkDD% TB `
n 4}E ˆkDDk
T 1 K T(kDD% TB `
n 4}E ˆkDDk TB `
& ˆkDD$ Tƒ & 3) @ 5 C
3 YS & TkDD$ T3
C TkDD$ Tƒ & 3) g @E M < J ; TH (^
(kDDd T@ E 4 3 @ ˆkDD% TB `
gC ˆkDDc T3 @ ˆkDDc T3 @
.)
4& 4< & (kDD% TB `
gC ˆkDDc T3 @ ) 4# 3 8 ^ ,
0
.
6[
C 4#
89:;< @
8:` ) * 3 & *
4
&3*
4& 0
. & .4 *
l ( = g T@ = C :;
4 ) ? 0 @3 0
& 0 4*#
Œ@ = C
@# B *& 8 S*SO & .4 &
@# 03
& 89:;< {4*#
B C 4C 8:`
@ 4 ;& C
& 0 ; 1 4 < 8:< @ 5
B C 4C
@# 03
&
2
h
B4 35=* l P &
35 # {4 3
T ^ W 0 ,E ( :w*SO l P
)
; C 1 & B4 35
0 50 4
, .
0 B ;K&
!
K B 34 5= 0 * C Y # =
0
4P &
@
! T 4 0 5• . ) . & .@ # & @
B;
& @ 1 ,. J @ g & hx H +;
K 0 B ;K& B *
4 ;A1 4 B 34 5=
1
^ W w*SO & ‚
J @ g
” 4C 0 ; )
TJ @ g g*E4}K & 39 0
50 , .
# @;&
3
g*E4}K
3 @,& .@#
1- Markie-Dadds
3- Leung
2- Bor
4- Cann
28
#$''
% &#$
!"
J @ g B 34 5= \ 4 Tw*SO z@
4
O*^4 &
(CBCL)
{ . g @E \ 4 ” 4C 0 ; )
Y* ` 3 h .@ #
g @E 0 &
0 @# 03
& 8:` b< #
C 034 5= %' T @ & B5 @F
.@ @# H +; T@ C RKC (T=de) 2 &
3 9&
” 4C 0 ; )
0 & ) ? 0 @3 0
& C @ C )& 6 8 S*SO Cg & .4 & g* q
T3 @ )
C
C g* 8:* O
;. i 0 ;G Š( &
@E
T)# 4. g @E 0
C ;< #)*, . @ 4# J & T(kDD%
4<
g* Š(
8:* O 0 ;G
;. œ OE 3 C (n=$D)
5B
@# H +; 34 5= k' )
.@ @# z/W r 4 3 T@ 4&
hx .@ @ 1 H +; T) 1 @ 4< 8 4r 5 4
234 5 C 0 4 B 4 &
1
A $e @, & ; C = 35 1
4P & B
g
A $$ T 4 35 ) Y*E & T #34 5 8 K . { # 3 @,& )
.@ ; 1 G
.@ @
G& ; C 1
A $e = 35 1
- *1 3 @ 0
&
=F
N 0
3 ` T
g :$(CBCL) ” 4C 0 ; )
” 4C )*,^ J & Tg @E 3 ` \ 4 C ) kŽ <5 0 & F & ;
89:; < J &
J*S
g
. 4# Y* ` ;#/1
=#
/H (^ T 1 K /
8:` 3 @
C ) @ # M*N DSM-IV-TR
0 ; g* 4G g; 1 @ T
CiB / .4
T @& 8:` T 1 K
‰94 , T‰: C 0 1 8 4r & T
g 0 J *S 89 [ .
#<
8 {4 F 3 .@ C )
Ar ƒ T 8 R* & C @ # & ‰:r
03
& 8:`
C0
T `#B4 G 0 ;
# < ; 0 J *S
1- Child Behavior Checklist
29
2- Achenbach of Empirically Based Assessment
#$''
% &#$
!"
TB
Ž <5 & F & ;
F
N & F 0 & .@ 5 ) & @ #
g T
;.
T &3 œ OE & 39 0 — ( 3 h ($%'e)
*
@, & 0 4 0 & 0 W @ ! 0 *1 4 2 3 A; & )
=+& % 3 * O
•(S J & K feX ;< d'X Y # A $e%'
`# x 0 =+& & B 1@ C ,. 3 0 @, B
# H4 . C T #
& ;
F
N
;K # 0 J *S
K . > . B;
*&
0 AE5 3 B5 0
G 9 & ‰ ; K Š(
(ASEBA) Ž <5 0 & F
& ;
@ 0 J *S 0 A E5 R ^ .) CBCL 0 & D/'c D/dc
0 & D/'$ D/de 3 B5 0
G
+&) ^ Š(
DSM-IV
* &F & ;
@ 0 J *S 0 AE5 R ^ g* q ) CBCL
G +& ) ^ Š(
@# 2 1 CBCL 0 &D/'' D/df 3 B5 0
- r & ” 4C 0 ; 0 *
@F B4 35iB4 35
g* q .)
@# Y* ` ‰ @F B , B 34 5= Tg @E 3 A $ke \ 4 ;A ' c
3
0 4 0 & t B4 35 B4 * 0 ; 1 ;K R ^ 3 A; &
Š(
;K R ^ - * C C B u ; .) 1 G Y* O 4 ;K&
)
3 ”: & ;K&
4
.)
4&
, 0 5 œ OE 3 P<D/Dc
$
AP 0 :;< - ; )<
* W
B C 4C 0 & 0@*C 0 * *`
4&
, P<D/Dc Š(
;K
R ^
C @# A;
@ g
R ^ 3 A; & J *S
;K
@; & * 3
4
.)
C) 1 G
& 4 & F
4 YC J & B4 *
;K
g*&
hx @ 4&
, 0 5 œ OE 3 (P<D/D$) Š(
rW R ^
& 3 4 YS;K 0
1 0 & t B4 35 0 * & F & 1 & *E &
1
g*&
0 /1
8 @G 3 =F
N g @
B
C) ; 1 G
1- Kidi
30
#$''
% &#$
!"
03 B 8:`
0 & 2 & ‚ S .)
@#
O = `
Ž <5 \ 4 q 5 &
4< &
C 8:`
.($%'e T
*E &
F &
1
@# 03 B &T @#
* ) 4& & & ‰: C 4&
w*SO
F 0 4*#
F ) . 39 \ # C 34 5= B
3 Tb*+
*E YW 3 @,&
B
g hx .@ C )C # ^ W =
C @# 84 T@ 4&
=
1B
@,& 0 W
.@ ; 1 G ; C = 35 1
4P &
& g .@ C )C # ) ? 0 @ 3 234 5 0 &
1 8 K . = 35
4
)*
) 4; ” 4Ci@E Y ,
;. 0 *1
@ 0
&
; B5
# & 234 5 @ g .@ C b+
” 4Ci@E 8: , 0 .
Y , Y; + 0 @ ; J 4 E C 3
g @E
0 *1 0 * ` 3
.@ C
*&=* B C 4C
5
;. @^ ; @ C
yAW
4<
0 @ ; 0 1@E 0 . & ” 4C ; C ) ? 0 8
T 4C/ 0
& T F *;
. 34 5 g @E &
&
;A ƒ Yr 4
&
C 4& ;
#34 5 K . ' Y # 4C/ 0
:)
4& 3 l # & 8 K . 0 4;O .@# .
&
8@
#5 3 h B 1@ C)C # K . g
:(
1 ) ? 0 @3 )
0 K.
; 1 G •O& 4
1 g* 4G T@ 4#
#5
& 0 4;O z@ & @`
@ 4# w 4 g @E g* q . 4# Š
B
0 & 0 ; 8:` )
B C 4C ; **I 0 & @
;<
4< ” 4C ; &
@
& C
.@ C g**,
31
#$''
% &#$
!"
)? ‚
F 0 &
0 ; K.g
:($ ” 4C @# › S )
0 K.
B 3 B … ;< TB o < & AP T” 4C & B C ) Or @ ) ” 4C &
0A g
& C 4#
; 4< g @E 3 4#
234 5 (” 4C & @*A
.@ 3 x& ƒ!4C 0
1
5 =S
0 ; =
234 5 g @E
g @ 4
0 &
0 ; K.g
:(k ” 4C @# 0 S ) 4 0 K .
& (... T @ C 1 0 )*E , B C M T A*r4 g* O ) ) ?
4 ! )G ! C 4#
234 5 5 &
4#
.@ & C &
234 5
0 8
;
F Tg;A1 TB@*
*
) . K .g
:(% ” 4C @# › S )
!0 K.
ƒ* ` T G A 234 5 @
0 ; ” 4C & @ @.
. 4#
234 5 g @E & ... B
A 0 @ * 0 & K. g
:($ @ 5 C ; ) @ ) MF 0 K .
234 5 ” 4C ; @4 & & S 0 &
0 ;
4# ) Or g @E &
M*S;K B
4; TM*S;K •O& Tg;# /1 B4 G Y # 2 g . 4#
.@# & g; 1 @
Tg#
& * g/ .0 0 ;
W g
& 64 0 & S 0 & ()C B 3 03
. 4#
:(k @ 5 C
; ) @ )M #0 K.
O T S( @ * Y #) ; * Y`#
234 5 g @E & R
0 ;
@#
, 0 2 `
& .4 & :(% @ 5 C ; ) @ ) M;A 0 K .
@` & B@# R*C @ 3 * @ 4#
•G 64
& g* * 8 K .
0
& T0 * 0 3 0
& Y # 0 & C 0
&
g @E & T@ ;K
32
#$''
% &#$
!"
3 8 4r & @ 4;& g @E
4#
234 5 0 ; 8 !
; Š* O
.@ C A; B5 3 4< ” 4C ; 4 ) @ 0 &
C 4#
234 5 g @E & K . g
:(B C 0
& =* 3 ) 0 K .
8K . 4 P @#
, 0 0 ; @ C
# (< 0 )*,G4
< ) (< 0 )*,G4
@# 0
& 0 )*E , ƒ* ` RE G
=*
S& 0 &
4
g* q
K .g
.@ *1 C & (B5 3 o <
. 4#
† B
& 4<
K.
TB
&‚
F 3 @,& @;&
C 4& g* ! C F 0 4O
C @# ; 4< 5 3 @# 413 & 5 0 & M Y& G
&3 & r 8 4^4
@
=S 0 A l ( B5 [ g;#
Y` J KW 8 4r
* K. B
.@
4 ;A1 •O& 4 g
K.0‡
—A &
@ 1 † B 1@ C)C # & @# | 8 4r & K . RE ( J4† r:<
39 .@#
5 &
g
) . T K . B5 & ‚4& 39 v*E ` g* q
4
hx
@#
Y G 8 K . RE ( K . 0 @;&
C ) CU &
& @# •O& T@ 4& @# . 4 B5 & 8
0 .
C :`
v*E `
B
4
.@#
;<
@ @. {4^4 & E ;W 89 [
8:` •
B4 35=*
@
F
#34 5 < @ 41– *
; C 1
; C = 35 1 B
T #34 5 8 K .
3 h .@ C )C # B4 35h
234 5 3 @,& Y G 0
)
.@ C Y* ` ” 4C 0 ; )
‰ @F
G Y* O
F 4
; g U B4 35 spss 0 4*x C 0
&ƒ C &
.@ ; 1
33
#$''
% &#$
!"
;
$$ @, g 3 C @# &
0 @ *1 & $ 0 #
.@# &
A kc ^ W =
@ C)C # B
YC @,
@. .@ ;K
;C 1
A $e = 35 1
A
; C = 35 1 B
B C 4C g 0 1
; C = 35
Š(
0 ,
0 .
0 35
1
t
@
@#
B
F
D/kd
k%
D/Xk
e/$
D/dc
k%
iD/ec
D/D$
B C 4C g
K S ($)
#
@.
b< #
z O
@ ;
g* *
$/Xe
kd/$'
= 35
$/%$
D/X%
D/X$
kd/fX
'/ec
'/kX
;C
= 35
;C
1
0 K S & ‚4& 0 @# @
t C@
B ($) @. @# †
4 & k% 0 35 0 . & (D/Xk) & & ; C 1 = 35 1 B
g
.@ # & = 35
;C
1 B
g
, 8 A 4. @
& &
35
;C
1 B C 4C g & ‚4& @#
O t @S
g* *
, 8 A
T O& S & K S
C @# &
.@# &
4 35
B
B C 4C
u ;
g* *
C
g* ! M
(iD/ec)
1
03
& 8:`
C0
@ ; z O g* * k 0 # @.
TB4 35=*
` #B4 G 0 ;
#<
; 0 J *S 3 @ #
.) @ 5 B4 35h B4 35=* Y^ A B4 35h
34
#$''
8:`
% &#$
C0
!"
J *S 3 8
& ‚4& A*r4 0 b< # (k)
5 Y^ A B4 35h TB4 35=*
@# 03
&
@; z O
g* *
k/XX
k/c'
k/Dk
$/cD
$/dD
$/fe
k/XD
k/ec
k/$c
k/e%
$/eD
$/Xe
D/fk
D/de
k/'k
D/'k
D/'D
$/$d
$$/f$
$D/X%
kk/de
$$/ec
$D/$'
k$/de
$$
$D/k$
k$/k$
$D
'/'k
$'/'k
D/f$
D/ce
$/e%
$/ec
$/%d
k/'k
#
@.
b< #
*I;
@# 03
@#03
@# 03
@#03
@# 03
@#03
#<
`# B4 G 0
& 8:`
#<
`#B4 G 0
& 8:`
#<
`# B4 G 0
& 8:`
#<
`# B4 G 0
& 8:`
#<
`#B4 G 0
& 8:`
#<
`#B4 G 0
& 8:`
1
B4 35
;
;C
;
=*
B4 35
C0
;
;
35
C0
;
;
;C
C0
;
;
h
B4 35
35
C0
;
;
;C
C0
;
;
35
Y^ A
i=*
h
B4 35
C0
T @ # 03
& 8:` = C & ) ? 0 @ 3 0
& *67
&0 &
#<
; 0 J *S 3 0
B4 35h i B4 35=* g* * Y^ A
35 1
@# 03
& 8:`
C0
*
`#B4 G 0 ;
35
#$''
&
%
-J *S
#
3
@ . .) 1
4
!"
; g U B4 35 J & ; C
.@# & @# u ; 0 @ *1
C 0 B4 35h B4 35=* 8 Y^ A g* * 0 K S (%)
& 8:` 0
; g U B4 35 J & @# 03
U
Š(
0 ,
Z
D/Dk
ik/k
%X
D/D$
ik/%
%d
D/DD%
G K S
% &#$
i%/D$
g
;
k%
g* *
b< #
1
$d/ec
$D/kX
$d/f%
$D/Df
= 35
;C
= 35
;C
$f/'d
= 35
X/$'
@.
;C
*I;
;
#<
0
;
`#B4 G
C0
& 8:`
@# 03
B4 35 3 # 0 @# @
Z C@
B % @. o @ u ; &
@# 03
& 8:`
C0
J *S 3 8
4
; g U
F*; B 4 g & & .@# &
,
O&
S & .4 & 41 = 35 1
8:`
C0
J *S 3 8 B4 35h B4 35=* Y^ A C ) 1
; 8
8
& .@# &
, 41 = 35 1
@# 03
&
1
@# 03
& 8:`
C0
`#B4 G 0 ; T
#<
h .) ; = C TB4 35=* & ) K B4 35h 8 **I & .4 & = 35
8:` = C • & TB
& ) ? 0 @3 0
& 234 5 C )A1 B 4
.) @# :; 0 E $D )A B C 4C @# 03
&
36
#$''
% &#$
!"
0 *1 F*; •O&
= 35 1
@# 03
& 8:`
C
B
^W =
0 ;
.4 & g & & .) ; = C B4 35=* & ) K B4 35h 8 **I & .4 &
TB
& ) ? 0 @3 0
& 234 5 C )A1 B 4
@5) &u ; &
0 ; & ; g .) @# B C 4C
@# 03
& 8:` = C • &
& ˆkDDd T@ E 4 3 @ ˆkDDe TB `
3 @ ˆkDD$ TB `
3@
;K& ˆ$X'' T@ 4 ˆkDDk TB `
& 3 YS & TkDDD T 3 ˆkDDk TB `
ˆkDDc T3 @ 3 YS & TkDD$ Tƒ & 3 ˆkDDD T3 @ 3 YS & T$XXf TB4 ;
.
4K TkDDc T3 @ 3 YS & TkDD$ T3
C ˆkDD% TB `
B4}E
)O T0 ; 89:;< & :;
8:`
C@ B
* B
g
* B
.@&
= C ) ? 0 @3 0
& 234 5 & ; 0 < @ *67
B C 4C 0 & ) ? 0 @ 3 0
& *67 &
0 ,E ( B4 C ` MV &
C ) B5 3 C W @ 4# T) ;
F @# 03
& 89:;< & :;
k
$
($X'X TB `
Y ) g @E 234 5 . 3 g @E 234 5
0 4*#
%
0 @# 03
& 89:;< = C
($X'f T C &) g @E 0 ; 234 5
ˆ$%fc TB *
P ˆ$%'% T 0 1 3 ˆ$%fe T O; ) @ # &
6[ B C 4C
.($%'c T0 G ˆ$%fk T= B KW
T234 5 6
@# 03
& 8:` = C & ‚4& 0 ;
& .4 &
) . 0@ 4 2 T ^ W =
@# ; 1 C & 0 < @ C )A1 B 4
g g** 0 & .)
4& :; B 34 5=
@# 03
& 89:;< = C
@# 03 B & 89:;< & :; B C 4C 8:` 3 0 *K& C )# .4 @ &
1- Parent Training
3- Behavior Parent Training
37
2- Dangel,R.F
#$''
% &#$
!"
g*
* 5 0 @ @ Y 4 @ 4#
; 1
4 < ,* P \*O
& B 3 g ; *& C KC 234 5 C ) / B 4 g & & .@
G \*O
R
0 ; = C ;W T@
& *67 g ; *& @ /1 ” 4C
@# 03 B & 8:` Š*^4
* ($XX') B4 ; .@
=
5
0 & 3
& g @E B5
C@
Š*^4 0 < ! TB C 4C
B ) S 4< 3
g Y& S
* B C 4C T@ 3
B C 4C & . 4
g .@ 4#
)+
B C 4C @ C
; *&
g @E T@
3 B C q*
B C 4C 03 * & •G 4 R V
C Y& S;
& ž4 0 < !
@# 03
&0 ;
8:` 3 0 *K& 0
T)
g @E g*
&
Y ,E 4;
4 ! C @#
234 5 8 K . g
g @E & . 4#
C @ ;<4 5 5 .@ & YG @W & 5
B C q*
;W C @ @& ” 4C
,P G T@ C R .
5 .4 @;& TB C 4C 3 v ;+ v p ) 4<
{4 g .@ C
@ * 0 * &
4< 0 ; 4< @ 4+& 0 *! 5 3
)O @E ” 4C g*& \& H4*, 0 < ! ) ;K 4 ‰9 ;W
@E ;
0 ; C F5 3
z P 3 .(kDDk T E & 3 YS &) @
G *67
Tg @E R V T@
Ž B
@# 03 B & 89:;< & :; B C 4C R
0 ; B4! @ C
P
5 @
4< B C 4C & *&@& & ž4
3 @ ) @ 4#
;#
@
‡ g* ! T@
Ž ”@ *K& R
3 ` C @#
Š*^4
#34 5 8 K . g @E 0 & .(kDDe TB `
0 *K&
3 T) g @E .4 R . R
0 ; 04 & B 5 0 )
& @ C
.4
& T@
F
; ” 4C ;G g @E T•G 4
@
& @ 4
4 ! C @ ;<4 5 8 K . g
g @E .@
2
&
B 2 3 @ = C
5 Tv*A< R
0 ; g;#
.@
) 4S
4< @ 3 R
0 ; B5 0 . & @ C 0 *14 . 5
38
#$''
% &#$
!"
4& ƒ 8 A;
\ #
;
&=
g 0 ; T 4 3
C 4P & @# 03 B & 89:;< C )# .4 @ & g g** 0 & .)
\ # T @ 5 4. & Y† K 0 4;O
) g` @ ! T)
0 @@
B5 & ) ? 0 @ 3 0
& C E4r 4 3 .@# & ;# )E < *
Y& G *V
50 ; 3
+& g**
5=S C)
0 4} T @# &
) & 8 S*SO
& .4 Y& G ) # w*SO g u ; P < g @& .) `
b+
0 @O ƒ
*67 g C )# .4 @ & @ ! .)
5
04 3 . 4# — V u ; M* ,
@ g & & .) @# F … < 0 #
g C@ ; 1 G
& 4 E fi$D B K \S ,E ( g
C q 5 g & & . 3 l ( B ;<
B5 *67 B * 4
@4
0 3 0 ;K1 T0@,& 0 =
0 &T 0
)
1 @5) &
. 1B
0 /
@
g@ E
B;
#YC2
234 5 G r 0 ` 3 ;
) ;K #
*
B;
# g 0 K 0 B ;K&
1 g* , B9 [K
.M*
` ,E ( g
@ C)C # B 34 5=
'f/D$/kd
'f/$$/%D
''/D%/%D
39
x
: E S *E 0 +K )
~
: ES
0 +K )
~
: ES 2 / ~
#$''
% &#$
!"
References
-B
T”4
•&
:;< & :; B C 4C g @E 03
;# @ & 8 @<
`#
4
. ,S&
*+
:B
:B
;F T
B KW
.@#
# C
.B
)< # .($%fX) . . TY
TB 4.4 B C 4C
0 5
C .($%fk)
:B
. . T8 ` & T.35 Tg
t ! T @ G: 4. : .
.
0 @# N @ @F g; .($%'$) `
0
.(M. ; Tn
h 35 ”
5
`# x
4+`* ^ @ O )
g F
89:;<
.g+ 8
0
: 13
.
i0 ;
4
B C 4C & 0 13
8
; :B
. @ G:
.H5
:B
8:`
= C & g @E 234 5
0 ;
. *E &
#B
0 ; 8:`
8 @<
.(M. ; T0 ` 4 .. 8
= C & g @E 234 5
`#
4
T”
Tg* * & T”
) 4 @ . � *E & `# x
& .($%'%) E V T
+& 6
013
# C B T(0 4 ,E ( ) ADHD B C 4C
;# @ & 8 @< `# 4
:B
@#
B
:;< M†: = C
`#
.($%'%) . .Y` T)K 4C 4 &
4. . .B
g @E 0 &
0 8
0 r:< .($%'k) * *.
: `# x
;
4
:B
g @E
& .($%'%) .
+& 6
.@#
# C
.B
B
.@#
# C
.B
P
TB C 4C
;# @ &
& *67 .($%fe)
) @ 234 5
:B
C TB *
* T O;
B �ADHD
;# @ & 8 @<
40
#$''
B 3
8
% &#$
; :B
!"
.Ž #5 & F & ;
.($%'e) . T *
?; B C 4C 2
234 5
+& N
.
&
F
Achenbach, T.M., & Rescolar, L.A. (2001). Manual for the ASEBA School
Age: Form & Profiles. Burlington, VT: University of Vermont,
Department of Psychiatry.
Anagold, A.; Costello, E., & Erkanli, A. (1999). Comorbidity. Journal of
Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 40, 57-97.
Barbara, M., Richard, R., Julie, M., Robert, G., & Haward, M. (2004).
Conduct Disorder and Propositional Defiant Disorder in National
Sample: Developmental Epidemiology. Journal of Child Psychology and
Psychiatry, 45,609-621.
Beena, J., (2002). Behaviour Problem in Children and Adolescents With
Learning Disabilities. The Internet Journal of Mental Health, 1(2), 4861.
Bor, W., Sanders, M.R., & Markie-Dadds, C. (2002). The Effective S of the
Triple P–positive Parenting Program on Preschool Children with CoOccurring Disruptive Behavior and Antinational / hyperactivity
Difficulties. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 30(6), 572-587.
Bradly, S.J., (2002). Affect Regulation and the Development of Psychology.
New York: The Guild Ford Press.
Breslow, R.E., Klinger, B.I. & Erikson, B.J. (1999). The Disruptive Behavior
Disorders in the Psychiatric Emergency Service. General Hospital
Psychiatry, 21, 214-219.
Burt, S.A., Krueger, R.F., Mc Gue, M., & Iacano, W., (2003). Parent-child
Conflict and the Co-morbidity among Childhood Externalizing Disorder.
Journal of Archives of General Psychiatry, 60, 505-513.
Cann, W., Roggers, H., Worley, G. (2003). Report on a Program Evaluation
of a Telephone Assisted Parenting Support Service for Families Living
in Isolated Rural Areas. Australian e–Journal for the Advancement of
Mental Health (AejAm), 2(3), 264-276.
Cartwright-Hatton, S., (2005).Parent Skill Training: An Effective Intervention
for Internalizing Symptoms in Younger Children. Journal of Child and
Adolescent Psychiatric Nursing,7 ,128-139.
41
#$''
% &#$
!"
Costin, J., lichte, C., Smith, A.H., Vance, A., & luk, E. (2004). Parent Group
Treatments for Children with Oppositional Defiant Disorder.Australian.
E-journal for the Advancement of Mental Health, 3, 1446-7984.
Davison, C.G, (2005). Abnormal psychology. New York :John Wiley.
Dean, C.; Myers, K., & Evants, E. (2003). Communicating-wide
Implementation of Parenting Program: The South East Sydney Positive
Parenting Program. Australian e-Journal for the Advancement of Mental
Helth, 2(3), 1-12
Gimpe, G.A., & Holland, M.L. (2002). Emotional and Behavioral Problem of
Young Children: Effective Intervention in the Preschool and
Kindergarten Years, New York: Guild Ford Press.
Leung, C., Sanders, M.R., Leung, S., Mark, R., Lau, J. (2003). An Outcome
Evaluation of The Implementation of The Triple P- Positive Parenting
Program in Hongkong. Family Process, 42(2), 531-544.
Loeber, R., Burkley, J.D., Lahey, B.B., winters, A., & Zora, M. (2000).
Oppositional Defiant and Conduct Disorder :A Review of the Past 10
Years, Part 1 Journal of American Academy of Child and Adolescents
Psychiatry 39,1468-1484
Marmorstin, N.R., (2006). Relationship between Anxiety and Exter- nalizing
Disorder in Youth: The Influences of Age and Gender, Journal of
Anxiety Disorder (Article in press).
Mash, E.J., & Barkley, R.A. (2002). Child psychopathology-New York :The
Guild Ford Press
Milen, J.M., & Edwards J.K. (2001). Family Treatment of Oppositional
Defiant Disorder: Changing Views and Strength-Based Approaches. The
Family Journal: Counseling and Therapy For Couples and Families, 1,
17-28.
Richard, R., Barbara, M., Andrew, P., Jane,c.,& Adrian, A. (2002). The
Relation between DSM-IV. Oppositional. Defiant Disorder and Conduct
Disorder: Finding From the Great Smoky Maintains Study. Journal of
Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 43, 39-50.
Sanders, M.R. (2000). Commuity-based Parenting and Family Support
Intervention and Prevention of Drog Abuse .Addctive Behavior, 25(6),
929-942
42
#$''
% &#$
!"
Sanders, M.R. (2003). The Translation of Evidence-based Parenting Program
in to Regular Clinical Services. Australian e-Journal for The
Advancement of Mental Health (AejAMH), 2(3), 1-4.
Sanders ,M.R. (2003). Triple P–positive Parenting Program: A Population
Approach to Promoting Competent Parenting. Australian e–Journal for
the Advancement of Mental Health (AejAm), 2(3), 1-17.
Sanders, M.R. (2005). Triple P: A Multi-Level System of Parenting
Intervention: Workshop Participant Notes. The University of
Queensland: Brisbane, Australia.
Sanders, M.R., & McFarland, M. (2006). Treatment of Depressed Mothers
with disorder children: A-controlled Elevation of Cognitive Behavior
Therapy, 31 (1), 89-112.
Sanders, M.R, Pidgeon, A.M., Gravesock, F.,Connors, D., Brown, S., &
Young, R.W. (2004). Dose Parental Attitudinal Retraining and Anger
Management Enhance the Effects of Triple P-positive Parenting
Program with Parents at Risk of Child Maltreatment. Behavior Therapy,
35 (3), 513-535.
Sanders, M.R., Turner, K.M.,& Markei-Dadds, C. (2003). The Development
and Dissemination of The Triple P-positive Parenting Program: A
Multilevel Evidence-based System of Parenting and Family Support.
Prevention Science, 3(3), 183-189.
Schachar, R., & Washmuth, R. (1990). Oppositional Defiant Disorder in
Children: A Validiation Study Compairing Conduct Disorder,
Pppositional Disorder and Normal Control Children. Journal of child
Psychology and Psychiatry, 31, 1089-1102.
Terri, L. Shelton., Russell, A. Barkely., Chergl, Crosswait, Maureen,
Moorehouse., Kenneth, Fletcher., Susan, Barrett, Lucy, Jenkins., &
LoriMetevia. (2000). MuLtimethod, Psycho educational Intervention for
Preschool Children with Disruptive Behavior: Two-year Post-Treatment
Follow-up. Journals Abnormal Child Psychology, 28(3), 253-266.
43
#$''
=>??
EF -
< EEG -A
B
& =>
-= - C
) 0
#
!"
!
D$ C -
" ) C - 2$
5
- 02$3 ) + G !
Jm @ )*&
Jm @ )*&
Jm @ )*&
B
% &#$
]#
4
1
1 *
KW A,. ;C
l:
35
;C
1 *
P P 3 4 Mp C@m* ;C
+&B 4 @]
; 0
gKW ;C
@*`!
)*E , & A
F* H F
@F & 3 *67
& ^W =
z@
T 4N g @& .@# &
13 4 0 1B & ,& &
& I
* 0 ,(G 0 *W
0 @# N @ @F 0 +K
13 4
0 1B & ,& • 34
; 8
J &
T 1B & Y #) 0 A kD 1 ! T
0 €:
Z K 5 ;* +# 0
4 35
.@ @# H +; K B 4F
0 , . 3 ( F* @
13 4 T 1B
I
* W 4 )*E , & 3 0 & .@ 4& (M !
T)
) h F;
&)
0 @ * & 0 M * ,(G
4 35 T A
F* H F
@F & 3 :<
g*W @# ; 4< B5 3 T @F & 3 )E W .@ 4 @
A 0 B F*
0 4*# & T
)E W
@ > ]
F* *V 0 41 & M * 0 & TM * 0 #
J KW 0 *! ! >
;] g & T@ >
B5
+# 1 > @ > ;
B u ; .@# ) 6 I
* 0 ,(G v ;+ W 4 3 EEG TYW g P .@ >
I )
* 0 ,(G 03
, =
& F
A
F* H F
>
44
#$''
% &#$
!"
F*
@
1B &
3 ; *& 13 4
1B
=
g T 1
03
, R.4 A
F* H F @F & 3 >
B u ; g* q .@# &
)E9
; T{4 F
. 4#
;* +# ,& J & I
* 0 ,(G 8 A; ‚ S
0 I )*E , 0 MK* ]
0 1Y @, =S 0 1B &
13 4 ,& > @ g &
&
A; *67
g @ B F*
4.MN
@F & 3 0
> )A1 B 4
T=
u ; & .4 & .@
I
* 0 ,(G 0 * W )*E ,
RG ,; 0 I )*E , 8 A; ;* +# ,& J & B F* 4.MN 8 A; 0
0 *3
B
T0 * * T
#R* 5 0 * 3
0@ @. 0 3 @ M ! TB5
. 5 B* &
T0 1B & T
* EEG
G T
T @F
& 3 TB F*
4.MN :-@* > B 1j
. 13 4
0 &4 )
] 0 =>
. 3 0 m@,; 0 0 = > 0
B F*
($XX% Tg > T ? B 4 &)
;.
P
0 = > ($XXD TJ@* >
T * 4* ) m.4 T NOE
B F* > @
B
& u ; .@ # &
0 ~ T(kDDd Thx ) N W T($XXX TB ]
q&) 0 *1M*
T(kDDc
;. 0 Y , (kDD% TB4K 4E ˆkDDD TB ]
4 4* >) Z j4E4 *
$
B F*
4.MN w 4
4 .@
G *67 )O ($XX' Tn >
; >)
@# & \
Z j4E4 *
;. T K. ) : 0 @ * 3 0 # &
> ) g & • Y& S 0 (S
(kDDf TkDDk TJ 1)
/Y x >) @# &
& (^
S < 0 :;<
& 3 MK* ] TB F*
4.MN
.(kDDf T4E & h *
)E W Z Y @,
1- emotion regulation
45
**I 4N
& >
1
—:P
E
& B F*
4.MN
#$''
% &#$
!"
v*r4 0 & R V 4 A g T ;< #B B4;
. 4#
; 1 > & F*
B F*
4.MN T@ ! .) @# ; 1 > & A 0 B F* Y @, @ 5
$
0
15 @ 3 * ‰ E T@# & * 0 @
0 @ *1 &
@4
k
]#5
B F*
4.MN > )A1 B 4 •G
.($XXc T34 4 J 1) @# &
0 @
:<
B5 @ @
**I @ @. F* 0 ~
F Y #
@ 3 0 & 0 m@,; 0 4W P .(kDDc TJ 1
K> ) @# &
4.MN
T
4 B4K *> T ? B 4 &) ) @# † B F*
4.MN 0
& TB F*
4.MN 0
0 ,E ( 0 . & ^ W =
.($XXX
e
%
& 3 .@# @ 4< >
03 &
;< # @F & 3
@;
c
0 @ * & 4SE & )m*,G4 Z *KA Y # > )
;< # **I 3 ]# T @F
d
F* 6 > ) 0 4*# & TB F*
& ˆ$Xdk T8 AE5 J 39) @ **I B5
Y # > @# & ~ Y @, 3 ]# 03 &
.(kDDe TJ 1 B . 3 YS
g H +; Y 9 .($XX% TB4K 4E J 1) ) 0 . B F* 3 & ; 0 3 &
ˆ@ 4#
A;
@; 8 4r &
1@ 3 ($ : >g 3 @ 8
ˆ@ # & 0
0 8 A J
& Y* O
F
35 0 ]; Y & G (k
@ #&
]O
0 B F*
4.MN
g 0 N œ OE & (%
3 Z
(e @
Y]# (kDDf TkDDk) J 1 0 N r 4O
'
f
~
& > ;
@ * & > ; 0
3 r 0 4 4>/
@ # & B5 3 > W 4>/ 0
0 *3
@# F 0 =
.@ # &
0 & F E T@ > @O 0 *& Y ) g]
A 0 B F*
>
M;K* )*E , 3
@& N W ] ˆ@
= > @ #4<
1- Awareness
3- Cognitive reappraisal
5- Construing
7- Antecedent-focused
2- Explicit strategies
4- Expressive suppression
6- Emotional impact
8- Response- focused
46
#$''
% &#$
!"
B @ & @ #4< 0 & F T @F
@ = > Z j4E4 *
;+*
& 3 TB5 z: < & .@ >
; *& Z; x
& ) g]
3
?< N WR +
.(kDDD TB ]
B4K]. ˆkDDk TJ 1)
0 )E W )* +# 0 1 > @
B
=
u ;
04 3
g 9 ˆ$XX$ Tg 9 ˆ$X'D T0 >Z ; 4>) @ # & \
@] & * F*
0 1B & 0 1 T ? B 4 & .($XX' T$XXf Tg 9 n *; ˆ$X'X T :;>
g 9) @ # & \
A 0 B F* &
13 4 0 1 ) ? 0 B F* &
v ;+ 0 @
& ;* +# ,& @ ! .($XXX T$XX' Tn *; ˆ$X'X T :;>
•
4 T B5 0 /1 *67 0 4O
@, B 4 b+ T@ /1
*67 F*
@, - & •O& T
#B
4O 4P T•G
.)
4& 0 m@,; 8 G
))
4& =
0 @ 0 4O 3 ] )* +# v*r4 0 & R
,&
N
& .($XXf T€ :> gK ˆkDDD TB4K]. g 4 4 ˆ$XXf Tg
& @* >
4. > )A1 B 4 T ;< #B 4
@# l ( ;* +# 0 1@ g; 1
k
0 *K& w 4 4 T)* +# Š(
(N)
13 4 $(E) 0 1B & Ÿ & @,&
)* +# 4
0 4 E
T@,& g .@# &
B
B AE[ 3
%
($XX' T x >)
;* +#
@ T )* +# 0@,&@ ! 0
e
T0 >Z ; 4>) )* +#
u 04 E ($Xfc TZ K 5 Z K 5) Z K 5
Ÿ & @,&
> ;* +# / 0 1@ 3 ] .@ # &
4
‰: > ($X'c
0
.
4< M ! & B5
T 13 4 0 1B & T ;* +#
& .@# & Z K 5 ;* +# 1@ T)
4 RK> ;< #B R 0 =
g* 9 & l4( R*C & B 4 T . g ; & & )* +# ($Xdf) ƒ K 5 S;
. 4 v*r4 d F* 0 @ / 13 4 c0 1B /0 1B & ;K. & )Ar
)* +# ;K 0 1@ 3 .@ # &
;< #R 0 & 3 0 8 Ar g
1- Extraversion (E)
3- Multidimensional Questionnaires
5- Extraversion-Introversion
47
2- Neuroticism (N)
4- Five-factor model
6- Neuroticism- Emotional Stability
#$''
% &#$
!"
Z K 5 S; & Tg* !M .@# &
I 0 = > 0 0 8 A Yr W T ;
F* 0 / = >
8 A & ;* +# 0 8 A ($XXeb T$XXea TZ K 5)
.($XXX Tg 9 ]K E3 ˆ$XXd TZ > /Z 4
>) @# & \
T@ ;K
F* 23 0 @
*1
M;K*
A ;+ >
!1
=S @# &
I
B F* €
23 M
> 3 ]
* 0 ,(G
04 E > @
B
0 ; .@ > A
F* 0 @
Z T|! )
* 0 ,( G EEG 04 E …4 < & T I ] ;]E )*E ,
A B F*
=S B
S; & > ) Z j4E4 * )*r4 <
EEG
G J & .($XXe Th>4 ˆ$XXk T$XXea T$X'e Tg @ 4 ) @ >
0
. |! )
* 0 ,(G > > • B 4
* 0 ,(G
* 0 ,(G EEG
G .@ >
< @ )* +# B F* T2 * v ;+
B 4 & T 4#
F |! ) 0 ] * )*E , K = w P 3 > I
) ; 1 G
# 4 I 0 > > @ 3
0 0 8 A
.(kDDe TgE5 B 4>)
* EEG
G B F* v ;+ 0
. \& B
G N
&
K )*E , 09 & l4( > @ > l ( • g (kDDe T$XX%) g @ 4
$
50 & ;
) ? 0 B F* & F
F & I |!
* 0 ,(G
F &\
I )
* 0 ,(G K )*E , 09 & l4(
@# &
k
@ 4 # Tg & B
.) H ; . & ;
A 0 BF * & F
/ AP 0 R* 5 Tw < 8 **I & I
* 0 ,(G )*E ,
G
Tg @ 4 ) @ ;< \
B F* 0 @ * & 0 €m O & = >
F*
Tg> 4 ˆ$XX% TB ]
ˆ$XXD TJ4]
g @ 4 Tg> 4 ˆ$XXkb
@# ) 6 @G 0
G T *K g @;
.($XXk TJ
Tg @ 4
T
1- Approach3-
2- Avoidance
48
#$''
% &#$
!"
& @# ; 1 > & F* 0 ~
*&=* 4N &
0 )E W :<
Tg & : .(kDDe Tg :> h]* * ) )
; 1 ;K
;* +# 0 1
0 / R* 5 = > & \
;* +# Y 4 & |!
* G )*E , =
T 4# gE5 Tg :> ˆ$XXf TgE5
4. /B4 ) ) ;K
T 1 K & &
> E W T($XXe Tg @ 4
g> 4 ˆ$XXX T 4# 8 €:& Tg :> ˆ$XX'
)
1 K & & 0 / R* 5 =
&\
|!
* G )*E , = >
.($XXD Tg @ 4 J4]
ˆ$XXcTg @ 4 )
0 I )*E , - (& 0 * 3
0 3 8 ,E ( T@# >U > 4PB
&) ; 1 8 4r ;* +# v ;+ 0 1 & I
* 0 ,(G EEG
G
u ;
($XXf Tg @ 4
g
ˆ$XXX TB ]
B 1 T ? B4
& V ;* +# 0
1 > ,E ( E T) ;#
M 0 @ > @*
@
13 4 T 1B & T 1B )
13 4 0 1B & ,& J & @ #
K S
,E ( 4 TB F*
4.MN
0 I )*E , N 3 ( F*
z P 3 .@ # & €@
#)
0N - * *
T@# &
G
T
;. T ;< # ,& & > M @
Z B 4 & B F*
4.MN T
T@ > g* ‡
):
& M
*67
0 ;
v ;+ W 4 )*E , & ;K& 0 @
;* +# 0 1 &
;K&
0 B F*
4.MN B
G N
&.
(
*
G W 4 …4 < &) I
0 ,(G EEG
G ] &M &
@F & 3 0 4*# & A
> )A1 B 4
T@ >
A B F* & F €
=S I
*
.@ @ ;< # B4 > T@ 4#
g Y @, R.4 > 0 I 0 MK* ]
W 4 0 AE5 03
, 04 E > ) l ( E7K g
4.MN
v ;+ ;* +# 8 *r4 < &
h . *I; ; > g ^ Tz@ g & Y* ) . Œ)
49
^W=
Tg & &
I
* 0 ,(G v ;+
4 !T A
F* H F
#$''
I
% &#$
!"
* 0 ,(G EEG 03
, 04 E
4.4 0 8 A
& &
13 4 T0 1B & T0 1B ) ;* +# ,& & ‚
B F*
4.MN
.) @# ;< ( F* @
2
0
1 4. YS;K *I; 0 †
0 ]; )*
& .4 & ^ W =
;< #2 œ OE & =
g .)
& F 0 l P 0 E4S 3 v ;+
65 0 K S 0 3 3 T
8
& . *1
G $\ ;+ 0 l P 0 ;K1
4.MN ) YS;K *I; v ;+ l4( 0 & F
1
v ;+ 0 0@ & >
k
0 ~ 0 K S œ OE 3
4 35B
=F
] 0 l P & ( F*
0 l P & (N E ;* +# ,& 0
&) v ;+ 0
1
4 35
%
. w,
4 35g*&
F* H F
@F & 3 ^ W 0 ,E (
3 @# SE A
,& g* !M .) @# ; 1 N
YS;K *I; B 4 & TM * = w P
T0 1B T0 1B & Š(
! (N)
13 4 (E) 0 1B & ;* +#
*I; .@ ; 1 G
& 4 1Y @, *I; B 4 & F* 0 @
13 4
* 0 ,(G v ;+ (0
) W 4 03
, B * :3 ) 8
;K&
.( 4>/ W 4
AE5 o4 w ( B 4 ,* P M; E J &) I
0 50 4
* ] 8:* O 0
B 4F
>@ #& B
J @ )*& 0
0 W
.@ 4& Y* O & 4I
1- Mixed designs
3- Between subject
, .
0 *> ^W =
0 5 0 , .
(
+ 0 ;> @#
# >)
g
$%'ci'd * O
2- Within subject
50
#$''
0 +K
.@# • 34
0
). A
0 ~
(E) 0
kD MFW
,& J
Z K5
% &#$
@ @# H +;
8 4r & B 4F
3 A $$DD T m
B5 g*& (EPQ-R) Z K 5 ;* +# 0
0 @# N @ @F
g;# /1 > T
4 35 2 g; 1 N
&T
0 W
fkc T$k3 9 & (L) • b< # 0
0 0
bG
; > A fkc B * 3 T 4 0 W
.@ @# H +;
01 &V
1B & @ ,&
• 34
; 8
J
& T 4& @ # @ * 7 B5
& ( F* @
13 4 T 1B T 1B &) 1
! (N)
13 4
&
4 35 H +; 0 *, $
# @.
.@ @# H +; A
;* +# 0
0 @# N @ @F 0 +K • J *S
;* +#
. 4#
@
(z) @ ; 0
0
& (EPQ-R)
=
0
8
L J *S
!"
r
8
0
P@,&
1 !
8
4 35 H +; 0 & @# ; 1 N
0
N @,&
8
0
E @,&
*, (¡)
# @.
& (z) @ ; 8
*,
ETP TN ,& J
L J *S
1
8
z/W 8 z/W
0
D/c & zP< - $/czN >
8 z/W
3 9 & e/%X 3 9 &
$X/$$
$d/k% 3 9 & & zE D/c- & z L <
e/e$
B5 3 9 & $$/'k 3 g*
D/c & zE > - D/c <
13 4
8
z/W 8 z/W c/Df 0
3 9 & e/%X 3 9 & 3 g*
e/e$
B5
& zP< - $/czN < 8 z/W
$d/k% 3 9 & & zE D/c & zL < - D/c
D/c & zE > - D/c <
$$/'k 3 g*
@
F*
8
z/W 8 z/W 8 z/W
3 9 & e/%X 3 9 & X/fc 3 9 &
e/e$
kD/de 0
B5 3 9 &
& zP< - $/czE >
& D/c & zL < - D/c
D/czN <-
1B &
8
z/W 8 z/W 8 z/W
3 9 & e/%X 3 9 & X/fc 3 9 &
e/e$
f/e$ 0
B5 3 g*
& zP< - $/czE < & D/c & zL < - D/c
D/c- zN <
1B
51
#$''
g
0
*, T #
% &#$
!"
4 0 1 & V 0 €: 0 & 4 0 4*# & :
.@# ; 1 N
3l # &
4 35 0 & =
ˆ( M !
@
T) ) h F; 0 &)
ˆ%c kk g*& g
ˆ *V B4K *> T3 ] Yx*;E4 T{ r @
K. 0 0 *& B @S
;< #B 0 :;< S & g;# @
4 > )m*,G4
:;& @
ˆ *V
i$
ik
i%
ie
*` v*P 0
:;< T & (^ T S < 0 :;<
ˆ{ r 0 S& g;# @ ic
ˆ0 I 0 & ^ 0 S& g;# @ id
ˆB 1B 0
Y]E z
@ if
ˆ F & 0 @# l:r
*& @
F &
*& i'
- *1 3 @ -
g :(EPQ-R)
J *S & ‚4&
& ‚4& B5 m
.)
&
$
Z K 5 ;* + # 0
0 @ # N@ @ F 0 + K
B5
¢‘ > ) *</ & ~
& m ¡’’ 0
‘¢ T(N)
13 4 J *S & ‚4& TB5
¢£ T(E) 0 1B &
(L) • J *S & ‚4& B5 ¢¡ (P)
134] J *S
Z K 5 ;* +# 0
0 @#
&
\ 4
@;& .@#
A Z T
B &3 8 *& b +;
) 1 G * &3 & 4 =
0@
3 ] \ 4 @ # . 0 +K T@
1- Eysenck Personality QuestionnaireRevised (EPQ-R)
N @ @F 0 +K 03
5 4N &
k
A; v ‡ - . 2 3 (EPQ-R)
A Z \ 4 hx
@# .
>) @ @*
K* B &3 b +;
,& 0 W
.@# • E ;W 0
2- Double translation
52
#$''
% &#$
3 h .@# @
•
!"
1 & K*
& ‰ @F
K* B &3 8 *& 0 ;> B 4F
4.4 89 ]# T r 0 +K
@ # . 0 +K )S& (
.@# 0 & & - 5
T N TE 0 J *S (Ž > 0 AE5 R ^) ; T($X'c) 8 & Z K 5 TZ K 5
D/f% TD/'c TD/'c B 3
D/'k D/'$ TD/'' TD/XDTB
R* & L P
=fkc) B
0 & Ž > 0 AE5 R ^ * =
g
.@ 5 ) & D/fX
.@ 5 ) & D/fc D/f' T D/'k TD/'d TR* & TL P T N TE 0 J *S
(n
)
%X 0
g :$( @# N @ @F
) 4E 0 & ) 0
8 :P
0m
@# & ) 0 )*E , & ‚4& B5 0 m %d >
8 4r &
c 8 ]*E v*P Z
g .@ > M
^ 8 O*^4
+fk ifk
Y> 8
8 **I 0
. 4# 0 /1
(ik +k)
g @ ($X'X) B@ & J4* ; \ 4 4E 0 & ) 0
.@# &
B5
; .@# &
m %k 0
g *E 0 +K .) @#
& g .) @# 2 1 H4 ( ($XXD) g 9
4# TB@ & TJ4* ; \ 4
;< #B R 0 =
0 &)
& 3 0 & v ;+ B SSO \ 4
.($XX' Tn * /g E4& B@ & TJ *E .€. ) ) ; 1 G A;
4
0
89 ]# •
v ‡ 0 . 3 h M 4>/ 0
@#
8 **I .@ 1
† . 8 **I
n
& R ; T 4.4
.)# @ Y > )S& ( B n
& > 4&
)*E ,
*#
@ 4P &
.@ 5 )
& D/Xk (n ='D) )
$D > )
$% 0
8 O*^4 <5 0
%
)
4#
1- Waterloo Handedness Questionnaire
53
B
0 &Ž
> 0 AE5 R ^ =
g
g :¡( @# N @ @F
) 4E 0 & 0
F \ 4 > ) ˜ )*E , & ‚4&
2- Waterloo Footedness Questionnaire- Revised
#$''
. 4# 0 /1
(ik
0 & 0
.@# &
4;
T
3 h TM
g
n
&R ; T
)*E ,
*#
@
Ž
% &#$
!"
+k) 8 4r & M
g . *1 &
* ]
+kD ikD3
g Y> 8 8 **I 0
; 0
@# g @ ($X'X) B@ & J4* ; \ 4
.(kDDD TB ]
B@ & & @* > ) )
9&
4.4 0
89 ]# •
v ‡ 0 .
4P & @#
8 **I .@ 1
† . 8 **I
> 0 AE5 R ^ * =
g
.)# @ Y > )S& ( B n
& > 4&
.@ 5 ) & D/Xe (n ='D) ) B 0 &
€m O 3 r g**, 2 3
4 35 0 &M ! g**, 0 & :0 &M ! g**,
Z & 3& M !
& @;& @# ; 4< B5 3 > R* g & .@# A;
*,
& ] g ^ .@ >
4& ; 1 G B5 3 0 ;
r
> )& 6 (S
3 h .@
0 *1
N 4 - (S w*G 8 4r & 4< ) # )
0 M ! > @#
; 4< 0 3 T (S B5 & 4 35 >
0 *1
)* ?
! .@ 2 1 )& 6 (S
F& . B *
;K& R* & 4<
–* & Z
M> 4>/ (S
F& . B * TB5 g;#
;K& g*W
>
.@#
,
& M ! B 4 )O 4&
,(G - † w P 3 ^ W =
A
F* H F : F* 0 M *
\ 4 @#
, 0 M * J & Tz@ g & & ) 0 & .@#
F
T F* 0 M * ,(G 03
, 4 0 4*# T(kDDf) J 1 0 TŸ
T 4.4
F* 0 M * g*& 3 T F* 0 M * ,(G
;
0 ,E ( Z RE G (J \ K B F* &) A
F* 0 4;O & M *
, . ; *& 8 *† .
& 0 &) @# H +;
& 3 0 &$
,(G
M*
&
,(G
@S
1- Pilot study
54
#$''
% &#$
!"
.($%'f T KW & @* >
0 5• . = 35 0 . @
J & 1 ! A fkc g*& 3 m - W
@# # ‰: G > 4PB
\ 4 0 4‡W - ,.
A J
P @;& .@ 4& @# H +; N E 8
T @# Y* ] 0
- F*; 3 R
4<3 & B g ^ T
H +; 0
4 35 T W g
.@ @# 84 =
0@,& 0 W & @# & V
g
.@ ; 1 G & 3
4 0 8 4r &
15 ) ^ RK> 3 h @#
B5 E ;W 0 4 & Š
4 35 0 & = 35 =
z@ K .
0 &) 0
4 35 Thx .@#
~
\ 4
€ O 3 r g**, \ 4 B5 0 &M ! @ > Y* ] 4E 0 &
T0 &)
0 €: B@#
5 & 3 h .) 1
G
& 4 *,
R* J & Thx .@# 0 /10 . I v ;+ (0
) W4
;]E
G
@F & 3 4 A M * ,(G T
Y& S; @# B3 4;
:@#
†
w P3 3 0 Y ,E 4; 4>/ )E W
.) 1
‰ A(E . > @* 4< @
* ,(G @ 3 h #» :��
@*
, M * ,(G 0 # g*W
.@* >
M * ,(G g & )G &
4#
F # M * ,(G g & B >
3 >
B F* 8 KW
T@ >
# &0
1 T > 4r & ˆ@* @ 3 &
B5 ;+ 4 @* 4< @
*
B F* M * ,(G 0 @
T ,*
M * 0 # g*W @* > 2: @ &
0 , 4;O - & 4< 8 A;
55
,(G @ 3 h #» : @F & 3 )E W
P 4P & .@* >
M * ,(G g & )G
# ˆ > @ 4< F #
KW
@F 0 & 3
)< # 3 A; &
#$''
= >
@# F
.«@& =
% &#$
!"
E ;W H4 (
@ #4< 0 B F*
8 KW TM *
B5 @ #4< H4 ( 6 ; g*& 3 B5 A *67 @*
T
4 35 & M> W
F* 0 )E W Z j4E4 * \ # ; > 4N &
.@#
F $c E X 8
g*& 3 Z P
4 35
0 & = 35
0 €m O E ;W 8 6 z/W
3= 0 & 39 0
= 35 0 ;
4<3 & B g ^ = 35
3 h .@# M
4 35 0 & F*
.@# @
4 35 & ] 0 & 0 @ T= 35 u ; & R
B > m>
I
] ;]E )*E , ) 6
@F & 3 YW
B
4P &
4 35 I ] ;]E )*E ,
) 4 v ;+ ‚ S 3 ;]E 0 @ *1 & Z :> & EEG w P 3 T F* H F
kDi$D
E g*& M;K* 0 E > k$ 04 E J & EEG ) 6 .@# ) 6
|! 241
;]E
] g ^ .) 1 8 4r ($XXe T ] 5 EEG , .)
%
$
04 .
( * 3) @ 1 ;]E B 4 )O
;]E Z k(A2) )
(A1)
=
T ;
> ke 3 {4 F
T
8
& .@# ; 1 > &
*
0
& \S =
z@ J & u ; Y* O
E @ 1 A; ^ W
T(F7) |!
.
* T(FP2) )
*
(G T(FP1) |!
*
(G
*
)
.
* T(F4) )
*
*
* T(F3) |! *
.@# @ 4< # (F8)
o4
w
; &)6
Salem j
1- Left earlobe (A1)
3- Grounded electrode
;]E h @x 5 = > 4N
> @S & @ 4& @# * ,
& o4 ) 6 { # 3 Y G
;]E 0 & >
0 YO
2- Right earlobe (A2)
56
#$''
% &#$
!"
;]E z:;< M 4 *> u 3 g* & ;]E
h @x 5 ; G .@#
.@# * EEG o 4 ) 6 0 & \ # T@*
M 4 *> Z 3 g* & g
high pass $ & & & low pass 0 0 I o 4 ) 6 0 & @# H +; j ; 4
• Y@ 3
03 m C 0 & . 4& )E ]* kDD Gain &
fD ,
$
z/W o 4
4.4
4 o 4 @;& 4N g 0 & .@# A; (FFT) 4
4P & 4 o 4 B @& 0 ,(G 0 & uV2 @W & AE5 o4 w ( B 4 T@ 1
,* P M; E TYr W 0
03 F 4N & .@#
O * 6 $D 8@
o +; @ @ 1
O
3 Z 0 & AE5 o4 B 4 g* *
@
r 0
RE G
AE5 w ( B 4 z , B 4 &
* 0
0 & @#
.@# SPSS-18 0
Y* O
F ).
;
v ;+ W 4 0 AE5 03
, 04 E @ ; z O g* * k
# @.
0 & A
F* H F
@F & 3 \ #
I
* 0 ,(G
B
@ 4# > 4#
5 .) @# o
;* +# v ;+ 0
1
23
& J4], 8 4r & (
$% ') AE5 o4 0
)*E , ˆ@
AE5 0
)*E , 0 G 0 M;K*
, 23
, .@# & \
0 G
T J4`, (& I )*E , & AE5 o4 K C 0
B 4 B4! .@&
= >
0 @ B T g* B 4
MC )*E , 0 @ B
*W
9 & B 4 /E
.) *W B5 9 & )*E ,
1- Artifacts
57
#$''
\ #
I
A
* 0 ,(G v ;+ W4 0 AE5 03
A
F* H F
F* H F
@ ; z O
g* *
A
% &#$
!"
, 04 E @ ; z O g* * (¢)
@F & 3
F* H F @F & 3
@ ; z O
g* *
] *
1
D/k%
D/kk
D/k$
D/kX
D/%$
D/%c
D/k'
D/ke
D/kc
D/%D
D/e%
D/kX
D/ef
D/eX
D/c'
D/eX
D/kk
D/$'
D/$c
D/k%
D/k'
D/$X
D/kk
D/k%
k/De
k/Dk
k/D%
k/D%
$/XX
k/D$
$/X%
$/'X
k/ke
k/DX
k/Dc
k/%$
d/k'
d/$%
d/kD
d/k%
D/d$
$/k$
$/kc
D/df
D/eX
$/$D
$/Dd
D/d'
D/%'
D/ke
D/k'
D/%%
D/%$
D/k%
D/$X
D/%%
D/%e
D/k%
D/kX
D/%k
D/dX
D/ee
D/%D
D/cX
D/%%
D/ef
D/%'
D/%'
D/%c
D/%D
D/kd
D/%e
$/df
D/Xf
$/Dc
$/kD
$/ke
$/D%
D/Xc
$/kd
$/ke
$/D$
$/DX
k/kD
e/$e
%/Dk
%/$D
e/df
k/$c
$/'$
$/'X
$/X%
k/$$
$/Xf
$/fk
k/DX
N+
D/kc
D/dX
D/e$
k/Dc
N+ F8
NE+
# @.
FP1
EN+
NE+
F3
E-
|!
N+
NE+
F7
EN+
NE+
LF
EN+
N- FP2
E+
)
EN+ F4
NE+
E-
58
#$''
% &#$
!"
(k)
A
F* H F
A
#
@. -
F* H F @F
& 3
@ ; z O
g* *
@ ; z O
g* *
D/$%
D/k%
D/%c
D/ec
D/%%
D/%c
$/k$
$/De
D/dk
$/'$
%/c%
%/%c
D/%c
D/k'
D/%k
D/X'
D/'%
D/%%
$/Xe
$/Xc
$/kk
d/%D
c/fk
c/cf
D/ee
$/Xf
D/fD
c/kc
] *
1
NE+
EN+
RF
NE+
E-
0
0 AE5 o4 )*E , g* * @
N & k @. 0
& .4 &
F* H F
@F & 3 )E W v ;+ 0
1
* 0 ,(G
@ 4< l ( ; *& 8 *† . & 0@,& 0 Y* O
u ; g .@# & 8 A; A
.@#
4 35 1 ! I
* 0 ,(G 0 AE5 03
, 04 E
&).
\ ;+ h
Y* O 3 @;& T A
F* H F @F & 3
)E W
1B & T F* @ T 13 4 ) 1 ! TY* O g
.@# A; e*(k*k*e)
T >g g ^ .@# ; 1 N
4 35g*& Y B 4 & ( 1B
I 0 ] * T( A
F* H F
@F & 3 ) B F*
4.MN
|! *
* T(FP1) |!
*
(G) 0
(|! )
*)
)
* (G T(LF) |!
* 0 ,(G Y> T(F7) |!
.
* T(F3)
* 0 ,(G Y> (F8) )
.
* T(F4) )
*
* T(FP2)
h
Y* O u ; .@ @# Y* O
4 35 B 0 Y B 4 & ((RF) )
. 4#
@
%
# @. e*(k*k*e) \ ;+
59
#$''
03
, 04 E
& 0 & e×(k×k×e) \ ;+ h
* 0 ,(G 0 AE5
% &#$
!"
Y* O u ; (%)
#
@.
!4 B4 35
F
g* *
8 /F
.
0 35
{4 F
8 /F
8 **I •
**c/eD
k/eD
%
f/X$
1
D/ee
fd
%%/f%
(<
***'/Dk
%/fX
d
kk/fc
F* H F
***X/kf
e/%'
$'
f'/XD
D/ef
ecd
k$c/c'
***'%'/f%
$$k/c%
$
$$k/c%
***ecX/k'
d$/dk
%
$'e/'f
D/$%e
fd
$D/kD
***$/X'
kc$e/%d
%
fce%/DX
**k/ec
D/%$
X
k/fX
D/$kf
kk'
k'/''
***$/'d
%kD/%c
d
$Xkk/$k
] * ×
F* H F
***$Dk/'%
$f/df
$'
%$'/Dk
× ] * ×
F* H F
1
D/$fk
ecd
f'/%c
***e/eD
D/dk
$'
$$/$d
***e/Xd
D/dX
ce
%f/fk
1×
r 6
r 6
Š(
0 ,
.
0 35
ii
ii
D/ekc
kD
iiii
iii
D/$cf
c
D/$f%
kD
D/$$'
$fD
D/fXd
c
F* H F
(<
] *
r 6
1× ] *
(<
r 6
1×
(<
(<
×
×
F* H F
×
F* H F
1
D/$e$
$%d'
$Xk/fc
(<
***kdd/XX
$k/X'
%
%'/X%
× ] *
***$cD/'f
f/%%
X
dc/XX
D/Dc
kk'
$$/D'
1×
× ] *
(<
60
#$''
% &#$
!"
(%)
#
@. !4 B4 35
F
g* *
8 /F
.
0 35
{4 F
8 /F
***kdd/XX
$k/X'
%
%'/X%
***$cD/'f
f/%%
X
dc/XX
D/Dc
kk'
$$/D'
***fkd/$'
cD/%D
$k/'k
dee/XX
***ed/Dc
%/$X
%'/ef
$kk/fD
H F× ] *
1×
× F*
D/DdX
/cc
Xfe
df/cD
(<
8 **I •
× ] *
1×
Š(
0 ,
.
0 35
D/fXd
c
D/DDD
$fD
× ] *
(<
×
P< =D/DD$ ***
F* H F × ] *
P<=D/D$ **
P<=D/Dc *
8: ,
4 35B
4 35g*& l4(
4#
NW: > 4PB
\ ;+ h
Y* O u ; 0 , & m.4 & .
4.
, 8 A B5
(F(fdT%) =c/eD ˆP<D/Dc) 1 r 6 …4 < & Tv ;+ l4(
e×(f×k×e)
* 0
3 ]
YG @W 1 ! g*& >
N;
0 & .@# & ;# 4.
, 8 A T A
F* H F @F & 3
@. B5 u ; > @# A;
>4 *S, B4 35 3 8 A g 0 ,
&
. 4#
@
c e
61
#$''
H F
)E W
I
* 0 ,(G 0 AE5 03 , 04 E
A
F*
1B
% &#$
& 0 & >4
1B &
F*
8 A
g* *
0 (<
@ ;
8 A
g* *
0 (<
@ ;
8 A
g* *
D/Df
D/Df
D/Df
D/DX
D/DX
D/DX
D/$D
D/$D
D/$D
D/$d
D/$d
D/$d
D/Dd
D/Dd
D/Dd
D/Df
D/Df
D/Df
D/D'
D/D'
D'/D
D/$k
D/$k
D/$%
D/D$
iD/DDd
D/DDc
D/$D
D/$$
D/De
iD/Df
iD/k$
iD/kd
D/Dc
iD/$D
iD/k$
iD/Dc
***D/ce
***D/c'
D/$'
***D/ek
***D/%'
D/Df
***D/cX
***D/ek
iD/$d
***$/cc
***$/%'
D/Df
D/Df
D/D$
iD/D$
D/D'
D/Dk
D/DX
D/DX
D/Dd
D/Df
D/DX
D/$D
D/$D
D/$X
D/Dc
D/$D
D/$d
D/$d
D/kd
D/$$
D/$d
D/Dd
D/Dd
***iD/de
D/Dd
D/Df
D/Df
***iD/cf
D/D'
D/D'
***iD/%e
D/$k
D/$k
***i$/cc
D/$e
D/$c
***iD/cX
***iD/d$
D/De
***iD/ck
D/$f
D/$k
***i$/fk
D/$f
P< =D/DD$ ***
)E W
> 4#
T(FP1) |!
*
iD/D$
iD/De
D/D'
@
e
(G 0
@.
03
S, B4 35 (£) @.
@
0 (<
@ ;
D/Df
!"
P<=D/D$ **
1
N+
NE+
N+
NE+
N+
NE+
N+
NE+
N+
NE+
N+
NE+
N+
NE+
N+
NE+
;K&
*I;
FP1
F3
F7
LF
FP2
F4
F8
RF
P< =D/Dc *
@# o 0 , l4( J
,
T A
F* H F
&
62
#$''
% &#$
!"
|!
* Y> 03
, (F7) |!
.
* T(F3) |! *
*
(G
03
, . 4#
@
1 ! g*& 0 , 8 A (LF)
*
(F8) )
.
* T(F4) )
*
* T(FP2) )
@
3 ; *& 1B
13 4
(RF) )
* Y> 03
,
)E W
> )A1 B 4 —4 u ; & m.4 & .@# &
1B &
F*
I )
* 0 ,(G
; *& 03
, = @ # A
F* H F
.M*;K 1B &
F* @
& K S
1B
13 4
@F & 3 )E W
I
* 0 ,(G 0 AE5 03
A
1B
, 04 E
F* H F
& 0 & >4
1B &
F*
S, B4 35 (“)
@
0 (<
@ ;
8 A
g* *
0 (<
@ ;
8 A
g* *
0 (<
@ ;
8 A¨
g* *
D/DX
D/DX
D/DX
D/D'
D/D'
D/D'
D/DX
D/DX
D/DX
D/$d
D/$f
D/$d
D/$k
D/$k
D/$k
***D/ef
D/DX
D/$D
***D/dk
D/DX
***D/fD
iD/k%
iD/$c
iD/Dk
*iD/k%
**iD/%$
***iD/Xd
***i$/$'
***i$/$D
*iD/ck
***i$/dc
***i$/cd
D/k$
iD/$k
iD/De
D/D'
D/D'
**D/kX
D/DX
D/DX
D/$e
iD/D'
D/DX
D/$d
D/$d
***$/De
D/$d
D/$k
D/$k
D/kc
iD/DX
D/$k
D/$D
D/$$
D/$D
D/D$
iD/$%
**iD/%f
D/$$
D/$D
**D/%'
D/$D
63
iD/DX
D/D'
D/kD
D/D'
D/kk
***$/$%
iD/D'
D/kc
# @.
*D/%e
D/$e
1
N+
NE+
N+
NE+
N+
NE+
N+
NE+
N+
NE+
N+
NE+
*I;
;K&
FP1
F3
F7
LF
FP2
F4
#$''
(“)
1B
0 (<
@;
8 A
g* *
D/$D
D/$$
D/$D
D/$D
D/$$
D/$$
D/ke
D/k%
D/ke
D/D$
iD/$%
**iD/%f
***D/'%
***D/fk
***D/f%
***$/Dc
D/ef
D/%k
% &#$
!"
@
8 A¨
g* *
1
# @. -
1B &
0 (<
8 A
@;
g* *
F*
0 (<
@;
D/$$
D/$D
**D/%'
D/$$
D/$$
D/$D
iD/DD'
D/$$
D/ke
D/k%
*D/fe
D/ke
D/$D
D/$e
D/kc
D/$$
D/c'
D/$c
P<=D/DD$ ***
P<=D/D$ **
N+
NE+
N+
NE+
N+
NE+
*I;
;K&
F4
F8
RF
P<=D/Dc *
F* H F @F & 3 )E W
> 4#
@
c @. u ; J &
1B & T F* @
(FP1) |!
* (G
03
, T A
(F3) |! *
*
03
, .@# &
13 4
3 ; *& 1B
g 03
, g* q ˆ@# &
13 4
3 ; *& 1B &
*
03
, .@# &
1B
3 ; *& 1B &
F* @
.
1B 3 ; *& 1B &
F* @ T 13 4
(F7) |!
3 ; *& 1B &
F* @
(LF) |!
* > 03
, .@# &
F* @ T 13 4
*W g 03
, Tg* q .@# &
13 4
)
*
(G
03
, .@# &
1B
3 ; *& 1B &
*
03
, .@# &
13 4
3 ; *& F* @
(FP2)
.@# &
1B
13 4
3 ; *& 1B &
(F4) )
*
T 1B &
3 ; *& 1B
(F8) )
.
*
03
,
64
#$''
% &#$
!"
1B &
(RF) )
* Y> 03
, .)
F* @
13 4
T@5) &u ; &)
& TY> .@# &
13 4
3 ; *& 1B
0 ,(G 8 A; W 4 03
, @ # A
F* H F @F & 3 )E W
.M*;K
13 4 0 1B & ;* +# ,& J
& I
*
0 *1 F*; •O&
04 E & A
F* H F 4.MN 0
. 4&
13 4
0 1B & ,& J &
Z ) ;< # @F & 3
;
4 (~
& > ;
Z ) *& ;
;* +# ,& J
& 4>/
I
* 0 ,(G 03
, 04 E
*67
& ^W=
z@
I
* 0 ,(G EEG
G
RE G B F*
4.MN 0
(@ * & > ;
>
B u ; .) 1 G
&
&
A; 65
13 4 0 1B &
.@
Z K 5 T F* 0 1 5
;* +# 0 1 g*& \& g** 0 &
0 ] # /0 G 0 S W ,
4O
)*E , & 0 0 8 A ($Xdf)
0 S W (0 4,r 3
, 0 ]# ;
J4 9 T0 I
G0@ ‚ )
; & \ 0 ;<
W I & I
G
\& ) k0 G /
W
0 & 3 T0 ] #/0 G 0 S W 0 = > )* KW .@
\
(0 >
S W g .@
Y*]
0 1B / 0 1B & @,& ;< #R
B4! .@
B 0 M>
> )*E , T 1B
& K S
1B &
> )A1 B 4 h T) @ #4
;>
> 4 4<
;+* & T 4< Y& S 0 ;
) ? (& 4. 3 > W 4>/ RE ( .@ >
& F 0 ; *& ;A#5 TJ ;
& .(kDDk TB ]
1) @# & @ #4<
A 0 B F* &
13 4
3 # ) g] \& g ($X'c TZ K 5 Z K 5 ˆ$Xdf) Z K 5 S;
@ 5&
13 4 0 .@ # & ;K 3 0
0 M;K*
0
0 8 A
4}K Z* *E ; T > .B5 3 .@
Z* *E ; )*E , g* 0 ; 5
T) (
M < TH (^ TJ T 1 *; 0 B F* …4 < &) B F*
) 4< Y& S 0 ; & K S
9&
13 4 8 *r4 < &
g & &
8@#
&
A 0 B F * 0 @ *1 & 0 @
T( F* @
# 0 1B & Z K 5 0 N J & T
04 3 . > @ 4< & F 0 ; *&
0 M;K*
0 ] # /0 G 0 S W )*E , Š(
0 0 8 A 3
& .@# &
* >—4 / * 4x* M;K* T3 @*K> g* 54 4 0 M;K* *N ;+* &
, 04F;K.
1B &
0 G ;+* & Š( B 4& g* & )
=
4N &
g \ 4 T **I
13 T Pu**
*N
;
.)# N; 1B &
) ? 0 B F* 3 < & 3 & B 4
;+* &
& 3
TI
* 0 ,(G 03
, 04 E
*&=* g
. 4& 4
A
F* H F @F
04 E & ^ W =
0 ; > )A1 B 4
T@5) &u ; &
&
04 E
I
* 0 ,(G EEG
G 0 & (kDDe) g @ 4 )* p
).
*
G |! )
W 4 g; b* + &
H ;. / 50
T$X'' Tg @ 4 ) ( A ) H ;. () ? ) 50 & ; 0 B F* 23
66
#$''
% &#$
!"
& .@# & 4K ($X'X Tg> 4 g @ 4 ˆ$XXD TB ]
g @ 4 ˆ$XXc
0 AE[ M
)* p 0 AE[ Y # M 4 E g (kDDe) 4.B4
S;
&. 4
;
@] 3
B5 B 4
&F
4 A 8 4r & ) 2 *
Z B4
* 0 ,(G EEG
G 0 & g @ 4 04 E J & 0 N
04 E J & .) 1 N
#*
) . 04 E Z (h 9 ) )* p 04 E
G )* p
& |!
*
K )*E , 09 & l4( T
* 0 ,(G EEG
&\
)
* K )*E , 09 & l4( ) ? 0 B F* & F
F
) . 04 E J & > E W T@# &
A 0 B F* - & F
F
& |!
* K )*E , 09 & l4( T
* 0 ,(G EEG
G #*
)
*
K )*E , 09 & l4(
50 & ; 0 B F*
F
.@# & H ;. & ; 0 B F* F & \
3 0 # TB F*
4.MN 0 3
;* +# ,& 0 (& B
G N
&
B F*
4.MN
& 3 Z j4E4 * 0 4 E 8 **I > @
B 8 ,E (
g ˆ$XX% Tg @ 4 ˆ$XXd T #
h>4 Th *]E >) @# & o & \
> ) g & S; T * 3 g
.($XX% TB ]
ˆ$XXf Tg @ 4
Z j4E4 *
;< # T0 ; 0 @
03 ! x] 0 & I
* 0 ,(G
.)
> @* , 4
F*
4.MN •* ) . )
; b +
@# &
* 0 ,(G 0 @
3 * B F* 0 F 0 3 &
B 3
Th>4 g @ 4 ) @ *1
G o *67 )O ‰ 4G B5 > @
B @ 4#
*& M ^ W =
0 ; .($XXf Tg @ 4
g ˆ$XXe TB 1 > ˆ$X'X
RE V 0 1 *67 )O A
F* H F & 3
> @# & g
.@# &
;* +#
J 1 TB F*
4.MN
0
.)
4 l(
67
> 0@ & E4S Z
T@# >U ‰: G > 4PB
~
& > ; @ * & > ; •*
#$''
% &#$
!"
Y > B@# , 3 Y G
> 4# —:P E
& @ * & > ;
.@
F T( B5 @ * Z j4E4 * 0 ~
) ; **I ~ 0 = 1
3 h b+# > 4# —:P E
&~
& > ; 0
Tg* q
B . ˆkDD$ T$XX' TJ 1) @
F B F* ~ 0 = 1 03 @
B
35 0 ;
0 0 8 A & ‚4& 8 ,E ( .(kDDe TJ 1
A 0 AP T F* *V 0 4*# & @ 35 0 ,G Z @F & 3 > @
@ 3 * z/W @ B F*
4.MN 0
& K S
@
= >
ˆkDDD TB ]
B4K].) ) 0 M> Z j4E4 *
;< # T
;. 0
> 4PB .(kDD% TB . J 1ˆ kDDk T$XX' TJ 1 ˆkDDD TJ 1
q
T0 ; 0 F
& K S
T B M ^W =
u ;
B F*
4. MN @
m*E W
3T
0 ; *&
+& 6 @F & 3
J q ) 4#
F* 0 = >
; 3 Y G B5 *67 4# { #
4.MN 0@
04 E
;< # R M 0 4 E J & .(kDDD TJ 1
8: , > ) g & • (kDD$ T8 & g @
K> ˆkDDk TJ 1) B F*
Y*]
@F & 3 0 & 3 TB F* 123 0 M;K*
;< # ; > g*&
$
B > &
( MPFC) *
* =*
G ;
W 4 .@
b+# ($XXf TB ]
B9 ˆ$XXX TB ]
4K
) 4< - &
F* 0 M * 0 @
F* 0 )E W :< T(kDDD TB ]
19 1)
B
T$XXf Tg @ 4
4# TB 5 TB
TB9 T$XX' T B ]
1 4*&)
.@ 4#
, ($XXf TB ]
0 & TB TB9)
($XXf TB ]
*67 > 3
; gU &
& g ^W =
u ;
v ;+ W 4 03
, )* KW
*1
G Y @, 4 ;* +# ,& \ 4
0
1 5 w& ( A
F* H F
)E W
I
* 0 ,( G
1- Medial Prefrontal Cortex (MPFC)
68
#$''
% &#$
!"
.)
;* +# ,&
F*
13 4
TI
* 0 ,(G 03 , 04 E B
G N
& g* q
N & g & & .@ >
; *& 8@# &
A
F* H F 1B
.@# & \
F* 0 / = >
8 A & ;* +# 0 8 A > @
=
0 ;
F* 0 / = >
0 0 8 A @*S J & T F*;
Z \ 4 B F*
4.MN 0
{4 > )# B U B 4
T ^W
@# &
)* +# Z j4E4 * 8 *r4 < & ;K& T 5 4.MN
+& 6
4.MN 0 & 0 I 0 ; )# N;
.@# & 0 I
;+* & v ;+ l4(
A
F* H F 4.MN *67 & (&
^ W = 0 ; T > 4P &
G / )* +# ‚ • T I
* 0 ,(G EEG
G & ;* +# ,&
> 4 l ( • g B4 =
u ; 0
& .@ > ) 4S 0 I
T@ # &
r < F* / # * M;K* ) @<
@G 0 ] * 3 Z
@!
=
g u ; J & Tg & & .@# & )* +# 0 1 *67 )O 5 03 ,
0 )E W )* +# 0 1 & \
I
* G 03 , > )A1 B 4
Y > 4P & 34 8: , g w*G MK* ] E T@# & B F*
4.MN v ;+
.)
50 * &0 =
1
B5 Y > )< # @ @
#
'f/DX/kd
'f/$D/k%
''/Dk/%D
69
: E S - *E - +K )
~
: ES
- +K )
~
: ES 2 / ~
#$''
References
) *E , &
; T
% &#$
!"
•&
F* H F
#B
0 ;>
E
.
@ F & 3 *67 .($%'f) A,. T KW
13 4 0 1B & ,& &
& I 0 *W
.J @ )*&
T@
American Electroencephalographic Society, (1994). Guideline Thirteen:
Guidelines for Standard Electrode Position Nomenclature. Journal of
Clinical Neurophysiology, 11, 111-113.
Beauregard, M., Leroux, J. M., Bergman, S., Arzoumanian, Y., Beaudoin, G.,
Bourgouin, P., & Stip, E. (1998). The Functional Neuroanatomy of
Major Fepression: An FMRI Study Using an Emotional Activation
Paradigm. NeuroReport, 9, 3253-3258.
Bechara, A., Damasio, H., Damasio, A.R., & Lee, G.P., (1999). Different
Contributions of the Human Amygdala and Ventromedial Prefrontal
Cortex to Decision-making. Journal of Neuroscience, 19, 5473–5481.
Bryden, P.J., Pryde, K.M., & Roy, E.A. (2000). A Performance Measure of
the Degree of Hand Preference. Brain and Cognition, 44, 402–414.
Cacioppo, J.T., Berntson, G.C., Larsen, J.T., Poehlmann, K. M., & Ito, T. A.
(2000). The Psychophysiology of Emotion. In M. Lewis & J.M.
Haviland-Jones (Eds.), Handbook of Emotions (2nd ed., pp. 173-191).
New York: Guilford Press.
Calkins, S.D., Fox, N.A., & Marshall, T.R., (1996). Behavioral and
Physiological Antecedents of Inhibited and Uninhibited Behavior. Child
Development, 67, 523- 540.
Campbell-Sills, L., & Barlow, D.H. (2007). Incorporating Emotion
Regulation Into Conceptualizations and Treatments of Anxiety and
Mood Disorders. In J.J. Gross (Ed.), Handbook of Emotion Regulation
(pp. 542–559), New York: Guilford Press.
Caspi, A., (1998). Personality Development Across the Life Course. In:
Damon, W., (Editor-in-Chief), Eisenberg, N. (Volume Editor),
Handbook of Child Psychology. Vol. 3, Wiley: New York, 311-388.
70
#$''
% &#$
!"
Coan, J.A., Allen, J.J.B. (2004). Frontal EEG Asymmetry as a Moderator and
Mediator of Emotion. Biological Psychology, 67, 7-49.
Costa, P.T., & McCrae, R.R. (1980). Influence of Extraversion and
Neuroticism on Subjective Well Being: Happy and Unhappy People.
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 38, 668–678.
Costa P.T., McCrae, R.R. (1985). The NEO Personality Inventory Manual.
Psychological Assessment Resources: Odessa, FL.
Davidson, R.J., (1984). Affect, Cognition, and Hemispheric Specialization.
InC. E. Izard, J. Kagan, & R. Zajonc (Eds.), Emotion, Cognition and
Behavior (pp. 320-365) .New York: Cambridge University Press.
Davidson, R.J., (1988). EEG Measures of Cerebral Symmetry: Conceptual
and Methodological Issues. International Journal of Neuroscience, 39,
71-89.
Davidson, R.J., (1992a). Anterior Cerebral Asymmetry and the Nature of
Emotion. Brain and Cognition, 20(1), 125-151.
Davidson, R.J., (1992b). Emotion and Affective Style: Hemispheric
Substrates. Psychological Science, 3(1), 39-43.
Davidson, R.J., (1993). Cerebral Asymmetry and Emotion: Conceptual and
Methodological Conundrums. Cognition and Emotion, 7, 115–138.
Davidson, R.J., (1994). Asymmetric Brain Function, Affective Style, and
Psychopathology: The Role of Early Experience and Plasticity.
Development and Psychopathology, 6,741-758.
Davidson, R.J., (1995). Cerebral Asymmetry, Emotion, and Affective Style.
In R.J. Davidson & K. Hugdahl (Eds.), Brain Asymmetry (pp. 361-388).
Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Davidson, R.J., (2004). What Does the Prefrontal Cortex “do” in Affect:
Perspectives on Frontal EEG Asymmetry Research. Biological
Psychology, 67, 219–233.
Davidson, R.J., Ekman, P., Saron, C., Senulis, J.A., & Friesen, W.V. (1990).
Approach-withdrawal and Cerebral Asymmetry: Emotional Expression
and Brain Physiology I. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,
58, 330–341.
71
#$''
% &#$
!"
Davidson, R.J., & Fox, N.A. (1989). Frontal Brain Asymmetry Predicts
Infants’ Response to Maternal Separation. Journal of Abnormal
Psychology, 98, 127-131.
Davidson, R.J., & Tomarken, A.J. (1989). Laterality and Emotion: An
Electrophysiological Approach. In F. Boller & J. Grafman (Eds.),
Handbook of Neuropsychology (pp. 419-441). Amsterdam: Elsevier.
Digman, J.M. (1997). Higher-order Factors of the Big Five. Journal of
Personality and Social Psychology, 73, 1246–1256.
Ekman, P. (1993). Facial Expression and Emotion. American Psychologist,
48, 384–392.
Elias, L.J., Bryden, M.P., & Bulman-Fleming, M.P. (1998). Footedness is a
Better Predictor Than is Handedness of Emotional Lateralization.
Neuropsychologia, 36, 37-43.
Eysenck, H.J. (1967). The Biological Bases of Personality. Springfield, IL:
Charles C. Thomas.
Eysenck, H. (1994a). The Big Five or Hiant Three: Criteria for a Paradigm.
In C.F. Halverson, & G.A. Kohnstamm (Eds.). The Developing Structure
of Temperament and Personality from Infancy to Adulthood. (pp. 37-51).
Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
Eysenck, H.J. (1994b). Personality: Biological Foundations. In P. A. Vernon
(Ed.), the Neuropsychology of Individual Differences (pp. 15 1-207). San
Diego, CA: Academic Press, Inc.
Eysenck, H.J., & Eysenck, S.B.G. (1975). Manual of the EPQ (Eysenck
Personality Questionnaire). San Diego, CA: EdITS.
Eysenck, H.J., & Eysenck, M.W. (1985). Personality and Individual
Differences: A Natural Science Approach. New York: Plenum Press.
Eysenck, S.B.G., Eysenck, H.J., & Barrett, P. (1985). A Revised Version of
the Psychoticism Scale. Personality and Individual Differences, 6, 21-29.
Fox, N.A. (1994). Dynamic Cerebral Processes Underlying Emotion
Regulation. In N. A. Fox (Ed.), The Development of Emotion
Regulation: Biological and Behavioral Considerations. Monographs of
72
#$''
% &#$
!"
the Society for Research in Child Development, 59 (2-3, Serial No. 240,
pp. 152-166).
Gallagher, H.L., Happe, F., Brunswick, N., Fletcher, P.C., Frith, U., & Frith,
C.D. (2000). Reading the Mind in Cartoons and Stories: An fMRI Study
of ‘Theory of Mind’ in Verbal and Nonverbal Tasks. Neuropsychologia,
38, 11-21.
Gomez, R., Gomez, A., & Cooper, A. (2002). Neuroticism and Extraversion
as Predictors of Negative and Positive Emotional Information
Processing: Comparing Eysenck’s, Gray’s and Newman’s Theories.
European Journal of Personality, 16, 333–350.
Gross, J.J. (1998). Antecedent- and Response-focused Emotion Regulation:
Divergent Consequences for Experience, Expression, and Physiology.
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 74, 224 –237.
Gross, J.J. (2001). Emotion Regulation in Adulthood: Timing is everything.
Current Directions in Psychological Science, 10, 214-219.
Gross, J.J. (2002). Emotion Regulation: Affective, Cognitive, and Social
Consequences. Psychophysiology, 39, 281-291.
Gross, J.J. (Ed.). (2007). Handbook of Emotion Regulation. NewYork:
Guilford Press.
Gross, J.J., & John, O.P. (2002). Wise Emotion Regulation. In L. Feldman
Barrett & P. Salovey (Eds.), The Wisdom of Feelings: Psychological
Processes in Emotional Intelligence (pp. 297-318). New York: Guilford.
Gross, J.J., & John, O.P. (2003). Individual Differences in Two Emotion
Regulation Processes: Implications for Affect, relationships, and
Wellbeing. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 85, 348–362.
Gross, J.J., & Levenson, R.W. (1993). Emotional Suppression: Physiology,
Self-report, and Expressive Behavior. Journal of Personality and Social
Psychology, 64, 970-986.
Gross, J.J., & Munoz, R.F. (1995). Emotion Regulation and Mental Health.
Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice, 2, 151-164.
73
#$''
% &#$
!"
Hagemann, D., Naumann, E., Lurken, A., Becker, G., Maier, S., & Bartussek,
D. (1999). EEG asymmetry, Dispositional Mood and Personality.
Personality and Individual Differences, 27, 541–568.
Harmon-Jones, E. (2004). Contributions from Research on Anger and
Cognitive Dissonance to Understanding the Motivational Functions of
Asymmetrical Frontal Brain Activity. Biological Psychology, 67, 51–76.
Harmon-Jones, E., & Allen, J.J. B. (1997). Behavioral Activation Sensitivity
and Resting frontal EEG Asymmetry: Covariation of Putative Indicators
Related to Risk for Mood Disorders. Journal of Abnormal Psychology,
106(1), 159-163.
Henriques, J.B., & Davidson, R.J. (1990). Regional Brain Electrical
Asymmetries Discriminate Between Previously Depressed and Healthy
Control Subjects. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 99(1), 22- 31.
Jackson, D.C., Burghy, C.A., Hanna, A.J., Larson, C.L., & Davidson, R.J.
(2000). Resting Frontal and Anterior Temporal EEG asymmetry Predicts
Ability to Regulate Negative Emotion. Psychophysiology, 37, S50.
Jackson, D.C., Malmstadt, J.R., Larson, C.L., & Davidson, R.J. (2000).
Suppression and Enhancement of Emotional Responses to Unpleasant
Pictures. Psychophysiology, 37, 515 –522.
John, O.P., & Gross, J.J. (2004). Healthy and Unhealthy Emotion Regulation:
Personality Processes, Individual Differences, and Lifespan
Development. Journal of Personality, 72, 1301-1334.
Kagan, J. (1994). On the Nature of Emotion. In N.A. Fox (Ed.), The
Development of Emotion Regulation: Biological and Behavioral
Considerations. Monographs of the Society for Research in Child
Development, 59 (2-3, Serial No. 240, pp. 7-24).
Kardum, I., & Hudek-Knezevic, J. (1996). The Relationship between
Eysenck's Personality Traits, Coping Styles and Moods. Personality and
Individual Differences, 20,341-350.
Keltner, D., & Kring, A. (1998): Emotion, Social Function, and
Psychopathology. Review of General Psychology, 2, 320 –342.
74
#$''
% &#$
!"
Kline, J.P., Allen, J.J.B., Schwartz, G.E., (1998). Is Left Frontal Brain
Activation in Defensiveness Gender Specific? Journal of Abnormal
Kline, J.P., Blackhart, G.C., & Schwartz, G.E.R. (1999). Gender Specificity
of Resting Anterior Electroencephalographic Asymmetry and
Defensiveness in the Elderly. Journal of Gender-Specific Medicine, 2,
35–39.
Lane, R.D., Reiman, E.M., Ahern, G.L., Schwartz, G. E., & Davidson, R.J.
(1997). Neuroanatomical Correlates of Happiness, Sadness, and Disgust.
American Journal of Psychiatry, 154, 926 –933.
Lane, R.D., Reiman, E.M., Bradley, M.M., Lang, P.J., Ahern, G.L.,
Davidson, R.J., & Schwartz, G.E. (1997). Neuroanatomical Correlates of
Pleasant and Unpleasant Emotion. Neuropsychologia, 35, 1437 –1444.
Larsen, R.J. (1991). Ketelaar, T Personality and Susceptibility to Positive and
Negative Emotional States. Journal of Personality and Social
Larsen, R.J., & Ketelaar, T. (1989). Extraversion, Neuroticism, and
Susceptibility to Positive and Negative Mood Induction Procedures.
Personality and Individual Differences, 10, 1221–1228.
Levenson, R.W. (2003). Autonomic Specificity and Emotion. In: Davidson
R.J., Scherer, K.R., & Goldsmith, H.H., editors. Handbook of Affective
Sciences. NewYork: Oxford University Press, 212–224.
Minnix, J.A., & Kline, J.P. (2004) Neuroticism Predicts Resting Frontal EEG
Asymmetry Variability. Personality and Individual Differences, 36, 823832.
Ochsner, K.N., & Feldman Barrett, L. (2001). A Multi-process Perspective
on the Neuroscience of Emotion. In G. Bonnano & T.J. Mayne (Eds.),
Emotion: Current Issues and Future Directions (pp. 38-81). New York:
Guilford.
Ochsner, K.N., & Gross, J.J. (2005). The Cognitive Control of Emotion.
Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 9, 242–249.
75
#$''
% &#$
!"
Phelps, E.A., (2006). Emotion and Cognition: Insights from Studies of the
Human Amygdale. Annual Review Psychology, 57, 27–53.
Paradiso, S., Jhonson, D.L., Andreasen, N.C., O’Leary, D.S., Watkins, G.L.,
Ponto, L.L., & Hichwa, R.D. (1999). Cerebral Blood Flow Changes
Associated with Attribution of Emotional Valence to Pleasant,
Unpleasant, and Neutral Visual Stimuli in a PET Study of Normal
Subjects. American Journal of Psychiatry, 156, 1618 –1629.
Parkinson, B. and Totterdell, P. (1999) Classifying Affect-regulation
Strategies. Cogntion and Emotion, 13, 277–303.
Paunonen, S.V., & Jackson, D.N. (2000). What is the Beyond the Big Five?
Plenty! Journal of Personality, 68, 821-835.
Reiman, E.M., Lane, R.D., Ahern, G.L., Schwartz, G.E., Davidson, R.J.,
Friston, K.J., Yun, L.S., & Chen, K. (1997). Neuroanatomical Correlates
of Externally and Internally Generated Human Emotion. American
Journal of Psychiatry, 154, 918 –925.
Richards, J. M., & Gross, J.J. (2000). Emotion Regulation and Memory: The
Cognitive Costs of keeping one’s Cool. Journal of Personality and
Social Psychology, 79, 410 –424.
Rottenberg, J., Ray, R.D., & Gross, J.J. (2007). Emotion Elicitation Using
Films. In J.A. & J.J.B. Allen (Eds.), The Handbook of Emotion
Elicitation and Assessment (pp. 9–28). New York: Oxford University
Press.
Rusting, C.L., (1998). Personality, Mood, and Cognitive Processing of
Emotional Information: Three Conceptual Frameworks. Psychological
Bulletin, 124, 165–196.
Rusting, C.L., (1999). Interactive Effects of Personality and Mood on
Emotion-Congruent Memory and Judgment. Personality and Social
Psychology, 77, 1073–1086.
Rusting, C.L., & Larsen, R.J. (1998). Personality and Cognitive Processing of
Affective Information. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 24,
200–213.
76
#$''
% &#$
!"
Rusting, C.L., & Larsen, R.J. (1997). Extraversion, Neuroticism and the
Susceptibility of Positive and Negative Affect: A Test of Two
Theoretical Models. Personality and Individual Differences, 22, 607–
612.
Steenhuis, R.E., & Bryden, M.P. (1989). Different Dimensions of Hand
Preference That Relate to Skilled and Unskilled Activities. Cortex, 25,
289-304.
Steenhuis, R.E., Bryden, M.P., Schwartz, M., & Lawson, S. (1990).
Reliability of Hhand Preference Items and Factors. Journal of Clinical
and Experimental Neuropsychology, 12, 921-930.
Sutton, S.K., & Davidson, R.J. (1997). Prefrontal Brain Asymmetry: A
Biological Substrate of the Behavioral Approach and Inhibition Systems.
Psychological Science, 8(3), 204-210.
Tomarken, A.J., Davidson, R.J., & Henriques, J.B. (1990). Resting Frontal
Brain Asymmetry Predicts Affective Responses to Films. Journal of
Personality and Social Psychology, 59, 791–801.
Tomarken, A.J., Davidson, R.J., Wheeler, R.E., & Doss, R.C. (1992).
Individual Differences in Anterior Brain Asymmetry and Fundamental
Dimensions of Emotion. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,
62(4), 676-687.
Tomarken, A.J., Davidson, R.J., Wheeler, R.E., & Kinney, L. (1992).
Psychometric Properties of Resting Anterior EEG Asymmetry: Temporal
Stability and InternalC. Psychophysiology, 29, 576–592.
Tomarken, A.J., & Davidson, R.D. (1994). Frontal Brain Activation in
Repressors and Nonrepressors. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 103,
339–349.
Tooby, J., & Cosmides, L. (1990). The Past Explains the Present: Emotional
Adaptations and the Structure of Ancestral Environments. Ethology and
Sociobiology, 11, 375-42.
Vuilleumier, P. (2005). How Brains Beware: Neural Mechanisms of
Emotional Attention. Trends in Cognitive Science, 9, 585–594.
77
#$''
% &#$
!"
Watson, D., Clark L.A. (1992). On Traits and Temperament: General and
Specific Factors of Emotional Experience and Their Relation to the fiveFactor Model. Journal of Personality, 60, 441-476.
Wheeler, R.E., Davidson, R.J., & Tomarken, A.J. (1993). Frontal Brain
Asymmetry and Emotional Reactivity: A Biological Substrate of
Affective Style. Psychophysiology, 30(1), 82-89.
Zelenski, J.M., & Larsen, R.J. (1999). Susceptibility to Affect: A Comparison
of Three Personality Taxonomies. Journal of Personality, 67, 761-791.
78
#$''
% &#$
!"
=>??
O13 E
& =>
>)3> $ 8"$/-=M
)
#
!
0J K )3
- P
-L L
:-A8H. ) 13
%
1 *
:
F < R 3 ;C
@*`!
0
.@
.@
(& 4N g 0 & . 3
B C 4C 0 ;
AP
+&MN 4< & 24 =S
& & ^ W 0 ,E (
; 8:`
( ; 1 T ;A#5 T & ;. T 14
Tg ) ;K E 0 ƒ T ;K E
& 24
U 0 @ RS B C 4C
1
& (IQ=Xci$$D) 0
(IQ=$kci$eD) 24 * T(IQ=cDifD) v*A<
1
& B C 4C C/E —4
1
0 ; 8:` & ;K E 0 ƒ
{4 g*& 0 (& g* !M
3 ) E )A =# 0
24 * Tv*A<
U 0 @ RS ” 4C X$ Y # =
g 0
4 35
g<5 0 ; 8:` J *S T @. H (^ 0 B4 35 Y # =
g 0 & .@ 4&
# (h .
Y* O 3 0 5 Y* O 0 & . 4& ;< #)*, . ;< wSO
@ * B4 #4 B4 35 T Ž &
B C 4C C
B =
u ; .@# A;
< B4 35 t B4 35 TLSD B4 35 0 *I; ƒ h
8 A
4& g*
1 3 @. H (^ B4 35 † ` 4< J *S 3 \S
U 0 @ RS
0 B C 4C 3 =*&
U 0 @ RS B C 4C C )<
`#5
M 0 ; .@
5 &0
,
!
U 0 @ RS B C 4C 1@ C • 34 g*& .@
G ;K E
(< • ,
24 *
g*& 8 A g C E W . 4&
, 8 A 0 B C 4C 1@ C • 34 & K S
;K E ƒ
3 =*&
U 0 @ RS B C 4C C
B
; g* !M .@ @
24 * 0 B C 4C
ƒ
0 ; 8:` B * g 9 & .@ ;K 0 ; 8:`
(< • ,
24 * 0 B C 4C
;K E 0 1 ! 0 ƒ g*& C E W .@# @
24 * 0
1
14
& ;.
.)# @ 4.
, 8 A 0 ; 8:` œ OE 3 @ RS B C 4C
0 ƒ T U 0 @ RS T24 * B C 4C T0 ; / AP 0 1M*N 4< T24 :0@* C 0 j
.0 ; 8:` T ;K E
79
#$''
% &#$
!"
0 ;
;. T AP 0 1M*N 4<
=S ” 4C
AP @ 4*
0 ;
AP 0 & F M*N 4}K ” 4C
;K E (& .
” 4C
$
3
0 4 E ” 4C
;K E 0 & 3 .($Xf% T E &) T) ” 4C
;<
& ” 4C 0 3 H F *67 )O C ) ( ) k ;K E 0 !
;#
4< ” 4C 8 C W
; & B@# n
4
q ! . 4#
%
4P & C
.@& *& g
;K E ƒ ” 4C
;W ; *& @# &
e
2
14
B C 4C ‰94 , @ ;K* @ ~
J ; Y& G @
)& 6
@ 4< & ;. B C 4C @ @ )* KW 4< B @ 3 M†: & C
.@
c
0 q+
&
4 < & w ,; B C 4C .($XXe T g*E & 0@* C) )#
;K E ƒ
& ‰94 , *V
/I 4 T” 4C & ; 4 T” 4C 3
C &
f
q ! .($XXk TB
Ÿ &@ 1 B TB B ) @ 1
F d ; 1 / ;A#5
0 & 39 0 @S @ C G & ” 4C & @ ~
) ? 0 (& @ 4;&
g B3 4 *
@ 0 @ @ .) @# M ” 4C F & 23
0 # C
P
;. 0@ 5 C & )
” 4C ; C 23 & Y& S; - (&
8 6 & 4< ; G 0 ;
;K E 0 ! q ! . 1
F
'
4< 0 &4 & C 4& @ 4+
=+&
0 ” 4C @# & @ C P
X
C W 8 S*SO 3 0 *K& . 4#
F @ #3 *V
A « 4<
04 E » &
$D
1@ ~
)* KW B * C @ 5 3
TB 4 TB4 @ ) ” 4C M†: &
$k
$$
B4 @ ˆ$XX% T
B3 i @ * # ˆ$XXD TB
Y x C T4 C )*
4 ! T($XXd TB 4
P g; / ” 4 C
K./ AP 0 3 * ^
1- working models
3- secure
5- Cassidy and Berlin
7- Ijzendroon & Vangoldberg
9- self working model
11- Pederson, Moran, Sitko, Campbell
2- attachment figure
4- ambivalent
6- disorganized / disoriented
8- secure base
10- responsivenss
12- Schneider, Rosen, Rothbaum
80
#$''
% &#$
!"
TB4K*E5 0 ; ˆ$XXc T$h @E4# T@ * B4K 4; )
; ƒ
” 4C
k
& ” 4C ;K E ƒ 0 *1Y`# M*S;K *V M*S;K ($XXc T B4 @ 4
3 g
B C 4C B
.@ 0 64 =S @ 5
0 ; )* +# B5 •
0
ƒ
@
G * Š(
F*
; )* & G œ OE
e
%
B4 @E TB & Tg 1 g &) @ @
T 9 | 9 Tg 4 T `C ˆ kDDD T B
0 8 A C C 4C &
& g @E AP (& C @
N & .(kDDD
0 B C 4C
& #4
;< # 0 = C œ OE 3 0 NW: Y& G … <
*K
@ 4;& ` 5 0 & B C 4C g 3 .)
4< & r < )* 3 @
…4 < & g @E & ME
AP (& ƒ & 8@# & @ *1 G 4O * &
@ 3 & @ ~
J KW T 1 ‚
ƒ F
)K`# .@ 3 *
04 6 0 bS =
B #4 *
AP
0 ; 8:`
& @4
5 C) l( 4 g . 1 F
U B 1@ RS
0@# 0 *<
9 & 24 5 Œ@
G { , E )O
;K E ‚
24 @
4
g* 24 h` &
Œ) ” 4C
AP
;K E 4O 0 @ CY* K
=S
4 < M;K* & C ^ V Y& G *V *67 Y*E & ( U 1@ RS )
” 4C 0 ; / AP 0 1M*N 4<
;K E 4O /1
@
@E
Œ 1 ” 4C 0 ; 8:`
& F ‰;
;<
. 4 *<7 &
U )*E4 , 3 # J ;
;W @
#4 bS C C 4C 4
@# & ;# @ C 6
1@ ~
)* KW )*A*C B * & ” 4C
c
T *C .($XXX T 8 & @ 4
T25 ) @ =
;K E
;W
d
hC4 TB E4
. @ RS ” 4C %d 0 & C
(kDDk) B
; W ; *& @ @ J KW
1 ;G ƒ C
@ & @ C
1- Stevenson - Hind, Shouldice
3- Biringer, Brown, Donalson
5- Roach, Orsmond, Barratt
81
2- Petrie- Allison, Davidson
4- Tarkka, Paunonen, lai ppala
6- Perkins, Holburn, Deaux
#$''
% &#$
!"
T©
4*E ,E ( J & .@ # & ;#
& ;.
14
0 @ RS ” 4C
$
- (& ƒ ) &
” 4C T U 1@ RS ($XXf)
*
hC 4& ;
k
B
3@*C g 4 gK
w*SO .@
G ; 1 / ;A#5 g
;K E
. C @*
U - @ RS B C 4C
;A#5 g
;K E ƒ * (kDDD)
• & ;W
4&
;K E 0 *1Y`# 0@ C *<7 & 24
bS
%
!:&) 4#
U 0 1@ RS { 4 3 < & B5 B @S
.($X'% T 3
( #5 )*,G4 2
)
3 @.
g*
A 0 = C 4.
e
J & .) \
5 ;K E B 3 & (DS) B
@
& :; B C 4C
& ;. g
;K E 8 S P
9 & 8 . & DS B C 4C ; g
c
4O
*<7 .(kDDD T
! C T) & Tg * 1) @ *1
. ; 1 / ;A#5
d
* ($XXk) B
. Tg*; @ * TYK C \ 4 DS B C 4C ;K E
$%' 0 & C
($XXe) B4*K ` Ÿ & @ 1 TB 1 .) @# @* 7
4S g œ OE 3
4 35 CB5 4. & C @ ;
T@
F DS ” 4C
3 < & .@ ;#
&
;K E )*A*C œ OE 3
@ 4& 8 A; E4O
f
@4 0
h ‰:? @
64
;K E ƒ
1@ RS {4 8 ,E (
& ;K E ‚
@ `# x @
& :; B C 4C C @ ;<
`#5 ($XXD)
.@ @ 0 F &
& Y& S; 8: ,
g* 24 C ) 1 F*; B 4
@# † w*SO 8 * & J & g & &
&
;< B 34
@ ªC
;K E 4O @ 5 @ 4
U )*E4 ,
8
& ) 9 & ” 4C 24 C
. 4# F g
;K E - ƒ
'
) @S;, (kDD%) C 4E Œ 4 & @ 4< 4 ! ;K E @ 5 ) 24 *
1- Lyons- Ruth, Easterbrooks, Cibelli
3- Blacher, Meyers
5- Ganiban, Barnett, Cicchetti
7- Reiss and Freund
2- Willimson, Swinkds
4- Down Syndrome
6- Crownel, Feldstein, Jansnow
8- Loveckly
82
#$''
% &#$
!"
&
— ( B * w P 3 24 * ” 4C
;K E *E @ 5 C
, )*A*C C 4E N w P & . 1 b+ ” 4C *E M†: 8 p
0 )*E , Š( •G
@
Ž 0 ; *& 8m@W 8@# & 24 * ” 4C
0 *1 T ; *& .4 )
9 & 0 B C 4C & ) K B C 4C g
0`
C @E .@ P g @E 3 0 @ @# *E 0 B@# 4.
; *&
(& @ 4
T@ ;K ) 4< g & ) K 0 ; *& 1@ ~
& G
B C 4C ;K E ƒ
4
C@ 8 ,E ( .@ 3 M
0 g
;K E
& B C 4C g
;K E {4 C @ 5 3 C W 5 ?C ) @# F 24 *
$
–*
;K 4* 0 ,E ( .
;K&
& g @E 0 1@E ƒ
& 8@#
B C 4C g
;K E & *1B 5
@;S
@E 0 ƒ
B (kDDd)
& g @E B5
C
P8 @G
@E ƒ
C EW ) \
24 *
&@
~ R
4O & 24 * ” 4C 0 3 *
@
*1 ” 4C
& ” 4C %c 0 & C
* (kDD%) C 4E .) \ g
;K E
& g 4P & 24 * B C 4C C )<
`#5
F 9 & & $fD #4 0 &
5 Y & B C 4C g g @E & C 0 W
.@ 4#
;K E 4< g @E
0 ^S &
0 4* # & Tg 24 * B C 4C g @E C @# .4;
0 1 &— (
@
R
~
4< B @ 3 @ @#
/ ) S
;K E (kDDd) – * ;K 4* w*SO J & T@ 4& w 4 24 * B C 4C
#4 * B C 4C .) \
B5
1 C B * & 24 * B C 4C g
.@ ;K g @ 9 &
;.
1 C C
&
;
=S M
E4O Y ƒ B 4 & ” 4C ;K E ƒ
04 3
23 0 ; C @ 5 &
v ;+ 8 ,E (
” 4C 0 ; )*,^
M 41 T) TJ4 ) ) ; *& g
;K E 0 ƒ 0 B C 4C
1- Neumeister & Finch
83
#$''
% &#$
!"
‚ ‡ & 8 ,E ( .($XXc Tn 4. To 4. Tg 4E4 ˆ $XX' TB4KE C ˆ$XXd T$4
k
T@
Tg* ) 4 < MC @ 5
S T($XX$ TB
J * TY x C) g <
%
T
#) ” 4C & K.
K . ; 4 T($X'X T z @ Y T
;K 3 /
0 1 T 4# w < T( K ) )*K . T($XXd B `
@
e
#4 0 & T :C 0 bS T($XX% T E4! & B xE5 T© 4*E) ” 4C H4*,
! C) g @E ;<
89:;< ($XX% Td)*A 4 T $XXk Tc # g* ) g*
T© 4*E .@ C @*C7 ” 4C 0 ; 8:`
& 5 =S T($XXf Tf241
” 4C g* 24 3 *C C @ C 2 1 ($XXc) B
hC & ;
f g
03
& 8:` - @ C *&=*
9 & 4P & g
;K E
@ ;# w , ; 1 / ;A#5 - S P & C 24 MC B C 4C %cD .@# &
E
w < M @ ;# ;A#5 ;K E M C C 4C T@ 4& 03
& 8:` 0
T # .($XXc T @
#) @ ;#
G M 4 ”@r 0 # < œ OE 3 4#
ƒ
& 0 ; 8:` 8@# g*& C @ ;
($XXf) B
@ T
; 1 / ;A#5 g
;K E B C 4C C 0 4P & .
4. (& ” 4C ;K E
3 %%$ C E W .@
B
0 ; 8:`
0 # < Š( g 9 &
.@ ;# 0 # < g B C 4C 3 %$f
14
3 %k' T & ;. B C 4C
C
U 0 @ RS B C 4C @ ;
($XXf) * hC & ;
©
4*E
03
& 0 ; 8:`
& :;& @,;K @
; 1 / ;A#5 g
;K E
1@ RS •G
.@ C @*
—4 0 ; * (kDDk) # n* C .@ ;K
0 ;
& 4< 0 &4 & C @
G ;A#5 ;K E *K
” 4C
U
0 ;
& ;. 0 @ RS B C 4 C
C E W . 4#
F 03
&
.($XXf T E & C ThC 4& ; T© 4*E) ) 03
& 3 =*& 03
1- Moss, Parent, Gosselm, Rousseau
3- Renken, Egeland, Marvinney, Mangelsdorf
5- Hinshaw
7- Cicchetti, Rogosh
2- Campbell and pierce
4- Lyons–Ruth, Alpern, Repacholi
6- Moffitt
84
#$''
% &#$
!"
Y*E
0
$
)K
(<
1@
=
&
U 0 @ RS B C 4C C @ C B *& (kDDd) gK . Y #
3 1@* 0 )*,G4
0 &S 0 8
B @S g
0
;K E
4` E5 g 4 5 T ;
g; C - ,E ( .@ ;K 0 ; *& 0 ; 8:`
C 4& B5 3 C W T@# . @ RS E di$% B C 4C 4
C (kDDf)
R* 5 Y? 0 ( 0 *I; < & \ 4 `# x
0 ; 8:`
g* 0 ;G )*,^ T@E ƒ & 1@ 3 Tg*
;. @# TB &3 @#
;. @^ 0 ; B 4& 9 & & * (kDDc) B4
B4
TB4K` .@&
@*C T@# &
;. )* O
S & ;G
&
U 0 @ RS B C 4C
k
ƒ& )1 T *& TB4
.@ C
& :; B C 4C
C@;
($XXX) B
%
. g* 24 ) ” 4C w < 3 6 ; ; *& 0 ; 8:`
@ `# x @
U - @ RS - E di$' B C 4C C (kDDd) B
TY
T ; TB C
@ RS B C 4C C @ ;
T@ C K S Ž & g<5 0 ; )
3 A; &
24 g*& 0 (& C
; z:< & .@ 0 ; *& 0 ; 8:` R
&
24 * B C 4C 4
C ,E ( @ C )& 6 0 ; 8:`
g*
/ 0 ; 8:` - @ CY* K
9 & 24 C ) B5 3 C W ; 1 8 4r
g
3 .@ F
\*O & B C 4C g ; *& 0 13
& ` & )K* AP
0 &S 0 8
9 & hA & ; T 4& 8 6 & A P œ OE 3 B C 4 C
)E4
& @ ;K
G 5 .@
P
8:`
& B@# . 4 0 & 0 04G
g 4C) @ *& C 5 & ; &
b*+
8:`
Y† K 0 ; *&
H4KO
4;C * 24 Š( ; E .($XX' T” C 3 YS $X'c TB
;. / 0 ; 0 0 F & C @ ;<
` #5 8 ,E (
< & . 4#
& 24 * B C 4C ) Y O ; @
9 & $'D #4 - & C C 4C
1- Kostentausta, Iivanainece, Almqrist
3- Fragile x Syndrome
85
2- Hatton, Baily, Hargett-Beck
#$''
% &#$
!"
; ƒ
. 3 0 @,; Y 4 W & .($XX' T” C) $%Di$cD #4 - &
R
@O T¬G ; 0 ) @O
T($XXd T©
4*E)
@E
$
g <
&7 4 ;` 0 1@E ƒ ($XX$ TB
@ 1 TB4KE C Tg& 4 )
z@ .)
64 24 * B C 4 C 0 ; 8:`
.(kDDd T– * ;K 4* )
(\ 4; Tg* T9 & #4 - &) 24 B * =S
& ^W=
r
T24 * B C 4C 0 ; 8:`
3 &
;K E 0 ƒ
0 *1Y` #
.) 0 B C 4C & K S
v*A<
U 1@ RS
2
- 50 4
, .
fD #4 0 & &) v*A<
U 0 @ RS B C 4C * C =
g
50 , .
(Xci$$D #4 0 & &) 0
($kci$eD #4 0 & &) 24 * (cDi
d$ =
g
& 4
0 4 .@ 4&
# E )A =#
%D
# E dif (24 * kX
U 0 @ RS %k)
?; ” 4C
g 0
4 35 YC g & & .@ 4& ( ; C 1)
1 g* 0 ” 4C A
0 B C 4C T U 0 @ RS B C 4C 0 & 4 2 . 4& A X$ =
2 & 1 5
J:C Y* O & 4I B C 4C g*& 3 24 *
.@ @# H +; MN 0 W @ !
- *1 3 @ -
&
B4 35 3
;K E 0 ƒ
& 3 0 &=
g
: @. H (^ B4 35
$
B5 0 @# N @ @F 0 +K ($X'') Ÿ & g 1 T ; 41 T4
@. H (^
\ 4 $%fX
& g*;K+ 0 & B4 35 g .@# A; ($%'k T F <)
1- Urban, Carlson, Egeland
2- Slough, Goyette, Greenberg
86
#$''
% &#$
!"
g
.($%'k T F <) ) @ #
— ( B
\ # &
F<
O H ;. T ` 4< T ;K E J *S 3
” 4C
J *S
Tg ) 4 35 ;K E ƒ
@` &
g K S J & . 1
!1
B B4 35 g 3 @ 5 ) & u ; . 4# b+ ( & ;. T 14
@# &
& ;. T 14
Tg
;K E ƒ
3 \S r - +K
Š^
. B ` C 0 4P & .@ ;#
*& *& 8 B C 4C 3 0 @, )
- S P g*& •G
.)# @ 4. & ; .
14
SP
5 g#
g ($XXD) g 4E4
g* N J
& C@; 1
G H ;.
14
)* & G
& 4N & .@ 4#
@* ;A#5 / ; 1 0 S P b+
0 SP
$ @. B5 u ; C @# A;
353 & 2 3 @. H (^ B4 35 ;
.) @# †
H ;.
0
` 4< T ;K E J *S 3
B4 35 0 . - W
, Š(
D/DDD
D/DDD
D/DDD
. 4#
@
;K
N
D/'D$**
D/'d' **
D/XfX**
%k
%k
%k
J *S 3
0 &
;K
R ^ ($)
#
@.
J *S 3
k
;K E $ ;K E
k ` 4< $ ` 4<
k H ;. $ H ;.
9&
; R ^$
@. w P &
C @# A;
. &
8 A 0
,
& 0 & * t B4 35 3 g* q
& ;K E 0 J *S 3 3 ƒ –*
0 .
g* * 8 A
C@
, p=D/%fe & H ;. p=D/ek% & ` 4< Tp=D/''X
.) B4 35 g 09 & ; )* & G
$
fX Y # &
Ž & g<5 ” 4C 0 ; )
: Ž & g<5 B C 4C 0 ; J *S
B4 35 . 4# 0 /1
Dik 8 4r & C @# & B C 4C ; 3 * 4
87
#$''
% &#$
!"
@# & ; 03 *# B C 4C 0 &
ƒ * \ 4 $%fc
Ž & g<5
Š(
C D/cXiD/'D 3 J *S 3 ; )* & G R ^ u ; .)
&
K
* ^W =
.) @# 2 1 T@ 4&
, p=D/DD$
& D/Xe & & & B4 35 YC 0 & C @ 1
O Ž C 0 AE5 2 3 A;
.@ 5 )
$X%'
B5
C B4 35 g
:kB4 @ * 0 h
B4 35
3 C @ C H +; 0 4 @ & 4 35 T) @# * $Xef
B5
- .
C )
B
Y* O .@ C 0 * h
& MC W B4 G
.) 9 & *K& 4 24 Y
, g *x G Y
B4 35 g ;#
;
T
`
4< T
;K E J *S 3
:)
0
4 35 A*r4 0 b< # k @.
@# † 4
@. H (^ B4 35 H ;.
24 * Tv*A<
U - @ RS B C 4C 0 5 0
+
@. H (^ B4 35 - 1 0 J *S 3
@ ; 0 (<
@ ; z O
( k)
@.
D/%$c
D/ece
D/cD'
$/f%
k/ee
%/De
g* *
X/kD
'/fk
'/dc
%D
kX
%k
1
0
24 *
U - @ RS
J *S {4
;K E
D/%d$
D/eDD
D/ckk
$/X'
k/$k
k/Xc
X/DD
'/d'
f/%$
%D
kX
%k
0
24 *
U - @ RS
` 4<
D/ce$
D/e'e
D/cdk
k/Xd
k/cd
%/$'
f/%d
'/$e
f/kc
%D
kX
%k
0
24 *
U - @ RS
H ;.
;K E B * g 9 & k
@. w P &
0
BC 4 C &w,;
1- Achenbach
` 4<
B C 4C
#
2- Test des matries progressives de raven
88
#$''
% &#$
!"
3 @ 5 ) & u ; .@# & 24 * B C 4C & w ,; H ;. B * g 9 &
g*& 3 C @
B LSD *S, B4 35 (ANOVA) P ƒ h
Y* O
T C/E —4 J *S 3
U - @ RS 24 * T0 B C 4C 3 1
0 B C 4C 1 &
U - @ RS B C 4C g*& ` 4< J *S 3 \S
4.
, 8 A 0 5 œ OE3 p<D/D%c & 24 * B C 4C & p<D/DDX &
& w ,;
` 4< g* * g g* @
B k @. 0 g* * .
.)
U - @ RS B C 4C
0
1
(B C 4C
;K E
-K S 0 &
< B4 35 u ; (%)
24 * B C 4C 1 & @ RS
1) YS;K *I;
24 *
U - @ RS
$d
$f/f
D/cc/k
$%
$$/%
D/ee/'
X
$c/D
D/k'/$
k%
$f/D
D/f$/X
A*r4 0
5
0
kD
$e/D
D/dd/f
$D
$d/D
D/%%/%
@# @
0N
#
@.
{4 ) ;K& *I;
( ;K E
g
;K E
@r
@# @
0N
g
;K E
@r
& w ,; g
;K E @r g 9 & 4#
@
% @.
C 4PB
1
& w ,;
;K E
@r g 9 & )
U - @ RS B C 4C
*, w P C ) B5 3 C W
< B4 35 u ; .@# & 24 * 0
2
œ OE 3
U - @ RS 0
1 g*& 8 A P<D/Dk Š(
=X/k%
2
=D/'$ & 24 * 0
1 g*& 8 A C E W .)
, 0 5
89
#$''
24 *
.)
T0
1
B C 4C
$d
$f/f
D/cc/k
f
d/X
D/ke/$
c
%/X
D/$f/k
$
D/c
D/%/e
!
C EW
.)K*
1 g*&
, Š(
D/DDD
;K E ƒ
24 *
1) YS;K *I;
U - @ RS
X
$c/D
D/k'/$
$$
X/%
D/%e/e
'
c/f
D/kc/D
e
k/$
D/$k/c
! K S 0 &
U - @ RS
A*r4 0
< B4 35 u ; (e)
5
0
kD
$e/D
D/dd/f
f
'/f
D/k%/%
%
c/%
D/$D/D
D
$/X
D/D
#
0 ƒ ) ;K&
( ;K E
@# @
0N
@.
*I;
g
@r
@# @
0N
14
@r
@# @
0N
& ;.
@r
@# @
0N
; 1
/ ;A#5
@r
U - @ RS 0
1 g*&
B
< B4 35 Š ;
2
.
4.
, 8 A p<D/D$
=$$/k'´ &
;K E ƒ
2
, 8 A p=D/kdk
=D/'$ & 24 * 0 B C 4C
1 g*&
B C 4C v ;+ 0
0
!"
g*& 8 A g* q .)K*
, 0 5 œ OE 3 p=D/kdk
, 0 5 œ OE 3 P<D/DkX 2=e/dD$ & *
U - @ RS
(B C 4C
24 *
% &#$
1 0 ; 8:` 0 *I; ƒ h
Y* O r:< (c)
0
24 * T U - @ RS
F
8 /F g* *
8 /F {4 F
$D/ck
eef'/kD
ekc/d'
'Xcd/eD
%'%$k/Dc
efkd'/ec
0 35 .
k
XD
Xk
#
@.
**I •
1 g*&
1B
YC
90
#$''
% &#$
!"
3 0
24 * T U - @ RS
1 (ANOVA) h
Y* O w P &
*S, B4 35 .@
@` & (p<D/DDD$) 0 , 8 A 0 ; 8:` œ OE
g* * 8 A &
U - @ RS 0 B C 4C 1 g*& C B
* LSD
U - @ RS B C 4C 1 g*& (p<D/DDD$) Š(
(MD=k$/dd)
, 8 A (P<D/DDD$) Š(
(MD=$X/dk) g* * 8 A & 24 *
(MD=k/De) & 0
24 * B C 4C g*& C E W
.
4. 0 5
.)K*
, 8 A (P=D/d'%)
;K E {4
Š(
0 ; 8:`
.
0 35
t @S
D/DDD
k'
ic/kk
D/%eD
%D
iD/Xf
D/DD$
kf
i%/cd
0
,
0 g* * K S 0 &
1
g /g
z O
@;
g* *
e/e'
$c/c$
kD/d%
kk/%%
'/ke
$c/f$
d/XD
kd/kD
kX/DD
%f/%e
'/$k
ke/%D
< B4 35 (d)
{4
;K E
g
g
g
g
g
g
#
@.
B C 4C
1
B C 4C
0
B C 4C
@ RS
B C 4C
24 *
=*& g B C 4C 0 ; 8:` , 1
d @. 0 g* * w P &
R
& 24 * 0
1
g* * 8 A g
.) g B C 4C 3
- @ RS B C 4C
C EW ) @#
, 0 5œO E3
4& 9 &
.)K*
,
U
91
#$''
&
;K E
Š(
0
,
D/DDD
D/cf$
D/D$'
% &#$
1 ! 0 ƒ 0 *I; ƒ h
Y* O r:< (f)
1 B C 4C 0 ; 8:`
!"
#
@.
F
g* *
8 /F
{4 F
8 /F
.
0 35
$c/Xf
$%d%/ke
'c/%eD
kfkd/e'
k%De/$'
cD%D/dd
k
kf
kX
1 g*&
1B
YC
D/d'
%%d/kf
eX%/'k
$DD'/'%
$%'kf/$f
$e'%d/DD
%
k'
%$
1 g*& - @ RS B C 4C
1B
U
YC
e/Dd
deD/dk
$cf/cc
$Xk$/'f
%X%'/Xc
c'dD/'k
%
kc
k'
1 g*&
1B
YC
8 **I •
B C 4C
0
1
B C 4C
24 * B C 4C
& 0 B C 4C
1
C ) B5 @ 4 (f @.) h
Y* O u ;
œ OE 3 ;K E 0 ƒ g*& p<D/D$' & 24 * B C 4C 1
p<D/DDD$
8 A œ OE g 3
U B 1@ RS
4.
, 8 A 0 ; 8:`
.@ @ (P=D/cf$)
,
ƒ
! 3 ƒ –*
U - @ RS B C 4C LSD B4 35 u ; w P &
0 B C 4C C E W .@ @
, 8 A 0 ; 8:` œ OE 3 ;K E
u ; .@ 0 5
, 8 A & ;.
14
g ƒ g*& 24 *
/
œ OE 3
1
B K B ;<
B
< B4 35
.@ @
, 8 A 0 ; 8:`
;K E
92
#$''
% &#$
!"
0 *1 F*; •O&
† ` 4< H ;. T ;K E J *S 3 h
Y* O 3 @ 5 ) & u ;
\S 0
24 * T @ RS
1
g*& 3 C )<
`#5 LSD B4 35
.@ B C 4C
&0
, 8 A
` 4< @,„&
U - @ RS B C 4C
-RS . 4&
1 3 g* B 1@ RS
` 4< g* * C 0 4P &
= C R.4 4< C )
4 0 `
@ @# ) ª &
U 1@
B *& ) C B !M
04 3 . 4# B
& ;K& =
† ` 4<
- † 4 Š( 3
A*E ` & 4< \*O
B4! @ RS B C 4C R V @ C
0;C
C J KW T 4< )K`# R V F*; @ 4#
. 4 4< 0
; = C 5 hA & ; Š(
4# RE V 5 & \*O & ; C @
.($X'% TB4K *& B4K *& 3 YS ) .@&
= B 5 B9 K1 & & ;K&
$
(kDDk) B
hC4 TB E4 T *C =
u ; & ^W =
; g
.) 4K
3 =*&
U - @ RS B C 4C C 4& B5 ^ W =
- ; g M
& ; g .@
G ;K E
(<• ,
24 * 0 B C 4 C
k
(kDDd) gK . Y 4 # ˆ(kDDk) ƒE4;
Y 4 TgK . ˆ=
u ;
%
Tg*; @ * TYK C ˆ(kDDc) B
14C T `* T 3 =
& g* !M
e
g E ;W g** 4N & .@# & 4K ($X'%) 3
!:& ˆ($XXk) J .
- (& ƒ ) @S;, ($Xf%) E & . C ;
A ;+ Y 4 & B 4
;
c
M;K* (” 4C) "C-S" M;K*
, ” 4Ci
o 3 0 ; 0 M;K* F &
C
.@ ;K @ C ^
@` \ 4 @ @` Y ` ( ) d"C-g"
1- Perkins, Holburn, Deaux
3- Zeanah, Smyke, koga
5- Care- seeking
93
2- Janssen, Schuengel, stolk
4- Blacher, Meyers
6- Care-giving
#$''
% &#$
!"
Y , @#
F &
U )*E4 ,
.3
*E & (” 4C) M;K* g 3 `
= C - † @ B4!
4 @# @ 4< Y;+ 0 ; M;K*
g g*&
5 @ 4 B@ # ;K`# T
& @ RS ” 4C •G4 & Š*Or 0 ;
)* KW )*A*C B * & @ 4
” 4C )*E4 , 3 # J ; T@ 3
.($XXf TY14 3 YS ) @ = C B5
;# /1 A 6
1@ ~
B C 4 C g @E 0 J ; C @ C l ( ($XXX) 8 & @ 4
T25
T” 4C 04 3 3 0 ^ S T ; *& ; G 8:` Y*E &
U - @ RS
0 B C 4C g @E 3 9 & R
& *V
E4O 0 *<7 T0 *1
0@ ªC
‰;
)* KW = C & g @E 09 & J ; C )K*E W g .)
” 4C ;K E =S &
E ;W 8 * 3 ` .@ F
” 4C ;K E
.) ‚4& 3J ; 0 )*,G4
0 &S 0 8
3 A;
@ RS
T ` j4E4*& Y& S; 0 @
& B K 4O @ @S;, (kDDd) gK . Y 4 #
;< #B 0 R* 5 g** 0 & F*; ) \
;.
;< #B
0 1M*N 4< ƒ 4.
. 3 .@ ;K *1 0 1@ ! l4( MR $
R.4
4& B 4
F* 0
;+* & &
+&MN
C @ 5 C AP
@ RS B C 4C
04 3 . 4#
&B
& A
AP \&
& 4< g C .@ F
3 03
#4 œ OE & C @ ;K
@E B @ 3 R V
” 4C AP 0 3 * )E W g ; &
/1 A *67 ” 4C 3 ) G Š(
1 K ) ^ 0
B 4& 9 & .@ C
^ v*,^
@C
4P &
@ C *67 B
)* KW Š( & * @ RS B C 4C B
(H (^
•G4 & Š*Or = C
@# 4< &
E4I
8 F* ) ª R.4
k
B *& (kDDd) 0 4 .($XXk T 4* ƒ; ) @
= C ” 4C M†:
&
w ª< ` & 4#
F
;K E
& 4< 0 4< & 24 bS C @ C
1- Mental retarded
2- Howe
94
#$''
% &#$
!"
T 3 .@
= C B5 ;# /1 A *67
)* KW & @ RS ”
;K E
M Y
) G )*A*C (kDDc) B4KE C 14C T `*
$
@ RS B C
@*
; g * (kDDd) Y # ƒE4; T x*# .@
B
C )<
`#5 * (kDDk) B
B E4 T * C =
.@
;W ; *& @ @ J KW
1 ;G ƒ
C 0 @ RS B C
.@ # & ;# & ;. 14
”
;K E ƒ
C C 4C 0
B5 8@#
; &B
4C
4C
C
4C
4C
1@ RS {4
B ($X'D) ‹@ E4C =
@;
($X'e) h 4E B 1 hC 4& .) 64
.@ ;K
@ ~ @ 0 9& S g
B C 4C ;K E ƒ
! 1@ C • 34 C )<
`#5
- ;
0 4P & .@
, 8 A F & B C 4C ;K E 0 ƒ &
U @ RS
B C 4C 3 @r k' \S g
;K E ƒ
0 B C 4C 3 @r dd/f C
T©
4*E 0 ; & ^ W =
- ; g .@ ;K g , @ RS
T($XXe) B
B4K *` TŸ &@ 1 TB 1 T($XXf) E & C hC 4& ;
^W =
.) n
4K ($XXc) k 4
ƒE 4 41 TŸ &@ 1
hx (@r %e/e) 14 ƒ
& w ,; @ RS B C 4C @ r g ; *&
g . w , (@r $k/c) ; 1 / ;A#5 ƒ @,& (@r kc) & ;. ƒ
ˆ($XXf) ©
4*E T(kDDD)
! C T) & Tg& 1 - ,E ( u ; & ;
%
C (kDDd) gK . Y 4# (kDD) B
Ÿ
Ci
& T C g 4 igK
w , ; 1 / ;A#5 ;K E ƒ
& ; *&
U @ RS B C 4C @ ;
& ‚4& @ 4
8 I g E ;W g** .)K* 4K
n
T@
C F 5 3 .@ # & ^ W =
0
4 35 & MC W
/ /
0 8 A
1- Schipper, stolk, Schuengel
2- Goldberg, Gotowlec, Sunumons
3- willemsen, swinkels, Barkerman, Kranenburg
95
#$''
% &#$
!"
ƒ
C C 4C
‰ S C @ ;<
`#5 @# F v ;+ 8 ,E (
T K . ; 4 3 0 q+
&
4 < 3 @ *1
G ; 1 / ;A#5
3 ($XXD T94 E ) @ ; < & MK* È
/I 4 T” 4C 3
C & T K.
B4 &
;K E
! - & F 3 ; 1 / ;A#5
;K E ;
04
& .(kDDD TM* g
4 C iB * ˆkDD$ T ) 4#
# ”
0 4.4
& g @E = 1
1
.3
Y 9 & & V 8 ,E (
@
N
3 =*& 4 , @ 3 & 0 ; @& ) 4 < & = 1
;W T0 0 )*S 4
;W ; C
g @E
0 S;
/ 0
& 4. .)
, . g @E
B C 4C F*;
3
l(
K.
K.
0 0 ; @&
($X'X) !:&
& .)
& ;. 14 3 ; C ;A#5 / ; 1 - @ RS
4< 4 , ” 4C & ) K 1 J KW C
@E C @ B 0 ,E (
g C@ 5
Y & 5 3 0 ; *& ) G
C
4< 3
5 ; C@
0@ 3 g* ! 4. 3 C
C E W .@ F
g
;K E &
`
4. * g @&
C P ” 4C
*
@ B
<
.@&
= ” 4C
& ;. ƒ 0 *1Y`# ; W ;*,^ g* ! .@ C
F*;
C@
*
8 A M <M
1 J KW M B
3 <&
0 ;
6 & & C )# @ 4< ‡;
KW 4< 4 , ” 4C & (&
z:< & .@ F
@ RS ” 4C
14
ƒ )
01
ƒ
=
g 0 ; w P & ;K E 4O @
g* 24 H + 8 *67
4#
0 B C 4C B #4 * g*& 0 5
, 8 A R.4 9 & 24
g & & .) & 0
24 *
1
;K E 0 ƒ
1@ C • 34
‰9 ;W ` & )K* ;K E 4O @ C@ ªC •
,9 & 24 @
N &
@ 4< *
;K E 4O @ CY* K
1
0
)? Y 4 & q !
J 3 T•
;C W
:C ‚
0 G & & G 24 * ” 4C 3 . 4&
96
#$''
% &#$
!"
1
) 4S
, 0 ; R* g @&
4& ;K E
! &R
* ; g . 4#
F
;K E
‰;
1@ ~ =
& 4< C
.) n
(kDDd) –* * ;K* 4* T(kDD%) C 4E =
&
3 =*&
U - @ RS B C 4C
B LSD =
h
Y* O u ;
C E W .@
G 0 ; 8:`
(< • ,
24 * 0 B C 4C
.@ @
@` &
, 8 A 0 ; 8:` œ OE 3 0
24 * B C 4C
$
& * ; g
Y # T(kDDc) !:& C & T 4 gK @ 0 *K& 0 =
k
i z
T
E T(kDDf) )* 4` E5 Th 4 5 T ;
g; C T(kDDd) gK .
c
e
%
*!4
h & ˆ(kDDd)
C ; ˆ(kDDd) B
g
g* C TB 4&
d
0 g** .) n
T(kDDk) B
4C Tg T ;KC T(kDDd) B
‚4& @ RS ” 4C
*&
Y 4 3 0 @, & ; g E ;W
- & ! C 0 4P & .)
U 1@ RS 8@# Y 4 g 3 ` . 4#
0 #<
4. , .@&
= 0 ; 8:` @r @# & g*
#4
- & & C 4C
C E W @r k$ ikc T 'D #4 - & & C 4C
.($X'% TB4K *& B4K *& 3 YS ) @&
= C @r $ki$d & 'DiXX #4
0 )*,G4
0 &S 0 8
B @S
0@ 5 C @
Y 4 3
;. — (
4 @ @# 4 C T(kDDd kDDk TgK . Y #) * & =E !
E4O 0 *<7 T)
4 0 ` R + g* 24 F*; C
. 3 .@# & ($X'% TB4K *& B4K *& )
;.
G:< 4O *<7 TB &3
B C 4C 0 4 < ?C g*
;. / 0 ;G )*,^ 64
*& Y 4
T)K 4` E5 Tg 4 5 T8 ;
g; C) 5 B
09 &
0 1@* T @ RS
* O 0 ) * T)*&
1@
J KW &
0 1@E ƒ T(kDDf
1- Eisenhower, Baker, Blacher
3- Leyfer, woodruff- Borden, klein- Tasman
5- Roberts, Mazzucchelli
97
2- Koskentausta, Iivanainence
4- Whitaker, Read
6- Castro, Veerman, Koops
#$''
=*& @
iz T
% &#$
!"
;K1 `# x 8:`
4. T($XXk T # g* )
@
v*,^
E) (c%/') H (^ … < 0 *&4 T(@r 'D/fk) T .4 bS / E ,
.@# & T(kDDd TB `
B 4&
0
B C 4C 0 ; 8:`
;K E
- (& w*SO g
g
0
B C 4C C )<
` #5 0 5 0 Y* O .@* 8 6 & 24 *
@ RS B C 4C 0 & ( & g C E W T@ ;K 0 ; 8:`
0
B C 4C 0 ; 8:` & ;K E 0 ƒ g*& - (& g* q .@ @* 7
M & ;.
14
;K E B C 4C C 0 4P & .@# @* 7 24 * 0
B C 4C & ) K 0 ; *& 0 ; 8:` 0 B C 4C M 24 * B C 4C
‚
g @ RS B C 4C
C E W .(f ' @.) @ ;# g
;K E
0 ƒ 3 ƒ – * g*&
U - @ RS B C 4C
, .4
,
- ; g .@ * )
&
, 8 A 0 ; 8:` œ O E 3
;K E
g ƒ 0 B C 4C 3 =*& g
0 ƒ B C 4C C ^ W =
$
4* 5 T *C 0 =
0 ; & @ ;K 0 ; 8:`
(< • ,
%
k
B `
h* ! T($XXc) 4 B TƒE 4 41 TŸ &@ 1 T($XXc) B `
C ) B5
g** ƒ .) n
($XXc) 4 5 B4 4E4 T($XXd)
M* , ” 4C v ;+ 0 ; 3 0 *K& & C )
;* +# )Ar ƒ
;K E
& 0@,& 23
g ) g
” 4C ;G .@
Y`# B5 @&
=+&
ƒ 0 g
” 4C .@ C
F :;< \*O B
g 1 .) Y`
! 0 ;
AP
*N 4<
F*;
)K*
12 ;V 0 ; .@
†
@*q*
** ($XX%) g* C T x TŸ &
0 4 E
+&MN & C @ 4# H4KO 0 ;K E 0
B 4 & ” 4C
1- Howkins, Arture
3- Nachmias
2- Golfberg, Golowlec, Sunmons
98
#$''
% &#$
!"
+&MN g 0 &
13 0
C
& T(g @E ) ; G
g
;K E B C 4C
C) l(
;W g .@ 4#
F T) 6[ *V
@ &
;K E
! .4 R . A
`# T 3Y`
12 ;V 0 ;
B C 4C C @ C B *& ($XX$) ;q T 4 T 4* C i @ 4C T3 .@ # & ;#
J KW *V g @E 8 4; Y& S
g @E - @ C
& B4 & g
N & .@
~ g @E & 3
& @ C
) S @ ~ *V
.) ” 4C g*;K+ 1@#
P & *
+
; g @
g
U - @ RS B C 4C g*& C 4& B5 =
0 ; 3
`
B C 4C
C E W . @ 4.
, 8 A 0 ; 8:` œ OE 3 g
0 ; 8:` 3 g
B C 4C & ) K g B C 4C R
& 24 * 0
- &)
U 0 bS 4< C ) B5 ; g E ;W g** .@ 4< & 0 ; C
4<0 4< & T ;K E
/
@ 0
Y 4 3 N z r (g* 24
” ; Y B4! .@
= 8@# & ” 4C
G ( 0 ; 8:`
8:` g & & )
U )*E4 , g
/g
1
M 0 3 (<
M & 0 ; )*,^ N 3
A
4& 9 & g /g
1
0 ;
. @ 4.
3 (< Y g 0
24 * B C 4C
C E W .@ @
0
1
;K E ƒ
! g*& 3 h
G 0 ; 8:`
(< • ,
8@# & 14
($X'c) z
.@ C @*C7 ” 4C & ‚
{4
; 8:`
14
M
& ; . B C 4C M
” 4C g 5Y` 0 ; ) @S;, ($Xf%)
J KW *V
ƒ 04 3 @#
0
)
;K E o 3 &
P ): )
99
Y* O 0 ; J &
& ;. ƒ 24 *
=S & 8 ,E ( .@
C
p **
E&@
B 03
&
C &
,* P ~ g
F* œ OE 3 J ; Y& G *V
#$''
*!4 Th
0 &0 ;
8:` Š(
0 1@E ƒ
% &#$
!"
& B4! SSO Y*E g*
& .)
;# \& g
0 *! C
/ 1 4 < 8:< @ 0 . & C @ C
* (kDDd) B
B4
E4O 8:` 0 B C 4C
U - @ RS B C 4C
& ) ? *67 Š*Or 234 5 w P 3 . = C
50 ;
. C Y @, B 4
B C 4C g 0 ; 8:` Ž g @E
'f/Dd/kf
''/D$/$c
''/Dk/%D
: E S - *E - +K )
~
: ES
- +K )
~
: ES 2 / ~
100
#$''
% &#$
!"
References
•&
;K E 0 *1Y`# &
g F 0 ; J *S
.B
^
T
@#
T
0
- (&
& T($%'$) R 3 T
F T ;K& =* B C 4C
.$%'k * T% - # TM;A
4C
; )* & G
?; B C 4C @#
F<
;. /0 ; 8:`
T
;
& T($%fc) ƒ * T
# C
B
T(CBCL) B C 4C
Biringer. Z.; Brown. D; Donaldson. L; Green. S. Kremarik. S; Lovas G.
(2000). Adult Attachment Interview: Linkage with Dimenions of
Emotional Availability for Mother and Their Prekindergardeners,
Attachment & Human Development. 2(2): 188-202.
Blacher, J., Meyers. CE. (1983). A Review of Attachment Formation and
Disorder of Handicapped Children. American Journal of Mental
Deficiency. 87 (4): 359-71.
Bowlby, J., (1973). Attachment and Loss: vol: II Separation, Anxiety and
Anger. London: The Hogarth press and the Institute Psycho- Analysis.
Bromley B., Blacher, J. (1989). Factors Delaying out of Home Placement of
Children with Sever Handicaps. American Journal Mental Retardation.
94 (3): 284-91.
Brooks-Gunn, J. Lewis, M. (1984). Maternal Responsivity in Interactions
with Handicapped Infants. Child Development. 55(3): 782-93.
Campbell, S.B., Pierce, E.W.March, C.L., &Ewing, L.J. (1991).
Noncompliant Behavior, Overactivity, and Family Stress as Predictors of
Negative Maternal.
Carlson, E.A. (1998). A Propective Longitudinal Study of Disorganized /
Disoriented Attachment. Child Development, 69, 1970-1979.
Cassidy, J., Berlin, J. (1994). The Insecure / Ambivalent Patterns of
Aattachment: Theory and Research. Child Development, 65, 971-991.
Castro, B.O.D. Veerman, J.W. Koops, W. Bosch, J.D. Monshouwer H.J.
(2002). Personality and Social Development Hostile Attribution of Intent
101
#$''
% &#$
!"
and Aggressive Behavior: A Meta-analysis. Child Development. 73 (3):
P, 916.
Cicchetti, D., & Rogosh, F.A. (1997). Equfinality and Multifinality in
Development Psychopathology. Development and Psychopathology, 8,
597-600.
Clegg, J. Sheard, C. (2002). Challenging Behavior and Insecure Attachment.
Journal of Intellectual Disabilitgy Research, 46 (6). P. 503.
Colledge J. (1980). Visiting the Mentally Handicapped in Residential Care.
British Journal of Psychiatry. 137: 313-8.
Crowncl. Feldstein S, Jasnow MD. Beebe B. Jaffe J. (1992). Down's
Syndrome and Infant Gaze. Gaze Behavior of Down's Syndrome and
Nondelayed Infants in Interactions with Their Mothers. Acta Paedo
Psychiatric. 55 (1): 51-5.
Dickson, K. Emerson, E. Hatton, C. (2005). Self-Reported Anti-Social
Behavior: Prevalence and Risk Factors amongst Adolescents with and
without Intellectual Disability. Journal of Intellectual Disability
Research. Volume 49. Issue 11. Page 820.
Eisenhower, A.S. Baker, B.L. Blacher, J. (2005). Preschool Children with
Intellectual Disability: Syndrome Specificity, Behaviour Problems, and
Maternal Well-being. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research.
Volume 49, Issue 6. p. 657.
Etzion-carasso A: Oppenheim. D., (2000). Open Mother-preschooler
Communication: Relations with Early Secure Attachment: Attach- HumDev. Dec 2 (3): 347-70.
Fogel, Alan. (1997). Infancy: Infant, Family, and Society. West Publishing
Company. Minneapolisst, Paul Newyor. Losangeles, Sanfrangisco.
Ganiban, J. Barnett. D. Cicchetti D. (2000). Negative Reactivity and
Attachment: Down Syndrome's Contribution to the AttachmentTemperament Debate. Development & Psychopathology. 12 (1): 1-21.
Goldberg, S., Gotowlec, A., & Sunmons, R.J. (1995). Infant-mother
Attachment and Behavior in Healty and Chronically Ill Preschoolers.
Development and Psychopathology. 7, 267-282.
102
#$''
% &#$
!"
Greenberg, M.T., Speltz, M.L., & DeKlyen, M., (1993). The Role of
Attachment in the Early Development of Disruptive Behavior Problems.
Development and Psychopathology, 5, 191-213.
Hatton, D.D. Bailey D.B. Margaret, B. Jr. Burchina land, M.R. Ferrell, K.A.
(1999). Developmental Growth Curves of Preschool. Children with
Vision Impairments. 68 (5): 788.
Hawkins, J.D., Artur, M. W., & Catalano, R.F. (1995). Preventing Substance
Abuse. In M. Tonry & D. Farrington (Eds), Crime and Justice: A Review
of Research, Vol. 19. Building A Safer Society: Strategic Approaches to
Crime Prevention (pp. 343-427). Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Hinshaw, S.P. (1992). Externalizing Behavior and Academic
Underachievement in Childhood and Adolescence: Causal Relationships
and Underlying Mechanisms. Psychological Bulletin, 111, 127-155.
Howe, David. (2006). Disabled Children, Parent-Child Interaction and
Attachment. Child & Family Social Work. 11(2): 95-106.
Ijzendoorn, M.H. Van Goldberg, S., Ekroonenenberg, P.M. & Frenkel. O.J.
(1992). The Relative Effects of Maternal and Child Problems on the
Quality of Attachment: A Meta-analysis of Attachment in Clinical
Samples. Child Development, 63-840-858.
Janssen, C.G.C. Schuengel, C. Stolk, J. (2002). Understanding Challenging
Behavior in People with Severe and Profound Intellectual Disability: A
Stress Attachment Model. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research 46
(6), 445-453.
Kirk, A.S. & Gallagher, J.J. & Anstasiow, N.J. (1997). Educating
Exceptional Children. HOUGHTON MIFFILN Company. Boston.
Newyork.
Koskentausta, T. livanainence M. Almqrist, F. (2007). Risk Factors for
Psychiatric Disurbance in Children with Intellectual Disability. Journal
of Intellectual Disability Research. Volume 51, Issue 1, Page. 43.
Leyfer, O.T. Woodruff-Borden, J. Klein-Tasman, B.D. Fricke, J.S. Mervis.
C.B. (2006). Prevalence of Psychiatric Disorders in 4 to 16- Years-olds
with Williams Syndrome. American Journal of Medical Genetics Part B:
Neuro Psychiatric Genetics. 141 B., Issue 6. P: 615-622.
103
#$''
% &#$
!"
Lovecky, D.V. (2003). Identity Development in Gifted Children: Moral
Sensitivity. http//: W. Sengifted. Org/ Articles Social/ Lovecky Identity
Development in Gifted Children.
Lyons-Ruth, K. Easterbrooks M.A. Cibelli CD. (1997). Infant Attachment
Strategies, Infant Mental Lag, and Maternal Depressive Symptoms:
Predictors of Internalizing and Externalizing Problems at Age 7.
Developmental Psychology. 33 (4): 681-92.
Lyons- Ruth, K., (1996). Attachment Relationships among Children with
Aggressive behavior Problems: The Role of Disorganized Early
Attachment Patterns. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 64,
46-73.
Lyons-Ruth, k. Easterbrooks, M.A. Davidson Cibelli, C.E. Bronfman, E.
(1995, April). Predicting School-age Externalizing Symptoms from
Infant: Contribution of Disorganized Attachment Strategies and Mild
Mental Lag. Paper Presented at the Biennial Meeting of the Society for
Research in Child Development, Indianapolis, IW.
Lyons-Ruth, K. Alpern, L. & Repacholi, B. (1993). Disorganized Infant
Attachment Classification and Maternal Psychosocial Problems as
Predictors of Hostile-aggressive Behavior in the Preschool Classroom.
Child Development, 64, 572-585.
Main, M., & Solomon, J. (1990). Procedures for Identifying Infant as
Disorganized/ Disoriented During the Ainsworth Strange Situation. In
M. Greenberg, D. Cicchetti, & E.M. Cummings (Eds.), Attachment in
the Preschool Years: Theory, Research and Intervention (pp.121-160).
Chicago: University of Chicageo Press.
Moffitt, T.E. (1993). Then Europsychology of Conduct Disorder.
Development and Psychopathology, 5, 135-151.
Moss, E., Parent, S., Gosselm, C., Rousseau, D., D., & St-Laurent, D. (1996).
Attachment and Teacher-reported Behavior Problems During the
Preschool and Early School-age Period. Development and
Psychopathology, 8, 511- 526.
Neumeister, S.K.L. Finch, H. (2006). Perfectionism in High-ability Syudents:
Relational Precursors and Influences on Achievement Motivation. Gifted
Child Quartely, Vol. 50, No 3. 238-251.
104
#$''
% &#$
!"
Pederson, D.R., Moran, G. Sitko, C., Campell, K. Ghesquire. K. & Acton, H.
(1990). Maternal Sensitivity and the Security of Infant-mother
Attachment: A Q-Sort study. Child Development, 61, 1974-1983.
Perkins, T.S. Holburn, S. Deaux, K. Flory, M.J. & Vietze, P.M. (2002).
Children of Mothers with Intellectual Disability: Stigma, Mother-Child
Relationship and Self-esteem. Journal of Applied Research in
Intellectual Disabilities, V. 15, Issue 4, P. 597.
Petrie- Allison & Davidson, Iain. F.W.K. (1995) Toward a Grounded Theory
of Parent Preschool Involvement. Early Child Development and Care,
Vol 111: 5-17.
Reiss AL. Freund L. (1990). Fragile X Syndrome, DSMIIIR, and Autism.
Journal of the American Acadamy if Child & Adolescent Psychiatry. 29.
(6): 885-91.
Renken, B., Egeland, B., Marvinney, D., Mangelsdorf, S., & Sroufe, L.A.
(1989). Early Childhood Antecedents of Aggression and Passive with
Drawal in Early Elementary School. Journal of Personality, 57, 257-281.
Renken, B., Egeland. B., Marvinney, D., Mangelsdorf, S., & Sroufe, L.A.
(1989). Early Childhood Antecedents of Aggression and Passive with
Drawal in Early Elementary School. Journal of Personality, 57, 257,
281.
Roach MA. Orsmond GI. Barratt MS. (1999). Mothers and Fathers of
Children with Down Syndrome: Parental Stress and Involvement in
Childcare. American Journal of Mental Retatdation. 104 (5): 422-36
Roberts, C. Mazzucchelli:, T. Studman, I. Sanders, MS. (2006). Behavioral
Family Intervention for Children with Developmental Disabilities and
Behavioral Problems. Journal of Clinical Child & Adolesent Psychology.
Vol. 35, No2. P. 180-193.
Robinson Nancy M.Robinson, Halbert, B. (1983). The Mentally Retarded
Child. A Psychological Approach. New York : Gulford press.
Schipper, J.C. Stolk. J. & Schuengel, C. (2006). Professional Caretakers as
Attachment Figures in Daycare Center Children with Intellectual
Disability and Behaviors Problems. Research in Developmental
Disabilities, 27, 203-216.
105
#$''
% &#$
!"
Schneider-Rosen. K., & Rothbaum, F. (1993). Quality of Parental Care
Giving and Security of Attachment. Development Psychology. Vol. 29,
No. 2, 358-367.
Schuengel, C. & Janssen, C.C. (2006). People with Mental Retardation and
Psychopathology: Stress, Affect Regulation and Attachment. A Review.
International Review Research Developmental Disabilities, 32, 231-262.
Shaw, D., Owens. E., Vondra. J., Keenan, K., Winslow, E. (1996) Early Risk
Factors and Pathways in the Development of Early Disruptive Behavior
Problems. Development and Psychopathology, 8, 679-700.
Show, D.S., & Vondra, J.I. (1995). Infant Attachment Security and Maternal
Ppredictors of Early Behavior Problems: A Longitudinal Study of Low
Income Families. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology. 23, 335-357.
Show, D.S., Owens. E.B., Vondra, J.I., Keenan, K., & Winsliw, E.B. (1997).
Early Risk Factors and Pathways in the Development of Early Disruptive
Behavior Problems. Development and Psychopathology, 8, 79300.
Slough, N. M., Goyette, M., Greenberg, M. T. (1988). Scoring Indices for the
Seattle Version of the Separation Anxiety Test. University of
Washington.
Solomon, J., George, C., & DeJong, A. (1995). Children Classified as
Controlling At Age Six: Evidence of Disorganized Representational
Strategies and Aggression at Home and at School. Development and
Psychopathology, 7, 447- 463.
Solomon, J., George. C., & Ivins, B. (1987). Mother-Child Interaction in the
Home and Security of Attachment at Age 6. Paper Presented at the
Biennial Meeting of the Society for Research in Child Develpoment.
Baltimore, MD.
Sroufe, L.A. (1985). Attachment Classification from the Perspective of Infant
Caregiver Relationships and Infant Temperament. Child Development,
56, 114.
Stack, D.M., & Muir, D. W. (1992). Adult Tactile Stimulation During Face–
to Face Interactions Modulates Five-Month Olds, Affect and Attention.
Child Development, 63, 150-155.
106
#$''
% &#$
!"
Stevenson-Hinde, J., Shouldice, A. (1995). Maternal Interactions and SelfReports Related to Attachment Classification at 4.5 Years. Child
Development, 66, 583-596.
Tarkka. M.T; Paunonen, M; Laippala. P. (2000). Firsttime Mother and Child
Care when the Child is 8 Months. J- Adv-Nurs. Jan; 31 (1): 20-6.
True. M. N. Pisani. Ljoumar. F (2001). Infant-mother Attachment among the
Dogan of Mail. Child Development. 72 (5): 1451-661.
Urban, J., Carlson, E., Egeland, B., & Sroufe, L.A. (1991). Patterns of
Individual Adaptation Across Childhood. Development and
Psychopathology, 3, 445-460.
Valenzuela, M. (1990). Attachment Inchronically Underweight Young. Child
Development, 61, 1984-1996.
Vaughn B.E. Goldberg S. Atkinson L. Marcovitch S. MacGregor D. Seifer R.
(1994). Quality of Toddler-mother Attachment in Children Down
Syndrome: Limits to Interpretation of Strange Situation Behavior. Child
Development. 65 (1): 95-108.
Waters, E. Kondo-Ikemura, K. Posada, G., & Richters, J.E., (1991). Learning
to Love: Mechanism and Milestones. In M. Gunnar & L.A. Sroufe (Eds),
Minnesota Symposia on Child Psychology: Vol. 23. Self Processes in
Development (pp. 217. 255). Hillsdale, NJ: Eribaum.
Whitaker, Simon, Read Stephen (2006). The Prevalence of Psychiatric
Disorders among People with Intellectual of Disabilities: An Analysis of
the Literature. Journal of applied Research in Intellectual Disabilities.
19 (4), 330-345.
Willemsen-Swinkels, S.H.N., Bakermans-Kranenburg, M.J., Buitelaar, J.K,
Van Ijzendoorn, M.H., Van England, H.V., (2000). Insecure and
Disorganoized Attachment in Children with a Pervasive Developmental
Disorder: Relationship with Social interaction and Heart Rate. The
Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry and allied Discipiliens. 41
(6): 759-767.
Zeanah, C.H. Smyke, A.T, koga. S.F., Carlson, E. (2005). Attachment in
Institutionalized and Community Children in Romania. Child
Development. V. 76. Issues: 5. P: 1015.
107
#$''
=>??
78.
!U
T
& =>
#
>)3> & 8=0 Q3M
% &#$
!"
!
$ 8=0 R -8> S
L%
5 -!$
JH
˜
1 i ,*
; i
+ 4 @`
; i0
1
; i
4 J @ )K j4E 4 i0@
1
B
`#
4
H
@*F @*
;C
*& 4
;C
gKW ;C
# o 4 ;C
W
q
;C
@*`!
;A1 4P & 0 ;A1 *V ;C W @* S - (&
& T=
g
, ;A1 4P =
& 0 ;A1 *V ;C W @* S 8
g 3 z@ :z@
*3
*67 ƒ*;K* B C 4C
.) B C 4C
kk ) / 8 4r 0 K S 2 & C T ,E ( g )K+ 0 W
:
& 2
J;
0 4 0 & ,E ( @ ;# )C # ME ” 4C %D ƒ*;K* ” 4C
- W
.) 1 G K S =F
4 T 1
;A1 4P T W g
.@# F
4P & ƒ*;K* B C 4C T) / 8 4r 0 < @
& F 8 4r & ,E ( C
T3 dD 8@ & T
35 1 B C 4C hx .@ @# M*KS ; C
35 1
&
;A1 4P T < @ 3 @,& Y G .@ ; 1 G 0 ;A1 *V @* S g
)O ) ƒ 3
B4 35 3
Y* O
.@# @*F
v*r4 B4 35 3 A; & 1
.@# ; 1 & h 4C Y* O B4* 1 TYS;K
108
#$''
% &#$
!"
.(P<0/01) @# @ ƒ*;K*
ME B C 4C ;A1 4P 0 , 8 A : ;
4 ƒ*;K* B C 4C
:C @* S
4 ;A1 4P g*& )
C W ; g* q
4. ) ?
;K T ,E (
, 8 A 4. 3 C W
T : & .(r=D/''e)
.(p< 0/01) @# &
<@ F 3 h ; C
35 1
;A1 4P g*&
;K
0 ;A1 *V ;C W @* S
;A1 4P g*& ƒ*;K*
;A1 4P =
& T0 ;A1 *V ;C W @* S 8
F
B C 4C :0 *1 F*;
4. 04G ) ?
. 1
F B C 4C g
. ;A1 T ;A1 4P T@* S TMK* :0@* C B 1j
; B 4.
3
C ) BK 1 g 4
g M B &3
E ) @# @
* B 4.
P
0 N ! 1 .@ C 3 ;
& P
0 N
3 B5 C
& O
1 B K B &3
@, 3 A; & .) B 4& @O
3T 1 g 3 ` .3
TM* C YS;
4 M* A M 3 K& @ @. . )
& M* 4 8 4r 3 0 @O
C & 8: . g g* hC–* B4 C M @* B
3 1 C : .
4& B @
@ B À; .4 4 3 & 3 B5 7
B &3 {4^4 .)
0 )* & G & B K 4 ! B 3 ! 3 )K*! B &3 ; < C = g .)
04 3 .) B N RW r .4 4 B q
C)
) )
&3
$
T @ C) ) H
4 0 4O 8 4^4 3 * B &3 ;< #R
4
B &3 H & •O& 0 4O g
3 ` .(kDDD T%YK*. k 4#
1- Kandel
3- Jessel
109
2- Schwartz
#$''
% &#$
!"
wP
5 .) I ;C W 0 C 3
;A1 B * (& T ;A1 , B5
*&
Œ@ )E <
@ )C W
C @ ;K 0 I wP B
;A1 @*E4
*1
&B
)
C
#
8C W
;A1 B * - (& - ,E ( & 5
$
g Œ &
BK
B &3 Y ` E ;W 7
& B4
@
F ;A1
@ 5@@ 0 # 8P w P3
4r *V 8 4r & @;& B K B &3 C N
3 ) @# YS;
;A1 0 @ & ) 8 C W Y ` @
hx
)
) @ 1 † B5 3 ) W
* 41 41 @ 4# C )
8 N
.
k
B 0 )
& ;A1
C C W T N g w& ( .(kDD% T g*; )
3 ) W
*E & @ 4# .) 0 # P
N B
@ 3 & M*
%
T Y* ƒ )
4. @ 4 # \ 4 ;A1 ”
4 & ) 8 C W )*
g )* ) @#
B 8 ,E ( < & \ 4 ‰ * < C 0 ;` E T(kDDc
)
;A1 ;C W 0
& 8 C & 3&) .
@ 41 & ƒ C 8 C W
4O C H
4 8 ,E (
; g @ @. 3 ` .(kDD% Te @* g @ 1)
F @* S
E@ T” T‚
0 @@ &) K
M
0* !
;C W h` 4C 0 B 3
+& C @# @
, 4& 0 5 0 B v C C
C ;G ` & @ 4#
, @
F
;C W 4 . C ;G
x #
g .@ C ƒ* # * @ C
@
0
\ 4 )C W B
F 4.
4< B
. <
CY 3
+K ƒ @ *& C 4# • & 1
.@&
C E ;W @r S 8 * F*;
; B5 & › ` & @# & ;#
” T E@ T0 @
0 *1 T@* S 0 & ** @ 4 0 5 0 B
B N RW r .4 T g & .4 & .($XXd ,c 9 ) @ 3 M
4< g U
g @# B
MK* v*P 89:; < & 0@ #
P
89:; < 0 (*W
1- gestures
3- McNeil
5- Rizzolatti
2- Stein
4- Goldin-Meadow
110
#$''
% &#$
!"
89 `# 3 & ) @ 4
0 50 B 0 `
:;< 5 C *^
C *SSO .@ 1 l ( @# & B &3 @#
4<g U T@* S MK* & B :;
; < 0 5 0 B Y ` * @ C )*E , B &3 Y ` 0 * 3
• g (kDD$ T$84E ) @ ; B K B &3 B@ 5 @ @ @ Š*^4 0 &
& ) 1 84G ) B &3 7
*E 0 B K
;K+ @* S
4 @# C
.@# •G 8 .4 B4 C @* S )*
@# Š( 3 @ 4
ƒ*;K* B C 4C 0@* S 0
4 ` & .4 &
k
;.
0
4 g*& ;? ‚
(kDDc T ) @ C 4 * B 5 5
4 g* !M 0@* S 0
4
;< #
Ten T% ; 4 ) B &3 @# @* S
d
c
B41 41 0 C C T@* S @
N & T) @# @ (kDD' T 3 . T z4 3
bS /E . 4# H4KO 0 *1 0 & 04G 0 &
;.
;< #
;< # B41 41 0 v*P 0@# 0 0 F
& ) g` MK*
0@* S
0 1@ 3 )*A*C
#3
`
& 0@ @# 8 6
4# F
;.
B4
, & ƒ C & 5 C 1 l ( = g B4 C .(• B ) / &
) 8 C W 0@* S 8
† & ‰ r4 < @* S @
*1
;C W wP
g
Œ C ƒ C MK* & :; B C 4C 0 ;A1 0 8
@# & B 4
@
Y* K MK* & :; B C 4C 3
1 & 0@* S v*E ` - † & T ,E (
.M*# & @ # B 0 ;A1 0 8
@#
:C *V @* S 6 M* 5 & @* S
@
B
:C 0 8
:C *V @* S
;K 8 ,E ( < & ! 1
@* S 8
3 A; B ` - &
)K* 4 , B @ ! (& g )*
)
@ ! 8 :P ƒ*;K* B C 4C 0 ;A1 0 8
4 &
:C *V
1- Allot
3- Vivanti
5- Ozonoff
111
2- Dodd
4- Nadig
6- Rogers
#$''
% &#$
!"
.(kDDc T ) )K*
B :; & # B &3 234 5 )
CW C
4.
2 1 C B5 4. &
(kDDd T$g 1) ) @# F B 5 0 ;A1 0 8
@# & :C @G MK*
&
g;<
G & B C 4C g
4 = ‰ r T@# g Y*E )K* 4 , E
;A1 0 8
@# & ) & @ @ 8 C W F
) B
&‚
& P
) & 3 o < 0@* S 0 8
,E ( g
.) @ 1 F
. 4# ? < P 0 8
@# E ;W 6
1
†
4 35
;C W 0
& 3 0 4 * 04O @,„&
;A1 0
& 1
04 3
Y @ ! @* S R*C
;C W @* S 0 8
=
&@
N & @# &
g M . C ƒ C MK* & B :; 04O 0 8
@# & B 4
;C W
; 1 G A;
4 v ;+ 8 ,E (
8 m C & C 04O @# b< # g u
8
*67
& & ,E ( g
.) MLU $ ;A1 4P g* * )
.M ;< ƒ*;K* B C 4C ;A1 4P g* * =
:C *V 0@* S
2
- 5- 4
, .
8 4r & F
;K 8 4r
& C)
*E &
35 C ƒ Tw*SO g
4P ‰ r )
8 4r 0 < @ 41–* T)K+ - W
.) ; /
T W g
g* !M .@# K S MK* & :;
ME B C 4C 1
;A1
ƒ*;K* B C 4C ;A1 4P & 0 ;A1 *V ;C W @* S B4 35 8
;K
B C 4C 1 .@# F 0 < @ 8 4r & =
T - W
.@ 1
&
35 1 0 & < @ @ @# M*KS
1
&
8 4r & ƒ*;K*
T
X %
- r
ƒ*;K* B C 4 C R V C B5 & .4 & .) 1 F
1- Mean length of utterance
112
#$''
% &#$
!"
.4 @ 3 * TB4 35
Y C )< # 3) @ ;# @
,E ( &
\ #
J;
0 4 *C0 &=
()
.4 Y& G :C ”
C
8 4r @ ;# ;#
,E ( &
0 *, C
ƒ
3- r
.@ @# ;< # w*SO &
0 *, \ # 0
A kk T{4 F
.) /
g* +; b*+
&) ME B C 4C 3 0 A %D 1 ƒ & B C 4C 3
1g
” 4C @ ƒ B C 4C B * 3
4P & C (
4 *
;A1 T AP
@ ;#
G
- r g*
@ @ 1 H +; B
# @;&
@ ƒ
.@ @ 1 K S
. - 4*#
* ƒ ) T” 4C …4 + E@ r ƒ 0 ” 4C T B4 35 F - K .
&
! ‚ 0 G & C 0 4P & ) 1
G Y& S
4 35 )K
K.3 o <@ G
C
& & ” 4C q ! 4
.@# & g`
5
0 —4
- †
@ C 1 0 03 & 3 A; & @ ;& 4 35 )#
v* `
. C @ G: K . \*O & ) K
5 ” 4C 0 /I
3 ƒ
.@# A;
#34 5 C
u
4 eD 3 T
v*r4
@#
; 4< B C 4C 3 C C )
0 ,G
4C B ;
g
&
g v*r4
” 4C C q 5 .@ C v*r4 @* *&
4
q5
& 4 35 \ 4 K . 3 o < @ 1 \ ^ T84r \ ^ \ 4
5 B &3
.@ 1
O ” 4C 0 ;A1 @, hx .@ 1
* 0 o 2
M*KS
;A1 YC @, &
O ” 4C 0 ;A1 4 0 j 4` YC {4 F
)
& ;A1
4P g* * T ;A1 @, & j 4` {4 F M*KS 3 .@ 1
A; 0 4 8 C
3 @;& v* ` F 2 & ” 4C
#5 0 & .@ 5
113
#$''
Š*^4
4
; 4* 8: . 3
A;
& @#
% &#$
!"
4 E ” 4C & @ 1
.@
.@# ; 1 4 E (kDD%) B `
3 . 0@* S u*` 3 T ;C W @* S B4 35
F @* S f T) 8 C W @* S Y f 3 ) 8
C v* ` $X u*` g
T ^ W 0 ,E (
.) @# A; 0 ! i
@* S c *# 0 &
A; ) 8 C W @* S c › *# 0 &
@* S e T0 ! @* S ƒ 3
g & .@ C @* S 8 A; )C W $D @#
; 4< ” 4C 3 {4 F
.@ 1
4N & .@ C ` @
F
4 35
q 5 @#
; 4< ” 4C 3 4N
† ” 4C & u*` g* 3 0@* S
v* `
@;& T” 4C & v* ` M* A
04O & ” 4C 0 @
4 35 C
@* S ” 4C C 4r
@ 1
.
Gw4
4
hx
)C W @# & @* S
*& C
eD 0 &
@# .
;K
.@
B4 35 g T ,E ( { # 3 =* T B4 35
& 4N &
;A ƒ
3 r & @ ;# @ )C
Tw*SO
C ME ” 4C
g .@ 1
O B4 35
4 35 ;K R ^
5)
& D/fX T ;C W @* S B4 35 D/X%
v*r4 B4 35 4
;
(
c/$%)
d$/d
g* * & ƒ*;K* ” 4C kk 0 & ,E ( g
(
c/Dd) dD/'
g* * & ME ” 4C %D ;< d K $d 3 Y` ;
B4 35 3 Yr W 0 ; $
# @. .) 1 F ;< f K k% 3 Y` ;
;A1 4P g* * 4#
@
C 4PB .@
B
v*r4
.@# & ($/'%) ƒ*;K* B C 4C ;A1 4P g* * 3 ; *& (%/cd) ME B C 4C
114
#$''
% &#$
!"
v*r4 B4 35 3 Yr W 0 ; ($)
3 z O 0 (<
g* *
*, z O
4P g* *
;A1
D/$Dk
D/kDd
D/ccX
D/XdX
%/cd
$/'%
#
@,
4 35
ME B C 4C ;A1 4P K S )
t @S
g* * 8 A
f/ck
$/f%
0 35 .
%$/$
4P 0 ;A1 *V ;C W @* S
r @
B u ; .
4.
.(%
# @.) )
ƒ*;K* B C 4C
;K
R ^
D/''e
ƒ*;K*
**I
115
0
;A1 4P
1
%D
kk
Š(
(f/ck) @# @
@S @
B k
4P N 3 ME B C 4C ƒ*;K* B C 4C g*&
@
B
1 g* * C 4PB . 4#
@
.) B ME B ; 3 ; C ƒ*;K*
(ƒ*;K*
@.
# @. C 4PB
& .)
, D/D$
0 , 8 A T ;A1
B C 4C ;A1 g* *
B4 35 u ; (k)
, Š(
ME
ƒ*;K*
#
@.
g* * 8 A 0 (<
D/DDD
D/k%
4 g*& )
CW 0 ; T
04 3
, ) ? - (& ƒ*;K* B C 4C ;A1
, D/D$ 0 AE5 Š(
(r=D/''e) @# @
;C W @* S
g**, R ^
Y@ R ^
D/f'k
D/ff$
;K
- (& 8@# (%)
5 & 3 z O 0 (<
D/ede
# @.
0
, Š(
D/DDD
B C 4C 3
1 0 ‰ r < @ B5 P C T
,E ( 0
35 1 ;A1 4P T < @ F 3 h )
CW ) /
;
F
#$''
% &#$
!"
) @# ; *& R
& ; C 1 0 ;A1 4P 3 ) ;# 0 * !
@
F B * 4#
@
c
# @.
C 4PB .(e
# @.)
;C W @* S 8
T
8
& .)
, D/D$ Š(
(F=%k/cc) @#
.(p<D/D$)) @* F ƒ*;K* B C 4C ;A1 4P =
&
;C
35
B4 35=*
;A1 4P
B4 35h
;A1 4P
1
;A1 4P *, z O
;A1 4P
1
(<
{4 F
B
{4 F
8 /F
f/$fD
kD/$cc
D/cc'
D/%e%
0 35 .
$
$
$X
k$
#
@.
1
g* *
*, z O
35
;C
35
;C
$/'%%
$/'%D
k/$ek
$/'$
./XfX
$/D$D
$/D%f
D/X'$
1 g*& 0 4;C
•
g* * (e)
6 (c)
g* *
8 /F
f/$fD
kD/$cc
D/cc'
$/ iDk
#
@.
F
/$$$d
''e
%k/ccf
Š(
0 ,
- /F
D/DDD
D/DDD
D/X'%
D/d%k
.)
< @ 3 @,& Y G ƒ*;K* B C 4C ;A1 4P &
35 1
;A1 4P g* * g*& T < @ 3 Y G 4#
) w(
@` & ‰: C 1
4
4#
@
1 B4 35h B4 35=*
;A1 4P g*& < @ 3 h
1
$/'$ ; C 1
;A1 4P g* * . 4#
@
.@# &
‚4&
3 4
@
C 4P
A –*
;C
($/'%=g* * )
0 , 8 A
k/$e
35
116
#$''
% &#$
!"
1
= 35
41
B4 35=*
;C
B4 35h
35
1
;A1 4P **I
4
- *1 F*; •O&
0 B &3
@# F 8 ,E ( & w 4 ; M * w*SO g 3 Yr W 0 ;
4& B ME B ; & ƒ*;K* B C 4C ;A1 4P =W 8 A 3 C W T
.(kDDc T )
;A1 4P
;C W @* S
4 g*&
B &3 ;C W - N 3 ) W @ 4
;C W @* S )
C W w*SO g 0
=
& F @ 1 †
<@ 0
8 A
117
.4 Y& G ) ?
;K
: &
C 0 .@# @ ƒ*;K* B C 4C
; g* q .(kDD$ T84E ) 4# l (
4P g
ƒ B 4 & C 0 ;A1 *V
. 1 MK* & B :; ;A1 4P
35 1 8
g* * g*& T0 5 0 B4 35 w& (
< @ F 3 h E 4#
@
A <@
C B5 & .4 &
F 3 =* ; C
#$''
) K w*SO < @ & 8 **I B 4
4&
3 =*& 0 @G < @ & @ ! *67 ) B 3 /1 6
% &#$
!"
4#
@
1 g*& 0 ,
4P C g & .4 &
04 3 .
4 =
F*; C 0@# 8 **I )
.) ;# @ w*SO 0 ;
1j & 3 & & ;A1
8 #
3 A; T ` 0 ; & w& (
$
Y& G g 3 T(kDD% T @* g @ 1 T$XXd T J C) @ F
0 ;A1 0 V =
=
& ;C W 8 # 3 A;
ƒ*;K* B C 4C
4 4 & C 4& N;
;C W - N 3 Tw*SO - < @ 3 h ;A1 4P = .@ F *& ;A1 4P
4< ;A1
4
;C W E 4
4 T N g w& ( .@ C ) W 4O
g
;A1 4P = ) CU B # .@
B
;A1 4P = 8 4r &
RKW &
;A1 4P @ 1
O ;A1 4P g* * b< # J & w*SO
RKW & ;A1 4P 1 C ) B5 3 C W wSO 8 @
.M C
O j 4`
@
4 C * ! 8 A M @*F
8: .
@# & C & 8 C @,
3 ‰ E B4 35h
35 1 ƒ*;K* B C 4C
8
& .@ 1
C 0 @*q* , ` & @ ` A; 4< 8: . 0 ; *& 8 C @,
.@ & C & @ 4& 0 ; *& 0 j 4` @, 0
*
) @O
B5 0 & . 4&
4 35 @,
) @O T=
g 0 ) @O g M
3 0 ; *& @, & ,E ( @ &
M* , w* SO g 0 ; B 4 ;&
@* S *67 T ;A1 4P & : 4#
*r4
04 3 . / F
4
;< # & C Tz r T ;< #o
4
. 3 TB &3 0 (*W
& ;C
3
C
35
W
1- Krauss
118
#$''
% &#$
!"
F Cg &
w*SO 0 ;
& .4 & *
@,& . 1
& *
T@ F
ƒ*;K* B C 4C ;A1 4P =
& 0 ;A1 *V ;C W @* S 8
;C W 0@* S 8
F
+ 4
0 0
&
4#
*
0 . & . *1 G N @ ƒ*;K* B C 4C 0 # 0 )* & G \K& 0 ;A1 *V
B5 0
G N @ ƒ*;K* B C 4C ;A1 4P = ‰ *S;K C B5
&B
8 4r g & .M* @#
;C W @* S
#8
M* 4 M* C C
A; ‚
g;<
G&).
;A1 g . 0 2 3 B C 4C C B5
0
4 @# & g @ 3 z P & 4< P 0 3 * @ 4
@ C
)*
& w*SO g 0 ; T
04 3 .@* F @ 4< * B
0 ;A1
1 .3
@*C7 MK* & B :;
:C 0 8
4 &
C 8 @G
@ #& @
&
C
;C W 8
3 B
MK*
& B :;
&
& * F
.)# @ 4< 0 ; *& ) * B
0 ;A1 0 8
.M &
MK*
+&B 4
* C )*
0
@ M< C
.M
*
x
MK* & :; B C 4C 0 4 <
* @* # @ @
( 0 G5
'f/DX/kd
'f/$D/k%
''/Dk/%D
119
x
* r0 ` 3
” 4C @
@
: E S - *E - +K )
~
: ES
- +K )
~
: ES 2 / ~
#$''
% &#$
!"
•&
References
-
R* 5 & :; B C 4C
.
+ 4
0 4;
;K & 4
0 j 4`
.@#
& C
& .($%'$) @*F @* T ,*
# C-
B
.B &3
Allot, R. (2001). Autism and Motor Theory of Language. The Great Mosaic
Eye, Ch 6. Lewes Press.
Dodd, S. (2005). Undrestanding Autism. Elsvier, Australia.
Gaffan, D. (2006). Widespread Cortical Networks Underlie Memory and
Attention. Science, Volt, 309, pp 2172-2173.
Goldin - Meadow, S. (2003). Hearing Gesture: How O2ur Jands Us Think.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Kandel, E., Schwartz, J., Jessel, T. (2000). Principles of Neural Science. 4th
ed. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Krauss, R. (1996). Nonverbal Behavior and Nonverbal Communication:
What Do Conversational Hand Gestures Tell Us? Advances in
Experimental Social Psychology, Vol. 28, pp 389-450.
McNeill, David (2005). Gesture and Thought. Chicago: Chicago University
Press.
Rizzolatti, G. (1996). Premotor cortex and the Recognition of Motor actions.
Cognitive Brain Research. Vol. 3, pp (131-141).
Rogers, S., Hepburn, S., Stackhouse, T., Wehner, E. (2003). Imitation
Performance in Toddlers with Autism and Those with Other
Developmental Disorders. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry,
Vol. 44, pp (763-781).
Rogers, S.J. (1996). Imitation and Pantomime in High Functioning
Adolescents with Autism Spectrum Disorders. Child Development, Vol.
67, pp (2060-2073).
Stein, J.F. (2003). Why Did Language Develop? International Journal of
Pediatric Ortorhinolaryngology. Sciencedirect. Com.
Vivanti, G., Nadig, A., Ozonoff, S., Rogers, S. (2008). What do Children
with Autism Attend to During Imitation Tasks? Journal of Experimental
Child Psychology, in Press.
120
#$''
% &#$
!"
=>??
O- 0$ 8"$
& =>
#
!
K ! 2 J L -'23 4 -S M -
- #8V,
V 1 AV
B
5
H %
VF $) - V0
! O- 0
;. 4
P P ^ G 4 O @*
1
;
W 4.
1 *
=
M#
@# J # C B * @F
# > 04F
:
1 *
;*& 4
J @ )*&
;*& 4
P P :
3 #34 5 0j4E4 `
B
#34 5 8 S*SO @#
V'
;C
;C
;C
U5
3
@*`!
1)<
1)< # T 1 ; 0 `
*67 )*
& m.4 & T ^ W =
& 4C/ 0 ` 3 ƒ
*67 0 K S z@ &
#34 5 0 )*E , 0 34W
35 l P T=
2 .) ; 1 Y`# B 34 5= 2
**I 0 *1Y`#
4
B 34 5=
T=
0 5 0 , . .) B4 35h B4 35=* &
1
3 z@ 0 , . 3 0 *1 4 0 & . 4& $%'% i'e * O
B
#
8 4r & ( 1) J:C $k T)
@# A; 0 W @ ! 0 #4< 0 *1 4 2
.@ 4& 34 5 = A %Dd Y # ‰ 4 F B4 35 4 0 J:C C @ @# H +;
m4
;. 8 * , 0 J 3 ` T=
z@ & & *; 4N &
#34 5 0
& 8 4r &
1)<
1)< # T 1 ;
`
J &
u 2 0
w P3
0 5 • . .) @ # .
W P 0 4*x C
121
#$''
% &#$
!"
4 LSD , B4 35
Pƒ h
Y* O 0 5 B4 35 3 A; & ;
F
W P *67 $ :) @# Yr W 3 u ; D/Dc 0
, Š(
; 1 G Y* O
3 ; *& B 34 5= 2
**I 0 *1Y`# &
1)<
`
& ;
#34 5
1)< # `
& ;
#34 5 W P *67
W P *67 k .(P D/DD$) )
; *& B 34 5= 2
**I 0 *1Y` # &
1)<
`
& ;
#34 5
1 ;
` & ; #34 5 W P *67 3
0
, 8 A % .(P D/DD$) )
& @ @ 234 5
1 ;
` J & C 34 5= 2
**I 0 *1Y`#
1 )< # ` J & C 34 5=
.(P D/Dc) @ 4. T@ @ 234 5
.
;. 0 2
T2
**I T
0
]
T #34 5 W P :0@* > B 1j
J T03
K vP 4 & .4 C
B5 3 ) `W )*& M* , ~
,& 3 `
8
& .)
4& /1 6 w 4 #34 5 0 N 0 ` 0 (S
B4 * 4 & ) K 0 2
AP @,& T 5 4. .4 Y& G M
*K&
T 4# .4 @,& g & 0@. ; *& !
)*&
M* ,
.) = 4<
`
Y 7 & @ g MS )Or .@# @ 4< @ 0 1@
; & 0 F *;
0 (*W ` 4. & . 1
g# *
RW r w 4 B *& ”4
@
N & T) @# M*KS
AP T ;< # -=+&
& #34 5
B* g
.) ; 1 G ) AV 4
(* W 3 ƒ
)* B * g**,
(0 4O g* x*K ) ;< # 0 (*W & .4 @* C7 g ; *&
0
& 0 *# W
AP 0 (*W ; 1 z4(, (0 W
0 34W)
B 2
234 5 3 @,& g
;
F 0 =
.) ; 1 G
0@*, ˆ$%'$ T . ) )
*3g
#34 5 N 0@ 5 C 3 C W *
.($%'D T *
P P ^ G ˆ$%ff T # ˆ$%fX Tg @E g* 4
4^
T
0
& AP @,& )*
; *& ! g** @ r
^W 0 ES
122
#$''
0
`
% &#$
!"
3 ƒ
*67 B * 0 K S
;. 0 2 234 5 0 4O
.)
&F =
ƒ RE G
1)<
1)< # T 1 ; #34 5
& 4 + 0 & & C)
)*E , g
@G 3 ` 2
234 5
2@ 2
234 5 T3 B . .) ;< B @& 4< 0 3 * 3 < &
S; B C 4C )*&
234 5 0 A*p
B 3 ƒ B4 & 4 <
+& @ 4
23 234 5 .
@ & B5 &
;. 0 F
23
=S
F
& .4# S
ƒ )* +# C ) * 3
T2
234 5 8 3 ) @ C 03 & , . F*;
)* +# 0 *1Y`#
*1 Y`# 0 , .
MC W 0 23 & .4 &
;. 0 2 .($%f$
Y`# F .@# & 8 A;
{ ;. &
;. 3 @ 4 Y*E g*
&
v ;+ • 4.
#34 5 B
& r 0 V@V 3 ` 2
* 5)m*S 4
B
#34 5 N
0
& 4.4
& 4. g & .)
0
#34 5 0 4 E ;
F *3g
0 * & 0@. 0 0
&
0
& .) @ g @
0
& # z @ g;< wSO 0 &
#34 5 0 2 & ! 1 * O
0
;. 8 * , ,
N@
;. 0 2 234 5 0 & 0
04 E E ) @# #
+
F @ 3 * #34 5 N
**I 41
F C )
@& .)
4
Ym 7 8 ^ g & m.4 & g & & .) 34W g
0@. w*G 0 =
W P *67 C ) B5 & , =
g T ; 1 8 4r 0 =
u ;
1)<
T 1)< # T 1 ;
`
& ;
#34 5
g & & . 4# K S
m4
B 34 5 = 2
**I 0 *1Y`#
3 ƒ @C & ;
#34 5 W P C ) g ^ W =
r E7K
2
**I g ; *&
1)<
T 1)< # T 1 ; 0 `
123
#$''
@# CU
& .4 & .
.@ ; 1 G
5
% &#$
!"
@ @ 234 5 4 {4^4 & ) K B 34 5=
& 4 g @ 3 0 *^ =
g
—4
`
`
& ;
& ;
#34 5 W P & C 34 5= 2
**I 0 *1Y`# g*& $
#34 5 W P & C 34 5=
@ @ 234 5
1)<
.
4.
, 8 A T@ @ 234 5
1)< #
`
`
& ;
& ;
#34 5 W P & C 34 5= 2
**I 0 *1Y`# g*& k
#34 5 W P & C 34 5=
@ @ 234 5
1)<
.
4.
, 8 A T@ @ 234 5
1 ;
`
`
& ;
& ;
#34 5 W P & C 34 5= 2
**I 0 *1Y`# g*& %
#34 5 W P & C 34 5=
@ @ 234 5
1)< #
.
4.
, 8 A T@ @ 234 5
1 ;
2
& .4 & ) $0 & > w*SO {4 3 ^ W =
Tw*SO z @ & .4 &
g P .) @# A;
*^ B4 35 0 & = 35 2 3 T=
)*
#34 5 0
& w P 3 @ @# H +;
8 4r &
4 35 T W
%0
& 0 4*x C #34 5 0
& % ‰ 4 F ) 1)<
1)< # T 1 ;
& 3 A; &
0 W
hx .@ ; 1 G 234 5 4 ( #34 5 @
=F
4 0 ; T AP T ;< # @,„&
4 35 0 2 Tk
& 3 2
**I 0
0 4*x C #34 5 0
& *67 B *
; 1 G
; C 1 ƒ v , *N 0 *& @ T=
; g* 7 0 & ; E .) @#
0 J 3 ` 4N g @& .)
4& @G
.4 4 B4 35=* g* !M
«ŒM
S ! ) 4` W
» B4 &
4
;. 8 * ,
1- Applied Research
2- Questionnaire
124
#$''
% &#$
!"
0 4*x C #34 5 0
& 8 4r & 4C/ `
J & @# H +;
89 [ & 1
B 34 5= 0 ~ 0 K S & @ @# .
W P
0 *1 F*; 4 E
*67 B * 4
0 5 0 Y* O 3 A; &
B4 35=* & & ƒ K
;<
35 0
13 ƒ
.) @ 5 Y &
& B4 35=* B @& & ƒ
04 E TX1 1 ; 04 E ) •O& 4 0 4 E 3 ƒ
; 1 C &
l P .@ @ 234 5 (X3 1)< 04 E X2 1)< #
.) @#
B $ @. @#
w*SO
B4 35h
T2
T2
T2
T2
T2
T2
T2
T2
T2
T2
T2
T2
125
0
@# ; 1 C &
*I; 0 .
YS;K
X1
X1
X1
X1
X2
X2
X2
X2
X3
X3
X3
X3
B4 35=*
T1
T1
T1
T1
T1
T1
-
l P ($)
#
@.
= 1
R( K )
R( K )
R( ;< )
R( ;< )
R( K )
R( K )
R( ;< )
R( ;< )
R( K )
R( K )
R( ;< )
R( ;< )
1
$=
k=
%=
e=
c=
d=
f=
'=
X=
$D =
$$ =
$k =
35
35
35
35
35
35
35
35
35
35
35
35
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
#$''
% &#$
!"
0 50 4
, .
B
#
4 0
B 34 5 =
T=
g 0 5 0 , .
@W T=
3 @,„& g
.@ 4& $%'%i'e * O
( A $e$eDc)
k
0 *1 4 2 3 z@ 0 , . 3 0 *1 4 0 & . 4& ( 1) J:C T$0 & 4
2
234 5 0 1 34 W 4 3 C R* g @& .) @# A; %0 #4<
8 4r & (e 0 S( ) S( ƒ T0 *1 4 0 #4< 0 & ? & TB
#
0 @ k
K 0 @ k)
@ e T S( B5 3 @# H +;
k $ 84 :3 @ 4& 8 R+; J @ .@ @# H +;
8 4r & ( ;<
J @ 3 .@ 4& 0
;E {4 3
@
! .( K ) k $
& T( ;< )
.@ ; 1 G B4 35 4 @ @# H +;
8 4r & ( 1) J:C $k 4C/
;C0
1 .@ 4& 34 5= A %Dd Y # ‰ 4 F B4 35 4 0 J:C
0
& @ @# H +;
8 4r & J:C 0 4 F B
3 = 35
1)<
T 1)< # T 1 ; 0 4 E J & C 0 4*x C #34 5
$ec ;<
4 35 3 A $d$ .@ @# ;# /1 . & 5 T@ 4& @# W P
T0 #4< 0 *1 4 2 T 4#
NW: C 4PB Tg & & .@ 4& K A
@. .@ 4& J:C @
#4< 3 0
* J @ 3 .)
4& 0 W
.@
B )*K . RKW &
4 35 • 34 k
)*K . RKW &
> @r
ck/d
$DD
1- Sampling Unit
3- Cluster
;, @r
ck/d
ef/e
$DD
4 35
• 34 (k)
#
@.
5
@r
)*K .
ck/d
ef/e
$DD
$d$
$ec
%Dd
;<
K
{4 F
2- Target Population
126
#$''
% &#$
!"
0 *1 3 @ 0
&
T ;< #) 0@,&
0 E4S ƒ T2
C F 5 3 : ;< wSO - =
04 3 0
TB5 8 **I B * =F 0 & T) (0 ;
KW
4 2 0 1
,& & v ;+ #34 5 0
& *67 @# W P wSO
;K& = ck0 W T N 4 0 ;< wSO 0
. *1 G 0 *1 3 @
0 & B5 [ k$ T2
;< # @,& 0 *1 3 @ 0 & B5 [ $c C 4& ~
0 ; @,& =F 0 & B5 [ $k T2
KW
AP @,& 0 *1 3 @
S P 0
8 +
&‚
* [ e
4 35 0 2
J *S
4 <&
*I; 0 *1 3 @ Š( . 4& @# W P B 34 5=
. 4& 0
J *S
* 0 4
$
*&=* {4 3 & F ; 3 u 2 0
F
; 0 &
k
& ‚4& 0
TB4 35
0 . 3 Y G .) @# A; 0 3
;
0 B 34 5= 3 A cD 0 & $$ 0 S( 84 4 0 @
B 34 5=
Y& G C
41 4
@# ; 4< B 34 5= 3 @# .
4
= g ; *& B 34 5= C 0 41 @
g P .@
[ T@ ;K* M
0 j 4C/ [
.) 1 G N @ @F 4 @ ;#
5 4
&
R ^ . 4 M Y& G B 34 5= ?C 0 & « @r 0 ` #» «
0 )* G »
3 h .@#
O D/'' W g
4C/ 0
(Ž C 0 AE5) †
@G
0 5• . &
=F
& ‰ @F
0 5• . B4 35 0 .
h
Tg* * *N
C
S
R ^ ` & : @ 1
g T) ; 1 G
O
4 Tu 2 0 1
,& 4
*, z O
@.
C @# o + ; * u 2 0
0 41 YC 4
8 :P
1- Predictive Validity
127
2- Construct Validity
#$''
% &#$
.)
u 2
*, z O
*, z O
T
h
kX/Xf
.)
h
$
R ^ (%)
Y* O Tu
2
S
0
@r
g** h
@#
D/dk
k/cX
$f/%D
D/d$
D/dD
D/XD
O & :
F 2 T W g
T=< ! 0 2 B *
# @,& & ‚4&
0 ; @,& & ‚4&
41
ƒ
& 3 ;A
4
&g 0 3
Y* O u ; (e)
@.
RK! &
Y
89 [
&
D/dc
R ^
R ^0
;< # =+& 89 [
#
@.
$ed/Xd
4& «$ r 0 AE[ & F » 2
Y* O
k
3 [
.) @# A; hC
=< ! 3
3
AP @,& & ‚4&
41 ƒ )K*& T ;<
,& 4. 0 @ C@* 7
41 g
Y* O .@# &
; z,
g )
,&
=+& 3
..)
;. 2
u 2
@# † e
g* *
'X'/$%e
; 1 8 4r *
!"
Y
@C 3 T 4# l ( h F
C
•O&
Œ 4# =+ M*S;K 4P & ` #
: 0 4# h F 8 K . @ 4
Œ@ C )C #
4< # B 1@
&@
3 !
Œ@
8 G:
.@ 4# H +;
@ ! 0 & h F B 1@
D/cD
ŒM*# & ;#
@ !@ &B
D/cD
A 04 ;A1 4< B 1@
&@ 4
Œ@ # & ;#
5
15
8P
$
;.
0ž 0 &
5
1 Factor Analysis
128
#$''
% &#$
!"
(e)
S
@r
h
g**
@#
&
D/ee
D/fD
D/cX
$/ce
$D/kX
D/c%
D/ed
D/d'
$/%'
X/k%
D/c%
D/fk
$/Dc
f/Dd
D/ck
i
e%/'X
i
@. 0
89 [
Y
& 0 4# h F
# B 1@
@,
Œ
;K& 0 *! !
B 1@
v p 3 3 4 3 ƒ @C
Œ)
: 0 4# h F
4< N 4 B 1@
4 !
Œ@ C H +;
!B
: 0 4# h F 0 ‡
Œ@ ;K
KC
4< B 1@
&@ 4
4 !
Œ@
8 G: h F
hC 0 . & @ 4
KC 8 & +;
5
Œ@ @& 0ž 0
0 4# h F
/ 0 )* G 5
Œ@
@
:
0 G: 4 0 @
H +;
5
Œ@ ;K 35 4<
4< B 1@
&@ 4
5
Œ@ K 4 &
$c
RK! &
3 )< #
h F B 1@
k
—4SW )
8 & +; B
—4SW 3
&‚
B 1@
i
Y
%
15
4<
e
YC
KMO = 0/82D
Bartlett’s Test = 1139/651
Sig = 0/000
129
#$''
u 2
S
0
h
@r
@# g**
AP =+& 0
&
41
% &#$
!"
Y * O u ; ( e)
41
#
Y
@.
RK! &
Y
` & @r @r h F B 1@
.@ ;K
g [ 0 5 Th F B 1@
0
D/fd
.@ ;K S 9
D/fX
e/kf
D/fd
kD/%%
D/f$
D/f$
D/fD
D/%f
D/d%
D/c%
%/DX
$e/fk
D/ck
D/ck
D/c$
& h F B 1@
C M `* ` g
.@ C Y H4< 4< v p
h F B 1@
g N &
)O T 4< 0 0 *1M*
.@ *1
N ‰: C
)
‰: C
&hF g N &
.)
. )
h F B 1@
g
.@ 5 M#4< 8 & +; 3 g
8 & +;
g N &
.@
B
4< 8 @G
0
: 0 4# h F =S
.)
3 *K& 4 C
ƒ B@# h F 0 @
g N &
.) @*A )* & C
0
0 & : 0 4# h F
.)
#3 & *K&
T4 C
hF
4 C 1 CM C
` g
& *& 0 4 C T@# & ;# @
. C @ 4< W
&
;
B 1@
hF
)*
hF
8 & +;
$
k
130
#$''
% &#$
!"
( e)
S
h
@r
@# g**
&
H +;
.@ ;K
g**, g 0ž C M C J KW g
.) 6[ *< 4 C )#4
D/ef
.)
& w ,; h F C M `* J KW g
.)
D/ck
w , * g & h F C M `* J KW g
.
D/ee
.M;K @
D/fe
T +# W . 8 P
. @ 0 *67 –* B 1@
'/$X
eX/$%
g N &
4< & 0 3 8 *;< 3 h F B 1@
.@ ;K
T@
D/cX
i
35 ‰: C 4 C ƒ B
D/cc
c/''
i
Y
C M C J KW g
35 :
‰ C 4< N 4
D/e'
D/dk
$/k%
RK! &
Y
41
D/cD
$/fk
@. 0
G: h F •W
@ 0ž KC &
. 4 &hF
k$
P<w,
hF &
%
& ;
8 & +;
e
i
YC
B@* # & g
g;# g N &
B@# H +;
1g N &
@4
KMO = 0/928
Sig = 0/000
131
#$''
u 2
S
@r
h
g**
@#
0
0 ; =+& 0
&
D/d'
3 hF 4
C
2 10#
&g
.M;K @ G: :
‰ CT 4# =+ B4 4
D/ec
D/%c
D/'e
D/'%
D/f'
D/c%
i
cD
i
RK! & Y
W B4 4 ƒ 0 ` # 1
0 ` # @# & #34 5 0 &
` # 0 # g T@ C =+
D/dd M# & ;# 4‡W h F Y<
C MG ;
*K& g
.M C # ƒ 3 h F B 1@
•O&
D/cc
@.
T @# Ÿ & ;G g
ƒ B C =+
hF 2 1
.M
Š*.
®*
#
Y
D/dX
D/d% .M C
k/fe kk/''
M 4<
!"
Y* O u ; (c)
41
D/fe . 4# h F 0 @
%/%D kf/ck
41
% &#$
& +; 0
0 & ‰ ;WTM 4;& 1 g
@G
F 0 &
&‚
B 1@
hF
$
T@# & h F 0 @
g 0 Y* 3 ` 1
. 4 & * r & C
)
#0 @
& ‰ ;W M# & ;#
`
1g
.MK 4
4<
0 *10ž YO
@4;
4 <0‡ 3 ` 1
.M
0ž 0 . & g T 4# ^ W
.M
0ž TM# & B 0ž g
1g
@G
)C
0 & k
.M
0ž ‰ ;W TM & B 0ž g
1g
8 & +;
B . & T @*
4 G g & ;G g
. C M 4< )C # 8 & +;
•
` & \S T 4 & h F 0 @
1g
. 4& M 4<
$k
i
YC
KMO = 0/894
Sig = 0/000
132
#$''
% &#$
!"
;
0 . T #34 5 0 4 E 3 ƒ
, G *67 3 B * P 4 W 4N &
0 . 3 h J:C d C R* g & .) @# ; 1 N
B4 35=*
B4 35=* F B @& * J:C d @ ; 1 G 234 5 • ,
TB4 35=*
4 E 3 ƒ
,G *67 B * & (&
w*G 0 5 Y* O .@ @ 234 5
@# ; 1 B4 35=* 5 3 C
1)
10
4 35 8 g* * 8 A
g*K 4(
() @ ; 1 B4 35=* 5 3 C
1)
1 ()
)
B4 35=* C
4 35 & ‚4&
A*r4 0
5 .@# @ 4< †
T@ ; 1 G 234 5 • ,
B4 35=* B @& C
4 35 @ C
.) @# † d @.
B4 35 0 4O RKW &
, F @r
;, @r
c$
$DD
-
c$
eX
$DD
4 35
• 34 (d)
#
@.
5
@r
c$
eX
$DD
$cd
$cD
%Dd
B4 35 0 4O
B4 35 =* &
B4 35 =* B @&
YC • .
B4 35=* M B 34 5= 3 A $cd T 1
NW: d @.
C 41B
.@ 4 )C # B4 35h \S A $cD @ 4 )C # B4 35h M
B4 35h B4 35=*
&)
YC 0
133
4 35 2
YC 0
g* * g*& 0 K S
& & R*
& B4 35h B4 35=*
2
YC 0
g* *
& ‚4& (T-Test) g* * 8 A B4 35 u ; .$cD/f$ $e%/%$
.) @# † f @. Y* A & B4 35h B4 35=* 2
#$''
B4 35h B4 35=*
Š(
0
,
O t
@#
.
0 35
D/D$e
2
%Dc
YC 0
;#
*,
k/efd
z O
*,
% &#$
(T-Test) g* * 8 A B4 35 (f)
k/$dce kf/%X $e%/%$
k/Dcd% kc/d' $cD/f$
B4 35 {4 J
,
D/$'
B4 35 {4
$cc
$c$
B4 35 {4 J &
4 35 2 YC 0
C
J:C) B4 35 {4 J & 2 YC
g*
B4 35 h
\S C
J: C & @ 4 )C #
*3g
0 w*G 8 :P ' @. . *1 8 4r
Š(
5
@,
4 35
g* *
@.
B4 35 =*
B4 35 h
(k/efd) @#
O t @S C F 5 3 f @ . w& (
; 1 F*; T) ;1 & D/Dc Š(
($/Xd) @. 3 %Dc
.)
, (B4 35h B4 35=* ) 1 g*&
0 35 0 .
z:;< 4#
0
!"
.
0 35
%Dc
&
4 35 2
O t
@#
D/$'e
*,
YC 0
;#
k/Dcd%
$/X'X%
g* * g*& 0 K S
* g*& C
8 ^
B4 35h B4 35=*
K S (@ 4 )C #
.@
†
g* * g*& 0 K S (')
z O
*,
g* *
kc/d'
ke/%d
$cD/f$
$ed/XD
@,
4 35
$cD
$cd
# @.
5
B4 35 {4
B4 35 =*
B4 35 h
@. t 3 %De 0 35 0 .
(D/$'e) @#
O t @S ' @. & .4 &
M C 34 5= g*& g & & T)
ƒ!4C TD/Dc 0
, Š(
($/Xd)
\S C
34 5= & @ 4 )C # B4 35h
M
B4 35=*
g* ! B 4
g & & . @ 4.
, 8 A T@ 4 )C # B4 35h
4& 234 5 0 F*; TB 34 5= 2 0
**I C C 0 *1 F*;
134
#$''
% &#$
!"
4 35 B4 35=* 0 . T
8
& .@# &
B4 35 =* 0 . 3 #
.) ;# @ 1@ 34 5 6 5 &
` F YS;K m*I; & ) K ;* KW
1)<
1)< # T
1 ;
`
+& 6 g*& K S
=
g
@# ; 1 C & 0 `
4
Pƒ h
Y* O u ;
T 1 ; 0 `
+& 6 B * g *& 0
, 8 A C@
B
& ) & & R* & 5 +& 6 g* * .
4.
1)<
T 1)< #
† $D X 0 @. Y* O g 3 Yr W u ; .$cD/ce T$e$/'c T$ee/$f
.) @#
0
`
+& 6 B *
4
Pƒ h
Y* O
2 & 1
A*r4 u ; (X)
?C @W
YG @W
*,
;#
*, z O
g* *
$Xk/DD
$Xe/DD
k$k/DD
i
cX/DD
c'/DD
ee/DD
i
$/'c'X
k/kdD$
$/'cdd
i
k%/kX%D
kf/$kk%
k%/'e'e
i
$ee/$ffe
$e$/'cce
$cD/ceff
i
@,
4 35
$Dd
Xc
$Dc
%Dd
#
@.
5
4 E
1 ;
1 )< #
1 )<
YC • .
g ; *&
1)< 04 E T 4#
NW: X @.
C 4PB
… ;< 4< & g* * ($e$/'cc) g ; C
1)< # 04 E ($cD/cef)
.@
2
0
, Š(
& 1u 0 4 E
F )* C
D/DDD
c/kDX
i
i
135
+& 6 g* *
Pƒ h
8 ,& g* *
8 ,& {4 F
%$'e/Xfc
d$$/efk
i
d%dX/Xc$
k'%$$$/%fX
k'Xe'$/%%D
Y* O ($D)
0 35 .
k
%D%
%Dc
@.
8 **I •
1B*
1B
YC
#$''
)
&
% &#$
!"
, 1 0 4 E *67 8 A B * h
Y* O B4 35 ` & .4 &
@#
B LSD , B4 35 3 A; & $$ @.
g 3 T@# &
1)< 04 E g* * 8 A 3 # ‰ @
# 4 8 A C
.@# &
1)< #
(LSD) 4 E
1 )<
+& 6 g* * g*&
1 )< #
id/%fD
i'/dXk
i
, 8 A YG @W ($$)
1 ;
k/%kk
i
'/dXk
D/DD$ Š(
(J) 4 E
(I) 4 E
i
ik/%kk
d/%fD
Mean Difference (I-J)
,
@.
1 ;
1)< #
1)<
D/Dc Š(
D/D$ Š(
,
,
+& 6 g* * g*& 8 A 4#
NW: $$ @ .
C 4PB
g* * g*& 8 A m .@# &
,
1 ;
1)< # 0 `
+& 6 g* * g *& g* q
T 1 ;
1)<
`
+& 6
` g*& 8 A g
4&
,
1)< #
1)< 0 `
&
1)<
` g*& 8 A 3 ; *&
1)< # `
&
1)<
.)
1 ;
0 *1 F*; •O&
`
& ;
#34 5 W P *67 0 K S z@ & ^ W =
B 34 5= 2
**I 0 *1Y`# &
1)<
T 1)< # T 1 ;
.@# F 34 5= %Dd g*& ‰ 4 F =
.) 1 F
m4 0
136
#$''
LSD
% &#$
!"
, B4 35
Pƒ h
Y* O B4 35 & @# 0 5• . 0
.@# Yr W 3 u ; @# Y* O
#34 5 W P & C 34 5= 2
**I 0 *1Y`# g*& :=
m - *^
#34 5 W P & C 34 5=
@ @ 234 5
1)<
`
& ;
.
4.
, 8 A T@ @ 234 5
1)< # ` & ;
`
*67 g*&
, 8 A
Pƒ h
Y* O 0 5 B4 35
C B
LSD , B4 35 Tg* !M . B
1)< #
1)<
B 34 5= 2
**I 0 *1Y`# &
1)< & ;
#34 5 W P *67
0 m*^ g & & .)
1)< # `
& ;
#34 5 W P *67 3 ; *&
.@# @* 7 =
m
W P & C 34 5= 2
**I 0 *1Y`# g*& :=
W P & C 34 5=
@ @ 234 5
1)<
`
&
.
4.
, 8 A T@ @ 234 5
1 ;
` &
`
*67 g*
*67 C
B
; *& B 34 5=
0 m*^ g
&
m
;
;
0 *^
#34 5
#34 5
, 8 A
P ƒ h
Y* O 0 5 B4 35
LSD , B4 35 *
B
1 ;
1)<
2
**I 0 *1Y`# &
1)< & ;
#34 5 W P
& & .)
1 ;
`
& ;
#34 5 W P *67 3
.@# @* 7 * =
W P & C 34 5= 2
**I 0 *1Y`# g*& :=
m4 0 *^
W P & C 34 5=
@ @ 234 5
1)< # `
& ;
#34 5
.
4.
, 8 A T@ @ 234 5
1 ;
` & ; #34 5
137
#$''
g* * g*& 0
.@ @ B
% &#$
!"
, 8 A LSD B4 35
0 Pƒ h
Y* O
1 ; &
1)< # ` & ;
#34 5 W P +& 6
.@ @* 7 =
4 0 *^ g & &
&
;
#34 5 W P *67 C @
B ($%f') 0 4 =
u ;
W P *67 3 ; *& ( 4 J
) B 34 5= 0 *1 & « & * 1» 04 E
=
u ; C E W .) « ; 2 » «Y » 04 E 0
& #34 5
04 E ) « 1)< #» ` & ;
#34 5 W P *67 C @
B
^W
#34 5 W P *67 3 ; C B 34 5= 2
**I 0 *1Y`# & ( & * 1
g* ! B 4
g & & T@# & (g . 04 E ) « 1)< » `
& ;
0 z@ & Y* 0 & « & * 1» W P 04 E 3 A; C C 0 *1 F*;
**I M 4P & AP (*W & ‚4& 0 z@ 0 & T)
R
;< #
.@
N &R
1)<
` & K S
b< 4P & 2
u ; 3.
4K ($%fX) p C =
u ; & ^W =
u ;
2
**I & «
1 •O&» h @ 2 *67 C @
B
pC =
.@# & «=S 0 A » «
+ » h @ 2
*67 3 ; *& B 34 5=
& ;
#34 5 W P *67 C @
B
* ^W =
u ; g* q
#34 5 W P *67 3 ; *& B 34 5= 2
**I & « 1)< » `
3 ` C † F 5 3 ) « 1)< #» « 1 ; » 0 `
& ;
¨ , )C
« 1)< » `
& ;
#34 5 W P r r
1 •O& 3 A; & B 34 5= 2
**I 234 5 @
B 34 5=
.
4K
pC=
u ; & u ; g /E T@# &
w < & 0 *1
& 5 g*& Y ,
C B 1)<
(*O Y 4
• g T ^W =
C @ @S;, @ ˜
u ; g* !M
, &F 3 ,
138
#$''
% &#$
G @* 7 4 2
=
u ; T 4#
9 , 34 5=
!"
**I
;#
C@
0 *1Y`# 4
T@ ;K 6[ = 0 *1Y`#
E ,A 8 4r & ) , C @ @S;, B 1)< .
Ž ;&
32
**I C
B
* ^W
.@# & ;# )C
1 0 •O&
'd/$k/$k
'f/Df/kd
'f/X/$d
139
: E S 0 *E 0 +K )
~
: ES
0 +K )
~
: ES 2 / ~
#$''
% &#$
!"
References
& Vn
•&
.J @ )*&
T$k
&» .($%ff) Y‡AE 4& T
0 4 E & B 4.4 = 1 & 6[ Y 4
10
$$
# T=
T@#
B9 K
&» .($%fX ) M K Tg @E g* 4
4 F T«({)
)* +#
:B T(dd$idfk br) T({)
T@#
0 F
.
1@ 3 & B
:>
# C 0
:B
)*& =
89 S
. : )*&
T
T«o C % S(
4& T *
T
J
:2
1 •O& T
T«B
8 *& 0 @]
0
;.
A*r4 n
+ h @ 0 2
#3 0 z@
234 5 8 3 T(
4< M ,
4 , T0 4
B ;K&
4
.
P P
4 O T
.
0A
4 O T 4^ 0@*,
# 0 B ; *& B 34 5=
*
B
0 *14 » .($%'D)
K 4
4
T«B
#34 5 W P v ;+ 0 4 E 0 K S » .($%f')
R;C 0 *1
M
B
@ T 4 < =S » .($%'$) ^ * T .
T« K B 4.4
O 0 ;
.ecife br
=
H/. & 6[ Y 4
:
T
# >0
#
P P ^G
8 S*SO
.($%'k) ) j T * r
8 ,E (
K
*67 K S » .($%fX) *O T
& ) K B 34 5=
2
p>
**I & =S
S*SO 0 j ) T« * O
.)*& M* , 0 @]
140
#$''
% &#$
!"
* ) 8 S*SO > T #34 5 0
& =
B 3 T2
234 5 8 3
0 &
U + …4 < 4]K 4 0 S( 1 >
2 1 .($%f$
.0j4E4 ] 4 g
RE V
23 234 5
.($%'D)
0 H ;C v*E7
. @ :B T[ .]
0
z @ .($%'$) 2
.)
0
& ; T2
;. 8 * ,
234 5 8 3
&
234 5 E 0 4# < *& T2
234 5 8 3
. @ :B .[ 4# &] * O
:B
T #34 5 0j4E4 ] 0 N
.($%'k) M# T=
Gropper, G.M. (1982). “A Behavioral Approach to Instructional Prescription”.
In C.M. Reigeluth (Eds.), Instructional Design: Theories and Models
Volume I ( PP. 101 – 161). Mahwah: Lawrance Erlbuam Associates.
Jonassen, D. (1999). “Designing Constructivist Learning Viron Environments”.
In C.M. Reigeluth (Eds.), Instructional Design: Theories and Models
Volume II (PP. 215-239). Mahwah: Lawrance Erlbuam Associates.
141
#$''
=>??
QE 2
8 )$ "
5W
& =>
#
% &#$
!"
!
H XS Y.! ;< #H
O-8 * ' X 3 -!$
4 0 ;C 04F
3 G +*E3
4 +& J
;C
1 *
; g @E *< 4 & & Y* . ;C
˜
@*`!
3 B ;<
& 6[ E7K YW Z
(*O T ;* +# Y 4 =S ^ W w*SO
%D 1
E $k $' B ;< 3 A dD 4N g 0 & .) ; 1 G
& 4
G K S 4 (*O Y 4
E7K YW Z T ;* +# Y 4 N 3 0
0 0A
- 4 w P 3 ) : - 
& , . & 0 B ; < .@ ; 1
g*& 3 0 #4<
0 *1 4 w P 3 0 B ;< @ @# H +; J ;
0 *1
n 5 B 4.4 )* +# 0
4 35 .@ @ # H +; B ; *&
J @
u ; @ > Y* ]
(*O Y 4
& ) . ;< wSO 0@*K> E7K YW Z
;>
4<= B
1B
1B & @,& 0 B ;< >
B =
8 A — < E7K YW Z
0 B ;< .@ 0 B ;< & 0
, 8 A ]
)* +# g*& .) 6[
3 B ;<
(*O Y 4 .@ 0 B ;< & 0
,
3 D/%% @W 4<= B
1B &
4. (& 0 B ;< E7K YW Z
E7K YW
; *I; 3 D/$D @W
1B &
> g**
E7K YW 0 1
- AE[
. > g**
8 6
4< 4F B
T ]
;>
4<= B
T
1B
1B & :0@* > B 1j
. E7K YW Z
F*
142
#$''
% &#$
!"
€ 4> T@ > €
<)
g @E - 3 . B @& > 4.4 € 4>
;K& - @ @ Z ) g]
.($%'k T N, ) 4#
@ G $0 B 4.4
(*O T 1 4 < 8:]
F*;
@4
@# & = 4< ) 4 04F;K. &
& :;& • ,
5 .@ . 4 0 3 Y† K & 0 B 4.4 .@ Ž
+#
0 0 F T /I 4 T
M;K* v,^ T ; 4 89:;< T ;& S 0 0 *&
*; T) A> J KW
hA 8 = > T 1 K Y* G 3 ;<
T :&) @ *1
G
;. @^ 0 ;
€4 89:;< T 4 z
4
k
B
& 5 • B@
3 & • g; 3 & 8 4r 0 B ;< . (kDD$
0 ) W 4 Y*E &
, . 4.4 \ # T{ ;. B@#
4<
8:] & @ ; # I# g;
g
] & & *; B 4 g]
4G
& ) 13 & 0 & 0 ; > h # > 0 4P & .@# @ 4< . 4 0 # & R
.)# @ 4< ,* P ME
1@ 3
, T@ ;K Y*<
>
4
# &
, 4 < 0 @ Y B ;<
K ]
g;
8 ,E ( B
F g 3 @# &
.($%'k T N, ) > @ 4< Z > Y‡,
>) 0 ^g & &
& .4 & .)#
= >
{ ;. r g>
g 30* * 0 &
6[ E7K YW Z
(*O T ;* +# Y 4 @# , =
g
Y† K
6[ Y 4 g M . *1 G
& 4
3 B ;<
8:]
Y† K T 0 & @# >U Y 9 @r 'D q ! @# &
1 4<
Y]E z
*N
+# Y† K B@ 35 Y?
@ 8:] )
1 4<
—4
04 & b+# * @+ 4
8:]
] * 0
A; A4 .@
Y # 1 4 < Y† K .(kDD$ T£: >) @ # &
1- Runaway
3- Cavilla
143
2- Blaha
13 V5 ‰94 ,
&
4< &
#$''
g* 4G &
3 8:]
Tg @E g*& • ,
% &#$
K. T K . T
!"
F*
A; 4
# 8:]
g @E *; ( &
4<) *
& 8:]
0 *1 TMN
T @
B@ 35 Y # @ & ‚4& 8:] .@# & g @E Y]E z
3
.@# & g * , 0 ; @ &
@
J KW T @ & g;# @ G:
0 K S
.@ > B *& T @ - &
A 8 N 0 ; *& ;W & 0
@ 5 ) & F*; g T ; 1 8 4r @ @
S& >
5
0 g*& >
$f 0
*V
@ r %d 0
@ - &
A 8 N >
4 < Y O Y& G *V
& )E K> \ # 0 0 B ;< .@# & @ r
.('$ T 4x > <) 4#
5
& F
4<
M> W \&
@ ;K 4<
0 0 ` @&
F* ) AV 0
T—:P
@. Tg B4!
4;C
k
B `
3 41 .(kDDk ,$” 4C \< 8 :P ) )
;K
& 4<
3
- S&
B < & 3 @r '%/c C @ ; 1 F*; 4< ,E (
(kDD')
.)
4& E $e/c 5
g*E g \ 4; @ ;#
r ;< 0
•& @ > B *& >
4. 0 @,; 0
N
(*O Y 4 @ *1 Y]# )* +# 4O P 3 1@*
4 &
&S
3 1@* Y 4 B * .($%fX T0 *&5) @
,P G =S )* +# 0 *1Y]#
{4
P3
G 0 *V B ;< & ) K 0 9 & Š(
0 B ;<
1@ 3 41 0 @
> 4# • &
)*,G4 3
& 3
/1 *67 * 3 1@* Y 4 g & & S - 4*# {4 & ] & @ > & 3
3
g >@
B
@# F 0 B ;< 4
>
& W .)
3
0 @ Y& S
@ 4< & 0 ; >
; W •& 3
; *& *K& 0 B ;<
3 1@* Y 4 B * .($%'DT N, ) @ / R* 5
1- Child Line Information
2- Gwadz
144
#$''
% &#$
!"
> & 4< 8:] & . 4 0 & 0 B ;< > 0 4*# .) 0 B ;< 3
)+ 0
0
B ;< .)
@ B F* @ 5 > 0 4*# ; *& @ &
;* +# 3 & 1 3 H (^
F* )* KW @ # &
r < ;* +#
.@ ;K H ( ^ @,;K B
& 3 ; *& B
.(¡‘¯¡ T0 3 &) ) 5
.@ # & 0 *V B ;< 3
1B 0 B ;< @
N &
YW
F @
3= 234 5 > @
B v ;+ 0 =
F*;
g R*> g* q .@# &
6[ 0 B ;<
&Y = >
E7K
@ 4< & 9 & H (^ 3 >
4.4 0 &
&0 0
& 234 5
@ 0
5 1@ 3 0 • , YW M 0 *1M*
4& 6[ @ 4
1 4 < 8:]
& & @ 4;& >0 4P & ;<
S 8:] Y& S
5
@5 > ]
@ @ *& S( 0 ]
& 4 
1 K
r4W & T † J KW
64 Y 4 3 ] .@ ] H +;
k
$
†4< 4F B
>0
@;
h>
4. .(kDD$ T: >) @# &
@ 4& @,;K 4< = 3
H (^ T 1 K 0 & @
> RK> †9 &
@ >
4< ;W
1 K Y*E & 0 v ‰ S .($‘°± T% ;E4#)
@4
†4< 4F B Y
> )A1 B 4;& @ # g & & .($%'k T0 *
@<)
.@# & ;# =S
2
=
YW Z
)
1 - Jorm
3- scholtz
145
;* +#
(*O Y 4 3 ) 8
] F wSO Y 4 g B4!
lP
> w*SO {4^4 & .4 &
3 B ;<
& 64 e E7K
2- Parks
4- problem solving
#$''
% &#$
!"
l P g & & . *1
G
& 4 T Ž ,* P 8 4r & > B5 {4G 3 h
5 (¡ B ;< 3 1 w*SO g
.@# &
(0 K S
) {4G 3 h
N 3 @ >
1@ 3 4< g @E & > 0 B ;< (¢ T@
>
3 >
T F* 8 6
4< 4F B T
1B
1B &) ;* +# Y 4
)U
35) (*O Y 4
E7K YW 2 T( ] ; >
4<= B
.@ @# K S M & ( 4 < 0 ‡ & z:;<
\*O
0 5- 4
, .
& > @ ;K 0 B ;< 5 3 A %D ) ;< dD 3 Y] ; 0 5 - , .
<@ >
> @ ;K 0 B ;< 0@,& A %D .@ >
1@ 3 4< g @E
A dD g .@ ; 1 G
& 4 B 3 0 3 & ) : - < TB O&
G K S 4 E7K YW Z
(*O
;* +# Y 4 N 3 0 A %D 1
J;
0 *1 4 T0 *1 4 2 0 B ;< M> @, & .4 & .@ ; 1
- & B ; *&
†
Š(
34 5= A %D 0 B ;< 4
.@# &
.@ @# H +;
e T% Tk T$ wP 3 0 #4<
0 *1 4 2
*
0 *1 3 @ 0
1 0 & @# &
4 'DY # B4 35 g :$n 5 B 4.4 )*
0 B * 0 & @* > e &
g 0 /1
) @# *
0
&= ]
n 5 \ 4 B4 35 g
. *1 8 4r L
n 5 .)
; 1 G @ * 7 4 8 A; 0 4*# v ;+
>@ 4
O D/fD 3 =*& v ;+ 8 S*SO
B4 35 g
&
+# B4 35
$' $k
P TN TE
8 *& F
= ]
1- Eysenck
146
#$''
B
B5
@*
% &#$
!"
B4 35 g & F
] RE . 4& =+&) ^
*< 5 N &
R* & B
g ; @* 7 & : 04E4
&\ 4
4
4 g**, (= ]
n 5 ; B @W ) D/'D D/fD
.($%'$ T0@ * 3 YS &) @
G
Y 4
#)*, . )*,^
&).
4 < 0 ‡ & z:;<
1@ 3 \*O
)U
;*& 4
;O @*
3 * B5 4;O
D/'c & & AE5 R ^ 3 A; &
g
g : ;< wSO
35 Y? 03
# (*O
; g**, 0 & @# ;<
.@# ; 1 Z >
.@ 5 ) &
;<
W
P ($XXd) $n 9 0@*K> 04 3 J *S g : E7K YW J *S
Y 4 3 @>
@F
Y d > )
4 ke 0
) @#
YW 0 1
T 1@
:3 @
Y 4 g .@# & B4 35
e @ *1 &
.0 5 0 Z
& ;. Z T E7K YW
; T)*G:< Z T E7K
R ^ .@# & ; ($%'D) W r 0@ O 04 3 E7K YW - 4*# J *S
] & .4 & .) @# b+
* B4 35
;K g* * AE5
D/dD & & & AE5 g* * ( 50 Z
F&) @ ;K D/cD 3 9 & AE5 R ^
3 J *S g T B4 35
;K g* * & .4 & g* !M @# &
& T
=
J *S g
; g* !M .)
4< & 39 ;
.($%'k TB ]
4 & &) ) @ 5 ) & D/ff & & & AE5 R ^ 3 A;
>B5 & ) B5 * )< 2
4;O
& ]; ; *& J *S g
& B5
R ^ 3 O^ g# •O& E7K YW - 4*# J *S Y ,E 4;
A; B5 3 > 0 @
@ 4# < & B5 0 4 - &
) @ * B*
1- Cassidy & long
147
#$''
% &#$
!"
4
* < & J *S ‚
- @ B T@ b + * 3 g
@ >
R ^ B 4 & ; b< # g; 1 N
&
z P 3 .@# &
&
TB ]
4 & &) =
Z ( ; R ^
&) & &
R ^)
E4 G Y& G R ^ > @ 5 ) & D/'f & & & J *S g
R ^ ($%'k
.)
0 3 & > T) :
< TB O&
<@ >
3 0
;< %D
J;
0 *1 4 w P 3 @ @#
#
B ;< 03
# B ;<
YW
Tn 5 B 4.4 ;* +#
)
5 3 @>
&
4
39 8 O*^4 @#
( ;< wSO
n 9 0@*K> E7K
0@,& 1 .@# &
=
YO .@#
5 & *
B >
w P3 1g @ >
1@ 3 4< 0 4 < & > @ 4& 0
;< %D M
0 & .@ @# H +;
e T% Tk T$ wP 3 0 #4<
0 *1 4 2
Y* O B4 35 3 0 B ;< E7K YW Z
)* +# &
- (&
&
- (&
& 0 & .) @# A;
] (MANOVA) *I; @ ! h
B4 *
;K 2 3 @;& 0 B ;< - E7K YW Z
)* +# g*&
¢ < B4 35 3 (*O Y 4
& 0 & .@# A;
1 & 1 B4* 1 3 hx
.@# A;
;
)* +# ,& 09 & @W g* @W T @ ; z O Tg* * T
4 35 @,
- 4 < & > 0 B ;<
3 0 B ;<
1 0 & E7K YW Z
.) @#
B $ @. @ >
1@ 3 4<
148
#$''
% &#$
8 A;
!"
1
=
0 *I;
A*r4
5 ($)
9 & @W
g* @W
@; z O
g* *
@,
kD
$X
kD
kk
$k
X
'
d
'
'
'
'
'
f
'
'
'
'
d
$
f
d
$
D
D
D
$
$
$
$
$
D
k
$
$
$
%/dX
e/ef
%/%c
%/XD
%/dk
k/fc
k/kc
k/Dd
k/k'
$/dd
$/Xc
$/'k
k/$c
k/%%
k/DX
$/'k
k/%f
$/dX
$e/%D
$%/fd
$k/%D
$f/$%
c/'%
%/%%
e/k%
%/cd
e/'d
e/'D
e/cd
d/$d
e/kD
e/$d
c/$D
c/$D
c/ed
c/Xd
%D
%D
%D
%D
%D
%D
%D
%D
%D
%D
%D
%D
%D
%D
%D
%D
%D
%D
• g T) /1 *67
.
*67
3 5
: 4 - *^ .
* 67
149
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
#
@.
4< 4F B
&
4< = B
1@
01
)*G:<
;
H ;.
= 1
3 B ;<
)* +# 5 ] g**, 0 &
& B ;<
4< 4F B : - *^ :) l (
3 5
&B ;<
1B : - *^
.
*67
3 5
& B ;< 4<= B
#$''
% &#$
!"
*I; @ ! h
Y* O 3 %
$ 0 *^
& B
~
4N &
0 Y œ OE 3 ;<
1 B * 8 A g**, 0 &
] (MANOVA)
$
0
, g**, 0 & @ 9 ]
*I; @ ! B4 35 3 @;& @# A; )* +#
.)
5 k @. B5 - F*; > @ 1 . ;* +# 0 Y
&
*I;
)* +# 0 Y
0
F
, Š(
D/DDD
&
]
0
,
D/d$f
D/DD
D/DDe
, B4 35 (k)
F
@.
*I;
@ 9 `
*67 (MANOVA) *I; @ ! h
Y* O u ; (%)
;>
B T 1B
1 B & T F* 8 6
g* *
8 /F
D/kc
e/kd
kd/fe %cD/e$
X/Dc X%/e$
$d/'c
$%/k%
$D/%c
M & 4< = B
8 A 4< 4F B
#
*I; @ ! B4 35
$$/Xc
4< 4F B
Š(
*I; @ ! 0
.
0 35
{4 F
8 /F
$
$
$
c'
c'
c'
dD
dD
dD
e/kd
%cD/e$
X%/e$
Xff/dd
fdf/fd
dDD/'%
$kfX'/DD
$e$$%/DD
$Xcc/DD
1B & @,&
N 3
1
;* +# 0
*I;
4< 4F B
&
B
4< 4F B
&
B
4< 4F B
&
B
#
@.
8 **I •
(<
Y>
1
4#
4 , % @. 3 > 4PB
> ) B5
*& u ; .@
, 8 A
1- Wilks lambda
150
#$''
% &#$
!"
4< 4F B @ @ * 7
- * ^ > )A1 B 4
g & & .@ @ 0
,
8 A
1B
1B & @,&
1 . @ *67
3 5
& B ;<
.@ 4& 0 B ;< 3
0
B ;< > 0 4P & @ ;# 0
,
3 5
& B ;<
@# @* 7
- *^ > )A1 B 4 g & &
0 B ;< & ] ; > 4<= B @,& 0 B ;< .
*67
4<= B h @# @* 7 * 4 - *^ g & & .@ 0
, 8 A
.
*67
3 B ;<
&
&0
, 8 A E7K YW Z
*I;
Z
0
.)
N 3
3 0
B ;< : ! - *^
.@ 0 B ;<
@ ! h
Y* O B4 35 3 e - * ^
& B ~
4N &
Š( œ OE 3 ;<
1 B * 8 A g**, 0 & PZ (MANOVA)
, g**, 0 & @ 9 ]
*I; @ ! B4 35 3 @;& @# A; E7K YW
@ 5 e @. B5 F*; > @# . E7K YW 04 E N 3 1 8 A
1
0
, Š(
D/D%
E7K YW 04 E
F
keX'
*I; @ ! 0
, B4 35 (e)
*I; @ ! B4 35
@ 9 `
@.
*I;
E7K YW 04 E
, E7K YW N 3
1 8 A 4#
4 , e @. 3 > 4PB
1 & E7K YW Z 0 AE[ @> 0 B ;< ] g**, ) . .)
A;
PZ (MANOVA) *I; @ ! h
Y* O B4 35 3 @ 8 A
.) @ 5 c @. B4 35 g u ; @#
151
#$''
E7K YW 04 E 8 A
0
,
D/k%
D/'X
D/DD
D/Xc
D/'X
D/%c
0
0
PZ (MANOVA) *I; @ ! h
1
% &#$
!"
Y* O F*; (c)
F
g* *
8 /F
.
0 35
{4 F
8 /F
$/ek
D/D$
$D/f%
D/DD
D/D$
D/''
d/dd
d/dd
%'/eD
$/dd
d/dd
%/fc
$
$
$
$
$
$
d/dd
d/dd
%'/eD
$/dd
d/dd
%/fc
1@
01
—:<
;
H ;.
= 1
e/dd
e/DD
%/cf
c/Dc
%/ff
e/ke
c'
c'
c'
c'
c'
c'
kfD/f%
k%k/kd
kDf/c%
kXk/Xd
k$'/'d
ked/e%
1@
01
—:<
;
H ;.
= 1
(<
dD
dD
dD
dD
dD
dD
$$XD/DD
$d%e
$Xfe
$%e%
$'DD
kk$$
1@
01
—:<
;
H ;.
= 1
Y>
B ;< & 0 B ;< 8 A 4#
B ;< > ) B5
*& u ; .@# &
YW Z
0
E7K
AE[
#
@.
•
8 **I
4 , c @. 3 > 4PB
, —:< E7K YW Z
152
#$''
*^
% &#$
!"
g & & .@ ;# 0
, 8 A 0
B ;< & —:< E7K YW Z
.@# @* 7 !
: 4& l (
4 < 0 ‡ & z:;< ) U
B4 35 F*; d @. .@#
.@
B
B ;<
3
0
, Š(
D/DDD
35 @
4
w*SO g
(*O Y 4 5 :
4
Œ) Y* ) B5 *& u ;
35 4 ; *& 0 B ;< @ P<D/Dc Š(
0
, 8 A 0
)U
35 &
> ) 1 F*; B 4
g & & .@ ; 1 G K. ) U
& z:;< *67 - &
k < B4 35 F*; f @. .
) ? - (&
K.
.@
B
B ;<
&
4 <0‡
4 < 0 ‡ & z:;< k < B4 35 u ; (f)
0
, Š(
D/DDD
)0
153
0 35 .
k
@.
23
k%/ek
, 8 A 0 B ;< & 4 < 0 ‡
.@ > >U 0 ; *& z:;< 0
k < B4 35
& z:;< N 3 0 B ;
$
$
D/%f*
$
D/$c
D/k'
$
D/c$**
D/$d
D/$d
$
$
D/$d
iD/$d iD/kd
iD/k% iD/ef**
D/$$ iD/kD
D/kD iD/$'
P<D/Dc
4< 4F B g*& - (&
*I; T *I; Z =
) )?
4< 4F B
YW 0 1
3 ; *& @ # &
)
A
&
E7K
E7K YW 0 1
3 ; >@
@# &
A
4<= B
YW 0 1
3 ; > @ #&
!:
4
@.
&
4F B
8 6
4<
F*
$
$
!"
4 g & B H 4. 0 &
.@# A;
1 & 1 B4* 1
R ^ u ; (')
1@
% &#$
$
iD/ek*
D/$f
iD/%%
iD/ke iD/%d
iD/%X* iD/c%**
iD/D% D/Df
D/DX D/%d*
iD/$d iD/De
iD/kd D/Df
iD/kX
D/%f*
D/$X
iD/D$
D
D/kf
4< 4F B
F* 8 6
&
4<= B
] ;>
1@
01
—:<
;
H ;.
= 1
P<D/D$
0 B ;<
: >@
B ' @. u ;
&
8
& (r=iD/ek) @# &
A
&
E7K YW 0 1
g*& - ( & @&
= >
4F B 0 B ;< @G
, (r=D/%f)
YW 0 1
g*& - (& .@ >
A; E7K
#&
& 0 B ;< @G
, (r=iD/c%)
01
g*& - ( & . > @ 4< A;
= B 0 B ;< @G
, (r=iD/%X)
154
#$''
% &#$
!"
) )?
& E7K YW
; g*& - (& . > @ 4< A; E7K
YW
; Z 3 ; *& @ # &
& 0 B ;< @G
, (r=D/%d)
)
A E7K YW
1@
; g*& - (& . > @ 4< A; E7K
(r=D/c$) @# & ) ? E7K YW
; & —:< Z g*& - (& (r=iD/ef)
h
g**
& 4N & (r=D/%f) .) ) ? = 1 H ;. g*& - (&
3 @>
0 & )* +# , & \ 4 E7K Y W Z 0 *I; 3 @>
B 4 & ;* +# , & €:
;K& *I; B 4 & E7K YW 0 AE[
*I;
=+& .@# . 1 & 1 2 & B4* 1 g*&=* YS;K *I;
; 1 N g*&=* *I; B 4 & )* +# ,& €: *I; B 4 & 1@
>U 3 F
@ @ B4* 1 @
)* +# ,& 3 @>–* > F 5 3 @#
)* +# ,& €: *I; B 4 & 0 1
0@,& =+&
4# 0 4< B5
, )* +# @,&
> B Yr W u ; T@# ; 1 N g*&=* B 4 &
@W ;K 4 *I;
g @ @# B4* 1 @
4< = B
&
>@ B
;& R ^ u ; @ > g**
E7K YW 0 1
AE[ 3 D/%%
$D X @. u ; @# &
A
4<= B
& R ^).
.) @ 5
YW
01
Š(
0
,
D/DD
D/DD
155
) . (YS;K *I; ) )* +# *I; 1 & 1 B4* 1 Y* O (X)
( ;K& *I; ) E7K
)K
F
g* *
8 /F
{4 F
8 /F
/X%
$D
ek/ck
%/'X
ek/ck
$D'/X%
$c$/ed
cf/%D
Xe/$d
$c$/ed
'/k$
k'/dk
%/e'
.
0 35
$
k'
kX
k
kf
kX
•
/ b< #
B4* 1
@ *G &
Y>
B4* 1
@ *G &
Y>
#
@.
*I;
g*&=*
&
&
= B
4<
#$''
Y* O
5&
% &#$
!"
@ ; 0 (< g**, R ^ TB4* 1 R ^ & ‚4& 8 :P r:< ($D)
( 1 & 1 B4* 1 Y* O 2 &) 0 1
& )* +# *67
0 (<
@ ;
5&
R ^
g**,
(R)
$/Xf
D/kc
$/'d
D/%%
Š(
t0
,
t)K
;& R ^
bR ^
g*& =* *I;
D/DD%
D/DDc
D/DeX
i%/%D
i%/D'
ik/Dc
iD/c%
iD/ef
iD/%$
iD/%d
iD/D%k
iD/kD
&
&
4<= B
@.
$
k
B4! @# ; 1 N €: *I; B 4 & )*G:< 0 AE[ 0@,& =+&
0 4< B5 >U 3 F
@ @ B4* 1 @
)* +# ,& 3 @> –*
& )* +# ,& €: *I; B 4 & ; *I; 0@,& =+& .) @#
& > B
@ 0 . 3 Yr W u ; .@# ; 1 N g*& =* B 4
E7K YW
; *I; 3 D/$D$ @W )K 4 @# B4* 1 @
)?
& R ^). >@
B
;& R ^ : & .@ > g**
YW Z 3 AE[
\S Y> .) @#
5 $k $$ @. u ; @# &
,& 3 @> –*
4< 4F B @,& * @ @# g** )* +# ,& \ 4 E7K
,& 3 @>–* * = 1 H ;. 0 AE[ 0 & . ] g**
E7K YW Z
.) @# 0 4< B5 >U 3 g & & @ @ B4* 1 @
)* +#
; ) . (YS;K *I; ) )* +# 1 & 1 B4* 1 Y* O ($$)
Š(
0
,
D/De
F)K
e/kc
g* *
8 /F
{4 F
8 /F
.
0 35
/ b< #
•
$f/fX
e/$f
$f/fX
$$f
$%e/'D
$
k'
kX
B4* 1
@ *G &
Y>
#
@.
*I;
g*&=*
&
156
#$''
5&
% &#$
!"
@ ; 0 (< g**, R ^ TB4* 1 R ^ & ‚4& 8 :P r:< ($k)
( 1 & 1 B4* 1 Y* O 2 &) ; & )* +# *67 Y* O
@ ; 0 (<
5&
R ^
(R)g**,
- , Š(
t0
D/$D$
D/De'
k/De
R ^
;&
bR ^
k/Dde D/%d%
D/k%e
)K
t
#
*I;
g*&=*
&
0 *1 F*;
4 < 0 ‡ & z:;<
\*O
) U 35) (*O Y 4 =
G
& 4
3 B ;<
& 64 ;* +# Y 4 0 & S
- S& > @ 4&
;<
1 Z .@ ; 1 G K S 4 B ;< 3 1
.@ >
1@ 3 4< 4 < & > @ 4& 0 B ;<
1 @ ;#
8 6
4< 4F B T
&) )* +# ,& N 3 1
4 (*O Y 4 E7K YW Z T( ]
;>
4<= B T
.) 1 G
& 4 E7K YW )* +# g*& - (& @ ; 1 G
:@ @#
& )* +# ,& N 3
0 B ;< &
3 0 B ;< >
.@ 4&
0 B ;< @ ;# 0
0
, 8 A 4<= B @,& 0
.@ 4& 0 B ;< 3 4<=
B
0
*
0
157
u ;
B ;< &
@ >
*V B ;<
.)
1
g @;& =
4& B5
*& =
, 8 A
B ;< & K S
B 0 B ;<
@.
•O&
g
Z
.) 1
3
g
F*
K S
g
;
g*E
& @,&
0 B ;<
>0 4P .@ ;#
4& E7K YW Z N 3 1
K S =
4 g*
0
, 8 A —:< E7K YW Z
0
B ;< >
A; —:< E7K YW 04 E 3 ; *& 0 B ;< @ ;#
&0
, 8 A 01
E7K YW Z
0 B ;<
4K ($%'D) N, ($%'%) 0 @*W ; & ; g .@ ;#
#$''
% &#$
!"
N 3 1 . 4&
& (*O Y 4 g*& - (&
&
4 g* 4
35
1 & ) K 0 B ;< .@ ;# 0
, 8 A M & (*O Y 4
> ) 1 F*; B 4 g & & .@ 4& > >U 0 ; *& z:;<
K. ) U
4E4 , ; g & 4K .) Y*<
3 B ;<
(*O Y 4
& z:;<
K. ) U
35 &
3 B ;<
C
B (kDDk) J C
. ) ? - (&
4 <0‡
0
B ;< E7K YW )* +# g*& - (&
&=
4 g* !
4< = B
& , )* +# @,&
> 4& B5 *& ; . 4&
; *I; 3 %$D
& @ > g**
01
E7K YW Z %%%
& 0 B ;< & K S
0 B ;< .@ > g**
E7K YW
\&
F* ) : & ) ? 8 4r &
& > @# 4 ,
& @ ! .@ ;K
>
5 3 ; & @ > RK> 0 3 &
> K>
.@ 4& 3 0 J ; & B@ 5 > & G T@ > RK>
&
>
4< & 0 &
;. ) W Z > 0 4. 0 ; *&
;W & g* !M B
&
.@ 4& J ; &
- ; 5B
.@ # &
0
)A1 B 4
g & & .(¡‘°± T ;E4#) @
g & 4K .) 0 B ;< 3 g*†
- ; 5 E K1 & 0 B 4.4 >
0 B ;< .(kDDk T%J4* . k4
1 Y # )* +#
- .g
1- simonz
3- Janus
5- psycopaty
B ; @# 4 , w*SO g
& 3 0 g* Y O
;<
Y O
- ; 5
$
$XXD
4 * ;
B
*†
Y O
B 0 B ;< & K S
2- Dembo
4- psychose
158
#$''
% &#$
!"
)K * c
4]
3 0 .
4<= B @ # & e34] )
&
.(@# & Y
1 b+#
& ,G 0
@ 0 , &
4] )
3) 3 T * 3 B & 8/E @ Tgp 4 T *&@& 3 > W b< # g
8 S W K #@ & J KW TB
35 & Y T0 @
MW 8 @G B
> ; # B *& (¡‘¯¢)
C ; g & 4K .) @,; 0 J4 & >
&B
]A .) M> 5 N W J 4W > T@ 4# )+
= B
g* q .@ 4# 13 B # 4< z P \*O & @ 4
@>
w* ( 8 *,G
* .@ 0 * 5 H (^ 0 ; & T0 B ;< & ) K 0 B ;<
g .@ >
v,^ 0
J
F > ) 0@* & 4
g
F* )* KW Tg* V w < T 1 K & Y )O 0 B ;<
Y 4
. 4# l ( 4 4# • &
)*,G4 3
& 3
/1 *67 * 3 1@* Y 4 g & & S - 4*# {4 & ] & @ > & 3
3
B
@# F 0 B ; < 0 & >
& ; g & 4K .)
Y& S
@ 4< & 0 ; >
; W •& 3
g > @
> 3 1@* Y 4 B * .($%'D T N, ) @ / R* 5 3
0 @
> 0 4* # Y& S
T) 0 B ;< 3 ; *& *K&
4. 0 B ;<
@ 5 > 0 4*# ; *& @ &
> & 4< 8:] & . 4 0 & B ;< g
.($%'% T0 @*W) ) @ B F*
'd/DX/kc
'f/De/$f
''/Dk/%D
159
: E S *E - +K )
~
: ES
- +K )
~
: ES 2 / ~
#$''
% &#$
References
S* ( ,E ( B
n
&S
. 4
4A
@# -
B
;<
•&
.($%fX) gKO T0 *&5
)*
.(CRI)
!"
&S 0 ~
J *S 0
&
.B
.($%'k)
T
F .B 4F
*;#5
;<
1@* B *
O;
4. T0 j ˆMp >@* T † P P ˆY* . T 4 & &
):
E7K YW 0 4*# g*& - (&
&
.$d % 8 OAr T$ # TM;A
T
;* +# 0
.J @ )*&
0
.
B ;<
T@#
;K E
Z
# >
;# @#
F @
# > -
B
.
.B
F
3 B ;<
. ; & @* #
•,
0
B ;<
T0@* W
4<
.
;#
T
+& 6
0 ;>
& .($%'%)
B ;<
@]
T0@ * 0 3 &
& .($%'k) @
3= 234 5 *67
.
g*;K+ 89 S @*]! .
.0
B
T 4 < )<
/< ) . E . 5 **I
; W0
. K 4 @]
TJ @ )*&
& E7K YW 0 8
@@
& .($%'$) H ;
1
*# T0 @*W
& Y
E
= >
T
4 < =S .($%'$) 4,K T 4x> <
.B
4<
#R* 5
>
4 < 0 R* 5 =S .($%'k) ^ @ O T0 * M T0 @<
4<
#R* 5 - > g*;K+ 89 S - @*]! .0
B ;<
. ; & @* #
160
#$''
:B
% &#$
.B *#
!"
24 *>
.
T) :
.($XX$
. 4
):
. ;*&
.(¡‘°¯) g *&
T4 }
r B &3 & ; ~ ) )
F* 24 g*& - (& .($%'%) A(
& E7K YW Z
4
@]
E7K YW 0 4*#
.
# >-
B
.
3
B
& .($%'%) H & T
0@ ž . g*& - (&
. *E &
# >-
TB
;, #
# > •(S B 4F
.
*O : .
.)* +# 0
N .(¡‘°±) g E @ * T ;E4 # B T ;E4#
.(¡±±¯ r B &3 & ; ~ ) =
:B T0@ O @*
.
:B
.)* +# ;K 3 0
N .($%'k) g*KW T
K
E7K YW Z
& .($%'D)
T Wr
ke 8 OAr TZ
# T @ . T ;<
4
F .0
.= 1 :B
YW 0 8
# >-
F @
B
3= 234 5 *67
.0
B ;<
>
@ T0@ O
& K S
.ek
.($%'k) : # T
N,
& .(¡‘¯’) g & T03 41
N,
Œ ! B ;<
. 4 0 4*#
1@* B *
.J @ )*&
& E7K
T@#
Blaha, Maureen. (2001). Runaway Prevention Curriculum Teacher Guide.
Journal of Adolescent Research.7:1-17
Cassidy, T., & Buanside, E. (1996). Problem-Solving Style, Stress and
Psychological Illness: Development of a Multifactorial Measure. British
Journal of Clinical Psychology, 35, 265-277.
161
#$''
% &#$
!"
Cavilla, Ana (2001). Consultation on Young Runaways. American Journal of
Public Health 91: 1409-1429.
Child Line Information (2002). Child Line January. Journal of Health and
Social Behavior 50: 401- 413.
Dimatteo, M.R. (1991). The Psychology of Heath, Illness and Medical Care.
An Individual Perspective, California: Brooks Cole Polishing Company.
Dembo, & Janus, M.C., (2002). Midwest Longitudinal Study of Homeless.
American Journal of Orthopsychiatry. 66(3):350-360
Fasulo, Samuelj & Cross. Theodore P. (2002). Children and Youth Services
Review. Vol. 24, No.8.623-640
Furnham, Adrian & Barrett, Lynne, (1988). Exploring Social Psychology.
Third Edition, Boston: Allyn and Bacon.
Gwadz, M.V. Gostnell, K. .Molenski, C. Willis, B. Nish, N. Nolan, C.T.
Tharaken, M, S. Ritchie, S.A., (2008) The Initiation of Homeless Youth
into the Street Economy. Journal of Adolescence, XX. 1-21
Scholt, E.M. (1997). Exploration of Criteria for Residential and Foster Care.
Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry. 38, 657-666.
162
#$''
% &#$
$
"
!"
=>??
& =>
<)3 ) -\ $ ) [L#
Z.
<
4 9%
#
!
F8 $) H<
(-\ $ -L.B ) ^L#
-\ $
8 )
= -!$
0) 1E A O-\ $
-\ $
B
M , )*&
1 C 4
;
*
= *> ^ *
J@
Ir 4
;>
*
@*]!
0 *1
2 * T ^ 0 @ 4< 0 *I;
;*K . 8 A
& & ^ W w*SO
K
;
0 4 4N g @& . 3
B ; *&
¯¢i¯‘ * O
B • 0 S( B 34 5= 3 K
; @ z:< & B ;< @
>
@ 4< T > @ @
B K @
^ ) * & M*S;K 6 g ; *&
.
^ ) * & *67 g ; *& ^
T ^
163
G
]
T ^
0 *1
2*
T ^
@ 4< )*K . :0@* C B 1j
. ^ ) *
#$''
% &#$
!"
* •O& •W 3 ] ;*K . 0 8 A
&
&0 0 8 A
&
K ; R.
)
. 0 @ @ ƒ B ;< & ) K ^
K B 34 5= 0 &
%
k
T$X'D ;
4 &) T$XXd T gK . T$XXd T g;*& TkDDD T$B `
h*E4 )
3 YS & kDDD 34*K > kDDDB4K
; T$XXc ; T$XXf ;*&
= *> T$XXe * J . =
3 0 *K& u ; (kDD% e F 4
4;*.
B K B ;< ^
]
>)
B (kDD% T F 4 4;*. T$%ff
c
€4 4 1 3 YS &) $X'D ;
4 &0 =
.) 8 A;
@] &
* 3g
>)
=
g*E
. 3 ($%ff T0 5 # . 2
]
@# F 0 B4 35
>
B
g 0 =
. 5 4. &
K>
; *& ;*K . 8 A .) ; & B ;< & ) K ^
B K
(h .
B #4 * ) * O ) * B * g 9 & > @# @
Bj» Z > @ > 9@;
†
] j4E4*& g** 8 A g 0 & B 5 .@ 4&
& ^
4 4 A & 0 *1 F*; g .
4. h . & ;K& « ^
. 5 4. & ;*K . 0 8 A 4
•O& =
0 FA B K
YS &) $XXk g ]E $X'X > T$X'f gx ) B
B5 3 @,& 0
;*K . z ]# B > g# 0 & ($%ff T0 5 # . T2
€4 4 1 3
4& g @# F 0 =
r 4 .@ ;< v ;+ 0 g** & ^
3 )
] j4E4*& Y 4 & ;
^
4
;*K . 0 8 A 5 >
Œ 4#
#
;. 0 & F 8 A
1- Mullis, et al
3- Janson
5- Benbow & Stanly
2- Beaton et al
4- Githua & Mawangi
164
#$''
% &#$
!"
($%fD T0 5 # . T2
€4 4 1 3 YS &) $B4 9
T@
&
^
4
;*K . 0 8 A > w*SO @r Z 3 Y* O & $XXD
E T@ B ;< 3 0 ; & ] B K T > 4P & > @ ; 1 F*; T@ 4& >
;*K . 0 8 A > @ ; 1 F*; 5 .) M> *K& B 5 g*& 8 A B *
) *
0 0 8 A g** €
> ) M> @G B5 ^
4
.@ 5
# &M
^
;*K . 0 8 A g; = > &
& .4 & $XX' kB `
0 8 A &@
;*K . 8 A {4
> ) ; 1 F*; ^
]
0
& &
^ ) *
;*K . 0 8 A 0 . ) K ] j4E4*&
;. Y K @
) K B K B ;< G ; 0 / , . T
j 0 P < g*
& .@
M
*K& h . g*& 8 A *.4
;. ,& & )*K . )IE .
G h . )IE Y& S
)*K .
.) ‚4&
] j4E4*& @ ‰ ; K 0 & 3 & h . > E W T
# 8 A
(TIMSS 1995, 1999 and 2003)
M;
K B 34 5=
`
, 8 A XX Xc ,E (
E g*& v ;+ 8 ,E ( 3 Yr W u ;
{4 F
C
B v ;+ 0 4 C
.) ; *& B ;< ` 3 ^
.)
4
, 8 A kDD% ,E (
$XX' TB `
T$X'c T TkDDD B `
h*E4 )
0 ;
^
`
;*K . 8 A C @
B ($Xff T%g #
= u @ &( * O
@W) 0 @ 234 5 * 0
B 34 5= C
0 ; {4
1
4
: C B ; *& <5 0
8 A Y 9 3 ` @ *1
C & ^ Y† K YW 0 & B ;K& B
1- Hyde, Fennema & Lamon
3- Fennema & Sherman
165
2- Fennema
#$''
‡,& (kDD$ T$ C
$X'f Tk
Y&) @
;*K
3 0 1@!0 4
B K
.) ; & B K 3 3 & ~
B
3
h4
.8
`
0
) @# &
A Y
C @ @S;,
4}
B
% &#$
!"
^
`
;*K .
^ B4 35 0 4 {4
B 5 ($XXD T%g E C F &
;< `
; & B ;<
B 34 5= 0
J & (kDD% T F 4 4;*. 3 YS &$XXf) e ;*&
C
B (TIMSS) c 4
^
E g*& 0 ,E (
@ C)C #
C
0
0 B4 35 0 4
B ;<
* 0 B4 35 0 4
B K
{4
B K B ;<
] 8 A ) ,E ( g .@
C RKC ; &
0 & @†4
@# F ,E (
.)
C 4F;K. B4 35 0 4
& kDDD TB4K
; $XXc T ; ) B ; *&
@;& J @ B 34 5=
@ ! 3 4 {4 **I >
B l4^ & u ; (kDD% T F 4 4;*. 3 YS
u ; )K* ^ ) *
;*K . 8 A ) T~ 3 & 0 4 & 0 1
. ¬G
> 0 4 & 0@†4 4
4
^
E g*& 8 ,E ( @ 0 ; J & @# F 0
&
B ;< ` \ 4; $XXX ,E (
C@
B
* B
(TIMSS)
` \ 4; kDD% ,E (
; C B K ` \ 4; 3 3 & ~
4 kD
$XXX ,E (
Y& S
.)
4& ; *& B K 3 4 kD g*
B ;<
; C B K ` \ 4; 3 0 1 @ ! 4 cX B ;< ` \ 4;
0 K
S B K & 4 cX g*
B ;< ` \ 4; kDD% ,E (
.(kDDd = *C) )
4&
1- Davis & Carr
2- Bell & Hay
3- Bolger & Kellaghan
4- Robitaile
5- Third International Mathematics and Science Study
166
#$''
% &#$
!"
h . g*& 8 A 4. @
41–* 0 B 34 5= 0
@
]
& )*K .
4 — r 24 * B 34 5=
v*,^ ^
]
T24
> ) @# @
* 0 4
=
g* q .(kDDd =
2 1 B K 3 ; & B ;< ^
& * 0 *K& 0 =
8 S*SO g Y& S
& 4< ,E (
J . .@ >
# ^
*K
] @* h .
] g*&
A
4
; g E ) *
, = 4<
* B K & ) K 24 * ; 3 YS & $XXdT J . ) @ 4&
*C) )
4& B K 3 ; & B ;<
]
] ($%'k)
Ar
($%'D) 3 G
.) @#
h.
g*& ` 8 A C
B 0@,& 0 =
8 S*SO
& kDD% T E C 2 ) /
*67
*&
0 *I; 4 F 3 ^
i ;< # N B4q
@ @. 0
N B@# l ( & ($%'% T Ir 4 3 YS
0 (&
` g \ 4 * O `
0 *1 g**
@&
;.
u @ & ) 1 G
& 4 * O ) *
`
& A ;+ 0 *I;
T * O 0@ 5 C 4< , @ 4< B4q
^ 0 *1 & \
M* A < &
234 5 & ‚4& 8 S*SO
0 *I; r & ... 0 *1 2 *
.@#
^ 0 *1
.)
@
4T ^ 0
…kDD% T F 4
* O ) *
0@,& ]
&
@ 4< *67 /E
167
^
4< ^ ) * 0 *1
&\
0 *I;
0 )* & G
8
3 @ *1 8 >
^ 0
4;*.) .) B5 3 B & 8/E
^ & G: T ^
* O 0 @ 4< & ‚
@ 0
N 3
G * O @ 4< @ g J & .)
.
/1
*67 0@,& @ 4< & *
G ]
.3
@ 4<
9@;
] (eXD
*67 @
*67
#$''
=
)
% &#$
!"
@
3 *> @ g .
. )E W * O `
* O
* )
* O @ 4< 4< =
@
) 8
@#
4<
@ >g**, )
* O ) * 8
@# @
)
* O
$
.($%'% T Ir 4 3 YS & $XXf T w* * 2 ) @# &
* O @ 4<
A; u ; )*K . & B5 0 (&
@ 4< 0 * 3
; 1 F 8 S*SO
T ; 1 F @ 4< & )*K . 6 * 3
> S*SO 3 k
.) ;#
^
@ 4< . 3 * O @ 4< r ;< 0 .
> *1
F*;
>0
w*SO
.($%'D T 3M > 3 YS &) 4#
@
;*K . 0 8 A
; (kDD% T F 4 4;*.) @# F * >
^
@ 4< & ‚
@ A; 0
, 4P & ^
@ 4
B
3 Yr W 0 ; .) ; *& B ; *&
B ;< 3 B K ^ 0 @ 4<
R*
& B ;< 4
C
B
B 34 5=
4
,E ( ƒ
%
ƒ C 4 &
;
^ &)K 2 T ^
@ 4< T
0 Y
)K 2
T
T ^
@ 4< R*
&B K 4
234 5
h
@ Cg** g 9 &
#34 5 ƒ C 4 &
;
^
&
.(kDDe = *C) @ # &
^ B4 35
`
.) 0 *1 2 *
^ ) * 0 *1
&
\
M* A
.3
;
23
&T
&2 *
)*K . •O&
B K ? 0 & .@ v ;+ ) * 0 * 3
;K # & \ 0 & K
B ;< @
^
23
* 3 B ;< & ) K 0 9 & ;K # 0 &
g .@
;. 0 )*E , B@ 4< TB &3 0 *1
0 9 & ;K # 0 &
e
T€ ; 3 YS &$XX% B ]
> ) @&
=
•4 & 3 @,& 8 A
1- Marsh & seeshing
3- Attribution
2- Wylie
4- Eccles
168
#$''
% &#$
!"
) g
… < 8 4^4 & 0 * 1 2 *
8 A
g & & .(kDD$
{4 & ;K& 0 =S @
N; @ 5 > 4P & K ;< 34 5= 4(! >
B ; *& { # & ) * 0 *, g; 1 N
& .@
F
4< h .
:kDD$ T€ ; ) @
23 ^
) * & B K 0 3 @ & B ;<
0 /1 6 & @# 4 €
Tv* ] ]
@# €
4 /E T(%X' …
>3
g#
^ 0 *1 2 *
8 ,E ( u ; )K* 2 * &
2 * & ) g]
* O 0 * 3 ;# B 4& R
3 ;*K . 8 >
%
k
$
3 YS & $X'X T g&
$X'd T @ $XXX B
g 1) /1 *67 0 *1
]&
)> # 0 & B 34 5= H +; > @ ;
B
> . (kDDD TeB4K
B
g 1 .)
;K& 8 *^ 3 5 0 /123 & ^ v*E ]
) * 2: 0
, 4P & 0 /123 0 *I; > @ > 2 1($XXX)
J:> = 1 H +;
B ;< 0 & M B K 0 & M
^ J:>
. (kDDD TB4K
]& 3 YS & ) @ > g** ^
& .)
^
`
& /1 *67 0 *I; 3 ` * ^
G ]
*S;K *V M*S;K *67 œ OE & ^
G ]
@# F 8 S*SO & .4
3 ] T /1
* O ]
& *I;
* O @ 4< w P 3 >
Y g .($XXe * J . ) )
^ ) * g**
M Y 4 g M
& *I;
w P 3 M*S;K *V M*S;K 4P & )*K . & ) g]
=* *67 0 & @# F 8 S*SO g* q . / & *67 ^ ) *
& M*S;K
*67
G ]
>@
B 0 *1
234 5
;K
c
˜ #34 5 0 * 1
5 0 1 H ;>
4 & g* F & .
* O ]
1- Green
3- Rothbone
5- Bloom
169
2- Handel
4- Debacker & Nelson
#$''
% &#$
!"
0 ; =+&
& B 1@ *1 0
0 1 ($%d' v* 3 YS &)
0 ; 3 4N .)
> M*KS AP 0
0 1
;< # 0
8 ^ 3 0 *1 0 & > ) B 34 5=
G 0 0 *1 T ;< # 0
& AP 0
0 1 .@ 5 H KW & 0 *1 3 * =* & ? &
*I;
3 .@ >
# @ @. 0 *1
& ) K @ *1 2 *
G:
0 ; T * O ) * & *67 œ OE 3 AP
;< # 0
0 ;
@# F 0 =
.@
* O ) * & *67 g ; *& ;< # 0
0 3 @ g*& > @
B
#34 5 0 *1
& *I; g *67 0 &
D/fD ;K
R ^ T * O ) * 0 3@
;< # 0
0 ;
*.4
* O ) * h
3 * @W ;< # 0 ;
, .
4.
k
0@,& ) * T( G ] ) ;< # 0
0 ; Tg & & (R =D/eX) @ >
) * 0@ B
* 4P & G ] T•G
.@
G *67 )O
Tv* ) )
* O ) * g**
M Y 4 g M 3 ] ) 0@,&
* O
G H F B 4 & AP
;< # 0
0 1 R*C ($%d'
.
& *67 0@,& `
C)
0 *14 T@ ;K & B5 & )*K . & @ G: B
> 0 @ Y]
> )K* 0 *1 3 @ 2
& H +;
T
0
&
@ .)
B5
&@ G
> E4 . 5
4. & w*SO u ; 3 0 *14 B ]
T @ 5 ) & u ; & .4
4 ! w*SO 0 . 0 4*# l P T
0 ; 2 1 *KA 0 4O .@ / & 6 =
0 ; &@ 4
;*K . 0 8 A 34W 8 S*SO 0 ; 3 . 4# 0 *14 ) g] * w*SO
) . 0@ 4# B 4
& S(
w* G 0 g** g; 1 N
B @ & RV
. 4#
A; ;<
K g*& U 0 8 A
170
#$''
% &#$
!"
0
*I;
& & K
;< ^
` 8 A
&
^W =
^ 0 *1 2 * T ^
@ 4<
. 3 ^ 0 *1
& \
*I; g 8 6 8 A C 3 b+
) ;<
^
G `
& .4 & /E .
^
`
K
;< 8 A g**
S !h.
;< ` 8 A w*G
& 0 & T *I;
0N 0 * *
. 3 ^ 0 *1
& \
0 *I; w P 3 ^ ) *
K
) > @# 2: ^
G `
^ 0 *1 2 * T ^
@ 4<
- & ] & g* * g*& 8 A K S & \S
K
;< ^ ) * 8 A
* * J &
@ 8 4r & *K Y* O 2 & 0 *I; @ ! Y* O 8 4r
z@ T @# B 4 RE ( & .4 & . 4# ; 1
& *I;
0N
) * g*&
8 A ! >)
4 g &B ~
^W=
r
B ;< ^
G ]
^ 0 *1 2 * T ^
@ 4<T ^
.@ h .
^ ) *
S ! 8 A g Œ
4. B K
) @#
& > @
)*K . *I; =S 89 4 g & 4 + 0 &
B K B ;< 0 & 0 1 @. 0 @
1@ ! Y* O 3 A; & g* q
g* * 8 A
& 0 & YS;K t B4 35 3 )
.) @# 23 &
.) @# A; ,E ( 4 0 *I;
2
0 5
4
, .
B
#2
234 5 d S( 0 B ; *&
B 34 5=
5 & .4 & .@
Y*]
,E ( 0 5 , . $%'ki'% * O
$'cX) 34 5= %k%D @, 'ki'% * O
d S( 2
234 5
171
#$''
Y* O
S(
g 0 B ; *&
( K 34 5=
% &#$
$%f$
!"
; < 34 5=
.@ >
.@# A; B 1@ C)C # H +; ) . 0 W @ ! 0 *1 4 2 3
; k B ; *&
3 .@# H +;
8 4r & K B ; *& e
%De {4 F
.@ @# H +;
8 4r & 34 5= $X J:>
3
.@ 1 Y* ` B 5 \ 4 N 4 0
@# H +; 34 5=
=
0
&
i'%
M* ^ B O; 3 ^ ) * =F 0 & : ^ ) * (vE
M* ^
.@# A;
^ ) * & B 4 & J @ 'k
0 5• . J @ 3 ^ ) *
B 4 & 8 O; B 3 h B 34 5=
.@#
B4
&
4
8 & \ 4 $X'%
4< 4 A 3 B4KE4*# 2
B 34 5=
^ 8
.@# ; 1 N
^
4< v*r4
K
: ^
G ]
G
=F
]
(H
*,
: ^
@ 4< J *S (o
1@ ! @ J & 2 4* *&
. ) @# ;<
@ 4< J *S .
G N @ @F 4
g $XXD
2
3 F4
4;*. \ 4 ) ; 1 G A;
4 =
g
> ^
Y* O 3 A; & ($XXD @# N @ @F +K ) 2
4< v*r4
4 $k Y #
g .) @# o +;
^ &\
0 Y
F 4 4;*. =
J *S g
K
; .) 8 ]*E J *S
Ž > 0 AE5 3 A; & B5
; ^W=
.) @# 2 1 D/''
172
#$''
% &#$
4 B5 89 4
!"
^
@ 4< J *S 0 . 3 @,& .@ 5 )
.) 1 G
& D/'X & & &
Y* O
&
&) 4;*. F
& 0 ;> E 3 J *S g : ^ 0 *1 2 * J *S (
( 4; B 34 5=
^ 0 *1 2 *
& \
0 Y
& B4
Y # J *S (kDD% T F 4 4;*.) .) @# ; 1 (kDD$
*>J @
k
$
€ T ^ 0 *1 )
T ^ 0 *1
& G: AE4 e
4 k'
%
.)
^ 0 *1 3 ) ^
^
)*S 4
;W
J *S
K
; .) ; 1 G
& 4 g*SSO \ 4 * >
& B5
; ^W=
.) @# 2 1 D/'X F 4 4;*. =
.) @#
O D/Xk & & & Ž > 0 AE5 3 A;
;
@ # >U =*
4& N
4 =
g
>
@ 89 4 & .4 &
8 :P @;& T
Y* O 4N & .@ ; 1 G
& 4 =
0 4
.) @#
5 4 & ‚4&
A*r4
( K ;< ) 4 Y> & ‚4&
A*r4 8 :P T
Y* O
F @;&
.) @# †
)K* . Z*]A & 4 0 & A*r4 0 b< # ($) @.
*, z O
X/ck
$%/k%
%/%%
e/cD
K
g* *
%%/'c
c%/$X
$e/c'
$D/XD
n
$ed
$ed
$ed
$ed
1- Interest in learning
3-Perceived Probability of Success
173
;<
*, z O g* *
$D/f%
$%/ec
e/Dk
c/%e
%k/kf
c$/%X
$c/$c
$D/Xe
*I;
n
$e'
$e'
$e'
$e'
2- Relevance
^
@
4<
^ 0 *1 2 *
^
G ]
^ ) *
#$''
&
4 0
*
^
$
!"
*I; g*& ;K
h
@# 0 5• . 0
& .4 &
.) @# † k @. @#
O
;K R ^
O
4 Y> 0 &
)
% &#$
G
)*K .
]
^
$
iD/$D
D/de**
$
iD/DDe
*I;
;K
0 *1
2*
^
$
D/%e**
D/D'
D/c%**
h
(k)
@.
@ 4<
^
$
**D/'D
D/ee**
D/$D
D/dd**
*I;
^
@ 4<
^ 0 *1 2 *
^
G ]
)*K .
^ ) *
** P<D/D$
;K
*I; 3 Z –* & )*K . *I; T
.@# &
, D/D$ Š(
A; $ * *&
t 23 T 5 & @
w P 3B
*I;
C @# , =
@; ;
5
;K
h
0
;K
*S&
) 2 3
*E
;
; 0 (< T @# @ ;
5&T;
@ *G & *K R ^ h
0 (<
z@ w P E S g
.) @#
O
& /E ) @#
~
r:< 4P & =
.) ; 1 G A;
4 8 *^
J
@
&
,
5 & 4N &
5 & R ^ .@#
;
5 &0 &
) 2
0 *^ &
B4 35 0 & @#
4 0 *I; & )*K . 6
& 4N & =
89 4
z@ w P
˜
& 4 % @.
*I; & )*K . YC M*S;K *V TM*S;K 8 6
&
1- Maximum likelihood
174
#$''
% &#$
!"
8 6 4& *I; 0 *I; @ !
& z@ ` & .4 & ; E @ ; 1 G
=
4 {4^4 & & ) @ 5 @. g
*
@
& *I;
.) ; 1 G
& 4
*I; & )*K . 8 6
*I; YC 8 6 M*S;K *V TM*S;K 8 6 (%)
0 (<
R2
Y> 8 6
8 6
@;
M*S;K *V
M*S;K 8 6
8 6
@#
h
@#
(D/fX)
D/k$
(D/%d)
D/de
@.
@#
@;
@;
i
i
i
^
D/$e**
i
D/$e**
D/ec**
i
D/ec**
D/$k*
D/$$**
D/D$
@ 4< 0
&
)*K . 3
^
^
G ]
0 *1
D/%d**
3
2*
&
)*K . 3
D/%d**
D/'D**
^
D/'D**
^
G ]
3
@ 4< 3
** P<D/D$
T ^
& )*K
)*K .
g* q
175
@ 4< & )*K . *I; @
. M*S;K 6
M*S;K *67
M*S;K 6
)K*
,
.)
, D/D$ 0 (<
M*S;K *V *67 ^ )
B
^ )
^ )
;W &
*
^
% @. C 0 4PB
*
^ 0 *1 2 *
*
^ 0 *1 2 *
^ - @ 4< & (D/$e)
0 *1 2 * & )*K .
#$''
% &#$
!"
(D/Df) )*K . 3
^ 0 *1 2 * & (D/$$) )*K . 3 M*S;K *V *K
;W & ^
@ 4< 3 0 / *67 0 1 ( w P 3 ^ ) * &
6 >) 0 (
*I; ^
@ 4< /E .@ # &
, D/D$ 0 (<
.@ > Y @, ^ ) * & M
^ 0 *1 2 * & M
)*K .
@
B
*I; & )*K . YC M*S;K *V TM*S;K 8 6 K S
&
)*K . *67 g ; *& ^
@ 4< & )*K .
, M*S;K *67 F& C
.@# & M*S;K *V w P 3
*I; &
$ 4
*,; *K
4 (M*S;K 8 6 ) R ^ 5 &
*K R ^ h
0 (< M*S;K 8 6 @. g
@. & .4 &
) @#
5
.)
@ 5 @ *G &
176
#$''
% &#$
!"
/&'
/ (
/
/ ***
- / (
/) **
!
/ **
/( **
/
" # $%
/ +
(B K B ;< ) 4 YC
*K Y* O @ ($)
4
**p<0.01
P-V = 0/8807
177
RMSEA = 0/000
df = 1
*p<0.05
Chi = 0/02
#$''
,E (
4 0
*I;
h.
% &#$
!"
g*& ]
8 A
&
@ z:;<
*K Y* O @ ,E ( 4 0 *I;
h . g*& z:;<
& 0 &
B ;< @
3 Yr W u ; ) @# 23 & M* h . 0 & 1 @.
>0 4
@ z:;< g**, 4N & .) ; 1 G K S 4 B K
Y> 8 6 M*S;K *V TM*S;K 8 6 R ^ g*&
A ! .) @# l ( 3
0 8 A
4 g & 41~ g ^ Œ
4. B K B ;< @
.) @#
& * @ g*& 4.4
0 *I; g*& ;K h
@# † c e @. h
B ;<
)
*
^
$
p<D/D$**
G ]
^
$
D/f'**
@
4
@#
@# 0 5• . 0
O R ^
O
;K
h
*I;
0 *1
2*
^
$
D/e%**
D/cf**
(e)
@.
@ 4<
^
$
D/'k**
D/c%**
D/dd**
) * & 0 9 & ;K
(D/f') ^
GT ]
) * &
;K
g 9 & (D/dd) ^
@ 4<
g*& (D/'k) h
;K
g 9& > @ @
.)
^ )
& .4 &
& 4
.)
*I;
^
^
@ 4<
0 *1 2 *
^
]
^ ) *
B ;< h
B5 3 @,& .
g* q .
*
^
^
^
@ 4<
178
#$''
% &#$
!"
B K @
)
*
G
^
]
*I;
^
;K
0 *1
2*
^
$
D/%%**
$
h
(c)
^
@ 4<
$
$
D/ff**
D/%d**
D/ef**
D/%%**
D/df**
@.
*I;
^
^
0 *1
@ 4<
2*
^
]
^ ) *
**p<D/D$
(D/df) ^
@ 4< B ;<
;K h
z: < & h
g
2 * B ;< @ z:< & g* !M .
^ ) * &
;K g 9 &
.
^ ) * &
;K g 9 & ^
@ 4< 3 @,& ^ 0 *1
g*& (D/ff) h
;K
g 9 & B ;< @ @
@ g
8 :;< 4 & B ~ 0 & .)
^ ) *
^
@ 4<
.) @#
& K S d @.
@ M*S;K 8 6 ;*K .
B K B ;<
(M*S;K 8 6 ) @#
B K @
@
*K R ^ M*S;K 8 6 (d)
@ ; ;
B ;< @
@.
*K
^
D/%%
D/c%
^
D/ff
D/%c
D/dd
iD/DX
@
^ )
) * & ^
179
-/',
D/cX
D/k'
D/XD
@ 4< 0 &
^
G ] 3
0 *1 2 * 0 &
^
@ 4< 3
^ ) * 0 &
^
G ] 3
^
@ 4< 3
^ 0 *1 2 * 3
* & ^
@ 4< M*S;K 6 & ‚4& 8 A g ; *&
@ 4< M*S;K *67 B ;< @
.) B K B ;<
#$''
% &#$
!"
) K 0 04G *< M*S;K 6 > ) D/dd B K @
.) D/k' ^
G ] M*S;K 6
@
8 A g* q .
B ;< @ &
&
G ] M*S;K *67 B ;< @
.)
^ ) * & ^
@ 4< > )A1 B 4
/E .@# & D/%c B K @
D/cX ^ ) *
& M*S;K 6 g ; *& B ;< @
G ]
B K @
^
@ 4< 0 1@ w P >@
B
; g .@
^ ) *
4< 1@ B K @
8
@# 1@ B ;< @
* O
.) M> W
. 4#
K S M*S;K *V 8 6 @
B K B ;<
@#
B K
@
@ ;
@
@
;
B ;<
@
&
8 A &~
0 &f
*I; M*S;K *V 8 6 (f)
@.
@.
*K
^
D/kd**
D/e%**
D/$X**
iD/Df
D/$X**
D/Df
0 *1 2 * 0 &
^
G ] 3
^ ) * 0 &
^
G ] 3
^
@ 4< 3
**p<D/D$
.@ ;K M * # @
M*S;K *V 8 6 > @
B
) *
^ 0 *1 2 *
&
G ] 3 M*S;K
@ 4< M*S;K *V 6 (&
. @
@! 8 A
6 B ;< @ ^ 0 *1 2 * w P 3 0 /1 *67
f @.
&
*V 8 6 - (&
@
^
w P 3 ^
180
#$''
g
% &#$
!"
> .) (iD/Df) A M*S;K *V 6 B K
.@ @# b+
B K B ;<
@#
@;
B K @
2
@
@
@
;
B ;<
Y> 8 6 (')
*I; Y> 8 6 (')
D/%%**
D/c%**
^
^
2
R =D/cX
R =D/df
D/kd**
D/ff**
D/e%**
D/'k**
^
2
R =D/cD
R =D/dX
D/ee**
D/c'**
iD/DX
D/f'**
D/%c**
D/DX
@.
@.
*K
2
R =D/k'
2
&
@;
@
R =D/$$
2
@#
@ (D/Df) ) ? M*S;K *V
.)K*
, @
6
@ 4< 0 &
G ] 3
0 *1 2 * 0
^
G ] 3
^
@ 4< 3
^ )
^
G
^
@
^ 0 *1
&
* 0 &
] 3
4< 3
2* 3
**p<D/D$
g ; *& . 4#
K S
G ]
*I;
Y& S
D/c') ^
^ ) * & @
(D/%% Y& S D/c%)
; *& B K @ ^
0 *1 2 * Y> 8
181
@
@
Y> 8 6 B *
@ 4< Y> 6 B
4< Y> 6 3 T >
G ] Y> 6 B
@ 4< & G
6 - (&
B K
&
K
@
;<
]
B
*I; Y> 8 6 @. g
B K B ;< @
8 A
@
.)
^ - @ 4<
@
^ ) * & (D/%c
@
.) ; *& B ;< @
Y> 6 3 ^
@ 4< &
;< @
8 A .)
#$''
)
A B K
@
) ? B ;<
@
% &#$
>)
^
.)K*
!"
) * & ^
, 8 6g ;E
2 * 3B 0 *I; @# g** h
B *
@
g 9 & ^ ) * B ;< @
.)
^ ) *
^
B * g 9 & ^ 0 *1 2 * B K @
.
@# g**
.
@# g**
23 & 0
5X
@.
B K
B K B ;<
23 &
B K
@
$
$
D/DDeX
D/DX
$
D/d%
D/DD
@
B ;< @ 23 & 4] 0
.) @# † B K B ;<
23 & 0
5 (X)
5 &
23 &
B ;<
8 A
0 *1
h
h
,
@
@.
5
@
$
$
D/DDk%
D/Dk%
$
D/''
D/DD
4P & B K B ;< @
.) @# @
B K B ;<
(GFI) 23 &
4] b< #
(AGFI)23 & @# Y @, b< #
(RMR)g* * @ *G & /.
<
@ 0 35 .
t 23
(PMSA)
>@
@ P 23
B
23 & 0
5
S
>@ 8 A .@ ; 23 &
182
#$''
% &#$
!"
5
@ *K 4 B K B ;< @
M*S;K 8 6 @. & .4 &
@ *G & *K R ^ h
0 (< M*S;K 8 6 @. g
.) @#
.) @ 5
D/%$
D/DX
D/dd
D/%%
D/c%
D/ff
D/fk
B ;<
183
4
*K Y* O @ (k)
4
D/k'
#$''
% &#$
!"
D/cD
˜^
)
*
iD/DX
D/%c
D/e$
˜^
˜^
˜ G `
- *1
2*
D/dd
D/%%
D/ff
˜^
@ 4<
D/'X
B K 4
*K Y* O @ (%)
4
184
#$''
% &#$
!"
g* * z:;<
4 0
*I;
h.
]
8 A
.) @#
& 0 4 & 41~ 0 &
A;
* YS;K t B4 35 3 ,E (
2* T ^
@ 4< 8
g* * K S 0 & YS;K 0
1 t B4 35 u ; ($D)
-�� T ^ 0 *1
�‫�� ﺱ‬
^
)
*
G `
^
0 *1
2*
^
@ 4<
^
@.
0 5 b< #
)*K .
c$/Xe
$D/XD
$c/$c
$e/c'
c$/%X
c%/$X
%f/kf
%'/'c
g* *
g* *
;<
K
kXk
iD/Dd
kXk
i$/%$
kXk
$/$c
kXk
$/%%
df
t
D/Xe
D/$X
D/ke
D/$'
Sig
!
1 g*& @#
O t
S @
;W $Di$ @. J &
*I;
! g & & .) ; *& D/Dc 3 kXk 0 35 - . & ,E ( 4 *I;
^ 0 *1 2 * T ^
G ` T ^
@ 4<)
& 4
. @ 4.
, 8 A K ;< B 34 5= g*& ( ^ ) *
0 *1 F*; •O&
6 C B u ; T C @
,E ( 4 0 *I; & )*K . 6
&
6 )K*
, ^ ) *
^ 0 *1 2 * & )*K . M*S;K
K ;< ^
@ 4< )
, ^
@ 4< & )*K . M*S;K
w P 3 )*K . M*S;K *V 6 @# &
@ 3 8 A; 0
, 4P &
)
, * ^ 2*
^ ) * & ^
@ 4< 0 /1 *67
185
#$''
% &#$
!"
YC 6
^ ) * &
, M*S;K *V 6 C E W )*K . *I;
C @ 5 ) & F*; g )K*
, ^ ) * & B5 M*S;K 8 6
0 *I; * & M*S;K *V w P 3
^ ) * & *67 g ; *& )*K .
.
^
`
&\
h.
] - 4O
@ 8 A
@
z:;<
&
> @ 5 ) & F*; g @
g*& *K R ^
& w P 3 ^ 0 *1
]
TB K @ g* q
h.
0 & > @ z:< & B ;< @
@
B K @
.
^ ) * & M*S;K 6 g ; *& ^
G
) * & M*S;K 6 g ; *& ^
@ 4< h .
0 & > @
=
) (kDDe ) = *C 0 ; & &
4K
; g .
^
^
` h
@ Cg** g 9 & ^
@ 4 *KA B 4 v ;+ — P &
; g
]#5 h .
8 *67 1@*q* *K R ^
@
8 A >@ #&
*I; 3 8 A; 0 *1 6 B K B ;< @
0 *I; 8 A
3
& ^ - @ 4< 3 ; *&
G ]
; @# & @ 4 g
*KA
@
) M> W @ 4< 8
@# 1@ /E T) 04G *K& @ 4<
4< 1@ T) 04G ^ ) * & @ 4< 6 ] & .4 & B K
^
@ 4< 6 M
> @
] .4 Y& G ;] .) M> W @ 4<
*67 1@ /E T) 04G *K& @ 4< & G ]
6M
^ ) * &
6
]
& @ 4< 6 > @
B
; g .) M> W
.
@*>
E ;*K . 8 A g & & .@ # & M
*K& @ 4< & G ]
.4 &) . 6 W g*
3
#41 0
& ) K ] & ; *&
@ 4< =
& 4 ƒ 3 @ & B , 2: /E .@ C @*
( > @ &
0 8
=
&
04 3
4< =
@ w P B 34 5=
^
234 5 g & & @# & z4(, 8
@# @ w P ( * O ) * ) * O
B K 234 5
( ^ ) * O 0 8
=
& @*C @ & B ;< ^
* h . g*& Y> 8 6
& .@# & ^
@ 4< =
& z4(,
8 A B K B ;< @
M*S;K *V 8 6
.@ 5 ) & u ; g*
.@ ;# 0 3 8 A * @
3B 0 *I; g** B * . @ B
@!
h
B * g 9 & ^ 0 *1 2 *
> @ @
B K @
B ;< 0 *1 2 * @#g** h
… ;< 4+&
@# g**
g** h
B * g 9 & ^ ) * B ;< @
.) B K 3 ; C
.) B ;< 3 ; C B K ^ ) * @# g** h
@#
‚ ; g* ! B 4
@
h
g**
*I; 0 K @, & .4 &
) * g**
TB ;< @ & ) K 0 3 Y 4 B K @
> >
@
B B K @
*I; 1@*q* T ; g @ ;K Y*< ^
0 3 Y 4 B ;< @
) @# g** ; C ^ ) * g & &
0 *1 2 * & ^
@ 4< 6 & .4 &) ^ 0 *1 2 * g**
187
#$''
Y* ) ; > B ;< @ 3 B K @ @# g** h
B * Y>
h.
^ ) * & 0 /1 6 Y 4
;*K . 0 8 A 9 ;W
0 ; *& Y 4 B K @
>
)*,G g & # g* q
@
.@ # &˜ 64 3B 0 *I; h
g**
^
@ 4< g*& >
B
,E ( 4 0 *I;
g* * 8 A
J . 0 ; & ; g . @ 4.
, 8 A K
;< B 34 5=
•A & ;*K . 0 8 A 4. &
(kDD%) F 4
4;*. T($XXe) *
0 8 A &
($%'k)
=
0 ; & g* q .@# & 4K B K
&$XXX) 1 J . 0 =
& .@# &
4K B ;< •A & ;*K .
.) 4K
^
@ 4< h . g*& 8 A 4. @ &
( 3 YS
.@ @
, 8 A * K
; J . 0 ; & ; g .@ @
, 8 A K
T($XXe) * J . 0 ; & .@# & 4K ( 3 YS & $XXd J .
0 4 = *> T($XXd) TgK . T($XXd) g;*& T(kDDe kDDD) B `
h*E4
) * B ;< & ) K B K @
B
> ($%'$) 0 * > T($%ff $%fd)
($%'D) 3 G =
& g* q .@# &
4K T@ 0 9 & ^
.@# & 4K B ;< •A & ;*K . 8 A &
($%'k)
188
#$''
K
&
% &#$
!"
; @ ˜ B
;
(kDD%) F 4
4;*. 0 ; & ; g . @ 4.
, 8 A
.@# & 4K K ;
B
& 4 0 *I;
g* * z:;<
&
g
&
. @ 4. ,E ( 4 0 *I;
K
;< g* * g*&
^ ) * - @ >g** 0 *I; > B
*K Y* O 2 & *I;
3 (Y> 8 6 M*S;K *V M*S;K & 8 6
F ) 0 @*q* 4P & @ 4
& )*K . 6 ^
@ 4< > @
B
; g .@ / *67 )*K .
3 # ^
`
h . g*& 8 A @ > Y @, ^ ) *
.@# &
^
@ 4< h . 8 A
B 34 5= ˜^ ) *
8 A > @ C˜ b+ =
g - ;
M*S;K 4P & > )
S;K
3B & 3B 0 *I; 3 # K ;<
h.
/1 *67 Y 4 g* q .@ /1˜ *67 ^ ) * & M*S;K *V
.) 8 A; 0 3 @W h .
^ ) * & Y 4 g *67
'd/Dc/D%
'f/Dd/$X
'f/$D/kk
189
: E S ²*E ²+K )
~
: ES
²+K )
~
: ES 2 / ~
#$''
% &#$
!"
References
^
)
•&
* & ^
.@#
0 *1
# C
@ 4< =S .($%'%)
2*
B
T (B
d S( ) B ; *&
- ,E ( g* 4 0
;
.)*& M* , @]
=
.@#
+# 0
; (B
# >
B
M , )*&
.($%d') >
)T #
.($%ff) 0 4 B W 0 ]
& ^*
.kk )# Z T @;&
^ TIMSS
*I;
&
Tv*
T=
*>
E g*&
0@ 5 > 4< =S .($%'k) 4,K T0 * >
^
TB
T Ir 4
B 34 5=
B
. 15 8
*
#
4
K
;
)
B
4
T 3M >
* & 0@ 5 > 4<
. K 4
Z *
;> : . T)*K . @# .g*& T2 /B 34 TŸ 4 4E41
.J4 SG 8 ; .B
Beaton, A.E., Mullis, I.V.S., Martin, M.O., Gonzalez, E.J., Kelly, D.L., &
Smith, T.A. (1996). Mathematics Achievement in the Middle School
years: IEA's Third International Mathematics and Science Study
(TIMSS). Chestnut Hill, MA: Boston College.
Bell, R.C. & Hay, J.A. (1987). Differences and Biases in English Language
Formats. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 57, 200-212.
Bolger, N. & Kellaghan, T. (1990). Methods of Measurement and Gender
Differences in Scholastic Achievement. Journal of Educational
Measurement, 31, 275-293.
190
#$''
% &#$
!"
Davis, H. & Carr, M. (2001). Gender differences in Mathematics: Strategy,
Use, the Influence of Temperament. Learning and Individual
Differences, 13, 83-95
Debacker, K. Tersa and Nelson, R. Micheal (2000) Motivation to Learn
Mathematics :Differences Related to Gender, Class Type and Ability
.Journal of Educational Research; vol. 93 Issue 4. Pages 245, 10 p.
Fennema, E. (1985). Explaining Sex-related Differences in Mathematics:
Theoretical Models. Educational Studies in Mathematics, 16, 303-312.
Fennema, E., Carpenter, E.T., Jacob, V.R., Frank, M.L., & Levi, L.W. (1998).
A Longitudinal Study of Gender Differences in Young Children’s
Mathematical Thinking. Educationa lResearcher. 27 (5), 6-11.
Fennema, E. & Sherman, J. (1977). Sex Related Differences in Mathematics
Achievement, Spatial Visualization and Social-Cultural Factors.
American Education Research Journal, 14, 51-71.
Janson, S. (1996). The contribution of large-scale assessment Programs to
Research on Gender Differences. Educational Research and Evaluation,
2, 25-49.
Githua, Bernard Nyingi; Mawangi, John Gowland, (2003). Student
Mathematics Self Concept and Motivation to Learn Mathematics:
Relationship and Gender Differences Among Kenya,s Secondary-school
Student in Nairobi and Rift Valley Provines. International Journal of
Educational Development, Vol 23, Issue 5. 487-499
Marsh, Herbert.W and koller. Olaf (2003). Unification of Theoretical Models
of Academic Self Concept /Achievement Relation: Reunification of East
and West German School Systems After the Fall of the Berlin Wall.
Contemporary Educational Psychology, Vol. 29, Issue3. 264-282
Marsh. Herbert. W. and Seeshing. Yeung. A. (1997). Casual Effects of
Academic Self Concept on Academic Achievement Structural Equation
Model of Longitudinal data. University of Western Sydney. Journal of
Educational Psychology. Vol 89. 1941-54
Kiamanesh, A.R. (1997). Mathematics Achievement in the Middle School
Years. Tehran: Institute for Educational Research Publications.
191
#$''
% &#$
!"
Kiamanesh, A.R. (2004). Factors Affecting Iranian Students’ Achievement in
Mathematics. In Proceedings of the IRC-2004 TIMSS (May 11-13, 2004,
Vol. I, pp. 157-169). Nicosia: Cyprus University. Available Online At
http://www.iea-dpc.org/download/ieahq/IRC2004/Kiamanesh.pdf
Kiamanesh, A.R. (2006). Gender Differences in Mathematics Achievement
Among Iranian Eighth Graders in Two Consecutive International Studies
(TIMSS 99 & TIMSS 2003). Paper presented at the IRC-2006, The US,
Washington DC. (November 8-10, 2006). Available online at http://
www.iea..nl/fileadmin/user_upload/IRC2006/IEA_program/TIMSS/Kia
manesh.pdf
Kiamanesh, A.R., & Kheirieh, M. (2001). Trends in Mathematics
Educational Inputs and Outputs in Iran: Findings from the Third
International Mathematics and Science Study and its Repeat. Tehran:
Institute for Educational Research.
Mullis, I.V.S., Martin, M.O., Beaton, A.E., Gonzalez, E.J., Gregory, K.D.,
Garden, R.A., O'Connor, K.M., Chrostowski, S.J., & Smith, T.A. (2000).
TIMSS 1999: International Mathematics Report, finding from IEA's
Report of the Third International Mathematics and Science Study at the
Eight Grades. MA, Boston, TIMSS International Study Center: Boston
College.
Mullis, I.V.S., Martin, M.O., Gonzalez, E.J., & Chrostowski, S.J. (2004).
TIMSS 2003: International Mathematics Report, Finding from IEA's
Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study at the Fourth
and Eight Grades. IEA International Association for the Evaluation of
Educational Achievement. Boston College.
Pajares, Frank and Miller, David. M. (1994). Role of Self-efficacy and Self
Concept Beliefs in Mathematical Problem Solving: A Path Analysis.
Journal of Educational Psychology. Vol 86(2). Pages.193-203
Santrock, John, (2001). Educational Psychology: NewYork. MC Graw-Hill.
192
#$''
% &#$
!"
=>??
& =>
#
!
k
-'E A $ 8"$ -# K )3 O$- ,3 $ 8"$ -# K )3 -
e
,3 `%
# - +"9 Q78
B
M , )*&
B
B
M , )*&
M , )*&
5 & H %
%
- 7> -# L+ )3
1 *
0
^ * ;C
1
;
# o 4 ;C
1 *
3 .. E ;C
1
;
*& 4
;C
0 ;C 04F
; C0
@*`!
4< T .4 0 ;
*N 4<
E , =*& .4 bS 0
&
&
E , =*& :;< & :;
3 0 *1 & & .@ 1 H +; =
(CSI-4) cB C 4C ^ M†: H + ; 4 B 4 & TbS &
0 ;
*N 4< T .4 0 ;
234 5
+& 6
& & ^W =
:C * , 4< # * 0 ;
*N
@;& 4 K B 34 5= . 3
4 - , . B4 &
# .4 bS
*+ - W T0 E & V 2
E , =*& :;< & :; 34 5= eD @,
*N 4<) 1 ! 0
1
@ @#
1- self-regulation of attentional behavior
3- verbal self-instruction
5- Children Pathological Symptoms
2- self-regulation of motivational behavior
4- Attention Deficit/Hyperactivity
Disorder(ADHD)
193
#$''
% &#$
!"
2 3 Tu ; Y* O 0 & .@ @# g . ( ; C
:C * , 4<
@ 5 Y & 0 Y* O u ; .@# A;
` 0 0 *1 3 @ 0 & h
&
, 8 6
.4 0 ;
*N 4< 0
234 5 (vE :@
bS &
E , =*& :;< & :; B 34 5= .4 bS 0
* , 4<
#* 0 ;
*N 4< 0
234 5 (H .
=*& :;< & :; B 34 5=
E , = *& 0
= C &
, 8 6
.@
T #*
0
;
*N 4 < T
g*& 0 ; 89:;< g
c E % @W @O; 89
Y`# .(kDD' TB `
$
u
#*
Y* O
B
= C
.4
T :C
E,
.4 0 ;
*N 4< :0@* C B 1j
. E , =*& T .4 bS T :C * , 4<
3 ` .4 bS &
2 1 J & .)
E4 ) @ ;K A:;
:;< g
E , =*& :;<
4 C ?C B 34 5=
& B 34 5=
@r
@ C Y;+
@
<
C C 8@# & :;< g g
C W @ 4# .) • # ; *& K g*&
:;< g ‰ E V .(kDD' kn *E@ )
.
=S `*; j Y 4 M
(*O Y 4 M :;< g
C ) B5 3
04G M 3 E , =*&/ .4
:;< & ‚
4 G 0 8 ,E (
%
N & .(kDDfTB `
1 &) @ C ) W :;< g 0 *1Y`# ƒ*; j
8 ,E ( u ; .@
:;< g 3 &
.4 Y& G M M (*O Y 4 @
@# & 1 4 < S @E ” 4C Y , T 1 4 < \& {4 C ) B5 3 C W
E , =*&/ .4
:;< 0 B C 4C R V .) ‚
:;< g 8@#
1- Foley
3- Berger
2- Findling
194
#$''
% &#$
!"
@
5 C
3 b<9 & @ 4#
b*+
E fi' g*
0
3 ` .@ 4# `#5
3 *< ) g`
Tg 4. & .@ 4#
:; B C 4C T ;< # 0 B4 35 .@ # & F *
*N 4< ) g` * E
;C W 4< 0 3 & ; C @ 3 * v*E `
E , =*& / .4
:;< &
B 3 4P
.4 yAW & @ 3 * v*E `
g* !M .@ ;K v*,^ ;< #
C@
B
E4P 0 =
.@ ;K v*,^
;K ` v*E ` *N
@r cDi fD0 & E K1 &
E , =*& 0 4 ` T .4 & r 0
@ * @ bS &
E , =*& :;< B 4 & @#
b*+ B C 4C
$
Tg ;
Y ) 4#
I#
* O T AP 0 R* 5 & F
@C
.(kDDf
TJ g & T 3 x& T@ @ 4* {4G & \*O
C q5 ; C
*&=* &
3 u ; g
5 @ 4< & @ 4 0 ; u ;
C C g & ; C g;#
4P & .@* @ 4< ?C @W & T) ? 0 @ * & 0 /1 6 0@ 4 = w P
B *& E , =*&/ .4
- & = 4< 0 N @
C &
q5 C
& @# @ 5
*E 4P & T0 ; 0 3 & (vE :) l # g & ) ;#
@ ;K*
4< & 1 g 3
. ; C C C ! C 4r T@ 5 )
0 bS (o .@ C 3 &
A; 0@# YW
. ; C 0 C C (H
4.4 bS 3 @
E , =*&/ .4
& C
. C C !
4.4
8 4r B5 @& **I @;& bS g q ! @ 4#
# 0 ; 0 3&
F*; 0 ; 0 3 & b S ( .h` & ) @ 4< 4 & *
C C
bS R.4
*N 4< 04 6 b S ( .@ 0@#
`*; j 0 Y
.@ C g**
E , =*& B @& .4 bS {4G @ g ( . 4# 0 3 &
1- Russel & Rostain
195
#$''
% &#$
!"
0 ; 0 3 & B @S *E =S & ($X'$) C & 0 N @
` Š*^4
- &4 & bS g .) @# @*C7 E , =*& / .4
:;< & :; B C 4C
@#
;A1 T0 C N W T *N 4< 0 34W 0
0 bS & 4<
0 @ @ 8:` T 4 6 0 bS 0 ;
. 4#
; @F 0@ &B 3
& F*
;. T * O T ;< # i 0 ; 0 34W B C 4C g B *
T * O ` v,^ T * O 2 * B @S & B 4 B *
C@ 5
4.
T ;+* & Tg* 0@ 5 C 4< T0 # < Tg* hA ) W T0 *1 0
4
T J 4W T0 / ƒ O T
;. Y† K YW 8
B @ S T ;G &
T 4C H 4< - < ! Tv*,^ ;C W
T ; * @#
B &3 T @O .4
$
& $X'$ T C &) 4
# B9 K & v*,^ 8 P
v*,^ F*
;C
k
.($XXk T h 4 TY 4!4 4C 3 YS
B @ ! T@ #4< u ; < & œ OE & P 0 `
& ; 0 0
i ;< # 0 B
& C 2 ;K1 & G: g 3 @ @ •G
G 4
0
.4 bS &
E , =*& :;< & :; B C 4C 4 0 ;
+& 6 & @ 5 Y & 8 S*SO 3 ,* =+&
.)
; =
*<
& B4
B* g
C ) @#
/1 Or 0 ; i ;< # 8:< @
e
%
T(kDD') n *E@ T(kDD$) B `
8 4 T(kDDD) B
@ 8 ,E (
c
C@
B
=
g 3 ƒ u ; .4
# (kDDf) B `
E
T ; 4S 4< T & 3 4< T N 4< g
)O
*N 4< 0
& 234 5
3 .4 Y& G =+& @ G T0
4<
4< ; @ 4< T ; C 4<
/ .4
:; < & :; B C 4C 0
`
E , =*& T .4 0 bS
1- Barkely
3- Vend Walle & Dane
5- Rapport
2- Kratochwill & Morris
4- Daly
196
#$''
% &#$
!"
Tg & : .@# & ;#
T(kDD%) C & T(kDDk) k041ƒ
C ) @# b+ (kDDd) c
0
0 34 5 3 0@
& &
0 ; @ 4#
G T ; 6 4<
4 & &w Pg 3 @ 5
04 & C@
;C
E , =*&
$
(T(kDD%) J \ 4 @ 5 Y & 0 =
ƒ
T(kDD') e ;*
*` T(kDD%) %
E , =*& / .4
:;< & :; B C 4C
& 3 4< T ; 4S 4< T N 4< T *N 4<
; C )O
4< E , =*& 0 ` T .4
.@ 4# Y† * O `
0 g*& \&
;
*N 4< T .4 ;
*N 4< +& 6 - K S ^ W =
E , =*& / .4
:;< 0
& :C ;
* , 4<
#*
($) : 4#
~
3 8 *^ & @ 5 Y & u ; - (
& ) l(
*N 4< T .4
*N 4< 234 5 RE G
#34 5
8:< @ 0@ & C
(k) @ +& 4 &
.4 bS 0
)
G :C * , 4< 2 *
E , = *& 0
4 &
234 5 - 1 0 0@ & C
+& 6
.@# &
64 0
`
2
A;
&F *
- * C 3 4& 8
DSM-IV-TR
d
:;<
1- Das
3- Mc Inemey
5- Wells
197
- 5- 4
, .
=
l P3
0 *^
&) .=
g
w*SO 4 - , . T ,E ( 4 {4^4 & ; .) @#
*+ 0 ”: J & C @;& 4 J:C K B 34 5=
& :; B 34 5= B 4 & B C 4C ^ M†: -
2- McGoey
4- Watkins & Wentzel
6- Diagnostic ˜ - :;< - 5 ˜ *+ and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders
#$''
% &#$
!"
H +; w( ) @ 4& @#
b*+
.4 bS &
E , =*&
3g g
.4 bS &
E , =*& :;< {4*# C 4& g
@;&
l P 1 ;K1 & .4 & .( @
C
3 234 5 g g 3 Y G
wP 3 C @# g & 2: T N 4 0 < @ F
4.4 0 ) @O
3 hx
4# H +; z
& S( ƒ
B; # 2
234 5
3 1 B5 @# H +;
4P &
@ e T @# H +; #34 5 - S(
0
1
C @ @ # H + ; 0 E & V - 4*# & 34 5= $D @,
@
.@ @# g . ; C = 35 1 !
4
)
- *1 3 @ -
&
-”: J & .4 bS &
E , =*& & :; B 34 5= b*+ 0 &
.@ 5 Y & W B 34 5=
B , Tg @E & DSM-IV-TR b*+ 0
^ M†: T .4 bS &
E , =*& :;< & 3 T”: g*
89:;< g • # 0 & 0 E & V & T
g . 4& (B ,
)
g @E )K*E ƒ! Y # @# M*N DSM 0 ”: J & C 4& B C 4C
‚4& B5
$' C )
$$k Y # 0 /1) : )
g .) B ,
8 ,E ( J & B4 35 g
.) .4 bS &
E , =*& :;< &
0
g*& ($%fX) A
.) @# 2 1 R
T 4;O
& ‚4&
H KW T @ 0 < J *S 0
& g* , 0 /1) : )
+K
(WISD-R) B C 4C 0 & KC #4 0 @# N @ @F J *S T0 @ 0
‚4& 0
T ,E ( g
.)
C2 1
,
A
;K
%'e T 353 & w P 3 (g* ,
) .4 bS &
E , =*& :;< &
0
3 *E & 3 T #34 5 i
0 <@
3 Y G .) @# 2 1
C 04O & T@ 5 Y & (B ,
) B C 4C ^ M†:
J & ^
198
#$''
% &#$
!"
T
\< g**,
& . C b+
8:< @ 0 \< T & 3 g u ;
.4 0 ;
*N 4< 0
234 5 B 4 )O #34 5 i
<@
.@* F 4P & K . $DT < @ 3 W g .@#
/1 . - W
&
)*,^ 3 & ƒ K .
8 4r & ; 4* 0 & 3 T8:< @ g 0 ;
M†:
3 A; & .4 bS &
E , =*& :;< ^ 0
#34 5 < @ {4
C ) CU & 39 .@ 5 Y & (B ,
) B C 4C ^
8:< @ 0 . 0 & .@ 1
F 4P & 1
#34 5 0
1
g` T(kDDk) @ & T(kDDk) C & 0 34 5 J & 1 @. #34 5 ;K&
3 `
T
13 ƒ
C R* g & .@# * ($Xf$) $B 41 &
0 & 39 8 ,E ( T8:< @ 0 . 3 Y G .@ C )
4C/ #34 5 0 2
& #34 5 0 ;K& 3 ƒ
; g
.@# F #34 5 0 ;K&
g**,
u ; C @# . 0 A
0
1 0 & AB 0 4 ƒ
35 l P 3 A;
8:< @ 3 ƒ
8
& T 4& #34 5 0 ;K&
+& 6 3 C W Yr W
.@ 4& 6[ E , =*&/ .4
:;< ^ 0
**I
#34 5
. - 4 *#
M†: 3 A; & ;K& 0 *I; & ‚4& 0 3 @
1
& K S ) . B4 35=* 0
@ 5 ) & (B ,
) B C 4C ^
T
4 35 & 0
&
1 .@# 0 5• . 0 * * B4 35 3 h 0
.@ & 4‡W #34 5 8 K . B5 J & @#
4 < J @ 0 *E
‰ @F 4
1 .@* C 4P
#34 5 8:< @ 0 . 8@
) B C 4C ^ M †:
3 A; & ;K& *I; & ‚4& 0 3 @
g* 4 0 & T #34 5 8:< @
3 @,&
! 1 .@ 5 ) & (B ,
4. & 8 **I @ 5 ) & 0 * * B4 35
;K& *I; & ‚4& 0 3 @ &
199
#$''
3
` 234 5 )O *
;C 10
:C
0 <@ & K S
% &#$
!"
;C 10
4 35 <5 1 . 4#
& @5
* , 4< < @ .@ ; 1 G
#34 5 0 2
35 0
10
< @ g 0 /1 *6 3 @# .
. 4& ; *&
;
e/ce
k/dk
$/%e
$/$$
k/kk
k/eD
ke/$
kk/'
k%/%
kc
$%
X/d
$/e%
$/f'
./dd
k/D$
k/e
$/e%
ke/$
k%/f
ke
kc/%
$e/k
X/X
234 5
*N 4<
.4
k/kf
k/fd
k/e
$/e%
$/Dd
$/cd
ke/e
$e/$
$D/'
kc/$
ke/'
ke/%
#
@.
.4
.4
.4
E,
E,
E,
bS
bS
bS
=*&
=*&
=*&
B 3
;K&
*I;
1
b< #
z O
234 5
*N 4<
2*
z O
g* *
z O
*,
z O
g* *
k%/'
ke/'
ke/%
ke/e
ke/k
ke/c
*,
234 5
*,
:C
;C
c/Dd
$/f%
$/%e
$/d
$/k'
$/d$
1 !0
1 *, z O g* * ($)
.4 bS ;K& *I; ) 0 * *
g* *
B4 35 B4 35h TB4 35=*
( E , =*& 0
1 *, z O g* * $ @.
= 35 v ;+ YW
( ;C
B4 35
) v ;+ 0
.@
B
*,
1
g* *
35
*,
1ƒ
B4 35 =*
B4 35 h
0 * * B4 35
B4 35 =*
B4 35 h
0 * * B4 35
Y & 8:< @ B 3 )#/1 6
C 4#
NW: $ @. 0
& .4 &
u ; &)K 0* ! 0 8 A
@ # w*
*I; < &
@5
1 u ; & B4
; g
.)
5 4. & B4 35h B4 35=*
1- Meichenbam & Goodman
200
#$''
% &#$
!"
1 0 5 0 b< # &
g* ! M . 4
# ( .4
*N 4< 234 5)
< @ 8 6 B 3 )#/1 6
C@
B (2 *
*N 4< 234 5)
& )K 0* ! 0 8 A
; w* , E , =*& *I;
@5 Y &
0 **I .4 bS *I;
C @ ! T) @ 5 4. & g* * 0
4 35
2*
*N 4< C ) B5 3 C W 8 **I g .) @ * 4. & J4KO
=* 4# # ) 39 . 4#
E , = *& 0
0 4 & R.4 B 3 /1
4 0
1h
0 & &3 B * P 0 &
i #34 5 8:< @ 0 . 3
@ [ B5 u ; C @# A; (Levene) B4E B4 35 3 ;K& 0 *I;
,E (
. 4& B4 35
h
0 *I; @ ! h
Y* O l P 3 $
#
@# † k
# @. Y* O g u ; .@#
- *^
& ).
A; ( ` 0 0 *1 3 @ )
.)
` 0 0 *1 3 @ 0 & h
Y* O (k)
#
@.
P
F
Ms
df
SS
**I •
i
D/DD$
D/DD$
i
ef/D'
e%/k'
/DD$
/DD$
e%cdc/c$
%$e/%f
i
$%c/'%
$ke/'f
k/''
c'$d%/D%
e$X/fe
$/%%
i
k
d
fk
$
%
%d
$kD
i
kf$/dd
feX/kd
kDf/f%
c'$d%/D%
$kcX/k%
e'/Dd
cX%X$/d'
4 35 B
(B4 35) B4;
(R×C) B4 35 × 1
(C×S/R) (<
4 35 g*&
( 1) ( ($)
(S/R) (<(k)
YC
1
0 0@ & C . 4# ‚ ; Y U
.@ ;#
, *6 T .4 bS 0
201
4 k
# @. 8 . @ & .4 &
8 **I F
i #34 5
#$''
% &#$
!"
#34 5 0 0@ & C B4 35 - 1 0 0@ & C B * Y , g* !M
/E . 5 4. & E , =*&/ .4 ˜
0
, 8 **I ) ;K 4
8 **I
, =S T 6 g l4( 3 ƒ @C C 4# b+ ) 0 ^
.@# ; 1 & 1@ ! 0 K S 2 3 T ; g
.) ;# T @ 5 4. &
, 8 A 0 * * B4 35 B4 35h & B4 35=* g*& C
B u ;
. @ 4.
, 8 A 0 * * B4 35 B4 35h g*& E
4. (p<0/01)
0 *I; {4 ; l4( Y , 0
, …4 < B 4 T%
# @. & .4 &
0
) ;K& *I;
S
**I 3 & (
1 ) 4‡ B4 35 B 3)
. 5 B * & g+
. & ( E , =*& / .4
, Y 4
0
, Š(
t
@ ; 0 (<
g* *
5 & (%)
#
B
@.
(B4 35) $ Y
( 1) k Y
D/DD$
D/ef
D/fk
D/fk
i
eD/c'
D/fk
D/%d
D/%d
i
D/cd
D/'k
D/'k
D/'k
i
k%/'
D/d
D/%
D/%
i
0
D/DD$
D/DD$
D/$
D/DDc
i
ck/ce
i$d/D%
i$/de
ik/XX
i
D/ef
D/ef
D/dd
D/dd
i
ke/'
i$D/f
i$/$
ik/D
i
0
B4 35 =*
Intercept
.4
$
k
%
e
bS
1
1
1
1
B4 35 h
Intercept
.4
$
k
%
e
bS
1
1
1
1
202
#$''
% &#$
!"
(%)
0
t
, Š(
D/DD$
D/DD$
D/cf
D/Df
i
de/Dd
ikc/$d
iD/cc
i$/'d
i
:C
* , 4<=%
#
@. -
@ ; 0 (<
g* *
B
D/%f
D/c%
D/c%
D/c%
i
ke/%
i$%/c
iD/%
i$
i
1 2*
*N 4<=k
(B4 35)$ Y
( 1)kY
0
0 * * B4 35
Intercept
.4
$
k
%
e
1
.4
bS
1
1
1
1
*N 4<=$
; C=e
1
1
B4 35=* )*,^
T ,E (
4 0
1 T 4#
@
C 41B
/1 & T Wg & .@ ;# @ E , =*& / .4
0
0
, 8 A
TB4 35h
C 04O & T) ; **I
G )*,^ TB4 35h & B4 35=* 3
1
E ) ; **I
, 4P & 4
0
1 g* *
T0 * * B4 35 u ; & B4 35h 3 /1 &
P 3 .) @ * 4. & 0 **I
& 4
1 g* * E ) ;
@
, 4P &
1 **I @F
B q
1
)
C @* ) 13 &
, *V B4 35=* )*,^
C3 &
, 8 **I 5 g* *
C B5 B @& T@ @
G & g* * )*,^
.@# &
0 *I; @ ! h
@# † e
#
203
Y* O l P 3 k
#
- *^
&).
@. Y* O g u ; .@# ; 1 & ( ` 0 0 *1 3 @ )
.)
#$''
` 0 0 *1 3 @ 0 & h
% &#$
Y* O (e)
#
!"
@.
P
F
Ms
Df
Ss
**I •
D/DD$
D/DD$
k$fkD/kf
%D'/D
eXf%c/e
fDc/kf
k/kX
$
%
%d
eXf%c/e
k$$c/'k
'k/e%
D/DD$
D/DD$
cDc/%'
$ce/d$
df$/c
kDc/e
$/%k
k
d
fk
$%e%/D$
$k%k/dc
Xc/dd
4 35 g*&
( 1) (
(S/R) (<
4 35 B
(B4 35) B4;
(R×C)B4 35× 1
(C×S/R) (<(k)
: 4#
‚ ;
C F *; @ ! e
@. 8 . @
& .4 &
T E , =* & 0
8 **I F
i #34 5 1 0 0@ & C
0 0@ & C B4 35 1
0 0@ & C g*& Y , g* q .@ ;#
*67
4. & E , =*& 0
, 8 **I ) ;K 4
i #34 5
, =S T 6 g l4( 3 ƒ @C 4# b+ ) 0 ^ /E T 5
& 1@ ! 0 K S 2 3 T ; g
.) ;# T @ 5 4. & 8 **I
8 A 0 * * B4 35 B4 35h & B4 35=* g *& C B u ; .@# ; 1
, 8 A 0 * * B4 35 B4 35h g*& E
4. <0/01(p)
,
. @ 4.
Y Y& S; 8 6 .@ # @
h
Y* O
@.
0 4PB
E , =*& 0
, 8 **I P</D$ Š(
(
1 ) 4‡ ×B4 35)
g *, @ *1 G
& 4
r 8 6 TJ g & .)
5 4. &
, 8 **I 3 & & F
Y g l4( 3 ƒ @C R*C C 4#
.) @# E , =*& 0
204
#$''
% &#$
!"
, Y 4
5 & (c)
@ ; 0 (<
g* *
#
@.
(B4 35)$ Y
( 1)kY
Š(
0 ,
t
D/DD$
D/k$
D/$$
D/k'
i
dk/$X
$/kd
$/dk
$/D'
i
D/%X
D/cc
D/cc
D/cc
i
ke/e
D/f
D/X
D/d
i
0
B4 35=*
Intercept
E , =*&
$ 1
k 1
% 1
e 1
D/DD$
D/%$D
D/$DD
D/DD$
i
cf/Xe
D/%%
i$d/X%
i$'/Xd
i
D/e$
D/cX
D/cX
/cX
i
ke/k
D/d
i$D
i$$/k
i
D/DD$
D/f%
D/DD$
D/DD$
i
dD/Dd
iD/%e
ikc/%
ikc/'
i
D/eD
D/cf
D/cf
D/cf
i
ke/c
iD/k
i$e/d
i$e/X
i
0
B4 35h
Intercept
E , =*&
$ 1
k 1
% 1
e 1
0
0 * * B4 35
Intercept
E , =*&
1
k 1
% 1
e 1
1
205
#*
0
;
*N
4<=k
B
1
.4 0 ;
; C=e 1
*N 4<=$ 1
:C
* , 4<=%
#$''
1
0
8 **I
) 4‡ B4
T
0*,
E , = *& 0
E , = *& 0
% &#$
!"
& 0 @ & C C @ 5 & g* ! h
Y* O u ; 3 {4 F
, *6 TB4 35 1 0 0@ & C & Y ,
i #34 5
35 r 8 6 =S T
, 8 *6 g
.
E , = *& 0
& .)
4&
,
1 ) 4‡ & B4 35 Y , *
1
, 8 **I F
0 * * B4 35 B4 35h 8 6
, 8 **I T B 3 g 3 ƒ
)
4& 3 &
.)
C3 &
0 *1 F*; •O&
bS &
E , =*& & :; B C 4C 8:`
C @ C B *& (kDD%) C &
ƒ & ) g` .4 bS 0
) 0 ; 0 3 & 0 * & 4P & .4
@ 0
8 **I C )# B *& B 4
J g & .@ C 3 &
3 *<7
C ! ˆ)
.4 & 0
& @S (0
`
E , =*&) 0 ; 0 3 &
**I & .4 @ 0
**I :C * , 4< #34 5 0@ & C YG @W
g & .) @# ‚4& (0
`
E , =*&) 0 ; 0 3 & @ 0
g*;K+
.4 bS 0
**I :C * , 4< 0@ & 1
C ,
&
3 8 **I g ` & T) ; * wSO (B4 35h ) 234 5 g 0 & C B 3
0
`
E , =*& 0
39 8 **I C (0 * * B4 35) @ ; 4* {4G
C 4#
@ u ; Y* O
P < g*
& ) ; wSO B4 35 h
bS 0
, *67 B4 35 h
:C * , 4< 234 5 0@ & C
.4 bS 0
0 & 0@ & C g *67 C 4r .) ;# @ .4
0 & 0 @ & C g 8 6 T ; g*
.) @# B
0 * * B4 35
4&
, B4 35h (0
`
E , =*&) 0 ; 0 3 & @ 0
.) @ @ 0 * * B 3 8 6 g
206
#$''
% &#$
!"
bS 0
& #34 5 - 1 0 0@ & C 3 < & 8 6 u ; T
8
&
E , =*&) 0 ; 0 3 & @ 0
**I 3 & C ) B5 3 C W .4
C ! 4# ;
.4 & 0
**I 3 & & ) g` (0
`
T
;
g g*& ‰9 C @
B (kDD%T$XX') C & 8 ,E (
3 wSO N 3
.4 & 0
‰* 6 T
4. %ce @W
;K
&
G )*
- .
0
`
E , =*& 0
&)K
;A1 *N 4< & C
:C * , 4< 234 5 0 *1 C & P < g*
*
.4 @ 0
8 **I T0 * * B4 35 ) ;K 4 4#
;
h
u ; C 41B . 5 4.4&
, **I
G *67 )O
.4
*N 4< 234 5 0@ & C
B $
# =
- *^ …4 <
0
, 8 **I 3 & & 0 * * B4 35 B4 35h
) ;K 4
& ) ;K 4 0@ & C {4 g ! C ) g 4
W . 4# ; .4 bS
234 5 0@ & C C 4 B 4 @ & 4 g ~
Œ 4# ; 0 F*; g* !
& C@Cƒ C
4 35 & ) ;K 4
.4 0 ;
*N 4<
0 1= C 4< T & 3 4< T ; 6 4< T N 4<) *N 4< 0 @
T8 :P ” T8 :P
B ) 8 :P 23 0 @ 5 @ 4;& ( ; 4S 4<
39 z (, @ +& 4 & ( I &
8 :P = 1 B C ; *
Y† )*,G4
~ 0 ^ **I &
5 4. & @ =* 0 ~
&
C Y* K
@&
;*, 4 0
)
T0@ & C g
P 3 .@ 4#
& .) @# ; (
4 35) B & C \ 4 ~ 0 4 E **I 8 ^ ”
3 & 1@ 3 0 )*,G4
~
**I & @G T8 **I g 0 ;
C 04O
04 E vG4
4 35 0@ 4 ) ;K 4 0@ & C g g* q .)
C
, 4 0 ; 0 (< & ) K 5 )* KW @ =
~
@ *
6 `
) .@ 3 &
39 z (, @ =* 0 `
5
207
#$''
% &#$
!"
bS 0
= C
.4 0 ;
*N 4< #34 5 0@ & C
+&
;C W 0 ; & ‚4& 8 C O
;C B & C
4 4 p 3 # T .4
© 4W & 4< .4
4 35 234 5 g C 04O & )
g 3 0 @ g U
@#
3 & 8 :P ;< z4(, {4G W
.@ C A; @ @ 0 ; B Y`# 0 & 8 :P
0@ & C C @# B 4 g* ! $
#=
- *^
& Tg & :
- +K 4#
; .4 bS 0
4 & & .4
*N 4< 234 5
g
C ) ; 1 G @ * 7 4 * g* * 0 =
- (
& 4C/
T(kDDD) B `
J94`* T(kDDk) B `
h 4; 8 ,E ( & B 4 B *
B `
g C 0 T($XX') B `
J4 :; C T(kDD%) B `
0
.4
# (kDDf) B `
E T(kDDd)
- 1
0 0@ & C
+& 6 » …4 <
*^ g*
^W =
, g &)
4& «0
`
E , = *& 0
4 &
#34 5
:C * , 4< 2 *
*N 4< T .4
*N 4< 0 234 5 0@ & C C
B Y* O u ; .@
, *67 T0
`
E , = *& 0
4 &
2*
*N 4<) B5 {4
#34 5 0@ & C {4
B* 3 C
0
`
E , =*& 0
, 8 **I @ ;K 4 ( :C * , 4<
! C ) g* ! u ; g *KA …4 <
=
W .@ 5 4. &
#* 0 ;
*N 4<) B5 {4 T
#34 5 0@ & C {4
B*
0
`
E , =*& 0
, 8 **I ) ;K 4 ( :C * , 4<
T `
;` .) l P Y& G ; ` @ ! 4 g & ~
Œ 5 4. &
, *67
.4 0 ;
*N 4< 234 5 C @
B
Y* O
- N ‰ @F F*; g .) ;# @ 0
`
E , = *& 0
8 **I
208
#$''
% &#$
!"
0 ; 0 3&
:;<
.4
:;<
@. …4 < ($XX') C &
**I
0 C C .4 0 ;
*N 4< C , g & .@ C
@* 7
& g ` & . @ (0
`
E , =*&) 0 ;
0 3& @ 0
.@ **I
Go 5 4
.4 & 0
@4
T #34 5
04 & &
:C
* , 4<
#*
*N 4< 234 5 0@ & C `
0 3 & 0@ 4
**I & * & **I g
4#
;
. 0 C C
. 4#
; 0
C i E , = *& 0
= C & ‰ ;F*; C 4#
;
4# • & :C * , 4<
#*
*N 4< 234 5 0@ & C T
&
; C = 4< 8 F* @ 4;& .4 bS &
E , =*& & :; B C 4C C
g T P 3 @ 4# Y
;
;+* & &
2* - ( & @ C
5 0 @
” O & @ 4;& B C 4C g C 4#
• & 0@ & C
@ 5h 0 @
& = 4< 0 N; 0 = C
@ @& 0 0 = C
.@ 5 0 @ @ 0 ; &
=
&
E , =*& & :; B C 4C C 4#
• & 234 5 g
04 3
T@ 5 0 ) 4S & B@*
B # 4< T
;A1 w P 3 @ 4;& .4 bS
& @# M* z @ J & @ # & g*& •G ~ H +;
@
,
( ; 4S 4<)
0
;K& & ` & @ 5 0 4<
# * )E W F
=
Y
1@ ! 0 l P F & ‰ ;
@
**I
4< # * )E W
#*
*N 4< #34 5 0@ & C Tg & B .@ 4# Y @ @ )*G:<
.4 bS &
E , =*& & :; B C 4C C 4# • & :C * , 4<
w P g 3 @ C 0 3 & @ ‚4& 0 4 0 @ * & C
; 3 & 3 @ 4;&
C @ 34 5
5 T ; g*
.@
& ? C @W & @ 5 0 @ * @ 4;&
T : & .@ C vG4; T 4#
;
A 0 @ * & C 0 ; @ * *
4
03 @ 4 TB5 RE G
C :C * , 4< #34 5 & 0@ & C
209
#$''
& @ 4;&
0
;K&
l PT
& C@ C
g & /1
0@ & C g
TB5 - (
& @ 5
C 4# R.4
@ @& ) . = 4<
@ G 3 0 *1 & T ;
ƒ C
&Y 4
@ 3 x& z@
0 * , & . 3 @ *&
& C 4#
;
*&=* & 3
% &#$
!"
.
G
;A1 0 *1 C &
,E (
; &(
*& 4<) r4 < ;A1 - (
g
.@ C @ 3 B 3 4P
;
g C ! T@ C
A
=S
&
@ 5 & z4(, TB 1 4< ; ) @
w 4, &
/1 3 0 4 < T 0@ 4
:C À 0 *1Y`# & ( :C * , 4<)
r4 < = 4< ; 4#
G
5
. 4# Y 8@ @ & 0 @ * B@
?C @W
*N 4< 0 34 5 =S C 4# ‚ ; g* ! T@# B 4 q 5 & ;
0 ` 0 ;
, = C
:C * , 4<
#* 0 ;
C ) ;A
g
T .4 bS &
E , =*& & :; B C 4C E , =*&
T0 C N W
*N 4< b<9 &
. 0
C C & 0@ & C {4 g
/1 *67
;+* & B F* 2 *
*N 4< 0 ;A1 *N 4<
4#
, )*,G4 & 5 @+ w 4, 0@ 4 T0 /1 6 g ( &
B@# , 6
. 4#
; 0 ; 0 3 & M;K* B@# , & )
& :; B C 4C 0
`
E , =*& B * 3 ; ; T0 ; 0 3 & M;K*
. 4#
; C .4 bS &
E , =*& :;<
E , =*& 0
& #* 0 ;
*N 4< 234 5
+& 6
B* g
C ) ; 1 G A;
4 * g* * 0 =
0
`
$
4
# (kDDk) 041 ƒ T(kDDD) h T(kDD$) 046 8 ,E ( & B 4
0
& :C * , 4< 234 5 C @
B
* g* * 8 ,E ( g & :
1- Hathway
210
#$''
% &#$
8 ,E ( & B 4
T$X'd) B `
T(kDDc)
# (kDDf) g ;
^W =
!"
B * g
C@
C 6 0
`
E , =*&
%
k
& g` T($XXc) @ C T(kDDk) h 4 T($XXX) $
1
c
e
34 T($Xfk T$X'$
4C ! h* 4! (kDDc) B `
f
Y T(kDD') n *E@ T(kDDd) @ T(kDDd) d
C @ ;K F ; @S
# T =
g T4
.@ @# •G @* 7 4 RKC
'f/Dd/Dd
'f/$k/kf
''/D$/%D
1- Graham
3- Kendal
5- Chronis & Chacko
7- Reid
211
: E S - *E - +K )
~
: ES
- +K )
~
: ES 2 / ~
2- Purdic
4- Hoza
6- Sangal
#$''
% &#$
References
= C
Tk $
B
!"
•&
2
# TB ! @* #
=+& 6
K S .($%fX) B `
;*&
R* W T A
4
F TADHD
.kX ce … …
A, Catharin, Dawan, A & Rabbins (2006). Behavioral Model of Impulsivity
in Telation to ADHD: Translation between Clinical and Preclinical
Studies, Clinical Psychological Review, 26, 33-39.
Barkle Y.K.A. (1998). Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder. In E.J. Mash
& R.A. Barkley, (Eds) Treatment of Childhood Disorders, (2n ed). PP.
55-110, NewYork Guilford Press.
Barkely, R.A. (2002). Major Life Activity and Health Out Comes Associated
with ADHD Journal of Clinical Psychiatry, 63, 10-15.
Barkley, R.A. (2003) ADHD in Children, Adolescents and Adults: Diagnosis,
Assessment and Treatment Paper Presented at 5th Annual National
ADHD. Conference, St. Louis, Mo.
Berger, A., Kofman, V., Avishai, U. (2007). Multidisciplinary Perspective on
Attention and the Development of Self-Regulation, Progress in
Neurobiology, Volume 82, Issue, 5, pp 256-86.
Chronis, A. and Chacko, A. (2004). Enhancements to the Behavioral Parent
Training Paradigm for Families of Children with ADHD: Review and
Future Directions. Clinical Child and Family Psychology Review, 7, 127.
Daly, B. Creed, T. Xanthopou, M. and Brown, R. (2007). Psychosocial
Treatments for Children with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder.
Neuropsychology Rew, 17, 73-89.
Das, J.P., (2003). Behavioral Inhibition and Hyperactivity. European of
Special Needs Education, 18, 183,195.
Findling, R. (2008). Evaluation of the Treatment of Attention-Deficit/
Hyperactivity Disorder in Children: A Review, Clinical Therapeutics,
Volume. 30, Number, 50.
212
#$''
% &#$
!"
Foley, M. & et'al. (2008). The Relationship Between Attention Deficit
Hyperactivity Disorder and Child Temperament, Journal of Applied
Developmental Psychology, 29, 157-169.
Hathaway, W.L. (2003). Self-regulation ADHD, and Child Religiousness,
Journal of Psychology & Christianity, 22, 101-114.
Hoza, B., Gerds, A.C., Mrug, S. Hindshaw, S. Bukowski, M. and Gold. J.
(2005). Peer-assessed Outcomes in The Multi-Model Treatment Study of
Children with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder, Journal of
Clinical Child & Adolescent Psychology, 34, 74-86.
Hughes, J.N. (1988). Cognitive-behavior Therapy with Children in School.
Pergamon Books. Inc.
Kendall, P.C., & Panichelli-Mindel, S.M. (1995). Cognitive Behavioral
Therapies with Children and Adolescents. In Behavioral Approaches for
Children and Adolescents, Challenges for Next Century (esl. H.P.J. Van
Bilsen. P.C. Kencloll, & J.H. Slane BURG), pp.1-18,
Kratochwill, T.R., & Morris, R.J. (1992). The Practice of Child Therapy
.NewYork: Academic Press NewYork.
McGoey, K.E. (2002). Early Intervention for Preschool-age Children with
ADHD Journal of Emotional and Behavioral Disorders. (pp.1-22),
Spring.
Mc Inemey, R.J., (2003). Time Reproduction in Children with ADHD:
Motivation Matters. Child Neuropsychology, 9, 91, 108.
Meichenbeum, D. (1986). Cognitive Behavioral Modification. In. F.H.
Kanfer. & A.P. Goldsein (Eds). Helping People Change (3rd ed)
Elmsford. NY: Pergman Press.
Meichenbaum. D.H., & Goodman, J. (1971). Training Impulsive Children to
Talk to Themselves. Journal of Abnormal Psychology.7722, 115-26.
Morein-Zamir, S. & Meiram, N. (2003). Individual Stopping Times and
Cognitive Control: Converging Evidence from a New Stop Signal
Paradigm Quartery Journal of Experimental Psychology, 56(3), 469-490.
Nicholas. J., & Cepecla, M.L. (2000). Task Switching and ADHD. Journal of
Abnormal Child Psychology (pp.1-16).
213
#$''
% &#$
!"
Purdic, N. (2002). Self-regulation, Self-efficacy and Health Behavior Change
in Order Adult, Educational Gerontology, 28, 70-400
Rapport, M.D., & Chung K. (2001). A Conceptual Model of Child
Psychopathology: Implication for Understanding ADHD and Treatment
Efficacy .Journal of Clinical Child Psychology, 34, 48-58.
Reid, R. (2006). Self-Regulated Strategy Development for Written
Expression with Students with Attention Deficit/ Hyperactivity Disorder,
Exceptional Children, Vol. 73, No, 1, pp, 53-68.
Russel, J. and Rostain, L. (2007). Psychosocial Treatments for AttentionDeficit/hyperactivity Disorder in Adults: Current Evidence and Future
Directions, Professional Psychology: Research and Practice, Vol. 38,
No, 4, 338-346.
Sangal, R. and Sangal, M. (2006). Attention- Deficit/ Hyperactivity Disorder:
Use of Cognitive Evoked Potential to Predict Treatment Response,
Clinical Neurophysiology, 117. 96-206.
Stevens, J.Q. Quittner, A.L. (2002). Behavioral Inhibition, Self-Regulation of
Motivation and Working Memory in Children with ADHD.
Developmental Neurophysiology, 21, 117-139.
Vende Walle, Dan (2000). Goal Orientation Why Wanting to Look
Successful Doesn’t Always Lead to Success, Organizational Dynamics,
30, 162-171.
Watkins, D. and Wentzel, K. (2008). Training Boys with ADHD to Work
Collaboratively: Social and Learning Outcomes, Contemporary
Educational Psychology, XXX.
Wender, E.H. (1995). Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder on
Adolescence. Journal of DENESOFMENTAL and Behavioral Pediatrics,
16, 192-195.
Wells, K.C., Chi, T. Hinshaw, S. Epstein, J. Pfiffner. L. and Nebel-Schwa In,
M., (2006). Treatment-related Changes in Objectively Measured
Parenting Behaviors in the Multimodal Treatment Study of Children
with Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder, Journal of Consulting
and Clinical Psychology, 74, 649-65.
Wilens, T.E., (2000). What ADHD Looked Like in Adultd. Attention, 4, 4143.
214
#$''
% &#$
!"
1 4<
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . .
..................................
;K J 5
.......................................................................................................
......... ..................
eD/DDD ;K ²
& XD$k$
ecee @ >
.@*
3 € ;# 8@
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . .
‡
&(
#0 .HK W &
,#
!) 9
4>/ ®
;*&
4< .@# &
;*&
x>
4
@]
gA
€ ;# ²
) @
Z&
Y U J 5 & € ;#
F ;
#
...........................
4
@]
& =* Yr
ˆ
ˆ
:J 5
De$$i%%cdDDX :h> De$$i%%e$$%% :gA c$ddd$effd: ;K @>
[email protected]
215
:Z* ;]E )K
#$''
% &#$
!"
Relationship between Personality Dimensions and Religious
Orientation
* H. Bahrami Ehsan (Ph.D)
** S. Pournaggash Tehrani (Ph.D)
Abstract
The aim of the present study was to determine the relationship
between personality, according to Eysenck's theory, and
different aspects of religious orientation. To do so, Eysenck's
personality questionnaire was administered to 80 randomly
chosen subjects (40 men and 40 women). To determine various
aspects of religious orientation, an author-made questionnaire
was used. Such scale measures 4 different religious orientations
including religiosity, religious disorganization, hedonism and
religious pretentiousness.
The results of the present study showed that there was a
significant difference between men and women in the subscales
of neuroticism and psychoticism and religious disorganization.
Also, an inverse relationship between religious orientation,
psychoticism and neuroticism was observed. Furthermore, our
results showed demographic variables as predictive variables,
along with neuroticism and psychoticism, did not predict
religious orientation. Regression analysis indicated that
psychoticism and neuroticism were negatively related to
religious orientation regardless of the presence of demographic
variables.
Keywords: Personality; Religious Orientation; Psychoticism;
Neuroticism; Religious Disorganization; Religious Pretentiousness.
* Assistant Professor, Department of Psychology University of Tehran.
** Assistant Professor, Department of Psychology University of Tehran.
216
#$''
% &#$
!"
The Effects of the Triple P-positive Parenting Program on 7-10
Years Old Children with Externalized Behaviour Problems
* M. Jalali (M.S)
** E. Pourahmadi (M.S)
*** J. Babapour (Ph.D)
**** M. Ashaeiri (Ph.D)
Abstract
The effects of the triple p-positive parenting program in 7-10 years old
children with externalized behaviour problems was investigated in this
study. Four schools were randomly selected from schools of nahavand
city. 28 mothers whose children had received scores above cut-point
on externalized problems of Child Behavioral Checklist (CBCL) were
selected. Subjects were divided into control and experimental groups.
Experimental group received Triple-p for 8 weeks, single a week
sessions lasted two hours. The results were analyzed using MannWhitney U and indicated that mothers in the experimental group
reported a significant decrease in signs of externalized problems in
comparison with the control group. The results showed that the
mother's training program did have a significant effect on the
reduction of externalized behaviour problems. The emerged findings
can have clinical applications in prevention and treatment of child
behavior disorder.
Keyword: Positive parenting program, Externalized behaviour
problems, CBCL, Children.
*M.S in General Psychology, University of Shahed, Tehran.
** M.S in Child and Adolescent Clinical Psychology, University of Shahid Beheshti, Tehran.
*** Assistant Professor, Departement of Psychology, University of Tabriz, Tabriz.
**** Assistant Professor, Departement of Psychology, University of Shahed, Tehran.
217
#$''
% &#$
!"
The Effect of Reappraisal and Suppression of Negative Emotional
Experience on Frontal EEG Asymmetry according to Neuroticism
and Extraversion Dimensions
* J. Hasani (Ph.D)
** P. Azadfallah(Ph.D)
*** S. Kazem Rasoulzade Tabatabaie(Ph.D)
**** H. Ashayeri (Ph.D)
Abstract
The aim of the current study is to assess the effect of reappraisal and suppression of
negative emotional experiences on regional activity of frontal lobe with regard to
extraversion and neuroticism dimensions. To do so, according to extreme scores in
extraversion and neuroticism dimensions of Persian version of the Eysenck
Personality Questionnaire- Revised (EPQ-R) and inclusion criteria, four groups
including introvert, extravert, neurotic and emotionally stable (each with 20 Ss) were
selected from male student’s population. All participants did have homogeneous
dextrality. In order to assess brain activity in frontal regions during reappraisal and
suppression of negative emotional experiences, participants watched to negative
emotion- eliciting film clips. In reappraisal condition, participants asked to think
about film nonemotionally and in suppression condition, participants asked to behave
in such a way that if a person viewing them could not be able to guess what they are
feeling. During these stages, EEG from different regions of frontal lobe was recorded.
Results indicated that the suppression of negative emotional experiences ultimately
increased right frontal activation; this increment was more in introverts and neurotics
in comparison to extraverts and emotionally stables. Results also showed that the
reappraisal of negative emotional experiences caused the activation of different sites
of frontal lobe with regard to personality dimensions. In general, findings indicate that
neuroticism and extraversion dimensions have a moderator role in brain activity
during emotion regulation strategies and these strategies have different effect on
frontal regional activation. According to findings one might claim that different
emotion regulation strategies on the basis of different personality dimensions and its
following brain activity put forward new perspectives in psychopathology, prevention,
treatment and other research fields.
Keywords: Emotion Regulation, Reappraisal, Suppression, Frontal EEG Asymmetry,
Extraversion, Neuroticism.
* Ph.D Tabriz Modarres University.
** Associate Prof. Tarbiat Modarres University.
*** Associate Prof. Tarbiat Modarres University.
**** Professor Iran University of Medical Sciences.
218
#$''
% &#$
!"
Intelligence and Attachment: Analysis of Affecive / Behavioral
Self-regulation among Bright, Mentally Retarded and Normal
Childern
* Z. Khanjani (Ph.D)
Abstract
The present research investigates the effect of intelligence on affective /
behavioral self-regulation of children. For this aim investigate relationship
between intelligence, attachment with secure and attachment styles (secure,
ambivalence, disorganize / disoriented) and behavioral problems of slight
mentally retarded (IQ=50-70), bright (IQ=125-140), normal children (IQ=95110): Also relationship between kind and styles of attachment with
behavioral problems in three groups was investigated. Samples this study
includes 91 mentally retarded, bright and normal children with age range
between 6-7 years old and of both genders of Tabrize city. Instruments were
separation anxiety test, Achenbach the child behavior ckeck list's (T.R.F),
Raven's progressive matrix test, demographic inventory. Analysed by data
were univariate analysis of variance, LSD follow-up test, T test, and Chi
square test. Results showed mentally retarded children only in self-reliance
sub-scale of separation anxiety test were lower in comparison with bright and
normal children significantly. Mentally retarded were more prone to insecure
attachment in comparison with abnormal and bright children. There are
significant differences between dispersion distributions of mentally retarded
in four attachment styles in comparison with dispersion distribution of
normal children, but there aren't singnificantly differences between
dispersion distribution of normal and bright children in four attachment
styles. Other results showed that mentally retarded are more prone to
behavioral problems in comparison with normal and bright children, but this
relationship is not significant in mentally retarded children. Also there is
highest behavioral problems in ambivalent and avoidant bright and normal
children but There is not significant differences between four of attachment
styles of mentally retarded children on the basis of behavioral problems.
Keyword: Intelligence
Behavioral problems.
mentally retarded, Bright,
* Associate Professor, Department of Psychology, Tabriz University
219
Attachment
styles,
#$''
% &#$
!"
Analysis of Environmental, Personality and Problem
Solving Factors Influencing the Run-Away-Girls
* Z. Golizadeh (Doctoral Student)
** A. Bakhshipour (Ph.D)
*** J. Babapour (Ph.D)
Abstract:
The present research is aimed at studying the effect of
environmental, personality and problem solving Factors on runaway-girls. For this reason 60 young girls in two groups of runaway(30) and normal girls(30) were compared. In these respects
the group of runway girls were selected through sampling form
health house intervention of crisis and foster care. The group of
normal girls were selected through stratified random sampling
from 1St-2nd-3rd- 4th and 5th urban areas of Tabriz. Subjects
completed the researcher- made questionnaires for analyzing
environmental factors, Eysenck Personality Inventory, Cassidy,
and Lang’s Problem solving tests. The results showed that
runway girls did have more psychosis and introversion
characteristics than group of normal girls. The two groups
significants differences in neuroticism dimension. There was
significant difference between two groups on the basis of
problem soving.
Keywords: Introversion-extroversion, Psychosis, Impulse control,
Neurotic, Emotional stability, Problem solving.
* Doctoral Student of Cognitive Neuroscience, Tabriz University.
** Associat Professor, Department of Psychology, Tabriz University
*** Assistant Professor, Department of Psychology, Tabriz University
220
#$''
% &#$
!"
Effect of Non-verbal Motor Imitation on Length of Utterance
of Autistic Children
* S.M. Rafiee (Ph.D)
** M. Bayrami (Ph.D)
*** H. Ashayeri (Ph.D)
**** T. Hashemi (Ph.D)
***** P. Ahmadi (M.D)
Abstract
Objective: This research was aimed to investigate the relation between nonverbal imitation and length of utterance, and effect of non-verbal motor
imitation exercises on length of utterance in autistic children.
Materials & Methods: in the first phase of this comparative research, 22
autistic and 30 normally developed children participated. The sampling
pattern was convenience. We examined and compared length of utterance, in
two groups. In the second phase, which was an experimental - interventional
study with a pretest-posttest and control group design, the autistic group
assigned to two matched groups by balanced randomized method. Then nonverbal motor exercises intervention executed in experimental group for 60
days (one hour a day). Before and after intervention, length of utterance in
the groups, were assessed by action pictures test. Data were analyzed by use
of t- test, regression analysis, and covariance.
Results: Research findings showed statistically significant difference
between autistic group and normal group in length of utterance (p<0.01). In
autistic group, there was a positive correlation between length of utterance
and non-verbal imitation ability (r=0/884). Furthermore findings showed
significant difference in length of utterance between control and experimental
group after intervention (p<0. 01).
Conclusion: this finding reveals that non-verbal motor imitation did have a
positive correlation with length of utterance and non-verbal imitation
exercises increases syntactic ability in autistic children.
Keywords: Autism, Imitation, Length of utterance, Utterance.
[
*Ph.D Tabriz University.
**Assistant Professor, Department of Psychology, Tabriz University.
*** Professor Iran Univetsity of Medical Sciences.
****Assistant Professor Tabriz University.
*****Assistant Professor Azad Eslami University.
221
#$''
% &#$
!"
Compare of Effectiveness of Instructional Design Inspired from
Behaviourism, Cognitive, and Constructivism Theories in Social
Attitudes Change
*S.M. Ghazi Tabatabayee (Ph.D)
**J. Hatami (Ph.D)
***H. Fardanesh (Ph.D)
****A. Majdanian (M.A)
***** Z. Eslami (M.A)
Abstract:
This research shaped in order to compare of effectiveness of three
main learning theories approach on the student’s attitude change in
middle school. This article reports the findings of an experimental
research with pre-test and post-test. Present research is about the all of
the middle schools students in Tehran. The cluster method has been
used to sampling and 12 classes have been selected randomly that
included 306 students. In order to superiority of research aims, one of
the social studies lesson in the text book has been selected and
designed in three different format to instruction. The prepared
instructional programs have been designed computer based. The data
collection has been down through the attitudinal questionnaire and in
order to data analysis used one-way ANOVA and LSD post-hock test.
The findings show that the constructivism based model is significantly
more effective than behaviourism and cognitive models. Also the
behaviourism model and cognitive model have same result, in other
word that’s results are not significant.
Key words: Instructional design, Psychological approach, Attitude
change, Social attitude.
*Associate Professor, University of Tehran.
** Assistant Professor, University of Tabriz.
*** Associate Professor, Tarbiat Modarres University.
**** Master of Art, University of Allame Tabatabaee.
*****Master of Art, University of Tehran.
222
#$''
% &#$
!"
Gender Differences in Variables Related to Students' Math
Performance and the Role of These Variables on Math
Achievement
* A.R. Kiamanesh (Ph.D)
** N. Pourasghar (M.A)
Abstract
In this study the gender differences in variables related to
students' mathematics performance (math self-concept,
motivation to learn mathematic, previous math performance)
and the role of these variables on math achievement of nine
grader students has been investigated. The sample was randomly
selected from nine graders at the district number 6 of the Tehran
city. Data were collected using four different instruments. Data
analysis for girls and boys as well as each gender separately
using Path analysis method shown that for girls' model (in spite
of other two models), the previous math performance has the
most direct effect on math achievement. In the boys' model (the
same as the boys and girls model); math self-concept has the
most direct effect on math achievement.
Keywords: Math self-concept, Motivation to learn mathematic,
Previous math performance, Gender, Math achievement.
* Professor. Tarbiat Moallem University
**
M.A in Psychology
223
#$''
% &#$
!"
The Effectiveness of Third folds Instructional Interventions
(self-Regulation of Attentional Behavior, Self-regulation of
Motivational Behavior and Verbal Self-instruction) on
Attention Deficit and Hyperactivity
[
* A .Moradi (PhD)
** T. Hashemi (PhD)
*** V. Farzad (PhD)
**** M. Beyrami (PhD)
***** H. Keramat
[
Abstract
This study investigated the effect of third fold instructional
interventions (self-regulation of attentional behavior, self-regulation
of motivational behavior and verbal self-instruction) on attention
deficit and hyperactivity symptoms. In this study, semi-experimental a
random sampling procedure was conducted to replace 40 grade 3
students from the city of Tabriz in to four groups.
Instruments included diagnostic interview on the basis of DSM-TR
criteria, Interview with parents and teachers and children pathological
symptoms questionnaire. Data were analyzed through on-way
variance and multi-variable variance procedures. The results revealed
that: a) Instruction of self-regulation of attentional behavior reduced
the attention deficit symptoms of ADHD students b) Instruction of
self-regulation of motivational behavior and verbal self-instruction
strategies reduced the hyperactivity symptoms of the ADHD students.
Keyword: Self-regulation of attentional behavior, Self-Regulation of
Motivational Behavior, Verbal Self-instruction, Attention Deficit and
Hyperactivity.
* Associate Professor Tarbiat Moallem University.
** Assistant Professor Tabriz University.
*** Associate Professor Tarbiat Moallem University.
**** Assistant Professor Tabriz University.
224
#$''
% &#$
!"
Contents
***** Ph.D Student
Relationship between Personality Dimensions and Religious Orientation
H. Bahrami Ehsan (Ph.D); S. Pournaggash Tehrani (Ph.D)
The Effects of the Triple P-positive Parenting Program on Children 7-10
Years Old with Externalized Behaviour Problems
M. Jalali (M.S); E. pourahmadi (M.S); J. Babapour (Ph.D);
M. Shaeiri (Ph.D)
Intelligence and Attachment: Analytic on Self-Regulation of Affective/
Behavioral Bright, Mentally Retarded and Abnormal Children
Zeynab Khanjani (Ph.D)
Analysis of Environmental, Personality and Problem Solving Factors
Influencing the Run-Away-Girls
Z. Golizadeh (); A. Bakhshipour (Ph.D); J. Babapour (Ph.D);
Effect of Non-verbal Motor Imitation on Length of Utterance of Autistic
Children
S.M. Rafiee (Ph.D); M. Bayrami (Ph.D); H. Ashayeri (Ph.D);
T. Hashemi (Ph.D); P. Ahmadi (Ph.D)
Behaviourism, Cognitive, and Constructivism Theories in Social Attitudes
Change
S.M. Ghazi Tabatabayee (Ph.D); J. Hatami (Ph.D); H. Fardanesh(Ph.D)
A. Majdanian (M.A); Z. Eslami (M.A)
The effect of Reappraisal and Suppression of Negative Emotional
Experience on Frontal EEG Asymmetry according to Neuroticism and
Extraversion Dimensions
Jafar Hasani (Ph.D); Parviz Azadfallah(Ph.D);
Seyed Kazem Rasoulzade Tabatabaie(Ph.D); Hasan Ashayeri (M.S)
Gender Differences in Variables Related to Students' Math Performance
and the Role of These Variables on Math Achievement
A.R. Kiamanesh (Ph.D); N. Pourasghar (M.A)
The Effectiveness of Third folds Instructional Interventions (selfRegulation of Attentional Behavior, Self-regulation of Motivational
Behaviors and Verbal Self-instruction) on Attention Deficit and
Hyperactivity
225
#$''
% &#$
!"
A .Moradi (PhD); T. Hashemi (PhD); V. Farzad (PhD)
M. Beyrami (PhD); H. Keramat
226
#$''
% &#$
!"
University of Tabriz
Vol. 4, No. 13, Spring 2009
Founder: Faculty of Education & Psychology
Editorial Manager: M. Bayrami, Ph.D
Editor-in-Chief: A.H.Mehryar, Ph.D
Executive Manager: M. Mahmoud Aliloo, Ph.D
Assistant Editor: J. Babapour, Ph.D
Adminstrative Manager: Y. Nejati
Typeseting: V. Jahedfar
Cover and Text Designer: T.Sadati
Printed by: Tabriz University Press
Address: Journal Office, Faculty of Education & Psychology, University of Tabriz,
Tabriz, Iran
Post Code: 5166614776, Tel: 0411-3341133, Fax: 0411-3356009
Web: www.tabrizu.ac.ir
Editorial Board:
J. Babapour Kheyraddin, Ph.D
P. Azadfallah, Ph.D
M. Bairami, Ph.D
A. Bakhshipour, Ph.D
B. Birashk, Ph.D
J. Ejei, Ph.D
E. Fathiazar, Ph.D
M. T.Garroci, Ph.D
T. Hashemi Nosratabad, Ph.D
S. D. Hosseini-Nasab, Ph.D
P. Kadeevar, Ph.D
Z. Khanjani, Ph.D
M. Khayyer, Ph.D
A. Kiamanesh, Ph.D
M. Mahmoud Aliloo, Ph.D
M. Mehrmohammadi, Ph.D
A. H. Mehryar, Ph.D
A. R. Moradi, Ph.D
R. Roshan, Ph.D
M. Shahrara, Ph.D
E. Shariatmadari, Ph.D
K. Soltanolgoraee, Ph.D
227
#$''
% &#$
!"
University of Tabriz
Vol. 4, No.13, Spring 2009
Relationship between Personality Dimensions and Religious
Orientation
The Effects of the Triple P-positive Parenting Program on Children 7-10
Years Old with Externalized Behaviour Problems
The effect of Reappraisal and Suppression of Negative Emotional
Experience on Frontal EEG Asymmetry according to Neuroticism and
Extraversion Dimensions
Intelligence and Attachment: Analytic on Self-Regulation of Affective/
Behavioral Bright, Mentally Retarded and Abnormal Children
Effect of Non-verbal Motor Imitation on Length of Utterance of
Autistic Children
Behaviourism, Cognitive, and Constructivism Theories in Social Attitudes
Change
Analysis of Environmental, Personality and Problem Solving Factors
Influencing the Run-Away-Girls
Gender Differences in Variables Related to Students' Math
Performance and the Role of These Variables on Math Achievement
The Effectiveness of Third folds Instructional Interventions (selfRegulation of Attentional Behavior, Self-regulation of Motivational
Behaviors and Verbal Self-instruction) on Attention Deficit and
Hyperactivity
228

Journal of Psychology

Transcription

Similar documents

Here

Nielsen BDS‐ Stations Monitored

Pharma Innovation at Korea

here - Bags of Rock

dgiv_edu_program_2008_ 2 _3

Alu-gußgekapselte Schutzkontakt

Mathshammil

akkar 2014 shotgun catalog