docCompare Go Logic
download 
Report Transcription
Compare Go Logic
October 15, 2014 Compare GoLogicXL™ Overview GoLogicXL™ provides advanced logic analyzer features yet… GoLogicXL-36™ is about 1/4 the cost of Tektronix® TLA6401B GoLogicXL-72™ is about 1/4 the cost of Tektronix® TLA6402B GoLogicXL-36™ is about 1/8 the cost of Agilent® 16851A GoLogicXL-72™ is about 1/7 the cost of Agilent® 16852A Laptop/computer not included About the comparison tables ™ The comparison tables illustrate how extremely cost effective the GoLogicXL is compared with Agilent® and Tektronix® logic analyzer products offering similar capabilities. The latest Agilent® and Tektronix® logic analyzer models were chosen to best match the GoLogicXL's features such as channels, sampling rates, sample depths, triggering, and so forth. Flying lead set probes were selected for all logic analyzers in this comparison. Memory options for competitor products were chosen to best match the GoLogicXL's mid memory option. The GoLogicXL large memory upgrade doubles the maximum sample depths for an additional $2,000 US. Agilent® and Tektronix® logic analyzer models are self-contained. The GoLogicXL requires a laptop or desktop ™ computer running Windows 8, 7, or Vista. This computer is not provided by NCI and is not factored into the prices presented in the tables. Competitor product prices are not presented here. Prices and specifications can change without notice, so the values presented here cannot be warranted to be correct. Contact Agilent® and Tektronix® directly for latest prices and specifications on their respective products. NCI® does not market or sell Agilent® or Tektronix® products. All prices are US dollars. Shipping and taxes not included. Prices and specifications are subject to change without notice. ® ™ ® ™ ™ Keysight , Agilent , 16851A , 16852A , and Soft Touch are trademarks or registered trademarks of Agilent Technologies and/or Keysight corporation in the United States and/or other countries. ® ™ ™ ™ Tektronix , TLA6401B , TLA6402B , and MagniVu are trademarks or registered trademarks of Tektronix corporation in the United States and/or other countries. ™ Mictor is a trademark or registered trademark of TE Connectivity / AMP corporation in the United States and/or other countries. ™ ® Windows is a registered trademark of Microsoft Corporation in the United States and other countries. NCI is a registered trademark. ™ ™ ™ ™ ™ ™ GoLogic , GoLogicXL , GoLogicXL-36 , and GoLogicXL-72 , SuperView , and PinPoint are registered trademarks of NCI, Inc. © Copyright NCI. 1992-2015 All rights reserved. ™ Table #1: GoLogicXL-36 October 15, vs.2014 Tektronix® TLA6401B GoLogicXL TLA6401B winner system ($3,900) + 1 lead set ($800) = $4,700 US Contact Tektronix® for current price GoLogicXL is about 1/4 the cost Data channels 36 34 GoLogicXL Max samples all channels 134M 64M GoLogicXL Max samples ½ channels 268M 128M GoLogicXL Price Max samples on 9 chans High speed overlay Normal timing all channels Normal timing max 536M † † † ™ GoLogicXL ™ SuperView 4 GHz; 16K samples MagniVu 25 GHz; 128K samples TLA6401B 1 GHz 1.6 GHz TLA6401B 4 GHz 1.6 GHz GoLogicXL Transitional all channels 500 MHz 1.6 GHz TLA6401B Transitional max 1 GHz 1.6 GHz TLA6401B Differential input mode yes no GoLogicXL Glitch capture yes yes - Max state clock 300 MHz 667 MHz TLA6401B Max clock chans 1 to 8 2 GoLogicXL 2 34 TLA6401B 0V to 3.3V -2V to 4.5V TLA6401B Trigger levels 16 16 - If/Then per level 6 16 TLA6401B Value triggers 16 24 TLA6401B Edge triggers 8 24 TLA6401B Range triggers 8 8 - Glitch triggers yes yes - Setup/Hold triggers no yes TLA6401B Selective storage yes yes - yes yes - yes - Thresholds Threshold range ™ Mictor probes Connectorless probes PinPoint ™ † The GoLogicXL™ mid memory option is used for these comparisons. The large memory option doubles the sample depth. ™ Table #2: GoLogicXL-72 October 15, vs.2014 Tektronix® TLA6402B GoLogicXL TLA6402B winner system ($5,900) + †† 2 lead sets ($1,600) = $7,500 US Contact Tektronix® for current price GoLogicXL is about 1/4 the cost Data channels 72 68 GoLogicXL Max samples all channels 67M 32M GoLogicXL Max samples ½ channels 134M 64M GoLogicXL Max samples ¼ chans 268M - GoLogicXL - GoLogicXL Price Max samples on 9 chans High speed overlay Normal timing all channels Normal timing max † 536M † † † ™ ™ SuperView 4 GHz; 16K samples MagniVu 25 GHz; 128K samples TLA6402B 1 GHz 1.6 GHz TLA6402B 4 GHz 1.6 GHz GoLogicXL Transitional all channels 500 MHz 1.6 GHz TLA6402B Transitional max 1 GHz 1.6 GHz TLA6402B Differential input mode yes no GoLogicXL Glitch capture yes yes - Max state clock 300 MHz 667 MHz TLA6402B Max clock chans 1 to 8 2 GoLogicXL 2 34 TLA6402B 0V to 3.3V -2V to 4.5V TLA6402B Trigger levels 16 16 - If/Then per level 6 16 TLA6402B Value triggers 16 24 TLA6402B Edge triggers 8 24 TLA6402B Range triggers 8 8 - Glitch triggers yes yes - Setup/Hold triggers no yes TLA6402B Selective storage yes yes - yes yes - yes - Thresholds Threshold range ™ Mictor probes Connectorless probes PinPoint ™ † The GoLogicXL™ mid memory option is used for these comparisons. The large memory option doubles the sample depth. †† Each GoLogicXL™ Flying lead set is $800 US. ™ Table #3: GoLogicXL-36 October 15, 2014 vs. Agilent® 16851A GoLogicXL 16851A winner system ($3,900) + 1 lead set ($800) = $4,700 US Contact Agilent® for current price GoLogicXL is about 1/8 the cost Data channels 36 34 GoLogicXL Max samples all channels 134M 128M - Max samples ½ channels 268M 256M - - GoLogicXL SuperView 4 GHz; 16K samples “Timing Zoom” 12.5 GHz; 256K samples 16851A 1 GHz 2.5 GHz 16851A 4 GHz 5 GHz 16851A Transitional all channels 500 MHz 2.5 GHz 16851A Transitional max 1 GHz 5 GHz 16851A Differential input mode yes yes - Glitch capture yes no GoLogicXL Max state clock 300 MHz 350 MHz 16851A Max clock chans 1 to 8 2 GoLogicXL 2 34 16851A 0V to 3.3V -5V to 5V 16851A Trigger levels 16 8 GoLogicXL If/Then per level 6 4 GoLogicXL Value triggers 16 16 - Edge triggers 8 4 GoLogicXL Range triggers 8 8 - Glitch triggers yes no GoLogicXL Setup/Hold triggers no no - Selective storage yes yes - yes yes - Price Max samples on 9 chans High speed overlay Normal timing all channels Normal timing max Thresholds Threshold range ™ Mictor probes Connectorless probes 536M † † † ™ PinPoint ™ Soft Touch ™ † The GoLogicXL™ mid memory option is used for these comparisons. The large memory option doubles the sample depth. - ™ Table #4: GoLogicXL-72 October 15, 2014 vs. Agilent® 16852A GoLogicXL 16852A winner system ($5,900) + †† 2 lead sets ($1,600) = $7,500 US Contact Agilent® for current price GoLogicXL is about 1/7 the cost Data channels 72 68 GoLogicXL Max samples all channels 67M 128M 16852A 256M 16852A - GoLogicXL - GoLogicXL SuperView 4 GHz; 16K samples “Timing Zoom” 12.5 GHz; 256K samples 16852A 1 GHz 2.5 GHz 16852A 4 GHz 5 GHz 16851A 500 MHz 2.5 GHz 16852A 1 GHz 5 GHz 16852A yes yes - yes no GoLogicXL Max state clock 300 MHz 350 MHz 16852A Max clock chans 1 to 8 2 GoLogicXL 2 34 16852A 0V to 3.3V -5V to 5V 16852A Trigger levels 16 8 GoLogicXL If/Then per level 6 4 GoLogicXL Value triggers 16 16 - Edge triggers 8 4 GoLogicXL Range triggers Glitch triggers 8 yes 8 no GoLogicXL Setup/Hold triggers no no - Selective storage yes yes - yes yes - Price Max samples ½ channels Max samples ¼ chans Max samples on 9 chans High speed overlay Normal timing all channels Normal timing max Transitional all channels Transitional max Differential input mode Glitch capture Thresholds Threshold range ™ Mictor probes Connectorless probes † 134M 268M 536M † † † ™ PinPoint ™ Soft Touch ™ † The GoLogicXL™ mid memory option is used for these comparisons. The large memory option doubles the sample depth. †† Each GoLogicXL™ Flying lead set is $800 US. - Glossary October 15, 2014 Normal Timing mode oversamples the input signals similar to how an oscilloscope recreates an analog signal. However, only the logic-levels are captured rather than voltage-levels. Transitional Timing mode is identical to Normal Timing except the logic analyzer stores the input signals to memory only when a change occurs. This eliminates all redundant samples between signal-changes. A timestamp is stored with each sample so the elapsed time between signal-changes is known. High-speed overlay is a relatively narrow burst of high-speed Normal Timing trace captured alongside the main trace capture across all channels. The overlay data provides a relatively small window of higher resolution trace which is centered at the trigger. Differential input mode combines two input signals to produce one signal. This halves the available input channels. For example, the GoLogicXL-72 captures up to 36 signals when differential input mode is active. Unlike Keysight/Agilent and Tektronix analyzers, the GoLogicXL does not require special probes to capture differential signals. Glitch triggers: While running, the logic analyzer triggers if two or more transitions occur on a signal between logic analyzer samples. Channels that detect glitch events can be enabled or disabled. Likewise, the glitch detection can be enabled or disabled on different trigger sequence levels. Glitch capture is a special sampling mode where the logic analyzer marks all glitch events in the trace data. Since glitches are between samples, no pulse is visible in the timing diagrams. Instead, a special mark is drawn on the data to show where the glitch occurred. Setup/Hold triggers allow a setup/hold condition to be specified. While running, the logic analyzer triggers when the setup/hold condition for any channel is violated. Selective storage: While running, each level of the trigger sequence can store all incoming data to memory, store only data that matches certain patterns, or can ignore all incoming data. Flying lead set probe: The most flexible probing option. Individual channels can be connected to a variety of input types. Normally pressed directly onto 25 mm (0.10”) header pins, gripper probes can also be used to attach each input to chip pins or exposed wires. The GoLogicXL standard lead sets are coaxially shielded, have a ground input per each channel, and are color-coded for fast access. Mictor is an acronym for Matched Impedance ConnecTOR. This board-to-board connector was developed by TE Connectivity / AMP corporation in the 1990s. The 38-pin variant of the connector is commonly used by logic analyzers to probe high-speed signals due to its low impedance nature. The pads for the female Mictor connector are included in a device’s printed circuit layout. The female Mictor connector can then be soldered to the device. The NCI Mictor probes are pin-compatible with similar probes from Keysight/Agilent and Tektronix. Connectorless probing is a high-speed, low-capacitive-load system. Two rows of pads are designed into the PCB. Four though-holes around the pads allow a “retention module” to be attached to the PCB when needed. The logic analyzer probe is inserted into the retention module. Tiny springs press probes directly against the pads. The NCI PinPoint™ probes are pin-compatible with similar probes from Keysight/Agilent and Tektronix.
