PDKN\F[GBF

FBG[F \NKDP
OKRCZF \SRM
\ G E F K F KT E P N Z J M [ QG M P
The Rabbinical
Assembly
Schechter Institute
of Jewish Studies
OKN[GZK
E"T[\
A
2005 = F"S[\
\GZGP[ \GKGMHF NM
The Rabbinical Assembly
2014 = E"T[\ :FKKR[ FSVEF
:FXVF
\GEFKF KTEPN ZJM[ QGMP
91160 OKN[GZK ,16080 E"\
074=780=0600 :QGVNJ
02=679=0840 :SYV
[email protected] :KRGZJYNB ZBGE
www.schechter.ac.il :JRZJRKB Z\B
NBZ[KC SVER
965=7105=29=3 C"\SP
OKN[GZK ,P"TC OKEGPKN QG[N :EGPKTG ZGEKS
FBG[F \NKDP N[ GH FZGEFP
\P[R KGNKTN \[EYGP
N"H
DZCENGD ERKYSKH YKRGP CZF
[JRTP ,\ZYGI ,FCZ
\GETGGF KZCI
FNKDPF \ETG
Z"GK ,QKYRKNGD EGE 'VGZV CZF
ZPF QCGBZ 'VGZV CZF
GNZF USGK CZF
ZVGT FKNE 'VGZV
QZCS 'DZG'D Z"E
ZNERK[ ISV Z"E CZF
QBR[ ZGEDKCB 'VGZV
\KDZGJKNF FETGGF
Z"GK ,OKK[ QGKX QC CZF
QPVGF QRIGK Z"E CZF
ZRHKKZ OZCB Z"E CZF
DZCRHGZ KZN ZP
SZKBP NBGK CZF
FBG[F \NKDP \ETG
Z"GK ,QHKKB SMNB ZP
OKK[ QGKX QC CZF
OKMZGT
QKYRKNGD EGE 'VGZV CZF
OKK[ QGKX QC CZF
\KZCTF FZGEFPF LZGT
QKYRKNGD EGE 'VGZV CZF
OKPTJG EGYKR
SGBZJ[ FCGJ \ZCD
OKRKKRTF QMG\
9
13
20
23
\GBGCP
ZPF QCGBZ 'VGZV CZF
QKYRKNGD EGE 'VGZV CZF
OKK[ QGKX QC CZF
\KZCTF FZGEFPN BGCP
25
FBG[F OGK CZTN FNKV\ ZES
29
QBR[ ZGEDKCB 'VGZV \BP FBG[F \NKDP
45
47
52
OKZK[
OG\K [KEY
FGY\F
9
a \GBGCP
F
LZE QGKX BKF "FBG[F \NKDP" N[ ZGBN F\BXG
FR[F IGNC [EGYP OGKM FBG[F OGK \G[Z\[FC
BZYPMG NCB+ OGKM GN KGBZF OGYPF \B SVG\F ,KEGFKF
\SRMC K\#KPTN K\BZY OK[K[F \GR[ UGSC ZCM .[EGY
LKZB\F N[ G\Z[MFN F[GZEF FMBNPC NKI\FN OKRCZF
\SRM \KC NM KEK NT OKPKB\P OKRVGBC ZP[KK[ OGKN FHF
NKM[R BN OB[ F\KF ,F\TM HB K\[GI\ .KEGFK NM KEK NTG
QSKRC H"MC GZPBKK Z[B FBG[F OGKN FNKV\ KTJY ZCIN
OPNGTN GMNK[ ZIBN ZMHKK BN FBG[F OGK ,FR[C FR[ KEP
.FBG[F KPKB \B OZ[CP GHI Z[B OK[RBF
\XGNI NBZ[KC OKRCZF \SRM F\KF OKRGP[F \GR[C
CNG[ Z[B ,"FBG[F OGKN \GNKV\ ZES" [CDN WPBPF
N[ F[EIF FZGEFPF ."K\NKV\ KRBG" ZGEKSC LM ZIB
\NNGM C"FZBC OKRCZF \SRM N[ "OGN[ OK[" ZGEKS
"FBG[F \NKDP" .FH \GNKV\ ZES N[ \RYG\P BSZKD
BZYKK Z[B ,KZCT JSYJ dY@^o#S^a FHF WPBPF \B FPKN[P
,FPXT CZG ZXY JSYJ ,FR[C FR[ KEP FBG[F OGKC
OT N[ KCKJYNGYF QGZMHFP YNIM NCY\FN CKKIG NGMK[
FKF\ ,ZGEN ZGEP ,FR[ ZIB FR[ FNKDPF \BKZY .NBZ[K
ZGSB Z[B OKPGKBF OK[TPF ZMHN KDZGJKNF SKSCF
ORKB FNB OKZXY OKYZV ,QCGPM .ONGTN GIM\[K[
LB ,GVYKF BGNPC ZGVKSF \B ZVSN GETGR BNG OKNDGSP
F\T [K FBG[F OGKN .Z\GKG Z\GK EGPNN QCZEN OKKG[T OF
Z[BC OKEGFKN U\G[PF ,EIB KHMZP JSYJ .GN[P FNKDP
FNKDP .ZGVKSF \IXRF \B Z[VBNG GR\GB EIBN TKKSK ,OF
FBG[F \NKDP
a
10
:OKKEGFKF OKKIF N[ [EIF KGGKXF \B OKKYN GRN TKKS\ GH
GZsCP FHI GNKBM GPXT \B \GBZN CKKI GR\KBP EIB NM
QGGKMP ,"GNKBM" IRGPF NT BGF QBM [DEF .FBG[F \B
\PBC LKB QKCFN NDGSP GRKB ,O[ FKF BN Z[B OEB[
FBG[F \GRCZY OT \GFEHFN OKNDGSP GRB[ \GZPN ,FKF
.ONCSG
QP Z\GKC \YIGZPF \GBKXPC FKFG C"FZBC NED[ OEBM
CKKGIP K\[DZF EKP\[ FECGTC SYGEZVF QP [K ,FBG[F
LMCG ,FVGZKBC GKF[ GNB KKI QKCG KKI QKC FBGG[F LGZTN
.QGJN[N FNT ZNJKF[ FR[C K\ENGR .O\KB \GFEHFN
FKRPZDC OKEGFKF \GVKEZ GNKI\F ZKTX ENK K\KKF[M
TZKB "INGECF NKN" .KPT KRC EDR OKYGI GYYIRG
C"FZBC K\EPN KRB .ZVSF \KCC KE#GPKN \B K\NI\F[M
KENK NT ZSBR[ FT[C ,OKRG[ OKTHDG \G\E KRC OKENK OT
GPYGF[MG OKK\MNPP ZVS K\CC EGPNN FKRPZDC OKEGFKF
GBNMR \GGXPN KTKDF OZJ .OKRG[BZF HGMKZF \GRIP
GXNBR KRPP OKZKTX OKENKG FVGZKBC \GBJKDC OKEGFK
GYRIR OKEGFKG ,QGHP KZGZKV BGXPN FV[B \GPZTC ZGCRN
IZHP KCIZC YRT \GZGC \V[ NT GZGR GB OKHD KB\C \GGPN
OK[R ,OK[RB _ OKK\SF NMF \GGXPN K\TDF[M .FVGZKB
.O\PDGEM FTEK BN \G[GRBF[ OKZVSPC GEP[GF UJG
WGI FBG[C OKVSRF NZGD QKCG KRKC EKZVF BN ZCE OG[
FVGZKB \B CGHTN K\CSG KCS N[ \KNZGDF O\JNIFP
GR\KBP EIB NM .OKZ[TF FBPF \NKI\C C"FZBN ZDFNG
.\BH IGM[N QKB ONGTN ;FBG[F N[ IGMC QCZY FKF
11
a \GBGCP
FNTPG O\B[N GRN F[Y[ \G[DZ GRCZYC \ZZGTP FBG[F
LB ,FRTP \TCG\ FBG[F .QFKNT \GCG[\ GRN QKB[ \GNB[
OG[ QKB LB ,QKCFN OKXGZ GRB .\GRTN EXKM \TEN F[Y
GR\RGPB \B QICPC FEKPTP FBG[F .QKCFN \GZ[VB
QKPC GR\RGPB \B _ FRG[BZCG [BZCG \EC ,OKFNBC
TGEP FNB[C N"HI GJCI\F FR[ 1,500 KRVN .K[GRBF
NT HTGR [ZEPC ?GKIB NCF \B DGZFN QKYN Z[VB\R
\K[BZC) "FPEBF QP KNB OKYTGX LKIB KPE NGY" YGSVF
:FHF N[PF \B KBIGK ZC QGTP[ KCZ TKXP ('K:'E
,LNPF KRVN QK[[GD\PG QKEPGT GKF[ OKJKN\B KR[N
FXZ BN .|OFKRKC EKZVF=~ Q[ZKV LNPF FXZ GNKB
FKFG ,GDZFG GZKCI NT EIB YHI |OEKZVFN=~ Q[ZVN
KRKE [YGCK=~ "BMNP OEY KRKE KTCK" :ZPGBG IGGX
QP KNB OKYTGX LKIB KPE NGY" LM ,|LNPF KRVN
,YCNB=ZGEGBK\ 'EFP ,'E:C"M FCZ \K[BZC) !"FPEBF
(216 'PT
OKFGNBF NB OKYTGX OKEGFK OKRGKNKP F[[ \GNGY
FPPE NGY OB KM FCG[\ GRN QKB LB ,YEXN OKTGG[PG
OKFGNBF QGXZ F\KF FBG[F[ EPNN GB ZPGN GRN NB .FYE
FBG[F[ BN GNKVBG ,GRKNT NKJF OKFGNBF[ [RGT GB
ZXY QPH FPYGF NBZ[K \RKEP[ QGGKMP \YEXGP F\KF
[K LB ,FBG[F KZ\SN FCG[\ GRN QKB[ QM\K .FKZIB
\RP NT ,NMG NMP \GIEN OKCKKI GRB Q\GB[ \GCG[\
\GCG[\ .OKP[ O[ NGNKIG NBZ[K OT EGCM NGNKI TGRPN
BGF OKFGNBF[ \KEGFKF \ZGSPN ZGPD EGDKRC \GEPGT GNB
:N[F T[GFK OFZCB ZKTF[ KVM .YEX CFGBG OGIZ NB
."OKFNBF QGXZN FC OKEDR\P[ FZKHF BKF FKZGJSKFF"
FBG[F \NKDP
a
12
OEBF KRC \B FGGXP OKFGNBF[ OGYPF BKF FKZGJSKFF
.NCF \B IXGZ QKY LB ,OKZIB OEB KRC CGFBN UBG ECMN
LB ,NBF N[ [ZGVPF QGXZN ZGPD EGDKRC BGF FHM IXZ
.\K[VGI FZKIC [K GRNGMN[ FECGTF \B OBG\ BGF
F\B QMG" N"HI G[ZE OKZXPC NBZ[K KRC EGCT[ QKKRTC
FRKM[ ,NGMKCM ,QKECTG[P NBZ[K[ QPH NM BXGP
NBZ[K OT Z[BM YZ NBDR F"CYF ."OFPT \ECTG[P
'EFP ,E"K F[ZV ,BISVE \MSP ,B\NKMP) NBDR
ZPGN GRB OKB[Z LMN FPGEC .(51 'PT ,QKCZ=WKCGZGF
F"CYF ,OKHD KB\G HGMKZ \GRIPN IN[R NBZ[K OT Z[BM[
OT BNG UEZRF N[ GNZGD OT FFEHP OKFGNBF .OPKT FKF
OKNGMK GRB LB ,\GNB[N \GCG[\ GRN QKB[ QM\K .OKVEGZF
.ZGVKSF \B ZVSN
YPGTN KGJKC OKR\GR GRB FBG[F \NKDP N[ ZGBN F\BXGFC
GRB .FPGKBF FBG[C GVSR Z[B GRK\GKIBG GRKIB NT NCB+F
ZP[P NMP ZGP[NG OKPNGTN OZMH \B ZGP[N OKCKKI\P
G\NGED NT HKZMFNG \GKIN LK[PR GRB ."KI NBZ[K OT" NT
.GKKI IZGBG NBZ[K OT N[
ZPF QCGBZ CZF
\KPNGTF OKRCZF \SRM BK[R
D"S[\ INGECF NKN ,OKN[GZK
13
a \GBGCP
F
QC KZGJSKF QGZMH NTC ONGT OT BGF KEGFKF OT
IKXRFN IKNXF EKP\ BGF ,QM NT Z\K .OKR[ KVNB
.OKK\E OKRINGV \ZHTC OKKHMZP OKKZGJSKF OKTGZKB
\YGNI QKKRTC O"GBF \ETG KRVC TKVGF QGKZGD-QC EGE[M
:FNB OKNKP ZPB BGF 1947 WKYC NBZ[K WZB
FKRB [EIF ONGTN FDKNVF FR[ \GBP [GN[M KRVN
\GENG\C NGED TZGBP FH FKF ."ZBGBNVKKP" FP[G
KNDRB [K OB ,\TEN KRB CB\ NCB .FYKZPBG FKNDRB
FPMG .\BH FKRB FDKNVF K\PKB YGKEC TEGKF ,EIB
?FKRB F\GBC GKF OK[RB FPM ...OKTEGK OKBYKZPB
?O\BXC GNMB[ OINF N[ GCKJ FKF FPG
,FR[ \GBP [GN[G OKVNB \[GN[P Z\GK KRVN ,FRFG
.OKZXPP OKEGFKF GBXK ,"ZBGBNVKKP"F \DNVF KRVN
FKSGZCG FYKZPBC UBG { ONGTC KEGFK NMG
:GBXK OGK FHKBC YGKEC TEGK { \KJKKCGSF
OIN FHKB YGKEC OKTEGK ONGMG .QSKRC Z[T-F[KPIC
OKEGFK OKNMGB FHF OGKF ETG .\GXP :OKEGFKF GNMB
{ QSKRC Z[T-F[KPIC GH FXP GNGM ONGTF NMC
OKZVSPG { \GZIB \GXZBCG FKSGZC ,FYKZPBC
B\[F :OKZPBP KR[C |OKI\GV~ OFG OKZXP \BKXKC
FR[N ,BMF B\[F ,QKZGI-KRC FBCF FR[N ,KECT
N[ OCKJ LM .NBZ[K WZBC ,QGKXC ,OKN[GZKC FBCF
\ETG KRVN GPGBR LG\P ,QGKZGD-QC EGE) OKEGFK
,CKCB N\ ,ISV :'C LZM ,OKETGPF ZVS ,FZKYIF
.(256 'PT ,D"N[\
\B OKZMGH GRB ISVF DIC[ [KDEF QGKZGD-QC EGE ,ZPGNM
{ ISV NKN ZES { K\E F[TP \GTXPBC OKZXP \BKXK
FBG[F \NKDP
a
14
FBXG\M .FR[C OTV OKZXP \BKXK \B \GKIFNG ZGMHN KEM
.GRPT \GENG\C \BHF F[ZVC KYC ONGTC KEGFK NM ,LMP
BCC \MSPC GREPN .[EYPF \KC QCZGI KCDN QKEF BGF
:C"T 'S UE BZ\C
GC ZKK[PG EKSC G\KC \B OEB ES :OKPMI GZPB LM
ZCE ZKK[PG FEGTS KMZX NM OEB F[GT ...JTGP ZCE
ZCE \ZKK[PG FKJK[M\ NM F[B F[GT ...JTGP
,KRKPK IM[\ OKN[GZK LIM[B OB" ZPBR[ ...JTGP
\B FNTB BN OB KMKZMHB BN OB KMIN KRG[N YCE\
KBP ...('G='F :H"NY OKNF\) "K\IP[ [BZ NT OKN[GZK
FNYP ZVB FH :YIXK CZ ZPB ?"K\IP[ [BZ NT"
...OKR\I [BZC[
F[TPN GDFR QMG ,LGZT QING[CG O"CPZC FMNFN YSVR QMG
.FNGDF \GNKFYP FCZFC
SGM OKZCG[ GRB FZ[T-TCZBF FBPFP NIF ,QM GPM
[BZ NT OKN[GZK QCZGI \B \GNTFN KEM FVGIN \I\P
KCE OKDFRPG ,E"T F"M ,\KRT\ \GMNF ,GC NM) GR\IP[
.(82 'PT ,DZCRJGZP O"ZFP
\GTXPBC OKZXP \BKXK N[ QGIXRF \B GRZMH ,ZPGNM
[EYPF \KC QCZGI N[ QGN[MF \BG ;K\EF F[TPF
.K\EF F[TPF \GTXPBC
OKMZE [GN[C GZMHR ,GRPT \B GEYV[ \GRGSB ,QMB
:\GKZYKT
ZB[G CBC FT[\ ECNP .ZGCKX \GKRT\ GRTCY ,NM \K[BZ
ZVSC OKZBG\PF [EYPF \KC QCZGIN OKZG[YF \GPGXF
15
a \GBGCP
QKKXN KEM ZGCKX \GKRT\ OD GRTCY ,\KRT\ \MSPCG FKZMH
:\GBPDGE [GN[ KZFG .OKZIB \GRGSB
NBZ[K WZBC FNNGI\R ,749 ZBGRKC 18 ,JC[C D"MC
FDZFG \GCZ OKZT EGSKF ET FSZF[ ,FBZGR FPEB \EKTZ
KNBZ[K WZB ZGEKS N[ FHKRD TJYC .OKCZTG OKEGFK KVNB
:FBCF FYSKVF FTKVGP
,[TZF OGX GFGBZYK NBZ[K WZBN OGX JC[C D"MCG
.OKZT FCZF FRPP GNVRG F[TZ NBZ[K WZB[ OG[P
OKZVGSG OKYKEXG OKEKSIG OKPMI \GCZIF \I\ G\PG
\GNMG OKR\IG OKZGICG OKNNGTG OKYRGKG OKEKPN\G
\PBF QKKE LGZC ZVSP QKBG ZGTK[ QKBN OK[RG OK[RBG
.(340 'PT ,|L"[\~ J"M WKCZ\)
EYGPF NT GNTGF ,(1171 KBPC 26) B"NY\\ QGGKSC 'MC
,\VZXC[ (Blois) [KKGNC ZKTC OKEGFK OKKR[G OK[GN[
QC OKZVB KCZ .FVGZKB \[CKC FRG[BZF ,OE \NKNT NNDC
KDZJF TZGBPF \B ZB\P (CGZKYC 1200=1132) QGCP CYTK
G\GET \B OKKSP BGF ."FZKMH ZVS" GN[ FYKRGZMC FHF
:FBCF FYSKVC
|OKVNB 'E=~ B"E QGKSC OKZ[T ,\C[C KTKCZF
SGRKZG OKF KKBG \VZX \GNKFY NM GFGNCKY ,B"NY\\G
GRKCZ QGBDF \GGXPCG O[VR QGXZP \KRT\G EVS OGKN
OFKNB C\M Z[B |O\ GRKCZ=~ ZKBP 'Z CZF QC CYTK
KRC NMN OGX GTCYN BGF KGBZ KM ,OTKEGFG OKZVS
,OYKIB QC FKNED OGXP ,FHF OGXF FKFK NGEDG ,GRPT
GRKCZ QG[N FH .(I"M:D"M BZYKG) "BGF OKZGVM OGK KM"
,QPZCF P"B) OKEGFKF GNCKY QMG QGMR QMG ,C\M Z[B
.(G"MY 'PT ,G"[\ ,OKN[GZK ,\VZXG HRM[B \GZHD ZVS
FBG[F \NKDP
a
16
QKNGVC NIF [KKGNCC OEF \NKNT KZIB OKR[ 477 YGKEC
KRGKC 10) I"\ \R[ QGGKSC 'MC .FCZFC ZGPI KEGFK QGSB
\B GN[ OKTZGVF OKYHGYFG KYXKRNPI QEDGC GSZF (1648
LNFPC .QKNGVC[ CGZKPRC \D[D[PF \KEGFKF FNKFYF
OKTZGVF \GKVGRM GMK[PF QMP ZIBN[ OK[EGIF \[[
T[VP OKVI OKEGFK 50,000 IGXZNG \GRTN FNBF
.\GKEGFK \GNKFY N[ NGED ZVSP EKP[FNG
FKKBZ ET FKF[ ,(1683 \R[C ZJVR) ZCGRFP TJR Q\R KCZ
ZGBK\F \B GRN ZKB[F ,FNBF \GTZGBPF QP OKCZN
Q+G^K" FRGMPF ,GZVS ."J"\G I"\ \GZKHD" N[ Z\GKC YKGEPF
KNGKC QKNGVC[ CNSHC C\MR ,('D:J"S OKNF\ FBZ) "FNGXP
Q\R KCZ .QMP ZIBN OKR[ [PI FKXRGGC OSZGVG 1648
"\GXZB TCZBE WZB KRGBD" GRYK\ 1650 \R[C[ GRN ZVSP
[EGIC OKZ[T OGKC QKNGV \RKEP NMN ZGCKX \KRT\
,NMN TGEKM CGZPR \GDKZF G[TR[ OGKC GC ,\GZGEN QGKS
NT FDKZFN OPXT GZSP[ FRG[BZ FNKFY F\KF[
Q+G^K) OPE OGYRK O[FG GRN EGPT\ O\GMH .O[F \[GEY
.(78 'PT ,G"M[\ ,CKCB N\ ,QKZVNKKF 'EFP ,FNGXP
QGMPC OKEKPN\G OKZGP N[ FXGCY[ FCKSF \BH ,QMB
.FBG[F OGKC FR[ NM ZGCKX \KRT\ \PKKYP ZJM[
QGDM ,KZCTF FR[F IGNC \GNCB N[ \GVGY\ GRTCY ,\KR[
,(CBC FT[\G HGP\C Z[T FTC[ QKC) "OKZXPF QKC"
.\GTGC[N ISV QKC[ FZKVSF \VGY\G
FMKB \NKDP ,BPDGEN .\GRKYG \GNKDP GRZCKI ,\K[KN[
749 \R[C NGEDF [TZF ;QG[BZ \KC QCZGI \B FIKXRF
\R[C [KGNCC OEF \NKNT ;OKJGKV N[ FZEKSC IXRGF
17
a \GBGCP
CZF TGEKF YSGVF .\GYKRGZMCG OKJGKVC FIXRGF 1171
O[C FNKDP ZCKI ,(1662=1621) L"[F ,QFMF K\C[
\GZHD NT \GRKY QMG ('C='B:'F FKZMH FBZ) "F@V@T \NKDP"
\GRKY Q\GB .1651 \R[C OEZJ[PBC GSVER QFG J"\G I"\
'MC FVGZKB IZHPC GZPBRG \GCZ OKPTV GSVER \GZIBG
.FBG[F ET FR[ \GBP [GN[ L[PC QGKS
IKXRFN \RP NT FNKDP CG\MN GTKXF OKZCIP FPM ,QMB
OKYGYH GRB" :1970 \R[C C\M JSGG QKPKRC .FBG[F \B
NT O[GZ F[TK[ YHIG ZXY GF[P ,FBG[F N[ 'FMKB'N
Yad Vashem News 2,) "EIBM OKRKPBP-BNG OKRKPBP
.(1970, p. 7
NGXKRG KEZI CZ ,NTSPB ZKBP CZF OSZKV ,B"P[\ \R[C
'PT ,B"P[\ HGP\=QGGKS ,D"N) "ZGBPF"C ZPBP ,FBG[
:QTJ GC[ (17
GKF BZGRF QGSBF ZIB FR[ G"N BKF[ G[MT QMN
OKRCZFG OKZ"GPEBF ,OTF K[BZ USB\FN OKMKZX
OGK TGCYNG FXT SMJN ,\GCK[K K[BZ KNGED OT EIKC
NGEDF QCZGIF NT EGVSNG QRGYN ,NCB OGKG \KRT\
,FMKB \NKDP GPM FNKDP QY\NG NBZ[K OTN FZY[
ET \GZGE ZGEN \BH ZGSPNG FH OGKC \BZYR FKF\[
*.LGV[F GRKIB OE OGYRKG GRYEX IK[P BGCK[
CZF KEK NT ZBG\PF LZGXF \B \BNPP "FBG[F \NKDP"
NT FNKDP ZCIN FPN :FNB[F \NB[R NCB .NTSPB
:ZCEC \GCG[\ [GN[ ?G[MT BYGGE FBG[F
'PT ,(B"R[\ WKY) 'D \G[TN \TC KZPBP NT SSGCP N"RF NM *
.54=37
FBG[F \NKDP
a
18
CZF .FKIF \GETF O\KBG OKPNTR OKNGXKRF ,NM \K[BZ
.FBG[ NGXKR BGF ,GRN[ FETGGC ZCI FKF[ ,ZNERK[ ISV
QKKIBG QC BGF { FNKDPF ZCIP { QBR[ ZGEDKCB 'VGZV
KNGXKR N[ Q\I BGF QZCS 'DZG'D Z"E .FBG[ KNGXKR N[
,EIB ZGE EGTC NCB .FBG[ KNGXKR N[ QKKIB KRB .FBG[
.FZY[ FP NT EKTFN OKNGXKR KRCG OKNGXKR GZB[KK BN ZCM
KI Z[Y [K QKKET[M FIXRFF KSGVE \B TGCYN GRKNT
.OKNGXKRN
OB YZ \GEFKC ZMHR KZGJSKF TGZKB ,NKTN ZGPBM ,\KR[
EK" \CIZC \GBG[P [[ \YNEF .K\E QINGVC QDGTP BGF
BKF OBF NCB ,K\GTP[P QINGV BKF OKNGXKR KEK NT "O[G
?OKKIC OKNGXKR EGT QKB[M EPTP YKHI\
QGZMH OGK QMB BGF FBG[F OGK ,NBZ[K \RKEPC[ ZGZC
BGNPC FBG[F OGKN OKSIKK\P FRKEPF KIZHBG ,KPGBN
GKEZF KRZE[ ETG ZVSF \KC KENKP ,NMF .\GRKXZF
EIGKPC OKTSGR OKCZG ,FBG[F NT OKZCEP ,FKHKGNJFG
OKDFRPF NM JTPM NCB .OKZIB OKRGBKHGPNG "O[G EK"N
NBZ[KC FBG[F OGK .KPGBN GB KRGNKI KVGB OKB[GR FNBF
EEGP\FN KRKXZ QGKSKR OG[ OK[GT QKB .K\E EPKP NM ZSI
Z\K .FNTP FBG[F[ \GKDGNGBK\FG \GK\EF \GNB[F OT
OG[ QKBG OKEIGKP OKK\E OKSYJ OG[ OKPKKYP QKB ,QM NT
,\KDZGJKNG \K\E FRKICP ,ZPGNM .OGKF \GNKV\N \VSG\
."NKDZM OKYST" N[ OGK BGF NBZ[KC FBG[F OGK
GTP[ BN FNGDC OKCZ OKEGFK .Z\GK UB TGZD FNGDC CXPF
ORKB \GCKGIP KNTC OKEGFK GNKVBG ,FBG[F OGK NT ONGTP
.ZIB OGK NMC Z[BP \ZIB GC OKDFGR
19
a \GBGCP
N[ \ZCGDG \MNGF FTVG\N GRKPKC OKET GRB ,\K[KN[
GRKNT \NJGP LMKVNG .FBG[F KVNSP N[G FBG[F K[KIMP
NT GNGM ONGTF \BG GRKENK \B LRIN F[YF FPK[PF
.\G[GRBF \GENG\ NMC G\PDGEM FKF BN[ TGZKB ,FBG[F
LZEM NBZ[K NNM KEK NT NCY\\ \BH FNKDP[ OKGGYP GRB
,\GZGE KZGEN FBG[F ZMH \B IKXRFN \K\GTP[P \K\E
\BG EIB EXP OKZXP \BKXK \B IKXRFN GRINXF[ O[M
GRC OKKGYK ,IKNXR OBG .KR[ EXP [EYPF \KC QCZGI
,FIM[FP FM[PR FNGDF" :J"[TCN SIGKPF OD\VF
."FNGBDF EGS FZKMHCG
QKYRKNGD EGE CZF
\GEFKF KTEPN ZJM[ QGMP BK[R
D"S[\ INGECF NKN ,OKN[GZK
FBG[F \NKDP
a
20
B
LB ,\T NMCG OEB NMN EKIVP ZCE BGF QGZMH EGCK
QGZMH EGCKB ,GRRPH N[ OKEGFKN EIGKPC ,OKEGFKN
NNMCG ,ZGMHN FP FCZF GRN [K .Z\GK EGT EKIVP ZCE BGF
OK[[GI GRB .IGM[N UKETP FKF ONGTF[ \GRGZMH OD FH
GZKMHK[ FBG[ KNGXKR \GIV [K FR[ NMC[ FECGTF IMGRN
.FHN FH NNGTN OKNDGSP OEB KRC FPG ,FZY FP ONGTNG GRN
KNGNKB ONGTF QGZMHP GIPKK[ \GP[ KRGKNKPN OKEZI GRB
UGS ET GECM\KG GZMHKK OF[ IKJCFN GRN[ TEGPF WPBPF
.\GZGEF NM
ZGEN OKZCTGPF OEGYF ZGEF N[ \GRGZMHF[ OKTEGK GRB
N[ EF BNB OF QKB .ZSIC OKKGYN ,CGJF FZYPC ,BCF
GH FCKSP BYGGE .OKBR\FG \G[DZF ,OKRPHF ,\GTZGBPF
OKETN GR\NGMK CJKPM CK[YFN EIGKP WPBP \G[TN GRKNT
[ZEKR GRB BCF ZGEC[ QGGKMP ,GRN GPEY[ \GTZGBPN
GB EIB ZGE YIZPC { GRN[ \GETF ."ET KVP ET" \GKFN
EK\TF \B TGCYN TKKS\ { OPXT \GTZGBPFP OKKR[
.KEGFKF
LZGBN QGZMHF LKNF\ \B [CDN TKKS KEGFKF FR[F IGN
\GR[ \B GRN ZKMHP \GMGSF DI .GRN[ FMGZBF FKZGJSKFF
\GTXPBC OKZMGH GRB[ OKZXP \BKXK ZIBN ZCEPC GRKEGER
DI .KRKS ZFC FZG\ Q\P GRN ZKMHP \GTGC[F DI .ISVF DI
OKRGGKK\PF NT OKCYPF QGIXR \B GRN ZKMHP FMGRIF
GRPT \NXF \B OKZGVF DIG ,\KRGGKF=\KZGSF FKZVPKBFG
21
a \GBGCP
FR[F IGNC OGX KPK .FYK\TF SZVC \T[GZP FPKHPP
.KR[ \KCG QG[BZ \KC QCZGIC OKRG[ OKCN[ GRN OKZKMHP
QGGKMP .K\EF ZG[KPC F[Y ZD\B BGF FBG[F QGZMH ,OZC
EBP OKYGIZ GRB ,TZKB[ FPN \KSIK LM NM OKCGZY GRB[
ZMH \B SKRMFN EXKM FNB[C \KPGBN OKTE \GPKP\P
.K\E Z[YFN OKRGKNKPF \[[
FNKFYF KECMRP { QHKKB SMNB ZP FNTF OKR[ FPM KRVN
{ FBG[ NGXKRG ,K\NKFYC NKTV ZCI ,GJRGZGJC \KEGFKF
GPM YGKEC FBG[F OGKC BZYK\[ FNKDP ZCIN QGKTZF \B
Z\SB \NKDPG CBC FT[\C FMKB \NKDP \B OKBZGY[
OGKN FCKYT F[KDC LZGXC ,YEXC ,[I BGF .OKZGVC
OGKN Q\K\ FBG[F OGKC ZGCKXC BZYK\[ FNKDP[G ,FBG[F
Z\GKG OKEGFK Z\GK KEK NT G\ZKP[N NKCG\G ,EIBP FRCP
.\KRIGZG \KRKXZ FZGXC \GKEGFK \GNKFY
BK[RN QHKKB ZP \TXF \B K\BCF ,QMP ZIBN ZXY QPH
CZN B"NECKG ,N"H DGZ\B ZGPKS CZF ,HBE OKRCZF \SRM
OFKR[G ,\KPNGTF OKRCZF \SRM N"MRP ,SZKKBP NBGK
ZCIP \B BGXPN YZ Z\GR .NTVPF \B OGIC GXPKB
,QKYRKNGD EGE CZF .KZYP IZGBC QPEHR QGZ\VFG FNKDPF
OKR[ QFMP ,OKN[GZKC \GEFKF KTEPN ZJM[ QGMP BK[R
,OT \KC = NBZ[K KRC = EGE \KC ,K\NKFYC IZGB CZM \GCZ
QHKKB ZP .QHKKB ZP N[ G\KCC IZB\P FKFG ,OKBZGRF OKPKC
QGKTZN OKMSF[ ,QKYRKNGD CZF KRVN GRGKTZ \B FNTF
OKN[GZKC ZJM[ QGMP LVF LMP FBXG\MG ,\GCFN\FC
CZF N[ G\KKIRFC .OKRCZF \SRM OT NTVPC NKTV U\G[N
'VGZV N[ \ICG[PF \KZCTC FNKDPF FC\MR QKYRKNGD
FBG[F \NKDP
a
22
CZF KEK NT OTJ CGJC \KNDRBN FPDZG\G ,QBR[ ZGEDKCB
EGYKRF \B FFKDF SGBZJ[ FCGJ \ZCD .GNZF USGK
"OKEGPKN QG[N"P NYRKV KRE ZPG ,BZYP KPTJ FVKSGFG
.SGVEF \KCN FBKCFG \ZCGIF \B EPKTG ZEKS
GKXPBP BNPNB ZGBN \BXGK F\KF BN FBG[F \NKDP
OKCB[PF SGKDN QHKKB SMNB ZP N[ OKBNR K\NCF
.GJRGZGJP OKCZ OKPZG\ N[ O\GCKERG OK[GZEF
FZGXC \SRMF \KCN SRMKFN CKKI OKRGKNKPF \[[ ZMH
KEP BZYK\ FBG[F \NKDP[ OKGGYP GRB .FCKYTG \ZEGSP
.ONGTF KCIZC \GKEGFK \GNKFYCG \SRM K\CC FR[
OKNGMK GRB ,YK\TFG KEKKPF ,QGZMHF \KKZNYVSBN ETCP
Q\K KP .OKKI TVG[ KEGFK EK\T ZD\BN CGJ Z\GK QRGM\FN
.ZIPF ONGTN FNB \GRGZMH ZKCTFN OKKGBZ FKFRG
O KK[ Q G KX Q C C Z F
FERY ,GJRGZGJ
D"S[\ INGECF NKN
23
a \GBGCP
\KZCTF FZGEFPN BGCP
\SSGCP ,\KZCTF \ZFJ NT ,FBG[F \NKDP N[ GH FZGEFP
OKR[C KNDRB-KZCT ISGRC ZGBN GBXK[ \GZGEFPF K\[ NT
N[ FCKER FPGZ\ \ZHTC FTKVGP GH FZGEFP .2004=2003
CZYP LM NT OFN OKEGP GRB .G\IV[P KRCG ZKBP EGE CZF
EGYKRC GNVR[ \GKGTJ FRYK\ SGBZJ[ FCGJ \ZCD .CN
NKD Z"E CZFG \GRG[BZF \GZGEFPF K\[ N[ OKPTJCG
N[G ZPF CZF N[ \GBGCPF N[ KRG[BZ OGDZ\ QKMF CK\R
NT BN[ FCKEBF O\ZHT NT OFKR[N GR\EG\ .OKK[ CZF
NJTJ[ ZTHERGB" ZK[F N[ OGDZ\F .SZV NCYN \RP
FBG[N QGZMHF OGKN BZYP KYZV" ZVSFP IGYN "JRTZC
ZK[F N[ OGDZ\FG ,30 'PT ,F"N[\ ,OKN[GZK ,"FZGCDNG
"K\BZY ZXPF QP" ZVSFP IGYN "NBP QKKY JKR DBH"
.J"VY 'PT ,J"K[\ ,OKN[GZK ,ZDZV F[P \MKZTC
WZBC NCY\\ FBG[F \NKDP N[ GH FZGEFP[ QGXZ KFK
\GNKFY \GZ[TC FNCY\R \KRG[N-GEF FZGEFPF[ O[M
:GRZGE N[ KGGKXF \B OKKYR LM KEK NTG ,FYKZPB QGVXC
."I#jr
^ v] NB# ,ZfM@H"
QKYRKNGD EGE CZF
\GEFKF KTEPN ZJM[ QGMP
F"S[\ FBG[F OGK ,OKN[GZK
25
a
FB@ftF# OfK CZ&&T^N F@k]Vv^ ZE&+S
.FIRP \NKV\ OKNNV\P
. Ne jr
# EE+fa EP+fT ,F@ReP<BF@ QfZBz ,FZ@fvF# QfZB
z
.OI@^jr
# ^N QKB+r
& F&kB+ \B& Z` j^H]N eRB@a
,Z+aE#^N Zr
@ ^VB& KB]r
& Z@Cc@ N#T Z+aE#^N eRB@a
.ZP@<B&R Kv]^N]a fZKB]r
^ F#^N QKB+ N@CBz
Fs
@ Tz#R Zr
& Bz \B& eRP+^X#T^N ZK]j^HF#^N eRB@a
.Fs
@ Tz#R B` N Zr
& Bz \B&^G
= F&RTzP# QF&@N QKB+r
& \fNB+t
^ F# \B& N` Br
^ ]N eRB@a
.F@NB+r
^ B` N^N QZ@KB]r
^ F#^N QKB+ N@CBz
.O@RKB+^G eRZ^#jF]r
& F&kB+ \B& Z` j^H]N E#XK+j eRB@ OKT]E^fK
.EI@B& OE@B@ Nr
& fZ^M]H \fNTzF#^N eRB@ OKT]E^fK
OZ@^M]H OK]NTzP# eR@kAj ,OK]N+CBz eR@kAj N@CBz
E@C^N]a EI@B& Nr
& YZ# B` N^G = BfaZ] \fBP+ rr
+ Nr
&
,eRZ^#jF]r
& F&kB+ YZ# B` N
...OZ@K]jP# fRKB+ rKB]r
& F&kB+ B@kB&
Z P F Q C G BZ C Z F
FBG[F \NKDP
a
26
,NB+Z@s
^]K ZP+fr
,NB+Z@s
^]K \KZ]B+r
^ Z` Pr
^
NB+Z@s
^]K E#CB` K NB#^G
.NB+Z@s
^]K TP#r
^ :OKZ]P^fBF@
,EI@B& Kfb ZP+fr
,EI@B& O#T \KZ]B+r
^ Z` Pr
^
EI@B& Kfb E#CB` K NB#^G
.EI@B& @K^K eRKF+` N<B @K^K yP^r
] OKE]Iz#Kl^F#
,rfEY@ Kfb ZP+fr
,rfEY@ O#T \KZ]B+r
^ Z` Pr
^
rfEY@ Kfb E#CB` K NB#^G
.rfEY@^N \ftEA^Y rNr
@ ^a OKr
] ^kr
# l^F#
,OK]ReRIz\#^a S+i#o\^P]e OKP]IzZ#^a F&pZ#\^P]
.Z+HfT QKB+ K]j K]R@T ZfE^N S+i#o\^F]^G F&pZ#\^F]
eRKI+B# \B& eRZ+^M@H^a eRK]M@a O#b eR^Cr
#@K
.eR+K^R@T KP+K]a eY^RI^&mr
& ^G eVZ^s
^]mr
& ^G eI^aJ^]mr
&
,eR+j^NP# eRK]CB@
.OKs
] TzP# eR@a QKB+ K]j eR+RTz#G eR+mI@
.eR+TKr
] fF^G E&SI&@G FY@E@^X eRl@T] Fs
+ Tz
27
a FNKV\ ZES
.CKZTP \NKV\ OKNNV\P
KRVN \GZR F[[ YKNEFN Z[VB .FBG[F \NKDP \B BGZYN Q\KR QBM
Q\KR .FNKDPF N[ YZV NM ZIBN EIB ZR YKNEFN GB FNKDPF \BKZY
.\GZRF \YNEF \T[C FRKDRPF \B QDRN GB "QKPBP KRB" ZK[N
QKP
RB
]B
zP
# K]
z
QKP]BzP# K]RBz
FP@+Nr
^ F@ReP<B&a
I#Kr
] l@F# \B#K]C^a
QKP]BzP# K]RBz
d#P+F^P#\^]ir
& K]o N#T UB#^G
.QKP]BzP# K]RBz F&H N@j OT]
29
a
F@B f t#F \#k]D^P
QBR[ ZGEDKCB \BP
:OF+ F&kB+^G ,OK]YZ@^V Ft
@r
] d@Ce
Z@
Cc
@ \Kr
] BZ
+
.B
.C
eF` C@
G eF` v WZ
M B` NP
&B
@F
@ N@
^
N` jF
T seZ@
oF
# N#
# xr
& ` IF
#
OfF^
vF
R^
o NeP NB
# K+
&
.E
\Z
G \&
VI
a
&P
&fB^
&Z
#P
^ NfY \#
ZfB KF
K EfT
]^
.G
.D
.F
FBG[F \NKDP
a
30
B YZV
ZC
@ c@ \Kr
] BZ+
:min¨
¦ Id© ix¥a§ C¦ azFM
¥ xn© `¨
od¤ aE
¨ ,mip¦ W
¨ it¥ l§ `© ,mlFrÎm
¨
r© lW
¤ eizFc
¨ lFY
§
od¥ zFMx£
ª`
:zFOªi`£ mip¦ W
¨ e§ zFel¥ W§ mip¦ W
¨ ,dr¨ x¨ zFpWE
§ daFh
¨
zFpW§
miA¦ x© min¨
¦ il§ dk¨
¨ f ,iW¦ t§ g¨ mr© kE
§ zFO`ª d¨ oiA¥ ,xk¥
¨ PaE
© Fvx§`© A§
,mc¨`¨ d¨ i¥pA§ eig¨ `¤ l§ eizFgFM
¨
n¦ mx©Y¨ ok¨ l£
¨ dn© aE
§ ,zg©
© p lW
¤
z`¤ ,zA¨ X
© d© mFi z`¤ e§ cg¨ `¤ l`¥ A§ d¨pEn¡`d¨ z`¤ md¤ l¨ wip¦ r¡d¤ e§
,mix¦ g£
¥ ` min¨
¦ iA§ K`© :mi`i
¦ a¦ P§ d© xqEn
©
z`¤ e§ mix¦ t¨ Q§ d© xt¤ q¥
miW¦ aFM
§
lW
¤ mN¨ rª zg© Y© w©p`
¡ p¤ ,mikEW£
¦ ge© miW¦ w¨
zFtx¥U§ ,zFx¥fbE
§ zC¨ zFn£gl§ n¦ A§ dz¨ P§ rª FWt©
§ p :mic¦ A§ r§ W
© nE
§
,mC¨ zFlil¦ r©
£e minFx
¦ bFR
§
,zF`h¥
¨ bl§ dwi
¨ g¦ C§ ,cwFO
¥ d© lr©
,el¥ W
¨ `Ÿle§ mr¨ d¨ hw© W
¨ `Ÿl :br© l¨
¨ e dl¨ R¨ W§ d© ,zFIl¨
ª be§ miWEx¥
¦ B
dc¨n§ r¨ e§ di
¨ R¦ z`¤ aEW¨e aEW dx¨r£R¨ l`¥ x¨U¦
§ i z`© p§ U¦ z¤vl¤ t§ nE
¦
z`¤ mr¨ d¨ wx©g¨ z`Ÿf lM¨ mr¦ e§ :FzFNk© l§ xFc¨e xFC lk¨ A§ eil¨ r¨
s`© min¦ r¨ tE
§ ,miM¦ O© l© Fe¥B oz¨
© p ,oiC¦ d© z`¤ eil¨ r¨ wiC¦ v§ d¦ ,ei¨PW¦
Fl xz¨ e§ sC©x§p¦ e§ cc¨
©p ,g© A§
¥ fO¦ d© iA©
¥ B lr© Fx`E¨v© z`¤ hW
© R¨
:mr¨
© f xŸar©
£i cr© hl¨ w§ n¦ mFwn§
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
31
a
FBG[F \NKDP
[/vfht ,bhdbnc turek ah erpv ;ux sgu itfn]
Fl− oi¬¥` ,ziv`¨
¦½ Pd© dRF
¨ xi
´ `¥ A§ Æl`¥ x¨U¦
§ i mr³©l§ FlÎr
º x©`¥ XÎd
¤ n© K´©`
d−¤Rl© x¬¨Wt§ `Îi
¤ `¦ eizFp
¨½ a§ l¦ e§ Æei¨pa¨ l§ dz¨À l§ r«¨ XÎd
¤ nE
© m®¥W
Er− x§w§ p¦ mdi
¤½ Y´¨
¥ An¦ ÆElb§ dª mcÀ¨`Îi¥
¨ pA§ xŸt´ qÎoi
§ `¥ :FW« x§t¨ l§
d³¨XW¦ :z¤enÎc
«¨ r© Ec¬ A§ r§ Wª e§ x−¨trÎc
¨ r© E¬lR§ W§ dª m®¤dizF
¥ g« R§ W§ O¦ n¦
mi½I¦ g© Ex´ A§ w§ p¦ ExFp
® F`´ Et− x§U§ p¦ Ew¾ p§ g¤
§ p ml¤ v¤½ A§ mi´¦`ExA§ ÆoFili
§ n¦
z¤v³¤lt§ O¦ d© dx¸¨r£R¨ mr© R©À d© :xŸT« aE
©
`¬¨n¨SA© ar−¨x¨A¨ EznÎF`
¥¾
xŸw− r£l© dW
¨¾ w§ aE
¦ m®¨
C d`i´¦
¨ Rw§ n© d−¨g¨ev§ A¦ wŸg½ i´¦la§ l¦ ƨdiƦRÎz`¤
cA¥½ `© lE
§ bŸx´ d£ l© Æcin¦ W§ d© l§ d³¨`v¨
§ i mg¥½ x© `Ÿl´ A§ :lŸM« dÎz
© `¤
ir−¥n§ A¦ W
¤ mix½¦ A¨ rª l§ Æcr© e§ min¨
½¦ IA© Æmi`¦ A¨ dÎo
© n¦ FN® Mª mr−¨dÎz
¨ `¤
zFp£
½ gO© dÎl
© `¤ ÆzFqEgc§ Ex£
³dC¨ xŸtÀ qÎoi
§ `¥ zFa´ M¨ x© :m«di
¤ z¥ ŸO« `¦
E´id¨ Æmi¦ Æ©nX
¨ d© K³©` mi®¦dŸl¡`dÎl
¨ `¤ x−¥OY© d¦ zFA½ x£
ª`´¨d ÆoW
© r©
£e
a−¥
xr¨ z§ d¦ zFpFx
½ T§ d© i´¥N©Bl©
§ B ÆwEWw§ W¦ :l«f¤ x§A© ri
© w−¦ x«¨d¨ e§ zW
¤ Ÿg½ p§
s²¥
xh¨ v§ d¦ l½f¤ x§A© d© zFz´ l§ C© Æzwi
© x¦ hÎl
§ `¤ e§ mi®¦al¨ M§ d© zFgi
´ a¦ p§ A¦
zi
¼ p¦ q¨ xFC
§
w¨
» pr£ zx¤Ÿn´ f§ z¦ M§ :zFx« O¨ qª O§ d© m¦i−©lr©
£Pd© Wr¬©
©x
rw©½ A¨ x´¤W£` dT¨½ C©d© d´¨nn¨ C§ d© ÆlFw Æz`¥ dN¤ `Îl
¥À M¨ EWix¡
´¦ gd¤
m−¤dA¨ r¬©bp¨ ÎxW£
¤ ` mlFr
¨½ d¨ zFO´ `ª Æici
¥ q£
¦ g hr®¨n§ d© i´¥zn§ zFA− N¦ n¦
:d«aFh
¨ l§ z`−Ÿf mi²¦dŸl¡` | m¯¤dl¨ dx¸¨k¨
§ f :midŸl¡
«¦ `d¨ x¬©aC§
d³¨lb§ P¦ XÎd
¤ n© K`©À d®¤`x§`¤ cFr´ d−¥Ax§d© e§ izi
¦ `½¦ x¨ x´¨aM§ ÆdA¥ x§d©
ÆE`x§a§ P¦ W
¤ mi³¦NO¦ dÎl
© M¨ :zF`« x§l¦ e§ aEW
¬ l¨ l−©kE` `Ÿl¬ mW
¨½ Æip© ir¥ l§
hr©½ n§ El´ e§ Æx`¥ z¨ l§ Egi³¦lv©
§ iÎ`Ÿl o®¨NMª zFt− V
¨ dÎl
© k¨ A§ E`½ x§A¦
¨ IW
¤ e§
g© ŸM® W§ l¦ l−©kE` `Ÿl¬ rc½¨`¥ z`´Ÿf Æs`© e§ :i«p¨ ir¥ l§ d−¨lb§ P¦ WÎd
¤ O© n¦
:oia«¦ d¨ l§ gF
© M− d© i¬¦AÎd¤id¦
§ iÎ`Ÿle§
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
FBG[F \NKDP
a
32
C YZV
eF` C@G eF` v WZ&B
@F
@ -NM
@ B` NP
^
:xg¥ `© mlFr
¨ l`¤ rQ¨ n© onFi
© KFYn¦
xW£
¤ ` mi`¨
¦ pFYr¦ lW
¤ d¨Ph© T§ d© zg© l© W§ O¦ A© izi¦
¦ id¨ xa¥ g¨
ixFg£
¥ `n¥ Wg¥ x©z§ O¦ dn© zF`x§l¦ ic¥M§ Fh¥Bd© l`¤ da¨ P©
§ Bz§ d¦
xU
¤ r¤ A§ iY¦ p§ w¨
© f od¤ aE
¨ mW
¨ izi
¦ d¦ W
¨ zFrW
¨ d¤pŸnW§ :eizFnFg
¨
d¤f d¨id¨ ix£
¥dW
¤ ,d¨Iq¥
¦ pM§ A© lN¥ R© z§ d¦ l§ Epx©§vr¨ EpM¥ x§c©A§ :mip¦ W
¨
EP©f`
¡ d¤ a¨bErd¨ lW
¤ eili
¨ l¦ v§ oFx£g`© mc¨
©PW
¤ M§ :oFW`x¦ mFi
da£
¨ d`© lr© ,la¤ q¨
¥ e mixEQ¦
¦ i lr© xA¥ c¦ `Ed :xnŸ
¤ Md© ix¥a§ c¦ l§
id§
¦ i" zM© x§a¦ A§ EpM¥ x§c©l§ EpzŸ
¨ ` gN© W¦ e§ ,cq¤ g¨
¤ e dl¨ n§ g¤ ,min£
¦ gx©e§
dxi¨ n¦ X§ d© i¥pzi
¨ A¦ i¥pR§ lr© Ept§ l© g¨ W
¤ M§ K`© :"mk¤ O¨ r¦ midŸl¡
¦ `d¨
mixEQ¦
¦ Id© EpO¨ r¦ ExzFp
§ ,Fh¥Bd© z`¤ dti
¨ T¦ O© d© dnFg
¨ A© xW£
¤`
:ca¨ l§ A¦ md¥ e§ ,la¤ Q¥ d© e§
mik¦ WFn
§
miW¨
¦ p`£ dWl
¨ WE
§ dl¨
¨ br£ EplEn
¥ l§ d`¨ v¨
§ i Epz¥ qi
¨ p¦ M§ mr¦
oW`Ÿ
¨ x ,di
¨ l¤ r¨ Enx§r¤
¤ p zFnExB§ zFIe¦B§ :DzF`
¨
mit£
¦ gFC
:mFlW
¨ l§ Epl¨ c¨p EN`¦ M§ Wia¦ M§ d© zFxFn£dn© a¤vw¤ A§ lh¥ l§ H© O¦ d©
mr¦ ,z¤eO¨ d© lW
¤ Fzix¦ A§ oA¤ mr¦ d¨pFW`x¦ l¨ EpW©
§ Bt§ p¦ KM¨
`Ede§ ,d¨PR¦ lk¨ A§ FA WEgl¨ `ŸNW
¤ d¨id¨ xW
¨ t§ `¤ i`¦ :ar¨ x¨d¨
mipF`
¦ xqŸ
¤ g ,zFaFgx§A¨ mc¨`¨ ili
¥ g¦ p§ zil¦ k§ z© `ŸlA§ ri
© p¦ d¥ W
¤
:zEvN¨ R© zF`x§n© hiA¦ Y© xW£
¤ ` lk¨ aE
§ :mdi¥
¤ pR§ lr© WE`¥ie§
z`¤ d¨ft§ g¨ A§ xiq¦ n¥ xa¤
¤ be§ ,oFYr¦ A§ miQ¦ kª n§ di¤
¨ pR¨ ,zn¥ ztEB
©
dC¨l©
§ i ;d¨ew§ z¦ A§ di
¨ qi
¤ k¦ A§ hH¥ g© nE
§ di
¨ l¤ r¨ xW£
¤ ` lir¦ O§ d©
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
33
a
FBG[F \NKDP
qt¤ `¤ A§ D¨pFar£x©A§ za¤ A©
¤ iO§ d© zwŸ¤ piY¦ d© DzFg£
¨ ` Dwi
¨ g¥ aE
§
hWFR
¥ oiN¦ t¦ Y§ xEhr£ WiW¨
¦ i ;d¨pW§
¥ i wt¥ q¨ zq¤ qFB
¤ wt¥ q¨ ,zFgFM
dQ¨ P¦ W
¤ xr©
© p ;lŸMn¦ `xFP
¨ d© mr¦ dn¨ l¨ W§ d© ei¨pir¥ aE
§ d¨iEtx§ c¨i
xY¨ kª n§ Fh¥Bd© l`¤ dn¨ c£
¨` igER
¥ Y© lW
¤ zFRl¦ w§ gi
© x¦ a§ d© l§
q©B wFgv§ A¦ miE¦l© O§ d© ,xn¨ W§ n¦ iW
¥ p§ `© lW
¤ zl¤ dFv
¤
d¨vEaw§ A¦
:z¤en¨ cr© dMª
¤ IW
¤ mcŸ¤w Fzh¨ W
¨ t§ d© z`¤
zg© `© :zFrcFn
¨ gEl
© lEnl§ dc¨cFB
§ z§ d¦ mixi¦ r¦ v§ lW
¤ d¨vEaw§
xA© q§ dª :iA¦ l¦ znEU
© Y§ z`¤ dk¨ W§ n¨ ,Wici¦
¦ iA§ daEz
¨ M§ ,od¤ n¥
dl¨ d¥ w§ n© ,mFIa© FA Kx¥r¥
¨ IW
¤ hx¤§vpFw
§ lr© dr¨ cFd
¨ FGW
¤ Epl¨
dxFz
¨ ixEr
¥ W¦ lr© ExR§ q¦ zFxg£
¥ ` zFrcFn
¨ :ccFA
¥ x¨Pk© e§ d¨Ph© w§
dN¤ `¥ lW
¤ mgFk
¨ A§ d¨id¨ m`¦ d© :`nFi
¨ c§ i¥pi§ p§ r¦ A§ zF`¨vx§d© e§
z`¤ wŸpg£ l© F` xQ©
¥ pO§ d© ar¨ x¨d¨ z`¤ ,r©bx¤l§ Ele§ ,wiY¦ W§ d© l§
gFM
© d© z`¤ micEd§
¦ Id© Ea£`W
¨ o¦iP© n¦ ?ciz¦ r¨ d¤ i¥pR§ n¦ dni
¨ `¥ d¨
!?zig¦ W§ O© d© K`¨ l§ O© d© lW
¤ ei¨pir¥ A§ KM¨ hiA¦ d© l§
xW£
¤ ` mil¦ l¨ n§ `ª ,ld¨ T¨ d© iW`
¥ x¨ ,h`x©p§ cEI
§ d© iW
¥ p§ `© A§ m©B EpW©
§ bR¨
zlŸ¤ ki§ il¦ A§ n¦ mdi
¤ zFi
¥ g§ `© e§ mdi
¤ g£
¥ ` i¥Ig© Ecw§ t§ dª mc¨¨iA§
lW
¤ hxFR
§ q§ p§ x©h§ o¥bx§`© l§ mdi
¤ l¥ r£ lH© dª aEW :mri
¨ WFd
¦ l§
:zi¦fM¨ x§O¤ d© xM¨ M¦ A© Enr£x¨ xa¨ M§ zFI`¦ V
¨ O© d© irFp
¥ nE
§ ,miW¨
¦ p`£
miWi
¦ W¦ w§ ,odi
¤ c¥l©
§ ie§ zFdO¨ `¦ Ew£gc§ p¦ zFwr¨ vE
§ zFtig¦ c§ A¦
di
¨ R¦ l`¤ miWEW
¦ zE
§ mik¨
¦ pe§ milFg
¦
,mdi
¤ ci
¥ A¦ mdi
¤ zFp
¥ r£W§ nE
¦
oM¨ x§c©A§ :zh¤
¤ Iqª n§ dni
¨ `¥ mN¨ kª i¥pir¥ aE
§ ,zi`¦ V
¨ O© d© lW
¤ xErR¨ d©
zFI`¦ V
¨ O© d© odi
¤ x£
¥g`© ExizFd
¦
,dkEn
¨ Q§ d© za¤ M¤ x©d¨ z©pg£ Y© l`¤
,za¤ `FM
¤ zi`¦ C©
¨e dri
¨ ci¦ e¦ ,xŸgW
¨ oW
¨ r¨ A§ dlEd
¨ n§ zn¤ N¤ `¦ dw¨ r§
¨f
cr© ,Fnv§ r© lr© d¤f d¤fg£ n© xŸfg£ i© m¦iz© x¢
¨gn¨ m©be§ xg¨ n¨ m©B iM¦
:Fh¥Bd© lW
¤ d¨pFx£g`© d¨ Fzni
¨ W¦ p§
14 13
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
FBG[F \NKDP
a
34
D¨pF`WE
§ D¨pFn£d lr© ,xir¦ d¨ lW
¤ iW`
¦ x¨d¨ DaFg
¨ x§ l`¤ dx¨¨fg£ d©
:mlFr
¨ l§ mlFr
¨ n¥ zg© `© A§ izF`
¦
dxi¨ a¦ r¡d¤ ,DwFg
¨ vE
§ Dx¨g¨ q§ nE
¦
:mipFW
¦ dŸM zFnlFr
¨ oiA¥ Ecix¦ t§ d¦ mix¦ r¨ W§ dO¨ k© e§ dwi
¨ T¦ C© xc¨
¥B
mlFr
¨ A¨ W
¤ mdi¥
¤ pk¥ W§ lr© cg¨ `¤ d¨ mlFr
¨ d¨ ix¥C¨ mir¦ cFI
§ dn©
ElkEi£
§ d - EaiW¦ w©
§ i m`¦ e§ ?EaiW¦ w©
§ id£ - xR¥ q£
© ` m`¦ e§ ?xg¥ `© d¨
xd¥ h© l§ F` xiA¦ q§ d© l§ EQ©pi§ `Ÿl m`¦ d© - Epin£
¦ `i© m`¦ e§ ?oin£
¦ `d© l§
dO¨ l¨ ipEl£
¦ `W¦
§ IW
¤ kE
§ ?miP¦ Wª nE
§ mipFW
¦
min¦ r¨ h§ A¦ m¨pERv§ n© z`¤
?aiW¦ `¨ dn¨ - z`Ÿf lM¨ micEd§
¦ Il© rx©`¥
23
24
25
35
a
FBG[F \NKDP
D YZV
N` jF
# NT
# xr
& ` IF
#
# seZo@F
:ur¥ zFHn¦ iY¥ W§ oiA¥ `¨vn§ P¦ W
¤ rEx
© w¨ sC© lr© aY© k§ p¦
six¦ S§ A© K`© ,Epxi¥ r¦ A§ Eid¨ cExh§ x¤§B dA¥ x§d© :in¦ W§ cExh§ x¤§B
o`M¨ W¥i :iC¦ a© N§ n¦ cExh§ x¤§B cFr oi`¥ d¤Gd© xT© d© e§ KŸx`¨ d¨
d¨pl¥ d¤ ,oilFR
¦ n¦ lhi
§ b¦ e§ d¨pi`¦ x¨wE`
§ n¥ d`¨ A¨ W
¤ dw¨ WEp
§ `¨
Eid¨ W
¤ in¦ lW
¤ dM¨ x£
ª` dxEW
¨ cFre§ ,o¨e¨In¦ d¨iv`
¦ x¨bE
§ d¨ip§ n© x¤§Bn¦
EpzF`
¨
a`© W
¨ WgEn
¨
iY¦ l§ aE
¦ `xFp
¨ h¤pb§ n© d¤fi`¥ :miW¨
¦ p mr© R©
:zg¨ `¤ zEnc§ A¦ EpN¨ Mª z`¤ w©vi¨e§ ,o`k¨ l§ zW
¤ A©
¤ Id© i¥ev§ w© lM¨ n¦
zFQk© l§ zg© `© dki
¨ n¦ U§ ,q©B cA© zl© n§ U¦ e§ ur¥ lW
¤ miA¦ w© a§ w©
sk© e§ gR© lW
¤ dx¨r¨ w§ m©be§ ,mg¥ x© r© cFi
¥ Fpi`¥ W
¤ xŸTA© EptEB
¥ z`¤
xT©
¥ pO§ d© ar¨ x¨d¨ z`¤ ri
© A¦ U§ d© l§ ic¥M§ od¤ A¨ d¨id¨ `Ÿl mlFr
¨ O¥ W
¤
wx© mi`¦ A¨ FnFwn§ aE
¦ Wh¥ W§ H© n¦ e§ KlFd
¥
xa¨ r¨ d¤ :sx¤d¤ `ŸlA§
z©pn§ ,dxi¨ t¦ Y§ d© z©pFkn§ ,r©bx¤d¨ ,dr¨ X
¨ d© ,mFId© ,d¤eFdd©
EpY¨ `¦ n¥ zFcg£
¨ ` zFhhFn
§ z§ n¦ FAW
¤ xC¨q§ O¦ d© ,gEl
© C¨d© wx¨O¨ d©
zFElª n§ od¥ W
¤ M§ ,zFnl¨ r¤
¡pe§ dxEX
¨ d© on¦ zFtl¨ W§ p¦ zFxg£
¥ `e©
:o`¨ l`¤ r© cFi
¥ Fpi`¥ Wi`¦ e§ ,mia¦ l¨ k§ aE
¦ zFg¨ev§ A¦
,xA¥ c©n§ Wi`¦ oi`¥ ciz¦ r¨ d¤ lr© :Epz¨
¥ ie¨d£ lM¨ z`¤ `N¥ n© n§ d¤eFdd©
:Epi¦id¨ mix¦ e§r¦ e§ mihFW
¦
dO¨ M© ,iFd :xa¨ r¨ d¤ z`¤ xŸMf§ `¤ iWŸ
¦ waE
§
gC¨P¦ d© gx§¨fO¦ d© l`¤ x¥Bd© lE
§ zc¤lFO
¤ d© z`¤ aŸfr£l© dr¨
¨ Sd© d© z`¤
,Epn§ N© r© z§ d¦ "micEd§
¦ Il© dqi
¨ p¦ M§ oi`"
¥ zFaFzM§ d© on¦ ,Epig¦ C¨
inE`
¥ p§
z`¤
rŸ© nW§ N¦ n¦
Epn§ h© `¨
Epi¥pf§ `¨
z`¤ e§
1
3 2
4
5
6
7
9 8
10
11
FBG[F \NKDP
a
36
miN¦ n¦ zFlFk§i xa¨ M§ dnE
© ,Eid¨ miN¦ n¦ wx© ix£
¥dW
¤ ,d¨ph§ V¦ d©
sŸRk§ p¦ wx© m`¦ W
¤ ,oin£
¦ `d© l§ Epiv¦ x¨ EpcŸ¥`n§ lk¨ A§ !?zeUr£l©
dl§
¨ iN© d© xg© `© l§ m©B :d¨Pp¤ i`¥ e§ dtEQ
¨ d© xŸar£Y© ,hw¨ on§
© fl¦ dnFw
¨
glŸ© ca§ A¦ EtvEd
§
zFaFgx§d¨ e§ ,zq¤
¤ pM§ d© iY¥ A¨ Etx§U§ p¦ FAW
¤
rx© ix£
¥dW
¤ ,aFhl§ zFEw© l§ Epk§ W
© n§ d¦ ,zFvRª
¨ pO§ d© zFIkEk§
¦ Gd©
zEAx§Y© i¥pA§ lŸMd© ix£
¥g`© EpN¨ kª e§ ,zFid§ l¦ lkEi
© `Ÿl xa¨ M§ xzFi
¥
:Epg¨
§ p`£
d¤f d¨id¨ :ciz¦ r¨ d¤ otFS
¥ dn© rc¨©i `ŸNW
¤ ,x¥Er¦ d¨ dhFX
¤ l© Fl iF`
`Q¥ k¦ A§ dk¨
¤ Pd© ia¦ `¨ ,cx¤t§ p§ nE
© ,oFlQ¨ A© Epa§ W¨
© i :ax¤r¨ A¨ iX¦ W¦ mFi
:Fic§ x©A¨ dr¨ n§ W§ dª W
¤ dl¨ d¥ w§ O© d© zxi© W¦ l§ sx¥h¨ v§ d¦ ,miN©
¦ Bl©
§b
ig¥ v§ g§ vª nE
§ c¤bA¤ ixŸ¥gW§ ,Eqp§ k§ p¦ md¥ e§ zl¤ C¤d© d¨vx§t§ p¦ rz© t¤ l§
fFx¡`l¤ EEv¦ Epil¥ r¨ e§ KEnQ¨ d© xc¤g¤ l© Et£gC¨ `A¨ `© z`¤ :s¨Bn©
o¨bEn mFwn¨ l§ zF`vFi
§ oY¤ `"
© :zFTC© xU
¤ r¤ KFzA§ dc¨
¨ef§ n¦
zFpEnY§ wx© oM¥ n¦ xg© `© lE
§ :"!xd¥ n© ,xd¥ n"
© ,Exn§ `¨ ,"gEh
© aE
¨
mdi
¤ h¥ A¨ n© ,zc¤cFA
¤
d¨Ix§¦ i :mir¦ H¨ wª n§ zFlFwe§ zFtEh£g
zw© r©
£f ,d`Et
¨ T§ d© xir¦ d¨ xM© M¦ ,mip¦ k¥ X§ d© lW
¤ milEl£
¦ gd©
DA¨ oi`¥ W
¤ za¤ M¤ x©d¨ ,d¨pig¦ v§ O© d© zi`¦ V
¨ O© d© ,`O¨ `¦ lW
¤ dc¨x¥R§ d©
,FA ur¥ zFHn¦ wx©W
¤ KŸx`¨ d¨ six¦ S§ d© ,dni
¨ W¦ p§ l¦ xie£
¦` zR© h¦
:mip¦ R¨ d© z©vEn£g FR`T¨ d© e§
akFM
¨ d© mFwn§ aE
¦ ,six¦ S§ l© Epq©
§ pk§ dª W
¤ M§ EgN§ B¦ EpizFx
¥ r£U
© z`¤
r©bx¤ FzF`nE
¥ :lŸgM¨ xR¨ q§ n¦ Epic¨
¥i lr© Eax¨§v ,dX
¤ Wª O§ d© aŸdS¨ d©
xg© `© mFi ,gFp
© n¨ `Ÿll§ ,ax¤r¤ cr© xwŸ¤ An¦ ,xŸRz§ l¦ e§ xŸRz§ l¦ wx©
s¨BO© l© Eni`¦ z©
§ IW
¤ m¦iq¨
© pk§ nE
¦ zFvl§ gª ,mili
¦ r¦ n§ ,mir¦ aFM
¨ ,mFi
dO¨ l¨ ?ip¦ `¨ dO¨ l¨ ."?dO¨ l"
¨ iY¦ l§ `© W
¨ cFr dN¨ g¦ Y§ A© :g¨vg§ vª O§ d©
12
13
15 14
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
37
a
FBG[F \NKDP
dl¨ `¥ X§ d© :lŸ`W§ N¦ n¦ iY¦ l§ c©g¨ K`© ?eW
¨ k§ r© dO¨ l¨ ?Epg¨
§ p`£
:daEW
¨ Y§ Dl¨ oi`¥ A§ xzFi
¥ dai
¨ `¦ k§ n©
,FR`T¨ d© dx¨R§ q¦ KM¨ :xg¥ `© mFwn¨ l§ EpN¨ Mª z`¤ Egw¦
§ i dl§
¨ iN© d©
z`Ÿf lM¨ za¤ zFM
¤ ip£
¦ ` :Exc¨w¨ di¤
¨ pR¨ K`© ,xa¨ C¨ dti
¨ qFd
¦
`Ÿle§
ilE`
©
,WFp¡` oA¤ mr© R© i`¥ FzF` `¨vn¦
§ i m`¦ e§ :x¨iP§ d© sC© lr©
`ŸNX
¤ dn© lr© lŸ`W§ l¦ FgFka§ d¤id¦
§i
25
27 26
28
29
FBG[F \NKDP
a
38
E YZV
OfFv
^F
# K+Ro^ NeP NB
&
:ie¦N¥ d© ia¦ v§ l`Fi
¥ oA¤ ce¦C¨ aŸwr©
£ i lW
¤ zFpFx£g`© d¨ eizFN
¨ n¦
d¨pFW`x¦ l¨ :iY¦ n¨ xa¨ M§ zg© `© mr© tE
© iY¦ c§ lFp
© min¦ r¨ R§ rA© x§`©
izFi
© g§ `© e§ ig© `© z©pFnWE
§ ixFd
©
zFl£dv§ n¦ lFwl§ iY¦ c§ lFp
©
Wn¥ g¨ e§ mix¦ U§ r¤ M§ i¥pt§ l¦ Kx©A¨ z¦
§ i i¨i§ zx§©fr¤ A§ mlFr
¨ l¨ iz`
¦ A¨ W
¤ M§
mip¦ X
¨ d© xU
¤ r¤ A§ iY¦ c§ lFp
©
zFtqFp
¨
min¦ r¨ R§ WlW
¨ :d¨pW
¨
z¤eO¨ d© ix£
¥g`© :zg¨ `¤ mr© R© xa¨ M§ iY¦ n© m©B od¤ aE
¨ ,zFpFx£g`© d¨
:z¤en¨ mEW cFr izF`
¦ cig¦ t©
§ i `Ÿl `Edd©
lM¨ ,EpzF`
¨
Etq§ `¨ W
¤ M§ ,d¨iv§ w§ l¤ Q¤ d© lil¥ A§ iY¦ c§ lFp
© d¨Ip¦ X§ A©
mia¦ kFM
¨ d© :zi¦fM¨ x§O¤ d© xM¨ M¦ d© l`¤ ,dx¨¨ir£A¨ W
¤ mix¦ a¨ B§ d©
:dk¨ W£
¥ gA© gi
© l¦ a§ d¦ aŸdS¨ d© i`l© H§ d© wx©e§ md¤ l¨ EwN§ Y© q§ p¦
EptEB
¥ bl¤ R¤ z`¤ sŸUg£ l© e§ dM¨ x£
ª` dxEW
¨ A§ xC¥Y© q§ d¦ l§ EpW§ x©c§ p¦
dd¨ M¥ on¤ W
¤ zxFp
© n§ lW
¤ DxF`
¨ l§ Epx§a© r¨ d¤f xg© `© d¤fA¨ :oFil§ r¤ d¨
F` oin¨
¦ il§ c¨i zrEp
© z§ A¦ dxFd
¨ W
¤ ,mixFg
¦ W§ WEal¨ oh¨ U
¨ c©il§
miw¨
¦ fg£ d© mig¦ l¨ W§ p¦ d¤f c©vl§ iM¦ iY¦ p§ a© d¥ c¨In¦ :l`ŸnU§ l¦
z`¤ iz`
¦ N¥ n¦ zExid¦ n§ A¦ :mip¦ w¥ G§ d© e§ miP¦ h© T§ d© mW
¨ lE
§ mipFq£
¦ gd© e§
z`¤ iY¦ g§ R© p¦ ,mix¦ h§ ni
¤ h¦ p§ q¤ dO¨ k© A§ iY¦ d§ a¨
© B Kk¨ e§ xt¨ r¨ A§ il© r©
£p
mr¦ iY¦ g§ l© W§ p¦ ;Fc¨il§ ix¦ a§ r¨ A§ izFpFd
©
A§ lr© iY¦ c§ r¨
© v s`© e§ i¦fg¨
i©Ig© iM¦ iY¦ r§ c¨©ie§ zFIx§¦ Id© z`¤ Epr§ n© W
¨ xzFi
¥ xg¨ `ª n§ :mipFq£
¦ gd©
:FnW§ Kx©A¨ z¦
§ i .d¨pY¨ n© A§ il¦ EpY§ p¦
1
32
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
39
a
FBG[F \NKDP
i¥pt§ l¦ cŸrv§ l¦ EpY¨ `¦ n¥ sl¤ `¤ Egw§ l§ p¦ xW£
¤ `M© iY¦ c§ lFp
© ziWi
¦ l¦ X§ A©
miA¦ x© miW¦ wFn
§ A§ `N¥ n© z§ p¦ gh© X
¤ d© :dn¨ g¨ l§ O¦ d© zFcU§ A¦ `a¨
¨ Sd©
mFi¨e mFi lk¨ A§ :d¤pg£ O© d© i¥pt§ l¦ d¨Ig© dnFg
¨ M§ Epi¦id¨ Ep`¨ e§
mirEq
¦ W§ mix¦ a£
¥ g Epix£
¥g`© mixi¦ zFn
¦ Ep`¨ W
¤ M§ Epx¥R¨ q§ n¦ hr¥ n© z§ d¦
EpY¨ `¦ n¥ d¨pFnWE
§ mir¦ a§ W¦ :xr¨
© Id© zFIg© e§ m¦in© X
¨ d© sFr lk£
© `n© l§
sFqA§ Epr©
§ Bd¦ W
¤ M§ Wc¨g¨ n¥ Epc§ lFp
© iM¦ iY¦ W§ g© :rQ¨ O© d© z`¤ Ecx§U
¨
.inFI
¦ d© lil¦ C¨d© wx¨O¨ d© z©pn§ l¦ Epik¨
¦ f FAW
¤ oA¥ z§ O© d© l`¤ mFId©
:mFi | mFi i¨i§ KExA¨
on¦ r©bx¤l§ iz`¨
¦ vi¨ :dl§
¨ il¨ FzF`A§ cFr iY¦ c§ lFp
© ziri
¦ a¦ x§A¨
z`¤ zF`x§l¦ iY¦ w§ R© q§ d¦ cFre§ ,zixFg£
¦ `d¨ x¥vg¨ d¤ l`¤ oA¥ z§ O© d©
dnFg
¨ d© :ziS¦ O© d© lW
¤ `il¦ g§ O© d© KEIg¦ d© z`¤ e§ z¨SP¦ d© xExt©
§ Bd©
dl¨ r¢d¨ oA¥ z§ O© d© :KxŸ¤v DA¨ oi`¥ aEWe§ DN¨ W
¤ z`¤ dz¨ U§ r¨ d¨Ig© d©
dlFr
¨ oA¨ x§w¨ ,dn§
¨ in© X
¨ d© cwFO
¥ d© lr© elr¨ ix©a£
¥ g lk¨ e§ W`¥ A¨
:Kx¨A¨ z¦
§ i midŸl`
¦ l¥
:ca¨ l§ A¦ zg© `© mr© R© zEn¨i `Ÿl min¦ r¨ R§ rA© x§`© clFP
© W
¤ in¦
iY¦ q§ R© z§ p¦ ,dt¨ x¥V§ d© mFwO§ n¦ iY¦ g§ x©A¨ W
¤ xg© `© l§ il© r¨ `A¨ izFn
¦
dcFa
¨ r£d¨ l`¤ d`¨ v¨
§ IW
¤ za¤ M¤ x© l`¤ iY¦ t§ xŸ©ve§ mi¦InFw
¦ n§ ici
¥ A¦
oŸeAq© ,Epl§ aEd
© EpN¨ kª e§ Epi¥pR¨ z`¤ dl¨ A§ w¦ zxŸ¤nf§ Y¦ :zx¤x¤g§ W
© O§ d©
xU
¨ A¨ lW
¤ gi
© x¥ :r¨GiªO§ d© EptEB
¥ z`¤ sŸhW§ l¦ ,Epic¨
¥iA§ za¤
¤ BnE
©
zxŸ¤nf§ Y¦ d© e§ ,Epic¨
¥iA§ xr© A¨ oFAQ© d© ;EpiWEg
¥
z`¤ six¦ h§ d¦ sExU
¨
on¦ oFx£g`© d¨ r©bx¤A¨ iY¦ t§ l© W§ p¦ ,il© r¨ l`¥ d¨ in£
¥ gx©A§ :z¤pB¤ p© n§
Et£gc§ P¦ W
¤ miO¦ xªr£d¨ mipFn£
¦ dd© l`¤ iY¦ t§ x©h¨ v§ d¦ `Ÿle§ dxEX
¨ d©
onE
¦ mixi¦ C¦ `© Wr© x©A§ dw¨ x§h§ p¦ zl¤ C¤d© :zE`x§t¦ A§ xc¤g¤ d© l`¤
:Fx£`z¨ l§ zr© cFi
© d¨Pp¤ i`¥ dt¨ V
¨ d© xW£
¤ ` lFw rw© A¨ xc¤g¤ d©
rn© W"
§ lW
¤ lil¦ a§ A¦ dz¨ E§lª g© xFv
¥ f©B lW
¤ Fzni
¨ x§¦ f zwi
© x¦ W§
i¨i§ " ,"`¨in¦ dx¤c§ n"
© e§ "EpidŸl¡
¥ ` i¨i§ " ,"rlrn`n"E
©
"l`¥ x¨U¦
§i
13
14
15
16
17
19 18
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
FBG[F \NKDP
a
40
dn¨ n¨ C§ lFwe§ zFhwFW
§ e§ zFkrFC
£ zFg¨ev§ ,"rlrh`h"
© e§ "cg¨ `¤
xŸwr£l© ,zFtEBd© z`¤ wN¥ q© l§ :ici¦ w¦ t§ Y© lig¦ z§ d¦ o`M¨ :dT¨ c©
:xEPY© d© iR¦ l`¤ miz¦ O¥ d© z`¤ qŸgc§ l¦ ,ad¨
¨ Gd© i¥PW¦ z`¤
dO¨ M© eizi
¦ `¦ x§ `ŸNW
¤ ,x¤fiil¥ ig¦ `¨ lW
¤ ei¨PW¦ z`¤ iY¦ x§w© r¨ W
¤ M§
zn¥ ip£
¦ `e© ,zFig§ l¦ KiW¦ n§ d¦ itEB
¦ ;iA¦ x§w¦ A§ iA¦ l¦ zn¥ ,mip¦ W
¨
:KxŸ¨an§ i¨i§ mW
¥ id§
¦ i ,mg¨ w¨ l§ xa¨ M§ i¨i©e mi¦Ig© il¦ oz¨
© p i¨i§ .KN¥ d© n§
,FA Epz¨
¥ pEn¡` z`¤ cA¥ `© P§ W
¤ ic¥M§ mlFr
¨ lW
¤ FpFAx¦ ln© r¨ dO¨ M©
:z`Ÿf EpiU¦ r¨ `Ÿl Fzn£
¨ g lr© e§ FR`© lr© K`©
,ElA¨ `© z§ Y¦ l`© e§ il© r¨ Erx§w§ Y¦ l`© ,zt¤ qFP
¤ d© mr© R© A© zEn`¨ W
¤ M§
dn© .dO¨ l¨ lŸ`W§ l¦ m©B Epid¦ Y¨ l`© :z¤en¨ xg© `© z¤en¨ oi`¥ W
¤
:il¦ l¨ b§ A¦ mix¦ g£
¥ ` EUr©
£i l`© ip¦ `¨ izi
¦ U¦ r¨ `ŸNX
¤
29
30
31
32
33
41
a
FBG[F \NKDP
F YZV
\Z&P
& fB^G \V&I
& Z#P
^ NfY \a
#
[/vburjtv vexPv
thmuvk 'vfht ,bhdbnc turek ah ukuf erpv ,t]
:dǬIkFa
¦ i¬¦p£` dN¤ −`Îl
¥ r© zx¤nF`
¤½ e§ zt´¤
¤ gx©n§ Æmi¦ Æ©nX
¨ n¦ lFwÎz
³ A©
zE`® x§t¦ A§ d−¤GnÎd¤
¦ f Er¬ x§w§ P¦ W
¤ cExh§ x§B¤½ ÎlW
¤ di
¨ xFdÎl
´¤
r©
:dǬIkFa
¦ i¬¦p£` dN¤ −`Îl
¥ r© :ldw
o−¨gFk d¬¨lM¨ W
¤ ,d¨iv`
§ x½¨bE
§ d¨p´¥ld¤ e§ ÆlhiƦ
§ be§ dw¨ WEp³¨
§ `e§ cExh§ x¸§B¤ Îlr©
d®¨
cFar£d¨ zF´pg£ n© A§
:dǬIkFa
¦ i¬¦p£` dN¤ −`Îl
¥ r© :ldw
ÆEWx§c§ P¦ W
¤ d½¨IcE¦ d§
´ Id© ÆFR`ƨTdÎl
© r© e§ h`x¨p§ cEÀ
§ Id© i´¥Wp§ `Îl
© r©
F`® N§ n© l§ lFk¨
´ i m−¨
c`¨ oi¬¥`W
¤ ciw½¦ t§ z© `´¥Nn© l§
:dǬIkFa
¦ i¬¦p£` dN¤ −`Îl
¥ r© :ldw
c´©lFpe§ m¦i−©nr£R© z¬¥OW
¤ i½e¦N¥ d© Æia¦ vÎl
§ `FiÎo
¥ A¤ c³¦eCÎaŸ
¨ wr©
£iÎlr©
r®©Ax§`©
:dǬIkFa
¦ i¬¦p£` dN¤ −`Îl
¥ r© :ldw
dn§
¨ i−©nX
¨ d© E¬lr¨ W
¤ eix½¨a£
¥ g Æmi¦ Æ©pWEÎmi
§
x¦ U§ r¤ zF`³ nÎr
¥ W
© YÎl
§ r©
mi®¦WwFO
§ d© zFc´ U§ A¦
:dǬIkFa
¦ i¬¦p£` dN¤ −`Îl
¥ r© :ldw
o®¥Az§ O© A© xEa¨
´ v mx−¨t£
¨ `W
¤ milFS
½¦ P¦ d© Ædr¨ a§ W¦ e§ mir³¦ a§ WÎl
¦ r©
:dǬIkFa
¦ i¬¦p£` dN¤ −`Îl
¥ r© :ldw
Îz`¤ Æd`¨ x¨ `Ÿl³ eizFnFl£
¨½
gA© W
¤ Æmiri
¦ e§¦fO© A© s³©`W
¤ x¤fiilÎl
¥¾ r©
Fz® tEB
¨ n¦ a−¨d¨Gd© i¬P¥ WÎz
¦ `¤ xwFr
¥¾ eig½¦ `¨
:dǬIkFa
¦ i¬¦p£` dN¤ −`Îl
¥ r© :ldw
zF`½ h´¥
¨ BA© ÆmiwEg
¦ C§ d© mipFi
¦À li
§ O¦ d© lr´©e§ d®¨IkFa
¦
i´¦p£` dN¤ −`Îl
¥ r©
Îlr© e§ zFx½ r§
¨ IA© Æmih¦ hFW
§ O§ dÎl
© r© :x«a¨ r£O© d© zFp£
− gn© aE
§
Æhl¨ w§ n¦ `³¨vO¨ W
¤ inÎl
º¦ r© mi®¦kEMaE
© mi−¦tY¥ x§O© A© mix¬¦ Y¨ q§ Oª d©
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
FBG[F \NKDP
a
42
ÆoY© P¦ W
¤ i³¦nÎlr© :ei«dŸl¡
¨ `Îz`¤ c−¥A`¦ F`¬ zx¤g¤½ `Îz
© C¨ wi´¥gA§
:o«di
¤ l¥ r£ `x¬¨w§ p¦ or−¨C§ nE
© `²¥tFx m¬¥XW
¤ sx®¨
¤ hÎzFIg© i−¥
ciA¦ mi½i¦ EQp¦ l§
F`− `V
¨½ n© za´¤
¤ Mx©A§ Æze¤O¨¸ l© w³©pg¤
§ p `n¨
¨½ SaE
© Æar¨ x¨A¨ z³¥OW
¤ inÎl
¸¦ r©
`v¨¸ EdW
¤ ÁinÎl
¦ r© :sx«¨U§ p¦ F`¬ i−©g x¬©Aw§ p¦ dxFp
¾¨ mi®¦fB¨ d© i´¥`z¨ A§
Æmi¦ n©¸ WÎm
¨ W
¥ i³¥WC§ w© nÎl
§ r© E¼`xi¦
¨ ie§ »E`x¦§i or´©
© nl§ dÀ¨Il¦ z§ A¦ b¹ xFd
¥ l§
i³¦nÎlr© z¤e®¨nÎcr© En£
´ gl§ p¦ e§ r−©pM¨ d¦ l§ E¬ax§Q¥ W
¤ l`¥½ x¨U¦
§ i m´¥We§
mi½I¦ g© A© ÆxzFP
© W
¤ i³¦nÎlr© :Fz¨
« ew§ z¦ e§ FcFa
− kE
§ Fzi
½ AÎz
¥ `¤ ÆcA¥ `¦ W
¤
:r©bx«¨ | r©bx¬¤e§ mF−i | mF¬i W®¨
cg¨ n¥ dr¨
−¨eG§ dÎz
© `¤ zF¬ig§ l¦
zF´bd£ l© Ec−n§ l¨ `¬ŸNW
¤ mil½¦ lF
¨ rÎl
´ r© d½¨IkFa
¦
i´¦p£` ÆdN¤ `Îl
¥¸ r©
m¬¥de§ md¤½ n¥ El§
´ fb§ p¦ Æmdi
¤ xEr
¥ P§ W
¤ zFcÀ li
¨ e¦ mic´¦ l§
¨ iÎlr© ‰`®¨O`Š
¦
Ek− x§A¨ z§ p¦ `¬ŸNW
¤ zFn½ l¨ r©
£e Æmin¦ l¨ rÎl
£ r© :d«gi
¨ x¦ R§ mx¬¤
¤ h El− n§ w¨
:cq«
¤ gÎl
¨ W
¤ d¬¨aiU
¥ l§ Ek¨
− f `¬ŸNW
¤ mip¾¦w§
¥ fÎlr© d®¨Rgª l© zg´©
© Yn¦
mlFr
¨À d¨
i´¦t§iÎlMÎl
¨ r© e§ dwi¦
¨ fEO½ dÎl
© r© e§ ÆzFxFn§fY¦ dÎl
© r©
xŸg® W
¨ e§ xŸt− `¨ e§ mE¬gÎwx© FN¾ kª e§ FzEI
½ pF
¦ r´ a§ v¦ ÆFl dc¨a³¨
§ `W
¤
:dǬIkFa
¦ i¬¦p£` dN¤ −`Îl
¥ MÎl
¨ r©
cq¤ gÎa
¤ x© mEgx©e§ oEPg© i¥pt§ l¦ cFBx§R© d© i¥pt§ l¦ iY¦ h§ A© g© z§ d¦ dO¨ M©
rcFp
© m`¦ d© :oia¦ d¨ l§ izi
¦ v¦ x¨e§ iY¦ p©
§ Pg© z§ d¦ e§ iY¦ W§ T© A¦ ,zn¡
¤ `e¤
Ffe§ dO¨ `ª Ff ?min£
¦ gx© `l¥ n¨ l`¥ x©fB¨ Kk£
¨ d ?minFx
¦ O§ A© xa¨ C¨d©
aWFi
¥ :dtEr§
¨ f dn¨ n¨ C§ wx© ,d¤pFr oi`¥ e§ lFw oi`¥ ,d¥Pd¦ e§ ?Dx¨k¨ U§
mix¦ Y¨ q§ p¦ e§ miT¦ nª r£ :o¨pFlz¦
§ i dn¨ n¨ C§ d© l¥vaE
§ oFil§ r¤ xz¤ q¥ A§
lFw zFpA§ `Ÿl m©B ,m¥pia§
¦ i `Ÿl Wi`¦ ;mix¦ a¨ C§ d© md¥ mi`¦ xFp
¨ e§
:m¦in¨ X
¨ n¦
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
21 20
22
43
a
FBG[F \NKDP
G YZV
ZfB KF
]^K EfT
:min¨
¦ Id© ix¥a§ C¦ azFM
¥ xn© `¨ e§ aW
¨
:xg© X
¨ d© i¥px§w© lW
¤ mipFW`
¦
x¦ zFdFbp§ ExM§ p¦ dl§
¨ iN© d© iz£
¥ `t© A§
lr© EdA¨ W
¤ miQ¦ t© ic¥b§ a¦ A§ mc¨`¨ ici
¥ x¦ U§ lr© Exi`¦ d¥ EN`¥
mtEb
¨ e§ gŸ© nU§ l¦ Ki`¥ Egk§ W
¨ xa¨ M§ :zFzn¥ m¦ip© ir¥ A§ mdi
¤ zFai
¥ a¦ q§
zFxFA l`¤ EwN§ q¦ mixFR
¦ g§ C© :md¤ l¨ r©Sdª W
¤ lkŸ¤ `d¨ z`¤ dg¨ C¨
Ff iA©
¥ B lr© Ff Elt¨
§ PW
¤ ,zFwiT¦ c©e§ zFOxªr£ zFIe¦b§ it¥ l§ `© w¨pr£
:mix¦ ai
¨ `¥ oFit§ x¦ A§
md¥ W
¤ M§ ,mc¨`¨ ili
¥ g¦ p§ lW
¤ zFx¨EM© Eaa§ q¨ mixEw
¦ r£ lW
¤ zFp£gn© A§
mic£
¦ gFR md¥ ix£
¥de© ,mdi
¤ zFg
¥ R§ W§ n¦ i¥pA§ z`¤ zFW`Fp
¨ miU¦ R§ g© n§
l`¤ aEWl¨ EQP¦ W
¤ mil¦ l¨ n§ `ª :mz¨
¨ ew§ Y¦ a¥fM¨ Y¦ oR¤ zFEw© l§
wx© ElS§ p¦ mr© R© `Ÿle§ ,mip§¦ iFr mip¦ k¥ W§ m©B md¤ A¨ E`v§ n¨ mdi
¤ Y¥ A¨
xW£
¤ ` F` Erc¨§ i `Ÿl xW£
¤ ` miW¨
¦ p`£ :bx¤d¨ xg© `© bx¤d¤ n¥ q¥pA§
Exq§ `¨ xW£
¤ ` F` oin£
¦ `d© l§ Eax§q¥ xW£
¤ ` ,zr© c©l¨ `Ÿl EWw§ A¦
z`¤ Ept©
§ i o`¨ l§ Erc¨§ i `Ÿle§ zFrExw§ m¦ip© ir¥ A§ Ecn§ r¨ ,oin£
¦ `d© l§
:m¨pERv§ n© z`¤ Ex£dh§
© i c©vik¥ e§ mh¨ A¨ n©
;Ec£g`© z§ d¦ dg¨ R¨ W§ n¦ i¥paE
§ mdi
¤ Y¥ a¨ l§ miW¨
¦ p`£ EaW
¨ h`© h`© K`©
Eth§ W
¨ miN©
¦ B xg© `© miN©
¦ B :EclFp
¨ mic¦ li
¨ e¦ E`V§ p¦ e§ EaW
¨ miW¨
¦ p`£
zEc£di© i¥fM§ x§nE
¤ dn¨ w¨ d`¥
¨ b d¨pic¦ n§ ,gx§¨fO¦ d© l`¤ milFS
¦ P¦ d©
ix¥z£
¨ ` l`¤ zFrqFp
§ aEW zFaM¨ x© :la¥ z¥ ia£
¥ gx©A§ mig¦ xFR
§
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
FBG[F \NKDP
a
44
,r© cFi
¥ inE
¦ :ux¤`¨ d¨ i¥ev§ w© lk¨ A§ zFl£dFv zFxFn§fz¦ e§ WtŸ¤ Pd©
mil¦ aFQ
§ l© e§ mil¦ a£
¥ `l¨ `¥vO¨ Y¦ W
¤ m¦in© X
¨ d© on¦ EWw§ A¦ KM¨ ilE`
©
:dn¨ zn© g¤
¨p
xn¡
© `p¤ "WiC¦ w"
© e§ q¥p lr© Elr¢d¨ Wt¤
¤ Pd© i¥Gr© lW
¤ dxEa
¨ b§ i¥iENB¦
,EnwEd
§
zF`h¨ x§C©p§ `© e§ EaY§ k§ p¦ zFpFxk¦
§ f ix¥t§ q¦ ,miz¦ O¥ d© lr©
:mdi
¤ z¥ n¥ z`¤ FA zFMa© l§ mFwn¨ sFq sFq `¨vn§ p¦ mil¦ a£
¥ `l¨ e§
K`© ,dx§¨fr¤ l§ Ek¨f Wt¤
¤ p F` sEb ik¥ p§ ,mW
¨ p§ r¨ lr© E`A¨ mir¦ WFR
§
,zFnFl£gd© K`© l§ n© z`¤ lŸAk§ l¦ ic¥M§ d¨id¨ `Ÿl dN¤ `¥ lk¨ A§
`Ÿle§ ,dl§
¨ il© xg© `© dl§
¨ il© milFS
¦ P¦ d© z`¤ zir¦ a§ d© l§ KiW¦ n§ O© d©
xA¥ q§ d¤ r© aFz
¥ e§ xT©
¥ pO§ d© ,oERv§ O© d© lFw z`¤ wiY¦ W§ d© l§ ic¥M§
- zFl`¥ X§ d© ll© WE
§ :aN¥ d© zEnih£
¦ `l© e§ zip¦ h¨ V§ d© zErW§ x¦ l¨
dO¨ l¨ ?Epg¨
§ p`£ `w¨ e§C© dO¨ l¨ ?dO¨ l¨ ?dO¨ l¨ ,mlFr
¨ lW
¤ FpFAx¦
Fll£
¨ gA© zFiElY§ ExzFp
§ - ?KM¨ dO¨ l¨ ?eW
¨ k§ r© dO¨ l¨ ?md¥ `w¨ e§C©
:o¦i`¨ - d¤pr£nE
© ,WFp¡` iU
¥ r£n© lM¨ lr© n¥ zFt£gx©n§ ,mlFr
¨ lW
¤
12
zn¡
¤ `A¤ Epa§ W
© w§ d¦ m`¦ dN©
¤ bi§ on§
© Gd© wx© ;Epc§ n© N¨ dn© EciB©¦ i min¨
¦i
:dn¨ c£
¨`d¨ on¦ Epil¥ `¥ wrFS
¥ d© mig¨
¦ vx§P¦ d© mC© lW
¤ FlFwl§
dg¨ k§ W¦ A§ Erw§ W§ Y¦ l`© K`© ,iC©n¦ xzFi
¥ ElA§ `© z§ Y¦ l`©
,EaEW¨IW
¤ KWŸ
¤ gd© ini
¥ l¦ EgiP¦ Y© l`© ;zEWic£
¦ ` lW
¤
El£gn§ Y¦ l`© ;dr¨ n§ C¦ d© z`¤ Egn§ m©be§ EkA§
;oia¦ d¨ l§ EQ©pY§ l`© ,Egl¨ q§ Y¦ l`© e§
:d¤pr£n© `Ÿll§ zFig§ l¦ Ecn§ l¦
!Ei£g Epin¥ c¨A§
16
13
14
15
17
18
45
a
OKZK[
EZ
N^
G FB
N QfZ@
j]
gF
N Z` j^
H]
K
&l
&#
@ft#
# OfK^
,eRK\+fKI^B# \B&^G eRKI+B# \B& Z` j^H]
R
,Z@V^jF# Kv+@a \B&^G ZKT]F@ Kv+@a \B&
\fZF@^R]j eRBz@nr
& FZ@@KTzF@ \fCfIZ^ \B&
:IZ#` B K+NTz EE+faF# Yc@^RAoF# \B&^G
,GK@R@o Zv+^S#N^Y]a rKr
]@iF# \B&
,dZ@E@eS^a OB+F@ \B&
,F@K\&fl#X^a FZ#Tz#mF# \B&
;Uh@F# \B&
NB+Z@s
^]K \fkF]^Y K+V^NB# \B&
,OE@B@F@ \fI^or
^ P] N#T
OKE]eF^iF# \E#Tz N@j \B&
F@ofZKB+ \P#E^B# N#T I#Ch&#N F@TZ^^MAF Zr
& Bz
;K]XB@mF# \Z+fjF# KE+KP]
O` B\^]o Y#T@gr
& rKB]F@ \B&
;\P+ f\Y@Tz#H^Ce
d@a]N NB& dY@fRKv] FY@^CI@r
& Ft
@ B]F@ \B&
;eI^R@X F@K\&fTfZ^He
OB+F@ \P#J^]o NB& \frt
^#DP^ GK\@fT^a^XB&r
& YfRKv]F# \B&
;\&R&RfX^G F@kIA^j BKF]^G
FBG[F \NKDP
a
46
,O]K#N^DZ#F@ \B&
J@N^VP] er^Y]ar
& O]K#N^DZ#F@ \B&
;EfT SfRP@ F@KF@ B` N^G
U` Z^DB&^N OF&KE+^K eX^Vq@r
& \B&^G
,N&HZ^#aF# \B& Q#VI@r
& U` Z^DB&F@
,QfHI@F& Yr
&&R^N F@KF@r
& N&HZ^#aF#
,EZ&l&F#^G reB+iF#
C@C+kF# KZ+@a OF+^G
O]K#RK+TF@ KI+eY^o OF+^G
E&D&mP] Or
@ ^V#R eMK]Nr
^ F]r
& OF+^G
;#TKr
] fF^kP] FZ@^XY@ OE@@K^G
,OfiF# \B& Z` j^H]R
F\@^N@Tr
& rP&t
& F# \B& ,GKZ@F>@X^a OfiF# \B&
,OKP]c@F# EY+fP N#T
;OKr
] KZ]IzP#e OKF]fC^b eEP^@Tr
& O]KP#t
@ F# \B&
Z&VB+F@ K+kv] \B& Z` j^H]R
.OKI]Z^foF# OK]m#b#N \I#v#P] Zr
& Bz
GK\@P+ \&B KI#F# Z` j^H]K
eR@N E&D&mP] OF+ F+mF] K]j
CK]C@S-CK]C@S O&FK+RK+T \fJ@a]R F+mF]
,eR@N KP]c> NB# ,KP]c> NB#^G
.OZ@^M]H^N OK]KeBZ^ eRK+iI# eKF^]K KE+Tz
ZRCGY BCB
47
a
OG\K [KEY
F@RfM^R FI@eRP^ B+XP^F# .OKP]fZl^#a Q+Mfr OKP
NP
]I
zZ
# B+
@ NB
+
#TK]YZ@F@ ZF#` H^j OKZ]fFJ^e OKr
] fE^Y \fNTzP#^a .F@RK]Mt
^ F# K+V^R#j \I#v#
,FB@ft#a eI^aJ^]mr
& NB+Z@s
^]K K+R^a eRKI+B# N@j \fPr
^]R \B& OKZ]KF]^HP#
\B& eZ^Sl@r
& ,eDZ^F&&mr
& ^G eVZ^s
^]mr
& ^G eY^RI^&mr
& ,UJ@@G OKr
]@R OKr
]@RBz
N#T#a B@mB@ .O\@I@eRP^ BF+v^ QE&+T Q#D^a ,Ot
+ F# rec]Y N#T Or
@ ^V#R
ZfZ^X]a Z` Z^Xe ,OKP]@NfT^N yK&V@R^j Z\&+S^a OZ+Kv]^SF# ,OKP]IzZ#F@
N#T OfNr
@ ^C eIeR@K^G ,O\@@NIz#R BeF @K^K ,OF&K\+fPr
^]R \B& OK]iI#F#
.QP+B@ ZP#B` R^G .OF&K\+fC^jr
^ P]
Of\@
K rKc
]Y
#
,B@aZ# dP+r
^ rc#Y#\^]K^G Nc##b\^]K
.d\+eM^NP# xK]NP^#K^G d\+eTZ^]M BZ@^C Kc] BP@^N@T^a
NB+Z@s
^]K \K+a N@ME^ K+iI#^Ce QfMKP+fK^Ce QfMK+iI#^a
:QP+B@ eZP^B]^G ,CKZ]Y@ QP#^H]Ce B@N@DTz#a
:B@iP#^N@T KP+^N@T^Ne O#N@T^N xZ#@CP^ B@aZ# dP+r
^ BF+^K
Bu
+#R\^]K^G OP#fZ\^]K^G ZB#@o\^]K^G I#av#r
^]K^G xZ#@a\^]K
.BeF xKZ]^a Br
@ E^YAc^ dP+r
^ N#kF#\^]K^G F&k#T\^]K^G Zc#F#\^]K^G
B\@Z@Kr
] ^G B\@@MZ^]a N@j QP] B@k+T^N
:QP+B@ eZP^B]^G ,BP@^N@T^a QZ@KP]Bzc# B\@P@I<&R^G B\@I@^ar
^ Av
,NB+Z@s
^]K N@j N#T^G eRK+N@T OK]iI#^G B@iP#r
^ QP] B@aZ# BP@@Nr
^ BF+^K
:QP+B@ eZP^B]^G
N@j N#T^G eRK+N@T OfNr
@ Fs
& Tz#K BeF GKP@fZP^]a OfNr
@ Fs
& fT
:QP+B@ eZP^B]^G ,NB+Z@s
^]K
FBG[F \NKDP
JRTZC NJTJ[ ZTHERGB
!JRTZC'S ,LTNZTEKZa !JRTZC'S
!JRTZC LTCTR NJTJ[ OTZB@ ZTHERGB KGB
QGHDZK JKP QJRKGG THKKC
QHB@NCTX QGB QMTZC ,QS#
KKZ
#
,QTPB#NV TENKGG KE LB@R ZTYZB#J[
!JRTZC QKG[ OGZB# WNB#
LKH KGHB# JYGY QGB JKKJ[ ZKB QGB
#
,JRTF TJDKKNZB#V JKP
= LKH KGHB# JYGY QGB JKKJ[ ZKB QGB
!JRTZC NJTJ[ ZTHERGB
\Z&T&fa eR\+Z@K@Tz
,F@VZ+s
^ FZ@@KTz@a ,OKI]B#
,d@kAj FZ@Tzfa eR\+Z@@KTz
,eZTz^S]K \fZfIr
^ \fIeZ d@a
,eZTz^C]K Q@aZ^I
A-\fCFz#N
,eZBzr
^]R B` N F@K\&fC^YT]
,rB+@C F@NfT BKF]
,O]KE#@K OK]Y^CfI Ov&B#^G
,FZ@^H&T JKr
] fF K]N^a
,CF##kF#-rB+ \B& \fa#M K]N^a
.FZ@@KTzF@ rB+
a
48
49
a
OKZK[
!F@VZ+s
^ ,eNK]pF# ,OKI]B#
,F@Tt
@ F# ,F@NK]NI@^G SI# ,F@CfZ^Y
,eEKP]\^#K \fCF@&kF# K]j
,eEKP]r
^#K F` o eR@kAj \B&
,eEKT]@K \fZK]Y-KE+KZ]s
^ YZ#
.F@KF@ F` ot
& FP#
,O]KE#@K OK]Y^CfI Ov&B#^G
,FZ@^H&T JKr
] fF K]N^a
,CF##kF#-rB+ \B& \fa#M K]N^a
.FZ@@KTzF@ rB+
!FZ@+T^a ,F@VZ+s
^ ,OKI]B#
.FZ@^H&TF@ BKF] E#C^N]a O&ME^&K^a YZ#
,\&CF&fB E@K eJKr
] fF rKI]
,\&Gl@F#P+ eNK]pF#^G
,\&CF&^Nr
# ea#j O&MP^E#^a
;OE@^a ea#j rKI]
,eE` PTzv# NB# YfIZ@P+
,F@NfT rB+F@ K]j
,O]KE#@K eY^aI#v^ B@R NB#
!F@NfE^D F@VZ+u
^ F#
DKJZKCD KMEZP
FBG[F \NKDP
a
50
NB@P QKKY JKR D@BH
,DTGG QJXTN OTE JSKKD GE HB# ,NB@P QKKY JKR DB@H
#
,DTJ TKGNC QNTJ[ZB#V TRTKKNC QTNPKF [JB@M
,FT[ TJYRTCTDSKGB ZTHERGB LB@R JTGG QTPGY
!B@E QTRKKH ZKP = JB@ZJ ZTHERGB QB@J YKGo B# JTGG'S
#
,KKR[ QGV ERB#N QJKKGG HKC ERB#NRTPNB#o OTRKZD QGV
,KKGG ZTHERGB JKP ,QKKo ZTHERGB JKP QB@ QTPGY ZKP
#
#
,JGNC ZTHERGB QGV WKZo[ B# HKB'S QNB#VTD eGG QGB
.JGP ZTHERGB ,FZGCD ZTHERGB JZB@E JTGG QXB@Zo[
,JRKKF OTE HERGB QENKDB#C QGHRDZB@P KE JTGG'S
#
#
JRKKV QJKP QERKGG[ZBV JTGG QJMTR ZTE QGB
#
= ZB@KB#Y OTE QKB QGH KE JTGG QTPB#HZB#V CKGB ZB@R
.ZGE GX ZGE QGV EKN SB@E QKKD NB@H NB@ZB#o B# KGG
,KKNC JKP JKR QGB JGNC JKP HKB QCKZ[TD EKN SB@E
#
#
,KKZV ZTE UGKB NDKGV B# QGV NEKN QKKY JKR HKB'S
#
#
JRTGG TYKERNB#V Q[KGGX YNB@V B# JB@F SB@E
.JRTF KE QKB STRB#DB#R JKP QTDRGHTD EKN SB@E
,DTGG QJXTN OTE JSKKD GE HB# ,NB@P QKKY JKR DB@H B@J
#
,DTJ TKGNC QNTJ[ZB#V TRTKKNC QTNPKF [JB@M
,FT[ TJYRTCTDSKGB ZTHERGB LB@R JTGG QTPGY
!B@E QTRKKH ZKP = JB@ZJ ZTHERGB QB@J YKGo B# JTGG'S
YKND [ZKF
51
a
OKZK[
ZP#B` \ B@R NB#
F@RfZIzB#F@ K]jZ^E# F+mF]" :ZP#B` \ B@R-NB#
!"F@R@RTzF@ KP+r
^ eZKv]^SF] OfiF# ZfB \B&
BfC@K^G N#T#K EfT fN eR^V#S^M]R OfK F&H
!F` o eRI^#RBz :OKT]Z^#K EfT eRE+@T^XP]e
OKZ]fV^M-K\+^jZ^#K E#T ZP@v@F#-WZ&B&P+
,OKZ]en]K^G \fCfB^MP#^a = F` o eRI^#RBz
FZ@^b]R Or
@ eRKP+c@-\#oJ] Zr
& Bz#Ce
.FZ@eC^D]a eRI+eZ-H` T EfT CeR@K B` NFz
,NF+@K ZfB eRP+fK N#T ZI#t
# F#-Eel#T
,N+X fP^j eR+NfPv^ U` NIz#K ZZ+fpF# OT]
= ZfBF@ BfC@N ZI+B#^K ,F@NK]NI@ ,OB] LB#
.ZfE^N ZfcP] ZKt
] F# BF+^K FP@^S]S fP^j
,Cv@^M]R BeF \Z&&VfTF@^G Oc@F# C\@^M]a
,CI#Z^l&F#^G ZfZc^F# Zfo]X \Z#Kr
] B` N BeF
,O@TF@ N@j eFeZr
@ OK]N^VfR \fZK]Y QK+C K]j
.OE@@K^a OK]RB#DB#R^G eFeZr
@ GKc@I^#K
F@RfZIzB#F@ K]jZ^E#" :ZP#B` \ B@R-NB# Q+j N#T
!"F@R@RTzF@ KP+r
^ eZKv]^SF] OfiF# ZfB \B&
BfC@K^G N#T#K EfT fN eR^V#S^M]R OfK F&H
!F` o eRI^#RBz :OKT]Z^#K EfT eRE+@T^XP]e
KYSRGN[ OFZCB KEK NT ODZG\
FBG[F \NKDP
a
52
FG@Y^v] F#
FP@K]R^o C@C+k#a EfT N@j
F@iP]fF KE]eF^K r&V&R
FP@KE]Y@ IZ@^HP] K\+Bz#V^Ne
F@i]VfX Qfi]X^N Q]K#T
eR\+@G^Y\] FE@^CB@ B` N EfT
O]K#o^NB# \fRr
^ \#a F@G^Yv]F#
eR+XZ^B#^a Kr
] ^VI@ O#T \fKF^]N
.O]K@Nr
@ eZK]G Qfi]X WZ&B&
FEGDB BKF ,YZGK-GKRC FC[GPG 1901-C FPYGF[ ,OKRCZF \SRM
OGEKYN \NTGV OKRCZF \SRM .OKKCKJCZSRGY OKRCZ N[ \KPGBNRKC
,OKZGEKS \PSZVP BKF ;NBZ[K NNM \CGJNG \KCKJCZSRGYF \GEFKF
FMZEF Q\GRF FMNF ETG NT \KBZIB BKF ;OKZIB OKZVSG OK[PGI
OKKTGXYPF OKMZXF \B \\Z[P BKF .\KCKJCZSRGYF FTGR\N \K\MNF
QM GPMG ETS \GKRMG\G ,OKSRM ,OKPGSZV \GTXPBC FKZCI N[ OKK[KBFG
OK\Z[P OKRCZF \SRM KZCI .FTGR\F N[ [GKBF \ETG NT \KBZIB
OKKRIGZ OKMKZEPM ,OKMRIPM ,OKSGVPYG \GNKFY KRCZM ONGTF KCIZC
.OKK\NKFY OKRGDZB N[ OKNFRPMG \GEFKN OKZGPM ,BCXCG OKNGI K\CC
The Rabbinical Assembly
3080 Broadway, New York, New York, 10027
Tel: 212-280-6000; Fax: 212-749-9166
Email: [email protected]
www.rabassembly.org
,ZGYIN G\ZJP[ FFGCD FNM[FN ESGP BGF \GEFKF KTEPN ZJM[ QGMP
\KRGKGG[ ,FIG\V ,\KPEYB F[KDC \GEFKF KTEP \B NKIRFNG EPNN
OKKIC OPG[KK NTG O\GTP[P NT [DE \PK[ LG\ ,\KJSKNZGNVG
\KPGI\-CZ B"P \KRMG\ ZJM[ QGMP NFRP LM O[N .OKKRZEGPF
OKMRIPF ZGCKXNG NNMC \TEF KZIG[ NFYN \GEFKF KTEPC \KR[EIG
,OKKPG[KK ZYIP KRGMP NFRP ,OPGSZVG OKZYIP \CK\M EEGTP ,JZVC
.OKSRMG QGKT KPK OKKYPG
[ZEPF \KC :\GVSGR \G\GPT [GN[ \GRMG[ ZJM[ QGMP N[ SGVPYC
WZBC \KCKJCZSRGYF FTGR\N OKRCZ ZK[MP[ ,ZJM[ O[ NT OKRCZN
LGRKI N[ \KRMG\ \NFRPF K"N\ ZVS K\C QTPN LGRKIF QZY ;ONGTCG
;OKK\MNPP OKENK KRDG ZVS K\C 250-P Z\GKC OKENK 45,000-N KEGFK
K\C N[ \[Z ,WZBC [ZEP K\C N[ \[Z \PKKYPF OKN[GZK \[ZEP
\KEGFK \GCZ\N HMZP ,ZJM[ FGGR \B ODG ,FRKBZYGBC \GNKFYG ZVS
.CKCB N\C YEX FGGR \RGM[C
\GEFKF KTEPN ZJM[ QGMP
91160 OKN[GZK ,16080 E"\ ,4 \GRZD OFZCB ’IZ
02=679=0840 :SYV ;074=780=0600 :’NJ
[email protected] :KRGZJYNB ZBGE
www.schechter.ac.il :JRZJRKB Z\B