Technology Changes the Auction As We Know It
Transcription
Technology Changes the Auction As We Know It
...as seen in Horological Times BY JENNIFER BILODEAU Technology Changes the Auction As We Know It Introduction I n this day and age, most of us have visited eBay at least a few times. Many have also likely purchased or sold items on eBay. In fact, online auctions like eBay are now the norm. Companies all over the world have brought their businesses to the web to sell their products through niche online auction sources. This article will examine three different companies that make good use of the Internet to reach the most customers possible. it’s convenient, are huge factors. In addition, internet search technology makes it easy to locate a single item from millions of different listings online. For sellers, online auctions create a larger market for their items. They can also easily reach a large group of bidders on short notice because online advertising works fast. There are a few disadvantages to internet auctions, however. The most obvious is that it’s hard for bidders to inspect goods before bidding in an online auction (even though they can ask the seller questions online, via e-mail or over the phone). Another downside is the number of cases of fraud reported by bidders in online auctions. However, the amount of fraud is tiny compared to the number of transactions which take place. Online auctioneers have pursued a number of ways to minimize fraud, such as encouraging third-party escrow services. The sellers we interviewed for this article all strive to take high-quality photos or videos of their items. Their goal is to provide detailed, accurate descriptions and offer excellent customer service for sellers and buyers; from the beginning to the end of the process. The three auction houses interviewed have different styles of business. However, all agreed that advertising is the key to a successful online auction. From search engine optimization (getting the right keywords into the search engines), to advertising in trade publications, or by posting on social media (Facebook, Twitter, etc.), they couldn’t put enough emphasis on “getting the word out” to the right buyers. Coincidentally, all three companies have a strong connection to the field of horology. Gordon Converse surrounds himself with the timepieces, writes while examining each piece, looks for facts of interest to collectors, and also notes condition prior to the on-site/online auction. The first company, Aumann Auctions, is owned and operated by Kurt Aumann, a professional auctioneer and auctioneering instructor. Kurt learned the auctioneering trade at twelve years old, getting a very early start in the business. In the 1990s, he refused to listen to other’s initial skepticism about the Internet. Instead, he helped pioneer the online auction. He developed his own auction software and launched his first auctions online with little hesitation. His auctions did so well, he now franchises his auction software to other businesses across the country. There are several advantages to conducting an online auction, along with—or instead of—holding a traditional on-site auction. For buyers, geographic and temporal convenience, and being able to bid when The second auction house interviewed, Carolina Auction & Realty, is owned and operated by Tom Jordan, a professional auctioneer. The company has a regional focus working mostly in North Carolina and sur- Horological Times is a monthly publication of the American Watchmakers-Clockmakers Institute (AWCI), Amy Dunn, Editor, 701 Enterprise Dr., Harrison, OH 45030, 866-367-2924, www.awci.com, copyright, 2012 ...as seen in Horological Times TECHNOLOGY CHANGES THE AUCTION AS WE KNOW IT BY JENNIFER BILODEAU rounding areas. They sell both real estate and personal property using the auction as their method of marketing. They also handle business liquidations, estates and commercial equipment. “Get Online or Get in the Bread Line” Tom finds that educating the public on the items he sells, and being there for them every step of the way, makes his auctions run smoothly. The son and grandson of watchmakers, Tom feels a connection to his timepiece auctions and posts videos on www.youtube.com for a historic account of each piece. This gives his clientele a sense of confidence when dealing with him online. Set in a rural area south of Springfield, Illinois, Aumann Auction’s spacious, modern buildings encompass nearly 16,000 square feet with three acres of parking. The Auction Center is designed to conduct two auctions simultaneously. The owner, Kurt Aumann, a seasoned veteran in the auction world, has also franchised his proprietary online auction software to 45 auction houses nationwide. Together, they hold a total of 4,000 auctions a year. The third auction house we spoke with was Gordon Converse & Company. The owner, Gordon Converse, has been an appraiser on Antiques Roadshow (yes, we have a bit of a TV celebrity as an AWCI member). After repairing clocks and watches for a living, Gordon decided to move his entire clock shop online and use the internet to sell. His online auctions went so well, he started assisting other people with selling their timepieces using online auction software. Gordon enjoys teaching his sellers the value of their clocks or watches. He is especially interested in helping them research their pieces. Additionally, he knows it’s vital to get items in front of the right buyers. All three of these companies couldn’t stress enough the importance of the online auction supported by advertising. Yet, all three have different business styles, backgrounds and success stories to share. This article will describe how online auctions work and how they could benefit you as a buyer or seller. Kurt Aumann, Aumann Auctions, ‘Ex’ Auction Software and MarkNet Alliance Kurt had an interesting start in the auction trade. He graduated from auctioneering school at the ripe old age of 12 years old. He was raised around farm equipment, farm toys and antiques and knew from an early age that auctions were his calling. He worked as an auctioneer throughout secondary school and after graduation. What Does the Internet Have to Do With the First Automobile? Kurt Aumann was never a person that take much stock in what everybody else around him was saying about “trends.” During the late 1990s, Kurt would hear, “We’re going to wait out this ‘Internet thing’ and see what happens,” but Kurt strongly disagreed. He viewed the Internet much like the first automobile. He realized this was a major development that was here to stay. Kurt was ready to take his auction business online, while other auction houses were scoffing at the thought of putting their business on the web. He saw the Internet as an opportunity to broaden his audience. The Internet would not require buyers to be in a certain place at a certain time; bidding could take place at the user’s convenience. He also realized the value of Amazon and started selling with them in 1999. The Next Step: Proprietary Software, MarkNet Alliance and Franchising After a few years, Kurt decided to develop his own online bidding software called, “Ex.” The software proved to be another great move, growing his Auctioneer and President of Aumann Auctions, Inc. Kurt Aumann bid calling at an auction. Horological Times is a monthly publication of the American Watchmakers-Clockmakers Institute (AWCI), Amy Dunn, Editor, 701 Enterprise Dr., Harrison, OH 45030, 866-367-2924, www.awci.com, copyright, 2012 ...as seen in Horological Times TECHNOLOGY CHANGES THE AUCTION AS WE KNOW IT company even more. In 2007, Kurt decided to franchise his online auction business. He then created MarkNet Alliance. This was founded in 2007 with 10 compa-nies and has grown to 45 companies licensed BY JENNIFER BILODEAU bid in increments of 15 minutes. This prevents a lastsecond bidder from pushing other bidders out of the running. Completing the Cycle Four years after starting his online auction businesses, Kurt was ready to share the wealth of information he had accumulated. He went to the auctioneer schools to teach classes on how to successfully advertise auction businesses online. Kurt felt that he had now completed the cycle. He had started out as an auctioneering student, answered the door when opportunity knocked with the Internet, and steadily grew his business. He now teaches others how to do the same. Kurt wants fellow auctioneers to be successful, just as he has been. He sees with clarity how quickly consumers adapt and push technology forward. This allows him to sell online to the world. Aumann Auction Inc. cashiers, Becky Carter-Beeson and Kiry Aumann, help register phone customers for bidder numbers. in over 40 states. MarkNet has now become recognized as a leader in online-only auctions. Kurt only sells his franchise to licensed, auction professionals with proven track records and thriving businesses. His software, Ex, allows his franchises to cooperate with other member auctioneers across the country while managing the process from their home office. The software also monitors each auction and allows his clients to track every aspect of the auction webpage and phone calls, thus giving them the mostup-to-date information on auction activity. Before the conversation with Kurt ended, he laughed and reminded business owners to, “Get online or get the in bread line.” He should know. As a pioneer in farm toy auctions, Kurt’s company, Aumann Auctions, has an online bidding platform and large buying base. They not only auction farm toy collections, but also maintain a presence in timepiece, coin, train, antique toy, firearm, advertising and petroliana auctions. Aumann Auctions, Inc., a member of NAA, conducts over 100 auctions a year. Visit www. aumannauctions.com for information. The Timing Couldn’t be Better for Online Auctions Smart Advertising Carolina Auction & Realty, Tom Jordan “If you are marketing your auctions correctly, you can reach any niche successfully,” Kurt says. He believes that all online auctions should be advertised in traditional formats such as print, and also on the web. For niche auctions, like antique clocks, he uses trade publications like AWCI’s Horological Times to get the word out to a target industry. Tom Jordan isn’t just an auctioneer in the North Carolina region. He is also the son and grandson of professional watchmakers. That’s why he’s especially excited when he has an opportunity to market timepieces. A good example was when an English client moved to the U.S. with fifty antique clocks. Tom noted that because of his family history, he felt a special connection to his client’s antique clocks which dated from the mid-1700s through the late 1800s. According to Tom, “The online auction went great. We had nineteen bidders on fifteen clocks that placed 184 bids over a 14-day period. Everyone was locked in. They already knew what they were willing to spend. The client and I were happy with the results.” With niche items like antique clocks, he will have a professional in horology assist his staff with correctly photographing and cataloging each clock. This information goes online and each sale is timed, similar to eBay. However, he has anti-sniping software programmed which allows the bidder to “push out” the Horological Times is a monthly publication of the American Watchmakers-Clockmakers Institute (AWCI), Amy Dunn, Editor, 701 Enterprise Dr., Harrison, OH 45030, 866-367-2924, www.awci.com, copyright, 2012 ...as seen in Horological Times TECHNOLOGY CHANGES THE AUCTION AS WE KNOW IT BY JENNIFER BILODEAU Tom says he works hard to establish honest and open communication with his clients. He wants each auction, whether online or in-person, to be a “win-win” outcome for the buyer and seller, both. “People need to trust their auction house. As an auctioneer, you are accepting responsibility for the seller’s livelihood. Our clients call us when they have a problem, and we have to own their problem. My aim is to give people that feeling that we are going to take care of them. And we do,” he states assuredly. Researching Items to be Sold Researching Auction Software Each of the online auctions also categorizes items to assist niche buyers. These buyers save time online— they don’t have to sort through a variety of unrelated items, which may happen at traditional auctions. When it came time for Tom to expand his business online, he made sure to perform meticulous research. After examining and comparing different bidder platforms (auction software), Tom chose Proxibid. This company works only with licensed auctioneers. He also knew Proxibid had a good reputation for advertising online and drew a lot of traffic. Additionally, they offer free training for potential buyers on how to bid online. “People enjoy buying online because they can log on from the comfort of their own home and research items ahead of time. They don’t feel rushed or pressured because we provide a lot of information and customer support for them,” Tom adds. “The auction takes place in a 14-day time span. This gives our buyers time to watch videos on items, perform their own research, check on shipping costs, and ask us questions. Our staff is always there helping to prepare the bidder. Tom does his homework when preparing for an online auction. He and his staff videotape each clock so potential buyers can see the timepiece running. He also includes a detailed description with each photo. In addition, Tom saves these videos on www.youtube. com permanently, in case another person ever needs to research that same piece. In a sense, he is “recording” history. Advertising is Still Everything Tom continues to perform auctions on-site for such clients needing business liquidations and selling commercial equipment. Whether he is auctioning items on-site or online, he advertises every auction online. Many buyers see his ads online and register to bid, or show up at the site to view items. Tom is a member of the NAA (National Auctioneers Association). The trade association provides training for auctioneers on how to advertise successfully online. The training covers how to perform SEO (Search Engine Optimization) for online auctions. Tom enters his own keywords on his website before an auction. He often uses Google Keywords to find the most highly searched terms, like “antique clock auction” or “antique clocks for sale.” His auctions attract buyers from all over the world. For the clock collection auction he told us about earlier, buyers placing bids from all over the U.S. to Singapore and Australia. Avoiding the “eBay Way” Tom Jordan conducts an online auction at Carolina Auction & Realty. Carolina Auction & Realty also chooses not to follow the eBay model. What is “the eBay Way?” During the last 30 seconds on eBay, anybody can sneak in a bid and knock other bidders out, even if others have been bidding diligently. To prevent this, Carolina Auction & Realty also uses “anti-sniping” software that detects when someone places a last minute bid. The software extends the sale automatically for 15 – 20 minutes— and sometimes up to an hour—to foil these last-second attempts. Horological Times is a monthly publication of the American Watchmakers-Clockmakers Institute (AWCI), Amy Dunn, Editor, 701 Enterprise Dr., Harrison, OH 45030, 866-367-2924, www.awci.com, copyright, 2012 ...as seen in Horological Times TECHNOLOGY CHANGES THE AUCTION AS WE KNOW IT BY JENNIFER BILODEAU tower clocks, museum pieces, and clocks for collectors and retail customers in the Philadelphia area. He also began writing and lecturing on antique clock topics and became an appraiser for the Antiques Roadshow between 1996 and 2006. He then trained his son to help in the shop with the antique clock repair. Time for Change Customers using the Proxibid software. Advice from One Professional to Another Tom Jordan has been successful in growing his business by adding online auctions to his traditional services. Even if you don’t wish to sell online, he suggests, “Everyone needs to buy a computer. It doesn’t have to be expensive, but at least buy something that will get you on the Internet. People should also consider advertising online because right now seems to be a very active time for sellers.” Tom is a member of the North Carolina Auctioneers Association (NCAA) and the National Auctioneers Association (NAA). He is a licensed auctioneer and real estate broker in 4 states. Tom and his staff have over 30 years of combined experience. Visit their website at: www.carolinaauctionrealty.com. “Live Auction” Software Fosters Healthy Competition Gordon Converse, Gordon Converse & Company Gordon Converse’s interest in timepieces started at the age of twelve when he joined a watch and clock trade organization and began collecting and repairing antique pocket watches. The goal of advancing his watchmaking career was put on hold while he served in the Vietnam War. After the 2000 recession, Gordon knew it was time to change his business model. First and foremost, Gordon wanted to “try out auctions” in his shop. After the first few auctions, he knew he was onto something good. After holding on-site auctions for a few years, he decided to launch an online auction business. He chose the software, “Live Auctions,” and ran every auction in-person at the same time he was running the online auction. Gordon’s customers appreciated the choice of either showing up or logging onto his website. He found the simultaneous activity created a healthy competition when on-site bidders began to compete directly with online bidders. Similar to other auction software, Live Auction also allows bidders to push out their bids for as long as needed for more fair results. A Typical Gordon Converse Auction Gordon’s process is to launch his auction’s catalog a month before the auction date, allowing bidder’s time for research. This also gives the company time to get the word out about the upcoming auction. As the sale date approaches, the bidding momentum builds. Gordon employs a licensed auctioneer and support staff to run each in-person auction, while Gordon himself will stand nearby, sharing facts and tidbits of information on the next piece for sale. Bidders can call in, place bids online, or even mail bids in advance. Like other successful online auction businesses, Gordon knows the value of promotion. He uses all avenues of marketing to promote sales, from web to print. Gordon states, “You can’t underestimate how important good photographs are to successful promotion. It’s essential we take the best possible photos to accurately represent each timepiece.” In 1979, Gordon then established an antique store and repair business that focused on antique clocks and watches. Along the way he was involved in restoring Horological Times is a monthly publication of the American Watchmakers-Clockmakers Institute (AWCI), Amy Dunn, Editor, 701 Enterprise Dr., Harrison, OH 45030, 866-367-2924, www.awci.com, copyright, 2012 ...as seen in Horological Times TECHNOLOGY CHANGES THE AUCTION AS WE KNOW IT BY JENNIFER BILODEAU clocks, fine art, porcelain and antiques.Bidders could also preview the lots on their website. At the auction, they offered a rare Waltham Girandole ornate banjo clock in excellent condition. The serial number was one of less than fifty and it featured an unusual added thermometer in the throat. The online and live bidding for this clock soared to a $17,255 winning bid. Many others sold for a strong price, including an antique Seth Thomas clock. New Technology Opens Auctions to the World Gordon Converse & Company runs its on-site and online auctions concurrently to foster a healthy competition among bidders. He also comments that “doing whatever it takes to make the seller and buyer happy” is his most important job. The company has been known to hand deliver a clock when shipping options aren’t optimal, but he jokingly adds, “Don’t quote me on that.” The use of software technology, combined with each company’s unique knowledge, has opened up a world of new business for these three successful auction firms, and for many other businesses,as well. Gordon Converse & Company research the value, photograph and catalog timepieces, then create a focused, custom marketing plan. For additional information see: www.converseclocks.com. t A Special Skill Gordon prides himself on the horology knowledge he has accumulated over the years. His forte is work ing with the sellers, teaching them about their timepieces, appraising their items and making sure they receive the price they deserve. Many clients may not know the value of their clocks or watches, and Gordon helps them research their pieces accurately. Waltham Girandole ornate banjo clock sold at auction for $17,255. Their recent auction held on December 28, 2011 near Philadelphia is a good example of how modern auction houses use online services to expand participation in a live auction. Gordon Converse held previews at the auction site for over 400 lots of antique Antique Seth Thomas clock sold at recent Philadelphia auction. Horological Times is a monthly publication of the American Watchmakers-Clockmakers Institute (AWCI), Amy Dunn, Editor, 701 Enterprise Dr., Harrison, OH 45030, 866-367-2924, www.awci.com, copyright, 2012