Mentality International Flash Report

Mentality International Flash
Report
Different Worlds Series 2: European Parliamentary
Elections
The staying power of the Eurosceptic voter rebellion
About Mentality
International
Executive summary:
The world is constantly changing. Exponential
growth of technologies and new media mean a
continuously faster distribution of knowledge
and products. The younger generations are
taking over the mantle from older generations.
The
challenges
for
companies
and
governments are greater than ever in the year
2014. It is crucial for organisations to have the
best understanding possible of future
developments. A necessary condition for
success is knowledge of fundamental trends,
what motivates people and how these can
differ from each other locally and relate to
each other worldwide.
In the context of the Mentality International
Project, Motivaction surveyed more than
46,000 respondents in 20 countries and 12
languages in December 2013 and January
2014. The study was conducted in the US,
Canada, Mexico, Brazil, Australia, Japan, China,
South Korea, India, Russia, Turkey, South
Africa, Italy, Poland, Germany, France, Spain,
Belgium, the Netherlands and the United
Kingdom. This selection of countries contains
58% of the world population and represents
75% of the world economy.
2
Far-right
Eurosceptic
political
parties
throughout Europe have a very distinctive
and similar voting base, in terms of
demography, cultural values, normative
behavior, political views and general
perspective on life. The depth and strength of
these similarities suggest that there is far
more to the Eurosceptic vote than one-issue
concerns in a one-off protest vote against the
EU. Moreover the expected Eurosceptic voter
insurgency for the European Parliamentary
elections in May 2014 may be just the
beginning of an ongoing rebellion in the heart
of EU decision making.
This is the main conclusion of a unique indepth survey into the voting base of
Eurosceptic political parties in Great Britain,
France, Italy, Belgium and the Netherlands
which was conducted in December 2013 and
January 2014. The results of this survey show
that voters of Eurosceptic parties feel
fundamentally abandoned and betrayed by
their own society and institutions. They feel
victims of both the economic crisis and the
broader process of globalization. Disengaged
from society at large they are seeking
structure and security in their personal lives.
In a separate analysis of the voter base of the
Five Star Movement (M5S) in Italy the survey
finds that Eurosceptic parties can also tap
into other voting bases. M5S are distinctively
more moderate and modern, but share the
institutional mistrust and general disillusion
of right wing Eurosceptic voters. If more
Eurosceptic parties manage to mobilize
voters such as M5S, that might pose an even
greater challenge to the European Union.
Flash Report – The staying power of the Eurosceptic voter rebellion
Insurgency of Eurosceptic
parties
Throughout Europe opinion polls predict a
big win for Eurosceptic political parties at
the European Parliamentary elections in
May 2014¹. In many countries Eurosceptic
parties are polling well over 20% of the
vote, in some countries they are expected
to come in as first. These parties challenge
the basic principles of the European Union:
the free movement of people, the monetary
union and membership of the EU itself.
Hard Euroscepsis, defined as the opposition
to membership of, or the existence of, the
European Union as a matter of principle is
mostly found among right wing populist
parties². Throughout Europe it is expected
that these right wing Eurosceptic parties
will be the big winners of the European
Parliamentary elections. This survey zooms
in on the voter base of five of these parties:
1. UK Independence Party (UKIP) – The UK
is historically one of the most
Eurosceptic countries, in part due to its
geographical separation from
continental Europe. Support for UKIP is
surging, the party gained one in four
votes during Municipal elections in
2013³. Under electoral pressure from
UKIP, UK Prime Minister Cameron
promised the British electorate an EU
‘in-or-out’ Referendum in 2017⁴.
2. Flemish Interest (VB) – VB has a long
history as a far right anti-EU party with
strong support. However it is one of the
few right-wing parties that is expected
to lose in the European elections⁵. The
party faces fierce competition from a
rival party that like VB promotes
Flemish secessionism, but unlike VB has
a pro-European agenda.
3. Freedom Party (PVV) – This outspoken
anti-EU party is making high waves in
opinion polls in the Netherlands as the
largest political party⁶. Together with FN
PVV leader Geert Wilders is trying to
establish a new Eurosceptic Group in
the European Parliament⁷.
4. National Front (FN) – Also Front
National is currently leading opinion
polls in France as the strongest political
party and was the big winner of the
municipal elections in March 2014. With
a projected 23% of the European
Parliamentary vote, FN could more than
triple her previous election results⁸.
5. Northern League (LN) – The party leader
once stated that the Euro is a ‘crime
against mankind’⁹. Although this
separatist party stands only at 6% in
current opinion polls¹⁰ that is mostly
because of competition from
Eurosceptic rival Five Star Movement.
1. www.economist.com/news/briefing/21592666-parties-nationalist-right-are-changing-terms-european-political-debatedoes?zid=309&ah=80dcf288b8561b012f603b9fd9577f0e
2. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euroscepticism
3. www.telegraph.co.uk/news/politics/ukip/10036463/Local-elections-2013-Nigel-Farages-Ukip-surges-to-best-ever-showing-winning-150-seats.html
4. www.theguardian.com/politics/2013/jan/23/david-cameron-eu-speech-referendum
5. www.demorgen.be/dm/nl/17103/Verkiezingen/article/detail/1792558/2014/02/13/Vlaams-Belang-krijgt-kiesdrempel-in-zicht.dhtml
6. https://www.noties.nl/peil.nl/
7. www.euractiv.com/eu-elections-2014/eurosceptics-compete-efd-groups-news-532158
8. www.thejc.com/news/world-news/115261/european-parliament-vote-a-step-too-far
9. www.ansa.it/web/notizie/rubriche/politica/2013/12/15/Lega-Salvini-contro-euro-Crimine-contro-umanita-_9781968.html
10. http://scenaripolitici.com/2014/03/sondaggio-scenaripolitici-3-marzo-2014-per-elezioni-europee-pd-275-m5s-254-fi-200-lega-63-tsipras-54-ncd-42-altripartiti-sotto-il-4.html
Flash Report – The staying power of the Eurosceptic voter rebellion
3
There are a number of other Eurosceptic
political parties that are expected to win in
the European Parliamentary elections that
cannot be classified as right-wing. These are
mostly new parties that have been
established in opposition to EU (and Member
States) policy responses to the economic
crisis. These parties include: Alternative for
Germany, SYRIZA in Greece and the Five Star
Movement (M5S) in Italy. In this report an
analysis is included on the voter base of M5S,
who put themselves centre stage in Italian
politics with 26% of the vote in the Italian
national elections in 2013 (with comparable
high polling numbers for the European
Parliamentary elections )¹¹.
Table 1: Right-wing and new Eurosceptic political parties
analysed in the survey¹²
Latest national elections
Political Party
UK
Independence
Party (UKIP)
Flemish
Interest (VB)
Freedom
Party (PVV)
National
Front (FN)
Northern
League (LN)
Five Stars
Movement
(M5S)
Country
United
Kingdom
European
Parliamentary
Elections 2009
Results Seats
Year
Results
2010
3%
17%
13
Belgium
Netherlands
2010
18%¹³
10%
2
2012
10%
17%
4
France
2012
14%
6%
3
Italy
2013
4%
10%
9
Italy
2013
26%
-
0
11. http://scenaripolitici.com/2014/03/sondaggio-scenaripolitici-3-marzo-2014-per-elezioni-europee-pd-275-m5s-254fi-200-lega-63-tsipras-54-ncd-42-altri-partiti-sotto-il-4.html
12. Data from www.wikipedia.com
13. Percentage taken from the Dutch language group vote
4
Flash Report – The staying power of the Eurosceptic voter rebellion
Methodology
In December 2013 and January 2014
Motivaction conducted a world-wide online
survey among respondents between age 18
and 65 in over 20 countries. For the purpose
of this current report analysis have been
made of the survey results in five European
countries:
the
UK,
Belgium,
the
Netherlands, France and Italy. The total
sample in these 5 countries contains 10,755
respondents. Voting behaviour in this survey
is based upon people’s recollection of their
vote during the last national elections. This
definition has the advantage over intended
voting behavior (as in opinion polls) because
it gives a better reflection of the people that
actually voted for certain political parties.
This survey therefore has no predictor value
about the results of the European
Parliamentary elections, but instead tries to
give insights in the values that underlie the
profile of the typical Eurosceptic voter. Only
for UKIP voters an exception is made in the
voter definition. Because the gap between
voting behavior in the latest national
elections in 2010 and voting intention now
is so large, the voting intention for UKIP has
been taken as the defining measure. Each
country in the survey has a subsample
differing between 2624 (Italy) and 1913
(Belgium) respondents. The data were
weighed so every country was equally
represented in the sample. All further
profiling analysis are based on a comparison
between right-wing Eurosceptic voters
(excluding M5S voters) and the average
outcome in the general population (not the
average voter). The analysis is made on 554
rightwing Eurosceptic voters taken together,
based on 117 National Front voters in the
last elections for the national parliament,
61 Northern League voters, 128 PVV voters,
104 Flemish Interest voters and 144
respondents who intend to vote UKIP if
elections for the national parliament were
held the day they completed the survey. In
a last paragraph a comparison is made
between the right-wing Eurosceptic voters
and voters for the M5S (388 voters from the
Italian sample).
Flash Report – The staying power of the Eurosceptic voter rebellion
5
Struggling working class
Let down by society
The socio-demographic profile of Eurosceptic
voters in some ways resembles the stereotype
of the ‘angry white man’. Eurosceptic voters
tend to be older (45+) and more often male
and married. In other characteristics the
Eurosceptic voter is more similar to the
average voter. Eurosceptic voters can be found
in all income groups and employment
situations (both employed and unemployed).
There are slightly more Eurosceptic voters with
lower education, but also those with higher
education are well represented. The
Eurosceptic voters do however associate
themselves more with the working class, a
group that according to many analysts are
experiencing stagnant wages and have not
profited even from the economic boom in the
nineties¹⁴. Eurosceptic voters also report
significantly more problems to ‘make ends
meet’, which makes clear that this group is
more than average struggling with the
economic crisis. More than other voter
segments they are facing difficulties in coping
with the pressures of the ever increasing
forces of globalisation.
The feeling of abandonment and mistrust is
key to understanding the state of mind of
the Eurosceptic voter. They feel ‘let down
by society’ more often. And they also have
less trust in other people. They find that ‘if
you give people too much freedom they will
abuse it’ and are less trustful that you can
‘take people on their word’. They are more
pessimistic about their own future and have
the fatalistic belief that every individual has
a particular destiny. In general they are less
happy in life than others. Apart from that
they are less willing to get involved in their
own community. The most pronounced
distrust is the low trust in their institutions.
Eurosceptic
voters
mistrust
their
government and parliament especially, but
also a range of other institutions such as
banks, religious institutions, trade unions
and the United Nations. Moreover this
institutional distrust includes the judiciary,
the one power that is supposed to hold a
check on the other two more political
institutions in the legislative and executive
branch.
Happiness
How happy do you feel
about your overall life
as a whole?
Basic Values
6,25
6,84
61%
47%
If you give people too much
freedom they abuse it
No trust in institutions
Government
66%
Parliament
Religion
Banks
Legal system
Trade union
United Nations
Eurosceptic
Non-eurosceptic
35%
65%
69%
55%
68%
60%
67%
47%
62%
52%
53%
86%
I believe in the existence of a
particular destiny for every…
44%
35%
84%
I sometimes feel that the
future holds nothing for me
40%
32%
I feel let down by society
36%
30%
Most of the time I take people
at their word
32%
38%
I feel strongly involved with
what is happening in my…
28%
34%
14. www.economist.com/news/briefing/21594264-previous-technological-innovation-has-always-delivered-more-long-run-employment-not-less
6
Flash Report – The staying power of the Eurosceptic voter rebellion
Seeking security and
structure
Watching TV
Maybe as a way to repair their crumbling
view on society, Eurosceptic voters are
longing for structure and security in their
own life. They like their life to be organised
and predictable. They more frequently
agree that ‘children should always obey
their parents’ and that nowadays there is
‘too little emphasis on traditional values’. In
general they are having more difficulties to
strategically navigate through modern life.
They find more often that ‘everything is
changing too fast’. This is also reflected in
their outlook on modern technology.
Naturally they make use of the internet, but
they are less frequent users of social media.
Instead TV remains their main media of
choice. They have a more utilitarian view on
life. Asked about the meaning of life they
more often answer: ‘having fun’.
Children should always obey
their parents
I like my life to be organised
and predictable
My most important aims are to
have fun and enjoy myself
Everything is changing too
often and too fast
18,16
15,51
Topics of concern
Immigration and integration
41%
57%
48%
56%
employment
Nature and environment
64%
36%
Crime and safety
17%
26%
Banking related issues urgent to solve
48%
Bonus culture
High salary level
Governments having to rescue
banks
Basic Values
I think that there is too little
emphasis on traditional values
in our country
Average hours spend
watching tv in a
week
35%
39%
29%
36%
27%
75%
57%
Eurosceptic
Non-eurosceptic
69%
59%
63%
54%
59%
47%
56%
46%
Eurosceptic
Non-eurosceptic
Flash Report – The staying power of the Eurosceptic voter rebellion
7
Tough on immigration,
crime and ‘corrupted elite’
It is sometimes suggested that there is more
political apathy among Eurosceptic voters, but
this is not reflected in this survey. Eurosceptic
voters do not differentiate from the average in
their interest for politics. They do have an
outspoken opinion about the political issues
that they care about. ‘Crime and safety’ and
‘immigration and integration’ are the most
distinctive issues that they find important. On
the other hand environmental policies and
concerns about employment score fairly low.
Eurosceptic voters are more than average
worried about governments having to rescue
banks. On social issues it is interesting that
while there is no large support for ‘more equal
distribution of wealth’, they are outspokenly
negative about the ‘bonus culture’ and the
generally ‘high salary levels’ in the banking
8
sector. This reflects a deep suspicion of
elites, which manifests itself also in their
support for companies to fight corruption
(instead of other Social Corporate
Responsibility goals). This suspicion of elites
also has a policy component in the sense
that Eurosceptic voters have a clear
aversion of all those policy issues that
elites, especially EU elites, tend to care very
much about: human rights, environmental
policies, cultural exchange and
multiculturalism. The one altruistic issue
that they do feel passionately about are
animal rights. Although this probably does
not point at fierce opposition against the
bio-industry, but relates more to their
affection for pets.
Flash Report – The staying power of the Eurosceptic voter rebellion
M5S voters: moderate
and modern, but similarly
disillusioned
The voting base that Beppe Grillo of the
Five Star Movement (M5S) has been able to
mobilize against Italy’s (and EU imposed)
economic policies is in many ways more
threatening for mainstream political parties
than the support for Eurosceptic parties
from the right. The reason is the far larger
potential voter base that parties such as
M5S can tap into. While right-wing voters
are older and generally more cynical, M5S
voters tend to be young and idealistic. On a
series of statements related to dreaming
about the future M5S voters score
significantly higher than average. Where
right-wing voters have difficulties with new
technology, M5S voters are frequent users
of it, especially in regards to social media. In
other words, M5S is tapping into the voting
base of the future. In political positioning
right-wing voters and M5S voters also
differentiate. The former are preoccupied
with immigration and crime, while the latter
care more about the environment and
employment. Nelson Mandela is often
mentioned as an icon by M5S voters, a
name much less mentioned by right-wing
voters. While having a modern and
moderate lifestyle, the similarity with right
wing voters is their general disillusion with
the current powers that be. Like right wing
voters they feel fundamentally let down by
society and the (political) leadership.
Appealing person
Nelson mandela
66%
27%
Topics of concern
Employment
52%
57%
Crime and safety
Nature and
environment
Immigration and
integration
Flash Report – The staying power of the Eurosceptic voter rebellion
81%
48%
17%
41%
37%
64%
Eurosceptic
M5S voters
9
Conclusion
The large number of value and normative
variables that set Eurosceptic voters apart
from the average indicate that right wing
parties might be able to build a lasting relation
with their voters. These are not one-off protest
votes, but votes of a group of people who feel
fundamentally disconnected from mainstream
politics and who recognize themselves in the
anti-establishment, anti-migration and anti-EU
rhetoric of right wing Eurosceptic parties.
Although this group is aging and generally less
engaged in societal debate and decision
making, this is an influential group during
elections. A political answer from mainstream
parties to this electoral group could be in
offering credible answers to their wish for
more structure and security in their personal
lives. For example by offering more protection
(welfare
state,
fighting
crime)
and
predictability (pensions, mortgages) on issues
where this group feels under pressure by the
economic crisis and other forces of
globalisation (migration, technology).
While the large group of right-wing
Eurosceptic voters should seriously worry
mainstream political parties, they should be
alarmed by the voter insurgency of more
mainstream oriented Eurosceptic parties such
as M5S. It is a sign on the wall when moderate
and modern voters turn their back towards the
European Union. Re-engaging this group of
voters in a positive way with the European
Union requires either a fundamental change of
course in the current way the EU (and Member
States) handle the economic crisis or the firm
believe that the current course will produce
economic results pretty soon.
10
Interested in the full
Electoral package?
This flash report only gives a glimpse of the
data and knowledge that is available about
voting behaviour, political issues and
communications. The full data-set consists of
hundreds of variables, throughout 8 EU
countries and 12 countries outside the
European Union. In a tailor made presentation
or report it is possible to zoom in on the voter
base and potential of relevant political parties
in specific countries and to build a
comprehensive voter and communications
profile for campaigning. Hereby you could think
about
socio-demographic
background,
attitudes towards political and social issues,
media use, activities, cultural values,
competitive analysis, etc.
For more information:
Martijn Lampert | research director
[email protected]
Tel: +31 (0)20 589 83 83
Roel Schoemaker | business development
[email protected]
Design: Wouter Vos
Analysis: Pieter Röhling & Anne Blanksma Çeta
Copyright: Motivaction International B.V.
2014, Amsterdam
Flash Report – The staying power of the Eurosceptic voter rebellion