43-101 Dikulushi Underground
Transcription
43-101 Dikulushi Underground
Mawson West Limited Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013. Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Perth Office Level 4, 50 Colin Street West Perth WA 6005 PO Box 1646 West Perth WA 6872 Australia Doc Ref: Tel: Fax: Print Date: 12 December 2013 Number of copies: Optiro Pty Limited ABN: 63 131 922 739 www.optiro.com Optiro: Mawson West Limited: Principal Author: Andrew Law MMin. MBA FAusIMM, FIQA, MAICD, AFAIM. Signature: Date: Principal Reviewer: Contributing author: +61 8 9215 0000 +61 8 9215 0011 12 December 2013 Ian Glacken FAusIMM(CP), CEng Signature: Date: 12 December 2013 Important Information: This Report is provided in accordance with the proposal by Optiro Pty Ltd (“Optiro”) to Mawson West Limited and the terms of Optiro’s Consulting Services Agreement (“the Agreement”). Optiro has consented to the use and publication of this Report by Mawson West Limited for the purposes set out in Optiro’s proposal and in accordance with the Agreement. Mawson West Limited may reproduce copies of this Report, in whole or in part, only for those purposes but may not and must not allow any other person to publish, copy or reproduce this Report in whole or in part without Optiro’s prior written consent. Unless Optiro has provided its written consent to the publication of this Report by Mawson West Limited for the purposes of a transaction, disclosure document or a product disclosure statement issued by Mawson West Limited pursuant to the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), Securities Act (Canada) or the rules of any relevant exchange, then Optiro accepts no responsibility to any other person for the whole or any part of this Report and accepts no liability for any damage, however caused, arising out of the reliance on or use of this Report by any person other than Mawson West Limited. While Optiro has used its reasonable endeavours to verify the accuracy and completeness of information provided to it by Mawson West Limited and on which it has relied in compiling the Report, it cannot provide any warranty as to the accuracy or completeness of such information to any person. P a g e | ii Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project, Democratic Republic of Congo A technical report on the Underground Project Prepared for Mawson West Limited Andrew Law Authors Director –Mining, Optiro Pty Ltd Ian Glacken Director –Geology, Optiro Pty Ltd MMin; MBA; FAusMM; FIQA; MAICD BSc (Hons) (Geology); Geology), MSc FAusIMM(CP), CEng MSc (Mining (Geostatistics), Date of report: 12 December 2013 P a g e | iii Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. SUMMARY 13 1.1. 1.2. 1.3. 1.4. 1.5. 1.6. 1.7. 1.8. 1.9. LOCATION OWNERSHIP MINERALISATION MINERAL RESOURCES & RESERVES MINING METALLURGICAL ECONOMIC ANALYSIS ENVIRONMENTAL CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATION 13 14 15 15 17 18 19 19 19 2. INTRODUCTION 20 2.1. 2.2. 2.3. 2.4. 2.5. 2.6. SCOPE OF THE REPORT AUTHORS PRINCIPAL SOURCES OF INFORMATION SITE VISIT INDEPENDENCE ABBREVIATIONS AND TERMS 20 20 21 22 23 23 3. RELIANCE ON OTHER EXPERTS 30 4. PROPERTY DESCRIPTION AND LOCATION 31 4.1. 4.2. 4.3. 4.4. 4.5. DEMOGRAPHICS AND GEOGRAPHIC SETTING PROJECT OWNERSHIP PROPERTY LOCATION THE PROPERTY TENEMENT AREA ENVIRONMENTAL PERMITS 31 31 31 32 34 5. ACCESSIBILITY, CLIMATE, LOCAL RESOURCES, INFRASTRUCTURE AND PHYSIOGRAPHY 36 5.1. 5.2. 5.3. 5.4. 5.5. 5.5.1. 5.5.2. 5.5.3. 5.5.4. 5.5.5. 5.5.6. 5.5.7. 5.5.8. ACCESS SITE TOPOGRAPHY, ELEVATION AND VEGETATION CLIMATE, PHYSIOGRAPHY, LOCAL RESOURCES AND INFRASTRUCTURE SURFACE RIGHTS SITE INFRASTRUCTURE WATER SUPPLY POWER SUPPLY MINE PERSONNEL TAILINGS STORAGE FACILITY ADMINISTRATION AND PLANT SITE BUILDINGS ACCOMMODATION COMMUNICATIONS MOBILE EQUIPMENT 36 36 37 37 37 38 38 39 39 39 40 41 41 P a g e | iv Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 5.5.9. SECURITY 42 6. HISTORY 44 6. 1. 6. 2. 6. 3. 6. 4. 6. 5. B E LG IA N EX PL OR A TI ON AN VI L M INI NG L TD M A W SO N W ES T RE S OU RC E H IS T OR Y PR O DU CT I ON HI S TO RY 44 44 45 45 46 7. GEOLOGICAL SETTING AND MINERALISATION 47 7.1. 7.2. REGIONAL SETTING PROJECT GEOLOGY 47 50 8. DEPOSIT TYPES 52 9. EXPLORATION 53 9.1. 9. 2. 9. 3. BRGM AN VI L M INI NG L TD EXP L OR AT I ON M W L EX PL OR A TI ON 53 53 54 10. DRILLING 55 10 .1 . 10 .2 . 10 .3 . 10 .4 . 10 .5 . 10 .6 . 10 .7 . 10 .8 . 10 .9 . 10 .1 0. INT RO D UC T ION AN VI L PR OGR AM M E 1 99 7 AN VI L PR OGR AM M E S 2 0 0 2 & 2 00 3 AN VI L PR OGR AM M E 2 00 4 AN VI L PR OGR AM M E 2 00 5 / 6 AN VI L PR OGR AM M E 2 00 7 AN VI L PR OGR AM M E 2 00 8 M W L P RO GR AM M E 2 01 0 SU RV E Y CON TR O L DR IL LI NG OR I EN TA T ION 55 55 56 56 56 57 57 57 58 58 11. SAMPLE PREPARATION, ANALYSIS AND SECURITY 59 11.1. 11.1.1. 11.1.2. 11.2. 11.3. 11 .4 . 11.4.1. 11 .5 . 11 .6 . 11.6.1. 11.6.2. 11 .7 . DIAMOND CORE SAMPLING DIAMOND CORE RECOVERY DIAMOND CORE LOGGING RC SAMPLING AND LOGGING SAMPLE QUALITY S AM P L E PR E P AR AT I ON A N D AN A LY TI C AL PR OC E D UR E S ANALYSES B UL K D E NS IT Y D E T ERM I NA TI ON S S AM P L E Q AQC STANDARDS AND BLANKS LABORATORY QAQC SU M M AR Y S T AT E M ENT 59 59 59 60 60 60 60 61 61 61 63 63 Page |v Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 12. DATA VERIFICATION 64 13. MINERAL PROCESSING AND METALLURGICAL TESTING 65 13.1. 13.2. 13.2.1. 13.2.2. 13.3. 13.4. INTRODUCTION ANVIL TESTWORK EARLY TESTWORK LATER TESTWORK PLANT OPERATIONAL RESULTS METALLURGICAL PROPERTIES OF THE CUT BACK ORE AND UNDERGROUND ORE 65 65 65 67 71 71 14. MINERAL RESOURCE ESTIMATES 75 14.1. 14.1.1. 14.1.2. 14.1.3. 14.1.4. 14.1.5. 14.1.6. 14.1.7. 14.1.8. 14.1.9. 14.1.10. 14.1.11. 14.1.12. 14.1.13. 14.1.14. 14.1.15. 14.2. 14.2.1. 14.2.2. 14.3. 14.3.1. 14.3.2. 14.3.3. 14.3.4. 14.3.5. 14.3.6. 14.3.7. 14.3.8. 14.3.9. 14.3.10. 14.3.11. DIKULUSHI MINERAL RESOURCE ESTIMATE GEOLOGICAL AND MINERALISATION MODELS DRILL DATA FOR MINERAL RESOURCE MODELLING DATA VALIDATION DATA PREPARATION FOR MODELLING DATA COMPOSITING STATISTICS SPATIAL STATISTICS BLOCK MODEL DENSITY ESTIMATES IN THE BLOCK MODEL DETERMINATION OF TOP CUTS GRADE ESTIMATION ORDINARY KRIGING INTERPOLATION MODEL VALIDATION MINERAL RESOURCE CLASSIFICATION RESOURCE TABULATION AND INVENTORY MINERAL RESOURCE ESTIMATE COMPARISONS MINERAL RESOURCE STATEMENT AUGUST 2011 VERSUS OCTOBER 2007 DEPLETION OF AUGUST 2011 MINERAL RESOURCES BY AUGUST 2013 OPEN PIT CUT BACK KAZUMBULA MINERAL RESOURCE ESTIMATE GEOLOGICAL AND MINERALISATION MODELS DRILL DATA FOR MINERAL RESOURCE MODELLING DATA VALIDATION DATA PREPARATION FOR MODELLING STATISTICS SPATIAL STATISTICS BLOCK MODEL DENSITY ESTIMATES IN THE BLOCK MODEL GRADE ESTIMATION MODEL VALIDATION MINERAL RESOURCE CLASSIFICATION 15. MINERAL RESERVE ESTIMATES 15.1. 15.2. DEPLETION OF THE OPEN PIT RESERVES UNDERGROUND MINE DESIGN AND SCHEDULE BASIS 75 77 78 79 79 80 81 81 84 85 85 85 85 86 88 89 89 89 91 94 94 95 96 97 97 97 97 99 99 100 100 101 101 101 P a g e | vi Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 15.2.1. 15.2.2. 15.3. 15.4. 15.5. EXISTING WORKINGS BASIS OF THE UNDERGROUND DESIGN AND SCHEDULE CUT-OFF GRADE CRITERIA MINING RECOVERY AND DILUTION UNDERGROUND MINERAL RESERVE TABULATION 16. MINING METHODS 16.1. 16.2. 16.2.1. 16.2.2. 16.2.3. 16.2.4. 16.3. 16.3.1. 16.3.2. 16.3.3. 16.3.4. 16.3.5. 16.4. 16.4.1. 16.4.2. 16.5. 16.6. 16.6.1. 16.6.2. 16.6.3. 16.6.4. 16.6.5. 16 .7 . 16.7.1. 16.7.2. 16.7.3. 16.7.4. 16 .8 . 16.8.1. 16.8.2. 16.8.3. 16.8.4. 16.8.5. 16.8.6. 16 .9 . 16.9.1. 16.9.2. 16.9.3. 16.9.4. 16.9.5. HISTORICAL MINING PROPOSED MINING METHOD – CUT AND FILL OVERHAND CUT AND FILL UNDERHAND CUT AND FILL MINING OF WIDER SECTIONS OF THE OREBODY PROPOSED MINING METHOD – EXTRACTION OF THE CROWN PILLAR GEOTECHNICAL DESIGN PARAMETERS STOPE LAYOUT AND SEQUENCE DRILL AND BLAST ORE EXTRACTION BACKFILLING ACCESSING THE OREBODY & REHABILITATION OF OLD WORKINGS VENTILATION PRIMARY VENTILATION SECONDARY VENTILATION DEWATERING MINING EQUIPMENT MINE DEVELOPMENT MINING SCHEDULE MINING SHIFTS DEVELOPMENT / STOPING RATES AIR LEG DEVELOPMENT RATES GE O T EC HN IC A L DATA GEOTECHNICAL DOMAINS POTENTIAL FAILURES MAPPING, MONITORING AND ADDITIONAL DATA GRO UN D S U PP OR T R E Q UI R EM EN TS SPLIT SETS SOLID STEEL ROCKBOLTS CABLE BOLTS SHOTCRETE GEOTECHNICAL FILL REVIEW CRF MIXING GRO UN D S U PP OR T ST A ND AR D S DECLINE SUPPORT STANDARD ACCESS SUPPORT STANDARD ORE DRIVE SUPPORT STANDARD WITH MESH 3 WAY INTERSECTION SUPPORT STANDARD 4-WAY INTERSECTION SUPPORT STANDARD 101 103 103 106 107 108 108 108 108 109 110 112 113 113 113 113 114 116 117 117 119 119 121 122 123 128 131 132 133 133 133 135 135 135 137 137 137 137 138 138 139 140 141 142 143 144 P a g e | vii Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 16 .1 0. 16 .1 1. W AS T E D UM P D ES IG N SU RF A C E WA T ER M A N A GE M ENT 145 145 17. RECOVERY METHODS 17.1. 17.2. 17.3. PLANT FLOWSHEET TAILINGS STORAGE FACILITIES (TSF) PROCESSING STATISTICS 18. PROJECT INFRASTRUCTURE 18.1. 18.2. 18.3. SURFACE FACILITIES POWER PROCESS WATER SUPPLY 19. MARKET STUDIES AND CONTRACTS 19.1. 19.2. MARKETS CONTRACTS 20. ENVIRONMENTAL STUDIES, PERMITTING AND SOCIAL OR COMMUNITY IMPACT156 21. CAPITAL AND OPERATING COSTS 21.1. 21.2. 21.2.1. 21.2.2. 21.2.3. 21.2.4. 21.3. CAPITAL COST ESTIMATE OPERATING COST ESTIMATE MINING OPERATING COST PROCESSING OPERATING COSTS MANAGEMENT AND ADMINISTRATION COSTS TRANSPORT AND SMELTING COSTS METAL PRICES 22. ECONOMIC ANALYSIS 161 22.1. 22.1.1. 22.2. 22.3. 22.4. OPERATIONS SUMMARY SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS PAYBACK MINE LIFE TAXATION 161 166 166 167 167 23. ADJACENT PROPERTIES 168 24. OTHER RELEVANT DATA AND INFORMATION 169 25. INTERPRETATION AND CONCLUSIONS 170 26. RECOMMENDATIONS 171 146 146 147 148 151 151 152 152 154 154 154 158 158 159 159 160 160 161 161 P a g e | viii Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 27. REFERENCES 172 28. CERTIFICATES 174 TABLES Table 1.1 Table 1.2 Table 1.3 Table 1.4 Table 1.5 Table 1.6 Table 2.1 Table 4.1 Table 6.1 Table 6.2 Table 6.3 Table 6.4 Table 9.1 Table 10.1 Table 13.1 Table 13.2 Table 13.3 Table 13.4 Table 13.5 Table 13.6 Table 13.7 Table 13.8 Table 13.9 Table 13.10 Table 13.11 Table 13.12 Table 13.13 Table 14.1 Table 14.2 Table 14.3 Table 14.4 Table 14.5 Table 14.6 Table 14.7 Table 14.8 Dikulushi Mineral Resource statement as at August 2011, using a 1.0% copper cut-off grade Depleted Dikulushi Mineral Resource statement as at August 2013, using a 1.0% copper cutoff grade Dikulushi Mineral Reserve statement as at August 2011, at a 1.0% copper cut-off grade Depleted Dikulushi Mineral Reserve statement as at August 2013, at a 1.0% copper cut-off grade Dikulushi Underground Mineral Reserve statement as at September 2013 The Kazumbula Mineral Resource statement as at November 2010 Glossary of terms Mawson West Limited Dikulushi tenement schedule Historical work summary at the Dikulushi Project Mineral Resource estimate as completed by FinOre in July 2006 and published in December 2006; a cut-off grade of 1.5% copper was used Historical Anvil production for the Dikulushi mine Recent MWL production for the Dikulushi mine Historical drilling summary for the Dikulushi copper silver project MWL drilling at Kazumbula Details of Dikulushi drill core used in Mintek metallurgical testing Head grades of chalcocite composites Relative abundance of significant minerals Comminution testwork results Effect of grind size on flotation performance (high grade chalcocite) Effects of collector addition on flotation performance (high grade chalcocite) Effect of grind size on flotation performance (disseminated and low grade chalcocite) Effect of collector addition on flotation performance (disseminated and low grade chalcocite) Effect of grind size and Eh level on flotation performance (Pb/Zn rich chalcocite) Head grades of chalcocite composites Locked cycle flotation test results Dikulushi processing summary (February 2007 – April 2008) Dikulushi processing summary (June 2010 – July 2013) Dikulushi Mineral Resource statement as at August 2011 above a 1.0% copper cut-off grade Domain codes for Dikulushi modelling Summary statistics for copper % and silver g/t per domain Dikulushi variogram models with angle1 about axis 3 (Z), angle2 about axis 1 (X) and angle3 about axis 3 (Z) Dikulushi - top cuts per domain Mean statistics per domain comparing model estimates with data values Dikulushi Mineral Resource statement using a 1.0% copper cut-off grade as at August 2011 Comparison of 2011 and 2007 Dikulushi Mineral Resource estimates 15 15 16 16 16 17 24 33 44 46 46 46 53 57 66 67 68 68 68 69 69 69 69 70 70 72 72 76 80 81 83 85 86 89 90 P a g e | ix Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Table 14.9 Table 14.10 Table 14.11 Table 14.12 Table 14.13 Table 14.14 Table 15.1 Table 15.2 Table 15.3 Table 15.4 Table 16.1 Table 16.2 Table 16.3 Table 16.4 Table 16.5 Table 16.6 Table 16.7 Table 16.8 Table 16.9 Table 16.10 Table 16.11 Table 16.12 Table 16.13 Table 16.14 Table 16.15 Table 16.16 Table 16.17 Table 16.18 Table 17.1 Table 17.2 Table 21.1 Table 21.2 Table 21.3 Table 21.4 Table 21.5 Table 22.1 Table 22.2 Comparison of August 2011 and August 2013 Dikulushi Mineral Resource estimates, showing the Open pit cut back depletion MWL drilling at Kazumbula Summary statistics of the two metre composite data for Cu% and Ag g/t for the Kazumbula deposit Density estimates for the Kazumbula deposit A table of mean statistics comparing model estimates with data values Kazumbula Mineral Resource statement as at November 2010. Dikulushi Mineral Reserve statement as at August 2011, using a 1.0% copper cut-off grade Depleted Dikulushi Mineral Reserve statement as at August 2013, using a 1.0% copper cut-off grade Mining dilution table Dikulushi Mineral Reserve statement as at September 2013 CRF Specifications CAF Specifications Dikulushi production mining equipment at site from previous mining activities Major mining fleet and equipment required for the extraction of the Dikulushi underground Mineral Reserves Underground horizontal development design parameters Underground vertical development design parameters Mining dilution Underground mine production physicals Work shifts Operational Management Labour Technical Services labour Support functions labour Labour requirements: underground operations Underground Workshop personnel Jumbo/production drill rates by development type Jumbo/production drill rates by individual machine Jumbo/production drill rates by fleet Air Leg development Dikulushi processing summary relevant to ore to be mined in the pit cut back Processing statistics for the LG material completed by MWL – June 2010 to May 2011 Dikulushi underground capital expenditure cost estimate. Major mining fleet and equipment required for the extraction of the Dikulushi underground Mineral Reserves Mining overhead and fixed costs Mining variable costs Metal prices used in modelling Dikulushi mining and financial summary Sensitivity analysis on the cash flow forecast for underground mining and treatment at Dikulushi 92 96 97 99 100 100 101 101 106 107 115 116 121 122 122 123 126 128 129 129 129 130 130 131 131 132 132 133 149 149 158 159 160 160 161 163 166 FIGURES Figure 1.1 Figure 4.1 Locality plan of the Dikulushi Project Exploration Licences of the Dikulushi copper silver project 14 32 Page |x Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Figure 4.2 Figure 4.3 Figure 5.1 Figure 5.2 Figure 5.3 Figure 5.4 Figure 5.5 Figure 5.6 Figure 5.7 Figure 5.8 Figure 7.1 Figure 7.2 Figure 7.3 Figure 7.4 Figure 11.1 Figure 11.2 Figure 11.3 Figure 11.4 Figure 13.1 Figure 14.1 Figure 14.2 Figure 14.3 Figure 14.4 Figure 14.5 Figure 14.6 Figure 14.7 Figure 14.8 Figure 14.9 Figure 14.10 Figure 14.11 Figure 14.12 Figure 14.13 Figure 14.14 Figure 14.15 Figure 14.16 Figure 14.17 Dikulushi mine infrastructure within the PE 606 Dikulushi mine site aerial view Barge on Lake Mweru Composite Temperature and Rainfall Data recorded over the last 5 years. Dikulushi airstrip and the G1 Charter plane provides safe staff transportation to and from site Dikulushi Administration Centre Dikulushi Camp Site Dikulushi Clinic and communications centre Dikulushi Workshop Dikulushi Store and Fuel Farm Regional Geology of Mawson’s convention area in the DRC Stratigraphy of Dikulushi region with known styles of mineralisation Local geology of the Dikulushi open pit A typical vertical cross section through the Kazambula deposit, highlighting key geology associated with mineralisation GBM301-7 suggests accurate values around low value samples (~0.55% Cu) The GBM301-8 is a high Cu value standard and suggests accurate results for high value samples (~10% Cu) The GBM398-4c is a low Cu value standard and suggests accurate results for low value samples (~0.39% Cu) Results for this blank demonstrate that contamination is well contained Dikulushi Underground sources of ore - showing North-South section view at 50205E An oblique southward looking 3D view of drillhole type and distribution at Dikulushi A vertically oriented 3D view at Dikulushi, looking southwest, showing mineralisation lenses and current drilling A plan showing the distribution of drillhole types across Dikulushi; blasthole data from the pit have been excluded Quantile-Quantile (Q-Q) plot of Diamond (DD) drilled samples versus sludge drilled samples within a common area Cumulative distribution of sample lengths highlighting the dominant 1m sample length Log histogram and probability plot for the main FW zone of mineralisation showing the results of robust domaining Variogram models for copper % across the FW zone of mineralisation A plan view slice through the FW zone block model illustrating the good comparison between model estimates and the nearby drillhole data A statistical plot of estimates versus drillhole data grades for successive 30m increments in elevation and the full strike length of the FW zone mineralisation 3D view of the Dikulushi model, looking south, and showing resource classification categories A waterfall chart of cumulative Mineral Resource changes from 2007 to 2011 A waterfall chart of cumulative Mineral Resource changes from 2011 to 2013 Grade tonnage curves for the combined remaining Measured and Indicated Mineral Resources Kazumbula vertical section, looking north, highlighting the modelled mineralisation as per the RC and diamond drilling Plan showing the distribution of RC and diamond drillholes across the Kazumbula deposit. Histogram and probability plots for the Kazumbula deposit two metre sample data. Variogram modelling for Cu % in the plane of mineralisation. 33 35 36 37 38 40 40 41 42 43 48 49 50 51 62 62 62 63 73 76 77 78 79 80 82 84 87 87 88 91 93 93 95 96 98 99 P a g e | xi Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Figure 15.1 Figure 15.2 Figure 15.3 Figure 16.1 Figure 16.2 Figure 16.3 Figure 16.4 Figure 16.5 Figure 16.6 Figure 16.7 Figure 16.8 Figure 16.9 Figure 16.10 Figure 16.11 Figure 16.12 Figure 16.13 Figure 16.14 Figure 16.15 Figure 16.16 Figure 16.17 Figure 17.1 Figure 18.1 Figure 18.2 Figure 18.3 Figure 20.1 Existing workings, showing as built underground development (grey), and the as-built pit (green) Underground reserve, showing as-built underground development (grey), as-built pit (green), and measured (purple) and indicated (red) Mineral Resources Relationship between cut-off NSR and metal grades Overhand cut and fill mining process Underhand cut and fill mining process Diagrammatic representation of sequential mining in wide orebody areas Orebody access development Pillar ratio diagram LHD loader with ‘rammer-jammer attachment Underground primary ventilation circuit (full) Underground primary ventilation circuit required for the extraction of the measured and indicated material only Primary ventilation fan location Existing underground dewatering infrastructure locations Proposed underground dewatering infrastructure locations Ore loss due to gaps left in the backfilling process Ore level schedule, by quarter Dikulushi orebody rock quality, Q (Turner, 2013) Dikulushi footwall rock quality, Q (Turner, 2013) Dikulushi hanging wall rock quality, Q (Turner, 2013) Dikulushi rock reinforcement chart (Turner, 2013) Dikulushi Plant flow diagram On-site office facilities at Dikulushi On-site Underground change room facilities at Dikulushi Average water balance Community Business making work clothes for the mine. 102 103 106 109 110 111 112 112 114 118 118 119 120 120 126 128 134 134 135 136 147 151 151 153 157 P a g e | xii Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 1. SUMMARY Mawson West Limited’s (MWL’s) Dikulushi Underground Project (the Project) is located in the Katanga Province of the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC). The Underground Mine comprises Mineral Resources from the main Dikulushi deposit’s “Footwall” zone, which has a 230 m strike length and true widths of up to 25 m. The open pit was recently completed as a cut back extension of the old Dikulushi open pit mined by Anvil Mining Limited (Anvil) during its tenure of the Dikulushi deposit. MWL has now completed an underground pre-feasibility study to re-enter and re-establish the old underground workings and mine out the previously developed high grade Mineral Reserves as a first stage. This study is the focus of this Technical Report, which also details information regarding the associated Kazumbula project. In addition to the mining of the remaining developed Mineral Reserves during the first stage, MWL will continue to explore and evaluate depth extensions of the remaining underground Inferred Mineral Resource. This will be done through additional underground drilling from within the reestablished Dikulushi underground workings and, once completed, will form the basis of further underground feasibility study work based on the additional drilling and Mineral Resource evaluation outcomes. 1.1. LOCATION The Project is located at latitude 08°53’37.7 south and longitude 28°16’21.8 east in the south eastern corner of the DRC, approximately 50 km north-northwest of the small town of Kilwa and situated on the south western side of Lake Mweru (Figure 1.1). P a g e | 13 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Figure 1.1 Locality plan of the Dikulushi Project 1.2. OWNERSHIP The Dikulushi mine is governed by the Dikulushi Mining Convention signed on January 31, 1998 with the Government of the DRC, and ratified by Presidential Decree issued on February 27, 1998. The Dikulushi Mining Convention is a mining concession granted to Anvil Mining Congo SARL (AMC) which sets out the regulatory and fiscal regime applicable to the tenements owned by AMC. Mawson West Investments Ltd, a wholly owned subsidiary of Mawson West Limited, holds 90% of the issued capital of AMC, with the remaining 10% being held by the Dikulushi–Kapulo Foundation NPO. Mining operations at Dikulushi are currently conducted under the Exploitation Permit 606 (PE) issued by Ministerial Decree under the terms of the Dikulushi Mining Convention. This guarantees the sole and exclusive rights to the benefit of the holding company for 20 years until 2022. The Dikulushi deposit forms part of the PE. This report presents technical information on the Dikulushi deposit, relating to the recently completed open pit cut back and, more particularly, to the planned re-establishment of the underground workings and trial stoping of the previously developed levels. Additionally, further exploration and drilling of the Inferred Mineral Resource and currently unclassified material will also be undertaken from the re-established underground workings. P a g e | 14 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 1.3. MINERALISATION The Dikulushi copper deposit is interpreted to be a hypogene, fault-controlled orebody, comprising disseminated, brecciated and massive chalcocite-bornite mineralisation with a supergene weathered and oxidised zone of semi-massive malachite, azurite and nodular cuprite. Most of the oxidised portion of the Dikulushi deposit has been mined out. 1.4. MINERAL RESOURCES & RESERVES The current Mineral Resource of the Dikulushi orebody has been derived from a mineralisation interpretation based upon copper drillhole grades. A block model estimate was completed in May 2009 by David Gray of Optiro and was depleted in August 2011 with updated surveyed volumes of historical mining. The resulting Mineral Resource is stated for a 1.0% copper cut-off grade in Table 1.1. Table 1.1 Dikulushi Mineral Resource statement as at August 2011, using a 1.0% copper cut-off grade Category Measured Mineral Resources Indicated Mineral Resources Total Measured and Indicated Mineral Resources Category Volume 3 (m *1,000) 184 90 274 Volume 3 (m *1,000) Density 3 (t/m ) 2.8 2.8 2.8 Density 3 (t/m ) Tonnes (*1,000) Copper (%) 516 251 7.0 5.6 767 Tonnes (*1,000) Silver (g/t) 6.6 Copper (%) Inferred Mineral Resources 136 2.8 380 The inferred silver grade was incorrectly reported previously at 91 g/t; the correct grade is 155g/t 211 114 179 Silver (g/t) 6.8 91 The resulting estimates are supported by historical production and current processing grades. The August 2011 Mineral Resource from Table 1.1 has now been depleted by the open pit cutback. The remaining Mineral Resources are stated for a 1.0% copper cut-off grade in Table 1.2. Table 1.2 Depleted Dikulushi Mineral Resource statement as at August 2013, using a 1.0% copper cut-off grade Category Measured Mineral Resources Indicated Mineral Resources Total Measured and Indicated Mineral Resources Category Volume 3 (m *1,000) 74 53 127 Volume 3 (m *1,000) Density 3 (t/m ) 2.8 2.8 2.8 Density 3 (t/m ) Tonnes (*1,000) 207 148 354 Tonnes (*1,000) Copper (%) Silver (g/t) 5.4 6.6 5.9 Copper (%) 163 131 150 Silver (g/t) Inferred Mineral Resources 130 2.8 365 7.0 160 The inferred silver grade was incorrectly reported at 91 g/t in the August 2011 Mineral Resource table and should have been 155g/t. This has now been corrected and adjusted accordingly in the depleted Mineral Resource. The open pit Mineral Reserves, as published 16 September 2011 and revised 8 January 2013, are shown in Table 1.3 and are stated for a 1.0% copper cut-off grade. Mineral Resources are reported as inclusive of Mineral Reserves. The Mineral Reserve, as per the CIM definition, incorporated mining losses and dilution material brought about by the mining operation. P a g e | 15 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Table 1.3 Dikulushi Mineral Reserve statement as at August 2011, at a 1.0% copper cut-off grade Category Volume 3 (m *1,000) Density 3 (t/m ) Tonnes (*1,000) Copper (%) Silver (g/t) Proven Probable 66.6 127.8 2.8 2.8 184.7 354.3 7.27% 5.51% 207 169 Total Proven and Probable Reserves 194.4 2.8 539.0 6.12% 182 The open pit Mineral Reserves have now been depleted with the mining of the open pit cut back as this was completed during July 2013. The open pit Mineral Reserves were based on the open pit reaching the 810 mRL. Mining ceased at the 825 mRL following some isolated sections of the pit wall deteriorating beyond what was predicted. Table 1.4 shows the depleted Mineral Reserves post cessation of mining of the open pit cut back. Table 1.4 Depleted Dikulushi Mineral Reserve statement as at August 2013, at a 1.0% copper cut-off grade Category Volume 3 (m *1,000) Density 3 (t/m ) Tonnes (*1,000) Copper (%) Silver (g/t) Proven Probable 1.0 29.9 2.8 2.8 2.7 83.7 6.8 5.5 186 188 Total Proven and Probable Reserves 30.9 2.8 86.4 5.5 188 The above remaining Mineral Reserves have subsequently been incorporated into the Underground Mineral Reserves, which are presented in Table 1.5 below and are now based on an NSR value cut off value of US$329/t, using a copper price of US$3.08/lb and a Silver price of US$20 per oz. Mineral Resources are inclusive of Mineral Reserves. The Mineral Reserve, as per the CIM definition, incorporates mining losses and dilution material expected to be incurred through the underground mining operation. Table 1.5 Dikulushi Underground Mineral Reserve statement as at September 2013 Category Volume 3 (m *1,000) Density 3 (t/m ) Tonnes (*1,000) Copper (%) Silver (g/t) Proven Probable 0 62 0 2.8 0 173 0 5.2 0 127 Total Proven and Probable Reserves 62 2.8 173 5.2 127 Notes: 1) The reporting cut-off grade is based on an NSR value of US$329/t, using a copper price of US$3.08/lb and a Silver price of US$20 per oz. 2) The above Mineral Reserve does not include any Inferred Mineral Resources. The Mineral Reserves detailed above are derived from the depleted Measured and Indicated Mineral Resources that remain below the open pit floor at the 825 m RL, and which can be economically extracted based on the modifying factors as compiled in the underground pre-feasibility study. The Kazumbula orebody was originally drilled by Anvil. MWL has developed confidence in this deposit’s grade and geological continuity by drilling additional reverse circulation (RC) and HQ3 diamond core during 2010. A litho-structural and grade based interpretation was completed by P a g e | 16 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 MWL geological staff. The Mineral Resources for Kazumbula effectively use a 0.5% copper cut-off grade for defining the mineralised volume and are shown in Table 1.6 below. Table 1.6 The Kazumbula Mineral Resource statement as at November 2010 Category Indicated Mineral Resources Volume 3 (m *1,000) 126 Density 3 (t/m ) 2.5 Tonnes (*1,000) 318 Copper (%) Silver (g/t) 1.8 19 1.5. MINING With the completion of the open pit cut back, continuation of mining activities at the Dikulushi project will now focus on re-establishing the underground mining operation at the deposit in order to exploit the previously-developed workings from underground mining activities conducted by previous owner of the mine, Anvil. Re-commencement of the underground mining activities requires the rehabilitation and reestablishment of the ventilation, electrical, air and water services. The mine is currently being dewatered, which is nearing completion. In addition to the re-establishment of services, additional ground support checks and repairs will be required to ensure that the existing underground development is to the required standard in order to allow safe access to the underground mining areas. Initial rehabilitation of the underground workings is expected to take approximately one month, and will be tied in with the development of service infrastructure requirements for the underground operations which includes escape way rises, return airway rises, and the installation of the primary ventilation fans. Production activities will commence in levels that were partially complete from previous underground mining activities. Work on these levels will extract the remaining ore contained within. Once the ore has been extracted from these levels, each of the drives will be backfilled using cemented fill. Development activities will also commence in other parts of the underground mine, establishing new levels for production. Ore extraction from the underground will be completed using overhand and underhand cut and fill mining practices, with the bulk of the ore being removed using the overhand mining method. Extraction of the ore between the upper levels of the underground workings and the bottom of the pit (the crown pillar) will be completed using a long hole stoping method. In addition to the recommencement of underground mining activities, additional exploration drilling is planned to be undertaken in order to upgrade the known Inferred Mineral Resource to a Measured and/or Indicated classification and possibly extend the depth of the Mineral Resource. The crown pillar extraction is planned to take place on a retreat method as a final operation prior to closing the underground on completion of the extraction of the current Mineral Reserves. Should the planned exploration drilling upgrade and extend the additional areas of the Mineral Resource classification, and thus the Mineral Reserves, mining of the crown pillar ore tonnes will need to be deferred. P a g e | 17 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 The current underground life of mine is 19 months, including one month for the re-establishment of the existing underground workings. The average monthly ore production rate over the life of mine is approximately 7,200 t at an average Copper grade of 5.15% Cu and a Silver grade of 127 g/t Ag. The production tonnes and grade quoted include the extraction of the crown pillar ore during the last 6 months of the mining schedule. 1.6. METALLURGICAL Several metallurgical testwork programmes have been completed by Anvil on the Dikulushi ore and are discussed in Chapter 13. These results are appropriate for deposits with similar styles of mineralisation, such as Kazumbula, and have subsequently been compared against actual production results during the period of operation by Anvil and more recently by MWL. The most recent metallurgical testwork was managed by Sedgman Metals, a metallurgical consulting company of Perth, Western Australia. Testwork was completed at AMDEL Laboratories in Perth. Metallurgical testwork was carried out previously by Anvil on the main Dikulushi orebody. Additional testwork was reported on in June 2004 by Independent Metallurgical Laboratories (IML), which utilised samples provided from the mill feed and an open pit sample to perform a locked cycle flotation test. Results indicated that from a feed grade of 8.76% copper and 306 g/t silver a recovery of 91.1% copper and 89.7% silver could be achieved to produce a concentrate with grades of 42.1% copper and 1,447 g/t silver. This sample contained 18% acid soluble copper in feed. Actual production results during operations by Anvil were higher. The float plant at Dikulushi operated from 2007 to 2008, was fed with high grade ore from the open pit and underground mine, and yielded recoveries of 90.4% copper and 90.3% silver, producing a concentrate with 55.5% copper and 1721 g/t silver. The current plant, under MWL control over the past year, has been fed from the open pit cut back and low grade stockpiles, with recoveries averaging 91.5% copper and 90.3% silver, producing a concentrate with 56.5% copper and 1,515 g/t silver. Plant operation under MWL over the past 6 months of production (Feb 2013 to July 2013) has seen fresh ore feed from the open pit cut back, combined with improved operating management practises, resulting in improved recoveries of 94.3% copper and 92.1% silver, producing a concentrate with 61.4% copper and 1,768 g/t silver. There has been no change in the material ore types since the previous open pit and underground operations and it is therefore expected that the current recoveries being achieved for the fresh ore from the open pit cut back feed will continue to be achieved with the re-establishment of the underground operations. The financial model uses 94% recovery for copper and 90% for silver, with a copper concentrate grade of 60% copper. P a g e | 18 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 1.7. ECONOMIC ANALYSIS In summary, the underground operation will produce some 174, 000 tonnes of ore at a copper grade of 5.15g/t and a silver grade of 127 g/t over a 19 month production period. This will produce some 8,100 tons of copper metal and 573,500 ounces of Silver for sale. Total operating costs are estimated at $44.6M ($257 per ore tonne milled or $1.86 per lb of copper - net of the silver credit); and the total net revenue is estimated at $57.7M, with net cashflow totalling $3M. The Internal Rate of Return is 8% for the project, and the Capital cost for the project is $9.6M. 1.8. ENVIRONMENTAL An Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) for the Dikulushi project was lodged in 2003. In 2009, an EIA for the underground Project was submitted to the DRC Government. Both of these reports were compiled by African Mining Consultants of Kitwe, Zambia, an environmental company that was licensed to work and report in the DRC. In 2011, an EIA for the cutback project was prepared by EMIS sprl, a DRC environmental company licenced to work and report in the DRC. All three environmental reports received DRC Government approval. A revised EIA, extending underground mining beyond 2013, has been submitted to Government. MWL has lodged $1.19M as an environmental bond. This financial guarantee is a contribution towards environmental rehabilitation costs for the Dikulushi mine. 1.9. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATION The Project is at an advanced stage and Dikulushi may be described as a producing and developing property. MWL has completed a pre-feasibility study in order to determine the economics of continuing to mine the Dikulushi deposit via the previously established and developed underground workings. Since this was previously an operating open pit and underground mine, the remaining ore zones present the same risks as before, being somewhat mitigated for the mineralogy, metallurgical properties and the processing aspects, which are well known. Risks associated with the mining operations will remain, however, and constant recognition of changing conditions will need to be ensured with appropriate changes made as mining progresses. Geotechnical knowledge will increase with the physical mining activities and a better understanding of the underground ground conditions will be established. There is likely to be continued resource development drilling throughout the mining operations in order to locate and evaluate additional resources associated with the same ore zone, either at depth or as lateral or parallel extensions. During the period required to re-establish the underground workings and re-commence development and stoping operations, MWL intends to continue processing the HG open pit cut back stockpile. In addition MWL is currently in the process of defining additional deposits on the Dikulushi property and within 50 km of the Dikulushi plant. P a g e | 19 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 2. INTRODUCTION 2.1. SCOPE OF THE REPORT Mawson West Limited (MWL) commissioned Optiro Pty Ltd (Optiro) in May 2013 to review the underground pre-feasibility study, generated by MWL, and to prepare an independent technical report regarding the copper-silver Mineral Reserves at the Dikulushi underground deposit based on the above study. This Technical Report has been written to comply with the reporting requirements of the Canadian National Instrument 43-101 guidelines, “Standards of disclosure for Mineral Properties” dated April 2011 (the Instrument) and with the “Australasian Code for Reporting of Mineral Resources and Ore Reserves” of December 2004 (the JORC Code) as produced by the Joint Ore Reserves Committee of the Australasian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy, Australian Institute of Geoscientists and Minerals Council of Australia (JORC 2004). The Technical Report has been written to provide the market with an update on the status of the Mineral Resources and Reserves for the Dikulushi Open Pit cut back project (mining now complete and processing due for completion late 2013) and to present the first stage of the underground Project study, which is to re-enter and re-establish the old underground workings and to mine out the previously developed high grade Mineral Reserves. This is the focus of this Technical Report. For completeness, the Mineral Resource estimation of the related but separate Kazumbula project is also described. All monetary amounts expressed in this report are in United States of America dollars (US$) unless otherwise stated. 2.2. AUTHORS The key authors for compiling this report are: Mr Andrew Law is the principal author and Qualified Person and takes overall responsibility for this report. Mr Law is the Director - Mining at Optiro and is a professional Mining Engineer. He has a HND Metalliferous Mining (1982) and an MBA from the University of Western Australia. He has more than 30 years’ experience in the planning, development and extraction of mineral reserves. Mr Law is a Fellow of the Australasian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy (FAusIMM) and has the relevant qualifications, experience and independence to be considered as a “Qualified Person” as defined in Canadian National Instrument 43-101. Mr Law has visited the Dikulushi deposit (February 2012) and the underground workings to the 830 m RL. Mr Law was a previous author for the Dikulushi Open Pit Cut back NI 43-101 report generated by Optiro for MWL. Mr Law has reviewed all sections of the “Pre-Feasibility” study generated by various other Qualified Persons, most of whom were independent of Mawson West, and collated into a pre-feasibility study by MWL. Mr Ian Glacken is a Qualified Person and takes responsibility for the Mineral Resources estimation portion of this report. Mr Glacken, is a full time employee of Optiro, where he holds the position of Geology Director, and is a professional Geologist. Mr Glacken has P a g e | 20 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 degrees from Durham University (BSc (Hons) Geology, 1979), The Royal School of Mines (MSc Mineral Exploration, 1981), Stanford University (MSc Geostatistics, 1996) and Deakin University (Postgraduate Diploma of Computing, 1996). Mr Glacken is a Fellow of the Australasian Institution of Mining and Metallurgy (Member Number 107194) and a Chartered Professional Geoscientist of that Institution. He is also a Member of the Institute of Mining, Metallurgy and Materials (UK) and a Chartered Engineer of that institution. Mr Glacken has the relevant qualifications, experience and independence to be considered as a “Qualified Person” as defined in Canadian National Instrument 43-101. Mr Glacken has not visited the Dikulushi deposit but has reviewed and supervised Mineral Resource models on the Dikulushi deposits. Optiro is an Australian-based mining and resources consulting and advisory firm which provides a broad range of expert services and advice, locally and internationally, to the minerals industry and financial institutions. In September 2011 Optiro generated and supervised Mineral Resource and Reserves models for the Dikulushi open pit cut back. In August 2013, Optiro depleted the Mineral Resource and subsequently the open pit cut back Mineral Reserves. With the completion of the open pit cut back, Optiro has now generated underground Mineral Reserves for the Dikulushi deposit based on the depleted Mineral Resources as at August 2013. Optiro is an Australian based mining and resources consulting and advisory firm which provides a broad range of expert services and advice, locally and internationally, to the minerals industry and financial institutions. The following authors contributed to the report: Name Andrew Law Ian Glacken Position Director-Mining, Optiro Pty Ltd Director – Geology, Optiro Pty Ltd Mike Turner Turner Mining and Geotechnical Pty Ltd Duncan Grant-Stuart Knight Piesold Consulting Peter Hayward Sedgman Ltd NI 43-101 Contribution Principal Qualified Person Qualified Person and contributing author of sections 1, 7.8, 9, 10, 11, 12 & 14. Geotechnical, QP and author of geotechnical submission in section 16 Engineer, QP and reviewer of tailings storage facilities in section 17 Metallurgical, QP and input into section 13 and 17. 2.3. PRINCIPAL SOURCES OF INFORMATION The principal source of information used to prepare this report is the information prepared for the development of the pre-feasibility study and the previously submitted NI 43-101 Technical Reports covering Mineral Resources and Reserves at Dikulushi. This pre-feasibility information was provided to Optiro by MWL. The Mineral Resource information has been sourced from the previously submitted NI 43-101 Technical Report, by Optiro, on the Dikulushi Project, Democratic Republic of Congo, 16 September 2011 and revised 8 January 2013. The Mineral Resource has recently undergone a review and depletion process based on the recently completed open pit cut back. In summary, the following are primary data sources: P a g e | 21 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 the NI 43-101 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Project, Democratic Republic of Congo, February 3, 2011 and subsequently revised March 7, 2011 historical and current production and processing data the NI 43-101 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Open Pit Project, Democratic Republic of Congo, issued 16 September, 2011 and Revised 8 January, 2013. A pre-feasibility study for the underground prepared by Mawson West based on inputs from various independent qualified persons. Optiro has made all reasonable enquiries to establish the completeness and authenticity of the information provided. In addition, a final draft of this report was provided to MWL along with a written request to identify any material errors or omissions prior to lodgement. The following professionals have been consulted for relevant detail contained in this report. Name Greg Entwistle Chris Marissen Gary Brabham Mike Turner Duncan Grant-Stuart Peter Shephard Peter Hayward Andries Strauss Glen Zamudio Company Mawson West Ltd Mawson West Ltd Mawson West Ltd Turner Mining and Geotechnical Pty Ltd Knight Piesold Consulting SRK Consulting Sedgman Ltd Knight Piesold Consulting Mawson West Ltd Pre-Feasibility Contribution Operational Management Review Mining Geological Geotechnical Tailings storage facilities Hydrology and Water Management Metallurgical Tailings storage facilities Commercial 2.4. SITE VISIT Mr Andrew Law visited the Dikulushi Project in February 2012 and specifically visited the underground decline and openings that were available at the time (approx. 830 mRL). He has now reviewed all sections of the Pre-Feasibility study collated by MWL and generated by various Qualified Persons, many of whom were independent of MWL. Mr David Gray (a former employee of Optiro and a QP for previous Dikulushi Technical Reports) completed a comprehensive site visit to the Dikulushi copper Project in November 2010. The purpose of this visit was to: verify the relative size, position and presence of copper mineralisation at the Dikulushi and Kazumbula deposits verify the presence and position of drillhole sampling for the respective resources and reserves inspect the drill core for mineralisation, geological relationships with mineralisation and general sample quality review the respective sampling methods and QAQC with onsite geologists review and confirm sample and assay data as stored in the drillhole database review historical and current production and processing data. Mr David Gray did not take independent samples due to the operational nature of the respective resources and the visible in-situ mineralisation which confirms drillhole sample results. Mr Ian P a g e | 22 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Glacken, Director-Geology at Optiro, has not visited the Dikulushi Operation, but has nonetheless supervised and peer reviewed the Dikulushi Project work complied by Mr Gray since 2009, and now accepts responsibility for the Mineral Resources estimation as stated in this report. Site visits have been carried out by the following persons: Name Andrew Law David Gray Chris Marissen Gary Brabham Mike Turner Duncan Grant-Stuart Peter Hayward Peter Shephard Glen Zamudio Company Optiro Optiro Mawson West Ltd Mawson West Ltd Turner Mining and Geotechnical Pty Ltd Knight Piesold Consulting Sedgman Ltd SRK Consulting Mawson West Ltd Section Mineral Reserves Resource NI 43-101 Mining Geology Geotechnical Date of Visits February 2012 November 2010 Various as employee of MWL Various as employee of MWL December 2012 Tailings storage facility Metallurgical Hydrology, Water Management Commercial July 2010 February 2012 Once during 2007 Various as employee of MWL 2.5. INDEPENDENCE Neither Mr Andrew Law or Mr Glacken, nor Optiro, have or have had any material interest in MWL or its related entities or interests. This report has been prepared in return for fees based upon agreed commercial rates and the payment of these fees is in no way contingent on the results of this report. 2.6. ABBREVIATIONS AND TERMS A listing of abbreviations and terms used in this report is provided in Table 2.1 below. P a g e | 23 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Table 2.1 Glossary of terms / $ % 2D 3D A AC ADT Ag allochthonous anticline arenaceous argillaceous As ASCu arsenopyrite azurite BCM, bcm bimodal black copper BOCO bornite boudinaged brecciated BMWi °C carbonates carrollite CCD cell chalcocite chalcopyrite chrysocolla clastic cm CMN Co conglomerate Per Dollars Percentage Two dimensional Three dimensional Ampere(s) Alternating Current Articulated dump truck The chemical symbol for the element silver A term applied to the material forming rocks which have been transported to the site of deposition A description of folding of rocks which has produced a convex shape A group of detrital sedimentary rocks, typically sandstones, in which the particles range in size from 0.06 mm to 2 mm A group of detrital sedimentary rocks, typically clays, shales, mudstones and siltstones, in which the particles range in size from less than 0.06 mm The chemical symbol for the element arsenic Acid Soluble copper A mineral that is made up of arsenic, iron and sulphur A mineral that is made up of copper, up to 55% copper, with carbonate and water Bank Cubic Metres, a measure of volume applied to unbroken rock Statistical term for two peaks in a graph of values An impure form of copper produced by smelting oxidised copper ores or impure scrap, usually in a blast furnace. The copper content varies widely, usually in the range of approximately 60 to 85% by weight Bottom of complete oxidation A mineral made up of copper, up to 63%, copper, iron and sulphur A minor structure arising from tensional forces, resulting in an appearance in crosssection similar to that of a string of sausages Describes rock made up of angularly broken or fractured rock generally indicating a fault plane Bond Mill Work index Temperature measurement in degrees Celsius (also called Centigrade) Rocks made up mainly of a metal, commonly calcium or magnesium or copper, zinc and lead and carbon dioxide A rare mineral that is made up of cobalt, copper and sulphur Counter Current Decantation A term applied to the three dimensional volume used in the mathematical modelling by computer techniques of ore bodies A mineral that is made up of copper, up to 80% copper and sulphur A mineral that is made up of copper, up to 35% copper, iron and sulphur A mineral that is made up of copper, up to 36% copper, silica and water Rocks formed from fragments of pre-existing rocks which have been produced by the processes of weathering and erosion, and in general transported to a point of deposition Centimetre Calcaire a Minerais Noirs (limestone and dolomite with black oxides) The chemical symbol for the element cobalt A sedimentary rock made up of various size particles from small pebbles to large boulders and rounded other rock fragments cemented together P a g e | 24 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Cu CuOx cuprous cut-off DC DCF Datamine diagenetic dilution disseminated dolomite domain DRC DStrat DTD DTM Dwi E EAF Écaille EGL EIA EMP EW FC ferric fluvial fluvio flotation framboidal g GAC Gécamines geostatistics GRAT GST ha The chemical symbol for the element copper copper in the oxide form, generally soluble in dilute sulphuric acid copper in ionic state of one missing electron The minimum concentration (grade) of the valuable component in a mass of rock that will produce sufficient revenue to pay for the cost of mining, processing and selling it Direct Current Discounted Cash Flow A proprietary computer program developed to model, view, report and analyse geological and mining data Pertaining to the processes affecting a sediment while it is at or near the Earth’s surface, i.e., at low temperature and pressure A term used to describe the waste or non economic materials included when mining ore Ore carrying fine particles, usually sulphides scattered throughout the rock A mineral containing calcium, magnesium and carbonate A term used mainly in mineral resource estimation or geotechnical investigations to describe regions of a geological model with similar physical or chemical characteristics Democratic Republic of Congo Dolomies Stratifies (stratified dolomite) Direct tailings disposal Digital Terrain Model Drop Weight index Easting coordinate Electric Arc Furnace – a smelting facility A French term meaning ‘fragment’, used to describe the large blocks of prospective Mines Series stratigraphy that appear to ‘float’ in a mega-breccia-type arrangement Effective Grinding Length Environmental Impact Assessment Environmental Management Plan Electrowinning Congolese Francs Iron in an ionic state of three missing electrons A geological process in, or pertaining to, rivers A description applied to moving material by streams of water A widely used process to concentrate valuable minerals after mining that treats finely ground rock in a water based pulp with chemicals that allow them to float to the surface where they are recovered in preference to waste or gangue minerals which sink Akin to the skin of a strawberry or raspberry Gram Gangue acid consumption La Générale des Carrierés et des Mines, Parastatal copper Mining Company of the DRC A mathematical method based on geological spatial knowledge of grade distributions used to estimate mineralisation grades Grey Roches Argilo-Talcqueuse (a dolomitic and talcose argillaceous rock) Goods and Services Tax Hectares P a g e | 25 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 HAZOP HDPE HG HLS HMS HQ3 hrs HT HV ICP ICWi 2 ID /IDS IT JORC kg kL km kt kV kW kWh kriging kurtosis L, l L/sec, L/s, l/sec, l/s lacustrine lb LIDAR LOB Log LOM LV m mm m% m3 Ma malachite mamsl massive MAX mbgl Hazard and Operability Study High Density Polyethylene High Grade Heavy Liquid Separation Heavy Media Separation. A process that uses high density fluids to separate valuable minerals from waste or gangue by exploiting differences in specific gravity Diamond drill core with a diameter of 63.5 mm Hours High tension High voltage Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry Impact Crushing Work index Inverse Distance Squared (method of estimating grades by mathematically weighting samples based on their distance away from the estimation point) Information technology An acronym for Joint Ore Reserve Committee, an Australian committee formed by the Australian Stock Exchange and Australasian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy, the purpose of which is to set the regulatory enforceable standards for the Code of Practice for the reporting of Mineral Resources and Ore Reserves Kilogram Kilolitre Kilometre Kilotonne Kilovolt Kilowatt Kilowatt hour A geostatistical method (named after the South African, D. G. Krige) of estimating the unknown grade of resource blocks from the grades of samples, taking cognizance of the sample distribution Statistical term for peaked graph shape (peakedness) Litres Litres per second Sediment deposition in lakes Pounds Light Detection and Ranging – a remote sensing system used to collect topographic data Lower Orebody Natural logarithm to the base 10 Life of Mine Low voltage Metre Millimetre Metre percentage (obtained by multiplying metres by % of assay value) Cubic metre Mega annum (Million years) A mineral containing copper, up to 57% Cu, carbonate and water Metres above mean sea level A term used to describe a large occurrence of a pure mineral species, often with no structure Maximum Metres below ground level P a g e | 26 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 mbs MCC MCK Mg MIR MIN MINDIL mineralisation mm ML MN MODFLOW MPa Mt MVa MW N Neo-Proterozoic NI OC ore orogeny P80 Pb PBC PDT PE PFDs PFS P&IDs pH PLC PLS ppm pseudomalachite PVC QAQC raffinate RAT RC recovery Metres below surface Motor Control Centre Mining Company of Katanga Milligrams Milling in raffinate Minimum A Whittle Four-X mine planning software term for mining dilution The presence of minerals of possible economic value or the description of the process by which the concentration of valuable minerals occurs Millimetre. Millions of litres Magnetic North. A groundwater modelling program used to assess the impact on the regional groundwater table of pumping and abstraction, and also contaminant flow Millions of Pascals Millions of tonnes Millions of Volt Amps Millions of Watts Northing Coordinate The term used in the geological time scale for the period from 545 million years ago to 1000 million years ago National Instrument Organic Continuous A natural aggregate of one or more minerals which, at a specified time and place, may be mined and sold at a profit or from which some part may be profitably separated Greek for ‘mountain generating’ - the process of mountain building. Orogenic events occur as a result of plate tectonic processes 80% of product passes The chemical symbol for the element lead Pinned Bed Clarifier Phase Disengagement Time Permis d’Exploitation (Exploitation Permit or Licence) Process Flow Diagrams Pre-feasibility Study Piping and Instrumentation Drawings Concentration of hydrogen ion Programmable Logic Controller Pregnant Liquor Solution Parts per million (same as grams per tonne) Pseudomalachite or ‘false malachite’ – named because it is visually similar in appearance to malachite Polyvinyl chloride Quality Assurance and Quality Control A liquid stream that remains after the extraction with the immisciable liquid to remove solutes from the original liquor. From French: raffinere, to refine. Roches Argilo-Talcqueuse (a dolomitic/talcose argillaceous rock) Reverse circulation (as in drilling) A measure in percentage terms of the efficiency of a process, usually metallurgical, in gathering the valuable minerals. The measure is made against the total amount of valuable mineral present in the ore P a g e | 27 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 reserve (Ore Reserve) resource (Mineral Resource) RL Roan Supergroup RMWi ROM RSA RSC RSF S s, sec SAG sandstone SCADA SD SEM SG siltstone silica SMC SNEL SPLP S/S, SS storativity stratiform strings supergene SURPAC SX SX-EW t TCu termitaria TN TOFR tpa The term for the economic quantities and grade of valuable materials as strictly applied in compliance with the definition in the Australian JORC Code and in the Canadian National Instrument (NI) 43-101 The term for the estimate of the quantities and grade of valuable materials but with no economic considerations as strictly applied in compliance with the definition in the Australian JORC Code and in the Canadian National Instrument (NI) 43-101 Reduced Level (same as elevation coordinate) Describes the stratigraphic succession of sedimentary rocks of Neo-Proterozoic age, in the Katanga Province of the Democratic Republic of Congo Rod Mill Work index Run-of-Mine (ore) Republic of South Africa Roches Silicieuses Cellulaires (siliceous rocks with cavities) Roches Siliceuses Feuilletees (foliated and silicified dolomitic shales) South Coordinate. Second Semi-autogenous Grinding A sedimentary rock consisting of sand size grains, generally the mineral quartz, which is in a consolidated mass Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition System Shales Dolomitiques (dolomitic shales) Scanning Electron Microscopy Specific Gravity A sedimentary rock consisting of grains from 0.063 to 0.25 mm, generally the mineral quartz and clay, which is in a consolidated mass A compound of silicon and oxygen, generally occurring in the form of a mineral called quartz SAG mill comminution Société Nationale d’Electricité – the provider of electrical power in the DRC Simulated Precipitation Leach Procedure Stainless steel The volume of water an aquifer releases from or takes into storage per unit surface area of the aquifer per unit change in head Describes a layered or tabular shaped body of mineralized rock within a sedimentary rock and implies that the layering of the mineralisation is parallel to the bedding planes in that sedimentary rock A term used to a digital line drawn within a computer program that outlines or describes a shape of an object or interpretation Pertaining to that part of an ore deposit in which the mineralisation has been increased as a result of the downward percolation of fluids carrying metal in solution A proprietary computer program developed to model, view, analyse and report on geological and mining data Solvent Extraction Solvent Extraction and Electrowinning Metric tonne Total copper Termite mounds True North Top of fresh rock Tonnes per annum P a g e | 28 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 tpd tph transmissivity TSF TSS UCS UTM V VAT VESDA VSD %v/v W Whittle Four-X WNW WRD %w/w Zn μm Tonnes per day Tonnes per hour The volume of water flowing through a defined cross-sectional area of an aquifer Tailings Storage Facility Total Suspended Solids Unconfined Compressive Strength Universal Transverse Mercator grid Volts Value Added Tax Very Early Smoke Detection and Alarm Variable Speed Drive Percent by volume Westing Coordinate A mine planning software program used to optimise resource models, based on economic and mining/processing parameters West North West Waste Rock Dump Percent by weight The chemical symbol for the element zinc Microns, micrometers P a g e | 29 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 3. RELIANCE ON OTHER EXPERTS This Technical Report has been prepared and approved under the supervision of Mr Andrew Law, Director Mining, Optiro Pty Ltd. Mr Andrew Law, who is the principal author of the report, is an independent Qualified Person as defined in National Instrument 43‐101. In preparing this report, the Qualified Persons have relied upon and taken responsibility for the information provided by MWL relating to mining, legal, environmental and financial information as noted below: Legal title to the tenements held by MWL in the DRC and MWL’s permits to mine, which is relevant to Sections 4 and 20 of this report. Environmental permit and bond information which is relevant to Sections 4 and 20 of this report. The nature and validity of any off-take agreements for concentrate held by MWL, which is relevant to Section 19 of this report. Financial and cash flow models were provided to Optiro by MWL which is relevant to Section 22 of this report. Metallurgical balance and current production information leading to the assessed head grade of the copper-silver concentrate produced from treatment of the mined ore, which is relevant to Sections 13 and 17 of this report. Mine design, geotechnical, hydrology, planning, scheduling and costing which is relevant to Sections 15, 16, 21, and 22 of the report. The Qualified Persons have made all reasonable inquiries to establish the completeness and authenticity of the information provided. Drafts of this report were provided to MWL with a request to identify any material errors or omissions prior to filing. Notwithstanding the reliance of the Qualified Persons on MWL for the financial and cash flow models, metallurgical balance information and mine design noted above, the Qualified Persons accept responsibility for all of the scientific/technical information related to these matters. P a g e | 30 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 4. PROPERTY DESCRIPTION AND LOCATION 4.1. DEMOGRAPHICS AND GEOGRAPHIC SETTING The Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC) is located in central Africa and straddles the equator. The DRC has an east-west lateral extent of approximately 1,500 km and extends over a north-south distance of some 1,800 km. The DRC is Africa’s second largest country, covering an area of approximately 2.3 million km2 and shares land borders with Angola, Zambia, Rwanda, Tanzania, Uganda, the Republic of the Congo, Sudan, Burundi and the Central Africa Republic. The capital city is Kinshasa, which is located in the western portion of the country. The DRC’s main port is Matandi, approximately 115km from the coast on the Congo River. The DRC has a population in excess of 75 million of which approximately 50% are aged between 15 and 64 years old. There are over 200 African ethnic groups within the country’s borders, although the Bantu and Hamitic groups account for approximately 45% of the population. The majority of the population reside in rural areas with one-third living in urban centres. Christianity is the dominant religion in the DRC, with approximately half of the population being of the Roman Catholic faith, with a further 20% Protestant. The remaining population follow the Kimbanguist (10%), Muslim (10%) and other (10%) faiths. The national language is French, although Lingala, Kingwana, Kikongo and Tshiluba are widely spoken. 4.2. PROJECT OWNERSHIP The Dikulushi mine is governed by the “Dikulushi Mining Convention”, signed on the January 31, 1998 with the Government of the DRC, and ratified by Presidential Decree issued on February 27, 1998. The Dikulushi Mining Convention is a mining concession granted to AMC. Mawson West Investments Ltd a wholly owned subsidiary of MWL, holds 90% of the issued capital of AMC, the remaining 10% is held by the Dikulushi – Kapulo Foundation (NPO). For the purposes of this report, the Mawson West Limited ownership structure, referred to as MWL, is used in this report for ease of reference. 4.3. PROPERTY LOCATION The Project is located within the Katanga Province in the south-eastern DRC, some 400 km north of Lubumbashi and 50 km north of the regional town of Kilwa. The Project is centred at approximately S 08° 53’ E 28° 16’, some 25 km west of Lake Mweru near the DRC border with Zambia. Figure 4.1 shows the property location of MWL’s holding within the DRC, which are effectively two distinct properties – the Dikulushi property (shown in green in figure 4.1) and the Kapulo property (shown in blue in figure 4.1). The focus of this report and the projects discussed herein, relate specifically to the Dikulushi property only. P a g e | 31 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Figure 4.1 Exploration Licences of the Dikulushi copper silver project 4.4. THE PROPERTY TENEMENT AREA MWL holds title to the Dikulushi mine and surrounding exploration tenements, as governed by the Dikulushi Mining Convention. Under the Dikulushi Mining Convention the exploration tenements known as “PR’s” were issued for an initial five year period and are renewable a further three times, each time for a period of five years; that is a total of 20 years. The Dikulushi PR’s shown in Table 4.1 below and Figure 4.1 above, and these were first granted on the 22 May 2001 and currently have “renewed” expiry dates April 2016. A further 5 year renewal period is available post this date. MWL currently holds 18 Exploration Permits and three Exploitation Permits under the Dikulushi Mining Convention, covering 7,283km². Under the Dikulushi Mining Convention, MWL is guaranteed sole and exclusive rights for exploitation for a period totalling 20 years from the date of the issue of the permit. P a g e | 32 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Mining operations at the Dikulushi mine are conducted under an Exploitation Permit PE 606, issued on 29 December 2003 by Ministerial Decree. The exploitation permit recognised that AMC had commenced mining operations form 31 January 2002. The PE covers an area of 40.77 km2 over the Dikulushi mine area (Figure 4.1 and Figure 4.2). Table 4.1 Mawson West Limited Dikulushi tenement schedule Tenement Schedule Project Group Entity Permit No. Type Granted Expiry Dikulushi AMC PE606 Area km² 40.77 Mining 29-Dec-03 30-Jan-22 Dikulushi Dikulushi AMC AMC PR546 PR1693 283.8 398.6 Exploration Exploration 23-May-11 12-Apr-11 22-May-16 11-Apr-16 Dikulushi Dikulushi AMC AMC PR1694 PR1700 398.5 398.4 Exploration Exploration 12-Apr-11 12-Apr-11 11-Apr-16 11-Apr-16 Dikulushi Dikulushi AMC AMC PR1703 PR1705 398.3 237.0 Exploration Exploration 22-May-11 22-May-11 21-May-16 21-May-16 Dikulushi Dikulushi AMC AMC PR1706 PR1707 398.0 397.7 Exploration Exploration 22-May-11 23-May-11 21-May-16 22-May-16 Dikulushi Dikulushi Dikulushi AMC AMC AMC PR1708 PR1709 PR1710 405.1 345.0 397.0 Exploration Exploration Exploration 22-May-11 22-May-11 22-May-11 21-May-16 21-May-16 21-May-16 Dikulushi AMC PR1711 396.9 Exploration 22-May-11 21-May-16 Total Area Figure 4.2 4,495.1 Dikulushi mine infrastructure within the PE 606 P a g e | 33 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 4.5. ENVIRONMENTAL PERMITS An EIA for the Dikulushi project was lodged in 2003. In 2009, an EIA for the underground project was submitted to the DRC Government. Both of these reports were compiled by African Mining Consultants of Kitwe, Zambia, an environmental company that was licensed to work and report in the DRC. An EIA was lodged for the cutback project, prepared by EMIS sprl, a DRC environmental company licences to work and report in the DRC. All three environmental reports received DRC Government approval. A revised EIA, extending underground mining beyond 2013, has being submitted to Government. Each EIA includes commitments relating to mine decommissioning. Annual reporting of environmental issues and measurements to relevant government bodies is a condition of the operating license and EMP. MWL have lodged $1.19M as an Environment Bond. The financial guarantee is a contribution towards an estimate of the total costs of closure, rehabilitation and re-vegetation of the Dikulushi mine. The development of the financial guarantee is conducted in compliance with: Articles 410 of the Mining Regulations Articles 124 and 125 of Appendix XI of the DRC Mining Regulations 2003; and Appendix II of the Mining Regulations 2003 Regular environmental audits are carried to determine the mine’s compliance with its Environmental Management Plan. An environmental monitoring database is maintained at the mine, comprising the following: wet/dry, min/max temperatures rainfall dust exposure noise levels ground and surface water quality groundwater levels Tailings Dam piezometer water levels light levels. A study into the acid rock drainage potential of the process plant tailings was conducted in 2005 and they were classified as low risk. Ongoing testwork and monitoring continues to support this conclusion. P a g e | 34 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Figure 4.3 Dikulushi mine site aerial view P a g e | 35 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 5. ACCESSIBILITY, CLIMATE, LOCAL RESOURCES, INFRASTRUCTURE AND PHYSIOGRAPHY 5.1. ACCESS Access to the Dikulushi Mine is by sealed road from Lubumbashi to Kasenga, along the Luapula River by boat to Kilwa and then approximately 54 km by gravel road from Kilwa to Dikulushi. The total travelling distance is approximately 500 km. The closest international airport is at Lubumbashi, approximately 450 km to the south. A gravel airstrip is located at the Dikulushi mine and charter flights using a G1 plane (as shown in Figure 5.3) from Lubumbashi can land directly at site. Supplies for the project are typically trucked on sealed roads from South Africa via Botswana to Nchelenge port on the Zambian side of Lake Mweru. Supplies are then transferred from Nchelenge to Kilwa on the Congo side of Lake Mweru on a 340 t capacity barge (Figure 5.1) owned by AMC; the water journey takes 5 hours. Access from Kilwa port to the mine is via a 54 km gravel road and takes approximately 1 hour by light vehicle. Figure 5.1 Barge on Lake Mweru 5.2. SITE TOPOGRAPHY, ELEVATION AND VEGETATION The Dikulushi deposit is located on a plateau approximately 1000 m above sea level. The area surrounding the Dikulushi site is almost entirely covered with woodland and forest, with some swamps or wetland areas. The plateau rises into the Kundelungu ranges 60 km to the west of Dikulushi and forms an escarpment 25 km to the east along the fault-bounded edge of Lake Mweru. A minor ephemeral stream is located near the Dikulushi mine site. The Luapula River is the main drainage into Lake Mweru and both form the international boundary between Zambia and the DRC. P a g e | 36 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 5.3. CLIMATE, PHYSIOGRAPHY, LOCAL RESOURCES AND INFRASTRUCTURE The average annual rainfall, as indicated by mission records, is 1,260 mm, with a range of 800 mm to 2,200mm. An Oregon Scientific weather station was installed at Dikulushi in 2006. A composite graph of the weather data collected at Dikulushi over the past 5 years is shown in Figure 5.2. The wet season begins towards the end of October and finishes at the end of April, with 90% of the annual rainfall occurring during this period. The average minimum recorded temperature is 15°C and the average maximum temp is 29°C during the year. Figure 5.2 Composite Temperature and Rainfall Data recorded over the last 5 years. 35 200 180 30 160 140 120 20 100 15 80 Rainfall, mm Temperature, °C 25 Rainfall Temperature (High) Temperature (Low) 60 10 40 5 20 0 0 Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec The wet season generally has minimal effect on mining or processing operations at Dikulushi. 5.4. SURFACE RIGHTS The Dikulushi mine is based on Exploitation Licence (PE606) granted on 29 December 2003. The lease is valid for 20 years and can be renewed for up to a further 20 years. There are no competing mining rights (for example, small artisanal mining licenses) in the project area. 5.5. SITE INFRASTRUCTURE The development of the Dikulushi mine has required development of seven major locations: 1. the treatment plant area, which includes the mine administration building 2. the mine services area, including workshops, fuel farm and powerhouse 3. the explosives storage area P a g e | 37 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 4. 5. 6. 7. the staff village the airstrip the process water dam tailings storage facility. These items of infrastructure are depicted in Figure 4.2 and Figure 4.3. This infrastructure was in place for the previous operations under Anvil and has been used for the open pit cut back operations with it being well established and maintained, as well as being of sufficient size for the current and future underground requirements. Figure 5.3 Dikulushi airstrip and the G1 Charter plane provides safe staff transportation to and from site 5.5.1. WATER SUPPLY Mine water is sourced from a raw water dam located adjacent to the Tailings Dam. Supernatant tailings water is reclaimed via penstock arrangements for use in the processing plant. A water supply flowchart and site wide water balance is provided in section 18 of this report. Potable water is supplied from various bores on the property which are tested regularly. 5.5.2. POWER SUPPLY The project is located in a remote area where there is no electrical utility grid. The mine power is supplied by diesel generators. There is sufficient back-up capacity. The existing power station at Dikulushi comprises the following generators: 4 x 1.2 MW FG Wilson ( being new units and installed during the 3rd quarter 2013 ) , 1 x 2.0 MW Caterpillar, 1 x 1.6 MW Caterpillar, 1 x 0.8 MW Mirrlees for a current total capacity of 9.2 MW. The current power demand for the plant and infrastructure is in the order of 2.0 MW. The 2.0 MW Caterpillar, 1.6 MW Caterpillar currently require major overhauls which will be completed during 2014. The 1 x 0.8 MW Mirrlees will be decommissioned during the 4th quarter of 2013. The new FG Wilson generating sets were installed to supply power to the operations as well as dewatering of the underground and P a g e | 38 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 normal underground operations. The 2.0 MW Caterpillar and the 1.6 MW Caterpillar will be used as backup standby power. MWL recognises that a consistent reliable fuel supply is crucial to the success of the Dikulushi operation. The operation currently uses approximately 450,000l of diesel per month. This fuel is supplied by three DRC based companies, two receive supplies from the port of Beira and the other receives supplies from the port of Dar es Salaam. MWL has contacted a further supplier from Dar es Salaam whom would be able to supply fuel to Dikulushi. MWL is regularly speaking to suppliers to guarantee no interruptions in fuel supply. MWL believes that it has mitigated the risk of fuel supply by having a number of suppliers whom source fuel from different ports and transport routes. 5.5.3. MINE PERSONNEL As at June 2013, the Dikulushi mine employed 515 people, of which 39 were expatriates. The requirements for the underground operations and other associated activities will require a total workforce of 500-550 employees. Contractors will be used as required. This a change from the open pit operations where the workforce was mainly contractor supplied. 5.5.4. TAILINGS STORAGE FACILITY There are currently three tailing storage facilities (TSF) on site. The initial TSF designed for HMS tailings, dormant since 2004, has had a section of the coarse portion reclaimed and retreated in early start up operations by MWL. The second TSF is dormant whilst the third is in use to accommodate the tailings resulting from the treatment of the current open pit operations. The third TSF has been reviewed for extended use beyond its current life. This will be raised to accommodate tailings resulting from the final open pit cut back mining operations and the planned underground operations. More detail on the TSF is covered in Section 17. 5.5.5. ADMINISTRATION AND PLANT SITE BUILDINGS The infrastructure on site includes administration offices (Figure 5.4), a warehouse, mining equipment and maintenance workshops, mechanical workshops and a service area with access pit for inspection and repair of vehicles. There is a fully equipped clinic on site (Figure 5.6) and a hospital at Kilwa, approximately 50 km from the mine. An assay laboratory on site facilitates metallurgical, exploration and grade control sampling assaying requirements. P a g e | 39 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Figure 5.4 Dikulushi Administration Centre 5.5.6. ACCOMMODATION A staff village has been constructed 1.8 km from the process plant. A mess hall, fully equipped kitchen, food storage and laundry facilities serve all employees. Recreational facilities are also available to employees. Figure 5.5 Figure 5.5 Dikulushi Camp Site P a g e | 40 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 5.5.7. COMMUNICATIONS Mobile phone coverage is available through a dedicated mast located on top of the waste dump. There are satellite systems for data transmission and VOIP telephone coverage. There is a base station radio system, along with vehicle and hand-held radios. Figure 5.6 Figure 5.6 Dikulushi Clinic and communications centre 5.5.8. MOBILE EQUIPMENT Sufficient mobile equipment for the efficient running of the operations is in place, comprising light vehicles (including an ambulance), light trucks, forklifts, buses and generators. Figure 5.7 P a g e | 41 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Figure 5.7 Dikulushi Workshop 5.5.9. SECURITY Security is provided by a contractor. Appropriate secure facilities are provided for the storage of fuel and explosives. Figure 5.8 P a g e | 42 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Figure 5.8 Dikulushi Store and Fuel Farm P a g e | 43 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 6. HISTORY The development of exploration and mining at Dikulushi and surrounds can be broken down into the following periods: • Early History – Copper mineralisation was first reported in the early 20th Century by Simkat. Other assessments were made in the 1950s and by the French Bureau de Recherches Geologiques et Minieres (BRGM) during the 1970s. • Recent History – Anvil, from 1996 to April 2008. • Current – Mawson West Limited from June 2010 to present. The history of the project is summarised in Table 6.1. Table 6.1 Historical work summary at the Dikulushi Project Year 1900s 1974-1981 1996-1997 1998-2002 2002-2006 2006-2008 2008 Supervision Belgian explorers BRGM Anvil Anvil Anvil Anvil Anvil 2010 onwards MWL 6.1. Work Completed Rock chips 48 Diamond drillholes Dikulushi Mining Convention signed and some drilling Modified convention signed, more drilling and metallurgical testwork, feasibility study Mining of open cut and regional soils and termite sampling and drilling Underground development at Dikulushi and further drilling of targets defined from above Anvil closes down Dikulushi Mine. Restarted plant on LG stockpiles and then proceeded to process ore from the pit cut back operation until July 2013 when the pit concluded operations due to reaching its design limits. BELGIAN EXPLORATION Copper mineralisation in the area was initially evaluated by Belgian explorers (Simikat) from 1910 until 1923. BRGM purchased an interest in the Dikulushi Deposits during the early 1970s and completed adit sampling, diamond drilling, metallurgical testwork, soil geochemistry and geophysics. The projects lay dormant until Anvil pegged the ground in the late 1990s and subsequently signed the JV agreement with Mawson West. 6.2. ANVIL MINING LTD An open pit mine was commissioned at Dikulushi in October 2002 by Anvil, with run-of-mine ore delivered to an on-site heavy media separation (HMS) concentrator at the rate of 250,000 tonnes per year. The copper-silver concentrate was subsequently transported by barge across nearby Lake Mweru into Zambia and then by road to smelters in South Africa and Namibia. During the first 15 months of operation, the geology within the open pit was extensively mapped and, with results of the drilling, resulted in a re-interpretation of the mineralised envelope at Dikulushi. The DevMin consulting group was approached by Anvil to undertake the Open Pit Mine Plan study to estimate the remaining open pit reserves and prepare an open pit life-of-mine schedule for the Dikulushi Mine. This study was initiated in August 2003 when a preliminary pit optimisation was P a g e | 44 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 undertaken using Anvil’s current in-house resource model. The initial study was largely an update of previous work carried out by DevMin and showed that with current economic parameters, the feasible depth for open pit mining at Dikulushi could potentially extend down to 150 m below surface. An earlier work phase, carried out in 2002 prior to the mine being commissioned, had stopped the pit at 130 m depth with remaining mineralisation proposed to be exploited by an underground mine. Further metallurgical work was carried out by Anvil in 2003, resulting in the installation of a ball mill and flotation plant in mid-2004 increasing the throughput to 350,000 tonnes per year. A second ball mill was installed in June 2005 with a further increase in throughput to 520,000 tonnes. This is the current capacity of the treatment plant and the mining fleet was increased to provide the appropriate plant feed tonnage. With the completion of the planned open cut operations in 2006, the focus moved to developing an underground operation. The ROM stockpile at the end of 2006 was considerable and it was expected that this would see the mine through to the commencement of production from the underground in early 2008. Upon commencement of underground mining, and due to time constraints, Anvil adopted a sublevel caving method for the underground. However with the realisation that such a method was inappropriate for the type of orebody geometry at Dikulushi, the decision was made to move to an Avoca method of mining. This necessitated a hiatus in ROM feed to the plant in April 2008 due to the intensive nature of development required for a bottom-up mining method. By the end of 2008, with the World financial markets in turmoil and the subsequent plunge in the copper price, the decision was made to place the Dikulushi Mine on care and maintenance. 6.3. MAWSON WEST MWL acquired the Dikulushi project from Anvil in April 2010. Plant refurbishment was started immediately and completed in July 2010 at which point MWL started processing the LG stockpile which continued into 2012. MWL has continued with the cut back of the open pit until July 2013, where practicable completion of the pit was reached. Ore is stock piled on the ROM pad to continue the milling operations until late 2013. The next phase is the re-establishment of the underground operations below the current open pit (825 mRL). Previously, the underground was developed by Anvil down to the 750 mRL. 6.4. RESOURCE HISTORY During the BRGM tenure of the deposit (1974 – 1981) a resource of 1.65 Mt at a copper grade of 10.46% and a silver grade of 310g/t to a vertical depth of 220 m was estimated for the Dikulushi deposit. Anvil published a Mineral Resource estimate for the Dikulushi deposit in December 2006. The estimate was completed by FinOre Mining Consultants (FinOre) in July 2006 and used 3D wireframe volumes to define the mineralisation. A 0.5% copper mineralisation cut-off was used to guide the wireframe volume. Estimates were completed using Datamine software and the resulting Mineral Resource is detailed in Table 6.2 below. P a g e | 45 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Table 6.2 Mineral Resource estimate as completed by FinOre in July 2006 and published in December 2006; a cut-off grade of 1.5% copper was used Tonnes Cu(%) Cu Metal (Tonnes) Ag g/t Ag Metal Mozs Measured 410,000 9.10 37,300 288 3.8 Indicated Measured and Indicated 650,000 7.90 51,100 184 3.84 1,060,000 8.30 88,400 224 7.64 Inferred 1,380,000 5.80 80,600 141 6.26 Category There are no other historically published Mineral Resources available for Kazumbula or any of the surrounding exploration targets. 6.5. PRODUCTION HISTORY Anvil mined the Dikulushi deposit between 2002 and 2008. Production statistics are presented in Table 6.3 below. Table 6.3 Historical Anvil production for the Dikulushi mine Year Tonnes processed Grade Cu% Grade Ag g/t 2002 (HMS) 2003 (HMS) 2004 (HMS/Float) 2005 (Float) 2006/07 (Float) 2008 (No Dec) 36,010 273,500 245,000 410,000 1,059,950 471,590 7.26 7.68 6.39 5.07 5.12 3.16 144 195 177 149 151 84 Average recovery (%) 66.7 66.1 69 86 81 75 Cu produced (tonnes) 1340 13,613 10,840 16,900 46,507 11,177 Ag produced Mozs 0.08 1.16 0.89 1.63 4.45 0.97 From 2010 MWL recommenced processing operations of low grade stockpiles whilst the cut back of the open pit commenced mining in Jan 2012 and ceased July 2013, with ore processing due to be completed late 2013. Production statistics for this period are presented in Table 6.4 below. Table 6.4 Recent MWL production for the Dikulushi mine Year Tonnes processed Grade Cu% Grade Ag g/t 2010/11 2011/12 2012/13* 467,958 347,863 355,043 1.46 1.80 5.21 35.31 34.2 141.5 Average recovery (%) 64.0 63.0 91.6 Cu produced (tonnes) 4251 3,948 16,925 Ag produced Mozs 0.36 0.27 1.46 *Note: 2013 Production is to the end of July 2013 (13months). [Note: These figures are available in table 17.2] P a g e | 46 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 7. GEOLOGICAL SETTING AND MINERALISATION 7.1. REGIONAL SETTING The Dikulushi and Kazumbula copper-silver deposits are located west of Lake Mweru (08°53’37”S; 28°16’21”E), near the eastern margin of the Katanga sedimentary basin, in an area known as the Kundelungu Plateau. Deformation of the Katanga Supergroup sedimentary rocks is mild, and comprises open upright folds developed in association with major north-northwest and subordinate north-northeast-trending faults. An angular unconformity separates the undeformed, uppermost subdivision of the Kundelungu Group (Plateau Series) from the remainder. Regionally, copper mineralisation is known from at least three stratigraphic levels in the Kundelungu Group, but all occur beneath this unconformity. These deposits are hosted by the Kalule Formation, and ore is best developed in red sandstones and shales of the Mongwe member, above a conspicuous reduction-oxidation (redox) and pH boundary with the grey carbonates of the underlying Kiaka member. Mineralisation at Dikulushi was strongly fault-controlled (Haest et al., 2007), but across the district many copper occurrences, including the nearby Kazumbula deposit, are associated with the same stratigraphic position. Stratabound mineralisation is known from higher (Mwitapile; Sonta member, Kiubo Formation) and lower in the stratigraphy (Lufukwe; Monwesi Formation; El Desouky et al., 2007). In the greater Dikulushi district, prospective parts of the stratigraphy are exposed in areas of low terrane from which the upper, un-mineralised sequences have been removed by erosion. Mineralisation occurred during the waning stages of the Lufilian Orogeny (560 Ma) as compression and ductile deformation gave way to extension and brittle deformation. Several hundreds of millions of years later the Dikulushi deposit was chemically reworked and upgraded by circulating groundwaters (Haest, 2009; Haest et al., 2010). Figure 7.1 depicts the regional geology of the Dikulushi district and Figure 7.2 summarises the regional stratigraphic sequence. P a g e | 47 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Figure 7.1 Regional Geology of Mawson’s convention area in the DRC P a g e | 48 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Figure 7.2 Super Group Stratigraphy of Dikulushi region with known styles of mineralisation Group Formation Plateaux Ks-3 Upper Kundelungu - Ks Kiubo Ks - 2 Lithology m-Approx thickness Kilunga Lupili Arkose Pink Arkose <200 Kapenga Schists Interbedded red argillaceous sandstone and red argillates 350 Sonta Sandstone Red sandstone and quartzite 100 Sampwe schists Interbedded red argillaceous sandstone and red argillates 300 Kyafwama Kombo Sandstone Red sandstone 50 Lufila schists Interbedded red argillaceous sandstone and red argillates 150 Kiubo Sandstone Red sandstone 50 Mongwa Schists Argillaceous red sandstones interbedded with argillates. Minor Sandstone <100 Lubudi Dolomites Interbedded pink, cross bedded dol-arenites,with olitic caps <50 Kanianga Sandstone Sandstone - argillaceous and weakly calcareous <50 Pink intramicrite flakestones <50 Interbedded white/pink carbonate muds and arenites <50 Basal dolomite (BD) 4 Le Petit Conglomerate Diamictite <100 Monwesi Fluvio glacial sandstones <50m Le Grand Conglomerate Diamictite 500 Dolomitic shales and sandstones ? Kiaka Carbonates Ks 1.2 Lusele Pink Dolomites Lower Kundelungu Ki Ks - 1.1 Roan R Mineralization Disseminated chalcocite and malachite at base of Sonta Sandstone Ks - 2.2 Ks - 1.3 Kalule Ks - 1 Unit Monwesi Likasi Ki-1 Ki -0 1.1 Mwashya R-4 R - 4.2 Fault controlled Cu-Ag mineralisation at the dolomite/ sandstone contact Zn-Pb mineralization at contact with diamictite Stratiform copper Kinkumbi, Lufukwe anticline P a g e | 49 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 7.2. PROJECT GEOLOGY The Dikulushi and Kazumbula deposits are principally fault-hosted lodes of massive to semi-massive copper sulphides with minor disseminated and stockwork mineralisation in the wallrocks. The deposits are mostly hosted by red siltstones, with lesser ore hosted by underlying grey carbonate rocks and fragmental rocks that mark the contact between the two. The mineralised Dikulushi Fault trends east-northeast and breaches the northeastern nose of a north-northeast plunging elongate anticline. This orebody therefore is suborthogonal to stratigraphy. Prior to mining at Dikulushi, it was approximately 400 m long, 10 metres wide and extended from surface to a depth of at least 450 metres (Figure 7.3). Figure 7.3 Local geology of the Dikulushi open pit P a g e | 50 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 The Kazumbula orebody (Figure 7.4) comprises a fault-controlled lode of disseminated and minor fracture hosted copper sulphides and oxides. The orebody is hosted by siltstones and intercalated granular lithic sandstones. These have pervasive grey-green hydrothermal illite alteration when they occur in the immediate wallrocks to the orebody, but are red-brown elsewhere. The mineralised Kazumbula Fault trends east-northeast, but mineralisation is located at the intersection of the fault with other structures trending north-northeast and north-northwest. These structures are considered to have been active in concert as parts of a conjugate strike-slip shear array. Gently folded stratigraphy on the eastern limb of the Kabangu Antiform abuts the fault plane. The orebody is sub-orthogonal to stratigraphy and appears to be restricted to preferred brittle and permeable stratigraphy. As it is presently known, the deposit is approximately 180 m long, 12 m wide and extends from surface to a depth of approximately 80 m (Zukowski et al., 2010) as confirmed by drillhole intercepts. Figure 7.4 A typical vertical cross section through the Kazambula deposit, highlighting key geology associated with mineralisation P a g e | 51 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 8. DEPOSIT TYPES The Dikulushi and Kazumbula copper deposits are interpreted to be hypogene, fault-controlled deposits, containing semi-massive and disseminated chalcopyrite-bornite mineralisation with azurite, malachite and cuprite developed in the supergene zone. The mineralisation is lithostructurally controlled and is hosted in shales and sandstones of the Kundelungu Group. The host sedimentary rocks show varying degrees of brecciation, with the highest grade zones comprising semi-massive bornite-chalcopyrite fault fill. The Dikulushi and Kazumbula deposits are not typical of the stratiform copper deposits which are common within the central African Copperbelt. Dikulushi ore comprises massive to semi-massive and fracture-disseminated copper sulphide minerals that filled open spaces and cemented breccias along the fault zone. Early mineralisation was polymetallic and contained Cu-Fe-Pb-Zn and Ag as chalcopyrite, bornite, galena and sphalerite. Subsequent remobilisation dissolved most of the Fe, Pb and Zn and led to upgrading of the coppersilver content of the ore. The central parts of the deposits commonly contain >10% Cu and >200 ppm Ag. As a result of this process, the deposits are now composed largely of the copper sulphide mineral chalcocite. Silver occurs as atomic-level substitutions and as very fine grained inclusions in chalcocite grains (Dewaele et al., 2006; Haest et al., 2009; Haest et al., 2010). Gangue minerals typically associated with the mineralisation at Dikulushi are quartz, feldspar, pyrite and clays. Figure 7.3 depicts the mapped geology of the Dikulushi open pit. P a g e | 52 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 9. EXPLORATION The Dikulushi areas copper deposits have been explored by three main groups over the last 40 years. The three main periods of exploration are: Simkat - BRGM (1910-1981) Anvil (1997 to 2008) MWL (2010 - current) 9.1. BRGM The Dikulushi deposit was discovered by Simkat around 1910 but no records of work completed are available. In the period from 1910 to 1936 the deposit was investigated by Simkat and Societe Miniere du Lac Moero. BRGM then appraised the deposit from 1974 to 1981, during which time 48 diamond holes for 5,223 m were drilled and a resource of 1.65 Mt @ 10.46% Cu and 310g/t Ag to a vertical depth of 220 m was estimated. In 1988 the BRGM withdrew from Zaire (previous name for the DRC) and the deposit was left dormant until Anvil took control in 1996. 9.2. ANVIL MINING LTD EXPLORATION In 1996 Anvil submitted a Mining Convention application to the Zaire government for the Dikulushi deposit. The documents were signed in January 1997 and this document was then re-negotiated with the new Kabila government in 1998, with a presidential decree issued the month after signing ratifying the convention. During the latter half of 1997, Anvil completed 26 reverse circulation drillholes and 18 diamond drillholes which, together with the BRGM drilling, formed the basis for a pre-feasibility study completed by Signet Engineering of Perth, Western Australia. Anvil subsequently carried out additional drilling in 2000, 2003, 2004, 2005-6, 2007 and 2008, which is detailed in Table 9.1. Table 9.1 Company BRGM Historical drilling summary for the Dikulushi copper silver project Period 1974-1981 1997 2000 2003 Anvil 2004 2005-2006 2007 2008 Type DDH DDH RC RC DDH RC RC/DDH DDH DDH DDH No. Holes 48 18 26 22 4 21 14 14 9 78 2 Metres 5226 2115 2305 786 885 1768 414/3811 5779 2061 4130.9 1251 Sequence DIK1-47 DDH1-14, DR15, 19, 20, 38 DRC15-40 DRC043-064 DDH16-19 DRC065-085 DDH020-035 (no 032) DDD38-052 DDD053-061 UGD001 to UGD97 SUR001&005 P a g e | 53 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 9.3. MWL EXPLORATION At Dikulushi MWL has completed some geotechnical drilling for pit cut back and underground development studies, but this has not been sampled. MWL has also carried out drilling at the Kazumbula deposit. Details of this are provided in Section 10.8. P a g e | 54 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 10. DRILLING 10.1. INTRODUCTION All the drilling prior to 2010 was completed by Anvil. This section describes the various Anvil programmes and the programmes carried out by MWL in 2010 which were relevant to the Kazumbula deposit. 10.2. ANVIL PROGRAMME 1997 In 1997 Anvil carried out an exploration programme at Dikulushi which aimed at confirming the BRGM results and allowing estimation of Mineral Resources to the standard of the Australian JORC Code. A total of 40 drillholes were completed using two drill rigs between September and October 1997. All holes were oriented at 60° towards an azimuth of 340° (grid north), and all holes were in the area previously drilled by the BRGM. These resources and reserves were subsequently reviewed in the light of the requirements of NI43-101, since Anvil was a listed company in Canada. A total of 18 HQ and NQ diamond drill (DDH) holes (DDH1-14 and DDH15, 19, 20, 38), including 4 with reverse circulation (RC) pre-collars, were completed in the 1997 programme. Mineralisation was intersected in 17 of the 18 holes. Downhole camera surveys were completed at least every 12 metres in the DDH holes and the results showed the DDH remained essentially straight with a maximum deflection of 2° in declination and 4° in azimuth. A core orientation spear was also used after every core run (usually 3 metres). Upon recovering the core it was oriented when possible, and was then logged for geotechnical defects, core recovery and geology. Core recovery averaged about 90%, except for minor soil, sandy and cavernous zones. Recoveries in mineralised zones are reported to have been about 90%. A total of 22 RC drillholes (DRC16-18, 21-37, 39, and 40) were completed during the 1997 programme using a booster compressor, which was essential due to large water inflows and broken ground. Mineralisation was intersected in 19 of the 22 RC holes. None of the wholly RC drilled holes was downhole surveyed. Four RC pre-collared holes were surveyed throughout their length but due to the presence of steel casing, only the cored section returned valid azimuth readings. The dip variations in these holes were minor; however, the cored sections showed consistent anticlockwise azimuth rotations of between 9 and 18°. Consequently, an average azimuth correction factor of 3.2° anti-clockwise deviation per 20 metre downhole has been entered into the RC drillhole database to compensate for this interpreted drillhole rotation. Of the holes drilled during the 1997 programme, 11 DDH holes and 6 RC drillholes were specifically collared to twin earlier BRGM DDH holes. Anvil also cleaned out and re-sampled six trenches and four test pits that were originally dug and sampled by the BRGM. A total of 90 channel samples and 18 rock-chip samples (pits) were taken from 191 metres of trenching as well as 18 rock chip samples from pits. Orientation soil and stream sampling and other regional reconnaissance sampling and exploration were also completed during the 1997 programme. P a g e | 55 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 10.3. ANVIL PROGRAMMES 2002 & 2003 The drilling programmes carried out in 2002 and 2003 were partly undertaken in response to the observation in Munro (1998) that as the “upper 30 metres of the deposit is poorly defined, infill pattern diamond drilling is required”, along with the need to clarify the extent of the mineralisation and to sterilise certain areas prior to the commencement of mining. The diamond core drilling procedures used during the 2002 and 2003 programs were compatible with those of the 1997 Anvil drilling program. A Stanley Drilling Longyear 38 Rig was used in the 2002-03 programmes. To avoid the need to reduce core size at depth to NQ, the first 60 m was drilled using PQ diameter, followed by HQ. This practice ensures that a good volume of mineralised intercept core is available for both assay and archive. Core orientation procedures were routinely conducted, although drilling conditions at times limited successful achievement of orientation results. Core recoveries across the mineralised horizons typically exceeded 95%. Regrettably, all archived core from the 1997 and 2002 campaigns was rendered useless after core trays were overturned by army units during the latter stages of the civil war. Fortunately, photographs of this core, taken for geotechnical purposes, are still available. 10.4. ANVIL PROGRAMME 2004 The objective of the 2004 programme was to extend the resource down to 300 m below surface and to provide data for a pre-feasibility study on an underground mine. 14 holes were pre-collared with RC (414 m) and drilled to a maximum ore intercept depth of 280 m below surface (3,811 m). The diamond core drilling procedures used during the 2004 programme were largely compatible with those of the previous two programmes, although core recoveries were not as good due to technical problems with the rig. Stanley Drilling was the contractor for both the RC and diamond drilling. Downhole surveys were carried out at 50 m intervals using an Eastman camera. Core orientation was attempted using the spear method, but poor ground conditions rendered the data to be of little practical use. 10.5. ANVIL PROGRAMME 2005/6 The objective of the 2005/6 programme was to increase the confidence in the geological model and upgrade the resource classification to a depth of 400 m below surface for a possible future underground mining operation. Diamond drillholes from this programme were identified with the prefix “DDD”. The programme was drilled with one of Anvil’s own Boart Longyear LF90 rigs, managed by Wallis Drilling. The holes were all drilled to 45 m with HQ (to which depth the holes were cased) and drilling continued with NQ. Drilling procedures were upgraded following recommendations made by Arnold (2004b), and included reducing the downhole survey interval (to approximately 30 m) and P a g e | 56 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 establishing the daily maintenance of an up-to-date digital database of geological and geotechnical logs, survey data, and QA/QC data. Each hole was surveyed every 30-40 m, using a single shot Tropari tool. Drilling procedures were similar to those of the 2004 programme. 10.6. ANVIL PROGRAMME 2007 A surface programme was drilled from the pit in 2007 to increase the confidence in the underground resource. A total of 9 diamond holes were completed for 2061 m to better define the mineralisation beneath the current pit at the time. The drillholes were all diamond HQ near surface and reduced to NQ at depth for the deeper holes. A total of 78 UGD series underground holes were completed as grade control diamond holes. 10.7. ANVIL PROGRAMME 2008 In late 2008 there was the recognition that another surface drilling programme was needed as there was significant and increasing capital cost being sunk into the Dikulushi Mine. The objective of the 2008 programme was to better define the resource below the 630 mRL to assist with the planned underground development. The orebody below the 630 mRL was at the bottom of the resource model at the time. A decision was made to mobilize a Titan drill rig to site in late October 2008 to commence drilling. By the time the mine was placed on care and maintenance in early December 2008, only two out of the 5 proposed holes had been completed. Both holes intersected the mineralisation but were not sampled. 10.8. MWL PROGRAMME 2010 The Kazumbula deposit was drilled by Anvil during 2008. The Anvil drilling data assisted MWL with drillhole planning and targeting of the Kazumbula deposit. MWL drilled RC and diamond holes (Table 10.1) to define the near surface copper mineralisation during August and September 2010. The drillhole spacing was approximately 15 m along drill lines spaced 20 m apart. Drillholes were drilled at approximately 60 degrees to the south-southeast to maximise the angle of intersection with the orebody. Table 10.1 MWL drilling at Kazumbula Prospect Kazumbula Kazumbula Type RC DDH/tail No Holes 17 10 Metres 1676 674.4 Samples 1676 674 The RC drilling was completed by Titan Drilling of Lubumbashi, utilizing a truck mounted RC rig. A supervising geologist was on site at all times during the drilling and industry standard procedures were followed during the RC drilling programme. The diamond drilling was contracted and completed by Chantete Emerald, who completed five diamond holes (HQ3) from surface and four diamond tails from RC pre-collars (HQ3). P a g e | 57 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 10.9. SURVEY CONTROL Drill hole collar locations have been located using a Leica total station by mine surveyors. Collar surveys were stored with both local mine grid and UTM coordinates. A local Dikulushi Grid was established and collar locations stored in both local mine grid and UTM co-ordinates. The relationships between Dikulushi Mine Grid and magnetic (MN) and true north (TN) orientations are as follows: • • 10.10. Grid North = MN - 20.2˚ Grid North = TN - 22.0˚ DRILLING ORIENTATION Downhole surveys of drillholes were completed every 30 m to 50 m of advance in order to ensure that each hole was not deviating too much from the planned dip and azimuth. The surveys were measured using Eastman downhole electronic single-shot cameras that record the dip and azimuth and results were then tabulated for each hole as a report, which was checked by the site geologists for accuracy. The camera has a stated accuracy of 1 degree in dip and azimuth. No magnetic minerals have been noted in the logging of the drill core at Dikulushi and thus the recorded azimuths are regarded as reliable. Holes at both Dikulushi and Kazumbula were generally drilled orthogonal to the mineralisation, and thus significant true width conversions were not required. The average mineralisation true thickness is significantly greater than the average (1 m) downhole drilling increment, so distorted intersections of the mineralisation at Dikulushi and Kazumbula were not obtained. P a g e | 58 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 11. SAMPLE PREPARATION, ANALYSIS AND SECURITY All of the drilling data used in the Dikulushi resource estimate was collected by Anvil. A review of Anvil’s procedures by Mawson personnel concluded that they were of an acceptable industry standard. The sampling procedures described below have been used for all diamond core drilled at the Dikulushi deposits. All sampling and logging data are stored in secure database systems and have been subject to routine validations during capture and storing. 11.1. DIAMOND CORE SAMPLING Drill core (HQ and NQ size) is sampled by splitting it in half with a water lubricated diamond blade saw. MWL has ensured the diamond blade is cleaned frequently using a brick to prevent across metre contamination (especially in zones of massive sulphide). All drill core was sampled on a metre basis from the start to end of hole. Minor residual sample lengths (less than one metre) may occur along mineralisation contacts or at the end of holes. Each metre sample of half drill core is collected from a consistent side of the drill core tray and placed into a sequentially numbered sample bag. Sample log books are used to record the drillhole number, sample number and the “from” and “to” sample depths. MWL has additionally incorporated electronic data capture of the sampling into a toughbook laptop computer. Calico/sample bags were tied up and placed into larger labelled plastic bags for transportation. Submission forms for the laboratory were completed and placed into a small plastic bag within the large labelled plastic bag. The samples were appropriately packaged for transport to the respective international or minesite laboratories. Transport documentation and customs clearance were completed by the company representatives. Laboratory turn-around times varied from a few days to typically three to four weeks for the international laboratories. 11.1.1. DIAMOND CORE RECOVERY At the end of a core run, the drillers attach a water hose and pump the HQ/NQ core out of the barrel into an angle iron ensuring minimal disturbance. The driller records the total depth and core run length on a core block, also noting any core loss, and places this into the core tray at the end of the run. The site geologist regularly checks the depths provided by the drillers with the core in the trays during site visits. Diamond core recovery is good and was noted to be above 95%. Any handling core breaks are marked with a cross. Once a core tray is full, the tray was labelled with from and to depths and the hole number. The labelled core trays were moved to the core logging/storage area at the Dikulushi mine site. 11.1.2. DIAMOND CORE LOGGING The drill core was washed to remove any residual cuttings. Downhole metre marks were made by the geologist on the consistent half of the core. Wet core was photographed for the more recent drillholes, using a digital camera before logging. Labels showing hole number, tray number and from and to depths were placed in the photo frame for each core tray photograph. Core recovery, RQD, geology, alteration and mineralisation were logged onto standard paper logs and more recently by MWL into a toughbook laptop computer using LogChief software. The logs were electronically P a g e | 59 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 captured into an Access database at Dikulushi or electronic logs were emailed to Mawson West’s Perth office and loaded into the central Datashed database. 11.2. RC SAMPLING AND LOGGING RC drilling by Anvil was generally limited to depths of less than 120 metres below the pre-mining surface. The portion of the Mineral Resource and Ore Reserve estimates that are the subject of this report are informed entirely by diamond core drill holes. 11.3. SAMPLE QUALITY Drill core samples that inform the portion of the Mineral Resource and Ore Reserve estimates that are the subject of this report are of good quality with no major risks identified for use in the resource estimate. Open pit blast hole grade control samples and underground sludge hole samples have not been used to inform the Dikulushi resource and reserve estimates. With respect to sample security, no sample preparation other than diamond core cutting was carried out by MWL or Anvil employees. Reference materials, including chips, core, pulps and residues are retained and stored at the Dikulushi mine site. Assessment of the data indicates that the assay results are generally consistent with the logged alteration and mineralisation tenor. 11.4. SAMPLE PREPARATION AND ANALYTICAL PROCEDURES Preparation and assaying of samples from the Dikulushi Project has been carried out at three independent laboratories: Genalysis (RSA) and Genalysis (Western Australia) ALS-Chemex (RSA) (from Jan 2008) SGS (Dikulushi). 11.4.1. ANALYSES Samples sent to Genalysis in Johannesburg, South Africa, were processed and analysed using the following methods. All samples were weighed, then dried at 110° for 8 hours and then crushed to a nominal 10 mm crush size in a conventional jaw crusher. The entire sample was then pulverised to a nominal 85% passing 75µm in an LM-5 mixer-mill. A scoop of the pulverised sample was then digested by the AX method which was a modified (higher precision) 4 acid digest for base metals. Analysis technique was by AAS for Copper (0.01% detection limit) and Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry (ICP-MS) for Ag (1ppm detection limit), As (10ppm detection limit), Co (1ppm detection limit) and U (0.1ppm detection limit). Results were reported electronically via email and a hard copy report was mailed to MWL and Anvil staff. Samples sent to ALS Chemex in Johannesburg, South Africa, were prepared and analysed by the following procedures. Samples were weighed and then dried for 8 hrs at 110° and then fine crushed to 2 mm with a 250 g split of the sample taken for pulverising to 85% passing -75µm. The sample was then digested in a four acid mixture (HF, HNO3, HClO4) and a HCL leach with analysis by AAS P a g e | 60 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 (method AA62) for Copper (0.01 to 40% reporting range). Other elements were analysed by the ICPAES (optical emission method) with detection limits of Ag (0.5ppm), As (5ppm), Co (1ppm), U (10ppm) and Co (1ppm). Samples sent to the SGS laboratory at Dikulushi were prepared and analysed by the following procedures. Received samples were sorted and dried at 105 degrees for a minimum of 8 hours and then crushed to a nominal 10 mm crush size using a jaw crusher. Samples were split to 250g and then pulverised to 90% passing -75µm. The sample was then digested in triple acid digest (A103 method;0.4g, Hydrochloric acid, Nitric acid and Perchloric acid) and finally analysed by AAS machine with low detection limit (DL) for Copper of 0.001% and an upper detection limit (UL) of 5%, Silver (DL was 5ppm and UL was 500ppm), Cobalt (DL was 20ppm and UL was 5%), Lead (DL was 10ppm and UL 2.5%), Arsenic (DL was 0.01% and UL was 5%), Zinc (DL was 10ppm and UL was 5%) and Fe (DL was 0.01% and UL was 100%). The sample batches included 2 standards, 2 blanks, 2 repeats and 1 replicate per 43 samples. 11.5. BULK DENSITY DETERMINATIONS Samples were collected every metre from the massive sulphide zones and from a representative selection from the transitional and primary zones and un-mineralised zones. Diamond core samples were prepared by ‘squaring off’ the ends of approximately 10-20 cm billets of half core. A total of 1,294 specific gravity (SG) measurements were made of dried half core to obtain the dry weight at Kazumbula. The same piece of core was then measured in water on a suspension cage below the same electronic scale. The conventional formula for SG determination was used, i.e. SG = Dry Sample Weight / (Dry Sample Weight – Wet Sample Weight) 11.6. SAMPLE QAQC 11.6.1. STANDARDS AND BLANKS QAQC for exploration drilling samples includes use of standards, blanks and duplicates, together with internal/laboratory batch control information. Results from submitted standards are shown in Figure 11.1, Figure 11.2 and Figure 11.3. GBM398-4c (Figure 11.3) is a low copper value standard and suggests accurate results for low value samples (~0.39% Cu). P a g e | 61 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Figure 11.1 GBM301-7 suggests accurate values around low value samples (~0.55% Cu) Figure 11.2 The GBM301-8 is a high Cu value standard and suggests accurate results for high value samples (~10% Cu) Figure 11.3 The GBM398-4c is a low Cu value standard and suggests accurate results for low value samples (~0.39% Cu) Analytical results from sample blanks, Figure 11.4, suggest that contamination was kept to a minimum. P a g e | 62 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Figure 11.4 Results for this blank demonstrate that contamination is well contained Both blank and standard sample results indicate that minor sample mislabelling occurred. 11.6.2. LABORATORY QAQC The respective laboratories perform internal QAQC checks as per the following description from ALS Chemex (Johannesburg): “The Laboratory Information Management System (LIMS) inserts quality control samples (reference materials, blanks and duplicates) on each analytical run, based on the rack sizes associated with the method. The rack size is the number of samples, including QC samples, included in a batch. The blank is inserted at the beginning, standards are inserted at random intervals, and duplicates are analysed at the end of the batch. Quality control samples are inserted based on the following basis: Sample Count 40 Methods Regular AAS, ICP-AES and ICP-MS methods QAQC Sample Allocation 2 standards, 1 duplicate, 1 blank The laboratory staff analyses quality control samples at least at the frequency specified above. If necessary, laboratory staff may include additional quality control samples above the minimum specifications.” Failed batches are automatically repeated until acceptable results are achieved. 11.7. SUMMARY STATEMENT Sampling of drillhole material and QAQC is comprehensive in its coverage of the mineralisation and does not favour or misrepresent in-situ mineralisation. Sampling and sub-sampling procedures are of good standard industry practice and have occurred in a safe and secure manner, with minimal time lags between drillhole sampling and analysis. Sufficient drillhole material has been retained should additional verification of results be required. Sample security, preparation and analytical procedures are believed to be able to support representative sample assay results for estimation. Submitted blanks did not raise any risks with regard to contamination. P a g e | 63 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 12. DATA VERIFICATION The comprehensive program of multiple standard and blank inserted at regular but random intervals has highlighted that the Dikulushi sampling is both accurate and precise. The accredited and independent laboratories have evidence of good internal QAQC practices. These results, combined with the good spatial distribution of QAQC sampling, support accurate, precise and uncontaminated sample assay results and have been verified by the principal author and Qualified Person. According to these results and the number of samples available for estimation, the Dikulushi and Kazumbula drillhole databases provide satisfactory sample support and quality for estimating in situ mineralisation. P a g e | 64 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 13. MINERAL PROCESSING AND METALLURGICAL TESTING 13.1. INTRODUCTION Historically Anvil has completed a significant amount of testwork for Dikulushi, and a summary of this work is presented below. Relevant operational data from the Dikulushi processing plant is also tabulated. As the underground ore will be mined from the same or close to the same areas as the ore previously treated at or below the current open pit floor, it is not unreasonable to expect that it will exhibit similar metallurgical characteristics during processing through the existing Dikulushi Processing plant. It should be remembered that the underground was previously developed, mined and ore processed through the current operating plant pre MWL ownership. 13.2. ANVIL TESTWORK 13.2.1. EARLY TESTWORK The following information was supplied by Mawson West as background to the original design for the process plant that was built at Dikulushi. Sedgman has not been able to review the original testwork reports and as such cannot verify the information in this sub-section. A significant amount of metallurgical testwork was undertaken by Anvil for the pre-feasibility phase of their Dikulushi Project between February 1998 and April 1998 by the Minerals Engineering Group of Mintek at their laboratories in Randburg, South Africa. Resource Management Group (RMG) established and supervised the testwork on behalf of Anvil. Local coordination and support in South Africa were provided by Fluor Daniel, Southern Africa. The Mintek data were used as the process design basis for the pre-feasibility study completed by Signet Engineering in Perth in April 1998. A previous testwork program was carried out by the Bureau de Recherches Géologiques et Minières (BRGM), the results of which were available in Report no. 80 SGN 260 MIN, issued in April 1980. A limited amount of preliminary testwork was initiated by Anvil and undertaken by Goldfields in Johannesburg and was detailed in their report no. FL04\ks dated 4 November, 1996. The metallurgical testwork program carried out by Mintek in 1998 was on various sulphide, oxide and host rock samples from Dikulushi. The locations of these samples, their average grades and the rock type classification are listed below in Table 13.1. Each composite comprised material from one to three drillholes. P a g e | 65 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Table 13.1 Details of Dikulushi drill core used in Mintek metallurgical testing Composite No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Drillholes DIK 15, 22 DIK 28, 31 DIK 6, 11, 14 DIK 26 DIK 5, 14 DIK 12, 13, 23 Classifications East-oxidised East-deeper West-main West-disseminated West-complex East-transition % Copper Total Oxide 9.5 1.5-2 15.2 0.8 10.1 1.0 2.8 0.3 9.0 1.3 7.9 0.6 Silver g/t 360 525 150 60 50 260 The sample nomenclature indicates that compositing was based upon special and oxidation properties of the ore. Sedgman cannot comment on the representivity of these samples with respect to the current study. Physical tests were undertaken for typical composites of massive sulphide and light grey sandstone. Flotation tests were carried out on primary, transition, oxidised and highly oxidised composites from the east zone, and primary and complex sulphide composites from the west. These composites represented an arbitrary sub-division of the ore body. Head analyses revealed a relatively high total copper grade of 15.2% for the East Primary composite, while the others were in the range of 8.2 - 11.4%, which was reasonably close to the target grade of 10% copper. Silver assays were variable, with a range of 138 - 562 g/t, the highest being for the East Primary. Iron and sulphur levels were relatively low. Potential penalty elements identified were lead and zinc in the West Complex, arsenic in the West Primary and West Complex, and fluorine in all composites. The previous testwork by BRGM in the 1980s indicated good flotation characteristics, with recoveries ranging from 84 - 96% for copper, and 79 - 96% for silver. High grade concentrate grades of 63 - 72% copper and 950 - 2,600 g/t silver were produced. BRGM found that sulphidation with Na2S was required for oxidised material, though highly oxidised near surface ore was not tested. Mineralogical examination revealed that the dominant copper sulphide mineral was chalcocite, in both massive and disseminated forms. Some of the massive chalcocite was crystalline, and may tend to slime during grinding. Complex sulphides in the west zone contained chalcopyrite, bornite and sphalerite. Sphalerite is also common in other areas associated with chalcopyrite. Near surface oxide contained malachite, azurite and chrysocolla. The latter did not float even when sulphidised. Silver was assumed to be present mostly in solid solution in chalcocite, and occasionally as selenide. Arsenic occurred as arsenopyrite and tennanite. Sandstone was the dominant host rock. The physical tests revealed that the Dikulushi ore was of moderate hardness, with figures of 14.1 17.4 for the Rod Mill Work Index (RMWI), 10.5 - 12.5 for Ball Mill Work Index (BMWI) and 0.21 - 0.39 for Abrasion Index (AI) being reported. The higher indices generally related to the massive ore. Flotation results at a grind size of 80% passing 75 microns were comparable to those in the BRGM data, with recoveries of 71 - 97% for copper and 63 - 95% for silver. The lower figures were for near surface highly oxidised material. The predicted concentrate grades were 48 - 70% copper, and 661 P a g e | 66 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 2,300 g/t silver. Detailed concentrate analyses revealed that fluorine was the only impurity over the penalty threshold. Reagent usage appeared modest, except for the Na2S required for the oxidised material, which required up to 3.2 kg per tonne of ore 13.2.2. LATER TESTWORK Additional testwork was performed by Independent Metallurgical Laboratories (IML) in Perth during 2003. The related testwork reports have been reviewed and Sedgman has been able to verify the information detailed in this sub-section. Five separate copper ore composites from Dikulushi were used for the testwork: high grade chalcocite disseminated and low grade chalcocite lead and zinc rich chalcocite bornite stockpiled dense media separation tailings. The various chalcocite composite assays are detailed in Table 13.2. Table 13.2 Head grades of chalcocite composites Element Unit Cu (Total) – Assay Cu (Total) – Calc. Cu (Total – Sequential.) – Calc. Cu (Acid Soluble) Cu (Cyanide Soluble) Cu (Residual) Ag Pb Zn % % % % % % ppm High grade chalcocite 21.9 20.1 20.4 3.52 16.8 0.14 624 39 ppm 189 ppm Disseminated & low grade chalcocite 3.05 2.99 3.05 1.27 1.73 0.04 75 21 ppm 115 ppm Pb/Zn rich chalcocite 6.30 5.53 5.67 0.26 3.83 1.58 23 1.58% 10.88% The Sequential Diagnostic Leach Analysis identifies the oxide component as Acid Soluble copper, the Secondary Sulphides (including Chalcocite and Covellite) report as Cyanide Soluble species and the residual fraction relates to primary copper sulphides such as chalcopyrite. Mineralogical examinations identified the abundance of various minerals as illustrated in Table 13.3. P a g e | 67 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Table 13.3 Relative abundance of significant minerals Disseminated Pb/Zn rich & low grade chalcocite Mineral chalcocite +0.1mm -0.1mm +0.1mm -0.1mm +0.1mm -0.1mm Chalcocite Dominant Dominant Dominant Dominant Minor Accessory Malachite Major Major Major Major Bornite Accessory Accessory Trace Trace Accessory Chalcopyrite Trace Major Minor Pyrite Trace Major Minor Sphalerite Accessory Dominant Dominant High grade chalcocite Note. Dominant: >50%, Major: 20 - 50%, Minor: 10 – 20%, Accessory: 1 – 10%, Trace: <1%. The comminution data derived for these composites relating to the Bond Ball Mill, Bond Rod Mill and Abrasion Indices are summarised in Table 13.4. Table 13.4 Comminution testwork results Composite High Grade Chalcocite Disseminated & Low Grade Chalcocite Pb/Zn Rich Chalcocite BRMWi (kWH/t) 15.7 17.3 17.7 BBMWi (kWh/t) 12.4 13.8 - BAi 0.1472 0.4224 0.2360 A series of flotation tests was performed on the composites. HIGH GRADE CHALCOCITE There was minimal difference in rougher flotation performance between grind P 80s of 75, 106 and 150 microns using a stainless steel mill. See Table 13.5. Table 13.5 Effect of grind size on flotation performance (high grade chalcocite) Grind P80 - mic 75 106 150 Cumulative Rougher Concentrates Copper Silver Assay (%) Distribution (%) Assay (ppm) Distribution (%) 52.0 97.8 1567 97.3 53.2 97.6 1632 97.3 54.9 97.7 1543 97.0 Using a grind P80 of 150 microns in each case, rougher flotation tests at potassium amyl xanthate (collector) additions of 70, 105 and 140 g/t resulted in high copper grades and recoveries in each case although flotation kinetics were significantly slower at the lower addition rate, see Table 13.6. P a g e | 68 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Table 13.6 Effects of collector addition on flotation performance (high grade chalcocite) Collector Addition (PAX) – g/t 70 105 140 Cumulative Rougher Concentrates Copper Silver Assay (%) Distribution (%) Assay (ppm) Distribution (%) 55.3 95.8 1818 96.8 51.0 96.2 1644 96.8 54.9 97.7 1543 97.0 DISSEMINATED AND LOW GRADE CHALCOCITE A set of flotation tests was conducted at various grind sizes. A grind P80 of 150 microns produced similar results to the finer grind sizes, see Table 13.7. Table 13.7 Effect of grind size on flotation performance (disseminated and low grade chalcocite) Grind P80 - mic 75 106 150 Cumulative Rougher Concentrates Copper Silver Assay (%) Distribution (%) Assay (ppm) Distribution (%) 13.4 82.3 303 80.6 14.3 81.5 326 79.4 13.1 81.5 303 78.8 The effect of variation in collector dosing was investigated. Although a higher collector addition produced better results, these tests were performed at the fine grind P 80 of 75 microns and before an optimised pulp Eh had been established. Consequently the testing was inconclusive, see Table 13.8. Table 13.8 Effect of collector addition on flotation performance (disseminated and low grade chalcocite) Collector Addition (PAX) – g/t 100 165 Cumulative Rougher Concentrates Copper Silver Assay (%) Distribution (%) Assay (ppm) Distribution (%) 22.4 75.8 521 75.3 25.5 78.0 615 79.5 PB/ZN RICH CHALCOCITE Two sets of tests were performed to investigate the effect of grind size at different pulp Eh levels. The results are shown in Table 13.9. Table 13.9 Effect of grind size and Eh level on flotation performance (Pb/Zn rich chalcocite) Grind P80 - mic Eh – mV (Ag/AgCl/Sat KCl) 75 106 150 150 106 150 70 70 Cumulative Rougher Concentrates Copper Zinc Assay (%) Distribution (%) Assay (%) Distribution (%) 11.9 98.0 23.8 88.6 13.1 94.8 27.3 82.0 12.0 12.6 97.6 98.1 23.2 25.3 90.7 90.4 P a g e | 69 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 The tests showed high copper recoveries but the copper grades were diluted by the amount of zinc also reporting to concentrate. A series of tests were performed to determine the effect of a range of Zinc Depressants – Sodium Cyanide, Zinc Sulphate and Sodium Meta-bisulphite. The results were disappointing with only sodium meta-bisulphite demonstrating any depression of zinc, but unfortunately it also depressed copper. A mineralogical examination of a first rougher concentrate showed that approximately 50% of the sphalerite was locked with chalcopyrite and another 10-20% of the sphalerite was associated with other sulphides. MIXED CHALCOCITE COMPOSITE A locked cycle flotation test was performed on a composite comprising 41.6% High Grade Massive Chalcocite and 58.4% Disseminated and Low Grade Chalcocite which produced a calculated head grade of 9.41% copper. A combined rougher/cleaner copper concentrate grade of 54.6% was produced at an overall recovery of 86.9%. The combined silver concentrate grade was 1,683 ppm at a recovery of 91.9%. ROM LOCKED CYCLE TEST In 2004 a locked cycle test was performed on a plant feed sample dated 25/11/2003 producing a unit flash flotation cell, rougher and cleaner concentrate. The head feed sequential analysis is shown in Table 13.10 and the test results in Table 13.11. Table 13.10 Head grades of chalcocite composites Element Cu (Total) - Assay Cu (Total) – Calc. Cu (Total – Sequential.) – Calc. Cu (Acid Soluble) Cu (Cyanide Soluble) Cu (Residual) Ag Pb Zn Table 13.11 Unit % % % % % % ppm ppm ppm 25/11/2003 Feed Sample 9.18 9.23 9.31 1.98 7.32 0.01 Not Assayed 41 857 Locked cycle flotation test results Product Wt% Unit Cell Conc. Rougher Conc. Cleaner Conc. Scavenger Tail Calculated Head 4.99 8.62 5.32 81.07 100.00 Assay (%) 61.32 47.80 14.25 1.03 8.79 Copper Distribution (%) 34.92 47.72 8.47 8.89 100.00 Assay (%) 2400 1600 305 39 306 Silver Distribution (%) 39.21 45.14 5.31 10.34 100.00 P a g e | 70 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 The results indicate a combined concentrate grade of 42.1% copper at an overall recovery of 91.1%. The combined silver concentrate grade was 1,447ppm at an overall recovery of 89.7%. TESTWORK SUMMARY Of the three chalcocite composites tested at IML in 2003 the high grade chalcocite composite was the most relevant to the Dikulushi Open Pit Project. However it cannot be considered truly representative as the head grade was far higher than the planned feed grade and operational data at Dikulushi showed that there was a positive correlation between copper head grade and recovery. Overall the testwork did demonstrate that provided the flotation conditions, including Redox potential, was carefully controlled, chalcocite ore could be effectively recovered by flotation producing fast kinetics, high concentrate grades and good recoveries. 13.3. PLANT OPERATIONAL RESULTS MWL has indicated that the flotation plant at Dikulushi previously operated from 2004 to 2008 and processed high grade ore from both the open pit and underground mine. According to Anvil production data between September 2004 and April 2008, it achieved recoveries of 88.3% copper and 88.5% silver, producing a concentrate containing 54.7% copper and 1,659 g/t silver. The plant was shut down in November 2008 after treating low grade stockpile material during the last months of operation. In May 2010 the plant was refurbished and commenced production in June 2010 by treating low grade stockpile ore and HMS tails. Over the past 3 years, recoveries vary between 60 - 70% for the low grade stockpile material and the open pit cut back ROM feed grade recoveries have varied between 75% - 95%. Concentrate grades in the last 12 months have averaged 56% copper and 1,515 g/t silver over the past year. Table 13.13 in the next section, shows the last 3 years production on a month by month basis. Sedgman has reviewed the production data as supplied by MWL for the periods Feb 2007 to Apr 2008 and June 2010 to May 2011, however, Sedgman has not reviewed the production data for the period June 2011 to July 2013. 13.4. METALLURGICAL PROPERTIES OF THE CUT BACK ORE AND UNDERGROUND ORE The Dikulushi deposit was mined and processed by Anvil for several years and the high grade chalcocite ore below the current pit floor has previously been processed in the mill during underground mining operations. Anvil monthly production reports, for the previously mined underground are tabled in table 13.12, where the mill feed was from the old open pit and the then underground mining operations. In reviewing the historic operating data, it can be seen that the copper recovery was approximately 90.4% over the period, with underground recoveries averaging 86.9 to 92.8%. P a g e | 71 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Table 13.12 Month Feb07* Mar-07 Apr-07 May-07 Jun-07 July 07* Aug-07 Sep-07 Oct-07 Nov-07 Dec-07 Jan-08 Feb 08* Dikulushi processing summary (February 2007 – April 2008) Blend % ROM RL mined (Ore Only) 60 Cu (%) Ag (ppm) Cu (%) Ag (%) Concentrate Grade Cu Ag (%) (ppm) 27,779 5.93 181 85.7 86.9 56.0 1730 Flotation Plant Tonnes Plant Feed Recovery 100 100 100 100 860 pit stockpile 860 pit stockpile 850 pit stockpile 850 pit stockpile 28,508 28,487 26,188 30,805 8.44 7.68 7.61 7.74 264 240 231 233 91.6 90.7 90.2 91.0 90.4 90.5 90.1 90.5 56.2 55.1 55.1 55.3 1734 1722 1670 1654 91.4 870 Dev 31,838 7.28 214 89.5 89.8 56.6 1668 30,802 25,934 31,193 30,286 30,641 30,746 30,789 7.96 7.97 8.18 7.81 8.45 6.00 5.09 245 258 272 250 266 187 154 91.2 91.3 92.4 92.2 92.8 90.6 87.2 90.5 91.4 92.5 91.8 92.0 89.4 87.7 56.2 54.9 54.6 56.3 56.8 55.2 55.7 1717 1777 1821 1793 1772 1694 1687 37,998 5.50 170 88.2 88.5 54.5 1691 33,400 455,395 4.76 7.04 139 218 86.9 90.4 88.4 90.3 54.0 55.5 1601 1721 100 100 100 100 100 100 81.4 Mar-08 100 Apr-08 90 stockpile 850 Dev 850 Dev & 890 Stoping 870 Dev & 890 stoping 870 Dev & 890 stoping 830 Dev & 890 stoping 830 Dev & 870 Stoping 830 Dev & 890/870 Stoping 830 Dev & 870 Stoping Total * Low grade ore blended in with the development or stoping ore. Table 13.3 below shows the current processing statistics for the MWL operations from June 2010 through to July 2013. During this period a combination of LG stockpile material from the old Anvil open pit was processed in the early months, to satellite orebodies such as Boom Gate etc, through to the current mill feed being exclusively from the open pit cut-back material. This process feed material is set to continue until December 2013. In reviewing the recent operating data, it can be seen that the copper recoveries realised over the past 7 months, reflecting the fresh open pit cut-back material feed, was approximately 94.3% over the period. Table 13.13 Ore Processed Mill Feed Grade Mill Feed Grade Tails Grade Cu Tails Grade Ag Conc Tonnes Conc Grade Cu Conc Grade Ag Cu metal in Conc Ag metal in Conc Recovery Cu Recovery Ag Dikulushi processing summary (June 2010 – July 2013) tonnes Cu % Ag g/t Cu % Ag g/t dmt Cu % Ag g/t dmt oz % % Jun10 5,387 1.28 35.87 0.34 10.1 128 38.7 1,067 51.45 4,384 74.62 70.57 Jul-10 36,157 1.45 40.4 0.39 11.1 896 43.5 1,138 389.6 32,778 74.31 69.88 Aug10 43,882 1.04 27.63 0.35 10.5 719 42.7 1,107 306.9 25,581 67.25 65.62 Sep10 40,839 1.27 31.72 0.46 10.9 783 43.0 1,119 336.7 28,177 64.92 67.65 Oct-10 27,450 3.78 77.17 1.64 23.0 1,380 44.1 1,139 608.5 50,534 58.64 74.20 Nov10 49,029 1.52 41.2 0.63 13.6 1,066 41.5 1,188 442.7 40,726 59.41 62.68 Dec10 41,111 1.17 28.5 0.52 10.70 684 39.74 1139 272 25,057 56.54 66.45 Jan-11 49,650 1.33 32.6 0.46 11.3 1001 40.1 1070 400 32,737 64.13 62.70 Feb11 42,839 1.32 29.2 0.43 7.95 890 41.6 1033 366 29,385 66.91 73.09 Mar11 46,054 1.28 27.8 0.46 7.85 893 39.35 941 351 27,279 62.66 63.34 Apr11 40,855 1.40 34.6 0.44 8.7 906 40.2 1092 365 31,904 67.46 71.25 May11 44,705 1.32 33.31 0.52 9.1 865 41.7 993 361 27,559 61.37 61.3 YTD 467,958 1.46 35.31 0.54 10.95 10,211 41.66 1089 4,251 356,101 64.05 66.68 P a g e | 72 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Jun-11 Jul-11 Aug-11 Sep-11 Oct-11 Nov-11 Dec-11 Jan-12 Feb-12 Mar-12 Apr-12 May-12 Jun-12 YTD-12 Ore Processed tonnes 41,684 44,113 31,913 35,566 32,799 34,417 30,084 14,008 23,756 15,009 13,061 14,096 17,355 Reconciliated Mill Feed Grade Reconciliated Mill Feed Grade Cu % 1.55 1.44 2.12 1.70 1.77 1.36 1.43 1.96 1.95 2.06 2.24 2.73 2.90 1.80 Ag g/t 28.14 29.65 37.08 33.20 32.12 27.30 29.86 41.37 37.87 38.07 40.57 49.30 50.06 34.15 Tails Grade Cu Cu % 0.62 0.59 0.92 0.68 0.73 0.54 0.53 0.71 0.93 0.74 0.69 0.76 0.74 0.69 Tails Grade Ag Ag g/t 7.40 8.28 9.02 7.77 8.90 7.70 7.85 14.25 16.50 13.10 12.60 14.76 13.84 10.75 10,437 Concentrate Tonnes Produced dmt 347,863 991 924 944 926 863 723 699 495 780 633 621 804 1,032 Concentrate Grade Cu Cu % 39.54 41.36 41.36 39.96 40.13 39.62 39.28 36.00 32.02 32.07 33.46 35.24 37.15 37.83 Concentrate Grade Ag Ag g/t 803.56 997.08 911.84 883.23 865.56 900.22 936.86 781.60 667.08 604.74 600.72 620.20 622.99 790.95 Cu metal in Concentrate dmt 392 382 391 370 346 287 275 178 250 203 208 283 383 3,948 Ag metal in Concentrate oz 25,608 29,629 27,683 26,290 24,007 20,934 21,064 12,440 16,737 12,314 11,998 16,036 20,667 265,405 Recovery Cu % 60.7 60.2 57.7 61.0 59.8 61.3 63.6 65.0 53.9 65.6 70.9 73.7 76.0 63.0 Recovery Ag % 67.9 70.5 72.8 69.3 70.9 69.3 72.9 66.8 57.9 67.0 70.4 71.8 74.0 69.5 Ore Processed tonnes Reconciliated Mill Feed Grade Reconciliated Mill Feed Grade Cu % 2.65 2.28 2.33 2.04 5.09 5.41 5.48 6.32 5.46 6.50 10.27 10.88 7.02 5.21 Ag g/t 47.22 42.24 39.35 34.53 152.94 139.04 145.47 183.09 146.87 164.68 316.98 354.49 226.97 141.47 Tails Grade Cu Cu % 0.65 0.59 0.55 0.45 0.42 0.44 0.40 0.43 0.36 0.44 0.51 0.61 0.46 0.48 Tails Grade Ag Ag g/t 11.59 10.92 9.94 6.03 21.39 14.95 15.08 11.72 15.47 20.70 22.94 25.50 20.14 14.93 Concentrate Tonnes Produced dmt 1,448 1,334 1,476 1,200 1,138 2,711 2,685 2,939 2,936 3,087 2,470 2,798 3,723 29,944 Concentrate Grade Cu Cu % 34.86 36.51 37.57 40.49 61.16 58.42 59.42 61.40 62.29 62.70 62.85 60.79 58.97 56.52 Concentrate Grade Ag Ag g/t 620 677 622 725 1,733 1,462 1,532 1,787 1,620 1,499 1,903 1,952 1,864 1,515 Cu metal in Concentrate dmt 505 487 554 486 696 1,584 1,596 1,804 1,829 1,936 1,552 1,701 2,195 16,925 Ag metal in Concentrate oz 28,876 29,014 29,496 27,950 63,410 127,429 132,235 168,837 152,974 148,824 151,060 175,621 223,058 1,458,783 Recovery Cu % 76.9 75.2 77.4 78.7 92.4 92.6 93.3 93.8 93.4 93.9 95.8 95.4 94.2 91.5 Recovery Ag % 76.9 75.4 76.0 83.2 87.1 90.2 90.5 94.2 90.3 88.7 93.9 94.0 92.1 90.3 Jul-12 24,739 Aug-12 Sep-12 Oct-12 Nov-12 Dec-12 Jan-13 Feb-13 Mar-13 Apr-13 May-13 Jun-13 28,351 30,690 30,242 14,808 31,614 31,232 30,442 35,865 31,706 15,787 16,387 Jul-13 33,181 YTD-13 355,043 Figure 13.1shows a cross section of the Mineral Resource as it relates to the previously mined parts of the orebody via the Anvil open pit, Anvil underground and MWL open pit cut-back. Figure 13.1 Dikulushi Underground sources of ore - showing North-South section view at 50205E The planned underground ore production is to be from the previously developed and mined levels at the 810 mRL down to the fully developed 770 mRL and a minor amount of ore from the partially P a g e | 73 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 developed 750 mRL. Thus large portions of the underground ore reserve ore tons have been previously treated in the processing plant, as can be seen in the production processing summary table 13.12; and the more recent production processing data in table 13.13, and hence significant variations in ore quality is not expected from the mining of the underground Mineral Reserves. P a g e | 74 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 14. MINERAL RESOURCE ESTIMATES 14.1. DIKULUSHI MINERAL RESOURCE ESTIMATE The Dikulushi Mineral Resource estimate was prepared in May 2009 by Mr. David Gray, Qualified Person and principal author of the technical report which was originally submitted in February 2011. The May 2009 Mineral Resource was subsequently updated in August 2011 using the latest available survey data of the historical volumes mined by Anvil and updated pre-feasibility study cut-off grades for the proposed cut back of the open pit. A previous (October 2007) Mineral Resource estimate for Dikulushi was generated for the purposes of evaluating underground Mineral Resources. The geological interpretation of copper-silver mineralisation beneath the open pit was largely based on the diamond drillhole database and enabled the main Footwall zone of mineralisation to be extended to the Kiaka Carbonates. Between the October 2007 estimate and the May 2009 estimate, an additional 23,610 m of underground, infill and extensional drilling was completed (Figure 14.1) across the Dikulushi ore body and can be broken down by sampling type: 802 m were derived from underground channel sampling 3,747 m from underground grade control diamond drilling 4,789 m from RC drilling 14,272 m from surface diamond drilling. The May 2009 estimate was based on all available data as at the end of November 2008, with no outstanding core logging, sampling or assay results remaining. Since that time there has been no additional data that impacts on the estimate of resources remaining below the base of the open pit cut back that was completed in July 2013. Dikulushi mineralisation (Figure 14.2, showing footwall mineralisation in green and hanging wall mineralisation in orange) is characterised by a hydrothermal copper-silver vein system hosted by Proterozoic sediments of the Upper Kundelungu Group, and has two distinct ore zones. A dominant “Footwall” zone is intersected over a 230 m strike length with thicknesses of up to 25 m, which decreases with increasing depth. This zone comprises semi-massive chalcocite and/or bornite veins, strikes east-northeast and dips southeast at approximately 65°. Exhibiting good strike continuity, it can be traced to depths of approximately 500 m below surface. A secondary “Hanging Wall” zone is observed within 50 m of the Footwall zone, and comprises discontinuous, steeply dipping, chalcocite veins, veinlets and disseminations. These dip at varying angles to the Footwall zone and may occasionally intersect it. Apart from minor other occurrences, the Hanging Wall zone is largely absent below the base of the open pit. Grade interpolation was undertaken for total copper (%) and silver grade (g/t). Wireframes were created for the domains and defined zones of similar weathering, faulting, stratigraphy and copper grade. Sample copper and silver analytical results were composited to one metre interval lengths per domain. Variography displayed reasonable continuity with low nugget values. P a g e | 75 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Figure 14.1 An oblique southward looking 3D view of drillhole type and distribution at Dikulushi The resulting Mineral Resource statement was depleted for open pit and underground material mined as surveyed from mined volumes and since the previous October 2007 estimate through to November 2008. The estimate is representative of all data acquired. Mineral Resources have been classified into Measured, Indicated and Inferred categories for the fresh sulphide mineralisation located below the November 2008 pit surface, as per Table 14.1. Table 14.1 Dikulushi Mineral Resource statement as at August 2011 above a 1.0% copper cut-off grade Volume 3 (m *1,000) 184 90 Density 3 (t/m ) 2.8 2.8 Tonnes (*1,000) 516 251 Copper (%) 7.0 5.6 Silver (g/t) 211 114 Measured & Indicated 274 2.8 767 6.6 179 Inferred 136 2.8 380 6.8 91 Category Measured Indicated It should be noted that this model has now been further depleted with the recently completed open pit cut back; the depletion tables are presented and discussed in Section 14.2. P a g e | 76 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 14.1.1. GEOLOGICAL AND MINERALISATION MODELS Lithology and lode profiles were developed using five metre spaced north-south cross sections. The ore body was modelled as a Footwall fault zone with sporadic mineralisation intersected within 50 m of the overlying hanging wall. Two Hangingwall domains, as observed in the pit, were delineated and modelled. The open pit has mined most of the weathered material and has exposed weathering to depths of 35 m; the impacts of weathering were therefore not considered in the 2009 estimate. Wireframes representing the boundaries relevant to the mineralisation were constructed in three dimensions (3D) using north-south vertical cross sections. Mineralisation outlines were guided by geological continuity between drillholes and a mineralisation threshold between 0.3% and 0.7% copper. Both blasthole and underground channel data (Figure 14.2) supported depth extensions of the Footwall Fault zone. Figure 14.2 A vertically oriented 3D view at Dikulushi, looking southwest, showing mineralisation lenses and current drilling P a g e | 77 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 14.1.2. DRILL DATA FOR MINERAL RESOURCE MODELLING Drill data was stored in Dikulushi’s on-site Access database. While some risk exists regarding the reliability of manually handled data in an Access database, the drillhole de-surveying process revealed only minor location errors, which were immediately corrected. A plan view of drillhole data by type is presented in Figure 14.3. A total of 567 holes were available for geological modelling, comprising 22,129 m surface diamond, 4,951 m surface reverse circulation, 1,285 m channel, 4,131 m underground grade control diamond and 1,369 m sludge samples. This translates as a net increase of 23,610 m from the previous resource estimate. Diamond drilling was undertaken along north-south oriented lines spaced 20 - 25m apart, with holes at 25 m intervals along each line. To maximise the true widths of the intersections, most drilling was angled at 50 to 60 degrees to the south. As the risk of undetected changes to orebody orientation increases with depth, additional infill drilling will naturally assist in improving the confidence in deposit geometry. In 2008, a total of 4 surface exploration drillholes were drilled to both infill and extend Footwall zone mineralisation. While the deposit remains open at depth, this recent drilling has led to only minor east-west extension. Figure 14.3 A plan showing the distribution of drillhole types across Dikulushi; blasthole data from the pit have been excluded Since twin-hole drilling was not completed, drilling and sampling methods were compared for potential bias across a similar volume of the FW zone mineralisation using quantile-quantile (Q-Q) plots. Diamond core was accepted as generally providing the most representative sample. This comparison emphasises the difference in copper values between diamond and sludge hole samples (Figure 14.4), with the latter decreasing as the former increases. As a direct result, sludge hole data was not used in this estimate. P a g e | 78 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Figure 14.4 Quantile-Quantile (Q-Q) plot of Diamond (DD) drilled samples versus sludge drilled samples within a common area 14.1.3. DATA VALIDATION A series of data validations were completed prior to de-surveying the drillhole data into a three dimensional format. These included: verification of collar coordinates with existing topography and underground development wireframes, with virtually no problems observed visualisation of downhole survey data to identify improperly recorded downhole survey values, with all minor discrepancies corrected dataset examination for sample overlaps and/or gaps in downhole survey, sampling and geological logging data, with none observed database interrogation for negative values representing codes such as ‘insufficient sample’, with all such samples set to absent examination for negative assays reflecting ‘below detection’ range; these values were all reset to 0.01% testing for absent or duplicate samples, with none recorded. 14.1.4. DATA PREPARATION FOR MODELLING The de-surveyed 3D assay drillhole file was coded and selected within the mineralisation and lithological 3D wireframes. Each sample interval was coded with a mineralisation zone and weathering profile, providing mineralised domain codes for estimation (Table 14.2). The coded drillhole data was exported for subsequent geostatistical analysis and grade interpolation. P a g e | 79 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Table 14.2 Domain codes for Dikulushi modelling Field name OREZONE WEATH MINED 14.1.5. Domain Oxidised FW zone Fresh FW zone Shallow HW zone A Shallow HW zone B Internal FW zone waste Soil to 5m Oxidised to 35m Transitional to 75m depth Fresh rock Air Not mined Open pit mined Mined underground Open pit reserves Code 50 100 200 300 400 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0 0 1 2 3 DATA COMPOSITING To determine the most common sample length, the distribution of raw sample lengths was plotted. Approximately 45% of the data had a sample length within a few centimetres of 1 m (Figure 14.5). All data was composited to 1 m sample lengths, ensuring that intervals provided good resolution across domain boundaries. The total raw sample length is identical to the composited total sample length. Figure 14.5 Cumulative distribution of sample lengths highlighting the dominant 1m sample length P a g e | 80 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 14.1.6. STATISTICS Statistical analyses of the data, including spatial statistics, were carried out using Supervisor software. The statistical analysis of composite copper grades was undertaken within each of the final domains and the summary results are presented in Table 14.3. Statistics for copper and silver were investigated by domain with histograms and probability plots. The objective of the domain selections was to reduce internal variability and domain mixing, thereby assisting with spatial analysis and providing a more robust estimate. The selected domains appear to be well defined, with a minimal degree of mixing as depicted in Figure 14.6 for Dikulushi’s principal Footwall zone. Table 14.3 Summary statistics for copper % and silver g/t per domain Samples Min Max Mean Std Dev CV Variance Skewness Log variance Geometric mean Waste domain (0) Oxide FW zone domain (50) Fresh FW zone domain (100) HW zone A (200) HW zone B (300) Cu (%) Cu (%) Cu (%) Cu (%) Cu (%) 10429 0.01 5.00 0.20 0.48 2.37 0.23 5.59 1.61 0.07 Ag (g/t) Samples Min Max Mean Std Dev CV Variance Skewness Log variance Geometric mean 14.1.7. 5456 1.00 325.00 14.22 31.09 2.19 966.27 6.19 1.43 6.13 1284 0.01 63.80 7.14 9.69 1.36 93.92 2.42 2.08 3.08 Ag (g/t) 1108 1.00 2615.00 214.27 340.51 1.59 115947.00 2.70 2.64 69.46 17145 0.01 74.34 6.06 8.47 1.40 71.81 2.84 2.75 2.32 Ag (g/t) 16221 1.00 1800.00 251.69 305.00 1.21 93023.50 2.02 2.10 111.94 956 0.01 11.00 2.29 1.76 0.77 3.09 1.60 1.21 1.54 Ag (g/t) 849 1.00 325.00 58.70 53.95 0.92 2910.94 2.11 0.96 39.20 204 0.02 23.00 3.03 4.27 1.41 18.23 2.68 1.87 1.36 Ag (g/t) 179 4.00 730.00 101.73 145.82 1.43 21262.30 2.70 1.37 50.07 Internal waste (400) FW zone Cu (%) 1629 0.01 17.00 0.50 1.69 3.41 2.84 6.62 2.02 0.12 Ag (g/t) 709 1.00 470.00 27.19 59.91 2.20 3588.70 4.98 1.24 11.82 SPATIAL STATISTICS For Dikulushi, variography was analysed using composite data located within the mineralised envelopes of each domain, based on the following methodology: data was declustered prior to variogram modelling so as to remove the effect of closely spaced blast hole and underground channel data the principal axes of anisotropy were determined using semi-variogram (variogram) fans based on normal scores variograms normal scores variograms were calculated for each of the principal axes of anisotropy P a g e | 81 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 downhole normal scores variograms were modelled for each domain and adjusted to determine the normal scores nugget effect variogram models were then determined for each of the principal axes of anisotropy using the nugget effect from the downhole variogram the variogram models were back-transformed to the original distribution and used to guide search parameters and complete ordinary kriging estimation. Figure 14.6 Log histogram and probability plot for the main FW zone of mineralisation showing the results of robust domaining P a g e | 82 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Variogram orientations were largely controlled by the strike of mineralisation and downhole variography. Variogram models for silver and copper were similar, with silver tending to have a slightly longer range of influence. Variogram models for the Footwall zone of mineralisation were robust with a clearly-defined nugget value and well-defined structure (Table 14.4). Omni-directional variogram models were derived for both HW zones and the upper oxidised FW zone. These domains were not critical to this Mineral Resource estimate as this ore has already been mined. They were included to ensure continuity with the deeper domains. Key variogram models for the main FW zone are depicted in Figure 14.7. Table 14.4 No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Assay CU AG CU AG CU AG CU AG CU AG CU AG Assay CU AG CU AG CU AG CU AG CU AG CU AG Dikulushi variogram models with angle1 about axis 3 (Z), angle2 about axis 1 (X) and angle3 about axis 3 (Z) Domain 0 0 50 50 100 100 200 200 300 300 400 400 Domain 0 0 50 50 100 100 200 200 300 300 400 400 Angle1 -5 -5 0 0 -10 -10 0 0 0 0 140 140 St2 par1 11.5 20 34.5 57 26.5 29 15.5 25.5 16 23 40 31 Angle2 130 130 0 0 100 100 0 0 0 0 80 80 St2par2 15 10 34.5 57 18.5 16 15.5 25.5 16 23 33 31 Angle3 10 10 0 0 -80 -80 0 0 0 0 -100 -110 St2 par3 9.5 11.5 34.5 57 8 6.5 15.5 25.5 16 23 14.5 31 Nugget St1 par1 0.06 0.06 0.04 0.04 0.21 0.2 0.11 0.12 0.27 0.28 0.07 0.06 St2 par4 0.29 0.25 0.3 0.33 0.25 0.25 0.32 0.35 0.15 0.26 0.23 0.15 St1 par2 4 10.5 5 5 9 11 5 4.5 3 4 5.5 3 St3 par2 191 399 5 6 5 5 3 1.5 5 4.5 3 4 5 3 0.54 0.51 0.66 0.63 0.3 0.29 0.4 0.33 0.58 0.46 0.7 0.79 St3 par3 St3 par4 10 89 0.12 0.18 39 118.5 - 84 121.5 38.5 48 - St1 par4 6 5 5 5 5 4.5 5 4.5 3 4 5.5 3 St3 par1 - St1 par3 49.5 84.5 38.5 48 - 15 15.5 38.5 48 - 0.25 0.27 0.17 0.2 - P a g e | 83 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Figure 14.7 Variogram models for copper % across the FW zone of mineralisation 14.1.8. BLOCK MODEL The block model dimensions and parameters were based on the geological boundaries and average drill grid spacing. Sub-blocks were used to ensure that the block model honoured the domain geometries and volume. Block estimates were controlled by the original parent block dimension. The individual parent block dimensions were 15 mE by 4 mN by 15 mRL, with sub-blocking allowed. This dimension was supported by a kriging neighbourhood study which demonstrated little change in the kriging efficiency or slope of regression (a measure of bias) from this block size to larger block sizes. P a g e | 84 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 14.1.9. DENSITY ESTIMATES IN THE BLOCK MODEL Density estimates were based on approximately 61 samples from the Footwall mineralisation and 1,236 samples from the surrounding waste material. These values have been tested and confirmed via two mill feed samples. The assigned density of the Footwall ore zone was 2.8 t/m 3 and the surrounding waste material 2.6 t/m3. 14.1.10. DETERMINATION OF TOP CUTS Top cut analysis was used to describe the maximum reasonable metal grade for a composite sample value within a given domain. If the grade of a sample exceeded this value, the grade was reset to the top cut value. The objective of applying top cuts is to minimise the risk of uniquely high metal concentrations biasing individual block estimates, especially those located within areas of low sample support. Top cuts for Dikulushi were established by investigating univariate statistics and histograms of sample values by domain. A top cut level was selected if it reduced the sample variance and did not materially change the mean value. The following top cuts were applied to the data for resource estimation (Table 14.5). Table 14.5 Dikulushi - top cuts per domain Domain 0 50 100 200 300 400 14.1.11. Copper% 5 56 11 23 17 Silver g/t 325 2000 1800 325 730 470 GRADE ESTIMATION Grades for copper and silver were estimated into parent blocks of an empty domain coded block model using ordinary kriging (OK). OK was deemed an appropriate interpolation technique owing to near normal data distributions and differentiable grade ranges particular to the lode style mineralisation. Estimation into parent blocks used a discretisation of 8 (X points) by 3 (Y points) by 8 (Z points) to better represent estimated block volumes. 14.1.12. ORDINARY KRIGING INTERPOLATION Estimation parameters for kriging were based on variography, geological continuity and the average spatial distribution of data. The first pass search radius was set within half to two thirds of the variogram range to improve the quality of the local block grade estimate for areas of close spaced drilling and to ensure that grade was not smeared laterally. Most blocks (75%) were estimated within the first search radius. Subsequent search radii were set to ensure that remaining blocks within the mineralised domain were interpolated with a copper grade. For the ore domains, a minimum of 8 samples were required for a single block estimate and a maximum of 40 samples to limit grade smoothing. Due to the long drillhole intercepts within the orebody estimates were limited to a maximum of 10 samples per drillhole. P a g e | 85 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Soft boundaries were created between the oxidised and fresh weathering domains in order to represent the variable nature of this boundary and the transition in values. All other domain boundaries were hard and data between domains was not included for estimation. 14.1.13. MODEL VALIDATION The first pass of model validation included: visual comparisons (Figure 14.8) of drillholes and estimated block grades checks for negative grade estimates; if there were any, they were reset to a minimum 0.01 % grade checks to ensure that only blocks significantly distal to the drillholes remained without grade estimates. The model was further validated by statistical comparison of mean composite grades and model grades, in addition to visual comparisons with drillholes. A table comparing the mean values for the estimate with those of the data (Table 14.6) illustrates acceptable correlation. Table 14.6 Mean statistics per domain comparing model estimates with data values Domain 100 100 50 50 400 400 Field Ag g/t Cu% Ag g/t Cu% Ag g/t Cu% Data 219.01 7.48 172.11 6.07 17.87 0.42 Model 201.22 7.44 169.34 6.18 15.82 0.42 % Variance 8.12 0.44 1.61 -1.81 11.46 0.19 Spatial statistical plots by domain are used to compare the mean model and drill grades data by relative elevation slices (Figure 14.9). Model estimates respond well to changes in the composite grade data, but local estimates are likely to be improved with additional drillhole intersections. Based upon the summary statistics, visual validations and graphical plots, the OK estimates are consistent with the drillhole composites, and are believed to constitute a reasonable representation of the Footwall mineralisation. P a g e | 86 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Figure 14.8 A plan view slice through the FW zone block model illustrating the good comparison between model estimates and the nearby drillhole data Figure 14.9 A statistical plot of estimates versus drillhole data grades for successive 30m increments in elevation and the full strike length of the FW zone mineralisation P a g e | 87 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 14.1.14. MINERAL RESOURCE CLASSIFICATION Classification of the Mineral Resource was primarily based on confidence in assayed grade, geological continuity, and the quality of the resulting kriged estimates. Geological confidence is supported by extensive open pit exposures and underground geological mapping and channel data, which in turn reinforces drillhole logging and domain volumes. Confidence in the kriged estimate is associated with drillhole coverage, analytical data integrity, kriging variance and efficiency and regression slope values. Specifically, kriging variances below 0.2, kriging efficiencies above 80% and regression slope values above 0.8 were considered appropriate for a Measured Mineral Resource category of classification. Whereas the use of mean domain density values is appropriate, subsequent models should make use of increased density data for more robust estimates. Regarding drillhole spacing, a Measured Mineral Resource category was considered appropriate with a 20 m separation between drill holes and drill line spacing between 25 m to 50 m. An Indicated Mineral Resource category was considered appropriate where there was a drill spacing of about 50 m to 75 m along drill lines and a line spacing of approximately 50 m. An Inferred Mineral Resource category was considered where there was a drill spacing of about 75 m to 100 m along drill lines and where the line spacing was around 100 m. The Measured Mineral Resources are located below the pit and where underground sampling and drilling is closely spaced. Indicated Resources extend as a consistent rim below the Measured Resources. Confidence in the estimates deteriorates rapidly into Inferred Resources with the increase in grid spacing and the short ranges of influence/grade continuity. Figure 14.10 3D view of the Dikulushi model, looking south, and showing resource classification categories P a g e | 88 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 The Mineral Resource has been classified and reported using the guidelines of the JORC Code (JORC, 2004), which in turnalign with the Standards on Mineral Resources and Reserves of the Canadian Institute of Mining, Metallurgy and Petroleum (CIM, 2000). 14.1.15. RESOURCE TABULATION AND INVENTORY The Mineral Resource at Dikulushi is derived from that portion of the block model which occurs below the current pit surface. Mineralisation appears to be open at depth, but is restricted to the west by the Kiaka carbonates and is observed to pinch out to the east. Resources were depleted for production and development from the underground mine, according to surveyed volumes. 112,000 tonnes of Mineral Resource was mined underground at an average of 8.5% copper. The Measured and Indicated Resources for Dikulushi (Table 14.7) total 0.77 million tonnes at 6.6% copper, and were determined above an economic cut-off grade of 1.0% copper. This is composed of: 0.52 million tonnes at 7.0% copper in the Measured Resource category 0.25 million tonnes at 5.6% copper in the Indicated Resource category. Table 14.7 Dikulushi Mineral Resource statement using a 1.0% copper cut-off grade as at August 2011 Category Measured Mineral Resources Indicated Mineral Resources Total Measured and Indicated Mineral Resources Category Inferred Mineral Resources Volume 3 (m *1,000) Density 3 (t/m ) Tonnes (*1,000) Copper (%) Silver (g/t) 184 90 2.8 2.8 516 251 7.0 5.6 211 114 274 2.8 767 6.6 179 Volume 3 (m *1,000) Density 3 (t/m ) Tonnes (*1,000) Copper (%) Silver (g/t) 136 2.8 380 6.8 91 14.2. MINERAL RESOURCE ESTIMATE COMPARISONS 14.2.1. MINERAL RESOURCE STATEMENT AUGUST 2011 VERSUS OCTOBER 2007 The August 2011 Mineral Resource estimates were compared to those of October 2007. These results (Table 14.8) reflect an overall tonnage decrease of 23%, together with a 7% increase in copper% and a 6% decrease in silver grade. Variance is against all resource categories: Measured, Indicated and Inferred. Notable category changes include a 124% increase in Measured Resource category tonnes and an 8% increase in Inferred Resource category tonnes, associated with the presence of additional data from underground exposures and from drilling. Most of these resources represent conversion from Indicated Resource material. There is a significant decrease in the Measured Resource copper % grades associated with extensional drilling within deeper, lower grade areas. In contrast the deeper infill and extensional drilling has supported an increase in the Inferred Resource copper grades. P a g e | 89 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 These comparisons were carried out using the 1.5% copper cut-off resource as the 2007 resources were only available at that cut-off grade. Table 14.8 Comparison of 2011 and 2007 Dikulushi Mineral Resource estimates Dikulushi Mineral Resource statement as at August 2011, using a 1.5% copper cut-off grade Category Volume 3 (m *1,000) Density 3 (t/m ) Tonnes (*1,000) Copper (%) Silver (g/t) Measured Indicated 176 86 2.80 2.80 493 241 7.32 5.79 219 118 Total Measured & Indicated 262 2.80 733 6.82 186 Inferred 129 2.80 361 7.11 94 Dikulushi Mineral Resource statement as at October 2007, using a 1.5% copper cut-off grade Category Volume 3 (m *1,000) Density 3 (t/m ) Tonnes (*1,000) Copper (%) Silver (g/t) Measured Indicated 78 307 2.83 2.83 220 869 9.63 6.50 289 155 Total Measured & Indicated 385 2.83 1,089 7.13 182 Inferred 119 2.83 336 4.30 112 Comparison by percentage variation between the August 2011 and October 2007 results. Category Volume 3 (m *1,000) Density 3 (t/m ) Tonnes (*1,000) Copper (%) -24% -11% Silver (g/t) Measured Indicated 126% -72% -1% -1% 124% -72% Total Measured & Indicated -32% -1% -33% -4% 2% 9% -1% 8% 65% -16% Inferred -24% -24% The 2011 Mineral Resource estimates have been guided by additional drillholes, underground sampling, density, geological and in-pit blasthole data available as of November 2008. The additional data has enabled an increase of some 21,000 copper tonnes from previous Indicated and Inferred Mineral Resources to be upgraded to a Measured category. Figure 14.11 illustrates the relative and cumulative change in copper tonnes between the 2007 to 2011 estimates. The 2011 Mineral Resource estimate has dropped by 14%, or a total of 13,000 tonnes of copper. Some of this is associated with mining depletion and significant changes to the volumes of mineralisation. Grade reductions for the Measured and Indicated categories are offset by increases in the Inferred category. P a g e | 90 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Figure 14.11 A waterfall chart of cumulative Mineral Resource changes from 2007 to 2011 14.2.2. DEPLETION OF AUGUST 2011 MINERAL RESOURCES BY AUGUST 2013 OPEN PIT CUT BACK The August 2011 Mineral Resource estimates were compared to those of August 2013, which features the depleted Mineral Resources after the mining of the open pit cut back. These results, as presented in Table 14.9 below, reflect an overall tonnage decrease of 37.3%, together with a 3.2% decrease in copper% and a 9.3% decrease in silver grade (corrected for a previous reporting error). The variance has been calculated for all resource categories, i.e., Measured, Indicated and Inferred. Notable category changes include a 60% decrease in Measured Resource tonnes, a 41% decrease in Indicated Resource tonnes, and a 3.9% decrease in the Inferred Resource category tonnes. All of these changes are wholly due to depletion as a result of mining of the open pit cut back, which was completed in July 2013. P a g e | 91 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Table 14.9 Comparison of August 2011 and August 2013 Dikulushi Mineral Resource estimates, showing the Open pit cut back depletion Dikulushi Mineral Resource statement as at August 2011, using a 1.0% copper cut-off grade* Category Volume 3 (m *1,000) Density 3 (t/m ) Tonnes (*1,000) Copper (%) Silver (g/t) Measured Indicated 184 90 2.80 2.80 516 251 7.0 5.6 211 114 Total Measured & Indicated 274 2.80 767 6.6 179 Inferred 136 2.80 380 6.8 91+ Dikulushi Mineral Resource statement as at August 2013, using a 1.0% copper cut-off + grade Category Measured Indicated Volume 3 (m *1,000) Density 3 (t/m ) Tonnes (*1,000) Copper (%) Silver (g/t) 74 53 2.80 2.80 207 148 5.4 6.6 163 131 Total Measured & Indicated 127 2.80 354 5.9 150 Inferred 130 2.80 365 7.0 160 Comparison by percentage variation between the August 2011 and August 2013 results. Category Volume 3 (m *1,000) Density 3 (t/m ) Tonnes (*1,000) Copper (%) Silver (g/t) Measured Indicated -51.1% -41.1% 0% 0% -59.9% -41.0% -22.7% +17.9% -22.7% +14.9% Total Measured & Indicated -53.7% 0% -53.9% -10.6% -16.2% -4.4% 0% -3.9% +2.9% +3.2* Inferred Note: + - The inferred silver grade was incorrectly reported at 91 g/t in the August 2011 Mineral Resource table and should have been 155 g/t. Note: * - This % has been corrected to show the “Real” comparison % based on the correction note above. Figure 14.12 is a waterfall chart which illustrates the relative and cumulative changes in Mineral Resource tonnes between the 2011 and the 2013 estimates. Figure 14.13 shows tonnage-grade and metal-grade curves for the depleted remaining Mineral Resource as at August 2013 as tabulated in Table 14.9. P a g e | 92 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Figure 14.12 A waterfall chart of cumulative Mineral Resource changes from 2011 to 2013 Figure 14.13 Grade tonnage curves for the combined remaining Measured and Indicated Mineral Resources Total Measured and Indicated tonnage and grade, remaining Dikulushi Mineral Resource 25.0 0.35 20.0 0.30 0.25 15.0 Cu% Resource tonnage and copper metal tonnage 0.40 0.20 10.0 0.15 0.10 5.0 0.05 0.00 0.0 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 Copper cut-off grade (Cu%) Resource tonnes (1,000,000) Cu tonnes (100,000) Cu % P a g e | 93 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 14.3. KAZUMBULA MINERAL RESOURCE ESTIMATE The Kazumbula Mineral Resource estimates were prepared in November 2010 by Optiro in conjunction with MWL geological staff, who worked on the Kazumbula Mineral Resources between March 2009 and December 2010. The content of this technical report is guided by the reporting requirements of the Canadian National Instrument 43-101 ‘Standards of Disclosure for Mineral Projects’ and the JORC Code. The Kazumbula deposit is located some 15 km north-northeast of the Dikulushi plant and has good drillhole coverage from both Anvil and Mawson West. The Kazumbula deposit is relatively small when compared to Dikulushi, and has a strike length of approximately 200 m. RC and diamond drilling define the Kazumbula deposit with a grid spacing of approximately 20 m to 25 m. Only the MWL drilling data have been used for estimating the Kazumbula Mineral Resource due to reliability issues with other drill campaigns. 14.3.1. GEOLOGICAL AND MINERALISATION MODELS The Kazumbula mineralised volume (Figure 14.14) was delineated on vertical sections per drill line. A 0.5% copper cut-off was used as a guideline for defining the mineralised volume. The delineated string envelopes per section were linked with wireframe surfaces to define the mineralised volume of the Kazumbula ore body. The Kazumbula mineralisation exhibits good downhole and betweenhole continuity. Mineralisation was also guided by the position of the interpreted fault surface. The boundary between oxidised and sulphide mineralisation was modelled according to the logged geology, oxidation and mineralogy; however, due to the relatively small size of the Kazumbula orebody and the limited number of intersections within the oxide and sulphide domains, it was not deemed appropriate to subdivide the mineralised domain. P a g e | 94 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Figure 14.14 Kazumbula vertical section, looking north, highlighting the modelled mineralisation as per the RC and diamond drilling 14.3.2. DRILL DATA FOR MINERAL RESOURCE MODELLING The deposit was drilled by Anvil during 2008, but MWL was not able to completely validate these drillhole data (i.e. logging, sampling, assay, drillhole collars and downhole surveys), and as a result the Anvil data were not used in this resource estimate. The Anvil drilling data has, however, assisted MWL with drillhole planning and targeting of the Kazumbula deposit. MWL drilled RC and diamond holes (Table 14.10) to define the near surface copper mineralisation during August and September 2010. The drillhole spacing was approximately 15 m on drill lines spaced 20 m apart (Figure 14.15). Drillholes were drilled at approximately 60 degrees to the south-southeast to optimise the angle of intersection with the orebody. No twin holes were completed for this programme, but significant mineralised intersections are comparable with those completed by Anvil. P a g e | 95 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Table 14.10 MWL drilling at Kazumbula Prospect Kazumbula Kazumbula Type RC DDH/tail No Holes 17 10 Metres 1676 674.4 Samples 1676 674 The RC drilling was completed by Titan Drilling of Lubumbashi, utilising a truck mounted RC rig. A supervising geologist was on site at all times during the drilling and industry standard procedures were followed during the RC drilling programme. The diamond drilling was contracted and completed by Chantete Emerald, who completed six diamond holes (HQ3) from surface and four diamond tails from RC pre-collars (HQ3). Figure 14.15 Plan showing the distribution of RC and diamond drillholes across the Kazumbula deposit. 14.3.3. DATA VALIDATION Drillhole collar coordinates were surveyed by the qualified Dikulushi mine surveyor. Collars were verified against the topography. Visual inspection of the downhole survey measurements was completed in order to identify any anomalously different bearings and dips. Micromine software was used to validate the drillhole logging and sampling data for any gaps or overlaps, with only minor errors identified. These errors were associated with typing and were corrected immediately in the MWL database. P a g e | 96 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 14.3.4. DATA PREPARATION FOR MODELLING The de-surveyed 3D assay drillhole file was composited to two metre lengths. As discussed, a single mineralised domain was used to model the Kazumbula orebody. As a result, the two metre composites were deemed appropriate for defining the extents of mineralisation and reduced some of the variability associated with the one metre samples. 14.3.5. STATISTICS Statistical analyses of the two metre sample data, including spatial statistics, were carried out using Supervisor software. The summary results are tabulated in Table 14.11. Statistics for copper and silver grade data were investigated with histograms and probability plots (Figure 14.16). The statistics highlight only minor internal variability and domain mixing, thereby assisting with spatial analysis and supporting a reasonable estimate. Table 14.11 Summary statistics of the two metre composite data for Cu% and Ag g/t for the Kazumbula deposit Cu (%) 14.3.6. Ag (g/t) Samples Min Max Mean Std Dev CV Variance Skewness Log variance Geometric mean 137 0.03 8.41 2.00 1.59 0.79 2.53 1.53 0.83 1.44 137 2.50 142.00 22.48 27.20 1.21 739.86 2.09 1.42 11.56 Log mean 137 137 SPATIAL STATISTICS For the copper and silver variography, no definitive anisotropy was evident from spatial analysis. A standardised nugget value of 0.37 was clearly defined from the downhole variography (Figure 14.17). Variography was oriented according to the plane of the fault and mineralisation, which dips at 75 degrees towards 340. An isotropic variogram model (Figure 14.17) in this plane of mineralisation was used to define the horizontal continuity of 60 m for copper and silver grades. The true width variogram range was set to 20 m. 14.3.7. BLOCK MODEL The block model dimensions were guided by the mineralised wireframe shape, orientation and volume, together with the drill grid spacing. Sub-blocks were used to ensure that the block model honoured the wireframe volume. The block model volume was within 1% of the mineralised wireframe volume. The individual parent block dimensions were 15 mE by 10 mN by 2 mRL, with sub-blocking allowed down to 5, 4 and 1 m respectively. Block estimates were controlled by the original parent block dimension. P a g e | 97 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Figure 14.16 Histogram and probability plots for the Kazumbula deposit two metre sample data. P a g e | 98 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Figure 14.17 Variogram modelling for Cu % in the plane of mineralisation. 14.3.8. DENSITY ESTIMATES IN THE BLOCK MODEL Diamond core samples were prepared by ‘squaring off’ the ends of approximately 10 cm to 20 cm billets of half core. A total of 118 bulk density (BD) measurements were made of dried half core. The same piece of core was then measured in water on a suspension cage below the same electronic scale. The conventional formula for BD was then applied, viz. BD = Dry Sample Weight / (Dry Sample Weight – Wet Sample Weight) The average BD measurements and statistics for Kazumbula for mineralised and un-mineralised core are shown in Table 14.12. The lower density for the mineralised oxide samples is explained by the lack of hematite alteration in the mineralised samples, being replaced by an illite clay assemblage and lowering the overall density of the rock. Table 14.12 Density estimates for the Kazumbula deposit Type Mineralised Oxide Unmineralised Oxide Mineralised Sulphide Unmineralised Sulphide 14.3.9. SG 2.41 2.47 2.65 2.61 GRADE ESTIMATION Grades for copper and silver were estimated into the parent blocks of an empty block model using ordinary kriging (OK). OK is believed to be an appropriate estimation method due to the pseudonormal data distributions of the mineralisation. Estimation into parent blocks uses a discretisation of 6 (X points) by 6 (Y points) by 2 (Z points) to better represent estimated block volumes, in addition to applying an octant sample selection strategy of four sectors and a minimum of 4 samples and maximum of 20 samples per sector. P a g e | 99 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 14.3.10. MODEL VALIDATION The model was validated by visual techniques. Block estimates, while smoothed, do reflect the average higher and lower grades of the drillhole samples. In addition, the model was also validated with an inverse distance to the power of two estimate (ID2), using the same sample selection parameters and search parameters. The mean grade estimate compared to the mean drillhole value and the mean ID2 estimate are all close to within 10% of each other. The declustered mean of the drillhole data has a value of 1.8% copper (Table 14.13). Table 14.13 A table of mean statistics comparing model estimates with data values Field Copper % Data 2.0 2 ID 2.0 Declustered data 1.8 OK estimate 1.8 From the summary statistics and visual validations, the OK estimates are consistent with the drillhole composites, and while smoothed, are believed to constitute a reasonable representation of the Kazumbula grade. 14.3.11. MINERAL RESOURCE CLASSIFICATION Classification of the Kazumbula Mineral Resource was based on quality of sample assays, grid spacing, the assigned density and the resulting kriged estimates. The Kazumbula deposit has been classified in its entirety as an Indicated Mineral Resource. The mineralised volume is adequately supported by a regular 20 m grid of drillhole intercepts and has been defined using an effective 0.5% copper cut-off. The Mineral Resource has been classified and reported using the guidelines of the JORC Code (JORC, 2004), which in turn comply with the Standards on Mineral Resources and Reserves of the Canadian Institute of Mining, Metallurgy and Petroleum (CIM, 2005). A resource summary is given in Table 14.14. Table 14.14 Kazumbula Mineral Resource statement as at November 2010. Category Indicated Oxide Mineral Resources Indicated Sulphide Mineral Resources Total Indicated Mineral Resources Volume 3 (m *1,000) 66 60 126 Density 3 (t/m ) 2.41 2.65 2.52 Tonnes (*1,000) 159 160 318 Copper (%) 1.75 1.89 1.82 Silver (g/t) 14.7 22.9 18.8 P a g e | 100 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 15. MINERAL RESERVE ESTIMATES 15.1. DEPLETION OF THE OPEN PIT RESERVES The open pit Mineral Reserves have been depleted with the mining of the Dikulushi open pit cut back, which commenced in August 2011 and was completed during July 2013. Processing of the stockpiled cut back ore is continuing, and it is estimated that this ore will be processed by midDecember 2013. Table 15.1 shows the Dikulushi Mineral Reserves statement as at August 2011. Table 15.1 Dikulushi Mineral Reserve statement as at August 2011, using a 1.0% copper cut-off grade Category Volume 3 (m *1,000) Density 3 (t/m ) Tonnes (*1,000) Copper (%) Silver (g/t) Proven Probable 66.6 127.8 2.8 2.8 184.7 354.3 7.27% 5.51% 207 169 Total Proven and Probable Reserves 194.4 2.8 539.0 6.12% 182 The Open Pit Mineral Reserve estimate was based on the Open Pit reaching the 810 mRL. Mining ceased at the 825 mRL due to safety concerns, with some isolated sections of the pit wall deteriorating beyond what was predicted. Table 15.2 shows the depleted Mineral Reserves post the cessation of mining of the open pit cut back. Table 15.2 Depleted Dikulushi Mineral Reserve statement as at August 2013, using a 1.0% copper cut-off grade Category Volume 3 (m *1,000) Density 3 (t/m ) Tonnes (*1,000) Copper (%) Silver (g/t) Proven Probable 1.0 29.9 2.8 2.8 2.7 83.7 6.8 5.5 186 188 Total Proven and Probable Reserves 30.9 2.8 86.4 5.5 188 The above remaining Mineral Reserves have been incorporated into the Underground Mineral Reserves, which are now presented in the following sections and discussions below. 15.2. UNDERGROUND MINE DESIGN AND SCHEDULE BASIS 15.2.1. EXISTING WORKINGS Mine design for the Dikulushi underground mining operations has utilised the existing decline level development completed by Anvil, which was completed prior to abandoning the underground. The mining operations consisted of a decline and level development down to the 750 mRL. The capital and development design criteria now used by MWL for the underground Mineral Reserve estimation are the same as the original underground workings completed by Anvil, with the following design cross-sectional areas: decline and decline stockpiles; 5.5 m high by 5.5 m wide arched profile level access / level stockpiles; 5.0 m high by 5.0 m wide arched profile P a g e | 101 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 return airway level drives; 5.0 m high by 5.5 m wide arched profile cut and fill ramp access; 5.0 m high by 4.5 m wide square profile ore drives / cut and fill; 5.0 m high by 4.5 m wide square profile return airway rise; 5.0 m diameter. Prior to the abandonment of the underground mining operations, Anvil completed stoping activities in the upper levels of the mining operations between the 910 mRL and 850 mRL. The stopes were mined using long-hole stoping. The success of stopes was limited due to ore dilution from the surrounding waste material located around the hanging wall. Handheld stoping was also trialled in the latter stages in some selected stopes, with better success. Figure 15.1 shows the open pit cut-back and the original underground workings, as developed previously by Anvil, which will now be utilised by MWL to form the basis of the underground Mineral Reserve development and production. Additional development will be undertaken to access the undeveloped Mineral Reserves. Figure 15.1 Existing workings, showing as built underground development (grey), and the as-built pit (green) P a g e | 102 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 15.2.2. BASIS OF THE UNDERGROUND DESIGN AND SCHEDULE The Mining schedule and designs focussed on the Measured and Indicated Mineral Resources, and were used in the development of the Mineral Reserves. No Inferred Mineral Resource Material was used in the schedule or for economic evaluation of the Mineral Reserves. Figure 15.2 Underground reserve, showing as-built underground development (grey), as-built pit (green), and measured (purple) and indicated (red) Mineral Resources and additionally shows the relationship between the current development (as built), and the Measured and Indicated Mineral Resources. Figure 15.2 Underground reserve, showing as-built underground development (grey), as-built pit (green), and measured (purple) and indicated (red) Mineral Resources 15.3. CUT-OFF GRADE CRITERIA Cut-off grade evaluation for the deposit has been completed using a Net Smelter Return (NSR) calculation method due to the polymetallic nature of the deposit, as both the silver and copper metals provide significant value to the final revenue of the mine. The first part of the calculation process was to identify the NSR of one tonne of material with an average grade of 5.38% copper and 128 g/t silver using Equation 15.1. The average grades for the copper (x1) and silver (x2) were taken from the Mineral Reserve schedule. Equation 15.1 Polymetallic NSR using average metal grades ( ) ( ) ( ( ) ( ) P a g e | 103 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 x1 - is the average copper grade expressed as a percentage x2 - is the silver grade expressed as a percentage r1 - is the percentage of copper recovered when producing the concentrate r2 - is the percentage of silver recovered when producing the concentrate p1 - is the copper concentrate percentage received after smelting charges p2 - is the copper concentrate percentage received after smelting charges V1 - is the market value of copper per tonne V2 - is the market value of silver per tonne R1 - is the refining cost of the copper per tonne of copper produced R2 - is the refining cost of the silver per tonne of silver produced Cs - is the smelting and refining cost per tonne of copper concentrate Ct - is the smelting and refining cost per tonne of copper concentrate K - is the number of ore tonnes required to be mined to produce one tonne of copper concentrate. The values used in the calculation were derived from both the mining schedule created for the Mineral Reserves Schedule and MWL’s financial model. The K value used was calculated using the tonnes and grade from the mining schedule. From the application of Equation 15.1 a NSR value of one tonne of ore averaging 5.38% copper and 0.0128% silver was calculated. The NSR value of one tonne using the average copper and silver grades from the schedule was $329. To allow the calculation of the NSR cut-off value for one tonne of rock with variable copper and silver grades, Equation 15.2 has been derived from Equation 15.1. This equation provides a mathematical relationship that allows the calculation of one variable component, if the other two variable components are known, providing a breakeven revenue position. For example, if the copper grade and an NSR cut-off value are known for a tonne of material, the silver content can then be calculated. This allows the metal content of each tonne mined to be economically evaluated with the aim of determining whether the material should go to the waste dump or be sent to the mill for processing. Equation 15.2 Variable grade NSR equation A stoping (cut-off) value for the underground mining operations was determined using Equation 15.3. The stope cut-off value relates to the drive/drift development used to extract ore from the level development. Equation 15.3 NSRc stope Stope cut-off equation ( ) - is the copper processing cost per tonne of ore mined and milled - is the incremental silver processing cost per tonne of mined and milled - is the waste processing cost per tonne mined - is the ore mining cost per ore tonne mined P a g e | 104 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 The mining costs used in the evaluation of the were taken from the mining schedule prepared for the Mineral Reserves, with the processing costs from MW’s financial model. As the processing cost provided did not differentiate between the individual metals contained, the variable for incremental cost of silver processing was set to $0 per ore tonne. When applying the mining and processing costs, a NSRc Stope value of $143.44 per tonne is required to determine whether the material should be mined or not. The development cut-off was calculated using the Equation 15.4. The NSR value from this calculation is used to determine whether material that must be mined from the underground operation should be sent to the mill or waste dump. This calculation determines the NSR value based on the difference between the mining and processing cost of ore and waste. Equation 15.4 – NSRc dev Development Cut-off equation ( ) ( ) ( ) - is the overhead costs associated with the mining and processing 1 tonne of ore - is the overhead costs associated with the mining and processing of 1 tonne of waste - is the waste mining cost per waste tonne mined When applying Equation 15.4, a value of $71.38 per tonne is required to determine if a tonne of material that has to be mined should be processed or not. Due to the polymetallic nature of the orebody, the cut-off grades are variable. Figure 15.3 shows a relationship between the metal grades and the NSR cut-off for both the development and stope cutoffs. Each of the lines shown on the graph has been calculated using the variable grade NSR Equation 15.2, with the NSR value in the equation substituted with either the NSRc Stope or . The silver content in g/t was then calculated for a variety of copper grades to produce the graph lines. P a g e | 105 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Figure 15.3 Relationship between cut-off NSR and metal grades 15.4. MINING RECOVERY AND DILUTION Mining ore loss has been estimated at 5%. Ore loss is estimated to occur as a result of small gaps left in the backfill process, caused by the inability to properly level off the top of backfill. This means that when using the backfill as the floor for the next level, the fill will generally have a rounded profile, and this will result in some material being lost in these corners as the next level is developed. There will also be a small amount of ore loss resulting from general activities, such as rehandle and material movement. Mining dilution for the project has been estimated at 8%. This has been calculated by allowing a 200mm dilution skin on the walls of development drives, which has then been used to determine the percentage dilution using the cross-sectional area of the drives. The figures use the average dimensions for development drives, and also assume a square cross-section for calculation purposes. Table 15.3 outlines the specific numbers for each development type. Table 15.3 Mining dilution table Development Width (m) Height (m) Drive Area (m2) Dilution width (m) Dilution skin area (m2) Dilution (%) 4.50 5.00 22.50 0.20 2.00 8.9 5.50 5.50 5.00 5.00 5.00 4.50 5.50 5.50 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 30.25 30.25 25.00 25.00 25.00 22.50 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 2.20 2.20 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 7.3 7.3 8.0 8.0 8.0 8.9 Ore Ore Drive Waste Decline Decline Stockpile Level Access Level Stockpile Return Airway Drive Cut and Fill Ramp P a g e | 106 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Average 5.08 5.17 0.20 26.26 2.07 7.9 15.5. UNDERGROUND MINERAL RESERVE TABULATION A financial model has been developed and analysis indicates that a positive return is expected. There are several areas where it is considered by Optiro that conservative estimates of mining costs have been made. It should be noted that the waste dilution rate of the ore is considered to be conservative for this type of operation, mining style and deposit. The resulting Mineral Reserves for the underground mine are only based upon Measured and Indicated Mineral Resources from the depleted Mineral Resources post mining of the open pit cut back. The Mineral Resources have been classified as Indicated due to the risks associated with underground mining of this deposit. The resulting Mineral Reserves are supported by historical production and current processing data and are tabulated in Table 15.4, using a cut-off grade based on an NSR value of US$329/t, at a copper price of US$3.08/lb and a Silver price of US$20 per oz. All stated Mineral Resources are inclusive of Mineral Reserves. The Mineral Reserve, as per the CIM definition, incorporates mining losses and diluting materials brought about by the mining operation. Table 15.4 Dikulushi Mineral Reserve statement as at September 2013 Category Volume 3 (m *1,000) Density 3 (t/m ) Tonnes (*1,000) Copper (%) Silver (g/t) Proven Probable 0 62 0 2.8 0 173 0 5.2 0 127 Total Proven and Probable Reserves 62 2.8 173 5.2 127 Note: 1) Cut-off grade is based on a NSR value of US$329/t, at a copper price of US$3.08/lb and a Silver price of US$20 per oz. 2) The above ore reserve does not include any Inferred category Mineral Resource material P a g e | 107 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 16. MINING METHODS 16.1. HISTORICAL MINING Anvil commenced Underground Mining operations at the Dikulushi deposit in 2006 and continued through until 2008, when falling copper prices and challenging mining conditions led to the underground operations being abandoned. During the period of underground mining, mine development was completed from the surface down to the 750 mRL, with extensive level development completed from the 790 RL to the surface. Longhole open stoping activities were also completed between the 900 and 850 mRL’s at the eastern end of the deposit. MWL acquired the Dikulushi mining operations through its purchase of Anvil’s subsidiary AMC in 2010, and recommenced the open pit mining operations through the implementation of a cut back of the original pit. The cut back was designed to reach the 805 mRL, and in doing so, would mine out parts of the “old” underground workings that had been previously developed by Anvil. Mining of the cut back commenced in late 2011 and continued through to July 2013, when mining was stopped at the 825 mRL. This was 20 m short of the cut back design depth, due to safety concerns with some isolated sections of the pit wall deteriorating beyond what was predicted. 16.2. PROPOSED MINING METHOD – CUT AND FILL The planned mining method to be used at the Dikulushi underground operations is cut and fill, using a combination of overhand and underhand variants. Initial ore production will be mined from the 800 mRL down to 755 mRL. Sections of the ore body between these two levels have good and poor rock mass characteristics and contain the bulk of the Measured and Inferred material contained within the Mineral Resource. Due to the variability of the rock mass in the zone, the backfilling of drives will be completed using one of three backfill methods Cemented rock fill (CRF), Cemented aggregate fill (CAF) Un-cemented rock fill (RF). Use of the different backfill types as planned in the mining schedule has been determined by the mining sequence and related mining activities that will be conducted after the fill has been placed. 16.2.1. OVERHAND CUT AND FILL Overhand cut and fill is a variant of cut and fill which moves from the bottom of the orebody upwards, using the fill from previous levels as the floor for the next level. Levels accessed are excavated from the decline through to the orebody, perpendicular to the strike of the orebody. From these accesses, ore drives are mined out along the strike of the orebody (shown in Figure 16.1), and once a level is fully extracted it is backfilled with CRF. Once the cement is cured, mining recommences directly on top of the backfilled level, using the backfill as the floor for the next ore drive. Overhand is the more productive of the two cut and fill variants suggested, and can be used where the ore (which forms the backs of the mining levels) is competent enough to work under P a g e | 108 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 safely. Overhand cut and fill is also initially more capital-intensive than underhand, as it requires development to the bottom of the ore block before commencing mining in an upwards direction. Figure 16.1 Overhand cut and fill mining process 16.2.2. UNDERHAND CUT AND FILL Underhand cut and fill mining works in a similar way to the overhand variety; however, mining advances downwards underneath previously mined and backfilled levels, with backfill forming the backs of each successive level. This is done by driving an access from the footwall of the deposit through to the orebody. In the narrow sections of the orebody stoping is done by developing a single strike drive to extract the ore on the level. The strike drives are developed and designed to minimise openings created for the extraction of ore, with the openings kept as small as possible thus minimising the amount of waste dilution taken with the ore being extracted. Once the orebody on the level has been fully extracted using the drive, cemented fill (CAF) is then used to fill up the void created by mining. After the backfill has been given sufficient time to cure and obtain the appropriate strength requirements, the next level is then developed directly below the level above with the cemented backfill forming the backs (roof) of the stoping drives developed below. Figure 16.2 shows the development sequence of this mining method in a horizontal long section view. Underhand cut and fill is the less productive and a higher cost method; however, it has the advantage of being able to control the condition of the backs. This means that it is suitable for any areas where the ore is not competent enough for the overhand method, or anywhere where there is a high propensity for rockbursts. P a g e | 109 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Figure 16.2 Underhand cut and fill mining process The primary mining method that has been selected and scheduled is the overhand cut and fill method, which accounts for 70% of the ore extraction. The underhand mining method is primarily used where the ore is extracted around previously developed levels and accounts for approximately 20% of the ore. The remaining 10% of the ore is extracted by Longhole stoping methods, which are confined to stope areas within the crown pillar below the pit floor. 16.2.3. MINING OF WIDER SECTIONS OF THE OREBODY In the sections of the orebody where the mineralisation exceeds the drive development width (4.5m), multiple drives will be developed to extract the ore in these zones. The development sequence of all drives will involve developing the initial drive along the hanging wall contact to the end of the orebody. This drive will then be filled with either CRF or CAF. Once the fill has been allowed to cure in the hanging wall drive, a second drive in the footwall will developed. Once the footwall drive development has been completed, CRF or CAF will be used to backfill the drive. Additional drives will then be developed to extract the remaining parts of the orebody between the hanging wall and footwall contact drives. This process should allow for complete extraction of the orebody where it exceeds the maximum drive width specified under the geotechnical requirements (4.5 m). Figure 16.3 is an example of the extraction sequence for sections where the orebody width exceeds the maximum stoping drive width. P a g e | 110 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Figure 16.3 Diagrammatic representation of sequential mining in wide orebody areas 5 3 5 15m 2 4 1 3 6 7 8m 1 Plan view The current design work produced for the underground has access of the decline to the orebody at 20 m vertical spacing. Each of the level take-off points from the decline will provide access to four stoping levels, with the levels developed from top to bottom (Figure 16.4 shows the access development of the stoping levels from the decline). The bottom stoping drives from each level access will sit directly above the top stoping drive from the decline access, 20 m below. P a g e | 111 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Figure 16.4 Orebody access development As the mining sequence will require multiple levels to be mined in the same period to provide ore feed to the processing plant, controls will need to be in place to maintain a minimum horizontal distance between mining levels. The vertical spacing between all drives should be a small proportion of the maximum void space created from the level above, in order to maintain a 1 to 1 void to pillar ratio (Figure 16.5) between active mining levels. This has been employed to minimise the risk of rock mass failure between the mining levels. Figure 16.5 Pillar ratio diagram 16.2.4. PROPOSED MINING METHOD – EXTRACTION OF THE CROWN PILLAR Extraction of the crown pillar from the 815 mRL to the base of the pit at the 825 mRL is to be extracted using a longhole stoping method. The extraction of ore via this method will involve mining through back filled sections of the 810 mRL to create a drive for the drilling of the ore from underground, with the blasted ore transported to the mill via the underground decline. Extraction and transportation of the ore via the open pit workings was not considered due to the possible undercutting of the existing pit walls. Removal of the crown pillar, as set out in the schedule, is undertaken at the end of the underground mine’s operational life as it stands. The reason for this is to minimise the risk of water inrushes into the underground and the potential destabilising of the open pit walls. MWL plans to continue P a g e | 112 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 underground exploration drilling of the orebody, and will review the success of those programs prior to undertaking to remove the crown pillar. 16.3. GEOTECHNICAL DESIGN PARAMETERS 16.3.1. STOPE LAYOUT AND SEQUENCE The mining sequence and layout developed for the mineral reserves schedule has been created in consultation with both Mike Turner from Turner Mining and Geotechnical Pty Ltd and John Keogh from Peter O’Bryan & Associates. For the purpose of the stope layout and designs, drives have been limited to 4.5 m wide by 5 m high in the ore body. This is due poor ground conditions experienced when mining was originally conducted. 16.3.2. DRILL AND BLAST Rock breakage for the development of the underground mining operations will be conducted using drill and blast. There are currently three development drills (Jumbos) located at the Dikulushi operations from previous mining activities. These three jumbos will be used to complete all drilling activities for horizontal mine development and stoping within the mining operations for ore and waste. The three jumbos on site include two twin boom jumbos and one single boom jumbo, with all three rigs able to drill holes using a 3.7 m steel. For the purposes of scheduling the underground mining operations it was decided that each jumbo would be able to take a mining cut to a depth of 3.3 m. Blasting of the rock will be done primarily using ANFO as the main explosive. In development cuts, reduced charging will be used in the perimeter holes of each cut to minimise the impact of the explosives on the drive walls and backs. On completion of drill and blast activities, the installation of weld mesh and steel bolts or split sets will be used to provide ground control for the drive walls and backs. Ground support work will be predominantly done using the single boom jumbo, with the twin boom jumbos bolting and meshing as required. 16.3.3. ORE EXTRACTION Extraction of the ore and waste material after blasting will be completed using standard underground loading and hauling practices. Ore material will be removed from the face of the drive by an LHD (load –haul-dump unit) to stockpiles located on the level. The ore is then loaded onto haul trucks and transported to the mill processing area on the surface. Waste material will be removed from the underground workings in the same manner as the ore. The waste material used for the production of CAF or CRF will be transported to surface where it will be screened or crushed to provide the appropriately sized material for each of the filler types. Where RF is to be used in the underground workings, this material will be transported to stockpiles in strategic locations underground for use as backfill on levels where ore mining has been completed. P a g e | 113 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 16.3.4. BACKFILLING Cut and fill mining methods rely heavily on the use of backfill, with the mining process using backfill material to provide stable material for either the floor (overhand cut and fill) or the backs (underhand cut and fill) or walls for the extraction of adjacent stoping drives. Backfilling operations for the Dikulushi underground will use three different types of back fill for the safe extraction of the orebody. ROCK FILL (RF) The use of RF within the mining schedule has occurred where all of the mining activities beside or below the location backfill have ceased, and the RF is used to provide the floor for extraction of the level directly above. This fill method is used extensively in certain sections of the orebody where a single drive is required to extract the ore from the level, and mining activities below the drive have been completed. Some levels use a combination of CRF and RF. RF is significantly cheaper than both the CRF and CAF backfilling methods, as no secondary screening or crushing is required and the RF can be directly hauled between locations with material dumped in a stockpile close to the backfill location. RF DESIGN AND PLACEMENT Placement of the RF will be done using underground LHD units, with the rock placed in the each of the drives working from the furthest end of the drive back towards the access. In addition to moving the RF to the fill location the LHD unit can be used to push up and pack in the RF (commonly by using a ‘rammer-jammer’ attachment on the bucket, as shown in Figure 16.6. Figure 16.6 LHD loader with ‘rammer-jammer attachment CEMENTED ROCK FILL (CRF) Selection of CRF as the primary method for backfilling stopes was done on the basis that materials required for the process were easily available, with waste development providing the rock fill and cement being easily imported to site with minimal technical or specialised gear required to produce the fill. The process for creating CRF involves the mixing of cement, water and rock from waste headings using a LHD unit in a stockpile located close to the area to be backfilled. P a g e | 114 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Once each of the ingredients has been mixed the LHD unit then transports the mix from the stockpile and deposits it in the area being backfilled in a layered approach. A half to one meter layer of CRF material is deposited onto the floor of the drive. The LHD unit then mixes more CRF, which is deposited on top of the initial layer. As the LHD unit deposits the next layer of CRF it compacts the layer below, helping to improve the strength of the CRF by removing any voids. To maximise the fill in the drive and minimise any voids between levels, the CRF in the upper sections of drive should be pushed up and packed in with the loader (commonly by using a ‘rammerjammer’ attachment on the bucket, Figure 16.6). To ensure there is sufficient supply of rock material, additional waste will be sourced from the open pit stockpiles. On completion of open pit mining operations, material in the pit was blasted, but not removed; this has been identified as an alternate source of rock fill, should the ground waste development not provide the volumes required to achieve the underground mining production. CRF DESIGN AND PLACEMENT CRF has been designed conservatively at a minimum of 10% cement, and rock fragments of 300 mm diameter or less. A water to cement ratio is designed at 0.45, i.e. for a mix of 1 tonne cement and 9 tonnes rock (10 tonnes total), 450 litres of water is required (Table 16.1). Table 16.1 CRF Specifications CRF Specifications Cement content Rock fragments Water:Cement ratio Curing time until full strength is obtained ≥10% ≤ 300mm 0.45 28 days The floor is to be covered in steel mesh, to be anchored into the sidewalls using resin encapsulated rebar bolts (post-tensioned) at a spacing of 1.2 – 1.5 m and where mesh sheets overlap. The mesh sheets are also to be shackled together along the overlaps. The minimum curing time of the CRF prior to the development of adjacent development has been set at 2 days within the schedule. This has been deemed as a significant time for the CRF to obtain ample strength to allow mining activities to occur alongside them. CEMENTED AGGREGATE FILL (CAF) Cemented Aggregate Fill (CAF) is similar to CRF in design; however, the rock has been sized (and can include sand) so as to achieve maximum strength. CAF is more expensive to produce than CRF due to the additional requirement of crushing and screening the rock prior to use (as CAF) as backfill. It is intended that CAF will be used on any levels that will subsequently form the backs for a level directly below. CAF DESIGN AND PLACEMENT CAF has been designed conservatively at a minimum of 10% cement and rock fragments of 25 mm diameter or less. The water to cement ratio is designed at 0.45, i.e. the CRF can be mixed at the P a g e | 115 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 surface using AGI trucks or by LHD using a mix of 1 tonne cement and 9 tonnes rock (10 tonnes total), 450 litres of water is required (Table 16.2). Table 16.2 CAF Specifications CRF Specifications Cement content Rock fragments Water : cement ratio Curing time until full strength is obtained ≥10% ≤ 25mm 0.45 28 days The floor is to be covered in steel mesh, to be anchored into the sidewalls using resin encapsulated rebar bolts (post-tensioned) at a spacing of 1.2 – 1.5 m and where mesh sheets overlap. The mesh sheets are also to be shackled together along the overlaps. The minimum curing time of the CRF prior to the development of adjacent development has been set at 2 days within the schedule. This is being deemed as significant time for the CRF to obtain ample strength to allow mining activities to occur alongside them. CEMENTED PASTE FILL Testwork is being conducted by MWL to identify whether the tails material produced from the production of the copper concentrate is suitable for use as paste backfill in the underground operations. Initial results of the testwork have indicated that there is a high likelihood of this material being suitable for backfilling operations. Should the testwork prove successful paste fill could be used as an alternative to either CRF or CAF. The advantage of paste fill is its ability to provide a better filling ratio in the backfilled drives, with minimal void space remaining after the completion of the backfilling process. The use of paste fill is highly unlikely in the current reserve mining plan due to the short mine life based on the Measured and Indicated Reserves. Should Inferred material within the geological reserve model be able to be upgraded to higher confidence categories, paste fill would provide a viable option for future mining activities. 16.3.5. ACCESSING THE OREBODY & REHABILITATION OF OLD WORKINGS Initial access to the ore body will be provided by the existing workings left behind by Anvil. This development includes extensive level development on the 810, 790 and 770 mRLs. The decline has been developed down to the 750 mRL and includes the initial take-off drive development for level access. Development of the decline below the 750 mRL will be completed using twin boom underground development drills, with ground support implemented as per the geotechnical recommendations from Mike Turner’s report ‘Geotechnical Input for re-opening Dikulushi Underground’, August 2013. Dewatering activities have made it easy to access the main decline. Prior to closure of the underground mine in 2008, M. Turner (Geotechnical Consultant) undertook a detailed inspection of the underground working areas. He highlighted a number of areas which required remedial support, and the need for ongoing inspections for mining activities to proceed. In late 2010, MWL asked Australian Mining Consultants (AMC) to undertake a geotechnical assessment of underground P a g e | 116 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 mining options proposed by the previous owners Anvil. As part of this work AMC provided the following comment: “Rehabilitation requirements below 900mRL are unknown, but for budgeting purposes, it should be assumed that all of the (ground) support will require replacement.” In December 2012 an inspection was performed by M. Turner to assess the decline down to the groundwater level (830 mRL). This concluded that the rock mass and support in the decline was in good condition, limiting the number of areas requiring support rehabilitation. Some areas would require bleeding of scats from behind damaged and sub-standard mesh, but most areas could be made safe by installing additional sheets of mesh over the existing support. Additionally, it was observed that some areas below 900 mRL had corroded mesh. After testing the mesh strength, MWL was satisfied that this would still perform as required. As dewatering proceeds, ongoing mesh testing is planned. As open pit mining has proceeded, the previously mined crosscuts and ore drives have been intersected. The installed ground support, which includes galvanised Split Set bolds and mesh, is exposed on the pit floor. This has allowed close inspection of installed support, and very little corrosion was consequently noted. This has been consistent when mining down through the various ore drives. Again, this lends weight to the premise that there has been only minor deterioration of the installed ground support. 16.4. VENTILATION 16.4.1. PRIMARY VENTILATION A series of primary ventilation rises will be developed in conjunction with the main decline. These rises will be mined using hand-held mining equipment, with a rise driven between the return air drives at a 1.5 m width and then stripped out from the top down to a diameter of 5 m. The rises will be connected to the decline through a series of small return airway drives strategically positioned at 20 vertical metre intervals. Ventilation of the decline between return airway levels will be provided through secondary fans in the development phase. A new section of the primary ventilation system will be developed, and ventilation bulkheads will be used to seal off the return airway drives located above the lowest return airway drive. This process will then provide primary ventilation to the bottom of the decline, allowing for further development. Figure 16.7 shows the proposed underground primary ventilation circuit down to the 520 mRL created by Red Rock Engineering. Figure 16.8 shows the ventilation development required for mining the existing Measured and Indicated material in the Mineral Reserve. P a g e | 117 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Figure 16.7 Underground primary ventilation circuit (full) Primary Ventilation Return Air Rises Figure 16.8 Underground primary ventilation circuit required for the extraction of the measured and indicated material only Primary Ventilation Return Air Rises The ventilation system sets up the return airways from each of the levels up to the 825 mRL, where the primary fans will be located. These fans will draw air out of the return airway system and exhaust it into the current open pit, with fresh air being drawn down the decline to complete the ventilation circuit. Figure 16.9 shows the proposed primary fan location. P a g e | 118 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Figure 16.9 Primary ventilation fan location Underground as built design information 16.4.2. Primary Ventilation Fan Location 825 mRL SECONDARY VENTILATION Secondary ventilation will be provided using smaller fans located in the decline, with ventilation bags extending into the levels and secondary ventilated areas. MWL plans to use the secondary ventilation fans and the electrical installations that were kept from the original underground workings completed by Anvil. All this equipment will be refurbished and made fit for purpose prior to re-installation in the underground workings. 16.5. DEWATERING When mining the Dikulushi open pit cut back, MWL decided against dewatering from within the open pit, and instead decided to access the existing decline and use it as a pumping platform. A 110mm diameter line was connected to a small floating pontoon within the decline, and as the water level receded, the pontoon was shifted down the decline. This strategy successfully minimised the impact of flood water on open pit mining. In the main decline, dewatering was rapid until established levels were encountered at 20 m vertical intervals, below 900 mRL. The extensive development encountered on these levels stored a significant amount of water and consequently reduced dewatering rates. As the open pit was mined, depressurisation holes were drilled at 10m vertical intervals, and 20 m horizontally apart within the walls. Significant volumes of groundwater were encountered in the eastern and western walls of the pit, which was allowed to flow onto the pit floor, eventually making its way into the underground workings. Prior to the 2012-13 wet season, (October 2012), the groundwater level had been lowered to the 820 mRL. During the wet season, a number of heavy downpours dramatically increased water flow into the underground, such that by the end of April 2013, the water level had risen to 849.5 mRL. Dewatering activities at the time were limited by the equipment available at the time of the rain events. The commencement underground mining will depend upon the success in reducing the water level to below the planned working areas. For initial mining, the water level will need to be below the 770 mRL level. The near term mining will need to effectively dewater all underground development P a g e | 119 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 down to the 750 mRL. For long term mining, ground water inflow will have to be carefully managed to minimise its impact on mining activities. Long-term dewatering of the underground mining operation would use the existing dewatering sumps and pumping locations originally set up. Dewatering stations will be set up as the water level is lowered throughout the existing mine workings. It is anticipated that dewatering equipment left behind by Anvil, once refurbished, will be suitable to control the water entering underground workings. In addition to the existing pumping locations and sumps, new sumps and pumping locations will be developed as the decline is advanced down to lower regions of the orebody. Figure 16.10 and Figure 16.11 show the existing underground dewatering infrastructure locations and proposed future dewatering locations respectively. The existing dewatering infrastructure implemented by Anvil had a sump located along the decline, with vertical distances between 60 and 75 m between stations. All dewatering pipelines were run between pumping stations using the main decline. Figure 16.10 Existing underground dewatering infrastructure locations Figure 16.11 Proposed underground dewatering infrastructure locations New Sump Location P a g e | 120 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 16.6. MINING EQUIPMENT With the purchase of Anvil, MWL acquired all the mining equipment associated with the mining operation. This included all of the underground equipment previously used by Anvil in the underground operations closed in 2008. MWL plans to refurbish this equipment and use it as the underground mining fleet for extraction of the underground Mineral Reserves. Table 16.3 is a list of the major pieces of mining equipment available. Additional mining equipment has also been retained from the previous underground mining activities, including dewatering pumps, ventilation fans, starter boxes, electrical supply and distribution equipment that was recovered as part of the abandonment process. Table 16.3 Dikulushi production mining equipment at site from previous mining activities Equipment type Make Model Description Development Drill Rig Development Drill Rig Development Drill Rig Haulage Truck Haulage Truck Haulage Truck LHD Diamond Drill Diamond drill Integrated tool carrier Sandvik Sandvik Sandvik Sandvik Sandvik Atlas Copco Sandvik Boart Longyear Kempe Caterpillar Axera 6 Axera 6 Axera 5 EJC533 EJC533 MT440 Toro1400 LM75 Twin Boom Jumbo Twin Boom Jumbo Single Boom Jumbo 30 t dump truck 30 t dump truck 30 t dump truck Underground Loader Diamond Drill Rig Diamond drill rig Integrated tool corner 924 The composition of the mining fleet required for extraction of the underground Mineral Reserve is shown in Table 16.4. In the equipment listed, the following items are still required to be hired or purchased one LHD two light vehicles - will be taken from existing LVs on site one charge up vehicle six air leg drills and a wire line scraper. Due to the short mine life based on the Measured and Indicated Mineral Resource, the purchase of major equipment such as the LHD has not been included as part of the capital cost. It is expected that these items will be obtained on a hire arrangement, with the cost included as part of the main operating costs. It is expected that parts of the fleet will have low utilisation due to the small tonnages being produced from the underground mining operations, providing ample coverage for breakdowns. The additional pieces will still be required, as they will provide the operation with the flexibility to increase mining rates as required. P a g e | 121 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Table 16.4 Major mining fleet and equipment required for the extraction of the Dikulushi underground Mineral Reserves Mining fleet Number 2 3 2 1 1 1 1 2 6 1 LHD Truck Jumbo twin Jumbo single Integrated Tool Carrier Charge up vehicle PC Ute Air leg drills Wire Line Scraper 16.6.1. MINE DEVELOPMENT The development of the underground operations will be completed using traditional drill and blast methods utilising two twin-boom jumbos. A single-boom jumbo is to provide rock support and rehabilitation capabilities, using weldmesh and rock bolts for the bulk of the mining development, as per the geotechnical guidelines provided by Mike Turner. In addition to the standard ground support outlined in the report, cable bolts will be installed at intersections and any areas of poor ground encountered. Table 16.5 is a list of the horizontal development design parameters, including the development location/type, width, height, back profile, ground support method and gradient. Table 16.5 Underground horizontal development design parameters Development type Width (m) Height (m) Decline Decline Stockpile Level Access Level Stockpile Return Airway Drive Cut and Fill Ramps Ore Drives 5.5 5.5 5.0 5.0 5.0 4.5 4.5 5.5 5.5 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 Profile Arched Arched Arched Arched Arched Arched Square Ground support method Mesh & Bolt Mesh & Bolt Mesh & Bolt Mesh & Bolt Mesh & Bolt Mesh & Bolt Mesh & Bolt Gradient 1 in 7 1 in 50 1 in 100 1 in 100 1 in 50 1 in 6 1 in100 Vertical development to be completed in the underground will be conducted using hand-held rising methods. Escape way rises will be developed in a single pass from bottom to top. Other vertical development, such as vent rises, will be developed initially with a single rise of 1.5 m in diameter developed from bottom to top. Stripping of the rise will then take place working from top to bottom, with all blast material scraped into the centre of the rise where it will fall down to the lower level for removal. Installation of split sets and mesh will be done as required in the larger development openings. Table 16.6 is a list of the expected vertical development required in the mining operation. P a g e | 122 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Table 16.6 Underground vertical development design parameters Diameter Development type (m) Length (m) Profile Vent Rise Escape Way Rise 15 to 20 15 to 20 Round Round 16.6.2. 5.0 1.5 Ground support method N/A As Required Angle (deg) 60 60 MINING SCHEDULE For the purposes of determining reserves for the Dikulushi underground mining operation several schedules were created. Each of the schedules created was produced in Enhanced Production Scheduler (EPS) using information from the reserve block model and underground designs provided by MWL. Initial scheduling of the underground operations involved creating a Measured, Indicated and Inferred schedule that would be the basis of identifying the economic prospects of the underground mining operation. This schedule was created to identify the probability of the mining operation having a longer life than would have been indicated by just evaluating the Measured and Indicated ore reserve only. This approach was taken due to the limited amount of Measured and Indicated ore reserve remaining after the completion of the open pit mining activities. The initial Measured Indicated and Inferred schedule was evaluated by MWL using an existing financial model to identify the project’s potential viability and to understand the impact of the operation within the company’s portfolio of mining operations. From the information output from MWL’s financial model, the following costs were used as a benchmark for evaluating the Measured and Indicated tonnes contained within the Initial schedule with an operational mining cost of $100 per ore tonne mined, a processing cost of $55 per ore tonne and an operational overhead costs of $68.20 per tonne. For the process of identifying the viability of the Measured and Indicated ore tonnes contained within the underground design, a total mining and processing cost per ore tonne was then estimated at $223.20. This cost was estimated for an underground operation with an ore mining and processing production rate of 183,291t per annum. In addition to the ore mining cost, a copper price of $6,800 per tonne and silver price of $20 per ounce were then used to determine the revenue from the contained Measured and indicated copper tonnes and silver ounces. The tonnes and grade for each of the levels were exported from EPS into a spreadsheet where a high level economic evaluation was performed. For the economic evaluation of the Measured and Indicated ore tonnes, each level was split into two sections - east and west of the level access. The revenue for each section was calculated by taking the Measured and Indicated copper tonnes and silver ounces contained in the mined material multiplied by the processing recoveries and product prices. Each section was then evaluated by subtracting the mining cost from the section from the revenue obtained from the sale of the measured and indicated copper tonnes and silver P a g e | 123 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 ounces to determine if it had a positive revenue. Each level that had a positive revenue was included as part of the Mineral Reserve schedule. From the evaluation process nine levels were identified as having positive revenues. Seven of the levels included both the drives to the East and West of the access, with two levels having development east of the access only. A second EPS schedule was set up to provide a practical mining schedule for the basis of the underground reserves. A second mining schedule was created to provide a new mining sequence, incorporating the development of capital mining development to provide primary ventilation of the mining operation access to the design ore drives from the existing underground workings development of the ore drives the use of backfill. This schedule excluded the higher risk ore contained in the crown pillar zone between the 805 and 825 mRL’s. The Measured and Indicated mining sequence created in EPS mined 121,000 ore tonnes at 5.4% copper over a period of 19 months. This timeframe allows for one month lead for rehabilitation of the existing underground workings and development of rises to establish primary ventilation along with one extra month at the end of the schedule to complete ore backfilling operations. The mining costs used in the schedule were a combination of time variables such as labour and administration costs which are independent of production activities, and direct production costs which are driven by the day-to-day production of the mining and processing operations. All costs used in the schedule were provided by MWL, with direct production costs created from first principle methods and the overhead costs calculated using historic site costs. The final reserves schedule included the extraction of the crown pillar tonnes from the 805 to the 825 mRL’s. The economic selection of the drives to be mined as part of the Mineral Reserve was completed using the same process as the second schedule. In addition an economic evaluation process for the ore drives was evaluated, based on their interaction with the existing Dikulushi open pit. Where the underground development could have a significant impact on the stability of the open pit shell, these ore tonnes were removed. The Measured and Indicated resource mining sequence created in EPS mined 173,000 ore tonnes at 5.2% copper over a period of 20 months. The extraction of the additional tonnes in the crown pillar area was scheduled in parallel with the ore tonnes produced from a second mining schedule being created. CONSTRAINTS The Measured and Indicated Mineral Reserve mining schedule produced in this report has tried to replicate the same parameters as outlined in the Measured Indicated and Inferred schedule produced for MWL. Mining activities were restricted to levels that provided a positive economic evaluation as described, with the mining sequence altered to minimise the mining timeframe required for the extraction of the ore. All drives were reduced in length where the copper grade fell P a g e | 124 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 below 1.5% towards the end of the drive. Ore drive sections where the grade fell below 1.5% but then rose above 1.5% further down have been retained in the schedule, and were treated as marginal ore, requiring that only the processing costs were covered by putting the ore tonnes through the processing plant as a tonnes would need to be mined regardless of grade to access the high-grade sections of the orebody. To ensure that the full cost of mining for each ore drive has been included as part of the economic evaluation, the Inferred and unclassified ore tonnes mined have not been included as part of the cost calculation process. The grade component from the Inferred and unclassified tonnes was not included as part of the revenue from the drive, diluting the grade from the Measured and Indicated tonnes mined. The production drilling rates that are used, are the maximum scheduled advance per month rate, as Jumbo development is the critical limiting factor in the schedule. Twin-boom Jumbo lineal advance rates have been scheduled at 193m per month per jumbo, or a total of 386 m per month for both twin-boom jumbos. Waste development has been scheduled at 100 m per month. Development rates for ore drives have been scheduled at the following rates: 52 m per month in the western end of the orebody 65 m per month in the central and eastern areas of the orebody 91 m per month for capital development Development rates used are outlined in greater detail in section 16.6.4. DEVELOPMENT AND LEVEL DESIGN The designs used in the schedule were in addition to work already completed by Red Rock Engineering, which consisted of designs for capital development and an ore body wireframe shape (stope6.dtm). Optiro has produced level designs in Datamine along the width of this stope shape using 5m vertical intervals and drive dimensions of 4.5 mW x 5.0 mH. Levels have then been broken into approximately 10m sections to allow more granular scheduling. The level development design sections were then imported into Mine 5D Planner, where they were evaluated against the block model and each section was assigned the corresponding average grade, tonnes and material properties of the model cells contained within it. Additional properties were also added such as development length and segment identification fields. ORE LOSS AND DILUTION For scheduling purposes, mining ore loss has been estimated at 5%. Ore loss will primarily occur as a result of gaps left in the backfill process, caused by the inability to properly level off the top of backfill as it is being placed in the drive. This means that when using the backfill as the floor for the next level the fill will generally have a rounded profile, and this will result in some material being lost to fill these corners as the next level is developed (see Figure 16.12). There will also be a small amount of ore loss from general activities such as rehandle and material movement. P a g e | 125 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Figure 16.12 Ore loss due to gaps left in the backfilling process Mining dilution for the project has been estimated at 8%, which is the average dilution calculated for the various drive dimensions. Dilution was estimated by allowing a 200mm dilution skin on the walls of development drives, which has then been used to determine the percentage dilution using the cross-sectional area of the drives. Drive profile calculations are outlined in Table 16.7. These estimations assume a square cross-section for calculation purposes. Table 16.7 Mining dilution Width (m) Height (m) Drive Area (m2) Dilution width (m) Dilution skin area (m2) Dilution (%) Ore Ore Drive 4.50 5.00 22.50 0.20 2.00 8.9 Waste Decline Decline Stockpile Level Access Level Stockpile Return Airway Drive Cut and Fill Ramp Average 5.50 5.50 5.00 5.00 5.00 4.50 5.08 5.50 5.50 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.17 30.25 30.25 25.00 25.00 25.00 22.50 26.26 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 2.20 2.20 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.07 7.3 7.3 8.0 8.0 8.0 8.9 7.9 Development Ore loss has been applied to the schedule by reducing the contained metal for each segment by 5%. Dilution has been applied to the in situ tonnes of the blocks, multiplying them by 1.08 and then subtracting the ore loss material. This only occurs in areas producing ore, and is limited to the Measured and Indicated tonnes only. Updated metal grades (including both ore loss and dilution) are then calculated from the ore-loss applied contained metal and the new diluted tonnes. For this schedule ore loss has been assumed for both copper and silver. Waste tonnes have been calculated for the purpose of financial evaluation of the schedule, and have been determined by simply taking the total tonnes for a segment and subtracting the ore tonnes. P a g e | 126 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 BACKFILL Backfilling has been scheduled by calculating the mined volume of the drives and allowing for an 80% fill factor due to the difficulty of pushing material all the way up to the backs. Backfill has been scheduled at a rate of 1,008 m3 per week per machine for all fill types, and minimum curing times have been scheduled at 28 days for mining underneath fill and 2 days for mining alongside fill. A density of 2.5 t/m3 has been assumed for backfill, which is conservatively high. Backfill sequencing has allowed for 5 m pillars between active levels. HAULAGE CALCULATIONS The schedule has included production tonnes-km figures, which are a metric used to represent haulage in terms of both the total tonnes and the total required haul distance for a given schedule block. Surface haul distances were calculated by measuring the haul distance from the waste dumps and ROM pad from the portal. Underground haul distances were calculated using differences in vertical distance between the portal (1015 mRL) and the schedule level RL, and multiplying it by 7 to estimate a decline distance. Total haul distances (in km) were then multiplied by the total tonnes mined in each schedule block to calculate the haulage tonnes-km value. SCHEDULE SEQUENCE The Mineral Reserve schedule utilises the existing capital development completed in previous underground mining activities. The mining activities that are required before a stoping operation can re-commence are the development of ventilation and escape way rises in the upper levels of the mine that were not previously completed. The development of the ventilation and escape way rise system is to be completed within the first 4 months of the mining operation’s re-commencement. This opens the opportunity to develop the maximum number of all drives from month 5 in the schedule onwards. Level development in the first 3 months of mining production is concentrated in the 800, 790, 765 levels. Towards the end of the quarter the 755 mRL opens up for mining activities with backfilling operations. Backfilling operations are initially concentrated in the eastern section on the 790 mRL for the first half of the quarter, with the 765, 770, and 800 RL backfilling activities commencing towards the end. Mining activities in the second quarter are scheduled to continue in the 790, 765 mRL’s. New mining activity then commences on the 770, 780 and 750 mRL’s. Backfilling activities continue in the 790 and 800 mRL’s with backfilling activities starting in the 770 and 755 mRL’s. Mining activities in both the 755 and 790 mRL’s is completed during this period. Quarter three mining activities concentrate around the 770, 780, 795 mRL’s with backfilling activities occurring on the same three levels. Mining of the 770 and 780 mRL’s is completed during this period. Quarter four mining activities are concentrated around the 795, 785 and 775 mRL’s and backfilling activities are concentrated around the 780 and 795 levels, with backfilling activities also occurring in the 785 and 775 levels towards the end of the period. P a g e | 127 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 The remaining mining activities for quarters five and six are concentrated in the 785 and 775 mRL’s, extracting the remainder of the current Measured and Indicated material. Due to the requirement for backfill to minimise the open stoping widths, mining and production significantly reduces. Backfilling activities during this period include the 785 and 755 mRL’s along with the 795 mRL. Mining activities are completed within the first month of quarter six, with backfilling activities finishing midway through the third month of the quarter. Figure 16.13 is a pictorial representation of the Measured and Indicated Mineral Reserve extraction sequence as described. Figure 16.13 Ore level schedule, by quarter Table 16.8 details of the planned mining production physicals on a quarterly basis. Table 16.8 Underground mine production physicals 16.6.3. MINING SHIFTS Mining personnel shifts will be split up into three 8 hour panels; a day shift, afternoon shift and night shift (outlined in Table 16.9). Day shift commences at 07H00 and shift changeover for the day shift to afternoon shift will occur at 15H00. This is timed to coincide with the primary blasting time, and afternoon shift start time will be dependent on re-entry periods following blasting. Shift changeover P a g e | 128 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 from the afternoon to the nightshift will occur at 23H00. Work rosters will be a 2 day shift / 2 afternoon shift / 2 night shift / 2 off basis. Table 16.9 Work shifts Start time Finish time Duration (hrs) Day 07H00 15H00 8 Afternoon 15H00 23H00 8 Night 23H00 07H00 8 Shift Project Management, Technical Services, and Support Personnel will generally work day shift only, covering the day and part of the afternoon mining shifts. Table 16.10 to Table 16.12 shows the estimated total number of personnel required for the site’s management, technical services and operational support functions. Table 16.10 Operational Management Labour Operational Management Project Manager Maintenance Manager Electrical Supervisor Senior Auto Electrician Maintenance Crew Leader/ Trainer Op. Crew Leader / Trainer Table 16.11 Quota 1 1 1 2 3 3 Technical Services labour Technical Services Technical Manager Mine Survey Mine Geology Geotechnical Engineer Mine Engineering Quota 1 2 2 2 2 P a g e | 129 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Table 16.12 Support functions labour Labour HSE Manager Onsite Medical Doctor Senior Environmental Officer Onsite Medical Nurse Environmental Technician General Clerk Ambulance Driver General Driver General Assistant Quota 1 2 2 6 3 3 3 3 6 Table 16.13 and Table 16.14 detail the shift personnel numbers required for the operation of each shift. The total numbers of personnel required to maintain the mining operations will be the number of personnel per shift multiplied by the number of shifts. Where the manning number is accompanied by an asterix, this means that this role is only filled during the day and afternoon shift, with no personnel rostered into this position during the nightshift. Table 16.13 Labour requirements: underground operations Underground Operations Mine Foreman Shift Supervisor Develop Drill Crew Rehab Crew General Service Crew Material Haul Material Load Charge Crew Air leg Drillers Backfill Crew Quota 1* 1 2 1 3 3 2 2 2* 2 P a g e | 130 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Table 16.14 Underground Workshop personnel Labour – Underground Workshop Workshop Foreman Crew Supervisor Develop Drill Fitter Workshop Fitter UG Fitter Trade Assistants Senior Electrician Mine Electrician 16.6.4. Quota 1* 1 1 2 2 2 1 1 DEVELOPMENT / STOPING RATES Development rates are outlined in Table 16.15, showing the estimated development turnaround, length and maximum number of cuts available to be taken in each type of heading per week. All the drive profiles can be found previously in Table 16.5 and Table 16.6. Table 16.15 Jumbo/production drill rates by development type Drive type Cut Length (m) Turn Around Maximum cuts per week Decline Decline Stockpile Level Access Level Stockpile Return Airway Drive Cut and Fill Ramps Ore Drives 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3 1.5 shifts 1.5 shifts 1.5 shifts 1.5 shifts 1.5 shifts 1.5 shifts 1.5 shifts 7 7 7 7 7 5 5 Table 16.16 details the individual Jumbo production rates applied in the scheduling process; these rates have been created by applying basic mining principles on a conservative production rate. The twin-boom development rate (193.1 m per month) has been applied to the schedule, and the singleboom jumbo rates provided are intended as back-up rates only. Monthly development for 2 twinboom jumbos has been scheduled at a lineal rate of advance of 386.1 m per month, or 117 cuts (shown in Table 16.17). The single-boom jumbo is assumed to be used primarily for cable bolting and rehabilitation work. P a g e | 131 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Table 16.16 Jumbo/production drill rates by individual machine Cut length (m) Cuts per shift No. of cuts per week Dist. advanced per week (m) No. of cuts per month Dev. adv. per month (m) Twin-boom 3.3 0.64 13.5 44.6 59 193.1 Primary Single-boom 3.3 0.31 6.5 21.5 42 139.4 Back up Jumbo advance Table 16.17 Dev. status Jumbo/production drill rates by fleet Units Cut length (m) Cuts per Shift No. of cuts per wk. Dist. advanced per wk.(m) No. of cuts per month Dev. adv. per month (m) Twin-boom 2 3.3 1.29 27 89.1 117 386.1 Primary Single-boom 1 3.3 0.31 6.5 21.5 42 139.4 Back up Monthly Development 16.6.5. Development Status AIR LEG DEVELOPMENT RATES Development work using air leg miners will occur on an eight hour day shift only, as the work conducted by these workers is regarded as high risk. Table 16.18 outlines the production rates that have been used in the schedule. Air leg/rise mining is a critical part of the mining plan, as it provides the return airways for the primary ventilation circuit and the alternate secondary escape a path for an emergency. Development of the air leg rises for escape ways has been split up into production rates for single and double rises. The development rate of rises varies with the air leg miners’ access to multiple headings. For a single rise being developed by itself the advance is 1.5 m per shift, if there are two rises close together this rate is able to be doubled due to the availability of equipment. This scheme was applied for the development of the ventilation rises in the schedule and involves air leg miners initially developing a rise from the lower level of the ventilation rise to the upper level. Once the rises can be completed, the air leg miner then proceeds to strip the surrounding parameter of the final rise diameter into the hole created by the initial rise. The process used by the air leg miner involves drilling and firing the material to be stripped into the hole during one shift, with the following shift required to clean out the fired material from the stripping, and installation of appropriate ground support around the rise as it is developed down. It is expected that the development of a 20 m rise will take one air leg miner approximately 42 days to complete the development from start to finish. P a g e | 132 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Table 16.18 Air Leg development Length advance (m) Turn around Advance per week (m) 1.5 per shift 7 3 per shift 7 Drill and Fire 1.5 per shift 3.5 Bog and Ground support 1.5 per shift 3.5 Development type Rise Development Single Double (side by side) Return Air Way stripping 16.7. GEOTECHNICAL 16.7.1. DATA A Geotechnical study into re-opening the underground operation has been performed by Turner Mining and Geotechnical (Turner, 2013). The study investigated geotechnical aspects of mining from the pit bottom around 825mRL to 500mRL, and was based on the following data: Diamond drill core logging databases (31 holes, Anvil and MWL). Underground mapping data (7 sites, personal data, undertaken for Anvil). Surpac files of current open pit and underground excavations (MWL). Surpac files of planned open pit and underground excavations (MWL and Red Rock Engineering Pty Ltd). Previous geotechnical reports (Turner Mining and Geotechnical (2008(a), 2008(b), 2012 and AMC Consultants (2004, 2011)). Observations made during multiple site visits (2003 to December 2012). 16.7.2. GEOTECHNICAL DOMAINS Rock Quality classification has been conducted by Turner Mining and Geotechnical, with the following geotechnical domains identified: The orebody ranges from Extremely Poor to Fair, with the majority classed as Poor. The footwall rockmass averages Fair. Hangingwall ranges from Extremely Poor to Fair, with the majority classified as Poor. The contours of Q for the orebody (Figure 16.14) show the very poor ground above the750mRL and west of 50300mE. This poor ground zone in the orebody is critically important to manage as it indicates severe ground control problems could be encountered when trying to extract ore out of this zone The contours of Q (rock quality) for the footwall (Figure 16.15) show 2 zones of very poor ground, centred around the 725mRL at 50125mE; and 525mRL at 50280mE. These two zones indicate that even though split sets and mesh might still be appropriate, there could be a need for shorter cuts/round lengths and secondary installation of grouted bolts. P a g e | 133 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 The contours of Q for the hanging wall (Figure 16.16) show a zone of very poor ground centred around the 725mRL at 50130mE. This poor hanging wall zone eliminated the use of any longhole stoping or benching in this zone. Figure 16.14 Dikulushi orebody rock quality, Q (Turner, 2013) Figure 16.15 Dikulushi footwall rock quality, Q (Turner, 2013) P a g e | 134 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Figure 16.16 Dikulushi hanging wall rock quality, Q (Turner, 2013) 16.7.3. POTENTIAL FAILURES From the previous mapping data gathered during mining activities in the 810 mRL in 2008 following the fall of ground in 810 mRL W2 drive. Unwedge analysis was performed to evaluate the potential for wedge instability in the walls and backs of excavations of the underground excavations. From this analysis it was identified that the use of solid steel bolts compared to standard spit sets in ground support activities provided an increase the factor of safety, reducing the likelihood of an wedge failure occurring. Recommendations from the report by Turner ‘geotechnical input for reopening of the Dikulushi underground’ suggest the use of solid steel rock bolts to be used during development of levels in the orebody where poor ground conditions have been identified (above the 755 mRL and West of the 50130 m E). 16.7.4. MAPPING, MONITORING AND ADDITIONAL DATA Mapping and monitoring of the underground drive development will form a significant part of the ground support risk mitigation activities for the underground development, especially where ore drives are located in areas of poor rock mass quality. 16.8. GROUND SUPPORT REQUIREMENTS The orebody rock mass quality in the poor ground section from 810 to 780 mRL west of 50130 mE ranges from Very Poor to Extremely Poor and the hanging wall is also Very Poor. Only small voids will remain stable in this zone, and will require very intensive support, including solid steel rockbolts, P a g e | 135 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 solid steel spiling bars and weldmesh or fibrecrete (Figure 16.17). Even with such support there will still be a risk of collapse that will need to be managed by operations. Figure 16.17 Dikulushi rock reinforcement chart (Turner, 2013) Detailed pre-scheduling of drives is also essential to ensure sufficient working places are available, taking into account the fill curing constraint. The strength and curing time need to correlate with the scheduled extraction sequence to ensure sufficient ore is produced. Testing of the different fill mixtures with varying cement percentages is another essential function prior to the introduction of this method. The fill will need to have a guaranteed strength of at least 10 MPa before excavation can proceed under the fill. It is also common practice to increase the cement content above that indicated from tests by up to 50% to cater for poor mix control. P a g e | 136 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Stope drifts should be maintained at no greater than 4.5 m width and split sets and mesh used as support quality control on cement percentage and mixing is essential the extraction sequencing of adjacent drifts in wide areas will be critical. 2.4 m solid steel bolts should be inserted into 1.2 m holes 0.3 m above the floor at 1.2 m spacing along each wall of the drive prior to fill being introduced in order to improve the tensile strength and wall adhesion in the critical lower corners of the filled drifts. Mesh should also be left at the same height across the width of the drifts if paste fill is used. 16.8.1. SPLIT SETS Most ore drives may be supported with split sets and mesh. Split sets (friction stabilisers) should be galvanised, 2.4 m long, 46 mm diameter and of the type installed by jumbos. Hole diameter control is an essential part of split set installation and bit sizes must be checked regularly to ensure that the hole diameter is 44 to 45 mm. 0.9 m, SS39 stubby split sets may be used for mesh overlaps. 16.8.2. SOLID STEEL ROCKBOLTS Solid steel rockbolts that are immediately active (no delay for grout curing) will be required for any development in the extremely poor ground in the orebody (above 775 mRL and West of 50130 mE). Suitable solid steel bolts include: 20 mm Posimix bolts 20 mm CT-Bolts 20 mm Gemini Bolts (South African version of the CT-Bolt) 20 mm MD Bolt (combination split set and mechanical wedge). These are either anchored using a mechanical shell/wedge or with resin, and can be used to install mesh to the face. Plain solid steel bars are also suitable for use as spiling bars in extremely weak ground to stabilise the backs ahead of the drive. 16.8.3. CABLE BOLTS All intersections should be cable bolted unless a geotechnical engineer is on site to map the intersection and determine if it is stable, without a potential for wedge failure. Cable bolts should consist of fully grouted, twin-strand 15.2 mm, plated and tensioned units on a 2.5 m spacing. Historically cable bolts have never been installed correctly at Dikulushi and suitable equipment should be purchased. Effective training and supervision will also be essential. 16.8.4. SHOTCRETE Fibrecrete may be used instead of mesh but the logistics of maintaining an operational shotcrete fleet at Dikulushi would probably preclude this option. Shotcrete with fibres would be useful for intersections of extremely weak ground, but these are only expected in the orebody, and if the ground is that weak there will be subsequent stope stability issues. P a g e | 137 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 16.8.5. GEOTECHNICAL FILL REVIEW Brief comments on fill strength and sizing have been recommended by Turner Mining and Geotechnical Pty Ltd in the 2013 report with additional comments provided by Peter O’Brian and Associates Pty Ltd. The 4 main types of fill considered for the operations in both reports were; rock fill (RF) cemented rock fill (CRF) cemented aggregate fill (CAF) and cemented paste fill (Paste) Rock fill was recommended for overhand cut and fill stoping .It was recommended that the use of standard underground development waste was sufficient, with the main function of the rock fill being to provide a working floor for the next mining levels/lift. Cemented rock fill (CRF) was recommended to be use in open stoping, bench stoping and cut and fill mining activities. The percentage of cement recommended was 10% and this is significant more than stand a cut and fill operations, which generally use 5 to 6% cement. In addition to the use of rock fill it was also recommended that material no greater than 300 mm be used. CAF was also recommended to be used in open stoping, bench stoping, underhanded cut and fill or standard cut and fill mining activities. In addition to the uses of CRF and CAF a review of the tailings from the Dikulushi processing plant was also conducted to identify there suitability for their uses in cemented paste fill. This review identified that the tailings from the plant would be suitable for the creation of paste fill for the underground mining operations, the tailings from the processing plant had an even size distribution which will lead to an increase in strength and fast curing times. The use of paste fill requires the construction of both a paste fill plant and underground delivery system either through pipework located in the decline or a series of boreholes to deliver fill to each of the levels. Additionally barricades need to be constructed at the end of the voids being filled with paste fill to contain the fill wallet sets. Construction of barricades could be undertaken using waste material and hand packed cemented fill bags sealing the opening to the backs of the drive. Due to the limited height of ore drives/Stopes in the underground working it is unlikely there will be a need for engineered barricades to contain the paste fill. 16.8.6. CRF MIXING Cemented Rock Fill (CRF) consists of waste rock mixed with cement. The source of the waste rock should be unweathered and without an excess of large rocks or fine material. Underground development waste is suitable but waste rock from the open pit waste dumps is not suitable due to the much larger fragment size. The method of mixing cement into the rock is critical and has a major impact on the cement content. P a g e | 138 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Mixing methods can include: Spray mixing with cement slurry at the entry to the stope Spray mixing at the tipping point into trucks. Batch mixing at the entry for trucks Batch mixing by loader in stockpile bays (reasonably common in small mines in Australia) A cement percentage of 5 to 6% is normally required for the scale of the mining methods proposed at Dikulushi, but where there is a risk of poor mixing and excess water content this should increase to 10%. A 10% composition is typically used in small-scale filling where the fill is mixed by loaders in stockpiles bays, calculated by adding the required number of cement bags to each loader bucket of waste placed in the stockpile bay. 16.9. GROUND SUPPORT STANDARDS Ground support standards have been developed for the Dikulushi underground mining operation by Turner mining and geotechnical Pty Ltd. The standards include ground support for the declines, access drives, ore drives and intersections and are shown in sections to 16.9.1 to 16.9.5 P a g e | 139 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 16.9.1. DECLINE SUPPORT STANDARD P a g e | 140 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 16.9.2. ACCESS SUPPORT STANDARD P a g e | 141 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 16.9.3. ORE DRIVE SUPPORT STANDARD WITH MESH P a g e | 142 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 16.9.4. 3 WAY INTERSECTION SUPPORT STANDARD P a g e | 143 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 16.9.5. 4-WAY INTERSECTION SUPPORT STANDARD P a g e | 144 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 16.10. WASTE DUMP DESIGN Waste material from the underground mining activities is expected to be minimal due to the use of waste material as a major component of the backfill required for the ore mining activities. In addition to the underground waste produced it is expected that suitable waste rock material will need to be sourced from the base of the open pit and surrounding waste dumps to make up any shortfall in waste material required for the production of backfill. Should the underground mining activities change to mining methods which require significantly less backfill material, it is expected that the existing waste dump surrounding the Dikulushi open pit can be modified to accept additional waste material. 16.11. SURFACE WATER MANAGEMENT The existing surface water management arrangements for the Dikulushi open pit mining operations are in conjunction with the underground dewatering system and it is expected to be capable of dealing with any surface water inflow into the underground mining operations. P a g e | 145 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 17. RECOVERY METHODS 17.1. PLANT FLOWSHEET The processing plant and associated infrastructure was refurbished prior to start up in June, 2010, and has been in continuous operation since. The crushing plant consists of 3 stages; primary jaw crushing, followed by 2 stages of cone crushing in a closed circuit with a double deck vibrating screen, producing a minus 20 mm product for the grinding circuit feed. The grinding circuit consists of two overflow ball mills in parallel configuration in closed circuit with a 250 mm hydrocyclone. Each ball mill is powered by a 750 kW motor. The grind sizing parameter is 70% passing 106 microns. The mill is capable of treating in excess of 520,000 tonnes of ore per annum. Both ball mills discharge to a common sump, and the slurry is pumped to a single 250 mm diameter cyclone. The cyclone underflow gravitates to an Outokumpu SK240 Unit Flotation Cell to recover coarse liberated copper sulphides, which report directly to the final concentrate. The cyclone overflow reports to conditioning and conventional flotation at 35% solids. A relatively simple flotation circuit is in place; the circuit consists of two sections, a primary sulphide flotation and a secondary sulphide/oxide flotation. See figure 17.1. Collector and frother addition is conventional when processing low grade ore. The splitting of the circuit is due to the presence of oxide minerals in some of the ore blends which require activation using sodium hydrosulphide (Na2S) to enable them to be recovered. As sodium hydrosulphide can depress some sulphide minerals, the majority of the sulphide minerals are recovered in the primary sulphide flotation circuit. The tailings from the primary sulphide flotation circuit are sulphidised and the liberated oxides and additional sulphides are recovered. In the event of the ore blend containing little or no oxides and thus not requiring sulphidising, the secondary sulphide circuit acts as a sulphide scavenger. The primary rougher circuit has provision for bypassing initial rougher concentrates directly to final concentrate. Lower grade rougher concentrates report to the cleaning flotation cells for upgrading. Final tailings from the secondary rougher circuit are pumped to the tailings storage facility. Supernatant water is recovered from the tailings dam and recycled to the processing plant. The circuit is based on a nominal flotation time of 20 minutes in each of the rougher flotation stages and a minimum 15 minutes in each of the cleaner stages. Final concentrate is pumped to a thickener and the underflow is pumped to a concentrate storage tank. The storage tank has sufficient capacity for 8 hours of concentrate production. A filter press with a capacity of 194t per day is operated in batch mode. Filter cake discharges directly onto a concrete floor below the filter where it is recovered and transported to a simple hopper/bagging arrangement with a skid steer loader. Concentrate is loaded into two tonne capacity bulk bags. Moisture content is near 10%. P a g e | 146 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Each bag is weighed ready for despatch by truck to the Kilwa port as outlined in (Figure 17.1) Figure 17.1 Dikulushi Plant flow diagram 17.2. TAILINGS STORAGE FACILITIES (TSF) The first TSF for HMS tailings, designed by Knight Piésold Consulting, South Africa, covers 1.8 hectares and has been dormant since September, 2004. A particularly coarse portion of the HMS tailings was recovered and processed through the flotation plant by Anvil. MWL has recovered and processed approximately 15,000t of coarse sand and slime material from this dump A second TSF (TD2), designed by D.E. Cooper and Associates, Australia, was built during 3Q, 2004 to receive flotation tailings. This facility is located ~100m North of the HMS TSF, covers about 12 hectares and is 12 m high on the eastern embankment. This facility has also reached capacity. A third TSF (TD3), designed by Knight Piésold, is located adjacent to and north of the second TSF and covers a 21 hectare area. This dam is a typical hillside impoundment and provides the needed area to limit the rise rate of tailings at acceptable norms. Supernatant tailings water is reclaimed via penstock arrangements for use in the processing plant. The third TSF (TD3) was utilized until December, 2008 and lay dormant until it was recommissioned in July 2010. At this juncture Knight Piésold was employed to carry out a volumetric assessment study to determine the storage capacity of the dam to accommodate 840,000t of tailings resulting P a g e | 147 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 from the processing of the low grade ore stockpile. The study concluded that a 2 m embankment raise would be required during 2011. Deposition continued until October 2010 when Knight Piésold was commissioned to further assess TD3 expansion capabilities to make provision for an additional 1,500,000t of deposition. The study concluded that the walls would require to be raised by 6m to accommodate this quantity of tailings. The raise will be carried out in 2 stages of 3m each, with the first raise completed in mid-2012. Sub aerial tailings deposition to TD 3 has continued since completion of this first stage 3m raise and as of June 2013, the TD 3 survey pick up indicated a residual storage volume capacity of 425,000 m3. Based on operational beach densities and freeboard management allowance, the residual storage capacity allowance is ensured until the TD 3 stage 2 raise, which is planned for during the dry season in 2014. In preparation for uninterrupted TD 3 works during this construction period, an interim storage capacity lift of 2m is proposed in TD 2 before TD 3 works commence. This will also allow for ongoing back-up operational capacity. This will provide a tailings storage facility capable of supporting the underground mining operation. The information on the upgrading of TD 3 has been supplied by MWL and Sedgman has not reviewed this data. 17.3. PROCESSING STATISTICS ANVIL PROCESSING Anvil processed 137,256 tonnes of low grade between May 2008 and December 2008 when the open cut run of mine ore ran out prior to full production from underground. Some production results from the February 2007 to April 2008 can be seen in Table 17.1. MWL PROCESSING MWL blended material from surface stockpiles and the HMS Tails through the plant to maximise copper output between June 2010 and February 2012. This was followed by the treatment of ore from satellite orebodies such as Boom Gate. The recoveries from this activity were much lower than from the fresh ore material from either the open pit or underground. It is reasonable to say that process recoveries and values are associated more with those from the previous open pit and underground mining operations carried out by Anvil. Processing statistics for the LG material completed by MWL are shown in Table 17.2. Commercial production from mining the Dikulushi open pit cutback commenced in November 2012 and was completed in July 2013. Processing of the cut back material is incomplete and open pit cut back ROM feed material will be processed till the end of 2013. Underground ore processing of ore will commence for approximately 18 months to Mineral Reserve Completion. P a g e | 148 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Table 17.1 Dikulushi processing summary relevant to ore to be mined in the pit cut back Grade Grade RL mined (Ore Only) Conc copper% Conc silver g/t 86.9 860 pit stockpile 56.0 1730 91.5 87.5 860 pit stockpile 56.0 1745 Month Blend % ROM Plant Feed copper% Silver g/t Copper Rec% Silver Rec % Feb-07* 60 5.93 181 85.7 Mar-07 100 8.41 273 Apr-07 100 7.65 233 90.7 92.2 850 pit stockpile 55.0 1696 May-07 100 7.61 231 90.2 90.1 850 pit stockpile 55.0 1670 Jun-07 100 7.74 233 91.0 90.5 870 Dev 55.0 1654 July 07* 91.4 7.28 214 89.5 89.8 stockpile 56.5 1668 Aug-07 100 7.92 245 91.1 89.4 850 Dev 56.0 1695 Sep-07 100 7.98 262 91.3 90.2 850 Dev & 890 Stoping 54.0 1890 Oct-07 100 8.18 272 92.4 92.5 870 Dev & 890 stoping 55.0 1821 Nov-07 100 7.81 250 92.2 91.8 870 Dev & 890 stoping 56.0 1793 Dec-07 100 8.45 266 92.8 92.0 830 Dev & 890 stoping 57.0 1772 Jan-08 100 6.00 187 90.1 89.4 55.0 1694 Feb 08* 81.4 5.09 154 87.2 87.7 56.0 1687 Mar-08 100 5.45 188 88.1 79.2 830 Dev & 870 Stoping 830 Dev & 890/870 Stoping 830 Dev & 870 Stoping 54.0 1668 54.0 1601 Apr-08 90 4.76 139 87.0 88.4 830/810 Dev & 870 Stoping * Low grade ore blended in with the development or stoping ore. Table 17.2 Ore Processed Mill Feed Grade Mill Feed Grade Tails Grade Cu Tails Grade Ag Conc Tonnes Conc Grade Cu Conc Grade Ag Cu metal in Conc Ag metal in Conc Recovery Cu Recovery Ag Processing statistics for the LG material completed by MWL – June 2010 to May 2011 tonnes Cu % Ag g/t Cu % Ag g/t dmt Cu % Ag g/t dmt oz % % Jun10 5,387 1.28 35.87 0.34 10.1 128 38.7 1,067 51.45 4,384 74.62 70.57 Jul-10 36,157 1.45 40.4 0.39 11.1 896 43.5 1,138 389.6 32,778 74.31 69.88 Aug10 43,882 1.04 27.63 0.35 10.5 719 42.7 1,107 306.9 25,581 67.25 65.62 Sep10 40,839 1.27 31.72 0.46 10.9 783 43.0 1,119 336.7 28,177 64.92 67.65 Oct-10 27,450 3.78 77.17 1.64 23.0 1,380 44.1 1,139 608.5 50,534 58.64 74.20 Nov10 49,029 1.52 41.2 0.63 13.6 1,066 41.5 1,188 442.7 40,726 59.41 62.68 Dec10 41,111 1.17 28.5 0.52 10.70 684 39.74 1139 272 25,057 56.54 66.45 Jan-11 49,650 1.33 32.6 0.46 11.3 1001 40.1 1070 400 32,737 64.13 62.70 Feb11 42,839 1.32 29.2 0.43 7.95 890 41.6 1033 366 29,385 66.91 73.09 Mar11 46,054 1.28 27.8 0.46 7.85 893 39.35 941 351 27,279 62.66 63.34 Apr11 40,855 1.40 34.6 0.44 8.7 906 40.2 1092 365 31,904 67.46 71.25 May11 44,705 1.32 33.31 0.52 9.1 865 41.7 993 361 27,559 61.37 61.3 YTD 467,958 1.46 35.31 0.54 10.95 10,211 41.66 1089 4,251 356,101 64.05 66.68 P a g e | 149 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Table 17.3 Processing statistics for the LG material completed by MWL – June 2011 to June 2012 Table 17.4 Processing statistics for the Open pit cut back ROM completed by MWL – Jul 2012 to July 2013 Jul-12 Aug-12 Sep-12 Oct-12 Nov-12 Dec-12 Jan-13 Feb-13 Mar-13 Apr-13 May-13 Jun-13 Jul-13 YTD-13 24,739 28,351 30,690 30,242 14,808 31,614 31,232 30,442 35,865 31,706 15,787 16,387 33,181 355,043 Ore Processed tonnes Reconciliated Mill Feed Grade Reconciliated Mill Feed Grade Cu % 2.65 2.28 2.33 2.04 5.09 5.41 5.48 6.32 5.46 6.50 10.27 10.88 7.02 5.21 Ag g/t 47.22 42.24 39.35 34.53 152.94 139.04 145.47 183.09 146.87 164.68 316.98 354.49 226.97 141.47 Tails Grade Cu Cu % 0.65 0.59 0.55 0.45 0.42 0.44 0.40 0.43 0.36 0.44 0.51 0.61 0.46 0.48 Tails Grade Ag Ag g/t 11.59 10.92 9.94 6.03 21.39 14.95 15.08 11.72 15.47 20.70 22.94 25.50 20.14 14.93 Concentrate Tonnes Produced dmt 1,448 1,334 1,476 1,200 1,138 2,711 2,685 2,939 2,936 3,087 2,470 2,798 3,723 29,944 Concentrate Grade Cu Cu % 34.86 36.51 37.57 40.49 61.16 58.42 59.42 61.40 62.29 62.70 62.85 60.79 58.97 56.52 Concentrate Grade Ag Ag g/t 620 677 622 725 1,733 1,462 1,532 1,787 1,620 1,499 1,903 1,952 1,864 1,515 Cu metal in Concentrate dmt 505 487 554 486 696 1,584 1,596 1,804 1,829 1,936 1,552 1,701 2,195 16,925 Ag metal in Concentrate oz 28,876 29,014 29,496 27,950 63,410 127,429 132,235 168,837 152,974 148,824 151,060 175,621 223,058 1,458,783 Recovery Cu % 76.9 75.2 77.4 78.7 92.4 92.6 93.3 93.8 93.4 93.9 95.8 95.4 94.2 91.5 Recovery Ag % 76.9 75.4 76.0 83.2 87.1 90.2 90.5 94.2 90.3 88.7 93.9 94.0 92.1 90.3 As stated in Section 13.3 the production data for the Period June 2011 to July 2013 was supplied by MWL and has not been reviewed by Sedgman. P a g e | 150 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 18. PROJECT INFRASTRUCTURE The Dikulushi operation is an operating mine and the infrastructure remains in place. It has been used and maintained by MWL since it took over the project site. The infrastructure is considered adequate for the continuation of the operations with the resumption of underground mining activities. 18.1. SURFACE FACILITIES The existing surface facilities (Figure 18.1) remaining from the previous underground operations and open pit cut back operations will be suitable for use by the underground mining personnel (Figure 18.1 and Figure 18.2). Figure 18.1 On-site office facilities at Dikulushi Figure 18.2 On-site Underground change room facilities at Dikulushi P a g e | 151 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 18.2. POWER The project is located in a remote area where there is no electrical utility grid. The mine power is supplied by diesel generators. Power for the Dikulushi operation will be provided by the existing diesel powered electricity generation installation. This installation has previously supplied power to the camp and the processing plant. Current production plans will not exceed previous levels and the installed capacity is expected to be sufficient for future activities. There is sufficient back-up capacity. The existing power station at Dikulushi comprises the following generators: 4 x 1.2 MW FG Wilson ( new units and installed during the 3rd quarter 2013 ), 1 x 2.0 MW Caterpillar, 1 x 1.6 MW Caterpillar and 1 x 0.8 MW Mirrlees, for a total capacity of 9.2 MW. The current power demand for the plant and infrastructure is in the order of 1.8 MW. The 2.0 MW Caterpillar and 1.6 MW Caterpillar generators currently require major overhauls, which will be completed during 2014. The 1 x 0.8 MW Mirrlees will be decommissioned during the 4th quarter of 2013. The new FG Wilson generating sets were installed to supply power to the operations as well as dewatering of the underground and normal underground operations. 18.3. PROCESS WATER SUPPLY Lake Newton on the perennial Dikulushi stream provides storage for dewatering and serves as a reservoir for the supply of process water. Meteorological data has been collected between August 2005 and August 2013, with the exception of 2009 and 2010, where little or no data was collected due to reduced activities on site. The mine water flow regime has changed over the past 3 years and the current water supply and balance system is shown in Figure 18.3. There are several sources of water on site: The Dikulushi stream, which traverses adjacent to the mine, has two abstraction points. The first abstraction point feeds water to the Process Plant, with the flow being measured. The second abstraction point is at Lake Newton which stores the water before routing it to the Return Water Dam (RWD) as make-up water. The flow between Lake Newton and the RWD is measured. The second source of water is from the Stream Borehole which supplies the Process Plant. The borehole is not currently in operation. The current main source of water is from the Open Pit which has a single supply pipeline to the Process Plant which is metered. Water from Tailings Dam 3 (TD3) is captured at the RWD where it is routed to the Process Plant, This flow is also metered. Other flow metered points are the Admin Building and the Power House which are internal plant meters. The Truck Feed receives water from Lake Newton and is used for dust suppression around the mine. A recent review and update was carried out on the full water balance during June and July P a g e | 152 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 which are amongst the driest months in the year and this has been used to update the current average water balance model, which is presented in Figure 18.3 Figure 18.3 Average water balance Process Plant Water Sources First option, must keep the water level down. Last option. Tailing Dam Lake Newton A 150m3/Day Returned Water Pond 1715m3/Day B To the Plant F G Main saurce for Process and Raw water. 3387m3/Day The river pond feed also the Process only when required. E 2205m3/Day Process Water U/G D 515m3/Day DIKULUSHI RIVER A B C D E F G H I J KEY Lake Newton Return Dam Water Boom Gate water River U/G Water 1 U/G Water 2 Process Water Admin/gardens Power House Gland service/lube cooling water Raw water Flowmeter 32m3/Day H To admin/garden 117m3/Day Pump J 1956m3/Day To Power House 32m3/Day I C 764m3/Day Emergency backup for Raw water.(Gland service) Camp Bore Hole Boom gate is the backup for Raw water and also Process water. Can feed also the river pond and overflow to Lake Newton. BG pit Based on the water balance review the following were noted: The total inflow onto the Tailings dam under present conditions is 3,607 m3/d of which 1,856 m3/d is returned back to the return water pond for reuse in the plant; The RWD gets about 2,433 m3/d from Lake Newton via the river and 1,856 m3/d from the tailings dam, while a total of 1,940 m3/d is sent to the plant for reuse; The main losses from the Tailings dam are seepage, evaporation and interstitial storage; The rainfall onto the open pit that is collected in the sumps below is reused in the plant and only when water cannot be reused in the plant is the water discharged into Lake Newton after the water is settled; The extended waste footprint means that there will be runoff from the dump that will need to be settled in paddocks and evaporated where possible; Borehole water is currently not being used but will be used as potable water and make-up water when it is in operation; Approximately 1,589 m3/d will need to be supplied from Lake Newton or from boreholes to sustain the mine during the dry months; During the wet season there will be times where the water will discharge from the RWD into the perennial stream as the plant will not be able to use all the water in the process. P a g e | 153 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 19. MARKET STUDIES AND CONTRACTS 19.1. MARKETS The Dikulushi plant is currently configured to produce a copper/silver concentrate which contains approximately 50% copper. MWL has not yet committed any of the concentrate that will be produced from the underground. This will be done via a tender process. In July 2013, the Company entered into a copper hedging transaction, forward selling 3,500 tonnes of copper at $6,875 per tonne for financial settlement at intervals commencing in November 2013 and ending in March 2014. 19.2. CONTRACTS MWL currently has a contract to sell the copper concentrate produced from the open pit project to Transamine Trading. This contract was awarded after a tender process. There are various contracts either already in place or required to be entered into for the following major areas: Explosives Diesel supply Transport Reagents Spares MWL recognises that a consistent reliable fuel supply is crucial to the success of the Dikulushi operation. The operation currently uses approximately 500,000 litres of diesel per month and will need additional fuel for the underground operations. This fuel is supplied by four DRC based companies; two receive supplies from the port of Beira in Mozambique and the other two receive supplies from the port of Dar Es Salaam in Tanzania. MWL had no interruptions during the open pit project when it was receiving up to 1,200,000 litres per month. Thus MWL believes that it has mitigated the risk of fuel supply by having a number of suppliers whom source fuel from different ports. MWL has a number of supply contracts for various inputs required for operations. MWL also has contracts to transport of concentrate from Dikulushi to Kilwa. The current revenue estimates include the concentrate being sold to the Concentrate trader who will on sell the concentrate to smelters, where it will be converted to metal and sold to the market. MWL receives 90% provisional payment for material delivered to Nchelenge in Zambia. A further 10% is received after finalisation of QP pricing and assay exchange. P a g e | 154 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Costs for the transport, as well as the treatment and refining charges for the copper and silver concentrates, along with the final net smelter returns have been sighted and used in calculations for the Mineral Reserves, but due to the commercial in confidence agreements with the smelters are not shown here. The study has used a copper price of $6,800/tonne copper ($3.08/lb. copper) and a silver price of $20 /oz silver. No formal off-take agreements have been confirmed to support these assumptions, but the expected revenue parameters are based on assessments completed by Mawson West of likely conditions and forward price curves The average cost per tonne of copper product for transport, treatment, refining and clearing is estimated to be $1,153 per tonne of copper metal sold. Long term commodity price projections have not been evaluated due to the short life of the underground and processing operations being less than 24 months, at this stage. P a g e | 155 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 20. ENVIRONMENTAL STUDIES, PERMITTING AND SOCIAL OR COMMUNITY IMPACT An Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) for the Dikulushi project was lodged in 2003. In 2009, an EIA for the underground Project was submitted to the DRC Government. Both of these reports were compiled by African Mining Consultants of Kitwe, Zambia, an environmental company that was licensed to work and report in the DRC. In 2011 an EIA for the cutback project was prepared by EMIS sprl, a DRC environmental company licences to work and report in the DRC. All three environmental reports received DRC Government approval. A revised EIA, extending underground mining beyond 2013, has been submitted to the Government for approval. MWL is required to provide annual environmental reports and demonstrate that it is in compliance with the EIA. Mine remediation is one of the compliance items in the EMP. MWL has lodged an environmental bond of $1.19M. The financial guarantee is a contribution towards an estimate of the total costs of closure, rehabilitation and re-vegetation of the Dikulushi mine. The development of the financial guarantee is conducted in compliance with: Articles 410 of the Mining Regulations Articles 124 and 125 of Appendix XI of the DRC Mining Regulations 2003; and Appendix II of the Mining Regulations 2003. The company recently had completed an annual review of the EIA which has been lodged. This review did not find any non-compliant items, or any breaches of the permitted conditions and requirements. MWL has number of corporate social responsibility programs that are run on the Dikulushi Property. The key programs are – A) The Dikulushi-Kapulo foundation – a community foundation to initiate, develop and support development projects for the benefit of local communities in health, education, infrastructure and reinforcement capabilities. The foundation acts as a catalyst to support community initiatives and development projects. B) Employment and training – MWL employs approximately 900 local employees. MWL has introduced various training programs that are also available to the local community. A teacher has been employed to assist women with language education in French, English and Swahili. C) Community Health – MWL has joined with the Australian Government’s DAP program and the program has contributed funds to improve the available health care facilities present in the Dikulushi community clinic. D) Education – MWL has contributed funds towards the upgrade of the Dikulushi School, to enclose classrooms and provide classroom equipment and resources. This project benefits 1,100 local school students. E) Kilwa Electrification – this project is working with the Kilwa community to provide power to the hospital and surrounding buildings in the village. P a g e | 156 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 F) Kipeto Community garden project – This project is to assist the community to establish a vegetable nursery in the community. G) MWL is committed to supporting local business by sourcing certain supplies from local villages surrounding Dikulushi and the Kapulo projects. Figure 20.1 is an example of this commitment. Figure 20.1 Community Business making work clothes for the mine. P a g e | 157 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 21. CAPITAL AND OPERATING COSTS 21.1. CAPITAL COST ESTIMATE Capital expenditure for the underground mining operations is estimated at around US$9M. The bulk of the Capital expenditure for the project is focussed on the mining equipment related to the underground operations. All other capital for the processing plant, infrastructure and administration is already in place and ongoing from the Open pit cut back operations. The list of items included in capital expenditure cost is shown in Table 21.1. Due to the short time period that the Mineral Reserves will be mined over, it has been planned that any additional major mining equipment required will be obtained on a hire arrangement, with costs covered as part of the annual operating cost. This has provided a significant saving in the capital spend for the reestablishment of the underground operations. Additional capital savings have been achieved through the refurbishment of the previous underground mining fleet and this is to provide the bulk of the mining fleet required to mine the underground Mineral Reserves. Table 21.1 Dikulushi underground capital expenditure cost estimate. Item Refurbishment of mobile equipment 2 x UG Loader & 2 x Truck (new) UG dewatering system & bores Vehicles & ancillary units Ventilation fans UG compressors Safety equipment and systems Ancillary support equipment Total Expenditure US$ 000’s 1,109 3,362 2,570 560 400 150 590 865 9,606 The total composition of the mining fleet is shown in Table 21.2. The majority of this fleet is already located on-site and was used as part of the previous underground mining activities conducted by Anvil. It is expected that parts of the fleet will have low utilisations due to the small tonnages being produced from the underground mining operations, and this will provide ample coverage for breakdowns. The additional pieces of equipment required will provide the operation with the flexibility to increase mining rates as required. P a g e | 158 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Table 21.2 Major mining fleet and equipment required for the extraction of the Dikulushi underground Mineral Reserves Mining fleet LHD Truck Jumbo twin Jumbo single IT Charge up vehicle PC Ute Air leg drills Wire Line Scraper Number 2 3 2 1 1 1 1 2 6 1 The majority of the above capital is spent over the first 6 months of the project. 21.2. OPERATING COST ESTIMATE The underground mining operations at the Dikulushi project will be run under an owner operator model. MWL will provide all the equipment and personnel to complete the mining operations. For the purpose of estimating the operating costs, the costs have been broken up into mining variable costs and overhead/fixed costs. This approach has been chosen so that the costs that are directly involved with development and ore production from the underground, will vary with the advance of the physical mining operation and are separated from other costs such as labour, management and supervision that are generally fixed operating costs on a month by month basis. 21.2.1. MINING OPERATING COST Table 21.3 shows the fixed mining and processing costs associated with the Dikulushi underground operation. The costs included in this table were provided by MWL and are based upon cost estimates in financial modelling already completed to evaluate underground mining at the site. G&A costs are included in the Site Costs item, along with camp costs, OH&S, site wide power and water supply for the camp. Variable costs are listed in Table 21.4, including development, haulage backfill and rehabilitation. Capital development, vertical development and production development costs are all inclusive of jumbo drilling, blasting, loading, ground support and services, including all the equipment operating costs involved. Costs have been calculated on a lineal metre basis. Decline costs have been calculated assuming drive dimensions of 5.5 mH by 5.5 mW. Level access and return airway drives have been calculated using dimensions of 5.0 mH by 5.0 mW. Production access and ore drives assume dimensions of 5.0 mH by 4.5 mW. Vertical development rises assume dimensions of 1.5 mH by 1.5 mW for escape ways and 5m diameter for vent rises. P a g e | 159 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Haulage costs are inclusive of loading, hauling to the waste dump or mill, and equipment operating costs. Table 21.3 Mining overhead and fixed costs Mining overhead and fixed costs Units Rate (million) Mining Personnel $/yr $0.75 Workshop Personnel $/yr $0.33 Technical Support Roles $/yr $2.60 Fixed Plant Costs $/yr $0.66 Power Consumption $/yr $1.76 Table 21.4 Engineering, Geology, survey etc. Mining variable costs Mining variable costs Capital Development Decline Level access / Stock piles Return Air Way Drives Vertical Development Air leg Rises Escape way Vent Rise Production Development Cut and Fill Ramp Access Ore Drives / Cut and fill Haulage Ore Waste Backfill CRF CAF RF Rehabilitation Drive rehab 21.2.2. Comments Units Rate $/m $/m $/m 1,739 1,677 1,739 $/m $/m 83 568 $/m $/m 1,330 1,330 5.0mH by 4.5mW 5.0mH by 4.5mW $/tkm $/tkm 2.21 3.19 Loading and haulage to waste dump or mill – incl. equipment operating costs $/m 3 $/m 3 $/m 44.57 55.70 3.23 - $/m 814 3 Comments 5.5mH by 5.5mW 5.0mH by 5.0mW 5.0mH by 5.5mW 1.5mH by 1.5mW - including equipping 5.0m diameter, air leg pilot + airleg strip Assumes all ground support is replaced PROCESSING OPERATING COSTS A $55.00 per ore tonne processing cost has been applied to all tonnes processed from the underground mining operations. This was provided by Mawson West and represents the overhead and variable processing costs associated with the operation of the processing plant for the production of the copper concentrate. 21.2.3. MANAGEMENT AND ADMINISTRATION COSTS The management and administration costs are based on the existing cost structure of the current operations and includes management and administration personnel, OH&S costs, logistics costs, camp costs and sustaining capital required for non-production related activities. The total annual cost is estimated at $10.6M per year. P a g e | 160 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 21.2.4. TRANSPORT AND SMELTING COSTS Costs for the transport, as well as the treatment and refining charges for the copper and silver concentrates, along with the final net smelter returns have been sighted and used in calculations for the Mineral Reserves, but due to the commercial in confidence agreements with the smelters are not shown here. 21.3. METAL PRICES Financial modelling has used a copper price of US$6,800/t and a silver price of US$20/oz. Details are provided in Table 21.5. Table 21.5 Metal prices used in modelling Product Copper Sensitivity Low Sensitivity High Silver Sensitivity Low Sensitivity High Units $/t $/t $/t $/oz $/oz $/oz Rate 6,800 6,120 7,480 20 18 22 22. ECONOMIC ANALYSIS 22.1. OPERATIONS SUMMARY Table 22.1 below provides a summary of the mining and cashflow performance of the Project mine including the extraction of the Crown pillar ore. The total material mined from the underground operations is 221 kt of material of which 173 kt is ore at a diluted and recovered grade of 5.15% copper. The average mining cost $83 per total tonne and $106 per ore tonne. The processing cost is $55 per ore of tonne processed. Management and administration costs are $97 per tonne of ore processed. Due to the long history of mining operations at the Dikulushi project, capital expenditure is minimal as the site already has the processing and major infrastructure in place from previous open pit and underground mining activities. In addition to the facilities the majority of the mining equipment required for the underground operations exists on site. The total capital costs allowed for as part of the underground mining project is $9M. Sustaining capital for the operations has been included in the above capital cost. The mine life is 19 months with the majority of the ore mined in the first 12 months of the mining operation, and ore production reduces towards the end of the mine life, as the number of production ore headings available reduces. Processing, copper production and sales have been scheduled in the month of extraction for the purpose of this economic evaluation. The processing recovery for copper used for this estimate was 94%, with silver recovery at 90% to produce a copper concentrate grading approximately 60% copper. P a g e | 161 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 The total cash cost of the operation is $44.6M. A total of 8.1 Kt of copper is sold along with 573 Koz of silver to produce net revenue of $57.7M, and net cashflow of $3.0M. Due to the short life of the existing underground workings no discount rate has been applied to the revenues in Table 22.1 P a g e | 162 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Table 22.1 Dikulushi mining and financial summary Pre-mining Qtr 1 Qtr 2 Qtr 3 Qtr 4 Qtr 5 Qtr 6 Total Physical Schedule Total material mined Waste Mined tonnes tonnes 3,564 3,564 50,672 17,346 30,517 4,271 25,044 6,084 38,069 5,576 38,713 11,044 34,548 0 221,128 47,885 Ore Mined Copper mined grade Silver mined grade tonnes copper% silver g/t 0 0.00 0.0 33,327 5.08 142.7 26,246 4.97 102.9 18,961 6.16 126.9 32,493 5.78 151.1 27,669 4.38 94.3 34,548 4.83 133.7 173,243 5.15 127.0 Copper mined Silver mined t oz 0 0 1,693 152,913 1,304 86,871 1,168 77,338 1,877 157,804 1,212 83,929 1,667 148,518 8,921 707,373 $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 134,790 42,538 3,811 0 0 24,091 0 88,110 55,414 146,792 0 1,186,964 28,678 0 140,714 119,642 307,128 264,331 166,243 440,376 0 829,203 0 0 114,775 31,200 994,495 264,331 166,243 440,376 0 349,937 0 0 40,237 37,816 306,330 264,331 166,243 440,376 0 702,380 0 0 94,240 37,977 586,851 264,331 166,243 440,376 0 923,050 0 0 115,531 68,728 472,853 264,331 166,243 440,376 0 324,052 0 427,327 59,772 0 172,134 264,331 166,243 440,376 134,790 4,358,124 32,488 427,327 565,269 319,454 2,839,791 1,674,093 1,052,874 2,789,046 Technical Support $ Total Mining Opex $ 216,313 711,859 648,938 3,303,014 648,938 3,489,560 648,938 2,254,206 648,938 2,941,334 648,938 3,100,050 648,938 2,503,172 4,109,938 18,303,195 Costs Mining Decline Rehabilitation Jumbo development Airleg Development Longhole Stoping Ore Haulage Waste Haulage Backfill Mining & Workshop Labour Fixed Plant Power P a g e | 163 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Total Mining Opex $/ore tonne mined $/total tonne mined Pre-mining Qtr 1 Qtr 2 Qtr 3 Qtr 4 Qtr 5 Qtr 6 Total 0.00 199.72 99.11 65.18 132.95 114.35 118.89 90.01 90.52 77.26 112.04 80.08 72.45 72.45 105.65 82.77 0 0.00 1,832,958 55.00 1,443,546 55.00 1,042,835 55.00 1,787,108 55.00 1,521,768 55.00 1,900,139 55.00 9,528,355 55.0 883,333 0.00 2,650,000 79.52 2,650,000 100.97 2,650,000 139.76 2,650,000 81.56 2,650,000 95.78 2,650,000 76.70 16,783,333 96.88 7,378,442 7,271,818 7,053,311 44,614,883 Processing Processing $ $/ore tonne milled Management & Admin Administration $ $/ore tonne milled Total Operating Costs $ 1,595,192 7,785,972 7,583,106 5,947,041 Total Capital Costs Sustaining Capital $ $ 4,990,000 26,316 3,921,000 78,947 495,000 78,947 200,000 78,947 78,947 78,947 78,947 9,597,000 500,000 Metal in concentrate copper t silver oz 0 0 1,592 140,680 1,225 79,922 1,097 71,151 1,765 145,180 1,139 77,215 1,567 136,636 8,385 650,783 Metal sold copper t silver oz 0 0 1,537 124,309 1,184 70,157 1,060 62,448 1,705 128,109 1,101 67,845 1,514 120,705 8,100 573,573 Sales & Transport Costs $ 0 1,394,211 1,059,225 948,462 1,540,389 986,344 1,371,896 7,300,528 Duties and Taxes $ 0 297,711 223,249 199,859 327,811 208,192 292,751 1,549,574 Revenue P a g e | 164 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Copper NSR $ $/t mined Pre-mining 0 0 Qtr 1 10,454,484 206.31 Qtr 2 8,049,030 263.75 Qtr 3 7,208,970 287.85 Qtr 4 11,591,067 304.48 Qtr 5 7,484,181 193.33 Qtr 6 10,294,229 297.97 Total 55,081,959 0 0 2,486,180 49.06 1,403,131 45.98 1,248,965 49.87 2,562,176 67.30 1,356,902 35.05 2,414,105 69.88 11,471,459 0 0 0 11,546,452 297,711 11,248,741 8,392,935 223,249 8,169,686 7,509,473 199,859 7,309,614 12,612,854 327,811 12,285,043 7,854,738 208,192 7,646,546 11,336,438 292,751 11,043,687 59,252,891 1,549,574 57,703,317 Silver NSR $ $/oz mined Total Revenue Revenue from Sales $ Royalties/taxes $ Net Revenue $ Cashflow from Operations NPV $ -6,611,508 NPV -537,178 $2,982,434 12,632 8% 1,083,626 4,827,653 295,781 3,911,429 2,982,434 IRR P a g e | 165 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 22.1.1. SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS MWL has carried out a sensitivity analysis on the cash flow forecasts, and this is provided in Table 22.2. Table 22.2 Sensitivity analysis on the cash flow forecast for underground mining and treatment at Dikulushi Table Dikulushi Copper Project Project Sensitivity to a Change in copper Price NPV (US$ million) Change in copper Price -10% -5% 0% 5% 10% -9.8 0.7 3.0 5.7 8.4 Table Dikulushi Copper Project Project Sensitivity to a Change in Silver Price NPV (US$ million) Change in Silver Price -10% -5% 0% 5% 10% 1.8 2.4 3.0 3.6 4.1 Table Dikulushi Copper Project Project Sensitivity to a Change in Operating Costs NPV (US$ million) Change in Operating Costs -10% -5% 0% 5% 10% 7.4 5.2 3.0 0.8 -1.5 22.2. PAYBACK As discussed the refurbishment cost of the mill has already been covered by the revenues from the LG stockpile treatment and the previous open pit mining activities, thus there is no formal capital payback period. The development of the underground mining is to be fully funded out of MWL’s current existing cash reserves. The maximum negative cashflow (including capital costs) is -$1.7M (end of the pre-mining period) and cash flow moves back into positive territory during the third quarter of operation. P a g e | 166 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 22.3. MINE LIFE Mine life is based on the Probable mining Mineral Reserve schedule and is approximately 19 months. This allows a one month lead for rehabilitation of the existing underground workings, and the development of ventilation rises to establish primary ventilation along with one extra month at the end of the schedule, to complete ore backfilling operations. 22.4. TAXATION The Dikulushi mine operates under the Dikulushi Mining Convention, which provides for concessionary rates of taxation for each new mine. The first five years of production were tax free, the effective tax rate from the sixth through tenth years of production is 16% and for the eleventh through fifteenth years of production 18%, thereafter 40%. Dikulushi has been producing for approximately eleven years. In addition to the usual deductions of expenses and accruals, the Dikulushi Mining Convention provides that taxable income is adjusted by allowances for: depreciation of moveable and immoveable fixed assets, a “depletion allowance” equal to 15% of gross sales up to 50% of net profit, and all exploration and evaluation expenses. AMC also receives the benefit of concessionary import duty rates. During the construction phase, 2% import duties are applied and then during production import duties are applied at the rate of 3% for fuel, lubricants and mining consumables and 5% of all other supplies. P a g e | 167 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 23. ADJACENT PROPERTIES There are no significant mining properties adjacent to the Dikulushi Property. MWL’s Kapulo copper exploration and development project is also part of the Dikulushi Mining Convention that includes the Dikulushi Property. However, MWL considers the projects to be separate and non-contiguous. The Dikulushi Mining Convention applies to an area of approximately 7,300 km2 and the two projects are located 124 kilometres apart, are on distinctly separate leases, and are separated across this distance by Lake Mweru and the Luapula River. Road access to the Dikulushi Mine is from the DRC side of Lake Mweru, while road access to the Kapulo Project is from the Zambian side of Lake Mweru. There is only rudimentary road access between the two projects. Development of the Kapulo Project is not dependent on, and will not share infrastructure with, the Dikulushi Mine. Each of the projects will have their own separate mills, facilities, equipment and administration, and will conduct independent processing operations. A definitive feasibility study on the development of the Kapulo Project is the subject of a NI 43-101 technical report dated June 30, 2011 entitled “Kapulo Copper Project, DRC, National Instrument 43-101 Technical Report”. P a g e | 168 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 24. OTHER RELEVANT DATA AND INFORMATION Historically, Dikulushi was a producing open pit operation from 2002 until 2006. It continued for a period of time supplying ore from underground operations until closure in November 2008. The Dikulushi mine was acquired from Anvil by Mawson West Limited in April 2010 and work started immediately on refurbishment of the plant, which was completed in June 2010. Since June 2010, MWL has produced copper-silver concentrate from a feed of blended HMS tails and reclamation of the LG stockpile, as well as the successful mining and processing of the Open pit cut back. The next stage of the operations is to now re-establish the underground workings and re-commence underground production as outlined in this report. It is also MWL’s intention to continue exploration drilling of the Dikulushi orebody from accessible locations within the underground. P a g e | 169 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 25. INTERPRETATION AND CONCLUSIONS The Dikulushi Property is a producing and developing property. Current processing of the Dikulushi LG stockpile reserves and open pit cut back ore has provided MWL with a robust cash flow, and production results demonstrate reliable grades of remaining ore stocks when compared with Mineral Reserve estimates. The Dikulushi deposit has a history of exploration and successful mining. Data quality across the unmined volume of the deposit is of good quality and has representative sample values for reliable Mineral Resource estimates. Mineral Resource classification supports both Proven and Probable Reserve categories within the underground Project. The pre-feasibility study and resulting Mineral Reserves from the underground further extends MWL’s production life from the Dikulushi Project. MWL has an opportunity, with the re-establishment of the underground, to actively pursue exploration drilling from selected locations in the underground to be able to upgrade Inferred Mineral Resource material and extend the total Mineral Resource. MWL intends to continue processing the open pit cut back ROM material during the re-establishment and build up phase to production from the underground. MWL’s strategy is to continue to develop satellite deposits around Dikulushi, such as Kazumbula, in addition to extending the remaining Dikulushi Mineral Resources located below the underground. The recent exploration drilling at Kazumbula has provided geological and sample information to support a robust Mineral Resource estimate. Upon completion of the mine design, scheduling and financial analysis, the Kazumbula deposit is most likely to be of reasonable size and grade to be able to contribute feed to the Dikulushi plant. Additional satellite deposits within 50 km of Dikulushi are currently being drilled by MWL. P a g e | 170 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 26. RECOMMENDATIONS It is recommended that MWL continues with the planned underground Project. The key aspects for the success of the underground Project are the establishment and maintenance of sound underground mining practices, including a key focus on the drilling and blasting operations and the post blasting ground support regimes. The backfilling operations and the selected fill support method for the ground conditions, will require on-going attention and review, as well as close attention to the fill specifications as recommended. Ongoing test and study work is recommended on the investigation of using the tails dam material as underground paste fill. The initial prefeasibility tests showed positive results. With the recommencement of undergrounds operations, it is recommended that exploration drilling be continued from selected underground positions to test the orebody at depth and to assist with the re-classification of the remaining Mineral Resource up to the Indicated Category and thus Probable Reserves. Ongoing annual reviews are required for the environmental approvals and permitting and a key component is to ensure the integrity of the tailings dam continues to be maintained. The development of additional targets within the 50 km radius of Dikulushi has good synergies with the overall MWL strategy. P a g e | 171 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 27. REFERENCES DevMin Pty Ltd (Feb 2004): Anvil Mining Ltd “Dikulushi Copper-Silver Deposit, NI34-101 Technical Report. February 16, 2004. Franey, N., Hillbeck, M. and Fahey, G. (2006): Technical Report, Dikulushi Copper – Silver Deposit. February 21, 2006 JORC (2004): Australasian Code for Reporting of Mineral Resources and Ore Reserves, Effective December 2004. Prepared by the Joint Ore Reserves Committee of The Australasian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy, Australian Institute of Geoscientists and Minerals Council of Australia (JORC). National Instrument 43-101, Standards of Disclosure for Mineral Projects, Supplement to the OSC Bulletin, April 8, 2011 Form 43-101F1 Technical Report, Supplement to the OSC Bulletin, April 8, 2011 Munro, K.D. & Associates (1998): Dikulushi Copper-Silver Project. Geological Review and Mineral Resource Estimate for Dikulushi Copper-Silver Project. Lemmon, T., Boutwood, A., Turner, B., (2003) The Dikulushi copper-silver deposit, Katanga, DRC. In, Proterozoic Sediment-hosted base metal deposits of Western Gondwana, ed., J. Cailteux, Abstract of the IGCP 450 conference and field workshop, July 14-24. Lubumbashi, DRC. Dewaele, S., Muches, P., Heijlen, W., Lemmon, T., Boutwood, A., (in press), Reconstruction of the hydrothermal history of the CU-Ag vein-type mineralisation of Dikulushi, Kundelunga foreland, Katanga, DRC. Fahey,G.,Franey,N., Anvil Mining Limited Dikulushi Copper-Silver Mine Katanga Region Democratic Republic of Congo technical Report (NI43-101), December 22nd, 2006 Mawson West Ltd Pre-Feasibility study, July 2011 Independent Metallurgical Laboratories (IML): Metallurgical Ore Characterisation of Dikulushi Copper Ores for Anvil Mining NL, August 2003 Independent Metallurgical Laboratories (IML): Confirmatory Metallurgical Testwork on ROM Dikulushi Copper Ore for Anvil Mining NL, June 2004 Metallurgical Design and Management Pty Ltd; Dikulushi Copper Silver Project, Stage 2 Flotation Project Interim Metallurgical Rreport, July 11, 2003 F Chikosha, Dikulushi Copper Mine Tailings Disposal Facility TD3 Expansion Study, June 2011 A J Strauss, Dikulushi Copper Mine Tailings TD3 Volumetric Assessment, July 2010 M.Turner, Indpendent geotechnical consultant: Dikulushi north wall cable bolts 270711, July 2011 M.Turner, Indpendent geotechnical consultant: MHTurner Project stability 260711, July 2011. SRK Consulting: Project No: 436159 Water Balance for Dikulushi Mine – 2011 Update P a g e | 172 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 Mawson West, Dikulushi Underground Mining Study, June 2013 Peter Wade, Capital Mine Consulting; Dikulushi Mining Operating Cost Review, June 2013 M.Turner, Dikulushi Underground Re-opening Geotechnical Study Report No. 0713, August 2013. J.Keogh, Dikulushi Underground Underhanded Cut & Fill Cemented Rockfill Preliminary Design Technical Note 13032, August 2013 P a g e | 173 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 28. CERTIFICATES OPTIRO PTY LTD CERTIFICATE OF QUALIFIED PERSON – ANDREW LAW As the lead author and a Qualified Person of the report entitled “Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project, Democratic Republic of Congo” (the Study) dated 12 December 2013, on the Underground Project of Mawson West Limited, I hereby state: 1. My name is Andrew Law and I am a full time employee of the firm Optiro Pty Ltd of Level 4, 50 Colin Street, West Perth, WA, 6005, Australia. 2. I am a practising Mining Engineer and a Fellow of the AusIMM (107318), also a Fellow of the Institute of Quarrying Australia (991004), and a Member of the Australian Institute of Company Directors (0044149). 3. I am a graduate of the Witwatersrand Technikon, Johannesburg, South Africa, with a HND Metalliferous Mining, in 1982. 4. I have practiced my profession continuously since 1983. 5. I am an “independent” and “qualified person” as the terms are defined in National Instrument 43-101 (Standards of Disclosure for Mineral Projects) (the “Instrument”). 6. I have performed consulting services and reviewed files and data associated with the Dikulushi Project from August 2011 to the present. 7. I visited the Dikulushi Project property and the underground as far as the 850Mrl (est water level) in February 2012. I have performed consulting services and reviewed files and data associated with Dikulushi between August 2011 and the present time 8. Based on the information provided by Mawson West Ltd and reviewed by myself, I contributed to Sections 1,4,5,6,15, 16, 19, 20, 21, 22, 24, 25, and 26. 9. As of December 12, 2013, the effective date of the Study, to the best of my knowledge, information and belief, the Study contains all scientific and technical information that is required to be disclosed to make the Study not misleading. 10. I have read the National Instrument and Form 43-101F1 (the “Form”) and the Study has been prepared in compliance with the Instrument and the Form. 11. I do not have nor do I expect to receive a direct or indirect interest in the Dikulushi property of Mawson West Ltd, and I do not beneficially own, directly or indirectly, any securities of Mawson West Ltd or any associate or affiliate of such company. Dated at Perth, Western Australia, on the 20 December 2013. Andrew Law FAusIMM Director - Mining (Optiro Pty Ltd) P a g e | 174 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 OPTIRO PTY LTD CERTIFICATE OF QUALIFIED PERSON – IAN GLACKEN. As one of the authors of the report entitled “Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project, Democratic Republic of Congo” (the Study) dated 12 December 2013, on the Underground Project of Mawson West Limited, I hereby state: 1. My name is Ian Glacken and I am a full-time employee of the firm Optiro Pty Ltd of Level 4, 50 Colin Street, West Perth, WA, 6005, Australia. 2. I am a practising geologist and a Fellow of the AusIMM (107194) and a Chartered Professional Geologist. I am also a Member of the Institution of Metals Mining and Materials (IMMM, 46394) and a Chartered Engineer of this Institution. 3. I am a graduate of Durham University in the United Kingdom with a BSc (Hons) in Geology in 1979, the Royal School of Mines in the United Kingdom with MSc in Mineral Exploration in 1981 and Stanford University in the USA with an MSc in Geostatistics in 1996. 4. I have practiced my profession continuously since 1981. 5. I am an “Independent” and “qualified person” as the terms are defined in National Instrument 43-101 (Standards of Disclosure for Mineral Projects) (the “Instrument”). 6. I have not visited the Dikulushi Project property. I have performed consulting services and reviewed files and data associated with the Dikulushi and Kazumbula Projects between May 2009 and the present. 7. I take responsibility for Sections 1 (in part), 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 14 of the Study and have contributed to Sections 17.1 and 17.3 and the associated text in the summary, conclusions and recommendations. 8. As of December 12, 2013, the effective date of the Study, to the best of my knowledge, information and belief, the Study contains all scientific and technical information that is required to be disclosed to make the Study not misleading. 9. I am independent of Mawson West Ltd pursuant to section 1.4 of the Instrument. 10. I have read the National Instrument and Form 43-101F1 (the “Form”) and the Study has been prepared in compliance with the Instrument and the Form. 11. I do not have nor do I expect to receive a direct or indirect interest in the Dikulushi property of Mawson West Ltd, and I do not beneficially own, directly or indirectly, any securities of Mawson West Ltd or any associate or affiliate of such company. Dated at Perth, Western Australia, on the 20 December, 2013. Ian Glacken BSc (Hons) (Geology), FAusIMM(CP), MIMMM, CEng Principal Consultant (Optiro Pty Ltd) P a g e | 175 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 TURNER MINING AND GEOTECHNICAL PTY LTD CERTIFICATE OF QUALIFIED PERSON – MIKE TURNER As one of the authors of the report entitled “Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project, Democratic Republic of Congo” (the Study) dated 12 December 2013, on the Underground Project of Mawson West Limited, I hereby state: 1. My name is Mike Turner and I am a full-time employee of Turner Mining and Geotechnical Pty Ltd of 3B Valley Road, Wembley Downs, WA, 6019, Australia. 2. I am a practising geotechnical and mining engineer and a Chartered Professional Fellow of the AUSIMM (205399). 3. I am a graduate of Imperial College, London University with a BSc (Eng) (Hons) in Mining in 1979. I also obtained a Master of Science in Mineral Production Management at the Royal School of Miners in 1984 and a Chamber of Mines Certificate in Rock Mechanics in South Africa in 1987. 4. I have practiced my profession continuously since 1979, apart from a 12 month period from 1983/1984 during which I completed the MSc course at Imperial College. 5. I am an “Independent” and “qualified person” as the terms are defined in National Instrument 43-101 (Standards of Disclosure for Mineral Projects) (the “Instrument”). 6. I visited the Dikulushi Project from 10th to 13th December 2012, the most recent visit prior to completion of the Study. I have performed consulting services and reviewed files and data associated with Dikulushi between July 2003 and the present. 7. I am responsible for the geotechnical section in Section 16. 8. As of December 12, 2013, the effective date of the Study, to the best of my knowledge, information and belief, the Study contains all scientific and technical information that is required to be disclosed to make the Study not misleading. 9. I am independent of Mawson West Ltd pursuant to section 1.4 of the Instrument. 10. I have read the National Instrument and Form 43-101F1 (the “Form”) and the Study has been prepared in compliance with the Instrument and the Form. 11. I do not have nor do I expect to receive a direct or indirect interest in the Dikulushi property of Mawson West Ltd, and I do not beneficially own, directly or indirectly, any securities of Mawson West Ltd or any associate or affiliate of such company. Dated at Perth, Western Australia, on 20 December 2013 Michael Harry Turner, MSC, DIC, BSc (Eng) (Hons) (Mining), ARSM, FAusIMM (CP), RPEQ Director, Turner Mining and Geotechnical Pty Ltd P a g e | 176 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 KNIGHT PIESOLD CERTIFICATE OF QUALIFIED PERSON – DUNCAN JOHN GRANT-STUART As a reviewer of the report entitled “Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project, Democratic Republic of Congo” (the Study) dated 12 December 2013, on the Underground Project of Mawson West Limited, I hereby state: 1. My name is Duncan John Grant-Stuart and I am a full time Engineer with the firm of Knight Piesold (Pty) Limited of PO Box 221, Rivonia, 2128, South Africa. 2. I am a practising Civil Engineer and member of the Institution of Civil Engineers (UK)(MICE) and am registered with the Engineering Council (UK) (C.Eng) and the Engineering Council of South Africa (PR.Eng). 3. I am a graduate of the University of the Witwatersrand with a BSC (Eng) degree completed in 1976. 4. I have practiced my profession continuously since 1976. 5. I am an “Independent” and “qualified person” as the terms are defined in National Instrument 43101 (Standards of Disclosure for Mineral Projects) (the “Instrument”). 6. I visited the Dikulushi Project property. I have performed consulting services and reviewed files and data supplied by Mawson West Ltd in 2011. 7. I reviewed Section 17 of the Study, as well as the associated text in the summary, conclusions and recommendations. 8. I am responsible for the geotechnical section and the associated text in the summary conclusions and recommendations. 9. I am not aware of any limitations imposed upon my access to persons, information, data or documents that I consider relevant to the subject matter of the study. 10. I am not aware as at 12 December 2013, the effective date of the Study, of any material fact or material change with respect to the subject matter of the Study, which is not reflected in the Study, the omission of which would make the Study misleading. 11. I am independent of Mawson West Ltd and AMC SARL pursuant to section 1.4 of the Instrument. 12. I have read the National Instrument and Form 43-101F1 (the “Form”) and the Study has been prepared in compliance with the Instrument and the Form. 13. I do not have nor do I expect to receive a direct or indirect interest in the Dikulushi property of Mawson West Ltd, and I do not beneficially own, directly or indirectly, any securities of Mawson West Ltd or any associate or affiliate of such company. Dated at Rivonia, South Africa, on 20 December 2013 Duncan John Grant-Stuart PR Eng 900014 C.Eng Technical Consultant P a g e | 177 Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project Democratic Republic of Congo – 12 December 2013 SEDGMAN SEDGMAN CERTIFICATE OF QUALIFIED PERSON – PETER HAYWARD As one of the authors of the report entitled “Technical Report on the Dikulushi Underground Project, Democratic Republic of Congo” (the Study) dated 12 December 2013, on the Underground Project of Mawson West Limited, I hereby state: 1. My name is Peter George Hayward and I am Senior Process Engineer with the firm Sedgman Limited, Suite 3, 3 Craig Street, Burswood, 6100. 2. I am a practicing Metallurgist and a Fellow of the Australian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy. 3. I am a graduate of the Ballarat Institute of Advanced Engineering and hold a Diploma of Metallurgy. 4. I have practiced my profession continuously since February 1974. 5. I am an “Independent” and “qualified person” as the terms are defined in National Instrument 43-101 (Standards of Disclosure for Mineral Projects) (the “Instrument”). 6. I have personally visited the Dikulushi property in February 2012. I have reviewed files and data supplied by Mawson West Ltd in September 2011 and in January 2013. 7. I have contributed to the Sections 13 and 17. 8. I am not aware of any limitations imposed upon my access to persons, information, data or documents that I consider relevant to the subject matter for the Study (apart from as indicated in the text). 9. I am not aware as at 12 December 2013, the effective date of the Study, of any material fact or material change with respect to the subject matter of the Study, which is not reflected in the Study, the omission of which would make the Study misleading. 10. I am independent of Mawson West Ltd pursuant to section 1.4 of the Instrument. 11. I have read the National Instrument and Form 43-101F1 (the “Form”) and the Study has been prepared in compliance with the Instrument and the Form. 12. I do not have nor do I expect to receive a direct or indirect interest in the Dikulushi property of Mawson West Ltd, and I do not beneficially own, directly or indirectly, any securities of Mawson West Ltd or any associate or affiliate of such company. Dated at Perth, Western Australia, on 20 December 2013 Peter Hayward P a g e | 178