dPMR™ Association dPMR Association
Transcription
dPMR™ Association dPMR Association
dPMR TM Association CommsConnect 2013 Information Handout Melbourne, Australia November 21~22, 2013 Contents: 1) dPMRTM 2) dPMRTM 3) dPMRTM 4) dPMRTM Association Product Showcase Introduction Presentation FAQ Whitepaper CC Info Handout | Copyright 2013 dPMR Association – All Rights Reserved dPMR™ Association: Product Showcase This is a brief introduction and overview to the current products and services provided by various members of the dPMR™ Association. The dPMR™ Association is currently a group of 17 member companies (as of November, 2013) from a diverse range of backgrounds in the PMR two-way radio industry. dPMR™ is recognized as one of three Business and Industry digital two-way radio protocols available now. This Product Showcase will outline what is available now, and what can be expected to become available in the near future. The products and services outlined here are done so with the permission of the member companies of the dPMR™ Association. We encourage you to visit the websites or directly contact the member company to obtain more details about the content explained here. dPMR™: It is a technology growing within the market day by day, and offers the most comprehensive scope (from license-free to the ability of providing nationwide networks) and scalability of the digital two-way protocols currently available outside of the public safety market. dPMR® Association Product Showcase | Copyright 2013 dPMR® Association – All Rights Reserved dPMR® Association Product Showcase | Copyright 2013 dPMR® Association – All Rights Reserved 2 Aeroflex Incorporated Test and measurement equipment dPMR™ Product/Service: 3920 Digital Radio Test Set Product Description: The latest software upgrade for the 3920 Digital Radio Test Set extends the versatility of the instrument for new digital PMR technologies. The dPMR™ standard has also been enhanced with new analog FM tests, allowing faster testing of this radio system. The all-new digital architecture of the 3920 not only delivers faster, more accurate measurements, thereby lowering the cost of test when compared to any of its contemporaries and predecessors, but also ensures that future market needs can be met in a timely fashion. The future of professional mobile radio is changing rapidly as technology advances and market needs expand and the 3920 is a platform that will stand the test of time. dPMR™ Product/Service: 3920 Digital Radio Test Set Product Description: The 3550 is the first truly portable touch-screen radio communication test system. The 3550 takes radio and repeater site testing to the next level with a quantum leap in an easy to use, integrated test system for complete radio receiver and transmitter performance testing, cable fault and antenna system analysis. With its ultra-responsive capacitive touch screen, the 3550 brings a whole new experience to RF testing Further Details: 3920: http://www.aeroflex.com/ats/products/product/Communications_Test/Radio_Test_Sets__PMR_Test/TETRA_Test/3920_Radio_Test_Set~171 3550: http://www.aeroflex.com/ats/products/product/Communications_Test/Radio_Test_Sets__PMR_Test/3550_Radio_Test_Set~816.html dPMR® Association Product Showcase | Copyright 2013 dPMR® Association – All Rights Reserved 3 CML Microcircuits Semiconductor Solutions dPMR™ Product/Service: CMX7141 multi-mode digital PMR/LMR processor chip Product Description: CML's CMX7141 Digital PMR (dPMR) Processor IC is ideally placed to meet the specific requirements of both new and emerging digital PMR radio systems and dual-mode digital/analogue two-way radio platforms. The CMX7141 digital PMR/LMR chip is an enabler for the radio platform concept. Incorporating functionality to support the RF transceiver side it only requires minimal control from the host microcontroller. Built on CML’s proprietary FirmASICョ technology the CMX7141 encompasses the elements required for the implementation of a digital radio air interface physical and data link layers. The vocoder is also completely managed and controlled by the CMX7141 enabling a small, low power host microcontroller to be utilised for overall radio operation. Further Details: http://www.cmlmicro.com/products/CMX7131_CMX7141_Digital_PMR_Processors/ dPMR® Association Product Showcase | Copyright 2013 dPMR® Association – All Rights Reserved 4 Etherstack Ltd. Protocol Stacks dPMR™ Product/Service: dPMR™ Mobile and Base Station Protocol Stack Product Description: This highly portable stack is available in two variants, Mobile Stack (MS) and Basestation Stack (BS). Written in highly portable ANSI C, the stack can be readily hosted on a wide range of popular microprocessors and DSPs. The dPMR stack provides a complete implementation including the PHY (physical layer) in software. The stack is available with Etherstack's ELITE automated test suite tools - to assist the manufacturer with integration, testing and maintenance of the implementation during the lifecycle of the product. Further Details: http://www.etherstack.com/jp/pdf/dmr.pdf dPMR® Association Product Showcase | Copyright 2013 dPMR® Association – All Rights Reserved 5 Fylde Micro Ltd. Infrastructure Manufacturer dPMR™ Product/Service: dPMR™ Mode 3 Controller Product Description: MultiLingo is the next generation Fylde trunking controller. This, our 4th generation controller, will support MPT1327, dPMR (other digital protocols as required) and conventional systems. More than that, MultiLingo has been designed to support these protocols within the same radio site. This allows customers to select their protocol of choice as and when they are ready. Fylde has partnered with Icom Inc. to provide the world’s first dPMRTM Mode 3 trunking systems. This partnership brings together the pioneering work undertaken by Icom in 6.25 kHz narrow band digital protocol development withthe unrivalled experience amassed by Fylde in the development of ruged and reliable trunked radio systems over the last 25 years. Further Details: http://fyldemicro.com/Fylde-Micro-Multi-Lingo-Controller.htm dPMR® Association Product Showcase | Copyright 2013 dPMR® Association – All Rights Reserved 6 Icom Incorporated Radio/Infrastructure Manufacturer dPMR™ Product/Service: All tiers and modes of dPMR™ equipment Product Description: Icom is proud to be the first manufacturer to supply dPMR446 license-free products, Tier 2 Mode 1 and 2 products to the market, as well as Mode 3 products in collaboration with Fylde Micro Ltd. The IDASTM suite of radios (portable and mobile), repeaters, IP networking cards and virtual radio/dispatch applications is a field proven reliable platform that has seen deployment in the 100,000’s of thousands worldwide. The dPMRTM variants of IDASTM are also deployed worldwide and are creating a solid reputation as a reliable digital solution in many market segments. The market’s anticiaption and expectations for Mode 3 are also very high, and Icom looks forward to providing further communications solutions to meet the varying needs of system operators both large and small. Further Details: http://www.icom.co.jp/world/idas/dpmr/ dPMR® Association Product Showcase | Copyright 2013 dPMR® Association – All Rights Reserved 7 JVC Kenwood Corporation Radio/Infrastructure Manufacturer dPMR™ Product/Service: Mode 2 dPMR™ equipment Product Description: Kenwood NEXEDGE® mid tier hand portable, mobile radios and repeaters can be adapted to operate as dPMR units meeting with ETSI Standards TS 102 658 Modes 1 & 2. Kenwood NEXEDGE® dPMR equipment offers many of the features and benefits of NEXEDGE® including outstanding voice quality, extended range, spectrum efficiency and increased security, in an open standard, ETSI compliant multi-vendor format. In addition NEXEDGE® dPMR capabilities can be further extended to include multiple user groups by employing the following repeaters: EU: NXR-710E, NXR-810E / Non-EU: NXR-710K, NXR-810K2 Further Details: http://www.kenwoodcommunications.co.uk/nexedge-dpmr/ dPMR® Association Product Showcase | Copyright 2013 dPMR® Association – All Rights Reserved 8 Sicomm Communications Baseband and RF PA chips dPMR™ Product/Service: SCT3252 Digital Radio Baseband Signal Processor Product Description: The SCT3252 is a highly integrated digital radio baseband signal processor designed by Sicomm. Its features include: Specialized Digital Radio IC: 4FSK Modem Multiple Vocoders Multiple Protocols Embedded large capacity FLASH/SRAM High performance, low power consumption Analog compatible・auto switch Embedded firmware Package 14x14mm LQFP100 It supports the following standards: dPMR™ (TS102490) with firmware upgrade to support Europe dPMR™ (TS102658) NXDN™ DCR (ARIB standard for Japan) A recent new Chinese standard Further Details: http://www.sicommtech.com/product.html dPMR® Association Product Showcase | Copyright 2013 dPMR® Association – All Rights Reserved 9 Wireless Pacific Applications/Solutions Provider dPMR™ Product/Service: PDX3522 Onsite Repeater Product Description: Wireless Pacific’s PDX3522™ onsite repeater is designed to provide a simple, yet fully selfcontained, digital or analog, single channel, radio repeater system. The PDX can be ordered as a standard repeater for digital: 6.25 kHz dPMR™ (NXDN™) or, 12.5/25kHz analog operation. With rugged waterproof construction, internal battery for power backup and compact design, the PDX3522™ is a flexible solution when instant communications are required in the field. Further Details: To be added dPMR® Association Product Showcase | Copyright 2013 dPMR® Association – All Rights Reserved 10 DISCLAIMER This document has been prepared by the dPMR™ Association as a reference document. The information in this document has been carefully checked, and is believed to be correct and accurate. However, the dPMR™ Association assumes no responsibility for inaccuracies or mistakes. Document Revisions The dPMR™ Association reserves the right to make changes to the content of this document at any time without notice or obligation. Document Copyrights No duplication or distribution of this document or any portion thereof shall take place without the express permission of the dPMR™ Association. Reproduction, distribution, or transmission for any purpose in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, shall only be allowed with the express permission of the dPMR™ Association. Trademarks dPMR and the dPMR logo are registered trademarks of the dPMR Association in Europe, the United States, Japan, China and/or other countries. All other products or brands are registered trademarks or trademarks of their respective holders. dPMR® Association Product Showcase | Copyright 2013 dPMR® Association – All Rights Reserved 11 dPMR™ Introduction November, o e be , 2013 0 3 Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. What is dPMR™? CONFUSED? Capacity Plus MOTOTRBO™ Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. What is dPMR™? An Introduction −An open ETSI technical standard Tier 1: TS 102 490 dPMR446 License-free Tier 2: TS 102 658 Licensed conventional/Trunked −Narrowband digital protocol/6.25kHz FDMA technology Low complexity complexity, low cost and spectrum efficient A digital alternative for analogue FDMA systems −Encourages g a Multi-vendor environment Radio products from 11 manufacturers to date Test equipment, silicon chips and protocol stacks −Interoperability I t bilit Supported by ETSI IOP/Conformance standards Established IOP test process within dPMR™ Association Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. What is dPMR™? Tier 1 Tier 2 (TS 102 490) (TS 102 658) dPMR446 M d 1 Mode License-free Licensed peer to peer Mode 2 Licensed Repeater Mode Mode 3 Licensed single site trunking Licensed multisite trunking Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. IOP Tests (TS 102 587 Parts 1 1-6) 6) IOP/Conformance Test Procedures for dPMR™ (TS 102 726 Parts 1-3) PICS (Protocol Implementation Conformance) (TS 102 795 Part 1) dPMR™ Requirements Catalogue What is dPMR™? dPMR™ Mode 1 Conventional peer to peer operation Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. What is dPMR™? dPMR™ Mode 2 Conventional communication via repeater and/or IP linked sites Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. What is dPMR™? dPMR™ Mode 3 Full single and/or multi-site multi site wide area trunking networks Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. The Basic Technology −General specifications: Access Method Transmission Rate Modulation Vocoder d Codec Rate Channel Spacing O Occupied i d bandwidth b d idth Applicable bands : FDMA : 4800 bps : 4-level FSK : AMBE+2™ : 3600 (Voice 2,450 + Error Correction 1,150 bps) : 6.25kHz : 4kH 4kHz : 30MHz to 1 GHz Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. What is good about dPMR™? Advantages g −The use of FDMA technology provides a “low complex, low cost” development platform Basic design technology maintained from analogue FM Low complexity does not mean simple capability. dPMR™ can be scalable from 1 repeater to a 1000 site system −Two-way radio fundamentals “built-in” Peer to peer standard (No “reinvention of the wheel”) No reduction in coverage g vs analogue g FM Technical advantages in analogue apply equally to digital −A like for like natural transition from analogue to digital S t System d design i fundamentals f d t l do d nott change h Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. What is good about dPMR™? Advantages −Flexibility in vocoder choice AMBE+2™ agreed on as standard vocoder for Tier 2 dPMR™ Tier 1 dPMR446 allows a choice of AMBE+2™ (standard), RALCWI or other yet to be defined choices −dPMR™ is spectrum efficient −dPMR True 6.25kHz channels, no “equivalent” caveats needed Will be a viable technology when 12.5kHz spectrum is full Future proofed investment for the near and mid-term mid term −No known IPR applicable to the dPMR™ standards Current IPR claims not substantiated No added costs resulting from IPR licenses or royalties Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. dPMR™ Features Note 1: List below is a general guide of available features Note 2: Implementation of features may differ between manufacturers Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. dPMR™ Features Note 1: List below is a general guide of available features Note 2: Implementation of features may differ between manufacturers Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. dPMR™ Features Note 1: List below is a general guide of available features Note 2: Implementation of features may differ between manufacturers Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. dPMR™ Features Note 1: List below is a general guide of available features Note 2: Implementation of features may differ between manufacturers Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. dPMR™ Features Note 1: List below is a general guide of available features Note 2: Implementation of features may differ between manufacturers Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. dPMR™ and other technologies NXDN™ Licensed peer to peer (12.5kHz/6.25kHz (12 5kHz/6 25kHz FDMA) Tier 1 (TS 102 490) Tier 1 (TS 102 361) License free digital PMR446 (12.5kHz FDMA) Tier 2 (TS 102 658) Licensed Repeater Mode (12.5kHz/6.25kHz (12 5kHz/6 25kHz FDMA) dPMR446 License-free Tier 2 (TS 102 361) Licensed peer to peer Licensed Repeater Mode (12.5kHz/2 slot TDMA) Mode 1 Licensed peer to peer Type-C NXDN™ Trunking yp g (Control Channel Type trunking) Licensed single site trunking Licensed multisite trunking Mode 2 Licensed Repeater Mode (12.5kHz/6.25kHz FDMA) Mode 3 Licensed single site trunking Licensed multisite trunking Type-D NXDN™ Trunking (No Control Channel Type trunking) Licensed single site trunking Licensed multisite trunking (6.25kHz FDMA) Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. Tier 3 (TS 102 361) Licensed single site trunking Licensed multisite trunking g (12.5kHz/2 slot TDMA) FDMA or TDMA? TDMA FDMA Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. FDMA or TDMA? The Facts −FDMA is still the most common two-way radio technology (65% of estimated 40 million radios in use) −Thus FDMA in both analogue and digital still consist the majority of nearly all radio manufactures’ revenue −The fallback mode for a TDMA system has typically been analogue FDMA, so FDMA is still a savior of last resort −TDMA claims battery life improvement over analogue. In reality, y, there is no distinct advantage g versus digital g FDMA (Most manufacturers guarantee 12~20 hours operating time) −More FDMA based digital standards are in use than f for TDMA at this hi time. i F For example,,, l Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. FDMA or TDMA? FDMA Digital Protocols Japanese Domestic 6.25kHz FDMA standards TDMA Digital Protocols dPMR™ DMR NXDN™ PDT Chinese Domestic 12.5kHz TDMA standard ARIB T-98 ARIB T-102 APCO P25 Ph.I Tetrapol APCO P25 Ph.II TETRA Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. FDMA or TDMA? The comparisons could continue with,,, The conclusion that dPMR™ provides: •All the fundamental requirements of a radio system •Is Is a technology backed up by decades of technical knowhow both in radio development and system design •Any known weaknesses, and thus improvements made in analogue FM are directly inherited by dPMR™ TDMA (DMR), while a viable alternative: •Still lacks the total proven history of FDMA technology •Has not proven the “potential interference issues” of 6.25kHz FDMA exist as originally claimed •Does Does not yet have a solution beyond 12.5kHz channel spacing •Claimed feature advantages often not even implemented by the TDMA (DMR) manufacturers (e.g. full-duplex) Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. FDMA or TDMA? The market will continue to evolve and adopt solutions that work best The market is and will continue to accommodate FDMA and TDMA digital solutions in all their flavours Customer’s p perceived value will define where the future lies And dPMR™ is one of those choices Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. The dPMR™ Association Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. The dPMR™ Association −Founded in 2007 Many members involved in the “DIIS Project” even before dPMR™/DMR work began −Currently 17 member companies Support a broad range of core competences in the industry −Established to follow up p TG-DMR dPMR™ standards work Direct liaison with TG-DMR and ETSI where required −Mandated the standard vocoder (AMBE+2™) Flexibility of alternative vocoders allowed for Tier 1 dPMR446 −Promote dPMR™ and a Multi-vendor environment −Create and support interoperability testing regime Three successful IOP sessions completed to date −Obtain/register Obt i / i t trademarks t d k for f dPMR™ Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. The dPMR™ Association Structure of the Association dPMR™ Association dPMR CHAIRMAN dPMR™ Association dPMR SECRETARY Technical WG Marketing WG (Chairman + Members) (Chairman + Members) TG-DMR dPMR™ Association MEMBERS Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. The dPMR™ Association Current Members More details at: http://www.dpmr-mou.org/ Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. Member’s Core Competences Radio/Infrastructure Manufacturers Protocol Stacks Semiconductor Solutions Application Solutions Test Sets Standards Administration/ IOP Testing Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. Interoperability Testing dPMR™ Compatible Manufacturer A dPMR™ Compatible Manufacturer B Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. Interoperability Testing How is it done? Step 1: IOP test t t session i announced Candidates C did t apply l to participate Candidates supply: •EN300 166 compliance proof •Completed PICS document •Applicable test profiles IOP test t t plan l drawn up IOP test carried out under Tech WG supervision Step 2: IOP test log file published IOP test report published & issued IOP test certificate published bli h d & issued i d Step 3: More details at: http://www.dpmrmou.org/Interoperability.htm Certified equipment list updated Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. IOP test t t session i confirmed Interoperability Testing IOP Test Events Held regularly under the guidance of the Technical WG 2nd IOP Test Event Wuxi, China 2012 3rd IOP Test Event Yokohama, Japan 2013 Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. Interoperability Testing Current IOP Results (As of April 2013) IOP Tested Product/Service dPMR446 dPMR™ Mode 1 dPMR™ Mode 2 dPMR™ Mode 3 Icom Incorporated p Terminals & Infrastructure YES YES YES --- Maldon, UK 2011 Wuxi,, China 2012 Yokohama, Japan 2013 JVC Kenwood Corporation Terminals & Infrastructure --- YES YES --- Yokohama, Japan 2013 CML Microcircuits p Baseband chip YES YES YES --- Maldon,, UK 2011 Sicomm Technologies Baseband chip --- YES YES --- Maldon, UK 2011 Wuxi, China 2012 Kirisun Terminals --- YES YES --- Yokohama, Japan 2013 Tianjin 712 Communication Ltd. Terminals --- YES YES --- Wuxi, China 2012 Quanzhou Feijie Electronics Co., Ltd Terminals --- YES YES --- Wuxi, China 2012 Xiamen Puxing Electronics Science & Technology Co., Ltd T Terminals i l --- YES YES --- W i China Wuxi, Chi 2012 Fujian Nanan Quansheng Electronics Co., Ltd Terminals --- YES YES --- Wuxi, China 2012 Quanzhou Xinwei Electronics Co., Ltd Terminals --- YES YES --- Wuxi, China 2012 Fujian Wanhua Electronic Technology Co., Ltd Terminals --- YES YES --- Wuxi, China 2012 Company Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. IOP Test Event dPMR™ in the Market Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. dPMR™ in the Market Market Segment/Tier High tier High-tier Public Safety/ Professional Vertical Markets Emergency g y Services/Police/Military Professional Utilities (Airports etc.)/Government/Private Systems Mid-high tier B&I/Light C i l Commercial Transportation/Local Govt./Utilities/Large Industry (Manufacturing ( g etc.)/ )/ Small-mid sized Systems/Security Low-tier B&I/ License-free Construction/Security/Retail/ / y/ / Hotels/Restaurants/Warehouses/ Theme Parks/Private Security/ Rental Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. Technology APCO P25/Tetra, but dPMR™ does suit certain user needs dPMR™ main target markets Analogue dPMR™ in the Market Examples of Actual dPMR dPMR™ Users − French prisons − Belgian prisons − United U i d Nations-Geneva N i G (UNHCR HQ HQ, Pl Place d de N Nations, i WIPO WIPO, Human H Rights) Ri h ) − UN installed systems in South Sudan and Afghanistan − ITU HQ-Geneva − French F h Red R d Cross C − French Presidential guard services − French Ministry of Defense/French Home Office − City of Cannes − DANONE and LEGRAND − Russian regional Police − European Diplomatic service armored vehicles − Docklands Light Railway in London − Sharjarh Airport (UAE) Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. Migration Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. Migration The Basic Migration Alternatives: −“Big Bang” Migration Throw away the existing system and completely start anew Obvious cost and system down time risk considerations need to be analyzed −Infrastructure migration g Initially replace older infrastructure with digital infrastructure Allows an orderly switchover of the system with no down time Can set up p and monitor IP links and RF coverage g for maximum smoothness of the eventual transition to digital mode −Infrastructure/Terminals mixed migration Replace R l sites it and d radios di as required i d Mixed analogue/digital mode terminals allow continuous communications with existing radios Advantages in cost outlays and system planning requirements Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. Migration The dPMR™ Advantage: −FDMA offers a like for like migration Use of existing site equipment possible RF propagation and coverage characteristics would be similar to analogue FM −Cross p protocol communications Some dPMR™ solutions offer the ability to call between dPMR™ and MPT radios for example This reduces the need and cost of running g two p parallel systems Radio users can continue to call analogue or digital radios without any change in learned operation −Natural system integrity Failsafe peer to peer if system fails Only one channel lost if repeater fails Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. In Summary dPMR™ is: −An open standard backed by a world standards body −A A continuously evolving standard −Supported by multiple leading industry players −Supported via a dedicated industry group −A multi-vendor selection of products/services p / −Has a legitimate interoperability qualification system −Spectrum efficient −Used in the field with proven success −A viable solution beyond 12.5kHz channel spacing Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. Trademarks: •dPMR and the dPMR logo g are registered g trademarks of the dPMR MoU Association •NXDN is a trademark of Icom Incorporated and JVC KENWOOD Corporation •All other logos and/or trademarks are the properties of their respective owners •Images used with the permission of dPMR MoU Association members Copyright 2013 dPMR™ Association. FAQ about Narrowband Technologies This is an information paper regarding the latest information about the respective narrowband two-way radio technologies in the market at present. It is intended to present a neutral and balanced view of the respective technologies, and also correct misrepresentations and misunderstandings seen in various media publications of presentation materials in circulation in the public domain. This document has been prepared by the dPMR™ Association Marketing Group with the full consensus and approval of the member companies. The dPMR™ Association hopes this document will provide clarification to the myriad of information currently available. The dPMR™ Association has checked the content for accuracy but reserves the right to amend and/or correct any part of this document without notice or obligation. *************************************************************************** Q1: What does “narrowband” really mean? A1: This should probably be clarified before anything else. To keep things simple, narrowband in its current form would refer to the use of 12.5 kHz channels for two-way PMR/LMR radio communication. However, as 6.25 kHz technologies exist, these would be considered “ultra-narrowband” or “very narrowband”. Q2: 6.25 kHz “equivalent” versus real 6.25 kHz capability. A2: Historically, professional two-way radio has dealt with the problem of congested spectrum/channels by narrowing the channel spacing. I.e. 50 kHz 25 kHz 12.5 kHz 6.25 kHz. The DMR system is often quoted as being 6.25 kHz “equivalent”, and dPMR™ or NXDN™ are true 6.25 kHz. Basically what this means is that the 2-slot TDMA architecture of DMR provides the equivalent of two 6.25 kHz voice or data paths in a 12.5 kHz channel and the FDMA systems’ channel spacing is 6.25 kHz. For a more detailed explanation of the technical difference of TDMA and FDMA, please see the “What is dPMR™?” tab on the dPMR™ Association website (http://www.dpmr-mou.org/what-is-dpmr-30-minutes.htm). Q3: Just what kind of narrowband technologies/systems are there? A3: Notice we have not used “digital” with narrowband. This is because analogue FM is considered narrowband technology based on the explanation in A1 above, and thus the first type of narrowband technology available. Diagrams are provided for the systems relevant to the discussion in this document with references to other systems as required. Analogue Narrowband: Good old reliable FM: As mentioned above, analogue FM 12.5 kHz products have been available for many years now, and fit the description of the current narrowband channel spacing standard of 12.5 kHz. FAQ about Narrowband Technologies | Copyright 2013 dPMR Association – All Rights Reserved Digital Narrowband: dPMR™: dPMR™ is a digital 6.25 kHz FDMA based protocol described in the ETSI technical standards TS 102 490 and TS 102 658. Details of what dPMR™ is and can do, can be found on the dPMR™ Association website, but the basic structure of the dPMR™ standards suite is shown in the graphic below. As the diagram shows, dPMR™ is a full featured system capable of providing communications solutions ranging from license-free all the way up to multi-site trunking networks. FAQ about Narrowband Technologies | Copyright 2013 dPMR Association – All Rights Reserved 2 NXDN™: NXDN™ is an open digital 12.5 kHz or 6.25 kHz FDMA based protocol described in the NXDN™ suite of standards. Details of what NXDN™ is and can do, can be found on the NXDN™ Forum website, (http://www.nxdn-forum.com/) but the basic structure of the NXDN™ standards suite is shown in the graphic below. As the diagram shows, NXDN™ is a full featured system capable of providing flexible trunking solutions for small to medium sized networks. FAQ about Narrowband Technologies | Copyright 2013 dPMR Association – All Rights Reserved 3 DMR: DMR is a digital 12.5 kHz 2-slot TDMA based protocol described in the ETSI technical standard TS 102 361. Details of what DMR is and can do, can be found on the DMR Association website (http://dmrassociation.org/), but the basic structure of the DMR standards suite is shown in the graphic below. As the diagram shows, DMR is a full featured system capable of providing communications solutions ranging from license-free all the way up to multi-site trunking networks. Other Digital Systems: APCO Project 25: APCO P25 is still an evolving digital standard targeted mainly for the United States public safety market. The current Phase 1 part of the standard is a digital 12.5 kHz FDMA based protocol described in the TIA APCO P25 standards. A Phase 2 standard which is a 2-slot TDMA 12.5 kHz protocol has also been completed. Tetrapol: This is a 12.5 kHz FDMA digital standard that is also targeted for the public safety market as well as high-end commercial markets. FAQ about Narrowband Technologies | Copyright 2013 dPMR Association – All Rights Reserved 4 Tetra: This is a digital 25 kHz 4-slot TDMA based protocol described in the ETSI EN 300 392 suite of standards. Tetra is also targeted for the public safety market as well as high-end commercial markets. Japanese and Chinese standards: ARIB standards T-98 and T-102 are NXDN™ based 6.25 kHz FDMA standards that are available in the Japanese domestic market. China has also developing a digital standard called Police Digital Trunking (PDT), which is a 12.5 kHz TDMA based standard. They are also looking at creating a separate Business and Industry digital standard, and discussions on proposed candidate protocols has begun. As the content above indicates, there are also movements to adapt base standards as country specific standards. Q4: Which is better, 6.25 kHz FDMA or 12.5 kHz TDMA? A4: This is the million dollar question. The answer is that both technologies have been accepted in the market based on the features and advantages provided respectfully. This basically says there is room for both. Below are some facts and statistics of interest. Fact 1: At least 65% if not more of EVERY two-way manufacturer’s business (including supporters of TDMA technology) is analogue FDMA based, and will continue to be so for the foreseeable future. FDMA has served the PMR/LMR industry as a reliable and proven radio technology for more than 70 years. Therefore, it is hard to believe that now the PMR/LMR world is going digital, FDMA is suddenly an “inferior” technology. It is still the most efficient method of achieving spectrum efficiency. Fact 2: The number of 6.25 kHz FDMA radios in the market is estimated to be over 1,300,000 units. Based on information in the public domain, the number of TDMA units in the market is estimated to be over 2,500,000 units where the majority of this number is claimed by one manufacturer. Fact 3: The number of countries where 6.25 kHz FDMA and TDMA digital systems are used worldwide is virtually the same. The majority of countries worldwide now have regulations and/or band plans in place that allow the use of 6.25 kHz in one way or another. Q5: “Professional” versus “Simple, low cost” A5: There have been comments in various media articles that dPMR™ is a low cost “nonprofessional” orientated system. This should not to be confused with the original intention of dPMR™ being conceived as a “low cost, low complexity” protocol. This means that the technology can be achieved by largely using existing FM hardware engineering architecture. Also, as explained with the diagrams in previous pages, each system offers basically the same level of functions, trunking and networking capability. As with the “Which is better?” question, the answer is “the system that best suits the end user’s needs”. Q6: What about IPR? A6: dPMR™ was also developed to avoid IPR and again reduce the total cost for both the manufacturer and ultimately the end user. A statement about dPMR™ and IPR can be found on the dPMR™ Association website. At this time, no IPR has been determined to be essential to the dPMR™ standards and thus no licenses* are required for developing dPMR™. * No licenses for the CAI, but a vocoder license may be required depending on implementation FAQ about Narrowband Technologies | Copyright 2013 dPMR Association – All Rights Reserved 5 Q7: What kind of products are available for dPMR™? A7: At this time, the following products and services are available from a number of dPMR™ Association member companies. Further details can be found in a Product Showcase document recently made by the Association (website link). Tier 1 dPMR446 license-free radios Tier 2 dPMR™ Mode 1, 2 and 3 radios, infrastructure and controllers Tier 1 baseband IC chips (for radio development) Tier 2 Mode 1 and 2 baseband IC chips (for radio development) Tier 2 Mode 1, 2 and 3 protocol stacks (for radio development) Test and Measuring equipment supporting dPMR™ (for radio development and maintenance) Various applications tailored for dPMR™ products FAQ about Narrowband Technologies | Copyright 2013 dPMR Association – All Rights Reserved 6 DISCLAIMER This document has been prepared by the dPMR™ Association as a reference document. The information in this document has been carefully checked, and is believed to be correct and accurate. However, the dPMR™ Association assumes no responsibility for inaccuracies or mistakes. Document Revisions The dPMR™ Association reserves the right to make changes to the content of this document at any time without notice or obligation. Document Copyrights No duplication or distribution of this document or any portion thereof shall take place without the express permission of the dPMR™ Association. Reproduction, distribution, or transmission for any purpose in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, shall only be allowed with the express permission of the dPMR™ Association. Trademarks dPMR and the dPMR logo are registered trademarks of the dPMR Association in Europe, the United States, Japan, China and/or other countries. NXDN is a trademark of Icom Inc. and JVC KENWOOD Corporation. All other products or brands are registered trademarks or trademarks of their respective holders. FAQ about Narrowband Technologies | Copyright 2013 dPMR Association – All Rights Reserved 7 Whitepaper 4 Level FSK/FDMA 6.25 kHz Technology dPMR Whitepaper Issue 1.3 | Copyright 2013 dPMR Association – All Rights Reserved dPMR™ digital Private Mobile Radio 6.25 kHz Technology Since the beginning of PMR radio, there has been a constant juggling act between available spectrum and channel size. As filter and modulation technology has advanced the channel size has progressively reduced, 100 kHz, then 50, followed by 25 and then the 12.5 kHz we have known for the last twenty or so years. Add to that the current policy of spectrum pricing and it becomes clear that a new advance was needed to make the most efficient and economical use of this scarce resource. Traditionally PMR has always operated with FDMA (Frequency Divided Multiple Access) technology as that has offered the best flexibility to users. The initial plan for European standardisation was based on 2-slot TDMA (Time Divided Multiple Access) technology as several of the major PMR players have proffered that 6.25 kHz FDMA was simply not possible. Research by Icom and Kenwood however showed that 6.25 kHz FDMA was a practical proposition and they entered into a joint agreement to develop the technology further. This new digital 6.25 kHz FDMA idea was taken up by ETSI (the European Telecommunications Standards Institute) and developed into a European Standard. dPMR™ became an open, non-proprietary EU standard and was published under the reference TS 102 490 (License-free) and TS 102 658 (Licensed). History Achieving 6.25 kHz channeling was impossible to do using analog technology, so it became necessary to develop a new digital protocol. Availability of high quality low bit rate voice codecs meant that 6.25 kHz was a practical plan if a suitable modulation scheme could be identified. Several methods were considered, including ACSB and the proposed APCO Project 25 Phase II CQPSK. However, both required a more expensive linear amplifier in the transmitter and neither is compatible with existing analog FM hardware. Instead, 4-Level FSK (4FSK) modulation was selected using FDMA for the access method. This method has a number of advantages: better communication range simpler design easy to maintain and service lower cost for business and industry customers compatible with existing FM radio hardware The first 6.25 kHz capable radios were introduced to the market in 2006. There are now 13 manufacturers that have 6.25 kHz FDMA products (dPMR™, NXDN™ and Japan ARIB standards based products) with more manufacturers still to develop products. These products operate in both digital conventional and digital trunking modes. To enable backwards compatibility, they also operate in 25 kHz and 12.5 kHz channel bandwidths. dPMR Whitepaper Issue 1.3 | Copyright 2013 dPMR Association – All Rights Reserved 2 Backwards compatibility to analogue only radios enables a planned migration path to “digital” with existing radios operating analogue only and new radios operating analogue and digital. How the Technology Works General specifications: Access Method: FDMA Transmission Rate: 4800 bps Modulation: 4-level FSK Vocoder: AMBE+2™ Codec Rate: 3600 (Voice 2,450 + Error Correction 1,150 bps) Modulation with 4LFSK uses a symbol mapping scheme. When the radio receives a binary number, that number is mapped to a symbol, which is interpreted as a 1050Hz frequency deviation. During demodulation, that deviation is detected, filtered and “unmapped” as a binary signal for transmission. dPMR Whitepaper Issue 1.3 | Copyright 2013 dPMR Association – All Rights Reserved 3 Signal Quality The FDMA signal BER performance exceeds that of APCO Project 25 Phase 1 radios, which have already been accepted by the market as quality digital radios. Audio Quality The 6.25 kHz dPMR™ technology also offers improved audio quality compared to P25 audio. Test engineers using a Mean Opinion Sample (MOS) found the audio quality was uniformly better, ranging from clean conditions to 5% BER. Using the AMBE+2™ vocoder makes this possible. dPMR Whitepaper Issue 1.3 | Copyright 2013 dPMR Association – All Rights Reserved 4 Range Audio quality over distance is also greatly improved with 6.25 kHz dPMR™ technology. Instead of the early degradation of audio that you see in an analog signal, the 6.25 kHz dPMR™ digital audio quality remains higher over a comparable distance. This has been seconded in real life use from end users. Spectrum Efficiency A channel is defined by the deviation either side of the carrier frequency. Migrating from a 25 kHz channel to a 12.5 kHz channel on the same carrier frequency is a 1-for-1 move. There is no increase in the capacity to load radio users. Some administrations have allocated 6.25 kHz frequencies/channels in their band plans, but most went unused because no 6.25 kHz radios were available. With dPMR™ FDMA technology, spectrum coordinators have total flexibility to either assign one 6.25 kHz channel within an existing 25 kHz or 12.5 kHz channel or as a stand-alone frequency somewhere else on the band. dPMR Whitepaper Issue 1.3 | Copyright 2013 dPMR Association – All Rights Reserved 5 The emission mask above left is established for 12.5 kHz channels. The signal must operate within the mask. The emission mask on the right shows that the dPMR™ FDMA signal clearly operates within the mask (In this case 2 x 6.25 kHz signals in a 12.5 kHz channel). Accordingly, administrations around the world have certified 6.25 kHz capable radios for use and there are in excess of 900,000 units already in operation worldwide. Radios are approved in Europe under EN 301 166, again the first ever 6.25 kHz radios for this region. Channeling Considerations A number of frequency allocation options for 6.25 kHz are available in for each country. It is advised that you check with your local administration on the conditions for licensing and use of 6.25 kHz FDMA equipment, as not all regulations are uniform at this point. Expand an Existing System In most cases spectrum license holders or site owners/operators will have licenses to use 12.5 kHz channels. While it is recommended that consultation with your administration on how you can use/apply 6.25 kHz equipment in your system, current 6.25 kHz FDMA systems offered in the market can already be used ‘as is’, and thus let you begin the migration to a digital system now. As the basic architecture of the equipment is based on existing FM hardware, assimilating components into an existing analogue system is relatively easy. The same antennas, power supplies, duplexors, isolators and combiners etc. can be used, so only the cost of adding a digital channel (s) with the accompanying terminals is required upfront. This is not much different to replacing old analogue equipment. Depending on local regulations, it may also be possible to increase the capacity of the system because of the narrower channel spacing of dPMR™. Applications for new additional 6.25 kHz channels and combine them with their current 25 or 12.5 kHz channels, or new frequencies could occupy the existing 25 kHz or 12.5 kHz bandwidth. Additional stand-alone 6.25 kHz channels could also be used. Split a 25 kHz or 12.5 kHz Shared or Exclusive Channel Because the emission mask is so tight, two 6.25 kHz dPMR™ signals can be used next to each other within a 12.5 kHz channel without causing interference to each other or adjacent channels. Compliance with EN 301 166 at 6.25 kHz for current equipment is one measure of guarantee that interference issues are no different than at 12.5 kHz or 25 kHz. Frequency co-coordinators in the U.S.A. have even made recommendations to the FCC that are expected to be approved soon, about setting up new 6.25 kHz systems adjacent to existing systems, outlining parameters to avoid harmful interference. 2-for-1 efficiencies may be realized by splitting existing 12.5 kHz channels. Using 6.25 kHz channels offset from the carrier frequency of a 12.5 kHz channel, it is possible to fit two 6.25 kHz channels into the 12.5 kHz bandwidth. dPMR Whitepaper Issue 1.3 | Copyright 2013 dPMR Association – All Rights Reserved 6 Again, we recommend that you contact the spectrum management service of your administration for details on how to modify your shared or exclusive 12.5 kHz license for operation of two 6.25 kHz signals. Current and Future Applications for 6.25 kHz Technology The new digital land mobile technology can be a platform for future integration of IT and IP technologies. To this end, dPMR™ manufacturers have developed a new generation of digital networking systems. The goal is to allow seamless migration from analog systems to new digital technologies. Multi-site IP Networks In-building and Intra-building Networks dPMR Whitepaper Issue 1.3 | Copyright 2013 dPMR Association – All Rights Reserved 7 Trunking Networks Handheld battery operated equipment As already explained, dPMR™ technology offers better audio quality at the extreme fringes of radio coverage. In addition to this, the fact of using narrower 6.25 kHz channels means that receiver filters are narrower too and that the RF sensitivity can be increased. This allows users the choice of reducing the RF power used to extend the possible battery life. Whilst this is possible, is it actually what is needed in real life? Handheld radios usually are employed in two scenarios: - integrated into a mobile network - in a dedicated portable only network Using handhelds in a network that is designed around mobile operation demands that the handhelds are operated for maximum possible range so that they come somewhere near the performance of the mobile units. In these cases the RF power is the first concern not the battery life. When the handheld application is a portable only type of system, i.e. in-house or localised area, the typical requirements for coverage normally mean that the radios are operated at reduced power anyway. In such cases the battery life considerably exceeds the operational requirements. dPMR™ offers a third option to add to these typical scenarios by integrating the localised area system into the full mobile network by means of a local repeater connected to the main network via an internet gateway. By exploiting the full flexibility of the dPMR™ protocol, system planners can ensure the maximum potential of such mixed systems. dPMR Whitepaper Issue 1.3 | Copyright 2013 dPMR Association – All Rights Reserved 8 6.25 kHz and ‘equivalence’ Many published comments and adverts use the term ‘6.25 kHz equivalent’. This is simply down to offering 2 voice channels in a 12.5 kHz bandwidth and thereby permit two separate radio systems. dPMR™ being based on a 6.25 kHz FDMA format is by definition always 6.25 kHz. There is no need to hedge the definition with - quote equivalent unquote. Where 6.25 kHz ‘equivalence’ is achieved by other means, such as a TDMA solution we can see why the definition ceases to be black and white. The very nature of TDMA ‘equivalence’ is such that the advantages offered leads to compromises in other areas. A TDMA repeater may well offer a lower installation cost as a single repeater will not require a duplexer. But where the common requirement of direct mode operations is added we see that the operation reverts to 12.5 kHz FDMA and any idea of 6.25 kHz ‘equivalence’ is lost. Similarly, the TDMA solution can offer the possibility of emergency break-in where another user can pre-empt a call in progress. However, this requires the use of two time slots to achieve, so again the possibility of two separate systems in 12.5 kHz has been lost. With dPMR™ the fundamental issue of true 6.25 kHz operation is never compromised. It can also be said that when the day comes where 12.5 kHz spectrum is full, a dPMR™ system will still be a viable solution, thus potentially a longer-term, future proof technology and investment. dPMR Whitepaper Issue 1.3 | Copyright 2013 dPMR Association – All Rights Reserved 9 Appendix A: Adjacent Channel Power Adjacent channel power is of primary interest to spectrum planners and coordinators. This is the measurement of how clean the modulation of the transmitter is and directly influences the possibility of using the channels either side of the user. For older technologies using 12.5 kHz channels the requirements are specified in EN 300 086 or EN 300 113. These standards both require a protection level of 60dB for 12.5 kHz channels. It should also be noted that older 25 kHz channels require a protection level of 70dB. European standards have allowed for the reduction of channel size by permitting 10dB degradation in adjacent channel power. It would therefore be totally reasonable to expect a similar 10dB relaxation when channel size is halved again to 6.25 kHz. However, such a relaxation was not required. For 6.25 kHz equipment it is the EN 301 166 standard that applies for radio approval purposes. EN 301 166 has requirements for not only the adjacent channel power but also for the unwanted power that could be detected two channels away from the user. These are known in the standard as ‘adjacent’ and ‘alternate’ respectively: fc Lower Alternate Lower Adjacent Wanted Channel Upper Adjacent Upper Alternate The requirements of EN 301 166 call for 60dB protection for the next 6.25 kHz channel and 70dB protection for the next channel. The simple fact that dPMR™ 6.25 kHz technology meets the same level of adjacent channel power protection as current 12.5 kHz equipment is a significant achievement that will no doubt reassure spectrum managers that dPMR™ technology can co-exist with older 12.5 kHz technologies. As mentioned above, frequency co-coordinators in the U.S.A. already have recommendations about setting up new 6.25 kHz systems adjacent to existing systems, outlining parameters to avoid harmful interference that could serve as reference to administrations contemplating regulatory changes or advice to system operators. dPMR Whitepaper Issue 1.3 | Copyright 2013 dPMR Association – All Rights Reserved 10 Here is an illustrative example of the Busy Channel Lockout feature operation. VHF Test Results Freq Steps of Radio 157.000000 (0 offset) "A" in kHz 157.007500 (7.5 offset) Weak Signal Sig Strength No Modulation / Full Dead Fully Voice Modulation Carrier Modulated Carrier Radio "B" Bandwidth Strong Signal Dead Fully Carrier Modulated Carrier Weak Signal Dead Fully Carrier Modulated Carrier Strong Signal Dead Fully Carrier Modulated Carrier 25 kHz 12.5 kHz 6.25 kHz AB AB AB ------- A A AB AB AB AB AB AB AB AB AB AB ------- A A AB A = "A" radio "busys" out B = "B" radio "busys" out Weak Signal: 2 Radios 3 Meters apart without antenna, 1Watt Strong Signal: 2 Radios 3 Meters apart with antenna, 1Watt "B" Radio ALWAYS at 157.00000 "A" Radio Starts at 157.00000 moves to 157.007500 "A" Radio always in 6.25 mode UHF Test Results Freq Steps of Radio 460.000000 (0 offset) "A" in kHz 460.00625 (6.25 offset) Sig Strength Weak Signal No Modulation / Full Dead Fully Voice Modulation Carrier Modulated Carrier Radio "B" Bandwidth Strong Signal Dead Fully Carrier Modulated Carrier Weak Signal Dead Fully Carrier Modulated Carrier Strong Signal Dead Fully Carrier Modulated Carrier 25 kHz 12.5 kHz 6.25 kHz AB AB AB ------- AB AB AB AB AB AB AB AB AB AB AB AB ------- AB AB AB A = "A" radio "busys" out B = "B" radio "busys" out Weak Signal: 2 Radios 3 Meters apart without antenna Strong Signal: 2 Radios 3 Meters apart with antenna "B" Radio ALWAYS at 460.00000 "A" Radio Starts at 460.00000 moves up to 460.00625 (6.25 kHz offset) "A" Radio always in 6.25 mode No interference when radio "A" is more than 12.5 kHz away from radio "B" under any conditions dPMR Whitepaper Issue 1.3 | Copyright 2013 dPMR Association – All Rights Reserved 11 DISCLAIMER This document has been prepared by the dPMR™ Association as a reference document about dPMR™. The information in this document has been carefully checked, and is believed to be correct and accurate. However, the dPMR™ Association assumes no responsibility for inaccuracies or mistakes. Document Revisions The dPMR™ Association reserves the right to make changes to the content of this document at any time without notice or obligation. IPR and Copyrights Any products or technologies described in this document may include Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) and/or copyrighted content. Such IPR and copyrighted content are protected by laws in Europe, the United States and other countries. Any IPR and/or copyrighted content contained herein may not be copied, reproduced, modified, reverse-engineered, or distributed in any way. Document Copyrights No duplication or distribution of this document or any portion thereof shall take place without the express permission of the dPMR™ Association. Reproduction, distribution, or transmission for any purpose in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, shall only be allowed with the express permission of the dPMR™ Association. Some of the content of this document has been taken from the marketing material and used with the permission of dPMR™ Association members. Trademarks dPMR and the dPMR logo are registered trademarks of the dPMR™ Association in Europe, the United States, Japan, China and/or other countries. AMBE is the trademark and property of Digital Voice Systems, Inc. All other products or brands are registered trademarks or trademarks of their respective holders. dPMR Whitepaper Issue 1.3 | Copyright 2013 dPMR Association – All Rights Reserved 12 NOTES | Copyright 2013 dPMR Association – All Rights Reserved 2 NOTES | Copyright 2013 dPMR Association – All Rights Reserved 3 NOTES | Copyright 2013 dPMR Association – All Rights Reserved 4