to the PDF version of this publication
Transcription
to the PDF version of this publication
Vol. 28, No. 1 • January 2015 2015 Hall of Fame Class Announced Chicago — Three industry leaders have been selected for induction into the Path to Purchase Institute/Shopper Marketing Hall of Fame in 2015. They are: nDirk De Vos, Senior Vice President, Commercial Marketing, Heineken USA. What impact has shopper marketing had on your brands? “WE STILL HAVE NOT 62% say ADEQUATELY MEASURED” Are beacons/geo-fencing/ micro-location part of your strategy? 49% say “NOT A PRIORITY AT THE MOMENT” Amy DraglandJohnson, Director, Shopper Marketing, S.C. Johnson & Son. n David VanderWaal, U.S. Head of Marketing, Home Appliance/Consumer Electronics, LG Electronics. n The 22nd annual induction ceremony will be held in conjunction with the Shopper Marketing Effie Celebration on Tuesday, March 17, in Schaumburg, Illinois. Both events are part of the Shopper Marketing Summit. Shopper Marketing will profile De Vos, Dragland-Johnson and VanderWaal in the March-May SM issues. Leadership University Headed to Bentonville Chicago — The Path to Purchase Institute Leadership University will offer Institute members two days of courses in Bentonville, Arkansas, in February. University instructors will conduct a “Fundamentals of Shopper Marketing” course on Feb. 18, followed by “Principles of Shopper Behavior & Engagement” on Feb. 19. Courses are also planned for Chicago in March and June, Cincinnati in April, and Minneapolis in May. For more information and to register, visit www.p2pi.org/leadershipu. SM What e-commerce fulfillment method could have greatest impact? “SAME-DAY HOME DELIVERY” What’s the primary barrier to adoption of mobile payment? “I DON’T KNOW” TRENDS2015 60% say INSIDE 40% say Results of our annual survey and a virtual roundtable discussion on mobile payment PAGE 16 Energizer’s Edge Helps Ubisoft Groom Gamers ‘Assassin’s Creed Unity’-themed shave gel cans target Millennial males By Chris Gelbach Shelton, Conn. — Energizer Personal Care, a subsidiary of St. Louis-based Energizer Holdings, recently partnered with French video game publisher Ubisoft for the Nov. 11 release of “Assassin’s Creed Unity,” the eighth main installment of the long-running video game franchise. The collaboration aimed to expand both manufacturers’ reach with Millennial males by introducing Energizer’s Edge shave gel products to gaming enthusiasts while exposing the Ubisoft brand to a broader mainstream audience. The cross-promotion centered on limited-edition Edge shave gel cans featuring “Assassin’s Creed Unity” artwork. The cans featured codes that enabled gamers to unlock exclusive gaming content. Each of three gel formulations – sensitive skin, extra moisturizing and ultra sensitive – featured a different code that gave gamers access to an exclusive downloadable sword, armor and assassin’s hood. “The Edge cans are one of the most underutilized pieces of real estate in CPG,” says Anthony Pietrini, brand manager for Edge shave gel. “The Ubisoft team saw value in the real estate that Edge cans could bring, as men engage with the cans multiple times per week. And Edge saw See Ubisoft, Page 14 Who’s Who in CUSTOMER TEAMS at Walmart We shine the spotlight on more than 100 individuals who are leading manufacturers’ customer teams in Bentonville, Arkansas. We explain the roles of customer teams and examine the history behind their development. PAGE 26 ACTIVATION GALLERY Cosmetics Page 38 Introducing the Answer to Your Omni-Media Campaign Needs Packaging, print, audio and video — Digimarc provides brands and retailers with one technology to facilitate mobile engagement at every touch point throughout the shopper’s journey. Every component of a marketing campaign — print ads, catalogs, direct mail, television and radio commercials, retail signage, product packaging and more — can be made interactive to facilitate deeper consumer engagement, build brand loyalty and drive immediate purchase opportunities. TRY FOR YOURSELF! Launch the Digimarc® Discover app and focus the camera on the images below to view Digimarc’s omni-media solution in action. AT HOME ON THE GO IN THE STORE To view Digimarc’s complete omni-media solution in action, visit: www.digimarc.com/omni dmrc_shopper_marketing_D2.indd 1 Untitled-7 1 7/26/13 12:53 PM 7/28/13 1:00 PM Ricci at Retail, Page 44 Editorial Director Bill Schober, (773) 992-4430 Executive Editor Tim Binder, (773) 992-4437 Managing Editor Linc Wonham, (773) 992-4432 Art Director/Production Manager Sonja Lundquist, (773) 992-4419 CONTENTS Contributing Editors Peter Breen, Sana Jafrani, Cyndi Loza, Rob Mahoney, Patrycja Malinowska, Samantha Nelson Contributing Writers Dan Alaimo, Michael Applebaum, Joe Bush, Anne Downes, Ed Finkel, Erika Flynn, Chris Gelbach, Sharon Goldman, Dawn Klingensmith, Neal Lorenzi, April Miller, Dan Ochwat, Betsy Spethmann Publisher Chuck Bolkcom, (773) 992-4420; [email protected] Associate Publisher Craig Hitchcock, (773) 992-4422; [email protected] ADVERTISING SALES Craig Hitchcock, (773) 992-4422; [email protected] Serving the Western United States 4 Editorial: Peter Breen 6 CPG Growth Specialty coffee retailer Barnie’s CoffeeKitchen is experiencing unprecedented retail expansion by thinking small with a focus on convenience. Rich Zelvin, (773) 992-4425; [email protected] Serving the Eastern United States, Canada, International Need help finding a supplier? We may be able to help. Send your email to [email protected] and be sure to include a daytime phone number. Shopper Marketing (ISSN 1040-8169) is published monthly by the Path to Purchase Institute, 8550 W. Bryn Mawr Ave., Suite 200, Chicago, IL 60631-3731. Periodicals Postage Paid at Chicago, IL, and at additional mailing offices. POSTMASTER: Send address changes to Shopper Marketing, Creative Data Services, 440 Quadrangle Dr., Suite E, Bolingbrook, IL 60440. Entire contents copyright © 2015 by the Path to Purchase Institute. Canada Post International Publications Mail Product (Canadian Distribution) Sales Agreement No. 40025274. Return undeliverable Canadian addresses to: Station A, P.O. Box 54, Windsor, ON N9A 6J5 or Email: [email protected] CHANGE OF ADDRESS and other circulation correspondence should be mailed to: Shopper Marketing, Creative Data Services, 440 Quadrangle Dr., Suite E, Bolingbrook, IL 60440, or email [email protected] for customer service. (Include your address label with all correspondence.) WHERE TO WRITE: Please direct all letters to the editor and other business/advertising correspondence to: Shopper Marketing, 8550 W. Bryn Mawr Ave., Suite 200, Chicago, IL 60631-3731. ARTICLE REPRINTS & E-PRINTS: Contact Quan Tran at (773) 992-4464 or [email protected]. NOTICE: The Path to Purchase Institute occasionally uses the logos of various companies in its marketing materials. These include promotional brochures for events such as the Shopper Marketing Conference & Expo, the Shopper Marketing Summit, the Design of the Times Awards and others. The use of these logos does not imply sponsorship or endorsement by the companies identified by those logos, unless specifically noted as such. p2pi.org Executive Director – Chief Executive Officer Peter W. Hoyt, (773) 992-4456 Managing Director – Chief Operating & Financial Officer Chris Stark, (773) 992-4444 Managing Director – Member Services & Events Maureen Macke, (773) 992-4413 Managing Director – Strategy & Development Steve Frenda, (773) 992-4461 Managing Director – Platforms & Publishing Chuck Bolkcom, (773) 992-4420 Managing Director – Content & Editorial Bill Schober, (773) 992-4430 PRODUCTION Director – Production Ed Ward, (773) 992-4418 Art Director/Production Manager Sonja Lundquist, (773) 992-4419 MARKETING Director – Marketing & Communications Michele Weston-Rowe, (773) 992-4440 Senior Manager – Marketing & Communications Brittney Winters, (773) 992-4441 Manager – Audience Development Stacy Stiglic, (773) 992-4443 Art Director Stephanie Beling, (773) 992-4442 MEMBER DEVELOPMENT & SERVICES Director – Member Development Pat Burke, (773) 992-4465 Director – Member Development Terese Herbig, (773) 992-4438 Manager – Member Development & Event Sales Quan Tran, (773) 992-4464 Marketing Analyst Carol Schiro, (773) 992-4463 Senior Coordinator – Member Services Cindy Hahn, (773) 992-4414 Editorial and Executive Offices 8550 W. Bryn Mawr Ave., Suite 200, Chicago, IL 60631-3731 PHONE: (773) 992-4450 FAX: (773) 992-4455 OPERATIONS Director – Finance & Accounting Mike Bernal, (773) 992-4445 Manager – Office Services/H.R. Crystal Stone, (773) 992-4447 Senior Coordinator – Administrative Services Ann Estey, (773) 992-4448 Staff Accountant Sajan Kuriakose, (773) 992-4446 INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY Director – Information Technology Jack Dare, (773) 992-4411 Director – Sites & Systems Rob Mahoney, (773) 992-4434 Coordinator – Digital Content Production Jean-Paul Masuda, (773) 992-4449 EVENTS & EDUCATION Managing Director – Professional Development Patrick Fitzmaurice, (773) 992-4466 Manager – Events Peggy Milbrandt, (773) 992-4412 Manager – Event Production & Marketing Stacey Bobby, (773) 992-4423 Manager – Member Development & Event Sales Quan Tran, (773) 992-4464 Director – Education & Faculty Administration Ronit Lawlor, (773) 992-4415 P2PI.ORG Associate Director – Content Patrycja Malinowska, (773) 992-4435 Associate Editor – Content Samantha Nelson, (773) 992-4436 Associate Editor – Content Cyndi Loza, (773) 992-4439 Associate Editor – Content Sana Jafrani, (773) 992-4433 PLATFORMS & PUBLISHING Managing Director – Special Content Peter Breen, (773) 992-4431 Director Craig Hitchcock, (773) 992-4422 Dir. – Market Development & Sales Rich Zelvin, (773) 992-4425 SPECIAL REPORTS 16 Trends 2015 8 The View from OASIS We surveyed hundreds of CPG marketing executives for our annual Trends report. The questions, developed by the Institute’s editors, cover a wide range of topics, from budgets and technology to collaboration and the retailers themselves. 10 S’mores at Target Mondelez International and Hershey bring their brands to life at Target stores in a guest-centric way. 16 Feature: Mobile Payment We convene a virtual roundtable to discuss the state of mobile payment and why it has yet to come into its own. 11 Growing Via E-Commerce 26 Feature: Customer Teams The Coca-Cola Co. entered the e-commerce channel in early 2013 and learned a lot in the ensuing 18 months about how to connect with shoppers. We explore the history behind and the current roles of consumer product manufacturers’ customer teams. 26 Who’s Who in Customer Teams at Walmart 12 Social Engagement The first in a series of Who’s Who reports identifies many of the leaders of CPG brands’ Walmart customer teams based in or around Bentonville, Arkansas. 6 Solution Provider News 8 Embrace Mobile’s Influence Albertsons’ social engagement strategy recognizes the importance of reaching consumers. It’s the retailer’s way of connecting to people and gathering their information to have a personalized conversation. 36So-Lo-Mo A roundup of social, local and mobile marketing activity at retail from: •Bazaarvoice and Sony Electronics •Black & Decker •Mondelez and Idomoo •Gigwalk •AccuWeather and Lotame •Verifone and MasterCard •MCX •SpyderLynk •Engage3 When consumers express a need through their devices, marketers need to be there in a contextually relevant way, says Michael Becker, managing partner and chief executive officer at mCordis. 8 Activation Gallery: Cosmetics 3 44 Ricci at Retail Joe finds small displays that are winners ... •Mucinex •Tums •UrgentRx 5 Personnel Appointments 4 46 Institute Strategist To complement our Who’s Who in Customer Teams at Walmart, we present a sampling of recent account-specific activity at Walmart. Retail expansion, Page 6 4 SHOPPER MARKETING JANUARY 2015 EDITORIAL Trendy Thinking S hopper marketing now commands 15% of the overall marketing budget, according to results from Shopper Marketing’s annual “Trends Report,” coverage of which begins on page 16. That number is up a full percentage point from last year’s survey and more than 5 points from our 2012 report. It seems pretty clear that shopper marketing is growing in importance. However, please remember that this number represents an industry average, which means that some companies are allocating less than 15% and some are allocating more. So the significance resides more in the trend than the data. Don’t go running down the hall shouting, “We need to devote 15% to shopper to keep pace with the industry.” Instead, try “We need to continue to increase our investment in shopper to keep pace with the industry.” I know. That second option doesn’t have the same certitude, but it’s also more realistic. You see, the Institute’s editors have always tried to stay levelheaded about data from the annual Trends Report. We understand that, even when you’re asking people to provide facts, an unquantifiable amount of estimation, conjecture, idealism, prejudice and even factual uncertainty is liable to color some results. Nonetheless, time and healthy respondent totals can give you a pretty good view of where the marketplace is heading. (We’re extremely grateful for the hundreds of marketing professionals who take the time to help us out each year.) What’s more, we’ve been pleased over the years to see the data we gather holding up pretty well: In 2013, for instance, just under 10% of our respondents predicted that their shopper marketing budgets would increase by more than 10% in 2014. In this year’s survey, just under 10% said that’s exactly what happened last year. Data is, as they say, in the eye of the beholder. And I’ve been accused of having a slanted view of the industry in some circles. But with that in mind, here are some other tidbits that caught my attention within this year’s results. It probably takes two? Better than 60% of responIncremental No significant We still have not adequately dents say they’ve verified that shopper marketing sales growth growth measured the impact programs drive increased support from, and stronAll Respondents 21.4 13.5 65.1 ger relationships with, retailers. This is interesting because the need for collaboration seems to be PACKAGED FOOD & BEVERAGE viewed by many as an optional component of shop17.5 13.8 68.7 per marketing – in fact, only about 20% of shopper By Primary PACKAGED NON-FOOD Products/Services programs are “true” joint efforts, according to other of Respondent’s 26.6 12.5 60.9 Company* data from this year’s survey. SPECIALTY 24.1 10.3 65.6 For the first time this year, we attempted to quantify the impact on a brand’s top-line growth 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% from shopper marketing in general and collab* Food & Beverage category includes packaged food, beverages, candy, beer, wine and liquor. that distinguishes it from consumer or trade So orative shopper marketing in particular. Roughly two Packaged Non-Food includes household items, pet food, personal care, cosmetics andpromotion. OTC drugs. Specialty includes consumer electronics, sporting goods, appliances, hardware, auto, apparel, bully to all those making it an objective. of every three respondents who’ve measured that have footwear and office supplies. found some pretty significant results. (See charts at right Base: Consumer product marketers. N= 190. to Purchase Institute/Shopper It ain’t the meat, it’sSource: thePath notion. “An activationMarketing plan based and on page 17.) on strong shopper insights” was selected as the most imThere’s no denying that real collaboration is hard work, portant asset a manufacturer can bring to a retailer. That requiring additional resources – money, time, people – means it beat out “iconic brands,” strong media support that aren’t always available (and probably never will be). and customized promotions among most of our respondent So it can be difficult to implement the practice across all cohorts – most notably including the brand managers, if shopper-targeting programs. Perhaps it needs to be underyou can believe that one. taken prudently with key accounts and/or for strategically Still whistling past the graveyard? While about half of the important initiatives. Nonetheless, I still feel that collaboration represents the respondents identify Walmart’s private-label strategy as a best-practice pinnacle of shopper marketing, so I’m glad to threat, few CPGs seem to be concerned about store brands having much of an impact on their own sales. OK, folks, see that it’s producing results. On the other hand, I’m definitely not happy to learn if you say so … that nearly two-thirds of all respondents still don’t feel as if The sky’s the limit. I’m happy to see that “drone delivery” is they’ve adequately measured the impact of shopper marketrated as the futuristic concept least likely to have an impact ing. If I can ask an erudite question: What’s up with that? on shopper marketing. I’ve already been worrying that a Thinking bigger. I’m also delighted to see that at least a few Tide-toting drone will orchestrate my ultimate demise.SM marketers (about one in five, technically) have quantified the impact that shopper marketing has on brand equity. This is another area that’s often questioned – or even disPeter Breen is managing director – special content for missed outright – when the value of shopper marketing is the Path to Purchase Institute. He can be reached at discussed. It’s also one of the key aspects of the discipline (773) 992-4431 or [email protected]. The League of Leaders is an exclusive organization of industry thought-leaders dedicated to advancing the understanding of all marketing efforts that culminate at retail. ABBOTT LABORATORIES • Jessica Krauser, Senior Manager, Shopper Marketing •Jamie LaRue, Director, Pediatric Commercial Analytics at Abbott ACCO BRANDS •Ellery Fischer, Director, E-Commerce •Gary Lazicki, Manager, Retail Merchandising •Mark Seeley, Senior Merchandising Manager ALCON • Jeremy Brown, Senior Manager, Shopper Marketing • Mark McKeon, Associate Director, Category & Shopper Insights •Shawn Millerick, Head of Marketing, U.S. OTC ANHEUSER-BUSCH • Melissa VanVickle, Shopper Insights Manager BARILLA AMERICA • Kimberly Humann, Senior Manager, Shopper Marketing • Nina Mlynek, Shopper Marketing Manager • Debbie Zefting, Director, Customer & Shopper Development, NA BAYER HEALTHCARE • Dominique Bruno, Shopper Marketing Manager • Susan Hayes, Director, Shopper Marketing & Insights • Richard Horris, Senior Shopper Marketing Manager BEIERSDORF INC. • Laura Cammarota, Senior Shopper Marketing Manager • Daniel Theroux, Manager, Business & Competitive Intelligence BIG HEART PET BRANDS • David Knoepfle, Director of Shopper Marketing & Activation •Todd Nettleton, VP, Market Development Organization •Mac Tillman, VP, Marketing BROWN-FORMAN CORP. • Christa Bryant, Director, Channel & Customer Marketing •Bob Krall, VP, Channel Sales Director, Casual Dining •Julie Lynn York, Group Manager, Partnership Marketing CAMPBELL SOUP/ PEPPERIDGE FARM • Deb Piaseczynski, Senior Group Manager, Shopper Marketing • Shelly Sinas, Director of Customer Engagement & Shopper Marketing CAPRE GROUP • Anne Chambers, CEO • Kristi Ross, Principal CATAPULT •Peter Cloutier, CMO • Joe Robinson, President CHURCH & DWIGHT • Dan Bracken, Director, Marketing Services CLOROX CO. •David Cardona, Director of Shopper Marketing, CAS & Multicultural Capabilities COCA-COLA CO. • Christopher Russell, Group Director, Shopper Insights • Rachel Smith, AVP, Shopper Marketing & Planning COLGATE-PALMOLIVE • Barry Roberts, Director, Retail Shopper Solutions & E-Commerce • Brad Watt, Worldwide Director, Global Shopper Marketing CONAGRA FOODS •Tammy Brumfield, VP, Shopper Marketing • Tom Lisi, Senior Director, Shopper Marketing, Walmart •Tim Miller, Senior Director, Shopper Insights CONSTELLATION BRANDS INC. •Carl Evans, VP of Trade Marketing & Promotions •Dale Stratton, VP, Strategic Insights CURB CROWSER •Tracie Curb-Crowser, CEO & Chief Creative Officer •Dean Forbes, President DEL MONTE FOODS •Jennifer Reiner, Director of Shopper Marketing DELL • Mary Flanagan, Shopper Marketing Strategy • Lori Pennington, Insights, Shopper Experience & Strategy • Dan Seymour, Director, Retail Marketing DIAGEO • Calvin Burwell, Director, Consumer Planning DIGIMARC CORP. • Bruce Davis, CEO & Chairman of the Board •Ed Knudson, EVP, Sales & Marketing DR PEPPER SNAPPLE GROUP •Scott Barcenilla, Shopper Marketing Manager, East • Richard Moulton, Director, Shopper Marketing – Walmart, West Grocery & C-stores E & J GALLO WINERY • Robert Ruijssenaars, Director, Customer Marketing • John Schoenecker, Director, Shopper Marketing ENERGIZER HOLDINGS INC. • Michael Law, Senior Director, Customer Strategy & Planning •David Morgart, Senior Director, Commercial Strategy & Planning •Beth St. Raymond, Director of Shopper Marketing FCB/RED • Tina Manikas, President •Curt Munk, SVP, Group Planning Director FOOD LION •Leslie Atkinson, Director of Brand Communications • Marci Grebstein, VP, Marketing & Brand Strategy •Neil Norman, Manager of Customer Loyalty In terms of top-line growth, what impact has collaborative shopper marketing activity had on your brands? FRITO-LAY INC. • Janelle Anderson, VP, Shopper Marketing • Shelley Pisarra, Senior Director, Shopper Insights & Strategy •Jeff Swearingen, SVP, Portfolio Marketing & Analytics GENERAL MILLS INC. •Brian Kittelson, Director of Integrated Shopper Marketing GEOMETRY GLOBAL • Carl Hartman, NA CEO •Scott McCallum, President, Shopper Marketing, North America GLAXOSMITHKLINE • Joe Cadle, Director, Shopper Marketing • Angelo Veotte, Global Category & Shopper Marketing Manager GREAT NORTHERN INSTORE • Brian Fiebig, VP, Marketing • Mike Schliesmann, SVP, Business Unit Manager HEINEKEN USA •Dirk De Vos, SVP, Commercial Marketing • Jonathan Simpson, Senior Director, Commercial Marketing HERSHEY CO. • Rafael Alcaraz, VP, Global Advanced Analytics, HR & Insight-Driven Supply Chain Analytics • Michael DePanfilis, General Manager, E-Commerce & Shopper Marketing • Michael Weinstock, VP, Global Knowledge HUNTER STRAKER •James Fraser, SVP •Chad Grenier, EVP, Retail Marketing Services IBOTTA •Kane McCord, COO • Dan Wallace, Account Executive IN MARKETING SERVICES •Todd Engels, EVP, Managing Director •Elizabeth Fogerty, SVP, Strategic Planning INTEGER GROUP • Jennine Friess, Director, Network Communications • Nicole Souza, SVP, Network Business Development Director INTEL CORP. •Renee Novello, Director, Global Retail Shopper Marketing Manager J.M. SMUCKER CO. •Jill Boyce, VP, Market Research • Ben Driss, Director, Category Development • Liz Mayer, Senior Manager, Shopper Marketing & Consumer Promotions JOHNSON & JOHNSON SALES AND LOGISTICS CO. • Danielle Jenkins, Director, Category Management & Shopper Marketing • John King, Senior Director, Shopper, Category Insights & Consumer Promotion JOHNSONVILLE SAUSAGE •Dan Baltus, Customer Research Manager • Betsy Bartlett,Consumer Research Manager KAO •Jackie Bishop, Director of Sales • Diane Isler, Senior Manager, Insights & Category Management •John Sullivan, VP, Sales KELLOGG CO. •Daniel Cooke, Digital Shopper Marketing, E-Commerce Lead KIMBERLY-CLARK • Anne Jenkins, Director, Shopper Marketing •Anne M. Jones, VP, Shopper Marketing & Business Development • Jill Wienkes, Senior Manager, Shopper Marketing Center of Excellence KRAFT FOODS GROUP INC. •Sue Carey Coyle, Director, Shopper Marketing, Growth Channels • Joan Francolini, Senior Director, Shopper Marketing •Art Sebastian, CVP, Category Leadership & Shopper Insights LG ELECTRONICS • Stewart Henderson, Manager, In-Store Marketing/Brand Marketing Home Appliances •Rachel Olson, In-Store Marketing Manager MARS CHOCOLATE US •Susan Barkalow, Shopper Marketing Team Leader •Natalie Sellfors, Shopper Marketing Manager MARS PETCARE • Jeff Hingher, Shopper Marketing Manager • Dustin Lehner, National Team Lead for Shopper Marketing & Insights MATTEL • Meredith Jang, Director, Shopper Insights & Analytics •Kevin Kuehler, Director, Customer Marketing MAXPOINT •Tom Dolan, VP, Enterprise Solutions •Matt Knust, Director of Shopper Marketing MEIJER INC. •Lanny Curtis, Director, Customer Marketing •Michael Ross, VP, Customer Marketing & Emerging Technology MENASHA PACKAGING CO. •Brian Mumau, EVP, Business Development • Will Phillips, Director, Retail Insights MEYER CORP. •Ingrid Ellerbrock, Senior Director of Consumer & Shopper Marketing MILLERCOORS •Kathleen Blum, Senior Marketing Manager, Shopper & Channel Insights •Dan Hennessy, VP, Channel Marketing • Royce Wills, Director, Customer Marketing MONDELEZ INTERNATIONAL •Steve McGowan, Director of Shopper Marketing • Michael Tilley, Associate Director, Shopper Marketing & Strategic Partnerships •Kim Yansen, Director, Field Shopper Marketing NESTLÉ USA •Joe Radabaugh, Division VP, Category and Shopper Excellence •Jill Schermerhorn, Team Leader, Shopper Marketing • Linsey Walker, Shopper Engagement Strategist REVTRAX • Mel Liebergall, VP, Channel & Partner Development • Jonathan Treiber, CEO OWNERIQ INC. •Charlie Guevara, VP, Sales • Steve Ustaris, SVP, Marketing ROCKTENN MERCHANDISING DISPLAYS •Jon Kramer, CMO •Tim Sullivan, VP, Sales PEPSICO (BEVERAGE) • Bryan Jones, Senior Director Shopper Marketing • Esperanza Teasdale, Senior Director, Shopper Marketing PEPSICO (QUAKER) • Jackie Clifton, Director, Shopper Marketer • Ana Fernandez, Senior Director, Shopper Marketing & Insights • Katie Schiavone, Director, Shopper Marketing PERNOD RICARD USA • Scot Henderson, Director, Customer Solutions •Tim Murphy, VP, Marketing, Absolut Vodka •Karen Quach, Division Marketing Director PFIZER • Chuck Meyer-Hanover, Director, Shopper Category & Insights PHILIPS CONSUMER LIFESTYLE •Kelly Downey, VP, Digital & Shopper Solutions • Monica Young, Senior Shopper Marketing Manager PROCTER & GAMBLE •Lynn Neal, NA Retail Strategy Leader •Stephanie Robertson, Associate Director, Shopper Marketing RB •Sam Gagliardi, Marketing Director, Digital Shopper Solutions •Taryn Mitchell, Global VP Sales, Digital Channel •Cheryl Policastro, Shopper Marketing Team Leader RED BULL NORTH AMERICA INC. • Melissa Leggett-Accad, Director, Trade Marketing RETAIL SOLUTIONS INC. (RSI) •Marie Jackson, CMO • Michael Quinn, General Manager & CMO, Digital Media, Consumer Packaged Goods & Retail SAFEWAY INC. •Deb Fifles, VP, Consumer & Shopper Insights •Dimitri Haloulos, Group VP, Shopper Marketing SC JOHNSON & SON INC. • Nicole Abramson, Shopper Marketing Manager • Amy Dragland-Johnson, Director, Shopper Marketing • Brigitte Shreiner, Senior Shopper Marketing Manager SHELFBUCKS • Jim Banks, VP, Sales • Catherine Lindner, CMO SHOPTOLOGY • Charlie Anderson, CEO •Julie Quick, SVP Head of Planning & Insights SONOCO DISPLAY AND PACKAGING • Philippe Erhart, Division VP, Sales •Jeff Tomaszewski, VP & General Manager STARBUCKS COFFEE CO. • Rachel Chambers, Director, Shopper Marketing & Shopper Insights SUN PRODUCTS CORP. •Jennifer Adams, Director, Shopper Activation TEMPT IN-STORE PRODUCTIONS POWERED BY QUAD/GRAPHICS •Mike Draver, President • Maura Packham, VP, Marketing & Communications THE MARS AGENCY •Fern Grant, EVP, Strategic Planning •Rob Rivenburgh, COO TIME INC. RETAIL • Jennifer Marchant, VP, Customer Marketing •Bill Romollino, VP, Shopper Insights •Troy Stratton, Director of Retail Operations & Display TPN • Sarah Cunningham, Senior Managing Director, Client Service & Development • Nancy Shamberg, Managing Director, Shopper Marketing TYSON FOODS • Wendyjean Bennett, Director, Customer Marketing Sales Services •Christopher Witte, VP, Customer Development UBISOFT •Paul Audino, Shopper Marketing Manager UNILEVER •Kevin Flagg, Senior Director Shopper Marketing • Dawn Hedgepeth, Marketing Director, U.S. Skin Care UNIVERSAL •Joe Battaglia, EVP •Francisco De Jesús, President & CEO WALGREEN CO. • Romina D’Andrea, Director, Insights • Louis Dorado, Director, Space Planning & Visual Merchandising •Cherise Ordlock, Senior Director, E-Commerce Planning & Analysis WALMART STORES INC. •Andy Murray, SVP, Creative •Matt Parry, Senior Director, Shopper Marketing WHITEWAVE FOODS •Erin Anderson, Shopper Marketing Manager • James Blumberg, Director, Integrated Marketing • Jon Searle, Associate Marketing Manager WILLIAM WRIGLEY JR. CO. •Matt Herrmann, Associate Brand Manager, Shopper Marketing • Lena Lewis, Senior Manager, Shopper Marketing •Kelley Walczak, Senior Associate Brand Manager, Shopper Marketing, Walmart & Sam’s Club WORLD KITCHEN • Sarah Ebner, Senior Manager, Marketplace Execution • Rita Finley, Director, Category & Shopper Insights •Michelle Malkin, VP, Customer Development & Packaging TO P- WHAT WOULD YOU LIKE TO CHANGE TODAY? It’s the question that defines and inspires us. We drive behavior change at every point of persuasion: with insights, ideas and creativity that inspire people to buy. We are the global brand engagement agency of FCB. We stand for Retail, Engagement and Digital. General Inquiries [email protected] New Business [email protected] *#5 Agency on The Hub Top 20, the annual survey of excellence in shopper marketing. 5 SH O PP ER M AR KE TI NG AG EN C Y* 6 PROGRAMS SOLUTION PROVIDER NEWS Crossmark Appoints Schuckenbrock to CEO Consumer brand marketing services provider Crossmark, Plano, Texas, has appointed Steve Schuckenbrock as its new chief executive officer, moving current CEO Ben Fischer to the position of chairman of the board to play an integral role in the leadership transition. Schuckenbrock brings more than 30 years of executive leadership experience with companies such as Dell, PepsiCo, Frito-Lay and IBM, as well as a deep expertise in the areas of sales, marketing and technology. He most recently served as the president of Dell Services, where he led strategic initiatives to increase customer satisfaction. “We are thrilled to welcome Steve to Crossmark,” Fischer said in a release. “His breadth of experience in leading and growing global service organizations will benefit our employees, clients and customers around the world.” MaxPoint Partners With RSi: Online ad tech firm MaxPoint, Raleigh, North Carolina, has partnered with point-of-sale analytics company Retail Solutions Inc. (RSi), Mountain View, California, making it possible to dynamically target, optimize and measure the sales impact and ROI from digital advertising programs run on behalf of CPG companies and retailers. MaxPoint can now connect RSi’s daily sales and inventory data from nearly 125,000 stores with hyperlocal store-level advertising programs to allow brands and retailers to maximize the impact of their new product launches, promotions and seasonal offerings. “We are now able to offer manufacturers, retailers and shopper marketers a complete digital solution that closes the ROI loop,” Tom Dolan, MaxPoint’s SVP of enterprise and shopper marketing solutions, said in a release. G-P Corrugated Introduces Packaging Solution: GeorgiaPacific Corrugated has developed a packaging solution the manufacturer says will drive consumer purchase intent, enhance the shopper’s experience and increase sales. Brand Ready Packaging (BRP) is a collaborative process that marries G-P’s research and insights with its CPG partners’ expertise about their own brands to create a more accessible solution that the Atlanta-based supplier says 90% of consumers in focus groups strongly preferred over a standard stocked shelf. The key differentiators include a stronger perforation solution (Clean and Easy-Perf) designed to work in tandem with high graphics (Color-Box capability) that are able to communicate a brand’s story more powerfully than today’s industry-standard, retail-ready packaging options. Deep Focus Lands Nestlé Account: New York-based digital marketing agency Deep Focus has been named digital and social media agency of record for Nestlé-Waters’ spring water brands Poland Spring, Zephyrhills and Ice Mountain. The selection comes shortly after Nestlé’s decision to shift lead agencies on the account to FCB Garfinkel from McCann-Erickson, both part of Interpublic Group. The manufacturer recently cut back on its number of digital shops, with Deep Focus, 360i, Huge and a handful of others making the final cut. Send your solution provider news – new projects and programs with brands and retailers – to [email protected]. SHOPPER MARKETING JANUARY 2015 Barnie’s Thinks Small for Big Growth Partnership with Delhaize’s Food Lion and Hannaford helps brand push single-serve convenience By Chris Gelbach Orlando, Fla. — Specialty coffee retailer Barnie’s CoffeeKitchen is experiencing unprecedented retail expansion by thinking small with a focus on single-serve convenience. The approach represents a major shift for the 34-year-old company, which once operated more than 120 cafes in malls throughout the Southeast U.S. “About 10 years ago, it became apparent that the mall strategy wasn’t going to work any longer – from the way consumers were buying product to the fact that being in a mall wasn’t convenient at all for them,” says Sonya Hardy, Barnie’s CoffeeKitchen senior vice president of marketing and strategic brand relations. “So we started to scale back that part of the business and grew the CPG side.” Barnie’s started with bagged coffee. Then, after Keurig Green Mountain’s K-Cup patent expired in 2012, Barnie’s got a single-cup-brewed patent of its own. “We were able to get into some new patented technologies for our cups, which allowed us to put more coffee in the cup than our competitors,” Hardy says. The technology permits 13.5 grams of coffee in a standard single-serve cup vs. the typical 9 to 11 ounces. According to Hardy, it also features a channel design that extracts the coffee in a way that more closely resembles a normal brewing process. In addition to the new CupUp singleserve products, which debuted in June 2014, the company further emphasized on-the-go convenience with the simultaneous launch of its Brewsticks line of single-serve liquid instant coffee. Barnie’s introduced a new company website in June along with the new products. The brand also ramped up activity on its social media sites, initially with a focus on Southeastern states where it had existing brand awareness. Focused on retail expansion, the company had a major presence at the Summer Fancy Food Show in New York, where thousands of buyers sampled the new products. A partnership with Delhaize America to carry the new products has already nearly doubled the company’s store count, according to Hardy. “We’re probably in about 2,700 stores now, and have expanded from the Southeast into the Northeast,” she says. To promote the new products in Delhaize’s Food Lion and Hannaford stores, Barnie’s offered instant redeemable coupons (IRCs) to encourage trial on all the products, as well as a complimentary Brewstick and CupUp box in certain locations. On shelves, the packaging for the new products focuses on consumer awareness and education. The entire back panel of the CupUp boxes is used to describe the patented channel design. Likewise, the Brewsticks box also focuses on consumer benefits; the various panels illustrating the different ways the product can be used on the go. Building on an existing relationship with Publix, Barnie’s is also scheduled to launch its first “buy one, get one” Barnie’s CoffeeKitchen has evolved from a chain of mall cafes into a successful CPG brand now available in nearly 3,000 stores along the East Coast, including Delhaize, Publix, Winn-Dixie, H-E-B and Walmart locations. program with the chain. It will be advertised in circulars as well as through front-of-store secondary placement. Barnie’s also participates in Publix Advantage Buy flyers and is working on a digital coupon with the grocer. The brand also increased its investment in pay-per-click advertising and search banners to drive customers to stores. In stores, seasonal floor displays feature both the CupUp and the bag coffee formats. Promoting the brand’s Santa’s White Christmas flavor – its year-round bestseller – one display features a nostalgic design based on the Bing Crosby “White Christmas” album cover. In addition to Publix and Delhaize stores, the brand is also available in H-E-B, Walmart and Winn-Dixie locations. Barnie’s is focused on continuing its growth nationally by using a flexible, customized approach to retail partnerships. “We are definitely aware that getting on the shelf is just the first step,” says Hardy. “Our immediate emphasis for the next six months is on an impactful, trial, branding element to the campaign where we’ll be heavy on the IRCs, complimentary products and brand awareness.” The company will ultimately define success for the campaign based on sales data and ongoing retail expansion. The campaign’s creative elements were handled in-house. SM BRAND: Barnie’s CoffeeKitchen KEY INSIGHT: The brand’s “mall” strategy wasn’t working as consumers were buying product in different ways and malls stores weren’t convenient. ACTIVATION: Barnie’s launched two new single-serve products in June supported by instant redeemable coupons and “buy one, get one” offers to encourage trial. In stores, seasonal floor displays feature the new products and packaging focuses on consumer awareness to help emphasize convenience. * Votee Topn Marketin Solutioo 2014 SHOPPER MARKETING EXPO SYMPOSIUM Let the Commer$ation begin 2014 Shopper Marketing Expo Your shopper marketing platform Connect across full path to purchase Connect with us: [email protected] Incent with cash or store cash Download Jingit App: Text “JINGIT” to 546448 *NextGen Digital Touchpoints on the Path to Purchase Symposium Available at over 100,000 retail locations 8 PROGRAMS SHOPPER MARKETING JANUARY 2015 Embrace Mobile’s Influence on Consumer Behavior By Cyndi Loza Minneapolis — Mobile has fundamentally changed consumer behavior and, as a result, marketing best practices, according to Michael Becker, managing partner and chief executive officer at San Franciscobased mobile marketing advisory firm mCordis. “When someone expresses a need through this device,” said Becker, holding an iPhone during a presentation at the Shopper Marketing Conference Expo in October, “or any number of the different types of devices they may have, you need to make sure that you’re there in a contextually relevant way.” Product placement in full-page interstitials, home-screen advertising and native advertising are just a few of the ways to reach consumers through mobile. Despite the method, however, “it’s critically important to recognize that you have to be doing these advertising models depending on your audience,” Becker stressed. Heineken USA’s 2014 campaign promoting its tequila-infused beer brand, Desperados, was a good example of what to do – and not do – to reach an intended audience, Becker said. Aimed at the coveted Millennial consumer, the brand had difficulties reaching its intended audience. “The retailers were saying, ‘Give me a multimil- lion-dollar media buy on TV and I’ll stock it on the shelves for you because that’s what my boss will see and ... I’ll trust that you’ll market it for me.’ And, guess what? Zero awareness,” Becker said. “It didn’t work. [Millennials are] not watching TV. That’s not where that consumer is.” After shifting its efforts over to native advertising, Desperados saw a 23% increase of awareness within three months, according to Becker. “Mobile has changed consumer behavior forever and we need to embrace that and when you’re thinking about that realize that it’s not about the technology … it’s about cultural practices,” he said. Becker explained mobile and digital has changed consumer expectations to want omnichannel, convenience, engagement, participation, experience, adventure and real-time dialogue. “Not real-time messaging, not real-time ads, not send me a coupon in my face. I want a dialogue.” Becker also challenged retailers and brands to be more than just a merchant and supplier. “How are you becoming not just a distributor of products or organization that has stuff on a showroom floor or on a website, but actually a platform and a publisher of services?” he said. THE VIEW FROM “Not real-time messaging, not real-time ads, not send me a coupon in my face. I want a dialogue.” Michael Becker, managing partner and chief executive officer, mCordis Walgreens in 2014, for example, encouraged third-party developers to integrate the retailer’s Balance Rewards application program interface (API) into their apps through a contest awarding $13,000 in prizes. Through these integrations, Walgreens loyalty cardholders can earn points via their third-party health and wellness apps. GenieMD, HoMedics, LifeTrak, Lose It! and RunKeeper are among the apps that have already integrated the Balance Rewards API. Becker also cited The Happy Kitten Co.’s GranataPet “Check in! Snack out!” Focus: Graduation Looking back to help with the planning ahead campaign in 2011 as a good example of merging the digital and physical world. Meant to attract pet owners walking their dogs, street-level billboards promoting the pet-food brand encouraged Foursquare users to check-in to the billboard to receive a free sample of the product in a bowl for their pet. “When you look at this path to purchase you have to realize that there is both this online and offline component and you need to manage that circadian rhythm as you engage and interact with that consumer throughout that journey,” Becker said. SM The Path to Purchase Institute’s Online Advertising Survey & Insights Service (OASIS) monitors leading retailer websites to collect digital advertising content and organize it for competitive, reporting and intelligence needs. CVS/Pharmacy logo horizontal 4-color process uncoated File Name: CVS_H_CMYK_uncoat.eps Amazon.com BestBuy.com CVS.com Kroger.com SamsClub.com Target.com ToysRUs.com Walmart.com May 1, 2014 May 11, 2014 May 16, 2014 May 11, 2014 May 2, 2014 May 13, 2014 May 8, 2014 May 28, 2014 Retailers’ themes Multiple, including: Graduation Gifts in Electronics; Congrats Grad!; Class of 2014 Graduation Gifts Multiple, including: The Latest for the Greatest Grad; Find the Perfect Graduation Gifts None None None Top Picks for Grads and Dads; Dads & Grads, Celebrate With Custom Cards & Invitations None Great Gifts 4 Grads; Save on Top Gifts Grads Love Categories employing Graduation-themed ads* Amazon Corporate, Computers & Tablets Best Buy Corporate Office/School Supplies, Computers & Tablets, Computer Related Office/School Supplies Camera & Camcorders, Computer Related, Computers & Tablets, Mobile, Candy, Home Audio Target Corporate, Home Entertainment, Mobile, Camera & Camcorders, Computers & Tablets Computer Related, Computers & Tablets, Camera & Camcorders, Small Appliances, Candy, Apps & Software Walmart Corporate, Home Audio Top categories overall* Amazon Corporate, Financial, Automotive Manufacturer, General Service, Apps & Software Best Buy Corporate, Computer Related, Computers & Tablets, Mobile, Home Audio Skin Care, CVS Corporate, Gastrointestinal, Candy, Hair Care Dairy, Condiments & Sauces, Personal Care, Kroger Corporate, Office/School Supplies Automotive, Candy, Gastrointestinal, Laundry, Water Home Entertainment, Pet Care, Target Corporate, Gastrointestinal, Skin Care Babies R Us/Toys R Us Corporate, General Service, Baby Gear, Water, Toys Walmart Corporate, Pet Care, Auto Insurance, Skin Care, Large Appliances Top brands employing Graduation-themed ads* Amazon Corporate, Dell Best Buy Corporate American Greetings, Dell, Intel Hallmark Shutterfly, Dell, Intel, HP, Verizon, Tiny Prints, M&M’s, Samsung, Beats Audio, AT&T Wireless Target Corporate, “The Wolf of Wall Street,” “Anchorman 2,” “Lone Survivor,” “300: Rise of an Empire,” Verizon, Shutterfly, Dell Intel, Dell, Shutterfly, Keurig, Tiny Prints, M&M’s, Just Wink, Princess Cruises, Toys R Us Corporate Walmart Corporate, Beats Audio Top brands overall* Amazon Corporate, American Express, Ford, Capital One, Amazon Prime, Bose Best Buy Corporate, Intel, HP, Samsung, Sony, Acer CVS Corporate, Neutrogena, Crest, Zantac, Cottonelle, Prilosec Silk, Unilever Corporate, Colgate, Hallmark, Dove, Axe Sam’s Club Corporate, Mobile, Nexium, Vitamin Water Zero, First Data, Dove Xfinity, Target Corporate, Nexium, Olay, Stackerz, Pantene Babies R Us/Toys R Us Corporate, Weight Watchers, LifeLock, Huggies, Evenflo, Pampers Walmart Corporate, State Farm, Neato Robotics, Orange Glow, Hallmark, Family Mobile June 29, 2014 May 28, 2014 June 6, 2014 May 17, 2014 May 10, 2014 July 4, 2014 June 29, 2014 June 5, 2014 First Graduationthemed ad appearance The day with the most Graduation-themed ads *For ad appearances May 1 through July 5, 2015 Note: Corporate ads comprise retailer ads and retailer campaigns INSTITUTE ANALYSIS: We determined the prime “Graduation” advertising period to be May 1 through July 5 based on the activity on these sites. The number of Graduation-themed ad appearances was 2.5 times higher in 2014 than in 2013. Of the sites showcased here, only Amazon.com and ToysRUs.com didn’t show a 2014 increase. Target.com, CVS.com and Amazon.com accounted for 76% of the total Graduation-themed ad appearances on these sites. American Greetings (on CVS.com) and Hallmark (on Kroger.com) represented 48% of the total Graduation-themed ad appearances on the sites OASIS monitors. Don’t just display. ©2015 Rock-Tenn Shared Services, LLC, Norcross, GA. All rights reserved. Dazzle. A RockTenn display delivers more of the wow factor. Like this interactive floorstand for Air Optix ® Colors. As the leading producer of in-store displays, we understand how to win at retail. How to translate insights into innovation. Maybe we can help you add a little extra dazzle to your next display? Kathy McGowan-Carnes | 855.229.2163 www.rocktenndisplays.com More in Store. Less Out-of-Pocket.® SHOPPER MARKETING JANUARY 2015 Hershey, Mondelez Grow S’mores at Target THE ART OF MERCHANDISING TM By Betsy Spethmann Minneapolis — The Hershey Co., Mondelez International and Kraft Foods Group brands have partnered for 20 years on national promotions for s’mores – that gooey treat made with Hershey’s chocolate, Mondelez’s Honey Maid grahams and Kraft’s Jet-Puffed marshmallows. Over the last seven years, the strategy has gone from a seasonal, April-to-September promotion to a year-round, 360-degree activation. While sales continue to rise every year and the brands are exceeding their KPI targets, according to Michael Klei, senior manager of shopper and customer marketing at Hershey, and Steve McGowan, director of shopper marketing at Mondelez, the companies saw a big opportunity for growth in 2013: bringing their brands to life at Target stores in a guest-centric way. brought the brands out of the candy & snacks aisle. Results: a 214% basket lift, plus a jump in concurrent purchases (41%, up 6 points from 2013). That success has prompted Hershey and Mondelez to collaborate even more. The two companies agreed on four key elements for future s’mores marketing at Target: Understand the ways that moms purchase s’mores ingredients; and help moms feel good about the purchase; alleviate moms’ guilt about serving indulgent snacks; help moms remember that their families’ treats came from Target. Hershey and Mondelez will pursue four key areas to drive their strategy with Target for the next few years: nBuild scale promotions. With consumer insights and its s’mores program as a model, Hershey and Mondelez Mondelez International’s Steve McGowan, left, and Hershey’s Michael Kei explain how they have brought their brands to life at Target. HOOKS | SHELF MERCHANDISING | LABELING WWW.TRIONONLINE.COM | 800-444-4665 ©2015 Trion Industries, Inc. During a presentation at the Shopper Marketing Conference & Expo in October, Klei and McGowan said that s’mores are about family, creativity and inspiration – qualities that resonate at Target. Hershey and Mondelez decided to use this insight to make their program more inspiring to shoppers. The team reviewed its past performance and saw room for improvement in three areas: planning, collaboration and execution. The goal was to extend Target’s typical timeline for planning, collaborate by pooling resources to create the best possible program for Target, and execute with excellence. The team pinned its planning process on two of Target’s own strategies: grow busy families, and win seasons. In summer – a very busy season at Target – confections and snacks can build baskets by driving concurrent purchases as shoppers buy all the ingredients for s’mores. Hershey and Mondelez leveraged their deepest data to date on the Target guest, including concurrent purchases, basket lift and affinity. They analyzed the data from each brand’s perspective to set their benchmark and goal. Execution included special displays and endcaps. The results: a 213% basket lift for participating brands. For 2014, the team started planning three months earlier and brought Target into the planning process early to create a more holistic program using all partners’ collective assets and insights. Two goals shaped planning: to reach Target shoppers more before they’re in-store, and to integrate digital into the program. Digital elements gave moms ideas for variations on homemade s’mores; exclusive recipes gave Target something to own in the marketplace. Activities and displays are improving other scale promotions, starting with their March Madness joint effort. Shoppers told the CPGs that the 2013 March Madness promotion was too complicated; Hershey and Mondelez simplified with a one-stop shop for March Madness party supplies, anchored by Reese’s Cups sporting basketball graphics. nDrive merchandising solutions. The CPGs create displays leveraging core equity of key brands, such as Oreo (think Double Stuf Racing League), and recipes for key seasons. nOffer innovation. To promote Hershey’s Lancaster Caramels, Hershey and Mondelez paired them with Hershey Kisses sandwiched between Ritz crackers (a Mondelez brand) and microwaved for a warm afterschool snack. The ingredients were merchandised together. nLeverage digital. Hershey and Mondelez approach digital differently; meanwhile, Target wants to expand its digital endeavors, too. The three partners want to get more mileage by working together. Hershey and Mondelez agree that the longer planning horizon is a critical element to their success, with time built in for revisions from all partners to evolve the concepts – and to incorporate Target’s goals into the CPGs’ planning. And what of categories where Hershey and Mondelez compete? “When you work together year after year, you know where the places are that you can’t cross,” said McGowan. “The best defense is that consumer insights drive the planning, and consumers are buying the products – so we know we’re giving them SM what they want.” PROGRAMS 11 JANUARY 2015 SHOPPER MARKETING Coca-Cola Learns and Grows Via E-Commerce By Betsy Spethmann Minneapolis — The Coca-Cola Co. entered the e-commerce channel in early 2013 and learned a lot in the ensuing 18 months about how to connect with e-commerce audiences. This evolution has put a new twist on Coca-Cola’s traditional marketing goal: to have Coke within an arm’s length of desire. “Our legacy is about trucks and getting to stores; e-commerce is a whole new experience,” said John Mount, vice president, commercial operations & marketing, during a Shopper Marketing Conference & Expo presentation in October. “There are a lot of physical barriers for us. A 24-pack of Coke cans is heavy, and the drones won’t be able to carry them to people’s houses,” he joked. But e-commerce growth is real, especially among Millennials. Coca-Cola has pinpointed five ways that changes in shopping dynamics require the brand to adapt: nShopper-led dialogue spins out product purchase (and consumption) to the consumer’s social networks. nPersonalization is growing, even for high-volume products. nDigital data informs pricing. nMobile and social are part of the purchase: Marketers want people to buy the product, and then tweet about it. nIntegration of online and offline is more crucial than ever. The upshot, Mount said, is that brands must remain shopper-centric. “Using key insights, we want to give consumers a great user experience.” To tap those insights, according to copresenter Jennifer Brevick, Coca-Cola’s director of e-commerce, the e-commerce team began with syndicated research to understand the channel: How big is it, where is it going, what percent of e-commerce is grocery, what percent is beverage, and who are the major players? Then the team developed proprietary research to understand shoppers, beginning with panel research on e-commerce across four groups: those buying groceries online today; those buying groceries who buy beverages online; prospects (those not buying groceries online now but are open to it); and “no way” (those not open to the idea of buying groceries online). Coca-Cola found that young, affluent males are the most common online shopper. But that’s not the manufacturer’s target audience for e-commerce; the target is “Shopper Mom,” who fits the “prospects” category. “The early adopters are shopping online right now, but right around the corner is Shopper Mom, stocking up for the household,” Brevick said. The next step for insights was to network, internally – especially in Europe and Asia, where e-commerce is more mature – and with non-compete CPG partners whose e-commerce business is more established. Overall, the biggest lessons Coca-Cola has learned are: nYou can’t afford to not be on the shopping list. E-commerce “favorites” lists populate the shopping basket based on past purchases. In Europe, 84% of the time that Coke is in a basket, it’s from the favorites list. Coke can get on the “favorites” list by sampling (free, full-size package automatically affixes the product to the list), or as an ingredient for a meal such as “lasagna night” (ingredients are automatically included on the list). nBlanket fixes don’t usually work. E-retailers have about seven different delivery systems for brand images. It’s tough to update all seven delivery systems when Coke changes a brand’s graphics. The key is flexible fixes, not blanket revisions. nThis is not brick-and-mortar. European colleagues told the U.S. team not to take its brick-and-mortar store and upload it. The shopper is different, and wants different items (especially hard-to-find flavors) and shops in a different mindset. That makes it crucial to review brick-andmortar insights through a different filter. nE-commerce often is the opposite of expectation. Coke had one product that sold poorly in stores. “We thought it might sell well online, so we tested it in a small quantity,” Brevick said. “It’s now our third-biggest seller online.” n There’s always more to learn. New formats are coming up all the time, such as concierge formats like Google Shop Express. There are also new delivery methods (drones!) and new ways to mine, then act on data. Jen Brevick and John Mount detail Coca-Cola’s advances in the e-commerce channel. Braced with its learnings, Coca-Cola is working now to unify the way its brands are represented online, with consistent high-quality graphics across all platforms, SM Mount said. APPLIED LEARNING TO EMPOWER YOUR SUCCESS Structured professional development courses designed to help individuals become peak performers in shopper marketing-related roles Who Should Attend P2PLU > Brand Marketers > Shopper Marketers > Customer Marketers > Sales/Category/Management Leaders > Buyers/Merchants > Insights Professionals > Agency/Solution Providers P2PLU Class Schedule Call (773) 992-4423 to register for any of these public training events. Feb. 18-19 ........ Bentonville, AR Mar. 16.............. Chicago, IL Apr. 22-23 ........ Cincinnati, OH May 13-14 ........ Minneapolis, MN Jun. 24-26 ........ Chicago, IL REGISTER TODAY! www.p2pi.org/leadershipu An exclusive benefit for Institute Members Learn more and register to attend at www.p2pi.org/leadershipu or email [email protected] 12 PROGRAMS SHOPPER MARKETING JANUARY 2015 Albertsons Evolves Through Social Engagement By Sana Jafrani Minneapolis — Social engagement and relevancy of content are crucial to developing a brand’s personality and building loyalty, according to Karl Meinhardt, Albertsons vice president of social and digital marketing. “We’re walking into a world where content will be everything and relevancy of that content is the key,” he said during a presentation at the Shopper Marketing Conference & Expo in October. In a Q&A session led by Brad Robertson, senior vice president of marketing services at MyWebGrocer, Meinhardt detailed how he laid the groundwork for what has become Albertsons’ social engagement strategy, recognizing the importance of reaching consumers. “Social engagement became our way of connecting to people and gathering their information, making it more of a personalized conversation,” he said. While connecting to customers is key, Meinhardt also credited executive involvement and “buy-in” as key drivers in the success of an initiative. “If you can get your leaders to not only approve and endorse but also to actually participate [in what you’re doing], then you’ve got something,” he said “You get them to be evangelists about it. The other thing is to really communicate both wins and losses.” However, getting executives on board involved another critical component: digital teaching. “What I was trying to get everybody to understand was the power of data, and why we need to protect our data,” explained Meinhardt. Another important component of Meinhardt’s plan was building up “digital evangelists” by launching campaigns like the Karl Meinhardt has ensured that Albertsons is having personalized conversations with its customers. recent “Summer of Selfies,” which he hailed as a success while citing Albertsons ability to see the influence of behavior across marketing. The Coca-Cola Co.-sponsored campaign called for customers to submit photos with a Coca-Cola product for a chance to win a $75 prize. For the first time, Meinhardt said, Albertsons was able to see the face of their customers in a digital space. He noted that user-generated content is “way more influential” than anything Albertsons had to say as a brand. Executives at the company agreed and encouraged more of the same. In the fall of 2014, Albertsons launched a “Hairy N’ Scary Foto Contest,” encouraging customers to submit photos of their pets dressed in costume to a dedicated website for a chance to win a $250 donation to an animal shelter of their choice. “People like to participate,” said Meinhardt, “It also sets the tone for your brand’s personality. If you like to have fun, people like to have fun, and if you deliver it nicely with some entertainment, they’ll want to play.” He said that social engagement is a space that allows brands to communicate and hear from consumers, but that space is also important in shaping a brand’s personality. “I think social engagement participation is key to any shopper marketing tactic. If you connect with one person and they share with 200 people? You could ride that to the end of the earth,” he said. With a recent holiday effort called “Sweater Meals,” Albertsons enlisted registered dietitian Annessa Chumbley as the face of the campaign. It is a content strategy that spans from digital to in-store texts to online, providing consumers with recipe ideas for the holidays. Meinhardt stressed the importance of these “non-price conversations” with consumers. “My goal is to create a relationship that is fun, informative and drives value to our customers. If it’s not fun, then people aren’t going to enjoy it,” he said. “Our belief is that we’re participating for nanoseconds of attention out there, and we need to capitalize and capture it and SM execute on it.” Untitled-4 1 12/9/14 5:12 PM So when can I get this order? When do you need it? Would next Thursday be out of the question? Yeah, that’s not going to happen. Ok, when can I get it? You’ll have it all tomorrow. What? Hey, everything you need is in stock and ready to ship. Really? That’s amazing. That’s just how we do it. COME SAY HI TO BILL AT GLOBALSHOP BOOTH #2143 Bill White VP Operations and KinterCare Specialist Sometimes you know exactly what you need. Sometimes you want to talk to someone who really knows retail hardware. In either case, you’ll find that our team of experienced sales consultants, including Bill, is among the best in the business. We look forward to your call. 10K DIFFERENT RETAIL DISPLAY PRODUCTS IN STOCK AND READY TO SHIP | LOW PRICES | EXPERIENCED SALES CONSULTANTS 800.323.2389 KINTER.COM 14 PROGRAMS Ubisoft Continued from Page 1 value in utilizing a tremendous property like ‘Assassin’s Creed’ to make the product more exciting for consumers.” According to Ubisoft’s Scott Horowitz, a senior shopper marketing manager based in San Francisco, research shows that in-game content is highly valued by the gaming community. And while this kind of partnership to offer exclusive in-game downloadable content is not new for Ubisoft, Horowitz says the Edge partnership is the biggest such effort to date. “This purchase-to-unlock model allows our partners to own a piece of the core experience outside of the SHOPPER MARKETING JANUARY 2015 game,” Horowitz says. “We can get creative with what that content is – fun add-ons that bring value to the player – without breaking the immersion in the game.” The model also allows partners to access a rabid fan base that has already shown an appetite for “Assassin’s Creed” apparel, artwork and toys. There is even a popular series of “Assassin’s Creed” novels. According to Horowitz, exclusive downloadable content offers are becoming more commonplace as companies outside of the gaming space see value in these consumers. “The challenge for all parties will be how to keep these activities fresh year over year,” he says. Horowitz notes that a core tenet of the Cross-promotion of Edge shave gel and Ubisoft’s “Assassin’s Creed Unity” included the gel cans themselves as well as video game endcaps. “Assassin’s Creed” franchise is deep, immersive storytelling. This influenced the decision to partner with Edge. “We found a partner that was looking for the same thing – to get a deeper immersion with their consumer through activities they loved, such as gaming,” he says. The custom Edge cans appeared at food, drug and mass retailers for one to two months following the game’s release. The brands also partnered with Target stores on a promotion offering a $10 gift card to customers who purchased both the “Assassin’s Creed Unity” game and any limited-edition Edge shave gel can from Nov. 16-26. To bring shoppers into stores, the offer was highlighted on the “Edge Shave Zone” and “Assassin’s Creed” Facebook pages, on the Edge Twitter page, and through additional PR activity. According to Pietrini, Edge and Ubisoft worked together for a year to bring the Target promotion to life. “I think the retailer recognized the value of connecting two of the strongest brand equities within each respective category,” he says. “It is so hard to get the attention of younger males, so the retailer saw the opportunity to connect Edge and ‘Assassin’s Creed’ to drive synergies we wouldn’t have realized on our own.” In Target stores, a co-branded endcap display with a 3-D header card was used for two weeks following the video game launch. Additionally, Walmart had instore signage the week of the game launch highlighting the co-promotion. “This was a win-win for both companies and the consumer, and at the end of the day will help the retailer,” Pietrini says. “It will help bolster the ‘Assassin’s Creed Unity’ launch and continue to engage men with their grooming routines.” Pietrini says that Edge worked with social and digital agency Beeby Clark+Meyler and PR agency Edelman, both in New York, on consumer communications for the campaign, and that domo domo IMG, Monroe, Connecticut, and Cincinnati, was SM responsible for the package design. BRANDS: Edge and “Assassin’s Creed Unity” KEY INSIGHTS: The mostly Millennial male gaming community puts a high value on in-game content, allowing marketing partners the opportunity to reach the demographic through the purchaseto-unlock model. Total Merchandising Solutions for In-Store Marketers New Oxford, PA | (717) 624-3500 | www.timbar.com ACTIVATION: Limited-edition Edge shave gel cans featuring codes to unlock exclusive content for the new “Assassin’s Creed” game appeared at food, drug and mass retailers, while a specific promotion at Target offered $10 gift cards to shoppers who purchased both the game and the gel from Nov. 16 to 26. 16 SHOPPER MARKETING JANUARY 2015 In October 2014, Shopper Marketing magazine and the Path to Purchase Institute surveyed hundreds of CPG marketing executives for our annual Trends report. The questions were developed by the Institute’s editors, and among the topics we cover are survey mainstays such as budgets and collaboration, while we also take our deepest dives yet into technology, e-commerce and mobile payment. Additionally, we continue down a popular path from recent years by having respondents answer questions about and rate specific retailers. TRENDS2015 MOBILE PAYMENT & SHOPPER MARKETING By Dawn Klingensmith W hen the Google Wallet mobile payment app went public in September 2011, its debut was met with the sound of crickets, according to an industry insider. So, too, was the announcement in the spring of 2014 that Starbucks may license its highly successful mobile payment app to other retailers. By contrast, the release of Apple Pay, Apple’s mobile wallet initiative, “was greeted with a lot of media hoopla” including predictions that it will “change commerce forever,” wrote the Path to Purchase Institute’s Bill Schober in his October editorial. Does that mean mobile payment has finally come into its own? We posed the question to six shopper marketing professionals who know as much as anyone about the state of walletless payment. The short answer: not yet. While Google Wallet remains quietly in the background, the two contenders for dominance are Apple Pay and CurrentC, a pilot-stage system developed by the Merchant Customer Exchange (MCX) made up of retail giants including Walmart and Target. Whereas Apple Pay links to users’ credit cards, CurrentC takes payment directly from their bank accounts. This frees retailers from paying credit card processing fees but raises concerns for shoppers. “Consumers want to know, ‘What’s in it for me?’ before they’ll switch over from credit cards,” explains Terry Logan, group director, digital, at The Integer Group, a shopper marketing agency headquartered in Lakewood, Colorado. “Since MCX doesn’t link to credit cards, consumers are left wondering, ‘My cash back, my points, my miles – does it all get lost? With a credit card, the retailer pays the fees and I get the points. With MCX, the retailer avoids the fees, but do those savings get passed on to me?’” continued on page 24 Our Virtual Roundtable Cezar Kolodziej, president, Iris Mobile Patrick Moorhead, former VP, mobile brand development, Catalina Bryan Leach, founder and CEO, Ibotta Bryon Morrison, president, digital, The Marketing Arm Terry Logan, group director, digital, The Integer Group Joe Rogness, co-founder, Jingit What is the primary barrier to adoption of mobile payment What is the primary barriersystems? to adoption of mobile payment systems? Security concerns Privacy Lack of retail Lack of Lack of retail added Lackvalue of support Security concerns Privacy concerns concerns support added value Lack of shopper Lack ofinterest shopper interest Competing Competing systemsDon’t systems know AllAll Respondents Respondents 18.6% 18.6% 39.9% 5.2% 39.9% 17.3% 4% 4% 6.9% 6.9% 8.1% 5.2% 17.3% 8.1% Base: Consumer product marketers. N= 190. Source: Path to Purchase Institute/Shopper Marketing * Food & Beverage category includes packaged food, beverages, candy, beer, wine and liquor. Packaged Non-Food includes household items, pet food, personal care, cosmetics and OTC drugs. Specialty includes consumer electronics, sporting goods, appliances, hardware, auto, apparel, footwear and office supplies. Base: Consumer product marketers. N= 190. Source: Path to Purchase Institute/Shopper Marketing What effect will mobile payment have on your brand/job? * Food & Beverage category includes packaged food, beverages, candy, beer, wine and liquor. Packaged Non-Food includes household items, pet food, personal care, cosmetics and OTC drugs. Specialty includes consumer electronics, sporting goods, appliances, hardware, auto, apparel, footwear and office supplies. (sampling of responses) None Little to no effect None for the short term A lot in the future Hard to determine Impact the channel that the consumer wishes to shop Great for insights and potentially trial Impact how, when and where we target Improved customer targeting Expand opportunities to cross-promote Add value in ways that we have not yet identified Don’t know 18 TRENDS 2015 SHOPPER MARKETING JANUARY 2015 BUDGETS How has your path to purchase marketing budget changed? How will it change next year? What percentage of your total marketing budget will be devoted to the following disciplines in the next year? Past Year (FY 2014) Shopper Marketing Consumer Promotion 15.3 All Respondents Trade Promotion Digital Media (mobile, paid search, etc.) 18.7 Traditional Media (TV, print, etc.) 26.9 Other Increased more than 10% 13.1 15 24.9 21.7 12.6 18.5 24.5 21.7 15.4 18.5 1.4 22.5 18.5 0.8 MARKETING/ ADVERT./PROMOTIONS 13.1 23.5 21.8 MERCH./PACKAGING 16.7 19.2 17.5 15.4 80% Increased 0.1% to 10% 22.9 17 27 12.1 11.2 18.9 0% 20% 35.2 40% 60% 38.7 60% 8.3 15.5 0.1 19.1 80% 100% 40% Stayed the same 24.3 4.8 SALES OPS/CAT. MAN/TRADE MKTG. Increase 0.1% to 10% 31.7 RESEARCH 14.9 8.8 2.4 27.2 1.8 BRAND/PRODUCT MANAGEMENT By Respondent’s Job Functions/ Areas of Responsibility Increase more than 10% 9.8 SHOPPER MARKETING 20.4 Next Year (FY 2015) 100% Stay the same 45.7 40.6 20% Base: Consumer product marketers. N= 190. Source: Path to Purchase Institute/Shopper Marketing Decreased 0.1% to 10% Decrease 0.1% to 10% 11.3 * Food & Beverage category includes packaged food, beverages, candy, beer, wine and liquor. Packaged Non-Food includes household items, pet food, personal care, cosmetics and OTC drugs. Specialty includes consumer electronics, sporting goods, appliances, hardware, auto, apparel, footwear and office supplies. 10.4 0% Decreased more than 10% Decrease more than 10% 1.5 1.5 LOOKING BACK Base: Consumer product marketers. N = 261. Source: Path to Purchase Institute/Shopper Marketing FY 2013* Increased >10% Increased 0.1% to 10% Stayed the same Decreased 0.1% to 10% Decreased >10% FY 2012* FY 2011* 13% 15.4%10.8% 35.4% 29%42.8% 40.4% 46.9%31.5% 7.6% 6.2%11% 3.6% 2.5%3.9% *From our 2014, 2013 and 2012 Trends surveys, respectively SHOPPER MARKETING IMPACT Which of the following benefits of shopper marketing programs have you verified at your company? In terms of top-line growth, what impact has shopper marketing activity had on your brands? Compared with traditional trade, account-specific or consumer promotion Incremental sales growth INCREMENTAL SALES 68.7 INCREASED RETAILER SUPPORT All Respondents No significant growth 24.5 We still have not adequately measured the impact 13.8 61.7 67.2 PACKAGED FOOD & BEVERAGE STRONGER COLLABORATIVE RELATIONSHIPS 60.5 By Primary Products/Services of Respondent’s Company* INCREMENTAL VOLUME 49.2 SHORT-TERM ROI 22 65.8 PACKAGED NON-FOOD 33.8 13.8 52.4 SPECIALTY 20 45.1 All Respondents 12.2 13.3 66.7 BRAND AWARENESS GROWTH 37.9 GREATER THAN $1 BILLION BRAND SHARE 31.3 37.4 By Annual Sales of Respondent’s Company CATEGORY SHARE 35.4 MARKET BASKET INCREASE 18.8 0% 16.4 10% 63.8 17.9 20% 67.8 40% 60% 80% * Food & Beverage category includes packaged food, beverages, candy, beer, wine and liquor. Packaged Non-Food includes household items, pet food, personal care, cosmetics and OTC drugs. Specialty includes consumer electronics, sporting goods, appliances, hardware, auto, apparel, footwear and office supplies. LONG-TERM ROI 0% 17.4 LESS THAN $100 MILLION 14.3 17.9 58.6 $100 MILLION TO $1 BILLION 28.7 BRAND EQUITY GROWTH 10.1 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% Base: Consumer product marketers. N=195. Source: Path to Purchase Institute/Shopper Marketing 70% Base: Consumer product marketers. N= 190. Source: Path to Purchase Institute/Shopper Marketing 100% 20 TRENDS 2015 SHOPPER MARKETING JANUARY 2015 WORKING WITH RETAILERS How successful have the following retailers been in developing an effective omnichannel marketing strategy? What percentage of your shopper marketing programs are retailer-driven, brand-driven or truly collaborative? Completely driven by retailer objectives Mostly driven by retailer objectives A true collaboration Mostly driven by our own objectives Completely driven by our own objectives 1 = “Lagging behind” All Respondents 18.8% Average scores 3 = “Making progress” 5 = “Leading the pack” BEST BUY 3.64 WALMART 3.62 3.47 TARGET 20.9% 11% 20.5% 28.8% COSTCO 3.3 STAPLES 3.26 KROGER 3.25 3.17 WALGREENS 3.13 HOME DEPOT 3.11 OFFICEMAX 3.08 Base: Consumer product marketers. N= 190. Source: Path to Purchase Institute/Shopper Marketing LOWE'S 3.04 * Food & Beverage category includes packaged food, beverages, candy, beer, wine and liquor. Packaged Non-Food includes household items, pet food, personal care, cosmetics and OTC drugs. Generally, our in-store marketing activity is … (choose one) Specialty includes consumer electronics, sporting goods, appliances, hardware, auto, apparel, footwear and office supplies. CVS/PHARMACY 3.02 LOOKING BACK TRENDS 2010 OFFICE DEPOT 3 SAM'S CLUB PUBLIX 2.88 Mostly driven by retailer objectives 26.7% SAFEWAY 2.84 A 50/50 collaboration 41.8% 28.8% BJ'S WHOLESALE Mostly driven by our own objectives 2.76 MEIJER 2.71 6.8% Completely driven by retailer objectives 3.1% Completely driven by our own objectives H-E-B 2.64 STOP & SHOP/GIANT 2.61 SHOPRITE 2.58 2.49 RITE AID In working with retailers, which asset/initiative typically matters most for gaining approval for your programs? An activation plan based on strong shopper insights An iconic brand with strong equity among shoppers A strong supporting media plan Pairing up with a non-competing national brand Custom packaging, displays, promotions, etc. Solutions-focused content (e.g., "Easy Meals," "Brighter Smiles," etc.) Behind-the-scenes Pairing up with a collaboration (e.g., aisle non-competing private resets, category redesigns, etc.) label product All Respondents WINN-DIXIE/BI-LO 2.31 AB ACQUISITION 2.29 DOLLAR GENERAL 2.23 DELHAIZE/FOOD LION 2.19 A&P 2.1 2.05 FAMILY DOLLAR 1.65 KMART 1 2 3 4 N= 127 to 66, depending on retailer. Source: Path to Purchase Institute/Shopper Marketing 31.7% 0.6% 3.4% 3.4% 23% 8% Which retailers have a private-label strategy that is threatening sales of your brands? The top 10 out of 27 retailers 13.2% 16.7% Base: Consumer product marketers. N= 190. Source: Path to Purchase Institute/Shopper Marketing * Food & Beverage category includes packaged food, beverages, candy, beer, wine and liquor. Packaged Non-Food includes household items, pet food, personal care, cosmetics and OTC drugs. Specialty includes consumer electronics, sporting goods, appliances, hardware, auto, apparel, footwear and office supplies. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 WALMART TARGET KROGER CVS COSTCO WALGREENS SAFEWAY MEIJER PUBLIX SAM’S CLUB Base: Consumer product marketers. N= 99. Source: Path to Purchase Institute/Shopper Marketing TRENDS 2015 21 JANUARY 2015 SHOPPER MARKETING TECHNOLOGY When do you plan to make beacons/geo-fencing/ micro-location a part of your shopper marketing strategy? Already using regularly Already testing Plan to explore soon Not a priority at the moment Which e-commerce fulfillment method has the greatest potential to impact future CPG sales? Same-day home delivery Automatic replenishment Offsite pickup of online orders All Respondents All Respondents 22.9% 3.4% At-store pickup of online orders Mail-based (multiple-day) home delivery 60.2% 24.6% 18.7% 49.1% 3.5% 4.1% Base: Consumer product marketers. N= 190. Source: Path to Purchase Institute/Shopper Marketing By Annual Sales of Respondent’s Company 3.1% 4.6% 8.4% 15.9% 31.8% 20.8% 31.8% 15.9% 65.1% $100 MILLION TO $1 BILLION * Food & Beverage category includes packaged food, beverages, candy, beer, wine and liquor. Packaged Non-Food includes household items, pet food, personal care, cosmetics and OTC drugs. Specialty includes consumer electronics, sporting goods, appliances, hardware, auto, apparel, footwear and office supplies. Rank the following on their potential future impact on shopper marketing: Average Rank 70.8% 31.8% GREATER THAN $1 BILLION 13% LESS THAN $100 MILLION Base: Consumer product marketers. N= 190. Source: Path to Purchase Institute/Shopper Marketing * Food & Beverage category includes packaged food, beverages, candy, beer, wine and liquor. Packaged Non-Food includes household items, pet food, personal care, cosmetics and OTC drugs. Specialty includes consumer electronics, sporting goods, appliances, hardware, auto, apparel, footwear and office supplies. 1 2 3 4 5 THE INTERNET OF THINGS BEACONS MOBILE PAYMENT AUGMENTED REALITY DRONE DELIVERY Base: Consumer product marketers. N= 167. Source: Path to Purchase Institute/Shopper Marketing SHOPPER SEGMENTS Are you devoting part of your budget to target the value/low-income shopper? Yes How are you targeting low-income shoppers? (sampling of responses) Developing programs for specific store clusters No Coupons Highly targeted digital tactics as well as traditional media All Respondents Developed a fighter brand 54% With products that are nearly loss leaders in order to introduce consumers to our brand Discounts paired with solutions 46% Value messaging Good pricing and right-size packaging Optimal selection in value sizes By Annual Sales of Respondent’s Company Low price High-index SNAP markets and stores 39.7% 65.2% 50% 34.8% GREATER THAN $1 BILLION 50% 60.3% $100 MILLION TO $1 BILLION LESS THAN $100 MILLION Base: Consumer product marketers. N= 190. Source: Path to Purchase Institute/Shopper Marketing * Food & Beverage category includes packaged food, beverages, candy, beer, wine and liquor. Packaged Non-Food includes household items, pet food, personal care, cosmetics and OTC drugs. Specialty includes consumer electronics, sporting goods, appliances, hardware, auto, apparel, footwear and office supplies. Timing communication to align to SNAP payments Economic empathy programs that provide significant discounts Prioritizing the retailers that they frequent Walmart-targeted communications Dollar store programs 22 TRENDS 2015 SHOPPER MARKETING JANUARY 2015 WORKING WITH RETAILERS For any retailer that you work with regularly, how many months in advance does it plan its seasonal events? For any retailer that you work with regularly, typically how many months in advance of execution do you need to present a collaborative marketing proposal? Average months in advance 9.4 TARGET 9.27 WALMART KMART 7.6 MEIJER 6.61 6.85 KMART 9.62 WALGREENS 8.95 CVS/PHARMACY 8.07 RITE AID 7.58 HOME DEPOT 8.59 CVS/PHARMACY 8.53 RITE AID 8.44 6.8 6.3 LOWE'S 9 SAM'S CLUB 8.48 COSTCO 8.31 COSTCO WALGREENS HOME DEPOT 7.3 LOWE'S 8.13 BJ'S WHOLESALE 6.86 BJ'S WHOLESALE 8.7 WALMART 7.36 MEIJER 9.21 TARGET 7.78 SAM'S CLUB PUBLIX 8.31 KROGER 8.3 8 SHOPRITE 7 SAFEWAY 8.07 STOP & SHOP/GIANT 8 WINN-DIXIE/BI-LO 8.08 KROGER 7.31 WINN-DIXIE/BI-LO H-E-B 6.71 A&P STOP & SHOP/GIANT 7.28 PUBLIX 7.3 7.21 SHOPRITE 6.95 SAFEWAY A&P 6.8 DELHAIZE/FOOD LION 6.81 DELHAIZE/FOOD LION 6.7 H-E-B 6.09 AB ACQUISITION OFFICE DEPOT 6.45 7.2 6.07 AB ACQUISITION 6.5 OFFICE DEPOT 5.56 OFFICEMAX 6.22 OFFICEMAX 5.5 STAPLES 6.18 STAPLES 5.5 7.5 DOLLAR GENERAL FAMILY DOLLAR BEST BUY 8.09 DOLLAR GENERAL 7.32 7.57 FAMILY DOLLAR 7 BEST BUY 4.22 N= 127 to 66, depending on retailer. Source: Path to Purchase Institute/Shopper Marketing SURVEY METHODOLOGY In mid-October 2014, several thousand U.S.-based CPG marketing executives were emailed a questionnaire to be completed online. The names were drawn randomly from Shopper Marketing magazine subscription and Path to Purchase Institute membership lists, with an emphasis on those with director, manager or senior executive titles. From those emailings, 266 CPG marketing executives submitted full or partially completed surveys, with 166 filling out the questionnaire completely. Each respondent was entered into a drawing for a grand-prize Apple iPad mini. The data was compiled and cross-tabulated by Irwin Broh & Associates, Des Plaines, Illinois. FOR ALL CHARTS Respondents: Consumer product marketing executives. Please source all charts to: the Path to Purchase Institute/Shopper Marketing magazine. SPECIAL NOTES n The Food & Beverage category includes packaged food, beverages, candy, beer, wine and liquor. n n The Packaged Non-Food category includes household items, pet food, personal care, cosmetics and OTC drugs. The Specialty category includes consumer electronics, sporting goods, appliances, hardware, auto, apparel, footwear and office supplies. 24 TRENDS 2015 SHOPPER MARKETING JANUARY 2015 continued from page 16 I’m a brand marketer, I want to be able to go to a retail partner like Target and say, “Look, we not only drove awareness and sales of Pampers, but we rewarded shoppers with a currency that will drive them back to Target.” Mobile payment per se is not going to do that. PayPal, Square, wireless carrier-backed Softcard (formerly Isis) and Level Up are the other principal players in these early stages of mobile payment. To prevail or even stay in the game, players will have to incentivize shoppers to replace a simple credit-card swipe with some other payment method that is not likely to save them any time. This is where shopper marketing enters the picture, with offers, coupon tie-ins and promotions somehow built around the actual transaction. What that might look like is anyone’s guess. It’s not even safe to say that the smartphone will serve as the mobile wallet of the future, according to the experts who took part in our virtual roundtable. It does seem certain that mobile payment will eventually gain widespread adoption, but not before it solves an actual problem and provides additional payoffs. MOORHEAD: It comes back to that value-added experience. The experience provided around the transaction is where opportunities for CPG brands exist. You can do all kinds of things with mobile technology that you can’t do with a credit card like loyalty programs and promotions and personalized product offerings. MORRISON: If Apple or Google took a step back from payments and became a de facto for building shopping lists, we’d have a rich environment for product marketers because at that stage they could start to influence what’s on the list. That’s where I see shopper marketing and mobile payment coming together (in an app). The ability to market in the app after someone makes a purchase makes it possible to influence the next shopping trip. Do consumers want mobile payment? PATRICK MOORHEAD: I can walk my mom through all the advantages and how it’s intended to work, and then she’ll pull out her wallet and credit card and say, “This is easier.” And she’s right! Mobile payment still feels like a solution looking for a problem. JOE ROGNESS: Consumers don’t necessarily want mobile payment, but they want value. So how do we add value to drive adoption? At what point will consumers change their purchase behavior to receive value? A 50-cent savings probably isn’t enough for me to change how I buy stuff, but if I get 50 dollars off a high-value item, maybe I’ll go through the steps to try a new method of payment. What would make consumers come around? MOORHEAD: Payment is not the end game; for consumers, it doesn’t matter. It’s everything you can wrap around payment to make my life easier, make my shopping trip faster and save me money that’s going to drive adoption. People aren’t going to use it because it’s easier. It’s not. People will use it in exchange for value. BRYON MORRISON: We’ve been myopic in our view of mobile payment as the literal transaction. Mobile technology can provide real solutions, making the entire shopping experience better and making payments a nonissue – something that just kind of fades in the background. Say you open an app, scan products as you shop, total it up, pay with your device and you’re done. Shoppers consistently complain about standing in line, so if you eliminate that, you solve a real problem. What are the other barriers to adoption? MORRISON: The one that everyone brings up is ubiquity. Mobile payment needs to be everywhere or consumers won’t use it. you stop at Walgreens to pick up a prescription; you go to the doctor and pay your co-pay. That’s a lot of information. They can see those transactional pieces all the way through. They’ll say they don’t capture it, but at the end of the day, it’s there to be had. ROGNESS: As a consumer, I’ve heard about so many security breaches, so if I’m going to adopt mobile payment, how is that more or less secure than using a credit card? The consumer doesn’t know this new landscape. How do retailers fit into the equation? MOORHEAD: To Apple, at least, retailers represent a hurdle. Various retailers have come out and said they won’t accept Apple Pay on their mobile payment network and have gone as far as disabling their NCF. BRYAN LEACH: What Apple Pay is doing is, more or less, just housing a credit card. So it’s the same Visa or MasterCard that retailers have always dealt with; it’s just being held in a different format than the magnetic strip of a credit card. If it’s costing retailers the same, what’s their incentive? ROGNESS: Merchants want to avoid those interchange fees, and that’s why they started MCX. Let’s be honest. LOGAN: But the participating merchants – those are all big retailers that I might go to once a week or once a month. That’s not going to change my behavior. Until I can use the “Until there’s massive consumer adoption – [consumer product marketers] don’t care. Until there’s massive retail adoption – don’t care. And until someone figures out a way for brands to play in the mobile wallet space – don’t care.” Patrick Moorhead, former VP at Catalina CEZAR KOLODZIEJ: If I go to 10 different stores and only half of them accept my specific mobile payment but all of them take my credit card, I’m going to use my credit card. For mobile payment to work, everything must be integrated and converged into, ideally, one worldwide solution so I can use the same technology to pay at any location. MORRISON: There’s a whole host of other barriers that are just realities of using a device, like battery life. We’ve all had our phones die and it’s no big deal, but if I need to get out of a situation by paying for something with my phone, battery life becomes a real concern. Little things like that make us cling to our wallets a little longer. What about privacy and security? TERRY LOGAN: With all these retailers collecting all these data points – that could be scary. You go grocery shopping; same mobile payment at my gas station and coffee shop and clothing boutique, we won’t see widespread adoption. Until it’s everywhere, my mindset is to use a credit card because most stores accept it. LEACH: Retail-specific currencies may be where all this is headed. The future of mobile payment to me means housing different retail currencies on a mobile device as loyalty rewards – $10 for REI, $5 for Starbucks, $15 for Target. That, I think, is where mobile payment will go and where it actually becomes relevant to the shopper marketing world. What role will mobile payment play in shopper marketing? LEACH: With retail-specific currencies, consumers watch ads and learn about products, and once they buy a featured product they get digital currency for a specific retailer. If Do consumer product marketers care about mobile payment? ROGNESS: I think capturing a large portion of their national media budget is the key to widespread adoption. It doesn’t make sense for the merchant to offer merchantlevel discounts through a mobile payment platform – the math doesn’t add up. But the manufacturers of the products they sell have billions of advertising dollars and a lot to gain. MOORHEAD: I think marketers need to be in touch with what’s going on, but they don’t really have anything to care about until the principal parties solve their various issues. Until there’s massive consumer adoption – don’t care. Until there’s massive retail adoption – don’t care. And until someone figures out a way for brands to play in the mobile wallet space – don’t care. Has it come down to Apple Pay vs. MCX? ROGNESS: They’re the only two getting talked about right now. What’s fascinating is the omission of the third party, which is Google Wallet. True, since its launch there’ve been crickets around adoption, but I wouldn’t count those guys out. I think they’re going to let the space evolve a little bit and then reemerge. With all the advertising Google garners, they could really start to connect the dots and create an ecosystem from national brand to shopper. MOORHEAD: Google Wallet is still a player because of the amazing scale of Android. It’s available on pretty much any NCF-enabled Android phone that’s come out in the last three years, so there’s already massive infrastructure around Google Wallet. And let’s not forget the ancillary payment market, which is Square, PayPal and Level Up. Those aren’t to be trifled with. MORRISON: But in terms of working out the experience with the terminals in stores, Apple, Google and MCX are driving that. How will widespread adoption of mobile payment affect purchasing behavior? KOLODZIEJ: If this is the way we make all our purchases, it could provide reports on our spending trends and make us smarter, more efficient shoppers. LOGAN: I have three kids, so there are always eight containers of something in the refrigerator. The utility of the tool, regardless of the technology, should prevent redundant purchases and waste, but my spending might actually increase if it also shows me different benefit features. What will mobile payment ultimately look like? MORRISON: It may be difficult to standardize mobile payment. Technology changes all the time, and while we’re focusing on how this might work on our mobile phones, in reality we may see wearables – watches, rings, bracelets – outpace the smartphone. LOGAN: The phone is a clunky way of doing it compared SM to wearables with biometric sensors for security. DETAIL FREAK “THEY SAY I’M MORE DEMANDING THAN OUR CUSTOMERS. I’M NOT HAPPY UNTIL THE LAST PRODUCT IS SHOPPED FROM THE DISPLAY.” NANCY FORBES-CASTANEDA ACCOUNT COORDINATOR, TEAM LEAD Where Insights and Marketing Intersect SECOND CHOICE Where Insights and Marketing Intersect The devil is in the details. Great Northern Instore is the “go-to” resource for retailers and CPG manufacturers who value a “can-do” attitude. We understand that execution of program requirements, turning on a dime and expediting decision-making is the way to manage cost, quality and delivery. Need a few FIRSTwe’ve CHOICE detail freaks? No problem; got a deep bench. Call us at 800.558.4711. Where Insights and Marketing Intersect greatnortherncorp.com | Where Insights and Marketing Intersect 26 SHOPPER MARKETING JANUARY 2015 Customer TEAMS As manufacturers moved closer to their retail customers, a shift in the supplier-retailer relationship resulted Who’s Who in I By Sharon M. Goldman t was the ultimate “Field of Dreams” scenario: If you build it, they will come. In 1987, Procter & Gamble helped negotiate the first customer team operation, putting the manufacturer’s boots on the ground in a customer’s HQ city. It was in Bentonville, Arkansas – home of Walmart. A P&G study had found the company’s relationship with the retailer lacking: Category expansion was disappointing; divisions overlapped in calling on the client; and trust between the two organizations was as low as it had ever been. “[Walmart founder] Sam Walton’s comment was, ‘If I want to punish any of my buyers, I put them on P&G’s business,’” recalls former P&G executive Tom Muccio of the challenges the manufacturer faced in its Walmart business. “But then Sam said, ‘If you thought of my stores as an extension of your company, we would do business entirely differently.’ That became our mantra going forward.” Soon after, the CPG powerhouse had a customer team in place in Northwest Arkansas, ready to call on Walmart at a moment’s notice, 24/7. It didn’t take long for other CPGs to catch on. Muccio, who led the development of the Walmart team and ultimately served as leader of the P&G-Walmart global relationship through 2003, says there are more than 1,000 customer teams in Northwest Arkansas today consisting of at least six team members each. And other cities with a major retail headquarters have also become accustomed to thousands of customer team members living in the community – collaborating with retail employees in the home office, eating with them in local restaurants, and joining them for coffee or a drink. There’s Cincinnati for Kroger; Minneapolis for Target; Pleasanton, California, for Safeway; Issaquah, Washington, for Costco; and Deerfield, Illinois, for Walgreens. “These are whole communities that are there for the sole purpose of doing business with the retailer,” says Dina Howell, CEO of Saatchi & Saatchi X and previously P&G vice president, global media and brand operations, who worked for seven years on the Walmart team. “Work really runs at the speed of retail, so you don’t have time to figure out how to get a flight in to get work done. You have to be there, in person.” continued on page 34 CUSTOMER TEAMS at Walmart Abbott Nutrition EMILY ANDERSON, Associate Shopper Marketing Manager Anderson began her career as a sales representative with Abbott in Seattle but moved to Bentonville for a position in sales analytics for Abbott’s pediatrics brands at Walmart. Joining the company’s shopper marketing group in 2013, she now supports the development of shopper platforms based on insights that align brand and customer marketing objectives to create consumer-relevant programs. Alcon Labs ANDI PRATT, Senior Shopper Marketing Manager Pratt serves as Alcon’s strategic retailer engagement lead for Walmart and Target. She previously held positions at Nestlé as Walmart shopper marketing for frozen foods, JWT Action on the Nestlé account, and CJRW agency supporting Tyson Foods. Anheuser-Busch RANDY ORNSTEIN, Vice President of Sales, Walmart and Sam’s Club, Anheuser-Busch Team Ornstein works with the entire beerbuying team on its joint business plan process to drive beer sales. During his 10-year career at Anheuser-Busch, he has spent six in Bentonville on the category team in various positions and has also led category management efforts for the large-format channel in St. Louis. Barilla NINA MLYNEK , Shopper Marketing Manager Mlynek is responsible for strategy, planning and execution of retailerspecific marketing programs at Walmart, Target, Safeway and BJ’s. Prior to her work at Barilla, she helped develop 52 new frozen food corporate brand items for Kroger and also worked for a consumer experience research agency and clients such as P&G, Chrysler and ConAgra. JON WADE , Walmart Team Leader Wade has spent 14 years with Barilla America, serving as Walmart Team Leader for the past two years. He is responsible for leading a cross-functional team executing sales plans and developing strategic marketing programs for sell-in to Walmart. Prior to joining Barilla, Wade also held a variety of sales roles at Sara Lee. Bayer HealthCare MARYBETH GOODMAN, Vice President of Sales, National Mass SCOTT MATHEWS, Team Leader STEVE MORANTE , Vice President – Field Sales Beiersdorf CANDACE CLARK FRIEDMAN, National Account Manager 28 WHO’S WHO IN CUSTOMER TEAMS AT WALMART Bic Consumer Products USA MICHAEL SEVART, Director of Sales, Walmart/Sam’s Club Team Sevart has 20 years’ experience working in the retail channel, the last 15 directly managing the high-growth, high P&L focus of the Walmart/ Sam’s Club business. He has worked for Walmart CPG supplier teams for companies with brands such as Advil, Black & Decker and Welch’s, and has a proven track record of success at Walmart, earning multiple Supplier of the Year/Quarter awards. Big Heart Pet Brands HANK SCHEPERS, General Manager – Walmart Team Schepers leads a cross-functional team on the ground for Colgate’s largest global customer. His responsibilities include full P&L accountability, senior-level customer engagement, strategic planning and people development. Schepers has spent 29 years with the company, most recently serving as director for PetSmart. ConAgra Foods ROBERT ROSALES, Senior Vice President – Global Strategy JEFF RATCLIFF, Vice President, Sales, Walmart & Sam’s Club Team TOM LISI, Senior Director, Shopper Marketing Bissell Homecare Conair Corp. STEVE GALEN, Senior Global Director, Walmart/Sam’s Club Brown-Forman ELIZABETH OWENS, National Account Manager Bumble Bee Seafoods ALLAN JACKSON, Vice President, Business Development Campbell Soup Co. TIM KWAN, Vice President, Walmart U.S. Prior to joining Campbell three years ago, Kwan spent 10 years at Kraft Foods in the U.S. and Canada. He is currently focused on strategically aligning Walmart HQ and the customer in both the short and long term to achieve sustainable, profitable and enterprise-wide growth. Church & Dwight BRIAN LYNCH, Walmart Team Leader The Clorox Co. JEFF TOMBLIN, Customer Team Lead, Walmart The Coca-Cola Co. JAMES BECK , Group Vice President, Shopper Marketing Beck and his team lead shopper marketing collaboration efforts for Coca-Cola’s portfolio of brands with Walmart and Sam’s Club on both a national and local market level. His work history includes 16 years spanning brand, retail and digital signage and shopper marketing. ROB GEHRING, President, Walmart Global Team Colgate-Palmolive PATRICK CASEY, Shopper Marketing Director, Walmart Casey leads the shopper marketing strategy and execution for Colgate’s oral, personal care and home care businesses at Walmart. A marketing professional with 15 years of experience in brand/general management and innovation with Colgate-Palmolive, he has held senior-level Canadian, global marketing and U.S. positions. WILL MALATESTA , Walmart Team Leader Coty Beauty PAUL PRITCHARD, Vice President – Team Leader, Walmart & Sam’s Club A senior leader with more than 20 years of experience in global sales and marketing, ranging from startups to Fortune 100 companies, Pritchard acts as the general manager for a cross-functional team of 24 people responsible for more than 1,200 items at Walmart & Sam’s Club. Dell KELLY MATTRAN, Shopper Marketing Account Manager Mattran recently joined Dell’s shopper marketing account management group, where she works on the mass/ club channel and partners with sales teams to lead shopper marketing agenda for Dell in Walmart, Sam’s Club and Costco. Prior to joining Dell, she worked for PepsiCo and Starbucks Corp. Disney Consumer Products SUSAN VAN HOSEN, Senior Vice President, North America Sales With Disney in various roles since 2001, Van Hosen leads the Disney Integrated Retail team in the U.S. and Canada, driving retail strategy and sales for Disney Consumer Products licensing, Disney Publishing, Disney Interactive and Studio Home Entertainment for licensed and vertical merchandise at key retailers. Dr Pepper Snapple Group LEAH BACH, Shopper Marketing Manager – SHOPPER MARKETING JANUARY 2015 Buy and other retailers representing half of Electronic Arts’ U.S. revenue results. Prior to joining the company in 2003, he worked for Kimberly-Clark for 10 years. Energizer Personal Care ANDY KAUFMAN, Senior Director, Walmart Team Kaufman leads a cross-functional team to develop and grow Energizer Personal Care’s diverse portfolio for Walmart. With more than 20 years of experience, he has led customer and internal strategy teams to deliver shopper solutions across Fortune 500 retailers, brands and consumer channels. Fleet Laboratories KEVIN HANEY, Director of Trade & Category Development As the Walmart Team leader for Fleet Laboratories, Haney is responsible for strategic planning, tactical account management and all related Walmart headquarter management activities. He has also most recently held positions at McNeil Consumer Products/Johnson & Johnson and DowBrands Personal Care. General Mills JAY PICCONATTO, Marketing Associate Director – Shopper Marketing As the shopper marketing lead for General Mills focused on Walmart initiatives, Picconatto has spent the past 15 years with the CPG company in a variety of marketing roles across its portfolio, from Big G cereals to Green Giant vegetables. ADAM DILL, Vice President, Walmart Team U.S. Georgia-Pacific MONICA BREITHAUPT, Vice President, Retail Sales (Walmart & Sam’s Club) H.J. Heinz Co. MAX WETZEL , Vice President, Global Walmart Business Unit Hallmark Cards WAYNE STRICKLAND, President & GM, Walmart Team Strickland is responsible for the development of the long-term strategy for the Walmart business as well as delivering the top and bottom line goals for both Hallmark and Walmart. Hamilton Beach Brands Inc. JASON OGLESBY, Senior Director, Walmart Team Lead E&J Gallo Winery Hasbro Inc. JOE FARNAN, Vice President, Sales BARRY HARRIS, Interim Team Lead and Vice President of Sales - Team Walmart Electronic Arts Inc. T. RYAN JAMES, Senior Director of Sales and Team Leader, U.S. Mass Merchant Channel James is responsible for the sales performance at Walmart, Target, Best DEBORAH RUDZIK, Vice President/General Manager – Walmart Sales & Customer Strategic Marketing 678 443 2280 ARE YOU LEAVING MONEY ON THE TABLE? Shopper Conversion Capability Framework™ Accelerating Results thru Capability ©The Capre Group 2013 CAPRĒ GROUP CAN TRANSLATE BRAND EQUITY INTO SHOPPER CONVERSION AND PROFITABLE GROWTH Contact us to find out more. CAPREGROUP.COM | 678 – 443 -2280 | [email protected] 30 WHO’S WHO IN CUSTOMER TEAMS AT WALMART SHOPPER MARKETING JANUARY 2015 Heineken USA Kraft Foods Group Mead Johnson BETH FREEMAN, Commercial Marketing Manager GINA ALLGAIER , Marketing Director, Kraft Walmart Team Team Freeman has been supporting Walmart and Sam’s Club for the past 15 years at Kraft Foods, Clorox and Nestlé USA before taking on her current role at Heineken. She develops channel activation strategies for both Walmart and Sam’s Club on all of the brands within the beverage company’s portfolio. Having been in shopper marketing on Walmart since 2009, Allgaier partners shopper insights and data with cutting-edge technology to get results. By leveraging digital, social and mobile technology with earned engagement tools and inspirational in-store POS, she has been successful with multiple platforms such as Walmart’s annual s’mores campaign and the recent “Great American Cheeseburger” program. TODD PASTOR , National Account Director, Walmart & Sam’s Club Pastor develops short- and long-term strategy for Heineken USA in relation to Walmart and Sam’s Club. He leads the company’s national team focused against both retailers to align with key strategies and tactics to deliver sales growth while also delivering joint business plan goals and objectives for Heineken USA. The Hershey Co. JEFFREY HARSH, Walmart Team Leader JENNI PUSTINGER , Senior Director, Shopper Marketing, Walmart/Sam’s Club Team Pustinger joined The Hershey Co. nearly three years ago after 17 years in marketing at P&G. She is responsible for the marketing strategy and plans for the company at Walmart and Sam’s Club. J.M. Smucker Co. JEFF GREER , Vice President, Walmart Team The Jel Sert Co. JOSEPH BOUMA, Vice President, Walmart/Sam’s Team Bouma leads the strategy development and retail execution for Jel Sert’s Walmart and Sam’s Club team. He oversees the partnerships with both internal and external stakeholders, establishes and reports sales targets, and leads the company’s team of business development managers, retail execution managers and replenishment managers. Johnson & Johnson JAMES ELY, General Manager, Walmart Global Kellogg Co. AARON ELLEMAN, Senior Director, Shopper Marketing, Walmart & Sam’s Club SCOTT ROBERTS, Senior Vice President of Sales, Walmart Kimberly-Clark ARIST MASTORIDES, Vice President, Global Walmart Team Lead SARA G. LEONARD, Director of Shopper Marketing, Walmart Inc. Starting with shopper insights, Leonard oversees the shopper marketing team in building Kimberly-Clark’s brands to differentiate its customers and drive category growth with an omnichannel approach. She recently joined the company after working at Clorox in shopper marketing for 10 years. Land O’Lakes ZAK LOWE , Director – Walmart Inc. Team Lowe has spent the past 11 years with Land O’Lakes in various sales and customer/trade marketing assignments. He currently drives strategy, structure, human resources and execution of the cross-functional team including sales, retail, shopper activation, analytics, IT, etc., growing the Walmart business. Lindt & Sprungli STEVE WILSON, Team Leader – Walmart/Sam’s Club Mars Chocolate North America HARVEY MILLAR , Vice President Sales, Walmart Over the past 19 years with Mars Inc., Millar has worked in sales and marketing leadership positions across diverse customers, channels and international geographies. He now oversees the customer relationship with Walmart and all P&L for his business. He is also site director for the company’s office in Northwest Arkansas with more than 90 associates supporting the Mars chocolate, petcare, gum and food segments. ALLISHA WATKINS, Shopper Marketing Manager, Walmart & Sam’s Club Watkins brings more than 12 years of marketing, market research, strategic planning and project management experience to her role at Mars Chocolate for Walmart and Sam’s Club. She is focused on working cross-functionally with key customers, internal stakeholders and strategic partners to deliver the best solutions for shoppers. Mars Petcare SUSAN BENNETT, Shopper Marketing Manager Bennett is new to the Mars organization. She spent seven years with Kellogg, most recently in shopper marketing for Sam’s Club and prior to that as the company’s brand growth manager for the frozen breakfast and vegetable categories at Walmart. In her new position, she manages Mars Petcare shopper marketing for Walmart and Sam’s Club. RICK DAW, Managing Director, Walmart Global Team Daw has been with Mars for 34 years, working across confectionary, frozen and food divisions. He currently leads the company’s Walmart Inc. crossfunctional team as well as representing its Walmart Mars Petcare global team. JEFF BRAZZEAL , Director, U.S. Walmart The Mentholatum Co. CURT T. YEFTICH, Team Leader/Director of Sales, Walmart & Sam’s Club Yeftich manages the Bentonvillebased sales team, responsible for the Walmart & Sam’s Club U.S. business. He has more than 25 years of experience in the industry working for such companies as Pfizer, Mars Inc. and Chattem, and 14 years of experience working on the Walmart and Sam’s Club businesses. Mike’s Hard Lemonade BRIAN FELTER , Manager, Shopper Marketing Felter spent six years in various sales and marketing roles with AnheuserBusch before moving over to Mike’s Hard Lemonade three years ago. He is responsible for shopper marketing strategy and execution across Walmart and Sam’s Club, working with the internal key account team to develop in-store retail programs for the company’s portfolio of brands. VANESSA KING, Senior Key Account Manager King leads the Mike’s Hard sales efforts at Walmart and Sam’s Club. She works collaboratively with Mike’s shopper marketing team to develop in-store marketing and digital programs. MillerCoors BRIAN FEIRO, Vice President, National Account – Walmart & Sam’s Club Feiro leads the strategic and tactical plan development, alignment and execution to deliver on joint business metrics while growing capabilities of the MillerCoors system. Prior to his current position, he held various roles in distributor management, sales operations, planning strategy, revenue management and pricing strategy, as well as customer leadership. DAVID HARRIS, Customer Marketing Manager Harris works with MillerCoors’ marketing teams to bring programming to life in a way that engages Walmart and Sam’s Club shoppers. His background includes positions at agencies such as ThompsonMurray, Saatchi & Saatchi X and The Integer Group. Mondelez International TODD HANUS, Vice President, Sales, Walmart & Sam’s Club Hanus has 20 years’ experience in various R&D, trade marketing, strategy and sales roles. He currently leads Mondelez sales for both Walmart and Sam’s Club. CAROLYN KUTZ , Director, Category and Shopper Insights, Walmart and Sam’s Club Responsible for driving a comprehensive analytic approach to the interpretation of category performance and providing qualitative and quantitative assessments to the sales team, Kutz works with key stakeholders, competitive activity, and issues and/or accomplishments that might affect sales results. / // WE SWEAT THE DETAILS YOU SELL MORE · · · · OUTSTANDING DESIGN ALL UNDER ONE ROOF CRISP EXECUTION ON TIME & ON BUDGET INNSTORE MARKETING SOLUTIONS // 1 1 5 5 B LO O M F I E L D AV E . , C L I F TO N , N J 0 7 0 1 2 · T 9 7 3 - 9 1 6 - 2 8 0 4 · W W W. R E G I S T E R P R I N T G RO U P. C O M DESIGN & ENGINEERING · TEMPORARY & SEMI PERMANENT DISPLAYS · STORE DECOR · LARGE FORMAT LITHO & DIGITAL PRINTING · FINISHING, FULFILLMENT & DISTRIBUTION 32 WHO’S WHO IN CUSTOMER TEAMS AT WALMART LAUREN WRIGHT, Associate Director, Shopper Marketing Wright has spent her 10-year career in shopper marketing and sales roles supporting Walmart. She is currently responsible for shopper marketing strategy and activation that drives Mondelez business in Walmart and Sam’s Club. Prior to joining the company in 2013, she spent nearly five years with ConAgra Foods. Nestlé Purina PetCare DUSTIN PRUITT, Team Leader – Walmart Pruitt leads the sales and business development efforts of Nestlé Purina PetCare’s pet food and cat litter businesses at Walmart. TONY DIMATTIA , Senior Shopper Marketing Manager Nestlé USA STACEY HUTT, Manager, Field Shopper Marketing Hutt leads shopper marketing strategy and activation for Nestlé’s Walmart team across the portfolio of frozen brands. She has spent five years in CPG working for Nestlé USA. Her responsibilities have included retail sales for Southern California grocery accounts, analytics and most field shopper marketing. COREY KLEIN, Manager, Field Shopper Marketing Klein has spent the past 12 years working for both the Nestlé Purina and Nestlé USA operating companies. Recent responsibilities have included both corporate and field-based shopper marketing management roles. He currently leads shopper marketing strategy and activation on the Nestlé Walmart team across its portfolio of ambient and chilled brands. JACK SEE , Vice President Nice-Pak Products Inc. DIANE YITRI, Vice President of Sales Walmart/Sam’s Club Nickelodeon KEN MANTEL , Senior Vice President, Retail Development, Walmart & Sam’s Club Novartis Consumer Health MICHAEL SEWELL , Team Leader - Director of Sales, Walmart Sewell leads the U.S. Walmart Novartis team to deliver sales and profit objectives, developing and implementing short- and long-term strategic plans and developing the strategic relationship with the customer. Prior to joining the company two years ago, he also held positions at Pharmavite and Dial/Henkel for more than 25 years. Oberto Brands JEFF WAKELIN, Field Vice President of Sales, Mass/Club Wakelin is charged with managing Oberto Brands’ Walmart/Sam’s Club business. He drives innovation internally to win at both retailers. Starting his career at SmithKline Beecham, he has worked for both large and small companies. PepsiCo MICHAEL DEL POZZO, Vice President/GM, Customer Management (Walmart Customer Team), Frito-Lay Del Pozzo serves as team lead of the Frito-Lay Walmart business, leading a cross-functional team in delivering the largest PepsiCo customer P&L globally. His team consistently partners with Walmart in delivering omnichannel customer solutions that align with the strategic priorities of PepsiCo and Walmart collectively. BRAD HOENER , Vice President/General Manager, Beverages, PepsiCo Sam’s Club Team Hoener manages the cross-functional team across the PepsiCo beverage business at Sam’s Club. Since joining PepsiCo he has led the National Category Management organization for Quaker, Tropicana and Gatorade and the PepsiCo Strategy and Insights team across the Walmart and Sam’s Club businesses. After moving into sales, he led the Quaker Walmart business before taking on his current position. CHRISTINA MENENDEZ , Vice President, Shopper Marketing and eCommerce Sales – PepsiCo Walmart Customer Team After 10 years in Frito-Lay’s Snacks Division, Menendez recently joined PepsiCo’s Walmart customer team, responsible for driving partnership and collaboration between PepsiCo and Walmart to create distinct programming that reinforces and elevates the brand narrative while also creating a unique shopper experience to drive conversion. WILLIAM LANGFORD, Senior Director, Shopper Marketing Langford has spent 15 years with the beverage company, first at Frito-Lay and then on the beverages business in various field and shopper marketing roles. He is currently responsible for leading the development of shopper marketing programs and initiatives at Walmart. MARIO PALOMINO, Director of Sales MARISA PEREZ , Senior Director, Shopper Marketing, Walmart Inc., Frito-Lay Perez is responsible for the Frito-Lay portfolio strategy, brand development and activation at Walmart and Sam’s Club. She collaborates crossfunctionally to deliver volume, profit and share goals within Walmart Inc. and leads the marketing relationships with retail partners. Pfizer Consumer Healthcare KATHRYN BECKER , Senior Manager, Shopper Marketing Becker has 12 years of experience in the CPG industry, often working on Walmart accounts. She currently represents all Pfizer Consumer Healthcare brands such as Nexium 24HR, Advil, Centrum, ChapStick and Robitussin, and she most recently led the shopper marketing efforts for the over-the-counter switch of Nexium at Walmart. SHOPPER MARKETING JANUARY 2015 SHANNON COX, Business Development Manager Cox leads the business development for digestive healthcare. He most recently led the over-the-counter switch of Nexium at Walmart, and Nexium 24HR is now a top-selling proton-pump inhibitor at Walmart. He has more than 15 years of experience in the industry, working at Pfizer, Nintendo of America, 3M Co. and TracFone Wireless. Pharmavite JOHN STARE , Vice President Sales, Global Walmart & Sam’s Club Pinnacle Foods Corp. CHUCK ARNOLD, Senior Vice President, Walmart/Sam’s Club Team SCOTT LARSON, Senior Director, Sales – Walmart Team Prestige Brands GREGG HOGUE , Senior Director of Sales/ Team Lead – Walmart and Sam’s Club Procter & Gamble JACQUES HAGOPIAN, Walmart Global Customer Team Marketing Director JEFFREY K. SCHOMBURGER , President – Global Walmart Team RB (formerly Reckitt Benckiser) JOSH SAFFRAN, Vice President, Sales – Walmart U.S. With Colgate-Palmolive for 13 years, Saffran moved to RB in October 2013. He is responsible for driving RB and Walmart market share, net revenue, overall P&L and joint business plans within the consumables division at Walmart. RICH ZAZZU, Global Vice President – Walmart Zazzu has 20 years of experience in various sales leadership and trade marketing roles. He has been with RB for nine years, the last seven of which he has been responsible for leading the global Walmart organization. Reynolds Consumer Products STAN LUCAS, Vice President, Sales – Walmart S.C. Johnson & Son Inc. GREG BLAIR , Senior Director, Sales Account Management, Walmart Team Lead Blair leads the cross-functional team responsible for S.C. Johnson’s business development at Walmart U.S. He has more than 20 years of experience with the company in a variety of field sales and customer marketing roles. WHO’S WHO IN CUSTOMER TEAMS AT WALMART 33 JANUARY 2015 SHOPPER MARKETING JAY LEFFORGE , Director, Shopper Marketing, Walmart & Club Samsung PAUL WOOD, Vice President, Walmart & Sam’s Club Team Wood leads the Walmart and Sam’s Club teams and is responsible for sales, replenishment, category management, marketing and retail. Prior to joining Samsung, he spent more than 17 years in the CPG industry with Frito-Lay, H.J. Heinz and Dean Foods. Welch’s Wm. Wrigley Jr. Co. DOUG BATIE , Vice President, Walmart and Sam’s Club President, Sales JOHN BOWDEN, Customer Team Leader, Walmart Bowden has been at Welch’s for nine years, first as category advisor to Walmart, then as business development manager and, for the past three years, as customer team leader for Welch’s on several businesses, currently bottled and sparkling. TOM DIFFENBACH, Vice of trade. Currently she leads Wrigley’s shopper marketing strategy and activation plan development for Walmart and Sam’s Club. KELLEY WALCZAK , Shopper Marketing Manager – Walmart & Sam’s Club Walczak has 10 years of CPG experience between her time at Kellogg and Wrigley working in cross-functional roles including category management, channel marketing and shopper marketing and supporting all classes Spectrum Brands/ United Industries SUSAN ABRAHAMS, Division Vice President – Walmart Platform Team Leader Starbucks MIKE COOK , Director, Walmart & Sam’s Club – Customer Business Development Tyson Foods PAUL DAVIS, Vice President – Customer Development JASON NICHOL , Vice President, Walmart Packaged Goods Nichol joined Tyson Foods less than a year ago after spending 20 years representing other CPG companies such as Nabisco, Cott and Scotts Miracle-Gro. He now leads the crossfunctional Walmart team for Tyson’s packaged goods business, which includes the Tyson, Jimmy Dean, Hillshire Farm, Ball Park, State Fair, Sara Lee and Wright brands. Ubisoft JOHN CAREY, Sales Lead – Walmart SCOTT HOROWITZ, Senior Shopper Marketing Manager Horowitz worked at Best Buy for more than six years in the corporate office as a buyer and Web planner for video games, but three years ago moved to the supplier side to apply his retail knowledge, insights and passion. He currently leads shopper marketing programs at Walmart and Target in support of Ubisoft’s game launches. Unilever JIM BREACH, Vice President, We do it all. FAST...er Go XL or go home. Customer Development AARON CRANDALL , Shopper Marketing Director AURORA, IL | BENTONVILLE, AR | WWW.XLPOP.COM | 630.896.3610 34 FEATURE: CUSTOMER TEAMS continued from page 26 Putting a customer team in place is an expensive and complicated endeavor, especially a large one with a variety of functions including sales, finance, supply chain and marketing. But it has become the norm for major CPGs. “It’s mandatory for the biggest CPGs,” says Howell. “And for agencies like ours, it’s also a real competitive advantage to be in the market directly with our manufacturing partners working alongside retail partners.” Teams in all Shapes and Sizes Industry experts say the one thing you can be sure of is that every customer team is different, depending on the size of the company, the expectations of the retailer and how the team evolved within the organization. “It’s all over the board – you’ll find that every CPG team is structured differently,” says Evan Anthony, a retail shopper marketing consultant and former Kroger marketing executive who spent more than 30 years with the retailer. “There are different shapes, sizes, levels of support; some have shopper marketing, some don’t.” John Mount, vice president of commercial operations & marketing at The CocaCola Co., previously co-led one of Coca- SHOPPER MARKETING JANUARY 2015 Cola’s total beverage customer teams in Cincinnati. He says many of Coca-Cola’s teams include field operations and national account executives to call on the largest customers’ divisions and regions. In addition, they also typically include cross-functional subject matter experts who support revenue management, category management, finance and shopper marketing. “Our customers expect us to have all of the key disciplines in place to help them win,” Mount says. “They want a holistic value proposition that drives topline revenue and profit growth. They expect us to fully engage along the entire path to purchase, and they engage and collaborate with us to win with their shoppers.” Every on-site customer team needs a leader, and these positions tend to be very senior, says Howell. “I can’t think of anyone who is not a vice president. And most often, they are from sales or general management. They need to be capable of running a multifunctional team.” The bottom line is that the CPGs need to fit their teams into the framework the retailer works in, but how each manufacturer deals with those challenges may be different, says Mike McMahon, previously vice president of integrated marketing at ConAgra Foods and now head of shopper marketing at Datalogix. “The way we put things in place at ConAgra was to push the majority of the decision rights for spending and program development into the hands of the people in the field, but we still made sure we touched base and had people come back [to the Chicago office],” he says. “Other companies pushed those rights into the field, but connectivity didn’t always come back.” In addition, McMahon points out, at ConAgra the on-site marketing team reported to the CMO, whereas at other companies that team might report up through sales. “And often, a company might not be large enough to deploy so many resources,” he says. “They might bring in agencies to help cover a lot of the gaps in coverage at HQ.” Shopper Marketing Migrates When the first customer teams evolved at the largest retailers in This Google map shows the locations of a multitude of major CPG customer team offices that are in proximity to Walmart’s Bentonville headquarters. “Work really runs at the speed of retail, so you don’t have time to figure out how to get a flight in to get work done. You have to be there, in person.” Dina Howell, CEO of Saatchi & Saatchi X the late 1980s, marketing was not a part of the team’s structure. That all changed when Howell joined P&G’s Walmart team in 1997. “At P&G, we had begun to create the concept of what we called customer marketing,” she says. “And we realized we could work in conjunction with retailers to impact shoppers and change their behavior at the store level.” Soon, Howell realized that P&G needed to prove out their concepts – which included the new-at-the-time concept of navigational signs to guide customers toward specific aisles – and that she needed to be on-site – at Walmart headquarters. “I was the lone wolf out there,” she says. Customer Teams From the Ground Up In the mid-1980s, CPGs had the clout. Most retailers were regional – none were international – and they typically viewed CPGs very tactically. Suppliers influenced buying, merchandising and logistics decisions, but they were not considered a strategic part of the retailer’s business. The P&G customer team for Walmart, established in 1987 and led by Tom Muccio, changed all of that and put into motion a seismic shift in the retailersupplier relationship. “We realized we had been very arrogant,” says Muccio, who’s now retired. “We measured everything by P&G’s fiscal year, not the retailer’s. We had our own internal measurements. We had seven or eight different product divisions, and we didn’t have anything that told what the total value of a customer was to P&G.” Worst of all, he remembers, was the confrontational language. “We referred to them as accounts, they called us vendors. We realized that dynamic was ‘them’ against ‘us.’ We needed to approach our customers on a more strategic basis.” Walmart welcomed the new customer team. At least, Walmart founder Sam Walton did. “He believed it showed the commitment of P&G wanting to change,” says Muccio. “Most Walmart people didn’t want us to be there, but Sam said to give us a chance.” As soon as the P&G Walmart customer team was announced, other retailers were quick to react because they felt Walmart had gained a competitive advantage. “As a result of starting those teams, P&G quickly went to Walmart competitors such as Target, Kmart and Costco.” It took other CPGs some time – Tom Muccio 18 months to two years – to get their own teams on the ground in Bentonville and other retailer HQ cities. “They didn’t understand how customer teams worked,” says Muccio. “”We also tried to leverage P&G’s size, scale and scope.” These days, the customer team landscape has changed, Muccio says. “The dynamics are different. Retailers are the big dogs, not CPGs. Five of P&G’s retailers have higher sales than P&G does.” Shopper marketing is a growing opportunity, he adds, but both customer teams and retailers have yet to fully push the envelope in terms of broader shopper themes such as health and wellness. “There is still money being left on the table,” he says. “It will take a breakthrough in thinking.” — Sharon M. Goldman FEATURE: CUSTOMER TEAMS 35 JANUARY 2015 SHOPPER MARKETING John Mount, vice president of commercial operations & marketing, The Coca-Cola Co. APP NOW AVAILABLE! Available for download on your mobile device in iTunes and Google Play stores. Search for ‘Shopper Marketing magazine.’ Featuring Detailed Promotional Calendars and Seasonal Data For Top Retailers RETAIL FO S BR U O A LL TB EAS M MAD W ER FL A T C M NES G U L AN E S E L C R ’S E Y TH ER DA N A AW Y ON N AR I G AT Y KS E CO N U A I R D N D N P L I G ES S RA L D IV S G O SU AS & IN M CA FLU TH H G M R ’S GG H E ER IS R ER EA ST Y ER TA I N TO I L N ’ I S R KS RY D G L L P G MO A A S RI IV N Y T GH & ING TH H I A FL SP OL N LL O RI ID G U W N A I GR Y N A A I DPER R YE G L W O B M A D Y NES S G RA D UA H TIO T L N M A RC H S O ES N p2pi.org RT EA H AW A RE N ES S A SUPPLEMENT TO: R IN COLLABORATION WITH: L O O H SC PROMO GUIDE TH O M Constant Collaboration, Value-Added Solutions The experience of working on an on-site customer team was “transformative,” says Howell, who adds that it allowed her to learn about team dynamics and different functions that all worked toward the same goals: delighting shoppers, delighting retailers and growing share for P&G. “There’s nothing better than when the entire customer team is rallying around one common vision or objective. Everyone takes a lot of pride in working to become our customer’s most valued supplier,” says Mount about his years on Coca-Cola’s customer team. “It’s a ton of fun being in constant collaboration with the customer and building a value-oriented relationship. You’re problem solving with the customer; you’re creating value-added solutions that may not always be within your expertise, and you’re engaging in different departSM ments across the customer.” EA H The Data-Driven Future Many CPGs have not integrated shopper marketing into their customer teams. “You’d be shocked by how many brands don’t even have one,” says Anthony. However, the advent of data into marketing has, overall, shifted the entire structure of onsite teams. “If there was no big data, teams would look the same way they did 10 years ago,” Anthony says. “But now you have the maturity of Kroger and Safeway and others. They demand a common language between them and their suppliers.” The shopper, Howell emphasizes, is firmly in charge – which means the future for shopper marketing on customer teams is very bright: “There is so much more potential for collaboration between CPGs and retailers than you could have imagined 20 years ago. Shopper marketing has truly become integrated in how retailers and manufacturers go to market.” “There’s nothing better than when the entire customer team is rallying around one common vision or objective. Everyone takes a lot of pride in working to become our customer’s most valued supplier.” EE N There were, not surprisingly, various reactions to shopper marketers joining the customer team. “Plenty of people were welcoming with open arms and appreciated the investment to bring marketing knowledge to work at retailers,” she says. “Others were extremely skeptical.” When McMahon joined ConAgra in 2004, shopper marketing wasn’t part of most of the company’s customer teams, which typically included folks from sales, operations and category management. But retailers were becoming more sophisticated and were hiring classically trained CPG marketers to head up their own data-driven efforts. “That put demands on the manufacturing community that the sales guys were not prepared to fulfill,” says McMahon. “There was a pressure from the retailer side for us to become less fragmented and smarter about how we won the confidence of our retailers.” Those demands, he explains, turned into a high-level organizational strategy discussion, which led to an increased investment in an on-site shopper marketing presence at Walmart, Albertsons and other retailers and arming them with budgets and data. “We pushed as many of our resources into the field as we possibly could,” he says. “That means all the shopper marketing people on the Walmart team, the Publix team, the Safeway team – they all were pushed out to the customer team location. Suddenly the head of the Walmart team had a marketing insights person he could lean on.” 36 SHOPPER MARKETING JANUARY 2015 SO-LO-MO Central Dan Ochwat served as an editor of Shopper Marketing for nine years. Send comments and So-Lo-Mo news to [email protected]. A roundup of social, local and mobile marketing activity at retail 1 SOCIAL 1 Bazaarvoice, Austin, Texas, has improved how brands and retailers can secure permission for a consumer’s social post or video over Twitter and Instagram to be used in an e-commerce campaign or on a brand page. It’s a “Rights Management” feature that automatically triggers a rights request to the consumer over the social site where they posted. It also expedites approved comments into a client’s automated bank of comments, reviews, videos or photos that Bazaarvoice works to curate. Sony Electronics uses the system for its Store.Sony.com site. Barbara Ross Miller, head of Sony Direct, says the solution allows them to integrate social content and “confidently showcase our Sony community in an e-commerce environment.” 2 Black & Decker launched a 2 social contest called “Your Big Finish” that was inspired by research that showed more than half of the 700 U.S. homeowners surveyed had an unfinished home improvement project, and nearly 80% had two or more unfinished projects. The survey also pointed out that lack of time leaves a project undone most often, followed by finances and then skill level. A big party is the biggest motivator to finish, according to the research, and the holidays are prime time for parties. The “Your Big Finish” contest ...for finishers only. ran over the holidays, awarding weekly Black & Decker product prizes and a grand prize of $10,000. The manufacturer set up a contest site at YourBigFinish.com, where consumers entered photos of a big project they finished, a photo of themselves and a description of the project. Black & Decker used Facebook to promote the contest and shared selected submissions over social channels and on a billboard in New York’s Times Square. ...permission granted. 3 ...global giftables. 3 Mondelez International leveraged personalized videos created from consumers’ Facebook pages to promote Cadbury Chocolate in Australia and Asia. The efforts, spawned by technology from Idomoo (U.S. office in New York), is said to be expanding to more markets based on the success. In India, Singapore and Hong Kong, consumers at CadburyGlow.com could personalize giftable chocolates with a shared personal video incorporating Facebook photos or uploaded photos. In Australia, Cadbury display ads drove consumers to Facebook where Idomoo technology used photos and information on the pages to generate personalized videos and enter a contest. 5 4 ...in-store intelligence. ...getting personal. SO-LO-MO CENTRAL 37 JANUARY 2015 SHOPPER MARKETING 7 MOBILE 7 Available in app stores but not available for use yet, a new app hopes to fight against Apple Pay. Called “CurrentC,” the app scans QR codes at the register to pay for a transaction, as well as add any savings, coupons or loyalty points that may be tied to a purchase. Sounds good, but the unanimous user comments on Google Play are already attacking the app, saying they didn’t trust a QR code and that the app was hacked before it even launched. At time of this writing, it had a 1.1 user score out of 5. The history behind the app is that a joint venture of retailers (Best Buy, CVS, Target, Walmart, Publix, 7-Eleven and more) under the name MCX started working on the app in 2011 to bypass credit card fees. The app works by deducting from a user’s checking account. (For more on mobile payments, see page 16.) 8 Englewood, Colorado-based SpyderLynk, creator of the SnapTag code, announced it has discovered a way for the scanning of a UPC to deliver information to a smartphone. Brands can drive a shopper to a landing page for nutritional 8 information, reviews and product information, or maybe send a shopper a mobile coupon or video to watch in the aisle. Essentially, the UPC scan can do what previously has been done with QR codes and SnapTags but without the extra step of making and printing that code. SpyderLynk’s new “Snap Reader” app can be integrated into an existing app or be used as a standalone reader. It works with SpyderLynk’s overall mobile platform, so brands can adjust programs online through the company portal, as well as access data. A “major CPG/snack food company and a large financial/insurance services company” are testing the technology, according to SpyderLynk. The company currently works with brands such as Dr Pepper, Bud Light, Coca-Cola, Office Depot, AEG, Samsung, M&M’s and Comcast. ...mixed reviews. 9 9 I learned of a new shopping app called ShoppingScout from Engage3, Davis, California. The app only serves the northern California region currently as it’s just underway. The app’s purpose is to offer a chance to price shop items among local stores. You build a shopping list by scanning bar codes and then see where it’s best to shop. There is a loyalty feature called mPOINTS. ...price shopper. ...mobile reader. 6 LOCAL 4 Gigwalk, San Francisco, announced a new, in-the-field intelligence platform that it named “Gigwalk Enterprise.” It leverages location-based mobile technology to help brand clients communicate with internal teams in the field. Essentially, teams can be armed with smartphones and an enterprise app, and immediately react to issues in-store or collect data. The company also announced some powerful new clients: Whirlpool, Red Bull, Pfizer and Wrigley. 5 Weather app AccuWeather, State College, Pennsylvania, announced it is partnering with Lotame, New York, and the latter’s data management platform to enable the app to deliver mobile display ads to users based on location, demographic, purchase intent, data points and other segmentation information to send ads as personalized as their forecasts. 6 Perhaps a slight twist on “location-based,” a test program in Las Vegas is giving taxi passengers a chance to purchase targeted offers seen on the backseat video screens. POS company Verifone, San Jose, California, has teamed up with MasterCard to enable passengers to purchase card-linked offers such as a meal at the Hard Rock Café, rounds of golf at the Bali Hai and Royal Links courses, or a racing day at the Las Vegas Motor Speedway. The activities or offers can be found by swiping a MasterCard at the backseat terminal video screen, or offers can be viewed by scrolling the screen itself. A rider can purchase in the moment with a swipe of the card or via Apple Pay if the cab can accept it. While more of a test for entertainment, I definitely see potential of impulse buying in a cab, particularly if it were a new product or a personalized offer based on credit card or smartphone information. ...moving target. 38 SHOPPER MARKETING JANUARY 2015 ACTIVATION GALLERY Cosmetics Seen at 7-Eleven: e.l.f. 7-Eleven recently added TPG Growth’s e.l.f. cosmetics to its product assortment (left) in an effort to appeal to female consumers. Available in some 3,000 7-Eleven stores, the line adds a variety of new products to the retailer’s health and beauty category, including eye liner, mascara, lip gloss sticks, concealer, false eyelashes and makeup remover wipes. E.l.f. can also be found at many other retailers, including Walmart (above). Upscale Look at Target Target has updated the beauty department with LED lighting, large backlit signage that highlights product attributes and ingredients, and shelving that allows for brand customization and cleaner presentations for an even more upscale look. Branded Endcaps at CVS To complement its cosmetics wall, CVS/pharmacy allows for cosmetics endcaps that showcase individual brands, here Coty Inc.’s Rimmel London and Milani Cosmetics’ Milani. HOW YOU SEE SHOPPERS HOW WE SEE SHOPPERS GNC Garnier Whirlpool Levi's Petco Samsonite Shark Dove CoverGirl Essence of Beauty Nutribullet Pantene Essie Timez Maybelline New York Kohl's CoverGirl CVS Vaseline Tide Burt's Bees Suave Yankee Candle Columbia LG Elle Jergens Disney John Frieda Tamron Crest Electrolux Eddie Bauer Tamron Ponds Ponds Pantene Nike St. Ives Staples Casio Programmatic shopper marketing has arrived. Find out more at owneriq.com/psm 40 ACTIVATION GALLERY: COSMETICS SHOPPER MARKETING JANUARY 2015 CoverGirl ‘Can’ at Walgreens Procter & Gamble’s CoverGirl activated its national “#GirlsCan” campaign at Walgreens through in-store, online and social media activity. CoverGirl has pledged $5 million to various nonprofits over the next five years to help empower young women to overcome barriers in their lives. In partnership with Walgreens, the brand promised $1 to Los Angeles-based nonprofit Step Up for every participating mascara SKU with “#GirlsCan” packaging sold in-store or at Walgreens.com. Beyond the Major Players Inline Displays at Rite Aid and Meijer Cosmetics walls are a staple in drug, mass and even grocery stores, and they often take on similar looks regardless of the channel. Here are examples of how cosmetics are merchandised at drug chain Rite Aid (top) and mass merchant Meijer. Lighted inline displays are not only reserved for the CoverGirls, Revlons and L’Oreals of the world. At Walmart, exclusive brand Flower from Drew Barrymore and Physicians Formula also receive the spotlight. BEST S ST PRACTICE DISCOVER MARKETING MERCHANDISING CELEBRATE EDUCATION RETAIL March 16-18, 2015 Renaissance Schaumburg Convention Center Hotel, Schaumburg, IL MOBILE/SOCIAL SOLUTIONS INSIGHTS & REGISTERACTIVATION TODAY! ENGAGEMENT STRATEGY INNOVATION COMMUNITY MERCHANDISING Early Bird Rates Expire January 30, 2015 www.ShopperSummit.com Sponsored by: 42 ACTIVATION GALLERY: COSMETICS SHOPPER MARKETING JANUARY 2015 Going Beyond Groceries While it’s not their primary focus, supermarket chains do offer a range of cosmetics. This enables grocery stores to become more of a one-stop shop, with busy moms obviously a target. Here is a look at how an H-E-B store in Cedar Park, Texas (top), and a Shop & Shop location in Jackson, New Jersey (bottom), are merchandising cosmetics. Similar Play for New York Color Coty Inc.’s New York Color secured endcap space at Rite Aid (left) and CVS/pharmacy. While the SKUs are presented differently, the headers communicate a consistent value message. Walgreens: Varying Look by Format The typical cosmetics wall found in the majority of Walgreens locations (below) is neatly organized and clearly labels products by brand, but it’s generally devoid of lighted headers. In the retailer’s newer Well Experience store format (right), the wall takes on a different look, perhaps more “beautiful,” as department signage indicates. Path to Purchase Fact: 90% OF RETAIL JOURNEYS STILL END IN A RETAIL STORE, EVEN THOSE THAT BEGIN ONLINE. THE PATH TO PURCHASE DESTINATION: BRICKS & MORTAR SOLUTIONS & INSIGHTS FOR RETAILERS. THE CODE CRACKED. THE PATH OPTIMIZED. A CENTERPIECE EXHIBIT REGISTER TODAY- WWW.GLOBALSHOP.ORG Produced by Sponsored by In Cooperation with 44 SHOPPER MARKETING JANUARY 2015 RICCI AT RETAIL 1 Good Things Come in Small Packages 1 2 These pint-sized displays are big winners 1 Mucinex It’s been fun to watch the evolution of the PDQ corrugated unit through the years. These displays have transformed from large, somewhat underfilled trays that caused brands to ship cases of mostly air, to the end-slide units that had the same retail presence while reducing shipping sizes by almost half, and now to the latest generation such as this one used by Mucinex from RB (formerly Reckitt Benckiser), Parsippany, New Jersey, that slides both product ends into the graphic middle panel. It’s nice to see the industry striving to become more efficient without reinventing the wheel. 2 Tums I often view clip strips as a double-edged sword in that they can be tremendously effective for gaining incremental sales and display opportunities, or they can be an annoying source of retail clutter. When properly placed on the sides of major fixtures, like this unit from Philadelphiabased GlaxoSmithKline’s Tums brand, clip strips do a fine job of making use of otherwise ...new and improved. wasted retail space that is far too valuable to leave empty. Common sense and good merchandising are required for these displays to work well and prevent them from becoming a nuisance, and that appears to be the case here. 3 3 UrgentRx This vacuum-formed and corrugated unit seemed to appear everywhere almost overnight, but especially at the checkouts of a major mass retailer. The metal attachment device straddles the back wall of the checkout lane and the unit itself is within the dimensions of the wall, making it extremely stable and compact for maximum efficiency. The individual packets from Denver-based UrgentRx are perfect impulse items for this area of the store, and the bright first aid colors readily attract attention to the array of pain relief items. ...smart use of space. Joe Ricci is an industry expert in P-O-P merchandising. He is the founder of Beacon Concepts Inc., Surprise, Ariz. Please offer your comments to him at [email protected]. ...small but sturdy. The “rebooted” digital edition of Shopper Marketing magazine brings you the same stellar content from the print edition in a more convenient format! ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ Easy to read on a tablet or mobile device. Enhanced links and background information. Rich media interaction. The most comprehensive coverage of the shopper marketing industry at your fingertips – literally. Available in iTunes and Google Play stores. Advanced shopper marketing impact through retail digital promotion expertise. ➧ Inform your shopper media strategy by identifying marketing trends ➧ Benchmark your performance against competitive activations ➧ Fuel shopper marketing decisions in real time For more information contact: Download the digital edition of each issue at www.shoppermarketingmag.com. A premium service for Path to Purchase Institute members. Terese Herbig • (773) 992-4438 • [email protected] Pat Burke • (773) 992-4465 • [email protected] PERSONNEL APPOINTMENTS 45 JANUARY 2015 SHOPPER MARKETING BRAND MARKETERS Anheuser-Busch, St. Louis The company recently announced the hiring of new shopper insights analysts Tony Cerame and Kyle Reinneck. Dell Inc., Round Rock, Texas Kelly Mattran, formerly of PepsiCo, has taken a shopper marketing position with the computer technology retailer-manufacturer. NBTY, Ronkonkoma, New York The nutritional supplement manufacturer and distributor has appointed Andrew Archambault, formerly with Bacardi USA and the Coca-Cola Co., to the newly created position of chief customer officer. Tempur Sealy International, Lexington, Kentucky The bedding manufacturer has appointed Jay G. Spenchian to the position of executive vice president, chief marketing officer. Choksi Denten Dietz Mizzouri’s headquarters in Nashville and the firm’s Cincinnati office. Momentum Worldwide, New York The agency has appointed Matthew Gidley, previously the director of insight and strategy at Momentum UK in London, as the new managing director of the Chicago office; Matt Denten, previously of Arc Worldwide, as senior vice president, Midwest executive creative director, also in Chicago; and Omid Farhang as chief creative officer, North America, in New York. Farhang Hargreaves Piston, San Diego The digital marketing agency recently promoted Obele Brown-West from account director to vice president, account management, to lead Piston’s client services group. RetailNext Inc., San Jose, California The retail marketing technology firm has added Marc Dietz in the role of chief marketing officer. RETAILERS Hart The mobile marketing solutions provider has hired David Hargreaves as chief client officer. Please send information regarding personnel appointments to: Linc Wonham, Shopper Marketing, 8550 W. Bryn Mawr, Ste. 200, Chicago, IL 60631 or email: [email protected] February 2015 June 2015 Schnuck Markets, St. Louis March 2015 August 2015 Todd R. Schnuck has officially advanced to the CEO and chairman position, replacing his brother, Scott Schnuck, who is now chairman of the executive committee. The retailer also named Anthony T. Hucker to the position of president and COO, marking the first time a person outside the family has held the position. SOLUTION PROVIDERS Acosta Sales and Marketing, Jacksonville, Florida Bill Cassidy, formerly of Heinz, is the agency’s new executive vice president of business intelligence. Benenson Strategy Group, New York The agency has expanded its strategic brand consulting team with the appointment of Asha Choksi as senior vice president. Crossmark, Plano, Texas The marketing services provider to the consumer goods industry recently announced the promotion of Jim Norred to president of Crossmark’s marketing solutions group. Delucchi Plus, Washington, D.C. The digital communications and marketing agency recently appointed Sarah Parada to the position of vice president of account services. Empire Packaging and Displays, Carson, California David Nguyen is a new designer at the P-O-P display firm. Frank Mayer and Associates, Grafton, Wisconsin The P-O-P marketing solutions provider has appointed Jay Rivard to the position of account executive, and Danielle Nelson to the position of sales associate. GPA, Chicago The specialty printing solutions provider announced that Tim Wild, territory sales manager for the Pacific Northwest, has retired and is being succeeded by Kim Kotel. Insignia Systems, Minneapolis Andy Bennington has joined the in-store promotions company as a marketing analyst. Jacob Tyler, San Diego Timothy Mutrie has joined the brand communications agency as chief strategy officer. Mizzouri, Nashville, Tennessee Former Procter & Gamble and Kantar executive Kim Dedeker has joined the startup market research firm as principal and chief research officer, dividing her time between Mutrie Snipp Interactive, Bethesda, Maryland FreshDirect, New York The online fresh food grocer has brought on Michelle Harmon-Madsen from MediaVest to help launch an extensive brand partnerships platform. Kotel Join us at these 2015 Institute events. Aldi U.S., Batavia, Illinois Jason Hart, one of three leaders currently comprising the retailer’s office of the president, will be promoted to a new role as CEO effective April 1. Charles Youngstrom and David Behm will support Hart in continued roles as co-presidents. Gidley 24-25 | Council on Digital Shopper Marketing Atlanta, GA 16-18 | Shopper Marketing Summit A paramount industry conference where senior-level experts share knowledge and best practices to help brands and retailers achieve new peaks of success along the path to purchase. Renaissance Schaumburg Convention Center Hotel • Schaumburg, IL www.shoppersummit.com 17 | Shopper Marketing Effie Awards Produced in partnership with Effie Worldwide and held in conjunction with the Shopper Marketing Summit, the Effies honor outstanding strategic shopper marketing campaigns that engage the shopper and guide his or her purchase process. Renaissance Schaumburg Convention Center Hotel • Schaumburg, IL www.effie.org 17 | Hall of Fame Induction An induction ceremony held in conjunction with the Shopper Marketing Summit honoring the shopper marketing industry’s best and brightest. Renaissance Schaumburg Convention Center Hotel • Schaumburg, IL www.shoppersummit.com 9-10 | League of Leaders Spring Meeting The Westin O’Hare • Rosemont, IL Council on Digital Shopper Marketing October 2015 13-15 | Shopper Marketing Conference & Expo A three-day event filled with symposiums, seminars, exhibits and awards dedicated to integrating the wide variety of solutions, tools and expertise needed to influence decision-making along the entire path to purchase. Minneapolis Convention Center Minneapolis, MN www.shoppermarketexpo.com 14 | Design of the Times The leading industry awards competition and ceremony held in conjunction with the Shopper Marketing Conference & Expo that celebrates the most inspiring and creative in-store activation tactics, displays and campaigns. Minneapolis Convention Center Minneapolis, MN www.dot-awards.com Throughout 2015 I-Seminars Industry webinar presentations. See the website for topics and schedules. May 2015 19-20 | StratConn: Digital Shopper Marketing StratConn will match providers of digital shopper marketing services with qualified teams of executives from leading manufacturers, agencies and retailers who are in search of digital solutions and platforms that drive shopper impact and activation. This event focuses on connecting buyers with sellers of tools and strategies for mobile marketing, social engagement, sampling, couponing and digital media. Chicago Marriott Suites O’Hare • Rosemont, IL www.stratconn.org www.p2pi.org/iseminars New In 2015! P2P Leadership University Events Professional development courses for shopper marketing executives. www.p2pi.org/leadershipu February 18-19 ....Bentonville, AR March 16................Chicago, IL April 22-23 ............Cincinnati, OH May 13-14 ..............Minneapolis, MN June 24-26 ............Chicago, IL Contact us at (773) 992-4450 for more information. 46 SHOPPER MARKETING JANUARY 2015 INSTITUTE STRATEGIST More info at Working Closely With Their Customer p2pi.org Here’s a sampling of manufacturers’ recent account-specific activity at Walmart By Patrycja Malinowska Walmart often receives special attention from product marketers of all types. Leading manufacturers regularly run exclusive promotions at the mass merchant, many of which are recurring efforts. The strategy is a given for major home video and ga me r ele a s e s. This winter, a partnership between PepsiCo and video game publisher Activ ision let s players of “Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare” unlock a custom digital in-game exoskeleton character enhancement when they purchase the game along with a Mountain Dew 24-pack or promotion al package of Doritos at Walmart. The effort is receiving heavy in-store support. The permanent pallet displays Mountain Dew has in Action Alley are outfitted with signs plugging the promotion, as are endcaps stocking PepsiCo beverages. Upfront security wraps and violators positioned in the video game aisle also tout the promotion. The account-specific offer is an overlay to a national campaign that stocks various retailers with promotional packaging of the popular gamer “fuel,” yet Walmart is the only chain boasting an exclusive. The national packaging carries codes redeemable for additional in-game bonuses, many of which are being offered exclusively via the promotion through Feb. 15. Each code redeemed also enters players into a sweepstakes awarding Microsoft Corp.’s Xbox One console. Activision released “Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare” on Nov. 4, 2014, though Walmart was among retailers that began selling the title one day earlier. The retailer also hosted in-store events spanning early-play tournaments and giveaways at some 2,800 locations starting at 10 p.m. on Nov. 2. Also, on Nov. 3 and Nov. 4, Walmart offered 50% more for shoppers trading in any used video game with purchase of the title or Sony’s PlayStation 4. Previously, PepsiCo tied in to the November 2013 launch of Xbox One by stocking Walmart shelves with an exclusive, limited-edition Doritos “Gamer Pack” boasting a resealable, wide-opening bag designed specifically for video gamers. Additionally, in spring of 2014, custom pallet displays from Frito-Lay merchandised Walmart-exclusive packages of chips that contained codes providing a free threeday trial subscription to the Xbox Live Gold service. Kellogg Co. Kellogg is also tying in to a new video game release for a Walmart exclusive. Promotional packages of Apple Jacks, Corn Pops, Frosted Flakes and Froot Loops carry Kellogg’s Family Rewards codes redeemable for a free oneday Redbox game rental of Ubisoft’s “Just Dance 2015.” Earlier this winter, special packages of the same cereals delivered codes redeemable for a collectible branded cereal bowl. Meanwhile, promotional packages of PopTarts, Krave, Frosted Flakes, Frosted MiniW he at s a nd Fro ot Loops carried codes good for $5 off Sony Pictures’ “The Amazing Spider-Man” via the retailer’s Vudu streaming service. With three or six codes, participants could also earn “Concession Cash” or “Movie Cash,” respectively, from TPG Rewards, New York. Kellogg regularly leverages its loyalty program for exclusive incentives at Walmart, and annually offers “super codes” redeemable for a free book through a partnership with Scholastic Inc. during the school year. Coca-Cola Co. Coca-Cola has earned annual upfront placement for a dump bin during the holidays by supplying exclusive seasonal “orb packaging” of its flagship-brand soda. Editorial Index Companies named in the editorial columns of this issue are listed below. 360i . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 7-Eleven . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 38 AccuWeather . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37 Activision . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 46 Albertsons . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 Amazon.com . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 American Cancer Society . . . . . . 46 Apple . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16 Barnie’s CoffeeKitchen . . . . . . . . . 6 Bazaarvoice . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 36 Beeby Clark+Meyler . . . . . . . . . . 14 Best Buy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 Black & Decker . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 36 Catalina . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16 Cleaning for a Reason . . . . . . . . . 46 Coca-Cola Co., The . . 11, 12, 34, 46 ConAgra . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 34 Coty Inc. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 38, 42 Crossmark . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 CVS/pharmacy . . . . . . . . . 8, 38, 42 Datalogix . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 34 Deep Focus . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Delhaize America . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 domo domo IMG . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14 Edelman . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14 Energizer Holdings . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Energizer Personal Care . . . . . . . . 1 Engage3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37 FCB Garfinkel . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Georgia-Pacific Corrugated . . . . . 6 Gigwalk . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37 GlaxoSmithKline . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 44 Google . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16 Happy Kitten Co., The . . . . . . . . . . 8 H-E-B . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42 Heineken USA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1, 8 Hershey Co. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10 Huge . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Ibotta . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16 Idomoo . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 36 Integer Group, The . . . . . . . . . . . . 16 Interpublic Group . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Iris Mobile . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16 Jingit . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16 Kellogg Co. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 46 Kraft Foods Group . . . . . . . . . . . . 10 Kroger . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8, 34 LG Electronics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 The seasonal effort is just one of Coca-Cola’s many collaborations with the retailer, the biggest of which is the ongoing “Effortless Meals” program that pairs private-label Marketside prepared foods with Coca-Cola beverages. Nestlé Purina Nestlé’s Purina this winter launched a holiday “Treat Catcher” digital game offering a chance to win free Purina treats. An FSI supported the effort, which was the latest in a steady supply of seasonal, digital content from the manufacturer. Procter & Gamble Earlier in 2013, P&G kept Walmart pink throughout October. Like many other retailers, the mass merchant has cut down on Breast Cancer Awareness Month activity, but it continues to accept an overlay to Pantene’s “B eaut if ul L eng t h s” program. The custom incentive in fall of 2014 delivered up to $50 back on salon services (in the form of a Citibank gift card) to consumers who purchased Pantene and donated a ponytail. The American Cancer Society distributes wigs made out of the hair to cancer patients. The program earned Pantene placement for a custom endcap display and a full-page feature in the retailer’s circular. Simultaneously, Swiffer deployed a pallet display in Action Alley touting its support of nonprofit Cleaning for a Reason (which Walmart also sponsors) and Crest supplied an endcap promoting P&G’s participation in the National Football League’s “A Crucial Catch” camSM paign, which focuses on early detection. Lotame . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37 Marketing Arm, The . . . . . . . . . . . 16 MasterCard . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37 MaxPoint . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 McCann-Erickson . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 mCordis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 MCX . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16, 37 Meijer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 40 Microsoft Corp. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 46 Milani Cosmetics . . . . . . . . . . . . . 38 Mondelez International . . . . 10, 36 MyWebGrocer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 National Football League . . . . . . 46 Nestlé Purina . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 46 Nestlé-Waters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Path to Purchase Institute . . . . . . 1 PepsiCo . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 46 Physicians Formula . . . . . . . . . . . 40 Procter & Gamble . . . . . . 26, 40, 46 Publix . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Reckitt-Benckiser . . . . . . . . . . . . . 44 Retail Solutions Inc. . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Rite Aid . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 40 Saatchi & Saatchi X . . . . . . . . . . . 26 Sam’s Club . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 Scholastic Inc. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 46 S.C. Johnson & Son . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Sony Electronics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 36 Sony Pictures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 46 SpyderLynk . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37 Stop & Shop . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42 Target . . . . . . . . . . . 8, 10, 14, 16, 38 Toys R Us . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 TPG Rewards . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 46 Ubisoft . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1, 46 UrgentRx . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 44 Verifone . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37 Walgreens . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8, 40, 42 Walmart . . . . . . . 1, 8, 14, 26, 40, 46