2015 CAPER Executive Summary and Financial
Transcription
2015 CAPER Executive Summary and Financial
2015 Consolidated Annual Performance & Evaluation Report (CAPER) City of Galveston CDBG & HOME Programs Executive Summary The City of Galveston 2015 Program Year covers the period of June 1, 2015 through May 31, 2016. The 2015 Program Year is the third reporting year of the 2013 5-year Consolidated Plan. Resources Made Available to Further the Objectives of the Consolidated Plan The following resources were made available to further the City of Galveston's housing, housing related and non-housing community development objectives of the Consolidated Plan: 2015 Community Development Block Grant $ 1,163,000.00 2014 HOME Investment Partnerships Program 223,373.00 CDBG Program Income (Est. $40,000) 87,862.12 HOME Program Income (Est. $15,000) 41,841.54 The City expended $1,749,360.76 in CDBG funds for community development and housing activities during the 2015 program year. In 2015, HOME activities expended $474,814.72 for the purpose of providing safe, decent affordable housing. The 2015 CDBG Program Income (PI) estimate was $40,000. The City received $87,862.12 in CDBG PI during 2015; $10,760.00 in Revolving Loan Fund and $77,102.12 in General PI. CDBG PI actually received was not within the City’s 25% rule for substantial amendments of the estimated $40,000 in PI. The City’s estimated 2015 HOME PI was $15,000 and the actual receipts were $41,841.54. The receipted HOME PI was not within the 25% rule of the estimated HOME PI. The City provided notice to the public in coordination with its Citizen Comment Period on the 2015 CAPER of the deviation of more than 25% from the projected CDBG and HOME PI receipts on August 10, 2016. City of Galveston 2015 CAPER Executive Summary 1 2015 Housing & Community Development Objectives The following were identified as the 2015 Housing & Community Development Objectives, of which all were identified as high priorities in the 2013 5-Year Consolidated Plan: 1. To provide and expand the supply of safe, decent, and affordable housing through the rehabilitation of existing residential property and the development of new residential property for low-moderate income persons; 2. To provide and expand homeownership opportunities for low-moderate income homebuyers; 3. To reduce the number of housing units containing lead based paint and other lead hazards; 4. To identify and eliminate barriers to affordable housing and impediments to fair housing; 5. Provide code enforcement and neighborhood revitalization activities to diminish blight, unsafe buildings and lots, and general neighborhood decay in low-moderate income areas; 6. Provide infrastructure enhancement to support neighborhood revitalization and new residential development in low-moderate income areas; 7. Promote the health and well-being of city residents through the provision of public and supportive services; 8. To facilitate neighborhood, comprehensive, and individual project management, planning, and capacity building activities for low/moderate income areas; 9. Provide economic development opportunities for low-moderate income and for their employers; and 10. Assist in the coordination of resources in the community through expansion/enhancement of the homeless Continuum of Care Program. The 2015 projects made significant progress toward meeting the goals and objectives as established in the 2015 Action Plan. The accomplishments are reported in the following sections. The grant-funded activities administered by the Grants and Housing Department met all program requirements and generally provided a positive impact to the low-moderate income neighborhoods and residents. The City distributed the funds in a timely manner and the projects were substantially on schedule to meet their objectives. The following programs were funded from the 2015 CDBG & HOME Programs: Project Public Service Activity Parks & Recreation Dept. Children & Youth Program 2015 Community Development Block Grant Description Provide staffing and supplies/equipment to implement educational & recreational summer and after-school supervised activities at Menard & Wright Cuney Parks and Recreation Centers for 1,000 primarily LMI children and youth ages 5-18 Public Facility & Improvement Activity Provide 52 blocks of sidewalk installation improvements and ADA ramps in the street right-of-ways used for pedestrian passageways in Public Works Dept. the LMI area of Ave. L-43rd to 53rd St., Ave. M-29th to 43rd St., and Sidewalk Installation Ave. O-25th to 53rd St. to assist in safe pedestrian walkways City of Galveston 2015 CAPER Executive Summary $ $ Allocation 145,950 145,950 $ 580,120 $ 580,120 2 Code Enforcement Activities Compliance Division Code Compliance Officers Compliance Division Demolition & Lot Clearance/Boardup Provide 4 compliance officers to work in LMI areas to conduct 9,000 property inspections to enforce local codes and follow-up notification and 3,500 reinspections for non-compliant properties Provide contracted demolition of 3 dilapidated/unsafe structures and lot clearance/boardup on 95 properties that are nuisance and safety issues in LMI neighborhoods and areas Planning & Program Administration Activity CDBG Program Provide management of the CDBG and HOME Programs to ensure Administration compliance with all regulatory requirements CDBG TOTAL ALLOCATION CDBG Program Income (Estimated) Project Provide 2013 Consolidated Plan CDBG Eligible Projects with PI received primarily from housing rehabilitation loan payments and payoffs and lot clearance, boardup, and demolition lien payoffs 2015 HOME Investment Partnerships Program Description Affordable Housing Activities Community Housing Provide a housing development activity to acquire property and Development Org. (CHDO) rehabilitate or construct affordable housing to be sold or rented to a Affordable Housing LMI household through a CHDO RFP process; Mandatory 15% SetProgram aside Requirement Grants & Housing Dept. Homebuyer Assist. Provide downpayment and closing cost assistance to 12 LMI Program households with first-time homeownership HOME Program Administration Activity HOME Program Provide management of the HOME Program to ensure compliance Administration with all regulatory requirements HOME TOTAL ALLOCATION HOME Program Income (Estimated) Provide 2013 Consolidated Plan HOME Eligible Projects with PI received primarily from housing rehabilitation loan payments TOTAL CONSOLIDATED PROGRAMS $ 204,330 $ 175,140 $ 29,190 $ 232,600 $ 232,600 $ 1,163,000 $ 40,000 $ Allocation 201,036 $ 51,036 $ 150,000 $ 22,337 $ 22,337 $ 223,373 $ 15,000 $ 1,386,373 Project Service Areas The focus of the activities contained in the City of Galveston’s 2015 Action Plan was on a citywide basis in the low-moderate income areas. The Public Services under the CDBG funds have been allocated on a Citywide basis as a direct benefit activity. Code Enforcement activities will be located in the LMI Neighborhoods. The Public Facility and Improvements under the CDBG funds have been allocated to a specific LMI area. All of the HOME funds are dedicated to Citywide projects. City of Galveston 2015 CAPER Executive Summary 3 The City of Galveston has a low-moderate income percentage of 55.96%. The population of the Island is 49,238 people with a racial/ethnic composition of: White 23,235 or 47.19%; Hispanic 14,516 or 29.48%; Black 9,060 or 18.4%; and Other 2,427 or 4.93%. (HUD CPD Maps Information – 2007-11 ACS). The Citywide low-moderate income neighborhoods are primarily located in the area of 1st Street to 61st Street (on the East and West) from Harborside, Avenue C, and Avenue E (on the North) to Seawall and Avenue S (on the South). Other low-moderate income areas outside of this core city area will also be considered for assistance. The low-moderate income areas are mostly located in Census Tracts: 7240, 7241, 7243, 7244, 7246, 7247, 7248, 7249, 7250, 7251, 7252, 7253, 7254, 7256, 7258 and 7259. These areas are also the primary locations for the minority concentrations of the City's population. The total population of this area is 36,643 with a LMI percentage of 62.54%. The following comprise the primary LMI neighborhoods in the core city area. This area has a population of 27,638 with a LMI percentage of 62.32% located in CT’s 7240, 7243, 7244, 7246, 7247, 7248, 7249, 7250, 7251, 7252, 7253, and 7254, and a minority concentration of 62.48% (2007-11 ACS). Old Central/Carver Park Neighborhood - The physical boundaries are 26th Street to 33rd Street from Mechanic to Avenue M, 33rd Street to 41st Street from Church to Avenue M, 41st Street to 45th Street from Postoffice to Avenue M, 45th Street to 53rd Street from Postoffice to Avenue L, and 53rd Street to 54th Street from Postoffice to Broadway. Old Central/Carver Park Neighborhood is primarily located in census tracts CT7240 BG1; CT1246 BG1, 2, and 3; CT7247 BG1; CT7251 BG1; and CT7252 BG1. San Jacinto Neighborhood - The physical boundaries are 6th Street to 23rd Street from Broadway to Seawall Blvd. San Jacinto Neighborhood is primarily located in census tract CT7244 BG1, 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6. Kempner Park Neighborhood - The physical boundaries are 23rd Street to 26th Street from Broadway to Seawall, 26th Street to 30th Street from Avenue M to Seawall, and 30th to 35th Streets from Avenue M to Avenue S. Kempner Park Neighborhood is primarily located in census tracts CT7247 BG2 and 3; CT7248 BG1, 2, and 3; and CT7249 BG1 and 2. Lasker Park/Bayou Shore Neighborhood - The physical boundaries are 35th Street to 45th Street from Avenue M to Avenue S, 45th Street to 53rd Street from Avenue L to Avenue S, and 53rd Street to 61st Street from Broadway to Avenue S and Stewart Road. Lasker Park/Bayou Shore Neighborhood is primarily located in census tracts CT1250 BG1 and 2; CT7251 BG2 and 3; CT7252 BG2 and 3; CT7253 BG1, 2, and 3; CT7254 BG1, 2, 3, 4, and 5; and CT7258 BG3. East End Neighborhood - The physical boundaries are 6th Street to 19th Street from Harborside to Broadway. East End Neighborhood is primarily located in census tract CT7243 BG1, 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6. There is 1 targeted LMI area for the Sidewalk Project as follows: The project is sited on Ave. L-43rd to 53rd, Ave. M-29th to 43rd, and Ave. O-25th to 53rd and located in CT’s 7247, 7248, 7249, 7251, 7252, 7253, and 7254. This area has a population of 14,593 with a LMI percentage of 60.79% and a Minority percentage of 66.55%. City of Galveston 2015 CAPER Executive Summary 4 The following project was conducted in facilities located in LMI neighborhoods and open on a Citywide basis for direct services to principally low-moderate income residents: City Parks & Recreation Department – Youth Recreation Program o Wright Cuney Park & recreation center, 41st St. & Ave. H (Ball) o Menard Park & recreation center, 27th St. & Seawall o Based on the CPD Mapping 2007-2011 Census ACS, the following minority concentrations comprise the service areas of this project: Wright Cuney Park – Area is 69.23% minority population Menard Park – Area is 59.19% minority population The following projects were conducted on a Citywide basis for direct services to low-moderate income households: City Grants & Housing Department – Housing Rehabilitation Program City Grants & Housing Department – Homebuyer Assistance Program CHDO – Affordable Housing Project (housing unit will be sold to a low-moderate income homebuyer) Minority information is collected with the applicant eligibility process The following projects were conducted within the Citywide low-moderate income areas: City Planning & Community Development Department – Code Enforcement Compliance Officers City Planning & Community Development Department – Demolition/Lot Clearance City Public Works Department – Sidewalk Installation Project o Based on the CPD Mapping 2007-2011 Census ACS, the area is 61.11% minority population The following table identifies the LMI Census Tracts and the Minority Concentrations: City of Galveston 2015 CAPER Executive Summary 5 Maps Maps of Projects and LMI Neighborhoods/Areas with Census Tracts, LMI by Percentages Concentration, and Race/Ethnicity Concentration follows. 2015 Project Map with LMI Census Tracts and LMI Neighborhoods City of Galveston 2015 CAPER Executive Summary 6 LMI Below 30% Concentration City of Galveston 2015 CAPER Executive Summary 7 LMI 30-50% Concentration City of Galveston 2015 CAPER Executive Summary 8 LMI 50-80% Concentration City of Galveston 2015 CAPER Executive Summary 9 Race-Ethnicity White Alone Concentration Map City of Galveston 2015 CAPER Executive Summary 10 Race-Ethnicity Black Alone Concentration Map City of Galveston 2015 CAPER Executive Summary 11 Race-Ethnicity Hispanic Concentration Map City of Galveston 2015 CAPER Executive Summary 12 Financial Impact of the CDBG and HOME Program The following contracts were awarded in the 2015 grant year. Total CDBG & HOME Contracts Total Amount of Contracts Total M/WBE Contracts Total Section 3 Contracts 56 $1,051,320.07 28/$370,508.74 18/$505,105.00 Through the CDBG and HOME Programs, the public service, public facility and improvements, code enforcement and program administration activities provided funds for 49 staff members. There were 10 Section 3 employees hired through these activities. The race/ethnicity of the employees was Asian-1, Black-24, Hispanic-9, and White-15. During the 2015 Program Year, a total of $1,749,360.76 in CDBG funding was expended to address the City of Galveston’s goals and objectives in meeting the CDBG Program primary purpose of providing decent housing and suitable living environment and expanding economic opportunities. There was a total of $474,814.72 in HOME funds utilized to accomplish the City’s goals and objectives and meet the primary purpose of the HOME Program of expanding the supply of decent, safe, sanitary affordable housing for very low-income persons. 2015 Program Year Project Accomplishments The following accomplishments reflect the impact of programs to the community from the 2015 CDBG and HOME Program. Housing Programs The effects of Hurricane Ike in 2008 on the housing units of the Island were still being assisted under the CDBG-Disaster Recovery Housing Program. Many citizens were without insurance and others received inadequate assistance to make the repairs to their housing. With the majority of the substandard housing also being damaged by the storm, citizens were counting on the disaster housing program for their assistance. From the start of the Disaster Program and through the 2015 grant year, the Disaster Housing Program has rehabilitated or reconstructed a total of approximately 1,300 units under Phase 1 and 2. Many of the residents applied to the City’s program for assistance due to the length of time it took for assistance from the Disaster Program or their inability to qualify for Disaster assistance. The City’s Housing Rehabilitation Program has developed a list of prospective applicants from the homeowner contacts that it works through as funding for housing rehabilitation becomes available. The following priorities and specific objectives were addressed during the 2015 Program Year. The City has identified that the housing priorities and objectives will primarily focus on assistance for owneroccupied and homeownership projects in an effort to assist in the increase of homeownership. The ACS 2010-2014 Census reflects the owner-occupied housing unit rate as 45.1%. This is far below the US rate of 64.4% and the Texas rate of 62.7%. Housing High Priority - To provide and expand the supply of safe, decent and affordable housing through the rehabilitation of existing residential property and the construction of new residential properties City of Galveston 2015 CAPER Executive Summary 13 o The City allocated $51,036 in HOME CHDO set-aside funds and will collaborate with a certified CHDO to acquire and rehabilitate a housing unit for low-moderate income person/s to purchase. Accomplishment: The City developed a Request for Proposal for a CHDO Affordable Housing Program for the 2015 HOME CHDO set-aside. The RFP was issued and responses will be due in the next reporting period. The City continued a CHDO project for prior multi-year funding of $467,667.35 funds to the Houston Area Community Development Corp. (HAUCDC) to implement the City’s CHDO affordable housing project. HAUCDC will purchase up to 5 properties, rehabilitate to code, and resell properties to eligible LMI households. HAUCDC expended $217,021.27 this period to complete the purchase of 3 properties and completed the rehab on 1 property; these are singlefamily units with 2 - 2 bdrm./1 bath and 1 - 3 bdrm./2 bath properties. In prior year, the CHDO conducted outreach community meetings and solicited homebuyer applicants to purchase properties. The HAUCDC CHDO balance is $250,646.08 to expend next period. The City CHDO balance for 2015 and prior year is $60,024.61. The City Grants & Housing Department Housing Rehabilitation Project Administration will provide management and oversight and project delivery costs for the housing rehabilitation and affordable housing programs and other housing related issues including projects funded through the CDBG Program, Revolving Loan Fund, HOME Program, and HOME Program Income to ensure regulatory compliance and building standards. The CDBG Program Income release of funds provided $140,000 for the Housing Rehabilitation Project Delivery and Management. Housing High Priority - To provide and expand homeownership opportunities for low- and moderateincome homebuyers The City Homeownership Assistance Program (HAP) with $150,000 HOME funds offers downpayment and closing cost assistance to eligible low-moderate income homeowners. It is anticipated that the HAP will provide assistance to 12 low-moderate income families or individuals. o Accomplishment: During the program year, the City Grants and Housing Department provided $9,958.39 in HOME funding assistance to 1 low-moderate income household in the purchase of their first home. The 1 first-time homebuyer was White with LMI percentage of 60%-80%. There were 8 homebuyer applicants that were approved as income eligible during the program year. The HAP has a balance of $158,024.78 (with prior year funds) to be expended in the next reporting period. Housing High Priority - To reduce the number of housing units containing lead based paint and other lead hazards The City of Galveston will enforce its Lead-Based Paint Ordinance. The ordinance is designed to reduce the hazards of Lead-Based Paint exposure through proper interim controls, abatement and removal techniques. The City will continue to increase public awareness of Lead-Based Paint hazards through its housing rehabilitation and environmental development programs. The City will enforce LBP hazards on each rehabilitation project that it undertakes and performs visual inspections for LBP and requires stabilization of any deteriorated paint prior to providing homebuyer assistance. o Accomplishment: The City takes all necessary actions to reduce lead-based paint hazards in housing units receiving federal assistance. The housing rehabilitation program completed 1 project this period, 2 projects were under construction, and 5 projects were in work-write-up development. The homebuyer assistance program provided 1 homebuyer with assistance. Housing High Priority - To identify and eliminate barriers to affordable housing and impediments to fair housing City of Galveston 2015 CAPER Executive Summary 14 The City will continue to review policies to ensure that no new ordinances are passed that will negatively impact affordable or fair housing or that changes in the economy and development practices do not render existing policies as adversely affecting fair and affordable housing choice. The City will continue to educate the consumers on the fair housing law and avenues for filing complaints. The City will receive fair housing complaints and forward them to the Houston HUD office. The City of Galveston periodically publishes the HUD Fair Housing toll-free hotline number and public service announcements in the general-circulation newspaper. The Grants & Housing Department also posts Fair Housing and contact information on its City webpage. o Accomplishment: The City is following its AI and Fair Housing Plan as submitted to HUD. - Actions taken to remove or ameliorate the negative effects of public policies that serve as barriers to affordable housing such as land use controls, tax policies affecting land, zoning ordinances, building codes fees and charges, growth limitations, and policies affecting the return on residential investment. Action: The City of Galveston is required to meet floodplain mitigation through elevation. The majority of the island is in a FEMA 100-Year Flood Plain. The City allocates CDBG and HOME funds to housing rehabilitation programs and first-time homebuyer programs to help alleviate the housing difficulties encountered by low- to moderate-income residents. These funds are available to provide homeowners with assistance in repairs or rebuilding their homes. All properties must meet Local and International Residential Building Codes for one and two family dwellings. Community Housing Development Organizations (CHDOs) access HOME and other funds for housing rehabilitation and new affordable housing construction. The Galveston Central Appraisal District and Tax Assessor/Collector provides tax relief in the form of installment payments and split payments to property owners. Homeowners 65 years of age or older can “defer” or postpone paying any property taxes on their homes for as long as they own and live in the unit. Property owners can also apply for exemption categories that will reduce the amount of property taxes due on their properties such as: residential homestead exemption, over 65 exemption, disability exemption, disabled veteran exemption, surviving spouse of disabled veteran or armed services member killed in action and over 65 exemption, and donated residence for disable veteran exemption. - Actions taken to address obstacles to meeting underserved needs: Action: The City of Galveston administers a First Time Homebuyer’s Program (HAP) which provides first time homebuyers with up to $14,500 in Home Investment Partnership Program funds for downpayment and closing costs to purchase a home. The Grants and Housing Department has assisted a total of 1 LMI family with downpayment and closing cost during this reporting period. The City of Galveston works with local Community Housing Development Organizations (CHDO) for the provision of first-time homebuyer’s assistance and the development or renovation/sale of affordable housing. The Galveston Historical Foundation CHDO currently has 3 single-family properties that were offered for sale to LMI households and was converted to rental due to failure to sell; the 3 properties are currently under lease this reporting period to LMI households. The City also continues to lease 2 single-family housing City of Galveston 2015 CAPER Executive Summary 15 units to LMI families under the rental program. The Houston Area Urban Community Development Corp. CHDO will purchase up to 5 properties, rehabilitate to code, and resell properties to eligible LMI households. This period the CHDO completed the purchase of 3 single-family properties and completed the rehab on 1 property. The CHDO has also conducted outreach community meetings and solicited LMI homebuyer applicants to purchase the properties. - Actions taken to reduce the number of poverty-level families: Actions: The City of Galveston gives preference to construction contractors who are Section 3-qualified or hire low-income laborers. One (1) Section 3 construction contract was awarded under the CDBG Program for $496,415.00. Our City Departments hire Section 3 residents/businesses whenever feasible. During this program year Code Enforcement awarded 17 Section 3 contracts totaling $8,690.00 and the Parks and Recreation Department hired 10 Section 3 residents. Galveston College Universal Access Scholarships are provided to ensure that every eligible high school graduate, or equivalent, who resides in the Galveston College taxing district, has the opportunity to attend college, receive an associate’s degree, or acquire technical training through a workforce development program and obtain a certificate. The College offers workforce education, continuing education programs, and developmental programs to assist in specific careers and vocations and skills training to assist residents with meeting the needs of the local job market. - Actions taken to develop institutional structure: Actions: The City of Galveston coordinates and administers its housing and community development efforts through the Grants and Housing Department. The Department functions as a liaison with other City departments, community groups, non-profit service providers, other governmental entities, and public and private organizations to share information, identify resources and coordinate community development activities, when possible. The City of Galveston works with City departments to provide infrastructure support, code enforcement, after school programs and activities for the youth as well as summer program and activities for the youth. The Housing Rehabilitation Program provides home improvements assistance to low to moderate income residents which includes minimum, moderate or substantial rehabilitation to the housing units. This program allows low to moderate income residents to maintain a housing unit that is affordable and code compliant. - Actions taken to enhance coordination between public and private housing and social service agencies: Actions: Through Fair Housing education and outreach activities during the 2015 year, the City provided Fair Housing Information to three (3) social service agencies that worked with “at risk” populations. The City of Galveston and Galveston Housing Authority sponsored a City of Galveston 2015 CAPER Executive Summary 16 Landlord Reception on April 20, 2016. Ada Raglin Thomas, Equal Opportunity Specialist with HUD’s office of Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity Office (Houston) gave an overview of Fair Housing requirements for landlords and property managers. The reception was well attended with over 30 interested residents and landlords. The City of Galveston attends meetings on a regular basis to foster a communication network to remain informed regarding local programs; these meeting include NAACP, FHAST (Fair Housing) quarterly roundtable meetings and Homeless Continuum of Care. The City provides support as appropriate and practical. The City also solicits public comment on CDBG & HOME Programs, including the availability of housing for low-income persons and Fair Housing. - Identify Actions taken to overcome the effects of any impediment identified in the jurisdictions analysis of impediments to fair housing choice: Actions: City staff regularly attends Fair Housing Training sponsored by HUD. The City promotes Fair Housing through the distribution of education materials and posting posters in City offices and public buildings. The City has translators available to assist limited English Proficient homeowners. The City allocates CDBG and HOME funds to housing rehabilitation programs and nonprofit housing agencies to help alleviate the housing difficulties encountered by low- to moderateincome residents. Community Housing Development Organizations (CHDOs) access HOME and other funds for housing rehabilitation and new affordable housing construction. On August 14, 2015, City staff participated in a Back to School Fair hosted by the Galveston Independent School District. A total of 50 residents visited the City’s booth and received information on the City’s housing rehabilitation and reconstruction programs, as well as information on first-time homebuyer assistance. City staff also distributed 80 Fair Housing informational booklets. As part of the City’s annual Fair Housing Celebration, on April 15, 2016, City staff and Galveston Housing Authority read “When Chocolate Milk Moved In” to four (4) kindergarten classes at Coastal Village Elementary. City staff also used puppets to illustrate the book. This book taught the kids the importance of love and diversity in the community and how to welcome newcomers to the neighborhood. On April 20, 2016, City staff co-hosted a Landlord Reception with Galveston Housing Authority at the Island Convention Center. This event was geared toward our current and potential landlords. Ada Thomas from HUD FHEO gave an overview of the Fair Housing requirements for landlords. Over 30 residents and landlords were in attendance. On April 27, 2016, staff attended a Fair Housing Conference at Gulf Coast Community Services Association. This conference focused on housing discrimination based on disability, specifically, the impact of housing discrimination on individuals with an invisible illness or mental disability. City of Galveston 2015 CAPER Executive Summary 17 On April 28, 2016, staff attended an Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing (AFFH) Educational Seminar at United Way Community Resource Center. This seminar focused on the new rules under AFFH, what program participants are required to do to meet their AFFH duties and to make informed policy decisions. On May 11, 2016, staff facilitated an informational presentation for the City employees in the Sanitation Department to advise them of the City’s Housing Assistance Program and the benefits of homeownership. The Sanitation employees are generally some of the lowest paid employees of the City. Our presentation focused on how the City’s program could help them purchase their first home and how a home is an asset that generates equity and potential wealth and that can be passed down through generations of family members. Outcome Measure – the Housing projects will provide the following performance measure: Affordability for the purpose of providing decent affordable housing by assisting 1 acquisition and rehabilitation of a housing unit to be sold to a low-moderate income homebuyer and 12 LMI firsttime homebuyers with home purchases o Actual: This year’s accomplishments provided for the affordability for the purpose of providing decent affordable housing by assisting CHDO affordable housing project began implementation and purchased and completed 1 housing unit to be sold to a LMI household and purchased 2 units to be rehabilitated and sold to LMI households next reporting period. Homebuyer assistance was provided to 1 LMI household. Community Development Programs The City of Galveston implemented the following activities with its 2015 Program Year funding to meet the non-housing community development needs eligible for assistance by CDBG eligibility category. All of the activities implemented in 2015 were listed as HIGH priorities in the 2013 5-year Consolidated Plan. Public Services Community Development High Priority - Promote the health and well-being of city residents through the provision of public and supportive services The City with CDBG funding of $149,950 will provide program staffing and supplies/equipment to implement youth recreational and educational activities through the Parks & Recreation Dept. summer and after-school programs. Project will benefit 1000 children and youth primarily of lowmoderate income families to meet the objective for new services for LMI persons. Programs are located in low-moderate income neighborhoods and available to young people on a citywide basis. This is a short term 1-yr. objective. o Accomplishment: The Parks & Recreation Dept. expended $132,020.17 and provided 36 staff members for implementation of summer and after-school programs in low-moderate income areas to 1,273 primarily LMI (90.5%) young people ages 5-18. The programs were conducted at the Menard Park Recreation Center and Wright Cuney Recreation Center; both located in LMI areas and with programs offered on a Citywide basis, the City is 55.96% LMI. There were 52,376 continuing daily units of service to the young people throughout the year; 26,591 at Wright Cuney and 25,785 at Menard. The race/ethnicity was 430 White, 726 Black, 21 Asian, 5 Am. Indian/Alaskan Native, 4 Am. Indian/Alaskan Native and White, 2 Asian and White, 44 Black and White, 3 Am. Indian/Alaskan Native and Black, 38 Multi-Racial with 302 Hispanic; there were 43 disabled children/youth served. Programs included supervised educational/recreational activities such as tennis, karate, weights, City of Galveston 2015 CAPER Executive Summary 18 open gym, arts & crafts, computer labs, homework labs, and sports. This project is complete; balance of $23,024.39 will be used to assist project in next period. Outcome Measure – the Public Services will provide the following performance measures: Availability/Accessibility for the purpose of creating a more suitable living environment by providing services to the youth education/recreation assistance 1,000 people of which an estimated 90% will be low-moderate income o Actual: The youth education/recreation activities assisted in the availability/accessibility to public services to 1,273 primarily LMI (90.5%) residents by creating a more suitable living environment. Public Facilities & Improvements Community Development High Priority - Provide infrastructure enhancement to support neighborhood revitalization and new residential development The City Public Works Dept. with CDBG funding of $580,120 will provide 52 block area of at least 4' W sidewalks and ADA handicap ramps installation improvements in LMI areas of Ave. L-43rd to 53rd, Ave. M-29th to 43rd, and Ave. O-25th to 53rd to enhance pedestrian safety for approximately 14,593 population with 60.79% LMI. Install sidewalks in LMI area to meet the objective to improve the quality and increase the quantity of public improvements for lower income persons. This is a short term 1-yr. objective. o Accomplishment: The Public Works Dept. expended $1,071.70 and contracted an engineering firm to complete the engineering for the project to develop the design and specifications to bid the sidewalk construction; engineering will be completed next period. The project completions were over-estimated in the original design; the project will complete 22 block area of 6,109 linear ft. of sidewalks and 24 ramps in the area of Ave. L-43rd to 53rd Sts. and Ave. M-29th to 30th Sts. for approximately 5,982 population with 63.55% LMI. This project will be bid and completed in the next reporting period expending the balance of $579,048.30. Outcome Measure – The Public Facility & Improvements will provide the following performance measure: Sustainability of a more suitable living environment by providing public facilities and infrastructure improvements to a City low-moderate income area as a direct benefit with an indirect benefit for the entire population of 14,593 with 60.79% LMI. o Actual: The sidewalk installation improvements projects will be completed next period for approximately 5,982 population with 63.55% LMI. Code Enforcement Community Development High Priority - Provide code enforcement and neighborhood revitalization activities to diminish blight, unsafe buildings and lots, and general neighborhood decay The City Compliance Division with CDBG funding of $175,140 will provide Code Enforcement through 4 Code Compliance Officers to perform inspections and reinspections and enforce housing, zoning, and environmental codes in low-moderate income neighborhoods. Approximately 9,000 property inspections will be conducted with 3,500 reinspections. Meet the objective to improve the services in LMI areas for approximately 27,638 population with 62.32% LMI. This is a short-term 1year objective. o Accomplishment: The City Compliance Division expended $169,647.69 and provided 4 compliance officers working in the LMI neighborhoods. The officers provided housing, zoning, and environmental code inspections on 10,386 properties resulting in 3,762 code violations issued. City of Galveston 2015 CAPER Executive Summary 19 o There were 6,624 properties re-inspected to ensure violations were abated. The Project is complete and final draw of $5,492.31 will be completed in the next period. The City Compliance Division with CDBG fundings of $29,190 will provide through contracted services on nuisance and substandard properties 3 demolitions of dilapidated unsafe structures and 95 lot clearances and boardups of properties that are unsafe or overgrown and strewn with debris that could lead to the investation of vermin and adverse environmental conditions. Meet the objective to improve the services in LMI areas for approximately 27,638 population with 62.32% LMI. This is a short-term 1-year objective. Accomplishment: The Compliance Division expended $11,110.00 and provided 116 lot clearances of nuisance properties and 4 boardups of unsafe units through 25 contracts with 15 Section 3 contracts and 19 M/WBE contracts. Balance of $18,080 will be expended in next period. Outcome Measure – the Code Enforcement activity will provide the following performance measure: Sustainability of a more suitable living environment by providing compliance officers in the City’s LMI neighborhoods for 9,000 property inspections and demolition/lot clearance and boardup for 98 properties to 27,638 population with 62.32% LMI o Actual: Sustainability for the purpose of creating a more suitable living environment through the provision of code enforcement for 10,386 property inspections identifying 3,762 code violations and 116 lot clearances and 4 boardups to an area of 27,638 population with 62.32%. Economic Development Community Development High Priority - Provide economic development opportunities for the lowmoderate income and for their employers The City will seek to utilize Section 3 residents/businesses and M/WBE contractors to participate in housing rehabilitation, public facility and improvements construction, demolition of dilapidated structures, clearance of overgrown lots and other contracting opportunities. o Accomplishment: Through the Housing Rehabilitation Program and Other Projects, the City awarded 56 Total Contracts for $1,051,320.07 with Total M/WBE Contracts of 28 at $370,508.74 and Total Section 3 Contracts of 18 at $505,105.00. Through the CDBG and HOME Programs, the public service, public facility and improvements, code enforcement and program administration activities provided funds toward 49 staff members. The race/ethnicity of the employees was Asian-1, Black24, Hispanic-9, and White-15. There were 10 Section 3 employees hired through these activities. Program Administration Community Development High Priority - To facilitate neighborhood, comprehensive, and individual project management, planning, and capacity building activities for low/moderate income areas The City Grants & Housing Department will provide management and oversight for the CDBG and HOME Programs to ensure compliance with all regulatory requirements. The CDBG Program funded $232,600 and HOME Program funded $22,337 for administration of the City’s projects. Prior Program Year Project Accomplishments Through continuing efforts with prior years’ CDBG and HOME funds, the City provided the following activities. City of Galveston 2015 CAPER Executive Summary 20 Housing Program Housing High Priority - To provide and expand the supply of safe, decent and affordable housing through the development of new residential property The City will collaborate with certified CHDO’s to acquire and rehabilitate housing units for lowmoderate income person/s to purchase. o Accomplishment: The City continued working with CHDO activities from past years. Through a previous year RFQ, the City contracted with Houston Area Community Development Corp. (HAUCDC) to implement the City’s CHDO affordable housing project utilizing multi-year funding of $467,667.35. HAUCDC will purchase up to 5 properties, rehabilitate to code, and resell properties to eligible LMI households. HAUCDC expended $217,021.27 this period to complete the purchase of 3 properties and completed the rehab on 1 property; these are single-family units with 2 - 2 bdrm./1 bath and 1 - 3 bdrm./2 bath properties. In prior year, the CHDO conducted outreach community meetings and solicited homebuyer applicants to purchase properties. The HAUCDC CHDO balance is $250,646.08 to expend next period. The Galveston Historical Foundation (GHF) 3 CHDO properties previously completed that did not sell and were converted to rental units for LMI households continued to provide rental units leased to eligible LMI tenants. Housing High Priority - To provide and expand homeownership opportunities for low- and moderateincome homebuyers The City Homeownership Assistance Program (HAP) with $17,983.17 prior year HOME funds offers downpayment and closing cost assistance to eligible low-moderate income homeowners. It is anticipated that the HAP will provide assistance to 2 low-moderate income families or individuals. o Accomplishment: During the program year, the City Grants and Housing Department provided $9,958.39 in HOME funding assistance to 1 low-moderate income household in the purchase of their first home. The 1 first-time homebuyer was White with LMI percentage of 60%-80%. There were 8 homebuyer applicants that were approved as income eligible during the program year. The HAP has a balance of $8,024.78 to be expended in the next reporting period. Housing High Priority - To provide and expand the supply of safe, decent and affordable housing through the rehabilitation of existing residential property and the construction of new residential properties The HOME Housing Rehabilitation Program had a balance of $651,986.92 multi-year funds to provide minimum, moderate, substantial and emergency rehabilitation to approximately 4 LMI single-family housing units to prioritize owner-occupied housing. o Accomplishment: The Grants & Housing Dept. Housing Rehabilitation Program expended $200,614.58 and completed 1 owner-occupied unit and had 4 housing rehabilitation/reconstruction projects underway during the 2015 program year. The completed homeowner unit race was White at 30%-50% LMI; this was a handicap accessible project. The homeowner units in progress are 2 White, 1 Black, and 1 Hispanic race/ethnicity with 1 at 0%-30%, 1 at 30%-50%, 1 at 50%-60%, and 1 at 60%-80% LMI; there is 1 handicap accessible unit and 2 senior citizen projects. The following CDBG Housing Rehabilitation Programs have projects in progress that were not completed this reporting period; there are 3 CDBG funded projects underway that will be completed and the funds expended next reporting period. The CDBG Revolving Loan Fund had a balance of $223,364.20 during the reporting period; $16,246.09 was used for the Housing Rehabilitation Program as reported in the following activities. There is a balance of $207,118.11 to be utilized in the next period. City of Galveston 2015 CAPER Executive Summary 21 Grant Year/ IDIS # 2011/ #1334 Activity/ Allocation Description/ Objective Total Accomplishments 2015 PY Comments Housing Rehabilitation Program/ $329,627 2012/ #1378 Housing Rehabilitation Program/ $71,010.11 & RLF $495.00 Minimum, moderate, substantial rehab for LMI single-family household/ Proposed 4 units Assisting with 3 units in progress with accomplishments to be reported at #1415 and #1378; expended $40,193.33; balance of $85,774.31 to be completed next period 2013/ #1415 Housing Rehabilitation Program/ $182,635 & RLF $15,751.09 Assisting with 3 units and Completed 4 single-family owner occupied units expending $243,852.69 1 unit in progress and assisted with 1 HOME unit w/accomp. reported at #1422 expending $14,641.64 2 units in progress expending $86,465.50 Minimum, moderate, substantial rehab for LMI single-family household/ Proposed 1 unit Minimum, moderate, substantial rehab for LMI single-family household/ Proposed 2 units 1 unit in progress expending $1,815.00; balance of $56,863.47 to be completed next period 2 units in progress expending $81,790.60; Balance of $111,920.59 will be completed next period In the 2015 program year, the CDBG and HOME funded Housing Program completed accomplishments providing the total Outcome Measure of affordability for the purpose of providing decent affordable housing as per the following: Activity Housing Rehabilitation-Homeowner Homebuyer Assistance Total Accomplishments Accomplishment 1 1 2 Activity Housing Rehabilitation-Homeowner Homebuyer Assistance CHDO Acquisition/Rehabilitation Total Projects In Progress In Progress 7 8 3 18 During the 2015 program year, the CDBG and HOME funded Housing Program had the following projects in progress: There are 5 total rental properties under the HOME Program affordable housing projects from previous years in the City’s housing inventory. 2 of the projects are being maintained by the City and 3 are under the Galveston Historical Foundation (GHF) CHDO supervision. During the 2015 reporting period, 4 of the properties provided affordable housing to LMI renters as follows: 1 White, 1 Black, 1 Am. Indian/Alaska Native and White, and 1 Hispanic with 1 at 30%-50% LMI, 2 at 50%-60% and 1 at 60%-80% LMI. One property became vacant during the reporting period and required repairs. Community Development Program Public Services Community Development High Priority - Promote the health and well-being of city residents through the provision of public and supportive services City of Galveston 2015 CAPER Executive Summary 22 Grant Year/ IDIS # 2014/ #1431 Activity/ Allocation Children & Youth Program/ $150,000.00 Description/ Objective Provide staffing for supervised recreational and education opportunities to 1000 primarily LMI children & youth ages 5-18 Total Accomp. Provided services to 1,455 (91.6% LMI) children and youth at the City’s recreation centers located in LMI areas of the City; expended $150,000 2015 PY Comments Assisted with 2015 # 1451 children and youth program with accomplishments reported there; expended balance of $5,776.69; activity completed Public Facilities & Improvements High Priority - Promote viable neighborhoods through the installation and improvements of parks and public facilities. Grant Year/ IDIS # 2013/ #1416 Activity/ Allocation Wright Cuney/ McGuire Dent Park Renovation/ Reallocation $185,813.74 Description/ Objective Replacement of the AC’s at Wright Cuney and McGuire Dent Recreation Centers Total Accomp. Completed installation of the HVAC at McGuire Dent, scoped Wright Cuney AC project and City’s AC contractor installed 2 units; expended $185,813.74; 2015 PY Comments No accompl., project set to complete this period Infrastructure Improvements High Priority – Provide infrastructure improvements to support neighborhood revitalization and new residential development. Grant Year/ IDIS # 2010/ #1427 2012/ #1369 2013/ #1417 Activity/ Allocation Sanitary Sewer Improvements/ $123,024.91 Alley Paving/ $133,786.00 Sidewalk Installation/ $159,558.60 and Reallocation $113,349.35 City of Galveston Description/ Objective Replacement, slip-lining or pipe-bursting with no capacity increase to 4 blks. of main sewer lines Pave 20 alleys in LMI areas Install 15,000 ln. ft. of sidewalks in area of Aves. K-L from 25th to 57th Sts. Total Accomp. 2015 PY Comments Completed 1,150 (4 blks) of slipline in main sewers 29th & Sealy to Ball and 29th to Winnie 59 Church; expended $118,810 No accompl., balance of $4,214.91 was released this period and activity set to complete Paved 25 alleys; expended $120,275.19 No accompl., balance of $13,510.81 released and activity set to complete Completed final draw $229,963.73 this period and set activity to complete Completed engineering and bid, installed 23 blks of sidewalk in area of Aves. K-L from 25th to 29th; total expenditures $272,907.95 2015 CAPER Executive Summary 23 2013/ #1418 Sidewalk Installation/ $163,172.40 2014/ #1428 Sidewalk Installation/ $596,257.00 & PI $48,729.64 & Redirected balances #1369 $752.40 & #1418 $6,345.73 Install 8 blks. of sidewalks in LMI area of Hollywood Hgts./Parker School Install 24 blk. area of sidewalks in LMI area of Hollywood Hgts./Parker School Completed engineering design and bid project, installed 8 blks of sidewalks; total expenditures $156,826.67 Completed engineering and installed approx. 28 blk. area with 7,061 linear ft. of sidewalks and 29 ADA ramps; expended $646,084.77 No accompl., draw of $176.09 for prior period expenses, balance of $6,345.73 redirected to #1428 Hollywood Hgts. Phase 2 sidewalk project; activity set to complete This period project bid out; completed installation of approx.. 28 blk. area with 7,061 linear ft. of sidewalks and 29 ADA ramps; expended $645,484.36; balance of $6,000 used for staff adj. next period Code Enforcement High Priority – Provide code enforcement and neighborhood revitalization activities to diminish blight, unsafe buildings and lots, and general neighborhood decay. Grant Year/ IDIS # 2014/ #1430 2014/ #1429 Activity/ Allocation Code Compliance Officers/ $180,000.00 & PI $8,710.33 Lot Clearance & Demolition/ $30,000.00 & PI $644.16 Description/ Objective Provide 4 compliance officers to conduct 6,000 property inspections and 3,000 reinspections in LMI areas to enforce codes and ordinances Provide 3 demos, 95 lot clearances and boardups in LMI areas/ Proposed 98 units Accomplishments 2015 PY Comments Completed 3 demos and 154 lot clearances; Total expenditures $30,644.16 Completed 1 demo and 24 lot clearances this period; awarded 5 contracts with 2 Section 3 contracts and 3 M/WBE contracts; $375 used with #1445 and accomp. reported there; expended $2,980 this period; activity completed this period Conducted 10,993 inspections and 6,614 reinspections finding 4,356 violations; Total expenditures $188,710.33 Completed final draw of $8,609.69 for 2014 PY; activity set to complete this period CDBG Reallocations The City did not complete any reallocation of activity unused balances this period. There were 2 projects, as follows, where funds were redirected to another activity for the same objective and benefit area as the original project. This allowed for the effective use of the balance of funds from prior year projects. From: Grant Year/ IDIS # 2012/ #1368 2013/ #1418 City of Galveston Activity Sidewalk Installation Sidewalk Installation Description/ Objective Install 7 sidewalks that were storm damaged in LMI areas Install 8 blks. of sidewalks in LMI area of Hollywood Hgts./Parker School 2015 CAPER Executive Summary Amount $752.40 $6,345.73 24 To: Grant Year/ IDIS # 2014/ #1428 Activity Sidewalk Installation Description/ Objective Install 24 blk. area of sidewalks in LMI area of Hollywood Hgts./Parker School (area received high degree of storm damage Amount $7,098.13 Project Summary All CDBG activities funded in the 2015 grant year were used to benefit one (1) of the three (3) national objectives of the Community Development Block Grant Program. The City expended 100% of its CDBG project funds during the program year for activities that benefited low-moderate income persons. The CDBG program met the overall benefit certification that at least 70% of the CDBG funds were allocated towards activities that benefit low and moderate-income people. The City also ensured that individual activities met a national objective to provide a benefit to persons where at least 51% were of low and moderate-income status. All of the CD projects were designed to be of benefit to the low-moderate income population either by designation to a low-moderate income area or a direct benefit to lowmoderate income clientele. Since the City of Galveston has a low-moderate income percentage of 55.96%, CDBG funds are primarily directed to activities that provide benefits on a citywide available basis to low-moderate income individuals. The citywide activities include housing rehabilitation activities and youth recreational/educational activities. The identification and correction of code violations was conducted in citywide low-moderate income neighborhoods. The public infrastructure and improvement activities are located in low-moderate income areas as previously identified. Each of these activities provides benefits to primarily low-moderate income persons and indirectly aids in the prevention of slum and/or blighted areas. The direct service activities are open to residents on a citywide basis and will provide benefits to low-moderate income persons or families as measured through in-take documentation and determined by median family income limits provided by HUD. The City met its CDBG timeliness ratio on April 2, 2016. The HOME deadlines were met as follows: 2011 disbursements and 2011 CHDO disbursements by the deadline of June 30, 2016. The commitments deadline will be September 30, 2016 for 2014 HOME funds and 2014 CHDO funds. The CHDO commitments are met and the City has projects lined up to meet the HOME funds deadline. Leveraging Resources The CDBG Disaster Recovery Round 1 funds of $242M for housing and non-housing projects is still assisting in the City’s efforts in rebuilding the housing stock to over 800 households and infrastructure that was damaged by Hurricane Ike. The Disaster Housing Program is utilizing Round 2 funding during this reporting period to begin assisting an estimated 500 households. The non-housing disaster program is continuing work on projects from Round 2 funding. Due to the storm damage, FEMA projects continued to provide resources to the City in its recovery processes. The City utilized funding from the Federal Transportation Administration, Federal Highway Administration, Texas Department of Transportation, Department of Justice, Dept. of Homeland City of Galveston 2015 CAPER Executive Summary 25 Security, Texas General Land Office, and Federal Aviation Administration to meet its community needs including Island Transit, Public Works, the City’s Scholes Airport, the Planning Dept., and the Police Dept. As the primary assistance for the homeless services, the Continuum of Care coordinated through the Gulf Coast Homeless Coalition for provision of homeless services under the Texas Homeless Network. The United Way of Galveston Capital Campaign provides funding to assist many of the social service agencies located in the City that provide public services to the low-moderate income residents. Leverage totaling $319,000 is provided for the 2015 CDBG funded projects as follows: approximately $229,000 from general funds in prorated salaries of managers and other staff implementing CDBG funded City projects and $90,000 in operational costs for City facilities housing CDBG projects. The Infrastructure Project to install sidewalk improvements will be leveraged with an ADA ramp installation project at bus stops with some of the ramps located in the sidewalk project sites funded from a US Dept. of Transportation FTA New Freedom Grant totaling $378,072. The HOME Match requirement is 25% of the participating jurisdiction’s project funds drawn for affordable housing. The City of Galveston is determined by HUD to be in fiscal distress and receives a 50% reduction of match, making its match contribution at 12.5%. The HOME match required will be provided by the City and CHDO. The City of Galveston will satisfy the Match Requirements by using existing match carried over from previous years, match commitments obligated by subrecipients using HOME dollars, waived permit fees for HOME funded projects, and the City will use Rental Rehabilitation funds in conjunction with the HOME funds to be counted toward Match. The City’s Affordable Housing program utilizes cash contributions of non-federal funds, waived fees and charges, donated land, and supportive services for rehabilitation projects benefiting low-moderate income persons. Subrecipients receiving HOME funds provide matching contributions for their affordable housing projects. The following table identifies the 2015 HOME Match. HOME Match 1. Excess match from prior Federal fiscal year 2. Match contributed during current Federal fiscal year 3. Total match available for current Federal fiscal year (Line 1 plus Line 2) 4. Match liability for current Federal fiscal year 5. Excess match carried over to next Federal fiscal year (Line 3 minus Line 4) 182,124 5,728 187,852 54,415 133,437 Managing the Process The City of Galveston’s Grants and Housing Department is designated as the lead agency for coordinating and implementing the Consolidated Plan and the 1-year Action Plan. The Grants and Housing Department supports the concept of staff development for members of its team. Staff members are provided access to community development training programs offered by HUD, HUD contractors, and others. The access to training and development initiatives not only keeps staff abreast of new community development trends and reporting tools, but also the requirements of citizen participation and consolidated planning to ensure citizens access to the program, especially lowmoderate income citizens. City of Galveston 2015 CAPER Executive Summary 26 Prior to the start of the program activities, Grants & Housing staff facilitated Implementation Meetings with each funded City Department. The purpose of the meetings is to ensure that the Department staff is cognizant of the City and Federal requirements associated with the CDBG and HOME funds. The scope of services, budgets and schedules are reviewed and discussed. The staff provides a booklet outlining the Guidelines and Instructions to each City Department. The booklet covers all reporting (beneficiary and financial) processes, financial recordkeeping, monitoring, and other programmatic aspects of administering a CDBG or HOME funded activity. Any and all questions posed by the Departments are addressed by Grants’ staff and if necessary, follow-up meetings are scheduled to assist the funded entity prior to the implementation of the programs. The Grants Division was responsible for administrative oversight of the CDBG Program (non-housing) activities for compliance with HUD’s regulatory requirements including all Federal Labor Standards provisions, EEO Compliance, citizen participation, preconstruction conferences, environmental reviews and monitoring program activities. Staff prepared and submited numerous programmatic performance reports to HUD, City Council and citizen groups in the areas of program management, Labor Standards Enforcement, Contractor/Subcontractor Activity, program beneficiaries and fiscal accountability. Grants’ staff also are responsible for approving all CDBG and HOME funded expenditures. The Housing Division was responsible for the administration of the Housing Rehabilitation Program and the HOME Investment Partnerships Program for compliance with HUD’s regulatory requirements. Staff coordinated all housing related programs. All housing rehabilitation projects are monitored to ensure the work is in conformance with local, state, and federal codes and regulations. Staff also provided housing related reports to HUD, City Council and the public. Due to the City’s management efforts, all activities were in compliance with the program and the comprehensive planning requirements. Citizen Performance Report The Public Notice for the availability of the 2015 CAPER was published on August 10, 2016 in the Galveston Daily News. The Public Notice was posted on the City’s website on August 10, 2016 and throughout the 15-Day Comment Period. The CAPER was made available to the public for examination for fifteen (15) days, from Thursday, August 11, 2016 through Thursday, August 25, 2016. The performance report available to citizens for review provided information on the major initiatives and highlights that were proposed and executed throughout the year and included: the Federal funds made available for furthering the objectives of the Consolidated Plan; the total amount of CDBG and HOME funds available (including program income); the total amount of funds committed during the reporting period; the total amount expended during the reporting period; and the geographic distribution (including the census tracts) and location of expenditures. Maps were included to show the geographic distribution and location of investment (including areas of minority concentration). The Grants & Housing Dept. will conduct a Public Hearing on the 2015 CDBG and HOME Programs CAPER on Wednesday, August 24, 2016 in the City Council Chambers, 2 nd Floor of City Hall at 823 Rosenberg, Galveston, Texas. City of Galveston 2015 CAPER Executive Summary 27 Office of Community Planning and Development DATE: 07-21-16 Integrated Disbursement and Information System PAGE: 1 U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development PR26 - CDBG Financial Summary Report TIME: 11:35 Program Year 2015 Metrics GALVESTON , TX Grantee Program Year PART I: SUMMARY OF CDBG RESOURCES 01 UNEXPENDED CDBG FUNDS AT END OF PREVIOUS PROGRAM YEAR 02 ENTITLEMENT GRANT 03 SURPLUS URBAN RENEWAL 04 SECTION 108 GUARANTEED LOAN FUNDS 05 CURRENT YEAR PROGRAM INCOME 05a CURRENT YEAR SECTION 108 PROGRAM INCOME (FOR SI TYPE) 06 FUNDS RETURNED TO THE LINE-OF-CREDIT 06a FUNDS RETURNED TO THE LOCAL CDBG ACCOUNT 07 ADJUSTMENT TO COMPUTE TOTAL AVAILABLE GALVESTON , TX 2,015.00 1,744,920.93 1,163,000.00 0.00 0.00 87,862.12 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 08 TOTAL AVAILABLE (SUM, LINES 01-07) 2,995,783.05 09 DISBURSEMENTS OTHER THAN SECTION 108 REPAYMENTS AND PLANNING/ADMINISTRATION 1,441,407.53 11 AMOUNT SUBJECT TO LOW/MOD BENEFIT (LINE 09 + LINE 10) 1,441,407.53 PART II: SUMMARY OF CDBG EXPENDITURES 10 ADJUSTMENT TO COMPUTE TOTAL AMOUNT SUBJECT TO LOW/MOD BENEFIT 12 DISBURSED IN IDIS FOR PLANNING/ADMINISTRATION 13 DISBURSED IN IDIS FOR SECTION 108 REPAYMENTS 14 ADJUSTMENT TO COMPUTE TOTAL EXPENDITURES 15 TOTAL EXPENDITURES (SUM, LINES 11-14) 16 UNEXPENDED BALANCE (LINE 08 - LINE 15) PART III: LOWMOD BENEFIT THIS REPORTING PERIOD 17 EXPENDED FOR LOW/MOD HOUSING IN SPECIAL AREAS 18 EXPENDED FOR LOW/MOD MULTI-UNIT HOUSING 0.00 307,953.23 0.00 0.00 1,749,360.76 1,246,422.29 0.00 0.00 19 DISBURSED FOR OTHER LOW/MOD ACTIVITIES 1,441,407.53 21 TOTAL LOW/MOD CREDIT (SUM, LINES 17-20) 1,441,407.53 20 ADJUSTMENT TO COMPUTE TOTAL LOW/MOD CREDIT 22 PERCENT LOW/MOD CREDIT (LINE 21/LINE 11) LOW/MOD BENEFIT FOR MULTI-YEAR CERTIFICATIONS 23 PROGRAM YEARS(PY) COVERED IN CERTIFICATION 24 CUMULATIVE NET EXPENDITURES SUBJECT TO LOW/MOD BENEFIT CALCULATION 25 CUMULATIVE EXPENDITURES BENEFITING LOW/MOD PERSONS 26 PERCENT BENEFIT TO LOW/MOD PERSONS (LINE 25/LINE 24) PART IV: PUBLIC SERVICE (PS) CAP CALCULATIONS 27 DISBURSED IN IDIS FOR PUBLIC SERVICES 28 PS UNLIQUIDATED OBLIGATIONS AT END OF CURRENT PROGRAM YEAR 29 PS UNLIQUIDATED OBLIGATIONS AT END OF PREVIOUS PROGRAM YEAR 30 ADJUSTMENT TO COMPUTE TOTAL PS OBLIGATIONS 31 TOTAL PS OBLIGATIONS (LINE 27 + LINE 28 - LINE 29 + LINE 30) 32 ENTITLEMENT GRANT 33 PRIOR YEAR PROGRAM INCOME 34 ADJUSTMENT TO COMPUTE TOTAL SUBJECT TO PS CAP 35 TOTAL SUBJECT TO PS CAP (SUM, LINES 32-34) 36 PERCENT FUNDS OBLIGATED FOR PS ACTIVITIES (LINE 31/LINE 35) PART V: PLANNING AND ADMINISTRATION (PA) CAP 0.00 100.00% PY: PY: PY: 0.00 0.00 0.00% 132,020.17 23,024.39 9,094.56 0.00 145,950.00 1,163,000.00 131,478.27 0.00 1,294,478.27 11.27% 37 DISBURSED IN IDIS FOR PLANNING/ADMINISTRATION 307,953.23 39 PA UNLIQUIDATED OBLIGATIONS AT END OF PREVIOUS PROGRAM YEAR 116,515.97 41 TOTAL PA OBLIGATIONS (LINE 37 + LINE 38 - LINE 39 +LINE 40) 232,600.00 38 PA UNLIQUIDATED OBLIGATIONS AT END OF CURRENT PROGRAM YEAR 40 ADJUSTMENT TO COMPUTE TOTAL PA OBLIGATIONS 42 ENTITLEMENT GRANT 43 CURRENT YEAR PROGRAM INCOME 44 ADJUSTMENT TO COMPUTE TOTAL SUBJECT TO PA CAP 45 TOTAL SUBJECT TO PA CAP (SUM, LINES 42-44) 46 PERCENT FUNDS OBLIGATED FOR PA ACTIVITIES (LINE 41/LINE 45) 41,162.74 0.00 1,163,000.00 87,862.12 0.00 1,250,862.12 18.60% LINE 17 DETAIL: ACTIVITIES TO CONSIDER IN DETERMINING THE AMOUNT TO ENTER ON LINE 17 Report returned no data. LINE 18 DETAIL: ACTIVITIES TO CONSIDER IN DETERMINING THE AMOUNT TO ENTER ON LINE 18 Report returned no data. LINE 19 DETAIL: ACTIVITIES INCLUDED IN THE COMPUTATION OF LINE 19 2013 2 1417 Voucher Number 5843112 2013 2 1418 5878575 Plan Year 2013 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2015 2015 IDIS Project 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 IDIS Activity 1418 1428 1428 1428 1428 1428 1428 1452 1452 5843112 5849987 5878575 5904638 5907410 5910609 5929872 5887675 5898606 2014 3 1429 5843112 2014 3 1429 5859644 2014 2014 2014 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 1429 1429 1429 1445 1445 1445 1445 1445 5849987 5870428 5907410 5872332 5904638 5907410 5929872 5944829 Matrix Code Public Works Ave L-K from 25th to 57th Streets Infrastructure 03L Improveemnts Public Works Hollywood-Heights/Parker School Area Sidewalk 03L Activity Name Installation Public Works Hollywood-Heights/Parker School Area Sidewalk Installation Public Works Hollywood-Heights/Parker School Area Sidewalk Installation Public Works Hollywood-Heights/Parker School Area Sidewalk Installation Public Works Hollywood-Heights/Parker School Area Sidewalk Installation Public Works Hollywood-Heights/Parker School Area Sidewalk Installation Public Works Hollywood-Heights/Parker School Area Sidewalk Installation Public Works Hollywood-Heights/Parker School Area Sidewalk Installation Sidewalk and ADA Handicap Ramps Installation Ave L, M and O Sidewalk and ADA Handicap Ramps Installation Ave L, M and O 03L 03L 03L 03L 03L 03L 03L 03L 03L 03L National Objective LMA LMA LMA $111,993.14 LMA $332,323.39 LMA $401.35 LMA LMA LMA Matrix Code 03L Demolition & Lot Clearance/Boardup 04 LMA Demolition & Lot Clearance/Boardup Demolition & Lot Clearance/Boardup Demolition & Lot Clearance/Boardup Demolition & Lot Clearance/Boardup Demolition & Lot Clearance/Boardup Demolition & Lot Clearance/Boardup 04 04 04 04 04 04 04 04 $32.15 LMA LMA LMA Demolition & Lot Clearance/Boardup $143.94 $68,260.00 04 04 $229,963.73 LMA Demolition & Lot Clearance/Boardup Demolition & Lot Clearance/Boardup Drawn Amount LMA LMA LMA $4,140.00 $97,073.61 $31,694.22 $670.35 $876,695.88 $500.00 $425.00 $1,455.00 $225.00 $375.00 LMA $8,835.00 LMA $1,200.00 LMA LMA LMA Matrix Code 04 $325.00 $400.00 $350.00 $14,090.00 2014 1 1431 5843112 Children & Youth Educational/Recreational Program 05 LMC 2015 1 1451 5872332 Children & Youth Educational/Recreational Program 05 LMC $77,624.52 Children & Youth Educational/Recreational Program 05 LMC $9,989.73 2014 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1431 1451 1451 1451 1451 1451 1451 1451 1451 5853060 5878575 5887675 5898606 5904638 5907410 5910609 5929872 5944829 Children & Youth Educational/Recreational Program Children & Youth Educational/Recreational Program Children & Youth Educational/Recreational Program Children & Youth Educational/Recreational Program Children & Youth Educational/Recreational Program Children & Youth Educational/Recreational Program Children & Youth Educational/Recreational Program Children & Youth Educational/Recreational Program 05 05 05 05 05 05 05 05 05 LMC LMC LMC LMC LMC LMC LMC LMC Matrix Code 05 2011 11 1334 5859644 CDBG Housing Rehabilitation Program 14A LMH 2012 6 1378 5859644 Housing Rehab Program-Redirected Funds 14A LMH Housing Rehabilitation Program/Affordable Housing Program 14A Housing Rehabilitation Program/Affordable Housing Program 14A 2011 2012 2013 2013 2013 2013 11 6 4 4 4 4 1334 1378 1415 1415 1415 1415 5944829 5907411 5849987 5907410 5944829 5944830 CDBG Housing Rehabilitation Program Housing Rehab Program-Redirected Funds Housing Rehabilitation Program/Affordable Housing Program Housing Rehabilitation Program/Affordable Housing Program 14A 14A 14A 14A 14A LMH LMH LMH Matrix Code 14A Housing Rehab Delivery & Mgmt (Admin) 14H LMH 2014 4 1437 5859644 Housing Rehab Delivery & Mgmt (Admin) 14H LMH 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2015 2015 2015 2015 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 8 8 8 8 1437 1437 1437 1437 1437 1437 1437 1455 1455 1455 1455 5870428 5878575 5887675 5898606 5907410 5929872 5944829 5887675 5898606 5904638 5907410 Housing Rehab Delivery & Mgmt (Admin) Housing Rehab Delivery & Mgmt (Admin) Housing Rehab Delivery & Mgmt (Admin) Housing Rehab Delivery & Mgmt (Admin) Housing Rehab Delivery & Mgmt (Admin) Housing Rehab Delivery & Mgmt (Admin) Housing Rehab Delivery & Mgmt (Admin) Housing Rehab Delivery & Mgmt (Admin) Housing Rehab Delivery & Mgmt (Admin) Housing Rehab Delivery & Mgmt (Admin) Housing Rehab Delivery & Mgmt (Admin) Housing Rehab Delivery & Mgmt (Admin) 14H 14H 14H 14H 14H 14H 14H 14H 14H 14H 14H 14H $9,637.44 $3,253.57 $4,523.35 $4,346.09 $6,569.15 $132,020.17 $2,150.00 $38,043.33 $1,320.00 $495.00 $62,484.82 5843112 5849987 $3,821.38 LMH LMH 1437 1437 $3,160.38 $1,354.69 4 4 $5,776.69 LMH 2014 2014 $3,317.87 LMH LMH LMH LMH $2,200.00 $15,751.09 $123,798.93 $1,320.05 $2,578.92 $933.26 $972.74 $730.40 $70.34 LMH $267.05 LMH $165.24 LMH $18,369.63 LMH $24,376.02 LMH LMH LMH LMH $35.64 $165.24 $31,278.95 $6,061.33 2015 8 1455 5910609 Housing Rehab Delivery & Mgmt (Admin) 14H LMH 2015 8 1455 5944829 Housing Rehab Delivery & Mgmt (Admin) 14H LMH 2015 8 1455 5929872 Housing Rehab Delivery & Mgmt (Admin) 14H 14H LMH Matrix Code 14H 2014 3 1430 5843112 Code Compliance Officers 15 LMA 2015 3 1444 5878575 Code Compliance Officers 15 LMA 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 1444 5872332 1444 5898606 1444 5904638 1444 5907410 1444 5910609 1444 5929872 1444 5944829 Code Compliance Officers Code Compliance Officers Code Compliance Officers Code Compliance Officers Code Compliance Officers Code Compliance Officers Code Compliance Officers Total 15 15 15 15 15 15 15 15 $6,258.17 $13,193.10 $9,769.09 $116,545.17 $8,609.69 LMA $76,521.42 LMA $19,249.71 LMA LMA LMA LMA LMA Matrix Code 15 $13,483.03 $22,284.00 $6,772.55 $6,722.76 $11,267.87 $13,346.35 $178,257.38 $1,441,407.53 LINE 27 DETAIL: ACTIVITIES INCLUDED IN THE COMPUTATION OF LINE 27 2014 1 1431 Voucher Number 5843112 2015 1 1451 5872332 Plan Year 2014 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 IDIS Project 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 IDIS Activity 1431 5853060 1451 5878575 1451 5887675 1451 5898606 1451 5904638 1451 5907410 1451 5910609 1451 5929872 1451 5944829 Children & Youth Educational/Recreational Program Matrix Code 05 National Objective LMC Children & Youth Educational/Recreational Program 05 LMC $77,624.52 Children & Youth Educational/Recreational Program 05 LMC $9,989.73 Activity Name Children & Youth Educational/Recreational Program Children & Youth Educational/Recreational Program Children & Youth Educational/Recreational Program Children & Youth Educational/Recreational Program Children & Youth Educational/Recreational Program Children & Youth Educational/Recreational Program Children & Youth Educational/Recreational Program Children & Youth Educational/Recreational Program Total 05 05 05 05 05 05 05 05 05 LMC LMC LMC LMC LMC LMC LMC LMC Matrix Code 05 Drawn Amount $3,317.87 $5,776.69 $3,160.38 $3,821.38 $9,637.44 $3,253.57 $4,523.35 $4,346.09 $6,569.15 $132,020.17 $132,020.17 LINE 37 DETAIL: ACTIVITIES INCLUDED IN THE COMPUTATION OF LINE 37 2013 6 1413 Voucher Number 5843112 2014 6 1432 5843112 Plan Year 2013 2014 2014 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 Total IDIS Project 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 IDIS Activity 1413 1432 1432 1453 1453 1453 1453 1453 1453 1453 1453 5904638 5849987 5859644 5872332 5878575 5898606 5904638 5907410 5910609 5929872 5944829 CDBG Program Administration Matrix Code 21A CDBG Program Administration 21A Activity Name CDBG Program Administration CDBG Program Administration CDBG Program Administration CDBG Program Administration CDBG Program Administration CDBG Program Administration CDBG Program Administration CDBG Program Administration CDBG Program Administration CDBG Program Administration CDBG Program Administration National Objective Drawn Amount $4,961.82 21A $10,180.32 21A $53,245.63 $26,546.71 21A $21,581.49 21A $50,296.22 21A $4,092.03 21A $11,329.13 21A $58,016.55 21A $8,846.47 21A $17,502.82 21A 21A 21A $21,601.49 Matrix Code 21A $19,752.55 $307,953.23 $307,953.23 Financial Summary Attachment A. Program Income Received 1. Revolving Fund 3. Demolition/Clearance 6. RLF Interest 10,760.00 77,102.12 19.93 B. Prior Period Adjustments C. Loans and Other Receivables Economic Development RLF Direct Homeownership (5-year deffered, forgivable) Housing Rehabilitation (5-year deffered,forgivable) D. LOCCS Reconciliation Unexpended Balance of CDBG funds LOC Balance Cash on Hand: Grantee Program Account Subrecipients Program Accounts Revolving Fund Cash Balances Section 108 Cash Balances Grantee CDBG Program Liabilities (include any reimbursmts. due from program funds) Subrecipient CDBG Program Liabilities (include any reimbursements due from program funds) $ $ 1,246,422.29 1,039,304.18 $ 207,118.11 Cash on Hand Total $ $ 207,118.11 Liabilities Total $ $ - $ Balance (provide an explanation if an unreconciled difference exists) (0.00) Explanation (if applicable): E. Unprogrammed Funds Calculation Amount of funds available during the reporting period Income expected but not yet realized** Subtotal Less total budgeted amount Unprogrammed Balance $ $ $ $ $ 2,995,783.05 2,995,783.05 2,712,012.41 283,770.64 ** This amount should reflect any income considered as a resource in the action plan (and any amendments) for the period covered by this report, as well as that identified in prior action plans/final statements (including any amendments), that was expected to be received by the end of the reporting period but had not yet been received; e.g., program income or Section 108 proceeds not yet received from an approved 108 loan. 8/10/2016 Page 1