The Office of CITY MANAGER CITY OF LINCOLN CITY CITY
Transcription
The Office of CITY MANAGER CITY OF LINCOLN CITY CITY
The Office of CITY MANAGER CITY OF LINCOLN CITY CITY COUNCIL WORKSHOP MEETING AGENDA February 4, 2015 4:00 pm to 6:00 pm 4:00 p.m. - The City Council of the City of Lincoln City will hold a workshop in the City Council Chambers, 801 S. Highway 101, 3rd Floor at City Hall. The meeting location is accessible to persons with disabilities. A request for an interpreter for the hearing impaired, for a hearing impaired device, or for other accommodations for persons with disabilities, should be made at least 48 hours in advance of the meeting to Cathy Steere, City Recorder, 541-996-1203. This meeting is a workshop only, and generally does not include public comment. A. CALL TO ORDER B. ROLL CALL C. SPECIAL ORDER OF BUSINESS 1. Discussion: Visitor and Convention Bureau D. ADJOURNMENT To: Mayor Williams and the City Council Fr: Ron Chandler Dt: January 29, 2015 Re: City Council Workshop The staff is preparing to initiate the hiring process for a permanent Visitor and Convention Center (VCB) Director. Prior to doing this, we wanted meet with the City Council in a work meeting to discuss your priorities and goals so they can be incorporated into the hiring process. The work meeting is intended to be a free‐flowing discussion and will include the following discussion items. 1) Report about the Lincoln City VCB – Bruce Bustamante 2) Discussion of priorities and goals for the VCB – Ron Chandler/Bruce Bustamante. To facilitate this discussion, we are including the following documents in this packet. a. The VCB Marketing and PR Plan 2014‐15 b. A Recommended Format for Future Marketing Plans c. The March 2006 Visitor/Tourism Assessment Report. Lincoln City Visitor & Convention Bureau Marketing and PR Plan 2014-15 MARKETING OVERVIEW: OUR MISSION: The Lincoln City Visitor & Convention Bureau (VCB) was created to promote tourism in the area. Although the ordinance which established it acknowledged several components of its focus, particular emphasis is placed on two elements: (a) to stimulate economic growth and (b) to enhance the quality of life in Lincoln City by stabilizing the seasonality of tourism, that is, growing tourism in the shoulder and off seasons to, among other things, create and maintain employment throughout the year. OUR SEASONS: 33% of trips to the Coast occur July through September (down from 2010); 27% happen April through June (up from 2010); 21% January through March (same as in 2010); and 19% October through December (up from 2010). (Longwoods International, 2010 and 2013) The Coast is no longer a sleepy area that rolls up its welcome mat for the winter. Its shoulder seasons are growing, but the summer may not be. THE ECONOMY AND TOURISM SPENDING: Tourism is slowly rebounding as the economy improves. Oregon's statewide lodging trends have shown continued positive growth from October 2013 vs. October 2012. See the Oregon Travel Barometer, maintained and updated monthly, at www.traveloregon.com//industry. Lincoln’s Cities Numbers: Lincoln City’s gross lodging sales numbers have steadily increased from the 2009 low of $45,705,267 to $52,028,053 in 2013. The 2014 numbers as generally reported will be skewed because of the annexation of Roads End. The Lincoln City Finance Department has the data to determine regular growth by excluding Roads End numbers in 2014. Beginning in 2015, the comparison once again becomes simple. Prior to annexation, Lincoln City’s room inventory, including RV spaces/ campsites, was 3,868. As of April 2014, it had grown to 4,327. In the past decade available rooms in Lincoln City have grown by 1,237, only 459 of which resulted from annexation. The pieces of the pie are considerably smaller, which impacts property owners. In order to maintain an average 60% annual occupancy, about 170,400 more room nights have now to be generated than in 1004. Some could survive on less, but even 40% requires about 114,000 more room nights. 99% of those will come by motorized vehicles on our street.Though we lack data for comprehensive analysis, it is likely this inventory growth has Page 1 of 25 increased competition and driven down revenue per available room (revPAR). Other economic factors also contribute, making individual business profit more difficult. Oregon Coast Numbers: According to the most recent Longwoods International report, updated for the 2013 year, about 34% (same as in 2010), 10.3 million, of the overnight trips to Oregon include travel to the Coast, representing $1.6 billion in spending. In 2010 there were 9.8 million trips, representing $1.4 billion in spending. Nearly all of those are leisure or business-leisure, e.g., staying over beyond a convention. The two largest spending sectors are lodging (39%, $625 million) and food and beverage (25%, $394 million). In 2010, the total lodging spending was 39% also, but only $552 million. Food and beverage was a percent lower in 2010 and represented $350 million in spending. Average spending per person on overnight leisure trips for lodging is $57 (business trips $49) and on food and beverage is $35 (business trips $31). In 2010, the average spending on lodging for leisure trips was $55 and for food and beverage $33. The average number of night stays has declined from 3.4 in 2010 to 3.3 in 2013, while the party size has increased from 3.2 to 3.3. 63% stay in hotels, motels or resort hotels, up from 55% in 2010. Although it is somewhat difficult to tell from how the segments are collected in Longwoods, it appears that VRD occupancy may be down 1%. The main purposes for visiting1 the Coast are resort, outdoors, or touring. They were nearly equal in 2010 and remain so. Our largest markets continue to include Oregon (67%, up from 64%), Washington (18%), California (5%, down from 8%), and Idaho (2%). Idaho and Washington are the same, Portland and Eugene are the highest locations of trip origin. The internet is used 60% of the time for planning the trips (up from 49% in 2010) and 56% of the time for booking the trips (up from 43% in 2010). The average age of our visitor has gone down by .4% to 46, a year older than the average visitor to all of Oregon, which went down by 1.7%. Overall, by percentage, household incomes appear to have gone down some; fewer visitors are unemployed or empty-nesters. A smaller percent of visitors are white, while African-Americans and “others” have increased. Longwoods International Report 2013. Within the activities of interest, the beach has declined by 4% and shopping has increased by the same amount. Visiting historic places, engaging in cultural activities and enjoying exceptional culinary experiences have all increased since 2010, by about 3% each, and remain the top three activities of special interest. 1 A day-trip visitor must have traveled more than 50 miles to be included in the Longwoods data. That is generally considered to be the determining factor of the definition of a visitor and is thus the survey data we collect in attractions and special events. Page 2 of 25 OUR MARKETS, GENERALLY: Lincoln City has traditionally been a leisure travel destination, touting itself as a family destination. Although there is some business and convention trade, sites are limited (only 5 with more than tiny space) and challenging. In addition, the cost of getting here for conferees seems daunting. Since there is limited public transportation, out-of-state conferees must absorb the cost of air travel and car rental, as well as extending travel time from Portland or Eugene, in order to get here. Those additional ground transportation costs and time are not a requirement in larger metropolitan areas. Government and corporate conferences originating from areas within 5 driving hours are more plentiful. Without the future creation of larger meeting space and better transportation from the Valley, however, business and convention travel, though important, will always be a much smaller piece of the pie than leisure travel. The VCB serves approximately 2 million travelers annually, we think. Acquisition of vehicle-count data from recently installed counters will help us know that better in the future. Most originate within 5 driving hours of the area, with the largest markets being Portland Metro, Eugene, and probably Salem. Most of the Eugene market goes to the South Coast. Local travelers seeking a weekend getaway are generally far less willing to pay higher prices for lodging. Our lodging costs are often dramatically below what would be found in larger metropolitan areas or other parts of the county. More than half of visitors to the Oregon Coast are female, and more than half of those are between the ages of 45 and 64 (half Boomer, half Generation X). A third of visitors are between ages 25 and 44 (mostly Generation X, soon to be partly Millennial). The promotion formula is simple: Get them here and show them a good time in attractive surroundings so they extend their stays and come back. Getting them here with advertising and free press, as well as events and attractions, is only the beginning. Building satisfying relationships with them is critical. It requires providing good quality attractions and events not readily available where they live and that set Lincoln City apart from other similar communities, quality restaurants and lodging, stellar customer service, an attractive city, regular reminders we’re here, and invitations to newcomers to become repeat overnight customers. It is a community-wide effort. The VCB participates in most of it and leads in much. It is obvious from Lincoln City’s numbers that we need to increase the average night stay in order to reduce the impact on our infrastructure, particularly streets. OUR SUPPLIERS: The VCB also serves about 45 hotels/motels, 150 individual nightly motel condos, 3 bed and breakfasts, 4 RV parks/campgrounds, a dozen or so vacation rental companies, 513 individual VRDs within the city limits, about 80 food establishments, and a host of other area businesses targeting tourists. The industry annually generates more than $185 million in lodging, food, retail, Page 3 of 25 gasoline, transportation, recreation, and other visitor services to the local community. THE PRODUCT VISITORS SEEK: According to Oregon Tourism Commission (OTC) and Longwoods International 2014, the most popular activities for travelers to the Coast include the beach, shopping, outdoor activities, gaming, dining, exceptional culinary experiences, cultural activities, museums and historical sites. “Trips including cultural and heritage activities comprise one of the most significant segments of the travel industry, accounting for 23 percent of domestic trips. And those trips generate economic activity for local businesses. Visitors to historic sites and cultural attractions --- including museums ---stay 53 percent longer and spend 36 percent more money than other kinds of tourists.” (Keni Sturgeon, curator Willamette Heritage Center at the Mill, Statesman Journal, March 20, 2011.) The baby boomer market (33% of travelers to the Coast are between the ages of 45 and 64 and 29% are age 65 or older), currently the largest market with the greatest dollars available for travel, is looking for value in travel and continues to seek hands-on transformative experiences and soft adventure --- traveling to learn. They want their vacations to be extraordinary --- creating experiences and memories they can’t get anywhere else. They want an experience of value, not just a product. Seeing the sights is not enough, and there is a move from simply seeing to truly experiencing and making the event transformational by being absorbed in that experience. There is a burgeoning desire to stray from that beaten path and understand how the locals live, work and play, and perhaps give something back in exchange for that understanding.” www.hotelmarketing.com What is experiential travel? Experiences that connect you with the essence of a place and its people…simply seeing the sights is no longer enough. Experiential travelers want to venture beyond the beaten tourist paths and dive deeper into authentic, local culture, connecting with people from other cultures in ways that enrich their lives and create lasting memories. www.AFAR.com The transformation can be through a structured educational program such as a cookery class or meditation retreat, or through living and immersing yourself in a community and culture…Experiential travel will continue to grow as a market, with travelers seeking to enrich their lives with a collection of experiences. This is becoming part of their individual sense of sustainability, improving their sense of self worth through acquiring skills, education, knowledge and personal wellbeing whilst contributing to Page 4 of 25 the lives of others. It is critically important to understand this market and stake a position in this value system. Tim Peck, www.HotelNewsNow.com Today’s vacationers are experience-hungry travelers who want a transformative stay. Authentic experiences drive tourism. The days of sightseeing are virtually gone. The cover of Travel Oregon’s 2011-13 Strategic Plan was titled “Winning the Hearts of Experience-Hungry Travelers”. The plan expands on that concept: “The mass-market-consumer world is yielding to a world where people value connections and experiences more than acquiring the next new thing…People are no longer content to just watch the game --- they expect to be in the game. Consumers are increasingly hungry for authentic adventure and exploration….People want their travel experiences to be unique and highly personalized.” A large market fitting our goals is the “empty nester” who wants quality products, learning vacations, a new experience and sufficient attractions to make a multi-day stay worthwhile. Generations X (born roughly between 1960 and 1982) and Y (Millennials, born roughly 1983 to mid-1990s) have similar desires albeit different ways of satisfying them. The data indicates that more than half our current visitors are Generation X. 30% of visitors to the Coast are age 25 to 44. We must develop product for them also, since they are a significant part of our visitor base. The VCB conducts surveys constantly in a variety of situations to learn what must be done to further develop and maintain a good reputation and relationship with our visitors regardless of their age. Massive surveys were done in 2013, including intercept and direct mail. The report is available upon request. Although it is unquestionably true the beach is the primary reason people come here, visitors have a variety of good beach options over Oregon’s 365-mile coast, and those coastal communities compete for the same visitors. More is needed to get visitors to choose Lincoln City. Creating authentic experiences which invite visitors to be IN THE GAME and differentiating ourselves from other neighboring similar communities is critical to our future wellbeing. CHANGING TRAVEL PATTERNS AND COMMUNICATION: The worldwide economic downturn also changed the way people travel, whether in a daytrip or overnight. The urgency to be economical has increased “togethering”, travel in larger groups lodging together, eating in more, buying fewer souvenirs and seeking out free or nearly free entertainment. Black Americans and Latinos in particular find family reunions and gatherings to be important to their cultural fabric. Virtually nothing in the tourism industry is as it was 8 or 10 years ago – not the economy, not the mindset and patterns of travelers, and not the media available to reach them and engage them in conversation. Print media continues to decline as people struggle to survive the 5000 advertising messages they are exposed to daily, but recent studies show that print visitor guides continue to be vital to Page 5 of 25 travelers. Social media has become the predominant communication forum and thus a critical component of tourism destination marketing. Our ability to measure past successes or inadequacies is hampered by lack of data. We do not now get occupancy data from local lodging properties. Access to that data would be extremely valuable in determining the most productive promotional plans and in aiding valuation of lodging properties and other businesses. The vehicle-count data may be valuable in future years. This plan is an overview of the marketing goals for the VCB during the 20152016 fiscal years. At the end of the plan is a summary of the approximate marketing activities by month. The VCB budget is part of the budget for the City and can be viewed at www.lincolncity.org. As 2015 approaches, there will be a new VCB director and a new City Manager, both of which could alter this plan. Marketing a destination is different from marketing a business and must be approached differently. In Lincoln City’s case, marketing includes product (events, attractions, and venues) development, improvement of curb appeal, as well as traditional marketing tools like website and other technology development, public relations, free editorial press, social media, and paid advertising. Sometimes the destination is promoted to thousands and sometimes to one traveler at a time. It is the relationship developed between Lincoln City and the traveler that matters; a good reputation and enhanced relationships expand the repeat visitor market. We must strive to make each and every visitor an advocate for Lincoln City. These are unusual times in the tourism industry and this plan must be seen as a fluid document. Terrorism and war, global economic crises, economic downturn, the fear of tsunamis, and high unemployment numbers make it difficult to forecast travel trends and outcomes. Recent budgetary decisions described below have also changed the way in which the VCB interacts with the community regarding events, attractions, and marketing. Our stated goals provide us with targets that will focus our efforts, but should be considered quite fluid, as is the market. Fluidity will help us adapt to changing conditions in a way most beneficial to the whole community. CHANGING DIRECTIONS: VCC recommendations: The primary recommendations made by the VCC (Visitor and Convention Committee) and adopted by City Council were (1) a reduction in the number of events produced by the VCB alone or in partnership with others, (2) positioning the VCB as a participant in but not a leader in development of or builder of attractions, (3) increased effort on package development in the private sector, (4) increased commitment to convention and conference development; and (5) increased emphasis on social media and other electronic communications and press. Page 6 of 25 The latter was an expressed desire of the City Manager and the VCB and an obviously important focus. Attraction development has been a significant part of the VCB efforts in past years (Glass Studio in 2005 and Culinary Center in 2007) and a focus recommended by the Economic Development Study for Lincoln City done in 2006. Funds are unlikely to be available for major attraction development in the fiscal year 2015-16. Programs and changed advertising tactics will need to be developed to support extended nightly stays and group travel. Staff must work with for-profits and nonprofits to develop events and media that support brand and sub-brands and appeal to Gen X and Y. SWOT ANALYSIS: Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, Threats LINCOLN CITY’S STRENGTHS: The three things people look for in leisure travel, all of which Lincoln City has, include the following: Affordability: The cost of the vacation. Lincoln City has options available from camping to luxury lodging (and unfortunately more rooms than any other Coastal town between San Francisco and Seattle---a condition which encourages price wars and bargaining). It also has a large number of VRDs and condominiums to serve the “togethering” market. Service quality: The Lincoln City community and the Chamber of Commerce are active in providing quality service to our visitors. Most survey results indicate consumer satisfaction with our hospitality. Accessibility in time and distance: We don’t have as much control over this factor, other than that we are accessible from a reasonable population base within 500 miles. We are a convenient destination. We can, however, be challenged by winter weather closing travel from the Valley. Glass promotion: Lincoln City has brought awareness to itself for the past 16 years through Finders Keepers: Glass Floats on the Beach. This program continues to be a high demand visitor experience. Adding glass sand dollars and crabs to the mix and dropping larger quantities at preannounced times has rejuvenated the program. When those large drops occur, the phone rings off the hook and a “feeding frenzy” occurs on the beach. Coming here to hunt for floats has become a tradition for many. Page 7 of 25 LINCOLN CITY’S MAJOR WEAKNESSES Not “unique”: Lincoln City has not successfully set itself apart from other similar communities on the Coast and needs to continue repositioning itself to strengthen the brand that we are a great place to enjoy a handson experience, through such vehicles as glass art, culinary experiences, and kite festivals. Government alone cannot accomplish this. It takes a significant portion of the whole community and a drum-beater. So far no one is beating the drum. Limited meeting space: Lincoln City has an interesting but comparatively small amount of meeting space, wedding reception venues, and group tour lodging. No “walkable” area: Lincoln City has no satisfactory “walkable” area for shopping and dining. The Taft and Oceanlake Districts have a good start, as will Nelscott, but are not yet there. The Villages may be the first, best opportunity to create such an area. It’s an opportunity that shouldn’t be missed. Tired appearance: Although there have been recent improvements, Lincoln City looks to many like a town struggling to survive. Businesses have closed. Moss grows visibly on the sides of buildings and stores are in obvious disrepair. Even before the economic downturn began, Lincoln City’s main street was very unappealing and its lodging properties looked tired. Quality affordable restaurants are limited. Very limited family activities: We have few available activities for small children and the younger portions of Gen X and Y. Lincoln City lacks indoor venues to execute large festivals and events that can attract and accommodate large 5-figure or 6-figure crowds. Lincoln City lacks outdoor venues that have sufficient space and parking to facilitate large outdoor festivals and events. The Lincoln City hospitality industry largely sees the town as a family destination. At the same time, there is economic pressure to increase travel during the shoulder and off-seasons, the times when family travel including children doesn’t happen much. Those somewhat opposing concepts fight each other for both effort and money. Difficult for persons with disabilities: Our available services and amenities for persons with disabilities are inadequate. Although this is begin addressed, there is much to do. If Lincoln City could meet this market’s demands, the increase in valuable tourism would explode. Page 8 of 25 OPPORTUNITIES We are a driving destination when the economy discourages air travel. We are a community that, for the most part, supports and thrives on diversity and ecological responsibility. We could be the first community on the Coast to capture the largest market-share of persons with disabilities. We could capture a much larger share of travelers from the Southwest, Midwest and Rocky Mountains by creating and promoting things to do in the area, with Lincoln City as home base, until we can add more visitor attractions to our community. That is possible because we own www.oregoncoast.org, which can generate “click-throughs” to anyone wishing to go anywhere on the Oregon Coast. THREATS Our biggest threat is exhaustion and myopia. There often seems little agreement on who we are or where we need to go. No one is beating the drum. Our second biggest threat is anger and blaming, rather than working together to improve and promote Lincoln City as a desirable travel destination. As a whole community, we have not fully embraced the idea that we must invest in our tourism market and be forward looking if we are to thrive and we must find cooperative voices to move forward successfully. Comments from our visitors frequently reflect this. Our “competition” (e.g. Bend and Newport) is much farther ahead in the process of developing tourism product, and setting themselves apart. TARGET AUDIENCES (BUYERS – not listed in order of importance): Our best market is repeat overnight visitors Married women with no children and a household income of more than $70,000. Women make most of the travel decisions. Empty-nesters Group Tours Pacific Northwest Latinos, Asians, Anglos and Black Americans Page 9 of 25 Southwest and Rocky Mountain states through AAA and other regional marketing opportunities GLBT (gay, lesbian, bi-sexual and transgender) “Green” travelers Small business and association meetings and retreats Medium and small-sized conferences and conventions Motor coach tour groups Travelers with disabilities Travelers with pets Generation X Generation Y Nature travelers “Foodies” Patrons of the arts, culture, and heritage GOALS: Increase our repeat overnight visitor market Encourage longer stays by visitors to the city---develop Southwest and Rocky Mountain markets Pursue shoulder and off-season markets Continue to position Lincoln City as a place where you can enjoy handson experiences – be in the game--- A Great Place to Try New Things Per City Council goals, position Lincoln City as a community with a social and environmental conscience that stretches beyond its own boundaries and a community that cares personally Position Lincoln City as a community that embraces equality Promote Lincoln City to travelers with disabilities, younger people Maximize the return on public and private investment in tourism Assist in the development of areas of critical mass Assist in the development of tourism product, like the Glass Studio, the Culinary Center, the Cultural Center, and a Heritage Trail Assist in attracting reunions, conferences, conventions, weddings Continue development of existing signature special events, specifically the kite festivals, cook-offs, fireworks, and placing glass floats on the beach Evaluate marketing and publicity results and needs Participate in area beautification Expand electronic and mixed-media marketing within the limitations of staff and administration demands of grant and sponsorship funds STRATEGIES AND TACTICS: 1) Expand our repeat overnight visitor market. STRATEGY: It is easier and more economical to grow and retain this market than it is to develop new ones. That’s done by developing a good Page 10 of 25 reputation as a destination, offering impeccable hospitality, responding to the needs and desires of visitors, providing a variety of activities and attractions that entertain them four times longer than it took them to get here, and making all of that information easily available. More than 48% of travelers plan trips using the internet and 42% book services online. TACTICS: By definition, accomplishing this goal includes the tactics for the goals to follow, like offering opportunities for people with disabilities Page 11 of 25 Place special emphasis on customer service, including local training films in conjunction with the Oregon Coast Visitors’ Association. Maintain a top-notch website, mobile web access and e-newsletters Assist businesses in building affordable and attractive packages 2) Position Lincoln City as a place where you can be IN the game. STRATEGY: Lincoln City has already established a name in glass, and the Jennifer Sears Glass Art Studio has brought it a step forward in offering “artisans in action” as a tourist opportunity. To avoid staying in a narrow glass niche, which could fade over time, repositioning Lincoln City as a location where you can learn a trade or skill while on vacation (a brand not existing in this area and appealing to the baby boomers and other generations, as well as being part of the unique experience movement) would be beneficial. Building this flexible image will allow the “brand” to mutate easily with changing fads in arts and crafts education and will accommodate a wide variety of visitors with different interests and abilities. If a broader brand is ultimately developed for Lincoln City, this repositioning can easily continue as a sub-brand. The addition of the Culinary Center added a high class element to this repositioning. Bundle the products together in advertising/ press releases and promote the products individually to interested audiences Identify the interested audiences and how to reach them Assist hospitality businesses in developing packages that include handson activities TACTICS: Find the drum beater Continue to develop the Culinary Center for motor coach group tours, team building, incentive travel, multi-day classes, and private classes. 79% of adults say they like to cook, and 30% say they love it (Harris Poll, 2010) Attach educational opportunities to events Contact websites and persons interested in the educational product and find out from them how to reach interested audiences outside of Lincoln City through internet searches, targeted advertising, focus groups, and survey results Develop advertising and other promotional endeavors to foster the above, including targeted e-mail and animated float videos Develop a catalogue of hands-on experiences Promote the Glass Studio and Culinary Center to other cultures/ethnicities, travelers with disabilities, Generations X and Y Develop a nature-based tourism package Seek grants and other funding opportunities to facilitate activities Page 12 of 25 3) Position Lincoln City as a community with a wide-reaching social and environmental conscience and one that cares personally. STRATEGY: Develop and foster mutually beneficial relationships with social and charitable organizations recognized in the Pacific Northwest and other groups and continue developing green travel programs. 85% of potential travelers to the Oregon Coast identify themselves as environmentally conscious. 4) TACTICS: Attach a charity as a beneficiary to as many special events and attractions as possible, e.g. the Ocean Conservancy Research appropriate causes, charities, and attractions to attach to events Research appropriate similar sponsorship opportunities Highlight the relationship on their websites Release the nature of the relationships through PSAs (public service announcements) and press releases Continue developing a special services section on the website for persons with disabilities, including development of activities and attractions that can meet those needs, and acquisition of appropriate equipment Continue developing methods for making travel easier for persons with disabilities. Continue responding to visitor survey statements directly Immediate personal follow-up on inquiries for weddings, reunions, conferences and meetings Free step-on guide service Respond personally to hospitality complaints Develop and lead spouse and incentive traveler programs Position Lincoln City as a community that embraces equality. STRATEGY: Make overt gestures to invite other cultures and ethnicities. Chinese visitation to Oregon doubled in 2010 over 2009. Blacks, Asians, and Hispanics accounted for 79% of the U.S. growth in population between 2000 and 2009, according to U.S. census data. In 10 states, whites are now a minority among people 18 and younger. Oregon’s Latino population surged 63% in 10 years, while the Asian population increased by 41%. “Overall, Oregon grew by 419,000 residents, with Latinos accounting for about 43% of that growth. The state’s white population increased 5%, its black population 22 % and its Native American population 6%. People identifying as more than one race grew 33%, making the number of Oregonians ---about 110,000---choosing the multiracial category larger than both black and Native combined.” (The Oregonian, February 24, 2011) “Non-Hispanic whites now account for Page 13 of 25 78% of the state’s population, down from 83% in 2000.” (Statesman Journal, February 24, 2011) The importance of the expanding Hispanic market is clear in Google’s efforts. “Google has decided to put more focus on the US Hispanic market,” John Farrell, general manager of Google Mexico, told MediaPost. ”Google has created a specialist team …and has developed a methodical approach to develop best practices to help advertisers connect with this market segment.” (Hispanic Business magazine, March 2011) During the height of the recession, a respected travel survey found the LGBT market a significant one for tourism destinations. “Gay men and lesbians travel more, own more homes and cars, spend more on electronics, and have the largest amount of disposable income of any niche market…Lesbians and gay men are a dream market for the tourism industry…” The annual economic impact of LGBT travelers is approximately $63 billion in the US alone. (Community Marketing, Inc., 2009) “…one demographic that has refused to let the current economy put a damper on travel…is the Gay market” -- “Gays and lesbians tend to spend more when they travel, as much as $800 per trip compared to $540 for a straight man…plus they have more disposable income.” (NTAonline.com, May 2009) The Chinese are coming. The international market is currently being heavily driven by the Chinese, who are also heavily courted by Travel Oregon. The internet usage by Chinese, whether living in mainland China/HK/Taiwan, or Chinese living overseas, is very high. Internet usage via mobile phone access is the highest (compared to computers.) This is true of young adults, and their 40something parents, as well as educated/professionals in their 50’s. Asians 20-45 in the US have jobs and start businesses at a higher rate than Caucasians of the same economic class. Asians are very driven to succeed, and thus they have disposable income. Many Asians, in their native countries and here as well, do more than one type of work, or they invest in real estate. They tend not to depend on one source of income. They buy homes to live in and they buy them for investments. They are fast-moving and savvy, therefore they’re dependent on mobile phones. TACTICS: Continue researching how to market to those groups Advertise in culturally targeted publications Join ethnic Chambers of Commerce, specifically Hispanic, Asian and Black American Attend and exhibit at cultural trade shows and celebrations Bundle product that appeals to specific cultures Link to other group websites Page 14 of 25 Update website language translations Continue multi-language banner program 5) Begin promoting Lincoln City to new audiences with additional emphasis on old audiences. STRATEGY: Identify the new desirable markets and take overt steps to invite them here. TACTICS: Follow the tactics in #2 and #3 above Research the interests of and trends in travel of generations X and Y Bundle the products of interest to generations X and Y Promote those bundled products through the media used by them (1/3 of population is X at $170 billion/yr. They use internet more than TV) Seek sponsorships for events of generations X and Y Maintain the connections to the Ducks and the Beavers and pursue relationships/partnerships with other Oregon and WA colleges Add other high-tech marketing tools to facilitate those avenues Continue using an ad banner plan on other websites Continue meeting sales group Continue pursuing pre- and post- Portland convention traffic including through private presentations Direct mail to associations and clubs---update the list Direct mail to tour operators and travel planners and travel agent lists Direct mail to churches Develop military specials plan Continue supporting the execution of travel writer fams (research tours) Continue attaching “Pet Friendly” to dog websites and events Publicize nightlife programs Direct mail to Hispanic Chamber of Commerce Fulfill Travel Oregon online leads program Explore methods for developing alumni and faith-based tours and student tours and the product needed to support them Continue using and developing social media like Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube, with an emphasis on video and still photography Complete evaluation of social media program and make adjustments Continue using lure piece for OTTA Tour operators - Work with Oregon Packaged Travel – adjust for housing location Customizable e-postcards---see www.meetingpalmspring.com Keyword purchases on web Testimonials on the website---change them periodically Narrow down desired publications and get their editorial calendars---then pursue with pitch letters, etc. Maintain relationships with OTTA, ODMO, OTC, MPI, OACVB, OCVQ, COCA and Oregon Film Page 15 of 25 6) Assist in the development of areas of critical mass. Lincoln City is badly in need of a pedestrian-friendly area where people can easily gather, shop, eat and enjoy activities. No area in town has been adequately developed to facilitate that, and it is a priority for locals and visitors alike. We have been identified in the Economic Development Study as one of the few (and possibly the only) towns on the coast that lacks this important component. STRATEGY: Develop a plan and identify area(s) that may be easily converted. This will require multi-agency cooperation and broad community support. The VCB needs to be involved in these projects even though it is an unusual activity for VCBs. TACTICS: Work with the VCC and motivate City Council, Urban Renewal and other stakeholders to make this a priority and assist in locating funding sources and partnerships to facilitate it. Find the drum-beater Participate in the development of The Villages as appropriate 7) Assist in the development of tourism product, like the Glass Studio and the Culinary Center. Because of the competition from other destinations and the need to brand Lincoln City, we must develop additional tourism venues for activities and attractions, as well as additional other product. Festivals and other special events contribute to that but are short-lived, labor-intensive, and frequently destroyed by weather. Attractions influence travel here all the time, while events do so only on the days of the event. Festivals and events generally do not create jobs, while attractions usually create several. STRATEGY: Become a player in a multi-agency effort to pursue additional tourism attraction development. TACTICS: Find the drum-beater Create more programs like the crabbing and clamming clinics, e.g. tide pooling and photography hike programs Continue to develop the potential of the Glass Studio Continue the development of the Culinary Center and its programs Work with the City, Urban Renewal and other agencies and consultants to design, create, and open another attraction Continue pursuing public art with the Public Arts Committee and others Page 16 of 25 Create marketing partnerships with local for-profit businesses producing events beneficial to tourism Participate in the development of The Villages as appropriate Add to the Heritage Trail Project 8) Maximize the return on public and private investment in tourism through outside sources. Partnerships are a critical piece of our ability to position Lincoln City positively in the travel marketplace. With limited dollars on all sides, partnerships help us leverage funding and grow the reach of our marketing and development programs, as well as offering advertising support to local businesses with limited budgets. STRATEGY: We will continue pursuing partnership opportunities from outside and local corporations and foundations for funding toward execution, advertising and promotion of special events and attractions. TACTICS: Continue developing compatible cooperative advertising and trade show opportunities with organizations outside Lincoln City, like the Central Oregon Coast Association (COCA),Travel Oregon, Oregon Disability Sports, Oregon Paralyzed Veterans, and Newport 9) Maximize the return on public and private investment in tourism through local partnerships. Partnerships within our community offer opportunities to expand the advertising and promotion budgets of Lincoln City tourism business. STRATEGY: We will increase partnership opportunities for our local tourism businesses for advertising and promotion of special events, attractions and tourism product. TACTICS: Research and develop compatible cooperative advertising and trade show opportunities for Lincoln City tourism product Develop industry side of the website to announce opportunities Research and develop compatible event and attraction marketing partnerships with local nonprofit and for-profit partners Continue working with Chinook Winds, the Museum and the Cultural Center on appropriate events and promotions Work with the lodging industry to obtain occupancy data Page 17 of 25 10) Encourage longer stays by visitors to the city. Lincoln City has three primary visitor markets: Overnight, Day Visitors, and Second Homeowners. Although the overnight visitor is more desirable, all three have an economic impact on Lincoln City, even if they don’t contribute to TRT. All three markets are looking for something to do, see or eat--something having “bragging rights”. They are looking for “adventure” tales to take home. STRATEGY: Increasing the length of visitor stays will be approached through increasing the opportunity for bragging rights, developing niche markets, and broadening our sales area to include those visitors who travel further and tend to stay longer. TACTICS: Bundle attractions, itineraries, and events and promote to Southwest and Rocky Mountain areas Develop video itineraries on the website with “Ron” as docent Research new niche and specialty publications/media for advertising and free press Research new and specialty publications/media for advertising designed to reach other races, cultures, and lifestyles and join their chambers and activities when possible Update our website to include unique interests and learning experiences Update niche market brochures Produce at least two additional group tour itineraries Continue to make niche market brochures available from website Continue to participate in Research Tours with Travel Oregon Host Travel Writer Research Tour Continue annually to notify second homeowners of events/attractions Develop a Travel to Learn catalog Continue offering the attractions map as tear-off sheets Work with and encourage businesses to “spruce up” Re-do website packages so they can be located by month/season Move advertising to be substantially online and video 11) Assist local entities in attracting reunions, meetings, conferences and conventions. Lincoln City has limited services for meetings, conferences and conventions. Other than Chinook Winds, there is no space available to hold meetings in excess of 375 people, and Chinook Winds’ Hotel has, at various times, had restrictions on providing room blocks, making it difficult to be the host hotel. Most conferences and conventions want the host hotel to block most of the rooms. Those factors severely limit the number of conferences and conventions that can be accommodated in Lincoln City. We do, however, have most of the necessary services (except transportation). The VCB will continue to pursue small meetings, Page 18 of 25 conferences and reunions to increase usage of smaller meeting spaces and support Chinook Winds in booking conventions. Although the VCB has no separate sales person, nevertheless, some assistance can be provided to local entities to attract conferences and conventions. STRATEGY: The primary means for achieving this goal is to facilitate the sharing of conference/convention opportunities with the local entities that can provide the services and to provide support services for conferences and conventions. Some limited direct solicitation can also be made through tradeshows, sales blitzes, and other avenues. TACTICS: Continue advertising and pursuing trade shows for reunions, meetings, weddings, travel planners, and tour operators Provide leads to appropriate service providers Try to establish a conference web calendar Participate in providing support services for booked conferences and conventions, like itineraries, travel companion programs and information packets/resources Disseminate RFPs and participate in responses Continue conference promotion group meetings at least quarterly 12) Reduce seasonal fluctuation in tourist-related industries. Travelers equate the beach with good weather and summer. Those same travelers will risk life and limb through snow and ice to go skiing. It is the activity or attraction that drives these travelers, not the weather. Our goal is to develop activities and attractions that reduce seasonal fluctuation. STRATEGY: Continue developing existing tourism product which can be experienced in the shoulder and off seasons. TACTICS: (Some of these same tactics also appear in other sections.) Develop/promote niche related learning experiences in shoulder seasons Develop our website to promote ‘year-round’ activities including antiques, kites, dining, glass, niche and unique interests Research tools available to contact specific interest visitors directly “Extend your stay” attachment to POVA meeting planner sites and presentations to other DMOs with convention services 13) Continue the development of existing signature special events. The VCB was required to reduce its special events in 2012-13. STRATEGY: Our strongest remaining events are kite festivals, culinary, and glass. Because they are consistent with re-positioning and have available satisfactory venues, our goal is to keep those alive and fresh. Page 19 of 25 Tactics: Continue to work with organizations for-profit and nonprofit businesses Add at least one new (preferably hands-on) activity to each event/festival or some other feature to create news 14) Evaluate and generate free publicity. Expansion of our free press (publicity) potential is critical to leveraging limited advertising dollars. The economic value and reach of free press is substantial. Editorial space is better than anything that could be purchased. STRATEGY: We will continue to increase our effort to acquire free press through methodical campaigns and upgrading of photo library. Tactics: Annually update our press kit and image library Continually update the PR/social media grid and calendar Organize and execute at least one travel writers’ familiarization tour Identify and research attractions/events in our area that would be of interest to niche markets Target press releases at specific publications/media in specific geographic or subject matter areas Establish a 4-hour block of staff time weekly to develop free press Solicit articles from our local experts – food, antiques, kites – for publications Provide tours and interactive experiences for the press/photo journalists Develop relationships with individual press members Set a schedule of publicity efforts (timeline) for each event and attraction 15) Enhance the value of the VCB in the community’s view. STRATEGY: Educate the community about the value of tourism and the activities of the VCB Tactics: Set up speaking engagements at Kiwanis, Rotary, Lions, Chamber Continually remind businesses when we do something that promotes their business Let businesses know when visitors comment about them in our email inquiry PowerPoint presentation for groups Co-op trade show opportunities for businesses Broadcast e-mail inquiries for information, like those sent out by COCA or Travel Oregon Quarterly e-mail/mail of calendar of events Weekly hot sheets Page 20 of 25 16) Posters and press releases carried to all public meetings to build audience Tie business specials to events Continue providing marketing materials to businesses Update and promote industry side to VCB website Evaluate marketing and publicity results and needs. Our goal is to track the effectiveness of advertising and events. STRATEGY: Continue to survey event attendees and media contacts through established in-house and online systems. 17) TACTICS: Continue surveying special events for media and patron information Continue compiling Visitor Center contact information as it relates to calls generated from specific media efforts Create special web addresses and key words for information requests Continue evaluating special events for revenue generation to the community Continue to survey web traffic as it pertains to certain pages of the website and evaluate the need for changes to the site or changes to the promotion contained in various portions Evaluate results of website and other surveys Get feedback from tour operators Evaluate which news sources people are picking up and develop method for pitching stories to them Use prize drawings to evaluate placement and drive subscribers Maintain internal clipping service Purchase external clipping service? Beautification. The goal is to make Lincoln City a more visually appealing place to be. STRATEGY: Work with businesses and groups in town to clean up and dress up Lincoln City. 18) TACTICS: Banners and flags for Roads End Support Public Arts Committee Further the bus stop mural program with Public Arts Committee Pursue permission to mural the wall across from Inn at Spanish Head Expand general electronic and interactive marketing STRATEGY: Shift and increase the VCB’s promotional resources to emphasize electronic and interactive opportunities available through websites, social media, and mixed media opportunities. Page 21 of 25 TACTICS: Expand design of the VCB’s website, mobile applications, blog, and other electronic and social media Create video docent program with “Ron” Continuously evolve website as a destination for visitors to learn, interact, and communicate with the VCB and the community—system for updating weekly Carry out an online web/media strategy targeting current market sectors and to develop new sectors, e.g. Gen X and Millennials. Use giveaway packages to induce e-newsletter subscription and measure ad effectiveness Develop methods for audiences to interact with our brand online Ensure that all designs are user-centric for a clear and logical self-service experience for customers Manage internal and external marketing and website analytics, converting and presenting data as actionable information Manage the calendar of visitor Maintain an effective online social media strategy, i.e., blogs, Facebook, email marketing and multimedia to communicate with and receive feedback from potential visitors Develop more videos Develop integrated online marketing programs to generate demand using email, banner ads, search marketing, landing pages and other web tools Maintain the OCVA website partnership agreement Use search including SEO to develop awareness and generate web traffic Stay current with social media and other electronic marketing trends and recommend and incorporate into strategy as appropriate to improve visitor/media experience, as well as marketing efficiency Use social media as a communications channel with visitors daily, including on weekends Manage content on social media sites, keeping content current, appropriate, and accessible Execute media plan including public relations, print advertising strategies, online advertising, social media, and all other aspects of marketing Cultivate relationships with members of the media (print and online) Update and maintain targeted media contact list Use web analytics to fine-tune and improve website’s performance PUBLICITY AND PR Publicity and PR support the marketing plan by targeting the influencers of the buyers. Since this is essentially a bid for “free press”, the plan requires targeting the right media to reach the desired audiences and “selling” the information to the right editors. Because the publicity and PR supports the marketing plan, its Page 22 of 25 goals, strategies and tactics are consistent with the ones described above and won’t be restated here. Publicity will primarily be worked as a support for events, attractions, and promotions, although other opportunities will likely arise from time-to-time. This will be more difficult with reduction in events. It will be necessary to create news. (See tactics above, specifically 14 and 18.) PRIMARY PUBLICITY MESSAGES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Lincoln City is a Great Place to Try New Things – you can be IN the game There is something fun to do here all times of the year Lincoln City welcomes visitors from all races, cultures, and lifestyles Lincoln City’s tourism industry cares about the environment and wishes to give back by supporting charitable causes Lincoln City will do everything reasonably possible to make travel easier for persons with disabilities Lincoln City is home base for a multi-day stay PUBLICITY OPTIONS AND ELEMENTS One or more of the following options (or others not listed) may be used to pursue publicity for any event, attraction or promotion: Press kit---radio, television, newspapers---cover letter Individual event and attraction press releases Fact sheet Pitch letters Photo library Live shows -- celebrity Press clippings Testimonials Clippings used to generate more publicity Blogs and chat rooms, MySpace, YouTube, etc. Press reprints on the web Press clippings in press kit Web links to articles Tip sheets Editorial Calendars Articles PSA scripts E-newsletter Sponsorships Contests (e.g. photo) Surveys Press Trips Creating News: How-to articles or tips articles Page 23 of 25 PRIMARY MEDIA CONTACTS A directory of primary print media contacts in the PNW has been compiled, including identification of target writers and journalists. PRIMARY MEDIA Establish editorial calendar timeline for topics, not less than 5 months before publication or as set by media Update annually Print Media Contacts Update annually other media contacts Record publications and writers of free press obtained as it comes in and include in the contacts list Update annually website links, webcast opportunities and calendars Update twice a year the print media press---media impressions (how many people see the message) by circulation X 2.5 CREATING NEWS: SURVEYS, CONTESTS, CALENDAR DAYS, TIPS AND HOW-TO ARTICLES Consider completing one to three of these per month. Ideas might include interesting information about the ocean, how to find the best value in a hotel room, how to get the best deals in the shoulder and off seasons, how to be prepared for a disaster, how to find a tsunami-ready hotel, how to catch your own dinner. A staff member will develop one of these every month to be included minimally in the e-newsletter. PRESS KIT FOR THE WEB: Update it annually Get article reprints or links on press page---write for permission Continue developing press release archive Make photos searchable by subject matter “Contact sheet” with thumbnails that load quickly---have different sizes available, at least 300 dpi Regular checks on Google re: traffic E-NEWSLETTERS A general one has been developed which goes out monthly through Constant Contact. One directed solely to culinary pursuits was started in March 2010. Increase the readership of each by 5% annually. MASTER CALENDAR GRID A master calendar has been created to manage the PR, advertising and other marketing efforts, by month, through 2015. Faithfully maintain it Page 24 of 25 Update it monthly going forward with activities and ideas for 2016 Keep all staff advised of activities and information, including front end staff so they can “promote” over the phone Page 25 of 25 Marketing and Public Relations Plan 2015-16 GOALS: 1. Enhance the value of the VCB in the community’s view. Be identified as the tourism industry expert for Lincoln City. 2. Increase our repeat overnight visitor market and encourage longer stays by visitors to the city and develop shoulder and off-season markets. 3. Continue to develop and improve key marketing tools to competitively position Lincoln City as a premier destination. 4. Continue to position Lincoln City as a place where you can enjoy hands-on experiences “A Great Place to Try New Things” 5. Communicate to the traveling public that Lincoln City is a community with a social and environmental conscience that embraces equality. Goal #1 Position the VCB as the tourism expert and educate the community about the value of tourism and the activities of the VCB STRATEGY: Engage with local business and organizations to emphasis the importance and economic impacts of tourism in the Lincoln City community. STRATEGY: Update community on progress against goals and timely status of the visitor market. STRATEGY: Create a tourism stakeholder group and engage tourism beneficiaries on the value of tourism to the community. STRATEGY: Act as a qualified voice for tourism on key capital projects that impact Lincoln City visitors and visitor attractions. STRATEGY: Participate in visitor industry support activities in position the VCB as the leading resource in tourism. STRATEGY: Participate in planning and identify area(s) of critical mass that may expand pedestrian capacity. LINCOLN CITY VISITOR & CONVENTION BUREAU 801 SW HIGHWAY 101 SUITE 401 LINCOLN CITY OREGON 97367 TELEPHONE 541 996 1274 800 452 2151 FAX 541-994-2408 TDD 541 994 7432 WEBSITE: www.oregoncoast.org EMAIL: [email protected] STRATEGY: partner with local business to create additional promotional and marketing opportunities which add value to Lincoln City brand and product. Goal #2 Continue efforts to increase our repeat overnight visitor market and encourage longer stays by visitors to the city and develop shoulder and offseason markets. STRATEGY: Develop a good reputation as a destination, offering impeccable hospitality, responding to the needs and desires of visitors. Promote a variety of activities and attractions that entertain and make visitor information easily available. STRATEGY: Promote Lincoln City to new audiences and continue to market to Repeat customers that Lincoln City is a premier destination on the Oregon Coast. STRATEGY: Increasing the length of visitor stays through developing niche markets, and broadening our geographic sales area to market Lincoln City as an overnight destination. STRATEGY: Develop leads and share conference/convention opportunities with the local entities that can provide the services and to provide support services for conferences and conventions. STRATEGY Continue developing compatible cooperative advertising and trade show opportunities with organizations outside Lincoln City. Goal #3 Continue to position Lincoln City as a place where you can enjoy handson experiences A Great Place to Try New Things. STRATEGY: Our strongest events are kite festivals, culinary, and glass. They are consistent with re-positioning and have available satisfactory venues, our goal is to keep those alive and fresh. STRATEGY: Further develop Lincoln City’s unique visitor attractions incorporate into destination product offering and messaging. LINCOLN CITY VISITOR & CONVENTION BUREAU 801 SW HIGHWAY 101 SUITE 401 LINCOLN CITY OREGON 97367 TELEPHONE 541 996 1274 800 452 2151 FAX 541-994-2408 TDD 541 994 7432 WEBSITE: www.oregoncoast.org EMAIL: [email protected] Goal #4 Continue to develop and improve key marketing tools to competitively position Lincoln City as s premier destination. STRATEGY: Expand our earned press (publicity) potential by developing relationships with Pacific NW travel writers and ensuring that our destination content accurately represents our destination. STRATEGY: Continue to survey event attendees and media contacts through established in-house and online systems. Track the effectiveness of advertising in promoting events STRATEGY: Shift and increase the VCB’s promotional resources to emphasize electronic and interactive marketing opportunities available through websites, social media, and mixed media opportunities. STRATEGY: Develop integrated online marketing programs to generate demand using email, banner ads, search marketing, landing pages and other web tools Goal #5 Position Lincoln City as a community with a wide-reaching social and environmental conscience and one that cares personally. STRATEGY: Continue pursuing partnership opportunities from outside and local corporations and foundations for funding toward execution, advertising and promotion of special events and attractions. STRATEGY: Participate in promoting green travel initiatives such as electric vehicle charging stations to meet the needs of our environmental conscience visitors. STRATEGY: Increase partnership opportunities for our local tourism businesses for advertising and promotion of special events, attractions and tourism product. LINCOLN CITY VISITOR & CONVENTION BUREAU 801 SW HIGHWAY 101 SUITE 401 LINCOLN CITY OREGON 97367 TELEPHONE 541 996 1274 800 452 2151 FAX 541-994-2408 TDD 541 994 7432 WEBSITE: www.oregoncoast.org EMAIL: [email protected] MARCH 2006 L I N C O L N C I T Y, O R E G O N VISITOR/TOURISM ASSESSMENT TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS I n January of 2006, a Tourism Assessment of Lincoln City, Oregon was conducted, and was presented in a three-hour workshop in March. A “Tourism Assessment” is a process in which the area is looked at from the eyes of a visitor. No prior research was facilitated, no community representatives were contacted except to set up the project, and the town and surrounding area was “secretly shopped.” Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 First impressions ...and some ideas to increase tourism spending. The assessment is a no-holds-barred look at the community from a visitor’s perspective. It includes marketing, signage, things to see and do (attractions mix), critical mass, ease of getting around, customer service, availability of visitor amenities (information, rest rooms, parking, etc.), general appeal, and the community’s ability to attract overnight visitors, who spend three times that of day visitors. There are two primary elements to the assessment process: 1) A Marketing Effectiveness Assessment 2) On-site Assessment In the Marketing Effectiveness Assessment two people were asked to plan trips into the region both as a leisure and business traveler. They are not told in advance what communities are actually being assessed. They are to use whatever resources they would typically use in planning a trip: travel guides, brochures, the internet, calling visitor information centers, etc. The community has four opportunities to close the sale: • Personal contact (visitor information, trade shows, etc.) • Internet (websites) • Brochures and printed materials • Word of mouth (referrals, image) In this process we test all four methods by contacting area visitor information services and attractions, looking for activities via the internet, requesting and reviewing printed materials, and asking visitors and regional contacts about their opinions of the area. This last method also includes looking at online articles, AAA Tour Book reviews, etc. The findings determine how “visible” the community is during the research and whether or not the materials and/or person- • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS al contacts were good enough to “close the sale,” convincing the potential visitor that the community is worth either a day trip, stop, or an overnight stay. The On-site Assessment process includes a look at enticement from freeways and highways (signs, billboards, things that would pull a visitor off the primary roadways), beautification, wayfinding (ease of getting around), visitor amenities (public restrooms, visitor information, parking), things to see and do, overall appeal of the community, business attractiveness (drawing power), signage (public and private), customer service, area attractions (things that might prompt a visitor to spend the night), retail mix (lodging, dining, shopping), critical mass (are these things concentrated in a pedestrian-oriented area?), availability of marketing materials and their effectiveness. The “Recommendations” made herein are referred to as “suggestions,” as they were developed without consulting the local community. It will be up to the community to adopt some or all of the suggestions, taking them from suggestions to recommendations. For every shortcoming or challenge we note during the assessment process, we have provided a low-cost suggestion (when possible) on how the challenge, obstacle or negative element can be corrected. It’s important to point out, that to increase the community’s tourism industry, fulfilling one or two of the suggestions will have little impact, but implementing a number of them, if not all of them, can have a profoundly successful impact on the community’s ability to tap into the tourism industry. Implementation of these suggestions must be a community effort - involving both privately owned businesses as well as county and state agencies, where appropriate. A Destination Marketing Organization (DMO or CVB, Chamber, etc.) cannot be successful if the tourism effort is not a community-wide effort. Tourism is largely a private-sector industry, after all, the benefit of tourism is to convince visitors to come, spend money, then go home. That spending takes place, primar • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 ily, in local businesses. Product development is far more of a driving factor in tourism than marketing. After all, you must be able to deliver on your marketing promises. Visitors are drawn to activities, not cities or counties. The Visitor/Tourism Assessment took place over a period of several days, providing a low-cost overall assessment with ideas the community can discuss and hopefully implement. Successful tourism translates to cash • The idea is to import more cash into your community than you export. When local residents earn money in the community and spend some of it outside the community, this is referred to as “leakage.” Tourism is a way to fill that gap, importing cash into the community, without the necessity of having to provide extended social and other services. Communities with successful tourism programs will see that the industry subsidizes the community, whereas communities which don’t have successful tourism programs find that they are subsidizing visitors - providing services which visitors use, but don’t leave enough money behind to cover the cost of having them available. There are three kinds of tourism • 1. Status quo If you do nothing to further the tourism industry, you will still have an element of tourism, just by the fact that some visitors will pull off local highways or freeways for services (gas, food, lodging), and by the fact that the number one reason for travel is to visit friends or family. If you have residents, you will have tourism. • 2. Getting people to stop Getting people to stop is always the first priority of successful tourism. Imagine how successful the businesses in the community would be if just 50% of the vehicles traveling through (there are hundreds of thousands every year) pulled off the highway and spent just 30 minutes in your community. And if there’s a strong pull, imagine the money spent if visitors stayed two hours in the community, which almost always translates to additional spending. • 3. Becoming the destination You cannot be a successful tourism destination if you can’t get people to stop. And to become the destination, you must have attractions (things to see and do) or amenities that will convince visitors to spend the night. Overnight visitors spend three times that of day visitors, and nearly ten times that of visitors making a “pit stop.” TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS The Four-Times Rule • Visitors will make it a point of stopping or staying in your community if you have enough to offer to keep them busy four times longer than it took them to get there. In other words, if a person has to drive 15 minutes to visit you, do you have enough for them to do to keep them busy for an hour? (4 times 15 minutes). If a visitor drives an hour, do you have the activities and amenities to keep them busy for four hours? In a nutshell, if you hope to keep visitors overnight, you must make it worth the drive. The more you have to offer, the further visitors will come, and the longer they will stay. This is why rural communities MUST typically market more than just the immediate downtown areas. You need to market neighboring communities, outdoor recreational opportunities, exploration, and discovery. Finally, you must also be different. Too many communities promote “outdoor recreation” as a primary draw. But if residents living in the markets you’re hoping to attract can enjoy the same activities closer to home, then why should they go out of their way or the extra distance to visit you? Market the broader package • Every community MUST market more than just the community in order to be successful with their tourism efforts. Remember the Four-Times Rule and also remember that visitors don’t • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 stay within or care about boundaries - so market the attractions you have around your community that might keep people in the area long enough to translate to another meal, some shopping, or an overnight stay. The more you have to offer “collectively,” the longer visitors will stay. And the longer they stay, the more they spend. Critical mass means cash • While it may not be the primary reason why visitors come to your community, shopping and dining in a pedestrian setting is the number one activity - and where visitors spend the most amount of money - other than lodging. Do you have a pedestrian-oriented shopping district? If not, can you create one? Many rural communities have been highly successful with the development of a two or three block long pedestrian “village” which would include visitor-oriented retail shops, dining, visitor information, restrooms, etc., all in an attractive, well-landscaped setting. The general rule of thumb is ten retail stores (more on that in a minute), and ten dining establishments which can include sit-down restaurants, espresso bars, cafes, dessert and ice cream shops, etc. “Visitor Retail” would include antique stores, galleries, collectibles, souvenir shops, T-shirt shops, outfitters, bike and jeep rentals, guided tour operations, activity shops (kites, hiking, climbing gear, etc.), home accents, jewelry, old-fashioned hardware stores, casinos, entertainment facilities such as movie theaters, pubs, etc. By grouping these businesses together, you will create the “critical mass” in a pedestrian setting that will draw visitors and will make it worth their while to stop and shop. Have you ever noticed at major intersections you will see a Chevron, Union 76, Conoco, and Shell on each of the four corners? Or how about fast food franchises? McDonald’s, Burger King, Jack In The Box, and Wendy’s on each corner. You would think these places would avoid being next to the competition, but they know that visitors are drawn to the “critical mass” where they have multiple choices that are convenient. Where are your visitor-oriented shops? If they are spread out, they will be marginally successful when it comes to tapping into visitor spending. Put them all together, and you have what it takes to get visitors out of their cars (or busses and RV’s) and into your stores. TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS You must be different or better than everyone else • To become a destination community where you’re the place visitors spend the night or multiple days, you must set yourself apart from everyone else. In order to make your community “worth the drive” and/or “worth a special trip,” you must be better or different from other competing communities. Ashland, Oregon, previously a depressed timber town, adopted its Shakespeare Festival which runs nine months of the year and draws hundreds of thousands of visitors who spend an average of six nights in the community. It became “different” than other communities and the festival set it apart. Leavenworth, Washington, another dying timber town, adopted a Bavarian architectural theme and all of their events revolve around the Bavarian theme. The town is one of the primary tourist attractions in Washington state, hosting more than two million visitors annually. They have something different to offer. Okanogan County, Washington (just south of the Canadian border in central Washington) is an outdoor recreational paradise - but so are 37 of the 38 other counties in Washington. So why go to the Okanogan? Because they are the best. They researched guide books, newspaper and magazine articles, and pulled quotes they could use in their advertising efforts. They started using quotes along the line of “Pinch Yourself, you’re in Okanogan Country with perhaps the best cross country skiing on the continent.” This, and numerous other quotes, • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 makes it “worth the extra drive” to visit Okanogan Country. They used third party endorsements to show that they are the “best.” Just look at how powerful movie ratings are when it comes to box office receipts. “Two thumbs up” carries a lot of weight. TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Tourism is the fastest growing industry in all 50 states and the nations third-largest industry. In Oregon, tourism is a $7.4 billion industry, and much of that is spent along the Oregon coast. For coastal communities, tourism is and always will be the primary industry. Hundreds of coastal communities have spent decades hoping to diversify from tourism, but with little success. The effort should be geared to creating a brand that sets the community apart from other coastal communities, will spur non-tourism development around the brand, and one that will extend the seasons. If you were to pick up the entire city of Lincoln City, and plop it down in the hills of McMinville, would the community survive? What do you have beyond the beach that will extend your seasons? The beach is, no question, the number one tourist attraction in the world - during the peak seasons, but what about the rest of the year? And most importantly, what do you have to offer that a visitor can’t get at other beach areas closer to home? The first element in a successful tourism program is getting visitors to stop. If you can get them to stay at least two hours, chances are you’ll see additional spending. But becoming the destination should be the primary goal. Overnight visitors spend three times more than day visitors. • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS BRANDING Branding is critical, especially for tourism-driven economies. Branding extends far beyond slogans and logos - branding is your image, your value, your promise. Branding is what sets you apart from everyone else. Many communities need to develop a branding image, and they do that through product development first, then public relations, followed by advertising and sales efforts. First, though, the community needs to take a close look at itself and decide what its brand will be - what does it already have that differentiates itself from other similar communities? What is its lure? Then build on that. Suggestion #1: Promote specific businesses that will make Lincoln City worth a special trip, or at least make it worth a stop. Stating “we have unique shops” doesn’t set you apart from anyone else. Sometimes visitors will travel a great distance to eat at a special restaurant that’s highly rated or renowned. You MUST promote these opportunities. Note Newport has done a good job sticking to its brand as a working fishing village and home of the Oregon Coast Aquarium. Everything fits the brand: the murals, the retail shops, the working marina and docks, etc. Visitors are drawn to the activities in downtown Newport. • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Branding ideas and comments • The “surf city” town of the Northwest, like Pismo Beach. Funky. 60s. • The “glass float” capital - not just one event. Glass blowing artists from around the world. Special events. Learning. • The Oregon Coast event capital. Always something going on. • The Oregon Coast Plaza - the shopping mecca of the coast. “Make tracks to the Ocean” is not a brand and promotes the entire coast, a very noble cause that I’m sure Seaside, Cannon Beach, Newport, and the other coastal communities appreciate. “The Beach is just the Beginning” is not a brand and doesn’t say anything about Lincoln City at all. Tell the visitor WHY they should come to Lincoln City. Who are you? What is your brand? What are you known for? And is that a good thing? What can you promote that is unique, positive, and worth the drive? Suggestion #2: Create a Tourism Development, Branding & Marketing Action Plan. This should be your number one priority. The Plan will help identify the brand, and what product development needs to take place to support the brand and make it successful. It will dovetail with non-tourism economic development efforts. It will include key messages, marketing slogans, graphic images, icons, signage design, ad design concepts, and recommendations regarding wayfinding, signage, and entries. The plan should also include recommendations for marketing, advertising, and public relations including detailed budgets. Recommendations should include ten to twenty year capital projects planning to support the brand development. The plan should also include a three to five year detailed marketing plan. You build your brand through public relations, advertising is used to maintain your position. • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Note It takes a village to obtain success. It must also be a grassroots effort - top down seldom works. • The business community must take the lead • Business organizations take on the cause • Together they come to the city for help • The business community STILL takes the lead. The city only provides support: grants, ordinances, funding, technical assistance • Winning popularity contests won’t result in a successful effort. You can’t be all things to all people. • Every branding effort requires a “tireless pioneer” Suggestions #3 & #4: Develop continuity in your marketing pieces. The brochures (above left) are terrific and help create continuity in your marketing efforts. Additionally, these have been developed around different experiences - a great job, and well done. Now get the guides and other materials to follow suit. Develop a professional photo library. Nothing sells better than excellent photography. Suggestion #5: Rework your advertising to be specific to Lincoln City. Most of the photos we viewed online, in brochures, the visitors guide and postcard seem dated and of poor quality. Invest in a new professional photo library. Make them modern and cutting edge. Once you develop a brand, it will help guide the type of photos you need, including content. • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Words to avoid Visitors are looking for activities, not just things to look at. Always sell the “rapids” - not the “river.” Avoid: • Marketing counties • Marketing cities Avoid these words: • Explore • Discover • Outdoor recreation • We have it all • Naturally fun • The four season destination • Something for everyone • Historic downtown • Center of it all • Gateway Main Street trends • Festivals and events is the fastest growing trend in tourism. • Creation of “gathering places” • Activity-based retail: Restaurant and culinary education, visiting artists • People are moving into downtowns Welcome to the experience economy. You must sell activities, education, culture, and fun - experiences. The beach is the draw, but then what? THE INTERNET The top marketing priority should be placed in the internet. 94% of all internet-abled people use the web as their primary travel resource. It is, by far, where most of the marketing effort should be directed. Even your advertising should drive people to your website. But then, the website MUST be good enough to close the sale. How do you stack up against Seaside? Cannon Beach? Newport? Rockaway Beach? Florence? 10 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Suggestion #6: Develop an e-marketing program. It must be permission-based, and provide the reader with real information about something they’re interested in or special deals. E-marketing creates top of mind awareness. The customer gets a short e-mail once a month, or even every other month, and when they see it, they remember Lincoln City. Since most getaways are now planned within three weeks of the departure, you want to be the first place that comes to mind when someone says, “let’s get away this weekend. Where should we go?” Make your teaser e-mails specific, short (one or two paragraphs, max), and good enough that the recipient will click on a link to get more information. Make it easy for them to unsubscribe, as well. Suggestion #7: Purchase key word listings. It’s one thing to have a great website; it’s another to have people find it. Purchase strategic, activitybased, key words from Google and Overture, who command 70% of all search engine searches. 11 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Purchase key words Make sure the keywords are activity based. People are looking for things to do, not locations. Some suggestions: • Oregon Coast • Glass floats • Ocean storms • Central Oregon Coast • Glass blowing Oregon • Surfing Oregon • Outlet malls Oregon • Shopping Oregon coast • Beachcombing Oregon coast Suggestion #8: Make all your marketing materials available for viewing online, and have them be downloadable for printing as well. Make it as easy and convenient for potential visitors as possible to get the information they want. Make sure your materials will print easily on 8.5” x 11” paper. Suggestion #9: Include special deals on your website - with specifics. Don’t use discount percentages - that doesn’t tell the reader what they really want to know, which is “how much!” Use real dollar amounts. Offering special deals on your website creates a call to action, a sense of urgency, and a reason to check back again and again for other, new special deals. 12 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Suggestion #10: Purchase additional domain names to help sell your activities. Make sure they are short and easy to remember. For instance, Tucson, Arizona uses visittucson.com, but during the winter when they are trying to attract frozen northerners, they promote another domain, www.worshipthesun.com. Both take you to the same site, but which is a better lure and still easy to remember? You may end up with half a dozen domain names used to market to niche groups. You can register a domain name for about $8.95 at GoDaddy.com. Suggestion #12: Develop some video clips to include on your website. Make it fun and engaging. But be sure the viewer has the OPTION of clicking on the video - don’t make it mandatory. Streaming video sells. Create one to four minute clips of various fun experiences. Suggestion #13: Work with OCVA to develop a new website. Use EOVA.org’s site as a benchmark. Be sure to use lots of eye-catching professional photography, and keep the text as brief as possible. Website viewers don’t read - they scan. Use bullet points, and be sure to provide the details and information that potential visitors want to know. What do you want to find out when you’re deciding where to go on vacation? Be sure to include that. Don’t overwhelm your viewer with too many categories, and make your site easy to navigate. 13 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Note The Eastern Oregon Visitors Association’s (EOVA) website (left) does a good job of selling experiences. It includes professional photography, itineraries, and is a very well designed website. Compare the OCVA site to central Oregon’s site and others. How does it stack up? Is it good enough to close the sale? Suggestion #14: Provide more details. Every day? Once a month? How often do you put floats out? If chances seem very remote that I might find a float, then why bother? Why pick Lincoln City over other coastal towns? What else could you do, with the same amount of money that might do a better job of closing the sale? Our secret shoppers weren’t so sure the glass floats was enough to entice them to Lincoln City over other beach destinations closer to home. Demographics: The baby boom generation The baby boom generation: • 350,000 turning 50 - every MONTH • For another nine years • They control 70% of North America’s wealth • Mindset: Individuality. Emphasis on youth. Self-absorption. • Currencies embraced: Time, comfort, easy access • Trend: “Downshifting” and simplicity. Entire trip planned and booked for them. • Empty nesters prefer to travel during the shoulder seasons. • Baby boomers will be inheriting $10.4 trillion from their parents. • A HUGE opportunity for “me-oriented” spending. 14 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Suggestion #15: Work with seasonal businesses to tell customers WHEN they will be open. “Open April 1st” Don’t just say you’re closed - let potential future customers know when you’ll be open so they’ll come back. Extend your seasons. Baby boomers, who are becoming empty nesters, travel extensively in April, May, September and October. Are you open for business? If not, when ARE you open? Events embraced by boomers • • • • Culinary tourism: visiting chefs, restaurants, education Art: Artists in action, learning new hobbies, education Ethnic events: European, Scandinavian, Cajun, Indian Home and garden: education, training, tours of gardens and historic homes with a great story to tell • Open air markets, farmers markets • Activity based events, albeit cushy adventure Wayfinding • If it’s not convenient, or easy to find, chances are that visitors will not find what you’re offering and will move on. • Adequate signage and wayfinding are essential to help visitors know where attractions and amenities are located, and what you have to offer. • Tourism-related signage, including wayfinding or directional signs, should be decorative and should help promote the area’s “brand.” 15 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Suggestion #16: Develop and implement a signage plan and program that includes: • Wayfinding • Gateways and entries • Attractions • Amenities • Billboards and marketing displays The signage should be decorative, like the samples shown here. The signs for Appleton, Wisconsin (below left) cost approximately $550 each, including stainless steel mounting hardware. Your signage should be decorative, and should promote the brand: the essence of who you are as a community. Suggestion #17: (Below) Add location information or at least distances. Where is this taking the visitor? The sign should read “Visitor Info - 1/4 mile” (or whatever the distance is). Once again, even this sign should be decorative. 16 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Suggestion #18: Never have more than five items on a sign. The sign (far right) has twelve, far too many to read from a passing car. Additionally, the sign should say what instead of who. What is “Filthy?” What is “The Red Cock?” What is “Sea Wick?” If a gallery, the sign should simply say “Gallery.” Sell the experience, not the business name. Consider a pedestrian-friendly plaza sign if this is what this is designed for. Suggestion #19: Is this sign saying that there is parking two blocks ahead on both sides of the street? If so, just put “Parking - 2 blocks” with a straight-ahead arrow. When they get there, direct them right or left. The first sign should simply state “Parking ahead two blocks.” Then when they get there (left) another sign will direct them to both sides of the street. 17 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Note Lincoln City should develop several different districts along its seven miles, then identify each with banners and signs like those shown above, identifying each district. Suggestion #20: Add directional signage to the “historic Taft district.” If we hadn’t been doing an assessment, we might never have found this little gem. The only signage we saw was for visitor information and parking. 18 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Suggestion #22: “The Beach is just the beginning” should be removed. Consider a brand defining slogan. The gateway signs, however are nice and provide a positive reflection on the community. Suggestion #24: Is this really where you want to begin to promote the core shopping area (above)? Consider redefining the boundaries. Start with just one block. Make it fun! Quit using brown and gray. Avoid using script text on banners and signs. First impressions are lasting impressions. When a visitor sees the first Ocean Lake banner, they will size up this area of town immediately. Reduce this district down to one or two blocks, where there is something to sell. 19 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 Suggestion #23: This isn’t Lincoln City? What is Ocean Lake? Where is Lincoln City? Consider a much more colorful banner. Instead of saying “Downtown Ocean Lake,” consider “Ocean Lake District.” TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS You need more than pole banners to effectively identify a district. StreetPrint is a company that embeds designs into asphalt (above and left) to help create a more powerful identifier for different districts. Suggestion #26: Consider removing these signs at both ends of town (left). Do they really serve any purpose? The locations do not provide a positive first impression of the community and just add to sign clutter, already somewhat of a problem in the area. Suggestion #27: Can you read this banner? (Right) • Never use script lettering on banners or signs • The general rule: Letters should be 1 inch tall for every 12 feet of viewing distance. • Begin putting banners where you will make the first, best impression. As part of a branding program, all banners, districts, and signage should be redesigned to fit the overall brand. There is no continuity between districts, banners, signs, promotional materials, advertising, etc. Banners should only have one simple graphic and the text should be readable from a distance. 20 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Note Salishan has done a great job with its gateway signage, which sets the ambiance, the brand as a lodge-style resort. Beautification Curb appeal is an investment with tremendous return. The greater the “perceived value,” the more visitors will spend and the longer they will stay. Planters with flowers, shrubs, street trees, decorative signage and facade improvements entice people to stop and linger, encouraging more spending. Sisters, Oregon (left) is considered to be one of Oregon’s most beautiful communities, and this effort has paid off with increased spending, and one of the state’s most successful small communities. 21 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Note Lincoln City, overall, can use major improvements in its beautification and curb appeal efforts. Compare the two top photos. Doesn’t the scene on the right stand out for its curb appeal, with the planters, shrubs, and street trees, compared to the scene on the left? This is in the town of Neenah, Wisconsin. Which shops (before or after) most catches your eye? Visitor information Visitor amenities are critical. The number one reason people stop is to use a restroom, so if you place public restrooms near where visitors can spend money, you’ll see your visitor spending increase. Promote your public restrooms. Likewise, if you place your visitor information center near where people can spend money, they will be likely to take advantage of stopping to get a cup of coffee, an ice cream cone, or buy a gift. 22 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Visitor information Visitor information should be working 24/7, 365 days a year. Travelers don’t just travel during business hours. Put up visitor information kiosks and outdoor brochure holders at local attractions, parking areas, and at visitor amenities such as public restroom areas. Make sure you have signage that notes 24 hour visitor information is available. Suggestions #29 & #30: Decide which place will be the official place for visitor information, then have all signage lead there. Instead of signing this “Chamber of Commerce,” use “Visitor Information.” Always sell the activity, the draw or lure, not the name of the organization. 23 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Note This is not a very attractive “front door” for the town or the chamber. Add some gingerbread. Make it fit the brand. Better yet, provide visitor information in the heart of downtown where there is visitor-oriented retail. This location is difficult to get to, not very convenient, and not very attractive. Suggestions #31 & #32: Consider not allowing advertising banners except with a temporary permit for two weeks. They do not enhance the appearance of any building. Signage should be decorative, permanent. Promote “24 hour visitor information.” Let visitors know you can help them, no matter what time of day or night they arrive. Instead of Chamber of Commerce, make Visitor Info prominent, then put Chamber of Commerce is smaller letters below. Once on the other side of the building you can see it’s quite attractive with nice landscaping, a nice walkway and landing. And 24 hour visitor info! Good job. Promote it. 24 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Suggestion #33: Is “Travel Info” different from “Visitor Info?” This sign should be removed. The signs below contain no traveler information, only rules and regulations. Suggestion #34: Note Does everything need to be painted brown or gray? Wouldn’t it be nice if Lincoln City was colorful, fun, vibrant? 25 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 This kiosk (left) is very poorly maintained. Either do something to keep it up, or close it down. It would be better served as an interpretive center than a visitor info center. It reflects very poorly on the community. TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Note There was no information whatsoever for Lincoln City in this kiosk. This is so poorly maintained it should be closed or turned into an interpretive kiosk. See if you can lease it from the state for $1 a year and convert it or just tear it down. This would be a great location for some public art. Suggestion #35: It was easy to miss the Visitor Information Center. Consider moving it to a visitor-oriented retail site. Tucked away in a corner next to a grocery store is not a good location. Visitor info should be placed in visitor-oriented shopping areas. While it’s convenient to city hall, the focus should be on making it convenient to the city’s customers: its visitors. 26 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Suggestion #36: Develop a new, simpler brand identity (logo) and maintain the sign. Most of the signage in Lincoln City is reflective of a second class destination. The landscaping should be maintained around important signage like this. Suggestion #37: Include signage to your public restrooms - but in places where visitors can spend money. Note This set of restrooms should be promoted with signage. It’s in the heart of the “shopping district.” Once a visitor gets out of their vehicle, you have a four-times greater chance of getting them to spend money. There should also be visitor information mounted on the restroom exterior walls. 27 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Parking time limits Shopping and dining in a pedestrian setting is the number one activity of visitors. Visitors will spend four hours in a pedestrian-friendly setting. Two hour parking sends customers away before they are done spending money. If you insist on parking limits, use courtesy tickets (warnings.) Include RV parking areas. Critical mass Again, the #1 visitor activity in the world is shopping and dining in a pedestrian setting. Visitor-oriented retail needs to be in a compact setting. Separate “neighborhood retail” from “visitor retail.” The average rule of thumb is 10/10/10: Ten retail stores, ten dining establishments, and ten entertainment options. All in a pedestrianfriendly setting. Critical mass Ever wonder why fast food restaurants and gas stations gather together at intersections? The critical mass (choice) translates into increased sales for all. Another great example is antique malls - all the competitors under one roof attracts the most shoppers. Lincoln City outside of the outlet mall and Salishan’s shopping village, is missing the critical mass. The businesses are in the community, but are scattered along the seven mile route - not convenient at all for shoppers. 28 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Critical mass (continued) By grouping together these visitororiented businesses, you will create the “critical mass” in a pedestrian setting that will draw visitors (and residents!) and make it worth their while to stop and shop. Currently, the only “critical mass” in Lincoln City is at Salishan. The number one activity of visitors around the world is shopping and dining in a pedestrian setting. It’s typically not the primary lure, but it is the top diversionary activity. Consider the success of intimate shopping areas like Cannon Beach, downtown Seaside as a couple of examples. Lincoln City’s most popular attraction is probably the factory direct stores - a powerful draw to the community. Note (Above) Seaview has a great little shopping district as does Salishan (left and right). The fireplace adds some ambiance to Salishan’s lodgestyle branding effort. 29 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Suggestion #38: Concentrate on just one area. Just one block. Work to make it a showcase - a demonstration project - and retailers in neighboring blocks will want to start working on their block. Start small, keep it manageable and really take it to the next level. To determine which block to begin with, talk with property owners and tenants. Revitalization is a public/private process. The city will invest in the block where the merchants will also invest. This may even include rearranging the merchant mix. Note This block has the makings as a starting point for revitalization. Most other areas are in need of major makeovers. This area does need some help, but it is much farther along and could set the standard for visitor-oriented retail. Note There are several “destination retail” businesses, but they are spread out over a seven-mile stretch, making it difficult for them to survive. Visitors want convenience above all else: park the car, walk a very short distance, to a variety of shops, restaurants and attractions. Lincoln City should work to find or create a district where these types of businesses can congregate and succeed. This is the “antique mall” mentality. Like businesses group together, and even though they are competitors, they all do more business. You’re a lot more effective as one loud voice than a bunch of small voices. This goes for marketing as well as critical mass. 30 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Note There are some outstanding galleries and shops at both the north and south ends of Lincoln City, but they are not convenient for most shoppers and so retail sales are probably not as strong as they could be. Suggestion #39: The signage throughout town does little to attract customers. Merchants need to work to improve the signage throughout town with decorative, well maintained, easy to read signs. What is your impression of the Bird Nest Gallery? Signage is a direct reflection of the business it’s suppose to promote. Suggestion #40: Develop new banners: consider “Ocean Lake District.” Downtown Ocean Lake sounds like it’s a different city than Lincoln City. Where is its downtown? Narrow this promoted area down to one or two blocks, then make it a showcase. 31 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS The rules of retail signage • Promote what you’re selling not the name of the business. • Promote the best lure that will pull customers in the door. • The quality of the signage is a direct reflection on the retailer. • Use perpendicular (blade) signs, like those shown to the left. Suggestion #42 Consider offering technical assistance to local retailers to help them raise the bar considerably. What is your impression of the shops and signs showcased below? Effective signage can dramatically increase sales. These say “stay away.” 32 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Suggestion #42 Consider developing a merchantdriven signage, sandwich board, and exterior display program. Offer technical assistance and retail training for downtown merchants. Most of the Lincoln City businesses do a very poor job of exterior displays, signage, and curb appeal making Lincoln City seem like a second-class citizen in an age where quality accounts for 80% of all visitor spending. 33 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Technical assistance to local businesses The examples above, show the benefit of quality exterior displays (above) and attractive signage, including sandwich boards (top right). Note The casino looks good - very clean and well-maintained, and a primary draw to the city. 34 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Suggestion #44: This hotel looks nice - does it have a name? Where do you go to check in? Is there a phone number? A sign stating the name of the hotel and other information would be very helpful, including a sign that tells visitors where the entrance is. Consider using a couple of different colors. The photo (below) was taken in Whistler Resort, but the lodging facilities there use two or three complementary colors. Note The Odysius, Looking Glass Inn, and Salishan seemed to be the primary upscale lodging properties in Lincoln City. The Landmark Inn also looks like a nice place to stay. Congrats on doing an excellent job with the landscaping and overall curb appeal. Of the more than 50 lodging establishments in Lincoln City, 90% seem dated, tired, and of an overall poor quality. 35 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Notes Most of the lodging properties seem tired and present a poor first impression, bringing the whole town down in overall appeal as a seaside destination. First appearances may be deceiving, though. Some of these properties may be nice. Consider beautification to make the first impressions more favorable: hanging baskets, new paint, landscaping, new signage, etc. The new construction (below) - Hotels? Condos? Timeshares? Fractional shares? 36 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Notes (continued) Most of the lodging facilities have little curb appeal, but could be charming. 80% of all lodging expenditures are spent in the highest quality establishments (20% of all properties.) The Sandcastle, for instance, could be charming with some hanging baskets, planters, garden areas - anything to break up the barrier between concrete and building. Like most of the other hotels, it looks dated. Note The cabins near the lake look terrific. This is a nice RV/resort park. (Below left) From a curb-appeal standpoint, the Italian Riviera looks like one of the best restaurants in the area. Is it worth a special trip? It looks like it. In fact, local residents gave it a two thumbs up. (Below) 37 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Suggestion #45: The Taft District (top left) has tremendous potential as the primary attraction to Lincoln City. Consider developing a better, more substantial gateway along the lines of the examples shown here. Gateways are a wonderful means to enhance a location, creating a special destination. 38 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Suggestion #46: (Above) Move all the rules and regulations inside the parking area. Where people can get out of their vehicles and read them without walking back out to the street. Java Eats is cute and funky. A little like Pismo Beach, CA. or other surfing destinations. The Taft District There’s not enough critical mass here to make it a shopping, dining, or entertainment district. It does have tremendous potential, if the right retail mix can be recruited, and the properties were made available. The rule for critical mass: 10+10+10. While this may be the primary beach access site in Lincoln City, it could be a hub for entertainment, shows, fairs, and for retail sales. 39 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS The Taft District (continued) Could some of the homes be zoned and converted to commercial uses? This district has tremendous potential for being a major Oregon coast attraction. The buildings are very quaint, the setting is charming. But to succeed, the district needs the critical mass. Most of the homes here would be outstanding artists in action workshops and galleries, little coffee shops, bistros, wine stores, etc. Suggestion #47: Once you decide on a pedestrianfriendly shopping/dining district, recruit like businesses to that location. The surf shop (below) would be a great fit along with Java Eats (previous page). 40 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Suggestion #48: It’s difficult to tell if the museum (left) is still in operation. Add exterior displays, an open neon sign, signage stating hours, etc. If it’s closed for the season, put up a sign stating when it will be open again. Is it, in fact, and operating museum? It’s certainly a nice facility. What’s its focus? Maritime? Fishing? Native American? “Historical Museum” is pretty bland. Make sure the museum concentrates on stories rather than the display of artifacts. Stories captivate visitors and bring them back. Artifacts don’t. Suggestion #49: This could be a major attraction, but has very poor curb appeal, poor signage, etc. (Middle and lower left) A glass float theme has tremendous appeal, so the potential for this business is great. Suggestion #50: Consider exterior pieces of art, decorative signage, curb appeal enhancements, etc. This type of business has great potential, and curb appeal and adequate signage would do a lot to help it attract customers. When is it open? Is it seasonal? 41 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Idea In downtown Appleton, Wisconsin, they have placed rotating wind sculptures (left) in front of one of the commercial buildings. Imagine placing wind-driven sculptures throughout Lincoln City to add motion, vibrancy, fun, and to develop a brand around the ocean breezes. Sculptures like this, in front of the glass blowing studio, would pull visitors in. Suggestion #51: Consider creating a variety of “districts” along Highway 101 so that visitors don’t judge the entire town by a few less-than-attractive locations. There is too much of this along the highway, which gives a poor impression of the entire town. The city needs to aggressively work with local land owners regarding signage, fallen fencing, abandoned sign posts, trash barrels, weed abatement, facade improvements, etc. The general impression is that Lincoln City has fallen on hard times and is still falling. 42 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Note Some areas of town show a lot of promise - like the entrance to this parking area. We never have figured out what the design is between the words “Public” and “Parking” (left). Is it an arrow pointing into the parking lot? Suggestion #52: The theater has potential, but little curb appeal. When is it open? What is the season? More information posted would be helpful including a brochure rack so visitors can pick up a guide to an upcoming season, if there is one. Note Develop perpendicular (blade) signage. Add landscaping. These two additions would do a lot to increase the ambiance of this part of town. 43 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Note The Tanger Outlet Center is nice and seems to be the major attraction in Lincoln City. It’s the one thing that sets the community apart from the other beach towns. Note This is a charming little retail mall, that with some curb appeal and landscape improvements, could be a real showcase. This should be one of the many districts in Lincoln City. Suggestion #53: Consider using two colors on shops, making the sign much simpler and easy to read. “Quilts” “Gifts” “Gallery” Barber Shop” (Bottom left) If each shop were painted a different color, it might have more appeal and look less like another strip mall. The building(s) are in bad need of paint and curb appeal improvements. 44 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Note The Espresso bar (left) is perhaps one of the best looking businesses in Lincoln City in terms of curb and architectural appeal. Note This is a great restaurant. Don’t be afraid to promote specifics! Have a travel writer or someone come from the outside and develop itineraries that include specific places to eat, things to do, and places to visit. The Blackfish Cafe is an outstanding restaurant, that is worth a drive from other communities. IN A NUTSHELL • Create a Tourism Branding, Development & Marketing Action Plan. Have it include a downtown plan. Consider this: If we were to mention to friends that when they visit the Oregon coast, they need to have dinner at the Blackfish Cafe in Lincoln City. Most people visit communities, stay in certain hotels and eat in certain restaurants, and even frequent specific shops based on recommendations. • Develop a brand, a new identity, and key messages. • Develop a pedestrian-friendly shopping district. Create a plan for redevelopment, business recruitment. • Have a Signage & Wayfinding System developed. • Create various downtown districts and appropriate pole banners for each along with other treatments. • Create a technical assistance program for local businesses. Perhaps a Main Street Program. 45 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 If we were to mention to friends that Lincoln City has a number of good restaurants, would this really close the sale? Probably not since every town has a number of good restaurants. Promote specific businesses that have raised the bar. Then as other reach that plateau, promote them so they can succeed. Success breeds more success. TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS The following pages contain “Marketing effectiveness assessments” done by Destination Development staff members. These will give you an idea of what impressions people have of the area, and whether or not they would visit and/or stay in Lincoln City. Enjoy. Assessment #1 If I were going to the Oregon Coast, I would plan to go to Cannon Beach. This is because of reputation and past experience rather than a look at current marketing materials - I know that Cannon Beach has a beautiful beach, quality accommodations and dining, and a charming downtown with lots of shopping. My impression is that Cannon Beach is more of a high-end beach destination than most, which appeals to me. However, I know that the entire Oregon Coast is fabulous, so if I had time, I would want to drive the entire coastline, staying for a few nights at several locations along the route. I would begin in Astoria; I understand they have revitalized their downtown in recent years, and its history is a real draw. I would travel on down to Cannon Beach, probably staying there the longest, making day trips to neighboring communities, such as Seaside, Lincoln City, and Newport, but spending most of the time in Cannon Beach The one draw I can see to Lincoln City is their glass float event, and the glass blowing factory and stores. Newport’s aquarium is a must-see. I’d probably pass through the Coos Bay area, but stop in Florence (visit the Sand Dunes) and head on down to the southern tip of the Oregon Coast. I’d probably stay in Brookings for a couple days before heading back home. My favorite place along the Oregon Coast is Cannon Beach because of its natural beauty and the charm of the town. If I were to take kids with me, I would probably follow the same itinerary, maybe spending more time in Seaside at their fun family activities. My thoughts on the following communities: • Astoria - historic seaside town - I think it would be fun to explore this town for its own charms • Seaside - family beach town - fun, carnival atmosphere • Cannon Beach - beautiful beach, charming town - higher end beach destination than most • Newport - Oregon aquarium, and fun town to visit - the old fishing town atmosphere along the river-front is great • Lincoln City - long spread-out town overlooking the ocean - mostly just a town you drive through as you go along the coast. Glass-blowing, glass float event. 46 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS • Coos Bay - logging. In doing research, I compared several of the towns’ websites, and found that Lincoln City’s site does have quite a bit going for it. The drawbacks are that there are not enough photos, and the text is invariably too long. But, I like how it is organized - it’s easy to find information, and the Welcome page is very good - the photo of the glass floats on the beach is absolutely fantastic! Other good things: I like how the “Things to Do” page is organized into the different categories; it is very helpful to have the photos of the lodging facilities; and the descriptions of the restaurants in the Dining section are very good. The shopping section was weak. In comparison, even though Cannon Beach would be my choice of where to go, I found their website to be very boring. Hardly any photos, no real attempt to “sell” a potential visitor on why they should visit. They used lists, rather than descriptions. If I were unfamiliar with the Oregon Coast, I wouldn’t choose Cannon Beach based on their website. The Astoria website had way too much text, and the font should be different - the one they used is difficult to read on a web-page. Seaside’s visitor information website only has lodging and dining information, but doesn’t tell about the town itself or what it has to offer visitors. Coos Bay’s website needs more photos, but I was surprised by all they have to do there. If I were planning the trip I talked about above, I would decide to spend some time in Coos Bay after all because of the activities they show on their website. Lincoln City needs to develop a niche or a specific identity - it could be the glass blowing and the glass floats - that appeals to me a lot. Without a major attraction, such as the aquarium, or a fantastic natural feature, such as Haystack Rock, Lincoln City has a greater challenge. It needs to MAKE its own niche. Assessment #2 • Heading down to the Oregon coast, where would you go and why? • What’s your favorite place on the Oregon Coast and why? Heading down the Oregon Coast, I really like the Cannon Beach area, particularly because of its proximity. Going to points further south can be such a long drive, but Cannon Beach isn’t too bad. It’s a nice getaway with cool beaches. As far as my favorite place, I honestly can’t say I have a favorite. Believe it or not, I haven’t spent a lot of time there. • Where would you go with friends and family? • With kids? • As a couple? Again, Cannon Beach would be a good choice for a vacation with friends and family. I could also see going further south to perhaps the Central Coast area. With kids, again because of the proximity, I like Cannon Beach. But Newport also comes to mind because of attractions like the aquarium. 47 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS As a couple, I’d pick a smaller town and stay at a cool B&B. When you think of the following communities, what do you think of each? What’s the first thing that comes to mind? Astoria – I haven’t been through Astoria in a while, but I think of it as being charming. Honestly, I don’t know if I’m right, but the picture I have in my head is of a cute little coastal town. Seaside – Beaches… Seaside makes me think of beaches. Again, it’s a place I haven’t been to in a long while, but what stands out for me is just the idea of a beach town. Cannon Beach – I always think of the big rock formations on the beach. I think of Cannon Beach as a good vacation spot; someplace I’d definitely choose to go. Lincoln City and Newport – I tend to lump these two together when I think about that area. I think of these as some of the larger cities on the Oregon Coast. They have more amenities, and possibly a longer list of attractions, but less small coastal town charm than other areas. Coos Bay – I honestly don’t know much about Coos Bay, so nothing particularly comes to mind. I believe it’s located in the south coast area, but that’s about all I know. Any other Oregon Coast communities that you like or know about? I’ve been to Florence and the surrounding area. I’ve also been to Depoe Bay, which is between Newport and Lincoln City. I’ve heard of Yachats as well, but I don’t know that I’ve ever been there, other than perhaps driving through. Assessment #3 First on my radar is always Cannon Beach, followed by Seaside. They are the places that my grandparents took us when we visited them in Longview, WA. The locations are just tried and true safe bets for a one or multi-day family outing. We visited friends in Oregon quite a few years ago and it was destination Seaside. We had the kids and it was a fun, family friendly place to visit. I have always enjoyed Astoria--even before the revitalization. Now with the revitalization I am really curious and have wanted to visit. Astoria would be fun as a couple’s getaway or with the kids. We loved looking at all of the old homes, while the kids begged to go back to the beach! The Astoria Riverfront Trolley sounds fun. Next pick is Long Beach, not on your list below, but again it is a known place and we are comfortable going there. Seaside brings to mind fun in the sun, family activities. 48 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS Astoria brings to mind a fishing town--reminds me of my Alaskan home. I love its location on the river, the downtown, and it’s close to the beaches. I also love the easy connection to WA via the bridge. Cannon Beach is always great. The big rocks, miles of shore--rain or shine a great location. I’ve enjoyed wandering around there in the evening too. The town is not too big, and I remember it as quiet, but not boring. I decided to research the Oregon Coast. I typed that into Yahoo! and the Oregon Coast Visitor Association’s website www.visittheoregoncoast.com was first on the list. Coos Bay looks like fun--of course I always like commercial fishing towns, but I also like the sound of the antique shops, galleries, etc. Because of Coos Bay’s size, I expect it will have plenty of amenities, i.e. shopping and dining. Newport looks beautiful to me--I love the lighthouses and the sound of all that fresh seafood. I also really like watching boats and commercial fishing activity, so this would be a top pick for me. And I know I would enjoy the aquarium. Lincoln City--The Kite Capital of The World sounds fun, but this alone would not compel me to go. The Lincoln City description on the OCVA site did little to persuade my visit. Other than the kites, it had this to say about Lincoln City. (I cut and pasted this from that site.) Recreation You’ll find the usual Oregon recreational activities available in Lincoln City including beachcombing, hiking, camping, fishing, whale watching charters, kite flying, shopping and great dining in many fine restaurants. Attractions * * * * * * * Chinook Winds Casino Resort Connie Hansen Garden Tanger Outlet Center Chinook Winds Golf Resort North Lincoln County Historical Museum Kites at D River Wayside Blue Heron Landing It then goes on to list annual events. Since this really did not pull me in and tell me I had to go to Lincoln City, I clicked on the Lincoln City Visitors and Convention Bureau’s site at www.oregoncoast.org and I’m glad I did! I really like the picture of the glass balls, and would recommend moving the info on the left of that page somewhere else, because the picture is pretty and good as a stand alone. I like it! I really like the sound of Finders Keepers: Sand Fire Glass. This is a fun idea and I would go there for that -- it is a good launching pad to other activities in the area. The idea is unique and I know my whole family would have fun with this activity. Who doesn’t like a treasure hunt? The kite competitions would be fun to view too. I would 49 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS also want to visit the Connie Hansen Gardens, one of Lincoln City’s “jewels”. Kids would enjoy the skate park, “one of the ‘gnarliest’ parks in the United States”. It looks like there are plenty of dining and shopping options in Lincoln City, which is good. I feel that there is probably plenty to do in Lincoln City and that it is worthy of a visit, now that I know more about it, but I am surprised that I hadn’t heard about it before now. I called my husband and asked him where he would go if visiting the Oregon Coast. I did not mention any towns at all. Here are his top picks and why: Newport--he likes the atmosphere and the central location Cannon Beach-because of scenery Lincoln City- Fun, nice place to stay--good hotels, dining, activities. He especially likes the hiking. I then asked about Seaside and Astoria. Neither of these would be among his picks for lodging, but both were worthy of a side trip from one of the other locales. 50 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006 TOURISM ASSESSMENT & SUGGESTIONS This visitor assessment was prepared by the team at: 510 Custer Way Suite 301 Olympia, WA 98501 (360) 754-7920 Voice (360) 754-7622 Fax [email protected] www.dditeam.com 51 • Lincoln City, Oregon • March 2006