revenue summary report
Transcription
revenue summary report
Ogden City City Council Work Session Notice May 21, 2015 – 5:30 p.m. City Council Work Room Municipal Building – Third Floor 2549 Washington Boulevard, Ogden, Utah 84401 Notice is hereby given that the City Council will meet in a work session on Thursday, May 21, 2015 at 5:30 p.m. in the Council Work Room on the third floor of the Municipal Building located at 2549 Washington Boulevard in Ogden City, Weber County, Utah. The purpose of the work session is to: Receive Employee Groups input on the FY2016 Proposed Budget; Receive a Council Staff review of the FY2016 Proposed Budget; Discuss specific issues in the FY2016 Proposed Budget for the following: o Compensation Plan o Fees o Fire Department o Police Department o Management Services Department Revenue Information Technology Annual Report and Equipment List Fleet and Facilities 2015-2016 Annual Report Discuss Council business. Pursuant to Section 52-4-207 “Electronic Meetings” of the Open and Public Meetings Law, Vice Chair White will participate in the meeting via teleconference and such electronic means will provide the public body the ability to communicate via the teleconference. ~~~~~ In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, persons needing auxiliary communicative aids and services for these meetings should contact the Management Services Department at 629-8701 (TDD# 629-8949) or by email: [email protected] at least 48 hours in advance of the meeting. CERTIFICATE OF POSTING The undersigned, duly appointed City Recorder, does hereby certify that the above notice and/or agenda was posted in three public places within the Ogden City Limits on this 18th day of May, 2015. These public places being: 1) City Recorder’s Office on the 2nd floor of the Municipal Building; 2) 2nd floor foyer of the Municipal Building; and 3) the Weber County Library. A copy was posted to the Utah State Public Notice Website and the Ogden City Website, as well as provided to the Standard-Examiner. TRACY HANSEN, MMC OGDEN CITY RECORDER Visit the City Council Meetings page at: councilmeetings.ogdencity.com Ogden City Council Agenda Information Line – 801-629-8159 FY2016 COMPENSATION PLAN PURPOSE OF WORK SESSION: Executive Summary Background To Review and Discuss the Proposed FY2016 Compensation Plan The Council will meet with members of the Administration to discuss the proposed Compensation Plan as set forth in the tentative Budget for FY2016. In addition, each Department Director will address compensation as it relates to each Department’s employees. Utah Code 10-16-11 (Utah Municipal Code – Uniform Fiscal Procedures Act for Utah Cities) requires that the City Administration prepare and present an annual, tentative budget at the first regularly scheduled meeting in May. The final budget must be adopted no later than June 22 of each year. In preparation for receiving and reviewing the budget, the Council also requests additional information from the Administration relating to areas of particular interest to the Council. This additional information includes reports on current fiscal year goals and accomplishments, progress on management audit recommendations, status of current year capital improvement projects, staffing issues, debt service, equipment replacement, and other relevant issues. Budget Review Process The Administrative and Council staff meet regularly as a Budget Team during the budget process to discuss and review not only the current year progress, but also any significant changes in the proposed budget. Council staff may request additional information and justification for major budget proposals. Staff also meets with each Department head regarding Compensation Plan During the Administration’s budget retreats, the Mayor, CAO and Department Directors determine an amount that will be recommended for Ogden City Council Work Session: March 21, 2015 1 employee merit or COLA increases. The Human Resources Division outlines a timeline and criteria for completing the Pay for Performance reporting in Halogen. A copy of that document outlining the timeline and criteria is attached. Each Director has also been asked to address how his department will apply the increases. Council Staff Contact: Janene Eller-Smith, (801)629-8165 Ogden City Council Work Session: March 21, 2015 2 Stout, Lisa Subject: FW: Halogen / Merit Increase timeline and Criteria From: Choate, Shawn Sent: Tuesday, April 21, 2015 10:18 AM To: Ashment, Mike; Buxton, Gregg; Christopulos, Tom; Johnson, Mark; Lowder, Jay; Mathieu, Mike; Williams, Gary; Anderson, Justin; Bauman, Eric; Brenkman, Todd; Bride, Terrence; Bridge, Edd; Brookins, Richard; Brown, Kevin; Brown, Mara; Burdett, Gregory; Carr, Paula; Choate, Shawn; Cook, Bill; Cooper, Brandon; Fishburn, Steve; Froerer, Buck; Greiner, Jon; Hansen, Tracy; Harvey, John; Huffaker, Perry; Johnson, Laurie; Junk, Mike; Moffett, Kenton; Montgomery, Greg; Ogden, Ward; Schwenk, Matt; Scothern, Greg; Stratford, Mark; Tarwater, Wayne; Wilkinson, Blake; Young, Eric Cc: Briskey, Heather; Judkins, Leslie; Olmedo, Heidi; Simpson, Trudi; Workman, Alison Subject: Halogen / Merit Increase timeline and Criteria Good Morning, Below is the Halogen and Merit Increase timeline and criteria. Please let me know if you have questions. Halogen Closes June 6th By June 12th – Each Director will have a Final report regarding each Department’s breakdown (score = increase amount). ALL evaluations must be complete and the process closed in order for me to run this report. Police: Score of 2 or higher = 4% increase. If an employee receives less than a 2, they do not receive an increase. Fire: Score of 2 or higher = 4% increase with compression correction. If an employee receives less than a 2, they do not receive an increase. Management Services: Score of 2 or higher = 4% increase. If an employee receives less than a 2, they do not receive an increase. Legal: Evaluation Score determines Merit Increase CED: Evaluation Score determines Merit Increase Public Services: Evaluation Score determines Merit Increase By June 19, 2015 – Personnel Action forms created and distributed to employees. July 10, 2015 – Pay check with all changes (Pay‐period June 20 – July 3). This year’s increase is a 4% Merit. Employee’s at the top or above their range will receive the 4% in the form of a one‐time bonus, if they meet the criteria set by the department director. Employees hired into a full time position after January 1, 2015 are not eligible for a Merit increase. Employees promoted or transferred from a full time position into a full time position are eligible for a merit increase assuming they were hired prior to January 1st and meet the evaluation criteria. Employees active in Eden as of the beginning date of the pay period (June 20th) are eligible for the pay increase assuming they were hired prior to January 1st and meet the evaluation criteria. All employees active in Eden as of April 8th were loaded into Halogen for an evaluation. Even if they aren’t eligible for an increase, they should receive the feedback in the review. Order of increases on paycheck: 1 – Reclass increases 1 2 – Merit Increase Divisions that are planning on providing an increase for part time staff need to contact Leslie to coordinate. Requests must be turned in to Leslie by June 19th. Shawn Choate, PHR Human Resource / Risk Manager, Ogden City Corporation 2549 Washington Blvd., Ogden, Utah 84401 T: 801.629.8731 | F: 801‐629.8735 [email protected] Director, Utah Human Resource State Council UtahSHRM.org 2 Merit Increase COLA Market Adjustment Benefit Changes Benefit Increase Bountiful Clearfield Davis County 5% 2% 0‐3.5% 2% No 1% No If necessary Few Positions Unknown Unknown No changes Unknown Unknown 4.6% Layton Avg. 3% No No changes No Lehi Logan Murray Ogden City Unknown 3% Unknown 4% Unknown No Unknown No Yes ‐ depends on position Unknown Few Positions Unknown No Unknown No changes Yes No changes Unknown 5% 11.5% 6.6% Orem Unknown No No Yes No Provo 2.5% No No changes 5% 2% Unknown 3% Unknown See note 1‐2% Avg. 2% 1% Unknown 1.8% Unknown See note 1.5% 2% Several positions No Unknown No Unknown Few Positions No Unknown Unknown No changes Unknown No changes No changes No changes No Unknown 3.9% Unknown No 3.9% 12% West Jordan 2.75% & 5% 1% No Unknown Unknown West Valley Avg. 2.5% No No No changes 8% Agency Roy Salt Lake City Sandy South Salt Lake City St. George Tooele City Weber County Notes Merit is given on anniversary date if employee is eligible. Merit increase is based on performance. COLA was in January 2015. 1.6% medical increase & 3% dental increase. Merit based on evaluation score. Medical increase. City will pick up insurance increase. 8% medical & 3.5% dental. Adding PEHP vision option ‐ employee paid 5% for medical ‐ will be shared with employees. 1.6% dental will be passed along to employees. Merit Increase planned January 2016. No traditional plan option – we now offer 2 HDHP/HSA options: $2k/$4k ded with $1k/$2k HSA or $3k/$6k ded with $1500/$3000 HSA Merit increase if not topped out. Market adjustments is 2.5% to those affected. Will not have any information until late May. Medical increase. City will pick up insurance increase. 7.5% increase to cover merit and market adjustments. Medical increase. Merit increase on employees anniversary date. Exempt non‐merit employees were given on 1/2/15. Medical increase 5% & Dental increase 7% effective 1/1/15. Merit increase is 2.75% for general employees & 5% for public safety employees. Merit increase for public employees effective date is unknown until approval. Police and Fire, if approved, is on anniversary date. Medical increase is 8%. BUDGET REVIEW – FISCAL YEAR 2016 PROPOSED AMENDMENTS TO THE ATTORNEY FEES COUNCIL STAFF REVIEW PURPOSES OF THE WORKSESSION: - To provide opportunity for the Administration to describe proposed fee changes in detail to the Council - Provide a work session for the Council to ask any questions about the proposed fee changes PROPOSED FEE AMENDMENTS FOR FISCAL YEAR 2016 BUDGET - LEGAL Attached to the Council Staff memo are memos and support information from the Administration describing the fee changes and providing rationale and explanation of the proposed changes as well as the Ordinances to implement the changes. Budget Guidelines and Financial Principles The Council’s Budget Guidelines proposed with the FY2016 budget state the following regarding fees: Fee Changes Proposed fee changes are to be adopted as part of the budget review process. The City Financial Principles related to fees are to be followed. The Council recognizes that some fees are impacted by the calendar year, by seasonal activity, or by the calendars or scheduling constraints of other governmental agencies or businesses and that certain fees may need to be amended during the fiscal year and cannot be amended during the budget process. Mid-year fee increase requests are due October 1 accompanied by sufficient rationale and justification. Fees to be implemented in January (excluding utilities) will be considered at that time by the Council if all applicable information is received. Utility Fees. The recommendations of the 2012 Utility Rate Study, also known as the Comprehensive Financial Sustainability Plan, are to be followed. A review of the proposed changes included in the Utility Rate Study will be performed in a joint effort Ogden City Council Work Session: May 21, 2015 1 beginning in November each year. Fee changes that are submitted without a detailed analysis will not be considered by the Council. Financial Principles The financial principles proposed with the FY2016 budget states the following regarding user fees: 1. The City will review the annual budget for those programs which can be reasonably funded by user fees. This review will result in a policy, which defines cost and specifies a percentage of that cost to be offset by a fee and establishes a rationale of the percentage. When establishing these percentages, the City will consider: a. b. c. d. Rates charged by other public and private providers, Costs required to change the rate, The ability of the users to pay, and Other policy considerations, e.g., set a fine at a higher price than is needed to cover the full costs of a program in order to serve as a deterrent. 2. The City will adjust user fee rates annually on an analysis of the criteria listed above. PROPOSED FEE OVERVIEW Legal Fee Changes The proposed fee amendments are specific to attorney fees assessed when a City attorney assists in the enforcement or the collection of citations for civil violations. Up to this point, there has been no established fee when this takes place leaving a question as to the appropriate amount to charge for such services. The Administration’s transmittal indicates that the proposed amount of $181 per hour is appropriate to recover expenses for such action and that the amount proposed is the same as surrounding jurisdictions. The ordinance proposed lists the fee as Attorney Fee for civil matters and includes some clarification language in the collections section of the code. Ogden City Council Work Session: May 21, 2015 2 Questions 1. Please discuss how the amount of $181 per hour was chosen and discuss what the actual cost of the services would be per hour. 2. How often on average has this service been required over the last few years? 3. Has there been any charge for this service up to this point? Attachments 1. 2. 3. Fees transmittal Attorney fee transmittal Proposed ordinance Memo Prepared By- Council Staff: Ogden City Council Work Session: May 21, 2015 Glenn Symes, 629-8164 3 Tentative FY2016 BUDGET FIRE DEPARTMENT PURPOSE OF WORK SESSION: To Discuss Tentative FY2016 Budget and Review FY2015 Accomplishments and Challenges ______________________________________________________________________________ Executive Summary Background The Administration will review the FY2016 Tentative Budget for the Fire Department. Utah Code 10-16-11 (Utah Municipal Code – Uniform Fiscal Procedures Act for Utah Cities) requires that the City Administration prepare and present an annual, tentative budget at the first regularly scheduled meeting in May. The final budget must be adopted no later than June 22 of each year. In preparation for receiving and reviewing the budget, the Council also requests additional information from the Administration relating to areas of particular interest to the Council. This additional information includes reports on current fiscal year goals and accomplishments, progress on management audit recommendations, status of current year capital improvement projects, staffing issues, debt service, equipment replacement, and other relevant issues. Budget Review Process The Administrative and Council staffs meet regularly as a Budget Team during the budget process to discuss and review not only the current year progress, but also any significant changes in the proposed budget. Council staff may request additional information and justification for major budget proposals. Staff also meets with each Department head regarding individual departmental budgets. The information gleaned from these meetings is then presented to the Council in a series of work sessions. These work sessions offer the Council an opportunity to review and Ogden City Council Work Session: May 21, 2015 1 understand the tentative budget allowing the Council to make more informed decisions. Ogden Fire Department Budgets The Ogden Fire Department is responsible for managing two budgets—the Fire Budget within the General Fund and the Medical Services Enterprise Fund. A comparison of the FY2015 Adopted Budget and the FY2016 Proposed Budget shows the followings: Fund Fire General Fund Medical Services Enterprise Fund FY2015 Adopted $7,000,800 FY2016 Proposed $7,000,950 Change Amount $150 $9,772,875 $7,299,425 ($2,473,450) % Change >.01% -25.31% Fire General Fund Changes Significant budget line items for the Fire General Fund expenditures are as follows: Proposed 4% Merit (1% to Base Pay) No City-paid retirement benefit increases (.17% will be paid by fire employees) No additional emergency management equipment requested Slight increases for training and education Medical Services Enterprise Fund Significant budget line items for the Medical Services Enterprise Fund expenditures are as follows: Proposed 4% Merit (1% to Base Pay) No City-paid retirement benefit increases (.17% will be paid by fire employees) Reduction of six (6) FTE’s—three (3) paramedic and three (3) paramedic captain positions (Change in County Paramedic Agreement) Ogden City Council Work Session: May 21, 2015 2 Removal of Wildland Fire Program (Unable to negotiate an acceptable contract) New Medicaid Assessment Increases for travel and training Organization Structure / Staffing (Proposed) Fire - General Fund Chief (1) Deputy Chief – Operations (1) Battalions Chief (4.5) Captains (18) Deputy Fire Marshal (2) Firefighters (48) Office Supervise (1) Senior Office Assistant (1) Total of 76.5 Positions Medical Services - Enterprise Deputy Chief - Medical (1) Battalion Chief (.5) Captains (0) (-3) Paramedics (27) (-3) Firefighters (9) Total of 37.5 Positions (-6) There are no new positions being recommended in Fire. There are a total of six reductions due to the change in the County Paramedic Contract. Capital Improvements OFD is housed in six (6) fire stations located as follows: Station #1/Admin 2186 Lincoln Station #2 1185 21st Street Station #3 340 Washington Station #4 730 W. 24th Station #5 3450 Harrison Station #6 BDO Practice Tower 760 W. 12th Street Ogden City Council Work Session: May 21, 2015 3 Funding to replace Station #3 at 450 North Street was budgeted in the FY2015 budget year. There are no new CIP projects planned for FY2016. Equipment There are no major equipment purchases scheduled for the Fire Department. Questions FIRE MANAGEMENT AUDIT 1. Please provide an update regarding the Fire Management Audit. Identify the items that have been completed during FY2015 and those that are proposed for completion in FY2016, if any. 2. Identify the remaining items from the Fire Management Audit that have not yet been completed. FIRE HYDRANT REPAIR PROGRAM 3. Describe the progress on the fire hydrants repair program. PERSONNEL AND STAFFING 4. Please identify any vacant positions and indicate when (or if) they will be filled. 5. Please explain how you plan to distribute the Merit increase to your employees. MEDICAL FUND 6. Please describe the new Medicaid Assessment. 7. Briefly explain why the Wildland Fire Program will not be going forward. GENERAL 8. Please review the documents provided in response to the Council information request (if not previously covered). Ogden City Council Work Session: May 21, 2015 4 9. Please update the Council on the Station #3 project, future plans for Station #4 and a new fire training tower. 10. Please review your Department’s successes for FY2015. 11. Please review recent or on-going challenges for your Department. Council Staff Contact: Janene Eller-Smith, (801) 629-8165 Glenn Symes (801) 629-8164 Ogden City Council Work Session: May 21, 2015 5 MEMORANDUM TO: Mark Johnson, CAO FROM: Fire Chief Mike Mathieu DATE: April 15, 2015 RE: Council Information Request for Proposed 2015-16 Budget Management Audit Update The following recommendations from the Management Audit have been completed. 1. Completed the re-hire of three firefighters through the help of the SAFER Grant (Staffing for Adequate Fire and Emergency Response) 2008. 2. Fleet Changes a. Replaced one fire pumper (1991 pumper) which was a front-line engine located at station #2 (1185 East 21st Street). A new pumper was placed in service in the fall of 2008. b. Replaced one fire pumper (1990 pumper) which was a front-line engine located at station #3 (340 Washington Blvd.) A new 2010 pumper was placed in service 09/2010. c. An order and delivery for a third new pumper identified in the audit has occurred. The 2011 pumper has been placed in service at station #5 3450 Harrison Blvd. d. Replaced one fire pumper (1991 pumper) which was a reserve with a 2007 front line unit that had been located at station #2. A 2013 pumper was placed into service at Station #2 in the first quarter of 2014. 3. At the completion of the audit our first line fleet average age was 10.6 years. Best practices suggest first line apparatus life expectancy of 15 years, and 5 years of reserve status. Our first line fleet average age after delivery of the latest pumper is 7.2 years old. (St #1 2004, #2 2013, #3, 2010, #4 2001, and #5 2011). The average age of our 2 reserve pumpers will be 14 years (2007 and 1995). 4. The Water Division began their work on a hydrant maintenance program in 2011. In May 2012 the Fire Department inspected and provided minor maintenance to all City hydrants. The Water Division used this information to focus on a highest priority maintenance program. Through FY2014, the Water Division has raised or repaired 277 hydrants at a cost of $144,138.79. Since July 1st 2014, 155 hydrants were operated with a more detailed inspection with 43 of them being repaired. Total costs of repairs for FY15 was $28,681.22. This represents a significant downward trend in fire hydrant maintenance costs as the program appears to have caught up from a backlog of needs. It is hoped this year’s numbers represent a baseline for future continued emphasis on hydrant maintenance. The Fire Department completed another round of inspection and minor maintenance during the months of April 2015 of all City hydrants. This information will once again be used by the Water Division to perform further inspection, maintenance and repair for the upcoming year. 5. Implemented Entry-Level Training Orientation Academy for new hires. Completed and in place 2007. Minor adjustments and fine tuning occur each year. 6. Completed restoration of station #5 in 2008. 7. Station #3 improvements of HVAC, kitchen remodel, painting and general maintenance is completed. 8. Acquired 2.12 acres located at 422 East North Street for the future home of fire station #3. 9. We have promoted a person to position of Emergency Management Coordinator and he is continually working on our City’s’ emergency operations planning efforts. He also serves as the department training officer. 10. Completed restoration of station #2 with reopening on Feb 13, 2014. The following completions have occurred within fiscal year 2014-15. 1. Hydrant maintenance continued with a slightly lower number and cost for 201415 over 2013-14. 2. Fire station #3 architectural drawings are complete and the station is going to bid for contractors to build. Anticipation of starting June 2015 with completion by December 2015. The following items are the remaining recommendations still to be addressed 1. Fire Stations: Remodel of station #4. However the focus for 2015-16 is to complete the building of station #3. We will look to FY16-17 or FY17-18 to address this station. 2. The training facility. From time to time Community Economic Development receives inquiries regarding potential uses for our current training ground property. The training facility location and replacement needs to be determined. With the relocation of Station #3 enhanced collaboration is possible with the Ogden/Weber ATC as they have begun an EMT (Emergency Medical Technician) program and are looking at a firefighter certification program. 3. Emergency Management within the Fire Department is moving forward. One person fills the responsibilities of City Emergency Manager and Training Officer for the fire department. At times the person is spread too thin to give adequate attention to both functions. Although these positions justify to be staffed separately, I recommend keeping them combined until funding allows for separation. I will be looking at 2016-17 to address this issue. 4. The clerical support position as identified within the audit is not being considered currently. The fire management audit of 2007 has been beneficial to focus on areas that needed the most attention. Thank you. OGDEN CITY FY2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET SUMMARY OF STAFFING CHANGES Enterprise Fund Department Medical Services Division Paramedics Position Title Captain position eliminated Enterprise Medical Services Paramedics Enterprise Public Services Refuse Utility Paramedic position eliminated Maintenance Technician positions added consistant with new Healthcare Reform requirements Equipment Operator positions added consistant with new Healthcare Reform requirements Maintenance Technician positions added consistant with new Healthcare Reform requirements Water Production Supervisor position added Backflow Technician I position added Water Plant Tradesman position added Backflow Technician title changed to Backflow Technician II Water Plant Operator position eliminated Water Plant Supervisor position eliminated Development Services Supervisor position eliminated Development Services Technician position eliminated Plan Review/Code Inspector position added Enterprise Enterprise Public Services Public Services Refuse Utility Sewer Utility Enterprise Public Services Water Utility Enterprise Public Services Water Utility Enterprise Public Services Water Utility Enterprise Public Services Water Utility Enterprise Public Services Water Utility Enterprise Public Services Water Utility General Community & Economic Development Community & Economic Development Community & Economic Development Community & Economic Development Community & Economic Development Building Services Building Services General Community & Economic Development Community & Economic Development Community & Economic Development Management Services General Management Services Comptroller General General General General General General General General Building Services Building Services Building Services Building Services Building Services Business Development Administration Management Services Comptroller Code Services Supervisor range increased from 39 to 50 Code Services Officer reclassified to Sr. Code Services Officer (moved from Major Grants Fund) Code Services Officer position added Benchmarked Reclassified Added 3 3 3 2 4 1 1 2 1 2 1 1 1 2 1 2 1 Code Services Collector position added 1 Project Coordinator - Arts Coordinator position added 1 Digital Media Producer position added Finance Manager/City Treasurer title changed to Comptroller Deputy Division Finance Manager title changed to Deputy Comptroller Eliminated Title Change 1 1 1 OGDEN CITY FY2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET SUMMARY OF STAFFING CHANGES Fund General Department Division Management Services Human Resources General Management Services Justice Court General Management Services Treasury General Police Police General Police Police General Police Police General Police Police General General General General General General Internal Service Internal Service Trust Police Public Services Public Services Public Services Police Engineering Public Ways & Parks Benchmarked Position Title Human Resources Manager title changed to Human Resources/Risk Manager Court Liaison range increased from 33 to 38 Fiscal Op Manager/City Treasurer position added Police Officer position eliminated Crime Analyst Position added Animal Services Officer position added Administrative Assistant reclassified to Office Supervisor and range increased from 31 to 38 Senior Office Assistant reclassified to Strike Force Office Technician and range increased from 24 to 30 Added Eliminated Title Change 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Building and Construction Inspector title changed to Construction Inspector (2 other Construction Inspectors moved to Engineering and charged out to Water and Sewer) New Maintenance Technician positions added consistant with new Healthcare Reform requirements 1 5 Recreation Supervisor position added Public Services Recreation - MWC Assistant Recreation Supervisor position added Public Services Recreation - MWC Maintenance Technician position added Management Services Information Technology Customer Account Coordinator reclassified to Senior Customer Account Coordinator Management Services Information Technology Telecommunications Administrator and Security Administrator reclassified to Network Administrators Community & Community Sr. Project Coordinator Economic Development reclassified to Deputy Development Community Development Division Manager Total Reclassified Recreation - MWC 1 1 1 1 2 1 0 11 30 12 4 Position Vacant for Three Months or Longer Title Division BUSINESS LIC ENFORCE OFFICER CASHIER - JUSTICE COURT CASHIER - JUSTICE COURT COMMUNITY SERVICE OFFICER COMMUNITY SERVICE OFFICER COMMUNITY SERVICE OFFICER FIRE CAPTAIN FIRE CAPTAIN FIRE CAPTAIN GIS ANALYST PARAMEDIC PARAMEDIC PARAMEDIC PARKING ENFORCEMENT OFFICER POLICE OFFICER POLICE OFFICER POLICE OFFICER POLICE OFFICER POLICE OFFICER POLICE OFFICER POLICE OFFICER POLICE OFFICER POLICE OFFICER POLICE OFFICER SR. ACCOUNT CLERK Building Services Justice Court Justice Court Police Police Police Fire Fire Fire IT Fire Fire Fire Police Police Police Police Police Police Police Police Police Police Police Comptroller/Treasury Notes Filled by part time employees. Filled by part time employees. Position being eliminated 06-30-15. Position being eliminated 06-30-15. Position being eliminated 06-30-15. Position being eliminated 06-30-15. Position being eliminated 06-30-15. Position being eliminated 06-30-15. Filled by part time employees. Position Vacant for Under Three Months CONSTRUCTION INSPECTOR DEVELOPMENT SERVICES SUPERVISOR SR. ANALYST WATER PLANT OPERATOR WATER PLANT OPERATOR - TRADESMAN Engineering Building Services Comptroller/Treasury Water Water Position advertised and closed. Position being eliminated 06-30-15. Interviews conducted. Interviews conducted. FIRE DEPARTMENT Organizational Structure Fire Department Administration Medical Services Operations Prevention Non-general operations indicated by underlined text. FUNCTIONS The Fire Department is responsible for responding to many types of public safety requests from the community. Services include fire prevention and emergency preparedness, education, investigations, fire suppression, hazardous material mitigation, emergency medical services, and the operation of a “911” emergency communication center. 89 OGDEN CITY 2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET FIRE GENERAL FUND EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT OPERATIONS OFD ADMINISTRATION PREVENTION 26,600 6,040,675 539,450 394,225 7,000,950 EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT OPERATIONS OFD ADMINISTRATION PREVENTION OVERALL RESPONSIBILITY GENERAL FUND CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROJECTS MEDICAL SERVICES 7,000,950 7,299,425 14,300,375 8,000,000 7,000,000 6,000,000 5,000,000 4,000,000 3,000,000 2,000,000 1,000,000 GENERAL FUND CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROJECTS 90 MEDICAL SERVICES OGDEN CITY 2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET SUMMARY OF DEPARTMENTAL EXPENDITURES GENERAL FUND 2014 ACTUAL 2015 7-MO ACTUAL 2015 ADOPTED 2016 BUDGET FIRE PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE DATA PROCESSING EQUIPMENT BUILDING IMPROVEMENTS OFFICE EQUIPMENT 6,027,433 133,180 65,614 366,539 185,775 9,762 1,820 6,790,123 3,372,545 54,259 32,611 200,966 6,032 333 3,666,746 6,441,275 154,725 74,900 311,400 17,000 1,500 7,000,800 6,423,475 164,225 79,900 304,350 7,500 20,000 1,500 7,000,950 PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE DATA PROCESSING EQUIPMENT BUILDING IMPROVEMENTS OFFICE EQUIPMENT DIVISION SUMMARY FIRE EMERGENCY OFD ADMINISTRATION PREVENTION OPERATIONS 423,179 325,069 6,041,876 6,790,124 180,359 226,150 3,260,237 3,666,746 513,000 368,725 6,119,075 7,000,800 - 26,600 539,450 394,225 6,040,675 7,000,950 3,500 6,957,300 3,500 6,922,450 FUNDING SOURCES FIRE CHARGES FOR SERVICES GENERAL REVENUES INTERGOVERNMENTAL OTHER FINANCING SOURCES USER FEES/PERMITS - 91 - 40,000 20,000 55,000 7,000,800 7,000,950 OGDEN CITY 2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET SUMMARY OF EXPENDITURES BY DIVISION GENERAL FUND 2014 ACTUAL 2015 7-MO ACTUAL 2015 ADOPTED 2016 BUDGET FIRE EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE BUILDING IMPROVEMENTS OFD ADMINISTRATION PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE DATA PROCESSING OPERATIONS PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE DATA PROCESSING EQUIPMENT OFFICE EQUIPMENT PREVENTION PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE DATA PROCESSING FIRE TOTAL: - - - 500 5,500 600 20,000 - - - 26,600 316,436 2,372 5,420 24,226 74,725 166,932 2,481 5,875 5,072 480,450 5,075 15,625 11,850 423,179 180,360 513,000 539,450 5,454,373 119,145 47,425 320,126 89,225 9,762 1,820 3,005,972 46,279 19,548 182,072 5,642,375 137,875 48,525 271,800 5,561,475 147,375 48,525 274,300 6,032 333 17,000 1,500 7,500 1,500 6,041,876 3,260,236 6,119,075 6,040,675 256,624 11,664 12,769 22,187 21,825 199,641 5,499 7,187 13,823 318,450 11,775 10,750 27,750 343,800 11,775 10,750 27,900 325,069 226,150 368,725 394,225 6,790,124 3,666,746 7,000,800 7,000,950 - - - - - - 92 518,200 4,575 15,125 1,550 - - - MEDICAL SERVICES Organizational Structure Medical Services Ambulance Services Paramedic Services Wildland Medical Non-general operations indicated by underlined text. FUNCTIONS The Medical Services Fund is a proprietary fund established to account for operations financed and operated in a manner similar to a private business. The Medical Services fund accounts for ambulance and paramedic services provided by Ogden City. 164 OGDEN CITY 2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET SUMMARY OF REVENUES AND EXPENDITURES MEDICAL SERVICES 2014 ACTUAL 2015 ADOPTED 2016 BUDGET MEDICAL SERVICES REVENUES CHARGES FOR SERVICES INTEREST INTERGOVERNMENTAL REVENUE MISCELLANEOUS OTHER FINANCING SOURCES 4,173,624 51,177 1,874,010 - 5,291,900 50,000 1,784,875 10,000 2,636,100 5,889,750 50,000 1,349,675 10,000 - 6,098,811 9,772,875 7,299,425 2,566,919 2,768,557 - 2,774,475 6,896,150 102,250 2,228,100 5,071,325 - 5,335,476 9,772,875 7,299,425 EXPENDITURES FIRE PARAMEDICS MEDICAL SERVICES WILDLAND MEDICAL 165 OGDEN CITY 2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET FISCAL YEAR REVENUE BUDGET MEDICAL SERVICES 2014 ACTUAL 2015 7-MO ACTUAL 2015 ADOPTED 2016 BUDGET CHARGES FOR SERVICES ADMINISTRATIVE (5,413,526) (3,542,936) (4,708,100) (4,708,100) 9,587,150 6,659,642 10,000,000 10,597,850 The entries in Administrative are for billing reductions which must be recorded separately from the billing revenue. OPERATIONS Operating Revenue is from operation of the ambulance services. 4,173,624 3,116,706 5,291,900 51,177 26,244 50,000 5,889,750 INTEREST GENERAL 50,000 Interest Earnings are from the fund's positive cash balance. 51,177 26,244 50,000 50,000 INTERGOVERNMENTAL REVENUE COUNTY FUNDS 1,715,634 730,472 1,663,125 1,330,175 138,541 301,538 102,250 - 19,500 19,500 County Funds are primarily pass-through of County assessed funds for paramedic services. FEDERAL GRANTS Federal Funds are reimbursements for participation in the Wildland Medical program. STATE GRANTS 19,835 - Any State grants or funding for medical services would be recorded under State Grants. 1,874,010 1,032,010 - - 1,784,875 1,349,675 MISCELLANEOUS OTHER 10,000 10,000 Other is to record miscellaneous revenue items. - - 166 10,000 10,000 OGDEN CITY 2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET FISCAL YEAR REVENUE BUDGET MEDICAL SERVICES 2014 ACTUAL 2015 7-MO ACTUAL 2015 ADOPTED 2016 BUDGET OTHER FINANCING SOURCES FUND BALANCE/CARRYOVERS - - 2,636,100 - Carryover is the use of fund balance to fund primarily capital purchases, but can also represent operating costs. MEDICAL SERVICES TOTAL - 6,098,811 167 4,174,960 2,636,100 9,772,875 7,299,425 OGDEN CITY 2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET SUMMARY OF DEPARTMENTAL EXPENDITURES MEDICAL SERVICES 2014 ACTUAL 2015 7-MO ACTUAL 2015 ADOPTED 2016 BUDGET FIRE PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE DATA PROCESSING FISCAL CHARGES EQUIPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE TRANSFERS OPERATING TRANSFERS FUND BALANCE/CARRYOVER 3,509,428 258,938 581,030 356,870 75,000 538,638 210,084 (194,512) 5,335,476 1,994,837 144,549 334,317 310,749 44,375 326,625 2,636,100 5,791,552 3,807,750 304,675 613,825 476,600 76,000 324,600 61,500 2,636,100 1,471,825 9,772,875 3,214,050 296,425 844,725 544,100 77,000 560,000 61,500 1,701,625 7,299,425 PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE DATA PROCESSING FISCAL CHARGES EQUIPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE TRANSFERS OPERATING TRANSFERS FUND BALANCE/CARRYOVER DIVISION SUMMARY FIRE MEDICAL SERVICES WILDLAND MEDICAL FIRE PARAMEDICS 5,768,557 4,378,434 - 2,566,919 8,335,476 1,413,117 5,791,551 6,896,150 102,250 2,774,475 9,772,875 5,071,325 1,784,875 60,000 2,636,100 5,291,900 1,349,675 60,000 9,772,875 7,299,425 2,228,100 7,299,425 FUNDING SOURCES FIRE INTERGOVERNMENTAL MISCELLANEOUS PRIOR FUND BALANCE USER FEES/PERMITS 168 5,889,750 OGDEN CITY 2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET SUMMARY OF EXPENDITURES BY DIVISION MEDICAL SERVICES 2014 ACTUAL 2015 7-MO ACTUAL 2015 ADOPTED 2016 BUDGET FIRE FIRE PARAMEDICS PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE DATA PROCESSING 2,383,804 46,046 64,203 36,090 36,775 1,303,288 21,603 26,952 39,499 21,775 2,507,900 64,550 85,800 78,950 37,275 1,928,325 64,550 85,800 111,650 37,775 2,566,918 1,413,117 2,774,475 2,228,100 WILDLAND MEDICAL PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES FUND BALANCE/CARRYOVER MEDICAL SERVICES PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE DATA PROCESSING FISCAL CHARGES EQUIPMENT INRASTRUCTURE TRANSFERS OPERATING TRANSFERS FUND BALANCE/CARRYOVER FIRE TOTAL: - - 64,000 8,250 30,000 - - - 102,250 - 1,125,624 212,892 516,826 320,780 38,225 538,638 210,084 (194,512) - 691,549 122,946 307,364 271,250 22,600 326,625 2,636,100 - 1,235,850 231,875 528,025 397,650 38,725 324,600 61,500 1,285,725 231,875 758,925 432,450 39,225 560,000 61,500 - - 2,636,100 1,441,825 1,701,625 2,768,557 4,378,434 6,896,150 5,071,325 5,335,475 5,791,551 9,772,875 7,299,425 169 TENTATIVE FY2016 BUDGET POLICE DEPARTMENT PURPOSE OF WORK SESSION: Discuss Tentative FY2016 Budget Review FY2015 Accomplishments and Challenges ______________________________________________________________________________ Executive Summary Background The Administration will review the FY2016 Tentative Budget for the Police Department. Utah Code 10-16-11 (Utah Municipal Code – Uniform Fiscal Procedures Act for Utah Cities) requires that the City Administration prepare and present an annual, tentative budget at the first regularly scheduled meeting in May. The final budget must be adopted no later than June 22 of each year. In preparation for receiving and reviewing the budget, the Council also requests additional information from the Administration relating to areas of particular interest to the Council. This additional information includes reports on current fiscal year goals and accomplishments, progress on management audit recommendations, status of current year Capital Improvement Projects, staffing issues, debt service, and equipment replacement, and other relevant issues. Budget Review Process The Administrative and Council staffs meet regularly as a Budget Team during the budget process to discuss and review not only the current year progress, but also any significant changes in the proposed budget. Council staff may request additional information and justification for major budget proposals. Council Staff also meets with each Department head regarding individual departmental budgets. The information gleaned from these meetings is then presented to the Council in a series of work sessions. These work sessions offer the Council an opportunity to review and Ogden City Council Work Session: May 21, 2015 1 understand the tentative budget allowing the Council to make more informed decisions. Police FY2015 Legislative Intents The Council identified four items in the Budget Guidelines and Goals for the Police Department in the FY2015 Budget. Budget Guidelines 8. Cops in Schools. The City Council supports the partnership with the Ogden School District with the Cops in School program. The designated officers will help teachers, parents, students, and the community as resource officers. The City has committed to funding a significant portion of these positions. 10. Crime Reduction Initiative. A report regarding the efforts of the Crime Reduction Unit is to be provided annually as part of the budget process. Ogden Police Department Budget - Comparison All of OPD operations are funded by the General Fund. Police - General Fund Adopted FY2015 Proposed FY2016 $18,533,225 $18,826,525 Change Amount $293,300 % Change 1.58% Police General Fund Changes Significant budget line items for the Police General Fund expenditures are as follows: Proposed 4% Merit (1% to Base Pay) No retirement benefit increases Two additional FTE’s New Radio Equipment Organization Structure / Staffing Admin / Uniform / Detectives-Major Crimes / Detectives -Youth Crimes / Detectives-Task Force / Cops in Schools / Support Services Community Policing Ogden City Council Work Session: May 21, 2015 2 Chief – 1 Deputy Chief – 2 Deputy Director (Non-sworn) -1 Lieutenant – 8 Sergeant – 15 Police Officers – 112 (-1) Comm. Service Officer – 5 Crime Analyst – 2 (+1) Project Coordinator - 1 Police Records Supervisor – 1 Community Service Officer – 10 Administrative Assistant –1 Special Services Coordinator – 1 Senior Office Assistant – 4 Police Records Clerk – 6 Park Enforcement Officer – 2 Animal Services Supervisor – 1 Animal Services Officer – 3 (+1) Total of 176 Positions (+1) The proposed FY2016 adds one new Animal Services Officer and one new Crime Analyst. It reduces the number of Police Officers by one for a net plus one (1) change in total number of FTE’s. Capital Improvements There are no CIP Projects proposed for OPD in the FY2016 Budget. Equipment An amount of $95,000 has been budgeted to begin replacing outdated radio equipment. Upgrades to Utah Communications Area Network (UCAN) will require all radio equipment to be updated in the next two or three years. Questions GENERAL 1. Please review the documents provided in response to the Council information request. Ogden City Council Work Session: May 21, 2015 3 2. Please review your Department’s successes for FY2015. 3. Please review recent or on-going challenges for your Department. PERSONNEL AND STAFFING 4. Please describe the proposed addition of one animal services officer and one crime analyst. 5. Please discuss the challenges with keeping the Department fully staffed. 6. Identify vacant positions and indicate how and when they will be filled. 7. Please explain how you plan to distribute the Merit increase to your employees. EQUIPMENT 8. Please review the request for funding for radio equipment. How many radios will the $95,000 replace? If the funding does not cover replacement of all required radio equipment, please outline future needs and timeline for replacement of all radio equipment. Council Staff Contact: Janene Eller-Smith, (801) 629-8165 Glenn Symes (801) 629-8164 Ogden City Council Work Session: May 21, 2015 4 Column1 Column3 Column4 Column6 Column8 Year Moving Non‐moving Parking 2013 6077 4867 9288 2014 6881 4796 9257 Total 12958 9663 Column9 Column10 Total 20232 20934 18545 Column11 3.35% Increase 41166 Ogden Police Department Traffic Citations 2013 vs 2014 10000 9288 9257 9000 8000 6881 7000 6077 6000 4867 5000 4796 4000 3000 2000 1000 0 Moving Non‐moving Parking 2013 2014 Column12 Column13 OPD’S investment in crime reduction • The Crime Reduction Unit represents 10% of OPD’s total work force. Represented below are average wages alone for the CRU for one year. – 1 Lieutenant ‐ $62,000 – 2 Sergeants ‐ $104,000 – 10 officers ‐ $416,000 Total ‐ $582,000 2013 COMPARED TO 2014 PART 1 CRIMES (20TH ST to 30TH ST / WASH BLVD to HARRISON) PART 1 CRIMES AGG ASSAULT ARSON AUTO THEFT BURGLARY HOMICIDE RAPE ROBBERY THEFT Grand Total 2013 TOTALS 62 4 102 182 1 4 36 602 993 2014 TOTALS 56 4 93 171 0 8 26 498 856 PERCENT CHANGE ‐10% 0% ‐9% ‐6% ‐100% 100% ‐28% ‐17% ‐14% PART 1 CRIMES (20TH ST to 30TH ST / WASH BLVD to HARRISON) 650 600 550 500 450 400 350 300 250 200 150 100 50 0 602 498 182 171 102 93 62 56 4 AGG ASSAULT ARSON 4 1 AUTO THEFT BURGLARY 2013 TOTALS HOMICIDE 8 4 RAPE 2014 TOTALS 36 26 ROBBERY THEFT CRU Statistics 2446 2500 1895 2000 1500 892 1000 653 633 530 500 581 402 346 375 263 360 0 Warrants Parole checks Citations Field Interviews 2013 2014 Drug cases Knock & Talk Continued to work with AP&P • In conjunction with Adult Probation and Parole the CRU has developed information sharing spreadsheet where the most active and “at risk” paroles are identified. • Each week AP&P Agents will ride along with CRU Officers and pay extra attention to these individuals. CRU Gang Suppression • Crime Reduction Unit meet with the Gang Unit and Adult Probation and Parole each week to share information on current gang members and investigations. Gang member/High risk Parolee example • Ogden Trece gang member Patrick Valdez. Valdez was a wanted fugitive from AP&P. • Responsible for 4 vehicle pursuits in the Ogden Area in summer of 2014. During pursuit he had a total disregard for innocent people driving very dangerously. • After pooling several weeks of surveillance, informant information and good old fashioned investigation, CRU captured him during a very violent escape attempt. Valdez attempted to flee in a vehicle when contacted by the arrest team. He rammed a home, a fence and a parked vehicle during his failed escape. While struggling with arresting officers, Valdez was bit by one of the K9’s, which led to his ultimate surrender. CRU Gang Suppression example • 12‐14‐14 CRU Officers investigated a shooting at 2825 Adams Ave. There was evidence that the weapon used in the shooting was in the home. • Search Warrant was drafted and the house was searched. • CRU located two firearms in the home. • Arrested Brent Vigil and Issac Duran both Ogden Trece gang members. • Vigil is felony on felony at the WCJ. This was the third shooting he had been involved in during 2014. Other highlighted cases • David Hernandez. 4 oz. of Meth and $4000 in cash. From routine traffic stop. • Kris Simmons. CRU worked with Major Crimes to track Simmons who was stealing cars in Ogden. Our use of electronic tracking equipment lead Officers to him in storage unit in Weber County. A standoff with SWAT and an Officer involved shooting ensued. Goals and new programs for 2015‐2016 • Bait vehicle and property‐ – In 2014 the CRU secured a grant from the Utah Commission on Crime and Juvenile Justice to purchase GPS property trackers and a vehicle. – The CRU received approval from the council to use evidence which was due to be auctioned or destroyed as bait to place the trackers in. – The vehicle has been set up as a bait car with cameras, a GPS tracker and remote kill system. Goals and new programs for 2015‐2016 – The CRU has successfully deployed both the vehicle and property. – We have already seen positive results and expect more in the next year. Goals and new programs for 2015‐2016 • CRU K‐9 – In a partnership with the Weber Morgan Strike Force the CRU will be adding a drug specific K‐9 within the next month. A private donation has helped us secure the dog and K‐9 vehicle. – We expect to see great results form the dog over the next year. The Ogden police Department currently has 13 open FTE officer positions. In the FY15 budget, OPD is authorized a total of 144 police positions with 118 of those being police officer positions. Five (5) of the 118 officer positions are called “float” positions as they may be filled with either a police officer or a (CSO) community service officer. In the Ogden City Staffing Document the Police and CSO positions are listed as follows: Position Range FY15 Police Chief DIR73 1 Deputy Chief DDD67 2 Lieutenant PL/57 8 Sergeant PS/50 15 Police Officer PO/38‐43 113 Police Officer/CSO PO/28 5.00 (Float) Community Service Officer 28 10 From FY12 through FY14 OPD averaged using four CSO float positions to fill ancillary jobs that had previously been filled with a police officer. Currently, CSOs are used to fill four ancillary positions, (2) Evidence Technicians, (1) Training/FLEET assistant and (1) CP assistant. The CP assistant manages the paperwork associated with the Good Landlord program and handles the Alarm Permit program. In an effort to put more officers on the street OPD redesigned the CSO front desk schedule for the FY15 budget year in an attempt to eliminate the need for using CSO float positions. The redesigned CSO desk officer schedule uses (6) CSO positions to cover front desk duties of the police department, thus allowing OPD to fill the aforementioned ancillary positions out of the authorized CSO staffing of ten (10). Initially, for FY15, OPD chose not to fill the four CSO float positions to ensure that the redesigned CSO desk officer schedule would produce the desired result. While not optimal, the redesigned CSO desk officer program does provide adequate coverage and will enable OPD to cover the stated ancillary positions with CSOs and to stop using “float” positions which equates to more officers on the street. OPDs ability to maintain authorized police officer staffing is being affected by several factors to include: Lack of quality police officer applicants o Highlighted by increased numbers of applicants with major background issues o Increased number of officer candidates failing to complete the FTO field training process o New hire candidates who decide after being hired that police work isn’t for them o Increased number of candidates scoring poorly on the psychological suitability testing Current Civil Service hiring process averages three months from job posting to initial job offers o Several top candidates have taken jobs with other agencies before our process has completed and have stated they wanted to work for Ogden, but needed a job “now” Utah POST – over the past several years POST has on short notice eliminated or delayed training sessions o POST training is 3 months and FTO is 3 months – average new hire does not go on the road for 6 months o Cancelled POST sessions can add months to the hiring and training process Officers choosing to retire at the 20 year minimum even though they can add to their retirement at a rate of 2% for each additional year they stay Officers leaving to go to other departments o Primary complaint is the lack of a defined merit pay plan o Low pay for number of years’ experience – due to (5) years with no merit or COLA raise o Compression within ranks – again the result of (5) years with no merit or COLA pay raise Twenty‐one (21) officers have terminated employment between January 2014 and April 2015. The breakdown of causes for termination are as follows: Retirement 4 Other police agency 7 Other employment non‐police 3 Training issues (FTO) 3 Education – law school 1 Resignation in lieu of termination 1 Other miscellaneous 2 We are currently in the process of offering a lateral hire opportunity to current POST certified law enforcement officers from other police departments in an effort to fill a number of the vacant positions. Although this will expedite the process of getting trained officers in the field, it creates contention and resentment amongst incumbent officers who have remained loyal and committed during the periods with no raises, only to see new officers who are starting at or above their current salary. Although 2015 is the off year for benchmarking, Ogden City HR has sent requests for pay and benefits information to several Utah cities that have been identified as having made wage and benefits adjustments in 2015, specific to the public safety sector, in an effort to curb employee loss and encourage retention. HR is also requesting information specific to retention programs for public safety that these and other cities currently have implemented or any programs they may be considering. Recruiting and retention for law enforcement officers in Utah and other states throughout the country has changed. The attached URL is just one article that illustrates the climate on a local level. We recently lost three officers to SLC on a lateral hire program due to significant pay increase and defined merit pay structure. http://www.ksl.com/?nid=148&sid=33529818 OGDEN CITY FY2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET SUMMARY OF STAFFING CHANGES Enterprise Fund Department Medical Services Division Paramedics Position Title Captain position eliminated Enterprise Medical Services Paramedics Enterprise Public Services Refuse Utility Paramedic position eliminated Maintenance Technician positions added consistant with new Healthcare Reform requirements Equipment Operator positions added consistant with new Healthcare Reform requirements Maintenance Technician positions added consistant with new Healthcare Reform requirements Water Production Supervisor position added Backflow Technician I position added Water Plant Tradesman position added Backflow Technician title changed to Backflow Technician II Water Plant Operator position eliminated Water Plant Supervisor position eliminated Development Services Supervisor position eliminated Development Services Technician position eliminated Plan Review/Code Inspector position added Enterprise Enterprise Public Services Public Services Refuse Utility Sewer Utility Enterprise Public Services Water Utility Enterprise Public Services Water Utility Enterprise Public Services Water Utility Enterprise Public Services Water Utility Enterprise Public Services Water Utility Enterprise Public Services Water Utility General Community & Economic Development Community & Economic Development Community & Economic Development Community & Economic Development Community & Economic Development Building Services Building Services General Community & Economic Development Community & Economic Development Community & Economic Development Management Services General Management Services Comptroller General General General General General General General General Building Services Building Services Building Services Building Services Building Services Business Development Administration Management Services Comptroller Code Services Supervisor range increased from 39 to 50 Code Services Officer reclassified to Sr. Code Services Officer (moved from Major Grants Fund) Code Services Officer position added Benchmarked Reclassified Added 3 3 3 2 4 1 1 2 1 2 1 1 1 2 1 2 1 Code Services Collector position added 1 Project Coordinator - Arts Coordinator position added 1 Digital Media Producer position added Finance Manager/City Treasurer title changed to Comptroller Deputy Division Finance Manager title changed to Deputy Comptroller Eliminated Title Change 1 1 1 OGDEN CITY FY2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET SUMMARY OF STAFFING CHANGES Fund General Department Division Management Services Human Resources General Management Services Justice Court General Management Services Treasury General Police Police General Police Police General Police Police General Police Police General General General General General General Internal Service Internal Service Trust Police Public Services Public Services Public Services Police Engineering Public Ways & Parks Benchmarked Position Title Human Resources Manager title changed to Human Resources/Risk Manager Court Liaison range increased from 33 to 38 Fiscal Op Manager/City Treasurer position added Police Officer position eliminated Crime Analyst Position added Animal Services Officer position added Administrative Assistant reclassified to Office Supervisor and range increased from 31 to 38 Senior Office Assistant reclassified to Strike Force Office Technician and range increased from 24 to 30 Added Eliminated Title Change 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Building and Construction Inspector title changed to Construction Inspector (2 other Construction Inspectors moved to Engineering and charged out to Water and Sewer) New Maintenance Technician positions added consistant with new Healthcare Reform requirements 1 5 Recreation Supervisor position added Public Services Recreation - MWC Assistant Recreation Supervisor position added Public Services Recreation - MWC Maintenance Technician position added Management Services Information Technology Customer Account Coordinator reclassified to Senior Customer Account Coordinator Management Services Information Technology Telecommunications Administrator and Security Administrator reclassified to Network Administrators Community & Community Sr. Project Coordinator Economic Development reclassified to Deputy Development Community Development Division Manager Total Reclassified Recreation - MWC 1 1 1 1 2 1 0 11 30 12 4 Position Vacant for Three Months or Longer Title Division BUSINESS LIC ENFORCE OFFICER CASHIER - JUSTICE COURT CASHIER - JUSTICE COURT COMMUNITY SERVICE OFFICER COMMUNITY SERVICE OFFICER COMMUNITY SERVICE OFFICER FIRE CAPTAIN FIRE CAPTAIN FIRE CAPTAIN GIS ANALYST PARAMEDIC PARAMEDIC PARAMEDIC PARKING ENFORCEMENT OFFICER POLICE OFFICER POLICE OFFICER POLICE OFFICER POLICE OFFICER POLICE OFFICER POLICE OFFICER POLICE OFFICER POLICE OFFICER POLICE OFFICER POLICE OFFICER SR. ACCOUNT CLERK Building Services Justice Court Justice Court Police Police Police Fire Fire Fire IT Fire Fire Fire Police Police Police Police Police Police Police Police Police Police Police Comptroller/Treasury Notes Filled by part time employees. Filled by part time employees. Position being eliminated 06-30-15. Position being eliminated 06-30-15. Position being eliminated 06-30-15. Position being eliminated 06-30-15. Position being eliminated 06-30-15. Position being eliminated 06-30-15. Filled by part time employees. Position Vacant for Under Three Months CONSTRUCTION INSPECTOR DEVELOPMENT SERVICES SUPERVISOR SR. ANALYST WATER PLANT OPERATOR WATER PLANT OPERATOR - TRADESMAN Engineering Building Services Comptroller/Treasury Water Water Position advertised and closed. Position being eliminated 06-30-15. Interviews conducted. Interviews conducted. POLICE DEPARTMENT Organizational Structure Police Department Administration Animal Services Investigations Support Services Uniform Non-general operations indicated by underlined text. FUNCTIONS The Police Department is to enforce the law of the United States and the State of Utah, as well as enforcing the ordinances of Ogden City. Additionally, Animal Services reports to this Department. 85 OGDEN CITY 2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET POLICE GENERAL FUND INVESTIGATIONS OPD ADMINISTRATION SUPPORT SERVICES UNIFORM 5,624,475 1,834,500 1,713,625 9,653,925 18,826,525 INVESTIGATIONS OPD ADMINISTRATION SUPPORT SERVICES UNIFORM OVERALL RESPONSIBILITY GENERAL FUND MISC. GRANTS & DONATIONS EXPENDABLE TRUST 18,826,525 18,826,525 20,000,000 18,000,000 16,000,000 14,000,000 12,000,000 10,000,000 8,000,000 6,000,000 4,000,000 2,000,000 - GENERAL FUND MISC. GRANTS & DONATIONS EXPENDABLE TRUST 86 OGDEN CITY 2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET SUMMARY OF DEPARTMENTAL EXPENDITURES GENERAL FUND 2014 ACTUAL 2015 7-MO ACTUAL 2015 ADOPTED 2016 BUDGET POLICE PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE DATA PROCESSING 14,694,300 528,466 1,000,922 898,716 562,650 17,685,054 8,700,328 322,969 262,901 500,265 9,786,463 16,132,100 376,600 1,112,175 912,350 18,533,225 16,382,100 426,600 1,097,175 920,650 18,826,525 PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE DATA PROCESSING DIVISION SUMMARY POLICE OPD ADMINISTRATION UNIFORM INVESTIGATIONS SUPPORT SERVICES 1,792,618 8,559,468 5,776,697 1,556,270 17,685,053 525,391 5,348,362 3,188,845 723,865 9,786,463 1,591,900 9,148,025 6,063,350 1,729,950 18,533,225 1,834,500 9,653,925 5,624,475 1,713,625 18,826,525 FUNDING SOURCES POLICE OTHER FINANCING SOURCES CHARGES FOR SERVICES FINES AND FORFEITURES GENERAL REVENUES INTERGOVERNMENTAL MISCELLANEOUS REVENUE USER FEES/PERMITS 184,000 660,000 16,994,150 509,575 32,500 153,000 18,533,225 87 95,000 190,000 620,000 17,229,525 535,000 157,000 18,826,525 OGDEN CITY 2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET SUMMARY OF EXPENDITURES BY DIVISION GENERAL FUND 2014 ACTUAL 2015 7-MO ACTUAL 2015 ADOPTED 2016 BUDGET POLICE INVESTIGATIONS PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE OPD ADMINISTRATION PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE DATA PROCESSING SUPPORT SERVICES PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE DATA PROCESSING UNIFORM PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE POLICE TOTAL: 5,466,497 60,056 136,078 114,066 3,006,942 43,423 62,258 76,222 5,694,550 42,550 160,000 166,250 5,229,575 66,625 160,000 168,275 5,776,697 3,188,845 6,063,350 5,624,475 664,591 147,838 427,780 14,759 537,650 396,461 98,954 21,699 8,277 1,039,800 91,100 454,375 6,625 1,232,025 141,100 454,375 7,000 1,792,618 525,391 1,591,900 1,834,500 1,108,142 28,044 316,106 78,979 25,000 568,499 13,773 92,950 48,644 1,111,800 72,025 392,400 153,725 1,117,400 47,950 392,400 155,875 1,556,271 723,866 1,729,950 1,713,625 7,455,070 292,529 120,958 690,911 4,728,426 166,819 85,994 367,123 8,285,950 170,925 105,400 585,750 8,803,100 170,925 90,400 589,500 8,559,468 5,348,362 9,148,025 9,653,925 17,685,054 9,786,464 18,533,225 18,826,525 - - - 88 - - - TENTATIVE FY2016 BUDGET MANAGEMENT SERVICES DEPARTMENT PURPOSE OF WORK SESSION: Discuss Tentative FY2016 Budget ______________________________________________________________________________ Executive Summary Background The Administration will review the FY2016 Tentative Budget for the Management Services Department and discuss other general budget issues. Utah Code 10-16-11 (Utah Municipal Code – Uniform Fiscal Procedures Act for Utah Cities) requires that the City Administration prepare and present an annual, tentative budget at the first regularly scheduled meeting in May. The final budget must be adopted no later than June 22 of each year. In preparation for receiving and reviewing the budget, the Council also requests additional information from the Administration relating to areas of particular interest to the Council. This additional information includes reports on current fiscal year goals and accomplishments, progress on management audit recommendations, status of current year capital improvement projects, staffing issues, debt service, equipment replacement, and other related issues. Budget Review Process The Administrative and Council staffs meet regularly as a Budget Team during the budget process to discuss and review not only the current year progress, but also any significant changes in the proposed budget. Council staff may request additional information and justification for major budget proposals. Staff also meets with each Department head regarding individual departmental budgets. The information gleaned from these meetings is then presented to the Council in a series of work sessions. These work sessions offer the Council an opportunity to review and Ogden City Council Work Session: May 21, 2015 1 understand the tentative budget allowing the Council to make more informed decisions. Revenues – All Funds In the budget proposed by the Mayor, the amount of revenue to be received in the fiscal year is estimated. This can be a difficult and complicated process. The amounts for each revenue source are estimated based on the historical amounts and what is known about the coming year in terms of variables that could affect them e.g., the economy and sales tax. It is not often that the Council makes changes to the revenues projected in the budget. Most changes to the proposed budget are done in the expenditure side of the budget. This is because projecting revenues is more difficult than determining what expenditures the City can afford based on the revenue projected. Revenues are tracked through the year as they become available. These are reported to the Council in the quarterly financial reports. Sources of Revenue There are five significant sources of revenue in the General Fund that account for approximately 75% of the revenue in the General Fund. These are the property tax, sales tax, franchise tax (taxes on utilities), fees in lieu of taxes, and allocations to municipal operations (transfers from the enterprise funds to the general fund). The proposed budget shows an increase in projected sales tax which includes general sales and use tax and municipal energy sales tax. Property and franchise taxes are expected to decrease from the previous year. This is due to a calculation adjustment for property tax and a continued decrease in franchise and telecommunications license fees. The continued decrease in telecommunications license fees is currently being investigated by municipalities throughout the state. Revenues from general sales and use taxes are projected to increase by $783,750 from last year’s budgeted amount. This is an increase of approximately 5.25% from last year’s budgeted amount. Total General Fund revenues are projected to increase by 0.5%. Ogden City Council Work Session: May 21, 2015 2 Other than the five large revenue generators, the other 25% of the General Fund revenue comes from fees, fines, permits, licenses miscellaneous other taxes and some intergovernmental funds such as B&C Road Funds. The General Fund is where the City has the most flexibility in terms of how the funds will be used. This is also where much of the budget deliberations are focused. However, the other City funds are also significant and should be understood in terms of where their revenue comes from. These include: 1) Enterprise funds show proposed estimated revenue of $77,266,175. This is an increase of $5,263,250 overall compared to last year’s budgeted amount. The majority of this change is due to the use of retained earnings in the utility funds for capital projects that have been scheduled for FY16. 2) The Internal Service funds show proposed estimated revenue of $16,784,575. This is a decrease of $7,875 from last year’s budgeted amount. 3) Major Grants come primarily from federal grants, such as Community Development Block Grant Money (CDBG), and program income from the City’s community development programs. The Council reviews these in the Annual Action Plan each year prior to review of the budget. The Annual Action Plan has been reviewed by the Council already this year. The Redevelopment Agency (RDA) Budget is also part of the proposed budget revenue and will be reviewed separately by the RDA Board during the budget process. Summary of Major Revenue Changes in Proposed FY 2015 Budget Below is a summary of the estimated revenues for all of the fund types in the City Budget except the Major Grants which is reviewed with the Annual Action Plan and the Redevelopment Agency which is presented in a separate RDA Budget. The yellow sheets included with the budget Ogden City Council Work Session: May 21, 2015 3 workbook show all of the projected revenue changes of $20,000 or more in each fund as well as the total for each fund. Projected Revenue by Fund Revenue Fund General Fund Enterprise Funds Water Fund Sewer Fund* Refuse Fund Airport Golf Courses Recreation BDO Infrastructure Storm Sewer* Medical Services Internal Service Funds Fleet and Facilities IT Risk Management Total $54,199,450 $ Change $272,475 $25,800,550 $11,529,125 $5,555,525 $3,516,375 $1,617,700 $270,075 $14,487,800 $7,189,600 $7,299,425 $222,250 ($4,473,600) $231,875 $767,750 ($98,650) $975 $3,896,500 $2,392,225 ($2,473,450) $11,249,075 $3,933,025 $1,602,475 ($60,950) $520,950 ($467,875) *The separation of Storm Sewer from the Sanitary Sewer fund is a change for the FY16 budget. Management Services FY2015 Budget Guidelines and Goals Budget Guidelines and Goals associated with the Management Service Department are included in a separate attachment. Management Services Department Budget - Comparison The Management Services Department is funded in part through the General Fund and through three Internal Service Funds. A comparison of the FY2015 adopted budget and the FY2016 proposed budget shows the following: Ogden City Council Work Session: May 21, 2015 4 General Fund Adopted FY2015 Proposed FY2016 Amount Change % Change $558,300 $667,800 $109,500 19.61% $1,477,100 $1,505,275 $28,175 1.91% Human Resources $530,025 $538,800 $8,775 1.66% Comptroller $593,325 $563,075 -$30,250 -5.10% Fiscal Operations $409,325 $476,050 $66,725 16.30% Purchasing $133,850 $133,050 -$800 -0.60% Recorder $405,750 $415,775 $10,025 2.47% $4,107,675 $4,299,825 $192,150 4.68% Administration Justice Court Total Internal Service Funds Adopted FY2015 Proposed FY2016 Amount Change % Change Fleet and Facilities $11,310,025 $11,249,075 -$60,950 -0.54% Information Tech $3,412,075 $3,933,025 $520,950 15.27% Risk Management $2,070,350 $1,602,475 -$467,875 -22.60% Management Services Organizational Structure / Staffing Administration - 3 Positions (+1) Justice Court - 14 Positions Human Resources - 5 Positions Risk Management - 1 Position Comptroller – 5.35 Positions Fiscal Ops (Treasury) - 5 Positions (+1) Purchasing - 2 Positions Recorder - 4 Positions Fleet and Facilities - 19 Positions Information Technology - 14 Positions Management Services – Total of 72.35 Positions Ogden City Council Work Session: May 21, 2015 5 The FY2016 Budget adds back the City Treasurer position which was combined with the Finance Manager position in the FY2015 budget. The Administration is also proposing that a digital media producer position be added for a total increase of two positions. Capital Improvements The Management Services Department has no proposed CIP projects for funding in FY2016. Equipment Management Services will not receive any new fleet equipment under the proposed FY2016 Budget. There will be new IT equipment purchases which will be discussed separately. Questions REVENUES 1. Please provide an overview of the projected revenues in the proposed FY2016 Budget. 2. Please review the plans for the Justice Court with regard to the continuing reduction in Court fines and forfeiture revenues. PERSONNEL AND STAFFING 3. Please review the personnel changes in the Department. 4. Please explain how the Department intends to distribute the proposed merit increase. FACILITIES 5. Please explain the Administration’s plans for future maintenance of city facilities. NON-DEPARTMENT ACCOUNTS 6. Please review the general purpose for all non-departmental accounts (e.g., why these funds are not in departmental budgets). 7. Please briefly review the following expenditure line items: Ogden City Council Work Session: May 21, 2015 6 a. b. c. d. e. Building Costs to Facilities Facilities Costs – General City Payroll Contingency UCAN Radio Service Fees Union Station Contract (New) GENERAL /OTHER FINANCIAL QUESTIONS 8. Please review the documents submitted in response to the Council’s request (if not otherwise covered). 9. Please review the fund balances for all funds, including the Fleet, IT and Risk Management. 10. Please review the debt summary sheet. 11. Please review the transfers among funds. 12. Please review the BDO Lease Revenue distribution. 13. Please review your Department’s successes for FY2015. 14. Please review recent or on-going challenges for your Department. 15. Please outline and discuss the “friendly” amendments that have been proposed to date that will be suggested prior to adoption of the FY2016 Budget. Council Staff Contacts: Janene Eller-Smith, (801) 629-8165 Glenn Symes, (801) 629-8164 Ogden City Council Work Session: May 21, 2015 7 Management Services Budget Guidelines and Goals Budget Guidelines 2. Budget Development. All ordinances, resolutions, fee studies, other studies, and supporting documentation will accompany the proposed budget for consideration during the budget process. The budget is submitted by the Mayor each year on the first Tuesday of May. The quantity of documentation, explanation and detail will be commensurate with the size, scope or complexity of each proposal. 3. Budget Transfers from Salaries and Benefits. In keeping with the intent of the pay-for performance system, the Council desires that all salaries and benefits are spent for this purpose and to receive notice of all budget transfers from salaries and benefits within 15 days of the actual transfer of funds. The notice is to include the dollar amount being transferred, where it is being transferred to, and for what purpose. 9. Council Notification. All significant changes to City programs and services that impact City employees, citizens or businesses (e.g., new programs, changes in level of service to existing programs or services, City events, contracting out of City Services, reorganizations, layoffs, reductions in force, etc.) will be communicated to the Council via Council Leadership or the Council Executive Director at least ninety (90) days prior to implementation or amendment to allow for adequate time for the Council's review and public process. 13. Fee Changes. Proposed fee changes are to be adopted as part of the budget review process. The City Financial Principles related to fees are to be followed. The Council recognizes that some fees are impacted by the calendar year, by seasonal activity, or by the calendars or scheduling constraints of other government agencies or businesses and that certain fees may need to be amended during the fiscal year and cannot be amended with the annual budget process. Mid-year fee increase requests are due October 1 accompanied by sufficient rationale and justification. Fees to be implemented in January (excluding utilities) will be considered at that time by the Council if all applicable information is received. Utility Fees. The recommendations of the 2012 Utility Rate Study, also known as the Comprehensive Financial Sustainability Plan are to be followed. A review of the proposed changes included in the Utility Rate Study will be performed in a joint effort beginning in November each year. Fee changes that are submitted without a detailed analysis will not be considered by the Council. Building Permit Fees. The City's building permit fees are to be evaluated on a biennial basis beginning with the FY2016 budget process. 1 14. Fleet Business Plan. The Fleet Division Business Plan will be reviewed annually. The updated Fleet business plan is to be provided at the beginning of the budget process each year. 15. Foundations. Contracts with the various Foundations operating City facilities will be monitored to ensure that management of the operations is consistent with the terms of the Agreement. The Council will meet with representatives of the Foundations annually to discuss short-term and long-term goals for the respective operations. The Foundations include Dinosaur Park, Union Station, Marshall White, Wildlife Rehabilitation Center, Ogden Pioneer Days and Get Out and Live (GOAL). 16. Grant Reporting and Monitoring. Grants are evaluated annually including grants received, the amount and source of City match if applicable, grants being applied that will require a City match, and the expected date of award. The "Annual Grants Report" is to be provided to the Council in January each year with a work session discussion to follow in February. 19. Revenue Forecasts. Revenue forecasts are to include the rationale and assumptions made for each of the significant revenue sources forecast in each proposed budget. Budget Goals 5—Adopted June 17, 2014 12. Union Station: To support the Union Station Foundations’ efforts to raise private funds to renovate Union Station and surrounding properties to create a world-class home for the Railroad, Browning, and Cowboy museums. 13. Visioning and Rebranding Efforts: To complete the rebranding efforts to create a unified City vision, logo, and website, etc., that reflects the goals, objectives and vision of the City. 15. Percent for Arts Program: To adopt amendments to the Percent for Arts Program that refocuses the efforts of the Arts Capital Improvement Program. The amendments will align with the updated arts master plan and the ongoing efforts to increase Ogden’s statewide, national, and international stature. A joint visioning process will also take place in conjunction with updates to the arts master plan. 2 OGDEN CITY 2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET REVENUE SUMMARY AIRPORT CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROJECTS GENERAL FUND GOLF COURSES GRANTS MAJOR GRANTS EXPENDABLE TRUST MISC. GRANTS & DONATIONS EXPENDABLE TRUST INTERNAL SERVICE FUNDS FLEET AND FACILITIES INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY RISK MANAGEMENT MEDICAL SERVICES OTHER CEMETERY PERPETUAL CARE EXPENDABLE TRUST DOWNTOWN OGDEN SPECIAL ASSESSMENT GOMER NICHOLAS NON-EXPENDABLE TRUST TOURISM & MARKETING PROPERTY MANAGEMENT BDO INFRASTRUCTURE RECREATION REFUSE UTILITY SANITARY SEWER UTILITY STORM SEWER UTILITY WATER UTILITY 3,516,375 1,705,200 54,199,450 1,617,700 9,043,200 2.21% 1.07% 33.99% 1.01% 5.67% 16,784,575 10.53% 7,299,425 466,875 4.58% 0.29% 14,487,800 270,075 5,555,525 11,529,125 7,189,600 25,800,550 9.09% 0.17% 3.48% 7.23% 4.51% 16.18% 159,465,475 100% 9,033,200 10,000 11,249,075 3,933,025 1,602,475 200,000 126,375 1,500 139,000 GENERAL FUND GOLF COURSES GRANTS CAP ITAL IMP ROVEMENT P ROJECTS INTERNAL SERVICE FUNDS $159,465,475 AIRP ORT MEDICAL SERVICES WATER UTILITY OTHER STORM SEWER UTILITY P ROP ERTY MANAGEMENT BDO INFRASTRUCTURE RECREATION SANITARY SEWER UTILITY REFUSE UTILITY 40 OGDEN CITY 2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET REVENUE SUMMARY REPORT 2014 ACTUAL GENERAL FUND CHARGES FOR SERVICES FINES AND FORFEITURES INTEREST INTERGOVERNMENTAL REVENUE LICENSES AND PERMITS MISCELLANEOUS OTHER FINANCING SOURCES TAXES DOWNTOWN OGDEN SPECIAL ASSESSMENT INTEREST MISCELLANEOUS OTHER FINANCING SOURCES TAXES TOURISM & MARKETING INTEREST OTHER FINANCING SOURCES TAXES 2015 ADOPTED 4,949,273 2,424,407 72,412 3,403,832 2,301,809 1,097,555 125,000 38,091,714 4,803,250 2,720,000 50,000 3,159,575 2,173,500 1,102,575 30,000 39,888,075 3,699,650 2,470,000 80,000 3,485,000 2,434,500 1,109,075 301,375 40,619,850 52,466,002 53,926,975 54,199,450 535 23,000 30,000 112,250 750 53,000 112,500 13,125 112,500 165,785 166,250 126,375 959 113,228 1,000 48,000 100,000 1,000 28,000 110,000 114,187 149,000 139,000 12,500 44,867 2,254,718 4,861,578 10,000 5,948,850 5,291,550 10,000 103,675 1,591,525 7,173,663 11,250,400 1,705,200 41 750 - - CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROJECTS CHARGES FOR SERVICES INTEREST INTERGOVERNMENTAL REVENUE OTHER FINANCING SOURCES 2016 BUDGET - - - OGDEN CITY 2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET REVENUE SUMMARY REPORT 2014 ACTUAL WATER UTILITY CHARGES FOR SERVICES INTEREST MISCELLANEOUS OTHER FINANCING SOURCES TAXES SANITARY SEWER UTILITY CHARGES FOR SERVICES INTEREST MISCELLANEOUS OTHER FINANCING SOURCES REFUSE UTILITY CHARGES FOR SERVICES INTEREST MISCELLANEOUS OTHER FINANCING SOURCES 2015 ADOPTED 17,696,227 118,103 49,787 768,780 850,923 19,594,575 50,000 42,500 4,803,500 1,087,725 19,434,950 50,000 42,500 5,408,500 864,600 19,483,820 25,578,300 25,800,550 14,601,820 124,341 17,532 899,274 14,962,175 60,000 12,150 968,400 10,658,900 50,000 12,150 808,075 15,642,967 16,002,725 11,529,125 5,224,433 26,016 1,151 5,319,650 1,000 3,000 5,388,800 1,000 3,000 162,725 - 5,555,525 325,000 500 350,000 18,350 2,054,775 360,000 500 1,300,000 24,800 1,831,075 1,282,466 2,748,625 3,516,375 983,936 1,842 82,825 19,911 545,000 1,096,000 1,000 83,300 6,000 530,050 1,096,000 1,000 1,633,514 1,716,350 1,617,700 377,397 (4,508) 658,913 17,989 232,675 GOLF COURSES CHARGES FOR SERVICES INTEREST INTERGOVERNMENTAL REVENUE MISCELLANEOUS OTHER FINANCING SOURCES 42 5,323,650 5,251,600 AIRPORT CHARGES FOR SERVICES INTEREST INTERGOVERNMENTAL REVENUE MISCELLANEOUS OTHER FINANCING SOURCES 2016 BUDGET 6,000 514,700 OGDEN CITY 2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET REVENUE SUMMARY REPORT 2014 ACTUAL RECREATION CHARGES FOR SERVICES INTEREST INTERGOVERNMENTAL REVENUE PROPERTY MANAGEMENT BDO INFRASTRUCTURE CHARGES FOR SERVICES INTEREST OTHER FINANCING SOURCES 240,100 1,000 28,000 240,100 1,000 28,975 584,973 269,100 270,075 4,068,640 41,723 3,385,590 3,503,750 45,000 7,042,550 3,413,750 45,000 11,029,050 7,495,953 10,591,300 14,487,800 - - 4,628,650 10,000 1,000 2,549,950 - - 7,189,600 4,173,624 51,177 1,874,010 5,291,900 50,000 1,784,875 10,000 2,636,100 5,889,750 50,000 1,349,675 10,000 6,098,811 9,772,875 7,299,425 7,085,400 (1,591) 3,513,346 600,000 8,839,950 5,000 267,125 2,197,950 8,861,275 5,000 267,125 2,115,675 11,310,025 11,249,075 - FLEET AND FACILITIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES INTEREST MISCELLANEOUS OTHER FINANCING SOURCES 11,197,155 43 2016 BUDGET 240,885 262 343,826 STORM SEWER UTILITY CHARGES FOR SERVICES INTEREST MISCELLANEOUS OTHER FINANCING SOURCES MEDICAL SERVICES CHARGES FOR SERVICES INTEREST INTERGOVERNMENTAL REVENUE MISCELLANEOUS OTHER FINANCING SOURCES 2015 ADOPTED - OGDEN CITY 2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET REVENUE SUMMARY REPORT 2014 ACTUAL INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY CHARGES FOR SERVICES INTEREST MISCELLANEOUS OTHER FINANCING SOURCES RISK MANAGEMENT CHARGES FOR SERVICES INTEREST MISCELLANEOUS GOMER NICHOLAS NON-EXPENDABLE TRUST INTEREST CEMETERY PERPETUAL CARE EXPENDABLE TRUST CHARGES FOR SERVICES INTEREST OTHER FINANCING SOURCES 2015 ADOPTED 3,383,351 25 439 108,425 3,190,075 2,500 500 219,000 3,248,525 2,500 500 681,500 3,492,240 3,412,075 3,933,025 2,070,484 5,462 42,542 2,067,350 2,000 1,000 1,599,475 2,000 1,000 2,118,488 2,070,350 1,602,475 2,074 150 1,500 2,074 150 1,500 17,935 7,003 9,250 12,000 9,250 12,000 178,750 - 21,250 24,938 MISC. GRANTS & DONATIONS EXPENDABLE TRUST CHARGES FOR SERVICES INTEREST INTERGOVERNMENTAL REVENUE MISCELLANEOUS OTHER FINANCING SOURCES 7,145 (258) 1,988,622 46,145 54,606 MAJOR GRANTS EXPENDABLE TRUST CHARGES FOR SERVICES INTEREST INTERGOVERNMENTAL REVENUE MISCELLANEOUS OTHER FINANCING SOURCES 44 200,000 3,000 3,000 - 13,000 7,000 - - 2,096,260 16,000 10,000 2,270,149 22,504 1,174,936 2,062 2,780,550 2,187,675 - - 6,383,650 94,600 438,275 4,893,975 110,700 1,840,850 3,469,651 9,697,075 9,033,200 139,794,547 164,022,475 159,465,475 - GRAND TOTAL: 2016 BUDGET OGDEN CITY 2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET SUMMARY OF REVENUES AND EXPENDITURES GENERAL FUND 2014 ACTUAL 2015 ADOPTED 2016 BUDGET GENERAL FUND REVENUES CHARGES FOR SERVICES FINES AND FORFEITURES INTEREST INTERGOVERNMENTAL REVENUE LICENSES AND PERMITS MISCELLANEOUS OTHER FINANCING SOURCES TAXES 4,949,273 2,424,407 72,412 3,403,832 2,301,809 1,097,555 125,000 38,091,714 4,803,250 2,720,000 50,000 3,159,575 2,173,500 1,102,575 30,000 39,888,075 3,699,650 2,470,000 80,000 3,485,000 2,434,500 1,109,075 301,375 40,619,850 52,466,002 53,926,975 54,199,450 321,252 1,102,462 1,590,849 1,235,343 819,135 756,737 154,281 537,383 916,226 2,280,844 1,274,567 596,745 544,508 2,219,719 504,700 1,924,300 1,771,816 423,179 6,041,876 325,069 1,792,618 5,776,697 1,556,270 8,559,468 3,048,281 649,931 327,514 141,917 411,836 1,603,880 3,314,951 441,725 1,123,950 1,565,950 1,181,100 720,850 794,400 165,475 593,325 1,008,275 2,269,450 1,292,000 409,325 530,025 915,000 535,750 2,035,400 3,848,850 513,000 6,119,075 368,725 1,591,900 6,063,350 1,729,950 9,148,025 2,924,625 591,375 398,650 133,850 405,750 1,372,650 3,135,200 263,600 1,184,550 1,705,025 1,196,225 881,275 789,900 167,700 563,075 1,038,750 2,260,250 26,600 681,150 476,050 538,800 910,000 609,650 2,173,075 3,599,525 539,450 6,040,675 394,225 1,834,500 5,624,475 1,713,625 9,653,925 3,096,125 615,275 443,025 133,050 415,775 1,519,475 3,110,650 52,524,352 53,926,975 54,199,450 EXPENDITURES ARTS, CULTURE, EVENTS ATTORNEY BUILDING SERVICES BUILDINGS BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT CED ADMINISTRATION COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COMPTROLLER COUNCIL DEBT SERVICE EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT ENGINEERING SERVICES FISCAL OPERATIONS HUMAN RESOURCES INTERFUND TRANSFERS MAYOR MS ADMINISTRATION NON-DEPT MISCELLANEOUS OFD ADMINISTRATION OFD OPERATIONS OFD PREVENTION OPD ADMINISTRATION OPD INVESTIGATIONS OPD SUPPORT SERVICES OPD UNIFORM PARKS PLANNING PUBLIC SERVICES ADMINISTRATION PURCHASING RECORDER RECREATION STREETS 60 MANAGEMENT SERVICES DEPARTMENT Organizational Structure Management Services Department Administration Comptroller Fiscal Operations Fleet and Facilities Human Resources Information Technology Justice Court Recorder Risk Management Non-general operations indicated by underlined text. FUNCTIONS The Department of Management Services serves as the focus for central support services in the areas of financial management, budgeting, purchasing, personnel, risk management, information technology and official recording of City documents, events and records. Additionally, the Justice Court staff reports to this Department for all administrative and day-to-day operations. 73 OGDEN CITY 2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET MANAGEMENT SERVICES GENERAL FUND COMPTROLLER FISCAL OPERATIONS HUMAN RESOURCES MS ADMINISTRATION PURCHASING RECORDERS 563,075 476,050 538,800 2,173,075 133,050 415,775 4,299,825 COMPTROLLER FISCAL OPERATIONS HUMAN RESOURCES MS ADMINISTRATION PURCHASING RECORDERS OVERALL RESPONSIBILITY FLEET AND FACILITIES GENERAL FUND GOMER NICHOLAS NON-EXPENDABLE TRUST CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROJECTS INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY RISK MANAGEMENT 11,249,075 4,299,825 1,500 3,933,025 1,602,475 21,085,900 12,000,000 10,000,000 8,000,000 6,000,000 4,000,000 2,000,000 FLEET AND FACILITIES GENERAL FUND GOMER NICHOLAS NON-EXPENDABLE TRUST 74 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROJECTS INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY RISK MANAGEMENT OGDEN CITY 2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET SUMMARY OF DEPARTMENTAL EXPENDITURES GENERAL FUND 2014 ACTUAL 2015 7-MO ACTUAL 2015 ADOPTED 2016 BUDGET MANAGEMENT SERVICES PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE DATA PROCESSING EQUIPMENT 3,148,439 74,472 615,590 75,164 215,625 27,397 4,156,687 1,775,520 36,561 295,653 29,363 13,964 2,151,061 3,295,825 93,825 603,925 114,100 4,107,675 3,487,975 93,825 603,925 114,100 4,299,825 PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE DATA PROCESSING EQUIPMENT DIVISION SUMMARY MANAGEMENT SERVICES MS ADMINISTRATION HUMAN RESOURCES COMPTROLLER FISCAL OPERATIONS PURCHASING RECORDER 1,924,300 544,508 537,383 596,745 141,917 411,836 4,156,689 1,059,552 279,433 326,337 193,088 76,675 215,977 2,151,062 2,035,400 530,025 593,325 409,325 133,850 405,750 4,107,675 2,173,075 538,800 563,075 476,050 133,050 415,775 4,299,825 FUNDING SOURCES MANAGEMENT SERVICES CARRYOVER CHARGES FOR SERVICES FINES AND FORFEITURES GENERAL REVENUES MISCELLANEOUS REVENUE 15,100 1,477,100 2,615,475 15,100 1,452,100 2,832,625 4,107,675 75 4,299,825 OGDEN CITY 2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET SUMMARY OF EXPENDITURES BY DIVISION GENERAL FUND 2014 ACTUAL 2015 7-MO ACTUAL 2015 ADOPTED 2016 BUDGET MANAGEMENT SERVICES COMPTROLLER PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE DATA PROCESSING FISCAL OPERATIONS PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE DATA PROCESSING HUMAN RESOURCES PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE DATA PROCESSING MS ADMINISTRATION PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE DATA PROCESSING EQUIPMENT PURCHASING PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE DATA PROCESSING 467,703 8,976 33,146 2,158 25,400 301,777 4,455 18,733 1,373 529,875 4,775 52,375 6,300 537,383 326,338 593,325 563,075 475,643 17,568 75,752 307 27,475 147,926 4,573 40,589 321,850 22,225 64,700 550 388,575 22,225 64,700 550 596,745 193,088 409,325 476,050 414,073 14,211 59,239 26,185 30,800 238,826 8,735 18,954 12,918 422,050 10,025 56,275 41,675 430,825 10,025 56,275 41,675 544,508 279,433 530,025 538,800 1,363,565 27,134 407,993 27,535 70,675 27,397 837,948 15,871 187,286 4,483 1,562,625 46,925 392,025 33,825 1,700,300 46,925 392,025 33,825 1,924,299 1,059,552 2,035,400 2,173,075 118,323 1,212 5,258 300 16,825 72,945 525 2,905 300 125,125 1,625 6,725 375 124,325 1,625 6,725 375 141,918 76,675 - - - - - - - - - - - 13,964 - 76 499,625 4,775 52,375 6,300 - 133,850 133,050 OGDEN CITY 2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET SUMMARY OF EXPENDITURES BY DIVISION GENERAL FUND 2014 ACTUAL RECORDER PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE DATA PROCESSING MANAGEMENT SERVICES TOTAL: 2015 7-MO ACTUAL 2015 ADOPTED 2016 BUDGET 309,133 5,371 34,203 18,679 44,450 176,098 2,404 27,186 10,290 334,300 8,250 31,825 31,375 411,836 215,978 405,750 415,775 4,156,689 2,151,064 4,107,675 4,299,825 - 77 344,325 8,250 31,825 31,375 - - NON-DEPARTMENTAL Non-Departmental Fund Buildings Debt Service Interfund Transfers Miscellaneous Non-general operations indicated by underlined text. FUNCTIONS The Non-Departmental Fund includes common costs, which are either not directly related to any one department or are common budgets shared by all entities in the General Fund. 81 OGDEN CITY 2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET NON-DEPARTMENTAL GENERAL FUND BUILDINGS DEBT SERVICE INTERFUND TRANSFERS MISCELLANEOUS 1,196,225 2,260,250 910,000 3,599,525 7,966,000 BUILDINGS DEBT SERVICE INTERFUND TRANSFERS MISCELLANEOUS OVERALL RESPONSIBILITY GENERAL FUND CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROJECTS MISC. GRANTS & DONATIONS EXPENDABLE TRUST TOURISM & MARKETING 7,966,000 384,000 139,000 8,489,000 9,000,000 8,000,000 7,000,000 6,000,000 5,000,000 4,000,000 3,000,000 2,000,000 1,000,000 GENERAL FUND CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROJECTS 82 MISC. GRANTS & DONATIONS EXPENDABLE TRUST TOURISM & MARKETING OGDEN CITY 2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET SUMMARY OF DEPARTMENTAL EXPENDITURES GENERAL FUND 2014 ACTUAL 2015 7-MO ACTUAL 2015 ADOPTED 2016 BUDGET NON-DEPARTMENTAL PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE DATA PROCESSING LAND DEBT SERVICE EQUIPMENT OPERATING TRANSFERS FUND BALANCE/CARRYOVER 98 1,581,187 1,345,873 10,000 2,280,844 70,000 2,219,719 7,507,721 2,554 935,675 867,183 955,075 2,176,885 40,875 533,750 5,511,997 100,000 1,423,125 1,776,800 1,637,075 2,269,450 70,000 915,000 22,950 8,214,400 100,000 1,158,050 1,791,925 1,675,775 2,260,250 70,000 910,000 7,966,000 PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE DATA PROCESSING LAND DEBT SERVICE EQUIPMENT OPERATING TRANSFERS FUND BALANCE/CARRYOVER DIVISION SUMMARY NON-DEPARTMENTAL BUILDINGS INTERFUND TRANSFERS MISCELLANEOUS DEBT SERVICE 1,235,343 2,219,719 1,771,816 2,280,844 7,507,722 841,547 533,750 1,959,816 2,176,885 5,511,998 1,181,100 915,000 3,848,850 2,269,450 8,214,400 1,196,225 910,000 3,599,525 2,260,250 7,966,000 297,000 5,571,950 2,125,550 219,900 357,725 5,227,625 2,112,750 217,900 50,000 FUNDING SOURCES NON-DEPARTMENTAL CHARGES FOR SERVICES GENERAL REVENUES PROPERTY TAXES FOR GO BOND DEBT FINES AND FORFEITURES OTHER FINANCING SOURCES 8,214,400 83 7,966,000 OGDEN CITY 2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET SUMMARY OF EXPENDITURES BY DIVISION GENERAL FUND 2014 ACTUAL 2015 7-MO ACTUAL 2015 ADOPTED 2016 BUDGET NON-DEPARTMENTAL BUILDINGS CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE DEBT SERVICE DEBT SERVICE INTERFUND TRANSFERS OPERATING TRANSFERS MISCELLANEOUS PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE DATA PROCESSING LAND EQUIPMENT FUND BALANCE/CARRYOVER NON-DEPARTMENTAL TOTAL: 22,683 1,212,660 51,880 789,667 1,181,100 1,196,225 1,235,343 841,547 1,181,100 1,196,225 2,280,844 2,176,885 2,269,450 2,260,250 2,280,844 2,176,885 2,269,450 2,260,250 2,219,719 533,750 915,000 910,000 2,219,719 533,750 915,000 910,000 - - - 98 1,558,504 133,213 2,554 883,796 77,516 955,075 10,000 70,000 100,000 100,000 - 1,158,050 595,700 1,675,775 1,423,125 595,700 1,637,075 - 40,875 - - - - - 70,000 22,950 70,000 - 1,771,815 1,959,816 3,848,850 3,599,525 7,507,721 5,511,998 8,214,400 7,966,000 84 OGDEN CITY FY2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET SUMMARY OF STAFFING CHANGES Enterprise Fund Department Medical Services Division Paramedics Position Title Captain position eliminated Enterprise Medical Services Paramedics Enterprise Public Services Refuse Utility Paramedic position eliminated Maintenance Technician positions added consistant with new Healthcare Reform requirements Equipment Operator positions added consistant with new Healthcare Reform requirements Maintenance Technician positions added consistant with new Healthcare Reform requirements Water Production Supervisor position added Backflow Technician I position added Water Plant Tradesman position added Backflow Technician title changed to Backflow Technician II Water Plant Operator position eliminated Water Plant Supervisor position eliminated Development Services Supervisor position eliminated Development Services Technician position eliminated Plan Review/Code Inspector position added Enterprise Enterprise Public Services Public Services Refuse Utility Sewer Utility Enterprise Public Services Water Utility Enterprise Public Services Water Utility Enterprise Public Services Water Utility Enterprise Public Services Water Utility Enterprise Public Services Water Utility Enterprise Public Services Water Utility General Community & Economic Development Community & Economic Development Community & Economic Development Community & Economic Development Community & Economic Development Building Services Building Services General Community & Economic Development Community & Economic Development Community & Economic Development Management Services General Management Services Comptroller General General General General General General General General Building Services Building Services Building Services Building Services Building Services Business Development Administration Management Services Comptroller Code Services Supervisor range increased from 39 to 50 Code Services Officer reclassified to Sr. Code Services Officer (moved from Major Grants Fund) Code Services Officer position added Benchmarked Reclassified Added 3 3 3 2 4 1 1 2 1 2 1 1 1 2 1 2 1 Code Services Collector position added 1 Project Coordinator - Arts Coordinator position added 1 Digital Media Producer position added Finance Manager/City Treasurer title changed to Comptroller Deputy Division Finance Manager title changed to Deputy Comptroller Eliminated Title Change 1 1 1 OGDEN CITY FY2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET SUMMARY OF STAFFING CHANGES Fund General Department Division Management Services Human Resources General Management Services Justice Court General Management Services Treasury General Police Police General Police Police General Police Police General Police Police General General General General General General Internal Service Internal Service Trust Police Public Services Public Services Public Services Police Engineering Public Ways & Parks Benchmarked Position Title Human Resources Manager title changed to Human Resources/Risk Manager Court Liaison range increased from 33 to 38 Fiscal Op Manager/City Treasurer position added Police Officer position eliminated Crime Analyst Position added Animal Services Officer position added Administrative Assistant reclassified to Office Supervisor and range increased from 31 to 38 Senior Office Assistant reclassified to Strike Force Office Technician and range increased from 24 to 30 Added Eliminated Title Change 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Building and Construction Inspector title changed to Construction Inspector (2 other Construction Inspectors moved to Engineering and charged out to Water and Sewer) New Maintenance Technician positions added consistant with new Healthcare Reform requirements 1 5 Recreation Supervisor position added Public Services Recreation - MWC Assistant Recreation Supervisor position added Public Services Recreation - MWC Maintenance Technician position added Management Services Information Technology Customer Account Coordinator reclassified to Senior Customer Account Coordinator Management Services Information Technology Telecommunications Administrator and Security Administrator reclassified to Network Administrators Community & Community Sr. Project Coordinator Economic Development reclassified to Deputy Development Community Development Division Manager Total Reclassified Recreation - MWC 1 1 1 1 2 1 0 11 30 12 4 Position Vacant for Three Months or Longer Title Division BUSINESS LIC ENFORCE OFFICER CASHIER - JUSTICE COURT CASHIER - JUSTICE COURT COMMUNITY SERVICE OFFICER COMMUNITY SERVICE OFFICER COMMUNITY SERVICE OFFICER FIRE CAPTAIN FIRE CAPTAIN FIRE CAPTAIN GIS ANALYST PARAMEDIC PARAMEDIC PARAMEDIC PARKING ENFORCEMENT OFFICER POLICE OFFICER POLICE OFFICER POLICE OFFICER POLICE OFFICER POLICE OFFICER POLICE OFFICER POLICE OFFICER POLICE OFFICER POLICE OFFICER POLICE OFFICER SR. ACCOUNT CLERK Building Services Justice Court Justice Court Police Police Police Fire Fire Fire IT Fire Fire Fire Police Police Police Police Police Police Police Police Police Police Police Comptroller/Treasury Notes Filled by part time employees. Filled by part time employees. Position being eliminated 06-30-15. Position being eliminated 06-30-15. Position being eliminated 06-30-15. Position being eliminated 06-30-15. Position being eliminated 06-30-15. Position being eliminated 06-30-15. Filled by part time employees. Position Vacant for Under Three Months CONSTRUCTION INSPECTOR DEVELOPMENT SERVICES SUPERVISOR SR. ANALYST WATER PLANT OPERATOR WATER PLANT OPERATOR - TRADESMAN Engineering Building Services Comptroller/Treasury Water Water Position advertised and closed. Position being eliminated 06-30-15. Interviews conducted. Interviews conducted. Merit Increase COLA Market Adjustment Benefit Changes Benefit Increase Bountiful Clearfield Davis County 5% 2% 0‐3.5% 2% No 1% No If necessary Few Positions Unknown Unknown No changes Unknown Unknown 4.6% Layton Avg. 3% No No changes No Lehi Logan Murray Ogden City Unknown 3% Unknown 4% Unknown No Unknown No Yes ‐ depends on position Unknown Few Positions Unknown No Unknown No changes Yes No changes Unknown 5% 11.5% 6.6% Orem Unknown No No Yes No Provo 2.5% No No changes 5% 2% Unknown 3% Unknown See note 1‐2% Avg. 2% 1% Unknown 1.8% Unknown See note 1.5% 2% Several positions No Unknown No Unknown Few Positions No Unknown Unknown No changes Unknown No changes No changes No changes No Unknown 3.9% Unknown No 3.9% 12% West Jordan 2.75% & 5% 1% No Unknown Unknown West Valley Avg. 2.5% No No No changes 8% Agency Roy Salt Lake City Sandy South Salt Lake City St. George Tooele City Weber County Notes Merit is given on anniversary date if employee is eligible. Merit increase is based on performance. COLA was in January 2015. 1.6% medical increase & 3% dental increase. Merit based on evaluation score. Medical increase. City will pick up insurance increase. 8% medical & 3.5% dental. Adding PEHP vision option ‐ employee paid 5% for medical ‐ will be shared with employees. 1.6% dental will be passed along to employees. Merit Increase planned January 2016. No traditional plan option – we now offer 2 HDHP/HSA options: $2k/$4k ded with $1k/$2k HSA or $3k/$6k ded with $1500/$3000 HSA Merit increase if not topped out. Market adjustments is 2.5% to those affected. Will not have any information until late May. Medical increase. City will pick up insurance increase. 7.5% increase to cover merit and market adjustments. Medical increase. Merit increase on employees anniversary date. Exempt non‐merit employees were given on 1/2/15. Medical increase 5% & Dental increase 7% effective 1/1/15. Merit increase is 2.75% for general employees & 5% for public safety employees. Merit increase for public employees effective date is unknown until approval. Police and Fire, if approved, is on anniversary date. Medical increase is 8%. Stout, Lisa Subject: FW: Halogen / Merit Increase timeline and Criteria From: Choate, Shawn Sent: Tuesday, April 21, 2015 10:18 AM To: Ashment, Mike; Buxton, Gregg; Christopulos, Tom; Johnson, Mark; Lowder, Jay; Mathieu, Mike; Williams, Gary; Anderson, Justin; Bauman, Eric; Brenkman, Todd; Bride, Terrence; Bridge, Edd; Brookins, Richard; Brown, Kevin; Brown, Mara; Burdett, Gregory; Carr, Paula; Choate, Shawn; Cook, Bill; Cooper, Brandon; Fishburn, Steve; Froerer, Buck; Greiner, Jon; Hansen, Tracy; Harvey, John; Huffaker, Perry; Johnson, Laurie; Junk, Mike; Moffett, Kenton; Montgomery, Greg; Ogden, Ward; Schwenk, Matt; Scothern, Greg; Stratford, Mark; Tarwater, Wayne; Wilkinson, Blake; Young, Eric Cc: Briskey, Heather; Judkins, Leslie; Olmedo, Heidi; Simpson, Trudi; Workman, Alison Subject: Halogen / Merit Increase timeline and Criteria Good Morning, Below is the Halogen and Merit Increase timeline and criteria. Please let me know if you have questions. Halogen Closes June 6th By June 12th – Each Director will have a Final report regarding each Department’s breakdown (score = increase amount). ALL evaluations must be complete and the process closed in order for me to run this report. Police: Score of 2 or higher = 4% increase. If an employee receives less than a 2, they do not receive an increase. Fire: Score of 2 or higher = 4% increase with compression correction. If an employee receives less than a 2, they do not receive an increase. Management Services: Score of 2 or higher = 4% increase. If an employee receives less than a 2, they do not receive an increase. Legal: Evaluation Score determines Merit Increase CED: Evaluation Score determines Merit Increase Public Services: Evaluation Score determines Merit Increase By June 19, 2015 – Personnel Action forms created and distributed to employees. July 10, 2015 – Pay check with all changes (Pay‐period June 20 – July 3). This year’s increase is a 4% Merit. Employee’s at the top or above their range will receive the 4% in the form of a one‐time bonus, if they meet the criteria set by the department director. Employees hired into a full time position after January 1, 2015 are not eligible for a Merit increase. Employees promoted or transferred from a full time position into a full time position are eligible for a merit increase assuming they were hired prior to January 1st and meet the evaluation criteria. Employees active in Eden as of the beginning date of the pay period (June 20th) are eligible for the pay increase assuming they were hired prior to January 1st and meet the evaluation criteria. All employees active in Eden as of April 8th were loaded into Halogen for an evaluation. Even if they aren’t eligible for an increase, they should receive the feedback in the review. Order of increases on paycheck: 1 – Reclass increases 1 2 – Merit Increase Divisions that are planning on providing an increase for part time staff need to contact Leslie to coordinate. Requests must be turned in to Leslie by June 19th. Shawn Choate, PHR Human Resource / Risk Manager, Ogden City Corporation 2549 Washington Blvd., Ogden, Utah 84401 T: 801.629.8731 | F: 801‐629.8735 [email protected] Director, Utah Human Resource State Council UtahSHRM.org 2 Schedule of Transfers FY2016 Tentative Budget Transfer To GF 1000-1-84001 1000-1-84003 RDA 3140-2-84000 CIP 4100-1-84001 4100-1-84004 4100-1-84006 Airport 5130-1-84001 5130-1-84002 Golf 5150-1-8400* BDO 5180-1-84001 Fleet/Facilities 6100-1-84002 IT 6120-1-84004 Major Grants 7130-1-84000 Other * Transfer From GF 1000-1-09-300200-41006 1000-1-09-300200-41005 1000-1-09-300200-41016 1000-1-09-300200-41004 1000-1-09-300200-41017 - 13,125 200,000 700,000 10,000 2,345,875 1,390,025 500,000 1,500 6,030,000 13,125 11,190,525 13,125 200,000 650,000 50,000 - 10,000 CIP 4100-1-09-300200-41000 BDO 5181-1-09-550103-4100* 5181-1-09-550103-41002 5181-1-09-550103-41004 5181-1-09-700100-52000 301,375 202,000 150,000 492,500 1,200,000 1,390,025 500,000 Medical 5200-1-09-400500-4100* 5200-1-09-400500-41000 - Fleet 6100-1-09-200901-41007 Gomer Nicholas 7100-1-09-200401-41000 - 1,500 RDA 660,000 Total 660,000 5,220,000 301,375 500,000 1,500 200,000 1,390,025 650,000 50,000 202,000 5,220,000 150,000 150,000 502,500 1,350,000 BDO LEASE REVENUE FUNDS PROPOSED BUDGET Accumulated Full year Fund Balance as of June 30, 2014 Quality Neighborhoods Funding FY 2016 Budget $ 4,235,877 $ (1,200,000) Funds Available $ 3,035,877 CBD Mall District for Debt Service Coverage/Reserve $ (500,000) Balance of Lease Revenue for Distribution $ 2,535,877 Other CIP Total Available $ 2,851,056 Balance Available TrackLine Business Park Infrastructure Curb, Gutter and Sidewalk Replacement ‐ City Curb, Gutter and Sidewalk Replacement ‐ 50/50 Street Construction General Facilities Improvements ($100K PSB) City Owned Parking Lot Improvements Irrigation System Replacement at Mt. Ogden (Golf) Gomer Nicholas Trust General Park Improvements ‐ Comm Plan Lester Repair Asphalt Ball Park Infield Grandview Restooms ‐ RAMP & Match NON ‐ CIP Union Station ‐ Site Plan Funding Facilities ‐ Underfunded Ongoing Sheltering at MWC & Golden Hours LAN/Network EOC ‐ Phones/Network EN039 Vehicular Bridge Upgrades ‐ Study FL008 UCA Radio Upgrades ‐ Non‐Lease IT001 Unified Communication System (Phase II) IT009 ERP Replacement RG053 Recreation Maintenance Funding ‐ Class Capital or B & C Road 2016 RAMP Funding Minimum for Capital Operations Funds, Interest $ 1,267,939 $ 1,267,939 $ 211,500 $ 103,679 $ 126,794 $ (126,794) $ ‐ $ ‐ $ 1,394,732 $ 1,141,145 $ 211,500 $ 103,679 50% split of Lease Revenue for Distribution Minimum for Community Plan Projects (10%) CD104 EN004A EN004B EN006 FL007 GC030 GF032 PK071 PK124 PY006 RG068 RM016 Balance for Proposed $ 250,000 $ 367,020 $ 40,000 $ 555,555 $ 883,750 $ 151,500 $ 202,000 $ 1,500 $ 151,500 $ 30,300 $ 120,202 $ 30,000 Total $ 8,789,960 Project Total $ 2,851,056 $ ‐ $ 2,851,056 $ ‐ Funded $ 250,000 $ 327,020 $ 40,000 $ 167,194 $ 232,500 $ 151,500 $ 202,000 $ 210,000 $ 1,500 $ 151,500 $ 30,300 $ 20,000 $ 20,000 $ 103,679 $ 1,592,014 $ ‐ $ 211,500 $ 103,679 $ 100,000 $ 150,000 $ 40,000 $ 40,000 $ 5,000 $ 101,010 $ 1,600,000 $ 210,080 $ 779,383 $ 35,353 Total $ 3,575,470 $ ‐ $ 50,000 $ 150,000 $ 20,000 $ 40,000 $ 2,500 $ 101,010 $ 95,000 $ 100,000 $ 350,000 $ 35,353 $ 943,863 $ ‐ $ ‐ Total $ 250,000 $ 327,020 $ 40,000 $ 377,194 $ 232,500 $ 151,500 $ 202,000 $ 1,500 $ 151,500 $ 30,300 $ 20,000 $ 123,679 $ 1,907,193 $ 50,000 $ 150,000 $ 20,000 $ 40,000 $ 2,500 $ 101,010 $ 95,000 $ 100,000 $ 350,000 $ 35,353 $ 943,863 $ 2,851,056 FY2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET MANAGEMENT SERVICES Information Technology - Strategic Plan - Equipment PURPOSE OF WORK SESSION: Executive Summary Background To review the FY2016 IT Strategic Plan, the Action Plan for the Management Study, and Tentative FY15 Budget The Administration will review the FY2016 IT Strategic Plan, the progress on the action plan outlined in the Management Study, and the Tentative FY2016 Budget for the IT Division. September 3, 2013 The Council adopted Resolution 2013-21 authorizing a contract with Plant & Moran to conduct a Management and Operations Study of Ogden City’s IT Division. A previous study had been completed in April of 2004. Given the significant advances in technology and changes in City operations, both the Administration and Council thought it would be beneficial to review existing policies and procedures to identify areas of improvement. The Management and Operations Study was completed in February 2014. IT Strategic Plan The IT Division initially issued a strategic plan in FY2004. An update to this plan has been submitted annually. A copy of the FY2016 Plan is attached. Ogden City Council Work Session: May 21, 2015 1 Budget Summary Information Technology Adopted FY2015 Proposed FY2016 Amount Change % Change IT Operations IT Communications IT GIS IT Cable TV Network Total $2,497,375 $531,350 $348,350 $35,000 $3,412,075 $2,985,425 $527,700 $384,900 $35,000 $3,933,025 $488,050 19.54% ($3,650) -0.69% $36,550 10.49% -00.00% $520,950 15.27% IT Internal Service Fund Changes The IT Division operates as an Internal Service Fund. Significant budget expenditures line items for the IT Division are as follows: Proposed 4% Merit (1% to Base Pay) No City-paid retirement benefit increases Additional funds for ERP replacement ($350,000) Additional funds for other equipment ($142,500) Questions 1. Please review the IT Strategic Plan. 2. Please review the Audit Action Plan and discuss the significant accomplishments for FY2015 and the most important issues to be addressed in the upcoming year. 3. Please review the process and plan for the ERP replacement. ________________________________________________________________________ Council Staff Contact: Janene Eller-Smith (801) 629-8165 Ogden City Council Work Session: May 21, 2015 2 Information Technology Strategic Master Plan FY 2016 Information Technology Strategic Master Plan March 2015 Purpose of Strategic Master Plan Promote order, alignment, prioritization, efficiency, and partnerships in technology implementations Describe clear annual objectives for the I.T. Division and for City technology advancement Describe multi-year software, hardware, and budget objectives Optimize technology investments Ensure hardware and software compatibility among City systems Ensure the security of the City’s data, networks, and infrastructure City Technology Mission Statement Provide a vibrant infrastructure, secure data and networks, robust information sharing and analysis tools, and software applications that are reliable, long term, and financially viable and secure to support City goals and strategic directions by Establishing a reliable and scalable technology infrastructure Prudently integrating “Cloud” hardware and software solutions Evaluating software solutions on a Buy then Build basis Providing a user-friendly data sharing infrastructure Implementing consumer (user) selected and managed solutions Promoting mobile computing and geographical solutions Researching leading edge technologies Prioritizing projects City Technology Policies 1400 – Project Development 1410 – Hardware and Software Purchasing 1420 – Cell Phones/Stipend 1430 – Software and Electronic Data 1450 – Computer and Telecommunications Hardware and Physical Security 1460 – Hardware/Software Support and Hardware Tiering 1470 – City Technology Governance Internal I.T. Policies IT-8 Naming of City-Owned Devices IT-9 Device and Software Maintenance Upgrade Schedule IT-10 Quoting and Purchasing IT Equipment and Software IT-11 City Information Access IT-12 Public Safety Vehicles IT-1 Customer Service IT-2 Electronic Data Removal from Devices IT-3 Sale of Surplus Equipment IT-4 Customer Support Procedures IT-5 Personal Appearance IT-6 Project Governance and Development IT-7 Approved IT Equipment Purchase by Departments 2 Information Technology Strategic Master Plan March 2015 Steering and User Liaison Committees I.T. Steering Committee guides and approves City technology planning and direction establishes and approves City technology financial initiatives and budgets approves and prioritizes City technology projects and initiatives approves and enforces City technology governance including ROI, policies, and standards Projects Review Committee reviews and scores City technology projects based on established technology governance, selection criteria, ROI, standards and policies, and Administrative objectives recommends project rankings and priorities to I.T. Steering Committee G.I.S. Committee reviews and recommends City G.I.S. technology, planning, direction, and standards promotes use of G.I.S. technology in City projects assists project teams with G.I.S. solutions and implementations Web Committee reviews and recommends City web site and social media technology, planning, direction, and standards promotes use of web sites and social media technology in City projects acts as liaison between departments and web site managers assists project teams with web site and social media solutions and implementations 3 Information Technology Strategic Master Plan March 2015 City Technology and Project Approval Governance Model All City technology efforts and activities shall flow through the above governance methodology. City technology activities listed on the right side of the model are proposed, initiated, and requested by department staffs partnered with central I.T. staff, as indicated on the bottom left side of the model. Moving up the left side of the model, proposed technology initiatives are reviewed by I.T. management for technical integrity and by User Liaison Committees for functional correctness, priority, and recommendation up. The I.T. Steering Committee, and Mayor/CAO if needed, approve all City technology proposals. 4 Information Technology Strategic Master Plan March 2015 I.T. Goals/Accomplishments FY 2015 FY15 Goal: Implement I.T. Assessment Recommendations FY15 I.T. Assessment Accomplishments I.T. STRATEGIC GOAL #1 Ensure that the City’s future technology investments and IT Services are aligned and prioritized in accordance with City management and Council. Action #1 - Establish a standard project initiation protocol Standard project initiation protocol established Project Request form enhanced to include ROI, priority, and other criteria Projects properly scoped so that timelines are set correctly Project governance model and approval process established Projects and project documentation now sized accordingly for the amount of money being spent and the time allocated to it Streamlined process created for requesting small and/or urgent projects Action #2 - Create a Project Portfolio Management Process Fully functional project tracking tool developed Project status list published on Intranet for user review Business case for each project developed using set of fifteen criteria questions including ROI, urgency, scope of use Long term costs and life expectancy now included in project scopes Action #3 - Create and routinely update an annual strategic technology plan Annual IT Strategic Plan created on annual basis and presented to City Administration and City Council City Operational Technology Protocol developed describing Technology roles and responsibilities for central IT and decentralized departments users Formal IT Liaison program implemented with three user led technology committees; Projects Review Committee, Web Committee, and GIS Committee In conjunction with the Annual Strategic Plan all IT job descriptions, staffing needs, and staffing duties are reviewed and recommendations for change submitted to the IT Steering Committee Service level agreements (Management Control Agreements) between IT and all departments were implemented including a Management Control Agreement between IT and OPD focusing on criminal justice responsibilities Multi-year hardware desktop replacement schedule approved and published annually Multi-year hardware infrastructure hardware replacement schedule approved and published annually Cost of Services Model provided in assessment was reviewed and services to be deleted, modified, and added were identified Multi-year IT budget projection created and submitted annually IT provided City Council with IT Assessment Action Plan and with periodic updates as requested I.T. STRATEGIC GOAL #2 Ensure that the City optimizes the use of its IT investment Action #1 - Enhance the current IT Steering Committee 5 Information Technology Strategic Master Plan March 2015 The I.T. Steering Committee was established in 2012. Its membership has been expanded to include all department directors. Its purpose and role in technology governance has been defined, approved, and implemented. Philosophical view of IT is shifting from one of Cost Control toward one of Strategic Investment City IT Governance model and procedures implemented IT and Comptrollers implemented gradual move away from charging department IT general fund IT budget accounts for IT services Membership of IT Steering Committee was increased to include all department directors Annual project submission to correspond with annual budgeting implemented Action #2 - Establish a technology review process that considers Return on Investment Technology review process is performed first by I.T. and then by the Projects Review Committee. Project prioritization now based on five areas of criteria; Risk, Alignment, Urgency, Impact, and Financial including ROI and expected life of hardware/software Action #3 - Integrate Technology Planning and Budgeting Processes The current standard of buying software versus building software was reviewed and a recommendation given to the I.T. Steering Committee to continue with the current standard and not implement in-house software development. The recommendation was approved. The City will continue to contract for software services when such software cannot be purchased. A health check of the Net Motion server and software was performed to see if it met best practices. Needed adjustments were completed. The TMobile air card problems were addressed by moving all air cards to Verizon as of November 2014. Police and Fire now use the same vendor for air cards resulting in consistent coverage. A Microsoft funded SharePoint test application was created to test and demo SharePoint capability. SharePoint demos were provided to the three liaison user committees and to the I.T. Steering Committee for the purpose of evaluation SharePoint as a City data sharing tool. A SharePoint proposal was presented to the ITSC in August 2014. It was not approved. A second proposal was presented in October 2014 and it was approved by the ITSC. The approved implementation consisted of a Departmental cloud based SharePoint under an I.T. umbrella. Each department is responsible for funding their own licenses. A city-wide SharePoint implementation will be discussed during FY16. The City continues its strategy of using server virtualization and is currently 80% virtualized. All new server requests are first evaluated for virtual server fit. A server replacement funding request was made for the FY16 and FY17 budgets. It is anticipated these will be approved. A Wireless infrastructure needs assessment was performed and wireless capability expanded to all City infrastructure locations. An assessment of City data storage (SAN) capability was performed, a SAN replacement schedule proposed and funded, and needed SAN upgrades completed. Explore the possibility of more fully using the benefits that are provided by the Enterprise Agreement. Some of the products that are included are: Online email Spam filtering, SharePoint Team Licenses, Forefront desktop and server virus protection, and System Center Configuration Manger. There are additional products that would be available if the desktop licensing were to be upgraded to the “Enhanced” level 6 Information Technology Strategic Master Plan March 2015 makes advanced SharePoint Licensing, Exchange Voice Licenses, and Excel Forms functionality. Comparison assessment of available Microsoft products is ongoing with the goal of replacing non-Microsoft products with their Microsoft equivalent thus reducing costs. Assessments already completed are Lync and SharePoint. Office 365, Forefront, and System Center are scheduled in the future. Action #4 - Invest in adequate training Cross training between Network Administrator and Telecommunications Administrator has been accomplished and is ongoing. Cross training among GIS staff has been accomplished and is ongoing. Cross training among Customer Support staff has been accomplished and is ongoing. Cross training among Database Administrators is currently in process. IT met with HR and evaluated training opportunities for IT staff in both technical and non-technical courses. An IT training plan was proposed and approved and will be prepared annually. Customer service training for IT staff is ongoing. Basic Crystal report training was provided to CACs. Advanced Crystal report training was provided to Technical Support II and III staff. The ITSC approved continuing with the City standard which assigns user departments as first line support for functional software needs with vendors and I.T. as secondary support. I.T. provides some training to IT staff regarding key user software applications on an ongoing basis. Training and internal policies and procedures have been accomplished to improve communication between IT staff in handling support issues. I.T. dress policies were reviewed and updated. I.T. has been trained to check in with departments prior to performing on site support. I.T. has moved to a bi-monthly schedule for performing system updates. A mobility criteria has been added to the project request form. I.T. STRATEGIC GOAL #3 Build upon the Customer Service framework to create deeper Partnerships with major technology users. Establish, communicate and implement a framework of standards, policies, and procedures that results in a consistent methodology for the achievement of operational excellence. Action #1 - Develop a formal IT liaison program. Three Liaison committees with representatives from each department are created, approved, and functioning. They are the Projects Review Committee, GIS Committee, and Web Committee and have roles in reviewing, scoring, and prioritizing projects, reviewing and recommending technology direction and standards, promoting the use of web and GIS technology, and assisting users with project implementations. Action #2 - Establish consistent policies and procedures as part of the development and deployment of technology-based solutions Technology policies are updated, approved, and implemented. I.T. will enforce the policies. Exceptions to the policy will be handled by the I.T. Steering Committee The Data Security Policy has been reviewed and enhanced. A requirement to change user passwords every 90 days is implemented. Acceptable Use, Internet, and Email Policies are contained within the Administration and Employee Handbook. 7 Information Technology Strategic Master Plan March 2015 Policies have been published to all users and are located on the City’s intranet. Additionally, I.T. has communicated policy, standard, and procedure updates to users via email and Division Manager presentations. Action #3 - Expand the skillset of the IT staff to include project management best practices and IT vendor management techniques I.T. will train its CAC staff on vendor management in spring 2015. CAC staff were trained in project management best practices and one has acquired PMP certification with the others to follow. I.T. STRATEGIC GOAL #4 Ensure that the investments in technology and staffing are occurring in the correct areas and to enable better customer service. Action #1 - Telephone System Project funded and completed to upgrade vulnerable parts of the telephone system. Action #2 – Security An Interagency and Management Control Agreement was established between I.T. and Police to assure compliance with FBI security requirements. Action #3 - Disaster Recovery I.T. is working with the EOC to begin a disaster recovery project for FY16. Action #4 - Enterprise Applications In conjunction with the ERP and Cartegraph OMS projects, I.T. will identify where data entry duplication exists and propose projects to resolve the issue. In conjunction with the ERP project, IT will identify all of the current and potential future data interfaces so they may be incorporated. As requests for new software applications are proposed, I.T. looks to existing City software first to see if it will satisfy the need. I.T. encourages technology discussions between business units through the use of the liaison committees. Fire is moved off of FDM and onto ImageTrend. A Contract Management system will be reviewed as part of the ERP project. A third party assessment of department needs and wants has been performed. Additional assessments will be performed as part of the ERP RFP build. Department users and key stakeholders are engaged in the assessments I.T. coordinates training on key user applications. Prior to replacing functionality of an existing enterprise application, users must ensure that functionality doesn’t already exist or can be better utilized by the current solution. Data entry of geocoded data has been pushed to users and off of GIS staff. A GIS Liaison Committee is established and functioning. Action # 5 – Staffing An assessment of the purposing and positioning of GIS within the City is being performed by the GIS Committee with a recommendation forthcoming. I.T. proposed the addition of two full time help desk positions but was turned down. Action #6 – Collaboration I.T. works with Weber State University for recruiting I.T. staff. 8 Information Technology Strategic Master Plan March 2015 I.T. Goals FY 2016 Implement remaining I.T. Assessment recommendations I.T. STRATEGIC GOALS #1 and #2 Ensure that the City’s future technology investments and IT Services are aligned and prioritized in accordance with City management and Council. And, ensure that the City optimizes the use of its IT investment Implement additional measures with Comptrollers and Administration to continue shift towards I.T. as a strategic investment. Perform a LanDesk and System Configuration Manager product comparison to comparative Microsoft tools and make a recommendation. Perform an e-Business capability evaluation in conjunction with the ERP project to determine where e-Business applications would fit within the City. Perform an enterprise comparison of Network Electronics to its Microsoft equivalent, taking local available skillsets into consideration, and make a recommendation to the IT Steering Committee. Create, approve, fund, and annually test a disaster recovery plan. Implement Forefront and System Center software. Compare current Microsoft Exchange software to Microsoft Office 365 software and make a recommendation to the I.T. Steering Committee. Review and catalog all Crystal Reports reports. Review and catalog all CarteGraph and SharePoint reports. Research and implement report training opportunities for I.T and user staff. Empower users to use reporting tools. I.T. STRATEGIC GOAL #3 Build upon the Customer Service framework to create deeper Partnerships with major technology users. Establish, communicate and implement a framework of standards, policies, and procedures that results in a consistent methodology for the achievement of operational excellence. Review and enhance data security policies to meet business processes. Establish a website content management policy (Web User Committee). I.T. STRATEGIC GOAL #4 Ensure that the investments in technology and staffing are occurring in the correct areas and to enable better customer service. Create, approve, fund, and annually test a disaster recovery plan. Identify areas of data duplication and propose projects to resolve (in conjunction with ERP project). Indentify all current and potential future data interfaces and propose solutions for interfacing and integrating data across applications. Work with the Legal Department to propose a direction for legal software at the City (to include Fortis and Worldox). As part of the ERP replacement project, identify and propose a city-wide project management collaboration tool, including the evaluation of Basecamp and SharePoint. Work with Legal and Recorders to propose resolutions to City contract management issues. Continue to assist departments with software training needs. Consider a projects/grants module when replacing the ERP. 9 Information Technology Strategic Master Plan March 2015 Propose streamlining HR and Financial processes using paperless technology. As part of the ERP replacement study, identify and propose a city-wide document management system. Work with the GIS Liaison Committee to identify options for managing external utility data. Review potential mobile data entry options for GIS data entry. Review Airport business needs and identify what can be met with GIS technology. Review positioning and purposing of GIS staff and make proposal. Streamline and accomplish FY17 annual project submissions Review and revise annual project submission process Begin annual submission process well ahead of September submission deadline Promote City-wide data security awareness, prevention, and detection Provide quarterly City-wide security training Complete defined security and disaster recovery projects Improve Internal Communications Teach, promote, and monitor positive and respectful face-to-face communication to I.T. staff Improve frequency and quality of internal project team meetings Improve City Hardware infrastructure Get City commitment to fund a multi-year hardware tiering plan Provide meaningful training to IT staff Increase training funds in FY16 budget Create FY16 staff training plan 10 Information Technology Strategic Master Plan March 2015 I.T. Financials Budgets and Revenues The proposed FY16 budget is slightly less that the FY15 adopted budget. FY16 and future year budget and expenditures will not exceed expected revenues. I.T. Budget History 5000000 4500000 4000000 3500000 3000000 2500000 2000000 1500000 1000000 500000 0 FY 08 FY 09 FY 10 Budget FY 11 FY 12 Expenses FY 13 FY 14 FY 15 FY16 Revenues I.T Fund Balance I.T. has a goal to completely eliminate its Fund Balance deficit as of June 30, 2015. 11 Information Technology Strategic Master Plan March 2015 Citywide Software/Hardware Upgrade Plan Enterprise Software Replacement – Proposed Schedule Software Worldox (Doc Mgmt) Sportsman/Sportsite Fortis (Doc Mgmt) Chameleon (Animal License) Code Enforcement Versadex (P.S. Doc Mgmt) Committee Mgmt Good Landlord Halogen (Perf. Appraisal) Sitecore (Content Mgmt) Ogdencity.com Refresh Eden Financials AR/AP/GL/CM/Bill Purchasing Bid Management Project/Grant Accounting Budget Development & Mgmnt Contract Management HR/App Track/Prof Dev Payroll/Emp Self Serv/Exp Reim Parcels/Permits/Inspections Community Development Work Orders (Cartgrph replace) Fleet Invent. (Cartgrph replace) Fleet & Facilities (Cartgrph rep) Business Licensing Parking Ticket Mgmnt & Collect Code Enforcement (Iworq rep) Utility Billing Fixed Assets Cashiering (Quadrant replace) Year FY15 FY15/16 FY16 FY16 FY17 FY?? FY?? FY16 – 19 FY16 FY16 FY16 FY16 FY16 FY16 FY17 FY17 FY17 FY17 FY17-18 FY17-18 FY17-18 FY18 FY18 FY18 FY18 FY18 FY18 12 Notes Ongoing upgrades Ongoing upgrades Ongoing upgrades Ongoing upgrades - Weber County manages Iworq – completion January 2015 Funded by Weber Dispatch Consortium $20k estimated replacement cost Project being initiated now Part of ERP replacement Web Site Refresh project Web Site Refresh project $60k - $100k Part of ERP replacement Part of ERP replacement Part of ERP replacement Part of ERP replacement Part of ERP replacement Part of ERP replacement Part of ERP replacement Part of ERP replacement Part of ERP replacement Part of ERP replacement Part of ERP replacement Part of ERP replacement Part of ERP replacement Part of ERP replacement Part of ERP replacement Part of ERP replacement Part of ERP replacement Part of ERP replacement Part of ERP replacement Information Technology Strategic Master Plan March 2015 Internally Developed Software Replacement – Proposed Schedule Software Pay For Performance Parcels/Permits Good Landlord Code Enforcement Business License Business License on-line Year FY17 FY17-18 FY16 FY15 FY18/FY19 FY18/FY19 Cost Potentially part of ERP project Potentially part of ERP project FY16 project (Requires contract programming) iWorq implemented Potentially part of ERP project Potentially part of ERP project The City has initiated a project to replace the current EDEN ERP software which has served the City for over sixteen years but is now inadequate. Weber Dispatch has intiated a project to replace its Public Safety software. Thus, most City business processes and functionalities may be improved through implementation of newer and better ERP and Public Safety software over the next several years. As part of the ERP replacement project the City, with its ERP consultant, has defined existing manual business processes and has initiated a project to review, eliminate, and/or improve these processes prior to implementation of new ERP software. 13 Information Technology Strategic Master Plan March 2015 Hardware Replacement (tiering) – Proposed Schedule Desktop, Laptop, Mobile, and Printer tiering is scheduled to be funded at 50% of normal through FY2020 thus stretching the desired replacement schedule to more than a four year rotation. I.T. provides each department with replacement recommendations. However, departments have ultimate say in what equipment is replaced and when it is replaced, based on the allowable budget. The proposed FY16 Infrastructure Hardware Replacement of $161,000 (see figure 1) is not fully funded in the proposed FY16 budget. Hardware Desk Top/Lap Top Tiering inc. Pads/Tablets/Printers Data Center HVAC (2) PBX Servers/Gateways (18) PBX Phones (491) Servers Physical (32) Servers Virtual (159) Network Firewall/Filter (6) Wireless AP (70) Data Storage (179 tb) Date Storage Remote (6 tb) Switches/Routers (77) Total (not inc. tiering) FY15 FY16 FY17 FY18 FY19 FY20 70k 70k 70k 70k 70k 70k 250k 50k 30k 121k 30k 30k 50k 15k 22k 72k 5k 99k 10k 15k 15k 20k 20k 10k 161k 14 30k 100k 175k 85k 185k 315k 45k Information Technology Strategic Master Plan March 2015 I.T. Staffing Plan The number of full time staffing positions for FY 2016 remains at the FY 2015 level of fourteen. We proposed the following position reclassifications in the FY 2016 budget, Security Administrator and Telecommunications Administrator positions be reclassified as Network Administrator positions because they perform the same functions Customer Account Coordinator Range 43 position be reclassified equal to the Customer Account Coordinator Range 50 position because they perform the same functions (the Range 43 position was a left over Programmer position that was used to hire a second Customer Account Coordinator in FY13) Position (Full-Time) Range 2015 2016 I.T. Manager DIV 1 1 Operations Supervisor 51 1 1 Customer Acct Supervisor 51 1 1 Customer Acct Coordinator 50 1 2 Database Administrator 50 1 1 Network Administrator 50 Security Administrator 49 1 Telecom. Administrator 48 1 Sr. GIS Project Coordinator 48 1 Customer Acct Coordinator 43 1 Customer Support Supervisor 43 1 1 Customer Support Tech III 41 2 2 2 1 GIS Analyst 38 1 1 Cust. Support Technician II 33 1 1 Division Full-Time Totals 14 14 Division Part-Time Totals 5 7 Division All Position Totals 19 21 15 Information Technology Strategic Master Plan March 2015 Companion documents to this Strategic Plan The following documents supplement the I.T. Strategic Plan. To access these documents click on the hyperlinks attached to each document title. I.T. Services Catalog Technical Standards and Operational Protocol City Technology Policies 1400, 1410, 1420, 1430, 1440, 1450, 1460, and 1470 Department Technology Master Plans Quotes from Industry Experts Regarding I.T and Enterprise Governance 16 OGDEN CITY FY2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET SUMMARY OF STAFFING CHANGES Enterprise Fund Department Medical Services Division Paramedics Position Title Captain position eliminated Enterprise Medical Services Paramedics Enterprise Public Services Refuse Utility Paramedic position eliminated Maintenance Technician positions added consistant with new Healthcare Reform requirements Equipment Operator positions added consistant with new Healthcare Reform requirements Maintenance Technician positions added consistant with new Healthcare Reform requirements Water Production Supervisor position added Backflow Technician I position added Water Plant Tradesman position added Backflow Technician title changed to Backflow Technician II Water Plant Operator position eliminated Water Plant Supervisor position eliminated Development Services Supervisor position eliminated Development Services Technician position eliminated Plan Review/Code Inspector position added Enterprise Enterprise Public Services Public Services Refuse Utility Sewer Utility Enterprise Public Services Water Utility Enterprise Public Services Water Utility Enterprise Public Services Water Utility Enterprise Public Services Water Utility Enterprise Public Services Water Utility Enterprise Public Services Water Utility General Community & Economic Development Community & Economic Development Community & Economic Development Community & Economic Development Community & Economic Development Building Services Building Services General Community & Economic Development Community & Economic Development Community & Economic Development Management Services General Management Services Comptroller General General General General General General General General Building Services Building Services Building Services Building Services Building Services Business Development Administration Management Services Comptroller Code Services Supervisor range increased from 39 to 50 Code Services Officer reclassified to Sr. Code Services Officer (moved from Major Grants Fund) Code Services Officer position added Benchmarked Reclassified Added 3 3 3 2 4 1 1 2 1 2 1 1 1 2 1 2 1 Code Services Collector position added 1 Project Coordinator - Arts Coordinator position added 1 Digital Media Producer position added Finance Manager/City Treasurer title changed to Comptroller Deputy Division Finance Manager title changed to Deputy Comptroller Eliminated Title Change 1 1 1 OGDEN CITY FY2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET SUMMARY OF STAFFING CHANGES Fund General Department Division Management Services Human Resources General Management Services Justice Court General Management Services Treasury General Police Police General Police Police General Police Police General Police Police General General General General General General Internal Service Internal Service Trust Police Public Services Public Services Public Services Police Engineering Public Ways & Parks Benchmarked Position Title Human Resources Manager title changed to Human Resources/Risk Manager Court Liaison range increased from 33 to 38 Fiscal Op Manager/City Treasurer position added Police Officer position eliminated Crime Analyst Position added Animal Services Officer position added Administrative Assistant reclassified to Office Supervisor and range increased from 31 to 38 Senior Office Assistant reclassified to Strike Force Office Technician and range increased from 24 to 30 Added Eliminated Title Change 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Building and Construction Inspector title changed to Construction Inspector (2 other Construction Inspectors moved to Engineering and charged out to Water and Sewer) New Maintenance Technician positions added consistant with new Healthcare Reform requirements 1 5 Recreation Supervisor position added Public Services Recreation - MWC Assistant Recreation Supervisor position added Public Services Recreation - MWC Maintenance Technician position added Management Services Information Technology Customer Account Coordinator reclassified to Senior Customer Account Coordinator Management Services Information Technology Telecommunications Administrator and Security Administrator reclassified to Network Administrators Community & Community Sr. Project Coordinator Economic Development reclassified to Deputy Development Community Development Division Manager Total Reclassified Recreation - MWC 1 1 1 1 2 1 0 11 30 12 4 INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY Organizational Structure Information Technology Cable TV Network Communications GIS IT Operations Non-general operations indicated by underlined text. FUNCTIONS The Information Technology Internal Service fund is used to account for the financing of technology related goods or services provided by the IT Division to other departments on a breakeven or cost reimbursement basis. The IT fund accounts for the City’s use of technology, system networks, telecommunications, GIS, software applications, cell phones, and Channel 17 cable TV network. Costs are charged to the departments on an estimated usage basis. 176 OGDEN CITY 2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET SUMMARY OF REVENUES AND EXPENDITURES INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY 2014 ACTUAL 2015 ADOPTED 2016 BUDGET INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY REVENUES CHARGES FOR SERVICES INTEREST MISCELLANEOUS OTHER FINANCING SOURCES 3,383,351 25 439 108,425 3,190,075 2,500 500 219,000 3,248,525 2,500 500 681,500 3,492,240 3,412,075 3,933,025 3,343,388 3,412,075 3,933,025 3,343,388 3,412,075 3,933,025 EXPENDITURES IT - INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY 177 OGDEN CITY 2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET FISCAL YEAR REVENUE BUDGET INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY 2014 ACTUAL 2015 7-MO ACTUAL 2015 ADOPTED 2016 BUDGET CHARGES FOR SERVICES OPERATIONS 3,383,351 2,279,897 3,190,075 3,248,525 Operating Revenues result from providing data processing and communication services to other City Departments. 3,383,351 2,279,897 3,190,075 3,248,525 INTEREST GENERAL 25 - 2,500 2,500 Interest Earnings are from the fund's positive cash balance. 25 - 439 329 2,500 2,500 MISCELLANEOUS OTHER 500 500 Miscellaneous revenues account for revenues that do not fit into other revenue categories. 439 329 500 500 OTHER FINANCING SOURCES TRANSFERS 108,425 - 219,000 681,500 Transfers represent the cost of upgrades benefiting other City Departments. 108,425 INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY TOTAL 3,492,240 178 2,280,226 219,000 681,500 3,412,075 3,933,025 OGDEN CITY 2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET SUMMARY OF DEPARTMENTAL EXPENDITURES INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY 2014 ACTUAL 2015 7-MO ACTUAL 2015 ADOPTED 2016 BUDGET MANAGEMENT SERVICES PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE DATA PROCESSING DEBT SERVICE EQUIPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE TRANSFERS FUND BALANCE/CARRYOVER 1,322,472 9,814 929,055 585,062 2,146 3,621 591,868 (100,651) 3,343,387 749,950 4,745 803,226 291,292 1,044 441,935 2,292,192 1,384,050 8,175 984,525 616,450 2,500 161,800 254,575 3,412,075 1,473,950 9,475 1,051,400 584,750 2,500 654,300 156,650 3,933,025 PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE DATA PROCESSING DEBT SERVICE EQUIPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE TRANSFERS FUND BALANCE/CARRYOVER DIVISION SUMMARY MANAGEMENT SERVICES IT - INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY 3,343,388 2,292,232 3,412,075 3,933,025 3,343,388 2,292,232 3,412,075 3,933,025 3,000 219,000 3,190,075 3,000 189,000 492,500 3,248,525 3,412,075 3,933,025 FUNDING SOURCES MANAGEMENT SERVICES MISCELLANEOUS PRIOR FUND BALANCE TRANSFER FROM OTHER FUNDS USER FEES/PERMITS - 179 FY2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET MANAGEMENT SERVICES Fleet and Facilities - 2015-2016 Operations Plan PURPOSE OF WORK SESSION: Executive Summary Background To Discuss the FY2015-2016 Fleet and Facilities Operations Plan and the proposed FY2016 Budget The Administration will review FY2015-2016 Fleet and Facilities Operations Plan and the proposed FY2016 Budget for Fleet. In 2002, the City Council conducted a management audit of the City’s Fleet Division. One of the recommendations of the audit suggested the Division complete an annual business plan. The Council has received the annual business plan every year since the management audit was completed. A copy of the 2015-2016 Operations Plan for the Fleet and Facilities Division is attached for the Council’s review. The report outlines the Division’s accomplishments for the past year and establishes goals and objectives for the coming budget year. Budget Guidelines and Goals The following were included in the FY2015 Budget Guidelines and Goals: Guidelines 14. Fleet Business Plan. The Fleet Division Business Plan will be reviewed annually. The updated Fleet business plan is to be provided at the beginning of the budget process each year. Ogden City Council Work Session: May 21, 2015 1 Goals 4. Fleet Management. To support the Administration’s ongoing efforts to improve the City’s fleet. The Council also continues to encourage the transition to more fuel efficient vehicles where practical and cost-effective. Budget Summary The Fleet and Facilities FY2016 budget is summarized below: Fleet and Facilities Adopted FY2015 Proposed FY2016 Facilities Fleet Operations Electronics Warehouse Totals $2,324,275 $7,677,950 $152,000 $1,155,800 $11,310,025 $2,357,250 $7,579,975 $154,675 $1,157,175 $11,249,075 Amount Change % Change $32,975 -$97,975 $2,675 $1,375 -$60,950 1.42% -1.28% 1.76% 0.12% -0.54% Fleet and Facilities Internal Service Fund Changes Significant budget line items for Fleet Division expenditures are as follows: Proposed 4% Merit (1% to Base Pay) No City-paid retirement benefit increases Reduction in debt service payments ($83,925) Slight reduction in fleet replacement funds ($50,000) Questions 1. Please review the FY2015-2016 Fleet and Facilities Operational Plan. 2. Please review the proposed FY2016 equipment purchases. 3. Please review the impact the state law regarding fuel efficient vehicle requirement has had/will have on the Division. 4. Please describe the challenges facing the Division in FY2016. Council Staff Contact: Janene Eller-Smith, (801)629-8165 Ogden City Council Work Session: May 21, 2015 2 Ogden City Management Services 2015-2016 Operational Plan FLEET AND FACILITIES DIVISION OGDEN CITY MANAGEMENT SERVICES OPERATIONAL PLAN 2015 INTRODUCTION Ogden City Fleet and Facilities is a Division of the Management Services Department and is comprised of the following sections; Fleet, Facilities, Central Stores, Communications and Security, and Administrative Services. The Fleet Section is responsible for vehicle and equipment maintenance, repair, licensing, vehicle and equipment surplus, and emergency services for Fleet equipment. The Fleet section is responsible for the procurement, warranty repair, contract maintenance, and service of 700 vehicles and pieces of motorized equipment, maintenance of emergency generators, and the CNG fueling facility. Under the direction of the Fleet Manager and the Sr. Project Coordinator, the shop supervisor and six mechanics maintain and repair the vehicular equipment. The shop supervisor is also responsible for holding a workplace safety meeting each week, which includes Facilities and Warehouse personnel. The Facilities Section is responsible for maintenance to City Facilities and communications equipment. Under the direction of the Fleet Manager and the Sr. Project Coordinator, this division is comprised of a Facilities Crew Leader and two Facilities Crew Maintenance Technicians. The Facilities Division is responsible for maintenance of all Ogden City facilities, construction, and property management of over 1000 parcels of property, and for maintenance and repair of 500,000 square feet of facilities. 2 The Communications and Security section is responsible for radio communication services, surveillance equipment and infrastructure, building access, and magnetic card reader accesses to Facilities. Under the supervision of the Facilities Crew Leader, we have one fulltime employee dedicated to provide these services. Our Administrative Services section is responsible for contract management and oversight, property management, recordkeeping, accounts payable, assigning and completing work orders and management of all documentation pertaining to each facility and each piece of equipment. This division also monitors and works within the parameters of the budget of $11.3 million in fiscal year 2015. Under the direction of the Sr. Project Coordinator, this section is comprised of two full-time Sr. Office Assistants and one part-time Office Assistant. The administrative section also manages the Central City Warehouse which maintains an inventory of about $850,000. The Central Stores Section, under the direction of the Sr. Project Coordinator and the Warehouse Supervisor, is staffed by three parts technicians, two full-time and one part-time. The Accomplishments, Challenges, and Goals for each of the four sections are as follows: 3 FLEET SECTION Accomplishments o o o o o o o 2014 - 2015 – The Fleet Committee continues to meet and further the progress on the triage plan for upgrading necessary vehicles. 2014 – Fleet and Facilities personnel were trained in bus service operations and obtained the proper endorsements to operate the shuttle services. This facilitated the operation of the shuttle and trolleys during the temple opening and other important city events. 2014 – Fleet and Facilities staff were trained in FEMA principals and communication for an emergency situation. Staff also obtained certifications in incident command theories and practices. 2014 – 2015 - Fleet purchased or leased 127 new pieces of equipment in FY 14, which included 35 police cars, 57 trucks and 10 refuse trucks. For FY15, Fleet has purchased 14 new pieces of equipment with some more purchases forthcoming. See Fleet Committee Report in Appendix B, which details the current equipment replacement plan through FY17 to better assess the needs of the city. 2014 – Since 2012, our average monthly attendance at safety meetings has continued to be 95%, demonstrating our commitment to workplace safety training. 2014 – Fleet personnel have gone 2,545 days without a lost time accident. Our supervisors and employees are committed to identifying and resolving workplace safety issues. 2014 – Ongoing commitment to alternative fuel research and use. Entire Refuse fleet consumes natural gas with a fully functioning fuel station located within the Public Works compound. The committee will strive to increase the fuel efficiency when considering replacement, as long as it is economically feasible. Challenges o o o o 2015 - In July 2012, the Cartegraph Software system went live, replacing the old Starry system. In 2013, we continued negotiations with Cartegraph to build reports and modifications to their system that were to enable increased access to information assisting in more effective management of the division and assist with small tools inventory for all city departments. We discovered Cartegraph will not support Fleet in their new OMS environment leaving us to explore additional software options to interface with Cartegraph OMS, which Public Services utilizes. Currently, we are looking at options that interface with Eden, which would improve the information flow with Accounting. Additionally, we are researching the possible benefits of converting to the Fuelman Gascard program through the state’s contract. This software program also interfaces with Eden and provides excellent reporting. The total replacement value of the fleet is nearly $22,000,000. To adequately replace equipment by the end of the life cycle for the vehicle or piece of equipment, Fleet would need a budget of $2,200,000 for vehicle replacement each year. The Fleet Committee is working to find additional funding to achieve this goal incrementally. Maintaining up-to-date training for all of our technicians is a challenge and a priority for our Fleet Shop Supervisor. The need to lift ambulance units for maintenance and repair is difficult with our current “flat rack” system. Upgrading to a larger unit is desired. 4 Goals o o o o o o Goal: The Division will provide fleet services to outside agencies when requested and fuel to Ogden City Schools. Goal: The Division will meet equipment requirements using the most appropriate and cost-effective method--rental, purchase, department sharing, etc. Goal: Upgrading our automotive and heavy truck diagnostic equipment which will help in creating faster repair times and provide more accurate diagnostics. Goal: The Division will review Departmental equipment requests, utilization and other factors affecting “right-sizing” to ensure the City is maximizing vehicle use, fuel economy and where possible, reducing departmental fleet budgets. Monthly usage reports will be provided to internal customers to assist them in managing costs. In order to maximize resources, all alternatives will be exhausted to guarantee economical funding for equipment while meeting users’ specifications. Goal: The Division’s Motor Pool will provide vehicles and equipment for using departments on a daily rental basis to encourage sharing of otherwise infrequently used equipment. One of Fleet’s most basic and critical services is to provide shortterm and long-term lease rentals of equipment and vehicles. Departments can rent a van from the pool for a few hours or a month, or if there is justification, can have a van assigned to the Department on a permanent basis. All costs associated with the vehicle—fuel, wear and tear, cleaning, tire wear, etc.—are calculated into the lease rate for the vehicle. (See “Rate Calculation” section below) If a using department has a special or unique need arise, Fleet will find the required vehicle or piece of equipment and acquire it—short-term or long-term as needed. Fleet offers specialized trucks, trailers, passenger vehicles, mowers, leaf blowers, generators and golf carts—just to mention a few. Operating the fleet on a lease rental basis provides the City and its users the flexibility to operate effectively while minimizing the cost of maintaining low-use or unique vehicles. Goal: Fleet Services has highly trained and certified mechanics performing the majority of the maintenance work on fleet vehicles. The Division has several contracts in place for larger repair jobs such as transmissions, differentials, brakes, etc. The Division also established contracts with vendors for repairs to ensure that every vehicle can be moved through the maintenance process as quickly as possible. Having contracts in place allows the fleet supervisor the flexibility needed to ensure that the equipment is repaired in an efficient and timely manner. 5 FACILITIES SECTION Accomplishments o o o o o o o 2015 – Approval and funding has been obtained for the modernization of the two elevators in the Municipal Building. The existing elevators were originally installed in 1929 and require constant maintenance and repair. We were able to negotiate a value-engineered modernization bid from the vendor who has been maintaining the elevators. Along with the modernization, we negotiated an on-going maintenance Services Agreement for all elevators in the city which will provide a cost savings of $26,537.76. The modernization will take several months to complete, but ultimately will provide reliable elevator service to everyone in the Municipal Building. 2014-2015 – The architectural design of Fire Station #3 has been completed and the plans are now in the engineering stage. The construction of the station should begin in early summer 2015. The Facilities Division is currently assisting with ensuring value engineering and the most cost effective and quality construction is utilized for the Fire Department for this project. 2014-2015 – Currently assisting with the installation of a T2 Luke II Paid Parking Station at the Ogden Airport. This Parking Station will be operational in spring 2015. The station will accept cash and credit card payments for parking at the airport. Additionally, customers will be able to use a smart-phone application to pay for their parking in real-time or in advance. It will also send texts to customers who can “Extend-by-phone” if their time limit for parking is going to expire. This project will be the benchmark for a paid parking program for the city, with the possibility of adding pay stations to other city surface lots in the future. 2014 – Completed a renovation of Fire Station #2, including seismic upgrades and tenant improvements. The project went well overall, and the Fire Department is pleased to be in their renovated building with all of the improvements. 2014 – Completed the remodeling of the office at the Ogden Airport. A new badging area was constructed that puts the Airport in compliance with TSA Standards. A conference room was added and a secured storage area was built for the TSA records. 2013 - 2015 – In November 2013, Ogden City partnered with a company called InScope Energy to help us monitor, measure, and manage our energy consumption and they installed the Enfuse Building Performance Management system in the Municipal Building. The purpose of installing Enfuse was to empower Ogden City to identify and reduce energy waste while aiding future budgeting and investment decisions with accurate modeling and historical data. At this point, InScope has not been able to provide a cost savings model that would be beneficial to the city. We are awaiting a response from InScope as to whether or not they can provide a better offer. This would help position Ogden City as a regional sustainability leader and major contributor to Utah’s energy efficiency efforts if it is economically feasible to go forward with the project. 2015 – Facilities personnel have worked 961 days without a lost time accident. This number shows that our supervisors and employees are committed to identifying and resolving workplace safety issues. Challenges o Being underfunded for the required preventative maintenance and proactive replacement of structural, electrical and mechanical needs is the greatest challenge the Facilities Division faces. In September 2013, a company called ISES conducted a Facility Condition Assessment for Ogden City Buildings. Their report included Current Replacement Value, Non-Recurring Project Costs by Priority, and Recurring Component Replacement Costs by Year, including deferred maintenance costs. This plan gives us projections through 2023 for 6 each facility. The goal of obtaining this information is to help in being proactive, rather than reactive and properly prepare and budget for upcoming maintenance costs. The results of this study showed that we have approximately $1,768,678.00 in critical repairs needed on city facilities to bring them up to code and ADA standards (listed as Critical). See Executive Summary listed in Appendix C. Goals o o o o Goal: The Division’s Facilities Section will provide routine maintenance and repair services to City facilities. The Division will also work to develop long term maintenance plans and budgets for much needed capital improvements. Failure of larger pieces of equipment, such as boilers, create funding challenges. The Division is looking for creative “fixes” and outside funding for replacement and high-priced repairs. Goal - The Division continues to work with the Division of Water Rights to obtain the proper licensing so we can begin construction on a Rocky Mountain Power Blue Skies funded Hydro Electric Power Plant. It will be located at the Water Treatment Facility in Ogden Canyon. As part of the grant requirements, it will be an educational facility and will be available for the public to tour. Goal: The Division will provide nuisance abatement services for the Community and Economic Development Department. The goal is to complete the request and the associated paperwork within 7 working days from receipt of the notification. For CY2014, Nuisance Abatement handled 336 separate cases at a total cost of $108,798.48. Goal: The Division will continue to use the Facilities Service Request in Microsoft Outlook to handle incoming service requests and to generate work orders. This has been very effective in meeting the service requests from the various city customers. The Facilities Techs have cell phones that receive request e-mails. Every facilities request is seen by each of the three techs. Emergencies are identified and handled immediately. Work orders are generated at the office and sent via e-mail to the techs so that they can complete the necessary paperwork as repairs or requests are completed. Communications and Security Accomplishments o o o o 2014-2015 – A Request for Proposal (RFP) was completed in 2014 for the installation of security cameras, card access and intrusion systems at the Water Treatment Plant and Water Sites. The project was awarded to the low bidder, DSI (Digital Systems Installation), a local Avigilon product dealer. The systems are currently being installed as part of the construction of the Water Treatment Plant. 2014-2015 – Communications helped with the purchase of two surveillance trailers for the Ogden Police Department. These trailers can be parked in various locations and offer video surveillance, and overt law enforcement warnings with bright, multiple flashing lights. The trailers’ main power source is solar, however can be changed to generator power depending on which functions are being used at any given time. 2014 – Facilities and Communications installed and implemented a comprehensive security access system in the Municipal Building using Avigilon products. 2014 – Facilities and Communications assisted the Airport in remodeling their office areas and coming in compliance with FAA regulations for Airport Access. Avigilon Cameras and Card Access Systems were utilized to upgrade the access requirements there. Due to the ability to use one standard platform for all cameras, and the excellent price structure, Avigilon products will continue to be implemented in any future security projects. 7 o 2014 – Under the direction of our Sr. Project Coordinator and with the assistance of our Fleet Sr. Office Assistant, Communications completed a radio inventory in late 2014. All applicable city departments were included in the inventory in order to identify the exact number of radio units. The purpose of the inventory was to determine how many radios will no longer be supported within the next year due to changes with UCAN. Many of the radios will no longer be supported and there is an urgent need for all police radios to be encrypted. Quotes were obtained for the replacement of the radios no longer supported and new models that will support encryption, blue tooth and GPS technology. These proposals were submitted to Administration in January budget sessions. Challenges o o The Mt. Ogden Communications Site is monitored and maintained by Communications. This is a particularly crucial service for the City, as the site serves the public safety community and several other public service agencies in Northern Utah. Services and space are also rented to private service providers when the equipment will not compromise the public safety mission. Communications services are charged at an established hourly rate and radios are billed as a fixed rate per month. Building space for communications equipment is charged by rack space and tower space used. The Division is in the process of completing an evaluation of the current rate structure and will make recommendations on the current rate structure and contract renewal once UCAN starts charging us fees. As cameras and card access systems need to be replaced, Avigilon products will be used for replacement. This will help standardize the hardware and functionality of the cameras and card access systems. Goals o o o o Goal: The Division will manage the Mount Ogden Communication Site with the assistance of a qualified engineering firm. The Division will also update the radio system for the City including the 800 MHz radio systems for better inter/intra departmental communications and track current technologies to ensure that the City is using the best possible communication methods. Goal: The Division will continue to provide radio support for all of the Fire Stations and communication support for outside agencies such as Weber 911 Dispatch and the FBI. Goal: Electronics will continue to provide amplified sound systems for special events and will provide set-up and takedown services. Electronics is also responsible for installing and maintaining all fuel monitoring equipment, all security hardware and repairing all radio, MDT, and AVL equipment in the public safety vehicles. Goal: Ensure that proper security equipment and access control minimize threats to City facilities and critical infrastructure. 8 Fleet & Facilities Administration Accomplishments o o o o o 2015 – Administrative staff continues to process invoices for payment in less than 5 days from the receipt of the invoice to ensure invoices are paid in a timely manner and maintain a positive relationship with vendors. 2014 – Communications, with the assistance of our Fleet Sr. Office Assistant, completed a radio inventory in late 2014, ensuring accountability for all radios currently in use. The inventory was completed with the input and reporting from all applicable departments in the city. We are currently looking at the future costs of replacement as many of the radios will no longer be supported within the next few years and the police department’s need for encryption, blue tooth and GPS is increasing. 2015 - The Division continues to streamline and maintain electronic files on each nuisance abatement case. We are currently going live with the IWorq Software to track the abatements. The Division completed cleanup of 336 cases in calendar year 2014 billing a total of $108,798.48, which includes administrative fees. 2014 – 2015 - The Sr. Project Coordinator is working with Accounting to review Fleet Lease rates being charged to the departments. We have succeeded in finding a way to reduce the work required by accounting to process the information submitted by Fleet and Facilities for billing. Administrative staff now processes the information for quarterly billings for lease rates. 2014 – Administrative staff continues working with Accounting to estimate cost per square footage to adequately recoup the money spent on facilities. Although funding does not currently exist to adequately cover expenses, this is a good place to start on the road to having Facilities funded to cover expenses required of the department. See Appendix D. Challenges o o o Our Supervisor continues to work on organizing contracts and their expirations to know when Request for Proposals, Request for Bids and contract renewals need to take place. With the Fortis software not providing us with the expiration information, the task must be done manually. 2015 - 2014 - In July 2012, we went live with the Cartegraph Software, replacing the old Starry system. In 2013, we continued negotiations with Cartegraph to build reports and modifications to their system to enable us to have increased access to information that would assist in more effective management of our division and with small tools inventory for all city departments. It was discovered that Cartegraph will not be able to support Fleet in their new OMS environment leaving us to explore additional software options to interface with Cartegraph OMS, which Public Services utilizes. Due to this issue, it takes days and sometimes weeks to compile reports easily accessible in the old Starry System. This will continue until conversion to a more dynamically functional software program can be implemented. Due to the unfortunate illness of the previous Sr. Project Coordinator, the administrative staff was overloaded with extra duties and assignments to help ensure the smooth functioning of the Division. The new Sr. Project Coordinator is working to make sure all necessary functions are being addressed and brought up to date. Specifically, the contracts with all vendors are in review to determine if renewals and expirations are taking place as needed. 9 Goals o o o Goal: We are currently reviewing other software vendors that can meet the needs of Fleet, Facilities, Central Stores and Communications. We hope to identify short and long term solutions to our current situation and move forward on a path towards making a change to a suitable software solution(s) before Cartegraph ceases to support the Navigator client, which we currently use. Goal: The Division’s Facilities Section will maintain the property records and inventory. Our Division offers support functions to all departments controlling property and handling property-related issues. Goal: The Warehouse section will manage warehousing operations for the City and continue to operate in compliance with OSHA standards. The annual inventory for FY2015 will be conducted June 29 & 30th, 2015. Throughout the year, quarterly cyclical counts are completed to track inventory. o o Goal: The Division will continue to purchase fuel and oil for the entire fleet and maintain two fueling stations within the City. Division staff monitors tank levels weekly to ensure there is adequate stock to meet the City’s needs. Orders are placed with a supplier when tanks reach a set point. Special care is taken to ensure there is adequate fuel for long weekends, special events, and snow plow season. The Division has also arranged with local vendors to provide fuel in emergencies. o The City’s ability to purchase in bulk keeps fuel and oil costs down and allows Fleet to operate cost-effectively. Weber County Strike Force and Ogden City Schools purchase fuel through the City. o The City has also installed a compressed natural gas (CNG) station used to fuel the Refuse fleet and other City vehicles as they are converted. Phase II of the project has been completed, and the station is available to any City CNG vehicle as a faster fueling option and back up to Phase I. Goal: The Division provides warehousing and parts procurement for any department needing assistance. However, staff’s primary function is to ensure that the front-line crews have the parts and tools necessary to complete their work in a timely and effective manner. Staff maintains and manages the inventory through use of the work order system—the Cartegraph Software System--which includes an inventory control system. Staff makes every attempt to take advantage of bulk price incentives and other cost saving measures. Parts are charged out on an averaged basis where the cost of new items in inventory is averaged with the cost of existing parts for a cost-per-item charge. Inventory for the Water Utility, and Fleet and Facilities is valued in excess of $850,000. 10 CONCLUSION The Fleet and Facilities Division will continue to provide outstanding customer service and the highest quality of work possible. The Division will continue to carry out its mandate in a cost effective and efficient manner and will strive for consistent excellence in all aspects of its mission. 11 Appendix A Organizational Chart 12 Fleet & Facilities Manager Administration Sr. Project Coordinator Property Management (Database Maintenance/Reporting) Communications (Mt. Ogden) Accounting/Budget All Bids/Contracts (Fleet & Facilities) City Zoning – Property Compliance (Demos) Warehouse Support, Mail Services Support for Facilities Maintenance, Nuisance Abatement Manage day-to-day office operations Lead Technician Oversee day-to-day Facilities Maintenance and Communications Contractor Oversight Security Oversight Facilities Technician Supervisor Manage day-to-day Warehouse & Mail Services Provide Office Support for Communications, Facilities, Fleet and Warehouse Contract Expirations/Renewals Parts Clerk Parts Clerk Parts Clerk Fleet Maintenance Facilities Maintenance Facilities Technician Communications Technician Oversee Mt. Ogden Operations Building Security MDT Vehicle Support Sr. Office Assistant Facilities Sr. Office Assistant Fleet Part Time Office Assistant Facilities 13 Foreman Fleet Maintenance Emergency Services Vehicle/Equipment Surplus Mechanic Mechanic Mechanic Mechanic Mechanic Mechanic Appendix B Fleet Committee Report 14 Fleet Committee Report – 2015 Annual Replacement 15 Value of Fleet Equipment by Department March 2015 Total Replacement Value for Ogden City $21,843,928.20 (Value includes Airport) Percent of Fleet Equipment by Department March 2015 16 Fleet Triage Summary 17 Replacement List / 4 Year Forecast 18 19 Appendix C ISES Report 20 Appendix D Facilities Costs and Square Footage Report 21 STRUCTURE AIRPORT FIRE STATION 2 FIRE STATION 3 FIRE STATION 4 FIRE STATION 5 FIRE STATION 6 THE JUNCTION NORTH PARKING STRUCTURE SOUTH PARKING STRUCTURE MARSHALL WHITE CENTER PUBLIC WORKS 2/SEWER OPS PUBLIC WORKS 5/REFUSE OPS PUBLIC WORKS 6/SIGN SHOP/FAC & COMM PUBLIC WORKS BUILDING 8 PUBLIC WORKS 9/WASH BAY PUBLIC WORKS 11/STORES WAREHOUSE PUBLIC WORKS GROUNDS FLEET FUEL ISLAND PARKS FUEL ISLAND COMMUNITY SERVICE BUILDING FRANCOM PUBLIC SAFETY CENTER GOLDEN HOURS SENIOR CENTER MUNICIPAL BUILDING PUBLIC WORKS 1/133 W 29TH OGDEN CITY JUSTICE COURT PROPERTY ID 400400 140090010 120660018 140190018 050200014 33134736 722402 010950001 010950006 101658 602400 605400 606400 608400 609400 611400 612400 622400 623400 102110 101400 565400 421734 601400 250400 YEARLY FUNDED: MUNICIPAL BLDG/FPSC/COMM SVC PUBLIC WORKS GOLDEN HOURS JUSTICE COURT $703,975.00 $188,575.00 $15,000.00 ??? TOTAL SQ FOOTAGE/ALL BUILDINGS: 1,053,804 FUND TYPE SQUARE FOOTAGE "A" BILL 12,400 "A" BILL 5,600 "A" BILL 6,500 "A" BILL 5,600 "A" BILL 5,600 "A" BILL 1,400 DIRECT BILL DIRECT BILL 211,958 DIRECT BILL 401,600 DIRECT BILL 45,000 ENTERPRISE/INTERSERVICE 6,000 ENTERPRISE/INTERSERVICE 8,000 ENTERPRISE/INTERSERVICE 11,000 ENTERPRISE/INTERSERVICE 23,000 ENTERPRISE/INTERSERVICE 3,000 ENTERPRISE/INTERSERVICE 7,200 ENTERPRISE/INTERSERVICE ENTERPRISE/INTERSERVICE ENTERPRISE/INTERSERVICE GENERAL FUND 8,784 GENERAL FUND 66,000 GENERAL FUND 22,500 GENERAL FUND 166,000 GENERAL FUND 36,000 GENERAL FUND 18,662 % SQ FOOTAGE OF TOTAL PROJECTED TOTAL FY15 1.18% $15,047.04 0.53% $337.68 0.62% $2,953.68 0.53% $0.00 0.53% $2,269.32 0.13% $0.00 $24,518.94 20.11% $311,247.84 38.11% $275,487.48 4.27% $112,995.00 0.57% $1,430.04 0.76% $125.28 1.04% $7,818.24 2.18% $95,301.66 0.28% $15,729.84 0.68% $6,095.70 $498.00 $10,664.77 $5,094.43 0.83% $90,382.74 6.26% $302,618.76 2.14% $54,307.32 15.75% $431,353.20 3.42% $179,434.56 1.77% $63,424.68 TOTAL SPENT: YEARLY FUNDED: DEFICIT: $1,993,751.48 $907,550.00 -$1,086,201.48 22 % OF $ SPENT 0.75% 0.02% 0.15% 0.00% 0.11% 0.00% 1.23% 15.61% 13.82% 5.67% 0.07% 0.01% 0.39% 4.78% 0.79% 0.31% 0.02% 0.53% 0.26% 4.53% 15.18% 2.72% 21.64% 9.00% 3.18% MAINTENANCE AVG SQ FT COST/SQ. FT COST/MONTH $1.34 $40.14 $0.41 $12.32 $0.52 $15.51 $1.22 $36.47 $0.95 $28.48 $0.45 $13.40 $1.06 $0.53 $3.08 $1.41 $0.63 $2.62 $5.16 $7.92 $1.12 $31.67 $15.92 $92.46 $42.42 $18.89 $78.58 $154.86 $237.73 $33.61 $0.07 $0.03 $6.00 $5.04 $2.78 $2.36 $5.62 $3.93 $1.98 $0.94 $179.94 $151.08 $83.48 $70.70 $168.61 $117.96 COST AT $2.75/SQ FT $34,100.00 $15,400.00 $17,875.00 $15,400.00 $15,400.00 $3,850.00 $582,884.50 $1,104,400.00 $123,750.00 $16,500.00 $22,000.00 $30,250.00 $63,250.00 $8,250.00 $19,800.00 $24,156.00 $181,500.00 $61,875.00 $456,500.00 $99,000.00 $51,320.50 $2,947,461.00 23 24 Appendix E Listing of All Ogden City Facilities 25 OGDEN CITY FACILITIES FY 2015 Facility Address City Services Municipal Building Public Services Public Works Building Justice Court Mt. Ogden Communication Site 2549 Washington Blvd 1875 Monroe Blvd 133 West 29th Street 310 26th Street Mt. Ogden Peak Public Safety Facilities Public Safety Building Fire Station #2 Fire Station #3 Fire Station #4 Fire Station #5 2186 Lincoln Avenue 1185 21st Street 340 Washington Blvd. 730 West 24th Street 3450 Harrison Blvd Operational Facilities Parks Shop Public Works Compound Bldg #2 - Garage Bldg #3 - Canopy Bldg #4 - Canopy Bldg #5 - Garage Bldg #6 - Facilities Bldg #7 - Salt Sand Dome Bldg #8- Fleet and Facilities Bldg #9 - Wash Bay Bldg #10 - Shed Bldg #11 - Parts Shed 1915 Monroe Blvd 133 W. 30th Street 175 W. 29th Street Sports, Event and Public Service Facilities Golden Hours El Monte Golf Course Mount Ogden Golf Course Lindquist Field City Stadium 650 25th Street 1300 Valley Drive 1787 Constitution Way 235 23rd Street 658 West 17th Street 26 Log Cabin Lorin Farr Pool Gift Ticket Shop Education Building Stewart Museum Picadilly Building 658 West 17th Street 1691 Gramercy 1810 Washington Blvd Water Utility Facilities Weber Basin Valve House Chlorination House Booster Pump House Caretaker Dwelling House Garage Water Treatment Plant Well Site Generator Bldg Pumphouse Chlorine House Pumphouse Well House Steel Reservoir Concrete Reservoir 46th North East 23rd Street East 23rd Street East 23rd Street 23rd Street 23rd & Buchanan 900 Ogden Canyon Eden Eden Mouth of Ogden Canyon 12512 Mountain Rd Airport Road 1600 E 36th St (2) 4800 S. Ridgedale (2) Airport Facilities Ogden Airport Terminal Airport Fire Station Airport Maintenance Bldgs C.A.P. Building Cordant Tech Hangar Airport Drive Airport Drive Airport Drive Airport Drive Airport Drive Parks Ogden River Parkway Info Big D Sports Park Beus Pond Bonneville Park College Heights (NS) Courtyard Park Dee Memorial Park Eccles Park (NS) Romrell Park 4th Street Softball Complex Francis Park (NS) Forest Green Park 1810 Washington Blvd 1376 East Park Blvd. 4240 Country Hills 200 Quincy Avenue 4090 College Drive 2200 Harrison Blvd 1240 Capitol Eccles & 25th Street 193 4th Street 400 Childs Avenue 625 East 675 North 4200 Taylor Avenue 27 Grandview Park Jaycee Park Lester Park Liberty Park Lions Club Park Lorin Farr Park MTC Learning Park Monroe Park Mt. Eyrie Park Marquardt Park Municipal Gardens 9th Street Park Orchard Park Rolling Hills Park Ron Claire Park Thomas Park (NS) West Ogden Park Miles Goodyear Park Mt. Ogden 3815 Jackson Avenue 25th & Fillmore 625 25th Street 2150 Madison Avenue 1220 23rd Street 600 Canyon Road 1750 Monroe 850 30th Avenue 1225 North Canfield Drive 3182 Taylor Avenue 2525 Washington Blvd 9th & Liberty 3250 Jefferson 1494 12th Street 925 East 825 North 2065 Buchanan 2471 E Avenue 2500 A Avenue 3090 Taylor Avenue Other Facilities Old Water Bldg(South Portion) Union Station Kiesel Parking Structure (MarketStar Bldg.) Junction Parking Structure - North Junction Parking Structure - South American Can Parking Structure Marshall White Center Dinosaur Park 133 W. 30th Street 2501 Wall Avenue 2450 Kiesel Approx 2250 Grant Approx 2350 Grant 2060 Lincoln 228 28th Street 1544 Park Blvd *Not Included - Homestead Properties in Various Phases of Redevelopment 28 FLEET & FACILITIES Organizational Structure Fleet & Facilities Central Stores Communications Facilities Fleet Non-general operations indicated by underlined text. FUNCTIONS The Fleet & Facilities Internal Service fund is used to account for the financing of goods or services provided by one department to other departments on a breakeven or cost reimbursement basis. The Fleet & Facilities fund includes costs of operating a maintenance facility for automotive, mechanical, and electrical equipment used by other departments. These costs are billed to the other departments at actual cost, which includes depreciation on the garage building, improvements, and the machinery and equipment used to provide the services. This fund also accounts for maintenance of City facilities, management of the City’s radio tower and radio equipment, and a central warehouse. 172 OGDEN CITY 2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET SUMMARY OF REVENUES AND EXPENDITURES FLEET AND FACILITIES 2014 ACTUAL 2015 ADOPTED 2016 BUDGET FLEET AND FACILITIES REVENUES CHARGES FOR SERVICES INTEREST MISCELLANEOUS OTHER FINANCING SOURCES 7,085,400 (1,591) 3,513,346 600,000 8,839,950 5,000 267,125 2,197,950 8,861,275 5,000 267,125 2,115,675 11,197,155 11,310,025 11,249,075 10,000,023 11,310,025 11,249,075 10,000,023 11,310,025 11,249,075 EXPENDITURES FLEET & FACILITIES 173 OGDEN CITY 2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET FISCAL YEAR REVENUE BUDGET FLEET AND FACILITIES 2014 ACTUAL 2015 7-MO ACTUAL 2015 ADOPTED 2016 BUDGET CHARGES FOR SERVICES OPERATIONS 7,085,399 4,870,316 8,839,950 8,861,275 Operating Revenue is from the sale of gasoline, rental of vehicles and equipment, and electronic services. 7,085,399 4,870,316 (1,591) - 8,839,950 8,861,275 INTEREST GENERAL 5,000 5,000 Interest Earnings are from the fund's positive cash balance. (1,591) - 5,000 5,000 MISCELLANEOUS OTHER 1,501,364 1,852,693 192,125 192,125 2,011,982 453 75,000 75,000 267,125 267,125 Other describes revenue received that does not fall into other revenue categories. SALE OF ASSETS Sale of Assets revenues generated through the occasional sale of City fixed assets that are declared surplus, primarily vehicles. 3,513,346 1,853,146 - - OTHER FINANCING SOURCES FUND BALANCE/CARRYOVERS 2,147,950 1,965,675 50,000 150,000 Carryover is the use of prior earnings to cover current operating expenses and/or equipment purchases. TRANSFERS 600,000 50,000 Transfers represent the cost of vehicles or equipment benefiting other City Departments. FLEET AND FACILITIES TOTAL 600,000 50,000 2,197,950 2,115,675 11,197,154 6,773,462 11,310,025 11,249,075 174 OGDEN CITY 2015-2016 TENTATIVE BUDGET SUMMARY OF DEPARTMENTAL EXPENDITURES FLEET AND FACILITIES 2014 ACTUAL 2015 7-MO ACTUAL 2015 ADOPTED 2016 BUDGET MANAGEMENT SERVICES PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE DATA PROCESSING DEBT SERVICE EQUIPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE TRANSFERS 1,349,011 134,546 2,266,285 6,044,477 114,850 50,592 6,213,364 (6,173,102) 10,000,023 786,575 55,370 1,155,601 3,190,261 66,975 464,660 5,719,442 1,456,675 181,975 1,870,500 5,308,075 114,850 1,309,400 1,068,550 11,310,025 1,529,650 181,975 1,870,500 5,308,075 114,850 1,225,475 1,018,550 11,249,075 PERSONNEL SERVICES SUPPLIES CHARGES FOR SERVICES OTHER OPERATING EXPENSE DATA PROCESSING DEBT SERVICE EQUIPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE TRANSFERS DIVISION SUMMARY MANAGEMENT SERVICES FLEET & FACILITIES 10,000,023 10,000,023 5,719,441 5,719,441 11,310,025 11,310,025 11,249,075 11,249,075 FUNDING SOURCES MANAGEMENT SERVICES INTEREST INCOME MISCELLANEOUS PRIOR FUND BALANCE SALE OF ASSETS TRANSFER FROM OTHER FUNDS USER FEES/PERMITS - 175 197,125 2,147,950 75,000 50,000 8,839,950 5,000 192,125 1,965,675 75,000 150,000 8,861,275 11,310,025 11,249,075