Media Watch Jul-Aug, 2014 - Media Council of Tanzania Website
Transcription
Media Watch Jul-Aug, 2014 - Media Council of Tanzania Website
Issue No. 145 July/august, 2014 ...It fits well dear friend MCT geTs new board at last a dream come true as ngC is held at Kimalang’ombe Page5 Juma nkamia makes a u-turn Page11 raid at Majira newsroom scare reporters Page14 Editorial Let’s all contribute and make this project a reality F or members of the Media Council of Tanzania (MCT) and media stakeholders, June 24 and 25, 2014 will always be remembered for their historical significance. Why? – It is simple. Since 1995 when media practitioners endorsed the establishment of the voluntary media council which began to operate in earnest from 1997, its secretariat has been operating in rented premises. When the issue of the Council’s sustainability gained currency among members and stakeholders, it first acquired a plot at Zinga village in Bagamoyo District for the purpose of setting a midcareer of Journalism training school but the idea and the project was slow to take off due to resource constraints. For badluck, the Zinga area was later taken over by government to Economic Processing Zone Authority (EPZA) activities. As the issue of sustainability was still paramount for the survival of the Council the question of having its own home was inescapable. This prompted the Secretariet to acquire an area at Kimalang’ombe in Bagamoyo. This time around, with a serious practical foresight, process of developing the area took hold. An architectural impression of the area was prepared and initial site developments have been undertaken. The sandy area of 14 merged plots covering 11,000 plus square meters is now fenced by a concrete brick wall with a sentry quarter. A water well has also been drilled. With this development, financed by resources raised by the Council through its various activities including management fees, consultancy and research, construction of MCT’s headquarters at Kimalang’ombe is no longer a dream but a reality that has carried the day. Those two days – June 24 and 25 are of specific significance in that on June 24, members of the MCT drawn from all over the country and other stakeholders participated in the annual professional Ethics symposium which preceded the National General Convention (NGC) held on the following day June 25,2014. Both the symposium and NGC were held in a large tent pitched in the Kimalang’ombe fenced space – earmarked for the construction of the proposed headquarters of MCT. The reason for holding the two events at that area was to instill the sense of belonging and ownership to the members and stakeholders. The project is expected to consume a colossal amount of TZS 7 billion on completion. Initial steps to raise the required amount of resources to develop the headquarter’s complex was to distribute fund-raising forms to members whereby each form bearer is expected to raise TZS 2 million by October this year. It is pertinent for members and stakeholders alike to understand the magnitude and importance of the sustainability venture. This project should not be taken as an isolated undertakin belonging to those who are running the Council. It squarely belongs to all media practitioners and stakeholders. In that regard, all of us should collectively get committed to see its completion. Everyone should strugle first to raise the required amount and take extra-ordinary steps to contribute to the project. Let’s rise to the occasion and make the project a reality 2 July - August 2014 Cover Story Mihayo to lead new board to steer MCT By MW Reporter A new nine-member Governing Board that will steer the Media Council of Tanzania (MCT) for the next three years has been elected at an historical National General Convention held at the site where the planned headquartersof the Council will be built. During the elections held in a large tent pitched in the fenced area of 14 plots covering11,769 squaremetres at Kimalang’ombe in Bagamoyo on June 25, 2014, about 90 active members of MCT and delegates to the NGC, elected Justice Thomas Mihayo the new President of the Governing Board. Justice Mihayo is not new at the Council as he has chaired the CoVEr PHOTO The outgoing norwegian ambassador, Ingunn Klepsvik smiles as the Human resources Manager of the Media Council of Tanzania, Ziada Kilobo, fits properly a headscarf on her while the regulation and standards Manager, Pili Mtambalike, looks on. Photo: adam Mzee. story and more photos page 9, 10. Justice Thomas Mihayo, the new President of the governing board of the Media Council of Tanzania (MCT). Council’s Ethics Committee for the past three years. He takes over from justice Dr. Robert Kisanga who had served in that capacity for two three year terms consecutively. Veteran broadcaster and Director General of Zanzibar Broadcasting Corporation (ZBC), Hassan Abdallah Continues page 4 VERBATIM While the legitimacy of the executive, legislature and judiciary is through the ballot box and the country’s constitution, that of the media is in the public it purports to serve – Kajubi Mukajanga, Executive Secretary MCT addressing Zimbabwe journalists in June, 2014. 3 Media Council of Tanzania Newsletter Cover Story Mihayo to lead new board to steer MCT The chairperson of the team which supervised the elections of governing board Members of the Media Council of Tanzania, Jane Mihanji, displays the ballot box before voting. From page 3 Mitawi was elected Vice chairperson. He takes over from Chande Omar Omar who, like Justice Kisanga had completed two three year terms running as provided by the Council’s Constitution. Mitawi had previously served as member of MCT’s Governing Board. Seven other members who were elected during the NGC are Wallace Mauggo, the managing editor of The Guardian, Tuma Abdallah - Senior Editor at Daily News, Badra Masoud Head of Communications at the Ministry of Energy and Minerals, Rose Haji Mwalimu – media consultant. Other members from the public elected include prominent businessman Ali Mfuruki, Justice JaxtonMlay, and Prof Bernadetta Killian. According to the Council’s 4 constitution, the president of the Governing Board is a non–media person while the Vice President comes from the media. It also provides that four of the members must be media persons and three must be representatives from the public. Badra Masoud and Rose Haji were members in the previous board while another previous member Rafii Haji Makame lost in the elections. Other members of the previous board –Kenneth Simbaya, UssuMallya and Prof Meena were not eligible for vying the elected positions as they had completed two three-year terms each. Outgoing President Justice Dr. Kisanga congratulated the new board members and also expressed gratitude to members of the Council for the good cooperation they had afforded him during his leadership. He also showered praise to the Council’s Secretariat pointing out that he has confidence in it. “ They are committed in running the Council under the strong leadership of the Executive Secretary of the Council, Kajubi Mukajanga”, he said. In his remarks, Justice Kisanga also spoke on the question of sustainability of the Council which he said had been dogging it throughout his leadership at the Council. One way of attaining sustainability , he said, is accomplishing the building of the Council’s headquarters. Dr. Kisanga said the project did not come out of the blue and appealed to membersof the Council and media stakeholders to give the Council adequate support. He also praised Council members for being responsible in paying their membership dues in time and urged them to continue with that spirit July - August 2014 News at last a dream come true as ngC is held at Kimalang’ombe By MW Reporter F or 178 members of the Media Council of Tanzania (MCT) including 38 new members, it is now real that the Council has a new seat – the site for the proposed headquarters at Kimalang’ombe in Bagamoyo some 50 kilometres west from the present premises of the Council’s secretariat at Mwenge in Dar es Salaam. On June 24 and 25, 2014 – the MCT members converged in a wide tent pitched at the walled site of 14 merged plots for a one-day professional symposiumon June 24 and the National General Convention (NGC) the following day. The Executive Secretary of MCT, Kajubi Mukajanga expressed deep appreciation on the landmark achievement for holding the symposium at the site of the proposed headquarters of the Council. He reminded the delegates that the decision of the Council to have its own premises was adopted during the NGC held in Zanzibar two years ago. He was happy that the cherished dream was beginning to materialise. As he welcomed the participants to the annual professional symposium that precedes the NGC, Mukajanga was elated as he pointed out it was a landmark achievement for the Council to have acquired its own home. He explained that the initial developments including the construction of a wall fence, a well and a sentry were completed using funds raised by the Council through Continues page 6 The executive secretary of the Media Council, Kajubi Mukajanga in a tete a tete with the President of the governing board of the Council, Justice dr. robert Kisanga during the national general Convention (gnC) held in bagamoyo on June 25, 2014. 5 Media Council of Tanzania Newsletter News From page 5 its various activities such as consultancy, management fees and research. Mukajanga has all the reasons to be happy on the achievement. On July 30, 2008 he expressed the wish for the Council to have its own home when he delivered his acceptance speech before the NGC after he was appointed Executive Secretary. He expressed the wish in style posing a rhetorical question to the delegates: “ How many of us here wish to see MCT as home owner”, he asked and added “Isn’t it a sweet dream?” at last a dream come true as ngC is held at Kimalang’ombe “So let us start working on it”, he had said adding that “we will strategise on how to raise funds for the building which can be a home as well as a source of income”. Mukajanga said “ We could let space to professional media associations, small schools of journalism, press conference organisers and so on. With a committed Secretariat and a supportive Board - five to six years later down the line MCT could stop being a tenant. Mukajanga had said. The idea of MCT having its own building was echoed by Justice Dr. Robert Kisang in his first speech as the President of the Council’s The regulation and standards Manager, Pili Mtambalike presents the annual progress report of the Media Council for 2013. The Finance Manager of the Media Council of Tanzania, John nguya,presents the audited finance report of the Council for the period ending 31, december 2013. 6 Governing Board. Speaking during the inauguration of the new Governing Board which was elected on December 17, 2008, Justice Dr. Kisanga said that by having its own building MCT would be sustainable and pointed out the government can assist in many ways to attain that goal. The inauguration held on Jan 27,2009 was graced by the then Vice President Ali Mohamed Shein who was represented by the then Minister in charge with the information docket, Muhammad Seif Khatib. Now six years later after Mukajanga posed the rhetorical question on the possibility of the Council owning its own home, realisation of that is coming closer following acqcusition of a large area of 14 plots. Within a short period to come the Council would be moving to realise its ambition of having its own home. In a way the government has played its part as it facilitated the Council to acquire the plots and the district Commissioner for Bagamoyo, Ahmed Kipozi who is by profession a media practitioner assisted in paving the road to the plots and installation of electricity. The Council has begun in earnest a campaign to raise funds for the project by providing special forms to its members . Each member has been asked to raise at least TZS 2 million by October this year. The Council expects to raise TZS 500 million from the members contributions for the project estimated to cost around TZS 7 billion. In a move to sentimental attachment to the move and steer up for contributions, MCT Executive Secretary, Mukajanga pledged to contribute TZS 2 million. In another symbolic gesture, delegates to the Convention planted trees around the area of 14 plots, a ritual to signify yet another blessing for the Council which was established by media practitioners and stakeholders in 1995 Media faces daunting challenges By Hamis Mzee A lthough the media has greatly transformed the society in terms of accountability and broader democracy, it is still facing daunting challenges, a university don and chairperson of the Think Tank of the Media Council of Tanzania , ProfessorPenninaMlama has said. Speaking during the annual The chairperson of the Think Tank on Freedom of expression and Media Issues, Prof. Penina Mlama makes a presentation before the Professional symposium on media held on June 24,2014. a Member of Think Tank – veteran journalist, media trainer and consultant, ndimara Tegambagwe emphasizes mentorship and specialization. July - August 2014 News professional symposium organized by the Media Council of Tanzania held in Bagamoyo, Prof. Mlama said we are now witnessing more space in the media, more independence and increased democracy . However she noted,with all these developments, there are challenges because under capitalism embraced in our society, almost everything is commercialized. Leadership,politics, people and media are commercialized akin products, Prof. Mlama said in her presentation during the symposium whose theme was:Celebrating two decades of pluralism and diversity of media in Tanzania. In this trend, she noted, women are the most affected casualities of the commoditization syndrome which should urgently be checked. Women are used in sales promotion for varying products and in dance groups unlike their male counterparts, they are portrayed dressed and dancing indecently, she said. Veteran journalist and member of the TT on Freedom of Expression and Media Issues, NdimaraTegambwage decried the tendency of government applying obnoxious legislations to suppress press freedom and even close media outlets. Ndimara also a media consultant and trainer said that journalists are public servants who are accountable to the people. In his opinion the government does not know journalism but it knows how to snatch the freedom of the press. The banning of media outlets, he said, inflict severe suffering to the workers of the affected media outlet,their families and relatives as they would go without salaries. Responding to questions on professional proficiency, efficacy and efficiency in the media raised during the discussion of the various presentations, Ndimara said there was a need to promote specialisation as well as mentorship in media Continues page 8 7 Media Council of Tanzania Newsletter News Media faces daunting challenges oFrom page 7 outlets where upcoming journalists would be mentored by more experienced colleagues. He also said that it was pertinent for journalists to develop the habit of wider reading so as to improve their perceptions and understanding on issues. Another veteran journalist and publisher Jenerali Ulimwengu expressed concern on the pace of the growth of the media industry in the country in relation to trained practitioners. He urged media owners and media outlets to invest in training warning that it was dangerous for people to write reports without establishing the truth. He expressed concern on religious bigotry and war mongering gaining currency in our society and urged media to stay away from such destructive trends by not highlighting them. Dr. Ayub Rioba, a senior lecturer at the School of Journalism and MassCommunications (SJMC) of the University of Dar es Salaam (UDSM) was of the opinion that there is a great need for researching on what type of journalism training is appropriate as the county has no known philosophy and ideology. Previously he said there was a clear direction in journalism as the country was promoting Ujamaa or traditional socialism but now as there is no clear direction in the society after liberalisation, we should focus on the type of training needed and the type of journalists we want, he said. In this score, he advised that media training institutions should promote contacts with media stakeholders. Simon Berege, a senior lecturer at Tumaini University spoke widely and passionately on the growing popularity of on-line journalism or 8 a Member of the Think Tank, veteran journalist, publisherand columnist, Jenerali Ulimwengu stresses investment in training. dr. ayub rioba, a senior lecturer at the school of Journalism and Mass Communication (sJMC) of the University of dar es salaam underscores focussed media. simon berege, senior lecturer at the Tumaini University harps on improvement of social media. social media. Pointing out that on-line journalism was on the increase and more appreciated as it is faster than most traditional media in releasing information, Berege also cautioned on its various challenges. As most blogs are run by untrained people and some by journalists there is an urgent need to provide assistance in terms of training to improve them July - August 2014 MCT is reliable and commands respect - ambassador By MW Reporter T he Media Council of Tanzania (MCT) is a reliable institution and commands great respect, the outgoing Norwegian Ambassador to Tanzania has said. Speaking at a farewell reception organized for her by MCT, Ambassador Ingunn Klepsvik said the Council is playing a crucial role in shaping and transforming the media in the country. By training and overseeing professional ethics, MCT is promoting qualitative and responsible media. She was of the opinion that the dramatic changes experienced also come with challenges and expressed confidence that Tanzania will be the jewel of Africa in terms of openness. As for the respect that MCT commands, Ambassador Klepsvik , said she had not heard any criticism leveled against it during her stay in the country. However, she recalled her first experience with the Council was bumpy as there were problems in the relations between the embassy and the Council. She caused laughter when she said she had feared to meet the Executive Secretary, Kajubi Mukajanga whom she was made to understand prior to her first contact with him that he was a fierce person. However she said her fears evaporated after meeting him and News officials of the Council and her embassy to sort out the problems between the two sides. She said it was such a wonderful experience to work with MCT, a body which is transforming the media in Tanzania for the better. Reflecting the warm relations with the Council, the Ambassador said she was deeply heartened by the Council when it was the first institution in Tanzania to offer condolences to the Norwegian people through the Embassy after a gunman went on rampage killing many youths in her country. “Other condolences were received but MCT was the first”, Ambassador Klepsvik said. Ninety one people killed on July 23, 2011 on the Island of Utoya in the incident when a lone gunman targeted the youths, members of the country’s Labour Party who had camped on the Island for summer vacation. Continues page 10 The outgoing nowergian ambassador, Ingunn Klepsvik admires her portrait with the new President of the governing board of the Media Council of Tanzania, rtd Justice Thomas Mihayo and the executive secretary of the Council, Kajubi Mukajanga. 9 Media Council of Tanzania Newsletter News MCT is reliable and commands respect - ambassador From page 9 She spoke highly of Tanzania, praising that it was akin to a seminar in functioning democracy and development and pledged that she would be the country’s ambassador in Norway in addition to the assigned Tanzania ambassador in her country. Speaking earlier at the reception held at the Ledger Plaza Bahari Beach on the shores of the Indian Ocean in Dar es Salaam the bustling coastal commercial city of Tanzania on July 18, 2014, the Executive Secretary of MCT Mukajanga, was appreciative of the outgoing envoy. He said she was a true friend and was very close to the Council. When she took over the leadership of Norwegian mission, she did not wait for the officials of the Council and the Embassy to sort out the problems that existed between the two sides. “She called me to ask if I could meet her and if we could solve the problem of funding the Council,” Mukajanga said. He recalled that at the meeting Ambassador Klepsvik asked them to talk and since then there is no problem. “Our partnership with Norway… we talk of special partnership”, Mukajanga said urging the invitees to the reception, including editors from mainstream media and media stakeholders and MCT staff to enjoy the evening and dance, secure with the knowledge that Norway is a true friend. The departing Ambassador was also showered accolades by the President of the Governing Board of MCT, Justice Thomas Mihayo and a representative of the Media Owners Associations of Tanzania (MOAT) and the Tanzania Editors Forum (TEF) Bakari Machumu who is the Executive Editor of Mwananchi Communications. “ We at MCT hold you very highly because during your tenure of office , you were accessible, willing to help, supportive and you knew well what the Council was doing and what it stands for”, Justice Mihayo told Ms Klepsvik. He said “the support of Norway to MCT has greatly enhanced the development and even more greatly enhanced the quality of media in Tanzania “ adding, “we are mostly grateful.” The media representative, Machumu recalled a very important engagement organised by the departing Ambassador for editors – a special workshop on the extractive industry gas and oil to shape the way forward in media coverage after abundant deposits of gas were discovered in the country. Towards the end of the farewell reception, the Ambassador was presented with a special wooden flower verse, an African dress which she was assisted to wear by the MCT Manager for Human Resources, Ziada Kilobo and Regulation and Standards Manager, Pili Mtambalike. She was also presented with her own portrait drawn by an artist. At the reception she was accompanied by Sven Olan Svoldal , country economist at the Norwegian Embassy. Norway together with Sweden and Switzerland fund the Council’s four year strategic programme ending in 2015 The outgoing norwegian ambassador, Ingunn Klepsvik poses in group photo with the staff, leadership of the Media Council of Tanzania and invited guests including editors from mainstream media at a party organized by the Council to bid her farewell. 10 July - August 2014 Opinion deputy Minister for Information, Youth, Culture and sports, Juma nkamia. Juma nkamia makes a u-turn By MW Reporter D eputy Minister for Information,Youth, Culture and Sports, Juma Nkamia, who is on record for uttering disapproving words against the Media Council of Tanzania (MCT) and the Tanzania Editors Forum(TEF) appears to be retreating. During a heated debate when members of Parliament steadfastly opposed the government’s procrastination in tabling new media legislation during the 2014/15 Budget session a year later after his infamous opinion against MCT and TEF, Nkamia made a complete u-turn praising the contribution of the two organs to the development of media sector in Tanzania. He had dismissed the two as “NGOs established to serve individual interests”. He also claimed that they had given themselves responsibilities to oversee media operations in the country. “I recognise the good work done by MCT and TEF”, Nkamia told Parliament, the two institutions he had casted aspersions as mere NGOs and cautioned the government against passing the legislation on the Right to Information touted by the Council, before his appointment as deputy minister. Nkamia who had earlier led a delegation of Members of Parliament and House of Representatives on study tour of India organized by MCT from September23 to 28, 2012 to learn on the implementation of the Right to Information legislation in that country, had cautioned the government not to rush into enacting it as it had myriad problems. His position in Parliament on May 20,2013 then dismayed media stakeholders who were surprised as Nkamia, then as Deputy chairperson of the Parliamentary Standing Committee onCommunity Development and as leader of delegation had praised the Indian model on his return. He had said that the legislation made the Indian government transparent, more responsive and accountable. During the debate on the budget estimates for 2014/15 session of the National Assembly, Shadow Minister for information,Youth, Culture and Sports, Joseph Mbilinyi, stood his ground in demanding the new media legislation. MPs Esther Bulaya, Felix Mkosamali and Daniel Ole Sendeka stood firm and supported the move to have the new legislation. The born-again Nkamia appeared apologetic to the stance by the MPs pointing out that the government had good intention and willing to table the legislation with the goal to improve the welfare of media workers in the country. While Nkamia was vacillating,observers cautioned on the motives of some MPs supporting the new media legislation. They warned that some MPs may be harbouring intentions to have obnoxious and more punitive legislation that would limit media space and freedom. Media Stakeholders had submitted to the government proposals for two media legislations – The Right to Information in 2007 and Media Services in 2008. Various ministers handling the information docket were promising each year that the government will table the information bill but to no avail, At one point the government had indicated it would combine the two and table one bill but after attracting opposition from media stakeholders, it changed stance. However, the Ministry of Information preferred bill to control the media – that is the Media Services Bill while the Right to Information bill would be taken on later. Lately after President Jakaya Kikwete pledged at a meeting of Open Govenment Partnership (OGP) held in London in the UK towards last year that the government would table freedom to information bill by April 2014, there has been a flurry of activities involving many players towards that end. As for Nkamia it is important for “doubters” and sober minded people to keep their fingers crossed before he changes his mind once more 11 Media Council of Tanzania Newsletter Photos national general Conve The Manager of the Zanzibar office of the Media Council of Tanzania (MCT), suleiman seif omar speaks during the national general Convention (ngC) held at Kimalang’ombe in bagamoyo. delegate salim ali salim from the Muslim University Morogoro speaks during the national general Convention The secretary of the njombe Press Club, Hamis Kasepa , makes a contribution during the national general Convetion. 12 ention 2014 in pictures July - August 2014 Photos delegates follow closely the proceedings during the national general Convention held in bagamoyo. The executive secretary of the Media Council of Tanzania (MCT), Kajubi Mukajanga, exchanges views with the executive director of the Union of Tanzania Press Club (UTPC), abubakar Karsan during the national general Convetion. a delegate from the Veteran electronics Media association, gervas Moshiro, makes a point during the national general Convention. delegates to the national general Convention (ngC) cast votes to elect members of the governing board of the Media Council of Tanzania. 13 Media Council of Tanzania Newsletter News raid at Majira newsroom scare reporters By MW Reporter I t has been reliably learnt that reporters of Majira newspapers are scared of doing investigative stories after unknown people invaded its newsroom and made away with computers. The invaders broke into the newsroom, the office of the managing editor and photo section on April 31, 2014 and took computers with key, crucial and sensitive editorial information. In addition the invaders also broke the draws of the editor’s desk and took away documents. The Media Council of Tanzania (MCT) has recorded the incident on its Press Freedom Violations Register on June 10, 2014. 14 Majira Managing editor, Imma Mbughuni Highly placed sources within the newspaper connect the invasion to its serialised publication ofinvestigation on drug peddling and the captivity of some Tanzanian youths engaged in the drug trade in private homes in Pakistan. Some of the youths kept in captivity as bonds in the illegal1 but lucrative trade were released and Majira had managed to interview one of the captives who was secretly returned to Tanzania. The newspaper had been running series of investigative stories on drug peddling and was closing in on drug barons. Majira’s Editor, Imma Mbughuni confirmed that his newsroom was raided at the night of April 31, 2014 and had reported the matter to the Police who have investigated the issue but to-date nothing has come of it. Majira did not report the incident publicly after it reported the incident to the police who cautioned the paper to tread carefully on its operations. Mbughuni shared the information on the incident with other media, a month later in June. This is a second known incident of a newsroom been raided and recorded in the Press Freedom Register of the Media Council of Tanzania. In March 2013 the Council had received a complaint from the then Editor of Mwananchi newspaper, Dennis Msacky that he had been trailed by unknown people and that his office was burgled and his computer taken away July - August 2014 News emotions erupt before ethics Committee The editor of Tanzania daima newspaper, edison Kamukara testifies before the ethics Committee of the Media Council of Tanzania . Left is Commissioner for Minerals in the Ministry of energy and Minerals, eng. Paul Masanja. By MW Reporter W hen editor Edison Kamukara of Tanzania Daima faced a team of senior officials from the Ministry of Energy and Minerals before the Ethics Committee of the Media Council of Tanzania (MCT), on June 16, 2014 the initial mood was quite deceptive. It had appeared that the Ministry’s three-member team led by Commissioner for Minerals,Paul Masanja and comprising Dr. Medard Kalemana the ministry’s advocate and Badra Masoud, head of Communications and editor Kamukara, would settle for a mutually agreed ruling by the Committee ending with the customary handshake, friendly chatter and group photograph of the parties after mediation. After all the parties presented their initial remarks in the dispute which the Ministry was accusing Tanzania Daima of malicious reporting the mood changed abruptly as emotions jumped high. The Minerals commissioner got emotional and had to be restrained to calm after uttering disapproving words against Kamukara. He was reminded by Ethics Committee member, Kenneth Simbaya that the committee was conducting itself in the spirit of promoting mutual respect and Continues page 16 15 Media Council of Tanzania Newsletter News From page 15 understanding. Committee Deputy Chairperson, Rose Haji Mwalimu, who was presiding over the hearing on behalf of Committee chairperson retired Justice Thomas Mihayo, concurred with the view raised by Simbaya. The ministry was disputing articles published by Tanzania Daima which it claimed were published with the intent to tarnish its reputation. On May 16,2014 Tanzania Daima published a story headlined: “Kashfa mpya nishati na madini” (new scandal at the energy and minerals) and on May 24 the paper ran another story on Escrow Account headlined : “Vigogo watosana ufisadi wa Escrow”. The ministry demanded aTZS 2 billion compensation claiming the paper’s articles disrupted a national campaign to raise awareness on the emerging extractive industry in the country. The paper claimed in the first article that foreign companies had sponsored a symposium organized by the ministry to enlighten religious leaders on the extractive industry and alleged that some participants were given money to support the view maintained by the ministry that local entrepreneurs do not have the financial capacity to invest in the industry. On May 19, the Permanent Secretary in the Ministry of Energy and Minerals wrote to the newspaper on the article saying that it had no grain of truth as the symposium was solely sponsored by the ministry. In the letter, the ministry was categorical that it was not serving the interest of anyone and denied that some participants to the symposium were paid to trumpet the concept that local investors do not have the wherewithal to engage in gas mining. It asked the paper to name the company which it claimed to allegedly sponsor the symposium and refute the report. The newspaper did neither. On May 27, the Secretariat of (MCT) wrote a letter to the Editor of Tanzania Daima requesting him to 16 emotions erupt before ethics Committee deal with the complaints raised by the ministry but the paper did not apologise to the complainant. In addition the ministry also disputes another article by the paper on the embezzlement of funds in the Escrow Account in the Bank of Tanzania. In the article the paper claimed that officials in the ministry were frantically trying to distance themselves from the embezzlement scam amounting to USD 122 million by sending sms messages to some members of parliament. The paper claimed that the officials were trying to implicate the Member of Parliament for Musoma Rural, Nimrod Mkono and UK’s High Commissioner in the country accusing them for allegedly bribing MPs in order to block the 2014/15budget estimates of the Ministry. During the hearing the Committee totally dismissed explanations given in defense by the paper’s editor Edison Kamukara. His argument that the story was done in good faith for the public interest could not stand the scrutiny of the Committee. The Committee in its ruling observed that the articles had serious professional discrepancies and were purely based on rumour and not facts. It ruled in the ministry’s favour in the complaint in which Tanzania Daima newspaper was accused of running disparaging articles based on rumours which the ministry had categorically denied and claimed were malicious. Tanzania Daima was ordered to run an apology and carry interviews with ministry officials to clear the polluted air. However the Committee could not entertain a punitive measure of paying TZS 2 billion compensation as requested by the ministry. Committee chairperson, Rose Haji said it does not have the mandate to impose punitive penalties as it operated on the spirit of mediation vested in the Court of Honour. After having given time to consult their superiors, the ministry officials came back into the boardroom to report that they would seek further avenues for legal redress. While granting the request, the Secretary of the Committee who is also the Executive Secretary of the Council, Kajubi Mukajanga, said the Ethics Committee was an independent body that does not take instructions from outside. However, he cautioned that the ruling reached by the Committee cannot be used in court as evidence but if the court is interested it can invite the Committee as a friend of the court. In another development, the Committee also agreed to a request by the conflicting parties – Mawio newspaper and the MPs - Vita Kawawa, Mariam Kasembe, Faith Mitambo and Mtututra A. Mtutura to allow them to settle their dispute outside the Committee. Advocates from the two sides briefed the Committee that they had started a dialogue with the aim of reaching an amicable settlement and that was smooth and promising progress. According to one of the advocates Valentino Daudi of KMVB Law Chambers representing the MPs the two parties had a meeting on Sunday June 15, 2014 and had reached an agreement to hold another meeting in Dodoma on June 22, 2014 where the Managing Director and proprietor of Mawio, Saed Kubeneya would meet with the Members of Parliament to iron out the sticking issue of compensation demanded by the offended MPs. The Committee was informed by the advocate of the Mawio’s readiness to pay compensation but it was seeking a reduction of the amount demanded. The MPs are demanding a TZS 5 million each for the damage inflicted on them following a report by the newspaper which associated them with a network of poachers. Mawio newspaper was represented by advocate John Mallya from Power Advocates July - August 2014 News The executive secretary of the Media Council of Tanzania (MCT), Kajubi Mukajanga addresses Zimbabwean journalists at a conference held in Kadona, Zimbabwe. He was the guest speaker at the Media Policy and regulation Conference organised by the Voluntary Media Council of Zimbabwe (VMCZ). Mukajanga emphasises editorial credibility and accountability By MW Reporter T he Executive Secretary of the Media |Council of Tanzania (MCT), Kajubi Mukajanga, has underscored the importance and relevance of credibility and accountability in the media. “We as media people are as good as we are credible and accountable”, Mukajanga told Zimbabwean journalists at a conference organized by the Voluntary Media Council of Zimbabwe held in Kadoma, 147.6 km from the capital, Harare. He emphasized in his presentation entitled Mapping Media Accountability in Africa and Beyond: Lessons from Zimbabwe, that media accountability should be closely linked to the power it wields – to create and shape on one side and shame and destroy on the other. “While the legitimacy of the executive, legislature and judiciary is through the ballot box and the country’s constitution that of the media is in the public it purports to serve”, he said. On regulation of the media, Mukajanga who is also the President of the World Associations of Press Councils (WAPC) said it should serve to make sure that media delivers ethically and responsibly. He cited the various modes of regulations as statutory regulation, co-regulation, independent regulation and self regulation. He said the most favoured model of regulation in Africa, is statutory regulation in which the regulatory body is set up by a statute and is controlled by the government. This mode is also effected through myriad of laws whose provisions submit media to state control. A statute would also require compulsory registration, Mukajanga noted pointing out that it always comes with the possibility of deregistration of a journalist or an entire media outlet. He explained co-regulation as a combination of government and media industry regulation while independent regulation implies independence from both media and government. As for self regulation which is exercised by MCT, Mukajanga described it as a peer review system operating within a set of self imposed Continues page 18 17 Media Council of Tanzania Newsletter News From page 17 rules by the media. Despite some positive trends in the statutory regulation as evidenced by the statutory regulatory India which is quite independent, Mukajanga said that Tanzanian media practitioners are skeptical of the system. He said the reason is simple – Many institutions which exist by law “independent and impartial” do not necessarily exhibit independence and impartiality in practice. They are evidently seen to be manipulated by the government, ruling party, or even powerful individuals and commercial interests. But another fact is that once in existence due to law, the powers that be can change that law anytime to suit their interests. He cited the Kenyan experiencethat despite constitutional provision (Article 34), Parliament in December 2013 passed a contentious anti press legislation, the Kenya Information and Communication (Amendments) Act and the Media Council Act which Mukajanga emphasises credibility and accountability critics say seek to effectively silence critical reporting through a new government controlled regulator and the threat of hefty fines. He said the Kenyan case is interesting as the country’s Media Council had initially operated as selfregulatory body and later became statutory and styled as co-regulation but now the powers have amended the statute and weakened the body. As for lessons for Zimbabwe, Mukajanga who in his presentation gave a wide narration of the experiences of MCT and its governance and leadership structure involving people of impeccable stature in society, said for self regulation to be credible and effective, the self regulator has to be seen to be fair and firm and media outlets have to submit to such voluntary mechanism. The executive secretary of the Media Council of Tanzania, (MCT), Kajubi Mukajanga (centre) is received by the Zimbabwe Minister for Information Prof. Jonathan Moyo (left) when he paid a courtesy call on the minister. right is board Chair of Voluntary Media Council of Zimbabwe (VMCZ), alec Muchadehama. 18 Citing the MCT experience, Mukajanga said the first chairperson of the Ethics Committee was Justice Joseph Warioba, Former Prime Minister and Vice President of Tanzania who is a highly respected leader while the Council’s President was Prof. Geoffrey Mmari a highly respected academic who was Vice Chancellor of the University of Dar es Salaam in late 80s and early 90s. The second President was Prof Issa Shivji while ethics committee was presided over by a highly respected jurist the first Tanzanian Attorney General Mark Bomani and current president is Court of Appeal judge Dr. Robert Kisanga while the Ethics Committee is chaired by Justice Thomas Mihayo. Another lesson for Zimbabwe, Mukajanga said is that the regulator has to be relevant. This can be done by ensuring that real life professional and ethical issues are tackled pro-actively and in a transparent manner. Mukajanga was empathic on the question of regulation which he told the Zimbabwean audience that “we cannot argue against government regulation, and at the same time refuse to respect self-regulation. “Are we mature enough to self reghulate? Are we ready? If not. Are we ready to try and work towards becoming better professionals, towards maturity, towards self regulation?” Mukajanga challenged. He said the Tanzanian experience has shown that if journalists and editors agree to make self regulation work, then government will be forced to accept the fact. With the new constitution, he said, Zimbabwe can install a working self regulatory system that works in its environment. Mukajanga said journalists and media houses need to give VMCZ all the support it needs and protect it advising them it is their duty to make it strong if they think it is weak”. While in the country, Mukajanga paid a courtesy call on the Minister for Information Prof. Jonathan Moyo with who he exchanged views on media issues Zimbabwe journalists win landmark case By MW Reporter I n a landmark judgment upholding the right to freedom of expression, the Supreme Court of Zimbabwe has struck down the legal provision under which tortured journalists Mark Chavunduka and Ray Choto were charged last year. If the prosecution had been successful, the journalists could have received prison sentences of up to seven years. Rather than responding to the charges, Chavunduka and Choto challenged their validity with a direct appeal to the Supreme Court. ARTICLE 19's lawyers worked closely with the applicants' legal team to develop a submission to the Court reflecting the best international and comparative standards in this area. The provision prohibits the publication of any false statement that is likely to cause fear, alarm or despondency among the public. In its ruling on June 5, 2014, The Court quoted from ARTICLE 19's brief: "Were this provision to be actively applied, it would exert a significant chilling effect on freedom of expression", holding that this represented "a fair and realistic summation of the harsh impact" of the provision. Reacting to the judgment, Andrew Puddephatt, Executive Director of ARTICLE 19 said: "We are delighted that the Zimbabwean Supreme Court, in a powerful and unanimous decision, has struck out the provision which might have led to the imprisonment of Ray Choto and Mark Chavunduka. "This is a very significant victory for freedom of expression and sends a clear signal that "false news" measures are unacceptable. ARTICLE 19 hopes to build on this, using the judgment to assist in our efforts to do away with the false news provisions that still exist and are actively applied in many countries," he added. Journalist Mark Chavunduka Journalist ray Choto Canadian Journalists for Free Expression (CJFE), which honoured Chavunduka and Choto with its 1999 International Press Freedom Award last fall, adds that "CJFE believes that the Supreme Court decision, overturning the 1960 Law and Order Maintenance Act, is a great victory for all citizens of Zimbabwe. By not only surviving their imprisonment and torture, but also fighting their case to the Supreme Court, Chavunduka and Choto have contributed to the greater freedom of their fellow citizens." Background: On 10 January 1999, The Standard newspaper published a story alleging that there had been an unsuccessful coup attempt in the Zimbabwean army. Two days later, Chavunduka, the editor of The Standard, was arrested and held for over a week. Choto, the author of the article, voluntarily surrendered himself to the police. Both were severely tortured and spent time in the UK receiving treatment. They were charged under section 50(2)(a) of the Law and Order (Maintenance) Act with publishing false statements likely to cause fear, July - August 2014 News alarm or despondency among the public or any section thereof. The Court held that false statements were protected by the constitutional guarantee of freedom of expression, and that the provision breached that guarantee in that it was excessively vague, did not serve a legislative objective of sufficient importance to warrant overriding a constitutionally protected right and was excessively broad. Pius Njawé, the Cameroon journalist, was imprisoned for nearly 10 months in 1998, after being convicted of publishing false news for alleging that the President of Cameroon was ill. ARTICLE 19 considers all false news provisions to breach international guarantees of freedom of expression and calls on those States which still have such laws to repeal them. In another development, on the night of June 19, 2014, police in Zimbabwe arrested the editor of a state-owned newspaper who was appointed two months earlier. Sunday Mail editor, Edmund Kudzayi was detained after computers were seized from his office. A police spokeswoman told the state-owned Herald paper that he was being held over articles he had written. Earlier in June, 2014 President Robert Mugabe accused his information minister Prof. Jonathan Moyo of using state-owned media to sow divisions in the ruling Zanu-PF party. Correspondents say there is tension in the party over who should succeed 90-year-old Mr Mugabe, who was re-elected president last year. Mr Kudzayi was among several newspaper editors recently appointed by Information Minister Jonathan Moyo whom the president had referred as the "devil incarnate" for firing editors at state-owned newspapers who were loyal to ZanuPF. Prof. Moyo has fallen in and out of favour with Mr Mugabe and was reappointed as his information minister last September 19 Media Council of Tanzania Newsletter News editors, MCT take common position on key issues The executive secretary of the Media Council of Tanzania, Kajubi Mukajanga (left) speaks during the third consultative summit of editors and the Council held in Machame. By MW Reporter L ots of sentiments - both positive and negative,even worries on journalism professional trends in the country featured prominently during the 3rd consultative summit between the Media Council of Tanzania (MCT) and Editors from various media outlets across the country. Some of the presentations like Journalists under siege- Press Freedom Violation Report 2013, Challenges to editorial independence, and Media in the eyes of the government, generated concerns during the summit held at Aishi Protea Hotel in Machame on the slopes of Mt. Kilimanjaro from May 29 to 30. The Regulations and Standards Manager of MCT, Pili Mtambalike cautioned on increased 20 press freedom violations and emphasized the need of reporting the violations ranging from denial of information, obstruction to access news or sources, threats against journalists and even physical attacks so that they could be recorded in the Press Freedom Violations Registry established by MCT. Bakari Machumu, the Executive Editor of Mwananchi Communications Limited publishers of the the Citizen and Mwananchi newspapers, spoke widely on the Challenges to Editorial Independence emphasizing on the need of media to tread carefully, conduct themselves professionally and adhere to journalistic code of ethics. The Chairperson of the Tanzania Editors Forum (TEF) Absalom Kibanda sounded more worrying in his presentation entitled: Media in the Eyes of the Government. He said, to the government the media was more of ‘troublemakers’ and are held suspiciously. It is unclear what triggers this suspicion, he said, as the media is driven by the spirit of genuinely serving the interests of the public. Other papers were Newsroom editorial challenges ahead of the 2015 Elections, was presented by Deodatus Balile, the Managing Editor of Jamhuri newspaper; Reflections on professional readiness for Civic and General Elections, presented by Neville Meena the TEF Secretary and editor at Mwananchi Communications and Jesse Kwayu, the Managing Editior of Nipashe presented a paper on cheque book journalism and challenges to editorial independence in election reporting. July - August 2014 John Mireny the Publications, Research and Documentation Manager of MCT presented two papers - State of the Media Report 2013: an overview and trends in 2013; News Media Agenda for 2015 elections while Mtambalike also presented a second paper entitled Strengthening Articles 30 and 31 in the Draft Constitutional Proposals. Theophil Makunga of Mwananchi Communicatins and member of the TEF board, spoke on Taking the litigation option to achieve freedom of expression and the press. At the end, the editors and MCT came up with a common position, resolving to jointly petition against legislations which stifle and impede freedom of expression and freedom of the press.. The resolutions were read by the Regulation and Standards Manager of MCT, Pili Mtambalike, who explained later that the anti press legislations include the 1976 newspaper Act, Broadcasting Act, sections of the penal code, official secrets and national security acts. The meeting also resolved that the media fraternity – MCT and TEF should come with a joint statement regarding confusing situation surrounding the Constituent Assembly on handling the on-going process of getting the new national constitution. The editors were in agreement that the statement should appeal to both sides of the political divide in the constitutional reform process to bury their differences and facilitate realisation of the new constitution. On election coverage, the meeting resolved that media outlets should stop relying on politicians and set their own budgets. They appealed to MCT, TEF, the Union of Tanzania Press Clubs (UTPC) and the Tanzania Media Fund (TMF) to initiate means to support the media in covering the elections. Besides all media institutions should coordinate election training programmes to avoid duplicating training especially in the regions. The editors were also in agreement on the need to improve coverage and adherence to the professional code of ethics all the News time. The consultative summit, the 3rd since 2012 was officially opened by Dr. Charles Mlingwa, the District Commissioner for Siha on behalf of the Kilimanjaro Regional Commissioner, Leonidas Gama. Dr. Mlingwa praised the media for its contribution to national development in his opening statement while the summit host, the Executive Secretary of MCT, Kajubi Mukajanga said that the summit was a useful platform for the media and the Council in general and even more so this time as the Council is planning its next four year (2016 2019) programme stragegy in 2015. Generally what transpired during the two day summit augured well with its theme – Reflect, Share, Strategize: Strengthening Media Ethics and Professionalism in Newsrooms. The first consultative meeting was held in Morogoro in 2012 and the second was held in Tanga in 2013 editors and some staff of the Media Council of Tanzania captured at the ndoro waterfalls at Marangu on the slopes of Mt. Kilimanjaro while on sight seeing expedition after the consultative summit held at Machame. 21 Media Council of Tanzania Newsletter News new attempt to establish trade union for journalists Media practitioners engaged in setting up a new trade union pose in group photo with the deputy secretary general of Tanzania Union of Trade Unions (TUCTa),Hezron Kaaya(second lefts eated ) and senior programmes officer of Interantional Federation of Journalists regional (IFJ) office for africa based in dakar senegal, Pa Louis Thomasi ( second right seated )pose in a group photograph. By MW Reporter A fter the de-registration of the Tanzania Union of Journalists, new efforts have been initiated to set up another trade union. On June 5 and 6, 2014 journalists from a number of regions met in Dar es Salaam to deliberate on the way forward in establishing the union. At the end of the two days, the group came up with a new name – Journalists Union of Tanzania (JUT) and picked a five-member team to work on its constitution before a bigger meeting of journalists from all across the country is convened. 22 A Senior Programmes officer with the African Region Office of the International Federation of Journalists (IFJ) based in Dakar, Senegal, Pa Louis Thomasi, was on hand and pledged the federation’s full support to Tanzania journalists to realize the goal of having a well grounded and strong trade union. He said it was utterly important for media practitioners in the country to realise their rights and interests and have them defended and protected. In his remarks before the meeting, he cautioned that media owners were driven by super profits and were ready to use any pretexts to protect their earnings adding that in this case journalists and media workers in general need to be organized to protect their benefits. He cited numerous examples where employers hoodwink employees to maximize on profits. “Workers should carefully read contracts before signing them as there may be clauses which are not favourable to them”, he warned. The Deputy Secretary General of the Tanzania Congress of Trade Union of Tanzania (TUCTA), Hezron Kaaya was equally supportive of the move by the journalists to set up the new trade union. He expressed dismay why in the first place, the federation had allowed July - August 2014 News its member – TUJ- not to be effective and active after failing to operate and recruit members, providing a recipe for its deregistration. He said journalists inTanzania are facing many problems including working without contracts and not appropriately remunerated. The federation even provided a legal expert, Edwin Mwakyembe to assist in the new efforts. Friedrich Ebert Stiftung, (FES) threw its weight in support of journalists getting organized under a trade union. Its country Director, Rolf Paasch, pledged that FES will provide assistance to facilitate the realisation of the goal of setting up the new trade union for journalists. “I know it is not easy, but through union and solidarity things will change,” said Paasch. The five-member team set up to steer the process of establishing the trade union comprises two pioneers - interim leader Samsom Kamalamo and Secretary Timothy Kitundu who prepared the JUT constitution and others are the Vice President of the Union of Tanzania Press Club (UTPC), Jane Mihanji, Editor with the Media Council of Tanzania (MCT), Hamis Mzee and a journalist with New Habari 2000 - Arodia Peter. Already efforts have been taken by some members of the team to inform other journalists on the new trade union . Delegates to the annual General National Convention of the Media Council of Tanzania held in Bagamoyo on June 25, 2014 and editors meeting under the umbrella of the Tanzania Forum (TEF) meeting in Mtwara on July 11 and 12, 2014 were told by some of the members of the team of the initiatives on the new trade union . In all these instances, the editors and journalists were asked to fully support the establishment of JUT. For the Media Council of Tanzania the initiative to set up JUT have come at the right time to ward off mounting pressure from journalists seeking assistance from it on such matters like pay disputes or lack of working without contracts which are purely trade union matters. During the MCT meeting at Bagamoyo, the Council’s Executive Secretary, Kajubi Mukajanga, passionately advised journalists to respond positively and actively to the efforts of establishing JUT MCT publishes book requested by Zanzibar President From page 24 “This is a great effort”,Vice President Seif said as he unveiled the ocean blue covered 230 page history book blended with golden colours. He praised the Media Council of Tanzania for making the request made by the Zanzibar President Dr. Shein come true. Dr. Shein had made his request to MCT delegation headed by its Executive Secretary Kajubi Mukajanga on March 13, 2012 when the team paid a courtesy call on him at the State House in Zanzibar. He had advised that it would be quite important if the media history on the Isles is properly recorded in the form of a book. Speaking during the launching ceremony,which was attended by a huge number of journalists and media stakeholders, Mukajanga confirmed that they had taken the request seriously and with great zeal culminating into the publication of the book. On his part Vice President Idd said it was a must read book to be used by journalists training schools. He also challenged the media fraternity to come up with another book on media veterans and stalwarts who may serve as role models to practicing and upcoming journalists in the country. The book records means of communication from prehistoric era to the establishment of contemporary media. In its introductory pages, it points out that the establishment of the Eastern Telegraph Company in Zanzibar in 1879 was among the first set-up of communications in Africa South of Sahara. It says that the first widely read newspaper was the Zanzibar Gazette founded in 1892 which was preceded by a religious publication Simuluzi. “The growth and significance of mass media outlets in Zanzibar became more noticeable from as early as 1902 when Samachar (meaning the news) and the Zanzibar Voice – two commercial newspapers , were established to promote Zanzibar globally. The Publications, Research and Documentation Manager of MCT, John Mireny, narrated the entire process culminating to the publication of the book, the first serious attempt to record the comprehensive history of media development on the Isles. The launching ceremony was accompanied with entertainment from traditional ngoma and taarab groups, puppet show and poetry 23 Media Council of Tanzania Newsletter News The Zanzibar second Vice President ambassador, seif Idd displays the book on Zanzibar Media History during its launch in Zanzibar.He is flanked left by the Zanzibar Urban west regional Commissiner, abdallah Mwinyi and right by executive secretary of the Media Council of Tanzania, Kajubi Mukajanga and far right by the Zanzibar Information services diorector, rafii Haji Makame. MCT publishes book requested by Zanzibar President By MW Reporter A t last a request by the Zanzibar President Dr. Ali Mohamed Shein to the Media Council of Tanzania (MCT) to publish a book on the history of the media in Zanzibar has been accomplished. The book titled: A history of Zanzibar Media Traditions and Transitions written by three Zanzibaris - veteran journalist Mariam Hamdani, journalist and consultant Ali Rashid and a Lawyer Fatma Amour was launched by the Zanzibar Second Vice President Ambassador Iddi Seif at a colourful ceremony held at the Zanzibar Beach Resort. Continues page 23 Complaints or inquiries should be addressed to: Executive Secretary, Media Council of Tanzania, P.O. Box 10160, Dar es Salaam, Tel.: 022-2775728, 022-2771947 Cell: 0784 314880 Fax: 022 2700370 E-mail: [email protected] www.mct.or.tz Printed by Ecoprint Ltd., E-mail: [email protected]