Port Hood Conceptual Plan
Transcription
Port Hood Conceptual Plan
Port Hood Conceptual Development Plan DRAFT May 2014 Prepared by: Ekistics Planning & Design In association with: Port Hood and Area Development Society and 1 Starr Lane, Dartmouth, NS, B2Y-4V7 ph: 902.461.2525 Municipality of the County of Inverness Table of Contents 1 Introduction and Background 1.1 The Project 1.2 Goal 1.3 History of the Community 1.4 Existing Conditions 2 Inventory and Analysis 2.1 Demographics 2.2 Climate 2.3 Water Temperature 2.4 Land Use & Value 2.5 Existing & Past Plans 2.6 Community Consultation 3 Brand & Positioning 3.1 Community Background 3.2 Brand Research 3.3 Brand Positioning 4 Conceptual Development Plan 4.1 Concept 4.2 Physical Plan Components 4.3 Design Details 5 Implementation 5.1 Priorities and Phasing 5.2 Capital Cost Estimates 5.3 Next Steps 3 4 1. Introduction & Background 1.1 The Project 1.2 Goal Ekistics Planning & Design was awarded the Conceptual Development Plan project for Port Hood in March, 2014. This report shall serve to communicate our experiences, research, and advice for the Port Hood Area. The Port Hood Area has long been the seat of Inverness County. The goal of this project is to provide guidance for planning documents and branding for the Port Hood Area that will ensure that it retains it’s unique position amongst the communities of the Ceilidh Trail. By developing a Conceptual Plan with a coincident Branding and Positioning strategy, this project will enhance the capability to attract new businesses, new shoppers, new tourists and newcomers to Port Hood. Separated into five chapters, the report begins with introductions to process, places, and hopes that the consulting team has had in mind throughout the planning process. Following from this, the report shares the outcomes of community consultation work, which leads into branding & positioning and eventually the physical plan and implementation strategy. For the physical plan, this goal includes description and demonstration of aspirational improvements building on plan analysis and public feedback. For both the brand and the plan the project has envisioned not only what, but how. The Implementation chapter identifies the next steps and proposed project costs for all proposed work will help the Port Hood and Area Development Society and the Municipality of the County of Inverness prepare to move forward. The process begins with a research phase, where we review best practices, conduct a design workshop and community survey, followed by a round of analysis. Armed with results, our process leads into an idea generation phase where numerous ideas are explored and reviewed against the design brief and findings, and various concepts are explored and refined. Port Hood indeed has certainly has many offerings: current and potential. With the work we are proposing as part of this project we strongly believe Port Hood can be prepared for upcoming developments in Inverness County. For the brand, this goal includes graphic representation for the community in the form of a logo, and consideration of how this logo can tie into anticipated strategies for the client. 5 1.3 History of the Community The Port Hood Area was formerly officially called, and is still today commonly called, Chestico. When Cape Breton Island was under the control of the French, prior to the fall of Louisbourg in 1758, the Port Hood Area was known as Les Iles aux Justaucorps. This was a reference to Port Hood Island being close to the shore by way of an allusion to common French waistcoat of the time. With the eventual migration of British Loyalists to Cape Breton through the late 18th century, attempts were made to rename areas to have Anglophone names. Port Hood is no exception. By the 1770s the name Justaucorps was replaced on maps with Port Hood, in honour of British Naval Commander Samuel Hood. Notwithstanding this change, Gaelic settlers who came to the area continued to refer to the area as Justaucorps, but with Gaelic pronunciation this became shess- ti- co, with a modern Anglicization to Chestico. This historic etymology speaks volumes to the history of Cape Breton Island, the impact of European settlers, and the influence of other cultures on the history of Inverness Country. Port Hood Island, when it was connected to the mainland via an isthmus contained a quarry for finished and dressed stone. This quarry produced much of the material for details at the Fortress of Louisbourg. This resource extraction, along with a fishing port, became the main driver for the local economy and population growth to the early 19th century. Maturation Port Hood was named the County Seat in 1824, a political win for the area that led to the founding of churches, the development of a service industry, and the establishment of a college in town. Origin & Founding The naturally protected waters of the Northumberland Strait and the natural resources available from the earth have always been a draw to Port Hood. The first settlements in the area were camps, only temporary and seasonal, but these encampments laid the groundwork for later permanent settlement taken up by the French in the 17th. Fig. 1 Port Hood Court House 6 Resource extraction expanded in the late 1800s with the opening of several coal mines on the Eastern hillside. These mines added to economic prosperity and diversified the local economy. A series of storms and fires decimated the commercial prospects of Port Hood in the time between and after the two World Wars. These acts of nature, in combination with the opening of the Canso causeway saw Port Hood join with other Cape Breton municipalities in losing population at an alarming rate. Port Hood today remains a popular location for families and even with the large migration through the 1990s still hosts a permanent population of 1,274 people. Over the years the Port Hood Area has produced many world class athletes, Duncan Gillis (Olympic Silver Medalist), Al MacInnis (NHL Hockey Player), Andrew MacDonald (NHL Hockey Player), and Bruce Beaton (CFL Football Player). The sporting nature of the area holds to this day, with the Port Hood Triathlon being held annual in the Area and local sporting events at the Sports Centre The Chestico Museum is the home of historic records for this community, and is the founding force behind the Chestico Days annual summer festival and the Ceol nan Cas step dancing festival. Today Port Hood thrives as a summer destination and as a service centre for a large part of Southern Inverness County. While Port Hood remains the county seat and home to local government its status as an independent town was removed in the latter half of the 20th century. Port Hood today is wholly contained within the Municipality of the County of Inverness. Fig. 2 Duncan Gillis 7 1.4 Existing Conditions Port Hood is well known for its beaches and sunsets, both functions of the natural environment in which it is situated. Fig. 3 shows the base map that was created to help understand current conditions within Port Hood. Core The intersection of High Road and Main Street serves as the geographic centre of the plan area, with extents stretching north to Murphy’s Pond, south to the Chestico Museum, and east to East Street. The majority of the area is within a 15-minute walk from the core. Highway 19 Continuing up from the South (Port Hawkesbury, Judique) Highway 19 begins to veer East - away from the water - at Port Hood, taking much of the traffic away from the centre of Port Hood and allowing it to continue through to Mabou. The 19 is a well maintained highway that is, for the most part, free of intersection and driveway interruptions between towns. In Port Hood some new development (Home Hardware, School) has been focused on this area of town. Collindale Road The alternative to traveling on Highway 19 is to turn off at Port Hood, travel through Main Street and make your way back along the ocean through to Collindale to Mabou Harbour. This scenic drive includes in it’s length a 9km stretch of compacted dirt road. Fig. 3 Base Map 8 Main Street Sunset Sands / Sports Centre Trans Canada Trail Main Street, Port Hood contains many of the institutions in the area including Town Hall, St. Peter’s Catholic Church, the associated Parrish Hall, St. Stephen’s Anglican Church, and the Library. Due to investment in public infrastructure a 1.5km stretch of Main Street has concrete sidewalk, curbs, and streetlights. Sunset Sands RV Park is situated on the water very near the centre of Port Hood. Closely linked to the Al MacInnis Sports Centre the RV Park hosts several dozen spaces for long and short stay visitors to the area. Amenities at the RV park include a heated swimming pool, showers, washrooms, laundromat, and fire pits. The Trans Canada Trail has a trail head located directly across Highway 19 from the Boardwalk Beach parking lot. This trail head leads east into the Rocky Ridge along an old rail line and provides the opportunity for day hikes or connections into the larger TCT system. The Beaches Murphy’s Pond At the western edge of the Port Hood, where the land meets the water there are five distinct beaches that stretch between Lawrence’s Beach (in Harbour View) and Murphy’s Pond / Public Dock. This does not include the beaches that are located around Port Hood Island. The area’s well known fishing port is located today at Murphy’s Pond Wharf, this is the primary economic engine of Port Hood. Fisher’s catch consists mainly of lobster, crab, tuna and mackerel. As many as 150 boats dock at Murphy’s Pond Wharf during tuna season; most come from Nova Scotia and Prince Edward Island. Each of the five beaches offer a unique waterfront experience and have a varying degree of public access. The Wharf, Lifeguard, and Murphy’s Pond beach are most closely linked to the study area through roadways and parking, but the two beaches to the south (Lawrence’s and Boardwalk Beach) also form part of Port Hood’s offering of summer active and passive recreation opportunities. Many of the homes located nearby the beaches are occupied by seasonal residents of the area, with permanent residents focused more toward Main Street. In addition to the commercial fishing support at Murphy’s Pond Wharf, the area also boast a wonderful look-off area beyond the fish huts and lobster traps that provides a scenic vista of the Northumberland Strait and Murphy’s Pond itself. Rocky Ridge Flanking the eastern edge of Port Hood is Rocky Ridge. This ridge gently gives way to the beaches one moves from east to west and is a defining physical feature of the Port Hood Area. Port Hood Island One of the most unique aspects of the physical area is the existing of Port Hood and Henry Islands just off the coast of Port Hood. These islands create a visual break as residents look to the Strait and a unique micro climate in the waters between the Islands and shore. Port Hood Island has approximately 3 dozen structures, mostly congregated around Smith’s Cove and the public dock. There is one permanent resident on the island with the remainder of the structures being occupied on a seasonal basis. 9 2. Inventory & Analysis large diversity of European ancestry amongst the population. British, Irish, Scottish, French, and Dutch cultures are all well represented in the Port Hood Area. Among the approximately 2,100 households in the larger Port Hood Area, the majority are couple households, with less than 250 households being single parent households (Fig. 5) and an additional 500 couple households having children as well. 2.2 Climate There are few visible minorities in Port Hood, but a 85 + 85 + 85 + 85 + 80-84 80-84 80-84 80-84 75-79 75-79 75-79 75-79 70-74 70-74 70-74 70-74 65-69 65-69 65-69 65-69 60-64 60-64 60-64 60-64 55-59 55-59 55-59 55-59 50-54 50-54 50-54 50-54 45-49 45-49 45-49 45-49 40-44 40-44 40-44 40-44 35-39 35-39 35-39 35-39 30-34 30-34 30-34 30-34 25-29 25-29 25-29 20-24 20-24 15-19 85 + 85 + 600 80-84 80-84 75-79 75-79 500 70-74 70-74 65-69 60-64 60-64 55-59 55-59 50-54 50-54 45-49 45-49 40-44 40-44 35-39 35-39 30-34 30-34 25-29 25-29 25-29 20-24 20-24 20-24 15-19 15-19 15-19 15-19 10-14 10-14 10-14 10-14 10-14 5-9 5-9 5-9 5-9 5-9 0-4 0-4 0-4 0-4 0-4 300 200 200 100 Male Fig. 4 Age Pyramids 0 100 0 100 Male Female 100 200 Female 200 300 300 40000 40000 30000 400 300 200 100 0 30000 20000 20000 10000 10000 0 Male 10000 0 Male Female 20000 10000 30000 20000 40000 30000 50000 40000 50000 Couples (with kids) 65-69 300 10 Halifax Halifax 700 20000 20-24 15-19 10-14 5-9 0-4 20000 15000 Female 15000 10000 10000 5000 0 5000 Male Fig. 5 Family Types 5000 0 Male Female Other Nova Scotia Nova Scotia Singles (no kids) Port Hood Port Hood Climate and weather in Port Hood follows the general trends common to Cape Breton. The high summer temperatures above 25 degrees Celsius and the lows through the winter in the freezing range create challenges with year round use of Singles (with kids) Most Nova Scotian communities in rural areas have seen a decline in population, and specifically youth population over past decades, with a significant turn down shown across the province in the 2011 Census. Port Hood is no exception to this reality, provided below (Fig. 4) are age pyramids for Port Hood and the province as a whole. It is clear from these pyramids that the aging population is outstripping the youth population in Port Hood. Providing for the community according to their needs is imperative, but this has to be done in concordance with showing youth the opportunities that exist for them in Port Hood for the long term. Couples (no Kids) 2.1 Demographics 10000 5000 Female 10000 15000 15000 20000 20000 Inventory and Analysis Site Context Average Prevailing Wind Frequency (Hrs) NOR TH 25 20 50 km/ h 345° 15 10 1 5° 330° 30° 40 km/ h 31 5° 5 0 45° 30 km/ h 300° 285° -15 W EST Daily Average Daily Minimum -10 75° 10 km/ h Daily Maximum -5 60° 20 km/ h hrs 200+ 180 160 140 120 100 80 60 40 < 20 Climate and Weather Average Temperature ( o C) E AS T Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Average Rainfall (mm) 160 255° 1 05° 120 240° 1 20° 225° 1 35° 21 0° 1 50° 1 95° 80 40 0 1 65° SOU T H Jan Feb Average Snow Depth (cm) 60 40 public amenities but with thoughtful design shoulder seasons (Fall & Spring) can accommodate public gather and use of public spaces. Winter snow fall levels are supportive of a local sledding and snowmobile recreation industry that takes advantage of existing trails. Being a coastal community the prevailing winds in the 20 - 30 km/h range are not surprising. These winds can be taken advantage of for water sports and potentially harnessing wind energy on Rocky Ridge. 20 0 Jan Feb Mar Average Precipitation (mm) 160 120 80 40 0 Jan Feb Mar Fig. 6 Climate & Weather 11 Inventory and Analysis City Context 2.3 Water Temperature Water Temperature o In our early work with the community and stakeholders we heard often that the waters off the shores of Port Hood were some of the warmest in the North Atlantic. Halifax Water Temperature ( C) 25 20 15 The data in Fig. 7 supports the claim that water temperatures in Port Hood are indeed much higher than the Atlantic coast of Nova Scotia, but they do not sustain the same highs that are common in the Carolinas and along the Eastern Seaboard. 10 5 0 Jan The increase in water temperature from the more populated coasts of Nova Scotia is a significant opportunity for the community of Port Hood. It is clear that they can offer a different suite of water based recreation opportunities with comfortably swimmable waters as early as May and as late as September (e.g. water above 10 degrees Celsius, air in the 20 degrees Celsius range). On the Atlantic Coast there are only two months where one can rely on the air and water temperatures being high enough to encourage beach activity. Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Port Hood Water Temperature ( o C) 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 Jan Feb Mar Apr Myrtle Beach Water Temperature ( o C) 30 25 20 15 10 Daily Minimum 5 Daily Maximum 0 Monthly Average Jan Feb Mar Apr Fig. 7 Water Temperature 12 2.4 Land Use & Value Using property tax data we were able to create a map of land use for the Port Hood Area. The vast majority of large lots are focused on Agricultural and Forestry Resource production, but around Main Street and through the core of Port Hood there is a higher density of residential and commercial uses. Notable in Fig. 8 are the areas of commercial land (includes recreation and non-profit uses) along Beach Road and Highway 19. Fig. 9 on the following page includes a property value / acre mapping of all of the lands within the Port Hood Area. The Canadian Urban Institute highlights important reasons to invest in areas with higher property values. While the urban core usually only consists of 1% of a city’s land base, it can make up 10% to 20% of the city’s assessment base and total revenue from property taxes. A strong core ensures sufficient revenue to maintain city services by increasing the city’s bottom line and improving economic prosperity in the area. It is also important to note that tax revenues associated with residential properties are generally lower than taxes associated with commercial properties, so urban areas with a strong commercial base can further increase a city’s revenue. By concentrating commercial development where the existing property values are high, the city is able to get the highest revenue from the smallest land area. Port Hood Land Use No Data Residential Commercial Mixed Use Forest Farm & Other Resource These principles can be instilled in the Port Hood development process to direct development in a way that will promote increased economic stability and prosperity for the area. Beach 0 250 500 1000 Fig. 8 Land Use 13 When studying the distribution of property value per acre we see that a dense concentration of high value is located surrounding the intersection of Main Street and High Road, and continuing north along Main Street. There is a clear correlation between higher property values and dense form of both commercial and residential land uses. This agrees with the Canadian Urban Institute findings, supporting the idea that future development in Port Hood should be concentrated in areas with higher property values. A need for increased economic stability from tourism, and poor infrastructure maintenance were concerns that arose from stakeholder interviews. Concentrated development along the commercial core of Port Hood will improve city resources, builds upon investments already made, and provide the opportunity for spin off benefit in property tax. By developing where property values are already high, the municipality can benefit from the tax collected immediately. By improving the infrastructure and amenities in Port Hood, the city will have a stronger means to attract tourism- increasing the amount of money coming into the community long term. Port Hood Property Value per Acre No Data < $25,000 $25,001 - $250,000 $250,001 - $1,000,000 $1,000,001 - $1,500,000 > $1,500,001 Beach Fig. 9 Property Value 14 0 250 500 1000 2.5 Existing & Past Plans An important component of establishing a baseline understanding of the existing context and conditions by way of reviewing existing planning policy and past relevant studies. The intent of this work is to develop a comprehensive picture of existing policy and understanding of the Town and to contrast this to established planning literature and the context of other similar municipalities. During the initial phase of the study, we summarized key findings that would be compared with outcomes of the public engagement work. This not only informs the outcomes of the public engagement process, but also ensures that the resulting plan is pragmatic and appropriate to the unique context of Port Hood. R-1 Residential Urban R-2 Residential Rural LITTLE MABO U RD C-1 Commercial C-2 Commercial Highway C-3 Harbourfront Development C-4 General Commercial O-1 Open Space M-1 Marine Industrial MA RBLE HILL RD M U R PH YS PO N D R D OL HAWL CO UR BEAC NV CO LANE H RD ER BAYB RY RD AR YN OLD S ST AV SE IEW LN ST ST WH F RD ST ER RD FR AS ER ST AS FR CK T ST EN EA WAT BA E RD T ST RE DG Y RI CK IN ST MA The summaries we have provided here are not exhaustive, but they provide necessary content for the development of the Conceptual Development Plan. Suggestions for changes to the Municipal Planning Strategy are included in the implementation chapter of the report. EYS D RO ER ST EX AC T BE H RD D RD FIEL 500 LL 0 BA 1,000 UPPER HIGH RD SOUTHWE ST MABOU RD 1,500 Metres PA N Y RO AD EX TE N CLAN RANALD RD DUNM CO M Municipal Planning Strategy for Port Hood OR E RD RD ANY COMP SH The MPS for the Port Hood Plan Area supports increased use of the Waterfront, commercial use along Highway 19, a broad mix of residential and governmental use within residential zones, and light industrial uses associated with resource production. AR ON DR HIGHWAY 19 BA CK Port Hood Island MAPLE GROVE RD RD BARBER RD The MPS was developed and amended out of past planning projects and matches well best practices for small community development. CAM KENZIE LANE HUGHIES LN Henry Island Fig. 10 Zoning MICHAEL D RD SHORE RD This map is a graphical representation of property boundaries which approximate the size,configuration and location of properties. This map is not a land survey and is not intended to be used for legal descriptions. THIS IS NOT AN OFFICIAL RECORD. MACMASSEY DR 15 Municipal Land Use By-Law for Port Hood Physical Activity Strategy The Land Use By-Law contains regulations for development of lots, usage on sites, access to developments, signage, and site density - among other items. The current By-Law mandates generous set backs in many zones, an issue that may have to be addressed in any effort to create an active street environment. The Physical Activity Strategy includes five goals and objectives for the Municipality. Most notable for the Conceptual Development Plan presented here is Goal 2, The Natural and Built Environment. This goal is set to better utilize existing assets and create and maintain built and natural environments and infrastructure which support and inspire citizens to be engaged in physical activity. Port Hood Waterfront Study A 2004 plan for the Waterfront areas of Port Hood identifies significant opportunity for improvements at Murphy’s Pond for tourists, residents, and the commercial fishery. By creating a destination at the northern extent of the community there is an effort to draw people through Port Hood rather than them potentially skirting it via Highway 19. A Plan for Community Based Development The Municipality’s plan for individual communities includes a Vision and Mission for Port Hood. Vision: “Focused on the sea, Port Hood is a vibrant, youthful town which promotes a wealth of happiness and economic growth and development.” Integrated Community Sustainability Plan The ICSP identifies infrastructure throughout the County that may be at risk considering environmental trends. In Port Hood the most significant asset that is highlighted within the ICSP are the municipally owned wharves that facilitate transportation between the mainland and Port Hood Island. Recommendations are made to ensure that capital budgets include provision for the maintenance and improvements to the wharf infrastructure, estimated at a cost of $350,000 at the time of the report. Mission Statement: “To encourage individuals, organizations and government to develop and operate commercial, social, recreational and similar endeavours in our area. We will also initiate and establish (similar) efforts on our own” Fig. 11 2004 Waterfront Study 16 2.6 Community Consultation To assist in the start up of the project we initiated a three pronged approach to community consultation. We immediately began stakeholder consultation poke with stakeholders in the community of Port Hood. Community members and stakeholders were contacted to inform the design firm on their area of expertise in relation to Port Hood. These interviews supported the preparation of an early analysis of opportunities and constraints which informed the development of the conceptual plan. Stakeholders Stakeholders brought forth a variety of issues, often directly or indirectly related to bringing people into the community- both as residents and as tourists. Many voiced concern surrounding the decreasing population base of Port Hood. Residents are moving out west looking for jobs, the local high school has closed due to lack of students, and there is fear that the elementary school will soon face the same fate. The general consensus was that Port Hood needs an economic generator to sustain the community, help local businesses grow and attract new businesses. needs to be upgraded to attract tourists. A marina was a common suggestion as a way to bring tourists into the area. A marina offers a docking opportunity for those coming by boat, and a pleasant atmosphere for those walking around town. In cooperation with the development of a marina, the need to better maintain the wharf, shoreline, and breakwater around Port Hood was a concern. Both the arena and the RV Park were highlighted as major drivers in attracting people to Port Hood, and are seen as linked to one another’s success. In the summer the arena attracts people to the area and the RV Park gives them a place to stay. The feedback collected through the stakeholder interviews do not represent the consensus of the town, however they highlight elements of some importance to the general community for the design firm to consider. Community Workshop On April 14th the consulting team led a community workshop in Port Hood where we worked with nearly 100 community members to identify opportunities and challenges relating to future development in Port Hood. From this exercise the consulting team was able to focus their design efforts on the areas of Port Hood that the community felt were important. What we heard overwhelmingly was that the focus should be on three physical areas: »» The Waterfront »» Main Street »» Highway 19 A recurring suggestion to improve the vitality of the community was an increased tourism base. However, to attract people to spend an extended period of time in the area many feel that improvements to existing infrastructure are needed. Infrastructure highlighted to be repaired included main roads and docks. Residents feel that Port Hood has much to offer in terms of natural beauty, and improved roadways can promote a scenic drive for tourists. As well, many participants stated that the overall aesthetics of the town and its buildings Fig. 12 Community Workshop 17 Online Survey To reach an even greater cross section of people, including summer residents of Port Hood, an online survey was launched the evening of the Community Workshop. The questions were in line with the direction of the workshop and the results of both methods of outreach resulted in similar feedback from the community. The most telling questions from the outreach focused on qualitative responses. Question: For a visitor / resident / business Port Hood is all about ... Key words were taken from each of the openended responses, and then ranked. The top five words for each question are illustrated in Fig. 13. Respondents noted that beaches were valued by both visitors and residents. Additionally, people, community and family were recurring themes. Relaxation was also a frequent topic when considering visitors in Port Hood. For business, responses focused on the challenges of survival and longevity year round, noting that community support is needed to help sustain business. Many responses also noted the opportunity and potential to take advantage of the summer months and increased tourism in the area. 18 Question: What do you believe are opportunities for the future of the Port Hood area? Question: List three SPECIFIC elements of the community that set Port Hood apart Survey respondents were asked to consider major development opportunities for the Port Hood area. Key words, topics, themes and ideas were drawn out of each of the open-ended responses. Some responses included more general issues and opportunities, while others suggested specific ideas. The themes and suggestions are illustrated with recurring comments appearing in larger text in Fig. 14 on the opposite page. For analysis of this question each response was distilled down to key words and then sorted and tallied based on how ofter the key word was raised. Each response was assigned a point value – the top response for each respondent was given 3 points, the second was given 2 points, and the third given 1 point. The total points were then added up for each word, and a final ranking was created. Specific issues that were noted frequently include limited access to Lawrence’s Beach, maintenance of the Government Wharf, potential for a marina, issues regarding the seasonal nature of Port Hood, and population aging and decline. More general comments included limited finances and funding, limited services and amenities and a need for maintenance and infrastructure improvements. Opportunities for the future included expanding tourism through a marina, campground expansion, additional recreational facilities and services, and improvements to the wharf and Murphy’s Pond. Many of the responses included ways to enhance the abundance of natural features, and provide the services and amenities to make Port Hood a summer destination. The top ten responses are illustrated with bubbles sized to reflect the total points in Fig. 15. What stands out is the emphasis on natural features, more specifically the beaches, trails, islands and sunsets. Additionally, many responses noted that the people, community, culture and history of Port Hood are unique and important to the respondents. Marina Golf course Small scale food production Wharf improvemenets Public washrooms Buy local Warm waters Tuna charters Small business development Natural beauty Skill building and job training Garbage cans Summer destination List three SPECIFIC elements that set Port Hood apart from other areas For a visitor Port Hood is all about: Beaches (22.8%) People (8.8%) Relaxation (7.6%) Scenery (7.0%) Friendliness (4.0%) Activities (3.5%) For a resident Port Hood is all about: Community (25.2%) Family (13.3%) Beaches (4.4%) PEI Ferry Murphy’s Pond Boat tours Fisheries Marina Warm waters Boat, kayak, canoe, bike rental Wharf improvemenets Tuna charters Accommodations Restaurants and shopping Public washrooms History Cafe and bakery Colindale Road improvements Highway signage Friends (3.7%) Boardwalk expansion and connection Garbage cans For a business Port Hood is all about: Survival & Longevity (18.7%) Culture Recreational facilities Beauty (3.7%) Safety (3.7%) Beaches People Sunsets Community Views Winter trails Beach improvements Support (14.7%) Golf course Opportunity & Potential (6.7%) Expanded campground Community (5.3%) Natural beauty Natural Features Islands Trails Seasonal (5.3%) Tourism (5.3%) Fig. 13 Perception of Place Fig. 14 Opportunities Wordle Fig. 15 Unique Identifiers 19 Photo credit: Bob Martin 20 3. Brand & Positioning 3.1 Community Background Brand development goes hand-in-hand with Ekistics’ community development plan for Port Hood. Community development is all about refining and re-purposing existing infrastructure in order to position a community for growth. Brand development helps to further re-establish the community by helping it define and focus on one major strength--and then market that strength to the world. Finding one major strength that encapsulates a community can sometimes be a challenge, however, Ekistics took the lead right away and began consulting Port Hood residents for their insights and feedback. The response from locals was nothing short of impressive. People of Port Hood clearly demonstrated they wanted to be part of the development process, responding in record numbers to our online survey/questionnaire. The community consultation process ran parallel to a research phase, where we read through a ream of helpful data, notably the Destination Inverness Strategic Tourism Plan Final Report. The document focused on marketing Inverness County as a whole-but it contained some very powerful insights that can be applied to the marketing of Port Hood. 3.2 Brand Insights The Strategic Tourism Plan noted how Cape Breton Island is internationally recognized for its breathtaking coastal touring—and “coastal experience” ranks as one of the top primary travel motivators to the island. (page ii, Destination Inverness Strategic Tourism Plan Final Report). The report also clearly states that “any tourism strategy for Inverness County must focus in part on beaches and beach access.” (page iv) Photo credit: Bob Martin Fig. 16 Port Hood Sunset 21 One of the strongest reasons for supporting this recommendation rests on visitor demand. Page ten of the report points out how “participation in outdoor activities was…higher among Cape Breton Island visitors (62%) compared with all Nova Scotia visitors (39%).” Based on this statistic, it’s easy to conclude that visitors clearly identify and enjoy everything Cape Breton Island has to offer— outdoors. If coastal experience and outdoor activities rank high on a visitors’ list to Cape Breton Island, then Port Hood is very well positioned and equipped; home to one of the finest coastal experiences in Inverness County, a stunningly beautiful series of sandy beaches alongside uncommonly warm waters. to spend a day at Port Hood. Simply put, Port Hood beach is a natural outdoor/ coastal experience that deserves greater promotion and marketing. Yes, there are many other things Port Hood has to share—from the boardwalk to the wetlands to Port Hood Island. But it all begins with the beach. The beach is the entry point—the drawing card--that stands to get visitors off the highway and into the town. Armed with these insights, the challenge became: how best to position Port Hood as a premier coastal experience in Inverness County. A strong convergence of opinion in the online survey/questionnaire and other stakeholder activities was noted. The community of Port Hood sees a lot of potential in their beach as a coastal experience and outdoor activity. An overwhelming number of respondents (40%) pointed to the beach as the community’s strongest asset. Anecdotal information also had a role to play in the branding process. Ekistics team members have a connection to Inverness County that goes beyond the professional. In our personal lives, several team members regularly vacation in the Port HoodMabou-Inverness area, while others have family in the county. The brand development process tapped into those personal insights as well. For example, anecdotally we know that Port Hood’s beaches rank high on the list of outdoor activities by native Cape Bretoners. Judique, Creignish and Troy are home to several nice beaches and yet people in these communities generally prefer to drive up the road Photo credit: Bob Martin Photo credit: Bob Martin Photo credit: Bob Martin Fig. 17 Port Hood Beaches 22 3.3 Brand Position Port Hood is first among equals when it comes to beaches. There are many communities up and down route 19 that have a beach—some are decent and others are very nice—but only Port Hood comes through with five superb beaches. (Lawrence’s, Boardwalk, Wharf, Lifeguard and Murphy’s Pond). So, let’s celebrate the fact with a marketing idea that places Port Hood as THE location for beaches in Cape Breton. We’re pulling out the stops and laying down the gauntlet with… Port Hood: The Beach Capital of Cape Breton. With this statement, our message is clear and confident: Port Hood is the king of beaches in Inverness County and beyond, offering up a style of sand & surf to suit everyone’s taste, from quiet and secluded to comfy and communal. It’s all here! Community reaction to this idea was overwhelmingly positive by the vast majority of people. They recognized the potential of the idea right away--an idea that encapsulates and celebrates Port Hood’s greatest asset. Comments and feedback were very constructive, focusing primarily on how we can extend this brand idea beyond standard beach months--July through August. We readily agree. To be truly strong and of value to the community, this idea must extend beyond the classic summer months and into the fall/ shoulder season. The following pages contain some creative ideas and renderings designed to bring out the best in this brand idea. 23 A Beac Ceped h for Ev eryone ! moloru m vole sequas , omnim et vid q o enim uosam molore porio vo faccus mos exc luptis e dolorio epudic aquun essimo ie diti ut q t fugit o tore po ue pro d iti as sun res et volecte d re it, p nis vel ed ut q m volo u m i o aut de rpor au llam sedita reptiis t reste eum nectiae m nect us et q stiorep acea a ue dem udaep utatum e q d u ic a m to dolo , ium si rum la elent la nci volo boribu tur? Ate rep taq s uis et u non exe aut volu t lam, te rovit, su ptatis vo ntius s verspe luptae. rae ace serchil is net ium Annua l Festiv als nossim a xima xim eve sequia lita ius sunt ha assit, e rum co licate m fugias nsecae possec volorro stem e tibus, q u ictor a ae volo us eius dollupta e t oditiori et facc s ut et s u e m ntorro q uiatu dunt re to s b a lam id rciis co bores dolend untirporep cit volu a pello erro dis re peliq ptae sa sum qu uindenim e nos u resequ u t s a a s tur, qu atem e quo do i quatu arum h lesr adita arupta ic tu ri tu b e videl us, odig r, sam ipsae vo nat op con eve tatatem luptior l evend as ere etumq rchi liq itaero uis eum q to u is ta si tu t dolup uo bla r ionese tae vellabo que do nusam . Adi co llu p tatem re dolu ressita lique e. Nam pta nis aut do usa as nobis a lorae n ma udae la os eniti bore d venet a dolorro i su s cum ccum q dolore aut ui cor si non ea comniti que do nt earu non re luptist mquae sciunt. etur aru m aliata te et, mest The war the nd waters a pitality t hos warmes for Join us ster our Lob Picnic ! Festivals d.ca PortHoo Fig. 18 Port Hood Brand Deployment 24 PO Box 24 Port Ho , od B0E 2W , NS 0 902-62 3-2252 PortHo od.ca porthood.ca NEWS & EVENTS | CONTACT US ABOUT THINGS TO DO WHERE TO STAY PLAN YOUR TRIP LOCATION GALLERY THE WARMEST WATERS & THE WARMEST HOSPITALITY Join us all year long! We have activities to keep you busy year round. So join us today! SUNSETS THAT STOP YOU IN YOUR STEPS & START YOUR HEART BOOK YOUR VACATION NOW THE WARMEST WATERS & THE WARMEST HOSPITALITY WE’VE BEEN EXPECTING YOU Port Hood is a vibrant, seaside community on the west coast of Cape Breton Island, and the capital of Inverness County, Nova Scotia. You’ll find us on the Ceilidh Trail, approximately 30 minutes north from the Canso Causeway, which links mainland Nova Scotia to Cape Breton Island. We have miles of sandy beaches on the warmest waters in eastern Canada. We host the annual Chestico Days and Lobster Picnic festivals. We are the home of NHL Hall of Famer Al MacInnis, CFL champion Bruce Beaton, the late “Godfather of Celtic Music” John Allan Cameron, and former Olympian Duncan Gillis, not to mention 2008 Canadian Idol runner-up, Mitch MacDonald! 2014 PORT HOODIE NOW AVAILABLE! Buy One Now! PO Box 24, Port Hood, NS B0E 2W0 [email protected] SUNSETS THAT STOP YOU IN YOUR STEPS & START YOUR HEART TRY NOVA SCOTIAN CUISINE AT ITS FINEST CURRENT WEATHER Monday May 26, 2014 Sunny with cloudy periods 20ºC Water Tempurature 16ºC Fig. 19 Port Hood Envisioned Web Presence 25 26 4. Conceptual Development Plan 4.1 Concept The Conceptual Development Plan that is presented in this chapter has been created with an eye to all sides of development. Within this plan we are providing policy, program, and capital investment direction for Port Hood and consideration of all of these factors is needed if the community is going to take full advantage of the assets available to it. The projects are described in detail here, with consideration of scalability in all cases. Each speaks to the specific challenges faced by Port Hood and if implemented well all will work to alleviate the stresses caused by challenging demographics and economics of Cape Breton in 2014. Plan Statement What became clear through analysis and outreach is that the community of Port Hood is at risk of dividing attention between two potentially conflicting identities. On one hand the summer brings a relaxing atmosphere that takes advantage of the natural surroundings and amenities that the North Western edge of Cape Breton Island provides. On the other hand, this is a community whose core is being bypassed by many Cape Bretoners and tourists with minimal advantage to the town. Fig. 20 Community Work 27 In conducting brand and positioning research for Port Hood there were clear directions for where development plans should focus, and while the work done here is not as “on the nose” as the proposed branding concept it does point fervently toward the Beach and the waterfront as areas of strength and best opportunity for the community. The vision for Port Hood that offers the greatest opportunity for success is one that takes all the advantages of the Beach identity and applies them to help ensure that the identity as being off the beaten path does not jeopardize future stability and success. The hope for Port Hood lies in the amazing experiences on the waterfront and beaches. Historic infrastructure development, the natural setting, and the combined opportunities of the Ceilidh Trail conspire against Port Hood and don’t provide optimal visibility for these natural amenities. That said, Port Hood has practical advantages beyond it’s beaches, there is great access to the Ceilidh Trail, a traditional core that holds the county seat for the Municipality of Inverness, and zoning and development that is supportive of capturing traffic along Route 19. These advantages together do not compete with an minimize the natural assets but rather they support development of the natural assets for purposes of sustaining the community that lives and works in this wonderful corner of Cape Breton Island. 28 The Vision presented here, and supported by the conceptual plan is one of a community that captures, entices, and entertains. Investment in Port Hood should work to capture the attention of users of Route 19, entice those who are open to coming to town, and entertain those who make the choice to come and spend time here. This plan addresses the perceived needs of Cape Bretoners and with that provide a path to sharing the absolute best face of the community to the tourists who pass by on a regular basis. Capture the mind of the tourist coming to Cape Breton, the attention of the commuter driving past, and the support of the residents of the Port Hood Area. Entice with coordinated efforts by local business, and with continued interest as you travel in town. Entertain with amenities suited to Port Hood’s strengths, by taking advantage of the natural setting, and by collaborating with successful enterprise. 4.2 Physical Plan Components Building from past plans, research, and community feedback the Conceptual Development Plan emphasizes interactions with the waterfront and the experience on and traveling from Route 19 to the waterfront. Fig. 21 shows the five opportunity sites where we have focused design efforts for this project. To ensure that residents as well as visitors to the Ceilidh Trail notice these improvements, significant efforts have been placed on improving the physical gateways (#1 in Fig. 21) that signal your arrival in Port Hood while traveling on the Ceilidh Trail. From these gateways we follow the desire lines to the waterfront through two areas that will benefit from increased attention - the Main Street Façade District (#2) and the Civic Core (#3). Experiences on the beaches and waterfront benefit from improved infrastructure in the Plan, looking specifically at Wharf/Lifeguard Beaches (#4) and Murphy’s Pond (#5). These interventions are described in detail, with illustrated plans and perspective renderings to help communicate the desired effect of each intervention. 5 Murphy’s Pond Beach Improvements 4 Community Core 3 2 Facade District 1 Route 19 Corridor Legend Opportunity Areas 2,220 cars per day Gateways Beaches Route 19 Fig. 21 Conceptual Development Components 0 250 500 1000 2000m 29 4.2.1. Ceilidh Trail Gateways Central to the capturing component of the Plan is an effort to slow the high volume of traffic that flows on Route 19 on a daily basis. The intent is to ensure that when you arrive in Port Hood on the Ceilidh Trail, you should feel as though you have arrived somewhere and have the opportunity to stop and explore this place. Currently a single branded gateway road sign points the way into Port Hood, it is directed toward north bound traffic at the southern end of Port Hood. There are recent developments near this gateway to allow for business opportunity in Port Hood on the Ceilidh Trail, an increase will only help enforce the feeling of arrival on the main thoroughfare in Eastern Cape Breton & Inverness County. Zoning & Land Assembly Zoning changes to allow for continued commercial development along Route 19 should be considered as part of the MPS and LUB reviews that the Eastern District Planning Commission is scheduled to undertake in the near future. There are currently 11 parcels that are zoned either Rural or Urban Residential in the area between the Denmore Road and Main Street intersections, of these the largest is the new school. We recognize that rezoning the school lands is not ideal but establishment of property utility with the School Board may allow for small segments of the property to be swapped with the town for potential future development. The plan for the Northern Gateway shown within Fig. 23 would require this sort of negotiation to allow for the full development opportunity as shown. While simply rezoning may lead to future development along the Port Hood Route 19 axis, a more aggressive approach could include land acquisition & assembly. Creating larger commercial pads that would be attractive for commercial interests that target the entire region. An active and informed Development Society could assist in By creating and supporting commercial development opportunities, parkland, and streetscape improvements (providing visual cues to the nature of Port Hood) the Plan addresses economic needs with respect to tourism as well as with respect to local economic growth. The capturing of the traveler will lead to opportunities for them to see and do more in the traditional core and waterfront of Port Hood. The development plan includes the following interventions along Route 19. Signage & Branding The new brand identity should be integrated into new signage that is placed in locations that allow for fast moving traffic to recognize the opportunity and have time to make a decision to enter Port Hood. This includes the current location and a mirrored location to the North of the second gateway as shown in Fig. 23.. 30 Fig. 22 Highway 19 Design for Interaction Fig. 23 Highway 19 Commercial Clustering 31 S A FR SE A FR R ST EX T BA FI E LL LD RD UP PER D HIGH R S O U THW 1,500 DU N C AN OM P CO M PA N Y RO AD EX TE N CLAN RANALD RD MO R Y RD ER D SH O AR N DR Fig. 24 Zoning planning and support these activities if undertaken by the municipality. Streetscape HIGHWAY 19 In addition to helping to create an identity for Port Hood on Route 19 this strategy will also bring added tax revenue and activity on a year round basis as regional services locate in this area. The imagery shared showing the potential streetscape and pedestrian environment on Route 19 is aspirational. The plan considers conditions along the high volume corridor and envisions a pedestrian environment that is protected from the traffic through intense plantings and amenity placement. by installation of these features at the edge of the right of way will assist in naturally slowing drivers, ushering into the community opportunity for highway commercial uses as well as an identity for Port Hood that is on the Ceilidh Trail rather than being just off the Ceilidh Trail. It is important that when proceeding with these suggested improvements communication is MAPLE GROVE RD facilitated with the Nova Scotia Department of Transportation and Infrastructure Renewal (TIR). BARBE R RD Port Hood faces a challenge that many small municipalities in Nova Scotia face in understanding how new development and infrastructure on local Provincial roads can be built so that it relates to the roadway and provides a sense of place rather than simply being a series of driveways and parking lots. The psychological narrowing of the travel way CA M KENZ 32 HUGH IES LN IE LAN E South Gateway The South Gateway into Port Hood is defined for the purposes of this plan as the area around the intersection of Route 19 and Main Street. The area has long been the location of the Port Hood welcome sign (Home of Al MacInnis) and with its location at a bluff overlooking the beaches and Port Hood Island there is significant opportunity here to capture traffic from Route 19 with a memorable experience that offers exposure to the strengths of Port Hood. The recommendation within this plan is to replace the welcome signage with new signage that matches the brand and positioning that Port Hood will move forward with. The branded gateway sign will provide direct information and subtle hints as to the experience that is available in the core of Port EST M ABO U Hood and on the beaches. Building from and around the signage, the plan creates the opportunity for a park built around the Sewage and Water Treatment facilities, creating walking paths and look offs that will allow visitors to stop and take in the views of the strait and Port Hood Island. Highway commercial zoning has been implemented in this area of Route 19. As discussed previously, current construction of a new regional scale Home Hardware store is a positive sign that there may be some appetite for this type of development in Port Hood. Opposite the Home Hardware the seasonal Four Maid Gift shop / Clove Hitch Bar & Bistro has the opportunity to remain open through the year if there is even a small change in the number of people who are destined for Port Hood from areas throughout Inverness County. impact on Route 19 motorists with relatively amount of development footprint. Suggestions for this area include consolidation of land and aggressive marketing of the opportunities’ by a public, or nonprofit agency with interests in the development of Port Hood. Regardless of the timeline of the potential development at this Gateway, it is imperative that the Development Society investigates the possibility for a second welcome sign that address travelers coming from North to South. This sign should be identical in design and messaging to the sign that is recommended for the South Gateway (Fig. 18). There is a subtle but significant change in the road alignment where High Road turns into Denmore Road. An effort should be made at the next opportunity to improve the legibility of the intersection, the dominant alignment should be the High to Denmore path, but current infrastructure still suggests the historic continuation of High Road that is currently a dead end. Improvements such as these should be made on an “as the opportunity arises” basis, but it is important that they get done to nudge local infrastructure toward the future that is desired rather than the past that is no longer relevant. Throughout both Gateways the commercial developments have been shown addressing the street and providing the opportunity to create an environment that supports a little walking around in addition to the expected autocentricity of large scale commercial uses. North Gateway The current state of the North Gateway (the intersection of Denmore Road and Route 19) is – to be polite – underwhelming. There is little to tell motorists what opportunities lie just off Route 19 in Port Hood, and the total lack of activity on neighbouring lands communicates that this is more of a controlled access highway then the secondary entrance to the Beach Capital of Cape Breton. Fig. 25 shows the current visual sensation as one drives North on Route 19. The vision for this intersection is highlighted by intense commercial growth at all four corners of the intersection. Modestly scaled buildings (1 – 2 storeys, three to seven thousand square foot floor plans) are placed in the four corners, creating a noticeable Fig. 25 Highway 19 Northern Gateway Today 33 4.2.2. Main Street Facade District Façade programs have a history of successful implementation throughout Cape Breton, initiatives in Cheticamp, St. Peters, Mabou, and North Sydney have all helped increase the curb appeal of – and pride in – Cape Breton communities. This success has led to the continued proliferation of such initiatives in practice and policy. Destination Cape Breton Corporation continues to include Façade programs as part of their strategic planning for the Tourism sector. This Conceptual Development Plan finds within Port Hood a suitably commercial strip that has several opportunity spots and existing businesses that will benefit for coordinated façade improvements. Fig. 26 shows the limits of the area that is best situated for a façade improvement district. Details & Eligibility In similar projects funding models have been offered whereby property owners of commercial spaces could access shared funding for the façade improvements. Consideration of the following terms is important in setting up the façade program: »» Set a cap for program spending in the entire district. »» Set a limit for individual commercial property owners on a per linear foot of building frontage basis. »» Grant funds only to commercial property owners »» Partnership with business tenant (if different from owners) allowable but focus for shared cost capital improvements should be for permanent infrastructure »» Grant funds for materials and labour The funding source is usually accomplished through a cost-sharing program between municipal, provincial, and federal initiatives. It is the recommendation of this plan to create the proposed façade district. nd hE s ort e er N Suppli m r Fo ding l i u B 1 ot Dep Fire Carrying from the overall theme and vision of this plan, the Main Street Façade district works to entice those traveling through Port Hood providing thematic queues to the recreation opportunities available through the beach and waterfront amenities. t Pos ada Can ary r Lib This section concludes with sample façade improvements for businesses on Main Street (between High Road and Route 19) within the district. M ood pF O Co- et ark 6 ens ffice O erm Fish p and O 2 Cooom R g inin Bar 3 D am Cre e n 4 Ic o i n it U red 5 C Fig. 26 Facade District Proposed Boundaries 34 By launching the program with a known cap on the total spending there will be enticement for commercial property owners to engage early while funds are available. This report includes general details on pricing to help assist the façade program in communicating the magnitude of potential expenses associated with façade improvement. Façade Styles »» Signage should be placed in areas originally dedicated for placement - in the sign band about the storefront, in windows, projecting from storefronts, or on awnings. »» The area of the storefront is where retail creativity can be unleashed. »» Use durable, low maintenance materials. »» If the original colour, detail, and materials are known, and if they meet modern fire safety requirements, use them. In keeping with the strong position of Port Hood as a beach brand and opportunity the Conceptual Development Plan advocates for a fun and summer evoking colourful style to the façade improvement program. Using a selection of bright hues and materials that evoke sandy beaches, the façade district will help ensure that the community encourages people to think of the waterfront and the beaches as they make their way through town. Façade Design Guidelines To assist in the creation of Facade Design Guidelines we crafted principles to assist the team when thinking about buildings in Port Hood; (i) the history and character of Port Hood is a valuable asset, (ii) all eras are part of this history, no single period is more important than another, (iii) Port Hood should look like everyone cares for it, and (iv) Port Hood is at its best in the bright summer months. Fig. 27 Example Facade 35 Sample Façade Improvements The following samples were produced to show the range of changes that might be expected for a facade program in Port Hood using the design principles outlined here. Efforts have been made in creating these conceptual facade improvements to show a brighter, livelier side of Port Hood. The bright colours allude to the sunny summer days that are the highlight of the calendar in Port Hood. Fig. 28 Facades Before & After 36 37 4.2.3. Civic Centre The meeting of High Road and Main Street is an important junction in Port Hood. Both these avenues provide exit and entry points to Route 19, as well as connection through this intersection to Colindale Road, and several public institutions and amenities are already located in the vicinity of this intersection. As an important civic landmark the convergence of the two roads should be a memorable experience for all those who enter. Traffic Circle While traffic at this location doesn’t necessarily require a traffic circle the lines of sight are important, and a traffic circle facilitates an installation at the intersection of the sightlines without taking away too much roadway. Fig. 30 shows the intersection of the lines of sight, while Fig.29 shows one of many ways to take advantage of the excessive space available at this intersection currently. Community Park & Playground It should be noted that the removal of “The Home of Al MacInnis” from the gateway signage is in no way meant to diminish the accomplishments of Mr. MacInnis or his role as a supporter of his hometown. Considering the bevy of high-level athletes who have hailed from this area, the Conceptual Development Plan considers a great opportunity to highlight the sporting history of Port Hood in the Community Park. Individual acknowledgment of the champions who have hailed from Port Hood would be integrated into the interpretation program at the park, with the ability to recognize many more athletes and place current successful athletes on the same plane as legends from the past. Additionally, an expansion of the playground – with better connection to Fraser Street and the Community Garden – will be a great investment in the young families that are choosing to stay and live in Port Hood. The investment in the Civic Core would build upon the investments made in the sidewalk and pedestrian lighting along Main Street and would provide a walkable destination for most – if not all – residents of Port Hood. Wedge Park & Shade Pavilion The plan improves upon the public realm in this location in many ways, most notably by capturing underutilized land and converting it into public spaces. The function of this revitalized centre will be to act as the civic hub for Port Hood residents and residents of neighbouring communities. The facilities detailed in this plan will support public gathering at times of celebration (Christmas Tree Lightings, Canada Day, Remembrance Day, etc.) and provide more appropriate park facilities within Port Hood. Fig. 29 Redesigned Intersection of High Road and Main Street 38 Fig. 30 High Road / Main Street Intersection 39 4.2.4. Beaches Recognizing the success of the beaches and their place in the hearts and minds of residents and visitors it is important that substantial investment is made to ensure that the opportunity for economic development arising out of their use is capitalized upon, without sacrificing the benefits of having a serene beach environment. By having improvements aimed at enhancing the beach experience for families and tourists focused on the area that is already heavily used we will avoid promoting undue stress on other, more sensitive beaches in the area. Special attention has been paid to the design of the public beach and wharf, as Port Hood’s beaches are vital to the implementation strategy for the Conceptual Development Plan. Public Access Public access has been improved to the Wharf Beach and the Lifeguard Beach by the addition of a formal boardwalk, with washrooms, change rooms, and new kiosks. On-site parking, improving access, reinforces the formal entrance. Supporting this formal entrance are multiple smaller, informal beach access points along the length of Wharf Beach. These access points consist of trails, which are located off the road with roadside parking. All entrances visually invite people to the site. The kiosks located along the boardwalk offer beach goers a variety of products and experiences. They create seasonal, local, commercial opportunities for the Port Hood community. The activity created by the service of these kiosks can offer a diverse experience in combination with recreational beach activities, drawing people to the area. 40 Fig. 31 Central Beaches Fire Pits Wharf Reconstruction The addition of public fire pits along the Wharf beach extending into a portion of the Lifeguard Beach creates additional recreational opportunity stimulating beach use through the day, and through the shoulder seasons. Fire pits are extremely popular destinations for tourists and residents. Areas such as South California have become known for their inclusion of fire pits along the beach, with people lining up as early as 5 am to reserve a pit. The existing wharf is in disrepair and unsafe for use. The prevailing winds in the area are southwesterly, making the docking experience and maintenance on the south side of the wharf challenging. For this reason, the T-shape of the current wharf has been altered in favour of floating docks located on the Northside of the wharf, protected from the wind and slosh. Additionally, the floating docks can be removed from the water in the winter, extending the lifespan of the infrastructure and reducing maintenance requirements. Fire pits offer gathering spots for entertainment and sharing, and create a pleasant atmosphere for both users of the pit and those simply walking along the beach. The communal experience of sitting at a fire and talking through the evening will imprint on people’s memories and draw them back year after year. Fire pits extend the hours of use along the water, keeping people late into the night, and improving the safety of the area. The nearby RV Park compliments the location of fire pits along Wharf Beach. Fig. 32 Active Central Beaches 41 4.2.5. Murphy’s Pond The location of the commercial fishery in Port Hood is coincidently located adjacent to the premier local vantage point for scenic vistas to the North face of Port Hood Island and the Northumberland Strait. By creating a landmark attraction and opportunities for physical recreation and entertainment at this location we create a pole at the north end of the community that doesn’t currently exist. This is in line with the well-supported 2004 plan, the updated concepts fit well within the overall brand and plan presented within this project. Lookoff Park The natural bluff at the North of Port Hood provides brilliant vistas that currently are accessible but not optimized as a destination. The concept Plan envisions a landmark feature on the site, potentially cantilevering off the edge of the cliff to accentuate the views and relationship to the Northumberland Strait. With increased traffic, interpretation of Port Hood Island becomes an added attraction at the site. The striking views of the homesteads on the Island and the opportunity to view both the Town of Port Hood and the Island in a single vista present a wonderful opportunity for delving into the relationship between these two sides of the Harbour. Parking for Lookoff Park Anticipating that many visitors will drive to this site, a properly appointed parking facility has been added to the site to support visitors. The 28 parking spaces proposed equal roughly the parking capacity of the Boardwalk Beach parking lot at the South end of Port Hood, albeit with better infrastructure support here at Murphy’s Pond (curbing, pavement, sidewalks, etc.). Fig. 33 Look Off Rendering 42 Fig. 34 Murphy’s Pond 43 Kiosk at Wharf boats be facilitated at the site. Murphy’s Pond Trail The active commercial fishery is a great opportunity to engage visitors to Port Hood, the Tuna season brings a large quantity of boats to the Harbour and is the sort of local economic driver that should be offered up as a unique Cape Breton experience. The addition of recreation to the usage at the Harbour will soften the impact of the busy commercial space and help smooth out peaks and troughs throughout the year with respect to usage of the Harbour. By situating a small kiosk, either information based or commercial, there creates a welcoming location amongst the Commercial infrastructure for people interested in tours, potential ferry service to Port Hood Island, and even Kayak rentals for day use in Murphy’s Pond itself. The suggested improvements include new regularized parking and access to the breakwaters / jettys, as well as new gangways and floating docks for supporting recreational use. Murphy’s Pond is a fascinating natural water body neighbouring the Commercial fishery in Port Hood. As part of the Conceptual Development Plan a trail and boardwalk system is proposed that will allow for complete circumnavigation of the 1km loop around the Pond. This short trail is the perfect length for locals using the trail for exercise, families with young children, and - again - opportunities for serenity and relaxation in Port Hood. While segments over marshy lands at the commencement of the trail are proposed as boardwalk, the majority of the trail is conceptualized as a natural walking trail. As an added benefit, the physical installation among the Murphy’s Pond wharf helps everyone understand that this place is primarily for Commercial uses, but we have to make room for locals and visitors who want to be part of the action (in a controlled manner). Marina Wharf Improvements The Marina Wharf facility is recognized as a Small Craft Harbour by the Federal Department of Fisheries and Oceans. The facility is managed by the Port Hood Harbour Authority and is designated as a Core Fishing Harbour. Continued erosion and deterioration of the breakwaters has provided the opportunity for potential Federal investment in the repair and reconfiguration of this facility. As this process is underway, with the driving force being the local Harbour Authority led by Frances Gillies, the Conceptual Development Plan only signifies that additions of recreational (power & sail) Fig. 35 Port Hood from Murphy’s Pond Lookoff 44 Fig. 36 Examples of Actual Build Out of Concepts & Programming 45 4.2.5. Signage & Wayfinding The suggested improvements in this plan aim to create easy to maintain, enjoyable spaces that will attract visitors to the town and encourage extended visits. As an added enhancement, the Conceptual Development Plan suggests several classes of signage that will assist Port Hood in communicating the brand and positioning that is desired. Some aspects of signage have been discussed already, this section summarizes all signage and provides examples with the proposed brand, or best practice examples from other jurisdictions. Fig. 38 on the opposite page shows proposed locations of each type of signage in each of the four Conceptual Development Plan Areas. and how long they will have to make a decision once spotting a gateway sign. The southern gateway sign benefits from a natural bend in the roadway, that draws motorists attention to the curve and primes them to a decision even before they recognize the gateway sign for what it is. The northern gateway sign however is suggested for placement on a straight stretch of Route 19. Considering speeds in excess of 80 km/h drivers would have less than 4s to respond to a gateway sign that they see at a distance of 80m from the turning point. The Conceptual Development Plan places the northern gateway sign at a distance of 100m from the turning point to allow for visual recognition up to 200m away and a decision making time line in the 10s range. Notably, Gateway Signage should include the visual identity for Port Hood, but also some idea of what opportunities await in Port Hood, and specifically on the Beach and Waterfront. Iconography should be deployed that is consistent with standard messaging in Nova Scotia, and that identifies the best opportunities in Port Hood. Based on the Conceptual Development Plan, iconography representing a supervised beach, vistas & views, trails, boating, dining, and hospitality – at a minimum – should be displayed along Route 19. Wayfinding & Directional Signage Wayfinding signs should be deployed at key decision points throughout the town. The determination of the content of such signs will depend on the direction that is taken in implementing this plan. Building from the brand and positioning work a clear direction for signage is readily attainable. The focus on the beach and graphic detailing as defined earlier should carry through all signage. Gateway Signage Fig. 37 shows a potential gateway sign for Port Hood, this example is built from the form of the current installation and is a fine example to pull from for queues on size, legibility, and materials. In designing gateway signage it is imperative that we consider the speed at which vehicles are traveling Fig. 37 Proposed Gateway Sign 46 Interpretive Panels Community Maps Wayfinding Fig. 38 Proposed Sign Locations Gateway Signs 47 Community Maps At key locations throughout Port Hood the installation of Community Maps will help visitors understand where they are in relation to other services as well as provide a reserved advertising opportunity for the business of Port Hood. These highly graphical maps should communicate with visitors who are unfamiliar with the area and provide structure for referencing both planned public spaces and the named beaches that form Port Hood. Community maps are located at locations that are frequented by visitors, such as public open spaces, the beaches, and trail heads. The design and fabrication of this map should be standardized to ensure quick roll out as new public amenities are created. Potential locations for first installations include Summer Sands, the Community Park & Playground, and the existing Beach kiosks. Interpretive Panels SPRING SUMMER FALL PORT HOOD HAS IT ALL LIFEGUARD BEACH WHARF BEACH LAWRENCE’S BEACH MURPHY’S POND BEACH BOARDWALK BEACH The public open spaces that have been proposed in this Conceptual Development Plan are each unique gathering places for the community in Port Hood, they are spaces that have been located and designed with an eye to the history and strengths of Port Hood. Each is an ideal location for Port Hood to tell its stories. Interpretive Panels and monuments are an ideal way to tell these stories and build community capacity through their development. Further, the stories they tell in these public spaces become the way in which visitors can participate in a deeper dive into the history and culture that makes Port Hood so special. 48 Fig. 39 Possible Deployment of Brand in New Signage The Chestico Heritage Society is an ideal partner in developing these stories and in the positioning of Port Hood and its history as an opportunity for engaging locals and visitors. Developing an interpretive program is an important step in ensuring that the development of Interpretive Panels is not scattershot, and is done with an eye to the most engaging stories to be told about Port Hood. Summary The Conceptual Development Plan that has been presented in this chapter follows and flows from the brand and positioning work. Together these efforts form an opportunity for development in Port Hood that responds to the desires of the community, fits with small town planning best practice, addresses economic, social, and recreational needs, and will ensure that Port Hood stands out among the many amazing offerings of the Ceilidh Trail and Inverness County. Throughout this introduction to the Conceptual Development Plan allusions have been made to implementation strategies and potential partnerships. In the following chapter these details will be fleshed out to provide direction to the Port Hood and Area Development Society, the Municipality of Inverness County, and the Eastern District Planning Commission in ensuring that Port Hood can capture the potential that exists among the stakeholders, residents, and businesses that were consulted throughout the planning process. Fig. 40 Example Community Maps & Wayfinding 49 50 5. Implementation The challenges that face small and medium sized communities in Nova Scotia and Cape Breton are significant. Success in development and in providing for the quality of life of citizens should begin with a conceptual plan, but it should lead to a clear implementation strategy. All proposed policy, infrastructure, and design changes within the Port Hood Conceptual Development Plan – be they private or public – must strive to achieve the development goals set out in the Municipal Planning Strategy for Port Hood as well as the individual goals of each project. The idea that either the Private or Public Sector can solve the challenges facing Port Hood on their own will not help enable the community to capitalize on the opportunities in front of them. The implementation strategy presents phasing and capital cost estimates (where possible) for each of the components of the Conceptual Development Plan. 5.1 Component Implementation opportunity sites on Route 19. Ceilidh Trail Gateways South Gateway Park Development - South Gateway Park is an 19,000 square foot green space with amenities programmed for the look off / scene chasing visitor. Gateway Signage - Using the existing sign as a guide, these monument signs will be situated on substantial brick posts and measure approximately 5m x 3m. This project should be led by the Port Hood and Area Development Society (PHADS). Rezoning (of available lands) - Rezoning of lands should be investigated as part of the anticipated 5 Year Review of the Municipal Planning Strategy & Land Use Bylaw being undertaken by the Eastern District Planning Commission (EDPC). Land Assembly - Land assembly along Route 19 should be led by the Municipality of Inverness (MI) with the Development Society acting as a liaison to communicate the value of the assembly and rezoning efforts. Streetscaping - The Municipality should lead communication with TIR to help advance better corridor conditions for Commercial uses on Route 19 in the study area. The work includes the addition of street trees and sidewalks along the 1km stretch of Roadway. Commercial Recruitment - The Development Society should lead the charge to find potential businesses and agencies that would be interested in medium to large commercial footprints at the North Gateway Development - Following from Rezoning and Land Assembly, commercial interests will develop the lands highlighted as part of the North Gateway. High Road / Denmore Road Intersection - When repairs are required to this intersection it is recommended that the curbs be redesigned to work with the majority of traffic in the area (Denmore High Road). Main Street Façade District Confirmation of Façade District - PHADS will work with members to ensure that the district as defined captures the intent of the planned program. Partnership and Façade Program Development - PHADS will work with the Municipality to help procure funding and partnership agreements with outside agencies. Identification of Façade Program Steering Committee - Building from this Conceptual Development Plan work, PHADS and the Municipality will identify a Steering Committee to 51 oversee deployment of the program in Port Hood. Beach Set Terms & Eligibility - The Steering Committee (with PHADS) will set the terms of reference for the program. Public Entrance & Access Paths - Improvements to the arrival experience at the main Beach service centre would be led by the Town, with support from PHADS to procure continued community feedback. Façade Improvements - Private owners will engage with the program to match funds for improvements to their façades. Civic Core Road Infrastructure / Traffic Circle, Wedge Park - Proceeding with reconfiguration of the road infrastructure requires buy in and leadership from the Municipality. Wedge Park - The 7,200 square foot park is a product of the creation of the Traffic Circle and simplified intersection. This space should be programmed with passive recreation opportunities and could potentially house a community garden. Shade Pavilion - The shade pavilion is a continuation of the effort to add to public spaces that residents of Port Hood can use on a regular basis and throughout the year. These structures are available as off the shelf items from many playground suppliers and only require footings and site furniture to greatly enhance the utility of the space in the shoulder seasons. Community Park & Playground Improvements - The Community Park could currently use a face lift, landscaping and amenity improvements for the 10,000 square foot space would be a great start. 52 Kiosks - New beach front kiosks could house supplies stores, lifeguard storage, seasonal food & bending, as well as potentially potable water & washrooms. Fire Pits - The Fire Pit installation is a move that would immediately show how PHADS is contributing to the life of Port Hood. The installation should be accompanied by a new bylaw or some level of regulation for the fires on the beach. Municipal Wharf Reconstruction - The Municipal Wharf is in need of serious repairs. Before proceeding the improvements recommended in the Conceptual Development Plan it would be prudent of the Municipality to consider if they can service Marina needs of residents through an improved Murphy’s Pond Wharf. Pond Lookoff Park & Parking - The 6,000 square foot boardwalk and cantilever structure and 28 stall parking lot support gathering and attraction at this location. As a Municipal project PHADS could assist as an intermediary between other organizations (Chestico Heritage Society) and the Municipality. Kiosk at Wharf - The kiosk at the wharf is conceptualized as a simple, movable timber kiosk structure approximately 12’ x 12’ square. Marina Wharf Improvements - The Marina Wharf Improvements suggested in the plan do not alter the breakwaters, they add floating docks and gangways, and support a new effort in surfacing the walking paths a top the stone breakwaters. Trail Around Murphy’s Pond - The trail around Murphy’s Pond includes a mini lookoff structure, 300m of boardwalk, and a 1km trail around the pond. Signage and Wayfinding Gateway Signage - see above. Community Maps - These maps will situate users in Port Hood and should be installed on footings that allow for horizontal viewing of the maps, oriented to align North on the map with true North. Wayfinding & Directional Signage - Directional signage should be installed as part of new and upgraded public spaces. The goal of this signage is to help guide visitors between the attractions in Port Hood. Interpretive Panels - Similarly to Community Maps, Interpretive Panels will be installed in public spaces to expand on local stories and history. Making the connection between the past and the present through a well designed interpretive program will help unify Port Hood for locals and those visiting. 5.2 Priorities and Phasing Based on stakeholder conversations and the outcomes of the public open house held in May a draft phasing table has been prepared for use by the Development Society. Port Hood Conceptual Development Plan Phasing Strategy for Program Implementation & Capital Budgetting Phase 1 Phase 2 Phase 3 1 - 3 Years 3 - 10 Years 10 - 20 Years Ceilidh Trail Gateways Gateway Signage (North & South) Rezoning (of available lands) The identification of the Lead Agency for each of the components is a helpful reminder to all stakeholders who is likely the best contact for inquiry as to progress on any individual component of the Conceptual Development Plan. Lead Agency PHADS EDPC / MI Land Assembly PHADS / MI Commercial Opportunity Definition PHADS / MI Commercial Recruitment PHADS Streetscaping MI / TIR South Gateway Park Development North Gateway Development High Road / Denmore Road Intersection MI MI / PHADS MI Main Street Façade Program Confirmation of Façade District PHADS Partnership and Façade Program Development PHADS / MI Identification of Façade Program Steering Committee PHADS / MI Set Terms & Eligibility PHADS Façade Improvements Private Civic Core Public Upgrades Road Infrastructure / Traffic Circle MI Wedge Park MI Shade Pavilion MI Community Park MI Playground Improvements MI Beach Public Entrance PHADS / MI Public Access Paths PHADS / MI Kiosks PHADS Fire Pits PHADS Municipal Wharf Reconstruction MI Murphy's Pond Lookoff Park MI / PHADS Road Infrastructure for Lookoff Park MI / PHADS Kiosk at Wharf PHADS Marina Wharf Improvements SH (Federal) Trail Around Murphy's Pond PHADS / MI Signage Community Maps PHADS / MI Way-finding & Directional Signage PHADS / MI Interpretive Panels PHADS Fig. 41 Project Phasing 53 5.3 Capital Cost Estimates Costing provided in this report is intended to provide an order of magnitude estimate that will correspond to the relative financial costs of each component of the plan. Further cost analysis should be done before proceeding with these projects. The table in Fig. 42 contains costing for capital components of projects as outlined in this Conceptual Development Plan. Port Hood Conceptual Development Plan Order of Magnitude Costing for Capital Budgeting Lead Total Cost Agency Ceilidh Trail Gateways Gateway Signage (North & South) Rezoning (of available lands) PHADS $ 70,000.00 EDPC / MI - Land Assembly PHADS / MI - Commercial Opportunity Definition PHADS / MI - Commercial Recruitment PHADS Streetscaping (Trees & Sidewalks both Sides, 1km Stretch) MI / TIR $ 500,000.00 MI $ 380,000.00 $ 100,000.00 South Gateway Park Development North Gateway Development High Road / Denmore Road Intersection - MI / PHADS MI - Main Street Façade Program Confirmation of Façade District PHADS - Partnership and Façade Program Development PHADS / MI - Identification of Façade Program Steering Committee PHADS / MI - Set Terms & Eligibility PHADS - Façade Improvements Private - Civic Core Public Upgrades Road Infrastructure / Traffic Circle MI $ 400,000.00 Wedge Park MI $ 144,000.00 Shade Pavilion MI $ 150,000.00 Community Park MI $ 200,000.00 Playground Improvements MI $ 60,000.00 Public Entrance PHADS / MI $ 202,500.00 Public Access Paths PHADS / MI $ 41,850.00 Kiosks PHADS $ 45,000.00 Fire Pits PHADS $ 3,900.00 Beach Municipal Wharf Reconstruction MI $ 4,000,000.00 Murphy's Pond Lookoff Park MI / PHADS $ 300,000.00 Road Infrastructure for Lookoff Park MI / PHADS $ 90,000.00 PHADS $ 15,000.00 Marina Wharf Improvements SH (Federal) $ 50,000.00 Trail Around Murphy's Pond PHADS / MI $ 90,000.00 Kiosk at Wharf Signage Community Maps PHADS / MI $ 12,000.00 Way-finding & Directional Signage PHADS / MI $ 18,000.00 PHADS $ 30,000.00 Interpretive Panels Fig. 42 Project Costing 54