Cam Designs and why
Transcription
Cam Designs and why
by John Dudley Cam Designs and why I have a steady flow of questions come to me each and every day through my website. One subject of question that is very common is Cams on compound bows. There are lots of good questions about cam types and positioning. Is this cam better than that? Will this bow be better if I use that cam? I am sure you get the point. If you have a basic understanding about cams you can certainly help assure maximum performance from your set up instead of minimizing it. However you need to be wise about it and stick to what the factory has put in front of you as an option. Every shooter has a certain need or certain feel they are after and to be honest that is why some companies offer such choices to the consumers. Yes it may make you slightly indecisive about what combination to choose however the results can be rewarding. I give credit to Hoyt for offering such options to the shooters. If any of you out there are in the manufacturing business you will definitely understand overhead and inventory. Hoyt tends to overlook this when it comes to cam options because nearly every bow they offer has choices on different cam types to choose from. What I would like to do is walk you through some of the cam choices available and what the differences are in these cams. Before I go much further I would like to mention something. Many of you want to know the difference in Cams simply so you can choose what bow configuration to order, while others want to know so they can make changes to the bows they already have. I think changing a cam is something most mid level archery enthusiast can do and eventually will do. I think there is a certain satisfaction that comes with taking a cam from one model bow and putting it to another model. It will make you feel like you have designed something yourself. This is 24 especially true if you try a combination that isn’t available. I know because I have done it. However, it is a false sense of creative design. Reality is though that when it comes to cams there is so much more to it that meets the eye. I can assure you though that the design teams that are in place inside the walls of the factory have already concocted every combination imaginable before they released that bow to the market. Many of them are good friends and I will vouch for their brain capacities. The “CAMbinations” that offer an advantage and are safe are the ones they have as an option. Cams that offer poor tuning, poor efficiency will not make it into the catalog as an option. Certain cams must go with certainly length limbs and certain limb angles. You may notice the parallel limb bows seldom have a compatible cam system as a straighter limb bow. There is a lot that goes into this and the reasons are numerous so be sure to pay attention to what the factory says for option cambinations. I wouldn’t encourage you to try cambinations outside the catalog or what is recommended from the factory. It will not only void your warranty in some cases be potentially dangerous. With that said let’s dive into some useful terminology and information about Cams. Common Cam Terminology Let Off- I am sure most of you know what let off is but I won’t assume all of you do. Let-Off is a term that is used to describe how the cam releases the difficulty of pull as you reach the full draw position. This is one of the many benefits to compound bows is that the holding weight is much easier that the pulling weight. With recurve bows this is the opposite and why many believe to be The more difficult to shoot. The most common let off options will be 65%, 70%, 75% & 80%. For simple math I will use a 100 pound pull and 80%let off as an example. As you pull the bow the cam is designed to let-off 80% of the weight you are trying to pull so once you are at full draw you will only have to hold the remaining 20% which in this example would be 20 lbs. If the let-off is 65% then you will have to hold the remaining 35% which would be 35#. Many target archers prefer the lower let-off because this forces to pull harder against the back wall. The added holding weight usually helps stabilize the bow and increase steadiness. On the other hand the higher let-off option is preferred by most Bow hunter’s because it allows them to hold the bow at full draw for a longer period of time with the heavier pulling weight that is common with hunting. A valuable thing to consider is that let-off is usually designed into the cam by the engineers during design. However we can slightly change let-off by making changes to the cable diameters. If you make the overall diameter of the cables larger than factory spec then you will intern lower the let-off. Likewise if you make the cables diameter smaller than the factory specs you can increase the achieved let-off. Valley- The Valley of the cam is the amount of space you feel in the let-off between the string going forward or backward. On older bows with round wheels they had very long valleys meaning you could pull it to full draw and still be able to let the string forward generously before it wanted to take off. Many people referred to long valley cams as feeling “spongy”. They longer valleys many times are more forgiving to shoot but with the cost of having lower performance. Most of the cams today have shorter valleys with Cam designs and why a very solid wall. This is the preferred feel by the highest percentage of archers because overall performance is higher and proper form is easier repeated. Some valleys however are shorter than others. On very aggressive cams with very short valleys it will almost feel as if the bow will either be getting pulled backwards or wanting to take off forwards with literally no in between. You are either pulling hard against the back wall of the cam or the bow is shooting forward! Some targets archers prefer this feel again because it forces strong shots and perfect shooting form. However a vast number of archers may have a difficult time keeping up with a very short valley especially when combined with a lower let-off. The short valley aggressive style cams are usually offered as an option and not always the standard option available. Force Draw Curve- The force draw curve is a plotted graph of the bows peaking force or weight as it is pulled to full draw. The further the bow is pulled the higher the force increase until reaching its peak force and then eventually falls lower again as the cam let-off happens. The force draw curve will reveal many characteristics of the bow it is plotting. The shape of the curve will let you know how quickly or slow it takes for the peak weight to be achieved and also how long it is sustained before falling off. When a trained eye is looking at a force draw curve they will almost certainly know the how the bow will feel and perform before they have even drawn it by hand. One of the most important parts of the Curve is that it tells 26 how efficient the cam is and how much energy you get out of the cam as compared to the energy you put in to draw it back. The Easton Bow Force Mapper is available to consumers and does a great job plotting the Force Draw Curve. It gives a curve reading the same as the machines top bow companies uses which cost thousands of dollars more. Bow Mapper Cam 1 & 2 plus Timing/Synchronization- There is a lot of marketing put into cam “timing” and why some companies have advantages over others. Personally I like to put all the hype aside and say that for all cam systems on the market there are still positions that make the cams work more efficiently than others. On the Hoyt Cam ½ system both cams are slaved together with the control cable so they argue the cams don’t have to be synch perfectly to still shoot well. However, I still say that having both cams reach the full draw position at the same time assure peak performance. On single cam bows they advertise “no timing” which is true because there isn’t another cam to time it or compare it against. However they still have cam “positioning or rotation” that greatly affects the nocking point position, nock travel, draw length and draw weight. If a single cam changes in position all four of those things are quickly affected resulting in a change of accuracy or groupings. So the The bottom line is it is important to know your cam system and make sure the settings are in the correct place. Comparing the available Cam ½ systems Cam1/2 Plus- This cam is based on the original Cam ½ systems that Hoyt developed 2003 but redesigned this year for optimized higher performance including a better force draw curves and higher speeds. This very proven design and has so many good attributes to offer any user. The Cam & 1/2 Plus™ has great speeds on all configurations, is one of the easiest cams to draw. One huge benefit to the Cam ½ and Cam ½ Plus is the draw length adjustability. The modules on the cams have settings A-F that allow for quickly adjusting draw length in ½” increments for 3 full inches of range. For new archers and growing archers that have not yet settled into a definite draw length this is a great feature. I rate Draw length as the #1 thing to have set correctly in relation to shooting form. The adjustability will help your local retailer quickly set the bow perfectly to your size. This cam is very forgiving and has a solid wall with an easy shooting valley. This is one of the least demanding systems on the market and has numerous high level results due to the easy shootability. It is available in 65% or 75% let-off and can be changed by replacing only the modules and not the entire cam. Over a Dozen current Hoyt model bows are adaptable with the Cam ½ Plus system. It has been my experience that the highest output of the Cam ½ Plus system are when the modules are set in the E or F positions. Spiral X Cam ½- This cam is also a newly remodeled version of a previous Cam ½ system. The original Spiral Cam ½ was designed specifically for the serious target archer that preferred a high output, demanding cam. It offered a rock solid wall with a short valley and aggressive draw cycle. The new Spiral X has been slightly tweaked to perfect the original Spiral Cam. This cam is going to give an easy 8-10 feet per second when compared to the Cam ½ Plus system. The Spiral X has an aggressive draw force curve and reaches peak weight at a quicker rate than any of the other systems. It is a fixed draw length cam that is designed specially to the size you order it in. Minimal adjustments can be made to the draw length by modifying the strings and cable length. Since the Spiral X is geared specifically to the performance archer it is only available in 65% - 55% let-off. What I have found with the Spiral X Cam ½ is that the valley is always fairly short. The feel of this cam greatly changes from riser to riser, limb to limb and draw length to draw length. Nearly every combination will have a slightly different feel. I have had my best results with Spiral systems but prefer to shoot them between 52-56#. Bottom Cam synch - BAD Top Cam synch - BAD Bottom Cam synch - GOOD Top Cam synch - GOOD Spiral Cams XTR Cam ½- This cam was designed specifically to work well with the new XTS limb available on the Alpha Max Series and Turbo Hawk. I personally see this as the best cam offered on short parallel limb bows. The XTR has a very good draw force curve and is very efficient. It has a comfortable valley and a very solid wall. This cam is only available in 75% let-off. What I like most about this cam is that it is also modular for draw length adjustment and can be adjusted without the use of a bow press. The XTR Cam ½ has a small module that is held in position by two screws that have been strategically placed on the cam so that you can remove them while the bow is at rest. I find that extremely convenient to be able to adjust a cam length without having to press the bow. The XTR delivers high speeds over 320 fps on both the Alpha Max 32 and the Turbo Hawk. On my personal bow I installed a thicker cable to lower the let-off slightly and used it for target shooting this year. XTR Cams Autumn 2009 Z3 Cam ½- The Z3 Cam ½ was originally designed for the Katera and Katera XL bows that used the XT 500 limb. This cam is in many ways very similar to the XTR Cam ½. It pulls a smooth draw curve and has a comfortable valley and a very solid wall. The Katera series were also very fast bows and achieved high performance from this cam. There are still several Women and Short draw archers making use of this cam on the target scene. This cam is highly efficient and continually delivers high speeds even at the shorter draw lengths. This is also a fixed draw length cam so the draw length must be ordered exact. Unlike the XTR Cam ½ the Z3 offered both a 65% & 75% let-off. Recently the Z3 Cam ½ has been determined to work well with the Alpha Max to achieve shorter draw lengths then originally available. If you considered The Z3 Cam shooting an Alpha Max but had a shorter draw than what was available then you should Contact Hoyt regarding this cam and its ability to achieve shorter draw lengths on the Alpha Max series. M4 Cam ½- The M4 was initially designed to fit the Mid Priced Hawk Series bows from 27 Cam designs and why Hoyt. This cam can easily be compared to the Cam ½ Plus system. It is easy to pull, with a comfortable valley and good wall. The M4 is fully adjustable for 4” of draw length. Much like the Cam ½ Plus the M4 has a rotating module system that is easily changed to suit your length. This cam however is only available in 75% let. I know this cam pulls very nicely and is a forgiving cam system to shoot. There is no doubt this system was designed specifically for the archer most likely to buy a mid level bow. Speed on this system is rated at the 303-306 fps mark. cam was designed for is the Trykon JR and has a draw length range of 17-25”. I believe it is very important to have entry level archers use equipment that they are capable of controlling. If the cam system is too aggressive or the peak pulling weight too high then it forces improper draw habits that typically result in poor shooting posture. This Cam is designed to perform with this that in mind. Versa Cam Wrapping Up M4 Cams Versa Cam ½- The versa cam is really designed with one thing in mind. A growing young archer! This cam is adjustable up to 9” in range. It pulls easily for a kid and has a long valley and soft wall. The bow that this I know sometimes as a consumer it is difficult when there is too many choices. I know I can certainly have problems being indecisive at times. However, options are a good thing to have. For a manufacturer it is an expensive thing to offer as well. I know that in production companies there are very few that decide to offer a lot of options and customizing. For those that do though you can have a good sense of individuality by selecting something that is really customized to fit your needs. I remember ordering my first pair of custom Oakley’s from the O custom shop and how special it made me feel getting them. Did they protect my eyes any better? NO, but I liked wearing them more often because they were something I put together with my mind. A Placebo is a very positive attribute to a competitor and customization is a very good placebo. Who knows, maybe the best shooting bow you will ever have is one you help customize. Each and every Cam offered from Hoyt has a certain feel, certain performance and certain intention. Consider the options and consider yourself and you can certainly find a perfect match. Good Luck… John Dudley www.dudleyarchery.info www.ddbowhunting.com Tournament Diary 13 September: Alton & Four Marks Archery Club’s 29th Annual Open Tournament. Venue: Four Marks Recreation Ground, Uplands Lane Four Marks. Rounds: Windsors (mainly for Archers who have not yet attained their 1st class, though experienced Archers are most welcome to come along and shoot). Send SAE to: Kaye Garrett, 77A Victoria Road, Alton, Hants. GU34 2DF. Tel: 01420 80481, or email to [email protected]. Details and entry forms can also be downloaded from our website: www.altonarchers.co.uk 25-27 September 2009: Residential archery weekend at Green Park Centre, Ashton Clinton, Aylesbury, Field, Golf, Clout & Novelties. For further details & entry form contact Ian Millar at [email protected] 19-20 September 2009: The Ipswich International. Venue: Ipswich's prestigious Trinity Park. The Tournament is open to all archers and consists of a World Record Status FITA 720 qualifying round on the Saturday followed by set format head to head matches on the Sunday. Entry to the event entitles you to one 720 round and at least one head to head match. 22 November 2009: ACA Worcester Tournament. Venue: The Agricultural Hall, Lockmeadow, Barker Road, Maidstone, Kent. ME16 8LW. Details: SAE to Mrs Sandra Punton, 577 Loose Road, Maidstone, Kent. ME15 9UH Tel: 01622 749960 In addition to the prize fund some major sponsors will be providing prizes for category winners. In addition to the usual categories the organisers intend to have prize categories that ensure that all entries have a realistic chance of winning a prize.The aim is to add some innovation into the shooting calendar and if this event takes off you can be sure that it will become a regular fixture that will no doubt grow. It's not often we get chance to take part in something new so go on get those entry forms in. Further details can be found at www.deben-archery.org.uk or email Steve at [email protected] 15-16 November 2009: Armistace Shoot; At the Marks, Speed, Cloth of Gold, Flight. Venue : Scotney Castle, Lamberhurst, Kent. Details: www.longbow-archers.com/keyeventsstgeorge.htm 12-13 December 2009: Christmas Pudding Shoot; At the Marks, Speed, Cloth of Gold, Flight. Venue : Torry Hill Estate, Milstead, Kent. Details: www.longbow-archers.com/keyeventsstgeorge.htm 3 January 2010: Welland Valley Archers’ Thirteenth Annual Indoor UK Record Status FITA 18. Venue: Market Harborough Leisure Centre. Details: www.wellandvalleyarchers.com or SAE to Paul Gash, 17 Oxendon Road, Arthingworth, Mkt. Harborough LE16 8LA. Tel: 01858 525189 or [email protected] 21 February 2010: ACA Portsmouth Tournament. Venue: The Agricultural Hall, Lockmeadow, Barker Road, Maidstone, Kent. ME16 8LW. Details: SAE to Mrs Sandra Punton, 577 Loose Road, Maidstone, Kent. ME15 9UH Tel: 01622 749960 28 The