10 Questions for a Timeshare Resale Broker
Transcription
10 Questions for a Timeshare Resale Broker
TimeSharing Today $4.50 ® The Trusted Independent Voice of Vacation Ownership since 1991 Issue #103 Jan/Feb, 2009 10 Questions for a ByTimeshare Resale Broker Scott Kilpatrick According to many consumer spending reports, in today’s economy, people are very cautious about purchasing goods and services right now. The timeshare resale market is one place where you want to ensure that your dollars are working for you. If you need to get your timeshare property sold, here are ten good questions to ask a timeshare resale broker in order to feel more confident that you are making a wise decision. ness in order to employ the technology and services to move timeshare properties on the resale market. 1 - How long have you been in business? The length of time that a timeshare resale broker has been in business speaks volumes about the stability of their organization as well as the morality of their practices. 5 - Can you guarantee the sale of the property? 2 - How much have you sold? A good marker of success can be established by the volume of sales the company has under its belt yearly, quarterly or since the inception of the company. It is a good idea to ask how much the company has sold in volume within a time frame, or simply ask how many closings the company has made within a period of time. 3 - What is your incentive to sell? Many resale companies charge an upfront fee to add your property to their resale inventory. This is not an incentive to sell, but a fee that covers items such as advertising your property on the resale market. A timeshare resale broker should have a motivation, such as sales commission, to ensure there is an incentive to get your property sold. Without it, there is no driving force to promote your timeshare in front of potential buyers. There needs to be an incentive for a sales agent to solicit potential buyers and offer your property to those looking to buy on the resale market. The last thing you want is your property sitting in a resale broker’s inventory and not getting worked. 4 - What is the size of your sales staff? If you have found a timeshare resale broker that has an incentive to sell your property, another good indication of the potential to get your property sold will be the number of sales agents at a resale broker’s office. Since commission based sales agents are motivated by a percentage or fee awarded for each sale, a large group of sales agents in one office is indicative of the amount of sales and closings taking place at the resale broker’s office. A resale company must remain a profitable busi- Asking a timeshare resale agent if the sale of your property can be guaranteed is a good way to quickly determine if the sales agent you are working with has integrity. If the answer is “yes” to a guaranteed sale, then you should take your business elsewhere. There is no way to guarantee the sale of a timeshare property. You may encounter a money back guarantee, but be sure you understand the terms completely and do not assume it means you will get your money back if you’re dissatisfied with the results you are getting. Like most guarantees, expect them to be bound by terms and guidelines. 6 - How much of the sales process can you complete? The paperwork that involves recording deeds, transferring ownership, escrow, and other documents associated with the timeshare resale process can be quite burdensome. Determining if a timeshare resale broker handles all of the sales process from inquiry to closing is a good indication that lends credence to their expertise, dependability and legitimacy. Inquiring about the sales process in its entirety will (Continued on page 12) TimeSharing Today 10 Questions (Continued from front page.) also help you determine if the sales agent you are working with is knowledgeable in the requirements of selling a timeshare on the resale market. 7 - Do you offer a refund? A good thing to determine before paying an upfront fee is the refund policy. Some timeshare resale companies may charge an upfront fee that may or may not be refundable under certain conditions. You may have a rescission period that is governed by state law. If you sell your timeshare by other means while it is listed with a timeshare resale broker, you may qualify to have your upfront fee refunded to you. Be sure you hold onto the paperwork to any guarantee or refund and fully read and understand your rights. 8 - Do you have exclusive rights to sell my property? Exclusive Right to Sell is a very important question to get answered. If a timeshare resale broker has an Exclusive Page 12 Right to Sell your property, you must allow them to make the sale during the contractual period of the listing. If you sell your timeshare by other means while your property is listed with a company that has the Exclusive Right to Sell, you may be required to pay a penalty or a commission to the resale broker even if they did not facilitate the sale of your property. 9 - How long is the sales contract good for? Determining how long a timeshare resale broker is going to work with your property to get it sold will help you determine if the upfront fee seems fair and just. Some timeshare resale companies may require an upfront fee for a six month or one year contract to sell your property while others may have a two to three year contracts for an upfront fee. Ensure you understand what happens when your contract to sale ends. Some resale brokers may require another full upfront fee, while others may give you a discount to extend the contract for another year or more. Jan/Feb, 2009 10 - Are you licensed to sell? Resale brokers must employ Licensed Agents or Licensed Realtors who are governed and bound by regulations that ensure their sales techniques and processes take place within legal and ethical guidelines. By utilizing a resale broker who uses licensed agents, you have the rules and regulations dictated by a higher authority on your side. If a resale company does not have licensed Agents, it is an advertising company, which is not permitted to negotiate on your behalf but can only forward any offers to you. If you are considering selling your timeshare, getting answers to these questions will be a responsible course of action. By getting these important topics addressed before you pay an upfront fee, you will have the criteria available to make an informed decision about selecting a timeshare resale broker. It is equally important to have these points addressed in writing; no timeshare resale broker should get an upfront fee until you have the terms and agreements, in writing, in hand. www.tstoday.com for back issues, message boards, Resale Value Tracker and much more TimeSharing Today TIMESHARING TODAY (ISSN 0000-1069) is published bi-monthly at $19 for 6 issues by TimeSharing Today, Inc., 140 County Road, Suite 114, Tenafly, NJ 07670. Periodicals postage paid at Tenafly, NJ. and at additional mailing offices. POST MASTER: Send address changes to TIMESHARING TODAY, 140 County Road, Suite 114, Tenafly, NJ 07670. Distribution is primarily by mail to subscribers, with limited distribution at resorts. All contents are copyrighted by TimeSharing Today, Inc. Contact us for reprint permission. DISCLAIMER TimeSharing Today makes no in dependent investigation of the proper ties, products or services advertised or of the people placing advertisements in this publication. We accept all ads that are submitted with the appropriate fee. Accordingly, we cannot accept any responsibility for any direct or conse quential damages arising from these advertisements. ARTICLES AND LETTERS All published articles and letters become the property of TimeSharing Today and may be republished in any format without further compensation. Contributors of articles, photos and let ters published in TimeSharing Today will be compensated: Letters or photos - a one issue subscription extension; articles - 10 or 5 issue subscription extension or a 4-line classified ad. HOW TO CONTACT US TimeSharing Today can be reached by mail at 140 County Rd., Tenafly, NJ 07670, by telephone at 201/871-4304, by fax at 201/871-4305 or by email to staff @tstoday.com. Website: www.tstoday.com. Access to the Online Edition, Re sort Report Cards, back issues, special reports, directories, etc. is through the Subscriber Only section. Current username: timeshare Current password: leslie Page 3 Sep/Oct, 2008 Use a licensed broker The suggested questions in the front page article provide a helpful guide for selecting a broker to handle the resale of your timeshare when you decide that you have more weeks than you need. While some brokers may disagree with a few of the comments related to each question, no one can seriously argue with the need to use reasonable diligence in selecting a broker to resell a timeshare week. When you are ready to sell, consider one of the licensed resale brokers who advertise in this magazine with display or classified ads. In addition to finding them through their advertisements, you can consult the directory of about 25 licensed resale brokers that we publish several times a year, with brief summaries of their fees, services and areas served. Almost all of them work on a commission payable when the week is sold. How valuable is the information in the directory? One of our subscribers has reported that she received a telephone solicitation offering to provide a list of eight (8) licensed timeshare resale brokers who would work only on commission, without an upfront fee. The cost of the list: $299. We frequently get emails asking if we heard of a particular company, usually one that has solicited a seller and requested an outrageous fee with a promise to sell the timeshare for an unrealistically high price, sometimes to a “buyer” who disappears after the fee is paid. In our recent resale survey, every single seller who fell victim to one of these pitches reported that no sale resulted. We can’t say this often enough or strongly enough: do not waste your money paying a large upfront fee to an unlicensed “broker” who promises to sell your timeshare at a price that you know is significantly higher than the prices advertised here. Deedbacks make sense In the Letters to the Editor section, the Director of Owner Relations at two resorts complains that companies who charge a fee to take over an owner’s maintenance fee obligations frequently ignore the payment obligations, forcing the resort “to go through a costly foreclosure process to obtain ownership of the week and try to sell it.” We have a better idea, one that has been advocated from time to time in letters and articles during the past few years: If an owner has gotten usage from a timeshare week over the years and finds it difficult to resell, the resort should ac cept a deed back from an owner who is ready to surrender ownership rights without compensation. This becomes a win-win situation; the owner doesn’t pay a company several thousand dollars to have the week taken off his or her hands, and the resort doesn’t have to go through a foreclosure proceeding to reclaim title. Instead of having a week that is accumulating unpaid maintenance fees, the resort has the week avail able to rent and can get it quickly into the resale market. Resorts resist taking back deeds because they feel they can keep collecting maintenance fees from owners who no longer need their weeks. But that policy eventually backfires, as indicated by the letter on page 5. Misleading sales tactics Recent actions against prominent developers by state Attorney Generals in Pennsylvania and Missouri are described in the article on page 35. We had hoped these high pressure and deceptive sales practices would become a thing of the past, but that hope has not yet been realized. However, the penalties described in the page 35 article, and the $1 million punitive damages judgment (page 23) may have a deterrent effect on other timeshare developers’ sales techniques. Perhaps not in this tough economic climate, as developers need to push harder for sales. But eventu ally, as timeshares continue to become a more commonplace vacation option, we may find them sold in a far more relaxed setting, where buyers can make a decision without being subjected to undue pressure and misstatements. www.tstoday.com for back issues, message boards, Resale Value Tracker and much more TimeSharing Today Page 4 Jan/Feb, 2009 Letters to the Editor Multiple resorts on same property I read the article on the couple who stayed at the Villas on the Green (at the Lawrence Welk Resort) in theJul/Aug issue. It made me curious so I looked up the reviews on Timeshare Users Group, and quickly found that this is a lockout resort with a rating of 7.75. The unit they had was the smaller of the 2 sides and, since it is the “second” bedroom side, has twin beds and less kitchen facilities. The original resort, Lawrence Welk Resort has a TimeSharing Today Resort Report Card rating of 9.3, but only has 2-bedroom units. I’ve also started doing searches with the resort name and “reviews,” which will usually bring up Tripadvisor and Yahoo, but the reviews don’t always break out which resort if there are multiple resorts on the same property. I notice that the actual Welk site is very lacking in breaking down what is on the property. Since it is listed as Welk San Diego, you might be led to believe it is in San Diego instead of over the hill and north of the city. Bruce Johnson Confidential list With regard Bob Wayland’s article in issue #101 (The Devil’s Advocate), I strongly disagree with his statement that the timeshare resort should provide a list and address of owners and that a sure sign that something is wrong if you encounter problems getting the list. As the Business Manager (and also an owner) at an ownerrun Resort for the last 30 years, I have been instructed by the Board of Directors to never to give out the names, addresses, etc. of the owners to anyone other than themselves. If the list should fall into (let us just say “unscrupulous”) hands and the owners started getting solicitations, calls etc., the Board would be subject to legal action from the owners. The owner list is held in strict confidence. Name not provided Maui tax on tourists I had a month of timeshares in Maui since the 1970s as well as several condos that I owned. In recent years, the Maui tax on timeshares has gone up substantially and now amounts to the majority of the maintenance fees. I am tired of the Relax! In 3 hours, you’ll know all about the special timeshare deal we’re offering on this flight only. You’ll get your free gift when we land. discrimination of the Hawaiian government’s prejudicial policies against tourists. Taxes are not the only way Hawaiian government entities act against the tourists that provide their bread and butter. Some officials I spoke to just laughed and smugly said they had me (us), and there was nothing I could do about it. I sold out. Ricky Davidson Disappointment in RI Our arrival at The Wharf in Newport, RI was a sort of “you’re here.” The next desk was over crowded with employees. We were issued our keys and told the location of our accommodations. We finally found the unit; it had an outdoor entrance and no close parking. (Employees using all open spaces?) We got into the apartment and what a sight: old furniture, an upstairs (which we had not been informed about), no chairs in main bedroom, no hangers in the closet. We put our groceries away and found out there was no place but a long couch for non-perishables. No coffee maker, no work space, loads of unnecessary dishes and unusable pots and pans. Then I tried the TV; it would not turn on with the remote and all channels were fuzzy. The remote worked but not for power on or off. We called for a coffee maker and soon were delivered an old used dirty coffee maker. The further we went, the worse it got. No instructions on how to use the hot tub. OK then we were ready to accept the lack-of shortages, etc., when we found there was no can opener. We had no idea where any of the pools, etc., were located, but if we wanted to use them, we had to go outside, across the parking lot, to get there and then found the door was locked, leaving us out in the cold. I cannot say anything good about this place. Even the sales people couldn’t give us any advice except “here are your free meal tickets.” I have 536,000 plus points, but this is the last place I would go or recommend. Howard Marshall, Parkville, MD www.tstoday.com for back issues, Resort Report Cards, articles on resorts and much more TimeSharing Today No tax benefits In June, 2008, we went through what came across as a very credible presentation about the resale of timeshare interests and how difficult it is to resell them because nobody wants to pay any amount close to what you’ve put into it, and there are so many units/weeks wanting to be sold. We paid a substantial fee for a company to take a couple of timeshare interests “off our hands,” and while the paperwork to transfer the timeshare week owned solely by my husband came through relatively quickly, we’re still waiting for the paperwork on the one we owned jointly. What it apparently boils down to is that the only real incentive this company offered was the “fact” that we could take credit on our tax returns for the next 7 years for the capital loss we will have suffered by not being able to recoup our purchase price for each timeshare interest. Only recently, I contacted our tax preparer to verify that fact, and he sent me an article that disputes that very point: because the timeshare is a personal asset and not a business asset, we cannot deduct the loss from the sale/transfer. So, basically, this company lied to us about the “benefit” we could receive from handing over our ownership to it; and, they did so in order to induce us to part with our money. (I feel so stupid, as we’ve been suckered like this before, only not to this extent!). Of course, one has only a short amount of time to decide whether or not you want them to handle it for you (because they have “another group of potential suckers waiting in the wings”), and that alone should have been our cue to not pursue it. But, we’re gullible; and there seem to be so many unscrupulous people out there waiting to take advantage of gullible ones like us! Name not provided Editors note: Here is an excerpt from a response by Dave McClintock, CPA, that was published in the last issue: Some of these companies tout that if an owner purchased a timeshare with an investment intent, the loss on the sale of the timeshare (i.e., the timeshare cost and their $2,500 fee) is deductible. In fact, a loss on the sale (including the $2,500 fee) is almost never deductible. If you or friends or relatives occupied or exchanged the timeshare or even if you never used it, the timeshare Page 5 constitutes a personal asset, just like your car, your primary residence or your TV set. And just like sales of those other personal assets, any loss on disposition is not deductible. The actual use of the timeshare is what controls the loss treatment, not your “investment intent.” The single exception would be for a timeshare that you rented to others on a regular basis - for at least the last two years before disposing of it. In that case, you should have a deductible ordinary (not capital) loss on sale. However, the loss is limited to the resale value (not your original cost) of the timeshare as of the date you converted the timeshare from personal to rental use. That resale value, if you couldn’t sell it, is probably quite low, meaning that your taxable loss would be negligible. The disposal fee ($2,500) would not be deductible even in this situation. **** From the Resort/Association perspective, this practice is hurting delinquency rates and incurring legal costs. Many of these companies have obtained weeks through buyout situations and abandoned Jan/Feb, 2009 the inventory when they could not quickly resell: I have a copy of an Agreement made with a former owner at Falcon Point Condominium Association. In 2006 the owner paid $2,499.00 to have a company take over his week. Today, that company is carrying a delinquent balance of $1,441.88 and we cannot locate any representative from the business. The only option the Association has is to go through a costly foreclosure process to obtain ownership of the week and try to sell it. The average cost of foreclosure is $1,400. This means the Association’s liability for this one buyout is $2,800+. This is only one of many weeks abandoned by the “buyout” practice. This is a huge problem and I appreciate you for gathering information. I hope TimeSharing Today will go forward to ARDA and any other avenue that could establish regulations against this practice. Jane Mastenbrook, Director, Owner Relations, Eagle Point and Falcon Point Condominium Associations Get more out of your timeshare ownership with Interval International membership There is a DIFFERENCE in vacation exchange companies As a timeshare owner, you’ve got a great vacation waiting for you year after year. Now, couple your timeshare ownership with Interval membership and see what the right vacation exchange company can do for you! • Worldwide exchange privileges at quality resorts • Specially-priced Getaway vacations • More options with two exchange methods • Valuable member benefits • An expansive Golf Resort program • All at an affordable price! Enroll or renew today! Call 800-977-7045 or go to IntervalWorld.com. www.tstoday.com for back issues, message boards, Resale Value Tracker and much more TimeSharing Today Page 6 Three Wyndham Discoveries Wyndham had a discovery program for those trying to “discover” if a purchase with that company was a possibility. Their mistake was in limiting properties to those low on the desirability list. We purchased 300,000 points which we then spent on three exchanges: Durango, CO; St. Thomas, VI; and New Bern, NC. After spending a week at each, none of these convinced us to invest in a Wyndham property. The Wyndham Durango timeshare, in Southwest Colorado and Your leading edge CHOICE... for RESORT MANAGEMENT • Independent company for 35 years • Flexible solutions for developers & BODs • Hands on, awardwinning team just a short drive from the spectacular Mesa Verde National Park, was well situated in the community, but as a converted Best Western Motel, the unit was cramped and too small for more than two people. The “Sleeps Four” description was a myth. The only “activity” provided was a sales presentation by a local candle merchant. The New Bern Fairfield Harbour timeshare was spacious, but in Call Marcus Wood • 800-365-1048 • www.tradingplaces.com Exchange • Rentals • Resort Management • & More Having trouble getting an exchange? TradeWinds Cruise Club has taken luxury sailing yachts, scrumptious and beautifully presented dishes, invigorating long drinks and added just a splash of timeshare to make the most exotic Caribbean Cocktail on the turquoise ocean. If you can’t get an exchange to TradeWinds Cruise Club, here’s another chance. For details please write to [email protected] See you in paradise – soon! www.tradewindscruiseclub.com TSM Ad No1.indd 1 Jan/Feb, 2009 a location so remote that a rental car was a necessity. On a technical note, the address listed on the directions provided turned out to be the Post Office where Wyndham gets its mail, with the result that our GPS dumped us several miles from our true destination near midnight, after a cross-country flight and a three-hour drive from RaleighDurham airport. Hauling luggage up three flights of stairs (the property is on stilts due to its hurricane-prone location) encouraged us to stay on the ground. Having laundry stolen from the third floor dryer made us a bit suspicious about security. Surely none of our fellow Wyndhamites were that desperate for a half-load of California underwear! Bluebeard’s Beach Club on St. Thomas was the lowest point on our discovery journey. The aging property was overdue for a face lift. The step down from bedroom to bathroom was poorly placed and dangerous (a lawsuit waiting to happen). According to the posted floor plan, our bed was in the middle of the dining room! The only free transportation provided was a taxi to another Wyndham resort for what turned out to be a sales presentation. (Surprise!) A rental car necessitated driving a left-side steering wheel on the left side of winding, hilly, narrow roads. Taxis were very expensive and there were no buses. A trip to a distant grocery store cost $26. The one bargain, a lunch barbeque, was called off due to an 8 a.m. rain squall which was only a faint memory by lunch time. Who would ever want to return? Needless to say, Wyndham’s Discovery Program no longer exists. It may well have discouraged more clients than it created future sales. We would have been better off putting our money into a timeshare advertised in TimeSharing Today’s classified section! www.tstoday.com for back issues, message boards, 08-03-01 Special 19.58.30 Reports and much more TimeSharing Today Page 7 Ron’s Select Holidays By Ronald G. Helms Centerville, OH The Land of Canaan: Adventure and Nature A previous review of The Land of Canaan in TimeSharing Today (issue 38), while generally positive seemed to provide a rather diffident review of this mountain treasure. We own ten weeks of timeshares, including Marriott at Hilton Head and West Palm Beach. Our twenty-five years of timeshare ownership have provided tony lodging for city business trips as well as elegant personal holidays. We find that a carefully selected Marriott trade offers a soignée sojourn. However, The Land of Canaan (www. landofcanaan.com) located in Canaan Valley, West Virginia, is a source of enrapture to those who seek to seek mountain adventure and the ardent pursuit of natural beauty. Canaan Valley is not for the disingenuous traveler. For those who prefer Disneyland, Myrtle Beach, Pigeon Forge, and the ilk, Canaan Valley offers an alternative: appreciation of natural beauty. The Land of Canaan check in procedure is as simple as a hotel check in. The Land of Canaan eschews high-pressure sales tactics of other timeshares (no obnoxious sales presentations or useless premiums are proffered), and the staff is able to recommend fine dining establishments as well as local sandwich shops. Local staples, groceries, and spirits are within a few minutes’ drive, and full scale grocery and traveler’s supplies are located in nearby Davis. The Land of Canaan offers a townhouse with two bedroom units that have been recently remodeled. A stone fireplace (gas or log) is located in the living room and dining area. Amenities include full size washers and dryers and large, home sized, fully equipped kitchen. The living room features a DVD and VHS. Sliding glass doors lead to a wooden deck that offers panoramic mountain and valley views. Problematic for the digiterati is the lack of WiFi in each unit, but the office has WiFi, and cellular connectivity is fine. Canaan Valley is located in the Potomac Highlands of the Allegheny Moun- tains. The resort features two ski resorts within minutes, and more advanced skiing is located at nearby Wisp in Maryland and Snowshoe located south of Elkins. Numerous high adventure activities include mountain biking, hiking, white water rafting, mountain zip lines, horseback riding, and all the expected resort activities. Canaan Valley offers an upscale second home development for some families who know the secret of a civilized vacation village near the East Coast. The Land of Canaan timeshare resort provides a serene alternative to renting a home in the mountains. A premier Canaan Valley Resort offers fine dining, golf, tennis and standard resort activities. Nearby Davis offers two unique artisan shops and is the gateway to Black Water Falls Resort. Canaan Valley is a relatively easy drive from the tidewater and from the Midwest, but one must invest some time in locating the optimum routes. If one is prepared to navigate, the access to Canaan Valley is a very pleasant experience. The Land of Canaan is a gem, and a four-season resort for a select clientele. Make no mistake; Canaan Valley is not a wilderness outpost. The Timberline Resort development is the site of $500,000 homes placed discretely in a natural setting. Other home and condo developments provide second homes for almost any budget. Dolly Sods is literally in the backyard of The Land of Canaan. This Canadian or Alaskan tundra experience is a mystery to most tourists, but if a few days of backpacking are scheduled, Dolly Sods may require a U.S. government permit as well as a four by four vehicle. The ubiquitous beauty of this special area is reserved for the truly adventurous. Jan/Feb, 2009 The Fairfax Stone is legendary. This stone is located at the source of the headwaters of the Potomac River. The Fairfax Stone marked the western boundary of land granted to Lord Fairfax by the King of England in the 1700s. In 1910, The Fairfax Stone marked the final state boundary between West Virginia and Maryland. Almost within a stone’s throw from the Fairfax Stone is a modern field of windmills. Whoever though that the infamous black carbon coal mines of WV would be replaced by the green windmill farms? The Land of Canaan is located at 3,200 feet and the ski mountains extend to 4,000 feet; the weather is very unpredictable, and winter storms can deposit 12 – 16 inches of snow within a few hours. Spring and fall offer much solitude. We have been frequent visitors to Canaan Valley and Black Water falls for over fifty years. The flora and fauna of this area are very special. www.tstoday.com for back issues, message board, Special Reports and much more TimeSharing Today Page 8 Jan/Feb, 2009 FOCUS ON: Sheraton Desert Oasis, Scottsdale, AZ By Susan/Elliot Miller, Elkins Park, PA We arrived in Phoenix, AZ on Friday afternoon, along with 250,000 other people. We came to Phoenix for a wedding; they all came to Phoenix for a NASCAR race. The airport provided clear directions to pick up our baggage; then we boarded a bus to the off site location of the pavilion where all of the rental cars were located. We paid for the car and were directed to the parking garage where we were told to “pick out any car in any of the 2 aisles over there.” We picked out a brand new Ford Mustang after we were told we had a free upgrade. It was a smooth entry to our vacation; we were on the road within an hour of landing. The traffic between Phoenix and Scottsdale, where our timeshare was located, was another story. It took us an hour to travel the 25 miles to Sheraton Desert Oasis at exit 35 on the 101 Freeway. When my husband got out to check in, he was informed that our room wasn’t ready, but we would be able to check into a different room. The check in personnel described the rooms and location, and within minutes we were issued our keys and offered a welcome packet. The concierge spent about 30 minutes with us, providing us with maps, directions and suggestions for the closest supermarkets and restaurants. Of course, there was the requisite offer for the timeshare presentation which we accepted and booked. Following the presentation, we were rewarded with a Timeshares 60-80% OFF RETAIL s and prices the best location 800.676.6290 www.holidaygroup.com/news IDE! CALL NOW for FREE BUYERS GU tst Visit Online>> holidaygroup.com/ s! Buy From Holiday & SAVE Thousand $50 dollar check, discounts on our trip to the Grand Canyon as well as coupons for several restaurants in the local area. After checking in, we were anxious to get to our unit and unload the car. We found ourselves in an optimal location on the 1st floor and 2 units away from the pool. We were pleasantly surprised when we entered the unit, it smelled and looked spotless. There was a small shelf with a decorative basket in the entryway of the unit; I felt it was located in the perfect place to put the car keys and room keys. To the right of the entryway behind a diagonal wall was the full kitchen and the washer/dryer. The kitchen was separated from the glass covered table and 4 chairs by a raised granite topped counter. The living room was nicely appointed with a large easy chair and a queen-sized pull out couch. There was a large screened TV, VCR and tape deck in a large entertainment center in the living room, as well. We always find the lighting to be sub-optimal when we are vacationing and were pleasantly surprised to find 3-way lamps in the living room. We were surprised, not so pleasantly, that there was not any Internet connection in the unit. There was a Wi-Fi connection in the Clubhouse at a cost of $5.95 per day; or $21.95 per week – both with a one time set up fee of $2.00. The bedroom had a king size bed, with plenty of pillows, and a 2 person whirlpool bathtub in the room. The TV was hidden in a lovely cabinet that had 2 drawers for storage. The bedside tables were large enough for my husband’s sleep apnea machine, and above each was sconce lighting. The 2 bathroom sinks were separated from the toilet and www.tstoday.com for back issues, message boards, Resale Value Tracker and much more TimeSharing Today shower area by a pocket door. There was generous sink top space for storage of toiletries – a hair dryer in the cabinet, as well as plenty of toilet paper. The large travertine shower stall had great water pressure – 2 shower heads, one with massage action. The bedroom and living room both had gas fireplaces – needed only one night during our early November week in Scottsdale. We found daytime temperatures to be very pleasant – varying from 75 to 80 degrees. We visited Taliesin West, the Grand Canyon and Sedona during our stay. Sedona was a highlight, especially because of our Jeep ride to view the spectacular red rock formations. Our tour guide, Storm, grew up in Sedona and provided local flavor – she sounded and dressed like a cowgirl. The drive back to Scottsdale on Route 89A over the Mingus Mountain was breathtaking. The 2 lane road had plenty of switchback curves and took us through Jerome, formerly a ghost town, but now a charming arts community perched on the side of the 6,000 foot Page 9 Jan/Feb, 2009 maculately maintained. The only complaint we witnessed was by someone who had a little too much contact with the birds in the outdoor café. Later that day, I took advantage of the concierge services at the resort by asking them to recommend a local spa where I could receive a massage. Not only was one recommended, but the concierge made an appointment for me and provided me with a discount coupon. It was one of the best massages I’ve ever received! Sadly, our trip was over before we had opportunities to exhaust the sightseeing possibilities and take advantage of the amenities at the Sheraton Desert Oasis. There was a lovely pool, with a “red rock” waterfall created out of cement under which there was a Jacuzzi. While there was plenty of outdoor seating around the pool, in the late afternoon when it started getting cool, it was difficult to locate chairs in the sun. All in all, this was one of our best experiences trading our home timeshare in Lake Buena Vista, FL and securing a comparable trade. high mountain. The tour of the Grand Canyon was through Arizona Land Tours. We felt somewhat misled by the promises that the timeshare resort hosted about this tour. It was a very long ride to the Grand Canyon – the van was fairly uncomfortable and cramped. If we were to repeat this trip again, I think we would probably stay overnight in Sedona to cut down the number of hours in the car. We booked our tour of Taliesin West on our own – it was well worth the $45 per person for the 3-hour guided tour that included tea and snacks in the dining room. We met several speakers during our tour who knew and worked with Frank Lloyd Wright – his presence certainly came alive for us. We ate lunch one day at the Arizona Biltmore Hotel in their outdoor café – an expensive fare, but with lots of ambience. The Biltmore has lots of pictures of the rich and famous who had vacationed there in the past. It was one of the most well appointed hotel lobbies we had ever seen; the grounds were im- Exchanging your timeshare week should be painless... after all, you have a vacation to get to... Simple and personal exchange services designed for timeshare owners Timesharing Today subscribers! Call us and mention this ad To receive $20 off of your next exchange, bonus week purchase or rental! • • • Offer good until March 1st, 2009 • • • • 800-468-1799 • Free Membership Low Exchange Fees No Guest Fees Pay when you confirm your exchange Look, hold, book, confirm online 3-year credit for your week deposit Primetime Rewards for select deposits www.daelive.com U.S. - Australia - U.K. - Asia - South Africa - New Zealand www.tstoday.com for back issues, Resort Report Cards, articles on resorts and much more TimeSharing Today Page 10 Jan/Feb, 2009 How Developers can regain control of an Association and what you can do to prevent it By Walter Anderson One of the main values of timeshare ownership has always been that, ultimately, the individual owners controlled the operation of the properties when they elected a majority of the members of the Board of Directors. The owner-elected Board then makes decisions related to the maintenance and operation of the property, including determining what the maintenance fees would be and, most importantly, monitors the financial aspects of the resort. The Board elected by the individual owners is in a position to protect the individual owner’s rights when the Developer or Management Company is not performing. Clearly, without this oversight, the Developer or Management Company is free to do whatever it wants. There is little question that a Developer should be able to control the manage- Don’t Pay Another Maintenance Fee! WE’LL SELL YOUR TIMESHARE FAST. NO UPFRONT COST! If we accept your timeshare for eBay®auction, we’ll sell it fast and charge no upfront fee. If we don’t sell it within 30 days, you’ll pay nothing—ever. It’s the risk-free, hassle-free sell-it-now solution! Hundreds of happy clients See full details at: TimeshareRecycler.com ment of a resort during the selling phase to ensure that the resort is operated in a manner that allows him to sell what he created. Most Master Deeds and Bylaws provide that the Developer can elect the Board of Directors until all but a few of the units are owned by him. Some states, such as Florida, have enacted laws require the turnover of control to the individual owners as the property is sold, with a final time period for transition. Without owner oversight, the Developer/Manager is free to use Association funds to upgrade and maintain portions of the property used for sales that an owner-controlled Board might recognize had no reasonable benefit for the existing owners. Without oversight by an ownercontrolled Board, a Developer can change all the signage on a property to reflect a change in ownership or name of the Developer and charge the cost (which can be many thousands of dollars) to the Association based on the premise that the signs are on Association property. Without oversight, the Association’s insurance can include coverage, with its related premium, for materials and activities, including business interruption insurance and building contents that would not be on the site if it were not for sales activity. Without ownership control of the Board, the owners who are paying the maintenance fees do not have control over how their money is being spent or how their resort is being maintained and operated. What is of even more concern are Developers who seek to regain control by electing owners who are disinterested, or worse, the Developer’s employees. If the Developer/Management Company’s activities are being questioned by the owner-controlled Board, the Developer/ Management Company may move to remove the Board rather than address the issues. There have been a number of ways Developers regained control of a Board even when they did not have a majority of the Board. These include: 1. Having the proxy state that “If no name is given on the proxy, the Management Company or Developer will have the proxy for the owner and can cast the owner’s vote as it chooses.” Since there are generally many more proxies submitted than owners attending Annual meetings, this provides the Developer/Manager with an overwhelming number of votes. 2. At the time of purchase, have the new purchasers sign a long term proxy to the Developer. The Developer can then cast the owner’s vote as it chooses until and unless the owner issues a new proxy or attends the meeting. 3. The Developer/manager creates a proxy that states that “this proxy can only be used for determining a quorum.” Because the Developer generally will have several hundred voting interests, either through purposely retained unit/weeks or mortgage foreclosures, the Developer can have a majority of the votes of those present at the meeting. Even if there are several thousand proxies given to the owner-controlled Board that would vote for owner representation on the Board, these votes cannot be counted, and the Developer can select owners or employees that they have undue influence over. 4. A number of Developers are contacting fixed week owners and converting them into Club Programs and, as part of the conversion process, the owners are assigning their voting rights to the Club or, in some cases, deeding their ownership interest to the club. The Developer then uses the votes assigned to the club to elect a Board of its choosing. 5. A Developer of a points program declares that it has one vote for a relatively small number of points or the smallest points package being sold, when the provisions of the Documents provides that each purchaser has only one vote regardless of the number of points. This can create a situation where the Developer has many times the voting power of an owner for the same number of points owned or percentage of ownership of the resort. 6. The Developer obtains unit weeks that have delinquent maintenance fees from the Association and instead of selling them, puts them into a club and retains the voting rights. If the Developer www.tstoday.com for back issues, message boards, Special Reports and much more TimeSharing Today Page 11 obtains voting rights of 51% of a quorum of the owners (which can be as little as 8% of the ownership), they may be able to elect their own staff to the Board unless a large percentage of the owners return their proxies and assign their voting rights to the owner-controlled Board. There would be little to say if a Developer had a majority of the total ownership interests in a resort. In that situation, the Developer would have every right to elect a majority of the Board Members. But, this is not what is happening. Because the quorum of members of Timeshare Associations is generally low, often at 15% or less of the membership, a Developer through the methods above, can have the majority of the votes at a meeting while actually owning only a small percentage of the total ownership himself. There are several things that an owner-controlled Board can do to protect the owners against having a Developer retake control of the Board from the individual owners. 1. The Developer/Manager should not be able to manipulate the owners to their benefit by modifying the proxy. The Board should pass a resolution that the proxy format must be approved by the owner-controlled Board. The Board can then specify that, if no name is filled in on the proxy, the Board will have the right to vote the proxy. The proxy must also not have a provision that restricts its use to just being used for obtaining a quorum. 2. The Board can also make a concerted effort to get the owners to all send their proxies back in to the owner-controlled Board. This can be done with the notice of the annual meeting and in newsletters and other mailings. 3. Contact all owners and inform them that if they are considering converting their ownership interest into a club program, they check to determine if they are giving up their voting rights. Further, advise the owners that they should take into consideration, when joining a club program which does not let the members retain their voting rights, that they are giving up any oversight protection they had and are relying on the Developer (and any other entity to which the Developer sells their club) to maintain and operate the Club with no oversight by the members. 4. Have the Association attorney review the documents and ensure that the meeting and notice is proper and correct and retain all voting rights with the owners. 5. Have the Association attorney attend the meeting. This can protect the Association from the Developer/Manager seizing control from the owner-controlled Board with a questionable interpretation of the documents or state statutes. Once a Developer/ Manager regains control of the Board and Association funds, it can be very difficult for the owners to again control the Board without expensive legal action. It should be remembered that once an individual purchases a timeshare interest whether it is a unit week or points or some other variation of ownership, it is no longer the Developer’s property, it belongs to the individual owner and not to the Developer. The owners should be the ones who determine which owners will represent them as Board Members. Any attempt by a Developer/ Manager to regain control of a Board through manipulating an election raises the question of the Developer/Manager’s motives and the ethics they are exhibiting. www.tstoday.com for back issues, Resort Report Cards, articles on resorts and much more Jan/Feb, 2009 TimeSharing Today ® Page 13 RESORT REPORT CARDS Ratings are based on a scale of 1 to 10, with 10 being the best. Jan/Feb, 2009 Report Card ratings for each resort are averages based on a significant number of reports received from readers. DESERT BREEZES TIMESHARE RESORT Palm Desert, CA 8.7 HARBOR RIDGE Southwest Harbor, Maine 9.2 Amenities and activities at resort: Pools, tennis, game room, exercise room, basketball, internet access, laundry facility, bicycles, hot tubs, BBQ grills, putting green. Amenities and activities at resort: Tennis, game room, fitness center, playground, hot tub, indoor pool, orientation breakfast, horseshoes, grills, picnic tables, internet access, games, welcome party, scavenger hunt, gift shop. Amenities and activities nearby: Golf, hiking, shopping, art galleries, tram, horseback riding, live theater, hot air balloons, water park, restaurants, Joshua Tree National Park, casinos, rock climbing, Living Desert Museum. Amenities and activities nearby: Hiking, restaurants, art gallery, museums, fishing, horseback riding, golf, shopping, Acadia National Park, ocean, whale watching Unit: Furnishings: 8.8 Cleanliness: 8.8 Kitchen inventory/appliances: 8.8 Maintenance: 9.1 Construction quality: 8.9 Amenities and activities: At resort: 8.0 Nearby: 9.9 Suitable for: Young children: 7.2 Pre-teens: 6.9 Seniors: 9.0 Teenagers: 7.1 Handicapped: 8.7 Resort: Restaurant facilities: NA Convenience store: NA Grounds and maintenance: 9.5 Security: 9.4 Staff: 9.1 General hospitality: 9.1 Exchange affiliation: RCI Unit: Furnishings: 9.0 Cleanliness: 9.4 Kitchen inventory/appliances: 9.3 Maintenance: 9.1 Construction quality: 8.9 Amenities and activities: At resort: 8.9 Nearby: 9.4 Suitable for: Young children: 7.7 Pre-teens: 8.0 Seniors: 7.6 Teenagers: 8.3 Handicapped: 6.0 Resort: Restaurant facilities: NA Convenience store: NA Grounds and maintenance: 8.4 Security: 6.8 Staff: 9.7 General hospitality: 9.8 Exchange affiliation: II Comments: Convenient location to the many area attractions. Beautiful grounds. Spacious units with fireplace. Comments: Excellent location for exploring this slow-paced area. Units have 3 floors. THE HOUSES AT SUMMER BAY KISSIMMEE, FL 9.3 MARRIOTT’S TIMBER LODGE South Lake Tahoe, CA 8.3 Amenities and activities at resort: Private screened pools, entertainment, exercise equipment, tennis, live music, lake, game room, playground, fishing, miniature golf, paddle boats, jet skis, basketball, Bingo, children’s program. Amenities and activities at resort: Outdoor pools, hot tub, exercise room, movie nights, welcome reception, ice rink, lake, beach, ski lift, skiing, internet access, valet parking. Amenities and activities nearby: Disney World, Sea World, Universal Studios, shopping, restaurants, golf. Amenities and activities nearby: Casinos, hiking, sight seeing, boating, restaurants, shopping, skiing, lake, cruises, sleigh rides, fishing, skating rink, golf, biking, theater. Unit: Furnishings: 9.1 Cleanliness: 9.2 Kitchen inventory/appliances: 8.7 Maintenance: 9.1 Construction quality: 9.1 Amenities and activities: At resort: 9.0 Nearby: 9.1 Suitable for: Young children: 9.1 Pre-teens: 9.0 Seniors: 9.4 Teenagers: 9.0 Handicapped: 9.0 Resort: Restaurant facilities: 6.5 Convenience store: 6.3 Grounds and maintenance: 9.0 Security: 8.3 Staff: 7.9 General hospitality: 8.1 Exchange affiliation: RCI Unit: Furnishings: 9.2 Cleanliness: 9.7 Kitchen inventory/appliances: 8.3 Maintenance: 9.3 Construction quality: 9.0 Amenities and activities: At resort: 8.7 Nearby: 9.6 Suitable for: Young children: 8.4 Pre-teens: 8.3 Seniors: 9.0 Teenagers: 8.7 Handicapped: 7.9 Resort: Restaurant facilities: 8.1 Convenience store: 6.8 Grounds and maintenance: 9.3 Security: 9.4 Staff: 9.7 General hospitality: 9.7 Exchange affiliation:II Comments: Units are private stand-alone houses with two master bedrooms with whirlpool tubs, third bedroom, garage, pool, washer/dryer. Houses beautifully decorated. Comments: Many activities available within walking distance of resort. Diverse activities; something for everyone. Resort adjacent to ski lifts. Fee for car parking. TimeSharing Today ® Page 14 RESORT REPORT CARDS Ratings are based on a scale of 1 to 10, with 10 being the best. Jan/Feb, 2009 Report Card ratings for each resort are averages based on a significant number of reports received from readers. FIESTA AMERICANA VACATION CLUB Cancun, MEX 8.4 PEPPERTREE ATLANTIC BEACH AlantIic Beach, NC 7.6 Amenities and activities at resort: Pool, beach, spa, snorkel/scuba instruction, fitness center, pool games, bingo, playground, nanny service, concierge, maid service. Amenities and activities at resort: Pools, game room, fitness room, tennis, playground, beach, crafts, beauty salon, grills, beach, planned activities, bike rentals. Amenities and activities nearby: Restaurants, nightclubs, shopping, buses, water sports, fishing, nature tours, Mayan ruins, golf, boat cruises, water park. Amenities and activities nearby: Restaurants, beach, state parks, historical sites, bird watching, fishing piers, boat rentals, shopping, water sports, sailing, jet ski rentals, bars, go carts, golf, art galleries, aquarium. Unit: Furnishings: 8.5 Cleanliness: 9.0 Kitchen inventory/appliances: 7.7 Maintenance: 8.8 Construction quality: 8.7 Amenities and activities: At resort: 8.1 Nearby: 8.6 Suitable for: Young children: 7.9 Pre-teens: 7.6 Seniors: 8.0 Teenagers: 7.5 Handicapped: 7.1 Resort: Restaurant facilities: 7.1 Convenience store: 5.6 Grounds and maintenance: 9.4 Security: 9.0 Staff: 9.5 General hospitality: 9.6 Exchange affiliation:RCI Comments: Older well maintained facility. Resort not handicapped friendly; too many stairs. Staff is excellent and responsive. Unit: Furnishings: 7.6 Cleanliness: 8.1 Kitchen inventory/appliances: 8.2 Maintenance: 8 Construction quality: 7.9 Amenities and activities: At resort: 7.5 Nearby: 8.5 Suitable for: Young children: 8.1 Pre-teens: 7.6 Seniors: 7.5 Teenagers: 7.3 Handicapped: 6.6 Resort: Restaurant facilities: NA Convenience store: 6.2 Grounds and maintenance: 8 .4 Security: 7.8 Staff: 8.8 General hospitality: 8.5 Exchange affiliation: II, RCI Comments: Well kept grounds and friendly staff. Half mile walk to the beach. Renovations being made during 2008. SHERATON MOUNTAIN VISTA Avon, CO 8.3 WESTGATE PAINTED MOUNTAIN GOLF Mesa, AZ 8.3 Amenities and activities at resort: Pool, hot tubs, garage, concierge, Bingo, exercise facility, welcome party, internet access, grills, sauna, nightly movies, sun deck, game room. Amenities and activities at resort: Pool, hot tub, exercise room, playground, golf course, organized activities, sauna, volleyball, internet access, video rental, concierge, ping pong, shuffleboard, basketball, horseshoes. Amenities and activities nearby: Running/bike trail, hiking, skiing, fishing, horseback riding, golf, skating, shopping, restaurants, ballooning, rafting, kayaking, sleigh riding. Amenities and activities nearby: Museums, botanical garden, casinos, zoo, golf, shopping, mountains, desert, movies, live entertainment, restaurants, hiking. Unit: Furnishings: 8.8 Cleanliness: 9.2 Kitchen inventory/appliances: 8.4 Maintenance: 8.8 Construction quality: 8.8 Amenities and activities: At resort: 7.4 Nearby: 7.8 Suitable for: Young children: 6.8 Pre-teens: 6.9 Seniors: 7.8 Teenagers: 7.1 Handicapped: 6.9 Resort: Restaurant facilities: NA Convenience store: NA Grounds and maintenance: 8.1 Security: 7.9 Staff: 8.7 General hospitality: 8.7 Exchange affiliation: II Unit: Furnishings: 8.1 Cleanliness: 8.6 Kitchen inventory/appliances: 8.4 Maintenance: 9.1 Construction quality: 8.5 Amenities and activities: At resort: 8.2 Nearby: 8.9 Suitable for: Young children: 6.9 Pre-teens: 6.8 Seniors: 8.2 Teenagers: 6.4 Handicapped: 7.5 Resort: Restaurant facilities: 6.8 Convenience store: NA Grounds and maintenance: 8 .6 Security: 7.9 Staff: 9.0 General hospitality: 9.0 Exchange affiliation: II, RCI Comments: Washer/dryer in units. Great views. Resort is best during ski season or Summer. Convenient location. Comments: Small resort being upgraded. Units are well stocked with supplies. Central location for sightseeing. TimeSharing Today By W. E. (Bill) Armbruster SPM Resorts, Inc. The current economic situation is affecting just about everyone in one form or another and timeshare resorts are no exception. There is concern that owners may not be able to take their vacation or pay their maintenance fees in a timely manner if at all. As with any challenge, careful planning and consideration of the needs of the individual owners can alleviate many of the negative aspects of a bad situation and may afford opportunities going forward. The Association must be prepared to cut costs if they find they are not collecting maintenance fees at the level they anticipated and/or generating income from the sale of local event tickets or services such as boat rentals or activities and lessons and increase rental programs. It is important to take into consideration the owners who pay their maintenance fees and that they very much deserve to have the quality of vacation Page 15 they expect. It is not right to close amenities or shut down programs if it will materially affect the vacation experience of the dues paying owner. However; if the resort experiences low occupancy, Management should be able to reduce expenses. If a resort has two heated necessary to prevent mold and mildew formation or pipe freezing. This can also reduce cleaning costs. In some situations and with the approval of the Board, it may be advisable to spread the maintenance fee payment over several months. While there may be additional costs related to this type of program, it can permit some owners to stay current when they otherwise would have gone delinquent. The one thing that must not be done is to ignore an increase in the number of delinquent owners. Management and the Board must be constantly aware of the number of delinquencies and the Associations cash flow position. Further, while modifications to the collection procedure may be warranted, a program should be maintained. Failure to do so is a recipe for financial disaster. Every challenge brings with it opportunities. Now is a prime time to examine the needs and desires of the owners and the physical needs of the resort and examine options that are available now that may not have been RESORT MANAGEMENT IN DIFFICULT TIMES pools, it may make sense to heat only one if one can accommodate the owners at the resort. The resort can also review the number and type of activities offered, if there is reduced participation it may make sense to modify or substitute these activities with ones that are less costly or can provide income to the resort. At resorts that are not fixed week or where the owners are amiable to changing units, it may be possible to close off sections of units at the resort during the less popular times. This can cut down on costs by setting heating and cooling levels to those that are at the minimum Jan/Feb, 2009 PROFESSIONAL TIMESHARE RESORT MANAGEMENT WE WORK FOR THE UNIT OWNERS AND REPORT TO THE BOARD PROVIDING MANAGEMENT FOR FIXED WEEK, FLOAT/FLEX WEEK AND POINTS BASED RESORTS ACTIVE ON SITE RENTAL AND RESALE PROGRAMS FOR RESORT HOAS AND INDIVIDUAL PRIVATE OWNERS FOR MORE INFORMATION PLEASE CONTACT US AT: (407) 253-1789 or via email: [email protected] SPM RESORTS, INC. 1051 SHINE AVE, MYRTLE BEACH, SC 29577 www.tstoday.com for back issues, message boards, Special Reports and much more TimeSharing Today [email protected] Page 16 available before. Reduction in occupancy allows more units to be available for rental programs. Depending on the laws of the state in which the resort is located, Management can enter into an aggressive rental program. While rentals may be down in many locations, it is important to recognize that units in timeshare resorts hold many advantages over standard hotel rooms. Guests who might have otherwise stayed in a hotel may likely choose a timeshare instead if they are presented with the opportunity. There are many avenues both through the internet and locally that can provide low cost advertising. This can be a significant source of income to the resort and individual owners that can ultimately carry into the future after the economy returns. Changes in owner use of the resort can also provide opportunities. Some resorts are reporting that owners and guests are cooking more in the units and not going out to eat as much. Eating out is often an important part of a vacation but it can be an expensive one too. The resort Jan/Feb, 2009 can help on both counts. The resort can sponsor, evening get togethers that can provide the owners with an opportunity to eat out at the resort. Such meal programs as “taco Tuesday”, a pig picking, or a fish fry can provide the guests with a fun inexpensive outing without leaving the resort. For resorts that do not have on site food service, local restaurants are often very happy to cater an event at the resort at a very modest cost. In times like these when mid level restaurants are reporting significant drops in business, this can be a very big benefit to them and can be the basis of a long term relationship for both the resort and the restaurant. The association can charge a modest fee over the cost and generate some income for other programs. Local attractions may also be experiencing difficult economic times. This is an opportunity for management to arrange programs with these attractions to have special hours and fees for a resort guest. There can be commissions paid back to the Association for setting up these programs where the owner obtains a heavy discount and the resort generates a few dollars as well. If the resort has been prudent in collecting and maintaining reserve funds, now may be the time to make improvements to the resort and renovate units. Currently, many contractors and supplies of goods and services are struggling to make ends meet. As a result they may be willing to provide goods and services at extremely reasonable prices. Additionally, if the resort is experiencing a lower than expected occupancy, now may be the time to accomplish maintenance work that might inconvenience owners when the resort is crowded. While it always important for Management and the Board to be aware of their cash position and maintain a current updated cash flow projection, it is particularly important in difficult economic times. The time to plan and act is not when the resort is in the midst of a financial melt down; it is when the first anomalies to the budget become apparent. It is critical that both Management and the Board review current financial statements. It is only then that they can take advantage of the challenges and opportunities that are there. www.tstoday.com for back issues, Resort Report Cards, articles on resorts and much more TimeSharing Today Page 17 TSToday Anywhere Subscriber Gary Tamblin enjoys his TimeSharing Today magazine while relaxing near the pool at the Royal Islander Resort in Cancun, Mexico. Jan/Feb, 2009 Carolyn Varone of Puyallup, WA, never leaves home without her TimeSharing Today. She is reading it on the patio of her exchange to Lake Pend Oreille Shores in Idaho. Genevia Gano relaxes with her TimeSharing Today on the patio of her home unit at Lehigh Resort Club in Lehigh Acres, FL. Joe and Bette Jo Sobel read their TimeSharing Today while on the patio of their exchange unit at Marriott’s Marbella Beach Resort in Spain. Joseph Mack from Polson, MT reads his magazine in front of the wind-operated generator that provides electricity to the office and laundry at the Windjammers Resort in Ocean Shores, WA. Jean Clements and her husband traded for a week at the Ocean Reef Yacht Club in the Bahamas, where she is shown reading her TimeSharing Today. While on exchange to Hawaii, Susan Ann Miller of Flagstaff, AZ shows her favorite magazine to the mule about to take her to the old leper colony on Molokai. www.tstoday.com for back issues, Resort Report Cards, articles on resorts and much more TimeSharing Today Page 18 Index of 2008 Articles Compiled annually by David McClintock as a service to fellow subscribers. A combined nine-year index is accessible in the Online Edition at www.tstoday.com (Page number & month) All-inclusive 4 Mar, 5 May ARDA – industry statistics 33 Sep ARDA HOA committee 4 Jul ARDA new website 20 Nov Ask Dave M 19 Sep, 23 Nov Camelot, FL lawsuit1 Mar, 23 Sep Cooperative Association of Resort Exchangers (“C.A.R.E.”) 25 Jul Cruise ship timeshares 24 Jan Cruise TS – Trade Winds 36 Sep Deed back to HOA 5 Jan, 11 May, 5 Jul Dial An Exchange benefits 20 May Diamond acquires Bluegreen 22 Sep Dining Guide 40 Jan, 13 Mar Disney FL expansion 8 Nov Disney Hawaii expansion 22 Jan “Greening” resort activities 35 Sep Exchange Company Comparison Chart 5 Jan, 30 Jul Festiva Atrium dispute 5 May FirstAgain 4 May, 33 Jul Handicap Accessible (RCI) 5 Mar Holiday Inn timeshares 9 Nov Homeowner Associations Boards of Directors 26 Sep Management Company Directory 27 Jan, 20 Sep Self management 37 Jan Interval International Cancellation policy 7 Jan Independence 28 Jan, 21 Mar Liberté Management profile 27 May Maintenance fees vary 1 Jan, 4 Mar 25 Mar, 4 Sep Multiple TS, owner of 7 Nov $275 Orange Lake, FL renovation 24 Jan Expansion in River Island 22 Sep Platinum Interchange 7 Jan Point systems, reviews 8 Mar RCI Disappointment 7 Jan Handicap accessible 5 Mar Points, conversion to 19 Nov Restriction against alternate exchange companies 32 Jul Revenues 5 Sep, 5 Nov Success 32 Jul Recession impact 3 Mar, 1, 3 Nov Redweek for rentals 19 Sep Refinance (FirstAgain) 4 May, 33 Jul Rentals, top-rated resorts 39 Jan Resale brokers Directory16 May, 16 Jul Why use a licensed broker 41 May Resale survey 9 Mar, 1, 3 Sep, 1 Nov Resales – how to sell 23 Nov Resort Mgt (RMC) profile 39 Jul Resort Report Cards Bay Club at Waikoloa, HI 15 Jan Carriage House, NV 15 Jan Club Ocean Villas II, MD 25 Sep Disney Old Key West, FL 25 Sep Escapes! Stonebridge, MO 25 May Ft Lauderdale Beach, FL 15 Nov French Lick Springs, IN 12 Jul Galleria at Split Rock, PA 16 Jan Golden Strand, FL 15 Nov Grand Mayan, MX 15 Nov Hilton Grand Sea World, FL 12 Jul Island Seas, Bahamas 15 Jan Kala Point, WA 14 Mar Lake Placid Club, NY 15 Jan Lake Tahoe Vacation, CA 12 Jul Lehigh Resort Club, FL 12 Jul Marriott’s Canyon Villas,AZ 25 May Marriott’s Ocean Pointe, FL 25 Sep Marriott’s Summit Watch, UT 14 Mar Marriott ‘s SurfWatch, SC 15 Nov Jan/Feb, 2009 Mayan Palace, MX 25 Sep Mizner Place, FL 14 Mar Oceancliff, RI 13 Jul, 5 Sep Olympia Vac. Owners, WI 26 May Palace View Spinnakr,MO 14 Mar Paniolo Greens, HI 16 Nov Polo Towers Villas, NV 15 Mar Pueblo Bonito, MX 25 May Rancho Banderas, MX 13 Jul Samoset, ME 24 Sep Sands of Kahana, HI 24 Sep Scottsdale Villa Mirage,AZ 15 Mar Sea Mist, MA 26 May Sedona Pines, AZ 16 Jan Steele Hill, NH 13 Jul Tahiti Village, NV 24 Sep Tahoe Ski & Beach, CA 26 May Tree Tops, TN 15 Mar Tybrisa at the Beach, GA 13 Jul Vacation Village, MA 16 Nov Villas on Green - Welk, CA 16 Jan Wapato Point, WA 26 May Williamsburg Plant., VA 16 Nov Worldmark Pinetop, AZ 24 Sep Worldmark Windsor, CA 15 Mar Wyndham Nashville, TN 16 Jan Wyndham Ocean Walk, FL 26 May Wyndham Smokey Mts,TN 16 Nov Reviews Acapulco Mayan Pal, MX 5 Jan Angel Fire, NM 6 Mar Apple Valley, OH 27 Jul, 40 Nov Balboa Towers, MX 26 Jan Bighorn Meadows, BC 29 Mar Blue Ridge Village, NC 6 May Cabana Club, WA 23 May Canyonview Resort, AZ 34 Sep Costa Linda, Aruba 26 Nov Costa Real Cabo, MX 32 Nov Cove at Yarmouth, MA 31 Jan Divi Little Bay,St. Maarten 26 Nov El Cid, MX 4 Jan Emerald Bay, MX 38 Mar Fairfield Ocean Ridge, SC 38 Sep Timeshare Closings Experience. Quality. Service. Providing Professional Timeshare Closing Services Since 1996 JRA Services, Inc. www.TimeshareResaleClosings.com (954) 718-7076 www.tstoday.com for back issues, message boards, Special Reports and much more TimeSharing Today First Fairway, TX 20 Jul Fox Hills, WI 24 Mar, 1 8Sep, 6 Nov French Lick, IN 11 Sep, 10 Nov Gatlinburg Town Sq, TN 38 Sep Golden Strand Ocean, FL 42 Nov Grand Mayan, MX 7 Mar Harbor Ridge, ME 31 Mar Highlands, Resort, AZ 22 May Holiday Hills, MO 41 Jul Horseshoe Resort, ONT 22 May Hyatt Piñon Pointe, AZ 17 Jan Inn at Silver Creek, CO 39 Sep Innsbruck Village CC, NM 6 Mar Lawrence Welk, CA 22 Jul, 18 Nov Logonita Lodge, CA 37 Nov Manhattan Club, NY 24 Nov Marriott’s Canyon Villas,CA 37 Mar Marriott’s Custom House,MA 14 Jul Marriott’s Imperial Palm, FL 16 Mar Marriott’s SurfWatch, SC 38 Sep Massanutten Shenandoah,VA 40 Mar Mayan Sea Garden, MX 22 Mar, 24 May, 28 Jul Mazatlan resorts 42 Sep. 4 Nov Mountain Edge, NH 16 Sep Mountain Loft, TN 37 May Ocean Shores, WA 32 Mar Pacific Shores, BC 9 Sep Pelican, St. Maarten 11 Mar Page 19 Pueblo Bay Mazatlan, MX 38 Mar Royal Resorts, MX 15 May San Luis Bay Inn, CA 5 Jan Sea Watch on Beach, FL 21 Jul Sedona Pines, AZ 19 Jan Sedona Springs, AZ 17 Jan Sheraton Vistana, FL 39 Nov Shores at Lake Travis, TX 18 Mar Silverleaf Hill Country, TX 8 Jan Surrey Grand Crowne, MO 29 Nov Tahiti Village, NV 27 Nov Tropic Shores, FL 33 Mar, 8 Jul Villa Vera Puerto Mio,MX 35 Mar Vista Mirage, CA 10 Jan, 40 Jul Westgate South Beach, FL 26 Mar Westgate Williamsburg,VA 41 Nov Williamsburg Plant., VA 39 May Wyndham Ave Plaza, LA 12 Mar Wyndham Flagstaff, AZ 21 Jan Royal Holiday MX complaints 1 Mar,1, 10 May, 5 Jul, 40 Sep Royal Oasis, Bahamas 25 Jan Royal Resorts, exchange fee 21 Nov RV compared to timesharing 12 May Scams/schemes Counterfeit cashiers’ checks 4 Jul The latest 3 Mar, 34 May, 28 Nov Shell expands in NH 6 Jul Silverleaf expansion CO 25 Jan Jan/Feb, 2009 Special assessments 4 Jan SPM Resorts – profile 23 Mar Summer Bay swap 11 Jul, 6 Sep Tahoe Seasons special assessment 5 Mar, 4 May, 5 Jul Tax on timeshares, Kauai 1 Sep Tax treatment – TS disposal 4 Nov Timeshare owners groups 30 Mar, 29 May, 26 Jul, 7 Sep New national group 26 Jul, 3 Sep Timeshares - How to sell 23 Nov One person’s ownership 7, 22 Nov TimeSharing Today Index, 2007 articles 33 Jan 100th issue; history 1, 3 Jul Success using ads 4 Jul, 4 Nov Survey 9 Mar, 1 May Trade Winds Cruise Club 36 Sep Trading Places, profile 28 Sep Travel tips 35 Jan, 10 Mar, 28 May, 37 Jul, 30 Sep TRI West rental fee 5 Mar Trusts, for ownership 5 May Vacation Resorts Intl (VRI) 35 Nov Windjammer Cruises – gone 33 May Wyndham Expansion 23 Jan, 20 Mar, 20 May, 6 Jul, 21, 23 Sep, 8 Nov Internet access 21 May Renovation - San Fran, CA 23 Jan www.tstoday.com for back issues, Resort Report Cards, articles on resorts and much more TimeSharing Today Page 20 Towards a 21st Century Exchange By David Skinner, President, Holiday Group Part 1: What the Past Can Teach Us The year was 1999 and it was all the buzz. It spread quickly, from universities and colleges to desktops across America. It was “techie.” It was cool. And it . . . would set the music industry on its heels, launch a potent social movement, and empower people in a bold, new way. “It,” was a simple, easy-to-use computer program developed by a young man named Shawn Fanning, who named it after his own childhood moniker: Napster. Once installed, it tirelessly roamed the Internet in search of other Napster users to allow them to share and download music files, to build a community of enthusiasts, and to never again have to shell out twenty bucks for a music CD—and in doing so, making history. In their own way, Fanning and the Napster network had “set information free.” Meanwhile, the recording industry, already in decline, saw the looming threat and launched a savage counterattack against Napster. It was David versus Goliath, America’s first fully “wired generation” versus the Evil Empire, a faceless monolith with absolute control of the manufacture, distribution, and sale of recorded music. While Napster won in the court of public opinion, it lost in the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. In two short years, Napster went from phenom to failure, from downloaded to downtrodden. The recording industry, led by A&M Records, • • • prevailed on a point of law. Music, after all, is not free; it’s copyrighted. What has Napster to do with timesharing? Perhaps plenty. It may just be the harbinger of a new paradigm in vaca- tion ownership. It may point towards an owner-empowered future, a changing of the guard, an exchange network for the people, by the people, and of the people. Is such a thing possible, you ask? The answer is yes, it’s possible, perhaps probable, and maybe inevitable. Some might even say it’s imperative. If the exchange of your timeshare is important to you, and in a recent ARDA survey 88% of owners indicated it is, then something like Napster or its next iteration could be in your future. A 21st century exchange that is self-governed, transparent, and fair, built on the principles that gave birth to Napster—a peer-to-peer owners’ network of sharing and exchanging, a community of timeshare enthusiasts to never again be denied or downgraded, and all the while making history. Yes, it’s possible. From his college dorm room using off-the-shelf technology, Fanning at- We are licensed to issue title insurance Unlike our competitors, we are attorney owned, ensuring your paperwork is in complete compliance with the law We have a network of attorneys licensed to prepare your documents in any state The choice is simple - choose the company who is looking out for your best interests. Jan/Feb, 2009 tracted a global network of people bound by similar interests, motivated by a single purpose, each collaborating with all for the common good. He rocked the world. Napster demonstrated that by coming together we can create change, we can level the playing field, and we can make a difference. In the end, Napster did make a difference. Shortly after its demise, the recording industry began to adapt to this new world of connectivity. Theirs was no longer the best means of music distribution. The degree to which Napster contributed to this revolution is hard to say, but it’s now possible to download music for only $.99 a song. And that’s something. Making It Happen THE TECHNOLOGY. The technology and software necessary for our exchange system is highly complex and multi-layered. It must be made scalable to allow for rapid growth, robust to handle thousands of concurrent transactions, and built as “open source” for universal connectivity and innovation. The good news is these technologies are currently available, demonstrable, and proven. Here are some familiar online companies already applying these technologies: Amazon sells books online as well as provides a platform for others to sell books. Expedia provides real-time travel information and reservations in seconds. eBay enables price negotiation, transfer settlement, and user quality ratings. Google makes key word searches, but also measures Web site traffic. Facebook, the social network site, creates communities around shared interests. Wikipedia, the online encyclopedia, is collaboratively written by volunteers. THE PROCESSES. When these technological applications are combined as a single enterprise system they provide the firmament for an electronic market to emerge. But technology alone is not enough. Next we need to lay down the processes involved in making transactions. At its simplest, a timeshare exchange is a marketplace composed of owners www.tstoday.com for back issues, message boards, Special Reports and much more TimeSharing Today making transactions and creating value. This was reconfirmed recently by Craig Nash, president of Interval International, when speaking to Wall Street analysts. He said our business “compares more favorably to the security exchanges than to time share, lodging or online travel. Interval is a marketplace, just like the NYSE and NASDAQ are marketplaces.” According to Ajit Kambil and Eric van Heck, authors of Making Markets, and respected authorities on electronic markets, there are five primary processes involved in online exchanges: Search processes that allow buyers and sellers to discover and compare trading opportunities Pricing processes to help buyers and sellers discover prices Logistical processes that coordinate the transfer of physical and digital goods between buyers and sellers Payment and settlement processes to transfer funds from buyer to seller Authentication processes to verify the quality of the goods sold and credibility of the buyers and sellers In addition, they cite five trade context processes that enhance trust among trading parties and legitimizes the trade: Product representation processes that specify the presentation of products and services to buyers and sellers Regulation processes that record and recognize the transaction within a framework of laws and rules to signal it as legitimate and conforming to a set of market rules and social principles Risk management processes to reduce buyer and seller risks in a transaction Influence processes to ensure the commitments among trading partners are met Dispute resolution processes that resolve conflicts among buyers, sellers, and market makers such as auction houses. Even given the latest technology as our foundation and with the structural processes in place, one element is still missing—the one necessary to breathe life into our network. THE HUMAN ELEMENT. Networks may be intentionally built or, providing the essential elements are present, they Page 21 may emerge spontaneously. In either case, a network must have a raison d’être, a reason to be, a calling, a compelling human need that must be fulfilled. Again referring to Kambil and van Heck, “electronic markets are not technological interactions. They are human interactions supported by technology.” What’s still missing, then, is the human element. In other words, before our network can emerge, we must arise. It’s not enough “to build it and they will come.” But rather, like Napster, timeshare owners must come together, motivated by a single purpose, each collaborating with all for the common good. Only then can we begin to create change, to level the playing field, to make a difference. In the famous words of Howard Beale from the 1976 movie, Network: “But first, you’ve gotta get mad! You’ve got to say, ‘I’m as mad as hell, and I’m not going to take this anymore!’ Then we’ll figure out what to do . . . .” In Part 2, we’ll look at the major timeshare exchange companies, the good, the bad and the important roles they might play in the 21st Century Exchange. Jan/Feb, 2009 TRI WEST Home of the Timeshare BLUEBOOK© & Vacation Gallery 800-423-6377 triwest-timeshare.com You are our business. We excel at timeshare management, sales and rental. But long term relationships with our owners, based on communication and trust, are the foundation of our success. If accountability, quality and cost containment are important to you – call us. With over 20 years experience, chances are we can help. 20 Executive Park Road Hilton Head Island, South Carolina 29928 888-433-4762 x-11113 [email protected] Resort Management www.tstoday.com for back issues, Resort Report Cards, articles on resorts and much more TimeSharing Today Page 22 Jan/Feb, 2009 AROUND THE INDUSTRY Celebrity acquires David Walley’s in NV Celebrity Resorts has acquired David Walley’s Resort, Hot Springs & Spa located in the Carson Valley of Genoa, Nevada. The resort is the 20th resort for Celebrity Resorts. David Walley’s is less than 13 miles from South Lake Tahoe, with a view of the Sierra Nevada Mountains, The resort features six natural hot mineral springs, a full-service spa, and two on-site restaurants. Resort accommodations include studio, one-bedroom, two-bedroom, and executive suites. The one and two-bedroom suites offer kitchens, private balconies, and fireplaces, while the executive suites feature private saunas. No discount for shellfish licenses The Block Island (Rhode Island) Town Council recently tackled the problem of timeshare owners claiming residency to obtain shellfishing licenses at the lower fees available to residents. The same owners were also asking to be placed on the resident mooring waiting list. The council reviewed the town’s legal definition of residency. It requires full-time residence and allows for an absence of up to three months in any calendar year provided the resident is also a registered Block Island voter. The council decided that only if the timeshare owner fit the criteria as set forth in the town ordinance, then he or she could qualify as a resident. Wyndham adds to portfolio of resorts Wyndham Vacation Ownership is now welcoming guests to its newest seaside resort, WorldMark Long Beach, along the Washington coast on the Long Beach Peninsula. The 98-unit oceanfront resort offers owners views of both the Pacific Ocean and the area’s local beaches. The resort is the company’s eighth property in the state and second on the Long Beach peninsula and will operate as a WorldMark by Wyndham resort. WorldMark Long Beach includes a variety of studio, one-, two- and three- bedroom standard units as well as three-bedroom Presidential units. Amenities include an outdoor pool, spa, wading pool, fitness center, business center, recreation room, arcade, barbeque grill area and retail shop. A popular vacation destination, Long Beach offers a number of outdoor activities. The area’s natural beauty, miles of beaches and wildlife viewing locations lend themselves well to such activities as beachcombing, hiking, clam digging and bird watching. Visitors can take in the views from the Long Beach Boardwalk or take a bike ride along the eight-mile Discovery Trail, which was built to commemorate the famed Lewis and Clark expedition. The region has a number of lighthouses, museums, restaurants, shops and historical sites for visitors to explore. Long Beach is home to several festivals throughout the year including the renowned Washington State International WorldMark Long Beach Kite Festival held annually in August. The initial phase of Wyndham Vacation Resorts Shawnee Village, its first new development at Shawnee Village in Pennsylvania’s Pocono Mountains, is now open. The resort is operating within the company’s FairShare Plus by Wyndham portfolio of properties. Currently sixteen units are available to guests and upon completion of the second phase in 2009, the resort will total 41 units within ten two-story buildings. The new property joins the company’s previously acquired fixed-week units located in the Shawnee Village development. The property includes a mix of twobedroom standard units and four-bedroom Presidential units, each featuring a full kitchen, fireplace, whirlpool tub and a washer and dryer. Owners have access to a number of resort amenities including an indoor and outdoor pool, sauna, game room, gift shop, playground, barbeque area, tennis courts and miniature golf course. Owners can enjoy boating and fishing on the nearby Delaware River, hiking in the Pocono Mountains, golfing and skiing the local slopes at the Shawnee Mountain Ski Area. Visitors can also explore local antique shops or experience the brilliant colors of the fall foliage. The new property joins the company’s existing 539 units at the complex which were obtained following its 2005 acquisition of Shawnee Development, Inc. The units originally obtained in that acquisition remain fixed-week. www.tstoday.com for back issues, Resort Report Cards, articles on resorts and much more TimeSharing Today Wyndham Vacation Ownership added to its portfolio of resorts in Colorado with the opening of Wyndham Vacation Resorts Steamboat Springs and the expansion of its established WorldMark Steamboat Springs property. These additions to the company’s FairShare Plus by Wyndham and WorldMark, The Club portfolios add 142 units to the popular resort complex. Located in Ski Town, U.S.A.®, the company’s Steamboat complex is within minutes of the area’s numerous ski slopes, trails and hot springs. “Steamboat Springs is one of only a few destinations where we have established resorts under both our WorldMark by Wyndham and Wyndham Vacation Resorts brands, which demonstrates the popularity of this destination among our more than 800,000 owner families,” said Gary Byrd, executive vice president, Hospitality Services, Wyndham Vacation Ownership. The new Wyndham Vacation Resorts Steamboat Springs’ includes a mix of 71 one-, two- and three-bedroom units in addition to two- and three-bedroom Presidential units. The WorldMark Steamboat Springs expansion includes 71 one-, two- and three-bedroom traditional units as well as two- and three-bedroom Penthouse and Presidential units. The complex includes a number of amenities for owners to share. Owners can relax in the resort complex’s lounge area, game room, steam room, sauna, outdoor spas and indoor and outdoor pools. For those looking for even more active adventures on site, the complex has an arcade, sports court and playground to enjoy. WorldMark New Braunfels is now Wyndham’s third Texas resort. Operating within the company’s WorldMark, The Club portfolio, the 44-unit resort offers owners a newly constructed retreat in the heart of the activity-filled Texas Hill Country, conveniently located between Austin and San Antonio. The resort’s two- and three-bedroom condominium-style units and threebedroom Penthouse units each feature a full kitchen and living room. On-site amenities include a fitness center; outdoor pool and spa; recreation room; arcade; barbeque grill area; and business center with internet access. New Braunfels is a favorite destination for outdoor enthusiasts. The Guadal- Page 23 upe and Comal Rivers offer opportunities for fishing, rafting and tubing. The new WorldMark New Braunfels resort is located adjacent to the Guadalupe River, near the Gruene Rapids, making for easy access to this popular rafting area. Visitors can also sail, boat, canoe, kayak and swim in nearby Canyon Lake. Beyond water activities, guests can play the area’s golf courses, explore the Natural Bridge Caverns or visit the Schlitterbahn Waterpark Resort, one of the top water parks in the world. Lastly, visitors can also experience New Braunfels’ German culture in addition to the city’s shops, restaurants and Historic District of Gruene. Westgate hits new high and low Westgate Resorts has reached new heights with the world’s tallest timeshare resort, and a new low with a $1 million punitive damage judgment rendered against it. In November, the $1.2 billion PH Towers by Westgate in Las Vegas reached a pivotal point in development with the attainment of the highest point of verti- Jan/Feb, 2009 cal construction. Located at the Planet Hollywood Resort & Casino, the upscale 52-story PH Towers will be the tallest timeshare building in the world. The 3.2 million-square-foot PH Towers will also hold the distinction of being the first vacation ownership resort to be fully integrated with a major resort and casino complex. The 2,500-guestroom Planet Hollywood Resort debuted last year, having been reinvented from the former Aladdin Resort & Casino via a $1 billion makeover, and will provide direct access to PH Towers. Ultimately, the timeshare property will feature approximately 1,200 luxury timeshare units, as well as a casino, a 35,000-square-foot convention center, a restaurant and 16,000 square feet of retail space. Also in mid-November, a Utah County jury hit Westgate Resorts with $1 million in punitive damages for luring people to its timeshare sales pitches in Park City by offering what turned out to be nearly impossible-to-redeem vouchers for free trips. Consumer Protection Group, a corpo- www.tstoday.com for back issues, message boards, Special Reports and much more TimeSharing Today ration created specifically to sue Westgate on behalf of consumers who believe it cheated them — won the lawsuit involving 15 parties who said they were promised airfare and two nights of lodging in Anaheim if they attended sales pitches at the Westgate Park City Resort & Spa. Attorney Scot A. Boyd said customers were given vouchers for the travel - supposedly worth $500 each - but “restrictions made them almost impossible to use.” While Westgate contracted with a third party to provide the travel, Boyd argued Westgate should have known travel vouchers it bought had little or no real value because “it was purchasing certificates for only $32, and it was supposedly good for $500 worth of air-inclusive travel. That by itself should have been a sign of trouble.” He said that despite numerous complaints by consumers, Westgate continued to offer the travel vouchers until it was sued. The parties involved in the lawsuit who did not receive promised travel were awarded $500 each by a Fourth District Page 24 jury in Provo last week — the purported value of the travel vouchers. The jury awarded an additional $1 million in punitive damages, which Boyd attributed to Westgate blaming problems on consumers and showing no remorse for their troubles. Boyd said the lawsuit involved only 15 parties out of more than 900 who have assigned their claims to Consumer Protection Group to pursue against Westgate — and that it plans to pursue even more of those claims now. Sol Melia opens in Dominican Republic Sol Meliá Vacation Club has opened The Reserve at Paradisus Palma Real in Punta Cana, Dominican Republic that will feature 190 one- and two-bedroom lockoff units with private hot tubs and direct access from the lower level patio units into a lazy river swimming pool. Presidential Club Suites will feature two, three and four bedrooms, with the four bedroom suites accommodating up to 10 people, to be sold as a multi-week product. Paradisus Palma Real’s amenities Jan/Feb, 2009 and services include spa treatments, a custom fitness program, championship golf course, a large sandy beach, variety of gourmet restaurants, specialty bars, a casino and nightly entertainment, supervised children’s programs, daily adult activities, concierge service and 24-hour room service. Including The Reserve at Paradisus Palma Real, Sol Meliá Vacation Club has three member resorts in Punta Cana. New European timeshare rules The European Parliament has passed a law to crack down on rogue timeshare and vacation clubs. The new rules will give consumers a 14-day right of withdrawal and also increase the obligations on traders. The sellers will have to provide a list of standard information, telling buyers exactly what is they are buying. A failure to offer such a list would extend the get-out clause to three months. “With this new law we are giving consumers additional protections, new rights and we are plugging the gaps, the loopholes the scam-merchants have been operating,” member of parliament Arlene McCarthy told the BBC. “Consumers will enjoy the same rights, whether they are buying in Varna on the Black Sea or Valencia on the Costa Blanca. They will now have a 14-day right of withdrawal, which means that if they had too much sun, or sangria or slivovitz, they can simply walk away and say ‘I am not interested’.” The Timeshare Consumers Association in the UK, and its sister organizations across Europe, are welcoming the vote, but are frustrated the right of withdrawal is only a two weeks. The new Directive aims to tackle loopholes in the current rules. Most importantly, it will extend the scope of the 1994 European Union Timeshare Directive to cover new products which have emerged on the market – like discount vacation clubs, and “timeshare-like” vacations on cruise boats, canal boats and recreational vehicles. It will also extend protection to areas like timeshare resale and exchange clubs. The new rules are intended to ensure that consumers are well protected across Europe and to create a level playing field in the market for timeshare products. www.tstoday.com for back issues, Resort Report Cards, articles on resorts and much more TimeSharing Today Trump gets approval in Scotland Developer Donald Trump has won permission to build “the world’s greatest golf course,” complete with high-rise timeshare units and eight-story hotel, on a rare and ecologically sensitive stretch of dunes overlooking the North Sea. The New York-based businessman said he was “greatly honored” after Scottish ministers in Edinburgh confirmed that his dream of creating one of golf’s most northerly resorts had been approved, despite vociferous opposition from environmentalists and many local residents. The resort, north of Aberdeen, will feature two 18-hole championship courses, four blocks of 950 timeshare units, 500 private homes, 36 villas, a golf academy, and housing for 400 staff. The approval, however, legally binds Trump to agree to a series of environmental checks and controls, giving Aberdeenshire council and the Scottish government’s environment agency, Scottish Natural Heritage, legal oversight to ensure remaining plant species and wildlife are fully protected. Trump will also be required to build a 225-pupil primary school, shops, 98 lowcost houses and 50 starter homes on land provided free by the council. Trump said: “It will be a tremendous asset and source of pride for both Aberdeenshire and Scotland for many generations. As I have often said, because of the quality of the land we are given to work with, we will build the greatest golf course in the world.” Conservationists were furious since ministers had agreed to override legal protection for part of the Foveran links, a system of naturally shifting sand dunes, which are designated a site of special scientific interest, but are central to Trump’s Page 25 vision. The so-called “back nine” holes of the main 18-hole course will be built over about a tenth of the dunes despite protests from Trump’s own ecologists and SNH that this was unnecessarily destructive. Trump had refused to move that section of the course, again overruling his own environmental experts, telling the planning inquiry in June that he didn’t do “half-assed.” It was, he told the inspectors, all or nothing. It was the “magnificence of the dunes, the valleys of the dunes, the access to the ocean, the views of the ocean, the elevations” that made it “potentially, the greatest course in the world,” he told the inquiry. The planning inspectors ruled that the damage to the dunes was outweighed by the resort’s substantial value to the economy. Trump has been warned that he can only begin building the high rise timeshare buildings in stages after a certain number of affordable homes are completed. He must also ensure that local walkers and visitors will still have unimpeded access to the dunes under Scotland’s strict right to roam legislation, rules Trump was unaware of until he was questioned by the Ramblers Association at the planning inquiry. Jan/Feb, 2009 First Disney resort in Hawai’i Walt Disney Parks and Resorts has broken ground for its first resort in Hawai‘i with a traditional Hawaiian blessing ceremony on its 21-acre oceanfront property, located at the Ko Olina Resort & Marina development on the western side of O‘ahu. Scheduled to open in 2011, the new destination, overlooking blue lagoons and white sand beaches, is planned to include 350 hotel rooms and 480 Disney Vacation Club timeshare villas. “This Disney destination resort will provide a unique way for families to experience Hawai‘i,” said Jay Rasulo, Chairman of Walt Disney Parks and Resorts. “We’ll create a place where all family members can discover the wonder of these special islands.” Rasulo noted that Disney chose to build a resort on O‘ahu due to the international popularity of Hawai‘i as a family vacation destination. Hawai‘i is among the top vacation choices of Disney Vacation Club members following Disney’s theme park destinations. Unfinished Cape Cod resort is foreclosed Navigator Beach Club in Dennisport on Cape Cod, MA, was supposed to be finished two years ago and include luxurious amenities like an indoor pool and sauna. But that never happened. Dozens of people paid thousands of dollars. But developer Robert Reposa took their money and never delivered. The project was never properly registered as a timeshare. Then Reposa stopped paying his $2.2 million mortgage. Finally, work stopped. The bank-threatened foreclosure was delayed last March when Reposa claimed to have an investor. But that didn’t materialize; the foreclosure deed has officially been filed with Barnstable County Registry of Deeds. Despite at least 50 complaints, the attorney general’s office won’t comment because this is an “ongoing investigation,” which is discouraging and frustrating to the people who at this point have little chance of ever seeing either their money or timeshare. www.tstoday.com for back issues, Resort Report Cards, articles on resorts and much more TimeSharing Today Page 26 Ask Dave M David McClintock has been a regular contributor to the message board at www. tstoday.com for many years. We are pleased to publish some of his responses to questions posted during the past year. Posted by Hazel on 01/29/2008: I received a mailed card from a company that wants to buy my timeshare with no money up front. They will be in my city and I am asked to call and make an appointment. They are not listed on the BBB out of Denver, their home base. Does anyone know about them and can you answer soon, because they will be here on Fri and Sat, this week. Posted by Dave M on 01/30/2008: These companies are often called “postcard companies,” because that’s how you hear about them. Based on ex- perience with other postcard companies and a lot that has been written about them in TimeSharing Today and on other timeshare sites, they most likely won’t pay you for your timeshare. It’s almost certain that they will try to convince you that your timeshare is an albatross that will be a heavy burden (special assessments, rapidly increasing maintenance fees, etc.) for you and your heirs and the only solution they have is for you to pay them to take your timeshare off your hands. How much? Likely in the range of $3,000-$5,000. Yes, you would pay them that much; they won’t pay you. Also, it’s likely that they won’t take your check, only a credit card. They won’t allow you to escrow your funds until the deal closes. They won’t allow you to take documents home to make a decision after careful thought. You’ll have to decide on the spot. If you agree to pay, you’ll likely find your account charged for the full amount that weekend, making it difficult to change your mind later. Then, assuming they are like other companies of this ilk, they will turn around and sell your timeshare, perhaps listing it on e-Bay for a starting bid of $1 plus closing costs, something you could do yourself without paying such a huge amount! For practical advice on how to sell your timeshare, please carefully read my two-part post on this forum of 10/29/2007. If you decide to attend the meeting, go armed with knowledge so that you don’t make a costly mistake! Posted by tdrum1 on 2/03/08 Has anyone ever dealt with National Timeshare Help Center? They supposedly are a membership type company. I have been trying to sell for awhile now (years) and am at wits end... Posted by Dave M on 02/04/2008: tdrum1 - NTHC is a legitimate company with a good record of renting/selling timeshares. Posted by Frankie on 02/22/2008: I have a timeshare with Marriott, If I wanted to rent it out myself or through TimeSharing Today, what is the proce- Jan/Feb, 2009 dure? What do I need to do at Marriott? Posted by Dave M on 02/18/2008: Frankie - Call Marriott Owner Services (the same number you call to reserve your week). First task is to reserve the very best week you can - the week that you figure will be more in demand by others than any other week (e.g., holiday, spring vacation or other weeks when kids are out of school). Next ask Marriott for a proposal on taking your week for a rental. You should do both of those things a full year in advance of the week you reserve in order to get the best week and to have the best chance that Marriott will be willing to make you an offer. If you have an off-season week or if you make your call much closer than a year to your check-in date, there is a good chance Marriott won’t make you an offer. Even if Marriott does make an offer, it’s likely to be a disappointing offer, almost certainly quite a bit less than what you can rent your week for by yourself. To do that, advertise here at TSToday, at Redweek, at myresortnetwork.com, and on other sites that don’t charge an upfront fee other than a nominal listing fee of $15-$40. Check other listings at those sites for comparable weeks and price your listing at or below what others are asking. Use the TSToday rental agreement when you find a renter. You can purchase the agreement online here for a nominal fee. Posted by Frankie on 02/18/2008: Thanks Dave M. Another question, do I have to notify Marriott that I am giving my week up to a renter if I rent it on my own? Or does the rental agreement cover them on check-in? Posted by Dave M on 02/19/2008: Frankie - No need to tell Marriott you plan to rent it. However, once you rent it and get paid, you should be sure to call Marriott and add the renter’s name to the reservation. Otherwise, your renter will not be permitted to check in. Better yet, ask your renter for his/her Marriott Rewards number. Then call Marriott and add the renter’s name (asking to have it listed first) and Marriott Rewards number (not your own number) to the reservation. Then your renter can log into his/her account at Marriott.com and see the reservation. Marriott doesn’t care about your rental agreement. Your phone call will be all the authorization they need. www.tstoday.com for back issues, message board, Special Reports and much more TimeSharing Today Page 27 BYU biz prof’s system gets more timeshare owners the weeks they want As the February Presidents Day holidays approach, timeshare vacation owners are taking advantage of vacation weeks to plan family gatherings and winter getaways. Research has shown that the majority of timeshare vacation owners desire to exchange their resort-weeks each year. But TimeSharing Today readers know that it is often difficult to get a desired resort-week. A new exchange method, developed at Brigham Young University, helps timeshare exchange companies better schedule vacation time at affiliated resorts, leading to happier customers and opportunities for increased revenue. Scott Sampson, a professor at Brigham Young University Marriott School of Management, created a new mathematical timeshare scheduling method that increased the number of customers who could stay at their mostpreferred resorts by 30 to 45 percent, without adding additional timeshare units or properties. His results, which demonstrate how using mathematical programming can help match owner requests to resort availability, can be found in the October issue of the academic journal Operations Research. “I knew that if we applied mathematics to this vacation timeshare problem, we would get tremendous results,” Sampson said. “When you’re a math geek like I am, you even look at going on vacation as mathematical.” After testing his equations on company data, Sampson implemented his new method at Owner’s Resorts and Exchange, a timeshare management company that was recently acquired by Vacation Resorts International. “In the first year, we demonstrated the potential for a phenomenal increase in satisfaction of timeshare exchange requests,” Sampson said. “If you have a better exchange, there can be more people who are happy because they get to go where they want to go. Timeshare exchange companies can perform more exchanges and get a better reputation. It is a win-win situation.” Sampson’s models, in different forms, can be applied to conferences, classes or any problem involving scheduling people and limited resources. “I look at problems involving customers to see how we can use mathematics to make people happier,” Sampson said. “If we can optimize, we can have more satisfaction, less stress and happier people.” “Survey data shows that more than 60 percent of the people who own timeshare intervals desire to trade them in a given year,” Sampson said. “Even though people buy specific weeks at specific properties, the timeshare industry is fundamentally based on exchange.” Exchanging timeshares can be frustrating for some owners because of complex policies, varying membership priority and limited resort availability. Many timeshare exchange companies use systems that allow people to select from a wide variety of properties for exchange, but without accommodating the fact that some resorts are so popular that it is very difficult to get them in exchange. The highest-priority customers might get to stay at the resort they choose, but there is much less of a guarantee for customers of lower priority. “The vacation timeshare industry sometimes gets a bad reputation,” Sampson said. “There are great locations you can trade into, but customers can be disappointed when they don’t consider the free market economics of availability.” Sampson’s system acknowledges limited availability, but takes advantage of the fact that people at all levels have some degree of flexibility. His optimization model uses flexibility in customer preferences to allow for trade-offs and to maximize the number of customers whose requests are granted, especially requests from high-priority customers. For example, a high-priority exchange customer might be indifferent between three different resort choices - Sampson’s system uses mathematics to determine which of those three options to give the customer so that other customers, of lower priority, can get the most from their resort choices. www.tstoday.com for back issues, message boards, Special Reports and much more Jan/Feb, 20009 TimeSharing Today Page 28 TRI West Real Estate Editor’s note: This is another in a series of advertisers’ articles spotlighting their services. TRI West Real Estate has been offering education and advice on timeshare ownership since 1981. They specialize in the resale and rental of quality timeshare resorts worldwide. TRI West Real Estate is the largest and oldest licensed resale and rental broker on the west coast and is recognized as an innovative pioneer in the timeshare resale/rental marketplace. TRI West was the first company to: • publish a monthly Timeshare Multiple Listing (MLS) book (1982) • conduct live annual National Timeshare Auctions (1985) • publish a combined (II/RCI) Resort Directory Guide (1995) • create the “Home of the Timeshare Bluebook” website (1995) • be approved by the California Department of Real Estate for optional Timeshare Multiple Listing Services (1997 ) • open a storefront Timeshare Resale & Rental Vacation Gallery (2000) • open Vacation Home Alternatives department for upscale fractionals (2003) TRI West has over 5,000 current listings worldwide with a large selection inArizona, California, Hawaii, Nevada and Mexico. Information on available listings, as well as consumer tips on renting or buying timeshares, is provided by TRI West licensed agents and at http://www.triwest-timeshare.com. The company has sold over 6,800 timeshares and processed over 3,000 rental transactions for owners, buyers and travelers worldwide. TRI West current services and fees are: • Listing a timeshare for sale or rent -no charge • Optional MDR Telecom MLS exposure -$225 • Sale commission subject to minimum -15% • Rental commission subject to minimum -40% Viccie Mac, TRI West Sales and Rental Manager, has been in the timeshare business since 1978. Before joining TRI West, she managed the marketing of off-site broker timeshare sales for several real estate offices for resorts in Arizona, Utah and Jan/Feb, 2009 Mexico. Mac gained additional resort experience as director of sales at a major Arizona resort. She has been active in the rental of timeshares since 1986 and began focusing on owner rentals in 1990. Viccie was quoted in a Family Circle article on timeshare and villa rentals. She published the first “Owner’s Guide to Renting” and “Rental Tips for Owners” in 1992. Mac has also developed a number of processing tools to facilitate the efficient processing of owner rentals for both the owner and traveler, as well as the resort. She is currently licensed in Arizona and California and manages both the sales and rental activities for TRI West. Senior Sales Agents include Greg Gibson and Betty Zipf. Mario Collura, President and Broker of TRI West, entered the timeshare industry as one of the developers at The Whaler in Maui, Hawaii in 1979. During the next few years he was also a sub-broker for a number of timeshare projects in California, Hawaii and Mexico. Since 1981, he has concentrated his efforts on helping to create a viable secondary market for the resales and rentals of timeshare properties. Collura is the author of “Mario’s Tips” and is frequently quoted in national media, including: Consumer Digest, Consumer Reports, Dollar $ense, Forbes and Kiplinger’s Personal Finance Magazine. His “Tips,” along with the other educational tools developed by TRI WEST, provide the basis for educating the consumer about timeshares and ultimately creating a mature secondary market for the timeshare industry. Mario earned a BSEE from Case Western Reserve University and has conducted graduate work toward an MBA Degree at UCLA. He is licensed in California as a general contractor, and as a real estate broker in the states of Arizona, California and Nevada. Mario has been a guest speaker on the subject of Timeshare Resales and Rentals at conventions of both the California Association of Realtors and ARDA, as well as many resort and management homeowner association meetings. He also served as an expert witness to testify regarding the value of timeshare property for California, Florida, and Federal court cases. Mario Collura is a Preferred Resale Broker recommended and trained by Four Seasons for the sale of Residence Club Intervals at Four Seasons Residence Club Aviara, North San Diego CA and Scottsdale at Troon North AZ. For more information on this company, contact TRI West Real Estate at 13353 Washington Blvd, Los Angeles, CA 90066, by phone at (800) 423-6377or email to [email protected]. www.tstoday.com for back issues, message boards, Resale Value Tracker and much more TimeSharing Today Page 31 Tootin’ In Steamboat By Don Thompson, Long Beach, CA We always try to make a yearly trip to Colorado and this time it was Steamboat Springs in the Fall. The cold snap didn’t come while we were there, so the Fall Foliage was limited to the very high country. But Best Laid Plans should always be sprinkled with flexibility, so we made do just fine, thank you. The town is named for the thermal springs that bubble up in many locations in town. The early settlers thought the bubbling sounded like a steamboat whistle, and the name stuck. It’s nickname is Ski Town, USA. A river runs through it and the old town is filled with charming shops. No cookie cutter national chain stores here, thank you very much. Our home for the week was Vacation Internationale - The Village at Steamboat. We arranged the trade through Interval International. We were very pleased with the accommodations and would recommend the resort to TimeSharing Today readers. We had a one bedroom unit on the 3rd floor of one of several buildings. Thank goodness for the elevator, especially on days we were hauling groceries. The living room was cozy, opening onto a balcony that had beautiful views of Mount Warner, the ski resort right in town. The kitchen had all the required implements, and the bedroom had a bed! What more could one ask for? Well.....a washer/dryer right in the unit. And so they were. The only negative thing about the complex was that there was construction going on all week. This meant big trucks and dust flying. But it was not outside our windows so we easily ignored it. The area is beautifully situated in the mountains, and is a year round vacation spot. The first morning, we rode the gondola lift to the top of the mountain, although we thought the $25 fee was quite steep for a short trip that didn’t require any gasoline. At the top is a panoramic view of the town and valley below. We hiked a circular nature trail which offered wonderful views of aspens and wild flowers. A little of God’s tears delayed our trip down the mountain long enough to have a cup of coffee. What’s to complain about? In the afternoon, we visited five of the springs in town and a little art gallery, located in the old train depot. We enjoyed another natural phenomenon: God’s frozen tears, hail. Time to go “home” for “B&B” (beer and balcony) and to watch the sun and moon trade places. Next day was a walking/gawking agenda. First was the Yampa River Botanic Park, with six acres of lush gardens. We had a picnic by the pond, joined by several pieces of statuary. A two hour stroll later, we were ready for a change of outdoor scenery, so we headed for Fish Creek Falls. They are spectacular, plunging 283 feet through a geological fault. A footbridge at the bottom of the falls provides an excellent view of the cascade. Jan/Feb, 2009 A driving tour was up on the following day. We headed for Yampa River State Park, just outside of Hayden, a small, proud farming community. The town had a charming local museum. Just outside the park, we pulled off the road to watch a flock of about a dozen sand cranes strut about the stubble of a plowed field. Later we asked a park ranger about them. He said the locals refer to them as “Ribeye on the fly.” We were game, but didn’t see any on the hiking trail we took after a picnic lunch. We had time for another stop before the siren of the B&B enticed us back to our unit. Nestled a block off the main Steamboat drag is the Tread of the Pioneers Museum, located in an old Victorian home. It’s worth a step back in time to visit. Up early the next morning for a “Must do before you die” experience: a hot air balloon ride. When I heard the price I almost fainted: $290 for the two of us for a ½ hour ride! But, since you must do it before you die, might as well do it now. A chase driver picked us up in a van and we drove out to a large church parking lot where our balloon and basket awaited us. WE NEED YOUR TIMESHARE! LOOKING TO MOVE TO FLORIDA? Major land developer on Florida’s West Coast is looking for a limited number of free and clear timeshare interests to be used in our new home construction promotion. Use your timeshare as a trade-in on a real property in a beautiful community on Florida’s Gulf Coast. 90 Minutes from Orlando 45 Minutes North of Tampa All homesites are a minimum of 1.25 acres wooded lots with paved roads, a 15,000 acre freshwater lake with 2 boat ramps, one for freshwater, the other for saltwater, minutes from the Gulf of Mexico. These homesites are 2 miles from a major hospital 5 miles from a major shopping mall. Call today for information Toll Free: 1-877-587-7614 www.tstoday.com for back issues, message boards, Resale Value Tracker and much more TimeSharing Today We shared the experience with a couple from Iowa. Since there were only four of us, plus the “pilot,” we had enough room to feel comfortable. With a blast of fuel and release of the tether we were aloft. I doubt that we got higher than 3,000 feet or drifted more than 10 mph, but the serenity, the view is something we will always remember. We will also remember the bill! We saw a herd of deer and lots of trophy homes. Too soon we were over the airport. The pilot dropped a rope to the chase crew and we settled down in the parking lot! What a way to get to the airport. And with no luggage. And it was only midmorning. The rest of the day lay ahead. We decided to spend it at Steamboat and Pearl lakes, a 20 minute drive north. We had a picnic and a stroll alongside Pearl Lake. Then we took a more challenging hike along Steamboat Lake, where we came across the graves of the pioneer family that first settled here. Then on to a gold mining camp that was founded in 1865. There are a dozen or so cabins and houses in this ghost town, and one, little, one room school. A charming way to end Page 32 the afternoon. Back to the balcony and a beer....or two. Although our complex has both an indoor and outdoor swimming pool, a Jacuzzi and a sauna, it does not have a hot mineral pool or springs. So we were off to Strawberry Park Hot Springs the next morning. It is seven miles from Steamboat Springs, up a steep, windy road, the last three miles of which are gravel. The resort is nestled between mountains in a heavily forested area. The setting is just beautiful. The mineral water bubbles up at 150 degrees, which is then channeled into several pools, where the temperature can be controlled. There are lounges and Adirondack-style wooden deck chairs surrounding the pools. The masonry and river rock architecture create a Hobbit like scene. It is one of the most unique experiences we have had on our many sojourns. The price for all day use was $10 and clothing is optional in the evening. We didn’t stay, though, for that! We finished our day with an easy hike along the Yampa River and a boardwalk stroll over a wetland that had been put up by the local Rotarians. The views of the mountain and the ski runs made me yearn Jan/Feb, 2009 TSToday Anywhere Subscriber Robert Anthony took this photo of his wife Nancy Jean as she shows off her TimeSharing Today near their exchange to “that great spot we enjoyed in Scotland.” for the white stuff. Then again I thought about my balcony and my beer. What a wonderful place to spend a week in the Fall. Maybe we will come back for some of the white stuff. www.tstoday.com for back issues, Resort Report Cards, articles on resorts and much more TimeSharing Today Page 33 Jan/Feb, 2009 Private and Vintage Rail Travel Available as a Timeshare In the Gilded Age, the mode of luxury transport for the elite was on a private rail car or “private varnish.” These well adorned cars had the exquisite finishes of a fine mansion, and a private chef to go with it. Ownership of a private rail car, of course, was reserved for only the wealthiest of Americans. Now, Train’shares Inc. is offering the private rail car experience with a unique twist – you can reserve a whole car or you can just reserve a single room on a vintage rail car on a weekly or timeshare basis. Train’shares will begin 8-day vacation journeys aboard “private varnish” and the vintage cars in April 2009 over routes throughout the United States. The private rail car, Abraham Lincoln, will be coupled together with the three cars that make up the American Traveler train to provide several vintage rail car options. First, guests may choose to reserve the entire Abraham Lincoln for a completely private experience with friends or family. The Abraham Lincoln was originally constructed in 1910 by the Pullman Company. The red gum wood interior has been meticulously restored. Period furnishings adorn the car. The vintage elegance of the Abraham Lincoln is rare. Or, if guests prefer a more social excursion, or if they are a party not large enough to want all the space a private rail car affords, they can choose to ride on the accompanying American Traveler. The American Traveler is a three car set with all the accoutrements of the private rail car experience. Aboard the American Traveler, guests have the option to reserve just a single room for the journey. While traveling like a president in the aptly named Abraham Lincoln or on the American Traveler, a private chef will have each guest eating like a king. Train’shares journeys will also have “ports of call” in the same vein as yacht excursions in the Caribbean or the Mediterranean. These “ports of calls” will allow travelers to disembark to The Abraham Lincoln Pullman car peruse the museums of Washington DC or to explore the natural wonders of the Grand Canyon. According to the company’s website at www.trainshares.com, timeshares range in cost from $3,970 to $6,620 per person. There was no indication, either in the press release or on the website, as to the annual maintenance fee. Each trip includes all meals, so that, unlike traditional timeshares, meal cost would be figured into the annual maintenance fee. A timeshare purchase entitles the owner to a trip of 8 days and 7 nights each year during an annual Designated Time Period or at any other time(s). Owners can also take more shorter vacations by using a desired number of Journey Nights at different times or can delay the use of Journey Nights until a future time. Timeshare ownership is for ten years. The project is affiliated with RCI’s Points system so that trainshares may be exchanged for stays at conventional timeshare resorts. www.tstoday.com for back issues, message boards, Special Reports and much more TimeSharing Today Page 34 Jan/Feb, 2009 FOCUS ON: Grand Mayan Riviera Maya, Playa Del Carmen, MX By Bill Dagenhart Our arrival to Cancun was flawless. After reading many reviews pro and con about renting a car, we decided not to. We emailed the resort for information about getting transportation to the resort. They responded the same day with instructions. This is a no charge service to the resort. Once we got past customs and the timeshare sales people in the airport (posing to be transportation/ drivers), the Grand Mayan driver was right outside the airport doors, holding up the Mayan sign. The ride to the resort took about 35 minutes. Not a lot to see once outside the airport limits. The return trip transportation cost was $15 per person. Arriving at the resort, check-in went quickly. For now, they are located in a huge tent that’s fixed up nicely inside, because the Grand Mayan Lobby is currently being built. We were approached by a timeshare person as you exit the lobby but this was painless, as I told her I only purchased resale. I never heard from them again. Our bellhop loaded our luggage and whisked us off to our unit. As we were driven around, you could see how expansive the resort was and how beautiful the grounds were. I heard one person say they had 300 gardeners at this resort. The grounds and pools were spectacular. The unit was impressive. I’d have to say, the nicest so far I’ve stayed in. The unit was approximately 900 square feet with approximately 12 foot ceilings. Everything in the unit was top notch, right down to the dipping pool that constantly overflowed, keeping cool water within, on our huge balcony. After a few hours in the sun, you appreciate all the pools, including the dipping pool on the balcony. The kitchen, as others have stated, is limited. You don’t see a lot of utensils or appliances, but still very functional if used. Our unit was located within about a 10 minute walk to the pools and different restaurants, market, internet cafe. We could have got carted to this area, but the walk was beautiful and we walk for miles anyway. It was unusual for us, but we bought no groceries; might have been the inconvenience of not having the rental car, but the food was excellent and, all things considered, reasonable. The cost was no more than what I pay to eat out where I live. There are several restaurants, as described on their website, and we ate at most of them. From Filet Mignon to pizza, it was all very good. If I came here again, I would still not get the rental car. Outside the walls of the resort, there didn’t appear to be anything nearby. For 6 bucks each round trip, a driver took us to Playa Del Carmen. We looked around a bit, ate lunch, went down to 5th street, where a beautiful ocean view and all the action is, bartered a bit for the local goods and then was picked up at the fixed time periods. Another day, we lined up transportation to Cancun. This was 9 bucks round trip a person. I thought this was a great price. We spent the day in Cancun and were picked up later that day The beach, as others have pointed out, is nice but very rocky for going into the water. If you take a short walk going right facing the water, as you make it around a long white wall ( private property boundary), the beach on the other side is wonderful. Absolutely no rocks. We swam there almost everyday. The water is just beautiful! Other than our day trips to Cancun and Playa, we did do one tour arranged through the resort. This was to Chichen Itza’ . I’m not usually much on the guided touristy stuff, but this tour was over the top. It wasn’t cheap at $110 per person, but after the day was over, I thought it was a great deal. It was about an 11 hour day, starting with a great luxury bus picking us up at the resort, then: a continental breakfast, a great trip to visit the blue cenote, which you could swim in, a wonderful upscale luncheon buffet, including all the cocktails you could down in an hour. Off then to see the impressive temple ruins in Chichen Itza’, from the Mayan civilization. The tour guide and all his information about this Mayan city was awesome. After a long afternoon in the sun, it was cocktails all the way home. Great tour! I would come back here again in a flash. The resort was great. The service outstanding and the waters are beautiful. www.tstoday.com for back issues, message boards, Special Reports and much more TimeSharing Today Page 35 Jan/Feb, 2009 Crackdown on Deceptive Sales Practices Pennsylvania Attorney General Tom Corbett recently filed a lawsuit against Bluegreen Resorts, accusing the company of illegally marketing vacation packages to lure consumers into aggressive and deceptive timeshare presentations. Corbett said more than 5,700 Pennsylvania residents bought Bluegreen timeshares, after the company violated Pennsylvania’s Consumer Protection Law, the Real Estate Licensing and Registration Act, the Telemarketer Registration Act and other consumer regulations. Corbett said that Bluegreen representatives allegedly called consumers who believed they were entering contests promising cars, cash and vacations. According to the lawsuit, consumers were told that they had not won the “grand prize,” but had been selected to receive other items, like free airline tickets. Consumers were also promised free gasoline and meals when they collected their prize, if they attended a 90 minute timeshare presentation. Virtually everyone who entered the contests was falsely told that they were a prize winner. In order to collect their “prizes,” consumers were required to schedule an appointment with a Bluegreen sales representative. In some cases, consumers were actually subjected to relentless marketing pitches that lasted five hours or more. According to the lawsuit, numerous deceptive statements were made to consumers during these presentations in an effort to get them to sign contracts immediately, including phony claims that prices would increase the next day, misrepresentations about when and where consumers could travel if they made a purchase and false statements about certain fees being waived. According to the lawsuit, consumers who sat through the timeshare presentations received “prizes” that were nothing like what they had been promised. The “four free airline tickets” were actually booklets that offered two airline tickets with each hotel room reserved, at high prices, in a limited number of cities. In some situations, consumers were required to commit to a 10 night stay at overpriced hotel rates before being able to select a local airport for their flight. Corbett said “free” gasoline and meals that consumers were promised turned out to be coupons or certificates with lengthy terms and conditions. For instance, consumers who were promised $40 in free gas were required to submit written requests to obtain a series of gas coupons. The coupons required consumers to pay for their gas first and then mail a receipt for reimbursement, with each coupon limited to a $5 purchase, with no more than one purchase per month. Corbett’s said contracts used by Bluegreen failed to properly inform consumers of their right to cancel their purchase. According to the lawsuit, Bluegreen made numerous calls to consumers who were on Pennsylvania’s Do Not Call list. The lawsuits seek restitution for consumers who suffered financial losses. Additionally, Corbett says the lawsuit asks the court to void all illegal consumer contracts and give consumers the right to cancel any agreement that did not include the state-required notice of cancellation. The lawsuit also seeks civil penalties for each violation of the Consumer Protection Law. Bluegreen’s Website states that it has more than 185,000 owners in over 40 resorts. Several months ago, the company had entered into a deal giving Diamond Resorts a right to acquire Bluegreen. The due diligence period was extended to December 15, 2008, but no decision on an acquisition was announced by either Bluegreen or Diamond at press time. Missouri’s Attorney General Jay Nixon had filed a lawsuit against Festiva Resorts several years ago. He alleged that Festiva violated Missouri consumer protection laws by falsely promising prospective timeshare buyers of the Cabins at Green Mountain that Festiva would help buyers sell other timeshares they owned, rent out timeshares they bought from Festiva, get good deals on condo rentals in attractive locations, get good deals on vacation packages. and give refunds to those dissatisfied with their purchase. The Attorney General also alleged that Festiva did not provide consumers with enough time to make decisions, creat- ing a sense of urgency and a high-pressure sales environment. Under an agreement signed June 25, 2008, Festiva will stop using false and misleading sales pitches and will pay a total of $324,393 in restitution to consumers. Consumers who have used their timeshare on at least once have the option of deeding their timeshare back to Festiva and receiving a partial refund, of retaining their timeshare and receiving a small cash payment or of retaining their timeshare and receiving a free status upgrade. Consumers who have never used their timeshare will be refunded a substantial percentage of amounts they paid to Festiva if they agree to deed their timeshare back to the company. Festiva will also pay a civil penalty of $5,000 and $10,000 to the state to pay for the costs of the investigation and enforcement of the case. Festiva is a privately-held company whose Website claims that it has 55,000 owners in 24 resorts. RE/MAX PROPERTIES S.W. Timeshare Resale Division The Smartest and Easiest way to Buy or Sell your Timeshare. Our team has over 30 years of combined Real Estate experience. (800)541-5666 ext 325 (407)352-5800 x 325 Fax (407)393-5788 www.TimeshareResalePros.com www.tstoday.com for back issues, message boards, Special Reports and much more TimeSharing Today Page 36 Day-Tripping near Tucson By Hank Jeffries, San Pedro, CA Here is a picture of me at the entrance to the Arizona-Sonora Desert Museum, located about 15 miles west of downtown Tucson. The picture was taken by my wife, Jill. The WorldMark Tucson Rancho Vistoso, where we stayed on an exchange, was hardly photogenic or even unique enough to waste my time trying to stage a picture. Take a look at RCI’s Web site for its two pictures of the resort; as you can see from them, there’s nothing outstanding there, just the main pool and the extremely uncomfortable cheap furniture! I did submit a Resort Report Card to TSToday of the last week, giving it only so-so marks - no activities (because it’s primarily a “points” resort where people stay sometimes only one night), thin walls and ceilings (two very active toddlers upstairs), and the uncomfortable furniture. During most of the week, the parking areas were less than half-full at night. While we were staying at this resort we did six “day trips” around the Tucson area, including the following: • Tohono Chul Park & Tearoom • De Grazia Gallery of the Sun • Tucson Botanical Garden • Sabino Canyon • Music Under the Stars at Reid Park • Arizona-Sonora Desert Museum (world-class!) • Saguaro National Park West • San Xavier del Bac Mission • ASARCO Mineral Discovery Center (an operating copper mine) • Titan Missile Museum (the only silo left with a missile in it, and it’s publicly accessible) • Tucson Museum of Art • Old Town Artisans • Walking tours of two historic districts in downtown Tucson • El Tiradito Shrine • Arizona Historical Museum • Pima Air & Space Museum contains a B-17, an SR-71, MiG 19, Air Force One, X-15, and several hundred others • • • Military airplane “boneyards”) Colossal Cave Flandreau Science Center & Planetarium (U of AZ campus) • Biosphere 2 As you can see there’s plenty to do in the Tucson area. We drove about 400 miles to do all of the above, primarily because the resort is in Oro Valley, located 15 miles north of downtown Tucson and many of our stops were south of town. We are already working on an itinerary for our next trip back to Southern Arizona Tombstone, Bisbee, Kartchner Cave, Kitt Observatory, etc.. I know, I’m starting to sound like the Chamber of Commerce or the “Southern Arizona Attractions Alliance” who publish a booklet of 2-for-1 admissions to many of the place we visited. People-to-People Diplomacy By David Firsten, Nanuet, NY Attached is a photo of my wife, Marilyn and me taken last August while standing in front of the Budapest Opera House in Budapest, Hungry. After we toured the Opera House, we went to the Budapest Market, which is a huge covered indoor place of many different stalls and vendors selling everything from fresh produce, meat, bakery items, clothing, etc. It is the main shopping point for the locals, as there are very few supermarkets in the city. It was close to closing and we were very tired after a long day touring. Our hotel had supplied us with the phone number of a local radio dispatched cab company. Our problem was this marketplace had no working www.tstoday.com for back issues, message boards, Special Jan/Feb, 2009 pay phones. I went up to several merchants and asked if they would be kind enough to call the car service for us. All refused. My wife spotted a man, well dressed in a suit, and suggested I ask him if he had a mobile phone. I approached him, assuming he had a mobile phone and respectfully asked if he would be willing to call the cab company for us. He said he had a mobile phone and would be willing and asked why we needed him to call. We explained we were tired from touring and needed a cab to get to our hotel. He then asked what hotel and then offered to take us there. We said we did not want to trouble him, but he insisted in taking us. We left the Market and when approaching his car, noticed he had diplomatic plates. I asked him what country he was from and he replied, “Russia.” In shock, I said “you’re not the ambassador?” To which he replied that he was not, but was a diplomat working out of the embassy. He inquired our country of origin and I told him the USA. He said, he had thought so, but wasn’t sure. On the way to our hotel, we discussed our trip many years ago to Moscow. This was such a nice experience and a highlight of our trip to Hungry. Two countries whose governments are at odds with each other, yet the people are warm and friendly to each other. There are many lessons to be learned from this gentlemen who gave of himself. TimeSharing Today Page 37 Jan/Feb 2009 Two Resorts Near Disneyworld By Jason Farlam, Clawson, MI Summer Bay Resort It was close to our departure date when this Gold Crown resort was offered by RCI Points, we weren’t sure what to expect. The Summer Bay Resort is very nice. Set in acres of lush tropical gardens, the resort comprises many low-rise twobedroom units and some larger single house units. There are a large number of large new two-bedroom lock offs in several four-story buildings toward the rear of the large property. All new development is in these new four-story buildings and it looks like they have room for lots more units. We know from talking to people around the pool that the units are different in different sections, so the unit specific comments may only apply to the newer two-bedroom lock offs we stayed in. The resort is mildly Caribbeanthemed, with widespread pineapple images, the symbol of hospitality, carved onto signs and in the architectural highlights. Other Caribbean touches include vast lush gardens and a pool side Tiki bar. A second resort theme is that its Summer All Year at Summer Bay Resort. A somewhat bold claim, but one you could almost play along with if you concentrated on the very tropical looking gardens and immersed yourself in the heated and tropically warm pools. Especially if you were fleeing the frigid cold of the American mid-west. In March of 2008, early morning golfers encountered upper 40’s and 50’s and late afternoons saw upper 60’s, 70’s and even 80’s a few days. Columbus, Ohio had 20 inches of snow the same week, so no one was complaining about the fresh sunny weather. Not as spread out as some really large resorts, it was always a reasonable walk to one of the pools whereever you were staying, but if you weren’t up to it, there was a free resort shuttle that even included the nearby Publix supermarket and liquor store. A large new pool complex was under construction very near our unit. Only 6 miles from Disney, Summer Bay seems farther away, especially since you drive along US192, through about two miles of undeveloped Florida wasteland leaving Orange County, where most resorts are clustered around the attractions area. At the Disney side of Lake County, near the US27 junction, a new cluster of development includes Summer Bay. The resort confronts this mis-perceived distance by providing extensive shuttles to major theme parks and even several outlet and conventional malls. It is the first resort in Central Florida that we could comfortably say you don’t need a car to enjoy the area. Our unit was new and well equipped. The lock off is arranged with 2 private doorways. As you walk in the main unit the complete kitchen has all expected appliances and nice cupboards holding complete dish sets. There are enough pots to cook for a family and an unexpected four microwave dishes. I was comfortably able to make a prime rib roast with all the trimmings. The dining area is next, located between the kitchen and living room, and has a good view of the big screen TV if you are one of those families who like to eat and watch television. Adjacent to the dining and living room is a large well equipped bathroom and a second door to the large bedroom makes it function as an en suite. The living room has a leather couch and love seat to watch TV and enough light to read. The bedroom has a king size bed and a second TV and beyond the living room and bedroom is a large balcony with a view of the tropical gardens. The lock off side includes a smaller kitchen and dining room, intended for four, and a living room, bathroom and bedroom similar to the main side. An in-unit washer and dryer is a really handy amenity. A feature unique to Summer Bay is that check is available all seven days of the week, so you could fly both ways at the much cheaper mid week rates if you wanted. Of course, we went a couple of times to the theme parks which were a little crowded since it was March break. If you haven’t been recently, there are significant changes and park updates, and even www.tstoday.com for back issues, message boards, Resale Value Tracker and much more TimeSharing Today a completely new Sea World attraction called Aquatica, just open. An expansion of the upscale Orlando Premium Outlets is underway with a large new parking deck that they desperately needed and a huge new wing of stores that will be open by Christmas, 2008. Some complained about the lack of restaurants in the immediate area, but we somehow managed the arduous six mile trek to the very fine Kobe Japanese Steakhouse where the chef puts on quite a show as he prepares your meal right at the table. Little kids, teenagers and their parents could brave a similar trip and enjoy the all-you-can-eat pizza, pasta, salad and dessert at Cici’s for just five dollars or so; and no, I don’t know how they can do it. I didn’t do a count, but I bet there are more than 100 other restaurants within 6 to 8 miles. Back at the resort, there is a small man-made sandy beach on the private lake and extensive water sports availability. Kids loved the paddle boats shaped like giant swans. There is an interactive children’s water park, kind of a smaller, warmer Wet and Wild, and the little kids Page 38 Jan/Feb, 2009 we saw were really enjoying it. The main pool and giant 15 person hot tub are open 24 hours and at 11:30 one night, we thought this could be a great opportunity for a nice quiet relaxing experience just before bed. Dozens of friendly, chatty college kids thought this would be a great opportunity to meet and socialize with their peers. We managed to coexist, but left the spring breakers alone the rest of the week. The clubhouse includes a nice fitness center, game room, and business center all available extended hours. Our long time favorite area resort is Florida Vacation Villas, but we have a second favorite now and would recommend Summer Bay Resort for couples, and families with children of all ages, right up through college. Parkway International Resort Many years ago, we met a woman from England who loved Parkway International and we were pleased to visit the resort ourselves in January 2008. Newly renovated rooms and modest, but nice, landscaping have earned a five-star rating from Interval International. In addition to some owners and exchangers, many of the guests when we were there were renting, as the resort operates an extensive on site rental program. It was among the coldest weeks in Florida I can ever remember and while that is clearly not the resort’s fault, some people were complaining. Even on the coldest day, with an unusual frost one night, the pool was still heated and warm enough to swim a few lengths and then enjoy the large hot tub. This part of the resort is older but fully functional, and there are lots of chairs and umbrellas around the pool area. There is a pool side bar and snack bar with average resort prices. Parkway International has a jungle theme that some people find tacky but others find entirely appropriate, especially for children. The resort is crowded into a wedge shaped piece of land right between Disney and the US192 and I4 interchange. We were not bothered by traffic noise, as the units are quiet and even when outside, the semi-natural tropical jungle insulates the area from outside noises. Lots of low-rise older units are located near the pool area. From talking to people, we learned that most, if not all, have been recently redecorated and updated. Newer units are farther away and we really wanted to see them ,so we signed up for the timeshare sales tour. That was a mistake. We were sur- prised to find a really high-pressure boiler room operation that kind of spoiled the whole experience for us. We have been around the timeshare industry long enough to know when stories are being spun and the truth is being stretched and did not appreciate this holdover from the bad old days. Operations like this one give the industry a black eye and are counter productive for the resort anyway, as they generate a large number of buyer’s remorse cancellations (legal after the fact in Florida) that just add to the cost of the operation. In talking to others after escaping the nearly five hour horror, we learned we were not alone and others had been treated even worse. One of the features most highly touted in the sales ordeal was the convenient location. We took advantage and enjoyed a surprisingly fun and relaxing trip to Gatorland, Central Florida’s oldest attraction. If you’ve never been, I would recommend it. Gatorland has the hokey down-home shows and gator wrestling, but also a large quiet animal sanctuary part with extensive raised walkways, where you can view these creatures, and rare Crocodilia from around the world in a naturalistic habitat. The location is also convenient to several outlet malls, a Walgreens drug- www.tstoday.com for back issues, Resort Report Cards, articles on resorts and much more TimeSharing Today store and a large Publix supermarket. With all the attractions nearby, and virtually unlimited restaurants and activities, you really can’t fault the location. There is a smaller children’s play area with a slide and climber. Small patches of gardens are located here and there in the compact grounds. The big landscape feature is the on-site semi natural jungle, and this jungle is the setting for jungle walkways which lead to other resorts. The Vacation Village Nature Walk leads to Vacation Village Resort and some more things to do. Not too far away is the Liki Tiki Water Park. We didn’t go, but others told us its quite a nice attraction, especially for small kids and includes a number of waterslide features. Admission to the water park is free if you’re staying at Parkway. The newer units are nice and reasonably well appointed and finished. You really can’t get a better location for quick highway departures to all the Central Florida attractions from Spring Training to NASA to theme parks. If you go to Parkway International Resort, enjoy the location. Page 39 Jan/Feb, 2009 Want to Save a Few Dollars? By Steve Appelbaum Actually, this is how to save a few dollars and stop local grocery stores from reaping high profits from tourists. If you are a timeshare owner, or are just staying somewhere that has the facility so that you can stock your kitchen or just your refrigerator with some snacks or a for quick bite, you might want to take advantage of this. We were in Palm Springs, California a couple of years back and were really surprised at some of the prices. Cherries, in season and grown just north of California, were going for almost $6 per pound. Many other prices followed suit. At the checkout counter, one of the customers gave me their store card to use and $12 worth of cherries became $5.45. Blueberries for 2 for $4.99 were now charged out at $1.99 for the two. Recently in Harris Teeter, a store in Charleston, SC, I applied for their card upon entering the store by giving my lo- cal hotel address and telephone number. The card was given to me on the spot and was used at the checkout. Our total was $31.50 and with the card, $4.98 was subtracted from the final total; a savings of about 15%. In Vons Grocery Store located in San Juan Capistrano, CA, the savings were even more dramatic. Once again, I completed the information for the card, was given the card and used it at checkout. The total was $51.13. The new total after using Von’s Card, $38.96; a savings of 24%. To me, these just look like cases of “Let’s take advantage of those passing through.” In any economy, a few bucks is a few bucks. Better in your pocket than in theirs. In case you are concerned about using the hotel address, I was informed there is no problem legally. And the bottom line: these stores would rather get you with the discount than not at all. Save thousands by Reducing Your Timeshare Interest Rate by nearly 50% The average timeshare interest rate is 14.1%. However, if you have excellent credit, you can buy or refinance a timeshare in minutes with the AnythingLoan from FirstAgain. Timeshare interest rates start at 7.99%**, which could save you thousands of dollars. Apply today at www.firstagain.com/TSToday * According to the 2006 ARDA PricewaterhouseCoopers benchmark study ** Rates vary by loan purpose, amount and term, and are subject to change without notice. For current rates, visit www.FirstAgain.com ©05/2008 www.tstoday.com for back issues, message boards, Resale Value Tracker and much more