an overview of the assessment and management of
Transcription
an overview of the assessment and management of
J Royal Naval Medical Service 2014, Vol 100.3 244 Eczema and dermatitis in the afloat population: an overview of the assessment and management of the common erythematous skin conditions encountered in adults deployed on afloat platforms Surg Lt Cdr A Lundie, Surg Cdr M Turner Abstract Skin conditions constitute a large proportion of the workload of deployed medical staff. Dermatology is an area where pattern recognition is key, and making a diagnosis can sometimes be difficult for deployed medical staff, who may have limited experience of dermatology. This article provides a structure to assess patients presenting with skin rashes, as well as a summary of the key features and management of common types of dermatitis that may be encountered when deployed afloat: atopic eczema; irritant contact dermatitis; pompholyx; scabies and plaque psoriasis. Introduction Skin conditions constitute a large proportion of the workload of deployed medical staff, with 20% of clinical presentations (n=83) during the author’s (AL) 2012 deployment to the Central Arabian Gulf being classified as dermatological disease (1). Dermatitis is defined as an inflammation of the skin, and although the underlying pathological trigger for the inflammation differs in the different types of dermatitis, all types result in an activation of the skin’s immune pathways resulting in inflammatory infiltration of the epidermis and epidermal spongiosis (intracellular oedema) (2,3). These conditions are often referred to as ‘eczema’, and this can often cause confusion as to whether the term is being used to describe the collective group of inflammatory skin conditions or the specific condition of atopic eczema. Therefore, for the purpose of this article, the term ‘dermatitis’ will be used to describe the collective group of inflammatory skin conditions. Although the underlying pathological trigger may differ (allergen, irritant or infection), the common histopathological features common to the different types of dermatitis result in very similar clinical features, i.e. variants of an erythematous maculopapular rash. This can make establishing an accurate diagnosis difficult. Management of dermatitis is best approached with an understanding of the natural progression of the disease. Figure 1 illustrates how an initial pathological trigger leads to an inflammatory response within the skin (4). Figure 1: The ‘Itch and Scratch Cycle’. A simplified illustration of how dermatitis can be triggered and result in a perpetuating cycle of worsening symptoms. Adapted from National Eczema Association (4). This infiltration of the skin with inflammatory mediators can cause the initial symptoms of inflammation, erythema and pruritis. The pruritis inevitably leads to scratching and excoriation, even in the most astute patients (it can often become an unconscious or even nocturnal habit). Excoriation leads to further skin damage, which in turn triggers further inflammation and the cycle continues. The concept of the ‘Itch and Scratch cycle’ should be communicated to patients early in a management plan. This will make the patient mindful of the fact that excoriation 245 will worsen pruritis and encourage the correct use of treatments (such as emollients) to ease pruritis. Environmental factors can also have a role to play in triggering or worsening pruritis. Humidity or exercise can result in increased perspiration which can trigger ‘prickly heat’ symptoms. Emotional stress can lead to anger, frustration and embarrassment, which causes skin flushing and pruritis (4). Management of dermatitis usually involves targeting one or many of the stages in this cycle. For example, emollients improve the skin’s barrier function and reduce skin damage as well as easing pruritis, whilst topical steroids suppress the release of inflammatory mediators. A management plan that takes a holistic approach and considers the multiple factors that contribute to the disease progression is likely to be more successful than focusing on just one aspect. The aim of this article is to provide a framework for making Clinical focus mainly on the inflammatory causes of dermatitis; readers should consult the article by Tanzer et al in a previous issue of this journal for a review of infective conditions (5). Diagnosis Both MBR and GDMO training focus on clinical history as an important area when formulating a diagnosis; this principle also applies in dermatology. A common pitfall in clinical practice is to focus immediately on the clinical appearance of the rash, at times at the expense of a thorough clinical history. This results in a less structured approach that may in turn lead to inaccurate diagnosis. The SOCRATES mnemonic is commonly used as a structure to follow when assessing a patient presenting with pain (6). It is the author’s opinion that this mnemonic can be easily adapted to structure a dermatological history and ensure both that key aspects of the history are not omitted (6,7), and also that a patient measure of severity is included (Box 1) (8). Site – Consider all the skin and scalp as well as mucous membranes. Is there a specific distribution? Is the rash only in sweaty or sun exposed areas? Is the rash limited to flexural or extensor surfaces? Onset – Is this an acute presentation or an ongoing chronic problem? Have they had rashes like this before? Is this an exacerbation of a pre-existing skin condition? Character – The symptoms experienced by the patient: Does it itch? Is it sore or tender to touch? Does it bleed or is there any discharge? Radiation – The development of the rash. Where did they notice the rash first and how has it spread across the body? Did it initially appear in one or multiple locations? Associated Symptoms – Is the patient well? Do they have a fever, lethargy or malaise? Do they have any pain elsewhere (e.g. in joints) that appeared at the same time as the rash? Do they have any other medical problems or past medical history? Timing – When did the rash appear and what was the patient doing prior to its appearance? Occupational history is important: consider whether the patient is a Marine Engineer who has been working in a hot engine room or a chef who has been regularly hand washing or using cleaning fluids. Did they eat something unusual or come into contact with anything new? Do they ever get this rash when there are at home or on leave? Are they under increased emotional stress? Exacerbating/Relieving Factors – Has the patient noticed that anything makes the rash worse or better, e.g. temperature changes, salt water or sun exposure? Are they known to be allergic or hypersensitive to anything? Have they tried any creams or medications before for this rash? Severity – The patient is asked to score the effect the rash is having both functionally and occupationally. Either score out of 10 or consider using a scoring system such as the Patient Oriented Eczema Measure (8). Box 1: The SOCRATES mnemonic for a dermatological history (Adapted from Kernicki JG (6) & Borton C (7)). an accurate diagnosis, outlining the key features of common dermatitis presentations on a deployed platform, as well as providing some guidance on how a General Duties Medical Officer (GDMO) or Medical Branch Rating (MBR) could approach the management in the deployed context within the limitations of the Medical Equipment Table for Service Afloat (METSA). The METSA governs the pharmaceutical repertoire on an afloat platform, providing a limited range, but adequate supply, of topical preparations to treat commonly encountered skin conditions. This article will Once a history has been taken, the clinician will hopefully have established a list of differential diagnoses that can be explored by clinical examination. First, observe the distribution, symmetry and colour of the rash. Symmetrical rashes tend to suggest endogenous disease (originating from within the body), such as psoriasis or atopic eczema, whereas exogenous rashes, such as tinea, are more likely to be asymmetrical (9). The morphology of the individual lesions should be noted, in particular: colour; shape; elevation; edge (distinct or ill defined); and the presence of J Royal Naval Medical Service 2014, Vol 100.3 any crusting or scale. Excoriation or infection may alter the appearance of the rash. Gently palpate the skin to assess the texture and thickness of the lesions, whether there is any tenderness and whether the colour will blanch with pressure. Gently scratching the skin may cause scale to become more apparent. Significant crusting should be carefully removed to allow for assessment of the skin underneath (9). Describing the lesion using the nomenclature defined in Box 2 may help with consolidation of examination findings and facilitate record keeping or discussion of findings with a senior colleague (9,10). Macule – Flat circumscribed area of change in skin colour (not raised) less than 1.5cm in diameter. Patch – As above but >1.5cm in diameter. Papule – small circumscribed elevation of the skin (<5mm diameter). Plaque – flat topped palpable lesion (a gathering of papules >5mm diameter) or an area of skin thickening. Nodule – Solid circumscribed elevation of the skin whose greater part is beneath the skin surface (more felt than seen). Vesicle – collection of clear fluid (diameter < 5mm). Bulla – collection of clear fluid (diameter > 5mm. Pustule – collection of pus Box 2: Terminology for use when describing skin lesions (9,10). Atopic eczema 80 % of cases of atopic eczema first present under the age of five years and, therefore, it is unlikely that the first presentation of this condition will occur on a deployed platform (11). Thorough exploration of past medical history is imperative before making this diagnosis (Box 3). The specific pathological trigger for atopic eczema is not The rash must be itchy and fulfill at least 3 of the following criteria: • History of itchiness in the skin creases (bends of the elbows or behind the knees) • Visible eczema in the skin creases (flexural eczema) • History of asthma or hay fever • Initial onset under the age of 2 years • A tendency towards dry skin If these criteria are not fulfilled other differential diagnoses should be considered. Box 3: The diagnostic criteria for atopic eczema (11). fully understood. However, it is thought to have genetic influences leading to immune dysfunction, combined with environmental influences. Eczema has shown degrees of concordance in twin studies and eczema and other atopic disorders (e.g. asthma and hay fever) have shown clustering 246 in families. Current theories regarding the genetics and immune mechanisms behind atopic eczema are summarized at the reference (12). Figure 2 demonstrates the classical flexural distribution of atopic eczema. Figure 2: Atopic eczema on flexural aspect of the arm. (DermNetNZ). Guidance for initial management is to avoid any obvious environmental precipitants, irritants to the skin, or substances that compromise the skin’s barrier properties. Low humidity, central heating and air-conditioning can dry the skin, affecting its barrier function and causing pruritis. Heat and high humidity can increase perspiration and pruritis. Coarse clothing or washing powders used to launder clothes can irritate the skin of some individuals. Avoidance of the climate, air conditioning or the washing powder used on clothing can be difficult on a deployed platform (although some platforms may have the facility to launder clothes separately using personal washing powder). The second line intervention is to maintain the barrier function of the skin by regular use of emollients and by avoiding shampoos and shower gels that dry and irritate the skin. One of the irritants found in many soaps, shampoos and shower gels is Sodium Lauryl Sulphate (SLS), which is also contained in Aqueous Cream. Use of products containing SLS (including Aqueous Cream) should be avoided in all patients suffering from dry skin conditions (13). SLS-free emollients can also be used Quantities of emollients recommended for generalised eczema 600g / week for an adult 250 - 500g / week for a child Suitable weekly quantities of emollients for specific areas of the body Scalp 100g Face 30g Both hands 50g Trunk 400g Both arms or legs 200g Groins & genitalia 25g Box 4: Emollient prescription quantity guide (11). 247 for washing in the place of shower gels (E45® Cream or Dermol® 500). The ideal frequency for application of emollients is every four hours, or at least three times a day; under-use of emollients is the usual reason for eczema not remaining under control (11). Patients should, therefore, be encouraged to integrate a skin care regimen into their daily routine. The quantity guide found in Box 4 will facilitate in the prescription of sufficient emollients and may assist the clinician in monitoring compliance. Emollients will also help ease pruritis, but if they are not sufficient an antihistamine could be considered (e.g. Loratadine or Chlorphenamine). Care should be taken when prescribing sedating antihistamines (e.g. Chlorphenamine) if the patient is likely to be operating heavy machinery or watch-keeping. Prescribing a sedating antihistamine to take at night can reduce this risk, but always consider the operational tempo and the roles that the individual will fulfill at both action and emergency stations. If regular emollient use is not sufficient, topical steroids can be used in short courses to manage an acute exacerbation of the condition. Most platforms carry a mild potency steroid cream (hydrocortisone 1%) and a potent steroid cream (betamethasone valerate 0.1%) or ointment. In most cases the mild potency agent should be sufficient, used sparingly once or twice daily until the eczema has resolved. In more severe cases a potent steroid cream may be required, but this should usually be limited to a three- to five-day course, and sensitive areas, such as the face, should be avoided (14). Book of Reference (BR) 1991 contains useful advice on emollients and steroids that can be provided to patients (15). As previously discussed, it is important to take a holistic approach to management of dermatitis and therefore incorporate strategies to manage scratching and excoriation into the management plan. Encourage the patient to become actively aware of scratching and try to break the cycle. Keeping occupied with structured daily activity, keeping fingernails cut short, moisturising instead of scratching and, if unable to resist scratching, using the back of the nails to limit excoriation will all help. Increased emotional stress can also precipitate scratching. It is therefore important for the clinician to explore this with the patient and facilitate the development of coping strategies (4). Irritant contact dermatitis Presenting in a similar fashion to atopic eczema, irritant contact dermatitis is caused by single or repeated exposures to a substance that irritates the skin. At a basic level water can be an irritant if the exposure is repetitive, and this type of dermatitis is often seen in chefs or healthcare workers who wash their hands on a regular basis or immerse their hands in water for long periods of time (16). Irritants range from mild, where repeated exposure causes symptoms, to more severe irritants, where a single exposure may be sufficient to cause symptoms. The management of severe Clinical irritants on afloat platforms will be governed by Control of Substances Hazardous to Health (COSHH) regulations; personal protective equipment (PPE) should be worn to prevent skin contact (16). It is, therefore, more likely that it will be prolonged exposure to milder irritants that will cause symptoms for deployed personnel. Initially the skin will become dry, followed by mild pruritis, soreness, erythema and cracking of the skin, as demonstrated in Figure 3. Figure 3: Irritant contact dermatitis (DermNetNZ). Unfortunately, from these initial stages the skin’s natural barrier is broken down, making it more susceptible to the irritant and causing a vicious cycle of increasing damage (17). Optimum treatment is preventing exposure to the irritant. However, if the irritant is water or soaps, this can be challenging. The clinician should advise patients to ensure that hands are well rinsed of soap residue after washing and thoroughly dried, paying special attention to the web spaces between the fingers. SLS-free emollients (E45® Cream or Dermol® 500) can also be used instead of soaps for hand washing. Emollients used regularly will create a protective barrier and preserve the integrity of the skin (17). Rubber or Nitrile gloves could also be worn when washing up, working in the galley or cleaning. However, prolonged wear may also irritate the skin further. Cotton gloves worn underneath may help to mitigate this. If the dermatitis becomes severe the individual may benefit from modification of their duties to allow the skin to heal. A short course of a steroid cream can also be used to suppress some of the inflammation and improve symptoms, but should be used with caution if there is evidence of cracking of the skin, as suppression of the immune response may delay wound healing (18). Pompholyx Also known as dyshydrotic dermatitis or dyshydrotic eczema, pompholyx is characterized by an itchy vesicular reaction on the hands, fingers and soles of the feet. Its aetiology is unknown, and although it is thought to be J Royal Naval Medical Service 2014, Vol 100.3 associated with excessive sweating, there is no histological evidence to support this. Despite this, 40% of patients with pompholyx also suffer from hyperhidrosis (excessive sweating), and the condition is more common in the spring and summer and in warmer climates. It can be acute, chronic or recurrent, and affects the hands in 80% of cases. It classically presents symmetrically with symptoms of itching and burning on the hands, feet or both, followed after several hours by an eruption of tiny vesicles initially on the lateral aspect of fingers, as shown in Figure 4, then on palms and soles (19). 248 valerate 0.1%) can control itching in the vesicular phase when the blisters are developing, but after the vesicles have dried emollients may be useful to prevent the skin from cracking. Large blisters can be drained aseptically (19). Scabies Scabies can be common on ships and submarines owing to close living conditions. The condition is caused by a parasitic infestation with Sarcoptes scabiei mites, which burrow under the skin to lay eggs. Burrows are usually Figure 4: Pompholyx vesicles on the hands and feet (DermNetNZ). Later in the disease progression, the vesicles will burst, occasionally with some development of scale and lichenification. Pompholyx usually requires no active treatment and will usually resolve spontaneously after three to four weeks. However, if the itching is severe, treatment may be requested. Potent steroid cream (betamethasone Figure 6: Pustular erythema on the hand as a result of scabies (DermNetNZ). located on the wrists or between the finger webbing, and appear as fine, dark or silvery lines 4-10mm long, as shown in Figure 5. Figure 5: A classic burrow in scabies (DermNetNZ). Around two to four weeks after infestation, a blotchy red rash (Figure 6) and widespread itching can occur (sooner 249 Clinical if the patient has had scabies before). This is owing to an allergic reaction to the mites’ saliva, faeces or eggs. Because of the delay in development of the rash, a patient can be contagious for some time before they present with symptoms. Therefore, if one person is diagnosed as having scabies, all close contacts (i.e. the whole mess deck) should be treated. Treatment is with an insecticide (usually Permethrin cream), while simultaneously washing all clothes, towels and bedding at a temperature of >50 degrees C. If washing facilities are limited an alternative is to seal clothing and bedding in plastic bags for at least 72 hours to allow the mites to die. The itch can be severe so the clinician may wish to consider providing patients with other treatment, such as Crotamiton 10% cream (Eurax), Hydrocortisone 1% cream or antihistamine tablets to provide symptomatic relief (20). well demarcated, red/pink lesions (plaques) with overlying white scale that can be accentuated by gentle scraping (21). Plaque psoriasis Like eczema, psoriasis is an endogenous condition that incorporates both a strong genetic basis (30% have a family history), along with environmental triggers. However, unlike eczema, it has an established T-cell mediated autoimmune aetiology, and is uncommon in children, usually first presenting before the age of 35. The commonest form of psoriasis is plaque psoriasis which accounts for 90% of psoriasis presentations. Other forms of psoriasis will not be covered in this article. Sunlight usually reduces the severity of psoriasis, with symptoms worsening in the winter and improving in summer; however, in a small minority, strong sunlight and sunburn can exacerbate Nail changes are often seen as pitting and onycholysis (separation of the nail from the nail bed) or yellow-red discoloration of the nail bed (the ‘oil drop’ sign) (Figure 8). The Psoriasis Area and Severity index (PASI) can be used to score the severity of the psoriasis (22). If the psoriasis as severe (>10% skin involvement), or if there is any evidence of systemic involvement, such as fever or malaise, urgent input should be sought from a base port general practitioner (GP). Treatment is similar to that of atopic eczema, and emollients should be used regularly to reduce itch and scale and preserve skin integrity. In addition to this, potent steroid creams (beclomethasone valerate 0.1%) and Vitamin D analogues (calcipotriol cream) can be applied once daily (one in the morning, one in the evening) for up to two weeks as initial treatment. Calcipotriol cream can be continued as long term therapy provided that local irritation does not occur. As with atopic eczema, ensure that a holistic approach is taken by addressing triggers and breaking the itch and scratch cycle. If patients fail to respond to treatment, advice from base port GPs or secondary care should be sought (21). Figure 7: Plaque psoriasis affecting the extensor surface of the arm (DermNetNZ). symptoms. Psychological stress may also play a role as in triggering the condition, as can smoking and alcohol. There are several drug triggers, with non steroidal antiinflammatories (NSAIDS), antimalarials and antibiotics (Doxycycline and Penicillin) being the main ones of most relevance to the afloat population. Finally, trauma and infection to the skin can cause the development and spread of psoriasis. As demonstrated in Figure 7, patients will typically present with symmetrical, occasionally itchy, Figure 8: Pitting and onycholysis when psoriasis affects the nails (DermNetNZ). Secondary infection Whenever the surface integrity of the skin is broken down by dermatitis an important immune barrier is breached. Therefore, there is a chance that opportunistic infections can develop. Bacteria can develop on the surface of the skin causing golden crusting, sometimes with vesicles and pustules, or can spread below the skin surface and cause cellulitis. When assessing all the skin conditions listed above, the clinician should consider whether there are any signs of secondary infection (the skin feeling hot to touch, looking exceptionally red and angry, or being tender to palpate). This is of particular importance when considering the use of steroid creams, which can worsen any infections that are present. This is particularly relevant in tinea infections (a common differential diagnosis to J Royal Naval Medical Service 2014, Vol 100.3 consider when assessing dermatitis), which are discussed in detail, along with other infective skin conditions, in an article recently published in this journal (5). Special occupational considerations When prescribing any medication it is important to consider the specific occupation of the individual concerned. Fortunately dermatological preparations are typically free of significant side effects and their use will not usually restrict personnel from their duties. Paraffin-based treatments (e.g. white soft paraffin and some ointments) are flammable and when in contact with clothing or dressings are easily ignited by a naked flame. The risk will be greater when these preparations are applied to large areas of the body (23). Clinicians should be mindful of this when prescribing these products to personnel in fire-fighting roles or those who might come into contact with naked flames (e.g. chefs). Divers should be made aware that dry suit seals perish quickly if emollients and oils (including most sun creams and insect repellents) are applied to them. Care should be 250 taken to ensure that dry suit seals are thoroughly cleaned after use to minimize damage (24). When prescribing for aircrew, Air Publication (AP) 1269 should be consulted. Of specific relevance to this article, the only approved antihistamine for aircrew use is Loratadine (25). Conclusion This article provides a basis for the assessment and management of the common forms of dermatitis encountered on board afloat platforms. Although written with the deployed Royal Navy clinician in mind, many of the concepts also apply to general practice as a whole. Deployed medical staff may have limited experience of dermatology, but it is hoped that this article may inspire confidence in making an accurate diagnosis and commencing treatment. In cases that are not so clear, the structure provided for history and examination should provide the information required to allow a base port medical practitioner to assist remotely. References 1. Unpublished data held by the author. Available on request. 2. Saint-Mezard P et al. Allergic contact dermatitis. Eur J Dermatol 2004;14:284-95. 3. DermNetNZ. Eczema Pathology. http://dermnetnz.org/pathology/eczema-path.html [Accessed May 2014]. 4. National Eczema Association. Eczema. http://www.nationaleczema.org/eczema [Accessed May 2014]. 5. Tanzer J, Macdonald A, Schofield S. Infective skin conditions in an adult sea-going population. J Roy Nav Med Serv 2014;100(1); 47-55. 6. Kernicki JG. Differentiating chest pain - advanced assessment techniques. Dimensions of Critical Care Nursing 1993;12(2):66-76. 7. Borton C, Thomas H. Dermatology History and Examination. http://www.patient.co.uk/doctor/dermatological-history-and examination [Accessed May 2014]. 8. Charman C, Venn A, Williams HC. The Patient-Oriented Eczema Measure: development and initial validation of a new tool for measuring atopic eczema severity from the patients’ perspective. Arch Dermatol 2004;140:1513-1519. 9. Primary Care Dermatology Society. Dermatology – The Basics. http://www.pcds.org.uk/p/skin-disease-examination [Accessed May 2014]. 10.DermNetNZ. Terminology in Dermatology. http://dermnetnz.org/terminology.html [Accessed May 2014]. 11. Primary Care Dermatology Society and British Association of Dermatologists. Guidelines for the Management of Atopic Eczema. 2006 (Updated October 2009). 12.Brown S, Reynolds N. Clinical review article: atopic and non atopic eczema and its management. BMJ 2006;332:584-88. 13.Moncrieff G, Cork M, Lawson S, et al. Use of emollients in dry-skin conditions: consensus statement. Clinical and Experimental Dermatology 2013;38:231-8. 14.National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence. TA81 - Frequency of application of topical steroids for atopic eczema. London; 2004. 15.The Ministry of Defence. Royal Navy Book of Reference 1991 2014; Ch 28 Annex 22K. 16.Health and Safety Executive. http://www.hse.gov.uk [Accessed May 2014]. 17.National Institute of Health and Clinical Excellence. Clinical Knowledge Summaries. ‘Dermatitis – Contact’. http://cks.nice.org.uk dermatitis-contact [Accessed May 2014]. 18.Joint Formulary Committee. British National Formulary (BNF) 67. BMJ Publishing Group Ltd and Royal Pharmaceutical Society; March 2014. 19.Draper R, Knott L. Pompholyx. http://www.patient.co.uk/doctor/pompholyx-pro [Accessed May 2014]. 20.Tidy C, Huins H. Scabies. http://www.patient.co.uk/doctor/scabies-pro [Accessed May 2014]. 21.Thomas H, Tidy C. Chronic Plaque Psoriasis. http://www.patient.co.uk/doctor/chronic-plaque-psoriasis [Accessed May 2014]. 22.DermNetNZ. PASI Score. http://dermnetnz.org/scaly/pasi.html [Accessed May 2014]. 23.MRHA. Paraffin-based treatments: Risk of fire hazard. Drug Safety Update Jan 2008;1(6):10. 24.LOMO Watersport. Drysuit Care. http://www.ewetsuits.com/Guides/Drysuit-Care.html [Accessed November 2014] 25.The Ministry of Defence. Royal Air Force Manual – Assessment of Medical Fitness AP 1296A 3rd ed. 1998. 251 Acknowledgements The authors are grateful to DermNetNZ.org for permission to reproduce the images used in this article. Authors Surgeon Lieutenant Commander AJ Lundie MB BS RN General Practice Specialty Training Registrar [email protected] Surgeon Commander MJ Turner MB BS, MRCS, MRCGP, Dip Derm, Dip Occ Med, Dip Av Med RN General Practitioner Department of Community Psychiatry RAF Brize Norton, Carterton, Oxfordshire Clinical