Mendel`s Law of Heredity
Transcription
Mendel`s Law of Heredity
Mendel's Law of Heredity Author(s): W. E. Castle Source: Science, New Series, Vol. 18, No. 456 (Sep. 25, 1903), pp. 396-406 Published by: American Association for the Advancement of Science Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/1630044 . Accessed: 26/11/2013 11:27 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp . JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. . American Association for the Advancement of Science is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Science. http://www.jstor.org This content downloaded from 130.225.209.174 on Tue, 26 Nov 2013 11:27:55 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 396 SCIENGZD. the giving up of the idea of relying upon private effort. That we lose most where the State does least is known to Mr. Chamberlain,for in his speeeh, to whiGhI have referred,on the University of Birmingham,he said: "As the importaneeof tsheaim we are pursuing betomesmore and moreimpressedupon the z>ninds of the people, we may find that we sha]l be more generously treated by the State." IJaterstill, on the oteasion of a visit to University College Sehool, Mr. Chamberlain spoke as follows: "When we are spending,as we are, many mi]lions I think it is 13,000,0001. a year on primary edutation, it tertainly see-lasas i-f we might add a little more, even a few tens of thousands,to what we give to University and setondary edutation" ( Ttrres, November6>1902). To eompeteon equal grounds with other nations we must have more universities. But this is not all we want a far better endowmbntof all the existing ones, not forgetting better opportunitiesfor researehon the part of both professors and students. Another erying need is that of more pro:Xessors and better pay. Another is the reduetion of fees; they should be redueed to the level in those eountrieswhith are eompeting with us, to say, one-fifth of their present rates, so as to enablemore students in the setondary and teehnieal sehools to Gompletetheir edueation. In all these ways, faeilities would be afforded for providing the highest instruetion to a mueh greater numberof students. At present there are almost as many professors and tnstructors in t-heuniversities and eolleges of the United States as there are day students in the universitiesand eollegeswofthe United Kingdom. Men of seienee, our leaders of industry, and the ehiefs of our politieal parties all agree that our present want of higher edu- LN S. VOL. XVIII. No. 4*56. eation in other words, properly equipped universities-is heavily handiGappingus in the present raGefor tommereialsuprematy, beeause it provides a relatively inferior brain-powerwhiGhis leading to a relatively redueed national intome. The faets show that in this eountry we ean not depend upon private effort to put matters right. How about loGaleffort? Anyonewho studies the statisties of modern muniGipalitieswill see that it is impossible for them to raise rates for the building and upkeep of universities. The buildings of the most modern university in Germany have Gost a million. DIfor upkeep the yearly sums found, ehiefly by the State, for German universities of different grades, taking the intomes of seven out of the twenty-two universities as examples,are: 1st Class............ 2nd Class........... , 130,000 Berlin f Bonn )< Gottingen 3rd Class............ f Konigsbelg 4th Class........... f i Strassburg Heidelberg Marburg A J t J t J 56,000 48,000 37,000 Thus if Ijeeds, whieh is to have a university, is eontene with the 4th elass German standard, a rate must be levied of 7d. in the pound for yearly expenses,independent of all buildings. But the faets are that our towns are already at the breaking strain. During the last £ty years, in spite of enormous inereases in rateable values, the rates have gone up from about 2s. to about 7s. in the pound for real local purposes. But no university ean he a merely loeal institution. NORMAN I2OCKYER. ( To be concl?bded.) MlSNDlSL'S LAW 0F HEREDITY.t- WHATwill doubtless rank as one of the great diseoveries in biology, and in the *tThis paper was originally published in part in tile Proceedings of the Anterican Academy of Arts aznd Sciencesa Vol. 38, No. 18, pp. 535-548, January, 1903. This content downloaded from 130.225.209.174 on Tue, 26 Nov 2013 11:27:55 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 25, 1903.] SEPTEMBER SGIENCE. study of heredity perhaps the greatest,was made by GregorMendel,an Austrian monk, in the garden of his cloister, some forty years ago. The diseovery was announeed in the proeeedings of a fairly well-known seientifie soeiety, but seems to have attraeted little attention and to have been soon forgotten. The Darwinian theory then oeeupied the eenter of the seientifie stage and Mendel's brilliant diseovery was all but unnotieed for a third of a century. Meanwhilethe diseussionarousedby Weismann's-germ-plasmtheory, in particular the idea'of the non-inheritaneeof aequired eharaeters, had- put the; seientifie public into a more receptive frame of mind. Mendel's law was rediscoveredindependently by three different botanists engaged in the study of plant-hybrids-de Vries, C'orrens and Tschermak-in the yeSar1900. It- remained, however, for a zoologist,Bateson, txvoyears later, to point out the full importanceand the wide applicability of the law. Since then the Mendelian diseoverieshave attracted the'attentionzof biologists generally. Accordinglya brief statement of'their underlying principles maaynot be without interest to others also.' 7 ' 1. T}ie Law of Domina?ce. When . . . .. mating oceurs between two animals or tplantsdiffering in some character,the off'springfrequently all exhibit the character of one parent only, in which case that character is said to be 'dominant.' Thus, when white mice are crossed--w-ith gray mice, all the offspring are gray, that color characterbeing dominant. The character which is not seen 'in- the immediate ofEspring is called;recesstre,' for though unseen it is still present in the young, as we shall see. White, in the instance given, is the recessive tharacter. The principle of heredityjust stated may be called the law -ofdomtnance. The first instance of it dis:coxrered hy Mendel related to the Gotyle.. . . . . 397 d.on-color. in peas obtainedby crossing different garden varieties. Yellow color of eotyledons was found to be dominant over green; likewise, round smoothform of seed was found to be dominant over angular wrinkled form; and violet eolor of blossoms, over white eolor. Other illustrations might be mentioned both among animals and amongplants, but these will suffice. 2. Peculiar Z[ybqxdFornts.-The law of dominangeeis not of universal applieability; Mendel does not so deelare, though some of his erities have thus interpreted him. In many eases the eross-br.edoSspring possess a eharacter intermediate betweenthose of the parents. This Mendel found to be true when varieties of peas differing in height were crossed. Ag.ainJthe cross-bredsmay possess what appearsto be aqttntensficatton of the character of one parent, as when in crossing dwarf with tall peas the hybrid plant is taller than etther nparent,or as when,. in cressing a brown-seeded.with a whiteseeded variety of bean, the ofEspringbear beans.of a darker brown than those of the brown-seededparent. . ... .. Thirdly, the cross-bredmay have a characte.rentirely different from that of either p.arent. Thus a cross between spotted, black-and-white mice, and albino -miee, prod.u.e.es commonl.ymice entirely.gray in color, like the house-mouse. ..Again in crossing beans, a var.ietyhaving yellowishb.romrnseeds crossed with a white-seeded variety yields sometimes black-mottled seed,. a char.acter possessed by neither parent. These three conditions may be grouped together by saying-the hybrid often possesses a characterof tts own, instead of the pure tharacter of one par.ent,as is true in cases of complete dominance. The hybrid ch.aractermay approximate that of one parent or the other, or it may be different from both.- There is no way of predieting This content downloaded from 130.225.209.174 on Tue, 26 Nov 2013 11:27:55 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 398 [N. S. SCIENCE. vOL. XVIII. No. 456. what the hybrid cha-racterin a-gi-ven-cross are..possible,sinee each parent will £urnis.h will be. It can be determinedonly by e'x- AsSa.ndB.s in equal numbers. The possible are AA, AB and.BB. Theperiment,but it is. always the same £or the co.mbinat.ions 'same cross, providedthe parents are pure. first.sort will.'consist of pure As and will 'Often the hybrid fornl resembles aNsup- breed true to that character ever aft.er-S; posed ancestral condition, in which case ;ward, unless crossed with individuals it is eommonlyd'esignateda reversion. -I1- having a d:ifferent-charaeter...Similarly, lustrationsare the gray hybrid mice,which- the. third-sort will consist of pure Bs. and; are indistinguishablein appearane-et from will breed.true to that character.; But the the'house-mouse,and slate-coloredpigeons second sort, AB, will consist of hybrid inresulting from crossing'white- w-ith buff dividuals, like those of 'which the first hyplxgeons. ,r r brid generation was excIusively compo'sed. 3. Pnty of the Germ-cells.-The great- I.f, as supposed, germ-cells,'A and B, are discovery of Mendel is this: The hybrtd7 produced in equal numbersby hybrids of whatever its own character,produces rtpe both seses, and unite at randomin fertiligerm-cellswhich bear only the pure char- zation, combinations AA, AB and B13 ' acter of orte parent or the other. Thus, should) occur "in the frequencies, 1: 2:1. when one parent has the characteraA,an'd Florin un.ionsbetween.t.wosets-of gametes, the other the character.B, the'jhybridwill each A+B, there is one chance each:for have the characterAB, or in cases of simple the combinations AA and BB, but two 'dominance,A(B')* or B(A). But-what- chances for the combinationAB. . ever the character"ofthe hybrid may be, If the three forms AA (.or;simply A), its germ-cells, when- mature, will bear AB and'B are all different in appearance, either the characterA or the characterB, i.t will be a very simple matter.in an exbut not both,;and As and Bs will be'pro- periment to count those of each class and dueed in eqxal nurnbers. This perfectlfir determinewhether they occur in the theosimple principle is known as the law of *reticaIproportions,1: 2: 1. One such case 'segregatton,',or the law of the 'purity of has been observedby Bateson ( :02, p. 183) the germ-cells.' It bids £air to prove as among Chinese primroses (Pqxmxlastnenfundamental to a right understanding of sts). An unfixabl.ehybrid variety known the facts of heredity as is tlie law of defi- as ' giant lavender,' bearing flowers of a nite proportions in chemistry. F'rom it lavender color, was produced by crossin¢ 'ollow many important consequences. TABLE I. - A first consequenceof the law of purity of the germ-eells is polymorphismof the Characters, ,",^, > AB. second and later hybrid generations. The Magenta LavWhite. vlantsbearingFlowersin Color Red. ender. individuals of the first'hybrid'generation are all of one type, provided the parent 1901, Lot 1.............. 14 27 1901, Lot 2.............. 9 9 0 individuals were pure. Each has a char- 1902, Lot 1.............. 12 23 acter resulting from the combination of 1902, Lot 2 .... .. .. ...... 11 14 26 an A with a B, let us say AB. [In cases 45 Totals ................. 54 96 22 Per cent. of whole..... 29 49+ of clominanceit would moreproperlybe expressed by A (B) or B (A)-.] But in the next generationthree sorts of combinations a. m.agenta red with a white flowering variety tinge.dfaintly with pink.. By seed 4t The parenthesis is used to indicate a recesthe hybrid constantly . produces plants sive character not visible in the individual. * . . . . . . . . . B. A. 19 S This content downloaded from 130.225.209.174 on Tue, 26 Nov 2013 11:27:55 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 11 Y G L 1G 1Y G 1G Y x' ... GY G lW1G .. GW SCIENCE. SEPTEMBER 25, 1903.] 399 preceding generation. These are precisely the theoretical proportions, A 4- 2 A(B) + B. In the case of mice, it has been shown independently by Cuenot ( :02) and by the writer's pupil, Mr. G. M. Allen, that the second hybrid generation, obtained by crossing gray with white mice, consists of gray mice and white miee approsimately in the ratio 3: 1. ( See Table III. ) The white are pure recessives, producing orlly TABLE II. white oftspring,when bred tnter se. What HEREDITYOF COTYIEDON COLOR AMONGC:ROSS-BREDportion of the gravs are pure dominants PEAS. \ has llot yet been determinedwith precision, but we may confidentlyexpect that it will Parents OfSpring. cro9sed Gen. I. Gen. II. -Gen. 1II. Gen.IV. prove to be not far from 1 in 3. bearing magenta red and white flowers respectively as well as other plants bearing lavender flowers. The numerical proportions observedin two successiveseasons are shown in Table I. The observednumbers, it will be seen, are quite close to the theoretical 1: 2: 1. In cases wherein the hybrid is indistinguishablefrom one of the parent for-ms, i. e., in cases of complete dominance of TABLE III. F Y(G) {2Y(G){ 342Y(G) HEREDITYOF (:eAT-COI.OR AMONGCROSSBREDMICE OnTAINFDBY MATINGWHITE MICE ( W ) WITH GRAY MICE ( G ) . l one parental character, only two categories of of}'spring will be recognizable and these will be numericallyas 3: 1. But further breeding will allow the separation of the larger group into two subordinate classes-first individuals bearing only the domirlant character; secondly, hybrids; that iS7 into groups A and A(B), which will be rlumericallyas 1: 2. Observed results are in this case also very close to theory. Mendel, by crossing yellow with green peas, obtained, as we have seen, only yellow (hybrid) seed. Plants raised from this seed bore in the same pods both yel]ow seed bnd green seed in the ratio 3: 1. (See Table II.) Under self-fertilization, the green seed produced in later generations green seed only. It bore only the recessive character. Of the yellow seeds, one in three produced on]y yellow oWspring,. e., contained only the clominantcharacter; but two out of three proved to be hybrid, producing both green and yellow seed, as did the hybrids of the Parents Crossed. l Offspring. Gen. II. Gen. I. 3{ ¢en. III. 1W 3 { 2G(W) GJ A further test of the correctness of gendel's hypothesis of the purity of the germ-cellsand of their productionin equal numbers, is afforded by back-crossingof a hybrid with one of the parental forms. For example, take a case of simple dominance7 as of cotyledon-color in peas or coat-color in mice. We have here characters D (dominant) and R (recessive). The first generation hybrids will all be D (R) . Any orle of them back-erossed with the recessiveparent will producefifty per eent. of pure recessive offspring and fift-yper cent. of hybrids. D+ R For the hybrid produces germ-cells The recessive parent producesgermR+ R cells ......................... 2D(R) + 2R The possible combina,tionsa,re.... This content downloaded from 130.225.209.174 on Tue, 26 Nov 2013 11:27:55 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 400 SCIENCE. [N. S. VOL.XVIII. NO.456. This ease has been testedffor peas and Goatpresents a eurious rough appearance, for miee and found to be substantially as for the reason that the hair stands out stiffly from the body in a number of 'eowstated. V9'ehave thus far eonsideredonly eases lieks' or rosettes. In erossesthe Abyssinian of eross-breedingbetween parents differ- or rough eoat regularly dominates over ing in a single eharaeter. We have seen the norrnal or smooth eoat. Now let us that in sueh eases, no new forms exeept eonsider what happens when a eross is the unstable hybrid form, are produeed. made involving both these pairs of Men:13utwhen the parent forms erossed differ delian eharaeters, albinism vs. pigmented in two or more eharaetersnthere will be eoat, and smooth vs. rough eoat. If a produeed in the seeond and later hybrid white Abyssinian is bred to a pigmented generations individuals possessing new smooth guinea-pig, the young are without of the eharaeters found in exeeption pigtnented and rough, these counbtqtattons all posstble cornbtna- being the domtnant members of thevtwo indeed, the parents; ttons of those eharaeters will be formed, pairs of eharaeters. But the young of and in the proportions demanded by eourse eontain in a latent condition the ehanee. Thus when parents are erossed two reeessive eharaeters, white eoat and whieh differ in two respeets, A and B, smooth eoat, whieh faet may be indicated let us designate the dominant phase o:f by designating them as already suggested, these eharaeters by A, B, the reeessive AB(ab) [A3 a referring to the rough or phase by a, b. The immediate oftfspring smooth eharaeter of the eoat and B, b to resulting from the eross will all be alike, its eolor]. AB(ab),4; but the seeond and later generaThese primary hybrids, if bred tnter SG, tions of hybrids will eontairlthe stable, . of four different sorts, e., pure elasses, AB, Ab, aB, ab, in addi- will produee young rough pigmented, routgh white, tion to other (unstable or still hybrid) viz., pigmented and smooth white. A smooth forms, namely, A13(ab), AB(b), A(a)B, number of the animals of eaeh A(a)b and aB(b). In every sixteen eertain breed true, . e., will produeeonly will sort seeond-generatio:noffspring there will be, sort when mated to animals like own their on the average, one representing eaeh of Theoreticallythere should be themselves. the stable eombinations. Two of the stable pure individual of eaeh of the four one eombinations wi]:l be identieal with the sorts in a total of sixteen young. The parent forms,.the other two will be new. pure individuals answerto the elasses The remaining twelve individuals will be four Ab, aB, ab already rnentioned. AB, hybrid in one or both eharaeters. >)esidesthese pure individuals,there But, An illustration may help to make this in three of the four elasses oeeur will ease elear. Among domestieated guineaindividuals, whieh will hybrid or tmpxre pigs, as among miee and rabbits, albinism their young the domiof some to transmit is recessivewbthrespeet to pigmentedeoat. whieh they eharaeters or eharaeter nant Further, there oceur amongguinea-pigsinto others of their but possess, themselves dividuals known as 'Abyssinians,' whose young the eorresponding reeessiareehar* This is Mendel's use of lower-case letters to aeter or charaeters. Only the class of I have designate recessive characters, with +^7hich smooth white animals ( of which there combinedthe use of a parenthesis when a character by nature recessive is not visible in the indi- should be one in sixteen young) eontains none but. pure individuals, for they bear vidual. This content downloaded from 130.225.209.174 on Tue, 26 Nov 2013 11:27:55 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions SEPTEMBER 25, 1903. ] SCIENCE. the two reeessive eharaeters (ab), and so eoneealno hidden reeessives. Thewr may at onee be set aside as pure. But in the other three elasses nothing but aetual breeding tests will serve to show whieh individuals >arepure and whieh impure or hybrid. To eaeh pure inclividualpossessing one dominant and one reeessive eharaeter there will be two others, exactly like tt tn appearance, but hybrid in one pair of eharaeters. This statement applies to the two elasses, rough-white and smooth-pigmented, in whieh the impure individuals would be designated A(a)b and aB(b) respeetively. Sueh impure animals bred tnter se would produee, in the ease of rough-whiteparents, both rough-whiteand smooth-whiteoflSspring,and in the ease of smooth-pigmentedparents, both smoothpigmented and smooth-whiteoffspring. In the elass of rough-pigmentedseeondgeneration oSspring, whieh eombines the two dominant eharaeters,there will be to eaeh pure individual ( AB ) eight whieh are impure in one or both charaeters. Two of the eight will be hybrid in one charaeter only, as in the rough vs. smooth eharaeter they form the elass A(a)B; two other individuals will be hybrid in the other eharaeter? albino vs. pigmented, Ieormingthe elaXssAl3(b); while the remaining four will be hybrid in bot7?eharaeters, exaetly like. the entire first generation of oifspring, AB (ab) . The task of the praetieal breeder who seeks to 'establish' or 'fix' a new variety, produeedbyeross-breeding,ina ease involving two variable eharaeters,is simply the isolation and propagation of that one in eaeh sixteen of the seeond-generationoffspring whieh will be pure as regards the desired eombination of eharaeters. Mendel's diseovery by putting the breeder in possessionof this information enables him to attaek his problem systematieally, with 401 eonfideneein the outeome,whereasthitherto his worlLd, important'and faseinating as it is, has eonsisted largely of groping for a treasure in the dark.' The greater the number of steparately variable eharaetesrsinvolved in a eross, the greaterwill be the nulnberof new eolnbinations obtainable; the greater, too, will be the numberof individuals whieh it will be neeessary to raise in order to seeure all the possible eombinations;and the greater, again, will be the diffieultyof isolating the pure, t. e., stable forms from sueh as are similar to them in appearanee but still hybrid in one or more eharaeters. Mendel has generalized these-statements substantially ' as follows: In -eases of eomplete dominanee,when the numberof differenees between the parents is n, the number of different elasses into whieh the seeond generation of offspring fall will be 3nSof whith 2n will be pure (stable); the remainder will be hybrid, though indistinguishable from pure individuals. The smallest number of individuals whieh in the seeond hybrid generationwill allow of one pure tndividual to eaeh visibly different elass will be 49. (See Table IV.) . TABLE IV. a Z 5 ;l 5 , F | E < n Sn 3n 4n 1 2 3 2 4 8 3 9 27 4 16 - 64 4 5 6 16 32 64 81 243 729 256 1024 4096 ° ) Tested byMendel Wforpeasand found J correct. Calculated. The law of Mendelreduees to an exaet seienee the art of breedingin the ease most earefully studied by him, that of entire This content downloaded from 130.225.209.174 on Tue, 26 Nov 2013 11:27:55 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 402 seIsNas. It gives to the breeder a new dominance. of ' purity. ' No animal or aonception deis 'pure' simply because it is plant posancestors of from a long line scended of characa sessingdesired combination if it but ay animal or plant is pure ters; even gametes of only one sort, produces its-grandparentsmay among themth'ough have possessed oppostte characters. selares existence of purity ean be established The breeding ithcertainty only by suitable M receswith tests(especially by crossing for but it may be safely assumed sives), paanimal or plant descended from any had which were like each other and rents shown'by breedingtests to be pure. been 1Wendel. Special Cases nder the Law of cases special -Stremains to speak of some apparently the law of Mendel,which under of the areexceptions to one or another already stated, and which probprinciples conditions ablyresult from exceptiona] sp'ecial These imperfectly. linownto us through caseshave come to light in part that through part in Mendel'sown ^ork, ofothers. It oeeasionally 1. lMosaic InhUerwtance. bring towhieh erosses happensthat in reeommonly gethera pair of eharaeters two the reeessive, and latedas dominant in eharaeters appear in the offspring animals piebald in as patchesside by side, The andparti-eoloredflowers and fruits. plaee gives normaldominance apparently in such eases to a balaneed relationship What betweenthe alternative charaeters. is relationships eonditionsgive rise to sueh seeured onee are unknown,but when they stability, they often prove to possess great example, for This, breedingtrue tnter se. usually whieh is the ease in spotted-miee, offspotted of produee a large majority eharof relationship balanced spring CL'he is transaeters possessed by the parents not as are, whieh mitted to the germ-eells, S. VOL.XVIII. [N. NO. 456. D or R, inordinaryhybrid individuals the to DR. This has been shown be but myand in spotted miee by Mr. Allen ease in a paper published elsewhere. self, and Allen, : 03. ) (Castle ease, 2.Stble XybridForms.-This is a whieh somerespeets similar to the last, in It familiar to Atendel ( :70) himself. was that happens, as we have seen, sometimes hybrid has a form of its own diSerent the eases that of either parent. To sueh from not does law of dominanee evidently the hyHteraciuen apply. In a few eases (Wiehura) (Mendel), Salix hybrids brids form --ithas been found that the hybrid not break up in the seeond generation does grandandproduee individuals like the hybrid own its to true but breeds parents, on only explained eharaeter.This ean be germthe Either oneof two assumptions. the balcellsbear the two eharaeters in of those aneedrelationship, AB? as do whieh spottedmiee, or, of the two gametes bears nnitein fertilization, one invariably eharaeter the other the eharaeter A, the former B. Of the two explanations, the probable. more seemsat present mueh the phe3. Co?pledChclracters.-Thisis the in eharacters of nomenonof eorrelation that, in heredity. It is sometimesfound not be ean eross-breedina,two eharaeters the separated. NVhen one is inherited, crossin other is inherited also. Thus, Jamesing diflSerentsorts of Datura (the purple town weed) it has been found that blue with eolor of stem invariably goes stems are green whereas eolor of flowers, flowers. eonstantly assoeiated with white other most Again in lrliee, rabbits and eyes eommammals,white hair and pink not be monly oeeur together and may howseparated in heredity. Very rarely, perever, as I have observed,an otherslTise eyes i feetly mrhiteguinea-pig has dark guinea-pi further the ordinary albino This content downloaded from 130.225.209.174 on Tue, 26 Nov 2013 11:27:55 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions SEPTEMBER - 25, 1903.] 403 SCIBXCE. - \ - with pink eyes has usual]y smutty (brown- -havebeen shown,-by breeding tests, to be pigmented) ears, nose and feet; and a race hybrids, sinee on crossing with white mice of miee with pink eyes, though partially they produce white miee, black mice, and, pigmented eoat, has formed the basis of in one or two eases, gray mice also. Aesome reeent importantsexperimentsin he- eordingly blaek mice elearly belong with sredityeonduetedby Darbishire (: 02,: 03) grays in the category of dominantindividat Oxford, England. The$e exeeptional uals [D or D (R)], but they-have visibly conditions probably represent stable coup- only the black constituent of the gray eoat, lings of a part only of th@dominantschar- the remaining eonstituent, a rufous tint, acter (pigmented eoat) with the reeessive having been separated from the blaek in charaeter (white coat), and are similar in eonsequeneeof eross-breeding. There is kind to the DR eharaeterof spotted mice. reason to believe that the rufous constiFurther, eoup]ing may oeeur between a tuent may become reeessive, . e., latent, in the number of charaeters greater than two, either in the blaek individuals or seen is It both. in or whites, reverted so that they form, to al] intents and purthe and black the both from separated poses, in heredity, one indissoluble comehocolate-brown the in pound eharacter. Thus, Gorrens (:00 ) white eharacters, individuals obtained observedthat in erossesbetweentwo speeies and reddish-yellow in cross-breeding. of stocks (lliathtola ineana DC. and M. A faneier of rabbits tells me that there glabra DC.) the seeond generationhybrids oeeurs a similar disintegrationof the eomshowedreversionto one or the other of the coat-eolor of the ' Belgian hare,' parental forms in ata three of t}e princtpal posite animal is crossedwith ordinary that when dtgereqtttatcharacters studied, viz., hairy the result being the producrabbits, white or glabrous stems, violet or yellow-white yellow and mottled indi.black, of tion flowers, and blue or yellow seed. A blue to ordinary grayaddition in viduals, seed always produced a hoary plant bearing violet flowers; a yellows seed always browns. The various distinct colors or color produced a glabrous plant bearing yellow patches of the guinea-pig have doubtless or white f owers. originated in a similar way by resolution is This 4. Disintegrattonof Characters. of the composite coat-color of the wild Not process. the converseof the foregoing Cavta, upon crossing with an albino sport. be simple only may charactersapparently subject is now undergoing investigaThis comcouple(l together in heredity to form tion. posite 1lnits o£ a higher order, but characCorrens ( :00) mentionsa case in plants, ters which ordinarily behave as units may as a result of crossing undergo disintegra- which probably belongs in this same catetion into elementsseparately transmissible. gory. In crossing the blue-flowered(domtncana with the yellowishThus the gray coat-color of the house- inant) 7[Iath>zolcl, mouse is always transmitted as a domin- white-flowered (recessive) M. glabraf the ant unit in primary crosses with its white second generation recessives produced in variety; but in the second cross-bredgen- some cases pure white flowers, in others eration a certain number of black mice ap- yellow flowers. In this case the recessive pear, some or all of which are probably aharacter, rather than the dominant, unhybrids. For similar black mice obtained derwent disintegration. 5. Departures from t7se Theorettcal by crossing black-white with white mice This content downloaded from 130.225.209.174 on Tue, 26 Nov 2013 11:27:55 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 40 SCIENCE. [N- S. VOL. XVIII. No. 456. It is possible, however, that there are Rattos of Dornants to Recessq>ves.Considerable departures are to be expected cases in which one of a pair of characters when the number of oflfspringtaken into is sometimes doninant, sometimes reeestonsiderationis small, but with increasein sive. Tschermak ( :01) believes that he the number of offspring examined,the de- has found a few such cases among crosspartures should grow less. This is usually bred beans. Sex and certain other difound to be true. Mendel's numbers are morphic conditions found in the higher shown by Weldon ( :02) to be well within animals and plants may prove to be cases the limits of probable error. But certain of this sort. Acceptance of Mendel's prineiples of cases have been observedin which departheredity as correctmust lead one to regard ures of a particular sort persist even with discontinuous ( or sport) variation as of considerablenumbers of offspring. Thus Allen and I have found the recessive char- the highest importanee in bringing about acter,white, in mice to be inherited'inabout polymorphismof species and ultiluately of \ three per cent. more than the caltulated theaformationof new species. A sport having once arisen affecting number of cases, while the equally recessive dancing characteris inherited'in about some one character of a species, may by thirty-three per 'cent. less than t-he caleu- crossing with the parent form be the cause lated number of cases. These fairly uni- of no end of disintegrationon the part of form departures indica;te,to my,mind, a any or all of the charactersof the species, vitality, on the part of the recessiare and the disintegrated characters may, ingamete, in one case somewhatsuperior, in deed ntest, form a great variety of nemr the other much inferior, to that of the Gombinationsof characters,some of which dominant gamete. Inferior vitality of will prove stable and self-perpetuating. if a particular combinationof ehargametes of either -sort xvould result in DE+ren greater rLlortalityand so in a diminished acters is uniformly eliminated by natural number of individuals derived from such selection under one set of conditions, it ulay reappear agairl and again, and finally gametes. ^ Of courseother explanationsare possible, meet with conditions which insure lts as, that the two sorts of gametes are not sueeess. We now have an explanationof the lonproduced in equal numbers. More extended investigations of such cases can reeognizedprinciple that new types of organisms are extremely varia-ble,whereas alone make their meaning elear. 6. Reversal ot7Dowtnarbce. Exeeptional old types vary little. A new type which cases are on record in which trossing of a has arisen as a sport will cross with the dominant with a reeessive has resulted in parent form. The offspring will then inthe production of pure dominants, or re- herit some characters dominant, others cessives, instead of hybrids. Sueh cases latent, and polymorphismof the race reare, I believe, eorrectly referred by Bate- sults. Only selection continued through son to the category of ' false hybridiza- long periods of time will serve to eliminate tion' as deseribed by Millardet, a phe- conzpletelythe latent recessives,and so to nomenonakin to parthenogenesis,in which eause the disappearance of certain abersesual union has served rnerely to sttrnts- rant variations. Bateson makes the pregnant suggestion late one gaqzete to developm,entwithout that even eases of coritinuous variation bringing about its union with the other may possibly prove eonformablewith AIengamete. This content downloaded from 130.225.209.174 on Tue, 26 Nov 2013 11:27:55 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions SEPTEX1BER25, 1903.] SCIEEGE. delian prineiples. Take, for example, the height of peas. It. has been found in certain crosses of a tall with a dwarf variety of pea, that the hybrid has an intermediate height. Now, if the hybrid produe.espure germ-eells, dwarf and tall respeetively, in equal numbers,the next generation will consist of three elasses of individuals, dwarf, intermediate and tall, in the proportions1: 2: 1. But if each of the original charactersshould undergo disintegration, we might get a dozen elasses, instead of three, resulting in a practically continuous frequeney-of-erroreurve. 405 4. There htaarefbeen observedthetfollowing exceptions to the principle of dominance, or to the principle of purity of the germ-eells,or to both; (a) Mosaic inheritance,in which a pair of ellaractersordinarily related a.s dominant and recessive occur in a balanced relationship, side by side in the hybrid individual and frequently in its germ-eells also. This balanced condition, once obtained, is usually stable under elose breeding, but is readily disturbedby cross-breeding, giving place then to the normal dominance. ( b) Stable (self-perpetuating) hybrid SUMMARY. forms result from certain crosses. These 1. The basie prineiple in Mendel's dis- teonstitutean exeeption to both the law of eoveries is that of the purity of the germ- dominan,eeand to that of purity of the eells, in aeeordaneewith this a eross-bred germ-eells. CFlor the hybrid is like neither animal or plant produees germ-eellsbear- parent, but the eharaetersof both parents ing only one of eaeh pair of eharactersin exist in a stable union in the mature germwhieh its parents differ. :lfromit follows eells produeedby the hybrid. the oeeurrencein the seeond and later hy(c) Coupling, t. e., eomplete ,eorrelabrid generations of a definite number of tion may exist between two or more eharforms in definite numerieal proportions. aeters, so that they form a eompoundunit 2. Mendel's prineiple of dominanee is not separablein heredity, at least in eertain realized in the heredity of a eonsiderable erosses. :numberof eharaetersamong both animals (d) Disintegration of eharaeters apand plants. In aeeordaneewith this prin- parently simple may take plaee in eonseeiple, hybrid ofEspringhave visibly the quenee of eross-breedin. eharaeterof only one parent or the other (e) Departuresfrom the expeeted ratios though they transmitthose of both parents. of dominants to reeessives may be ex3. In other eases the hybrid has a dis- plained in some eases as due to inferior tinetive eharaeterof its own. This may ap- vigor, and so greater mortality,on the part proximate more or less elosely the ehar- of dominants or recessives respeetively. aeter of one parent or the other or it may (/) Cases of apparent reversal of dombe entirely different from both. CFlre- inanee nzayarise from 'false hybridization' quently the distinetive hybrid charaeter (indueed parth>3nogenesis). Possibly in resembles a lost aneestral eharaeter. In other eases the determination of domsome eases of this sort, as in eoat-eolorof inallee rests with circumstances as yet mammals, the hybrid eharaeter probably unknown. results from a reeombinationof the ehar 5. Mendel's prineiples strengthen the aeters seen in one or both parents, with view that speeies arise by diseontinuous certain other eharaeters latent (that is variation. They explain why new types reeessive) in one parent or the other. are espeeially variable, how one variation . This content downloaded from 130.225.209.174 on Tue, 26 Nov 2013 11:27:55 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 406 [N.S. NToL.XVIII. saIsNcs. eausesothers?and why tertain variations areso persistenl;in their occurrence. BIBI.IOGRAPHY. \'V. BATESON, :02. ' Mendel's Principles of Heredity, a Defence.' MTith a Translation of Mendel's Original Papers on Hybridization. 12mod212 pp. Cambridge. [England. Contains bibliography and portrait of Mendel.] E. R. W., ANDSAUNDERS, BATESONT, :02. 'Experimental Studies in the Physiology of Heredity.' Reports to the Evolution Committee of the Royal Society. Report I., 160 pp. London. M. STLE,NV.E., ND ALLEN,GLOVER CA :03. 'The Heredity of Albinism.' Proc. Am. Acad . A rts Sc+., Vol. 38, pp. 603-622. C. CORR1BATS, :00. ' G. Mendel'sRegeln iiber das Verhalten del Nachkommenschaft der Rassenbastarde.' Ber. dexhtsch. bot. Gesellach., Jahrg. 18, pp. 158-168. L. CUTENOT, :02. ' La loi de Alendel et l'heredite, de la pigmentation chez les souris.' Compt. Rend., Parisd 'Rom.134, pp. 779-781. A. D. DARBISHIRE, :02. 'Notes on the Results of Crossing Japanese Walt7ing Mice with European A1bino Races.' Btornetrzka, Vol. 2, Pt. 1, pp. 101-104, 4 figs. A. D. DAR13ISH1}{E, :03. ' Second Report on the Results of Crossing Japane3e Waltzing Mice with European Albino Races.' Biornetrika, Vol. 2, Pt. 2, pp. 165-173, 6 figs. MENDEI.,G#. :66. 'Versuche iiber Pflanzenhybriden. Verh. l\Tat?rf.-97ereins in Brxnn, Bd. 4, Abh., pp. 3-47. (Translation in Bateson, :02. ) MENDEI.,G#. :70. ' Ueber einige aus lviinstlicher Be£ruchtung Hieraci¢m-Bastard e.' entnomennen tn Brxnn, Bd. Nat1hrf.-Vereins Verh. 8, Abh., pp. 26-31. (Translation in Bateson :02. ) E. 51SCHEPUMAK :00. ' Ueber kiinstliche Kl euzung bei Pis¢ns satisvxqn. Zeitsch. f. Iandxwirths. Verslxchs1cese^ i¢ Oester., Jahrg. 3, pp. 46t5_<,55 No. 456we E. TSCHERMAK, :01. ' Weiteze Beitrage uber Velschiedenwerthigkeit der Merkmale bei Kreuzung von Erbsen und Bohnen.' (Vorlaufige Mittheilung.) Ber. deutsch. bot. Gesellsch., Jahrg. 19; pp. 3551. E. DE. VRIES, :00. ' Sur la loi de disjonction des hybrides. Comnpt.Bend., Paris, Tom. 130, ppw 845-847. H. DE. VRTES. :00. ' Das Spaltungsgesetz der Bastarden. Jahrg; Ber. de¢tsc7l. bc)t. CZesellse1W., 83-90. pp. 1S, M. F- R77EI.I)ON, :02. ' Mendel's Laws of Altelnative Illhelitance in Peas.' Biomet}ika, Vol. 1 pp. 228 254, pl. 1, 2. NV.E. CASTLE. ITY. 29t\DC,-1\E12S Hh1tX _ l l l,B UlB CIjIAtTO\- WNIGHT. THEsubjeet of this sketch was born on a farm at Rochelle, Illinois, December13s 1858. Early in his boyhood his parents, Mr. and Mrs. David A. Knight, removed to a farm at no great distance from Lineoln, Nebraska. Here he grew to young manhoodgaining the strength of body ancl mind whith is so often developedin unfettered eountry life. Self-relianee ancl strength of tharacter came to him in the struggle that he, in commonwith the other nzembersof the family, had plat f(rth in what was then the new west, in order to wrest from nature the daily bread. Life in all of its foruls, and the hills an=lr)eks appealed strongly to him. By the time that he had secured such education as the he had also become eountry school alcEorded more than ordinarily familiar with the £auna,the flora and the geological fornlaLionsof his neighborhood. Being unusually £ond o£ athletie sportst of fishing and of hu;rlting,he led many a merry party in these pursuits, frequently to the complete exhaustion of most of his fellows. In more recent years, his many friends who at one time or another shared This content downloaded from 130.225.209.174 on Tue, 26 Nov 2013 11:27:55 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions