36ee breast
Transcription
36ee breast
ADMINISTRATIVE REPORT MEETING DATE: June 10, 2015 AGENDA SECTION: Action Items ITEM: 10. C APPROVED BY DEPARTMENT DIRECTOR GENERAL MANAGER TO: Honorable Members of the Board FROM: Kevin Kalman. General Manager DATE: June 4, 2015 SUBJECT: Healthcare Benefits for Full-Time Staff and Board Members RECOMMENDATION: To authorize the General Manager to negotiate and execute a contracts with United Healthcare/Guardian for the provision of employee health and welfare insurance plans for fiscal year 2016. BACKGROUND: The District’s insurance broker, Employer Resource Group (ERG), solicited proposals for the District’s medical insurance plan as part of the renewal process for the various lines of employee group health and welfare benefits. Due to the District’s policy of extending coverage to board members, the pool of providers is limited to two, Aetna and United Healthcare (UHC). ERG received proposals from incumbent vendor Aetna and United Healthcare. Administrative Report - Subject: Healthcare Benefits for Full-Time Staff and Board Members Page 1 ADMINISTRATIVE REPORT The District is no longer qualified for large group aggregate insurance rates as there are less than 50 team members eligible to participate in the plan. In January 2016 large group will transition to 100+ eligible team members further cementing the District as a small group provider under the current healthcare reform laws. This change affects the method of calculation for premiums moving forward. Each team member’s premium will be based on the age of the insured, employee and dependents. Aetna has agreed to extend aggregate pricing for one more renewal. However, Aetna proposes a significant rate increase (approximately 25%) for the July 1, 2015 renewal. Aetna’s proposal plan includes one HMO and one PPO plan option. Both plan options increase out of pocket expense for co-pays, hospitalization, and prescribed medication. UHC pricing, and future pricing with any alternate provider, is based on the age of the insured. UHC proposal includes two HMO and two PPO plan options allowing for team members to choose the plan that best suits their individual situation and budget. The plan choices offer similar benefits as Aetna at a lower total cost. However, it should be noted that while overall cost is lower with UHC, each team member will be impacted differently due to the individual pricing structure. Effective July 1, 2014 the District implemented an employer contribution cap of $1,380 per month for medical premiums. This action was intended to control the District’s liability for the continuous increase in insurance premiums. The cap was set at an amount that would allow all team members to select a plan that would cover 100% of the employee and their dependent premiums in the first year of implementation. This policy was initiated with the understanding that team members would need to contribute to escalating premiums in future years. As a result, team members selected plans that required the least amount of employee contribution based on their individual situation. Only 1 of 34 team/board members elected a plan that required the employee/board member to contribute to their premium. Premiums are projected to continue to rise at unprecedented rates (14-18%) as mandates of the Affordable Care Act continue to be implemented. During the Study Session of May 13, 2015 it was suggested that the employer contribution cap be raised to $1,725 (25%) to cover 100% of employee and dependents on the Aetna’s proposed HMO plan and to renew with Aetna. Staff does not recommend increasing the employer contribution cap at this time. In order for the District to consider adding the much needed full time team members to implement the Boards vision, it is critical that these cost be controlled and shared. Administrative Report - Subject: Healthcare Benefits for Full-Time Staff and Board Members Page 2 ADMINISTRATIVE REPORT Based on the analysis of caps $1,380, $1,500, $1,769 and implementing an Employer Sponsored Base Plan (ESBP) staff has determined the following: 1. ESBP provides 100% coverage for Employees and Dependents 2. ESBP provides the most equitable distribution of cost should team members choose to buy up to another plan. 3. ESBP provides the District and team members a lower cost than all cap scenarios 4. United Healthcare is the more affordable choice in all scenarios Therefore staff is recommending the Board move to United Healthcare under the ESBP structure. PREVIOUS BOARD AND/OR STAFF ACTION: May 13, 2015 the Board continued Study Item 9. A Healthcare Benefits for Full-Time Staff and Board Members. May 28, 2016 the Board passed Resolution 14-33 Revising the Compensation and Benefits Plan for FY2015. FINANCIAL IMPACT The maximum financial impact for FY2016 with 38 eligible team/board members is $629,280. Administrative Report - Subject: Healthcare Benefits for Full-Time Staff and Board Members Page 3 ATTACHMENT MEMORANDUM MEETING DATE: June 10, 2015 AGENDA SECTION: Action Items ITEM: 10. C TO: Honorable Members of the Board FROM: Kevin Kalman, General Manager DATE: June 5, 2015 Documents related to the Subject: Healthcare Benefits for Full-Time Staff and Board Members 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Employer Sponsored Base Plan Structure United Healthcare Medical Benefits Proposal Guardian Vision, Dental, Etc. Proposal Healthcare Benefits Analysis Presentation ERG Study Session Presentation Page 1 Employer Sponsored Base Plan Aetna Renewal HMO Age 44 36 33 33 54 47 36 51 27 52 62 61 43 33 45 56 27 51 40 24 35 51 59 60 50 50 46 Coverage EE/CH EE/SP EE FAM EE/SP FAM FAM FAM FAM EE/SP EE/SP EE/SP FAM FAM FAM FAM EE FAM EE/CH EE EE EE/CH EE/SP EE/SP EE EE FAM Totals DRD $ 1,027.00 $ 1,255.00 $ 571.00 $ 1,769.00 $ 1,255.00 $ 1,769.00 $ 1,769.00 $ 1,769.00 $ 1,769.00 $ 1,255.00 $ 1,255.00 $ 1,255.00 $ 1,769.00 $ 1,769.00 $ 1,769.00 $ 1,769.00 $ 571.00 $ 1,769.00 $ 1,027.00 $ 571.00 $ 571.00 $ 1,027.00 $ 1,255.00 $ 1,255.00 $ 571.00 $ 571.00 $ 1,769.00 $ 34,751.00 Aetna Monthly Aetna Annually TM $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ 34,751 $ 417,012 PPO DRD $ 1,027.00 $ 1,255.00 $ 571.00 $ 1,769.00 $ 1,255.00 $ 1,769.00 $ 1,769.00 $ 1,769.00 $ 1,769.00 $ 1,255.00 $ 1,255.00 $ 1,255.00 $ 1,769.00 $ 1,769.00 $ 1,769.00 $ 1,769.00 $ 571.00 $ 1,769.00 $ 1,027.00 $ 571.00 $ 571.00 $ 1,027.00 $ 1,255.00 $ 1,255.00 $ 571.00 $ 571.00 $ 1,769.00 $ 34,751.00 TM $ 393.00 $ 480.00 $ 218.00 $ 676.00 $ 480.00 $ 676.00 $ 676.00 $ 676.00 $ 676.00 $ 480.00 $ 480.00 $ 480.00 $ 676.00 $ 676.00 $ 676.00 $ 676.00 $ 218.00 $ 676.00 $ 393.00 $ 218.00 $ 218.00 $ 393.00 $ 480.00 $ 480.00 $ 218.00 $ 218.00 $ 676.00 $ 13,283.00 No TM Cost Plan YES NO 26 0 HMO Platinum DRD TM $ 775.52 $ 118.50 $ 752.25 $ 114.96 $ 348.35 $ 53.24 $ 1,250.65 $ 191.11 $ 1,096.25 $ 167.52 $ 1,763.01 $ 269.42 $ 1,089.27 $ 166.45 $ 1,805.74 $ 275.98 $ 794.13 $ 121.35 $ 1,043.03 $ 159.40 $ 1,707.75 $ 261.00 $ 1,437.91 $ 219.75 $ 1,149.17 $ 175.61 $ 890.66 $ 136.11 $ 1,183.78 $ 180.89 $ 1,970.91 $ 301.41 $ 304.74 $ 46.57 $ 1,352.41 $ 206.70 $ 1,137.83 $ 173.78 $ 290.78 $ 44.44 $ 355.33 $ 54.31 $ 833.08 $ 127.33 $ 1,350.09 $ 206.34 $ 1,437.62 $ 219.71 $ 519.33 $ 79.37 $ 519.33 $ 79.37 $ 1,410.01 $ 215.46 $ 28,568.93 $ 4,366.08 HMO Gold DRD $ 775.52 $ 752.25 $ 348.35 $ 1,250.65 $ 1,096.25 $ 1,763.01 $ 1,089.27 $ 1,805.74 $ 794.13 $ 1,043.03 $ 1,707.75 $ 1,437.91 $ 1,149.17 $ 890.66 $ 1,183.78 $ 1,970.91 $ 304.74 $ 1,352.41 $ 1,137.83 $ 290.78 $ 355.33 $ 833.08 $ 1,350.09 $ 1,437.62 $ 519.33 $ 519.33 $ 1,410.01 $ 28,568.93 TM $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ $ ‐ United Healthcare Monthly United Healthcare Annually United Healthcare PPO Gold DRD TM $ 775.52 $ 252.88 $ 752.25 $ 245.30 $ 348.35 $ 113.60 $ 1,250.65 $ 407.83 $ 1,096.25 $ 357.47 $ 1,763.01 $ 574.89 $ 1,089.27 $ 355.20 $ 1,805.74 $ 588.83 $ 794.13 $ 258.95 $ 1,043.03 $ 340.12 $ 1,707.75 $ 556.88 $ 1,437.91 $ 468.89 $ 1,149.17 $ 374.73 $ 890.66 $ 290.44 $ 1,183.78 $ 386.01 $ 1,970.91 $ 642.69 $ 304.74 $ 99.37 $ 1,352.41 $ 441.01 $ 1,137.83 $ 371.03 $ 290.78 $ 94.82 $ 355.33 $ 115.87 $ 833.08 $ 271.66 $ 1,350.09 $ 440.25 $ 1,437.62 $ 468.79 $ 519.33 $ 169.35 $ 519.33 $ 169.35 $ 1,410.01 $ 459.78 $ 28,568.93 $ 9,315.99 $ 28,569 $ 342,827 PPO Silver DRD TM $ 775.52 $ 31.72 $ 752.25 $ 30.79 $ 348.35 $ 14.26 $ 1,250.65 $ 51.17 $ 1,096.25 $ 44.85 $ 1,763.01 $ 72.14 $ 1,089.27 $ 44.57 $ 1,805.74 $ 73.90 $ 794.13 $ 32.49 $ 1,043.03 $ 42.68 $ 1,707.75 $ 69.89 $ 1,437.91 $ 58.84 $ 1,149.17 $ 47.02 $ 890.66 $ 36.45 $ 1,183.78 $ 48.43 $ 1,970.91 $ 80.65 $ 304.74 $ 12.47 $ 1,352.41 $ 55.36 $ 1,137.83 $ 46.56 $ 290.78 $ 11.90 $ 355.33 $ 14.54 $ 833.08 $ 34.10 $ 1,350.09 $ 55.26 $ 1,437.62 $ 58.83 $ 519.33 $ 21.26 $ 519.33 $ 21.26 $ 1,410.01 $ 57.68 $ 28,568.93 $ 1,169.07 No TM Cost Plan YES NO 26 0 PROPOSAL FOR Desert Recreation District RATES SHOWN ARE VALID FROM: June 1, 2015 - June 15, 2015 Presented by: ERG Insurance Services, Inc Sales Representative: Shirley Mejia Telephone: (949) 885-1742 SIC Code: 7997 State & Zip: CA 92201 Created: March 17, 2015 PLAN DESIGN We offer comprehensive benefits plans that can be customized to the needs of employers. To help you evaluate the plans, we have provided detailed benefits summaries within this package. RATES Rates and premiums presented are based on the employee data submitted in your request for a proposal. Final rates and premiums are based on the plans selected and the information provided on the enrollment forms. BROAD RANGE OF PRODUCTS We offer a variety of flexible, cost-effective employee benefits plans that can help employers meet the needs of employees and their families, and manage costs at the same time. Our benefits plans include Dental, Disability, Life, Vision, Critical Illness, and many more. WHY GUARDIAN? • Enrollment Support – Dedicated professionals help ensure smooth plan implementation • Multi-Product Discounts – Combine plans to meet customer needs and save money • Convenient Access to Service – One phone number and one secure website • Streamlined Billing – All plans billed on one invoice • Experience & Expertise – Over 50 years group benefits experience with exemplary ratings The Guardian Life Insurance Company of America 7 Hanover Square, New York, NY 10004-4025 Desert Recreation District John Henry Garcia Basic Term Life RATES per $1,000 Census Life Rate AD&D Rate Volume Monthly Premium Annual Premium 34 $0.200 $0.020 $1,725,000 $379.50 $4,554.00 Rate Guarantee 2 Years Minimum Participation Contributory plans assume a minimum of 75% participation of eligible employees. Non-contributory plans assume a minimum of 100% participation of eligible employees. Evidence of Insurability Medical Underwriting may be required for amounts in excess of Guaranteed issue amount. Future entrants age 70 and over are limited to $10,000 of life insurance without evidence of insurability. Guarantee Issue $100,000 Proposal Assumptions: • *Package Sale: Life, Voluntary Life, Dental & Vision + one supplemental line (CI, Accident or Cancer) BENEFITS All Eligible Employees Employee Benefit 100% of salary to a maximum of $100,000 with a minimum of $15,000 Enhanced Employee AD&D 100% of Life Benefit to a maximum of $100,000 Common Carrier Not Included Accelerated Life 75% of the death benefit, Minimum: $10,000, Maximum: $250,000 Waiver of Premium If disabled, insurance will continue until age 70 or no longer disabled. Portability Included with Evidence of Insurability Conversion Included Benefit Reduction (of original amount) Age 70 75 Reduction 35% 55% PLAN HIGHLIGHTS Enhanced AD&D Features Include: • Education & Retraining Benefit • Repatriation Benefit • Day Care Expense • Seatbelt & Airbag Benefit • Catastrophic Loss • Child Education Benefit IMPORTANT NOTES Rates and premiums are based on the employee data submitted. Final rates and premiums are based on the plan and employee/dependent data provided on the enrollment forms. State specific requirements may apply. • Life rate is only valid if sold with another Guardian coverage. • Waiver of Premium: Insured must be totally disabled prior to age 60. • Portability ceases on attainment of age 70. • Earnings Definition for salary based plans will match Disability earnings definition. SUMMARY OF PLAN LIMITATIONS AND EXCLUSIONS Life Plan • In order to be eligible for coverage: Employees must be legally working: (a) in the United States or (b) outside the United States, for a US based employer, in a country or region approved by Guardian. • Employees must be working full-time on the effective date of your coverage; otherwise, your coverage becomes effective after the completion of the specific waiting period GP-1-A-GP-90-1, et al. • Evidence of Insurability is required for all late enrollees. Benefit increases may require underwriting. Accidental Death and Dismemberment Plan • We pay no Accidental Death and Dismemberment benefits for an insured where death or dismemberment occurs as the result of a disease or a bodily infirmity; through willful self-injury; by declared or undeclared war, act of war, armed aggression, or while a member of armed forces; while driving motor vehicle without a current, valid driver’s license; while legally intoxicated; while participating in civil disorder or committing a felony; traveling on any type of aircraft while having any duties on that aircraft; while voluntarily using a non prescription controlled substance GP-1-R-ADCL1-00 et al. • Guardian Basic Term Life Insurance is underwritten by The Guardian Life Insurance Company of America, New York, NY and will not be effective until approved by a Guardian underwriter. This proposal is subject to satisfactory financial evaluation. Please refer to certificate of coverage for full plan description; plan documents are the final arbiter of coverage. Valid from 06/01/15 to 06/15/15 Tracking Code# 00160409662-03 Page 1 of 20 Desert Recreation District John Henry Garcia Voluntary Term Life RATES per $1,000 Age <30 30-34 35-39 40-44 45-49 50-54 55-59 60-64 65-69 70+ Rates $0.075 $0.085 $0.126 $0.226 $0.350 $0.531 $0.839 $1.418 $2.333 $4.540 Census Child 34 $0.167 Rate Guarantee 2 Years Minimum Participation Voluntary, Greater of 25% or 10 enrolled employees. Re-enrollment Annual Election Option: allows an employee to annually enroll for an increase of coverage, by an electable amount up to $50,000, not to exceed the case Guarantee Issue. Underwriting Requirements Employee <65 Spouse <65 Child Employee 65<70 Spouse 65<70 Employee 70+ Spouse 70+ Guarantee Issue $50,000 $10,000 $10,000 $50,000 $10,000 $10,000 $0 Proposal Assumptions: • *Package Sale: Life, Voluntary Life, Dental & Vision + one supplemental line (CI, Accident or Cancer) BENEFITS All Eligible Employees Employee Benefit $10,000 to $300,000 in $10,000 increments Spouse Benefit $5,000 to $50,000 in $5,000 increments, not to exceed 100% of Employee's amount Child Benefit $1,000 to $10,000 in $1,000 increments, not to exceed 10% of Employee's amount Infant Benefit $500 Dependent Age Limits 14 days to 26 years (26 if full time student). Infant Age: Birth to 14 days. Spouse terminates at 70. Accelerated Life 50% of the death benefit, Minimum: $10,000, Maximum: $250,000 Waiver of Premium If disabled, insurance will continue until age 65 or no longer disabled Portability Included, without Evidence of Insurability Conversion Included Seatbelt/Airbag Employee: $10,000/$15,000, Dependent: $5,000/$7,500 Benefit Reduction (of original amount) Age 65 70 Reduction 35% 50% PLAN HIGHLIGHTS Will Prep Services: • Provides resources to prepare wills and other planning documents. Will Prep Services include: free Estate Planning documents, access to Estate Planners and Resource Library. For a small fee, Attorney Assisted Will Preparation is also available. IMPORTANT NOTES Rates and premiums are based on the employee data submitted. Final rates and premiums are based on the plan and employee/dependent data provided on the enrollment forms. State specific requirements may apply. • Life rate is only valid if sold with another Guardian coverage. • Waiver: must be disabled prior to age 60. Total Disability is required. • Portability ceases on attainment of age 70. • Spouse rate is based on employee's age bracket. Child rate is a per $1,000 for all children. Dependent life insurance will not take effect if a dependent, other than a newborn, is confined to a hospital or other health care facility or is unable to perform the normal activities of someone of like age and sex. SUMMARY OF PLAN LIMITATIONS AND EXCLUSIONS Life Plan • In order to be eligible for coverage: Employees must be legally working (a) in the United States or (b) outside the United States, for a US based employer, in a country or region approved by Guardian. • We pay no benefits if the insured’s death is due to suicide within two years from the insured’s original effective date. This two year limitation also applies to any increase in benefit. This exclusion may vary according to state law. GP-1-A-GP-90-1-et al. (continued) Valid from 06/01/15 to 06/15/15 Tracking Code# 00160409662-03 Page 2 of 20 Desert Recreation District John Henry Garcia Voluntary Term Life SUMMARY OF PLAN LIMITATIONS AND EXCLUSIONS (continued) • Employees must be working full-time on the effective date of your coverage; otherwise, coverage becomes effective after the completion of the specific waiting period. • Evidence of Insurability is required for all late enrollees. Benefit increases may require underwriting. • Guardian Voluntary Term Life Insurance is underwritten by The Guardian Life Insurance Company of America, New York, NY and will not be effective until approved by a Guardian underwriter. This proposal is subject to satisfactory financial evaluation. Please refer to certificate of coverage for full plan description; plan documents are the final arbiter of coverage. Valid from 06/01/15 to 06/15/15 Tracking Code# 00160409662-03 Page 3 of 20 Desert Recreation District John Henry Garcia Long Term Disability RATES Per $100 of Monthly Covered Payroll Census Employee Rate Monthly Payroll Monthly Premium Annual Premium 29 $0.478 $133,333 $637.33 $7,647.96 Rate Guarantee 2 Years BENEFITS All Eligible Non-Board Member Employees Contribution/Participation Non-contributory/100% Elimination Period 90 days Duration of Benefits Social Security normal retirement age Definition of Disability 2 year Own Occupation/Any Occupation thereafter Monthly Benefit 60% to $6,000 Guarantee Issue $6,000 Evidence of Insurability Medical Underwriting may be required for amounts in excess of GI Interruption of Elimination Period Unlimited, no set number of days Return to Work Zero Day Residual Work Incentive 12 month Maximum Partial Disability Earnings 80% Indexed Own Occ/ 80% Indexed Any Occ Partial Disability Calculation Greater of direct reduction or proportionate loss Income Recovery Included Integration Method Direct Offset, Family Salary Continuation /Association IDI No offset Minimum Benefit $50 Mental Health & Substance Abuse 24 Month lifetime payment limit, combined Pre-Existing Conditions 3 months prior, 12 months after Exclusion, Continuity of Coverage Earnings Definition Standard, excluding bonus & commission State Integration CA SDI Rehabilitation Services 110% benefit amount, voluntary participation, Includes Dependent care expense Survivor Benefit 3 months net, accelerated Worksite Modification $2,500 PLAN HIGHLIGHTS • Guardian’s Financial Strength: Guardian has a long history of earning exemplary ratings from independent rating services which provide 1 essential measures of a company’s value as well as common ground for valid comparison. For additional details, visit our web site: http://www.guardianlife.com/AboutGuardian/FinancialHighlights/Ratings/index.htm • Experienced and Innovative Disability Service Team: Our services help disabled employees return to maximum potential by having a dedicated claims analyst work closely with the employer, disabled employee and physicians to encourage and support successful outcomes. For additional details, see our disability page: https://www.guardiananytime.com/gafd/wps/portal/fdhome/employers/products-andcoverage/disability • Income Recovery Benefit: This provision continues a monthly benefit payment to a claimant who is recovered from disability and returns to full-time work in his or her own occupation but is unable to earn 80% of pre-disability earnings. This benefit will continue up to 12 months or until the claimant is able to earn 80% of indexed pre-disability earnings. 1 Financial information concerning The Guardian Life Insurance Company of America as of December 31, 2013 on a statutory basis: Admitted Assets = $42.1 Billion; Liabilities = $37.1 Billion (including $32.7 Billion of Reserves); and Surplus = $5.0 Billion. Valid from 06/01/15 to 06/15/15 Tracking Code# 00160409662-03 Page 4 of 20 Desert Recreation District John Henry Garcia Long Term Disability IMPORTANT NOTES Rates and premiums are based on the employee data submitted. Final rates and premiums are based on the plan and employee/dependent data provided on the enrollment forms. State specific requirements apply. • If an Own Occupation/Any Occupation plan is selected: During the elimination period and the own occupation period, the employee must be unable to perform, on a full-time basis, the major duties of his or her own occupation. After the end of the own occupation period, the employee must be unable to perform, on a full-time basis, the major duties of any gainful work. The employee is not disabled if he or she earns, or is able to earn, more than this plan’s maximum allowed income earned during disability. • These rates are contingent upon LTD being purchased with Guardian Life coverage and without Guardian STD coverage. SUMMARY OF PLAN LIMITATIONS AND EXCLUSIONS • We limit the duration of payments for long term disabilities caused by mental or emotional conditions, or alcohol or drug abuse. • We do not pay benefits for charges relating to a covered person: taking part in any war or act of war (including service in the armed forces) committing a felony or taking part in any riot or other civil disorder or intentionally injuring themselves or attempting suicide while sane or insane, and for the voluntary use of any poison, chemical, prescription or non-prescription drug or controlled substance unless it has been prescribed by a doctor and is used as prescribed. • We do not pay benefits during any period in which a covered person is confined to a correctional facility, an employee is not under the care of a doctor, an employee is receiving treatment outside of the US or Canada and the employee’s loss of earnings is not solely due to disability. • During the exclusion/limitation period, this disability plan does not pay charges relating to a pre-existing condition. A pre-existing condition includes any condition for which an employee, in a specified period of time prior to coverage in this plan, consults with a physician, receives treatment, or takes prescribed drugs. If this plan is transferred from another insurance carrier, the time an insured is covered under that plan will count toward satisfying Guardian’s pre-existing condition exclusion /limitation period. Please refer to the plan details for specific time periods. Contract # GP-1-LTD07-1.0 et al. (AG09) • In order to be eligible for coverage; employees must be legally working: (a) in the United States or (b) outside the United States, for a US based employer in a country or region approved by Guardian. • This policy provides disability income insurance only. It does not provide "basic hospital", "basic medical", or "major medical" insurance as defined by the New York State Insurance Department. • Evidence of Insurability is required on all late enrollees. • Guardian Long Term Disability Insurance is underwritten by The Guardian Life Insurance Company of America, New York, NY and will not be effective until approved by a Guardian underwriter. This proposal is subject to satisfactory financial evaluation. Please refer to certificate of coverage for full plan description; plan documents are the final arbiter of coverage. Valid from 06/01/15 to 06/15/15 Tracking Code# 00160409662-03 Page 5 of 20 Desert Recreation District John Henry Garcia Dental RATES Monthly Rate Employee Employee & Spouse Employee & Child(ren) Full Family Monthly Premiums Annual Premium $39.44 $75.54 $88.95 $133.67 $3,025.31 $36,303.72 11 6 3 14 Census Rate Guarantee 1 Year Proposal Assumptions: • *Package Sale: Life, Voluntary Life, Dental & Vision + one supplemental line (CI, Accident or Cancer) BENEFITS All Eligible Employees DentalGuard Alliance Contribution/Participation Deductible DentalGuard Preferred Out-of-Network Contributory, Assumes 80% of eligible employees. Dental is sold with Guardian Life coverage. $0 $50 $50 Calendar Year Calendar Year Calendar Year Family Limit 3 per family 3 per family 3 per family Waived For Preventive Preventive Preventive $2,500 plus Maximum Rollover $2,000 plus Maximum Rollover $1,500 plus Maximum Rollover Period Annual Maximum Maximum Rollover Threshold $700 Rollover Amount $350 In-Network only Rollover $500 Account Limit Claim Payment Basis Network Coinsurance - Preventive $1,250 Negotiated Fee Schedule Negotiated Fee Schedule Negotiated Fee Schedule DentalGuard Alliance DentalGuard Preferred None 100% 100% 100% w Oral Exams (twice/12 mos.) w Cleanings (twice/12 mos.) w X-Rays (Full-mouth series once/60 mos.) w Fluoride Treatment (to age 19, twice/12 mos.) w Sealants (to age 16, once/36 mos.) w Space Maintainers/Harmful Habit Appliances Coinsurance - Basic 100% 90% 80% w Fillings w Perio Maintenance Procedure (twice/12 mos.) w Periodontal Services (eg Scaling and Root Planing) w Periodontal Surgery w Simple Extractions w Complex Extractions w Endodontic Services (eg. Root Canal) Coinsurance - Major 100% 60% 50% w Bridges & Dentures w Single Crowns w Repair & Maintenance of Crowns, Bridges & Dentures w General Anesthesia w Inlays, Onlays & Veneers Coinsurance - Orthodontia Orthodontia Lifetime Maximum Dependent Age Limits Waiting Periods Plan Type & Code 50% for children (Orthodontia in Progress - covered) $1,500 $1,500 To Age 26 None Freedom Plan (I5E3) PLAN HIGHLIGHTS Strong Network Coverage Nationwide • Guardian's DentalGuard Preferred network is the #2 network nationally and we're growing fast. In many parts of the country, Guardian offers more providers than any other network (Netminder, 3/12). • Guardian has over 100,000 dentists at more than 256,000 locations. • Network dentists charge discounted fees - savings average 34%. • Guardian has an easy to use provider online search. Just visit GuardianLife.com and select 'Find a Provider'. (continued) Valid from 06/01/15 to 06/15/15 Tracking Code# 00160409662-03 Page 6 of 20 Desert Recreation District John Henry Garcia Dental PLAN HIGHLIGHTS (continued) Guardian Freedom Plan • The Guardian Freedom plan helps employers more actively manage plan costs. This plan allows employees to choose between: • DentalGuard Alliance (More Savings): This smaller network offers greater discounts on dental care and richer benefits with more procedures covered in full. • DentalGuard Preferred (More Choice): One of the nation's largest networks, DentalGuard Preferred dentists offer discounts averaging 30%. • Out-of-Network (More Freedom): While in-network dentists provide the most value, members can see any dentist they want without being penalized. Depending on plan design, they will be reimbursed at UCR or set fee schedule. • This choice makes the Guardian Freedom Plan one of the most flexible dental programs ever devised. Even better, employees don't have to decide which network to use when they enroll. They can go in-network to get the most value from the plan, or go to any dentist outside the network and still get Guardian Freedom benefits. International Dental Travel Assistance • While traveling internationally, Guardian members can get a referral to a local dentist for immediate dental care through the International Dental Travel Assistance Program. This service is available 24/7, in over 200 countries. Coverage will be considered under the out-of-network benefits. • International Dental Travel Assistance services are administered by AXA Assistance USA, Inc. AXA Assistance is not affiliated with Guardian Life Insurance, and the services they provide are separate and apart from the benefits provided by Guardian Life Insurance. IMPORTANT NOTES Rates and Premiums were determined using a census of eligible employees and dependents. Final rates and premiums are based on the plan and employee/dependent data provided on the enrollment forms. State specific requirements apply. • We reserve the right to adjust rates if actual participation is below assumed level. We also reserve the right to adjust rates if there is an average of more than 4 children per dependent unit (EE+CH or FAM). • We reserve the right to withdraw this proposal if actual employee participation is below the greater of 25% or 5 enrolled employees. This requirement does not apply to any pre-paid dental plans quoted. • Cleanings and Perio Maintenance Procedures share the frequency. Limited to a total of two cleanings or two perio maintenance procedures in any 12 consecutive month period. • If your plan includes Section 125/Flex Plan, open enrollment must be held the month prior to the renewal/anniversary date. • Orthodontia, when covered, is for dependent children who are less than age 19 when active appliance is first placed. Please see the Summary of Plan Limitations and Exclusions that appears either on this page or the last page of this coverage. SUMMARY OF PLAN LIMITATIONS AND EXCLUSIONS • Coverage is limited to charges that are necessary to prevent, diagnose or treat dental disease, defect or injury. Depending on plan type, deductibles, waiting periods, per service frequency limitations, and payment limits may apply. • The list of dental services shown is not exhaustive. • This coverage will not be effective until approved by a Guardian underwriter. Please refer to certificate of coverage for full plan description. This plan does not pay for: • Any restoration procedure, appliance or dental prosthesis used solely to: a) alter vertical dimension; b) restore or maintain occlusion, except to the extent that this plan covers orthodontic treatment; c) splint or stabilize teeth for periodontal reasons; or d) treat a condition caused by abrasion or attrition. • Cosmetic or experimental treatments, unless specifically listed in the BENEFIT DETAIL section of this proposal as a covered cosmetic service. • Replacing a lost, stolen or missing appliance or prosthetic device; or making a spare appliance or device. • Treatment needed due to: a) an on-the-job or job-related injury; or b) a condition for which benefits are payable by Workers' Compensation or similar laws. • Replacing an appliance or prosthetic device with a like appliance or device, unless: a) it is damaged while in the covered person's mouth in an injury suffered while insured, and can't be fixed; or b) can't be made usable and meets the replacement age criteria selected by the employer. • Treatment for which no charge is made. • The replacement of extracted or missing third molars/wisdom teeth. • Treatment of congenital or developmental malformations, or the replacement of congenitally missing teeth. • Evaluations and consultations for non-covered services; detailed and extensive oral evaluations. • Any procedure performed in conjunction with, as part of, or related to a non-covered procedure. • Any procedure not specifically listed as a covered benefit. • GP-1-DG2000 et al. • Guardian Dental is underwritten by The Guardian Life Insurance Company of America, New York, NY. Products are not available in all states. Policy limitations and exclusions apply. Optional riders and/or features may incur additional costs. Plan documents are the final arbiter of coverage. Valid from 06/01/15 to 06/15/15 Tracking Code# 00160409662-03 Page 7 of 20 Desert Recreation District John Henry Garcia Vision RATES All Eligible Employees Employee Employee & Spouse Employee & Child(ren) Full Family Monthly Premium Annual Premium $7.85 $13.22 $13.48 $21.33 $504.73 $6,056.76 11 6 3 14 Monthly Rate Census Rate Guarantee 1 Year Proposal Assumptions: • *Package Sale: Life, Voluntary Life, Dental & Vision + one supplemental line (CI, Accident or Cancer) BENEFITS All Eligible Employees Contribution/Participation Voluntary, Assumes 91% of eligible employees. Vision is sold with Dental. Dependent Age Limits To Age 26 Network/Plan VSP/Full Feature - Choice B Copay Split(Exams/Materials) $10/$25 SERVICE FREQUENCIES Once Every: Eye Exams Calendar Year Lenses Benefit Calendar Year Contact Lenses Calendar Year Frames Other Calendar Year REIMBURSEMENT SCHEDULE In Network (Copay) Out Network (After Copay) $10 $39 max Single Vision $25 $23 max Bifocal $25 $37 max Trifocal $25 $49 max Lenticular $25 $64 max Covered after copay $210 max $130 max (Copay waived) $100 max (Copay waived) $130 retail max + 20% off balance $46 max Eye Exams Benefit Lenses Benefit Contact Lenses Benefit** Medically Necessary Elective Frames Benefit **In lieu of complete set of glasses PLAN HIGHLIGHTS • Guardian's affiliation with Vision Service Plan (VSP) offers one of the largest vision care networks in the industry with over 50,000 provider locations nationwide. On average 95% of members use an in-network provider. Just visit GuardianLife.com and select 'Find a Provider'. • Guardian's affiliation with Vision Service Plan (VSP) Choice Network offers access to over 50,000 provider locations nationwide which is a lower cost plan with higher out of pocket costs for the members compared to a Signature Plan. On average 95% of members use an in network provider. Just visit GuardianLife.com and select 'Find a Provider'. • Choice plans offer 20% off any additional pairs of glasses purchased within 12 months of the exam. Members also receive 20% off the amount exceeding the copay and allowance on frames purchased as well as 15% off providers' professional services for prescription contact lenses. These discounts only apply to services from an in network provider. (continued) Valid from 06/01/15 to 06/15/15 Tracking Code# 00160409662-03 Page 8 of 20 Desert Recreation District John Henry Garcia Vision PLAN HIGHLIGHTS (continued) • With our Choice plans, members will receive significant discounts on lens options, discounts will range from 20-25% off the U&C. For example, standard progressive plastic lenses will cost the member $55 and scratch resistant coating will cost $17. Solid tints and dyes are covered in full. IMPORTANT NOTES Rates and premiums are based on the employee data submitted. Final rates and premiums are based on the plan and employee/dependent data provided on the enrollment forms. State specific requirements apply. • The covered person must remain enrolled until the plan's next vision annual open enrollment period. Someone who waives or drops coverage can't enroll until the plan's next vision annual open enrollment period. These requirements do not apply if the vision plan is sold on a noncontributory basis or if enrollment is tied-to a dental or medical plan. • If an employee has employee/spouse vision coverage and the spouse obtains new employment and elects vision coverage with the new employer, Guardian lock-in does not apply to that spouse and the spouse is free to move with no negative impact. • If an employee has employee/spouse vision coverage and both the employee and spouse elect to move over to the spouse's new employer's vision plan, again, Guardian lock-in does not apply to either spouse or employee. • If an employee gets married and wishes to go on the new spouse's plan, the member may decline outside of open enrollment only if the member actually goes on the new spouse's plan. • We reserve the right to adjust rates if actual participation is below assumed level. We reserve the right to withdraw this proposal if actual participation is below 25%. Please see the Summary of Plan Limitations and Exclusions that appears either on this page or the last page of this coverage. SUMMARY OF PLAN LIMITATIONS AND EXCLUSIONS • Coverage is limited to those charges that are necessary to prevent, diagnose and treat a vision condition. • For a calendar year plan A or B, if a member purchases contact lenses they must wait 2 calendar years to purchase frames. • Members cannot bank unused allowance amounts for future use, they must use their allowance during the same office visit. The plan does not pay for: • Orthoptics or vision training and any associated supplemental testing. • Medical or surgical treatment of the eye. • Eye examination or corrective eyewear required by an employer as a condition of employment. • Lenses and frames furnished under this plan, which are lost or broken (except when services are otherwise available). • The plan limits benefits for blended lenses, oversized lenses, photochromic lenses, coated or laminated lenses, a frame that exceeds plan allowance, cosmetic lenses, U-V protected lenses, and optional cosmetic processes. • Medically necessary contact lenses are covered only if needed: (1) after cataract surgery; (2) to correct extreme visual acuity problems that cannot be corrected with eyeglasses; (3) for certain conditions of Anisometropia; or (4) for Keratoconus. • The services, exclusions and limitations listed above do not constitute a contract and are a summary only. • GP-1-VSN-96-1 et al. Valid from 06/01/15 to 06/15/15 Tracking Code# 00160409662-03 Page 9 of 20 Desert Recreation District John Henry Garcia Critical Illness MONTHLY PREMIUM Employee Benefit Amounts <20 20-24 25-29 30-34 35-39 40-44 45-49 50-54 55-59 60-64 65+ $5,000 $3.49 $4.01 $4.64 $5.49 $6.81 $9.25 $13.05 $18.13 $24.48 $33.82 $49.81 $10,000 $5.84 $6.71 $7.79 $9.44 $12.11 $16.95 $24.45 $34.48 $46.93 $65.12 $95.61 $15,000 $8.19 $9.41 $10.94 $13.39 $17.41 $24.65 $35.85 $50.83 $69.38 $96.42 $141.41 $20,000 $10.54 $12.11 $14.09 $17.34 $22.71 $32.35 $47.25 $67.18 $91.83 $127.72 $187.21 $25,000 $12.89 $14.81 $17.24 $21.29 $28.01 $40.05 $58.65 $83.53 $114.28 $159.02 $233.01 Spouse Benefit Amounts <20 20-24 25-29 30-34 35-39 40-44 45-49 50-54 55-59 60-64 65+ $1,000 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 Child (ren) $1,000 Rate Guarantee 1 Year Eligible Lives 34 Premiums Premiums listed are for Issue Age and will not increase due to an insured aging Underwriting Requirements Employee <70 Spouse <70 Child (ren) Employee 70+ Spouse 70+ Conditional Issue Health questions are required for all amounts. Health questions are required for all amounts. All child amounts are guaranteed Health questions required. Health questions required. BENEFITS All Eligible Employees Contribution/ Participation Voluntary/Minimum of 5 enrolled employees. Employee Critical Illness Benefit Amounts Employee may choose a lump sum benefit of $5,000 to $25,000 in increments of $5,000 Dependent Critical Illness Benefit Amount Spouse: $1,000 Lump Sum Benefit Child: $1,000 Lump Sum Benefit Covered Conditions (lump sum payments) Condition First Ever Occurrence Second Ever Occurrence Invasive Cancer: 100% 50% Heart Attack 100% 50% Kidney Failure 100% 50% Stroke 100% 50% Carcinoma In Situ 25% 0% Total Amount Payable During an insured's lifetime, this plan will not pay more than 300% of the lump sum benefit for all critical illnesses combined Critical Illness Benefit Waiting Period 30 days starting on the insured’s effective date for this coverage Hospital Admission Benefit Provides $50 per day for each day employee is hospitalized for a condition other than the critical illnesses listed above, 10 day per year limit after a 2 day elimination period Dependent Hospital Admission Benefit Spouse: $50 per day benefit Child: $50 per day benefit Dependent Age Limits 0 days to 26 years (26 if full time student) Pre-Existing Condition Limitation 3 month look back period, 12 month exclusion period (continued) Valid from 06/01/15 to 06/15/15 Tracking Code# 00160409662-03 Page 10 of 20 Desert Recreation District John Henry Garcia Critical Illness BENEFITS (continued) All Eligible Employees Benefit Reduction (of original amount) Age 65 70 75 80 Reduction 35% 60% 75% 85% PLAN HIGHLIGHTS • Guardian’s Critical Illness Product provides ability for an insured to receive a lump sum benefit payment upon first ever and second ever diagnosis of any qualified Critical Illnesses listed under covered conditions. • Benefits are paid directly to the insured when they need it most. Expenditure for claim proceeds are not limited to cover medical expenses, funds can be used under the discretion of the insured for things such as childcare, transportation and to fill in gaps in their medical plan, like co-pays and deductibles. • An insured must port Critical Illness coverage prior to age 70. • An insured must port Specified Disease coverage prior to age 70. • The Hospital Admission Benefit pays a daily benefit for each day an employee is hospitalized for a condition other than the covered critical illness. IMPORTANT NOTES Rates and premiums are based on the employee data submitted. Final rates and premiums are based on the plan and employee/dependent data provided on the enrollment forms. States specific requirements apply. Rates Notes • These rates are contingent upon Critical Illness being purchased with another Guardian coverage. • Spouse rate is based on employee's age bracket. Child rate is for all children. Dependent Critical Illness insurance will not take effect if a dependent, other than a newborn, is confined to the hospital or other health care facility or is unable to perform the normal activities of someone of like age and sex. Benefits Notes • Major Organ Transplant & Coronary Artery Bypass Graft are not covered conditions under the Critical Illness benefit of your policy. To constitute this Critical Illness policy as a permitted insurance in conjunction with a Health Savings Account (refer to IRS code 223), these conditions were excluded. This means that insureds who are covered by this Critical Illness benefit and who are otherwise eligible to contribute to a Health Savings Account (HSA) remain eligible to make HSA contributions. • Flat dependent benefits are standardly limited to 50% of the employee benefit. • The policy has exclusions and limitations that may impact the eligibility for or entitlement to benefits under each covered condition. See the actual policy or contact your sales representative for full details. • Employees age 70 & older must answer health questions for all amounts. • The applicant will be required to answer health questions in order to qualify for coverage. SUMMARY OF PLAN LIMITATIONS AND EXCLUSIONS • The policy has exclusions and limitations that may impact the eligibility for or entitlement to benefits under each covered condition. There are limitations & special requirements for each condition. See the certificate of coverage or contact your sales representative for full details. • We do not pay benefits for a first ever occurrence of a critical illness that occurs less than 3 months after the first ever occurrence of a different critical illness for which this plan paid benefits. • We do not pay benefits for a second ever occurrence of a critical illness if the insured has exhibited symptoms or received treatment for that critical illness within the past 12 months (care or treatment does not include: (a) preventive medications in the absence of disease; and (b) routine scheduled follow-up visits to a doctor.) • First ever & second ever occurrence refers to the first & second time ever in an insured's lifetime that he/she experiences or is diagnosed with a covered critical illness. • We do not pay benefits for a third or later occurrence of a Critical Illness. • A pre-existing condition includes any condition for which an employee, in the three month period prior to coverage in this plan, consults with a physician or receives treatment. Please refer to the plan documents for specific time periods. State variations may apply. • If the plan is new (not transferred): During the exclusion period, this Critical Illness plan does not pay charges relating to a pre-existing condition. If this plan is transferred from another insurance carrier, the time an insured is covered under that plan will count toward satisfying Guardian's pre-existing condition limitation period. Please refer to the plan details for specific time periods. State variations may apply. • We do not pay benefits for charges relating to a covered person: taking part in any war or act of war (including service in the armed forces) committing a felony or taking part in any riot or other civil disorder or intentionally injuring themselves or attempting suicide while sane or insane. • In order to be elibigle for coverage: Employees must be legally working: (a) in the United States or (b) outside the United States, for a US based employer, in a country or region approved by Guardian. Subject to state specific variations. • Employees must be working full-time on the effective date of coverage; otherwise, coverage becomes effective after the completion of the specific waiting period. (continued) Valid from 06/01/15 to 06/15/15 Tracking Code# 00160409662-03 Page 11 of 20 Desert Recreation District John Henry Garcia Critical Illness SUMMARY OF PLAN LIMITATIONS AND EXCLUSIONS (continued) • Health questions are required on all late enrollees, Benefit increases may require underwriting. • This coverage will not be effective until approved by a Guardian underwriter. This proposal is subject to a satsfactory financial evaluation. Please refer to certificate of coverage for full plan description; plan documents are the final arbiter of coverage. Valid from 06/01/15 to 06/15/15 Tracking Code# 00160409662-03 Page 12 of 20 Desert Recreation District John Henry Garcia Accident MONTHLY RATES Plan #1 Plan #2 Plan #3 Employee $13.59 $18.04 $22.10 Employee & Spouse $22.31 $29.63 $36.31 Employee & Child $23.08 $30.48 $37.14 Family $31.80 $42.07 $51.35 Census 34 34 34 Rate Guarantee 2 Years 2 Years 2 Years Plan #1 Plan #2 Plan #3 All Eligible Employees All Eligible Employees All Eligible Employees Value Plan Advantage Plan Premier Plan Voluntary / 5 enrolled employees Voluntary / 5 enrolled employees Voluntary / 5 enrolled employees BENEFITS Schedule Contribution/Participation Accident Coverage Off Job Off Job Off Job Included without Evidence Included without Evidence Included without Evidence Child(ren) Age Limits Birth to 26 years (26 if full time student), subject to state limitations Birth to 26 years (26 if full time student), subject to state limitations Birth to 26 years (26 if full time student), subject to state limitations Accident Emergency Treatment $150 $175 $200 $25 up to 6 treatments $50 up to 6 treatments $75 up to 6 treatments Air Ambulance $500 $1,000 $1,500 Ambulance $100 $150 $200 Appliance $100 $125 $125 $300 $300 $300 9 sq inches to 18 sq inches: $0/$2,000 18 sq inches to 35 sq inches: $1,000/$4,000 Over 35 sq inches: $3,000/$12,000 9 sq inches to 18 sq inches: $0/$2,000 18 sq inches to 35 sq inches: $1,000/$4,000 Over 35 sq inches: $3,000/$12,000 9 sq inches to 18 sq inches: $0/$2,000 18 sq inches to 35 sq inches: $1,000/$4,000 Over 35 sq inches: $3,000/$12,000 Portability Accident Follow-Up Visit Doctor Blood/Plasma/Platelets 2nd 3rd Burns ( Degree/ Degree) Burn – Skin Graft Child Organized Sport Chiropractic Visits Coma 50% of burn benefit 50% of burn benefit 50% of burn benefit 20% increase to child benefits 20% increase to child benefits 20% increase to child benefits No Benefit $25 per visit up to 6 visits $50 per visit up to 6 visits $7,500 $10,000 $12,500 Concussions $50 $75 $100 Dislocations Schedule up to $3,600 Schedule up to $4,400 Schedule up to $4,800 Diagnostic Exam (Major) $100 $150 $200 Emergency Dental Work $200/Crown $50/Extraction $300/Crown $75/Extraction $400/Crown $100/Extraction Epidural Pain Management $100, 2 times per accident $100, 2 times per accident $100, 2 times per accident $200 $300 $300 Family Care $20/day up to 30 days $20/day up to 30 days $20/day up to 30 days Fracture Schedule up to $4,500 Schedule up to $5,500 Schedule up to $6,000 Eye Injury Hospital Admission $750 $1,000 $1,250 $175/day – up to 1 year $225/day – up to 1 year $250/day – up to 1 year $1,500 $2,000 $2,500 Hospital ICU Confinement $350/day – up to 15 days $450/day – up to 15 days $500/day – up to 15 days Initial Physician’s office/Urgent Care Facility Treatment $50 $75 $100 Hospital Confinement Hospital ICU Admission (continued) Valid from 06/01/15 to 06/15/15 Tracking Code# 00160409662-03 Page 13 of 20 Desert Recreation District John Henry Garcia Accident BENEFITS (continued) Plan #1 Plan #2 Plan #3 All Eligible Employees All Eligible Employees All Eligible Employees $500 $500 $750 $1,500/$750/$750 $2,500/$1,250/$1,250 $3,500/$1,750/$1,750 Schedule up to $300 Schedule up to $400 Schedule up to $500 $100/day, up to 30 days for companion hotel stay $125/day, up to 30 days for companion hotel stay $150/day, up to 30 days for companion hotel stay $25/day up to 10 days $25/day up to 10 days $35/day up to 10 days 1: $500 2 or more: $1,000 1: $500 2 or more: $1,000 1: $750 2 or more: $1,500 $150/day up to 15 days $150/day up to 15 days $150/day up to 15 days $500 $500 $750 Schedule up to $1,000 Hernia: $125 Schedule up to $1,250 Hernia: $150 Schedule up to $1,500 Hernia: $200 Surgery – Exploratory or Arthroscopic $150 $250 $350 Tendon/Ligament/Rotator Cuff 1: $250 2 or more: $500 1: $500 2 or more: $1000 1: $750 2 or more: $1500 $400, 3 times per accident $500, 3 times per accident $600, 3 times per accident $20 $30 $40 Knee Cartilage Joint Replacement (hip/knee/shoulder) Laceration Lodging Occupational or Physical Therapy Prosthetic Device/Artificial Limb Rehabilitation Unit Confinement Ruptured Disc with Surgical Repair Surgery (Cranial, Open Abdominal, Thoracic) Transportation X-Ray PLAN HIGHLIGHTS • No underwriting required. IMPORTANT NOTES The benefits listed are payable if the service, treatment or procedure is due to injuries incurred in a covered accident. • Appliance - Benefit is paid if a wheelchair, leg or back brace, crutches, walker, walking boot that extends above the ankle or brace for the neck is prescribed by a physician as necessary due to an injury sustained as the result of a covered accident. • Child Organized Sport - Benefit is paid if the covered accident occurred while your covered child is participating in an organized sport that is governed by an organization and requires formal registration to participate. This benefit is only payable if child coverage is included on the plan. • Family Care - Benefit is payable for each child attending a Child Care center while the insured is confined to the hospital, ICU or Alternate Care or Rehabilitative facility due to injuries sustained in a covered accident. • Lodging - Benefit is paid for a companion’s hotel stay while the insured is confined to the hospital as the result of a covered accident. The hospital must be more than 50 miles from the insured’s residence. • Transportation - Benefit is paid if you have to travel more than 50 miles one way to receive special treatment at a hospital or facility due to a covered accident. SUMMARY OF PLAN LIMITATIONS AND EXCLUSIONS • Employees must be legally working in the United States in order to be eligible for coverage. Underwriting must approve coverage for employees on temporary assignment: (a) exceeding 1 year ; or (b) in an area under travel warning by the US Department of State, subject to state specific variations. • This proposal summarizes the major features of the Guardian Accident benefit plan. It is not intended to be a complete representation of the proposed plan. For full plan features, including exclusions and limitations, please refer to your Policy. • This proposal is hedged subject to satisfactory financial evaluation. This plan will not pay benefits for any injury caused by or related to: • Declared or undeclared war, act of war, or armed aggression; taking part in a riot or civil disorder; or commission of, or attempt to commit a felony; Intentionally self inflicted injury, while sane or insane; suicide or attempted suicide, while sane or insane. • The covered person being legally intoxicated. • Treatment rendered or hospital confinement outside the United States or Canada. • Travel or flight in any kind of aircraft, including any aircraft owned by or for the employer except as a fare-paying passenger on a common carrier. (continued) Valid from 06/01/15 to 06/15/15 Tracking Code# 00160409662-03 Page 14 of 20 Desert Recreation District John Henry Garcia Accident SUMMARY OF PLAN LIMITATIONS AND EXCLUSIONS (continued) • • • • • • • Participation in any kind of sporting activity for compensation or profit, including coaching or officiating. Riding in or driving any motor-driven vehicle in a race, stunt show or speed test. Participation in hang gliding, bungee jumping, sailgliding, parasailing, parakiting, ballooning, parachuting, and/or skydiving. Job related or on the job injuries. Injuries to a dependent child received during the birth. An accident that occurred before the covered person is covered by this plan. Sickness, disease, mental infirmity or medical or surgical treatment. Policy #: GP-1-AC-IC-12. Guardian's Accident Insurance is underwritten and issued by The Guardian Life Insurance Company of America, New York, NY. Products are not available in all states. Policy limitations and exclusions apply. Optional riders and/or features may incur additional costs. Plan documents are the final arbiter of coverage. Valid from 06/01/15 to 06/15/15 Tracking Code# 00160409662-03 Page 15 of 20 Desert Recreation District John Henry Garcia Cancer MONTHLY RATES Plan #1 Plan #2 Plan #3 Employee $13.09 $22.14 $34.60 Employee & Spouse $25.42 $42.43 $66.24 Employee & Child $14.92 $24.95 $38.58 Full Family $27.25 $45.24 $70.22 34 34 34 2 Years 2 Years 2 Years Conditional Underwriting required Conditional Underwriting required Conditional Underwriting required Census Rate Guarantee Issue Underwriting BENEFITS Plan #1 Plan #2 Plan #3 All Eligible Employees All Eligible Employees All Eligible Employees Value Advantage Premier Voluntary / 5 enrolled employees Voluntary / 5 enrolled employees Voluntary / 5 enrolled employees Included without Evidence Included without Evidence Included without Evidence Birth to 26 years (26 if full time student), subject to state limitations Birth to 26 years (26 if full time student), subject to state limitations Birth to 26 years (26 if full time student), subject to state limitations 12 month look back period, 12 month exclusion period 12 month look back period, 12 month exclusion period 12 month look back period, 12 month exclusion period $250/trip, limit 2 trips per hospital confinement $1,500/trip, limit 2 trips per hospital confinement $2,000/trip, limit 2 trips per hospital confinement No Benefit No Benefit $50/visit up to 20 visits Ambulance $200/trip, limit 2 trips per hospital confinement $200/trip, limit 2 trips per hospital confinement $250/trip, limit 2 trips per hospital confinement Anesthesia 25% of surgery benefit 25% of surgery benefit 25% of surgery benefit Schedule Contribution/Participation Portability Child(ren) Age Limits Pre-Existing Condition Limitation Air Ambulance Alternative Care Anti-Nausea No Benefit $50/day up to $150 per month $50/day up to $250 per month $25/day while hospital confined. Limit 75 visits. $25/day while hospital confined. Limit 75 visits. $25/day while hospital confined. Limit 75 visits. Blood/Plasma/Platelets $50/day up to $5,000 per year $100/day up to $5,000 per year $200/day up to $10,000 per year Bone Marrow/Stem Cell No Benefit Bone Marrow: $7,500 Stem Cell: $1,500 nd 50% benefit for 2 transplant $1,000 benefit if a donor Bone Marrow: $10,000 Stem Cell: $2,500 nd 50% benefit for 2 transplant $1,500 benefit if a donor Experimental Treatment No Benefit $100/day up to $1,000/month $200/day up to $2,400/month Government or Charity Hospital No Benefit $300/day in lieu of all other benefits $400/day in lieu of all other benefits Hormone Therapy $25/Treatment up to 12 treatments per year $25/Treatment up to 12 treatments per year $50/Treatment up to 12 treatments per year Hospital Confinement $300/day for first 30 days; $300/day for first 30 days; $400/day for first 30 days; $600/day for 31st day thereafter per $600/day for 31st day thereafter per $800/day for 31st day thereafter per confinement confinement confinement ICU Confinement $400/day for first 30 days; $400/day for first 30 days; $600/day for first 30 days; $600/day for 31st day thereafter per $600/day for 31st day thereafter per $800/day for 31st day thereafter per confinement confinement confinement Attending Physician Immunotherapy $500 per month $2500 lifetime max $500 per month $2500 lifetime max $500 per month $2500 lifetime max Inpatient Special Nursing No Benefit $100/day up to 30 days per year $150/day up to 30 days per year Medical Imaging No Benefit $100/image up to 2 per year $200/image up to 2 per year Outpatient or Ambulatory Surgical Center No Benefit $250/day, 3 days per procedure $350/day, 3 days per procedure (continued) Valid from 06/01/15 to 06/15/15 Tracking Code# 00160409662-03 Page 16 of 20 Desert Recreation District John Henry Garcia Cancer BENEFITS (continued) Plan #1 Plan #2 Plan #3 All Eligible Employees All Eligible Employees All Eligible Employees Outpatient and Family Member Lodging No Benefit $75/day, up to 90 days per year $100/day, up to 90 days per year Physical or Speech Therapy No Benefit $25/visit up to 4 visits per month, $400 lifetime max $50/visit up to 4 visits per month, $1,000 lifetime max Prosthetic Surgically Implanted: $2,000/device, $4,000 lifetime max Non-Surgically: $200/device, $400 lifetime max Surgically Implanted: $2,000/device, $4,000 lifetime max Non-Surgically: $200/device, $400 lifetime max Surgically Implanted: $3,000/device, $6,000 lifetime max Non-Surgically: $300/device, $600 lifetime max Radiation Therapy Chemotherapy Schedule amounts up to a $4,000 benefit year maximum Schedule amounts up to a $4,000 benefit year maximum Schedule amounts up to a $12,000 benefit year maximum Reconstructive Surgery No Benefit Breast TRAM Flap $2,000 Breast reconstruction $500 Breast Symmetry $250 Facial reconstruction $500 Breast TRAM $3,000 Breast reconstruction $700 Breast Symmetry $350 Facial reconstruction $700 Reproductive Benefit No Benefit No Benefit $1500 egg harvesting, $500 egg or sperm storage, $2,000 lifetime max $200/surgical procedure $200/surgical procedure $300/surgical procedure Biopsy Only: $100 Reconstructive Surgery: $250 Excision of a skin cancer: $375 Excision of a skin cancer with flap or graft: $600 Biopsy Only: $100 Reconstructive Surgery: $250 Excision of a skin cancer: $375 Excision of a skin cancer with flap or graft: $600 Biopsy Only: $100 Reconstructive Surgery: $250 Excision of a skin cancer: $375 Excision of a skin cancer with flap or graft: $600 Schedule amount up to $2,750 Schedule amount up to $4,125 Schedule amount up to $5,500 No Benefit $0.50/mile up to $1,000 per round trip/equal benefit for companion $0.50/mile up to $1,500 per round trip/equal benefit for companion Included Included Included Second Surgical Opinion Skin Cancer Surgical Benefit Transportation/Companion Transportation Waiver of Premium IMPORTANT NOTES Please see the Summary of Plan Limitations and Exclusions that appears either on this page or the last page of this coverage. • Cancer means an insured has been diagnosed with a disease manifested by the presence of a malignant tumor characterized by the uncontrolled growth and spread of malignant cells in any part of the body. This includes leukemia, Hodgkin's disease, lymphoma, sarcoma, malignant tumors and melanoma. Cancer includes carcinomas in-situ (in the natural or normal place, confined to the site of origin, without having invaded neighboring tissue). Pre-malignant conditions or conditions with malignant potential, such as myelodyplastic and myeloproliferative disorders, carcinoid, leukoplakia, hyperplasia, actinic keratosis, polycythemia, and nonmalignant melanoma, moles or similar diseases or lesions will not be considered cancer. Cancer must be diagnosed while insured is under the Guardian Cancer plan. • Alternative Care - Benefit is paid for palliative care (bio-feedback or hypnosis) or lifestyle benefits such as visits to an accredited practitioner for smoking cessation, yoga, meditation, relaxation techniques and nutritional counseling. • Blood/Plasma/Platelets - Benefit is paid each day you receive blood, plasma and/or platelets for the treatment of internal cancer. • Experimental Treatment - Benefits will be paid for experimental treatment prescribed by a doctor for the purpose of destroying or changing abnormal tissue. All treatment must be NCI listed as viable experimental treatment for Internal Cancer. • Outpatient and Family Member Lodging - Benefit is paid if you stay in a hotel while receiving treatment for internal cancer and treatment cannot be obtained locally. A benefit is also payable if a family member stays in a hotel while you are confined in a hospital for internal cancer treatment. Lodging must be more than 50 miles from your home. • Transportation/Companion Transportation - Benefit is paid if you have to travel more than 50 miles one way to receive treatment for internal cancer. • Waiver of Premium - If you become disabled due to cancer that is diagnosed after the employee’s effective date, and you remain disabled for 90 days, we will waive the premium due after such 90 days for as long as you remain disabled. Unless otherwise noted, the benefits listed are payable if the service or treatment is due to the insured’s diagnosis of cancer while covered. SUMMARY OF PLAN LIMITATIONS AND EXCLUSIONS • Conditional Underwriting is one medical question as a part of the enrollment form. • State variations may apply. • A pre-existing condition includes any condition for which an employee, in the specified time period prior to coverage in this plan, consults with a physician, receives treatment, or takes prescribed drugs. Please refer to the plan documents for specific time periods. State variations may apply. (continued) Valid from 06/01/15 to 06/15/15 Tracking Code# 00160409662-03 Page 17 of 20 Desert Recreation District John Henry Garcia Cancer SUMMARY OF PLAN LIMITATIONS AND EXCLUSIONS (continued) • This plan will not pay benefits for (state variations may apply): • Services or treatment not included in the Schedule of Insurance. • Services or treatment provided by a family member. • Services or treatment rendered for hospital confinement outside the United States. • Any cancer diagnosed solely outside of the United States. • Services or treatment provided primarily for cosmetic purposes. • Services or treatment for non-cancer sicknesses. • Cancer arising from war or act of war, even if war is not declared. Guardian's Cancer Insurance is underwritten and issued by The Guardian Life Insurance Company of America, New York, NY. Products are not available in all states. Policy limitations and exclusions apply. Optional riders and/or features may incur additional costs. Plan documents are the final arbiter of coverage. Contract #: GP-1-CAN-IC-12 Valid from 06/01/15 to 06/15/15 Tracking Code# 00160409662-03 Page 18 of 20 Desert Recreation District John Henry Garcia Employee Assistance Plan (EAP) WORKLIFE MATTERSsm Comprehensive Employee Assistance Program sm 1 WorkLife Matters , Guardian’s comprehensive Employee Assistance Program (EAP) is available at no cost to groups purchasing three or more 2 sm of Guardian’s Group products! With WorkLife Matters , employees can receive expert support services to assist them and their families with a variety of life issues from family care, stress, depression, or addiction. In today’s environment, addressing work-life balance issues is more important than ever. Not only will employers be providing a program that employees will appreciate, they will also be helping to ensure a productive workplace. Key Employer Services • Employers can receive expert support service to assist in implementing a Drug-Free Workplace Program. • Managers and supervisors will have access to human resource consultants to address workplace issues, including performance problems. Key Employee Services • Unlimited Telephonic Counseling through a convenient toll-free number. Up to three face-to-face visits per family member, per year, with a doctoral psychologist or other behavioral health professional. • Variable resources to assist persons who are facing life challenges such as locating childcare, providing elder care, planning for adoption or learning about pregnancy or child development. • A comprehensive, online database including information on everyday home and family issues – accessible twenty-four hours a day, seven days a week. • Financial consultation for insureds and their beneficiaries who receive a death benefit of $50,000 or more, or are receiving Long-Term Disability payments. The purpose is to educate the beneficiaries on options available to protect the benefit received; no solicitation is done. • Unlimited legal advice by telephone, referral to a local attorney for a free 30 minute session, and any additional legal service at a 25% 3 discount. These services may include, but are not limited to real estate living wills and estate and probate law. sm See for yourself how WorkLife Matters can complete your group’s benefit package. Call your Guardian Group Benefits Expert today for more information or visit www.guardianlife.com 1 sm WorkLife Matters is administered by Integrated Behavioral Health, an independent national employee assistance program. 2 Available at no cost if three or more qualified Guardian Group products are purchased and if at least one of these products is employer sponsored with 75% participation. 3 WillPrep Services are provided by Integrated Behavioral Health, Inc., and its contractors. The Guardian Life Insurance Company of America (Guardian) does not provide any part of WillPrep Services. Guardian is not responsible or liable for care or advice given by any provider or resource under the program. This information is for illustrative purposes only. It is not a contract. Only the Administration Agreement can provide the actual terms, services, limitations and exclusions. Guardian and IBH reserve the right to discontinue the WillPrep Services at any time without notice. Legal services will not be provided in connection with or preparation for any action against Guardian, IBH, or your employer. Rates and premiums are based on the employee data submitted. Final rates and premiums are based on the plan and employee/dependent data provided on the enrollment forms. Valid from 06/01/15 to 06/15/15 Tracking Code# 00160409662-03 Page 19 of 20 Desert Recreation District John Henry Garcia College Tuition Benefit® Rewards Employees now have an added incentive to participate in Guardian’s Dental Plan. Employees can earn Tuition Rewards that can be used to pay up to one year’s tuition at over 330 SAGE Scholar private colleges and universities across the nation. That’s one third of the National Association of Independent Colleges and Universities (NAICU). 80% of SAGE colleges have received an “America’s Best” ranking in US News and World Report. One Tuition Reward point = 1 USD. What you can expect from the College Tuition Benefit? • 2,000 Tuition Rewards® are given to each Guardian plan subscriber when he/she registers an eligible student or students. Subscriber Tuition Rewards® can be allocated to any registered student. • 500 Tuition Rewards are given to each student registered. Student Tuition Rewards® can only be used by the specific registered student. • 2,000 additional Tuition Rewards® are given to the subscriber, annually in the month following the Guardian’s Plan’s renewal. • 2,500 bonus Tuition Rewards® are given to the subscriber the month following the Guardian’s Plan’s third renewal (4th year) for a total reward of 4,500 for that year. The example below shows how the program would help a 12 year old in the family of a Guardian dental subscriber. If the registered student attends a participating SAGE Scholar College, the tuition will be reduced by $17,000 spread evenly over four years. College Tuition Benefit® Rewards Policy Year Subscriber Reward* Subscriber’s Reward Balance (balance does not accrue interest) Initial Registration Subscriber and Student Rewards 2,500 (2000+500) 2 2,000 4,500 3 2,000 6,500 4 4,500 (Bonus Year) 11,000 5 2,000 13,000 6 2,000 15,000 7 2,000 17,000 IMPORTANT NOTES • In order to be registered for the College Tuition Benefit: Planholder’s must complete a Planholder Service Agreement and each employee must provide a valid email address. By accepting this optional program you acknowledge that SAGE Scholars Tuition Reward points are discounts applied towards the full tuition cost of SAGE member colleges and universities, and are not cash and do not accrue interest. It will be disclosed to employees that providing a personal user name and password to SAGE CTB LLC and/or SAGE Scholars is authorization for you to provide the employee’s employment status and information essential to the administration of this program. The service fee is $0.33 per employee per month (PEPM), which shall be included in your billed premium amount. Such service fee will be paid to SAGE CBT by Guardian on a monthly basis. • Every Dental plan enrollment, subscribers receive a Welcome email. Check your spam folder. If you do not receive a welcome email contact [email protected] • The welcome email is notification that an online account is established. Subscribers can log in to see the points posted to their account, and add additional eligible students as they wish. If you do not log in to your account in the first 6 months, your Tuition Reward may be reduced. • Eligible students include children, grandchildren, nieces, and nephews. • The maximum rewards you can use, per registered student, cannot exceed one year’s tuition at a participating school. • Families do not select a college ahead of time. • Each Tuesday, registered employees receive Market Cap and Gown, an e-newsletter that details events and topics related to college financing, and notifies employees of new colleges in the network. Deadline dates: • To use Tuition Rewards, a child must be registered by August 24th of the year he/she enters 11th grade. • The Scholarship credits are held in the subscriber’s account until they are pledged to a registered student. When a Subscriber has a registered student in 11th grade, the subscriber will be emailed and asked if he/she wants to pledge some or all of the Tuition Rewards to the Registered Student. If the subscriber wants to use Tuition Rewards, he/she must go online before August 24th of the year the registered student enters 12th grade and transfer Tuition Rewards to that registered student’s account. SUMMARY OF PLAN LIMITATIONS AND EXCLUSIONS • Guardian's Group Dental Insurance is underwritten by The Guardian Life Insurance Company of America (Guardian) or its subsidiaries. • The Tuition Rewards program is provided by College Tuition Benefit. The Guardian Life Insurance Company of America (Guardian) does not provide any services related to this program. College Tuition Benefit is not a subsidiary or an affiliate of Guardian. • To find out more information, go to https://guardian.collegetuitionbenefit.com #2014-15023 Exp. 12/2016 Valid from 06/01/15 to 06/15/15 Tracking Code# 00160409662-03 Page 20 of 20 Healthcare Benefits FY2016 ITEM 10.C DRD Healthcare Benefits FY2016 ▪ Review May 13, 2015 Study Session ▪ Present New Information on Caps and Team Member Polling ▪ Choose Provider - Aetna vs. United Healthcare ▪ Set Employer Contribution to Premium ▪ Approve Staff Recommendation or Provide Alternative Motion DRD Healthcare Benefits FY2016 ▪ Review May 13, 2015 Study Session ▪ ERG Provided an update on impacts of the Affordable Care Act ▪ District is now a small group with under 50 eligible team members ▪ January 2016 small group designation with be under 100 team members ▪ Pricing structure is now based on age – no longer eligible for aggregate pricing. ▪ Premiums are expected to continue to increase at 14-18% per year DRD Healthcare Benefits FY2016 ▪ Review May 13, 2015 Study Session ▪ ERG provided 2 plan options for FY2016 ▪ Carrier choice is limited due to board members receiving benefits ▪ Aetna and United Healthcare are our only choices ▪ Aetna will extend aggregate pricing 1 year with 25% increase to premiums DRD Healthcare Benefits FY2016 Aetna United Healthcare/Guardian ▪ Benefits ▪ Benefits ▪ Less staff time to implement ▪ Flat rate structure ▪ No changes to doctors/dentists ▪ Drawbacks ▪ Higher cost ▪ Short term solution/long term problem ▪ Lower cost ▪ More choice of plans ▪ Sets structure for long term ▪ Drawbacks ▪ More staff time to implement ▪ Employee based premiums ▪ May require changing doctors/dentist DRD Healthcare Benefits FY2016 ▪ Review May 13, 2015 Study Session ▪ Board Requested Items ▪ Poll Team Members for their input regarding health benefits vs. COLA ▪ Look at raising the Employer Contribution Cap From $1,380 to $1,769 ▪ Continue as action item on future agenda DRD Healthcare Benefits FY2016 ▪ New information on Caps and Team Member Polling ▪ Team Member Polling ▪ FT Team Members would like to have an option that provides 100% coverage for themselves and their dependents ▪ FT Team Members believe COLA is important for PT Team Members ▪ PT Team Members want COLA but are not concerned with FT benefits ▪ Grant funded positions do not receive merit – COLA is built in to contracts DRD Healthcare Benefits FY2016 ▪ New information on Caps and Team Member Polling ▪ Team Member/Board Member Goals derived from Polling and Study Session 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 100% Employer paid coverage for Team Member and their dependents Control cost for the District and Team Members Equitable Distribution of Employee contributions if necessary Greatest amount of choice possible FT benefits treated separately from COLA DRD Healthcare Benefits FY2016 ▪ New information on Caps and Team Member Polling ▪ Caps reviewed at $1,380 - $1,500 - $1,769 ▪ Every scenario shows United Healthcare to provide the lowest total cost ▪ Used the premise that each Team Member would maximize buying power without coming out of pocket ▪ No Cap Scenario met 100% of Board/Team Member Goals DRD Healthcare Benefits FY2016 Aetna Renewal HMO Age Coverage 44 EE/CH $ DRD 1,027.00 $ 36 EE/SP $ 33 EE 33 FAM PPO - $ DRD 1,380.00 $ TM 40.00 1,255.00 $ - $ 1,380.00 $ $ $ 571.00 $ 1,380.00 $ - $ 389.00 $ 54 EE/SP 47 FAM 36 FAM 51 FAM 27 FAM $ $ $ $ $ 1,255.00 1,380.00 1,380.00 1,380.00 1,380.00 389.00 389.00 389.00 389.00 52 EE/SP $ 1,255.00 $ 62 EE/SP $ 1,255.00 $ 61 EE/SP 43 FAM 33 FAM 45 FAM 56 FAM $ $ $ $ $ 1,255.00 1,380.00 1,380.00 1,380.00 1,380.00 27 EE 51 FAM 40 EE/CH $ $ $ 571.00 $ 1,380.00 $ 1,027.00 $ 24 EE $ 35 EE 51 EE/CH $ $ $ $ $ TM No TM Cost Plan YES NO a $ 355.00 a $ 789.00 $ 1,380.00 $ 1,065.00 a 1,380.00 1,380.00 1,380.00 1,380.00 1,380.00 $ $ $ $ $ 355.00 1,065.00 1,065.00 1,065.00 1,065.00 a - $ 1,380.00 $ 355.00 - $ 1,380.00 $ 867.21 $ a $ 401.59 $ $ 1,380.00 $ a a a a $ $ $ $ $ - $ - $ $ DRD 775.52 $ $ 752.25 $ - $ 997.55 $ - $ 348.35 $ 61.76 $ 1,250.65 $ - $ $ 461.95 $ 1,380.00 $ $ $ $ $ $ 1,380.00 1,380.00 1,380.00 1,380.00 1,053.08 $ - - $ 362.61 $ 278.48 $ 1,301.82 $ - a a $ $ $ $ $ 455.15 499.64 - a 1,380.00 $ 3.15 $ 1,085.71 $ - a 884.63 $ 1,380.00 $ 397.64 355.00 a $ 1,380.00 $ 588.75 $ 1,380.00 $ 327.75 $ 1,380.00 $ $ $ $ $ $ 355.00 1,065.00 1,065.00 1,065.00 1,065.00 a $ $ $ $ $ 277.66 892.12 57.91 590.91 $ $ $ $ $ 1,380.00 1,380.00 1,181.10 1,380.00 1,380.00 - $ 389.00 $ - $ 789.00 $ 1,380.00 $ 1,380.00 $ 1,065.00 40.00 a - $ $ $ 404.11 $ 1,380.00 $ 1,380.00 $ 571.00 $ - $ 789.00 $ $ $ 571.00 $ 1,027.00 $ - $ - $ 789.00 $ 1,380.00 $ 59 EE/SP $ 1,255.00 $ - $ 60 EE/SP $ 1,255.00 $ - $ 50 EE $ 571.00 $ - $ 789.00 $ - 50 EE 46 FAM Totals $ 571.00 $ $ 1,380.00 $ $ 30,472.00 $ - $ 389.00 $ 4,279.00 $ 789.00 $ 1,380.00 $ 33,714.00 $ 1,065.00 14,320.00 a 1,380.00 1,324.78 1,026.77 1,364.67 1,380.00 $ $ $ $ $ $ 1,043.03 $ $ $ $ $ $ 1,380.00 1,149.17 890.66 1,183.78 1,380.00 $ $ $ $ $ - $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 73.72 957.90 64.47 1,014.57 - 526.80 143.90 189.79 1,233.60 $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 1,141.10 1,380.00 1,133.84 1,380.00 826.62 1,380.00 1,196.19 927.11 1,232.21 1,380.00 a a a a a $ $ $ $ $ 116.75 671.56 a a a - $ 317.21 $ 413.42 $ 1,380.00 $ 128.86 $ 1,184.39 $ 27.77 - a a a a a $ 351.31 $ $ 1,380.00 $ $ 1,311.71 $ a $ 335.22 $ - $ 290.78 $ - $ 385.60 $ - $ 302.68 $ - a 40.00 a a $ $ 409.64 $ 960.41 $ - $ $ 355.33 $ 833.08 $ - $ $ 471.20 $ 1,104.74 $ - $ $ 369.87 $ 867.18 $ - a a 1,380.00 $ 355.00 a $ 1,380.00 $ 176.43 $ 1,350.09 $ - $ 1,380.00 $ 410.34 $ 1,380.00 $ 25.35 1,380.00 $ 355.00 a $ 1,380.00 $ 277.33 $ 1,380.00 $ 57.62 $ 1,380.00 $ 526.41 $ 1,380.00 $ 116.45 a $ - a 16 a 10 598.70 $ - $ 304.74 $ 179.11 $ 1,352.41 $ - $ 1,137.83 $ 383.01 425.74 - a a - a a a a $ $ $ $ $ No TM Cost Plan YES NO - $ 1,202.43 $ 1,380.00 1,380.00 1,380.00 1,380.00 1,380.00 1,096.25 1,380.00 1,089.27 1,380.00 794.13 PPO Silver DRD TM 807.24 $ 783.04 $ a $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ TM 652.43 701.72 - 389.00 389.00 389.00 389.00 1,263.77 1,380.00 1,255.72 1,380.00 915.48 - United Healthcare PPO Gold DRD TM $ 1,028.00 $ HMO Gold $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ HMO Platinum DRD TM 894.02 $ - - $ 519.33 $ $ 598.70 $ - $ 519.33 $ $ 1,380.00 $ 245.47 $ 1,380.00 $ $ 28,882.13 $ 4,052.78 $ 26,695.98 $ - $ 688.68 $ - $ 688.68 $ 30.10 $ 1,380.00 $ 1,873.04 $ 30,544.69 $ - $ 540.59 $ - - $ 540.59 $ 489.79 $ 1,380.00 $ 87.69 7,339.83 $ 27,340.00 $ 2,398.00 a a a a 20 a 6 Under Current Policy - $1,380 Cap • • • • • • Aetna - 16 TM’s Covered 100% Aetna – TM contributions equal Aetna – More $$ for TM & DRD UHC – 20 TM’s Covered 100% UHC – TM contributions all over UHC – Less $$ for DRD/most TMs DRD Healthcare Benefits FY2016 Aetna Renewal HMO Age Coverage 44 EE/CH 36 EE/SP 33 EE 33 FAM 54 EE/SP 47 FAM 36 FAM 51 FAM 27 FAM 52 EE/SP 62 EE/SP 61 EE/SP 43 FAM 33 FAM 45 FAM 56 FAM $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ DRD 1,027.00 1,255.00 571.00 1,380.00 1,255.00 1,380.00 1,380.00 1,380.00 1,380.00 1,255.00 1,255.00 1,255.00 1,380.00 1,380.00 1,380.00 1,380.00 27 EE 51 FAM 40 EE/CH $ $ $ - $ 1,380.00 $ 1,027.00 $ 24 EE $ - $ 35 EE 51 EE/CH 59 EE/SP 60 EE/SP $ $ $ $ 50 EE $ - $ 50 EE 46 FAM Totals $ - $ $ 1,380.00 $ $ 27,617.00 $ 1,027.00 1,255.00 1,255.00 PPO TM $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ DRD 389.00 389.00 389.00 389.00 389.00 389.00 389.00 389.00 389.00 $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ No TM Cost Plan YES NO TM - $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ - a a a - $ 389.00 $ - $ 789.00 $ - $ - $ - a - $ 789.00 $ - 789.00 - a a a a a a a a a a a a a $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ HMO Platinum DRD TM - $ - $ - $ - $ 1,263.77 $ - $ 1,255.72 $ - $ - $ 1,202.43 $ - $ - $ 1,324.78 $ - $ 1,364.67 $ - $ HMO Gold DRD - $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ TM 1,380.00 1,380.00 1,380.00 1,380.00 1,380.00 $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 383.01 425.74 327.75 57.91 590.91 United Healthcare PPO Gold DRD TM $ 1,028.00 $ $ 997.55 $ $ 461.95 $ $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ $ 1,053.08 $ $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ $ 1,181.10 $ $ - $ $ - $ - $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ PPO Silver DRD TM - $ - $ - $ 1,301.82 $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ No TM Cost Plan YES NO - a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a - $ - $ - $ 1,352.41 $ - $ - $ - $ $ $ 404.11 $ - $ - $ - $ $ $ - $ $ $ - a a a - a $ - $ - $ - $ 385.60 $ - $ - $ - a $ $ $ $ - a a a a $ $ $ $ - $ $ $ $ - $ $ $ $ - $ $ $ $ - $ $ $ $ - a a a - $ 789.00 $ - a $ - $ - $ $ 688.68 $ - $ - $ - a - $ 389.00 $ 4,279.00 $ 789.00 $ - $ 3,945.00 $ - a - $ 30.10 $ 1,873.04 $ 688.68 $ - $ 8,464.69 $ - $ - $ $ - $ $ 1,301.82 $ - a $ $ $ $ 16 a 10 $ - $ $ - $ $ 7,723.08 $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ $ 1,350.09 $ $ 1,380.00 $ - $ - $ - $ - $ 1,380.00 $ - $ 12,362.50 $ 57.62 - $ $ $ $ 471.20 1,104.74 - • Aetna – $378,744 DRD • Aetna - $51,348 TM a $ - $ $ - $ $ 1,311.71 $ a $1,380 Cap a 20 a 6 • UHC - $358,225 DRD • UHC - $22,476 TM DRD Healthcare Benefits FY2016 Aetna Renewal HMO Age Coverage 44 EE/CH $ 36 EE/SP $ DRD - $ 1,255.00 $ 33 EE 33 FAM 54 EE/SP 47 FAM 36 FAM 51 FAM 27 FAM 52 EE/SP 62 EE/SP 61 EE/SP 43 FAM 33 FAM 45 FAM 56 FAM $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 1,500.00 1,255.00 1,500.00 1,500.00 1,500.00 1,500.00 1,255.00 1,255.00 1,255.00 1,500.00 1,500.00 1,500.00 1,500.00 27 EE 51 FAM 40 EE/CH $ $ $ - $ 1,500.00 $ - $ 24 EE $ - $ 35 EE 51 EE/CH 59 EE/SP 60 EE/SP $ $ $ $ 50 EE $ - $ 50 EE 46 FAM Totals $ - $ $ 1,500.00 $ $ 25,285.00 $ PPO - $ - $ 1,255.00 1,255.00 $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ - $ $ 1,441.46 $ $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ $ 1,324.78 $ $ - $ $ 1,364.67 $ $ - $ - 1,500.00 1,500.00 1,500.00 1,500.00 a $ - $ $ - $ $ 1,311.71 $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - a $ - $ - $ - $ - $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ - a a a a $ $ $ $ - - - - - $ 789.00 $ - a $ - $ - $ 269.00 $ 2,959.00 $ 789.00 $ - $ 8,994.00 $ - a - $ - $ DRD 1,420.00 $ - $ TM - a a $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ - a - $ 269.00 $ - $ 789.00 $ - $ 1,420.00 $ - a - $ 789.00 $ 269.00 269.00 269.00 269.00 269.00 269.00 269.00 269.00 269.00 - $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 789.00 - 789.00 1,420.00 - $ $ a a a a a a a a a a a a a a 16 a 10 HMO Platinum DRD TM - $ - $ United Healthcare PPO Gold DRD TM - $ 1,028.00 $ - $ 997.55 $ HMO Gold DRD TM - $ - $ TM No TM Cost Plan YES NO $ $ $ $ $ - $ $ - $ $ 5,442.62 $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ - $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ 6,000.00 $ 263.01 305.74 207.75 470.91 $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ - $ No TM Cost Plan YES NO - a a $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ $ 1,496.75 $ $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ - a a a 404.11 $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ 1,407.77 $ - $ - $ - a a a 385.60 $ - $ - $ - a $ - $ $ - $ $ 1,405.35 $ $ 1,496.45 $ - a a a a - $ - a - $ - $ - $ 1,467.69 $ - $ 7,274.01 $ - a a 22 461.95 1,453.72 1,444.47 1,053.08 1,383.15 1,181.10 - 471.20 1,104.74 - $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 688.68 $ - $ 688.68 $ - $ - $ 1,247.41 $ 12,746.03 $ - $ - $ PPO Silver DRD TM - $ - $ - - - $ $1,500 Cap • Aetna – $411,348 DRD • Aetna - $35,508 TM a a a a a a a a a a a 4 • UHC - $377,551 DRD • UHC - $14,968 TM DRD Healthcare Benefits FY2016 Aetna Renewal HMO Age Coverage 44 EE/CH $ 36 EE/SP $ DRD 33 EE 33 FAM 54 EE/SP 47 FAM 36 FAM 51 FAM 27 FAM 52 EE/SP 62 EE/SP 61 EE/SP 43 FAM 33 FAM 45 FAM 56 FAM $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 1,769.00 1,769.00 1,769.00 1,769.00 1,769.00 1,769.00 1,769.00 1,769.00 1,769.00 27 EE 51 FAM 40 EE/CH $ $ $ - $ 1,769.00 $ - $ 24 EE $ 35 EE 51 EE/CH 59 EE/SP 60 EE/SP PPO - $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ $ 1,657.66 $ $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ - 1,763.01 1,769.00 1,707.75 1,769.00 a a a $ - $ $ 1,559.11 $ $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ 404.11 $ - $ 1,508.86 $ - a $ - $ - $ - $ 385.60 $ $ $ $ $ - a a a a $ - $ $ - $ $ 1,556.43 $ $ 1,657.33 $ - - - - $ 789.00 $ - a $ - $ - $ - $ - $ 789.00 $ - $ 21,139.00 $ - a a 26 $ - $ $ 1,625.47 $ $ 8,056.00 $ - $ - $ DRD 1,420.00 $ 1,735.00 $ - 789.00 1,735.00 1,735.00 1,735.00 1,735.00 - TM - a a $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ - a a a a a a a a a a a a a a - $ - $ - $ 789.00 $ - $ 1,420.00 $ - - $ - $ 789.00 $ $ $ $ $ - - 50 EE $ - $ 50 EE 46 FAM Totals $ - $ $ 1,769.00 $ $ 19,459.00 $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 789.00 1,420.00 1,735.00 1,735.00 0 HMO Platinum DRD TM - $ - $ United Healthcare PPO Gold DRD TM - $ 1,028.00 $ - $ 997.55 $ HMO Gold DRD TM - $ - $ TM - $ - $ No TM Cost Plan YES NO - $ - $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ 7,008.76 $ 36.74 201.91 $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ - $ 461.95 1,658.48 1,453.72 1,444.47 1,053.08 1,383.15 1,523.90 1,181.10 1,569.79 - 471.20 1,104.74 - $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $1,769 Cap - $ - $ PPO Silver DRD TM - $ - $ No TM Cost Plan YES NO - a a $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ - a a a a a - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - a a a - $ - $ - a - - $ $ $ $ - a a a a - $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ - • Aetna – $487,176 DRD • Aetna - $0 TM a a a a a a a a a 688.68 $ - $ - $ - a - $ 688.68 $ - $ - $ 238.65 $ 19,007.06 $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - a a 24 2 • UHC - $408,861 DRD • UHC - $2,863 TM DRD Healthcare Benefits FY2016 Aetna Renewal HMO Age Coverage DRD PPO TM DRD TM No TM Cost Plan YES NO HMO Platinum DRD TM United Healthcare PPO Gold DRD TM HMO Gold DRD TM PPO Silver DRD TM No TM Cost Plan YES NO 44 EE/CH $ 1,027.00 $ - $ 1,027.00 $ 393.00 a $ 775.52 $ 118.50 $ 775.52 $ - $ 775.52 $ 252.88 $ 775.52 $ 31.72 a 36 EE/SP $ 1,255.00 $ - $ 1,255.00 $ 480.00 a $ 752.25 $ 114.96 $ 752.25 $ - $ 752.25 $ 245.30 $ 752.25 $ 30.79 a 33 EE $ 571.00 $ - $ 571.00 $ 218.00 a $ 348.35 $ 53.24 $ 348.35 $ - $ 348.35 $ 113.60 $ 348.35 $ 14.26 a 33 FAM $ 1,769.00 $ - $ 1,769.00 $ 676.00 a $ 1,250.65 $ 191.11 $ 1,250.65 $ - $ 1,250.65 $ 407.83 $ 1,250.65 $ 51.17 a 54 EE/SP $ 1,255.00 $ - $ 1,255.00 $ 480.00 a $ 1,096.25 $ 167.52 $ 1,096.25 $ - $ 1,096.25 $ 357.47 $ 1,096.25 $ 44.85 a 47 FAM $ 1,769.00 $ - $ 1,769.00 $ 676.00 a $ 1,763.01 $ 269.42 $ 1,763.01 $ - $ 1,763.01 $ 574.89 $ 1,763.01 $ 72.14 a 36 FAM $ 1,769.00 $ - $ 1,769.00 $ 676.00 a $ 1,089.27 $ 166.45 $ 1,089.27 $ - $ 1,089.27 $ 355.20 $ 1,089.27 $ 44.57 a 51 FAM $ 1,769.00 $ - $ 1,769.00 $ 676.00 a $ 1,805.74 $ 275.98 $ 1,805.74 $ - $ 1,805.74 $ 588.83 $ 1,805.74 $ 73.90 a 27 FAM $ 1,769.00 $ - $ 1,769.00 $ 676.00 a $ 121.35 $ 794.13 $ - $ 794.13 $ 258.95 $ 794.13 $ 32.49 a 52 EE/SP $ 1,255.00 $ - $ 1,255.00 $ 480.00 a $ 1,043.03 $ 159.40 $ 1,043.03 $ - $ 1,043.03 $ 340.12 $ 1,043.03 $ 42.68 a 62 EE/SP $ 1,255.00 $ - $ 1,255.00 $ 480.00 a $ 1,707.75 $ 261.00 $ 1,707.75 $ - $ 1,707.75 $ 556.88 $ 1,707.75 $ 69.89 a 61 EE/SP $ 1,255.00 $ - $ 1,255.00 $ 480.00 a $ 1,437.91 $ 219.75 $ 1,437.91 $ - $ 1,437.91 $ 468.89 $ 1,437.91 $ 58.84 a 43 FAM $ 1,769.00 $ - $ 1,769.00 $ 676.00 a $ 1,149.17 $ 175.61 $ 1,149.17 $ - $ 1,149.17 $ 374.73 $ 1,149.17 $ 47.02 a 33 FAM $ 1,769.00 $ - $ 1,769.00 $ 676.00 a $ 136.11 $ 890.66 $ - $ 890.66 $ 290.44 $ 890.66 $ 36.45 a 45 FAM $ 1,769.00 $ - $ 1,769.00 $ 676.00 a $ 1,183.78 $ 180.89 $ 1,183.78 $ - $ 1,183.78 $ 386.01 $ 1,183.78 $ 48.43 a 56 FAM $ 1,769.00 $ - $ 1,769.00 $ 676.00 a $ 1,970.91 $ 301.41 $ 1,970.91 $ - $ 1,970.91 $ 642.69 $ 1,970.91 $ 80.65 a 27 EE $ 571.00 $ - $ 571.00 $ 218.00 a $ 304.74 $ - $ 304.74 $ 304.74 $ 12.47 a 51 FAM $ 1,769.00 $ - $ 1,769.00 $ 676.00 a $ 1,352.41 $ 206.70 $ 1,352.41 $ - $ 1,352.41 $ 441.01 $ 1,352.41 $ 55.36 a 40 EE/CH $ 1,027.00 $ - $ 1,027.00 $ 393.00 a $ 1,137.83 $ 173.78 $ 1,137.83 $ - $ 1,137.83 $ 371.03 $ 1,137.83 $ 46.56 a 24 EE $ 571.00 $ - $ 571.00 $ 218.00 a $ 290.78 $ 35 EE $ 571.00 $ - $ 571.00 $ 218.00 a $ 51 EE/CH $ 1,027.00 $ - $ 1,027.00 $ 393.00 a $ 59 EE/SP $ 1,255.00 $ - $ 1,255.00 $ 480.00 a 60 EE/SP $ 1,255.00 $ - $ 1,255.00 $ 480.00 50 EE $ 571.00 $ - $ 571.00 $ 218.00 50 EE $ 571.00 $ - $ 571.00 $ 46 FAM $ 1,769.00 $ - $ $ 34,751.00 $ - $ Totals 794.13 $ 890.66 $ 304.74 $ 46.57 $ 99.37 $ 44.44 $ 290.78 $ - $ 290.78 $ 94.82 $ 290.78 $ 11.90 a 355.33 $ 54.31 $ 355.33 $ - $ 355.33 $ 115.87 $ 355.33 $ 14.54 a 833.08 $ 127.33 $ 833.08 $ - $ 833.08 $ 271.66 $ 833.08 $ 34.10 a $ 1,350.09 $ 206.34 $ 1,350.09 $ - $ 1,350.09 $ 440.25 $ 1,350.09 $ 55.26 a a $ 1,437.62 $ 219.71 $ 1,437.62 $ - $ 1,437.62 $ 468.79 $ 1,437.62 $ 58.83 a a $ 519.33 $ 79.37 $ 519.33 $ - $ 519.33 $ 169.35 $ 519.33 $ 21.26 a 218.00 a $ 519.33 $ 79.37 $ 519.33 $ - $ 519.33 $ 169.35 $ 519.33 $ 21.26 a 1,769.00 $ 676.00 $ 1,410.01 $ 215.46 $ 1,410.01 $ - $ 1,410.01 $ 459.78 $ 1,410.01 $ 57.68 34,751.00 $ 13,283.00 a 26 $ 28,568.93 $ 4,366.08 $ 28,568.93 $ - $ 28,568.93 $ a 26 0 9,315.99 $ 28,568.93 $ 1,169.07 DRD Sponsored Base Plan • Aetna – $417,012 DRD • Aetna - $0 to $13,283 BOTMC • UHC - $342,827 DRD • UHC - $0 to $9,315 BOTMC 0 DRD Healthcare Benefits FY2016 ▪ Team Member/Board Member Goals derived from Polling and Study Session 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 100% Employer paid coverage for Team Member and their dependents Control cost for the District and Team Members Equitable Distribution of Employee contributions if necessary Greatest amount of choice possible FT benefits treated separately from COLA DRD Healthcare Benefits FY2016 Team Members Covered 100% 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 $1,380 Cap $1,500 Cap $1,769 Cap Aetna United Healthcare ESBP DRD Healthcare Benefits FY2016 Control Cost to DRD/TM 500,000 450,000 400,000 350,000 300,000 250,000 200,000 150,000 100,000 50,000 0 $1,380 Cap $1,500 Cap $1,769 Cap Aetna United Healthcare ESBP DRD Healthcare Benefits FY2016 Greatest Choice of Plans 4 4 3 3 2 2 1 1 0 $1,380 Cap $1,500 Cap $1,769 Cap Aetna United Healthcare ESBP DRD Healthcare Benefits FY2016 Equitable Distribution of Cost Aetna UHC $1,380 Cap Yes No $1,500 Cap Yes No $1,769 Cap Yes No ESBP Yes Yes DRD Healthcare Benefits FY2016 ▪ Choose Provider - Aetna vs. United Healthcare ▪ United Healthcare meets all TM/Board goals ▪ Set Employer Contribution to Premium ▪ The Employer Sponsored Base Plan meets all TM/Board Goals ▪ Staff Recommendation or Provide Alternative Motion ▪ To authorize the General Manager to negotiate and execute a contracts with United Healthcare/Guardian for the provision of employee health and welfare insurance plans for fiscal year 2016. ADMINISTRATIVE REPORT MEETING DATE: May 13, 2015 AGENDA SECTION: Study Session ITEM: 9. A TO: FROM: DATE: Honorable Members of the Board Kevin Kalman, General Manager April 24, 2015 SUBJECT: Discussion Regarding Healthcare Benefits for Full‐Time Staff and Board Members RECOMMENDATION: To provide staff direction regarding healthcare benefits for full‐time staff and board members. BACKGROUND: The Desert Recreation District maintains the following health and welfare plans for fulltime team members and board members paying $1,380 of the medical premium costs and 100% of all other benefits, which includes dependent coverage. These benefits renew each July 1, with Board of Directors’ approval: Medical benefits through Aetna Blue Cross (HMO and PPO options); Dental benefits through Principal; Life, Long‐term Disability and Accidental Death & Dismemberment benefits through Principal; Vision benefits through Vision Services Plan (VSP) John Henry Garcia of Employer Resource Group (ERG) will present information on renewal pricing for current plans, as well as discuss the impact of the Affordable Care Act. Staff requests board direction for health and welfare benefit plans effective July 1, 2015 and will present Administrative Report ‐ Subject: Discussion of healthcare benefits for fulltime staff and board members Page 1 ADMINISTRATIVE REPORT several options to the board for discussion. These options take into consideration budget constraints and the impact of the Affordable Care Act. BOARD STRATEGIC GOALS OR KEY OBJECTIVES ADDRESSED: A qualified, committed staff that is motivated and customer oriented, whose skills are competitively compensated, and whose achievements are recognized. Administrative Report ‐ Subject: Discussion of healthcare benefits for fulltime staff and board members Page 2 Health & Welfare Benefits FY16 Presented by: John Henry Garcia Employer Resource Group & Insurance Services License #0E52001 FY16 EMPLOYEE BENEFITS RENEWAL 2 Due to the reduction in team members, DRD is now considered “small group” employer. Currently, we have 27 team members enrolled. Beginning in 2016 all employers with less than 100 full time employees will be considered a small group employer under ACA. In small group, premiums are calculated by age, compared to composite (avg.) rates in large group. In small group, plan designs are not as flexible and fall within 4 categories: Platinum, Silver, Gold or Bronze. These plans are highly regulated by the State. Aetna’s rate increase: 25% (still in negotiations)—this is due to the reduction in team members, new ACA plans and older demographics. Aetna is allowing another year with composite rates, but with new ACA plans. Consideration: Renewing with Aetna at composite rating structure or changing to a small group, age-rated carrier. AETNA RENEWAL 3 Employee Employee+Spouse Employee+Ch/rn Employee+Fam # 2 4 1 10 17 HMO Aetna FY15 $ 445.00 $ 979.00 $ 802.00 $ 1,380.00 $ 19,408.00 Total Monthly Billing: PPO Aetna FY15 $ 615.00 $ 1,354.00 $ 1,107.00 $ 1,907.00 $ 10,643.00 $ 30,051.00 # 2 4 1 10 17 HMO Aetna FY16 $ 556.00 $ 1,224.00 $ 1,002.00 $ 1,725.00 $ 24,260.00 25% # 4 3 2 1 10 27 PPO Aetna FY16 $ 769.00 $ 1,692.00 $ 1,384.00 $ 2,384.00 $ 13,304.00 $ 37,564.00 HMO PPO In Network HMO (New) PPO In (New) $15/$20 None $250Admit $2,500 $100copay $15/$25/$40/20% None Full Network $15/$15 $300 Ded+20% $2,500 $100ded+20% $15/$25/$40/20% None PPO Network $20/$25 None $500Admit $2,500 $100copay $20/$35/$50/20% None Full Network $20/$20 $500 Ded+20% $3,500 $100ded+20% $20/$35/$50/20% None PPO Network Benefits Office Visits-PCP/Spec Deductible-Indv Hospital-Indv Annual Max ER Rx-Gen/Brand/NonForm/Spec Rx-Ded Brand/NF/Spec only # 4 3 2 1 10 27 Actual Cost to District with HMO Family Cap or less: Total Monthly District Cost: Total Annual District Cost: Costs are based on current elections # 27 Aetna FY15 $ 1,380.00 $ 29,524.00 $ 354,288.00 # 27 Aetna FY16 $ 1,725.00 $ 36,349.00 $ 436,188.00 23% 4 SMALL GROUP HMO & PPO OPTIONS Consider changing to United Healthcare under “small group” and offer multiple plan options. UHC is our only option in small group due to W-2 salary amounts for board members. Group will be “age rated”, including dependents. 4 plans to chose from: High/Low HMO and High/Low PPO. Due to ACA plan structures (Platinum, Gold, Silver, Bronze) benefits and out of pocket costs are higher than the current Aetna plan. See small group structure handout. COSTS & BENEFITS 5 Aetna HMO Plan - Large Group (Renewal) Office Visits/PCP/Spec Deductible/Individual Hospital/Individual Annual Max ER Rx-Gen/Brand/NonForm/Spec Rx-Ded Brand/NF/Spec Only $24,260.00 HMO $15/$20 None $250Admit $2,500 $100copay $15/$25/$40/20% None Full Network $13,304.00 PPO $15/$15 $300 Ded+20% $2,500 $100ded+20% $15/$25/$40/20% None PPO Network Current Enrollment - 17 HMO & 10 PPO United Health Care Small Group HMO Option Office Visits/PCP/Spec Deductible/Individual Hospital/Individual Annual Max ER Rx-Gen/Brand/NonForm/Spec Rx-Ded Brand/NF/Spec Only $21,740.00 HMO Platinum $20/$40 None $250/day; max 4 $4,000 $100 $15/$35/$50/25% up to $300 None Full Network $18,858.00 HMO Gold $30/$50 None $1,000/day; max 4 $6,350 $300 $15/$35/$70/25% up to $300 None Reduced Network Current Enrollment - 17 HMO & 10 PPO United Health Care Small Group PPO Option Office Visits/PCP/Spec Deductible/Individual Hospital/Individual Annual Max ER Rx-Gen/Brand/NonForm/Spec Rx-Ded Brand/NF/Spec Only Current Enrollment - 17 HMO & 10 PPO $12,878.00 $10,109.00 PPO Gold $15/$30 $500 $250 then 10% after ded $4,000 $100 $15/$35/$60/25% None PPO Network PPO Silver $35/$60 $1,800 $250 then 30% after ded $6,250 $200 $25/$50/$70/20% after $200 $200/Brand/NF PPO Network DENTAL & VISION 6 Dental Plan Principal Principal Guardian FY15 De ntal FY 16 De ntal FY 16 De ntal POS Employee 7 $ Re ne w al 43.23 $ 45.78 Re com m e nde d $ 39.44 Employee+Spouse 8 $ 85.05 $ 90.07 $ 75.54 Employee+Ch/rn 3 $ 97.50 $ 103.25 $ 88.95 15 $ 144.77 $ 153.31 $ 133.67 33 $ 3,447.06 $ 3,650.42 $ 3,152.30 Employee+Fam M onthly Cos t: Dental Benefits Preventive Basic Major Annual Max Deductible Ortho-child only Vision Plan 100%/100%/100% 100%/100%/100% 100%/100%/100% 100%/90%/80% 100%/90%/80% 100%/90%/80% 100%/60%/50% 100%/60%/50% 100%/60%/50% $2k/$1500/$1500 $2k/$1500/$1500 $2500/$2000/$1500 $0/$50/$50 $0/$50/$50 $0/$50/$50 Child Only Child Only Child Only VSP VSP VSP-Guadian FY15 Vis ion FY16 Vis ion FY16 Vis ion Curre nt Employee 11 $ 10.75 Re ne w al $ 10.75 Re com m e nde d $ 7.85 Employee+Spouse 6 $ 18.42 $ 18.42 $ 13.22 Employee+Ch/rn 3 $ 18.81 $ 18.81 $ 13.48 14 $ 30.32 $ 30.32 $ 21.33 34 $ 709.68 $ 709.68 $ 504.73 Employee+Fam M onthly Cos t: Exam/Lens/Frames Copays: 12e/12L/24f 12e/12L/24f 12e/12L/12f $10exam/$25mat $10exam/$25mat $10exam/$25mat LIFE & LTD 7 Life/AD&D Principal Principal Guardian Group Life,AD&D Group Life,AD&D Group Life,AD&D 1xAnnual 1xAnnual 1xAnnual .24/$1000 .24/$1000 .22/$1000 Board Volume 125000*(.203)/1000 125000*(.203)/1000 125000*(.2)/1000 Staff Volume 1493000*(.24)/1000 1493000*(.24)/1000 1493000*(.22)/1000 $ $ Team Members 32 Monthly Prem ium : LTD Staff Volume Monthly Prem ium : Monthly Total: Annual Savings vs. Current: Annual Savings vs. Renewal: 377.97 377.97 $ 353.46 Principal Principal Guardian LTD LTD LTD $.53/$100 $.56/$100 $.48/$100 132934*.53%cme 132934*.56%cme 132934*.48%cme $ 699.74 $ 744.43 $ 638.08 $ 5,234.45 $ 5,482.50 $ 4,648.57 $ $ 7,030.56 10,007.16 8 EE/DEP COSTS ( SMALL GROUP) WORKSHEETS