Post-Eckerd turnaround exceeds expectations
Transcription
Post-Eckerd turnaround exceeds expectations
Report Annual Post-Eckerd turnaround exceeds expectations BY MICHAEL JOHNSEN Rite Aid began posting same-store sales results across its acquired Brooks/Eckerd store base in June, and already the chain is painting a more rosy picture. Rite Aid’s July comp results were well ahead of several analyst expectations, including Lehman Brothers, which had projected July comp sales of 2.7 percent across Rite Aid’s legacy store base versus actual same-store sales improvements of 3.8 percent. Across the Brooks/ Eckerd store base, Lehman Brothers analyst Meredith Adler had projected negative same-store sales results of –4.6 percent, versus actual results of –3.8 percent. If Rite Aid can continue that improvement across the Brooks/Eckerd stores, the perception of Rite Aid ought to change from a can-theydo-it company to a they-can- do-it company, marking feather No. 2 in the proverbial caps of the company’s turnaround specialists—the first “feather” was for Rite Aid’s turnaround of its core business earlier this decade. “Front-end results were particularly encouraging,” Adler noted. “With legacy Rite Aid reporting its best frontend comp since November 2005 and Brooks/Eckerd realizing 430 basis points of sequential improvement from June despite the increasingly difficult external environment,” she said. “We continue to expect sequential improvement at Brooks/Eckerd with comps turning positive in September, and we expect core Rite Aid stores to show modest improvement due to an easy comparison, more new stores and relocations and a better promotional program.” Goldman Sachs’ analyst, The Brooks/Eckerd acquisition already is paying dividends for Rite Aid, which has seen comp-store results exceed analysts expectations, especially in terms of front-end sales. John Heinbockel, who has historically been a little more critical regarding Rite Aid’s potential going forward, also used the word “encouraging” to describe Rite Aid’s July results. “This is encouraging in that it suggests that Rebranding builds sales growth Rite Aid is fast approaching the completion of assimilating its Brooks/Eckerd acquisition of last year. By October, the chain expects to have completed the last of its minor remodels, rebranding all of its acquired stores as Rite Aid inside and out and removing from the drug store landscape a retail brand, in Eckerd, that still had been tainted by illadvised promotional programs and frequent out-ofstocks from its days under the stewardship of JCPenney. As a result, customer feedback is inching back up in those Brooks/Eckerd stores that have completed the transformation; and comparable sales, while still negative as of the end of July, are trending in a positive direction. CONTINUED ON PAGE 5 Drug Store News Before (top) and after (bottom): Rite Aid is expecting to have all its acquired Brooks and Eckerd stores rebranded inside and out by October and states it has seen improvement in customer feedback. www.drugstorenews.com the business may be stabilizing despite the difficult economic environment which, in turn, could limit the downside in 2008 EBITDA to roughly our $1 billion estimate,” he said. “The pickup has actually been so strong that it raises two related questions: One, is it being driven by promotions; and two, how sustainable is it?” And while promotions may certainly play a factor in those better-than-expectCONTINUED ON PAGE 6 Refinancing provides flexibility for growing chain In July, Rite Aid completed another round of debt refinancing, which included issuing new debt, in a move that provides greater flexibility for the chain as it nears completion of the conversion of the Brooks/Eckerd stores, especially given the current economic climate and uncertainty in the capital markets. The refinancing pushed Rite Aid’s debt needle higher, to $6.05 billion from $5.98 billion, but in so doing, pushed most of that debt out beyond 2013. A highly leveraged company operating during a potentially recessionary economy has certainly raised many eyebrows among analysts along Wall Street. However, there are no concerns over Rite Aid’s liquidity in the vendor community. Rite Aid didn’t exactly have liquidity issues before the refinancing, and they certainly have a lot fewer concerns about having access to cash flow now. “We had just increased our size by more than 50 percent and embarked on a 16-month integration of more than 1,800 stores that called for integrating six new distribution centers, converting all store systems, adding 8,000 items of new merchandise and a minor remodel program to make the stores all look and feel like Rite Aid,” Mary Sammons, Rite Aid chairman, president and chief executive officer, told CONTINUED ON PAGE 5 September 2008 • 1 Report Annual Rite Aid hopes new promotions ‘fuel’ Rx growth BY MICHAEL JOHNSEN Across a national drug retailing landscape where just filling a prescription increasingly is becoming a commodity, Rite Aid in the past few months, has implemented a number of programs designed to capture a greater share of scripts. The chain last month expanded its Rite Aid Rx Savings Card into the Georgia, North Carolina and South Carolina markets, hoping consumers there will come to equate the Rite Aid brand with savings on prescription drugs and over-the-counter medicines. Introduced in Michigan three months ago, the Rx Savings Card includes a 20-percent discount on all generic medications and most branded drugs, and offers more than 400 generic medications at a flat $8.99 for a 30-day supply or $15.99 for a 90day supply. The card also is good for a 10 percent savings on all Rite Aid store brands. While anyone can apply for the Rite Aid Rx Savings Card, it will especially benefit residents who have no or limited prescription drug insurance, explained Bill Wolfe, Rite Aid group vice president of managed care and government affairs. “With nearly 50 million people in the United States without health insurance, there is a Rite Aid recently has added such programs as Fill Up and Fuel Up, offering $30 Rite Aid gift cards and a chance to win a year of free gasoline, in an effort to gain a greater share of prescriptions. The chain also has expanded its Rx Savings Card program into the Georgia, North Carolina and South Carolina markets. serious need for a card like this to help people take care of themselves and their families,” Wolfe said. In addition to the Rx Savings Card, Rite Aid in June introduced its Fill Up and Fuel Up program, which entices patients to transfer their prescriptions in exchange for a $30 Rite Aid gift card and a chance to win a year’s worth of free gasoline. Rite Aid also is testing a few other concepts outside of the traditional prescription-filling box. Earlier this year, the chain partnered with Patient Portal Technologies on a Philadelphia-area pilot to create a unique prescription-delivery service to discharged hospital patients. “We see [this] as a great opportunity to support the community to ease the burden of hospital patients,” said Cheryl Slavinsky, Rite Aid spokeswoman, noting that Rite Aid is serving as the fulfillment arm for the delivery operation. Neither Rite Aid nor Patient Portal were willing to comment on the specific financial arrangements as part of the agreement. However, the service affords Rite Aid an opportunity not only to bolster its standing and reputation in the community, but also to potentially grow its share of the Philadelphia pharmacy market organically with the branding opportunities Rite Aid will have with these discharged patients. To be called MedEx Home Delivery, the service will offer free home delivery of prescriptions for hospital patients who are being discharged, eliminating their need to stop for the medication on their way home. “In today’s competitive healthcare landscape, hospitals are looking for trusted partners to deliver simple solutions that enhance longterm, customized care for patients,” stated Kevin Kelly, chief executive officer of Patient Portal. “Our objective is to continue to manage the patient experience beyond the traditional four walls of the hospital.” Patient Portal has been developing MedEx Home Delivery for the past 18 months, said Trish Corey, vice president of business development at Patient Portal, and marks the first partnership of its kind in the industry. “This is really a groundbreaking effort,” she said. The pilot program will be evaluated over the next 12 months, after which it will potentially be expanded to other markets. “Our intent is to move out nationwide,” Corey said. CVS/Longs deal won’t deter Rite Aid’s West Coast plans CVS Caremark’s acquisition of Longs Drug Stores last month certainly places increased pressure on Rite Aid’s West Coast operations. The new CVS California footprint catapults that chain ahead of Rite Aid as the biggest drug store chain in the state—830 (pending store closures) versus Rite Aid’s 606. California accounts for 12.2 percent of Rite Aid’s store base. But don’t expect Rite Aid to back down. “The West Coast is a very strong contributor to our overall results,” said Mary Sammons, chairman, president and chief executive officer, 2 • September 2008 during a conference call with analysts held well prior to the announcement of the CVS/Longs deal. Sammons was explaining the rationale behind not divesting the West Coast stores to help lighten the chain’s debt load. “[The West Coast] is also a strong contributor to … scale, our ability to really have greater capacity to buy better and do what we do and leverage expenses,” she said. “We have strong market shares out there. We’ve invested a lot of dollars out there,“ Sammons noted, explaining that any divestiture would have to be extraordi- narily lucrative to offset both the lost cash flows and buying leverage those West Coast operations provide. “Even under the most optimistic net proceeds assumptions, if you will, the leverage ratio would not go down much,” said Kevin Twomey, Rite Aid executive vice president and chief financial officer. “So with the combination of not really being significantly [de-leveraged] and the loss of scale and the exit of a pretty nice growth market, it just doesn’t make business sense.” Don’t expect Rite Aid to divest its West Coast stores just because of CVS’ recent acquisition of Longs Drug Stores. www.drugstorenews.com Drug Store News Report Annual GNC partnership supplements strong front end BY MICHAEL JOHNSEN One of the bigger drivers— and differentiators—behind Rite Aid’s front-end performance is the chain’s partnership with Pittsburgh-based specialty retailer GNC. Rite Aid currently operates more than 1,600 GNC store-withina-store locations, including 366 in the chain’s acquired Brooks/Eckerd stores. “We’re really doing a lot around all of our stores that have potential to sell GNC,” Mary Sammons, Rite Aid chairman, president and chief executive officer, recently told analysts. “That [partnership] expands our presence in health and wellness, and that [GNC] customer carries higher market basket, higher margin.” The two retailers renewed their partnership last year, with plans to grow to more than 2,300 locations by 2014. According to data in GNC’s annual report, the specialty channel is projected to grow at a rate of 4 percent per year over the next five years. And the growing brand identity of GNC, now under the direction of former Rite Aid executive Beth Kaplan, will continue to help establish Rite Aid as a destination center for dietary supplements. Rite Aid’s partnership with GNC took a new twist earlier this year as the chain featured several GNC athletes, including bodybuilder Chad Gregory and professional fitness and figure competitors Allison Frahn and Tina Durkin, at the Rite Aid Health and Beauty Expo in Atlanta. Other celebrities on hand at the Expo included fitness expert Denise Austin, former NBA star Dominique Wilkins, TV’s “Biggest Loser” host Alison Sweeney and Tae Bo expert Billy Blanks. Another boon to Rite Aid’s front-end performance is the chain’s commitment to its healthcare platforms—a series of six areas that help tie in pharmacist expertise to the chain’s front-end selection, including diabetes management, weight management, heart health, allergy awareness and skin care. The chain most recently introduced its oral care platform this summer, distributing a free oral care guide and oral care tip book to help educate customers on the One of the drivers of Rite Aid’s strong front-end sales is the chain’s partnership with Pittsburgh-based supplement retailer GNC. importance of taking care of their mouths and how oral health can impact a variety of health conditions. As part of the program, Rite Aid pharmacists have been trained to offer patients information on proper dental care. Rite Aid also has boosted two core drug store drivers this year—beauty and photo—with new offerings. Earlier this year, the chain debuted the c.booth derma skin care line that was created exclusively for Rite Aid and a new line of Rite Aid’s Pure Spring bath and body products. All products in the line sell for under $20. C.booth is the creation of skin care specialist Colleen Booth, and is being merchandised as an exclusive high-end brand line for Rite Aid— c.booth clinically formulated skin care—but at a value price. Many Rite Aid stores also have added a natural organics section, including bath, body and skin care products, reflecting a continuing trend toward more environmentally-friendly, natural and organic products. Rite Aid said the new lines are part of its strategy to increase its exclusive brand offerings, as well as to continue to position Rite Aid as a first-choice beauty destination. As many as 76 new exclusive products are being introduced in skin care and bath categories alone, including 15 products in the new c.booth line and 61 products in the Pure Spring line. Earlier this year, Rite Aid partnered with Fujifilm U.S.A. on an all-inclusive imaging solutions agreement, which is expected to boost the appeal of the chain’s photofinishing services. “Fujifilm will be our partner and the end-to-end solution provider as we relaunch our photo products business,” said John Pollock, Rite Aid vice president category management. Under the multiyear agreement, Fujifilm this summer launched a range of photography solutions, including online and in-store photofinishing services and consumer photo products, at Rite Aid. Rite Aid photo centers will operate using Fujifilm GetPix kiosk instant print solutions and Fujifilm Frontier Dry Lab solutions. Charity events clean up for sick children and families Rite Aid’s brass this summer traded their suits and ties for jeans and T-shirts for the company’s ninth annual Rite Aid Car Wash event—where executives washed associates’ cars to help benefit the Penn State Children’s Hospital. Other activities at the event this year included a Rite-Athalon, in which top executives competed in three sports events, including a football toss, a basketball shoot and a putting contest. Each Rite Aid executive competitor had been challenged to raise at Drug Store News least $5,000 in sponsorships for the competition. And more than 20 Rite Aid headquarters associates competed in an inter-departmental Oreo eating contest. The chain also added a Rite Aid Idol contest to the fundraiser this year, in which Rite Aid associates participated in a singing contest. Associates at Rite Aid stores across the country have already raised more than $4 million for the Children’s Miracle Network this year. From March 23 through May 10, store associates sold more than 3.4 million paper balloons and held fundraising events to benefit children’s hospitals in their hometowns. All proceeds from the executive car wash event benefit sick children and their families in the Harrisburg, Pa., area through the Children’s Miracle Network and Penn State Children’s Hospital. Rite Aid hoped to raise at least $200,000 through the event. Rite Aid has raised more than $34 million since 1994 for 117 pediatric hospitals that benefit from the Children’s Miracle Network. www.drugstorenews.com Rite Aid chairman, president and chief executive officer Mary Sammons happily participates in the ninth annual Rite Aid Car Wash, which raises money for sick children and their families in the Harrisburg, Pa., area. September 2008 • 3 Report Annual SouVez sponsorship builds outreach to new moms BY MICHAEL JOHNSEN Rite Aid has set its sights on an important customer segment: new mothers. The No. 3 drug chain earlier this year became a pre-launch sponsor of SouVez, a New York-based marketing communications firm specializing in health care and multiethnic markets that’s preparing to launch a marketing program, called “the Health Record,” targeting new moms, in 2009, SouVez announced last month. Pre-launched in 2008, the Health Record already has reached more than 350,000 mothers across the country. With a major launch set to roll out in 2009, the program is projected to cover 25 percent of the new-mom market nationwide—equating to more than 1.2 million new moms in 40 states—via the program’s 600-plus hospital partners. The Health Record is a bilingual journal, personal- ly signed and hand-delivered by a healthcare professional to new mothers in hospitals. The program has been designed to empower new mothers by helping them keep an organized, documented record of their child’s health and development, including immunizations, illnesses, hospitalization and emergency records, as well as medical providers and key medical guidelines. “We feel the material is of such value that we are discontinuing our moms and baby book that we usually hand out, and are presenting the health record to our new moms,” said Stephanie Zinn, marketing manager of Gerber Memorial Health Services. “Unlike the other stuff we give out, I love the Health Record because it’s so presentable and not something parents will throw away.” The Health Record offers numerous leveraging oppor- tunities for advertisers, as the program is measurable and fully integrated and includes a database for future marketing efforts, couponing, logo brand placement and messaging with CSR functionality. Advertisers can present a range of products or several brands to new mothers via one platform while delivering value to the mother, child and family, or sponsor a public relations or CSR campaign around the health record. Partnerships keep retail clinic business healthy, growing While Rite Aid doesn’t own a retail clinic operator, the chain still embraces the concept on a partner-bypartner/region-by-region basis. Most recently, Rite Aid opened four MedStar PromptCare clinics in Baltimore and Washington this past summer with clinic partner MedStar Health. That deal brings Rite Aid’s total clinic count to 24. “Our strategy has been quite a bit different than our competitors in that we really work to partner with local, well-recognized health providers,” Mary Sammons, Rite Aid chairman, president and chief executive officer explained. “In this instance, [it] happens to be a physician-staffed clinic,” Sammons said. The MedStar PromptCare physicians will be credentialed by and have admitting privileges to MedStar Health’s hospitals, including Georgetown University Hospital and Washington Hospital Center in Washington, as well as Montgomery General Hospital in Montgomery County, Md., and Franklin Square Hospital Center, Good Samaritan Hospital, Harbor Hospital, and Union Memorial Hospital, all of 4 • September 2008 which are located in pick up the free mateBaltimore. rials, including a 12Earlier this year, page Healthy Weight Rite Aid opened its Guide that includes third Saint Alphonsus information on the Express Care medical growing obesity epiclinic in Caldwell, demic and metabolic Idaho. “This third clinsyndrome, helpful adic is a great addition to vice on weight manthe two Express Care agement, a Body Mass clinics already located Index calculator, tips within area Rite Aid on how to create a stores, and it offers healthy diet, informaservices that completion on the imporment the medication tance of exercise and, counseling and care compliments of provided by our pharFitness magazine, an macists,” said Mark de exercise routine. Bruin, Rite Aid execu- Rite Aid operates retail clinics in 24 of its stores, including Rite Aid’s focus on tive vice president of three ExpressCare clinics. weight management pharmacy, in making is part of its healththe announcement. While the leading medically-super- and- wellness platforms, the clinics are staffed with vised weight-control pro- which helps bridge the gap nurse practitioners and grams in the nation, in 2006, between the Rite Aid physician assistants, those marking one of its first forays healthcare professional, who need additional serv- into the retail clinic space. As pharmacist or retail cliniices can access, through part of that partnership, earli- cian, and the front end. referral, the Saint Alphon- er this year Rite Aid develCurrently, Lindora opersus network of physicians, oped weight-management ates nine health clinics hospitals and other health- tips and information, as well across Southern California. care service providers. as the Rite Weight Plan, a As part of its partnership Saint Alphonsus is a 387- step-by-step online weight- with Lindora Medical Clilicensed bed regional med- loss program available at nics, Rite Aid last year ical center serving people www.riteaid.com designed began selling Lindorathroughout southwestern to help a dieter lose 10 per- branded diet products Idaho, eastern Oregon and cent of his or her body across some 400 Rite Aid northern Nevada. weight in 10 weeks. locations in Southern Prior to all of that, Rite Aid As part of that program, California. The items inalready had signed a deal with customers can visit any Rite clude a selection of protein Lindora, which features one of Aid store nationwide and bars, shakes, nutritional www.drugstorenews.com supplements, weight-loss program books, instructional DVDs and Lindora’s “Weight Loss Starter Kit,” all of which were previously only available online or through one of Lindora’s weight-loss clinics. Rite Aid has pursued a more conservative, “waitand-see” strategy in partnering with regional operators, such as Lindora Health and Sutter Health in California, as opposed to acquiring a dedicated retail clinic operator, such as Walgreens did with Take Care Health or CVS Caremark with MinuteClinic. “On the economics of clinics, for everybody, it’s a difficult economic proposition,” Sammons said. “Now, it may get better legs in the future, but right now it takes a significant number of patient visits today, and [consistent] patient visits, for even the larger clinic operators to make money,” she said. And while there is the benefit of a prescription being written in the store, which is more likely to go to that store’s pharmacy than anywhere else, those prescriptions still represent a small percentage of the overall business, Sammons said. Drug Store News Report Annual Rebranding CONTINUED FROM PAGE 1 Rite Aid only just started reporting Brooks/Eckerd results as they’re broken out from the core Rite Aid stores in June. And while that will translate into an initial drag on Rite Aid’s comparablestore results in the shortterm—Rite Aid reported only a slight lift of 1.2 percent in same-store sales across its entire store base for the month of July, representing an amalgamation of a 3.8-percent lift across Rite Aid’s core stores and a 3.8percent decline across its acquired stores—it’s expected to be a net positive over the mid- to long-term. To be sure, Brooks/Eckerd same-store sales results should show some pretty bold improvement as Rite Aid’s results today are compared against a number of year- Drug Store News ago factors, such as the transition from the Jean Coutu Group’s promotional strategy, and before that JCPenney’s, to Rite Aid’s. “Brooks/Eckerd still faces a tough comparison in June against ‘hot’ promotions implemented by prior management [that were] not ended until mid-July,” noted Meredith Adler, Lehman Brothers analyst. About the time those aggressive promotions ended, Rite Aid moved to a single advertising circular—which consequently, was before the Brooks/Eckerd stores had the full complement of Rite Aid merchandise, a fact that limited Rite Aid’s promotional capabilities for almost two quarters. That transition from a Brooks/Eckerd product mix to Rite Aid’s planogram, CONTINUED ON PAGE 6 Source: Rite Aid Refinancing C 1 ONTINUED FROM PAGE shareholders earlier this year, describing the tough economic climate in which Rite Aid was operating in at the time.“More highly leveraged companies like ours became unpopular with investors despite the fact that we already had the financing we needed,” she said. Rite Aid is still projecting EBITDA of between $1 bil- www.drugstorenews.com lion and $1.1 billion for fiscal 2009, and has proved it can control expenses in the midst of a turnaround. The refinancing includes the issuance of a new $350 million senior secured term loan due 2014 and $470 million of new 10.375 percent senior secured notes due 2016. Rite Aid used the financing to help tender the company’s 8.125 percent senior secured notes due 2010, 9.25 percent senior notes due 2013 and 7.5 percent senior secured notes due 2015. “The amendments eliminate substantially all covenants that restricted borrowings under the company’s $1.6 billion senior secured credit facility,” noted Bill Dreher, Jr., an analyst with Deutsche Bank. The month prior, Rite Aid issued $158 million of 8.5 percent convertible notes due 2015 to refinance 6.125 percent senior notes due 2008. September 2008 • 5 Report Annual Post-Eckerd C 1 ONTINUED FROM PAGE ed comparable sales results, the fact of the matter is that Rite Aid has a lot of other factors pulling in its favor. For example, the performance of Brooks/Eckerd stores today are being compared against the heavy promotional periods a year ago and later the disruptive conversion of the Brooks and Eckerd stores to Rite Aid. That should provide a boost to Brooks/Eckerd comp numbers going forward, as Rite Aid works on Rebranding 5 C ONTINUED FROM PAGE another factor that will be cycled through this fall, was also more disruptive to sales than Rite Aid executives had initially anticipated. As Rite Aid assumed control of the Brook/Eckerd stores last year, they took on a front-end 6 • September 2008 ramping up performance in those stores to keep any momentum moving forward. “They were very promotional last year … and that continued into the February timeframe,” Mary Sammons, Rite Aid chairman, president and chief executive officer, told analysts late last year. “[There were] a whole lot of consumables in the ads and a lot of, what I’d call cherry-picker pricing, and that we did not repeat in our ads [going forward].” “If you go back and look at the numbers that CVS gave after they bought their Eckerd stores, they had, at certain points, 20 percent comps in the front end. We’re not expecting anything like that, if nothing else the economy is certainly slower,” Adler said. “But we do think they can achieve, by their standards, very strong comps.” Rite Aid’s current promotional strategy is more in tune with today’s discretionarycash-challenged consumer. “Our promotion plan going forward will continue to deliv- er good value to attract a more cost-conscience customer but keep markdowns and margins in better balance at the same time,” Sammons recently told analysts. Though a drooping economy may represent somewhat of a drag on that positive comp story, it’s also an equalizing factor in that Rite Aid isn’t the only retailer having to account for the fact that customers just don’t have as many discretionary dollars as they did a year ago. “It was a challenging first quarter as the economic climate contin- ued to impact most retailers with rising unemployment and higher food and fuel costs,” Sammons told analysts during a conference call. “Despite these headwinds, our business in the pharmacy continued to improve as we increased pharmacy samestore sales, filled more prescriptions and increased pharmacy gross margin rate. Front-end same-store sales also increased, and importantly, sales trends in the acquired Brooks/Eckerd stores continued moving in a positive direction.” operation that had been on the decline during the nine months it took from acquisition-announcement to acquisition-completion, in part because of the number of outof-stocks on store shelves. To date, Rite Aid has completed more than 70 percent of its Brooks/Eckerd remodels, with the final remodel expect- ed to be completed just as the chain begins rolling out its Christmas-season planograms. “As you you would expect, front-end sales are improving more quickly [in the remodeled Brooks/Eckerds], and we’ve cut the rate of decline in half with strong growth in core drug store categories like OTC and vitamins, which include high margin Rite Aid brands,” Mary Sammons, Rite Aid chairman, president and chief executive officer told analysts. And while that sales-disruptive transformation from Brooks/Eckerd product mix to Rite Aid’s planogram won’t be entirely cycled through until October 2009, it should spark a significant increase in private label penetration. Rite Aid enjoyed a 12.9 percent penetration of store brand products through fiscal 2008. Meanwhile, the acquired stores private brand penetration had reached 11.5 percent by May 2008, which was earlier than had been anticipated by Rite Aid. www.drugstorenews.com Drug Store News