l*::t:::* T - Karnataka Information Commission

Klc9246 PTN 2013
C
vind Bhav
zG;-
w br tt.-udd... t http ://www'kic'sov'i n
"
VAT Division'
[sriB.PrakashBhatvs.(i)Administrativeofficer&Plo,officeofJointcommissionerofcommerc
(ii) lointCo*Jsr-i'o*t oibot'n""ial Taxes& FAA'
DVO,Davanagere,
Taxes,
ORDER
19.03.2014
Commissionerof CommercialTaxes
Appellantis absent.Sri M. S. Raju, Assistant
l.
Sn Kuchela' Joint Commissionerof
& plo, Central Office, Davanager"i.i..r*as
CommercialTaxes(DVO)&FAA,VATDivision,Davanagerewithauthorization'SriS'
Assistant commissioner of
M. Rajashekhar,cTo representsSri veerendrakumar, with authorization.
District
Be'llar.vCommercialTaxes& PIo, LVo-500, Hospeth,
dated 04.05'2013 addressedto
Appellant in his request io, information
2.
plb. office of Joint commissioner of commercial raxes,
Administrative ofircer &
informatio-n:
DVO. I)avanagere,has soughtthe follos'ing
to Sri lluthiah P\\D contractorand etc
Gued
regardingcertificateof registration
Office of Joint commissionerof
RespondentNo.l AdminisUadre oft-rcer& PIO'
3.
the application r-r/s6(3) of the act
CommercialTares- DvO. Davanagerehas transferred
Commissioneiof CommercialTaxes &
on 09.05.2013to RespondentNo-2 Assistant
PIO,LVO-500,Hospeth,BellaryDistricttofurnishtheinformationdirectlytothe
raxes& plo, Lvocommercial
of
commissioner
Assistant
No.2
too"ttili;pondent
party u/s 11 (01) of the Act
to the third
500, Hospeth,Bellary District has issuednotice
on 14.05.2013.
they
No'2 Sri S. M. Rajashekhar,CTO statesthat
of Respondent
Representative
5.
the
provide
not to
party on 1A.OS.ZO\3,
have received objection filed by the third
informationto the APPellant'
Taxes & PIO' LVORespondentN;.2 AssistantCommissionerof Commercial
6.
20'05'2013to the Appellant statedthat'
500, Hospeth,Bellary District in his letter dated
is a objectionfrom the third party to
the soughtinformationcannotbe provided,as there
disclosethe information.
Commissionerof Commercial
Appellant had frled first Appeal before the Joint
7.
u/s 19(1)of the Act on 29'06'2013'alleging
Taxes& FAA, VAT Division,Davanagere
ihut, th. soughtinformationis not a third party information.
Taxes(DVO) & FAA'
g.
commissionnotedthat Jointcommissionerof commercial
of the Appeal on 23'08'2013'bl
VAT Division, Davanagerehas heard and disposed
holdingthe decisionof the PIO'
u/s 19(3) of the Acr on
filed secondappealto the commission
;:''"'"o;;";;;';",
r--. ,L^ DTA
Q'rhconrrenflv
lha
byih?nlg;l*::t:::* T:
.*.io\\.;ilil;,r,"ii,."i,"J;";;;i"ed information
the Commission
EEi;be.fore
the Parties
Commissionissued summonsto both
",1 9 . 0 3 . 2 0 1a4I 1' 1 . 0 0A . M .
tril
-;;:.,../
-1t.,
No.1 Sri Kuchela,Joint Commissioner
of CommercialTaxes(DVO)
10. Respondent
& FAA, VAT Division, Davanagerein his memo dated 19.03.2014to the Commission
statedthat, the soughtinformationis third parry information,as there is a objectionfrom
the third party, hence this information cannot be provided and also submittedthat
relevant documentis neither createdand preparedby the Public authority, nor is the
outcomeof its activities,the PIO hascorrectlyappliedSectionu/s 8(1) (d) & (e) of the
act for withholdingthe information.
of RespondentNo.2 Sri S. M. Rajashekhar,CTO statesthat, the
11. Representative
provided
to
the
Appellant on 19.03.2014,throughRPAD and producedthe copy
sameis
of the PostalAcknowledgementfor havingsentthe intimation.
12. Commission noted that, submissionof the Respondentis accepted,hence
Appeal is disposedof.
13. Dictated,draft corrected,signedandpronouncedin the openCourt, this l9'h day of
March 2014.
(DR. S
.A.RD. SAJJANAR)
STATE INFORMATION COMMISSIONER
Addressesof parties:
Ktc9246 PTN 2013
Ktc9246 PTN 2013
Sri B. PrakashBhat.
BehindS. S. Sadan,Kodialbail,
Sri N. Veerendrakumar,
AC of CommercialTaxes& PIO.
h. BellarvDistrict.
LVO-500,
KTC 9246PTN 2013
Sri Kuchela,
JC of CommercialTaxes& FAA,
VAT Division,Davanagere.
(i) Public Information Officer must mention his full name,addressand telephonenumber
in all communicationsconcerningRTI.
(ii) All parties must mention the casenumber in all communicationsrelating to this case,
rvhetheraddressedto the Commissionor other persons.
,,ff!.o*.
€+